You are on page 1of 71

Atlas

chwastów

Sumi-Agro Poland Sp. z o.o.


Al. Jana Pawła II 80, 00-175 Warszawa
tel.: 0-22 637 32 37, fax: 0-22 637 32 38
e-mail: biuro@sumi-agro.com.pl
www.sumi-agro.com.pl
Edbnh¨^`dcXZeX_VXV¨dÑX^/
Hjb^"6\gdEdaVcY
Va#?VcVEVl¨V>>-%!%%"&,*LVghoVlV!EA

De^hnX]lVhi‹l^`dchjaiVX_Z/ OlVaXoVc^ZX]lVhi‹lc^Z_ZhioVYVc^Zb¨Vilnb#H`jiZXocdсln`dcnlVcnX]degn"
9g^cè#BVgX^c@doV` h`‹loVaZènXoŸhiddYl¨VÑX^lZ_dXZcnhiVcjoVX]lVhoXoZc^V!ViVb#^c#dYedegVl"
9g^cè#L^Zh¨VlLd_X^ZX]dlh`^ cZ\dgdoedocVc^V\Vijc`‹lX]lVhi‹l#6iaVh!`i‹gnbVX^ZEV²hildlgŸ`VX]!j¨Vil^
^YZcinÉ`VX_Ÿ X]lVhi‹l l g‹ècnX] [VoVX] ^X] gdold_j#
;did\gVÉZ/ IdbVho H^`dgh`^ @h^|è`V odhiV¨V iV` edbnÑaVcV! Wn 8oniZac^` b‹\¨ ¨Vild gdoedocV X]lVhi!
`^Zgj_|Xh^Ÿ`hoiV¨iZba^ÑX^Zc^^^ccnb^YdhigoZ\Vacnb^XZX]Vb^#IV`^j`¨VY_Zhiegon"
H`¨VY/GV[V¨HnalZhiZgÐl^|iZ` YVicn ol¨VhoXoV egdYjXZcidb WjgV`‹l! `i‹gon bjho| ln`dcnlV degnh`^ l cV_"
@dgZ`iV/:aèW^ZiVL^c^Vgh`V"<gVWdho lXoZÑc^Z_honX][VoVX]gdold_jX]lVhi‹l#
9o^Ÿ`^he^hdl^Va[VWZinXocZbjbdècVWZoigjYjdYcVaZ„de^hX]lVhij!`^Zgj_|X
h^Ÿ_Z\dcVol|#LViaVh^ZocV_Yj_|h^Ÿg‹lc^Zè^c[dgbVX_Zdho`dYa^ldÑX^X]lVhi‹l!
ViV`èZl^ZaZX^Z`VldhiZ`oc^b^ol^|oVcnX]#
8]X^V¨WnbWVgYod!VWnidlnYVlc^Xildh¨jèn¨dEV²hiljcVXdYo^Z²#J[Vb!èZ
Î6iaVhX]lVhi‹l¿hiVc^Zh^ŸedbdXcnlZl¨VÑX^lZ_e^ZaŸ\cVX_^jegVl^jonh`^lVc^j
lnhd`^X]eadc‹l#

IdbVhoH^`dgh`^
9ngZ`idgbVg`Zi^c\jHjb^"6\gdEdaVcY

Egon\didlVc^Z/BVgi^c?VXdWhe#od#d#!ja#B^²h`V*)"*+!*)"+&%LgdX¨Vl!EA
9gj`/?6@H!ja#7d\ZYV^cV-!*%"*&)LgdXVl!EA
,

He^higZÑX^

He^higZÑX^######################################################## ,
He^hVa[VWZinXocnX]lVhi‹l¼^cYZ`hcVoledah`^X]######################## -
He^hVa[VWZinXocnX]lVhi‹l¼^cYZ`hcVol¨VX^²h`^X] ####################### .
EdYo^V¨X]lVhi‹loZlo\aŸYjcV`hoiV¨ia^ÑX^Zc^########################## &%
AZ\ZcYV######################################################## &&
EgoZYbdlV ###################################################### &*
HoXoZ\‹¨dlnViaVhX]lVhi‹l######################################### &,
7c^ZXW^V¨n################################################### &-
@dbdhVW^V¨V################################################# '%
@dc^XoncVedacV ############################################### ''
@gonldhon_edacn############################################## ')
BVgjcVWZoldccV############################################## '+
BaZXoolnXoV_cn############################################### '-
Bc^hoZ`edheda^in ############################################## (%
Dhig‹èZXo`VedacV############################################## ('
Egonb^dicd`VcVYn_h`^Z######################################### ()
Egonija^VXoZecV############################################### (+
GYZhi`daVc`dln############################################### (-
GYZhieaVb^hin################################################ )%
HiVgoZXolnXoV_cn############################################## )'
IVhoc^`edheda^in############################################### ))
IdWd¨`^edacZ################################################# )+
L^aXodbaZXodWgdicn########################################### )-
;^d¨Z`edacn################################################## *%
>\a^XVedheda^iV################################################ *'
EgoZiVXoc^`WajhoXon`dln ######################################## *)
EgoZiVXoc^`eZgh`^ ############################################## *+
Gjb^VcZ`edheda^in############################################ *-
拨ia^XVYgdWcd`l^VidlV######################################## +%
7^Zaj²Yo^ŸYo^ZgoVlV ############################################ +'
9nbc^XVedheda^iV############################################# +)
<l^VoYc^XVedheda^iV########################################### ++
@jgonÑaVYedacn############################################### +-
Eh^Vc`VXoVgcV################################################# ,%
7dYo^hoZ`YgdWcn############################################## ,'
8]VWZgW¨VlViZ` ############################################### ,)
DhigdèZ²edacn################################################ ,+
Edl‹_edacn################################################## ,-
C^ZoVedb^cV_`VedacV########################################## -%
?VhcdiVejgejgdlV############################################# -'
- .
?VhcdiVg‹èdlV################################################ -) Edo^Zlc^`hodghi`^###############-- HedgZ`edacn ##################&%'
@|`daedacn################################################## -+ EgoZiVXoc^`WajhoXon`dln #########*) HiVgoZXolnXoV_cn###############)'
Edo^Zlc^`hodghi`^ ############################################## -- EgoZiVXoc^`eZgh`^ ###############*+ HoVg¨Vihodghi`^################&%)
Gjb^Vcedacn ################################################# .% Egonb^dicd`VcVYn_h`^Z##########() HoXoVledacn##################&%+
HoXoVlolnXoV_cn############################################## .' Egonija^VXoZecV################(+ HoXoVlolnXoV_cn###############.'
7VW`VaVcXZidlViV############################################# .) Eh^Vc`VXoVgcV##################,% IVhoc^`edheda^in################))
BV`edacn#################################################### .+ GYZhi`daVc`dln################(- IdWd¨`^edacZ##################)+
GYZhiedld_dln############################################### .- GYZhieaVb^hin#################)% L¨dÑc^XVh^cV#################&(%
GYZhieiVh^################################################## &%% GYZhiedld_dln################.- L¨dÑc^XVo^ZadcV ###############&('
HedgZ`edacn ################################################# &%' GYZhieiVh^###################&%% L^aXodbaZXodWgdicn############)-
HoVg¨Vihodghi`^############################################### &%) Gjb^Vcedacn ##################.% Ln`VXoiZgdcVh^ZccV############&&+
HoXoVledacn################################################# &%+ Gjb^VcZ`edheda^in#############*- Ln`VYgdWcd`l^VidlV ##########&&-
<dgXonXVedacV############################################### &%- GoZeV`do^bn#################&&' Ln`VeiVh^V##################&'%
Ed`gonlVèZ\Vl`V############################################ &&% GodY`^ZlÑl^goZeV#############&&) æ
 ܬia^XVYgdWcd`l^VidlV#########+%
GoZeV`do^bn\VijcZ`oVX]lVhoXoV_|Xn########################### &&'
GodY`^ZlÑl^goZeV############################################ &&)
Ln`VXoiZgdcVh^ZccV########################################### &&+
Ln`VYgdWcd`l^VidlV ######################################### &&-
Ln`VeiVh^V################################################# &'%
He^hVa[VWZinXocnX]lVhi‹l
8]lVhic^XV_ZYcdhigdccV######################################## &''
>cYZ`hcVol¨VX^²h`^X]
B^di¨VoWdèdlV ############################################### &')
Dl^Zh\¨jX]n################################################ &'+
EZgol¨VÑX^ln################################################ &'- 6\gdengdcgZeZch################&'- BZaVcYg^jbVaWjb###############&-
L¨dÑc^XVh^cV################################################ &(% 6\gdhiZbbV\^i]V\d ###############-+ Bndhdi^hVgkZch^h#################-%
L¨dÑc^XVo^ZadcV ############################################## &(' 6bVgVci]jhgZigdÊZmjh############&%) EVeVkZgg]dZVh###################.+
E^Ñb^Zcc^Xild################################################### &() 6cV\Vaa^hVgkZch^h################+- EZgh^XVg^VaVeVi]^[da^V#############(-
DjegVl^ZWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\d ####################################### &(+ 6ci]Zb^hVgkZch^h################.% EaVciV\daVcXZdaViV###############.)
BZidYnolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹l####################################### &(, 6eZgVhe^XV"kZci^ ################&') Edan\dcjbVk^XjaVgZ##############&%%
IdgZgd*%%H8 ################################################### &)& 6kZcV[VijV###################&'+ Edan\dcjbXdckdakjajh#############.-
7gVhh^XVcVejh##################&&' Edan\dcjbaVeVi]^[da^jb############(-
8VehZaaVWjghV"eVhidg^h #############)) Edan\dcjbeZgh^XVg^V##############)%
8ZciVjgZVXnVcjh #################,) GVe]VcjhgVe]Vc^higjb ###########&&)
He^hVa[VWZinXocnX]lVhi‹l 8^gh^jbVgkZchZ ##################,+
8dchda^YVgZ\Va^h#################('
GjbZmVXZidhV ###################.'
GjbZmVXZidhZaaV################&%+
>cYZ`hcVoledah`^X] 8dckdakjajhVgkZch^h###############,- HZcZX^dkja\Vg^h##################)'
9VijgVhigVbdc^jb ###############+' HZiVg^V\aVjXV ##################&(%
9Zae]^c^jbXdchda^YV ##############(' HZiVg^Vk^g^Y^h ##################&('
7VW`VaVcXZidlViV##############.) @dc^XoncVedacV ################'' :X]^cdX]adVXgjh"\Vaa^#############&'' H^cVe^hVgkZch^h #################&%-
7^Zaj²Yo^ŸYo^ZgoVlV#############+' @gonldhon_edacn###############') :g^\ZgdcXVcVYZch^h###############() HdaVcjbc^\gjb#################,%
7c^ZXW^V¨n####################&- @jgonÑaVYedacn################+- :gdY^jbX^XjiVg^jb###############*' HdcX]jhdaZgVXZjh#################'-
7dYo^hoZ`YgdWcn###############,' BV`edacn#####################.+ :je]dgW^V]Za^dhXde^V ##############)- HeZg\jaVVgkZch^h################&%'
9nbc^XVedheda^iV##############+) BVgjcVWZoldccV###############'+ ;jbVg^Vd[ÉX^cVa^h################+) HiZaaVg^VbZY^V##################++
;^d¨Z`edacn###################*% B^di¨VoWdèdlV################&') <VaZdeh^hiZigV]^i #################-- IVgVmVXjbd[ÉX^cVaZ ##############(%
<dgXonXVedacV ################&%- BaZXoolnXoV_cn################'- <Va^chd\VeVgk^ÊdgV ##############+% I]aVhe^VgkZchZ##################)+
<l^VoYc^XVedheda^iV############++ Bc^hoZ`edheda^in ###############(% <Va^jbVeVg^cZ##################(+ Ig^[da^jbVgkZchZ#################''
8]VWZgW¨VlViZ` ################,) C^ZoVedb^cV_`VedacV###########-% <ZgVc^jbejh^aajb###############,' Jgi^XVjgZch###################&&%
8]lVhic^XV_ZYcdhigdccV########&'' DhigdèZ²edacn#################,+ 8]ZcdedY^jbVaWjb ###############'% KZgdc^XV]ZYZg^[da^V###############*)
>\a^XVedheda^iV#################*' Dhig‹èZXo`VedacV###############(' AVb^jbVbeaZm^XVjaZ##############-) KZgdc^XVeZgh^XV##################*+
?VhcdiVejgejgdlV##############-' Dl^Zh\¨jX]n#################&'+ AVb^jbejgejgZjb###############-' K^X^VXgVXXV####################&'%
?VhcdiVg‹èdlV#################-) EZgol¨VÑX^ln#################&'- AnXdeh^hVgkZch^h##################') K^X^V]^ghjiV ###################&&-
@|`daedacn###################-+ Ed`gonlVèZ\Vl`V#############&&% BVig^XVg^VX]Vbdb^aaV#############*- K^X^ViZigVheZgbV ################&&+
@dbdhVW^V¨V##################'% Edl‹_edacn###################,- BVig^XVg^V^cdYdgV###############'+ K^daVVgkZch^h###################*%
&% &&

EdYo^V¨X]lVhi‹l AZ\ZcYV
oZlo\aŸYjcV`hoiV¨ia^ÑX^Zc^

:A>EIN8OC: D@Gx<ç: De^hn\Vijc`‹lX]lVhi‹ldWZ_bj_|/cVolŸ\Vijc`dl|edah`|!cVolŸ\Vijc`dl|


7c^ZXW^V¨n C^ZoVedb^cV_`VedacV ¨VX^²h`|!b^ŸYoncVgdYdlne^ŸX^da^iZgdlnhnbWdaX]lVhij!cVolŸgdYo^cnWdiVc^Xo"
@dbdhVW^V¨V DL6AC: cZ_edah`|!¨VX^²h`|lcVl^VhVX]edYVcdhiVgho|cdbZc`aVijgŸ!cVolŸolnXoV_dl|!
@dc^XoncVedacV ?VhcdiVejgejgdlV cVolŸ \Vijc`dl| Vc\^Zah`|! [gVcXjh`|! c^Zb^ZX`|! XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ! oVgnh
@gonldhon_edacn ?VhcdiVg‹èdlV `hoiV¨ija^ÑX^Zc^V!de^hh^Zl`^!oVgnh`hoiV¨ije^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V!de^hgdÑa^cnYdgdh¨Z_!
BVgjcVWZoldccV @|`daedacn lnhiŸedlVc^Z!ho`dYa^ldс^X^Z`Vldhi`^#
BaZXoolnXoV_cn Edo^Zlc^`hodghi`^ @aVhnÉ`VX_Ÿ \Vijc`‹l X]lVhi‹l Yd edhoXoZ\‹acnX] \gje egoZegdlVYodcd
Dhig‹èZXo`VedacV Gjb^Vcedacn ldeVgX^jdoVgnh`hoiV¨ija^ÑX^Zc^/
Egonb^dicd`VcVYn_h`^Z HoXoVlolnXoV_cn
Egonija^VXoZecV GÙLCDLxH@>: :A>EIN8OCN C:G@DL6IN DL6ACN
GYZhi`daVc`dln 7VW`VaVcXZidlViV
GYZhieaVb^hin BV`edacn
HiVgoZXolnXoV_cn GYZhiedld_dln
IVhoc^`edheda^in GYZhieiVh^
IdWd¨`^edacZ HedgZ`edacn ?6?DL6IN D9LGDIC>:?6?DL6IN GÙLCDLxH@>
L^aXodbaZXodWgdicn HoVg¨Vihodghi`^
?6?DL6I: HoXoVledacn
;^d¨Z`edacn H:G8DL6I:
>\a^XVedheda^iV <dgXonXVedacV
EgoZiVXoc^`WajhoXon`dln Ed`gonlVèZ\Vl`V A6C8:IDL6IN D@Gx<çN H:G8DL6IN
EgoZiVXoc^`eZgh`^ GoZeV`
Gjb^VcZ`edheda^in GodY`^ZlÑl^goZeV
拨ia^XVYgdWcd`l^VidlV LN@>
A6C8:IDL6I: Ln`VXoiZgdcVh^ZccV
7^Zaj²Yo^ŸYo^ZgoVlV Ln`VYgdWcd`l^VidlV
9nbc^XVedheda^iV Ln`VeiVh^V @hoiV¨ie^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^Vl¨VÑX^lZ\degoZYhiVl^dcdloVgnh^Z/
<l^VoYc^XVedheda^iV ?:9CDA>Ð8>:CC:
@jgonÑaVYedacn 8]lVhic^XV_ZYcdhigdccV LNG6ƒC>:L>9D8OC: Hç67DL>9D8OC:
Eh^Vc`VXoVgcV B^di¨VoWdèdlV JC:GL>:C>:7A6HO@>A>Ð8>DL:? JC:GL>:C>:7A6HO@>A>Ð8>DL:?
C:G@DL6I: Dl^Zh\¨jX]n
7dYo^hoZ`YgdWcn EZgol¨VÑX^ln
D9LGDIC>:?6?DL6I: L¨dÑc^XVh^cV
8]VWZgW¨VlViZ` L¨dÑc^XVo^ZadcV
DhigdèZ²edacn
Edl‹_edacn

  edY¨j\dlViddlVacZ
 aVcXZidlVidg‹lcdl|h`^Z
&' &(

CVolVl_Ÿon`jedah`^b
CVolVed¨VX^c^Z docVXoZc^ZhnhiZbVin`V
B>–9ONC6GD9DLN@D98=L6HIJ oY_ŸX^ZgdÑa^cn
oY_ŸX^ZgdÑa^cn oY_ŸX^Zb¨dYZ_
DocVXoZc^ZgdYo^cnl_Ÿon`jedah`^b!¨VX^²h`^b l[Vo^Z
l[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^ gdÑa^cn
CVolVolnXoV_dlV e^ZglhonX]a^ÑX^
CVolVl_Ÿon`jVc\^Zah`^b
CVolVl_Ÿon`j[gVcXjh`^b
CVolVl_Ÿon`jc^Zb^ZX`^b
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

oY_ŸX^ZgdÑa^cn
Yd_goV¨Z_
de^hgnhjc`j
hX]ZbVia^ÑX^Zc^VloVgnh^Z
hX]ZbVia^ÑX^VloVgnh^Z
cV\¨‹lZ`
de^hcV\¨‹l`V
docVXoZc^Z`hoiV¨ija^ÑX^Zc^

oY_ŸX^Z`l^Vij
EgoZYbdlV

8]lVhiVb^edacnb^h|lhonhi`^ZgdÑa^cnlnhiŸej_|XZcVedaj!l¨Vc^ZgdÑa^cnjegVl"
cZ_!`i‹gZc^Zh|egoZYb^diZbjegVln#EdldYj_|dcZed\dghoZc^ZoVg‹lcdl^Za`dÑX^!
_V`^_V`dÑX^eadcj#Bd\|idWngdÑa^cnYo^`^Z!oYo^XoV¨Z[dgbngdÑa^cjegVlcnX]!_V`
g‹lc^ZèdWXZgdÑa^cnjegVlcZ#GdÑa^cndWXZ\d\Vijc`jXon^ccZ_dYb^Vcnc^ègdÑa^cV
jegVlcVWŸY|XVXZaZbYo^V¨VacdÑX^gdac^`Vc^Zh|X]lVhiVb^!lÑX^h¨nbocVXoZc^jiZ"
\dh¨dlV!aZXoh|iol#gdÑa^cVb^oVX]lVhoXoV_|Xnb^#
Ho`dYa^ldс X]lVhi‹l lnc^`V \¨‹lc^Z o`dc`jgZcXn_cdÑX^ ogdÑa^c| jegVlc|
dh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ!ldYŸ^Ñl^Vi¨d!X]dlegoneVY`jeZlcnX]\Vijc`‹lX]lVh"
i‹l_ZhidcVocVXoc^Zl^Ÿ`hoV#8]lVhinbd\|WneVhdèniVb^@Vc^Vc`V`dc^Xoncd"
lV¼8jhXjiVig^[da^^e‹¨eVhdèniVb^gdÑa^cjegVlcnX]HoZaŸèc^`l^Ÿ`hon¼G^cVi]jh
VaZXidgdade]jh#>ccZ\Vijc`^bV_|l¨VÑX^ldÑX^igj_|XZYaVajYo^^ol^Zgo|i!_V`/7^Zaj²
Yo^ŸYo^ZgoVlV 9VijgV higVbdc^jb! @|`da edacn 6\gdhiZbbV \^i]V\d! Dhig‹èZXo`V
edacV8dchda^YVgZ\Va^hXonEh^Vc`VXoVgcVHdaVcjbc^\gjb#A^XocZ\Vijc`^X]lVh"
i‹led\VghoV_|g‹lc^Zè_V`dсegdYj`i‹lgdacnX]^ol^ZgoŸXnX]#DWZXcdсlo^Vgc^Z
oW‹èegoZocVXodcnX]cVegoZb^V¨dldX‹lCVlgdijedacZ\dA^i]dheZgbjbVgkZchZ!oZ
lo\aŸYjcV^X]ilVgYdс!hegVl^VlgVèZc^Ze^Vh`jlb|XZ!cVidb^VhijYo^V¨leVhon
YaV `g‹l baZXocnX] IdWd¨`‹l edacnX] I]aVhe^ VgkZchZ! <dgXonXn edacZ_ H^cVe^h
VgkZch^h! HoXoVl^j iŸeda^hicZ\d GjbZm Xg^hejh Xon Gjb^Vc`j WZoegdb^Zc^hiZ\d
BVig^XVg^VbVig^XVg^d^YZh_ZhiegonXonc|\dgo`^Z\d!c^Zegon_ZbcZ\dhbV`j^XoŸhiZ"
\dehjX^Vh^ŸbaZ`V^egoZildg‹lbaZXocnX]#Dl^Zh\¨jX]n6kZcV[VijVoZlo\aŸYj
cV oV`d²XoZc^Z o^Vgc^V`V Y¨j\| ^ he^gVac^Z h`gŸXdc| dhig| dÑX^|! V DhigdèZ² edacn
8^gh^jbVgkZchZoZlo\aŸYjcVdhigZa^ÑX^Z^¨dYn\^!bd\|WnegonXonc|edlVècnX]
edYgVèc^Z²!d`VaZXoZ²^oVWjgoZ²j`¨VYjed`VgbdlZ\d#8]lVhinedÑgZYc^Xo|g‹l"
c^ZèlgdoegoZhigoZc^Vc^jh^ŸX]dg‹W^ho`dYc^`‹lgdÑa^cjegVlcnX]#Egon`¨VYdld
X]lVhin o gdYo^cn igVl EdVXZVZ h| ènl^X^ZaVb^ b|il^`V oWdèdlZ\d! eadc^Vg`^
oWdè‹l`^ Xon gYon „Y„W¨dlZ_! o `daZ^ X]lVhin o gdYo^cn `VejhicnX] 7gVhh^XVXZVZ
h|ènl^X^ZaVb^oVhiŸeXonb^ajWd`da^XocdÑX^dlnb^h¨dYnho`VgoZeV`dlZ\d!W^Za^c`V
`Vejhic^`VXon\gonWVlnld¨j_|XZ\d`^¨Ÿ`VejÑX^Vc|#LgdocdhoZc^j^gdoegoZhigoZ"
c^Vc^j h^Ÿ X]dg‹W o^Zbc^V`V jXoZhic^Xo| X]lVhin o gdYo^cn eh^Vc`dlVinX] HdaV"
cVXZVZ!VlWjgV`VX]X]lVhinogdYo^cn`dbdhdlVinX]!X]dX^VèWnedejaVgcV@dbd"
hVW^V¨V8]ZcdedY^jbVaWjb#EdcVYidXoŸÑX]lVhi‹lbdèZ`gonèdlVh^ŸogdÑa^cVb^
jegVlcnb^!_V`Dl^Zh\¨jX]noDlhZbjegVlcnbXon<dgXonXVedacVo<dgXonX|
W^V¨|#Ho`dYa^ldсX]lVhi‹llnc^`Vg‹lc^ZèobVhdldÑX^^X]lnhiŸedlVc^Vl¨Vc^Z!
egdlVYo|XYdoV\¨jhoVc^VgdÑa^cnjegVlcZ_#>ccZ\Vijc`^!_V`Edl‹_edacn8dckd"
akjajhVgkZch^h!GYZhiedld_dlnEdan\dcjbXdXckdakjajhXonEgonija^VXoZecV<Va^db
VeVg^cZ deaViV_|X ^ XoŸhid egoZgVhiV_|X gdÑa^cŸ jegVlc|! edldYj_| lnaZ\Vc^Z ¨Vcj
^jigjYc^V_| oW^‹g! V_ZhoXoZ ^ccZ X]lVhin! _V` ƒ‹¨ia^XV YgdWcd`l^VidlV <Va^chd\V
eVgk^ÊdgVX]VgV`iZgnoj_|h^ŸWVgYodYjè|ènldicdÑX^|^igjYcdÑX^|^X]olVaXoVc^V#
OcVXocVho`dYa^ldсX]lVhi‹lbV_|XV^hidicnle¨nlcVobc^Z_hoZc^Zl^Za`dÑX^
^ed\dghoZc^Z_V`dÑX^eadcjgdÑa^cnjegVlcZ_hegVl^V!èZedcVYed¨dlVeZhinXnY‹l
&+
oVaZXVcnX]YddX]gdcngdÑa^clgdac^Xil^Zid]ZgW^XnYn#9ZXnYj_|Xh^ŸcVX]Zb^Xoc|
bZidYŸlVa`^oX]lVhiVb^edl^cc^Ñbn_ZYcV`egoZhigoZ\VlhoZa`^X]gZ\j¨ol^|oV" HoXoZ\‹¨dlnViaVhX]lVhi‹l
cnX]o`dYZ`hZbYdWgZ_egV`in`^gdac^XoZ_#LÑg‹Yl^ZajXoncc^`‹lh¨jè|XnX]d\"
gVc^XoVc^j ojènX^V ]ZgW^XnY‹l lnb^Zc^VcZ _Zhi cV_XoŸÑX^Z_ hidhdlVc^Z egZeVgVi‹l
ledXo|i`dlZ_[Vo^Zgdold_dlZ_X]lVhi‹l#Hi|YiZèhiV¨dh^ŸidYaV6jidg‹l^che^gVX_|
YdedY_ŸX^VdegVXdlVc^VÎ6iaVhjX]lVhi‹l¿de^ZgV_|XZ\dh^ŸlhlnbedYo^VaZegoZYZ
lhonhi`^bcVoVgnh^Z`hoiV¨i‹l^X]a^ÑX^Zc^#9o^Ÿ`^iV`^Zbjj`¨VYdl^ejWa^`VX_^bV"
bncVYo^Z_Ÿ!èZWŸY|bd\a^EV²hildhonW`d^hidhjc`dld¨VildgdoedocVX]lVhin
lnhiŸej_|XZcVLVhonX]edaVX]^oVhidhdlVcV_dYedl^ZYc^Z_hon]ZgW^XnYldein"
bVacZ_YVlXZ#Deg‹XoiZ\docV_Yo^ZX^ZiV`èZhoZgZ\^c[dgbVX_^YdinXo|XnX]ln\a|Yj!
gdold_j!ho`dYa^ldÑX^^^ccnX]X^Z`VlnX]XZX]edhoXoZ\‹acnX]\Vijc`‹l#H|Yo^bn!
èZd\gdbc|edbdX|ldocVXoZc^j\Vijc`‹lX]lVhi‹lWŸY|YaVEV²hilVYdh`dcV¨Z
oY_ŸX^VVjidghilVEVcVIdbVhoVH^`dgh`^Z\d#OcV`db^X^ZloWd\VXV_|dcZde^hndgVo
oVgnhna^ÑX^Zc^^e^ZglhonX]a^ÑX^egonXonc^V_|Xh^ŸYdj\gjcidlVc^Vl^ZYondYVcnb
\Vijc`jX]lVhij#
ænXo|X l^Zaj jYVcnX] ajhigVX_^ edadlnX] o ViaVhZb l gŸ`j ^ igV[cnX] YZXno_^
llnWdgoZegZeVgVi‹legV\c^ZbnEV²hilVoVeZlc^!èZina`dleZ¨c^egd[Zh_dcVacZ
olVaXoVc^Z X]lVhi‹l YV_Z \lVgVcX_Ÿ jonh`Vc^V hVinh[V`X_dcj_|XnX] Z`dcdb^Xoc^Z
eadc‹l#

BVgX^c@doV`
L^Zh¨VlLd_X^ZX]dlh`^
&- &.

7c^ZXW^V¨n
BZaVcYg^jbVaWjbB^aa#
B:A6A
<d„Yo^`dlViZ!8Vgnde]naaVXZVZ
<d„Yo^Zc^Z`W^V¨n
7aVYYZgXVbe^dc
8dbeV\cdcWaVcX
LZ^›ZA^X]icZa`Z

GdÑa^cV Ylje^ZccV! _ZYcdgdXocV! YljaZic^V ajW l^ZadaZic^V# H^Zl`^ ed_Vl^V_| h^Ÿ


cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

l^dhc|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^Zg‹ènXo`dlVidh`je^dcZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс*.bb! @DGO:°/gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!W^V¨d苨in
cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ! c^ZlngV„c^Z oVdhigodcZ! çD9N<6/ lnh#(%&%%Xb!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcVdY
Za^einXocZ

o cVhVY| olŸèdc|! oW^Z\V_|X| l `g‹i`^ edYhiVln!b^Ÿ``ddl¨dh^dcV!l\‹goZaZe`V!


d\dcZ` loc^Zh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/aVcXZidlViZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!`g‹i`d!
Y¨j\dс(*bb!cV\V!WaVYdo^ZadcV b^Ÿ``ddl¨dh^dcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ edY¨j\dlVidZa^ein" @L>6IDHI6C/l^ZgoX]di`VYljgVb^ZccV
XocZ^hoZgd`dZa^einXocZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! @L>6I/  gdÑa^cV Ylje^ZccV! `l^Vin W^V¨Z!
cV hoXonX^Z iŸed olŸèdcZ ^ oV`d²XodcZ YjèZ!\gjXod¨dlViddbhodcZ!`^Za^X]`l^Vi‹l
Yo^‹W`dlVinbYgdWcnbdhigoZb bŸh`^X]gjg`dln!èZ²h`^X]gdoYŸin
DLD8/idgZW`VdlVacV!_ZYcd`dbdgdlV!di"
l^ZgV_|XVh^ŸcVhoXonX^Zo&%o|W`Vb^
C6H>:C>:/cZg`dlViZd\goW^ZX^Zlnej`¨nb!
WgdYVl`dlViZ!ede^ZaViZ!bVidlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ `dc^Xoncn! ajXZgcn! d`dedlZ! oWdèV! ¨|`^! c^Zjèni`^


<A:7N/g‹ècZ!ènocZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlVodi
ho`dYa^ldс LhX]dYnhedin`Vh^Ÿlg‹ècnX]jegVlVX]!VaZleZ¨c^gdol^_Vh^Ÿ
\¨‹lc^Zl`dc^XoncVX]!ajXZgcVX]^cV¨|`VX]#CVh^dcV`^Z¨`j_|ledl^ZgoX]c^dlZ_
lVghil^Z\aZWn#Ho`dYa^ldсÑgZYc^V#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdobcVèVh^ŸoVedbdX|cVh^dcdgVoe|Xo`‹legonWnhodlnX]cV
hon_`VX]W^V¨d苨inX]`dgoZc^#
'% '&

@dbdhVW^V¨V
8]ZcdedY^jbVaWjbA#
8=:6A
@dbdhdlViZ!8]ZcdedY^VXZVZ
AZW^dYV
;Vi]Zc
8]ZcdedYZWaVcX
LZ^hhZg<~chZ[jhh

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#@^Z¨`j_ZegoZoXV¨nd`gZhlZ\ZiVX_^#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ lhonhi`^Za^ÑX^ZdWjhigdcc^ZW^V¨d"b|Xonhiddl¨dh^dcZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ! olŸèdcZ! Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/eVadln!lgoZX^dcdlVin!bdXcn
d`#-bb!\gjWdс&!*bb!cV`g‹i`^X] çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс'%&%%Xb!iŸed`VcX^Vh"
Za^einXocZ

^X^Zc`^X]d\dc`VX]!b^Ÿh^hiZ!ol^ZgoX]j iV!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!ed`gniVb|XonhinbcVad"
bVidlZ!hoVgdo^ZadcZ!edYhedYZbXoZg" iZb!XoVhVb^XoZgldcdoVWVgl^dcV!gdÑa^cVl^Z"
ldcdÉdaZidlZ oZ hgZWgonhinb db|XoZ" adedhiVX^dlVA>Ð8>:/ig‹_`|icZ!gdbWdlViZajW
c^Zb!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ çD9Næ@6 aVcXZidlViZ! d\dc`dlZ d ob^Zccnb `hoiV¨X^Z
ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ Y¨j\dс&''*bb! ldWgŸW^ZgdÑa^cn!oln`aZ`a^cdlViZlcVhVYo^Z!
dl¨dh^dcV!XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V j¨dèdcZ h`gŸidaZ\aZ! WgoZ\^Zb ¨V\dYc^Z o|W`d"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^ZglhoVeVgV_V_dlV" lVcZ! hoVgdo^ZadcZ! \‹gcZ a^ÑX^Z aVcXZidlViZ!
iZoc^ZlngV„cnb^o|W`Vb^Wa^èZ_cVhVYn XV¨dWgoZ\^Z @L>6IDHI6C/ `¨ŸW^`^ \Ÿhid`l^V"
ajWXV¨dWgoZ\^Z!`daZ_cZa^ÑX^ZgdbWdlViZ idlZ h`je^dcZ l `¨dh e^gVb^YVacn @L>6I/
d `a^cdlViZ_ cVhVYo^Z! lngV„c^Z e¨ni`d YgdWcn! o^Zadc`Vln d e^ŸX^j a^hi`VX] d`l^Vij!
lX^ŸiZ o ed_ZYncXonb^ dYaZ\¨nb^ o|W" olngV„c^Z lnhiV_|Xnb^ \goW^ZiZb! e^Ÿ egŸX^"
`Vb^ `‹l!ocVb^dcVh¨je`V`g‹i`^ZDLD8/dgoZhoZ`!
YgdWcn! hoVgdXoVgcn! d`g|\¨Vln! hdXoZl`dlVid
he¨VhoXodcn! l d`l^VX^Z `l^VidhiVcj j¨dèdcn
e^dcdld!XoŸhidd`gninoZhX]¨nbd`l^ViZb
C6H>:C>:/ XoVgcZ!aÑc^|XZ!edYYjènbedl^Ÿ"
`hoZc^ZbWVgYodYZa^`Vic^Zejc`idlVcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ d`dedlZ! oWdèdlZ! goZeV`! hiVcdl^h`V g‹ècZ <A:7N/


ènocZ! eg‹X]c^XocZ! oVhdWcZ l Vodi ho`dYa^ldс ?ZYcV Ydgdh¨V gdÑa^cV bdèZ lni"
ldgon Yd `^a`j inh^ŸXn cVh^dc! `i‹gZ dYocVXoV_| h^Ÿ dYedgcdÑX^| cV c^Zhegon_V_|XZ lVgjc`^
ÑgdYdl^h`VdgVooVX]dlj_|l\aZW^ZènldicdсegoZo`^a`VaVi#@dbdhVW^V¨VedoWVl^V\aZWŸ
YjènX]^adÑX^h`¨VYc^`‹led`VgbdlnX]!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZediVhj#EdcVYid_Zhiènl^X^ZaZbg‹ècnX]
eVid\Zc‹lWŸY|XnX]V\gd[V\Vb^gdÑa^cjegVlcnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|Yjèdh`¨VYc^`‹ldYènlXonX]!edheVgoZc^jbd\|Wn
jèni`dlVcZ_V`deVhoVYaVol^Zgo|i#B¨dYZgdÑa^cn@dbdhnW^V¨Z_h|Wd\ViZll^iVb^cŸ8Yd
'-(b\!bd\|WnhedènlVcZ_V`hoe^cV`egoZoajYo^ajW_V`deVhoVo^ZadcVYaVol^Zgo|i#
'' '(

@dc^XoncVedacV
Ig^[da^jbVgkZchZA#
IG;6G
Bdina`dlViZ!;VWVXZVZEVe^a^dcVXZVZ
@di`^
=VgZÁh"[ddiXadkZg
GãÊZ YZh X]Vbeh
6X`Zg"@aZZi

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocVajWYljaZic^V!cVedaVX]jegVlcnX]_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ\¨‹lc^Zl^dhc|#

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ!Y¨#()bb!cV @DGO:°/eVadln!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
hoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ!cV`g‹i`^X]d\dc" çD9N<6/ lnh#*(%)%Xb!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!
Za^einXocZ

`VX]!X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!ajWXoZgldcVldcV" gdoZh¨VcV ajW edYcdho|XV h^Ÿ! lgVo o a^сb^


W^Z\¨Z!c^ZXdhdXonhiZ `dhbVid"hoVgddl¨dh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ igonWaVho`dlZ!da^hi`VX]edY¨j\d"
Y¨# )*bb! h¨VWd gdol^c^ŸiV! `g‹i`V!
lVidhZgXdlVinX]!ed`gninX]goVY`^b^l¨dh"
X^Zc`V!jYd¨jW^V¨VlV!j\‹gnWgjcVicd" `Vb^!ÑgdY`dlna^hiZ`l^Ÿ`hondYWdXocnX]
XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V @L>6IDHI6C/ \¨‹l`V!`dhbViddl¨dh^dcV!
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhona^сdlVacn! XoŸhidXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V
cVhoXonX^ZoYgdWcnblX^ŸX^Zb!ed`gnin @L>6I/ XoZgldcn!g‹èdlnajWegVl^ZW^V¨n!
l¨dh`Vb^!od\dc`^ZbYlj`gdic^ZY¨jè" `dgdcV`l^VijWVgYodYgdWcV
honbdYWaVho`^a^ÑX^dlZ_ DLD8/ hig|`!YgdWcn!XoŸhiddijadcn`^Za^"
X]Zb
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZX^Zb" C6H>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ!_Vhcd苨iZ!o^Zadcd苨iZ
cdo^ZadcZ!ajWXoZgldcVldcVW^Z\¨Z!¨d" ajWWgjcVicZ!dh¨VWnbed¨nh`j
Ynè`V edYa^ÑX^Zc^dlV j Yd¨j W^V¨VlV!
j\‹gnWgjcVicdXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V!gdÑ"
a^cV \Ÿhid! `dhbVid dl¨dh^dcV! \¨‹l`^
`dhbViddl¨dh^dcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèV!^ccZ\Vijc`^!¨|`^<A:7N/e^VhoXonhiZ!e^VhoXon"
hid"\a^c^VhiZ!hjX]Zlo\‹goV
ho`dYa^ldс ?V`d gdÑa^cV bdina`dlV _Zhi Yd eZlcZ\d hidec^V edèniZXocV!
\Ynèjèn„c^V\aZWŸ^bVeZlc|lVgidсeVhiZlc|lh¨dbVX]oW‹è!l`dc^XoncVX]
c^Zedè|YVcVoZlo\aŸYjcVoVc^ZXonhoXoZc^ZcVh^dc#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ O^ZaZ@dc^XoncnedacZ_hidhdlVcdlo^d¨daZXoc^Xil^ZajYdlnb#
') '*

@gonldhon_edacn
AnXdeh^hVgkZch^hA#
AN86G
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

HbVaaWj\adhh
EZi^iZWj\adhhZ
6X`Zg"@gjbb]Vah

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bV^_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|!cVedXo|i`jaViV^ _Z"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

h^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^Zol^ZgoX]jhodghi`dhoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ!gdÑa^"
cVhoinlcd^`¨j_|Xddl¨dh^dcV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ! Y¨# &%&(bb! @DGO:°/gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
hoZgd`^Z!cVhoXonX^ZiŸedolŸèdcZ!jYd¨j çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&*)*Xb!dW¨V!loc^Z"
Za^einXocZ

`a^cdlVid oW^Z\V_|XZ! o^ZadcZ! cV l^Zgo" h^dcVajWedYcdho|XVh^Ÿ!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcVajWc^Z!


X]jhodghi`dhoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ!edY l¨dh`^`¨j_|XZdYhiV_|XZ
hedYZboln`aZcV\^Z A>Ð8>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!dWgoZ\j[Va^hinb!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ YgdWcd lX^cVcd o|W`dlVcZ ajW XV¨dWgoZ\^Z!
Y¨j\dс&'&*bb!\gjWVlV!o^Zadc`V" \‹gcZ ¼ hZgXdlViZ! egVl^Z h^ZYo|XZ! YdacZ
lV!cV\V!lVaXdlViV ¼d\dc`dlZ
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ h`gŸidaZ\¨Z! aVcXZid" @L>6IDHI6C/ja^hic^dcVh`gŸi`V
lViZ!dWjhigdcc^ZhoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ @L>6I/_Vhcdc^ZW^Zh`^dYhedYjoW^V¨|`daVc"
`dlVido\^Ÿi|gjg`|`dgdcn!cV`g‹i`^Z_hon"
ej¨XZ
DLD8/ dgoZhoZ`!l`hoiV¨X^ZeVcid[Za`V!
ooVd`g|\adcnbhoXoniZb!YgdWcdWgdYVl`d"
lVcn!hoVgnajWXoVgcdWgjcVicn
C6H>:C>:/edY¨jècZ!hoVgZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZ!c^Zjèni`^ <A:7N/ e^VhoXonhiZ!hj"


X]Z^l^a\dicZ!oV`lVhodcZajWlVe^ZccZ
ho`dYa^ldс @gonldhon__Zhi\dhedYVgoZbedÑgZYc^bgYonWgjcVicZ_èniV!cV
a^ÑX^VX]iZ\dX]lVhijildgo|h^Ÿl^dhZccZoVgdYc^`^Îd\c^`dlZ¿oV`VèV_|XZèniddo^bZ#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ EdYd_goZc^jWVgYod¨Vilddhnej_Zh^Ÿ^oVX]lVhoXoV\aZWŸ#8oŸhid
hedin`Vcnol¨VhoXoVle‹¨cdXcZ_^lhX]dYc^Z_XoŸÑX^`gV_j#
'+ ',

BVgjcVWZoldccV
BVig^XVg^V^cdYdgVA#
B6I>C
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

HXZciaZhhXdbdb^aaZ
8dbdb^aaZ^cdYdgZ
<ZgjX]adhZ@Vb^aaZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!YljaZic^VajWl^ZadaZic^V#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|^_Zh^Zc^|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Z^¨dYn\VedgdoiVgX^jWZooVeVX]jedl|X]V_!`dhon"
Xo`^`l^VidlZdYc^ZeZ¨cnb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс()bb! @DGO:°/X^Zc`^!lgoZX^dcdlVin
YgdWcZ! cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ! cV hoXonX^Z oVd" çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс &*+%Xb! d`g|\¨VlV!
Za^einXocZ

`g|\adcZ dYed¨dlngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!cV\V
çD9Næ@6 ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/Ylj"VaWdigon`gdic^Ze^ZgoVhidh^ZXo"
Y¨#(&%bb!cV\V!o^ZadcV cZ! dYX^c`^ g‹lcdl|h`d aVcXZidlViZ o hoZg"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ dhoXoZedlVidig‹_" honbdYX^c`^ZbhoXonidlnb!b^Ÿh^hiZ
Yo^ZacZajWed_ZYncXode^ZgoVhidYo^ZacZ! @L>6IDHI6C/`dhonXoZ`cVlnY¨jèdcZ_hon"
cV\^Z!X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ ej¨XZ
@L>6I/ `l^VinWgoZècZ_ŸonXo`dlViZW^V¨Z!
`l^VinlZlcŸigocZgjg`dlZ苨iZ!Ycd`l^V"
idlZlneZ¨c^dcZ!hidè`dlZ
DLD8/c^Z¨je`V\gVc^Vhidh¨jedlV!cVhoXon"
X^ZÑX^ŸiV!X^ZbcdWg|odlV
C6H>:C>:/c^ZgZ\jaVgcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!goZeV`!iglV¨Zjèni`^o^ZadcZ!hiV"
cdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ <A:7N/ g‹ècZinen\aZWhoXoZ\‹ac^Z\a^c^VhiZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!l^a"
\dicZ!edheda^inX]lVhicVXV¨nbdWhoVgoZ`gV_j
ho`dYa^ldс 7VgYod YjèV e¨dYcdс gdÑa^c! lnYV_| edcVY &%% %%% cVh^dc
o_ZYcZ_gdÑa^cn#OVX]dlj_|ènldicdсYdhoZÑX^jaVi#BdèZ`^Z¨`dlVXV¨ngd`!h^ac^Z
oVX]lVhoXoV_|XjegVln#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgV\VgWc^`^!bVl¨VÑX^ldÑX^dlVYdW‹_XoZ#CVh^dcVoV"
l^ZgV_|Yd'%i¨jhoXoj#
'- '.

BaZXoolnXoV_cn
HdcX]jhdaZgVXZjhA#
HDCDA
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ
çdXon\VlVgonlcV
8dbbdchdl"i]^hiaZ
AV^iZgdca^hhZ
@d]a"<~chZY^hiZa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸcV_a^Xoc^Z_l^dhc|^cVedXo|i`jaViV#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdÑa^cVoW^V¨nbhd`^ZbbaZXocnb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс*,bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!WVgYodgdo\V¨Ÿo^d"
o^ZadcZ!cV\^Z!cVhoXonX^ZiŸeZ!`g‹i`d" cn!honW`dgdhc|Xn
Za^einXocZ

d\dc`dlZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс(%.%Xb!oW^V¨nbhd"


çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ `^Zb baZXocnb! cV\V! \gjWV! ejhiV! loc^Z"
Y¨j\dс(*bb!_Vhcdo^ZadcV!ed`gniV h^dcV!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV
cVadiZbWgjcVicnb A>Ð8>:/ a^gdlViZ!edlX^cVcZ!\gjWd^YgdWcd
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhona^сd`g|\ o|W`dlVcZ!dYXolVgiZ\da^ÑX^Ved`gniZW^V"
¨Vln!`daZ_cZaVcXZidlViZ!h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!cV ¨nb^l¨dh`Vb^
hoXonX^Z^ l cVhVYo^ZiŸeZ @L>6IDHI6C/ c^Za^XocZ`dhonXo`^!oZWgVcZ
lWVaYVho`dlViZl^ZX]n
@L>6I/ _ŸonXo`dlVin! WaVYd苨in! l YdacZ_
XoŸÑX^ejgejgdldegŸ\dlVcn
DLD8/ c^Z¨je`V!Yd¨Zb^\‹g|olŸèdcV!
oigoZbVèZWZg`Vb^!苨iVldWgjcVicZ!he¨Vho"
XodcZ
C6H>:C>:/edY¨jècZ!he¨VhoXodcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!^ccZ\Vijc`^_VgZ!d\gdYn!hVYn
\a^c^VhiZ!ènocZ!aèZ_hoZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlVodi!c^Z`lVÑcZ
<A:7N/
ho`dYa^ldс HoinlcV!dhigVgdÑa^cV!lnXoZgej_|XV\aZWŸoVodij#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ LÑgZYc^dl^ZXojjegVl^VcV_V`dgdÑa^cVlVgonlcV#
(% (&

Bc^hoZ`edheda^in
IVgVmVXjbd[ÉX^cVaZ LZW#
I6GD;
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ
9bjX]Vl^ZX!BaZXoPcVolVc^ZegVl^Y¨dlVR
8dbbdcYVcYZa^dc
E^hhZca^i
<ZbZ^cZgAŽlZcoV]c
GdÑa^cVl^ZadaZic^V#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|!hoXoZ\‹ac^Za^Xoc^ZcV`dc^ZXbV_V#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

Le^Zglhonbgd`jlZ\ZiVX_^lnilVgoV_|g‹ènXo`^a^ÑX^dlZ^bV\Voncj_|Vhnb^aVin
lo\gjW^V¨nb`dgoZc^j!cVhiŸec^Zo^bj_|^oV`l^iV_|lcVhiŸecnbgd`j#

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ!XoŸhidegVl^Z`d" @DGO:°/ eVadln!\gjWn!j\‹gnh^ac^Zgdo\V"
a^hiZloVgnh^Z!Y¨j\dс*,bb!lcV" ¨Ÿo^V_|Xnh^Ÿ!\¨ŸWd`^Ydd`d¨d*%XbçD9N<6/
Za^einXocZ

hVYo^ZolŸèdcZ!o^ZadcZ!cV\^Z lnh#&%(%!goVYo^Z_Yd*%Xb¨dYn\V`l^V"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ idhiVcdlV!ejhiVlÑgdY`j!WZoa^hicVA>Ð8>:/
Y¨#*&%bb!WgjcVicdo^ZadcV!cV\V oZWgVcZlegono^Zbc|g‹ènXo`Ÿ!edY¨j\dlVid
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/dlVacn!dWgoZ\VX]l^Z" aVcXZidlViZ! _Vhcdo^ZadcZ! oln`aZ oVid`dld
adWdXoc^Z¨VbVcnX]!oYgdWcnb^dhignb^ e^ZgoVhid lX^cVcZ d ¨deVi`VX] ig‹_`|icnX]!
o|W`Vb^cVY`|iVb^^`a^cdlVi|cVhVY|! h`^ZgdlVcnX]lin¨ajWgoVYo^Z_c^ZedYo^ZadcZ!
_Vhcdo^Zadcn!cV\^ cV\^ZajWaZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ@L>6IDHI6C/`d"
honXoZ`!Yjèn'!**Xb!a^XocZa^hi`^d`gnln!
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ ¨deVi`^a^ÑX^V aVcXZidlViZ!h^ac^ZdY\^ŸiZ @L>6I/ _Vhcd苨in!
ig‹_`|icZ! oZlcŸigocZ a^hi`^ d`gnln `d" _Vh`gVln! _ŸonXo`dln! de^ŸX^j o|W`VX]! dWj"
honXo`V `l^VidhiVcdlZ\d dY\^ŸiZ! `d" e¨X^dlnDLD8/c^Z¨je`VedY¨j\dlViV!_Vhcd"
honXo`^dÑgZYc^Xnd`d¨d*Xb WgjcVicVajWo^Zadc`VldhoVgV!Xoldgd\gVc^Vh"
iV! j \‹gn olŸèV_|XV h^Ÿ l Y¨j\^ c^i`dlVin
Yo^‹WZ`!oVdeVigodcnlejX]`^Za^X]dln!aZ``d
he¨VhoXodcV C6H>:C>:/ l egoZ`gd_j gdbWd"
^YVacZ!_VhcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/`dc^Xoncn!ajXZgcn!d`dedlZld\gdYVX]!igVln!hVYn<A:7N/
\a^c^VhiZ! ènocZ! c^Z`lVÑcZ ho`dYa^ldс GdobcVèV h^Ÿ oVg‹lcd \ZcZgVinlc^Z egoZo
c^Z¨je`^oejX]Zb`^Za^X]dlnbegoZcdhodcZegoZol^VigcVYjèZdYaZ\¨dÑX^!_V`^lZ\ZiVinl"
c^ZegoZodYgdhin`dgoZc^dlZYo^Ÿ`^e|Xo`db`Vajhdlnb[gV\bZcin`dgoZc^V&'Xbbd\|
YV cdl| gdÑa^cŸ# IgjYcn l olVaXoVc^j! h^ac^Z d\gVc^XoV gdol‹_ gdÑa^c! hoXoZ\‹ac^Z \Vijc`‹l
ljegVlVX]l^ZadaZic^X]# X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVaZXoc^XoV^igj_|XVln`dgonhinlVcZh|
`dgoZc^Z^a^ÑX^Z#CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|d`d¨d'%i¨jhoXoj#@dgoZc^Z!a^ÑX^Z^`l^VinoVl^ZgV_|\dgnXo
iVgV`hVXncŸ!`dgoZc^Z¼\VgWc^`^!`VjXoj`^^cja^cŸ#GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgVd`d¨d&((b\l^iVb^cn
8!VedcVYid6!7&!7'!9^Yjèdhda^ediVhdlnX]#B¨dYZ!c^ZojeZ¨c^Zgdol^c^ŸiZa^ÑX^Zbd\|Wn
hedènlVcZ_V`dhV¨Vi`Vl^dhZccV!`dgoZc^ZlnegVèdcZhiVcdl^|cVb^Vhi`ŸXn`dg^^#
(' ((

Dhig‹èZXo`VedacV
8dchda^YVgZ\Va^hH#;#<gVn9Zae]^c^jbXdchda^YVA#
8CHG:
?Vh`gdlViZ!GVcjcXjaVXZVZ
Dhig‹è`VedacV
;dg`^c\aVg`hejg
E^ZYYÁVadjZiiZ
6X`Zg"G^iiZghedgc

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ d`l^Vih`¨VYVh^Ÿoe^ŸX^jXoŸÑX^!\‹gcVXoŸÑd`l^Vijed"
h^VYVedegoZXoc|dhigd\Ÿ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс)*bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!h¨VWdgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!
cV\^Z!egoncVhVYo^ZaZ``ddbhodcZ!o^Z" WgjcVicVln
Za^einXocZ

adcZ!`jhoXonidl^aZ``dolŸèdcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс'%*%Xb!gdo\V¨Ÿo^d"


çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ cV!egonaZ\aZdl¨dh^dcV
Y¨#&''*bb!cV\V!XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V A>Ð8>:/ Ylj"ajWigon`gdic^Zig‹_h^ZXocZ!
ajWWgjcVicV h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!o^ZadcZ!`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhona^сe^ŸX^d" @L>6IDHI6C/aj„cZ\gdcd
`aVedlVcn!dYlgdic^Z_V_dlVin @L>6I/ c^ZW^Zh`^ZoÉdaZidlnb dYX^Zc^Zb
dhigd\VajWc^ZW^Zh`d"ÉdaZidld"h^cZ
DLD8/ b^ZhoZ`!he¨VhoXodcn!cV\^!cV\aZ
olŸèdcnlY¨j\|hon_`Ÿ
C6H>:C>:/ dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ!dhoXonX^Z
olŸèdcnb! ed`gniZ YVX]‹l`dlVinb^! h`‹"
goVhinb^WgdYVl`Vb^!X^ZbcdWgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèV <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ!gŸYo^cn!oVhdWcZllŸ\aVc


lVec^V!goVYo^Z_cV\aZWVX]aèZ_honX]
ho`dYa^ldс OVX]lVhoXoVegoZYZlhonhi`^boWdèVdo^bZ#LnhiŸej_ZcVXV¨nb
c^èj!edheda^iV#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcV!`l^Vin^o^ZaZoVl^ZgV_|igj_|XZVa`Vad^Yn!egdhoZ`ocVh^dc
_ZhihidhdlVcn_V`d^chZ`inXnY#GdÑa^cVb^dYdYV_cV#
() (*

Egonb^dicd`VcVYn_h`^Z
:g^\ZgdcXVcVYZch^hA#
:G>86
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

8VcVY^VcÊZVWVcZ
KZg\ZgZiiZYj8VcVYV
@VcVY^hX]Zh7Zgj[h`gVji

CVedaVX]jegVlcnX]gdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#CVc^Zjèni`VX]YljaZi"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

c^V#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|^_Zh^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^Z_V_dlViZ!`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcZ!X^ZbcdhoVgZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс()bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!X^Zc`^
YgdWcZ!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ! çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&*&%%Xb!gdo\V¨Ÿo^d"
Za^einXocZ

cVl^ZgoX]jYgdWcddl¨dh^dcZ!cV`g‹i" cV!egdhiV!hodghi`ddl¨dh^dcV
`^bd\dc`j A>Ð8>:/g‹lcdl|h`daVcXZidlViZ!Y¨j\doVd"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ higodcZ!hoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ!YdacZgoVY`d
Y¨# '( bb! `g‹i`V! h¨VWd gdol^c^ŸiV! o|W`dlVcZ
c^Z`^ZYnejgejgdldh^cV!cV\V @L>6IDHI6C/ `dhonXo`^!YgdWcZ!h`je^dcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!X^ZbcdhoVgZ ll|h`^Zl^ZX]n
`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcZ! @L>6I/`l^VinYgdWcZ!WgjYcdW^V¨Z!WgoZècZ!
h¨je`dlZ!lZlc|igogjg`dlZ!dWje¨X^dlZ
DLD8/ c^Z¨je`VedY¨j\dlViV!c^ZXdhe¨Vho"
XodcV! edY¨jèc^Z aZ``d WgjoY`dlVcV! _Vhcd"
hoVgV!dl¨dh^dcVejX]Zb`^Za^X]dlnb
C6H>:C>:/edY¨jècZ!_VhcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/g‹ècZ\Vijc`^!d\gdYn!hVYn!j\dgn<A:7N/aZ``^Z!hj"
X]Z!cV_XoŸÑX^Z_e^VhoXonhiZ!jc^`V\aZWlVe^ZccnX]
ho`dYa^ldс Egonb^dicd `VcVYn_h`^Z _Zhi edheda^inb X]lVhiZb l c^èhonX]
eVgi^VX] \‹gh`^X] ^ cV c^èj# çVild h^Ÿ gdoegoZhigoZc^V Yo^Ÿ`^ adicnb c^Z¨je`db!
`i‹gZgdoh^ZlVl^Vig#9dсh^ac^Z`dc`jgj_Zo\Vijc`Vb^jegVlcnb^dh`¨VYc^`^ed"
`VgbdlZ#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ O^ZaZoVl^ZgVdaZ_Z`ZiZgnXocnYd&!,^ÊVldcd^Yn#
(+ (,

Egonija^VXoZecV
<Va^jbVeVg^cZA#
<6A6E
BVgoVcdlViZ!GjW^VXZVZ
Egonija^VaZeXonXV
8aZVkZgh
<V^aaZi\gViiZgdc
@aZiiZcaVW`gVji

LjegVlVX]edadlnX]gdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dh"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

c|^_Zh^Zc^|#LaVhVX]\VijcZ`l^ZadaZic^#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ XV¨VgdÑa^cVh^ac^ZoVYo^ZgonhiV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ! Y¨# ,&-bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
lnY¨jèdcZ! cV hoXonX^Z l|h`d lX^ŸiZ! çD9N<6/ lnh#(%&*%Xb!lhe^cV_|XVh^Ÿ!
Za^einXocZ

o^ZadcZcV\^Z!olngV„cnbh^ViZXo`dlV" \V¨Ÿo^hiV!XoiZgd`VcX^VhiV!h^ac^ZoVYo^ZgonhiV!
inb jcZgl^Zc^Zb! cV X^Zc`^X] Y¨j\^X] l lŸo¨VX] c^ZXd o\gjW^V¨V! hoinlcd dl¨d"
d\dc`VX] h^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ `a^cdlVidaVcXZidlViZ!cVWgoZ\VX]
Y¨j\dс&*'%bb!dW¨V!cV\V!c^Z`^Z" ^edYhedYZbh^ac^ZoVYo^ZgonhiZ!oZWgVcZed
YnXoZgldcVldÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V hoZсYddÑb^jld`‹¨`VX]
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ h`je^dcZld`‹¨`j! @L>6IDHI6C/ WVaYVX]d`hoiV¨icn!Ylj"VaWd
l a^XoW^Z XoiZgZX]! dlVacZ! cV hoXonX^Z igon`l^Vi`dln
oVdhigodcZ! egVl^Z h^ZYo|XZ! cV WgoZ\j @L>6I/`l^Vinl`|iVX]a^ÑX^!oZWgVcZedYlV
ed`gniZYgdWcnb^!h^ac^ZoVYo^Zgonhinb^! YdigoZX]!W^V¨ZajWo^Zadc`VldW^V¨Z!egoZlVè"
]VXon`dlVinb^hoXoZX^c`Vb^ c^ZdWje¨X^dlZ
DLD8/ gdo¨je`V`ja^hiV!ed`gniV\Ÿhinb^!
]VXon`dlVinb^hoXoZX^c`Vb^
C6H>:C>:/aZ``dcZg`dlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèV!d`dedlZ!goZeV`^goZe^`!d\gdYn!aVhn!oVgdÑaV


<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!l^a\dicZ
ho`dYa^ldс Egonija^V dYocVXoV h^Ÿ Yjè| oYdacdÑX^| egonhidhdlVlXo| Yd lV"
gjc`‹lh^ZYa^h`V!edldYj_|XlnaZ\Vc^ZgdÑa^c^jigjYc^V_|XoW^‹gbZX]Vc^Xocn#H^ac^Z
`dc`jgj_Zo\Vijc`Vb^jegVlcnb^dÑl^Vi¨d^h`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ!egoZoXdln"
XoZgej_Z\aZWŸoZh`¨VYc^`‹led`VgbdlnX]#CVh^dcVegoZcdhodcZh|obViZg^V¨Zb
h^ZlcnboW‹è!\YnèigjYcdh^Ÿ_ZdYYo^ZaVdYo^VgcV!ViV`èZegoZoajYo^^ol^ZgoŸiV#
8]lVhigdoegoZhigoZc^¨h^Ÿ\¨‹lc^Zedd`gZh^ZhidhdlVc^V]ZgW^XnY‹linejgZ\jaVid"
g‹llogdhij!cV`i‹gZ_ZhiXoŸÑX^dlddYedgcn#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ O^ZaZoVl^ZgV`jbVgncŸ^XoZgldcnWVglc^`!VcigVejejgncŸ#
(- (.

GYZhi`daVc`dln
Edan\dcjbaVeVi]^[da^jbA#2EZgh^XVg^VaVeVi]^[da^VA#H#;#<gVn
EDAA6
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

EVaZeZgh^Xg^V
GZcdj‚Zª[Zj^aaZhYZeVi^ZcXZ
6be[Zg"@cŽiZg^X]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸedY`dc^ZXl^dhcn^lXoZhcnbaViZb#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^ZcVYdacZ_higdc^Zo^ZadcZ!cV\^Z!gdÑa^cVoln`aZo\gj"
W^V¨VllŸo¨VX]!`l^VidhiVcnlnY¨jèdcZ!lVaXdlViZ!W^V¨VlZajWXoZgldcVlZ!`l^V"
inc^Zed`gniZ\gjXod¨Vb^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
edY¨jèc^ZZa^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
A>Ð8>:C>:/
&%&* bb! o dWj higdc `g‹i`d dl¨d" çD9N<6/ lnh# (%&%%Xb! cV\V! oln`aZ
Za^einXocZ

h^dcZ llŸo¨VX]o\gjW^V¨V!loc^Zh^dcVajWgdoZh¨VcV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlVidaVcXZidlViZ!oVdhigodcZ!cV
Y¨# &%&* bb! lVaXdlViV! XoZgldcd `g‹i`^X]d\dc`VX]deVginX]dcVhVYnoln`aZ
cVW^Z\¨V!cV\VajW`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcV gdoYŸinX] cV\^X] \ViZ` edX]Zl W¨dc^Vh"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhona^сedY¨j" inX]!XoŸhidoaZ``|eaVb`|lÑgdY`jWaVho`^
\dlVin!YVahoZa^ÑX^ZaVcXZidlViZ!h`gŸid" @L>6IDHI6C/ `¨dhoW^inlnY¨jèdcn!j\‹gn
aZ\¨Z olŸèdcn!aZ``dol^hV_|Xn
@L>6I/ YgdWcn!d`l^ViW^V¨najWg‹èdlVln!
honej¨`^`l^Vi‹loln`aZWZo\gjXod¨‹l
DLD8/ dgoZX]!YgdWcn!`ja^hin!odWjhigdc
l`aŸh¨n!l\‹gcZ_XoŸÑX^oVdhigodcnlYo^‹WZ`!
he¨VhoXodcn!X^ZbcdWgjcVicn!ed¨nh`j_|Xn
C6H>:C>:/edY¨jècZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZol¨VhoXoV_VgZ <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ!


X^Ÿè`^Z!edYbd`¨Z!aZ``d`lVÑcZ
ho`dYa^ldс ?ZhiidX]lVhil^ZajjegVl!oZlo\aŸYjcVlnèhoZlnbV\Vc^ViZg"
b^XocZlhX]dYo^e‹„c^Z_c^èGYZhieaVb^hin#LnYV_ZcVh^dcVdl^ZadaZic^Z_ènldicdÑ"
X^!o_ZYcZ_gdÑa^cnd`#&%%%hoij`#Ildgong‹ècZ[dgbn!edYdWcZce#YdGYZhij\gj"
Xod¨dlViZ\d#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ OZ lo\aŸYj cV hidhjc`dld lnhd`^Z lnbV\Vc^V l^a\dicdÑX^dlZ
ajW^hiVcdl^h`Vld`da^XnoW^dgc^`‹lldYcnX]^X^Z`‹l#
)% )&

GYZhieaVb^hin
Edan\dcjbeZgh^XVg^VA#
EDAE:
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

GZYh]Vc`
GZcdj‚ZeZgh^XV^gZ
;ad]"@cŽiZg^X]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸlbV_j^XoZglXj#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^ZoWgjcVicdXoZgldc|eaVb|cVhigdc^ZoZlcŸigocZ_

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZajWdYlgdic^Z_V_d" @DGO:°/gdol^Yadcn
lViZ! Y¨# +-bb! cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ VaWd çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс'%+%Xb!`daVc`dlV"
Za^einXocZ

XoZgldcVlZ!cVhoXonX^ZiŸeZajWoVd`g|" iV!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!lnegdhidlVcVajWc^Z"
\adcZ XdaZè|XV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/aVcXZidlViZ!hoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ!
Y¨j\dс+&%bb!cV\V!XoZgldcdajW o W¨dc^Vhi| edX]l| l b^Z_hXj lngVhiV_|XnX]
ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V a^ÑX^ÑX^ÑaZegonaZ\V_|XVYd¨dYn\^
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ Za^einXocZ!h`|eddl" @L>6IDHI6C/`¨dh!lVaXdlVin!\Ÿhin!egdhin
¨dh^dcZ!h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!lcVhVYo^ZoW¨dc^Vh" ajWaZ``do\^Ÿin
i|edX]l| @L>6IN/g‹èdlZ!WVgYodgoVY`dW^V¨VlZ
DLD8/ig‹_\gVc^VhindgoZhoZ`!oVdhigodcncV
_ZYcnb`d²Xj!XoVgcn
C6H>:C>:/he¨VhoXodcZ!X^ZbcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZ!goZeV`!d\gdYn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZ"
gVacZ<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!l^a\dicZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ\¨‹l"
c^ZVodi
ho`dYa^ldс DgoZho`^h|l\aZW^ZWVgYodiglV¨Z!c^ZigVX|oYdacdÑX^`^Z¨`dlV"
c^VcVlZiYd'%aVi#C^ZigVX|iV`èZènldicdÑX^edegoZ_ÑX^jegoZoegoZl‹Yed`Vgbd"
lnol^Zgo|i!hi|YdWZXcZldWdgc^`joVX]lVhoXoV_|edcdlc^ZjegVln#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVb^dYdYV_cV!edldYj_ZjXojaZc^Vjol^Zgo|iW^V¨djbVho"
XodcnX]edYle¨nlZbÑl^Vi¨V#EdldYj_ZoVigjX^VjigodYnX]aZlcZ_#
)' )(

HiVgoZXolnXoV_cn
HZcZX^dkja\Vg^hA#
H:CKJ
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

<gdjcYhZa
H‚cZâdckja\V^gZ
<ZbZ^cZh<Z^h`gVji

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸbVhdldhoXoZ\‹ac^Zl^dh"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

c|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZlngV„c^ZcVl^ZgoX]jX^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!h^ac^Zed¨nh"
`j_|XZ!edYhedYZbg‹èdlZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ Za^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс*-bb! @DGO:°/ gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn oa^Xocnb^ WdXocnb^
cV\^Z!cVl^ZgoX]jX^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!ed¨nh" dY\V¨Ÿo^Zc^Vb^
Za^einXocZ

`j_|XZ!edYhedYZbg‹èdlVlZ!cVhoXon" çD9N<6/ lnh#&*)%Xb!d`g|\¨VlV!gdo"


X^ZiŸeZajWaZ``doVd`g|\adcZ \V¨Ÿo^dcV! loc^Zh^dcV! cV\V ajW aZ``d eV_Ÿ"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ XoncdlViddl¨dh^dcV
Y¨#*&%bb!cV\V!j\‹gnh^cVldWgj" A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼edY¨j\dlVid"¨deVi`dlViZ!
cVicdcVW^Z\¨V olŸèV_|XZh^Ÿld\dcZ`!X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!e^¨`d"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/dlVacZ!cV\^Z!h`gŸid" lVcZ!\‹gcZ¼oZWgVcZlg‹ènXo`VX]!ed`gniZ
aZ\¨Z!WgoZ\^Zbo`VèYZ_higdcndYigoZX] X^Zc`^b^!hoVgnb^l¨dh`Vb^
YdXoiZgZX]o|W`‹l @L>6IDHI6C/ `dhonXoZ`oZWgVcZl\ŸhiZ!
gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcZl^ZX]n
@L>6I/ oZlcŸigocnX]_ŸonXo`dlnX]¼WgV`!
`l^VinlZlcŸigocZ¼gjg`dlZ苨iZ
DLD8/ c^Z¨je`V!edY¨j\dlViV!èZWZg`dlV"
cV!X^ZbcdhoVgV!¨VilddYeVYV_|XnejX]`^Z"
a^X]dln
C6H>:C>:/lnY¨jèdcZ!he¨VhoXodcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d\gdYn!d`dedlZ!bdina`dlZl^ZadaZic^Z!hiVcdl^h`V
gjYZgVacZ<A:7N/eg‹X]c^XocZ!l^a\dicZ!oVhdWcZlVodi
ho`dYa^ldс 8]lVhilhX]dYo^egoZoXV¨nd`gZhlZ\ZiVXn_cn!YV_|X`^a`Ved`d"
aZ²lX^|\jgd`j#DldXZdog‹èc^XdlVcnbd`gZh^ZhedXonc`j!bd\|`^Z¨`dlVcV"
inX]b^VhiedYd_goZc^j#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cV igj_|XV! XoŸÑ o^ZacV oVl^ZgV Va`Vad^Yn# EdYZ_goZlV h^Ÿ _|
dl¨VÑX^ldÑX^`VcXZgd\ZccZ#
)) )*

IVhoc^`edheda^in
8VehZaaVWjghV"eVhidg^hA#BZY#
86E7E
@VejhidlViZ@gonèdlZ!7gVhh^XVXZVZ8gjX^[ZgVZ

H]Ze]ZgYÁh"ejghZ
8VehZaaZWdjghZªeVhiZjg
=^giZci~hX]Za`gVji

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|!cVedXo|i`jaViV
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

^_Zh^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ lhonhi`^Za^ÑX^Zed`gniZ\l^VoY`dlVinb^^ed_ZYncXonb^
l¨dh`Vb^edg‹lcV_IdWd¨`^edacZ¼cV\^Z

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/Za^einXocZ!Y¨#')bb!Ygd" @DGO:°/ lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!W^V"
WcZ!cV\^Z!_Vhcdo^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZiŸeZ ¨Vln
Za^einXocZ

çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ çD9N<6/ lnh#(+%Xb!loc^Zh^dcV!oln`"


Y¨j\dс*,bb!cV\V!W^V¨VlV aZgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!dl¨dh^dcVajWgoVYo^Z_cV\V!
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ! gdÑa^cVl^ZadedhiVX^dlV
\l^VoY`dlViddl¨dh^dcZ!cVegoZX^laZ\" A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼Za^einXocZoZWgVcZlg‹"
¨Z!XV¨dWgoZ\^Z ènXo`Ÿ!\‹gcZ¼h^ZYo|XZ!lX^cVcZoo|W`Vb^!
\l^VoY`dlVid dl¨dh^dcZ! o|W`dlVcZ ¼ goV"
Yo^Z_XV¨dWgoZ\^Z
@L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
@L>6I/`l^VinYgdWcZ!W^V¨Z!c^ZedodgcZ
DLD8/ ¨jhoXonc`Vig‹_`|ic^ZhZgXdlViV!cV
hoXonX^Ze¨ni`dlX^ŸiVo`g‹i`|hon_`|
C6H>:C>:/ edY¨jèc^ZdlVacZ!he¨VhoXodcZ!
XoZgldcVld苨iZVaWd苨iVldWgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèdlZ! d`dedlZ! d\gdYn! hiVcdl^h`V gjYZgVacZ


¼ oVX]dlj_Z h^Ÿ _V` gdÑa^cV YljaZic^V <A:7N/ g‹ècZ inen \aZW! hoXoZ\‹ac^Z eg‹X]"
c^XocZ!ènocZ
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ` l^ZadedhiVX^dln! YjèV egdYj`X_V cVh^dc dl^ZadaZic^Z_
ènldicdÑX^(%)%aVi^og‹èc^XdlVcnbd`gZh^ZhedXonc`j#LnYV_ZlX^|\jgd`j
YlV Yd igoZX] ed`daZ²# ?Zhi ènl^X^ZaZb edÑgZYc^b \gonW‹l ^ ho`dYc^`‹l gdÑa^c
ogdYo^cn`VejhicnX]`gonèdlnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8oŸÑo^ZacVgdÑa^cn_ZhihidhdlVcV_V`dÑgdYZ``gl^diVbj_|Xn#CV"
h^dcVoVl^ZgV_|d`#(&i¨jhoXoj#
)+ ),

IdWd¨`^edacZ
I]aVhe^VgkZchZA#
I=A6G
@VejhidlViZ@gonèdlZ!7gVhh^XVXZVZ8gjX^[ZgVZ

;^ZaYeZccn"XgZhh
IVWdjgZiYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg"=ZaaZg`gVji

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|!l^dhc|^cVedXo|i"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

`jaViV#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdoiVgiZa^ÑX^Z^¨dYn\^eVX]c|lngV„c^ZXodhc`^Zbedl|"
X]V_!jlV\V/gdÑa^cVigj_|XV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dlVacdZa^einXocZ!Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!W^V¨Vln
+-bb!cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoV" çD9N<6/ lnh# &%*%Xb! aZ``d `VcX^VhiV!
Za^einXocZ

d`g|\adcZ^c^Z`^ZYnaZ``dlX^ŸiZ j\‹gngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!cV\V
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ!oZWgVcZ
Y¨j\dс),bb!cV\V!o^Zadc`VlV lg‹ènXo`^!edYhedYZbh^cVldo^ZadcZ!\‹gcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ! ¼ edY¨j\dlViZ! _Vhcdo^ZadcZ! oVid`dld o|W"
_Vhcdo^ZadcZ! h`gŸidaZ\¨Z! c^Z`^ZYn WgoZ" `dlVcZ!cVhoXonX^ZiŸedoVdhigodcZ
\^Zb[Va^hiZ @L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
@L>6I/`l^VinYgdWcZ!W^V¨Z!enac^`^苨iZ
DLD8/¨jhoXonc`V!`da^hiV!e¨Vh`V!cVhoXon"
X^Zol|h`^b!\¨ŸWd`^blX^ŸX^Zb!hoZgd`ddh"
`gonYadcV
C6H>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ! he¨VhoXodcZ! `dcXZc"
ignXoc^Zgdl`dlVcZ!X^ZbcdWgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/goZeV`!oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZ"
gVacZ <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ! eg‹X]c^XocZ! oVhdWcZ l h`¨VYc^`^ ed`VgbdlZ! goVYo^Z_ cV
\aZWVX]aèZ_honX]
ho`dYa^ldс CVh^dcVoYdacZYd`^Z¨`dlVc^VegoZYXV¨`dl^inbYd_goZc^ZbgdÑ"
a^cn!dhnej_|h^ŸegoZYoW^dgZboW‹è#GdÑa^cVlnYV_Zd`#&%%%cVh^dc!`i‹gZbd\|
oVaZ\Vl\aZW^Z&%'%aVi#GdÑa^cVlnYV_Z`^a`Ved`daZ²lX^|\jgd`j!h^ac^ZoV"
X]lVhoXoVjegVln#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cV igj_|XV dh^acnb c^Zegon_Zbcnb oVeVX]j Xodhc`j! `i‹gn
egoZYdhiV_Zh^ŸYdegdYj`i‹lbaZXocnX]#CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|d`#()i¨jhoXoj#
)- ).

L^aXodbaZXodWgdicn
:je]dgW^V]Za^dhXde^VA#HXde#
:E==:
L^aXodbaZXodlViZ!:je]dgW^VXZVZ
L^aXodbaZXoe^¨`dlVcn!@d¨dlgdiZ`
Hjchejg\Z
:je]dgWZg‚kZ^abVi^c
HdccZc"Lda[hb^aX]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV!goVYo^Z_do^bV#H^Zl`^l^dhZccZ^_Zh^ZccZlnhiŸej_|cVed"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

aVX]jegVlcnX]dgVold\gdYVX]#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdÑa^cVoVl^ZgVX]VgV`iZgnhinXocnhd`baZXocn

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
Za^einXocZ!edY¨jècZ!Y¨j\dс
A>Ð8>:C>:/ @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!h¨VWn
-&%bb!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ çD9N<6/lnh#&*)%Xb!loc^Zh^dcV!egdh"
Za^einXocZ

çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ iVajWgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!ogoVY`VaZ``ddl¨dh^dcV
Y¨j\dс &*'% bb! WgjcVicVlV VaWd A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViZ! j \‹gn YgdWcd
XoZgldcVlV!ohd`^ZbbaZXocnb o|W`dlVcZ!苨ido^ZadcZ!o^ZadcZajWXoZgld"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ! cVldcVW^Z\¨Z
cV\^Z! h`gŸidaZ\¨Z! hoZgd`d oVd`g|\adcn @L>6IDHI6C/ \¨‹lcVl^ZgoX]di`Voegon"
hoXoni!lngV„c^Zl^YdXocncZgl!cVYda" hVY`Vb^!dYig‹_"Yde^ŸX^dgVb^ZccV
cZ_higdc^ZX^Zbcdejc`idlVcZ @L>6I/`l^Vinc^ZedodgcZ!苨ido^ZadcZ!bŸh"
`^Z^èZ²h`^Z
DLD8/gdo¨je`V!\¨VY`V
C6H>:C>:/ egVl^Z`ja^hiZ!¨je^cVh^Vi`dlVid
Yd¨`dlVcV!Wg|odldXoVgcV!cVhoXonX^Zo_Vh"
cd苨inbZaV_dhdbZb

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèV!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ!ddYXonc^Z


dWd_ŸicnbajWaZ``d`lVÑcnb!oVhdWcVlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ
ho`dYa^ldс GdÑa^cVdbc^Z_hoZ_`dc`jgZcXn_cdÑX^oedldYjh¨VW^Z_gdol^c^Ÿ"
iZ\dhnhiZbn`dgoZc^dlZ\d#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ BaZXocnhd`oVl^ZgVigj_|X|hjWhiVcX_ŸZj[dgWdc!ènl^XŸ!`lVhndg"
\Vc^XocZ!`VjXoj`#GdÑa^cVigj_|XVol¨VhoXoVYaVigodYnX]aZlcZ_#
*% *&

;^d¨Z`edacn
K^daVVgkZch^hBjgg#
K>D6G
;^d¨`dlViZ!K^daVXZVZ
7gViZ`edacn
;^ZaYeVchn
EZch‚ZYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg"Hi^Z[b“iiZgX]Zc

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|_V`^l^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zo`VgWVb^cVd`g|\¨d¼^bhiVghona^с!inb`VgWnWVg"
Yo^Z_lngV„cZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/_V_dlViZ!Y¨#)*bb!cV\^Z! @DGO:°/eVadln!lgoZX^dcdlVin
cVl^ZgoX]jo^ZadcZ!edYhedYZbÉdaZid" çD9N<6/lnh#&%(%Xb!egdhiVajWgdo\V"
ld cVW^Z\¨Z! o dWj higdc h`dÑc^Z ÑX^ŸiZ ¨Ÿo^dcV!gdoZh¨VcV
igjYcZYddYg‹èc^Zc^V A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼_V_dlViZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!
_V_dlViZ

çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ \‹gcZ ¼ aVcXZidlViZ! o X]VgV`iZgnhinXocnb^


Y¨#(-bb!cV\V!o^Zadc`VlV!j\‹gn Y¨j\^b^egona^hi`Vb^XoŸÑX^edYe^ZgV_|XZa^с
ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V diV`^Z_hVbZ_l^Za`dÑX^Xda^с
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ d`g|\¨Vld_V_dlViZ! @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
cV\^ZajWaZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ!oYldbVl^" @L>6I/ `l^Vined_ZYncXoZcVY¨j\^X]hon"
YdXocnb^ lX^ŸX^Vb^ `VgWVb^ ed Wd" ej¨`VX]!W^V¨d苨iZoaZ``^bdYX^Zc^ZbÉdaZ"
`VX]!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ idlnb
DLD8/idgZW`Vigon`dbdgdlV!eŸ`V_|XVed"
Y¨jèc^Z
C6H>:C>:/ X^Zbcd苨iZajW_VhcdWgjcVicZ!
oZaV_dhdbZb!edY¨jèc^Z_V_dlViZ!ed¨nh`j_|XZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!goZeV`!d\gdYn<A:7N/g‹ècZinen
\aZW!\VijcZ`WVgYodeaVhinXocn
ho`dYa^ldс ;^d¨Z` oVX]lVhoXoV l^Ÿ`hodс jegVl! ol¨VhoXoV do^bnX] oWdèV!
goZeV`#CVh^aVh^Ÿle¨dYdob^Vc^Zolnhd`^bjYo^V¨ZboW‹è^lbdcd`jaijgoZ#A^Xo"
c^Z^Y¨j\doVaZ\V_|XZl\aZW^ZcVh^dcVjigonbj_|lnhd`|oYdacdс`^Z¨`dlVc^V#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ IdgZW`^eŸ`V_|XlngojXV_|Yd_goV¨ZcVh^dcVcVYjèZdYaZ\¨dÑX^!ed"
cVYidcVh^dcVegoZcdho|bg‹l`^#8oŸÑo^ZacVgdÑa^cnoVl^ZgV\a^`donY¼l^daV`lZg"
XnigncŸdgVol^iVb^cŸ8!WVgl^cV苨id!cVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|Yd(-i¨jhoXoj#
*' *(

>\a^XVedheda^iV
:gdY^jbX^XjiVg^jbA#
:GD8>
7dYo^ho`dlViZ!<ZgVc^VXZVZ
7dX^Vcn
8dbbdchidg`Áh"W^aa<7!GZYhiZbÉaVgZZ JH6
:gdY^jbª[Zj^aaZhYZX^\j…
HX]^Zga^c\h"GZ^]ZghX]cVWZa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|^l^dhc|!hoXoZ\‹ac^Z
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

a^Xoc^ZcV\aZWVX]e^VhoXonhinX]#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^Z^e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZXoŸhidXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨Z

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ loVgnh^Z_V_dlViZ!lcVhVYo^Z @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!X^Zc`^!W^V¨Vln!gdo"
hZgXdlViZ!Y¨#,-bb!Ylj"!igon"ajW \V¨Ÿo^dcn
XoiZgd`aVedlZ!WdXocZ`aVend`g|\¨Z çD9N<6/ lnh#&%*%Xb!dYYd¨jgdo\V¨Ÿ"
çD9Næ@6 ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ lVaXdlViV! o^dcV! loc^Zh^dcV ajW edYcdho|XV h^Ÿ! dl¨d"
_V_dlViZ

Y¨# &%&*bb! WaVYdo^ZadcV! l\‹goZ h^dcV!Yd¨Zboln`aZXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V


oln`aZdbhodcV A>Ð8>:/ e^ZgoVhidh^ZXocZ! dYX^c`^ \¨ŸWd`d
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ Ylj`gdic^Z e^ZgoVh" edlX^cVcZ!h^ZYo|XZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨ZajWh`gŸ"
idh^ZXocZ! doVgnh^Z ig‹_`|icnb! h`gŸid" idaZ\¨Z
aZ\¨Z! a^ÑX^Z ^ d\dc`^ ed`gniZ YgdWcnb^! @L>6IDHI6C/WVaYVX]!cVY¨j\^Z_honej¨XZ
W^V¨Vlnb^l¨dh`Vb^!jcZgl^Zc^Zc^Zln" @L>6I/ a^a^dln ajW WaVYdejgejgdln! \‹gcn
gV„cZ o_VÑc^Z_ho|ajWX^Zbc^Z_ho|eaVb`|
DLD8/ gdo¨jec^V! e^ŸX^dYo^ZacV! lgoZX^dcd"
lViV!cVedl^ZgoX]c^YgdWcdWgdYVl`dlVcV!
X^ZbcdWgjcVicV!o¨dX^hiddl¨dh^dcV!oYo^‹W"
`^Zb
C6H>:C>:/ lVaXdlViZ! edY¨jècZ! \¨VY`^Z!
XoZgldcdWgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!b^ZYoZ <A:7N/ e^VhoXonhiZ!oV`"


lVhodcZ\a^c^VhiZ
ho`dYa^ldс @^Z¨`j_Z^gdol^_Vh^ŸegoZoXV¨nhZodclZ\ZiVXn_cnl`VèYnX]lV"
gjc`VX]ed\dYdlnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVaZXoc^XoV!gdoh^ZlVh^ŸYo^Ÿ`^Yo^‹W`dboYgZlc^V¨Zhon_`^
h¨je`V! ol^_V_|Xnb h^Ÿ Ña^bV`dlVid egon ob^Vc^Z l^a\dicdÑX^ edl^ZigoV ^ \aZWn#
9Vlc^Z_ln`dgonhinlVcVYdb^ZgoZc^Vl^a\dicdÑX^edl^ZigoV#
*) **

EgoZiVXoc^`WajhoXon`dln
KZgdc^XV]ZYZg^[da^VA#
K:G=:
IgŸYdlc^`dlViZ!HXgde]jaVg^VXZVZ

>kn"aZVkZYheZZYlZaa
K‚gdc^fjZª[Zj^aaZhYZa^ZggZ
:[ZjWa~iig^\Zg:]gZcegZ^h

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocVdo^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|^XoŸÑX^dldl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZolngV„cnb^YldbV`VgWVb^edWd`VX]!


oVocVXoV_|Xnb^ig‹_a^hi`dldсWaVho`^a^ÑX^dlZ_

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ! Y¨# Yd &( bb! cV" @DGO:°/eVadln
\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZajW çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс &%(%Xb! d`g|\¨VlV!
aZ``dlX^ŸiZ X^Zbcdo^ZadcV! gdoZh¨VcV! o goVY`V Y¨j\d
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ dl¨dh^dcV
_V_dlViZ

Y¨j\dс*'%bb!cV\VajWgoVY`ddl" A>Ð8>:/ hZgXdlVidcZg`dlViZ!`aVedlVcZ


¨dh^dcV!WgjcVicVlV dYigoZX]Ydh^ZYb^j`aVeZ`!egonedb^cV_|
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!aZ``ddl¨d" WajhoXo
h^dcZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!`aVedlViZ @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
@L>6I/ `l^Vin ed_ZYncXoZ lngVhiV_|XZ o`|"
i‹l a^ÑX^ cV Y¨j\^Z_ honej¨XZ! W¨Ÿ`^icdW^V¨Z
ajWWaVYdW¨Ÿ`^icZ
DLD8/ idgZW`V!cV\V!egVl^ZXol‹gYo^ZacV!
cVhoXonX^ZobV¨nblX^ŸX^Zb!`dbdgn_ZYcd"
ajWYljcVh^ZccZ
C6H>:C>:/`ja^hidcZg`dlViZ!WgjoY`dlVcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ l^Ÿ`hodсjegVl!oWdèdlZ!hoXoZ\‹ac^Zdo^bZ!d`d"


edlZ<A:7N/dYe^VhoXonhinX]Yd\a^c^VhinX]!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZllVe²
ho`dYa^ldс @g‹i`^Xn`agdold_dlnedldYj_Z!èZ\VijcZ`iZch^ac^Z`dc`jgj_Z
d h`¨VYc^`^ ed`VgbdlZ oZ oWdèVb^ do^bnb^ lZ lXoZhcnX] [VoVX] gdold_dlnX]#
@^Z¨`dlVc^Z bdèZ dYWnlV h^Ÿ cV edl^ZgoX]c^ \aZWn! VaZ c^Z cV Ñl^ZiaZ# LnèhoV
iZbeZgVijgV]Vbj_Z_Z\dgdol‹_#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 9dgdoh^ZlVc^VegonXonc^V_|h^Ÿbg‹l`^!X]Ÿic^Zo_VYV_|XZZaV_dhd"
bn ocV_Yj_|XZ h^Ÿ cV cVh^dcVX]# CVh^dcV `^Z¨`j_| _jè l iZbeZgVijgoZ %•8# 8oŸÑ
o^ZacVoVl^ZgVVj`jW^cŸ#
*+ *,

EgoZiVXoc^`eZgh`^
KZgdc^XVeZgh^XVEd^g#
K:GE:
IgŸYdlc^`dlViZ!HXgde]jaVg^VXZVZ

8dbbdcÉZaY"heZZYlZaa
k‚gdc^fjZYZEZghZ
EZgh^hX]Zg:]gZcegZ^h

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^EgoZiVXoc^`VeZgh`^Z\dlnhiŸej_|cV_XoŸÑ"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

X^Z_l^dhc|VaZg‹lc^ZècVedXo|i`jaViV^_Zh^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ ¨dYnè`VedYa^ÑX^Zc^dlVl\‹gcZ_XoŸÑX^ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V!
`l^VincVWVgYodY¨j\^X]dl¨dh^dcnX]honej¨`VX]

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/d`g|\¨Vld _V_dlViZ! Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/eVadln!lgoZX^dcdlVin
),bb! cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ edY hedYZb çD9N<6/ lnh#&%)%Xb!d`g|\¨VlV!gdo"
c^ZXd ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨Z! cV hoXonX^Z \V¨Ÿo^dcV!gdoZh¨VcVoYldbVgoŸYVb^dYhiV"
oVd`g|\adcZ _|XnX]l¨dh`‹l!oV`dgoZc^V_|XVh^Ÿ
_V_dlViZ

çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ hoZgd`d_V_dlViZ!WgoZ\^Zb\gjWd


Y¨j\dс &%'%bb! YgdWcd dbhodcV! ^\¨ŸWd`de^¨`dlVcZ!\‹gcZYgdWcZ!`VgWdlV"
X^Zbcdo^ZadcV cde^¨`dlVcZ!goVY`ddl¨dh^dcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!aZ``ddl¨d" @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
h^dcZ! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! WgoZ\^Zb [Va^hid @L>6I/ `l^Vined_ZYncXoZlngVhiV_|XZo`|"
lgŸWcZ i‹la^ÑX^cVY¨j\^X]dl¨dh^dcnX]honej¨`VX]!
c^ZW^Zh`dW¨Ÿ`^icZ
DLD8/ idgZW`V!dYlgdic^ZcZg`dlViV!oiŸ"
enblnX^ŸX^ZbcVhoXonX^Z!_Vhcdh^Vi`dlVid
jcZgl^dcV!dl¨dh^dcVajWcV\V!oVl^ZgVXoiZ"
gnYdYo^Zl^ŸX^jcVh^dc
C6H>:C>:/苨iVlZ!dlVacZ!WgdYVl`dlVcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZol¨VhoXoV_VgZ!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn
<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!e^VhoXonhid"\a^c^VhiZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!ènocZ!l^a\dicZ
ho`dYa^ldс 8]lVhi gdol^_V h^Ÿ WVgYod honW`d! `l^ic^Z ^ dldXj_Z egoZo XV¨n
d`gZhlZ\ZiVXn_cn#CV_a^Xoc^Z_ed_Vl^Vh^ŸlaViVl^a\dicZ#H^ac^Z`dc`jgj_Zo\Vijc"
`Vb^jegVlcnb^dh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ#@^Z¨`j_ZegoZoXV¨nd`gZhlZ\ZiVX_^WgV`
hedXonc`jjcVh^dc#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8oŸÑo^ZacVoVl^ZgVVj`jW^cŸ#
*- *.

Gjb^VcZ`edheda^in
BVig^XVg^VX]Vbdb^aaVA#
B6I8=
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

<ZgbVcX]Vbdb^aZ
8Vbdb^aaZbVig^XV^gZ
@Vb^aaZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdÑa^cVcV\V!dX]VgV`iZgnhinXocnboVeVX]j!`l^VinoZWgV"
cZlldccn`dhonXoZ`dejhinbYc^Z`l^Vidlnb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ!Y¨#*-bb!aZ``d @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!l|h`^
hdXonhiZ çD9N<6/ lnh# &*)%Xb! egdhiV ajW dY
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ X^Zc`V!Y¨j" cVhVYngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!cV\V
\dс&%&*bb!o^Zadc`VlV A>Ð8>:/ Ylj"ajWigon`gdic^Ze^ZgoVhidYo^Za"
_V_dlViZ

E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ l|h`d aVcXZidlViZ cZ! d g‹lcdl|h`^X]! dhignX] ^ he¨VhoXodcnX]


o_ZYc|! YldbV eVgVb^ aVcXZidlVinX] dYX^c`VX]
dYX^c`‹l! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! WgoZ\^Zb @L>6IDHI6C/ `dhonXoZ`dejhinbYc^Z
o|W`dlVcZ `l^Vidlnb
@L>6I/ WgoZècZ`l^Vinc^Wn_ŸonXo`dlZ!
digoZX]o|W`VX]!W^V¨Z!h¨je`dlZ!lZlcŸigo"
cZ `l^Vin gjg`dlZ! d e^ŸX^j o|W`VX]! 苨iZ!
dWje¨X^dlZ
DLD8/c^Z¨je`V!edY¨j\dlVid_V_dlViV!苨"
iVldhoVgV! èZWZg`dlVcV! oZ ÑX^Ÿinb l^Zgo"
X]d¨`^Zb
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ!苨iVlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèV!d`dedlZ!lVgonlV!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ
<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!ènocZ!aZ``d`lVÑcZ
ho`dYa^ldс Edheda^inX]lVhiloVX]dYc^Z_EdahXZ!`dc`jgj_ZÑgZYc^dajWh^ac^Z
lYjènbcV\gdbVYoZc^jdh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZo\Vijc`^ZbjegVlcnb#BdèZ
`^Z¨`dlVegoZoXV¨ngd`#?ZhigdÑa^c|Yc^VY¨j\^Z\d!^be‹„c^Z_loZ_Yo^ZcVl^dhcŸ!
inb`g‹ihonbVd`gZhlZ\ZiVX_^cVlZiYd)%Yc^#H^Zl`^_Zh^ZccZbd\|o^bdlV
ledhiVX^gdoZin#9jèVe¨dYcdс!`^a`Vinh^ŸXncVh^dcdog‹èc^XdlVcnbd`gZh^Zhed"
Xonc`j^YjèZ_oYdacdÑX^`^Z¨`dlVc^V#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgV%!*&!*daZ_`jZiZgnXocZ\d!Wd\ViZ\dlVojaZc!
\VgWc^`^!ènl^XŸ!\dgnXo^\a^`donYnÊVldcdlZ# HidhdlVcV l aZXoc^Xil^Z l edhiVX^
lnhjhodcnX]`dhonXo`‹l`l^VidhiVcdlnX]#
+% +&

拨ia^XVYgdWcd`l^VidlV
<Va^chd\VeVgk^ÊdgV 8Vk#
<6HE6
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

<VaaVcihdaY^Zg
<Va^chd\VªeZi^iZhÊZjgh
@aZ^cWa“i^\Zh;gVcodhZc`gVji

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#9d`^Z¨`dlVc^VedigoZWj_ZYjèdX^Ze¨V!lhX]dYned_Vl^V_|
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

h^Ÿe‹„cded¨dlVbV_V^iglV_|egoZoXV¨nd`gZhlZ\ZiVXn_cn#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZlngV„c^Z_Vhcdo^ZadcZ!h^ac^Zed¨nh`j_|XZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ!Y¨#&*'%bb!cV" @DGO:°/ eVadlngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!oa^Xocnb^
\^Z!_Vhcdo^ZadcZ!ed¨nh`j_|XZ!cVhoXonX^Z WdXocnb^dY\V¨Ÿo^Zc^Vb^
aZ``dlX^ŸiZ çD9N<6/ lnh#&%)%Xb!d`g|\¨VlV!h^ac^Z
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!egonaZ\V_|Xddl¨dh^dcV
_V_dlViZ

Y¨j\dс*&%bb!cV\V!c^Z`^ZYnaZ``d A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼_V_dlViZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!


ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V! aZ``d WgjoY`dlVcV \‹gcZ¼aVcXZidlViZ!aZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ!_Vhcd"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!aZ``ddl¨d" o^ZadcZ!o|W`dlVcZ
h^dcZ! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! WgoZ\^Zb [Va^hid @L>6IDHI6C/ `dhonXo`^cVY¨j\^X]honej¨"
lgŸWcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVdhigodcZ `VX]oZWgVcZlWVaYVX]d`hoiV¨icZ`l^VidhiVcn
@L>6I/ `l^VinWgoZècZ_ŸonXo`dlViZW^V¨Z
oln`aZ e^Ÿ! `l^Vin lZlcŸigocZ gjg`dlZ!
苨iZ(*)%
DLD8/ c^Z¨je`VdbhodcV!XoiZgd`VcX^VhiV!
XoVgcV
C6H>:C>:/ d`g|\¨VlZ!XoVgcZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ d\gdYn!d`dedlZ!goVYo^Z_oWdèdlZ <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ


dgVoaZ``^Z!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlVodi
ho`dYa^ldс Lhegon_V_|XnX]lVgjc`VX]bdèZlnYV`^a`Ved`daZ²lX^|\j
aViV#?ZYcVgdÑa^cVlnYV_ZWVgYodYjèddldX‹lYd(%%%%%hoi##Lne^ZadcV!Vc^Z
hego|ic^ŸiVoedaV!honW`dj`dgoZc^Vh^Ÿedcdlc^Z!ildgo|X`dgoZc^ZegonWnhodlZcV
eŸYVX]#7VgYodlgVèa^lVcVc^h`^ZiZbeZgVijgn¼\^c^Zegone^ZglhonX]egonbgdo"
`VX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVYd_goZlV_|cVlZiedlnglVc^jgdÑa^cno\aZWn!h|lnigon"
bV¨ZcVbg‹o^oVX]dlj_|oYdacdс`^Z¨`dlVc^VegoZoY¨j\^ZaViV#
+' +(

7^Zaj²Yo^ŸYo^ZgoVlV
9VijgVhigVbdc^jbA#
96IHI
Eh^Vc`dlViZ!HdaVcVXZVZ
7^Zaj²edYl‹godln!9o^ŸYo^ZgoVlV
?^bhdclZZY
9VijgVhigVbd^cZ
<ZbZ^cZgHiZX]Ve[Za

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸcV`dc^ZXl^dhcn#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ h^Zl`^ dc^Zegon_Zbcnb! dYjgoV_|Xnb oVeVX]j! a^ÑX^Z


oW^V¨VlnbcVadiZb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/aVcXZidlViZ!Y¨#'*(*bb! @DGO:°/b^Ÿh^hin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
j\‹gnolŸèdcZ!cV`d²XjdhigZ!Yd¨Zb çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс'%.%Xb!l^YaVhid
gdohoZgodcZ!egonhVbZ_cVhVYo^ZolŸèd" gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV! cV\V ajW YZa^`Vic^Z dbhodcV!
cZld\dcZ` loc^Zh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!lcVhVYo^Z`a^cdlViZ!oV"
Y¨#'%'**%bb!o^Zadc`VlV!\gjXod" dhigodcZ!\gjWd!oVid`dldo|W`dlVcZ!d\dc"
aVcXZidlViZ

¨dlViddl¨dh^dcV `dlZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ edY¨jèc^Z_V_dlViZ! @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
Y¨j\doVdhigodcZ!XV¨dWgoZ\^Z!ol^ZgoX]j @L>6I/W^V¨n!ed_ZYncXon!aZ_`dln!jb^ZhoXod"
X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!Yd¨ZbcVWgoZ\VX]!cZg" cncV`g‹i`^X]honej¨`VX]
l^Z^d\dc`jW^V¨ddbhodcZ DLD8/idgZW`V!_V_dlViV!`daXoVhiV!o^ZadcV
C6H>:C>:/ cZg`dlViZ!Ydсh^ac^Zhe¨VhoXod"
cZ!YgdWcd!h^ViZXo`dlVidbVghoXodcZ!X^Zb"
cdWgjcVicZ!bVidlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!bV`!d\gdYn!gjbdl^h`V!c^Zjèni`^
<A:7N/ \aZWne^VhoXonhiZ!g‹ècZhiVcdl^h`V
ho`dYa^ldс HedgVYnXoc^ZoVX]lVhoXoVd\gdYn#?ZYcVidgZW`VoVl^ZgVYd`^a"
`jhZicVh^dc!_ZYcVgdÑa^cVlnYV_ZYd`^a`jinh^ŸXncVh^dc#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ A^ÑX^Z oVl^ZgV_| %!'%!)* Va`Vad^Y‹l! \¨‹lc^Z ]^dhXn_Vb^cŸ
^]^dhXncŸdgVo\VgWc^`^#CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|%!'%!(*Va`Vad^Y‹l!egoZYZlhonhi"
`^b ]^dhXn_Vb^cŸ# HidhdlVcn l aZXoc^Xil^Z Yd lngdWj iVWaZiZ` egoZX^lVhibV"
inXocnX]#
+) +*

9nbc^XVedheda^iV
;jbVg^Vd[ÉX^cVa^h A#
;JBD;
9nbc^XdlViZ!;jbVg^VXZVZ

8dbbdc[jb^idgn
;jbZiZggZd[ÉX^cVaZ
<ZbZ^cZg:gYgVjX]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ\¨‹lc^Zl^dhc|^_Zh^Zc^|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Z dX]VgV`iZgnhinXocZ_ h^cZ_ ajW hoVgdo^ZadcZ_ WVgl^Z!


¨dYn\Voc^ZW^Zh`do^ZadcnbcVadiZb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!Y¨#&%&*bb! @DGO:°/ lgoZX^dcdlVin! W^V¨Vln ajW Wgj"
cV\^Z! h^cVldo^ZadcZ! cV hoXonX^Z dhigd cVicVld苨in!bV¨dgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
oVdhigodcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс&%*%Xb!`VcX^VhiV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!loc^Zh^dcV!cV\V!XoVhZb
Y¨#&%&*bb!cV\V!ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V XoZgldcVldcVW^Z\¨V!ed`gniVc^ZW^Zh`do^Zad"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^ZglhoZYlVa^ÑX^Z cnbcVadiZb
aVcXZidlViZ

Ylj`gdic^ZY¨dc^Vhidig‹_h^ZXocZ!cVegoZ" A>Ð8>:/ Ylj"ajWigon`gdic^Ze^ZgoVhidh^ZXo"


b^VcaZ\¨Z cZ! ¨Vi`^ `d²XdlZ g‹lcdl|h`d aVcXZidlViZ!
h^cVldo^ZadcZ
@L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
@L>6I/ `l^VinXoZgldcZ!g‹èdlZajWejgej"
gdlZcVhoXonX^ZX^Zbc^Z_hoZ
DLD8/YgdWcndgoZhoZ`!dYlgdic^Z_V_dlVin!
hoVgdWgjcVicn
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!goVYo^Z_oWdèdlZ!d\gdYn
<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!l^a\dicZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlVodi
ho`dYa^ldс LnhiŸej_ZcVhiVcdl^h`VX]l^a\dicnX]^oVhdWcnX]lh`¨VYc^`^
ed`VgbdlZ#OZlo\aŸYjcVldh`dlncVadiigjYc^Z_hoZolVaXoVc^Z]ZgW^XnYVb^#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVaZXoc^XoV#BdèZWnigV`idlVcV_V`d\VijcZ`lh`V„c^`dln
lnhd`VhegVlcdсgda^#
++ +,

<l^VoYc^XVedheda^iV
HiZaaVg^VbZY^VA#K^aa#
HI:B:
<d„Yo^`dlViZ!8Vgnde]naaVXZVZ

8dbbdcX]^X`lZZY
BdjgdcYZhd^hZVjm
Kd\Zab^ZgZK^aa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^lnhiŸej_|loVh^ZlVX]l`VèYZ_edgoZ
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

gd`j#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^Z^e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZWVgYodYZa^`VicZ!cVhoXonX^ZdhigZ!
\l^VoYc^XVcVgVèdcVcVX]¨dYn¼WVglVÉdaZidlV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!Y¨#*,bb! @DGO:°/X^Zc`^!l|i¨n
dl¨dh^dcZ!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZdhigZ çD9N<6/ lnh# *)%Xb! X^Zc`V! gdoZh¨VcV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ _ZYcdhoZgZ\dlddl¨dh^dcV!oV`dgoZc^V_|XVh^Ÿ
Y¨#*&%bb!cV\V!o^Zadc`VlV A>Ð8>:/YdacZ^ÑgdY`dlZ¼_V_dlViZ!d\dc`d"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ hoZgd`d_V_dlViZ!cV" lZ! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! \‹gcZ ¼ h^ZYo|XZ! cV\^Z
\^Z!oYgdWcnbdhigoZbcVhoXonX^Z!X^Zb" ajWaZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ
aVcXZidlViZ

cdo^ZadcZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z @L>6IDHI6C/YljgVb^ZccVl^ZgoX]di`V
@L>6I/ `l^VinYgdWcZ!W^V¨Z!cVY¨j\^X]hon"
ej¨`VX]
DLD8/ idgZW`V! edY¨j\dlViV! eŸ`V_|XV dY
cVhVYnhoZÑX^dbVdildg`Vb^
C6H>:C>:/d`g|\¨VlZajWcZg`dlViZ!he¨Vho"
XodcZ!X^ZbcdWgjcVicZ!bVidlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/lhonhi`^ZjegVln!hoXoZ\‹ac^Zd`dedlZ!lVgonlV
<A:7N/ g‹ècZinen\aZW!l^a\dicZ!oVhdWcZlVodi¼\VijcZ`VodidajWcn
ho`dYa^ldс JX^|èa^lnX]lVhidYocVXoV_|Xnh^ŸhonW`^bgdold_Zb^ènldicdÑ"
X^|#HoXoZ\‹ac^ZdWÉX^Z gdogVhiV h^Ÿ l aViVX] d YjèZ_ hjb^Z deVY‹l! ildgo|X e¨Vh`^Z
`Ÿen#GdobcVèVh^ŸocVh^dc^XoŸÑX^¨dYn\ce#ede^ZaZc^j#LX^|\jaViVbdèZlnYV
YlVYdigoZX]ed`daZ²#?ZYcVgdÑa^cVlnYV_Zd`#&%%%cVh^dc#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8oŸÑ o^ZacV oVl^ZgV hVedc^cn! bdèZ Wn ln`dgonhinlVcV _V`d
eVhoVo^ZadcVYaVol^Zgo|iYdbdlnX]^YgdW^j!ol^Ÿ`hoVbaZXocdс`g‹l!`‹o^dl^ZX#
GdÑa^cVb^dYdYV_cV#
+- +.

@jgonÑaVYedacn
6cV\Vaa^hVgkZch^hA#
6C66G
E^Zgl^dhc`dlViZ!Eg^bjaVXZVZ

HXVgaZie^beZgcZa
Bdjgdcgdj\Z
6X`Zg"<VjX]]Z^a

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ\¨‹lc^Zl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ cVYdacZ_higdc^Za^ÑX^ZWgjcVicdejc`idlVcZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!Y¨#)*bb! @DGO:°/gdol^Yadcn
cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVdhigodcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс*'%Xb!XoiZgd`VcX^V"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ hiV!e¨dè|XV!Yd¨Zbgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!cV\V
Y¨j\dс*&%bb!cV\V!苨iVlV!XoZg" A>Ð8>:/dlVacZ!h^ZYo|XZ!XV¨dWgoZ\^Z!cVYda"
ldcdcVW^Z\¨V cZ_higdc^ZWgjcVicdejc`idlVcZeaVb^hiZ
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ dlVacZ! X^Zbcdo^Zad" @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
aVcXZidlViZ

cZ!h^ac^Zed¨nh`j_|XZ!cV\^Z!cVegoZX^l" @L>6I/ `l^VincVY¨j\^X]honej¨`VX]!XZ\aV"


aZ\¨Z hidXoZgldcZajW`gl^hidXoZgldcZ
DLD8/l^ZadcVh^ZccVidgZW`V!`ja^hiV!dil^Z"
gV_|XVh^Ÿl^ZXo`^Zb
C6H>:C>:/ ig‹_\gVc^VhiZ!o_ZYcZ_higdcnln"
ej`¨Z!XoVgcdWgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/lhonhi`^ZjegVln!hoXoZ\‹ac^Zd`dedlZ!lVgonlV
<A:7N/ g‹ècZinen\aZW!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZoVhdWcZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ
ho`dYa^ldс ?V`dhidhjc`dldc^ZYjèVgdÑa^cVc^ZedldYj_ZocVXo|XnX]ho`‹Y
ljegVlVX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8]lVhiegVlYdedYdWc^Zedh^VYVl¨VÑX^ldÑX^igj_|XZ!oVl^ZgV\d"
gnXo!\VgWc^`^^hjWhiVcX_ZdX]VgV`iZgoZhVedc^c#
,% ,&

Eh^Vc`VXoVgcV
HdaVcjbc^\gjbA#
HDAC>
Eh^Vc`dlViZ!HdaVcVXZVZ

7aVX`c^\]ih]VYZ
BdgZaaZcd^gZ
HX]lVgoZgCVX]ihX]ViiZc

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸcV_XoŸÑX^Z_lYgj\^Z_ed¨dl^ZbV_V^cV
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

edXo|i`jXoZglXV#
XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ lnYo^ZaV h^acn! c^Zegon_Zbcn oVeVX] edl|X]V_! jlV\V/
gdÑa^cVigj_|XV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ hoZgd`daVcXZidlViZ! Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin
*&% bb! cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ edY hedYZb çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&%*%Xb!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!
ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨Z! cV hoXonX^Z oVdhigod" iŸed`VcX^VhiV!X^Zbcdo^ZadcV!cV\VajWaZ``d
cZ o X]VgV`iZgnhinXocnb cZglZb ÑgdY" dl¨dh^dcV
`dlnb A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ ajW gdbWdlViZ! WgoZ\^Zb
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ oVid`dldo|W`dlVcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVdhigodcZ
aVcXZidlViZ

Y¨# &%'%bb! \Ÿhid dl¨dh^dcV! o^Zad" @L>6IDHI6C/edYWVaYVhoZ`


cV!ÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V @L>6I/ `l^Vin W^V¨Z! YgdWcZ! egdb^Zc^hiZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/hoZgd`d_V_dlViZlcV" denac^`VX]o¨dX^hid苨inX]h`je^dcnX]le^"
hVYo^ZhZgXdlViZ!h^ac^Zdl¨dh^dcZ!h`gŸid" gVb^Y`Ÿ
aZ\¨Z!XoŸhidÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨Z! cV hoXon" DLD8/_V\dYV`ja^hiV!XoVgcVgoVYo^Z_o^Zadc"
X^ZoVdhigodcZ `VlV
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ!he¨VhoXodcZ!o_ZYcZ_higd"
cnoVd`g|\adcZ!cVedl^ZgoX]c^YgdWcdh^Vi"
`dlVcZ!_Vhcd苨iZ!bVidlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d\gdYn!d`dedlZ!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ
<A:7N/ eg‹X]c^XocZ!ènocZ!egoZl^ZlcZ!oVhdWcZlVodi\VijcZ`lh`V„c^`dln
ho`dYa^ldс CVh^dcVd`#*%%o_ZYcZ_gdÑa^cnbd\|cVinX]b^Vhi`^Z¨`dlV#
ænl^X^ZaX]dg‹W^ho`dYc^`‹lViV`j_|XnX]gdÑa^cnogdYo^cneh^Vc`dlVinX]dgVob|i"
l^`Vo^Zbc^VXoVcZ\d#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8oŸÑX^o^ZacZgdÑa^cn!VhoXoZ\‹ac^Zc^ZYd_goV¨ZdldXZigj_|XZ!oVl^Z"
gV_|\a^`donYhdaVc^cŸYd%!,#GdÑa^cVWVgl^Zgh`V#
,' ,(

7dYo^hoZ`YgdWcn
<ZgVc^jbejh^aajbA#
<:GEJ
7dYo^ho`dlViZ!<ZgVc^VXZVZ

HbVaa\ZgVc^jb
<‚gVc^jbªi^\Zh\gäaZh
@aZ^cZgHidgX]hX]cVWZa

GdÑa^cV cV edaVX] jegVlcnX] _ZYcdgdXocV! _VgV ajW do^bV# H^Zl`^ gdol^_V_| h^Ÿ
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

lXoZhc|l^dhc|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^Zglhon^Ygj\^a^сY¨dc^Vhidh^ZYb^dYo^Zacn!WaVho`^^d\dc`^
ed`gniZ\ŸhiddYhiV_|Xnb^l¨dh`Vb^!XV¨VgdÑa^cVX]VgV`iZgnhinXoc^ZeVX]c^Z

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ cZg`dlViZ! Y¨# )+bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!aZ``dgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
ohoZgd`^b lX^ŸX^Zb! Y¨j\^b^! Yd¨Zb çD9N<6/ lnh# &%*%Xb! gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!
XoZgldcVld cVW^Z\¨nb^ d\dc`Vb^! cV oln`aZgdoZh¨VcV!`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcV!l\‹goZ
l^ZgoX]d¨`joYgdWcnb\jo`^Zble¨ni" XoŸhidXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V
`^blX^ŸX^j A>Ð8>:/ Y¨dc^VhiddYe^ŸX^d"YdYo^Zl^ŸX^d"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ Yo^ZacZ! loVgnh^Z d`g|\¨VlZ ajW cZg`dlViZ!
Y¨#-&%bb!cV\V!ajWl\‹goZdbhod" cVdWjhigdcVX]\Ÿhiddl¨dh^dcZ!XoVhVb^XV¨Z
cV!WgjcVicdajWXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨Z
cZg`dlViZ

E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhon^Ygj\^a^с @L>6IDHI6C/WVaYVX]d`hoiV¨icn


Y¨dc^Vhidh^ZYb^dYo^Zacn!WaVho`^^d\dc`^ @L>6I/ `l^Vinl`|iVX]a^ÑX^!_VhcdÉdaZidlZ
ed`gniZ\ŸhiddYhiV_|Xnb^l¨dh`Vb^ ajW WaVYdejgejgdlZ! honej¨`^ `l^VidlZ ed
egoZ`l^ic^Zc^jdY\^ŸiZlY‹¨
DLD8/ gdo¨jec^VgdoeVYV_|XVh^ŸcVe^Ÿ
gdo¨jeZ`! egonaZ\aZ dl¨dh^dcV! 苨iVldWgj"
cVicV
C6H>:C>:/ _V_dlViZ!\¨VY`^Z!o‹¨iVldWgj"
cVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèV!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn!`dc^Xoncn!ajXZgcn!hiVcdl^"
h`VgjYZgVacZ<A:7N/e^VhoXonhid"\a^c^VhiZ!hjX]Z!oVhdWcZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`ÑgZYc^d^ciZchnlc^ZlnXoZgej_Z\aZWŸoZh`¨VYc^`‹led"
`VgbdlnX]#BdèZildgon[dgbnYljaZic^Z#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgV\VgWc^`^#
,) ,*

8]VWZgW¨VlViZ`
8ZciVjgZVXnVcjhA#
8:C8N
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ
BdYgV`!7¨VlViZ`
8dgcÊdlZg
7aZjZiYZhX]Vbeh
@dgcWajbZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#8]lVhio^bj_|Xn#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZhoVgVldo^ZadcZ!dWjhigdcc^Zh^ac^ZeV_ŸXon"
cdlViddl¨dh^dcZeVigo¼ÉaXdlViZ l¨dh`^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViZ! Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/ eVadln! lgoZX^dcdlVin! Yd '%Xb
&%&*bb! cV\^Z! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ ajW Y¨j\dÑX^
XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨Z!cVhoXonX^ZaZ``doV" çD9N<6/lnh#&%-%Xb!`VcX^VhiV!dYed"
d`g|\adcZ!hdXonhiZ ¨dlngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!eV_ŸXoncdlViddl¨dh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ YdacZdYo^db`dlZ¼_V_dlVidaVc"
Y¨j\dс *&% bb! cV\V! o^Zadc`VlV XZidlViZoYldbV!igoZbVdYaZ\¨nb^dYX^c"
ajWXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V `Vb^ o dWj higdc! \‹gcZ ¼ aVcXZidlViZ! h^Z"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/edY¨j\dlVidaVcXZid" Yo|XZ! aZ``d dl¨dh^dcZ! hoVgdo^ZadcZ! XV¨d"
lViZ! hoVgVldo^ZadcZ! WgoZ\ [Va^hin! o|W" WgoZ\^Z
`dlVcZ @L>6IDHI6C/`dhonXoZ`cVY¨j\^Z_honej¨XZ
dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ

@L>6I/ `l^VinWgoZècZaZ_`dlViZc^ZW^Zh`^Z!
`l^Vin lZlcŸigocZ gjg`dlZ c^ZW^Zh`dÉdaZ"
idlZ
DLD8/c^Z¨je`V!hgZWgonhiV!edY¨j\dlViVoZ
o¨dX^hinb^ajWÉdaZidldWgjcVicnb^ hoXoZX^c"
`Vb^cVÑX^Ÿinb`d²Xj
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ!edY¨j\dlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèdlZ! d`dedlZ! bdina`dlZ <A:7N/ g‹ècZ inen


\aZW!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZaZ``^ZjWd\^ZllVe²
ho`dYa^ldс 8]lVhi \¨‹lc^Z gdÑa^c oWdèdlnX] do^bnX]! Yd_goZlV_|X g‹lcd"
XoZÑc^ZoZoWdèdlnb^!oVX]lVhoXoV\aZWŸ^bViZg^V¨h^Zlcn#DldXZ!dYjèZ_oYdacdÑX^
`^Z¨`dlVc^V!edYle¨nlZbob^ZccZ_l^a\dicdÑX^ln`dcj_|gjX]neZ¨oV_|XZ#8]VWZg
bdèZld\gVc^Xodcnbhidec^jgdobcVèVh^Ÿg‹lc^ZèlZ\ZiVinlc^Z#?ZhiedÑgZYc^b
ènl^X^ZaZbc^X^Zc^ViV`j_|XnX]oWdèV^`dc^XoncŸ#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ @l^Vin Wn¨n YVlc^Z_ jènlVcZ Yd lngdWj WVglc^`V dWZXcdс
Xn_Vc^cn! l^cV YdbdlZ\d dgVo aZXoZc^V X]dg‹W dXoj# CVh^dcV oVl^ZgV_| Yd '-
i¨jhoXoj#
,+ ,,

DhigdèZ²edacn
8^gh^jbVgkZchZA#HXde#
8>G6G
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ
DhZiedacn
8gZZe^c\i]^hiaZ
8]VgYdcYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg"9^hiZa

GdÑa^cVYlje^ZccV!l^ZadaZic^V#H^Zl`^^dYgdhin`dgoZc^dlZed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ lngV„c^Zl^YdXocZYjèZ!`daXoVhiZo|W`^cVWgoZ\VX]a^ÑX^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dYlg#_V_dlViZ!Y¨#-&%bb! @DGO:°/ h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!\¨ŸWd`^
cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!b^Ÿh^hiZ!cVhoXonX^ZoVd`" '+ b! lVaXdlVin! 苨iVldW^V¨n ajW 苨"
g|\adcZ jlV\V/ [dgbn o gdobcVèVc^V iVldWgjcVicn
lZ\ZiVinlcZ\d XoŸhid ^X] c^Z lnilV" çD9N<6/ lnh# )%&'%Xb! dW¨d`VcX^VhiV!
goV_| h^ac^Z gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV! hoVgdo^Zad"cV! cV\V ajW
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ \‹g| aZ``d dl¨dh^dcV A>Ð8>:/ g‹ècZ_ ed"
Y¨j\dс&(bb!`g‹i`V!cV\V!W^V¨Vld" hiVX^! Za^einXocZ ajW edY¨jèc^Z aVcXZidlViZ!
o^ZadcV ob^Zcc^Z dl¨dh^dcZ! ol^ZgoX]j o^ZadcZ! edY
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViZ! hedYZbede^ZaViZ!h^ac^Z`daXoVhido|W`dlVcZ
h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!ol^ZgoX]jaZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ! @L>6IDHI6C/`dhonXoZ`
dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ

edY hedYZb ede^ZaVid \Ÿhid dl¨dh^dcZ! @L>6I/ `l^Vin gdoYo^Zacde¨X^dlZ! _VhcZ!


o|W`dlVcZ ejgejgdlda^a^dlZ ajW g‹èdlda^a^dlZ WVgYod
goVY`dW^V¨ZDLD8/c^Z¨je`V!_VhcdWZèdlV!
`a^cdlViV!oe^ZgoVhinbejX]Zb`^Za^X]dlnb
d Y¨j\dÑX^ '%(%bb C6H>:C>:/ dlVacZ!
edY¨j\dlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/lhonhi`^ZjegVln!b^ZYoZ!egonYgdèV!hiVcdl^h`Vgj"
YZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZWoln_|i`^ZbcV_jWdèhonX]
ho`dYa^ldс DhigdèZ²oVX]lVhoXoVlhonhi`^ZjegVln#H^ac^ZlnXoZgej_Z\aZWŸ
oZh`¨VYc^`‹led`VgbdlnX]#GdÑa^cVlnilVgoVYd`^a`jYo^Zh^ŸX^jinh^ŸXn(*%%%
c^Z¨jeZ`!VaZhedgV^X]a^XoWV_Zhijho`VYoVcVegoZoèn_|XZl`dhonXo`VX]aVglndlV"
Y‹l#?ZèZa^gdobcVèVh^ŸocVh^dc!idle^Zglhonbgd`jildgon_ZYnc^ZgdoZiŸa^ÑX^d"
l|#DldXZln`Voj_|og‹èc^XdlVc^ZedYlo\aŸYZbY¨j\dÑX^d`gZhjhedXonc`jdgVo
lnbV\V² iZgb^XocnX] ^Ñl^ZiacnX] edYXoVh `^Z¨`dlVc^V# LZ\ZiVinlc^Z gdobcVèV
h^Ÿogdo¨d\‹l!VcdlZdYgdhinbd\|h^ŸildgonoWVgYod`g‹i`^X]^X][gV\bZci‹l#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ L^VigbdèZegoZcdh^c^Z¨je`^cVdYaZ\¨dсd`#*%%bZig‹l#Edod"
hiVl^dcZ!c^Zl^Za`^Zedl^ZgoX]c^Zgdhc|XZ\ddhigdèZc^V)!*b'bd\|edldYdlV
legonho¨dÑX^oVX]lVhoXoZc^ZcVlZi*%]VjegVl#
,- ,.

Edl‹_edacn
8dckdakjajhVgkZch^hA#
8DC6G
Edld_dlViZ!8dckdakjaVXZhZ

;^ZaYW^cYlZZY
A^hZgdcYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg"L^cYZ

GdÑa^cViglV¨V!deaViVgdÑa^cnjegVlcZ!aZe^Z_gdol^_Vh^Ÿlb^Z_hXVX]cVh¨dcZXoc^d"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

cnX]#LnhiŸedlVc^Zedld_jol^Ÿ`hoVh^ŸlaViVX]hjX]nX]#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdÑa^cVedegoZX^ŸX^jlnYo^ZaVhd`baZXocnXoŸhidbnadcV
ogYZhiZbedld_dlnb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViZ! Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/ eVadln! \¨ŸWd`^ Yd '!* b odY"
-&%bb!loVgnh^ZXoldgd`|icZ!cV\^Z! X]dYo|Xnb^ dY c^Z\d `dgoZc^Vb^ WdXocnb^!
X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZhoZgd`dlX^ŸiZ! `i‹gZedXo|i`dldgdhc|edo^dbd!VcVhiŸec^Z
o lngV„cnb h^Vi`dlVcnb jcZgl^Zc^Zb oV\¨ŸW^V_|h^ŸedY`|iZbegdhinblY‹¨#
^XoZgldcd cVW^Z\¨nb^ d\dc`Vb^ jlV" çD9N<6/lnhd`dс'%&%%Xb!d`g|\¨VlV!
\V/[dgbnogdobcVèVc^VlZ\ZiVinlcZ\d l^_|XVh^ŸlaZld!eZ¨oV_|XV!`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcV
XoŸhid^X]c^ZlnilVgoV_| A>Ð8>:/ higoV¨`dlViZ ajW dhoXoZedlViZ! cV"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ \^Z! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ! XV¨dWgoZ\^Z! cV hoXonX^Z
Y¨j\dс&%'%bb!cV\V!苨iVldXoZg" oVd`g|\adcZ
ldcV @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ

E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ ig‹_`|ic^Z _V_dlViZ! @L>6I/ `l^Vin oZWgVcZ ed _ZYcnb ajW YlV
cV\^Z! h`gŸidaZ\¨Z! o oVd`g|\adcnb ajW l`|iVX]a^ÑX^!WaVYdg‹èdlZ!oe^ŸX^dbVXoZg"
iŸenbhoXoniZb ldcnb^hbj\Vb^dYoZlc|igo!eVX]c|XZ
DLD8/ idgZW`V! cV\V! didXodcV `^Za^X]Zb!
_VhcdWgjcVicVajWhoVgV
C6H>:C>:/ dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViZ! cV ed"
l^ZgoX]c^ YgdWcd WgdYVl`dlVcZ! l\‹goZ
oVd`g|\adcZ! X^ZbcdhoVgZ ajW X^ZbcdWgj"
cVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZhoXoZ\‹ac^Z`j`jgnYoV!d`dedlZ!hiVcdl^"
h`VgjYZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZW!\¨‹lc^ZaZ``^Z!hiVcdl^h`VhjX]hoZ
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`h^ac^Z`dc`jgj_|Xndh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZogdÑa^c|je"
gVlc|!deaViV_|edldYj_|XlnaZ\Vc^Z^jigjYc^V_|XoW^‹g#CVedaVX]gdobcVèVh^Ÿ
\¨‹lc^Z egoZo edX^ŸiZ l XoVh^Z jegVln edYo^ZbcZ [gV\bZcin `dgoZc^ ^gdo¨d\‹l!
`i‹gZlhX]dYo|lhoZgd`^boV`gZh^ZiZbeZgVijg^\¨ŸWd`dÑX^#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cV igj_|XV! oVl^ZgV_|XV `dcldalja^cŸ! ol^|o`^ `jbVgncdlZ
^\VgWc^`^#HoXoZ\‹ac^Zc^ZWZoe^ZXocVYaV`dc^#
-% -&

C^ZoVedb^cV_`VedacV
Bndhdi^hVgkZch^hA#
BND6G
Hodghi`da^hicZ!7dgV\^cVXZVZ
C^ZoVedb^cV_`VedÑgZYc^V
;^ZaY[dg\Zi"bZ"cdi
Bndhdi^hYZhX]VbehcZbÁdjWa^ZoeVh
6X`Zg"KZg\^›bZ^cc^X]i

GdÑa^cVcVedaVX]jegVlcnX]_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Z"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

h^Zc^|^l^dhc|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Z^¨dYn\Vhodgh`ddYhiV_|Xddl¨dh^dcZ!YgdWcZ!X^Zb"
cdc^ZW^Zh`^Z!o苨i|\VgYo^Za|!cVdYhiV_|XnX]honej¨`VX]

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/d`g|\¨Z! Y¨j\dс ()bb! @DGO:°/gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
ed`gniZYgdWcnb^!`g‹i`^b^l¨dh`Vb^ lnhd`dс&*)%Xb!loc^Zh^dcV!
çD9N<6/
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ oln`aZl\‹goZgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!dYhiV_|Xddl¨d"
Y¨j\dс)*bb!lVaXdlViV!cV\V!Wgj" h^dcV
cVicVlV A>Ð8>:/ YdacZdYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ!dYo^db"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ e^Zglhona^сedY¨j" `dlZoZWgVcZlg‹ènXo`Ÿ!lngVhiV_|WZoedÑ"
\dlVid"dYlgdic^Z _V_dlVin! cV hoXonX^Z gZYc^d cVY a^ÑX^Zc^Vb^! d\dc`dlZ! hoVgdo^Z"
iŸen!XoVhZbaZ``dlX^Ÿin adc`VlZ!\‹gcZaVcXZidlViZ!h^ZYo|XZ
@L>6IDHI6C/aj„cZh`gŸi`^
@L>6I/ `l^VinYgdWcZ!X^Zbcdc^ZW^Zh`^Z!
o苨i|\VgYo^Za|!cVdYhiV_|XnX]honej¨`VX]
DLD8/gdo¨je`VgdoeVYV_|XVh^ŸcVc^Z¨je`^!
d`g|\¨Z

_V_dlViV!cVhoXonX^ZoVdhigodcV!WVglnXoVg"
cZ_!\¨VY`V!h^ac^Zed¨nh`j_|XV
C6H>:C>:/c^ZgZ\jaVgcZ!WZèdlZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèVdo^bZ^_VgZ!d`dedlZ!`dc^Xoncn
<A:7N/lhonhi`^gdYoV_Z\aZW!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZaZ``^Z!e^VhoXonhiZ!d\gdYn^aVhn
ho`dYa^ldс C^Z¨je`^c^ZoVedb^cV_`^h|igjYcZYddYYo^ZaZc^VdYcVh^dc`dc^"
Xonc#L\aZW^ZoVX]dlj_|h^¨Ÿ`^Z¨`dlVc^Vd`#Yl‹X]aVi#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ <VijcZ`edejaVgcnliZ`hiVX]l^Zaje^dhZcZ`#
-' -(

?VhcdiVejgejgdlV
AVb^jbejgejgZjbA#
A6BEJ
LVg\dlZ!AVb^VXZVZ

GZYYZVY"cZiiaZ
AVb^ZgedjgegZ
GdiZIVjWcZhhZa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV^do^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|ajWl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ WdgYdlZoVWVgl^Zc^ZcV¨dYn\VX]hi|YcVolV!h^acnX]V"
gV`iZgnhinXocnoVeVX]edl|X]V_

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dlVacZ!Y¨j\dс)-bb! @DGO:°/eVadln!gdol^Yadcn
cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^Ze¨ni`dlX^ŸiZ
çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&%(%Xb!XoldgdWdXo"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ cV! Yd¨Zb gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV! cV\V ajW cV `gVlŸ"
Y¨j\dс-&*bb!cV\V!Yd¨Zbo^ZadcV! Yo^VX]dl¨dh^dcV
\‹g|WgjcVicdXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V A>Ð8>:/ hoZgd`d_V_dlViZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ dlVacdhZgXdlViZ! `g‹i`d dl¨dh^dcZ! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ! h^ac^Z `Vg"
dWjhigdcc^ZaZ``ddl¨dh^dcZ!cVegoZX^l" WdlVcZ
aZ\¨Z!`VgWdlVcZ @L>6IDHI6C/ WgV`
@L>6I/ `l^VinoZWgVcZlc^Wnd`ܬ`VX]cV
hoXonX^ZgdÑa^cn!ejgejgdlZ
DLD8/gdo¨je`V!dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViV!_Vhcd"
hoVgV! cV hoXonX^Z iŸeV! o YgdWcnb^ W^V¨nb^
WgdYVl`Vb^
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ
dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z  JEG6LN/ d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZ!ÑX^Zgc^h`V!d\gdYn!hiVcdl^h`V


gjYZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZW!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ
ho`dYa^ldс 8]lVhigdol^_V_|Xnh^Ÿ^ciZchnlc^Z!lX^|\jgd`jbdèZYV`^a`V
ed`daZ²# Edheda^in lZ lhonhi`^X] jegVlVX]! hoXoZ\‹ac^Z cVldèdcnX] dWdgc^`^Zb!
ViV`èZcVc^Zjèni`VX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ DldXZegoZcdhodcZh|egoZobg‹l`^!Xdol^Ÿ`hoVgdoegoZhigoZc^V"
c^ZX]lVhi‹lljegVlVX]#
-) -*

?VhcdiVg‹èdlV
AVb^jbVbeaZm^XVjaZA#
A6B6B
LVg\dlZ!AVb^VXZVZ

=ZcW^iYZVY"cZiiaZ
AVb^ZgVbeaZm^XVjaZ
HiZc\Zajb[VhhZcYZIVjWcZhhZa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV^do^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|^_Zh^Zc^|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zh^ac^Z`VgWdlVcZ_V`jWdYo^ho`V!VaZiVbina`digon
`aVe`^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dlVacZ^lngV„c^ZlX^ŸiZ @DGO:°/eVadln!gdol^Yadcn
j cVhVYn XZX]V X]VgV`iZgnhinXocV! Y¨# çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс &%(%Xb! XoiZgd`Vc"
*,bb!cVhoXonX^ZaZ``doVd`g|\adcZ X^VhiV!lYdaZgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!cV\V!gdoZh¨VcV
olX^ŸX^Zb!cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ ¼ d`g|\¨Vld hZgXdlViZ! c^Z"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ g‹lcd`VgWdlVcZ!YgdWcZ!\‹gcZ¼cZg`dlV"
Y¨j\dс &%&*bb! cV\V! j Yd¨j W^V" iZ!h^ZYo|XZ
¨VlV!j\‹gnXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ ig‹_`|ic^Z_V_dlViZ! @L>6I/ `l^Vin _VhcdejgejgdlZ! h`je^dcZ
hoVgVld dl¨dh^dcZ! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! cV lc^Wnd`‹¨`^edhoZсYdYo^Zh^ŸX^j!lngVhiV_|
hoXonX^ZoVd`g|\adcZ l`|iVX]a^ÑX^!`l^VinedlhiV_|XZe‹„c|_Zh^Z"
c^|^lXoZhc|l^dhc|c^Zdil^ZgV_|h^Ÿ`aZ_hid"
\Vb^XocZ
DLD8/ gdo¨je`V dYlgdic^Z _V_dlViV! cV
hoXonX^ZiŸeV!_VhcdhoVgV!W^V¨dWgdYVl`dlVcV
dlVacZ

C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZ!`dc^Xoncn!ÑX^Zgc^h`V!hiVcdl^h`V
gjYZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZW!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZhjX]ZhiVcdl^h`V
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`oVX]lVhoXoVl^Ÿ`hodсjegVl#7VgYodedheda^incVg‹è"
cnX]ineVX]\aZWVX]!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZoVhdWcnX]llVe²#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ C^Za^XocZ dldXZ d`# '%% hoij` o _ZYcZ_ gdÑa^cn h| egoZcdhodcZ
egoZobg‹l`^#EgVlYdedYdWc^Z_ZhigdÑa^c|igj_|X|!hoXoZ\‹ac^Zlo\aŸYZb`dc^#
-+ -,

@|`daedacn
6\gdhiZbbV\^i]V\dA#
6<D<>
<d„Yo^`dlViZ!8Vgnde]naaVXZVZ

8dgcXdX`aZ
C^ZaaZYZhWa‚h
@dgcgVYZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!do^bVajW_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸcV_a^Xoc^Z__Zh^Zc^|!Vc^Z`^Z"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

YniV`èZl^dhc|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Z\Ÿhided`gniZY¨j\^b^dYhiV_|Xnb^W^V¨Vlnb^l¨dh"
`Vb^!¨dYn\VhoVgddl¨dh^dcV

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dlVacZ!c^Zg‹lcZ_l^Za`dÑX^ @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!aZ``dgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
Y¨j\dс '%(%bb! edY¨jècZ! o l^Zgo" çD9N<6/lnhd`dс(%.%Xb!hoVgd!b^Ÿ``d
X]d¨`^Zb oVd`g|\adcnb! edX]l^Vhid o¨|" Y¨j\ddl¨dh^dcV!\‹g|gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV
XodcZld\dc`^ A>Ð8>:/ g‹lcdl|h`daVcXZidlViZ!cVegoZ"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ X^laZ\¨Z!dl¨dh^dcZ
Y¨#&%'*bb!WaVYd"o^ZadcV @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!cVegoZ" @L>6I/ `l^Vined_ZYncXoZcVY¨j\^X]hon
X^laZ\¨Z!dhigZ ej¨`VX]!ejgejgdlZ^ÉdaZidlZ
DLD8/ idgZW`V!dil^ZgVh^Ÿe^ŸX^dbVo|W"
`Vb^
C6H>:C>:/cZg`dlViZ!XoVhZb`ja^hiZ!Xold"
gdÑX^ZccZ!X^ZbcdWgjcVicZajWXoVgcZ!\Ÿhid
ed`gniZdhignb^lngdhi`Vb^
dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèV hoXoZ\‹ac^Z ènid <A:7N/ g‹ècZ inen \aZW!


oVg‹lcdX^ŸèhoZ!_V`^aZ``^Z
ho`dYa^ldс @|`da_Zhiedheda^inbX]lVhiZboW‹èdo^bnX]^_VgnX]#9d_goZlV
gVoZboZoWdèVb^^YaViZ\dYdhiV_Zh^ŸYdbViZg^V¨jh^ZlcZ\d#CVh^dcV`|`dajhid"
hjc`dldhonW`digVX|hld_|ènldicdсldWdgc^`j^l\aZW^Z#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcV`|`dajoVl^ZgV_|igj_|X|hVedc^cŸ^\^iV\^cŸ#EgonYjènb
oVc^ZXonhoXoZc^jo^VgcVcVYV_|b|XZh^acZoVWVgl^Zc^Z^c^Zegon_Zbcn\dgo`^hbV`#
-- -.

Edo^Zlc^`hodghi`^
<VaZdeh^hiZigV]^iA#
<6:I:
LVg\dlZ!AVb^VXZVZ

8dbbdc]Zbe"cZiiaZ
Dgi^ZgdnVaZ
<ZbZ^cZg=d]aoV]c

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸegoZYZlhonhi`^bl^dhc|!VaZg‹lc^Zè
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

lXoZhcnbaViZb#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ gdÑa^cVh^ac^Z!hodghi`ddl¨dh^dcVhi|YcVolV\Vijc`j

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ d`g|\¨VlddlVacZ!Y¨j\dс @DGO:°/eVadln!h^ac^Zgdol^c^Ÿin
*-bb!cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZoV" çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс&%&%%Xb!llŸo¨VX]
d`g|\adcZ!aZ``dlX^ŸiZ o\gjW^V¨V!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!h^ac^Z!hodghi`d
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ dl¨dh^dcV
Y¨j\dс&%(*bb!cV\V!l\‹goZXoZg" A>Ð8>:/_V_dlVidaVcXZidlViZ!dl¨dh^dcZ!o^Z"
ldcdcVW^Z\¨V adcZ! e^¨`dlVcZ ajW `VgWdlVcZ! cV hoXonX^Z
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ Za^einXocZ!aZ``ddl" oVdhigodcZ
¨dh^dcZ!cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z!WgoZ\^Zbe^¨`d" @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
lVcZajW`VgWdlVcZ @L>6I/`l^VinoZWgVcZlc^Wnd`ܬ`^!ejgej"
gdlZ!g‹èdlZajW`gZbdlZ
DLD8/ d`g|\¨d_V_dlViV!aZ``dhe¨VhoXodcV!
X^ZbcdhoVgVgdo¨je`V!oXoVgcnb!bVgbjg`d"
lVinbe^\bZcidlVc^Zb
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ
dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ
<A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ_V`^e^VhoXonhiZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!l^a\dicZ
ho`dYa^ldс Edo^Zlc^`lnhiŸej_ZhoXoZ\‹ac^Za^Xoc^ZloWdèVX]!ol¨VhoXoV_V"
gnX]#Jc^`V\aZWhjX]nX]^jWd\^X]lVodi#DldXZdhnej_|h^ŸegoZYoW^dgZboW‹è!
VaZcVd\‹¨c^Z`^Z¨`j_|dYgVoj!d`gZhhedXonc`jodhiV_ZegoZglVcnYde^ZgdedegoZ"
o^bdlVc^jgdo¨jeZ`#ænldicdсdldX‹llncdh^ina`d`^a`VaVi#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|Yd))i¨jhoXoj!`i‹gndYocVXoVh^Ÿl¨VÑX^ldÑ"
X^Vb^igj_|Xnb^#GdÑa^cVb^dYdYV_cV^en¨`dYV_cV#9o^V¨Vigj_|XdcVol^ZgoŸiV\dhed"
YVgh`^Z!hoXoZ\‹ac^Z`dc^Z#
.% .&

Gjb^Vcedacn
6ci]Zb^hVgkZch^hA#
6CI6G
6higdlViZO¨dèdcZ!6hiZgVXZVZ8dbedh^iVZ

8dgcX]Vbdb^aaZ
6ci]‚b^hYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg=jcYh`Vb^aaZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV^do^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸegoZYZlhonhi`^b_Zh^Zc^|dgVo
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

l^dhc|#
XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ ¨dYnè`VedYa^ÑX^Zc^dlVlngV„c^ZWgjcVicdXoZgldcV!Ycd
`l^VidlZl`dhonXo`joeaZl^c`Vb^!lnej`¨Z

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ dlVacZ!Y¨#)+bb!b^Ÿh^hiZ! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin
cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ! cV hoXonX^Z aZ``d lX^ŸiZ
çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс &%)%Xb! d`g|\¨VlV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!egonaZ\V_|Xddl¨dh^dcV
Y¨j\dс*&%bb!cV\V!WgjcVicdXoZg" A>Ð8>:/Ylj`gdic^Ze^ZgoVhidh^ZXocZ!dYX^c`^
ldcV g‹lcdl|h`daVcXZidlViZYdсdYaZ\¨ZdYh^Z"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ ed_ZYncXode^ZgoVhid" W^Z!XV¨dWgoZ\^ZajWo|W`dlVcZ!b^Ÿh^hiZ
Yo^ZacZ o YldbV eVgVb^ aVcXZidlVinX] @L>6IDHI6C/`dhonXoZ`
dYX^c`‹l! aZ``d dl¨dh^dcZ! cVegoZX^l" @L>6I/ `l^Vin WgoZècZ _ŸonXo`dlViZ W^V¨Z!
aZ\¨Z `l^VinlZlcŸigocZgjg`dlZ苨iZ!Ycd`l^V"
idlZoeaZl^c`Vb^!lnej`¨Z
DLD8/ c^Z¨je`V egnobVinXocV! cV hoXonX^Z
aZ``dl`aŸh¨V!oa^Xocnb^edY¨jècnb^èZWZg`V"
b^!苨iVldhoVgV!XoiZgd"ajWe^ŸX^d`VcX^VhiV
C6H>:C>:/c^ZgZ\jaVgcZ
dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!oWdèdlZ!goZeV`!iglV¨Zjèni`^o^ZadcZ!hiV"
cdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZWaZ``^Z!ÑgZYc^Z!X^Ÿè`^Z!edheda^inX]lVhi
cVXV¨nbdWhoVgoZ`gV_j
ho`dYa^ldс 8]lVhilnhiŸej_|Xnedheda^X^Zlg‹ècnX]jegVlVX]!hoXoZ\‹ac^Z
oWdèdlnX]#Gdol^_Vh^ŸYdWgoZcV\aZWVX]e^VhoXonhinX]!`lVÑcnX]!jWd\^X]lh`¨VY"
c^`^ed`VgbdlZ#CV_ZYcZ_gdÑa^c^ZlnilVgoV`^a`Vinh^ŸXndldX‹ldog‹èc^XdlVcZ_
l^Za`dÑX^^d`gZh^ZhedXonc`j#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ Gjb^VcdYYo^V¨j_Z_V`dcVijgVacn^chZ`inXnY#
.' .(

HoXoVlolnXoV_cn
GjbZmVXZidhVA#
GJB66
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

8dbbdchdggZa
<gVcYZdhZ^aaZ
<gd›ZgHVjZgVbe[Zg

GdÑa^cVl^ZadaZic^V!Ylje^ZccV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZXdb^Ÿh^hiZ!_V`Wnob|XonhinbcVadiZb

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/dlVacZ!Y¨j\dс*%,%bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
cVhoXonX^ZoVdhigodcZajWoVd`g|\adcZ çD9N<6/lnhd`dс(%&%%Xb!loc^Zh^dcV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ Y¨j\dс cV\VajWWVgYod`g‹i`ddl¨dh^dcV
-&%bb!XoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨V A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ _V_dlVid aVcXZidlViZ! `g‹i`d
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/e^Zglhona^с_V_dlVin! oVdhigodcZ!\‹gcZaVcXZidlViZ!egVl^Zh^ZYo|XZ
YVahoZ edY¨j\dlVid _V_dlViZ! iŸeZ! cV @L>6IDHI6C/\V¨Ÿo^hin!aj„cn!WZoa^hicn
Y¨j\^X]d\dc`VX] @L>6I/ dYYo^Zac^ZgdÑa^cno`l^ViVb^bŸh`^"
b^ ^ èZ²h`^b^! XoŸÑ d`l^Vij WaVYdo^ZadcV!
WgoZ\^ZbXoZgldcVlV
DLD8/dgoZhoZ`!edY¨jècn!oigoZbVdhignb^
`VciVb^!X^ZbcdWgjcVicn!\¨VY`^!aÑc^|Xn
C6H>:C>:/`VcX^VhiZ!WZèdlZ
dlVacZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ `dc^Xoncn!ajXZgcn!¨|`^^eVhil^h`V <A:7N/ \a^c^VhiZ!


ènocZ!aZ``d`lVÑcZ
ho`dYa^ldс GdÑa^cVWVgYode¨dYcV!_ZYZcd`VobdèZlnildgonYd)%%b^a^d"
c‹lo^VgZcen¨`j#@dc`jgj_Zo\Vijc`Vb^jegVlcnb^egoZYZlhonhi`^bcV¨|`VX]
^eVhil^h`VX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgV`lVhhoXoVl^dln!b¨dYZa^ÑX^ZcVYV_|h^ŸcVojeŸ#
EgonbVhdlnblnhiŸedlVc^jcV¨|`VX]bdèZedldYdlVoVigjX^VjWnY¨V#
.) .*

7VW`VaVcXZidlViV
EaVciV\daVcXZdaViVA#
EA6A6
7VW`dlViZ!EaVciV\^cVXZVZ

G^WldgieaVciV^c
EaVciV^caVcX‚da‚
He^iolZ\Zg^X]

GdÑa^cViglV¨V#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZWVgYodl|h`^Z!¨dYnè`VedYa^ÑX^Zc^dlVXoZgldcdcVW^Z"
\¨V!a^ÑX^ZlngV„c^ZaVcXZidlViZ!d\dc`^a^ÑX^dlZXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨Z

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!lcVhVYo^Z @DGO:°/ \¨‹lcnlgoZX^dcdlVin!`g‹i`^!
ogdÑc^ŸiZ! Y¨j\dс (**% bb! cV\^Z! \gjWn!li‹gn`dgoZ²b^diZ¨`dlVin
o^ZadcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс&%(%Xb¨dYn\^`l^V"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ idhiVcdlZ
dW¨V!Y¨j\dс,.bb!XoZgldcVldcV" A>Ð8>:/ aVcXZidlViZ!oZWgVcZlgdoZiŸ!cV
W^Z\¨V!cV\V WgoZ\VX] YZa^`Vic^Z ¨VbVcZ! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/aVcXZidlViZ!cVhoXon" d\dc`^a^ÑX^dlZ!oln`aZXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨Z
X^Z oVdhigodcZ! aZ``d ed`gniZ X^Zc`^b^ @L>6IDHI6C/ `¨dhhoXonidln!WVgYod\Ÿhin!
l¨dh`Vb^ _V_dlVidedY¨j\dlVin
@L>6I/ hjX]dW¨dc^VhiZ`l^Vin!WgjcVicZ_
WVgln
DLD8/idgZW`VYljcVh^ZccV!lYdacZ_XoŸÑ"
X^ol^ZXo`^Zb
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ!_Vhcd"ajWX^ZbcdWgjcVi"
cZ!\¨VY`^Z!ed¨nh`j_|XZ
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ `dc^Xoncn!ajXZgcn!aZc!oWdèV_VgZ^do^bZ!eVhil^h`V


^¨|`^<A:7N/g‹ècZ!aZ``^Z^X^Ÿè`^Z
ho`dYa^ldс CVedaVX]jegVlcnX]_ZhihoXoZ\‹ac^ZjX^|èa^lVlgoVY`^X]`dc^"
XoncVX]^ajXZgcVX]!l`i‹gnX]oln`aZlnhiŸej_ZbVhdld#CVh^dcVjigonbj_|oYda"
cdс`^Z¨`dlVc^VegoZo`^a`VaVi^`^Z¨`j_|\¨‹lc^Zl^dhc|#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ A^ÑX^ZoVl^ZgV_|Ñajo!\a^`donYVj`jW^cŸ!ediVh^`lVhXnigncdln#
?ZhihidhdlVcVlaZXoc^Xil^ZajYdlnb#
.+ .,

BV`edacn
EVeVkZgg]dZVhA#
E6EG=
BV`dlViZ!EVeVkZgVXZVZ

8dbbdcedeen
8dfjZa^Xdi
@aVihX]"Bd]c

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^cVj\dgVX]^oWdèVX]lnhiŸej_|bVhdld
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

_Zh^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^ZlngV„c^Zdl¨dh^dcZ!edYhedYZboh^cnbcVadiZb!
¨dYn\Vh^ac^Zdl¨dh^dcV!h^cdo^ZadcV!edegoZX^ŸX^jlnYo^ZaVhd`baZXocn

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!Y¨#+.bb!cV" @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin
\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZaZ``doVdhigodcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd"`dс'%+%Xb!d`g|\¨VlV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ loc^Zh^dcV! h^ac^Z hoXoZX^c^Vhid dl¨dh^dcV!
Y¨#(,bb!cV\V!c^i`dlViV!o^ZadcV h^cVldo^ZadcV
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/_V_dlViZ!cV\^ZajWaZ`" A>Ð8>:/ dlVacZ!ed_ZYncXodajWedYl‹_c^Z
`d dl¨dh^dcZ! cVegoZX^laZ\¨Z! cV hoXon" e^ZgoVhidYo^ZacZ!olŸèV_|XZh^Ÿld\dcZ`!edY
X^ZoVdhigodcZ hedYZboh^cVlnbcVadiZb!WgoZ\^ZblngV„"
c^Zo|W`dlVcZ
@L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
@L>6I/ `l^Vined_ZYncXoZ!ejgejgdldXoZg"
ldcZoYjè|X^Zbc|eaVb|jcVhVYne¨Vi`‹l
`dgdcn
DLD8/idgZW`V!dlVacVajW`ja^hiV!XV¨`^Zb
cV\V
C6H>:C>:/ cZg`dlViZ!bVidlZ!_VhcZVaWd
X^ZbcdWgjcVicZ
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZhoXoZ\‹ac^Zdo^bZ!d`dedlZ
<A:7N/X^Ÿè"`^Z!\a^c^VhiZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!goVYo^Z_aZ``^Z!jWd\^ZlediVh
ho`dYa^ldс GdÑa^cV WVgYod e¨dYcV# 8oŸÑ cVh^dc bdèZ `^Z¨`dlV cV Ñl^ZiaZ
oedl^ZgoX]c^\aZWn!^ccZedodhiV_|l\aZW^ZcVY¨j\^ZaViV#Gdol^_Vh^Ÿ^ciZchnlc^Z
laViVX]l^a\dicnX]!lb^Z_hXVX]\Yo^ZYdi|Yc^ZlnhiŸedlV¨#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 8]lVhiigj_|Xn!oVl^ZgVVa`Vad^YgZVYncŸ!YaVWnY¨V!`dc^^igodYn
X]aZlcZ_#@l^VibV`j_ZhihidhdlVcnlo^d¨daZXoc^Xil^Z#
.- ..

GYZhiedld_dln
Edan\dcjbXdckdakjajhA#
EDA8D
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

7aVX`W^cYlZZY
GZcdj‚Za^hZgdc
L^cYZc"@cŽiZg^X]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸcV_a^Xoc^Z_lbV_j^XoZglXj!ViV`èZ
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

lXoZhc|_Zh^Zc^|#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ Y¨j\^Z!g‹lcdl|h`^Za^ÑX^Zc^Z!e^Zglhona^сlngV„c^Zig‹_"
`|icn

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!Y¨#&%'%bb! @DGO:°/ lgoZX^dcdlVin!苨iVldWgjcVicn!
cV\^Z!o^ZadcZedYhedYZbXoZgldcVlZ! \¨ŸWd`^!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
cVhoXonX^ZiŸeZajWoVd`g|\adcZ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс '%&%%Xb! `VcX^VhiV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ Yd¨Zbgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!l^_|XVh^Ÿ!`g‹i`ddl¨d"
Y¨j\dс &*'%bb! Yd¨Zb cV\V! \‹g| h^dcV!hodghi`V
aZ``ddbhodcV!`Vgb^cdldXoZgldcV A>Ð8>:/ hZgXdlVidhigoV¨`dlViZ!d\dc`dlZ!
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ higoV¨`dlViZ! h`gŸid" cVhoXonX^ZdhigdoV`d²XodcZ!o`g‹i`|\Vi`|
aZ\¨Z!cVhoXonX^ZdhigZ jcVhVYn
@L>6IDHI6C/`¨dhd`hoiV¨icn
@L>6I/ `l^Vino^Zadc`VldW^V¨Z!WgoZ\^Zb
W^V¨Z!c^ZedodgcZ
DLD8/ig‹_\gVc^VhindgoZhoZ`!oVdhigodcncV
_ZYcnb`d²Xj!XoVgcn
C6H>:C>:/edY¨j\dlViZ
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZhoXoZ\‹ac^Z_VgZ!d`dedlZ!lVgonlV!hiVcd"
l^h`VgjYZgVacZ<A:7N/aZ``^Z!ÑgZYc^Z!idaZgj_ZdYXonc`lVÑcn
ho`dYa^ldс OZlo\aŸYjcV\¨ŸWd`^hnhiZb`dgoZc^dln\VijcZ`dYedgcncV
c^ZYdWdgn l^a\dX^ ^ h`¨VYc^`‹l ed`VgbdlnX] l \aZW^Z# DeaViV gdÑa^cn jegVlcZ
hegon_V_|XlnaZ\Vc^j^jigjYc^V_|XoW^‹gbZX]Vc^Xocn#9d_goZlVgVoZboZoWdèVb^
oVX]lVhoXoV_|X oVg‹lcd \aZWŸ! _V` ^ bViZg^V¨ h^Zlcn# DldXZ cVlZi `^a`V inh^ŸXn
o_ZYcZ_gdÑa^cn`^Z¨`j_|Yde^Zgdl^dhc|cVhiŸecZ\dgd`jo\¨ŸWd`dÑX^cVlZi'%Xb#
GdocdhodcZh|odWdgc^`^Zb^\cd_dl^X|!oVX]dlj_|XènldicdсYd'%aVi#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cV o_ZYodcV lhiVc^Z o^Zadcnb bdèZ edldYdlV oVigjX^V
j`dc^#DldXZoVl^ZgV_|WVglc^`^Yd[VgWdlVc^Vi`Vc^c#
&%% &%&

GYZhieiVh^
Edan\dcjbVk^XjaVgZA#
EDA6K
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

@cdi"\gVhh
GZcdj‚ZYZhd^hZVjm
Kd\Za`cŽiZg^X]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸegoZYZlhonhi`^blbV_j#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zc^ZedY¨j\dlViZ!lngV„c^ZoZhdW|ogdÑc^ŸiZcVhVYVb^
lW¨dc^Vhi|edX]lŸ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!ogdÑc^ŸiZcVhV" @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!\¨ŸWd`^
YVb^! Y¨# &%&*bb! cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ! çD9N<6/lnh#&*+%Xb!`daVc`dlV!jcV"
ed¨nh`j_|XZ!cVhoXonX^ZiŸedoV`d²XodcZ hVYngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!aZè|XV!goVY`dloc^Zh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ Za^einXocdaVcXZidlViZ!h^cdo^ZadcZ!
Y¨j\dс&*'%bb!cV\V!XoZgldcdcV" ogjg`dlVi|edhigoŸe^dc|\Vi`|jcVhVYn!cV
W^Z\¨V hoXonX^ZaZ``doVdhigodcZ
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ Za^einXocZ!bdYgVld" @L>6IDHI6C/WgV`
o^ZadcZ!cV\^Z!oW¨dc^Vhi|^edhigoŸe^dc| @L>6I/`l^VinYgdWcZoZWgVcZed`^a`VYlV
\Vi`| Yd e^ŸX^j l `|iVX] a^ÑX^! g‹èdlZ! lZlc|igo
W^V¨do^ZadcZ
DLD8/ig‹_\gVc^VhindgoZhoZ`d_ZYcZ_bc^Z_"
hoZ_ÑX^Vc^Z!X^ZbcdWgjcVicn!XoŸhidogZhoi`|
d`l^Vij
C6H>:C>:/XoZgldcVld苨iZ!ho`a^hiZ
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZhoXoZ\‹ac^Zdo^bZ!d`dedlZ!d\gdYn!WgoZ\^
e‹agdÑa^cVÑl^Vi¨dajWcV!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ<A:7N/g‹ècZinen\aZW!ildgonl^Z"
aZ[dgbog‹èc^XdlVcnX]bdg[dad\^Xoc^ZloVaZècdÑX^dYhiVcdl^h`V!l`i‹gnbgdÑc^Z
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`ildgonl^ZaZog‹èc^XdlVcnX][dgb!Ñl^Vi¨dajWcn#OVX]"
lVhoXoVegoZYZlhonhi`^bWgoZ\^e‹a#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ O^ZaZoVl^ZgVÊVldcd^Yn! l^iVb^cŸ 8! egdl^iVb^cŸ 6 dgVo \a^`d"
onYnVcigVX]^cdcdlZ#HidhdlVcnlo^d¨daZXoc^Xil^Z!dldXZbd\|hiVcdl^eVhoŸYaV
YgdW^j#
&%' &%(

HedgZ`edacn
HeZg\jaVVgkZch^hA#
HEG6G
<d„Yo^`dlViZ!8Vgnde]naaVXZVZ

8dgchejggZn
HeZg\jaZYZhX]Vbeh
6X`Zg"HeŽg\Za

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|¼lbV_j^XoZglXj#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZcV\‹gcZ_higdc^Zlnej`¨Z!oedY¨jèc|WgjoY"
`|cVYdacZ_!gdÑa^cVaZe`V

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!Y¨#-'*bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdol^Yadcn
cV\^Z! o^ZadcZ! cV hoXonX^Z iŸed oV`d²" çD9N<6/lnh#&%+%Xb!locdho|XV!dYcV"
XodcZ hVYngdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ c^i`dlViZ! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ! oZWgVcZ
dW¨V! Y¨j\dс *&%bb! c^i`dlViV! ld`‹¨`^!b^Ÿh^hiZ!aZe`^Z
o^Zadc`VlVajWWgjcVicdXoZgldcV @L>6IDHI6C/l^ZgoX]di`VYljgVb^ZccV
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ egVl^Z c^i`dlViZ! @L>6I/ YgdWcZ`l^Vin!W^V¨Z!cVY¨j\^X]hon"
cV \‹gcZ_ higdc^Z lnej`¨Z! o edY¨jèc| ej¨`VX]
WgjoY`|cVYdacZ_!h`je^dcZlc^Wnd`‹¨`j DLD8/idgZW`V!eŸ`V_|XV!oVl^ZgV_|XVa^XocZ
YgdWcZcVh^dcV
C6H>:C>:/ `ja^hiZ! he¨VhoXodcZ! oW^V¨Vl|
W¨dc^Vhi|dWl‹Y`|
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèV_VgZ!d`dedlZ <A:7N/ aZ``^Z!e^VhoXonhiZ!WVg"


Yodh¨VWZ!ol¨VhoXoV`lVÑcZgdÑa^cVlh`V„c^`dlV
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`dYjèZ_oYdacdÑX^VYVeiVXn_cZ_!lnhiŸej_Zlg‹ècnX][dg"
bVX]Z`dad\^XocnX]#CVh^dcVoVX]dlj_|oYdacdс`^Z¨`dlVc^VegoZol^ZaZaVi#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 9Vlc^Z_ jegVl^Vcn _V`d gdÑa^cV eVhodlV# 8]Ÿic^Z o_VYVcn egoZo
ol^ZgoŸiV#
&%) &%*

HoVg¨Vihodghi`^
6bVgVci]jhgZigdÊZmjh A#
6B6G:
HoVg¨VidlViZ!6bVgVci]VXZVZ

8dbbdcVbVgVci]<7!GZY"gddie^\lZZYJH6
6bVgVciZg‚Ê‚X]^Z
GVj]VVg^\Zg6bVgVci

GdÑa^cV _ZYcdgdXocV# H^Zl`^ ed_Vl^V_| h^Ÿ l Ygj\^Z_ ed¨dl^Z l^dhcn ^ cV edXo|i`j
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

aViV#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Zol^ZgoX]jhoVgdo^ZadcZWgoZ\^Zb^cVhedYc^Z_higd"
c^ZXoZgldcVlZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z!Y¨#,&'bb! @DGO:°/ lgoZX^dcdlVin! \gjWn! gdo\V¨Ÿ"
cV\^Z! o l^ZgoX]j o^ZadcZ! cV hedYc^Z_ o^dcn!aZ``dg‹èdln
higdc^ZcV_XoŸÑX^Z_XoZgldcVldcVW^Z\¨Z! çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&%&%%Xb!loc^Zh^dcV!
cVhoXonX^Zoln`aZiŸeZ ed_ZYncXoVajWgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!_Vhcdo^ZadcVYd
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ XoZgldcVlZ_!`g‹i`d^hodghi`ddl¨dh^dcV
Y¨j\dс&%'%bb!cV\V!`Vgb^cdld" A>Ð8>:/ gdbWdld _V_dlViZ! hoVgdo^ZadcZ! cV
XoZgldcV WgoZ\j XoZgldcVlZ! h`gŸidaZ\¨Z! cV hoXonX^Z
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlViZ!egoncZg" aZ``d oVdhigodcZ ajW iŸeZ! WgoZ\^Zb aZ``d
lVX]`ŸYo^ZgoVlddl¨dh^dcZ!cVhoXonX^Z o|W`dlVcZ
lX^ŸiZ @L>6IDHI6C/`¨dh!oW^in!aZ``d`¨j_|Xn
@L>6I/ `l^VinbV¨Z!c^ZedodgcZ!llŸo¨VX]
cV`d²Xj¨dYn\^!lo\aŸYc^ZcV`d²XVX]eŸY‹l!
h`je^dcZ l o^Zadc`VlnX] XoŸhid ol^hV_|XnX]
l^|o`VX]`l^VidlnX]!dh¨dcV`l^Vi‹lodhi"
gnX]`daX‹l
DLD8/ _ZYcdcVh^ZccVidgZW`Vol^ZXo`^Zb!
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

\¨VY`V
C6H>:C>:/ hdXoZl`dlViZ! d`g|\¨Z! WgjcVi"
cVldXoVgcZ!h^ac^Zed¨nh`j_|XZ!\¨VY`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!`j`jgnYoV!d\gdYn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ
<A:7N/ g‹ècZinen\aZWhoXoZ\‹ac^ZaèZ_hoZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!oVhdWcZlVodi!\VijcZ`
Ñl^Vi¨dajWcn
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`gdol^_Vh^ŸWVgYodhonW`d!lnildgon¨l^ZaZ[dgbdYedg"
cnX]cV]ZgW^XnYnig^VoncdlZ#<¨ŸWd`^hnhiZb`dgoZc^dln&&!*bXonc^\dc^Z"
lgVèa^lnbcVhjhoZ#LYjènbhidec^jdWc^èVeadc^jigjYc^VoW^‹ggdÑa^cjegVlcnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVWd\ViZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZh|X]Ÿic^Zo_VYVcZegoZo
eiVXild#GdÑa^cVcVYV_Zh^ŸcV`^hodc`^#
&%+ &%,

HoXoVledacn
GjbZmVXZidhZaaVA#
GJB66
GYZhidlViZ!Edan\dcVXZVZ

H]ZZeÁhhdggZa
EZi^iZdhZ^aaZ
@aZ^cZgHVjZgVbe[Zg

GdÑa^cVl^ZadaZic^V!Ylje^ZccV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ YdacZa^ÑX^Zd\dc`dlZdXoZgldcdcVW^Z\¨nX]d\dc`VX]!


\‹gcZh^ZYo|XZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/g‹lcdl|h`^Z! Y¨# ()bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!
iŸed oV`d²XodcZ! _Vhcdo^ZadcZ ajW XoZg" lnYV_|XndYgdhin
ldcdcVW^Z\¨Z!cV\^Z çD9N<6/lnhd`dс&%'*Xb!X^Zc`V!h¨VWd
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!a^XocZeŸYneZ¨oV_|XZ
Y¨j\dс (-bb! XoZgldcd cVW^Z\¨V! A>Ð8>:/ dYlgdic^Z_V_dlViZ!aVcXZidlViZajW
cV\V g‹lcdl|h`^Z!o_ZYcnbajWYldbVoŸWVb^
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ YlVajWigona^ÑX^Z @L>6IDHI6C/gdoe^ZgoX]¨Vl^ZX]V
hoZgd`d _V_dlViZ ajW d`g|\¨VlZ! h`gŸid" @L>6I/ `l^Vin bŸh`^Z d 苨inX] enac^`VX]!
aZ\¨Z `l^VinèZ²h`^ZoZh¨je`Vb^d_VhcdXoZgldcnX]
ocVb^dcVX]
DLD8/ YgdWcn dgoZhoZ`! ig‹_\gVc^Vhin! oV"
dhigodcn!_VhcdWgjcVicn!ed¨nh`j_|Xn
C6H>:C>:/ ig‹_`|icZ l egoZ`gd_j! _Vhcd`gZ"
bdlZ
g‹lcdl|h`^Z

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèVol¨VhoXoVènid!aZc!`dc^Xoncn^ajXZgcn!j\d"
gn!¨|`^^eVhil^h`V<A:7N/aZ``^Z!e^VhoXonhiZ!oV`lVhodcZ
ho`dYa^ldс ?Zhiedheda^inbX]lVhiZbcV\aZWVX]aZ``^X]!\Yo^ZllVgjc`VX]
oV`lVhoZc^Vh^ac^Z`dc`jgj_Zo\Vijc`^ZbjegVlcnbhoXoZ\‹ac^Z`dc^XoncVb^^aj"
XZgcVb^dh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ^Ñl^Vi¨d#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVoVl^ZgVYd&!*hoXoVl^VcjediVhj!Yo^V¨V_|XZ\digj_|Xd
cVol^ZgoŸiV#
&%- &%.

<dgXonXVedacV
H^cVe^hVgkZch^hA#
H>C6G
@VejhidlViZ@gonèdlZ!7gVhh^XVXZVZ8gjX^[ZgVZ
D\c^X]V!=dYgnX]
8]VgadX`
BdjiVgYZYZhX]Vbeh
6X`ZghZc[

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿlg‹ècnX]edgVX]gd`j!VcV_a^Xoc^Z_
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

lnhiŸej_|l^dhc|#
XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^Z h¨VWd edlX^cVcZ lX^ŸX^V c^Z h^Ÿ\V_| cZglj \¨‹lcZ\d!
XV¨VgdÑa^cVhodghi`d!h^ac^Zdl¨dh^dcV!edYdWcVYdGodY`l^Ñl^goZen

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ hZgXdlViZX]VgV`iZgnhinXo @DGO:°/çD9N<6/ lnh#&%+%Xb!gdo"
cZYaVgdÑa^c`gonèdlnX]!Y¨#)&%bb! \V¨Ÿo^dcV!loc^Zh^dcV!hodghi`ddl¨dh^dcV
cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^ZlngV„c^ZlX^Ÿ" A>Ð8>:/YdacZ¼a^gdlViZ!X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!\‹g"
iZ cZ¼edY¨j\dlViZ!hodghi`ddl¨dh^dcZ!oVid"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ `dldo|W`dlVcZ
Y¨# &%&*bb! cV\V! o^Zadc`VlV! c^Z" @L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
`^ZYnaZ``dÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V @L>6I/ `l^Vin o¨dX^hid苨iZ! Yo^V¨`^ `^Za^X]V
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/dlVacZajWdYlgdic^Z dYhiV_|XZ
_V_dlViZ o c^ZocVXoc^Z ed[V¨YdlVcnb DLD8/ ¨jhoXoncV g‹lcdl|h`V o igoZbV Yd
WgoZ\^Zb! aZ``d dl¨dh^dcZ! aZ``d edl" e^ŸX^j lngV„cnb^ cZglVb^! o egdhinb Y¨j"
X^cVcZ \^b Yo^‹W`^Zb! l^ZadcVh^ZccV! cVh^dcV j¨d"
èdcZgoŸYdld
C6H>:C>:/ egVl^Z `ja^hiZ! \¨VY`^Z! WgjcVi"
cdXoZgldcZ ajW X^ZbcdWgjcVicZ! aZ``d ed"
¨nh`j_|XZ
hZgXdlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ lhonhi`^Z jegVln _VgZ <A:7N/ ol^Ÿo¨Z! eg‹X]c^XocZ!


oVhdWcZllVe²
ho`dYa^ldс ?ZYcVgdÑa^cVlnYV_Z`^a`Vinh^ŸXncVh^dc!`i‹gZoVX]dlj_|ènldi"
cdсegoZo+&%aVi!XdedldYj_ZbVhdlZlnhiŸedlVc^ZiZ\d\Vijc`j#EdW^ZgVYjèZ
^adÑX^h`¨VYc^`‹led`VgbdlnX]o\aZWnVaZbc^Z_c^èGodY`^ZlÑl^goZeV#ænl^X^Za
X]dg‹W^ho`dYc^`‹lViV`j_|XnX]gdÑa^cnogdYo^cn`VejhicnX]`gonèdlnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cVigj_|XVhoXoZ\‹ac^Zld`gZh^Z`l^ic^Zc^V^dldXdlVc^Vigj"
_|XZl¨VÑX^ldÑX^oVX]dlj_ZiV`èZh^Vcd#CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|\a^`donYhncVaW^cŸ#O_V"
YVcVegoZool^ZgoŸiVcVYV_Zc^Zegon_ZbcnhbV`b^Ÿhj^egdYj`idbbaZXocnb#?ŸXo"
b^Z²oVX]lVhoXodcncVh^dcVb^<dgXonXnedacZ_edldYj_ZoVigjX^VjigodYnX]aZl"
cZ_#GdÑa^cVb^dYdYV_cV#
&&% &&&

Ed`gonlVèZ\Vl`V
Jgi^XVjgZchA#
JGIJG
Ed`gonldlViZ!Jgi^XVZVZ

HbVaacZiiaZ
Dgi^ZWg’aVciZ
@aZ^cZ7gZccZhhZa

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸegoZYZlhonhi`^bl^dhc|!VaZiV`èZl^c"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

cnX]edgVX]gd`j#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ a^ÑX^ZooVd`g|\adc|cVhVY|edh^VYV_|l¨dh`^eVgo|XZ

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ hZgXdlViZ!Y¨#'!*(bb! @DGO:°/lgoZX^dcdlVin!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn!W^V¨n
o^ZadcZ!j\‹gngdohoZgodcZ!obV¨nblX^Ÿ" çD9N<6/ lnh# &**%Xb! XoiZgd`VcX^VhiV!
X^Zb cV hoXonX^Z! l cVhVYo^Z cV\aZ dY cVhVYn gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV! loc^Zh^dcV! lgVo
olŸèdcZ l d\dcZ`! ed`gniZ YgdWcnb^! oa^сb^dl¨dh^dcV
W^V¨Vlnb^l¨dh`Vb^ A>Ð8>:/ _V_dlVidgdbWdlViZ!lcVhVYo^ZoV"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ d`g|\adcZ!oVdhigodcZ!lX^cVcddhigdo|W`dlV"
Y¨j\dс ,-bb! lVaXdlViV! _Vhcdo^Z" cZ! YdacZ o d\dc`Vb^ Y¨jèhonb^ dY WaVho`^
adcV!cV\V! a^ÑX^dlZ_
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/hoZgd`d_V_dlViZ!iŸed @L>6IDHI6C/`¨dhd`hoiV¨icZ\gdcd
oV`d²XodcZ!dhigde^¨`dlVcZ!cVegoZX^l" @L>6I/YgdWcn!gdoYo^Zacde¨X^dln!XoiZgd`gd"
aZ\¨Z!cVX^Zc`^X]d\dc`VX] icn
DLD8/ dgoZhoZ`! _V_dlVin! hdXoZl`dlVid
he¨VhoXodcn!o^ZadcdhoVgn!aZ``ded¨nh`j_|Xn
C6H>:C>:/dlVacZ
hZgXdlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!d\gdYndgVoc^Zjèni`^!gjbdl^h`V
<A:7N/ eg‹X]c^XocZ!cVldèdcZdWdgc^`^Zb!oVhdWcZlh`¨VYc^`^ed`VgbdlZ!hoXoZ"
\‹ac^ZVodi
ho`dYa^ldс LnXoZgej_Z\aZWŸoZh`¨VYc^`‹led`VgbdlnX]!\¨‹lc^ZVodij#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|d`#&+i¨jhoXoj#B¨dYZgdÑa^cnh|hedènlVcZ
hedgVYnXoc^Z_V`dlVgonlddgVoo_VYVcZegoZool^ZgoŸiV\dhedYVgh`^Z#GdÑa^cVaZXo"
c^XoV#
&&' &&(

GoZeV`do^bn\VijcZ`oVX]lVhoXoV_|Xn
7gVhh^XVcVejhA#

@VejhidlViZ@gonèdlZ!7gVhh^XVXZVZ8gjX^[ZgVZ

GVeZkdakjiZZgh
8daoV"gZedjhhZh
GVehhZaWhihVVi hVbdh^ZlngoZeV`jlWjgV`jXj`gdlnb

<VijcZ`jegVlcn![dgbV_VgV^do^bV#8oŸhidedegoZodhneVc^ZcVh^dc^higVinedY"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XoVhoW^dgjoVX]lVhoXoV_|XnjegVlnoWdèdlZ#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^Zglhona^сc^ZW^Zh`do^Zadcn!cV\^jgoZe^`j_Vhcdo^Zadcn!
dl¨dh^dcn

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ hZgXdlViZ! Y¨# &%'%bb! @DGO:°/ çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс -%&+%Xb!
cV\^Z!c^ZW^Zh`do^ZadcZ!ed¨nh`j_|XZ loc^Zh^dcV!l\‹goZgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!o^ZadcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ ¼ a^gdlViZ! X^Zbcdo^ZadcZ!
Y¨j\dс&%'%bb!cV\V!o^ZadcV d\dc`dlZ!\‹gcZ¼a^gdlVidaVcXZidlViZ!h^Z"
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/a^gdlViZ!c^ZW^Zh`do^Z" Yo|XZ
adcZ!d\dc`dlZildgo|gdoZiŸ!cV\^Z @L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
@L>6I/`l^Vin苨iZ
DLD8/¨jhoXoncV!hoVgV
C6H>:C>:/ egVl^Z `ja^hiZ! WgjcVicdXoZgld"
cZajWWgjcVicd\gVcVidlZ
hZgXdlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ\VijcZ`oVX]lVhoXoV_|Xn
<A:7N/ g‹ècZ inen \aZW hoXoZ\‹ac^Z \a^c^VhiZ! eg‹X]c^XocZ! oVhdWcZ lh`¨VYc^`^
ed`VgbdlZ
ho`dYa^ldс EdldYj_Zdh¨VW^Zc^Zgdol^_V_|XnX]h^ŸgdÑa^coWdèdlnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ IglV_|egVXZ]dYdlaVcZcVYdYb^VcVb^dcVh^dcVX]苨inX]!X]V"
gV`iZgnoj_|XnX]h^ŸdWc^èdc|oVlVgidÑX^|l¨‹`cV#
&&) &&*

GodY`^ZlÑl^goZeV
GVe]VcjhgVe]Vc^higjbA#
G6EG6
@VejhidlViZ@gonèdlZ!7gVhh^XVXZVZ8gjX^[ZgVZ
çdejX]V
L^aYgVY^h]
GVkZcZaaZ
=ZYZg^X]

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV_VgV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|^lXoZhcnbaViZb#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^Zglhona^сa^gdlVin!Yjèn!hoVgVld"X^Zbcdo^Zadcno_ZYc|
YdYl‹X]eVgYgdWcnX]aVcXZidlVinX]dYX^c`‹l

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
oVgnha^ÑX^Zc^V

h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ hZgXdlViZ! Y¨# &%&*bb! @DGO:°/bdXcn!`g‹i`^!X^Zc`^
hoZgd`^Z!cV\^Z!o^ZadcZ!cVhoXonX^Z\¨Ÿ" çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс &%+%Xb! d`g|\¨VlV!
Wd`dlX^ŸiZ gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!Yd¨Zbhodghi`ddl¨dh^dcV
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ A>Ð8>:/ YdacZ¼a^gdlViZ!h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!\‹gcZ
Y¨j\dс*&*bb!cV\V!W^V¨Vldo^ZadcV ¼ aVcXZidlViZ! hodghi`d dl¨dh^dcZ! o^ZadcZ!
ajWÉdaZidld cVW^Z\¨V WgoZ\^Zbh^ac^Zo|W`dlVcZ
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ a^gdlViZ!h^ac^ZhoXoZ" @L>6IDHI6C/\gdcd
X^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcZ!h`gŸidaZ\¨Z!WgoZ\^Zb @L>6I/`l^Vin_Vhcd苨iZajWodYX^Zc^ZbW^V"
h^ac^Zo|W`dlVcZ ¨Vlnb!XoŸhidoÉdaZidlnb èn¨`dlVc^Zb
DLD8/ egoZlŸo^hiV ¨jhoXoncV! edY¨jèc^Z
èZWZg`dlVcV!oYo^‹W`^Zb!gdo¨Vbj_|XVh^Ÿed
Yd_goZc^j
C6H>:C>:/ edY¨jècZ! _V_dlVid `ja^hiZ! h^Vi"
`dlVidYd¨`dlVcZ!XoZgldcVldWgjcVicZ
hZgXdlViZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ_VgZ!\gn`V!goZeV`d`dedlZ!b^ZhoVc`^eVh"
iZlcZ!d\gdYn<A:7N/aZ``^Z!e^VhoXonhiZ!aZ``d`lVÑcZ`l^Vin苨iZ!\aZWn\a^c^V"
hiZ!hjX]Z!jWd\^ZllVe²`l^VinW^V¨VlZ
ho`dYa^ldс GdÑa^cV lnXoZgej_Z h^ac^Z \aZWŸ oZ h`¨VYc^`‹l ed`VgbdlnX]#
BdèZ`^Z¨`dlVcVedl^ZgoX]c^\aZWn#HZ\bZcin¨jhoXoncc^ZYV_|h^ŸdYYo^Za^Yd`"
¨VYc^Z dY o^Vgc^V`‹l oW‹è ^ `Vhon \gnXoVcZ_ oZ lo\aŸYj cV edYdWc| l^Za`dс
^`hoiV¨i# ænl^X^Za X]dg‹W ^ho`dYc^`‹l ViV`j_|XnX] gdÑa^cn ogdYo^cn `VejhicnX]
`gonèdlnX]#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcV h| igj_|XZ! bd\| edldYdlV bVhdlZ oVigjX^V _V\c^|i!
WnY¨V^`dc^edo_ZYoZc^jegoZ`l^ic^ŸiZ_GodY`l^Ñl^goZen#
&&+ &&,

Ln`VXoiZgdcVh^ZccV
K^X^ViZigVheZgbVA#
K>8I:
Bdina`dlViZ!;VWVXZVZEVe^a^dcVXZVZ

AZci^akZiX]
KZhXZªfjVigZ\gV^cZh
K^ZghVb^\ZL^X`Z

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿ_Zh^Zc^|^l^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ igone^ZglhoZa^ÑX^Zo_ZYc|eVg|a^hiZXo`‹l

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ c^Zl^YdXocZedodhiV_|lcV" @DGO:°/eVadln!gdol^Yadcn
h^Zc^j!`^Z¨`j_Z]ned\Z^Xoc^Z çD9N<6/ lnh# '%+% Xb! cV\V! X^Zc`V!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ l^_|XVh^Ÿ!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV
c^Zl^YdXocV A>Ð8>:/eVgonhide^ZgoVhiZ!dYigoZX]YddÑb^j
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ eVgonhide^ZgoVhiZ! dY eVgg‹lcdl|h`^X]a^hi`‹l!cVhoXonX^ZoV`d²"
igoZX] Yd e^ŸX^j eVg g‹lcdl|h`^X] a^hi" XodcnX]l|hZbXoZecnb
`‹l! cV l^ZgoX]d¨`j olŸèdcnX] l l|h @L>6IDHI6C/ \gdcd!_ZYcd"ajWYlj`l^Vi"
XoZecn `dlZ
@L>6I/ `l^VinYgdWcZ!W^V¨VlZajWW^V¨da^"
a^dlZ!oèn¨`Vb^ÉdaZidlnb^
DLD8/hig|`!oln`aZcV\^^\¨VY`^!h¨db^Vhid"
苨inajW苨iVldWg|odln!XoiZgdcVh^Zccn
C6H>:C>:/ `ja^hiZ! dedl^ZgoX]c^ bVidlZ_!
XoVgcdWgjcVicZ!eaVb^hiZ
ln`^

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!aZc!`dc^Xoncn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZ"


gVacZ<A:7N/e^VhoXonhiZ!aZ``^Z!egoZl^ZlcZ!jWd\^ZllVe²
ho`dYa^ldс LnhiŸej_Z _V`d X]lVhi hZ\ZiVacn l jegVlVX] oW‹è! edldYj_|X
ol^Ÿ`hodcZlnaZ\Vc^Z¨Vcj^jigjYc^V_|XoW^‹gbZX]Vc^Xocn#CVh^dcVYd_goZlV_|oln"
`aZegoZYoW^dgZbgdÑa^cnjegVlcZ_#8oŸhid`^Z¨`j_ZYde^ZgdlYgj\^bajWigoZX^b
gd`jedhegon_V_|XnX]_Z_lhX]dYdboVW^Z\dbjegVldlnb#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ 9dWgVgdÑa^cVeVhiZlcVYaVg‹ècnX]\Vijc`‹lol^Zgo|i#
&&- &&.

Ln`VYgdWcd`l^VidlV
K^X^V]^ghjiVA#H#;#<gVn
K>8=>
Bdina`dlViZ!;VWVXZVZEVe^a^dcVXZVZ
Ln`Vhodghi`V
I^cnkZiX]<gVn]V^gniVgZ
KZhXZ]‚g^hh‚Z
GVj]]VVg"L^X`Z

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^ŸegoZYZlhonhi`^bldo^b^"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

cVX]#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ YlVe^ZglhoZa^ÑX^ZoYldbVeVgVb^a^hiZXo`‹l

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ c^Zl^YdXocZedodhiV_|lcV" @DGO:°/eVadln!gdo\V¨Ÿo^dcn
h^Zc^j!`^Z¨`j_Z]ned\Z^Xoc^Z çD9N<6/ lnhd`dс'%-%Xb!`VcX^VhiV!
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ aZè|XV ajW edYcdho|XV h^Ÿ! dY cVhVYn gdo\V"
c^Zl^YdXocV ¨Ÿo^dcV!XoŸhidaZ``ddl¨dh^dcV
E>:GLHO:A>Ð8>:/ eVgonhide^ZgoVhiZ! A>Ð8>:/eVgonhide^ZgoVhiZ!dYXoiZgZX]YdYo^Z"
dYl‹X]eVgVX]edY¨j\dlVinX]!g‹lcd" h^ŸX^j eVg g‹lcdl|h`^X] a^hi`‹l! cV hoXonX^Z
l|h`^X]a^hi`VX]!cVl^ZgoX]d¨`jolŸèd" oV`d²XodcZl|hZbXoZecnb
cZl`g‹i`^l|hXoZecn @L>6IDHI6C/ \gdcddYYlj"YdYo^Zh^ŸX^d"
`l^Vi`dlZ
@L>6I/`l^VinYgdWcZ!W¨Ÿ`^icZajWW^V¨VlZ
DLD8/ hig|`! WgjcVicn ajW XoVgcn! oln`aZ
dl¨dh^dcn!`g‹i`^!oln`aZYljcVh^Zccn
C6H>:C>:/egVl^Z`ja^hiZ!c^ZXdhe¨VhoXodcZ!
\¨VY`^Z!aZ``daÑc^|XZ!WgjcVicdo^ZadcZ
ln`^

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/ oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!aZc!`dc^Xoncn!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZ"


gVacZ<A:7N/e^VhoXonhiZ!aZ``^Z!egoZl^ZlcZ!jWd\^ZllVe²
ho`dYa^ldс DeaViV_|X gdÑa^cn jegVlcZ d\gVc^XoV YdhiŸe Ñl^Vi¨V! edldYj_Z
ol^Ÿ`hodcZlnaZ\Vc^Z¨Vcj^jigjYc^VoW^‹g#CVh^dcVegoZol^ZaZaVibd\|edodhiVlV
l\¨ŸWhonX]lVghilVX]\aZWn!c^ZigVX|Xh^¨n`^Z¨`dlVc^V#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVh|dYedgcZcVYo^V¨Vc^Zhd`‹ligVl^ZccnX]ol^Zgo|i#
&'% &'&

Ln`VeiVh^V
K^X^VXgVXXVA#
K>88G
Bdina`dlViZ!;VWVXZVZEVe^a^dcVXZVZ
Ln`Vl^Ÿod¨`V
7^gYkZiX]
KZhXZXgVXXV
Kd\Za"L^X`Z

GdÑa^cViglV¨V#H^Zl`^!WVglnX^Zbcdo^ZadcZ_!ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ igon e^ZglhoZ a^ÑX^Z o_ZYc| eVg| a^hiZXo`‹l! cV hoXonX^Z
oc^ZYjènbdhigoZb!\gdcd'%)%`l^Vi‹l

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
A>Ð8>:C>:/ c^Zl^YdXocZedodhiV_|lcV" @DGO:°/eVadln
h^Zc^j!`^Z¨`j_Z]ned\Z^Xoc^Z çD9N<6/lnhd`dс(%&%%Xb!èZWZg`dlV"
çD9Næ@6ED9A>Ð8>:C>DL6/ cV! l|i¨V! egonaZ\V"_|XV ogoVY`V dl¨dh^dcV!
c^Zl^YdXocV ec|XVh^Ÿ
E>:GLHO: A>Ð8>:/ e^ZglhoZ igon a^ÑX^Z A>Ð8>:/eVgonhide^ZgoVhiZ!dYhoZÑX^jYdYo^Z"
cdgbVac^Zgdol^c^ŸiZo_ZYc|eVg|a^hi`‹l h^ŸX^j eVg g‹lcdl|h`^X] a^hi`‹l! cV hoXonX^Z
g‹lcdl|h`d aVcXZidlVinX]! cV hoXonX^Z oV`d²XodcZl|hZbXoZecnb
oc^ZYjènbdhigoZb @L>6IDHI6C/ \gdcd!_ZYcdhigdccZ!'%)%
`l^Vi‹l
@L>6I/`l^VindèV\^Za`jiV`Y¨j\^b_V`ajYo"
`^eVocd`^Z!c^ZW^Zh`dÉdaZidlZ
DLD8/ hig|`edY¨j\dlVidgdbWdlVin!Wgj"
cVicn!he¨VhoXodcn
C6H>:C>:/ egVl^Z `ja^hiZ! X^ZbcdhoVgd"o^Z"
adcZajWX^ZbcdWgjcVicZ!oX^ZbcnbbVgbj"
g`dlnbgnhjc`^Zb
ln`^

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZ!d`dedlZ!hiVcdl^h`VgjYZgVacZ
<A:7N/\a^c^VhiZ!eg‹X]c^XocZ!lVe^ZccZ
ho`dYa^ldс Ln`VeiVh^VlhiVc^ZYo^`^blnhiŸej_ZcV¨|`VX]!loVgdÑaVX]^cV
b^ZYoVX]#LjegVlVX]edheda^iVcVXV¨nbc^èj^l\‹gVX]#DeaViV\Vijc`^jegVl"
cZ!edldYj_|Xol^Ÿ`hodcZlnaZ\Vc^ZgdÑa^c#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CVh^dcVoVl^ZgV_|\a^`donYXn_Vcd\Zccn!bd\|Wnid`hnXocZYaV
ol^Zgo|i!VhoXoZ\‹ac^ZYaV`dc^#
&'' &'(

8]lVhic^XV_ZYcdhigdccV
:X]^cdX]adVXgjh"\Vaa^A#7ZVck#
:8=8<
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

8dX`hejg<7!7VgcnVgY\gVhhJH6
EVc^Xe^ZYYZXdf
=“]cZg]^ghZ

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^gdol^_V_|h^ŸlYgj\^Z_ed¨dl^Zl^dhcn^cVedXo|i`j
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

aViV#
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ h^acZhe¨VhoXoZc^ZedX]lna^ÑX^dlZ__V`j`j`jgnYon

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/ hoZgd`daVcXZidlVin! @DGO:°/l^|o`dln
ol^c^Ÿin! WZo jhoZ` ^ _ŸonXo`V! X^Zbcd" A>Ð8>:/ X^ZbcdhoVgd"o^ZadcZ!g‹lcdl|h`^Z!
ajWhoVgdo^Zadcn!Y¨j\^&*'%bb aVcXZidlViZ! Ydhn hoZgd`^Z! ina`d j edYhiV"
ln WaVho`^ a^ÑX^dlZ_ o YgdWcnb dl¨dh^Zc^Zb
WgoZ\‹l!WZojhoZ`^_ŸonXo`V
ƒ9ƒ7çD/ lnhd`dс(%&%%Xb!loc^Zh^dcZ
ajW`daVc`dlVidedYcdho|XZh^Ÿ!lŸo¨no`d"
hbn`^Zbl¨dh`‹l
@L>6IDHI6C/l^ZX]V!`¨dh`^_ZYcd`l^VidlZ!
Y¨j\dс '(bb! \Ÿhid hi¨dXodcZ cV \¨‹l"
cZ_dh^loVb^Zcc^ZajWegoZX^laZ\¨Zhid_|XnX]
edodgcnX] `¨dh`VX]! dh¨Vc^V_|XV eaZl`V ed"
c^èZ_l^ZgoX]d¨`V`l^Vi`VegoZlVèc^ZoY¨j\|
dÑX^|
DLD8/ o^Vgc^V`!dlVacn!lnej`¨ndYhigdcn
\goW^ZidlZ_!VdYWgojhocZ_egVl^Ze¨Vh`^!_Vh"
cdWgjcVicn

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!`j`jgnYoV!d\gdYn<A:7N/e^VhoXonhid"\a^"
c^VhiZajWe^VhoXonhiZ!ènocZ!l^a\dicZ
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

ho`dYa^ldс Gdol‹_X]lVhic^XnoVaZèndYY¨j\dÑX^Yc^V/lXoZÑc^ZlhX]dYo|XZ
gdhc|Y¨j\d^Wj_c^Z!h^ac^Zdh¨VW^V_|X\VijcZ`jegVlcn!cVidb^Vhih^Zl`^loZho¨Ze‹„"
cnb aViZb gdol^_V_| h^Ÿ WVgYod honW`d! VaZ c^Z hiVcdl^| iV` h^acZ_ `dc`jgZcX_^#
LXoVh^Z `^Z¨`dlVc^V ^ Yd_goZlVc^V lnbV\V lnhd`^Z_ iZbeZgVijgn# ?ZYcV gdÑa^cV
bdèZlnYVdY)%%Yd*%%%o^Vgc^V`‹l#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ GdÑa^cV^o^Vgc^V`^bd\|WnjèniZ_V`dWVgYodlVgidÑX^dlVeVhoV
YaVWnY¨V^YgdW^j#
&') &'*

B^di¨VoWdèdlV
6eZgVhe^XV"kZci^A#
6E:HK
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

AddhZh^a`n"WZci
?djZiYjkZci
<ZbZ^cZgL^cY]Vab

GdÑa^cV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgVajWdo^bV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|^_Zh^Zc^|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ h^acZgdol^c^Ÿin!Y¨j\^!edhigoŸe^dcn_ŸonXoZ`edX]lna^Ñ"
X^dlZ_

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/ l|h`^!YZa^`Vicn!egVl^Z @DGO:°/l^|o`dln
c^i`dlVin!Y¨j\^&*(%bb!cVhoXonX^Z A>Ð8>:/e¨Vh`^Z!hodghi`^Z!hoZgd`^Z'*bb!
oVdhigodcn!Yd¨ZbedYl^c^Ÿin!cV\^ h`gŸXdcZ ÑgjWdld! cV\^Z! edX]ln a^ÑX^dlZ
\¨VY`^ZajWc^ZXdhodghi`^Z!WZojhoZ`!oY¨j"
\^bedhigoŸe^dcnb_ŸonXo`^Zb
ƒ9ƒ7çD/ lnhd`dс (%&'%Xb! lnegdhid"
lVcZajWo\^ŸiZl`daVc`VX]!locdho|XZh^Ÿ
@L>6IDHI6C/l^ZX]V!h^ac^Zgdo\V¨Ÿo^dcV!_ZY"
cd`l^VidlZ`¨dh`^!dh¨Vc^V_|XVeaZl`Vhodghi
`V! o dÑX^| edc^èZ_ l^ZgoX]d¨`V dÑX^ egdhiZ!
igon"ajWXoiZgd`gdic^ZY¨jèhoZc^èeaZl`V
DLD8/ o^Vgc^V`!deaZl^dcn!odÑX^|^XoŸÑX^|
dh^ `¨dh`V igodcZ` ed higdc^Z WgojhocZ_!
ol^Z²XZb hgZWgonhidW^V¨nX]! hoXoZX^c`dlV"
inX]l¨dh`‹ljedYhiVln

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèdlZhoXoZ\‹ac^Zdo^bZ!`dc^Xoncn!d`dedlZ
<A:7N/ e^VhoXonhiZajWe^VhoXonhid"\a^c^VhiZ!l^a\dicZ!aZ``d`lVÑcZ
ho`dYa^ldс B^di¨VoWdèdlV_ZhijedgXonlnbX]lVhiZblnhiŸej_|XnbegoZ"
lVèc^ZloWdèVX]do^bnX]!goVYo^Z_`dc^XoncVX]#LoWdèVX]Yd_goZlVc^ZXdlXoZÑ"
c^Z_^dhnej_Zo^Vgc^V`^lXoVh^Zèc^l!ogZhoi|bc^Z_Yd_goV¨nX]o^Vgc^V`‹lYdhiV_Zh^Ÿ
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

edYXoVhoW^dgjYdoW^dgc^`V`dbWV_cj!\Yo^ZoVc^ZXonhoXoVo^Vgcd#O^Vgc^V`^b^di¨n
`^Z¨`j_| cV edl^ZgoX]c^ \aZWn ajW cV c^Zl^Za`^Z_ \¨ŸWd`dÑX^ edY edl^ZgoX]c^|#
L\¨ŸWhonX]lVghilVX]bd\|edodhiVlVegoZo`^a`VaVi!oVX]dlj_|Xlnhd`|oYda"
cdс `^Z¨`dlVc^V# ?ZYcV gdÑa^cV bdèZ lnYV Yd `^a`j inh^ŸXn o^Vgc^V`‹l! bVhdld
ed_Vl^Vh^ŸlaViVegoZ`gdecZ#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ LnhiŸej_ZegVl^ZlXV¨Z_EdahXZ!WgV`_Z_ina`dle^ŸigVX]\‹gh`^X]
@VgeVi#
&'+ &',

Dl^Zh\¨jX]n
6kZcV[VijVA#
6K:;6
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

L^aY"dVi
;daaZVkd^cZ
;aj\]V[Zg

IgVlV_ZYcdgdXocV!_VgV#H^Zl`^DlhV\¨jX]Z\ded_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ g‹lcdl|h`^! hoZgd`^! lYdacZ_ ^WgoZècZ_ XoŸÑX^ ed`gnin


goVY`^b^YdсY¨j\^b^dYhiV_|Xnb^l¨dh`Vb^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/ g‹lcdl|h`^!hoZgd`^! @DGO:°/l^|o`dln!b^diZ¨`dlVin
lYdacZ_^WgoZècZ_XoŸÑX^ed`gningoVY`^" A>Ð8>:/ g‹lcdl|h`^Z! Ydhn hoZgd`^Z! edX]"
b^ Ydс Y¨j\^b^ dYhiV_|Xnb^ l¨dh`Vb^! lnYdacnX]a^ÑX^dl¨dh^dcZ!_ŸonXoZ`a^ÑX^dln
Y¨j\dс,%.%bb! Y¨j\^
ƒ9ƒ7çD/lnh#+%&'%Xb!loc^Zh^dcZ
@L>6IDHI6C/ l^ZX]V gdoe^ZgoX]¨V! `¨dh`^
Ylj"ajWigon`l^VidlZ!Y¨j\dс'(bb!dÑ
`¨dh`VjYd¨jed`gniVWgjcVicnb^l¨dh`Vb^
DLD8/ o^Vgc^V`! eaZl`^ ogdÑc^ŸiZ o o^Vgc^V"
`^Zb!hoXoZX^c^Vhiddl¨dh^dcn!WgjcVicZ

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/oWdèV_VgZ!d`dedlZgoVYo^Z_<A:7N/bVg\a^hid"\a^c^V"
hiZajW\a^c^VhiZ!edYbd`¨Z
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

ho`dYa^ldс GdobcVèVh^ŸoVedbdX|o^Vgc^V`‹l!`i‹gnX]XoŸÑdhnej_Zh^ŸcV
edaj^oVX]lVhoXoV\aZWŸ#Hidhjc`dldaZ``^Z^Y¨j\ddl¨dh^dcZo^Vgc^V`^gdoh^ZlVcZ
h|egoZol^Vig#O^Vgc^V`^dlhVbd\|aZèZl\aZW^Z!egoZo`^a`VaVic^ZigVX|XoYdacdÑX^
`^Z¨`dlVc^V#OdlhZbh^Zlcnbildgonb^ZhoV²XZ!`i‹gZed_Vl^V_|h^ŸlcVhiŸecnX]
oVh^ZlVX]dlhVh^ZlcZ\d#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ CV edaVX] bdècV _ZhoXoZ hedi`V hed`gZlc^dcZ \Vijc`^ dlhV
hodghi`^Z\d^dlhV`g‹i`^Z\d#
&'- &'.

EZgol¨VÑX^ln
6\gdengdcgZeZchA#7ZVjk#
6<GG:
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

FjVX`\gVhh
8]^ZcYZcigVbeVci
<ZbZ^cZFjZX`Z

IgVlVl^ZadaZic^V!gdo¨d\dlV#H^Zl`^ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿl^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]n hoXoZ\‹acZ e^Zglhon a^с g‹lcdl|h`^! X^Zbcdo^Zadcn! o dWj higdc ^ cV


WgoZ\jed`gnin`g‹i`^b^YgdWcnb^l¨dh`Vb^!edX]lVa^ÑX^dlVoln`aZXoZgldcVldh^cd
cVW^Z\¨V!a^ÑX^Zhodghi`VlZ!gdÑa^cVoWVgYodY¨j\^b^edYo^Zbcnb^eZ¨o|_VXnb^gdo¨d\Vb^

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/ g‹lcdl|h`^!X^Zbcdo^Z" @DGO:°/`¨|XoZoY¨j\^b^gdo¨d\Vb^
adcn!Y¨j\dс-%&%%bb!odWjhigdc A>Ð8>:/ e¨Vh`^Z!ènldo^ZadcZajWh^cdo^ZadcZ!
^cVWgoZ\jed`gnin`g‹i`^b^YgdWcnb^ jcVhVYnWaVho`^a^ÑX^dlZ_jho`VdhigZ
l¨dh`Vb^!edX]lVa^ÑX^dlVoln`aZXoZg" ƒ9ƒ7çD/lnhd`dс(%&*%Xb!loc^Zh^dcZ!
ldcVldh^cdcVW^Z\¨V cV\^Z!\¨VY`^Z
@L>6IDHI6C/ `¨dh `g‹i`^! `¨dh`^ _V_dlViZ!
dYhiV_|XZ dY e^ŸX^d" Yd Yo^Zh^ŸX^d`l^VidlZ!
Y¨# &%&*bb! YdacV eaZl`V oV`d²XodcV
oln`aZdÑX^|
DLD8/o^Vgc^V`!deaZl^dcn

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/_V`dgdÑa^cViglV¨VoVh^ZYaVlhonhi`^ZjegVln!`daZ_cd
oV_bj_|XZoVeZgodcZedaZ <A:7N/ lhonhi`^ZgdYoV_Z\aZW!hoXoZ\‹ac^ZX^Ÿè`^Z!ènocZ
^l^a\dicZ
ho`dYa^ldс GdÑa^cVdYjènX]lnbV\Vc^VX]Ñl^ZiacnX]!h^ac^ZgdoegoZhigoZc^V
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

h^Ÿegono¨nbhiVc^ZoVh^Zl‹l#EZgoedW^ZgVlX^|\jgd`jo&]V\aZWnd`#*%`\Vod"
ij!(%`\[dh[dgj!,%`\ediVhj#Gdo¨d\^dYocVXoV_|h^Ÿl^Za`|ènldicdÑX^|#EdX^ŸiZ
cVlZicVYgdWcZ`VlV¨`^lnYV_|cdlZgdÑa^cn^h^ac^ZgdogVhiV_|h^Ÿ#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ @¨|XoZeZgojoVl^ZgVlŸ\adldYVcn!ig^inXncŸ^^chja^cŸ!Ñajo!\a^"
`donY! daZ_Z` ZiZgnXocn! V\gdengZc! egdl^iVb^cŸ l^iVb^cn 6^7! `lVh `goZbdln
^ediVh#EdaZèZc^jl`dbedÑX^ZhiV_Zh^ŸlVgidÑX^dlnbcVldoZb#BVoVhidhdlVc^Z
laZXoc^Xil^Z!bdèZh¨jènYdlngdWjYdbdlZ\de^lV#
&(% &(&

L¨dÑc^XVh^cV
HZiVg^V\aVjXVA#7ZVjk#
H:IEJ
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

NZaadlWg^hiaZ"\gVhh
H‚iV^gZ\aVjfjZ
C^ZYg^\Z7dghiZc]^ghZ

IgVlV_ZYcdgdXocV_VgV#H^Zl`^L¨dÑc^Xnh^cZ_ed_Vl^V_|h^Ÿe‹„c|l^dhc|!\Ynèo^Vg"
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

c^V`^iZ\dX]lVhijlnbV\V_|Yd`^Z¨`dlVc^V\aZWncV\goVcZ_Yd&*'%•8#LnhiŸ"
ej_Zg‹lc^ZèloVh^ZlVX]le‹„c^Z_honX]edgVX]aViVegonYdhiViZXocZ_l^a\dicdÑX^
\aZWn#

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHON A>Ѐ/ g‹lcdl|h`^! cV hoXon" @DGO:°/b^diZ¨`dlVin
X^Z dhign! Y¨j\^ &*'% bb! o a^Xocnb^ A>Ð8>:/ hoVgdo^ZadcZ! g‹lcdl|h`^Z! Ydhn
g‹lcdaZ\¨nb^cZglVb^!WgV`_ŸonXo`V hoZgd`^Z! ina`d jedYhiVln WaVho`^ a^ÑX^dlZ_
o YgdWcnb dl¨dh^Zc^Zb WgoZ\‹l! WZo jhoZ`
^_ŸonXo`V
XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ `¨dhd`hoiV¨icV ƒ9ƒ7çD/ lnh# *)%Xb! loc^Zh^dcZ ajW
l^ZX]Vo苨idWgjcVicnb^ajWXoZgldcV" edYcdho|XZh^Ÿ!edX]lna^ÑX^dlZaZ``dhe¨Vho"
lnb^hoXoZX^c`Vb^ XodcZ
@L>6IDHI6C/ `¨dhd`hoiV¨icVl^ZX]V!`¨dh`^
_V_dlViZ! _ZYcd`l^VidlZ! Y¨j\^Z '(bb!
XoŸhidoXoZgldcVlnb^hoXoZX^c`Vb^
DLD8/ o^Vgc^V`!_V_dlVin!aZ``doVehigodcn!
X^ZbcdhoVgn!XoVgcd^YgdWcdejc`idlVcn
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!oWdèV_VgZ^do^bZ!ajXZgcV!ÑX^Zgc^h`V!j\d"
gn<A:7N/e^VhoXonhiZ!e^VhoXonhid"\a^c^VhiZ!WZolVe^ZccZ
ho`dYa^ldс <VijcZ`bVhdldlnhiŸej_ZcVÑX^Zgc^h`VX]ènic^X]!\Yo^Zgdol^_V
h^ŸhoXoZ\‹ac^Z^ciZchnlc^Z#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ O^Vgc^V`^bd\|Wnln`dgonhinlVcZ_V`ded`VgbYaVeiVXilVYd"
bdlZ\d#
&(' &((

L¨dÑc^XVo^ZadcV
HZiVg^Vk^g^Y^hA#E#7#
H:IK>
L^ZX]a^cdlViZIgVln!EdVXZVZ<gVb^bZVZ

<gZZcWg^hiaZ"\gVhh
H‚iV^gZkZgiZ
<g“cZ7dghiZc]^ghZ

IgVlV_ZYcdgdXocV_VgV#H^Zl`^gdol^_V_|h^Ÿe‹„c|l^dhc|#
cVolVedah`V
cVolV¨VX^²h`V
b^ŸYoncVgdYdln`dYX]lVhij
gdYo^cVWdiVc^XocV
cVolVolnXoV_dlV
cVolV`daZ_cd/
Vc\^Zah`V![gVcXjh`V!c^Zb^ZX`V

XZX]nhoXoZ\‹acZ e^Zglhona^сedY¨j\dlVin!oXoZgldc|edX]l|edoWVl^d"
c|_ŸonXo`V

oVgnhe^ZglhoZ\da^ÑX^V
h^Zl`V gdÑa^cVYdgdh¨V
E>:GLHONA>Ѐ/ edY¨j\dlVin!oXoZgld" @DGO:°/b^diZ¨`dlVin
cV edX]l| edoWVl^dc| _ŸonXo`V! Y¨j\^ A>Ð8>:/ g‹lcdl|h`daVcXZidlViZ! igVl^Vhid"
&%&'bb!l^ZadcZgldln o^ZadcZoc^ZW^Zh`VlnbcVadiZb!_ŸonXoZ`oV"
hi|e^dcneŸXo`^Zbl¨dh`‹l
ƒ9ƒ7çD/lnh#*+%Xb!X^Zc`^Z!edYcdho|"
XZh^Ÿ!edY`l^VidhiVcZbhodghi`^Z!jcVhVYn
\V¨Ÿo^hiZ
@L>6IDHI6C/l^ZX]V`¨dhd`hoiV¨icV!lVaXd"
lViV! `¨dh`^ Y¨j\dÑX^ 'bb! `¨dhZ` _ZYcd"
`l^Vi`dln
DLD8/o^Vgc^V`!_V_dlVin!WZoWVglcn
_ZYcda^ÑX^ZccZigVln

lnhiŸedlVc^Z JEG6LN/d`dedlZ!d\gdYn!oWdèVdo^bZ!XoVhZb_VgZ!ÑX^Zgc^h`V
<A:7N/ aZ``^Z!e^VhoXonhid"\a^c^VhiZajWe^VhoXonhiZ
ho`dYa^ldс GdobcVèV h^Ÿ egoZo o^Vgc^V`^ oVX]lVhoXoV_|XZ \aZWŸ cV b^Z_hXj
ajW gdoh^ZlVcZ ooVc^ZXonhoXodcnb o^VgcZb h^Zlcnb ajW odWdgc^`^Zb# O^Vgc^V`^
l\aZW^Zc^ZigVX|h^¨n`^Z¨`dlVc^VegoZo&%&*aVi#
X^Z`Vldhi`^ ?ZYcVgdÑa^cVlnYV_ZYd`^a`jinh^ŸXno^Vgc^V`‹l#
E^Ñb^Zcc^Xild

8=DGDB6²H@>@#>LHE#&.--#EgoZldYc^`¨|`Vgh`^#ELG^A!LVghoVlV!hh#*,*#
=Vc[ B# &..%# 6X`Zgjc`g~jiZg :jgdeV b^i ^^]gZc @Z^ba^c\Zc jcY HVbZc# B“cX]Zc!
hh#).+#
@GŸè:AG#!E6GNA6@9#!O>BCNA#&...#OV\VYc^Zc^VjegVlngda^^gdÑa^c#LnYVlc^Xild
6GlZLgdX¨Vl^j!LgdX¨Vl!h#&)."'%&#
B>G:@O#>LHE#&..*#KVhXjaVgeaVcihd[EdaVcYVX]ZX`a^hi#Eda^h]7diVc^XVaHijY^Zh!<j"
^YZWdd`hZg#&*!@gV`‹l!hh#(%-#
BDLHODL>8O?#&.-+#@gV_dlZX]lVhinedacZ^d\gdYdlZ#ELG^A!LVghoVlV!hh#+,'#
C>:L>69DBH@>L#>LHE#&..'#H¨dlc^`6\gd"7^d"IZX]c^Xocn#AjWa^c!hh#,,.#
H@GONE8O6@<#!7A:8=6G8ON@6#&..,#EdYgŸXocnViaVhX]lVhi‹l#BZY^mEajh#EdocV²!
hh#'&)#
HO6;:GL¨#@JA8ON²H@>HI#!E6L¨DLH@>7#&.-+#GdÑa^cnEdah`^Z#ELC!LVghoVlV!
I#&^'!hh#&%&.#
INBG6@>:L>8OL¨#&.,+#6iaVhX]lVhi‹l#ELG^A!LVghoVlV!hh#)(.#

CVonlVbh^ŸIdgZgd#IdgZgd*%%H8#?ZhiZbegVlYo^lnb
V\ZciZbYdoVYV²heZX_VacnX]#H`jiZXoc^ZZa^b^cj_Ÿ
lhonhi`^ZX]lVhinlWjgV`VX]#9o^V¨Vbh^ac^ZcVa^hic^Z
^Yd\aZWdld#6XdcV_lVèc^Z_hoZ!WjgV`^bd\|h^ŸXoj
egonbc^ZXV¨`dl^X^ZWZoe^ZXoc^Z#

IdgZgd*%%H8#
OVW‹_XonYaVX]lVhi‹l!
WZoe^ZXocnYaVWjgV`‹l#
edaZXVcncV hidhdlVc^Z YVl`dlVc^Z
`dbdhŸW^V¨|!X]VWgV edh^Zl^ZWjgV`‹l¼ cV_XoŸÑX^Z_'a$]V
W¨VlVi`V!hVbdh^Zln ¼cVlhX]dYo|XZX]lVhin
goZeV`j!hoVg¨Vihodghi`^!
gjb^VcdlViZ!egonija^Ÿ
XoZec|!gYZhin^^ccZ

lll#hjb^"V\gd#Xdb#ea!iZa#''+(,('(,
DjegVl^ZWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\d BZidYnolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹l
cVeaVciVX_^WjgV`V

JegVlVWjgV`VoVa^XoVcV_ZhidYaViYdinX]!`i‹gZegoncdho|\dhedYVghildbgda" ?ZYc| ocV_lVèc^Z_honX] XonccdÑX^ e^ZaŸ\cVXn_cnX] ljegVl^Z WjgV`V Xj`gdlZ\d


cnb ocVXocZ ^hiVW^acZ YdX]dYn# ?ZYcdXoZÑc^Z _Zhi id jegVlV lnbV\V_|XV YjènX] _ZhiolVaXoVc^ZX]lVhi‹l#>X]lnZa^b^cdlVc^ZbVoVeZlc^hidhjc`dldc^Za^Xocnb
cV`¨VY‹l ÉcVchdlnX]! YdWgZ\d oVeaZXoV iZX]c^XocZ\d ^c^ZbV¨nX] jb^Z_ŸicdÑX^ cVedajgdÑa^cdbWjgV`V`^a`VYo^Zh^|iinh^ŸXnWjgV`‹lldWZXb^a^dc‹lX]lVhi‹l
gdac^`V# LnbV\Vc^V! _V`^Z cVgojXV jegVlV WjgV`‹l! egonXonc^V_| h^Ÿ Yd `dgonhi" dYedl^ZYc^|egoZhigoZ²Ydlogdhij^gdold_j#HidhdlVc^Zlnhd`^Z__V`dÑX^]ZgW^Xn"
cnX]ob^Vcl\dhedYVghil^Z!`i‹gZedldYj_|logdhi^ciZchnlcdÑX^egdYj`X_^gdacZ_ Y‹llYVl`VX]Yo^ZadcnX]jbdèa^l^Voc^hoXoZc^Zlhonhi`^X]X]lVhi‹lWZognon`V
ld\‹aZ# jho`dYoZc^Vb¨dYnX]gdÑa^cWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\d#9dhidhdlVc^VbZidY|YVlZ`Yo^Z"
Ob^Vcn! _V`^Z oVho¨n ledah`^b Xj`gdlc^Xil^Z ldhiVic^X] aViVX] hegVl^¨n! èZ adcnX]edaZXVbnhoZgZ\]ZgW^XnY‹lh`jiZXocnX]llVaXZoX]lVhiVb^^WZoe^ZXocnX]
gdac^Xnc^ZegdYj`j_|_jèÎ`dgoZc^¿!aZXoWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\d¼hjgdl^ZXYaVXj`gdlc^! YaV X]gdc^dcZ\d WjgV`V# H| id/ @DCI6@IIL>C! IDGC69D ^ IDG:GD# CV
heZ¨c^V_|Xnlnhd`^ZlnbV\Vc^V_V`dÑX^dlZ# cV_Wa^èhoZaViVhoXoZ\‹ac^ZedaZXVbnhidhdlVc^Z_ZYcZ\doYl‹X]egd\gVb‹ldX]gd"
EaVciVidgon oZ lo\aŸYj cV gn\dgn jb‹l oXj`gdlc^Vb^ X]X| dh^|\V eadcn cn/ e^ZglhoZ\d deVgiZ\d cV ]ZgW^XnYVX] @DCI6@IIL>C ^IDGC69D dgVo
lnhd`^Z^hiVW^acZ!c^ZoVaZèc^ZdY lVgjc`‹led\dYdlnX]#LnbV\V idgVX_dcVacZ_ Ygj\^Z\dWVoj_|XZ\dcVegZeVgVX^ZIDG:GD#LdWjegoneVY`VX]YdolVaXoVc^Vh^a"
jegVln\aZWn!cdldXoZhcnX]dYb^Vc!Ydh`dcV¨Z\dh^Zlj!deinbVacZ\dcVldèZc^V cZ\doVX]lVhoXoZc^VX]lVhiVb^_ZYcda^ÑX^Zccnb^eZgo!X]lVhic^XVjojeZ¨c^Zc^Zb
CE@! jojeZ¨c^V_|XZ\d Yda^hicZ\d cVldèZc^V b^`gdZaZbZciVb^ ol¨VhoXoV WdgZb! egd\gVbjedl^c^ZcWn_ZYZcoYdhiŸecnX]\gVb^c^XnY‹l#
h`jiZXocnX]^WZoe^ZXocnX]YaVWjgV`VbZidYolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹l#LnhiŸej_|XZ_jè E^Zglhon oVW^Z\ X]lVhidW‹_Xon bdèZ Wn ln`dcVcn oVg‹lcd `g‹i`d ed h^Zl^Z
c^ZbVaedlhoZX]c^ZX]dgdWna^ÑX^WjgV`VX]ldÑX^`WjgV`V!WgjcVicVeaVb^hidсa^ÑX^ WjgV`VegoZYlhX]dYVb^X]lVhi‹l!_V`^e‹„c^Z_!cVlhX]dYo|XZX]lVhin#
^^ccZobjhoV_|gdac^`‹lYdedocVc^V^hidinedldYj_|XnX]_ZeVid\Zc‹l^hidhdlV" LnW^ZgV_|X lVg^Vci e^Zglhon! hidhj_Zbn ÑgdY`^ X]lVhidW‹_XoZ dWVgYod YdWgnb
c^VdYedl^ZYc^X]ÑgdY`‹l\gonWdW‹_XonX]# Yo^V¨Vc^j egoZo \aZWŸ! _ZYcdXoZÑc^Z \lVgVcij_|XZ hoZgd`^Z heZ`igjb olVaXoVcnX]
Gdojb^Z_|XlogVhiV_|XZoVedigoZWdlVc^ZeaVciVidg‹lWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\dcVXdgVo X]lVhi‹l^WZoe^ZXocZlhX]dYnWjgV`‹lce#IDG:GD(a$]VajWIDGC69D'a$]V#
Ydh`dcVahoZbZidYne^ZaŸ\cVX_^^dX]gdcngdÑa^c!Hjb^"6\gdEdaVcYhiVaZgdohoZgoV Ln`dcVc^Z degnh`j ed h^Zl^Z WjgV`‹l cV ÎXoVgc|¿ \aZWŸ _Zhi `dgonhicZ llV"
hld_|d[ZgiŸcdldXoZhcnX]ÑgdY`‹ldX]gdcn^cVldo‹lYda^hicnX]# gjc`VX]YdWgZ\d_Z_jl^a\dic^Zc^V#EdaZXVcZbdèZWnol¨VhoXoVl\dhedYVghilVX]!
l`i‹gnX] lo\aŸYn iZX]c^XocZ ajW dg\Vc^oVXn_cZ bd\¨nWn hedldYdlV igjYcdÑX^
oiZgb^cdlnb ln`dcVc^Zb e^ZglhoZ\d degnh`j cV lhX]dYo|XZ X]lVhin# @daZ_cZ
oVW^Z\^ln`dcj_ZbnedlhX]dYVX]X]lVhi‹l#
LVg^VciYgj\^oV`¨VYVolVaXoVc^ZX]lVhi‹l_ZYnc^ZedlhX]dYdldedegoZoln`d"
cVc^ZYl‹X]ajWigoZX]degnh`‹lcVlhX]dYo|XZX]lVhin#
CV_lVèc^Z_honblVgjc`^ZbedldYoZc^VledlhX]dYdlnbolVaXoVc^jX]lVhi‹l
YVl`Vb^ Yo^Zadcnb^ _Zhi degnh`^lVc^Z ^X]
l[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^#
@daZ_cZ degnh`^ ln`dcj_Zbn oVlhoZ
l[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^X]lVhi‹l#?ZÑa^_ZYcV`lVg"
jc`^ed\dYdlZajW^ccZlo\aŸYnjc^Zbdèa^"
l^|egoZegdlVYoZc^Zdegnh`jldeinbVacnb
iZgb^c^Z!ln`dcV_bndegnh`liZYn!\Ynina`d
WŸYo^Z id bdèa^lZ! ol^Ÿ`hoV_|X YVl`Ÿ hidhd"
lVcnX]]ZgW^XnY‹ldYedl^ZYc^dYdl^Za`dÑX^
X]lVhi‹l IDG:GD ^ @DCI6@IIL>C
bVm#Yd(a$]V#
Ln`dcj_|X Îhe‹„c^dcn¿ degnh`! oVlhoZ
ol^Ÿ`hoV_bnYVl`ŸÑgdY`V!edc^ZlVèZlZc"
ijVacZ c^ZedldYoZc^Z cV inb ZiVe^Z bdèZ DeinbVacniZgb^cdegnh`j
&(- &(.
Wnc^ZYddYgdW^Zc^Vegon`daZ_cnX]oVW^Z" ™ 9gj\^degnh`bVoVoVYVc^Zoc^hoXonlhonhi`^ZX]lVhincVeaVciVX_^!oVg‹lcd
\VX]# Ina`d oc^hoXoZc^Z lhonhi`^X] X]lV" iZ!`i‹gZYde^ZgdloZho¨nl[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^_V`^iZ!`i‹gZbd\¨nedodhiVededegoZY"
hi‹ldocVXoVhj`XZhoVhidhdlVcnX]Yo^V¨V²# c^boVW^Z\j#Hidhj_ZbnhiVcYVgYdlZYVl`^ÑgdY`‹lX]lVhidW‹_XonX]#OlVaXoV_|X
OlVaXoVc^ZX]lVhi‹ledlhX]dYdldYV_Z hoZgd`^Z heZ`igjb X]lVhi‹l! IDG:GD dgVo @DCI6@IIL>C  IDGC69D
bdèa^ldсdXZcnhiVcjoVX]lVhoXoZc^VeaVc" \lVgVcij_|Yjè|h`jiZXocdсiZ\ddegnh`j!cVlZi\YncVeaVciVX_^lnhiŸej_|X]lV"
iVX_^ `dc^ZXocV _Zhi jb^Z_Ÿicdс ^X] gdo" hinhoXoZ\‹ac^ZjX^|èa^lZ#
edocVlVc^V l hiVY^jb h^Zl`^ ^ edolVaV HidhdlVc^Z ]ZgW^XnY‹l bdècV d\gVc^Xon Yd Yl‹X] degnh`‹l! _ZÑa^ oV`¨VYV h^Ÿ
jhiVa^! `i‹gZ ]ZgW^XnYn ^ _V`^Z ^X] YVl`^ e‹„c^Z_hoZ!gŸXocZjhjlVc^Zed_ZYncXonX]X]lVhi‹l#
WŸY|cV_dYedl^ZYc^Z_hoZlYVcZ_hnijVX_^# ™ IgoZX^ degnh` edl^c^Zc Yd`d²Xon Yo^Z¨V olVaXoVc^V X]lVhi‹l# ?ZYcdXoZÑc^Z
OcV_|X oV`gZh Yo^V¨Vc^V edhoXoZ\‹acnX] lVècnb XZaZb iZ\d degnh`j _Zhi edodhiVl^Zc^Z l\aZW^Z iV`^Z_ ^adÑX^ hjWhiVcX_^
]ZgW^XnY‹l! bdèZbn lnWgV hidhdlVc^Z c^hoXo|XnX] X]lVhin! Wn c^Z YdejÑX^ Yd lnhi|e^Zc^V iol# oVX]lVhoXoZc^V li‹gcZ\d#
IDG:GD ajW b^ZhoVc^cn @DCI6@IIL>C Hidhj_ZbnhiVcYVgYdlZYVl`^IDG:GDXoniZè@DCI6@IIL>CJ IDGC69D#
 IDGC69D! iV` Wn cV eZlcd o\^cŸ¨n OVlVgiZ loVhidhdlVcnX] ]ZgW^XnYVX] hjWhiVcX_Z V`inlcZ edodhiV_| l\aZW^Z l^adÑX^
ÎHe‹„c^dcn¿degnh`¼`dc^ZXocV lhonhi`^Z X]lVhin# ?ZYcdXoZÑc^Z cVaZèn \lVgVcij_|XZ_jigonbVc^ZldacZ\ddYX]lVhi‹ledaVVèYdoW^dg‹l#
lnèhoVYVl`V]ZgW^XnYj eVb^ŸiV!èZl¨VÑX^lVdXZcVeaVciVX_^^Yd" 9dWgoZln`dcVcZdegnh`^]ZgW^XnYZbIDG:GDajWb^ZhoVc^c|@DCI6@IIL>C
W‹g cV_aZehonX] YVlZ` ]ZgW^XnY‹l bjho| IDGC69DidedaZldacZdYX]lVhi‹lc^Zina`dlbV_j^XoZglXj!VaZiV`èZlh^Zge"
WnYd`dcnlVcZ`VèYdgVodldegoZY`daZ_cnb^degnh`Vb^# c^j^lgoZÑc^jVèYdoW^dg‹l#
=ZgW^XnYn bjho| Yo^V¨V _ZYcdXoZÑc^Z cVa^hic^Z ^Yd\aZWdld# Ina`d liZc ?V`dсjegVlnegoZYh^ZlcZ_bVle¨nlcVZ[Z`inlcdсlVa`^oX]lVhiVb^#
hedh‹Weddegnh`jWŸY|\^c|iZX]lVhin!`i‹gZWn¨n_jècVYedl^ZgoX]c^|\aZWn!_V` CVedl^ZgoX]c^„aZegon\didlVcZ_\aZWnocV_Yj_|h^Ÿa^XocZ\gjYn#EdYc^b^X]lVhin
^iZ!`i‹gZWŸY|eg‹WdlV¨nlhX]dYo^egoZo`daZ_cZYc^# bd\|ÎXojh^Ÿ_V`edYeVgVhdaZb¿#CVlZiedYdWgoZln`dcVcnbdegnh`jhjWhiVc"
9o^Ÿ`^ Yo^V¨Vc^j Yd\aZWdlZbj lnY¨jèV h^Ÿ dYhiŸe edb^ŸYon degnh`Vb^! Ved X_VV`inlcV]ZgW^XnYjc^ZbVhoVchYdigoZYda^ÑX^ajW`dgoZc^j`gniZ\dX]lVhij#
igoZX]YdWgoZln`dcVcnX]oVW^Z\VX]c^Zed_Vl^Vh^ŸcVedajoVX]lVhoXoZc^Zli‹gcZ# Gdol^_Vh^ŸdcWZoe^ZXoc^Z!dh^|\V_|XedY\gjY`|"eVgVhdaZbl^Za`dс!`i‹gVjigjYc^V
E‹„cnbaViZbc^ZhiZgXo|edcVYWjgV`Vb^`dbdhn!hoVg¨VinXongoZeV`^!VoW^‹g`d" _Z\doc^hoXoZc^Z`daZ_cnb^degnh`Vb^#
goZc^egoZW^Z\VWZojigjYc^Z²# CV\aZW^ZYdWgoZegon\didlVcZ_Ydh^ZljoVg‹lcdlhX]dYnWjgV`‹l!_V`^olVa"
XoVc^ZX]lVhi‹legoZW^Z\V_|WZol^Ÿ`honX]jigjYc^Z²#
IZgb^ch^ZljbdèZb^Zle¨nlcVhide^Z²oVX]lVhoXoZc^V/
™ LXoZhcn h^Zl lo^bc| \aZWŸ edldYj_Z! èZ lhX]dYn WjgV`‹l h| edldacZ Yd
`^Z¨`dlVc^VWjgV`lnbV\VX^Ze¨Z_\aZWn!cVidb^VhiX]lVhinlhX]dYo|^ciZchnlc^Z#
LnocVXoZc^Z iZgb^cj e^ZglhoZ\d degnh`j _Zhi `¨dedia^lZ# OlVaXoVc^Z X]lVhi‹l
jigjYc^dcZ#
™H^ZlldeinbVacnbiZgb^c^ZlX^Ze¨|\aZWŸhegVl^V!èZWjgV`^lhX]dYo|honW`d!
lhX]dYnh|dWÉiZ ^ lng‹lcVcZ# 8]lVhi‹l _Zhi bc^Z_ ^ XoŸhid lhX]dYo| Yde^Zgd ed
WjgV`VX]#çVild_ZhilnocVXoniZgb^ce^ZglhoZ\ddegnh`jdgVoYdWgVegZeVgVin
9o^V¨Vc^Z]ZgW^XnYjedW^ZgVcZ\dina`degoZoa^ÑX^Z ^^X]YVl`^#
IZgb^c h^Zlj lnW^ZgVbn oVlhoZ oZ lo\aŸYj cV edldYoZc^Z jegVln WjgV`‹l#
OiZ\dedldYjXdgVoXoŸÑX^Z_lnW^ZgVbnlXoZhcnh^Zlll^a\dic|edo^b^Z\aZWŸ#
?ZYcV`bjh^bneVb^ŸiVdbdèa^lnX]liV`^Z_hnijVX_^jigjYc^Zc^VX]lolVaXoVc^j
X]lVhi‹l#
EgoZW^Z\ ed\dYn egoZY degnh`^Zb bV le¨nl cV edYVicdс X]lVhi‹l cV
]ZgW^XnYn#
Ed\dYV hegon_V_|XV gdold_dl^ gdÑa^c X^Ze¨d! l^a\dicd hegVl^V! èZ lhX]dYn
^logdhiX]lVhi‹lh|^ciZchnlcZ!VdcZhVbZWVgYo^Z_edYVicZcV]ZgW^XnYn!`i‹gZ
bdèZbnhidhdlVlc^ZXdc^èhonX]YVl`VX]#
9o^V¨Vc^Z]ZgW^XnYjedW^ZgVcZ\degoZoa^ÑX^Z^`dgoZc^Z Ed\dYVc^Zhegon_V_|XVgdold_dl^gdÑa^chjhoV!X]¨‹YedldYj_Zc^Zg‹lcdb^ZgcZ!
edldacZlhX]dYnX]lVhi‹l#IgjYcdoYZXnYdlVddeinbVacnbiZgb^c^Zdegnh`j#
@VèYnohZg^^Yl‹X]ajWigoZX]degnh`‹l_Zhi_ZYcV`dldlVècn/ 8]lVhined`gnlV_|h^ŸdX]gdcc|lVghil|`ji^`ja^^hiV_|h^Ÿbc^Z_lgVèa^lZcV]ZgW^"
™ E^Zglhondegnh`bVcVXZajoc^hoXoZc^Z_V`cV_l^Ÿ`hoZ_a^XoWnX]lVhi‹l!_ZYcV` XnYn#Hidhj_bnliZYnlnèhoZYVl`^egZeVgVi‹l!YdYVlV_bnlhedbV\VXoZdaZ_dlZ#
c^Z bdèZ Wn edldYZb oV]VbdlVc^V logdhij Xon jho`dYoZc^V lhX]dYo|XnX] ?V`dсhVbZ\ddegnh`jbVg‹lc^ZèocVXo|Xnle¨nlcV`d²Xdlnhj`XZh#Degn"
WjgV`‹l#IDG:GDdgVo@DCI6@IIL>C IDGC69D!WŸY|X_ZYcnb^ocV_" h`^lVXo edl^c^Zc Wn hegVlcn iZX]c^Xoc^Z hegVlYoVbn b^ZhoVY¨d! Éaign! YnhoZ!
WZoe^ZXoc^Z_honX]]ZgW^XnY‹l!YdWgoZlneZ¨c^V_|iZclVgjcZ`#D^aZcVidedolda^ Ygdècdс egoZldY‹l ^iY#! Xd _Zhi c^Zoln`aZ lVècZ egon hidhdlVc^j YVlZ` Yo^Z"
hiVceaVciVX_^dYedl^ZYc^V[VoVlhonhi`^X]X]lVhi‹l!WgV`\Vijc`‹ljX^|èa^lnX]! adcnX]# LhoZa`^Z W¨ŸYn l^adÑX^ lnYVi`dlVcZ_ X^ZXon WŸY| dW_Vl^V¨n h^Ÿ WgV`^Zb
`dgonhicVed\dYV!bdècVoVhidhdlVc^èhoZooVaZXVcnX]YVlZ`# h`jiZXocdÑX^# 9d degnh`j hidhj_Zbn bdèa^l^Z bV¨| ^adс ldYn egon oVX]dlVc^j
&)%
jhiVadcZ_YVl`^hVbZ\d]ZgW^XnYj#7Za`Ÿdegnh`^lVXoVjigonbj_ZbncVlnhd`dÑX^
d`#*%XbedcVYgdÑa^cVb^!oVX]dlj_ZbnhiV¨|egŸY`dсX^|\c^`V^jlVèVbn!Wnc^Z IdgZgd*%%H8
db^c|[gV\bZcijedaV# WZoe^ZXocnYaVWjgV`‹l!oVW‹_XonYaVX]lVhi‹l
EVb^ŸiV_bn/Ydhidhdlj_|Xhedh‹WolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹lYdV`ijVacZ_hnijVX_^cV
cVhonbedaj!bdèZbnoVdhoXoŸYo^hedgde^Zc^ŸYon^dh^|\c|ocV`db^inZ[Z`i#

>9:6
DWZXc^ZYdolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹llWjgV`VX]jènlVh^Ÿhidhjc`dldc^Za^XocZ_\gjen
hjWhiVcX_^YdhiŸecnX]cVgnc`jdYl^ZajaVi#C^ZbV_ZYcV`ed_ZYncXoZ_hjWhiVcX_^
h`jiZXocZ_ egoZX^l`d lhonhi`^b X]lVhidb# 9aViZ\d! X]X|X olVaXon bdèa^l^Z _V`
8]lVhinedY\gjY`|/gYZhieiVh^edaZlZ_^hoVg¨Vin cV_l^ŸXZ_\Vijc`‹lX]lVhi‹l!oln`aZ¨|Xonh^Ÿl^ZaZc^ZgoVY`dXoiZgn^l^ŸXZ_hjW"
hiVcX_^W|Y„idegon\didlj_|XegoZYdegnh`^ZbX^ZXojèni`dl|!W|Y„iddegVXdlj_|X
l[VWgnXZcdlnegdYj`i#
IDG:GD*%%H8idegdYj`iojeZ¨c^ZcdlZ_^YZ^¼oVb^Vhi¨|XonXdgVoidl^ŸXZ_
hjWhiVcX_^!edhiVcdl^dcdgVo_ZhoXoZ\gjcidlc^ZdXZc^V`inlcdсW^dad\^Xoc|`VèYZ_
oc^X]#OcV_|XYd`¨VYc^ZoVaZin^lVYng‹ècnX]hjWhiVcX_^!lnWgVcdiV`^ZYl^Z!`i‹gZ
cV_Z[Z`inlc^Z_olVaXoV¨nX]lVhinYo^V¨V_|XoVg‹lcdegoZoa^ÑX^Z!_V`^`dgoZc^Z!cV_"
aZe^Z_h^ŸjojeZ¨c^V¨n^Wn¨ncV_WZoe^ZXoc^Z_hoZYaVX]gdc^dcnX]WjgV`‹l#CVhiŸec^Z
jhiVadcd cV_`dgonhic^Z_ho| egdedgX_Ÿ b^ŸYon c^b^! egon\didlVcd dYedl^ZYc^|
[dgbjaVX_Ÿ ^l iZc hedh‹W digonbVcd IDG:GD *%% H8 ¼ ÑgdYZ` X]lVhidW‹_Xon
oVl^ZgV_|Xn&*%\Zid[jbZhVij^(*%\bZiVb^igdcjl&a^igoZ#

H@JI:8OCDЀ
HeZ`igjbolVaXoVcnX]egoZoIDG:GD*%%H8X]lVhi‹ledolVaVcVdX]gdcŸeaVc"
iVX_^WjgV`VXj`gdlZ\dWZo`dc^ZXocdÑX^hidhdlVc^V^ccnX]]ZgW^XnY‹l#
IDG:GD *%% H8 Yo^V¨V_|X cV X]lVhin egoZo a^ÑX^Z ^egoZo \aZWŸ edolVaV
h`jiZXoc^Z oc^hoXon \VbŸ cV_WVgYo^Z_ jX^|èa^lnX] \Vijc`‹l lnhiŸej_|XnX] cV
eaVciVX_VX] WjgV`V Xj`gdlZ\d# OVlVgiZ lIDG:GD *%% H8 hjWhiVcX_Z V`inlcZ
c^hoXo| X]lVhin dYb^Zccnb^ hedhdWVb^# 9lV bZX]Vc^obn Yo^V¨Vc^V ediŸ\j_|
Z[Z`iX]lVhidW‹_Xon^c^Z_ZYcd`gdic^Zh`jiZXoc^ZolVaXoVcZh|iV`èZ\Vijc`^!`i‹gZ
edYXoVh Yo^V¨Vc^V _ZYcZ\d o`dbedcZci‹l jlVèV h^Ÿ oV ÑgZYc^d lgVèa^lZ# 9d iZ_
\gjenbdècVoVa^XonXdgVoWVgYo^Z_\gd„cZcVeaVciVX_VX]WjgV`VgYZhin#EdoVc^b^
IDG:GD*%%H8h`jiZXoc^ZolVaXoViV`jX^|èa^lZ\Vijc`^!_V`/X]VWZgW¨VlViZ`!
`dbdhVW^V¨V!egonija^VXoZecV^hoVg¨Vihodghi`^#Jc^Zbdèa^l^ViZègdol‹_X]lVhi‹l
gjb^VcdlVinX]#Ðl^Zic^ZcVYV_Zh^ŸcVhiVcdl^h`VedgoZeV`jdo^bnb0Yo^Ÿ`^YjèZ_
oVlVgidÑX^bZiVb^igdcjIDG:GD*%%H8h`jiZXoc^Zc^hoXonhVbdh^ZlngoZeV`j#
Lnhd`VZ[Z`inlcdсX]lVhidW‹_XoV_Zhig‹lc^Zè\lVgVcidlVcVllVgjc`VX]!\Yn
YdX]dYo^Yd`dbeZchVX_^Ynbc^Xnedheda^iZ_!Éd¨`V edacZ\d! _Vhcdi! c^ZoVedb^cV_`^
edacZ_!edo^Zlc^`Vhodghi`^Z\d!ed`gonlnèZ\Vl`^!egoZiVXoc^`‹lXoneh^Vc`^XoVg"
cZ_# OX]lVhi‹l _ZYcda^ÑX^ZccnX] gZYj`dlVcZ h| X]lVhin egdhdlViZ X]lVhic^XV!
eVajhoc^`!l¨dÑc^XZ!l^ZX]a^cVgdXocVdgVolnXonc^ZXedacniVWZaV&#
&)' &)(
IVWZaV&#H`jiZXocdсX]lVhidW‹_XoV]ZgW^XnYjIdgZgd HIDHDL6C>:
aViV&..-¼'%%%#7VYVc^V>chinijijDX]gdcnGdÑa^clEdocVc^j IDG:GD*%%H8hidhj_ZbnedlhX]dYdldcVX]lVhinl[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^/
('a$]V#
IDG:GD*%%H8bdècVhidhdlViV`èZ`g‹i`dedh^Zl^Z0liZYnegd\gVbdX]gdcn
ln\a|YVcVhiŸej_|Xd/
> oVW^Z\ egoZYlhX]dYVb^WjgV`‹l (a$]V
>> oVW^Z\ cVX]lVhinl[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^ 'a$]V
>>> oVW^Z\ cVX]lVhinl[Vo^Za^ÑX^Zc^ 'a$]V
9aVoVeZlc^Zc^Vlnhd`^Z_h`jiZXocdÑX^]ZgW^XnYjl`VèYnX]lVgjc`VX]ed\dYd"
 hiVcYVgY/YZhbZY^[Vb [ZcbZY^[Vb Zid[jbZhVi lnX]oVaZXVbnYdYVlVc^ZlhedbV\VXondaZ_dlnX]Ydlhonhi`^X]degnh`‹loVaZXZ"
IDG:GD *%% H8 oVl^ZgV Yl^Z hjWhiVcX_Z h^ac^Z Yo^V¨V_|XZ egoZo \aZWŸ# 9o^Ÿ`^ c^Z_Zhil`d²XdlnbZiVe^ZgZ_ZhigVX_^#L^ŸXZ_^c[dgbVX_^jcVhonX]YdgVYX‹l#
^X] Y¨j\diglV¨Zbj Yo^V¨Vc^j eaVciVX_V WjgV`‹l Vè Yd oW^dgj edodhiV_Z ldacV dY
X]lVhi‹l#OViZbegoZoXV¨nd`gZhlZ\ZiVX_^WjgV`^bV_|`dgonhicZlVgjc`^logd" JOJE:çC>:C>:

hij#EdcVYidoW^‹g`dgoZc^WjgV`‹loc^ZoVX]lVhoXodcZ\dedaVegoZW^Z\VhegVlc^Z! IDG:GD *%% H8 bV iZè ^ccZ lVadgn!


VZlZcijVacZoVc^ZXonhoXoZc^Vh|c^Zl^Za`^Z# bdèZbc^Z_ocVXo|XZlhidhjc`jYdde^"
hVcnX] dWd`/ aZXo XoŸhid YgdWcZ oVaZin
7:OE>:8O:°HILD YZXnYj_|d`d²XdlnbedldYoZc^j#
IDG:GD *%% H8 _Zhi XV¨`dl^X^Z WZoe^ZXocn YaV X]gdc^dcnX] WjgV`‹l! \Ynè/ OViZb/
™ oVl^ZgVina`dYl^Zc^ZoWŸYcZhjWhiVcX_ZV`inlcZ0 ™ IDG:GD *%% H8 bV jc^lZghVacn
™ c^ZoVl^ZgVV\gZhnlcZ\dYZhbZY^[Vbj0 bZX]Vc^ob Yo^V¨Vc^V# OVlVgiZ lc^b
™ oVl^ZgV_ZYnc^ZWZoe^ZXocZhjWhiVcX_ZlhedbV\V_|XZ0 hjWhiVcX_Z ln`Voj_| V`inlcdс oVg‹l"
™ _V`dgdoejhoXoVac^`VjènidldYn# cd egoZo a^ÑX^Z! _V` ^l \aZW^Z# 8ZX]V iV
7gV`Éidid`hnXocnX] dW_Vl‹l Yo^V¨Vc^V ]ZgW^XnYj IDG:GD *%% H8 l hidhjc" edolVaV ln`dgonhiV ÎXV¨n¿ egZeVgVi#
`j Yd WjgV`‹l egon lng‹lcVcZ_ ^c^Zob^Zc^dcZ_ ed oVW^Z\VX] X]lVhidW‹_XonX] EdYXoVh degnh`‹l edlhX]dYdlnX]
^X] a^XoW^Z cV XV¨Z_ edl^ZgoX]c^ jegVln Ñl^VYXon dlnhd`^Z_ hZaZ`inlcdÑX^ iZ\d hedèni`dlVcV_ZhioVg‹lcdiVX^ZXo!`i‹gV
egZeVgVij iVWZaV '# Jbdèa^l^V id ln`dcnlVc^Z oVW^Z\‹l l`VèYZ_ [Vo^Z gdold" heVYVcVa^ÑX^Z!_V`^iVXoŸÑX^ZXon!`i‹gV
_dlZ_WjgV`‹lWZodWVln^X]jho`dYoZc^V#7Zoe^ZXoZ²hildWjgV`VedoVhidhdlVc^j heVYVcV\aZWŸ#
IDG:GD*%%H8^h^acZYo^V¨Vc^ZX]lVhidW‹_XoZh`¨VYV_|h^ŸcVedcVYYlj`gdic^Z ™ EdlnèhoVoVaZiVhegVlYoVh^ŸiZèedY"
lnèhon eadc lhidhjc`j Yd dW^Z`i‹l c^ZdYX]lVhoXoVcnX] ^edcVY '* lnèhon XoVh c^ZhedYo^ZlVcZ\d YZhoXoj WZoedÑ"
lhidhjc`j Yd dX]gdcn egdYj`iZb hiVcYVgYdlnb# LVgid olg‹X^ jlV\Ÿ! èZ Yd gZYc^deddegnh`j#Obninoa^ÑX^egZeVgVi
ÑgZYc^X]l¨|Xodcdlnc^`^ogd`j'%%%!l`i‹gnbeVcdlV¨Vh^acVhjhoV# YVaZ_Yo^V¨VegoZo\aZWŸ#
™ IDG:GD*%%H8Yo^V¨VYdWgoZiV`èZ
IVWZaV'#Lenl]ZgW^XnYjIdgZgdcVdWhVYŸ^eadcWjgV`VXj`gdlZ\d lc^h`^X] iZbeZgVijgVX]# 8]d oVaZXVcZ
aViV&..-¼'%%%#7VYVc^V>chinijijDX]gdcnGdÑa^clEdocVc^j _Zhi hidhdlVc^Z IDG:GD *%% H8 liZbeZgVijgoZ c^Z c^èhoZ_ c^è &% •8! lVgid
l^ZYo^Z!èZ_ZYZco`dbedcZci‹l¼Zid[jbZhVi!_V`d_ZYncno]ZgW^XnY‹lWjgVXoV"
cnX]!oVXoncVYo^V¨V_jèlegoZYo^VaZdY'•8Yd,•8!Xona^loV`gZh^ZiZbeZgVijg
`^Z¨`dlVc^VocVXocZ_XoŸÑX^X]lVhi‹l#Hi|YiZèc^ZocVXocVdWc^è`ViZbeZgVijgned
ln`dcVcnboVW^Z\jc^ZoVigonbj_ZXV¨`dl^X^ZegdXZhjolVaXoVc^VX]lVhi‹l#

 hiVcYVgY/YZhbZY^[Vb [ZcbZY^[Vb Zid[jbZhVi

CdldXoZhcV [dgbjaVX_V IDG:GD *%% H8 ^dYedl^ZYc^ YdW‹g hjWhiVcX_^ Xonc"


cnX]ol^Ÿ`hoV_|WZoe^ZXoZ²hildX]gdc^dcnX]WjgV`‹l#

You might also like