Professional Documents
Culture Documents
&KU]HVW2JQLD
5R]G]LD
:yZF]DVU]HNDZUy NDGRZLHG PLQD7DN FLGDPUDG REXM HOD]QHEXW\
ZH GRU NLNRVWXU HOD]Q\,G Z HOD]Q\FKEXWDFKQDNRQLHF ZLDWDDGURJ SU]HG
VRE NRVWXUHPPDFDM]DPLVNUDSODM,G SU]H]RJLH L ZRG QLHXVWDZDMZVWHF]
VL QLHRJO GDM$JG\MX ]HGU VL FKRGDNLJG\]HWU]HVL NRVWXU HOD]Q\JG\MX
RGZLDWUXL DUXZ\VFKQ WZHRF]\WDN H MX QLMHGQD]D]QLFKZ\S\Q QLH
]GRDZyZF]DVQDNR FX ZLDWDRGQDMG]LHV]WRF]HJRV]XNDV]LWRFRNRFKDV]%\
PR H
, :LHG PLQSRV]HGSU]H]RJLH LZRG ZVWHF]VL QLHRJO GD$OHQLHZ]L QL
EXWyZ HOD]Q\FKQLNRVWXUD:]L W\ONRVZyMPLHF]ZLHG PL VNL1LHSRVXFKD
VyZZUy NL,GREU]H]URELERWRE\D]DZUy ND
)ORXUHQV'HODQQR\%DMNLLNOHFKG\
5R]G]LDSLHUZV]\
: NU]DNDFKGDU\VL SWDNL
=ERF]HSDURZXSRUDVWDDJ VWD]ELWDPDVDMH \QLEHUEHU\VyZZ\PDU]RQH
PLHMVFHGRJQLD]GRZDQLDLGR HUXQLFWHG\G]LZQHJR H URLRVL WDPRGSWDFWZD
=DZ]L FLHWU\ORZD\G]ZR FH ZLHUJRWD\F]HF]RWNLLSLHJ HFRFKZLOD
UR]EU]PLHZDRWH G ZL F]QHSLQNSLQN]L E\=L EDG]ZRQLQDGHV]F]
SRP\ ODD0LOYDRGUXFKRZRVSRJO GDM F QDQLHER1LHE\RFKPXU$OH]L E\
]DZV]HG]ZRQL QDGHV]F]3U]\GDRE\VL QDUHV]FLHWURFK GHV]F]X
0LHMVFHQDZSURVWZ\ORWXNRWOLQNLE\RGREU\PP\ OLZVNLPVWDQRZLVNLHP
GDM F\PQLH]HV]DQV QDXGDQHSRORZDQLH]ZDV]F]DWXZ%URNLORQLHPDWHF]QLNX
]ZLHU]\Q\:DGDM FHSRW Q\PREV]DUHPODVXGULDG\SRORZD\QLH]PLHUQLH
U]DGNRDF]RZLHNMHV]F]HU]DG]LHMRGZD DVL WX]DSXV]F]D7XWDM GQ\PL VD
OXEVNyURZFDVDPVWDZDVL RELHNWHPRZyZ%URNLOR VNLHGULDG\QLHPLD\
OLWR FLGODLQWUX]yZ0LOYDSU]HNRQDDVL NLHG\ R W\PQDZDVQHMVNyU]H
&]HJRMDNF]HJRDOH]ZLHU]DZ%URNLORQLHPHEUDNRZDR-HGQDN0LOYDWNZLD
Z ]DVDG]FHMX SRQDGGZLHJRG]LQ\LQDGDOQLFQLHZ\FKRG]LRQDVWU]D3RORZD]
PDUV]XQLHPRJDSDQXM FDRGPLHVL F\VXV]DZ\VDDSRV]\FLHFKUXVWHPLOL PL
'RMHMSLHUZV]HJRVSRWNDQLD]ZLHG PLQHPGRV]RZOLSFXGZDW\JRGQLHSR
Z\GDU]HQLDFKQDZ\VSLH7KDQHGGLZ\EXFKXZRMQ\Z'RO$QJUD0LOYDZUyFLD
GR%URNOLRQXSRNLONXQDVWRGQLRZHMQLHREHFQR FLSU]\SURZDG]LDUHV]WNLNRPDQGD
6FRLD
WDHOUR]ELWHJRZ7HPHULLSRGF]DVSUyE\SU]HGRVWDQLDVL QDWHUHQREM WHJR
ZRMQ $HGLUQ:LHZLyUNLFKFLD\SU]\ F]\VL GRSRZVWDQLDZ]QLHFRQHJRSU]H]
HOI\Z'RO%ODWKDQQD1LHSRZLRGRLPVL JG\E\QLH0LOYDE\RE\SRQLFK$OH
]QDOD]\0LOY L D]\OZ%URNLORQLH
=DUD]SRSU]\MH G]LHSRLQIRUPRZDQRM H $JODLVSLOQLHRF]HNXMHMHMZ&RO
6HUUDL0LOYD]G]LZLDVL WURFK
$JODLVE\DSU]HR RQ EURNLOR VNLFKX]GURZLFLHOHNDJ ERNDSHQDJRU F\FK
UyGHLMDVNL NRWOLQD&RO6HUUDLE\DPLHMVFHPX]GURZLH
8VXFKDDMHGQDNZH]ZDQLDE G F SU]HNRQDQD H FKRG]LRMDNLHJR OHF]RQHJR
HOIDSUDJQ FHJR]DMHMSR UHGQLFWZHPVNRQWDNWRZDVL ]HVZ\PNRPDQGHP$
JG\]REDF]\DUDQQHJRZLHG PLQDLGRZLHG]LDDVL ZF]\PU]HF]ZSDGDZLVWQ\
V]D:\ELHJD]JURW\]UR]ZLDQ\PZRVHPLFD ]R Z\DGRZDDQD$JODLV
:LG]LDPQLH:LG]LDPRM WZDU]&]\SRMPXMHV]F]\PPLWRJUR]L"
1LHQLHSRMPXM RGU]HNDFKRGQRX]GURZLFLHONDWR*Z\QEOHLGG
:LHG PLQ3U]\MDFLHO%URNLORQX-HVWWXRGF]WHUQDVWXGQLRGQRZLX,MHV]F]HMDNL
F]DVXS\QLH]DQLPE G]LHPyJZVWDLQRUPDOQLHFKRG]L3UDJQLHZLH FL]H
ZLDWDZLH FLRMHJREOLVNLFK7\ONRW\PR HV]PXLFKGRVWDUF]\
:LH FL]H ZLDWD"&K\ED UR]XPVWUDFLDG]LZR RQR&]\W\ZLHV]FRWHUD]
G]LHMHVL QD ZLHFLH]DJUDQLFDPLWZRMHJRVSRNRMQHJRODVX":$HGLUQWUZD
ZRMQD:%UXJJHZ7HPHULLLZ5HGDQLL]DP WSLHNRZLHONLHRZ\=DW\PLFR
UHEHOL ZV]F] OLQD7KDQHGGJRQL ZV] G\:V] G\SHQRV]SLHJyZLDQ
JL\DUH
MHGQRVRZRQLHUD]Z\VWDUF]\XURQLXVWDVNU]\ZLJG\QLHWU]DLMX NDWFLZ
ORFKXF]HUZRQ\P HOD]HP]D ZLHFL$MDQDSU]HV]SLHJLPDPFKRG]LGRS\W\ZD
VL ZLH FL]ELHUD".DUNXQDGVWDZLD",GODNRJR"'ODMDNLHJR Sy \ZHJR
ZLHG PLQD"$FRWRRQPLEUDWDOERVZDW", FLHUR]XPX]E\D $JODLV
-H OLPDV]]DPLDUZU]HV]F]HSU]HUZDDVSRNRMQLHGULDGDWRLG P\GDOHMZ
ODV-HPXSRWU]HEQ\MHVWVSRNyM
0LOYDREHMU]DDVL PLPRZROLQDZ\ORWMDVNLQLZNWyUHMSU]HGFKZLO ZLG]LDD
UDQQHJR.DZDFKRSDSRP\ ODDRGUXFKRZRFKRFKXG\DOHMHGQD \DHE
ELD\DOHEU]XFKSDVNLQLE\XPRG]LNDZLGQR H WUXGPX]DXFKHPQLHVRQLQDL
SLZR
2QQD7KDQHGGE\VWZLHUG]LDQLH]DS\WDD5HEHOLDQW
1LHZLHPZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPL$JODLV6DDVMI3RWU]HEXMHSRPRF\5HV]WD
PQLHQLHREFKRG]L
XNO NDQDMHGQRNRODQRQLVNRVNRQLDJRZ
% G SR]GURZLRQD3DQL(LWKQH
:DGF]\QL%URNLORQX]DWNQ D]D\NRZ\SDVHN]RW\QR \NRNV]WDFLHVLHUSD
:VWD SRZLHG]LDD3U]HMG P\VL &KF ] WRE SRUR]PDZLD
'XJRV]\UD]HPSU]H]SHHQFLHQLODVPDDVUHEUQRZRVDGULDGDLZ\VRND
SRZRZRVDG]LHZF]\QD DGQDQLHSU]HU\ZDDPLOF]HQLD
'DZQRQLH]DJO GDD GR'XHQ&DQHOO0DULR
&]DVXQLHVWDR3DQL(LWKQH'R'XHQ&DQHOOGDOHNDRG:VW NLGURJDDMD
3U]HFLH ZLHV]
:LHP=P F]RQDMHVWH "
(OI\SRWU]HEXM SRPRF\=WZHJRUR]ND]XLPSU]HG\SRPDJDP
1DPRM SUR E
, FLH1DSUR E
0DPMHV]F]HMHGQ
7DNHPP\ ODD:LHG PLQ"
3RPy PX
0LOYD]DWU]\PDDVL L RGZUyFLDRVWU\PUXFKHP]DPDD]DZDG]DM F JD ]N
ZLFLRNU]HZXREUyFLDM Z SDOFDFKFLVQ DQD]LHPL
2GSyURNXSRZLHG]LDDFLFKRSDWU] F ZVUHEU]\VWHRF]\GULDG\JRZ Z
KD]DUGVWDZL HOIyZ]UR]JURPLRQ\FKNRPDQGSU]HSURZDG]DPGR%URNLORQX
*G\Z\SRF]Q L ]UDQVL Z\OHF] QD]DGLFKZ\ZRG] 0DRWHJR"1LHGR
XF]\QLDP"&RQyZQDV]ODNFLHPQ QRF UXV]DP6R FDVL MX O NDPMDN
QLHWRSHU]DOERSXV]F]\NMDNL
1LNWQLH]QDOH Q\FK FLH HNOHSLHMRGFLHELH
:NQLHLQLHGRZLHPVL QLF]HJR:LHG PLQSRQRFKFHE\PZLH FL]ELHUDD
PL G]\OXG]LSRMHFKDD7RUHEHOLDQWQDMHJRLPL PDM DQ
JLYDUHZ\RVWU]RQHXV]\
0QLHVDPHMWH QLMDNZPLDVWDFKVL SRND]\ZD$MDNPQLHNWRUR]SR]QD"3DPL
R WDPW\P \ZDMHV]F]HQLHSU]\VFKDMHV]F]HWDPWDNUHZ%RGX R E\RZWHG\
NUZL3DQL(LWKQH
1LHPDRVUHEUQHRF]\VWDUHMGULDG\E\\REFH]LPQHQLHSU]HQLNQLRQH
1LHPDRSUDZGDWR
-H OLPQLHUR]SR]QDM QDSDOQDZOHN
-HVWH UR]ZD QD-HVWH RVWUR QDLF]XMQD
%\ZLH FLRNWyUH:LHG PLQSURVLSR]ELHUDWU]DVL F]XMQR FLZ\]E\7U]D
S\WD$WHUD]FLHNDZR QLHEH]SLHF]QLHREMDZLD-H OLPL SRFKZ\F
0DV]NRQWDNW\
8P F] =DNDWXM $OER]JQRM Z 'UDNHQERUJX
$ZREHFPQLHPDV]GXJ
0LOYDRGZUyFLDJRZ ]DJU\]DZDUJL
$QRPDPSRZLHG]LDDJRU]NR1LH]DSRPQLHPLRW\P
3U]\PNQ DRF]\WZDU]VNXUF]\DVL MHMQDJOHXVWDGUJQ \] E\]ZDU\VL
VLOQLH3RGSRZLHNDPLEODGR]D ZLHFLRZVSRPQLHQLHXSLRUQ\PNVL \FRZ\P
EODVNLHPWDPWHMQRF\:UyFLQDJOHEyOZNRVWFHXFDSLRQHMU]HPLHQQ S WO
SXDSNLEyOZVWDZDFKGDUW\FKV]DUSQL FLHP:XV]DFKUR]EU]PLDV]XPOL FL
SURVWXM FHJRVL JZDWRZQLHGU]HZD.U]\NM NG]LNDV]DOH F]DSU]HUD RQD
- WH ]RVWDZZVSRNRMX1DUD]LH
:HGOHUR]ND]X&]\PRJ RGHM "
0R HV]
$JHQWZ\V]HGRVWUR QLHLFLFKXWNR]DP\NDM F ]DVRE G ERZHGU]ZLNRPQDW\
'LMNVWUDPLOF]DGXJR]DSDWU]RQ\ZSL WU] FHVL QDVWROHPDS\OLVW\GRQRV\
SURWRNR\SU]HVXFKD L Z\URNL PLHUFL
2UL
6HNUHWDU]XQLyVJRZ FKU] NQ 0LOF]D
:LHG PLQMHVWZ%URNLORQLH
2UL5HXYHQ]QRZX]DFKU] NDRGUXFKRZRVSRJO GDM F SRGVWyZNLHUXQNXQRJL
V]HID'LMNVWUD]DXZD \VSRMU]HQLH
=JDG]DVL 7HJRPXQLH]DSRPQ ZDUNQ 3U]H]GZDW\JRGQLHQLHPRJHP
SU]H]QLHJRFKRG]L6WUDFLHPWZDU]ZREHF)LOLSS\PXV] F MDNSLHVVNDPOHL
SURVLRMHMFKROHUQHF]DU\ERLQDF]HMNXV]W\NDE\PGRG]LVLDM&y VDPVRELH
MHVWHPZLQLHQQLHGRFHQLHPJR1DMJRUV]H H QLHPRJ PXVL WHUD]
]UHZDQ RZDGREUDGRMHJRZLHG PL VNLHMGXS\6DPQLHPDPF]DVXDSU]HFLH
QLHPRJ GODSU\ZDW\X \ZDPRLFKOXG]L3UDZGD2UL H QLHPRJ "
+HPKHP
1LHFKU] NDM:LHP$FKGRGLDEDMDNWDZDG]DQ FL-DNNXVLE\VL QL
SRVX \-DNDWZRVL ]DSRPQLHJG\VL M PD$OHJG\VL ]DSRPQLUD]NR FD
QLHPD&]\)LOLSSD(LOKDUWFL JOHMHV]F]HVLHG]LZ0RQWHFDOYR"
7DN
%LHU]SLyURLNDDPDU]3RG\NWXM FLOLVWGRQLHM3LV]3VLDNUHZVNXSLVL QLH
PRJ &RWR]DFKROHUQHZU]DVNL2UL"&RVL WDPG]LHMHQDSODFX"
DF\REU]XFDM NDPLHQLDPLUH]\GHQFM QLOIJDDUG]NLHJRSRVD=DSDFLOL P\LP
]DWRKHPKHPMDNPLVL ]GDMH
$KD'REU]H=DPNQLMRNQR-XWURQLHFK DF\SyMG REU]XFDILOL EDQNX
NUDVQROXGD*LDQFDUGLHJR2GPyZLPLXMDZQLHQLDNRQW
*LDQFDUGLKHPKHPSU]HND]D]QDF]Q VXP QDIXQGXV]ZRMHQQ\
+D1LHFKZL F REU]XFDM WHEDQNLNWyUHQLHSU]HND]D\
:V]\VWNLHSU]HND]D\
$FKQXGQ\MHVWH 2UL3LV]SRZLDGDP8PLRZDQD)LOVR FHPRLFK
&KROHUDFL JOHVL ]DSRPLQDP:H QRZ\DUNXV]*RWyZ"
7DNMHVWKHPKHP
'URJD)LOLSSR3DQL7ULVV0HULJROGPDUWZLVL SHZQLHRZLHG PLQDNWyUHJR
WHOHSRUWRZDD]7KDQHGGGR%URNLORQXF]\QL F ]WHJRIDNWXJ ERNLVHNUHWQDZHW
SU]HGHPQ FRRNUXWQLHPQLH]DERODR8VSRNyMM :LHG PLQPDVL MX GREU]H
-X QDZHW]DF] Z\V\D]%URNLORQXHPLVDULXV]NL]]DGDQLHPV]XNDQLD ODGyZ
NVL QLF]NL&LULOOLRVyENLNWyUDWDN&L SU]HFLH LQWHUHVXMH1DV]SU]\MDFLHO*HUDOW
QDMZ\UD QLHMQLHZLH H &LULOODMHVWZ1LOIJDDUG]LHJG]LHVSRVRELVL GR OXEX]
FHVDU]HP(PK\UHP=DOH \ PLDE\:LHG PLQVSRNRMQLHVLHG]LDZ%URNLORQLH
GODWHJRWH SRVWDUDPVL HE\WDZLH GRWDUDGRQLHJR1DSLVDH "
+HPKHPGRWDUDGRQLHJR
2GDNDSLWX=DVWDQDZLDPQLH2ULZ\FLHUDMSLyURGRFKROHU\3LV]HP\GR
)LOLSS\QLHGRUDG\NUyOHZVNLHMOLVWPDZ\JO GDHVWHW\F]QLH2GDNDSLWX
=DVWDQDZLDPQLHGODF]HJR:LHG PLQQLHV]XNDNRQWDNWX]<HQQHIHU1LHFKFHPL
VL ZLHU]\DE\WHQJUDQLF] F\]REVHVM DIHNWZ\JDVWDNQDJOHQLH]DOH QLHRG
RSFMLSROLW\F]Q\FKMHJRLGHDX=GUXJLHMVWURQ\JG\E\WR<HQQHIHUE\DW NWyUD
GRVWDUF]\D&LULOO (PK\URZLLJG\E\E\\QDWRGRZRG\WR]FK FL E\PVSUDZL
HE\:LHG PLQGRVWDMHGRU NL3UREOHPUR]ZL ]DE\VL VDPSHZLHQMHVWHP
WHJRDZLDURRPQDF]DUQRZRVDSL NQR QLHE\DE\SHZQDGQLDQLJRG]LQ\
:LHG PLQQLHOXELJG\NWR GRW\NDMHJRG]LHZF]\QNL$UWDXG7HUUDQRYDGRZRGQLH
SU]HNRQDVL R W\PQD7KDQHGG&KFLDE\PZLHU]\)LO H QLHPDV]GRZRGyZ
]GUDG\<HQQHIHULQLHZLHV]JG]LHRQDVL XNU\ZD%RODRE\PQLHEDUG]RJG\E\
VL RND]DR H WRNROHMQ\WDMRQ\SU]HGHPQ VHNUHW-DQLHPDPSU]HG7RE
VHNUHWyZ
=F]HJRVL PLHMHV]2UL"
=QLF]HJRKHPKHP
3LV]-DQLHPDPSU]HG7RE VHNUHWyZ)LOLOLF] QDZ]DMHPQR 3R]RVWDM ]
J ERNLPXV]DQRZDQLHPHWFDHWHUDHWFDHWHUD'DMSRGSLV]
2UL5HXYHQSRV\SDOLVWSLDVNLHP'LMNVWUDXVLDGZ\JRGQLHM]DNU FLP\QND
NFLXNDPLVSOHFLRQ\FKQDEU]XFKXGRQL
7D0LOYDNWyU :LHG PLQZ\V\DQDSU]HV]SLHJL]DJDGQ &RPR HV]PLR
QLHMSRZLHG]LH"
=DMPXMHVL KHPKHPFKU] NQ VHNUHWDU]SU]HU]XFDQLHPGR%URNLORQX
JUXS6FRLD
WDHOUR]ELW\FKSU]H]ZRMVNDWHPHUVNLH:\SURZDG]DHOI\]REDZL
NRWyZXPR OLZLDM F LPZ\SRF]\QHNLSRQRZQHVIRUPRZDQLHZERMRZH
NRPDQGD
1LHUDF]PQLHZLHG] SRZV]HFKQLHGRVW SQ SU]HUZD'LMNVWUD']LDDOQR
0LOY\MHVWPL]QDQD]DPLHU]DPM ]UHV]W Z\NRU]\VWD*G\E\QLHWRGDZQR
U]XFLE\PM QD HU7HPHUF]\NRP&RPR HV]PLSRZLHG]LHRQLHMVDPHM"2
0LOYLHMDNRWDNLHM"
3RFKRG]LMDNPLVL ]GDMH]MDNLHM ]DSDGHMZVLZ*yUQ\P6RGGHQ1DSUDZG
QD]\ZDVL 0DULD%DUULQJ0LOYDWRSU]\GRPHNNWyU\QDGD\MHMGULDG\:6WDUV]HM
0RZLH]QDF]\
.DQLDSU]HUZD'LMNVWUD:LHP
-HMUyGWR]G]LDGDSUDG]LDGDP\ OLZF\/H QLOXG]LH]DSD EUDW]NQLHM *G\
V\QDVWDUHJR%DUULQJD]DWUDWRZDR VWDU\Z\XF]\OH QHJRU]HPLRVDFyUN *G\
]PDURPXVL PDWNDSRQRZQLHZ\V]D]DP +HPKHP0DULDQLHDG]LD]
RMF]\PHPLXFLHND]GRPX0LDDZWHG\MDNPLVL ]GDMHV]HVQD FLHODW
3RZ GURZDDQDSyQRF \D]SRORZDQLDDOHOH QLF\EDURQyZQLHXPLODOLMHM
\FLDVDP WURSLOLLV]F]XOLQLE\]ZLHU]D=DF] DZL F NXVRZDZ%URNLORQLHL
WDPKHPKHPGRSDG\M GULDG\
,]DPLDVWXNDWUXSLSU]\JDUQ \PUXNQ 'LMNVWUD8]QD\]DVZRM $RQD
RGZG]L F]\DVL =DZDUDSDNW]:LHG P %URNLORQX]HVWDU 6UHEUQRRN (LWKQH
0DULD%DUULQJXPDUDQLHFK \MH0LOYD,OHHNVSHG\FML]DDWZLD]DQLPFLZ
9HUGHQL.HUDFNSRDSDOLVL " 7U]\"
+HPKHP&]WHU\MDNPLVL ]GDMH2ULHPX5HXYHQRZLFL JOHFR VL
]GDZDRFKRSDPL PLDQLH]DZRGQ %\RWHJRGRNXS\FR NRRVHWNLOXG]L
W\FKQDM]DMDGOHMV]\FKGRSRORZD QDG]LZR RQLHVNDOS\$GXJRQLHPRJOLVL
SRDSDER0LOYDF]DVHPZ\QRVLDMHGQHJR]U]H]LQDZDVQ\FKSOHFDFKDRFDORQ\
SRGQLHELRVDZ\FKZDODMHMP VWZR'RSLHUR]DF]ZDUW\PUD]HPZ9HUGHQMDNPL
VL ]GDMHNWR VL Z F]RRSDFQ -DN H WRWDN]DZU]D OLQDJOHKHPKHP H
SU]HZRGQLF]NDNWyUDOXG]LQDG]LZR RQ\VNU]\NXMH]DND G\PUD]HP] \FLHP
XFKRG]L",Z\OD]RV]\GR]PLHFKD H SU]HZRGQLF]NDZLHG]LHDOHZSRWU]DVN
ZSURVWSRGVWU]D\F]HNDM F\FKZ]DVDG]FHGULDG
'LMNVWUDRGVXQ QDEU]HJELXUNDSURWRNy]SU]HVXFKDQLDERZ\GDRPXVL H
SHUJDPLQZFL FXFKQLHL]E WRUWXU
,ZWHG\GRP\ OLVL 0LOYD]QLNQ DZ%URNLORQLHMDNVHQMDNL]RW\$OHGR
G]L Z 9HUGHQWUXGQRRRFKRWQLNyZGRZ\SUDZQDGULDG\6WDUD(LWKQHLPRGD
.DQLDGRNRQD\QLH]HMVHOHNFML,RQLR PLHODM VL WZLHUG]L H SURZRNDFMDWR
QDV]OXG]NLZ\QDOD]HN$PR H
+HPKHP"]DFKU] ND2UL(HXYHQ]G]LZLRQ\XUZDQ\P]GDQLHPL
SU]HGX DM F\PVL PLOF]HQLHPV]HID
0R H ZNR FX]DF] OLXF]\VL RGQDVGRNR F]\]LPQRV]SLHJSDWU] F QD
GRQRV\SURWRNR\SU]HVXFKD L Z\URNL PLHUFL
*G\QLJG]LHQLHGRVWU]HJDIDUE\0LOYD]DQLHSRNRLDVL 3U]\SRPQLDDVRELH
QDJOH H NR]LRHN]URELNURNZPRPHQFLHVWU]DX=URELOXEFKFLD]URELFRQD
MHGQRZ\FKRG]LR5XV]\VL DVWU]DDPRJDWUDILZEU]XFK0LOYD]DNO D6WU]D
Z EU]XFKSU]HNOH VWZRLKD EDGODRZF\3HFK7IXWIX]HOLFKR
6]\ENRSRGELHJDGR]ERF]DNRWOLQNLUR]JO GDM F VL EDF]QLHZ UyGMH \Q
PFKyZLSDSURFL6]XNDDVWU]D\=DRSDWU]RQDZJURWRF]WHUHFKEU]HV]F]RWDFK
Z\RVWU]RQ\FKWDN H JROL\ZRVNL]SU]HGUDPLHQLDZ\SXV]F]RQD]RGOHJR FL
SL G]LHVL FLXNURNyZVWU]DDPXVLDDSU]HELNR]DQDZ\ORW
'RVWU]HJD]QDOD]DLRGHWFKQ D]XOJ VSOXQ DWU]\NURWQLHUDGD]IDUWX
1LHSRWU]HEQLHVL REDZLDDEDE\ROHSLHMQL SU]\SXV]F]DD6WU]DDQLHE\D
REOHSLRQDNOHLVW L PLHUG] F WUH FL R GND1LHQRVLDWH ODGyZMDVQHM
Uy RZHMLSLHQLVWHMIDUE\]SXF%U]HFKZDE\DFDDSRNU\WDFLHPQ ERJDW
F]HUZLHQL *URWSU]HV]\VHUFH0LOYDQLHPXVLDDVL VNUDGDDQLSRGFKRG]LQLH
F]HNDMHMGXJLPDUV]SR ODGDFK.R]LREH]Z WSLHQLDOH DPDUWZ\ZJ V]F]X
QLHGDOHMQL VWRNURNyZRGSRODQNLZPLHMVFXNWyUHZVND H MHMIDUED$
SRVWU]HORQ\ZVHUFHNR]LRPXVLDSRSDUXVNRNDFKIDUERZDZLHG]LDDZL F H
]QDMG]LH ODG]DWZR FL
3RG]LHVL FLXNURNDFKRGQDOD]DWURSSRG \DQLPSRQRZQLHSRJU DM F VL Z
P\ ODFKLZVSRPQLHQLDFK
'RWU]\PDDGDQHMZLHG PLQRZLRELHWQLF\:UyFLDGR%URNLORQXQDZHW
ZF]H QLHMQL RELHF\ZDDSL GQLSR ZL FLH QLZSL GQLSRQRZLX
]DF]\QDM F\PQOXG]LPLHVL F VLHUSLH DXHOIyZ/DPPDVVLyGP\SU]HGRVWDWQL
VD\DHGURNX
3U]HSUDZLDVL SU]H]:VW N R EU]DVNXRQDLSL FLXHOIyZ.RPDQGRNWyUH
ZLRGDOLF]\RSRF] WNRZRG]LHZL FLXNRQQ\FKDOH RGDF\]%UXJJHFD\F]DV
V]OLLFKWURSHPWU]\VWDMDQLDSU]HGU]HN ZVLHGOLLPQDNDUNSU]\FLVQ OLSRQLHFKDOL
GRSLHURQDG:VW N JG\ZRSDUDFK ZLWX]DPDMDF]\LP%URNLORQQDSUDZ\P
EU]HJX RGDF\EDOLVL %URNLORQX7RLFKXUDWRZDR3U]HSUDZLOLVL
:\FLH F]HQLSRUDQLHQL,QLHZV]\VF\
0LDDGODZLHG PLQDZLH FLDOHE\DSU]HNRQDQD H *Z\QEOHLGGZFL MHVWZ
&RO6HUUDL=DPLHU]DDSyM GRQLHJRGRSLHURRNRRSRXGQLDZ\VSDZV]\VL MDN
QDOH \=GXPLDDVL JG\QDJOHMDNGXFKZ\RQLVL ] PJ\%H]VRZDXVLDG
RERNSDWU] FMDNPR FLVRELHOHJRZLVNRXNDGDGHUN QDNXSLHJD ]L
$OH FLSLOQRSRZLHG]LDD]SU]HN VHP:LHG PLQLHMD]QyJOHF ']LH L
QRFQDNXOEDFHW\NDQLHF]XM DSU]HPRF]RQDMHVWHPGRS SNDER P\VL ZLWHP
MDNRZLOF\SU]H]QDGU]HF]QHR]\SU]HG]LHUDOL
3URV] FL 'RZLHG]LDD VL F]HJR "
'RZLHG]LDDPSDUVNQ DUR]V]QXURZXM F L]]XZDM F SU]HPRF]RQHRSLHUDM FH
VL EXW\=QLHZLHONLPWUXGHPERRVSUDZLHJR QR H WDWZRMDSDQQDWDND
SHUVRQDWHJR PLQLHSRZLHG]LD0\ ODDPVRELHSDVLHUELFDWZRMDFKXG]LDF]HN
MDNL VLHURWDSU]H]ORVXNU]\ZG]RQD$WXPDV]FLQWU\MVNDNUyOHZQD+D$PR H
L W\SU]HEUDQ\NVL "
0yZSURV]
1LHGRVWDQ MHMMX Z U FHNUyORZLHERWDWZRMD&LULOODMDNVL Z\MDZLR]
7KDQHGGSURVWRGR1LOIJDDUGXXFLHNDSHZQRZUD]]W\PLPDJLNDPLFR]GUDG]LOL
$ Z1LOIJDDUG]LHFHVDU](PK\U]SRPS M SU]\M ,ZLHV]FR"3RQR HQLVL ] QL
]DP\ OD$WHUD]GDMPLRGHWFKQ &KFHV]SRJDGDP\MDNVL Z\ SL
:LHG PLQPLOF]D0LOYDUR]ZLHVLDPRNUHRQXFHQDURVRFKDWHMJD ]LWDNE\
]QDOD]RMHZVFKRG] FHVR FHV]DUSQ DNODPU SDVD
5R]G]LDVL FKF EXUNQ D&]HJRWXMHV]F]HVWRLV]")RUWXQQLHMV]\FKZLH FL
FK\ED VL VSRG]LHZDQLHPyJ"1LFFLMX QLHJUR]LQLNWRFLHELHQLHS\WD
SU]HVWDOLVL WRE V]SLHG]\]DMPRZD$WZRMDG]LHZNDZ\PNQ DVL NUyORP
FHVDU]RZ E G]LH
7RSHZQDZLDGRPR "
1\QLHQLFQLHSHZQH]LHZQ DXVLDGDQDEDURJLFK\EDWR H VRQHF]NRFR
GQLDQLHEHPRGZVFKRGXQD]DFKyGSRGUy XMH$OHRQLOIJDDUG]NLPFHVDU]XLR
NUyOHZQLH]&LQWU\PXVLSUDZG E\FRJDGDM *R QRRQLHM
6N G WHQQDJ\UR]JRV"
1LE\WRQLHZLHV]2QDZV]DN(PK\URZLZZLDQLHV]PDW]LHPLZQLHVLH1LH
W\ONR&LQWU SRWHMVWURQLH-DUUXJLWH +DWR L PRMDWRE G]LHSDQLERMD]
*yUQHJR6RGGHQDFDH6RGGHQSRND]DRVL MHMOHQQR7HG\JG\ZMHMODVDFK
1DZLGRNZFKRG] FHJRGRVDOLDXGLHQF\MQHMQLOIJDDUG]NLHJRDPEDVDGRUD
'LMNVWUDZHVWFKQ VNU\FLH6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUOHQSRVHFHVDU]D(PK\UDYDU
(PUHLVDPLD]Z\F]DMSURZDG]LUR]PRZ\ZM ]\NXG\SORPDW\F]Q\PLXZLHOELD
ZSODWDZ]GDQLDSRPSDW\F]QHM ]\NRZHG]LZRO JL]UR]XPLDOHW\ONRGOD
G\SORPDWyZLXF]RQ\FK'LMNVWUDVWXGLRZDZDNDGHPLLR[HQIXUFNLHMLFKRQLH
X]\VNDW\WXXPDJLVWUD]QDSRGVWDZ\QDG WHJRXQLZHUV\WHFNLHJR DUJRQX
1LHFK WQLHMHGQDNVL QLPSRVXJLZDERZJ ELGXV]\QLHFLHUSLDSRPS\L
ZV]HONLFKIRUPSUHWHQVMRQDOQHJRFHUHPRQLDX
:LWDPHNVFHOHQFMR
3DQLHKUDELRXNRQLVL FHUHPRQLDOQLH6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUOHQ$FKUDF]FLH
Z\EDF]\0R H MX SRZLQLHQHPPyZLMD QLHR ZLHFRQ\NVL " :DV]D
Z\VRNR UHJHQFLH":DV]DPR VHNUHWDU]XVWDQX"1DKRQRUZDV]DZLHOPR QR
JRGQR FLV\SL VL QDZDVWDNLPJUDGHP H GRSUDZG\QLHZLHPMDNPDP
W\WXRZDE\QLHXFK\ELSURWRNRRZL
1DMOHSLHME G]LHZDV]DNUyOHZVNDPR RGU]HNVNURPQLH'LMNVWUD:LHFLH
ZV]DNHNVFHOHQFMR H WRGZyUF]\QLNUyOD$QLHREF\MHVWZDP]DSHZQHIDNW H
JG\MDNU]\NQ 3RGVNDNLZDWRGZyUZ7UHWRJRU]HS\WD-DNZ\VRNR"
$PEDVDGRUZLHG]LD H 'LMNVWUDSU]HVDG]DDOHZFDOHQLHWDNEDUG]R.UyOHZLF]
&LULOODNUyORZD&LQWU\SRSUDZL]QDFLVNLHP6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUOHQQLH
]RVWDDXSURZDG]RQDOHF]SRV]XNDDZFHVDUVWZLHD]\OX1LHPDWRQLFZVSyOQHJR
] LQF\GHQWHPQD7KDQHGG
'RSUDZG\"
,QF\GHQWQD7KDQHGGFL JQ ]NDPLHQQ WZDU] DPEDVDGRUZEXG]L
QLHVPDNFHVDU]D$VNU\WREyMF]\GRNRQDQ\SU]H]V]DOH FD]DPDFKQD \FLHNUyOD
9L]LQLLUDZ\ZRDMHJRV]F]HU L \Z DERPLQDFM -HV]F]HZL NV] DERPLQDFM
EXG]L]D V]HU]RQDZ UyGSRVSyOVWZDRK\GQDSORWNDR PLHODM FDVL V]XNDZ
&HVDUVWZLHLQVW\JDWRUyZW\FK]EURGQL
8M FLHU]HF]\ZLVW\FKLQVW\JDWRUyZSRZLHG]LDZROQR'LMNVWUDSRR \ NUHV
SORWNRPPLHMP\QDG]LHM $XM FLHLFKLZ\PLHU]HQLHVSUDZLHGOLZR FLWRVSUDZD
F]DVX
-XVWLWLDIXQGDPHQWDPLUHJQRPPSU]\]QDSRZD QLH6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUOHQ
$ FULPHQKRUULELOLVQRQSRWHVWQRQHVVHSXQLELOH=DU F]DP H -HJR&HVDUVND0R
UyZQLH SUDJQLHE\WDNVL VWDR
-HVWZPRF\FHVDU]DVSHQLWRSUDJQLHQLHU]XFL-RGQLHFKFHQLD'LMNVWUD
NU]\ XM F UDPLRQDQDSLHUVL-HGQD]SU]\ZyGF]\ VSLVNX(QLGDQ*OHDPLDGR
QLHGDZQDF]DURG]LHMND)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLU]FHVDUVNLHMDZ\EDZLVL Z NUyORZ
PDULRQHWNRZHJRSD VWZDHOIyZZ'RO%ODWKDQQD
-HJR&HVDUVND:\VRNR XNRQLVL V]W\ZQRDPEDVDGRUQLHPR H PLHV]D
VL GRVSUDZ'RO%ODWKDQQDQLH]DOH QHJRNUyOHVWZDX]QDQHJRSU]H]ZV]\VWNLH
V VLDGXM FHPRFDUVWZD
$OHQLHSU]H]5HGDULL 'OD5HGDQLL'RO%ODWKDQQDWRQDGDOF] NUyOHVWZD
$HGLUQ&KRZHVSy]HOIDPL6DHGZHQUR]HEUDOL FLH$HGLUQQDV]WXNLFKR]/\ULL
QLH]RVWDODSLVVXSHUODSLGHP]E\WZF]H QLHVNUH ODFLHWHNUyOHVWZD]PDS\ ZLDWD
=E\WZF]H QLHHNVFHOHQFMR-HGQDNQLHF]DVLQLHPLHMVFHG\VNXWRZDRW\P1LHFK
)UDQFDHHVFD)LQGDEDLUNUyOXMHVRELHQDUD]LHQDVSUDZLHGOLZR SU]\MG]LHSRUD$
FR]LQQ\PLUHEHOLDQWDPLLRUJDQL]DWRUDPL]DPDFKXQDNUyOD9L]LPLUD"&R]
9LOJHIRUW]HP]5RJJHYHHQFR]<HQQHIHU]9HQJHUEHUJX"6 SRGVWDZ\E\
PQLHPD H SRNO VFHSXF]XRE\GZRMH]ELHJOLGR1LOIJDDUGX
=DSHZQLDPXQLyVJRZ DPDEDVDGRU H WDNQLHMHVW$JG\E\GRWHJR
GRV]R]DU F]DP H QLHPLQLHLFKNDUD
1LHZREHFZDV]DZLQLOLQLHGRZDVWHG\QDOH \ LFKNDUDQLH6]F]HUHSUDJQLHQLH
VSUDZLHGOLZR FLE G FHMZV]DNIXQGDPHQWRPUHJQRLXPFHVDU](PK\U
XGRZRGQLE\Z\GDM F QDPSU]HVW SFyZ
1LHPR QDRGPyZLVXV]QR FLZDV]HPX GDQLXSU]\]QD6KLODUG)LW]
2HVWHUOHQXGDM F ]DNRSRWDQ\ PLHFK2VyEW\FKMHGQDNQLHPDZ&HVDUVWZLHWR
SULPR6HFXQGRJG\E\QDZHWWDPWUDIL\WRLVWQLHMHLPSHGLZI6:W(NVWUDG\FML
GRNRQXMHVL ] Z\URNXSUDZDZGDQ\PSU]\SDGNXIHURZDQHJRSU]H]UDG
FHVDUVN =ZD FLHZDV]DZLHOPR QR H ]HUZDQLHSU]H]5HGDQL VWRVXQNyZ
G\SORPDW\F]Q\FKWRDNWQLHSU]\MD]Q\DWUXGQROLF]\QDWRE\UDGDSU]HJRVRZDD
HNVWUDG\FM RVyESRV]XNXM F\FKD]\OXMH OLWHMHNVWUDG\FML GDNUDMQLHSU]\MD]Q\
%\DE\WRU]HF]EH]SUHFHGHQVX&K\ED HE\
HE\FR"
HE\VWZRU]\SUHFHGHQV
1LHUR]XPLHP
-H HOLNUyOHVWZR5HGDQLLE\RE\JRWRZHZ\GDFHVDU]RZLMHJRSRGGDQHJR
XM WHJRWXSRVSROLWHJR]EURGQLDU]DFHVDU]LMHJRUDGDPLHOLE\SRGVWDZ\E\
RGZ]DMHPQLWHQJHVWGREUHMZROL
'LMNVWUDPLOF]DGXJRVSUDZLDM F ZUD HQLH H GU]HPLHOXEP\ OL
2NRJRFKRG]L"
1D]ZLVNRSU]HVW SF\DPEDVDGRUXGD H VWDUDVL SU]\SRPQLHVRELH
ZUHV]FLHVL JQ GRVDILDQRZHMWHF]NLSRGRNXPHQW:\EDF]FLHPHPRULDIUDJLOLV
HVW0DP1LHMDNL&DKLU0DZU'\IILU\QDHS&HDOODFK1LHEDKHQDQLPFL
JUDZDPLQD3RV]XNLZDQ\MHVW]DPRUGHUVWZRGH]HUFM UDSWXVSXHOODHJZDW
NUDG]LH L IDV]RZDQLHGRNXPHQWyZ8FLHNDM F SU]HGJQLHZHPFHVDU]D]ELHJ]D
JUDQLF
'R5HGDQLL"'DOHN Z\EUDGURJ
:DV]DZLHOPR QR X PLHFKQ VL OHNNR6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUOHQQLH
RJUDQLF]DZV]DN H VZ\FK]DLQWHUHVRZD OLW\ONRGR5HGDQLL1LHPDPFLHQLD
Z WSOLZR FL H JG\E\SU]HVW SFDWHQ]RVWDXM W\ZNWyU\PNROZLHN]H
VSU]\PLHU]RQ\FKNUyOHVWZZDV]DZLHOPR QR ZLHG]LDDE\RW\P]UDSRUWyZ
VZ\FKOLF]Q\FK]QDMRP\FK
-DNPyZLOL FLH]ZLHVL yZ]EURG]LH "
&DKLU0DZU'\IILU\QDHS&HDOODFK
'LMNVWUDPLOF]DGXJRXGDM F H V]XNDZSDPL FL
1LHSRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLH1LHXM WRQLNRJRRWDNLPLPLHQLX
'RSUDZG\"
0RMDPHPRULDQLHE\ZDIUDJLOLVZWDNLFKVSUDZDFK DXM HNVFHOHQFMR
-DUyZQLH RGU]HNORGRZDWR6KLODUG)LW]2HVWHUKQ=ZDV]F]DWHJR H
Z]DMHPQDHNVWUDG\FMDSU]HVW SFyZQLHZ\GDMHVL Z WDNLFKZDUXQNDFKPR OLZDGR
SU]HSURZDG]HQLD1LHE G GX HMQX \ZDV]HMPLR FL
\F] ]GURZLDLSRZRG]HQLD
:]DMHPQLH HJQDPHNVFHOHQFMR
$PEDVDGRUZ\V]HGZ\NRQDZV]\NLONDVNRPSOLNRZDQ\FKFHUHPRQLDOQ\FK
XNRQyZ
3RFDXMPQLHZVHPSLWHPXPPHDPFK\WUXVLH]DPUXF]D'LMNVWUDNU]\ XM F
UDPLRQDQDSLHUVL2UL
6HNUHWDU]F]HUZRQ\RGGXJRSRZVWU]\P\ZDQHJRFKU] NDQLDLSRNDV\ZDQLD
Z\RQLVL ]]DNRWDU\
&]\)LOLSSDZFL VLHG]LZ0RQWHFDOYR"
7DNKHPKHP6 ] QL SDQLH/DX[$QWLOOH0HULJROGL0HW]
=DG]LH OXEGZDPR H Z\EXFKQ ZRMQD]DFKZLO JUDQLFDQD-DUXG]H
]DSRQLHDWH]DV]\\VL Z MDNLP G]LNLP]DPF]\VND%LHU]SLyURSLV]
8PLRZDQD)LO&KROHUD
1DSLVDHP'URJD)LOLSSR
'REU]H3LV]GDOHM0R H &L ]DLQWHUHVXMH H FXGDNZKHPLH]SLyUDPLNWyU\
] 7KDQHGG]QLNQ UyZQLHWDMHPQLF]RMDNVL SRMDZLQD]\ZDVL &DKLU0DZU
'\IIU\QLMHVWV\QHPVHQHV]DOD&HDOODFKD']LZQHJRWHJRRVREQLNDSRV]XNXMHP\
QLHW\ONRP\DOHMDNVL RND]XMHUyZQLH VX E\9DWWLHUDGH5LGHDX[LOXG]LHWHJR
VNXUZ\V\QD
3DQL)LOLSSDKHPKHPQLHOXELWDNLFKVyZ1DSLVDHPWHMNDQDOLL
1LHFKE G]LHWHMNDQDOLL6WHIDQD6NHOOHQD:LHV]]D UyZQLHGREU]HMDNMD
GURJD)LO H VX E\Z\ZLDGRZF]H(PK\UDSLOQLHSRV]XNXM W\ONRW\FKDJHQWyZL
HPLVDULXV]\NWyU\P(PK\USRSU]\VL J]DODVDGD]DVNyU 7DNLFKNWyU]\PLDVW
Z\NRQDUR]ND]OXE]JLQ ]GUDG]LOLLUR]ND]XQLHZ\NRQDOL5]HF]Z\JO GD]DWHP
GR G]LZQLHZV]DN H E\OL P\SHZQL H UR]ND]\WHJR&DKLUDGRW\F]\\SRMPDQLD
NVL QLF]NL&LULOOLLGRVWDUF]HQLDMHMGR1LOIJDDUGX$NDSLW']LZQHDF]
X]DVDGQLRQHSRGHMU]HQLDNWyUHWDVSUDZDZ]EXG]LDZHPQLHRUD]QLHFR
]DVNDNXM FHDF]QLHSR]EDZLRQHVHQVXWHRULHNWyUHPDPFKFLDE\P
SU]HG\VNXWRZD]7RE Z F]WHU\RF]\=Z\UD]DPLJ ERNLHJRXV]DQRZDQLDHW
FHWHUDHWFHWHUD
3RMHFKDDQDSRXGQLHSURVWRMDNVWU]HOLQDMSLHUZEU]HJLHP:VW NLSU]H]
:\SDODQLDSy QLHMSU]HSUDZLZV]\VL SU]H]U]HN SRGPRN\PLZ ZR]DPL
]DURV\PLPL FLXWNLPMDVNUDZR]LHORQ\PG\ZDQHPSRQQLND=DNDGDD H
:LHG PLQQLH]QDM F WHUHQXWDNGREU]HMDNRQDQLHE G]LHU\]\NRZDSU]HSUDZ\
QDOXG]NLEU]HJ FLQDM F SRW Q\Z\EU]XV]RQ\ZVWURQ %URNLORQXXNU]HNLPLDD
V]DQV GRJRQLJRZRNROLFDFKNDVNDG\&HDQQ7UHLVH3RGUy XM F V]\ENRLEH]
SRVWRMyZPLDDV]DQV QDZHWJRZ\SU]HG]L
=L E\QLHP\OL\VL JG\G]ZRQL\1LHERQDSRXGQLX]DFKPXU]\RVL
Z\UD QLH3RZLHWU]HVWDRVL J VWHLFL NLHNRPDU\LJ]\]UREL\VL Z\M WNRZR
QDWU WQHLGRNXF]OLZH
*G\ZMHFKDDZ J]DUR QL W\REZLHV]RQ ]LHORQ\PLMHV]F]HRU]HFKDPL
OHV]F]\Q L JR\PF]DUQLDZ\PV]DNDNLHPSRF]XDREHFQR 1LHXV\V]DD
3RF]XD:LHG]LDDZL F H WRHOI\
:VWU]\PDDNRQLDE\XNU\FLZJ V]F]XXF]QLF\PLHOLPR OLZR GREU]HVL MHM
SU]\MU]H:VWU]\PDDWH RGGHFK:QDG]LHL H QLHWUDILDQDSRS GOLZ\FK
1DGSU]HZLHV]RQ\PSU]H]]DGNRQLDNR]LRNLHPEU] F]DDPXFKD
6]HOHVW&LFKHJZL]GQL FLH=DJZL]GDDZRGSRZLHG]L6FRLD
WDHOQLF]\PGXFK\
Z\RQLOLVL ] ]DUR OLD0LOYDGRSLHURZyZF]DVRGHWFKQ DVZRERGQLHM=QDDLFK
1DOH HOLGRNRPDQGD&RLQQHDFKD'R%HR
+DHOSRZLHG]LDD]VLDGDM F4XH
VVYD"
1H
VVRGU]HNVXFKRHOINWyUHJRLPLHQLDQLHSDPL WDD&DHPP
2SRGDOQDSRODQFHRER]RZDOLLQQL%\RLFKFRQDMPQLHMWU]\G]LHVWXZL FHMQL
OLF]\RNRPDQGR&RLQQHDFKD0LOYD]G]LZLDVL 2VWDWQLPLF]DV\RGG]LD\
:LHZLyUHNWRSQLD\UDF]HMQL URV\2VWDWQLPLF]DV\VSRW\NDQHNRPDQGDE\\
JUXSDPLSRNUZDZLRQ\FK]JRU F]NRZDQ\FKOHGZRWU]\PDM F\FKVL Z VLRGDFKL
QDQRJDFKREV]DUSD FyZ7RNRPDQGRE\RLQQH
&HDG&RLQQHDFKSR]GURZLD]EOL DM FHJRVL GRZyGF
&HDGPLOVRU
FD
6RU
FD6LRVWU]\F]ND7DNM QD]\ZDOLFL]NWyU\PLE\DZSU]\MD QLJG\FKFLHOL
Z\UD]LV]DFXQHNLV\PSDWL ,WR H SU]HFLH E\OLRGQLHMZLHOHZLHOH]LPVWDUVL=
SRF] WNXE\DGODHOIyZW\ONR'K
RLQHF]RZLHNLHP3y QLHMJG\MX UHJXODUQLHLP
SRPDJDDPyZLOLQDQL $HQ:RHGEHDQQDQLHZLDVWD]ODVX-HV]F]HSy QLHM
SR]QDZV]\OHSLHMZ]RUHPGULDG]ZDOLM 0LOY .DQL -HMSUDZG]LZHLPL NWyUH
Z\MDZLDDQDMEDUG]LHM]DSU]\MD QLRQ\PRGZ]DMHPQLDM F SRGREQHJHVW\]LFK
VWURQ\QLHSDVRZDRLPZ\PDZLDOLMH0HDU
\D]FLHQLHPJU\PDVXMDNJG\E\Z
LFKPRZLHQLHDGQLHLPVL NRMDU]\R,]DUD]SU]HFKRG]LOLQDVRU
FD
'RN G WR]PLHU]DFLH"0LOYDUR]HMU]DDVL EDF]QLHMDOHQDGDOQLHGRVWU]HJDD
UDQQ\FKDQLFKRU\FK1DVP 0LO " 'R%URNLORQX"
1LH
3RZVWU]\PDDVL RGGDOV]\FKS\WD ]QDDLFK]E\WGREU]H:\VWDUF]\RMHM
W\ONRNLONXVSRMU]H QDQLHUXFKRPHVW DHWZDU]HQDSU]HVDGQ\GHPRQVWUDF\MQ\
VSRNyM]MDNLPSRU] GNRZDOLHNZLSXQHNLEUR 'R E\RMHGQHJRXZD QHJR
VSRMU]HQLDZJ ERNLHEH]GHQQHRF]\:LHG]LDD H V]OLGRZDONL
2GSRXGQLDQLHERFLHPQLDRFKPXU]\RVL
$GRN G W\]PLHU]DV]VRU
FD"VS\WD&RLQQHDFKSRWHPV]\ENRU]XFLRNLHP
QDSU]HZLHV]RQHJRSU]H]NRQLDNR]DX PLHFKQ VL OHNNR
1DSRXGQLHFKRGQRZ\SURZDG]LDJR]E GX'ULHVFKRW
(OISU]HVWDVL X PLHFKD
/XG]NLPEU]HJLHP"
3U]\QDMPQLHMGR&HDQQ7FHLVHZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPL3U]\NDVNDGDFK
SHZQLNLHPZUyF QDEURNLOR VN VWURQ ER
2GZUyFLDVL V\V] F FKUDSDQLHNRQL1RZL6FRLD
WDHOGR F]DOLGRLWDNMX
QLH]Z\NOHOLF]QHJRNRPDQGD7\FKQRZ\FK0LOYD]QDDMHV]F]HOHSLHM
&LDUDQNU]\NQ DFLFKRQLHNU\M F ]GXPLHQLD7RUXYLHO&RZ\WXURELFLH"
/HGZRFRPZDVSU]HSURZDG]LDGR%URNLORQXDZ\]QyZ
(VV
FUHDVDVRU
FDSRZLHG]LDSRZD QLH&LDUDQDHS'HDUEK6SRZLMDM F\
JRZ HOIDEDQGD SODPLDV F] FDVL NUHZ
7DNWU]HEDSRZWyU]\D]DQLP7RUXYLHO]VLDGDM F RVWUR QLHE\QLHXUD]L
]JL WHJRZWHPEODNXUDPLHQLD3U]\V]\ZLH FL1LHPR HP\WNZLZ%URNLORQLH
JG\OLF]\VL ND G\XN
*G\E\PE\DZLHG]LDDZ\G DZDUJLQLHWUXG]LDE\PVL GODZDV1LH
QDGVWDZLDDE\PNDUNXQDSU]HSUDZLH
:LH FLSU]\V]\ZF]RUDMZQRF\Z\MD QLDFLFKR7RUXYLHO1LHPRJOL P\
1LHPR HP\ZWDNLHMFKZLOL]RVWDZLQDV]\FKWRZDU]\V]\EURQL1LHPR HP\
]UR]XPWRVRU
FD
1LHERFLHPQLDRFRUD]EDUG]LHM7\PUD]HP0LOYDZ\UD QLHXV\V]DDGDOHNL
JURP
1LHMHG QDSRXGQLHVRU
FDSRZLHG]LD&RLQQHDFK'H5HR1DGFKRG]L
EXU]D
$Fy PQLHEXU]DPR HXUZDDVSRMU]DDQDQLHJRXZD QLHM+D$ZL F
WRWDNLHZLH FLZDVGRV]\"1LOIJDDUGWDN"3U]HNUDF]DM -DUXJ Z 6RGGHQ"
8GHU]DM QD%UXJJH"'ODWHJRZ\UXV]DFLH"
1LHRGSRZLHG]LD
7DNMDNZ'RO$QJUDVSRMU]DDZMHJRFLHPQHRF]\=QRZXQLOIJDDUG]NL
FHVDU]SRVX \ VL ZDPLE\ FLHOXG]LRPP W QDW\DFKF]\QLOLPLHF]HPDRJQLHP
$ Sy QLHMFHVDU]PLU]NUyODPL]DZU]HDZDVZ\WXN :RJQLXNWyU\Z]QLHFLFLH
VDPL]JRU]HMHFLH
2JLH RF]\V]F]D,KDUWXMH7U]HEDSU]H]H SU]HM $HQ\HO)KDHOHOO
HDVRU
FD"
3RZDV]HPXFKU]HVWRJQLD
0LOV]\PLLQQ\RJLH 0LOYDRGWURF]\DNR]DL]ZDOLDJRQD]LHPL SRGQRJL
HOIyZ7DNLNWyU\SRGUR HQNLHPWU]DVND0DFLHE\ FLHZSRFKRG]LH]JRGXQLH
RVDEOL0QLHMX QLHSRWU]HEQ\
1LHMHG]LHV]QDSRXGQLH"
-DG
-DG SRP\ ODDMDG V]\ENR0XV] RVWU]HFWHJRJXSWDNDZLHG PLQDPXV]
XSU]HG]LZMDN ]DZLHUXFK VL SDNXMH0XV] JR]DZUyFL
1LHMHG VRU
FD
'DM H PLSRNyM&RLQQHDFK
1DGFKRG]LEXU]DRGSRXGQLDSRZWyU]\HOI,G]LHZLHONDQDZDQLFD,ZLHONL
RJLH 6FKUR VL Z %URNLORQLHVLRVWU]\F]NRQLHMHG QDSRXGQLH=URELD GODQDV
GR ZL FHMMX QLHPR HV],QLHPXVLV]0\PXVLP\(VV
WHGGHVVHFUHDVD1D
QDVF]DV HJQDM
3RZLHWU]HE\RFL NLHLJ VWH
=DNO FLHWHOHSURMHNF\MQHE\RVNRPSOLNRZDQHPXVLD\MHU]XFDZVSyOQLH
] F]\ZV]\GRQLHLP\ OL1DZHWZyZF]DVRND]DRVL H WRGLDEHOQLHGX \
Z\VLHN%RWH L RGOHJR E\DQLHPDD=DFL QL WHSRZLHNL)LOLSS\(LOKDUW
]DGUJD\7ULVV0HULJROGG\V]DDQDZ\VRNLHF]RR.HLU\0HW]SRWZ\VW SLL
NURSODPL7\ONRQDWZDU]\0DUJDULW\/DX[$QWLOOHQLH]QDE\R]P F]HQLD
:VN SRR ZLHWORQHMNRPQDFLH]URELRVL QDJOHEDUG]RMDVQRSRFLHPQHM
ERD]HULL FLDQ]DWD F]\DPR]DLNDUR]E\VNyZ1DGRNU J\PVWRHP]DZLVD
MDU] FDVL POHF]Q\PEODVNLHPNXOD)LOLSSD(LOKDUWZ\VNDQGRZDDNR FyZN
]DNO FLDDNXODRSDGDQDSU]HFLZQDMHGQR]GZXQDVWXXVWDZLRQ\FKZRNyVWRX
NU]HVH:HZQ WU]NXOLSRMDZLDVL QLHZ\UD QDSRVWD2EUD]GUJDSURMHNFMDE\D
QLH]E\WVWDELOQD$OHV]\ENRVWDZDDVL Z\UD QLHMV]D
-DVQDFKROHUDPUXNQ D.HLUDRFLHUDM F F]RR&]\RQLWDPZ1LOIJDDUG]LH
QLH]QDM JODPDU\HDQLF]DUyZXSL NV]DM F\FK"
1DMZLGRF]QLHMQLHVWZLHUG]LD7ULVVN WHPXVW2PRG]LHWH FK\EDQLJG\QLH
V\V]HOL
$QLRF]\P WDNLPMDNPDNLMD SRZLHG]LDDFLFKR)LOLSSD$OHWHUD]V]D
G]LHZF]\Q\,QLHJDSFLHVL QDQL 7U]HEDXVWDELOL]RZDSURMHNFM L SRZLWD
QDV]HJRJR FLD:]PRFQLMPQLH5LWD
]DPNX-DNRLQLFMDWRUNDVSRWNDQLDLJRVSRG\QLSR]ZRO VRELHGRNRQDSUH]HQWDFML
3RPRMHMSUDZHM]DVLDGD0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWLOOHUHNWRUNDDNDGHPLLZ$UHWX]LH3R
PRMHMOHZHM7ULVV0HULJROG]0DULERUXL.HLUD0HW]]&DUUHUDV'DOHM6DEULQD
*OH\LVVLJ]$UG&DUUDLJK6KHDODGH7DQFDQGOOHSU]\E\D]&UH\GHQ].RYLUX
)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLU]QDQDWH MDNR(QLGDQ*OHDQQDREHFQDZDGF]\QL'ROLQ\
.ZLDWyZ,ZUHV]FLH$VVLUHYDU$QDKLG]9LFRYDURZ&HVDUVWZLH1LOIJDDUGX$
WHUD]
$WHUD]MDVL SR HJQDPZU]DVQ D6DEULQD*OHYLHVLJZVND]XM F )UDQFHVN
XSLHU FLHQLRQ GRQL 3RVXQ D VL ]DGDOHNR)LOLSSD1LHPDP]DPLDUX
VLHG]LHSU]\MHGQ\PVWROH]W FKROHUQ HOIN QDZHWMDNRLOX]MD.UHZQDPXUDFKL
SRVDG]NDFK*DUVWDQJXQLH]G \DVSRZLH$WRRQDUR]ODDW NUHZ2QDL
9LOJHIRUW]
3URVLDE\PR]DFKRZDQLHIRUP)LOLSSDREXU F]ZVSDUDVL QDNUDZ G]LVWRX
,]LPQHMNUZL:\VXFKDMFLHWHJRFRPDPGRSRZLHG]HQLD2QLFZL FHMQLH
SURV] *G\VNR F] ND GD]ZDV]GHF\GXMHF]\SR]RVWDF]\RGHM 3URMHNFMD
MHVWGREURZROQDPR QDM SU]HUZDZND GHMFKZLOL-HG\QHRFRSURV] WHNWyUH
]GHF\GXM VL RGHM WRGRFKRZDQLHWDMHPQLF\RW\PVSRWNDQLX
:LHG]LDDP6DEULQDSRUXV]\DVL WDNJZDWyZQLH H QDPRPHQWZ\SDGD]
SURMHNFML6HNUHWQHVSRWNDQLH7DMQHXVWDOHQLD.UyWNRPyZL FVSLVHN,FK\ED
RF]\ZLVWHSU]HFLZNRPXZ\PLHU]RQ\&]\W\NSLV]]QDV)LOLSSD" GDV]
GRFKRZDQLDVHNUHWXSU]HGQDV]\PLNUyODPLSU]HGNROHJDPLNWyU\FKQLHX]QDD ]D
VWRVRZQHWX]DSURVL$WDPVLHG]L(QLG)LQGDEDLU]DVNL(PK\UDYDU(PUHLVD
NUyOXM FDZ'RO%ODWKDQQDZDGF]\QLHOIyZNWyU]\F]\QQLHL]EURMQLHZVSLHUDM
1LOIJDDUG0DRWHJR]H]GXPLHQLHPVWZLHUG]DPRWRQDWHMVDOLSURMHNFM
F]DURG]LHMNL]1LOIJDDUGX2GNLHG\WRF]DURG]LHMH]1LOIJDDUGXSU]HVWDOLZ\]QDZD
OHSHSRVXV]H VWZRLQLHZROQLF]\VHUZLOL]PZREHFFHVDUVNLHMZDG]\"2MDNLFK
VHNUHWDFKP\WXPyZLP\"-H OLRQDWXMHVWWR]D]JRG L ZLHG] (PK\UD=MHJR
UR]ND]X-DNRMHJRRF]\LXV]\
3U]HF] WHPXSRZLHG]LDDVSRNRMQLH$VVLUHYDU$QDKLG1LNWQLHZLH H
XF]HVWQLF] Z W\PVSRWNDQLX%\DPSURV]RQDRGRFKRZDQLHWDMHPQLF\
GRFKRZDDPMHMLGRFKRZDP7DN H ZPRLPZDVQ\PLQWHUHVLH%RJG\E\WR
Z\V]RQDMDZQLHXQLRVDE\PFDRJRZ\1DW\PERZLHPRSLHUDVL VHUZLOL]P
F]DURG]LHMyZZ&HVDUVWZLH0DM GRZ\ERUXVHUZLOL]POXEV]DIRW3RGM DP
U\]\NR3U]HF] MDNRE\PSU]\E\DWXZFKDUDNWHU]HV]SLHJD8GRZRGQLPRJ WR
Z MHGHQW\ONRVSRVyEZDVQ PLHUFL :\VWDUF]\]DPDWDMHPQLF RNWyU
DSHOXMHSDQL(LOKDUW:\VWDUF]\E\ZLH RQDV]\PVSRWNDQLXZ\V]D]DWHPXU\D
VWUDF \FLH
'ODPQLH]GUDGDVHNUHWXUyZQLH PRJDE\PLHSU]\NUHNRQVHNZHQFMH
X PLHFKQ DVL XURF]R)UDQFHVFD0DV]ZVSDQLD VSRVREQR GRUHZDQ X
6DEULQR
-DUHZDQ XM VL Z LQQ\VSRVyEHOINRF]DUQHRF]\6DEULQ\]DSRQ \
]RZUy EQLH-H HOLVHNUHWZ\MG]LHQDMDZWRQLH]PRMHMZLQ\F]\QLHRVWUR QR FL
%\QDMPQLHMQLH]PRMHM
&]\W\FR VXJHUXMHV]"
2F]\ZL FLHZWU FLD)LOLSSD(LOKDUW2F]\ZL FLH H 6DEULQDVXJHUXMH
'HOLNDWQLHSU]\SRPLQDSDQLRPRPRMHMZVSySUDF\]6LJLVPXQGHP'LMNVWU -DN
JG\E\VDPDQLHPLDDNRQWDNWyZ]Z\ZLDGHPNUyOD+HQVHOWD
-HVWUy QLFDZDUNQ D6DEULQD-DQLHE\DPSU]H]WU]\ODWDNRFKDQN
+HQVHOWD$QLW\PEDUG]LHMMHJRZ\ZLDGX
'RV\WHJR=DPLONQLM
3RSLHUDPSRZLHG]LDDQDJOHJR QR6KHDODGH7DQDQ7LOOH=DPLONQLM
6DEULQR'R MX R 7KDQHGGGR V]SLHJRZVNLFKLSR]DPD H VNLFKDIHUDFK1LH
SU]\E\DPWXE\EUDXG]LDZVSRUDFKF]\Z\VXFKLZDZ]DMHPQ\FK
UHVHQW\PHQWyZL]QLHZDJ1LHMHVWHPWH ]DLQWHUHVRZDQDURO PHGLDWRUNLLMH OLZ
W\PFHOXPQLHWX]DSURV]RQRWRR ZLDGF]DP H GDUHPQ\E\WR]DFKyG=DLVWH
PDPSRGHMU]HQLD H XF]HVWQLF] GDUHPQLHLQLHSRWU]HEQLH H WUDF F]DV
Z\JRVSRGDURZDQ\]WUXGHPNRV]WHPPRMHMSUDF\EDGDZF]HM3RZVWU]\PDPVL
MHGQDNRGSUHVXSR]\FML3URSRQXM ZUHV]FLHRGGDJRV)LOLSSLH(LOKDUW
'RZLHG]P\VL QDUHV]FLHFHOXWHJR]JURPDG]HQLD3R]QDMP\UROHZMDNLFKPDP\
WXZ\VW SL:yZF]DVEH]]E\WHF]Q\FKHPRFML]DGHF\GXMHP\F]\NRQW\QXRZD
SU]HGVWDZLHQLHF]\VSX FLNXUW\Q '\VNUHFMDRNWyU SURV]RQRRF]\ZL FLH
]RERZL ]XMHQDVZV]\VWNLH=NRQVHNZHQFMDPLNWyUHMD6KHDODGH7DQFDU\LOOH
RVREL FLHZ\FL JQ ZREHFQLHG\VNUHWQ\FK
DGQD]F]DURG]LHMHNQLHSRUXV]\DVL DQLQLHRGH]ZDD7ULVVDQLSU]H]PRPHQW
QLHZ WSLDZRVWU]H HQLH6KHDOL6DPRWQLFD].RYLUXQLH]Z\NDE\DU]XFDJUy E
QDZLDWU
2GGDMHP\FLJRV)LOLSSR'RV]DFRZQHJR]JURPDG]HQLD]D ]ZUDFDPVL ]
SUR E R ]DFKRZDQLHFLV]\GRFKZLOLJG\)LOLSSDGD]QD H VNR F]\D
)LOLSSD(LOKDUWZVWDDV]HOHV]F] F VXNQL
6]DQRZQHNRQIUDWHUNLSRZLHG]LDD6\WXDFMDMHVWSRZD QD0DJLDMHVW
]DJUR RQD7UDJLF]QHZ\GDU]HQLDQD7KDQHGGGRNWyU\FKSRZUDFDPP\ O ] DOHP
L QLHFK FL GRZLRG\ H HIHNW\VHWHNODWSR]RUQLHEH]NRQIOLNWRZHMZVSySUDF\Z
PJQLHQLXRNDSRV]\QDPDUQHJG\GRJRVXGRV]\SU\ZDWDLZ\JyURZDQH
DPELFMH2EHFQLHPDP\UR]EUDWEH]DGZ]DMHPQ ZURJR LQLHXIQR 7RFRVL
G]LHMH]DF]\QDZ\P\NDVL VSRGNRQWUROL$E\NRQWURO RG]\VNDDE\QLH
GRSX FLGR \ZLRRZHJRNDWDNOL]PXQDOH \ Z]L ZPRFQHU FHVWHUWHJR
WDUJDQHJRV]WRUPHPRNU WX-DSDQL/DX[$QWLOOHSDQL0HULJROGLSDQL0HW]
SU]HG\VNXWRZD\ P\MX W VSUDZ L MHVWH P\]JRGQH2GEXGRZDQLH]QLV]F]RQ\FK
QD7KDQHGG.DSLWX\L5DG\QLHZ\VWDUF]\1LHPD]UHV]W ] NRJRRGEXGRZ\ZD
REXW\FKLQVW\WXFMLQLHPDJZDUDQFML H RGEXGRZDQHQLHE G RGSRF] WNX
]DUD RQHFKRURE NWyUD]QLV]F]\DSRSU]HGQLH3RZLQQDSRZVWD]XSHQLHLQQD
VHNUHWQDRUJDQL]DFMDNWyUDVX \E G]LHZ\ F]QLHVSUDZRPPDJLL.WyUDXF]\QL
ZV]\VWNRE\QLHGRSX FLGRNDWDNOL]PX-H HOLERZLHP]JLQLHPDJLD]JLQLHWHQ
ZLDW7DNMDNSU]HGZLHNDPL ZLDWSR]EDZLRQ\PDJLLLQLHVLRQHJRSU]H]QL
SRVW SXSRJU \ VL Z FKDRVLHLPURNXXWRQLHZNUZLLEDUEDU]\ VWZLH:V]\VWNLH
REHFQHWXSDQLH]DSUDV]DP\GRZ]L FLDXG]LDXZQDV]HMLQLFMDW\ZLHGRDNW\ZQHJR
XF]HVWQLFWZDZSUDFDFKSURSRQRZDQHJRWDMQHJR]HVSRX3R]ZROL\ P\VRELHZDV
WXSU]\ZRDDE\XV\V]HZDV]H]GDQLHZWHMNZHVWLL6NR F]\DP
']L NXMHP\VNLQ DJRZ 6KHDODGH7DQFDU\LOOH-H HOLSDQLHSR]ZRO MD
UR]SRF]Q 3LHUZV]HPRMHS\WDQLHGURJD)LOLSSREU]PLGODF]HJRMD"'ODF]HJR
PQLHWDSU]\ZRDQR":LHORNURWQLHRGPDZLDDPZ\VXZDQLDPHMNDQG\GDWXU\GR
.DSLWX\]R \DPUH]\JQDFM ] IRWHODZ6 G]LH3RSLHUZV]HSRFKDQLDPQLHPRMD
SUDFD3RGUXJLHXZD DDPLQDGDOXZD DP H V Z .RYLU]H3RYLVVL+HQJIRUV
LQQLJRGQLHMVLW\FK]DV]F]\WyZ=DS\WXM GODF]HJR]DSURV]RQRWXPQLHDQLH
&DUGXLQD"1LH,VWUHGGD]$HGG*\Q\DHO7XJGXDODOXE=DQJHQLVD"
%RWRP F]\ QLRGU]HND)LOLSSD2UJDQL]DFMDRNWyUHMPyZLDPPD]D
VNDGDVL Z\ F]QLH]NRELHW3DQL$VVLUH"
:\FRIXM PRMHS\WDQLHX PLHFKQ DVL QLOIJDDUG]NDF]DURG]LHMND%\R
]ELH QHZWUH FL]S\WDQLHPSDQL'H7DQFDU\LOOH2GSRZLHG PQLHVDW\VIDNFMRQXMH
7U FLPLWREDEVNLPV]RZLQL]PHPSRZLHG]LDD]SU]HN VHP6DEULQD
*OHYLVVLJ=ZDV]F]DZWZRLFKXVWDFK)LOLSSDSRWZRMHM]PLDQLHRULHQWDFML
HURW\F]QHM-DQLHPDPQLFSU]HFLZP F]\]QRP:L FHMMDXZLHOELDPP F]\]QL
\FLDVRELHEH]QLFKQLHZ\REUD DP$OH3RFKZLOL]DVWDQRZLHQLD7RZVXPLH
MHVWVXV]QDNRQFHSFMD0 F]\ QLV SV\FKLF]QLHQLHVWDELOQL]E\WSRGDWQLQD
HPRFMHQLHPR QDQDQLFKOLF]\ZPRPHQWDFKNU\]\VX
7RIDNWSU]\]QDDVSRNRMQLH0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWLOOH6WDOHSRUyZQXM
Z\QLNLDGHSWHN$UHWX]\]HIHNWDPLSUDF\FKRSFyZ]HV]NR\Z%DQ$UGD
SRUyZQDQLHZ\SDGDQLHRGPLHQQLHQDNRU]\ G]LHZF] W0DJLDWRFLHUSOLZR
GHOLNDWQR LQWHOLJHQFMDUR]ZDJDZ\WUZDR WDN H SRNRUQHOHF]VSRNRMQH
]QRV]HQLHSRUD HNLQLHSRZRG]H 0 F]\]QJXELDPELFMD2QL]DZV]HFKF WHJR
R F]\PZLHG] H WRQLHPR OLZHLQLHRVL JDOQH$PR OLZHJRQLH]DXZD DM
'RV\GRV\GRV\ DFKQ DVL 6KHDODQLHNU\M F 8 PLHFKX1LHPDQLF
JRUV]HJRQL QDXNRZRSRGEXGRZDQ\V]RZLQL]PZVW\G VL 5LWD:V]HODNR
7DNMDUyZQLH XZD DP]DU]HF]VXV]Q ]DSURSRQRZDQ MHGQRSFLRZ VWUXNWXU
WHJRNRQZHQWXF]\WH MH OLNWRZROLOR \-DNV\V]\P\FKRG]LRSU]\V]R
PDJLLDPDJLDWRVSUDZD]E\WSRZD QDE\MHMORVSRZLHU]DP F]\]QRP
-H OLPR QDRGH]ZDDVL PHORG\MQLH)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLUFKFLDDE\P
SU]HUZDQDPRPHQWG\ZDJDFMHRQDWXUDOQHMLQLHXOHJDM FHMNZHVWLLGRPLQDFML
QDV]HMSFLDVNXSLVL QDVSUDZDFKGRW\F] F\FK]DSURSRQRZDQHMLQLFMDW\Z\FHO
NWyUHMQDGDOQLHGRNR FDMHVWGODPQLHMDVQ\$FKZLODQLHMHVWSU]\SDGNRZDL
EXG]LVNRMDU]HQLD7UZDZRMQD1LOIJDDUGSRJURPLLSU]\SDUSyQRFQHNUyOHVWZD
GRPXUX&]\]DWHPSRGRJyOQLNRZ\PLKDVDPLMDNLHWXV\V]DDPQLHNU\MHVL
]UR]XPLDDFK E\V\WXDFM RGZUyFL"%\SRJURPLLSU]\SU]HGRPXUX
1LOIJDDUG"$Sy QLHMGREUDVL GRVNyU\]XFKZD\PHOIRP"-H OLWDNMHVWGURJD
)LOLSSRWRQLH]QDMG]LHP\SDV]F]\]Q\SRUR]XPLHQLD
&]\WRMHVWSRZyGGODNWyUHJRMD]RVWDDPWX]DSURV]RQD"VS\WDD$VVLUHYDU
$QDKLG1LHSR ZL FDPZLHOHXZDJLSROLW\FHDOHZLHP H DUPLDFHVDUVNDRGQRVL
Z ZRMQLHSU]HZDJLQDGZDV]\PLZRMVNDPL3R]DSDQL )UDQFHVN L SR]DSDQL GH
7DQFDUYLOOHSRFKRG] F ] NUyOHVWZDQHXWUDOQHJRZV]\VWNLHSDQLHUHSUH]HQWXM
NUyOHVWZDZURJLH&HVDUVWZX1LOIJDDUG]NLHPX-DNPDPUR]XPLHVRZDR
PDJLF]QHMVROLGDUQR FL"-DNR]DFK W GR]GUDG\"3U]\NURPLDOHQLHZLG] VL Z
WDNLHMUROL
6NR F]\ZV]\SU]HPRZ $VVLUHSRFK\OLDVL MDNE\GRW\NDDF]HJR FRQLH
PLH FLRVL Z SURMHNFML7ULVV]GDZDRVL H V\V]\PLDXF]HQLH
2QDPDMHV]F]HNRWDV]HSQ D.HLUD0HW]=DR VL H F]DUQHJR
&LV]HMV\NQ D)LOLSSD'URJD)UDQFHVNRV]DQRZQD$VVLUH1DV]D
LQLFMDW\ZDPDE\DEVROXWQLHDSROLW\F]QDWRMHVWMHMSRGVWDZRZH]DR HQLH
.LHURZDVL E G]LHP\QLHLQWHUHVDPLUDVNUyOHVWZNUyOyZLLPSHUDWRUyZOHF]
GREUHPPDJLLLMHMSU]\V]R FL
.LHUXM F VL GREUHPPDJLL6DEULQD*OH\LVVLJX PLHFKQ DVL V]\GHUF]RQLH
]DSRPQLP\FK\EDMHGQDNRGREURE\FLHPDJLF]HN"$SU]HFLH ZLHP\MDN
WUDNWRZDQLV F]DURG]LHMHZ1LOIJDDUG]LH0\WXVRELHE G]LHP\DSROLW\F]QLH
JDGDDJG\1LOIJDDUG]Z\FL \ LGRVWDQLHP\VL SRGFHVDUVN ZDG] ZV]\VWNLH
E G]LHP\Z\JO GDWDNMDN
7ULVVSRUXV]\DVL QLHVSRNRMQLH)LOLSSDOHGZLHV\V]DOQLHZHVWFKQ D.HLUD
RSX FLDJRZ 6KHDODXGDD H SRSUDZLDERD)UDQFHVFDSU]\JU\]DZDUJ 7ZDU]
$VVLUHYDU$QDKLGQLHGUJQ DDOHSRNU\DVL OHNNLPUXPLH FHP
:V]\VWNLH]QDVVSRWNDPDUQ\ORVFKFLDDPSRZLHG]LHGRNR F]\DV]\ENR
6DEULQD)LOLSSD7ULVVLMDZV]\VWNLHWU]\E\\ P\QD:]JyU]X6RGGHQ(PK\U
UR]OLF]\VL ] QDPL]DWDPW NO VN ]D7KDQHGG]DFDRNV]WDWQDV]HMG]LDDOQR FL
$OHWRW\ONRMHGQR]]DVWU]H H NWyUHEXG]LZHPQLHGHNODURZDQDDSROLW\F]QR
WHJRNRQZHQWX&]\XG]LDZQLPR]QDF]DQDW\FKPLDVWRZ UH]\JQDFM ] F]\QQHML
SROLW\F]QHMZV]DNVX E\NWyU REHFQLHSHQLP\SU]\QDV]\FKNUyODFK"&]\WH
PDP\ZWHMVX ELHSR]RVWDLVX \GZyPSDQLRPPDJLLLZDG]\"
-DX PLHFKQ DVL )UDQFHVFDJG\NWR NRPXQLNXMHPL H MHVWDSROLW\F]Q\
]DZV]HS\WDPNWyU ] SROLW\NNRQNUHWQLHPDQDP\ OL
$MDZLHP H ]SHZQR FL QLHPDQDP\ OLWHMNWyU SURZDG]LSRZLHG]LDD
$VVLUHYDU$QDKLGSDWU] F QD)LOLSS
-DMHVWHPDSROLW\F]QDXQLRVDJRZ 0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWL,OH,PRMDV]NRD
MHVWDSROLW\F]QD0DPQDP\ OLZV]\VWNLHW\S\URG]DMHLJDWXQNLSROLW\NLMDNLH
LVWQLHM
'URJLHSDQLHRGH]ZDDVL PLOF] FDRGGX V]HMFKZLOL6KHDOD3DPL WDMFLH
H MHVWH FLHSFL GRPLQXM F 1LH]DFKRZXMFLHVL ZL F MDNG]LHZF]\QNL
Z\V]DUSXM FHVRELHSU]H]VWyWDF ] DNRFLDPL=DSURSRQRZDQHSU]H])LOLSS
SULQFLSLXPMHVWZV]DN H MDVQH3U]\QDMPQLHMGODPQLHDZFL ]DPDRPDP
SRGVWDZE\XZD DZDV]DPQLHME\VWUH3R]DW VDO E G FLHNLPFKFHFLHVX FLH
NRPXFKFHFLHLF]HPXFKFHFLHWDNZLHUQLHMDN]HFKFHFLH$OHJG\NRQZHQWVL
]ELHU]H]DMPRZDE G]LHP\VL Z\ F]QLHPDJL L MHMSU]\V]R FL
7DNZD QLHWRVRELHZ\REUD DPSRWZLHUG]LD)LOLSSD(LOKDUW:LHP H
SUREOHPyZMHVWZLHOH H V Z WSOLZR FLLQLHMDVQR FL2PyZLP\MHSU]\
QDVW SQ\PVSRWNDQLXZNWyU\PZV]\VWNLHZH PLHP\XG]LDQLHZSRVWDFL
SURMHNFMLF]\LOX]MLOHF]ZHZDVQ\FKRVREDFK2EHFQR X]QDQDE G]LHQLH]D
IRUPDOQ\DNWSU]\VW SLHQLDGRNRQZHQWXOHF]]DJHVWGREUHMZROL2W\PF]\WDNL
NRQZHQWZRJyOHSRZVWDQLH]DGHF\GXMHP\ZVSyOQLH0\ZV]\VWNLH1DUyZQ\FK
SUDZDFK
0\ZV]\VWNLH"SRZWyU]\D6KHDOD:LG] WXSXVWHNU]HVD]DNDGDP H QLH
XVWDZLRQRLFKSU]\SDGNRZR
.RQZHQWSRZLQLHQOLF]\GZDQD FLHF]DURG]LHMHN&KFLDDE\PDE\
NDQG\GDWN QDMHGQR]W\FKSXVW\FKNU]HVH]DSURSRQRZDDQDPLSU]HGVWDZLDQD
QDVW SQ\PVSRWNDQLXSDQL$VVLUH:&HVDUVWZLH1LOIJDDUGX]QDMG]LHVL ]
SHZQR FL MHV]F]HMHGQDJRGQDF]DURG]LHMND'UXJLHPLHMVFH]RVWDZLDPGRREVDG\
WRELH)UDQFHVFDE\ MDNRMHG\QDF]\VWHMNUZLHOINDQLHF]XDVL RVDPRWQLRQD
7U]HFLH(QLGDQ*OHDQQDXQLRVDJRZ
3URV] R GZDPLHMVFD0DPGZLHNDQG\GDWXU\
&]\NWyUD ] SD PDFR SU]HFLZWHMSUR ELH"-H OLQLHMDWH VL ]JDG]DP
0DP\G]L SL W\G]LH VLHUSQLDSL W\G]LH SRQRZLX6SRW\NDP\VL SRQRZQLH
GUXJLHJRGQLDSRSHQLGURJLHNRQIUDWHUNL]DF]WHUQD FLHGQL
=DUD]SU]HUZDD6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOH-HGQRPLHMVFHZFL SR]RVWDMH
SXVWH.WRPDE\GZXQDVW F]DURG]LHMN "
7RE G]LHZD QLHSLHUZV]\PSUREOHPHPNWyU\P]DMPLHVL OR D )LOLSSD
X PLHFKQ DVL WDMHPQLF]R=DGZDW\JRGQLHSRZLHPZDPNWRSRZLQLHQ]DVL
QDGZXQDVW\PNU]H OH$SRWHPZVSyOQLH]DVWDQRZLP\VL MDNVSUDZLE\WD
RVREDWX]DVLDGD=G]LZLZDVPRMDNDQG\GDWXUDLWDRVRED%RWRQLHMHVW]Z\ND
RVREDV]DQRZQHNRQIUDWHUNL7RMHVW PLHUDOER \FLH'HVWUXNFMDOXE
2GURG]HQLHDGOXE&KDRV=DOH \MDNQDWRVSRMU]H
&DDZLH Z\OHJDSU]HGSRW\E\SDWU]HQDSU]HMD]GEDQG\7X]LNZ\V]HG
ZUD]]LQQ\PL0LDURERW DOHQLHPyJVL SRZVWU]\PD2VWDWQLDZLHOHJDGDQRR
6]F]XUDFK.U \DQDZHWSORWND H ZV]\VWNLFKVFKZ\WDQRLSRZLHV]RQR3ORWND
E\DMHGQDNIDV]\ZDGRZyGGHPRQVWUDF\MQLHLEH]SR SLHFKXSDUDGRZDZD QLH
SU]HGFD ZVL
%H]F]HOQHRWU\V]HSQ NWR ]DSOHFDPL7X]LNDDE\WRV]HSWSHHQSRG]LZX
URGNLHPZVLZDO
:\VWURMHQLMDNE\QDZHVHOH
$MDNLHNRQLH,X1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZWDNLFKQLHREDF]\V]
%D]UDERZDQH6]F]XU\ZV]\VWNLPNRQLHELRU .RQLDWHUD]ZV] G\VSU]HGD
DWZR$OHQDMOHSV]HVRELHRVWDZLDM
7HQQDSU]HG]LHSDWU]DMFLHWR*LVHOKHU+HUV]WLFKQL
$SRGOHQLHJRQDNDV]WDQFHWRWDHOIND,VNUDM ZRDM
=]DSORWXZ\SDGNXQGHO]DQLyVVL V]F]HNLHPXZLMDM F VL WX SU]\SU]HGQLFK
NRS\WDFKNODF]\,VNU\(OINDSRWU] VQ DEXMQ JU]\Z FLHPQ\FKZRVyZREUyFLD
NRQLDSRFK\OLDVL PRFQRLVPDJQ DSVDQDKDMHP.XQGHO]DVNRZ\F]DL
WU]\NURWQLHREUyFLVL Z PLHMVFXD,VNUDQDSOXDQDQLHJR7X]LN]PHZ] EDFK
SU]HNOH VWZR
6WRM F\RERNV]HSWDOLQDGDOG\VNUHWQLHZVND]XM F NROHMQ\FK6]F]XUyZMDG F\FK
VW SDSU]H]ZLH 7X]LNVXFKDERPXVLD=QDSORWNLLJDGNLQLHJRU]HMQL LQQL
EH]WUXGXGRP\ ODVL H WHQ]H]PLHU]ZLRQ\PLVL JDM F\PLUDPLRQZRVDPL
NRORUXVRP\JU\] F\MDENRWR.D\OHLJK H WHQEDUF]\VW\WR$VVHDWHQZ
KDIWRZDQ\PSyNR XV]NXWR5HHI
'HILODG ]DP\ND\GZLHG]LHZF]\Q\MDG FHERNZERNLWU]\PDM FHVL ]DU FH
0LOHQD
0LOHQNDMHJRMHG\QD \M FDFyUNDMHJRRF]NRZJRZLHSU]HZLHVLDVRELHSU]H]
SOHF\SDW\NQDV]QXUNXXGDM F\PLHF]:RV\UR]SX FLDGRZHQLDQHMF]DSHF]NL
SU]\F]HSLDNRJXFLHSLyUNRQDV]\L]DPRWDDPDWF]\Q FKXVWHF]N :G]LZDF]Q
IDQWD]\MQ NRNDUG
2F]\PLDD]LHORQH
7X]LNQLJG\GRW G QLHELFyUNLQLJG\QLHURELX \WNX]RMFRZVNLHJRU]HPLHQLD
7RE\SLHUZV]\UD]
1DKRU\]RQFLHE\VQ R]DJU]PLDR3RGPXFKZLDWUXMDNEURQDSU]HRUD
SRZLHU]FKQL :VW NL% G]LHEXU]DSRP\ ODD0LOYDDSREXU]\SU]\MG]LHVRWD
=L E\QLHP\OL\VL
3RS G]LDNRQLD-H OLFKFLDDGRJRQLZLHG PLQDSU]HGEXU] PXVLDDVL
VSLHV]\
5R]G]LD
3R]QDHPZ \FLXZLHOXZRMVNRZ\FK=QDHPPDUV]DNyZJHQHUDyZ
ZRMHZRGyZLKHWPDQyZWULXPIDWRUyZOLF]Q\FKNDPSDQLLLELWHZ3U]\VXFKLZDHP
VL LFKRSRZLH FLRPLZVSRPQLHQLRP:LG\ZDHPLFKVFK\ORQ\FKQDGPDSDPL
U\VXM F\FKQDQLFKUy QRNRORURZHNUHVNLUREL F\FKSODQ\REP\ ODM F\FK
VWUDWHJLH:WHMSDSLHURZHMZRMQLHZV]\VWNRJUDRZV]\VWNRIXQNFMRQRZDR
ZV]\VWNRE\RMDVQHLZV]\VWNRZHZ]RURZ\PSRU] GNX7DNE\PXVLZ\MD QLDOL
ZRMVNRZL$UPLDWRSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPSRU] GHNLDG:RMVNRQLHPR H LVWQLHEH]
SRU] GNXLDGX
7\PG]LZQLHMV]HMHVW H SUDZG]LZDZRMQDDNLONDSUDZG]LZ\FKZRMHQ
ZLG]LDHPSRGZ]JO GHPSRU] GNXLDGXGR]XG]HQLDSU]\SRPLQDRJDUQL W\
SR DUHPEXUGHO
-DVNLHU3yZLHNXSRH]ML
5R]G]LDGUXJL
XNXNRPDUyZNDUN']LNLNUDMREUD]WHMGROLQ\GRVWDUF]DZSUDZG]LH
QLH]UyZQDQ\FKZUD H HVWHW\F]Q\FKDOHGODRGPLDQ\SRSDWU]\E\PFK WQLHQD
MDN PQLHMHVWHW\F]Q REHU :NUyWFHPLQLHW\G]LH RGNLHG\SRG]LZLDP
URPDQW\F]Q SU]\URG SHM]D H LRGOHJHKRU\]RQW\=DW VNQLHPGRZQ WU]
=ZDV]F]DWDNLFKZNWyU\FKSRGDM FLHS VWUDZ L ]LPQHSLZR
3U]\MG]LHFLSRW VNQLMHV]F]HF]DVMDNL :LHG PLQRGZUyFLVL Z VLRGOH
%\PR H ]DJRG]LWZHFLHUSLHQLD ZLDGRPR H LPQLHWURFK W VNQRGR
F\ZLOL]DFML-DNZLHV]WNZLHPZ%URNLORQLHUyZQRWU]\G]LH FLV]H GQL,QRF\Z
NWyUHURPDQW\F]QDSU]\URGD]L ELDPLW\HNSH]DDSRSOHFDFKLRVLDGDDURV QD
QRVLH+RRRRR=DUD]D=DSU]HVWDQLHV]ZUHV]FLHIRFKyZSU]HNO WDNRE\R"
% NLM NXM *DG\]UREL\VL ]DMDGHLNUZLR HUF]HMDNWRSU]HGEXU] 1D
SRXGQLXJU]PLLE\VNDFRUD]F] FLHM
=DXZD \HP:LHG PLQVSRMU]DZQLHERSRZVWU]\PXM F UR]WD F]RQHJR
NRQLD:LDWUWH MHVWLQQ\0RU]HP]DODWXMH=PLDQDSRJRG\DQLFK\EL-HG]LHP\
3RS G QRWHJRRSDVHJRZDDFKD-DVNLHU
0yMUXPDNQD]\ZDVL 3HJD]
-DN HE\LQDF]HM:LHV]FR"0RM HOIL NRE\ WH MDNR QD]ZLHP\+PPP
0R H 3RWND"]DNSLWUXEDGXU
3RWND]JRG]LVL :LHG PLQDGQLH
*HUDOW"
6XFKDP
&]\PLDH Z \FLXNRQLDNWyU\QLHQD]\ZDVL 3RWND"
1LHRGU]HN:LHG PLQSRFKZLOL]DVWDQRZLHQLD1LHPLDHP3RS G
Z\ZDDV]RQHJR3HJD]D-DVNLHU'DOHNDGURJDSU]HGQDPL
,RZV]HPEXUNQ SRHWD1LOIJDDUG,OHWRPLOZHGXJFLHELH"
'X R
'RWU]HP\SU]HG]LP "
'RWU]\MP\ZSLHUZGR9HUGHQ7DPSU]HG\VNXWXMHP\SHZQHVSUDZ\
-DNLH"1LH]QLHFK FLV]PQLHDQLQLHSR]E G]LHV]VL % G FLWRZDU]\V]\7DN
SRVWDQRZLHP
=REDF]\P\3RZLHG]LDHPGRWU]\MP\GR9HUGHQ
$GDOHNRMHV]F]H"=QDV]WHWHUHQ\"
=QDP-HVWH P\SU]\NDVNDG]LH&HDQQ7UHLVHSU]HGQDPLPLHMVFHNWyUH
QD]\ZDVL 6LyGPD0LOD7HJyUNL]DU]HN WRV 6RZLH:]JyU]D
$P\MHG]LHP\QDSRXGQLH]ELHJLHPU]HNL":VW NDZSDGDGR-DUXJLJG]LH
Z RNROLFDFKWZLHUG]\%RGURJ
3RMHG]LHP\QDSRXGQLHDOHWDPW\PEU]HJLHP:VW ND]DNU FDNX]DFKRGRZL
P\SRMHG]LHP\ODVDPL&KF GRWU]HGRPLHMVFDNWyUHQD]\ZDVL 'ULHVFKRWF]\OL
7UyMN W7DPVFKRG] VL JUDQLFH9HUGHQ%UXJJHL%URNOLRQX
$VWDPW G"
1DG-DUXJ ,GRXM FLD'R&LQWU\
$SRWHP"
$SRWHPVL ]REDF]\-H OLWRZRJyOHPR OLZH]PX WZHJRJQX QHJR3HJD]D
GRQLHFRV]\EV]HJRFKRGX
8OHZDGRSDGDLFKSRGF]DVSU]HSUDZ\QDVDP\P URGNXU]HNL1DMSLHUZ]HUZD
3U]HFLHWR1LOIJDDUGF]\NL6R F QDV]OHPDFKQLHZLG]LV]"+DIWyZQDF]DSUDNDFK"
=ELHUDMFLHVL ELHU]HPQRJL]DSDVZQHWPRJ WXGDOVLQDGFL JQ &LWXWDM
SRGMD]GHPV]OL
1LHP\ O SRNU FLJRZ HE\WRE\SRGMD]GDOERVWUD SU]HGQLD3RFR
LQQHJRWXSU]\MHFKDOL
$SRFRFLHNDZR "
3RWRZVND]DQDOH F QDZR]LHVRVQRZ WUXPQ FLHPQLD RGGHV]F]X
3DGDRMX VDELHMLSU]HVWDRJU]PLH%XU]DSU]HVXZDDVL NXSyQRF\:LHG PLQ
SRGQLyVOH F\Z UyGOL FLPLHF]ZVNRF]\QDZy]NOQ F ]FLFKDERNRODQR
ZFL MHGQDNSU]\SRPLQDRVL EyOHP
3RPy PLWRRWZRU]\
&y WRXPDUODNDFKFHV]0LOYDXUZDDZLG] F Z\ZLHUFRQHZZLHNX
RWZRU\'ROLFKD \ZHJRKD\HNDUZW\PSXGOHZLy]"
7RMDNL MHQLHF*HUDOWSRGZD \ZLHNR+DQGODU]F]HNDWXQD
1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZE\LPJRSU]HND]D:\PLHQLOLVL KDVHPLRG]HZHP
:LHNRRGHUZDRVL ] WU]DVNLHPRGVDQLDM F ]DNQHEORZDQHJRF]RZLHND
U]HPLHQQ\PLS WODPLSU]\NU SRZDQHJRGRERNyZWUXPQ\]DU FHLQRJL:LHG PLQ
SRFK\OLVL 3U]\MU]DXZD QLHM,MHV]F]HUD]MHV]F]HXZD QLHM,]DNO
1RSURV] SRZLHG]LDSU]HFL JOH$WRVLXUSU\]D.WRE\VL VSRG]LHZD"
7\JR]QDV]ZLHG PLQLH"
=ZLG]HQLDX PLHFKQ VL SDVNXGQLH6FKRZDMQy 0LOYD1LHUR]FLQDMPX
S W7RMHVWMDNZLG] ZHZQ WU]QDQLOIJDDUG]NDVSUDZD1LHSRZLQQL P\VL
ZWU FD=RVWDZLP\JRWDNMDNMHVW
&]\MDGREU]HV\V] " RGH]ZDVL ]]DLFKSOHFyZ-DVNLHU%\ZFL MHV]F]H
EODG\DOHFLHNDZR MX SU]HPRJDLQQHHPRFMH
&KFHV]]RVWDZLZOHVLH]ZL ]DQHJRF]RZLHND"'RP\ ODPVL H UR]SR]QDH
NRJR ]NLPPDV]QDSLH NXDOHWRMHVWSU]HFLH MHQLHFGRGLDED%\ZL QLHP
OXG]LNWyU]\G\EDOLQDQDVLRPDOQLH]DELOL:UyJQDV]\FKZURJyZ
8UZDZLG] F H :LHG PLQZ\FL JDQy ] FKROHZ\0LOYDFKU] NQ DFLFKR
&LHPQRE NLWQHPUX RQHGRW\FKF]DVSU]HGNURSODPLGHV]F]XRF]\]ZL ]DQHJR
UR]V]HU]\\VL *HUDOWSRFK\OLVL L UR]FL S WO ZL F MHJROHZHUDPL
6SyMU]-DVNLHUSRZLHG]LDFKZ\WDM F ]DQDGJDUVWHNLSRGQRV] F XZROQLRQ
U N :LG]LV]W V]UDP QDGRQL"7R&LULJRFL D1DZ\VSLH7KDQHGGPLHVL F
WHPX7R1LOIJDDUGF]\N3U]\MHFKDQD7KDQHGGVSHFMDOQLHSRWRE\XSURZDG]L
&LUL&L DJREURQL F VL SU]HGSRUZDQLHP
1DQLFSU]HFLH]GDDVL WDREURQDPUXNQ D0LOYD&R WXMHGQDNR WDN
VRELHP\ O NXS\VL QLHG]LHU \-H OLRQ H WZRM &LUL]RVWURZXGOD1LOIJDDUGX
SRUZDMDN PRG GRWHMWUXPQ\SRSDG"&]HPXJRKD\HNDU1LOIJDDUGF]\NRP
ZD QLHZ\GDZD"=GHMPLMPX]J E\NQHEHOZLHG PLQLH0R H QDPFRSRZLH"
:FDOHQLHFKF JRVXFKDSRZLHG]LDJXFKR-X WHUD]U NDPQLH ZLHU]EL
E\JRSFKQ JG\WDNOH \ LSDWU]\/HGZRVL KDPXM *G\VL RGH]ZLHQLH
SRKDPXM VL 1LHZV]\VWNRRQLPZDPSRZLHG]LDHP
1LHKDPXMVL WHG\0LOYDZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPL3FKQLMMH OLWDNLWR
QLHJRG]LZLHF$OHFRU\FKOHMERF]DVQDJOL0yZLDP1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZW\ONR
SDWU]H,G SRPHJRNRQLD
QDS\WDQLH-DVNUD.RQQLWR1LOIJDDUGF]\F\
$SLHVL"
3LHVLWRQLH1LOIJDDUGF]\F\
.RQQLWRUHJXODUQDMD]GD]9HUGHQSRZLHG]LDD0LOYDGRWHMSRU\SRQXUDL
SRGHMU]DQLHPDRPyZQD:\V]\WHV]DFKRZQLFHPDM QDMXNDFK$FLZHZLRVFH
WREUXJJH VNLH]DFL QHZRMDNL7RSRFKRU JZLSR]QD
:VDPHMU]HF]\UR]RFKRFHQLNROHMQ\PVXNFHVHPNQHFKFLZ]QLH OLQDGV]D FHP
]LHORQ\V]WDQGDU]ELD\PNU]\ HPNRWZLF]Q\P*HUDOWSU]\JO GDVL XZD QLHDOH
ZF]H QLHMV]WDQGDUXQLHGRVWU]HJREUR F\SRGQLH OLJRGRSLHURWHUD]:LGRF]QLH
QDSRF] WNXELWZ\JG]LH VL ]DSRG]LD
'XJRWXE G]LHP\VLHG]LH"VS\WD-DVNLHU
0DV]WRELHPUXNQ D0LOYD3\WDQLH]DGD5R]HMU]\MVL -DNVL QLH
REUyFLV]WDNU]\]W\X
-DVNLHUQLHPXVLDUR]JO GDVL DQLREUDFD&D\ZLGQRNU J SDVLDVW\E\RG
VXSyZG\PX1DMJ FLHMG\PLRQDSyQRF\L]DFKRG]LHWDPJG]LHNWyUH ] ZRMVN
SRGSDOLRODV\/LF]QHG\P\EL\WH Z QLHERQDSRXGQLXWDPGRN G ]PLHU]DOL
JG\GURJ ]DJURG]LDLPELWZD$OHZFL JXJRG]LQ\MDN VS G]LOLQDZ]JyU]X
G\P\XQLRV\VL UyZQLH QDZVFKRG]LH
:V]HODNR SRGM DXF]QLF]NDSRFKZLOLSDWU] F QD*HUDOWDWRPQLH
ZLHG PLQLHL FLHFLHNDZLFy WRWHUD]SRF] ]DP\ ODV]=DQDPL1LOIJDDUGL
SRQ FDNQLHMDFRSU]HGQDPLVDPPLDUNXMHV]-DNLHWHG\PDV]SODQ\"
0RMHSODQ\QLHXOHJ\]PLDQLH3U]HF]HNDPW ELMDW\N L UXV]DPQDSRXGQLH
1DG-DUXJ
&K\EDUR]XPX]E\H Z\NU]\ZLDVL 0LOYD3U]HFLHZLG]LV]FRVL G]LHMH
*R\PSU]HFLHRNLHPZLGD H WRQLHMDND WDPUDM]DNXSVZDZROQ\FKDOHZRMQD
FRVL ]RZLH1LOIJDDUGSRVSRX]9HUGHQLG]LH1DSRXGQLX-DUXJ MX SHZQLH
SU]HV]OLSHZQLHMX FDH%UXJJHDPR H L6RGGHQZRJQLX
0XV] GRWU]HGR-DUXJL
3L NQLH$SRWHP"
=QDMG yG SRS\Q ] SU GHPVSUyEXM SU]HGRVWDVL GRXM FLD3y QLHM
VWDWHN6WDPW GGRFKROHU\PXV] NXUVRZDMDNLH VWDWNL
'R1LOIJDDUGX"SDUVNQ D3ODQ\QLHXOHJ\]PLDQLH"
1LHPXVLV]PLWRZDU]\V]\
, FLHQLHPXV] ,FKZDOLERJyZERMD PLHUFLQLHV]XNDP/ NDVL MHMQLH
O NDPDOHWRFLPXV] U]HF]DELVL GDQLHZLHONDWRV]WXND
:LHPRGSRZLHG]LDVSRNRMQLH0DPSUDNW\N 1LHZ GURZDE\PZWDPWH
VWURQ\JG\E\PQLHPXVLD$OHPXV] ZL F MDG 1LFPQLHQLHSRZVWU]\PD
+D]PLHU]\DJRZ]URNLHP$OH JRVMDNE\NWRQR HPGQRVWDUHJRJDUQND
GUDSD*G\E\FL FHVDU](PK\UV\V]DZJDFLHE\SHZQLHSRSX FL]HVWUDFKX'R
PQLHVWUD HGRPQLHKXIFHPRMHFHVDUVNLHELDGDELDGDMX WXGRPQLHGR
1LOIJDDUGX:LHG PLQF]yQHPS\QLHZUD]WXE G]LH \FLDLNRURQ\]EDZL
=JXELRQ\P
3U]HVWD 0LOYD
$MX FL&]DVE\FLNWR ZUHV]FLHSUDZG Z RF]\U]HN1LHFKPQLHZ\OLQLD\
NUyOLNZ\FK GR \MH OLPNLHG\GXPLHMV]HJRFKRSDZLG]LDD(PK\URZLMHG]LHV]
SU]HVWD\SU]\SRPLQDJRV\OXG]L
,P\PDP\L QDSRXGQLH"VS\WDSRHWDSDWU] F Z\PRZQLHQDZLHG PLQD
3U]H]WHSR DU\"7DPVN G QDGFL JDM WDF\U]H QLF\"
:\GDMHPLVL RGU]HN]RFL JDQLHP*HUDOW H QLHPDP\Z\ERUX
0DP\SRZLHG]LDD0LOYD0RJ SU]HSURZDG]LZDVODVDPLQD6RZLH
:]JyU]DL]SRZURWHPGR&HDQQ7UHLVH'R%URNLORQX
3U]H]SRQ FHODV\"3U]H]]DJRQSU]HGNWyU\POHGZRXFLHNOL P\"
3HZQLHMV]HWRQL GURJDQDSRXGQLH'R&HDQQ7UHLVHMHVWZV]\VWNLHJR
F]WHUQD FLHPLODMD]QDP FLH NL
:LHG PLQSDWU]\ZGyQDJLQ F Z SR DU]HZLH
1LOIJDDUGF]\F\XSRUDOLVL MX ] MH FDPLMD]GDIRUPRZDDVL Z NROXPQ
PDUV]RZ 3VWURNDWDZDWDKD6FRLD
WDHOUXV]\DJR FL FHPZLRG F\PQDZVFKyG
-DQLHZUDFDPRGU]HNWZDUGR$OHSU]HSURZDG GR%URNLORQX-DVNUD
1LH]DSURWHVWRZDSRHWDFKRQDGDOQLHRG]\VNDQRUPDOQ\FKNRORUyZ
-DG ] WRE
0LOYDPDFKQ DU N SRGQLRVDNRF]DQLXN]URELDNURNZVWURQ NRQLQDJOH
RGZUyFLDVL
'RGLDEDZDUNQ D=DGXJRL]DF] VWRHOIyZRG]JXE\UDWRZDDP1LMDN
PLWHUD]SDWU]HMDNNWR JLQLH3U]HSURZDG] ZDVGR-DUXJLV]DORQHSDNL$OHQLH
SRXGQLRZ\PMHQRZVFKRGQLPV]ODNLHP
7DPWH MX SRQ ODV\
3U]HSURZDG] ZDVSU]H]RJLH 3U]\Z\NDP
1LHPXVLV]WHJRUREL0LOYD
3HZQLH H QLHPXV] 1RQDNXOEDNL5XV]FLHVL ZUHV]FLH
1LHXMHFKDOLGDOHNR.RQLH]WUXGHPSRUXV]D\VL Z J V]F]XLQD]DUR QL W\FK
FLH NDFKDQLHRGZD DOLVL NRU]\VWD]GUyJ]HZV] G GRELHJDLFKW WHQWL
V]F] N]GUDG]DM F\FL JQ FHZRMVND=PURN]DVNRF]\LFKZ UyG]DNU]DF]RQ\FK
SDURZyZ]DWU]\PDOLVL QDQRFOHJ1LHSDGDRQLHERE\RMDVQHRGXQ
=QDOH OLVWRVXQNRZRVXFKHPLHMVFHXVLHGOLRZLQ ZV]\VL Z RSR F]HLGHUNL
0LOYDSHQHWURZDDRNROLF *G\W\ONRRGHV]D-DVNLHUGDXSXVWGXJR
ZVWU]\P\ZDQHMFLHNDZR FLMDN Z]EXG]DDZQLPEURNLOR VNDXF]QLF]ND
']LHZF]\QDMDNDQLDPUXF]D7\PDV]V]F] FLHGRWDNLFK]QDMRPR FL
*HUDOW6WU]HOLVWDL]JUDEQDFKRG]LMDNE\WD F]\D:ELRGUDFKWURFK ]DZ VND
MDNQDPyMJXVWDZUDPLRQDFKRGURELQN ]DPRFQDDOHSU]HFLH NRELHFD
NRELHFD7HGZDMDEXV]ND]SU]RGXKRKR0DRNRV]XODQLHSUD QLH
3U]\PNQLMVL -DVNLHU
:GURG]HPDU]\GDOHMSRHWD]GDU]\RPLVL GRWNQ SU]\SDGNLHP8GR
PyZL FLMDN]PDUPXUX2KRQLHQXG]LRFLVL SU]H]WHQPLHVL F Z%URNOLRQLH
0LOYDNWyUDZD QLHZUyFLD]SDWUROXXV\V]DDWHDWUDOQ\V]HSWL]DXZD \D
VSRMU]HQLD
2PQLHJDGDV]SRHWR"&]HJRVL ZHPQLHZSDWUXMHV]OHGZLHVL RGZUyF "
3WDNPLQDSOHF\QDVUD"
:FL QLHPR HP\VL QDG]LZLWZHPXXF]QLF]HPXNXQV]WRZLZ\V]F]HU]\
] E\-DVNLHU1D]DZRGDFKVWU]HOHFNLFKPDR]QDOD]DE\ NRQNXUHQWyZ
%DMXEDMX
2 ZLFLH]DF] RSDGD1LHWDNMDNSRSU]HGQLHJRGQLDJG\EXU]\WRZDU]\V]\D
VLOQDOHF]NUyWNRWUZDDXOHZD1LHERSRV]DU]DRL]DVQXRVL RRZLDQ\PQDORWHP
=DF] RP \GUREQRUyZQRLGRNXF]OLZLHVL SL
-HFKDOLQDZVFKyG0LOYDSURZDG]LD*G\*HUDOW]ZUyFLMHMXZDJ H -DUXJD
MHVWQDSRXGQLXXF]QLF]ND]EXUF]DDJRLSU]\SRPQLDD]HWRRQDMHVW
3U]H]QDVW SQHGZDGQLQLHSU]HMHFKDOLQDZHWGZXG]LHVWXPLO3DGDRQDGDO
&KRQQDSROHWQLHMVXV]\]LHPLDRSLDVL MX ZRG GRSU]HV\WXOH QHGUy NL
]DPLHQL\VL Z ERWQLVWH OL]JDZNL0J\LRSDU\RGHEUD\LPPR OLZR
REVHUZRZDQLDG\PyZSR DUyZDOHVPUyGVSDOHQL]Q\ZVND]\ZD H ZRMVNDV
ZFL QLHGDOHNRLQDGDOSDO ZV]\VWNRF]HJRLPDVL RJLH
8FLHNLQLHUyZQLHZLG]LHOL%\OLZ UyGODVyZVDPL3U]\QDMPQLHMWDNP\ OHOL
*HUDOWSLHUZV]\XV\V]DFKUDSQL FLHLG FHJRZ ODG]DQLPLNRQLD=NDPLHQQ
WZDU] ]DZUyFL3RWN -DVNLHURWZRU]\XVWDDOH0LOYDJHVWHPQDND]DDPX
PLOF]HQLHZ\M DXN]VDMGDNDSU]\VLRGOH
-DG F\]DQLPLZ\RQLVL ] ]DUR OL=REDF]\ H F]HNDM QDQLHJRL]DWU]\PD
NRQLDFLVDZHJRRJLHUD6WDOLWDNZFLV]\SU]HU\ZDQHMW\ONRV]XPHPGHV]F]X
=DEURQLHPFLMHFKD]DQDPLSRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLH:LHG PLQ
1LOIJDDUGF]\NNWyUHJR-DVNLHURVWDWQLUD]ZLG]LDZWUXPQLHZELRF]\ZPRNU
JU]\Z 3RHWDOHGZLHJRSR]QDRG]LDQHJRZNROF]XJ VNyU]DQ\NDIWDQLSDV]F]
EH]Z WSLHQLD]ZOHF]RQH]NWyUHJR ] ]DELW\FKSU]\ZR]LHKDYHNDUD=DSDPL WD
MHGQDNPRG WZDU]NWyUHMRGF]DVXSU]\JRG\SRGEXNLHPQLH]GRD]PLHQL
VN SRV\SL F\VL ]DURVW
=DEURQLHPFLSRZWyU]\:LHG PLQ
=DEURQLH SU]\]QDZUHV]FLHPRG]LN0yZLEH]QLOIJDDUG]NLHJRDNFHQWX
$OHMDPXV]
*HUDOW]HVNRF]\]NRQLDSRGDZRG]HSRHFLH,Z\FL JQ PLHF]
=VL G SRZLHG]LDVSRNRMQLH=DRSDWU]\H VL MX Z NDZDHN HOD]DMDN
ZLG] 7RGREU]H1LMDNPLE\RFL ]DU]\QDJG\E\H EH]EURQQ\7HUD]WRFR
LQQHJR=VLDGDM
1LHE G ] WRE ZDOF]\1LHFKF
'RP\ ODPVL -DNZV]\VF\WZRLURGDF\ZROLV]LQQ\URG]DMZDONL7DNLMDNZ
WHMVPRODUQLRERNNWyUHMPXVLDH SU]HMHFKDMDG F QDV]\PWURSHP=VLDGDM
SRZLHG]LDHP
-HVWHP&DKLU0DZU'\IIU\QDHS&HDOODFK
1LHSURVLHPE\ VL SU]HGVWDZLD5R]ND]DHPE\ ]VLDG
1LH]VL G 1LHFKF VL ] WRE EL
0LOYD:LHG PLQVNLQ QDXF]QLF]N =UyEPLDVN ]DELMSRGQLPNRQLD
1LH1LOIJDDUGF]\NXQLyVU N ]DQLP0LOYDRVDG]LDVWU]D QDFL FLZLH
1LHSURV] =VLDGDP
/HSLHM$WHUD]GRE G PLHF]DV\QNX
0RG]LNVSOyWU FHQDSLHUVL
=DELMPQLHMH OLFKFHV]-H OLZROLV]ND WHMHOIFH]DVWU]HOLPQLH]XNX1LH
E G VL ] WRE EL-HVWHP&DKLU0DZU'\IIL\QV\Q&HDOODFKD&KF &KF VL
GRZDVSU]\ F]\
&K\EDVL SU]HV\V]DHP3RZWyU]
&KF VL GRZDVSU]\ F]\-HG]LHV]QDSRV]XNLZDQLHG]LHZF]\Q\&KF FL
SRPyF0XV] FLSRPyF
7RMHVWV]DOHQLHF*HUDOWRGZUyFLVL GR0LOY\L-DVNUD'R]QDSRPLHV]DQLD
]P\VyZ0DP\GRF]\QLHQLD]V]DOH FHP
3DVRZDE\GRNRPSDQLLPUXNQ D0LOYD-DNXODE\SDVRZD
3U]HP\ O MHJRSURSR]\FM *HUDOW]DGUZL-DVNLHU.RQLHFNR FyZWR
QLOIJDDUG]NLV]ODFKFLF0R H ]MHJRSRPRF DWZLHMQDPE G]LHSU]HGRVWDVL GR
7U]\PDMM ]RUQDZRG]\SU]HUZDPXRVWUR:LHG PLQ'DOHM HGRE G
PLHF]D1LOIJDDUGF]\NX
1LHE G VL EL,QLHMHVWHP1LOIJDDUGF]\NLHP3RFKRG] ] 9LFRYDURD
QD]\ZDPVL
1LHREFKRG]LPQLHMDNVL QD]\ZDV]'RE G EURQL
1LH
:LHG PLQLH0LOYDSU]HFK\OLDVL Z VLRGOHVSOXQ DQD]LHPL &]DVELH \
D GHV]F]PRF]\1LOIJDDUGF]\NQLHFKFHFLVWDQ DW\FKRVURJLHVWURLV]PLQ\
SU]HFLHJRQLH]DU ELHV]]]LPQ NUZL 0DP\WDNVWHUF]HWXGRXVUDQHM PLHUFL"
:VDG] MHJRFLVNRZLVWU]D Z VDEL]Q L MHG P\ZVZRM GURJ 3LHV]R]DQDPL
QLHQDG \
&DKLUV\Q&HDOODFKDMHGQ\PVXVHPGRSDGFLVDZHJRRJLHUDZVNRF]\QDVLRGR
L SRJDORSRZD]SRZURWHPNU]\NLHPSRS G]DM F ZLHU]FKRZFDGRV]\EV]HJRELHJX
:LHG PLQSU]H]FKZLO SDWU]\]DQLPSRWHPZVLDGQD3RWN :PLOF]HQLX,QLH
RJO GDM F VL
6WDU]HM VL PUXNQ SRMDNLP F]DVLHJG\3ORWND]UyZQDDVL ] NDURV]HP
0LOY\=DF]\QDPPLHZDVNUXSX\
$QR]GDU]DVL X VWDU\FKXF]QLF]NDVSRMU]DDQDQLHJR]HZVSyF]XFLHP
2GZDU]PLRGXQNLSRPDJDQDWR$QDUD]LHNDG VRELHSRGXV]HF]N QDVLRGR
6NUXSX\Z\MD QLSRZD QLH-DVNLHUWRQLHWRVDPRFRKHPRURLG\0LOYD
0\OLV]SRM FLD
$NWRE\WDPSRM ZDV]HP GUHJDGDQLH8VWDZLF]QLHJDGDFLHWRMHQR
XPLHFLH'DOHMZGURJ
0LOYD]DS\WDSRFKZLOL:LHG PLQFKURQL F WZDU]SU]HGGHV]F]HPVLHN F\P
Z JDORSLH=DELDE\ SRGQLPNRQLD"
1LHSU]\]QDDQLHFK WQLH.R QLF]HPXQLHZLQLHQ$LWHQ1LOIJDDUGF]\N
3RNLHJRELHVDRQ]DQDPL OHG]L"&]HPXJDGD H PXVL"
1LHFKPQLHGLDEOLMH OLZLHP
3DGDRQDGDOJG\QDJOHODVVL VNR F]\LZ\MHFKDOLQDJR FLQLHFZLM F\VL
Z UyGZ]JyU]]SRXGQLDQDSyQRF/XERGZURWQLHVWRVRZQLHGRSXQNWXZLG]HQLD
7RFR]REDF]\OLQDJR FL FXQLH]DVNRF]\RLFK:LG]LHOLWRMX :\ZUyFRQHL
Z\EHEHV]RQHZR]\WUXS\NRQLSRUR]U]XFDQHSDNXQNLMXNLLXE\,]DFKPDQLRQH
]DVW\JHZG]LZQ\FKSR]DFKNV]WDW\NWyUHMHV]F]HQLHGDZQRE\\OXG PL
3RGMHFKDOLEOL HMEH]O NX%RZLGRF]QHE\R H U]H PLDDPLHMVFHQLHG]L
OHF]ZF]RUDMOXESU]HGZF]RUDM1DXF]\OLVL MX UR]SR]QDZDWDNLHU]HF]\DPR H
Z\F]XZDOLMHL FLH]ZLHU] F\PLQVW\QNWHPNWyU\REXG]L\LZ\F]XOL\ZQLFK
SRSU]HGQLHGQL1DXF]\OLVL WH SHQHWURZDSRERMRZLVNDERQLHNLHG\U]DGNR
XGDZDRVL LP]QDOH Z UyGSRUR]U]XFDQHJRGRE\WNXRGURELQ SURZLDQWXDOER
ZRUHNSDV]\
:LGQRMHV]F]HQLH RQDWDNLHG\WDNZ\ZLMD
8PWDXPWDXKXKD
3DWU]DMWDWDPQDO JXZLOF]HNDS\ZOHF]H
HEVSXV]F]RQ\FKZDVWVNXORQ\]RNDH]NDFLHF]H
&]HPX WRWDEHVW\MDWDND]DVPXFRQD"
:LGQRZF]RUDMR HQLRQDDOER]DU F]RQD
+XKXKDRGZU]DVQ \]FDNLHPEOLVNDOLF]QHJRV\
+XNQ JURPNL PLHFKNWR SU]HQLNOLZLH]DJZL]GDQDSDOFDFKSRF]\P]]D
]DNU WXJR FL FDZ\RQLDVL G]LZQDDF]PDORZQLF]DNRPSDQLDPDV]HUXM FD
J VLHJRUR]EU\]JXM FDERWRU\WPLF]Q\PLXGHU]HQLDPLFL NLFKEXFLRUyZ
.UDVQROXG\VWZLHUG]LDSyJRVHP0LOYD$OHWRQLH6FRLD
WDHO%UyGQLH
PDM ]DSOHFLRQ\FK
1DGFKRG] F\FKE\RV]H FLX2G]LDQLE\OLZNUyWNLHPLHQL FHVL QLH]OLF]RQ\PL
RGFLHQLDPLV]DUR FLLEU ]XSDV]F]H]NDSWXUDPLQRV]RQH]Z\NOHSU]H]NUDVQROXG\
Z F]DVLHVRW\3DV]F]HWDNLHMDNZLHG]LD*HUDOWPLD\]DOHW DEVROXWQHM
ZRGRRGSRUQR FLX]\VNLZDQ Z GURG]HNLONXQDVWROHWQLHMLPSUHJQDFMLG]LHJFLHP
NXU]HP]JR FL FyZLUHV]WNDPLWXVWHMVWUDZ\3UDNW\F]QDWDSU]\RG]LHZD
SU]HFKRG]LD]RMFDQDQDMVWDUV]HJRV\QDWRWH G\VSRQRZD\QL ] UHJX\Z\ F]QLH
GRMU]DHNUDVQROXG\.UDVQROXGRVL JDGRMU]DR JG\EURGDVL JDDPXSDVDFR
QDVW SRZDR]Z\NOHZZLHNXSL G]LHVL FLXSL FLXODW
DGHQ]H]EOL DM F\FKVL QLHZ\JO GDQDPRGV]HJR$OHLQLHQDVWDUV]HJR
3URZDG] OXG]LPUXNQ D0LOYDUXFKHPJRZ\ZVND]XM F *HUDOWRZLJUXSN
Z\DQLDM F VL ] ODVXZ ODG]DV]yVWN NUDVQDOL1LHFK\EQLH]ELHJyZER
WRERDPLREMXF]HQL
6DPLWH REMXF]HQLV QLH OHVWZLHUG]L-DVNLHU
:VDPHMU]HF]\ND G\NUDVQROXGWDV]F]\EDJD SRGNWyU\PZNUyWNLPF]DVLH
SDGE\QLHMHGHQF]RZLHNLQLHMHGHQNR 2SUyF]]Z\N\FKUXN]DNyZLVDNZ*HUDOW
GRVWU]HJ]DPF]\VWHNXIHUNLVSRU\PLHG]LDQ\NRFLRHNLFR FRZ\JO GDRMDN
PDDNRPyGND-HGHQQLyVQDSOHFDFKNRRRGZR]X
,G F\QDF]HOHQLHQLyVEDJD X=DSDVHPPLDQLHZLHONLWRSRUHNQDSOHFDFK
GXJLPLHF]ZSRFKZLHRZLQL WHMVNyUDPLSU JRZDW\FKNRWyZDQDUDPLHQLX
]LHORQ PRNU LQDVWURV]RQ SDSXJ :D QLHWHQLFKSR]GURZL
:LWDMFLHU\NQ ]DWU]\PXM F VL SR URGNXGURJLLELRU F SRGERNL&]DV\
WDNLH H OHSLHMZLONDVSRWNDZERUXQL OLF]RZLHNDDMH OLMX WRUDG]LHM
VSRWNDQHJREHWHP]NXV]\QL OLGREU\PVRZHPSRZLWD$OHNWR SLHZHPZLWD
NWRPX]\N VL SU]HGVWDZLDWHQZLGDVZyMFKRS$OERLVZRMDEDED]
SU]HSURV]HQLHPPLHMSDQL:LWDMFLH-HVWHP=ROWDQ&KLYD\
-HVWHP*HUDOWSU]HGVWDZLVL SRFKZLOLZDKDQLD:LHG PLQWHQNWyU\
SLHZDWR-DVNLHU$WRMHVW0LOYD
5UUUUZDPD]DVNU]HF]DDSDSXJD
=DPNQLMG]LyEZDUNQ QDSWDND=ROWDQ&KLYD\:\EDF]FLH0 GUHWR
]DPRUVNLHSWDV]\VNRDOHQLHRE\F]DMQH']LHVL WDODUyZ]DFXGDNDGDHP=RZLH
VL )HOGPDUV]DHN'XGD$WRUHV]WDPRMHMNRPSDQLL0XQUR%\X\V<D]RQ<DUGD
&DOHE6WUDWWRQ)LJJLV0HUOX]]RL3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFK
3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFKQLHE\NUDVQROXGHP6SRGPRNUHJRNDSWXUDPLDVW
VNRWXQLRQHMEURG\Z\]LHUDGXJLLV]SLF]DVW\QRVQLH]DZRGQLHRNUH ODM F\
SU]\QDOH QR SRVLDGDF]DGRVWDUHMLV]ODFKHWQHMUDV\JQRPyZ
$WDPFL=ROWDQ&KLYD\ZVND]DQD]DWU]\PDQ L VNXSLRQ RSRGDOJUXSN WR
XFLHNLQLHU]\].HUQyZ-DNZLG]LFLHVDPHEDE\]G]LHFLDNDPL%\RLFKZL FHMDOH
1LOIJDDUGRJDUQ LFKJUXS WU]\GQLWHPXZ\U Q LUR]SURV]\1DWNQ OL P\VL QD
QLHZODVDFKLWHUD]ZVSyOQLHLG]LHP\
PLDRLG]LHFLHSR]ZROLVRELHQDXZDJ :LHG PLQ*R FL FHPL]H
SLHZHP
1LHZ\GDMHPLVL SRUXV]\EURG NUDVQROXGE\PDUV]]SDF]HPE\
OHSV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHP2G'LOOLKQJHQV]OL P\ODVDPLFLFKRLVNU\FLHJG\ZRMVND
SU]HV]\Z\V]OL P\QDJR FLQLHFE\F]DVQDGUREL8UZDSRSDWU]\SR
SRERMRZLVNX
'RWDNLFKZLGRNyZZVND]DQDWUXS\SU]\Z\NOL P\2GVDPHJR'LOOLQJHQ
RG-DUXJLQDJR FL FDFKMHGQD PLHU1DOH HOL FLHGRW\FKWXWDM"
1LH1LOIJDDUGZ\U Q NXSFyZ
1LH1LOIJDDUGSRNU FLJRZ NUDVQROXG]EH]QDPL WQ PLQ SDWU] F QD
]DELW\FK6FRLD
WDHO5HJXODUQHZRMVNRQLHWUXG]LVL Z\FL JDQLHPVWU]D]WUXSyZ
$ GREU\JURWNRV]WXMHSyNRURQ\
=QDVL PUXNQ D0LOYD
'RN G LG]LHFLH"
1DSRXGQLHRGU]HNQDW\FKPLDVW*HUDOW
2GUDG]DP=ROWDQ&KLYD\]QRZXSRNU FLJRZ 7DPLVWQHSLHNRRJLH L
]DJDGD'LOOLQJHQMX QLHFK\EQLH]GRE\WHFRUD]ZL NV]HVL\&]DUQ\FKSU]HFKRG]
-DUXJ ODGDPRPHQW]DOHM FD GROLQ QDSUDZ\PEU]HJX-DNZLG]LFLHV WH MX
SU]HGQDPLQDSyQRF\LG QDPLDVWR%UXJJH-HG\Q\UR]XPQ\]DWHPNLHUXQHN
XFLHF]NL7RZVFKyG
0LOYDZ\PRZQLHVSRMU]DDQDZLHG PLQDD:LHG PLQSRZVWU]\PDVL RG
NRPHQWDU]D
0\ZD QLHQDZVFKyG]PLHU]DP\FL JQ =ROWDQ&KLYD\-HG\QDV]DQVDWR
VNU\VL ]DIURQWDRGZVFKRGXRGU]HNL,Q\UXV] VL Z NR FXZRMVNDWHPHUVNLH
&KFHP\WHG\L OH Q\PLGXNWDPLGRZ]JyU]7XULRXJKSRWHP6WDU 'URJ GR
6RGGHQGRU]HNL&KRWOLNWyUDGR)HQ\ZSDGD&KFHFLHSRPDV]HUXMHP\UD]HP
-H OLZDPZDG]LQLHE G]LH H ZROQR:\PDFLHNRQLHDQDPXFLHNQLHU]\
]ZDOQLDM WHPSR
:DPZV]HODNR RGH]ZDDVL 0LOYDSDWU] F QDQLHJRSU]HQLNOLZLHMDNR WR
QLHZDG]L.UDVQROXGQDZHWEDJD HPSLHFKW\WU]\G]LH FLPLOG]LHQQLHPR H
*HUDOWE\SHZLHQ H NUDVQROXGRPSU]\MG]LHU\FKRSRU]XFL]GRE\W\Zy]JG\
WHQQDGREUHXZL QLHQDUR]PL N\FKGXNWDFKDOHP\OLVL .DU\E\\VLOQHMDN
E\NLDZLRG FHQDZVFKyGOH QHGURJLRND]D\VL WUDZLDVWHLQLH]E\WJU] VNLH
3DGDRQDGDOEH]SU]HUZ\0LOYD]URELDVL SRQXUDL]DMH HOLVL RG]\ZDDWR
W\ONRDE\Z\UD]LSU]HNRQDQLH H ODGDPRPHQWNRQLRPSRS NDUR]PL N\UyJQD
NRS\WDFK=ROWDQ&KLYD\REOL]\ZDVL Z RGSRZLHG]LSU]\JO GDNRS\WRPL
SRZLDGDVL PLVWU]HPZSU]\U] G]DQLXNRQLQ\F]\PGRSURZDG]D0LOY GRV]DOX
8WU]\P\ZDOLVWD\V]\NNWyUHJRFHQWUXPVWDQRZLFL JQL W\QD]PLDQ Zy]
3U]HGZR]HPPDV]HURZD=ROWDQRERNQLHJRMHFKDQD3HJD]LH-DVNLHUGURF] F VL
] SDSXJ =DZR]HPMHFKDOL*HUDOW]0LOY QDNR FXZORNRVL V]H NRELHW]
.HUQyZ
3U]HZRGQLNLHPE\]Z\NH3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFKGXJRQRV\JQRP8VW SXM F
NUDVQROXGRPZ]URVWHPLVL GRUyZQ\ZDLPZ\WU]\PDR FL D]ZLQQR FL
]QDF]QLHSU]HZ\ V]D:PDUV]XQLHXVWDQLHNOXF]\V]SHUDSRNU]DNDFK
Z\VIRURZ\ZDVL GRSU]RGXL]QLNDSRF]\PREMDZLDVL QDJOHLQHUZRZ\PL
PDSLPLJHVWDPLGDZD]GDOHND]QDN H ZV]\VWNRZSRU] GNXPR QDL GDOHM
&]DVDPLZUDFDLV]\ENR]GDZDUHODFM R SU]HV]NRGDFKQDV]ODNX,OHNUR
ZUyFLPLDGODF]ZyUNLVLHG] F\FKQDZR]LHG]LHFLJDU MH \QRU]HFK\OXEMDNLH
G]LZDF]QHDOHZ\UD QLHVPDNRZLWHN F]D
7HPSRPLHOLSRWZRUQLHZROQHPDV]HURZDOLGXNWDPLWU]\GQL1LHQDWNQ OLVL QD
DGQHZRMVNDQLHZLG]LHOLG\PyZDQLXQ1LHE\OLMHGQDNVDPL=ZLDGRZFD
3HUFLYDONLONDNURWQLHPHOGRZDLPRNU\M F\FKVL Z ODVDFKJUXSDFKXFLHNLQLHUyZ
.LONDWDNLFKJUXSPLQ OLLWRV]\ENRERPLQ\X]EURMRQ\FKZZLG\LNRQLFH
FKRSyZQLH]DFK FD\GRQDZL ]\ZDQLDNRQWDNWyZ3DGDSURSR]\FMDE\MHGQDN
VSUyERZDQHJRFMDFMLLSR]RVWDZLNWyUHM ] JUXSNRELHW\].HUQyZDOH=ROWDQE\
SU]HFLZQ\D0LOYDJRSRSDUD.RELHW\WH ZFDOHQLHNZDSL\VL E\RSX FL
NRPSDQL %\RWRRW\OHG]LZQH H RGQRVL\VL GRNUDVQROXGyZ]Z\UD Q
SU]HSHQLRQ VWUDFKHPQLHFK FL L UH]HUZ QLHRG]\ZD\VL SUDZLHZFDOHDQD
ND G\PSRVWRMXWU]\PD\VL QDXERF]X
*HUDOWSU]\SLV\ZD]DFKRZDQLHNRELHWWUDJHGLLMDN L QLHGDZQRSU]H \\
SRGHMU]HZDMHGQDN H SU]\F]\Q QLHFK FLPRJ\E\WH GR VZRERGQHPDQLHU\
NUDVQROXGyZ=ROWDQLMHJRNRPSDQLDNO OLUyZQLHSOXJDZLHLF] VWRFRSDSXJD
QD]\ZDQD)HOGPDUV]DNLHP'XG DOHPLHOLERJDWV]\UHSHUWXDU SLHZDOL ZL VNLH
SLRVHQNLZF]\P]UHV]W G]LHOQLHVHNXQGRZDLP-DVNLHU3OXOLVPDUNDOLZSDOFHL
SXV]F]DOLJURPNLHE NLVWDQRZL FH]D]Z\F]DMRND]M GR PLHFKyZ DUWyZL
ZVSy]DZRGQLFWZD:NU]DNLFKRG]LOLZ\ F]QLH]DQDSUDZG JUXE SRWU]HE ]
O HMV]\PLQLHWUXG]LOLVL GDOHNLPFKRG]HQLHP7RRVWDWQLHUR]MXV]\RZUHV]FLH
0LOY NWyUD]GURZRREUXJDD=ROWDQDJG\WHQUDQNLHPZ\VLNDVL QDFLHS\
MHV]F]HSRSLyRJQLVND]XSHQLHQLHSU]HMPXM F VL ZLGRZQL =Z\P\ ODQ\=ROWDQ
QLHVWURSLVL L R ZLDGF]\ H ZVW\GOLZLHXNU\ZDVL ] WHJRURG]DMXF]\QQR FLDPL
]Z\NOLW\ONRRVREQLF\GZXOLFRZLSHUILGQLLVNRQQLGRGRQRVLGHOVWZDSRF]\PVL
WDNLFK]Z\NOHUR]SR]QDMH1DXF]QLF]FHMHGQDNHORNZHQWQHZ\MD QLHQLH DGQHJR
ZUD HQLDQLHZ\ZDUR.UDVQROXG\SRF] VWRZDQH]RVWD\ERJDW ZL ]DQN L
NLONRPDEDUG]RNRQNUHWQ\PLJUR EDPLNWyUHSRVNXWNRZD\ERZV]\VF\
SRVXV]QLH]DF] OLFKRG]LZ]DUR OD%\QLHQDUD]LVL MHGQDNQDPLDQR
SHUILGQ\FKGRQRVLFLHOLFKRG]LOLJUXSRZR
1RZHWRZDU]\VWZR]XSHQLHQDWRPLDVWRGPLHQLR-DVNUD3RHWDE\]
NUDVQROXGDPL]DSDQEUDW]ZDV]F]DJG\RND]DRVL H QLHNWyU]\V\V]HOLRQLPL
]QDM QDZHWMHJREDOODG\LNXSOHW\-DVNLHUQLHRGVW SRZD=ROWDQRZHMNRPSDQLLQD
NURN1RVLZ\F\JDQLRQ RGNUDVQROXGyZSLNRZDQ NXUW ]QLV]F]RQ\NDSHOXVLN]
SLyUNLHP]DVW SL]DZDGLDFNLPNXQLPNRSDNLHP3U]HSDVDVL V]HURNLP
QDELMDQ\PPRVL G]HPSDVHP]DNWyU\]DWNQ RWU]\PDQ\ZSUH]HQFLHQy R
]EyMHFNLPZ\JO G]LH1R HPW\P]Z\NOHNXVL Z SDFKZLQ SU]\ND GHMSUyELH
SRFK\OHQLDVL 1DV]F] FLHV]\ENR]JXELJG]LH PRUGHUF]\SXJLQDDGUXJLHJR
MX QLHGRVWD
: GURZDOLZ UyGJ VW\FKODVyZSRUDVWDM F\FK]ERF]D7XUORXJK/DV\]GDZD\
VL Z\PDUHQLHE\R ODGX]ZLHU]\Q\Z\SRV]RQHMZLGDSU]H]ZRMVNDL]ELHJyZ
1LHE\RQDFR]DSRORZDDOHJyGLPQDUD]LHQLH]DJUD D.UDVQROXG\WDUDEDQL\
]HVRE VSRURSURZLDQWX*G\WHQ]D VL VNR F]\DVNR F]\VL U\FKRERJ E
GRZ\ \ZLHQLDE\RVSRUR<D]RQ<DUGDL0XQUR%UQ\V]QLNQ OLOHGZLHVL
FLHPQLRELRU F ]HVRE SXVW\ZRUHN*G\QDGUDQHPZUyFLOLPLHOLGZDZRUNL
REDSHQH:MHGQ\PE\DSDV]DGODNRQLZGUXJLPNUXS\P NDVXV]RQD
ZRRZLQDOHGZLHQDSRF] W\NU J VHUDDQDZHWRJURPQ\NLQG]LXNVSHFMDZSRVWDFL
QDG]LHZDQHJRSRGUREDPLZLHSU]RZHJR R GNDVSUDVRZDQHJRPL G]\GZLHPD
GHV]F]XNDPLQDNV]WDWGPXFKDZ\GRQLHFHQLDRJQLDZNRPLQNX
*HUDOWGRP\ ODVL VN G SRFKRG]L\]GRE\F]H1LHVNRPHQWRZDRGUD]XOHF]
RGF]HNDQDVSRVREQ FKZLO JG\E\]=ROWDQHPVDPQDVDP]DJDGQ JR
JU]HF]QLHF]\QLHZLG]LQLF]HJR]GUR QHJRZRNUDGDQLXLQQ\FKXFLHNLQLHUyZQLH
PQLHMZV]DN H RGQLFKJRGQ\FKLQDUyZQL]QLPLZDOF] F\FKRSU]H \FLH
.UDVQROXGRGU]HNSRZD QLH H RZV]HPEDUG]RVL WHJRZVW\G]LDOHWDNLMX PD
FKDUDNWHU
0RM RJURPQ SU]\ZDU Z\MD QLMHVWQLHSRKDPRZDQDGREUR-DSRSURVWX
PXV] F]\QLGREUR-HVWHPMHGQDNUR]V GQ\PNUDVQROXGHPLZLHP H ZV]\VWNLP
Z\ ZLDGF]\GREUDQLH]GRDP*G\E\PSUyERZDE\GREU\GODZV]\VWNLFKGOD
FDHJR ZLDWDLZV]\VWNLFK]DPLHV]NXM F\FKJRLVWRWE\DE\WRNURSHONDSLWQHM
ZRG\ZVRQ\PPRU]XLQQ\PLVRZ\VWUDFRQ\Z\VLHN3RVWDQRZLHP]DWHP
F]\QLGREURNRQNUHWQHWDNLHNWyUHQLHLG]LHQDPDUQH-HVWHPGREU\GODVLHELHL
GODPHJREH]SR UHGQLHJRRWRF]HQLD
*HUDOWQLH]DGDZDZL FHMS\WD
3RGZyFKGQLDFKGHV]F]SU]HVWDSDGDZ\MU]DRVR FH/DV\RGHWFKQ \
RSDUHPLV]\ENRUR]ZLHZDM F VL PJ SWDNLJZDWRZQLH]DF] \QDGUDELD
Z\PXV]RQHVRW PLOF]HQLH=ROWDQSRZHVHODL]DU] G]LGX V]\SRVWyMSRNWyU\P
RELHF\ZDV]\EV]\PDUV]LGRWDUFLHGR6WDUHM'URJLZFL JXJyUDMHGQHJRGQLD
.RELHW\].HUQyZR]GREL\ZV]\VWNLHRNROLF]QHJD ]LHF]HUQL L V]DUR FL
VXV]RQHMSU]\RG]LHZ\VDPHW\ONRZJLH]HNDFKVNU\\VL ZVW\GOLZLHZNU]DNDFK
L SLWUDVL\VWUDZ 5R]HEUDQHG]LHFLDNLUR]LJUD\VL QDZ\V]XNDQHVSRVRE\
]DNyFDM F GRVWRMQ\VSRNyMSDUXM FHMSXV]F]\-DVNLHURGV\SLD]P F]HQLH0LOYD
]QLND
.UDVQROXG\RGSRF]\ZD\DNW\ZQLH)LJJLV0HUOX]]RL0XQUR%UX\VXGDOLVL QD
SRV]XNLZDQLHJU]\EyZ=ROWDQ<D]RQ<DUGD&DOHE6WUDWWRQL3HUFLYDO
6FKXWWHQEDFKRVLHGOLQLHRSRGDOZR]XLEH]Z\WFKQLHQLDJUDOLZJZLQWDLFK
XOXELRQ JU NDUFLDQ NWyUHMSR ZL FDOLND G ZROQ FKZLO QDZHWZSRSU]HGQLH
PRNUHZLHF]RU\:LHG PLQSU]\VLDGDVL QLHNLHG\LNLELFRZDWHUD]XF]\QL
SRGREQLH6NRPSOLNRZDQ\FKUHJXWHMW\SRZRNUDVQROXG]NLHMJU\QDGDOQLHPyJ
SRM DOH]DFKZ\FDVL Z\M WNRZRVWDUDQQ\PZ\NRQDQLHPNDUWLPDOXQNDPL
ILJXU:SRUyZQDQLXGRNDUWZNWyUHJUDOLOXG]LHNDUW\NUDVQROXGyZE\\
SUDZG]LZ\PLDUF\G]LHDPLSROLJUDILL*HUDOWSRUD]NROHMQ\SU]HNRQ\ZDVL H
WHFKQLNDEURGDWHJROXGNXE\ PRFQR]DDZDQVRZDQDE\QDMPQLHMQLHZ\ F]QLHZ
G]LHG]LQLHJyUQLFWZDKXWQLFWZDLPHWDOXUJLL7R H ZNRQNUHWQHMNDUFLDQHM
G]LHG]LQLH]GROQR FLNUDVQROXGyZQLHSRPRJ\LPZ]PRQRSROL]RZDQLXU\QNX
Z\QLNDR]IDNWX H NDUW\E\\Z UyGOXG]LZFL PQLHMSRSXODUQHRGNR FLD
OXG]F\KD]DUG]L FLQLHZ\ZRG]LOLVL ] JUXSSU]\ZL ]XM F\FKZDJ GRHVWHW\NL
/XG]F\NDUFLDU]HNWyU\FK:LHG PLQPLDQLHMHGQ RND]M REVHUZRZDJU\ZDOL
]DZV]HZZ\PDPDQHNDUWRQLNLWDNEUXGQH H SU]HGSRR HQLHPQDVWyWU]HED
E\RMHPR]ROQLHRGOHSLDRGSDOFyZ)LJXU\E\\Z\PDORZDQHWDNQLHFKOXMQLH H
RGUy QLHQLHSDQQ\RGQL QLNDPR OLZHE\RW\ONRG]L NLWHPX H QL QLNVLHG]LDQD
NRQLX.WyU\WRNR EDUG]LHM]UHV]W SU]\SRPLQDNDOHN DVLF
:L]HUXQNLQDNDUWDFKNUDVQROXGyZZ\NOXF]D\SRGREQHSRP\NL1RV] F\
NRURQ Z\ QLNE\SUDZG]LZLHNUyOHZVNLSDQQDF\FDWDLXURG]LZDDX]EURMRQ\Z
KDODEDUG QL QLN]DZDGLDFNRZ VDW\)LJXU\WH]ZD\VL SRNUDVQROXG]NXKUDYDO
YDLQDLEDOOHWDOH=ROWDQLMHJRNRPSDQLDX \ZDOLZJU]HM ]\NDZVSyOQHJRLQD]Z
OXG]NLFK
6R FHJU]DRODVSDURZD*HUDOWNLELFRZD
3RGVWDZRZ ]DVDG NUDVQROXG]NLHJRJZLQWDE\RFR SU]\SRPLQDM FHJR
OLF\WDFM QDWDUJXNR VNLPWDNLQWHQV\ZQR FL MDNLQDW HQLHPJRVX
OLF\WXM F\FK1DVW SQLHSDUD]JDV]DM FDQDMZ\ V] FHQ VWDUDDVL ]GRE\MDN
QDMZL FHMZ]L WHNF]HPXGUXJDSDUDQDZV]HONLHVSRVRE\SU]HV]NDG]DD
5R]JU\ZNDSU]HELHJDDJR QRLJZDWRZQLHDRERNND GHJRJUDF]DOH DJUXE\
NLM2NDGDQRVL NLMDPLGR U]DGNRDOHZ\PDFKLZDQRF] VWR
-DNH JUDZRNXW\]ER RZ\"3DR]DNXWD"&]HPX Z OLVWNLPLDVWZVHUFD
Z\V]HG"&RWRMDGODNURWRFKZLOLZVHUFDZLVWRZDHP"$FKZ]L E\PSD L
ZDOQ FL Z WHQJXSLHE
0LDHPF]WHU\OLVWNL]QL QLNLHPP\ ODHPZ\RSW\PRZD
&]WHU\OLVWNLDMX FL&K\ED ZDVQHJRSWRNDGROLF]\NDUW\QDSRGRNX
G]LHU F\7\P\ O WURFK 6WUDWWRQERWXQLHXQLZHUV\WHW7XVL Z NDUW\JUD1R
DOHL ZLQLDEXUPLVWU]DRJUDDJG\GREUHNDUW\PLDD5R]GDZDM9DUGD
3ODFHNZG]ZRQNL
0DDNXSDZNXOH
*UDNUyOZNXOHSU]HVUDNRV]XO 'XEHOZOLVWNL
*ZLQW
1LH SLM&DOHE'XEHO]JZLQWHPE\&ROLF\WXMHV]"
'X D NXSDZG]ZRQNL
$NFHV+DDD,FR"1LNWQLHJZLQWXMH"'XG\ZPLHFKV\QNRZLH":LVWXMHV]
9DUGD3HUFLYDOMHV]F]HUD]GRQLHJRPUXJQLHV]WRFL WDNSLHSU]Q Z RF]RGy H
GR]LP\QLHSRPUXJDV]
1L QLN
3DQQD
:\ QLNLHPSRQLHM3DQQDZ\G\PDQQD%LM L KDKDMHV]F]HVHUFDPDPQD
F]DUQ JRG]LQ XNU\WH1L QLNNUD\ NDNUDOND
,WUXPIHPSRQLHM.WRQLH FL JDNR]HU\WHQMHVWF]WHU\OLWHU\,ZNXOH$KD
=ROWDQ"7XPFL Z PL WNLHWUDIL
:LG]LHOL FLHJRJQRPDSLHSU]RQHJR(FKZ]L E\PSD
1LP=ROWDQ]URELX \WHN]SD\]ODVXGRELHJLFKSU]HUD OLZ\ZU]DVN
*HUDOW]HUZDVL SLHUZV]\=DNO ZELHJXERNRODQR]QRZXSU]HV]\PXEyO
7X ]DQLPSRVSLHV]\=ROWDQ&KL\D\FKZ\FLZV]\]ZR]XVZyMRPRWDQ\NRFLPL
VNyUNDPLPLHF]3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFKLUHV]WDNUDVQROXGyZELHJOL]DQLPL
X]EURMHQLZSDNL]W\XSRG D-DVNLHUUR]EXG]RQ\NU]\NLHP=ERNX]ODVX
Z\VNRF]\OL)LJJLVL0XQUR5]XFLZV]\NRV]\NL]JU]\EDPLREDNUDVQROXG\]DSD\
L RGFL JQ \XFLHNDM FHG]LHFL1LHZLDGRPRVN G SRMDZLDVL 0LOYDZELHJX
Z\FL JDM F VWU]D ] NRF]DQDLZVND]XM F ZLHG PLQRZLPLHMVFHVN G GRELHJD
NU]\N
1LHSRWU]HEQLH*HUDOWV\V]DZLG]LDLMX ZLHG]LDZF]\PU]HF]
.U]\F]DRMHGQR]G]LHFLSLHJRZDWDG]LHZL FLROHWQLDPR H G]LHZXV]ND]
ZDUNRF]\NDPL6WDDMDNZU\WDNLONDNURNyZSU]HGVWHUW VSUyFKQLD\FKSQL*HUDOW
GRVNRF]\E\VNDZLF]QLHFKZ\FLM SRGSDFK SU]HU\ZDM F G]LNLSLVNN WHPRND
RZL F UXFKSRPL G]\SQLDPL&RIQ VL V]\ENRZSDGDM F QD=ROWDQDLMHJR
NUDVQROXGyZ0LOYDNWyUDUyZQLH GRVWU]HJDUXFKZ UyGSQLDNyZQDSL DXN
1LHVWU]HODMV\NQ =DELHU]VW G G]LHFLDNDSU GNR$Z\FRIQ VL 7\ONR
VSRNRMQLH1LHZ\NRQ\ZD]E\WJZDWRZQ\FKUXFKyZ
=SRF] WNX]GDZDRLPVL H SRUXV]\DVL NWyUD ]HVSUyFKQLD\FKNyGL FLH
MDNE\PLDD]DPLDU]OH ]QDVRQHF]QLRQHMVWHUW\LSRV]XNDFLHQLDZ UyGGU]HZ
'RSLHURXZD QLHMV]HVSRMU]HQLDSR]ZROL\GRVWU]HFQLHW\SRZHGODNRG\HOHPHQW\
SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPF]WHU\SDU\FLHQNLFKQyJRJUX]RZDW\FKVWDZDFKZ]QRV] F\FK
VL QDGSREUX G RQ\PQDNUDSLDQ\PLSRG]LHORQ\PQDUDF]HVHJPHQW\SDQFHU]HP
7\ONRVSRNRMQLHSRZWyU]\FLFKR*HUDOW1LHSURZRNXMFLHJR1LHFKZDVQLH
]ZLHG]LHMHJRSR]RUQDQLHUXFKDZR 1LHMHVWDJUHV\ZQ\DOHSRWUDILSRUXV]DVL
E\VNDZLF]QLH-H OLSRF]XMHVL ]DJUR RQ\PR H ]DDWDNRZDDQDMHJRMDGQLHPD
RGWUXWNL
6WZyUSRZROXWNXZSH]QDNRG 3U]\JO GDVL OXG]LRPLNUDVQROXGRPZROQR
REUDFDM F RVDG]RQ\PLQDVXSNDFKRF]DPL3UDZLHVL QLHSRUXV]D&]\ FLNR FH
RGQy \SRNROHLXQRV] F MHLVWDUDQQLHSRV]F]\SQM F LPSRQXM F\PLRVWU\PL
XZDF]NDPL
7\OHE\RZU]DVNXR ZLDGF]\QDJOHEH]HPRFML=ROWDQVWDM F RERN
ZLHG PLQD HPP\ OD H WRFR QDSUDZG VWUDV]QHJR1DSU]\NDGNDZDOHU]\VWD
] RFKRWQLF]HMYHUGH VNLHMIRUPDFML$OERSURNXUDWRU$WRRWWDNLVRELHZ\UR QL W\
SDM NRZDW\VNRUXSLDN7U]HEDSU]\]QDFLHNDZHIRUP\SRWUDILSU]\ELHUDQDWXUD
-X QLHSRWUDILRGU]HN*HUDOW7RFRWDPVLHG]LWRMHVWRNRJyZ7ZyU
&KDRVX:\PLHUDM F\UHOLNWSRNRQLXQNF\MQ\MH OLZLHV]RF]\PPyZL
3HZQLH H ZLHPNUDVQROXGVSRMU]DPXZRF]\&KRFLD QLHMHVWHP
ZLHG PLQHPVSHFHPRG&KDRVXLWDNLFKVWZRU]RQHN1RZLHOFHPFLHNDZFR
:LHG PLQWHUD]]UREL]UHOLNWHPSRNRQLXQNF\MQ\P'RNDGQLHMPyZL FFLHNDZ
MHVWHPMDN:LHG PLQWR]UREL8 \MHV]ZDVQHJRPLHF]DF]\ZROLV]PyMVLKLOO"
DGQDEUR *HUDOWU]XFLRNLHPQDPLHF]NWyU\=ROWDQZ\FL JQ ]RPRWDQHM
NRFLPLVNyUNDPLSRFKZ\Z\NRQDQHM]ODNL$OHQLHE G]LHSRWU]HEQD
&LHNDZHSRZWyU]\=ROWDQ0DP\]DWHPVWDLSU]\JO GDVL VRELH
Z]DMHP"&]HNDD UHOLNWSRF]XMHVL ]DJUR RQ\"$PR H ]DZUyFLLZH]ZDQD
SRPRF1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ"&RSURSRQXMHV]]DEyMFRSRWZRUyZ"
3U]\QLH FLH]ZR]XFKRFKO L SRNU\ZN RGNRFLRND
&R"
1LHG\VNXWXM]HVSHFHP=ROWDQRGH]ZDVL -DVNLHU
3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFKNRSQ VL GRZR]XLZPJQLHQLXRNDGRVWDUF]\
Z\PDJDQHSU]HGPLRW\:LHG PLQPUXJQ GRNRPSDQLLSRF]\P]FDHMVL\M
ZDOL\ N Z SRNU\ZN
'R 'R ZU]DVQ SRFKZLOL=ROWDQ&KLYD\SU]\FLVNDM F GRQLHGRXV]X
&KRFKHON NXUZD]QLV]F]\V]6NRUXSLDNXFLHN8FLHNMX FKROHUDMDVQD
-HV]F]HMDNXFLHND]DFKZ\FLVL 3HUFLYDO$ VL NXU]\R0RNURMHVWD
NXU]\RVL ]DQLPQLHFKMDVNRQDP
2NRJyZZ\MD QLFKRGQR*HUDOWRGGDM F NUDVQROXGRPOHNNRSRJL WH
NXFKHQQHXWHQV\OLDPDQLH]Z\NOHF]X\LZUD OLZ\VXFK1LHPDXV]XDOHV\V]\
]HVL WDNZ\UD FD\PVRE :V]F]HJyOQR FLPHWDOLF]Q\FKG ZL NyZQLHMHVWZ
VWDQLH]QLH 'R]QDMHEyOX
1DZHWZU]\FLSU]HUZD=ROWDQ:LHPERMDWH GR]QDHPJG\]DF] H WXF
Z SRNU\ZN -H OLPRQVWUXPPDVXFKF]XOV]\QL OLMDZVSyF]XM PX1LHZUyFL
RQWXDE\"1LHSU]\SURZDG]LNROHJyZ"
1LHV G] E\QD ZLHFLHSR]RVWDRZLHOXMHJRNROHJyZ6DPRNRJyZWH ]
SHZQR FL QLHSU GNRZUyFLZWHVWURQ\1LHPDVL F]HJRO ND
2SRWZRUDFKG\VNXWRZDQLHE G ]DV SLVL NUDVQROXG$OHWZyMNRQFHUWQD
LQVWUXPHQW\EODV]DQHV\FKDE\RSHZQLHD QD:\VSDFK6NHOOLJHQLH
Z\NOXF]DE\P H MDF\ PLR QLF\PX]\NLMX FL JQ Z WHVWURQ\OHSLHME\QDVWX
QLH]DVWDOLJG\QDGFL JQ =ZLMDP\REy]FKRSF\+HMQLHZLDVW\RG]LHZDVL L
SU]HOLF]\G]LHFL:\PDUV] \ZR
*G\]DWU]\PDOLVL QDQRFOHJ*HUDOWSRVWDQRZLZ\MD QLQLHMDVQR FL=ROWDQ
&KLYD\W\PUD]HPQLH]DVLDGGRJU\ZJZLQWDQLHE\RZL F SUREOHPyZ]
RGFL JQL FLHPJRZXVWURQQHPLHMVFHQDV]F]HU P VN UR]PRZ =DF] EH]
RZLMDQLDZEDZHQ
*DGDMVN G ZLHG]LDH H MHVWHPZLHG PLQHP"
.UDVQROXG\SQ QDQLHJRLX PLHFKQ VL SU]HELHJOH
0yJE\PFKHSLVL SU]HGWRE P VSRVWU]HJDZF]R FL 0yJE\PSRZLHG]LH
H ]DXZD \HPMDN]PLHQLDM VL WZRMHRF]\SR]PLHU]FKXLZSHQ\PVR FX
0yJE\PWH Z\ND]D HPNUDVQROXGE\ZD\LV\V]DHPQLHMHGQRR*HUDOFLH]
5LYLL$OHSUDZGDMHVWEDUG]LHMEDQDOQD1LHSDWU]ZLONLHP7\ G\VNUHWQ\DOHWZyM
SU]\MDFLHOEDUG SLHZDLJDGDJ EDPXVL QLH]DP\ND6W G ZLHPMDNDWZD
SURIHVMD
*HUDOWZVWU]\PDVL ] ]DGDQLHPNROHMQHJRS\WDQLD,VXV]QLH
1RGREUDSRGM =ROWDQ-DVNLHUZ\JDGDZV]\VWNR:\F]XPXVLD H
V]F]HUR VRELHFHQLP\DWHJR H P\GRZDVSU]\MD QLHXVSRVRELHQLQLHPXVLD
SU]HFLHZ\F]XZDERP\XVSRVRELH QLHNU\MHP\.UyWNRZLHPGODF]HJRFLWDN
QDSRXGQLHSLOQR:LHPMDNLHWRZD QHLSLOQHVSUDZ\GR1LOIJDDUGXFL ZLRG
:LHPNRJRWDPV]XND]DPLHU]DV],QLHW\ONR]SORWHNSRHW\0LHV]NDHPSU]HG
ZRMQ Z &LQWU]HLV\V]DHPRSRZLH FLR']LHFNX1LHVSRG]LDQFHLELDRZRV\P
ZLHG PLQLHNWyUHPX1LHVSRG]LDQNDE\DSU]H]QDF]RQD
*HUDOWLW\PUD]HPQLHVNRPHQWRZD
5HV]WDSRGM NUDVQROXGWRMX NZHVWLDREVHUZDFML3RQLHFKDH WHJR
VNRUXSLDWHJRREU]\GOLZFDFKRFLD H :LHG PLQDZLHG PL VN ZV]DN H VSUDZ
MHVWWDNLHPRQVWUDW SL$OHSRWZyUQLF]HJRWZRMHM1LHVSRG]LDQFHQLHZ\U] G]L
ZL F SR DRZDH PLHF]DSU]HS G]LH JRW\ONRZSRNU\ZN WXN F%R W\ WHUD]
QLH:LHG PLQDOHV]ODFKHWQ\U\FHU]NWyUHQSRUZDQHMLXFL QLRQHMG]LHZLF\QD
UDWXQHNVSLHV]\
:FL PQLHRF]DPLZLHUFLV]GRGDQDGDOQLHPRJ GRF]HNDVL RGSRZLHG]L
OXENRPHQWDU]D:FL ]GUDG Z V]\V]QLHVSRNRMQ\MDNWH Z\MDZLRQ\VHNUHW
SU]HFLZWRELHREUyFLVL PR H1LHJU\ VL 'RMG]LHP\ZVSyOQLHGR,Q\Z]DMHP
VRELHSRPDJDM FZVSLHUDM F VL Z]DMHP7DNLVDPFHOSU]HGWRE MDNLSU]HGQDPL
SU]H \L \GDOHM3RWRE\V]ODFKHWQ PLVM NRQW\QXRZD$OER \]Z\F]DMQLH
DOHWDNE\QLHPXVLHZVW\G]LVL Z JRG]LQLH PLHUFL7\P\ OLV] H VL
RGPLHQL H ZLDWVL RGPLHQL$SU]HFLHWDNLWHQ ZLDWMHVWMDNLZSU]yG\E\WDNL
VDP,W\MHVWH WDNLVDPMDNE\H 1LHJU\ VL
3RU]XP\ O RRG F]HQLXVL =ROWDQZ]QRZLPRQRORJQLHVSHV]RQ\
PLOF]HQLHPZLHG PLQDLRVDPRWQHMSRGUy \ QDSRXGQLHSU]H]%UXJJHL6RGGHQ
NX-DUXG]H0XVLV]SRV]XNDLQQHMGURJLGR1LOIJDDUGX&KFHV]GRUDG] FL
1LHGRUDG]DM*HUDOWSRPDVRZDNRODQRNWyUHJRRGNLONXGQLQLHSRU]XFDEyO
1LHGRUDG]DM=ROWDQ
2GQDOD]-DVNUDNLELFXM FHJRXSL F\PZJZLQWDNUDVQROXGRP%H]VRZDZ]L
SRHW ]DU NDZLRGFL JQ ZODV-DVNLHURGUD]X]RULHQWRZDVL RFRFKRG]L
Z\VWDUF]\RPXMHGQHJRVSRMU]HQLDQDWZDU]ZLHG PLQD
3DSODSRZLHG]LDFLFKR*HUDOW*DGXD.DSLJ ED- ]RUE\FLZOHV]F]RW
GHVWHU:LVWRFLHDGQDV]WXND HOD]D
+ SDUVNQ 3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFK6]WXND HOD]D:H L OHSLHMVL
SU]\MU]\MER]DFKZLO JRWyZ H WRNDZDNLHPFKU]DQXQD]ZD
0LDHPNLHG\ OHSV]\PLHF]
1LHSU]HF] Z]UXV]\UDPLRQDPL=ROWDQ%RQLHFK\EQLHSRFKRG]L]QDV]\FK
NX QL:\ZLHG PLQLXPLHFLHPLHF]DPLZ\ZLMDDOHSU]HFLHVDPLLFKQLHURELFLH
7DNLHPLHF]HW\ONRXQDVVL NXMHZ0DKDNDPLHSRGJyU &DUERQ
.UDVQROXG\Z\WDSLDM VWDOGRGD3HUFL\DOLZ\NXZDM ZDUVWZRZHJRZQLH
$OHWRP\JQRP\]DMPXMHP\VL V]OLIHPLRVWU]HQLHP:QDV]\FKZDUV]WDWDFK
:HGOHQDV]HMJQRPLHMWHFKQRORJLLWDNMDNQLHJG\ URELOL P\QDV]HJZ\K\U\
QDMOHSV]HPLHF]H ZLDWD
0LHF]NWyU\WHUD]QRV] *HUDOWREQD \NOLQJ SRFKRG]L]%URNLORQX]
NDWDNXPEQD&UDDJ$Q'RVWDHPJRRGGULDG3LHUZV]RU] GQDEUR DSU]HFLH DQL
NUDVQROXG]NDDQLJQRPLD7RHOILEU]HV]F]RWPD]HVWRDOERLGZLH FLHODW
2QVL Z RJyOHQLH]QD]DZRDJQRPELRU F PLHF]GRU NLLZRG] F SRQLP
SDOFDPL:\NR F]HQLHMHVWHOILHRZV]HP5 NRMH MHOHFLJRZLFD7DN H HOILH
MHVWWUDZLHQLHU\WF\]HOHUNDLLQQH]GRELHQLD$OHJRZQLDMHVWNXWDLRVWU]RQDZ
0DKDNDPLH,SUDZGDWR H Z\NRZDQRM SDU ZLHNyZWHPXZVWHF]ERRGUD]X
ZLGDWHWRSR OHGQLDVWDOLREUyENDSU\PLW\ZQD2WSU]\y GRQLHJRVLKLOO
=ROWDQDZLG]LV]Uy QLF "
:LG] 0yMVSUDZLDZUD HQLHQLHJRU]HMZ\NRQDQHJR
*QRPSDUVNQ LPDFKQ U N =ROWDQX PLHFKQ VL = Z\ V]R FL
%U]HV]F]RWZ\MD QLPHQWRUVNLPWRQHPPDFL DQLHVSUDZLDZUD HQLHL
QLHSRZUD HQLXVL JDRFHQLD5]HF]ZW\P H WZyMPLHF]WR]Z\NDNRPSR]\FMD
VWDOLL HOD]DDPyMVLKLOOPDJRZQL NXW ]HVWRSXXV]ODFKHWQLRQHJRJUDILWHPL
ERUDNVHP
1RZRF]HVQDWHFKQLNDQLHZ\WU]\PD3HUFLYDOJRU F]NXM F VL QLHFR
DOERZLHPG\VNXUVQLHFK\EQLHVFKRG]LQDGREU]H]QDQHPXVSUDZ\.RQVWUXNFMDL
NRPSR]\FMDJRZQLOLF]QHZDUVWZ\PL NNLHJRUG]HQLDRNXWHWZDUG QLH]D
PL NN VWDO
=ZROQD]ZROQD]PLW\JRZDJRNUDVQROXG0HWDOXUJD]QLHJRQLH]URELV]
6FKXWWHQEDFKQLHQXG JRGHWDODPL-DPXWRZ\MD QL SURVWR'REU WZDUG
PDJQHW\WRZ VWDOZLHGPLQLHQLHV\FKDQLHWUXGQRQDRVWU]\'ODF]HJR"%RMHVW
WZDUGD*G\VL QLHG\VSRQXMHWHFKQRORJL WDNMDNP\QLHJG\ DZ\GRG]LVLDMD
FKFHVL PLHRVWU\PLHF]XWZDUG]RQ\UG]H JRZQLRNXZDVL QDNUDZ G]LDFK
PL NN VWDO PQLHMRSRUQ Z REUyEFH7DN ZD QLHXSURV]F]RQ PHWRG
Z\NRQDQ\MHVWWZyMEURNLOR VNLPLHF]1RZRF]HVQHNOLQJLZ\NRQDQHV RGZURWQLH
PL NNLUG]H WZDUGHRVWU]H2EUyENDMHVWF]DVRFKRQQDLMDNSRZLHG]LDHP
Z\PDJD]DDZDQVVZDQHMWHFKQRORJLL$OHZUH]XOWDFLHPR QDRWU]\PDNOLQJ
NWyU GDMHVL SU]HFL ZSRZLHWU]XSRGU]XFRQ\EDW\VWRZ\IXODU
7ZRLPVLKLOOHPGDVL GRNRQDWDNLHMV]WXNL"
1LHX PLHFKQ VL NUDVQROXG7DNZ\RVWU]RQHHJ]HPSODU]HPR QDQD
SDOFDFKSROLF]\LU]DGNRNWyU\Z\V]HGSR]D0DKDNDP$OHJZDUDQWXM FL
VNRUXSDWDPWHJRNRVWURSDWHJRNUDEDVWDZLDE\VLKLOORZL]QLNRP\RSyU3RFL E\
JRQDSRUFMHLQDZHWE\ VL QLH]P F]\
'\VNXVMDRPLHF]DFKLPHWDOXUJLLWUZDDMHV]F]HF]DVMDNL *HUDOWSU]\VXFKLZD
VL ] ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHPG]LHOLZDVQ\PLGR ZLDGF]HQLDPLX]XSHQLDZLHG]
S\WDRWRLRZRRJO GDLZ\SUyERZ\ZD=ROWDQRZ\VLKLOO1LHZLG]LDMHV]F]H H
MX QD]DMXWU]SU]\MG]LHPXX]XSHQLWHRUL SUDNW\N
3LHUZV]\PV\JQDHP H ZRNROLF\PLHV]NDM OXG]LHE\VWRM F\Z UyGZLyUyZL
NRU\UyZQ\V J RSDRZHJRGUHZQDGRVWU]H RQ\SU]\GXNFLHSU]H]LG FHJRZ
DZDQJDUG]LH3HUFLYDOD6FKXWWHQEDFKD
=ROWDQ]DWU]\PDSRFKyGLZ\VLDJQRPDQDGDOHNL]ZLDG3HUFLYDO]QLNDSR
SyJRG]LQLHZUyFLS GHPSRGQLHFRQ\L]G\V]DQ\]GDOHNDJHVW\NXOXM F'RELHJ
DOHPLDVWRGUD]XSU]\VW SLFGRUHODFMLFKZ\FLVL SDOFDPL]DGXJLQRVL
Z\VPDUNDSRW QLH]RGJRVHPSU]\SRPLQDM F\PJUDQLHSDVWHUVNLHMWURPELW\
1LHSRV]]ZLHU]\Q\ZDUNQ =ROWDQ&KLYD\,JDGDM&RWDPSU]HGQDPL"
6DG\EDZ\G\V]DJQRPZ\FLHUDM F SDOFHZSR\VZHJRRSDWU]RQHJR
OLF]Q\PLNLHV]HQLDPLNDEDWD1DSRODQLH&KDXSWU]\VWRGRDSDU NOHFL3R
SRGZyU]XODWDSLHVD]NRPLQDG\PL6WUDZDVL WDPyMJRWXMH2ZVLDQNDLWRQD
POHNX
7\FRZNXFKQLE\H " ]D PLDVL -DVNLHU'RJDUQNyZ]DJO GDH " 6N G
ZLHV] H WRRZVLDQND"
*QRPVSRMU]DQDQLHJR]Z\ V]R FL D=ROWDQSU\FKQ JQLHZQLH
1LHREUD DMJRSRHWR2QZ\Z V]\ DUFLHQDPLO -H OLPyZL H WRRZVLDQND
]QDF]\RZVLDQND&KROHUDQLHSRGREDPLVL WR
$WRF]HPX"0QLHRZVLDQNDVL SRGRED=MDGE\P]FK FL
=ROWDQPDUDFM SRZLHG]LDD0LOYD$W\PLOF]-DVNLHUERWRQLHSRH]MD
-H OLRZVLDQNDMHVWQDPOHNXWRWDPMHVWNURZD$NPLHNWyUHQ]RF]\G\P\
ELHU]HNURZ L ]P\NDZNQLHM &]HPXWHQDNXUDWQLH]HPNQ "6NU FDMP\ZODV
REHMG P\XNLHP OHPLWRSDFKQLH
=ZROQD]ZROQDPUXNQ NUDVQROXG8FLHF]DZV]H]G \P\$PR H MX
SRZRMQLH"0R H UXV]\DVL ZUHV]FLHWHPHUVNDDUPLD"&RP\WXZLHP\ZWHM
NQLHL"0R H MX JG]LHZDOQDE\DELWZDPR H RGSDUW\1LOIJDDUGPR H IURQWMX ]D
QDPLFKRSLLNURZ\GRGRPyZZUDFDM " 7U]HEDVSUDZG]LZ\ZLHG]LHVL
)LJJLV0XQURREDMWX]RVWD FLHDRF]\PLHMFLHRWZDUWH0\]D XF]\QLP\
UHNRQHVDQV-H OLE G]LHEH]SLHF]QLH]DZRDPJRVHPNURJXOFD
*RVHPNURJXOFD"QLHVSRNRMQLHSRUXV]\EURG 0XQUR%UX\V3U]HFLHW\
SRM FLDQLHPDV]RQD ODGRZDQLXSWDVLFKJRVyZ=ROWDQ
,RWRFKRG]L*G\XV\V]\V]G]LZQ\QLHSRGREQ\GRQLF]HJRJRVWRE G M
3HUFLYDOSURZDG *HUDOWSyMG]LHV]]QDPL"
:V]\VF\SyMG]LHP\-DVNLHU]VLDG]NRQLD*G\E\WRE\DMDND ]DVDG]NDZ
GX HMJUXSLHE G]LHEH]SLHF]QLHM
=RVWDZLDPZDP)HOGPDUV]DND=ROWDQ]GM SDSXJ ] UDPLHQLDLSRGDM
)LJJLVRZL0HUOX]]R3WDV]\VNRJRWRZH]QDJD]DF] NXUZDPLVDG]L
ZQLHERJRV\LGLDEOLZH]P VNU\WHSRGHM FLH,G]LHP\
3HUFLYDOV]\ENRZ\SURZDG]LLFKQDVNUDMODVXZJ VWHNU]DNLG]LNLHJRE]X=D
NU]DNDPLWHUHQOHNNRRSDGDSL WU]\DVL WDPNXSDZ\NDUF]RZDQ\FKSQLDNyZ
'DOHMUR]FL JDDVL ZLHONDSRODQD:\MU]HOLRVWUR QLH
5HODFMDJQRPDE\DSUHF\]\MQD1D URGNXSRODQ\IDNW\F]QLHVWD\WU]\FKDXS\
5R]G]LD
0DQGUDJRUDDG]LZRVWU WURG]DMUR OLQ]URG]LQ\SVLDQNRZDW\FKREHMPXM F\
UR OLQ\]LHOQHEH]RG\JRZH]NRU]HQLDPLU]HSRZHPLZNWyU\FKGRVWU]HFPR QD
SRGRELH VWZRGRSRVWDFLOXG]NLHMOL FLH]HEUDQHV Z UR]HW 0DXWXPQDOLVD
RIILFLQDOLVXSUDZLDQDQDQLHZLHON VNDO Z 9LFRYDUR5RZDQL<PODFG]LNRUR QLH
U]DGNR-DJRG\]LHORQHQDVW SQLH yNQ FHMDGDQHV ] RFWHPLSLHSU]HPOL FLH
X \ZDM VL Z VWDQLHVXURZ\P.RU]H PG]L FHQLRQ\ZPHG\F\QLHLIDUPDFML
PLDGDZQLHMZLHONLH]QDF]HQLHZ]DERERQDFK]ZDV]F]DXOXGyZ3yQRF\
Z\U]\QDQR]QLHJRILJXUNLOXG]NLHDLUXQLNLDLUDXQ\LSU]HFKRZ\ZDQRZGRPDFK
MDNRV]DFRZQ\WDOL]PDQ8ZD DQRMH]DRFKURQ RGFKRUyEGDZD\V]F] FLHZ
SURFHVDFKNRELHWRP]DSHZQLD\SRGQR LDWZHSRURG\6WURMRQRMHZVXNLHQNLL
QDQRZLXGDZDQRQRZ RG]LH .RU]HQLDPLPSURZDG]RQRKDQGHODFHQDLFK
GRFKRG]LDGRV]H G]LHVL FLXIORUHQyZ'RWHJR FHOXX \ZDQHE\\NRU]HQLH
SU]HVW SXRE:HGOH]DERERQXE\NRU]H PX \ZDQ\GRF]DUyZL
F]DURG]LHMVNLFKILOWUyZDWDN H WUXFL]QSU]HV G WHQSRZUyFLZRNUHVLHSRORZD QD
F]DURZQLFH=DU]XW]EURGQLF]HJRSRVXJLZDQLDVL PSRVWDZLRQRPLQZSURFHVLH
/XNUH]LL9LJRRE8 \ZDPMDNRWUXFL]Q\PLDDWH OHJHQGDUQD)LOLSSD(OLKDUG
RE
(IIHQEHUJL7DOERW
(QF\FORSDHGLD0D[LPD0XQGLWRP,;
5R]G]LDWU]HFL
O HMV] PLHU
:\V]HG]WUXPQ\SRNLZDJRZ -DVNLHUSDWU] F QD*HUDOWDZ\PRZQLH
W\ONRSRWRE\]JQLZMDNLP URZLH
1DW\PVNR F]\RVL HSLWDILXPGOD&DKLUDV\QD&HDOODFKDZ\SXV]F]RQHJR]
WUXPQ\1LOIJDDUGF]\NDNWyU\WZLHUG]L H QLHMHVW1LOIJDDUGF]\NLHP:L FHMRQLP
MX QLHUR]PDZLDQR3RQLHZD *HUDOWPLPRZLHORNURWQ\FKJUy E QLHNZDSLVL
MDNR UR]VWD]QDURZLVW 3RWN FLVNDGRVLDG=ROWDQ&KLYD\.UDVQROXGQLHVL JD
QRJDPLVWU]HPLRQDOHRJLHUHNE\DJRGQ\LGDZDVRE SRZRGRZD
1RF ZLGQRNU J ZFL MD QLDRGXQ]DGQLDZVW JLG\PyZXQRVL\VL Z QLHER
EUXG] F E NLW:NUyWFHWUDILOLQDVSDORQH]DEXGRZDQLDRJLH QDGDOMHV]F]HSH]D
SR]Z JORQ\FKEHONDFKLNDOHQLFDFK7X RSRGDO]JOLV]F]VLHG]LDRR PLX
REHUZDQFyZLSL SVyZVROLGDUQLH]DM W\FKREMDGDQLHPUHV]WHNPL VD]
UR]G WHJR]Z JORQHJRSRF] FLNR VNLHJR FLHUZD1DZLGRNNUDVQROXGyZ
XF]WXM F\]HPNQ OLZSRSRFKX=RVWDW\ONRMHGHQF]RZLHNLMHGHQSLHVNWyU\FK
DGQDJUR]DQLHE\D]GROQDRGHUZDRGQDMH RQHMJU]HELHQLHP HEHUSDGOLQ\
=ROWDQL3HUFLYDOVSUyERZDOLLQGDJRZDF]RZLHNDDOHQLF]HJRVL QLHGRZLHG]LHOL
&]RZLHNNZLOLW\ONRG\JRWDZFL JDJRZ Z UDPLRQDLGDZLVL ]G]LHUDQ\PL]
JQDWyZRFKDSDPL3LHVZDUF]DLRGVDQLD] E\D SRNUD FHG]L VH.R VNL
]HZRNFXFKQ ZVWU WQLH
=DU\]\NRZDOLLQLHSRU]XFLOLGURJLNWyUDZNUyWFHGRSURZDG]LDLFKGRNROHMQHJR
SRJRU]HOLVND3XV]F]RQRWX]G\PHPVSRU ZLH ZSREOL X NWyUHMPXVLDRWH
GRM GRSRW\F]NLERWX ]DG\PL F\PLUXLQDPL]REDF]\OL ZLH \ NXUKDQ$Z
SHZQHMRGOHJR FL]DNXUKDQHPUyVQDUR]VWDMDFKROEU]\PLG E' E E\
REZLHV]RQ\ R G]LDPL
,OXG PL
7U]HEDWRREHMU]H]DGHF\GRZD=ROWDQ&KL\D\NDG F NUHVG\VNXVMLRU\]\NX
L ]DJUR HQLX3RGMHG P\EOL HM
3RMDN FKROHU XQLyVVL -DVNLHUFKFHV]RJO GDW\FKZLVLHOFyZ=ROWDQ"
HE\LFKREHGU]H":LG] VW G H QLHPDM QDZHWEXWyZ
*XSL 1LHRLFKEXW\PLFKRG]LDOHRV\WXDFM PLOLWDUQ 2UR]ZyMZ\GDU]H
QDWHDWU]HG]LDD ZRMHQQ\FK&]HJRUHFKRF]HV]"7\MHVWH SRHWDQLHZLHV]FRWR
VWUDWHJLD
=DVNRF] FL :LHP
$MDFLSRZLDGDP H QLHUR]SR]QDE\ VWUDWHJLLQDZHWZWHG\JG\E\
Z\VNRF]\D]NU]DNyZLNRSQ DFL Z GXS
:U]HF]\VDPHMWDNLHME\PQLHUR]SR]QD6WUDWHJLHZ\VNDNXM FH]NU]DNyZ
]RVWDZLDPNUDVQROXGRP:LV] FHQDG EDFKUyZQLH
=ROWDQPDFKQ U N L SRPDV]HURZDZVWURQ GU]HZD-DVNLHUNWyU\QLJG\QLH
SRWUDILRSDQRZDFLHNDZR FLSRS G]L3HJD]DLSRMHFKD]DQLPVW SD*HUDOWSR
FKZLOL]DVWDQRZLHQLDUXV]\Z ODG=REDF]\ H 0LOYDMHG]LH]DQLP
HUXM FHQDWUXSDFKZURQ\]RFL JDQLHP]HUZD\VL QDLFKZLGRNNUDF] F L
V]XPL F SLyUDPL1LHNWyUHRGOHFLD\NXODVRZLLQQHSU]HVLDG\VL W\ONRQDZ\ V]H
JD ]LHSRW QHJRGU]HZD]]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHPSU]\JO GDM F VL )HOGPDUV]DNRZL
'XG]LHNWyU\]UDPLHQLDNUDVQROXGDSOXJDZLHXEOL DLFKPDWNRP
3LHUZV]\]VLHGPLXZLVLHOFyZPLDQDSLHUVLWDEOLF]N ] QDSLVHP=GUDMFD
QDURGX'UXJLZLVLDMDNR.RODERUDQWWU]HFLMDNR(OILNDSX F]ZDUW\MDNR
'H]HUWHU3L WDE\DNRELHWDZSRGDUW\PLSRNUZDZLRQ\PJLH OHR]QDNRZDQD
MDNR1LOIJDDUG]NDNXUZD'ZyFKZLVLHOFyZQLHPLDRWDEOLF]HN]F]HJRQDOH DR
ZQRVL H ZLVLHOLSU]\SDGNRZR
'REUDMHVWUR]UDGRZDVL =ROWDQ&KLYD\ZVND]XM F QDWDEOLF]NL:LG]LFLH"
3U]HV]\W G\QDV]HZRMVND1DVLFKRSF\PDORZDQLSU]HV]OLGRRIHQV\Z\RGSDUOL
DJUHVRUD,PLHOLMDNZLG] F]DVQDRGSRF]\QHNLZRMDFNLHUR]U\ZNL
,FRWRGODQDVR]QDF]D"
7R H IURQWSU]HVXQ VL MX DRG1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZRGG]LHODQDVZRMVNR
WHPHUVNLH-HVWH P\EH]SLHF]QL
$G\P\SU]HGQDPL"
7RQDVLR ZLDGF]\SHZQ\PJRVHPNUDVQROXG3DO ZLRVNLZNWyU\FKGDQR
:LHZLyUNRPQRFOHJOXEVS\ -HVWH P\MX ]DIURQWHPSRZLDGDPZDP=WHJR
UR]VWDMDELHJQLHSRXGQLRZ\V]ODNNWyU\ZLHG]LHGR$UPHULLSUH]\GLXPOH FHJR
Z ZLGDFK&KRWOLL,Q\'URJDZ\JO GDSRU] GQLHPR HP\QL L
1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZO NDVL MX QLHPXVLP\
*G]LHVL G\PLWDPVL SDOLRGH]ZDDVL 0LOYD$JG]LHVL SDOLWDPVL
VSDU]\PR QD7DNVRELHP\ O H JXSLDWRU]HF]QDRJLH VL NLHURZD*XSLD
WRU]HF]GURJ L QDNWyUHMMD]GDZPLJPR H QDVRJDUQ =DSDGQLMP\ZODV\
7 G\SU]HV]OL7HPHUF]\F\OXEDUPLD]6RGGHQXSLHUDVL NUDVQROXG
-HVWH P\]DIURQWHP0R HP\EH]O NXZDOLJR FL FHPMH HOLQDSRWNDP\ZRMVND
WRQDV]H
+D]DUGRZQLHSRNU FLDJRZ XF]QLF]ND-H OLWDNL]FLHELHZRMHQQLN
=ROWDQWRZLHV]SU]HFLH H 1LOIJDDUG]Z\NE\GDOHNR]DJRQ\MD]G\SXV]F]D
7XWDME\OL7HPHUF]\F\PR H WRE\$OHFRMHVWSU]HGQDPLWHJRQLHZLHP\1LHER
QDSRXGQLXD F]DUQHRGG\PXDQLFK\ELJRU]HMHZD QLHRZRWZRMHSUH]\GLXPZ
$UPHULL7HG\P\QLH]DIURQWHPDOHQDIURQFLH0R HP\QDG]LDVL QDZRMVNR
QDPDUXGHUyZQDOX QHKXOWDMVWZRQD:LHZLyUNL,G P\NX&KRWOLDOHGXNWDPL
5DFMDSRSDUWM -DVNLHU0QLHWH QLHSRGREDM VL WDPWHG\P\1DZHWMH OL
7HPHULDSU]HV]DGRRIHQV\Z\SU]HGQDPLPRJ E\MHV]F]HZ\VIRURZDQH
QLOIJDDUG]NLHV]ZDGURQ\&]DUQLUREL GDOHNLHUDMG\:\FKRG] QDW\\ F] VL ]H
6FRLD
WDHOUREL P W L]DZUDFDM 3DPL WDPFRG]LDRVL Z *yUQ\P6RGGHQ
SRGF]DVSRSU]HGQLHMZRMQ\7H MHVWHP]GDQLD HE\L ODVDPL:ODVDFKQLFQDP
QLH]DJUR]L
1LHE\E\PWHJRWDNLSHZLHQ*HUDOWZVND]DQDRVWDWQLHJRZLVLHOFDNWyU\
FKRG\QGDZ\VRNR]DPLDVWVWySPLDSRRUDQHSD]XUDPLVNUZDZLRQHNLNXW\]H
VWHUF] F\PLNR PL6SyMU]FLH7RURERWDJKXOL
8SLRUyZ"=ROWDQ&KLYD\FRIQ VL VSOXQ 7UXSRMDGyZ"
-DNQDMEDUG]LHM:QRF\Z UyGODVyZPXVLP\VL VWU]HF
.UUUUZDPD]DVNU]HF]D)HOGPDUV]DHN'XGD
=XVWPLWRZ\M H SWDNX]PDUV]F]\EUZL=ROWDQ&KLYD\2WSRSDGOLP\Z
NDED -DN H ZL F":ODVJG]LHXSLRU\F]\GURJ JG]LHZRMVNDLPDUXGHU]\"
:ODV\SRZLHG]LDD]SU]HNRQDQLHP0LOYD$FRJ VWV]H:RO JKXOHQL OL
OXG]L
2SRZWyU]\=ROWDQ
&R"*G]LH"VS\WD-DVNLHUVWDM F ZVWU]HPLRQDFKL]DJO GDM F GRZ ZR]XZ
NLHUXQNXZVND]\ZDQ\PSU]H]NUDVQROXGD1LF]HJRQLHZLG]
2
1LHSOHMDNSDSXJD&RR"
5]HF]NDZ\MD QLVSRNRMQLH=ROWDQ3UDZ\GRS\Z&KRWOL1D]\ZDVL 2
$DD
6N G H ]QRZX]D PLDVL 3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFK5]HF]ND$ZSDGDGR
&KRWOLZJyU]HU]HNLNDZDGURJLVW G7RMHVW2QLH$
3DUyZGQHPNWyUHJRS\Q DU]HF]NDRQLHVNRPSOLNRZDQHMQD]ZLH]DUR QL W\
E\VL JDM F SRQDGJRZ\SLHV]\FKNUDVQROXGyZSRNU]\Z SU]HQLNOLZLHSDFKQLD
PL W L ]EXWZLD\PGUHZQHPLUR]EU]PLHZDQLHXVWDQQ\PUHFKRWHP DE0LDWH
VWURPH]ERF]DLWHZD QLHRND]DRVL IDWDOQH:y]9HU\/RHZHQKDXSWNWyU\RG
SRF] WNXSRGUy \ G]LHOQLH]QRVLSU]HFLZQR FLORVXLSRNRQDZV]\VWNLH
SU]HV]NRG\SU]HJUDZVWDUFLX]U]HF]N 2:\PNQ VL ] U N VSURZDG]DM F\FKJR
Z GyNUDVQROXGyZ]MHFKDSRGVNDNXM F QDVDPRGQRMDUXLUR]OHFLDVL
GRNXPHQWQLH
5UUXUUZDPD]DVNU]HF]D)HOGPDUV]DHN'XGDNRQWUDSXQNWXM F FKyUDOQ\
RNU]\N=ROWDQDLMHJRNRPSDQLL
QDSRODQ\QLVNLHEU]H]LQ\LVXFKH NL0LPRWHJRMHFKDOLZROQR=DSU]\NDGHP
0LOY\NWyUDQDW\FKPLDVWSRZ\UXV]HQLXZ]L DQD N SLHJRZDW G]LHZXV]N ]
ZDUNRF]\NDPL-DVNLHUUyZQLH SRVDG]LG]LHFNRQD3HJD]DD=ROWDQZ]L QD
FLVDZHJRRJLHUNDGZRMHVDPV]HGRERNWU]\PDM F ZRG]H$OHWHPSRQLHZ]URVR
NRELHW\].HUQyZQLHE\\ZVWDQLHQDG \
NRURQDPLGU]HZ7HG\SLHUZV]DNRQFHSFMDMHVWWDNDSOX P\QDU]HF]N
]DZUyP\Z\MG P\]MDUyZ]QRZXQDVXFK\WHUHQLLG P\SU]H])HQ&DPZVNUR
PL G]\U]HF]DD GR&KRWOL
'UXJDNRQFHSFMD"
2MHVWS\WND&KRSRRVWDWQLFKGHV]F]DFKQLHVLHZL FHMZRG\QL ]Z\NOH
PR QDM SU]HEURG]L7QLMP\PHDQGU\EURG] F VWUXJ LOHNUR]DJURG]LQDP
V]ODN7U]\PDM F NLHUXQHNSRGOHVR FDZ\MG]LHP\ZSURVWQDZLG\&KRWOLL,Q\
1LHRGH]ZDVL QDJOH:LHG PLQ=GUXJLHMNRQFHSFMLSURSRQXM RGUD]X
]UH]\JQRZD1DZHWRW\PQLHP\ OP\1DWDPW\PEU]HJXSU G]HMF]\Sy QLHM
ZSDNXMHP\VL QDNWyUH ] 0LHFKXQRZ\FK8URF]\VN7RSDVNXGQHPLHMVFD
VWDQRZF]RUDG] WU]\PDVL RGQLFK]GDOHND
=QDV]WHG\WHWHUHQ\"%\H WXNLHG\ " :LHV]MDNVL VW G Z\GRVWD"
:LHG PLQPLOF]DSU]H]FKZLO
%\HPWDPUD]SRZLHG]LDWU F F]RR7U]\ODWDWHPX$OHZMHFKDHP]
SU]HFLZQHMVWURQ\RGZVFKRGX=PLHU]DHPNX%UXJJHLFKFLDHPVNUyFLVRELH
GURJ $MDNVL Z\GRVWDHPQLHSDPL WDP%RZ\ZLH]LRQRPQLHSy \ZHJRQD
ZR]LH
.UDVQROXGSDWU]\QDQLHJRSU]H]FKZLO DOHZL FHMS\WD QLH]DGDZD
=DZUyFLOLZPLOF]HQLX.RELHW\].HPyZV]\]WUXGHPSRW\NDM F VL L
ZVSLHUDM F QDNRVWXUDFKDOH DGQDQLHXURQLDVRZDVNDUJL0LOYDMHFKDDWX RERN
ZLHG PLQDSRGWU]\PDM F ZUDPLRQDFKX SLRQ QD NXG]LHZXV]N ]
ZDUNRF]\NDPL
0LDUNXM RGH]ZDDVL QDJOH H SRKDUDWDOLFL WDPQDXURF]\VNDFKZWHG\
WU]\URNLWHPX-DNL SRWZyUPQLHPDP+D]DUGRZQHPDV]]DM FLH*HUDOW
1LHSU]HF]
-DZLHPSRFKZDOLVL ] W\X-DVNLHUMDNWRZWHG\E\R%\H UDQQ\MDNL
NXSLHFZ\ZLy]FL VWDPW GDSRWHPQD=DU]HF]XRGQDOD]H &LUL0yZLDPLR
W\P<HQQHIHU
1DG ZL N LPLHQLD0LOYDX PLHFKQ DVL OHNNR8ZDG]H*HUDOWDWRQLHXV]R
3RVWDQRZLQDQDMEOL V]\PELZDNX]GURZRQDWU]H-DVNURZLXV]X]D
QLHSRKDPRZDQHPLHOHQLHR]RUHP=QDM F SRHW QLHOLF]\MHGQDNQDHIHNW\W\P
EDUG]LHM H SUDZGRSRGREQLH-DVNLHUZ\SDSODMX ZV]\VWNRFRZLHG]LD
0R H OHVL MHGQDNVWDRSRZLHG]LDDSRFKZLOLXF]QLF]ND H QLH
SRMHFKDOL P\QDWDPWHQEU]HJQDXURF]\VND-H OL ZRQF]DVG]LHZF]\Q RGQDOD]
(OI\SRZLDGDM H MH OLZWyU\UD]WDNLHPLHMVFHRGZLHG]LJG]LHVL FR
Z\GDU]\RWRF]DVSRZWyU]\VL PR H0yZL QDWR3VLDPD]DSRPQLDDP
6WU\F]HNORVX"
3 WODSRSUDZL3 WODORVX
7IXVNU]\ZLVL -DVNLHU3U]HVWDOLE\ FLHJDGDRVWU\F]NDFKLS WODFK0QLH
NLHG\ HOINDZ\ZUy \D H QDUXV]WRZDQLXSR HJQDPWHQSDGyH]]DVSUDZ
PDRGREUHJRPLVWU]D1LHZLHU] ZSUDZG]LHZWHJRW\SXWDQLHZUy ELDUVWZRDOH
SDU GQLWHPXSU]\ QLRPLVL H PQLHZLHV]DM 2EXG]LHPVL FD\VSRFRQ\
OLQ\QLHPRJHPSU]HNQ DQLWFKX]DSD1LHUDGZL F VXFKDPMDNNWR R
V]XELHQLFDFKUR]SUDZLD
1LHGRFLHELHJDGDPMHQRGRZLHG PLQDRGSDURZDD0LOYD$W\XV]yZQLH
QDGVWDZLDMWHG\QLFSDVNXGQHJRQLHZOHFLGRQLFK&R*HUDOW"&RQDRZ S WO
ORVXU]HNQLHV]"*G\E\ P\QDXURF]\VNDSRMHFKDOLDQX SRZWyU]\OE\VL F]DV"
'ODWHJRGREU]H H ]DZUyFLOL P\RGSRZLHG]LDV]RUVWNR1LHPDP
QDMPQLHMV]HMRFKRW\SRZWDU]DNRV]PDUX
ZU]XFDFLHDOHRWRLOHGUDFKPDDOUDXQ\NRV]WXMH=E\WGURJLWRWUXQHNMDNGODQDV
0DQGUDJRUDV]HSQ ]SRG]LZHP-DVNLHUZVND]XM F QDSL WU] F VL Z N FLH
V]DDVXNXSN EXOZSU]\SRPLQDM F\FKPDHEXUDNLFXNURZH7RMHVWPDQGUDJRUD"
3UDZG]LZDPDQGUDJRUD"
2GPLDQD H VNDNLZQ JRZ DOFKHPLN5R QLHZGX \FKVNXSLVNDFK
ZD QLHQDFPHQWDU]XQDNWyU\PSU]\V]RQDPVL SR]QDMRPL'ODWHJRWH WXWDM
ZD QLHVS G]DPODWR
:LHG PLQZ\PRZQLHVSRMU]DQD=ROWDQD.UDVQROXGPUXJQ 5HJLV
X PLHFKQ VL SyJ ENLHP
3URV] SURV] SDQRZLHMH OLPDFLHRFKRW VHUGHF]QLH]DSUDV]DPGR
GHJXVWDFML'RFHQLDPZDV]WDNWDOHZREHFQHMV\WXDFMLPDRPDPV]DQVE\
GRZLH HOLNVLU\GRREM WHJRZRMQ 'LOOLQJHQ7RZV]\VWNRLWDNPXVLDRE\VL
]PDUQRZDZ]ZL ]NX]F]\PQLHPyZP\RFHQDFK3U]HSUDV]DPDOHQDF]\QLH
GRSLFLDPDPW\ONRMHGQR
:\VWDUF]\PUXNQ =ROWDQELRU F PHQ]XUN L RVWUR QLHQDF]HUSXM F ]
FHEU]\ND3D VNLH]GURZLHSDQLH5HJLV8XXXXXFK
3URV] Z\EDF]HQLDX PLHFKQ VL ]QRZXF\UXOLN-DNR GHVW\ODWX
SR]RVWDZLD]DSHZQHZLHOHGR \F]HQLD7RZ]DVDG]LHSyIDEU\NDW
7RQDMOHSV]\SyIDEU\NDWMDNLZ \FLXSLHP]DSDRGGHFK=ROWDQ0DV]
SRHWR
$DDDFK2PDWNRPRMD3U]HGQL6SUyEXM*HUDOW
*RVSRGDU]RZL:LHG PLQXNRQLVL OHNNRZVWURQ (PLHOD5HJLVD*G]LH
WZRMHPDQLHU\-DVNLHU"
5DF]FLHZ\EDF]\SDQRZLHRGNRQLVL DOFKHPLNDOHQLHSR]ZDODPVRELH
QD DGQHX \ZNL=GURZLHMX QLHWRFRQLHJG\ SU]\V]R]UH]\JQRZD]ZLHOX
SU]\MHPQR FL
1DZHW\F]ND"
&KRG]LR]DVDG Z\MD QLVSRNRMQLH5HJLV1LJG\QLHDPL ]DVDGNWyUHVDP
VRELHRNUH ODP
3RG]LZLDPL]D]GURV]F] SU\QF\SLDOQR FL*HUDOWXSLQLHFR]PHQ]XUNLSR
FKZLOLZDKDQLDJROQ GRGQD:GHOHNWRZDQLXVL VPDNLHPSU]HV]NRG]L\QLHFR
]\FLHNQ FH]RF]X3R R GNXUR]ODRVL R \ZF]HFLHSR
3yMG SR0LOY ]DRILDURZDVL RGGDM F QDF]\QLHNUDVQROXGRZL1LH
Z\GXGOLMFLHZV]\VWNLHJRQLPZUyFLP\
0LOYDVLHG]LDDZSREOL X NRQLSU]HNRPDU]DM F VL ] SLHJRZDW G]LHZXV]N
NWyU FD\G]LH ZLR]DQD NX*G\GRZLHG]LDDVL R JR FLQQR FL5HJLVD]UD]X
Z]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPLDOHQLHGDDVL GXJRSURVL
*G\ZHV]OLGRV]DDVX]DVWDOLWRZDU]\VWZRSU]\RJO G]LQDFK]PDJD]\QRZDQ\FK
NRU]HQLPDQGUDJRU\
3LHUZV]\UD]ZLG] SU]\]QDVL -DVNLHUREUDFDM F ZSDOFDFKN F]DVW EXOZ
5]HF]\ZL FLHQLHFRSU]\SRPLQDF]RZLHND
3RNU FRQHJRSU]H]OXPEDJRVWZLHUG]L=ROWDQ$WHQGUXJLRZ\SLV]
Z\PDOXMEDEDZFL \7HQ]D ]SU]HSURV]HQLHPMDNE\GZRMHOXG]L]DM W\FK
SRFK Gy N
:DPW\ONRMHGQRZJRZLH0LOYDFKZDFNRZ\FK\OLDQDSHQLRQ PHQ]XUN
&RPR HV]PLQDWRSRUDG]L"
1LFQLHVWHW\-HV]F]HSU]H]GXJLF]DVE G]LHV]QLHRP\OQLHSU]HZLG\ZDVRW
=LP EyOHVL QDVLO 1LH]DOHFDE\PFLMHGQDNVLOQ\FKOHNyZ]QLHF]XODM F\FK
=ZDV]F]DQDUNRW\NyZ-HVWH ZLHG PLQHPZWZRLPSU]\SDGNXMHVWWRDEVROXWQLH
QLHZVND]DQH
3ROHF] VL ZL F WZRM PDQGUDJRU :LHG PLQXQLyVQDSHQLRQ PHQ]XUN
NWyU ZD QLHZU F]\DPX0LOYDZ\SLGRGQDL]DNDV]ODD ]\QDS\Q \PXGR
RF]X-X PLFKROHUDOHSLHM
1LHMHVWHPSHZLHQ5HJLVX PLHFKQ VL ]DFL QL W\PLZDUJDPLF]\OHF]\V]
ZD FLZ FKRURE 3U]\SRPLQDPWH H ZLQQRVL OHF]\SU]\F]\Q\QLH]D
REMDZ\
1LHZSU]\SDGNXWHJRZLHG PLQDSDUVNQ QLHFRMX UXPLDQ\-DVNLHU
SU]\VXFKXM F\VL UR]PRZLH-HPXDNXUDWQDMHJR]PDUWZLHQLDJRU]DNDGREU]H
]UREL
7RELHWH SRZLQQD*HUDOW]PUR]LSRHW Z]URNLHP=ZDV]F]DMH OLFLRG
QLHMM ]RUVNRRZDFLHMH
1DWRE\PUDF]HMQLHOLF]\X PLHFKQ VL ]QRZXF\UXOLN:VNDGSUHSDUDWX
ZFKRG]LEHOODGRQQD:LHOHDONDORLGyZZW\PVNRSRODPLQD=DQLPPDQGUDJRUD
ZDVUR]ELHU]HZV]\VF\QLH]DZRGQLHGDFLHPLSRSLVHORNZHQFML
3RSLVF]HJR"VS\WD3HUFLYDO
:\PRZQR FL3U]HSUDV]DP8 \ZDMP\SURVWV]\FKVyZ
*HUDOWVNU]\ZLZDUJLZSVHXGRX PLHFKX
6XV]QLHSRZLHG]LDDWZRSRSD ZPDQLHU L ]DF] X \ZDWDNLFKVyZ
QDFRG]LH /XG]LHPDM ZyZF]DVUR]PyZF ]DDURJDQFNLHJRED]QD
$OER]DDOFKHPLNDSRZLHG]LD=ROWDQ&KLYD\F]HUSL F PHQ]XUN ] FHEUD
/XE]DZLHG PLQDSDUVNQ -DVNLHUNWyU\QDF]\WDVL E\PyFLPSRQRZD
SHZQHMF]DURG]LHMFH&]DURG]LHMNLPRLSDQRZLHQDQLFWDNQLHOHF MDNQD
Z\V]XNDQ\EDMHU3UDZG PyZL *HUDOW"1RRSRZLHG]QDPFR
2SX NROHMN -DVNLHUSU]HUZD]LPQR:LHG PLQ
=DV]\ENRG]LDDM QDFLHELH]DZDUWHZW\PELPEU]HDONDORLG\5R]JDGDH VL
3U]HVWDE\ *HUDOWVNU]\ZLVL =ROWDQ]W\PLWZ\PLVHNUHWDPL:LHOH
QRZHJRQDP-DVNLHUQLHSRZLHG]LD1LFQDWRQLHSRUDG]LV] H MHVWH FKRG] F
OHJHQG +LVWRULHRWZRLFKSU]\JRGDFKJU\ZDVL Z WHDWU]\NDFKNXNLHNRZ\FK:
W\PLKLVWRUL R WRELHLF]DURG]LHMFHLPLHQLHP*XLQHYHUH
<HQQHIHUSRSUDZLSyJRVHP5HJLV2JO GDHPWDNLVSHNWDNO+LVWRUL R
SRORZDQLXQDG LQQDRLOHPQLHSDPL QLHP\OL
%\HPSU]\W\PSRORZDQLXSRFKZDOLVL -DVNLHU PLHFKXE\RSRZLDGDP
ZDP
2SRZLHG]ZV]\VWNLP*HUDOWZVWD3RSLMDM F LXEDUZLDM F DGQLH-DLG VL
SU]HM
(M H DFKQ VL NUDVQROXG1LHPDVL R FRREUD D
1LH]UR]XPLDH PQLH=ROWDQ,G XO \S FKHU]RZL&y ]GDU]DVL WRQDZHW
FKRG] F\POHJHQGRP
1RFE\D]LPQDMDNZV]\VF\GLDEOL.RQLHWXSD\LSRFKUDS\ZD\SDUDEXFKDD
LP]QR]GU]\=DODQDNVL \FRZ\P ZLDWHPEXGDF\UXOLNDZ\JO GDDL FLH
EDMHF]QLH:\SLV]Z\PDOXMFKDWNDOH QHMZUy NL:LHG PLQ]DSL VSRGQLH
0LOYDNWyUDZ\V]DZNUyWFHSRQLPFKU] NQ DQLHSHZQLH-HMGXJLFLH
]UyZQDVL ] MHJRFLHQLHP
&]HPX]SRZURWHP]ZyF]\V]"VS\WDD1DSUDZGH VL QDQLFKUR]H OL"
1LH]DSU]HF]\
3RNLHJRELHVDVWRLV]WXWHG\VDPSRNVL \FX"
/LF]
+ "
2GZ\UXV]HQLD]%URNLORQXPLQ RGZDQD FLHGQLZF]DVLHNWyU\FKSU]HE\HP
MDNLH V]H G]LHVL W PLO&LULMDNJRVLSORWNDMHVWZ1LOIJDDUG]LHVWROLF\
FHVDUVWZDPLH FLHRGNWyUHJRG]LHOLPQLHZHGXJRVWUR Q\FKUDFKXQNyZFR
RNRRGZyFKLSyW\VL FDPLO=SURVWHMNDONXODFMLZ\QLND H ZW\PWHPSLHGRWU
WDP]DURNLF]WHU\PLHVL FH&RW\QDWR"
1LF0LOYDZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPLFKU] NQ D]QRZX1LHXPLHPUDFKRZD
WDNGREU]HMDNW\&]\WDQLSLVDZRJyOHQLHXPLHP-HVWHPJXSLDSURVWD
G]LHZXFKD]HZVL DGQDGODFLHELHNRPSDQLD1LGUXKGRJDGNL
1LHPyZWDN
: G\WRSUDZGDRGZUyFLDVL JZDWRZQLH3RFR PLWHGQLLWHPLOH
Z\OLF]\"%\PFLFRSRUDG]LD"2WXFK\GRGDD"/ N WZyMRGS G]LDVWXPLD DO
FRWDUJDWRE JRU]HMQL OLEyOZSRDPDQ\PNXODVLH"1LHXPLHP7RELHNRJR
LQQHJRWU]D7DPWHMRNWyUHM-DVNLHUJDGD0 GUHMXF]RQHM8NRFKDQHM
-DVNLHUMHVWSDSOD
-X FL$OHF]DVHP]JRZ SDSOH:UDFDMP\FKF VL MHV]F]HQDSL
0LOYD"
&]HJR"
1LJG\PLQLHSRZLHG]LDD GODF]HJR]GHF\GRZDD VL MHFKD]HPQ
1LJG\ QLHS\WD
7HUD]S\WDP
7HUD]]DSy QR7HUD]MX VDPDQLHZLHP
1RMHVWH FLHQDUHV]FLHXFLHV]\VL QDLFKZLGRN=ROWDQZ\UD QLHMX
]PLHQLRQ\PJRVHP$P\ P\WXZ\VWDZFLHVRELHXVWDOLOL H 5HJLVUXV]D]
QDPLZGDOV] GURJ
'RSUDZG\":LHG PLQVSRMU]DQDF\UXOLNDXZD QLH6N G WDQDJDGHF\]MD"
3DQ=ROWDQQLHVSX FLRF]X5HJLVX ZLDGRPLPL H PRMHRNROLFHRJDUQ D
ZRMQD]QDF]QLHSRZD QLHMV]DQL Z\QLNDRWR]RSRZLH FLXFLHNLQLHUyZ3RZUyWZ
WDPWHVWURQ\QLHZFKRG]LZJU SR]RVWDQLHQDW\PSXVWNRZLXQLHZ\GDMHVL
P GUH6DPRWQHZ GURZDQLHUyZQLH
$P\FKR]XSHQLHFLQLH]QDQLZ\JO GDP\QDWDNLFK]NWyU\PLZ GUXMHVL
EH]SLHF]QLH:\VWDUF]\FLMHGHQU]XWRND"
'ZDRGU]HN]OHNNLPX PLHFKHPF\UXOLN-HGHQQDNRELHW\NWyU\PLVL
RSLHNXMHFLH'UXJLQDLFKG]LHFL
=ROWDQEHNQ JURPNRVNUREQ PHQ]XUN R GQRFHEU]\ND
3R]RU\PRJ P\OL]DGUZL0R H P\]DPLHU]DP\VSU]HGDWHEDE\Z
QLHZRO " 3HUFLYDO]UyEQRFR ] W\PDSDUDWHP2GNU WURFK ]DZyUDOERFR"
&KFHP\VL QDSLDFLHF]HMDNNUHZ]QRVD
&KRGQLFDQLHZ\UREL:\JRQE G]LHFLHS\
1LHV]NRG]L1RFMHVWFKRGQD
&LHSDZ\VDPRJRQRVWURSREXG]LNRQZHUVDFM -DVNLHU=ROWDQL3HUFLYDOQDEUDOL
UXPLH FyZJRV\]PLHQL\LPVL MHV]F]HEDUG]LHMZSU]\SDGNXSRHW\LJQRPD
PR QDE\RMX Z ]DVDG]LHPyZLROHNNLPEHNRFLH=JRGQLDZV]\WRZDU]\VWZR
XR]LPQ NRQLQ L SRJU\]DR]QDOH]LRQHZFKDFLHNRU]RQNLFKU]DQXURQL F ]\
ERFKU]DQE\UyZQLHNU]HSNLMDNELPEHU$OHGRGDZDRJQLDG\VNXVML
5HJLVQDJOHGDZ\UD]]G]LZLHQLXJG\RND]DRVL H ILQDOQ\PFHOHPZ GUyZNL
QLHMHVWHQNODZDPDV\ZX0DKDNDPRGZLHF]QDLEH]SLHF]QDNUDVQROXG]ND
VLHG]LED=ROWDQNWyU\]URELVL MHV]F]HJDGDWOLZV]\RG-DVNUDR ZLDGF]\ H GR
0DKDNDPXQLHZUyFLSRG DGQ\PSR]RUHPLGDXSXVWVZHMQLHFK FLZREHF
SDQXM F\FKWDPSRU] GNyZ]ZDV]F]D]D ZREHFSROLW\NLLDEVROXWQHMZDG]\
VWDURVW\0DKDNDPXLZV]\VWNLFKNUDVQROXG]NLFKNODQyZ%URXYHUD+RRJD
6WDU\JU]\EZU]DVQ LQDSOXZSDOHQLVNRSLHF\ND6SRMU]\V]LQLHZLHV]
\Z\F]\Z\SFKDQ\3UDZLHVL QLHUXV]DLGREU]HMDNR H SLHUG]LSU]\ND G\P
SRUXV]HQLX1LHVSRVyE]UR]XPLHFRJDGDERPXVL EURGD]Z VDPLVNOHLD
]HVFK\PEDUV]F]HP$OHU] G]LZV]\VWNLPLZV]\VWNLPLZV]\VF\PXV] WD F]\
MDN]DJUD
7UXGQRMHGQDNWZLHUG]LE\SROLW\NDVWDURVW\+RRJDE\D]DZWU FL5HJLV
7RG]L NLMHJR]GHF\GRZDQ\PDNFMRPNUDVQROXG\RG F]\\VL RGHOIyZLQLH
ZDOF] MX ZVSyOQLH]H6FRLD
WDHO$G]L NLWHPXXVWD\SRJURP\G]L NLWHPXQLH
GRV]RGRNDUQHMHNVSHG\FMLQD0DKDNDP6SROHJOLZ ZNRQWDNWDFK]OXG PL
SU]\QRVLRZRFH
*yZQRSUDZGD=ROWDQZ\FK\OLPHQ]XUN :VSUDZLH:LHZLyUHNVWDUHPX
SLHUQLNRZLQLHV]RR DGQ VSROHJOLZR OHF]RWR H ]E\WZLHOXPRG]LNyZ
U]XFDRURERW Z NRSDOQLDFKLNX QLDFKSU]\ F]DRVL GRHOIyZE\ZNRPDQGDFK
]D \VZRERG\LP VNLHMSU]\JRG\*G\]MDZLVNRXURVRGRUR]PLDUyZSUREOHPX
%URXYHU+RRJZ]L JyZQLDU]\ZWZDUGHNDUE\*G]LH PLD]DELMDQ\FKSU]H]
:LHZLyUNLOXG]LLELPEDQDUHSUHVMHVSDGDM FH]WHJRW\WXXQDNUDVQROXGyZZ
W\PLQDZDV]HRVDZLRQHSRJURP\7HRVWDWQLHJX]LNJRREFKRG]L\LJX]LN
REFKRG] ERNUDVQROXGyZRVLDG\FKZPLDVWDFKXZD D ]DRGV]F]HSLH FyZ&RVL
]D W\F]\]DJUR HQLDZSRVWDFLNDUQ\FKHNVSHG\FMLQD0DKDNDPWRQLH
UR] PLHV]DMFLHPQLHPLOLPRL1LMDNLHJR]DJUR HQLDQLHPDLQLHE\RER DGHQ]
NUyOyZQLHR PLHOLE\VL UXV]\0DKDNDPXQDZHWSDOFHP:L FHMZDPSRZLHP
QDZHW1LOIJDDUGF]\F\JG\E\XGDRLPVL RSDQRZDRWDF]DM FHPDV\ZGROLQ\
0DKDNDPXUXV]\VL QLHR PLHO :LHFLHGODF]HJR"3RZLHPZDP0DKDNDPWR
VWDO,QLHE\OHMDND7DPMHVWZ JLHOWDPV PDJQHW\WRZHUXG\QLHSU]HEUDQ\
SRNDG:V] G]LHLQG]LHMDE\VDPDGDUQLyZND
,WHFKQLNDMHVWZ0DKDNDPLHZWU FL3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFK+XWQLFWZRL
PHWDOXUJLD:LHONLHSLHFHQLHMDNLH WDP]DVUDQHG\PDUNL0RW\ZRGQHLSDURZH
0DV]3HUFLYDOJROQLMVRELH=ROWDQSRGDJQRPRZLQDSHQLRQH]QRZX
QDF]\QLHER]DQXG]LV]QDVW WZRM WHFKQLN :V]\VF\ZLHG] R WHFKQLFH$OHQLH
ZV]\VF\ZLHG] H 0DKDNDPHNVSRUWXMHVWDO'R.UyOHVWZDOHLGR1LOIJDDUGXWH
$ MH OLQDVNWRSDOFHPWNQLH]QLV]F]\P\ZDUV]WDW\L]DOHMHP\NRSDOQLH$
ZyZF]DVELMFLHVL OXG]LHDOHQDG ERZHSD\NU]HPLHQLHLR OHV]F] NL
1LE\WDNL]DZ]L W\MHVWH QD%URXYHUD+RRJDLSRU] GNLZ0DKDNDPLH
]DXZD \:LHG PLQDQDJOH]DF] H PyZLP\
$LRZV]HPSRWZLHUG]L]DSDOF]\ZLHNUDVQROXG-HVWFR WDNLHJRMDN
VROLGDUQR QLH"3U]\]QDP H WURFK WH L GXPDPQLHUR]SLHUD H P\P GU]HMVL
RGS\V]DNyZHOIyZ1LH]DSU]HF]\FLHFK\ED"(OI\SU]H]SDU VHWHNODWXGDZD\ H
ZDVOXG]LZFDOHQLHPD:QLHERSDWU]D\NZLDWNLZ FKD\DQDZLGRNF]RZLHND
RGZUDFD\Z\SDF\NRZDQHRF]ND$JG\VL RND]DR H WRQLFQLHGDMHQDJOH
RFNQ \VL L ]DSD\]DEUR 3RVWDQRZL\]DELMDLGDVL SR]DELMD$P\
NUDVQROXG\"0\ P\VL SU]\VWRVRZDOL1LHQLHGDOL P\VL ZDP
SRGSRU] GNRZDQLHFKVL ZDPWRQLHPDU]\7RP\ P\ZDVVRELH
SRGSRU] GNRZDOL(NRQRPLF]QLH
3UDZG SRZLHG]LDZV]\RGH]ZDVL 5HJLVZDPE\RDWZLHMVL
SU]\VWRVRZDQL HOIRP(OIyZLQWHJUXMH]LHPLDWHU\WRULXP:DVLQWHJUXMHNODQ
*G]LHNODQWDPRMF]\]QD*G\E\QDZHWMDNL V]F]HJyOQLHNUyWNRZ]URF]Q\NUyO
]DDWDNRZD0DKDNDP]DOHMHFLHNRSDOQLHLEH] DOXSRZ GUXMHFLHJG]LHLQG]LHM:
LQQHRGOHJHJyU\$FKRE\LGROXG]NLFKPLDVW
$SHZQLH:ZDV]\FKPLDVWDFKPR QDFDNLHPIDMQLH \
1DZHWZJHWWDFK"-DVNLHU]DSDRGGHFKSRKDX FLHGHVW\ODWX
$FR]HJRZJHWWDFK":RO PLHV]NDZ UyGVZRLFK1DFRPLLQWHJUDFMD"
%\OHE\QDVGRFHFKyZSU]\SX FLOL3HUFLYDORWDUQRVU NDZHP
:NR FXNLHG\ GRSXV]F] U]HN]SU]HNRQDQLHPNUDVQROXG$QLHWR
E G]LHP\SDUWDF]\DOER]DR \P\ZDVQHFHFK\QLHFK]DGHF\GXMH]GURZD
NRQNXUHQFMD
$MHGQDNZ0DKDNDPLHMHVWEH]SLHF]QLHMQL Z PLDVWDFK]DXZD \5HJLV
0LDVWDPRJ Z ND GHMFKZLOLSyM ]G\PHP5R]XPQLHME\RE\SU]HF]HNDZRMQ
Z JyUDFK
.RPXZRODQLHFKWDPLG]LH=ROWDQQDF]HUSD]FHEUD0QLHPLOV]D
VZRERGDDZ0DKDNDPLHMHMQLHX ZLDGF]\V]1LHZ\REUD DFLHVRELHMDNZ\JO GD
ZDG]DVWDUHJR2Q]DEUDVL RVWDWQLR]DUHJXODFM VSUDZMDNWRQD]\ZD
VSRHF]Q\FK'ODSU]\NDGXZROQRQRVLV]HONLD]DOLQLH-H NDUSLDRGUD]XF]\
F]HNDD VL JDODUHWD]HWQLH-HVWOLJUDQDRNDU\QLH]JRGQD]QDV] ZLHORZLHNRZ
NUDVQROXG]N WUDG\FM D]DOLWR]JXEQ\ZS\Z]JQLHMLGHNDGHQFNLHMNXOWXU\OXG]L
3RLOXODWDFKSUDF\PR QD]R \ZQLRVHNRSU]\G]LDVWDHM RQ\.WyU U N VL
SRGFLHUD:MDNLHMRGOHJR FLRGNRSDOQLGR]ZDODVL JZL]GD,WHPXSRGREQH
VSUDZ\R \ZRWQ\P]QDF]HQLX1LHFKRSF\MDQLHZUDFDPSRGJyU &DUERQ1LH
PDPRFKRW\VS G]L \FLDQDSU]RGNXZNRSDOQL&]WHUG]LH FLODWQDGROHRLOH
ZF]H QLHMQLHSLHUG\NQLHPHWDQ$OHP\MX PDP\LQQHSODQ\FR3HUFLYDO"
0\ P\MX VRELH]DSHZQLOLSU]\V]R
3U]\V]R SU]\V]R JQRPZ\SLPHQ]XUN VPDUNQ LVSRMU]DQD
NUDVQROXGDQLHFRMX ]DPJORQ\PZ]URNLHP1LHPyZP\KRS=ROWDQ%RMHV]F]H
PRJ QDV]DSDDZWHG\QDV]DSU]\V]R WRVWU\F]HN$OER'UDNHQERUJ
=DPNQLMJ E ZDUNQ NUDVQROXGSDWU] F QDQLHJRJUR QLH5R]JDGDH VL
6NRSRODPLQDPUXNQ ]FLFKD5HJLV
*QRPEDMGXU]\0LOYDE\DSRQXUD=ROWDQ]DSRPQLDZV]\ H MX UD]WRF]\QL
RSRZLDGDZV]\VWNLPR+RRJXVWDU\PJU]\ELHVWDUR FLH0DKDNDPX*HUDOW
]DSRPQLDZV]\ H MX UD]Z\VXFKDVXFKD5HJLVWH VXFKDLQDZHWGRGDZD
NRPHQWDU]H]XSHQLHQLHVSHV]RQ\W\P H MHVWMHG\Q\PWU]H Z\PZPRFQRMX
SLMDQ\PWRZDU]\VWZLH-DVNLHUEU]G NDQDOXWQLL SLHZD
1LHG]LZRWD H V KDUGHXURG]LZHSDQLH
:V]DNLPGU]HZRZ\QLR OHMV]HW\PWUXGQLHMZOH QDQLH
,GLRWDVNRPHQWRZDD0LOYD-DVNLHUQLHSU]HM VL
: G\L]SDQQ L]HGU]HZHPNWRQLHNLHSSRUDG]L
7U]HEDRZV]HPZ]L L]HU Q QRLSR]DZDG]LH
3XFKDUEHNRWD3HUFLYDO6FKXWWHQEDFK.LHOLFK]QDF]\=MHGQHJR
NDZDNDPOHF]QHJRRSDOXZ\U QL W\2WDNLZLHONL=QDOD]HPJRQDV]F]\FLH
JyU\0RQWVDOYDW%U]HJPLDZ\VDG]DQ\MDVSLVDPLDSRGVWDZDE\D]H]RWD,VWQH
FXGR
1LHGDZDMFLHPXZL FHMZyGNLSRZLHG]LD=ROWDQ&KLYD\
=DUD]]DUD]]DFLHNDZLVL -DVNLHUUyZQLH QLHFREHNRF] F&RVWDRVL ]
W\POHJHQGDUQ\PNLHOLFKHP"
:\PLHQLHPJRQDPXD3RWU]HERZDHPPXDE\SU]HZLH DGXQHN
.RUXQG\LNU\VWDOLF]Q\Z JLHO0LDHPWHJR(HH&D NXS (HHHSDGXQHN
]QDF]\FL NLEH]PXDDQLUXV]3RFKROHU PLE\WHQSXFKDU"
.RUXQG\": JLHO"
1RSRZDV]HPXUXELQ\LGLDPHQW\%DUG]RHHHSSU]\GDWQH
-DP\ O
'R ZLGUyZLGRSLOQLNyZ'RR \VN0LDHPWHJRFD NXS
6\V]\V]*HUDOW"=ROWDQPDFKQ U N L FKRFLD VLHG]LDRPDRQLH
SU]HZUyFLVL RGWHJRPDFKQL FLD0D\MHVWWRSU GNRVL XU Q .XSD
GLDPHQWyZPXVL QL8ZD DM3HUFLYDO HE\FLVL WHQVHQQLHVSUDZG]L:
SRRZLH7HMNWyUDQLHGRW\F]\GLDPHQWyZ
6Q\VQ\]DEHNRWDO]QRZX-DVNLHU$W\*HUDOW"=QRZX QLH R &LUL"%R
WU]HEDFLZLHG]LH5HJLV H *HUDOWPDSURURF]HVQ\&LULWR']LHFNR
1LHVSRG]LDQND*HUDOW]ZL ]DQ\MHVW]QL ZL ]DPLSU]H]QDF]HQLDGODWHJRZLG]LM
0LOYDFRFLMHVW"
1LHRG]\ZDMVL GRPQLHSLMDQ\JXSNX
+HMRQDSDF]H+HMSDWU]FLH
,G GRELHVDPyZL XF]QLF]NDRWDUD]\%RFL PL G]\RF]\]G]LHO
ZLHUV]RNOHWRW\FK GR RQ\'DZDMV]NOHQLF =ROWDQ
*G]LH VL ]DSRG]LDDZ\EHNRWDNUDVQROXG2MHVW']L NLF\UXOLNX$
JG]LHXGLDEDMHVW6FKXWWHQEDFK"
:\V]HG-DNL F]DVWHPX-DVNLHUSU]\SRPLQDPRELHFDH RSRZLHG]LHPL
KLVWRUL R ']LHFNX1LHVSRG]LDQFH
=DUD]=DUD]5HJLV7\ONRVRELH\NQ ,ZV]\VWNRRRSRZLHP2&LULR
ZLHG PLQLH=GHWDODPL
1DSRK\EHOVNXUZ\V\QRP
&LFKDM HNUDVQROXG]LH']LHFLDNDSU]HGFKDXS SREXG]LV]
1LH]R VL XF]QLF]NR0DV]QDSLMVL
(HHHFK-DVNLHUSRWRF]\SRV]DDVLHOHNNRE GQ\PZ]URNLHP HE\PQLH
WDNWHUD]]REDF]\DKUDELQDGH/HWWHQKRYH
.WR"
1LHZD QH&KROHUDWHQELPEHUIDNW\F]QLHUR]ZL ]XMHM ]\N*HUDOWQDODFL
MHV]F]H"*HUDOW
'DMPXSRNyMSRZLHG]LDD0LOYD1LHFK QL
5R]G]LD
:DPSLUDXSLyUMHVWF]RZLHN]PDU\SU]H]&KDRVR \ZLRQ\3LHUZV]H \FLH
XWUDFLZV]\ZGUXJLHJRZQRFQHMSRU]HX \ZD:\FKRG]L]JUREXSU]\ ZLHWOH
NVL \FDLMHQR]D ODGHPMHJRSURPLHQLSRVW SRZDPR HQDSDGD SL FH
G]LHZF] WDOXEPRG\FKSDUREF]DNyZNWyU\FKQLHSU]HEXG]LZV]\NUHZLFKVRGN
VVLH
3K\VLRORJXV
5R]G]LDF]ZDUW\
U]H ND&KyGSRUDQNDZ\EXG]LLRFXFLELUEDQWyZDOHQLH]GRDFDNRZLFLH
XQLFHVWZLVNXWNyZG]LDDQLDPDQGUDJRURZHJRVDPRJRQX*HUDOWRFNQ VL Z
N FLHOHSLDQNL]JRZ QDSRGRNX0LOY\=ROWDQL-DVNLHUREM FLOH HOLQDVWHUFLH
DOUDXQRZ\FKNRU]HQLFKUDSL F WDN H D SRZLHZD\ZLV] FHQD FLDQDFKZL ]NL
]Ly3HUFLYDORGQDOD]VL ]DFKDXS ]ZLQL W\ZN EHNZNU]DNXF]HUHPFK\L
QDNU\W\VRPLDQ URJy N VX F 5HJLVRZLGRZ\FLHUDQLDEXWyZ&DDSL WND
]GUDG]DDZ\UD QHFKR]Uy QLFRZDQHV\PSWRP\]P F]HQLDLLQWHQV\ZQLHNRLD
SUDJQLHQLHSU]\ UyGHNX
*G\MHGQDNUR]ZLD\VL PJ\LF]HUZRQDNXODVR FD]DSRQ DZNRURQDFK
VRVHQLPRGU]HZL)HQ&DPNRPSDQLDE\DMX Z GURG]H ZDZRPDV]HUXM F Z UyG
NXUKDQyZ3URZDG]L5HJLV]DQLPNURF]\OL3HUFLYDOL-DVNLHUGRGDM F VRELH
DQLPXV]X SLHZDQ QDGZDJRV\EDOODG R WU]HFKVLRVWUDFKLZLONX HOD]Q\P=D
QLPLWXSD=ROWDQ&KLYD\FL JQ F ]DZRG]HFLVDZHJRRJLHUD.UDVQROXG]QDOD]Z
REHM FLXF\UXOLNDV NDW ODJ ] MHVLRQRZHJRGUHZQDWHUD]ZDOLQL ZHZV]\VWNLH
PLMDQHPHQKLU\L \F]\GDZQRXPDU\PHOIRPZLHF]QHJRRGSRF]\QNX]D
VLHG] F\QDMHJRUDPLHQLX)HOGPDUV]DHN'XGDVWURV]\SLyUDLRGF]DVXGRF]DVX
VNU]HF]DQLHFK WQLHQLHZ\UD QLHLMDNR EH]SU]HNRQDQLD
1DMPQLHMRGSRUQ QDDLUDXQRZ\GHVW\ODWRND]DDVL 0LOYD0DV]HURZDD]
Z\UD Q\PWUXGHPE\DVSRFRQDEODGDL]DMDNRVDQLHRGSRZLDGDDQDZHWQD
V]F]HELRWDQLHG]LHZXV]NL]ZDUNRF]\NDPLZLH]LRQHMQDVLRGOHNDURV]D*HUDOWQLH
SUyERZDZL F QDZL ]DUR]PRZ\VDPUyZQLH QLHE\ZQDMOHSV]\PQDVWURMX
0JDDWDN H Z\ SLHZ\ZDQHJR Q\PLDF]QLHFRSU]HSLW\PLJRVDPLSHU\SHWLH
HOD]QHJRZLONDVSUDZL\ H QDJUXSN ZLH QLDNyZZSDNRZDOLVL QDJHLEH]
RVWU]H HQLD&KRSLQDWRPLDVWV\V]HOLLFKMX ] GDOHNDLF]HNDOLVWRM F QLHUXFKRPR
Z UyG]DU\W\FKZ]LHPL PRQROLWyZDLFKV]DUHVLHUPL JL]QDNRPLFLHLFK
PDVNRZD\1LHZLHOHEUDNRZDRE\=ROWDQ&KLYD\]G]LHOLMHGQHJRODJ ELRU F JR
]DNDPLH QDJUREQ\
2KRKRKRNU]\NQ :\EDF]FLHOXG]LH1LH]DXZD \HPZDV'REU\G]LH
3RZLWD
']LHVL WNDFKRSyZZ\PUXF]DDQLHVNDGQ\PFKyUHPRGSRZLHG QD
SR]GURZLHQLHSRQXURSU]\SDWUXM F VL NRPSDQLL:U NDFKZLH QLDF\ FLVNDOL
RSDW\RVNDUG\LV QLRZHMGXJR FL]DRVWU]RQHNRNL
:LWDMFLHSRZWyU]\NUDVQROXG=JDGXM H FLH]RER]XQDG&KRWO
8WUDILHP"
=DPLDVWRGSRZLHG]LHMHGHQ]FKRSyZZVND]DUHV]FLHNRQLD0LOY\
.DU\SRZLHG]LD:LG]LFLH"
.DU\SRZWyU]\GUXJLLREOL]DZDUJL, FLHNDU\:VDPUD]E G]LH
+ " =ROWDQ]DXZD \VSRMU]HQLDLJHVW\1RNDU\,FR]WHJR"3U]HFLHWR
NR QLH \UDIDG]LZRZDVL QLHPDF]HPX&RWXSRUDELDFLHNXPRWU]\QDW\P
FPHQWDU]\VNX"
$Z\"FKRSREU]XFLNRPSDQL QLHFK WQ\PVSRMU]HQLHP&RZ\WXURELFLH"
.XSLOL P\WHQWHUHQNUDVQROXGVSRMU]DPXSURVWRZRF]\LVWXNQ ODJ R
PHQKLU,PLHU]\P\NURNDPLF]\QDVQLHRV]XNDOLQDDNUDFK
$P\WXZ SLHU]DWURSLP
.RJR"
: SLHU]DSRZWyU]\GRELWQLHQDMVWDUV]\]FKRSyZGUDSL F VL Z F]RRSRG
V]W\ZQ RGEUXGXILOFRZ F]DSN *G]LH WXVZHOH H PLHPXVLSU]HNO WQLN
2VLQRZ\FKNRNyZQDVWUXJDOLPQDMG]LHPSRW SLH FDSU]HERG]LHPJRFRE\MX
QLHZVWD
,ZRG ZL FRQ PDP\ZGZRMDNDFKNWyUHMQDPERJRVDZLRQ\NDSDQ
X \F]\]DZRDRFKRF]RGUXJLZLH QLDNGHPRQVWUXM F QDF]\QLH3RNURSLP
NUZLRSLMF QLHFKQDZLHNLZLHNyZVF]H QLH
+DKDSRZLHG]LD=ROWDQ&KLYD\]X PLHFKHP3RORZDQLHMDNZLG] FD
J E V]HURNR]DNURMRQHLGHWDOLF]QLHSU]\JRWRZDQH:DPSLUPyZLFLH"1RWR
PDFLHV]F] FLHGREU]\OXG]LH0\VSHFMDOLVW RGXSLRUyZZNRPSDQLLPDP\
ZLHG
8UZDL]DNO ]FLFKDDOERZLHP:LHG PLQVLOQLHNRSQ JRZNRVWN
.WRWHJRZDPSLUDZLG]LD"VS\WD*HUDOWZ\PRZQ\PVSRMU]HQLHPQDND]XM F
WRZDU]\V]RPPLOF]HQLH6N G ZLDGRPR H ZD QLHWXWDMJRQDOH \ V]XND"
&KRSLSRV]HSWDOLPL G]\VRE
1LNWJRQLHZLG]LDSU]\]QDZUHV]FLHWHQZILOFRZHMF]DSFH$QLQLHV\V]D
-DN H MHJRZLG]LHJG\RQQRF ODWDZHPLH"-DN H MHJRV\V]HJG\RQQD
QLHWRSHU]\FKVNU]\GDFKIUXZDEH]V]PHUXLV]XVWX"
: SLHU]DQLHZLG]LHOLPGRGDGUXJL$OH ODG\VWUDV]QHJRMHJRSURFHGHUX
E\\2GNLHG\PLHVL F ZSHQLFRQRFNRJR ] QDV]\FKPRUGXMHXSLRU]\VNR
'ZRMHMX UR]GDUQDV]WXNLSRV]DUSD%DE MHGQ L RWURNDMHGQHJR=JUR]DD
WUZRJD1DV]PDW\Z SLHU]QLHV]F] VQ\FKSRGDUFD ] \NUHZZ\SL7DNFR
QDPEH]F]\QQLHWU]HFLHMQRF\F]HND"
.WRSRZLHG]LD H VSUDZF E\ZD QLHZDPSLUDQLHLQQ\GUDSLH QLN".WR
ZSDGQDWRE\EXV]RZDSRFPHQWDU]\VNX"
ZL WREOLZ\NDSDQWDNU]HN8F]RQ\LSRER Q\F]HNERJRPG]L NL H GR
QDV]HJRRER]XSRSDG=UD]X]JDG H WRZ SLHU]QDVQDFKRG]L=DNDU ER P\
PRGyZ]DQLHGEDOLL ZL W\QQ\FKGDWNyZ2QQ\QLHZRER]LHPRGOLWZ\RGSUDZLDL
SU]HJ]RUG\]P\ZV]HODNLHQDP]D QDND]DJURERZFDSRV]XNLZDZNWyU\P
PDUWZLHG]LRQNLSU]HV\SLD
:D QLHWXWDM"
$JG]LHJUREXZ SLHU]DV]XNDMH OLQLHQD DOQLNX"$WRSU]HFLHHOIRZ\
DOQLNND GHG]LHFNRZLH H HOI\WRUDVDSRGDLEH]ER QDFRGUXJLHOISR PLHUFL
SRW SLH FHP]RVWDMH:V]\VWNRFR]HSU]H]HOIyZ
,EDOZLHU]\SRZD QLHNLZQ JRZ =ROWDQ3UDZGD.D GHG]LHFNRZLH
'DOHNRWHQREy]RNWyU\PE\DPRZD"
2MQLHGDOHNR
$QLHU]HNDMFLHLP]DGX RRMF]H2ZVLZXMXZDUNQ ]DUR QL W\FKRS]
ZRVDPLSREUZLWHQNWyU\MX SRSU]HGQLRREMDZLDQLHFK 'LDVHNLFKZLHFR
RQL]DMHGQLSRGHMU]DQDWRMDND V]DMND1X HGRG]LHD1LHFK H NRQLDGDM D
SRWHPLG Z VZRM VWURQ
$QR ZL WDSUDZGDU]HNVWDUV]\ZLH QLDN7U]DQDPG]LHRNR F]\ER
F]DVELH \'DMWDNRQLD7HJRNDUHJR3RWU]HEQ\QDPE\Z SLHU]DRGV]XND
=GHMPPyGNRG]LHFLDND]NXOEDNL
0LOYDNWyUDSU]H]FD\F]DV]RERM WQ PLQ JDSLDVL Z QLHERSRSDWU]\DQD
FKRSDDU\V\]DRVWU]\\MHMVL QLHEH]SLHF]QLH
'RPQLHPyZLV]NPLRFLH"
: G\GRFLHELH'DZDMNDUHJRSRWU]HEQ\QDP
0LOYDSRWDUDVSRFRQ\NDUNL]DFL D] E\DZ\UD]MHM]P F]RQ\FKRF]XVWDVL
SUDZG]LZLHZLOF]\
2FRZDPFKRG]LOXG]LH":LHG PLQX PLHFKQ VL SUyEXM F UR]DGRZD
QDSL W V\WXDFM 3RFRZDPNR RNWyUHJRWDNJU]HF]QLHSURVLFLH"
$MDN H QDPLQDF]HMJUyEXSLRUD]QDOH ": G\ZLDGD H WU]DQDNDU\P
UHEFX DOQLNREMHFKDDXNWyUHMPRJL\ UHELHFVWDQLHLUXV]\VL ] PLHMVFDQLH
GR]ZROLWDPZ SLHU]OH \:WHG\WU]DJRZ\NRSDLRVLQRZ\PNRNLHPSU]HEL
1LHSU]HFLZFLHVL ERQDPZy]DOERSU]HZy]0XVLPWHJRNDURV]DPLH
,QQDPD VS\WDSRMHGQDZF]R-DVNLHUZ\FL JDM F NXFKRSXZRG]H3HJD]D
QLHPR H E\"
1LMDN
7HG\ELHGDZDPSRZLHG]LDDSU]H]]DFL QL WH] E\0LOYD%RMDNRQLDQLH
GDP
-DN H WRQLHGDV]"1LHEDF]\D FRPyZLOLPG]LHZNR"1DPPXV
:DP$PQLHQLH
,VWQLHMHUR]ZL ]DQLHSROXERZQHRGH]ZDVL DJRGQLH5HJLV-DNUR]XPLHP
SDQL0LOYDZ]GUDJDVL SU]HGRGGDQLHPZLHU]FKRZFDZFXG]HU FH
-X FLXF]QLF]NDVSOXQ DVLDUF]\ FLH:]GU\JDPVL QDVDP P\ O
$E\ZL F ZLONE\V\W\DRZFDFDDNRQW\QXRZDVSRNRMQLHF\UXOLN
QLHFKDM H SDQL0LOYDVDPDZVL G]LHQDNDURV]DLGRNRQDNRQLHF]QHJRMDNRE\
REMD]GXQHNURSROLL
1LHE G MDNJXSLDSRFPHQWDU]XMH G]L
: G\FL QLNWQLHSURVLG]LHZNRNU]\NQ WHQ]ZRVDPLSREUZL'RWHJR
WU]DMXQDNDFKZDWDELDHMJRZLHZNXFKQLSU]\JDUQNDFKVL NU] WD']LHZNDL
RZV]HPPR H VL Sy QLHMSU]\GDERSU]HFLZXSLRUXZLHOFHV ]\G]LHZLF]H
SU]\GDWQHMH OLZ SLHU]DSRNURSLQLHPLVSRQLHMDNR DJLHZ$OH OR]\PXVL
F]\VWDLQLHUXFKDQDMHV]F]HPyGNDSU]HOD1LHZLG]LPLVL HE\ W\WDNDE\D
ELDNR7HJG\W\GRQLF]HJRQLH]GDWQD
0LOYD]URELDV]\ENLNURNGRSU]RGXLQLHXFKZ\WQ\PUXFKHPZ\U]XFLDSU]HG
VLHELHSUDZ SL 7U]DVQ RJRZDFKRSDRGVNRF]\DSU]H]FR]DUR QL WDV]\MDL
SRGEUyGHNXWZRU]\\]QDNRPLW\FHO']LHZF]\QD]URELDGUXJLNURNLZDOQ DQD
ZSURVWQDVDG RWZDUWHMGRQLZ]PDJDM F VL FLRVXVNU WHPELRGHULEDUNX&KRS
SRGUHSWDGRW\OX]DSO WDVL ZHZDVQHDSFLHLZ\ZDOL]HV\V]DOQ\PWU]DVNLHP
XGHU]DM F SRW\OLF R PHQKLU
7HUD]ZLG]LV]GRF]HJRP]GDWQDSRZLHG]LDDGU F\P]Z FLHNR FLJRVHP
XF]QLF]NDUR]FLHUDM F SL .WR]QDVFKZDWDNRPXSU]\JDUQNDFKPLHMVFH
:LHU QLHPDWRMDNNXDF]Q\EyMSRQLPZV]\VWNR]DZ G\ZLDGRPH.WRMXQDNL
FKZDWWHQQDQRJDFKVWRLNWRNLHSLFKXU JDWHQQD]LHPLOH \3UDZDP
NPLRWNRZLH"
:LH QLDF\QLHVSLHV]\OLVL ] SRWZLHUG]HQLHPSDWU]\OLQD0LOY ] RWZDUW\PL
J EDPL7HQZILOFRZHMF]DSFHXNO NSU]\SRZDORQ\PLGHOLNDWQLHSRNOHSDJRSR
SROLF]NX%H]HIHNWX
=ZL NV]RQDOLF]HEQLHNRPSDQLDSU]\SRPLQDDWHUD]RUV]DNSRJU]HERZ\LZORND
VL Z SRJU]HERZ\PWHPSLH
&RSRZLHV]RW\PLFKZDPSLU]H"]DJDGQ ZLHG PLQD=ROWDQ&KL\D\
:LHU]\V]ZW KLVWRUL "
1LHZLG]LDHP]DELW\FK1LFQLHPRJ SRZLHG]LH
7RMDZQDOLSDR ZLDGF]\]SU]HNRQDQLHP-DVNLHU.PLRWNRZLHPyZLOL H
]DELFLE\OLUR]V]DUSDQL:DPSLUQLHUR]V]DUSXMH:JU\]DVL Z DUWHUL L Z\SLMD
NUHZ]RVWDZLDM F GZDZ\UD QH ODG\NyZ2ILDUDZFDOHF] VWRSU]H \ZD
&]\WDHPRW\PZVSHFMDOLVW\F]QHMNVL G]H%\\WDPWH JUDZLXU\SU]HGVWDZLDM FH
ODG\XN V]H ZDPSLUDQDDE G]LFKV]\MDFKG]LHZLF3RWZLHUG *HUDOW
&RPDPSRWZLHUG]L"1LHZLG]LDHPW\FKJUDZLXU1DG]LHZLFDFKWH PDRVL
Z\]QDM
1LHNSLM ODG\XN V]H ZDPSLU]\FKPXVLDH ZLG\ZDQLHUD]LQLHGZD
=QDOD]HP$OHQLHZLHPF]\E G]LHQDVVWD7XWDM]DZV]\VWNRZRDM
]DSDW\DFHQ\ H SURV] VLDGD0 NDLNUXS\NRURQ ]DIXQW7DOHU]FLHQNLHM]XS\
GZDQREOH*DUQXV]HN]RZLRQ\FKZ&KRWOLZLXQyZNRV]WXMHW\OHFRZ'LOOLQJHQ
IXQWZ G]RQHJRRVRVLD
$REURNGODNRQL"
0LDUNDRZVDWDODUD
,OH"ZU]DVQ NUDVQROXG,OH"
,OHLOHZDUNQ D0LOYD.RQLVS\WDMLOH3DGQ JG\LPWUDZ V]F]\SD
ND HP\7X]UHV]W L WUDZ\QLHPD
=RF]\ZLVW\PLIDNWDPLQLHE\RVSRVREXG\VNXWRZD1LHSRPRJ\WH RVWUH
WDUJL]G\VSRQXM F\PRZVHPZLH QLDNLHP&KRSRGHEUD-DVNURZLUHV]WN JURV]D
RGHEUDWH NLONDZ\]ZLVN=ROWDQDZFDOHVL ]UHV]W QLPLQLHSU]HMPXM F$OH
NRQLH]RFKRW ZVXQ \E\ZZRUNL]REURNLHP
&KROHUQH]G]LHUVWZRZU]HV]F]DNUDVQROXGZ\DGRZXM F ]R FLRVDPLODJL
Z NRDPLMDQ\FKZR]yZ']LZQH H RGG\FKDWXSR]ZDODM ]DGDUPRQLHZRDM
SRSyJURV]NXRGZGHFKX$OERSL WDNDRG]URELRQHMNXS\
:\ V]HSRWU]HE\IL]MRORJLF]QHR ZLDGF]\]XSHQLHSRZD QLH5HJLVV
Z\FHQLRQH:LG]LFLHW UR]SL W QDNLMDFKSDFKW " ,FKRSDNWyU\VWRLRERN"
)U\PDUF]\ZG]L NDPLZDVQHMFyUNL&HQDGRX]JRGQLHQLD3U]HGFKZLO
ZLG]LDHPMDNSU]\M NXU
OHZUy ZDV]HMUDVLHOXG]LHU]HNSRQXUR=ROWDQ&KLYD\.D GHUR]XPQH
VWZRU]HQLHQDW\P ZLHFLHJG\SRSDGQLHZELHG Q G] L QLHV]F] FLH]Z\NR
NXSLVL GRSREUDW\PFyZERZ UyGQLFKDWZLHM]\F]DVSU]HWUZDERMHGHQ
GUXJLHPXSRPDJD$Z UyGZDVOXG]LND G\W\ONRSDWU]\MDNE\WXQDFXG]HM
ELHG]LH]DUREL*G\JyGWRQLHG]LHOLVL DUFLDW\ONRQDMVDEV]\FKVL ] HUD
3URFHGHUWDNLVSUDZG]DVL X ZLONyZSR]ZDODSU]HWUZDRVREQLNRPQDM]GURZV]\P
L QDMVLOQLHMV]\P$OHZ UyGUDVUR]XPQ\FKWDNDVHOHNFMD]D]Z\F]DMSR]ZDOD
SU]HWUZDLGRPLQRZDQDMZL NV]\PVNXUZ\V\QRP:QLRVNLLSURJQR]\
Z\FL JQLMFLHVRELHVDPL
-DVNLHU]DRSRQRZDJZDWRZQLHU]XFDM F ]QDQ\PLPXSU]\NDGDPLQDMHV]F]H
ZL NV]H]G]LHUVWZRLLQWHUHVRZQR NUDVQROXGyZDOH=ROWDQL3HUFLYDO]DJXV]\OL
JRMHGQRF]H QLHLGRQR QLHLPLWXM F ZDUJDPLSU]HFL JHRGJRV\WRZDU]\V] FH
SLHUG]HQLXFRXREXUDVX]QDZDQHE\R]DZ\UD]OHNFHZD HQLDDUJXPHQWyZ
DGZHUVDU]DZG\VSXFLH
.UHVNyWQLSRR \RQDJHSRMDZLHQLHVL JUXSNLFKRSyZSURZDG]RQ\FKSU]H]
]QDQHJRMX LPRZF ZDPSLUyZVWDUFDZILOFRZHMF]DSFH
0\Z]JO GHP&KRGDNDSRZLHG]LDMHGHQ]ZLH QLDNyZ
1LHNXSXMHP\ZDUNQ OLXQLVRQRNUDVQROXGLJQRP
,G]LHRWHJRNWyUHPX FLHHEUR]ELOLZ\MD QLSU GNRGUXJLFKRS0\MHJR
HQL]DP\ ODOL P\
1LHPDPQLFSU]HFLZNRWHPXSRZLHG]LDJQLHZQLH=ROWDQ:V]\VWNLHJRPX
\F] GREUHJRQDQRZHMGURG]H \FLD=GURZLDV]F] FLDSRP\ OQR FL
,PQyVWZRPD\FK&KRGDF]NyZGRGD-DVNLHU
1RQRSDQRZLHSRZLHG]LDZLH QLDN:DVILUOHMHVL WU]\PDM DMDNP\
MHJRWHUD] HQLPDP\".LHG\RQSRW\PMDNJRZUR]XPQDWOXNOL FLHNRRZDW\
FD\GQLDRGQRF\QLHRGUy QLD"
1RD WDN OHSU]HFLHQLHMHVWEXUNQ D0LOYDSDWU] F Z]LHPL :LG]LPL
VL H MX PXOHSLHM'X R OHSLHMVL PDQL OLVL ] VDPHJRUDQDPLD
1LHZLHPMDMDNVL &KRGDN]VDPHJRUDQDPLDRGSDURZDFKRS$OHDE\
FRZLG]LDHPMDNVWDSU]HGKRREO V]WRUFHPSRVWDZLRQ L SUDZLWHMKROREOL H
NUD QD]QLHMG]LHZND$WFRWXGX R JDGD.UyWNRU]HNQ ]DSDFLH
JyZV]F]\]Q
&R"
-DNU\FHU]FKRSDXELMHPDJyZV]F]\]Q ]DSDFL7DNZSUDZLHVWRL
1LHMHVWHPU\FHU]HPZU]DVQ D0LOYD
7RSRSLHUZV]HSRSDUM -DVNLHU3RGUXJLHWRE\Z\SDGHN3RWU]HFLH
&KRGDN \MHQLHPR H E\]DWHPPRZ\RJyZV]F]\ QLHDFRQDMZ\ HMR
QDZL ]FHF]\OLEDVDUXQNX$OHSRF]ZDUWHQLHPDP\SLHQL G]\
7RNRQLHRGGDMFLH
(M H RF]\0LOY\]Z ]L\VL ]RZURJR&K\ED ]ELHVLVL NPLRWNX%DF]
E\ QLHSU]HKRORZD
.UUUUZDPD]DVNU]HF] )HOGPDUV]DHN'XGD
2WXWUDILSWDNZVDPRVHGQRU]HNSU]HFL JOH=ROWDQ&KLYD\SRNOHSXM F
]DWNQL W\]DSDVWRSRUHN:LHG]FLHUROQLF\ H LMDQLHPDPQDMOHSV]HMRSLQLLR
PDWNDFKRVREQLNyZNWyU]\P\ O Z\ F]QLHR]DURENXQDZHWMH OL]DURELVL PD
QDUR]ELW\PELHVZRMDND5XV]DMFLHSUHF]OXG]LH-H HOLRGHMG]LHFLHEH]]ZRF]QLH
RELHFXM H QLHE G ZDVJRQL
1LHFKFHFLHSDFLQLHFKQDVZ\ V]DZDG]DUR]V G]L
.UDVQROXG]JU]\WQ ] EDPLLMX VL JDSREUR JG\*HUDOWFKZ\FLJR]D
RNLH
6SRNRMQLH7DNFKFHV]UR]ZLNDWHQSUREOHP"3R]DELMDLFK"
3RFR]DUD]SR]DELMD":\VWDUF]\SRU] GQLHRNDOHF]\
'R WHJRGRGLDEDV\NQ :LHG PLQSRF]\PREUyFLVL GRZLH QLDND
.WRVSUDZXMHWXRZ Z\ V] ZDG] RNWyUHMZVSRPQLHOL FLH"
6WDURVWDQDV]RER]RZ\+HFWRU/DDEVVRW\V]HVSDORQHM%UH]\
3URZDG FLHWHG\GRQLHJR'RJDGDP\VL MDNR
2Q]DM W\WHUDR]QDMPLZLH QLDN6 G QDGF]DURZQLF RGSUDZLD2W
ZLG]LFLHMDNLHWDP]ELHJRZLVNRSRGOHNORQD":LHG P VFKZ\WDQRNWyUD]
Z SLHU]HPE\DZ]PRZLH
=QRZXZDPSLU-DVNLHUUR]R \U FH6\V]\FLH"2QL]QRZXVZRMH-DNQLH
FPHQWDU]UR]NRSXM WRF]DURZQLFHRZL ZDPSLU]HZVSyOQLF]NL/XG]LHDPR H
PLDVWRUDVLDL]ELHUDZLHG PLQDPL]RVWDQLHFLH"
:ROQHSD VNLH DUW\SRZLHG]LDFKRS, PLFK\FKLFK\.DSDQWXMHVWD
NDSDQSHZQLHMV]\QL OL:LHG PLQ.DSDQRU]HN H Z SLHU]]DZ G\GRVSyNL]
F]DURZQLF SURFHGHUVZyMF]\QL&]DURZQLFDSU]\]\ZDXSLUDLRILDU\ZVND]XMH
MHPXDZV]\VWNLPRF]\PURF]\ HE\QLHZLG]LHOLQLF
,SRND]DRVL H ZVDPHMU]HF]\WDNMHVWGRGDGUXJL:LHG P Z UyGQDV
]GUDG]LHFN KRGRZDOL P\$OHNDSDQMHMF]DU\SU]HMU]DLWHUDM VSDOLP
-DN HE\LQDF]HMPUXNQ :LHG PLQ1RFy U]XFLP\RNLHPQDWHQZDV]
V G,SRJDGDP\]SDQHPVWDURVW R Z\SDGNXNWyU\VSRWNDQLHV]F] VQHJR
GXUQLD
-DVNLHUZ\PRZQLHL]QDG]LHM SRSDWU]\QDZLHG PLQDDOH*HUDOWXQLNDMHJR
Z]URNX
$F]HJy MH OLQLHQLHZLH FLHJRF]DURVWZDV REHFQHQDV]HNO VNLL
QLHV]F] FLDZ\QLNLHP"ZU]HV]F]DGDOHMNDSDQ:V]DNQLHNWRLQQ\D
F]DURZQLFHNUyOyZ]GUDG]L\QDZ\VSLH7KDQHGG]DPDFKQDNUyOD5HGDQLLXNQX\
:V]DNQLHNWRLQQ\DHOILDZLHG PD]'RO%ODWKDQQDQDV\DQDQDV:LHZLyUNL
:LG]LFLHWHUD]GRMDNLHJR]DSU]\ZLRGDNRQILGHQFMD]F]DURZQLFDPL
7ROHURZDQLHLFKSOXJDZ\FKSUDNW\N3U]\P\NDQLHRF]XQDLFKVDPRZRO LFK
]XFKZD S\FK LFKERJDFWZR$NWRWHPXZLQLHQ".UyORZLH=DGXIDPZDGF\
Z\U]HNOLVL ERJyZRGVXQ OLNDSDQyZRGHEUDOLLPXU] G\LPLHMVFDZUDGDFKD
REPLHU]HF]DURZQLFHREV\SDOL]DV]F]\WDPLL]RWHP,PDM WHUD]VNXWHN
$KD7RWXOH \ ZDPSLUSRJU]HEDQ\SRZLHG]LD-DVNLHU0\OLH VL 5HJLV
7XRSROLW\N QLHRZDJLQ FKRG]L
,RSLHQL G]HGRGD=ROWDQ&KLYD\
=DSUDZG U\F]DNDSDQSRZLDGDPZDPQLPVWDQLHP\GRZDONL]
1LOIJDDUGHPRF]\ P\ZSLHUZ]W\FKDERPLQDFMLZDVQ\GRP:\SDOP\WHQ
ZU]yGELD\P HOD]HP2F]\ P\FKU]WHPRJQLRZ\P7DNLHMNWyUDSDUDVL
F]DUDPLQLH]H]ZyOP\ \
1LH]H]ZROLP\1DVWRV]QL
3U]\ZL ]DQDGRZR]XG]LHZF]\QD]D PLDDVL KLVWHU\F]QLHSU]HZUyFLDRF]DPL
=DUD]DUDSRPDOX NXRGH]ZDVL PLOF] F\GRWHMSRU\SRV SQ\ZLH QLDN
ROEU]\PLHJRZ]URVWXGRNRDNWyUHJRNXSLDVL JUXSNDSRGREQLHPLOF] F\FK
P F]\]QLNLONDSRQXU\FKNRELHW'RQ\QLHMHQRDE\NU]\NLV\V]HOLP.U]\ND
ND G\SRWUDILZURQDQDZHW2GZDV ZL WREOLZ\V]DFXQHNZL FHMF]HNDQL RG
ZURQ\ND H
1HJXMHFLHPHVRZDVWDURVWR/DDEV"6RZDNDSDQD"
1LHQ\JXVXM MDQLF]HJRROEU]\PVSOXQ QD]LHPL L SRGFL JQ ]JU]HEQH
SRUWNL7DG]LHZNDWRVLHURWDLSU]\E GDQLNWGODPQLH-H OLVL SRND H H ]
Z SLHU]HPMHVWZ]PRZLHELHU]FLHM XELMFLH$OHSyNLPMDWHJRRER]XVWDURVW
SRW\MHQRZLQQ\FKNDUDVL WXE G]LH&KFHFLHNDUDZSU]yGGRZyGZLQ\
SRND FLH
$SRND NU]\NQ NDSDQGDM F ]QDNVZRLPSDFKRNRPW\PNWyU]\
QLHGDZQRZNDGDOLSRGNRZ\GRRJQLD'RRF]XSRND :DP/DDEVL
ZV]\VWNLPREHFQ\P
3DFKRNRZLHZ\QLH OL]]DZR]XLXVWDZLOLQD]LHPLQLHGX \RVPRORQ\NRFLRHN
] SD NLHP
2WRGRZyGU\NQ NDSDQNRSQL FLHPZ\ZUDFDM F NRFLRHN1D]LHPL
FKOXVQ DU]DGNDFLHF]RVDG]DM F QDSLDVNXNDZDHF]NLPDUFKZLZVW NL
QLHUR]SR]QDZDOQHM]LHOHQLQ\LNLONDPD\FKNRVWHN
:LHG PDZDU]\DPDJLF]QHNRQNRNHMH(OLNVLUG]L NLNWyUHPXPRJDZ
SRZLHWU]XODWD'RVZHJRPLR QLNDZDPSLUDE\]QLPREFRZDZ\VW SQLHL
GDOV]H]EURGQLHNQX=QDPMDF]DURZQLNyZVSUDZ\LVSRVRE\ZLHPMD]F]HJR
WHQGHNRNW&]DURZQLFDXJRWRZDD \ZFHPNRWD
7XPRFKQ ]H]JUR]
UDNDU]JDGDFLH
7DNMDPMHVWF]HNER \]DU\F]DNDSDQSU]HNU]\NXM F Z]PDJDM F\VL
Z UyGZLH QLDNyZSRPUXN:ERVN ZLHU] VSUDZLHGOLZR NDU L SRPVW ,Z
ER \ V G1LHFKSU]HGER \PV GHPZLHG PDVWDQLH6 G ER \
ZLHWQ\SRP\VSU]HUZDJR QR:LHG PLQZ\VW SXM F ]WXPX
.DSDQ]PLHU]\JR]\PZ]URNLHPFKRSLSU]HVWDOLV]HPUDJDSLOLVL ]
RWZDUW\PLXVWDPL
6 G ER \ SRGM *HUDOWZ UyGDEVROXWQHMFLV]\WRU]HF]FDNRZLFLHSHZQDL
EH]Z]JO GQLHVSUDZLHGOLZD2UGDOLDDNFHSWRZDQHV UyZQLH SU]H]V G\ ZLHFNLHL
PDM VZHUHJX\5HJX\WHVWDQRZL H ZSU]\SDGNXRVNDU HQLDQLHZLDVW\
G]LHFNDVWDUFDOXERVRE\XRPQHMGRV GXVWDQ PR H REUR FD3UDZGDSDQLH
VWDURVWR/DDEV"=JDV]DPVL RWRQDREUR F 2JURG FLHV]UDQNL.WRSHZLHQMHVW
ZLQ\WHMG]LHZF]\Q\LQLHERLVL V GXER HJRQLHFKZ\VW SLGRZDONL]HPQ
+D]DZRDNDSDQZFL PLHU F JRZ]URNLHP1LH]DFK\WU]HPR FL
QLH]QDMRP\"'RSRMHG\QNXZ\]\ZDV]"1DSLHUZV]\U]XWRNDZLGD H UH]XQL
U EDF]1DWZyMPLHF]EDQG\FNLFKFHV]]GDV G ER \"
-H OLPLHF]ZDPQLHSRP\ OL ZL WREOLZ\R]QDMPLSU]HFL JOH=ROWDQ
&KLYD\VWDM F RERN*HUDOWDLMH OLWHQMHJRPR ZDPQLHSDVXMHWRPR H MDE G
JRGQ\"3URV] QLHFKRVNDU \FLHOG]LHZNLVWDQLH]HPQ QDWRSRU\
$OER]HPQ QDXNL0LOYDPUX F RF]\UyZQLH Z\VW SLD3RMHGQHM
VWU]DOH]HVWXNURNyZ
:LG]LFLHOXG]LHMDNV]\ENRPQR VL REUR F\ZLHG P\"NU]\NQ NDSDQ
SRF]\PRGZUyFLVL L Z\NU]\ZLWZDU]ZSU]HELHJ\PX PLHFKX'REU]H
KXOWDMHSU]\MPXM GRRUGDOLXPFD ZDV] WUyMN :QHWV G ER \ VL RGE G]LH
ZQHWXVWDOLP\ZLQ ZLHG P\DLZDV] FQRW VSUDZG]LP\]DUD]HP$OHQLHQD
PLHF]HWRSRU\NRSLHF]\VWU]D\=QDFLHPyZLFLHUHJX\V GXER HJR",MDMH
]QDP2WRSRGNRZ\ZZ JOHZR RQHUR]SDORQHGRELDR FL&KU]HVWRJQLD1X H
F]DURVWZDSRSOHF]QLF\.WyU\SRGNRZ ] RJQLDZ\MPLHGRPQLHM SU]\QLHVLHL
ODGXRSDU]H QLH]GUDG]LWHQGRZLHG]LH H ZLHG PDMHVWEH]ZLQ\-H OL]D FR
LQQHJRV G ER \ SRND HWHG\LZDP PLHULMHM5]HNHP
1LHFK WQHSRPUXNLVWDURVW\/DDEVDLMHJRJUXS\]JXV]\\HQWX]MDVW\F]QH
ZU]DVNLZL NV]R FL]JURPDG]RQHM]DNDSDQHPZLHWU] FHMNDSLWDOQ XFLHFK L
ZLGRZLVNR0LOYDVSRMU]DDQD=ROWDQD=ROWDQQDZLHG PLQDD:LHG PLQQD
QLHERDSRWHPQD0LOY
:LHU]\V]ZERJyZ"VS\WDSyJRVHP
:LHU] RGEXUNQ D]FLFKDXF]QLF]NDSDWU] F QDZ JOHZRJQLVNX$OHQLH
GXPDPE\FKFLDRLPVL ]DSU] WDJRZ\JRU F\PLSRGNRZDPL
2GRJQLVNDGRWHJRVXNLQV\QDZV]\VWNLHJRWU]\NURNLV\NQ SU]H]]DFL QL WH
] E\=ROWDQ-DNR Z\WU]\PDPSUDFRZDHPZKXFLH0yGOFLHVL MHGQDN]D
PQLHGRW\FKZDV]\FKERJyZ
&KZLOHF]N (PLHO5HJLVSRR \NUDVQROXGRZLU N QDUDPLHQLX3URV]
ZVWU]\PDVL ] PRGDPL
&\UXOLNSRGV]HGGRRJQLVNDXNRQLVL NDSDQRZLLSXEOLF]QR FLSRF]\P
VFK\OLVL V]\ENRLZR \U N Z JRUHM FHZ JOH7XPZU]DVQ MHGQ\PJRVHP
=ROWDQ]DNO 0LOYDZSLDSDOFHZUDPL *HUDOWD5HJLVZ\SURVWRZDVL
2FXFLJRNRSQLDN
/H D]JRZ RSDUW R NRRSU]HZUyFRQHJRZR]XWX RERNQLHJRNXUF]\VL
-DVNLHU.RSL F\PRND]DVL NQHFKWZSU]HV]\ZDQLF\LRNU J\PKHPLH2ERN
QLHJRVWDGUXJL2EDMWU]\PDOL]DZRG]HNRQLHSU]\VLRGDFKNWyU\FKZLVLD\NXV]H
L WDUF]H
0\QDU]HF]\NLGLDEH"
'UXJLNQHFKWZ]UXV]\UDPLRQDPL*HUDOW]REDF]\ H -DVNLHUQLHRGU\ZDRF]X
RGWDUF]6DPWH MX GDZQR]DXZD \ H QDWDUF]DFKE\\OLOLH*RGDNUyOHVWZD
7HPHULL7DNLHVDPH]QDNLQRVLOLLQQLVWU]HOF\NRQQLRGNWyU\FKURLRVL Z
SREOL X:L NV]R ]DM WDE\DDSDQLHPNRQLLREG]LHUDQLHP]ZRN:ZL NV]R FL
QRV] F\FKF]DUQHQLOIJDDUG]NLHSDV]F]H
2ER]RZLVNRQDGDOE\RG\PL F UXLQ SRV]WXUPLHDOHMX SRMDZLOLVL FKRSL
NWyU]\RFDOHOLLQLHXFLHNOL]DGDOHNR6WU]HOF\NRQQL]WHPHUVNLPLOLOLDPLVS G]DOL
LFKGRNXS\SRNU]\NLZDOL
0LOY\=ROWDQD3HUFLYDODL5HJLVDQLJG]LHQLHE\RZLGD
7X RERNVLHG]LDERKDWHUQLHGDZQHJRSURFHVXRF]DU\F]DUQ\NRFXU
EH]QDPL WQLHSDWU] F QD*HUDOWD]LHORQR]RW\PLRF]DPL:LHG PLQ]G]LZLVL
QLHFR]Z\NOHNRW\QLH]QRVL\MHJREOLVNR FL1D]DVWDQDZLDQLHVL QDG
QLHFRG]LHQQ\P]MDZLVNLHPQLHPLDF]DVXERMHGHQ]NQHFKWyZV]WXUFKQ JR
GU]HZFHPRV]F]HSX
:VWDZDREDM+RODWHQVLZ\PDPLHF]
5]XEUR NU]\NQ GUXJLSU]\ZRXM F SR]RVWD\FK0LHF]QD]LHPL DOH
MX ERJHZL SU]HERG
*HUDOWXVXFKD:JRZLHPXG]ZRQLR
:\FR]DMHGQL"
3RGUy QLSRZLHG]LD-DVNLHU
-X FLSDUVNQ RGDN3RGUy XMHFLHGRGRP"=ELH DZV]\VSRG]QDNXL
]U]XFLZV]\EDUZ\"'X R ZW\PRER]LHWDNLFKSRGUy Q\FKFRVL 1LOIJDDUGX
SU]HO NOLFRLPZRMVNRZ\FKOHEHNQLHVPDNRZD1LHNWyU]\VWDU]\QDVL]QDMRPL=
QDV]HMFKRU JZL
7\FKSRGUy Q\FKWHUDLQQDSRGUy F]HND]DUHFKRWDGUXJL.UyWND'RJyU\
QDJD
1LHMHVWH P\GH]HUWHUDPLZU]DVQ SRHWD
3RND H VL NLPMHVWH FLH6]DU \ ]GDFLHVSUDZ
=]DSLHU FLHQLDVWU]HOFyZNRQQ\FKZ\RQLVL RGG]LDOHNNLHMMD]G\SURZDG]RQ\
SU]H]NLONXFL NR]EURMQ\FK]S\V]Q\PLSLyURSXV]DPLQDKHPDFK
-DVNLHUSU]\MU]DVL U\FHU]RPRWU]HSD]P NLLGRSURZDG]LGRSRU] GNX
SU]\RG]LHZ SRF]\PSRSOXQDGR L SU]\F]HVD]PLHU]ZLRQHZRV\
7\*HUDOWPLOF]XSU]HG]L-DE G SDNWRZD$IHWHPHUVNLHU\FHUVWZR
5R]ELOL1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ1LFQLH]UREL -X MDZLHPMDNVL ] SDVRZDQ\PL
UR]PDZLD7U]HEDLPSRND]D H QLH]SRVSyOVWZHPOHF]]UyZQ\PLVRELHPDM
VSUDZ
-DVNLHU]PLXMVL
1LHWXUEXMVL ZV]\VWNRE G]LHGREU]H= E\]MDGHPQDUR]PRZDFK]
U\FHUVWZHPLV]ODFKW SRRZD7HPHULLPQLH]QD+HM]GURJLSDFKRNLQDVW SFLH
VL 0DPVRZRGRZDV]\FKSDQyZ
.QHFKFLSRSDWU]\OL]ZDKDQLHPDOHXQLH OLQDVWDZLRQHZyF]QLHUR]VW SLOLVL
-DVNLHUL*HUDOWUXV]\OLZVWURQ U\FHU]\3RHWDNURF]\GXPQLHL]ZLHONRSD VN
PLQ PDRSDVXM F GRZ\VWU] SLRQHJRLXW\WDQHJRZP FHNDEDWD
6WDU\NQ GRQLHJRMHGHQ]SDQFHUQ\FK$QLNURNX&R FLH]DMHGQL"
$NRPXWRQLE\QLDPVL RSRZLDGD"-DVNLHUZ]L VL SRGERNL,GODF]HJR"
.LPWRV XURG]HQLSDQRZLHE\QLHZLQQ\FKSRGUy Q\FKRSU\PRZD"
1LHWRELHS\WDKR\V]X7RELHRGSRZLDGD
7UXEDGXUSU]HNU]\ZLJRZ SRSDWU]\QDKHUE\QDWDUF]DFKLWXQLNDFKU\FHU]\
7U]\VHUFDF]HUZRQHZSROX]RW\P]DXZD \=WHJRZ\QLND H FLH$XEU\
: JRZLHWDUF]\ODPEHORWU]HFK] EDFKD]DWHPPXVLFLHE\SLHUZRURGQ\P
V\QHP$Q]HOPD$XEU\
HJR5RG]LFDZDV]HJRGREU]H]QDPSDQLHU\FHU]X$Z\
SDQLHNU]\NOLZ\FRWDPQDVUHEUQHMWDUF]\QRVLFLH"0L G]\JU\ILPLJRZDPLVXS
F]DUQ\"+HUEURGX3DSHEURFNyZMH OLVL QLHP\O DMDZWDNLFKVSUDZDFKU]DGNR
VL P\O 6XSMDNSRZLDGDM RG]ZLHUFLHGODZD FLZ\F]RQNRPWHJRURGX
SRP\ OXQHN
3U]HVWD GROLFKDM NQ *HUDOW
-HVWHPV\QQ\SRHWD-DVNLHUQDG VL EDUGQLH]ZUDFDM F QDQLHJRXZDJL
3HZQLNLHPV\V]HOL FLH"3URZDG FLHWHG\GRZDV]HJRGRZyGF\GRVHQLRUDER]
UyZQ\PLVRELHSU]\Z\NHPUR]PDZLD
3DQFHUQLQLH]DUHDJRZDOLDOHZ\UD]LFKWZDU]\VWDZDVL FRUD]EDUG]LHM
QLHV\PSDW\F]Q\D HOD]QHU NDZLFHFRUD]PRFQLHM]DFLVND\VL QDR]GREQ\FK
WU ]ODFK-DVNLHUQDMZ\UD QLHMWHJRQLHGRVWU]HJD
1RFy WR]ZDPL"]DS\WDZ\QLR OH&]HJRVL WDNJDSLFLHU\FHU]X"7DN
GRZDVPyZL SDQLHVXSLHF]DUQ\&]HPXPLQ\URELFLH".WR ZDPSRZLHG]LD H
MH OL]PUX \FLHRF]\LZ\VXQLHFLHZSU]yGGROQ V]F] N E G]LHFLHZ\JO GDSR
P VNXP QLHGRVWRMQLHLJUR QLH"1DEUDZDVWHQNWR :\JO GDFLHQDNRJR NWR
RGW\JRGQLDQLHPLDV]F] FLDSRU] GQLHVL Z\VUD
%UDLFKZU]DVQ GRNQHFKWyZSLHUZRURGQ\V\Q$Q]HOPD$XEU\HJR
QRVLFLHOWDUF]\]WU]HPDVHUFDPL6XSF]DUQ\]URGX3DSHEURFNyZG JQ UXPDND
RVWURJDPL
%UDLFK:\NDKXOWDMyZ
6]OL]DNR PLFL JQLHQLQDSRZUR]DFK F] F\FKLFKVNU SRZDQHQDGJDUVWNL]
NDPLVLRGH6]OLDQLHNLHG\ELHJOLERMH G F\QLH DRZDOLDQLZLHU]FKRZFyZ
DQLMH FyZ-DVNLHUGZXNURWQLHZ\ZDOLVL L NLONDFKZLOMHFKDQDEU]XFKX
ZU]HV]F] FD OLWR EUDD6WDZLDQRJRQDQRJLPDROLWR FLZLHSRQDJODM F
GU]HZFHPRV]F]HSD,JQDQRGDOHM.XU]]DZLLR OHSLDRF]\GXVLLZLHUFLZ
QRVLH3UDJQLHQLHSDOLRJDUGD
-HGQRE\RSRFLHV]DM FHGURJDNWyU LFKJQDQRZLRGDQDSRXGQLH*HUDOW
SRGUy RZDRWRQDUHV]FLHZHZD FLZ\PNLHUXQNXLWRZFDOHV]\ENR1LHFLHV]\
VL MHGQDN%R]XSHQLHLQDF]HMZ\REUD DVRELHWDN SRGUy
1DPLHMVFHGRWDUOLZPRPHQFLHJG\-DVNLHURFKU\SRGEOX QLHUVWZPLHV]DQ\FK
] ZRDQLHPRPLRVLHUG]LHDEyOZRNFLXLNRODQLH*HUDOWDVWDOVL LVWQ WRUWXU QD
W\OHGRWNOLZ E\:LHG PLQ]DF] UR]ZD DSRGM FLHUDG\NDOQ\FKFKRE\L
UR]SDF]OLZ\FKDNFML
'RWDUOLGRZRMVNRZHJRRER]XUR]PLHV]F]RQHJRGRNRD]UXMQRZDQHMQDZSy
VSDORQHMZDURZQL=DSLHU FLHQLHPVWUD \NRQLRZL ]yZLG\PL F\FKELZDNRZ\FK
RJQLXMU]HOLR]GRELRQHSURSRUFDPLQDPLRW\U\FHUVWZDRWDF]DM FHREV]HUQ\L
UXFKOLZ\PDMGDQ]DSRUR]ZDODQ L RVPDORQ SDOLVDG 0DMGDQRND]DVL NUHVHP
LFKZ\PXV]RQHMZ GUyZNL
8MU]DZV]\NRU\WRGRSRMHQLDNRQL*HUDOWL-DVNLHUQDSL OLSRZUR]\-H G F\QLH
E\OLSRF] WNRZRVNRQQLSX FLLFKGRZRGRSRMXDOHV\Q$Q]HOPD$XEU\
HJR
SU]\SRPQLDVRELHZLGDRU]HNRPHM]QDMRPR FL-DVNUD]HVZ\PURG]LFLHOHPL
]HFKFLDE\DVNDZ\:HSFKQ OLVL PL G]\NRQLHQDSLOLREP\OLWZDU]H
VNU SRZDQ\PLU NRPD6]DUSQL FLHSRVWURQNyZZNUyWFHSU]\ZLRGRLFK
U]HF]\ZLVWR FL
.RJR FLHPL]QRZXSU]\ZLHGOL"VS\WDZ\VRNLLV]F]XS\U\FHU]Z
V]PHOFRZDQHMERJDWR]RFRQHM]EURLF\XGHU]DM F U\WPLF]QLHEX]G\JDQHPR
RUQDPHQWRZDQ WDV]N 1LHPyZFLHPLDE\ H WRNROHMQLV]SLHG]\
6]SLHG]\DOERGH]HUWHU]\SRWZLHUG]LV\Q$Q]HOPD$XEU\
HJR3RMPDOL P\
=DV]F]\WWRGODQDVSUDZG]LZ\SDQLHKUDELRXNRQLVL V]W\ZQR*HUDOW$OH
F]DVQDJOL0XVLP\UXV]DZGURJ
$OH SURV] VL QLHNU SRZDX PLHFKQ VL 'DQLHO(WFKHYHUU\=Z\N\
VNURPQ\ RQLHUVNLSRVLHN6DUQLQDMDU] ENLVWHULHW\WUXIOH
2GPyZL-DVNLHUSU]HNQ OLQ L ]PLHU]\ZLHG PLQDZ\PRZQ\P
VSRMU]HQLHPZLHONLPE\RE\QLHWDNWHP&KRG P\QLHPLHV]NDM FSDQLHKUDELR
&]\WDZMO%_6QDPLRWWHQERJDW\ZE NLWQR]RW\FKEDUZDFK"
1LH7RQDPLRWJyZQRGRZRG] FHJR/D]XUL]RWRWREDUZ\MHJRRMF]\]Q\
-DNWR"]G]LZLVL -DVNLHU3HZLHQE\HP H WHDUPLD7HPHULL H Z\WX
GRZRG]LFLH
7RMHVWZ\G]LHORQ\RGG]LDDUPLL7HPHULL-DMHVWHPRILFHUHP F]QLNRZ\P
NUyOD)ROWHVWDVX \ WXWH VSRURWHPHUVNLHMV]ODFKW\]SRF]WDPLNWyUHGODSRU] GNX
OLOLHQRV] QDWDUF]DFK$OHWU]RQWHJRNRUSXVXVWDQRZL SRGGDQLLQQHJRNUyOHVWZD
:LG]LFLHV]WDQGDUSU]HGQD]DLRWHLD"
/Z\*HUDOW]DWU]\PDVL =RWHOZ\QDE NLWQ\PSROX7R7RJRGR
&LQWU\SRWZLHUG]LKUDELD7RV HPLJUDQFL]NUyOHVWZD&LQWU\REHFQLH
RNXSRZDQHJRSU]H]1LOIJDDUG'RZRG]LQLPLPDUV]DHN9LVVHJHUG
*HUDOWRGZUyFLVL ] ]DPLDUHPR ZLDGF]HQLDKUDELHPX H SLOQHVSUDZ\
]PXV]DM JRMHGQDNGRUH]\JQDFML]VDUQLQ\VWHUOHWyZLWUXIOL1LH]G \=REDF]\
]EOL DM F VL NXQLPJUXS QDF]HOHNWyUHMV]HGSRVWDZQ\EU]XFKDW\LVLZ\U\FHU]
Z E NLWQ\PSDV]F]XL]H]RW\PD FXFKHPQD]EURL
2WRSDQRZLHSRHFLZD QLHPDUV]DHN9LVVHJHUGZHZDVQHMRVRELH
SRZLHG]LD'DQLHO(WFKHYHUU\3R]ZyOFLHZDV]DZLHOPR QR H ZDP
SU]HGVWDZL
1LHWU]HEDSU]HUZDFKUDSOLZLHPDUV]DHN9LVVHJHUGZLHUF F *HUDOWD
Z]URNLHP%\OL P\MX VRELHSU]HGVWDZLHQL:&LQWU]HQDGZRU]HNUyORZHM
&DODQWKH:GQLX]DU F]\QNUyOHZQ\3DYHWW\%\RWRSL WQD FLHODWWHPXDOHMD
SDPL PDPGREU $W\DMGDNXZLHG PLQLH"3DPL WDV]PQLH"
3DPL WDPNLZQ JRZ *HUDOWSRVXV]QLHSRGDM F RQLHU]RPU FHGR
]ZL ]DQLD
5R]G]LD
'RRSHUDFML&HQWDXUEU\JDGDSU]\VW SLDMDNRRGG]LDZ\G]LHORQ\,9$UPLL
.RQQHM2WU]\PDOL P\ZVSDUFLHZSRVWDFLWU]HFKURWOHNNLHMMD]G\YHUGH VNLHMNWyUH
SU]\G]LHOLHPGR*UXS\%RMRZHM<UHHPGH=UHV]W\EU\JDG\Z]RUHPNDPSDQLLZ
$HGLUQZ\G]LHOLHP*UXS\%RMRZH6LHXHUVL0RUWHLVHQND G Z VNDG]LH
F]WHUHFKV]ZDGURQyZ
=UHMRQX]H URGNRZDQLDSRG'ULHVFKRWZ\V]OL P\QRF ] F]ZDUWHJRQDSL WHJR
VLHUSQLD5R]ND]GOD*UXSEU]PLDRVL JQ UXELH 9LGRUW&DUFDQR$UPHULD
XFKZ\FLSU]HSUDZ\QD,QLHQLV]F] F QDSRWNDQHJRQLHSU]\MDFLHODDOHRPLMDM F
ZL NV]HSXQNW\RSRUX:]QLHFDM F SR DU\]ZDV]F]DQRFQHR ZLHWOLGURJ
G\ZL]MRQRP,9$UPLLZ\WZRU]\SDQLN Z UyGOXGQR FLF\ZLOQHMLGRSURZDG]LGR
]DNRUNRZDQLD]ELHJDPLZV]\VWNLFKDUWHULLNRPXQLNDF\MQ\FKQDW\DFKZURJD
3R]RUXM F RNU HQLHVS\FKDZ\FRIXM FHVL RGG]LD\ZURJDZNLHUXQNX
U]HF]\ZLVW\FKNRWyZ'RNRQXM F HOLPLQDFMLZ\EUDQ\FKJUXSOXGQR FLF\ZLOQHM
EXG]LSU]HUD HQLHSRJ ELDSDQLN L DPDPRUDOHQLHSU]\MDFLHOD
=DGDQLDSRZ\ V]HEU\JDGDZ\NRQDD]ZLHONLP RQLHUVNLPSR ZL FHQLHP
(ODQ7U E =DFHVDU]DLRMF]\]Q &KZDOHEQ\V]ODNERMRZ\9,,'DHUOD VNLHM
%U\JDG\.DZDOHULL
5R]G]LDSL W\
P\ ODFZDRZDELHJSU]H]EU]H]LQ RVSDOHOHQLZLHLZROQR&KRSLQD]RVWD
]QDF]QLH]W\OX]DUHV]W NRQLRNUDGyZ*G\XV\V]DL]REDF]\]DSOHFDPL0LOY
EH]]DVWDQRZLHQLD]RNRF]\LGDGUDSDNDZFKDV]F]HREXU F]SRGWU]\PXM F JDFLH
0LOYDQLH FLJDDJRSU]HPRJDZU F Z QLHM G] FL NLHJRPRUGRELFLD
:VNRF]\DQDVLRGR]ELHJXRVWURD ]DEU] F]D\VWUXQ\OXWQLSU]\WURF]RQHMGR
MXNyZ
2EH]QDQD]NR PL]GRDD]PXVLZDDFKDGRJDORSX&]\WH UDF]HMGR
RFL DHJRFKRGXNWyU\3HJD]XZD D]DJDORS
$OHQDZHWWHQSVHXGRJDORSZ\VWDUF]\DOERZLHPXFLHF]N NRQLRNUDGyZ
SU]\KDPRZDNROHMQ\QLHW\SRZ\NR 1DURZLVWD3ORWNDZLHG PLQDJQLDGD
NODF]NDNWyU UR]]RV]F]RQ\MHMIRFKDPL*HUDOWQLHMHGHQUD]RELHF\ZDZ\PLHQL
QDLQQHJRZLHU]FKRZFDFKRE\RVDPXDOXEQDZHWNR]D0LOYDGRS G]LD
]RG]LHLZPRPHQFLHJG\]GHQHUZRZDQDQLHZSUDZQ\PSRFL JQL FLHPZRG]\
3ORWND]ZDOLDMH G FDQD]LHPL DUHV]WDFKRSyZ]HVNRF]\ZV]\]VLRGHVWDUDD
VL SRVNURPLUR]EU\NDQ L ZLHU]JDM F NRE\N %\OLWDN]DM FL H GRVWU]HJOL
0LOY GRSLHURZWHG\JG\ZSDGDQDQLFKQD3HJD]LHLNRSQ DMHGQHJRZWZDU]
DPL F PXQRV*G\SDGDZ\M F LZ]\ZDM F SRPRF\ERVNLHMUR]SR]QDDJR%\
WR&KRGDN&KRSNWyU\QDMZ\UD QLHMQLHPLDV]F] FLDGROXG]L$]ZDV]F]DGR
0LOY\
0LOY QLHVWHW\WH RSX FLRV]F] FLH'RNDGQLHMELRU FQLHV]F] FLHE\R
ZLQQHOHF]MHMZDVQDDURJDQFMDLOHNNRSRGEXGRZDQHSUDNW\N SU]HNRQDQLH H
E\OHGZyMFHZLH QLDNyZ]GROQDMHVW]DZV]HVSX FLWDNLHODQLHMDNLHX]QD]D
VWRVRZQH$OHJG\]HVNRF]\D]VLRGDGRVWDDQDJOHSL FL Z RNRLQLHZLHG] F
NLHG\]QDOD]DVL QD]LHPL'RE\DQR D]GHF\GRZDQDQDSUXFLHIODNyZDOH
REHUZDDSRJRZLHJUXE\PNLMHPWDN H NLMS N]DV\SXM F MHMRF]\NRU L
SUyFKQHP2JXV]RQDLR OHSLRQD]GRDDMHGQDNXF]HSLVL NRODQDQDGDO
RNDGDM FHJRM XRPNLHPNLMDZLH QLDNDDZLH QLDNQLHVSRG]LHZDQLH]DZ\L
XSDG'UXJLZU]DVQ ]DVDQLDM F JRZ REXU F]
0LOYDSU]HWDUDRF]\L]REDF]\D H FKURQLVL SU]HGV\SL F\PLVL QDQLHJR
UD]DPLSOHWQL]DGDZDQ\PLSU]H]MH G FDVLHG] FHJRQDVLZ\PNRQLX=HUZDDVL
] UR]PDFKHPNRSQ DREDORQHJRFKRSDZV]\M .RQLRNUDG]DFKDUF]DZLHU]JQ
QRJDPLLUR]NUDF]\VL D0LOYDQDW\FKPLDVWWRZ\NRU]\VWDDZNDGDM F Z
SUHF\]\MQLHPLHU]RQ\NRSQLDNFD ]R &KRS]ZLQ VL Z N EHN]DFLVQ
GRQLHQDNURF]XL]DZ\WDN H D OLVWRZLHSRV\SDRVL ] EU]y]
-H G]LHFQDVLZNXXSRUDVL W\PF]DVHP]GUXJLPFKRSHPLEURF] F\P]QRVD
&KRGDNLHPSU]HS G]LLFKZODVUD]DPLEDWD=DZUyFLE\Z\VPDJDZ\M FHJR
DOHZVWU]\PDNRQLD%R0LOYD]G \DMX GRSD VZHJRNDURV]DMX PLDDZ
JDU FLXNLVWU]D QDFL FLZLH&L FLZDE\DZSRRZLHQDFL JXDOHJURWVWU]D\
PLHU]\SURVWRZSLHU MH G FD
3U]H]FKZLO SDWU]\OLQDVLHELHMH G]LHFLG]LHZF]\QD3RWHPMH G]LHFZROQ\P
UXFKHPZ\GRE\]]DSDVDVWU]D RSLHU]RQ GXJLPLORWNDPLLU]XFLM SRGQRJL
0LOY\
:LHG]LDHPU]HNVSRNRMQLH H E G PLDRND]M ]ZUyFLFLWZyMJURWHOINR
1LHMHVWHPHON 1LOIJDDUGF]\NX
1LHMHVWHP1LOIJDDUGF]\NLHP2SX QDUHV]FLHWHQXN*G\E\P \F]\FL OH
*G\Z\VRNL6FRLD
WDHOSRFK\OLVL QDGQLP]ZL ]DQ\ZNLM6WUX\FNHQ
SU]\PNQ RF]\]HVWUDFKX0yZLRQR H QLHLVWQLHM EU]\GNLHHOI\ H ZV]\VWNLHV
XURG]LZHMDNMDGHQP H WDNLHVL URG] %\PR H OHJHQGDUQ\SU]\ZyGFD
:LHZLyUHNWH XURG]LVL SL NQ\$OHWHUD]MHJRWZDU]SU]HFLQDDVNRVHPSDVNXGQD
V]UDPD]QLHNV]WDFDM FDF]RREUHZQRVLSROLF]HN]ZD FLZHMHOIRPXURG\QLH
]RVWDRQLF
3RNLHUHV]RZDQ\HOIXVLDGQDOH F\PRERNSQLX
-HVWHP,VHQJULP)DRLOWLDPDSRZLHG]LD]QRZXSRFK\ODM F VL QDGMH FHP
2GF]WHUHFKODWZDOF] ] OXG PLRGWU]HFKODWGRZRG] NRPDQGHP3RFKRZDHP
SROHJHJRZERMXEUDWDF]WHUHFKNX]\QyZSRQDGF]WHU\VWXWRZDU]\V]\EURQL:
PRMHMZDOFHZDV]HJRFHVDU]DPDP]DVSU]\PLHU]H FDFRZLHORNURWQLH
XGRZDGQLDHPSU]HND]XM F ZDV]\PVX ERPLQIRUPDFMHZ\ZLDGRZF]H
SRPDJDM F ZDV]\PDJHQWRPLUH]\GHQWRPOLNZLGXM F ZVND]DQHSU]H]ZDVRVRE\
)DRLOWLDUQD]DPLONGD]QDNXU NDZLF]RQ GRQL 6WRM F\RSRGDO6FRLD
WDHO
SRGQLyV]]LHPLQLHGX DJLHZN Z\NRQDQ ] EU]R]RZHMNRU\=DJLHZNLEL
VRGNL]DSDFK
0LDHPLPDP1LOIJDDUG]DVSU]\PLHU]H FDSRZWyU]\HOI]EOL]Q 'ODWHJR
SRF] WNRZRQLHGDZDHPZLDU\JG\PyMLQIRUPDWRURVWU]HJPQLH H V]\NXMHVL
QDPQLH]DVDG]N H RWU]\PDPSROHFHQLHVSRWNDQLDVL VDPQDVDP]
QLOIJDDUG]NLPHPLVDULXV]HPDJG\SU]\E G ]RVWDQ XM W\1LHZLHU]\HP
ZDVQ\PXV]RPDOHE G F ]QDWXU\RVWUR Q\VWDZLHPVL QDVSRWNDQLHQLHFR
ZF]H QLHMLQLHVDP-DN H ZLHONLHE\RPRMH]G]LZLHQLHLUR]F]DURZDQLHJG\
RND]DRVL H ZPLHMVFXWDMQHJRVSRWNDQLD]DPLDVWHPLVDULXV]DF]HNDV]H FLX
]ELUyZZ\SRVD RQ\FKZU\EDFN VLHSRZUR]\VNyU]DQ KDXE ] NQHEOHPLNDIWDQ
]DSLQDQ\QDSDV\LNODPU\(NZLSXQHNSRZLHG]LDE\PVWDQGDUGRZRX \ZDQ\
SU]H]ZDV]Z\ZLDGSU]\SRUZDQLDFK:\ZLDGQLOIJDDUG]LG]DSUDJQ VFKZ\WD
PQLH)DRLOWLDP \ZHJR]DZLH GRN G ]DNQHEORZDQHJR]DSL WHJRSRXV]\Z
NDIWDQEH]SLHF]H VWZD6SUDZD]DJDGNRZDSRZLHG]LDE\P:\PDJDM FD
Z\MD QLHQLD5DGMHVWHP H FKRMHGHQ]]DVDG]RQ\FKQDPQLH]ELUyZEH]
Z WSLHQLDLFKGRZyGFDGDVL XM \ZFHPLE G]LHZVWDQLHZ\MD QLH PL
XG]LHOL
6WUX\FNHQ]DFLVQ ] E\LRGZUyFLJRZ E\QLHSDWU]HQDSRNLHUHV]RZDQ
WZDU]HOID:RODSDWU]HQDDJLHZN ] EU]R]RZHMNRU\SU]\NWyUHMEU] F]D\GZLH
RV\
7HUD]ZL F SRGM )DRLOWLDPDZ\FLHUDM F FKXVWN VSRFRQ V]\M
SRJDZ G]LP\VRELHSDQLHSRU\ZDF]X'ODXDWZLHQLDNRQZHUVDFMLZ\MD QL NLOND
GHWDOL:WHMRWRDJLHZFH]QDMGXMHVL NORQRZ\V\URS-H OLQDV]DUR]PRZDQLH
PURZLVND]GHF\GRZDVL PyZL&KRNRQVHNZHQFMHPRJ\E\VWUDV]QLHMV]HQL
PUyZNL
3DQLH-H OLNWR VL R W\PGRZLHWR]JLQ HP$OHZ\]QDPZDP
:LG]LDHPVHNUHWQHUR]ND]\3RGVXFKDHP3RZLHPZV]\VWNR
7RRF]\ZLVWHNLZQ JRZ HOI5HNRUGZPURZLVNXZ\QRV] F\JRG]LQ L
F]WHUG]LH FLPLQXWQDOH DGRSHZQHJRRILFHUD]RGG]LDyZVSHFMDOQ\FKNUyOD
'HPDZHQGD$OHLRQZNR FXPyZL1R]DF]\QDM6]\ENRVNDGQLHLNRQNUHWQLH
&HVDU]MHVWSHZLHQ H QD7KDQHGG]GUDG]RQRJR=GUDMF MHVW9LOJHIRUW]]
5RJJHYHHQF]DURG]LHM,MHJRSRPRFQLN]Z F\VL 5LHQFH$SU]HGHZV]\VWNLP
&DKLU0DZU'\IIU\QDHS&HDOODFK9DWWLHU3DQ9DWWLHUQLHMHVWSHZLHQF]\L
Z\ FLHQLHPDF]DOLSDOFyZZWHM]GUDG]LHFKRE\QLH ZLDGRPLH'ODWHJRUR]ND]D
ZDVXM LFLFKFHPGRVWDUF]\GR1DVWURJD3DQLH)DRLOWLDPDMDGZDG]LH FLDODW
SUDFXM Z Z\ZLDG]LH9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[WRPyMWU]HFLV]HI
6NDGQLHMSURV] ,SU]HVWD VL WU] -H OLE G]LHV]]HPQ V]F]HU\PDV]
V]DQV SRVX \MHV]F]HNLONXV]HIRP
&KRXWU]\P\ZDQRWRZQDMJ EV]HMWDMHPQLF\DOHMDZLHG]LDHP
:LHG]LDHPNRJR9LOJHIRUW]L&DKLUPLHOLVFKZ\WDQDZ\VSLH,Z\FKRG]LRQDWR
H VL LPXGDR%RGR/RF*ULPSU]\ZLH]LRQRW -DNMHMWDP1RNUyOHZQ ]
&LQWU\7RPP\ OD H VXNFHV H &DKLUL5LHQFH]RVWDQ EDURQDPLDWHQ
F]DURG]LHMKUDEL FRQDMPQLHM$]DPLDVWWHJRFHVDU]ZH]ZD3XV]F]\ND=QDF]\
SDQD6NHOOHQDLSDQD9DWWLHUDUR]ND]DVFKZ\WD&DKLUD,5LHQFH
DL
9LOJHIRUW]D:V]\VF\NWyU]\PRJOLFR R 7KDQHGGZLHG]LHLRWHMVSUDZLHPLHOL
E\NDG]HQLQDWRUWXU\,Z\WH 1LHWUXGQRE\RVL GRP\ OL1R H E\D
]GUDGD H GR/RF*ULPSU]\ZLH]LRQRIDV]\Z NUyOHZQ
6]SLHJ]G\V]DVL QHUZRZRDSDSRZLHWU]HXVWDPL]DOHSLRQ\PLNORQRZ\P
V\URSHP
5R]ZL FLHJRVNRPHQGHURZDOVZ\P:LHZLyUNRP)DRLOWLDPD,QLHFKVRELH
XP\MHWZDU]
5R]ND]Z\NRQDQREH]]ZRF]QLH3RFKZLOLRUJDQL]DWRUQLHXGDQHM]DVDG]NLVWD
MX ] RSXV]F]RQ JRZ SU]HGWHJHQGDP\PSU]\ZyGF 6FRLD
WDHO)DRLOWLDPD
SU]\JO GDPXVL RERM WQLH
:\WU] QLMVNUXSXODWQLHV\URS]XV]XSRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLH1DGVWDZLFKL
Z\W SDPL MDNSU]\VWRLV]SLHJRZL]ZLHOROHWQL SUDNW\N 'DPGRZyGPRMHM
ORMDOQR FLZREHFFHVDU]D]GDPSHQ UHODFM R LQWHUHVXM F\FKZDVVSUDZDFK7\
]D ZV]\VWNRVRZRZVRZRSRZWyU]\V]9DWWLHURZLGH5LGHDX[
$JHQWVNZDSOLZLHSRNLZDJRZ
:SRRZLH%ODWKHF]\OLZHGXJZDV]HMUDFKXE\QDSRF] WNXF]HUZFD]DF]
HOIQDZL ]DD]HPQ NRQWDNW(QLGDQ*OHDQQDF]DURG]LHMND]QDQDMDNR
)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLU=MHMSROHFHQLDSU]\E\ZNUyWFHGRPRMHJRNRPDQGDQLHMDNL
5LHQFHSRGREQRWRWXPIDFNL9LOJHIRUW]D]5RJJHYHHQWH PDJLND:QDMJ EV]HM
WDMHPQLF\RSUDFRZDQ\]RVWDSODQDNFMLPDM FHMQDFHOXZ\HOLPLQRZDQLHSHZQHM
OLF]E\F]DURG]LHMyZSRGF]DV]MD]GXQDZ\VSLH7KDQHGG3ODQ]RVWDPL
SU]HGVWDZLRQ\MDNRDNFMDPDM FDSHQHSRSDUFLHFHVDU]D(PK\UD9DWWLHUDGH
5LGHDX[L6WHIDQD6NHOOHQDLQDF]HMQLH]JRG]LE\PVL ZVSySUDFRZD]'K
RLQH
F]DURG]LHMDPLF]\QLHER]DZLHOHZLG]LDHPZ \FLXSURZRNDFML=DDQJD RZDQLH
GUHZQLDQHMWUXPQ\LSU]\SRPRF\]QDMRPHJRKD\HIIWGRVWDUF]\ZHZVND]DQHZ
OL FLHPLHMVFH1LHE\HPSU]\]QDM WRVNRQQ\GRXV]F]XSOHQLDNRPDQGDR
HVNRUW 1LHZLHPNWRZ\PRUGRZDZDV]\FKOXG]LZPLHMVFXVSRWNDQLD$RW\P
JG]LHWRMHVWZLHG]LDHPZ\ F]QLHMD-H OLZL F QLHRGSRZLDGDZDPZHUVMD
FDNLHPSU]\SDGNRZHM]DJDG\ZDV]HJRRGG]LDXWR]GUDMF\V]XNDMFLHXVLHELHER
RSUyF]PQLHW\ONRZ\]QDOL FLHWHUPLQLPLHMVFH
)DRLOWLDUQDZVWD
7RZV]\VWNR:V]\VWNLHSRZ\ V]HLQIRUPDFMHV SUDZG]LZH:ORFKDFK
1DVWURJDQLHGRVWDUF]\E\PZDPLFKZL FHM.DPVWZDLNRQIDEXODFMHNWyU\PL
E\PR HSUyERZDE\P]DGRZROL OHGF]HJRLRSUDZFyZ]DV]NRG]L\E\ZDP
UDF]HMQL SRPRJ\1LF]HJRZL FHMQLHZLHPZV]F]HJyOQR FLQLH]QDPPLHMVFD
SRE\WX9LOJHIRUW]DL5LHQFH
DQLHZLHPWH F]\VXV]QLHSRGHMU]HZDFLHLFKR
]GUDG 2 ZLDGF]DPWH GRELWQLH H QLFQLHZLHPRNUyOHZQLH]&LQWU\DQL
SUDZG]LZHMDQLIDV]\ZHM3RZLHG]LDHPZV]\VWNRFRZLHG]LDHP/LF] H SDQ
GH5LGHDX[DQL6WHIDQ6NHOOHQQLH]HFKF MX ]DVWDZLDQDPQLH]DVDG]HN'K
RLQH
RGGDZQDSUyEXM PQLHVFKZ\WDOXE]DELQDEUDHPWHG\]Z\F]DMX
EH]Z]JO GQHJRHNVWHUPLQRZDQLDZV]\VWNLFK]DVDG]NRZLF]yZ:SU]\V]R FL
UyZQLH QLHE G GRFLHNDF]\NWyU\ ] ]DVDG]NRZLF]yZQLHMHVWSU]\SDGNLHP
SRGZDGQ\P9DWWLHUDOXE6NHOOHQD1LHE G PLDQDWDNLHGRFLHNDQLHDQLF]DVX
DQLRFKRW\&]\Z\UD DPVL MDVQR"
6WUX\FNHQNLZQ JRZ SU]HNQ OLQ
%LHU]ZL F NRQLDV]SLHJXLZ\QR VL ] PRLFKODVyZ
1LMHGQHJRRJQLDV]HSQ D0LOYDZSDWU]RQDZFLHPQ\EU]HJ]DO QL F Z
ZLHWOHNVL \FDU]HN 1L \ZHJRGXFKDWDPQLHPDZLG]LPLVL :RER]LHE\R
]HGZLHVHWNL]ELHJyZ DGHQJRZ\QLHXQLyV"
-H OLFHVDUVF\SU]HZD \OLSRS G]LOLZV]\VWNLFKZQLHZRO RGV]HSQ O &DKLU
-H OL]Z\FL \OLZDVL]DEUDOLLFKRGFKRG] F
3RGHV]OLEOL HMEU]HJXGR]DUDVWDM F\FKEDJQRWU]FLQ0LOYDQDGHSQ DQDFR L
RGVNRF]\DWXPL F NU]\NQDZLGRNZ\DQLDM FHMVL ] ERWD]HV]W\ZQLDHM
SRNU\WHMSLMDZNDPLU NL
7RW\ONRWUXSPUXNQ &DKLUFKZ\WDM F M ]DUDPL 1DV]'DHULD F]\N
.WR"
6LyGPDGDHUOD VNDEU\JDGDNDZDOHULL6UHEUQ\VNRUSLRQQDU NDZLH
%RJRZLHZ]GU\JQ DVL JZDWRZQLHG]LHZF]\QD FLVNDM F XNZVSRFRQHM
SL FL6\V]DH WHQJRV"&RWRE\R"
:LON
$OERJKXO$OERLQQ\SRW SLHQLHF7DPZRER]LHWH PRFWUXSyZPXVL
OH H=DUD]DQLHSyMG Z QRF\QDWDPWHQEU]HJ
=DF]HNDP\GR ZLWX0LOYD"&RWXWDNG]LZQLH
5HJLVXF]QLF]NDVWXPLDNU]\NZ V] F ]DSDFKSLRXQXV]DZLLNROHQGU\L
DQ\ NX5HJLV"7RW\"
-DF\UXOLNEH]V]HOHVWQLHZ\RQLVL ] PURNX0DUWZLHPVL R FLHELH1LH
MHVWH VDPDMDNZLG]
$QRGREU]HZLG]LV]0LOYDSX FLDUDPL &DKLUDNWyU\MX GRE\ZDPLHF]D
-DQLHVDPDLRQMX WH QLHVDP$OHWRGXJDKLVWRULDMDNQLHNWyU]\PyZL 5HJLV
FR]ZLHG PLQHP"=-DVNUHP"=UHV]W " :LHV]FRVL ] QLPLVWDR"
:LHP0DFLHNRQLH"
0DP\:R]LHXNU\WH
5XV]DMP\ZL F QDSRXGQLH]ELHJLHP&KRWOL%H]]ZRNL3U]HGSyQRF
PXVLP\E\SRG$UPHUL
&R]ZLHG PLQHPLSRHW " \M "
\M $OHPDM NRSRW\
-DNLH"
7RGXJDKLVWRULD
7DPF\UXOLNZVND]DSDDM FHSXQNFLNLELZDNRZ\FKRJQL7DPMHVWIRUW
$UPHULDDNWXDOQLHREy]IRUSRF]W\ZRMVNWHPHUVNLFKVNRQFHQWURZDQ\FKSRG
0D\HQ
7DPZLHG PLQDL-DVNUDZL " 0LOYDVWDQ DZVWU]HPLRQDFK+DWHG\
NLHSVNR7DPKXUPD]EURMQHJROXGDPXVLE\DLVWUD H GRRNRD1LHOHNNRE G]LH
VL WDPyMSU]HNUD
1LHE G]LHFLHPXVLHOLRGU]HN5HJLV]VLDGDM F ]3HJD]D:DDFKSDUVNQ
SU]HFL JOHRGZUyFLHEZ\UD QLH]GHJXVWRZDQ\ZLHUF F\PZQRVLH]LRRZ\P
]DSDFKHPF\UXOLND
1LHE G]LHFLHPXVLHOLVL SRGNUDGDSRZWyU]\-DVDPWR]DDWZL :\
]DF]HNDFLH]NR PLWDPJG]LHE\V]F]\U]HNDZLG]LFLH"3RQL HMQDMMD QLHMV]HM
JZLD]G\6LHGPLX.y]7DP&KRWODZSDGDGR,Q\*G\Z\FL JQ ZLHG PLQD]
WDUDSDWyZVNLHUXM JRZWDPW VWURQ 7DPVL VSRWNDFLH
:LHOFH]DGXIDQ\PUXNQ &DKLUGR0LOY\JG\]VLDGDM F ]QDOH OLVL EOLVNR
VLHELH6DPEH]QLF]\MHMSRPRF\E G]LH]WDUDSDWyZZ\FL JDV\V]DD " .WRWR
MHVW"
, FLHQLHZLHPRGPUXNQ D0LOYD:]JO GHP]D Z\FL JDQLDWRMDPX
ZLHU] :F]RUDMQDP\FKRF]DFKJR GRQL Z\FL JQ UR]SDORQ SRGNRZ ]
Z JOL
&]DURG]LHM"
'UDNHQERUJUHGD VNLIRUW]DPLHQLRQ\QDREy]PWHALIHZDQLDHOIyZLLQQ\FK
Z\ZURWRZ\FKHOHPHQWyZPLDSRQXUHWUDG\FMHZ\WZRU]RQHZFL JXWU]HFKODW
IDQNJIUQRZDQLD-HGQ ] WDNLFKWUDG\FMLE\RZLHV]DQLHR ZLFLH'UXJ E\R
ZF]H QLHMV]HJURPDG]HQLHVND]DQ\FKQD PLHUZGX HMZVSyOQHMFHOLVN G R
EU]DVNXZ\SURZDG]DQRSRGV]XELHQLF
6ND]D FyZJUXSRZDQRZFHOLSRNLONXQDVWXDFDLFZHUNDZLHV]DQRGZyFK
WU]HFKF]DVDPLF]WHUHFK3R]RVWDOLF]HNDOLQDVZRM NROHMN 'XJR1LHNLHG\
W\G]LH 2F]HNXM F\FK]ZDQRZRER]LH:HVRNDPL%RDWPRVIHUDZRNy PLHUFL
]DZV]HE\DZHVRD3RSLHUZV]HGRSRVLNyZSRGDZDQRMH FRPNZD QHLPRFQR
UR]FLH F]RQHZLQRQRV] FHZRER]RZ\P DUJRQLHQD]Z :\WUDZQ\'LMNVWUD
QLHE\RERZLHPVHNUHWHP H SU]HG PLHUWQ\WUXQHNVHUZRZDQ\E\VND]DQ\PQD
RVRELVW\UR]ND]V]HIDUHGD VNLFKVX E Z\ZLDGRZF]\FK3RGUXJLHQLNRJR]FHOL
PLHUFLQLHZOHF]RQRMX ZL FHMQDSU]HVXFKDQLDZ]RZURJLHMSRG]LHPQHM3UDOQL
D VWUD QLNRPQLHZROQRE\R]Q FDVL QDGZL QLDPL
7HMQRF\WUDG\FMLUyZQLH G]LDRVL ]DGR :FHOL]DMPRZDQHMSU]H]V]H FLX
HOIyZMHGQHJRSyHOIDMHGQHJRQL]LRNDGZyFKOXG]LLMHGQHJR1LOIJDDUGF]\ND
E\RZHVRR
:\WUDZQHJR'LMNVWU VROLGDUQLH]OHZDQRQDEODV]DQ\WDOHU]LFKHSWDQREH]
SRPRF\U NDOERZLHPWDNLVSRVyEGDZDQDMZL NV]HV]DQV OHNNLHJRFKRE\
RV]RRPLHQLDVL FLH NXV]HP7\ONRMHGHQ]HOIyZ6FRLD
WDHO]UR]ELWHJRNRPDQGD
ORUZHWKDQLHGDZQRPRFQRVNDWRZDQ\Z3UDOQL]DFKRZ\ZDVSRNyMLSRZDJ
]DM W\Z\VNURE\ZDQLHPQDEHOFH FLDQ\QDSLVX:ROQR OXE PLHU3RGREQ\FK
QDSLVyZZLGQLDRQDEHONDFKNLONDVHW3R]RVWDOLVND]D F\WH ]JRGQLH]WUDG\FM
SLHZDOLZNyNRK\PQ:HVRNyZDQRQLPRZ XR RQ Z 'UDNHQERUJXSLH
NWyUHMVyZND G\]ZL QLyZXF]\VL Z EDUDNDFKVXFKDM F QRFDPLG ZL NyZ
GRELHJDM F\FK]FHOL PLHUFLZLHG] F H NLHG\ L MHPXSU]\MG]LHZ\VW SLZ
FKyU]H
7D F] QDVWU\F]NDFKZLVLHOF\
: GUJDZNDFKVL NXUF] U\WPLF]QLH
SLHZDM VZRM SLRVHQN
0HODQFKROLF]QLHL OLF]QLH
:VSDQLDOHEDZL VL :HVRNL
&KZLO ZVSRPLQDND G\WUXS
*G\Z\WU FRQRVSRGQyJVWRNL
, JG\VWDQ \RF]\ZVXS
6WXNQ D]DVXZD]D]JU]\WD]DPHN:HVRNLSU]HUZD\SLH :FKRG] F\R
ZLFLHVWUD QLF\PRJOLR]QDF]DW\ONRMHGQR]DPRPHQWFKyU]RVWDQLH
XV]F]XSORQ\RNLOND]JRVyZ3\WDQLHEU]PLDRF]\LFK
6WUD QLF\ZHV]OLNXS 1LH OLSRZUR]\VX FHGRNU SRZDQLDU N ZLHG]LRQ\P
SRGV]XELHQLF -HGHQSRFL JQ QRVHPZ]L SDN SRGSDFK UR]ZLQ SHUJDPLQ
RGNDV]OQ
(FKHO7URJHOWRQ
7UDLJKOHWKDQSRSUDZLEH]QDFLVNXHOI]NRPDQGD,RUZHWKD-HV]F]HUD]
SRSDWU]\QDZ\VNUREDQHKDVRLZVWD]WUXGHP
&RVPR%DOGHQ\HJJ
1L]LRHNJR QRSU]HNQ OLQ 1D]DULDQZLHG]LD H ZL ]LRQRJRSRG]DU]XWHP
DNWyZG\ZHUVMLGRNRQ\ZDQ\FKQD]OHFHQLHQLOIJDDUG]NLHJRZ\ZLDGX%DOGHQ\HJJ
QLHSU]\]QDZDVL MHGQDNGRZLQ\LXSDUFLHWZLHUG]L H REDNDZDOHU\MVNLHNRQLH
XNUDG]ZDVQHMLQLFMDW\Z\LGOD]DURENXD1LOIJDDUGQLFGRWHJRQLHPD$OH
QDMZ\UD QLHMQLHXZLHU]RQRPX
1D]DULDQ
1D]DULDQZVWDSRVXV]QLHSRGDVWUD QLNRPU FHGR]ZL ]DQLD*G\
Z\SURZDG]DQRFD WUyMN UHV]WD:HVRNyZSRGM D SLHZ
7D F] QDVWU\F]NDFKZLVLHOF\
: GUJDZNDFKVL NXUF] ZHVRR
$ ZLDWUSLRVHQN LFKQLHVLH
' ZL F]Q\PUHIUHQHPZRNRR
PLHV]DQLHF6FKLUUXREXMXU\VWyZ]DPRUGRZDLGRPLFKSRG HJ=EURG]LH
1D]DULDQZV]\VWNRQDRZHJR6FKLUUXVWU FD]DSU]HF]DLZ\SLHUDVL MDNRE\RQ
VDPPRUGRZDDOHWRSHZQLH]HVWUDFKXSU]HGVWU\F]NLHP&R]DVL -:3+UDELHJR
]DLQWHUHVRZDPR HMHVWSU]HG]EURGQL QDMXU\VWDFKSRSHQLRQ ]RF]\ F\RZLWR
MHVW1D]DULDQSyHOI6FKLUUXL-DJDZLHG]PLQD OHG]LOLQLHMDNLHJR*HUDOGD]5LYLL
NWyUHQWR]MXU\VW &RGULQJKHUHPSRWDMHPQLHVL ]QRVL:MDNLHMVSUDZLHWHJR
]RF]\ FD1D]DULDQQLHZLHERVL SU]HGQLPDQLU]HF]RQ\ZF]H QLHM5\HQVDQL
SyOHOI6FKLUUX]VHNUHWXQLHVSX FLOL$OHJG\5\HQVRZLUDSRUWRNRQV]DFKWDFKW\FK
]GDQ\]RVWD5\HQVUR]ND]DMXU\VWyZ]JDG]L
'DOHM]H]QD]RF]\ FD1D]DULDQZVSyOQLNMHJR6FKLUUX]GRPXMXU\VWyZ
GRNXPHQWDVNUDGNWyUH5\HQVRZLGRVWDUF]RQHE\\GR&DUUHUDVGRREHU \ 3RG
/LVHP3U]HFKHU 2F]\P5\HQVL6FKLUUXWDPNRQZHUVRZDOL1D]DULDQRZLQLHMHVW
ZLDGRPHDOHQD]DMXWU]FDDRZDSU]HVW SF]DWUyMFDGR%UXJJHVL XGDDLWDP
&]ZDUWHJRGQLDSRQRZLXGRSX FLDVL SRUZDQLDPRGHMSDQQ\]GRPX]FHJ\
F]HUZRQHMQDGU]ZLDFKNWyUHJRPRVL QHQR \FHSU]\ELWHE\\3DQQ 5\HQV
PDJLF]Q\PQDSRMHPRV]RRPLD]EURGQLDU]H6FKLUUXL1D]DULDQZZLHONLP
SR SLHFK\NRODVN M SRZLH OLGR9HUGHQGRWZLHUG]\1DVWURJ$UD]U]HF]
QDVW SXMHNWyU ZLHONLHMXZDG]H-:3+UDELHJRSROHFDP]RF]\ F\Z\GDOL
SRUZDQ SDQQ QLOIJDDUGNLHPXNRPHQGDQWRZLWZLHUG]\XSHZQLDM F MHJR]HRZD
SRUZDQD]ZLHVL &\U\OD]&LQWU\.RPHQGDQWMDNR]H]QD]EURG]LH 1D]DULDQ
ZLHOFHW ZLDGRPR FL E\XNRQWHQWRZDQ\
3RZ\ V]H FL OHWDMQLHNXULHUHP-:3+UDELHPXHNVSHGLXM 'RNDGQ\SURWRNy
SU]HVXFKDQLDWDNR SR O MHQRJRVNU\EDQDF]\VWRSU]HSLV]H8QL HQLH-:3
+UDELHJRRLQVWUXNFMHXSUDV]DPFR]H]RF]\ F 1D]DULDQHPXF]\QL$]DOL
ZV\SDPXN VDEL]XQHPE\ZL FHMRVWDOLUDF]\SU]\SRPQLHVRELHD]DOL
REZLHVLZHGOHREVHUZDQF\L
.UH O VL ] V]DFXQNLHPHWFHWF
9DVFRLJQH]DPDV]\ FLHSRGSLVDUDSRUWRGFLVQ SLHF] LZH]ZDJR FD
7UH UDSRUWX]QDQDE\OD'LMNVWU]HZLHF]RUHPWHJRVDPHJRGQLD)LOLSSLH(LOKDUW
]QDQDE\DZSRXGQLHGQLDQDVW SQHJR
SURZL]RU\F]QHJRRSDWUXQNXJG\SRF]XDQDUDPLHQLXU N L ]Z V]\D]QDMRP\
]DSDFKSLRXQXDQ\ NXLLQQ\FK]Ly5HJLVVZRLP]Z\F]DMHP]MDZLVL QLH
ZLDGRPRNLHG\QLHZLDGRPHMDNLQLHZLDGRPRVN G
3R]ZyOSRZLHG]LDZ\FL JDM F ]HVZHMSU]HSDVWQHMWRUE\PHG\F]QHXWHQV\OLD
L LQVWUXPHQW\-DVL W\P]DMP
*G\F\UXOLNRGU\ZDRSDWUXQHNRGUDQ\-DVNLHU]DM F]DEROH QLH
6SRNRMQLHU]HNL5HJLVSU]HP\ZDM F UDQ 7RQLF7URFK NUZL7\ONRWURFK
NUZLDGQLHSDFKQLHWZRMDNUHZSRHWR
,ZD QLHZyZF]DV:LHG PLQ]DFKRZDVL Z VSRVyEMDNLHJR0LOYDQLHPRJD
RF]HNLZD3RGV]HGGRNRQLDLZ\FL JQ ]SU]\SL WHMSRGW\ELQN SRFKZ\GXJL
QLOIJDDUG]NLPLHF]
2GHMG RGQLHJRZDUNQ VWDM F QDGF\UXOLNLHP
DGQLHSDFKQLHWDNUHZSRZWyU]\5HJLVQLH]ZUDFDM F QDZLHG PLQD
QDMPQLHMV]HMXZDJL1LHZ\F]XZDPZQLHM]DSDFKX]DND HQLDNWyUHZUDQLH
JRZ\PRJRE\PLHIDWDOQHVNXWNL$UWHULDL \DQLHQDUXV]RQH7HUD]
]DV]F]\SLH
-DVNLHU]DM F]DJZDWRZQLHZFL JQ SRZLHWU]H0LHF]ZGRQLZLHG PLQD
]DGUJD]DO QL ZLDWHPRGELW\PRGU]HNL
=DR NLONDV]ZyZSRZLHG]LD5HJLVQDGDOQLH]ZUDFDM F XZDJLDQLQD
ZLHG PLQDDQLQDMHJRPLHF]% G P Q\-DVNLHU
-DVNLHUE\P Q\
-X NR F] 5HJLV]DEUDVL ]DEDQGD RZDQLH'RZHVHODWU\ZLDOQLH
PyZL F]DJRLVL 5DQDZVDPUD]GODSRHW\-DVNLHU% G]LHV]FKRG]LMDN
ZRMHQQ\ERKDWHU]GXPQ\PEDQGD HPQDF]ROHDVHUFDSDWU] F\FKQDFLHELH
SDQLHQWRSLVL E G MDNZRVN7DNL FLHSRHW\F]QDUDQD1LHWRFRSRVWU]DZ
EU]XFK5R]ZDORQDZ WUREDUR]GDUWHQHUNLLMHOLWDZ\ODQDWUH LND]DSDOHQLH
RWU]HZQHM1RJRWRZH*HUDOWMX MHVWHPGRWZRMHMG\VSR]\FML
:VWDDZyZF]DV:LHG PLQSU]\VWDZLPXPLHF]GRJDUGD5XFKHPWDN
V]\ENLP H D XP\NDM F\PRF]RP
&RIQLMVL ZDUNQ GR0LOY\5HJLVQLHGUJQ QDZHWFKRV]W\FKPLHF]D
GHOLNDWQLHRSLHUDVL R MHJRV]\M XF]QLF]NDZVWU]\PDDRGGHFKZLG] FMDN
RF]\F\UXOLNDUR]SDODM VL Z PURNXG]LZQ\PNRFLP ZLDWHP
1RGDOHM H SRZLHG]LDVSRNRMQLH5HJLV3FKQLM
*HUDOWVW NQ ]]LHPL-DVNLHUFDNLHPSU]\WRPQLH&]\ W\GRUHV]W\
]ZDULRZD"2QXUDWRZDQDVVSRGV]XELHQLF\2SDWU]\PLHE
2FDOLZRER]LHG]LHZF]\Q L QDVSU]\SRPQLDDFLFKR0LOYD
0LOF]FLH1LHZLHFLHNLPRQMHVW
&\UXOLNQLHSRUXV]\VL $0LOYDQDJOH]SU]HUD HQLHPGRVWU]HJDWRFR
SRZLQQDE\DGRVWU]HFMX GDZQR5HJLVQLHU]XFDFLHQLD
:VDPHMU]HF]\SRZLHG]LDZROQR1LHZLHPNLPMHVWHP$SRUDE\ FLH
ZLHG]LHOL1D]\ZDPVL (PLHO5HJLV5RKHOOHF7HU]LHII*RGHIUR\ \M QDW\P
ZLHFLHF]WHU\VWDGZDG]LH FLDRVLHPODWZHGXJZDV]HJRUDFKXQNXV]H VHW
F]WHUG]LH FLGZDODWDZHGXJUDFKXE\HOIyZ-HVWHPSRWRPNLHPUR]ELWNyZ
QLHV]F] VQ\FKLVWRWXZL ]LRQ\FKZ UyGZDVSRNDWDNOL]PLHNWyU\Z\QD]\ZDFLH
.RQLXQNFM 6IHU8FKRG] GHOLNDWQLHPyZL F]DSRWZRUD=DNUZLR HUF]H
PRQVWUXP$WHUD]WUDILHPQDZLHG PLQDNWyU\]DZRGRZRSDUDVL
HOLPLQRZDQLHPWDNLFKMDNMD7RZV]\VWNR
,Z\VWDUF]\*HUDOWRSX FLPLHF]$ QDGWR=P\NDMVW G(PLHOX5HJLVLH
&R 7DP-DNR 7DP:\QR VL
7RQLHE\ZDH]DGUZL5HJLV3R]ZROLV]PLRGHM "0QLHE G FHPX
]DJUR HQLHPGODOXG]L":LHG PLQSRZLQLHQZ\NRU]\VW\ZDND G RND]M GR
HOLPLQRZDQLDWDNLFK]DJUR H
=MH G DM2GGDOVL LWRV]\ENR
:MDNGDOHNLHVWURQ\PDPVL RGGDOL"VS\WDZROQR5HJLV:NR FXMHVWH
ZLHG PLQHP:LHV]RPQLH*G\XSRUDV]VL MX ] WZRLPSUREOHPHPJG\
]DDWZLV]FRPDV]GR]DDWZLHQLD]DSHZQHZUyFLV]ZWHVWURQ\:LHV]JG]LH
PLHV]NDPJG]LHE\ZDPF]\PVL ]DMPXM % G]LHV]PQLHWURSL"
1LHZ\NOXF]DP-H OLE G]LHQDJURGD-HVWHPZLHG PLQHP
\F] SRZRG]HQLD5HJLV]DSL WRUE UR]ZLQ SDV]F]%\ZDM$FKMHV]F]H
MHGQR-DNZ\VRNDPXVLDDE\E\E\QDJURGD]DPRM JRZ E\ ]HFKFLDVL
IDW\JRZD"-DNPQLHZ\FHQLDV]"
&KROHUQLHZ\VRNR
HFKF]HV]PRM SUy QR $NRQNUHWQLH"
6SLHSU]DM5HJLV
-X $OHSU]HGWHPZ\FH PQLH3URV]
=D]Z\NHJRZDPSLUDEUDHPUyZQRZDUWR GREUHJRNRQLDSRGZLHU]FK$W\
SU]HFLH ]Z\N\QLHMHVWH
,OH"
: WSL JRVZLHG PLQDE\]LPQ\MDNOyG: WSL E\NRJRNROZLHNE\R
VWD
5R]XPLHPLG]L NXM ZDPSLUX PLHFKQ VL W\PUD]HPRGVDQLDM F ] E\1D
WHQZLGRN0LOYDL&DKLUFRIQ OLVL D-DVNLHUVWXPLNU]\NSU]HVWUDFKX
%\ZDMFLH3RZRG]HQLD
%\ZDM5HJLV1DZ]DMHP
(PLHO5HJLV5RKHOOHF7HU]LHII*RGHIUR\VWU]HSQ SDV]F]HPRZLQ VL QLP
]DPDV]\ FLHL]QLN3RSURVWX]QLN
7HUD]*HUDOWRGZUyFLVL QDGD]REQD RQ\PPLHF]HPZGRQLF]DVQD
FLHELH1LOIJDDUGF]\NX
1LHSU]HUZDDJQLHZQLH0LOYD:\ HMXV]XPDPMX WHJR1DNRQLH
Z\QR P\VL VW G5]HN NU]\NLVL QLRV DQLVL REHMU]\PJG\NWR QDPWXQD
NDUNZVL G]LH
1LHSRMDG Z MHJRWRZDU]\VWZLH
7RMHG VDPZU]DVQ DUR]Z FLHF]RQDQLHQD DUW\:LQQ VWURQ :\ HM
XV]XPDPMX WZRLFKKXPRUyZZLHG PLQLH5HJLVDSU]HS G]LH FKR \FLHFL
]UDWRZDDOHWRWZRMDVSUDZD$OH&DKLU]UDWRZDPQLHWHG\PLGUXKHP-H OL]D
WRELHMHVWZURJLHPWRZUDFDMGR$UPHULLZROQDGURJD7DPWZRLSU]\MDFLHOHMX ]H
VWU\NLHPF]HNDM
1LHNU]\F]
7RQLHVWyMQLE\NR3RPy PLZVDG]L-DVNUDQDZDDFKD
2FDOLD QDV]HNRQLH"3RWN WH "
2QRFDOLUXFKHPJRZ\ZVND]DDQD&DKLUD-D]GDZGURJ
WDQRZDV]DURZRVDQD]\ZDQD)DON $VVHL5HHI]DP\NDOLSRFKyGFL JQ F
OX]DNLQLHFK\EQLH]UDERZDQHLSU]\SURZDG]RQHQDVSU]HGD %\OL]P F]HQLL
SRNU\FLNXU]HPDOHWU]\PDOLVL Z VLRGDFKG]LDUVNRRFKRF]RRGSRZLDGDOLQD
SR]GURZLHQLDJRV]F] F\FKZ/RUHGRNDPUDWyZL]QDMRP\FK=HVNRF]\ZV]\]NRQL
L SRF] VWRZDQLSLZHPQDW\FKPLDVWSU]\VW SLOLGRKDD OLZ\FKQHJRFMDFML]
KDQGODU]DPLLSDVHUDPL:V]\VF\RSUyF]0LVWOHLWHMQRZHMV]DURZRVHMQRV] FHM
PLHF]SU]HU]XFRQ\SU]H]SOHF\7HSRV]\PL G]\VWUDJDQ\MDN]Z\NOH
]DSHQLDM FHPDMGDQ/RUHGRPLDRVZRMHGQLWDUJRZHZWHG\REOLF]RQDQD
SU]\MH]GQ\FKEDQG\WyZRIHUWDWRZDUyZE\DV]F]HJyOQLHERJDWDLUy QRURGQD
']LVLDMZD QLHE\WDNLG]LH
6HUYDGLRRVWUR QLHSRG \]DG]LHZF]\QDPL$E\]DURELPXVLDGRQLH DE\
GRQLH PXVLDSRGVXFKD
']LHZF]\Q\RJO GD\NRORURZHFKXVWNLNRUDOLNLKDIWRZDQHEOX]NLF]DSUDNL
R]GREQHQDF]yNLGODNRQL3U]HELHUD\ZWRZDU]HDOHQLHNXSRZD\0LVWOHSUDZLH
FD\F]DVWU]\PDDU N QDUDPLHQLXV]DURZRVHM
6]SLFHORVWUR QLHSU]\VXQ VL EOL HMXGD H RJO GDU]HPLHQLHLSDV\QD
VWUDJDQLHU\PDU]D']LHZF]\Q\UR]PDZLD\DOHFLFKRQLHPyJZ\UR]XPLH
EOL HM]D O NDVL SRGFKRG]L0RJ\]DXZD \QDEUDSRGHMU]H
1DMHGQ\P]NUDPyZVSU]HGDZDQRFXNURZ ZDW ']LHZF]\Q\SRGHV]\0LVWOH
NXSLDGZDRPRWDQH QLH Q VRGNR FL SDW\F]NLMHGHQZU F]\DV]DURZRVHM7D
GHOLNDWQLHVNXEQ D%LD\NDF]HNSU]\NOHLVL MHMGRZDUJL0LVWOHVWDUWDJR
RVWUR Q\PSLHV]F]RWOLZ\PUXFKHP6]DURZRVDV]HURNRRWZRU]\DV]PDUDJGRZH
RF]\ZROQLXWNRREOL]DDXVWDX PLHFKQ DVL ILJODUQLHSU]HNU]\ZLDM F JRZ
6HUYDGLRSRF]XGUHV]F]VWUX N ]LPQDVS\ZDM F\]NDUNXSRPL G]\RSDWNL
3U]\SRPQLDVRELHSORWNLNU FHRREXEDQG\WNDFK
=DPLHU]DZ\FRIDVL FK\NLHPE\RMDVQH H QLF]HJRQLHSRGVXFKDDQLQLH
Z\V]SLHJXMH']LHZF]\Q\QLHUR]SUDZLD\RQLF]\PZD Q\PQDWRPLDVWQLH
RSRGDOWDPJG]LH]JURPDG]LDVL VWDUV]\]QDUR]EyMQLF]\FKV]DMHN*LVHOKHU
.D\OHLJKLSR]RVWDOLKDD OLZLHNyFLOLVL WDUJRZDOLZU]HV]F]HOLFRLUXV]
SRGVWDZLDOLNXENLSRGV]SXQWDQWDND2GQLFK6HUYDGLRPLDV]DQV GRZLHG]LHVL
ZL FHM.WyU\ ]H6]F]XUyZPyJXURQLVRZRDFKRE\SyVRZD]GUDG]DM FHJR
QDMEOL V]HSODQ\EDQG\LFKWUDV OXEFHO*G\E\XGDRPXVL SRGVXFKDLZSRU
GRVWDUF]\ZLDGRPR RQLHU]RPSUHIHNWDOXE \ZRLQWHUHVXM F\PVL 6]F]XUDPL
DJHQWRP]1LOIJDDUGXQDJURGDE\DMX SUDNW\F]QLHZNLHV]HQL*G\E\]D QDED]LH
MHJRLQIRUPDFMLSUHIHNW]GRD]DVWDZLXGDQ ]DVDG]N 6HUYDGLRPyJOLF]\QD
QDSUDZG ]QDF]Q\SU]\S\ZJRWyZNL.XSL EDELHNR XFKP\ ODJRU F]NRZR
']LHFLRPEXWNLQDUHV]FLHL]DEDZNLMDNLH $VRELH
']LHZF]\Q\VSDFHURZD\Z]GX VWUDJDQyZREOL]XM F LVNXEL F ]SDW\F]NyZ
FXNURZ ZDW 6HUYDGLRQDJOH]RULHQWRZDVL H V REVHUZRZDQH,ZVND]\ZDQH
SDOFDPL=QDW\FKNWyU]\ZVND]\ZDOL]RG]LHLLNRQLRNUDGyZ]V]DMNL.QW\
]ZDQHJR:\GU]\FKZRVWHP
=RG]LHMHZ\PLHQLOLNLONDZ\]\ZDM FRJR Q\FKXZDJUR]UHFKRWDOLVL 0LVWOH
]PUX \DRF]\SRR \DV]DURZRVHMU N QDUDPLHQLX
6\QRJDUOLF]NLSDUVNQ MHGHQ]H]RG]LHL:\GU]\FKDZRVWDGU\EODV]Z VDPL
Z\JO GDM F\PLMDNZLHFKFLHSDNX3DWU]DMWDL FLH]DUD]G]LyENyZVRELHGDG]
6HUYDGLRZLG]LDMDNV]DURZRVDGUJQ DZLG]LDMDN0LVWOH]DFLVNDSDOFHQDMHM
EDUNX=RG]LHMH]DUHFKRWDOLFKyUHP0LVWOHRGZUyFLDVL ZROQRNLONXQDW\FKPLDVW
SU]HVWDRVL PLD$OHWHQ]SDNXRZ\PLZ VDPLE\DOER]E\WSLMDQ\DOER
]XSHQLHSR]EDZLRQ\Z\REUD QL
0R H FKRSDNWyUHM ] ZDVWU]D"SRGV]HGEOL HMZ\NRQXM F REU]\GOLZHL
QLHGZX]QDF]QHJHVW\:LHU WDNLHMDNZ\LQRSU]HFK GR \]GURZRDZPLJVL
] SHUZHUV\LXOHF] +ROD'RFLHELHPyZL W\
1LH]G \MHMGRWNQ 6]DURZRVD]ZLQ DVL MDNDWDNXM FD PLMDPLHF]
E\VQ LXGHU]\]DQLPMHV]F]HXSXV]F]RQDFXNURZDZDWDXSDGDQD]LHPL
: VDF]]DWRF]\VL ]DJXOJRWDMDNLQGRUNUHZ]SU]HFL WHMV]\LVLNQ DGXJLP
VWUXPLHQLHP']LHZF]\QD]ZLQ DVL SRQRZQLHGRSDGDZGZyFKWDQHF]Q\FK
NURNDFKFL DMHV]F]HUD]IDODSRVRNLEU\]JQ DQDVWUDJDQ\WUXSUXQ SLDVHN
ZRNyQLHJRPRPHQWDOQLH]UXG]LD.WR ZU]DVQ 'UXJL]RG]LHMVFK\OLVL
Z\GRE\Qy ] FKROHZ\DOHZW\PVDP\PPRPHQFLHSDG]G]LHORQ\SU]H]
*LVHOKHUDRNQW\WWWWU]RQNLHPQDKDMNL
'R E G]LHMHGQHJRWUXSDZU]DVQ KHUV]W6]F]XUyZ7HQWXVDPVRELD
ZLQLHQQLHZLHG]LD]NLP]DG]LHUD&RIQLMVL )DOND
6]DURZRVDGRSLHURWHUD]RSX FLDPLHF]*LJHOKHULPLyWVDNLHZN L SRWU] VQ
QL
:HGOHSUDZQDV]HJREUDFWZDSDF ]DWHJRXELWHJR8F]FLZLHZHGOHZDJL
WDODU]DND G\IXQWSDUV]\ZHJR8ZRND,QDW\PNRQLHFZD QL'REU]HPyZL
NDPUDFL"+HM3LWLWRFRU]HNQLHV]"
,VNUD.D\OHLJK.HHIL$VVHVWDQ OL]DKHUV]WHP7ZDU]HPLHOLMDN]NDPLHQLD
GRQLHQDU NRMH FLDFKPLHF]\
8F]FLZLHRGH]ZDVL ] JUXS\EDQG\WyZ:\GU]\FKZRVWQLVNLNU]\ZRQRJL
P F]\]QDZVNyU]DQ\PNDEDFLH3UDZ\ *LVHOKHU.RQLHFZD QL
6HUYDGLRSU]HNQ OLQ XVLXM F ZWRSLVL Z RWDF]DM F\MX ]DM FLHWXP1DJOH
SRF]X H QLHPD]DJURV]RFKRW\NU FLVL NRR6]F]XUyZLNRRSRSLHODWRZRVHM
G]LHZF]\Q\NWyU QD]\ZDQR)DON 1DJOHX]QD H RELHFDQDSU]H]SUHIHNWD
QDJURGDZFDOHQLHMHVWWDNZ\VRNDMDNP\ OD
)DONDVSRNRMQLHVFKRZDDPLHF]GRSRFKZ\UR]HMU]DDVL 6HUYDGLRRVXSLD
ZLG] FMDNMHMGUREQDWZDU]]PLHQLDVL QDJOHLNXUF]\
0RMDZDWDM NQ D DR FLZLHG]LHZF]\QDSDWU] F QDZDODM F\VL QD
EUXGQ\PSLDVNXVPDNR\N0RMDZDWDPLXSDGD
0LVWOHREM DM
.XSL FLGUXJ
PDM F ]DPLDUXRGFKRG]L
3U]\VXFKLZDHPVL SU]HGFKZLO WZRMHMUR]PRZLH]-DVNUHPLXF]QLF]N
SRZLHG]LDQLHEH]GUZLQ\ZJRVLH7U]HEDSU]\]QDPDV]SUDZG]LZ\WDOHQWGR
SR]\VNLZDQLDVRELHOXG]L&KRFD\ ZLDW]GDMHVL QDFLHELHG\EDW\OHNFHVRELH
ZD \V]SUDJQ F\FKFLSRPyFWRZDU]\V]\LVSU]\PLHU]H FyZ
ZLDWVWDQ QDJRZLH:DPSLUE G]LHPQLHXF]\MDNPDPSRVW SRZD]
OXG PL&RW\ZLHV]ROXG]LDFK5HJLV"-HG\QDU]HF]NWyU ]QDV]WRVPDNLFKNUZL
&KROHUDMDVQD]DF] HP]WRE UR]PDZLD"
ZLDWVWDQ QDJRZLHSU]\]QDZDPSLUFDNLHPSRZD QLH=DF] H 0R H
ZL F ]HFKFHV]UyZQLH Z\VXFKDUDG\"
1LH1LH]HFKF -HVWPL]E GQD
3UDZGDE\E\P]DSRPQLD5DG\V FL]E GQHVSU]\PLHU]H F\V FL]E GQL
EH]WRZDU]\V]\SRGUy \ UyZQLH VL REHMG]LHV]&HOWZRMHMZ\SUDZ\WRZV]DNFHO
RVRELVW\LSU\ZDWQ\ZL FHMFKDUDNWHUFHOXZ\PDJDE\ ]UHDOL]RZDJRVDP
RVREL FLH5\]\NR]DJUR HQLHWUXGZDOND]H]Z WSLHQLHPPXV] REFL \W\ONRL
Z\ F]QLHFLHELH%RV ZV]DNHOHPHQWDPLSRNXW\RGNXSLHQLDZLQ\NWyUHFKFHV]
X]\VND7DNLSRZLHG]LDE\PFKU]HVWRJQLD3U]HMG]LHV]SU]H]RJLH NWyU\SDOL
DOHLRF]\V]F]D6DPVDPRWQLH%RJG\E\NWR FL Z W\PZVSDUSRPyJZ]L QD
VLHELHFKRE\F] VWN WHJRFKU]WXRJQLDWHJREyOXWHMSRNXW\]XER \E\FL W\P
VDP\P3R]EDZLQDOH QHMPX]DZVSyXG]LDF] FLHNVSLDFMLNWyUDZV]DNMHVW
Z\ F]QLHWZRM HNVSLDFM 7RZ\ F]QLHW\PDV]GXJGRVSDFHQLDQLHFKFHV]
VSDFDJR]DGX DM F VL MHGQRF]H QLHXLQQ\FKZLHU]\FLHOL&]\UR]XPXM
ORJLF]QLH"
$ G]LZQLH H QDWU]H ZR7ZRMDREHFQR GUD QLPQLHZDPSLU]H=RVWDZ
PQLHVDPQDVDP]PRM HNVSLDFM SURV] ,]PRLPGXJLHP
%H]]ZRF]QLH5HJLVZVWD3RVLHG SRP\ O$UDG\MHGQDNFLXG]LHO
3RWU]HEDHNVSLDFMLRF]\V]F]DM FHJRFKU]WXRJQLDSRF]XFLHZLQ\WRQLHV U]HF]\
GRNWyU\FKUR FLVRELHPR HV]Z\ F]QHSUDZR \FLHW\PUy QLVL RG
EDQNRZR FL H ]QDGXJLNWyUHVSDFDVL ]DGX HQLHPXLQQ\FK
2GHMG SURV]
%H]]ZRF]QLH
:DPSLURGV]HGGR F]\GR-DVNUDL0LOY\3RGF]DV]PLDQ\RSDWUXQNXFDD
WUyMNDGHEDWRZDDFRE\WX]MH 0LOYDZ\WU] VQ D]ZLHUV]\GUREQLF L SU]\MU]DD
VL QDGZ\UD]NU\W\F]QLH
1LHPDFRPHG\WRZDSRZLHG]LDD7U]DQDG]LDWHPDHNDUDOXFK\QDZLWNL
L XSLHFMHQDG DUHP
1LHSRNU FL ZLH R REDQGD RZDQ JRZ -DVNLHU7RQLHMHVWGREU\SRP\V
5\EHNMHVW]DPDRQLHQDMHP\VL QLPL3URSRQXM E\XJRWRZD]QLFK]XS
=XSD]U\E"
-DVQH0DP\NXS WHJRGURELD]JXPDP\VyO-DVNLHULOXVWURZDZ\OLF]DQLH
RGJLQDQLHPNROHMQ\FKSDOFyZ=GRE\OL P\FHEXO PDUFKHZSLHWUXV]N VHOHU]
QDFL ,NRFLR3R]VXPRZDQLXRWU]\PXMHP\]XS
2FKX PLHFKQ VL 5HJLVVL JDM F GRWRUE\=W\PSUREOHPXQLHE G]LH
%D]\OLDSLPHQWSLHSU]OL ODXURZ\V]DZLD
'R GR SRZVWU]\PDJR-DVNLHU:\VWDUF]\PDQGUDJRU\Z]XSLHQDP
QLHSRWU]HED'REUDGRURERW\2F]\ U\ENL0LOYD
6DPMHF]\ 3DWU]DMWDLFK0\ O H MDNPDM QLHZLDVW Z NRPSDQLLWRLP
E G]LHSU]\NXFKQLKDURZD3U]\QLRV ZRG\LRJLH UR]QLHF $]W\PLSLVNRU]DPL
VDPLVL SDSU]FLH
7RQLHV SLVNRU]HSRZLHG]LD5HJLV7RV NOHQLHSRWNLMD]JDU]HL
SRGOHV]F]\NL
+DQLHZ\WU]\PD-DVNLHU=QDV]VL QDU\EDFKMDNZLG]
-H OL WDNLXF]RQ\0LOYDMHV]F]HUD]GPXFKQ DZRJLH SRF]\PZVWDDWR
XF]HQLHZ\SDWURV]WHU\EL WD-DSRZRG SyMG
'DV]UDG SU]\QLH SHQ\NRFLR"*HUDOWSRPy MHM
'DPUDG SDUVNQ D0LOYD$MHJRSRPRF\QLHWU]DPL2QPDZDVQH
RVRELVWHVSUDZ\QLHO]DPXSU]HV]NDG]D
*HUDOWRGZUyFLJRZ XGDM F H QLHV\V]\-DVNLHULZDPSLUVSUDZQLHF]\ FLOL
U\ELGURELD]J
&KXGDE G]LHWD]XSDVWZLHUG]L-DVNLHUZLHV]DM F NRFLRQDGRJQLHP
=GDDE\VL FKROHUDMDND ZL NV]DU\END
7DPR H E\"]ZLNOLQ\QDJOHZ\RQLVL &DKLUQLRV F ]DNDUN
WU]\IXQWRZHJRV]F]XSDNDZFL MHV]F]HSU FHJRRJRQLSRUXV]DM FHJRVNU]HODPL
2KR$OH NUDVDZLFH6N G JRZ\WU]DVQ H 1LOIJDDUGF]\NX"
1LHMHVWHP1LOIJDDUGF]\NLHP3RFKRG] ] 9LFRYDURDQD]\ZDPVL &DKLU
'REU]HGREU]HMX V\V]HOL P\6N G PDV]V]F]XN S\WDHP"
=PDMVWURZDHP HUOLF -DNRSU]\Q W\X \HP DE\=DU]XFLHPZMDP SRG
EU]HJLHP6]F]XSDNZ]L ]PLHMVFD
6DPLVSHFMDOL FLSRNU FLREDQGD RZDQ JRZ -DVNLHU6]NRGD H QLH
]DSURSRQRZDHPEHIV]W\NyZSHZQLH]DUD]SU]\QLH OLE\NURZ 1RDOHELHU]P\
VL ]DWRFRPDP\5HJLVZV]\VWNLHPDHU\ENLZDOZNRFLR]JRZDPLL
RJRQDPL6]F]XN ]D WU]HEDDGQLHVSUDZL8PLHV]1LOI&DKLU"
8PLHP
'RG]LHD]DWHP*HUDOWGRMDVQHMFKROHU\GXJRPDV]]DPLDUWDPVLHG]LH]
REUD RQ PLQ " :DU]\ZDRELHU]
:LHG PLQZVWDSRVXV]QLHGRVLDGVL DOHGHPRQVWUDF\MQLHGDOHNRRG&DKLUD
=DQLPMHV]F]H]G \SRVNDU \VL H QLHPDQR D1LOIJDDUGF]\NF]\WH
9LFRYDUF]\NSRGDPXVZyMGRE\ZDM F GUXJL]FKROHZ\3U]\M Z\EXUF]DZV]\
SRG]L NRZDQLH
:VSyOQDSUDFDV]DVNDGQLH3HHQU\ELHMGUREQLF\LZDU]\ZNRFLRZNUyWFH
]DEXOJRWDL]DSLHQLVL :DPSLU]U F]QLH]HEUDSLDQ Z\VWUXJDQ SU]H]0LOY
\ N *G\&DKLUVSUDZLLSRG]LHOLV]F]XSDND-DVNLHUZU]XFLGRNRWDRJRQ
SHWZ\NU JRVXSL] EDW\HEGUDSLH QLND]DPLHV]D
0QLDPPQLDPDOH SDFKQLH*G\VL WRZV]\VWNRZ\JRWXMHRGFHG]LP\
PLHFL
3U]H]RQXF FK\EDZ\NU]\ZLDVL 0LOYDVWUXJDM F NROHMQ \ N -DN H
FHG]LJG\SU]HWDNDQLHPDP\"
$OH GURJD0LOYRX PLHFKQ VL 5HJLV7DNQLHPR QD7RF]HJRQLH
PDP\]DWZR FL ]DVW SLP\W\PFRPDP\7RZ\ F]QLHNZHVWLDLQLFMDW\Z\L
P\ OHQLDSR]\W\ZQHJR
,G GRELHVD]WZ\PXF]RQ\PJDGDQLHPZDPSLU]H
3U]HFHG]LP\SU]H]PRM NROF]XJ SRZLHG]LD&DKLU&RWDPSRWHPVL M
Z\SXF]H
3U]HGWHPWH VL M Z\SXF] R ZLDGF]\D0LOYD,QDF]HMMDWHM]XS\MH QLH
E G
&HG]HQLHSRV]RVSUDZQLH
7HUD]ZU]XFDMGRZ\ZDUXV]F]XN &DKLU]DU] G]L-DVNLHU$OH ]DSDFK
PQLDPPQLDP1LHSRGU]XFDMFLHMX GUHZQDQLHFKW\ONRPUXJD*HUDOWGRN G VL
SFKDV]]W \ N 7HUD]VL MX QLHPLHV]D
1LHZU]HV]F]1LHZLHG]LDHP
1LHZLHG]DX PLHFKQ VL 5HJLVQLHVWDQRZLXVSUDZLHGOLZLHQLDGODQLH
SU]HP\ ODQ\FKG]LDD *G\VL QLHZLHJG\PDVL Z WSOLZR FLGREU]HMHVW
]DVL JQ SRUDG\
=DPNQLMVL ZDPSLU]H*HUDOWZVWDLRGZUyFLVL SOHFDPL-DVNLHUSDUVNQ
2EUD]LVL SDWU]FLHJR
2QMX WDNLMHVWVWZLHUG]LD0LOYDZ\G\PDM F ZDUJL*DGDF]-H OLQLHZLH
FRF]\QLJDGDMHQRLREUD D VL -HV]F]H FLHWHJRQLHZ\PLDUNRZDOL"
'DZQRU]HNFLFKR&DKLU
'RGDSLHSU]X-DVNLHUREOL]D\ N ]DPODVND'RGDMHV]F]HVROL$FK
WHUD]MHVWZVDPUD]=HVWDZP\NRFLR]RJQLD3VLDNUHZDOHJRU F\1LHPDP
U NDZLF
-DPDPU]HN&DKLU
$MD5HJLVFKZ\FLNRFLR]GUXJLHMVWURQ\QLHSRWU]HEXM
'REUDSRHWDZ\WDU\ N R VSRGQLH1RNRPSDQLDGRVLDGDVL
6PDF]QHJR*HUDOWF]HNDV]QDVSHFMDOQH]DSURV]HQLH"1DKHUROGDLIDQIDU\"
:V]\VF\FLDVQRREVLHGOLXVWDZLRQ\QDSLDVNXNRFLRHNLSU]H]GXJLF]DVV\FKD
E\RMHG\QLHG\VW\QJRZDQHVLRUEDQLHSU]HU\ZDQHGPXFKDQLHPZ\ NL3R
]MHG]HQLXSRRZ\Z\ZDUXUR]SRF] RVL RVWUR QHRZLHQLHNDZDNyZV]F]XSDND
ZUHV]FLH\ NLGUDSQ \SRGQLHNRFLRND
$OHVL QD DUDPVW NQ D0LOYD7RQLHJXSLE\SRP\V]W SROHZN
-DVNLHU
:U]HF]\VDPHMSU]\]QD5HJLV&RSRZLHV]*HUDOW"
3RZLHPG]L NXM :LHG PLQZVWD]WUXGHPSRPDVRZDNRODQRNWyUH]QRZX
]DF] N VDEyO:\VWDUF]\"&]\SRWU]HEQHV IDQIDU\"
=QLPWDN]DZV]HPDFKQ U N SRHWD1LHSU]HMPXMFLHVL QLP,WDNPDFLH
V]F] FLHPQLHSU]\V]RE\]QLPZyZF]DVJG\NyFLVL ] W MHJR<HQQHIHU
EODG SL NQR FL R KHEDQRZ\FKZRVDFK
'\VNUHWQLHMXSRPQLDJRZDPSLU,QLH]DSRPLQDMRQPDSUREOHP\
3UREOHP\&DKLUVWXPLEHNQL FLHQDOH \ UR]ZL ]\ZD
%DU]HN-DVNLHU$OHMDN"
0LOYDSDUVNQ DZ\JRGQLHMXNDGDM F VL QDJRU F\PSLDVNX
:DPSLUMHVWXF]RQ\$QLFK\ELZLH
5]HF]SROHJDQLHQDZLHG]\OHF]QDXPLHM WQ\P]ZD HQLXNRQLXQNWXUU]HN
VSRNRMQLH5HJLV$JG\VL NRQLXQNWXU\]ZD \GRFKRG]LVL GRZQLRVNX H
PDP\GRF]\QLHQLD]SUREOHPHPQLHUR]ZL ]\ZDOQ\P&DHWRSU]HGVL Z]L FLHMHVW
SR]EDZLRQHV]DQVQDVXNFHV3UDZGRSRGRELH VWZRRGQDOH]LHQLD&LULUyZQDVL
]HUX
$OH WDNQLHPR QD]DNSLD0LOYD7U]DGXPDSR]\W\ZQLHLMHQF\WMDW\ZQLH
7RWDNMDNR]W\PVLWHP-H OLQLHPDP\]DVW SP\F]\PLQQ\P7DNVRELHP\ O
'RQLHGDZQDFL JQ ZDPSLUV G]LOL P\ H &LULMHVWZ1LOIJDDUG]LH
'RWDUFLHWDPLZ\]ZROHQLHF]\WH Z\NUDG]HQLHMHMZ\GDZDRVL
SU]HGVL Z]L FLHPSRQDGVL\7HUD]SRUHZHODFMDFK&DKLUDZRJyOHQLHZLHP\
JG]LH&LULMHVW7UXGQRPyZLRLQLFMDW\ZLHJG\QLHPDVL SRM FLDZNWyU VWURQ
M VNLHURZD
&y WHG\PDP\F]\QL" DFKQ DVL 0LOYD:LHG PLQXSLHUDVL E\QD
SRXGQLHUXV]\
'ODQLHJRX PLHFKQ VL 5HJLVVWURQ\ ZLDWDQLHPDM VSHFMDOQHJR
]QDF]HQLD:V]\VWNRPXMHGQRZNWyU UXV]\E\OHE\QLHVLHG]LHEH]F]\QQLH
, FLHZLHG PLQVNLHSULQFLSLXP ZLDWSHHQMHVW=DZ\VWDUF]\WHG\L JG]LHRF]\
SRQLRV DQDSRW\NDQHSRGURG]H=RXQLFHVWZLDW\PVSRVREHPSU]\VX \VL
VSUDZLH'REUD5HV]WDSU]\MG]LHVDPD,QDF]HMPyZL FUXFKMHVWZV]\VWNLPFHO
QLF]\P
2VLHOVWZRVNRPHQWRZDD0LOYD: G\MHJRFHOWR&LUL-DN H WRRQD
QLF]\P"
DUWRZDHPVRELHSU]\]QDZDPSLU\SL F QDZFL RGZUyFRQHJRSOHFDPL
*HUDOWD,WRQLH]E\WWDNWRZQLH3U]HSUDV]DP0DV]UDFM GURJD0LOYR1DV]FHO
WR&LUL$SRQLHZD QLHZLHP\JG]LHRQDMHVWVHQVRZQLHMHVWGRZLHG]LHVL WHJRL
RGSRZLHGQLRXNLHUXQNRZDG]LDDQLD6SUDZD']LHFND1LHVSRG]LDQNLMDN
]DXZD DPD W WQLRGPDJLLSU]H]QDF]HQLDLLQQ\FKQDGSU]\URG]RQ\FK
HOHPHQWyZ$MD]QDPNRJR NWRZWDNLFKVSUDZDFK ZLHWQLHVL RULHQWXMHL
]DSHZQHQDPSRPR H
+DXFLHV]\VL -DVNLHU.WRWRWDNL"*G]LH"'DOHNR"
%OL HMQL VWROLFD1LOIJDDUGX'RNDGQLHU]HF]ELRU FFDNLHPEOLVNR:
$QJUHQLH1DW\PEU]HJX-DUXJL0yZL R GUXLG]NLPNU JXPDM F\PVZ VLHG]LE
Z ERUDFKQD&DHG'KX
5XV]DP\EH]]ZRNL
&]\QLNW]ZDV]GHQHUZRZDVL ZUHV]FLH*HUDOWQLHXZD D ]DVWRVRZQH
]DS\WDPQLHR]GDQLH"
&LHELH"-DVNLHURGZUyFLVL 7\ZV]DNSRM FLDQLHPDV]FRF]\QL1DZHW
]XS NWyU FKHSWDH ]DZG]L F]DV]QDP*G\E\QLHP\E\E\ JRGQ\,P\WH
JG\E\ P\F]HNDOLQDWZRM DNW\ZQR 7HQNRFLRHN]XS\WRG]LHRNRRSHUDFML
(IHNWZVSyOQHJRG]LDDQLDJUXS\GUX \Q\]MHGQRF]RQHMSU]H]ZVSyOQ\FHO
3RMPXMHV]WRSU]\MDFLHOX"
-DN H MHPXWRSRM "Z\NU]\ZLDVL 0LOYD2QFL JLHPW\ONRMDLMDVDP
VDPRWQLH:LONVDPRWQLN:LGD H DGHQRZFD]QLHJR H ]ODVHPQLHRE\W\1LH
SROXM ZLOF\VDPRWQLH1LJG\:LONVDPRWQLNKDH WRJXSLHPLHV]F]XFKyZ
EDMDQLH$OHRQWHJRQLHSRMPXMH
$OH SRMPXMHSRMPXMHX PLHFKQ VL 5HJLVVZRLP]Z\F]DMHP]
]DFL QL W\PLZDUJDPL
2QW\ONRWDNJXSLRZ\JO GDSRWZLHUG]L-DVNLHU$OHFD\F]DVOLF] QDWR H
5R]G]LD
.UyORZDRGU]HND1LHPQLHRDVN SUR DOHW\FKNWyU\FKF]DUDPLWZ\PL
XNU]\ZG]LD 0LDD RGZDJ ]HF]\Q\SRSHQLDPLHM H RGZDJ L WHUD]JG\
SRJR L VSUDZLHGOLZR EOLVNR1LHZPRMHMPRF\JU]HFK\FLZ\EDF]D1DWHQF]DV
]DSDUVNDDZLHG PDQLE\NRW]DE\V\MHM]HRF]\0RMD]JXEDEOLVNR
]DNU]\NQ DDOHLWZRMDQLHGDOHNRNUyORZR:VSRPQLV]MHV]F]HZJRG]LQLH
VWUDV]QHM PLHUFL/DU 'RUUHQLMHMNO WZ $LWRZLHG] H SU]HNOH VWZRPRMH
GR FLJQLHLSRWRPNyZWZRLFKGRG]LHVL WHJRSRNROHQLD=PLDUNRZDZV]\MHGQDN
]HZSLHUVLNUyORZHMQLHXO NHELMHVHUFH]DHOILDF]DURZQLFDSU]HVWDDO \L
JUR]LNO WZ VWUDV]\]DF] DMDNVXNDVNDPOHRSRPRFL]PLRZDQLH
%D R /DU]H'RUUHQZHUVMDOXG]ND
DOHEDJDQLDQLH]PL NF]\\NDPLHQQ\FKVHUF'K
RLQHEH]OLWRVQ\FKRNUXWQ\FK
OXG]L$JG\/DUDSURV] F ROLWR MX QLHGODQLHMDOHGODMHMG]LHFNDXF]HSLDVL
GU]ZLNDUHW\QDNUyOHZVNLUR]ND]]ELUNDWXGHU]\NRUGHPLRGU EDMHMSDOFH$JG\
Z QRF\PUy]OXW\ FLVQ /DUDZ\GDDRVWDWQLHWFKQLHQLHQDZ]JyU]XZ UyGODVyZ
URG] F FyUHF]N NWyU FKURQLDUHV]WN WO FHJRVL Z QLHMMHV]F]HFLHSD,FKR
ZRNyE\DQRF]LPDL QLH \FDQDZ]JyU]XVWDDVL QDJOHZLRVQDL]DNZLW\
NZLDW\IHDLQQHZHGG'RG]L WDNLHNZLDW\NZLWQ W\ONRZGZyFKPLHMVFDFKZ'RO
%ODWKDQQDLQDZ]JyU]XQDNWyU\PVNRQDD/DUD'RUUHQDHS6KLDGKDO
%D R /DU]H'RUUHQZHUVMDHOILD
5R]G]LDV]yVW\
7ZRMHVQ\SRZLHG]LDDZUHV]FLH7RSU]H]WHWZRMHVQ\WDN"3UDZLHFRQRF
]U\ZDV]VL ] NU]\NLHP7RFRQLHJG\ SU]HV]D ZUDFDZVQDFK=QDPWR
&LULQLHRGSRZLHG]LDD
1LJG\PLRVRELHQLHPyZLD 0LVWOH]QRZXSU]HUZDDFLV] 2W\PFR
SU]HV]D $QLRW\PVN G MHVWH $QLF]\PDV]EOLVNLFK
&LULJZDWRZQLHSRUXV]\DU N NRRV]\LDOHW\PUD]HPWRE\DW\ONRELHGURQND
0LDDPEOLVNLFKSRZLHG]LDDJXFKRQLHSDWU] F QDWRZDU]\V]N 7R]QDF]\
P\ ODDP]HPLDDP7DNLFKNWyU]\RGQDOH OLE\PQLHQDZHWWXQDNR FX
ZLDWDJG\E\W\ONRFKFLHOL/XEJG\E\ \OL2FKRFRFLFKRG]L0LVWOH"0DPFL
R VRELHRSRZLDGD"
1LHPXVLV]
7RGREU]H%RWRSHZQLHW\ONR]DEDZD-DNZV]\VWNRPL G]\QDPL
1LHUR]XPLHP0LVWOHRGZUyFLDJRZ GODF]HJRQLHRGHMG]LHV]MH OLFLWDN
]HPQ OH
1LHFKF E\VDPD
7\ONRW\OH"
7RGX R
0LVWOH]DJU\]DZDUJL1LPMHGQDN]G \DFRNROZLHNSRZLHG]LHXV\V]D\
JZL]G=HUZD\VL RELHRWU]HSD\]LJOLZLDGRSDG\NRQL
=DF]\QDVL ]DEDZDU]HND0LVWOHZVNDNXM F QDVLRGRLGRE\ZDM F PLHF]D
MDN RGSHZQHJRF]DVXOXELV]SRQDGZV]\VWNLHLQQH)DOND1LHP\ O H QLH
]DXZD \DP
&LUL]H]R FL XGHU]\DNRQLDSL WDPL3RJQD\]ERF]HPZ ZR]XQDHEQD
V]\M V\V] F MX G]LNLHKDDNRZDQLHSR]RVWD\FK6]F]XUyZZ\SDGDM F\FK]
]DJDMQLNDSRGUXJLHMVWURQLHJR FL FD.OHV]F]H]DVDG]NL]DP\ND\VL
3U\ZDWQDDXGLHQFMDE\DVNR F]RQD9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[LFHKQLEX(LGGRQV]HI
Z\ZLDGXZRMVNRZHJRFHVDU]D(PK\UDYDU(PUHLVDRSX FLELEOLRWHN NDQLDM F
VL NUyORZHM'ROLQ\.ZLDWyZZVSRVyEQDZHWXSU]HMPLHMV]\QL WHJRZ\PDJD
SURWRNyGZRUVNL8NRQE\MHGQRF]H QLHEDUG]RRVWUR Q\DUXFK\9DWWLHUD
Z\SUDFRZDQHLSRZ FL JOLZHV]SLHJFHVDUVNLQLHVSXV]F]DZ]URNX]GZyFK
RFHORWyZZ\FL JQL W\FKXVWySZDGF]\QLHOIyZ=RWRRNLHNRW\Z\JO GD\QD
UR]OHQLZLRQHLVHQQHDOH9DWWLHUZLHG]LD H WRQLHPDVNRWNLOHF]F]XMQLVWUD QLF\
JRWRZLZPJQLHQLXRND]DPLHQLZNUZDZ PLD]J ND GHJRNWRXVLRZDE\
]EOL \VL GRNUyORZHMQDRGOHJR PQLHMV] RGRNUH ORQHMSURWRNRHP
)UDQFHVFD(PGDEDLUQD]\ZDQD(QLGDQ*OHDQQD6WRNURWND]'ROLQRGF]HNDD
D ]D9DWWLHUHP]DPNQ VL GU]ZLSRJDVNDDRFHORW\
-X ,GDSRZLHG]LDD
,GD(PHDQDHS6L\QH\HOILDF]DURG]LHMNDZROQD$HQ6HLGKH]*yU6LQ\FK
SRGF]DVDXGLHQFMLVNU\WDSRGF]DUHPQLHZLG]LDOQR FL]PDWHULDOL]RZDDVL Z N FLH
ELEOLRWHNLSRSUDZLDVXNQL L F\QREURZRUXGHZRV\2FHORW\]DUHDJRZD\MHG\QLH
QLHFRV]HUV]\PRWZDUFLHPRF]X-DNZV]\VWNLHNRW\ZLG]LD\QLHZLG]LDOQHQLH
PR QDE\RLFKRV]XNDWDNSURVW\P]DNO FLHP
'UD QLPQLHMX ]DF]\QDWHQIHVWLZDOV]SLHJyZSRZLHG]LDD]SU]HN VHP
)UDQFHVFDSU]\ELHUDM F Z\JRGQLHMV] SR]\FM QDKHEDQRZ\PNU]H OH+HQVHOW]
.DHGZHQQLHGDZQRSU]\VDPLNRQVXOD'LMNVWUDVNLHURZDGR'RO%ODWKDUPD
PLVM KDQGORZ $WHUD]VDPDUF\V]SLFHO9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[$FKDZF]H QLHM
NU FLVL WX6WHIDQ6NHOOHQ:LHONL&HVDUVNL1LNW$OHQLHXG]LHOLDPPX
SRVXFKDQLD-DMHVWHPNUyORZ D6NHOOHQMHVWQLNLP&KR]XU] GXDOHQLNLP
6WHIDQ6NHOOHQSRZLHG]LDDZROQR,G (PHDQE\UyZQLH X QDVJG]LHPLD
ZL FHMV]F] FLD5R]PDZLD])LODYDQGUHOHPL9DQDGDLQHP
,SRGREQLHMDN9DWWLHUPQLHZ\S\W\ZDLFKR9LOJHIRUW]D<HQQHIHU5LHQFH
DL
&DKLUD0DZU'\IIU\QDDHS&DHOODFKD"
0L G]\LQQ\PL=G]LZLV]VL DOHEDUG]LHMLQWHUHVRZDDJRRU\JLQDOQDZHUVMD
SURURFWZD,WKOLQQH$HJOLDHS$H\HQLHQ]ZDV]F]DIUDJPHQW\PyZL FHR$HQ+HQ
,FKDHU6WDUV]HM.UZL,QWHUHVRZDDJRUyZQLH 7RU/DUD:LH D 0HZ\L
OHJHQGDUQ\SRUWDOQLHJG\ F] F\:LH 0HZ\]7RU=LUHDHO:LH -DVNyNL
-DN H WRW\SRZHGODOXG]L(QLG/LF]\QDWR H RGUD]XQDVNLQLHQLH
Z\ ZLHWOLP\LP]DJDGNLLWDMHPQLFHNWyUHVDPLVWDUDP\VL UR]ZLNDRGVHWHNODW
)UDQFHVFDXQLRVDU N L SU]\MU]DDVL SLHU FLHQLRP
&LHNDZHSRZLHG]LDDF]\)LOLSSDZLHRG]LZQ\FK]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDFK
6NHOOHQDL9DWWLHUD",(PK\UDYDU(PUHLVDNWyUHPXRQLREDMVX "
5\]\NRZQLHE\RE\]DNDGD H QLHZLH,GD(PHDQVSRMU]DDE\VWURQD
NUyORZ L]DWDLQDQDUDG]LHZ0RQWHFDOYRWRFRZLHP\P\WDNSU]HG)LOLSS
MDNLSU]HGFD OR 1LH]E\WDGQH ZLDWRU]XFLRE\WRQDQDV$FKFHP\
ZV]DN HE\WDOR D ]DLVWQLDD&KFHP\E\QDPHOILPPDJLF]NRPXIDQRQLH
SRV G]DQRRSRGZyMQ JU
5]HF]ZW\P H P\SURZDG]LP\SRGZyMQ JU ,GD,WURV]N LJUDP\]
RJQLHP=%LD\P3RPLHQLHP1LOIJDDUGX
2JLH SDOL,GD(PHDQSRGQLRVDQDNUyORZ SU]HGX RQHRVWU\PPDNLMD HP
RF]\DOHLRF]\V]F]D7U]HEDSU]H]H SU]HM 7U]HEDSRGM U\]\NR(QLG7DOR D
SRZLQQD]DLVWQLHSRZLQQD]DF] G]LDD:SHQ\PVNDG]LH'ZDQD FLH
F]DURG]LHMHNZ UyGQLFK]D WDMHGQDRNWyUHMPyZLSURURFWZR1DZHWMH OLWRJUD
SRVWDZP\QD]DXIDQLH
$MH OLWRSURZRNDFMD"
7\OHSLHM]QDV]]DDQJD RZDQHZVSUDZ RVRE\
(QLGDQ*OHDQQD]DVWDQRZLDVL
6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOHSRZLHG]LDDZUHV]FLHWRVNU\WDVDPRWQLFDQLHPD
DGQ\FKSRZL ]D 7ULVV0HULJROGL.HLUD0HW]PLD\DOHWHUD]RELHV
HPLJUDQWNDPLNUyO)ROWHVWZ\S G]L]7HPHULLZV]\VWNLFKF]DURG]LHMyZ
0DUJDULW /DX[$QWLOOHLQWHUHVXMHW\ONRMHMV]NRDQLFSR]DW\P2F]\ZL FLHZ
WHMFKZLOLWU]\RVWDWQLHV SRGVLOQ\PZS\ZHP)LOLSS\D)LOLSSDMHVW]DJDGN
6DEULQD*OHYLVVLJQLH]UH]\JQXMH]ZS\ZyZSROLW\F]Q\FKNWyUHPDZ.DHGZHQ
DOHQLH]GUDG]LOR \=E\WSRFL JDM ZDG]DNWyU OR D GDMH
$RZD$VVLUHYDU$QDKLG",WDGUXJD1LOIJDDUGNDNWyU SR]QDP\Z
0RQWHFDOYR"
0DRRQLFKZLHPX PLHFKQ DVL OHNNR)UDQFHVFD$OHJG\W\ONRMH
]REDF] E G ZLHG]LDDZL FHM*G\W\ONR]REDF] ZFRLMDNV XEUDQH
,GD(PHDQ]PUX \DZ\PDORZDQHSRZLHNLDOHSRZVWU]\PDDVL ] ]DGDQLHP
S\WDQLD
=RVWDMHQHIU\WRZDVWDWXHWNDSRZLHG]LDDSRFKZLOL:FL QLHSHZQDL
HQLJPDW\F]QDILJXU\QND]QHIU\WXZ]PLDQHNRNWyUHMWH PR QDGRV]XNDVL Z
,WKOLQQHVSDWK&K\EDMX F]DVE\GDVL MHMZ\SRZLHG]LH,R]QDMPLFRM F]HND
3RPyFFLZGHNRPSUHVML"
1LH]UREL WRVDPD:LHV]MDNUHDJXMHVL QDUR]SDNRZDQLH,PPQLHME G]LH
ZLDGNyZW\PPQLHMGRWNOLZ\E G]LHWRFLRVGODMHMGXP\
)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLUMHV]F]HUD]VSUDZG]LDF]\FD\G]LHG]LQLHFV]F]HOQLH
RGL]RORZDQ\MHVWRGUHV]W\SDDFXSROHPRFKURQQ\PSU]HVDQLDM F\PZLGRNL
WXPL F\PG ZL NL=DSDOLDWU]\F]DUQH ZLHFHRVDG]RQHZOLFKWDU]DFK
]DRSDWU]RQ\FKZHZNO VHOXVWU]DQHUHIOHNWRU\/LFKWDU]HVWD\ZPLHMVFDFK
Z\]QDF]RQ\FKNROLVW PR]DLN SDZLPHQWXSU]HGVWDZLDM F RVLHP]QDNyZ
9LFFDHLQHR
=RGLDNXQDV\PERODFKR]QDF]DM F\FK%HOOHWH\Q/DPPWIL<XOH:HZQ WU]
]RGLDNDOQHJRNRDPR]DLNDWZRU]\DGUXJLHPQLHMV]HXVLDQHPDJLF]Q\PL
V\PERODPLLRWDF]DM FHSHQWDJUDP1DWU]HFKV\PERODFKPQLHMV]HJRNRD
)UDQFHVFDXVWDZLDQLHZLHONLH HOD]QHWUyMQRJLQDQLFK]D RVWUR QLHL
SLHF]RRZLFLH]DPRQWRZDDWU]\NU\V]WD\6]OLIVSRGyZNU\V]WDyZRGSRZLDGD
IRUPLH]DNR F]H WUyMQRJyZSU]H]FRXR HQLHVL U]HF]\PXVLDRE\SUHF\]\MQH
DOH)UDQFHVFDVSUDZG]LDZV]\VWNRNLONDNURWQLH:RODDQLHU\]\NRZDE GX
1LHRSRGDOV]XPLDDIRQWDQQDZRGDWU\VNDD]PDUPXURZHJRG]EDQD
WU]\PDQHJRSU]H]PDUPXURZ QDMDG F]WHUHPDVWUXPLHQLDPLVSDGDDGRVDG]DZNL
ZSUDZLDM F ZUXFKOL FLHQHQXIDUyZPL G]\NWyU\PL PLJD\]RWHU\ENL
)UDQFHVFDRWZRU]\DV]NDWXN Z\M D]QLHMPDOXWN Z\NRQDQ ] QHIU\WX
P\GODQ Z GRW\NXILJXU\QN XVWDZLDM GRNDGQLHSR URGNXSHQWDJUDPX&RIQ D
VL MHV]F]HUD]]DMU]DDGROH FHJRQDVWROLNXJULPRLUH
DZ]L DJ ERNLZGHFK
XQLRVDU FHLZ\VNDQGRZDOD]DNO FLH
ZLHFHPRPHQWDOQLH]DSRQ \MD QLHMIDVHW\NU\V]WDyZUR]E\V\LWU\VQ \
VPXJDPL ZLDWD6PXJL]HVWU]HOL\VL QDILJXU\QFHNWyUDQDW\FKPLDVW]PLHQLD
NRORU]]LHORQHMVWDDVL ]RWDDSRFKZLOLWUDQVSDUHQWQD3RZLHWU]H]DGUJDRRG
PDJLF]QHMHQHUJLLELM FHMRRFKURQQHHNUDQ\-HGQD]H ZLHFSU\VQ DLVNUDPLSR
SRVDG]FH]DWD F]\\FLHQLHPR]DLND]DF] D \]PLHQLDNV]WDW\)UDQFHVFDQLH
RSXV]F]DDU NQLHSU]HU\ZDDLQNDQWDFML
)LJXUNDURVDE\VNDZLF]QLHSXOVXM F LW WQL F]PLHQLDDVWUXNWXU L NV]WDW
QLF]\PSH]DM F\SRSRVDG]FHRERNG\PX ZLDWRELM FH]NU\V]WDyZ
SU]HV]\ZDRG\PZVPXJDFKEODVNXSRMDZL\VL UXFKLWZDUGQLHM FDPDWHULD
-HV]F]HPRPHQWDZFHQWUXPPDJLF]Q\FKNySRND]DDVL QDJOHSRVWDOXG]ND
3RVWDF]DUQRZRVHMNRELHW\EH]ZDGQLHOH FHMQDSRVDG]FH
ZLHFH]DNZLW\ZVW NDPLG\PXNU\V]WD\]JDV\)UDQFHVFDRSX FLDU FH
UR]SU \DSDOFHLRWDUDSRW]F]RD
&]DUQRZRVDNRELHWDQDSRVDG]FH]ZLQ DVL Z N EHNL]DF] DNU]\F]H
:'RO%ODWKDQQD
<HQQHIHUZ\WDUDQRV
'UDNDQD7KDQHGGMHV]F]HWUZD"
1LH6NR F]\DVL 3yWRUDPLHVL FDWHPX
0XVLDDPFL EDUG]RVNU]\ZG]LSRZLHG]LDDSRFKZLOL<HQQHIHU0XVLDDP
]GURZR]DOH FL]DVNyU (QLG$OHPR HV]X]QDQDV]HUDFKXQNL]DZ\UyZQDQH
=HP FLD VL JRGQLHFKRPR H WURFK ]E\WVDG\VW\F]QLH1LHPRJD RJUDQLF]\
VL GRSRGHU QL FLDPLJDUGD"
1LHPyZJXSVWZHOINDVNU]\ZLDXVWD6SDNRZDDPFL L Z\QLRVDP]
*DUVWDQJXE\RFDOLFL \FLH:UyFLP\GRWHJRDOHSy QLHMQLHFR3URV] RWR
U F]QLN2WRSU]H FLHUDGR1RZ VXNQL GRVWDQLHV]SRN SLHOL:VWRVRZQ\P
PLHMVFXZZDQQLH]FLHS ZRG -X Z\VWDUF]DM FR]DV]NRG]LD ]RW\PU\ENRP
,GD(PHDQL)UDQFHVFDSL\ZLQR<HQQHIHUSLDJOXNR] L VRN]PDUFKZL:
RJURPQ\FKLOR FLDFK
3RGVXPXMP\SRZLHG]LDDZ\VXFKDZV]\UHODFML)UDQFHVNL1LOIJDDUGSRGEL
/\UL GRVSyNL].DHGZHQUR]HEUD$HGLUQVSDOL9HQJHUEHUJ]KRGRZD9HUGHQ
ZD QLHSRGELMD%UXJJHL6RGGHQ9LOJHIRUW]]QLNEH] ODGX7LVVDLDGH9ULHV
SRSHQLDVDPREyMVWZR$W\]RVWDD NUyORZ 'ROLQ\.ZLDWyZFHVDU](PK\U
NRURQ L EHUHPRGZG]L F]\FLVL ]DPRM &LULNWyUHMWDNGXJRSRV]XNLZDD
NWyU WHUD]PDLZ\NRU]\VWDZHGOHZROLL]DFKFLDQNL0QLHVSDNRZDD L SU]H]
SyWRUDPLHVL FDWU]\PDD Z SXGHNXMDNRVWDWXHWN ] QHIU\WX,]DSHZQH
VSRG]LHZDV]VL H FL]DWRSRG]L NXM
:\SDGDRE\RGU]HNDFKRGQR)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLU1D7KDQHGGE\QLHMDNL
5LHQFHNWyU\]DSXQNWKRQRUXSRVWDZLVRELH]DGDQLHFLSRZROQHMLRNUXWQHM
PLHUFLD9LOJHIRUW]RELHFDPXWRXPR OLZL5LHQFHXJDQLDVL ]DWRE SRFD\P
*DUVWDQJX$OHQLH]QDOD]ERMX E\D QHIU\WRZ ILJXU\QN ]DPRLPGHNROWHP
,E\DPW ILJXU\QN F]WHUG]LH FLVLHGHPGQL
7DN-D]D S\WDQDPRJDPVSRNRMQLHRGSRZLDGD H <HQQHIHU]
9HQJHUEHUJXQLHPDZ'RO%ODWKDQQD3\WDQRZV]DNR<HQQHIHUQLHRVWDWXHWN
&RVL ]PLHQLR H ZUHV]FLH]GHF\GRZDD VL UR]SDNRZDPQLH"
:LHOH=DUD]FLWRZ\MD QL
3U]HGWHPZ\MD QLV]PLFR LQQHJR1D7KDQHGGE\*HUDOW:LHG PLQ
3DPL WDV]SU]HGVWDZLDPFLJRZ$UHWX]LH&R]QLP"
8VSRNyMVL \MH
-HVWHPVSRNRMQD0yZ(QLG
7ZyM:LHG PLQSRZLHG]LDD)UDQFHVFDZFL JXMHGQHMW\ONRJRG]LQ\]UREL
ZL FHMQL QLHMHGHQSU]H]FDH \FLH1LHUR]ZRG] F VL ]DPDQRJ 'LMNVWU]H
XFL JRZ ZH$UWDXGRZL7HUUDQRYLHLEHVWLDOVNR]DU EDRNRRG]LHVL FLX
6FRLD
WDHO$FKE\DE\P]DSRPQLDDREXG]LMHV]F]HQLH]GURZHSRGQLHFHQLH.HLU\
0HW]
6WUDV]QH<HQQHIHUZ\NU]\ZLDVL SU]HVDGQLH$OH.HLUDGRV]DMX FK\EDGR
VLHELH"1LH \ZLFK\EDGRQLHJRXUD]\"7R H SRGQLHFLZV]\M QLHZ\FK GR \
Z\QLNDR]FD SHZQR FL ] EUDNXF]DVXQLH]EUDNOLV]DFXQNX=DSHZQLMM R W\P
Z PRLPLPLHQLX
6DPDE G]LHV]PLDDRND]M WRXF]\QLSRZLHG]LDDFKRGQR6WRNURWND]
'ROLQ,WRZNUyWFH:UyP\MHGQDNGRVSUDZZ]JO GHPNWyU\FKQLHXGROQLH
XGDMHV]RERM WQR 7ZyM:LHG PLQWDN]DSDOLVL GRREURQ\&LUL H SRVW SL
EDUG]RQLHUR]V GQLH5]XFLVL QD9LOJHIRUW]D$9LOJHIRUW]]PDVDNURZDJR7R
H QLH]DELZ\QLNDR]SHZQR FL ] EUDNXF]DVXQLH]EUDNXVWDUD ,FR"1DGDO
E G]LHV]XGDZD H QLFFL WRQLHZ]UXV]D"
1LHJU\PDVQDXVWDFK<HQQHIHUSU]HVWDZ\UD DV]\GHUVWZR1LH(QLG
:]UXV]DPQLHWR:NUyWFHQLHNWyUHRVRE\EOL HM]DSR]QDM VL ] PRLP
Z]UXV]HQLHP0DV]QDWRPRMHVRZR
7DNMDNZF]H QLHMGUZLQ WDNWHUD])UDQFHVFDQLHSU]HM DVL JUR E
7ULVV0HULJROGWHOHSRUWRZDDVNDWRZDQHJRZLHG PLQDGR%URNOLRQX
SRZLHG]LDD=WHJRFRZLHPGULDG\OHF] JRWDPQDGDO0DVL MX SRGREQR
GREU]HDOHOHSLHME\QLHZ\FK\ODVWDPW G QRVD7URSL JRDJHQFL'LMNVWU\L
Z\ZLDG\ZV]\VWNLFKNUyOyZ&LHELH]UHV]W WH
&]\P H ]DVX \DPVRELHQDWDNLHZ\Uy QLHQLH"-DSU]HFLH QLF]HJR'LMNVWU]H
QLH]DPDDP$FKQLHPyZVDPD]JDGQ =QLNDP]7KDQHGGEH] ODGX1LNW
QLHGRP\ ODVL H Z\O GRZDDPZWZRMHMNLHV]HQL]UHGXNRZDQDLVSDNRZDQD
:V]\VF\V SU]HNRQDQL H XFLHNDPGR1LOIJDDUGXZUD]]PRLPLZVSyOQLNDPL
VSLVNRZFDPL:V]\VF\RSUyF]IDNW\F]Q\FKVSLVNRZFyZPDVL UR]XPLHDOHFL
QLNRJRQLHZ\SURZDG] ] E GX:V]DN H WUZDZRMQDGH]LQIRUPDFMDWRRU
RVWU]HNWyUHJR]DZV]HPXVLE\GREU]HZ\FHORZDQH$WHUD]SRF]WHUG]LHVWX
VLHGPLXGQLDFKSU]\V]HGF]DVE\RU D X \0yMGRPZ9HQJHUEHUJXVSDORQ\
MHVWHPSRV]XNLZDQD1LFW\ONRSU]\VWDGRNRPDQGD6FRLD
WDHO/XEZLQQ\VSRVyE
Z F]\VL GRZDONLRZROQR HOIyZ
<HQQHIHU\NQ DVRNX]PDUFKZLZSLDZ]URNZRF]\ZFL ]DFKRZXM FHM
VSRNyMLFLV] ,G\(PHDQDHS6LYQH\
&RSDQL,GR"3DQLZROQD$HQ6HLGKH]*yU6LQ\FK"7UDIQLHRGJDGXM SLVDQ\
PLORV"&]HPXWRPLOF]\SDQLQLE\JD]"
-DSDQL<HQQHIHURGU]HNDUXGRZRVDHOLNDPLOF] JG\QLHPDPQLF
VHQVRZQHJRGRSRZLHG]HQLD=DZV]HWROHSLHMQL VQXQLHX]DVDGQLRQH
SU]\SXV]F]HQLDLPDVNRZDQLHSRNyMJDGXOVWZHP3U]HMG GRU]HF]\(QLG
:\MD QLMSDQL<HQQHIHURFRFKRG]L
=DPLHQLDPVL Z VXFK<HQQHIHUGRWNQ DSDOFDPLREV\GLDQRZHMJZLD]G\QD
DNVDPLWFH0yZ)UDQFHVFD6WRNURWND]'ROLQRSDUWDSRGEUyGHNQD] F]RQ\FK
GRQLDFK
']L R]QDMPLDMHVWGUXJDQRFRGNLHG\NVL \FMHVWZSHQL=DPD FKZLO
WHOHSRUWXMHP\VL GR]DPNX0HQWHFDOYRVLHG]LE\)LOLSS\(LOKDUW:H PLHP\
XG]LDZSRVLHG]HQLXRUJDQL]DFMLNWyUDSRZLQQDFL ]DLQWHUHVRZD=DZV]HZV]DN
E\D ]GDQLD H PDJLDVWDQRZLZDUWR QDMZ\ V] VWRM F SRZ\ HMZV]HONLFK
SRG]LDyZVSRUyZZ\ERUyZSROLW\F]Q\FKRVRELVW\FKLQWHUHVyZDQVyZ
$OHQLHPDP]DPLDUX]PXV]DGRF]HJRNROZLHN$]ZDV]F]DGRORMDOQR FL0DV]
Z\EyU
'RP\ ODPVL MDNL
'REU]HVL GRP\ ODV]$OHZFL MHVWWRZ\EyUZROQ\=HVZHMVWURQ\JRU FR
MHGQDNQDPDZLDPE\ Z\EUDDOR :LHU]PLZWHQVSRVyESRPR HV]WZRMHM&LUL
R ZLHOHVNXWHF]QLHMQL U]XFDM F VL QDR OHSZZLUZ\GDU]H QDFRMDNPQLHPDP
PDV]ZLHON RFKRW &LULJUR]L PLHU8UDWRZDPR H M W\ONRQDV]HVROLGDUQH
G]LDDQLH*G\Z\VXFKDV]WHJRFRE G]LHSRZLHG]LDQHZ0RQWHFDOYRSU]HNRQDV]
VL H PyZLDPSUDZG <HQQHIHUQLHSRGREDM PLVL E\VNLNWyUHZLG] Z
WZRLFKRF]DFK'DMPLVRZR H QLHE G]LHV]SUyERZDXFLHF]NL
1LHSRNU FLDJRZ <HQQHIHUSU]\NU\ZDM F GRQL JZLD]G QDDNVDPLWFH
1LHGDP)UDQFHVFD
&KFLDDE\PORMDOQLHFL XSU]HG]LPRMDGURJD
:V]\VWNLHVWDFMRQDUQHSRUWDOH0RQWHFDOYRPDM EORNDG SDF] F .D G\NWREH]
SU]\]ZROHQLD)LOLSS\FKFLDE\WDPZHM DOERVWDPW G Z\M O GXMHZORV]NXR
FLDQDFKZ\R RQ\FKGZLPHU\WHP:DVQHJRWHOHSRUWXQLHRWZRU]\V]QLH
G\VSRQXM F NRPSRQHQWDPL7ZRMHMJZLD]G\QLHFKF FLRGELHUDERPXVLV]E\Z
SHQLZDG]XP\VRZ\FK$OHMH HOLVSUyEXMHV]ILJOL<HQQHIHUMDQLHPRJ
SR]ZROL/R D QLHPR H SR]ZROLE\ V]DOH F]RLVDPRWQLHSRJQDDUDWRZD&LUL
L V]XND]HPVW\-DZFL PDPWZRM PDWU\F PDPDOJRU\WP]DNO FLD=UHGXNXM
FL L VSDNXM ]QRZXZQHIU\WRZ VWDWXHWN -H OLE G]LHWU]HEDQDNLONDPLHVL F\
$OERODW
']L NL]DRVWU]H HQLH$OHVRZDQLHGDPFLLWDN
QDV]PDUDJGRZ\PQDV]\MQLNXZ\SHQLDM F\PNDURGHNROWX2ERN
]PDWHULDOL]RZDDVL $VVLUHYDU$QDKLGWDNLH]DXZD DOQLH]GHQHUZRZDQD)ULQJLOOD
PLDDMHGQDNSRGVWDZ\SU]\SXV]F]D H SU]\MDFLyN SHV]\QRZ\LQLHW\SRZ\GOD
QLHMVWUyMQLHZ\P\ OQDDOHEDUG]RHOHJDQFNDVXNQLDZNRORU]HKLDF\QWX
X]XSHQLRQDPDOXWN L VNURPQ NROL ] DOHNVDQGU\WyZ
=GHQHUZRZDQLHSU\VRPRPHQWDOQLH:ZLHONLHMMDVQHMRGPDJLF]Q\FK
ODPSLRQyZVDOLE\RFKRGQRLFLFKR1LJG]LHQLHGDRVL ]DXZD \QDJLHJR
0XU]\QDZDO FHJRZE EHQDQLSO VDM F\FKQDVWROHG]LHZF] W ]FHNLQDPLQD
Z]JyUNDFKRQRZ\FKQLHZ\F]XZDRVL ]DSDFKXKDV]\V]XLNDQWDU\G\
1LOIJDDUG]NLHF]DURG]LHMNL]RVWD\QDW\FKPLDVWSRZLWDQHSU]H])LOLSS (LOKDUW
SDQL ]DPNXVWURMQ SRZD Q XSU]HMP L U]HF]RZ ,QQHREHFQHF]DURG]LHMNL
]EOL \\VL L SU]HGVWDZL\D)ULQJLOODRGHWFKQ D]XOJ 0DJLF]NL]3yQRF\E\\
SL NQHNRORURZHLVNU]\\VL RGEL XWHULLDOHZSRGNUH ORQ\FKVWRQRZDQ\P
PDNLMD HPRF]DFKQLHE\R ODGXDQL URGNyZRGXU]DM F\FKDQLQLPIRPDQLL
DGQDWH QLHPLDDRGNU\W\FKSLHUVL:U F]SU]HFLZQLHGZLHE\\QLH]Z\NOH
VNURPQLH]DSL WHSRGV]\M VXURZDRG]LDQDZF]HU 6KHDODGH7DQFDU\LOOHL
PRG]LXWND7ULVV0HULJROGRE NLWQ\FKRF]DFKLSU]HSL NQ\FKNDV]WDQRZ\FK
ZRVDFK&LHPQD6DEULQD*OHYLVVLJRUD]EORQG\QNL0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWLOOHL.HLUD
0HW]QRVL\GHNROW\DOHQLHZLHOHJ EV]HRGGHNROWX)ULQJLOOL
2F]HNLZDQLHQDLQQHXF]HVWQLF]NLNRQZHQWXZ\SHQLDJU]HF]QDNRQZHUVDFMD
SRGF]DVNWyUHMZV]\VWNLHPLD\RND]MHSRZLHG]LHFR R VRELHDWDNWRZQH
VWZLHUG]HQLDLXZDJL)LOLSS\(LOKDUWV]\ENRL]U F]QLHDPD\ORG\FKRMHG\Q\P
ORGHPZRNROLF\E\WHQQDEXIHFLHQDNWyU\PSL WU]\DVL JyUDRVWU\J,QQ\FK
ORGyZQLHZ\F]XZDRVL 6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOHEDGDF]NDQDW\FKPLDVW]QDOD]D
PQyVWZRZVSyOQ\FKWHPDWyZ]EDGDF]N $VVLUHYDU$QDKLG)ULQJLOOD]D V]\ENR
QDEUDDV\PSDWLLGRZHVRHM7ULVV0HULJROG.RQZHUVDFMLWRZDU]\V]\RDNRPH
SRFKDQLDQLHRVWU\J1LHMDGDMHG\QLH6DEULQD*OH\LVVLJQLHRGURGQDFyUD
NDHGZH VNLFKSXV]F]NWyUDSR]ZROLDVRELHZ\UD]LSRJDUGOLZ RSLQL R
R OL]J\FKSDVNXG]WZDFKLRFKRW QDNDZDHN]LPQHMVDUQLQ\]H OLZNDPL
)LOLSSD(LOKDUWPLDVW]DUHDJRZDQDREUD] Z\QLRV\PFKRGHPSRFL JQ D]D
V]QXUG]ZRQNDDSRFKZLOLPDRU]XFDM FDVL Z RF]\LEH]V]HOHVWQDVX ED
GRVWDUF]\DPL VLZR=GXPLHQLH)ULQJLOOLE\RRJURPQH&y SRP\ ODDFRNUDM
WRRE\F]DM
7HOHSRUWPL G]\NROXPQDPLUR]E\VQ LV\V]DOQLH]DZLEURZD1DWZDU]\
6DEULQ\*OHYLVVLJRGPDORZDRVL EH]EU]H QH]GXPLHQLH.HLUD0HW]XSX FLDQD
OyGRVWU\J L Qy 7ULVVVWXPLDZHVWFKQLHQLH
=SRUWDOXZ\RQL\VL WU]\F]DURG]LHMNL7U]\HOINL-HGQDRZRVDFKZNRORU]H
FLHPQHJR]RWDMHGQDF\QREURUXGDLMHGQDNUXF]RF]DUQD
:LWDM)UDQFHVFDSRZLHG]LDD)LOLSSD:MHMJRVLHQLHV\FKDE\RHPRFML
NWyU Z\UD D\RF]\V]\ENRMHGQDN]PUX RQH:LWDM<HQQHIHU
2WU]\PDDPSU]\ZLOHMREVDG]HQLDGZyFKIRWHOLSRZLHG]LDDPHORG\MQLH
QD]ZDQD)UDQFHVN ]RWRZRVDHOINDQLHZ WSOLZLH]DXZD DM F ]GXPLHQLH)LOLSS\
2WRPRMHNDQG\GDWNL=QDQDZV]\VWNLP<HQQHIHU]9HQJHUEHUJX,SDQL,GD(PHDQ
DHS6LYQH\$HQ6DHYKHPH]*yU6LQ\FK
,GD(PHDQVNRQLDOHNNRUXG JRZ ]DV]HOH FLDSRZLHZQ RQNLORZ VXNQL
0LHMVFDSU]\RNU J\PVWROHRSUyF]MHGQHJRE\\R]QDF]RQH)ULQJLOOD
VLHG]LDDRERN$VVLUHYDU$QDKLGPDM F SRSUDZHMZD QLHRZRZROQHNU]HVR
RGG]LHODM FDM RG6KHDOLGH7DQFDU\LOOH]DNWyU ]DM \PLHMVFD6DELQD*OHYLVVLJL
.HLUD0HW]1DOHZRRG$VVLUHVLHG]LDD,GD(PHDQ)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLUL
<HQQHIHU'RNDGQLHQDSU]HFLZ$VVLUHXVDGRZLDVL )LOLSSD(LOKDUWPDM FDSR
SUDZHM0DUJDULW /DX[$QWLOOHDSROHZHM7ULVV0HULJROG
:V]\VWNLHNU]HVDPLD\SRU F]HU]H ELRQHZNV]WDW\VILQNVyZ
)LOLSSDUR]SRF] D3RZWyU]\DSRZLWDQLHLQDW\FKPLDVWSU]HV]DGRU]HF]\
)ULQJLOODNWyUHM$VVLUH]GDDV]F]HJyRZ UHODFM R SRSU]HGQLP]HEUDQLXR \QLH
GRZLHG]LDDVL ]HZVW SXQLF]HJRQRZHJR1LH]DVNRF]\\MHMUyZQLH DQL]R RQH
SU]H]ZV]\VWNLHF]DURG]LHMNLGHNODUDFMHRSU]\VW SLHQLXGRNRQZHQWXDQLSLHUZV]H
JRV\ZG\VNXVML
%\DMHGQDNOHNNRVSHV]RQDDOERZLHPWHSLHUZV]HJRV\GRW\F]\\ZRMQ\MDN
&HVDUVWZRSURZDG]LR]1RUGOLQJDPLD]ZDV]F]DFDNLHPQLHGDZQRUR]SRF] WHM
RSHUDFMLZ6RGGHQL%UXJJHZWUDNFLHNWyUHMZRMVNDFHVDUVNLHVWDU\VL ]EURMQLH]
DUPL 7HPHULL0LPR]DNDGDQHMDSROLW\F]QR FLNRQZHQWXF]DURG]LHMNLQLHE\\Z
VWDQLHXNU\VZ\FKSRJO GyZ1LHNWyUHHZLGHQWQLHQLHSRNRLDREHFQR 1LOIJDDUGX
X EUDP)ULQJLOODGR]QDZDDPLHV]DQ\FKXF]X=DNDGDD H RVRE\WDN
Z\NV]WDFRQHSRZLQQ\UR]XPLH H &HVDUVWZRQLHVLHQD3yQRFNXOWXU GREURE\W
SRU] GHNLVWDELOQR SROLW\F]Q =GUXJLHM]D VWURQ\QLHZLHG]LDDMDNVDPD
UHDJRZDDE\JG\E\WRGRMHMGRPX]EOL D\VL REFHZRMVND
)LOLSSD(LOKDUWQDMZ\UD QLHMPLDDMHGQDNGR G\VWRUVMLRVSUDZDFKPLOLWDUQ\FK
:\QLNXZRMQ\QLNWQLHMHVWZVWDQLHSU]HZLG]LHSRZLHG]LDD&RZL FHM
SU]HZLG\ZDQLHWDNLHSR]EDZLRQHMHVWVHQVX6SyMU]P\ZUHV]FLHQDW U]HF]
FKRGQ\PRNLHP3RSLHUZV]HZRMQDQLHMHVWD WDNZLHONLP]HP%DUG]LHM
REDZLDDE\PVL VNXWNyZSU]HOXGQLHQLDNWyUHQDW\PHWDSLHUR]ZRMXUROQLFWZDL
SU]HP\VXR]QDF]DRE\WRWDOQ NO VN JRGX3RGUXJLHZRMQDWRNRQW\QXDFMD
SROLW\NLZDGFyZ,OX]REHFQLHU] G] F\FKE G]LH \R]DODWVWR" DGHQWR
RF]\ZLVWH,OHG\QDVWLLSU]HWUZD"1LHVSRVyESU]HZLG]LH']LVLHMV]HVSRU\
WHU\WRULDOQHG\QDVW\F]QHG]LVLHMV]HDPELFMHLG]LVLHMV]HQDG]LHMHE G ]DVWRODW
SURFKHPLS\HPQDNURQLNDFK$OHMH OLP\VL QLH]DEH]SLHF]\P\MH OLGDP\VL
ZFL JQ ZZRMQ ]QDVWH ]RVWDQLHSURFKLS\-H HOLQDWRPLDVWVSRMU]\P\QLHFR
SRQDGV]WDQGDU\MH OL]DPNQLHP\XV]\QDERMRZHLSDWULRW\F]QHRNU]\NL
SU]HWUZDP\$PXVLP\SU]HWUZD0XVLP\ERSRQRVLP\RGSRZLHG]LDOQR 1LH
ZREHFNUyOyZLLFKSDUW\NXODUQ\FK]DZ RQ\FKGRMHGQHJRNUyOHVWZDLQWHUHVyZ
0\RGSRZLDGDP\]D ZLDW=DSRVW S=D]PLDQ\NWyUHWHQSRVW S QLHVLH
2GSRZLDGDP\]DSU]\V]R
7LVVDLDGH9ULHVXM DE\WRLQDF]HMSRZLHG]LDD)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLU-HM
]DZV]HFKRG]LRRRGSRZLHG]LDOQR ZREHF]Z\N\FKSURVW\FKOXG]L1LHZ
SU]\V]R FLDOHWXLWHUD]
7LVVDLDGH9ULHVQLH \MH*G\E\ \DE\DE\Z UyGQDV
=DSHZQHX PLHFKQ DVL 6WRNURWND]'ROLQ$OHQLHP\ O E\]JRG]LDVL
] WHRUL R ZRMQLHMDNRUHPHGLXPQDNO VN JRGXLSU]HOXGQLHQLD=ZUyFLHXZDJ
QDWRRVWDWQLHVRZRV]DQRZQHNRQIUDWHUNL2EUDGXMHP\X \ZDM F M ]\ND
ZVSyOQHJRPDM FHJRXDWZLSRUR]XPLHQLH$OHGODPQLHMHVWWRM ]\NREF\&RUD]
EDUG]LHMREF\:M ]\NXPRMHMPDWNLQLHPDVRZDSU]HOXGQLHQLHDVRZR
SU]HHOILHQLHE\RE\QHRORJL]PHP1LHRG DRZDQHMSDPL FL7LVVDLDGH9ULHV
SU]HMPRZDDVL ORVHP]Z\N\FKOXG]L-H HOLFKRG]LRPQLHWRQLHPQLHMZD Q\
MHVWORV]Z\N\FKHOIyZ&K WQLHSU]\NODVQ DE\PLGHLZ\ELHJDQLDP\ O Z
SU]\V]R LWUDNWRZDQLDGQLDG]LVLHMV]HJRMDNRHIHPHU\G\$OH]SU]\NUR FL
VWZLHUG]DP H G]LH G]LVLHMV]\ZDUXQNXMHMXWU]HMV]\DEH]MXWUDQLHE G]LH
SU]\V]R FL'ODZDVOXG]L PLHV]Q\MHVWPR H SDF]QDGNU]DNLHPE]XNWyU\
VSRQ ZF]DVLHZRMHQQHM]DZLHUXFK\ZV]DN H E]XQLH]DEUDNQLHQLHE G]LHWHJR
E G]LHLQQ\DQLHE G]LHE]XFy E G]LHDNDFMD:\EDF]FLHERWDQLF]QHPHWDIRU\
$OHSU]\MQPFLHDVNDZLHGRZLDGRPR FL H WRFRGODZDVOXG]LMHVWNZHVWL
SROLW\NLGODQDVHOIyZMHVWNZHVWL IL]\F]QHJRSU]HWUZDQLD
3ROLW\NDPQLHQLHLQWHUHVXMHR ZLDGF]\DJR QR0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWLOOH
UHNWRUNDDNDGHPLLPDJLF]QHM-DSRSURVWXQLH \F] VRELHE\G]LHZF] WDNWyU\FK
HGXNDFMLVL SR ZL FLDPZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQRMDNRNRQGRWLHUDP\GO F LPRF]\
VORJDQDPLRPLR FLRMF]\]Q\2MF]\]Q W\FKG]LHZF] W MHVWPDJLDWHJRLFKXF]
-H HOLPRMHG]LHZF] WDNWR ]DDQJD XMHZZRMQ SRVWDZLQDQRZ\PZ]JyU]X
6RGGHQWRRQHE G SU]HJUDQHQLH]DOH QLHRGZ\QLNXQDSROXELWZ\5R]XPLHP
WZRMH]DVWU]H HQLD(QLGDOHPDP\VL ]DMPRZDSU]\V]R FL PDJLLQLH
SUREOHPDPLUDVRZ\PL
0DP\]DMPRZDVL SU]\V]R FL PDJLLSRZWyU]\D6DEULQD*OHYLVVLJ$OH
SU]\V]R PDJLLZDUXQNXMHVWDWXVF]DURG]LHMyZ1DV]VWDWXV1DV]H]QDF]HQLH
5RO MDN VSHQLDP\ZVSRHF]H VWZLH=DXIDQLHV]DFXQHNLZLDU\JRGQR
SRZV]HFKQDZLDUDZQDV] SU]\GDWQR ZWR H PDJLDMHVWQLH]E GQD6WRM FD
SU]HGQDPLDOWHUQDW\ZD]GDMHVL SURVWDDOERXWUDWDVWDWXVXLL]RODFMDZZLH DFK]
NR FLVRQLRZHMDOERVX ED6X EDQDZHWQDZ]JRU]DFK6RGGHQQDZHWMDNR
NRQGRWLHUNL
$OERMDNRVX FHLG]LHZNLQDSRV\NL"7ULVV0HULJROGRGU]XFLD]UDPLHQLD
VZHSL NQHZRV\=H]JL W\PNDUNDPLJRWRZHGRSRVXJQDND GHNLZQL FLH
FHVDUVNLHJRSDOFD"%RZV]DN H WDN URO SU]\G]LHOLQDP3D[1LOIHJDDUGLDQDMH OL
SRZV]HFKQLH]DSDQXMH
-H OL]DSDQXMHSRZLHG]LDD]QDFLVNLHP)LOLSSD0\QLHPDP\DOWHUQDW\Z\
0\PXVLP\VX \$OHPDJLL1LHNUyORPLFHVDU]RPQLHLFKG]LVLHMV]HMSROLW\FH
1LHVSUDZRPUDVRZHMLQWHJUDFMLERWDUyZQLH SRGGDQDMHVWG]LVLHMV]\PFHORP
SROLW\F]Q\P1DV]NRQZHQWGURJLHSDQLHQLHSRWR]RVWDSRZRDQ\E\ P\
GRSDVRZ\ZD\IIOWGRG]LVLHMV]HMSROLW\NLLFRG]LHQQ\FK]PLDQQDOLQLLIURQWX1LH
SRWRE\ P\JRU F]NRZRV]XND\UR]ZL ]D DGHNZDWQ\FKGRGDQHMV\WXDFML
]PLHQLDM F NRORUVNyU\NDPHOHRQLPVSRVREHP5RODQDV]HMOR \ ZLQQDE\
DNW\ZQD,FDNLHPRGZURWQD5HDOL]RZDQDZV]\VWNLPLGRVW SQ\PLQDP
VSRVREDPL
-H OLGREU]HSRMPXM XQLRVDJRZ 6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOHQDPDZLDV]QDVGR
DNW\ZQHJRZS\ZDQLDQDELHJZ\GDU]H :V]\VWNLPLVSRVREDPL5yZQLH
EH]SUDZQ\PL"
2MDNLPSUDZLHPyZLV]"2W\PGODPDOXF]NLFK"2W\P]DSLVDQ\PZ
NRGHNVDFKNWyUHVDPHRSUDFRZD\ P\LSRG\NWRZD\ P\NUyOHZVNLPMXU\VWRP"
1DVREOLJXMHW\ONRMHGQRSUDZR1DV]H
WXFKRG]LRG\QDVWL 7DNXVWDZLRQDSRSU]HF]NDZ\NOXF]DFLHELH)LOLSSR
Z\NOXF]DPQLHZ\NOXF]DQDZHW.HLU L 7ULVVQDMPRGV]HZ UyGQDV:\NOXF]DWH
ZV]\VWNLHDGHSWNL]PRMHMV]NR\NWyUH]UHV]W L GODQDVV PDRFLHNDZHERWR
S F]NLRQLHZLDGRP\PZFL MHV]F]HNRORU]HSDWNyZQLHGRSRP\ OHQLDMHVWE\
NWyUDNROZLHNPRJD]DVL QDGZXQDVW\PSXVW\PPLHMVFX]DW\PVWRHP,QQ\PL
VRZ\QDZHWJG\E\FD\.RYLURV]DODLE\VNRQQ\]DDNFHSWRZDPD H VWZR
NUyOHZLF]D]F]DURG]LHMN QLH]QDMG]LHP\WDNLHMF]DURG]LHMNL.WRZL F PDE\
RZ .UyORZ 3yQRF\"
']LHZF]\QD]NUyOHZVNLHJRURGXRGU]HNDVSRNRMQLH)LOLSSD: \DFK
NWyUHMS\QLHNUHZNUyOHZVNDNUHZNLONXZLHONLFKG\QDVWLL0RG]LXWNDL]GROQD
URG]L']LHZF]\QDRQLHE\ZD\FK]GROQR FLDFKPDJLF]Q\FKLZLHV]F]\FK
QRVLFLHOND]ZLDVWRZDQHMSU]HSRZLHGQLDPL6WDUV]HM.UZL']LHZF]\QDNWyUD
SLHZDM FRJUDDE G]LHVZRM URO EH]G\U\JHQWyZVXIOHUyZSRSOHF]QLNyZL
V]DU\FKHPLQHQFMLERWHJRFKFHMHMSU]H]QDF]HQLH']LHZF]\QDNWyUHMIDNW\F]QH
]GROQR FL]QDQHV L E G ]QDQHW\ONRQDP&LULOODFyUND3DYHWW\]&LQWU\
ZQXF]ND/ZLF\&DODQWKH6WDUV]D.UHZ/RGRZ\3RPLH 3yQRF\1LV]F]\FLHOND
L 2GQRZLFLHONDQDGHM FLHNWyUHMZ\SURURNRZDQRMX SU]HGVHWNDPLODW&LUL]
&LQWU\.UyORZD3yQRF\,MHMNUHZ]NWyUHMQDURG]LVL .UyORZD ZLDWD
3RWHPRGMHFKDDQLHRJO GDM F VL
%\RSR]DVDG]FH(VNRUWDZ\ELWDGRQRJL$VVHL5HHI]DWU]\PDOLNDUHW
XF]HSLZV]\VL X]GSDU\OHMFRZ\FK=HSFKQL W\]SUDZHJROHMFRZHJRIRU\
PRG]LXWNLFKRSDNZNRORURZMOLEHULLNO F]DQD]LHPLSDNDLZRDOLWR FL
6WDQJUHWU]XFLOHMFHLWH EDJD]PLRZDQLDVNDGDM F U FHMDNGRPRGOLWZ\
*LVHOKHU,VNUDL0LVWOHSRGJDORSRZDOLGRNDUHW\.D\OHLJK]HVNRF]\]NRQLDL
V]DUSQ GU]ZLF]NL&LULSRGMHFKDDEOL HM]VLDGDZFL WU]\PDM F ZGRQLSRNU\W\
NUZL PLHF]
:NDUHFLHVLHG]LDDJUXEDPDWURQDZUREURQLHLF]HSFXREHMPXM FDPRG L
SU]HUD OLZLHEODG G]LHZF]\Q Z F]DUQHM]DSL WHMSRGV]\M VXNLHQFH]
JLSLXURZ\PNRQLHU]\NLHP'RVXNLHQNLMDN]DXZD \D&LULSU]\SL W E\D
JHPPD%DUG]RDGQD
$OHWDUDQFLNLNU]\NQ D,VNUDRJO GDM F ]DSU] J1DNUDSLDWNL OLF]QHMDN]
REUD]ND'RVWDQLHP\]DW F]ZyUN NLONDIORUHQyZ
$NDUHWN .D\OHLJKZ\V]F]HU]\VL GRNRELHW\LG]LHZF]\Q\SRFL JQ GR
PLDVWHF]NDVWDQJUHWLIRU\ QDR \ZV]\VRELHV]RUNL$JG\E G]LHSRGJyUN WR
RELHSDQLXVLHSRPRJ
3DQRZLH]EyMF\]DM F]DDPDWURQDZUREURQLHNWyU REOH Q\X PLHFK
.D\OHLJKDQDMZ\UD QLHMSU]HUD DEDUG]LHMQL RNUZDZLRQH HOD]RZU NX&LUL
$SHOXM GRZDV]HJRKRQRUX1LHSRKD ELFLHZV]DNWHMPRGHMG]LHZLF\
+HM0LVWOH]DZRD.D\OHLJKX PLHFKDM F VL NSLDUVNR7XVL MDNV\V]
DSHOXMHGRWZRMHJRKRQRUX
=DPNQLMJ E VNU]\ZLVL *LVHOKHUZFL Z VLRGOH1LNRJRQLH PLHV]
WZRMHIDFHFMH$W\XVSRNyMVL NRELHWR0\MHVWH P\6]F]XU\1LHZRMXMHP\]
QLHZLDVWDPLLQLHNU]\ZG]LP\LFK%HHI,VNUDZ\SU] JDMFLHNXVDNL0LVWOH]DS
ZLHU]FKRZH,ZLHMHP\
0\6]F]XU\QLHZRMXMHP\]QLHZLDVWDPLZ\V]F]HU]\]QRZX] E\.D\OHLJK
ZSDWUXM F VL Z SREODG WZDU]G]LHZF]\Q\ZF]DUQHMVXNLHQFH&]DVHPW\ONR
]DEDZLDP\VL ] QLPLMH OLPDM FK $W\PDV]SDQLHQNR"1LH ZLHU]ELFL
Z\SDGNLHPPL G]\Qy NDPL"1RQLHPDVL F]HJRZVW\G]L:\VWDUF]\NLZQ
JyZN
:L FHMV]DFXQNXNU]\NQ DDPL F\PVL JRVHPGDPDZUREURQLH-DN
PLHV]WDNPyZLGRMD QLHZLHOPR QHMEDURQyZQ\SDQLH]EyMX
.D\OHLJK]DUHFKRWDSRF]\PXNRQLVL SU]HVDGQLH
:\EDF]HQLDXSUDV]DP1LHFKFLDHPXEOL \&RQDZHWVS\WDQLHZROQR"
.D\OHLJK]DZRDD,VNUD&KRG WX&]HJRWDPPLWU \V]"3RPy QDP
WDUDQW\Z\SU] F)DOND5XV]VL
&LULQLHRGU\ZDDRF]XRGKHUEXQDGU]ZLDFKNDUHW\VUHEUQHJRMHGQRUR FDZ
F]DUQ\PSROX-HGQRUR HFP\ ODD:LG]LDDPNLHG\ WDNLHJRMHGQRUR FD.LHG\"
: LQQ\P \FLX"$PR H WRE\W\ONRVHQ"
)DOND&R]WRE "
-HVWHP)DOND$OHQLH]DZV]HQL E\DP1LH]DZV]H2WU] VQ DVL ]DFL D
ZDUJL%\DPQLHPLDGOD0LVWOHSRP\ ODD8UD]LDPM 0XV] M MDNR
SU]HSURVL3RVWDZLDQRJ QDVWRSQLDFKNDUHW\ZSDWU]RQDZJHPP QDVXNLHQFH
EODGHMG]LHZF]\Q\
'DZDMWRSRZLHG]LDDNUyWNR
-DN PLHV]"]DFK\VQ DVL PDWURQD&]\ZLHV]GRNRJRPyZLV]"7RMD QLH
XURG]RQDEDURQyZQD&DVDGHL
&LULUR]HMU]DDVL XSHZQLDF]\QLNWQLHV\V]\
%DURQyZQD"V\NQ D1LVNLW\WX$QDZHWJG\E\V]F]HQLDUDE\DNRQWHVV
WRSRZLQQDSU]HGHPQ G\JDWDNE\W\HF]HNE\SU]\]LHPLDJyZNDQLVNR
'DZDMEURV]N 1DFRF]HNDV]"0DPM ] FLHELH]HGU]HUD]HP]JRUVHWHP"
QLHE G]LHNUyWND
+LVWRULD/DU\L&UHJHQQDQDWRKLVWRULDSUDZG]LZDREHFQLHMHGQDNWDNREUR QL WD
EDMNRZ\PLRUQDPHQWDPL H PDRUR]SR]QDZDOQD,VWQLHM WH ROEU]\PLH
UR]ELH QR FLPL G]\OXG]N D HOIL ZHUVM OHJHQG\ZREXSREU]PLHZDM
V]RZLQL]PLQLHQDZL UDVRZD'ODWHJRWH RGU]XF R]GREQLNLRJUDQLF] VL GR
VXFK\FKIDNWyZ,WDN&UHJHQQDQ]/RGE\F]DURG]LHMHP/DUD'RUUHQDHS
6KLDGKDOHOIL PDJLF]N $HQ6DH\KHPH:LHG] F MHGQ ] ]DJDGNRZHMQDZHWGOD
QDVHOIyZQRVLFLHOL+HQ,FKDHU6WDUV]HM.UZL3U]\MD DSRWHP]ZL ]HNPLRVQ\
RERMJDE\SRF] WNRZR]UDGR FL SRZLWDQ\SU]H]RELHUDV\ZNUyWFHMHGQDN
SRMDZLOLVL ZURJRZLH]GHF\GRZDQLSU]HFLZQLF\NRQFHSFMLSR F]HQLDOXG]NLHML
HOILHMPDJLL7DNZ UyGHOIyZMDNLZ UyGOXG]L]QDOH OLVL WDF\NWyU]\XZD DOLWR
]D]GUDG %\\WH MDNLH QLHMDVQHMX G]L ]DWDUJLRFKDUDNWHU]HRVRELVW\P
]D]GUR L]DZL .UyWNRZZ\QLNXXNQXWHMLQWU\JL&UHJHQQDQ]RVWD]JDG]RQ\
/DUD'RUUHQ]DV]F]XWDL FLJDQD]PDUD]Z\FLH F]HQLDQDMDNLP SXVWNRZLX
URG] F FyUN ']LHFNRXUDWRZDQRFXGHP3U]\JDUQ DMH&HUURNUyORZD5HGDQLL
3U]HUD RQDNO WZ NWyU U]XFLDQDQL /DUDJG\&HUURRGPyZLDMHMSRPRF\L
Z\S G]LDQDPUy]ZWU FLD.HLUD0HW]*G\E\QLHSU]\JDUQ DG]LHFNDPLD\
QDQL L QDFD\MHMUyGVSD VWUDV]OLZHNO VNL
7RZD QLHV EDMHF]QHRUQDPHQW\]NWyU\FK]UH]\JQRZDD)UDQFHVFD
SU]HUZDD)LOLSSD(LOKDUW7U]\PDMP\VL IDNWyZ
3URURF]H]GROQR FL:LHG] F\FK]H6WDUV]HM.UZLV IDNWDPLSRZLHG]LDD,GD
(PHDQXQRV] F RF]\QD)LOLSS $SRZWDU]DM F\VL ZHZV]\VWNLFKZHUVMDFK
OHJHQG\VXJHVW\ZQ\PRW\ZSURURFWZDGDMHGRP\ OHQLD
'DMHGRG]L L GDZDQLHJG\ SRWZLHUG]LD)UDQFHVFD3RJRVNLRNO WZLH
/DU\QLHFLFK\SU]\SRPQLDQRVRELHRQLFKQDZHWSRVLHGHPQDVWXODWDFKJG\
SU]\JDUQL WDSU]H]&HUURG]LHZF]\QNDQD]ZDQD5LDQQRQZ\URVDQDSDQQ R
XURG]LH]DPLHZDM FHMQDZHWOHJHQGDUQ XURG PDWNL3U]\VSRVRELRQD5LDQQRQ
QRVLDRILFMDOQ\W\WXUHGD VNLHMNUyOHZQ\DLQWHUHVRZDRVL QL ZLHOHGRPyZ
SDQXM F\FK*G\VSR UyGZLHOXNRQNXUHQWyZ%LDQ%RQZ\EUDDZUHV]FLH
*RLGHPDUDPRGHJRNUyOD7HPHULLQLHZLHOHEUDNRZDRE\SORWNLRNO WZLH
]QLZHF]\\PDULD =SUDZG]LZLHMHGQDN]ZLHORNURWQLRQ VL SRJRVNLSRV]\Z
OXGWU]\ODWDSR OXELH*RLGHPDUDL5LDQQRQ3RGF]DVUHEHOLL)DONL
)ULQJLOODNWyUDQLJG\QLHV\V]DDDQLR)DOFHDQLRMHMUHEHOLLXQLRVDEUZL
)UDQFHVFD]DXZD \DWR
'ODNUyOHVWZSyQRFQ\FKZ\MD QLDE\\WRZ\GDU]HQLDWUDJLF]QHLNUZDZH
GRG]L \ZHZSDPL FLFKRPLQ RSRQDGVWRODW:1LOIJDDUG]LH]NWyU\P
SRGyZF]DV3yQRFQLHPLDDSUDZLH DGQ\FKNRQWDNWyZVSUDZD]DSHZQH]QDQDQLH
MHVWGODWHJRSR]ZRO VRELHVNUyWRZRSU]\SRPQLHSHZQHIDNW\)DONDE\DFyUN
9ULGDQNDNUyOD5HGDQLL=PD H VWZDNWyUHUR]ZL ]DJG\ZRNRZSDGDPX
SL NQD&HUURWDVDPDNWyUDSy QLHMSU]\JDUQ DG]LHFNR/DU\=DFKRZDVL
GRNXPHQWUR]ZOHNOHL]DZLOHSRGDM F\SU]\F]\Q\UR]ZRGXDOH]DFKRZDVL
UyZQLH ZL FHMPyZL F\SRUWUHFLNSLHUZV]HM RQ\9ULGDQNDV]ODFKFLDQNL
NRYLUVNLHMQLHZ WSOLZLHSyHOINLDOHR]GHF\GRZDQHMSU]HZDG]HFHFKOXG]NLFK
2F]\V]DORQHMHUHPLWNLZRV\WRSLHOLF\LXVWDMDV]F]XUNL.UyWNREU]\GXO
RGHVDQRGR.RYLUXUD]HP]URF]Q FyUN )DON ,ZNUyWFH]DSRPQLDQRRMHGQHML
GUXJLHM
)DONDSRGM DSRFKZLOL(QLGDQ*OHDQQDSU]\SRPQLDDRVRELHSR
GZXG]LHVWXSL FLXODWDFKZ]QLHFDM F SRZVWDQLHLZDVQ MDNRE\U N PRUGXM F
RMFD&HUURLGZyFKEUDFLSU]\URGQLFK=EURMQDUHEHOLDZ\EXFKDSRF] WNRZRMDNR
SRSLHUDQDSU]H]F] WHPHUVNLHMLNRYLUVNLHMV]ODFKW\ZDONDOHJDOQHMSLHUZRURGQHM
R QDOH Q\MHMWURQDOHZNUyWFHSU]HLVWRF]\DVL Z ZRMQ FKRSVN R RJURPQ\P
]DVL JX2ELHVWURQ\GRSXV]F]D\VL PDNDEU\F]Q\FKRNUXFLH VWZ)DONDSU]HV]D
GROHJHQGMDNRNUZDZ\GHPRQZLVWRFLHSUDZGRSRGREQLHMV]HMHVW H SRSURVWX
SU]HVWDDSDQRZDQDGV\WXDFM L QDGZFL QRZ\PLKDVDPLNWyUHZ\SLV\ZDQRQD
SRZVWD F]\FKV]WDQGDUDFK PLHUNUyORP PLHUF]DURG]LHMRP PLHUNDSDQRP
V]ODFKFLHERJDF]RPLSDQRPZNUyWFH PLHUZV]\VWNLHPXFR \MHERSUDQHM
NUZL F]HUQLQLHVSRVyEE\RMX RNLH]QD5HEHOLD]DF] DVL UR]V]HU]DQDLQQH
NUDMH
1LOIJDDUG]F\KLVWRU\F\SLVDOLRW\PSU]HUZDD]Z\UD Q\PSU]HN VHP6DEULQD
*OH\LVVLJ$SDQL$VVLUHLSDQL9LJRQLHZ WSOLZLHF]\WD\6NUDFDM)UDQFHVHD
3U]HMG GR5LDQQRQLWURMDF]NyZ]+RXWERUJD
3URV] XSU]HMPLH5LDQQRQSU]\JDUQL WDSU]H]&HUURFyUND/DU\'RUUHQWHUD]
MX RQD*RLGHPDUDNUyOD7HPHULL]RVWDDSU]\SDGNRZRSRMPDQDSU]H]
UHEHOLDQWyZ)DONLLXZL ]LRQDZ]DPNX+RXWERUJ:FKZLOLSRMPDQLDE\D
FL DUQD=DPHNEURQLVL MHV]F]HGXJRSRVWXPLHQLXEXQWXLSRVWUDFHQLX)DONL
DOH*RLGHPDUZ]L JRZUHV]FLHV]WXUPHPLRVZRERG]L RQ =WUyMN G]LHFL
GZLHPDG]LHZF]\QNDPLNWyUHMX FKRG]L\LFKRSFHPNWyU\SUyERZD5LDQQRQ
E\DRE NDQD5R]Z FLHF]RQ\*RLGHPDUUR]FL JQ QDWRUWXUDFKZV]\VWNLFK
MH FyZL]HVWU] SNyZSU]HU\ZDQ\FKZ\FLHP]H]QD XR \VL F]\WHOQ\REUD]
)DONDNWyUDXURG SU]HM DUDF]HMSRHOILHMEDEFHQL SRPDWFHKRMQLHREGDU]DD
ZG]L NDPLZV]\VWNLFKVZ\FKKHWPDQyZRGV]ODFKW\SR]Z\N\FKZDWD NyZL
UH]XQyZ]DSHZQLDM F W\PVRELHLFKZLHUQR LORMDOQR =DV]DZUHV]FLHZFL
L
XURG]LDG]LHFNRGRNDGQLHZW\PVDP\PF]DVLHJG\XZL ]LRQDZ+RXWERUJX
5LDQQRQSRZLDEOL QL WD)DONDUR]ND]DDGRR \VZHJRQLHPRZODNDGRG]LHFL
5LDQQRQ-DNVL SRGREQRPLDDZ\UD]LJRGQH]DV]F]\WXE\FLDPDPNDPLMHM
E NDUWyZV W\ONRNUyORZHWDNLORVF]HNDZV]\VWNLHNRURQRZDQHVDPLF]NLZ
QRZ\PSRU] GNXNWyUHRQD)DOND]EXGXMHSR]Z\FL VWZLH
3UREOHPSROHJDQDW\P H QLNWZ F]DM F ZWR5LDQQRQQLHZLHG]LDNWyUH]
WUyMNLMHVWG]LHFNLHP)DONL'RPQLHP\ZDQR]GX GR] SUDZGRSRGRELH VWZD H
MHVWWHMHGQD]G]LHZF]\QHNER5LDQQRQXURG]LDSRGREQRG]LHZF]\QN L FKRSFD
3RZWDU]DPSRGREQRDOERZLHPSRPLPRFKHSOLZ\FKGHNODUDFML)DONLG]LHFL
NDUPL\]Z\F]DMQHFKRSVNLHPDPNL5LDQQRQJG\Z\OHF]RQRM ZUHV]FLH]
RE GXSUDZLHQLF]HJRQLHSDPL WDD2ZV]HPURG]LD2ZV]HPSU]\QRV]RQRMHM
F]DVDPLGRy NDLSRND]\ZDQRWURMDF]NL1LFZL FHM
:yZF]DVZH]ZDQRF]DURG]LHMyZE\]EDGDOLWUyMN L XVWDOLOLNWRMHVWNLP
*RLGHPDUE\WDN]DZ]L W\ H SRZ\NU\FLXE NDUWD)DONLPLD]DPLDUVWUDFL
G]LHFNRLWRSXEOLF]QLH'RWHJRGRSX FLQLHPRJOL P\3RVWXPLHQLXSRZVWDQLD
QDSRMPDQ\FKUHEHOLDQWDFKGRSXV]F]DQRVL QLHZ\SRZLHG]LDQ\FKEHVWLDOVWZ
QDOH DRQDUHV]FLHSRR \WHPXNUHV(J]HNXFMDPQLHMQL GZXOHWQLHJRG]LHFND
Z\REUD DFLHVRELH"'RSLHURSRZVWD\E\OHJHQG\$MX L WDN]DF]\QDDNU \
GRJXVWXLW\PVSRVREHPFyUND5LDQQRQSUDSUDSUDEDENDZDV]HM&LUL]RVWDD
ZNUyWFHNUyORZ &LQWU\
:QRV] F GRG\QDVWLL&RUDPyZV\QQ\JHQNWyU\Z\WURSLOL FLHQDGDO
)LRQDSRZLHG]LDDVSRNRMQLH(QLGDQ*OHDQQDQLHE\DQRVLFLHON JHQX
6WDUV]HM.UZL.WyU\P\MX ZyZF]DVQD]\ZDOL P\JHQHP/DU\
-DNWR"
1RVLFLHOHPJHQX/DU\E\$PDYHWDQDV]HNVSHU\PHQWWUZD%R$QQD
.DPHQ\SU]H]NWyU VWUDFLOL \FLHNRFKDQHNLP E G F MHV]F]HZ DRELHSR
RE\GZXSRZLDEOL QL WD&KRSFDLG]LHZF]\QN 2MFHPE\QLHZ WSOLZLH$PDYHW
ERG]LHZF]\QNDE\DQRVLFLHON JHQX2WU]\PDDLPL 0XULHO
0XULHO3L NQDRWU]\FD"]G]LZLDVL 6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOH
'X R Sy QLHMX PLHFK DVL )UDQFHVFD=SRF] WNX0XULHO0LOXVLD
)DNW\F]QLHE\RWRPLOXWNLHVRGNLHG]LHFNR*G\VNR F]\DF]WHUQD FLHODW
PyZLRQRMX QDQL 0XULHO$NVDPLWQRRND1LHMHGHQZW\FKRF]DFKXWRQ
:\GDQRM ZUHV]FLH]D5REHUWDKUDELHJR*DUUDPRQH
$FKRSLHF"
&ULVSLQ1LHQRVLJHQXZL F QLHLQWHUHVRZDQDV=GDMHVL H SROHJQDMDNLHM
ZRMQLHERW\ONRZRMDF]NDPXE\DZJRZLH
=DUD]6DEULQDJZDWRZQ\PUXFKHPUR]EXU]\DZRV\0XULHO3L NQD
RWU]\FDE\DSU]HFLH PDWN $GDOLL]ZDQHM:Uy N
=JDG]DVL SRWZLHUG]LD)UDQFHVFD&LHNDZDRVRED$GDOLD6LOQH UyGR
GRVNRQD\PDWHULDQDF]DURG]LHMN 1LHVWHW\QLHFKFLDDE\F]DURG]LHMN :RODD
E\NUyORZ
$JHQ"VS\WDD$VVLUHYDU$QDKLG1RVLDJR"
&LHNDZHDOHQLH
7DNP\ ODDPNLZQ DJRZ $VVLUH*HQ/DU\PR H E\SU]HND]\ZDQ\Z
VSRVyEFL J\W\ONRSROLQLL H VNLHM-H OLQRVLFLHOHPMHVWP F]\]QDJHQ]DWUDFD
VL Z GUXJLPQDMGDOHMZWU]HFLPSRNROHQLX
$OHSRW\PMHGQDNVL XDNW\ZQLDU]HND)LOLSSD(LOKDUW3R]EDZLRQDJHQX
$GDOLDE\DZV]DNPDWN &DODQWKHD&DODQWKHEDEND&LULE\DSU]HFLH QRVLFLHON
JHQX/DU\
3LHUZV] SR5LDQQRQRGH]ZDDVL QDJOH6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOH
3RSHQLOL FLHE G)UDQFHVFD%\\GZDJHQ\-HGHQWHQZD FLZ\E\XWDMRQ\
ODWHQWQ\SU]HJDSLOL FLHJRX)LRQ\]P\OHQLVLOQ\PLZ\UD Q\PJHQHP$PDYHWD
$OHWRFRPLD$PDYHWQLHE\RJHQHPOHF]DNW\ZL]DWRUHP3DQL$VVLUHPDUDFM
,G F\]P VNLHMOLQLLDNW\ZL]DWRUE\MX X $GDOLLWDNPDRZ\UD Q\ H QLH
Z\NU\OL FLHJR$GDOLDE\DSLHUZV]\PG]LHFNLHPRWU]\F\QDVW SQH]SHZQR FL
QLHPLD\QDZHW ODGXDNW\ZL]DWRUD/DWHQWQ\JHQ)LRQ\WH ]DSHZQH]DQLNE\XMHM
P VNLFKSRWRPNyZQDMGDOHMZWU]HFLPSRNROHQLX$OHQLH]DQLNLMDZLHP
GODF]HJR
-DVQDFKROHUDV\NQ DSU]H]] E\<HQQHIHU
=JXELDPVL R]QDMPLD6DEULQD*OH\LVVLJ:J V]F]XWHMJHQHW\NLL
JHQHDORJLL
)UDQFHVFDSU]\VXQ DGRVLHELHSDWHU ] RZRFDPLZ\FL JQ DU N Z\PUXF]DD
]DNO FLH
)ULQJLOODLG F ODGHPZ]URNX7ULVV0HULJROGGRVWU]HJDMDNGRQLH<HQQHIHU
]DFLVQ \VL QDJOHQDU]H ELRQ\FKSRU F]DFKNU]HVD
2WRFR F]\ZWHMFKZLOL<HQQHIHUL)UDQFHVN P\ ODDJRU F]NRZR7ULVV
ZFL XQLNDM F Z]URNXSU]\MDFLyNL:\UDFKRZDQLH%RZV]DN H QLHRE\RVL EH]
NRMDU]HQLDZSDUNLLKRGRZOL7DNLFKSODQ\Z]JO GHP&LULLNUyOHZLF]D].RYLUX
FKR]SR]RUXQLHSUDZGRSRGREQHV SU]HFLH FDNLHPUHDOQH2QHMX WRUREL\
6DG]D\QDWURQDFKDNRJRFKFLD\WZRU]\\]ZL ]NLLG\QDVWLHMDNLFK]DSUDJQ \
MDNLHE\\GODQLFKZ\JRGQH:UXFKV]\XURNLDIURG\]MDNLHOLNVLU\.UyORZHL
NUyOHZQ\]DZLHUD\QDJOHG]LZDF]QHF] VWRPRUJDQDW\F]QHPD H VWZDF] VWR
ZEUHZZV]\VWNLPSODQRP]DPLDURPLXPRZRP$Sy QLHMW\PNWyUHFKFLD\
URG]LDQLHSRZLQQ\SRGDZDQRWDMHPQLH URGNL]DSRELHJDM FHFL \7HNWyUH
URG]LQLHFKFLD\DWU]HEDE\RE\URG]L\]DPLDVWRELHFDQ\FK URGNyZ
RWU]\P\ZD\SODFHERZRG ] OXNUHFM 6W G WHZV]\VWNLHQLHSUDZGRSRGREQH
NROLJDFMH&DODQWKH3DYHWWD,&LUL<HQQHIHUE\DZWR]DDQJD RZDQD$WHUD]
DXMH,PDVXV]QR 'ROLFKDMH OL*HUDOWVL R W\PGRZLH
6ILQNV\P\ ODD)ULQJLOOD9LJR6ILQNV\U]H ELRQHQDSRU F]DFKIRWHOL7DNWR
SRZLQQR]RVWD]QDNLHPLJRGHPOR \:LHG]DWDMHPQLFDPLOF]HQLH2QHV
VILQNVDPL2QHEH]WUXGXRVL JQ WRF]HJRFKF 7RGODQLFKIUDV]NDSR HQL
.RYLU]W LFK&LUL0DM PRF0DM ZLHG] ,PDM URGNL%U\ODQWRZDNROLDQD
V]\L6DEULQ\*OHYLVVLJZDUWDMHVWFK\EDEH]PDDW\OHLOHFD\ELODQVSDWQLF]\
OHVLVWHJRLVNDOLVWHJR.DHGZHQ%H]WUXGXRVL JQ \E\WRFRSODQXM $OHMHVWMHGHQ
V]NRSX
$KDSRP\ ODD7ULDV0HULJROGQDUHV]FLH]DF]\QDPyZLVL R W\PRGF]HJR
QDOH DR]DF] 2GWU]H ZL FHJRLFKRG] FHJR]DSDIDNWX H &LULMHVWZ
1LOIJDDUG]LHZHZDG]\(PK\UD%DUG]RGDOHNRRGF]\QLRQ\FKWXSODQyZ
1LHXOHJDNZHVWLLPyZLD)LOLSSD H (PK\USRORZDQD&LULOO RGGDZQD
:V]\VF\V G]LOL H FKRG]LRRSROLW\F]Q\PDULD ] &LQWU L ]DZDGQL FLHOHQQHP
E G F\PSUDZQ\PG]LHG]LFWZHPG]LHZF]\Q\1LHPR QDMHGQDNZ\NOXF]\ H WX
FKRG]LQLHRSROLW\N DOHRJHQ6WDUV]HM.UZLNWyU\(PK\UFKFHZSURZDG]LGR
FHVDUVNLHMOLQLL-H OL(PK\UZLHWRFRP\PR H FKFLHE\SURURFWZR]L FLRVL Z
MHJRURG]LHDSU]\V]D.UyORZD ZLDWDXURG]LDVL Z 1LOIJDDUG]LH
3RSUDZNDZWU FLD6DEULQD*OHYLVVLJ7RQLH(PK\UWHJRFKFHOHF]
QLOIJDDUG]F\F]DURG]LHMH7\ONRRQLPRJOLZ\WURSLJHQLX ZLDGRPL(PK\URZL
MHJR]QDF]HQLH2EHFQHWXQLOIJDDUG]NLHSDQLH]HFKF ]DSHZQHWRSRWZLHUG]LL
Z\MD QLVZ URO Z LQWU\G]H
']LZLPQLHQLHZ\WU]\PDD)ULQJLOODWHQGHQFMDSD GRWURSLHQLDQLFLLQWU\J
Z GDOHNLP1LOIJDDUG]LHSRGF]DVJG\SU]HVDQNLND V]XNDVSLVNRZFyZL
]GUDMFyZ]QDF]QLHEOL HMZDVVDP\FK
8ZDJDUyZQLHEH]SR UHGQLDFRFHOQD6KHDODGH7DQFDU\LOOHRVWU\P
VSRMU]HQLHPXFLV]\DJRWRZL F VL GRULSRVW\6DEULQ ,QIRUPDFMDR6WDUV]HM
.UZLSU]HFLHNDGR1LOIJDDUGXRGQDVZV]\VWNLHSU]HVDQNLQDWRZVND]XM
&]\ E\]DSRPQLD\SDQLHR9LOJHIRUW]X"
-DQLHZF]DUQ\FKRF]DFK6DEULQ\]DSRQ QDVHNXQG RJLH QLHQDZL FL-D
QLH]DSRPQLDDP
3U]\MG]LHQDQLHJRF]DV]RZURJRE\VQ D] EDPL.HLUD0HW]$OHQDUD]LH
-HGHQ]WRZDU]\V] F\FK'LMNVWU]HDJHQWyZ]DMU]DGRORFKXFRIQ VL
JZDWRZQLHRSDURPXUL]EODGMDNSyWQRZ\JO GDMDNE\]DPRPHQWPLD
]HPGOH'LMNVWUD]DQRWRZDZSDPL FLE\SU]HQLH GHOLNDFLNDGRSUDF\
SDSLHUNRZHM$OHJG\VDP]DMU]DGRFHOLQDW\FKPLDVW]PLHQL]GDQLH R GHN
SRGMHFKDPXGRJDUGD1LHPyJMHGQDNVNRPSURPLWRZDVL SU]HG
SRGZDGQ\PL1LHVSLHV] F VL Z\M ]NLHV]HQLSHUIXPRZDQ FKXVWN
SU]\R \ZV]\M GRQRVDLXVWSRFK\OLVL QDGQDJLPL]ZRNDPLOH F\PLQD
NDPLHQQHMSRVDG]FH
%U]XFKLPDFLFDUR]FL WH]GLDJQR]RZDVLO F VL QDVSRNyML]LPQ\WRQ
%DUG]RZSUDZQLHU N FKLUXUJD=G]LHZF]\QNLZ\M WRSyG*G\WRURELRQR \D
$OHQLHURELRQRWHJRWXWDM:V]\VWNLHV Z WDNLPVWDQLH"/HQQHSPyZL GRFLHELH
1LHDJHQWGUJQ RGHUZDZ]URNRGWUXSD,QQ\PSRDPDQRNDUNL
]DNU FDQ JDURW 1LHE\\FL DUQH$OH]URELP\VHNFM
F]QLHLOH]QDOH]LRQR"
2SUyF]WHMWXWDMF]WHU\ DGQHMQLHXGDRVL ]LGHQW\ILNRZD
1LHSUDZGD]DSU]HF]\]]DFKXVWNL'LMNVWUD-DMX ]G \HP]LGHQW\ILNRZD
W WXWDM7R-ROLHQDMPRGV]DFyUNDJUDID/DQLHUD7DNWyUDURNWHPXSU]HSDGDEH]
ZLH FL5]XF RNLHPQDSR]RVWDH
1LHNWyUHRJLH QDGWUDZLSRZLHG]LD/HQQHS&L NRE G]LHSR]QD$OH
SDQLHSUyF]WHJR=QDOH OL P\
*DGDMSU]HVWD VL M ND
:WDPWHMVWXGQLDJHQWZVND]D]LHM F Z SRGRG]HG]LXU V NR FL'X R
NR FL1LH]G \OL P\Z\GRE\L]EDGDDOHJRZ VWDZL H ZV]\VWNRWRE G
NR FLPRG\FKG]LHZHN*G\E\WDNSRSURVLPDJLNyZPR H GDRE\VL
UR]SR]QD,SRZLDGRPLW\FKURG]LFyZNWyU]\ZFL SRV]XNXM ]DJLQLRQ\FK
FyUHN
3RG DGQ\PSR]RUHP'LMNVWUDRGZUyFLVL JZDWRZQLH$QLVRZDRW\P
FRWX]QDOH]LRQR1LNRPX$]ZDV]F]DPDJLNRP3RW\PFRWXZLG]LDHPWUDF
GRQLFK]DXIDQLH/HQQHSF]\JyUQHSR]LRP\]RVWD\GRNDGQLH]EDGDQH"1LH
RGQDOH]LRQRQLF]HJRFRPRJRE\SRPyFZSRV]XNLZDQLDFK"
1LF]HJRSDQLH/HQQHSRSX FLJRZ *G\W\ONRGRWDURGRQDVGRQLHVLHQLH
S G]LOL P\GR]DPNXFRNR Z\VNRF]\$OHSU]\E\OL P\]DSy QR:V]\VWNR
VSRQ R2JLH R VWUDV]OLZHMPRF\0DJLF]Q\DQLFK\EL-HQRWXWDMZORFKDFK
F]DUQLH]HZV]\VWNLPSRG]LDD1LHZLHPGODF]HJR
$MDZLHP=DSRQXQLHRGSDOD9LOJHIRUW]OHF]5LHQFHDOERLQQ\WRWXPIDFNL
F]DURZQLND9LOJHIRUW]QLHSRSHQLE\E GXQLH]RVWDZLE\QDPQLFSUyF]
F]DUQHJRQDORWXQDPXUDFK7DNRQZLH H RJLH RF]\V]F]D,]DFLHUD ODG\
$QR]DFLHUDPUXNQ /HQQHS1LHPDQDZHWGRZRGX H yZ9LOJHIRUW]Z
RJyOHWXE\
6IDEU\NXMFLH]DWHPWDNLHGRZRG\'LMNVWUDRGM FKXVWN RGWZDU]\0DP
ZDVXF]\MDNVL WRUREL"-DZLHP H 9LOJHIRUW]WXE\:SRG]LHPLXRSUyF]
WUXSyZQLFQLHRFDODR"&RMHVWWDP]DW\PL HOD]Q\PLGU]ZLDPL"
3R]ZyOFLHSDQLHDJHQWZ]L ]U N SRPRFQLNDSRFKRGQL 3RND ZDP
1LHE\RZ WSOLZR FL H PDJLF]Q\]DSRQPDM F\VSRSLHOLZV]\VWNRFR
]QDMGRZDRVL Z SRG]LHPLXXORNRZDQ\E\ZD QLHWXWDMZSU]HVWURQQ\P
SRPLHV]F]HQLX]D HOD]Q\PLGU]ZLDPL% G Z]DNO FLXZ]QDF]QHMPLHU]H
]QLZHF]\WHQSODQDOHSR DULWDNE\VLOQ\LJZDWRZQ\2JLH ]Z JOLUHJD\
]DMPXM FHMHGQ ]H FLDQSRUR]VDG]DLVWRSLV]NODQHQDF]\QLD]DPLHQLZV]\VWNR
Z PLHUG] F PDV 7\PFRZSRPLHV]F]HQLXSR]RVWDRQLHQDUXV]RQHE\VWy]
EODV]DQ\PEODWHPLGZDZPXURZDQHZSRGRJ NU]HVDRG]LZDF]Q\FKNV]WDWDFK
']LZDF]Q\FKDOHQLHSR]RVWDZLDM F\FKZ WSOLZR FLFRGRSU]H]QDF]HQLD
7RMHVWWDNVNRQVWUXRZDQHSU]HNQ OLQ /HQQHSZVND]XM F NU]HVDL
]DPRFRZDQHQDQLFKXFKZ\W\E\WU]\PDQRJLZUR]ZDUFLD6]HURNLP
UR]ZDUFLX
6NXUZ\V\QZDUNQ SU]H]]DFL QL WH] E\'LMNVWUD&KROHUQ\VNXUZ\V\Q
: FLHNXSRGGUHZQLDQ\PIRWHOHPNRQW\QXRZDFLFKRDJHQW]QDOH OL P\
ODG\NUZLNDXLXU\Q\6WDORZ\IRWHOMHVWQRZLXWNLFK\EDQLJG\QLHX \ZDQ\1LH
ZLHPFRRW\PV G]L
$MDZLHPSRZLHG]LD'LMNVWUD7HQVWDORZ\V]\NRZDQ\E\GODNRJR
VSHFMDOQHJR.RJR NRJR9LOJHIRUW]SRGHMU]HZDRVSHFMDOQH]GROQR FL
:FDOHQLHOHNFHZD 'LMNVWU\LMHJRZ\ZLDGXSRZLHG]LDD6KHDODGH
7DQYFDUYLOOH:LHP H RGQDOH]LHQLH9LOJHIRUW]DWRNZHVWL F]DVX3RPLMDM F
MHGQDNPRW\ZRVRELVWHM]HPVW\]GDM F\VL SDVMRQRZDQLHNWyUH]SD SR]ZRO
VRELH]DXZD \ H ZFDOHQLHMHVWSHZQH H WR9LOJHIRUW]PD&LUL
-H HOLQLH9LOJHIRUW]WRNWRM PD"%\DQDZ\VSLH DGQD]QDVMDNUR]XPLHP
QLHWHOHSRUWRZDDMHMVWDPW G1LHPDMHM'LMNVWUDDQL DGHQ]NUyOyZZLHP\WR$
Z JUX]DFK:LH \ 0HZ\QLHRGQDOH]LRQRMHMFLDD
7RU/DUDSRZLHG]LDDZROQR,G (PHDQNU\DQLHJG\ EDUG]RVLOQ\SRUWDO
&]\Z\NOXF]DFLH H G]LHZF]\QDXFLHND]7KDQHGGW\PSRUWDOHP"
<HQQHIHU]DNU\DRF]\U] VDPLZSLDSD]QRNFLHZJRZ\VILQNVyZQDSRU F]DFK
IRWHOD7\ONRVSRNRMQLHSRP\ ODD7\ONRVSRNRMQLH3RF]XDQDVRELHZ]URN
0DUJDULW\DOHQLHSRGQRVLDJRZ\
-H HOL&LULZHV]DZWHOHSRUW]7RU/DUDSRZLHG]LDD]PLHQLRQ\PQLHFR
JRVHPUHNWRUND$UHWX]\WRREDZLDPVL H RQDV]\FKSODQDFKLSURMHNWDFK
PR HP\]DSRPQLH2EDZLDPVL H PR HP\MX &LULQLJG\ZL FHMQLH]REDF]\
1LHLVWQLHM F\MX SRUWDO:LH \ 0HZ\E\XV]NRG]RQ\Z\SDF]RQ\=DEyMF]\
2F]\PP\WXPyZLP\"Z\EXFKQ D6DEULQD HE\ZRJyOHZ\NU\WHOHSRUW
Z ZLH \ HE\ZRJyOHPyFJR]REDF]\WU]HEDE\RX \PDJLLF]ZDUWHJR
VWRSQLD"$GRXUXFKRPLHQLDSRUWDOXSRWU]HEDE\R]GROQR FLDUF\PLVWU]RZVNLFK
1LHZLHPF]\9LOJHIRUW]]GRDE\WHJRGRNRQDDFRGRSLHURMDND SL WQDVWROHWQLD
WHM)DOFHWDNLHJRVLHG]L
0R H FR WDNLHJRFRLZZDV]DGUZL6WHIDQ6NHOOHQ&KRFLD QLH
Z\EDF]FLH:\ZV]DNQLHELHU]HFLHSLHQL G]\]D]DELMDQLHOHF]]D ZLDGF]RQH
XVXJL3UDZG]LZ\]ZDVU]HPLH OQLN%RQKDUWVROLGQ\NDZDSURIHVMRQDD)DFK
MDNND G\LQQ\"5RERWDGRRGZDOHQLD"3DF ]DWRD \WU]HED"+ "
RZFDQDJUyGSDWU]\QDQLHJRGXJR7DNGXJRD ] ZDUJ3XV]F]\ND]QLN
ZUHV]FLHX PLHV]HN
, FLHSRZLHG]LD \WU]HED-HGHQ]DUDELDQDWR \FLHW\PFRXPLH'UXJL
URELWRFRPXVL: G\PQLHSRV]F] FLRVL Z \FLXMDNPDRNWyUHPX
U]HPLH OQLNRZLFK\ED H QLHNWyUHMNXUZLH3DF PL]DU]HPLRVRNUyUHV]F]HU]HL
SUDZG]LZLHOXEL
7HOHSRUWRZDDVL VWZLHUG]LDFKRGQRLEH]HPRFML)UDQFHVFD)LQGDEDLUJG\
W\ONRXVSRNRLRVL Z\ZRDQH]QLNQL FLHP<HQQHIHU]DPLHV]DQLH1LHPDVL FR
JRU F]NRZDPRMHSDQLH7HUD]MX QLFQDWRQLHSRUDG]LP\-HVW]DGDOHNR7RPyM
E G3RGHMU]HZDDP H MHMREV\GLDQHZDJZLD]GDPDVNXMHHFKR]DNO
-DNRQDWR]URELDFKROHUDMDVQD"ZU]DVQ D)LOLSSD(FKRPRJDVWXPLWR
QLHMHVWWUXGQH$OHMDNLPFXGHPRWZRU]\DVRELHSRUWDO"0RQWHFDOYRPDEORNDG
1LJG\MHMQLHOXELDPZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPL6KHDODGH7DQFDUULOOH1LJG\QLH
SRFKZDODDPMHMVW\OX \FLD$OHQLJG\QLHNZHVWLRQRZDDPMHM]GROQR FL
2QDZ\V]F]HNDZV]\VWNRUR]GDUDVL 6DEULQD*OHYLVVLJ:V]\VWNRROR \
3ROHFLZSURVW
%]GXUDSU]HUZDD \ZR7ULVV0HULJROGSDWU] F QD)UDQFHVN L ,G (PHDQ
<HQQHIHUQLH]GUDG]LQDV1LHGODWHJRVW G XFLHNDE\QDV]GUDG]L
7ULVVPDUDFM SRSDUDM 0DUJDULWD/DX[$QWIOOH-DZLHPGODF]HJRRQD
XFLHNDNRJRFKFHUDWRZD-DZLG]LDDPMHRELHM L &LULUD]HP,ZV]\VWNR
UR]XPLHP
$MDQLFQLHUR]XPLHPZU]DVQ D6DEULQDL]QRZX]URELRVL JR QR
$VVLUHYDU$QDKLGQDFK\OLDVL NXSU]\MDFLyFH
1LHS\WDPGODF]HJRWR]URELD V]HSQ D1LHS\WDPMDNWR]URELD 3\WDP
GRN G"
)ULQJLOOD9LJRX PLHFKQ DVL QLH]QDF]QLHJDV]F] F SDOFDPLU]H ELRQ JRZ
VILQNVDQDSRU F]\IRWHOD
$VN G MDPRJ ZLHG]LHRGV]HSQ D]NWyUHJRZ\EU]H D SRFKRG] WH
RVWU\JL"
5R]G]LD
,WOLQDZD FLZLH,WKOLQQH$HJOLFyUND$HXHQLHQOHJHQGDUQDHOILDX]GURZLFLHOND
DVWUROR NDLZUy ELWNDV\Q FD]ZLHV]F]EZUy E LSURURFWZ]NWyU\FK
QDMV\QQLHMV] MHVW$HQ,WKOLQQHVSHDWK3U]HSRZLHGQLD,WLOLQ\:LHORNURWQLH
VSLV\ZDQDLZPQRJLFKIRUPDFKRGGDZDQD3U]HSRZLHGQLDZUy Q\FKRNUHVDFK
ZLHON VL FLHV]\DSRSXODUQR FL DNRPHQWDU]HNOXF]HLZ\MD QLHQLDGRQLHM
GR F]DQHGRVWRVRZ\ZD\WHNVWGRELH F\FKZ\GDU]H FRXPDFQLDRSU]HNRQDQLH
R ZLHONLPMDVQRZLG]WZLH:V]F]HJyOQR FLPQLHPDVL H SU]HSRZLHG]LDD,:RMQ\
3yQRFQH:LHONLH=DUD]\LNUZDZ :RMQ 'ZyFK
-HGQRUR FyZLQDMD]G+DDNyZ-DVQRZLG]LHPLDDWH /
REVHUZRZDQHRGNR FD;,,,Z]PLDQ\NOLPDW\F]QH%LDH=LPQRNWyUH]DERERQ
]DZV]H]DSRF] WHNNR FD ZLDWDXZD DL F]\]ZLHV]F]RQ\PQDGHM FLHP
1LV]F]\FLHONLRE7HQ HSDVVXV]3U]HSRZLHGQL,GDDVXPSWGRQLHVDZQ\FK
SRORZD QDF]DURZQLFHLSU]\F]\QLVL GR PLHUFLZLHOXQLHZLDVWL
G]LHZF] W QLHV]F] VQ\FK]DLQNDUQDFM 1LV]F]\FLHONLXZD DQ\FK']L / XZD DQD
MHVWSU]H]OLF]Q\FKEDGDF]\]DSRVWDOHJHQGRZ DSURURFWZD]DFDNLHP
ZVSyF]H QLHVIDEU\NRZDQ\DSRNU\ILSU]HELHJHOLWHUDFNLHV]DOELHUVWZR
(IIHQEHUJL7DOERW
(QF\FORSDHGLD0D[LPD0XQGLWRP;
5R]G]LDVLyGP\
3RVLDQH]LDUQRQLHSRNRMXLQLHSHZQR FL]DNLHNRZDRMHGQDNLZ]HV]R*G\
]DWU]\PDOLVL QDQRFOHJDWPRVIHUDZFL E\DFL NDLQDSL WDQLHUR]DGRZDDMHM
QDZHWVWU]HORQDSU]H]0LOY QDGU]HF]N WXVWDR PLRIXQWRZDFK\EDJ EHPLNOD
NWyU REOHSLOLJOLQ XSLHNOLL]MHGOLRJU\]DM F GRF]\VWHQDMPQLHMV] QDZHW
NRVWHF]N =DELOLJyGDOHQLHSRNyMSR]RVWD5R]PRZDQLHNOHLDVL SRPLPR
W\WDQLF]Q\FKZ\VLNyZ-DVNUD*DGDQLHSRHW\VWDRVL PRQRORJLHPWDNZ\UD QLH
RF]\ZLVW\P H ZUHV]FLHRQVDPWH WH ]DXZD \L]DPNQ VL 3DQXM F SU]\
RJQLVNXJURERZ FLV] ]DNyFDMHG\QLHFKU] VW XWHJRSU]H]NRQLHVLDQD
0LPRSy QHMSRU\QLNWMHGQDNQLHVSRVRELVL MDNR GRVQX0LOYDJU]DDZRG
Z ]DZLHV]RQ\PQDGRJQLHPNRFLRNXLUR]SURVWRZ\ZDDQDGSDU ]PL WHORWNL
VWU]D&DKLUUHSHURZD]HUZDQ NODPU EXWD*HUDOWVWUXJDSDW\N$5HJLVZRG]L
RF]DPLSRZV]\VWNLFKSRNROHL
1RGREU]HSRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLH:LG] H WRQLHXQLNQLRQH=GDMHVL H MX
GDZQRSRZLQLHQHPE\ZDPZ\MD QLSHZQHVSUDZ\
1LNWRGFLHELHWHJRQLHZ\PDJD*HUDOWZU]XFLGRRJQLVNDGXJRLQDPL WQLH
VWUXJDQ\NRHNLSRGQLyVJRZ -DQLHSRWU]HEXM WZRLFKZ\MD QLH -HVWHP
W\SHPVWDURPRGQ\PJG\Z\FL JDPGRNRJR U N L DNFHSWXM MDNRNRPSDQDWH
GODPQLH]QDF]\ZL FHMQL NRQWUDNW]DZDUW\ZSU]\WRPQR FLQRWDULXV]D
0LOF]DF]DVMDNL
3R]QDHPSHZQ ZDPSLUN 0RJRWRE\LFK\EDE\RFR SRZD QHJR
3U]HVWDHPV]DOH$OHQLHQDGXJR2GHV]DRGHPQLH$MD]DF] HPSLZ
GZyMQDVyE5R]SDF] DOMDNZLHFLHWRGRVNRQDHXVSUDZLHGOLZLHQLD
:V]\VWNLPVL Z\GDMH H UR]XPLHM 1DZHWPQLHZ\GDZDRVL H UR]XPLHP
$ Z\ F]QLHGRSDVRZ\ZDHPWHRUL GRSUDNW\NL1XG] ZDV"-X NR F]
=DF] HPZUHV]FLHURELU]HF]\QLHGRSXV]F]DOQHDEVROXWQLHQLHDNFHSWRZDOQH
WDNLHMDNLFKQLHUREL DGHQZDPSLU=DF] HPODWDSRSLMDQHPX.WyUHM QRF\
FKRSDNLSRVDOLPQLHGRZVLSRNUHZDMDFK\ELHPG]LHZF]\Q\LG FHMNXVWXGQL]
UR]S GXZ\U Q HPZFHPEURZLQ &KRSLPDRPQLHQLH]DWXNOLQDV]F] FLH
QLHZLHG]LHOLMDNVL GRWHJR]DEUD3RG]LXUDZLOLPQLHNRNDPLRGU EDOLJRZ
REODOLZRG ZL FRQ L ]DNRSDOL3U]HGVWDZLDQHVRELHMDNF]XHPVL SR
SU]HEXG]HQLX"
3U]HGVWDZLDP\SRZLHG]LDD0LOYDRJO GDM F VWU]D :V]\VF\SRSDWU]\OLQD
QL G]LZQLHXF]QLF]NDFKU] NQ DLRGZUyFLDJRZ 5HJLVX PLHFKQ VL
QLH]QDF]QLH
-X NR F] SRZLHG]LD:JURELHPLDHPGR F]DVXQD]DVWDQRZLHQLHVL
QDGVRE
'R "VS\WD*HUDOW-DNZLHOH"
5HJLVVSRMU]DQDQLHJR
&LHNDZR SURIHVMRQDOQD"2NRRSL G]LHVL FLXODW*G\]UHJHQHURZDHPVL
SRVWDQRZLHPZ]L VL Z JDU DWZRQLHE\RDOHSRUDG]LHPVRELH2GWDPWHJR
F]DVXQLHSLM
:RJyOH"-DVNLHU]DM NQ VL DOHFLHNDZR SU]HPRJD:RJyOH"1LJG\"
3U]HFLH
-DVNLHU*HUDOWXQLyVOHNNREUZL2SDQXMVL ,]DVWDQyZ:PLOF]HQLX
3U]HSUDV]DPEXUNQ SRHWD
1LHSU]HSUDV]DMU]HNSRMHGQDZF]RZDPSLU$W\*HUDOWQLHVWURIXMJR
5R]XPLHPMHJRFLHNDZR -DDGRNDGQLHMELRU F MDLPyMPLWXRVDELDP\
ZV]\VWNLHMHJROXG]NLHO NL7UXGQRZ\PDJDRGF]RZLHNDE\Z\]E\VL O NyZ
/ NLSHQL Z SV\FKLFHF]RZLHNDURO QLHPQLHMZD Q RGZV]\VWNLFKSR]RVWD\FK
VWDQyZHPRFMRQDOQ\FK3V\FKLNDSR]EDZLRQDO NyZE\DE\SV\FKLN NDOHN
:\VWDZVRELHSRZLHG]LD-DVNLHURG]\VNXM F NRQWHQDQV H QLHEXG]LV]ZH
PQLH]JUR]\%\E\PZL F NDOHN "
*HUDOWSU]H]FKZLO V G]L H 5HJLV]DGHPRQVWUXMH] E\LXOHF]\-DVNUD]
PQLHPDQHJRNDOHFWZDDOHP\OLVL :DPSLUQLHPLDLQNOLQDFMLGRWHDWUDOQ\FK
JHVWyZ
0yZLHPRO NDFK]DNRU]HQLRQ\FKZ ZLDGRPR FLLSRG ZLDGRPR FL
Z\MD QLVSRNRMQLH1LHFKFL QLHGRWNQLHPHWDIRUDDOHZURQDQLHERLVL
]DZLHV]RQ\FKQDNLMXNDSHOXV]DLNDSRW\JG\MX SU]HDPLHO N LXVL G]LH$OHJG\
ZLDWUV]DUSQLHVWUDFKHPSWDN]DUHDJXMHXFLHF]N
=DFKRZDQLHZURQ\WXPDF]\ZDONDRE\W]DXZD \]FLHPQR FL&DKLU
7XPDF]\VUDF]\SDUVNQ D0LO\D1LHVWUDFKDZURQDVL ERLLQRF]HNDER
F]HNNDPLH PDLVWU]D\QDQL
:DONDRE\WSU]\WDNQ *HUDOW7\OH H ZOXG]NLPQLHZURQLPZ\GDQLD
VXPPDFXPODXGH
:ZDV]\P ZLHFLHSR.RQLXQNFML6IHU]RVWDRRNRRW\VL FDGZXVWXZ\ V]\FK
ZDPSLUyZ&DNRZLW\FKDEVW\QHQWyZERRSUyF]PQLHMHVWWDNLFKQLHPDR
UyZQRZD \ OLF]EDSLM F\FKSRQDGPLDU MDNMDVZHJRF]DVX8 UHGQLDM F
VWDW\VW\F]Q\ZDPSLUSLMHZND G SHQL NVL \FDERSHQLDMHVWGODQDV ZL WHP
NWyUH]Z\NOL P\KPPPREOHZD6SURZDG]DM F U]HF]GROXG]NLHJR
NDOHQGDU]DLSU]\MPXM F GZDQD FLHSHQLZURNXRWU]\PXMHP\WHRUHW\F]Q OLF]E
F]WHUQDVWXW\VL F\F]WHU\VWXXN V]RQ\FKOXG]LURF]QLH2G.RQLXQNFMLSRQRZQLH
OLF] F ZHGXJZDV]HMUDFKXE\F]DVXPLQ RRNRRW\VL FDSL FLXVHWODW=UH]XOWDWX
SURVWHJRPQR HQLDZ\QLND H ZFKZLOLREHFQHMQD ZLHFLHZLQQRWHRUHW\F]QLH
HJ]\VWRZDGZDG]LH FLDMHGHQPLOLRQyZV]H VHWW\VL F\ZDPSLUyZ-H OL]D
UDFKXQHNX]XSHQLRSU]\URVWJHRPHWU\F]Q\
'R ZHVWFKQ -DVNLHU1LHPDPDEDNXVDDOHOLF]E Z\REUD DPVRELH$
UDF]HMQLHZ\REUD DP=QDF]\]DUD DQLHZDPSLU\]PHPWRE]GXUDLZ\P\V
']L NXM 5HJLVXNRQLVL 3U]HMG P\GRQDVW SQHJRPLWXNWyU\JRVL
ZDPSLUWRF]RZLHNNWyU\XPDUDOHQLHFDNLHP:JURELHQLHJQLMHLQLHREUDFDZ
SURFK/H \ VRELHZPRJLOH ZLH XWNLLUXPLDQ\JRWyZGRZ\M FLDLN VDQLD6N G
ELHU]HVL WDNLPLW-H OLQLH]ZDV]HMSRG ZLDGRPHMDLUUDFMRQDOQHMRGUD]\ZREHF
F]FLJRGQ\FK]PDU\FK"2WDF]DFLH]PDU\FKF]FL L SDPL FL PDU]\FLHR
QLH PLHUWHOQR FLZZDV]\FKPLWDFKLOHJHQGDFKFRLUXV]NWR ]PDUWZ\FKZVWDMH
]Z\FL D PLHU$OHJG\E\ZDV]F]FLJRGQ\QLHERV]F]\NSUDG]LDGHNIDNW\F]QLH
Z\OD]QDJOH]JUREXL]D GDSLZDSRZVWDDE\SDQLND,QLHG]LZL VL 0DWHULD
RUJDQLF]QDZNWyUHMXVWDM SURFHV\ \FLRZHXOHJDQLHSU]\MHPQLHREMDZLDM FHMVL
GHJUDGDFML PLHUG]LUR]S\ZDVL Z PD 1LH PLHUWHOQ\GXFKQLHRG]RZQ\
HOHPHQWZDV]\FKPLWyZ]HZVWU WHPSRU]XFD PLHUG] F SDGOLQ L XODWXMH-HVW
F]\VW\PR QDVSRNRMQLHJRF]FL:\P\ OLOL FLHMHGQDNWDNLRGUD DM F\URG]DM
GXFKDNWyU\QLHRGODWXMHQLHRSXV]F]D]HZRNDEDQLHFKFHQDZHW PLHUG]LH7R
ZVWU WQHLPHVDWVV-
6-ILQH \Z\XPDU\WRGODZDVQDMREU]\GOLZV]D]
REU]\GOLZ\FKDQRPDOLL-DNL NUHW\QXNXQDZHWWHUPLQPDUWZLDNNWyU\PWDN
FK WQLHQDVREGDU]DFLH
/XG]LHX PLHFKQ VL OHNNR*HUDOWV UDV SU\PLW\ZQ L ]DERERQQ 7UXGQR
LPZSHQL]UR]XPLHLZD FLZLHQD]ZDLVWRW NWyUD]PDUWZ\FKZVWDMHFKR
SRG]LXUDZLRQRM NRNDPLSR]EDZLRQRJRZ\L]DNRSDQRQDSL G]LHVL W ODWZ
]LHPL
$QRWUXGQRZVDPHMU]HF]\ZDPSLUQLHSU]HM VL V]\GHUVWZHP:DV]D
]PXWRZDQDUDVDUHJHQHUXMHSD]QRNFLHZRV\LQDVNyUHNQLH]GROQDMHVWZV]DN H
]DDNFHSWRZDIDNWX H LVWQLHM UDV\SRGW\PZ]JO GHPGRVNRQDOV]H1LH]GROQR
WDQLHZ\QLNDMHGQDN]SU\PLW\ZL]PX:U F]SU]HFLZQLH]HJRFHQWU\]PXL
SU]HNRQDQLDRZDVQHMGRVNRQDR FL&R FRMHVWRGZDVGRVNRQDOV]HPXVLE\
REU]\GOLZ DEHUUDFM $REU]\GOLZHDEHUUDFMHZSLVXMHVL GRPLWyZ:FHODFK
VRFMRORJLF]Q\FK
*yZQR]WHJRZV]\VWNLHJRUR]XPLHPR]QDMPLDVSRNRMQLH0LOYDRGJDUQLDM F
ZRV\]F]RDEU]HFKZ VWU]D\: G\SRMPXM H REDMNDFKJDGDFLHDEDMNL
SU]HGHLMD]QDPFKRFLD HPJXSLDG]LHZND]ODVX:LHOFHPQLHG]LZXMH H W\VL
ZFDOHVR FDQLHO NDV]5HJLV:EDMNDFKVLRQFHZDPSLUDQDSRSLySDOL0DPOLL
QDMPQLHMZD Q\-HVWWRPLWNWyU\SRG\NWRZD\ZDPZDV]HIRELHVHNVXDOQH
&DKLUSDUVNQ ]FLFKD
0LW]RVWDZLHPQDNRQLHF5HJLV]PLHU]\JRZ]URNLHPLVDPWDNWRZQLHQLH
QDSRP\NDE\PRQLPWR*HUDOWZ\]ZDPQLHQLHRV]F] G] JRZDP]DWHP
/XG PLQDMVLOQLHMSRZRGXM O NLRSRGR X VHNVXDOQ\P']LHZLFDRPGOHZDM FDZ
X FLVNXVV FHJRM ZDPSLUDPRG]LHQLDV]HNZ\GDQ\QDSDVWZ ZVWU WQ\FK
SUDNW\NZDPSLUNLE G] FHMXVWDPLSRMHJRFLHOH7DNWRVRELHZ\REUD DFLH*ZDW
RUDOQ\:DPSLUSDUDOL XMHRILDU VWUDFKHPL]PXV]DM GRVHNVXRUDOQHJR&]\
UDF]HMREU]\GOLZHMSDURGLLVHNVXRUDOQHJR$WDNLVHNVZ\NOXF]DM F\ZV]DN
SURNUHDFM MHVWF]\P ZVWU WQ\P
0yZ]DVLHELHPUXNQ :LHG PLQ
$NWXNRURQRZDQ\QLHSURNUHDFM DOHUR]NRV] L PLHUFL NRQW\QXRZD5HJLV
8F]\QLOL FLH]WHJR]RZURJLPLW6DPLSRG ZLDGRPLHPDU]\FLHRF]\P WDNLP
DOHZ]GUDJDFLHVL E\FR WDNLHJRGDSDUWQHURZLOXESDUWQHUFH5RELWRZL F ]D
ZDVyZPLWRORJLF]Q\ZDPSLUXUDVWDM F SU]H]WRGRIDVF\QXM FHJRV\PEROX]D
$QLHPyZLDP"ZU]DVQ D0LOYDJG\W\ONR-DVNLHUVNR F]\MHMREMD QLDR
FRV]R5HJLVRZL1LFMHQRRW\P0 GU]H]DF]\QDM D]DZ G\QDGXSLHNR F]
7U ELHQLH XUDZLSRZROLFLFKRZRGGDOL
1D]DMXWU]SU]\SRPQLDVRELH:LHG PLQZ]QDF]QLHSRSUDZLRQ\FKQDVWURMDFK
Z\UXV]\OL P\QDV]ODN,ZWHG\FDNLHPQLHVSRG]LDQLH]QRZXGR FLJQ DQDV
ZRMQD
3RGUy RZDOLSU]H]SRUR QL W\G]LNLPERUHPSUDNW\F]QLHEH]OXGQ\L
VWUDWHJLF]QLHPDRZD Q\NUDMQLHPRJ F\Q FLQDMH]GQLNyZ&KRFLD GR
1LOIJDDUGXE\REOLVNRDRG]LHPFHVDUVNLFKRGG]LHODDLFKW\ONRSD :LHONLHM
-DUXJLE\DWRUXELH QLHDWZDGRSRNRQDQLD7\PZL NV]HE\RLFK]DVNRF]HQLH
:RMQDREMDZLDVL Z VSRVyEPQLHMVSHNWDNXODUQ\QL Z %UXJJHL6RGGHQJG]LH
QRFDPLKRU\]RQWMD QLDRGXQD]DGQLDVXS\F]DUQHJRG\PXSU]HNUH OD\E NLW
7XZ$QJUHQLHQLHE\RWDNZLGRZLVNRZR%\RJRU]HM1DJOH]REDF]\OLVWDGR
ZURQ]G]LNLPNUDNDQLHPNU FHQDGODVHPDZNUyWFHSRWHPQDWNQ OLVL QD
WUXS\&KRREGDUWH]RG]LH \ LQLHPR OLZHGR]LGHQW\ILNRZDQLD]ZRNLQRVL\
QLHRP\OQHLZ\UD QH ODG\EDUG]RJZDWRZQHM PLHUFL/XG]LHFL]RVWDOL]DELFLZ
ERMX,QLHW\ONR:L NV]R WUXSyZOH DDZ]DUR ODFKDOHQLHNWyUHPDNDEU\F]QLH
RNDOHF]RQHZLVLD\]DU FHOXE]DQRJLQDJD ]LDFKGU]HZZ\FL JD\]Z JORQH
NR F]\Q\]Z\JD QL W\FKVWRVyZVWHUF]D\QDSDODFK, PLHUG]LD\&D\$QJUHQ
]DF] QDJOH PLHUG]LHSRWZRUQ\PZVWU WQ\PRGRUHPEDUEDU]\ VWZD
1LHWUZDRGXJRDPXVLHOLMX WDLVL Z MDUDFKLFKDV]F]DFKER]SUDZDLOHZD
] SU]RGXL]W\X]LHPLDUR]KXF]DODVL RGNRS\WNDZDOHU\MVNLFKNRQLDFRUD]WR
LQQHRGG]LD\PLMD\LFKNU\MyZN Z]ELMDM F NXU]
=QRZXNU FLJRZ -DVNLHU=QRZXQLHZLHP\NWRELMHNRJRLGODF]HJR
=QRZXQLHZLHP\NWRMHVW]DQDPLDNWRSU]HGQDPLNWRZMDNLPNLHUXQNX
]PLHU]D.WRMHVWZQDWDUFLXDNWRZRGZURFLH=DUD]DQLHFKWRSRUZLH1LH
SDPL WDPF]\PyZLHPZDPWRMX DOHVWZLHUG]DP H ZRMQD]DZV]HSU]\SRPLQD
EXUGHORJDUQL W\SR DUHP
0yZLH SU]HUZD*HUDOW'REU VHWN UD]\
2FRWXWDMVL ELM " SRHWDVSOXQ VRF]\ FLH2MDRZFHLSLDFK\"1LF]\P
ZL FHMZV]DN H QLHG\VSRQXMHWDSU]HSL NQDNUDLQD
: UyGW\FKFROH HOLZNU]DFKSRZLHG]LDD0LOYDE\\HOI\.RPDQGD
6FRLD
WDHOFKRG] W G\]DZV]HFKRG]L\7 G\GURJDLPZ\SDGDJG\RFKRWQLNL]
'RO%ODWKDQQDL*yU6LQ\FKFL JQ GR7HPHULL.WR LPW GURJ ]DJURG]LFKFH
7DNVRELHP\ O
1LHMHVWZ\NOXF]RQHSU]\]QD5HJLV H WHPHUVNLHZRMVNRURELWXREDZ\QD
:LHZLyUNL$OH]DGX R FR WHJRZRMVNDZRNROLF\3RGHMU]HZDP H
1LOIJDDUGF]\F\SU]HV]OLMHGQDN-DUXJ
7H WDNSRGHMU]HZDPVNU]\ZLVL OHNNRZLHG PLQSDWU] F QD]DFKRZXM FHJR
NDPLHQQHREOLF]H&DKLUD7UXS\NWyUHZLG]LHOL P\UDQRQRVL\ ODG\
QLOIJDDUG]NLHJRVSRVREXZRMRZDQLD
-HGQLRGGUXJLFKQLHOHSVLZDUNQ D0LOYDQLHVSRG]LDQLHELRU F PRGHJR
1LOIJDDUGF]\NDZREURQ $QD&DKLUDRF]XQLHNR ER FLHWHUD]REDMMHGQDN D
SU]HG]LZQ GRO ] F]HQL-HPX PLHUJG\&]DUQ\PZDS\ZSDGQLHDW\
QLHGDZQR7HPHUF]\NRP]HVWU\F]NDVL XUZD3Uy QRWHG\GRFLHNDMDNLHZRMVNR
]DQDPLMDNLHSU]HGQDPLNWyU]\VZRLNWyU]\FXG]\NWyU]\GREU]\DNWyU]\ OL
1\QLHZV]\VF\QDVLWRZVSyOQLQLHGUXJRZLH]DMHGQRMDNLHEDUZ\QRV]
0DV]UDFM
&LHNDZHU]HNL-DVNLHUJG\QDVW SQHJRGQLD]QRZXXWDLOLVL Z MDU]H
SU]HF]HNXM F NROHMQ NDZDONDG :RMVNRFZDXMHSRZ]JyU]DFKD ]LHPLDGXGQL
D ]GRXRG-DUXJLV\FKDVLHNLHU\'UZDOHU EL ODVMDNJG\E\QLJG\QLF
6\V]\FLH"
0R H WRQLHGUZDOH]DVWDQRZLVL &DKLU0R H WRWH ZRMVNR"-DNLH
VDSHUVNLHURERW\"
1LHWRGUZDOHVWZLHUG]L5HJLV1DMZ\UD QLHMQLFQLHMHVWZVWDQLHSU]HUZD
HNVSORDWDFMLDQJUH VNLHJR]RWD
-DNLHJR]RWD"
3U]\MU]\MFLHVL W\PGU]HZRPZDPSLUSRUD]NROHMQ\SU]\EUDSHHQ
Z\ V]R FLWRQZV]\VWNRZLHG] FHJRP GUFDSRXF]DM FHJRPDOXF]NLFKL
QLHUR]JDUQL W\FK7RQWDNL]GDU]DRPXVL SU]\ELHUDGR F] VWRFRWURFK
*HUDOWD]R FLR
7HGU]HZDSRZWyU]\5HJLVWRFHGU\MDZRU\LVRVQ\DQJUHQVNLH%DUG]R
FHQQ\PDWHULD:V] G]LHV WXELQGXJL]NWyU\FKVSDZLDVL SQLHZGyU]HNL
:V] G]LHV Z\U E\DWRSRU\VWXNDM G]LH L QRF:RMQDNWyU REVHUZXMHP\L
V\V]\P\QDELHUDVHQVX1LOIJDDUGMDNZLHFLHRSDQRZDXM FLH-DUXJL&LQWU L
9HUGHQWDN H *yUQH6RGGHQ:WHMFKZLOLUyZQLH SUDZGRSRGREQLH%UXJJHLF]
'ROQHJR6RGGHQ7RR]QDF]D H VSDZLDQH]$QJUHQXGUHZQR]DRSDWUXMHMX
FHVDUVNLHWDUWDNLLVWRF]QLH3yQRFQHNUyOHVWZDSUyEXM ZL F ZVWU]\PDVSDZ
1LOIJDDUGF]\F\SU]HFLZQLHFKF E\U EDQRLVSDZLDQRMDNQDMZL FHM
$P\MDN]Z\NOHPDP\SHFKDSRNLZDJRZ -DVNLHU%RQDPWU]HEDQD
&DHG'KXDNXUDWQLHSU]H]6DP URGHN$QJUHQXLWHMGUHZQLDQHMZRMQ\1LHPD
FKROHUDLQQHMGURJL"
DZDQJDUG]LHLE G PLDEDF]HQLHQDZV]\VWNR1DSU]HJQLHSQLHNXS\
ZRGRURVWyZNU]DNLN S\WUDZUR OLQ\QDZHWRUFKLGHH%RQD<VJLWKQDZHW
RUFKLGHDF]DVDPLW\ONRZ\JO GDQDNZLDWZU]HF]\ZLVWR FLMHVWMDGRZLW\P
NUDERSDM NLHP7U]HEDE G]LHWU]\PD-DVNUDNUyWNRSLOQRZDE\F]HJR QLH
GRWNQ 7\PEDUG]LHM H QLHEUDNXMHWDPUR OLQOXEL F\FKX]XSHQLDFKORURILORZ
GLHW NDZDNLHPPL VD7DNLFKNWyU\FKS G\ZNRQWDNFLH]HVNyU G]LDDM UyZQLH
VNXWHF]QLHMDNMDGNUDERSDM ND1RLJD]RF]\ZL FLH7UXM F\RSDU7U]HED
SRP\ OHR]DVRQDFKQDXVWDLQRV
-DN H ZL F"5HJLVZ\UZDJR]]DP\ OHQLD$NFHSWXMHV]SODQ"
$NFHSWXM 5XV]DMP\
&R PQLHZyZF]DVWNQ RSU]\SRPQLDVRELHZLHG PLQE\QLHPyZLUHV]FLH
NRPSDQLLRSURMHNFLHSU]HSUDZ\SU]H]<VJLWK HE\SRSURVL5HJLVDE\WH VL
W\PQLHFKZDOL6DPQLHZLHPGODF]HJRVL RFL JDHP']LVLDMJG\ZV]\VWNR
UyZQRLWRWDOQLHVL SRSLHSU]\RPyJE\PVRELHZPDZLD H ]ZUyFLHPXZDJ QD
]DFKRZDQLH0LOY\1DSUREOHP\NWyUHPLHZDD1DHZLGHQWQHREMDZ\$OHWRQLH
E\DE\SUDZGD1LF]HJRQLH]DXZD \HPDWRFR]DXZD \HP]OHNFHZD \HP
-DNEDZDQ,MHFKDOL P\QDGDOQDZVFKyGRFL JDM F VL ]HVNU FHQLHPNXEDJQRP
=GUXJLHMVWURQ\GREU]H H VL RFL JDOL P\SRP\ ODGRE\ZDM F PLHF]DL
GRW\NDM F NFLXNLHPRVWUHMMDNEU]\WZDNOLQJL*G\E\ P\ZyZF]DVRGUD]X
SRMHFKDOLNX<VJLWKQLHPLDE\PG]L WHMEURQL
2G ZLWXQLHZLG]LHOLDQLQLHV\V]HOL DGQ\FKZRMVN0LOYDMHFKDDSU]RGHP
GDOHNRSU]HGUHV]W NRPSDQLL5HJLV-DVNLHUL&DKLUJDGDOL
2E\W\ONRFLGUXLG]L]HFKFLHOLVL Z\VLOLE\QDPSRPyFZVSUDZLH&LUL
PDUWZLVL SRHWD=GDU]DRPLVL VSRW\NDGUXLGyZLZLHU]FLHPLE\\WRPUXNL
QLHX \WH]G]LZDF]DHRGOXGNL0R H ]GDU]\VL WDN H ZRJyOHQLH]HFKF ] QDPL
JDGDDFRGRSLHURX \ZDPDJLL
5HJLVSU]\SRPQLD:LHG PLQ]QDNRJR Z UyGW\FK]&DHG'KX
$QLHGDWXMHVL DE\WD]QDMRPR VSU]HGWU]\VWXOXEF]WHU\VWXODW"
-HVW]QDF]QLHPRGV]D]DSHZQL]]DJDGNRZ\PX PLHFKHPZDPSLU=UHV]W
GUXLG]LV GXJRZLHF]QL6WDOHSU]HE\ZDM QDSRZLHWU]XZ UyGSLHUZRWQHML
QLHVND RQHMSU]\URG\DWR]QDNRPLFLHZS\ZDQD]GURZLH2GG\FKDMSHQ SLHUVL
-DVNLHUZ\SHQLDMSXFDOH Q\PLSRZLHWU]HPWH E G]LHV]]GURZ\
2GWHJROH QHJRSRZLHWU]DU]HN]SU]HN VHP-DVNLHUQLHGXJRVLHU FL
SRURVQ FKROHUD3RQRFDFK QL PLVL NDUF]PDSLZRLD QLD$SLHUZRWQ
SU]\URG QLHFKSLHUZRWQD]DUD]DSRUZLHSRZ WSLHZDP]UHV]W Z MHM]EDZLHQQ\
ZS\ZQD]GURZLH]ZDV]F]DSV\FKLF]QH5]HF]HQLGUXLG]LV WXQDMOHSV]\P
SU]\NDGHPDOERZLHPV WR]G]LZDF]DOLSRP\OH F\0DM DEVROXWQHJRFK\]LDQD
SXQNFLHWHMLFKSU]\URG\LMHMRFKURQ\0DRWRUD]\E\HP ZLDGNLHPMDN]DQRVLOL
SHW\FMHGRZDG]"1LHSRORZDGU]HZQLHZ\FLQDJQRMyZHNGRU]HNQLH
VSXV]F]DLWHPXSRGREQHE]GXU\$V]F]\WHPJXSRW\E\R]MDZLHQLHV FDHMLFK
SU]\EUDQHMZMHPLRRZHZLH FHGHOHJDFMLXNUyOD(WKDLQDZ&LGDULV%\HPWDP
DNXUDW
&]HJRFKFLHOL"]DFLHNDZLVL *HUDOW
&LGDULVMDNZLHFLHWRMHGQR]NUyOHVWZZNWyU\PZL NV]R OXGQR FL
XWU]\PXMHVL ] U\ERyZVWZD'UXLG]L]D GDOLE\NUyOQDND]DX \ZDVLHFLR
3U]H]SyGQLDZ GURZDOLUD]HP]NUDVQROXGDPLLLFKSRGRSLHF]Q\PL3RWHP
=ROWDQ&KLYD\]DWU]\PDSRFKyGLZ]L ZLHG PLQDQDVWURQ
7U]HEDVL UR]VWDR ZLDGF]\NUyWNR0\ P\*HUDOWSRGM OLGHF\]M 1D
SyQRF\QLHELHV]F]\VL MX 0DKDNDPWD]D GROLQDZSURVWZJyU\ZLHG]LH'R
SU]\JyG:UDFDP\GRVZRLFK3RGJyU &DUERQ
5R]XPLHP
0LR H FKFHV]UR]XPLH \F] FLV]F] FLDWRELHLWZRMHMNRPSDQLL']LZQHM
NRPSDQLLR PLHO VL ]DXZD \
&KF PLSRPyFU]HNFLFKR:LHG PLQ7RGODPQLHFR QRZHJR'ODWHJR
SRVWDQRZLHPQLHGRFLHNDSREXGHN
0 GU]H=ROWDQ FL JQ ]SOHFyZVZyMNUDVQROXG]NLVLKLOOZSRFKZLH]ODNL
RPRWDQHMNRFLPLVNyUNDPL0DV]ELHU]1LPVL QDV]HGURJLUR]HMG
=ROWDQ
1LHJDGDMW\ONRELHU]0\ZJyUDFKW ZRMQ SU]HVLHG]LP\QDQLFQDP HOD]R
$OHSU]\MHPQLHE G]LHQLHUD]SU]\SLZLHZVSRPQLH H NXW\Z0DKDNDPLHVLKLOO
Z GREU\PU NXLZGREUHMVSUDZLH ZLV]F]\ H QLH]KD ELVL $LW\JG\W NOLQJ
NU]\ZG]LFLHOLWZRMHM&LULE G]LHV]SDWDSDWQLMFKRMHGQHJR]D&DOHED6WUDWWRQD
, ZVSRPQLM=ROWDQD&KLYD\DLNUDVQROXG]NLHNX QLH
0R HV]E\SHZLHQ*HUDOWSU]\M PLHF]SU]HZLHVLJRSU]H]SOHF\0R HV]
E\SHZLHQ H E G ZVSRPLQD1DW\PSDUV]\Z\P ZLHFLH=ROWDQLH&KLYD\
GREURXF]FLZR LSUDZR PRFQR]DSDGDM Z SDPL
$LRZV]HPNUDVQROXG]PUX \RF]\'ODWHJRMDQLH]DSRPQ DQLFLHELHL
PDUXGHUyZQDOH QHMSRU ELHDQL5HJLVDLSRGNRZ\Z DU]H-H OL]D FKRG]LR
Z]DMHPQR SRGW\PZ]JO GHP
=DZLHVLJRVFKU] NQ FKDUNQ LVSOXQ
0\ P\*HUDOWREURELOLNXSFDSRG'LOOLQJHQ%RJDF]DFRVL QDKD\HNDUVNLP
KDQGOXXSDV*G\]DDGRZD]RWRLNOHMQRW\QDZy]L]PLDVWDXFLHND
]DVDG]LOL P\VL QDQLHJR-DNROHZPDM WNXEURQLSRPRF\Z]\ZDZL F UD]\
NLONDREXV]NLHPZF]HUHSZ]L LSRWHPMX VSRNRMQ\E\LFLFKXWNL3DPL WDV]
NXIHUNLNWyUH P\WDV]F]\OLQDZR]LHZLH OLDQDNRQLHFQDGU]HF]N 2 Z]LHPL
]DU\OL"7DPZD QLHE\R]UDERZDQHKDYHNDUVNLHGREUR=RG]LHMVNLXSQDNWyU\P
QDV] SU]\V]R ]DPLDUXMHP\SREXGRZD
'ODF]HJRPLWRPyZLV]=ROWDQ"
%RFLHELHMDNPQLHPDPRV]XND F]HSR]RU\]ZLRG\QLHWDNGDZQR7RFR]D
GREURLSUDZR PLDH RND]DRVL SRG\PLQLHJRG]LZ\PSRGDGQ PDVN
&LHELHDWZRRV]XNDZLHG PLQLHERW\QLHGRFLHNDV]SREXGHN$OHMDQLHFKF FL
RV]XNLZD7HG\QLHSDWU]QDWHEDE\LG]LHFLQLHPLHMNUDVQROXGDNWyU\SU]HG
WRE VWRL]DSUDZHJRLV]ODFKHWQHJR6WRLSU]HGWRE ]RG]LHMUDEX DPR H L
PRUGHUFD%RQLHZ\NOXF]DP H RELW\KD\HNDUVNDSLDZURZLHSU]\GLOOLQJH VNLP
JR FL FX
0LOF]HOLGXJRSDWU] F QDGDOHNLHWRQ FHZFKPXUDFKJyU\QDSyQRF\
%\ZDM=ROWDQU]HNZUHV]FLH*HUDOW%\PR H VL\ZLVWQLHQLHNWyU\FK
SRZROLSU]HVWDM Z WSLSR]ZRO QDPVL MHV]F]HNLHG\ VSRWND&KFLDE\PE\
WDNE\R&KFLDE\PPyFSU]HGVWDZLFL&LULFKFLDE\PE\PRJDFL SR]QD$OH
QDZHWMH OLVL QLHXGDZLHG] H QLH]DSRPQ FL %\ZDMNUDVQROXG]LH
KHUDOG\F]QHJRGDWRUDF]HMQLHPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD]DUPL 7HPHULL$QLHV G]
E\GRU\VNLFKJHU\ODVyZGRWDUDMX ZLH RGZyFKV]SLHJDFKNWyU]\QLHGDZQR
WDMHPQLF]R]ELHJOLVSRGV]XELHQLF\PDUV]DND9LVVHJHUGD*G\E\ P\QDSDWRF]\OL
VL QDW\FKSDUW\]DQWyZPDP\V]DQV VL Z\JD
0R QDQDWROLF]\SRZLHG]LD*HUDOWXVSRNDMDM F EU\NDM F 3RWN $OH
V]F]HU]HPyZL FZRODE\PVL QLHQDSDWRF]\
7RZV]DN H WZRLURGDF\ZLHG PLQLHU]HN5HJLV3U]HFLH QD]\ZDM FL
*HUDOWHP]5LYLL
3RSUDZNDRGU]HN]LPQR7RMDVDPVL WDNQD]\ZDP HE\E\RDGQLHM
,PL ] WDNLPGRGDWNLHPEXG]LXPRLFKNOLHQWyZZL NV]H]DXIDQLH
3RMPXM X PLHFKQ VL ZDPSLU'ODF]HJRMHGQDNZ\EUDH ZD QLH5LYL "
&L JQ HPSDW\NLR]QDF]RQHUy Q\PLG ZL F]Q\PLQD]ZDPL=DVXJHURZDPL
W PHWRG PyMZLHG PL DNLSUHFHSWRU1LHRGUD]X'RSLHURZyZF]DVJG\XSDUHP
VL SU]\EUDQD]ZLVNR*HUDOW5RJHU(U\NGX+DXWH%HOOHJDUFLH9HVHPLUX]QDWR
]D PLHV]QHSUHWHQVMRQDOQHLNUHW\ VNLH=GDMHVL H PLDUDFM
-DVNLHUSDUVNQ JR QRZ\PRZQLHSDWU] F QDZDPSLUDL1LOIJDDUGF]\ND
0RMHZLHORF]RQRZHQD]ZLVNRU]HNQLHFRXUD RQ\VSRMU]HQLHP5HJLVMHVW
QD]ZLVNLHPSUDZG]LZ\P,]JRGQ\P]ZDPSLU] WUDG\FM
0RMHUyZQLH SRVSLHV]\]Z\MD QLHQLHP&DKLU0DZUWRLPL PRMHMPDWNL
D '\IIU\QSUDG]LDGND,QLHPDZW\PQLF PLHV]QHJRSRHWR$W\VDPFLHNDZR
MDNVL QD]\ZDV]"3U]HFLH -DVNLHUWRRF]\ZLVW\SVHXGRQLP
1LHPRJ X \ZDL]GUDG]DSUDZG]LZHJRQD]ZLVNDRGU]HNWDMHPQLF]REDUG
]DG]LHUDM F GXPQLHQRV-HVW]E\WV\QQH
$PL Z F]\DVL QDJOHGRUR]PRZ\0LOYDRGGX V]HJRF]DVXSRQXUDL
PLOF] FDVURG]H OLRJG\PL VSLHV]F]DOLQD0DMD0DQLDDOER0DULOND*G\NWR
WDNLHLPL V\V]\]DUDGXPD H ZROQRSRW\NXNOHSD
/HNRNWyU\RQDSURVLRGH]ZDVL FLFKR&DKLUQLHMHVWFXGRZQ\P
SDQDFHXP0DPWU]\VLRVWU\ZLHPFRPyZL 2QD]GDMHVL P\ OL H ]ZLHF]RUD
Z\SLMHRGZDUDQD]DMXWU]UXV]\]QDPLZGDOV] GURJ 1LH]WHJR3U]H]MDNLH
G]LHVL GQLQLHPDFRQDZHWPDU]\RW\PE\]GRDDXVLHG]LHQDNRQLX=DQLP
SRGDV]MHMWHQOHN5HJLVPXVLV]MHMRW\PSRZLHG]LH$SRGDPHG\NDPHQW
PR HV]MHMGRSLHURZWHG\JG\]QDMG]LHP\GODQLHMy NR&]\VWHy NR
=UR]XPLDHPNLZQ JRZ 5HJLV-HGHQJRV]D$W\*HUDOW"
&RMD"
0RLSDQRZLHZDPSLUSRZLyGSRQLFKVZ\PLFLHPQ\PLRF]DPL1LH
XGDZDMFLH H QLHUR]XPLHFLH
:1LOIJDDUG]LHSRZLHG]LD&DKLUF]HUZLHQLHM F LRSXV]F]DM F JRZ R
WDNLFKVSUDZDFKGHF\GXMHZ\ F]QLHNRELHWD1LNWQLHPDSUDZDZS\ZDQDMHM
GHF\]M 5HJLVSRZLHG]LD H 0LOYDMHVW]GHF\GRZDQDQDPHG\NDPHQW7\ONR
GODWHJRZ\ F]QLHGODWHJR]DF] HPQLHFKF F\P\ OHRW\PMDNRRIDNFLH
GRNRQDQ\P,RVNXWNDFKWHJRIDNWX$OHMDMHVWHPFXG]R]LHPFHPQLH]QDM F\P
1LHSRZLQLHQHPVL Z RJyOHRG]\ZD3U]HSUDV]DPZDV
=DFR"]G]LZLVL WUXEDGXU&]\W\QDVPDV]]DG]LNXVyZ1LOIJDDUGF]\NX"
=DSU\PLW\ZQHSOHPLRQDVWRVXM FHVL GRMDNLFK V]DPD VNLFKWDEX"7R
RF]\ZLVWH H W\ONRNRELHWDPR H SRGM WDN GHF\]M WRMHMQLH]E\ZDOQHSUDZR
-H OL0LOYDGHF\GXMHVL QD
=DPNQLMVL -DVNLHUZDUNQ O :LHG PLQ=DPNQLMVL EDUG]RFL SURV]
8ZD DV]LQDF]HM"XQLyVVL SRHWD&KFLDE\ MHM]DND]DDOER
=DPNQLMVL GRFKROHU\ERQLHU F] ]DVLHELH5HJLVW\MDNPLVL ]GDMH
SU]HSURZDG]DV]Z UyGQDVFR Z URG]DMXSOHELVF\WX3RFR"7RW\MHVWH
PHG\NLHP URGHNRNWyU\RQDSURVL7DN URGHNVRZRPHG\NDPHQWMDNR PL
QLHOH \7\ONRW\PR HV]MHMWHQ URGHNSU]\U] G]LLGD,]URELV]WRJG\
SRSURVLSRQRZQLH1LHRGPyZLV]
URGHNMX SU]\U] G]LHP5HJLVSRND]DZV]\VWNLPPDOH N EXWHOHF]N ]
FLHPQHJRV]ND-H OLSRSURVLSRQRZQLHQLHRGPyZL -H OLSRSURVLSRQRZQLH
2FRZL F FKRG]L"2QDV] MHGQRP\ OQR "2SRZV]HFKQ DNFHSWDFM " 7HJR
RF]HNXMHV]"
'REU]HZLHV]RFRFKRG]LU]HNZDPSLU'RVNRQDOHF]XMHV]FRQDOH \
]UREL$OHSRQLHZD S\WDV]RGSRZLHP7DN*HUDOWRWRZD QLHFKRG]L7DNWR
ZD QLHQDOH \ ]UREL1LHWRQLHMDWHJRRF]HNXM
&]\PR HV]PyZLMD QLHM"
1LH-DVNLHURGU]HNZDPSLU-D QLHMMX QLHPRJ 7\PEDUG]LHM H QLHPD
SRWU]HE\3UDZGD*HUDOW"
3UDZGD:LHG PLQRSDUF]RRQD] F]RQ\FKGRQLDFK7DNSVLDNUHZ
SUDZGD$OHGODF]HJRSDWU]\V]QDPQLH"-DPDPWR]UREL"-DWHJRQLHXPLHP1LH
SRWUDIL .RPSOHWQLHQLHQDGDM VL GRWHMUROL.RPSOHWQLHUR]XPLHFLH"
1LH]DSU]HF]\-DVNLHU.RPSOHWQLHQLHUR]XPLHP\&DKLU"&]\W\
UR]XPLHV]"
1LOIJDDUGF]\NVSRMU]DQD%HJLVDSRWHPQD*HUDOWD
&K\EDWDNSRZLHG]LDZROQR7DNV G]
$KDNLZQ JRZ WUXEDGXU$KD*HUDOW]UR]XPLDZORW&DKLUV G]L H
UR]XPLH-DZRF]\ZLVW\VSRVyEZ\PDJDPR ZLHFHQLDDOHQDMSLHUZUR]ND]XMHPL
VL PLOF]HSRWHPV\V] H QLHPDSRWU]HE\E\PUR]XPLD']L NXM
'ZDG]LH FLDODWZVX ELHSRH]MLGRVWDWHF]QLHMGXJRE\ZLHG]LH H V U]HF]\
NWyUHDOERUR]XPLHVL Z ORWQDZHWEH]VyZDOERQLJG\VL LFKQLH]UR]XPLH
:DPSLUX PLHFKQ VL
1LH]QDPQLNRJRSRZLHG]LDNWRSRWUDILE\SL NQLHMWRXM
$]UHV]W SRFRPLWRZLHG]LH:DPSLUZQHWVSRU\V]XQDJRWRZL3U]\MG]LH
ZDPRVWDZLQPLHJG]LHZMDNLHMZVL1LHQLHJDGDMQLFPLOF]-DZLHPMDNL W\
7\QDZHWWZHMQDURZLVWHMNRE\\QLHSRU]XFLV]QLHRVWDZLV]QDLQQ QLH
Z\PLHQLV]FKRRGJUD DV]VL FL JLHP7\ QLH]WDNLFKFRRVWDZLDM $OHWHUD]
PXV3RVSRU\V]XQDNXOEDFHQLHXVLHG] $OHLWRZLHG] H JG\R]GURZLHM UXV]
]DZDPLZ ODG%RFKFLDDE\PE\ WZRM &LULRGQDOD]ZLHG PLQLH%\ M ]
PRM SRPRF RGQDOD]LRG]\VND
7RGODWHJRSRMHFKDD ]HPQ SRZLHG]LDWU F F]RR'ODWHJR
2SX FLDJRZ
'ODWHJRZD QLHSRZ GURZDD ]HPQ SRZWyU]\:\UXV]\D E\SRPyFZ
UDWRZDQLXFXG]HJRG]LHFND&KFLDD SDFL6SDFLGXJNWyU\MX ZyZF]DV
Z\UXV]DM F]DPLHU]DD ]DFL JQ &XG]HG]LHFNR]DZDVQH$MDRELHFDHPFL
SRPRFZSRWU]HELH0LOYDMDQLHSRWUDIL FLSRPyF:LHU]PLQLHSRWUDIL
7\PUD]HPRQDPLOF]DD2QQLHPyJ&]X H QLHZROQR
:WHG\Z%URNLORQLHMD]DFL JQ HPZREHFFLHELHGXJLSU]\U]HNHP H JR
VSDF 1LHUR]V GQLH*XSLR2ND]DD PLSRPRFZFKZLOLJG\EDUG]RSRPRF\
SRWU]HERZDHP1LHVSRVyEVSDFLWDNLHJRGXJX1LHPR QD]DSDFL]DFR FR
QLHPDFHQ\1LHNWyU]\WZLHUG] H ND GDDEVROXWQLHND GDU]HF]QD ZLHFLHPD
VZRM FHQ 7RQLHSUDZGD6 U]HF]\NWyUHFHQ\QLHPDM V EH]FHQQH1DMDWZLHM
SR]QDWDNLHU]HF]\SRW\P H UD]XWUDFRQHV XWUDFRQHQD]DZV]H6DPVWUDFLHP
ZLHOHWDNLFKU]HF]\'ODWHJRG]L QLHSRWUDIL FLSRPyF
:OD QLHSRPRJH RGU]HNDEDUG]RVSRNRMQLH1DZHWQLHZLHV]MDNPL
SRPRJH WHUD]RGHMG SURV] =RVWDZPQLHVDP 2GHMG ZLHG PLQLH2GHMG
]DQLPGRNR FDUR]ZDOLV]PyM ZLDW
P\V]\SRSXVW\PVSLFKU]X
1DWDPWHQEU]HJ"M NQ JG\GRZLHG]LDVL F]HJRRGQLHJRFKF =DQLF
7DPQLOIJDDUG]ND]LHPLDDWHUDZRMHQQ\F]DV3RFKZ\F QDSDOSRVDG] 1LH
SRS\Q 8ELMFLHQLHSRS\Q
8ELPR HP]JU]\WQ D] EDPL0LOYD2ELSU]HGWHPWH PR HP
5R]HZU]\MQRMHV]F]HUD]J E DREDF]\V] H PR HP
:RMHQQ\F]DVZDPSLUSU]HZLHUFLSU]HZR QLNDZ]URNLHP]SHZQR FL QLH
SU]HV]NDG]DZSU]HP\FLHFRGREU\F]RZLHNX"7HPXZV]DN H VX \ WZyMSURP
FK\WU]H]DLQVWDORZDQ\]GDODRGNUyOHZVNLFKLQLOIJDDUG]NLFKIRUGRQyZQLHP\O
VL " 'DOHM H ZL FVS\FKDMJRQDZRG
7DNE G]LHUR]V GQLHMGRGD&DKLUJDV]F] F U NRMH PLHF]D% G]LHV]VL
RFL JDWRSU]HSUDZLP\VL VDPLEH]FLHELHDZyZF]DVWZyMSURP]RVWDQLHQD
WDPW\PEU]HJXE\JRRG]\VNDE G]LHV]PXVLDS\ZD DEN $WDNSU]HSUDZLV]
QDVLZUyFLV]*RG]LQNDVWUDFKXSRWHP]DSRPQLV]
$E G]LHV]VL VWDZLDNSLHMHGHQ]DZDUF]DD]QRZX0LOYDWRWDNFL
SU]\R H GR]LP\QDVQLH]DSRPQLV]
:REOLF]XWZDUG\FKQLHSRGOHJDM F\FKG\VNXVMLDUJXPHQWyZSU]HZR QLNXVW SL
L ZNUyWFHFDDNRPSDQLD]QDOD]DVL QDSURPLH1LHNWyUHZLHU]FKRZFH]ZDV]F]D
3RWNDRSLHUD\VL L QLHFKFLD\VL ]DRNU WRZDDOHSU]HZR QLNLMHJRJXSDZ\
SRPRFQLNQDR \OLLPGXGNL]SDW\NyZLV]QXUNyZ:SUDZD]MDN WRXF]\QLOL
GRZRG]LD H QLHSRUD]SLHUZV]\SU]HP\FDM SU]H]-DUXJ NUDG]LRQHNRQLH
*XSHNZDOLJyUDZ]L VL ]DNU FHQLHQDS G]DM F\PSURPNRHPLUR]SRF] DVL
SU]HSUDZD
*G\Z\S\Q OLQDSD L RZLDLFKZLDWUQDVWURMHSRSUDZL\VL 3U]HSUDZDSU]H]
-DUXJ E\DF]\P QRZ\PZ\UD Q\PHWDSHPZVND]XM F\PQDSRVW S ZSRGUy \
3U]HGQLPLE\OQLOIJDDUG]NLEU]HJUXELH JUDQLFD:V]\VF\R \ZLOLVL QDJOH
8G]LHOLRVL WRQDZHWJXSDZHPXSRPRFQLNRZLSU]HZR QLNDNWyU\]DF]DLQDJOH
SRJZL]G\ZDLQXFLMDN NUHW\ VN PHORG\MN *HUDOWWH F]XG]LZQ HXIRUL
MDNJG\E\ODGDPRPHQW]ROV]\QQDOHZ\PEU]HJXPLDDZ\RQLVL &LULL
NU]\NQ UDGR QLHQDMHJRZLGRN
=DPLDVWWHJRNU]\NQ SU]HZR QLN,E\QDMPQLHMQLHUDGR QLH
%RJRZLH3U]HSDGOLP\
*HUDOWVSRMU]DZHZVND]DQ\PNLHUXQNXL]DNO
: UyGROV]\QQDZ\VRNLPEU]HJXE\VQ \]EURMH]DGXGQL\NRS\WD=DPRPHQW
OHZREU]H QDSU]\VWD SURPRZD]DURLDVL RGNRQQ\FK
&]DUQLZU]DVQ SU]HZR QLNEOHGQ F LSXV]F]DM F NRR1LOIJDDUGF]\NL
PLHU5DWXMFLHERJRZLH
7U]\PDMNRQLH-DVNLHUUR]GDUDVL 0LOYDSUyEXM F MHGQ U N Z\GRE\XN
] OXEX7U]\PDMNRQLH
7RQLHFHVDUVF\SRZLHG]LD&DKLU1LHZ\GDMHPLVL
-HJRJRV]DJXV]\\RNU]\NLNRQQ\FK]SU]\VWDQLLZU]DVNSU]HZR QLND
3RQDJORQ\ZU]DVNLHPJXSRZDW\SRPRFQLNSRUZD]DWRSyU]DPDFKQ VL L ]
LPSHWHPVSX FLRVWU]HQDOLQ 3U]HZR QLNSRPyJPX]GUXJLPWRSRUHP-H G F\
QDSU]\VWDQLGRVWU]HJOLWRWH ]DF] OLZU]HV]F]H.LONXZMHFKDRGRZRG\
FKZ\FLRSRZUy]
=DPNQLMJ E L FKZ\]DW\N
1DOHZ\PSDVNLPWHUD]MX EOL V]\PEU]HJXN ELOLVL NRQQL]LGHQW\ILNRZDQL
SU]H]-DVNUDMDNRO\ULMVF\SDUW\]DQFL:U]HV]F]HOLZ\PDFKLZDOLU NDPL*HUDOW
GRVWU]HJZ UyGQLFKMH G FDQDELD\PNRQLX1LHE\SHZLHQDOHZ\GDRPXVL
H MH G]LHFMHVWNRELHW -DVQRZRVDNRELHW Z ]EURLDOHEH]KHPX
&RRQLNU]\F] " QDGVWDZLXFKD-DVNLHU&R R NUyORZHMF]\MDN"
:U]DVNLQDOHZ\PEU]HJXZ]PRJ\VL :\UD QLHXV\V]HOLV]F] N HOD]D
7RELWZDRFHQLNUyWNR&DKLU6SyMU]FLH=ODVXZ\SDGDM FHVDUVF\
1RUGOLQJRZLHXFLHNDOLSU]HGQLPL$WHUD]V Z SXDSFH
:\M FLHP]WHMSXDSNL*HUDOWVSOXQ GRZRG\E\SURP&KFLHOL]GDMHPL
VL RFDOLFKRFLD VZ NUyORZ L VWDUV]\]Q SU]HZR F LFKSURPHPQDGUXJL
EU]HJ$P\ P\WHQSURPSRUZDOL2MQLHOXEL QDVRQLWHUD]QLHOXEL
$SRZLQQLU]HN-DVNLHU3URPQLHRFDOLE\QLNRJROHF]]DQLyVSURVWRZ
DS\1LOIJDDUGF]\NRPQDSUDZ\PEU]HJX0\WH XQLNDMP\SUDZHJREU]HJX=
/\U\MF]\NDPLSRGHMPXM VL SDNWRZDDOH&]DUQL]DWXN QDVEH]OLWR FL
1LHVLHQDVFRUD]V]\EFLHMRFHQLD0LOYDWH VSOXZDM F GRZRG\LSU]\JO GDM F
VL RGGDODM FHMSOZRFLQLH, URGNLHPSORVD0RJ QDVZU]\SRFDRZDMHGQLL
GUXG]\=DNU W\DJRGQHEU]HJLUyZQHLFDHZZLNOLQLH3\QLHPZGy-DUXJLQLH
GR FLJQ QDV5\FKRLPVL ]QXG]L
DMQRM NQ SU]HZR QLNL3U]HGQDPL&]HUZRQD%LQGXJD7DPyMPRVW,
PLHOL]QD3URPXWNQLH-H OLQDVZ\SU]HG] E G WDPF]HNDOL
1RUGOLQJRZLHQDVQLHZ\SU]HG] 5HJLVZVND]D]UXI\OHZ\EU]HJ0DM
ZDVQH]PDUWZLHQLD
)DNW\F]QLHQDSUDZ\PEU]HJXZU]DD]DFLHNDZDOND-HMFHQWUXPE\RXNU\WHZ
OHVLHLGDZDRRVRELH]QDMHG\QLHELWHZQ\PZU]DVNLHPDOHZZLHOXPLHMVFDFK
F]DUQLLNRORURZLMH G F\SUDOLVL PLHF]DPLZSU]\EU]H QHMZRG]LHWUXS\]
SOXVNLHPSDGD\ZQXUW-DUXJL=JLHNLV]F] N HOD]DFLFK\SURPPDMHVWDW\F]QLH
DOHGR V]\ENRVS\ZDZGyU]HNL
3\Q OL URGNLHPQXUWXDQD]DUR QL W\FKEU]HJDFKQLHZLGDE\R]EURMQ\FKQLH
V\FKDE\RRGJRVyZSR FLJX*HUDOWMX ]DF]\QDPLHQDG]LHM H ZV]\VWNR
GREU]HZHVNR F]\JG\]REDF]\OLSU]HGVRE GUHZQLDQ\PRVWVSLQDM F\RED
EU]HJL5]HNDSRGPRVWHPRS\ZDDDFK\OHZ\VS\QDQDMZL NV]HM]WDNLFKZ\VS
RSLHUDVL MHGHQ]PRVWRZ\FKILODUyZ1DSUDZ\PEU]HJXE\DELQGXJDZLG]LHOL
]ZD\SQLV JLVWHUW\GUHZQD
7DPZV] G]LHPLDNRZ\G\V]DSU]HZR QLN-HQR URGNLHPGDVL
SU]HS\Q SUDZRRGZ\VS\1XUWWDPZD QLHQDVQLHVLHDOHFKZ\FLHW\NPRJ
VL SU]\ZRG]LJG\E\ P\XWNQ OL
1DW\PPR FLH&DKLUSU]\VRQLRF]\GRQL MHVWZRMVNR1DPR FLHLQD
ELQGXG]H
:V]\VF\MX ZLG]LHOLRZRZRMVNR,ZV]\VF\]REDF]\OLMDNQDRZRZRMVNR
Z\SDGDQDJOH]ODVX]DELQGXJDZDWDKDNRQQ\FKZF]DUQ\FKL]LHORQ\FK
SDV]F]DFK%\OLMX QDW\OHEOLVNRE\PyFXV\V]HELWHZQ\ZU]DVN
1LOIJDDUGVWZLHUG]LVXFKR&DKLU&LNWyU]\QDV FLJDOL:WDNLPUD]LHFLQD
ELQGXG]HWR1RUGOLQJRZLH
=DW\NLNU]\NQ SU]HZR QLN3yNLVL ELM PR H SU]HPNQLHPVL
U\NQ OLG]LNR]DP\QNRZDOLPLHF]DPLLVNRF]\OLEH]]DVWDQRZLHQLDGZDM
WRZDU]\V]HGZDMGUXKRZLHLNRPSDQLQDVSRWNDQLHZVSyOQ\FKZURJyZQD
QLHUyZQ\EyM,WRE\LFKFKU]HVWRJQLD&KU]HVWZVSyOQHMZDONLZ FLHNR FL
V]DOH VWZDL PLHUFL6]OLQD PLHURQLGZDMWRZDU]\V]H7DNP\ OHOL1LHPRJOL
SU]HFLH ZLHG]LH H QLHXPU WHJRGQLDQDW\PZD QLHPR FLHSU]HU]XFRQ\P
QDGU]HN -DUXJ 1LHZLHG]LHOL H SU]H]QDF]RQDMHVWLPREXLQQD PLHU:LQQ\P
PLHMVFXLZLQQ\PF]DVLH
1LOIJDDUGF]\F\PLHOLQDU NDZDFKVUHEUQHKDIW\Z\REUD DM FHVNRUSLRQ\&DKLU
]DU EDGZyFKV]\ENLPLFLRVDPLVZHJRGXJLHJRPLHF]D*HUDOW]DVLHNGZyFK
XGH HQLDPLVLKLOOD3RWHPZVNRF]\QDEDOXVWUDG PRVWXELHJQ F SRQLHM
]DDWDNRZDSR]RVWD\FK%\ZLHG PLQHPXWU]\PDQLHUyZQRZDJLE\RGODQLHJR
IUDV]N DOHDNUREDW\F]Q\Z\F]\Q]GXPLDL]DVNRF]\DWDNXM F\FK
1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ,XPDUOL]GXPLHQLL]DVNRF]HQLRGFL NUDVQROXG]NLHJR
EU]HV]F]RWXGODNWyUHJRNROF]XJLE\\MDNZHQD.UHZ]EU\]JDDZ\ OL]JDQHGHVNL
L G\OHPRVWX
2EVHUZXM FDRU QHSU]HZDJLGRZyGFyZVLOQDMX OLF]HEQLHPRVWRZDDUPLD
Z]QLRVDFKyUDOQ\RNU]\NU\NZNWyU\PV\FKDE\RSRZUDFDM FHPRUDOHL
Z]ELHUDM F\GXFKERMRZ\,VWDRVL WDN H QLHGDZQLVSDQLNRZDQL]ELHJRZLH
U]XFLOLVL QD1LOLJDDUGF]\NyZMDN]DMDGHZLONLU EL F PLHF]DPLLWRSRUDPL
G JDM F G]LGDPLWXN F PDF]XJDPLLKDODEDUGDPL3 N\EDOXVWUDG\NRQLH
SROHFLD\GRU]HNLUD]HP]MH G FDPLZF]DUQ\FKSDV]F]DFK
5\F] FDDUPLDZZDOLDVL QDSU]HGPR FLHQDGDOSFKDM F SU]HGVRE *HUDOWDL
&DKLUDSU]\SDGNRZ\FKGRZyGFyZQLHSR]ZDODM F LP]URELWHJRFRFKFLHOL
]UREL$FKFLHOLZ\FRIDVL FK\NLHPZUyFLSR0LOY L GDQRJ QDOHZ\EU]HJ
1DELQGXG]HZU]DDZDOND1LOIJDDUGF]\F\RWRF]\OLLRGFL OLRGPRVWX RQLHU]\
NWyU]\QLH]ELHJOLFLEURQLOLVL ]DFLHNOH]]DEDU\NDG]EXGRZDQ\FK]FHGURZ\FKL
VRVQRZ\FKNORFyZ1DZLGRNQDGFL JDM FHMRGVLHF]\JDUVWNDEURQL F\FKVL
SRGQLRVDUDGRVQ\ZU]DVN1LHFR]E\WSRFKRSQLHLSU]HGZF]H QLH=ZDUW\NOLQ
RGVLHF]\Z\SFKQ LZ\PLyW1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ]PRVWXWHUD]MHGQDNQD
SU]HGPR FLXUXQ RQDQLFKIODQNRZHNRQWUXGHU]HQLHMD]G\*G\E\QLHEDU\NDG\L
V JLELQGXJLKDPXM FH]DUyZQRXFLHF]N MDNLLPSHWNDZDOHULLSLHFKRWDZ
PJQLHQLXRNDSRV]DE\ZUR]V\SN 3U]\SDUFLGRV JyZ RQLHU]HSRGM OL]DFL W\
EyM
'OD*HUDOWDE\RWRFR F]HJRQLH]QD]XSHQLHQRZ\URG]DMZDONL1LHE\R
PRZ\RIHFKWXQNXLSUDF\QyJE\DW\ONRFKDRW\F]QDU EDQLQDLQLHXVWDQQH
SDURZDQLHFLRVyZNWyUHOHFLD\]HZV]\VWNLFKVWURQ:FL MHGQDNNRU]\VWD]
QLH]E\W]DVX RQHJRSU]\ZLOHMXGRZyGF\ yQLHU]HNXSLOLVL GRQLHJRRVDQLDOL
ERNLFKURQLOLSOHF\Z\PLDWDOLIURQWSU]HGQLPUREL F PLHMVFHZNWyUHPyJ
XGHU]\LXN VLQD PLHU$OHWRNURELVL FRUD]ZL NV]\:LHG PLQLMHJR
ZRMVNRQLHZLHG]LHNLHG\ZDOF]\MX UDPL Z UDPL ] SRNUZDZLRQ L
Z\FLH F]RQ JDUVWN REUR FyZEDU\NDG\ZZL NV]R FLNUDVQROXG]NLPL
QDMHPQLNDPL:DOF]\OLZSLHU FLHQLXRNU HQLD
$SRWHPSU]\V]HGRJLH
-HGQ\P]ERNyZEDU\NDG\XV\WXRZDQ\PPL G]\ELQGXJ D PRVWHPE\D
ZLHONDNROF]DVWDMDNMH NXSDVRVQRZ\FKNRQDUyZLJD ]LQLHSRNRQDQD
.21,(&720875=(&,(*2