Intra-flow Loss Recovery and Control for VoIP

Henning Sanneck, Long Le,

Georg Carle

Adam Wolisz

GMD Fokus
Kaiserin-Augusta-Allee 31
D-10589 Berlin, Germany

Technical University Berlin, Telecommunication

Networks Group, Sekr. FT 5-2
Einsteinufer 25
D-10587 Berlin, Germany

[sanneck,le,carle]@fokus.gmd.de

wolisz@ee.tu-berlin.de

ABSTRACT

 
 "!#%$'&#()+*,,-!/.0&+&%)1$#

%k+C S!;781T,&_78/:J&#6&78,,1&N)

&#'
23*,45*,6&#784,&9;:<;""=>;*,,%?4&

GW1,&@,&rCB\"#,&h,15K,&<;5*,1E

 !@* A47881&;,&(BC#"!@=D1,1EGF-!(C)H!2*,';:

& X%&+'\!xk(C*, L@478K?D78&+%;&y5\G;"!#,D%$y;&<$

V!#%!<;S4W;
b

,78<; I!8;#*4,%?,1&#*,D*JCK,*4 0L+E2M;BD1,'!,

1$#$# ,1&*S$#;f;&<$d$K*4L}?D!#%1$%&d5\>%D4$#%$!#,*4

CK,*4 0L,78< 78&+N,H0-:O1*4$NPQ1&&J!<&$N)?D1&!;R5CK

,*,*N76;,&(;,&,&W''&#8D(,T!#,"!`,/DK C*,* L6]$K&+ 

;:-*,1S<T76LU$#%V4W& X<&+* LU!'5,*, L>;: !#

%;*HV5\T"

Y,&3!S*,&WV7_E

,DHY1&%*!#JH*,1Z;&<$I![\"!B,W1&*#*]L(

C#',',&+CK%$NE_^I&@!#8!"V!&<$ )R78`B76L
5\I<;,C#*4;&#,,DTV*,1Y-!#L6%?LG78;I,78\;&+
,&K:a76?,1&_,&378:ZC#Y\K4&G!&3;!YE
_X3$#D1*,1c;&c&<$(;&<$978($#*Y5<;%$d1&d*,GC&K
b

*,&#W!#_,!e!,!ef%&g$#"45\h!@*,h$K,45#C#,1&

 !#4&_=i<%E F-!S<;""0*,D1* 78,/;S!#&`*4,&#%$`
C#*,D*5Kj,D[\!=k+C<*, LT78,EQlI,&W-!#4 :O;78
\)+-/X&<$'!;J:a*,?/78#,&#W=;78*,5<;%$2($K
mAn o/pUq  !>*,1S&*,78&+S,1*4?%$rT*,1%;&>5\
1&%*,%$-*,*s);!%;R5CKQ*,Z!<%DJ!,W1!#R\#C*
,78%E3M=!#4W!#78#,&WG:O78"05%$h($# mt E u1v;w q

Categories
and Subject Descriptors
o E v(E = B hZQKI=\frQRa1#%O\U3('NAPNS,45#C#
%$e(LK78OsA(0d"< AsA#

E v(E g = hRQ(

= @rRQa1O\3("=<;HAP=.&+&#(,&W?e/(0"";

o E G =\hZQ(2NH#@=V;<RO1%O<HAP n :O76;&Y:
(LK78@("8"B0(A"; o E = hZH(NQ
n :a;76&8:Y+L#78eh% a(

#@>V?<RO#%O\HAP
0(s<"

General
Terms
S,W&H) p C#78&+%)

n ":a76;&)<Y*,];5,*, L

&x1&6!&<$@!#6478':T*,1'4V78#*4 X%$@!#CW1!y"

K1W?,1&r%C#%$U5(L`!=$K($#"IX<* I7878,)#!CW1!
&`!#T;!!<;&<$8C!6($#,&W=!78 !*,6B\:a;7z*,1
1&%*,78&+/5+L8{(;\1*4;,1&G:Q$#($#/?1E o 1&+;L8
;78*,5<;%$U($#TV!%|!<;Y!=&%;*,78&+I\:O

Keywords
1,-?DR. n );HJK&#,,D( L+)H
,) ^I5(j,D`(\!xIC<;*,,0L

o 1&#%*,78&+%)1H p "

p 
 &K

C#78&+%)JICC#

W78&+%)#S
&+4;%$3KD(,

76;&B76Ld05#%;(G?I;& ,1&T,!#,&>!#'\"!U,W&<*

!#%-D"%E
3!&}#\1U78!<;&,78V!#4!d$K
&+4;U5\0-&
b

Y,!#,&>6D11,'$;2i?|6784&#,784~S!B,78<"I;:

[*,1E b

/$#4W&<?!#-78!#($#[;=0,&(?Ai<%*,1

?DL`&$`1&+1*sE -!T&<$(A&<$2*,D1*s)4$#&( X%;,1&
;:-I& ,D=`*,1 m &$# q I*,*[S*,1&#%* 
78&(

m 4D1 q

1.
INTRODUCTION
o 1&#4$#,&W!<?H/* A478Zi?h76LI"{#\"4&[178[
*,1)K!T478:Q*476%L2D1?L8,W1& X%&+* LG$#\&$#&+1&
(AU<2;_*,18 !#4&Ui<%E9.&x!6:a1*,*,%,&Wf-
$#,,&WC,!30-V%;1&#Y:OTC!_VD;45#*,*4T& ,DK 0LNP

1V#*];1EyT1K05+L(!fC#\2!78

m ;,,%*,* L q 1$Kr!#h*,13:=1&#h%)

E2 "IK1-"asa%Os+_N18:ITIlI=!,"!9,2;

*]?%$y,&f478676Lh*41$fr$#,CK4&=,&x!#6D(41E

!#,"!G4&4$#"%$G78;I,78\;&(%)#;W,&#I;&;!&S;:

Y!<?-!,/
"/,-:aC#!#;W1W%D;%$G5(L2178I,&K
$#\&<$#&/5\0-&GYSlI m sE 1E,)+!<?&YTSl}%&

!#&*,*,%

!#78Ii%e!#,"!_,:R*4%I,78\;&1EJT5\!G<;"+

1&* LV5\$#($K%$V!&6S#D(,1C#YSld5\:OY!<JC"

:aC#*,*,Ld5\&},D%$d;&<$d$K($#$ q EM#GD1,1)T;

Copyright 2001 by the Association for Computing Machinery, Inc. Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal
or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made
or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this
notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish,
to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission
and/or a fee. Request permissions from Publications Dept, ACM Inc., fax
+1 (212) 869-0481. or permissions@acm.org.
To appear in ACM MULTIMEDIA 01 Ottawa, Canada

',&W*4/1&+,&-0LK,%*,* L`D;*QYSlI m D1,

:O78 q !,Z
[,Z!(CR78;-,W1&#,X%&+[!<;&'E WKEZ:a;
DK4$K#EI.0I;&*4;5<,%;*,*,LU`,1*4;$rS*,
DC/*,T!;+CKY4&35C#E
v(EI "asO%as>V`T_9"0"+" "as

o ",&fYSlI

784W!+V&+,&;':I!#G&($K%$y4W&<;*!#,"!9;

Y#*4,%?,1&B;/lT& %P ![C&#,H:#$#;-78 %$S5+LIC#
($KYC!_TVD(4$#'YD4S:O78E

(%
)

(%

et
ck

et

pa

ck

-1

pa

te

te
ra
ss
lo

(%
)

FQh$#"45\`!,2
8;&<$x#?D(]$K3U;{K&17=L@:O6$K,
"

+1
p

&+IV&!&#78&+K;"!#)+-T4&+($KCT&?D*"

50

los
s

rat
e

78,&*4WL Pr-r$#,W&<;>78!<;&,788!,!d,&#i<C#&rI+

<?78"_5\&i<% m !(C3$#@!#@*,1_?f:
1&#Vi<%?!2{K\&#2:!#i<% q

50
100
loss rate [all packets] (%)

50
100
loss rate [all packets] (%)

<;"1' !,&>i%6$K781&#;%$f,&MR4WC#

;5\;D11)
#?D(4$#Ba ?#i<%IG&!&#78&+%ETTI+G78"!&,78
!<%D`h5\G,78*,78&+%$@ !,&x!G&0- m !#1K05+L(! q

Q2O<%[h<?G>#<Qr]#%B0#ah[<?< TQ<;<K

786,78\;&+' !yW?$frC#2\"#,&f!<&

!#B:/!#8782i<%EGH"'C#B1&#]$KVGi<%,!
V:O;78SLK\/;:Z*4;W1*,L_$#
&+\#C*N478\;
&# m -6;C786788,~1)Z:]%k+C&#L@&<$h&_,&+
$#\&<$K&35\&!#3:O;78 q EclT&<$#"8!3*,G;:
;:(![<;"")%!Z\#C<;*+k+C<;*4 0LID;,H!KC#W1* L

5\0-&x!G%_!#3!#

1

:T!`:O782,!

!,W!r\"#C*H478\;&#=;B,D%$>;&<$3!B%;
!"S!

;

Ba (%i<%zI+\E

K!78R!,!H),&V!#-#&/;: *,1)K$#

&(4?/5\&

O<Q?<6HHr%a>QaaOcQR1%O<R3Q([KRQK `<

1

J,&5*,%$ EZYC* [:a-C*<\"

C!_'&1&K*4,&#%;Y5\!?D(,"E

ack
ets

-1
p
rat
e

50

los
s

b)

MR,W#E  q )+!!,W1!#-,J!\&+4*W,&6,&8C#,*, L2!#&2!

,D$3k+C<;*4 0L3;TCK,*4 0L`:OY7VC#* 478$#4';#*4,%?,1&Y{K!,5#,

utility (%)

100

,&f3W;":aC*$#W;1$#;,1&f;:-!2#*,4;,1&N =C#,*, L+E 

!<?T!#B!,W1!#T!#B&1&K*4,&#%; L3:[!BCK4*, L31&+,5CK,1&
:B!#r <;""G, m $#D(4;,1&d:]17!>$K%$dC#DU,&
#;,1&8:O

50
100
loss rate [all packets] (%)

(%
)
ack
ets

100

;Y#%$6&$8!#T&<$K

&#W1-;:\*,1R?[4&$#,%?%$=5+L!#!<$#%$=;KEJF-!,RC#* 

of the -1 packets

50
100
loss rate [all packets] (%)

&$G*,1?D"LG&3!(C/\;K1\* LG?DY'4$#"

utility contribution
of the +1 packets
with loss recovery

50

+1

ra
ss

50

lo

a)

%$KC%$ )+5\%;CY!I

utility (%)
overall utility

100

100

*,T,78\;&+-:O;78Y;4D1%$NE

&$<?6,&!#3&$9LK78

m &<$(;&<$ q ) _!<%DG&#!"

;{K,:[*4;,X%;,&HE

F-!`$K;,1&x;:Y!#6&<$K% '5#,?`_!#6C#&+=&"
-;1&#W1,1&?yr;&g,&+;Ai<%I+c!78 m *4
;s\")T ; q 4V$# 8C#* 'r#* L@UD11,1E o 1&#4$#,&W
!<?D1,Si%Y!%D'D1L`*4%e5 ?1)#!#I*4;,D1Y:
&#78 4&#W_!8:a%$#5@,&#:O76;,&9,=!,W1! m !#&y172
<?%$21E W#EZBD(4$#Si%

q E[FQ%$#C#-!,J1 !/:a%$#5

,&+D1;*K1C#*]$'&%$BS5\/,&%$ )!&'*,%1$K4&#WII!#,W1!"

#5<;5,*,,0L_;:Z/1&W6$;#;,&>$#,,1&#EF-!B76%j;S$K,V
C#*,0L+)(!%-D%)#4-!#S*46:[=($#T!,"!G,C#* L6%*45#*,
,&G78/;:R 1CKC#-5 ;B;&<$6\&<$K4&#W2\#C<;*
k+C<;*4 0L+E o CK&+*,L>;&<$#;$#,~$hD42($# m u? q CC*,* L
1&#* L'!%D-/X{K%$B1CKC#R5 ;1E b

`C#\:a;T%;* ,78S7'C* ,78%$#4Bi<%%&U&_1&#

!&$f,7;'
,&W>_*,*42D(,1)Z!,!H)[!#?D%)Z
5\8,78#*478&+%$> !#4&f3<;""0 !%$r&0-; )Q4*,* 5\
1* L@:O=!2&#r#?D(]$K'&$r!(CS:O=!8C"%E_^I&
!#S!#!<;&<$ )K !#4&3V*,1LGD(,1)K!;5\;D1S& ,D( L
1&;,&(G7VC#65\>;&d,&+y;1C#&+%E.0`,GC#G1&#W
5\*4,:6!;>!,>&$#Uc5\x$#&y,&dW1&,y/L+)=sE E4)
&#U#*,,%;,&#\ X<`(&%*,%$#W m 5\C#=<?4C*4;'($#,&#W
!78I1E WKE q

!C*4$U5\'&#?L_ !,&U!=&0-;U&$N)

D(,BD()\&VK&#%*4$#W1'5\C#Y&"-;3\,XY!1C#*4$_5\

&#?Ly !,&};&};#*4,%?,1&HE9N2C#V&#?z1&#]$K2!#
_!<?

:2;:Bri??_4$#&+ X<%$878;

1
,78\;&+ m $K,W1&;%$c5+Lz  q 3*4_,78\&+ m 0  q
 q
!#%BGW1&,2CK4*, L3:aC&#,1&@$#,5#4&#W`!#2;*,,%?4&#
*,D1*RIC*, L6;:JKD(, m I q $K\&<$K&+-&3!T\&+W
$KCS6;&(LG:Z!#B5\?DB&#,,D( LG1&#,&+EMR,W1CK

;:-S*,1%EVM;S%* A,78V7'C* ,78%$#42;8)HC#"!rC#,* 

 0Ly!C*4$y\&<$yh\",D%$yD(4$#;D4_k+C<;*4 0L+Ef.0:
!#=*]?,D',78\;&';: !#=T4T&;S(&%&U5+L3!#
;&78,,1&>LK7_)K!B*,1T?T:OT!=

&$3 <+
" ?/%k+C<;*AERSCT!/?D#\,1&*K& ,D( L':<!#

/8*,1I-*,*Z;Y!#B$#\&$#&#:[!#&<$(;

&<$2*,1J?DL'\:a;76&#1&2!Y )!#/C#,*, L
:OC&#,1&U,I$K%;,&W6,W1& X%&+* L_,&U2&#1&#*,,&%?T-L m ;#
K%{#,76?%$',&V!#-X<W1CK-5+L=,A,*,4&#%;J:aC#&,& q ,!
;&_,&,&W8*,1;EMR,WC# 5 q #&+/!I%S!#
;*,*

<=?GK$y;=!6{K\&6;:Y

m :a;V*,1B;6

F-!#6$#%Lh:!8C#,*, L>:aC#&,&

E
; q ,

U "!y5\"-&fD4`($#

!,*,- [!<;Z5\&=#\1%$

m v? q )Z! p ^ m C5(j,D

k+C<;*4 0L q D*,C#/:aY!($#Y78#*4%L+$G$K2&;I$K

Y7VC!HP
1E W#E,);!Z.F-ly($# t E u1v;KE ) t E uvw() t E u1v;K) t E u1vY&$ t E u 1
?DTV5# ;S&#W1:O7

E 2(5 ";-6;2(5 ";/!,*,!

C5(j,Dk+C<;*4 0L`$#
/5+L6*,-!<;& E v 1&3 ; p ^
%;*4 m ;A) PY5<1$ ) PY{K*,*,&+Bk+C<;*4 0L q EK8!&>!#V%D,* 
5#,*4 0LG;:ZC#2,&+178#C#,&W=\%-Y,YC78$N)(!T*4%
5 ?`($#6%;&f5\8"!#1&y\"76&&(* LU !C#VC*,* L
$#%,&#W2!S\#C*Hk(C*, L+E
M;8*,1_"U1&&9&$KA&$f5<,)-$#C6h!#`* 
,78B$#*4LG1&#,&+)\1\&K*4+U"!#78*,,=M-;$UZ
 o ;,1& m MZ o/q !?D1I5\&`#\1%$ m v? q E b !,*,SC!
!78Y?'?,DB5\C!#L3&_5\BC$31&_!#.&#
&#Z($L+)1!#L'*,S!?D1/D;*$(%5(E[F-!;781C&+
: %$KC&$&+J,&#:O76;,&`&#%$KJ5\Y1$#K4D1YB%D]$V;+
,&W>5<;&<$(]$(!x/Lf:O7;!'i<%EfF-!#,81$##?,1&x,
C#4*-\4*,* Ly!&y!8:],1&x;:Y?8`C,&WU%$KC&#
$;&L_"!#78S,S*4;W m ; q E=.0:J!B%$#C#&<$#&"L_,B`C#
($K4&#W2 * :)\*,, Y!<;Y;:O&35\&3K1\%$

m u? q )!#172

78&+S:O75\?D8&y1$##?,1&y;*4r;* L+E6lT4&#W3%$KC&#

$;&L2!<*,V,78#*4,%?,1& =!#T#*]L+C#-$#*4L61$#K;,1&
m % q 78#*4%L+$BI$#,j [!#-<;""[;Z! ,D%E 
!<?-!Y#&+%$2LK\-;:Q*,1&# 4D( L8*,8#* L2'K
b !,*,YI!<%D5#,&#%$VC* J!,"!6&#X#7!#Y!\Y:
!80?D*,*#C#,*,,0LKSC#D1/!%&2,&8MR,W#E )+*,%?* LV!/CK,*4 0L
:aC#&,&Z:!/ ? 0C5;Ai<%[&$B!# Z*4;,1&#!,8;
78I178#*4"{3;&<$`1&* L3##%{K476?* LG1$$K 4D11E

 j&,@%EU*sE m w; q E>.0',',&+,&#W>U&#8!<?':O2*,*

 ?
;T ! mY q- !##5<5#,*4 0L3:a;I!#=&#{(Y<
&;'>5\6*,1 mA0m;q=
q ,'W1&#*,* LyDL@!,W1! m
(),&
5\1*4$BLK\:s; q !#%;[!#& m q[ ! ;;& ,1&
#5<;5,*,,,B3!;BD&(S?DB!V;&W8: %  E
F-!<?-78%;&[!<?-<;V0&=*,1=D&+ $#B&;-?
!#*4
#+B7'C!h;<;*,1BD&+EB.0&(C# 4D1* L_!,78
@76;3&1)/5\%C#U@C:aC#*,*,L};,D(,&Wh<2%&
5\V&f;G,&<$K,%;;:aB1&W,1&r*,4":E8Y&<$(&>%E'*sE
m q ;I-*4*R  %j&,_"%EI;*sE m v q 5\!>&#X#78%$G!,T5(L
78%;C#,&WB!Y1/*4;,&_:N!T*4 &<$8&#*,1AC&K
*,&W;!E9F-!#Ly%;78`>!6C* 2!;8C#"!x;*4;,1&,
DL>%\E3F-!,',78#*4,!;=<?&B:!#=*,1'5C#

#ZO8<INB<Q_?<R%OO\>R?<RRaaO%]#T1 hRQK

<<#QH#Q (;Q(?<1R%OQ<KQ(;
;<#hNQKS0%RO;d<;Q(1'Hx(%ROx(1S<06,(

State
000
001
010
011
100
101
110
111

Probability of
being in the state
0.8721
0.0208
0.0142
0.0102
0.0208
0.0036
0.0102
0.0481

Probability
of l(s)=0
0.9779
0.6112
0.8819
0.2710
0.9278
0.4198
0.8109
0.1539

Probability
of l(s)=1
0.0221
0.3888
0.1181
0.7290
0.0722
0.5802
0.1891
0.8461

,&+\%$G !_!#Y\,($#;:[C:aC*N<;"1T;,D1;*,
+CK[;* L m &4&=!,Z&("{KZ!;[,&8FR;5*, !#-<?&
%(

#*,4;,1&#V!,!?6&!&%$f5+Lf&$KA&$h*,1V?DL

F-!(C)K,&G!#I:a*4*,%,&W278*,%L`'78($K* m v? q !,!31&#* L

&4$#T!B<;I*,1ID&+:aI!B;B&#,,&rK15K

78"!&,78E=[&<$(;&<$U78!<;&,78I%;&r$#C2&$r!# :O

C#"!3& ,D(,,Y5CK/%;&&;Y178S*42*,,784&;S!#7_E

5#,*4 0L+EBF-!=&(C7V5\"I;:?S:J!=78($#*R%&r5\B%$#C#%$


EUF-!,=78%&#S!<?=61&* Lh1&#4$#=!

:O7v

F-!#:O/,&!,Q-;S-C78J!<?Q!J*,%-[\45#*,-5 

?'!#4!>#?D(4$#I!#V$K %$>k+C<*, L_4I"!#1&NE

m m?qmT#q"mT qTq

;=&#,,&@#5<;5,*,,0L> J
mT  q/
 A)\!" fm Uq

  8

 !#

 !

:O%$K5<#$K;,1&c&#6%$KC&<$#&#L946C#%$N)!#?D%)Y?

,@dD;4;5*,x<;;78%E

b 9$#X&x,h"(4"(O 
:a;`h%k+C#&G:  1&C#,D* Lx*,1`2$K$?
}m
  ! m6U
q 
q@
mqr
;&<$
m    q'

 G A)r5\,&WU!#A!05C#

!#B&<$(;&<$3*,D1*s) ]$K&+ X<%?4&\?76;(,&W6:J<;"1T&#

 ,D8*,1 m &<$K q T*,*R;T*,1T1&#%;*478&( m 4D1 q
;R#*41ERI1K5(L(!SC#\Q"!#78H!#&=*,*,%y1$#,&#W
!#*,1:[&<;"1%)(!,"!34&4$#"%$378I478\;&+%)

*,1YD&+KE ;I!<?/!S;78"/:R!#S78($#*N5\178

,&<$K\&<$K&+I;: !#'k(C#&'&(C7'5\ &$U%&>&%|;!"
5\B$#,5\%$G5+L6!S+C#&# =:[V*,YC#&3*,&W;!  E

;W;4&#J&#!"Z1&#:#!J78[i<%f!#4!=4Q:<*,%-"[478\;

;&E
b

278*,%LhC*J($#V;&<$@78C#'! =C#,*, L

,&6!T#&#I;:R-*,/C,&W'15(j,DT\!3k+C*, L

78C#78&+%E
F-!#@\343CCK%$3:O1*,*,?PcK"4&vy,&+($#C
b r78*,%L!#>78,
>$K,5\2!8& ,DK 0L@;: . n ;88_=*,1=4&
,1&U(E K,&3V5K,iL6,&+($#C#Vk+C#CY76&W178&+
;*,W1 !#7!,!h%;&h5\'C%$_:OB,&+;Ai<%*,11&+1*sEB.&
,1&

6$KX<&#V!2;&<$K17D1?45*,"!

 B:a*,*4%P"!

P@0&
$}m
 Uq Ph%%A  1&#C#,D
cm

Uq Px=4  1&K
<;"1V*,1K)/;&<$!'&
b

V&$dC*,D*T78,E

) -2K&+IC#* $#+C#78&+,&W8!'\:a;76&

;:#!# K1\%$78"!&#478N?Z5\!S!# &$KA&$S&$!1K

5+L(!G*,D*AE(,1&U'1&#*,C<$#!#S<;\%E

<;"1=*4#)#!

CK,DVS*,1KE

!,!VW4D1[*4 K155,*, ,J$#\&$#&+Z&V! 5CK[*4&W!NE

.&8!#T78($K*s)+:a-DL21$$K 4&<;*N*,/<;""!,!`1$$K 
!T*,&W;!3:R'*,1/5#C#=;I;& ,1&`/#*41EJ.:R

<;"1S,C:aC#*,*,L>,D%$N) !#'?'CK&I(!

E
F-!(C)\!#'?V#5<;5,*,,0LU:J!=LK7:a 
,

#q E2SC#'6!2*,,78 %$>7878L3:-!#VLK7_) !

|
, jC$KX<&#%$UG
&C#,D=<

Uq 5\,&WU!#G?GK15<;5,*, L+E t ,D&

*,1K)  !9 m !
!,!y$#"45\B!#8*,1

NV mIm?q6QmS9Uq"m v q"mS q'q 5\8!8?

;& ,1&2K155,*, L=:\TW1&;* p ??D=78($K*+:<$#" )
!# m?q 4/!#*4T,&$#,%;;T:OC&#,1&3:OY!<;"1,!
!#'k(C#&V&(C7'5\ ET*,*R7V5,&;,1&#I:a;S!=D1;*,C m
;&<$ q ;:! %k+C&# m#Uq"m# v q"m# q ;\%?[4&
!#B;=<1ETTT&U{#78#*,B mZm?q
+mY v q"0mY
qG
( q W1,D2!#_;3;& ,1&dK155,*, Lx!&9!#

 !>!,B$#"X<& ,1&N) -2;5*,,!f

ms q

m !)&

*4I;*!

K+Y,T$KX<&#%$3;/:a1*,*,%P

C#&+

*,1C#&#*,&W;!878($#*K !GSX& T&(C#7V5\[;:Q?

2. METRICS
2.1
Packet-level metrics
W1&#* p ;?Dr78($#* m w()J; q

!<;Y5+L6:s?!S*,%-T;K155,*, L q E

,*,1%)N!'#D(,1C#S<;"1 T !<S*,

T v6!S&#I5\&r*4%E=F-!'&KC#7V5\

!`%;G;:S_X<&# G&(C7'5\=:Y<;"1+r:a8Ui%) !#4!

 2G<;"1B$K)H-8!<%D=!V*]?
{K\,&#, $-/.10

>#q :O+?A@ q :a;2!

,D6:O%k+C&L436587  :9<; m m !
=
+CK&S:[=*,15CK:R*,&#W!  EJY&3;#%{K,76;,1&`:a;
!T{K\?4&3;:Q!Y&$#17D1?45*,B!%&G5\I78CK%$
. 0
- 1

 3 587  ;&<$]$K&+ X<%$c !e!#g78&e*4

"3 5

;#E b  %;&V;*,S##%{K,76;Z! ;K155,*, ,Z:K!

mF#q$-/. 0H 3 5C7
78($#*J5+L>!VC7'C*4;,D'*4=?B3 5C7 DE
G

G
GML
ONP9Q mFUUq E=F-!
-. 0
m  _q ;&<$I3 587

G KJ
=

&# 4&c#5<5#,*4 ,6:a;
&d5\U78CK%$
%;4* L_P

5\&h*,B&$>

;:V?U:=!r78($#*S,UvVEzF-9;r& ,1&#U%&

;r*4>:O7

;&+Ld:B!#h?EzF-!(C#)Y!#>&KC#7V5\`;:
;;78!,!@!<%D'_5\8178#C#%$>,'v
E`JD1&h:O

*]?,D* L>76*,*

3
J

L ON
J

!,I781C#&+I;:;78"I,$K,2C* I

5\D1;*4C;%$U;&<$`178;%$ E-FR;5*, !%T178D*,C/:O

!#2;2&<$U&# 4&f#5<;5,*,,,:O=GW&"* p ;?D
78($K*K:\! $V;$#J78%;C#%$'&<$(;&<$=4&'!/.&+&#[5+L

WV
R

JTR SU

 SU
 N
TJ SU L O N
JTSU

L ON

R
J SU

1X
JTSU


L ON

SL U ON

F-!h&<$K,,&<*I*4_#5<;5,*,,,_W;,&e&c5\r##%{(


mFq
Z\[^] _F`\a  N

b c ; 9Q
EM;
Qd
9 GWY
J
L
ON
Z\[^] _F`\a
b c ;\egf 9 Q
Q2
J

,76;%$|5(L 365C7 D

p m0
p00

10

p 20

p10
X== 1

X=0

X== 2

p 23

p 12

p 01

X== m

m !

cf !

p00

MR,WKE v'!#?!

p11 (clp)

#

O\Q?N$j \%d;RHOKQ<%hNQK32O%'

#

GOO[K?3hNQKA

interface to hop-by-hop
loss control

G L k
NP9 Q
b c a M
Qd
Qd
b c Ja G 9 Q

ms_qJ

9 GdY

p01

dUq !<%D1P

365C7 D

p(m-1)m

O\Q?ihNjJ\%2;RHOKQ%hNQK8O

pmm

m q
PCM signal
pre-encoder
analysis

;?D`"!,&G:OY!S78($K*sE

T$$K,,&<*,* L+)K-B*,`$#"X<&S'&$#17

encoder-based
analysis

network
model

Encoder

D;4;5*,ml!#4!_$K

"45\`!#U$#,,5CK4&d:S5C#6*,G*,&#W!8 !\

6!'5CKS*,1D1&+n m ;&<$U&;SGID&+I*,,'4&
!#>$#X& ,1&:! q E b 3!<%D3!#_5CKG*,G*,&#W!?
9 ;
-;&G476?Y:O m l pq EJF-!(C#)+!Y78%&
o 
b c f 9<Q
Qd


;b c f 9q; r-/.10
 o 
5#C#'*,12*,&#W!x, o
Y

;b c f 9 ;
;b c f 9 ;
\&<$#,&#W2"s8 l m %DWB*4TW1N)Q q E

post-decoder
concealment
Components used with

F-!#`C#&#*,&W;!f78($#*,78*,,'_W178,3$K4,5#C#,1&f:O

EJM/!#S#5<5#,*4 0L3;:[V5CK*,1
]$K,&W8,&3?m!
*,&#W!U;: 

decoder-based Decoder
concealment

Decoder

PCM

reference / original
signal

perceptual
model

G.729

<;"1/-!(C%&3178#C#S,76?Y:OT\

:O76;&<?78"J,&8S!#,W1!";$#J78($#*KK&+;,&

m &#!<?!# lg#&+ !#;&<$K17D1?45*,YC%$2,&2!#

test
signal

data path
control path

!#,W1!"0;$#I78($#*, q EYM;S2!KB;=78($#*N-=!<%DB1E W#E

m l p#q P

speech quality measure

:OI

t m l

pq[vu

p#qJ 3
P
0

q P
3
3 L m 3
0




2

m l

&dv

O\Q?QB= h[\H# %=</%QUKRHKRO\%'?K1KN

m v q

(?#\N;<h(<%Q?#hKN'(%Q

M#Y!S\];*R%;=;:JVLK7z !>V7878;L6:[1&#* LG!#

ms
q )R-8&fC#2!VC#&*,&W;!y$#, 

2.2
Objective Speech Quality Metrics
lI&#*,41[!#Z1&(D&(,&<*178!($KN*,,Z! (4W&<;*,A;

5#C#,1&y:O6>,78*,G178CK;,1&x;:T!#G;78"V;:T!#

178781&#* LKC#%$ t ,*,5\278($K* m MR,WKEJ q r!<?"4~`!#

,76;I!#SC5(j,Dk+C<;*4 0L3;/*,1* L_/\1,5#*4B5+L678($K

KD(,1CB

*,=K+ m !5\4&#WG!#2+]?%$h;&<$#7D;45#*4',!

P=&#8<;""*4#)g!
B*,1 q E-F-!#&3!#
!

K155,*, L@:Y5\,&W>,&y;

%;&y5\`&x=!_(\gw

;asA<1R,-<s as'C*,U;&<$_;K?{K,76;$35+L`!#B78%&

*, m 3 5 3 587 q EV^I&* L>1&#_\;asA<1[,I<s as8*4

:OY!I;& ,1& ?

{K,P

38587 D

9 GdY

.:Y*48:T1&#`i%

. 0

myxG

;`;*4;%$

q 

m q

m sE E4)J!`*,12K155,* 

 0Ly:T&9?4D(,&W>'4',&#i<C#&%$f5+L@!6&+45#C#,1&

6!=;': !'k(C#C=5+LU6#D(,1C#S<;"1I;:!#';78
i%&$<;;85\!y!#GKD(4CV&<$f!#GCK&+2'
}| 3h&<$
5#C#0LU;,D*,: !#I?81)J ? q '!%Dz3C{

K| 3h!# t ,*,5\B78($#*R,%k+C,D1?

!(C#~ 3 | 3QE'M3 {

*,&+TG 0? m
"&1C#,*4*, q 78($K*H !~ 3 | 3 m &6*,1

*4;,& q E
Y4&3%k+C<;,&>v=-&U78C#I&_476?S:a;T!#S#5#
;5,*, LG:JV5#C#Y*,1Y*4&W!3:  </:OT2!,W1!#Y$K
78($K* #&(?,1&HP
t m l

p#q[p| 3

L m | 3 q

m q

,

1,JI?
mq )#&?D*N15(j,DBk+C<*, LG78%;C#?78#/2

*,,&W}!#@!(C76;&eC<$K LLK7_E.&1CK>D1;*,C<;,&|-

CY'5Kj,Dk+C<;*,,0L678%CKPR!#S[&!<;&$ p ($K X<%$

-?9K\;*-S,,&

m p

/K') v q

;&<$f!

%CK

76;*4,~,&#W_
*,+K mp
q $#"45\$@,&h!VT#\&<$K,{

..I;:/!2.F-lT0FT17878&$?4& n E 1 m ; q E3F-!20-
,&W

15(j,DBk+C<*, L678C#/;S\;%$`'!<%DI'DL6!#,W1!

;*4;,1&_ !3C#5Kj,DS)K!,/*]?,1&3=!I;&W1
:<C5(j,D ZC* JD*,C mp ^ q ,[*,1-I5\4&#WS*,,&%?
&$_!L_;B17878&<$#$_T5\,&W`C 5#*4B:a;S!BD*,CK
;,&_:Z\"!3$#W;1$K%$G5+L8&#78,4&3;4&`%*N&"
-;}&(D( 1&#78&+`C#"!;35#,G;_&$:O;78h"C#
m ()v q E}
!}78"42;_$#,&#378%;C#) sE 1E,)>"
C* ID1;*4C#';: ,78*,,I\":ak(C*, L+)<!#'*4?W1!#=D*,C#1)
!'-8!#2\!fk+C<;*,,0Lr4 m ,&fMR,WKE 8!%&@;{K,
 !>##%{K476?\1&<$K,&W p ^GD*,C q E/M;S;*4*H,72
C*4?4&S,&>!,I\T-'78*,%L+%$_5\;!r!78EYT!"L
LK,*4$#%$>DL3478,*4;C* 
  m !CW! p
eC#* W1&#*,* L
{K!,5#,$G*,YD1?];5,*, L q  1&#* LGK&+Y p
/KC#* E

3.
VOIP LOSS SENSITIVITY
MR,W1CK`3!%=!#8178\&&+;:/!878%;C#78&+"C
!,!c->4*,*C#rxD*,C<?>1C#_##;"!cx7V5,&#%$
&$KA&$r;&<$>!#5+LK!#1U*,1?D"Lr&<$r1&+*AEVF-!

!1$K%$35\%{KT!#%|!#178\&&+/,&_!B$#;V;!3!#

78"!&,78/;:[*4Y?DLG;*,+%?%$NE-FQ1W! !3!#
;;78:R!#S&"-;678($#* m ,&rv(E q &$`!#S\
#C*\78($#*-T15#;,&3B78%CK78&+ C8!,!3;*,*4%
C#I376;r`\,X n o/p
4W&<;*J,&#C#T_6\!@k+C*, L
78C#E
b

4.5

!#,*48C#,&WU_,78*,8&$KA&$r*,'!<? 

3.5

!#C#*,ZK&+%$B! --C#%$V 1

;&#R:a; !V,72
C#*4;%$=1&$# ,1&V:O T,&W*,Y\"!'78#*4 q EZF-!,[#+%$#CK
;!(C/,&+6C&+!<?Y!#,78<":J*,1Y1&U;&U4&#CK
,W&<*N76L6&;5\I!781W&C m sE 1E,)<=*45C#/ !#4&G1&#

Perceptual distortion

~;,1&N)KTW&";TB*4?W1I&(C#7V5\[;:Q*,1 <?& 5(L'C,&#W

$K
&+[%$K[:OZ!#-C$#;;&<$K17&(C7'5\RW&"; m :O

W178&+R;:(!<;Q,W1&<;*+%&B!?D1$#

&(H\#C<;*,78<;

clp=0.0
clp=0.1
clp=0.2
clp=0.3
clp=0.4

JL`?D1W4&#WV!C#*,;:Q!#I15(j,DSk+C<;*,,0L678%CKT:O

\":a76;&Y: !#Y($#Y1\?,&WBC&$#S;4&6&#
*,-1&$# ,1&NE b 78#*4%L+$2 t ,*45\"-78($#* m MR,W#E( q ; !#

2.5

1.5

!&U'*4T5#C#;:Z!S;784~S,!#,&U&#!"TW178&+ q E

D*/*,V<?&)[G!?D1G_*,45#*,3,&<$K4;,1&y:a;V!#

0.5

ulp=clp
0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2
0.25
0.3
unconditional loss probability

0.35

0.4

0.45

MOS

&#h78($#*[:a;V!8,7'C*4;,1&#)JB-6!<%D8:O1C&$h!<?

!#_!#4W!6;$#678($K*,6$#h&2#?D(]$K_7VC#"!9$$# ,1&*

O\Q?N`%aaO1Q?\9<=

,&K:a76?,1&HE

1(<ahKN3

3.1 Temporal sensitivity

3.1.1
PCM
b rX#_;&<;*,LK~r!>5\!?D(,1CK3:O4 *4

m ;

4.5

,!x;&<$>,!#1CKV*,1=&%;*,78&+%)Q!"6!#8*,1

1&%*,78&+J<;, ,1*4;%$6*,11&* L m \!8;,1&; L

no/p

i<%

(5#,"? q

C* G>15#;,&%$} !c!#`1&#%;*478&(3*,W !78E
MR,WC#

!%B!8%;` !C#=*,1'1&#%*,78&+=&5*,%$

,*,5\=78($#*[<?78"B;8D;,%$NE`F-!#VC#*,,&#W

\"!>k+C*, L_,T4&#& ,D8!*,1S$#,,5C#,&U<;;72

" my| 3 q EfF-!#GC#* 2;GD&x*,,W1!+* Lx$#%,&#Wh:a;6&

| H
3 )#\,&(,&#W'2=,W1& X%&+D;45#4*, L`;:Q!Y
C#* E.&UMR,W1CKVV!#C* ,!U*,I&%;*,78&+S?'$K
#,%$NE b !&G!*,1T*4?4& my| 3 q ,I*,%)\*,1T1&#%* 
78&(K?DK4$KYV,W1& X%&+T\:a;76&478K?D78&+%E[F-!#
*]?,Dh,78K;D178&+6,&%;G !,&,&Wx*,1 m ~ 3 q E
,&#%,&#W

| x
3 D*,C'!`%;V !9&<$f !C#V1&#%* 
78&(=5\1788,&,&W*,Lx,78,*4;V&$f!%
!#8786\
:O76;& ; | 3 KEZMR4WC# ;&<$/\,D* LB;*4Y&#
;,&6BC#D/!#?,&#WB!#\:a;76&YC#&<$K[!C#78#,1&
;: ;&<$K17*, m
&#1C,*,*,Z78($#*s)6~ 3 | 3 q ESF-!(C) &#
4$K,&W2BW1,D&(~ 3Q)K-I*,/<;"&`;:Z;*,"&<;,&#W
*, mAm 78($8v q m 78($2v q q 1C#*]$_&<5#*,B
1&4$K5#*4T\:a;76&#T,78K;D178&+ m  !( 
 P
)\Jk<E q E
38587 D
9 GdY

3.5
Perceptual distortion

&r1&* L>5\VC78$U:OB76;*4*Z,78=4&+D*, q EBYC* ?

m 1 q EK,78,*]?
!#%&>:OS!#V n o &*,78&+S;*,W1 !#7

!#

2O%Q\H>O\%>1\H

2.5

1.5
clp=0.0
clp=0.1
clp=0.2
clp=0.3
clp=0.4

0.5

ulp=clp
0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2
0.25
0.3
unconditional loss probability

0.35

0.4

0.45

M#2!#,W1!"

O \Q? (G%aOO"eH;\@0<=
hK _ K _

2O%eO\%3\R1(<4

4.5

YNJ:O1C#&<$S5+LSD(,C<;*1,&\"4&!<;N!J$K4,5#C#,1&#Q:(!#

\"#C* $#,,&fD1;*,CS:O'1&V*4'1&<$K 4&f7
;K?{K,76;*,LB:O1*,*,?dI&;76*K$#,,5CK,1&V/78*,%L=78%&
;&<$2;&<$?$8$#D(4;,&2B$#,5\!/?4,%;*\D1?45,*, L
;:I!#378%;C#%$yD*,CEMR,W1CK>uU#&+V!#3\#C*
$K,,1&'R,&B!J#D(,1C#HXW1C#J5CKZ;*4YW1,DJ!J&$;$

Perceptual distortion

3.5

2.5

1.5

$KD(4;,1&hS"5;I:OS!#=\,DV*,11&<$K 4&HE.

!#%R!J4&#%;4&#WID;45#,*4 0LB:K![C* R !B4&#%;4&#W

*,T;*4;,1& my| 3 q )(!,*,S!ID1?];5,*, LG$#+&#7z

0.5

!<;&W87VC!>,!f&f,&"%,&W>;781C#&(B;:/*,1

m ~ 3 q EG^I&

&T!<&$2!,-\1,&+=1781)+!#1C#W1!8-%;\)#& ,DK 0L8,!

W;$yr!W1&# L m sE 1E,)- V76;=!,"!;r;:T!#
\"!c,W&<*

m D1,$<;C#&(D1,%$ q

{K\,&Gf5#C#6*,1 q E

^I&'!!#!&$V !#?)1!<;S*4;WT&(C7'5\[:N$K

&+

clp=0.0
clp=0.4

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2
0.25
0.3
unconditional loss probability

0.35

0.4

0.45

O\Q? ;O#ZaaO<>%Q[(;1(R%QURa<?%]\
8OdO\%81<R1(<sr# U K HU

resync time (frames)

4.5

Perceptual distortion

3.5

2.5

frame position

1.5

clp=0.1
clp=0.3
clp=0.5

0.5

0.05

0.1

0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
unconditional loss probability (ulp)

0.35

0.4

O\Q?_NB8KHRH;<RO#%O\9%shhay;<hK;T<-%H
>gh>H#HHK'(V%H3O<%=<  1\Q#1Q%O\G0?\r#

0.45

O<Q? `%aaOz1Q?\d09Q}>gh<e1NQK

@ ;s'V@0RR%O\d<Y;<hU[\%O%]\

m &$r&#I1&* LU1&C#,1& q

Loss of
1 frame
2 frames
3 frames
4 frames

1\?,1&B,&U!Vk(C*, L>;

78&+%E

*,S<?&Y,T&#?L_:a;2;,&r\"!U;78*,!&

C#,&Wy15(j,D>\!k(C*, L78%CK78&+2x;G!#
,78;:[*4V,;sA61&3C\#,1&NE

3.1.2
t E uvw

3.2
Sensitivity due to ADU heterogeneity
n o/p
,[Y7878LK*,R&#($#,&#W#E[F-!#:a;-!TSlx&(&(
,I&* L_-(* LU!"1W1&C m MR,WC#Vu q EIF-!KC#)\,&U!,T
,1&V1&#&+;1&'! t E u1;
v wS($#EJF-!/{K\,78&+Z-
%?L'C#[,RI78C# ! L#&#"!K1&#4~;,1&V,78 :<!#-$#"
($K[;:]  1&#CK4D1 :O;78Z?*,1%E[F-!# t E u1v;wI$K($#"

G.729

m u? q C#B! o 1&;jC#W;3(C#C#6Y*,W15K, o ($K

Z{K %$3N,&%? n %$K,,1& mo + o J n q ($#,&#WV!78I&<$
\;B;B6(5 ";EB.0& t E uvwK)R`\"!U:]78V,  78T4&
$KC#?4&HEGM;'!@:O;781)Q!#

,Z4$=T!<%DJLK&!#1&#,~%$,!=! &($KZ!&=!#&K

W;L8: !;-,W1&*<:a*,*,/5\*,?}1&#T\&+;:N!#T&W;L
:[!#'$K($K%$_,W1&<;*R !1CKT:]78=*,1 m !#,I,Tk(C#,D1;*4&(

E uvw_&#($#"2;&<* LK~!#

,&#C#$?&$2{([!<?78" ;:\! o ($#T[{K %$
N,&%?

n %$#,,&

mo nq

>_,W1&* A&4`;, mq 

 !#!#1*4$f:Tv , q E>F-!
4q ,'78CK%$r&f
;',W&<* &"WL m &<$>!(CS! #

78($#*JC!y;'*,,&%?2K%$#,,1&

X* 2+"8,&+2;&<$y{K ;,1&xDE b !#&x_:O786,

*,;C#$N)(! t E uvw2$K($K/C-!I;;78-;:

\A:O;78S5<;,E-MR,W1CKBwV!%!IL#&#"!K1&#4~;,1&3,78

m {K#%$84&8!#T&(C7'5\J:N:O;78-&%$#%$8C#&(,*K!!#!K

!#3KD(4C2:]78Gh,&("\1*4;3!#1_;:I!#3*,18:]781E

F-!#G*,,&G\;*-<;,V+84&( m R n?q :Y!6*48W+($

1*4$8, "{#%$#$ q *,%$8;W;4&#-!\,,&`;: !*,1 m sE 1E,)
!`,&<$K{y:Y!6XV*,12:]78 q :a8$#
&+2D*,C#V;:  E

:]78=;S\%;%$U;&<$G!#SW;,&U+8,&+I;S1&3:O7

F-!I\!G;78*,S,/#($KC%$65+L`=76;*,S\%1/!S&

m ~C q &# 4&_+CKT,&`!,W1!+!`:O78E

!#-#DK,CZ:O;78/5C#Q!L';$#78\%$SW;1$#C*,* L'$#C

!# -,78<;%E b

C&(D,%$<?D1,$

!&6S:O;78*4+C#)+!Y$K($#"-%;&&;

C# $?3 2;)C#*,,&#W@,&}r$#,D"W1&#3;:S&#($#8&<$

$K($K`;1EF-!(C#)/`?U&6&* L9,&(($KC$}$#CK
,&#Wr!#G,78G\"4($yK&+%$x5(Lh!GC#&+':O78G5CK
;*,G,&3!#B:O1*,*,%4&#WG&E.0&U1$#$# ,1&U2!,78Y:[!#
78,,&Wy($#$#)T$K4;,1&c,G,&#%$d5(L9!U78,,&W
C# $?U:!UK%$#,;GX* `7878,8:a;G!#U*,4&#>\
;*< 8;&<$y!`*,4&#%;6K%$#,,&LK&+!,VX* 87878;
,E MR,W1CKB'!#?-!;/:O,78,*]?&0-;`1&<$K 4&-!#
C##C#Bk+C<;*,,0L>: ! t E uvw28,S-;2!<;& n o/p
,!h*,1
1&%*,78&+%)$#78&;,&#W=!#S178K,1&GDCk+C*, L
$#;
>C&$#<-*4EJ.&+,&W* L8!I*,/*4?4&
my| 3V;;78 q !R78,78<;Z1&B! \!Vk+C*, L+);!%/
D%)Q!#2
"B4%r\1,&+,&W3U`;4&h15C#&B;:
t E uvw'($# !`W1;$2B!/,*,4&L8=1&#CK4D1

!#

B*,1V$KC'G!2,&+&<;*[*4B1&#%*,78&+%E8Y1&#
5\"W3!<;$#&V`,78,*4;{K\,78&+ m w? q )Q!#?,&#WG!<?I!#
$K
&-5\&B!J,W1,&*#&<$! 1&#%;*4$',W1&*(,!
,&#%,&#W3*,1S5#C#,&S,&>"78I:878%&Kk(C;%$_"
,=,W1& X%&+%)[!%D%E_F-!,2$K781&#;!8,78\;&
;:Q\"#C*<78"4 !,!`;T5*,B4&#*,C<$KT&*,78&+

R n `;>;&!#`#&(?,1&d;:!U*,,&%?3K%$#,,1&

+8,&+E
F- t E u1v;wV:O78T?1&+;4&#%$3,&_'<%E

[%;&BZ:O17gMR,W1C# w!<?H!#[\1 ,1&=:#:O;78 *,1H!<;

b

64W& X<&+S,&#iC&#=1&U!C#*,,&#WG,W1&*J$#W1$#;,1&C)

!,*,'!#V$KW$?4&h,S&#T!<;I& ,D=`!#=*,&#W!r:
!':O78V*4B5C#  E6F-!#2*,1B:-C&(D1,$>:]78B78
9!<%Dhx?!376*,*,78<"_1&!r,W1&*=$#W;1$#;,1&
&$@!`$#($#'?DB!6?G,&#:O76?4&y:s'!"
;:]%E F-!*,1;:ZD1,$`:O;78/%;CY'*4?W1I$#W;1$#;,1&
:!#_\!d,W1&*I&<$x!>$K($#"G&#%$K8783,783
LK&!#&,~=,!>!=&$#%EBT?D%) !#'*,1;:-D,%$
:O;78Z?Z&BC#&KD11,%$;D4%$S& ,1&=*,%1$KQYY,W& X<%;&+
$#W1$#;,1&6;:N!#/,W1&<;*sE b

!<%D-\%?%$V!{K\,78&+

:a;S$K
&+76*,;&<$G:O76*,\%;Y&$G15K,&$3,784*4?
C#*,EyFR(,&Wr,&(h1C#&('!`C%$y($K,&Wr"!#781)[!
5\?D'!#&78&&r1C*4$r5\V{K*4;4&#%$rS:a*,*4%P=
%C#
D4%$@1C#&<$K!<%D83!#,W1!"B&W;Lh!&hC&(D1,$rC&<$K)
!B*,1T:JD4%$_:O78T%;CI8*]?W1I,W1&<;*[$#W;1$#;,1&
!<;&r!#V*,1B;:-C&(D,%$U:O78E2I%D%)H$#C#'`!V\"
,($#,_K1\0Ly:TD1,$9C&<$K) !#_$K($#"8%&x&*

b !,*,31&91&#G!&$y3`!<?

78%CK2:]&$#
&;>*]?f-*,*B !C5(j"4D1f\!k+C<;*,,0L+)1&e!
!#Z!&<$S!#*4;W/$#
&#R,&B! #4 A!#!#1*4$K5<;%$
LK&!#&,~%?4&_,78S*,%;* L3\1,&+Y224W& X<&+Y478
1&3C5(j,D\"!3k+C<*, L+E

F-!,/;781C#&([1$K4&#W!Y*4-:QU 'W;,&

m ,&G'?4,%;*Q&# q EJMR,W#E %
0 V<;"1/:Q!I;78Ti?

p0(avg)
p+1(avg1) p-1 (avg1)

!%J!/&KD1&+4&<;*TJ$(12K15<;5,*, L2C#D m 3 { ;

:aC#&,&V:!/%D;W1/k+C#C-,~ :a ;*4*#;,D*,#+ o q )!#4!
,I;#*4,%$`8*,*QC#&76?%$ m  q ?8 m 5<;"(WC&$`;21P

-F q E
F-!3&;Lx*4;,1&#!,}5\"-&!#_$KK155,*, ,
:a;I/76?%$3; 6;&<$} 2%;&_5\B$#"4D1%$3;Y:O1* 
*,% m &!<?-!,J*4;,1&#!,3,-D*,4$`5\;!`;-!#T&$KA

2 maxp

&$6*,D1*\&$8DLV4&$#,D(4$#C<;*<! q PRH+

+M{H+

+ L
5\/!?D;*4*&KC#7V5\[;:N78 %$V<;"1 5+LV&`MZFyi<%c;&<$
+M  x R5\!#=&(C#7V5\;:[<Y5\*,1&#W1,&W86

-1

maxp

0
+1

min th

maxth

avg
avg 1

;,&'*4; m !J!= T*4Z;\1&$#Q m C&#76;$ q

+
+ V V ;&<$61&K
5\
B;8 q EF-!#&H)+ !+

L

4$#,&#Wr!;V!#8C* ,&WrD(,3!'>5\`5\2"

8,&
!I*4&W27_)(!<%D1P

O<Q?@HBHGP K?K %O<IQ?<9R?<RRaaO%]#2

hQR1%O<d<T(\(?<HQKQ_%OK

+ { 3 { +
3

+

3
L L

m
q
+ V V 3

3
L

3
L

!#S*,1/;:ZD1,$6:]78-*,*H&S /!/5#,&#%$GCK8,&+

,&K:a76?,1&r1&U!7_ETF-!#V$K($#"S:s;4*,I`&%;*R!=*,1
;:ID11,%$f:O;782?8;&yC&(D1,$<;D11,%$f&# 4&x5\%C#
 6?78#B>1&#%;*-!`*42:TD4%$f:O782C,&WU!#
X* +2,&+&$U!#'"{#,?,1&>:a=;&>C&(D1,$>C&$NE
p

;?D%)(5\C-!#

E u1vw&#($#"C#JS78;D(,&WI%DW

X*  K%$#,J!D*,C ;:N!#/*,4&#T\*<  &<$2&* L

;&78 !#S$#
&T5\&6!T*N&$`K%$#,%$8D* 
C#)H,;`*,B: ,78':a;!V$#($KGL#&#"!K1&#4~
 !3!#I&#($#"T&I,Y!-:s;,*4$G25C#,*]$8!SK1K]?
*,,&;T#%$K4"4&3X<* %E

4.
b

QUEUE MANAGEMENT FOR INTRAFLOW

LOSS CONTROL
!,*,BB!<%D!,W!*,,W1!+%$3!& ,DK 0L_: 1. n ;2B

+3 {
m +

v3 {

+M{ q 38{
3

m q

SC#3h!#42*]?,1&!#,c5\&!#U$K}K15<;5,*, Lx:a;

 x&$0 f<;"")-->$K,W1&<?U!,6k+CC#_76&W1"
78&+[;*4W !7B0S
&+4*,I[ m S
TJ q E1MR,WC# %
!%8!G\1&<$K,&Wf$(19#5<5#,*4 0LC#DE9SC#G
+
+ V V ,&6$$# ,1&8!&(D&#


L

,1&* I[5\!<%D(,1CK%)K!#TI,

T[e,78#*478&+;,1&6!C*4$
*,B781&# J!Y &$ ;,D*<K+E[.:\!/;,B:
!&<$K,,&`;:H+

 <;""I?S8W?/LU,T& m  !"S$KC878,

5\!?D(,&W8i?IB8,W1&#,X%&+&(C#7V5\T:Ji<%I!#4!>!<%D
* %$KLr{K\,&#%$h*,'?B%;*,,=! q !# *,=K15K
5#,*4 0Lf,V$K%;%$y&$h!G K155,*, L@4=,&%$y?
!;78S,78S!KC#$#W;1$K4&#W2!D(,:a;S;*,*RCEF-!
!<$#%$h;%;V;5\?D8&$h5\*,%!2g{ m + o q CKD m MR,W#E % q
!%!\;,&#W8;%V!#&G!#,Y,&U4Y$$#$NE

!#U$#,,5CK,1&};:*,1`,&!3*];`,1&#)/-_&#?-&+

m ; q
65K4"iL_,&+($#C#=6k(C#C76;&<;W178&+Y78!<;&,7

.&9 ?
 !5\&r!%&>!<?BC,&W`1&#*,LU!#V&(D&+,1&<;*

!#,"!f,=5#*,2_&#:O8!#V*4;,D8K:a&=:!8;#

TJ

#*,4;,1&_ !3W1;$GV*4E

G1&4$KVi?= !9=76;$h ! h&$0
 m ;/$#,5\%$84&6!Y,&+($#C"4& q 2:aW1C#&<$8;8
m MZF q &$2!" m 5\-
; q i%-V5<;"(W;1C&$V;8
b

m
F q E n T76;(,&W#),&h$$K,,&_`1,&#W2!=$# ;5*,

%D"W1`k+CC2,~"+ o :a;VI,

T[z1\?,1&f,=&
C#2,&+%EF-!#4`,`$#C_h!U\&(4;*4* L78,4&#Wy*]?
,1&8;:N!#178#C#%$*+M o D*,C5\0-&81&#C#,DT ;&<$
;,D*,)J\4*,* Ly!&x!#6!<;`:Y!`MZF;8`,
*,%E3Y!,78,W1!+C* =,&f3C#&#:a '$#,,5C#,&f:/*,
5\0-&h!8MZF&$@
-F:O;,1&)JG\ X<I+ o
D1;*4C#8,

78C#$5+L};78*,,&Wf!#>k(C#CU,~r1&#* Lc;3MZF;,D1;*

K1\0Ly:I;3W1W;W?,1&} !,&x!`&0-;y3

,&;&(E F-!(C)#V"DK,B$K
&+4;,1&`:a:OW;1C&$G;:]

K1\%$r5+LG!=.JF/M}S

&+4;%$hK"DK,S;! "C#1)

X<,\1,5#*4B!,!U$#+Y&#T$#

:]171&(D&(,&<*NTJ
5\!?D(,1CKY4&`!S*,&W27
%D"W1 m sE 1E,)<,&G!#m~ 3 q E

,T{K*,1 %$_!#81&(DL`!,&+;Ai?e%k+C 78&(;:J
i%EY- /!C*4$G5\I%D14$#$6'4&+($KCY$K,&WV;:Q!#
8;:Bri?,&9!_&#f-U1&4$K678!<&#,78
:O-!#T76;&<;W178&+ :Q4&#W1*,Sk+C#C !G$K
&+-K4; L
*,D1*,E ^I&Y##;"!2S*,,~I,&+Ai<%9D(,I$K
&+4;
m TJ|,!G. &<$G^IlSFI,)
,&_C,&WVV,&W*4Bk+C#CT4Y.^
? q E b  !fY.^')N-_?D1WGk+C#C8,~'=&W14&y,&#
m !#,W1!fK4; L q
$K,%;;V?`178CK%$NPB&SjCB:a;'!#8.
m *,?K4; L q
6;&<$9&;!8:O`5\!9.
&$d^IlIF

5. INTRA-FLOW LOSS RECOVERY AND

CONTROL
5.1
Temporal sensitivity
o 1&#4$#,&W'Ii<%9 !678\*#*,1& ,DK 0L+)+<?W;!

E

KE E !<;R!%&!<?Z478#*,1);\,($#,*,1Z;&&!<;&

![\:O76;&[:(!#J&<$KA;0&<$I*,1H?DL+EHF-!J<?&

5\&8$#4W&%$=$#"%-!#n~ 32&25+L';,C#*]?[i<%?

,~%?4&3 !3!T,&(($KC$G78,/,Y#*,,%5#*4E .0&`!#,

!#B{K\&B:J;!Yi<%EY.&_!#4-;\)\!%-D%)<=-&+
>@!I~ 3;'W,D&y5+Lf;!'<?78B!,*,`78($# 

<?W;!=-/;C78!;[i<%x{K#%$= R78\;*(&K

n 876?%$x`^IlIFz;U$(1#\%$9;*,, m 4&

"78T;:Z!=%DWVk+C#C,~ q !<;&_. EY.^g!

:]LK4&#Wr!#6*46$#,,5CK4&y:a'!6:a;WC&<$y;2

m MZF q E

, &#[,%$';,C*4?)1!#:OTI\Ai<%9"!;;

 ,DK 0L@5+Lr76;(,&W_ Bi<% !x&y;*,"&<;,&#WU<;"&f:



+ 0 KE

runlength model (m=2)

10
Drop Tail
DiffRED
Drop Tail (estimated)
DiffRED (estimated)

burst loss length rate gk, estimated burst loss length

10

Drop Tail
DiffRED
Drop Tail (estimated)
DiffRED (estimated)

10

burst loss length rate gk, estimated burst loss length

10

10

10

10

10

10

10

10

10

runlength model (m=1): Gilbert model

10

O<Q?<<

5
6
burst length k

B hR#O\

<}<1%H<x<R

10

10

O\Q?hN

K%sh#K

5
6
burst length k

= rR;a\

10

<c1%Q9R#sh#

RQ;6O\%2OKQ%d?KV2h0RR1O\d<YZQ;8OKQ%
 %H;(r#>QHOKQ<HR#rHH#

ZQ;8]\%8OKQ<%d?#KV<VhQR1%O<d<ZQ;6OKQ<%
 "=f>;RH]#H<%HQ<KehNQKSGa]J(?;

MR,WC# 1 ;&<$ vV!%e!I?Y:O!B;C<;*R;&<$`!#

,76?%$r5#C#*,=*,&#W!#I:a;V6!#"0? ms

v q ;&<$r

0- ; ms
) t ,*45\" q 78($#*J\,D*,L^1E b `%&

5.2
Sensitivity due to ADU heterogeneity
.&<?W;!c(E E vh-U!?D1_&}!;6&# 4D( L9yYSl
!"1W& 0L3C#*,Y,&U2;,&U&1&K\,($#,B*4I;&NE
F-!(C)=}78"!&,7
? m r&; q !@&<$K>,r&#?L

5D1I!<?S
I[g!\-!#S5CK/#5<5#,*4 0LGC#DT4&
!#_$K %$9-%L+E p 6:S!#3#5<;5,*,,0Lx762,8&&#

!,!d$K,DV!;8;&x:O7!GD1,U$#;(EdMCK!

m !24$#*[5\!<%D(,1CK-1C#*4$h5\V!#

+C#&#8:-1&* Lh,1*4;%$h*4 mFr
q !,!f%&h5\8{(
K%$2 ! | 3 ,&6"78 ;: t ,*,5\78($#*<;;78 q E

?%$@?B,1*4;%$f*,

,!>I>FR,*[;&h;K?{K,76;*,L3W178,%*,* Lr$#%,&#W

5#C#=*,1'#155#4*, Lr !y,&%;,&WU5CK=*4&W! m k<ER q
,_5#;4&5#*4)I!"r!# | 3<;;7834`*4;,D* L*4;W
b

!#1C#W1!HErF-!(C#)[1&#]$K,&WrD1,8 !y78\;**,1V& 

,D( Lr;S!':OW;1C#&<$r?82;:-,&+%)N,!hS
I[
*4?W1&(C7V5\"R: !#J;&&%LK,&WT5C#[%;&V5\$#%$VW;,&
G*]?W1=&(C7'5\S;:/,1*4;$f*4'&<$>:a*,1&#W_*,1B5CK
m !#,"!U+C#I!#&_!=k+CC,TC#&<$KT78\;LG?D*,$N)
sE 1E,)C+ o

9

+ 8y )<MR,W#E % q E

/%&V/!<;[!#-!#?/78($#*(,76;,& m k<Ev q 

iN!RY;%;Q:(!#JI,
T[y1\?4& m ![!<?B$K1
b

;:\!-5#C#[*,1[*,&#W!V?-:a V

vT&<$B!/$K%;Y*,1&#W

  v q EJF-!#, 

SW178"4*,* L8$#%,&#W';LK78#-:O (
&&#'5\8%KC#%$h5(Lr!20-U?`78($K* m k<EH q !,"!
!(C#T?D476?T!#B5C#I*,1S*,&#W!_;B:a; G v8&<$
!#&@!(C#W1* LrC&$#,76?S B:a 
v+E6.&+,&W* L+)H:O
T1hFR,*s)Q!#4*,25\;!h78($K*,S%;#C#=!'!<\': !2;
C*-C#D1)[!#`*,%-"8$K278($K*,278;G;CK;`4&y!#
476?,1&HE_F-!,=%&y5\8{K#*];,&%$f;=:O1*,*,%P8 :/!85CK
*,Z*4&W!=#5<;5,*,,,[?-,&:s"[*,1TYW178"4*K$#,
,5#C#,1&N)K!#I,76?I,/78Y15C#/ :Z;*4*H$?=,/,&*4C$#%$
m &#/!<?[!-C&K*4&W!V5<$2##%{K476?,1&8:\!#/1&$# 
,&<*Q*4TK155,*, L3

m !

ef !

cUq 1
 &#*,LG,&*,C$#Y*,1
PJJk<E q E

C#&#*,&W;!3+C#&#*4;W1"I;Tk(C* 

b `1&* L9$K4C2!`C* 6k+C<;*,,?,D* Lx!`hW,DU&

"{;78*,V!#%
;&@,&+;Ai<%*,1B&+1*J*,W1; !7\:a;78
;&<$6'!#?e!#?*,Y78($K*,-%;&3%;#C#T!,-\:O76&#1E
I,*,21&y!#G,7VC#*4;,1&x&;,h&<$y;78"V%;&x5\
:O1C#&<$3,&@ v?AE

78)<;&_{K*,, I+1\?4&>5\&_&$KA&$G;&<$3!#1K

5+L(0!#1`78!<&#,78-,T&#?L m MR,W#E q E
ICI!#IC* ;:Z<?W;!U(E v=2$KD*,13V&"<
76;(,&WY!78J%*,*,%$VK\! n \L(0
-$V(*,,D-S :]
:a"&+];* n  p ;(,&W m n J

0I.MZM p T q E F-!>S.MZMQ
p T
!78'&&(?I!#'!#4W!S#, L_<I1&
b

!2:]78'&+4*_!#8\!y,W1&<;*/&$h*,,V&f!

$#($#% Y1&#%;*478&(/:OT!#/:O;78E
MR,W1CK `!%I!#',78*,V*,W1;,!#7/ &r4&r6C$#;
($K`!;2,'C%$fr$#2;&xC&(D1,$<;D11,%$ m ~C q &K
 ,1&x&$hKB!#8D1,%$r:O78'?B!25\W,&&,&#WU:
D4%$@,W1&*sE>F-!6K+%$#CK>\ a2,BC%$hU*]; :OL
>5*,+"y;:  :]786;2D1,$N) C&(D1,$N)JI~Cr&#,,&HE
"\^Y,-C%$8=&<$`=5#*,+"8;:  O: ;78/B,&W*4I<
m  !
 3+ #)T 93  q E

 !c!r##1K4;r#, L

T/!#=*,W !7W1,DY1&#* L_25#4&;LG76;(,&W8$K,,1&

m #;!#V<;"1B&# q )N-278*,%LrG,78*,2;*,W1 !#7
S&$=!#&;Lh0 S<;""R:a 78\&?4& m Jk<E q P
;:]I5CK ;: + S<;""J!J5\&'&+%)+S;\1&$#,&W
&(C7'5\Z: ; <;"1[4J&+[,7878%$#4?* L+E[(?5\C#[!
&;Lh&(C7'5\:5\&+B 3<B,BK,&@!
D&(!;!= n
c;*4W !7,W1WT!#&{(Y+ 85C#
5\:OB*,*  V<;"1-&;L`:a;178\&;,&3?S&+%E
F-!(C)N&r?DS,78=,&("D1;*4T!,"!h;'*,1&WG178;%$_
!8 5#C#,78)N!878%;&h*,=:O=!Vi?,*,*5\
m k<E q E
,'`#0$KX<&#%$
D*,CG&$9$KX<&#=!%z76;&(Lh:O;782?V!`5\W4&#&,&W>;:S
D4%$U4W&<;*[;'65\=#;%$ E^ICKI,7VC#*4;,1&# m MR,W#ENw q
%k+C<;*ZG!V15\B
;_%;

!<%D`!%&x!<?V!6&#W1`:O17
% fv ?_;##4;
D*,C:a; m $K\&<$K,&WV&_!&#`*4T1&<$K 4& q E.&
!I47'C*4;,&/#&+%$G5\*,%)S!+1

2

v+)<=LK,%;*

W4

Marking Scheme

qFqO Fqn
 q
FF qWq F  Fqn
dFOI1
 qFF
d1qq d
W
P<n W qI1
<n W qzqn2dF< <M
FWM F<n2W#1
 F
FWM F<n2<q1
Wd
 F
Fd Fqnd11
WdF<
qn2dF< <qn WF< <2
Wd

Network Model

NO MARK

FULL MARK

p0

+1 +1 +1 +1 +1 +1

+1 p

0 +1

SPB MARK

+1 +1

ALT MARK

+1

SPB DIFFMARK

+1 +1 -1 -1

ALT DIFFMARK

-1

0
+1

+1

+1

+1 p
+1

-1

p-1

+1 -1

+1 -1

+1


 qFF W OF<dF <2
Fd Fqnd11
W
qn2dF< <qn WF< <2
 F
P<n W qI1
<n W qzqn2dF< <M
FWM F<n2W#1
 F
FWM F<n2<q1
Wd
Wd
WW

;HOQ_%;Q#hKYRr1<??#[\QRaQ>Q(

*,>;*4*,%
`%&<5#*,GD*,C;,1&f;:!%*,1'4&h!`
*4T;
!S\:O76;&;:Z!B n

0;*4W !78E
M;[T$K Z78<?4&= !V n
S.MZM p

Yz2)"- D1;*,C<;

3!78'!8=;6;*,"&<;,&#W1* Lf76?%$rB5\,&W

 !" ;  +  m IKFS.MZM p Yz2)MR,W1CK q E b -:aCK
!"78S,&*4C$#I*]?%$3,&+Ai<%e*,1Y#,1&_!78E
m MRlSQ
p T2)T*,*
F-!fX#>"!#78@C#U:aC#*4*=#;,1&
<;"1;S76?%$6/  q EF-!#B n
 p T!78T1K
?2,78,*]?* Lfh n
S.MZM p Yz2)Q5C#'&c r<

W q

O\Q?yMN=

O\Q?_H

=<;rHH#O1

G K

(KRQ9=NQ

;T&+ :O/178\&#;,1& m !T;T*,'76?%$8;

 q EhM;V78<?4&f-`W1,&xCG_"!#782!"`+
`;>;* &<?4&#W1* L76;%$965\,&#Wf !6 y;G 
m IKF p T q EHMR4&*,* L+)[<;""=;:CK815\'
_i%

D*,C#=:OS,&+;,D'\"!U;&78,,1&T?DI!#B.&+&"

m v _ :#C$#,Y$?\"Q q EQf*]?W1R&KC#7V5\N;:  -1C#*4$

p T%;h,&
;r$(1\$ !}!UK15<;5,*, Li38{ m ^
MR,W#E q EGM;B!` n
76;(,&WG"!#78S!#2\&+;W16:

!#*,U6$#CB!#*4;,DV?D"!%$_:[!=#;+1*Z!#%1$K

+

5#C#-*,V,&"%-!#T,~%?4&3$K*4L6&$676; &<$K

Q&$h0 76;$'<;"1R\,D*,L',[ :OJ!

\!V76?4*KC%$ E b  15K,&%$'478,*4;J76?K,&#WT\&+

*]; X<%?4&_;&<$V4D1-&*,78&+,&8%;T;:Q *,1

m $KCI2V*4;W1"I*,1YW; q 78S$# 8C#*,%E

76;6{#;* L

5.2.1
End-to-end simulation description
ICB`!#'&#1&#\,($K4'*,1<?&H) V&%$_G{K#*4, * L
;+4;66$KU#5<5#,*4 0L_ !h8,&W*,V<;"1I !,&r&
&<$KA;0&<$x78($#*sEcF-!#:OU-UC#Uh;?U1&"0?
p ??Dy78($#* m
&#1C,*,*,78($#* q r$K,5\G!#G&#
5\!<%D(4C#`;8&}5+Ly!}*46;:S<;"1Ed1
6
;
 m $#,W1&;%$65+L2 =4&`MR,W#E q ?I$(1#\%$2,!8!#
K155,*, Lm3C{)+!-76?%$' !9
?V$(1#\%$G !>#155#4*, ,I;:H3

';&<$y0 
 \,D* L+E


;&<$3 L
F-!#, , I%&<5#*,T;C78K4&8 !VW1;$VS!/,&+$K

\&<$#& :!#-$K,

"&+Z*4[,&B:s"%)+Z Z!Z5\&'!#?&
m MR,W1E  ;&<$ v q ;"!#,DV3:s 6;781C#&(=;:

!;'S
I[

$K;*4;,1&d;:= &<$x 8*,1E D1!*,2
,&#*,C<$#r178>;*4;,1&e5\0-&d!#>*43h!%D>

3

% L 38{S:OI!#BC5k(C#&+Y47'C*4;,&ETF-!,I!#1C#*]$

F-!9##1K4;&#h;:6!y,78*,x&<$(A&<$e78($#*,,&W

C#%$G!5\&G,&KD1,W;$3,&@ v%Q !U$#,"D&+/,7VCK
*4?4&>C,&W687VC#* ,!#1G\1*,1W;L>&$U$#;,*4$_78($#*,,&W8;:
:OW;1C#&<$U&$G5KW;1C#&<$`?81CKE

W:a;';!S\!@78#*,E8F-!#8IKFg76;(,&W`!78

;

:Q! Y<;""5\,&Wf

KE

5.2.2
Results
MR,W1CK % !%B!2\"#C* $#,,&f:a=!V76;(,&W
!78Y$K\&<$K&+1&_!#B$K13#155#4*, L3 { E-F-!BC&##
m  ^
p T q !<Y!B!,W!\"#C*Z$K,

$>

,&U&$6!(C-!#TY\!_k+C<;*,,0L^E F-!$K,

"&+];*
76;(,&W9!78 m n
S.MZM p Yz q 
>9,W1& X%&+* L
5\B\"!@k+C<*, LrD1&r!#&f&* LrC,&W33&0-;r"
D(,S!,!>781C#&+-815\Y
;84&G!*,1&#W27_E 
!<?B!8T#FS.MZM p Tz76;(,&WG;W;Lf$K+'&#'$# :]
:a"Y:]17
!#S15\
2 m !,!3&#X#78!IC* :
<?W;!VKE E v q E- n
J0I.MZM p T},[;*4ID&=5\Z!&
![,&+Ai<%xISIKF p T9!781)?\4;*4* L:OR!#,W1!"
D*,C/;:C3 { EJF-!SC#* /D1;*44$#;I!#I;WL`:ZC#Y n

76;(,&W!78Q!<?[$#Y&;Z%k+C<;*4* LB76?*,*(<;""Q !V
!,W![K4; L=5CKR;!#[#;JTC#5[;::]78R!;J;
&+4*(T!#\"!Vk(C*, L+EQF-! n
JMZ o !78 m v? q )

b !<%D*,=\:a;78%$V,&#:O76;*<*,4&,&W[!,!81&K

X78$6!#SC* C,&W'!S5Kj,D78,E

:a;7$# * LrB!#4!f?85<;%$@1&h*,4&#%;=K%$#,,1&NE6M;

n o/p
 !C#=*,1=1&#%;*478&(B8!<%D2:aC&$r!<?=,=&# 

3.5
Perceptual distortion

!"I{K!#45# Y,W& X<%;&+I78\;*Q& ,DK 0L_&;I& ,DK 0L

SPBFEC
NO MARK
SPBMARK
SPBDIFFMARK
ALTMARK
ALTDIFFMARK
FULL MARK

4.5

`<LK*411$U!"1W& 0L+E

b  !>*4S&%;*,78&+%) !%-D1%)

!V\!yk+C<*, L>,B,&%$f5#C#S!#878C&+:-4&#%;
{K!,5#,G1&#W978\;*S& ,DK 0L+E

M#;785<$d($#

78#*,,:]Lf&y1&6!&<$@!#8,78<"V;:T*,V5+L@"2K1W?

,1&N)+!1C#W1!61&8!#T;!!<&$2C!6($#,&W=!78J!*48
\:O7
*,/1&#%*,78&+5(LV{(\*]?,1&`:Q$#($K/?1E
o 1&+?Lyr;78*,5<;%$y($#V-G!<%D`!%&x!<;'!

2.5

&%;*,78&+[\:a;76&-:<!# t

E u1v;w$#($#[76L>5K%(

;Y&# 4&Y,!#,&_!B\!U,W1&<;*R!%D%)#!KC#!%/

,&W2&W2& ,DK 0LG2L#*,11$3!#1W&,0L+E
1.5

!%D5#,i#LG,&+($#C#%$_Vk(C#C76;&<;W178&+;*,W1 !#7

b

!,!>4I5#*4B61&+*R*,1S;&#Y !C#I"!&W,&W8!

78C&+`:=*,13&<$d!<?"4~%$c,G\:a;76&#U:aG!

0.5

*,1&+1*R;:-8i<%{K!#45# 4&#W878\;*R& ,D( L+EF-!#&
0

0.05

0.1

0.15
drop probability parameter p0

O<Q?MNT(;1(R%H< 3a<?%O\

r;HOQy%;Q#hK'<Q

0.2

-`$KD*,1\$y_&<;""'76?(4&#W_!788%;*,*4$xK\!

n 1\0LK0
-;%$K*4,DxS
&+4* n ;"1 p ;(,&Wc:a;

0.25

U'<G%Q

&2,&+U#;,1&e:=:O;785<$($#E

F-!y n
J
S.MZM p T!781&#&+;!B!#4W!T#,;,0L3+
 1&8!/:O;78&+];*<!\!8,W1&<;* &$8*4,1&
!6$K($K% '&*,78&+B:a'!#B:O;78E
b

8!<%D8;*4

D*,C<?%$`!#S76#,&W':[;&3&$KA&$G;*,W1 !#7',&("

!#,"!fC#S%$KC&<$#&#L^V,W1W;LK5<%$r1&r!276;4&h<LK*,1$
 m IM o v w1() u% q `K"6C5"I;: !#')
&<5#*,-SD"LVW+($6C##C#J\!6k+C<*, L':a;-*,%d*,1J;E
T%-D"%)R =!1C#*4$h5\2&#%$>!<;!#878C&+;:$?3&+
?D" !#/&0-', ,&"%%$85+L' E ;!;J!/,7VCK
*4?4&3KC78J!<?!,/$$K,,&<*,* L6&C78$25<&$K4$K!
 * :T$#+'&#=1&+,5CK8,W1& X%&+* L@_1&W,1&NE>F-!,
;C78K4&G,/&* L6D1;*,]$6 :R=76*,*<:O;,1&G:Q?8S,-D,
m ? q ESF-!V n
0MZ o C#D1=,S1&(D{` !r,&#%,&#W38{1)\
$KC2!B,&"%,&W`*,1T*4?4&@;&U,&%;,&W`&KC#7V5\
;:Z&CK,D<;""/%;LK,&WV$#C&$;&L`?*4Y*41$#,&#W
8C#&#;D15#*4B*,1EIF-!#BC#DS:O n
S.MZM p Yz,
1&?D11)1!#%-D"%)LK,*4$#,&WT5\Z\":a76;&J:a;63 {I

v1v(E

F-!#V,&+Ai<%I+UIKF p T!78 m ;

 :J!=<+

"S;'76;$ q &!&#T!#B\KC<*Rk(C*, +
L ETI%-D%)
!#`C<$K L@$#,&#`&<$r!6\KC<;*$K4;,1&x:/!#
n
J p Yz
"!#78 m  !@
;:/*,*J<;""76;%$ q ,
,W& X<%;&+*,L@*,?V&<$hDLh*,18_!6k+C<;*,,0Lr:!8$K
($#%$>,W1&<;*R!&r;*4*ZI;V76?%$ m MRlIQ p T q E
F-!#,6*,f!%8!<?85+Ly#;,&Wr!G&+,`i<%1&#* L9
78,&#8,78#?D78&+V,&!#3\#C*Yk+C<*, Lx,85#,&#%$NE
F-!#GC#* V:a;8!GMRlSQ p T"!#783;*,@!%
!;%)
!#,*4=!=*,1S;: 78';: !#'

T!<T178=78%CK

;5*,6,78<"%)R!8,78<;B1&y\"#C* k+C<*, Lh%;&f,*4*5\

1&4$K%$G25\D1L`*4%E

6.
CONCLUSIONS
.0&S!,N<\"H !?D1Z"!;",~%$S![5\!?D(,1CKQ;:#-78*,
5%$8($K

mAno/pUq &<$6I:]785<;%$8($#

mt

E u1v;w q ,&2!#

K&# ;:H*,1E b  !?D1[!#&B$#D*,1\%$U04&+?i%

*,[?DL=&$1&+1*(78!<;&,78HY,&-!J\#
C*Zk+C*, L+E b

!#4*,B-=!<%D%$_;!I($#I&* L_,&#:O

76;*,*,L+)+T!#4&#V!<?/1CKC#* -i<"!Y:aC#&<$;78&+*\$K :O

:O&#5\0-&'($KQ!#,"!B !"R&#($#J!J\!B-%D

b '*,3C#%$_!
($#,&WKE

E uvw`&($KS:OS!#=%$KC&$&+T1CK

i<%K"4&HE

b

'!<%DB:aC&<$U!<?S!'*,,D'76;(,&W

!78/\:O78 *,781-JW1+($6J!/K,&`;: !/&K
 'i?;B6,W1& X%&+* L>*,?B&(C7'5\I;:-&#?L>!,W1!K
#,;,0L3E
F-!(C)17'5,&$=,&+;Ai<%x&$KA&$=T!#5+LK!#1!78
75\J*,* 0C# %$S:aQ!%%D(,* LK*,$#%$&#(H !=-* 
;,D*,LB*4?W1 :],&V:D1,[;21E[F-!,R,Q!#%;5\C
!"L_&,!#S&#%$3!#'$$K,,&r;: $#C&$;&LG&;I:a%$#5
m !,!V-C*4$',&#C# 1$#$# ,1&*#$;I&<$'$#*4L';D1!%$ q ;&<$
!(C/LK,*4$35#*4BD,Bk+C<*, L3*,2:OT!,W1!#I*,Y?I$KC
;5&#/: MZ o &<$B:a$#5<;"=*,1E (C!'!78Z%&25\"
178($?T($#J !6X#{K%$V1CKCK 5# ;)+!#4!6;
$# 8C* /',&+W;;,&+VMZ o "!#78-%k+C#,,&#WV$K,DK 0L
:5\;!@!6($K`&$h!2%$KC&$&#LrW1&#;;%E>T*,K)Z 
,IC#:aC#*R:aS1$##,D=($KTC#&&#4&#W6;T!B*,?\45#*,
5 ?1E TD]$K,&W'$#C&$;&L`;&<$`:O%$K5<6,T;*,84&+
,&WT4&'7VC#*,,%;[1&K:a&,&WI&<?,1Z!-!#&$KA&$
*,1[!<;;,,J:<!#-$#
&([;!#R*,%1$K4&#WII787V5\
:I!_,&;U*4;W* Ld$K,
"&+%Ee^IC#8x!<;`*4;* L
:a+C%$@&f*,,&(,&W3,78#*4V&<$(;&<$>78($#*,S!#4!@&f5\
%;4* L9<?78,~$y !x!`(&%&!<?"4,_;:I!#1K
5+L(0!#1h*4'1&+1*J_C*,D*78,EGT&f&<;* L#,=:Y
*4;W=*,V$K*,%LK78&+/:[&#1&K$;#,DS;I$;#,DBMZ o ;
78<;$8=B$#*,%L#78&(J;:QC#-17V5#,&%$2!78/%k+C#,
*,%?*,LG:aCK!C$KL+E

7.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
b Y-C*4$`*,,Y'!<;& b 1&#!  ;&W=&$`Y15\
FQ78#*,`lT&,D 0L+)R:a;2#?D(4$#,&W_!#` p

 ;&(;&K)

/(;:O0/;`:a;
!`15(j,D_\!k(C*, Ly78C#78&+E p ,"!*z &K
$#"%) tp M1(C#)<!*4\$3,!_!#,7VC*4?4&Y:[!Bk+C#C
76&W78&+/!78E

!(NP 1;;&&#"\E &""?%?"!<;#C5*,,%?4&%!,

8. #REFERENCES
E<T&<$(&H) p EI,*4$#,&WK)<;&<$`VE

 !HEKlI&$#;&<$#,&#W

&$KA&$`,&+&"/;8B$(L#&78,EK.&/%O(

# Bn >)<(L#$K&L+)KYC*,4K)

ww1(E

?D7V5\

#&#& K%

?B'E#;&&"`&$
*,W1;,!#7

 ;\) 

) p

;!


w1w1w(E

:OHP ?:ONE :a1(C#E W76$NE $#%;C#5\?W1*,1&#?;\#&#&<ww %

P
.&+;0MR*,%E #E W1~1E

?VE o *4;G&<$

b EM<&#W#E[{K*,, T*,*,+%;,&r;:[5\


;TY$K*,4D1L`D(41E\FQ"!#&,%*NY\%) p .F
o \) w1w1u(E\!+HP $#
D\E *,E 78 %E $#C\ n \?{K#
*,*,+0$$KA/:E  $K:0E

;BE o %{G&$

;B'E#;&&"\) EH1)&$3BE b 1*,,~1E\Z8,&+II+

C\;/:a; 1
 ,?D. n ;*,,%?4&YC,&WV*,,D
<76?(4&#W#EK.&r1#A1N "A@ " s1
(A";TY1TwAsa8' a"`T>K sa8;A6d
a " 0"\sA;\13;#"y; #0a 4+"#
>K sa6A T<(sa( _  ?)#<;W1  1 K)
/*4;&(, o  0L+) #)<M#5#C;L3v 1 E
:OHP ?:ONE :a1(C#E W76$NE $#%;C#5\?W1*,1&#?;\#&#& 1 v+P
. n 076?(4&#W#E E W~1E

n EgS+&HEH%e5 A;\!3($#:a;

7VC#* 478$#4=1787VC#&,%?4&HE  ;VV(#AsA#

h%1O ")<WYW )\S7V5\

w1w1(E

#E<M&$#,~;&<$_BEH~%?%E o &CK,D<;""*4T,&

%;*,A,78<;"1/;8E.0&-%;a('SO ("O
0"\;sA\ \""\V;UB V'K#AsA#

;0"V # )#<WT \(1v;#)N
;*,&<K)C1C&#
ww E
?

Eg14&#W6&<$`'E<K!(C*,~,&&#1EI+`78C#78&+/:

b

.&+&#/%;*,A,78S7'C* ,78%$#4BD(4E<.0&-%;a(

 (YmH) o !<;\*QT4*,*s) o )g1C&#=v 1 E
u%

E n "K,&#).E^CD*];) ^'EKI($K1&N) p ES&$#*,L+)K;&<$

#E
1*,;%E\JF n %LK*,$`:OY%$#C#&<$;&+C$#,8$?KE#IM o
v w1()\.JF/M)\(#7V5\

w1w1u(E

:ONP 1?:]HE ,:E ;W+?:O??:O?v wKE {(%E

?

p E n ($#1*,+L+) o E<Y178%)#&$_\E p  o ;&&#1E (47'C*4;,&

:JMZ o 5<;%$3;T1&+1* :a;IYC$#,2&3!
.&+&#%EK.&/%"a+ p Bn U)#W
\ v()NK&_MK&4#) o B) p ?"! w1wKE

w?#ET&(5\W#E t E\uvw2;?DL6:a;I.0&+&
FQ*,#!&(L E n ?jT\%) o 1*,C7'54VlI&#,D L+) w1wu+E

? B'EK!(C*,~,&&#1)CKEgCK11)&$GVEFQ%*,L+E\N1

*4?4&_:a;Sk+CC- !_5#C#L6,&#C#78E#.&
/%"a+ Wn )#WTv w\Kvv;#) o !#,%W#)\.J) w1w1v(E
?BVE\(,*,7&$_=E b 1*,,~1E\NIIgF o-n A:]4&<$#* L
1$;#?4&HP |78C#78&+&$G78<;,&_C<$(L+E#.0&

/%"a+

>K sa8;A2;0"')\<;W1

M5#C;L
p

FQ!&#,%*NlI&#4D1 L`:J
"*4,&N)\^I5\Iv 1 E

ww1(E

*4?4&U,&3!

[{K\,78&+* 78%;C#78&(-&<$`76;?D6!<,&

78($#*,EFQ!&,%;*HY\;Iw  1% 
) S<?78&+/:
o 178CKTK4&1)#lI&#,D L`: p !(C)
T78!"%) w1w E
p

E  ?j&,\)\\E p +&H)C#EgCK11)&$GVEFQ%*,L+E

%CK78&+Y&$G78($#*4*,,&WV:Z!T78\;*

v
p

$#\&$#&#S,&3*,1E\FQ!&,%;*HY\;Yw1;u;K)

S<?78&+/: o 178CKTK4&1)#lI&#,D L`:
p !(C)<T78!#%) w1wKE

ww1(E
:ONP 1?:]HE :a(CE W176$ E $K?;#C5<;W1*,&??<\"1#;&&w1 KP

v?B'E<#;&&#"\Eg" T""3< #s12

#A`##'aAh"BO #0""\"sE n !g!#,)
tp MKC#YVFQ*,1787VC#&,%?4& ( t 1CN)

)C1C#&Bv 1 E

E  ?j&,\)CKEgCK11)<&<$`VE#FQ%*,L+E n ;""T*,

p
1&B7'C* ,%&#\P

w?

w()NTC#4&N)#Fk')g1C&#

I$#K4D11E E W1~1E

?
B.&+&<?,1&<;*QFH*,1787'C&#4;,1&GlI&,&HE<^I5Kj,D
k(C*, L`78%;C#78&+/;:R*,#!1&#5<;&<$ m 1 ;  T~ q
\!_($#EY7878&<$#;,1& n E 1 )\.F-lY0FI)

 B'E<#;&&#"\E o 1&#%;*478&(;:[*,1Y\!_<;"1/C,&W

1$#K4D1<,~%?,1&HE#.&/%O( 

 #KN) o !\*NI,*,*s)

u%B.&+&<?,1&<;*QFH*,1787'C&#4;,1&GlI&,&HE o ($#,&W2;:

\!U;YV(5#,"?C,&W21&jCW1;C"C#
*,W15K,($K{K %$_*,4&#%;K%$#,,1& mo (0 o nq E
T17878&$;,& t E u1v;wK)\.F-lT0FI) p ;! ww1(E

 *#ET&(5\W#)JE<I,CH)#&$3'EK!(C*,~,&&#1EK.&+W;;,&W

<;"1YMZ o ,&+21$#K4D1D1,#*]L+C#5#C#

*,W !781&G!S.0&("&%EK.&/%O(
 Bn U)FH*QYD(4D\)K.;*s) p ?"!>v 1 E

E o ;*,1E\|k+CC#S76&W178&+

,?(O
V'(AsA;B<
\%""\V T<(0" 
" ;" Wnn %)#<WY w\+vK) ;,\) p B)
^I15\ w1w1w(E

E\
*,%) \E<M#1 n ;,,) ;&<$G'E<FQ%*,L+E

I$#K4D1MZ o 5%$3"Y1&+*H:a;Y4&+;,D

 Bn U) 

:aY,&+;Ai<%eD(,B$#

&(4?4&U,&G!

15\Y
;2.&+&#%EK.&-%a+VO#

v%#E  o

C$#,2,&3!#S.&+&#%EK.&-%a+

HE  $K:E

v
b

E  &#W2;&<$GBE  ;&(;&KE#.078#?D78&(: p
-K5+L

%*,,&W8&#1,B76(,&W'!K!*4$3&$3;*4;,1&
&<;* L#, ! p ^G$K,
"&,&#%1$3;: p ^ E#.&
p

/%"a+
;!

ww1wKE

W S#-)#WI1u\(u;K) n !+&# {N)BR)