Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN
978-81-925192-1-0
Title
Author
Year
2013
Edition
First
Vol
Publisher
www.edupublication.com
Dr. J. R. Sonwane
Department of Education
M. K. Bhavnagar University, Bhavnagar
INDIA
Contact
edupublication@gmail.com
Price
Free
Pages
121
Subject
Educational Research
Language
Gujarati
an&k\m(Nki
p\iAti(vk
s>Si[Fn l[Knmi> urN (vS[n&> ai p&Atk Si miT[?
p&Atk ki[ni miT[?
p&Atkn) (vS[Pti
1. urN
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7
2.8
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
7-12
13-25
26-44
2
3.5
3.6
3.7
3.8
3.9
3.10
3.11
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
5.1
5.2
3
5.3
5.5
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
S)P<k
l[K k[ p\krNn&> S)P<k
jn<l, sim(yk k[ y&Zz l[Trni S)P<k
p&Atk an[ (rpi[T<
S)P<kmi> (bnpr>prigt mi(ht)
p\kiSnn) mi(ht)
jn<l, sim(yk k[ y&Zz l[Trni S)P<k
p&Atk an[ (rpi[T<
6. el[T^i[(nk s\i[t an[ AYindS<kn) (vgt
URL n) smj
74-86
DOI
114
115-121
APA
(vS[Pt: S]x(Nk s>Si[Fn miT[ni ah[vili[ t]yir krniri s>Si[Fki[ miT[ C[. simiy r)t[
ai p&Atk S]x(Nk upri>t ay simi(jk (vXini[mi> s>Si[Fn ah[vili[ t]yir krniri
s>Si[Fki[n[ pN upyi[g) Yiy t[m C[, kirN k[
APA
(vXini[mi> s>Si[Fn ah[vilni l[Kn an[ p\kiSn miT[n) t]yir)ni> lgBg sv<Av)kZt
ai>trriOT^)y Fi[rNi[ rj* kr[ C[. ai Fi[rNi[ni[ m*LB*t h[t& s>Si[Fn (vPyk p\Ryiynmi>
ApOTti an[ sitRy (so krvini[ C[.
ai p&Atk S]x(Nk s>Si[Fnn[ lgti lG& Si[F(nb>F, mhi (nb>F, s>Si[Fnl[K,
aYvi (rsc< p\i[j[T (rpi[T< - a[vi ki[e pN Av$pmi> s>Si[Fn ah[vilmi> urNi[ rj*
krvini> APA S]l) m&jbni> Fi[rNi[ dSi<v[ C[. at: ai p&Atk ai bFi S]x(Nk s>Si[Fni[
miT[ C[.
ai p&Atk s>Si[Fni[n&> po(tSiA#i (research methodology) S)Kniri
(vwiY)<ai[ tYi ai (vPy S)Kvniri ayipki[n[ pN upyi[g) Yiy t[m C[.
a>tmi>, ai p&Atk s>Si[Fn (vPyk XinvZ( krnir) ki[e pN y(tn) urNi[n)
rj*ait miT[n) (jXisi s>ti[P) SkS[.
vs>t p>cm), f[b\&air), 2013
jgd)p si[nvN[
p&Atkn) (vS[Pti
ai p&Atk (nymi[ tYi t[ni udihrNn) smj siY[n&> C[. t[Y) t[n&> vicn vF& smy
mi>g) l[ C[. t[ni[ upyi[g p\s>gi[vS - Sdki[S (Dictionary) an[ Xinki[S
(Thesaurus) n) j[m - Ye Sk[.
urN miT[ APA p(lk[Sn m[y&al {2010} mi> dSi<v[li mi[Ti Bigni>
s*cni[n[ an&sr) (voini[ni a(Bp\iyi[n[ k[Wmi> riK) g&jrit) s>Si[Fn l[Knmi>
urN miT[ni (nymi[ udihrN siY[ dSi<viyi C[.
si(hRy)k ci[r) (Plagiarism) - a[Tl[ k[ b)jini si(hRyn[ pi[tini lKiN k[
p\kiSn $p[ rj* krvini di[P an[ apriF s>dB[< ai>trriOT^)y smj an[ t[
a>g[ni ci[ks (nymi[ an[ ki[p) rieT tYi kiydik)y bibti[ dSi<v) C[.
avtrN, (v(vF (ch`ni[, a[k k[ vF& l[Kki[ni kiyi[<, ki]>sn) (vgti[, y(tgt
p\Ryiyn, T>&kixri[ vg[r[n) (vgti[ aivyktin&sir sirN) tYi ki[OTk vD[
dSi<vvimi> aiv) C[.
pi(rBi(Pk Sdi[ a>g\[J - g&jrit) tYi g&jrit) - a>g\[Jmi> dSi<yi C[.
p&Atkni a>t[ (vPys*(c (Index) aipvimi> aiv) C[, j[Y) j[ - t[ m&in[
srLtiY) p&Atkmi>Y) Si[F) Skiy.
vF& vicn miT[ p&Atki[ tYi v[b sieTn) mi(ht) dSi<v) C[.
p\krN -1 urN
p\krN -1 urN
urN a[Tl[ S&>?
s>Si[Fn ah[vil dryin s\i[tn) ni[>F k[ ul[K a[Tl[ urN. udihrN tr)k[,
s>Si[Fn ah[vilni piqyvAt& (text) mi> s>Si[Fk ay l[Kkni s>Si[Fnl[Kn) ni[>F
k[ ul[K kr[ ti[ t kh[ C[. APA S]l) an&sir s>Si[Fn ah[vilni piqyvAt&mi>
simiy r)t[ l[Kkn) aTk an[ s\i[tni p\kiSn aYvi l[Knni vP<n) ni[>Fni
Av$pmi> urN s>(xt hi[y C[. uZt s\i[tn) s>p*N< (vgt s>Si[Fn ah[viln[ a>t[
s>dB<s*(cmi> hi[y C[.
urN yir[ krv&>?
pi[tini kiy<n[ j[mni (vciri[, (si>ti[ (theories) k[ s>Si[Fnn[ p\Ryx r)t[
p\Bi(vt ky&<> hi[y t[mni s\i[t k[ kZ(tn&> s>Si[Fk urN kr[ C[. urN m& yRv[ aiTli>
kiy< kr[ C[: {1} s>Si[Fnn) B*(mkin) civ)$p jiNkir) aip[ C[, {2} s>Si[Fkni
gZ(ht (thesis) n&> smY<n k[ (vri[F kr[ C[, an[ {3} mh_vn) yiyiai[ an[
mi(ht) (data) aip[ C[. s\i[tn&> urN s*cv[ C[ k[ s>Si[Fk[ pi[t[ t[ s\i[t vi>yi[ C[.
s>Si[Fk urN oiri pi[tini gZh)tn) rcnimi> upyi[g) Yy[li b)jiai[ni
(vciri[ni NAv)kir kr[ C[. upri>t simiy Xin n hi[y t[vi> tyi[n&>
dAtiv[JkrN p*r&> piD[ C[.
s>Si[Fn (vPyk lKiNni u[y m&jb t[mi> uZt Yti s\i[tin) s>yi j&d)
j&d) hi[y C[. mi[Ti Bigni s>Si[Fnl[K aYvi Si[F(nb>Fmi> civ)$p dr[k m&i miT[
si]Y) vFir[ p\(t(n(F$p hi[y t[vi a[k k[ b[ s\i[ti[ uZt Yiy C[. pr>t& ki[e (vPyni
s>Si[Fnn[ lgti si(hRyn) sm)xini l[Kni[ u[y a[ (vPy pr j[Tl&> lKiy&> hi[y
t[ bFini[ p(rcy vickn[ krivvini[ hi[viY) si(hRyn) sm)xini l[Kmi> urNi[n)
s>yi GN) mi[T) hi[y C[. ah)>, sirN) 1.1 mi> urNni yi[y Atrn&> udihrN
ji[e Skiy C[.
10
11
am[(rkn siyki[li[(jkl a[si[(Sa[Sn { APA, 2010}, uqi>tr) s>b>F[ upyi[g)
(nymi[ dSi<v[ C[. p(lk[Sn m[y&almi> dSi<yi p\miN[ l[Kk aYvi s>Si[Fk
ayni (vciri[ k[ Sdi[ pi[tini C[ t[ r)t[ ul[K n kr) Sk[. yi> s\i[t
dSi<vvin) j$r hi[y an[ m*L l[Kk k[ (vcir aipnirni nimi[l[Kn) j$r hi[y
Ryi> avypN[ t[ni[ ul[K Yvi[ j ji[ea[. yi> ayni (vciri[ SdS: dSi<yi
hi[y Ryi> avtrN (ch`nni[ upyi[g Yvi[ ji[ea[.
uprni udihrNn[ ji[ti ApOT jNiS[ k[ l[Kk[ ci[s r)t[ a[ kiLJ riK) C[ k[ j[
t[ (nymi[ APA oiri aipvimi> aiyi C[ an[ yi> j$r jNiy Ryi> s\i[t an[
nimni[ ul[K kyi[< C[. yir[ rj&ait g&jrit)mi> hi[y Ryir[ { . . .l[Kkn&> nim} ni
mt m&jb, { . . .l[Kkn&> nim} ni an&sir, { . . .l[Kkn&> nim} jNiv[ C[ k[ j[vi viyi[ oiri rj&ait Ye Sk[. a>g\[J lKiN hi[y ti[ According to
{l[Kkn&> nim. . . } vg[r[ oiri rj&ait Ye Sk[.
m&t r)t[ AYini>t(rt Yt) mi(ht)ni ud`BvAYinn) jiN l[Kkn[ hi[y ti[
t[vi s\i[tni[ ul[K y(tgt p\Ryiyn a>tg<t Ye Sk[. { y(tgt p\Ryiynn)
vF& mi(ht) (vBig 1.20 mi> mL) SkS[.}
Av- si(hRy ci[r) k[ uqi>tr) (Self-Plagiarism)
j[m l[Kk ayni lKiNni[ pi[tini lKiN k[ (vcir tr)k[ ul[K n kr) Sk[, a [j
r)t[, t[ pi[tini p*v[< p\ki(St ki[e l[K k[ (vcirni[ pN pi[tini nvi Xin k[ Si[F
tr)k[ ul[K n kr) Sk[. ji[ k[ pi[tini j lKiN k[ (vciri[n[ dSi<vvin) p(r(AY(t
12
K*b j ai[C) hi[y C[. mi[T[ Big[ upkrN, p(t k[ ki[e p\(k\yimi> pi[tini agiuni
p\kiSnni[ upyi[g krvini[ p\s>g up(AYt Yiy C[. pi[tini j nimni[ ul[K
pi[tini j ay l[Kmi> krvin&> a(nCn)y k[ ayi[y ligS[ a[m min) l[Kki[
pi[tini nimni[ urN krvin&> TiL[ C[. yir[k b>n[ l[Kni l[Kk pi[t[ j C[ t[Y)
aivi ki[e ul[Kn) j$(ryit nY) a[v) Ki[T) miyti pN p\vt[< C[. ai bF)
myi<din[ d*r kr) h>m[Si yi[y hi[y Ryi> urN j$r) bn[ C[.
am[(rkn siyki[li[(jkl a[si[(Sa[Sn{APA) p(lk[Sn m[y&al{ 2010}
m&jb ji[ pi[tini p*v[<ni l[Kmi>Y) nkl kriy[l Sdi[ni[ yip ai[Ci[ hi[y ti[ nkl
Av)kiy< C[. yir[ nkl kriy[l Sdi[ni[ yip vF& hi[y Ryir[ t[ni[ urN Yvi[
ji[ea[. k[Tli Sdi[n[ ai[Ci[ k[ vF& yip gNvi[ t[ bibt ApOT krv) m&k[l C[.
simiy smj a[v) C[ k[ ki[e upkrN, p(t k[ p(tSiA#i s>dB[< nvi Xin aYvi
m*L lKiNn) smj miT[ j*ni lKiNni[ smiv[S a[k gwK>Dmi> Ye Sk[, ji[
rj&ait l>biNy&t hi[y ti[ b[ k[ #iN gwK>Di[mi> pN t[ smiv) Skiy. p\Ry[k
gwK>Dn[ a>t[ urN krvi[ j$r) C[.
nvi gwK>Dn) S$aitmi> j[m l[Kk oiri p*v[< cci< krvimi> aiv) ht)
j[vi viyi[ oiri gwK>Dn) S$ait krvimi> aiv[ ti[ vickn[ agiuni si(hRy
(vS[n) mi(ht) mL[ C[.
T&>kmi>, l[Kkni pi[tini p*v[< p\ki(St Yy[l (vciri[ k[ l[Ki[ miT[ (n:s>ki[cpN[
nim siY[ urN krvi[ an[ s>dB<s*(cmi> t[n[ dSi<vvi.
13
p\krN -2
avtrN an[ Sdi>tr
14
15
a>g\[J miymmi> BNnir biLkni[ Si(dk (vkis @>Fiti[ nY) {pin.
65}, miym a>g[ni ay s>Si[Fni[ pN ai p(rNimi[n[ smY<n aip[ C[.
ji[ avtrN viyni a>t[ hi[y ti[ avtrN (ch`ni[ siY[ avt(rt Bign[ p*N< krvi[.
ki]>smi> avtrN (ch`ni[ bid trt j s\i[tn&> urN krv&>
a>(tm ki]>sn) bhirn) trf p*N<(vrim aYvi ay (vrim siY[ a>t krvi[.
di.t.,
SiLin) (p\l)mnr) an[ a[s. a[s. s). bi[D< n) pr)xini p(rNimi[mi>
siyti ji[vi mL[ C[. g&jrit), (hd), smij(vwi, vi(Nyg(Nt,
minvJvn, (vXin vg[r[ (vPymi> SiLin) (p\l)mnr) pr)ximi> u>ci an[
n)ci p\iti>k m[Lvnir a[s. a[s. s). bi[D< n) pr)ximi> pN an&k \m[ U>ci
tYi n)ci p\iti>k m[Lv[ C[ {niyk, 2010, pin. 32}.
ji[ avtrN 40 k[ t[Y) vF& Sdi[n&> hi[y ti[ viyn[ avtrN (ch`ni[ (vni Avt>#i li[kmi> m*kv&>.
aivi li[kn[ nv) lienY) S$ krv&> an[ li[kn[ Dib) trfni mi(j<nY)
aDFi e>c Ks[D)n[ m*kv&> { a[k nvi p[r[g\if/ gwK>Dn) j[m j }.
16
ji[ Ryi> avtrN a>tg<t p[r[g\if hi[y ti[ t[ gwK>Dni p\Ym viyn[ aDFi
e>c Ks[D)n[ m*kv&>.
smg\ avtrNn[ Dbl Ap[s aipv).
li[kni avtrNn[ a>t[ p*N<(vrim m*kv&>.
ul[(Kt s\i[tni[ an[ pinn&> urN ki]>smi> krv&>.
di.t.,
s>Si[Fnmi> aivriy[l s>Si[Fnx[#i[ p]k) si]Y) vF& aikP<N S]x(Nk m*yi>kn an[
pr)xi {26.36%} tYi ayisk\m an[ piq`yp&Atk {21.82%} an[ Ryirbid
ksi[T)n) rcni an[ p\miN)krN {15.45%} tYi (Sxk - p\(SxN {13.64%}
mi> K[DiN Yy[l&> ji[vi mL[ C[. ai upri>t S]x(Nk mni[(vXin an[ t_vXin j[vi
x[#ii[mi> pN p*rti p\miNmi> s>Si[Fni[ Yy[li ji[vi mL[ C[.
p(t an&sir sv[<xN p(tmi> si]Y) vF& s>S i[Fni[ Yyi C[. b)ji k\mni
s>Si[Fni[[mi> p\iyi[(gk s>Si[Fn p(tni[ upyi[g Yyi[ hi[y C[. {pT[l, 2008,
pin. 2}.
v]k(pk r)t[, ji[ li[kni ul[Kni p(rcyiRmk viymi> s\i[tni[ ul[K hi[y ti[
ft pin n>br aYvi gwK>D n>br j avtrNni a>t[ dSi<vvini[ rh[ C[.
17
18
di.t.,
d[sie an[ Sih {2011} T[kni[l(jni (vkis s>dB[< jNiv[ C[ hv[ Labor
theory of value n) jyia[ Knowledge theory of value n&>
mh_v vF) rH&> C[ {p[r[. 4}.
ji[ dAtiv[jmi> (vBign&> S)P<k hi[y, pr>t& gwK>D k[ pinn>br ji[e Skiy a[m n
hi[y ti[ S)P<kni[ urN kr) t[n[ an&srti gwK>Dni[ ul[K krvi[ j[Y) vick
ul[(Kt si(hRyn&> AYin jiN) Sk[.
di.t.,
am*t< tk< a>g[ Sih {2010} a[ amdivid Sh[rni 1000 (vwiY)<ai[ upr
ayis hiY Fyi[< hti[ , j[mi jNiy&> C[ smg\ Ci[kri Ci[kr)ai[n) sr[riS
am*t< tk< S(tmi> ji(tgt tfivt ji[vi mL[ C[. Ci[kr)ai[n) am*t< tk< S(t
Ci[kri krti> vF& ji[vi mL[ C[ { cci< (vBig, p[r[. 2}.
k[Tlik (kAsimi> pin n>br k[ gwK>D n>br ji[e Skiy a[m n hi[y. vL), S)P<k pN
urN krvimi> (bnj$r) r)t[ K*b mi[T&> hi[y, ti[ gwK>Dni urN miT[ avtrN
(ch`ni[ siY[n&> T*>k& S)P<k lKv&>.
di.t.,
19
Bivngr y&(nv(s<T) s>ln b). a[D`. ki[l[ji[ {g\iy (vAtir} ni til)miY)<ai[ni
p\iyi[(gk piq a>g[ni a(Bp\iyi[: a[k sv[<xNiRmk ayis
uprni udihrNni[ urN avtrN siY[ n)c[ m&jb kr) SkiyS)P<k ht&>- b). a[D`. ki[l[ji[ni til)miY)<ai[ni p\iyi[(gk piq a>g[ni a(Bp\iyi[.
20
21
b[ viyi[ vc[ni d&r Yy[l Bign[ dSi<vvi cir Tpki>ni[ upyi[g krvi[.
{. . . .} ai cir Tpki> p]k)n&> ph[l&> Tpk&> ul[(Kt viyni[ a>t s*cv[ C[,
yir[ bik)ni #iN Tpki>ai[ t[n[ an&sr[ C[.
di.t.,
p\mi(Nt s>Si[Fn upkrNi[ s>Si[Fn (nONiti[ oiri p\mi(NkrNn) li>b) p\(k\yin[
a>t[ t]yir Yy[li hi[y C[. . . . p\mi(Nt upkrN oiri mL[l) mi(ht) (vVsn)y
mL[ C[.
22
(vPyvAt&n&> um[rN
s\i[tni l[Kkni m*L kiy<mi> ay y(t oiri Yt&> um[rN k[ avtrNn[ dSi<vvi miT[
b\[k[T ni[
di.t.,
yir[ pi#ii[ p\yi[gpi#ii[ n[ j$r) s*cni aipvimi> aiv) ht).
Bir um[rvi[ / dSi<vvi[
ji[ avtrNmi> ki[e a[k Sd k[ Sdi[ um[rvi hi[y ti[ t[ Sdi[n[ eTi(lk krvi an[
eTi(lk kyi< bid b\[k[Tmi> avFirN um[rN dSi<vv&>. ji[ viy a>g\[J hi[y ti[
[emphasis added] vD[ Bir dSi<vvi[.
di.t.,
k[vT {2011} n)c[ p\miN[ ni[>F[ C[:
(Sxki[n&> d](nk aiyi[jn ni[>Fpi[Y) p\Ry[n&> vlN nkiriRmk C[. vF& an&Bv)
avFirN
um[rN ji[ k[ A#i)pi#ii[ p&$Ppi#ii[ krti ni[>Fpi[Y) p\Ry[ U>c&> vlN dSi<v[
C[.
23
24
25
ji[ tm[ ki[p)rieT si(hRyni mi(lkn) l[(Kt m>j*r) l)F) hi[y , ti[ ul[K
kriy[l si(hRyn) n)c[ pidni[>Fmi> ki[p)rieT mi(lk trfY) siBir Av)kir
dSi<vvin&> rh[ C[. pidni[>F miT[n&> miLK&> n)c[ dSi<y&> C[.
s\i[tni[ p\kir1
jn<l
p&Atk
26
(vBig-3
lKiNmi> s>dBi[<n&> urN
27
28
p\if [sr, Di.- DiTr vg[r[ (vni} tYi p\kiSnni vP<ni[ yi[y AYin[ ul[K krvini[
rh[ C[.
di.t.,
d[sie {1968} a[ S]x(Nk s>Si[Fn (vS[ jNiy&> C[ k[
mitZBiPimi> (SxN mni[v]Xi(nk r)t[ upyi[g) C[ { mhijn, 2010}.
ji[ ki[e l[Kkn&> nim vN<nni Big tr)k[ aivt&> hi[y { j[mk[ WOTi>t ph[l&>} ti[ mi#i
p\kiSnni vP<ni[ j ki]>smi> ul[K krvi[. nh)tr upr dSi<v[li udihrN k\m-2 n)
j[m nim an[ p\kiSnnni vP<n[ ap(vrim oiri j&di piD)n[ ki]>smi> rj& krvi. ji[
s>dB<mi> mis/ m(hni an[ vP< b>n[ni[ ul[K hi[y ti[ pN urNmi> mi#i vP<ni[ j
ul[K krvi[. K*b j ai[Ci (kAsimi> vP< an[ l[Kkni nim- b>n[n[ lKiNni Big
tr)k[ dSi<vvimi> aiv[ C[, Ryi> ki]>smi> vFirin) ki[e mi(ht) dSi<vv) nh)>.
di.t., mhijnni[ vP< 2009 ni[ ayis dSi<v[ C[ k[ . . .
gwK>Dmi> yir[ {uprni udihrNn) j[m} l[Kkn>& nim m*L lKiNni vN<nni[
Big bn[ Ryir[ yi> s&F) j[ - t[ ayis ay ayis siY[n) m&zvN UB) n kr[
ti[ vP<ni[ ul[K ki]>s vgr krvin) j$(ryit nY). vP<ni[ ki]>smi> smiv[S krvi[.
di.t.,
29
si>v[(gk b&( s>dB[< pT[l {2010} ni[ ayis jNiv[ C[ k[ jit)ytin) (OTa[
A#i)ai[ni[ b&(ai>k p&$Pi[n) t&lnimi> vF& jNiyi[ hti[. . . . (vAtirni s>dB<mi>
pN tfivt ji[vi myi[ hti[, j[mi g\iy (vAtirn) A#i)ai[ krti Sh[r) (vAtirn)
A#i)ai[ni[ b&(ai>k vF& ji[vi myi[ hti[ {pT[l, 2010}.
vF&mi, yir[ nim an[ vP< b>n[ ki]>smi> hi[y Ryir[ gwK>Dmi> an&gim) urNmi>
vP<ni[ smiv[S krvi[.
di.t.,
g\iy (vAtirn) A#i)ai[ krti Sh[r) (vAtirn) A#i)ai[ni[ b&(ai>k vF& ji[vi myi[
hti[ {pT[l, 2010}. pT[l {2010} n&> s>Si[Fn vF& a[k bibt a>g[ p\kiS piD[
C[.
30
yir[ ki[e kiy<ni #iN, cir k[ pi>c l[Kki[ hi[y Ryir[ p\Ym vKt bFij l[Kki[n)
aTkni[ ul[K krvi[, an[ t[ni an&vt)< urNmi> mi#i p\Ym l[Kkn) aTkni[
ul[K kr) - an[ ay lK) Ryir bid vP<ni[ ul[K krvi[.
di.t.,
{1} ai(hr, kisr, Kin, niyk an[ s[vk {2008} ni mtin&sir { p\Ym
urNmi> ai m&jb ul[K krvi[.}
{2} ai(hr an[ ay {2008} ni mtin&sir { b)J vKt an[ Ryirbidni
an&vt)< urNmi> ai m&jb ul[K krvi[.}
{3} ai(hr an[ ayni mtin&sir
{gwK>Dmi> a[kvir ki]>smi> vP<ni[ ul[K Ye gyi[ hi[y pC) t[ j gwK>Dni
an&vt)< urNmi> ki]>smi> vP<ni[ ul[K krvin) aivykti rh[t) nY)}.
apvid: ji[ a[ksmin vP<mi> #iNY) vFir[ aTkviLi smin nimi[viLi s>dB< hi[y
ti[ p\Ym l[Kkn) aTk lKv) an[ s>dBi[<n) (Bnti miT[ {,} (vrim
(ch`n tYi an[ ay lK) (nd[<S krvi[.
di.t.,
{1} ai(hr, kisr, Kin, niyk an[ s[vk, 2008
{2} ai(hr, kisr, ci]hiN, an[ an[ s[vk, 2008
31
32
uprni udihrNmi> p\Ym b[ nimi[ smin C[ pr>t& #i)ji nimi[ an&k\m[ Kin an[
ci]hiN j*di C[. j[ni vD[ b>n[ (nd[<Si[ j*di C[ t[ni yil aiv[ C[. aim, yi> s&F)
b>n[ (nd[<Si[n) Avt>#i ai[LK UB) Yiy Ryi> s&F) l[Kki[ni nimn) ni[>F krv).
cil& lKiNmi> a>(tm nim lKti ph[li an[ Sd lKvini[ rh[ C[. ki]>sni
(vPyvAt&mi, sirN) an[ S)P<kmi>, s>dB<s*(cmi> nimi[n[ oiri ji[Dvimi> aiv[
C[.
pT[l an[ Sih {2009} ni dSi<yi m&jb
b&( an[ s>v[gi[ vc[ shs>b>F C[ {pT[l Sih, 2009}.
yir[ ki[e kiy<n[ C k[ vF& l[Kki[ hi[y Ryir[ mi#i p\|Ym l[Kkn) aTkni[ j (nd[<S
krvi[ an[ Ryirbid an[ ay tYi vP<ni[ ul[K krvi[.
di.t.,
1
ci]hiN,
ai(hr an[
{2008}
ay
2008
ji[ C k[ t[Y) vF& l[Kki[ a[k j Av$pmi> lKiyi hi[y ti[ p\Ym l[Kkni[ ul[K
krvi[ an[ b>n[ s>dB<n[ C*Ti piDvi miT[ j$r) hi[y t[Tli an&vt)< l[Kki[ni[ (vrim
(ch`n {,} an[ an[ ay oiri (nd[<S krvi[.
di.t.,
1
ay. {2008}
33
34
k[Tlik j*Yni aiKi nimi[ p\|Ym (nd[<Smi> ji[vi mL[ C[ an[ Ryirbid T*>ki
nimi[ ji[vi mL[ C[. j*Yni nimi[n[ T*>kivt) vKt[ T*>ki nimi[ni simiy
(nymi[n[ k[Wmi> riK)n[ vickn[ s>dB<s*(cmi> m*L s\i[tn[ Si[Fvimi> m&k[l) n
pD[ t[n) kiLJ riKvin) rh[. ji[ m*L nim K*b j li>b& an[ jT)l hi[y an[ t[n&>
T*>k&>nim jiN)t&> hi[y, aYvi srLtiY) smJ Skiy a[m hi[y ti[ t[ nim
n[ Ryirbid (nd[<S)t kr) Skiy C[. ji[ nim T*>k&> hi[y aYvi ji[ T*>k&>nim srLtiY)
smJ Skiy a[m n hi[y ti[ t[ nimn[ dr vKt[ t[ni m*L Av$p[ j lKv&>.
an[ v[bp[j, p\krN k[ l[Kni S)P<kn[ b[vDi avtrN (ch`n { } mi> m*kv&> tYi
(rpi[T<, p&Atk, simi(yk k[ mi(ht)p#ikni S)P<kn[ eTi(lk krv&>.
di.t.,
aiF&(nk (SxNn) g(t { (SxNni p\ni[ , 2008}
kiydik)y si(hRyni s>dB<n[ nim vgrni l[Kkni kiy<n) j[mj dSi<vv&>. ki[T< k[s
k[ kiydik)y (vgti[n[ dSi<vvi miT[ s>dB<mi> ph[li Yi[Di> Sdi[ an[ pC)
vP<ni[ ul[K krvi[.
di.t.,
g&jrit riyn) b).a[D`. ki[l[ji[ {2009}
yir[ kiy<ni l[Kkn&> nim aXit ly&> hi[y Ryir[ t[ni (nd[<Smi> aXit lK)
ap(vrim an[ Ryirbid vP< lKv&>.
di.t.,
{aXit, 2011}
s>dB<s*(cmi> aXit kiy<n[ aXit nim siY[ kivir) p\miN[ dSi<vv&>.
35
36
a[k j l[Kkni b[ k[ t[Y) vF& kiyi[< hi[y ti[ t[n[ p\kiSnni vP< p\miN[ gi[qvv&>.
a[kvir l[Kkn) aTk dSi<vv), Ryirbid mi#i p\kiSnni vP<ni[ j ul[K
krvi[. p\[smi> hi[y t[ kiy<n[ a>tmi> dSi<vv&> an[ Ryi> p\[smi> a[m lKv&>.
di.t.,
s>Si[Fnn) p(tai[ j[ie Skiy C[ { uciT, 1999, 2001}
s>Si[Fnn) p(tai[ j[ie Skiy C[ { uciT, 1999, 2001, 2011, p\[smi>}
a[k j l[Kk oiri a[k j p\kirn&> p\kiSn j*di-j*di vP<mi> Yy&> hi[y
Ryir[ l[Kkn&> nim dSi<v) vP<n[ a>t[ a, b, c, d. a>g\[Jmi> dSi<vvi.
ji[ s>dB<ni[>F g&jrit)mi> hi[y ti[ k, K, g . . . ai m&jb dSi<v) Skiy.
a,b,c,d. k[ k, K, g, G ni[ k\m s>dBi[<n) s>yin[ aiFir[ aigLni k\m
an&sir ni[>F Ye Sk[. j[m k[ a, b, c, d, e, f, g, h, . . . . vg[r[. a[ m&jb
apvid: tm[ m&y (nd[<Sn[ ki]>sni ay (nd[< Si[Y) j*di piDvi eCti hi[v
ti[ ay j*ai[ j[vi Sdi[ni[ upyi[g kr) Ski[. ai m&jbni[ ul[K
a>(tm (nd[<S ph[li krv&>. a>g\[J miT[ see also lKv&>.
di.t.,
37
38
{ kisr an[ Kin, 2001; ay j*ai[, gi>F), 2002; Sih, 2001}
( Kasar & Khan, 2001; see also Gandhi, 2002; Shah, 2001)
39
lKiNmi> an&gim)
(nd[<S {ki]>smi>}
(nd[<S{ki]>smi>}
pT[l {2010}
{pT[l,2010}
{pT[l, 2010}
{pT[l an[
kiy<
b[ l[Kki[ oiri a[k
kiy<
#iN l[Kki[ oiri
riv,2005}
pT[l, BiT, an[ Sih {2007}
a[k kiy<
a[k kiy<
{2009}
40
a[k kiy<
yi(Xk {2010}
mhijn an[ ay
{2005}
2005}
2005}
a[n s) T) e, {2010}
{n[Snl kius)l
{a[n s) T) e, 2010}
T*kinim oiri
a[y&kS
[ n {a[n s) T) e, 2010}
ai[LK) Skiy}
a[n s) T) e,
l[Kk tr)k[
{2010}
j*Y { T*>knim
vgr} l[Kk tr)k[
Bivngr y&(nv(s<T)
{Bivngr
{Bivngr y&(nv(s<T),
{2011}
y&(nv(s<T), 2011}
2011}
41
42
di.t.,
{ pT[l, an&. 1931}
{Sih, 1890/1983}
SiA#i)ykiyi[< k[ p\ic)n, Fi(m<k lKiNi[ j[vik[ g\)k, ri[mnni kiyi[<, Bgvd` g)ti
vg[r[ni li[ki[, eRyid)ni[ s>dB<s*(cmi> smiv[S krvi[ j$r) nY). SiA#i)y
kiyi[<ni Bigi[ j[mk[ p&Atk, p\krN, viyi[- vg[r[mi> (vPyvAt&n[
k\mb
r)t[ p\Ry[k aivZ(_imi> dSi<v[l hi[y C[. ai k\mni[ pin s>yin[ bdl[ upyi[g Ye
Sk[.
di.t.,
~)md` Bgvd` g)ti 2:12
di.t.,
{S]x(Nk smAyiai[n) cci<, 2010, pZ.10}
{stt (SxN, 2009, p\krN 3}
43
44
y(tgt p\Ryiynni k[Tlik Av$pi[ p&n: p\iy C[ an[ t[n[ s>dB<s*(c a>tg<t
p&n: p\iy simg\)mi> smiv[S krvi[ ji[ea[.
(vBig-4
s>dB<s*(c
45
46
(vBig-4 s>dB<s*(c
s>dB<s*(c s>Si[Fn ah[viln[ a>>t[ rj& Yiy C[. SdS: ji[ea[ ti[ s>Si[Fn ah[vil,
Si[F(nb>F k[ (rsc< p\i[j[Tni (rpi[T<ni (vBigi[ k[ p\krNi[ni piqyvAt& (text) mi>
uZt (cited) a[Tl[ k[ ul[Kiy[li s\i[tin) yid) t[ s>dB<s*(c. References
are those sources which are referred in the text of the
research report.
s>dB<s*(c smi(vOT s\i[ti[n) ai[LK miT[n) tYi t[mn[ g\>Yily eRyi(dmi>Y)
m[Lvvi miT[n) j$r) mi(ht) aip[ C[. APA oiri p\ki(St Yti> sim(yki[ tYi
ay GNi> sim(yki[ni l[Ki[n[ a>t[ s>dB<s*(c (List of References) aipvimi>
aiv[ C[, Bibliography2 n(h.
APA S]l) an&sir s>dB<s*(c nvi pZOq pr S$ Yiy C[. References
k[ s>dB<s*(c Sd mymi> lKiy/ Tiep Yiy C[. t[mi> dr[k s>dB< Dbl Ap[smi>
hi[y C[ an[ hanging indent format mi> hi[y C[, a[Tl[ k[ p\Ym p>(t Dibi
hi>(syi Bri[Br Tiep Yiy C[ an[ pC)n) p>(tai[ eD[T kriy C[.
Reference list { s>dB<s*(c} mi> ci[s l[Kni[ aiFir p*ri piDti an[ ul[K Yyi hi[y t[vi
j kiyi[<ni[ smiv[S Yiy C[. yir[ Bibliography mi> l[Kn) pcidB*(mki aYvi vF& vicn
miT[ni s>dBi[<ni[ pN ul[K Yyi[ hi[e Sk[.
s>dB<s*(cmi> mi#i uZt s>dBi[< j hi[viY) p#i[ j[vi> y(tgt p\Ryiyni[ tYi
ay ani]pci(rk p\Ryiynni[ ul[K TiLvi[.
47
48
s>x[p
Av)kZt s>x[p j[mk[ p&Atkni[ Big k[ ay p\kiSnn[ n)c[ m&jb dSi<v) Skiy.
di.t., ji[ (vgt a>g\[Jmi> hi[y ti[-
Abbreviation
Book or publication
Ed
Edition
Rev. ed.
Revised edition
2nd ed.
second
Ed. (Eds.)
Editor (Editors)
Trans.
Translator(s)
n.d.
no date
p.(pp.)
page (pages)
Vol.
Volume ( as in Vol. 4)
Vols.
No.
Number
Pt.
Part
Tech. Rep.
Technical Report
Suppl.
Supplement
ar[(bk n>br
ji[ k[ k[Tlik p&Atki[ni vi[y&m n>brn[ ri[mn ai>kDimi> dSi<vvimi> aiyi hi[y pr>t&
APA ar[(bk ai>kDini[ upyi[g kr[ C[ {di.t., Vol-3, Vol-III nh)>}. kirNk[
ri[mn a>k vF& jyi ri[k[ C[. ji[ ri[mn a>k S)P<kni[ a[k Big hi[y ti[ tn[ ri[mn
a>k tr)k[ j riKvi.
4.2 a[k$pti
s>dB<S]l)mi> a[k$pti j$r) C[. simiy r)t[ T[kni[l(jni[ upyi[g Yyi[ hi[y Ryir[
ky*Tr p\i[g\im oiri t]yir Yy[l yid)n[ m*L yid) siY[ tpis) jv&> an[ vickn[
srLtiY) an[ yi[y r)t[ s\i[t mL[ t[ ji[v&>.
49
50
aigL hi[vi Cti> K&Silkr krti> K&Sil aTkviLi s>dB<n) ni[>F aigL
krvimi> aivS[.
p*v<gi[ (Prefix) n[ pN kkivir) p\miN[ gi[qvvi. g&jrit)mi> ai j$(ryit
nY) rh[t). pr>t& a>g\[Jmi> M, Mc an[ Mac j[vi p*v<gi[ hi[y C[. ah)>
bFi p*v<gi[n[ ji[DN) an&sir gN) t[n[ kkivir) p\miN[ gi[qvvi.
j[mk[, Mc Arthur
51
52
53
s>dB<mi> l[Kki[ni nimi[ srKi hi[y Ryir[ p\kiSnni vP< an&sir t[mn)
gi[qvN krv).
di.t.,
ai(hr, r. t. an[ pT[l, j. l. {2001}
ai(hr, r. t. an[ pT[l, j. l. {2004}
jyir[ l[Kki[ni nimi[, t[mni[ k\m tYi p\kiSnni vP< pN smin hi[y Ryir[
S)P<k an&sir gi[qvv&>.
kr)n[ S)P<k gNv&>. tYi ki[>smi> vP< dSi<yi bid t&r>t a, b, k... a[m k\mS:
dSi<vv&>.}
di.t., si[nvN[, j.r. {2005a} (k\yiRmk s>Si[Fnmi>. . . . .
si[nvN[, j. r. {2005b} (SxNmi> . . . .
uprni udihrNmi> b>n[ s>dBi[<ni l[Kki[ni> nimi[ smin C[, p\kiSnn&> vP< pN
smin C[. aiY) S)P<kni p\Ym Sdni p\Ym axr an&sir (k\yiRmk
54
smin aTkviLi j&di j&di p\Ym l[Kki[n>i j&d) j&d) kZ(tai[ni[ k\m:
yir[ j&d) j&d) kZ(tai[ni p\Ym l[Kki[n) aTk smin hi[y t[v) (AY(tmi>
l[Kki[ni nimni p\Ymixr an&sir gi[qvN krv).
di.t., a>bisNi, a. a., an[ pT[l, r. m. {1998}.
a>bisNi, r. m., an[ birD, k. l. {1998}.
ah)>, b>n[ s>dBi[<ni l[Kki[ j&di j&di C[, pr>t& t[mn) aTk smin C[. aiY)
ah)> l[Kki[ni nimni p\Ymixrn[ yinmi> l[vimi> aiyi C[. p(rNim[
55
m&y s>AYini[ k\m t[n) upSiKiai[ni k\m krti ph[li aivS[. { di.t., minv
s>siFn (vkis m>#iily, uc (SxN (vBig}.
ji[ kiy<ni l[Kk tr)k[ ApOT r)t[ aXit a[m ly&> hi[y - mi#i t[ an[
t[ j (kAsimi> - aXit a[ sic&> nim hi[y a[ r)t[ t[n[ kivir) p\miN[
gi[qvv&>.
yi> l[Kkn&> nim aipvimi> n aiy&> hi[y t[v) (AYt)mi> S)P<kn[
l[Kkni nimn[ AYin[ le jv&> an[ l[Kni S)P<kni p\Ym Sdn[ le t[n[
kkivir)ni k\mmi> gi[qvv&>.
56
57
(vBig-5
s>dB<ni GTki[
58
di.t.,
k\m
l[Kkn&> nim
k\m
l[Kkn&> nim
ai(hr, t.B.
ji[S), B.h.
uciT, d.n.
t[r]yi, r.c.
K[r, m.y.
Yi[riT, j.g.
civDi, j.d.
dv[, l.s.
59
ai(hr, t.B.,
6
t[r]yi, r.c., . . .
5
ji[S), B.h.,
8
dv[, l. s.
uprni udihrNn[ ji[ti jNiS[ k[ l[Kni k&l aiq l[Kki[ C[. pr>t& uprni
(nymin&sir C l[Kki[n) ni[>F bid #iN Tpki> krvimi> aiyi C[, Ryirbid
sitmi l[Kkni nimni[ ul[K TiL)n[ s)Fi aiqmi l[Kkni[ ul[K krvimi>
aiyi[ C[.
ji[ s>dB<ni[>Fmi> a[kj aTk an[ nimni smin p\Ymixr Frivti a[kY) vF&
l[Kki[ hi[y Ryir[ l[Kkn&> nim ki]>smi> aip) Skiy.
di.t.,
s>dB<ni[>F miT[:
pT[l, r. rm[S. {1986}.
60
l[Kkni nimn[ j&di piDvi, aTk an[ nimni p\Ymixrn[ j&di piDvi miT[
ap (vrim (Comma) ni[ upyi[g krvi[. b[ Y) sit l[Kki[n) ni[>Fmi>
a>(tm l[Kkni nimn) ni[>F p*v[< g&jrit)mi> n[ lKv&>, a>g\[J s>dB<mi> & n)
(nSin) m*kvimi> aiv[ C[.
61
di.t.,
ai(hr, t.B.{2010}.
ai(hr, t.B., uciT, d.n. n[ K[r, m.y.{2010}.
j*Y l[Kk tr)k[ hi[y Ryir[ j*Yni aiKi nimni[ ul[K krvi[.
di.t.,
Bivngr y&(nv(s<T), (SxNSiA#i Bvn, S]x(Nk T[knil(j. {2011}.
ji[ l[Kki[ni nim siY[ k[ with siY[ ul[(Kt hi[y, ti[ lKiNni urNmi>
mi#i m&y l[Kkni[ j ul[K krvi[ an[ s>dB<ni[>Fmi> m*L l[Kkni nim siY[
k[ with siY[ ul[(Kt hi[y t[vi nimi[n[ ki]>smi> dSi<vvi.
di.t.,
pT[l, r.t. { niyk, n. m. siY[}.
ji[ ki[e l[Kni l[Kkn&> nim n hi[y ti[ l[Kni S)P<kn[ l[Kkni nimn[ AYin[
{ a[Tl[ k[ p\kiSnn) (vgtn) p*v[<} dSi<vv&> , Ryirbid p\kiSnn&> vP< lKv&>.
di.t.,
62
(SxN
(c>tn.
p&n:
p\iy
s\i[t
http://www.shikshanchintan.org/board/news-atglance/215546/topstory.html
smicirp#ini[ l[K
t$Ni[mi> ji[vi mL[li asimiy f[rfiri[. {2010, sT[br 14}. (dy
63
y(tgt s>g\h
pr)xi s>dB[< (SxN (vBig[ l)F[li[ upyi[g) (nN<y. {1992, ai[gOT
21}. a[k vNai[LKiy[l d](nk smicirp#imi>Y). nkl l[Kkn[
hAtk.
s>pidk:
s>pi(dt p&Atkn) s>dB<ni[>F miT[ s>pidkni nimn[ l[Kkni nimn[
AYin[ m*kvi an[ ki]>smi> s>. n[ a>(tm nimn[ a>t[ lKv&>, Ryirbid
p\kiSnni vP<n[ dSi<vv&>
di.t.,
s>pidkn&> nim
niyk, ki. an[ ji[S), h.
{2010}.
ay (vgti[
(SxNmi> s>Si[Fn.
ji[ ki[e s>pi(dt p&Atkni p\krNni[ s>dB< hi[y ti[ j[-t[ p\krNni
l[Kkni nimn) upr jNiyi m&jb ni[>F krv). ah)>, p&Atkni
s>pidkni nimn) ni[>F S$aitmi> n krv).
64
l[Kkn&> nim
p\kiSn
vP<
l[Kn&> S)P<k
s>pidkn&>
nim
kti(ryi, l. d.
{2010}.
(SxNmi>
nv(vcir
biri[T, c. s. {s>pi.}.
pin k\mi>k
AYL
p\kiSk
123-135,
amdivid:
snitn.
p&Atkn&>
{eTi(lk}
S)P<k mi>
mi>
{s>pi.}.
ji[ s>pidki[n) s>yi vFir[ hi[y ti[ p|\Ym s>pidkn) (vgti[ lK) an[ ay
lKv&>.
l[Kkn&> nim
s>pidkn&>
nim
{s>pi.}.
65
kti(ryi, l. d.
{2010}.
(SxNmi> nv(vcir
biri[T, c. {s>pi.}.
s.
an[
ay
pin k\mi>k
AYL
p\kiSk
nv(vcir
p(rvt<n.
123-135,
amdivid:
snitn.
an[ mi>
yir[ ki[e p&Atkni s>pidkn&> nim aipvimi> n aiy&> hi[y ti[ p&Atkni
nimn) piCL mi> lKv&>.
sim(yk, smicir p#i k[ y&z l[Tr miT[ p\kiSn vP<, mis tYi ci[ks
tir)K ki]>smi> ap (vrimY) j*d) piD)n[ aipv). ji[ p\kiSnni
66
smygiLin[ ki[e misn) j[m dSi<vvimi> aiy&> hi[y ti[ ki]>smi> vP<
an[ misn[ ap(vrimY) j*d&> piD)n[ dSi<vv&>.
(s>G, k. b. {2008, m[}.
zi, a. y. {1998, sT[br 16}.
yidv, d. s. { 2009, vs>t}.
(mT)>gmi> p[pr an[ pi[ATr rj*ait Ye hi[y t[vi (kAsimi> (mT)>gni[
mis an[ vP<n[ ki[>smi> ap(vrimY) j*d&> piD)n[ dSi<vv&>.
j[ l[K p\kiSn miT[ Av)kiriyi[ hi[y pr>t& hj& p\ki(St n Yyi[[ hi[y,
t[ni miT[ p\[smi> lKv&>. yi> s&F) l[K viAtvmi> p\ki(St n Yyi[ hi[y
Ryi> s&F) ki[e ci[ks tir)K aipv) nh)>. j[ l[K (ry& miT[, p&n:
lKiN k[ p\kiSnn) p\(k\yi a>tg<t hi[y t[ni miT[ n)c[ m&jb rj&ait
krv).
67
ji[ p\kiSnn) tir)K uplF n hi[y ti[ ki]>smi> {ti. n.} g&jrit)mi>,
aYvi a>g\[J hi[y ti[ ki]>smi> (n.d.) lKv&>.
68
5.3 S)P<k
l[K k[ p\krNn&> S)P<k. ki[e l[K k[ p\krNni S)P<kn[ eTi(lk krv&> nh)>, t[m j
ki[e avtrN (ch`nmi> m*kv&> nh). a>g\[J S)P<kmi> S)P<kni p|\Ym axrn[
k[(pTlmi> lKvi[ aYvi ti[ ki[e upS)P<k hi[y ti[ t[n[ k[(pTlmi> lKv&> pr>t&
bFi j Sdi[n[ k[(pTlmi> lKvi nh)>.
Fi[rN 12 mi> ayis krti uc b&(kxi Frivti (vwiY)<ai[n) ayyn
S]l)ni[ ayis.
Jvn (SxN
Review of Educational Research
69
ki]>sn) (vgti[
ji[ ki[e vi[y&m mi[Ti, Avt>#i S)P<kn) hirmiLi k[ s>g\hni[ Big hi[y
ti[ hirmiLi an[ vi[y&mni S)P<kn[ b[ Bigni S)P<k tr)k[ gNv&>.
riqi[D, n. m. an[ yi(Xk, v. t. {1998}. vg<K>Dmi> (c>tniRmkti.
Bi[giyti, D. l. (SxNmi> (c>tniRmkti {s>pi(dt hirmiLi}mi>,
S]x(Nk s>Si[Fn hirmiLi: vi[y&m.1 (c>tniRmk (SxN {pin.
140-156}.
70
ki[e pN ki]>sn) mi(ht) pC) t&r>t j ci[rs ki]>smi> m*kv). ci[rs ki]>s a[
S)P<k nh)> pN Av$pn&> vN<n dSi<v[ C[. ah)> kiy<ni Av$pn) ai[LK mL[ t[
miT[n) k[Tl)k ni[>F dSi<v) C[.
s>pidkn[ p#i
(v(SOT a>k
(v(SOT (vBig
mi[ni[g\if
siri>S
~iy p&n: p\sirN
mi(ht) fiel
mi(ht) p#ik
c(lt (c#i
yiyin ni[>F
s)D)
ky*Tr si[f`Tv[r
(vD)yi[ v[bkiAT
p*rk simg\)
71
72
73
(dh): (hmily.
Bivngr: l[Kk.
s&rt: pi[y&lr.
nvsir): v[di>t.
74
(vBig-6
el[kT^i[(nk s\i[t an[ AYinn) (vgt
75
76
vir vick pi[t[ pN l[Kmi> s&Firi - vFiri kr) Sk[ C[. ai bibt vickn&> j[
t[ l[K siY[n&> smiyi[jn vFir) d[ C[. aim Cti l[Kmi> GN) vir dSi<v[li>
bFi> ji[DiNi[ t>d&rAt nY) hi[ti>.
ainlien p\kiSnni[ p\kiSnni[ yip an[ lxNi[n[ ji[ti> APA
ainlien p\kiSnn) ai[LK miT[ k[Tli>k s*cni[ dSi<v[ C[; j[Y) vick j[ t[
s\i[t s&F) srLtiY) phi[>c) Sk[ tYi j$r) mi(ht) p&n: p\it kr) Sk[. ai
miT[ APA y&(nfi[m< (rsi[s< li[k[Tr (URLs), (DJTl aij[T
aieD[(Tfiyr (DOIs) an[ ainlien p\kiSnni s\i[tni (nd[<S tYi
s>dB<ni[>Fn) cci< kr[ C[.
6.1 URL n) smj
URL a[ eTrn[T upr (DJTl mi(ht)ni nkSi tr)k[ upyi[gmi> l[viy C[.
URL ni GTki[ n)c[ m&jb C[.
p\i[Ti[ki[l
Di[m[en n[m
dAtiv[jni[ mig<
ci[ks
dAtiv[jn&>
fiel nim
http:
www.apa.org
Monitor/oct00
Workplace.html
j[ t[ sieT upr m*kiy[l mi(ht)n[ fiel sv<r oiri AYini>t(rt krvi miT[
v[b b\iuzr miT[ upyi[g krvi a>g[n) p(tn) (vgt p\i[Ti[ki[l dSi<v[ C[.
77
78
sirN) 6.1
(bn Bi]gi[(lk x[#i p\kir
x[#i p\kir
vN<n
.com
.net
.edu
.int
.gov
.mil
.org
ai j r)t[ Bi]gi[(lk x[#i p\kir pN hi[y C[. j[n[ sirN) 6.2 mi> ji[e Skiy
C[.
79
sirN) 6.2
Bi]gi[(lk x[#i p\kir
x[#i p\kir
d[Sn&> s*ck
x[#i p\kir
d[Sn&> s*ck
.in
Birt
.pk
pi(kAtin
.au
ai[AT^[(lyi
.uk
y&nieT[D
e>l[D
.us
jm<n)
.ca
k[n[Di
(AvT`Zl[<D
.ch
(k>gDm/
kim n krt) URL k[ t&T[l) hiepr(l>kni[ upyi[g Yyi[ hi[y t[v) mi(ht)n[
eTrn[T prY) d&r krvimi> aiv[ C[. ai m&k[l)n[ hl krvi miT[ p\kiSki[
jn<l l[K an[ ay si(hRyn[ DOI aipvin&> S$ ky&<>.
6.2 DOI
p\kiSki[ni j**Y oiri t]yir kriy[l DOI eTrn[T si(hRyn[ yvAYipnn)
ai[LK p\din kr[ C[ { j&ai[, http:// www.doi.org}. ai DOI n&>
r(jAT^[Sn crossref j[v) s>AYiai[ oiri Yiy C[ j[ p\kiSn miT[ (nd[<S an[
ji[DiN (link) n) s[vi aipt) s>AYi C[.
80
81
t[mi> Al[S siY[ j*di pDti an&g an[ p*v<g ji[Diy[li hi[y C[. p*v<g
simiyt: cir k[ t[Y) vF& ai>kDini[ hi[y C[ j[ s>AYin) ai[LK aip[ C[.
an&g p\kiSk oiri p\ki\Snn) kxi an&sir aipvimi> aiv[ C[. yir[ DOI
uplF hi[y Ryir[ (p\T an[ el[T^i[(nk, b>n[ Av$pmi> t[ni[ ul[K krvi[
ji[ea[.
DOI El[T^i[(nk jn<lni p\Ym pini upr ki[p)rieT s*cnin) nJk
dSi<v[li[ hi[y C[. {j*ai[ aikZ(t 6.3}. DOI l[Kni D[Tib[z l[(D>g p[j
upr pN uplF hi[y C[. {j*ai[, aikZ(t 6.4}.
82
ji[ (vPyvAt&n[ DOI uplF n Yyi[ hi[y ti[ jn|<l, p&Atk k[ URL
hi[mp[jn[ dSi<vv&>. ji[ tm[ ki[e King) D[Tib[z prY) l[K m[Lv) rHi
hi[v ti[ tmir[ t[ URL n[ Si[Fvi v[bsc< krv&> pD[. j[ t[ URL n[
ki[p) kr) b\iuzrmi> m*kv&>. { yin riKv&> k[ vD< p\i[s[sr b>F hi[y,
nh)>tr (l>kn&> Av$p bdlie Sk[}.
ji[ tmn[ lienmi> yi>k URLn[ ti[Dvi[ pD[ ti[ yir[y hiefn m*kv&>
nh)>. t[ni bdl[ m&y (vrimn) ph[li URL ti[Dv&>.
{apvid: http://}
p\i(tn) bibt C[.
83
84
aikZ(t 6.3
jn<lmi> Digital Object Identifier (DOI) n&> AYin
Theme Articles
Journal of Teacher Education
60(5) 443 449
2009 SAGE Publications
Wesley Null
Abstract
In this essay, the author argues for a reconsideration of the teachers college tradition within teacher ed curriculum. The author draws upon
85
aikZ(t 6.4
D[Tib[z l[D)g p[j l[K miT[ DOI n&> AYin
Full Record
Display
Unique Identifier
2009-08834-010
Title
Publication Year
2009
Language
English
Author
Wesley Null
Wesley.null@gmail.com
Correspondence
Address
Source
ISSN
Publisher
Sage Publications
Other Publisher
Electronic
Publication Type
Document Type
Journal Article
Digital Object
Identifier
10.1177/0022487109344433
86
Key Words
Index Terms
Teacher
Methodology
Qualitative Study
20090516
87
pi(rBi(Pk Sdi[
88
pi(rBi(Pk Sdi[
{a>g\[J - g&jrit)}
A
abbreviations
s>x[p, s>x[pixr
accepted
Av)kZt
abstract
siri>S
accuracy
ci[ksie
acknowledgement
Av)kir, Av)kZ(t
acronyms
adaptation
an&k*ln
additional link
vFirin) l)>k
89
advance
aigt, ag\)m
adverb
(k\yi(vS[PN
advisory
slihkir)
alignment
r[Ki>kn
alphabetical
kivir) k\m
order
alphabetization
kivir)
alternation
a[ki>tr[
ampersand
anonymous
anim)
APA
am[(rkn siykil(jkl
asi[(Sa[Sn {a[ p) a[}
appeal
(vn>t)
90
appendices
p&rvN)
arabic numerals
ar[(bk n>br
archival copy
archival function
archival sources
article
l[K
article identifier
l[K ai[LK
author
l[Kk
author note
l[Kk ni[>F
91
block quotation
lik avtrN
brackets
b\k\[T
breaks
C
capitalization
citation
(nd[<S p\(k\yi
classical work
SiA#i)y kiyi[<
colon
g&$(vrim
colum
kTir
colum head
kTirn&> mYiL&
comma
ap (vrim
92
comparison
t&lni
copyright
p\kiSnni h
copyright holder
p\kiSn hFirk
DOIs
DOI system
t>#i
Domain name
x[#in&> nim
x[#inimn&> (vAtrN
Duplicate
p\(tkZ(t/ b[vD&>
Ed.
s>pidkni[ T&>kixr
93
Eds.
s>pidki[ni[ T&>kixr
Editor
s>pidk
Editorial
s>pidk)y
Electronic sources
(vjiN&> s\i[ti[
locater information
Et. al.
an[ ay
Fair use
yiy) upyi[g
Footnote
pidni[>F
Foreign abbreviation
(vd[S) T&>kixri[
94
Groups
j*Yi[
guideline
mig<d(S<ki
protocol)
{ ky*Trn) BiPi}
HTTPS(hypertext transfer
protocol secure)
Hyphen
yi[jn(ch`n
Indexing
kivir s*(c
95
In press
p\[smi>
Insertion
diKl krv&>
Jargon
Key terms
civ)$p Sdi[
Legal material
kiydik)y si(hRy
96
M
Meta-analysis
a(F-(vl[PN
Multivolume works
n.d.
tir)K nh)>
Omission
smiv[S n krvi[
Online archive
Online material
ainlien si(hRy
Online network
ainlien jiL&>
97
P
Page number
pin n>br
Para.
Paraphrasing
Sdi>tr
Parts of work
kiy<ni (vBigi[
Permission
m>j*r)
Personal communication
y(tgt p\Ryiyn
Protocol
(SOTicir
Publication data
p\kiSn simg\)
Publication date
p\kiSn tir)K
Publication information
p\kiSn (vgti[
98
Punctuation
(vrim (ch`ni[
Quantity
s>yi
Quotation
avtrN
Quotation mark
avtrN (ch`n
Quoting
avt(rt krv&>
Reference abbreviation
s>dB< T&>kixri[
Reference component
s>dB< GTki[
Reference list
s>dB< yid)
99
Reference section
s>dB< (vBigi[
Reprinting
p&n: m&WN
Retrieval dates
Semicolon
ap (vrim
Sic
Slash
Suffixes
an&g
Translation
an&vid
100
U
URLs
Version
aivZ(_i
Version of record
dAtiv[jn) aivZ(_i
Volume number
Written consent
l[(Kt m>j&r)
101
Year of publication
p\kiSnn&> vP<
102
pi(rBi(Pk Sdi[
{g&jrit) a>g\[J}
a
a(F-(vl[PN
Meta analysis
an&k*ln
Adaptation
anim)
Anonymous
an&g
Suffix
an&vid
Translation
Multivolume work
kiy<
an[ ay
et. al.
103
Ampersand
ar[(bk n>br
Arabic numbers
am[(rkn siykil(jkl
American Psychological
a[si[(Sa[Sn
Association (APA)
ap (vrim
semicolon
avtrN
Quotation
avtrN (ch`n
Quotation mark
avt(rt krv&>
Quoting
a[ki>tr[
Alternation
aigt, a(g\m
Advanced
aivZ(_i
Version
a[v&>, a[ j p\miN[
Sic
104
Online archive
ainlien si(hRy
Online material
ainlien jiL&>
Online network
kiydik)y si(hRy
Legal material
kiy<ni (vBigi[
Part of work
(k\yi (vS[PN
adverb
Para.
g&$(vrim
colon
civ)$p Sdi[
Key words
ci[ksie
Accuracy
105
j
j*Yi[
Groups
(DJTl aij[T
DOIs
aieD[(Tfiyr
(DJTl aij[T
DOI system
aieD[(Tfiyr t>#i
t
tir)K nh)>
n.d.
t&lni
Comparison
dAtiv[jn) aivZ(_i
Version of record
diKl krv&>
Insertion
106
n
(nd[<S p\(k\yi
Citation
yiy) upyi[g
Fair use
pidni[>F
footnote
pin n>br
Page number
Retrieval date
Archival copy
Archival sources
p&n: m&WN
Reprint
p&rvN)
appendix
Volume number
107
p\kiSn tir)K
Publication date
p\kiSnn&> vP<
Year of publication
p\kiSn (vgti[
Publication data
p\kiSn h
copyright
p\kiSn h Firk
Copyright holder
p\(tkZ(t/ b[vD&>
Duplicate
p\[smi>
In press
Acronym
bn[l
lik avtrN
Block quotation
b\[k[T
Bracket
108
m
mig<d(S<ki
Guideline
m*Lixrni[ k\m
Alphabetical order
m*Lixr)krN
Alphabetization
Capitalization
m>j*r)
Permission
yi[jn (ch`n
Hyphen
URLs
109
r[Ki>kn
Alignment
l[K
Article
l[K ai[LK
Article identifier
l[Kk
Author
l[Kk ni[>F
Author note
l[(Kt m>j*r)
Written consent
vFirin) l)>k
Additional link
y(tgt p\Ryiyn
Personal communication
(vjiN& s\i[ti[
Electronic sources
110
mi(ht)
locator information
(vd[S) T&>kixri[
Foreign abbreviation
(vrim (ch`n
Punctuation
(vn>t)
Appeal
Jargon
Sd
Word
Sds*(c
Indexing
SiA#i)y kiyi[<
Classical work
(SOTicir
Protocol
111
smiv[S n krvi[
Omission
slihkir)
Advisory
At>B
Colum
At>Bn&> mYiL&>
Colum head
Av)kir
Acknowledgement
Av)kZt
Accepted
siri>S
Abstract
s>yi/ jYi[
Quantity
s>pidk
Editor
s>pidk {T&>kixr}
Ed.
s>pidki[ {T&>kixr}
Eds.
s>pidk)y
Editorial
112
s>dB< GTki[
Reference component
s>dB< T&>kixri[
Reference abbreviation
s>dB< yid)
Reference list
s>dB< (vBig
Reference section
s>dB<s*(c
Reference
s>x[p
Abbreviation
protocol)
HTTPS ( hypertext
(syi[r
113
x[#in&> nim
Domain name
x[#in&> (vAtrN
114
References
American Psychological Association. (2010). Publication Manual of
American Psychological Association (6th ed.). Washington, DC:
Author.
APA Publications and Communications Board Working Group on
Journal Article Reporting Standards. (2008). Reporting standards
for research in psychology: Why do we need them? what might
they be? American Psychologist, 63, 839-851. doi: 10.1037/0003006X.63.9.839
Deshpande, P. G. (2006). Oxford Universal English-Gujarati
Dictionary(25th ed.). New Delhi: Oxford University Press
Modern Language Association. (2009). MLA Handbook for writers of
Research Papers (7th ed.).New Delhi: Author.
http://www.apa.org
http://wwwcrossref.org
http://www.doi.org
http://www.journals.apa.org
http://www.oxford.com/dictionary
http://www.webster.com/dictionary
115
Sd s*(c
u
a,b,k,
uqi>tr)
aTk
um[rN
a(F(vl[PN
a[
ay j*Yi[
a[k$pti
an&gim)
ani]pci(rk p\Ryiyn
aprk[S
ayis j*Yi[
ar[(bk n>br
a[js)
ap(vrim
a[si[(Sa[Sn
avtrn (ch`n
ai[
avFirN
ain lien
av[J
ai[LK (vnin&>
aXit`
aikZ(_i
k, K, g
aivZ(_i
kivir)
116
ki[T<k[s
eTi(lk
kip)rieT
ED[T
kipi[<r[Sn
El[T^i[(nk
ky*Tr
k\m
ey& n>br
ki]>s
ki]>sn) simg\)
dAtiv[j
King) p#i
F
g&$(vrim
Fi(m<k
n
civ)$p GTk
nkl
(ch`n
(nd[<S
ci[ksie
(nd[<(St
ci[pi(nyi
y&z l[Tr
117
p
C k[ vF& l[Kki[
p(t
pidni[>F
j(Tl
p&n: ap\iy
p&n: m&WN
Tpki>
p&rivi
T*>ki nimi[
p&Atk
T[(lfi[(nk cci<
p*rk simg\)
p*N< (vrim
Di[Tr
p*v<g
p[pr
tir)K
pi[OTr
p\krN
p\kiSn
m[mi[
p\(k\yi
mini[g\if
p\(t(n(F
118
p\mi(NkrN
yid)
p\mi(Nt
y&(nv(s<T)
p\[sni[T
p\ic)n
(p\T
(ry&
rimn
p\i[f[sr
lKiNi[
lG&Si[F (nb>F
li[k
b[ l[Kki[
(bn pr>prigt
l[(Kt m>j*r)
b\[k[T
li[ark[s
li[p
Bir um[rvi[
v
vN<n
mhi(nb>F
vN<nni[ Big
mi(j<n
vP<
mi(ht) p#ik
viyi[
m&y s>AYi
(vjiN& p\Ryiyn
119
m&likit
(vd[Sni> nimi[
m[en
(vrim(ch`ni[
(v(SOT a>k
Av si(h(Ryk ci[r)
(vPyvAt&
s\i[t
(vVsn)y
s>dB<s*(c
viy*m
s>pidk
y(tgt p\Ryiyn
s>pi(dt
y(tgt s>g\h
s>Si[Fn p#i
yiyi
s>AYi
yiyinni[>F
s>x[p
yip
hAtp\t
SiA#i)y kiyi[<
hiefn
S)P<k
S]l)
120
smicirp#i
smili[cn
a,b,c,d
srkir) s>AYi
APA
siBir Av)kir
Author-date method
sirN)
Auxiliary material
siri>S
AYin
ApOT)krN
Bibliography
C
Ap[s
Comma
Classification code
T
Digital object
Technical term
Display
The
Translator
E
Edition
Editor
I
Volume
W
Identifier
With
121
Index term
ISSN
N
No date
Number part
P
Page
Peer reviewed
Prefix
R
Reference list
Revised edition
S
See also