Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AUGUST 2015
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank all of my professors for their help during this journey. Thank you
Elizabeth Delacruz and Michelle Tillander for guiding me along the way. I would also
like to thank my friends and family for their support and Dale Cobler for helping me with
it all.
Table of Contents
Title Page.............................................................................................................................1
UF Copyright Page..............................................................................................................2
Acknowledgments...............................................................................................................3
UF Formatted Abstract........................................................................................................4
Table of Contents.................................................................................................................6
Introduction..........................................................................................................................8
Statement of the Problem.........................................................................................8
Purpose and Goals of the Study...............................................................................9
Research Questions................................................................................................10
Significance of the Study.......................................................................................10
Assumptions...........................................................................................................11
Limitations.............................................................................................................11
Definition of Terms................................................................................................11
Literature Review..............................................................................................................12
Methodology......................................................................................................................20
Peer Reviewers......................................................................................................22
Research Site.........................................................................................................22
Data Collection Procedures and Instrumentation..................................................22
Data Analysis Procedures......................................................................................23
Findings.............................................................................................................................24
Throughout my time at the University of Florida, Ive had one professor that
inquired as to what it is from my lessons that leaves a lasting impression? That same
professor later asked the class if your students remembered anything about your course
what would it be? These questions compelled me to think deeper about the subject
matter and how I teach my students. Yes, my students enjoy my art class and learn a lot
about artistic styles or techniques but what else? Does my drawing content provide
students with opportunities to challenge the way they think? Does it prepare them for a
real world? Does the art taught open new perspectives? Sadly it does not. Simply put, my
curriculum provides students a chance to problem solve using creativity and artistic
techniques. This realization led me to my Capstone Project. My Capstone Project has
allowed me to investigate how I can effectively incorporate contemporary social issues
into a unit of study in drawing for my high school Drawing II students.
Statement of the Problem
Gude suggests that art educators have the ability to foster student participation in
democratic society (2009). It is the responsibility of educators to provide students with
the ability to experience the pleasures, anxieties, and responsibilities of democratic life
(Gude, 2009, p. 8). Gude also observes that many art teachers often teach art the way they
were taught in school (2000). I have always taught students in a studio format based
purely on different drawing techniques, which is how I learned. I have realized that a
high school art curriculum should present students with greater abilities than learning
mediums and art making skills. Art classes should provide opportunities that better the
students skills and mind. As a teacher in a developing community and a diverse nation, I
believe my curriculum should interest students in being a part of the democratic society.
This ideal has left me with a dilemma; I have not had a chance to study how foster and
promote conditions for development of engagement. Further, I was not familiar with how
to teach such a lesson.
Purpose and Goals of the Study
The purpose of this study is to develop a way to create a beneficial drawing
curriculum that will be more meaningful while at the same time exploring contemporary
social issues that students face on a daily basis. Students that I work with in the past are
not prone to talk about various social issues in society and the local community. Many
pupils gather their knowledge through second-hand sources, social networking, and
through peer persuasion. Adolescents are developing tremendously at this age; they are
easily influenced and are going through a tough part of their school life. Teaching
contemporary social issues through drawing in the secondary art room will provide
students with an opportunity to explore various matters in a safe environment while
creating a more grounded understanding of their society. My goal is to establish a
drawing curriculum unit that will incorporate contemporary social issues and offer
students an activity to express their self in a secondary art environment through activist
art. Through research I built upon my knowledge of curriculum development. I also want
to deepen my understanding of contemporary art and issues prevalent to todays society.
Also through my research and resulting curriculum I allow students a chance to develop
conscious awareness of the issues of interest and the many ways art (drawing) can
negotiate the human experiences.
10
Research Questions
Reflecting on my art curriculum and current teaching practices has led me to
investigate a new curriculum unit that is relevant to the students needs. This unit of study
will focus primarily on contemporary social issues and engage students in activist art.
The following research questions guided my investigation:
1.
How can contemporary social issues be explored in a high school drawing course?
2.
3.
What contemporary social issues could be addressed in the high school drawing
class?
4.
11
Assumptions
In my research I assumed that I would find many resources available on
contemporary social issues and on activist art lessons plans. I also speculated that
creating a work of art based on an issue would prepare students to become more engaged
citizens of society. Students would be allowed to convey their thoughts in an engaging
manner through their artworks. Lastly I considered those contemporary artists who create
activist works of art would be abundant and guide me in my research.
Limitations
The time frame of completing my Capstone Project has limited my study and the
examination of the curriculum unit. Due to completing my research during the summer
semester I was not able to implement the unit to establish what works sufficiently and
what should be adjusted. This limitation also prohibits me from knowing if the lesson in
deed would create a lasting impact on my students. In addition finding contemporary
artists and addressing issues that are not overtly controversial was a minor limitation.
Working in a public school district discourages me from touching on certain issues that
are deemed to controversial as well as showing particular artists.
Definition of Terms
Activist art. Any form of art that is created and draws attention to a particular
injustice and in one way or another encourages others to take part as active observers
(Whittaker, 1992).
Contemporary art. Contemporary art is a range of art and practices in different
styles and media dating from the recent past to the present (The J. Paul Getty Trust online
dictionary, 2000).
12
Contemporary Issues. This term relates to any issue that is relevant to the
present time (Whittaker, 1992).
Social Issues. This term refers to problems that occur in the world that involve
people or groups of people in society that deem it as being undesirable. (Whittaker,
1992).
Literature Review
Visual arts are a vital part of the curriculum, but a curriculum founded on
primarily artistic techniques is not enough. The development of intellect with a heavy
emphasis on skill has been the main purpose of art education for some time now (Foshay,
1998). Art education can do more than just allow opportunities for learning new art
techniques; it can promote change. An art curriculum taught with an approach to
contemporary social issues provides an outlet for students to contribute to social life and
have the opportunity to learn through art. A democratic art education approach can make
a lasting difference in student learning. Contemporary social issues addressed in art
lessons allow the teachers to extend past technical quality. Education is, by its very
nature, an agent in the development and maintenance of social beliefs, behaviors, and
values (Hicks, 1994, p. 49). Addressing contemporary social issues in the art curriculum
can help establish links between local communities, national concerns, and political
concerns. An established curriculum permits students to learn, experience, and become a
link to civil society (Delacruz, 2005). This sort of curriculum can also reveal
complexities, diversities, and reconstruct belief (Freedman, 2000).
A developed art curriculum with the inclusion of contemporary social issues
permits teachers to view how students construct meaning and personal beliefs.
13
Contemporary social issues in art can initiate deeper conversations about critical topics. It
will grant the students to explore their world, get to know themselves, understand the
relationships, and become better human beings (Albers, 1999). An established program
can help develop a connection that provides a developed capacity of self-awareness
through which one vividly notices and interacts with a world of ideas. Art lessons can
help promote intense awareness with a strong sense of self and deeper inner engagement
with feelings. Students can tolerate a sense of isolation, work through anxiety associated
with the art process, and sustain a sense of identity. Individuals are also able to pursue
investigations, utilize meaning, and reformulate existing meaning (Gude, 2009). This
approach is a contributor to a social perspective; construction of meaning towards a
broader, more sophisticated understanding of visual culture and issues (Freedman, 2000).
Adolescent Development
Students in high school all have something in commontheir developmental
patterns. Adolescents are starting to approach adulthood and gain an understanding of
adult art practices. Cognitive thought is being developed as students are developing a
degree of skill and intellect. Teenagers in high school, between ages 13-17 years old, can
think abstractly and have a capacity for metacognitive activity (Simpson, Delany, Carroll,
Hamilton, Kay, Kerlavage, & Olson, 1998). Adolescents emotional, moral, and social
development can be a cause for some concern. As students reach puberty, they begin to
experience more stress and a lack of understanding due to their increased hormone levels.
Teens start to seek acceptance from their peers that enables their decisions to be adversely
influenced by their peers (Lin, 2010). Students at this age are going through a difficult
time (Hawkes, 2010). As they begin to develop a sense of self and grow into their
14
immediate community, students often venture into risky behaviors (Simpson, et al.,
1998). Peers easily persuade adolescents; this results in a social reliance that impacts their
thought making process. Students need to be aware of how their decisions are constructed
as they develop. At the secondary level, students should be presented with social issues
(p. 298). Students attempt to comprehend the world through social issues and rationalize
their thoughts through visual expression.
Incorporating Contemporary Social Issues into the Curriculum
As educators we create citizens of a democratic society we should create
experiments of pleasure and anxiety (Gude, 2009, p. 14). The curriculum should allow
students to question assumptions, consider moral citizenship in a society (Milbrandt,
2002), challenge social and structural inequality, as well as promote social and cultural
diversity (Stuhr, 1994). Quality art projects will aid the students in exploring their sense
of being while introspectively examining how complex families, social, and media
impact their experiences. Through a quality curriculum, students should be in a position
to sense, examine, and identify important themes. Play in art and investigation with
pupils allows them to develop learning skills. The curriculum should pertain to everyday
life, consider barriers, pose problems, and explore life issues (Gude, 2007). The material
examined needs to be meaningful to the students, grounded in authentic practice, foster a
critical, reflective attitude, and pursue pluralist perspectives (Sullivan, 1993).
Curricular Approaches
There have been numerous recommendations in the profession of art education on
how to incorporate contemporary social issues into the art curriculum. Darts (2006)
shares a curriculum he developed and implemented with his high school students. His
15
student driven unit began by the students generating a list of various social and
contemporary issues that were relevant to them. The students proceeded by splitting into
groups and researching one concept in detail. The students were then responsible for both
initiating classroom discussion and providing instruction on the creation of artworks that
addressed the issue at hand.
Buffington (2007) examines the work of a contemporary artist and provides
guidelines to assist in creating a unit around contemporary social issues. The suggested
steps involve generating a list of issues that students are interested in. The students would
then choose an issue and analyze how their personal artistic style can heighten the
message that it portrays. The learners would begin by creating thumbnails that
incorporate their issues into a meaningful, communicative work of art following the
completion of the aforementioned steps. In addition, the students would reflect their
thoughts and ideas in their sketchbook. Students will discuss their work with peers, selfreflect, and share their findings throughout the process. Buffington also provides
educators and readers with suggestions on how to assess the work. Educators should be
seeking formative assessment by monitoring the process of the students and their
reflections. Summative assessment evaluations come from examination of the final artist
statement and a rubric. The suggested rubric addresses the materials used to share the
concept, how well the art communicates the idea, and how change is being integrated into
the artwork.
Another method mentioned addressing contemporary social issues in the high
school art classroom is through art-based research. Marshall and DAdamo (2011)
examine an art based research model in depth and how it contrasts with conventional
16
17
relatable, the students can explore alternative views and rethink their initial assumptions
(Guadelius & Spiers, 2002).
Meaning Making in Drawing Using Contemporary Social Issues
Art reveals students beliefs about their self, roles in society, social locations, and
imagination (Albers, 1999). Incorporating social and contemporary issues into the art
room makes the art no longer about individual emotions but the personalization of social
issues (Freedman, 2000). Artist Tyree Guyton uses his upbringing in Detroit, Michigan to
influence his art. Guytons art is influenced by various personal stories and one can notice
it in many of his public artworks around Detroit. The Dotty Wotty House (19932001) (Buffington, 2007, p. 26) was constructed to beautify a declining residential area.
The painted house was covered with a variety of colorful polka dots in many different
sizes. The polka dot idea came from his grandfather, but the concept came from a quote
by Martin Luther King Jr. We are all the same color on the inside (Buffington, 2007, p.
26). Guytons variety of polka dots represents the diversity in the world. In Calling All
Cars (2002) Guyton created a drawing on how the community does not have enough
police cars to respond to situations (Buffington, 2007, p. 32). Guyton claimed that the
work takes on a cartoon effect because of the humor of police reaching anyone in a
timely fashion (Buffington, 2007). Additional activist artist can be found in my resources
created (see Appendix A)
In another example of engaging social issues, a group of pre-service teachers in
Los Angeles divided up into different groups to document issues relevant to themselves
as individuals. One of the groups that were mostly parents focused on the violence being
18
exposed to children through mass media. The teachers constructed an environment for a
child that attempted to provide a cozy and inviting atmosphere presenting soft colors with
a teddy bear. Upon further examination it became apparent that the bedspread was a quilt
consisting of different CD and video game covers that depict violent images associated
with war. The bedside had a gift wrapped in G.I. Joe paper and a coloring book with
violent images to color. Rashes of shootings lead another group to focus on the violence
and the innocent victims. This group created a large cardboard sculpture to resemble a
realistic 9mm pistol aimed at two targets. Recent headlines from the news were being
discharged from the pistol representing ammunition. The targets are composed of images;
one target displays pictures of the innocent victims while the other target displays images
of the guilty and the shooters.
In looking for contemporary art that also addresses social issues, the PBS series
and website Art 21 allows viewers to become familiar with different contemporary artists
who address a collection of relevant topics. Most of the topics addressed can be relatable
to students in a high school art class. In an episode focusing on artistic change, Art 21
recognizes several artists who work to promote engagement in current situations around
the world. For example, one of the artists featured in the Art 21 artists, Ai Weiwei, is a
Chinese artist and human rights activist. Weiwei has been arrested and held for three
months for his outspoken actions. His artwork consists of sculptures, photographs, and
public art all examining Chinese political as well as social issues. His art examines social
issues over time with the use of sarcasm and symbolism. Catherine Opie is another artist
mentioned in the Art 21 change episode. Opie is an Ohio native and explores her
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
my curriculum unit by studying art lessons taught by Darts (2006), Watson (2012), and
information analyzed by Milbrandt (2002) addressing issues of society. Each of these
articles provided me with some insight on what I wanted to do and what I did not think
would work for my situation. Darts (2006), despite being a good unit, would not work for
my situation because I was not able to devote an entire semester to one content area.
Watson (2012) offered some very useful insight on how to engage students and was
considered when I created my lesson. Milbrandts (2002) study allowed me to
conceptualize what other art educators deemed relevant and appropriate for students in
the classroom. All of this information and much more was analyzed and documented in
my field notes.
Another useful source I discovered that helped me personally explore these
matters through art was the Art21 website created by PBS. This website was a
tremendous tool to take advantage of in my research. The sources on this webpage were
endless. Videos on a range of issues with focus on particular artist were extremely
informative. The website also offers biographies of the artists and educators resource
guides to use along with screening the video. One particular matter that I found to be
interesting was the Change segment from the Season Six episode. Hearing artist Ai
Weiwei and El Anatsui discuss their art and how it could be transforming seemed to be an
engaging topic, one that I could see students enjoying. I created a PowerPoint that would
help students explore matters in a new light using this episode and the educator resource
PDF download.
The peer responses provided me with insightful information. My original
curriculum unit was pretty sparse. The response from my peers who participated included
27
suggestions that I provide the students with more resources to explore. I had originally
designed a Pinterest board with various artists all collected in a few boards; feedback
suggested that I still allow students to research artists and topics but provide them with
some direction. I revamped the Pinterest site to make it more navigable and created a
Delicious account for the students to find more contemporary artists through museum
links. I also collected additional artists webpages and compiled them into a document to
assist students (see Appendix F).
28
29
teaching in the same county and has seen negative reactions from certain topics. This left
me debating what in particular I should be allowed to discuss in class. From this point I
decided that approval from the administration was a necessary item to obtain. It was
suggested that I draft a letter to parents explaining that the students will be exploring
contemporary social issues in their drawing class and will be creating an activist work of
art. If there were any parents who wanted their child not to explore any particular issue,
the student could be given a refined list of topics to choose from. Depending on the
students in the class any topic could be approached if on a sensitive level. Some of the
topics that I believe are appropriate are: advertising, discrimination, conservation,
consumerism, delinquency, bullying, eating disorders, etc. (see Appendix G for full list).
The abundant amount of artists available provided me with more options and a
chance to be selective on the content that I show my students. Working in a public high
school has certain limitations. Works of art by Kara Walker or Robert Mapplethorpe,
albeit very nice and illustrative of social issues, would not be appropriate for my high
school students. Artworks that are appropriate and artists sites that were not too
controversial such as, Scott Erickson, Bjorn Richter, Pawel Kuczynski, Sue Coe etc. were
saved to my compilation of pins and to my resources list (see Appendix A for full list).
Third Finding: Activist Artists and Their Art
As previously stated in the data analysis section, I organized the information on
artists and issues found into subcategories. I pulled a few of the artists from the list and
did further research on them to create PowerPoints. These PowerPoints will be used as a
way to introduce the lesson and display how different artists work to address social
issues.
30
A few considerations were made when debating which topic I should introduce to
the students. First to contemplate was the community I teach in, Fort Mill, South Carolina
is a very diverse growing community located directly south of Charlotte, North Carolina.
A lot of Charlottes employees commute from Fort Mill, which contributes to the
diversity within our schools. Fort Mill, once a very small town first inhabited by Native
Americans, is very rich in morals and the small town culture. Even with the growing
diversity in the small town it still remains pretty friendly with very few issues. Another
aspect worth considering is what is relevant in the news and world today. One of the most
recent topics in the news over the past few months has been racism. This is all a subject
my students are familiar with through school lessons and the social media broadcasts. My
experience teaching at this school for five years and growing up near this city leads me to
believe that this is not a particular issue that the students deal with on a regular basis.
Therefore, I decided to use this as a topic to introduce to them. I began my additional
research by finding credible sources that have non-biased statistics on racism and plugged
in the graphs to a PowerPoint. I even managed to find a video on an organizations page
about how racism became an issue in North America.
I proceeded by finding some contemporary artists that address racism and racist
stereotypes into their art. Among the first piece I found and included was Girl with a
Bamboo Earring, by Awol Erizku. This work is a recreation of Girl With a Pearl Earring
by Vermeer but alters the models race and jewelry, representing race between African
Americans and Caucasians. The Reconcile Mural by Gregg Deal is another piece I found
to display. From my experience, when students think about racism their mind jumps to
white or black when the issue is more complex than that. Gregg Deal is a Native
31
American whose works of art address how history has been unkind to Native Americans.
This piece in particular showcases how land was taken and then reconciled by giving a
professional football team an Indian Mascot (Redskins). Another work of art I chose
was What are you looking at? by Masami Teraoka. This piece is quite different than the
rest because it addresses Asian culture and American culture. Several pieces of Teraokas
work addresses interracial relationships and the sometimes-strained relationship Asians
may have with Americans.
Figure 5. The Reconcile Mural, Gregg Deal, 2014, photo by Dakota Fine
After creating an example on researching a social issue, I created a list of social
issues to refer to if needed to motivate student thinking. I also created some PowerPoints
focusing primarily on one artist with some background information. I found two new
favorite artists during the gathering of my research. Scott Erickson is a working studio
artist who brings art and important matters to the publics attention. Erickson works on
32
many different projects but what I found the most interesting was his work with nonprofit organizations. The ideal behind his Orphan Art Project is what captured my
attention the most. He first heard about the orphan situation in Swaziland in 2011 and
wanted to help in some way. Erickson has spent some time in Swaziland and has seen the
conditions of the children. Approximately 41 % of the population is HIV positive and
kills off most of the adult population; in his video on YouTube
(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtzqNGAxsK0) he has found research that by 2020
there will be no adults left if conditions remain the same. Erickson started the Orphan Art
Project (orphanartproject.com). This project began with orphan children painting
canvases and then Scott completed the paintings back in the United States. All proceeds
of the prints go to an orphanage in Swaziland (Erickson, 2011).
33
in a shocking way. A particular series of art is called Running the Numbers: An American
Self-Portrait. This series is broken into two parts but both capture the same concept:
Americas rate of consumption. The image below, Cigarette Butts, depicts 139,000
cigarette butts. This number is equal to the number of cigarettes that are smoked and
discarded every fifteen seconds in the United States. Cigarette butts are the number one
littered item found in public spaces. Much of his work addresses items that are consumed
by students or that students have some association with. It is a sad realization but Jordan
does a great job at showing how a serious topic can be displayed in a way to engage
student thought without being overtly controversial.
34
while exploring answers to my main questions for this project. Learning about new artists
also allowed me to collect more resources to make a curriculum unit more relevant to
each students individual needs.
Discussion and Conclusion
In this Capstone Project, I wanted to create an art unit for my drawing class that
would explore contemporary social issues as well as make them more engaged, civil
citizens. I wanted to research different artists and the reasons why this was important to
my students. Scholars recommend that teachers should promote civil leadership and
engagement at a younger age. Education is an agent in the structure and maintenance of
beliefs, values and behaviors (Hicks, 1994). Contemporary social issues explored in an
art class allows students to identify and rethink their beliefs about their role in the larger
world (Albers,1999). Social reconstruction education prepares students to challenge
social, structural inequality and to promote the coal of diversity (Stuhr, 1994). Creating
an art unit of curriculum geared towards contemporary art and contemporary social issues
through arts-based research and curriculum development has allowed me to create a
series of lessons that will promote learning and individual character development.
Interpretation of Findings
Based on the findings from this Capstone Project, I believe that teaching
contemporary social issues will not be as challenging as what I first perceived.
Resources referenced through this process and communication with peers has provided
me with more awareness to implement a lesson on a controversial, yet needed topic.
There are many practicing art teachers that believe contemporary social issues should be
explored in an art class. The biggest hesitance for these teachers is in knowing how to
35
implement them in a safe manner (Milbrandt, 2002). I am pleased to have found multiple
resources to aid me on my journey and to share with other art educators. This is not a new
idea or approach to teaching but something that should be considered.
Significance, Implications, and Recommendations
I believe that exploring contemporary art and contemporary social issues is a good
practice. This research has provided me with insight for when I implement the lesson. I
will feel confident and secure with the role of facilitating student learning on these topics.
The understandings gained from the arts-based research have proven to me to be the most
intuitive choice of methodology for this project. The resources created to aid me in
teaching will prove to be the most important component of the lesson. These resources
will not only engage all students but also provide them with many different abilities while
cutting back on disturbances and downtime during research. Lists of activist artists,
drawing artists, contemporary artists, and contemporary art museums will enhance
student learning and growth. This amount of exposure will allow students the opportunity
to find what interests them most and what will help guide them in developing their own
artistic style. These teaching aids are so valuable that they can be applied to many other
lessons and different art studio courses as well.
Art educators can use this research and the resources created to help initiate their
own unique lesson to suit their needs. Art teachers can help promote student awareness
and increase knowledge on contemporary art techniques by utilizing the Capstone Project
created. Activist art can be a tool for developing a sense of community within the class
and school for many art teachers. This lesson can also promote community awareness to
make a positive impact.
36
In looking ahead, I would encourage all art educators to become familiar with the
various issues. Knowing your class is a very key element in the unit. In order to teach this
unit and be effective, the classroom environment must be a safe place and allow students
to feel comfortable in expressing their individual ideals. An atmosphere such as this will
allow students to be respectful of others even if their beliefs contrast their peers. Having a
response plan set up in the chance things get out of hand would be a great idea to
consider. I would also encourage any art educator to speak with their administration to
establish guidelines for what may be considered too controversial for that particular
school. Lastly, I would recommend any art educator to understand that this lesson has not
yet been exercised, which will be essential in understanding its full potential.
Conclusion
Creating this Capstone Project has been an enlightening experience. I have grown
to learn more about my personal artistic interests and beliefs on contemporary social
issues. It has been a self-discovery in a way I did not think possible. It is my opinion that
once I implement this art unit into my curriculum, it will create more engaging students. I
also think that it will provide the other departments in my school some new light on how
art can be beneficial to the students. As I proceed, I look forward to seeing what amazing
pieces my students will create and how they will continue to amaze me. My complete
body of work can be located at www.aliciabagley.weebly.com. This website houses all
resources and links to references mentioned.
37
References
Albers, P. (1999). Art education and the possibility of social change. Art Education,
52(4), 6-11.
Amorino, J. (2009). The artistic impetus model: A resource for reawakening artistic
expression in adolescents. Studies in Art Education, 50(3), 214-231.
Buffington, M. (2007). Art to bring about change: The work of Tyree Guyton. Art
Education,60(4), 25-32.
Darts, D. (2006). Art education for a change: Contemporary issues and the visual arts.
Art
Education, 59(5), 6-12.
Delacruz, E. (2005). Art education in civil society. Visual Arts Research, 31(2), 3-9.
Erickson, S. (2011). Orphan art project. Retrieved from
www.scotterickson.com/projects/
Freedman, K. (2000). Social perspectives on art education in the U.S.: Teaching visual
culture in a democracy. Studies in Art Education, 41(4), 314-329.
Foshay, A. W. (1998). Problem solving and the arts. Journal of Curriculum &
38
39
Education,7(2),184229.
Hicks, L. (1994). Social reconstruction and community. Studies in Art Education,
35(3),
149-156.
Ianni, F. (1968). The arts as agents for social change: An anthropologists view. Art
Education, 21(7), 15-20.
Kimpston, R. & Rogers, K. (1986). A framework for curriculum research. Curriculum
Inquiry 16(4), 463-474.
Lin,X.(2010).Identifyingpeereffectsinstudentacademicachievementbyspatial
autoregressivemodelswithgroupunobservable.JournalofLaborEconomics,
28(4),825860.
Marshall, J. & DAdamo, K. (2011). Art practice as research in the classroom: A new
paradigm in art education. Art Education, 64(5), 12-18.
McTighe, J. & Thomas, R. (2003). Backward design for forward action. Educational
Leadership, 60(5), 52-55.
Milbrandt, M. (2002). Addressing contemporary social issues in art education: A survey
40
41
42
Appendix A
List of Activist Artists
Robert Ernst MarxPaints and sculpts to personify the human condition. His favorite themes to
address is power, the exclusivity of church and state, and abuse.
http://roberternstmarx.com/
Masami Teraoka
Draws images to represent globalization and the clash between cultures.
http://masamiteraoka.com/archive/biography.php
Pawel Kuczynski
Illustration artist whose works convey many messages and meanings. His art
addresses war, social media, politics, etc.
http://www.pawelkuczynski.com/index.php
Young Soon Min
Los Angeles artist from Korea. Her art consist of many themes that deal with
issues of representation, cultural identities, history and memories.
http://www.yongsoonmin.com/biography/
Dread Scott
Draws, sculpts, photographs, and performance art are the genres he works in. His
topics range from adolescent youth, stereotypes, exploitation, and suffering.
http://www.dreadscott.net/about/
Chris Jordan
Photographic artist whose works portray human consumption and the impact it
has on the environment.
http://www.chrisjordan.com/gallery/rtn2/ - bees
Bjorn Richter
An artist/illustrator, graphic designer, and sculptor. His art addresses many social
issues mainly concerned with the environment and the use of resources.
http://bjornrichter.no/richter_hovedsider.htm
Gregg Deal
A Native American artist who addresses his heritage, culture, prejudice among
Native Americans.
http://greggdeal.com/
Sue Coe
43
Mixed media artist who addresses various issues. Most of her work documents the
protest animal rights and some of her work addresses politics, rape, foreign
policy, greed, and more.
http://www.moma.org/collection/artist.php?artist_id=1170
http://www.artnet.com/artists/sue-coe/
Scott Erickson
A visual artist who works with non-profits to help raise funds and awareness. His
art has dealt with AIDS, orphans, cultural differences, etc.
http://scottericksonart.com/about/
Ricardo Levins Morales
Considers himself an artist/activist and addresses many topics in his work. His
favorite medium is scratchboard. You can find art about education, different
cultures, politics, consumption, gender, etc on his website.
http://www.rlmartstudio.com/
Mel Chin
A conceptual visual artist motivated largely by political, cultural, and social
circumstances.
http://www.melchin.org/
Wayne Gilbert
Uses oil and human cremated remains to create works of art on life and age.
http://www.waynegilbert.com/about/
Ai Weiwei
A Chinese contemporary artist who addresses human rights, political issues, and
government corruption.
http://aiweiwei.com/
Allora and Calzadilla
Through a wide range of mediums and work these artist concentrate on political
tension and the public.
http://www.lissongallery.com/artists/allora-and-calzadilla
Hank Willis Thomas
Contemporary African-American artist whose particular interest deals with race,
advertising, and popular culture.
http://www.hankwillisthomas.com/
Arman Pierre Fernandez
An artist who addressed many topics and was influenced from Pop Art and
Dadism. Some of his well known work address consumerism and the amount we
waste.
http://www.armanstudio.com/arman-biography-1-eng.html
44
Dhruvi Acharya
Her art addresses the aspects of an urban womans life. Her art is also addresses
death, love, and the environment.
http://www.dhruvi.com/
Rokni Haerizadeh
Dubai based artist whose work addresses social and public gatherings in Iran.
http://www.ivde.net/artists/rokni_haerizadeh/biography
Banksy
A graffiti street artist whose work often addresses many controversial issues.
http://banksy.co.uk/in.asp
Mike Edwards
A typographic artist whose images incorporate text to portray various meanings.
http://mikeedwards.co.uk/index.htm?nbtn=0
Kryzysztof Wodiczko
An artist who creates many of his many and images through projections upon
monumental architecture. Art ranges in topics from political to homelessness.
Mark Vallen
American activist artist whose art addresses many issues from globalization to
war.
http://www.art-for-a-change.com/Vallen/vallen.htm
45
Olafur Eliasson
http://www.olafureliasson.net/
Amanda Schachter
http://www.architalx.org/levi-schachter/
Naziha Mestaoui
http://www.electronicshadow.org/nm/
Mathilde Roussel
http://www.mathilderoussel.com/
Mary David Hobson
http://marydanielhobson.com/
Ester Hernandez
http://www.esterhernandez.com/
Vik Muniz
http://vikmuniz.net/
Ales Nabaum
http://www.alexnabaum.com/
Paulo Grangeon
http://www.papiermache.co.uk/gallery/artist/580/
Thomas Saliot
http://www.thomassaliot.com/
Anna Westfall
http://art.unm.edu/anna-westfall/
Megan Jacobs
http://www.meganjacobs.com/
Cathy Whysocki
http://cathywysocki.com/
Vincent Leandro
http://hansonhowardgallery.com/2011/07/meet-vincent-leandro/
Kenji Nakayama
http://kngee.com/
46
Christopher Hope
http://fineartamerica.com/profiles/christopher-hope.html
Heather Soltz
http://sewingstories.com/
Dylan Taverner
Jerry W. Miller
http://jerrymillerart.com/
Laura Dunn
http://www.lauradunnart.com/
Chelsea Briganti
Marc Clamage
http://www.ipaintwhatisee.com/
47
48
Appendix B
Curriculum Unit (as adapted from my district)
Exploring Contemporary Social Issues in a High School Drawing Curriculum
Grade Level: 10-12 (Drawing 2)
Length of unit: 3-4 weeks
Task Description:
Students will identify and examine various contemporary social issues in their
own lives and in their local and global community.
Students will choose a topic relevant to them and will plan and create a work of
art that investigates meaning to the theme/idea. Students will identify, locate and
examine the work of contemporary artists who have addressed this theme.
After in-progress class critiques, students will revise and complete their art and
write an artist statement. Students will then curate and display their art around
school grounds.
Instructional objectives aligned with the National Visual Arts Standards:
Creating:
Experiment/Imagine/Identify
1. Students examine and identify themes in contemporary artworks.
2. Students summarize the themes in contemporary artworks.
Investigate/ Plan/Make
3. Students plan, experiment, and shape an artistic investigation on a social or
contemporary issue
4. Students select and use a contemporary art making approach to create a work of
art.
Reflect/Refine/Continue
5. Students share, explain, and discuss in-progress artwork.
6. Students critique and use feedback to make decisions about revising and/or
refining art work.
7. Students compose an artists statement.
49
Presenting:
Select/Analyze
1. Students identify and apply criteria for selecting art and artifacts for an exhibit
or display.
2. Students explain reasons for selecting key art and artifacts for an exhibit or
display.
Prepare/Curate
3. Students investigate and identify a site or space for installing an exhibit or
display.
4. Students compare a variety of factors and methods when planning an exhibit or
display.
Exhibit/Share
5. Students work with others to plan and create a physical or digital exhibit or
display of selected works of art and/or artifacts for an identified audience.
6. Students evaluate what they learned from the process of curating and
presenting the exhibit or display.
Responding:
Perceive /Analyze
1. Students identify approaches for shaping interpretations.
2. Students analyze responses to works of contemporary art.
Enduring Understandings in alignment with standards:
Creativity and innovative thinking are essential life skills that can be developed.
Artists and other presenters consider various techniques, methods, venues, and
criteria when selecting works for presentation.
Artists and designers shape artistic investigations, following or breaking with
traditions in pursuit of creative art making goals.
Vocabulary:
Artist Statement
Artist investigation
Contemporary Art
content
Context
Curate
Critique
Innovative thinking
50
Activist art
Materials:
Color pencils
Graphite pencils
Tortillions
Erasers
Newsprint
Newspaper
Resources:
Art 21 http://www.pbs.org/art21/
Artist websites/ museum websites/ blogs /Pinterest
My personal Pinterest collection and Scoop.it board
http://www.scoop.it/u/alicia-bagley-1
https://www.pinterest.com/abagley0619/
Instructional Procedures:
Lesson 1 (Introduction and the research)
Day 1
Students will begin class by responding to writing prompt What do you know/remember
about contemporary drawing? Following sufficient time for each student to respond in
his or her sketchbook, the teacher will then initiate a class discussion on contemporary
drawing. Following this the teacher will then present a PowerPoint to the class on
Contemporary drawing based off of the book Contemporary Drawing: Key Concepts
and Techniques by Margaret Davidson. (Contemporary Drawing PowerPoint located on
website).
For the remainder of class students will be given the opportunity to play in their
sketchbook. The class will be able to experiment with various mediums available to
create mini-contemporary drawings.
Day 2
Students will begin class by responding to a questionnaire form (attached). The form will
encourage students to begin thinking about various issues.
51
After ample time has been given to the students, the teacher will then present a
PowerPoint to students on social, contemporary issues and activist art.
(Contemporary/Social Activist Art Project located on webpage under lesson plan)
As a class we will compile a large list of topics that fall into the categories. Each student
will be allowed/required to go to the list on the smart board and write down a few topics.
Some class discussion will guide the students and help create a brief understanding of
such topics.
Students will then be introduced to Art21 on PBS. Students will watch a small clip of
from season four on change and will respond to some questions in a PowerPoint
(questions are from the teacher resource guide on the website and Art21 Change
PowerPoint is located on webpage)
The teacher will then present a PowerPoint created on the topic of Racism. Students will
be able to see how different artist portray race in many ways. Students will then create a
mini drawing in their sketchbook about what race means to them. (Racism PowerPoint is
located on webpage under additional resources)
Day 3-6
The teacher will begin the class with a PowerPoint titled Historical Activist Art on how
art has been used in the past to create a difference or promote change. (On website under
additional resources)
Following the brief history of art lesson the teacher will then present the students to artist,
Scott Erickson via PowerPoint/artist website and a YouTube video. The teacher will
emphasize how Erickson works with various non-profit organizations as motivation to
create a difference. During this time the students will be working in their sketchbook
taking notes. (Erickson PowerPoint on website, link to video is on Scoop.it!)
Students will then refer to the list they made as a class the previous day and pick out
some of the topics that is relevant to them and society. In their sketchbook the students
will document how their chosen topics are relevant to them and society.
For the remaining of class and the next four days the students will be allowed access to
individual laptops (checked out from the library) to construct their research. Guidelines
of the research will be presented/reviewed from the PowerPoint showed on Day 2.
Guided resources will be provided to students on various artists and museums to look out
through handouts, Art21, Pinterest, Scoop.it, Delicious, and the teachers website.
Note: Days 2-4 will begin with a recap of what is required and introduction to a new
artist.
Goals by days (to keep students on track, **some adjustments may be made)
All information will be dated and recorded in the students sketchbook.
52
Day 1 of research: Narrow down your list of topics to one strong topic
you wish to work with
Day 2 of research: Locate and document a minimum of two strong
sources that inform you of your chosen topic and find a minimum of
one artist with annotation. (All must be in your sketchbook)
Day 3 of research: Locate further information required and find at least
two more artists that work within your theme.
Day 4 of research: Find additional artists as required, post research on
artists to Pinterest. Finish collecting any data needed.
53
In-process critiques will be provided along the way and teacher feedback will be
administered on a regular basis.
Following completion students will create an artist statement evaluating their artwork and
their understanding of the topic. Students will also include how their research on
contemporary artists and the issue assisted their artistic creative journey.
A rough checklist to keep student progress consistent:
Day 1 of the art project: Students should have completed the contour
of their drawing
By the end of day 3: Students should have 1/3 of the drawing
completed.
By the end of day 5: Students should be close to having 2/3 of the
drawing completed.
By the end of day 7: Students should be done with the project or close
to completion. What ever left to be done will be considered homework.
Finished product and artist statement will be required in two days.
54
Formative Checklists
= meets
Items I will be looking for. (End of day 3)
=excee
ds
Mini contemporary drawing
Questionnaire worksheet
Notes from PowerPoint
Art 21 response
Mini drawing on what you think race is
Notes on any discussed artist
Historical activist notes
Narrowed list of topics
Thoughts on these topics and relevance
= meets
=excee
ds
= meets
=excee
ds
Item I will be looking for. When thumbnails are showed to teacher (around day
9)
First thumbnail thumbnail
Second thumbnail
Third thumbnail
Fourth thumbnail
Criticism from student 1
Criticism from student 2
Criticism from student 3
In progress critiques- teacher will collect sketchbooks at the end but will walk around
throughout the class to make sure student participation is checked off each day (therefore
students will not wait to the last day).
= meets
In progress critiques (Did the student acquire sufficient in progress critiques in
=excee the beginning of class from their peers and document it in their sketchbook?)
ds
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Participates in critique
constructively (5)
Revises works (5)
Connects work to personal
interest/theme/idea and
provides description (20)
Total
55
56
Teacher
Comments_______________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________
Sketchbook/journal
shows a variety of
possible solutions and
approaches
Sketchbook/journal
shows personalization
of the topic selected
Sketchbook/journal
makes connections
between theme and
contemporary artworks
Needs Improvement
(1)
Student has identified
their chosen topic.
Research lacks
statistics,
organization or other
key information.
Thumbnails show
little to no personal
connection.
Students have
identified a 2-3
contemporary
artworks by various
artists that address the
Students lack
adequate research on
artists.
57
Total
Teacher
Comments:______________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________
Observed
Comments
Questionnaire form
58
Name:_________________________
For a daily grade based on completion and genuine answers please answer the following
questions to the best of your ability. Underdeveloped answers will not receive credit.
1.Have you ever done a project that addresses a social issue or problems in the world?
Briefly explain.
2. Do you like talking about social issues, or problems in the world? Why or why not?
3. How do contemporary social issues present in what we see today affect how we think?
4. In addition to the 1 thing you would change in the world if given the
chance, what other social or contemporary issues are important to you?
(You cannot say I do not know {or any sort of answer in that way}, you
must answer).
59
Appendix C
Email Participant From
Dear ________,
I am attending the University of Floridas Distance Learning program to complete a
masters degree in Art Education. I am currently working on my capstone in lieu of a
thesis. My research is titled Exploring Contemporary Social Issues in a High School
Drawing Curriculum. For my capstone I will be designing a curriculum unit for a
secondary art drawing unit that will explore contemporary social issues. I would
greatly appreciate some feedback and suggestions on my curriculum unit. Any
feedback would be appreciated I am particularly interested in feedback on the
assessment and the students individual research portion.
Participation in this study is voluntary and there are no risks with participation.
The rewards for participation in this research will inform the discipline of art
education for a high school art class. All identities of participants in this study will
remain confidential. There is no compensation for participation and there are no
direct benefits to me for participating. If you are willing to participate and agree to
the procedure I have attached the permission form. Once I have received your form I
will supply you with my curriculum unit. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Regards,
Alicia Bagley
60
Appendix D
Teacher Consent Form
Consent for Teachers:
Exploring Contemporary Social Issues in a High School Drawing Curriculum
Purpose of the research study:
The purpose of this study is to create a curriculum for an art drawing unit.
What will you be asked to do in the study:
I will be creating a drawing unit of study to implement in the future. This drawing unit
will explore contemporary social issues. Participants will be asked to review and
provide advice and feedback to the curriculum at their availability. Participation will
take approximately twenty minutes.
Participation, Risks and Rewards:
Participation in this study is voluntary. There are no risks with participation. The
rewards for participation in this research will inform the discipline of art education for
a high school art class. All identities of participants in this study will remain
confidential. There is no compensation for participation and there is no direct benefits
to me for participating.
Right to withdraw from the study
You have the right to withdraw from the study at anytime without consequence.
Who to contact if you have questions about the study
Alicia Bagley, Graduate Student, College of Art, University of Florida
Bagleya2@ufl.edu; Supervisor, Michelle Tillander, PhD, Assistant Professor,
College of Art. PO Box 115801, Gainesville, FL 32611-5801 Office Phone:
352.392.9977 Fax: 352.392.8453 mtilland@ufl.edu
Who to contact about your rights as a research participant in the study
IRB02 Office Box 112250, University of Florida
Gainesville, FL 32611-2250 phone 392-0433.
Agreement:
I have read the procedure described above. I understand as a volunteer, my participation in
this study is not required and my identity will remain confidential. I voluntarily agree to
participate in the project and I understand that the feedback will be provided through
emails, phone conversations, and in person dialogue.
Participant Name:_________________________________ Date:________________________
Participants Signature: ___________________________________________________________
61
Appendix E
IRB Protocol Submission Forms
THIS FORM MUST BE TYPED. DO NOT STAPLE. Send this form and the supporting documents to IRB02, PO Box 112250, Gainesville, FL
32611. Should you have questions about completing this form, call 352-392-0433.
Title of Protocol:
Principal Investigator:
Bagley
(Last Name)
Degree / Title:
Alicia
(First Name)
Mailing Address: (If on
campus provide PO Box
address):
Department:
UFID #:********
**********
Email:
Bagleya2@ufl.edu
Telephone #:
***-***-****
Co-Investigator(s):
Coordinator:
Research Asst.:
UFID#:
(Last Name)
(First Name)
Mailing Address(If on
Degree/Title
Department:
Supervisor (If PI is
student):
Telephone #:
Tillander
(Last Name)
Degree / Title:
Department:
Email:
Michelle
(First Name)
PhD
Mailing Address:
UFID#
****-****
Email :
mtilland@ufl.edu
Telephone #:
757-619-4444
352-392-9977
Dates of Proposed
Research:
62
Summer 2015
No funding sources
63
Maximum
Number of
Participants (to
be approached
with consent)
Age Range of
Participants:
24-50
Amount of
Compensation/
course credit:
No Compensation
(SIGNATURE SECTION)
Principal Investigator(s)
Signature:
Date:
5/5/2015
Co-Investigator(s) Signature(s):
Date:
Supervisors Signature:
Date:
5/5/2015
Date:
Appendix F
List of Some Contemporary Drawing Artists
Gala Bent
http://galabent.com/
Robert Birmelin
http://robertbirmelin.com/
Kiki Smith
http://www.artnet.com/artists/kiki-smith/
William Kentridge
http://www.moma.org/collection/artist.php?artist_id=7919
Barbara Fugate
http://www.barbarafugate.com/
Robert Ernst
http://roberternstmarx.com/
Shaun Tan
http://www.shauntan.net/
Robert Flexner
http://whitney.org/Exhibitions/2010Biennial/RolandFlexner
Joseph Pentheroudakis
http://jpentheroudakis.com/
Louise Hopkins
http://www.mummeryschnelle.com/pages/louisebiog.htm
Agnes Denes
http://www.agnesdenesstudio.com/
Peter Millett
http://www.gregkucera.com/millett.htm
James Valerio
http://forumgallery.com/artist/james-valerio/
Ellen Gallagher
http://www.hauserwirth.com/artists/7/ellen-gallagher/biography/
64
65
Anish Kapoor
http://anishkapoor.com/
Wolfgang Thomas
http://www.saatchiart.com/gaeg
Takashi Murakami
http://www.gagosian.com/artists/takashi-murakami
Mike Kelly
http://mikekelley.com/
Ida Applebroog
http://idaapplebroog.com/
Anselm Kiefer
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/kief/hd_kief.htm
Steve McQueen
http://www.mariangoodman.com/artists/steve-mcqueen/
Pieere Huyghe
http://www.mariangoodman.com/artists/pierre-huyghe/
Thomas Hirschhorn
http://www.art21.org/artists/thomas-hirschhorn
Marlene Dumas
http://www.marlenedumas.nl/
Richard Serra
http://www.pbs.org/art21/artists/richard-serra
Vija Celmins
http://www.pbs.org/art21/artists/vija-celmins
Matthew Barney
http://www.cremaster.net/
Bruce Nauman
http://www.pbs.org/art21/artists/bruce-nauman
Albert Oehlen
http://www.skarstedt.com/artists/albert-oehlen/
66
67
68
69
Appendix G
Abortion
Battered Women
Corporal
Punishment
Academic Freedom
Binge Drinking
Corporate
Downsizing
Adoption
Birth Control
Advertising
Bisexuality
Crime
Blogging
Criminal Justice
System
Ageism / Age
Discrimination
Body ARt
Cults
Bulimia Nervosa
Cyber Bullying
(Cyberbullying)
Date Rape
Death Penalty
Depression
Diet
Air Pollution
Bullying
Airport Screening
Procedures
Campus Crime
Cancer
Capital Punishment /
Death Penalty
Airport Security
Alcoholism
Americans with
Disabilities Act
Animal Rights
Anorexia Nervosa
Anti-Muslim
Discrimination
Celebrity Culture
Discrimination
Cell Phones
Diversity
Censorship
Disaster Relief
Chemical Weapons
Domestic Violence
Child Abuse
Child Labor
Child Molesting/porn
Climate Change
Drug Legalization
Drunk Driving
Eating Disorders
Arms Control
Artificial Intelligence
Assisted Suicide
Attention Deficit
Disorder
Cloning
Autism
Colorisim
Baby Boomers
Cloud Hacking
Bankruptcy
Computer Hacking
Elder Abuse
Global Warming
Elections
Globalization
Endangered Species
Graffitti
Energy
Conservation
Energy Resources
Environmental
issues
70
Meth
Labs (Methampheta
mine Laboratories)
Militarization of
Police
Gun Control
Minimum Wage
Gun Rights
Minorities
Hate Crimes
National Debt
Hazing
Environmental
Pollution
Health Care
Disparities
National Rifle
Association
Noise Pollution
Environmental
Racism
Nuclear Weapons
Equal Pay
HIV / AIDS
Nutrition
Equal Rights
Homelessness
Euthanasia / Mercy
Killing / Assisted
Suicide
Homophobia
Obamacare
(Affordable Care Act)
Obesity
Honor Killings
Oil Spills
Human Trafficking
Hunger
Identify Theft
Organized Crime
Illegal Immigration
Outsourcing Jobs
Interracial
Dating/Marriage
Overpopulation
Ozone Layer
Legalization of
Marijuana
Patriot Act
Patriotism
Excessive Force By
Law Enforcement
Famine
Fast Food
Firearms
Felony
Feminism
Gambling
Gang Violence
Gay Rights
Genetic Engineering
Genetically Modified
Food
Juvenile
Delinquency
Mall Shootings
Pet Overpopulation
Mass Murder
Pedophilia
Mentally Disabled
Photobombs
Physical Fitness
Plagiarism
Riots
Police Brutality
Rock Music
Police Militarization
Same-Sex Marriage
Political Corruption
Pollution
71
Texting While
Driving
Texting While
Walking
Sex Trade
Unemployment
Sexism
Vandalism
Popular Culture
Sexual Abuse
Vegetarianism
Pornography
Sexual Harassment
Veterans
Poverty
Sexting
Video Games
Prayer in Schools
Shopping While
Black
Vigilantism
Pregnancy
Violence in Schools
Prisoners Rights
Violence in Music
Videos
Privacy
Prostitution
Violence in Video
Games
Race
Voter
Disenfranchisement
Racial Disparities in
Sentencing
Voting Rights
Restrictions
Racial Profiling
War Crimes
Racism
Waste Pollution
Rap Music
Weapons
Rape
Welfare Reform
Retail Profiling
White Supremacy
Recycling and
Conservation
Wilderness
Preservation
Wildlife conservation
Women in the
Military
Womens Rights
Single Parenting
Sleeper Cells
Smoking / Tobacco
Use
Social Networking
and Privacy
Spousal Abuse
Steroid Use in
Sports
Stereotyping
Suicide
Sweat Shops
Teen Pregnancy
Refugees
Teen Suicide
Religion
Right to Work
Television and
Violence
Terrorism
Working Parents
Workplace Violence
72
73
Figure 3. Screenshot of my
webpage..27
Figure 5. The Reconcile Mural, Gregg Deal, 2014, photo by Dakota Fine...
31
Author Biography
My name is Alicia Bagley and I am a fifth year high school art teacher. I
am 27 years old and one of three art teachers at Nation Ford High School in Fort Mill,
South Carolina. I completed my undergraduate studies at Winthrop University in Rock
Hill, South Carolina.
with the students and play with different mediums. My personal work captures my idea of
beauty into photographs, paintings, or drawings. I also enjoy traveling and finding hidden
gems that also is noted in my personal art.