Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Krzysztof Jassem,
professor at Adam Mickiewicz University, Pozna, Faculty of Mathematics and Computer
Science,
author of books on Polish Club
This article concerns the case of withdrawing the invitation to Bermuda Bowl to the pair:
Cezary Balicki, Adam mudziski.
The article is designed as follows:
Section 1. states the main facts concerned with the invitation withdrawal and the
participation of team Poland in Bermuda Bowl.
Section 2. describes the method of analysis carried out in Section 3.
Section 3. analyses material sent unofficially by Mr. Brogeland to Mr. Kalita of the Polish
national team the day after the invitation withdrawal.
Section 4. concludes the article with the authors opinion on the case as well as a suggestion
for proceeding in similar cases.
76
AJ
K 10 8 7 2
K5
62
KQ9765
A J 10 2
10 9 8 3
9
Q J 10 9 8 4 3
4
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
Pass
Pass
Dbl
Pass
Pass
Pass
All pass
Brogelands commentary:
Zmuds 2D bid is almost over Pass holding 1098x x QJ1098xx x
Comment: Super minimum response
Table 2. shows the range of hands that are consistent with the current bidding.
Hand value
-2
-1
0
1
2
Example hand
10732 3 KQ10865 J2
10732 J6 KQJ865 2
10732 76 AQJ865 2
Q103 76 AQJ865 2
K107 76 AQ10865 32
The actual hand does not fit to any row of the Table 2. The hand is non-standard, hard to
classify. Because of the scarcity of the material (6 boards) I will not remove this hand from
the analysis. For the favour of the hypothesis I am trying to verify, I will classify the hand to
the group indicated by the message code: very negative.
Message Code
-2
Hand Value
-2
AKQ943
K76
Q 10 9
Q 10 6
Q 10 9 7 3
K65
J 10 8
J854
A87
A42
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
Pass
Pass
1NT
Figure 1. The picture delivered by Mr. Brogeland commented as: The second pass is quite far from the first one.
97
Q 10
K98753
K7
10 9 8 5 4
AJ73
Q6
AJ642
Q964
Q2
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
pass
Pass
Hand value
-2
-1
0
1
2
Example hand
AJ1043 AJ10532 J6
AJ1043 AJ1053 K63
AJ1043 AJ10532 K6
AQ1043 AJ10532 K6
AQ1043 AQ10432 K6
Message Code
2
Hand Value
0
KJ543
J 10 7
9654
QJ876
A93
42
Q
2
AQ3
K5
AKJ9873
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
Pass
Pass
Pass
Pass
Hand value
-2
-1
0
1
2
Example hand
KJ54 QJ2 8432 65
KJ54 QJ2 842 865
A654 K82 842 865
A1096 K82 1042 1065
A1096 K82 1042 J106
Message Code
-2
Hand Value
1
A98
75
Q987532
AK64
Q9
J654
Q72
Q J 10 9 8 4 3
10
10 7
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
3
Pass
4NT
Pass
Example hand
72 Q1098743 102 107
72 QJ109843 102 107
Q72 Q1098743 10 107
Q72 QJ109843 10 107
K72 QJ109843 10 107
Message Code
-2
Hand Value
1
KJ964
A8
KQ2
J92
J98762
K3
- J 10 7 3
AQ653
AQ54
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
Pass
Pass
dble
Mr Brogelands commentary:
Balickis double is almost on 1H bid Axxx xxxx K10xx 10.
Comment: Minimal values for Double.
Commentary on the bidding:
I am not sure about Balickis intention for double. It looks to me like a kind of co-operative
double: partner should pass with flat distribution (given the bidding), e.g. 1444, and bid on
with better shape. Table 10. is consistent with such an interpretation. All examples take into
consideration that Balicki did not bid 4 instead.
Hand value
-2
-1
0
1
2
Example hand
A873 9654 10 QJ73
A873 9654 K1087 10
A873 9654 10 K1087
A873 9654 J2 KJ7
A873 9654 J2 KQ7
Message Code
-2
Hand Value
-1
Q 10 8 4
10 2
987
A987
K5
KQ52
5
KJ643
Q J 10 6 2
94
Open Room
West
North
East
South
ATABEY
BALICKI
KAYA
ZMUDZINSKI
2D!!
2NT
Pass
3(1)
Pass
Pass
Pass
Pass
Dbl
All pass
The contract went two down, 4 spades would have been set one down.
Hand value
-2
-1
0
1
2
Example hand
KJ643 J1086 J943
KJ643 J10862 J93
5 KJ643 QJ1062 94
KJ643 QJ1062 943
5 KJ643 K1062 Q94
Table 11. Board 32: Example hands consistent with the bidding
Message Code
1
Hand Value
0
Coded Message
Hand Value
The coefficient shows very weak correlation between the code and the actual hand value.
4. Conclusions.
1) In my opinion this report should end The Balicki-Zmudzinski case.
2) I suggest the following objective method of examining similar cases: