Fay Nae INCIDENT/INVESTIGATION caer Davie “olice Department REPORT i 15056914 Taped 1 fot [iad s2015 19:02 Man| ‘ 061200 Tom cos a Toma LOLS 18:10 Man : Resdence- Single Fan | 243 10057015 18,45 2 [ayer {Gon Wen Tor APPLICABLE ta |) coat Maer ay isa sey » fg) oie Te a ay a Hl Fy i Se A 7a) oe TF [er W Ey BE aud M0 atc 0 [Te Ta onesie i Ne a Fa HD Ty] >] Rone Sa, v lvl (Ca Fo ee Fede] ct i A © |Home Adress Home Phone 1, [Basie Naan SS SS — WRITS vi com 7 [ine INDIVIDUAL NOTTAWENTORCEMENT i 2 ea [Sas ray es] a |= RE oa, Ty, fe | | CHAPMAN, ALBERTIN AROLDIS. sei oa 28/7988 ToOhienest Branch Sis & LRP Age 27 |B IM Non-Residen| 5 | ica cd 8 Davie, FL 33324 jt Tgp New or a 1 N’ ["aype INDIVIDUAL/ NOT LAW ENPORCEMENT Injury: > |= ileal fea See ESSE | 1 Luo wir Non-Restden| \ Pes Toe 5 Fort Lederdate, FL. 33334 — ae None ARE a Sa Re DS Da FC Ca Tea Fad PP eps oe rss Floaal SE vine [ox or gy Dei waa Seta ntr , k $ , é fi t y ) Teves DY (Up Superson 893) anf Con =a Tae ; Saf Co Sao maso1s| Pagel Tracy SOOT ae OTT awINCIDENT/INVESTIGATION REPORT By SCOTT, La072015 1602 Davie Police Department fee Case 15-056914 Sea = “Recovered D=Damaged Z=Solaed B~ Burned C= Counters’ For on SSR L= Tot $= Stolen RRecweed D=Damaged Z=Selzed B—Bumed C= Court / Forged n eR] stan] Quantity [Tyne Measure Suspected Type Upto3 types ofsetiviy Assisting Officers ‘Swspoot Hate Biss Motivated None NARRATIVE ‘On 10/05/2015 at approximately 1830hrs I was contacted by phone by the reporting party/homeowner of i reference to a possible burglary in progress by his ex-girlfriend. 1 responded tothe residence, long with OfeSchende| and made contact wit MMI sic she was atthe residence to cote hr lohing as well 5 fumure and clothing that belong tothe daughter they haven common. ined a key to the residence She told me she has resided athe above mentioned adress for approximately three years and only recently roke-up with the homeowner legally evicted trom the property. He said she had not been evicted, however, was adament the account| providing was inaceurate, 1 contacted the homeowner again by phone and explained that had key set aloe gga a tbe The homeowner advised me he an MMted fo i oer a ea an ha eid n common. They wee living together in an pert in Mian drig tat tine ed ved back io his Devi sence btween 6 an weoks ag, Ter relsonhip ced recent an MI ota eh the residene over ane week ago an ok some a her ling an thoes lthing te proces He los he never proved her Wisk o he residence and Blloves so ok a ey witou bis pension peor o moving oat ‘The homeowner is currently out of town and no one was atthe residence, He said he will return to the residence on Friday afternoon, He said MMMM cout return to the residence at that time to collect whatever belongings she stil had there, as they previously agreed upon Based on the conflicting stories | recommended IEMreturn on Friday to collect her and her child's belongings and to contact Davie Police to stand-by for the process. INN decided to leave the residence and return another day to collect her belongings,Tapa Ra INCIDENTIINVESTIGATION asc 12-82359 Davie Police Department REPORT Sac « fort 2in012 2 x 0061200 Tat Rawwn Seow © raion Fame 2 D mie FL 33324- Residence - Single Family| 24,3 12302012 21-48 Su E fa] cine lncdents) (Com) | Wewpon! Teel NOT APPLICABLE ain N |#2) s¢noive Ditsnrbance / Without Decibel Meter = < relael nena iy Et ay D [pa] iment 7 | Wena Tele Tay R | 2] t Ty i Seay A ya) Came i 7] Wap Teas ad | ay ar Seaniy ro] Presence Of VstinlOn Promises forvisies 7 [Dee INDIVIDUAL) NOT LAW ery No tory Domestic. Rati Roses] aaah | Reisen Sans] Mary c 1a Sw |ulver | Resident © [Rome ios one Phone " ie, FL 33324 fi 1 | Balser Nene ade asi Fone bie one WR as ede Soe] Car Tee vi ‘CODES Vz Visin (Opie VE V)_O= Over (ener an wna) R= Repring Pecan (Foe dun VAIaD o [Bre Injus ae (as Fit MID im g¢] 008 | Race] Sex] Keath | Rese Se oo erent reer ea Reve} Sex| TS Ortenee E Age & | Homentia Tone Pane 5 Tala Nene a as Fane MRIS Fis 1 * Pipe Taj Soe | Re (a Fine Md Tit pt] — DOB [Ras] Sex] Reap Reve Ses | ede eaeeses : comet ees fare L Ae Y ome Raa Tn D Fair ane ARES os Nae awe Tated $= Salen R=Roogeed D= Damaged Z=Scaad B= Darel C= Comma Raped Fo Ra OF = Recoree i Outer Juri) Wwe 23] vane | os Jory Property Deseiption Make/Model Serial Number P R 6 » E k , ¥ fies CHIN, SHELIA (711 Tet DY (0 Sunwise RAVINE, SHAWN (635) Trad Complain Sat Tasos Cas Dapp Sau om Sera Bete s2aororal Cried By Aeres —ppayz012 | Pave | Printed By: SSCOTT Syst S9BR2 THOWBOIS AGTINCIDENT/INVESTIGATION REPORT By: SSCOTT, 120772015 1611 Page 2 Davie Police Department : Case 1.082359 olen R= Resovered ied B= Burned C= Connect Forged P= Found la Sa Damaged vucr tans] Quanity —_[aype Mesure Suspected Type Upto 3 ypes oF atv Asisting Officers FIGUEROA, J. (763) ‘Suspest Hine / Biss Motivted’ None Page 2 NARRATIVE On Dee 30, 2012 C responded AME reference to loud music. I met with [IIL victim, who advised that his neighbor across the canal is playing excessively loud music. I walked onto (I patio and could hear the musi’ bass coming across the canal for SE WHEL vised thax he has called several times about the same neighbor playing loud music. llerces to sign an affidavit of complaint wishing to prosecute his neighbor forthe ordinance violation and was given a case card. has called previously to complaining about excessive music coming from his neighbors home case numbers 12-067392, 12-073315, 065576, and 021274. The following officers responded and noted that they had ‘made contact wit the homeowner regarding the loud music and ordinance: 12-066242 Osficer Patton; 12-065599 Officer Crabtree; 12-59416 Officer Urbaez. T made contaet with Albertin Chapman, homeowner, and issued him an NTA for violation of the Town of Davie Noise Ordinance. Officer Fiqueroa responded as a back-up officer to translate into Spanish an explanation for the NTA, the court date, and the Town of Davie ordinance,Incident Report Suspect List Davie Police Department OCA: 72-082359 ifs a eee a CHAPMAN, ALBERTIN AROLDIS nr Basinas Address TY Dom Pree] SR] Wa] BS] Skis ies CS oaasivse| 21| 2 |a |x | 603| 200| arx| pro| eo a Sar Was, Too oe soguing ars aa Data SORTS Te Tar Eo Fea |e Ta Gar YC] Dea a Modot Te Tan Da Sa oie aT vs ows Physical Car Printed By: SCOTT, 120072015 16:11 Paon 2ektont poate INTHE COUNTY COURT, IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA gre ee er NOTICE TO APPEAR & INITIAL DISCOVERY EXHIBIT aot = % i9-30-1) [DAVIE Fotice [Dang TS 982267 a oa Ce aoe aApMAW ALB ERTIN [AIG 2 lars |Be B20 |B /: ‘AZ| aro ae cuBA — — Ta pase 15S -oo| -82-o6f 3 ‘DEFENDANT Cas Name in ane ame a award County Fags he undersigned ers that hearse has sk and resonable grounds to beleve and oe DoT, toton eas |D~3OAD ge gry DABS cat AF twcstos LATO GW iVe Ren intron Can, F te above aed onda cere the aera Cage int dtd Ptrevciotc canine ees empty rat FS E Wwe a He CoD ma sie Coma < S THE CAN fR2e70 A Hem’ ehere the ouv it HAD PRivoutly Been TOLD ABUT WHE 02 Dave anata Osendont Stotemets SS TE Se Pe Sse I-TWESASS warning oven (case. utensan_f comes» a ]vicTina AEFIOWT: that the abowe | Snot and bse seat Jsrcconecttothe bs ofay vane anabelefardl (60 C} CONT deseo prosecite bo ma, § § “ paras oe Trcrmiedoniadedgap) headed mares nonodoemn TAD eae oe seeINCIDENT/INVESTIGATION aN a —$— Davie Police Department REPORT Dan Time Re ‘ ena raion ° ream iam atta —} =e Sar oe rR il N |) Battery Simple Domestic Fay ir oaay BATT SMP DOM. M. D ‘Crime Incident t [Weapon / Tools Aatieiy i a frees xe Fares ROTA RAW ea cay © | Hame, “Home Phone ‘ Fort Lauderdale, FL 33334- o [am RvinTAL Nor AWEweRcoST aa ey ° eaten io Ss =e ut |" | CHAPMAN, ALBERTIN AROLDIS. Chine | 92/28/1988) To Ortender lanes + rie, FL 33324 — rat : Te Injury: © [ow [Name ) fcune # fo iteadee foronehSttus : se & tae Ta i onan ae oes VY dcoel as] vate | ox Jory Property Description Make Mode SerialNumber : i 5 : : i : i _ ‘invest IDF BRENT, MARK _(700) ‘Supervisor ROSEN, CHAD (712) Ee an ; = = ™ naaive / Open, 11102015) aa Page 1Incident Report Additional Name List Davie Police Department QCA: 15-062191 ae = owt 06/03/1997 18 WM Empvadar PrintsdBy:SSCOTT, 1207/2015 1609INCIDENT/INVESTIGATION REPORT By SSCOTT, ——_av0T2018 16:08 Page3 Davie Police Department couse HGS U-lot S-Sokm RoRewacd D-Oumgd ZeSami Oobancd C=C Fost F=Foud ven |sina] —_quantty [pe News Supe De Unb opr ofasiiy > & t 6 s ais Ones ALSTON, S. (702), BART, S. (785), BRITO, D. (594), CAPOTA, S, (892), CUNEO, E. (852), HAINES, D. (911), HONORE, H, (931), MULFORD, D. (908), PATTON, P. (718). PERMENTER, J. (870), RABELO, P. (939), RAY, M. (894), ROSEN, C. Suspect Hate Bias Motivated: None Page 3 NARRATIVE On 10/31/2015 at 2213 hours, Ofe. Rynning and I arrived at 2390 SW 106th Terrace in response to a reported domestic disturbance where an unknown type firearm had been discharged. Upon arrival, Ofe. Rynning and I beyan to walk towards the residence and observed an Hispanic female, later identified 25 III victim) walking towards us HBB ace the statement while walking towards Ofe. Ryaning and I that, "those guns aren't needed." We asked her intially what had hhappened end why she had called police, She advised that she and her boyftiend, later identified as Albertin Chapman had an argument. She intially advised that he had pushed her and the argument had been broken up by family members. Chapman walked outside the residence and [IMMIMMadvised she heard "shotgun" blasts but did not know where they were coming from. She then ran to the south side of the residence to the north of the incident location and had hid behind bushes until she made contact with police. She advised her infant child was also still inside the residence with Chapman. (fe. Rynning, Ofe. Ray, Ofe. Shannon, Ofe. Bart, Ofe. Rabelo and I then approached the residence and observed several persons leaving the residence. As the subjects walked out, there were given instructions to approach officers and were checked for any firearms or involvement in the incident. None of the subjects that left the residence were Chapman. A perimeter was thon established on the residence and attempts were made to contact Chapman and have him exit the residence. Eventually, Chapman exited the front ofthe residence ‘without incident Of, Honore made contact with IM vbo advised she wished to give a sworn recorded statement regarding the incident. fe, Honore then began to take the statement and [tated she got into a verbal altercation with her child's father Alberto Chapman because she found something in bis phon tha she did not ike, She went into the bathroom with his phone and he tk the phone away from her wile they were inside ofthe bathroom. After tat, se followed him tothe bar and told him that she wanted o tlk to him inside ofthe movie cheater. Both parties then walked tothe movi theatar and once inside, she said that he beceme aggravatod and pushed her agains the wall. Thais when her brother, lace dented 25 MMMM came inthe theater and separated them. After hey were separated, ill MMB on outside because she was scared for her and her daughter. She rn o her neighbor's residence and hid outside inthe bushes. ‘While she was hiding, she heard ene gun shot, but se doesnot know who it came fom, MMB igned an affidavit of complaint advising she did not wish to prosecute. OF ie ok i Eig ee, I ie A ws ig ter ‘at the above listed residence with family and fiends. During the gathering, werheard his sister and Chapman arguing in the front living room area. AIEEE went to defend his sister and attempted to stop the argument, While {las trying to stop the argument, other also tried to intervene, [I stated that he was concerned for his mother, so he escorted her away from the victim and (Chapman. ifMstayec with his mother in a separate room while the argument continued in the front living room area | not see any type of physical altercation other than a verbal argument between Chapmen and {I MII refused to give a swomINCIDENTIINVESTIGATION REPORT Narr. (cont,) OCA: 15-062191 Davie Police Department Page 4 recorded statement fe. Haines hen spoke with II win is Chapman's employed driver vised Ofe. Haines he had observed the altercation between Albertin Chapman and the mother of his child, stated he was standing at the entrance of the residence’s theater room when be beard Albertin and rung inside he theazer. a I room with Chapman's phone, She then tured io the theater oom, charging at Chapman and tackled him said brother, SNM then saw Chapman and the floor where Chapman was pushing ot of him, brother then jumped in to dofend his sister. Once MINIS brothcr got involved, MINIs the parties went their separate ways and the altercation ended IMME fused wo provide aswom tape recorded statement Of. Rivas and Of. Brito then made coatact with Chapman due to Chapman speaking Spanish. Chapman advised that earlier ody, while having a party with ends and farily at his house his grfiend started fighting wit him over his cell phone. He advised that he used his index and middle finger he poked his irtiend on the left shovlder and told her not to talk to him ike that. He sad that she fel othe floor end started yelling. Her brother came in and pushed Chapman tothe ground, Friends and family separated the two so that they would aot Bight. Chapmn said he got up and exed the residence. He wanted to drive away but friends would no let him. He got in the passenger seat of his white 2015 Land Rover bearing Fl tag? INEM his rind got inthe driver's seat. He then punched the passenger side window with his left fist from inside the vehicle, cree .a laceration to his left pinky knuckle. He then retrieved his pistol from the glove compartment, exited his vehicle and went locked himselfin the garage alone. He then shot scveral shots inside the garage and threw his pistol away inside the garage. His friends then took him to his room and locked themselves init. When Police arcived they had everyone exit the residence. Chapman refs to give a sworn recorded statement or sign an affidavit of complaint. Chapman did sign ‘consent to search for his exterior garage. 1 then spoke to IIIT regarding the incident. She advised that Chapman had pushed her against the wall near the movie theater room, inside the residence. She then advised she had then exited the room to the bathroom with Chapman's cell phone. I asked her about the witness account of her running towards Chapman and "tackling" him to the ground, She advised she did not know anything about that. She then advised that she was on the ground with Chapman and had then run out ofthe theater room. I asked her how she had fallen to the ‘round and she could not advise. She then sad that he ad pushed her up against the wall and she then fell to the floor. She then advised that Chapman had "choked" her by placing his hands around her neck, but did not prevent her from breathing at any time. I asked her ‘where he grabbed her and she pointed to her neck, but there were no injuries or even redness anywiere on her neck or chest. She then advised she did not want to have any further involvement with the incident and wished to gather her belongings and leave. She was eventually allowed to get her Belongings end leave the residence. She was advised that if she wished to get the rest of her belongings at a later time, she could ask for Davie Police officers to stand by while she does so. She left the residence on her own aecord atthe time of this incident, Photographs of her neck and chest were later placed into Davie Police property control. 1 then spoke to IIMB asked him to retell what he had observed during the incident. IIIEMinen advised that he was not going to make any other statements unless he feels that police officers are not handling the incident to his satisfaction. [Ic was later determined that after CST. Shaw was unable to locate a fitearm inside the garage: NMI had removed the firearm from the garage and placed it inside Chapman's white 2015 Cadillac Escalade. IIEEMEMedvised he had moved the firearm and placed it inside the vehicle to prevent anyone finding the fitearm and hurting themselves. MINN was advised that he had removed evidence from the crime scene IIB tarred hat he ha hindered he investigation by doing so. He advised he understood and it was not has intent to hinder the investige Due to several inconsistencies in the victim's statements, as well as the statement from {IY changing several times during the investigation, this case will be forwarded tothe State Attomey's Office for review. CST. Shaw arrived during the investigation and processed the scene.jent Report Suspect List Davie Police Department OCR: 15-062191 _ oe, RE soe Mim fe | | 307] 150 | eo] aro] men a ima a |e 10] Fate |p wor pak te art spe pa ee = a ae =n Pa 0228/1988 | 27|B |M | H 603 | 200 | BLK| BRO| MED Es Se clo ae 2 [ale ee carat EeCASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2015 16:09 Davie Police Department oca: 15062191 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW iS CONFIDENTIAL -FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY (Case Status: JVACTIVE / OPEN Case Mng Status: JNACTIVE/ OPEN Oceured: 10/30/2015 (Offense: BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC "ATTON, PETER (718) Date Time: 10/30/2015 23:47:15, Friday (852) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/31/2015 06:25:47, Saturday Reference: Supplement ‘On 10-30-15 at 2210 hours, [responded to 2390 SW 106th Ter in reference to a domestic disturbance involving a firearm. The reportee, IIE stated that her husband had a shotgun and that she had heard a shot go off. She said that her four month old daughter was stil inside the residence while she had fled outside, I responded as part of the Crisis Response Team, in antipation for potential negotiations. Upon arrival I met with fellow CRT member, Officer Honore, who was in contact with lend was in the process of obtaining information from her. We learned that there was a large party going on inside ofthe residence and there were still approximately 20 subjects inside, including another young child, We obtained a phone number for the suspect, identified as Albertin Chapman, and immediately began to cal in an attempt to each him. Uhad prior knowledge that Albertin does not speak English, so we had Officer Urbaez come over to give instructions to him in Spanish over the phone. Other Davie Officers, who had posted up out front of the residence, began giving verbal commands to the subjects inside to exit. As the subjects exited, they were quickly debriefed to determine if they had witnessed anything or if they had any additional information to give about Albertin Fight attempts were made to call Albertin’s cell phone, all which went fo voicemail, While we were attempting to contact Albertin, he eventually exited the residence along with the last three houseguests. 1 stood by with EEE nti relieved by Officer Honore, who obtained a taped statement from her. I had no further involvement with this ease. + sp3 Page 6CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2015 16:09 Davie Police Department Oca: 15062191 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY INACTIVE / OPEN (Case Ming Status: JNACTIVE / OPEN Occured: 10/30/2015 BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC Investigator: URBARZ, KELVIN (888) Date/Time: 10/31/2015 00:05:50, Saturday Supervisor: CUNEO, EDWARD (852) ‘Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/31/2015 06:25:23, Saturday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 10/30/2015 responded to| in reference to a domestic violence call. Upon arrival [assisted Officer Byrne #818 in collecting information from (involved other) stared that his sister (victim) was having a gathering at the above listed residence with family and friend: During the gathering, {Nb verheard his sister and the defendant arguing in the front living room arca. A went to defend his sister and attempted to stop the argument. While =. trying to stop the argument, NIE mother also tried to intervene {IIIB stated that he was concerned for his mother, so he escorted her away from the victim and defendant, MIEEMstayed with his mother in a separate room while the argument continued in the front living room area, Hid not sce any type of physical altercation other than a verbal argument between the defendant and vietim. PE cfissea to take a taped recorded statement. spp Page 7CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2015 16:09 Davie Police Department coca: 15062191 "THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL -FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY ‘Case Status: VACTIVE / OPEN (Case Mng Status: [ACTIVE / OPEN Occured: 10/30/2015 Offense: BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC Investigator: HONORE, HERBY (931) Date / Times 10/31/2015 00:31:24, Saturday UNEO, EDWARD (852) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/31/2015 06:25:01, Saturday Reference: Supplement On 10-30-15 approximately 2207 ours expended MMIII cece oa domene disturbance While on scene, I assisted by initiating a swom taped statement of the victim [EERIE who stated the following accounts: She got into a verbal altercation with her child’s father Alberto Chapman because she found something in his phone that she did not like. She went into the bathroom with his phone and he took the phone away from her while they were inside of the bathroom. After that, she followed him to the bar and told him that she wanted to talk to him inside of the movie theater. While inside of the theater, she said that he became aggravated and pushed her against the wall ‘That is when her brother came in the theater and separated them. After they were separated, she ran outside because she was seared for her and her daughter. She ran to her neighbor's residence and hid outside in the bushes. While she was hiding, she heard one gun shot, but she does not know who it came from. placed the sworn statement into Davie Police Property for transcription. I had no further involvement in this case. rsp Page 8CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2015 16:09 Davie Police Department coca: 15062191 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY (Case Status: INACTIVE / OPEN (Case Mng Status: JWACTIVE / OPEN Oveured: 10/30/2015 Offense: BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC Investigator: HAINES, DAVID (911) Date / ime: 10/31/2025 01:05:05, Saturday ROSEN, CHAD (712) Supervisor Review Date/Time: /0/31/2015 06:16:24, Saturday Reference: Supplement On 10/30/15 at approximately 2207 hrs officers responded to a dispatched call of a domestic disturbance a AA HERE ire on scene I made contact with TINNNINININ sh stated he observed the altercation between ‘Aroldis Chapman and the mother of his child, IE stated he was — at the entrance of the residence’s theater room when he heard Aroldis and {He rguing inside the theater. stated that ran out of the room with Aroldis’ phone. She then returned to the theater room, charging at Aroldis, and tackled him. HERB said BIBI brother then saw Aroldis and {IEEE on the floor: where Aroldis was pushing fff of him, brother then jumped in to defend his sister. Once IE s brother got involved [aid the Parties went their separate ways and the altercation ended. [MJ refused to provide a swom tape recorded statement, ‘Nothing further. rsp Page 9‘CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2013 16:09 Davie Police Department coca: 15062191 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL -FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Sta Offenses BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC 8 INACTIVE / OPEN (Case Ming Status: [ACTIVE / OPEN Occured: 19/30/2015 Investigator: RIVAS, ABEL (947) Date /Time: 10/31/2015 01:11:52, Saturday Supervisor: ROSEN, CHAD (712) ‘Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/31/2015 06:19:34, Saturday Contact: Reference: Supplement On 10/30/2015 at 2230 hours I arrived at RRR as « backup/translating officer in reference to a Domestic Disturbance call Upon arrival I met with Sgt. Rosen (712) and Aroldis Chapman. asked Chapman in Spanish to tell me what had ‘occurred and translated it to Set. Rosen. He told me that earlier today, while having a party with friends and family at his house his girlfriend started fighting with him over his cell phone. He advised that using his index and middle finger he poked his girlfriend on the left shoulder and told her not to talk to him like that. He said that she fell to the floor and. started yelling. Her brother came in and pushed Chapman to the ground. Friends and family separated the two so that they would not fight, ‘Chapman said he got up and exited the residence. He wanted to drive away but friends would not let him. He got in ‘the passenger seat of his car and his friend got in the driver's seat, He then punched the passenger side window with his left fist, creating a laceration to his left pinky knuckle, He then retrieved his pistol from the glove compartment, exited his vehicle and went locked himself in the garage alone, He then shot several shots inside the garage and threw his pistol away inside the garage. His friends then took him to his room and locked themselves in it. When Police arrived they had everyone exit the residence. rep Page 10CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/07/2015 16:09 Davie Police Department Oca: 15062191 THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNFLONLY (Case Status: IVACTIVE / OPEN (Case Ming Status: INACTIVE / OPEN Oceured: 10/30/2015 Offense: BATTERY SIMPLE DOMESTIC Investigator: BRENT, MARK — (700) Date / Time: 11/04/2015 15:32:18, Wednesday Sapervisor: CHOQUETTE, ROBERT (645) _ Supervisor Review Date Time: 11/10/2015 14:12:25, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Supplement ‘On 10-30-15 Officer Byrne responded to a domestic disturbance where a firearm was discharged. Further investigation revealed that Albertin Aroldis Chapman was hosting a party at his residence for family and friends. During the party he ‘Was involved in a physical altercation with his girlfriend, (EEN over information she obtained from his cell phone. Conflicting stories were given by Mr. Chapman and] long with the witnesses who were family members. There were also no visible signs of injury on Mr. Chapman or EEE A fier the altercation, Mr. ‘Chapman left the residence and entered a friend's vehicle that was parked next to his garage. While inside the vehicle, Mr. Chapman punched the passenger side window with his left hand then reached inside the glove box and removed hhand gun, Mr. Chapman then exited the vehicle and entered his garage, which at the time of the incident was While inside the garage, Mr. Chapman fired seven rounds into a conerete wall and fired one round that ‘exited the garage through 2 window, the round was believed to have traveled into a large area of vacant land, During the shooting there were no guests present inside or outside of the garage that could have been injured. CST Shaw responded for crime scene investigations and recovered (8) shell casing inside the garage. The gun was turned in by Mr. Chapman's ani, ‘who removed the gun from the garage and held it for safe keeping until the police arrived and conducted the investigation. No arrest was made during the investigation due to conflicting stories and a lack of cooperation from all parties involved. [EEE collected some belongings and left the residence. On 11-03-15 T made contact with IIE s poe who would not provide me with a statement concerning the incident. I then asked him to give me phone number, but he refused to do so. I then mrovided him with my phone number and asked that he give the number to his sister so that she could call me. Mr: BB vies that he would give her my number but stated that she would probably not call. On 11-03-15 I made contact with ASA Marcie Zaccor and discussed the incident, I was advised that due to conflicting stories, no cooperating witnesses, and no physical injuries, there is insufficient evidence to charge Mr. Chapman with simple battery. [ was also told that since Mr. Chapman fired a gun inside of a closed and unoccupied garage there is also insufficient evidence to charge him with a gun violation Due to conflicting stories, lack of cooperation by the victim and witnesses, no physical injuries, and the fact that Mr. Chapman fired his gun in a closed garage with no one present, there is insufficient evidence to charge him with a crime. ‘This case is inactive/open, 1 smpp3 Page 11