Professional Documents
Culture Documents
--------------------Aditya Mongra @ Professors Classes-------------------reform. Like several contemporary sociologists, he argued that reserved
representation is
harmful in so far as it tends to perpetuate the distinction based on birth.
Cooperation in the satisfaction of the needs of common social life through the machinery
of Government is one of the potent factors that have dissolved tribal bonds and created
nation-communities... Special representation for some castes ... means the negation of
such co-operation.
Ghurye argued that reservation of seats will induce more and more castes to
clamour for individual representation, reducing national life to an absurdity. He
further argues that the burgeoning of caste associations has led to an increase in
caste-consciousness and strengthened the community-aspect of caste, creating a
vicious circle. Ghurye stated that the feeling of caste-solidarity is now so strong
that it is truly described as caste-patriotism. This, together with adverse economic
conditions and competition for jobs, has led to caste-animosity, and
contemporary society presents the spectacle of self-centred groups more or less in
conflict with one another. In order to kill caste-patriotism, the government
should not recognize caste in any way. Instead, national feeling should be nurtured
through inter-caste marriage, since fusion of blood has been found to be an
effective method of cementing alliances and nurturing nationalities. As another
strategy for increasing social integration, Ghurye recommends that the priesthood,
which traditionally has been a cohesive force in Hindu society, should be reformed
and revitalized by doing away with brahmin monopoly and the distinction between
Vedic and non-Vedic rites, and by training enlightened priests.
Ghurye was of the view that, free India, is in danger of disintegration due to
divisions of religion, caste, language, and region, and it would have to seek its
unity by rediscovering its true (Hindu) past. Hindu civilisation, with some modest
reforms, would be the foundation of the nation, and any movement that works
against national integration (reservations, regional autonomy) must be opposed.