Professional Documents
Culture Documents
6DSNRZVNL$QGU]HM
:LH D -DVNyNL
)ORXUHQV'HODQQR\%DMNLLNOHFKG\
WRELHRSDUFLDLSRPRF\1LHZROQRFLVL EDQLHZROQRFLSDQLNRZD2SDQXMVL
1LHUyEQDP]DZRGX
-DUUHRGHWFKQ J ERNRSUyEXM F XVSRNRLGU HQLHU N LZDUJ
7RQLHVWUDFKZ\V]HSWDXQLNDM F Z]URNXF]DURG]LHMNL-DVL QLHERM MD
VL PDUWZL 2QL :LG]LDHPZH QLH
-DWH ZLG]LDDP]DFLVQ DZDUJL7ULVV QLOL P\WHQVDPVHQW\MDL
1HQQHNH$OHDQLVRZDRW\P
.UHZQDMHMWZDU]\7\OHNUZL
0LOF]SURVLDP1HQQHNHQDGFKRG]L
$UF\NDSDQNDSRGHV]DGRQLFK7ZDU]PLDD]P F]RQ 1DQLHPHS\WDQLH7ULVV
RGSRZLHG]LDDSU]HF] F\PUXFKHPJRZ\=DXZD \ZV]\ H -DUUHRWZLHUDXVWD
XSU]HG]LDJR
1LHVWHW\QLF*G\']LNL*RQSU]HODW\ZDQDG ZL W\QL ]EXG]L\VL SUDZLH
ZV]\VWNLHDOH DGQDQLHPLDDZL]ML1DZHWWDNPJOLVWHMMDNQDV]H,G VSD
FKRSF]HQLFWXSRWRELH']LHZF] WDSURV] GRGRUPLWRULXP
2EXU F]SRWDUDWZDU]LRF]\
(FK(NZLQRNFMXP&KROHUQDQRF,G VL SRR \7ULVV1LFQLHPR HP\
]UREL
7DEH]VLD]DFLVQ DSL FLF]DURG]LHMNDGRSURZDG]DPQLHGRV]DX1D
P\ O H RQDWDPJG]LH FLHUSL H NUZDZL H JUR]LMHM3VLDNUHZJG\E\P
ZLHG]LDDFR]UREL
1HQQHNHDUF\NDSDQND ZL W\QL0HOLWHOHRGZUyFLDVL
$SUyERZDD VL PRGOL"
1D3RXGQLXKHQ]DJyUDPL$PHOOZ(EELQJZNUDLQLH]ZDQHM3HUHSOXWHPQD
UR]OHJ\FKPRNUDGDFKSU]HFL W\FKU]HNDPL<HOG /HWHL$UHWHZPLHMVFX
RGGDORQ\PRGPLDVWD(OODQGHUL ZL W\QL0HOLWHOHRRVLHPVHWPLOORWHPZURQ\
NRV]PDUVHQQ\JZDWRZQLH]EXG]LQDGUDQHPVWDUHJRSXVWHOQLND9\VRJRW
3U]HEXG]RQ\9\VRJRWD]DQLFQLHPyJSU]\SRPQLHVRELHWUH FLVQXDOHG]LZQ\
QLHSRNyMQLHSR]ZROLPXMX XVQ
=LPQR]LPQR]LPQREUUUJDGDGRVLHELH9\VRJRWDPDV]HUXM F FLH N
Z UyGWU]FLQ=LPQR]LPQREUUUU
.ROHMQDSXDSNDE\DSXVWD$QLMHGQHJRSL PDND:\M WNRZRQLHXGDQ\SRyZ
9\VRJRWDRF]\ FLSXDSN ]HV]ODPXLU] V\PDPURF] F SU]HNOH VWZDLSRFL JDM F
]]L EQL W\PQRVHP
=LPQREUUUKXKDJDGDLG F ZNLHUXQNXVNUDMXEDJQD$SU]HFLHWR
MHV]F]HZU]HVLH 3U]HFLHGRSLHURF]WHU\GQLSR(NZLQRNFMXP+DWDNLFKFKRGyZ
Z NR FXZU]H QLDQLHSDPL WDPMDNGXJR \M $ \M SU]HFLH GR GXJR
.ROHMQDSU]HGRVWDWQLDMX SXDSNDWH E\DSXVWD9\VRJRFLHQLHFKFLDRVL
QDZHWNO
1LHFK\EQLHWDNMHVWJO G]LLG F H NOLPDWR]L ELDVL ] URNXQDURN$WHUD]
NRQVWUXNFMDIL]\F]QDW\SRZDUDF]HMGODPRGHMHOINLDOHQLHVWZLHUG]RQR DGQ\FK
FHFKPHW\VNLGRNZDUWHURQNLZ F]QLH1L V]\SURFHQWHOILHMNUZLPR HMDN
ZLDGRPRQLHSR]RVWDZLD ODGyZ
9\VRJRWDMDNE\WHUD]GRSLHURSU]\SRPQLDVRELH H QLH]DSLVDQDDUNXV]XDQL
MHGQHMUXQ\DQLMHGQHJRVRZD3U]\R \SLyURGRSDSLHUXDOHLQNDXVWZ\VHFK
6WDU]HFZFDOHVL W\PQLHSU]HM
1LHFK H ]DQRWRZDQH]RVWDQLHLWRSRGM H G]LHZF]\QDQLJG\QLHURG]LD$
WDN H LWR H QDFLHOHQLHPD DGQ\FK]DVWDU]D\FK]QDPLRQEOL]QV]UDP DGQ\FK
ODGyZMDNLH]RVWDZLDM FL NDSUDFDZ\SDGNLKD]DUGRZQH \FLH3RGNUH ODP
PRZDR ODGDFK]DVWDU]D\FK ODGyZ ZLH \FKQLHEUDNXMHQDMHMFLHOH
']LHZF]\QDE\DELWD&KRVWDQDLWRE\QDMPQLHMQLHRMFRZVN U N .RSDQDE\D
SUDZGRSRGREQLHWH
=QDOD]HPWH QDMHMFLHOHGR G]LZQ\]QDNV]F]HJyOQ\+PPP=DSLV]P\
WRGODGREUDQDXNL:SDFKZLQLHWX SU]\Z]JyUNXRQRZ\PG]LHZF]\QDPD
Z\WDWXRZDQ F]HUZRQ Uy
9\VRJRWDZVNXSLHQLXREHMU]D]DRVWU]RQ\NRQLHFSLyUDSRF]\P]DQXU]\MHZ
NDDPDU]X7\PUD]HPQLH]DSRPQLDMHGQDNZMDNLPFHOXWRXF]\QLV]\ENR
]DF] SRNU\ZDDUNXV]UyZQ\PLOLQLMNDPLSRFK\HJRSLVPD3LVDGRSyNLSLyUR
QLHRVFKR
3ySU]\WRPQDPyZLDLNU]\F]DDSRGM -HMDNFHQWLVSRVyEZ\VDZLDQLD
VL MH OLSRPLQ J VWHZWU W\ZREVFHQLF]Q\P DUJRQLHNU\PLQDOLVWyZV GR
NRQIXQGXM FHWUXGQHGRXPLHMVFRZLHQLDDOH]DU\]\NRZDE\PVWZLHUG]HQLH H
SRFKRG] UDF]HM]3yQRF\QL ] 3RXGQLD1LHNWyUHVRZD
=QRZXSRVNU]\SLDSLyUHPSRSHUJDPLQLHQLH]E\WGXJRRZLHOH]DNUyWNRE\
PyF]DSLVDZV]\VWNRFRSU]HGFKZLO Z\U]HN3RF]\PSRGM PRQRORJ
GRNDGQLHWDPJG]LHJRSU]HUZD
1LHNWyUHVRZDLPLRQDLQD]Z\NWyUHG]LHZF]\QDZ\EHNRWDDZPDOLJQLH
ZDUWHV ]DSDPL WDQLD,]EDGDQLD:V]\VWNRZVND]XMHQDWR H EDUG]RDOHWR
EDUG]RQLHFRG]LHQQDRVRED]QDOD]DGURJ GRFKDW\VWDUHJR9\VRJR\0LOF]D
SU]H]FKZLO QDVXFKXM F
2E\W\ONR]DPUXF]DFKDWDVWDUHJR9\VRJRW\QLHRND]DDVL NUHVHPMHM
GURJL
9\VRJRWDSRFK\OLVL QDGSHUJDPLQHPLQDZHWSU]\R \GRQLHJRSLyURDOHQLH
]DSLVDQLFDQLMHGQHMUXQ\5]XFLSLyURQDVWy3U]H]FKZLO VDSDPUXF]D
JQLHZQLHSRVPDUNLZD3DWU]\QDSU\F] VXFKDGRELHJDM F\FKVWDPW G
RGJRVyZ
7U]HEDVWZLHUG]LL]DSLVDSRZLHG]LD]P F]RQ\PJRVHP H MHVWEDUG]R
QLHGREU]H:V]\VWNLHPRMHVWDUDQLDL]DELHJLPRJ RND]DVL QLHZ\VWDUF]DM FHD
Z\VLNLSRQQH0RMHREDZ\E\\X]DVDGQLRQH5DQDMHVW]DND RQD']LHZF]\QD
VLOQLHJRU F]NXMH:\VW SL\MX WU]\]F]WHUHFKNDUG\QDOQ\FKREMDZyZRVWUHJR
VWDQX]DSDOQHJR5XERUFDORULWXPRUDWZRMX Z WHMFKZLOLVWZLHUG]LRNLHPL
GRW\NLHP*G\PLQLHV]RNSR]DELHJRZ\SRMDZLVL L REMDZF]ZDUW\GRORU
1LHFK H ]DSLVDQH]RVWDQLH H PLQ REOLVNRSyZLHNXRGNLHG\]DMPRZDHPVL
SUDNW\N PHG\F]Q F]XM MDNODWDWHFL
QDPHMSDPL FLLQD]U F]QR FLP\FK
SDOFyZ1LHZLHOHXPLHP]URELMHV]F]HPQLHMPRJ ]UREL URGNyZL
PHG\NDPHQWyZPDPPQLHMQL PDR&DDQDG]LHMDZPHFKDQL]PDFKREURQQ\FK
PRGHJRRUJDQL]PX
'ZXQDVWDJRG]LQDSR]DELHJX=JRGQLH]RF]HNLZDQLDPLSU]\V]HGF]ZDUW\
NDUG\QDOQ\REMDZ]DND HQLDGRORU&KRUDNU]\F]\]EyOXJRU F]NDLGUHV]F]H
Z]PDJDM VL 1LHPDPQLF]HJR DGQHJR URGNDNWyU\PyJE\PMHMSRGD
'\VSRQXM QLHZLHON LOR FL HOLNVLUXGDWXURZHJRDOHG]LHZF]\QDMHVW]DVDEDE\
SU]H \MHJRG]LDDQLH0DPWH QLHFRDNRQLWXPDOHDNRQLWXP]DELRE\M
QLHFK\EQLH
1LHVSDGU]HPDW\ONRJG\]GU]HPNLZ\UZDJRVWXNLRPRWNWyUHPX
WRZDU]\V]\M N%DUG]LHMZ FLHNR FLQL EyOX
1D]HZQ WU]GQLDRV]SDU\RNLHQQLFV F]\\QLNH ZLDWHNR.OHSV\GUD
SU]HV\SDDVL GRNR FDLWRGDZQR9\VRJRWDMDN]Z\NOH]DSRPQLDM REUyFL
.DJDQHNOHGZRSHJDUXELQRZ\ DU]SDOHQLVNDVDERR ZLHWODN W L]E\6WDU]HF
ZVWDRGVXQ ]DLPSURZL]RZDQ\SDUDZDQ]NRFyZNWyU\PRGJURG]LSU\F] RG
UHV]W\SRPLHV]F]HQLDE\]DSHZQLFKRUHMVSRNyM
&KRUD]G \DMX SR]ELHUDVL ] SRGRJLQDNWyU SU]HGFKZLO XSDGD
V\PSDWLL:LHF]QDG]LHZF]\QNDQDZHWJG\GZXG]LHVWHEDWU]\G]LHVWHXURG]LQ\
MX GDZQR]DSDGQ Z QLHSDPL 7DN9\VRJRWDGREU]H]QDWHQW\SXURG\-HJR
GUXJD RQDE\DWDND-HJRFyUNDE\DWDND
0XV] VW G XFLHNDSRZLHG]LDDQDJOHG]LHZF]\QD,WRSLOQLH-HVWHP
FLJDQD3U]HFLH ZLHV]RW\P
:LHPNLZQ JRZ %\\WRWZRMHSLHUZV]HVRZDNWyUHZEUHZSR]RURP
QLHE\\PDMDF]HQLHP'RNDGQLHMMHGQH]SLHUZV]\FK1DMSLHUZVS\WDD R WZHJR
NRQLDLRWZyMPLHF]:WHMNROHMQR FL*G\]DSHZQLHPFL H LNR LPLHF]V
SRGGREU RSLHN QDEUDD SRGHMU]H H MHVWHPZVSyOQLNLHPMDNLHJR %RQKDUWDL
QLHOHF] FL OHF]SRGGDM WRUWXU]HQDG]LHL*G\QLHEH]WUXGXZ\SURZDG]LHPFL ]
E GXSU]HGVWDZLD VL MDNR)DONDLSRG]L NRZDD PL]DUDWXQHN
7RGREU]HREUyFLDJRZ QDSRGXV]FHMDNJG\E\FKFLDDXQLNQ
NRQLHF]QR FLSDWU]HQLDPXZRF]\7RGREU]H H QLH]DSRPQLDDPSRG]L NRZD
-DWDPWRSDPL WDPMDNSU]H]PJ 1LHZLHPFRE\RMDZ DFRVQHP%DDPVL
H QLHSRG]L NRZDDP1LHQD]\ZDPVL )DOND
7HJRWH VL GRZLHG]LDHPFKRUDF]HMSU]\SDGNRZR0yZLD Z JRU F]FH
-HVWHP]ELHJLHPSRZLHG]LDDQLHRGZUDFDM F VL 8FLHNLQLHUHP
1LHEH]SLHF]QLHMHVWGDZDPLVFKURQLHQLH1LHEH]SLHF]QLHMHVWZLHG]LHMDNVL
QDSUDZG QD]\ZDP-DPXV] ZVLDGDQDNRQLDLXFLHND]DQLPPQLHWX
Z\WURSL
3U]HGFKZLO SRZLHG]LDDJRGQLHPLDD NRSRW\]VL FLHPQDQRFQLN1LH
EDUG]RZLG] FL VLDGDM F QDNRQLD$OH]DSHZQLDPWXWDMMHVWH EH]SLHF]QD1LNW
FL WXQLHZ\WURSL
=SHZQR FL PQLH FLJDM ,G SR ODGDFKSU]HWU] VDM RNROLF
8VSRNyMVL &RG]LHQQLHSDGDQLNWQLHRGQDMG]LH ODGyZ7\]D MHVWH QD
SXVWNRZLXZSXVWHOQL:GRPXSXVWHOQLNDNWyU\RGFL VL RG ZLDWD7DNE\
ZLDWXWH QLHDWZRE\RJRRGQDOH -H OLMHGQDNVRELH \F]\V]PRJ SRV]XND
VSRVREXE\ZLH RWRELHSU]HND]DEOLVNLPOXESU]\MDFLRRP
1LHZLHV]QDZHWNLPMHVWHP
-HVWH UDQQ G]LHZF]\Q SU]HUZD8FLHNDM F SU]HGNLP NWRQLHZDKDVL
UDQLG]LHZF]\Q&]\ \F]\V]VRELHE\PSU]HND]DMDN ZLDGRPR "
1LHPDNRPXRGU]HNDSRFKZLOLD9\VRJRWD]RZLXFKHP]PLDQ JRVX
0RLSU]\MDFLHOHQLH \M :V]\VWNLFK]DPRUGRZDQR
1LHVNRPHQWRZD
-DMHVWHP PLHUFL SRGM DG]LZQLHEU]PL F\PJRVHP.D G\NWRVW\NDVL
]HPQ XPLHUD
1LHND G\]DSU]HF]\SU]\JO GDM F VL MHMEDF]QLH1LH%RQKDUWWHQNWyUHJR
LPL Z\NU]\NLZDD Z JRU F]FHWHQSU]HGNWyU\PFKFHV]WHUD]XFLHND:DV]VW\N
]DV]NRG]LUDF]HMWRELHQLHMHPX7RRQ]UDQLFL Z WZDU]"
1LH]DFLVQ DXVWDE\VWXPLFR FRE\RDOERM NLHPDOERSU]HNOH VWZHP
: WZDU]]UDQLPQLH3XV]F]\N6WHIDQ6NHOOHQ$%RQKDUW%RQKDUW]UDQLPQLH
]QDF]QLHSRZD QLHM* ELHM&]\LRW\PPyZLDPZJRU F]FH"
8VSRNyMVL -HVWH RVDELRQDSRZLQQD XQLNDVLOQ\FKZ]UXV]H
1D]\ZDPVL &LUL
=UREL FLRNDG]DUQLNL&LUL
MDVQ\PLQLHSR]RVWDZLDDPLHMVFDQDGRP\V\&LULZVWDD]WUXGHP3RVLRGRL
XSU] QDZHWQLHSUyERZDDVL VFK\OD6SUDZG]LDW\ONRF]\NODF]PDVLDQRL
RZLHVZ RELH]DF] DZ\FLHUDJU]ELHWLERNLNRQLDZLHFKFLHPVRP\9\VRJRWD
F]HNDZPLOF]HQLXLGRF]HNDVL ']LHZF]\QD]DWRF]\DVL QDVXSSRGWU]\PXM F\
VWURS]EODGDMDNSyWQR%H]VRZDSRGDMHMNRVWXU
1LFPLQLHMHVW7\ONR
7\ONRZJRZLHFLVL ]DNU FLRERMHVWH FKRUDLVDEDMDNQRZRURGHN
:UDFDMP\0XVLV]VL SRR \
2]DFKRG]LHVR FDSU]HVSDZV]\DGQ\FKNLONDJRG]LQ&LULZ\V]DSRQRZQLH
9\VRJRWDZUDFDM F ]QDGU]HNLQDWNQ VL QDQL SU]\QDWXUDOQ\PMH \QRZ\P
\ZRSRFLH
1LHRGFKRG ]E\WGDOHNRRGFKDXS\SRZLHG]LDFLHUSNR3RSLHUZV]HMHVWH
]E\WRVDELRQD
&]XM VL OHSLHM
3RGUXJLHWRQLHEH]SLHF]QH'RRNRDMHVWRJURPQHPRNUDGRQLHNR F] FHVL
SROHWU]FLQ1LH]QDV] FLH HNPR HV]]DE G]LOXEXWRQ ZWU] VDZLVNX
$W\ZVND]DDQDZRUHNNWyU\WDV]F]\ FLH NL]QDV]RF]\ZL FLH,QDZHW
QLHGDOHNRQLPLFKDG]DV]D]DWHPPRNUDGRZFDOHQLHMHVWWDNLHZLHONLH*DUEXMHV]
VNyU\DE\ \MDVQH.HOSLHPRMDNODF]PDRZLHVDSRODWXQLHZLG] 0\
MHGOL P\NXU L NUXS\,FKOHE3UDZG]LZ\FKOHEQLHSRGSRP\NL&KOHEDQLH
GRVWDE\ RGWUDSHUD$]DWHPZRNROLF\MHVWZLH
%H]E GQLHZ\GHGXNRZDQHSRWZLHUG]LVSRNRMQLH5]HF]\ZL FLHGRVWDM
SURZLDQW\]QDMEOL V]HMZVL1DMEOL V]HMDOHZFDOHQLHEOLVNLHMOH FHMQDVNUDMX
EDJLHQ0RNUDGRSU]\OHJDGRU]HNL:\PLHQLDPVNyU\QD \ZQR NWyU
SU]\ZR PLRG]L &KOHENDV] P N VyOVHUF]DVDPLNUyOLNDOXENXU
&]DVDPLZLDGRPR FL
1LHGRF]HNDVL S\WDQLDZL F NRQW\QXXRZD
:DWDKDNRQQ\FKZSR FLJXGZXNURWQLHE\DZRVDG]LH=DSLHUZV]\PUD]HP
RVWU]HJDQRE\FL QLHXNU\ZDJUR RQRFKRSRPPLHF]HPLRJQLHPMH OL
]RVWDQLHV]ZRVDG]LHVFKZ\WDQD=DGUXJLPRELHF\ZDQRQDJURG ]DRGQDOH]LHQLH
WUXSD7ZRLSU]H ODGRZF\V SU]HNRQDQL H OH \V]PDUWZDZODVDFKZMDNLP
MDU]HF]\Z GROH
,QLHVSRF]Q PUXNQ DGRSyNLQLHRGQDMG ]ZRN:LHPRW\PGREU]H
0XV] PLHGRZyG H QLH \M %H]WHJRGRZRGXQLH]UH]\JQXM % G V]SHUD
ZV] G]LH:UHV]FLHWUDIL L WXWDM
%DUG]RLP]DOH \ ]DXZD \3RZLHG]LDE\PQLH]Z\NOHLP]DOH \
=DFL DXVWD
1LHO NDMVL 2GMDG ]DQLPPQLHWX]QDMG 1LHQDUD FL 1LHEyMVL
6N G SU]\SXV]F]HQLH H VL ERM " Z]UXV]\UDPLRQDPL H MHVWSRZyGE\
VL O ND"7XWDMQLNWQLHWUDILQLNWFL WXQLHZ\ OHG]L-H OLMHGQDNW\Z\VWDZLV]QRV
] WU]FLQWUDILV]WZRLPSU]H ODGRZFRPSURVWRZU FH
,QQ\PLVRZ\SRGU]XFLDKDUGRJRZ PXV] WX]RVWD"7RFKFLDH
SRZLHG]LH"
1LHMHVWH ZL QLHP0R HV]RGMHFKDJG\]HFKFHV]'RNDGQLHMJG\]GRDV]
$OHPR HV]WH ]RVWDXPQLHLSU]HF]HND FLJDM F\]QLHFK F VL NLHG\ =DZV]H
+HQ&HUELQGLF
VVDHQQ
RJ=LUHDHO
$DUNDDUNFDHOPIRLOHWHYHORHHOO"
=LUHDHO
8UZDRSDURNFLHRVWyDSRGEUyGHNQDVSOHFLRQ\FKSDOFDFK&LULV]DUSQ D
JRZ Z\SURVWRZDDVL VSRMU]DDQDQLHJRZ\]\ZDM FR,GRNR F]\D
=LUHDHOXHORHTXH
VVDHQHQ
VVDQLUFK
0DERJ+HQ&HUELQYHDQQLJXLUNTXLUN
=JRU]NQLD\LQLHXIQ\VWDUXFKSRZLHG]LDSRFKZLOL9\VRJRWDQLH]PLHQLDM F
SR]\FMLSU]HSUDV]DPRG HUXG\WN 6 G]LZ\NUXNZV] G]LHZ V] F\SRGVW S L
RV]XVWZRSURVLRZ\EDF]HQLHMDVNyN NWyUHMMHG\Q ZLQ MHVWWR H MHVWPRGDL
SHQD \FLD,DGQLXWND
7HUD]SOHFLHV] DFKQ DVL RGUXFKRZR]DNU\ZDM F GRQL EOL]Q QDSROLF]NX
7DNLHNRPSOHPHQW\PR HV]VRELHGDURZD1LHSRSUDZL RQHNR ODZ\FK
FLHJyZNWyU\PLVIDVWU\JRZDH PLVNyU 1LHP\ O WH VRELH H ]GRE G]LHV]Z
WHQVSRVyEPRM XIQR -DQDGDOQLHZLHPNLPW\ZD FLZLHMHVWH 'ODF]HJR
RNDPDH PQLHZVSUDZLHW\FKGDWLGQL,ZMDNLPFHOX]DJO GDH PLPL G]\QRJL
FKRUDQQDE\DPZWZDU],F]\QD]DJO GDQLXVL VNR F]\R
7\PUD]HPXGDRVL MHMZ\SURZDG]LJR]UyZQRZDJL
&RW\VRELHZ\REUD DV]VPDUNXOR"NU]\NQ 0yJE\PE\WZRLPRMFHP
']LDGNLHPSRSUDZLD]LPQR$OERLSUDG]LDGNLHP$OHQLHMHVWH -DQLH
ZLHPNLPMHVWH $OHQDSHZQRQLHMHVWH W\P]DNRJRFKFLDE\ XFKRG]L
-HVWHPW\PNWR]QDOD]FL QDEDJQLHQLHPDOSU]\PDU]QL W GRPFKX]F]DUQ
VNRUXS ]DPLDVWWZDU]\QLHSU]\WRPQ ]DSDVNXG]RQ L EUXGQ -HVWHPW\PNWR
]DEUDFL GRGRPXFKRQLHZLHG]LDNLPMHVWH DGRP\ ODVL PLDSUDZR
QDMJRUV]HJR.WRRSDWU]\FL L SRR \GRy ND/HF]\JG\NRQDD ] JRU F]NL
3LHO JQRZD0\'RNDGQLH:RNROLFDFKWDWXD X UyZQLH
=QRZXVS VRZLDDDOH]MHMRF]XDQLP\ ODR]QLNDEH]F]HOQHZ\]ZDQLH
1DW\P ZLHFLHZDUNQ DV]DFKUDMVNLHSR]RU\F]DVHPXGDM SUDZG VDPWDN
SRZLHG]LDH -DWH MX WURFK ]QDP ZLDWZ\REUD VRELH8UDWRZDH PQLH
RSDWU]\H SLHO JQRZDH ']L NLFL]DWR:G]L F]QDFLMHVWHP]D]DGREUR$OH
SU]HFLH MDZLHP H QLHPDF]HJR WDNLHJRMDNGREUREH]
%H]Z\UDFKRZDQLDLQDG]LHLQDNRU]\ GRNR F]\]X PLHFKHP7DNWDN
ZLHPE\ZD\]HPQLHF]HNNWRZLHF]\QLH]QDP ZLDWDUyZQLHGREU]HMDNW\
&LUL5DQQHG]LHZF]\Q\MDNZLDGRPRRJUDELDVL ]HZV]\VWNLHJRFRPD
MDN NROZLHNZDUWR -H OLV QLHSU]\WRPQHOXE]E\WVDEHE\VL EURQL
]Z\F]DMRZRSRSXV]F]DVL FXJOLZDVQ\PFKXFLRPL G]RPQLHU]DGNRQD
Z\VW SQHLSU]HFLZQHQDWXU]HVSRVRE\3UDZGD"
1LFQLHMHVWWDNLHQDMDNLHZ\JO GDRGU]HND&LULSRUD]NROHMQ\REOHZDM F VL
UXPLH FHP
-DN H SUDZG]LZHWZLHUG]HQLHGRU]XFLNROHMQ VNyU QDZD FLZ NXSN ,
MDN H EH]OLWR QLHZLRG FHQDVGRZQLRVNX H P\&LULQLHZLHP\RVRELHQLF]HJR
=QDP\W\ONRSR]RU\DWHP\O
1D]\ZDPVL 9\VRJRWD]&RUYR%\HPOHNDU]HP&KLUXUJLHP%\HP
DOFKHPLNLHP%\HPEDGDF]HPKLVWRU\NLHPILOR]RIHPHW\NLHP%\HP
SURIHVRUHPZ$NDGHPLL2[HQIXUFNLHM0XVLDHPVWDPW G XFLHNDSR
RSXEOLNRZDQLXSHZQHJRG]LHDNWyUHX]QDQR]DEH]ER QH]DFRZyZF]DV
SL G]LHVL W ODWWHPXJUR]LDNDUD PLHUFL0XVLDHPHPLJURZD0RMD RQD
HPLJURZDQLHFKFLDDZL F SRU]XFLDPQLH$MD]DWU]\PDHPVL GRSLHURGDOHNR
QDSRXGQLXZ&HVDUVWZLH1LOIJDDUG]NLP=RVWDHPZUHV]FL Z\NDGRZF HW\NLZ
$NDGHPLL,PSHULDOQHMZ&DVWHOO*UDXSLDQJRGQR W SLDVWRZDHPEOLVNRG]LHVL
ODW$OHLVWDPW G PXVLDHPXFLHNDSRRSXEOLNRZDQLXSHZQHJRWUDNWDWX
1DZLDVHPPyZL FG]LHRWUDNWRZDRRWRWDOLWDUQHMZDG]\L]EURGQLF]\P
FKDUDNWHU]H]DERUF]\FKZRMHQDOHRILFMDOQLH]DU]XFDQRG]LHXLPQLHPHWDIL]\F]Q\
PLVW\F\]PLVFKL]P NOHU\NDOQ 8]QDQR H G]LDDHP]SRGXV]F]HQLD
HNVSDQV\ZQ\FKLUHZL]MRQLVW\F]Q\FKXJUXSRZD NDSD VNLFKIDNW\F]QLH
U] G] F\FKNUyOHVWZDPL1RUGOLQJyZ'R ]DEDZQHZ ZLHWOHPRMHJRZ\URNX
PLHUFL]DDWHL]PVSU]HGGZXG]LHVWXODW%\R]UHV]W DNXUDWWDN H QD3yQRF\
HNVSDQV\ZQLNDSDQLGDZQRMX SRV]OLZ]DSRPQLHQLHDOHZ1LOIJDDUG]LHQLH
SU]\MPRZDQRWHJRGRZLDGRPR FL F]HQLHPLVW\F\]PXL]DERERQX]SROLW\N
E\R FLJDQHLVXURZRNDUDQH
']L RFHQLDM F ]SHUVSHNW\Z\ODWP\ O H JG\E\PVL XNRU]\LRND]D
VNUXFK PR H DIHUDUR]ZLDDE\VL DFHVDU]RJUDQLF]\GRQLHDVNLEH]VL JDQLDSR
URGNLGUDVW\F]QH$OHMDE\HPUR]JRU\F]RQ\3HZQ\VZ\FKUDFMLNWyUHPLDHP]D
SRQDGF]DVRZHQDGU] GQHZREHFWHMF]\LQQHMZDG]\OXESROLW\NL&]XHPVL
VNU]\ZG]RQ\VNU]\ZG]RQ\QLHVSUDZLHGOLZLH7\UD VNR1DZL ]DHPZL F
DNW\ZQHNRQWDNW\]G\V\GHQWDPLWDMQLH]ZDOF]DM F\PLW\UDQD=DQLPVL
REHMU]DHPVLHG]LDHPUD]HP]G\V\GHQWDPLZORFKXDQLHNWyU]\JG\SRND]DQR
LPQDU] G]LDZVND]DOLQDPQLHMDNRQDJyZQHJRLGHRORJDUXFKX
&HVDU]VNRU]\VWD]SUDZDDVNL]RVWDHPMHGQDNVND]DQ\QDEDQLFM SRG
JUR E QDW\FKPLDVWRZHMNDU\ PLHUFLZSU]\SDGNXSRZURWXQD]LHPLHFHVDUVNLH
:yZF]DVREUD]LHPVL QDFD\ ZLDWQDNUyOHVWZDFHVDUVWZDLXQLZHUV\WHW\
QDG\V\GHQWyZXU] GQLNyZSUDZQLNyZ1DNROHJyZLSU]\MDFLyNWyU]\]D
GRWNQL FLHPPDJLF]QHMUy G NLSU]HVWDOLE\QLPL1DGUXJ RQ NWyUDSRGREQLH
MDNSLHUZV]DXZD DD H NRSRW\P D WR]DVDGQLF]\SRZyGGRUR]ZRGX1D
G]LHFLNWyUHVL PQLHZ\U]HN\=RVWDHPSXVWHOQLNLHP7XZ(EELQJQDEDJQDFK
3HUHSOXWX3U]HM HPVDG\E Z VFKHG]LHSRSHZQ\PHUHPLFLHNWyUHJR]GDU]\RPL
VL NLHG\ SR]QD3HFKFKFLD H 1LOIJDDUG]DDQHNWRZD(EELQJLQL]WHJRQL]
RZHJR]QDOD]HPVL ]QRZXZ&HVDUVWZLH1LHPDPMX DQLVLDQLFK FLQDGDOV]H
Z GURZDQLHGODWHJRPXV] VL XNU\ZD&HVDUVNLHZ\URNLQLHXOHJDM
SU]HGDZQLHQLXQDZHWZV\WXDFMLJG\LPSHUDWRUNWyU\MHZ\GDGDZQRQLH \MHD
REHFQ\FHVDU]QLHPDSRZRGyZE\PLOHZVSRPLQDWDPWHJRLSRG]LHODMHJR
SRJO G\:\URN PLHUFLSR]RVWDMHZPRF\7DNLHMHVWSUDZRL]Z\F]DMZ
1LOIJDDUG]LH:\URNL]D]GUDG VWDQXQLHSU]HGDZQLDM VL L QLHSRGOHJDM DPQHVWLL
NWyU ND G\FHVDU]RJDV]DSRNRURQDFML3RZVW SLHQLXQDWURQQRZHJRFHVDU]D
DPQHVWLRQRZDQL]RVWDM ZV]\VF\NWyU\FKMHJRSRSU]HGQLNVND]D]DZ\M WNLHP
ZLQQ\FK]GUDG\VWDQX1LHPD]QDF]HQLDNWRU] G]LZ1LOIJDDUG]LHMH OLZ\GDVL
H \M L DPL Z\URNEDQLFMLSU]HE\ZDM F QDFHVDUVNLPWHU\WRULXPPRMDJRZD
VSDGQLHQDV]DIRFLH
-DN]DWHPZLG]LV]&LUL]QDMGXMHP\VL Z FDNLHPSRGREQHMV\WXDFML
&RWRMHVWHW\ND":LHG]LDDPWRDOH]DSRPQLDDP
1DXNDRPRUDOQR FL2SUDZLGDFKSRVW SRZDQLDRE\F]DMQHJRV]ODFKHWQHJR
SRF]FLZHJRLXF]FLZHJR2Z\ \QDFKGREUDQDNWyUHZ\QRVLGXV] OXG]N
SUDZR LPRUDOQR ,RRWFKDQLDFK]DZNWyUHVWU FDQLHSRF]FLZR L
QLHPRUDOQR
:\ \Q\GREUDSDUVNQ D3UDZR 0RUDOQR 1LHUR] PLHV]DMPQLHER
PLVL V]UDPDQDS\VNXUR]S NQLH0LDH V]F] FLH H FL QLHWURSLOL H QLHSRVDOL
]DWRE RZFyZQDJUyGWDNLFKMDN%RQKDUW=REDF]\E\ FRWRV RWFKDQLH]D
(W\ND"DMQRZDUWDMHVWWZRMDHW\ND9\VRJRWR]&RUYR7RQLH]\FKL
QLHSRF]FLZ\FKVWU FDVL QDGQRQLH2QLH7R OLDOH]GHF\GRZDQLVWU FDM WDP
WDNLFKNWyU]\V PRUDOQLXF]FLZLLV]ODFKHWQLDOHQLH]GDUQLZDKDM F\VL L SHQL
VNUXSXyZ
']L NL]DQDXN ]DGUZL:LHU FKRE\ FD\ZLHNSU]H \QLJG\QLHMHVW]D
Sy QRE\F]HJR VL QDXF]\=DLVWH]DZV]HZDUWRSRVXFKDRVyEGRMU]D\FK
E\ZD\FKLGR ZLDGF]RQ\FK
$NSLMVRELHNSLMV]DUSQ DJRZ 3yNLPR HV]%RWHUD]PRMDNROHMWHUD]
MD]DEDZL FL RSRZLH FL 2SRZLHPFLMDNWRE\R]HPQ $JG\VNR F]
]REDF]\P\F]\QDGDOE G]LHV]PLDRFKRW GUZL
5R]G]LD
:NUDF]DM F ZZLHNGRMU]HZDQLDPRGDG]LHZF]\QD]DF]\QDSRGHMPRZDSUyE\
SHQHWUDFMLG]LHG]LQ \FLDXSU]HGQLRMHMQLHGRVW SQ\FKFRZED QLDFKV\PEROL]XMH
ZHM FLHGRWDMHPQLF]HMZLH \ LSRV]XNLZDQLHXNU\WHMWDPNRPQDW\']LHZF]\QD
ZVSLQDVL QDV]F]\WZLH \VW SDM F SRNU FRQ\FKVFKRGDFKVFKRG\ZVQDFKV
V\PEROHPSU]H \FLDHURW\F]QHJR=DND]DQDNRPQDWDyZPD\]DPNQL W\QDNOXF]
SRNyMV\PEROL]XMHYDJLQ SU]HNU FHQLHNOXF]DZ]DPNXWRV\PERODNWX
VHNVXDOQHJR
%UXQR%HWWHOKHLP7KH8VHVRI(QFKDQWPHQW
WQ 0HDQLQJDQG,PSRUWDQFHRI)DLU\7DOHV
=DFKRGQLZLDWUSU]\QLyVQRFQ EXU]
&]DPRILROHWRZHQLHERS NRZ]GX OLQLLE\VNDZLF\HNVSORGRZDR
SU]HFL J\PRVNRWHPJURPX1DJ\GHV]F]XGHU]\ZNXU]GURJLNURSODPLJ VW\PL
MDNROHM]DV]XPLDQDGDFKDFKUR]PD]DEUXGQDRNLHQQ\FKERQDFK$OHVLOQ\
ZLDWUV]\ENRSU]HS G]LXOHZ RGHJQDEXU] JG]LH KHQGDOHNR]DSRQ F\
E\VNDZLFDPLKRU\]RQW
,ZWHG\UR]V]F]HND\VL SV\=DGXGQL\NRS\WD]DEU] F]DDEUR ']LNLH
KDDNRZDQLDLJZL]G\]MH \\ZRVUR]EXG]RQ\PZLH QLDNRP]U\ZDM F\PVL Z
SRSRFKX]DSLHUDM F\PGU JDPLGU]ZLLRNLHQQLFH6SRFRQHGRQLH]DFLVND\VL QD
VW\OLVNDFKVLHNLHUQDWU]RQNDFKZLGH=DFLVND\VL PRFQR$OHEH]VLOQLH
7HUURUWHUURUOHFLSU]H]ZLH FLJDQLF]\ FLJDM F\"6]DOHQLLRNUXWQL]
Z FLHNR FLF]\]HVWUDFKX"3U]HOHF QLHZVWU]\PXM F NRQL"&]\WH UR]MDU]\VL ]D
FKZLO QRFRJQLHPJRUHM F\FKVWU]HFK"
&LFKRFLFKRG]LHFL
0DPRF]\WRGHPRQ\"&]\WR']LNL*RQ"=PRU\]SLHNDURGHP"0DPR
PDPR
&LFKRFLFKRG]LHFL7RQLHGHPRQ\QLHGLDE\
*RU]HM
7ROXG]LH
3V\XMDGD\' ZLFKHU5 D\NRQLHRPRWD\SRGNRZ\3U]H]ZLH L QRF
OHFLDDKXODMSDUWLD
+RWVSRUQZMHFKDQDZ]JyUHNZVWU]\PDLREUyFLNRQLD%\SU]H]RUQ\L
RVWUR Q\QLHOXELU\]\ND]ZDV]F]DZWHG\JG\F]XMQR QLFQLHNRV]WRZDD1LH
VSLHV]\VL ]H]MD]GHPZGyQDGU]HF]N GRVWDFMLSRF]WRZHM:RODSLHUZHM
GREU]HVL SU]\SDWU]H
3U]HGVWDFM QLHE\RNRQLDQL]DSU] JyZVWDWDPZ\ F]QLHMHGHQIXUJRQLN
]DSU] RQ\ZSDU PXyZ1DSDFKFLHZLGQLDQDSLVNWyUHJR+RWVSRUQQLHPyJ]
GDOHNDRGF]\WD$OHQLHEH]SLHF]H VWZHPQLHSDFKQLDR+RWVSRUQSRWUDIL
Z\F]XZDQLHEH]SLHF]H VWZR%\]DZRGRZFHP
=MHFKDQDG]DNU]DF]RQ\L]DUR QL W\R] EU]HJ]GHF\GRZDQLHZSDUNRQLDZ
U]HN SU]HEURG]LJDORSHPZ UyGELM F\FKSRZ\ HMVLRGDUR]EU\]JyZZRG\
7DSODM FHVL SU]\EU]HJXNDF]NLXFLHN\]JR Q\PNZDNLHP
+RWVSRUQSRQDJOLNRQLDSU]H]UR]JURG]RQ\SRWZMHFKDQDSRGZyU]HVWDFML
7HUD]PyJMX RGF]\WDQDSLVQDSDFKFLHIXUJRQXJRV] F\0LVWU]$OPD\HUD
.XQV]WRZQLN7DWXD X.D G\Z\UD]QDSLVXZ\PDORZDQ\E\LQQ\PNRORUHPL
]DF]\QDVL RGSU]HVDGQLHZLHONLHMR]GREQLHLOXPLQRZDQHMOLWHU\$QDVNU]\QL
ZR]XSRZ\ HMSUDZHJRSU]HGQLHJRNRDZLGQLDDZ\PDORZDQDSXUSXURZ IDUE
QLHGX D UR]GDUWDVWU]DD
=NRQLDXV\V]D]]DSOHFyZ1D]LHPL D \ZR5 FH]GDOHNDRG
U NRMH FL
3RGHV]OLJRLRWRF]\OLEH]V]HOHVWQLH]SUDZHM$VVHZF]DUQHMVNyU]DQHMNXUWFH
QLWRZDQHMVUHEUHP]OHZHM)DONDZ]LHORQ\P]DPV]RZ\PNXEUDF]NXLEHUHFLH]
SLyUNDPL+RWVSRUQ FL JQ NDSWXUL]DVRQ ] WZDU]\
+D$VVHRSX FLPLHF]7RZ\+RWVSRUQ3R]QDE\PDOH]P\OLPQLHWHQ
NDU\NR
$OH NRE\ND OLF]QDSRZLHG]LDD]]DFKZ\WHP)DONDRGVXZDM F EHUHWQD
XFKR&]DUQDLO QL FDMDNZ JLHODQLZRVNDMD QLHMV]HJR$]JUDEQD(FK
NUDVDZLFD
$QRWDNDVL WUDILD]DQLHFDHVWRIORUHQyZX PLHFKQ VL QLHGEDOH+RWVSRUQ
*G]LH*LVHOKHU": URGNX"
$VVHNLZQ JRZ )DONDSDWU] F QDNODF]MDNXU]HF]RQDSRNOHSDDM SRV]\L
*G\ELHJDSU]H]ZRG XQLRVDQD+RWVSRUQDZLHONLH]LHORQHRF]\WRE\D
QLF]\PLVWQDNHOSLH*G\E\]PRU]DVL Z\QXU]\DDQLH]U]HF]NLQLH
XZLHU]\DE\P H WRQLHSUDZG]LZDNHOSLH
$ZLG]LDDSDQQD)DONDNLHG\SUDZG]LZ NHOSLH"
1DREUD]NXG]LHZF]\QDVSRFKPXPLDDQDJOH'X R E\RW\PJDGD
&KRG FLHGR URGND*LVHOKHUF]HND
NRORURZHJRREUD]ND
&KRG EOL HM+RWVSRUQ]DSURVL*LVHOKHURGVXZDM F ]\GHORGGDOV]HJRVWRX
]DNWyU\PVLHG]LD],VNU .D\OHLJKHPL5HHIHP'ZDMRVWDWQLMDN$VVHWH
RG]LDQLE\OLZF]DUQ FLHO F VNyU XVLDQ NODPHUNDPLZLHNDPLD FXV]NDPLL
LQQ\PLZ\P\ OQ\PLR]GREDPL]HVUHEUD-DNL U]HPLH OQLNPXVLDQDQLFKSRW QLH
]DURELSRP\ OD+RWVSRUQ6]F]XU\JG\QDSDGDLFK]DFKFLDQNDZ\VWURLVL
SDFL\NUDZFRPV]HZFRPLU\PDU]RPL FLHSRNUyOHZVNX-DVQDU]HF]QLJG\WH
QLHE\\RGWHJRE\SRSURVWX]HGU]H]QDSDGQL WHMRVRE\RG]LH OXEEL XWHUL
NWyUDZSDGDLPZRNR
=QDOD]H MDNZLG] QDV] ZLDGRPR ZUXLQDFKVWDUHMVWDFML"SU]HFL JQ VL
*LVHOKHU+DFRJDGDPLQDF]HMSU]HFLHQLHE\RE\FL WX6]\ENRQDZHW
]MHFKDH SU]\]QDPXV]
%RNODF] OLF]QDZWU FLD)DOND=DR VL H LU F]D
-DZDV] ZLDGRPR ]QDOD]HP+RWVSRUQQLHVSXV]F]DRND]*LVHOKHUD$
FR]PRM " 'RWDUDGRFLHELH"
'RWDUD]DM NQ VL KHUV]W6]F]XUyZ$OH1RNUyWNRPyZL F1LHE\R
ZWHG\F]DVX$SRWHP H P\VL SRSLOLLPXVE\VL WURFK Z\ZF]DVRZD$
Sy QLHMLQQDQDPGURJDZ\SDGD
&KROHUQLJyZQLDU]HSRP\ OD+RWVSRUQ
.UyWNRPyZL FQLHZ\NRQDH SROHFHQLD"
$QRQLH:\EDF]+RWVSRUQ1LHE\RMDN$OHQDVW SQ\PUD]HPKRKR
1LH]DZRGQLH
1LH]DZRGQLHSRWZLHUG]L]HPID] .D\OHLJKFKRQLNWQLHSURVLJRE\
SRWZLHUG]D
&KROHUQLQLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQLJyZQLDU]H3RSLOLVL $Sy QLHMLQQDGURJDLP
Z\SDGD'RNUDZFyZSRIU\PX QHFLXV]NLDQLFK\EL
1DSLMHV]VL "
']L NXM QLH
$PR H WHJRVNRV]WXMHV]"*LVHOKHUZVND]DVWRM FHZ UyGJ VLRUNyZL
NXENyZR]GREQHSX]GHUHF]NR]ODNL+RWVSRUQMX ZLHG]LDF]HPXZRF]DFK
6]F]XUyZMDU]\VL WDNG]LZQ\EODVNF]HPXLFKUXFK\E\\WDNQHUZRZHLV]\ENLH
3LHUZV]RU] GQ\SURFK]DSHZQL*LVHOKHU1LHZH PLHV]V]F]\SW\"
']L NXM QLH+RWVSRUQZ\PRZQLHVSRMU]DQDSODP NUZLLQLNQ F\Z
NRPRU]H ODGQDWURFLQDFKZ\UD QLHZVND]XM F\NWyU G\LGRN G SRZOHF]RQR
WUXSD*LVHOKHU]DXZD \VSRMU]HQLH
-HGHQSDFKR]XFKDWXFKFLDRGJU\ZDSDUVNQ $ JR,VNUDVNDUFL
PXVLDD
,VNUD]D PLDDVL JDUGRZR2GUD]XE\RZLGD H MHVWPRFQRSRGQLHFRQD
QDUNRW\NLHP
7DNJRVNDUFLDP H VL NUZL ]DFK\VQ SRFKZDOLDVL $ZWHG\LQQL]
PLHMVFDVSRNRUQLHOL7RVL QD]\ZDWHUURU
%\DMDN]Z\NOHREZLHV]RQDNOHMQRWDPLGLDPHQWRZ\NROF]\NPLDDQDZHWZ
VNU]\GHNXQRVD1LHQRVLDVNyU\OHF]ZL QLRZ\NDIWDQLN]EURNDWRZ\P
Z]RUNLHPMX QDW\OHV\QQ\E\E\RVWDWQLPNU]\NLHPPRG\Z UyG]RWHM
PRG]LH \ ]7KXUQ3RGREQLHMDNMHGZDEQDFKXVWDNWyU RZLMDJRZ *LVHOKHU
1LHUR]V GQLH6]F]XU\5\]\NRZQLHLQLHEH]SLHF]QLH
H MDN"
5\]\NRZQLHLQLHEH]SLHF]QLH
*LDHOKHUZ]UXV]\UDPLRQDPL,VNUDSDUVNQ DLZ\VPDUNDDVL QDSRGRJ
5HHI.D\OHLJKL)DONDSDWU]\OLQDNXSFDWDNMDNJG\E\ZD QLHR]QDMPLLP H
VR FHZSDGRGRU]HF]NLLWU]HEDMHV]\ENRZ\RZL]DQLPMHUDNLRV]F]\SL
+RWVSRUQ]UR]XPLD H ZD QLHRGZRDVL GRUR]V GNXV]DORQ\FKVPDUNDF]\ H
RVWU]HJSU]HGU\]\NLHPLQLHEH]SLHF]H VWZHPSHQ\FKV]DOH F]HMEUDZXU\
IDQIDURQyZNWyU\PSRM FLDWHE\\FDNRZLFLHREFH
3R FLJ]DZDPLLG]LH6]F]XU\
1RLFR]WHJR"
+RWVSRUQZHVWFKQ
'\VNXUVSU]HUZDD0LVWOHNWyUDSRGHV]DGRQLFKQLH]DGDM F VRELHWUXGXE\VL
XEUD3RVWDZLDQRJ QDDZLHLNU F F ELRGUDPL]DGHPRQVWURZDDZV]HPLZREHF
G]LHRPLVWU]D$OPDYHU\S VRZ Uy QD]LHORQHMRG\ FH]GZRPDOLVWNDPL
XV\WXRZDQ QDXG]LHWX SU]\SDFKZLQLH
+D"VS\WDDELRU F VL SRGERNL-HMVL JDM FHQLHPDORNFLEUDQVROHW\
E\VQ \EU\ODQWRZR&RSRZLHFLH"
OLF]QR FLSDUVNQ .D\OHLJKRGJDUQLDM F ZRV\+RWVSRUQ]DXZD \ H
6]F]XUQRVLNROF]\NLZSU]HNXW\FKPD RZLQDFKXV]Q\FK1LHXOHJDR
Z WSOLZR FL H ZNUyWFHWDNLHNROF]\NLE G SRGREQLHMDNQDELMDQDPHWDOHPVNyUD
ZPRG]LHZ UyG]RWHMPRG]LH \ Z7KXUQLZFD\P*HVR
7ZRMDNROHM)DONDSRZLHG]LDD0LVWOH&RND HV]VRELHZ\NX"
)DONDGRWNQ DMHMXGDSRFK\OLDVL L SU]\MU]DDWDWXD RZL=EOLVND0LVWOH
SLHV]F]RWOLZLHSRF]RFKUDDMHMSRSLHODWHZRV\)DOND]DFKLFKRWDDLEH] DGQ\FK
FHUHJLHOL]DF] DVL UR]ELHUD
&KF WDN VDP Uy R]QDMPLD:W\PVDP\PPLHMVFXFRXFLHELH
NRFKDQD
=LPQR'LDEHOQLHFKRGQHWHUD]QRFH$SU]HFLH WRMHV]F]HQDZHWQLHSRWRZD
SD G]LHUQLND2SRZLDGDMGDOHM&LUL
&LULSU]H]FKZLO VLHG]LDDQLHUXFKRPR]DSDWU]RQDZSDOHQLVNR2JLH R \QD
SRGU]XFRQ\PGUHZQLH]DWU]HV]F]D]DKXF]DFLVQ QDRV]SHFRQ WZDU]
G]LHZF]\Q\]RW\EODVNLUXFKOLZHFLHQLH
2SRZLDGDM
ZVNUR :MHFKD\RGIURQWXZ\MHFKD\RGSRGZyU]D
$9DUQKDJHQRZLH]RVWDOL]RWZDUW\PLJ EDPLQDGSRELW\PLNXIODPLLUR]ODQ\P
SLZVNLHP3RZLHV]PR H H WRPDDIDQWD]MD"
1LHSRZLHXSU]HG]LDRGSRZLHG 0LVWOHX PLHFKDM F VL ]R OLZLH1LH
SRZLHERZLHNWR]DF]6]F]XU\-HJRJLOGLDWH WRZLH
0LVWU]$OPDYHUDVNR F]\WDWXRZD&LULSRG]L NRZDD]GXPQ PLQ XEUDD
VL L GRVLDGDGRNRPSDQLL3U\FKQ DF]XM F QDVRELHG]LZQ\WDNVXM F\LMDNE\
NSL F\Z]URN+RWVSRUQD\SQ DQDQLHJR]\PRNLHPPDQLIHVWDF\MQLH
SU]\WXODM F VL GRUDPLHQLD0LVWOH=G \DMX Z\SUDNW\NRZD H WDNLH
PDQLIHVWDFMHSHV] L VNXWHF]QLHFKRG] ]DSD\SDQyZNWyU\PZJRZLHE\\
DPRU\:SU]\SDGNX+RWVSRUQDG]LDDDQLHFRQDZ\URVWERQLE\NXSLHFQLHE\
Z W\PZ]JO G]LHQDWU WQ\
+RWVSRUQE\GOD&LUL]DJDGN :LG]LDDJRSU]HGWHPW\ONRMHGHQMHG\Q\UD]
UHV]W RSRZLHG]LDDMHM0LVWOH+RWVSRUQL*LVHOKHUZ\MD QLD]QDM VL L NXPDM
RGGDZQDPDM XPyZLRQHV\JQD\KDVDLPLHMVFDVSRWND 3RGF]DVW\FKVSRWND
+RWVSRUQGDMHLQIRUPDFMHLZWHG\MHG]LHVL QDZVND]DQ\WUDNWLQDSDGDQD
ZVND]DQHJRNXSFDNRQZyMOXENDUDZDQ 1LHNLHG\]DELMDVL ZVND]DQ RVRE
=DZV]HWH XPDZLDQ\MHVW]QDNQDNXSFyZ]WDNLP]QDNLHPQDZR]DFKQDSDGD
QLHZROQR
&LULSRF] WNRZRE\D]GXPLRQDLOHNNRUR]F]DURZDQDSDWU]\DQD*LVHOKHUDMDN
Z W F] PLDD6]F]XU\]DZ]yUVZRERG\LQLH]DOH QR FLVDPDSRNRFKDDW
VZRERG W SRJDUG GODZV]\VWNLHJRLZV]\VWNLFK$ WXQLHVSRG]LDQLHSU]\V]R
Z\NRQ\ZDURERW QD]DPyZLHQLH-DNQDMHPQ\P]ELURPNWR UR]ND]\ZDLP
NRJREL0DRWHJRNWR NRJR ]DND]\ZDLPELDRQLVXFKDOLVSX FLZV]\
XV]\
&R ]DFR Z]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPLLQGDJRZDQD0LVWOH+RWVSRUQZ\GDMHQDP
UR]ND]\DOHLGDMHLQIRUPDFMHG]L NLNWyU\PSU]H \ZDP\6ZRERGDLSRJDUGD
PDM VZRMHJUDQLFH:NR FX]DZV]HMHVWWDN H MHVWVL F]\LP QDU] G]LHP7DNLH
MHVW \FLH6RNROLF]NR
&LULE\D]G]LZLRQDLUR]F]DURZDQDDOHSU]HV]RMHMV]\ENR8F]\DVL 7DN H
WHJRE\QLHG]LZLVL ]DGX R L]DGX R QLHRF]HNLZDERZWHG\UR]F]DURZDQLH
E\ZDPQLHMGRWNOLZH
-DGURJLH6]F]XU\PyZLW\PF]DVHP+RWVSRUQPLDE\PUHPHGLXPQD
ZV]\VWNLHZDV]HNRSRW\1D1LVVLUyZEDURQyZSUHIHNWyZQD%RQKDUWDQDZHW
7DNWDN%RFKR]DFLVNDVL QDZDV]\FKV]\MDFKDUNDQMDPLDE\PVSRVyEQDWR
E\VL ] S WOLZ\ OL]Q
,VNUDSDUVNQ D5HHI]DUHFKRWD$OH*LVHOKHUXFLV]\LFKJHVWHPSR]ZROL
+RWVSRPRZLNRQW\QXRZD
:LH JRVLSRZLHG]LDSRFKZLOLNXSLHF H ODGDG]LH RJRV]RQDE G]LH
DPQHVWLD-H OLQDZHWQDNLPFL \ NRQGHPQDWDEDMH OLQDZHWQDGNLP VWU\F]HN
ZLVLE G]LHPLDGDURZDQHMH OLW\ONRVL XMDZQLLZ\]QDZLQ\:DVWH WR
GRW\F]\
3LHSU]HQLHNU]\NQ .D\OHLJK]D]DZLRQ\QLHFRERZD QLHZFL JQ E\GR
QRVDV]F]\SW ILVVWHFKX1LOIJDDUG]NDV]WXF]NDIRUWHO1LHQDVVWDU\FKZUyEOyZ
QDWDNLHSOHZ\FKFLHEUD
:\WUZDP\ZWHMDPQHVWLLSU]\]ZRLFLHLJU]HF]QLHWDNMDNR GRZLRVQ\$
ZLRVQ *G\WUDZNDVSRG QLHJXZ\MU]\
6]F]XU\]D PLD\VL FKyUHPFLFKR]RZLHV]F]R2F]\JRU]D\LPMDN
SUDZG]LZ\PV]F]XURPJG\QRF ZFLHPQ\P]DXNXSRGFKRG] GRUDQQHJR
QLH]GROQHJRVL EURQLF]RZLHND
:\SLMP\U]HN*LVHOKHU%RQKDUWRZLQDSRK\EHO=MHG]P\WHM]XS\DSRWHP
VSD:\SRF] ERGRGQLDUXV]\P\
-DVQHSDUVNQ D,VNUD%LHU]FLHSU]\NDG]0LVWOHL)DONLWHMX RGJRG]LQ\Z
y NX
RQDJRVSRGDU]DVWDFMLSRF]WRZHM]DG\JRWDDSU]\VDJDQLH]QRZXV\V] F RG
VWRXFLFK\]\SDVNXGQ\FKLFKRW
-HG P\
%UDZRSDQQR)DONR0 GUDGHF\]MD0yZLHPSDQQDW\OH P GUDFRSL NQD
3U]HVWD W\WXRZDPQLHSDQQ +RWVSRUQ:WZRLFKXVWDFKEU]PLWRMDNR
REUD OLZLHDMDQLHSR]ZDODPVL EH]NDUQLHREUD D
&RW\ONRSDQQDUR]ND H
GRVWU]H RQR
&RWR]DMHGQL"V\NQ D&LULZ\JU]HEXM F VL VSRG+RWVSRPDLZ\WU] VDM F ]
ZRVyZUR]JQLHFLRQHVXURMDGNL
/XG]LHSUHIHNWD"9DPKDJHQRZLH"
=Z\NOLEDQG\FL+RWVSRUQZ\SOXOL FLH*UDVDQFL
=DSURSRQXMLPDPQHVWL ]JU]\WQ DSLDVNLHPZ] EDFK2ELHFDMLP
% G FLFKR8V\V]
+RRRR+RRRRR7XXWDDDDDMGRELHJDR]JyU\=OHZD]DFKRRRRRG =
OHZDDDDD
+RWVSRUQ"
&R"
0DV]NUHZQDSOHFDFK
:LHPRGU]HN]LPQRZ\FL JDM F ]]DSD]XFK\]ZLWHNSyWQDLRGZUDFDM F VL
GRQLHMERNLHP:HSFKQLMPLWRSRGNRV]XO 1DZ\VRNR OHZHMRSDWNL
*G]LHGRVWDH " 1LHZLG] EHWX
7RE\DUEDOHW HOD]Q\VLHNDQLHFQDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHMXFL W\KXIQDO=RVWDZ
QLHGRW\NDM7RMHVWWX SU]\NU JRVXSLH
3VLDNUHZ&RZL F PDP]UREL"
=DFKRZDFLV] :UDFDM
=DRPRWD\NRS\WDNWR SU]HV]\ZDM FRJZL]GQ .WR ZU]HV]F]DQDZR\ZD
UR]ND]\ZDNRPX E\]DZUDFD&LULQDGVWDZLDXV]X
2GMH G DM PUXNQ D=DQLHFKDOLSR FLJX1LH]DSDOLNRQL
7RGREU]H
0\WH LFKQLH]DSLHP\% G]LHV]PyJL "
1LHE G PXVLDX PLHFKQ VL SRND]XM F MHM]DSL W QDSU]HJXELHGR
WDQGHWQLHZ\JO GDM F EUDQVROHWN .XSLHPW E\VNRWN UD]HP]NRQLHP-HVW
PDJLF]QD.ODF]QRVLDM RG UHEDND*G\SRFLHUDPRZWHQVSRVyEWRWDN
MDNE\PM SU]\]\ZD-DNE\V\V]DDPyMJRV3U]\ELHJQLHWX7URFK WRSRWUZD
DOHSU]\ELHJQLH]SHZQR FL 3U]\RGURELQLHV]F] FLDWZRMDGHUHV]NDSU]\ELHJQLH
]DQL
$SU]\RGURELQLHSHFKD"2GMHG]LHV]VDP"
)DONRSRZLHG]LDSRZD QLHM F-DQLHRGMDG VDPMDOLF] QDWZRM SRPRF
0QLHWU]HEDE G]LHSRGWU]\P\ZDZVLRGOH3DOFHXQyJMX PLPDUWZLHM 0RJ
VWUDFLSU]\WRPQR 3RVXFKDMWHQZ Zy]GRSURZDG]LFL GRGROLQ\VWUXPLHQLD
3RMHG]LHV]ZJyU SRGSU GQDSyQRF=DZLH]LHV]PQLHGRPLHMVFRZR FLR
QD]ZLH7WHJDPR7DP]QDMG]LHP\NRJR NWRE G]LHXPLDZ\FL JQ PL HODVWZR
] SOHFyZQLHSU]\SUDZLDM F SU]\W\PR PLHUOXESDUDOL
7RMHVWQDMEOL V]DPLHMVFRZR "
1LH%OL HMMHVW=D]GUR NRWOLQ MDNLH GZDG]LH FLDPLOZVWURQ SU]HFLZQ ]
ELHJLHPVWUXPLHQLD$OHWDPQLHMHG SRG DGQ\PSR]RUHP
'ODF]HJR"
3RG DGQ\PSR]RUHPSRZWyU]\PDUV]F] F WZDU]1LHFKRG]LWXRPQLH
OHF]RFLHELH=D]GUR WRGODFLHELH PLHU
1LHUR]XPLHP
1LHPXVLV]=DXIDMPLSRSURVWX
*LVHOKHURZLSRZLHG]LDH
=DSRPQLMR*LVHOKHU]H-H OLFKFHV] \]DSRPQLMRQLFKZV]\VWNLFK
'ODF]HJR"
=RVWD ]HPQ 'RWU]\PDPRELHWQLF\.UyORZR QLHJX3U]\VWURM FL Z
V]PDUDJG\2EV\SL FL QLPL
=DLVWH ZLHWQDSRUDGR DUWyZ
=DZV]HMHVWSRUDGR DUWyZ
+RWVSRUQREM M QDJOHSU]\FLVQ UDPLHQLHPL]DF]DUR]SLQDMHMEOX]N
%H]FHUHPRQLDOQLHDF]EH]SR SLHFKX&LULRGHSFKQ DU N
=DLVWHZDUNQ D ZLHWQDSRUDLQDWR
1DWRWH ND GDSRUDMHVWGREUD=ZDV]F]DGODPQLHWHUD]0yZLHPFLWR
NU JRVXS-XWURPRJ SRMDZLVL WUXGQR FL&RURELV]"$FKFKROHUD
7\PUD]HPRGHSFKQ DJRPRFQLHM=DPRFQR+RWVSRUQSREODG]DJU\]ZDUJL
]DVW ND]EyOX
3U]HSUDV]DP$OHMH OLNWR MHVWUDQQ\SRZLQLHQOH HVSRNRMQLH
%OLVNR WZHJRFLDDVSUDZLD H ]DSRPLQDPREyOX
3U]HVWD GRFKROHU\
)DONR% G PLDGODF]RZLHNDFLHUSL FHJR
% G]LHV]FLHUSL F\MH OLQLH]DELHU]HV]U NL=DUD]
&LV]HM*UDVDQFLJRWRZLQDVXV\V]H7ZRMDVNyUDMHVWMDNDWDV1LHZLHU
VL XOLFKD
$FKGRGLDEDSRP\ ODD&LULDQLHFKWDP:NR FXMDNLHWRPD]QDF]HQLH"
-HVWHPFLHNDZD:ROQRPLE\FLHNDZ :W\PQLHPD DGQHJRXF]XFLD
3RWUDNWXM JRX \WNRZRLW\OH,EH]SUHWHQVMRQDOQLH]DSRPQ
3RGGDDVL GRW\NRZLLSU]\MHPQR FLMDN SU]\QRVL2GZUyFLDJRZ DOH
X]QDDWR]DSU]HVDGQLHVNURPQHLRV]XND F]RSUXGHU\MQHQLHFKFLDDXFKRG]L]D
XZRG]RQ FQRWN 6SRMU]DDPXSURVWRZRF]\DOHZ\GDRVL MHMWR]E\W PLDHL
Z\]\ZDM FHWDNLHMWDN H QLHFKFLDDXGDZD3U]\PNQ DZL F ]Z\F]DMQLH
SRZLHNLREM DJR]DV]\M L SRPRJDSU]\JX]LNDFKERV]RPXQLHVSRURL
PDUQRZDF]DV
'RGRW\NXSDOFyZGR F]\VL GRW\NZDUJ%\DMX EOLVNDWHJRE\]DSRPQLHR
FD\P ZLHFLHJG\QDJOH+RWVSRUQ]QLHUXFKRPLDZEH]ZDG]LH3U]H]FKZLO
OH DDFLHUSOLZLHSDPL WDD H MHVWUDQQ\L H UDQDPXVLPXGRNXF]D$OHWR
WUZDRWURFK ]E\WGXJR-HJR OLQDVW\JDMHMQDVXWNDFK
+HM+RWVSRUQ" SLV]"
&R SRFLHNRMHMQDSLHU L ERN'RWNQ DSDOFDPL.UHZ
+RWVSRUQ]HSFKQ DJR]VLHELH+RWVSRUQXPDUH "
*XSLHS\WDQLHSRP\ ODD3U]HFLH ZLG] 3U]HFLH ZLG] H XPDU
9\VRJRWDQLHE\WHJRSHZLHQ
-HG\QHFRZWHG\F]XDPGRGDDQDGDORGZUyFRQDWRUR]F]DURZDQLH
6]RNXMHFL WR"
1LH7RDNXUDWQLH
5R]XPLHP6WDUDPVL QLHXEDUZLDRSRZLH FLQLF]HJRQLHSRSUDZLD
1LF]HJRQLH]DWDMD&KRF]DVHPPDPRFKRW ]ZDV]F]DQDWRRVWDWQLH
3RFL JQ DQRVHPSRGXEDDNQ\NFLHPZN FLNXRND
3U]\ZDOLDPJRJD ]LDPLLNDPLHQLDPL%\OHMDNZ\]QDM FLHPQLDR
PXVLDDPWDPSU]HQRFRZD%DQG\FLZFL NU FLOLVL Z RNROLF\V\V]DDPLFK
RNU]\NLLE\DPMX ZL FHMQL SHZQD H WRQLHE\OL]Z\F]DMQLEDQG\FL1LH
ZLHG]LDDPW\ONRQDNRJRSRORZDOLQDPQLHF]\QDQLHJR0XVLDDPMHGQDN
VLHG]LHFLFKR&D QRF'R ZLWX2ERNWUXSD%UUU
2 ZLFLHSRGM DSRFKZLOLSRSR FLJXGDZQRSU]HSDGVXFKDMX PRJDP
Z\UXV]\0LDDPMX ZLHU]FKRZFD0DJLF]QDEUDQVROHWNDNWyU ]GM DP]U NL
+RWVSRUQDIDNW\F]QLHG]LDDD.DUDNODF]ZUyFLD7HUD]QDOH DDGRPQLH7RE\
PyMSUH]HQW-HVWWDNL]Z\F]DMQD:\VSDFK6NHOOLJHZLHV]"']LHZF]\QLHQDOH \
VL NRV]WRZQ\SRGDUHNRGMHMSLHUZV]HJRNRFKDQND&R]WHJR H PyMXPDU
]DQLP]G \QLP]RVWD"
.ODF]XSQ DSU]HGQLPLNRS\WDPLR]LHPL ]DU DDVWDQ DERNLHPMDNE\
ND F VL SRG]LZLD&LULQLHPRJDSRZVWU]\PDZHVWFKQLHQLD]DFKZ\WXQDZLGRN
WHMGHOILQLHMV]\LSURVWHMLVPXNHMDOHPRFQRXPL QLRQHMPDHMNV]WDWQHMJRZ\
R Z\SXN\PF]ROHZ\VRNLHJRN EXEXGRZ\]DFKZ\FDM FHMSURSRUFMRQDOQR FL
=EOL \DVL RVWUR QLHSRND]XM F NODF]\EUDQVROHWN QDQDSL VWNX.ODF]
SU\FKQ DSU]HFL JOHVWXOLDUXFKOLZHXV]\DOHSR]ZROLDFKZ\FL]DNU OHLGDD
VL SRJDVNDSRDNVDPLWQ\PQRVLH
.HOSLHSRZLHG]LDD&LUL-HVWH F]DUQDL]ZLQQDMDNPRUVNDNHOSLH-HVWH
F]DURG]LHMVNDMDNNHOSLH% G]LHV]ZL F QD]\ZDVL .HOSLH,QLHGEDPF]\WR
SUHWHQVMRQDOQHF]\QLH
.ODF]]DSDUVNDDSRVWDZLDXV]\VWU]HSQ DMHGZDELVW\PRJRQHPVL JDM F\P
S FLQ&LULOXEL FDZ\VRNLGRVLDGVNUyFLDU]HPLHQLHSX OLVNREPDFDD
QLHW\SRZHSDVNLHVLRGREH]WHUOLF\LNXOLSU]HGQLHJR NX'RSDVRZDDEXWGR
VWU]HPLHQLDLFKZ\FLDNRQLD]DJU]\Z
6SRNRMQLH.HOSLH
6LRGRZEUHZSR]RURPE\RFDNLHPZ\JRGQH,]RF]\ZLVW\FKZ]JO GyZGX R
O HMV]HRG]Z\N\FKNDZDOHU\MVNLFKNXOEDN
7HUD]SRZLHG]LDD&LULNOHSL F NODF]SRJRU FHMV]\L=REDF]\P\F]\MHVWH
UyZQLHU F]DMDNSL NQD&]\MHVWH SUDZG]LZDG]LDQHWNDF]\W\ONREOHQGHUND&R
SRZLHV]QDGZDG]LH FLDPLOJDORSX.HOSLH"
'ROLQDVWUXPLHQLDE\DUyZQDGRJRGQDGRMD]G\ZL F .HOSLHV]DMDNZLFKHU
2F]\ZL FLHQLHMHFKDDPZJyU DOHZGyU]HF]NL3DPL WDDPW V]F]HJyOQ
QD]Z =D]GUR 3U]\SRPQLDDPVRELHFR+RWVSRUQPyZLQDVWDFMLGR*LVHOKHUD
3RM DPGODF]HJRPQLHRVWU]HJDSU]HGW RVDG :=D]GUR FLPXVLDDE\
]DVDG]ND*G\*LVHOKHU]EDJDWHOL]RZDRIHUW DPQHVWLLLSUDF\GODJLOGLL+RWVSRUQ
FHORZRQDSRPNQ PXRNZDWHUXM F\PZRVDG]LHRZF\QDJUyG:LHG]LD H WDN
SU]\Q W 6]F]XU\SRNQ H SRMDG WDPLZSDGQ Z SRWU]DVN0XVLDDPGRWU]H
SRG=D]GUR SU]HGQLPLSU]HFL LPGURJ XSU]HG]L=DZUyFL:V]\VWNLFK
$OERFKRFLD VDP 0LVWOH
'RP\ ODPVL PUXNQ 9\VRJRWD H FLVL QLHXGDR
:yZF]DVSRZLHG]LDDJXFKRV G]LDP H Z=D]GUR FLF]HNDOLF]Q\L
X]EURMRQ\SR] E\RGG]LD:QDM PLHOV]\FKP\ ODFKPLQLHSRVWDR H WD
]DVDG]NDWRMHGHQF]RZLHN
=DPLOND]DSDWU]RQDZFLHPQR
1LHPLDDPWH SRM FLDMDNLWRF]RZLHN
RGJU\]QDMSLHUZNDZDHNMDMNDSRWHPNDZDHNNURPNL
$JG]LH)DOND"VS\WDQLHZ\UD QLH'URELQNL yWNDVSDG\]PX]Z VyZL
ZDUJ
RZFDXQLyVJRZ
&LULZELHJX]HVNRF]\D]NRQLD]DWRF]\DVL XSDGDQDMHGQRNRODQR
%RQKDUWX PLHFKQ VL
6]F]XU]\FDSRZLHG]LD6LyGPD6]F]XU]\FD'REU]H H MHVWH %UDNRZDR
PLFLHELHGRNRPSOHWX
0LVWOH]QDOD]DPLHF]DOHQLHE\DZVWDQLHJRXQLH =DFKDUF]DDLU]XFLDVL
SRGQRJL%RQKDUWDUR]G\JRWDQ\PLSDOFDPLZSLDVL Z FKROHZ\MHJREXWyZ
2WZRU]\DXVWDE\NU]\NQ ]DPLDVWNU]\NX]XVWZ\UZDDVL O QL FDNDUPLQRZD
VWUXJD%RQKDUWNRSQ M VLOQLH]ZDODM F ZJQyM0LVWOHWU]\PDM F VL REXU F]]D
UR]FL W\EU]XFK]GRDDMHGQDNSRGQLH VL ]QRZX
1LHHHHHHZU]DVQ D&LUL0LLLLLLLVWOH
RZFDQDJUyGQLH]ZUyFLXZDJLQDMHMZU]DVNQDZHWQLHRGZUyFLJRZ\
=DZLQ PLHF]HPLXGHU]\]DPDV]\ FLHMDNNRV SRW Q\PFLRVHPNWyU\
SRGHUZD0LVWOH]]LHPLLFLVQ QL D SRGPXUPL NN MDNV]PDFLDQDODONDMDN
]DEDEUDQ\F]HUZLHQL DFKPDQ
.U]\NVNRQDZJDUGOH&LUL5 FHMHMG\JRWD\JG\VL JDDSRPLHF]
0RUGHUFDSRZLHG]LDDG]LZL F VL REFR FLVZHJRJRVX2EFR FLZDUJNWyUH
QDJOH]UREL\VL SRWZRUQLHVXFKH0RUGHUFD.DQDOLD
%RQKDUWREVHUZRZDM FLHNDZLHSU]HNU]\ZLDM F OHNNRJRZ
% G]LHP\XPLHUD"VS\WD
&LULV]DNXQLHPXRWDF]DM F JRSyNROHP0LHF]ZXQLHVLRQ\FKL
Z\SURVWRZDQ\FKU NDFKSRUXV]DVL P\OL]ZRG]L
RZFDQDJUyG]D PLDVL JURPNR
8PLHUDSRZWyU]\6]F]XU]\FDFKFHXPLHUD2EUDFDVL SRZROLVWRM F Z
PLHMVFXQLHGDM F VL ]ZDELZSXDSN SyNROD$OH&LULE\RZV]\VWNRMHGQR
*RWRZDDVL ] Z FLHNR FLLQLHQDZL FLG\JRWDD] G]\PRUGX&KFLDDGRSD
WHJRVWUDV]QHJRVWDUFDSRF]XMDNNOLQJDZFLQDVL Z FLDR&KFLDDZLG]LHMHJR
NUHZFKOXVWDM F ] SRFL W\FKW WQLFZU\WPLHRVWDWQLFKXGHU]H VHUFD
1R6]F]XU]\FR%RQKDUWSRGQLyVXEURF]RQ\PLHF]LSRSOXQDRVWU]H
=DQLP]GHFKQLHV]SRND FRZWRELHVLHG]L*UDMPX]\NR
9\VRJRWDVLHG]LDQLHUXFKRPR2GGX V]HMFKZLOLWDNVLHG]LD:VWU]\P\ZD
QDZHWRGGHFK&LULNRQW\QXRZDDRSRZLH DMHMJRVURELVL FRUD]EDUG]LHM
JXFK\FRUD]EDUG]LHMQLHQDWXUDOQ\LFRUD]EDUG]LHMQLHSU]\MHPQ\
5R]ND]DW\PFRVL ]ELHJOLE\PXSU]\QLH OLZRUHNVROLLDQWDHNRFWX,SL
1LHZLHG]LDDP1LHPRJDP]UR]XPLHFR]DPLHU]D-HV]F]HZWHG\QLH
ZLHG]LDDPGRF]HJRMHVW]GROQ\-DE\DPSU]\ZL ]DQDGRNRQLRZL ]X
=DZRDMDNLFK SDFKRNyZUR]ND]DLPE\WU]\PDOLPQLH]DZRV\L]DSRZLHNL
3RND]DLPMDN7DN HE\PQLHPRJDRGZUyFLJRZ\DQL]DPNQ RF]X%\P
PXVLDDSDWU]HQDWRFRUREL7U]HED]DGEDE\WRZDUVL QLH]HSVXSRZLHG]LD
%\QLHXOHJUR]NDGRZL
*ORV&LUL]DDPDVL VXFKRXZL ]ZJDUGOH9\VRJRWDZLHG] F QDJOHFR
XV\V]\SRF]XMDN OLQDZ]ELHUDPXZXVWDFKMDNIDODSRZRG]L
2GHU Q LPJRZ\SRZLHG]LDDJXFKR&LUL3L *LVHOKHU.D\OHLJK$VVH
5HHI,VNUD,0LVWOH2GU]\QDLPJRZ\3RNROHL1DPRLFKRF]DFK
5R]G]LD
&] VWRVWDZLDQRPLS\WDQLHMDNWRVL VWDR H ]GHF\GRZDHPVL VSLV\ZDPH
ZVSRPQLHQLD:LHOXOXG]L]GDZDVL LQWHUHVRZDPRPHQWZNWyU\PPHPXDU\
PRMH]DF] W\SRZVWDZDMDNLPLDQRZLFLHIDNWZ\GDU]HQLHF]\WH HZHQHPHQW
SRF] WNRZLVSLV\ZDQLDWRZDU]\V]\OXEGDDVXPSWGRQLHJR3RSU]HGQLRUy Q\FK
XG]LHODHPZ\MD QLH L JDHPQLHU]DGNRWHUD]DWROLSUDZG]LHRGGDPKRG
DOERZLHPG]L JG\PLZRVSRELHODLSU]HU]HG]LW JRZLHP H SUDZGDWRFHQQH
]LDUQRH ]D QLHJRGQHSOHZ\
$SUDZGDMHVWWDNDHZHQHPHQWHPNWyU\ZV]\VWNLHPXGDDVXPSWNWyUHPX
]DZG]L F]DPSLHUZV]H]DSLVNL]MDNLFK]DF] WRVL IRUPRZDSy QLHMV]HG]LHR
PHJR \FLDE\RSU]\SDGNRZH]QDOH]LHQLHSDSLHUXLRyZNDZ UyGU]HF]\NWyUHMDL
PRLNRPSDQLXNUDGOL P\]O\ULMVNLFKZRMVNRZ\FKWDERUyZ=GDU]\RVL WR
-DVNLHU3yZLHNXSRH]ML
NRODERUXM F ] GULDGDPLL6FRLD
WDHO]DPLHV]DQ MDNVL RND]DRZRVDZLRQH
PDVDNU\OXG]LQDUXELH DFK/DVX%URNLORQ'RWHJRGRR \QDOH \ &DKLUDDHS
&HDOODFK1LOIJDDUGF]\NDRE\ZDWHODZURJLHME G FRE G QDFMLNWyUHJRREHFQR
SRQLHZD FLZHMVWURQLHIURQWXQLHDWZRGDRE\VL HNVSOLNRZDLXVSUDZLHGOLZL
7DNVL VNDGDR H MHG\Q\F]RQHNQDV]HMGUX \Q\NWyUHJR \FLRU\VXQLHSDSUD\
VSUDZ\SROLW\F]QHOXENU\PLQDOQHE\ZDPSLUHP7DNLPWRVSRVREHP
]GHPDVNRZDQLHLUR]SR]QDQLHNRJRNROZLHN]QDVJUR]LRZV]\VWNLPSR]RVWD\P
ZELFLHPQD]DRVWU]RQHRVLQRZHNRNL.D G\G]LH VS G]RQ\SRF] WNRZRPLOH
]UHV]W V\WRLEH]SLHF]QLHZFLHQLXO\ULMVNLFKV]WDQGDUyZ]ZL NV]DRZRU\]\NR
*HUDOWJG\PPXRW\PGRELWQLHSU]\SRPQLD]PDUNRFLVL OHNNRDOH
SU]HGVWDZLVZRMHUDFMHNWyU\FKPLDGZLH3RSLHUZV]H0LOYDSRMHMSU]\NU\P
Z\SDGNXZFL Z\PDJDDRSLHNLLVWDUD DZZRMVNXE\OLIHOF]HU]\3RGUXJLH
DUPLDNUyORZHM0HYHNLHURZDDVL QDZVFKyGZNLHUXQNX&DHG'KX$QDV]D
GUX \QD]DQLP]PLHQLDNLHUXQHNLZSDNRZDDVL Z RSLVDQ SRZ\ HMELWZ
UyZQLH ]PLHU]DDGR&DHG'KXRGE\WXM F\FKWDPGUXLGyZPLHOL P\ERZLHP
QDG]LHM ]GRE\MDNLH LQIRUPDFMHPRJ FHSRPyFZSRV]XNLZDQLDFK&LUL=SURVWHM
GURJLNXZ]PLDQNRZDQ\PGUXLGRP]HSFKQ \QDVJUDVXM FHSR$QJUHQLHSRGMD]G\
L VZDZROQHNXS\7HUD]SRGRFKURQ SU]\MD]QHJRO\ULMVNLHJRZRMVNDZDVFHL
SU]\FK\OQR FLNUyORZHM0HYHGURJDGR&DHG'KXVWDDRWZRUHPEDZ\GDZDDVL
SURVWDLEH]SLHF]QD
2VWU]HJDHPZLHG PLQD H W\ONRVL WDNZ\GDMH H WRSR]yUMHQR H DVND
NUyOHZVNDMHVW]XGQDLQDSVWU\PNRQLXMH G]L:LHG PLQVXFKDQLHFKFLD$SR
F]\MHMVWURQLHE\DVXV]QR ZQHWVL SRND]DR*G\RWRJUXFKQ DZLH H RG
ZVFKRGXRGSU]H F]\.ODPDWZGX HMSRW G]HLG]LHQD$QJUHQQLOIJDDUG]ND
NDUQDHNVSHG\FMDZRMVNR/\ULLQLHPLHV]NDM F]DZUyFLRQDSyQRFZVWURQ JyU
0DKDNDPX*HUDOWRZLMDNDWZRVL GRP\ OL]XSHQLHQLHNRQZHQLRZDDWD
]PLDQDNLHUXQNXVSLHV]\RPXVL GRGUXLGyZQLHGR0DKDNDPX1DLZQ\MDN
G]LHFNRSROHFLDGRNUyORZHM0HXH]]DPLDUHPX]\VNDQLD]ZROQLHQLD]DUPLLL
NUyOHZVNLHJRERJRVDZLH VWZDGODMHJRSU\ZDWQ\FKLQWHUHVyZ,ZW\PPRPHQFLH
VNR F]\DVL NUyOHZVNDPLR LSU]\FK\OQR DV]DFXQHNLSRG]LZGODERKDWHUD
%LWZ\R0RVWUR]ZLD\VL MDNWHQG\P5\FHU]RZL*HUDOWRZL]5LYLLFKRGQ\P
DF]WZDUG\PWRQHPSU]\SRPQLDQRRMHJRU\FHUVNLFKRERZL ]NDFKZREHFNRURQ\
:FL VDEXM F 0LOX ZDPSLUD5HJLVDLQL HMSRGSLVDQHJRSROHFRQRZ F]\
GRNROXPQ\FL JQ F\FK]DWDERUDPL]ELHJyZLF\ZLOyZ&DKLUDHS&HDOODFKURV\
PRG]LDQNWyU\] DGQHMVWURQ\QDF\ZLODQLHZ\JO GD]RVWDSU]HSDVDQ\ELDR
E NLWQ V]DUI L ZFLHORQ\GRWDN]ZDQHMZROQHMNRPSDQLLWR]QDF]\RGG]LDXMD]G\
]R RQHJR]SU]HUy QHMPD FLKXOWDMVWZD]ELHUDQHJRSRGURJDFKSU]H]O\ULMVNL
NRUSXV7\PVSRVREHPUR]G]LHORQRQDVLZV]\VWNRZVND]\ZDRQDWR H QDV]D
Z\SUDZD]DNR F]\DVL GHILQLW\ZQLHL]NUHWHVHP
-DNMHGQDNGRP\ ODV]VL GURJLF]\WHOQLNXQLHE\WRZFDOHNRQLHFEDQLHE\
WRQDZHWSRF] WHN0LOYDJG\GRZLHG]LDDVL R UR]ZRMXZ\SDGNyZQDW\FKPLDVW
RJRVLDVL ]GURZ L VSUDZQ LSLHUZV]DGDDKDVRGRUHMWHUDG\&DKLUFLVQ Z
NU]DNLNUyOHZVNLHEDUZ\L]ZLD]ZROQHMNRPSDQLLD*HUDOWZ\PNQ VL ]
OXNVXVRZ\FKQDPLRWyZGRERURZHJRU\FHUVWZD
1LHE G UR]ZRG]LVL QDGV]F]HJyDPLDPRGHVWLDQLHSR]ZDODPLQD
QDGPLHUQHHNVSRQRZDQLHP\FKZDVQ\FKQLHPD\FK]DVXJZRSLV\ZDQ\P
SU]HGVL Z]L FLX
6WZLHUG] IDNWQRF ] SL WHJRQDV]yVW\ZU]H QLDFDDQDV]DGUX \QDFLFKDF]HP
RSX FLDNRUSXVNUyORZHM0HYH3U]HGSR HJQDQLHP]O\ULMVNLPZRMVNLHPQLH
RPLHV]NDOL P\]DRSDWU]\VL REILFLHZFDOHSU]\W\PQLHS\WDM F R]JRG V]HID
VX E NZDWHUPLVWU]RZVNLFK6RZRUDEXQHNNWyUHJRX \D0LOYDXZD DP]D
]E\WGRVDGQH1DOH DDVL QDPZV]DN H MDND JUDW\ILNDFMD]DQDV]XG]LDZ
ZLHNRSRPQHM%LWZLHR0RVW$MH OLQLHJUDW\ILNDFMDWRFKRE\]DGR XF]\QLHQLHL
Z\UyZQDQLHSRQLHVLRQ\FKVWUDW
3RPLMDM F WUDJLF]Q\Z\SDGHN0LOY\QLHOLF] F VNDOHF]H L SRWXF]H *HUDOWDL
&DKLUDZELWZLH]DELWROXERNDOHF]RQRQDPZV]\VWNLHNRQLHSUyF]PHJR
ZLHUQHJR3HJD]DLQDURZLVWHM3RWNLNODF]\ZLHG PLQD:UDPDFKUHNRPSHQVDW\
SREUDOL P\ZL F WU]\SHQRNUZLVWHNDZDOHU\MVNLHZLHU]FKRZFHLMHGQHJR
SRGMH]GND3REUDOL P\WH W\OHUy QHJRHNZLSXQNXLOHQDPZU FHZOD]RJZROL
VSUDZLHGOLZR FLGRGDP H SRRZ SU]\V]RQDPSy QLHMZ\U]XFL-DNU]HND
0LOYDWDNE\ZDJG\NUDGQLHVL SRFLHPNX
1DMZL FHMSR \WHF]Q\FKU]HF]\SREUD]ND]LRQQ\FK]DSDVyZZDPSLU5HJLV
NWyU\SRFLHPNXZLG]LOHSLHMQL ]DGQLD5HJLVGRGDWNRZRREQL \REURQQR
O\ULMVNLHMDUPLLRJUXEHJRP\V]DWHJRPXDNWyUHJRZ\ZLyG]]DJURG\WDN
VSU\WQLH H QLMHGHQ]ZLHU]DNQLH]DSDUVNDDQLQLHWXSQ 2SRZLH FLR
]ZLHU] WDFKZ\F]XZDM F\FKZDPSLU\LUHDJXM F\FKQDLFKZR SDQLF]Q\P
VWUDFKHPQDOH \ ]DWHPZR \PL G]\EDMNLFK\ED H FKRG]LRQLHNWyUH]H
]ZLHU] W LQLHNWyUH]ZDPSLUyZ'RGDP H RZHJRP\V]DWHJRPXDPDP\GRG]L
3RVWUDFLHSRGMH]GNDNWyU\]DJLQ QDPSy QLHMZODVDFK=DU]HF]DVSRV]RQ\
SU]H]ZLONLPXQLHVLHQDV]GRE\WHNDUDF]HMWRFR]QLHJR]RVWDR0XQRVLLPL
'UDDNXO=RVWDWDNQD]ZDQ\SU]H]5HJLVD]DUD]SRNUDG]LH \ LWDNMX ]RVWDR
5HJLVDQDMZ\UD QLHMEDZLWRLPL QLH]DZRGQLHPDM FHMDNLH GRZFLSQH]QDF]HQLH
Z NXOWXU]HLPRZLHZDPSLUyZDOHQDPZ\MD QLWHJRQLH]HFKFLDWZLHUG] F H WR
QLHSU]HWXPDF]DOQDJUDVyZ
:WDNLRWRVSRVyEGUX \QDQDV]D]QRZX]QDOD]DVL QDV]ODNXDGXJDMX
SU]HGWHPOLVWDOXG]LNWyU]\QDVQLHOXELOLZ\GX \DVL MHV]F]HEDUG]LHM*HUDOW]
5LYLLU\FHU]EH]VND]\QL]PD]\SRU]XFLV]HUHJLU\FHUVWZD]DQLPMHV]F]H
SDVRZDQLHSRWZLHUG]RQRSDWHQWHPL]DQLPMHV]F]HQDGZRUQ\KHUROGZ\P\ OLPX
KHUE$&DKLUDHS&HDOODFKZZLHONLPNRQIOLNFLH1LOIJDDUGX]1RUGOLQJDPL]G \
MX ZDOF]\ZREXDUPLDFKL]REX]GH]HUWHURZDZREX]DUDELDM F ]DRF]Q\Z\URN
PLHUFL5HV]WD]QDVZFDOHQLHE\DZOHSV]HMV\WXDFMLZNR FXVWU\F]HNMHVW
VWU\F]NLHPLGUREQDWRQDGHUUy QLFD]DFRVL ZLVL]DXMP F]FLU\FHUVNLHM
GH]HUFM F]\QD]ZDQLHZRMVNRZHJRPXDLPLHQLHP'UDDNXO
1LHFKFL ZL F QLH]G]LZLF]\WHOQLNX H F]\QLOL P\L FLHW\WDQLF]QHZ\VLNLE\
PDNV\PDOQLHSRZL NV]\RGOHJR G]LHO F QDVRGNRUSXVXNUyORZHM0HXH&RVL
Z NRQLDFKJQDOL P\QDSRXGQLHNX-DUXG]H]DPLHU]DM F SU]HSUDZLVL QDOHZ\
EU]HJ:FDOHQLHW\ONRSRWRE\RGJURG]LVL U]HN RGNUyORZHMLMHMSDUW\]DQWyZ
DOHGODWHJR H SXVWNRZLD=DU]HF]DE\\PQLHMJUR QHRGREM WHJRZRMQ $QJUHQX
GRGUXLGyZZ&DHG'KXRZLHOHUR]XPQLHME\RSRGUy RZDOHZ\PDQLHSUDZ\P
EU]HJLHP3DUDGRNVDOQLHDOERZLHPOHZ\EU]HJ-DUXJLWRMX E\RZURJLH
-DVNLHU1LH SLMZVLRGOH
-DQLH SL -DWZyUF]RP\ O
VLHELHZDPSLUDLXF]QLF]N *HUDOWERZLHPFKRZDOF]\]&DKLUHPUDPL Z
UDPL FKRXMHJRERNX]DJO GD PLHUFLZRF]\QDGDOE\ZREHF1LOIJDDUGF]\ND
QLHXIQ\LV\PSDWL JRQLHGDU]\=HVZ\PUHVHQW\PHQWHPVWDUDVL FRSUDZGD
NU\DOH H E\FK\EDMX QDSRP\NDHPRW\PRVREQLNLHPSURVW\PMDNGU]HZFH
G]LG\XGDZDQLHXPLDLDQW\SDWLDZ\D]LDQDND G\PNURNXQLF]\PZ JRU]]
G]LXUDZHJRZL FLHU]D
3U]\F]\QDE\DHZLGHQWQDDE\DQL &LUL
/RVVSUDZL H E\HPQDZ\VSLH7KDQHGGSRGF]DVOLSFRZHJRQRZLXNLHG\WR
GRV]RGRNUZDZHMUR]SUDZ\PL G]\F]DURG]LHMDPLZLHUQ\PLNUyORPD]GUDMFDPL
SRGEXU]RQ\PLSU]H]1LOIJDDUG=GUDMFyZZVSRPRJ\:LHZLyUNLEXQWRZQLF]HHOI\
L&DKLUV\Q&HDOODFKD&DKLUE\QD7KDQHGGSRVWDQRJRWDPZVSHFMDOQHMPLVML
PLDSRMPDLXSURZDG]L&LUL%URQL F VL &LUL]UDQLDJR&DKLUPDQDOHZHM
GRQLEOL]Q QDZLGRNNWyUHM]DZV]HURELPLVL VXFKRZXVWDFK%ROHWRPXVLDR
GLDEHOQLHDGZDSDOFHQDGDOQLH]JLQDM PXVL
$ SRW\PZV]\VWNLPWRP\ P\JRXUDWRZDOLQDG:VW N JG\MHJRZD QL
URGDF\ZLH OLJRZS WDFKQDRNUXWQ ND =DFRS\WDP]DMDNLHSU]HZLQ\FKFLHOL
JRVWUDFL"&]\W\ONR]DSRUD N QD7KDQHGG"&DKLUQLHMHVWJDGDWOLZ\DOHMDXFKR
PDPF]XHQDZHWQDSyVyZND&KRSQLHPDMHV]F]HWU]\G]LHVWNLDZ\JO GD H
E\ZDUPLLQLOIJDDUG]NLHMRILFHUHPZ\VRNLHJRVWRSQLD3RQLHZD M ]\NLHP
ZVSyOQ\PSRVXJXMHVL QLHQDJDQQLHDWRX1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZQLHF] VWHPQLHPDP
H ZLHPZMDNLPURG]DMXZRMVN&DKLUVX \LGODF]HJRWDNV]\ENRDZDQVRZD,
GODF]HJR]OHFDQRPXWDNG]LZQHPLVMH:W\P]DJUDQLF]QH
%RSU]HFLH ZD QLH&DKLUE\W\PNWRMX UD]XVLRZDXSURZDG]L&LUL%OLVNR
F]WHU\ODWDWHPXSRGF]DVU]H]L&LQWU\:yZF]DVSRUD]SLHUZV]\GDRRVRELH]QD
NLHUXM FHORVDPLWHMG]LHZF]\Q\SU]H]QDF]HQLH
3U]\SDGHNVSUDZL H UR]PDZLDHPRW\P]*HUDOWHP%\RWRWU]HFLHJRGQLDSR
SU]HNURF]HQLX-DUXJLG]LHVL GQLSU]HG(NZLQRNFMXPSRGF]DVSU]HSUDZ\SU]H]
ODV\=DU]HF]D5R]PRZDWDFKREDUG]RNUyWNDSHQDE\DQLHSU]\MHPQ\FKL
QLHSRNRM F\FKQXW$QDWZDU]\LZRF]DFKZLHG PLQDMX ZyZF]DVPDORZDDVL
]DSRZLHG RNURSLH VWZDNWyUHHNVSORGRZDRSy QLHMZQRF(NZLQRNFMXPSR
W\PMDNGR F]\DGRQDVMDVQRZRVD$QJRXOHPH
:LHG PLQQLHSDWU]\QD-DVNUD1LHSDWU]\SU]HGVLHELH3DWU]\QDJU]\Z
3RWNL
&DODQWKHSRGM WX SU]HG PLHUFL Z\PRJDQDNLONXU\FHU]DFKSU]\VL J
0LHOLQLHSR]ZROLE\&LULGRVWDDVL Z U FH1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ3RGF]DVXFLHF]NL
W\FKU\FHU]\]DELWRD&LUL]RVWDDVDPDZ UyGWUXSyZLSR RJLZSXDSFH]DXNyZ
SRQ FHJRPLDVWD1LHXV]DE\] \FLHPWRQLHXOHJDNZHVWLL$OHRQM RGQDOD]
2Q&DKLU:\ZLy]M ] F]HOX FLRJQLDL PLHUFL2FDOLM %RKDWHUVNR
6]ODFKHWQLH
-DVNLHUZVWU]\PDQLHFR3HJD]D-HFKDOL]W\X5HJLV0LOYDL&DKLUZ\SU]HG]DOL
LFKRMDNLH ZLHUVWDMDQLDDOHSRHWDQLHFKFLDE\FKRVRZR]WHMUR]PRZ\
GRWDURGRXV]XWRZDU]\V]\
3UREOHPZW\PFL JQ :LHG PLQ H QDV]&DKLUE\V]ODFKHWQ\QDUR]ND]
%\V]ODFKHWQ\MDNNRUPRUDQQLHSRNQ U\E\ERPLDQDJUG\FHSLHU FLRQHN0LD
]DQLH U\E Z G]LRELHGRVZHJRSDQD1LHXGDRPXVL ZL F SDQ]DJQLHZDVL QD
NRUPRUDQD.RUPRUDQMHVWWHUD]ZQLHDVFH&]\GODWHJRV]XNDSU]\MD QLL
WRZDU]\VWZDU\E"-DNP\ OLV]-DVNLHU"
7UXEDGXUSRFK\OLVL Z VLRGOHXQLNDM F QLVNR]ZLVDM FHMJD ]LOLS\*D
PLDDMX ]XSHQLH yWHOL FLH
-HGQDNXUDWRZDMHM \FLHVDPSRZLHG]LDH ']L NLQLHPX&LULXV]D]&LQWU\
FDR
,NU]\F]DDSRQRFDFKZLG] F JRZH QLH
-HGQDNWRRQM XUDWRZD3U]HVWD UR]SDPL W\ZD*HUDOW=DGX R VL
]PLHQLREDFRGQLDVL ]PLHQLDUR]SDPL W\ZDQLHQLHGDQLFRSUyF]]JU\]RW
NWyUHZ\UD QLHFLQLHVX 2QXUDWRZD&LUL)DNWE\MHVWLSR]RVWDQLHIDNWHP
*HUDOWRGHUZDZUHV]FLHZ]URNRGJU]\Z\SRGQLyVJRZ -DVNLHUU]XFLRNLHP
QDMHJRWZDU]LSU GNRXFLHNRF]DPLZERN
)DNW]RVWDQLHIDNWHPSRZWyU]\:LHG PLQ]\PPHWDOLF]Q\PJRVHP2
WDN2QWHQIDNWZ\NU]\F]DPLZWZDU]QD7KDQHGGD]H]JUR]\JRVZL ]PXZ
JDUGOHERSDWU]\QDNOLQJ PRMHJRPLHF]D7HQIDNWLWHQNU]\NWRPLD\E\
DUJXPHQW\E\PJRQLHPRUGRZD&y VWDRVL L FK\EDVL QLHRGVWDQLH$V]NRGD
%RQDOH DRMX ZWHG\QD7KDQHGGUR]SRF] D FXFK'XJLD FXFK PLHUFL
D FXFK]HPVW\RNWyUHMMHV]F]HSRXS\ZLHVWXODWNU \\E\RSRZLH FL7DNLH
NWyU\FKEDQRE\VL VXFKDSR]PURNX5R]XPLHV]WR-DVNLHU"
1LHEDUG]R
7RGRGLDED]WRE
3DVNXGQDE\DWRUR]PRZDLSDVNXGQ :LHG PLQPLDZWHG\J E 2MQLH
SRGREDRPLVL JG\SRSDGDZWDNLQDVWUyML]DF]\QD]WDNLHMEHF]NL
3U]\]QDMHGQDNPXV]H H REUD]RZHSRUyZQDQLH]NRUPRUDQHPVZ UROH
VSHQLR]DF] HPVL QLHSRNRL5\EDZG]LRELHQLHVLRQDWDPJG]LHM RJXV]
Z\SDWURV] L XVPD 6\PSDW\F]QDSUDZG]LZLHDQDORJLDUDGRVQHSHUVSHNW\Z\
5R]V GHNSU]HF]\MHGQDNWDNLPREDZRP:NR FXMH OLGDOHMWU]\PDVL
U\EQ\FKPHWDIRUWRNLPP\E\OL P\"
3RWNDPLPD\PLR FLVW\PLSRWNDPL:]DPLDQ]DWDNOLFK ]GRE\F]NRUPRUDQ
&DKLUQLHPyJOLF]\QDFHVDUVN DVN 6DP]UHV]W SHZQLHWH ZFDOHQLHE\D
WDNLPV]F]XSDNLHP]DMDNLHJRFKFLDXFKRG]L%\SRWN WDNMDNLP\:
F]DVDFKJG\ZRMQDRUDDQLF]\P HOD]QDEURQDWDN]LHPL MDNLOXG]NLHORV\NWRZ
RJyOH]ZUDFDXZDJ QDSRWNL"
*RZ GDP H Z1LOIJDDUG]LHQLNWMX R &DKLU]HQLHSDPL WD
9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[V]HIQLOIJDDUG]NLHJRZ\ZLDGXZRMVNRZHJR]RSXV]F]RQ
JRZ Z\VXFKLZDFHVDUVNLHMUHSU\PHQG\
7DNZL F FL JQ ]MDGOLZLH(PK\UYDU(PUHLV,QVW\WXFMDNWyUDSRFKDQLD
WU]\NURW\OHEXG HWXSD VWZDFRV]NROQLFWZRNXOWXUDLV]WXNDUD]HPZ]L WHQLH
MHVWZVWDQLHRGQDOH MHGQHJRF]RZLHND&]RZLHNRW]QLNDVRELHSRSURVWX
XNU\ZDVL FKRFLD MDZ\GDM EDMR VNLHVXP\QDLQVW\WXFM SU]HGNWyU QLFQLHPD
Z FLHN\JQLHZWZDU]LPSHUDWRUDWRZV]\VWNRPR H E\GH]LQIRUPDFMD%\
]RK\G]LF]DURG]LHMD7RSRGREQHGR'LMNVWU\
0DFLH]QDOH 9LOJHIRUW]DLRGHEUDPX&LUL'RFKROHU\FL NLHM1LH
G\ZDJRZDLVQXSU]\SXV]F]HQLD*G]LHMHVW3XV]F]\N"1DGDOZ*HVR"3U]HFLH
SRGREQRRGZUyFLMX WDPND G\NDPLH L ]DMU]DGRND GHMG]LXU\Z]LHPL"
3U]HFLH SRGREQRG]LHZF]\Q\WDPQLHPDLQLHE\R"3U]HFLH DVWURORJVL SRP\OL
DOERNDPLH"7RZV]\VWNRV F\WDW\]MHJRUDSRUWyZ&RRQZL F WDPMHV]F]HUREL"
.RURQHU6NHOOHQR PLHO VL ]DXZD \SRGHMPXMHG]LDDQLDQLH]E\WMDVQH
6ZyMRGG]LDWHQNWyU\:DV]D:\VRNR UR]ND]DDPX]RUJDQL]RZDZHUEXMHGR
0DHFKWGRIRUWX5RFD\QHJG]LH]DR \ED] 2GG]LDWHQSR]ZRO VRELHGRGD
WRZLHOFHSRGHMU]DQD]JUDMD=D QDGHUMX G]LZQ\PMHVW H SRGNRQLHFVLHUSQLD
SDQ6NHOOHQZ\QDM RVDZLRQHJRQDMHPQHJRPRUGHUF
&R"
:\QDM QDMHPQHJR]ELUD]SROHFHQLHP]OLNZLGRZDQLDJUDVXM FHMSR*HVR
EDQG\FNLHMV]DMNL5]HF]VDPDZVRELHFKZDOHEQDDOHF]\WRMHVW]DGDQLH
FHVDUVNLHJRNRURQHUD"
&]\SU]H]FLHELHQLHSU]HPDZLDSU]\SDGNLHPLQZLGLD9DWWLHU",F]\WRQLHRQD
GRGDMHWZRLPGRQLHVLHQLRPNRORUXLIHUZRUX"
6WZLHUG]DPMHG\QLHIDNW\:DV]D:\VRNR
)DNW\FHVDU]ZVWDJZDWRZQLHWRMDFKF ZLG]LH=QXG]LRPLVL MX
VXFKDRQLFK
]JDGQLHV] H WRLOX]MD
9DWWLHUVFKRZDV]W\OHW:FDOHQLH]JDG H WRLOX]MDDOHWHUD]MX ZLHG]LD
=E\WZLHONLPMHVWH WFKyU]HP5LHQFHSRZLHG]LDE\SRND]DVL WXZDVQ
UHDOQ RVRE :LHV]ZV]DN HFRE\FL ZyZF]DVVSRWNDR
&HVDU]QDGDOWDNLQDPQLH]DZ]L W\",QDPRMHJRPLVWU]D9LOJHIRUW]D"
7ZRMDEH]F]HOQR MHVWUR]EUDMDM FD
'RGLDED9DWWLHU=DSHZQLDP H QDGDOVWRLP\SRZDV]HMVWURQLHMDL
9LOJHIRUW]1RSU]\]QDM RV]XNDOL P\ZDVGDM F IDV]\Z &LULOO DOHWRZGREUHM
ZLHU]HE\RZGREUHMZLHU]HQLHFKPQLHXWRSL MH OL 9LOJHIRUW]]DNDGD H
VNRURSUDZG]LZDSU]HSDGDOHSV]DE G]LHIDV]\ZDDQL HOL DGQD6 G]LOL P\ H
MHVWZDPZV]\VWNRMHGQR
7ZRMDEH]F]HOQR SU]HVWDDUR]EUDMD]DF] D]QLHZD D1LHPDP]DPLDUX
WUDFLF]DVXQDUR]KRZRU\]H]QLHZD DM F\PPQLHPLUD HP.LHG\ZUHV]FLH
GRSDGQ FL Z SUDZG]LZHMSRVWDFLSRNRQZHUVXMHP\LWRGXJRSU]\U]HNDP'R
WHM]D SRU\$SDJH5LHQFH
1LHSR]QDM FL 9DWWLHU'DZQLHMFKRE\QDZHWVDPGLDEHFLVL REMDZL
SU]HGHJ]RUF\]PHPQLHRPLHV]NDE\ ]EDGDF]\QLHGDVL ] WHJRSU]\SDGNLHP
F]HJR X]\VND
9DWWLHUQLH]DV]F]\FLLOX]MLVSRMU]HQLHPPLDVWWHJRREVHUZRZDREURVHJR
JORQDPLNDUSLDOHQLZLHP F FHJRPXZVWDZLH
8]\VND"SRZWyU]\ZUHV]FLHZ\G\PDM F SRJDUGOLZLHZDUJL2GFLHELH"$
Fy W\PyJE\ PLGD"0R H SUDZG]LZ &LULOO " 0R H WZRMHJRSDWURQD
9LOJHIRUW]D"0R H &DKLUDDHS&HDOODFK"
6WRSLOX]MD5LHQFH
DXQLRVDLOX]RU\F]Q U N :\PLHQLH
&RZ\PLHQLHP"
&DKLU'RVWDUF]\P\ZDPJRZ &DKLUD-DLPyMPLVWU]9LOJHIRUW]
=OLWXMVL 5LHQFHSDUVNQ 9DWWLHU2GZUy H NROHMQR
-DNFKFHV]9LOJHIRUW]]PRM VNURPQ SRPRF GDZDPJRZ &DKLUDV\QD
&HDOODFKD:LHP\JG]LHRQMHVWPR HP\JRZ\M MDNUDND]VDNDSRGXJZROL
$ WDNLHPDFLHPR OLZR FLSURV] SURV] $ WDNGREUHZW\F]NLZZRMVNX
NUyORZHM0HYH"
3UyEXMHV]PQLH"Z\NU]\ZLVL 5LHQFH&]\QDSUDZG QLHZLHV]"&K\EDWR
GUXJLH&DKLUPyMGURJLZLFHKUDELRMHVW0\ZLHP\JG]LHMHVW:LHP\GRN G
]PLHU]DZLHP\ZMDNLHMNRPSDQLL&KFHV]MHJRJRZ\"'RVWDQLHV]M
*RZ X PLHFKQ VL 9DWWLHUNWyUDQLHE G]LHPRJDRSRZLHG]LHFR
QDSUDZG Z\GDU]\RVL QD7KDQHGG
&K\EDWDNE G]LHOHSLHMU]HNF\QLF]QLH5LHQFH3RFRGDZD&DKLURZL
PR QR PyZLHQLD"1DV]\P]DGDQLHPMHVW]DDJRG]LDQLHSRJ ELDQLPR]MH
PL G]\9LOJHIRUW]HPDFHVDU]HP'RVWDUF] FLPLOF] F JRZ &DKLUDDHS
&HDOODFK=DDWZLP\WRWDN H E G]LHWRZ\JO GDRQDWZRM LZ\ F]QLHWZRM
]DVXJ 'RVWDZDZFL JXQDMEOL V]\FKWU]HFKW\JRGQL
3UDVWDUHNDUSLVNRZVWDZLHZDFKORZDRZRG SHWZDPLSLHUVLRZ\PL%HVWLD
SRP\ OD9DWWLHUPXVLE\EDUG]RP GUD7\ONRFRPXSRWHMP GUR FL":FL WHQ
VDPPXLWHVDPHQHQXIDU\
7ZRMDFHQD5LHQFH"
'URELD]J*G]LHMHVWLFRNQXMH6WHIDQ6NHOOHQ"
3RZLHG]LDHPPXFRFKFLDZLHG]LH9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[Z\FL JQ VL QD
SRGXV]NDFKEDZL F VL SXNOHP]RW\FKZRVyZ&DUWKLLYDQ&DQWHQ:LG]LV]
PRMDVRGNDGRSHZQ\FKVSUDZWU]HEDSRGFKRG]LP GU]H$P GU]HWR]QDF]\
NRQIRUPLVW\F]QLH-H OLE G]LHVL SRVW SRZDLQDF]HMQLHE G]LHVL PLDRQLF
7\ONR]JQL ZRG L PLHUG] F\PXZEDVHQLH,FR]WHJR H EDVHQ]PDUPXUXL
H WU]\NURNLRGSDDFX"&]\ QLHPDPUDFMLPRMDVRGND"
&DUWKLDYDQ&DQWHQSLHV]F]RWOLZLH]ZDQD&DQWDUHOO QLHRGSRZLHG]LDD9DWWLHU
ZFDOHQLHRF]HNLZDRGSRZLHG]L']LHZF]\QDPLDDRVLHPQD FLHODWLRJO GQLH
PyZL F QLHE\DJHQLXV]HP-HM]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDSU]\QDMPQLHMREHFQLH
VSURZDG]D\VL GRXSUDZLDQLDPLR FL]SU]\QDMPQLHMREHFQLH9DWWLHUHP
&DQWDUHOO E\DZVSUDZDFKVHNVXQDWXUDOQ\PWDOHQWHP F] F\P]DSDL
]DDQJD RZDQLH]WHFKQLN L DUW\]PHP1LHWRE\RMHGQDNQDMZD QLHMV]H
&DQWDUHOODPyZLDPDRLU]DGNR ZLHWQLHLFK WQLHQDWRPLDVWVXFKDD3U]\
&DQWDUHOOLPR QDE\RZ\JDGDVL RGSRF] RGSU \VL GXFKRZRL
]UHJHQHURZDSV\FKLF]QLH
&]RZLHNZWHMVX ELHPR H GRF]HNDVL W\ONRUHSU\PHQGSRZLHG]LD]
JRU\F] 9DWWLHU%RQLHRGQDOD]MDNLHM WDP&LULOOL$WR H G]L NLSUDF\PRLFK
OXG]LDUPLDRGQRVLVXNFHV\WRPDR"$WR H V]WDEJHQHUDOQ\]QDND GHSRVXQL FLH
ZURJDWRQLF"$PDRWRWZLHUG]NWyUHWU]HEDE\]GRE\ZDW\JRGQLDPLRWZDUOL
FHVDUVNLPZRMVNRPPRLDJHQFL"$OHQLH]DWRQLNWQLHSRFKZDOL:D QDMHVWW\ONR
MDND WDP&LULOOD
6DSL F JQLHZQLH9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[Z]L ]U N &DQWDUHOOLNLHOLFKQDSHQLRQ\
]QDNRPLW\P(VW(VW]7RXVVDLQWZLQHPRURF]QLNXSDPL WDM F\PF]DV\JG\
FHVDU](PK\UYDU(PUHLVE\WPD\PZ\]XW\P]SUDZGRWURQXLRNUXWQLH
VNU]\ZG]RQ\PFKRSFHPD9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[PRG\PLPDROLF] F\PVL Z
KLHUDUFKLLRILFHUHPZ\ZLDGX
7RE\GREU\URF]QLN'ODZLQ
9DWWLHUSRSLMDEDZLVL NV]WDWQ\PLSLHUVLDPL&DQWDUHOOLLRSRZLDGD&DQWDUHOOD
ZVSDQLDOHVXFKDD
6WHIDQ6NHOOHQPRMDVRGNDPUXF]DV]HIFHVDUVNLHJRZ\ZLDGXWR
NRPELQDWRULVSLVNRZLHF$OHMDE G ZLHG]LDFRRQNRPELQXMH]DQLPMHV]F]H
GRWU]HWDP5LHQFH-DMX PDPWDPF]RZLHND%DUG]REOLVNR6NHOOHQD%DUG]R
EOLVNR
&DQWDUHOODUR]ZL ]DDV]DUI VSLQDM F V]ODIURN9DWWLHUDSRFK\OLDVL 9DWWLHU
SRF]XMHMRGGHFKLM NQ ZSU]HZLG\ZDQLXUR]NRV]\7DOHQWSRP\ OD$SRWHP
PL NNLHLJRU FHGRWNQL FLHDNVDPLWQ\FKZDUJZ\S G]LRPX]JRZ\ZV]HONLH
P\ OL
&DUWKLDYDQ&DQWHQSRZROL]U F]QLHL]WDOHQWHPGRVWDUF]DDUR]NRV]\
9DWWLHURZLGH5LGHDX[V]HIRZLFHVDUVNLHJRZ\ZLDGX1LHE\WRZV]HODNRMHG\Q\
WDOHQW&DUWKLL$OH9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[QLHPLDRW\PSRM FLD
1LHZLHG]LD H ZEUHZSR]RURP&DUWKLDYDQ&DQWHQG\VSRQRZDDGRVNRQD
SDPL FL L LQWHOLJHQFM \Z MDNUW
:V]\VWNRRF]\PRSRZLDGDMHM9DWWLHUND G LQIRUPDFM ND GHVRZRNWyUH
SU]\QLHMXURQL&DUWKLDMX QD]DMXWU]SU]HND]\ZDDF]DURG]LHMFH$VVLUHYDU
$QDKLG
, WRWDOQLHZ\SUDQ\]SRF]XFLDKXPRUX
&LHPQRZRVDFyUNDEDUWQLNDRGU]XFLDQDSOHF\]DZDG]DM F\MHMZDUNRF]
ZUyFLDGRZ FLHNOHHQHUJLF]QHJRREUDFDQLD DUHQ:\VLNL-DVNUDSR]RVWDZD\
GDUHPQHVRZDSRHW\]GDZD\VL Z RJyOHQLHWUDILDGRDGUHVDWNL-DVNLHU
PUXJQ GRUHV]W\NRPSDQLLXGD H Z]G\FKDLZ]QRVLRF]\NXSRZDOH$OHQLH
UH]\JQRZD
'DMSRZWyU]\V]F]HU] F ] E\'DMDMDSREUXV] DW\VNRF]GRSLZQLF\SR
SLZR3U]HFLH PXVLWXJG]LH E\XNU\W\ORV]HNDZORV]NXDQWDHN0DPUDFM
OLF]QRWNR"
'DOLE\ FLHVSRNyMG]LHZFHSDQLHSRZLHG]LDDJQLHZQLHEDUWQLNRZD
NU] WDM FDVL SU]\NXFKQLZ\VRNDLV]F]XSDNRELHWD]DVNDNXM FHMXURG\
3U]HFLHPMX ZDPSRZLDGDD H QLHPDWXXQDVQLMDNLHJRSLZD
=WX]LQUD]\ZDPWRE\RPyZLRQHSDQLHSRSDU RQ EDUWQLNSU]HU\ZDM F
UR]PRZ ] ZLHG PLQHPLZDPSLUHP1DJRWRZLPZDPQDOH QLNyZ]PLRGHP
WHJG\SRMHFLH$OHZSU]yGQLHFK H G]LHZF]\QDZVSRNRMX]LDUQRQDP N ]PLHOH
ZV]DNEH]P NLLF]DURG]LHMQDOH QLNDQLHXF]\QL1LHFKDMFLHMHMQLHFK H EUXVLZ
SRNRMX
6\V]DH -DVNLHU"]DZRD:LHG PLQ2GF]HSVL RGG]LHZF]\Q\L]DMPLM
F]\P SR \WHF]Q\P$OERPHPXDU\SLV]
3LPLVL FKFH1DSLE\PVL F]HJR SU]HGMHG]HQLHP0DPWURFK ]Ly
SU]\U] G] VRELHQDSDU%DENR]QDMG]LHVL WXZFKDFLHXNURS"8NURSS\WDP
]QDMG]LHVL "
6LHG] FDQDSU]\SLHFNXVWDUXV]NDPDWNDEDUWQLNDSRGQLRVDJRZ ]QDG
FHURZDQHMVNDUSHW\
=QDMG]LHJR EHF]NX]QDMG]LH]DPDPODD,QR H Z\VWXG]RQ\
-DVNLHUM NQ ]UH]\JQRZDQ\GRVLDGVL GRVWRXJG]LHNRPSDQLDJDZ G]LD]
EDUWQLNLHPZF]HVQ\PUDQNLHPQDSRWNDQ\PZERUX%DUWQLNE\QLVNLNU S\
F]DUQ\LSRWZRUQLH]DUR QL W\QLHG]LZRWDZL F H Z\DQLDM F VL QLHVSRG]LDQLH]
NQLHLQDS G]LGUX \QLHVWUDFKD]RVWDZ]L W\]DO\NDQWURSD HE\E\R PLHV]QLHM
W\PNWyU\SLHUZV]\]DZU]DVQ :LONRDNZLONRDNE\ZDPSLU5HJLV
3RZVWDRWURFK ]DPLHV]DQLDDOHVSUDZDU\FKRVL Z\MD QLDDEDUWQLNFKR]
SR]RUXJEXURZDW\RND]DVL JR FLQQ\LXSU]HMP\'UX \QDEH]FHUHJLHOLSU]\M D
]DSURV]HQLHGRMHJRVDG\E\6DG\ED]ZDQDZEDUWQLF]\P DUJRQLHVWDQHPVWDD
QDZ\NDUF]RZDQHMSRODQLHEDUWQLNPLHV]NDZQLHM]PDWN RQ L FyUN 'ZLH
RVWDWQLHE\\NRELHWDPLRQLHSU]HFL WQHMDF]G]LZQHMQLHFRXURG]LHHZLGHQWQLH
ZVND]XM FHM H Z UyGSU]RGNyZE\DGULDGDDOERKDPDGULDGD
3RGF]DVUR]PyZMDNLHVL Z\ZL ]D\EDUWQLN]UD]XVSUDZLDZUD HQLH H
PR QD]QLPSRJDGDZ\ F]QLHRSV]F]RDFKEDUFLDFKG]LHQLDFKOH]LZDFK
SRGNXUDFKZRVNDFKPLRGDFKLPLRGREUDQLDFKDOHLWRE\MHG\QLHSR]yU
:SROLW\FH"$FRPDZQLHME\"7RFR]Z\NOH'DQLQ\FRUD]ZL NV]HWU]D
RGGDZD7U]\XUQ\PLRGXDFD\ZU E ZRVNX/HGZRG\FKDPE\QDVWDUF]\RG
ZLWXGR]PLHU]FKXQDOH]LZLHVLHG] EDUFLHSRGUQLHWDP.RPXGD SDF " $
WHPXNWRZRDVN G PQLHZLHG]LHSU]\NLPQ\QLHZDG]D"2VWDWQLPLF]DV\WHQ
WHJRZQLOIJDDUG]NLHMPRZLHZRDM 3RQRP\WHUDLPS\ULDOQDSUHZHQFMDF]\
MDNR WDN=DPLyGMH OLFRSU]HGDPSDF LPS\ULDOQ\PSLHQL G]HPQDNWyU\P
F\VRU]MHVWZ\ELW\=J E\WDNLZL FHMQDGREQ\FKRVXURZ\]UD]XSR]QDV]7HQ
WHJR
2EDSV\F]DUQ\LUXG\XVLDG\QDSU]HFLZZDPSLUD]DGDU\JRZ\L]DF] \
Z\%DUWQLNRZDKDPDGULDGDRGZUyFLDVL RGSDOHQLVNDL]G]LHOLDMHPLRW
=\]QDNRU]HNEDUWQLNNLHG\SVLZ URGNXGQLDZ\M 7HQWHJR2F]\PWR
MDPLDJDGD"
2GUXLGDFK]&DHG'KX
+ 7DNWRQLHE\OLV]XWNLMD QLHSDQ\":\SUDZLHFKFHFLHGRGUXLGyZL "
\ZRWZDPREU]\GF]\OLMDN"7RWDP PLHU-HPLRODU]HND GHJRNWRVL QDLFK
SRODQ\ZHM SRZD \DSL ZHZLNOLQRZHSDXE\ZVDG]DM L QDZROQ\PRJQLX
SDO
*HUDOWVSRMU]DQD5HJLVD5HJLVPUXJQ GRQLHJR2EDMGRVNRQDOH]QDOLNU FH
R GUXLGDFKSORWNLFRGRMHGQHM]P\ ORQH0LOYDL-DVNLHU]DF] OLQDWRPLDVWVXFKD
] ZL NV]\PQL GRW\FKF]DV]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHP,Z\UD Q\P]DQLHSRNRMHQLHP
-HGQLPyZL NRQW\QXRZDEDUWQLN H -HPLRODU]HPV]F] VL ERLP
1LOIJDDUGF]\NLSLHUZV]HGRNXF]\\ZV]HGV]\QD ZL WHG EURZ\SU]H]'RO$QJUD
L ]DF] ZV]\GUXLGyZELEH]GDQLDUDFML:WyU]\]D SRZLDGDM H WRGUXLG]L
]DF] OLFDSQ ZV]\LQD PLHUXP F]\ZV]\SDUXF\VDUVNLFKWHG\LP1LOIJDDUG
RGSDFD-DNRQRSRSUDZG]LHMHVWQLHZLHG]LH$OHU]HF]WRSHZQDGUXLG]LDSL
ZH:LNOLQRZ %DE NDG L SDO , PL G]\QLFKSHZQD]JXED
0\VL QLHERLP\U]HNVSRNRMQLH*HUDOW
3HZQLHEDUWQLN]PLHU]\Z]URNLHPZLHG PLQD0LOY L &DKLUDNWyU\ZD QLH
ZFKRG]LGRFKDXS\RSRU] G]LZV]\NRQLH:LGD H FLHQLHO NOLZHOXG]LHELWQH
D ]EURMQH+ ]WDNLPLMDNZ\QLHVWUDFKSRGUy RZD7HQWHJR$OHQLHPDV]
MX MHPLRODU]\Z&]DUQ\P*DMXSUy Q\WHG\ZDV]WUXGLZDV]DGURJD3U]\FLVQ
LFK1LOIJDDUGZ\ HQ ]&DHG'KX1LHPDV]LFKWDPMX
-DNWR"
7DNWR8FLHNOL-HPLRODU]HSUHF]
'RN G"
%DUWQLNSRSDWU]\QDVZ KDPDGULDG PLOF]DFKZLO
'RN G"SRZWyU]\:LHG PLQ3U JRZDW\NRWEDUWQLNDXVLDGSU]HGZDPSLUHP
L SU]HUD OLZLH]DPLDXF]D+DPDGULDGD]G]LHOLDJRPLRW
=\]QDNJG\NRFXUZ URGNXGQLDPLDXF]\Z\E NDEDUWQLNG]LZQLH
]PLHV]DQ\$GUXLG]L7HQWHJR8FLHNOLQD6WRNL7DN'REU]HPyZL 1D
6WRNL
'REUHV]H G]LHVL W PLOQDSRXGQLHRFHQL-DVNLHUGR VZRERGQ\PDQDZHW
ZHVR\PJRVHP$OH]DPLONQDW\FKPLDVWSRGVSRMU]HQLHPZLHG PLQD
:FLV]\NWyUD]DSDGDV\FKDE\RMHG\QLH]RZUy FHPLDXF]HQLH
Z\S G]RQHJRQDGZyUNRWD
:]DVDG]LHRGH]ZDVL ZDPSLUWRFRQDP]DUy QLFD"
5DQHNGQLDQDVW SQHJRSU]\QLyVGDOV]HQLHVSRG]LDQNL,]DJDGNLNWyUHMHGQDN
EDUG]RV]\ENR]QDOD]\UR]ZL ]DQLH
1LHFKPQLH]DUD]DSRZLHG]LDD0LOYDNWyUDSLHUZV]DZ\JUDPROLDVL ]
EURJXUR]EXG]RQDUR]JDUGLDV]HP
1LHFKPQLHSRNU FL3RSDWU]QRQDWR*HUDOW
3RODQDSHQDE\DQDURGX1DSLHUZV]\U]XWRNDZLGDE\R H ]HEUDRVL WX]
SL DOERV]H EDUWQLF]\FKVWDQyZ:SUDZQHRNRZLHG PLQDZ\RZLRWH ] WXPX
NLONXWUDSHUyZLFRQDMPQLHMMHGQHJRVPRODU]D F]QLHJURPDG QDOH DRRFHQL
QDMDNLFK GZXQDVWXFKRSDG]LHVL EDEG]LHVL FLRURZ\URVWNyZSFLRERMJDL
W\OH PDROHWQLFKG]LHFL1DZ\SRVD HQLXJURPDGDPLDDV]H ZR]yZGZDQD FLH
ZRyZG]LHVL NUyZLF]WHU\NR]\VSRURRZLHFDWDN H QLHPDRSVyZLNRWyZ
NWyU\FKV]F]HNLLPLDXNLQDOH DRZW\FKZDUXQNDFKEH]Z]JO GQLHX]QD]D
QLHGREU\RPHQ
&LHNDZ\PSU]HWDURF]\&DKLUFRWRPR H R]QDF]D"
.RSRW\U]HN-DVNLHUZ\WU]HSXM F VLDQR]ZRVyZ
5HJLVPLOF]DDOHPLQ PLDG]LZQ
3URVLP\ QLDGDZLHOPR QHSD VWZRSRZLHG]LDLFK]QDMRP\EDUWQLN
SRGFKRG] F GREURJXZWRZDU]\VWZLHEDUF]\VWHJRP F]\]Q\*RWRZHMX
QLDGDQLH2ZVLDQNDQDPOHNX,PLyG$WRSR]ZyOFLHSU]HGVWDZL-DQ&URQLQ
VWDURVWDQDV]EDUWQ\
0LRPLVNDPD:LHG PLQQLHRGSRZLDGDM F QDXNRQWDN H GODWHJR H
NRODQRERODRJRZ FLHNOH$WDJURPDGDWRVN G VL WXZ]L D"
7HQWHJREDUWQLNSRGUDSDVL Z FLHPL :LG]LFLH]LPDLG]LH%DUFLHMX
SRD ELRQH]DG]LDWNLSRF]\QLRQH&]DVMX QDPZUDFDQD6WRNLGR5LHGEUXQH
0LyGRGVWDZLSU]H]LPRZD$OHZODVDFKQLHEH]SLHF]QLH6DPHPX
6WDURVWDEDUWQ\]DFKU] ND%DUWQLNVSRMU]DQDPLQ *HUDOWDLMDNE\OHNNRVL
VNXUF]\
:\ FLHNRQQLL]EURMQLZ\VW ND%LWQLD PLDOL]UD]XSR]QD=WDNLPLMDN
Z\Z GURZDQLHVWUDFK$LZDPZ\JRGDE G]LH0\ND G FLH N ND G\
GXNWND G\JU G LF]DKDU]QDP\,NDUPLZDVE G]LHP\
$GUXLG]LSRZLHG]LD]LPQR&DKLUZ\Z GURZDOL]&DHG'KX:D QLHQD
6WRNL&y ]DQLHE\ZD\]ELHJWUDIyZ
*HUDOWSRZROLSRGV]HGGREDUWQLND2EXU F]XM JR]DNDEDWQDSLHUVL$OHSR
FKZLOLUR]P\ OLVL SX FLZ\JDG]LRG]LHQLH1LFQLHSRZLHG]LD2QLFQLH
]DS\WD$OHEDUWQLNLWDNSRVSLHV]\]Z\MD QLHQLDPL
3UDZG JDGDHP3U]\VL JDP1LHFKVL SRG]LHPL ]DSDGQ MH OLP]HJD
8V]OLMHPLRODU]H]&DHG'KX1LHPDV]LFKWDP
,V QD6WRNDFKWDN"]DZDUF]D*HUDOW7DPGRN G ZDPGURJDFDHMZDV]HM
KDDVWU]H"'RN G FKFHFLH]DDWZLVRELH]EURMQ HVNRUW " *DGDMFKRSLH$OH
XZD DM]LHPLDJRWRZDQDSUDZG VL UR]VW SL
%DUWQLNVSX FLZ]URNL]QLHSRNRMHPSRSDWU]\QDJUXQWSRGQRJDPL*HUDOW
Z\PRZQLHPLOF]D0LOYD]UR]XPLDZV]\QDUHV]FLHZF]\PU]HF]]DNO D
SDVNXGQLH&DKLUSDUVNQ SRJDUGOLZLH
1R"SRQDJOL:LHG PLQ'RN G Z\Z GURZDOLGUXLG]L"
$NWRLFKSDQLHZLHGRN G Z\EHNRWDZUHV]FLHEDUWQLN$OHQD6WRNDFK
PLRGXOHSLRQDZHWG]LHZF]\Q\
7DERUV]HG]SU GNR FL SLHV]\FKLZR]yZWHPSRPDUV]XQLHVSDGRMHGQDNER
QLHE G]LOL P\OHF]V]OL P\MDNSRV]QXUNXEDUWQLF\]QDOLGURJL FLH NLLJUREOH
PLHG]\MH]LRUDPL$SU]\GDDVL WD]QDMRPR RMSU]\GDDER]DF] RVL SLL
QDJOHFDOHFKROHUQH=DU]HF]HXWRQ RZJ VWHMMDN PLHWDQDPJOH%H]EDUWQLNyZ
SRE G]LOLE\ P\EH]RFK\E\DOERLSRWRSLOLVL JG]LH QDEDJQDFK1LHPXVLHOL P\
WH WUDFLF]DVXLHQHUJLLQDRUJDQL]RZDQLHLSU]\U] G]DQLHVS\ \ NDUPLRQRQDV
WU]\UD]\G]LHQQLHVXWRFKRQLHZ\V]XNDQLH,SR]ZDODQRSRMHG]HQLXSROH H
FKZLONLONDEU]XFKHPGRJyU\
.UyWNRPyZL FE\RFXGRZQLH1DZHW:LHG PLQWHQVWDU\SRQXUDNLQXG]LDU]
]DF] F] FLHMX PLHFKDVL L FLHV]\ \FLHPERZ\OLF]\ H SRNRQXMHP\SR
SL WQD FLHPLOG]LHQQLHDRGZ\UXV]HQLD]%URNLORQXQLHXGDRQDPVL DQLUD]X
GRNRQDSRGREQHMV]WXNL5RERW\:LHG PLQQLHPLD DGQHMERFKR=ZLOJH
8URF]\VNRE\R]ZLOJHWDN H Z\REUD]LVRELHWUXGQRFR EDUG]LHM]ZLOJHJR
PRQVWUyZ DGQ\FKQLHQDSRWNDOL P\2WWURFK Z\\SRQRFDFKXSLRU\]DZRG]L\
OH QHSDF]NLLE GQHRJQLNLWD F]\\QDWU] VDZLVNDFK1LFVHQVDF\MQHJR
7URV]HF]N SUDZGDQLHSRNRLR H ]QRZXMHG]LHP\ZGR SU]\SDGNRZR
Z\EUDQ\PNLHUXQNXL]QRZXEH]GRNDGQLHVSUHF\]RZDQHJRFHOX$OHMDNZ\UD]L
VL ZDPSLU5HJLVOHSLHMEH]FHOXL QDSU]yGQL EH]FHOXVWDZPLHMVFXD]
SHZQR FL R QLHEROHSLHMQL EH]FHOXVL FRID
-DVNLHU3U]\WURF]SRU] GQLHMWHQWZyMWXEXV%\DE\V]NRGDJG\E\SyZLHNX
SRH]MLXUZDRVL L ]DJXELRZSDSURFLDFK
1LHPDVWUDFKX1LH]JXEL E G FLHSHZQL,RGHEUDVRELHQLHGDP.D G\
NWRFKFLDE\PLWHQWXEXVRGHEUDSLHUZHME G]LHPXVLDSU]HVW SLQDGP\P
VW\JQ F\PWUXSHP0R QDZLHG]LH*HUDOWFRZ\ZRXMHWZyMSHUOLVW\ PLHFK"
3R]ZyOQLHFK]JDGQ :URG]RQ\NUHW\QL]P"
HNLS SURIHVRU6FKOLHPDQQZ\ELWQ\VSHFMDOLVWDRGVIUDJLVW\NL:LHNyZ0URF]Q\FK
]LGHQW\ILNRZDWHQKHUEMDNRJRGR5LYLLVWDUR \WQHJRNUyOHVWZDRQLH
SRWZLHUG]RQHMORNDOL]DFML
3RGQLHFHQLHDUFKHRORJyZVL JQ RV]F]\WXDOERZLHPZWXEXVDFKWDNLFKZ
:LHNDFK0URF]Q\FKSU]HFKRZ\ZDQRU NRSLV\DFL DUSRMHPQLNDSR]ZDOD
SU]\SXV]F]D H ZHZQ WU]MHVWVSRURSDSLHUXOXESHUJDPLQX ZLHWQ\VWDQWXEXVD
GDZDQDG]LHM QDWR H GRNXPHQW\E G F]\WHOQHLU]XF ZLDWRQDSRJU RQ Z
PURNDFKSU]HV]R 0LD\RWRSU]HPyZLZLHNL%\DWRQLHE\ZDDJUDWND
]Z\FL VWZRQDXNLNWyUHJRQLHZROQRE\R]DSU]HSD FL3U]H]RUQLHZH]ZDQR]
&DVWHOO*UDXSLDQOLQJZLVWyZLEDGDF]\M ]\NyZPDUWZ\FKDWDN H VSHFMDOLVWyZ
XPLHM F\FKRWZRU]\WXEXVEH]U\]\NDQDMPQLHMV]HJRFKRE\XV]NRG]HQLDFHQQHM
]DZDUWR FL
: UyGHNLS\SURIHVRUD6FKOLHPDQQDUR]HV]\VL W\PF]DVHPSRJRVNLR
VNDUELH7U]HEDWUDIX H VRZDWHGRWDU\GRWU]HFKZ\QDM W\FKGRNRSDQLDZ
JOLQLHRVREQLNyZ]QDQ\FKMDNR=G\E&DSL.DPLO5RQVWHWWHU3U]HNRQDQL H
WXEXVGRVRZQLHZ\SFKDQ\MHVW]RWHPLNRV]WRZQR FLDPLWU]HMZ\PLHQLHQL
NRSDF]HJZL]GQ OLQRF EH]FHQQ\DUWHIDNWLXFLHNOL]QLPGRODVX7DPUR]SDOLOL
PDOXWNLHRJQLVNRLVLHGOLZRNy
1DFRF]HNDV]"SRZLHG]LDGR=G\ED&DS2WZLHUDMWHUXU
.LHG\VL QLHGDSRVNDU \VL &DSRZL=G\E7U]\PLHMDNJDPUDFNLV\Q
7REXWHPMRFK GR RQRJDPUDWNHSRUDG]L.DPLO5RQVWHWWHU
3RGREFDVHP=G\ED]DPNQL FLHEH]FHQQHJR]QDOH]LVNDSX FLRLQD]LHPL
Z\SDGD]DZDUWR
2 H JDPUDWNDFK GR RQDNU]\NQ ]GXPLRQ\&DS&RWRWDNLHMHVW"
3\WDQLHE\RJXSLHDOERZLHPQDSLHUZV]\U]XWRNDZLGDE\R H V WRDUNXV]H
SDSLHUX'ODWHJR=G\EPLDVWRGSRZLDGDZ]L MHGHQ]DUNXV]\GRU NLL]EOL \
JRGRQRVD3U]H]GX V] FKZLO SU]\JO GDVL REFRZ\JO GDM F\P]QDNRP
=DSLVDQ\VWZLHUG]LZUHV]FLHDXWRU\WDW\ZQLH7RV OLWHU\
/LWHU\"ZU]DVQ .DPLO5RQVWHWWHUEOHGQ F ]H]JUR]\=DSLVDQHOLWHU\"2
H JDPUDWND
=DSLVDQH]QDF]\F]DU\Z\EHNRWD&DS]SU]HUD HQLDG]ZRQL F ] EDPL
/LWHU\]QDF]\JXVD1LHGRW\NDMWDWHJRJDPUDWNDMHJRFK GR RQDPD7\PVL
]DUD]LPR QD
=G\EQLHGDVRELHGZDUD]\SRZWDU]DFLVQ DUNXV]GRRJQLDLQHUZRZRZ\WDU
GU FHGRQLHRVSRGQLH.DPLO5RQVWHWWHUNRSQLDNLHPZWU FLGRRJQLVNDUHV]W
SDSLHUyZZNR FXMDNLH G]LHFLPRJ\QDSDWRF]\VL QDWRFKROHUVWZR3RWHP
FDDWUyMNDSRVSLHV]QLHRGGDOLDVL ] QLHEH]SLHF]QHJRPLHMVFD%H]FHQQ\]DE\WHN
SL PLHQQLFWZD:LHNyZ0URF]Q\FKSDOLVL MDVQ\PZ\VRNLPSRPLHQLHP3U]H]
NLONDNUyWNLFKFKZLOZLHNLSU]HPDZLD\FLFKXWNLPV]HSWHPF]HUQLHM FHJRZRJQLX
SDSLHUX$SRWHPSRPLH ]JDVLJDPUDFNLHFLHPQR FLRNU\\]LHPL
5R]G]LD
+RXXHQDJKHO'RPLQLN%RPEDVWXVZ]ERJDFLVL Z (EELQJSURZDG]RQ\P
QDRJURPQ VNDO KDQGOHPLRVLDGZ1LOIJDDUG]LHV]DQRZDQ\RGSRSU]HGQLFK
FHVDU]yZPLDQRZDQ\]RVWD]DU] GyZLPSHUDWRUD-DQD&DOXHLWDEXUJUDEL L
XSQLNLHPXHQHQGDOVNLPDZQDJURG SRR RQ\FK]DVXJPLDVRELHQDGDQH
VWDURVWZRQHZHXJH VNLH:LHUQ\GRUDGFDFHVDU]DSRVLDGD+MHJRZ]JO G\LLEUD
XG]LDZZLHOXVSUDZDFKSXEOLF]Q\FKZ-HV]F]HZ(EELQJSURZDG]L+
V]HURN G]LDDOQR FKDU\WDW\ZQ ZVSLHUDSRWU]HEXM F\FKLQLHPDM WQ\FK
]DNDGDVLHURFL FHV]SLWDOHLRFKURQNLR \QDQLHQLHPDHVXPP\:LHONL
PLR QLNV]WXNSL NQ\FKLVSRUWXXIXQGRZDZVWROLF\WHDWUNRPLF]Q\RUD]VWDGLRQ
REDMHJRLPL QRV] FH8FKRG]L]DSU]\VRZLRZ\Z]yUSUDZR FLXF]FLZR FLL
]DFQR FLNXSLHFNLHM
(IIHQEHUJL7DOERW
(QF\FORSDHGLD0D[LPD0XQGLWRP9,,
1D]ZLVNRLLPL ZLDGND"
6HOERUQH.HQQD=QDF]\VL SU]HSUDV]DP-RDQQD
3URIHVMD"
ZLDGF]HQLHXVXJUy Q\FK
ZLDGND DUW\VL WU]\PDM " ZLDGNRZLSU]\SRPLQDVL H VWDMHSU]HG
FHVDUVNLPWU\EXQDHPZSURFHVLHR]GUDG VWDQX2G]H]QD ZLDGND]DOH \ \FLH
ZLHOXOXG]LDOERZLHPNDU ]D]GUDG MHVW PLHU ZLDGNRZLSU]\SRPLQDVL H
VDPDVWRLSU]HGWU\EXQDHPE\QDMPQLHMQLH]ZROQHMVWRS\DOHGRSURZDG]RQD]
F\WDGHOL]PLHMVFDRGRVREQLHQLDDWRF]\WDPSRZUyFLF]\Z\MG]LHQDVZRERG
]DOH \ PL G]\LQQ\PLRG]H]QD ZLDGND7U\EXQDSR]ZROLVRELHQDW GXJ
W\UDG DE\XQDRF]QL ZLDGNRZLMDNGDOHFHQLHVWRVRZQHV QDWHMVDOLNURWRFKZLOH
L IDFHFMH6 RQHQLHW\ONRQLHVPDF]QHDOHWH JUR EDUG]RSRZD Q\PL
NRQVHNZHQFMDPL ZLDGNRZLGDMHVL SyPLQXW\QDSU]HP\ OHQLHWHMVSUDZ\3R
W\PF]DVLHWU\EXQD]DGDS\WDQLHSRZWyUQLH
-X ZLHOPR Q\V G]LR
3URV] ]ZUDFDVL GRQDVZ\VRNLWU\EXQDOH3URIHVMD ZLDGND"
-HVWHPF]XMQDZ\VRNLWU\EXQDOH$OHJyZQLHQDXVXJDFKFHVDUVNLHJR
Z\ZLDGX]QDF]\VL
3URV] XG]LHODRGSRZLHG]LNRQNUHWQ\FKLNUyWNLFK*G\V G ]DSUDJQLH
V]HUV]\FKZ\MD QLH VDPRQLHSRSURVL6 GRZL]QDQ\MHVWIDNWZVSySUDF\
ZLDGND]VHNUHWQ\PLVX EDPLFHVDUVWZD3URV] MHGQDNSRGDGRSURWRNRXFR
3XV]F]\NMHFKDZ]URNLHPRGWZDU]\GRWZDU]\RGV\OZHWNLGRV\OZHWNL
1LHNWyU\FK]QDRVREL FLHOHSLHMOXEJRU]HM,QQ\FKNWyU\FKUR]SR]QDZD]QD]H
V\V]HQLD=UHSXWDFML
7LO(FKUDGHMDVQRZRV\HOI]ZLDGRZFDJHPPHUVNLFK3DF\ILNDWRUyZ5LVSDW/D
3RLQW ZDFKPLVWU]]WHMVDPHMIRUPDFML,QDVW SQ\*HPPHUF]\N&\SULDQ)ULSS
0RGV]\6NHOOHQE\SU]\HJ]HNXFML6WDUV]HJR2EDMEUDFLDV\Q OL]
VDG\VW\F]Q\FKVNRQQR FL
'DOHMVZRERGQLHSU]HJL WDQDNXOEDFHVURNDWHMNODF]\&KORH6WLW]]RG]LHMND
F]DVDPLZ\QDMPRZDQDLZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQDSU]H]WDMQHVX E\3XV]F]\NV]\ENR
XFLHNZ]URNLHPSU]HGMHMEH]F]HOQ\PLRF]\PDL]R OLZ\PX PLHFKHP
$QGUHV9LHUQ\1RUGOLQJ]5HGDQLLUH]XQ6WLJZDUGSLUDWUHQHJDW]H6NHOOLJH
'HGH9DUJDVGLDEHZLHVN G SRFKRG] F\]DZRGRZ\PRUGHUFD.DEHPLN7XUHQW
PRUGHUFD]]DPLRZDQLD
,LQQL3RGREQL:V]\VF\RQLV SRGREQLSRP\ OD6NHOOHQ%UDFWZR
NRQIUDWHUQLDZNWyUHMSR]DELFLXSLHUZV]\FKSL FLXOXG]LZV]\VF\UREL VL WDF\
VDPL7DNLHVDPHUXFK\WDNLHVDPHJHVW\WDNDVDPDPDQLHUDPRZ\UXFKyZL
VWURMX
7DNLHVDPHRF]\%H]QDPL WQHLFKRGQHSDVNLHLQLHUXFKRPHMDNXZ \ RF]\
NWyU\FKZ\UD]XQLFQDZHWQDMSRWZRUQLHMV]DRNURSQR QLHMHVWMX Z VWDQLH
]PLHQL
,MDN"3DQLH6WHIDQLH"
1LH OH1LH]DKDQ]D6LOLIDQW
'DFUHMHV]F]HEDUG]LHMSRNUD QLD]DVDOXWRZDSRJHPPHUVNXSL FL
SU]\R RQ GRNRSDND
6SHFMDOQLH \F]\HPVRELHSU]\SRPQLD6NHOOHQNLONXWDNLFKNWyU\P
QLHREFDMHVWPDJLD.WyU]\VL QLH]O NQ DQLF]DUyZDQLF]DURZQLNyZ
3DPL WDHP-HVWSU]HFLH7LO(FKUDGH$SUyF]QLHJRRWDZ\VRNDSDQQDQD
SDUDGQHMNDV]WDQFHWDRERN&KORH6WLW]
3y QLHMSU]\SURZDG]LV]M GRPQLH3XV]F]\NRSDUVL R EDOXVWUDG VWXNQ Z
QL RNXW\PWU]RQNLHPQDKDMNL
&]RHPNRPSDQLD
&]RHPSDQLHNRURQHU
:LHOX]ZDVSRGM 6NHOOHQJG\SU]HEU]PLDRHFKRFKyUDOQHJRU\NXEDQG\
SUDFRZDRMX ]HPQ ]QDPQLHLPRMHZ\PDJDQLD&L]HFKF Z\MD QLW\PNWyU]\
PQLHQLH]QDM F]HJRRF]HNXM RGSRGNRPHQGQ\FKDF]HJRXSRGNRPHQGQ\FKQLH
WROHUXM -DQLHE G ZL F VWU] SLVRELHQLHSRWU]HEQLHJ E\
-X G]L QLHNWyU]\]ZDVRWU]\PDM ]DGDQLDLMXWURR ZLFLHZ\UXV] E\MH
Z\NRQD1DWHU\WRULXP(EELQJ3U]\SRPLQDP H (EELQJMHVWIRUPDOQLH
NUyOHVWZHPDXWRQRPLF]Q\PLIRUPDOQLHQLHPDP\WDP DGQHMMXU\VG\NFMLWRWH
QDND]XM G]LDDUR]ZD QLHLG\VNUHWQLH3R]RVWDMHFLHZVX ELHFHVDUVNLHMDOH
]DND]XM REQRVLVL ] W\PFKHSLLDURJDQFNRWUDNWRZDPLHMVFRZHZDG]H
1DND]XM ]DFKRZ\ZDVL WDNE\QLH FL JDQLF]\MHMXZDJL-DVQH"
7DNMHVWSDQLHNRURQHU
7XZ5RFD\QHMHVWH FLHJR PLLPDFLH]DFKRZ\ZDVL MDNJR FLH=DND]XM
RSXV]F]DQLDSU]\G]LHORQ\FKNZDWHUEH]NRQLHF]QHMSRWU]HE\=DND]XM NRQWDNWyZ]
, RSRZLDGD
2SRZLDGDRW\PFRF]WHU\GQLZF]H QLHMZ\GDU]\RVL Z =D]GUR FL
2SRZLDGDFRLUXV]]PLHQLDM F ZHUVMHGRNDGDM FNRQIDEXOXM F F ZUHV]FLHZ
\ZHRF]\FRZFDOHQLHSU]HV]NDG]DRVXFKDF]RP%\ZDOF\]DMD]GXFLORNDOQLL
FLSU]\MH]GQLVXFKDOLFK WQLH$1\FNODURSRZLDGDXGDM F GREU]H
SRLQIRUPRZDQHJR,FRUD]F] FLHMVWDZLDM F VZ ZDVQ RVRE Z FHQWUXP
VNRQIDEXORZDQ\FKZ\GDU]H
-X WU]HFLHJRZLHF]RUDMHJRZDVQ\M ]RU FL JQ PXQDNDUNNRSRW\
1DZLGRNOXG]LNWyU]\ZHV]OLGRNDUF]P\]DSDGDJURERZDFLV]DZFLV]\WHM
EU] N RVWUyJV]F] N PHWDORZ\FKVSU] F]HNL]JU]\WRNXEURQL]DEU]PLD\MDN
]RZUy EQ\G]ZRQZLHV]F] F\QLHV]F] FLH]HV]F]\WXG]ZRQQLF\
1\FNODURZLQLHGDQRQDZHWV]DQV\SUyERZDRGJU\ZDERKDWHUD=RVWD
FKZ\FRQ\LZ\SURZDG]RQ\]NDUF]P\WDNV]\ENR H FK\EDW\ONR]HWU]\UD]\
]GRDGRWNQ REFDVDPLSRGRJL=QDMRPNRZLHNWyU]\MHV]F]HZF]RUDMSLM F ]D
MHJRSLHQL G]HGHNODURZDOLGR]JRQQ SU]\MD WHUD]ZPLOF]HQLXJRZ\QLHPDO H
SRGEODW\VWRyZSRZW\NDOLMDNE\WDPSRGVWRDPLQLHZLDGRPRMDNLHFXGDVL
Z\SUDZLD\DOERJRHEDE\WD FRZD\1DZHWREHFQ\Z]DMH G]LH]DVW SFDV]HU\ID
RGZUyFLVL NX FLDQLHLQLHSLVQ VyZND
1\FNODUWH QLHSLVQ VyZNDQLH]DS\WDNWRFR]DFRLGODF]HJR3U]HUD HQLH
]PLHQLRPXM ]\NZV]W\ZQ\LVXFK\NRHN
:VDG]LOLJRQDNRQLDND]DOLMHFKD.LONDJRG]LQ3RWHPE\IRUW]SDOLVDG L
ZLH 3RGZyU]HFSHHQEXWQHJRKDD OLZHJRREZLHV]RQHJREURQL RGDFWZD,
L]ED:L]ELHWU]HFKOXG]L'RZyGFDLGZyFKSRGZDGQ\FK]UD]XE\RZLGD
'RZyGFDQLHGX \F]DUQLDZ\ERJDWRRG]LDQ\E\VWDWHF]Q\ZPRZLHLQDG
SRG]LZJU]HF]Q\1\FNODUD J E UR]G]LDZLJG\XV\V]D H SU]HSUDV]DVL JR]D
NRSRWLQLHZ\JRG\WXG]LH XSHZQLD H QLHE G]LHPXNU]\ZG\$OHQLHGDVL
QDEUD&LOXG]LH]DEDUG]RSU]\SRPLQDOLPX%RQKDUWD
6NRMDU]HQLHRND]DRVL ]DG]LZLDM FRWUDIQH:D QLH%RQKDUWLFKLQWHUHVRZD
1\FNODUPyJVL WHJRVSRG]LHZD%RSU]HFLH WRMHJRZDVQ\M ]RUZS G]LJRZ
W NDED
:H]ZDQ\]DF] RSRZLDGD8SRPQLDQRJRE\PyZLSUDZG E\QLHXEDUZLD
8SRPQLDQRJU]HF]QLHDOHVXURZRLGRELWQLHDWHQNWyU\XSRPLQDWHQERJDWR
RG]LDQ\FD\F]DVEDZLVL RNXW SOHWQL DRF]\PLDSDVNXGQHL]H
1\FNODUV\QWUXPQLDU]D]RVDG\=D]GUR RSRZLHG]LDSUDZG &D SUDZG L
W\ONRSUDZG 2W\PMDNWRZGQLXG]LHZL WHJRZU]H QLDUDQNLHPZRVDG]LH
=D]GUR %RQKDUWRZFDQDJUyGZ\U Q ZSLH EDQG 6]F]XUyZGDURZXM F \FLH
W\ONRMHGQHMUR]EyMQLF]FHQDMPRGV]HMWHMNWyU QD]\ZDQR)DON 2SRZLHG]LDMDN
FDD=D]GUR VL ]ELHJDE\SDWU]HMDN%RQKDUWE G]LHSRMPDQ VSUDZLDLND QL
DOH]DZLHGOLVURG]HVL OXG]LVNDER%RQKDUWRG]LZR)DONLQLHXWUXSLQLH
WRUWXURZDQDZHW1LHXF]\QLMHMQLFQDGWRFR]Z\N\FKRSF]\QL RQLHZVRERW
ZLHF]RUHPZUDFDM F ]REHU \ RW]Z\F]DMQLHVNRSDZSDS VWU]HOLNLONDUD]\L
ZL FHMQLF
%RJDWRRG]LDQ\SDQHN]SOHWQL PLOF]DD1\FNODURSRZLHG]LDMDNSy QLHM
%RQKDUWQDRF]DFK)DONLXU]\QDSR]DELMDQ\P6]F]XURPJRZ\LMDN]W\FKJyZ
QLF]\PURG]\QNL]FLDVWDZ\VNXE\ZD]RWHNROF]\NL]NDP\NDPL-DN)DOND
1LH]P\ ODV]"
1DPDWNLPHMPRJL VL NOQ 1LHND FLH PQLHELSDQLH]RW\3RPLXMFLH
1RQRSRGQLH VL QLH OL EXWyZ1D FLWXGHQDUD
6WRNURWQHG]L NLDVNDZFR
0yZLHPQLH OL PLEXWyZ2OD0XQZ\SRMPXMHFLHFR ] WHJR"&RPD
ZVSyOQHJRV]ZDOQLD
6]F]ZDOQLDSRZLHG]LDQDJOH%RUHDV0XQ1LHV]ZDOQLDDOHV]F]ZDOQLD
$QRNU]\NQ FKRSDN7DNU]HN-DNE\ FLHE\OLSU]\W\PSDQLH]RW\
6]F]ZDOQLDLKHFD2OD+DUVKHLPXGHU]\SL FL R SL 8PyZLRQ\V]\IU
DOHQLHQDGWRZ\P\ OQ\DWZ\+HFDV]F]XFLHWRRVWU]H HQLHSU]HGSR FLJLHPDOER
REDZ %RQKDUWRVWU]HJLFKE\XP\NDOL$OHSU]HGNLP"3U]HGQDPL"
.WRZLHSRZLHG]LDZ]DP\ OHQLX3XV]F]\N.WRZLH7U]HEDE G]LHSRVD
OXG]LGR&ODUHPRQW,GR)DQRWH =DMPLHV]VL W\P2ODSU]\G]LHOLV]]DGDQLD
JUXSRP6XFKDMQRFKRSLH
1DUR]ND]SDQLH]RW\
*G\RGMH G DH ] =D]GUR FL]OLVWDPL%RQKDUWDRQWDPMDNUR]XPLHPQDGDO
E\"$VSRVRELVL GRGURJL"6SLHV]\"0yZLPR HGRN G ]PLHU]D"
1LHPyZL$LGRGURJLQLMDNPXE\RVL VSRVREL3U]\RG]LHQLHFRPLD
NUZL RNUXWQLHSREU\]JDQHSUDLF]\ FLVRELHQDND]DWHG\VDPZNRV]XOLL
JDFLDFKMHQRFKRG]LDOH]PLHF]HPSU]\SDVDQ\P: G\P\ O H VSLHV]\
3U]HFLH6]F]XUyZSRELLJRZ\LPXU]H]DGODQDJURG\PXVPXE\RMHFKDLVL R
RQDXSRPQLH$LW )DON WH SU]HFLHSRWRXM E\ \ZFHPNRPX GRVWDUF]\
7DNDSU]HFLHMHJRSURIHVMDQLH"
7D)DOND3U]\MU]DH VL MHMGREU]H"&]HJRUHFKRF]HV]GXUQLX"
2MSDQLH]RW\&]\MDVL MHMSU]\MU]D",MHV]F]HMDN=GHWDODPL
1HUDWLQ&HNDL%RUHDV0XQMHFKDOLSU]RGHP]DQLPLERNZERN.DEHUQLN
7XUHQWL&\SULDQ)ULSS0RGV]\GDOHM.HQQD6HOERUQHL&KORH6WLW]QDNR FX
$QGUHV9LHP\L'HGH9DUJDV'ZDMRVWDWQL SLHZDOLPRGQ RVWDWQLR RQLHUVN
SLRVHQN VSRQVRURZDQ L ODQVRZDQ SU]H]0LQLVWHUVWZR:RMQ\1DZHWSR UyG
RQLHUVNLFKSLRVHQHNWDZ\Uy QLDDVL SU]HUD OLZ Q G] U\PyZLUR]EUDMDM F\P
EUDNLHPSRV]DQRZDQLDGOD]DVDGJUDPDW\NL1RVLDW\WX1DZRMHQFHDOERZLHP
ZV]\VWNLH]ZURWNLDE\RLFKSRQDGF]WHUG]LH FL]DF]\QD\VL RGW\FKZD QLH
VyZ
1DZRMHQFHE\ZDUy QLH
5D]NWR NRPX JRZ XU QLH
5D]]QyZGDG] ]QDR]PLHU]FKX
H NWR IODNLPDQDZLHU]FKX
0LHF]QLN(VWHUKD]\GXJRSDWU]\QD%RUHDVD0XQDQLHVSLHV] F VL ]
RGSRZLHG]L QD]DGDQHS\WDQLH
0R H %RQKDUGWXE\SRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLHEDZL F VL ]DZLHV]RQ QDV]\L
NR FLDQ JZL]GDZN $PR H JRWXQLHE\R".WRZLH"7XWDMPRLSD VWZR
PDP\ZDUV]WDWSURGXNXM F\PLHF]H1DZV]HONLHS\WDQLDGRW\F] FHPLHF]yZ
RGSRZLHP\FK WQLHV]\ENRS\QQLHLZ\F]HUSXM FR$OHQLHZLG] SRZRGXE\
RGSRZLDGDQDS\WDQLDGRW\F] FHQDV]\FKJR FLLNOLHQWyZ
.HQQDZ\FL JQ D]U NDZDFKXVWN XGDD H Z\FLHUDQRV
3RZyGPR H VL ]QDOH SRZLHG]LD1HUDWLQ&HND0R HFLHJR]QDOH Z\
SDQLH(VWHUKD]\0RJ MD=HFKFHFLHZ\EUD"
3RPLPRSR]RUyZ]QLHZLH FLDR FLWZDU]1HUDWLQDSRWUDILDE\WZDUGDDJRV
]RZUy EQ\$OHPLHF]QLNW\ONRSDUVNQ EDZL F VL JZL]GDZN
:\EUDPL G]\SU]HNXSVWZHPDJUR E " 1LH]HFKF -HGQRLGUXJLHXZD DP
]DZDUWHZ\ F]QLHSOXQL FLD
7\ONRMHGQDPDOH NDLQIRUPDFMDRGFKU] NQ %RUHDV0XQ&]\WRWDNZLHOH"
=QDP\VL SU]HFLHQLHRGG]L SDQLH(VWHUKD]\DLQD]ZLVNRNRURQHUD6NHOOHQD
REFHZDPSU]HFLHWH QLHMHVW
1LHMHVWSU]HUZDPLHF]QLN DGQ PLDU QLHMHVW6SUDZNLLZ\F]\Q\]
NWyU\PLWRQD]ZLVNRVL NRMDU]\WH QLHV QDPREFH$OHWXPDP\(EELQJ
NUyOHVWZRDXWRQRPLF]QHLVDPRU] GQH&KRSR]RUQLHDOH]DZV]H'ODWHJRQLF
ZDPQLHSRZLHP\,G FLHVRELHZVZRM GURJ 1DRVRG SU]\U]HNDP\ZDP H
MH OL]DW\G]LH OXEPLHVL F NWR E G]LHZ\S\W\ZDRZDVXV\V]\RGQDVUyZQLH
PDR
$OH SDQLH(VWHUKD]\
7U]HEDZ\UD QLHM"3URV] EDUG]R:\QRFKDVW G
&KORH6WLW]V\NQ DZ FLHNOHGRQLH)ULSSDL9DUJDVDSRSH]\NXU NRMH FLRP
$QGUHV9LHUQ\RSDUSL RZLV] F\QDXG]LHQDG]LDN1HUDWLQ&HNDQLHSRUXV]\
VL WZDU]QLHGUJQ DPXQDZHW.HQQDZLG]LDD H QLHVSXV]F]DRND]NR FLDQHM
JZL]GDZNL1LPZHV]OL%RUHDV0XQRVWU]HJLFKJZL]GJZL]GDZNLE\KDVHP
GODF]HNDM F\FKZXNU\FLXRFKURQLDU]\]DZRDQ\FKU EDMyZNWyU\FKZ
ZDUV]WDFLHPLHF]QLNDQD]\ZDQRNRQWUROHUDPLMDNR FLZ\UREyZ
$OHSU]HZLG]LDZV]\ZV]\VWNR1HUDWLQL%RUHDV]DSODQRZDOLQDVW SQ\UXFK
0LHOLZ]DQDGU]XNR]HUQ NDUW
.HQQ 6HOERUQH&]XMQ
.HQQDMX ZF]H QLHMVRQGRZDDPLHF]QLNDGHOLNDWQLHNXDJRLPSXOVDPL
RVWUR QLH]DSXV]F]DDVL Z J V]F]MHJRP\ OL7HUD]E\DJRWRZD3U]\R \ZV]\
GRQRVDFKXVWN ]DZV]HLVWQLDRQLHEH]SLHF]H VWZRNUZRWRNXZGDUDVL GR
Py]JXSXOVDFM L UR]ND]HP(VWHUKD]\]DNU]WXVLVL SRF]HUZLHQLDREXU F]XFDSL
EODWVWRX]DNWyU\PVLHG]LDMDNJG\E\EDVL H VWyXOHFLGRFLHS\FKNUDMyZ
UD]HP]SOLNLHPIDNWXUNDDPDU]HPLSU]\FLVNLHPGRSDSLHUyZSU]HGVWDZLDM F\P
QHUHLG ZFLHNDZ\VSRVyEILJOXM F ] GZRPDWU\WRQDPLQDUD]
6SRNRMQLHUR]ND]DD.HQQDWRQLFQLFVL QLHG]LHMH3RSURVWXPDV]RFKRW
RSRZLHG]LHQDPRW\PFRQDVFLHNDZL3U]HFLH ZLHV]FRQDVFLHNDZLDVRZDD
UZ VL ] FLHELHQDZRO 'DOHM H ZL F=DF]\QDM=REDF]\V]JG\W\ONR]DF]QLHV]
PyZLZJRZLHSU]HVWDQLHFLV]XPLHZVNURQLDFKKXF]HDZXV]DFKNX,
VNXUF]V]F] N WH RGSX FL
%RQKDUWSRZLHG]LDFKUDSOLZLH(VWHUKD]\RWZLHUDM F XVWDF] FLHMQL
Z\QLNDRE\]V\ODELF]QHMDUW\NXODFMLE\WXF]WHU\GQLWHPXGZXQDVWHJR
ZU]H QLD0LD]HVRE G]LHZF]\Q NWyU QD]\ZD)DON 6SRG]LHZDHPVL WHM
ZL]\W\ERGZDGQLZF]H QLHMGRVWDUF]RQRPLOLVWRGQLHJR
=OHZHMG]LXUNLQRVDSRFLHNDPXFLHQLXWNDVWUX NDNUZL
0yZUR]ND]DD.HQQD0yZ0yZZV]\VWNR=REDF]\V]MDNFLXO \
=P\OLDJRVSRMU]HQLHPZERNLRV]XND F]\PGUJQLHQLHPEDUNXXGHU]\DMDN
SLRUXQ]SDVNLHJRVLQLVWUX.OLQJD]DG]ZRQLDRSDUDG WDNVLOQ H &LUL
]DFKZLDDVL PXVLDDRGVNRF]\]DZDG]DM F ELRGUHPRVWy]PLHF]DPL3UyEXM F
RG]\VNDUyZQRZDJ RGUXFKRZRRSX FLDPLHF]ZLHG]LDD H ZW\PPRPHQFLH
JG\E\FKFLD]DELE\M EH]QDMPQLHMV]HJRSUREOHPX
&]\Z\ FLHSRV]DOHOL"SRGQLyVJRV(VWHUKD]\DJZL]GDZN ]QRZXPLDZ
U NX6X F\LU]HPLH OQLF\SU]\JO GDOLVL Z RVXSLHQLX
2Gy HOD]R%RQKDUWQLHVSXV]F]D&LUL]RNDQDSDWQHU]DZRJyOHQLH
]ZUDFDXZDJL2Gy PyZL %RRGU EL FLU N
8VXFKDDSRFKZLOLZDKDQLD%RQKDUWX PLHFKQ VL XSLRUQLH
-DZLHPNLPW\MHVWH PLMR$OH]PXV] FL E\ VDPDPLWRZ\]QDD
6RZHPDOERF]\QHP=PXV] FL E\ Z\]QDDNLPMHVWH ,ZWHG\FL ]DELM
(VWHUKD]\V\NQ MDNE\NWR JR]UDQL
$WHQPLHF]%RQKDUWQDZHWQLHVSRMU]DQDQLHJRE\GODFLHELH]DFL NL
3U]H]WRE\D ]E\WZROQD%\D ZROQDMDN OLPDNZFL \(VWHUKD]\7RFRMHM
GDH E\R]DFL NLHRFRQDMPQLHMF]WHU\XQFMH
0LHF]QLNE\EODG\:RG]LRF]DPLRGQLHMGRQLHJRRGQLHJRGRQLHMDWZDU]
PLDG]LZQLH]PLHQLRQ :UHV]FLHVNLQ QDSDFKRNDSyJRVHPZ\GDPXUR]ND]
0DPFR SRZLHG]LDZROQRFRSRZLQQRFL XVDW\VIDNFMRQRZD%RQKDUW
'ODF]HJRZL F QLHSRND]DH PLWHJRRGUD]X"ZDUNQ RZFD3LVDHP H
FKF F]HJR HNVWUD0R H V G]LV] H QDOHSV]\PLHF]PQLHQLHVWD"
-DZLHPQDFRFLHELHVWDU]HN]QDFLVNLHP(VWHUKD]\1LHRGG]L WRZLHP
$ H QLHSRND]DHPRGUD]X"1LHPRJHPSU]HFLH ZLHG]LHNRJRGRPQLH
SU]\SURZDG]LV]QDVP\F]\]REUR QDV]\L1LHPRJHPVL GRP\ OLGODNRJR
PDE\PLHF]LGRF]HJRPDVX \7HUD]MX ZLHPZV]\VWNR
3DFKRHNZUyFLQLRV F SRGX QHSXGR
=EOL VL G]LHZF]\QRSRZLHG]LDFLFKR(VWHUKD]\6SyMU]
&LUL]EOL \DVL 6SRMU]DD,ZHVWFKQ DJR QR2EQD \DPLHF]V]\ENLP
UXFKHP2JLH ] NRPLQDR OHSLDM FR]DSRQ QDIDOL FLH]DU\VRZDQ\PV]ZLH
RVWU]D]DMDU]\VL F]HUZRQRZD XURZDQLDFK]DVWDZ\
-DVNyNDGRNR F]\D&LUL=LUHDHO0RMHLPL
)DNW\F]QLHQLHEU]\GNDU]HF]SRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLH%RQKDUW*QRPLDURERWD
RGUD]XZLGD7\ONRJQRP\WDNLHFLHPQH HOD]RNX\7\ONRJQRP\RVWU]\\
SRPLHQL FLHLW\ONRJQRP\D XURZD\NOLQJLE\]PQLHMV]\ZDJ 3U]\]QDMVL
(VWHUKD]\7RUHSOLND"
1LH]DSU]HF]\PLHF]QLN2U\JLQD3UDZG]LZ\JQRPLJZ\K\U7DJRZQLD
PDSRQDGGZLH FLHODW2SUDZDPDVL UR]XPLHMHVWRZLHOHPRGV]DDOHUHSOLN
E\PMHMQLHQD]ZD*QRP\]7LU7RFKDLUUREL\M QDPRMH]DPyZLHQLH:HGXJ
GDZQ\FKWHFKQLNPHWRGLZ]RUFyZ
&KROHUD0R H E\ H IDNW\F]QLHQLHE G]LHPQLHVWD,OH WR]DZLQV]XMHV]
VRELH]DWHQEU]HV]F]RW"
(VWHUKD]\PLOF]DF]DVMDNL 7ZDU]PLDQLHSU]HQLNQLRQ
-DJRRGGDP]DGDUPR%RQKDUWSRZLHG]LDZUHV]FLHJXFK\PJRVHP:
SRGDUXQNX HE\Z\SHQLRVL FRPDVL Z\SHQL
']L NXM U]HN%RQKDUWZLGRF]QLH]DVNRF]RQ\']L NXM &L(VWHUKD]\
.UyOHZVNLSRGDUXQHNL FLHNUyOHZVNL3U]\MPXM SU]\MPXM ,MHVWHPWZ\P
GX QLNLHP
1LHMHVWH 0LHF]MHVWGODQLHMQLHGODFLHELH3RGHMG G]LHZF]\QRQRV] FD
REUR QDV]\L3U]\MU]\MVL ]QDNRPZ\WUDZLRQ\PQDNOLQG]H1LHUR]XPLHV]LFK
WRRF]\ZLVWH$OHMDFLMHREMD QL 6SyMU]/LQLDZ\W\F]RQDSU]H]ORVMHVWNU WDDOH
ZLHG]LHNXWHMRWRZLH \.X]DJDG]LHNX]QLV]F]HQLXXVWDORQ\FKZDUWR FL
XVWDORQHJRSRU] GNX$OHRWRQDGZLH ZLG]LV]"-DVNyND6\PEROQDG]LHL:H
WHQPLHF]1LHFKDMZ\SHQLVL FRPDVL Z\SHQL
&LULRVWUR QLHZ\FL JQ DU N GHOLNDWQLHSRJDG]LDFLHPQ\EU]HV]F]RW]
O QL F\PLMDNOXVWUDNUDZ G]LDPL
:H JRU]HNSRZROL(VWHUKD]\SDWU] F QD&LULV]HURNRUR]ZDUW\PLRF]DPL
:H JR:H JRGRU NLG]LHZF]\QR:H
1LHNU]\NQ QDJOH%RQKDUWSRGVNDNXM FFKZ\WDM F &LUL]DUDPL L
RGS\FKDM F M JZDWRZQLHLPRFQR3UHF]
&LULXSDGDQDNRODQD ZLUSRGZyU]DEROH QLH]DNXGRQLHNWyU\PLVL
SRGSDUD
%RQKDUW]DWU]DVQ SXGR
-HV]F]HQLHWHUD]]DZDUF]D-HV]F]HQLHG]L -HV]F]HQLHQDGV]HGF]DV
1DMZLGRF]QLHMSU]\WDNQ VSRNRMQLH(VWHUKD]\SDWU] F PXZRF]\7DN
QDMZLGRF]QLHMMHV]F]HQLHQDGV]HG6]NRGD
&ODUHPRQWSRZWyU]\9\VRJRWD=QDPWRPLDVWHF]NR'RN G FL ]DZLy]"
'RZLHONLHJRGRPXZU\QNX=NROXPQDPLLDUNDGDPLSU]\ZHM FLX2GUD]X
E\RZLGD H PLHV]NDWDPERJDF]
FLDQ\NRPQDWSRNU\ZD\ERJDWHDUUDV\LSU]HS\V]QHWDSLVHULHSU]HGVWDZLDM FH
VFHQ\UHOLJLMQHP\ OLZVNLHLVLHODQNL]XG]LDHPUR]HEUDQ\FKNRELHW0HEOHO QL\
LQWDUVMDPLLPRVL G]HPRNXDG\ZDQ\E\\WDNLH H SU]\VW SQL FLXVWRSD
]DJ ELDDVL SRNRVWN &LULQLH]G \D]DREVHUZRZDV]F]HJyyZER%RQKDUW
NURF]\V]SDUNRLFL JQ ]DD FXFK
:LWDM+RX\HQDJKHO
:W F]\NRORUyZU]XFDQHMSU]H]ZLWUD QDWOHP\ OLZVNLHMWDSLVHULLVWD
P F]\]QDRLPSRQXM FHMWXV]\XEUDQ\ZNDSL F\RG]RWDNDIWDQLREV]\ZDQ
Z\SRUNDPLGHOL &KRZVLOHZLHNXP VNLHJRE\PRFQR\V\DSROLF]NL]ZLVD\
PXMDNXRJURPQHJREXOGRJD
:LWDM/HRSRZLHG]LD,W\SDQL
DGQDSDQL%RQKDUWSRND]DD FXFKLREUR :LWDQLHWU]HED
*U]HF]QR QLFQLHNRV]WXMH
2SUyF]F]DVX%RQKDUWSRFL JQ ]DD FXFKSRGV]HGEH]FHUHPRQLDOQLH
SRNOHSDJUXEDVDSREU]XFKX
DGQLH SU]\EUDRFHQL1DKRQRU+RXYHQDJKHOJG\VWRLV]QDGURG]H
DWZLHMFL SU]HVNRF]\QL REHM
'REURE\WZ\MD QLMRZLDOQLH+RXYHQDJKHOL]DWU] VSROLF]NDPL:LWDMPL
ZLWDM/HR0L\PPLMHVWH JR FLHPERPWH G]L L UDGRVQ\QLH]PLHUQLH,QWHUHV\
LG QDGSRG]LZGREU]H H D VL FKFHRGXURNXSOXNDVDW\ONREU] F]\7\ONR
MHVWF]HNEDQNLHUVNLQDVWRIORUHQyZ7XDNWXPRZ\RFHVML]RERZL ]D QDPRF\
NWyUHJRZ\FL JQ RG9DPKDJHQyZ]*HVRQDJURG ]DJRZ\EDQG\WyZ3RGSLV]
']L NXM 1DOH \ FLVL MHV]F]HSURFHQW]ZS\ZyZ]SU]HGVWDZLHQLDDOHQLH
]DPNQL WRMHV]F]HUDFKXQNyZNDVDZFL EU] F]\-HVWGX H ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH/HR
1DSUDZG GX H/XG]LRPZPRLPPLDVWHF]NXRNUXWQLHGRNXF]DM QXGDLFKDQGUD
8UZDSRSDWU]\QD&LUL
0DPV]F]HU QDG]LHM H VL QLHP\OLV]FRGRWHMRVRE\ H ]DSHZQLQDPRQD
JRG]LZ UR]U\ZN H ]HFKFHNRRSHURZDJZROLZVSyOQHJR]\VNX
'ODQLHM%RQKDUW]PLHU]\&LULRERM WQ\PVSRMU]HQLHPQLHE G]LHZW\P
DGQHJR]\VNX2QDRW\PZLH
+RX\HQDJKHOVNU]\ZLVL L DFKQ
7RQLHGREU]HGRGLDEDQLHGREU]H H RW\PZLH1LHSRZLQQDZLHG]LH&R]
WRE /HR"$MH OLRQDQLH]HFKFHE\UR]U\ZNRZDMH OLRND H VL ]R OLZLH
QLHVSROHJOLZD"&RZWHG\"
%RQKDUWQLH]PLHQLZ\UD]XWZDU]\
:WHG\SRZLHG]LDSRV]F]XMHP\QDQL QDDUHQLHWZRMHEU\WDQ\2QHMDN
SDPL WDP]DZV]HE\\UR]U\ZNRZRVSROHJOLZH
&LULPLOF]DDGXJRWU F RNDOHF]RQ\SROLF]HN
=DF]\QDDPUR]XPLHSRZLHG]LDDZUHV]FLH=DF]\QDDPSRMPRZDFR
FKF ]HPQ ]UREL6SL DPVL E\DP]GHF\GRZDQDXFLHNDSU]\SLHUZV]HM
VSRVREQR FL*RWRZDE\DPQDND GHU\]\NR$OHQLHGDOLPLRND]ML3LOQRZDOL
PQLHGREU]H
9\VRJRWDPLOF]D
=DZOHNOLPQLHQDGy7DPF]HNDOLJR FLHWHJRJUXEHJR+RXYHQDJKHOD
1DVW SQHRU\JLQD\6N G QD ZLHFLHELHU]HVL W\OXG]LZDF]Q\FKUDURJyZ
9\VRJRWR"
0QR VL 'REyUQDWXUDOQ\
3LHUZV]\]P F]\]QE\QLVNLLJUXELXWNLSU]\SRPLQDUDF]HMQL]LRNDQL
F]RZLHNDQDZHWQRVLVL MDNQL]LRHNVNURPQLHDGQLHVFKOXGQLHLSDVWHORZR
'UXJLP F]\]QDFKRQLHPRG\PLDVWUyMLSRVWDZ RQLHU]DE\SU]\PLHF]XD
QDUDPLHQLXMHJRF]DUQHJRNXEUDNDE\V]F]DVUHEUQ\KDIWSU]HGVWDZLDM F\VPRNDR
QLHWRSHU]\FKVNU]\GDFK.RELHWDE\DMDVQRZRVDLFKXGDPLDDOHNNR
KDF]\NRZDW\QRVLZ VNLHZDUJL-HMSLVWDFMRZHMEDUZ\VXNQLDE\DPRFQR
Z\GHNROWRZDQD1LHE\WRQDMOHSV]\SRP\V'HNROWPLDGRSRND]DQLDQLHZLHOH
MH OLQLHOLF]\SRPDUV]F]RQHMLSHUJDPLQRZRVXFKHMVNyU\SRNU\WHMJUXE ZDUVWZ
Uy X LEODQV]X
-D QLHXURG]RQDPDUNL]DGH1HPHQWK8\\DUSU]HGVWDZL+RXYHQDJKHO3DQ
'HFODQ5R DHS0DHOFKODGURWPLVWU]UH]HUZ\ZRMVNNRQQ\FKMHJRLPSHUDWRUVNLHM
PR FLFHVDU]D1LOIJDDUGX3DQ3HQQ\FXLFNEXUPLVWU]&ODUHPRQW$WRSDQ/HR
%RQKDUWPyMNUHZQLDNLGDZQ\NRPLOLWRQ
%RQKDUWXNRQLVL V]W\ZQR
7RZL F MHVWRZDPDDUR]EyMQLF]NDNWyUDPDQDVG]L ]DEDZLVWZLHUG]LD
IDNWFKXGDPDUNL]DZSLMDM F Z&LULEODGRQLHELHVNLHRF]\*RVPLDDFKUDSOLZ\
VHNVRZQLHZLEUXM F\LRNURSQLHSU]HSLW\1LH]E\WSL NQDU]HNDE\P$OHQLH OH
]EXGRZDQD&DNLHPSU]\MHPQHFLDHF]NR
&LULV]DUSQ DVL RGHSFKQ DQDWU WQ U N EOHGQ F ]HZ FLHNR FLLV\F] F MDN
Z
3URV] QLHGRW\NDU]HN]LPQR%RQKDUW1LHNDUPL1LHGUD QL1LHELRU
RGSRZLHG]LDOQR FL
&LDHF]NRPDUNL]DREOL]DDZDUJLQLH]ZUDFDM F QDQLHJRXZDJLPR QD
]DZV]HSU]\ZL ]DGRy NDZWHG\MHVWEDUG]LHMSU]\VW SQH0R H E\ FLHPLM
RGVSU]HGDOLSDQLH%RQKDUW"/XELP\]PRLPPDUNL]HPWDNLHFLDHF]NDDSDQ
+RX\HQDJKHOF]\QLQDPZ\U]XW\JG\FKZ\WDP\WXWHMV]HSDVWHUNLLFKRSVNLH
G]LHFL0DUNL]]UHV]W QLHPR H MX SRORZDQDG]LHFLDNL1LHPR H ELHJDDWR]
SRZRGXW\FKV]DQNUyZLNRQG\ORPDWyZNWyUHPXVL Z NURF]XSRRWZLHUD\
'R GR 0DW\OGRU]HNDJRGQLHDOHV]\ENR+RXYHQDJKHOZLG] F QD
WZDU]\%RQKDUWDZ\UD]URVQ FHJRREU]\G]HQLD0XVLP\MX L GRWHDWUX3DQX
EXUPLVWU]RZLGRQLHVLRQRZD QLH H GRPLDVWDZMHFKD:LQGVRU,PEUD]RGG]LDHP
NQHFKWyZEDURQD&DVDGHL=QDF]\QDQDVF]DV
%RQKDUWZ\FL JQ ]NDOHW\IODNRQLNSU]HWDUU NDZHPRQ\NVRZ\EODWVWROLF]ND
Z\V\SDQDQLHJRPDOXWNLZ]JyUHNELDHJRSURV]NX3U]\FL JQ &LUL]DD FXFK
SU]\REUR \
:LHV]MDNWHJRX \ZD"
&LUL]DFLVQ D] E\
:FL JQLMGRQRVD$OERZH QDSR OLQLRQ\SDOHFLZHWU]\MZG]L VR
1LH
%RQKDUWQDZHWQLHRGZUyFLJRZ\
=URELV]WRVDPDSRZLHG]LDFLFKRDOER]UREL WRMDDOHWDNLPVSRVREHPE\
ZV]\VF\REHFQLPLHOLXFLHFK 0DV] OX]yZN QLHW\ONRZXVWDFKLZQRVLH
6]F]XU]\FR:NLONXLQQ\FK]DEDZQ\FKPLHMVFDFKUyZQLH =DZRDPSDFKRNyZ
ND FL UR]HEUDSU]\WU]\PDLX \M W\FK]DEDZQ\FKPLHMVF
0DUNL]DGH1HPHQWK8\YDU]D PLDDVL JDUGRZRSDWU] FMDN&LULGU F
U N VL JDSRQDUNRW\N
=DEDZQHPLHMVFDSRZWyU]\DLREOL]DDZDUJL&LHNDZ\SRP\V:DUWRE\
NWyUHJR GQLDZ\SUyERZD(M HHM HG]LHZF]\QRRVWUR QLHQLHWUZR GREUHJR
ILVVWHFKX=RVWDZWURFK GODPQLH
1DUNRW\NE\RZLHOHVLOQLHMV]\RGWHJRNWyUHJRSUyERZDDX6]F]XUyZ:NLOND
FKZLOSRX \FLX&LULRJDUQ DR OHSLDM FDHXIRULDNV]WDW\Z\RVWU]\\NRQWXU\
ZLDWRLEDUZ\]DNX\RF]\]DSDFK\SRGUD QL\QRVG ZL NL]UREL\VL
QLH]QR QLHJR QHDZV]\VWNRGRRNRDVWDRVL QLHUHDOQHXORWQHQLF]\PVHQQH
PDU]HQLH%\\VFKRG\E\\ PLHUG] FHFL NLPNXU]HPDUUDV\LWDSLVHULHE\
FKUDSOLZ\ PLHFKPDUNL]\GH1HPHQWK8\YDU%\RSRGZyU]HE\\V]\ENLH
NURSOHGHV]F]XQDWZDU]\V]DUSQL FLHREUR \NWyU ZFL PLDDQDV]\L2JURPQ\
EXG\QHN]GUHZQLDQ ZLH L ZLHONLPREU]\GOLZLHNLF]RZDW\PPDOXQNLHPQD
IURQWRQLH0DOXQHNSU]HGVWDZLDSV\N VDM FHSRWZRUDQLWRVPRNDQLWRJU\IDQL
'RSUDZG\"/HR":LHV]RF]\PPyZLSDQVHQHV]DO"
%H]NSLQ1DVWXSL WQDVWXMHVW3R)DON SU]\MHFKDOL P\'DZDMFLHQDPM ER
E G]LH OH
1LHSRMPXM WZHMHNVF\WDFML,PEUD]PDUV]F]\EUZL+RXYHQDJKHO$OH
]ZUDFDPXZDJ WXQLH*HVRDQL]LHPLHZDV]HJREDURQDVRELHSDQD% G]LHFLH
KDDV\F]\QLLLQNRPRGRZDWRZDVND VW G EL]XQDPLSU]HS G]L
%H]XUD]\SDQLH+RXYHQDJKHO]PLW\JRZDVL :LQGVRU,PEUD$OHSUDZR]D
QDPL2EHFQ\WX%RQKDUWSU]\RELHFD)DON SDQXEDURQRZL&DVDGHL6RZRGD
1LHFK H VL ] GDQHJRVRZDZ\ZL H
/HR"+RXYHQDJKHO]DWU] VSROLF]NDPL:LHV]RF]\PRQJDGD"
:LHPLUDFM PXSU]\]QDM %RQKDUWZVWDQLHGEDOHPDFKQ U N 1LHE G
RSRQRZDDQLF]\QLVXELHNFML']LHZF]\QDRWJG]LHZV]\VF\ZLG] .RPXZROD
QLHFKM ELHU]H
:LQGVRU,PEUDRVXSLDZDUJD]DGUJDDPXVLOQLH
H MDN"
']LHZF]\QDSRZWyU]\%RQKDUWPUXJDM F GR+RXYHQDJKHODMHVWGODWHJR
NWRM ]HFKFH]DUHQ\]DEUD \Z OXEPDUWZ SRGXJJXVWXLVPDNX
H MDN"
3VLDNUHZSDFMHQFM WUDF SRPDX%RQKDUWXGDWQLHXGD]R 1LFLQRMDNL
MDN.DWDU\QNDFKROHUQD-DN"$WDNMDNVRELHFKFHV]:RODWZRMDWRPL VR]DWUXM
MDGHPU]XMHMMDNZLOF]\F\$OHQLHZLHPF]\RQD]H UH1DJXSL QLHZ\JO GD
FR"1LH,PEUD.WRFKFHM GRVWDPXVLVL GRQLHMVDPSRIDW\JRZD7DPQD
DUHQ &KFHV])DONL"7RELHU]M
7\PLW )DON SRGQRVSRGVXZDV]QLE\VXPRZL DE QDZ G]LH]DZDUF]D
:LQGVRU,PEUD1LHXIDPFL%RQKDUW1RVHPF]XM H HOD]Q\KDNZWHM
SU]\Q FLHXNU\W\VLHG]L
&]XHJRQD HOD]RQRVDSRJUDWXORZD%RQKDUWZVWDZ\M VSRGODZ\
RWU]\PDQ\Z)DQRPLHF]Z\FL JQ JR]SRFKZ\LU]XFLQDDUHQ WDN]U F]QLH H
EU]HV]F]RWZELVL Z SLDVHNSLRQRZRGZDNURNLSU]HG&LUL2WMHVWL HOD]R
-DZQHZFDOHQLHXNU\WH%RMDRW G]LHZN QLHVWRM NWRFKFHQLHFKM ELHU]H
-H OLM Z]L ]GRD
0DUNL]DGH1HPHQWK8\YDU]D PLDDVL QHUZRZR
-H OLM Z]L ]GRDSRZWyU]\DVZ\PSU]HSLW\PNRQWUDOWHP%RWHUD]MX
FLDHF]NRPDPLHF]%UDZRPR FL%RQKDUW:VWU WQ\PPLVL ]GDZDRFLDHF]NR
EH]EURQQHZ\GDQDSDVWZ W\FKDSVHUGDNyZ
3DQLH+RXYHQDJKHO:LQGVRU,PEUDZ]L VL SRGERNLQLH]DV]F]\FDM F
FKXGHMDU\VWRNUDWNLQDZHWVSRMU]HQLHP7RSRGSD VN VL DXVSLFM WHMDVHND
Z\SUDZLDERZ G\WHDWUXPZDV]H5]HNQLMFLHPLMHQRZHGOHF]\LFKUHJXL
SUDZLGHLJUDWXPDP\ZDV]\FKOLF]\WH %RQKDUWRZ\FK"
:HGXJWHDWUDOQ\FK]DUHFKRWD+RXYHQDJKHOWU] V F EU]XFKHPLEXOGR \PL
SROLF]NDPL%RFKRSUDZG MHVW H WHDWUXPPRMHWRZV]DN H NOLHQWQDV]SDQRQ
SDFLRQZ\PDJD7RNOLHQWXVWDQDZLDUHJX\0\]D NXSF\ZHGOHW\FKUHJX
SRVW SRZDPXVLP\F]HJRNOLHQW GDWRWU]HEDMHPXGD
.OLHQW"=QDF]\WHOXG]LH":LQGVRU,PEUDV]HURNLPJHVWHPSRZLyGSR
Z\SHQLRQ\FKDZDFK7HZV]\VWNLHOXG]LHSU]\V]OLWXL]DSDFLOLE\VL
G]LZRZLVNXG]LZRZD"
,QWHUHVMHVWLQWHUHVRGU]HN+RXYHQDJKHO-H OLMHVWQDFR SRS\WF]HPXWHJR
QLHVSU]HGDZD"3DF OXG]LH]DEyMZLONyZ"=DZDONLHQGULDJLDDUGYDUNyZ"=D
V]F]ZDQLHSVyZQDERUVXNDZEHF]FHDOERQDZLZHUQ " &]HPXW\VL WDNG]LZLV]
,PEUD"/XG]LRPLJU]\VNDLKHFHV MDNFKOHESRWU]HEQHEDEDUG]LHMDQL HOLFKOHE
:LHOX]W\FKFRWXSU]\V]OLRGXVWVRELHRGM WR$VSyMU]QDQLFKMDNLPVL RF]\
ZLHF 'RF]HNDVL QLHPRJ E\VL KHFD]DF] D
$OHQDKHF\GRGD%RQKDUWX PLHFKQL W\]MDGOLZLHSR]RU\FKRVSRUWX
]DFKRZDQHE\PXV] -D ZLHFQLPJRVREDN ]EHF]NLZ\ZOHN PR H N VD
] ELVNDPLWDNMHVWVSRUWRZR$G]LHZF]\QDPDNOLQJ 1LHFKLWXE G]LHVSRUWRZR
&RGREU]\OXG]LH"0DPUDFM "
'REU]\OXG]LHQLHVNDGQ\PDF]JURPNLPLUDGRVQ\PFKyUHPSRWZLHUG]LOL H
%RQKDUWPDUDFM Z FDHMUR]FL JR FL
%DURQ&DVDGHLU]HNZROQR:LQGVRU,PEUDQLHUDGE G]LHSDQLH
+RXYHQDJKHOU F] ZDP H E G]LHQLHUDG1LHZLHPF]\ZDUWRZDPZ]ZDG ]
QLPZFKRG]L
,QWHUHVMHVWLQWHUHVSRZWyU]\+RXYHQDJKHOLSRUXV]\SROLF]NDPL%DURQ
&DVDGHLZLHRW\PGREU]HVLDSLHQL G]\RQXPQLHQDPD\SURFHQWSR \F]\D
JG\SU]\MG]LHE\MHV]F]HSR \F]\ZWHG\MDNR QDV]H]ZDG\]DDG]LP\$OHQLH
E G]LHPLVL MDNL ]DJUDQLF]Q\SDQEDURQZWU FDZSU\ZDWQ L LQG\ZLGXDOQ
SU]HGVL ELRUF]R 7XV ]DNDG\SRURELRQHDOXG]LH]DZHM FLH]DSDFLOL:WHQ
SLDVHNWDPQDDUHQLHPXVLZVL NQ NUHZ
0XVL"UR]GDUVL :LQGVRU,PEUDDMQRSVLH2WNRUFLPQLHE\ZDP
SRND]D H QLHPXVLZFDOH2WZ\MG VW G LSUHF]VRELHSRMDG ZVWHF]VL DQL
RJO GDM F:WHG\ZDVQ VHWXNUHZZ\WDF]DMFLH0QLHPLHU]LVDPDP\ OE\
PRWRFKRZLXFLHFK\SU]\VSDU]D
1LHFK H LG]LH]WXPXZ\VW SLQDJOH]DUR QL W\D SRRF]\W\SZNXEUDNX]
NR VNLHMVNyU\1LHFK H LG]LHMH OLMHJRPLHU]L0QLHWDPQLHPLHU]L0yZLOL H
NWRW 6]F]XU]\F XVLHF]HZH PLHQDJURG -DVL ]JDV]DPLQDDUHQ ZFKRG]
$WDNLHJR]DZU]DVQ QDJOHMHGHQ]OXG]L,PEU\QLHZ\VRNLOHF] \ODVW\L
PRFQR]EXGRZDQ\P F]\]QD:RV\PLDEXMQHSRWDUJDQHLVNRWXQLRQH
0\ ZDSLHUZVLE\OL3UDZGDFKRS\"
%DZLHU ]DZWyURZDGUXJLFKXG\]HVSLF]DVW EUyGN 3U]\QDV
SLHUZV]H VWZR$W\VL KRQRUHPQLHXQR :LQGVRU&R]WHJR H F]HU VL
SU]\JO GD")DONDQDDUHQLHZ\VWDUF]\U N Z\FL JQ LZ]L $FKDPVWZRQLHFK
Z\WU]HV]F]DJD\QDPSOXQDWR
,MHV]F]HQDPFR VNDSQ QDERNXJRWRZR]DU DWU]HFLXVWURMRQ\ZGXEOHWR
\ZHMEDUZLHDPDUDQWX-DNVSRUWWRVSRUWQLHWDNOLSDQLH+RXYHQDJKHO"-DN
KHFDWRKHFD%\DWXRMDNLHMVLQDJURG]LHPRZD
+RXYHQDJKHOX PLHFKQ VL V]HURNRLSU]\WDNQ NLZQL FLHPJRZ\GXPQLHL
PDMHVWDW\F]QLHWU] V F REZLV\PLSROLF]NDPL
$MDN]DFLHNDZLVL WHQ]EUyGN ]DNDG\VWRM "
1DUD]LH]D PLDVL NXSLHFZ\QLNXZDONLMHV]F]HVL QLHREVWDZLD1DUD]LH
MHQRWU]\GRMHGQHJRVWRL H QLMHGHQ]ZDVQLHR PLHOLVL ZHM GRRJURG]LH FD
3KXXXXZU]DVQ .R VND6NyUD-DVL R PLHO -DPJRWyZ
0R FLDSDQQR]DZU]DVQ :LQGVRU,PEUDJHVWDPLSU]\ZRXM F
SRGNRPHQGQ\FK3RUDQLRQ\FKSR]ZyO]DEUD3R]ZyOZHM QDDUHQ L ]DEUD
LFKQLPVL Z\NUZDZL L SRPU % G H OXG]NDPR FLDSDQQR
/XG]NDSRZWyU]\D]Z\VLNLHP&LULF]XM FMDNGRSLHURWHUD]]DF]\QDELZ
QL DGUHQDOLQD2SDQRZDDVL V]\ENRVHUL Z\XF]RQ\FKRGGHFKyZ:HMG FLHL
]DELHU]FLHLFKSRZLHG]LDD$OHZHMG FLHEH]EURQL% G FLHLZ\OXG]F\
&KRFLD UD]
1LHHHHHU\F]DLVNDQGRZDWXP=DEL=DEL
:\SRGHE\GODNL&LULRGZUyFLDVL WDQHF]QLHZLRG F Z]URNLHPSR
WU\EXQDFKLDZNDFK:\QLNF]HPQH ZLQLH:\NDQDOLH:\VNXUZ\V\Q\
SDUV]\ZH&KFHFLHNUZL"&KRG FLHWX]HMG FLHSRVPDNXMFLHLSRZ FKDMFLH
:\OL FLHSyNLQLHVNU]HSD%\GODNL:DPSLU\
0DUNL]DM NQ D]DG\JRWDDSU]HZUyFLDRF]DPLLPL NNRSU]\OJQ DGR
%RQKDUWDQLHZ\MPXM F U N VSRPL G]\XG%RQKDUWVNU]\ZLVL L RGVXQ M RG
VLHELHZFDOHQLHVLO F VL QDGHOLNDWQR 7XPZ\.WR U]XFLQDDUHQ
SRJU\]LRQ NLHEDV NWR LQQ\EXWMHV]F]HNWR FLVQ RJyUNLHPFHOXM F Z&LUL
5R]VLHNDRJyUHNXGHU]HQLHPPLHF]DZ]EXG]DM F MHV]F]HJR QLHMV]\U\N
:LQGVRU,PEUDLMHJROXG]LHSRGQLH OL$PDUDQWDL.R VN 6NyU $PDUDQWJG\
JRUXV]RQR]DU\F]D.R VND6NyUDQDWRPLDVW]HPGOD.RWXQL6WDYURQLHGDZDOL
MX DGQ\FK]QDNyZ \FLD&LULFRIQ DVL WDNE\VWDMDNQDMGDOHMMDNW\ONR
SR]ZDODDDUHQD/XG]LH,PEU\WH VWDUDOLVL WU]\PDRGQLHMQDG\VWDQV
:LQGVRU,PEUDVWDQLHUXFKRPR&]HNDD Z\WDV]F] UDQQ\FKL]DELW\FK
3DWU]\QD&LULVSRG]PUX RQ\FKSRZLHNDGR PLDQDU NRMH FLPLHF]DNWyUHJR
PLPRSU]\U]HF]HQLDQLHRGSDVDZFKRG] F QDDUHQ
1LHRVWU]HJDOHGZRSRUXV]DM F ZDUJDPL1LH]PXV]DMPQLH3URV]
,PEUDE\EODG\7XPWXSDU\F]DLZ\
1LHVXFKDMMHM%RQKDUW]QRZXSU]HNU]\F]DUHMZDFK'RE G PLHF]D:
SU]HFLZQ\PUD]LHSyMG]LHZ ZLDW H WFKyU]L]DVUDQLHF2G$OE\SR-DUXJ
JR QRE G]LH H :LQGVRU,PEUDXFLHNSU]HGPDROHWQL G]LHZF]\Q SRGNXOLZV]\
RJRQMDNNXQGHO
.OLQJD,PEU\QDFDOZ\VXQ DVL ] SRFKZ\
1LHSRZLHG]LDD&LUL
.OLQJDVFKRZDDVL
7FKyU]]DU\F]DNWR ] WXPX*yZQRMDG=DM F]DVNyUD
,PEUD]NDPLHQQ WZDU] SRGV]HGGRVNUDMXDUHQ\1LPFKZ\FLZ\FL JQL WH]
JyU\U FHNDPUDWyZRGZUyFLVL MHV]F]HUD]
&K\EDZLHV]FRFL F]HNDG]LHZNRSRZLHG]LDFLFKR&K\EDMX ZLHV]NLP
MHVW/HR%RQKDUW&K\EDMX ZLHV]FR/HR%RQKDUWSRWUDIL&RJRSRGQLHFD
% G]LHV]Z\S\FKDQDQDDUHQ\% G]LHV]]DELMDQDXFLHFK WDNLP ZLQLRPL
VZRRF]RPMDNWHWXWDM,MHV]F]HJRUV]\PRGQLFK$JG\MX WR H W\]DELMDV]
SU]HVWDQLHLFKEDZLJG\%RQKDUWD]QXG]L]DGDZDQ\FLJZDWZWHG\]DELM FLHELH
:\SXV]F] QDDUHQ W\OX H QLH]GRDV]REURQLSOHFyZ$OERZ\SXV]F] SV\,
SV\FL UR]WDUJDM DF]HU QDZLGRZQLE G]LHQLXFKDNUHZLELEUDZR$W\
]GHFKQLHV]QDXEURF]RQ\PSLDVNX7DNMDNG]LVLDMFLNWyU\FKSRVLHNDD
:VSRPQLV]PRMHVRZD
-DNZLG]LV]PLDUDFM SRZLHG]LDD]Z\VLNLHP&LUL1LH]GRDDP
9\VRJRWDPLOF]D7U]\PDVNyUN QXWULL1LHUXFKRPR2GGX V]HJRF]DVX
1LHPDO]DSRPQLDRWHMVNyUFHVXFKDM F
6WFKyU]\DP%\DPWFKyU]HP,]DSDFLDP]DWR7DNMDNSDFLND G\WFKyU]
%yOHPKD E SDVNXGQ\PXSRNRU]HQLHP,RNURSQ\PZVWU WHPGRVLHELHVDPHM
9\VRJRWDPLOF]D
5R]G]LD
.WRSU]HOHZDNUHZF]RZLHNDWHJRNUHZSU]H]F]RZLHNDE G]LHSU]HODQD
*HQHVLV
9\VRJRWD]&RUYR
&]HJR:LHG PLQV]XNDQDPRLPWHUHQLH"SRZWyU]\S\WDQLH)XONR$UWHYHOGH
SUHIHNW]5LHGEUXQHZ\UD QLHMX ]QLHFLHUSOLZLRQ\SU]HGX DM F VL FLV] 6N G
:LHG PLQSU]\E\ZD"'RN G ]PLHU]D":MDNLPFHOX"
7DNRWRNR F]\VL ]DEDZDZGREUHXF]\QNLSRP\ OD*HUDOWSDWU] F QD
SR]QDF]RQH]JUXELD\PLEOL]QDPLREOLF]HSUHIHNWD7DNNR F]\VL RGJU\ZDQLH
V]ODFKHWQHJRZLHG PLQDJZROLPLRVLHUG]LDGODEDQG\]DIDMGDQ\FKOH Q\FKOXG]L
7DNNR F]\VL SUDJQLHQLHOXNVXVXLQRFRZDQLHZREHU DFKZNWyU\FK]DZV]H
]QDMG]LHVL V]SLFHO7DNLHV VNXWNLSRGUy RZDQLD]JDGX ZLHUV]RNOHW 2WR
VLHG] WHUD]ZSU]\SRPLQDM F\PFHO SRPLHV]F]HQLXEH]RNLHQQDWZDUG\P
SU]\PRFRZDQ\PGRSRGRJLNU]H OHGODSU]HVXFKLZDQ\FKDQDRSDUFLXWHJR
NU]HVDQLHVSRVyEWHJRQLH]DXZD \V XFKZ\W\LVNyU]DQHSDVNL'R
VNU SRZDQLDU N LXQLHUXFKRPLHQLDV]\L1DUD]LHQLHX \WRLFKDOHV
, MDNGRMDVQHMFKROHU\PDPVL WHUD]]Z\ZLQ ]WHMNDED\"
NRPSDQLD \ZR]DSURWHVWRZDD
'\VSRQXM F SLHQL G]PLRGEDUWQLNyZR ZLDGF]\OL5HJLVL&DKLUL]QDMGXM F VL
Z PLH FLHJG]LHKDQGOXMHVL ZV]\VWNLPQDOH \ X]XSHQLSURZLDQWLHNZLSXQHN,
GRNXSLVWU]DGRGDD0LOYDERRGQLHMFL JOHZ\PDJDVL G]LF]\]Q\DRQDQLH
E G]LHVWU]HOD]DVWUXJDQ\PLSDW\NDPL&KRFLD MHGQ QRFSU]HVSDVL Z y NXZ
]DMH G]LHGRGD-DVNLHUSRR \ZV]\VL GRWHJRy NDSRN SLHOLL]PL\PSLZQ\P
UDXV]HP
'UXLG]LX]QDOLZV]\VF\FKyUHPQLHXFLHNQ
&KRMHVWWRDEVROXWQ\]ELHJRNROLF]QR FLGRGD]G]LZQ\PX PLHFKHP
ZDPSLU5HJLVDOHQDV]DGUX \QDMHVWQDDEVROXWQLHZD FLZHMGURG]H]PLHU]DZ
DEVROXWQLHZD FLZ\PNLHUXQNX-HVWQDP]DWHPHZLGHQWQLHLDEVROXWQLH
SU]H]QDF]RQHE\GRGUXLGyZWUDILG]LH OXEGZD]ZRNLQLHPDM ]QDF]HQLD
&RVL ]D W\F]\SR SLHFKXGRR \ILOR]RILF]QLHWRZUD HQLH H F]DV
RNURSQLHQDJOLMHVW]D]Z\F]DMV\JQDHPDODUPRZ\PQDND]XM F\P]ZROQLWHPSR
G]LDDSRPDXL]QDOH \W\PUR]P\VHP
*HUDOWQLHRSRQRZDLQLHNyFLVL =ILOR]RIL ZDPSLUDWH QLHFKRFLD
QDZLHG]DM FHJRQRFDPLG]LZDF]QHVHQQHNRV]PDU\UDF]HMVNDQLD\GRSR SLHFKX
3RPLPRIDNWX H WUH FLW\FKNRV]PDUyZQLHE\VRELHZVWDQLHSU]\SRPQLHSR
SU]HEXG]HQLX
%\VLHGHPQDVW\ZU]H QLDSHQLD'RMHVLHQQHJR(NZLQRNFMXP]RVWDZDRV]H
GQL
0LOYD5HJLVL&DKLUZ]L OLQDVLHELH]DGDQLHSRF]\QLHQLD]DNXSyZL
VNRPSOHWRZDQLDHNZLSXQNX*HUDOWL-DVNLHUPLHOL]D SU]HSURZDG]LZ\ZLDGL
]DVL JQ M ]\NDZPLDVWHF]NX5LHGEUXQH
3RR RQHZ]DNROXU]HNL1HZL5LHGEUXQHE\RPLDVWHF]NLHPQLHZLHONLPMH OL
EUDSRGXZDJ ]ZDUW PXURZDQ L GUHZQLDQ ]DEXGRZ ZHZQ WU]SLHU FLHQLD
QDMH RQ\FKSDOLVDG ZDyZ]LHPQ\FK$OH]ZDUWD]DEXGRZD]DZDDPLVWDQRZLD
REHFQLHW\ONRFHQWUXPPLDVWDD \PRJDWXQLHZL FHMQL MHGQDG]LHVL WD
SRSXODFML']LHZL G]LHVL W\FKE\WRZDR]D Z KDD OLZ\PPRU]XRWDF]DM F\FK
ZD\FKDWFKDXSV]DDVyZEXGV]RSQDPLRWyZLVX F\FKMDNRPLHV]NDQLD
ZR]yZ
=DFLFHURQHVX \ZLHG PLQRZLLSRHFLHNUHZQLDNEDUWQLNDPRG\FZDQ\L
DURJDQFNLW\SRZ\HJ]HPSODU]PLHMVNLHJRRELMEUXNDNWyU\ZU\QV]WRNXVL URG]L
Z QLHMHGQ\PU\QV]WRNXVL N SDLZQLHMHGQ\PSUDJQLHQLHJDVL:PLHMVNLP
]JLHNXWRNXEUXG]LHLVPURG]LHF]XVL yZPRG]LDQMDNSVWU J ZNU\VWDOLF]QHM
JyUVNLHME\VWU]\QLHDPR OLZR RSURZDG]HQLDNRJR SRVZ\PRGUD DM F\P
PLH FLHHZLGHQWQLHJRUDGRZDD1LHSU]HMPXM F VL IDNWHP H QLNWRQLFJRQLH
S\WDXOLF]QLN]]DSDHPXG]LHODZ\MD QLH :\MD QL H 5LHGEUXQHVWDQRZLZD Q\
HWDSGODRVDGQLNyZQLOIJDDUG]NLFKZ GUXM F\FKQDSyQRFSRSU]\RELHFDQHSU]H]
FHVDU]DQDGDQLHF]WHU\DQ\F]\OLOHNNROLF] F SL VHWPyUJ,GRWHJRMHV]F]H
G]LHVL FLROHWQL ZROQL]Q SRGDWNRZ 5LHGEUXQHOH \ ERZLHPZZ\ORFLH
SU]HFLQDM FHM*yU\$PHOOGROLQ\'RO1HZLSRSU]H]SU]H F]7KHRGXO F] FHM
6WRNLL=DU]HF]H]0DJ7XUJD*HVR0HWLQQ L 0DHFKWNUDMDPLMX RGGDZQD
SRGOHJ\PLQLOIJDDUG]NLHPXLPSHULXP0LDVWR5LHGEUXQHZ\MD QLXOLF]QLNMHVW
GODRVDGQLNyZRVWDWQLPPLHMVFHPZNWyU\PPRJ MHV]F]HOLF]\QDFR ZL FHMQL
&R:LHG PLQURELQD6WRNDFK"&]HJRWXV]XND"
7\PNWyU\S\WDQLH]DGDE\EDUF]\VW\FLHPQRZRV\P F]\]QD]WZDU]
SU]\R]GRELRQ EUX]GDPLEOL]QLVNyU]DQ NODSN ]DNU\ZDM F OHZ\RF]RGy:
FLHPQHMXOLF]FHZLGRNWHMF\NORSLHMWZDU]\]GROHQE\Z\GU]HM N ]JUR]\]
QLHMHGQHMSLHUVL$MDN H QLHVXV]QLH]ZD \ZV]\ H E\DWRWZDU]SDQD)XOND
$UWHYHOGHSUHIHNWD5LHGEUXQHQDMZ\ V]HJRUDQJ VWUy D SUDZDLSRU] GNXZFDHM
RNROLF\
&]HJR:LHG PLQV]XNDQD6WRNDFK"SRZWyU]\QDMZ\ V]\UDQJ VWUy SUDZD
Z FDHMRNROLF\
*HUDOWZHVWFKQ Z]UXV]\UDPLRQDPLXGDM F RERM WQR
.WRWRMHVW$QJRXOHPH"
']LHZF]\QD]QRZXSRFL JQ DQRVHPSRFK\OLDJRZ Z\WU]HV]F]\DQD
*HUDOWDZLHONLHRF]\2U]HFKRZHQLH]LHORQH3RWHPSRWU] VQ DQLHSRU] GQ
JU]\Z MD QLXWNLFKMDNVRPDZRVyZQLHSRVXV]Q\PLSDVHPNDPLVSDGDM F\FKQD
EUZL
: \FLXJRQLHZLG]LDDPREOL]DDNUHZNWyUD FLHNDMHMQDZDUJ $OH
ZLHPNWRRQ]DF]-X ZDPWR]UHV]W PyZLDPSDQLH)XONRWHUD]ZLHFLH H QLH
JDDP2QQD]\ZDVL *HUDOW-HVWZLHG PLQHP-DNLH G]LHVL GQLWHPX
SU]HNURF]\-DUXJ L ]PLHU]DZNLHUXQNX7RXVVDLQW=JDG]DVL ELDRZRV\ZXMFLX"
0RGHWR3RFKHSRZLHG]LDV]\ENRVWUD QLN]QLHMDNLPQLHSRNRMHP
SDWU] F QDSUHIHNWD$OH)XONR$UWHYHOGHVNU]\ZLVL W\ONRLSRNU FLJRZ
7\MHV]F]HQDV]DIRFLHE G]LHV]ILUOHMHVWURL$QJRXOHPH'REUDMHG]LHP\
GDOHM=NLPZHGXJFLHELHWHQ H :LHG PLQ*HUDOWSRGUy XMH"
7H ZDPMX PyZLDP=SU]\VWRMQLDNLHPRLPLHQLX-DVNLHUNWyU\MHVW
WUXEDGXUHPLZR]L]HVRE OXWQL =PRG NRELHW NWyUDPDZRV\FLHPQREORQG
REFL WHQDNDUNX-HMLPLHQLDQLH]QDP,]P F]\]Q MHGQ\PEH]RSLVXLPL WH
QLHE\RZ\PLHQLDQH5D]HPMHVWLFKF]ZyUND
*HUDOWRSDUSRGEUyGHNQDNQ\NFLDFK]]DLQWHUHVRZDQLHPSU]\JO GDM F VL
G]LHZF]\QLH$QJRXOHPHQLHVSX FLDZ]URNX
$OH W\PDV]RF]\SRZLHG]LDD2F]\G]LZRF]\
'DOHMGDOHM$QJRXOHPHSRQDJOLNU]\ZL F VL SDQ)XONR.WRMHV]F]H
QDOH \ GRWHMZLHG PL VNLHMNRPSDQLL"
1LNW0yZLDPMHVWLFKF]ZRUR8V]XQLHPDV]ZXMFLX"
*HVWNODVQ RSRFLHNR6WUD QLNSRPDVRZDGR R ELRGURSRZVWU]\PXM F VL
RGXZDJRSRFKR FLPRG]LH \
HV]$QJRXOHPHSRZLHG]LDSUHIHNW,OXLFKMHVWS\WDPSRUD]ZWyU\"
-DNVRELHFKFHFLHSDQLH)XONR-DNVRELHFKFHFLH:DV]DZROD-HVWLFKGZXVWX
7U]\VWX6]H FLXVHW
3DQLHSUHIHNFLH*HUDOWV]\ENRLRVWURXSU]HG]LUR]ND]ELFLD=RVWDZP\WR
MH OLPR QD7RFRSRZLHG]LDDMHVWQDW\OHSUHF\]\MQH H RNDPVWZLHPRZ\E\
QLHPR HUDF]HMRQLHGRLQIRUPRZDQLX$OHVN G RQDPDLQIRUPDFMH"6DPD
SU]\]QDD H ZLG]LPQLHSRUD]SLHUZV]\Z \FLX-DM WH ZLG] SRUD]SLHUZV]\
=DU F]DPZDP
']L NXM $UWHYHOGHVSRMU]DQDQLHJRNU]\ZR]DSRPRFZ OHG]WZLH-DN H
FHQQ *G\]DF]Q SU]HVXFKLZDZDVOLF] H RND HFLHVL UyZQLHZ\PRZQL
$QJRXOHPHV\V]DD FRSRZLHG]LDSDQ:LHG PLQ"0yZ,QLHND VL SRQDJOD
%\RSRZLHG]LDQHG]LHZF]\QDREOL]DDFLHNQ F ] QRVDNUHZ H MH OL
ZDG]RPGRQLH RMDNLHM SODQRZDQHM]EURGQLMH OLZ\GDNWRSODQXMHMDNLH
RWURVWZRWRE G]LHDVNDRND]DQD1RWRMDPyZL QLH":LHPRV]\NRZDQHM
]EURGQLFKF ]DSRELHF]HPXF]\QRZL6XFKDMFLHFRSRZLHP6RZLNLMHJRKDQ]D
F]HNDM Z %HOKDYHQQDWHJRWXZLHG PLQDLPDM JRWDPXWXF1DGDLPWHQ
NRQWUDNWMHGHQSyHOIREF\F]DUWZLHVN G SU]\E\\QLNWJRQLH]QD:V]\VWNR
SRZLHG]LDWHQSyHOINWRMDNZ\JO GDVN G SU]\E G]LHNLHG\SU]\E G]LHZ
MDNLHMNRPSDQLL8SU]HG]L H WR:LHG PLQ H QLHE\OHIUDMHUOHF]ZLN HE\QLH
JUD]XFKyZDOHZSOHF\SFKQ ]NXV]\XVWU]HOLDQDMOHSLHMRWUXJG\E\JG]LH
NRURQQ\G]LHZF]\QD]URELDSU]HFLH VZRMH
-HV]F]HQLH
-DNWR"
+RPHU6WUDJJHQ]ZDQ\6RZLNLHPWRZ\M WNRZRQLHEH]SLHF]Q\RWU2NUXWQ\
L EH]F]HOQ\SU]HELHJ\LQLHJXSLDSU]\W\PPDM F\V]F] FLH-HJREH]NDUQR
]DFK FDLQQ\FK0XV] ] W\PVNR F]\'ODWHJRSRV]HGHPQDXNDG\]
$QJRXOHPH2ELHFDHP H MH OLVNXWNLHPMHMZ\]QDQLD6RZLN]RVWDQLHXM W\D
MHJRV]DMNDUR]ELWD$QJRXOHPH]RVWDQLHSRZLHV]RQD
6XFKDP":LHG PLQQLHSU]HVDG]L]H]G]LZLHQLHP7RWDNWXZ\JO GD
LQVW\WXFMDNRURQQHJR ZLDGND":]DPLDQ]DZVSySUDF ] ZDG]DPLVWU\F]HN"$
]DRGPRZ ZVSySUDF\FR"
3DO3RSU]HG]RQ\Z\XSLHQLHPRF]XLV]DUSDQLHPSLHUVLUR]SDORQ\PL
REF JDPL
:LHG PLQQLHSRZLHG]LDDQLVRZD
7RVL QD]\ZDSU]\NDGJUR]\SRGM SRFKZLOL)XONR$UWHYHOGH5]HF]
DEVROXWQLHNRQLHF]QDZZDOFH]EDQG\W\]PHP&]HPX WR]DFLVNDFLHSL FL H
QLHPDOV\V] FKU] VWNQ\NFL"-HVWH FLHPR H ]ZROHQQLNLHP]DELMDQLD
KXPDQLWDUQHJR"6WDZDVQDWHQOXNVXVZDOF]\FLHSU]HFLH JyZQLH]LVWRWDPL
NWyUHMDNE\WR PLHV]QLHQLHEU]PLDRWH ]DELMDM KXPDQLWDUQLH0QLHQDWDNL
OXNVXVQLHVWD-DZLG]LDHPNXSLHFNLHNDUDZDQ\LGRP\RJUDELRQHSU]H]6RZLND
L MHPXSRGREQ\FK:LG]LDHPFRURELRQROXG]LRPE\ZVND]DOLVNU\WNLOXEZ\GDOL
PDJLF]QHKDVDV]NDWXLNDV:LG]LDHPNRELHW\XNWyU\FK6RZLNQR HP
VSUDZG]DF]\QLHXNU\\NRV]WRZQR FL:LG]LDHPOXG]LNWyU\PMHV]F]HJRUV]H
U]HF]\URELRQRW\ONRJZROL]EyMHFNLHM]DEDZ\$QJRXOHPHNWyUHMORVWDNZDV
Z]UXV]DEUDDXG]LDZWDNLFK]DEDZDFKWRSHZQH'RVWDWHF]QLHGXJRE\DZ
EDQG]LH$JG\E\QLHF]\VW\SU]\SDGHNJG\E\QLHWR H ]EDQG\XFLHNDQLNWQLH
GRZLHG]LDE\VL R ]DVDG]FHZ%HOKDYHQDZ\SR]QDOLE\ FLHM Z LQQ\VSRVyE
0R H WRRQDVWU]HOLDE\ZDPZSOHF\]NXV]\
1LHOXEL JG\EDQLD=QDQ\MHVWZDPSRZyGGODNWyUHJRXFLHND]V]DMNL"
-HM]H]QDQLDE\\ZWHMNZHVWLLP WQHDPRLPOXG]LRPQLHFKFLDRVL
G\ZXOJRZD$OHZV]\VF\ZLHG] H 6RZLNQDOH \ GRP F]\]Q
VSURZDG]DM F\FKNRELHW\GRUROLSRZLHG]LDE\PSLHUZRWQLHQDWXUDOQHM-H OL
LQDF]HMPXQLHZ\FKRG]LQDU]XFDNRELHWRPW URO VL 'RWHJRGRV]\]
SHZQR FL NRQIOLNW\SRNROHQLRZH6RZLNWRP F]\]QDGRMU]D\DRVWDWQLD
NRPSDQLD$QJRXOHPHWRV]F]HQLDNLWDNLHVDPHMDNRQD$OHWRV VSHNXODFMHZ
JUXQFLHU]HF]\QLFPQLHWRQLHREFKRG]L$ZDVSR]ZRO VRELHVS\WDGODF]HJRWR
WDNREFKRG]L"'ODF]HJRRGSLHUZV]HJRZHMU]HQLD$QJRXOHPHZ\ZRXMHZZDVWDN
\ZHHPRFMH"
']LZQHS\WDQLH']LHZF]\QDGRQRVLR]DPDFKXMDNRE\V]\NRZDQ\PQDPQLH
SU]H]MHME\\FKNDPUDWyZQD]OHFHQLHMDNLHJR SyHOID5]HF]VDPDZVRELH
VHQVDF\MQDDOERZLHPQLHPDP DGQ\FK]DGDZQLRQ\FKZD QL] DGQ\PLSyHOIDPL
']LHZF]\QDQDGWRZLHZMDNLPWRZDU]\VWZLHSRGUy XM =WDNLPLV]F]HJyDPLMDN
WR H WUXEDGXUPDQDLPL -DVNLHUDNRELHWDPDREFL W\ZDUNRF]7HQZDUNRF]
ZD QLHVSUDZLD H SRGHMU]HZDPZW\PZV]\VWNLPNDPVWZROXESURZRNDFM 7R
E\DE\ DGQDV]WXNDGRSD LZ\S\WDNWyUHJR ] OH Q\FKEDUWQLNyZ]NWyU\PL
Z GURZDHPRVWDWQLW\G]LH ,V]\ENR]DLQVFHQL]RZD
'R $UWHYHOGHKXNQ SL FL Z VWy1DGWRPLVL WXUR]S G]DFLHPyM
SDQLH=QDF]\WRMDPLDE\PQLE\FR WXLQVFHQL]RZD"$ZMDNLPWRFHOX"%\ZDV
RV]XNDXVLGOL"$NLPWRZ\MHVWH FLHE\VL WDNO NDSURZRNDFMLLXVLGODQLD"
7\ONRQD]RG]LHMXF]DSNDJRUHSDQLHZLHG PLQLH7\ONRQD]RG]LHMX
3RGDMFLHPLLQQHZ\WXPDF]HQLH
1LHWRZ\PLMHSRGDMFLH
3U]\NURPL1LHPDPWDNRZHJR
0yJE\PFR SRGSRZLHG]LHSUHIHNWX PLHFKQ VL ]R OLZLH$OHSRFR"
3RVWDZP\VSUDZ MDVQR0QLHQLHLQWHUHVXMHNWRFKFHZLG]LHZDVPDUWZ\PLL
GODF]HJR1LHREFKRG]LPQLHVN G WHQNWR PDRZDVWDNLH ZLHWQHLQIRUPDFMHGR
NRORUXLGXJR FLZRVyZZ F]QLH3RZLHPMHV]F]HZL FHMMDPyJE\PZRJyOH
QLHSRZLDGDPLDFL R W\P]DPDFKXZLHG PLQLH0yJE\PVSRNRMQLHSRWUDNWRZD
ZDV] NRPSDQL MDNRQLH ZLDGRP QLF]HJRSU]\Q W QD6RZLND OHG]LF]HND
D 6RZLNSRNQLHKDF]\NOLQN FL DUHNLVSDZLN,ZWHG\Z]L JRMDNVZHJR
%RWRRQLHJRPLLG]LHQDQLPPL]DOH \$ H ZyZF]DVZ\MX JU\ OLE\ FLH
]LHPL " +D]RNRQLHF]QHNRV]W\ZDVQH
=DPLON*HUDOWQLHNRPHQWRZD
:LHG]FLHPyMSDQLHZLHG PLQLHSRGM SRFKZLOLSUHIHNW H MD
SRSU]\VL JHPVRELH H QDW\PWHUHQLH]DSDQXMHSUDZR=DZV]HON FHQ L
ZV]HONLPLPHWRGDPLSHUDVHWQHIDV%RSUDZRWRQLHMXU\DSUXGHQFMDQLHJUXED
NVL NDSHQDSDUDJUDIyZWRQLHILOR]RILF]QHWUDNWDW\QLHQDEXUPXV]RQHEUHGQLHR
VSUDZLHGOLZR FLQLHZ\ ZLHFKWDQHIUD]HV\RPRUDOQR FLLHW\FH3UDZRWR
EH]SLHF]QHGURJLLJR FL FH7RPLHMVNLH]DXNLNWyU\PLPR QDVSDFHURZDQDZHW
SR]DFKRG]LHVR FD7R]DMD]G\LNDUF]P\]NWyU\FKPR QDZ\M GRZ\FKRGND
]RVWDZLDM F VDNLHZN QDVWROHD RQ SU]\VWROH3UDZRWRVSRNRMQ\VHQOXG]L
SHZQ\FK H ]EXG]LLFKSLDQLHNXUDDQLHF]HUZRQ\NXU$GODW\FKFRSUDZR
DPL VWU\F]HNWRSyUSDOLF]HUZRQH HOD]R.DUDRGVWUDV]DM FDLQQ\FK7\FK
NWyU]\SUDZRDPL QDOH \ FKZ\WDLNDUD:V]HONLPLGRVW SQ\PL URGNDPLL
PHWRGDPL(M HZLHG PLQLH&]\GH]DSUREDWDPDOXM FDVL QDWZRLPREOLF]X
RGQRVLVL GRFHOXF]\PHWRG"0\ O H GRPHWRG%RPHWRG\NU\W\NRZDDWZR
DOHZEH]SLHF]Q\P ZLHFLHFKFLDRE\VL \FR"1RRGSRZLHG]
1LHPDRF]\PJDGD
-DP\ O H MHVW
0QLHSDQLH)XONRU]HNVSRNRMQLH*HUDOWQDZHWSRGREDVL ZLDW]WZRMHM
ZL]MLLWZRMHMLGHL
'RSUDZG\"7ZRMDPLQD ZLDGF]\RF]\P SU]HFLZQ\P
ZLDW]WZRMHMLGHLWR ZLDWDNXUDWGODZLHG PLQD1LJG\QLH]DEUDNQLHZQLP
GODZLHG PLQDURERW\=DPLDVWNRGHNVyZSDUDJUDIyZLQDEXUPXV]RQ\FKIUD]HVyZ
R VSUDZLHGOLZR FLWZRMDLGHDGDMHEH]SUDZLHDQDUFKL VDPRZRO L SU\ZDW
NUyOHZL W LVRELHSDQNyZQDGJRUOLZR FKF F\FKSU]\SRGREDVL ]ZLHU]FKQLNRP
NDULHURZLF]yZ]D OHSLRQ P FLZR IDQDW\NyZRNUXFLH VWZRVLHSDF]\UHZDQ L
VDG\VW\F]Q ]HPVW 7ZRMDZL]MDWR ZLDWVWUDFKX ZLDWZNWyU\POXG]LHERM VL
Z\FKRG]LSR]PLHU]FKXQLH]O NXSU]HGEDQG\WDPLDOHSU]HGVWUy DPLSUDZDER
ZV]DN H HIHNWHPZLHONLFKRZyZQDEDQG]LRUyZ]DZV]HMHVWWR H EDQG]LRU\
-DVNLHUE\SLHUZV]\NWyU\]DEUDJRVJG\*HUDOWVNR F]\RSRZLDGD
6NRU\JXMPQLHMH OLVL P\O SRZLHG]LD7DG]LHZF]\QD$QJRXOHPHNWyU
RFKRF]RLQLHIUDVREOLZLHGR F]\H GRQDV]HMGUX \Q\WRNU\PLQDOLVWND%\RFDOL
M RGNDU\]UHV]W ]DVX RQHM]JRG]LH VL NRODERURZD]1LOIJDDUGF]\NDPL
'DH VL Z\QDM %DQLHW\ONRVLHELHQDVZV]\VWNLFKZ\QDM H 0DP\ZV]\VF\
GRSRPyF1LOIJDDUGF]\NRPVFKZ\WDOXEX PLHUFLMDNLHJR /RNDOQHJR]EyMF
.UyWNRW\*HUDOW]RVWDH QLOIJDDUG]NLPQDMHPQLNLHPRZF QDJUyGSDWQ\P
]DEyMF $P\DZDQVRZDOL P\QDWZRLFKDNROLWyZ&]\WH IDPXOXVyZ
0DV]QLHSUDZGRSRGREQ\WDOHQWGRXSUDV]F]DQLD-DVNLHUPUXNQ &DKLU
&]\ E\ QDSUDZG QLHSRMPRZDRFRFKRG]L"&]\WH JDGDV]GODVDPHJR
JDGDQLD"
0LOF]1LOIJDDUGF]\NX*HUDOW"
=DF]QLMP\RGWHJR:LHG PLQZU]XFLGRRJQLVNDSDW\NNWyU\PEDZLVL RG
GX V]HJRF]DVX H ZW\PFR]DPLHU]\HPQLNWQLHPXVLPLSRPDJD0RJ WR
]DDWZLVDP%H]DNROLWyZLIDPXOXVyZ
=XFKZD\MHVWH ZXMFLXRGH]ZDDVL $QJRXOHPH$OHKDQ]D6RZLNDWR
GZXG]LHVWXLF]WHUHFKGREU\FK]XFKyZRZLQDZHWZLHG PLQDQLH]O NQ VL WDN
DFQRDMH OLRPLHF]RZ VSUDZ LG]LHWRFKRE\LSUDZG E\RFRRZLHG PLQDFK
JDGDM QLNWVDPRMHGHQQLHGRVWRLGZyPWX]LQRP8UDWRZDH PL \FLHZL F MDFL
RGSDF W\PVDP\P2VWU]H HQLHP,SRPRF
&RWRMHVWXGLDEDKDQ]D"
$HQKDQV Z\MD QL&DKLUWRZQDV]\PM ]\NX]EURMQDGUX \QDDOHWDND
NWyU F] ZL ]\SU]\MD QL
.RPSDQLD"
2ZD QLH6RZRMDNZLG] ZHV]RGRWXWHMV]HJR DUJRQX
+DQ]DMHVWKDQ]DSU]HUZDD$QJRXOHPH$SRQDV]HPXKXODMSDUWLDDOER
KDVVD2F]\PWXJDGD"-DRVWU]HJDDPSRZD QLH1LHPDV]DQVMHGHQSU]HFLZ
FDHMKDQ]LH1DGRPLDU]HJRQLH]QDM F\DQL6RZLNDDQLZRJyOHQLNRJRZ
%HOKDYHQLRNROLF\QLZURJyZQLSU]\MDFLyDOERVSU]\PLHU]H FyZ1LH]QDM F\
GUyJNWyUHGRPLDVWDSURZDG] DSURZDG] Uy QH-DPyZL WDNQLHGDVRELH
:LHG PLQVDPUDG\1LHZLHPMDNLHXZDVSDQXM RE\F]DMHDOHMDZLHG PLQD
VDPHJRQLH]RVWDZL 2QPQLHMDNWRSRZLHG]LDZXMFLR-DVNLHURFKRF]RL
$WRF]HPX"VS\WDOLSUDZLHMHGQRF]H QLH$QJRXOHPHL&DKLU
:D QLHSRZLHG]LDZROQR5HJLV&]HPX"
%RQLHPDPGRQLHJR]DXIDQLDR]QDMPLNUyWNR:LHG PLQ
0LOF]HQLHNWyUH]DSDGRE\RQLHSU]\MHPQHFL NLHOHSNLHQLHPDO2GVWURQ\
ODVXSRGNWyU\PRER]RZDDNDUDZDQDNXSLHFNDLJUXSDLQQ\FKSRGUy Q\FK
GRELHJD\SRGQLHVLRQHJRV\RNU]\NLL SLHZ\
:\MD QLMSRZLHG]LDOZUHV]FLH&DKLU
.WR QDV]GUDG]LU]HNLVXFKR:LHG PLQ3RUR]PRZLH]SUHIHNWHPLSR
UHZHODFMDFK$QJRXOHPHQLHPDFRGRWHJRZ WSOLZR FL$JG\VL GREU]H
]DVWDQRZLGRFKRG]LVL GRZQLRVNX H ]GUDMFDMHVWZ UyGQDV$GRWHJRE\
]JDGQ NWRQLPMHVWZFDOHQLHWU]HEDVL GXJR]DVWDQDZLD
7\MDNPLVL ]GDMH]PDUV]F]\EUHZ&DKLUSR]ZROLH VRELH]DVXJHURZD
H W\P]GUDMF MHVWHPMD"
1LHXNU\ZDPJRVZLHG PLQDE\]LPQ\ H PQLHWDNDP\ O QDSDGDL
RZV]HP:LHOHQDWRZVND]XMH:LHOHE\WRZ\MD QLDR%DUG]RZLHOH
*HUDOWU]HN-DVNLHU&]\W\QLHSRVXZDV]VL RGURELQN ]DGDOHNR"
1LHFKPyZLZ\G ZDUJL&DKLU1LHFKPyZL1LHFKVL QLHNU SXMH
=DVWDQDZLDRQDV*HUDOWSRWRF]\Z]URNLHPSRWZDU]DFKNRPSDQyZMDN
PRJRGRM GRU]HNRPHJRE GXZUDFKXQNX:LHFLHRF]\PPRZD2W\P H
MHVWQDVSL WNDDQLHF]ZyUND0\ OHOL P\ H NWR VL SRSURVWXSRP\OL
WDMHPQLF]\SyHOIUR]EyMQLN6RZLNDOER$QJRXOHPH$MH OLRGU]XFLZHUVM
E GX":WHG\QDVXZDVL ZHUVMDQDVW SXM FDGUX \QDOLF]\SL RVyEDOH6RZLN
PD]DELW\ONRF]WHU\%RSL WDWRVSU]\PLHU]HQLHF]DPDFKRZFyZ.WR NWRVWDOH
LFKLQIRUPXMHRUXFKDFKGUX \Q\2GSRF] WNXRGPRPHQWXNLHG\SR]MHG]HQLX
V\QQHMU\EQHM]XS\GUX \QDVL VIRUPRZDD3U]\MPXM F GRVZHJRVNDGX
1LOIJDDUGF]\ND1LOIJDDUGF]\NDNWyU\PXVLGRSD &LULPXVLM RGGDFHVDU]RZL
(PK\URZLERRGWHJR]DOH \ MHJR \FLHLGDOV]DNDULHUD
$ZL F MHGQDNQLHP\OLHPVL SRZLHG]LDZROQR&DKLU-HGQDNMHVWHP
]GUDMF 3RG\PGZXOLFRZ\PVSU]HGDZF]\NLHP"
*HUDOWRGH]ZDVL ]QRZX5HJLV:\EDF]V]F]HUR DOHWZRMDWHRULDMHVW
G]LXUDZDMDNVWDUHU]HV]RWR$WZRMDP\ OPyZLHPFLWRMX MHVWQLHDGQD
-HVWHP]GUDMF SRZWyU]\&DKLUMDNJG\E\QLHV\V]DVyZZDPSLUD-DN
MHGQDNUR]XPLHPGRZRGyZPRMHM]GUDG\QLHPD DGQ\FKV MHG\QLHP WQH
SRV]ODNLLZLHG PL VNLHGRP\V\-DNUR]XPLHPWRQDPQLHVSDGQLHFL DU
XGRZRGQLHQLDPRMHMQLHZLQQR FL7RMDE G PXVLDGRZLH H QLHMHVWHP
NRQLHP7DN"
%H]SDWRVX1LOIJDDUGF]\NXZDUNQ *HUDOWVWDM F SU]HG&DKLUHPLXGHU]DM F
JRZ]URNLHP*G\E\PPLDGRZyGWZRMHMZLQ\QLHWUDFLE\PF]DVXQDJDGDQLH
OHF]UR]SDWDFL QDG]ZRQNDMDN OHG]LD=QDV]]DVDG FXLIWRUDR"7RRGSRZLHG]
PLNWRRSUyF]FLHELHPLDFKRE\QDMPQLHMV]\SRZyGE\]GUDG]L".WRRSUyF]
FLHELH]\VNDE\QD]GUDG]LHFRNROZLHN"
2GVWURQ\RER]XM FHMNXSLHFNLHMNDUDZDQ\UR]OHJVL JR Q\LSU]HFL J\WU]DVN
1DF]DUQ\PQLHELHJZLD G]L FLHHNVSORGRZDF]HUZRQR]RW\V]PHUPHUDFH
Z\VWU]HOL\URMHP]RW\FKSV]F]yRSDG\NRORURZ\PGHV]F]HP
1LHMHVWHPNRQLHPSRZLHG]LDPRG\1LOIJDDUGF]\NG ZL F]Q\PPRFQ\P
: FLHN\FKyULIXUNRWVNU]\GHOHONyZNR]RGRMyZ]EXG]L\LFKSU]HG ZLWHP
:\UXV]\OLWX SRZVFKRG]LHVR FDNWyUHR OHSLDM F\PRJQLHP]DSDOLRSy QLHM
QLHJLQDV]F]\WDFKJyU:\UXV]\OLQDGXJRSU]HGW\P]DQLPVR FH]GRDR
XND]DVL ]]DV]F]\WyZ=UHV]W ]DQLPVL XND]DRQLHER]DVQX\FKPXU\
-HFKDOLZ UyGODVyZDGURJDZLRGDFRUD]Z\ HMLZ\ HMFRGDRVL PLDUNRZD
SR]PLDQDFKZGU]HZRVWDQLH
' E\LJUDE\VNR F]\\VL QDJOHZMHFKDOLZPURNEXNRZLQZ\VDQ\FK
RSDG\POL FLHPSDFKQ F\FKSOH QL SDM F]\Q L JU]\EDPL*U]\EyZE\RZEUyG
0RNU\NRQLHFODWDSUDZG]LZLHREURG]LMHVLHQQ\PJU]\EHP3RV]\FLHEXNRZLQ
PLHMVFDPL]QLNDRZU F]SRGNDSHOXV]DPLERURZLNyZU\G]yZLPXFKRPRUyZ
%XNRZLQ\E\\FLFKHZ\JO GDR H ZL NV]R SWDNyZ SLHZDM F\FKRGOHFLDD
MX QDZ\UDM7\ONR]PRNHZURQ\NUDND\QDVNUDMDFK]DUR OL
3RWHPVNR F]\\VL EXNL]MDZLVL ZLHUN=DSDFKQLDR \ZLF
&RUD]F] FLHMWUDILD\VL \VHSDJyU\LJRRERU]DZ UyGNWyU\FKGRSDGDLFK
ZLFKHU5]HND1HZLSLHQLDVL QDSURJDFKLNDVNDGDFKMHMZRG\PLPRGHV]F]yZ
VWD\VL NU\VWDOLF]QLHSU]HMU]\VWH
1DKRU\]RQFLHZ]QRVLDVL *RUJRQD&RUD]EOL HM
=NDQFLDVW\FKERNyZSRW QHMJyU\MDNURNGXJLVS\ZD\ORGRZFHL QLHJL
SU]H]FR*RUJRQDZ\JO GDD]DZV]HMDNE\SU]HSDVDQDELD\PLV]DUIDPL6]F]\W
'LDEOHM*yU\QLE\JRZ L V]\M WDMHPQLF]HMREOXELHQLF\QLHXVWDQQLHVSRZLMD\
ZRDOHFKPXU1LHNLHG\]D *RUJRQDMDNWDQFHUNDSRWU] VDDVZ ELD SU]\RG]LHZ
ZLGRNE\SL NQ\DOHQLyV PLHU]XUZLVW\FK FLDQJyU\V]\RWRODZLQ\
]PLDWDM FHQDVZHMGURG]HZV]\VWNRD GRUXPRZLVNSRGQy D LGDOHMZGy
]ERF]HPD SRQDMZ\ V]H ZLHUNRZHUHJOHQDGSU]H F] 7KHRGXODQDGGROLQDPL
1HZLL6DQVUHWRXUQDGF]DUQ\PLRF]NDPLJyUVNLFKMH]LRUHN
6R FHNWyUHPLPRZV]\VWNR]GRDRSU]HELFKPXU\]DV]RRZLHOH]DV]\ENR
SRSURVWXVNU\RVL ]DJyU\QD]DFKRG]LHSRGSDODM F MHSXUSXURZR]RW XQ
3U]HQRFRZDOL6R FHZ]HV]R
, SU]\V]HGF]DVDE\VL UR]G]LHOL
&LULJDVNDDF]DUQHJRNRWDNWyU\RE\F]DMHPZV]\VWNLFKNRWyZ ZLDWDZUyFLGR
FKDW\QDPRF]DUDFKJG\XPLRZDQLHZROQR FLLDMGDF]HQLDVL ]RVWD\]DFKZLDQH
SU]H]FKyGJyGLQLHZ\JRG\7HUD]OH DQDNRODQDFKG]LHZF]\Q\LSRGVWDZLD
NDUNSRGMHMGR ] PUXNLHP ZLDGF] F\PRJ ERNLHMUR]NRV]\
7RRF]\PG]LHZF]\QDRSRZLDGDDNRWDQLHREFKRG]LR]DJURV]
7RE\MHG\Q\UD]NLHG\ QLDPR*HUDOFLHSRGM D&LUL2GWDPWHJRF]DVX
RGUR]VWDQLDQDZ\VSLH7KDQHGGRG:LH \ 0HZ\QLJG\QLHZLG]LDDPJRZH QLH
'ODWHJRV G]LDP H QLH \MH,QDJOHVS\Q WHQVHQWDNLMDNLHPLHZDDP
GDZQLHMVQ\RNWyU\FK<HQQHIHUPyZLD H V ZLHV]F]HSUHNRJQLF\MQH H
SRND]XM DOERSU]HV]R DOERSU]\V]R 7RE\RZSU]HGG]LH (NZLQRNFMXP:
PLDVWHF]NXNWyUHJRQD]Z\QLHSDPL WDP:SLZQLF\ZNWyUHM]DPNQ PQLH
%RQKDUW3RW\PMDNPQLHVNDWRZDL]PXVLE\PZ\]QDDNLPMHVWHP
=GUDG]LD PXNLPMHVWH " XQLyVJRZ 9\VRJRWD3RZLHG]LDD PX
ZV]\VWNR"
=DWFKyU]RVWZRSU]HNQ D OLQ ]DSDFLDPXSRNRU]HQLHPLSRJDUG GR
VDPHMVLHELH
2SRZLHG]RWZRLP QLH
:LG]LDDPZQLPJyU ZLHON VWURP NDQFLDVW MDNNDPLHQQ\Qy
:LG]LDDP*HUDOWD6\V]DDPFRPyZL'RNDGQLH.D GHVRZRMDNE\PE\D
5R]G]LD
:LDGRP\PMHVW H :LHG PLQJG\P N FLHUSLHQLHL PLHU]DGDMHWRWDNLHM
VLPLOLVVLPHOXER FLLUR]NRV]\GR]QDMHMDN F]HNSRER Q\LQRUPDOQ\W\ONR
ZWHQF]DVPDJG\]PD RQN VZ OXEQ REFXMHLELGHPFXPHLDFXODWLR=WHJR
MDVQRZ\S\ZD H LZWHMPDWHULL:LHG PLQQDWXU]HSU]HFLZQ\PMHVWVWZRUHP
QLHPRUDOQ\PLSOXJDZ\P]Z\URGQLDOFHP]GQDSLHNO QDMF]DUQLHMV]HJRL
QDMVPURGOLZV]HJRVL URG] F\PDOERZLHP]FLHUSLHQLDLP NLVDPFK\EDW\ONR
GLDEHUR]NRV]F]HUSDPR H
$QRQLP0RQVWUXPDOERZLHG PLQDRSLVDQLH
=MHFKDOL]JyZQHJRV]ODNXZLRG FHJRGROLQ 1HZLSRMHFKDOLQDVNUyW\SU]H]
JyU\-HFKDOLWDNV]\ENRMDNSR]ZDODWD FLH NDZ VNDNU WDSU]\WXORQDGRVNDR
IDQWDVW\F]Q\FKNV]WDWDFKSRNU\W\FKOLV]DMHPUy QRNRORURZ\FKPFKyZL
SRURVWyZ-HFKDOLZ UyGSLRQRZ\FKVNDOLVW\FKXUZLVN]NWyU\FKVSDGD\
SRVWU] SLRQHZVW JLVLNODZLZRGRVSDGyZ3U]HMH G DOLSU]H]Z ZR]\LMDU\SU]H]
FK\ERWOLZHPRVWNLQDGSU]HSD FLDPLQDGQLHNWyU\FKELD SLDQ NRWRZD\VL
VWUXPLHQLH
*UDQLDVWDNOLQJD*RUJRQ\]GDZDDVL Z]QRVLWX QDGLFKJRZDPL6]F]\WX
'LDEOHM*yU\QLHPRJOLZLG]LHXWRQ ZFKPXUDFKLPJDFK]DVQXZDM F\FK
QLHER3RJRGDMDNWRZJyUDFKSRSVXDVL Z FL JXNLONXJRG]LQ]DF] RVL SL
VL SLGRWNOLZLHLZUHGQLH
*G\]DF]\QDRPLHVL QD]PLHU]FKZV]\VF\WURMHQLHFLHUSOLZLHLQHUZRZR
]DF]\QDOLUR]JO GDVL ]DSDVWHUVNLPV]DDVHP]UXMQRZDQ RZF]DUQL OXEFKRE\
MDVNLQL =DF]\PNROZLHNFRXFKURQLRE\ZQRF\RGNDSL FHM]QLHEDZRG\
3U]HVWDRFK\EDSDGDSRZLHG]LDD]QDG]LHM Z JRVLH$QJRXOHPH.DSLH
MX W\ONR]G]LXUZGDFKXV]DDVX-XWURQDV]F] FLHE G]LHP\MX Z EOLVNR FL
%HOKDYHQDQDSRGJURG]LX]DZV]HPR QDSU]HQRFRZDZMDNLHM V]RSLHDOER
VWRGROH
1LHZMHG]LHP\GRPLDVWD"
2ZMHFKDQLXLPRZ\QLHPD2EF\QDNRQLDFKU]XFDM VL Z RF]\D6RZLNPD
Z PLH FLHNXS LQIRUPDWRUyZ
5R]ZD DOL P\SODQE\ ZLDGRPLHZ\VWDZLVL QDSU]\Q W
1LHSU]HUZDD7RNLHSVNLSODQ7R H MHVWH P\UD]HPZ]EXG]LSRGHMU]HQLD
6RZLNWRSU]HELHJ\GUD DZLH RPRLPSRMPDQLXQDSHZQRMX VL UR]HV]D
-H OL]D FR ]DQLHSRNRL6RZLNDWRLGRSyHOIDGRMG]LH
&RZL F SURSRQXMHV]"
2EMHG]LHP\PLDVWRXNLHPRGZVFKRGXRGZ\ORWXGROLQ\6DQVUHWRXU7DPV
NRSDOQLHUXG\:MHGQHM]W\FKNRSDOQLPDP]QDMRPND2GZLHG]LP\JR.WRZLH
MH OLE G]LHP\PLHOLV]F] FLHWRPR H RSDFLVL QDPWDZL]\WD"
0R HV]PyZLMD QLHM"
3RZLHPMXWUR:NRSDOQL HE\QLH]DSHV]\
&DKLUGRU]XFLGRRJQLVNDEU]R]RZ\FKJD ]L3DGDRFD\G]LH LQQ\P
GUHZQHPQLHGDRE\VL SDOL$OHEU]H]LQDFKRPRNUDWURV]N W\ONR
SRVNZLHUF]DDL]DUD]EXFKQ DZ\VRNLPVLQDZ\PSRPLHQLHP
6N G SRFKRG]LV]$QJRXOHPH"
=&LQWU\ZLHG PLQLH7RWDNLNUDMQDGPRU]HPSU]\XM FLX-DUXJL
:LHPJG]LHOH \ &LQWUD
7RF]HPXS\WDV]MH OLW\OHZLHV]"7DNFL EDUG]R]DMPXM "
3RZLHG]P\ H WURFK
0LOF]HOL2JLH SRWU]DVNLZD
0RMDPDWNDSU]HPyZLDZUHV]FLH$QJRXOHPHSDWU] F ZSRPLHQLHE\DZ
&LQWU]HV]ODFKFLDQN L WRERGDMZ\VRNLHJRURGX:KHUELHPLDWHQUyGNRWD
PRUVNLHJRSRND]DDE\PFLERPLDDPPHGDOLRQLN]W\PLFK]DIDMGDQ\PNRWHP
RGPDWNLDOHPJRSU]HJUDDZNR FL$OHWHQUyGVUDLFKPRUVNLSLHVZ\SDUVL
PQLHERPRMDPDWNDSX FLDVL SRGREQR]MDNLP FKDPHPERGDM H VWDMHQQ\PL
MDE\DPEDVWDUGVURPKD EDLSODPDQDKRQRU]H2GGDOLPQLHQDZ\FKRZDQLH
GDOHNLPSRZLQRZDW\PFLZSUDZG]LHZKHUELHQLHPLHOLDQLNRWDDQLSVDDQLLQQHM
NXUZ\DOHQLHE\OLGODPQLH OL'RV]NySRVDOLZVXPLHPDRELOL&KRGRV\
F] VWRPLSU]\SRPLQDOLNLPMHVWHPMDNLPWRE NDUWHPZSRNU]\ZDFKVSRG]RQ\P
0DWNDRGZLHG]LDPQLHPR H ]HWU]\OXEF]WHU\UD]\JG\E\DPPDD3RWHP
SU]HVWDDPQLHRGZLHG]D0QLH]UHV]W JyZQR]DOH DR
-DNLPVSRVREHPWUDILD PL G]\SU]HVW SFyZ"
3\WDV]MDNV G]LD OHGF]\SDUVNQ DZ\NU]\ZLDM F VL JURWHVNRZR0L G]\
SU]HVW SFyZSKXXX=GURJLFQRW\SKHHH
3REXUF]DDSRJU]HEDD]DSD]XFK Z\FL JQ DFR F]HJR:LHG PLQQLHZLG]LD
GRNDGQLH
-HGQRRNL)XONRSRZLHG]LDDQLHZ\UD QLH]DZ]L FLHZFLHUDM F VRELHFR Z
G]L VDLZFL JDM F GRQRVDWRMHGQDNSU]\]ZRLW\JR &R]DEUDWR]DEUDDOH
SURFK]RVWDZL:H PLHV]V]F]\SW ZLHG PLQLH"
1LH:RDE\P HE\ L W\QLHEUDD
'ODF]HJR"
%RQLH
&DKLU"
1LHX \ZDPILVVWHFKX
$OHPLVL ZL WRV]NRZLHWUDILOLSRNU FLDJRZ =DUD]PLSHZQLH
]DF]QLHFLHPRUD\SUDZL H QLE\RGSURFKyZR OHSQ RJXFKQ L Z\\VLHM " H
XURG] XSR OHG]RQHG]LHFNR"
=RVWDZWR$QJRXOHPH,GRNR F]RSRZLDGDQLD
']LHZF]\QDNLFKQ DSRW QLH
'REUDMDNFKFHV]1DF]\PWRMD$KD:\EXFKDZRMQDZLHV]]
1LOIJDDUGHPNUHZQLVWUDFLOLFD\PDM WHNPXVLHOLSRU]XFLGRP0LHOLWURMH
ZDVQ\FKG]LHFLDMDVWDDPVL GODQLFKFL DUHPZL F RGGDOLPQLHGRSU]\WXNX
3URZDG]RQHJRSU]H]NDSDQyZSU]\MDNLHM ZL W\QL:HVRHWRE\RPLHMVFHMDN
VL RND]DR=DPWX]]Z\F]DMQ\ERUGHOQLFGRGDQLFXM GODWDNLFKFROXEL
NZD Q\RZRF]ELD SHVWN NDSXMHV]"0RGHG]LHZXV]NL,PRG\FKFKRSFyZ
WH -DJG\WDPWUDILDPE\DPMX ]E\WZ\UR QL WDGRURVDQLHE\RQDPQLH
DPDWRUyZ
&DNLHPQLHVSRG]LHZDQLHREODDVL UXPLH FHPZLGRF]Q\PQDZHWZ ZLHWOH
RJQLVND
3UDZLHQLHE\RGRGDDSU]H]] E\
,OHPLDD ZWHG\ODW"
3L WQD FLH3R]QDDPWDPMHGQ G]LHZF]\Q L SL FLXFKRSDNyZZPRLPZLHNX
L WURFK VWDUV]\FK,GRJDGDOL P\VL UD]GZD=QDOL P\E\RQLHE\ROHJHQG\L
RSRZLH FL26]DORQ\P'HLR&]DUQREURG\PREUDFLDFK&DVVLQL=DFKFLDRVL
QDPQDV]ODNQDVZRERG QDJUDVDQWN &RWRU]HNOL P\VRELHW\ONR]DWR H QDV
WXWDMGZDUD]\ZG]LH NDUPL WRPDP\MDNLP ZVWU FLXFKRPQD]DZRDQLHGXS\
GDZD
3RZ FL JQLMVRZQLFWZR$QJRXOHPH:LHV]FR]DGX RWRQLH]GURZR
']LHZF]\QDFKDUNQ DSU]HFL JOHVSOXQ DZRJQLVNR
$OH ZL WRV]HN'REUDGRU]HF]\SU]HMG ERPLVL JDGDQLHFKFH:
SU]\WXNRZHMNXFKQL]QDOD]\VL QR HZ\VWDUF]\RMHGREU]HQDNDPLHQLX
Z\RVWU]\LQDSDVNXZ\ZHFRZD=WRF]RQ\FKQyJRGG ERZHJRNU]HVDZ\V]\
SL NQHSD\3RWU]HEQHE\\W\ONRNRQLHLSLHQL G]HZL F ]DF]HNDOL P\QDSU]\MD]G
GZyFK]EHUH QLNyZVWD\FKE\ZDOFyZVWDUXFKyZWIXFK\EDF]WHUG]LHVWROHWQLFK
3U]\MHFKDOLVLHGOLZLQNRSRSLMDOLF]HNDOLD LPNDSDQL]Z\N\PRE\F]DMHP
SU]\ZL
Z\EUDQ PDRODW GRWDNLHJRVSHFMDOQHJRVSU\WQHJRPHEOD$OHQLH
SRGXGNDOLVRELHWHJRGQLD
$QJRXOHPH
'REUDGREUD.UyWNR]DU Q OL P\L]DWXNOL P\REX]EHUH Q\FKG]LDGyZ
WU]HFKNDSDQyZLSD]LDMHG\QHJRNWyU\QLHXFLHNLNRQLEURQL ZL W\QQHJR
V]DIDU]DFRQLHFKFLDNOXF]DRGV]NDWX\Z\GDRJQLHPSU]\SLHNDOL P\WDNGXJR
D Z\GDDOHGDURZDOL P\ \FLHPERPL\E\VWDUXV]HN]DZV]H \F]OLZ\LGREU\
, SRV]OL P\QD]EyMQDJR FL FH5y QHE\\QDV]\FKORVyZNROHMHUD]QDZR]LH
UD]SRGUD]P\ELOL P\UD]QDVELOL5D]E\RV\WRDUD]JRGQR+DJRGQR
F] FLHM=WHJRFRSH]D]MDGDPZ \FLXZV]\VWNRFRVL GDRNXUZD]RZL$
] WHJRFRIUXZDUD]]MDGDPQDZHWODWDZLHFERE\VNOHMRQ\NOHMHP]P NL
=DPLONDJZDWRZQLHSRF]RFKUDDVZHMD QLXWNLHMDNVRPDZRV\
$FKFRE\RWRE\R7\OHFLSRZLHP]W\FKFR]HPQ ] SU]\WXNXXFLHNOL
QLH \MHMX QLNW'ZyFKRVWDWQLFK2ZHQDL$EODXWUXSL\SDU GQLWHPXNQHFKW\
SDQD)XOND$EHOSRGGDVL MDNLMDDOHLWDNJR]DU EDOLFKRPLHF]U]XFL0QLH
RV]F] G]LOL1LHP\ O H ]GREURFLVHUFD-X PQLHQDSDV]F]XQDNU]\ UR]NDGDOL
DOHSU]\OHFLDRILFHULQDXFLHFK QLH]H]ZROL1RDRGV]DIRWXW\ PQLHRFDOL
=DPLONDQDFKZLO
:LHG PLQLH"
6XFKDP
-DZLHPMDNZG]L F]QR RND]D-H OLW\ONR]HFKFHV]
6XFKDP"
=REDF] FRWDPXNRQLSRZLHG]LDV]\ENR&DKLULZVWDRZLMDM F VL
SDV]F]HP3U]HMG VL WURFK SRRNROLF\
']LHZF]\QDNLFKQ DSRFL JQ DQRVHPFKU] NQ D
$QLVRZD$QJRXOHPHXSU]HG]LM QDSUDZG ]\QDSUDZG ]DZVW\G]RQ\
QDSUDZG ]PLHV]DQ\$QLVRZD
&KU] NQ D]QRZX
1DSUDZG QLHPDV]QDPQLHRFKRW\"$QLWURV]HF]N "
2G0LOY\MX GRVWDD U]HPLHQLHPVPDUNXOR-H OLQDW\FKPLDVWQLH
]DPLONQLHV]RGHPQLHGRVWDQLHV]GRNDGN
-X QLFQLHPyZL
*U]HF]QDG]LHZF]\QND
*HUDOWL&DKLUSRVXV]QLHSU]\MU]HOLVL REXZLXXW\WDQHPXZV]ODPLHRG]LZQHM
F]HUZRQDZHMEDUZLH
3yHOINWyUHJRV]XNDP\XSU]HG]LDS\WDQLD$QJRXOHPHPLDSRGF]DV
UR]PRZ\]H6RZLNLHPWDNLHVDPLXWNLHF]HUZRQLXWNLHERWNRQDNDPDV]DFK
.DSXMHFLH"
7HUD]WDN$NUDVQROXG"
1LHRG]\ZDMFLHVL GRQLHJRZRJyOH-DELRU QDVLHELHJDGDQLH:DVQDWRPLDVW
PDRQPLH]DWDNLFKFRQLHJDGDM DOHU EL 3U]\ELHU]FLHJUR QHPLQ\
1LHPXVLHOLSU]\ELHUDVSHFMDOQ\FKPLQ1LHNWyU]\]SU]\JO GDM F\FKVL
JZDUNyZV]\ENRRGZUDFDOLRF]\LQQL]DPLHUDOL]RWZDUW\PLXVWDPL&LNWyU]\
]QDOH OLVL QDLFKGURG]HSRVSLHV]QLH]QLHMVFKRG]LOL*HUDOWGRP\ ODVL
GODF]HJR1DWZDU]\&DKLUDLMHJRZDVQHMZFL ]QDE\RVL FHNUZLDNL
VNDOHF]HQLDLRSXFKOL]Q\PDORZQLF]H ODG\EyMNLLODQLDMDNLHVSX FLDLP0LOYD
:\JO GDOL]DWHPQDRVREQLNyZNWyU]\]QDMGXM XSRGREDQLHZSUDQLXSRJ EDFK
VLHELHZ]DMHPDGRGDQLDZPRUG RVRELHWU]HFLHMWH QLHWU]HEDLFKGXJR
QDPDZLD
.UDVQROXG]QDMRPHN$QJRXOHPHVWDSRGEXG\QNLHP]QDSLVHP6WRODUQLDL
PDORZDFR QDWDEOLF\]ELWHM]GZyFKKHEORZDQ\FKGHVHN=REDF]\
QDGFKRG] F\FKRGR \S G]HORGVWDZLNXEHHN]IDUE SU]\MU]DVL VSRGHED
1DMHJRR]GRELRQHMSRSODPLRQ EURG IL]MRQRPLLRGPDORZDVL QDJOHZ\UD]
VURJLHJR]GXPLHQLD
$QJRXOHPH"
6L PDV]'UR]GHFN
7RW\"NUDVQROXGUR]G]LDZLEURGDW J E 7RQDSUDZG W\"
1LH7RQLHMD7R ZLH R ]PDUWZ\FKZVWD\SURURN/HELRGD=DGDMMHV]F]H
MDNLH S\WDQLH*RODQ'ODRGPLDQ\PR H MDNLH P GU]HMV]H
7\QLHNSLM-DVQD-DMX VL FLHELHXMU]HQLHVSRG]LHZDHPZL FHM%\WXSL
GQLWHPXQD]DG0XOLFDSUDZL H FDSQ OLFL L QDSDOZELOLZ5LHGEUXQH.O VL
H WRSUDZGD
=ZV]\VWNLHJRMHVWSR \WHNZ]UXV]\DUDPLRQDPLG]LHZF]\QD% G]LHWHUD]
0XOLFDSLHQL G]HSR \F]DLNO VL H RGGDWRW\MX ZLHG]LDE G]LHV]LOHMHJR
NO WZ\ZDUWH
-DPWRMX ZSU]yG\ZLHG]LDRGSDUNUDVQROXGV]\ENRPUXJDM F LSRUXV]DM F
QRVHP]XSHQLHMDNNUyOLN-DE\MHPXLV]HO JD]DPDQHJRQLHSR \F]\FKRE\
RQPLWXXVUDVL L ]LHPL MDG$OH H W\ \ZDLFDDFLHV] VL FLHV] KHM0R H
L ]GDU]\VL H PLGXJRGGDV]D"
0R H.WRZLH"
$NWy WRMHVW]WRE -DVQD"
'UXK\GREUH
(FKPRUG\$GRN G ERJLSURZDG] "
-DN]Z\NOHQDPDQRZFH$QJRXOHPH]DQLFVRELHPDM F SLRUXQXM FH
VSRMU]HQLDZLHG PLQDZFL JQ DGRQRVDV]F]\SW ILVVWHFKXUHV]W ZWDUDZ
G]L VR1LXFKQLHV]*RODQ"
1RFK\EDNUDVQROXGSRGVWDZLGR ZFL JQ SRGDURZDQ V]F]\SW
QDUNRW\NXGRQR]GU]D
=QDF]\"]PDUV]F]\DQRVHN$QJRXOHPH
=QDF]\W\PLSLHQL G]HZLQQDMHVWH -DVQD0LDVWRGGDQRZHGXJLFKFHV]
]DFL JD3RZD QHGXJLER]DWRRFRS\WDV]PR QDSRELHZ]L LWRQLHJR
U N DVLHNLHUN &RWRGODPQLH]DLQWHUHV"&]\PLVL E G]LHRSDFDRMH OLE G
FR R SyHOILHZLHG]LDK " &]\GRVWDQ FRVLN"%RMH OLW\ONRU\]\NRD]\VNX
DGQHJR
*HUDOWPLDGR 1XG]LDJRUR]PRZDGUD QL\ DUJRQLPDQLHUD
%\VNDZLF]Q\PUXFKHPFKZ\FLNUDVQROXGD]DEURG V]DUSQ LSFKQ *RODQ
'UR]GHFNSRWNQ VL R ZLDGUR]IDUE XSDG:LHG PLQSRGVNRF]\GRQLHJR
RSDUNRODQRRSLHU L ]D ZLHFLQR HPZRF]\
=\VND]DZDUF]DPR HV]WR H ] \FLHPXMG]LHV]*DGDM
2F]\*RODQDZ\GDZDRVL ]DFKZLO Z\MG ] RUELWLSyMG VRELHSRVSDFHURZD
SRRNROLF\
*DGDMSRZWyU]\*HUDOW*DGDMFRZLHV],QDF]HMWDNFLSU]HU Q JUG\N H
ZF]H QLHMVL XWRSLV]QL Z\NUZDZLV]
5LDOWRZ\VW NDNUDVQROXG:NRSDOQL5LDOWR
UR]SR]QDOL3VLDPD$OH P\ZSDGOL
=GRDV]VL Z\JD"PUXNQ &DKLU
1LHOLF]FLHQDWR
%R"
2NUDGDP6RZLNDXFLHNDM F ]KDQ]\1LHGDUXM PLWHJR$OHVSUyEXM :\
PLOF]FLH0LHMFLHRF]\RWZDUWHLE G FLHJRWRZL1DZV]\VWNR
.RQQL]EOL \OLVL 3U]RGHPMHFKDRGZyFKGXJRZRV\V]SDNRZDW\W\SZ
ZLOF]XU]HLPRG\GU JDO]EURG HZLGHQWQLH]DSXV]F]RQ E\VNU\]HV]SHFHQLDSR
WU G]LNX8GDZDOLRERM WQ\FKDOH*HUDOWGRVWU]HJWDMRQHE\VNLQLHQDZL FLZH
Z]URNXNWyU\PPLHU]\OL$QJRXOHPH
-DVQD
1RYRVDG<LUUHO:LWDMFLHDGQ\G]LH G]LVLDM6]NRGDW\ONR H SDGD
6]SDNRZDW\]VLDGDUDF]HM]HVNRF]\]NXEDNL]DPDV]\ FLHSU]HU]XFDM F
SUDZ QRJ QDGNR VNLPEHP3R]RVWDOL]VLHGOLUyZQLH 6]SDNRZDW\RGGDZRG]H
GU JDORZL]EURG QD]ZDQHPX<LUUHOHPVDPSRGV]HGEOL HM
3URV] SRZLHG]LD1DV]DVURF]NDJDGDWOLZD3RND]XMHVL \MHV]L]GURZD "
,QRJDPLILNDP
6PDUNXORS\VNDWD*RVLDSORWND H ILNDV]DOHQDSDOX*RVLDSORWNDFK\FL
FL -HGQRRNL)XONR*RVLDSORWND H SLHZDDQDP NDFKMDNWXUNDZNDZV]\VWNR
Z\GDDRFRS\WDOL
*RVLDSORWNDSU\FKQ D$QJRXOHPH H WZRMDPDWND1RYRVDGZRDDRG
NOLHQWyZW\ONRF]WHU\W\P\DLWDNQLNWQLHFKFLDGDZL FHMQL GZD
=EyMFDVSOXQ MHMSRGQRJL]SRJDUGOLZ PLQ $QJRXOHPHSU\FKQ D]QRZX
]XSHQLHMDNNRWND
1RYRVDGSRZLHG]LDDEH]F]HOQLHELRU F VL SRGERNL'R6RZLNDLQWHUHV
PDP
&LHNDZH%RRQGRFLHELHWH
=DZU]\MJ E L VXFKDMSyNLPDPFK JDGD'ZDGQLWHPXPLO ]D
5LHGEUXQHMDLFLRWRGUXKRZLHPRL]DU EDOL P\WHJRZLHG PLQDFRE\QDQLHJR
PRNU\NRQWUDNW.DSXMHV]"
1RYRVDGSRSDWU]\]QDF] FRSRNDPUDWDFKSRWHPSRGFL JQ U NDZLFH
RWDNVRZDZ]URNLHP*HUDOWDL&DKLUD
7ZRLQRZLGUXKRZLHSRZWyU]\SU]HFL JOH+DZLG] SRJ EDFK H QLH
NDSDQLWR:LHG PLQD]DELOLSRZLDGDV]"$MDN"6]W\FKHPZSOHF\"&]\ZH QLH"
-HVWWRQLHZD Q\VWU]HJy$QJRXOHPHZ\NU]\ZLDVL MDNPDSND:D Q\
VWU]HJyMHVWQDWRPLDVWWDNL H GDQ\:LHG PLQ]LHPL JU\]LH3RVXFKDM1RYRVDG
-D]H6RZLNLHPZDG]LVL QLHFKF QLZSDUDG PXZD]L$OHLQWHUHVMHVWLQWHUHV
3yHOIGDZDP]DOLF]N QDNRQWUDNWRW VL QLHXSRPQ WRZDV]SLHQL G]QD
NRV]WDL]DIDW\J $OHGUXJDUDWDNWyU SyHOISRURERFLHSU]\U]HNZHGOHSUDZD
PRMD
:HGOHSUDZD"
7DNMHVW$QJRXOHPHQLH]ZUyFLDXZDJLQDVDUNDVW\F]Q\WRQ0\ P\WR
ERZLHPNRQWUDNWZ\SHQLOLZLHG PLQDXELOLQDFRPR HP\SyOHOIRZLGRZRG\
SRND]D:H]P WHG\FRPRMHLSyMG VRELHZVLQ L PJOLVW GDO=H6RZLNLHP
MDNHPU]HNDNRQNXURZDQLHFKF ERGODPQLHLGODQLHJRQD6WRNDFK]DFLDVQR
7RPXSU]HND 1RYRVDG
7\ONRWR"]QRZXMDGRZLW\VDUND]P
,XFDRZDQLDSDUVNQ D$QJRXOHPH0R HV]PX]DPQLHZ\SL GXS SHU
SURFXUD
1DOHSV]\FLMDNRQFHSWZSDGHPR]QDMPL1RYRVDG]HUNDM F QDNRPSDQyZ
-DPXWZRM GXS Z RU\JLQDOH]DZLR] $QJRXOHPH-DPXFLHELH$QJRXOHPHZ
S WDFKGRVWDZL DRQMX ZWHG\]WRE ZV]\VWNRREJDGDL]DDWZL,XUHJXOXMH
:V]\VWNR6SyURWRNRPXQDOH \ VL SLHQL G]]DNRQWUDNWSyHOID6FKLUUX$L
RGSDWD]DWRFR XNUDGD$LWR H 6WRNLGODQDV]DFLDVQH:V]\VWNRVL W\P
VSRVREHP]DDWZL'HWDOLF]QLH
-HVWV]NRSXMHGHQ$QJRXOHPHRSX FLDU FH-DNW\FKFHV]PQLHGR6RZLND
]DSURZDG]L1RYRVDG"
$RWWDNEDQG\WDZ\FL JQ U N =DNDUN*HUDOWE\VNDZLF]Q\PUXFKHP
GRE\VLKLOODLSRGVWDZLJR1RYRVDGRZLSRGQRV
1LHUDG] ZDUNQ
1RYRVDGRGVNRF]\Z\FL JQ PLHF]<LUUHO]V\NLHPZ\GRE\NU]\Z V]DEO ]
SRFKZ\QDSOHFDFK3R]RVWDOLSRV]OL]DLFKSU]\NDGHP
1LHUDG] SRZWyU]\:LHG PLQ
1RYRVDG]DNO 3RSDWU]\SRNRPSDQDFK1LHE\PRFQ\ZDU\WPHW\FHDOH
Z\V]RPX H SL FLXWR]QDF]QLHZL FHMQL WURMH
%LMZU]DVQ U]XFDM F VL QD*HUDOWD=DELM:LHG PLQSyREURWHPXQLNQ
FLRVXLFL JRQDRGOHZZVNUR =DQLPMHV]F]H1RYRVDGXSDG$QJRXOHPH
SRFK\OLDVL Z NUyWNLP]DPDFKXQy ZLVQ ZSRZLHWU]XDWDNXM F\<LUUHO
]DWRF]\VL VSRGSRGEUyGNDVWHUF]DDPXNR FLDQDU NRMH =EyMSX FLV]DEO
REXU F]Z\V]DUSQ Qy ] V]\LEOX]JQ NUZL D$QJRXOHPH]SRGVNRNXNRSQ D
JRZSLHU L REDOLDQD]LHPL :W\PF]DVLH*HUDOW]DVLHNGUXJLHJREDQG\W &DKLU
]DU EDQDVW SQHJRSRGSRW Q\PXGHU]HQLHPQLOIJDDUG]NLHJRPLHF]D]F]DV]NL
]EyMF\RGSDGRFR QDNV]WDWSRUFMLDUEX]D2VWDWQL]ELU]UHMWHURZDVNRF]\GR
NRQLD&DKLUSRGU]XFLPLHF]FKZ\FL]DNOLQJ L FLVQ MDNRV]F]HSHPWUDILDM F
]EyMDUyZQRPL G]\RSDWNL.R ]DU DLV]DUSQ JRZ SU]\VLDG]DWXSD
ZORN F SRF]HUZRQ\PERFLHWUXSD]U N ]DG]LHU]JQL W Z U]HPLH ZRG]\
:V]\VWNRWUZDRQLHGX HMQL SL XGHU]H VHUFD
/XG]LHHHHZU]DVQ NWR VSRPL G]\EXG\QNyZ/XG]LHHH1DSRPRRRF
0RUGPRUGPRUGXM
:RMVNR:H]ZDZRMVNRNU]\NQ GUXJLJyUQLNRGS G]DM F G]LHFLNWyUH
RGZLHF]Q\PRE\F]DMHPZV]\VWNLFKG]LHFL ZLDWD]MDZL\VL QLHZLHG]LHVN GE\
SU]\JO GDVL L S WDSRGQRJDPL
1LHFKNWR ELH \ SRZRMVNR
$QJRXOHPHSRGQLRVDVZyMQy Z\WDUWDJRLZVXQ DGRFKROHZ\
$QLHFKELH \SURV] EDUG]RRGZU]DVQ DUR]JO GDM F VL &RZ\
JZDUNRZLH OHSLF]\MDN"7RE\DVDPRREURQD1DSDGOLQDQDVRSU\V]NLMHGQH$
ERWRLFKQLH]QDFLH"0DRZDP]HJRQDURELOL"0DR]ZDVKDUDF]X FL JQ OL"
.LFKQ DPRFQR3RWHP]GDUDGUJDM FHPXMHV]F]H1RYRVDGRZLVDNLHZN ]
SDVNDSRFK\OLDVL QDG<WUUHOHP
$QJRXOHPH
&R"
=RVWDZ
'ODF]HJRQLE\"7R]GRE\F]0DV]]DGX R SLHQL G]\"
$QJRXOHPH
+HMZ\UR]OHJVL QDJOHG ZL F]Q\JRV3R]ZyOFLHQRWX
:RWZDUW\FKZURWDFKEDUDNXE G FHJRPDJD]\QHPQDU] G]LVWDRWU]HFK
P F]\]Q'ZDME\OLNUyWNRRVWU]\ RQ\PLRVLNDPLRQLVNLFKF]RDFKL
QLH]DZRGQLHQLVNLPSRP\ OXQNX7U]HFLPW\PNWyU\LFKRNU]\NQ E\
QLH]Z\NOHZ\VRNLFLHPQRZRV\SU]\VWRMQ\P F]\]QD
1LHFKF F\V\V]DHPUR]PRZ NWyUDSRSU]HG]LD]DM FLHSRZLHG]LD
P F]\]QD1LHEDUG]RFKFLDRPLVL ZLHU]\Z]DELFLHZLHG PLQDP\ ODHP
H WRF]F]HSU]HFKZDNL7HUD]MX WDNQLHP\ O :HMG FLHWXGREDUDNX
$QJRXOHPHVO\V]DOQLHZFL JQ DSRZLHWU]H6SRMU]DDQDZLHG PLQDLOHGZR
GRVWU]HJDOQLHNLZQ DJRZ
0 F]\]QDE\SyHOIHP
3yHOI6FKLUUXE\Z\VRNLPLDGREU]HSRQDGV]H VWySZ]URVWX'XJLHFLHPQH
ZRV\QRVL]ZL ]DQHQDNDUNXZRSDGDM F\QDSOHF\NR VNLRJRQ0LHV]DQ NUHZ
]GUDG]D\RF]\GX HNV]WDWXPLJGDyZ]LHORQR yWHMDNXNRWD
:\ FLHZL F ]DELOLZLHG PLQDSRZWyU]\X PLHFKDM F VL QLHDGQLH
8SU]HG]DM F +RPHUD6WUDJJHQD]ZDQHJR6RZLNLHP"&LHNDZHFLHNDZH-HGQ\P
VRZHPWRZDPPDP]DSDFLSL G]LHVL W IORUHQyZ'UXJ UDW 6WUDJJHQGRVWD
ZL F VZRMHSyVHWNL]DGDUPR%RFK\EDQLHSU]\SXV]F]DFLH H ZDPRGGD
-DNMDVL ]H6RZLNLHPXR WRMX PRMDU]HF]SRZLHG]LDD$QJRXOHPH
VLHG] FDQDVNU]\QLLPDFKDM FDQRJDPL$XPRZDZ]JO GHPZLHG PLQDE\DR
G]LHR,WRP\ P\WHJRG]LHDGRNRQDOL0\QLH6RZLN:LHG PLQZ]LHPL-HJR
NRPSDQLZV]\VF\WURMHZ]LHPL:\FKRG]LNRQWUDNWZ\NRQDQ\
7DNSU]\QDMPQLHMWZLHUG]LFLH-DNWRVL RGE\R"$QJRXOHPHQLHSU]HUZDD
PDFKDQLDQRJDPL
1DVWDUR R]QDMPLDVZ\P]Z\N\PEH]F]HOQ\PWRQHPVSLV] KLVWRUL
PHJR \ZRWD2SLV] Z QLHMMDNRGE\ZDRVL WRMDNWDPWRDMDNRZDPWR'RWHJR
F]DVXPXVLFLHZ]L QDZVWU]\PDQLHSDQLH6FKLUUX
$ WDNVL WHJRZVW\G]LFLH]DXZD \]LPQRPLHV]DQLHF:L F D WDNZUHGQLH
L ]GUDG]LHFNRWHJRGRNRQDOL FLH
3U]HV]NDG]DZDPWR"RGH]ZDVL *HUDOW
6FKLUUXVSRMU]DQDQLHJREDF]QLH
1LHRGU]HNSRFKZLOL:LHG PLQ*HUDOW]5LYLLQLH]DVXJLZDQDOHSV]\ORV
%\WWRQDLZQLDNLJXSLHF*G\E\PLDDGQLHMV] XF]FLZV] KRQRURZ PLHU
SRZVWD\E\OHJHQG\$RQQLH]DVXJLZDQDOHJHQG
PLHUMHVW]DZV]HWDNDVDPD
1LH]DZV]HSRNU FLJRZ SyHOIZFL XVLXM F ]DMU]HZVNU\WHFLHQLHP
3X G]LHZF]\Q
$OHMDFL ]QDPQLHW\ONR]RSLVXNRQW\QXRZD6FKLUUXDQLP\ O F SX FL
$QJRXOHPH-DFL MX ZLG]LDHP-DFL QDZHWNLHG\ OHG]LHP:7HPHULL:
OLSFX-HFKDHP]DWRE D GRPLDVWD'RULDQ'RVLHG]LE\MXU\VWyZ&RGULQJKHUDL
)HQQD.RMDU]\V]"
*HUDOWREUyFLPLHF]WDNE\NOLQJD]D ZLHFLDZRF]\SyHOID
&LHNDZMHVWHPSRZLHG]LD]LPQRMDN]DPLHU]DV]Z\EUQ ]WHMSDWRZHM
V\WXDFML6FKLUUX-DZLG] GZDZ\M FLD3LHUZV]HQDW\FKPLDVWSX FLV]
G]LHZF]\Q 'UXJLH]DELMHV]G]LHZF]\Q $ZVHNXQG Sy QLHMWZRMDNUHZ
SL NQLHXEDUZL FLDQ\LVXILW
:DV]DEUR 6FKLUUXEUXWDOQLHV]DUSQ $QJRXOHPH]DZRV\PD]QDOH VL
QD]LHPL]DQLPGROLF] GRWU]HFK3RWHP]DF]Q G]LZN NURL
=REDF]\P\LOH]G \V]XNURL-DP\ O H QLHGX R
5D]
'ZD]DF] ZDVQHOLF]HQLH*HUDOW]DZLMDM F VLKLOOHPV\F] FHJRP\ FD
=]HZQ WU]GRELHJLFKRPRWNRS\WU HQLHLSU\FKDQLHNRQLRNU]\NL
,FRWHUD]"]D PLDVL 6FKLUUX1DWRF]HNDHP7RMX QLHSDWOHF]PDW
3U]\E\OLPRLSU]\MDFLHOH
'RSUDZG\"SRZLHG]LD&DKLUZ\JO GDM F RNQHP:LG] XQLIRUP\
FHVDUVNLHMOHNNLHMNDZDOHULL
$ZL F WRPDWDOHGODFLHELHU]HN*HUDOW3U]HJUDH 6FKLUUX3X
G]LHZF]\Q
$NXUDW
'U]ZLEDUDNXXVW SL\SRGNRSQL FLDPLGR URGNDZNURF]\RNLONXQDVWXOXG]L
Z ZL NV]R FLF]DUQRLMHGQROLFLHXPXQGXURZDQ\FK:LyGLFKMDVQRZRV\EURGDF]
]HVUHEUQ\PQLHG ZLHG]LHPQDQDUDPLHQQLNX
4XHDHQVXHFF
V"VS\WDJUR QLH&RVL WXG]LHMH".WRRGSRZLDGD]DW
UR]UyE " =DWHWUXS\QDG]LHG]L FX"*DGDPLWXQDW\FKPLDVW
3DQLHGRZyGFR
*ODHGG\YDQYRUW5]XFLPLHF]H
3RVXFKDOL%RPLHU RQRGRQLFK]NXV]LDUEDOHWyZ3XV]F]RQDSU]H]6FKLUUX
$QJRXOHPHFKFLDD]HUZDVL ]HVWRXDOHQDJOH]QDOD]DVL Z X FLVNXNU SHJR
NRORURZRRG]LDQHJRGUDEDRZ\XSLDVW\FKMDNX DE\RF]DFK&KFLDDNU]\NQ DOH
GUDE]DFLVQ MHMQDXVWDFKXU NDZLF]RQ SL
3RZVWU]\PDMP\VL RGSU]HPRF\]DSURSRQRZDFKRGQR*HUDOWGRZyGF\]
QLHG ZLHG]LHP1LHMHVWH P\SU]HVW SFDPL
$WRFLGRSLHUR
']LDDP\]DZLHG] L ]JRG SDQD)XOND$UWHYHOGHSUHIHNWD]5LHGEUXQH
$WRFLGRSLHURSRZWyU]\1LHG ZLHG GDM F ]QDE\SRGQLHVLRQRL]DEUDQR
PLHF]H*HUDOWDL&DKLUD=DZLHG] L ]JRG 3DQD)XOND$UWHYHOGH:D QHJRSDQD
$UWHYHOGH6\V]HOL FLHFKRSF\"
-HJROXG]LHFLF]DUQLLFLNRORURZL]DUHFKRWDOLFKyUHP
$QJRXOHPH]DV]DPRWDDVL Z X FLVNX DELRRNLHJRQDGDUHPQLHXVLXM F
NU]\F]H1LHSRWU]HEQLH*HUDOWMX ZLHG]LD=DQLPMHV]F]HX PLHFKQL W\6FKLUUX
]DF] FLVNDSRGDZDQHPXSUDZLFH=DQLPF]WHUHFKF]DUQ\FK1LOIJDDUGF]\NyZ
FKZ\FLR&DKLUDDWU]HFKLQQ\FKVNLHURZDRNXV]HSURVWRZMHJRWZDU]
DELRRNLSFKQ $QJRXOHPHZU FHNDPUDWyZ']LHZF]\QD]DZLVDZLFK
FKZ\FLHMDNV]PDFLDQDODOND1DZHWQLHSUyERZDDVWDZLDRSRUX
1LHG ZLHG ZROQRSRGV]HGGR*HUDOWDLQDJOHXSQ JRZNURF]HSL FL Z
SDQFHUQHMU NDZLF\*HUDOW]JL VL DOHQLHXSDG1DQRJDFKWU]\PDDJR]LPQD
Z FLHNR
0R H SRFLHV]\FL ZLH SRZLHG]LD1LHG ZLHG H QLHMHVWH FLHSLHUZV]\PL
GXUQLDPLNWyU\FK-HGQRRNL)XONRZ\NRU]\VWDGRZDVQ\FKFHOyZ6RO Z RNXV
PX]\VNRZQHLQWHUHV\MDNLHMDWXWDMSURZDG] ] SDQHP+RPHUHP6WUDJJHQHP
SU]H]QLHNWyU\FK]ZDQ\P6RZLNLHP)XONDV]ODJWUDILD H ZUDPDFKW\FK
LQWHUHVyZSU]\M HP+RPHUD6WUDJJHQDQDVX E FHVDUVN L PLDQRZDHPGRZyGF
RFKRWQLF]HMNRPSDQLLRFKURQ\JyUQLFWZD1LHPRJ F ZL F P FLVL RILFMDOQLH
QDMPXMHUy Q\FKRWU]\NyZ
,ZLHG PLQyZZWU FL]MDGOLZLHX PLHFKQL W\6FKLUUX
1D]HZQ WU]U]HNJR QR1LHG ZLHG PRNQLHQDGHV]F]XSL WUXSyZ
=DPRUGRZDOL FLHOXG]LE G F\FKZVX ELHFHVDUVNLHM=DNyFLOL FLHSUDF Z
NRSDOQL1LHPDP DGQ\FKZ WSOLZR FLMHVWH FLHV]SLHG]\G\ZHUVDQFLLWHUURU\ FL
1DW\PWHUHQLHRERZL ]XMHSUDZRZRMHQQH1LQLHMV]\PZWU\ELHGRUD Q\PVND]XM
ZDVQD PLHU
DELRRNL]DUHFKRWD3RGV]HGGRSRGWU]\P\ZDQHMSU]H]EDQG\WyZ$QJRXOHPH
V]\ENLPUXFKHPFKZ\FLM ]DSLHU ,PRFQR FLVQ
1RLFR-DVQD"]DVNU]HF]DDJORVRND]DRVL PLDMHV]F]HEDUG]LHM DEL
DQL HOLRF]\%DQG\FNLVREU\NLHWRLOHVDPJRVRELHQDGDGRZRG]LSRF]XFLD
KXPRUX$MH OLPLDWRE\PDM F\NDPXIORZDDOLDVWRVSUDZG]DVL
HNVWUDRUG\QDU\MQLH
6SRWNDOL P\VL MHGQDN]QRZX]DVNU]HF]D]QRZX DEL6RZLNV]F]\SL F
$QJRXOHPHZSLHU &LHV]\V]VL " ']LHZF]\QDM NQ DEROH QLH
*G]LHPDV]NXUZRSHU\LNDPLHQLHNWyUH PLXNUDGD"
:]L MHZGHSR]\W-HGQRRNL)XONRZU]DVQ D$QJRXOHPHQLHXGROQLH
XGDM F H VL QLHERL=JR VL GRQLHJRSRRGELyU
6RZLN]DVNU]HF]DLZ\EDXV]\RF]\Z\JO GDWHUD]MDNQDMSUDZG]LZV]D DED
W\ONRE\RSDWU]HMDN]DF]QLHRZLPXFK\M ]\NLHP-HV]F]HPRFQLHMXV]F]\SQ
$QJRXOHPHNWyUD]DV]DPRWDDVL L M NQ DMHV]F]HEROH QLHM=]DF]HUZRQHMPJ\
Z FLHNR FLNWyUD]DVQXDRF]\*HUDOWDG]LHZF]\QD]QRZX]DF] DSU]\SRPLQD
&LUL
%UDLFKUR]ND]D]QLHFLHUSOLZLRQ\1LHG ZLHG 1DSRGZyU]H]QLPL
7R:LHG PLQU]HNQLHSHZQLHMHGHQ]EDQG\WyZ]H6RZLNRZHMNRPSDQLL
RFKURQ\JyUQLFWZD&KDUDNWHUQLN-DNWXMHJRJR U N EUD"*RWyZQDVMDNLP
XURNLHP]DF]DURZDDOERF]\PLQV]\P
1LHPDVWUDFKXX PLHFKQL W\6FKLUUXSRNOHSDRNROLFHNLHV]HQL%H]
:LHG PLQVNLHJRDPXOHWXQLHZ\GROLF]DURZDDDPXOHWPDPMD%LHU]FLHJR
PLDR1DSRGZyU]XF]HNDOLGDOVL]EURMQL1LOIJDDUGF]\F\ZF]DUQ\FKSDV]F]DFKL
NRORURZD6RZLNRZDKDVVD=HEUDDVL WH JUXSNDJyUQLNyZ.U FL\VL
ZV] GRE\OVNLHG]LHFLLSV\
6RZLNVWUDFLQDJOHSDQRZDQLHQDGVRE =XSHQLHMDNE\GLDEHZQLHJRZVW SL
JDUGHPMHGHQ]H6RZLNRZ\FKEDQG\WyZXSDG]EHWHPZNDUNXMHGHQ]
RVWU]\ RQ\FKRVLNyZ8SDG]PDNDEU\F]Q\PM NLHP1LHG ZLHG 6WU]DDWUDILD
JRZSLHU SRGPRVWHNSRQL HMU\QJUDIX%\DWRFKRQLNWZLHG]LHWHJRQLH
PyJVWU]DDXNUDG]LRQD]ZRMVNRZHJRWUDQVSRUWXVWDQGDUGRZ\Z]yUFHVDUVNLHM
DUPLLOHNNRSU]HURELRQ\6]HURNLGZXEU]HV]F]RWRZ\JURW]RVWDZNLONXPLHMVFDFK
QDGSLRZDQ\FHOHPX]\VNDQLDHIHNWXUR]SU\VNX
*URWSL NQLHUR]SU\VQ VL Z WU]HZLDFK1LHG ZLHG]LD
3UHF]]W\UDQHP(PK\UHP:ROQH6WRNL
6RZLNVNU]HNQ FKZ\WDM F VL ]DGUD QL WHEHWHPUDPL
3RNXODVL Z F]HUZRQ\PERFLHMHGHQ]G]LHFLDNyZSU]HV]\W\QDZ\ORWVWU]D
NWyUHJR ] JRU]HMFHOXM F\FKERMRZQLNyZRZROQR 3DGMHGHQ]WU]\PDM F\FK
*HUDOWD=ZDOLVL MHGHQ]WU]\PDM F\FK$QJRXOHPH']LHZF]\QDZ\UZDDVL
GUXJLHPXE\VNDZLF]QLHZ\FL JQ DQy ] FKROHZ\FL D]V]HURNLHJRUR]PDFKX
= JRU FR FLFK\ELDJDUGR6RZLNDDOHSL NQLHUR]ZDOLDPXSROLF]HNQLHPDOGR
VDP\FK] EyZ6RZLN]DVNU]HF]DMHV]F]HVNU]HNOLZLHMQL ]D]Z\F]DMDRF]\
Z\XSLMHV]F]HZ\XSLD FLHM
2VXQ VL QDNRODQDEOX]JDM F NUZL VSRPL G]\GRQLNWyU\PLWU]\PDVL ]D
WZDU]$QJRXOHPH]DZ\DSRW SLH F]RGRVNRF]\DE\GRNR F]\G]LHDDOHQLH
]GRDDERPL G]\QL D 6RZLNLHPHNVSORGRZDDNROHMQDERPEDEXFKDM F RJQLHP
L N EDPLVPURGOLZHJRG\PX
'RRNRDMX KXF]DSR DULSDQRZDRRJQLVWHSDQGHPRQLXP.RQLHV]DOD\U D\
L ZLHU]JD\%DQG\FLL1LOIJDDUGF]\F\ZU]HV]F]HOL*yUQLF\ELHJDOLZSRSRFKX
MHGQLXFLHNDOLGUXG]\XVLRZDOLJDVLSRQ FHEXG\QNL
*HUDOW]G \MX SRGQLH XSXV]F]RQ\SU]H]1LHG ZLHG]LDVLKLOO:\VRN
NRELHW Z NROF]XG]HNWyUD]DPLHU]DDVL QDZVWDM F $QJRXOHPHPRUJHQVWHUQHP
NUyWNRFL ZF]RR&]DUQHPX1LOIJDDUGF]\NRZLQDGELHJDM FHPX]HV]SRQWRQHP
UR]SODWDXGR1DVW SQHPXNWyU\SRSURVWX]QDOD]VL QDGURG]HUR]VLHNJDUGR
7X RERNV]DOHM F\SRSDU]RQ\S G] F\QDR OHSNR REDOLLVWUDWRZDGUXJLHJR
G]LHFLDND
DSNRQLDDSNRQLD&DKLU]QDOD]VL WX RERNQLHJRF]\QLLPREXUXP
]DPDV]\VW\PLFLRVDPLPLHF]D
*HUDOWQLHVXFKDQLHSDWU]\=DU EDQDVW SQHJR1LOIJDDUGF]\ND5R]JO GDVL
]D6FKLUUX
$QJRXOHPHQDNRODQDFK]RGOHJR FLWU]HFKNURNyZVWU]HOLD]SRGQLHVLRQHM
NXV]\SDNXM F EHWZSRGEU]XV]HDWDNXM FHJRM EDQG\W\]NRPSDQLLRFKURQ\
JyUQLFWZD3RWHP]HUZDDVL L XZLHVLDX G]LHQLF\ELHJQ FHJRRERNNRQLD
DSMDNLHJR *HUDOWNU]\NQ &DKLU,ZQRJL:LHG PLQUR]SDWD
NROHMQHJR1LOIJDDUGF]\NDFL FLHP]JyU\RGPRVWNDGRELRGUD*ZDWRZQ\P
V]DUSQL FLHPJRZ\VWU] VQ NUHZ]EUZLLU] V6FKLUUX*G]LHMHVWH GUDQLX"
&L FLH.U]\N&LHSHNURSOHQDWZDU]\
/LWR FL]DZ\NO F] F\ZERFLHFKRSDNZF]DUQ\PXQLIRUPLH:LHG PLQ
]DZDKDVL
2SDPL WDMVL U\NQ &DKLUFKZ\WDM F JR]DUDPLRQDLSRWU] VDM F PRFQR
2SDPL WDMVL :V]DZSDGH "
:UDFDDJDORSHP$QJRXOHPHFL JQ F ]DZRG]HGUXJLHJRNRQLD FLJDOLM GZDM
&]HPX"
1LHPDWHUD]F]DVXQDJDGDQLD-D]GD:\GX FLH]NRQLLOHVL GD
&ZDRZDOL*QLDGRV]ZLHG PLQDFKUDSD
*QLDGRV]QLHQDGDZDVL GRGDOV]HMMD]G\/HGZRV]HGQD]HV]W\ZQLD\FKMDN
NRNLQRJDFKSRW QLHURELERNDPLSRZLHWU]HZ\FKRG]LR]QLHJR]FKUDSOLZ\P
U] HQLHP:UHV]FLHSDGQDERNZLHU]JQ V]W\ZQRSDWU]\QDMH G FDDZMHJR
]P WQLD\PRNXE\Z\U]XW
.R &DKLUDE\ZQLHFROHSV]\PVWDQLHDOH]DWR&DKLUE\ZJRUV]\P=VLRGD
SRSURVWXVSDGSRGQLyVVL DOHW\ONRQDF]ZRUDNL]Z\PLRWRZDJZDWRZQLH
FKRQLHEDUG]RPLDF]\P
*G\*HUDOWL$QJRXOHPHVSUyERZDOLGRWNQ MHJR]DNUZDZLRQHMJRZ\
]DNU]\F]D
-DVQDFKROHUDSRZLHG]LDDG]LHZF]\QD$OHPXIU\]XU ]DIXQGRZDOL
6NyUDQDGF]RHPLVNURQL PRGHJR1LOIJDDUGF]\NDZUD]]ZRVDPLE\DQD
]QDF]QHMGXJR FLRGG]LHORQDRGNR FLF]DV]NL*G\E\QLHWR H NUHZXWZRU]\D
MX NOHM F\VNU]HSOX Q\SDWRSDGE\FK\EDD QDXFKR:LGRNE\PDNDEU\F]Q\
-DNWRVL VWDR"
5]XFLOLPXSURVWRZHEWRSRUNLHP HE\E\R PLHV]QLHMWRQLHE\DQL
&]DUQ\DQLQLNWRG6RZLNDDOHNWyU\ ] NRSDOQLDQ\FKJZDUNyZ
-HVWDNXUDWRERM WQHNWRU]XFL:LHG PLQFLDVQRRZLQ JRZ &DKLUD
XGDUW\PU NDZHPNRV]XOL:D QHLV]F] OLZH H NLHSVNLE\WRPLRWDF]
RVNDOSRZDW\ONRDPyJUR]ZDOLF]DV]N $OHNR FLF]HUHSXWH VL PRFQR
GRVWDR$LPy]JWRRGF]X2QQLHXWU]\PDVL Z VLRGOHQDZHWJG\E\NR ]GRD
XQLH MHJRFL DU
&RWHG\SRF]QLHP\"7ZyMNR ]GHFKMHJRSUDZLH]GHFKD]PRMHJRD
NDSLH$]DQDPLSRJR 1LHPR HP\WX]RVWD
0XVLP\WX]RVWD-DL&DKLU,NR &DKLUD7\MHG GDOHM2VWUR7ZyMNR MHVW
PRFQ\Z\WU]\PDJDORS$QDZHWJG\E\ PLDDJR]DMH G]L$QJRXOHPHJG]LH
Z GROLQLH6DQVUHWRXUF]HNDM QDQDV5HJLV0LOYDL-DVNLHU2QLF]\PQLHZLHG] L
PRJ ZSD 6FKLUUXZDS\0XVLV]LFKRGQDOH LXSU]HG]LDSRWHPZV]\VF\
F]ZRURFRVLZNRQLDFKZDOFLHGR7RXVVDLQW7DPQLHE G ZDV FLJD0DP
QDG]LHM
$W\L&DKLU"$QJRXOHPH]DJU\]DZDUJL&RE G]LH]ZDPL"6RZLNQLHMHVW
JXSLJG\]REDF]\Sy]GHFKHJROX]DNDSU]HU\MHND G\Z\NURWZRNROLF\$W\
GDOHNR]&DKLUHPQLHXMG]LHV]
6FKLUUXERWRRQQDV FLJDSRMHG]LH]DWRE
7DNP\ OLV]"
-HVWHPSHZLHQ-HG
&RFLRWNDSRZLHJG\VL EH]ZDVSRMDZL "
:\WXPDF]\V]1LH0LOYLHW\ONR5HJLVRZL5HJLVE G]LHZLHG]LDFRQDOH \
]UREL$P\*G\&DKLURZLF]XSU\QDQLHFRPRFQLHMSU]\VFKQLHGRF]HUHSX
SRZ GUXMHP\NX7RXVVDLQW7DPVL MDNR RGQDMG]LHP\1RQLHPLWU
G]LHZF]\QR1DNR L MD]GD1LHGDMSRJRQLVL ]EOL \1LHSR]ZyOE\ FLJDOLFL
QDRNR
1LHXF]G]LDGDMDNFKDUFKD7U]\PDMFLHVL 'R]REDF]HQLD
'R]REDF]HQLD$QJRXOHPH
1LHRGGDOLVL RGGURJL]E\WGDOHNR1LHPyJVRELHRGPyZLU]XFHQLDRNLHPQD
FLJDM F\FK$ZJUXQFLHU]HF]\QLHREDZLDVL DGQ\FKDNFML]LFKVWURQ\
ZLHG]LD H QLHWUDF F F]DVXSRMDG ]D$QJRXOHPH
1LHSRP\OLVL
-H G F\NWyU]\ZSDGOLQDSU]H F]SRPQLHMQL ZLHUJRG]LQLH]DWU]\PDOLVL
FRSUDZGDQDZLGRNOH FHJRNRQLDSRZU]HV]F]HOLSRNyFLOLVL RENXVRZDOL
SU]\GUR QHNU]DNLDOHSUDZLHQDW\FKPLDVWZ]QRZLOLSRJR GURJ 1LHZ WSOLZLH
X]QDOL H ]WUyMNLXFLHNDM F\FKGZRMHMHG]LHWHUD]QDMHGQ\PNRQLXLE G]LHPR QD
V]\ENRLFKGRSD MH OLQLHE G]LHVL PLWU \*HUDOWZLG]LD H QLHNWyUHNRQLH
SR FLJXWH QLHE\\ZQDMOHSV]\PVWDQLH
: UyG FLJDM F\FKQLH]E\WZLHOHE\RF]DUQ\FKSDV]F]\QLOIJDDUG]NLHMOHNNLHM
MD]G\GRPLQRZDOLNRORURZL]EyMF\6RZLND*HUDOWQLHPyJGRMU]HF]\VDP
6RZLNELHU]HXG]LDZSRJRQLF]\WH ]RVWDLNXUXMHSRVLHF]RQ J E
*G\W WHQWRGGDODM FHJRVL SR FLJX FLFK*HUDOWZVWD]NU\MyZNLZ
SDSURFLDFKSRGQLyVLSRGWU]\PDVW NDM FHJRLSRM NXM FHJR&DKLUD
.R MHVW]DVDE\E\FL QLH % G]LHV]PyJL "
1LOIJDDUGF]\NZ\GDRGJRVPRJ F\E\UyZQLHGREU]HSRWZLHUG]HQLHPMDN
]DSU]HF]HQLHP$OERF]\P LQQ\P$OHQRJLSU]HVWDZLDDRWRJyZQLHV]R
=HV]OLGRMDUXGRNRU\WDVWUXPLHQLD&DKLURVWDWQLHNLONDQD FLHVWyS OLVNLHM
VWURPL]Q\SRNRQDGR EH]DGQ\P]MD]GHP'RSH]GRSRWRNXSLREILFLH]OHZD
ORGRZDW ZRG RSDWUXQHNQDJRZLH:LHG PLQQLHSRQDJODJRVDPRGG\FKD
J ERNR]ELHUDM F VL\
6]HGZJyU VWUXPLHQLDSRGWU]\PXM F &DKLUDLMHGQRF]H QLHFL JQ F NRQLD
EURG] F ZZRG]LHSRW\NDM F VL QDRWRF]DNDFKL]ZDORQ\FKSQLDFK&DKLUSR
MDNLP F]DVLHRGPyZLZVSySUDF\QLHSU]HVWDZLDMX SRVXV]QLHQyJSU]HVWD
QLPLZRJyOHSRUXV]D:LHG PLQ]Z\F]DMQLHJRZOyN7DNGDOHML VL QLHGDR
W\PEDUG]LHM H NRU\WRVWUXPLHQLD]DWDUDVRZD\SURJLLZRGRVSDG\*HUDOWVW NQ
Z]L UDQQHJRQDSOHF\&L JQL W\NR WH \FLDQLHXDWZLD*G\ZL F ZUHV]FLH
Z\GRVWDOLVL ] MDUX:LHG PLQSRSURVWX]ZDOLVL QDPRNUHSRV]\FLHLOH D
G\V] FNRPSOHWQLHZ\FLH F]RQ\RERNM F] FHJR&DKLUD/H DGXJR.RODQR
]QRZX]DF] RSXOVRZDZ FLHN\PEyOHP
1DUHV]FLH&DKLUGD]QRZX]QDNL \FLDDZNUyWFHSRWHPRG]LZRZVWDNOQ F
L WU]\PDM F VL ]DJRZ 3RV]OL&DKLUSRF] WNRZRV]HGG]LHOQLH3RWHP]ZROQL
3RWHPSDG
*HUDOW"
6XFKDP"
&DKLUSRSUDZLGUZDZRJQLVNX]DSRPRF ]QDOH]LRQHMNR FLXGRZHM
:NRSDOQLJG\ P\VL ELOL3U]HVWUDV]\HPVL ZLHV]"
:LHP
3U]H]FKZLO Z\JO GDR H ZSDGH Z PRUGHUF]\V]D H QLFMX VL GODFLHELH
QLHOLF]\2SUyF]PRUGRZDQLD
:LHP
%DHPVL GRNR F]\VSRNRMQLH H ZDPRNX]DVLHF]HV]WHJR6FKLUUX$]
RQLHU]QLHNZHVWLRQXMHUR]ND]yZPyZL&DKLUREPDFXM F RSDWUXQHNQD
JRZLH1LHDQDOL]XMHLFKQLH]DVWDQDZLDVL QDGQLPLQLHF]HNDE\PX
:FDOHPLQLHGR PLHFKX
'ODWHJRZD QLH]ZDPLMDG 5R]XPLHV]"
&KFHV]MHMGODVLHELHF]\GODWZHJRFHVDU]D"
-HVWHPUHDOLVW V]HSQ 3U]HFLH RQDPQLHQLH]HFKFH$MDNRPD RQN
FHVDU]DPyJE\PM SU]\QDMPQLHMZLG\ZD
-DNRUHDOLVWDSU\FKQ :LHG PLQSRZLQLHQH ZLHG]LH H QDMSLHUZPXVLP\
M RGQDOH LRFDOL=DR \ZV]\ H WZRMHVQ\QLHNDPL L &LULIDNW\F]QLHMHV]F]H
\MH
:LHPRW\P$JG\M RGQDMG]LHP\"&RZWHG\"
=REDF]\P\=REDF]\P\&DKLU
1LH]ZyG PQLH% G V]F]HU\3U]HFLH QLHSR]ZROLV]E\PM ]DEUD
1LHRGSRZLHG]LD&DKLUQLHSRQDZLDS\WDQLD
'RWHJRF]DVXVS\WDFKRGQRPR HP\E\GUXKDPL"
0R HP\&DKLU-HV]F]HUD]SU]HSUDV]DPFL ]DWDPWR1LHZLHPFRZHPQLH
ZVW SLR:JUXQFLHU]HF]\QLJG\SRZD QLHQLHSRGHMU]HZDHPFL R ]GUDG F]\
GZXOLFRZR
-DQLHMHVWHP]GUDMF -DFL QLJG\QLH]GUDG] ZLHG PLQLH
5R]G]LD
3XNDF]WDNR ]ZD NQDNHUFREO\QDXSROWHUGXNNDUNRULRVUXEH]DKOVNDUEQLND
3XVWHFNLMHVWRGPLDQ NREROGDNWyUHJRZV]HODNR3UR]PLDURZ]URVWHPLVL
]QDF]QLHSU]HQRVL1RV] WH 3]Z\F]DMQLHEURG]LVNDRJURPQHNWyU\FKNREROG\
QRV] F QLH]Z\N\%\WXMH3ZV]WROQLDFKV]DFKWDFKJUX QLDFKSU]HSD FLDFK
FLHPQ\FKMDPDFKZHZQ WU]XVNDZHZV]HODNLFKJURWDFKMDVNLQLDFKLSRVWDFLDFK
NDPLHQQ\FK7DPJG]LH \ZL QLHFK\EQLHZ]LHPLERJDFWZDV VNU\WHMDNWR
NUXV]FHUXG\NDUERQVyODROHMVNDOQ\'ODWHJRWH]3F] VWRNURZNRSDOQLDFK
QDSRWNDPR QDRVREOLZLHRSXV]F]RQ\FKDOHLZF]\QQ\FKOXELVL SRND]D
=R OLZ\GHVSHWQLNLV]NRGQLNSU]HNOH VWZRLLVWQ\GRSXVWER \ GODJyUQLNyZL
JZDUNyZNWyU\FKUR]SDQRV]RQ\3QDPDQRZFHZRG]LSXNDQLHPZVNDO PDPLL
VWUDV]\FKRGQLNL]DZDODJyUQLF]\SU]\U] G LZV]HODN FKXGRE NUDGQLHLSVRZDD
RGWHJRE\]]DZ JDSD Z HEVWU]HOLWH QLHMHVW
$OHSU]HNXSLJRPR QDE\QLHSVRFLQDGPLDU SRR \ZV]\JG]LHZFKRGQLNX
FLHPQ\POXERZV]DFKFLHFKOHE]PDVHPRVF\SHNSRHZ G]RQHMV]RGU\DOH
QDMOHSLHMJ VLRUHNRNRZLW\QDW ERZLHP3RNUXWQLHMHVWDNRP\
3K\VLRORJXV
WUXEDGXURZL]D]HQLHZLHG]LHF]HPX:7RXVVDLQWQLHFK\EQLHMHVWMDNL P Z
NWyU\PQDZLGRN-DVNUDPRJ RG \ZVSRPQLHQLD$OHWRZJUXQFLHU]HF]\
QLHZD QH:UyP\GRNRQNUHWyZ&R]SR FLJLHP"0DPQDG]LHM H
1LHV G] X PLHFKQ VL 5HJLVE\SU]HV]OL]DQDPLGR7RXVVDLQW*UDQLFD
URLVL RGE GQHJRU\FHUVWZDNWyUHQXG]LVL QLH]Z\NOHLV]XNDRND]MLGRELWNL
1DGWRP\ P\ZUD]]JUXS QDSRWNDQ\FKQDJUDQLF\SLHOJU]\PyZWUDILOLRGUD]XGR
ZL WHJRJDMX0\UNYLG$PLHMVFHWREXG]LVWUDFK1DZHWSLHOJU]\PLLFKRU]\
NWyU]\]QDMGDOV]\FK]DN WNyZZ GUXM GR0\UNYLGSRX]GURZLHQLH]DWU]\PXM VL
Z RVLHGOXQLHGDOHNRVNUDMXODVXQLH PLHM F ZFKRG]LZJ E%RNU
SORWNL H
NWRRGZD \ VL ZHM GR ZL W\FKG EUyZNR F]\VSDORQ\QDZROQ\PRJQLXZ
:LNOLQRZHM%DELH
*HUDOWZFL JQ SRZLHWU]H
&]\ E\
2F]\ZL FLHZDPSLU]QRZXQLHSR]ZROLPXGRNR F]\:JDMX0\UN\LG
E\WXM GUXLG]L&LNWyU]\GDZQLHMPLHV]NDOLZ$QJUHQLHZ&DHG'KXSRWHP
Z\Z GURZDOLQDGMH]LRUR0RQGXLPDZUHV]FLHGR0\UNYLGGR7RXVVDLQW%\R
QDPSU]H]QDF]RQH H GRQLFKWUDILP\1LHSDPL WDPPyZLHP H MHVWQDPWR
SU]H]QDF]RQH"
*HUDOWRGHWFKQ PRFQR-DG F\]DMHJRSOHFDPL&DKLUWH
7ZyM]QDMRP\MHVWZ UyGW\FKGUXLGyZ"
:DPSLUX PLHFKQ VL ]QRZX
7RQLHMHVW]QDMRP\OHF]]QDMRPDZ\MD QL2ZV]HPMHVWZ UyGQLFK
1DZHWDZDQVRZDD3U]HZRG]LFDHPX.U JRZL
+LHURIDQWND"
)ODPLQLND7DNVL QD]\ZDQDMZ\ V]\GUXLG]NLW\WXJG\QRVLJRNRELHWD
7\ONRP F]\ QLE\ZDM KLHURIDQWDPL
3UDZGD]DSRPQLDHP5R]XPLHP H 0LOYDLUHV]WD
6 WHUD]SRGRSLHN IODPLQLNLL.U JXZDPSLUVZRLP]Z\F]DMHP
RGSRZLHG]LDQDS\WDQLHZWUDNFLHMHJR]DGDZDQLDSRF]\PQDW\FKPLDVWSU]\VW SL
GRRGSRZLHG]LQDS\WDQLDMHV]F]HQLH]DGDQH
-DQDWRPLDVWSRVSLHV]\HPQDVSRWNDQLH]ZDPL$OERZLHPZ\GDU]\DVL U]HF]
]DJDGNRZD)ODPLQLNDNWyUHM]DF] HPSU]HGVWDZLDQDV] VSUDZ QLHGDDPL
GRNR F]\2 ZLDGF]\D H ZLHRZV]\VWNLP H MX RGMDNLHJR F]DVXVSRG]LHZD
VL QDV]HJRSU]\E\FLD
6XFKDP"
-DWH QLHPRJHPXNU\QLHGRZLHU]DQLDZDPSLUZVWU]\PDPXDVWDQ Z
VWU]HPLRQDFKUR]HMU]DVL
6]XNDV]NRJR F]\F]HJR " VS\WD&DKLU
-X QLHV]XNDP]QDOD]HP=VL G P\
:RODE\PMDNQDMSU G]HM
=VL G P\:\MD QL FLZV]\VWNR
0XVLHOLPyZLJR QLHME\PyFSRUR]XPLHVL Z V]XPLHZRGRVSDGX
VSDGDM FHJR]H]QDF]QHMZ\VRNR FLSRSLRQRZHM FLDQLHVNDOQHJRXUZLVND:GROH
WDPJG]LHZRGRVSDGZ\SXNDVSRUHMH]LRUNRZVNDOH]LDF]DUQ\RWZyUMDVNLQL
7DNWRZD QLHWDP5HJLVSRWZLHUG]LSU]\SXV]F]HQLHZLHG PLQD
:\MHFKDHPFLQDVSRWNDQLHERSROHFRQRPLFL WXVNLHURZD'RWHMMDVNLQL
E G]LHV]PXVLDZHM 0yZLHPFLGUXLG]LZLHG]LHOLRWRELHZLHG]LHOLR&LUL
ZLHG]LHOLRQDV]HMPLVML$GRZLHG]LHOLVL WHJRRGRVRE\NWyUDRWDPPLHV]ND
2VREDWDMH OLZLHU]\GUXLGFHSUDJQLH]WRE SRUR]PDZLD
-H OLZLHU]\GUXLGFHSRZWyU]\]SU]HN VHP*HUDOW-DE\ZDHPZW\FK
RNROLFDFK:LHPFRPLHV]NDZJ ERNLFKMDVNLQLDFKSRG*yU 'LDED0LHV]NDM
WDPUy QLPLHV]ND F\$OH]SU]HZD DM F ZL NV]R FL QLHGDVL JDZ G]LFK\ED
H PLHF]HP&RMHV]F]HSRZLHG]LDDWDWZRMDGUXLGND":FRMHV]F]HPDP
XZLHU]\"
:VSRVyEZ\UD Q\ZDPSLUXWNZLZ*HUDOFLHF]DUQHRF]\GDDPLGR
]UR]XPLHQLD H QLHSU]HSDGD]DRVREQLNDPLQLV]F] F\PLL]DELMDM F\PL \Z
SU]\URG Z RJyOQR FLD]DZLHG PLQDPLZV]F]HJyOQR FL:\MD QLHP H Z
FKZLOLREHFQHMMHVWH ZLHG PLQHPUDF]HMW\WXODUQ\P H DEVROXWQLHQLH
QDSU]\NU]DV]VL \ZHMSU]\URG]LHRLOHWDRVWDWQLDWRELHVL QLHQDSU]\NU]D
)ODPLQLNDWU]HEDFLZLHG]LH]HMHVWWRNRELHWDQLH]Z\NOHE\VWUD]DXZD \D]
PLHMVFD H ZLHG PL VWZD]DQLHFKDH QLHZVNXWHN]PLDQ ZLDWRSRJO GRZ\FKOHF]
]PXV]RQ\RNROLF]QR FLDPL:LHPGRVNRQDOHSRZLHG]LDD H QLHV]F] FLH
VSRWNDREOLVN ZLHG PLQRZLRVRE :LHG PLQ]PXV]RQ\E\ZL F ]DQLHFKD
ZLHG PL VWZDLSRVSLHV]\QDUDWXQHN
*HUDOWQLHVNRPHQWRZDDOHMHJRVSRMU]HQLHE\RQDW\OHZ\PRZQH H ZDPSLU
SRVSLHV]\]Z\MD QLHQLDPL
2 ZLDGF]\DF\WXM 1LHE G F\ZLHG PLQHP:LHG PLQXGRZRGQL H VWD
JRQDSRNRU L SR ZL FHQLH:VW SLZPURF]Q F]HOX ]LHPL%H]EURQQ\
=RVWDZLZV]\ZV]HONLRU ZV]HONLHRVWUH HOD]R:V]HONLHRVWUHP\ OL:V]HON
DJUHVM JQLHZ]R DURJDQFM :HMG]LHZSRNRU]H$ZyZF]DVWDPZF]HOX FL
SRNRUQ\QLHZLHG PLQ]QDMG]LHRGSRZLHG]LQDS\WDQLDNWyUHJRGU F] =QDMG]LH
RGSRZLHG]LQDZLHOHS\WD $OHJG\:LHG PLQSR]RVWDQLHZLHG PLQHPQLH
]QDMG]LHQLF]HJR
*HUDOWVSOXQ ZVWURQ ZRGRVSDGXLMDVNLQL
7R]Z\NDJUDR ZLDGF]\=DEDZD)LJOH-DVQRZLG]WZRSR ZL FHQLH
WDMHPQLF]HVSRWNDQLDZJURWDFKRGSRZLHG]LQDS\WDQLD7DNRJUDQHFKZ\W\
PR QDQDSRWNDW\ONRXZ GURZQ\FKG]LDGyZEDMDU]\.WR WXNSLVRELH]HPQLH
: QDMOHSV]\PUD]LH$MH HOLWRQLHMHVWNSLQD
.SLQ QLHQD]ZDE\PWHJRZ DGQ\PUD]LHSRZLHG]LDVWDQRZF]R5HJLV:
DGQ\P*HUDOFLH]5LYLL
&RWRZL F MHVW"-HGQR]RVDZLRQ\FKGUXLG]NLFKG]LZDFWZ"
1LHE G]LHP\ZLHG]LHRGH]ZDVL &DKLUGRSyNLVL QLHSU]HNRQDP\
&KRG *HUDOWZHMG]LHP\WDPUD]HP
1LHSRNU FLJRZ ZDPSLU)ODPLQLNDE\DZW\PZ]JO G]LHNDWHJRU\F]QD
:LHG PLQPXVLZHM WDPVDP%H]EURQL'DMPLWZyMPLHF]=DRSLHNXM VL QLP
Z F]DVLHWZHMQLHREHFQR FL
1LHFKPQLHGLDEOL]DF] *HUDOWDOH5HJLVV]\ENLPJHVWHPSU]HUZDPXWRN
Z\SRZLHG]L
'DMPLWZyMPLHF]Z\FL JQ U N $MH OLPDV]MHV]F]HMDN EUR ]RVWDZ
PLM WDN H3DPL WDMRVRZDFKIODPLQLNL DGQHMDJUHVML3R ZL FHQLH3RNRUD
&]\W\ZLHV]NRJRWDPQDSRWNDP".WROXEFRF]HNDQDPQLHZWHMMDVNLQL"
1LHQLHZLHP1DMUy QLHMV]HVWZRU\]DPLHV]NXM SRG]LHPQHNRU\WDU]HSRG
*RUJRQ
6]ODJPQLHWUDIL
:DPSLUFKU] NQ FLFKR
7HJRZ\NOXF]\QLHPR QDU]HNSRZD QLH$OHPXVLV]SRGM WRU\]\NR
3U]HFLH ZLHP H MHSRGHMPLHV]
NZD Q\]DSDFK
0XVLDVL ]DWU]\PD1DMHJRGURG]HPL G]\GZRPDVWDODJPLWDPLZPLHMVFX
NWyUHJRRPLQ QLHPyJOH DVSRU\HFKLQRSVQDMH RQ\PDV GXJLFKNROFyZ
*HUDOWSU]HNQ OLQ :LHG]LDD QDGWRGREU]H H HFKLQRSVSRWUDILVWU]HOD
NROFDPLQDRGOHJR G]LHVL FLXVWyS.ROFHPLD\V]F]HJyOQ ZD FLZR ZELWH
Z FLDRDPD\VL DRVWUHNR FyZNLZQLND\LZ GURZD\FRUD]J ELHMLJ ELHM
D ZUHV]FLHGRVL JD\MDNLHJR ZUD OLZHJRRUJDQX
:LHG PLQJXSLXV\V]D]PURNX:LHG PLQWFKyU]OLZ\0DVWUDFKDKD
KD
*RVEU]PLDRVREOLZLHLREFRDOH*HUDOWV\V]DMX WDNLHJRV\QLHMHGHQLQLH
GZDUD]\7DNPyZL\LVWRW\QLHSU]\]Z\F]DMRQHGRSRUR]XPLHZDQLDVL ]D
SRPRF PRZ\DUW\NXRZDQHMSU]H]WRG]LZQLHDNFHQWXM FHLLQWRQXM FH
QLHQDWXUDOQLHSU]HFL JDM FHV\ODE\
:LHG PLQJXSL:LHG PLQJXSL
3RZVWU]\PDVL RGNRPHQWDU]D=DJU\]ZDUJLLRVWUR QLHSU]HV]HGRERN
HFKLQRSVD.ROFHSRWZRUD]DIDORZD\MDNPDFNLXNZLDX$OHW\ONRQDPRPHQW
SRWHPHFKLQRSV]QLHUXFKRPLDL]QyZ]DF] SU]\SRPLQDZLHON N S EDJLHQQHM
WUDZ\
'ZDRJURPQHEDUEHJD]LSU]HWRF]\\VL SU]H]MHJRGURJ V]ZDUJRF] F L
SRZDUNXM F=JyU\VSRGVNOHSLHQLDGRELHJRSRWERQLDVW\FKVNU]\GHLV\F] F\
FKLFKRWQLHRP\OQLHV\JQDOL]XM F\REHFQR OL FLRQRVyZLZHVSHUW\OyZ
3U]\V]HGWXWDMPRUGHUFD]DELMDF]:LHG PLQUR]OHJVL Z PURNXWHQVDP
JRVNWyU\V\V]DXSU]HGQLR:OD]WXWDM2 PLHOLVL $OHQLHPDPLHF]D
]DELMDF]7RMDNFKFH]DELMD":]URNLHP"+DKD
$PR H UR]OHJVL GUXJLJRV]MHV]F]HEDUG]LHMQLHQDWXUDOQ DUW\NXODFM WR
P\MHJR]DELMD"+DDDD"
%DUEHJD]L]DJDZRU]\\JR Q\PFKyUHP-HGHQZLHONLMDNGRMU]DDG\QLD
SU]\WRF]\VL EDUG]REOLVNRLNODSQ ] EDPLWX SU]\SL WDFK*HUDOWD:LHG PLQ
VWXPLFLVQ FHVL QDZDUJLSU]HNOH VWZR3RV]HGGDOHM=HVWDODNW\WyZNDSDD
ZRGDG]ZRQL F VUHEU]\VW\PHFKHP
&R XF]HSLRVL MHJRQRJL3RZVWU]\PDVL E\QLHRGWU FLJZDWRZQLH
6WZRUHNE\QLHGX \QLHZLHOHZL NV]\RGSVDSHNL F]\ND7URFK WH
SHNL F]\NDSU]\SRPLQD=REOLF]D=UHV]W\SU]\SRPLQDPDSN *HUDOWQLHPLD
SRM FLDFRWRMHVW: \FLXQLHZLG]LDQLF]HJRSRGREQHJR
:LG PLQZ\DUW\NXRZDZL]JOLZLHDOHZFDOHZ\UD QLHSHNL F]\N
NXUF]RZRZF]HSLRQ\ZEXW*HUDOWD:LG PPPLQ6XNLQV\Q
2GF]HSVL U]HNSU]H]]DFL QL WH] E\2GF]HSVL RGEXWDERNRSQ FL Z
GXS
%DUEHJD]L]DJDZRU]\\JR QLHMJZDWRZQLHMLJUR QLHM:FLHPQR FLDFKFR
]DU\F]DR*HUDOWQLHZLHG]LDFRWRE\R%U]PLDRMDNNURZDDOH:LHG PLQV]HG
R ND G\]DNDG H NURZDWRQLHE\D
:LG PLQVXNLQV\Q
3X PyMEXWSRZWyU]\]WUXGHPSDQXM F QDGVRE 3U]\V]HGHPWX
EH]EURQQ\ZSRNRMX3U]HV]NDG]DV]PL
8UZDL]DNU]WXVLVL IDO REU]\GOLZHJRIHWRUXRGNWyUHJRRF]\]DZL\DZRV\
]ZLMD\VL Z N G]LRUNL
:SLW\ZMHJR\GN SHNL F]\NRSRGREQ\VWZRUHNZ\EDXV]DRF]\LGHIHNRZD
PXSURVWRQDEXW2K\GQHPXVPURGRZLWRZDU]\V]\\MHV]F]HRK\GQLHMV]HRGJRV\
=DNO DGHNZDWQLHGRV\WXDFMLLRGHSFKQ QRJ QDFKDOQHVWZRU]RQNR'X R
GHOLNDWQLHMQL QDOH DR$OHLWDNVWDRVL WRF]HJRRF]HNLZD
.RSQ PDHJR]DU\F]DRFR ] FLHPQR FLSRQDGKXUDJDQRZ\PZU F]
V]ZDUJRWDQLHPLVNRZ\WHPEDUEHJD]L.RSQ PDHJR6NU]\ZG]LPQLHMV]HJRRG
VLHELH
1DMEOL V]HEDUEHJD]LSU]\WXUOD\PXVL GRVDP\FKQyJ3RF]XMDNLFKV NDWHL
WZDUGHMDNNDPLHQLHDSVNDFKZ\WDM JRLXQLHUXFKDPLDM 1LHEURQLVL E\
]XSHQLH]UH]\JQRZDQ\:IXWURQDMZL NV]HJRLQDMEDUG]LHMDJUHV\ZQHJRZ\WDU
REIDMGDQ\EXW&L JQL W\]DXEUDQLHXVLDG
&R ZLHONLHJR]VXQ RVL SRVWDODJQDFLH]HVNDNXM F QDVS J2GUD]XZLHG]LD
FRWRMHVW3XNDF].U S\S NDW\NRVPDW\NU]\ZRQRJLV]HURNLZEDUDFKFK\EDQD
V H ]UXG EURG NWyUDE\DMHV]F]HV]HUV]D
=EOL DQLXVL SXNDF]DWRZDU]\V]\\ZVWU] V\JUXQWXMDNJG\E\WRQLHSXNDF]VL
]EOL DDOHSHUV]HURQ=URJRZDFLDHLV]HURNLHVWRS\SRWZRUDPLD\MDNNROZLHNE\
WR PLHV]QLHEU]PLDRSRSyWRUHMVWRS\GXJR FLND GD
3XNDF]SRFK\OLVL QDGQLPL]LRQ ZyGN 6]HOP\S G] WXVDPRJRQSRP\ OD
PDFKLQDOQLH*HUDOW
8GHU]\H PQLHMV]HJRRGVLHELHZLHG PLQLHZ\ PLHUG]LDPXZWZDU]
SXNDF]%H]GDQLDUDFML]DDWDNRZDH L VNU]\ZG]LH PDHDJRGQHQLHZLQQH
VWZRU]RQNR:LHG]LHOL P\ H QLHPR QDFLXID-HVWH DJUHV\ZQ\0DV]LQVW\QNW\
PRUGHUF\,OXQDV]\FK]DELH NDQDOLR"
1LHX]QD]DFHORZHRGSRZLDGD
2RRRRSXNDF]MHV]F]HPRFQLHM]LRQ QDQLHJRSU]HWUDZLRQ\PDONRKROHP
2GG]LHFNDRW\PPDU]\HP2GG]LHFND:UHV]FLHVSHQLRVL PRMHPDU]HQLH
6SyMU]ZOHZR
6SRMU]DMDNNWRJXSL,GRVWDSUDZ SL FL Z ] E\WDN H XMU]DZLHON
MDVQR
2RRRRRSXNDF]Z\V]F]HU]\]J VWZ\ PLHUG] FHMEURG\ZLHONLHNU]\ZH
] ELVND2GG]LHFNDRW\PPDU]\HP6SyMU]ZSUDZR
'RV\UR]OHJVL JG]LH ] J ELMDVNLQLJR Q\LG ZL F]Q\UR]ND]'RV\
W\FKLJUDV]HNLILJOL3URV] JRSX FL
*HUDOWZ\SOXNUHZ]UR]FL WHMZDUJL2EP\EXWZVWUXP\F]NX FLHNDM FHMSR
VNDOHZRG\6NXQNV]IDFMDW SHNL F]\NDV]F]HU]\VL QDQLHJRV]\GHUF]RDOH]
EH]SLHF]QHMRGOHJR FL3XNDF]WH VL V]F]HU]\PDVXM F SL
,G ZLHG PLQLH]DZDUF]D,G GRQLHJRVNRURFL Z]\ZD-DSRF]HNDP%R
SU]HFLH WRW G\E G]LHV]PXVLDZUDFD
-DVNLQLDGRNWyUHMZV]HGRG]LZRSHQDE\D ZLDWD3U]H]RWZRU\ZMH F\P
VL RGVRSOH FyZVNOHSLHQLXZSDGD\NU]\ XM FHVL VXS\MDVQR FLZ\GRE\ZDM FH
]HVNDLQDFLHNRZ\FKIRUPDFMLIHHUL EODVNyZLNRORUyZ:SRZLHWU]XZLVLDDWX
QDGWRSRQ FDMDVQR FL PDJLF]QDNXODZVSRPDJDQDUHIOHNVDPLNZDUFXZ
FLDQDFK0LPRFDHMWHMLOXPLQDFMLNUDQLHFMDVNLQLJLQ ZPURNXZSHUVSHNW\ZLH
NROXPQDG\VWDODJQDWyZF]DLDVL F]DUQDFLHPQR
0R H GODWHJRRGU]HNVXFKR H WRQLHXQLNQLRQH"
(OIRGZUyFLVL JZDWRZQLH
&R]DS\WDSU]H]]DFL QL WH] E\MHVWQLHXQLNQLRQH"
0R H WR*HUDOWRZLQLHFKFLDRVL SRGQRVLJRVX H PLQLHGDOV]\FKSDU ODW
L OXG]LHSRSURVWXZH]P VRELHND G ZLHG] QLHEDF] FF]\NWR ]HFKFHG]LHOL
VL QL ] QLPLF]\QLH":W\PWDN H LZLHG] R W\PFRW\HOIL:LHG] F\VSU\WQLH
XNU\ZDV]]DQDVNDOQ\PLIUHVNDPL"/LF] F QDWR H OXG]LHQLH]HFKF UR]ZDOD
NLORIDPLWHM FLDQ\]DPDORZDQHMIDV]\Z\PGRZRGHPSUDOXG]NLHJRLVWQLHQLD"&R"
0yMW\RJQLXSUy QR FL"
(OISDUVNQ :FDOHZHVRR
2WDNSRZLHG]LD3Uy QR FL L FLHSRVXQL W GRJXSRW\E\RE\PQLHPD
H F]HJR QLHUR]ZDOLFLH5R]ZDOLFLHZV]\VWNR7\ONRFR]WHJR"&R]WHJR
F]RZLHNX"
1LHZLHP3RZLHG]PL$MH OLQLHX]QDV]]DVWRVRZQHWRVRELHSyMG
1DMFK WQLHMLQQ\PZ\M FLHPERSU]\WDPW\PF]HNDM QDPQLHWZRLVZDZROQL
NRPSDQLSUDJQ F\QDGZHU \PL HEHU
3URV] HOIJZDWRZQ\PUXFKHPUR]SRVWDUU FHD FLDQDVNDOQDUR]ZDUDVL
]H]JU]\WHPLWU]DVNLHPEUXWDOQLHG]LHO F ILROHWRZHJREL]RQDSU]H]Sy:\MG
W G\6W SDMNX ZLDWX:SU]HQR QLF]\GRVRZQLHWR]UHJX\ZD FLZDGURJD
6]NRGDWURFK PUXNQ *HUDOW0DPQDP\ OLIUHVN
DUWXMHV]FK\EDSRZLHG]LDSRFKZLOLPLOF]HQLDHOI]DG]LZLDM FRZU F]
DJRGQLHLSU]\MD QLH)UHVNRZLQLFQLHE G]LH,GHQW\F]Q\P]DNO FLHP]DPNQ
VND QDZHW ODGXU\V\QLH]RVWDQLH&KRG :\MG ] WRE SU]HSURZDG] FL
'RV]HGHPGRZQLRVNX H PDPFLMHGQDNFR GRSRZLHG]HQLD,GRSRND]DQLD
:HZQ WU]SDQRZDDFLHPQR DOH:LHG PLQ]PLHMVFDZLHG]LD H MDVNLQLDMHVW
RJURPQDSR]QDWRSRWHPSHUDWXU]HLUXFKXSRZLHWU]D ZLUSRNWyU\PV]OLE\
PRNU\$YDOODF
KZ\F]DURZD ZLDWRHOIL PRG W\ONRJHVWHPEH]Z\SRZLDGDQLD
]DNO FLD-DU] FDVL NXODZ]OHFLDODNXVNOHSLHQLXIRUPDFMHNU\V]WDXJyUVNLHJRZ
FLDQDFKJURW\]DSRQ \PLULDGHPUHIOHNVyZLO QLH ]DWD F]\\FLHQLH:LHG PLQ
ZHVWFKQ PLPRZROL
1LHSLHUZV]\UD]ZLG]LDHOILHU]H E\LSRV JLDOH]DND G\PUD]HPZUD HQLH
E\ORWDNLHVDPR H ]DVW\JHZSyUXFKXZSyOGUJQLHQLDSRVWDFLHOIyZLHOIHNQLH
V G]LHHPGXWDU]H ELDU]DOHF]HIHNWHPSRW QHJRF]DUX]GROQHJR]PLHQL \Z
WNDQN Z ELD\PDUPXU]$PHOO
1DMEOL V]DVWDWXDSU]HGVWDZLDDHON VLHG] F QDSRGNXUF]RQ\FKQRJDFKQD
ED]DOWRZHMS\FLH(OINDRGZUDFDDJRZ MDNJG\E\]DDODUPRZDQDV]PHUHP
]EOL DM F\FKVL NURNyZ%\D]XSHQLHQDJD%LD\LZ\JDG]RQ\GRPOHF]QHJR
EODVNXPDUPXUVSUDZLD H ZU F]F]XRVL HPDQXM FH]SRV JXFLHSR
$\DOODF
K]DWU]\PDVL L RSDURMHGQ ] NROXPQZ\W\F]DM F\FKGURJ Z UyG
DOHLSRV JyZ
3RUD]GUXJLRGH]ZDVL FLFKRE\VNRWOLZLHPQLHUR]V]\IURZDH *HUDOFLH
7DNPLDH UDFM EL]RQLHPDORZLGRQDVNDOHWRE\NDPXIOD 0DM F\]QLHFK FL
GRUR]NXZDQLDLSU]HELMDQLD FLDQ\0DM F\XFKURQLWRZV]\VWNRWXWDMSU]HG
JUDELH L GHZDVWDFM .D GDUDVDHOILDUyZQLH PDSUDZRGRNRU]HQL7RFR
ZLG]LV]WRV QDV]HNRU]HQLH6W SDMSURV] RVWUR QLH7RMHVWZJUXQFLHU]HF]\
FPHQWDU]
7D F] FHSRJyUVNLFKNU\V]WDDFKUHIOHNV\ ZLDWDZ\GRE\ZD\]PURNXGDOV]H
V]F]HJy\]DDOHM SRV JyZZLGDE\RNROXPQDG\VFKRG\DPILWHDWUDOQH
NUX JDQNLDUNDG\LSHU\VW\OH:V]\VWNR]ELDHJRPDUPXUX
&KF SRGM $\DOODF
K]DWU]\PXM F VL L ZVND]XM F GRQL E\WRSU]HWUZDR
1DZHWJG\P\RGHMG]LHP\JG\FD\WHQNRQW\QHQWLFD\WHQ ZLDW]QDMG]LHVL SRG
PLORZ ZDUVWZ ORGXL QLHJX7LUQD%HD$UDLQQHSU]HWUZD2GHMG]LHP\VW GDOH
NLHG\ WXSRZUyFLP\0\HOI\3U]\U]HNDQDPWR$HQ,WKOLQQHVSHDWKSURURFWZR
,WKOLQQH$HJOLDHS$HYHQLHQ
:\QDSUDZG Z QL ZLHU]\FLH":W ZLHV]F]E " $ WDNJ ERNLMHVWZDV]
IDWDOL]P"
:V]\VWNRHOIQLHSDWU]\QDQLHJROHF]QDPDUPXURZHNROXPQ\SRNU\WH
GHOLNDWQ MDNSDM F]\QDSDVNRU]H E ]RVWDRSU]HZLG]LDQHLZ\SURURNRZDQH
:DV]HSU]\E\FLHQDNRQW\QHQWZRMQ\SU]HOHZHOILHMLOXG]NLHMNUZL:]UDVWDQLH
ZDV]HMUDV\GHNDGHQFM QDV]HM:DON ZDGFyZ3yQRF\L3RXGQLD,SRZVWDQLH
RWRNUyO3RXGQLDSU]HFLZNUyORP3yQRF\L]DOHMHLFK]LHPLHMDNSRZyG E G RQL
]GUX]JRWDQLDQDURG\LFK]QLV]F]RQH
,WDN]DF]QLHVL ]DJDGD ZLDWD3DPL WDV]WHNVW,WOLQ\ZLHG PLQLH".WRMHVW
GDOHNRXPU]HRG]DUD]\NWRMHVWEOLVNRSDGQLHRGPLHF]DNWRXFKRZDVL XPU]H
] JRGXNWRSU]HWUZDWHJR]JXELPUy]$OERZLHPQDGHMG]LH7HGG'HLUHDGK&]DV
.R FD&]DV0LHF]DL7RSRUD&]DV3RJDUG\&]DV%LDHJR=LPQDL:LOF]HM
=DPLHFL
3RH]MD
:ROLV]PQLHMSRHW\FNR":VNXWHN]PLDQ\N WDSDGDQLDSURPLHQLVRQHF]Q\FK
SU]HVXQLHVL LWR]QDF]QLHJUDQLFDZLHF]QHM]PDU]OLQ\7RJyU\]PLD G \ L
RGHSFKQLHGDOHNRQDSRXGQLHVXQ F\]SyQRF\OyG:V]\VWNRSU]\V\SLHELD\
QLH HN:DUVWZ JUXE QDSRQDGPLO ,]URELVL EDUG]RDOHWREDUG]R]LPQR
% G]LHP\QRVLFLHSOHJDFLH]DSRZLHG]LDEH]HPRFML*HUDOW.R XV]NL,
IXWU]DQHF]DSNL
=XVWPLWRZ\M H ]JRG]LVL VSRNRMQLHHOI,ZW\FKJDFLDFKLF]DSNDFK
SU]HWUZDFLHE\NWyUHJR GQLDZUyFLWXNRSDGR\LV]SHUDZW\FKMDVNLQLDFKE\
QLV]F]\LNUD :LHV]F]ED,WOLQ\WHJRQLHPyZLDOHMDWRZLHP1LHVSRVyE
FDNRZLFLH]QLV]F]\OXG]LLNDUDOXFKyZ]DZV]H]RVWDQLHFRQDMPQLHMSDUND&RGR
QDVHOIyZ,WOLQDMHVWEDUG]LHM]GHF\GRZDQDRFDOHM W\ONRFLNWyU]\SyMG ]D
-DVNyN -DVNyNDV\PEROZLRVQ\MHVWZ\EDZLFLHON W NWyUDRWZRU]\=DND]DQH
'U]ZLZVND H GURJ Z\EDZLHQLD,XPR OLZLRGURG]HQLH ZLDWD-DVNyND
']LHFNR6WDUV]HM.UZL
&]\OL&LUL"QLHZ\WU]\PD*HUDOW$OERG]LHFNR&LUL"-DN",GODF]HJR"
$\DOODF
K]GDZDRE\VL QLHGRV\V]D
-DVNyND]H6WDUV]HM.UZLSRZWyU]\=MHMNUZL&KRG ,VSyMU]
1DZHWVSR UyGLQQ\FKQLHVDPRZLFLHZU F]UHDOLVW\F]Q\FKXFKZ\FRQ\FKZ
UXFKXOXEJH FLHSRV JyZZVND]\ZDQ\SU]H]$YDOODF
KDZ\Uy QLDVL %LDD
PDUPXURZDHOINDSyOH FDQDS\FLHVSUDZLDZUD HQLHMDNJG\E\SU]HEXG]RQD
PLDD]DFKZLO XVL LZVWD%\DREUyFRQDWZDU] NXSXVWHPXPLHMVFXXMHM
ERNXDXQLHVLRQDGR ]GDZDDVL GRW\NDWDPF]HJR QLHZLG]LDOQHJR
7RMHVWDOERSRH]MDDOERPHWDIL]\ND$OERMHGQRLGUXJLHERF]DVDPLWUXGQR
UR]JUDQLF]\&]\PR OLZHV MDNLH NRQNUHW\"&KRE\PLQLPDOQH"&K WQLH
SRG\VNXWRZDE\P]WRE R W\PLRZ\PDOHWDNVL VNDGD H PLSLOQR
$YDOODF
K]PLHU]\JRSU]HFL J\PVSRMU]HQLHP
$GRN G WRWDNFLSLOQR"$FKZ\EDF]7\MDNPLVL ]GDMHQLH]UR]XPLDH
QLF]WHJRFRPyZLHP3RZLHPZL F SURVWRWZRMDZLHONDZ\SUDZDUDWXQNRZD
SR]EDZLRQDMHVWMX VHQVX&DNRZLFLHJRVWUDFLD
3RZRGyZMHVWNLONDSRGM HOISDWU] F QDNDPLHQQ WZDU]ZLHG PLQD3R
SLHUZV]HMHVWMX ]DSy QR]DVDGQLF]H]RMX VL GRNRQDRQLHMHVWH MX Z VWDQLH
RFDOLSU]HGQLPG]LHZF]\Q\3RGUXJLHWHUD]JG\ZVW SLDMX QDZD FLZ GURJ
-DVNyND ZLHWQLHSRUDG]LVRELHVDPD]E\WSRW Q PRFQRVLZVRELHE\O NDVL
F]HJRNROZLHN7ZRMDSRPRFMHVWMHM]E GQD$SRWU]HFLH+PPP
-DFL FD\F]DVVXFKDP$\DOODF
K&D\F]DV
3RWU]HFLH3RWU]HFLHNWR LQQ\MHMWHUD]SRPR H&K\EDQLHMHVWH D WDN
DURJDQFNLE\P\ OH H W G]LHZF]\Q W\ONRLZ\ F]QLH]WRE SRZL ]DR
SU]H]QDF]HQLH
7RZV]\VWNR"
7DN
'RZLG]HQLD]DWHP
=DF]HNDM
0yZLHP3LOQRPL
=Dy P\SU]H]FKZLO U]HNVSRNRMQLHHOI H MDIDNW\F]QLHZLHPFRVL
VWDQLH H ZLG] SU]\V]R -H HOLSRZLHPFL H WRFRPDVL VWDVWDQLHVL L WDN
QLH]DOH QLHRGF]\QLRQ\FKSU]H]FLHELHZ\VLNyZ"2GSRGHMPRZDQ\FKLQLFMDW\Z"
-H OL]DNRPXQLNXM FL H PyJE\ Z\V]XNDVRELHMDNLH VSRNRMQHPLHMVFHQD
]LHPLLVLHG]LHWDPQLFQLHUREL FF]HNDM F QDQLHXQLNQLRQHNRQVHNZHQFMHELHJX
Z\GDU]H F]\]GHF\GXMHV]VL QDFR WDNLHJR"
1LH
$MH HOL]DNRPXQLNXM FL H WZRMDDNW\ZQR ZLDGF] FDREUDNXZLDU\Z
QLH]DFKZLDQHPHFKDQL]P\&HOX3ODQXL5H]XOWDWXPR HFKR
SUDZGRSRGRELH VWZRMHVWQLNHU]HF]\ZL FLH]PLHQLFRQLHFRDOHZ\ F]QLHQD
JRUV]H"&]\SU]HP\ OLV]VSUDZ SRQRZQLH"$FKMX ] WZRMHMPLQ\ZLG] H QLH
=DS\WDPZL F SRSURVWXGODF]HJRQLH"
1DSUDZG FKFHV]ZLHG]LH"
1DSUDZG
'ODWHJR H MD]Z\F]DMQLHQLHZLHU] Z WZRMHPHWDIL]\F]QHNRPXQD\RFHODFK
SODQDFKLRGJyUQ\FK]DP\VDFKVWZyUFyZ1LHZLHU] UyZQLH Z ZDV] V\QQ
ZLHV]F]E ,WOLQ\LLQQHSURURFWZD0DPMHZ\REUD VRELH]DWDNLVDPNLWL
KXPEXJMDNWZRMHQDVNDOQHPDORZLGR)LROHWRZ\EL]RQ$YDOODF
K1LFZL FHM
1LHZLHPF]\QLHSRWUDILV]F]\WH QLHFKFHV]PLSRPyF1LHPDPMHGQDNGR
FLHELH DOX
3RZLDGDV]QLHSRWUDIL F]\WH QLHFKF FLSRPyF$ZMDNLVSRVyEPyJE\P"
*HUDOW]DVWDQDZLDVL SU]H]PRPHQWDEVROXWQLH ZLDGRP H RGZD FLZHJR
VIRUPXRZDQLDS\WDQLD]DOH \ ZLHOH
2G]\VNDP&LUL"
2GSRZLHG E\DQDW\FKPLDVWRZD
2G]\VNDV]3RWRW\ONRE\QDW\FKPLDVWM XWUDFL,WRQD]DZV]H
QLHRGZRDOQLH=DQLPGRWHJRGRMG]LHVWUDFLV]ZV]\VWNLFKNWyU]\FLWRZDU]\V]
-HGQHJR]WZ\FKWRZDU]\V]\VWUDFLV]ZFL JXQDMEOL V]\FKW\JRGQLPR H QDZHW
GQL0R H QDZHWJRG]LQ
']L NXM
-HV]F]HQLHVNR F]\HP%H]SR UHGQLPLU\FK\PVNXWNLHPWZRMHMLQJHUHQFMLZ
PLHO FH DUQD&HOXL3ODQXE G]LH PLHUNLONXG]LHVL FLXW\VL F\OXG]L&R]UHV]W
QLHPDZLHONLHJR]QDF]HQLDDOERZLHPQLHGXJRSy QLHM \FLHVWUDFLNLONDG]LHVL W
PLOLRQyZOXG]L ZLDWMDNLPJR]QDV]SRSURVWX]QLNQLHSU]HVWDQLHLVWQLHE\SR
XS\ZLHVWRVRZQHJRF]DVXRGURG]LVL Z ]XSHQLHRGPLHQLRQHMSRVWDFL$OHQDWR
DNXUDWQLNWQLHPDLQLHE G]LHPLD DGQHJRZS\ZXQLNWQLHMHVWZVWDQLHWHPX
]DSRELHFDQLRGZUyFLNROHLU]HF]\$QLW\DQLMDDQLF]DURG]LHMHDQL:LHG] F\
$QLQDZHW&LUL&RW\QDWR"
)LROHWRZ\EL]RQ7\PQLHPQLHMG]L NXM FL$YDOODF
K
6ZRM GURJ Z]UXV]\UDPLRQDPLHOIWURFK FLHNDZLPQLHFRPR H ]G]LDD
NDP\F]HNZSDGDM F\ZWU\E\ DUHQ&]\MHV]F]HFR PRJ GODFLHELH]UREL"
5DF]HMQLH%RSRND]DPL&LULMDNV G] QLHPR HV]"
.WRWDNSRZLHG]LD"
*HUDOWZVWU]\PDRGGHFK
$\DOODF
KVNLHURZDV]\ENLHNURNLZVWURQ FLDQ\MDVNLQLGDM F ]QDNE\
:LHG PLQV]HG]DQLP
FLDQ\7LUQD%HD$UDLQQHZVND]DQDVNU] FHVL JyUVNLHNU\V]WD\PDM
V]F]HJyOQHZD FLZR FL$MDEH]S\FK\PDPV]F]HJyOQHXPLHM WQR FL3Ry QD
W\PU FH:SDWU]VL 0\ O LQWHQV\ZQLH2W\PMDNRQDEDUG]RFL WHUD]
SRWU]HEXMH,]DGHNODUXM H VL WDNZ\UD PHQWDOQ FK SRPRF\0\ O RW\P H
FKFHV]ELHFQDUDWXQHNE\XERNXFR Z W\PJX FLH2EUD]SRZLQLHQSRMDZLVL
VDP,E\Z\UD Q\3DWU]DOHSRZVWU]\PXMVL RGJZDWRZQ\FKUHDNFML1LFQLH
PyZ7RE G]LHZL]MDQLHNRPXQLNDFMD
8VXFKD
3LHUZV]HZL]MHZEUHZRELHWQLF\QLHE\\Z\UD QH%\\QLHMDVQHDOH]DWRWDN
JZDWRZQH H FRIQ VL RGUXFKRZR2GU EDQDU NDQDEODFLHVWRX.UHZ
UR]EU\]JQL WDQDV]NOLVWHMWDIOL.R FLRWUXS\QDV]NLHOHWDFKNRQL<HQQHIHU
]DNXWDZNDMGDQ\
:LH D"&]DUQDZLH D"$]DQL ZWOH=RU]DSRODUQD"
,QDJOHEH]RVWU]H HQLDREUD]VWDVL NODURZQ\$ QDGWRNODURZQ\
-DVNLHUZU]DVQ *HUDOW0LOYD$QJRXOHPH
+ " ]DLQWHUHVRZDVL $YDOODF
K$FKWDN=GDMHPLVL H ZV]\VWNR
]HSVX
*HUDOWRGVNRF]\RG FLDQ\MDVNLQLRPDRQLHSU]HZUDFDM F VL R ED]DOWRZ\
SRVWXPHQW
1LHZD QHGRFKROHU\NU]\NQ 6XFKDM$YDOODF
KMDPXV] MDNQDMSU G]HM
GRVWDVL GRWHJRGUXLG]NLHJRODVX
&DHG0\UNYLG"
%RGDM H0RLPGUXKRPJUR]LWDP PLHUWHOQHQLHEH]SLHF]H VWZR:DOF] R
RGJU\]VRELHM ]\ND
5\FHU]DZELD\PSDV]F]XWU]HMEDQG\FL FL JQ OL]VLRGDWHUD]XVLRZDOLJR
XNDWUXSL-HGHQVWDQ ZV]\ZUR]NURNXJU]PRFLWRSRUHPGUXJLU EDPLHF]HP
WU]HFLPD\LUXG\SRGVNDNLZDRERNMDN]DM FV]XNDM F RND]MLLQLHRVRQL WHJR
PLHMVFDZNWyUHPyJE\ZUD]LURKDW\Q 2EDORQ\U\FHU]ZU]HV]F]D
QLH]UR]XPLDOH]ZQ WU]DKHPXLRGELMDUD]\WU]\PDQ REXU F]WDUF] =DND G\P
FLRVHPWRSRUDWDUF]DE\DFRUD]QL HMMX SUDZLHRSLHUDDVL R QDSLHU QLN%\R
RF]\ZLVWHMHV]F]HMHGHQGZDWDNLHXGHU]HQLDLU\FHU]RZLIODNLZ\MG ZV]\VWNLPL
V]F]HOLQDPLSDQFHU]D
*HUDOWZWU]HFKVXVDFK]QDOD]VL Z UyGN ERZLVNDFL ZNDUN
SRGVNDNXM FHJRUXG]LHOFD]URKDW\Q V]HURNRFKODVQ SU]H]EU]XFKWHJR]
WRSRUHP5\FHU]]ZLQQ\PLPR]EURLZ\U Q WU]HFLHJR]EyMF Z NRODQRUDQWHP
WDUF]\]ZDORQHJRWU]\NURWQLHJU]PRWQ ZWZDU]D NUHZVSU\VNDDSXNOHU]
=HUZDVL QDNRODQDPDFDZ UyGSDSURFLZSRV]XNLZDQLXPLHF]DEXF] F MDN
RJURPQ\EODV]DQ\WUXWH 1DJOH]REDF]\*HUDOWDL]QLHUXFKRPLD
:F]\LP H MHVWHPU NX"]DWU EL]J ELQKHPX
:QLF]\LP H&LNWyU]\WXOH WRUyZQLH PRLZURJRZLH
$KDU\FHU]XVLRZDXQLH ]DVRQ KHPXDOHEODFKDE\DSRJL WDL
PHFKDQL]PVL ]DEORNRZD1DKRQRU']L NLZDPVWRNURWQH]DSRPRF
:DP3U]HFLH WRZ\ FLHSU]\V]OL]SRPRF PQLH
'RSUDZG\".LHG\"
1LFQLHZLG]LDSRP\ OD*HUDOW1DZHWPQLHQLH]DXZD \SU]H]G]LXUNLZW\P
HOD]Q\PJDUQNX
-DNZDV]HPLDQR"VS\WDU\FHU]
*HUDOW=5LYLL
+HUEX"
1LHF]DVSDQLHU\FHU]XQDKHUDOG\N
1DKRQRUSUDZL FLHP Q\NDZDOHU]H*HUDOFLHU\FHU]RGQDOD]VZyMPLHF]
ZVWD-HJRSRV]F]HUELRQ WDUF] SRGREQLHMDNNURSLHU]NRQLD]GRELD]RWR
F]HUZRQDXNR QDV]DFKRZQLFDZSRODFKNWyUHMZLGQLD\QDSU]HPLHQQLHOLWHU\$L
+
7RQLHMHVWPyMURGRZ\KHUE]DKXF]DZ\MD QLDM FR7RV LQLFMD\PHM
VX]HUHQNLNVL QHMSDQL$QQ\+HQULHWW\-D]Z VL 5\FHU]HP6]DFKRZQLF\
-HVWHPU\FHU]HPE GQ\P,PLHQLDPHJRLNOHMQRWXQLHZROQRPLZ\MDZLD
8F]\QLHP OXEU\FHUVNL1DKRQRUMHV]F]HUD]G]L NLFL]DSRPRFNDZDOHU]H
&DDSU]\MHPQR SRPRMHMVWURQLH
-HGHQ]SRZDORQ\FKEDQG\WyZ]DM F]DL]DV]HOH FLZOL FLDFK5\FHU]
6]DFKRZQLF\GRVNRF]\LSRW Q\PSFKQL FLHPSU]\JZR G]LJRGR]LHPL=EyM
]DWU]HSDU NDPLLQRJDPLMDNSU]HNXW\V]SLON SDM N
3RVSLHV]DMP\U]HNU\FHU]+XOWDMVWZRMHV]F]HVL WXVUR \1DKRQRU
MHV]F]HQLHF]DVRGSRF]\ZD
3UDZGDSU]\]QD*HUDOW%DQGDJUDVXMHSROHVLH]DELMDSLHOJU]\PyZL
GUXLGyZ0RLSU]\MDFLHOHV Z RSDDFK
3U]HSUDV]DPQDFKZLO
'UXJL]EyMGDZD]QDNL \FLD7H ]RVWD]DPDV]\ FLHSU]\JZR G RQ\D
]DGDUW\PLQRJDPLZ\ZLQ WDNLHJRKRXEFD H D PXEXW\SRVSDGD\
1DKRQRU5\FHU]6]DFKRZQLF\Z\WDUPLHF]RPHFK&L NRW\P
DSVHUGDNRPUR]VWDVL ] \FLHP1LHFKFL QLHG]LZLNDZDOHU]H H UDQLRQ\FK
GR JLZDP1DKRQRUGDZQLHMWHJRQLHF]\QLHP$OHFLXUZLSRWFLHZUDFDM GR
]GURZLDWDNV]\ENR H XF]FLZ\F]RZLHNPR H W\ONRSR]D]GUR FL2GN G ]
MHGQ\PV]HOP ]GDU]\RPLVL PLHVSUDZ WU]\UD]\SRGU] G]DF] HP
Z\ND F]DLFKSLHF]RRZLFLHM7DN HE\MX QDDPHQ
5R]XPLHP
-DZLG]LFLHMHVWHPE GQ\$OHQDKRQRUQLHRE NDQ\2MHVWPyMNR
&KRG WX%XFHID
7\ONRXFKRFLXUZDRVWZLHUG]LDZUHV]FLH1LHPDVL F]\PSU]HMPRZD
DWZRFLPyZL-DEDUG]ROXELHPWRXFKR3RPy PLF]\P WRRZL ]DER
PLFLHF]H]DNRQLHU]*G]LHV -DVNLHUL$QJRXOHPH"
:FKDXSLH]SLHOJU]\PDPL2]DUD]D=DRPRWD\NRS\WD]PJ\Z\RQLOL
VL WU]HMMH G F\QDERMRZ\FKUXPDNDFKSRZLHZDM F\ZJDORSLHSDV]F]DPLL
SURSRUFDPL1LPMHV]F]HSU]HEU]PLDLFKERMRZ\NU]\N*HUDOWXFDSL0LOY ]D
UDPL L ZFL JQ M SRGZy]1LHE\R DUWyZ]NLP NWRV]DU RZDX]EURMRQ\Z
NRSL R GXJR FLF]WHUQDVWXVWySGDM F HIHNW\ZQ\]DVL J G]LHVL FLXVWySSU]HG
JRZ NRQLD
:\D]L5XPDNLU\FHU]\U\\SRGNRZDPL]LHPL ZRNyZR]X5]XFLEUR
L Z\D]L
% G]LHP\ZLVLHPUXNQ D0LOYD0RJDPLHUDFM
+DRSU\V]NL]DU\F]DEU] NOLZLHMHGHQ]U\FHU]\QRV] F\QDWDUF]\F]DUQ
E\F] JRZ QDVUHEUQ\PSROX
+DDMGDF\1DKRQRUE G]LHFLHZLVLH
1DKRQRU]DSLDPRG]LH F]\PJRVHPGUXJL]WDUF] MHGQROLFLHE NLWQ
1DPLHMVFXLFKUR]VLHNDMP\
+RODKROD6WD
=PJ\Z\RQLVL QD%XFHIDOH5\FHU]6]DFKRZQLF\8GDRPXVL ZUHV]FLH
SRGQLH Z\NU]\ZLRQ ]DVRQ KHPXVSRGNWyUHMZ\JO GD\WHUD]EXMQHSRZH
Z V\
8ZROQLMFLHLFKFR \ZR]DZRD7RQLHV JUDVDQFLOHF]SUDZLLXF]FLZL
OXG]LH1LHZLDVWDP QLHVWDZDDZREURQLHSLHOJU]\PyZ$WHQNDZDOHUWRGREU\
U\FHU]
'REU\U\FHU]"%\F]D*RZDSRGQLyV]DVRQ KHPXSU]\MU]DVL *HUDOWRZL
QDGHUQLHGRZLHU]DM FR1DKRQRU1LHPR H WRE\
1DKRQRU5\FHU]6]DFKRZQLF\ZDOQ VL Z QDSLHU QLNSDQFHUQ SL FL
0R H WRE\SDUROGDM 0 Q\WHQNDZDOHU \FLHPL]UDWRZDZRSUHVMLJG\P
SU]H]KXOWDMyZQD]LHPL E\]ZDORQ=ZLHVL *HUDOW]5LYLL
+HUEX"
1LHZROQRPLZ\MDZLDEXUNQ :LHG PLQQLSUDZG]LZHJRLPLHQLDQL
NOHMQRWX8F]\QLHP OXEU\FHUVNL-HVWHPE GQ\*HUDOW
2RRZU]DVQ QDJOH]QDMRP\EH]F]HOQ\JRV3RSDWU]FLHFRWH NRW
SU]\QLyV+DPyZLDPFLFLRWND H :LHG PLQSU]\E G]LHQDPZVXNXUV
,ZVDP SRU NU]\NQ QDGFKRG] F\]$QJRXOHPHLJUXSN SU]HVWUDV]RQ\FK
SLHOJU]\PyZ-DVNLHUQLRV F\OXWQL L VZyMQLHRG F]Q\WXEXV1LRVHNXQG ]D
ZF]H QLH0DV]GREUHZ\F]XFLHGUDPDW\]PX*HUDOW3RZLQLHQH SLVDV]WXNLGOD
WHDWUyZ
=DPLONQDJOH%\F]D*RZDSRFK\OLVL Z VLRGOHRF]\PX]DE\V\
:LFHKUDELD-XOLDQ"
%DURQGH3H\UDF3H\UDQ"
=]DG EyZZ\RQLRVL QDVW SQ\FKGZyFKU\FHU]\-HGHQZJDPF]NRZ\P
KHPLHR]GRELRQ\PZLHOFHXGDWQ SRGREL]Q ELDHJRDE G]LD]UR]R RQ\PL
VNU]\GDPLSURZDG]LQDDUNDQLHGZyFKMH FyZ'UXJLU\FHU]E GQ\DOH
SUDNW\F]Q\SU]\JRWRZ\ZDVWU\F]NLLZ\SDWU\ZDGREUHMJD ]L
XMPDLG\VKRQRUQLHVSRWND\WDPQDV]HJRGUXKD-DVNUD7R]QDF]\WIX-XOLDQD
1DKRQRU]D PLDVL QDJHEDURQ DGQDXMPDQLG\VKRQRUQLHVSRWNDM
ZLFHKUDELHJR-XOLDQDSDUROQDWRGDJRWRZ\P%RPSU]HSRPQLDZDP
SRZLHG]LHZLFHKUDELR H NVL FLX5DMPXQGRZL]PDURVL GZDODWDWHPXQD
DSRSOHNVM
+DKD]DZRD-DVNLHUSURPLHQLHM F JZDWRZQLH.VL
NLSQ $WR
GRSLHURZVSDQLDDLUDGRVQDQRZLQD7R]QDF]\FKFLDHPU]HFVPXWHNL DO
V]NRGDLVWUDWD1LHFKPX]LHPLDOHNN E G]LH-H OLMHGQDNWDNMHVWWRMHG P\GR
%HDXFODLUFR \ZLHMSDQRZLHU\FHU]H*HUDOW0LOYD$QJRXOHPHGR]REDF]HQLDQD
]DPNX
\ZFHP$OH]F]ZDUW\PVFKZ\WDQ\PPXQLHZ\V]RFK\EDSU]H]QLHXZDJ ]E\W
PRFQR FLVQ FRGDRVL PLDUNRZDSRZ\EDXV]RQ\FKRF]DFKRILDU\LM ]\NX
Z\ZDORQ\PGDOHNRD QD]DSDSUDQ\NUZL L Z\PLRFLQ SRGEUyGHN
:QDVW SQHMVHNXQG]LHZLVLHOLMX Z SRZLHWU]XRSOHFHQLJD ]LDPLZV]\VF\
WURMHGU F VL ZQLHERJRV\
3D SD SD XV\V]HOL]GRXRGVWURQ\NRU]HQL3D SD 'U]HZNR
=DG ERSRWZRUHPOHNNRSRJDQLDM F JROL FLDVW ZLWN NURF]\DPRGDGUXLGND
Z ELDHMV]DFLHLNZLHWQ\PZLDQXV]NXQDJRZLH
1LHNU]\ZG 'U]HZNRQLH FLVNDM'HOLNDWQLH3D SD SD
1LHMHVWH P\]EyMFDPL]DVW ND]JyU\*HUDOW]OHGZR FL GRE\ZDM F JRVX
] PLD G RQHMRSORWHPNRQDUDSLHUVL.D PXE\QDVSX FL-HVWH P\QLHZLQQL
:V]\VF\WDNPyZL GUXLGNDRGS G]LDPRW\ONDNU FHJRQDGMHMEUZL
3D SD SD
3RVLNDDPVL ]DM F]DD$QJRXOHPH3VLDNUHZSRVLNDDPVL
0LOYDW\ONR]DFKDUF]DD*RZDRSDGDMHMQDSLHU *HUDOW]DNO SOXJDZLH%\R
WRMHG\QHFRPyJ]UREL
3RJDQLDQ\SU]H]GUXLGN G ERSRWZyUUD QRSRELHJODVHP3RGF]DVWHJRELHJX
ZV]\VF\FLNWyU]\E\OLSU]\WRPQLG]ZRQLOL] EDPLZU\WPSRGVNRNyZVWZRUD
$ V]RHFKR
3RQLHGXJLPF]DVLH]QDOH OLVL QDREV]HUQHMSRODQLH*HUDOW]REDF]\JUXS
ELDRRG]LDQ\FKGUXLGyZDRERNQLFKGUXJLHJRG ERSRWZRUD7HQGUXJLPLD
VDEV]\SRyZ]MHJRNRQDUyZ]ZLVDRW\ONRWU]HFKEDQG\WyZ]WHJR \FK\ED
W\ONRMHGHQ
3U]HVW SF\]EURGQLDU]HOXG]LHQLHJRG]LZLSU]HPyZL]GRXMHGHQ]
GUXLGyZVWDU]HFZVSDUW\QDGXJLPSRVRFKX3U]\MU]\MFLHVL GREU]H3RSDWU]FLH
MDNDNDUDVSRW\NDZ/HVLH0\UNYLG]EURGQLDU]\LQLHJRG]LZFyZ3U]\SDWU]FLHVL L
]DSDPL WDMFLH:\SX FLP\ZDVE\ FLHPRJOLRW\PFR]DFKZLO XMU]\FLH
RSRZLHG]LHLQQ\P1DSU]HVWURJ
1DVDP\P URGNXSRODQ\SL WU]\VL ZLHONLVWRVELHUZLRQLFKUXVWXDQDVWRVLH
ZVSDUWDGU JDPLVWDDXSOHFLRQD]ZLNOLQ\NODWNDPDM FDNV]WDWZLHONLHM
SDXERZDWHMNXN\.ODWNDSHQDE\DZU]HV]F] F\FKLV]DPRF] F\FKVL OXG]L
:LHG PLQZ\UD QLHV\V]D DELHRFKU\SHRG]JUR]\VNU]HNLUR]EyMQLND6RZLND
:LG]LDELD MDNSyWQRLZ\NU]\ZLRQ SDQLF]Q\PVWUDFKHPWZDU]SyHOID6FKLUUX
SU]\SUDVRZDQ GRZLNOLQRZ\FKVSORWyZ
'UXLG]LZU]DVQ *HUDOWPRELOL]XM F GRWHJRZU]DVNXZV]\VWNLHVL\E\E\
V\V]DQ\PZ UyGRJyOQHJRUHMZDFKX3DQLIODPLQLNR-HVWHP:LHG PLQ*HUDOW
6XFKDP"RGH]ZDDVL ] GRXZ\VRNDLFKXGDNRELHWD]ZRVDPLNRORUX
V]DUHMVWDOLRSDGDM F\PLQDSOHF\ FL QL W\PLQDF]ROHZLDQNLHP]MHPLR\
-HVWHP*HUDOW:LHG PLQ3U]\MDFLHO(PLHOD5HJLVD
3RZWyU]ERQLHGRV\V]DDP
*HUDDDDDOW3U]\MDFLHOZDPSLLLLLUD
$FK7U]HEDE\RWDNRGUD]X
1DGDQ\SU]H]VWDORZRZWRV GUXLGN ]QDNG ERSRWZyUSRVWDZLLFKQD]LHPL
1LH]E\WGHOLNDWQLH8SDGOL DGQHQLHPRJRZVWDRZDVQ\FKVLDFK0LOYDE\D
QLHSU]\WRPQDNUHZFLHNDMHM]QRVD*HUDOWSRGQLyVVL ] WUXGHPXNO NQDGQL
5R]G]LD
.UyOEH]JUDQLF]QLHNRFKDVZ PD RQN NUyORZ DRQDFD\PVHUFHPNRFKDD
MHJR&R WDNLHJRPXVLDRVNR F]\VL QLHV]F] FLHP
)ORXUHQV'HODQQR\%DMNLLNOHFKG\
'HODQQR\)ORXUHQVM ]\NR]QDZFDLKLVWRU\NZ9LFRXDURZODWDFK
VHNUHWDU]LELEOLRWHNDU]QDGZRU]HFHVDUVNLP1LHVWUXG]RQ\EDGDF]OHJHQGL
ED QLOXGRZ\FKDXWRUZLHOXUR]SUDZXZD DQ\FK]DSRPQLNLGDZQHJRM ]\NDL
OLWHUDWXU\SyQRFQ\FKUHJLRQyZ,PSHULXP=G]LHMHJRQDMZD QLHMV]HV 0LW\L
OHJHQG\OXGyZ3yIQRF\%DMNLLNOHFKG\1LHVSRG]LDQNDDOERPLW6WDUV]HM
.UZL6DJDRZLHG PLQLHRUD]:LHG PLQLZLHG PLQNDF]\OLQLHXVWDM FH
SRV]XNLZDQLH2GURNXSURIHVRUDNDGHPLLZ&DVWHOO*UDXSLDQJG]LH]PDU
(IIHQEHUJL7DOERW
(QF\FORSDHGLD0D[LPD0XQGLWRP,9
7UHWRJRUMHGQDNGHPRQVWUDF\MQLHR]QDMPL H 3yQRFJRQLHLQWHUHVXMH-DN
X]QDOLNUyOHZVF\MXU\ FLRERZL ]XMH]DVDGDZ]DMHPQR FLDSDQD NRYLUVNLQLH
SRQRVL DGQ\FKSRZLQQR FLZREHFNRURQ\WHG\NRURQDQLHXG]LHODSRPRF\
.RYLURZL7\PEDUG]LHM H .RYLUR DGQ SRPRFQLJG\QLHSURVL
7\PF]DVHP]WRF]RQ\FKQDSyQRF\ZRMHQ.RYLUL3RYLVVSRGQLRV\VL
VLOQLHMV]HLSRW QLHMV]H0DRNWRZyZF]DVRW\PZLHG]LD:\UD QLHMV]\P
V\JQDHPURVQ FHMSRW JL3yQRF\E\FRUD]DNW\ZQLHMV]\HNVSRUW2.RYLU]HSU]H]
G]LHVL WNLODWPDZLDQR H MHG\Q\PERJDFWZHPWHMNUDLQ\MHVWSLDFKLPRUVNDZRGD
'RZFLSSU]\SRPQLDQRVRELHJG\SURGXNFMDNRYLUVNLFKKXWLVDOLQSUDNW\F]QLH
]PRQRSROL]RZDD ZLDWRZ\U\QHNV]NDLVROL
$OHFKRVHWNLOXG]LSLMD\]HV]NODQLF]H]QDNLHPNRYLUVNLFKKXWLVROL\]XS
SRYLVVN VRO ZFL E\WRZ ZLDGRPR FLOXG]NLHMNUDMQLHE\ZDOHRGOHJ\
QLHGRVW SQ\VXURZ\LQLHSU]\MD]Q\,SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPLQQ\
:5HGDQLLL.DHGZHQ]DPLDVWGRZV]\VWNLFKGLDEyZPyZLRVL SU]HJRQL
NRJR GR3RYLVV-DNVL ZDPXPQLHQLHSRGREDPDZLDPLVWU]GRNUQ EUQ\FK
F]HODGQLNyZWRZROQDGURJDGR.RYLUX1LHE G]LHWXNRYLUVNLFKSRU] GNyZ
NU]\F]DSURIHVRUQDQLHVIRUQLHUR]G\VNXWRZDQ\FK DNyZ'R3RYLVVLG VL
P GU]\ZRDUROQLNGRV\QDNU\W\NXM FHJRSUDG]LDGRZHUDGRL DURZ\V\VWHP
XSUDZ\
.RPXVL QLHSRGREDM RGZLHF]QHSRU] GNLZROQDGURJDGR.RYLUX
$GUHVDFLW\FKZ\SRZLHG]LSRPDXSRPDOH NXM OLVL ]DVWDQDZLDLZNUyWFH
]DXZD \OL H IDNW\F]QLHGURJLGR.RYLUXL3RYLVVQLFDOHWRDEVROXWQLHQLFQLH
WDUDVXMH1DSyQRFUXV]\DGUXJDIDODHPLJUDFML7DNMDNLSRSU]HGQLDIDODWD
JyZQLHVNDGDDVL ] QLH]DGRZRORQ\FKFXGDNyZNWyU]\Uy QLOLVL L FKFLHOL
LQDF]HM$OHW\PUD]HPQLHE\OLWRVNyFHQL] \FLHPLQLJG]LHQLHSDVXM F\
DZDQWXUQLF\3U]\QDMPQLHMQLHMHG\QLH
1DSyQRFSRFL JQ OLXF]HQLNWyU]\ZLHU]\OLZVZHWHRULHFKRWHRULHWH
RNU]\F]DQR]DQLHUHDOQHLZDULDFNLH7HFKQLF\LNRQVWUXNWRU]\SU]HNRQDQL H
ZEUHZSRZV]HFKQHMRSLQLLGDVL MHGQDN]EXGRZDZ\NRQF\SRZDQHSU]H]
XF]RQ\FKPDV]\Q\LXU] G]HQLD&]DURG]LHMHGODNWyU\FKVWRVRZDQLHPDJLLGR
VWDZLDQLDIDORFKURQyZQLHE\R ZL WRNUDGF]\PGHVSHNWHP.XSF\GODNWyU\FK
SHUVSHNW\ZDUR]ZRMXREURWX]GREL E\DUR]VDG]LV]W\ZQHVWDW\F]QHL
NUyWNRZ]URF]QHJUDQLFHU\]\ND5ROQLF\LKRGRZF\SU]HNRQDQL H QDZHW]
QDMJRUV]\FKJUXQWyZPR QD]URELGDM FHXURG]DMSROD H ]DZV]HGDVL
Z\KRGRZDRGPLDQ\]ZLHU] WNWyU\PGDQ\NOLPDWVX \
1DSyQRFSRFL JQ OLWDN H JyUQLF\LJHRORJRZLHGODNWyU\FKVXURZR G]LNLFK
JyULVND.RYLUXVWDQRZLDQLHRP\OQ\V\JQD H MH OLQDZLHU]FKXWDNDELHGDWR
SRGVSRGHPPXVLE\ERJDFWZR1DWXUDNRFKDERZLHPUyZQRZDJ
3RGVSRGHPE\RERJDFWZR
0LQ RZLHUZLHNXL.RYLUZ\GRE\ZDW\OHNRSDOLQLOH5HGDQLD$HGLUQL
.DHGZHQUD]HPZ]L WH:\GRE\FLHPLSU]HUyEN UXG HOD]D.RYLUXVW SRZDW\ONR
0DKDNDPRZLDOHGR0DKDNDPXV]\].RYLUXWUDQVSRUW\PHWDOLVX F\FKGR
Z\NRQ\ZDQLDVWRSyZ1D.RYLUL3RYLVVSU]\SDGDDZLDUWND ZLDWRZHJR
Z\GRE\FLDNUXV]FyZVUHEUDQLNOXRRZLXF\Q\LF\QNXSRRZDZ\GRE\FLD
NUXV]FyZPLHG]LLPLHG]LURG]LPHMWU]\F]ZDUWHZ\GRE\FLDNUXV]FyZPDQJDQX
SRXGQLHPXVLDFKFLDF]\QLHFKFLDFD\VZyMWRZDUZ\VWDZLQDVSU]HGD Z
NWyU\P ] UHGD VNLFKPLDVWLVSU]HGDJROXE]DZUyFL7HQVDPSU]\PXV
VSRW\NDNXSFD]GDOHNLHJR3RXGQLD]PLHU]DM FHJRGR.RYLUX
2GWRZDUyZNWyUH.RYLUWUDQVSRUWRZDPRU]HPQLH]DZLMDM F GRUHGD VNLFKF]\
WHPHUVNLFKSRUWyZ5HGDQLD]D GDD]EyMHFNLFKFH6WDWNLNRYLUVNLHU]HF]MDVQD
SDFLQLHFKFLD\SDFL\W\ONRWHNWyU\PQLHXGDRVL XFLHF:UR]SRF] WHMQD
PRU]X]DEDZLHZNRWNDLP\V]N U\FKRGRV]RGRLQF\GHQWX3DWURORZLHFUHGD VNL
SUyERZDDUHV]WRZDNRYLUVNLHJRNXSFD]MDZL\VL GZLHNRYLUVNLHIUHJDW\
SDWURORZLHFVSRQ %\\RILDU\
0LDUNDVL SU]HEUDD5DGRZLG5\ \ SRVWDQRZLQDXF]\PRUHVXQLHSRVXV]QHJR
ZDVDOD&]WHURW\VL F]QDDUPLD5HGDQLLVIRUVRZDDU]HN %UDDDHNVSHG\F\MQ\
NRUSXV].DHGZHQZNURF]\GR&DLQJRP
3RW\JRGQLXGZDW\VL FHRFDOD\FK5HGD F]\NyZIRUVRZDR%UDDZGUXJ
VWURQ DQ G]QHQLHGRELWNLNDHGZH VNLHJRNRUSXVXZORN\VL GRGRPX
SU]H F]DPL*yU3XVWXOVNLFK:\MDZLVL NROHMQ\FHONWyUHPXSRVX \R]RWR
SRPRFQ\FKJyU6WD DUPL .RYLUXVWDQRZLRGZDG]LH FLDSL W\VL F\
]DSUDZLRQ\FKZERMDFKLUR]ERMDFK]DZRGRZFyZ FL JQL W\FK]QDMGDOV]\FK
]DN WNyZ ZLDWDNRQGRWLHUyZEH]JUDQLF]QLHZLHUQ\FKNRYLUVNLHMNRURQLH]D
QLHE\ZDOHV]F]RGU\ RGL]DJZDUDQWRZDQ NRQWUDNWHPHPHU\WXU *RWRZ\FKQD
ND G\KD]DUGGODQLHE\ZDOHV]F]RGUHMSUHPLLZ\SDFDQHM]DND G Z\JUDQ ELWZ
7\FKERJDW\FK RQLHU]\ZLHGOL]D GRERMXGR ZLDGF]HQL]GROQLLREHFQLH
EDUG]RERJDFLGRZyGF\NWyU\FK5\ \ LNUyO%HQGD].DHGZHQ]QDOL ZLHWQLH
E\OLWRFLVDPLNWyU]\ZFDOHQLHWDNGDZQRVX \OLZLFKZDVQ\FKDUPLDFKDOH
QLHVSRG]LHZDQLHSU]HV]OLZVWDQVSRF]\QNXLZ\MHFKDOL]DJUDQLF
5\ \ QLHE\JXSFHPLXPLDXF]\VL QDE GDFK8 PLHU]\OEX F]XF]Q\FK
JHQHUDyZGRPDJDM F\FKVL NUXFMDW\QLHGDXFKDNXSFRP GDM F\PJRGRZHM
EORNDG\XJDVND%HQG ] .DHGZHQ GQHJRNUZLL]HPVW\]D]DJDG VZHM
HOLWDUQHMMHGQRVWNL5\ \ ]DLQLFMRZDURNRZDQLD1LHSRZVWU]\PDRJRQDZHW
XSRNRU]HQLHJRU]NDSLJXNDNWyU SU]\V]RSU]HNQ .RYLUJRG]LVL QD
UR]PRZ\DOHXVLHELHZ/DQ([HWHU.R]DPXVLDDSU]\M GRZR]D
3\Q OLZyZF]DVGR/DQ([HWHUMDNSHWHQFLSRP\ OD'LMNVWUDRWXODM F VL
SDV]F]HP-DNXQL HQLVXSOLNDQFL=XSHQLHMDNMDG]LVLDM
5HGD VNDHVNDGUDZS\Q DGR=DWRNL3UDNVHG\LVNLHURZDDVL NXNRYLUVNLHPX
Z\EU]H X=SRNDGXIODJRZHJRRNU WX$ODWD5DGRZLG5\ \%HQGD].DHGZHQL
WRZDU]\V] F\LPZUROLPHGLDWRUDKLHUDUFKD1RYLJUDGX]H]GXPLHQLHPSU]\JO GDOL
VL Z\ELHJDM F\PZPRU]HIDORFKURQRPQDGNWyU\PLZ]QRVL\VL PXU\LNU SH
EDVWHMHIRUWHF\VWU]HJ FHMGRVW SXGRPLDVWD3RQW9DQLV$S\Q F RG3RQW9DQLVQD
SRPRFZVWURQ XM FLDU]HNL7DQJRNUyORZLHZLG]LHOLSRUW\SU]\SRUWDFKVWRF]QLH
RERNVWRF]QLSU]\VWDQLHRERNSU]\VWDQL:LG]LHOLODVPDV]WyZLNXM F RF]\ELHO
DJOL.RYLUMDNVL RND]\ZDRPLDMX JRWRZHUHPHGLXPQDEORNDG\UHWRUVMHL
ZRMQ\FHOQH.RYLUE\HZLGHQWQLHJRWyZGRSDQRZDQLDQDGPRU]DPL
$ODWDZS\Q DZV]HURNLHXM FLH7DQJRLU]XFLDNRWZLF Z NDPLHQQ\FK
V]F] NDFKDZDQSRUWyZ$OHNUyOyZNXLFK]G]LZLHQLXF]HNDDMHV]F]HMHGQD
SRGUy ZRG 0LDVWR/DQ([HWHUQLHPLDRXOLFOHF]NDQD\:W\PE G F\JyZQ
DUWHUL L RVL PHWURSROLL:LHONL.DQDZLRG F\RGSRUWXZSURVWGRPRQDUV]HM
UH]\GHQFML.UyORZLHSU]HVLHGOLVL QDJDOHU\XGHNRURZDQHV]NDUDWQR]WRW\PL
JLUODQGDPLLKHUEHPQDNWyU\P5\ \ L%HQGD]H]GXPLHQLHPUR]SR]QDZDOL
UHGD VNLHJRRUDLNDHGZH VNLHJRMHGQRUR FD
3\Q F :LHONLP.DQDHPNUyORZLHLLFK ZLWDUR]JO GDOLVL L ]DFKRZ\ZDOL
PLOF]HQLH:D FLZLHQDOH DRE\SRZLHG]LH H LFK]DWNDR0\OLOLVL V G] F H
ZLHG] FRWRMHVWERJDFWZRLSU]HS\FK H QLHPR QDLFK]DVNRF]\SU]HMDZDPL
GRVWDWNXL DGQ GHPRQVWUDFM OXNVXVX
3\Q OL:LHONLP.DQDHPPLMDM F LPSRQXM F\JPDFK$GPLUDOLFMLLVLHG]LE
*LOGLL.XSLHFNLHM3\Q OLZ]GX SURPHQDGZ\SHQLRQ\FKNRORURZ\PLGRVWDWQLR
RG]LDQ\PWXPHP3\Q OLZV]SDOHU]HZVSDQLD\FKPDJQDFNLFKSDDF\NyZL
NXSLHFNLFKNDPLHQLF]HNRGELMDM F\FKVL Z ZRG]LH.DQDXW F] SU]HS\V]QLH
]GRELRQ\FKDF]QLHE\ZDOHZ VNLFK FLDQIURQWRZ\FK:/DQ([HWHUSDFLRVL
ERZLHPSRGDWHNRGIURQWXGRPXLPIURQWV]HUV]\W\PSRGDWHNSURJUHV\ZQLH
Z\ V]\
1DGRW\NDM F\FK.DQDXVFKRGDFKSDDFX(QVHQDGDPRQDUV]HMUH]\GHQFML
]LPRZHMMHG\QHJREXG\QNXRV]HURNLPIURQFLHRF]HNLZDMX NRPLWHWSRZLWDOQ\L
NUyOHZVNDSDUD*HGRYLXVZDGFD.RYLUXLMHJRPD RQND*HPPD
3DUDSU]\ZLWDDSU]\E\\FKGZRUQLHJU]HF]QLHLQLHW\SRZR'URJLVWU\MDV]NX
]ZUyFLVL *HGRYLXVGR5DGRZLGD.RFKDQ\G]LDGNXX PLHFKQ DVL GR%HQG\
*HPPD*HGRYLXVE\ZV]DN H 7URMGHQLG *HPPD]D MDNVL RND]DRZLRGD
VZyMUyGRG]ELHJHM].DHGZHQEXQWRZQLF]HM$LGHHQZ \DFKNWyUHMS\Q D
NUHZNUyOyZ]$UG&DUUDLJK
8GRZRGQLRQHSRNUHZLH VWZRSRSUDZLRQDVWURMHLZ]EXG]LRV\PSDWL DOHZ
URNRZDQLDFKQLHSRPRJR:]DVDG]LHWRFRQDVW SLRWRQLHE\\ DGQH
URNRZDQLD']LHFLSRZLHG]LD\NUyWNRF]HJR GDM ']LDGNRZLHZ\VXFKDOL,
SRGSLVDOLGRNXPHQWSU]H]SRWRPQ\FKQD]ZDQ\3LHUZV]\P7UDNWDWHP([HWHUVNLP
'ODRGUy QLHQLDRG]DZDUW\FKSy QLHM3LHUZV]\7UDNWDWQRVLWH QD]Z ]JRGQ ]
SLHUZV]\PLVRZDPLMHJRSUHDPEX\0DUH/LEHUXP$SHUWXP
0RU]HMHVWZROQHLRWZDUWH+DQGHOMHVWZROQ\=\VNMHVW ZL W\.RFKDMKDQGHOL
]\VNEOL QLHJRMDNVZyMZDVQ\8WUXGQLDQLHNRPX KDQGORZDQLDLRVL JDQLD]\VNX
MHVWDPDQLHPSUDZQDWXU\$.RYLUQLHMHVWQLF]\LPZDVDOHP-HVWQLH]DZLV\P
VDPRU] GQ\PLQHXWUDOQ\PNUyOHVWZHP
1LHZ\JO GDRE\*HGRYLXVL*HPPD]HFKFLHOLGODVDPHMFKRE\JU]HF]QR FL
XF]\QLFKRMHGQRFKRE\QDMPQLHMV]HXVW SVWZRFR FRXUDWRZDRE\KRQRU
5DGRZLGDL%HQG\$OHMHGQDN]URELOLWR=JRG]LOLVL DE\5DGRZLG5\ \
GR \ZRWQLRX \ZDZRILFMDOQ\FKGRNXPHQWDFKW\WXXNUyOD.RYLUXL3RYLVVD
%HQGDGR \ZRWQLRW\WXXNUyOD&DLQJRPL0DOOHRUH
2F]\ZLVWD]]DVWU]H HQLHPGHQRQSUHLXGLFDQGR
*HGR\LXVL*HPPDSDQRZDOLSU]H]GZDG]LH FLDSL ODWQDLFKV\QX*HUDUG]LH
VNR F]\DVL NUyOHZVNDJD 7URMGHQLGyZ1DWURQNRYLUVNLZVW SL(VWHULL
7K\VVHQ=DR \FLHOGRPX7K\VVHQLGyZ
:QLHGXJLPF]DVLH]ZL ]DQLZL ]DPLNUZL]HZV]\VWNLPLSR]RVWD\PL
G\QDVWLDPL ZLDWDNUyORZLH.RYLUXQLH]RPQLHSU]HVWU]HJDOL7UDNWDWyZ
([HWHUVNLFK1LJG\QLHPLHV]DOLVL GRVSUDZV VLDGyZ1LJG\QLHSRGQRVLOLVSUDZ
REFHMVXNFHVMLFKRQLHUD]]DZLURZDQLDG]LHMRZHVSUDZLD\ H NUyOF]\NUyOHZLF]
1LFRGHPXVGH%RRWQLHZ\WU]\PD'LMNVWUD
%OLVNRDOHQLHFHOQLHNUyO.RYLUXZ\V]F]HU]\DODEDVWURZRELDH] E\7RE\
9\VRJRWD]&RUYR0QLHM]QDQ\DOHWH GREU\HW\NLILOR]RI3RF]\WDMSROHFDP
0R H ]RVWDDXZDVMHV]F]HMDND MHJRNVL NDPR H QLHZV]\VWNLHVSDOLOL FLH"1R
DOHGRU]HF]\GRU]HF]\7\'LMNVWUDWH EH]VNUXSXyZSRVXJXMHV]VL LQWU\J
SU]HNXSVWZHPV]DQWD HPLWRUWXUDPL2NLHPQLHPUXJQLHV]VND]XM F NRJR QD
PLHUOXEND F VNU\WREyMF]R]DPRUGRZD7R H ZV]\VWNRURELV]GODNUyOHVWZD
NWyUHPXZLHUQLHVX \V]QLHXVSUDZLHGOLZLDFL L QLHF]\QLZPRLFKRF]DFK
V\PSDW\F]QLHMV]\P%\QDMPQLHM:LHG]RW\P
6]SLHJNLZQ JRZ QD]QDN H ZLH
7\MHGQDNFL JQ (VWHUDGMHVWH MDNVL U]HNRVNXUZ\V\QHPSUDZHJR
FKDUDNWHUX,GODWHJRFL OXEL L V]DQXM GODWHJRXG]LHOLHPFLSU\ZDWQHMDXGLHQFML
%RW\'LMNVWUDPDM F PLOLRQ\RND]MLQLJG\Z \FLXQLH]URELH QLF]HJRGOD
SU\ZDW\LQLHXNUDGH QDZHWV]HO JD]SD VWZRZHMNDV\1DZHWSyV]HO JD
=XOH\NDVSyMU]=DUXPLHQLVL F]\PLVL ]GDMH"
.UyORZDXQLRVDJRZ ]QDGUREyWNL
3RPRGHVWLLLFKSR]QDFLHSUDZR LFK]DF\WRZDDXVW S ]'REUHM.VL JLFKR
PXVLDDZLG]LH H QDWZDU]\V]SLHJDQLH]DJR FLQDZHW ODGUXPLH FD
'REUDU]HN(VWHUDG'RU]HF]\&]DVSU]HM GRVSUDZSD VWZRZ\FK2Q
=XOH\NRSU]HS\Q PRU]HNLHURZDQ\SDWULRW\F]Q\PRERZL ]NLHP5HGDQLDMHJR
RMF]\]QDMHVW]DJUR RQD3RWUDJLF]QHM PLHUFLNUyOD9L]LPLUDSDQXMHWDPFKDRV
5HGDQLDU] G]LEDQGDDU\VWRNUDW\F]Q\FKLGLRWyZQD]\ZDM FDVL 5DG 5HJHQF\MQ
%DQGDWDPRMD=XOH\NRQLHXF]\QLGOD5HGDQLLQLF:REOLF]X]DJUR HQLDXFLHNQLH
DOER]DF]QLHSRSVLHPXDVLVL GRREV]\W\FKSHUDPLFL P QLOIJDDUG]NLHJR
FHVDU]D%DQGDWDSRJDUG]D'LMNVWU ERWRV]SLHJPRUGHUFDSDUZHQLXV]LFKDP
$OHWR'LMNVWUDSU]HS\Q PRU]HE\UDWRZD5HGDQL 'HPRQVWUXM FNRPX
QDSUDZG QD5HGDQLL]DOH \
(VWHUDG7K\VVHQ]DPLONVDSQ ]P F]RQ\SU]HPRZ SRSUDZLNDUPD]\QRZR
JURQRVWDMRZHFKDSHDXNWyUHOHNNRRVXQ RPXVL QDQRV
1R'LMNVWUDSRGM &RGROHJDWZRMHPXNUyOHVWZX"2SUyF]EUDNXSLHQL G]\
PDVL UR]XPLH"
2SUyF]EUDNXSLHQL G]\WZDU]V]SLHJDE\DMDN]NDPLHQLDWRG]L NXM
ZV]\VF\]GURZL
$KDNUyONLZQ JRZ FKDSHDX]QRZXRVXQ RPXVL QDQRVL]QRZXWU]HED
E\RMHSRSUDZLD$KD3RMPXM
3RMPXM FL JQ ,SU]\NODVNXM LGHL*G\PDVL SLHQL G]HPR QDVRELH
NXSLOHNDUVWZRQDND G LQQ GROHJOLZR 6 N ZW\PE\SLHQL G]HPLH:\QLH
PDFLH*G\E\ FLHPLHOLWRE\FL WXQLHE\R&]\UR]XPXM SUDZLGRZR"
%H]]DU]XWX
$LOH WRZDPWU]HEDFLHNDZR "
1LHZLHOH0LOLRQEL]DQWyZ
1LHZLHOH"(VWHUDG7K\VVHQSU]HVDGQ\PJHVWHPFKZ\FLVL REXU F]]D
FKDSHDX7RPDE\QLHZLHOH"$MDM
'ODZDV]HMNUyOHZVNLHMPR FLE NQ V]SLHJWDNDVXPDWRZV]DN H
GURELD]J
'URELD]J"NUyOSX FLFKDSHDXLZ]QLyVGRQLHNXSODIRQRZL$MDM0LOLRQ
EL]DQWyZWRGURELD]JV\V]\V]=XOH\NDFRRQPyZL"$F]\W\ZLHV]'LMNVWUD H
PLHPLOLRQLQLHPLHPLOLRQDWRUD]HPGZDPLOLRQ\"-DUR]XPLHPMDSRMPXM H
W\L)LOLSSD(LOKDUWJZDWRZQLHLJRU F]NRZRSRV]XNXMHFLHNRQFHSFMLQDREURQ
SU]HG1LOIJDDUGHPDOHFRZ\FKFHFLHFD\1LOIJDDUGNXSLF]\MDN"
'LMNVWU QLHRGSRZLHG]LD=XOH\NDV]\GHNRZDD]DZ]L FLH(VWHUDGSU]H]
FKZLO XGDZD H SRG]LZLDJRHQLPI\QDSODIRQLH
&KRG QRZVWDQDJOHVNLQ QDV]SLHJD3RGHV]OLGRROEU]\PLHJRPDORZLGD
SU]HGVWDZLDM FHJRNUyOD*HGRYLXVDVLHG] FHJRQDVLZ\PNRQLXLEHUHP
SRND]XM FHJRZRMVNXFR QLHPLHV]F] FHJRVL QDSyWQLH]DSHZQHZD FLZ\
NLHUXQHN(VWHUDGZ\JU]HED]NLHV]HQLPDOXWN SR]DFDQ Uy G N GRWNQ QL
UDP\REUD]XSyJRVHPZ\PyZL]DNO FLH*HGRYLXVLVLZ\NR ]QLNOLSRMDZLD
VL SODVW\F]QDPDSD]QDQHJR ZLDWD.UyOGRWNQ Uy G N VUHEUQHJRJX]LNDZURJX
PDS\LPDJLF]QLH]PLHQLVNDO ]DZ DM F ZLGRF]Q SRD ZLDWDGR'ROLQ\-DUXJL
L &]WHUHFK.UyOHVWZ
1LHELHVNLHWR1LOIJDDUGZ\MD QL&]HUZRQHWRZ\1DFRVL JDSLV]"7XWDM
SDWU]
'LMNVWU RGHUZDZ]URNRGLQQ\FKREUD]yZJyZQLHDNWyZLVFHQ
PDU\QLVW\F]Q\FK=DVWDQDZLDVL NWyU\]QLFKE\F]DURG]LHMVNLPNDPXIOD HPGOD
LQQHMRVDZLRQHMPDS\(VWHUDGDWHMNWyUDREUD]RZDDZRMHQQ\LKDQGORZ\
Z\ZLDG.RYLUXFD VLDWN SU]HNXSLRQ\FKLQIRUPDWRUyZLOXG]LV]DQWD RZDQ\FK
NRQILGHQWyZNRQWDNWyZRSHUDF\MQ\FKG\ZHUVDQWyZQDMHPQ\FKPRUGHUFyZ
DJHQWyZX SLRQ\FKLUH]\GHQWyZF]\QQ\FK:LHG]LD H WDNDPDSDLVWQLHMHRG
GDZQDEH]VNXWHF]QLHSUyERZD]QDOH GRQLHMGRM FLH
&]HUZRQHWRZ\SRZWyU]\(VWHUDG7K\VVHQ.LHSVNRWRZ\JO GDSUDZGD"
.LHSVNRSU]\]QDZP\ OL'LMNVWUD2VWDWQLREH]SU]HUZ\RJO GDPDS\
VWUDWHJLF]QHDOHWHUD]QDSODVW\F]QHMPDSLH(VWHUDGDSRR HQLH]GDZDRVL E\
MHV]F]HJRUV]H1LHELHVNLHNZDGUDFLNLXNDGD\VL Z NV]WDWVWUDV]OLZ\FKVPRF]\FK
V]F] N JRWRZ\FKZND GHMFKZLOLFDSQ L]JUXFKRWD] ELVNDPLELHGQHNZDGUDFLNL
F]HUZRQH
(VWHUDG7K\VVHQUR]HMU]DVL ]DF]\P FRPRJRE\VX \MDNRZVND QLNGR
PDS\Z\FL JQ ZUHV]FLH]QDMEOL V]HJRSDQRSOLDR]GREQ\UDSLHU
1LOIJDDUGUR]SRF] Z\NDGSRND]XM F UDSLHUHPFRWU]HED]DDWDNRZD/\UL
L $HGLUQMDNRFDVXVEHOOLRJDV]DM F DWDNQDSRJUDQLF]Q\IRUW*OHYLW]LQJHQ1LH
E G GRFLHNDNWRQDSUDZG QDSDGQD*OHYLW]LQJHQLZMDNLPSU]HEUDQLX=D
SR]EDZLRQHVHQVXXZD DPWH GRP\V\RLOHGQLF]\JRG]LQ]EURMQDDNFMD(PK\UD
Z\SU]HG]LDDQDORJLF]QHSU]HGVL Z]L FLH$HGLUQL7HPHULL=RVWDZLDPWR
KLVWRU\NRP%DUG]LHMLQWHUHVXMHPQLHV\WXDFMDG]LVLHMV]DLWRFRE G]LHMXWUR:WHM
FKZLOL1LOIJDDUGVWRLZ'RO$QJUDL$HGLUQRVRQL W\EXIRUHPZSRVWDFLHOILHJR
GRPLQLXPZ'RO%ODWKDQQDJUDQLF] F\P]W F] FL $HGLUQNWyU NUyO+HQVHOW]
.DHGZHQPyZL F REUD]RZRZ\UZD(PK\URZL]] EyZLVDP]H DU
'LMNVWUDQLHVNRPHQWRZD
2FHQ PRUDOQ DNFMLNUyOD+HQVHOWDUyZQLH ]RVWDZLDPKLVWRU\NRPSRGM
(VWHUDG$OHMHGQHJRVSRMU]HQLDQDPDS Z\VWDUF]\E\]REDF]\ H DQHNVM
3yQRFQHM0DUFKLL+HQVHOW]DJURG]L(PK\URZLGURJ GR'ROLQ\3RQWDUX
1LH1LHZVSRPLQD
2ELHPLOF]D\SU]H]FKZLO .RWQDNRODQDFK$VVLUHPUXF]DJR QR
3DQL$VVLUH
6XFKDP&DUWKLD
&]\GXJRMHV]F]HE G PXVLDDJUDURO QLHP GUHMNRFKDQNL"&KFLDDE\P
ZUyFLQDVWXGLDSR ZL FLVL SUDF\QDXNRZHM
1LHGXJRSU]HUZDD$VVLUH$OHMHV]F]HWURFK :\WU]\PDMG]LHFNR
&DQWDUHOODZHVWFKQ D
6NR F]\\UR]PRZ L SR HJQD\VL $VVLUHYDU$QDKLGVS G]LDNRWD]IRWHOD
MHV]F]HUD]SU]HF]\WDDOLVWRG)ULQJLOOL9LJREDZL FHMZ7KXVVDLQW=DP\ OLDVL
DOERZLHPOLVWQLHSRNRL1LyVPL G]\ZLHUV]DPLMDNLH WUH FLNWyUH$VVLUH
Z\F]XZDDDOHLFKQLHSRMPRZDD%\RMX SRSyQRF\JG\$VVLUHYDU$QDKLG
QLOIJDDUG]NDF]DURG]LHMNDXUXFKRPLDPHJDVNRSLQDZL ]DDWHOHNRPXQLNDFM ]
]DPNLHP0RQWHFDOYRZ5HGDQLL
)LOLSSD(LOKDUWE\DZNUyFLXWNLHMQRFQHMNRV]XOLQDFLHQLXWNLFKUDPL F]NDFKD
QDSROLF]NXLGHNROFLHPLDD ODG\XV]PLQNRZDQ\FKXVW$VVLUHQDMZ\ V]\P
Z\VLNLHPZROLSRZVWU]\PDDJU\PDVQLHVPDNX1LJG\SU]HQLJG\QLH]GRDPWHJR
]UR]XPLHSRP\ ODD,QLHFKF WHJRUR]XPLH
0R HP\PyZLVZRERGQLH"
)LOLSSDZ\NRQDDGRQL V]HURNLJHVWRWDF]DM F VL PDJLF]Q VIHU G\VNUHFML
7HUD]WDN
0DPLQIRUPDFMH]DF] DVXFKR$VVLUH6DPHZVRELHQLHV RQHVHQVDF\MQH
PyZL R W\PQDZHWEDE\SU]\VWXGQLDFK:V]HODNR
-DN ZLDWGXJLE\LV]HURNLZV]\VWNLHSDU\NUyOHZVNLHPLHZD\RGG]LHOQH
V\SLDOQLH.UyORZLH]EDUG]RUy Q F] VWRWOLZR FL RGZLHG]DOLV\SLDOQLH
NUyORZ\FK]GDU]DRVL H NUyORZHVNDGD\QLHVSRG]LHZDQHZL]\W\ZV\SLDOQLDFK
NUyOyZ3RWHP]D PD RQNRZLHUR]FKRG]LOLVL GRZDVQ\FKNRPQDWLy
0RQDUV]DSDUD.RYLUXLSRGW\PZ]JO GHPVWDQRZLDZ\M WHN(VWHUDG7K\VVHQL
=XOH\NDV\SLDOL]DZV]HUD]HPZMHGQHMV\SLDOQLQDMHGQ\PROEU]\PLPR X ]
ROEU]\PLPEDOGDFKLPHP
3U]HG]D QL FLHP=XOH\NDZR \ZV]\RNXODU\ZNWyU\FKZVW\G]LDVL
SRND]\ZDSRGGDQ\P]Z\NOHF]\W\ZDDVZ 'REU .VL J (VWHUDG7K\VVHQ
]Z\NOHJDGD
7HMQRF\WH QLHE\RLQDF]HM(VWHUDGZR \V]ODIP\F DGRU NLZ]L EHUR
/XELWU]\PDEHURLEDZLVL QLPDRILFMDOQLHWHJRQLHURELEREDVL H
SRGGDQLRNU]\NQ JRSUHWHQVMRQDOQ\P
:LHV]=XOH\NDJDGDSU]HG]LZQHPDPRVWDWQLRVQ\-X NWyU\ UD]]U] GX
QLPLVL WDZLHG PDPRMDPDWND6WDMHQDGHPQ L SRZWDU]D0DP RQ GOD
7DQNUHGDPDP RQ GOD7DQNUHGD,SRND]XMHPLV\PSDW\F]Q DOHEDUG]RPRG
G]LHZHF]N $ZLHV]=XOH\NDNLPMHVWWDG]LHZHF]ND"7R&LULZQXF]ND&DODQWKH
3DPL WDV]&DODQWKH=XOH\NR"
3DPL WDPPyMP X
&LULJDGDGDOHM(VWHUDGEDZL F VL EHUHPWRMHVWWD]NWyU MDNRE\FKFHVL
HQL(PK\UYDU(PUHLV']LZDF]Q\PDULD ]DVNDNXM F\-DNLPZL FXF]DUWD
VSRVREHPPLDDE\WRE\ RQDGOD7DQNUHGD"
7DQNUHGRZLJRV=XOH\NL]PLHQLVL QLHFRMDN]DZV]HJG\PyZLDRV\QX
SU]\GDDE\VL RQD0R H E\VL XVWDWNRZD
0R H (VWHUDGZHVWFKQ &KRZ WSL DOHPR H:ND G\PUD]LH
PD H VWZRMHVWMDN V]DQV +PPP7D&LUL+D.RYLUL&LQWUD8M FLH-DUXJL
1LH OHWREU]PLQLH OHDGQ\E\E\VRMXV]DGQDNROLJDF\MND1RDOHMH OLW
PD XSDWU]\VRELH(PK\U7\ONRGODF]HJRZD QLHRQDSRMDZLDPLVL Z VQDFK"
, GODF]HJRGRGLDEDMDZRJyOH QL MDNLH JXSVWZD":(NZLQRNFMXPSDPL WDV]
ZWHG\JG\FLHELHWH REXG]LHP%UUUFy WRE\]DNRV]PDUUDGMHVWHP H QLH
PRJ SU]\SRPQLHVRELHV]F]HJyyZ+PPP0R H ]DZH]ZDMDNLHJR
DVWURORJD":Uy ELW " 0HGLXP"
3DQL6KHDODGH7DQFDQGOOHMHVWZ/DQ([HWHU
1LHVNU]\ZLVL NUyO7HMF]DURZQLF\QLHFKF =DP GUD5R QLHPLWXSRG
ERNLHPGUXJD)LOLSSD(LOKDUW7\PP GU\PEDERP]E\WSDFKQLHZDG]DQLH
PR QDUR]]XFKZDODLFKDVNDPLLSRXIDR FL
-DN]Z\NOHPDV]UDFM PyMP X
+PPP$OHWHVQ\
'REUD.VL JD=XOH\NDSU]HZUyFLDNLONDVWURQSRZLDGD H JG\F]RZLHN
XV\SLDERJRZLHRWZLHUDM PXXV]\LSU]HPDZLDM GRQLHJR=D SURURN/HELRGD
XF]\ H ZLG] F VHQZLG]LVL DOERZLHON P GUR DOERZLHON JXSRW 6]WXNDZ
W\PE\UR]SR]QD
0D H VWZR7DQNUHGD]QDU]HF]RQ (PK\UDZLHON P GUR FL UDF]HMQLHMHVW
ZHVWFKQ (VWHUDG$MH OLMX R P GUR FLPRZDWRRJURPQLHE\PVL XFLHV]\
JG\E\VS\Q DQDPQLHZH QLH&KRG]LRVSUDZ ]NWyU SU]\E\WX'LMNVWUD
&KRG]LREDUG]RWUXGQ VSUDZ %RZLG]LV]QDMXNRFKD V]DPRMD=XOH\NR
UR]V GHNQLHSR]ZDODVL FLHV]\JG\1LOIJDDUGRVWURSU]HQDSyQRFLJRWyZODGD
G]LH ]DM 1RYLJUDGER]1RYLJUDGXZV]\VWNRZW\PLQDV]DQHXWUDOQR
Z\JO GDLQDF]HMQL ] GDOHNLHJRSRXGQLD'REU]HE\ZL F E\RJG\E\5HGDQLDL
7HPHULDSRZVWU]\PD\QDSyU1LOIJDDUGXE\SU]HS G]L\QDMH G F ] SRZURWHP]D
,GLHJR]DMDGOLLFKSDUW\]DQFL,WRQLHW\ONRWDF\FRSRSLHUDOLJ E ZL NV]R
VLHG]LDD]DG\ZHUVM ]DPDFK\UHZROW\]EURQL Z U NX0LQLVWHUVSUDZ
ZHZQ WU]Q\FKE\SU]HUD RQ\WDWRPRFQR]DQLHSRNRMRQ\
']LDGHN]D RSRZLDGDGLXN PLDVL MDNE\WRE\QDMOHSV]\ DUW$SRWHP
SRZLHG]LDSDPL WDPND GHVRZRWDN6]NRGDWRZLHONDSDQRZLH H QLH
F]\WXMHFLHGRSRGXV]NL'REUHM.VL JL*G\E\ FLHF]\W\ZDOLUR]XPLHOLE\ FLHLGHH
ZDV]HJRPRQDUFK\$WDNE G]LHFLHZ\NRQ\ZDOLUR]ND]\QLHUR]XPLHM F LFK$OH
QLHPDUWZFLHVL QLHSRWU]HEQLHLQD]DSDVZDV]PRQDUFKDZLHFRF]\QL7HUD]]D
LG FLHLSRZ\SXV]F]DMFLHZV]\VWNLHPRMHSVRWQHNRW\V]NRGQLNLXWUDSLRQH
7DNZD QLHSRZLHG]LDSVRWQHNRW\V]NRGQLNL$FKRG]LRRF]\PQLNW
ZyZF]DVZLHG]LHQLHPyJRSy QLHMV]\FKERKDWHUyZGRZyGFyZRNU\W\FK
FKZD L VDZ 7\PLNRWDPLG]LDGNDE\OLV\QQLSy QLHMNRQGRWLHU]\$GDP
$GLHX3DQJUDWW/RUHQ]R0ROOD-XDQ)URQWLQR*XWWLHUH],-XOLD$EDWHPDUFR
NWyUD]DV\Q DZ5HGDQLLMDNR6RGND7U]SLRWND:\PRG]LWHJRQLH
SDPL WDFLHDOH]DPRLFKF]DVyZJG\ P\EDZLOLVL Z ZRMQ ND G\FKRSDNFKFLD
E\$GLHX3DQJUDWWHPDND GDG]LHZF]\QD-XOL 6RGN 7U]SLRWN $GOD
G]LDGNDWRE\\SVRWQHNRW\KHKH
3y QLHM]D PDUQLD*XLVFDUG9HUPXHOOHQG]LDGHNZ]L PQLH]DU N L
]DEUDQDWDUDV]NWyUHJREDEND=XOH\NDNDUPLDPHZ\']LDGHNSRZLHG]LDGR
QLHM3RZLHG]LD
6WDUXV]HNSRZROLL]RJURPQ\PWUXGHPSUyERZDSU]\SRPQLHVRELHVRZD
NWyUHZyZF]DVSU]HGRVLHPG]LHVL FLRPDSL FLRPDODW\NUyO(VWHUDG7K\VVHQ
Z\U]HNGR RQ\NUyORZHM=XOH\NLQDJyUXM F\PQDG:LHONLP.DQDHPWDUDVLH
SDDFX(QVHQDGD
&]\ZLHV]PRMDQDMXNRFKD V]D RQR H GRVWU]HJHPMHV]F]HMHGQ P GUR
SR UyGP GUR FLSURURND/HELRG\"7DN NWyUDGDPLMHV]F]HMHGQ NRU]\ ]
REGDURZDQLD5HGDQLLSVRWQ\PLNRWDPL".RW\PRMD=XOH\NRZUyF GRGRPX.RW\
]DZV]HZUDFDM GRGRPX1RDJG\PRMHNRW\ZUyF JG\SU]\QLRV RG
]GRE\F]ERJDFWZD7RMDWHNRW\RSRGDWNXM
*G\NUyO(VWHUDG7K\VVHQSRUD]RVWDWQLUR]PDZLD]'LMNVWU E\RWRZF]WHU\
RF]\QDZHWEH]=XOH\NL1DSRGRG]HJLJDQW\F]QHMVDOLEDZLVL ZSUDZG]LH
G]LHVL FLROHWQLQDRNRFKRSF]\NDOHWHQVL ZV]DNQLHOLF]\DSRQDGWRWDNE\
]DM W\VZ\PLRRZLDQ\PL RQLHU]\NDPL H QLH]ZUDFDQDUR]PDZLDM F\FK DGQHM
XZDJL
7R*XLVFDUGZ\MD QL(VWHUDGZVND]XM F FKRSFDUXFKHPJRZ\0yMZQXN
V\QPRMHM*DXGHPXQG\LWHJRQLFSRQLDNVL FLD9HUPXHOOHQD$OHWHQPDOHF
*XLVFDUGWRMHG\QDQDG]LHMD.RYLUXJG\E\7DQNUHG7K\VVHQRND]DVL *G\E\
7DQNUHGRZLFR VL SU]\GDU]\R
'LMNVWUD]QDSUREOHP.RYLUX,RVRELVW\SUREOHP(VWHUDGD:LHG]LD H
7DQNUHGRZLMX VL FR SU]\GDU]\R&KRSDNMH HOLZRJyOHPLD]DGDWNLQDNUyOD
WRW\ONRQDEDUG]R]HJR
7ZRMDVSUDZDSU]HPyZL(VWHUDGMHVWMX Z ]DVDG]LH]DDWZLRQD0R HV]MX
]DF] UR]ZD DVSRVyEQDMHIHNW\ZQLHMV]HJRVSR \WNRZDQLDPLOLRQDEL]DQWyZ
NWyU\ZNUyWFHWUDILGRWUHWRJRUVNLHJRVNDUEFD
3RFK\OLVL L XNUDGNLHPSRGQLyVMHGQHJR]RRZLDQ\FKLMDVNUDZR
SRPDORZDQ\FK RQLHU]\NyZ*XLVFDUGDNDZDOHU]\VW ]HZ]QLHVLRQ\PSDDV]HP
:H WRLGREU]HVFKRZDM7HQNWRSRND H FLGUXJLHJRWDNLHJRZRMDND
LGHQW\F]QHJRE G]LHPRLPZ\VDQQLNLHPFKRE\QLHZ\JO GDFKRE\ ZLDU\QLH
PyJGD H WRPyMF]RZLHNL]QDVSUDZ QDV]HJRPLOLRQD.D G\LQQ\E G]LH
SURZRNDWRUHPLSRWUDNWXMJRMDNSURZRNDWRUD
5HGDQLDXNRQLVL 'LMNVWUDQLH]DSRPQLWHJR:DV]HM.UyOHZVNLHM0R FL-D
]D ZHZDVQ\PLPLHQLXFKFLDE\P]DSHZQLRPRMHMRVRELVWHMZG]L F]QR FL
1LH]DSHZQLDMDOHGDZDMWXWHQW\VL F]DSRPRF NWyUHJRSODQRZDH ]\VND
SU]\FK\OQR PHJRPLQLVWUD&y WRSU]\FK\OQR NUyODQLH]DVXJXMHQDDSyZN "
:DV]D.UyOHZVND0R ]QL \ VL
=QL \]QL \'DZDMSLHQL G]H'LMNVWUD0LHW\VL F LQLHPLHW\VL FD
WRUD]HPGZDW\VL FH:LHP
: RGOHJ\PVNU]\GOH(QVHQDG\ZNRPQDFLHR]QDF]QLHPQLHMV]\FKJDEDU\WDFK
F]DURG]LHMND6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOHZVNXSLHQLXL]SRZDJ Z\VXFKDDUHODFML
NUyORZHM=XOH\NL
'RVNRQDOHNLZQ DJRZ 'RVNRQDOH:DV]D.UyOHZVND:\VRNR
=URELDPZV]\VWNRWDNMDNSROHFLD SDQL6KHDOR
']L NXM ]DWR,]DSHZQLDPUD]MHV]F]HG]LDD\ P\ZVSUDZLHVXV]QHM'OD
GREUDNUDMX,G\QDVWLL
.UyORZD=XOH\NDRGFKU] NQ DJRV]PLHQLVL MHMOHNNR
$$7DQNUHGSDQL6KHDOR"
'DDPVRZRSRZLHG]LDD]LPQR6KHDODGH7DQFDUYLOOH'DDPPRMHVRZR
H ]DSRPRFRGZ]DMHPQL VL SRPRF :DV]D.UyOHZVND:\VRNR PR H VSD
VSRNRMQLH
%DUG]RE\PSUDJQ DZHVWFKQ D=XOH\ND%DUG]R-H OLMX MHVWH P\SU]\
VQDFK.UyO]DF]\QDFR SRGHMU]HZD7HVQ\G]LZL JRDNUyOJG\FR JRG]LZL
URELVL SRGHMU]OLZ\
=DSU]HVWDQ ]DWHPQDF]DVMDNL ]V\DNUyORZLVQ\RELHFDDF]DURG]LHMND
:UDFDM F ]D GRVQXNUyORZHMSRZWDU]DPPR H RQE\VSRNRMQ\.UyOHZLF]
7DQNUHGUR]VWDQLHVL ]H]\PWRZDU]\VWZHP1LHE G]LHMX E\ZDQD]DPNX
EDURQD6XUFUDWDVVH$QLXSDQLGH/LVHPRUH$QLXUHGD VNLHMDPEDVDGRURZHM
1LHE G]LHMX RGZLHG]DW\FKSHUVRQ"1LJG\"
3HUVRQ\RNWyU\FKPRZDZFLHPQ\FKRF]DFK6KHDOLGH7DQFDU\LOOH]DSDOLVL
G]LZQ\E\VNQLHRGZD VL MX ]DSUDV]DLEDDPXFLNUyOHZLF]D7DQNUHGD1LH
RGZD VL QDWRMX QLJG\% G ERZLHP ZLDGRPHNRQVHNZHQFML5 F] ]DWRFR
XPLHUD]JRGX:\REUD DV]WRVRELH"
6]F]HU]HPyZL FQLH
$MDWDN2]L ELHQLHNOLPDWXPR H QDVZV]\VWNLFK]DJRG]L*yGWRZUyJ]
NWyU\PFKROHUQLHWUXGQRZDOF]\
6]SLHJNLZQ JRZ ]DP\ ORQ\
'LMNVWUD"
:DV]D.UyOHZVND0R "
:HZQ WU]NUDMXPDV]MX VSRNyM"
1LHEDUG]R$OHVWDUDPVL
:LHPJR QRRW\P=W\FKNWyU]\]GUDG]LOLQD7KDQHGG \Z\]RVWDW\ONR
9LOJHIRUW]
3R PLHUFL<HQQHIHUWDN:LHV]NUyOX H <HQQHIHUSRQLRVD PLHU"=JLQ D
RVWDWQLHJRGQLDVLHUSQLDZ]DJDGNRZ\FKRNROLF]QR FLDFKQDRVDZLRQHM* EL
6HGQ\PL G]\:\VSDPL6NHOOLJHDSU]\O GNLHP3HL[HGH0DU
<HQQHIHU]9HQJHUEHUJXSRZLHG]LDZROQR(VWHUDGQLHE\D]GUDMF]\QL 1LH
E\DZVSyOQLF]N 9LOJHIRUW]D-H OLFKFHV]GRVWDUF] FLQDWRGRZRGyZ
1LHFKF RGSDUSRFKZLOLPLOF]HQLD'\NVWUD$PR H ]HFKF DOHQLHWHUD]
7HUD]Z\JRGQLHMV]DMHVWGODPQLHMDNR]GUDMF]\QL
3RMPXM 1LHXIDMF]DURG]LHMNRP'LMNVWUD)LOLSSLH]ZDV]F]D
1LJG\MHMQLHXIDHP$OHPXVLP\ZVSySUDFRZD%H]QDV5HGDQLDSRJU \
VL Z FKDRVLHL]JLQLH
7RSUDZGD$OHMH OLPRJ FLUDG]LSRIROJXMQLHFR:LHV]RF]\PPyZL
6]DIRW\LL]E\WRUWXUZFD\PNUDMXRNUXFLH VWZDSRSHQLDQHQDHOIDFK,WHQ
VWUDV]Q\IRUW'UDNHQERUJ:LHP H URELV]WR]SDWULRW\]PX$OHEXGXMHV]VRELH
] OHJHQG -HVWH Z QLHMZLONRODNLHPFKHSF F\PQLHZLQQ NUHZ
.WR WRPXVLUREL
,QDNLP PXVLVL VNUXSL:LHP H VWDUDV]VL E\VSUDZLHGOLZ\DOHSU]HFLH
QLHXQLNQLHV]SRP\HNERQLHGDVL LFKXQLNQ 1LHGDVL WH SR]RVWDF]\VW\P
EDEUDM F VL ZHNUZL:LHP H QLJG\QLHVNU]\ZG]LQLNRJRGODSU\ZDW\DOHNWR
Z WRXZLHU]\".WRE G]LHFKFLDZWRZLHU]\":GQLXJG\ORVVL RGZUyFL
SU]\SLV] FLPRUGRZDQLHQLHZLQQ\FKLF]HUSDQLH]WHJRNRU]\ FL$NDPVWZROHSL
VL GRF]RZLHNDMDNVPRD
:LHP
1LHGDG] FLV]DQV\QDREURQ 7DNLPMDNW\QLJG\QLHGDMHVL V]DQV\2EOHSL
FL VPR Sy QLHM3RIDNFLH6WU]H VL 'LMNVWUD
6WU]HJ VL 1LHGRVWDQ PQLH
'RVWDOLWZHJRNUyOD9L]LPLUD6\V]DHPV]W\OHWZERND SRJDUG
.UyODDWZLHMXJRG]LQL V]SLHJD0QLHQLHGRVWDQ 1LJG\PQLHQLHGRVWDQ
,QLHSRZLQQL$ZLHV]GODF]HJR'LMNVWUD"%RQDW\P ZLHFLHPXVLE\
NXUZDMDND VSUDZLHGOLZR
0yJZDOF]\]DPJORQHQLHZLG] FHRF]\*XLVFDUGD9HUPXHOOHQDSDWU]\\Z
RWFKD ZVSRPQLH =DPDFKRZFyZE\RW\ONRWU]HFKG]LDGHNE\VLOQ\P
P F]\]Q 0yJZDOF]\EURQLVL GRFKZLOLJG\QDGELHJDE\VWUD 0yJWH
SRSURVWXXFLHF$OHE\DWDPEDEND=XOH\ND']LDGHNRVDQLDLFKURQL=XOH\N
W\ONR=XOH\N RVLHELHQLHGED*G\ZUHV]FLHSU]\V]DSRPRF=XOH\NDQLHE\D
QDZHWGUD QL WD(VWHUDGGRVWDSRQDGGZDG]LH FLDSFKQL 8PDUSRWU]HFK
JRG]LQDFKQLHRG]\VNDZV]\SU]\WRPQR FL
5R]G]LD
2GJURGXVWDUR \WQHJRLVWDZQHJR$VVHQJDUGXXV]OL P\PR H ]HV]H VHWHN
VWDMD QDSRXGQLHGRNUDMX]ZDUWHJR6WRMH]LRU\*G\]HZ]JyU]QDWHQNUDM
SRJO GQ XMU]\VL RQHOLF]QHMH]LRUDV]WXF]QD]DLVWHU]HF]\NROHM XR RQHZH
Z]RU\UR]PDLWH: UyGW\FK H Z]RUyZSU]HZRGQLNQDV]HOI$YDOODF
KND]DWDNLHJR
V]XNDNWyUHQSRGREQ\MHVWGROL FLDWULEOLXP,ZU]HF]\VDPHMWDNRZ\
Z\SDWU]\OL P\3U]\F]\PZ\MDZLRVL H QLHWU]\DOHF]WHU\MHVWMH]LRUERMHGQR
SRGXJRZDWH]SRXGQLDQDSyQRFVL FL JQ FHMHVWMDNRE\RQHJROL FLDV]\SXN
-H]LRURWR]Z FHVL 7DP0LUDF]DUQ\PMHVWRWRF]RQHODVHPDXSyQRFQHJRMHJR
NUD FDEDV]WDRZDWDMHPQDZ]QRVLVL MDNRE\PLDD:LH \F -DVNyNLQD]\ZDQD
Z HOIyZ]D PRZLH7RU=LUHDHO
=UD]XMHGQDNRZR QLHZLG]LHOL P\QLFMHQRPJ -X HPVL VSRVRELE\HOID
$YDOODF
KDRZLH RZ ]DJDGQ JG\WHQ H GD]QDNPLOF]HQLDVDP]D Z WHVRZD
U]HN&]HNDLPLHQDG]LHM 1DG]LHMDSRZUyFL]H ZLDWHPL]GREU ZUy E
%DF]FLHQDEH]PLDUZyGWDPXMU]\FLHSRVWyZGREU\QRZLQ\
%X\YLG%DFNKX\VHQ
3HUHJU\QDFMHSRV]ODNDFKLPLHMVFDFKPDJLF]Q\FK
7DNVL NDWRRGSRF] WNXGRNR FDKXPEXJ5XLQ\QDGMH]LRUHP7DP0LUDE\\
ZLHORNURWQLHEDGDQH1LHV PDJLF]QHZEUHZHQXQFMDFMRP%%DFNKX\VHQDQLH
PRJ WHG\E\SR]RVWDOR FL OHJHQGDUQHM:LH \ -DVNyNL
$UV0DJLFD(G;,9
3\Q 3\Q
<HQQHIHUREXU F]SU]\WU]\PDDWDUJDQHPRNU\PZLDWUHPZRV\VWDQ DSU]\
EDOXVWUDG]LHVFKRGyZXVXZDM F VL ] GURJL]ELHJDM F\FKQDQDEU]H H NRELHW
3FKDQ\]DFKRGQLPZLDWUHPSU]\EyM]RPRWHPUR]ELMDVL R EU]HJ]UR]SDGOLQ
PL G]\VNDDPLFRLUXV]VWU]HOD\ELDHSLyURSXV]HSLDQ\
3\Q 3\Q
= JyUQ\FKWDUDVyZF\WDGHOL.DHU7UROGHJyZQHMZDURZQL$UG6NHOOLJZLGD
E\RFD\EH]PDDDUFKLSHODJ1DZSURVW]DFLH QLQ OH DD$Q6NHOOLJRGVWURQ\
SRXGQLRZHMQLVNDLSDVNDRGQLHZLGRF]QHMSyQRFQHMXUZLVWDLSRFL WDILRUGDPL
3ROHZHMGDOHNRRVWU\PLNDPLUDIUR]ELMDDIDOHZ\VRNDL]LHORQD6SLNHURRJ]
JyUDPLRV]F]\WDFKWRQ F\FKZFKPXUDFK3RSUDZHMZLGDE\RVWURPHNOLI\
Z\VS\8QGYLNURM FHVL RGPHZSHWUHOLNRUPRUDQyZLJXSWDNyZ=]D8DG\LN
Z\DQLDVL OHVLVW\VWR HN+PGDUVIMDOOQDMPQLHMV]HMZ\VHSNLDUFKLSHODJX*G\E\
E G]LHV]SUyERZDDX \ZDPDJLL
$MH OLQLHGDP"
0DUTXDUGQDV]F]DURG]LHM]JLQ QD7KDQHGGQLHPDP\WXWHUD]PDJLNDNWyU\
PyJE\Z]L FL SRGNRQWURO $OHZLHG] H E G]LHV]SRGEH]XVWDQQ REVHUZDFM
QDMOHSV]\FKXF]QLNyZ6NHOOLJH-H OLFKRE\U N UXV]\V]ZSRGHMU]DQ\VSRVyE
]RVWDQLHV]]DVWU]HORQD
-DVQHNLZQ DJRZ 'DM ZL F VRZR
'RVNRQDOH']L NXM HJQDM<HQQHIHU1LHE G FL MXWURRGSURZDG]D
&UDFK
2GZUyFLVL QDSL FLH
6XFKDP
1LHPDPQDMPQLHMV]HJR]DPLDUXZVLDGDQDVWDWHNS\Q F\GR1RYLJUDGX1LH
PDPF]DVXE\XGRZDGQLD'LMNVWU]H H MHVWHPQLHZLQQD1LHPRJ U\]\NRZD H
MX VSUHSDURZDQRGRZRG\PRMHMZLQ\1LHPRJ U\]\NRZD H NUyWNRSR
DUHV]WRZDQLXXPU QDQDJ\Z\OHZNUZLGRPy]JXOXEZMDNL VSHNWDNXODUQ\
VSRVyESRSHQL Z FHOLVDPREyMVWZR1LHPRJ WUDFLF]DVXLSRGHMPRZDWDNLHJR
U\]\ND1LHPRJ WH Z\MD QLDFLGODF]HJRWRGODPQLHWDNU\]\NRZQH1LH
SRS\Q GR1RYLJUDGX
3DWU]\QDQL GXJR
1LHSRS\QLHV]SRZWyU]\&y WDNLHJRSR]ZDODFLWDNPQLHPD"&]\ E\WR
H QLHJG\ F]\\QDVPLRVQHXQLHVLHQLD"1LHOLF]QDWR<HQQHIHU&RE\RDQLH
MHVWQLHSLV]HVL Z UHMHVWU
:LHPLQLHOLF] 1LHSRS\Q GR1RYLJUDGXMDUOXGODWHJR H PLSLOQR
Z\UXV]\QDSRPRFRVRELHNWyUHMSRSU]\VL JDP H QLJG\QLH]RVWDZL MHMVDPHML
EH]SRPRF\$W\&UDFKXDQ&UDLWHMDUOX6NHOOLJHGRSRPR HV]PLZPRLP
SU]HGVL Z]L FLX%RLW\]R \H SRGREQ SU]\VL J ']LHVL ODWWHPX'RNDGQLH
WXJG]LHVWRLP\QDW\PQDEU]H X7HMVDPHMRVRELH&LULZQXF]FH&DODQWKH
/ZL WNX]&LQWU\-D<HQQHIHU]9HQJHUEHUJXXZD DP&LUL]DP FyUN 'ODWHJR
Z MHMLPLHQLX GDPE\ GRWU]\PDWZRMHMSU]\VL JL'RWU]\PDMMHM&UDFKXDQ
&UDLWHMDUOX6NHOOLJH
VNDUEFDLZ\VSLDUVNLHMILOLLEDQNX&LDQIDQHOOLFK5\VRZDDLNUH OLDDU\VXQNLL
Z\NUHV\QDW\FKPLDVWWUDILD\GRU N U]HPLH OQLNyZDOFKHPLNyZ]RWQLNyZ
V]NODU]\MXELOHUyZ
-DNL F]DVZV]\VWNRV]RVSUDZQLHSRWHP]DF] \VL NRSRW\
-DNW\VRELHWRZ\REUD DV]<HQQHIHU"]PDUV]F]\EUZL*UDFKDQ&UDLWH
0DPZ\VD]EURMQ\FKE\Z]L OLV]WXUPHPLRJUDELOLW ZL W\QL " 0DP]DJUR]L
NDSDQNRPPRLPJQLHZHPMH OLQLHZ\GDG] EU\ODQWX"7RQLHZFKRG]LZJU 1LH
MHVWHPVSHFMDOQLHUHOLJLMQ\DOH ZL W\QLDWR ZL W\QLDDNDSDQNLWRNDSDQNL0RJ
MHW\ONRJU]HF]QLHSRSURVL'DGR]UR]XPLHQLDMDNEDUG]RPL]DOH \ LMDNZLHOND
E G]LHPRMDZG]L F]QR $OHWR]DZV]HE G]LHW\ONRSUR ED8QL RQDVXSOLND
.WyU PR QDSRWUDNWRZDRGPRZQLH"
7DNMHVW$OHVSUyERZDQLH]DZDG]L&]\PU\]\NXMHP\"3\ P\ZHGZRMHQD
+LQGDUVIMDOOSU]HGVWDZP\W VXSOLN -DGDPNDSDQNRPGR]UR]XPLHQLDFR
QDOH \$SRWHPMX ZV]\VWNRZWZRLFKU NDFK1HJRFMXM3U]HGVWDZDUJXPHQW\
3UyEXMSU]HNXSVWZD'UD QLMDPELFMH2GZRDMVL GRZ\ V]\FKUDFML5R]SDF]DM
SDF]VSD]PXMELHU]QDOLWR 'RZV]\VWNLFKPRUVNLFKGLDEyZPDPFL XF]\
<HQQHIHU"
7RZV]\VWNRQDQLF*UDFK&]DURG]LHMNDQLJG\QLHGRJDGDVL ] NDSDQNDPL
=E\WRVWUHV SHZQHSRG]LD\ ZLDWRSRJO GRZH$ZNZHVWLLE\SR]ZROL
F]DURG]LHMFHX \ ZL WHJRUHOLNWXF]\DUWHIDNWX1LH]DSRPQLHWU]HEDRW\P
1LHPDV]DQV
'RF]HJRFLZD FLZLHWHQEU\ODQW"
'REXGRZ\RNQD7R]QDF]\WHOHNRPXQLNDF\MQHJRPHJDVNRSX0XV]
SRUR]XPLHVL ] NLONRPDRVREDPL
0DJLF]QLH"1DRGOHJR "
*G\E\Z\VWDUF]\RZHM QDV]F]\W.DHU7UROGHLJR QRZRDQLH
]DZUDFDDE\PFLJRZ\
3URV] =UyEWRGODPQLH,GOD&LUL
.OHMQRW%ULVLQJDPHQ1DV]\LERJLQL
6WXPLD]LHZQL FLH*G\E\FKRFLD MDNLH SLHZ\SRP\ ODDMDNLH LQNDQWDFMH
MDNLH PLVWHULD-DNL PLVW\F]Q\IRONORU%\RE\PQLHMQXGQRVHQE\WDNQLH
PRU]\$OHRQHSRSURVWXNO F] VFK\OLZV]\JRZ\%H]UXFKXEH]G ZL NX
$OHMHGQDNSRWUDIL JG\FKF RSHURZD0RF QLHUD]UyZQLHGREU]HMDNP\
F]DURG]LHMNL:FL MHVW]DJDGN MDNRQHWRUREL DGQ\FKSU]\JRWRZD DGQHM
QDXNL DGQ\FKVWXGLyZ7\ONRPRGOLWZDLPHG\WDFMD'\ZLQDT
D"5RG]DM
DXWRKLSQR]\"7DNWZLHUG]LD7LVVDLDGH9ULHV&]HUSL HQHUJL QLH ZLDGRPLHZ
WUDQVLHQDE\ZDM ]GROQR FLMHMSU]HWZRU]HQLDDQDORJLF]QHMGRQDV]\FK]DNO
3U]HWZDU]DM HQHUJL WUDNWXM F WRMDNRGDULDVN EyVWZD:LDUDGDMHLPVL
'ODF]HJRQDPF]DURG]LHMNRPQLJG\QLHXGDRVL QLFWDNLHJR"
6SUyERZD".RU]\VWDM F ]DWPRVIHU\LDXU\WHJRPLHMVFD"0RJDE\PSU]HFLH
VDPDZSURZDG]LVL Z WUDQV&KRE\SDWU] F QDWHQEU\ODQW%ULVLQJDPHQ
,QWHQV\ZQLHP\ O F RW\PMDN ZLHWQLHSHQLE\VZ URO Z PRLPPHJDVNRSLH
%ULVLQJDPHQ%\V]F]\MDNJZLD]GD]DUDQQDWDPZPURNXZG\PLHNDG]LGHL
NRSF F\FK ZLHF
<HQQHIHU
3RGHUZDDJRZ
: ZL W\QLE\ORFLHPQR,QWHQV\ZQLHSDFKQLDRG\PHP
=DVQ DP":\EDF]
1LHPDQLFGRZ\EDF]DQLD&KRG ]HPQ
1D]HZQ WU]QRFQHQLHERSDDRPLJRWOLZ\P]PLHQLDM F\PVL MDNZ
NDOHMGRVNRSLH ZLDWOHP=RU]DSRODUQD"<HQQHIHUSU]HWDUDRF]\Z]GXPLHQLX
$XURPERUHDOLV:VLHUSQLX"
,OHMHVWH Z VWDQLHSR ZL FL<HQQHIHU"
6XFKDP"
-HVWH JRWRZDSR ZL FLVLHELH"6ZRM EH]FHQQ PDJL "
6LJUGULIRSRZLHG]LDD]H]R FL 1LHSUyEXM]HPQ W\FKQDWFKQLRQ\FK
V]WXF]HN-DPDPG]LHZL G]LHVL W F]WHU\ODWD$OHSRWUDNWXMWRSURV] MDNR
WDMHPQLF VSRZLHG]L=ZLHU]DPFLVL W\ONRGODWHJRE\ ]UR]XPLDD H QLHPR QD
WUDNWRZDPQLHMDNG]LHFND
1LHRGSRZLHG]LDD QDPRMHS\WDQLH
,QLH]DPLHU]DP%RWRPLVW\F\]PNWyUHJRQLHDNFHSWXM 8VQ DPQDZDV]\P
QDER H VWZLH=QX \RPQLHL]QXG]LR%RQLHZLHU] Z WZRM ERJLQL
6LJUGULIDRGZUyFLDVL D<HQQHIHUZEUHZZROLZ]L DEDUG]RJ ERNLZGHFK
1LH]E\WMHVWGODPQLHSRFKOHEQDWZRMDQLHZLDUDSRZLHG]LDDNRELHWDRRF]DFK
Z\SHQLRQ\FKS\QQ\P]RWHP$OHF]\WZRMDQLHZLDUDFRNROZLHN]PLHQLD"
-HG\Q\PFR<HQQHIHUE\DZVWDQLH]URELE\Z\GHFK
3U]\MG]LHF]DVSRZLHG]LDD]RWRRNDNRELHWDJG\DEVROXWQLHQLNWZOLF]DM F
5yZQLQD0RU]HWUDZ:U]RVRZLVNR*D]Z\VWDM F\]QDGZU]RVyZMDNJU]ELHW
SU]\F]DMRQHJRGUDSLH QLND
7\]DSUDJQ D PRMHJRNOHMQRWX<HQQHIHU1LHPRJ FLJRGDQLH
XSHZQLZV]\VL XSU]HGQLRZ]JO GHPQLHNWyU\FKVSUDZ&KF VSUDZG]LFRZ
WRELHWNZL'ODWHJRSU]\ZLRGDPFL WXGRWHJRPLHMVFDRGQLHSDPL WQ\FKF]DVyZ
E G FHJRPLHMVFHP0RF\L3RW JL7ZRMDEH]FHQQDPDJLDMHVWSRGREQRZV] G]LH
3RGREQRZ\VWDUF]\Z\FL JQ U N 1LHERLV]VL MHMZ\FL JQ "
<HQQHIHUQLHPRJDZ\GRE\G ZL NX]H FL QL WHJRJDUGD
6LD]GROQD]PLHQLD ZLDWSRZLHG]LDDNRELHWDNWyUHMQLHZROQRE\R
QD]\ZDLPLHQLHPMHVWZL F ZHGXJFLHELH&KDRVHPV]WXN L QDXN "
3U]HNOH VWZHPERJRVDZLH VWZHPLSRVW SHP"$QLHMHVWSU]\SDGNLHP:LDU "
0LR FL " 3R ZL FHQLHP"
6\V]\V]"3LHMHNRJXW.DPEL)DODELMHREU]HJIDODSFKDQDG]LREHP1DJOIDUD
5R]EU]PLHZDUyJ+HPGDOODVWRM FHJRWZDU] NXZURJRPQDW F]RZ\PXNX
%LIURVWX1DGFL JD%LDH=LPQRQDGFL JDZLFKXUDL]DPLH=LHPLDGU \ RG
JZDWRZQ\FKSRUXV]H : D:LONSR HUDVR FH.VL \FF]HUQLHMH-HVWW\ONR
]LPQRLFLHPQR 1LHQDZL ]HPVWDLNUHZ
3RF]\MHMVWURQLHVWDQLHV]<HQQHIHU"&]\E G]LHV]QDZVFKRGQLPF]\
]DFKRGQLPNUD FX%LIURVWX"% G]LHV]]+HPGDOOHPF]\SU]HFLZQLHPX"
3LHMHNRJXW.DPEL
'HF\GXM<HQQHIHU:\ELHUDM%RSU]HFLH W\ONRSRWRSU]\ZUyFRQRFL NLHG\
\FLXE\ ZHZD FLZHMFKZLOLPRJDGRNRQDZ\ERUX
ZLDWRF]\&LHPQR "
'REURL=R ZLDWRL&LHPQR DGL&KDRV"7RW\ONRV\PEROHZ
U]HF]\ZLVWR FLQLHLVWQLHMHWDNDELHJXQRZR ZLDWRL0URNV Z ND G\PWURFK
WHJRLWURFK WHJR%H]VHQVXMHVWWDUR]PRZD%H]VHQVX1LHSU]HVWDZL VL QD
-DQND-DQHF]ND
=DELHU]RGHPQLHWHJRJDUEDWHJRSRWZRUD1LHFKF QDQLHJRSDWU]H
7RWZRMDFyUNDWDNVDPRMDNPRMD
'RSUDZG\"']LHFLNWyUHMDVSRG]LHPV QRUPDOQH
-DN PLHV]-DN PLHV]VXJHURZD
7RZWZRMHMHOILHMURG]LQLHE\\F]DURZQLFH7RW\XVXQ D SLHUZV] FL 7R
SU]H]WR0DV]VND RQ HOIL NUHZLRQRNRELHWR'ODWHJRURG]LV]SRWZRU\
7RQLHV]F] OLZHG]LHFNR7DNDE\DZRODERJyZ7RWZRMDFyUNDWDNVDPRMDN
L PRMD&RPLDDP]UREL"8GXVLM " 1LHSRGZL ]\ZDS SRZLQ\"&RPDP
]URELWHUD]":\SURZDG]LM GRODVXL]RVWDZL"&]HJRW\RGHPQLHFKFHV]QD
ERJyZ"
7DWR0DPR
3UHF]G]LZRO JX
-DN PLHV]-DN PLHV]ELG]LHFNR6WyM'RN G LG]LHV]"'RN G"'RQLHMWDN"
'RQLHM
$WDNNRELHWR-HVWHPP F]\]Q ZROQRPL]DVSRNDMD G]HJG]LHFKF L
NLHG\FKF WRPRMHSU]\URG]RQHSUDZR$W\PQLHPLHU]LV]7\LRZRFWZHJR
]Z\URGQLDHJR \ZRWD1LHF]HNDM]ZLHF]HU] 1LHZUyF QDQRF
0DPR
'ODF]HJRSDF]HV]"
'ODF]HJRPQLHELMHV]LRGS\FKDV]"3U]HFLH E\DPJU]HF]QD
0DPR0DPXVLX
&]\]GROQDMHVWH GRZ\EDF]DQLD"
:\EDF]\DPMX GDZQR
1DV\FLZV]\VL SLHUZHM]HPVW
7DN
DXMHV]"
1LH
%yOSRWZRUQ\EyOPDVDNURZDQ\FKGRQLLSDOFyZ
7DNMHVWHPZLQQD&]\WRFKFLDD XV\V]H":\]QDQLHLVNUXFK " &KFLDD
XV\V]HMDN<HQQHIHU]9HQJHUEHUJXNDMDVL L NRU]\"1LHWHMSU]\MHPQR FLFLQLH
GDP:LQ\Z\]QDM L RF]HNXM NDU\$OHW\QLHGRF]HNDV]VL PRMHMVNUXFK\
%yOVL JDJUDQLFWHJRFRF]RZLHNMHVWZVWDQLHZ\WU]\PD
:\SRPLQDV]PL]GUDG]RQ\FKRV]XNDQ\FKZ\NRU]\VWDQ\FKZ\SRPLQDV]PL
W\FKFRXPDUOLSU]H]HPQLH]ZDVQHMU NL]PRMHMU NL7R H SRGQLRVDPNLHG\
U N QDVLHELH"0LDDPZLGDSRZRG\,QLH DXM QLF]HJR&KRE\PPRJD
FRIQ F]DV1LH DXM QLF]HJR
6RNyXVLDGQDMHMUDPLHQLX
:LH D -DVNyNL:LH D -DVNyNL6SLHV]GR:LH \ -DVNyNL&yUHF]NR
3LHMHNRJXW.DPEL
&LULQDNDUHMNODF]\]V]DU\PLZRVDPLWDUJDQ\PLZLDWUHPZJDORSLH=MHM
WZDU]\OHMHVL L SU\VNDNUHZMDVNUDZD \ZDF]HUZLH .DUDNODF]Z]ELMDVL MDN
SWDNJDGNRSU]H OL]JXMHVL QDGEHON NRRZURWX&LULFKZLHMHVL Z VLRGOHDOHQLH
VSDGD
&LULZ UyGQRF\Z UyGNDPLHQQRSLDV]F]\VWHJRSXVWNRZLD]HZ]QLHVLRQ U N
] U NLZ\ODWXMH ZLHF FDNXOD-HGQRUR HFJU]HEL F\NRS\WHP ZLU:LHOH
MHGQRUR FyZ2JLH 2JLH
*HUDOWQDPR FLH:ZDOFH:RJQLX3RPLH RGELMDVL Z RVWU]XPLHF]D
)ULQJLOOD9LJRMHM]LHORQHRF]\V]HURNRUR]ZDUWHZUR]NRV]\MHMFLHPQD
RVWU]\ RQDJyZNDQDRWZDUWHMNVL G]HQDIURQW\VSLVLH:LGDIUDJPHQWW\WXX
8ZDJLR PLHUFLQLHFK\EQHM
: RF]DFK)ULQJLOOLRGELMDM VL RF]\*HUDOWD
2WFKD '\P6FKRG\SURZDG] FHZGy6FKRG\NWyU\PLWU]HED]HM &R VL
NR F]\1DGFKRG]L7HGG'HLUHDGK&]DV.R FD
&LHPQR :LOJR3U]HUD OLZH]LPQRNDPLHQQ\FK FLDQ=LPQR HOD]DQD
SU]HJXEDFKU NQDNRVWNDFKQyJ%yOW WQL F\Z]PDVDNURZDQ\FKGRQLDFKUZ F\
Z ]PLD G RQ\FKSDOFDFK
&LULWU]\PDM ]DU N 'XJLFLHPQ\NRU\WDU]NDPLHQQHNROXPQ\PR H
SRV JL0URN:QLPV]HSW\FLFKHMDNV]XPZLDWUX
'U]ZL1LHVNR F]HQLHZLHOHGU]ZLRJLJDQW\F]Q\FKFL NLFKVNU]\GDFKRWZLHUD
VL SU]HGQLPLEH]V]PHUX
$QDNR FXZQLHSU]HELWHMFLHPQR FLWDNLHNWyUHQLHRWZRU] VL VDPH.WyU\FK
RWZRU]\QLHZROQR
-H HOLVL ERLV]]DZUy
1LHZROQRRWZRU]\W\FKGU]ZL7\RW\PZLHV]
:LHP
$MHGQDNSURZDG]LV]PQLHWDP
-H HOLVL ERLV]]DZUy-HV]F]HMHVWF]DVE\]DZUyFL-HV]F]HQLHMHVW]DSy QR
$W\"
'ODPQLHMHVW
3LHMHNRJXW.DPEL
1DGV]HG7HGG'HLUHDGK
$XURUDERUHDOLV
ZLW
<HQQHIHU=EXG VL
3RGHUZDDJRZ 6SRMU]DDQDGRQLH0LDDRELH&DH
6LJUGULID"=DVQ DP
&KRG
'RN G"V]HSQ D'RN G W\PUD]HP"
6XFKDP"1LHUR]XPLHPFL &KRG 0XVLV]WR]REDF]\&R VL VWDR&R
G]LZQHJR DGQD]QDVQLHZLHMDNLF]\PWRZ\WXPDF]\$MDVL GRP\ ODP
DVND6S\Q DQDFLHELHDVNDERJLQL<HQQHIHU
2FRFKRG]L6LJUGULIR"
6SyMU]
6SRMU]DD,ZHVWFKQ DJR QR
%ULVLQJDPHQ ZL W\NOHMQRW0RGURQ3UH\MLQLHZLVLDMX QDV]\LERJLQL/H DX
MHMVWyS
7ULVVQLHJDUG]LDRZRFDPLPRU]D3U]HFLZQLH]MDGDLFKGZDUD]\ZL FHMQL
]DPLHU]DDLWHUD]]DF] DVL REDZLDRWDOL RWHGZDG]LH FLDGZDFDOH]NWyU\FK
E\DWDNGXPQD3RVWDQRZLDZVSRPyFWUDZLHQLHELD\PZLQHPV\QQ\P(VW(VW]
7RXVVDLQW3RGREQLHMDN&UDFKSLDMH]URJX
7DNZL F SRGM DUR]PRZ <HQQHIHU]MDZLDVL WXG]LHZL WQDVWHJRVLHUSQLD
VSHNWDNXODPLHVSDGDM F ]QLHEDZU\EDFNLHVLHFL7\MDNRZLHUQ\OHQQLN&LQWU\
XG]LHOLH MHMD]\OX3RPRJH ]EXGRZDPHJDVNRS=NLPLRF]\PUR]PDZLDD
RF]\ZL FLHQLHZLHV]
&UDFKDQ&UDLWHW JRSRFL JQ ]URJXLVWXPLEHNQL FLH
1LHZLHPX PLHFKQ VL FK\WU]H3HZQLH H QLFQLHZLHP6N G MDELHGQ\L
SURVW\ HJODU]PyJE\PZLHG]LHFRNROZLHNRSRF]\QDQLDFKPR Q\FK
F]DURG]LHMHN"
7DNSU]\SXV]F]DDPSRZLHG]LDD7ULVV<HQQHIHU]DF] DRG]GRE\FLD
WDMQHJRUDSRUWXNRPLVML5DGFOLIIH
DNWyUDEDGDDVSUDZ Z\SDGNyZQD7KDQHGG
1LHZLHPMDNLHZLH FLRWHMDIHU]HGRWDU\WXQD6NHOOLJH6\V]DH R WHOHSRUFLH
:LH \ 0HZ\",RNRPLVML5DGFOLIIH
D"
&UDFKDQ&UDLWHVSRMU]DQDF]DURG]LHMN SRGHMU]OLZLH
7XQDZ\VS\Z\NU]\ZLVL QLHGRFLHUDQLSROLW\NDQLNXOWXUD-HVWH P\
]DFRIDQL
.RPLVMD5DGFOLIIH
D7ULVVX]QDD]DFHORZHQLH]ZUDFDXZDJLDQLQDMHJRWRQ
DQLPLQ V]F]HJyRZR]EDGDDZLRG FH]7KDQHGG ODG\WHOHSRUWDF\MQH
=QDMGXM F\VL QDZ\VSLHSRUWDO7RU/DUDGRSyNLLVWQLDQHJRZDZ]QDF]Q\P
SURPLHQLXZV]HON PDJL WHOHSRUWDF\MQ $OHMDNQLH]DZRGQLHZLHV]:LH D 0HZ\
HNVSORGRZDDLUR]SDGDVL F]\QL F WHOHSRUWDFM PR OLZ :L NV]R XF]HVWQLNyZ
Z\SDGNyZQD7KDQHGGZ\GRVWDDVL ] Z\VS\]DSRPRF XWZRU]RQ\FKSRUWDOL
:VDPHMU]HF]\X PLHFKQ VL MDUO7\ HE\GDOHNRQLHV]XNDSROHFLDD
SURVWRGR%URNLORQX=ZLHG PLQHPQDSOHFDFK
1RSURV] 7ULVVVSRMU]DDPXZRF]\1LHGRFLHUDSROLW\NDQLHGRFLHUD
NXOWXUDDSORWNLGRFLHUDM $OH]RVWDZP\WRFKZLORZRZUyP\GRSUDFNRPLVML
5DGFOLIIH
D.RPLVMLFKRG]LRRGRNDGQHXVWDOHQLHNWRVL ] 7KDQHGGWHOHSRUWRZDL
GRN G8 \WRWDN]ZDQ\FKV\QRSVyZF]DUyZ]GROQ\FKRGWZRU]\REUD]
SU]HV]\FKZ\GDU]H L ]HVWDZLZ\NU\WH ODG\WHOHSRUWDF\MQH]NLHUXQNDPLGR
NWyU\FKZLRG\DZNRQVHNZHQFMLSU]\SLVDGRRNUH ORQ\FKRVyENWyUHSRUWDOH
RWZDU\8GDRVL SUDNW\F]QLHZHZV]\VWNLFKSU]\SDGNDFK3R]DMHGQ\P-HGHQ
ODGWHOHSRUWDF\MQ\ZLyGGRQLN G'RNDGQLHMZPRU]H1D* EL 6HGQ\
.WR GRP\ OLVL ] PLHMVFDMDUOWHOHSRUWRZDVL QDF]HNDM F\Z
XPyZLRQ\PPLHMVFXVWDWHN&LHNDZHW\ONR H WDNGDOHNR,ZPLHMVFHRWDN]HM
VDZLH1RDOHMH OLWRSyUZLVLQDGNDUNLHP
:D QLH.RPLVMDWH QDWRZSDGD,VIRUPXRZDDZQLRVHNQDVW SXM F\7R
9LOJHIRUW]VFKZ\WDZV]\&LULLPDM F RGFL W LQQ GURJ XFLHF]NLVNRU]\VWD]
Z\M FLDUH]HUZRZHJRZUD]]G]LHZF]\Q WHOHSRUWRZDVL QD* EL 6HGQ\QD
F]HNDM F\WDPQLOIJDDUG]NLRNU W7QZD QLHZHGXJNRPLVMLZ\MD QLDIDNW H &LUL
E\DSU]HGVWDZLRQDQDGZRU]HFHVDUVNLPZ/RF*ULPMX G]LHVL WHJROLSFD
]DOHGZLHG]LHVL GQLSRZ\GDU]HQLDFKQD7KDQHGG
1RWDNMDUL]PUX \RF]\7RZLHOHZ\MD QLD0DVL UR]XPLHSRG
ZDUXQNLHP H NRPLVMDVL QLHSRP\OLD
2ZV]HPF]DURG]LHMNDZ\WU]\PDDVSRMU]HQLHSR]ZROLDVRELHQDZHWQD
GUZL F\X PLHV]HN:/RF*ULPPDVL UR]XPLHPyJE\UyZQLHGREU]H
]DSUH]HQWRZDQ\VRERZWyUQLHSUDZG]LZD&LUL7RWH PR H ZLHOHZ\MD QLD1LH
Z\MD QLDMHGQDNMHV]F]HMHGQHJRIDNWXNWyU\XVWDOLDNRPLVMD5DGFOLIIH
D7DN
G]LZQHJR H ZSLHUZV]HMZHUVMLUDSRUWXSRPLQL WRJRMDNR]E\W
QLHSUDZGRSRGREQ\:GUXJLHMZHUVMLUDSRUWX FL OHXWDMQLRQHMWHQIDNWSRGDQR
MHGQDN-DNRKLSRWH]
=DPLHQLHPVL Z VXFKMX MDNL F]DVWHPX7ULVV
+LSRWH]DNRPLVMLEU]PLWHOHSRUW:LH \ 0HZ\E\F]\QQ\G]LDD.WR QLP
SU]HV]HGDHQHUJLDWHJRSU]HM FLDE\DWDNVLOQD H WHOHSRUWHNVSORGRZDLXOHJ
GHVWUXNFML
<HQQHIHUSRGM DSRFKZLOL7ULVVPXVLDDVL R W\PGRZLHG]LH2W\PFR
Z\NU\DNRPLVMD5DGFOLIIH
D&RXPLH FLDZWDMQ\PUDSRUFLH,VWQLHMHPLDQRZLFLH
V]DQVD&LH V]DQV\ H &LULXGDRVL EH]SLHF]QLHSU]HM SRUWDOHP7RU/DUD H
XPNQ DSU]HG1LOIJDDUGHPLSU]HG9LOJHIRUW]HP
*G]LH WHG\VL ]QDMGXMH"
7H FKFLDDE\PWRZLHG]LH
%\RGLDEHOQLHFLHPQRVNU\W\]D]ZDDPLFKPXUNVL \FZRJyOHQLHGDZD
ZLDWD:SRUyZQDQLXGRSRSU]HGQLFKQRFE\DMHGQDNZ\M WNRZRPDRZLHWU]QDL
G]L NLWHPXQLHWDN]LPQD&]yQROHNNRW\ONRNR\VDRVL QDSRPDUV]F]RQHM
IDONDPLSRZLHU]FKQLZRG\3DFKQLDREDJQHP%XWZLHM F\P]LHOVNLHP,
Z JRU]\P OX]HP
*G]LH SRGEU]HJLHPEyEUVWU]HOLRJRQHPRZRG WDN H RERMHSRGVNRF]\OL
&LULE\DSHZQD H 9\VRJRWD]DGU]HPDDEyEUJRREXG]L
2SRZLDGDMGDOHMSRZLHG]LDDZ\FLHUDM F QRVF]\VW QLHSRNU\W MHV]F]H
OX]HPF] FL U NDZD1LH SLM*G\W\SU]\V\SLDV]PQLHUyZQLH RF]\VL
NOHM MHV]F]HSU G QDV]QLHVLHLREXG]LP\VL QDPRU]X2SRZLDGDMGDOHMRW\FK
WHOHSRUWDFK
8FLHNDM F ]7KDQHGGSRGM SXVWHOQLNSU]HV]D SU]H]SRUWDO:LH \ 0HZ\
7RU/DUD$*HRIIUH\0RQFNQDMZL NV]\FK\EDDXWRU\WHWZNZHVWLLWHOHSRUWDFML
DXWRUG]LHD]DW\WXRZDQHJR0DJLD6WDUV]HJR/XGXE G FHJRRSXVPDJQXP
ZLHG]\RHOILFKWHOHSRUWDFKSLV]H H SRUWDO7RU/DUDZLHG]LHGR:LH \ -DVNyNL
7RU=LUHDHO
7HOHSRUW]7KDQHGGE\VSDF]RQ\SU]HUZDD&LUL0R H GDZQLHMQLPVL
SRSVXWRZLyGGRMDNLHM MDVNyNL$OHWHUD]ZLHG]LHQDSXVW\QL 7RVL QD]\ZD
SRUWDOFKDRW\F]Q\8F]\DPVL R W\P
-DZ\REUD VRELHWH SDUVNQ VWDUXV]HN:LHOH]W\FKQDXNSDPL WDP
'ODWHJRWH WDN]GXPLHZDPQLHWZRMDRSRZLH 1LHNWyUHMHMIUDJPHQW\:D QLH
WHNWyUHGRW\F] WHOHSRUWDFML
0R HV]PyZLMD QLHM"
0RJ &LUL0RJ $OHWHUD]F]DVQDMZ\ V]\Z\FL JQ DN-X SHZQLH
QDOD]RGRQLHJRZ JRU]\*RWRZD"
*RWRZD&LULSRSOXWDZGRQLHLFKZ\FLDERVDN9\VRJRWDXM ]DPNQ F\Z
ZRG]LHV]QXU
:\FL JDP\5D]GZDWU]\,GRRG]LDSMH&LULDS'RNRV]DER
SRXFLHNDM
PLHMVFD"
7XSRND]DNR FLVW\PSDOFHP&]\WDMQDJRV
']LZDF]Q\PM ]\NLHPSLVDWHQFD\%X\YLG$VVHQJDUGWRE\FK\EDMDNL
]DPHNMH OLVL QLHP\O $OHFRWR]DNUDLQD6WRMH]LRU\"1LJG\RWDNLHMQLH
V\V]DDP,FRWRMHVWWULIROLXP"
.RQLF]\QND$R$VVHQJDUG]LHL6WXMH]LRUDFKRSRZLHPFLJG\GRNR F]\V]
F]\WDQLD
,MDNR \ZROHGZLHHOI$\DOODF
KRQHVRZDZ\U]HNMDNZ\ELHJOLVSRGZyG
MH]LRUQ\FKSWDV]NRZLHRZLPDOLLF]DUQLFRVL QDGQLHRGP WXFD ]LP SU]HG
PUR]HPFKURQLOL$OERZLHPMDVNyNDMDNWRZLHG] OXG]LHXF]HQLWU\EHPLQQ\FK
SWDNyZQDZ\UDMQLHOHFLLZLRVQ QLHSRZUDFDOHF]SD]XUNDPLZZLHONLHNXS\VL
SRV]F]HSLDZV]\QDGQRZyG]DSDGDWDPFD ]LPRZ SRU SU]HS G]DLGRSLHUR
ZLRVQ VSyGZyGGHSURIXQGLVZ\ODWD-HVWDWROLWHQSWDNQLHW\ONRZLRVQ\LQDG]LHL
V\PEROHPDOHLF]\VWR FLQLHVNDODQHMZ]RUHPDOERZLHPQD]LHPLQLJG\QLH
VLDG\ZDL]]LHPVNLPEUXGHPLSOXJDVWZHPVW\F]QR FLQLMDNLHMQLHPD
:UyP\MHGQDNR GRMH]LRUDQDV]HJRNU F\SWDV]NRZLHPJ U]HNE\
VNU]\GHF]NDPLVZHPLUR]SURV]\OLERWDQGHPQLHVSRG]LDQLHZ\RQLDVL ] PJ\
ZLH \FDFXGRZQDF]DUQRNVL VNDDP\ P\MHGQ\PZHVWFKQ OLSRG]LZXJRVHPER
E\DRQDZLH \FDMDNRE\]RSDUXXWNDQDPJ\PDM FD]DIXQGDPHQWXPDXV]F]\WX
]ZLH F]RQDO QLHQLHP]RU]\F]DUQRNVL VN DXURUDERUHDOLV=DLVWHSRW Q
PDJLF]Q V]WXN PXVLDDE\RZDZLH D ]EXGRZDQDSRQDGOXG]NLH]UR]XPLHQLH
6SRVWU]HJQDV] DGPLUDF\M HOI$UDOODF
KLU]HN
2WR7RU=LUHDHO:LH D -DVNyNL2WR%UDPD ZLDWyZL:URWD&]DVX1DFLHV]
F]RZLHNXRF]\W\PZLGRNLHPERQLHND GHPXLQLH]DZ G\E\ZDRQGDQ\
3\WDQ\]D D]DOLSU]\EOL \VL PR QDL]EOLVNDQDRZ :LH SRJO GQ DOER
SURSULDPDQXGRWNQ ]D PLDVL $YDOODF
K7RU=LUHDHOU]HNWRGODZDV
PDU]HQLHVHQQHQLHGRW\NDVL PDU]HQLD,GREU]HWRGREDZLODOERZLHP:LH D
VX \ MHG\QLH:LHG] F\PLQLHOLF]Q\P:\EUDQ\PGODNWyU\FK:URWD&]DVXV
EUDPDPLQDG]LHLLRGURG]HQLD$OHGODSURIDQyZV WREUDP\NRV]PDUX
/HGZLHWHVRZDZ\U]HNRSDG\]QRZXPJ\LSURVSHNWXRZHJRF]DURZQHJR
RF]RPQDV]\PRGPyZL\
.UDLQD6WRMH]LRU\Z\MD QL9\VRJRWDG]LVLDMQD]\ZDVL 0LO7UDFKWD-HVWWR
EDUG]RUR]OHJHSU]HFL WHU]HN <HOHQ SRMH]LHU]HZSyQRFQHMF] FL0HWLQQ\
EOLVNRJUDQLF\]1D]DLUHPL0DJ7XUJD%X\\LG%DFNKX\VHQSLV]H H V]OLNX
MH]LRUX]SyQRF\RGVWURQ\$VVHQJDUGX']L QLHPDMX $VVHQJDUGX]RVWD\
W\ONRUXLQ\QDMEOL V]\PPLDVWHPMHVW1HXQUHXWK%X\YLGZ\OLF]\RG$VVHQJDUGX
V]H VHWVWDMD 5y QHVWDMDQLDE\ZD\ZX \FLXDOHSU]\MPLMP\QDMSRSXODUQLHMV]
UDFKXE ]JRGQLH]NWyU V]H VHWVWDMD GDMHQDRNU JRSL G]LHVL W PLO1D
SRXGQLHRG$VVHQJDUGXNWyU\RGQDVRG3HUHSOXWXRGGDORQ\MHVWRMDNLH WU]\VWD
SL G]LHVL W PLO,QDF]HMPyZL FRG:LH \ -DVNyNLRGG]LHODFL SOXVPLQXVWU]\VWD
-DNFLLG]LH"2SRZLDGDM<HQQHIHU
:SLHUZW\RGSRZLHG]PLQDS\WDQLHNLPV GZLHNRELHW\NWyUHQLH]PLHQQLH
VSRW\NDPJG\LG GRFLHELH"$NWyUH]DZV]HREGDU]DM PQLHVSRMU]HQLDPL
QRUPDOQLH]DUH]HUZRZDQ\PLGODOH FHJRQDG\ZDQLHNRFLHJRJyZQD".LPRQH
V "
&]\LQWHUHVXMHFL VWDQIRUPDOQRSUDZQ\F]\IDNW\F]Q\"
7HQGUXJL
:WDNLPUD]LHWRV PRMH RQ\
5R]XPLHP:\MD QLMLPPR H SU]\VSRVREQR FL H FRE\RDQLHMHVWQLH
SLV]HVL Z UHMHVWU
:\MD QLDHP$OHEDE\MDNWREDE\0QLHMV]D]W\P2SRZLDGDM<HQQHIHU
,QWHUHVXM PQLHSRVW S\ZWZHMSUDF\
$OERMHGQRLGUXJLH
:LHG]LDD]JU]\WQ ] EDPL&UDFK$OHGDOHMURELDVZRMH%RWRPLDDE\
SU]\Q WD"2QDVDPDPLDDE\SU]\Q W " 8GDZDD H ZLHZL FHMQL ZLHG]LDDE\
VSURZRNRZDZURJD",SRS\Q DQD* EL 6HGQ\
5]XFDM F Z\]ZDQLH3URZRNXM F6WUDV]QLHU\]\NRZDD&UDFK
:LHP1LHFKFLDDQDUD DQLNRJR]QDV3R]DRFKRWQLNDPL'ODWHJRSRSURVLD
R GZDGUDNNDU\
0DPGODFLHELHGZDGUDNNDU\RNWyUHSURVLD $ON\RQHL7DPDU ,
GUX \Q PDVL UR]XPLH$ON\RQHGRZRG]LE G]LH*XWKODIV\Q6YHQDSURVLR
WHQ]DV]F]\WSU]\SDGD PXGRJXVWX<HQQHIHU7DPDU GRZRG]L$VD7KMD]L
NDSLWDQGRNWyUHJRPDPDEVROXWQH]DXIDQLH$KDE\E\P]DSRPQLD:]DRG]H
7DPDU\E G]LHWH PyMV\Q+MDOPDU.U]\ZRJ E\
7ZyMV\Q",OHPDODW"
']LHZL WQD FLH
:F]H QLH]DF]\QDH
3U]\JDUQ NRFLRJDUQNRZL+MDOPDUSURVLRZ F]HQLHJRGR]DRJL]
SRZRGyZRVRELVW\FK1LHPRJHPRGPyZL
=SRZRGyZRVRELVW\FK"
1DSUDZG QLH]QDV]WHMKLVWRULL"
1LH2SRZLHG]
&UDFKDQ&UDLWHZ\FK\OLUyJ]D PLDVL GRVZRLFKZVSRPQLH
']LHFLDNL]$UG6NHOOLJ]DF] XZLHOELDM ]LP EDZLVL QD\ ZDFK
GRF]HNDVL QLHPRJ QDPUy]3LHUZV]HZ\D QDOyGOHGZRVNXMHMH]LRURQD
WDIO WDNFLHQN H GRURV\FKE\QLHXWU]\PDD0DVL UR]XPLHQDMOHSV] ]DEDZ
V Z\ FLJL5R]S G]LVL L JQDLOHVL]MHGQHJRNUD FDMH]LRUDQDGUXJL
&KRSDNL]D XU] G]DM ]DZRG\ZWDN]ZDQ\PVNRNXRVRVLD3ROHJDWRQD
VNDNDQLXQD\ ZDFKSU]H]SU]\EU]H QHVNDNLVWHUF] FH]ORGXMDNUHNLQLH] E\
7DNMDNRVR JG\VNDF]HSU]H]SURJLZRGRVSDGyZ:\ELHUDVL RGSRZLHGQLR
GXJLU] G WDNLFKNDPLHQLELHU]HUR]S G+DVDPWDNVNDNDHPMDNRVPDUNDF]
&UDFKDQ&UDLWH]DGXPDVL X PLHFKQ OHNNR
2F]\ZLVWDSRGM WDNLH]DZRG\Z\JU\ZDLSXV]\VL SRWHPMDNSDZWHQ
NWRSU]HVNRF]\QDMGX V]\U] G JD]yZ:VZRLPF]DVLH<HQQHIHUWHQ]DV]F]\W
F] VWRSU]\SDGDWZHPXXQL RQHPXVXG]HLREHFQHPXUR]PyZF\KHKH:
F]DVLHNWyU\QDVEDUG]LHMLQWHUHVXMHF]HPSLRQHPE\ZDPyMV\Q+MDOPDU6NDND
SU]H]WDNLHNDPLHQLHSU]H]NWyUH DGHQ]FKRSDNyZQLHR PLHODVL VNRF]\,
FKRG]L]]DGDUW\PQRVHPZ\]\ZDM F ZV]\DWNLFKE\SUyERZDOLJRSRNRQD,
SRGM WRMHJRZ\]ZDQLH&LULFyUND3DYHWW\]&LQWU\1DZHWQLHZ\VSLDUNDFKRVL
]DWDN XZD DDMDNR H VS G]DDWXZL FHMF]DVXQL Z &LQWU]H
1DZHWSRZ\SDGNX3DYHWW\"0\ ODDP H &DODQWKH]DEURQLDMHMWXE\ZD"
:LHV]RW\P"VSRMU]DQDQL E\VWUR1RWDNW\GX R ZLHV]<HQQHIHU
'X R*QLHZL]DND]\&DODQWKHQLHWUZD\GX HMQL SyURNXSRWHP&LUL]QRZX
]DF] DVS G]DWXODWDL]LP\1D\ ZDFKMH G]LDMDNF]DUWDOH HE\VNDND
RVRVLHPZ]DZRG\]FKRSDNDPL",Z\]\ZD+MDOPDUD":JRZLHVL QLH
PLH FLR
6NRF]\DGRP\ OLDVL F]DURG]LHMND
6LHG] F\SU]HGMDUOHPNDSLWDQ$VD7KMD]LE\QLHVSRNRMQ\2EOL]\ZDZDUJL
ZLHUFLVL QDDZLHZ\DP\ZDSDOFHWDN H D VWU]HOD\NQ\NFLH
&]HUZRQHVLRQFHZ\UZDZV]\VL QDUHV]FLH]]DOHJDM F\FKQLHERFKPXUSRZROL
RSXV]F]DRVL QDG6SLNHURRJ
*DGDM$VDUR]ND]D*UDFKDQ&UDLWH$VD7KMD]LRGFKU] NQ PRFQR
6]OL P\RVWURSRGM ZLDWUVSU]\MDURELOL P\GREUHGZDQD FLHZ ]yZ
7HG\MX GZXG]LHVWHJRG]LHZL WHJRXMU]HOL P\QRF ZLDWRODWDUQL]3HL[HGH0DU
2GELOL P\QLHFRQD]DFKyGE\QLHQDSDWRF]\VL QDMDNLHJR1LOIJDDUGF]\ND$
QDG]LH SU]HGZU]H QLRZ\PQRZLHPR ZLFLHSU]\S\Q OL P\ZUHMRQ* EL
6HGQ\:WHQF]DVF]DURG]LHMNDZH]ZDDPQLHL*XWKODID
3RWU]HEXM RFKRWQLNyZSRZLHG]LDD<HQQHIHU7\ONRRFKRWQLNyZ1LH
ZL FHMQL WRNRQLHF]QHE\SU]H]NUyWNLF]DVVWHURZDGUDNNDUHP1LHZLHPLOX
GRWHJRSRWU]HEDOXG]LQLH]QDPVL QDW\P$OHSURV] E\QLH]RVWDZLQD
$ON\RQHQDZHWMHGQHJRF]RZLHNDSRQDGNRQLHF]Q OLF]E ,SRZWDU]DPVDPL
RFKRWQLF\7RFR]DPLHU]DP]URELMHVWEDUG]RU\]\NRZQH%DUG]LHMQL PRUVND
ELWZD
3RMPXM NLZQ JRZ VWDU\VHQHV]DO,]JDV]DPVL SLHUZV]\-D*XWKODI
V\Q6YHQDSURV] R WHQ]DV]F]\WSDQL
<HQQHIHUGXJRSDWU]\DPXZRF]\
'REU]HSRZLHG]LDD$]DV]F]\FRQDMHVWHPMD
7H VL ]JRVLHPSRZLHG]LD$VD7KMD]L$OH*XWKODIVL QLH]JRG]L.WR
U]HNPXVLNRPHQG WU]\PDQD7DPDU]H:UH]XOWDFLH]JRVLRVL SL WQDVWX:
W\P+MDKQDUMDUOX
&UDFKDQ&UDLWHXQLyVEUZL
,OXSRWU]HED*XWKODI"SRZWyU]\DF]DURG]LHMNDLOXMHVWQLH]E GQ\FK"
3URV] E\ WRSUHF\]\MQLHZ\OLF]\6HQHV]DOPLOF]DF]DVMDNL NDONXORZD
:R PLXGDP\UDG U]HNZUHV]FLH-H OLQLH]DGXJR$OHSU]HFLHFLWXWDM
WRVDPLRFKRWQLF\QLHPDWHG\PXVX
:\]QDF]R PLXVSR UyGW\FKSL WQDVWXSU]HUZDDRVWUR:\]QDF]VDP,ND
Z\EUDQ\PSU]HM QD$ON\RQH5HV]WD]RVWDMHQD7DPDU]H$KDMHGQHJRNWyU\
]RVWDMHZ\]QDF] MD+MDOPDU
2SRZLDGDM$VD
0DJLF]ND*XWKODIDRZDyVHPNDRFKRWQLNyZZHV]OLQD$ON\RQHL
SR HJORZDOLQD* EL 0\ P\QD7DPDU]HZHGOHUR]ND]XQDXERF]XVL
WU]\PDOLDOHWDNE\]DQDGWRQLHRGVWD=SRJRG ]D NWyUDGRWHMSRU\QDGSRG]LZ
QDPVSU]\MDDMDNLH GLDEHOVWZR]DF] RVL QDJOHG]LD7DNL FLHGREU]HJDGDP
H GLDEHOVWZRERQLHF]\VWDWRE\DVLDMDUOX1LHFKPQLHSRGVW SN SU]HFL JQ
MH OL
2SRZLDGDM
7DPJG]LHP\ P\E\OL7DPDUD]QDF]\VSRNRMQLHE\R&KRZLFKHUWURFK
ZLV]F]DLQLHERVNRQSRFLHPQLDRGFKPXUWDN H ]GQLDQRFVL QLHPDOXF]\QLD
$OHWDPJG]LHE\D$ON\RQHWDPSLHNRVL UR]S WDR]QLHQDFND3LHNR
SUDZG]LZH
DJLHO$ON\RQH]DRSRWDQDJOHWDNJZDWRZQLH H V\V]HOLWRRSRWDQLHPLPR
G]LHO FHMGUDNNDU\RGOHJR FL1LHERSRF]HUQLDRFKPXU\VN EL\VL 0RU]HNWyUH
ZRNy7DPDU\Z\GDZDRVL ]XSHQLHVSRNRMQHZ]EXU]\RVL L ]DJRWRZDR
JU]\ZDF]DPLSU]\EXUWDFK$ON\RQH.WR NU]\NQ QDJOHNWR ]DZWyURZDDSR
FKZLOLNU]\F]HOLZV]\VF\
3RGJRG] F\PZQL VWR NLHPF]DUQ\FKFKPXU$ON\RQHWD F]\DQDIDOLMDN
NRUHNNU F F VL ZLUXM F LSRGVNDNXM F]DSDGDM F ZIDOHMX WRG]LREHPMX WR
UXI 0RPHQWDPLGUDNNDU]XSHQLHQLHPDO]QLNDLP]RF]X0RPHQWDPLZLGD
E\RW\ONRSDVLDVW\ DJLHO
7RF]DU\Z\ZU]HV]F]DNWR ]DSOHFDPL$V\7RGLDEHOVNDPDJLD
:LUNU FL$ON\RQHFRUD]V]\EFLHMLV]\EFLHM7DUF]HRGU\ZDQHVL
RG URGNRZ RGEXUWGUDNNDUD]DIXUF]D\ZSRZLHWU]XMDNG\VNLIUXQ \QDSUDZRL
OHZRSRWU]DVNDQHZLRVD
5HIXM DJLHOZU]DVQ $VD7KMD]L,GRZLRVH3\QLHPWDP1DUDWXQHN
WU]D
%\RMX MHGQDN]DSy QR
1LHERQDG$ON\RQH]URELRVL F]DUQHF]HU HNVSORGRZDDQDJOH]\J]DNDPL
E\VNDZLFNWyUHRSORW\GUDNNDUQLF]\PPDFNLPHGX]\6N ELRQHZIDQWDVW\F]QH
NV]WDW\FKPXU\VNU FL\VL Z SRWZRUQ\OHM'UDNNDUNU FLVL Z NyNR]
QLHVDPRZLW SU GNR FL 0DV]WWU]DVQ MDN]DSDND]HUZDQ\ DJLHOSRPNQ QDG
JU]\ZDF]DPLQLE\RJURPQ\DOEDWURV
:LRVXMZLDUD
3U]H]ZDVQHZU]DVNLSRSU]H]]DJXV]DM F\ZV]\VWNRKXN \ZLRyZXV\V]HOL
MHGQDNNU]\NOXG]L]$ON\RQH.U]\NWDNQLHVDPRZLW\ H ZRV\VWDQ \LPG ED
,PVWDU\PZLONRPPRUVNLPNUZDZ\PEHUVHUNHURP HJODU]RPNWyU]\ZLG]LHOLL
V\V]HOLQLHMHGQR
3X FLOLZLRVD ZLDGRPLEH]VL\2VXSLDOLSU]HVWDOLQDZHWNU]\F]H
$ON\RQHZFL ZLUXM FSRZROLZ]QLRVDVL QDGIDOH,Z]QRVLDFRUD]Z\ HML
Z\ HM:LG]LHOLRFLHNDM F\ZRG REUR QL W\PXV]ODPLLJORQDPLNLO=REDF]\OL
F]DUQ\NV]WDWVSDGDM F Z IDOHV\OZHWN 3RWHPGUXJ ,WU]HFL
2QLVNDF] U\NQ $VD7KMD]L:LRVRZDFKRS\QLHXVWDZD&RVL
3\QLHP\QDSRPRF
$ON\RQHE\DMX GREUHVWRRNFLQDGEXOJRF] F MDNZU] WHNSRZLHU]FKQL
PRU]D1DGDOZLURZDDRJURPQHRFLHNDM FHZRG ZU]HFLRQRRSOHFLRQHRJQLVW
SDM F]\Q E\VNDZLFQLHZLG]LDOQ VL ZFL JDQHZVN ELRQHFKPXU\
1DJOHSRZLHWU]HUR]GDUD ZLGUXM FDXV]\HNVSOR]MD&KRSFKDQDGRSU]RGXVL
SL WQDVWXSDUZLRVH7DPDUDSRGVNRF]\DQDJOHLSROHFLDDZVWHF]MDN
VWDUDQRZDQD7KMD]LHPXSRNDGXFLHNVSRGQyJ8SDGXGHU]DM F VNURQL R EXUW
6DPQLHPyJZVWDSRGQLHVLRQRJR%\RV]RRPLRQ\NU FLLWU] VJRZ
]DWDF]DVL EHNRWDQLHVNDGQLH:U]DVNL]DRJLV\V]DMDN]]D FLDQ\3RGV]HG
GREXUW\FKZLHM F VL MDNSLMDQ\ZF]HSLSDOFHZUHOLQJ
:LFKHU FLFKIDOHXVSRNRL\VL $OHQLHERQDGDOE\RF]DUQHRGN EL F\FKVL
FKPXU
3R$ON\RQHQLH]RVWDRQDZHW ODGX
5R]G]LD
6XV]Q\PMHVWDE\QLHV]F] OLZ\FLHUSLD-HJREyOLXSRNRU]HQLDZ\QLNDM ]
SUDZQDWXU\DGODUHDOL]DFMLFHOyZQDWXU\SRWU]HEQHMHVW]DUyZQRLVWQLHQLH
FLHUSL FHJRMDNWH L W\FKNWyU]\SU]\VSDU]DM F PXVWUDSLH VDPLFLHV] VL
SRZRG]HQLDPL7DZD QLHSUDZGDSRZLQQDVWXPLZ\U]XWVXPLHQLDZGXV]\
W\UDQDF]\]RF]\ F\1LHPXVLVL SRZ FL JDZLQLHQGRSXV]F]DVL PLDR
ZV]\VWNLFKF]\QyZNWyUHURG] VL Z MHJRLPDJLQDFMLJG\ WRJRVQDWXU\PXMH
SRGVXZD
-H OLWDMHPQHLQVSLUDFMHQDWXU\ZLRG QDVGR]DWRZLGRF]QLH]RMHVWQDWXU]H
QLH]E GQH
'RQDWLHQ$OSKRQVH)UDQFRLVGH6DGH
+XNLV]F] N QDMSLHUZRWZLHUDQ\FKSRWHP]DP\NDQ\FKGU]ZLFHOL]EXG]L
PRGV] ] VLyVWU6FDUUD6WDUV]DVLHG]LDDSU]\VWROH]DM WDZ\VNURE\ZDQLHPNDV]\
SU]\VFKQL WHMGRGQDF\QRZHMPLVNL
1RLMDNE\RZV G]LH.HQQD"
-RDQQD6HOERPH]ZDQD.HQQ QLFQLHPyZL FXVLDGDQDSU\F]\RSDUWDRNFLH
R NRODQDDF]RRRGRQLH
0RGV]D6FDUUD]LHZQ DEHNQ DLSLHUGQ DJR QR3U]\FXSQL W\QD
SU]HFLZOHJHMSU\F]\.RKXWPUXNQ FR QLHZ\UD QLHLRGZUyFLJRZ %\
REUD RQ\QD.HQQ QDVLRVWU\LQDFD\ ZLDW
:]Z\N\FKZL ]LHQLDFKQDGDOWUDG\F\MQLHG]LHORQRDUHV]WDQWyZZHGXJSFL:
ZRMVNRZ\FKF\WDGHODFKE\RLQDF]HM-X FHVDU](PLUYDU(PUHLVSRWZLHUG]DM F
VSHFMDOQ\PGHNUHWHPUyZQRXSUDZQLHQLHNRELHWZDUPLLFHVDUVNLHM]DU] G]L H
MH HOLHPDQF\SDFMDWRHPDQF\SDFMDUyZQRXSUDZQLHQLHPDE\FD J E L QD
FD\PIURQFLHEH] DGQ\FKZ\M WNyZDQLVSHFMDOQ\FKSU]\ZLOHMyZGOD
NWyUHMNROZLHN]SFL2GWDPWHJRF]DVXZWZLHUG]DFKLF\WDGHODFKZL QLRZLH
VLHG]LHOLNRHGXNDF\MQLH
1RWRMDN"SRZWyU]\DVWDUV]D6FDUUD:\SXV]F]DM FL "
$NXUDWU]HNDJRU]NR.HQQDQDGDO]JRZ RSDUW R GRQLH% G PLDD
V]F] FLHMH OLQLHSRZLHV] &KROHUD=H]QDZDDPFD SUDZG QLF]HJRQLH
XNU\DPQRSUDZLHQLF]HJR]QDF]\VL $WHVXNLQV\Q\MDN]DF] \PQLH
PDJORZDWRQDMSLHUZLGLRWN ]HPQLHSU]HGZV]\VWNLPL]URELOLSRWHPRND]DR
VL HPMHVWRVREDQLHZLDU\JRGQDLHOHPHQWSU]HVW SF]\DQDVDP\PNR FX
Z\V]HGZVSyXG]LDZVSLVNXPDM F\PQDFHOXREDOHQLH
2EDOHQLHSRNLZDDJRZ VWDUV]D6FDUUD]XSHQLHMDNE\UR]XPLDDRFR
FKRG]L$DDMH OLREDOHQLH7RGXSDEODGD.HQQD
-DNE\PQLHZLHG]LDD
0RGV]D6FDUUDSU]HFL JQ DVL ]LHZQ D]QRZXV]HURNRLJR QRQLF]\P
ODPSDUFLFD]HVNRF]\D]JyUQHMSU\F]\HQHUJLF]Q\PNRSQLDNLHPXVXQ D
]DZDG]DM F\MHMWDERUHW.RKXWDVSOXQ DQDSRGRJ RERNWDERUHWX.RKXW
]DZDUF]DDOHQDQLFZL FHMVL QLHR PLHOL
.RKXWE\QD.HQQ PLHUWHOQLHREUD RQ\$VLyVWUVL ED
*G\SU]HGWU]HPDGQLDPLGRNZDWHURZDOLPX.HQQ GRFHOLU\FKRRND]DRVL
H .RKXWMH HOLZRJyOHGRSXV]F]DHPDQF\SDFM L UyZQRXSUDZQLHQLHNRELHWWRPD
QDWDVSUDZ\ZDVQHSRJO G\: URGNXQRF\]DU]XFL.HQQLHNRFQDJyUQ SRRZ
FLDDL]DPLHU]DSRVX \VL GROQ SRRZ FRSHZQLHE\PXVL XGDRJG\E\QLH
IDNW H WUDILQDHPSDWN .HQQDZGDUDPXVL GRPy]JXWDN H .RKXW]DZ\MDN
ZLONRDNL]DSO VDOSRFHOLMDNXN V]RQ\SU]H]WDUDQWXO .HQQD]D ] F]\VWHM
P FLZR FL]PXVLDJRWHOHSDW\F]QLHE\VWDQ QDF]ZRUDNDFKLU\WPLF]QLHZDOL
JRZ Z RELWHEODFK GU]ZLFHOL*G\]DDODUPRZDQLVWUDV]Q\PKXNLHPVWUD QLF\
RWZRU]\OLGU]ZL.RKXWWU\NQ MHGQHJR]QLFK]DFRGRVWDSL UD]yZRNXW SDN
L W\OH NRSQLDNyZ5HDVXPXM F.RKXWQLH]D]QDWHMQRF\UR]NRV]\QDNWyU
OLF]\,REUD]LVL QD.HQQ 2UHZDQ X QDZHWQLH PLDP\ OHERQD]DMXWU]GR
FHOLWUDIL\VLRVWU\6FDUUD3HSL NQDE\D]DWHPZSU]HZDG]HDQDGWRU\FKR
RND]DRVL H SRJO G\VLyVWUQDUyZQRXSUDZQLHQLHV ]EOL RQHGR.RKXWRZ\FK
W\OH H FDNLHPRGZURWQHMH OLLG]LHRSU]\SLVDQHSFLRPUROH0RGV]D6FDUUD
SDWU]\DQDP F]\]Q GUDSLH Q\PRNLHPLZ\JDV]DDQLHGZX]QDF]QH
NRPHQWDU]HDVWDUV]DUHFKRWDD]DFLHUDM F U FH(IHNWE\WDNL H .RKXWVSD]
WDERUHWHPNWyU\PZUD]LHF]HJR]DPLHU]DEURQLVZHJRKRQRUX
0DUQ PLDZV]HODNR V]DQV L ZLGRNLRELH6FDUUDVX \\ZZRMVNDFK
OLQLRZ\FKLE\\ZHWHUDQNDPLZLHOXELWHZWDERUHWXE\VL QLHXO N\MH OLFKFLD\
]JZDFLWR]JZDFL\QDZHWMH OLP F]\]QDE\X]EURMRQ\ZEHUG\V].HQQD
E\DMHGQDNSHZQD H VLRVWU\W\ONR DUWRZD\1RSUDZLHSHZQD
6LRVWU\6FDUUDVLHG]LD\ZSXGOH]DSRELFLHRILFHUDZVSUDZLHE G FHJR
SURZLDQWPDMVWUHP.RKXWDWUZDR]D OHG]WZR]ZL ]DQH]ZLHON V\QQ L
]DWDF]DM F FRUD]WRV]HUV]HNU JLDIHU ] NUDG]LH ZRMVNRZ\FKXNyZ
'XSDEODGD.HQQDSRZWyU]\DVWDUV]D6FDUUD:DGQ NDED ZSDNRZDD
VL ZWHG\$UDF]HMWRFLHELHZSDNRZDOL H VL WH GRGLDEDFL NLHJRQLH
SRDSDDZSRU H WRSROLW\F]QDJUD
%D
6FDUUDVSRMU]DDQDQL QLHEDUG]RZLHG] FMDNUR]XPLHMHGQRV\ODERZH
VWZLHUG]HQLH.HQQDXFLHNDZ]URNLHP
1LHSRZLHPZDPSU]HFLH WHJRFRSU]HPLOF]DDPSU]HGV G]LDPLSRP\ ODD
7HJR H ZLHG]LDDPZMDN JU VL ZSO WDDP$QLWHJRNLHG\LZMDNLVSRVyEVL
GRZLHG]LDDP
* VWHJRVRELHSLZDQDZDU]\D VWZLHUG]LDP GU]HPRGV]D6FDUUDWD
]QDF]QLHPQLHMUR]JDUQL WDNWyUD.HQQDE\DWHJRSHZQD]DJURV]QLH
UR]XPLDDZF]\PU]HF]
$MDNWRZNR FXE\R]W FLQWU\MVN NVL QLF]N " QLHUH]\JQRZDDVWDUV]D
6FDUUD3U]HFLH ZUHV]FLHFDSQ OL FLHM QLH"
&DSQ OL P\2LOHWDNWRPR QDQD]ZD.WyUHJRG]L PDP\"
'ZXG]LHVWHJRGUXJLHJRZU]H QLD-XWUR5yZQRQRF
+D2W]ELHJSU]\SDGNyZG]LZQ\7RMXWURE G]LHRGWDPW\FKZ\GDU]H UyZQR
URN-X URN
.HQQDZ\FL JQ DVL QDSU\F]\SRGNDGDM F VSOHFLRQHGRQLHSRGNDUN6LRVWU\
PLOF]D\ZQDG]LHL H E\WRZVW S GRRSRZLH FL
1LF]WHJRVLRVWU]\F]NLSRP\ ODD.HQQDSDWU] F QDQDED]JUDQHQDGHVNDFK
JyUQHMSU\F]\SOXJDZHU\VXQNLLMHV]F]HSOXJDZV]HQDSLV\1LHE G]LH DGQHM
RSRZLH FL1DZHWQLHZW\PU]HF] H PLHUG]LHO.RKXW PLHUG]LPL]DVUDQ\P
NDSXVLHPDOERLQQ\P ZLDGNLHPNRURQQ\P3RSURVWXQLHFKFHPLVL R W\PJDGD
1LHFKFHPLVL WHJRZVSRPLQD
7HJRFRE\RSU]HGURNLHP3RW\PMDN%RQKDUWZ\PNQ VL QDPZ
&ODUHPRQW
3U]\E\OL P\WDPGZDGQL]DSy QRSU]\SRPQLDDVRELHWURSMX ]G \
RVW\JQ 'RN G RZFDSRMHFKDQLNWQLHZLHG]LD1LNWRSUyF]NXSFD
+RXYHQDJKHOD]QDF]\VL $OH+RXYHQDJKHO]H6NHOOHQHPJDGDQLHFKFLDDQLJR
QDZHWSRGGDFKQLHZSX FL3U]H]VX E SU]HND]D H QLHPDF]DVXLDXGLHQFMLQLH
XG]LHOL3XV]F]\NG VDVL L ] \PDDOHFRPLDUREL"7RE\R(EELQJQLHPLD
WDNLHMMXU\VG\NFML$LQQ QDV] PRG QLHV]RVL ]D+RXYHQDJKHODZ]L ERRQ
PLDWDPZ&ODUHPRQWSU\ZDWQ DUPL DSU]HFLHQLHPR QDE\RZRMQ\
ZV]F]\QD
%RUHDV0XQZ V]\'DFUH6LOLIDQWL2OD+DUVKHLPSUyERZDOLSU]HNXSVWZD7LO
(FKUDGHHOILHMPDJLLMDF]XMQLDPLVXFKDDPP\ OLDOHQLHQDZLHOHVL WR]GDR
'RZLHG]LHOL P\VL DE\WHJR H %RQKDUWZ\MHFKD]PLDVWDSRXGQLRZ EUDP $
]DQLPZ\MHFKD
:&ODUHPRQWE\D ZL W\QNDPDOXWND]PRGU]HZLDPL3U]\SRXGQLRZHM
EUDPLHSU]\SODF\NXWDUJRZ\P3U]HGRGMD]GHP]&ODUHPRQW%RQKDUWQDW\P
SODF\NXSU]HGW ZL W\QN VNDWRZD)DON KDUDSHP1DRF]DFKZV]\VWNLFKWDN H
NDSDQyZ]WHM ZL W\QNL:\NU]\NLZD H XGRZRGQLMHMNWRMHVWMHMSDQHPL
ZDGF H RWRZLF]\M EDWRJLHPMDNFKFHDMDN]HFKFHWR]DZLF]\QD PLHU
ERQLNWVL ]DQL QLHXMPLHQLNWQLHGDSRPRF\DQLOXG]LHDQLERJRZLH
0RGV]D6FDUUDZ\JO GDDRNQHPZLV] F XF]HSLRQDNUDW6WDUV]DZ\MDGDD
NDV] ] PLVNL.RKXWZ]L WDERUHWSRR \VL L QDNU\NRFHP
5R]OHJVL G]ZRQ]NRUGHJDUG\ZDUWRZQLF\RNU]\NQ OLVL QDPXUDFK
.HQQDREUyFLDVL WZDU] NX FLDQLH
.LONDGQLSy QLHMVSRWNDOL P\VL SRP\ ODD-DL%RQKDUW7ZDU] Z WZDU]
3DWU]\DPZMHJRQLHOXG]NLHU\ELHRF]\RW\PMHGQ\PP\ O F MDNW G]LHZF]\Q
EL,ZP\ OLPX]DMU]DDP1DPRPHQW$E\RWRWDNMDNE\PJRZ ZVDG]LDZ
UR]JU]HEDQ PRJL
7RE\RZ(NZLQRNFMXP
$ZSU]HGG]LH GZXG]LHVWHJRGUXJLHJRZU]H QLD]RULHQWRZDDPVL H ZNU FL
VL PL G]\QDVQLHZLG\PND
6WHIDQ6NHOOHQNRURQHUFHVDUVNLZ\VXFKDQLHSU]HU\ZDM F$OH.HQQD
ZLG]LDDMDN]PLHQLDPXVL WZDU]
3RZWyU]6HOERUQHZ\FHG]L3RZWyU]ERQLHZLHU] ZDVQ\PXV]RP
2VWUR QLHSDQLHNRURQHUPUXNQ D8GDZDMFLHJQLHZQHJR H QLE\MDGR
ZDV]SUR E DZ\QLHSR]ZDODFLH'ODSR]RUX]QDF]\-DQLHP\O VL SHZQD
MHVWHP2GGZyFKGQLNU FLVL SU]\QDVMDNL QLHZLG\PND1LHZLG]LDOQ\V]SLHJ
3XV]F]\NWU]HEDE\RPXWRSU]\]QDE\E\VWU\DSDZORW
1LH6HOERUQHRGPDZLDPU]HNJR QRDOHXQLNDM F DNWRUVNLHMSU]HVDG\WDNZ
WRQLHMDNLZPLQLH'\VF\SOLQDRERZL ]XMHZV]\VWNLFK1LHPDZ\M WNyZ1LH
Z\UD DP]JRG\
5DF]FLH FKRFLD Z\VXFKDSDQLHNRURQHU.HQQDQLHPLDDWDOHQWX
3XV]F]\NDQLHXQLNQ DV]WXF]QR FLDOHZRGJU\ZDQHMVFHQFHV]WXF]QR L
]DNRSRWDQLHSHWHQWNLE\\GRSU]\M FLD5DF]FLH FKRFLD Z\VXFKD
0yZ6HOERUQH%\OHNUyWNRL]ZL OH
6]SLHJXMHQDVRGGZyFKGQLZ\PUXF]DDXGDM F H XQL HQLHZ\NDGDVZH
UDFMH2G&ODUHPRQW0XVLMHG]LH]DQDPLWDMQLHDQDELZDNDFKSU]\FKRG]L
QLHZLG]LDOQ\NU FLVL Z UyGOXG]LVXFKD
6XFKDV]SLHJFKROHUQ\6NHOOHQQLHPXVLDXGDZDVXURZHJRL
UR]JQLHZDQHJRZMHJRJRVLHZU F]ZLEURZDDZ FLHNR -DNJRZ\NU\D "
-DNH FLHSU]HGZF]RUDMSU]HGNDUF]P Z\GDZDOLUR]ND]\SDQX6LOLIDQWRZL
NRFXUFRQDDZLHVSD]DV\F]DLXV]\SRR \3RGHMU]DQHPLVL WR]GDRER
QLNRJRQLHE\RZWHMVWURPH$SRWHPFR Z\F]XMQLDPP\ O MDNE\REF P\ O L
ZRO *G\GRRNRDVDPHVZRMVNLHP\ OL]Z\F]DMQHWRGODPQLHWDNDREFDP\ O
SDQLHNRURQHUWRMDNE\NWRNU]\NQ JR QR=DF] DPEDF]\PRFQRZ
GZyMQDVyELZ\F]XZDPJR
0R HV]JR]DZV]HZ\F]X"
1LH1LH]DZV]H0DMDN PDJLF]Q RFKURQ &]XM JRW\ONR]EDUG]REOLVNDD
L WRQLH]DND G\PUD]HP'ODWHJRWU]DGDZDSR]yUERQLHZLDGRPRF]\DNXUDW
QLHNU\MHVL Z SREOL X
%\OHJRQLHVSRV]\Z\FHG]L3XV]F]\N%\OHJRQLHVSRV]\-DJRFKF
\Z\P6HOERPH&RSURSRQXMHV]"
=URELP\JRQDSLHURJD
1DSLHURJD"
&LV]HMSDQLHNRURQHU
$OH$FKQLHZD QH'REUD'DM FLZROQ U N
-XWURVSUDZFLHE\ P\VWDQ OLZMDNLHM ZVLQDNZDWHU -DMX UHV]W ]DDWZL
$ WHUD]GODSR]RUX]EXUF]FLHPQLHVURJRDMDRGHMG
1LMDNPLEXUF]HX PLHFKQ VL GRQLHMRF]DPLLPUXJQ OHNNRQDW\FKPLDVW
SU]\ELHUDM F QDG W PLQ VXURZHJRGRZyGF\%R]DGRZRORQ\MHVWHP]SDQLSDQL
6HOERUQH
3RZLHG]LDSDQL3DQL6HOERPH-DNGRRILFHUD
0UXJQ ]QRZX
8GHU]\G]ZRQNRUGHJDUG\V\JQD]PLDQ\ZDUW\6LRVWU\6FDUUDFKUDSD\
PHORG\MQLH.RKXWPODVNDSU]H]VHQREHMPXM F WDERUHW
*UD]XFKDSU]\SRPQLDDVRELH.HQQDXGDZDRGZD QHJRWHQFD\5LHQFH
&]DURZQLN5LHQFH]URELRQ\QDSLHURJDLSU]\ZL ]DQ\GRVWRRZ\FKQyJ]JR\PL
SL WDPLZJyU]H*UD]XFKDDOHQLHRV]XNDQLNRJRDPQLHMX QDMPQLHM3XV]F]\N
XSU]HG]L H WRF]DURZQLNPLHV]DDPPXZL F P\ OLE\QLHPyJF]DURZDDQL
Z]\ZDPDJLF]QHMSRPRF\3U]\RND]MLF]\WDDPJR%URQLGRVW SXDOHJG\
SRQLXFKDG\PXZ JOLSDOHQLVNDZNWyU\PUR]JU]HZD\VL HOD]DMHJRPDJLF]QH
RFKURQ\LEORNDG\SX FL\QDZV]\VWNLFKV]ZDFKMDNVWDUHJDFLHDMDPRJDPJR
F]\WDSRGXJZROL-HJRP\ OLQLF]\PQLHUy QL\VL RGP\ OLLQQ\FKNWyU\FK
F]\WDDPZWDNLFKVDP\FKV\WXDFMDFK0\ OLOXG]LNWyU\FK]DFKZLO E G
WRUWXURZD0\ OLUR]SLHU]FKHUR]G\JRWDQHSHQHVWUDFKXLUR]SDF]\0\ OL
]LPQHR OL]JHPRNUHLFXFKQ FH-DNZQ WU]QR FLWUXSD
0LPRWHJRJG\Z\FL JQL WRPXNQHEHOF]DURZQLN5LHQFHSUyERZDXGDZD
]XFKD
'LDEHLFKFK\ED]HVDGREU\SDQLHSXVWHOQLNXZ\PUXF]DFKRS
SU]HU\ZDM F QDFKZLO OLF]HQLHVNyUHN'LDEHFK\ED2GVDPHJR=UyZQDQLDSR
ODVDFKJDQLDOLMDNLHM G]LHZNLV]XNDOL6WUDV]\OLNU]\NDOLJUR]LOLDOH]DUD]GDOHM
MHFKDOLQLH]G \OLVL QLJG\]DQDGWRQDSU]\NU]\$OHWHUDLQV] LQV]R
Z\GXPDOLRVWDZLOLSRQLHNWyU\FKZVLDFKLRVDGDFKMDNLH MDNWR3XVWHUXQNLF]\
MDNR WDN1LMDNLHWRQLHV UXQNLGREU\SDQLHDQLSXVWHDQLSHQHMHQR]Z\F]DMQLH
WU]HFKDOERF]WHUHFKRWUyZV]XEUDZ\FKXWUDSLHQLHMHGQR3RQRE G FD ]LP WDN
F]DWRZDF]\G]LHZNDNWyU FLJDM QLHZ\FK\OLVL VN GVL ] XNU\FLDLGRZVLQLH
]DMU]\:WHQF]DVPDM WHQSXVW\UXQHNFK\WQ
8ZDVWH V "
&KRSVSRFKPXUQLD]D]JU]\WD] EDPL
8QDVQLH0LHOLPV]F] FLH$OHZ'XQ'DUHSyGQLDRGQDVVLHG]LF]WHUHFK
: NDUF]PLHQDZ\VLyNXNZDWHUXM RWU\GREU\SDQLHSXVWHOQLNXRWU\]DWUDFRQH
SDVNXGQLNL'RG]LHZHNVL EUDOLDMDNVL LPFKRS\SRVWDZL\WRXELOLSDQLH
GREU\EH]OLWR FL1D PLHU
=DELOLOXG]L"
'ZyFK6RW\VDLMHV]F]HMHGQHJR,MHVWWRNDUDQDWDNLFKSDQLHGREU\
KXOWDMyZ"-HVWSUDZR"1LHPDV]NDU\QLSUDZD-HGHQVWHOPDFKFRGRQDV]'XQ
'DUH] RQ L FyUN XV]HGU]HNDSU\E\OLGU]HZLHMQD ZLHFLHZLHG PLQL2QL
SRU] GHN]ZV]HODNLPRWURVWZHPF]\QLOL:H]ZDE\GR'XQ'DUHZLHG PLQDFR
E\W\FKV]HOPyZZ\W SL
:LHG PLQL]DELMDOLSRWZRU\QLHOXG]L
7RRWU\GREU\SDQLHSXVWHOQLNXQLH DGQHOXG]LHMHQRRWU\]SLHNDZ\OD]R
:LHG PLQDQDQLFKWU]DU\FKW\NZLHG PLQD1RDOHPQLHZGURJ F]DVGREU\
SDQLHSXVWHOQLNX8FKLG]LH]LPQR6NRURF]yQRFKRZDMDVDQLHZ\FL JDM$QD
RWUyZ]'XQ'DUHSDQLHGREU\ZLHG PLQDWU]D
3U]\ZLHF]HU]\SRVSU]HF]DOLVL ]QRZX
=GDMHV]VL GX R ZLHG]LHRSUREOHPDFKGREUDL]D
%RZLHP,WRQLH]XQLZHUV\WHFNLFKNVL J
1LHRF]\ZL FLH7\ZV]\VWNRZLHV]]ZDVQHJRGR ZLDGF]HQLD=SUDNW\NL
=GRE\D ZV]DNPQyVWZRGR ZLDGF]H Z WZ\PGXJLPV]HVQDVWROHWQLP \FLX
'R LFK]GRE\DP:\VWDUF]DM FRGX R
*UDWXOXM .ROH DQNRXF]RQD
7\VRELHGUZLV]]DFLVQ D] E\QDZHWSU]HGVWDZLHQLDQLHPDM FLOH
QLHGREUHJRQDURELOL FLH ZLDWXZ\]G]LDG]LDOLXF]HQLWHRUHW\F\]ZDV]\PL
NVL JDPL]HVWXOHWQLPGR ZLDGF]HQLHPF]\WDQLDWUDNWDWyZPRUDOQ\FKWDN
VXPLHQQLH H QLHPLHOL FLHF]DVXQDZHW]RNQD]REDF]\MDNQDSUDZG ZLDW
Z\JO GD:\ILOR]RIRZLHV]WXF]QLHSRGWU]\PXM F\V]WXF]QHILOR]RILHE\EUD
SHQVMHQDXQLZHUV\WHWDFK$ H SLHV]NXODZ QRJ QLH]DSDFLE\ZDP]DEU]\GN
SUDZG R ZLHFLHZ\P\ OLOL FLHHW\N L PRUDOQR QDXNLDGQHLRSW\PLVW\F]QH
7\OH H ]HJDQHLV]DFKUDMVNLH
1LFEDUG]LHMV]DFKUDMVNLHJRQDGQLHSU]HP\ ODQ\RV GVPDUNXOR1DG
SRVSLHV]QHLQLHUR]ZD QHZ\URNRZDQLH
1LH]QDOH OL FLHUHPHGLXPQD]R$MDVPDUNDWDZLHG PLQN ]QDOD]DP
1LH]DZRGQHUHPHGLXP
1LHRGSRZLHG]LDDOHWZDU]PXVLDDJR]GUDG]LER&LULJZDWRZQLH]HUZDDVL
]]DVWRX
8ZD DV] H Z\JDGXM JXSVWZD" H PyZL QDZLDWU"
8ZD DPRGU]HNVSRNRMQLH H PyZLV]ZUR]GUD QLHQLX8ZD DP H
SODQXMHV]]HPVW Z UR]GUD QLHQLX,JRU FRFL QDPDZLDPE\ VL XVSRNRLD
-DMHVWHPVSRNRMQD$]HPVWD"2GSRZLHG]PLGODF]HJRQLH"'ODF]HJRPDP
UH]\JQRZD]]HPVW\":LPL F]HJR":\ V]\FKUDFML"$Fy Z\ V]HJRQDG
SRU] GHNU]HF]\ZNWyU\P]HXF]\QNLV NDUDQH"'ODFLHELHILOR]RILHLHW\NX
]HPVWDWRF]\QQLHODGQ\QDJDQQ\QLHHW\F]Q\ZUHV]FLHEH]SUDZQ\$MDS\WDP
JG]LHNDUD]D]R".WRPDM VWZLHUG]LRU]HFLZ\PLHU]\".WR"%RJRZLHZ
NWyU\FKQLHZLHU]\V]":LHONLGHPLXUJVWZyUFDNWyU\PSRVWDQRZLH ERJyZ
]DVW SL"$PR H SUDZR"0R H QLOIJDDUG]NDVSUDZLHGOLZR FHVDUVNLHV G\
SUHIHNFL"7\QDLZQ\VWDUF]H
$ZL F RNR]DRNR] E ]D] E".UHZ]DNUHZ"$]DW NUHZQDVW SQDNUHZ"
0RU]HNUZL"&KFHV] ZLDWZHNUZLXWRSL"1DLZQDVNU]\ZG]RQDG]LHZF]\QR"
7DNFKFHV]ZDOF]\]H]HPZLHG PLQNR"
7DN:D QLHWDN%RMDZLHPF]HJR=RVL O ND1LHHW\NLWZRMHM9\VRJRWR
QLHND]D QLHPRUDOQ\FKWUDNWDWyZRSRF]FLZ\P \FLX=REyOXVL O NDNDOHFWZD
FLHUSLHQLD PLHUFLZUHV]FLH=UDQLRQH=RZ\MH]EyOXMDNSLHV7DU]DVL QD
SRGRG]HLNZLF]\SDWU] FMDNNUHZFKOXVWD] \LDUWHULLZLG] F VWHUF] FH]
NLNXWyZNR FLZLG] F NLV]NLZ\SH]DM FH]EU]XFKDF]XM FMDNZUD]]]LPQHP
QDGFKRG]L PLHU:WHG\LW\ONRZWHG\=XZRV\G EDVWDM QDELHLZU]HV]F]\
ZWHG\=R/LWR FL DXM ]DJU]HFK\'REUHMX E G L SRF]FLZHSU]\VL JDP
7\ONRUDWXMFLH]DWDPXMFLHNUHZQLHGDMFLHSRGOHVF]H]Q
7DNSXVWHOQLNX:WDNLVSRVyE]ZDOF]DVL =R-H OL=RFKFHZ\U] G]LFL
NU]\ZG ]DGDFLEyOXSU]HG MHQDMOHSLHMZWHG\JG\=RVL QLHVSRG]LHZD-H OL
]D QLH]GRDH =DXSU]HG]LMH OL]RVWDH SU]H]=RVNU]\ZG]RQ\WRRGSDPX
'RSDGQLMQDMOHSLHMZWHG\JG\MX ]DSRPQLDRJG\F]XMHVL EH]SLHF]QH2GSD
PXZGZyMQDVyE:WUyMQDVyE2NR]DRNR"1LH2ERMHRF]X]DRNR= E ]D] E"
1LH:V]\VWNLH] E\]D] E2GSD=X6SUDZE\Z\R]EyOXE\RGWHJRZ\FLD
S N\PXJDNLRF]QH,ZWHG\SRSDWU]\ZV]\QDSRGRJ PR HV] PLDRLSHZQLH
SRZLHG]LHWRFRWXWDMOH \MX QLHVNU]\ZG]LQLNRJRQLNRPXQLH]DJUR]L%RMDN
PR H NRPX ]DJUR]LQLHPDM F RF]X"1LHPDM F REXU N"-DNPR H VNU]\ZG]L
JG\MHJRIODNLZyF] VL SRSLDFKXDMXFKDZWHQSLDFKZVL ND"
$W\SRZLHG]LDZROQRSXVWHOQLNVWRLV]]]DNUZDZLRQ\PPLHF]HPZGRQL
SDWU]\V]QDNUHZZVL NDM F Z SLDFK,PDV]F]HOQR P\ OH H RWR]RVWD
UR]ZL ]DQ\WHQRGZLHF]Q\G\OHPDWRVL JQL WH]RVWDRPDU]HQLHILOR]RIyZ
0\ OLV] H QDWXUD=D]RVWDDRGPLHQLRQD"
$WDNSRZLHG]LDDEX F]XF]QLH%RWRFROH \ QD]LHPLLEURF]\WRMX QLH
MHVW=R0R H WRMHV]F]HQLH'REURDOH=RQLHMHVWWRMX ] SHZQR FL
0yZL SRZLHG]LDZROQR9\VRJRWD H SU]\URGDQLH]QRVLSUy QL7RFR
OH \ QD]LHPLFREURF]\FRSDGRRGWZHJRPLHF]DMX QLHMHVW=HP&RQLPWHG\
MHVW"&]\]DVWDQDZLDD VL NLHG\ QDGW\P"
1LH-HVWHPZLHG PLQN *G\PQLHXF]RQRSRSU]\VL JDPVRELH H E G
Z\VW SRZDSU]HFLZ=X=DZV]H,EH]]DVWDQRZLHQLD
%RJG\VL ]DF]QLH]DVWDQDZLDGRGDDJXFKR]DELMDQLHSU]HVWDMHPLHVHQV
=HPVWDSU]HVWDMHPLHVHQV$GRWHJRQLHZROQRGRSX FL
3RNU FLJRZ DOHJHVWHPSRZVWU]\PDDJRSU]HGDUJXPHQWRZDQLHP
&]DVE\PGRNR F]\DPRM RSRZLH 9\VRJRWR2SRZLDGDDPFLSU]H]SRQDG
WU]\G]LH FLQRF\RG(NZLQRNFMXPGR6DRYLQH$SU]HFLH QLHRSRZLHG]LDDPFL
ZV]\VWNLHJR=DQLPRGMDG PXVLV]VL GRZLHG]LHFRZ\GDU]\RVL Z G]LH
(NZLQRNFMXPZZLRVFHNWyUDQD]\ZDDVL *RZRUR HF
%RQKDUWZHVWFKQ
1LHSDWU]ZLONLHP6NHOOHQSRZWyU]\&KFLDHP]Z\F]DMQLH]DUREL0QLH
XZD DV]QDHPHU\WXU SRUDQDZHUDQG]LHVLHG]LHQDJR ELHSRSDWU\ZD
'DZDH PL]D6]F]XU]\F VWRIORUHQyZNRQLHF]QLHFKFLDH PDUWZ =DVWDQRZLR
PQLHWR,OHWH WDSDQQDPR H E\QDSUDZG ZDUWDSRP\ ODHP,
Z\NRPELQRZDHP H JG\VL M ]DELMHOXERGGD]SHZQR FL PQLHME G]LHZDUWD
QL JG\E\VL M ]DWU]\PDR6WDUD]DVDGDHNRQRPLLLKDQGOX7RZDUWDNLMDNRQD
VWDOHSU]\UDVWDZZDUWR FL0R QDVL SRWDUJRZD
3XV]F]\N]PDUV]F]\QRVMDNE\ZRNROLF\FR ]D PLHUG]LDR
6]F]HU\MHVWH %RQKDUWGREyOX$OHSU]HMG GRU]HF]\'RZ\MD QLH
8FLHNDV]]G]LHZF]\Q SU]H]FDH(EELQJDQDUD]]MDZLDV]VL L WXPDF]\V]
]DVDGDPLHNRQRPLL:\MD QLMFR]DV]R
&RWXZ\MD QLDX PLHFKQ VL REOH QLH5LHQFH3DQ%RQKDUWSRSURVWX
SRDSDVL ZUHV]FLHNLPQDSUDZG G]LHZNDMHVW,LOHMHVWZDUWD
6NHOOHQQLH]DV]F]\FLJRVSRMU]HQLHP3DWU]\QD%RQKDUWDZMHJRU\ELH
SR]EDZLRQHZ\UD]XRF]\
,W GURJRFHQQ G]LHZF]\Q Z\FHG]LW ZDUWR FLRZ ]GRE\F]PDM F
]DJZDUDQWRZDHPHU\WXU Z\S\FKDVL Z &ODUHPRQWQDDUHQ L ND H ZDOF]\QD
PLHU5\]\NXMHVL MHM \FLHPFKRSRGREQR \ZDW\OHZDUWD-DNWRMHVW
%RQKDUW"%RFR PLWXQLHJUD
*G\E\]JLQ DQDWHMDUHQLH%RQKDUWQLHVSX FLRF]XWRE\]QDF]\R H QLF
QLHE\DZDUWD
5R]XPLHP3XV]F]\N]PDUV]F]\OHNNREUZL$OH]DPLDVW]DZLH G]LHZN
QDNROHMQ DUHQ SU]\ZLR]H M GRPQLH'ODF]HJRMH OLZROQRVS\WD"
3RZWDU]DPZ\NU]\ZLVL 5LHQFH3RDSDVL NLQDRQDMHVW
%\VWU\MHVWH FLHSDQLH5LHQFH%RQKDUWSU]HFL JQ VL D ]DWU]HV]F]D\
VWDZ\2GJDGOL FLH7DNSUDZGDWR]HV]NRORQ Z .DHU0RUKHQZLHG PLQN
ZL ]DDVL MHV]F]HMHGQD]DJDGND:*HVRSRGF]DVQDSDGXQDV]ODFKFLDQN
G]LHZNDUR]SX FLDM ]\F]HN H QLE\WDNDZD QDLXW\WXRZDQD H EDURQyZQDWR
GODQLHMIXUGDLV]\V]NDQLDVL QLVNRSRZLQQD7HG\RZD)DONDP\ O VRELHWR
FRQDMPQLHMKUDELDQND&LHNDZH:LHG PLQNDWRUD]'X R WRZLGXMHVL
ZLHG PLQHN":EDQG]LH6]F]XUyZWRGZD&HVDUVNLNRURQHUZDVQ ZD Q RVRE
XJDQLDVL ]DQL RG.RUDWKXSR(EELQJUR]ND]XMHX PLHUFLWU]\$GRWHJR
ZV]\VWNLHJRV]ODFKFLDQNDMDNRE\Z\VRNLHJRURGX+DP\ O VRELHWU]HEDE G]LH
G]LHZN ZUHV]FLHVS\WDNLP H WRRQDQDSUDZG MHVW
=DPLONQDFKZLO
3RF] WNRZRZ\WDUQRVPDQNLHWHPQLHFKFLDDJDGD&KRSURVLHP5 N
QRJ EDWHPSURVLHP.DOHF]\QLHFKFLDHP$OHWU]HEDWUDIXQDSDWRF]\VL
F\UXOLN=SU]\U] GDPLGRUZDQLD] EyZ3U]\ZL ]DHPM GRNU]HVD
6NHOOHQV\V]DOQLHSU]HNQ OLQ 5LHQFHX PLHFKQ VL %RQKDUWREHMU]D
PDQNLHW
:V]\VWNRPLSRZLHG]LDD]DQLP*G\W\ONR]REDF]\DLQVWUXPHQW\7H] EQH
NOHV]F]HLSHOLNDQ\2GUD]XVL ]URELDUR]PRZQLHMV]D2ND]DRVL H WR
.VL QLF]ND&LQWU\U]HN5LHQFHSDWU] F QD3XV]F]\ND6SDGNRELHUF]\QL
WURQX.DQG\GDWNDQD RQ FHVDU]D(PK\UD
&]HJRWRSDQ6NHOOHQSRZLHG]LHPLQLHUDF]\VNU]\ZLXVWDRZFDQDJUyG
.D]D]Z\F]DMQLHXNDWUXSLNLONDUD]\WR]D]QDF]D=DELQDPLHMVFXLEH]OLWR FL
-DNWRSDQLH6NHOOHQ"=DELNUyORZ " 3U]\V] OXEQ VZHJRFHVDU]D"=NWyU MH OL
SORWFHZLHU]\FHVDU]W\ONRSDWU]HMDNQDNRELHUFXVWDQLHSRF]\PE G]LHZLHOND
DPQHVWLD"
:\JDV]DM F RUDFM %RQKDUWZLHUFL6NHOOHQDZ]URNLHP$OHNRURQHUFHVDUVNL
RF]XQLHVSX FL
2WSRGM RZFDZ\FKRG]LNDEDD7DNWHG\FKR] DOHPDOH]HVZRLFK
SODQyZZ]JO GHPWHMZLHG PLQNLNVL QLF]NL]UH]\JQRZDHP3U]\ZLR]HPFD
W NDED WXWDMGRSDQD6NHOOHQD%\SRJDGDSRXNDGDVL %RWDNDEDDWR
WURV]HF]N MDNE\]DGX R MDNQDMHGQHJR%RQKDUWD
%DUG]RVXV]Q\ZQLRVHNSRZLHG]LDRVNU]HNOLZLHFR ]]DSD]XFK\5LHQFH
D
%DUG]RVXV]Q\ZQLRVHNSDQLH%RQKDUW7RFR]DSDOL FLHSDQRZLHWRWURFK ]D
GX R GODZDVREX1DZDV]HV]F] FLHPDFLHMHV]F]HPQLH
&RWRMHVW"6NHOOHQ]HUZDVL ] NU]HVD&RWRFKROHUDMHVW"
0yMPLVWU]F]DURG]LHM9LOJHIRUW]5LHQFHZ\M ]]DSD]XFK\PDOXWNLHVUHEUQH
SX]GHUNR'RNDGQLHMJRVPHJRPLVWU]D'RELHJDM F\]WHJRRWRPDJLF]QHJR
XU] G]HQLD]ZDQHJRNVHQRJOR]HP
:LWDPZV]\VWNLFKSDQyZSRZLHG]LDRSX]GHUNR6]NRGD H PRJ ZDV
W\ONRV\V]HDOHQDWHOHSURMHNFM OXEWHOHSRUWDFM QLHSR]ZDODM PLSLOQH]DM FLD
7HJRSVLDNUHZMHV]F]HEUDNRZDRZDUNQ 3XV]F]\N$OHPRJHPVL
GRP\ OL5LHQFHMHVW]DJXSLE\G]LDDVDPLQDZDVQ U N 0RJHPVL
QLHXQLHVLHV]E G]LHV]SRWU]HERZDMXF]QHJRPXD:\VWDUF]\FLQDHPHU\WXU
ZHUDQG JR ELHDQDZHWQDZyGN L G]LZNLMH OL]DFKRZDV]UR]V GQ\XPLDU
=JRGDSDQLHPDJLNX]D PLDVL SR]RUQLHEH]WURVNRRZFD7 ZyGN L W\PL
G]LZNDPL]DLVWH]DVHUFH H FLHPQLHXM OL'RELMHP\WDUJX$OHQDRZR
]DSURSRQRZDQHSU]\JO GDQLHWH E\PUHIOHNWRZD:RODE\PFRSUDZGDSDWU]H
MDNRQD]G\FKDQDDUHQLHDOHQDZDV] QR RZ URERW WH FK WQLHU]XF RNLHP
'Ry FLHUDEDWHP
7DUJGRELW\
6]\ENRZDPSRV]RRFHQLFLHUSNR3XV]F]\N=DSUDZG 9LOJHIRUW]V]\ENR
L JDGNR]DZDUH ] %RQKDUWHPVSyN 6SyN NWyUDZV]DNMHVWLE G]LHVRFLHWDV
OHRQLQD$OHQLH]DSRPQLHOL FLHDE\RF]\P " ZLHWOLF ZNWyUHMVLHG]LFLHL
&LQWU\MN NWyU KDQGOXMHFLHRWDF]DM GZDWX]LQ\]EURMQ\FKOXG]L0RLFKOXG]L
'URJLNRURQHU]H6NHOOHQ]DEU]PLD]SXGHNDJRV9LOJHIRUW]D2EUD D PQLH
SDQV G] F H ZZ\PLDQLHFKF SDQDVNU]\ZG]L:SURVWSU]HFLZQLH=DPLHU]DP
E\QLH]Z\NOHKRMQ\1LHPRJ SDQX]DSHZQLRZHMMDNWRSDQUDF]\QD]ZD
GHPRNUDFML$OH]DJZDUDQWXM SDQXSRPRFPDWHULDOQ ZVSDUFLHORJLVW\F]QHL
GRVW S GRLQIRUPDFMLG]L NLNWyU\PSU]HVWDQLHSDQE\GODVSLVNRZFyZQDU] G]LHP
L VXJXVHPDVWDQLHVL SDUWQHUHP7DNLP]NWyUHJRRVRE L ]GDQLHPOLF]\VL
E G]LHNVL
-RDFKLPGH:HWWGLXN$UGDODHS'DQ\KUDELD%URLQQHKUDELD
G
$UY\LFDDUHV]WDE NLWQRNUZLVW\FKVSLVNRZFyZ&R]WHJR H WRVRFLHWDV
OHRQLQD"2ZV]HPMH OLXSHPMHVW&LULOODWROZL F] XSXZH]P MDMDNPLVL
]UHV]W ]GDMH]DVX HQLH$ WDNFL WREROL":V]DNVDP]\VNLE G]LHV]PLD
QLHPDH-H OLRGGDV]PL&LQWU\MN VWDQRZLVNR9DWWLHUDGH5LGHDX[PDV]MX Z
NLHV]HQL$E G F V]HIHPWDMQ\FKVX E6WHIDQLH6NHOOHQPR QDUHDOL]RZD
SU]HUR]PDLWHXWRSLHERGDMQDZHWGHPRNUDFMHLXF]FLZHZ\ERU\-DNZL F ZLG]LV]
]DMHGQ FKXG SL WQDVWRODWN GDM FLVSHQLHQLH \FLRZ\FKPDU]H L DPELFML
:LG]LV]WR"
1LHSRNU FLJRZ 3XV]F]\N:\ F]QLHV\V]
5LHQFH
6XFKDPPLVWU]X
'DMSDQX6NHOOHQRZLSUyEN MDNR FLQDV]\FKLQIRUPDFML3RZLHG]FR
Z\GRE\H RG9DWWLHUD
:W\PRGG]LDOHSRZLHG]LD5LHQFHMHVWV]SLHJ
&R"
7RFRV\V]\V]9DWWLHUGH5LGHDX[PDWXZW\F]N :LHRZV]\VWNLPFR
URELV]'ODF]HJRWRURELV]LGODNRJR9DWWLHUZNU FLPL G]\ZDVVZRMHJRDJHQWD
3RGV]HGGRQLHMFLFKR3UDZLHJRQLHV\V]DD
.HQQD
1HUDWLQ
%\D F]XMQDQDPRMHP\ OL7DPZ ZLHWOLF\:LHV]RF]\PP\ ODHP
:LHV]ZL FNLPMHVWHP
3RVXFKDM1HUDWLQ
1LH7RW\SRVXFKDM-RDQQR6HOERUQH6WHIDQ6NHOOHQ]GUDG]DNUDMLFHVDU]D
6SLVNXMH:V]\VF\NWyU]\]QLPWU]\PDM VNR F] QDV]DIRFLH% G UR]U\ZDQL
NR PLQDSODFX7\VL FOHFLD
-DQLFQLHZLHP1HUDWLQ-DZ\NRQXM UR]ND]\&]HJRW\RGHPQLHFKFHV]"-D
VX NRURQHURZL$NRPXW\VX \V]"
&HVDUVWZX3DQXGH5LGHDX[
&]HJRW\RGHPQLHFKFHV]"
%\ Z\ND]DDUR]V GHN
2GHMG 1LH]GUDG] FL QLHSRZLHP$OHRGHMG SURV] -DQLHPRJ
1HUDWLQ-DMHVWHPSURVWDNRELHWD1LHQDPRM WRJRZ
1LHZLHPFRUREL6NHOOHQPyZLSDQL6HOERUQH-DNGRRILFHUD.RPX
VX " -HPX"&HVDU]RZL"&HVDUVWZX"
$VN G PQLHWRZLHG]LH"
.HQQDRGHSFKQ DVL SOHFDPLRGZ JDFKDXS\PDFKQL FLHPZLWNLLJUR Q\P
SRPUXNLHPSU]HS G]LDZLHMVNLHG]LHFLDNLFLHNDZLHSU]\JO GDM FHVL VLHG] FHM
SRGVXSHP)DOFH
2MZDGQ NDED VL ZSDNRZDDP2M]DSDFKQLDRZSRZLHWU]XVWU\F]NLHP,
NR VNLPJyZQHPQDSODFX7\VL FOHFLD
1LHZLHPF]\PWRVL VNR F]\SRP\ ODD.HQQD$OHPXV] Z QL ZHM :W
)DON &KRSU]H]FKZLO SRF]XMHMP\ OL:LHG]LHWRFRRQD
=UR]XPLH
Sy QLHMF]HUSDQLHPRJDPNRU]\VWD$RQDWDNRELHWDGDDPL6L ZU F]
ZHSFKQ DPLEUR GRU NL7RE\DPRMDV]DQVD
6WUD H ZRD\QDPXUDFKF\WDGHOL6LRVWU\6FDUUDFKUDSD\ZGXHFLH.RKXW
JR QRVLNDGRSXVWHJRNLEOD
.HQQDSRGFL JQ DNRFSRGEURG :VSRPLQDD
1LHGRJRQLOLG]LHZF]\Q\=QLND3RSURVWX]QLND%RUHDV0XQQLHE\ZDH
]JXEL ODGNDUHMNODF]\SRMDNLFK WU]HFKPLODFK1DJOHEH]RVWU]H HQLD]URELRVL
FLHPQRZLFKHUSU]\JL GU]HZDQLHPDOGR]LHPL/XQ GHV]F]EDKXNQ \QDZHW
JURP\]D ZLHFL\E\VNDZLFH
%RQKDUWQLHGDURZD:UyFLOLGR*RZRUR FD:U]HV]F]HOLQDVLHELHZV]\VF\
MHGHQSU]H]GUXJLHJRLMHGHQQDGUXJLHJR%RQKDUW3XV]F]\N5LHQFHLWHQF]ZDUW\
]DJDGNRZ\QLHOXG]NLVNU]HF] F\JRV3RWHPSRGQLH OLQDVLRGDFD KDQ] SUyF]
W\FKNWyU]\WDNMDNMDQLHE\OLZVWDQLHMHFKD6NU]\NQ OLFKRSyZ]
SRFKRGQLDPLSRJQDOLZODV\:UyFLOLQDGUDQHP
:UyFLOL]QLF]\P-H OLQLHOLF]\]JUR]\NWyU PLHOLZRF]DFK
*DGNLSU]\SRPQLDDVRELH.HQQD]DF] \VL GRSLHURSRNLONXGQLDFK
3RF] WNRZRZV]\VF\]E\WEDOLVL 3XV]F]\NDL%RQKDUWD&LE\OLWDNZ FLHNOL H
OHSLHME\RQLHOH LPZRF]\=DMDNLH QLHEDF]QHVRZRQDZHW%HUW%ULJGHQ
RILFHUZ]L SU]H]HEWU]RQNLHPQDKDMD
$OHSRWHPJDGDQRRW\PFRG]LDRVL ZyZF]DVSRGF]DVSR FLJX2PDOXWNLP
VRPLDQ\PMHGQRUR FX]NDSOLF]NLNWyU\QDJOHXUyVGRUR]PLDUyZVPRNDL
VSRV]\NRQLHWDN H MH G F\SRVSDGDOLFXGHPMHG\QLHQLHDPL F NDUNyZ2
FZDXM FHMSRQLHELHNDZDONDG]LHRJQLVWRRNLFKZLGPQDV]NLHOHWDFKNRQL
ZLHG]LRQHMSU]H]VWUDV]OLZHJRNUyODNR FLRWUXSDUR]ND]XM FHJRVZ\PVXJRP
XSLRURP]DFLHUD ODG\NRS\WF]DUQHMNODF]\SRVWU] SLRQ\PLSDV]F]DPL2
PDNDEU\F]Q\PFKyU]HOHONyZNR]RGRMyZZRDM F\FK/LLLNZRUUU]NUZLOLLLN
ZRUU]NUZL2EXG] F\P]JUR] Z\FLXXSLRUQHMEHDQQ
VKLH]ZLDVWXQNL PLHUFL
:LDWUGHV]F]FKPXU\NU]DNLLGU]HZDRIDQWDVW\F]Q\FKNV]WDWDFKGRWHJR
VWUDFKNWyUHQPDZLHONLHRF]\NRPHQWRZD%RUHDV0XQNWyU\SU]HFLH WDPE\
2WFDHZ\MD QLHQLH$OHONL"/HONLMDNWROHONLGRGDZDNU]\F] ]DZV]H
$WURS ODG\NRS\WNWyUHQDJOHQLNQ MDNE\NR Z QLHELRVDXOHFLD"
7ZDU]%RUHDVD0XQDWURSLFLHODXPLHM FHJRZ\WURSLU\E Z ZRG]LHW DDQD
WRS\WDQLH:LFKHURGSRZLDGDZLFKHU]DZLD ODG\SLDVNLHPLOLVWRZLHP,QQHJR
Z\WXPDF]HQLDQLHPD
1LHNWyU]\QDZHWZLHU]\OLSU]\SRPQLDDVRELH.HQQD
1LHNWyU]\QDZHWXZLHU]\OL H WRZV]\VWNRE\\]MDZLVNDQDWXUDOQHDOER
SU]\ZLG]HQLD,QDZHW PLDOLVL ] QLFK
$OHSU]HVWDOLVL PLD3R'XQ'DUH3R'XQ'DUHQLH PLDVL MX QLNW
'RSDQL5LW\9\VRJRWR-DNWRE\RGDZQR
:LH D -DVNyNLWROHJHQGD3DPL WDMWRW\ONROHJHQGD
-DWH MHVWHPW\ONROHJHQGDSRZLHG]LDDJRU]NR2GXURG]HQLD=LUHDHO
-DVNyNDG]LHFNRQLHVSRG]LDQND:\EUDQND']LHFNRSU]H]QDF]HQLD']LHFNR
6WDUV]HM.UZL-DG 9\VRJRWR%\ZDMZ]GURZLX
%\ZDMZ]GURZLX&LUL
.DUF]PDQDUR]VWDMDFK]DZ\VLyNLHPE\DSXVWD&\SULDQ)ULSS0RGV]\LMHJR
WU]HMGUXKRZLH]DND]DOLZVW SXPLHMVFRZ\PLSU]HS G]DOLSU]HMH]GQ\FK6DPL]D
XF]WRZDOLLSLOLFD\PLGQLDPLSU]HVLDGXM F Z]DG\PLRQ\PLPURF]Q\PORNDOX
PLHUG] F\PWDNMDN]Z\NOH PLHUG]LNDUF]PDZ]LPLHJG\QLHRWZLHUDVL RNLHQ
DQLGU]ZLSRWHPNRWHPP\V]DPLRQXFDPLVR QLQ E G]LQ WXV]F]HP
VSDOHQL]Q L PRNU SDUXM F RG]LH
6UDSLHVWDN GRO SRZWyU]\SRUD]FK\EDVHWQ\<X]-DQQRZLW]
*HPPHUF]\NPDFKDM F ZVWURQ G]LHZHNVX HEQ\FKE\SU]\QLRV\ZyGNL HE\
WHJR3XV]F]\NDSRNU FLR:WDNLHMG]LXU]HSDUV]\ZHMND]DVLHG]LH-X E\FK
ZRODSRODVDFK]SDWURODPLMH G]L
7R FK\EDJXSLRGU]HN'HGH9DUJDV1DGZRU]HVDNUDPHQFNL]L E-DWDP
ZRO Z FLHSOH,SU]\SDQQLH
=UR]PDFKHPNOHSQ G]LHZN Z SR ODGNL']LHZNDSLVQ DQLH]E\W
SU]HNRQXM FRL]Z\UD Q\P]RERM WQLHQLHP%\DSUDZG SRZLHG]LDZV]\
SU]\JXSDZD3UDFDZNDUF]PLHQDXF]\DM W\ONRWHJR H MDNNOHSL DOERV]F]\SL
Z\SDGDSLV]F]H
&\SULDQ)ULSSLMHJRNRPSDQLDGREUDOLVL GRREXVX HEQ\FKG]LHZHNMX
GUXJLHJRGQLDSRSU]\MH G]LH.DUF]PDU]EDVL SURWHVWRZDDG]LHZNLE\\]E\W
PDRUR]JDUQL WHE\P\ OHRSURWHVWDFK \FLHQDXF]\RMHMX H MH OLG]LHZND
SURWHVWXMHWRM ELM 5R]XPQLHMZL F SRF]HNDD VL ]QXG]
7DFDD)DOND]QXG]RQ\5LVSDW/D3RLQW SRGM NROHMQ\VWDQGDUGRZ\WHPDW
]QXG]RQ\FKZLHF]RUQ\FKUR]PyZVNDSLDDJG]LH Z ODVDFKSRZLDGDPZDP
:LG]LDHPMDNM ZWHG\6NHOOHQZJ E RULRQHPVLHNQ MDN]QLHMMXFKDIRQWDQQ
EOX]JQ D=WHJRSRZLDGDPZDPQLHPRJDVL Z\NDUDVND
3XV]F]\NFK\ELMHMRU]HN<X]-DQQRZLW]/HGZR]DZDG]LRULRQHP* E L
RZV]HPQLH OHMHMUR]ZDOLVDPHPZLG]LD$OHSU]HV]NRG]LRWRG]LHZFHZVNRNX
SRQDGNRRZUyW"6SDGD]NRQLD"$NXUDW$NRRZUyW]PLHU]\OLPSRWHPVLHGHP
VWySLGZDFDOHMDNZS\VNGD,FR"6NRF]\D,MDNMHV]F]H0L G]\VLRGRD
GXSN NOLQJLQR D E\ QLHZFLVQ
.UHZ]QLHMV]DE\]FHEUD]DSURWHVWRZD5LVSDW/D3RLQW -HFKDDPyZL
ZDPMHFKDDDSRWHPVSDGDLVNDSLDODZMDNLPZ\NURFLHZLOF\LSWDF\ FLHUZR
]MHGOLNXQ\GRNR F]\OLDPUyZF\Z\F]\ FLOL ODG\.RQLHFGHLUHDGK7HG\P\WX
SRZLDGDPZDPQDGDUPRVLHG]LP\LSLHQL G]HSU]HSLMDP\,WRZDVQHERODI\
MDNR QLHZLGD
PD
']LHFLFLG]LDGXF]DURZQLFDPLVWUDV]\
1LHZ\PyZFLHSDQLHZ] JRG]LQ %RMHV]F]HZDPU]HNQ H
QDMJUR QLHMV]HZLHG P\WHZLHG PRZHJRVWDQXKUDELQ\LNVL QHRKRKRWHQLH
QDPLRWDFKQLHQDR RJDFKQLPR G]LHU]DFKMH G QLH7HFZDXM QDVZ\FK
F]DUQ\FKNRWDFK
+HKHKHKH
3UDZGDWR$OERZLHPZZLOL 6DRYLQHQDW MHGQ MHG\Q QRFZURNX
]PLHQLDM VL NRW\ZLHG P ZF]DUQHMDNVPRDNODF]H,ELDGDWHPXNWRQRF MDN
NLUF]DUQ SRV\V]\VWXNNRS\WLXMU]\ZLHG P QDNDUHMNODF]\.WRVL ] WDN
ZLHG P VSRWNDQLHRGHMPLHVL PLHUFL=DNU FLQLPZLHG PDMDNZLHM
OL FLRZLHPSRUZLHZ]D ZLDW\
*G\ZUyFLP\GRNR F]\V]$GREU DE\RSRZLH Z\NRQF\SXMG]LDGX
VDNUDPHQFNLDGXG\Z\U\FKWXM*G\ZUyFLP\E G]LHWXKXODQND% G]LHVL WX
WD FRZDLSDQQ NRZDOyZQ REDSLD&RMHVW5LVSDW"
5LVSDW/D3RLQW NWyU\Z\V]HGQDJDQHNE\XO \S FKHU]RZLZUyFLELHJLHP
D WZDU]PLDELD MDN QLHJ*ZDWRZQLH]DJHVW\NXORZDZVND]XM F QDGU]ZL1LH
]G \Z\NU]WXVLVRZD,QLHE\RWU]HED=SRGZyU]DGRQR QLH]DU DNR
.DUDNODF]SRZLHG]LD)ULSS]WZDU] QLHPDOSU]\NOHMRQ GRERQRNQD7D
VDPDNDUDNODF]7RRQD
&]DURZQLFD"
)DONDGXUQLX
7RMHMGXFK5LVSDWJZDWRZQLHZFL JQ SRZLHWU]H8SLyU2QDQLHPRJD
SU]H \8PDUDLZUDFDXSLRUHP:QRF6DRYLQH
3U]\E G]LHQRF MDNNLUF]DUQ ]DPDPURWDG]LDGSU]\FLVNDM F SXVW\NXIHOGR
EU]XFKD$NWRVL ] QL VSRWNDQLHRGHMPLHVL PLHUFL
%UR EUDEUR SRZLHG]LDJRU F]NRZR)ULSS%\VWUR'U]ZLREVWDZL]
REXVWURQ1LHUR]XPLHFLH"3RV]F] FLRVL QDP)DONDQLHZLHRQDV]MHFKDDWX
E\VL RJU]DPUy]LJyGZ\JQD\M ] NU\MyZNL3URVWRZQDV]HU FH3XV]F]\NL
5LHQFH]RWHPQDVREV\SL %LHU]FLHEUR
6NU]\SQ \GU]ZL
']LDG]JDUELVL QDGEODWHPVWRX]PUX \RF]\:LG]LD OH2F]\PLDVWDUH
]UXMQRZDQHMDVNU L FKURQLF]Q\P]DSDOHQLHPVSRMyZHN'RWHJRZNDUF]PLHE\R
FLHPQDZRLG\PQR']LDGOHGZRZLG]LDZL F V]F]XS SRVWDNWyUDZNURF]\DGR
L]E\]VLHQLXEUDQDZNXEUDN]SL PDF]\FKVNyUHNQRV] FDNDSWXULV]DO
]DVDQLDM F\WZDU]6XFKQDWRPLDVWG]LDGPLDGREU\6\V]DFLFK\RNU]\NMHGQHM
]HVX HEQ\FKG]LHZHNVWXNVDERWyZGUXJLHMSyJR QHSU]HNOH VWZRNDUF]PDU]D
6\V]D]JU]\WPLHF]yZZSRFKZDFK,FLFK\]MDGOLZ\JRV&\SULDQD)ULSSD
0DP\FL )DOND1LHVSRG]LHZDD VL QDVWXFR"
6SRG]LHZDDPVL XV\V]DG]LDG,]DG\JRWDQDG ZL N WHJRJRVX
=REDF]\UXFKV]F]XSHMSRVWDFL,XV\V]DZHVWFKQLHQLD]JUR]\=GXV]RQ\NU]\N
NWyUHM ] G]LHZHN1LHPyJZLG]LH H QD]ZDQD)DON G]LHZF]\QD]GM DNDSWXUL
V]DO1LHPyJZLG]LHV]NDUDGQLHRV]SHFRQHMWZDU]\,RF]XXPDORZDQ\FK
GRRNRDEDUZLF]N ] VDG]\LWXV]F]XWDN H Z\JO GD\MDNRF]\GHPRQD
1LHMHVWHP)DON SRZLHG]LDDG]LHZF]\QD']LDG]QRZX]REDF]\MHMV]\ENL
5R]G]LD
0DPZLHONLH OHSLDE\FL GREU]HZLG]LH]DZU]DVQ R HOD]QHZLOF]\VNR
0DPZLHONLHDS\E\FL QLPLFKZ\FLHLREM :V]\VWNRPDPZLHONLHZV]\VWNR
]DUD]VL R W\PSU]HNRQDV]GRZRGQLH&]HPXWDNG]LZQLHPLVL SU]\SDWUXMHV]PDD
G]LHZF]\QNR"&]HPXQLHRGSRZLDGDV]"
:LHG PLQNDX PLHFKQ DVL
0DPGODFLHELHQLHVSRG]LDQN
)ORXUHQV'HODQQR\
1LHVSRG]LDQND]WRPX%DMNLLNOHFKG\
1LHFKFHP\E\VNRWOLZHJRSURURFWZDQLHFKFHP\HQLJP\RW\VL FXUR]ZL ]D
&KFHP\REUD]X-DVQHJRREUD]X:H DXU ] W\FKSU]HGPLRWyZRQHQDOH D\GR
&LUL&LULLFKGRW\NDD:H DXU 3RZROL1LHPDSR SLHFKX
1D]HZQ WU]Z\DZLFKXUDLN ELDVL NXUQLDZD'DFK\LSRGZyU]HF ZL W\QL
V]\ENRSRNU\ZD QLHJ
%\G]LHZL WQDVW\G]LH OLVWRSDGD3HQLDNVL \FD
-HVWHPJRWRZDPDWNRSRZLHG]LDDVZ\PPHORG\MQ\PJRVHP,ROD3LHUZV]D
=DF]\QDM
-HGQ FKZLO 7ULVVSRGQLRVDVL ] DZ\MDNSFKQL WDVSU \Q ]U]XFLD]
UDPLRQIXWUR]V]\QV]\OL-HGQ FKZLO 1HQQHNH&KF ZHM ZWUDQVUD]HP]QL
7RQLHMHVWEH]SLHF]QH
:LHP$OHMDFKF ZLG]LH:DVQ\PLRF]\PD-HVWHPMHMWRZLQQD&LUL-DW
G]LHZF]\Q NRFKDPMDNPRGV] VLRVWU :.DHGZHQXUDWRZDDPL \FLHVDPD
U\]\NXM F JRZ
*RVF]DURG]LHMNL]DDPDVL QDJOH
=XSHQLHMDN-DUUHSRNU FLDJRZ DUF\NDSDQND%LHFQDUDWXQHNQDR OHS
QD]DPDQLHNDUNXQLHZLHG] F GRN G LSRFR$OH-DUUHWRQDLZQ\FKRSDF]HNW\
MHVWH GRMU]D L P GU MDNRE\PDJLF]N 3RZLQQD ZLHG]LH H ZFKRG] F ZWUDQV
QLHSRPR HV]&LUL$VRELHPR HV]]DV]NRG]L
&KF ZHM ZWUDQVUD]HP],RO SRZWyU]\D7ULVVJU\] F ZDUJL3R]ZyOPL
1HQQHNH=UHV]W F]\PU\]\NXM " $WDNLHPHSLOHSVML"1DZHWJG\E\Z\FL JQLHV]
PQLH]WHJRSU]HFLH
5\]\NXMHV]SRZLHG]LDDZROQR1HQQHNH H ]REDF]\V]WRF]HJRQLH
SRZLQQD ZLG]LH
:]JyU]HSRP\ ODD]SU]HUD HQLHP7ULVVZ]JyU]H6RGGHQ1DNWyU\PNLHG\
XPDUDP1DNWyU\PPQLHSRFKRZDQRLZ\NXWRPRMHLPL QDQDJUREQ\PREHOLVNX
:]JyU]HLJUyENWyUHNLHG\ XSRPQ VL R PQLH:LHPWR-X PLWRNLHG\
Z\SURURNRZDQR
-DMX SRGM DPGHF\]M SRZLHG]LDD]LPQRLZ\QLR OHZVWDM F LREXU F]
RGU]XFDM F QDNDUNVZRMHSL NQHZRV\=DF]\QDMP\
1HQQHNHXNO NDRSDUDF]RRR]R RQHUD]HPGRQLH
=DF]\QDMP\SRZLHG]LDDFLFKR3U]\JRWXMVL ,ROD.O NQLMRERNPQLH
7ULVV:H ,RO ]DU N
1D]HZQ WU]E\DQRF:\DZLHM V\SDR QLHJLHP
1D3RXGQLXKHQ]DJyUDPL$PHOOZ0HWLQQLHZNUDLQLH]ZDQHM6WRMH]LRU\Z
PLHMVFXRGGDORQ\PRGPLDVWD(OODQGHUL ZL W\QL0HOLWHOHRSL VHWPLOORWHP
ZURQ\NRV]PDUVHQQ\JZDWRZQLH]EXG]LU\EDND*RVW 3U]HEXG]RQ\*RVWD]D
QLFQLHPyJSU]\SRPQLHVRELHWUH FLVQXDOHG]LZQ\QLHSRNyMGXJRQLHSR]ZDOD
PXXVQ
W\PVNR F]\
0LVWU]X"6\V]\FLHPQLH"0LVWU]X"
.VHQRJOR]PLOF]DMDN]DNO W\
5LHQFHPRFQRSRUXV]\UDPLRQDPLFKXFKQ Z]JUDELDHGRQLH.DUNLSOHF\
N VDR]LPQRNU]\ L O G ZLHEROD\ND G\PRFQLHMV]\UXFKNRQLDSU]\SRPLQDR
W\PEyOX1LHFKFLDRVL MX QDZHWNO
3UDZLHWU]\W\JRGQLHZVLRGDFKZQLHXVWDM F\PSR FLJX:SU]HQLNOLZ\P
]LPQLHDRGSDUXGQLZWU]DVNDM F\PPUR]LH
$9LOJHIRUW]PLOF]\
0\WH PLOF]\P\,SDWU]\P\SRVRELHZLONLHP
5LHQFHUR]WDUWGRQLHQDFL JQ U NDZLFH
6NHOOHQSRP\ ODJG\QDPQLHVSRJO GDPDG]LZQ\Z]URN&]\ E\NQX
]GUDG " &R ]DV]\ENRL]DDWZR]JDGDVL ZWHG\]9LOJHIRUW]HP$WHQRGG]LD
WHUH]XQ\SU]HFLH MHPXV ZLHUQLMHJRUR]ND]\Z\NRQXM *G\VFKZ\WDP\
G]LHZF]\Q JRWyZQLHEDF] F QDXNDG]DELM DOERXSURZDG]LGRW\FKVZRLFK
VSLVNRZFyZE\ZFLHODZ \FLHV]DOH F]HSRP\V\RGHPRNUDFMLLU] GDFK
RE\ZDWHOVNLFK
$PR H 6NHOOHQRZLMX SU]HV]RVSLVNRZDQLH"8URG]RQ\NRQIRUPLVWDL
NRQLXQNWXUDOLVWDPR H WHUD]MX P\ OLRGRVWDUF]HQLXG]LHZF]\Q\FHVDU]RZL
(PK\URZL"
']LZQLHQDPQLHVSRJO GD3XV]F]\N,WDFDDMHJREDQGD7D.HQQD
6HOERUQH
$%RQKDUW"%RQKDUWWRQLHREOLF]DOQ\VDG\VWD*G\PyZLR&LULJRVGU \ PX]
Z FLHNR FL:]DOH QR FLRGZLG]LPLVL SRMPDQ G]LHZF]\Q JRWyZ]DNDWRZD
DOERSRUZDE\ND]DMHMZDOF]\QDDUHQDFK8NDG]9LOJHIRUW]HP"2Q]DQLF
E G]LHPLDWHQXNDG=ZDV]F]DWHUD]JG\9LOJHIRUW]
:\M NVHQRJOR]]]DSD]XFK\
0LVWU]X"6\V]\FLHPQLH"7X5LHQFH
$SDUDFLNPLOF]D5LHQFHQLHPLDMX QDZHWRFKRW\]RU]HF]\
9LOJHIRUW]PLOF]\6NHOOHQL5LHQFH]DZDUOL]QLPSDNW$]DG]LH OXEGZDJG\
GRS G]LP\G]LHZF]\Q PR H VL RND]D H SDNWXQLHPD$ZWHG\MDPRJ GRVWD
QR HPSRJDUGOH$OERSRMHFKDZS WDFKGR1LOIJDDUGXMDNRGRZyGL]DNDG
3XV]F]\NRZHMORMDOQR FL
=DUD]D
9LOJHIRUW]PLOF]\1LHXG]LHODUDG1LHZVND]XMHGURJL1LHZ\MD QLD
Z WSOLZR FLVZ\PVSRNRMQ\PORJLF]Q\PWUDILDM F\PGRJ ELQGXV]\JRVHP
0LOF]\
.VHQRJOR]XOHJDZDULL0R H SU]H]WR]LPQR"$PR H
0R H 6NHOOHQPLDUDFM " 0R H 9LOJHIRUW]QDSUDZG ]DM VL F]\P LQQ\PLQLH
GEDRQDVLQDV]ORV"
'RZV]\VWNLFKGLDEyZQLHP\ ODHP H WRWDNE G]LH*G\E\PSU]\SXV]F]D
QLHUZDE\PVL WDNGRWHJR]DGDQLD3RMHFKDE\P]DELZLHG PLQD]DPLDVW
6FKLUUX3VLDNUHZ-DWXPDU]Q D6FKLUUXSHZQLHJU]HMHVL Z FLHSHNX
3RP\ OH H VDPVL QDSLHUDHPE\WRPQLH]OHFRQR&LULD6FKLUUXZLHG PLQD
6DPRWRSURVLHP
SU]\ELHUDM F\SRVWDLWZDU]5LHQFH
D
2ELHFDHP H MHMRGSDF 7\PLU NRPD
0DRPQLHREFKRG]LFRMHMRELHFDH 3RZWDU]DPSRWU]HEQDPLMHVW \ZDL
]GROQDGRDUW\NXRZDQHMPRZ\
=NRWDLZLHG P\]D PLDVL WHQNWyU\WU]\PDM ]DZRV\QLHWDNDWZR
\ZRWZ\EL
1LHP GU]VL 6FKLUUX3RZLHG]LDHPZ\VWDUF]\ELFLD3RGQLH FLHM -DNVL
PDV]<HQQHIHU"
&]DURG]LHMNDVSOXQ DF]HUZRQRSRGQLRVDSXFKQ F WZDU]:SLHUZV]HMFKZLOL
QLHSR]QDDJR1RVLFR Z URG]DMXPDVNL]DNU\ZDM FHMFD OHZ VWURQ JRZ\
$OHSU]HFLH ZLHG]LDDNWRWRMHVW
,G GRGLDED9LOJHIRUW]Z\EHNRWDDRVWUR QLHGRW\NDM F M ]\NLHPSU]HGQLFK
] EyZLSRNDOHF]RQ\FKZDUJ
-DNRFHQLDV]PRMH]DNO FLH"3RGREDRFLVL MDNSRGQLRVHPFL ] PRU]DUD]HP
] W yGN " 3RGREDFLVL ORW"-DNLPL]DNO FLDPLVL ]DEH]SLHF]\D H ]GRDD
SU]H \XSDGHN"
,G GRGLDED
=HUZLMFLHMHM]V]\LW JZLD]G ,GRODERUDWRULXP]QL 1LHPDUQXMP\F]DVX
:OHF]RQRM FL JQL WRF]DVDPLQLHVLRQR.DPLHQLVWDUyZQLQDQDQLHMOH DD
UR]ZDORQD$ON\RQH,OLF]QHLQQHZUDNLVWHUF] F\PL HEUDPLZU JyZ
SU]\SRPLQDM FHV]NLHOHW\PRUVNLFKSRWZRUyZ&UDFKPLDUDFM SRP\ ODD6WDWNL
NWyUHEH]ZLH FL]QLNQ \QD* EL6HGQ\QLHXOHJ\NDWDVWURIRPQDWXUDOQ\P
%RJRZLH3DYHWWDL'XQ\
1DGUyZQLQ GDOHNRVWHUF]D\Z]DFKPXU]RQHQLHERV]F]\W\JyU
3RWHPE\\PXU\EUDP\NUX JDQNLSRVDG]NLVFKRG\:V]\VWNRMDNLH G]LZQLH
QLHQDWXUDOQLHZLHONLH:FL ]DPDRV]F]HJyyZE\PRJD]RULHQWRZDVL
JG]LHMHVWGRN G WUDILDGRN G ]DQLRVRM ]DNO FLH7ZDU]MHMSXFKDGRGDWNRZR
XWUXGQLDM F REVHUZDFM -HG\Q\PGRVWDUF]DM F\PLQIRUPDFML]P\VHPVWDVL Z FK
PRPHQWDOQLHZ\F]XDIRUPDOLQ HWHUVSLU\WXV,PDJL =DSDFK\ODERUDWRULXP
%UXWDOQLHSRVDG]RQRM QDVWDORZ\PIRWHOXQDSU]HJXEDFKLNRVWNDFKEROH QLH
]DWU]DVQ \VL ]LPQHLFLDVQHREHMP\=DQLPVWDORZHV]F] NLLPDGD FLVQ \
VNURQLHLXQLHUXFKRPL\JRZ ]GRDDUR]HMU]HVL SRREV]HUQHMLMDVNUDZR
R ZLHWORQHMVDOL=REDF]\DMHV]F]HMHGHQIRWHOG]LZDF]Q VWDORZ NRQVWUXNFM QD
NDPLHQQ\PSRGH FLH
,RZV]HPXV\V]DDJRVVWRM FHJR]W\X9LOJHIRUW]D7HQIRWHOLNMHVWGOD
WZRMHM&LUL&]HNDMX RGGDZQDQLHPR H VL GRF]HND-DWH
6\V]DDJR]EOLVNDZU F]F]XDMHJRRGGHFK:ELMDMHMLJ\ZVNyU JRZ\
SU]\SLQDFR GRPD RZLQXV]X3RWHPVWDQ SU]HGQL L ]GM PDVN <HQQHIHU
ZHVWFKQ DPLPRZROQLH
7RG]LHRZD QLHWZRMHM&LULSRZLHG]LDZVND]XM F VZHQLHJG\ NODV\F]QLH
SL NQHWHUD]RK\GQLH]PDVDNURZDQHREOLF]HRNUDWRZDQH]RW\PLNODPUDPLL
XFKZ\WDPLSRGWU]\PXM F\PLZLHORIDVHWNRZ\NU\V]WDZOHZ\PRF]RGROH
8VLRZDHPM SRFKZ\FLJG\ZFKRG]LDZWHOHSRUW:LH \ 0HZ\Z\MD QL
VSRNRMQLHF]DURG]LHM&KFLDHPUDWRZDMHM \FLHSHZLHQ H WHOHSRUWM ]DELMH
1DLZQ\3U]HV]DJDGNR]WDN VL H SRUWDOZ\EXFKQ HNVSORGRZDPLSURVWR
Z WZDU]6WUDFLHPRNRLOHZ\SROLF]HNWDN H VSRURVNyU\QDWZDU]\V]\LLSLHUVL
%DUG]RSU]\NUHEDUG]RGROHJOLZHEDUG]RNRPSOLNXM FH \FLH,EDUG]RQLHDGQH
SUDZGD"+DWU]HEDE\RPQLHZLG]LH]DQLP]DF] HPWRPDJLF]QLHUHJHQHURZD
*G\E\PZLHU]\ZWDNLHU]HF]\SRGM ZS\FKDM F MHMGRQRVD]DJL W
PLHG]LDQ UXUN SRP\ ODE\P H WR]HPVWD/\GLLYDQ%UHGHYRRUW=]DJUREX
5HJHQHUXM WRDOHSRZROQLHF]DVRFKRQQLHLRSRUQLH=ZDV]F]D]UHJHQHUDFM
JDNLV WUXGQR FL.U\V]WDNWyU\PDPZRF]RGROHVSHQLDVZ URO ]QDNRPLFLH
ZLG] WUyMZ\PLDURZRDOHMHGQDNWRFLDRREFHEUDNQDWXUDOQHMJDNLRF]QHM
F]DVDPLGRSURZDG]DPQLHGRSUDZG]LZHMSDVML:WHG\RJDUQL W\LUUDFMRQDOQ
SU]HFLH ]R FL SU]\VL JDPVRELH H JG\VFKZ\WDP&LULRGUD]XSRVFKZ\WDQLX
ND 5LHQFH
RZLZ\XSLMHMMHGQR]W\FKZLHONLFK]LHORQ\FKRF] W3DOFDPL7\PL
SDOFDPLMDNWRRQ]Z\NPyZL0LOF]\V]<HQQHIHU"$F]\ZLHV] H LWRELHPDP
RFKRW Z\UZDRNR"$OERRE\GZRMHRF]X"
:ELMDMHMJUXEHLJ\Z \\QDZLHU]FKXGRQL1LHNLHG\QLHWUDILDNXD GR
NR FL<HQQHIHU]DFLVNDD] E\
1DURELD PLNRSRWyZ=PXVLD GRRGHUZDQLDVL RGSUDF\1DUD]LD QD
U\]\NR3FKDM F VL W yGN QD* EL 6HGQ\SRGPyM:V\VDF](FKRQDV]HJR
NUyWNLHJRSRMHG\QNXE\RVLOQHLGDOHNLHPRJRRELVL R Z FLEVNLHLQLHSRZRDQH
XV]\$OHQLHPRJHPVL SRZVWU]\PD0\ O H E G FL WXPyJPLH H E G
PyJSRG F]\FL GRPRMHJRVNDQHUDE\D]E\WSRFL JDM FD
%RFK\EDQLHSU]\SXV]F]DV]ZELNROHMQ LJ H GDHPVL QDEUDQDWZRM
SURZRNDFM " H SRNQ HPSU]\Q W " 1LH<HQQHIHU-H OLWDNP\ OLV]P\OLV]
QLHER]JZLD]GDPLRGELW\PLQRF QDSRZLHU]FKQLVWDZX7\WURSLD PQLHMD
QDWRPLDVWWURSLHPFLHELH:S\ZDM F QD* EL XDWZLD PLSRSURVWX]DGDQLH
%RMDZLG]LV]VDPQLHPRJ Z\VNDQRZD&LULQDZHW]DSRPRF WHJRRWRQLH
PDM FHJRVRELHUyZQ\FKXU] G]HQLD']LHZF]\QDPDVLOQHZURG]RQHPHFKDQL]P\
REURQQHVLOQ ZDVQ DXU DQW\PDJLF]Q L VXSUHV\MQ ZNR FXWR6WDUV]D.UHZ
$OHLWDNPRMHVXSHUVNDQHU\SRZLQQ\M Z\NU\$QLHZ\NU\ZDM
<HQQHIHUE\DMX FDDRPRWDQDVLHFL VUHEUQ\FKLPLHG]LDQ\FKGUXFLNyZ
REXGRZDQDUXV]WRZDQLHPVUHEUQ\FKLSRUFHODQRZ\FKUXUHN1DSU]\VWDZLRQ\FKGR
IRWHODVWRMDNDFKFKZLD\VL V]NODQHSRMHPQLNL]EH]EDUZQ\PLS\QDPL
3RP\ ODHPZL F 9LOJHIRUW]ZHSFKQ MHMGRQRVDGUXJ UXUN W\PUD]HP
V]NODQ H MHG\Q\PVSRVREHPQDZ\VNDQRZDQLH&LULMHVWVRQGDHPSDW\F]QD'R
WHJRSRWU]HEQ\E\PLMHGQDNNWR NWRPLD]G]LHZF]\Q GRVWDWHF]QLHVLOQ\
NRQWDNWHPRFMRQDOQ\LZ\SUDFRZDHPSDW\F]Q PDWU\F WDNL H X \M QHRORJL]PX
DOJRU\WPXF]XLV\PSDWLLZ]DMHPQHM0\ ODHPRZLHG PLQLHDOH:LHG PLQ
]QLNQ SR]DW\PZLHG PLQLV PDUQ\PLPHGLDPL0LDHP]DPLDUND]DSRUZD
7ULVV0HULJROGQDV] &]WHUQDVW ]H:]JyU]D=DVWDQDZLDHPVL QDG
XSURZDG]HQLHP1HQQHNH](OODQGHU$OHJG\RND]DRVL H W\<HQQHIHU]
9HQJHUEHUJXVDPDZU F]SFKDV]PLVL Z U FH'RSUDZG\QDQLFOHSV]HJROLF]\
QLHPRJHP3RG F]RQDGRDSDUDWXU\Z\VNDQXMHV]GODPQLH&LUL2SHUDFMD
Z\PDJDFRSUDZGDNRRSHUDFML]WZRMHMVWURQ\$OHV MDNZLHV]VSRVRE\QD
]PXV]HQLHGRNRRSHUDFML
2F]\ZL FLHSRGM Z\FLHUDM F U FHQDOH DRE\FLVL WURFK Z\MD QLH 1D
SU]\NDGVN G LMDNGRZLHG]LDHPVL R 6WDUV]HM.UZL"2G]LHG]LFWZLH/DU\
9LOJHIRUW]VSRMU]DQDEH]ZDGQLHFLDRZOHF]RQHSRSRVDG]FHZNLHUXQNX
VFKRGyZSURZDG] F\FKGRSRG]LHPL3RWHPSRGQLyVRNRQD5LHQFH
DL6FKLUUX
=DZV]HLVWQLHMHU\]\NRSRZLHG]LD H NWyU\ ] ZDVZSDGQLHZU FHPRLFK
-H OLFKRSLQLHJDOL6WHIDQ6NHOOHQVWDQ ZVWU]HPLRQDFKWRMH]LRURPXVL
E\]DW\PZ]JyU]HPZNRWOLQLH
7DPWH WURSZLHG]LHSRWZLHUG]L%RUHDV0XQ
&]HJRWHG\VWRLP\"5LHQFHSRWDU]PDU]QL WHXFKR.RQLRPRVWURJ L MD]GD
1LHWDNE\VWURZVWU]\PDJR%RQKDUW5R]G]LHOP\VL 2WRF]P\NRWOLQ 1LH
ZLHP\NWyU\PEU]HJLHPMH]LRUDSRMHFKDD-H OLZ\ELHU]HP\]\NLHUXQHNPR H
VL QDJOHRND]D H MH]LRURRGG]LHOLQDVRGQLHM
5DFMD ZL WDSU]\WDNQ %RUHDV
-H]LRUD FL OyG
0R H E\]DVDE\GODNRQL%RQKDUWPDUDFM WU]HEDVL UR]G]LHOL
6NHOOHQV]\ENRZ\GDUR]ND]\*UXSDSURZDG]RQDSU]H]%RQKDUWD5LHQFH
DL
2O +DUVKHLPDOLF] FDGRNXS\VLHGHPNRQLSRFZDRZDDZVFKRGQLPEU]HJLHP
V]\ENRQLNQ F ZF]DUQ\POHVLH
'REUDVNRPHQGHURZD3XV]F]\N-HG]LHP\6LOLIDQW
2GUD]X]RULHQWRZDVL H FR MHVWQLHWDN2EUyFLNRQLDWU]HSQ JRQDKDMHP
QDMHFKDQD-RDQQ 6HOERUQH.HQQDFRIQ DVZHJRZLHU]FKRZFDDWZDU]PLDDMDN
] NDPLHQLD
7RQDQLFSDQLHNRURQHUSRZLHG]LDDFKUDSOLZLH1LHSUyEXMFLHQDZHW0\
QLHMHG]LHP\]ZDPL0\]DZUDFDP\0\WHJRGRV\PDP\
0\"ZU]DVQ 'DFUH6LOLIDQW.WRP\"&RWREXQW"
6NHOOHQSRFK\OLVL Z VLRGOHVSOXQ QD]PDU] ]LHPL =D.HQQ VWDQ OL
$QGUHV9LHP\L7LO(FKUDGHMDVQRZRV\HOI
3DQL6HOERUQHSRZLHG]LDSU]HFL JOHL]MDGOLZLH3XV]F]\N1LHZW\PU]HF]
H PDUQXMHSDQLSL NQLH]DSRZLDGDM F VL NDULHU H WUZRQLLZQLZHF]REUDFDSDQL
VZ \FLRZ V]DQV 5]HF]ZW\P H E G]LHSDQLRGGDQDNDWX5D]HP]W\PL
GXUQLDPLNWyU]\SDQLSRVXFKDOL
&RPDZLVLHQLHXWRQLHRGU]HNDILOR]RILF]QLH.HQQD$NDWHPQDVQLH
VWUDV]FLHSDQLHNRURQHU%RQLHZLDGDNRPXEOL HMGRUXV]WRZDQLDZDPF]\QDP
7DNV G]LV]"RF]\3XV]F]\NDE\VQ \7DNLHJRSU]HNRQDQLDQDEUDD
FK\WU]HJG]LH F]\MH P\ OLSRGVXFKDZV]\"=DP GU]HMV] FL PLDHP$W\
]Z\F]DMQLHJXSLDMHVWNRELHWR=HPQ ]DZV]HVL Z\JU\ZDSU]HFLZPQLH]DZV]H
VL SU]HJU\ZD=DSDPL WDMWR&KRE\ PQLHMX ]DSRJU RQHJRPLDDMDMHV]F]H
]GRDPSRVDFL QDV]DIRW6\V]\FLHZ\ZV]\VF\"&]HUZRQ\PLKDNDPLND
RGU\ZDZDPPL VRRGNR FL
5D]PDWNDURG]LDSDQLHNRURQHUSRZLHG]LDPL NNR7LO(FKUDGH:\ FLH
Z\EUDOLZDV] GURJ P\ P\Z\EUDOLQDV] 2ELHGURJLQLHSHZQHLU\]\NRZQH$
QLHZLDGRPRFRNRPXGRODSU]H]QDF]\D
1LHE G]LHFLHQDV.HQQDGXPQLHXQLRVDJRZ MDNW\FKSVyZV]F]XQD
G]LHZF]\Q SDQLH6NHOOHQ,QLHGDP\VL QDNRQLHFMDNSV\XELMDN1HUDWLQ&HND
$GR WHJRJDGDQLD=DZUDFDP\%RUHDV-HG ] QDPL
1LHSRNU FLJRZ WURSLFLHORFLHUDM F F]RRIXWU]DQ F]DSN %\ZDMFLHZ
]GURZLXQLH \F] ZDP OH$OH]RVWDM 6X ED3U]\VL JDHP
.RPX"]PDUV]F]\DEUZL.HQQD&HVDU]RZLF]\3XV]F]\NRZL"&]\
F]DURZQLNRZLJDGDM FHPX]SX]GHUND"
-DMHVWHP RQLHU]6X ED
=DF]HNDMFLH]DZRD'XIILFH\.ULHOZ\MH G DM F ]]DSOHFyZ'DFUH6LOLIDQWD
-D]ZDPL-DWH PDPWHJRGR :F]RUDMZQRF\Z\ QLHPPRM ZDVQ PLHU
-DQLHFKF ]G\FKD]DW SDUV]\Z L SRGHMU]DQ VSUDZ
=GUDMF\ZU]DVQ 'DFUHF]HUZLHQLHM F MDNF]HUH QLD]GDZDRVL F]DUQD
NUHZWU\ QLHPX]WZDU]\3U]HQLHZLHUF\3RGHVREDNL
=DPNQLMJ E 3XV]F]\NZFL SDWU]\QD.HQQ DRF]\PLDUyZQLHSDVNXGQH
MDNSWDNRGNWyUHJRZ]L SU]H]ZLVNR2QLGURJ Z\EUDOLV\V]DH SU]HFLH 1LH
PDFRNU]\F]HDQL OLQ\WUDFL$OHVSRWNDP\VL MHV]F]HNLHG\ 2ELHFXM ZDP
0R H QDZHWQDMHGQ\PV]DIRFLHSRZLHG]LDDEH]]MDGOLZR FL.HQQD%R
ZDV6NHOOHQQLH]MD QLHNVL WDPLSU]HFLHND QLE G DOH]QDPLFKDPDPL
$OH FLHSUDZQLHPDFR OLQ\WUDFL-HG]LHP%\ZDM%RUHDV%\ZDMFLHSDQLH
6LOLIDQW
'DFUHVSOXQ QDGXV]DPLNRQLD
=GH]HUWHURZDOL"SRZWyU]\]QLHGRZLHU]DQLHP%RQKDUW1DVW SQL
]GH]HUWHURZDOL",RWWDNVRELHRGMHFKDOL"6NHOOHQ"3R]ZROLH "
-H OLQDVV\SQ ]DF] 5LHQFHDOH3XV]F]\NSU]HUZDPXQDW\FKPLDVW
1LHV\SQ ERLPVDP\PJRZ\PLH$]UHV]W FRPRJHP]UREL"*G\5ULHO
GRQLFKGR F]\]HPQ ]RVWDOLW\ONR%HUWL0XQDLFKE\RF]ZRUR
&]ZRURSRZLHG]LD]RZURJR%RQKDUWWRZFDOHQLHWDNGX R1LHFKW\ONR
GRJQDP\G]LHZF]\Q UXV] ]DQLPL,QDNDUPL QLPLZURQ\:LPL SHZQ\FK
SU\QF\SLyZ
'RJQDMP\M ZSLHUZXFL 3XV]F]\NQDKDMN SRS G]DM F VLZND%RUHDV
3LOQXMWURSX
.RWOLQ Z\SHQLDJ VW\NR XFKPJ\DOHZLHG]LHOL H ZGROHMHVWMH]LRURER
WXWDMZ0LO7UDFKWDZND GHMNRWOLQLHE\RMH]LRUR7R]D NXNWyUHPXZLyG ODG
NRS\WNDUHMNODF]\QLH]DZRGQLHE\RW\PNWyUHJRV]XNDOLW\PNWyUHJRND]DLP
V]XND9LOJHIRUW].WyUHGRNDGQLHLPRSLVD,SRGDQD]Z
7DP0LUD
-H]LRURE\RZ VNLHQLHV]HUV]HQL VWU]HOHQLH]XNXZWRF]RQHOHNNR]DJL W\P
SyNVL \FHPPL G]\Z\VRNLHVWURPH]ERF]DSRUR QL WHF]DUQ\P ZLHUNRZLHP
SL NQLHSRV\SDQ\PELD\P QLH Q\PSXGUHP=ERF]DVSRZLMDDFLV]DWDND H D
G]ZRQLRZXV]DFK=DPLON\QDZHWZURQ\NWyU\FK]RZLHV]F]HNUDNDQLHRG
NLONXQDVWXGQLWRZDU]\V]\RLPQDV]ODNX
7RMHVWSRXGQLRZ\NUDQLHFVWZLHUG]L%RQKDUW-H OLF]DURZQLNQLHSRNSL
]GUDG]LE\WR
'R JDGDQLDXGD3XV]F]\NSDWU] F ZW\ZPJ ZNWyUHM]QLNQ
ZUDFDM F\%RQKDUW1DSU]yG3RV]OL
&LHSOHMVL URELVDSQ %RUHDV0XQ/yG]ZLHU]FKXWRSQLHMHQDOHG VL
WZRU]\
0JDJ VWQLHMH
$OH ODG\ZFL ZLGDVWZLHUG]L'DFUH6LOLIDQW=GDMHPLVL SRQDGWR H
G]LHZF]\QDLG]LHZROQLHM7UDFLVL\
7DNMDNLP\5LHQFH]HUZDF]DSN L SRZDFKORZDVL QL
&LFKR6LOLIDQW]DWU]\PDVL QDJOH6\V]HOL FLH"&RWRE\R"
-DQLFQLHV\V]DHP
$MDWDN-DNE\]JU]\W=JU]\WSRORG]LH$OHQLHVWDPW G %RUHDV0XQ
ZVND]DZPJ ZNWyUHM]QLND\ ODG\-DNE\RGOHZHM]ERNX
7H V\V]DHPSRWZLHUG]L3XV]F]\NUR]JO GDM F VL QLHVSRNRMQLH$OHWHUD]
XFLFKR3VLDNUHZQLHSRGREDPLVL WR1LHSRGREDPLVL WR
ODG\SRZWyU]\]H]QXG]RQ\PQDFLVNLHP5LHQFH:FL ZLG]LP\MHM
ODG\2F]XQLHPDFLH"2QDLG]LHSURVWRMDNVWU]HOL*G\E\VNU FLDFKRE\QD
NURNFKRE\QDSyNURNXSR]QDOLE\ P\WRSR ODGDFK0DUV]V]\EFLHM]DFKZLO
E G]LHP\M PLHOL=DU F]DP]DFKZLO ]REDF]\P\
8UZD%RUHDV0XQZHVWFKQ D ]DJUDRPXZSXFDFK3XV]F]\N]DNO
']LHVL NURNyZSU]HGQLPLWX SU]HGZ\W\F]RQ SU]H]J VWHPOHNRPJ\
JUDQLF ZLG]LDOQR FL ODG\NR F]\\VL =QLND\
=DUD]DPRURZD
&RMHVW"
8OHFLDDF]\MDN"
1LHSRNU FLJRZ %RUHDV0XQ1LHXOHFLDD*RU]HM
5LHQFH]DNO ZXOJDUQLHZVND]XM F Z\FL WHZORGRZHMVNRUXSLHU\V\
\ Z\ZDUNQ ]DFLVNDM F EH]ZLHGQLHSL FL0LDD\ Z\L]DR \DMH
7HUD]SRPNQLHSRORG]LHMDNZLFKHU1LHGRJRQLP\MHM*G]LHFKROHUDQDMHJR
NDUNSRG]LHZDVL %RQKDUW"1LHGRJRQLP\G]LHZF]\Q\EH]NRQL
%RUHDV0XQFKU] NQ JR QRZHVWFKQ 6NHOOHQZROQRUR]SL NR XV]HN
RGVDQLDM F VNRVHPSU]HFLQDM F\SLHU EDQGROLHU]U] GHP2ULRQyZ
1LHE G]LHP\PXVLHOLMHMJRQLSRZLHG]LD]LPQR7RRQDGRJRQLQDV
2EDZLDPVL H QLHE G]LHP\GXJRF]HND
2V]DODH "
%RQKDUWWRSU]HZLG]LD'ODWHJR]DZUyFLSRNRQLD:LHG]LD H G]LHZF]\QD
ZFL JDQDVZSXDSN 8ZDJD1DGVWDZLDMFLHXV]XQD]JU]\W\ HZROyG
'DFUH6LOLIDQW]EODGE\RWRZLGRF]QHQDZHWPLPRSRNUD QLD\FKRGPUR]X
SROLF]NyZ
&KRS\ZU]DVQ 8ZDJD%DF]HQLHPLH,GRNXS\GRNXS\1LHJXEL
VL ZHPJOH
=DPNQLMVL U\NQ 3XV]F]\N=DFKRZDFLV] %H]Z]JO GQDFLV]DERQLH
XV\V]\P\
8V\V]HOL=OHZHJRQDMRGOHJOHMV]HJRNUD FDDZ\]PJ\GRELHJLFKNUyWNL
XUZDQ\NU]\N,RVWU\FKUDSOLZ\]JU]\W\ HZSRGQRV] F\ZRV\MDNSRFL JQL FLH
HOD]HPSRV]NOH
%HUWZU]DVQ 3XV]F]\N%HUW&RVL WDPVWDR"8V\V]HOLQLH]UR]XPLD\
RNU]\ND]DPRPHQW]PJ\Z\RQLVL %HUW%ULJGHQXFLHNDM F\QD]DPDQLH
NDUNX-X E G F EOLVNRSR OL]Q VL Z\ZDOLSRMHFKDEU]XFKHPSRORG]LH
'RVWDD6WLJZDUGDZ\G\V]DZVWDM F ]WUXGHP=DVLHNDZSU]HORFLH
7DNV]\ENR H OHGZRPM ZLG]LD&]DURZQLFD
6NHOOHQ]DNO 6LOLIDQWL0XQREDM]PLHF]DPLZGRQLDFKREUDFDOLVL
Z\WU]HV]F]DM F RF]\ZHPJ
=JU]\W=JU]\W=JU]\W6]\ENR5\WPLF]QLH,FRUD]Z\UD QLHM&RUD]
Z\UD QLHM
6N G WR"]DU\F]D%RUHDV0XQREUDFDM F VL ZRG] F ZSRZLHWU]XRVWU]HP
WU]\PDQHJRREXU F]PLHF]D6N G WR"
&LFKRNU]\NQ 3XV]F]\N]2ULRQHPZHZ]QLHVLRQHMGRQL&K\ED]
SUDZHM7DN=SUDZHM1DGMH G D ]SUDZHM8ZDJD
,G F\QDSUDZ\PVNU]\GOH*HPPHUF]\N]DNO QDJOHRGZUyFLVL L SRELHJQD
R OHSZHPJ FKODSL F SRWRSQLHM FHMZDUVWHZFHORGX1LHXELHJGDOHNRQLH
]G \QDZHW]QLNQ LP]RF]X8V\V]HOLRVWU\]JU]\WVXQ F\FK\ HZGRVWU]HJOL
UR]PD]DQ\UXFKOLZ\FLH ,E\VNPLHF]D*HPPHUF]\N]DZ\:LG]LHOLMDNXSDG
ZLG]LHOLV]HURNLUR]EU\]JNUZLQDORG]LH5DQQ\U]XFDVL ]ZLMDNU]\F]DZ\
3RWHPXFLFKL]QLHUXFKRPLD
$OHSyNLZ\]DJXV]\]EOL DM F\VL ]JU]\W\ HZ1LHVSRG]LHZDOLVL H
G]LHZF]\QD]GRD]DZUyFLWDNV]\ENR
:SDGDPL G]\QLFKZVDP URGHN2O +DUVKHLPDFL DZSU]HORFLHQLVNRSRG
NRODQRDPL F JRMDNVF\]RU\N=DNU FLDVL Z SLUXHFLH]DV\SXM F %RUHDVD0XQD
JUDGHPNXM F\FKGURELQORGX6NHOOHQRGVNRF]\SR OL]Q VL FKZ\FL]DU NDZ
5LHQFH
D8SDGOLREDM\ Z\]D]JU]\WD\WX RERNQLFKRVWUH]LPQHRNUXV]NL
SRN VD\LPWZDU]H-HGHQ]*HPPHUF]\NyZZU]DVQ ZU]DVNXUZDVL G]LNLP
VNU]HNLHP3XV]F]\NZLHG]LDFRVL VWDR6\V]DZLHOXOXG]LNWyU\PSRGU]\QDQR
JDUGD
2OD+DUVKHLPNU]\F]DWDU]DM F VL QDORG]LH
=JU]\W=JU]\W=JU]\W
&LV]D
3DQLH6WHIDQLHZ\EHNRWD'DFUH6LOLIDQW3DQLH6WHIDQLH:WRELH
QDG]LHMD5DWXM1LHGDMSU]HSD
2NXODZLDPQLHNXUZDDDDDGDUVL 2OD+DUVKHLP3RPy FLH PDZDV]
3RPy FLH ZVWDDDD
%RQKDUWZU]DVQ ZHPJ 6NHOOHQ%RQKDDDDUW1DSRPRRRRF*G]LH
MHVWH W\VXNLQV\QX"%RQKDDDDUW
2WDF]DQDVZ\G\V]D%RUHDV0XQREUDFDM F VL L QDGVXFKXM F-H G]LNRHP
ZHPJOH8GHU]\QLHZLHG]LHVN G PLHU7DG]LHZNDWR PLHU=GHFKQLHP\
WX% G]LHPDVDNUDMDNZ'XQ'DUHZQRF6DRYLQH
7U]\PDMFLHVL Z NXSLHM NQ 6NHOOHQWU]\PDMFLHVL Z NXSLHRQDSROXMHQD
SRMHG\QF]\FK*G\]REDF]\FLH H QDGMH G DQLHWUDFLHJRZ\5]XFDMFLHMHM
SRGQRJLPLHF]HVDNZ\SDV\&RNROZLHNE\M
1LHGRNR F]\7\PUD]HPQDZHWQLHXV\V]HOL]JU]\WX\ HZ'DFUH6LOLIDQWL
3DQLHZ\VW ND%RUHDV0XQNWyUHPXQLHZLDGRP\PVSRVREHPXGDRVL
Z\F]RJDQDOyG'DMFLHU N 3DQLHNRURQHU
:\FL JQL W\6NHOOHQ]VLQLDL]DF] VWUDV]OLZLHG\JRWD3RG6LOLIDQWHPNWyU\
XVLRZDZ\OH VNUDMNU\]DDPDVL 'DFUH]QRZX]QLNQ SRGZRG $OH]DUD]
Z\QXU]\VL NU]WXV] F VL L SOXM FQDGOXG]NLPZ\VLNLHPZ\GDUVL QDOyG
:\F]RJDDL L SDGZ\F]HUSDQ\GRJUDQLF2ERNQLHJRURVDNDX D
%RUHDVM NQ ]DPNQ RF]\6NHOOHQG\JRWD
5DWXM0XQ3RPRF\
1DVNUDMXWDIOL]DQXU]RQ\SRSDFK\ZLVLD5LHQFH0RNUHZRV\JDGNR
SU]\OHJD\PXGRF]DV]NL= E\G]ZRQL\MDNNDVWDQLHW\EU]PLDRWRMDNXSLRUQD
XZHUWXUDGRMDNLHJR LQIHPDOQHJRGDQVHPDFDEUH
=D]JU]\WD\\ Z\%RUHDVQLHSRUXV]\VL &]HND6NHOOHQG\JRWD
1DGMH G DD:ROQR=MHMPLHF]D FLHNDDNUHZ]QDF]\DOyGNURSOLVW\P
ODGHP%RUHDVSU]HNQ OLQ &KRE\GRQLWNLSU]HPRF]RQ\ORGRZDW ZRG
]URELRPXVL QDJOHRNURSQLHJRU FR
$OHG]LHZF]\QDQLHSDWU]\DQDQLHJR3DWU]\DQD5LHQFH
DQDGDUHPQLH
XVLXM FHJRZ\GRVWDVL QDNU
3RPy 5LHQFHSU]HPyJV]F] NDQLH] EyZ5DWXM
']LHZF]\QDZ\KDPRZDDREUDFDM F VL QD\ ZDFK]WDQHF]Q JUDFM 6WDDZ
OHNNLPUR]NURNXWU]\PDM F PLHF]REXU F]QLVNRZSRSU]HNXG
5DWXMPQLH]DVNRZ\F]D5LHQFHZSDMDM F ZOyGGU WZLHM FHSDOFH
8UDWXM$SRZLHPFL*G]LHMHVW<HQQHIHU3U]\VL JDP
']LHZF]\QDZROQR FL JQ DV]DO]WZDU]\,X PLHFKQ DVL %RUHDV0XQ
]REDF]\SDVNXGQ V]UDP L ]WUXGHPVWXPLNU]\N
5LHQFHSRZLHG]LDD&LULZFL X PLHFKQL WD7\SU]HFLH PLDH PQLH
QDXF]\EyOX3DPL WDV]"7\PLU NRPD7\PLSDOFDPL7\PL"7\PLNWyU\PLWHUD]
WU]\PDV]VL ORGX"
5LHQFHRGSRZLHG]LD%RUHDVQLH]UR]XPLDFRER] E\F]DURG]LHMDG]ZRQL\L
NOHNRWD\ZVSRVyEXQLHPR OLZLDM F\DUW\NXRZDQ PRZ &LULREUyFLDVL QD
\ ZDFKLXQLRVDU N ] PLHF]HP%RUHDV]DFLVQ ] E\SU]HNRQDQ\ H U EQLH
5LHQFH
DDOHG]LHZF]\QDQDELHUDDW\ONRLPSHWXGRMD]G\.XRJURPQHPX
]GXPLHQLXWURSLFLHODRGMHFKDDV]\ENRUR]S G]DM F VL RVWU\PLZ\U]XWDPLUDPLRQ
=QLNQ DZHPJOH]DPRPHQW FLFKWH U\WPLF]Q\]JU]\W\ HZ
0XQ:\Z\Z\\FL JQLMPQLHZ\V]F]HND5LHQFH]SRGEUyGNLHPQD
NUDZ G]LNU\:\U]XFLRELHU FHQDOyGSUyERZDXF]HSLVL SD]QRNFLDPLDOH
ZV]\VWNLHMX PLD]HUZDQH5R]SURVWRZDSDOFHSUyEXM F F]HSLDVL
]DNUZDZLRQHMWDIOLGR PLLQDGJDUVWNDPL%RUHDV0XQSDWU]\QDQLHJRLPLD
SHZQR SU]HUD DM F SHZQR
=JU]\W\ HZXV\V]HOLZRVWDWQLPPRPHQFLH']LHZF]\QDQDGMH G DD]
QLHVDPRZLW SU GNR FL ZU F]UR]PD]\ZDDVL Z RF]DFK1DGMH G DDVDP\P
VNUDMHPNU\PNQ DWX SU]\NUDZ G]L
5LHQFHZU]DVQ ,]DFK\VQ VL J VW RRZLDQ ZRG ,]QLNQ
1DNU]HQDUyZQLXWNLP ODG]LH\ Z\]RVWDDNUHZ,SDOFH2VLHPSDOFyZ
%RUHDV0XQZ\U]\JDVL QDOyG
%RQKDUWJDORSRZDVNUDMHPQDGMH]LRUQHMVNDUS\JQDSRZDULDFNXQLHEDF] F
H ODGDPRPHQWNR PR H SRDPDQRJLQDSU]\V\SDQ\FK QLHJLHPUR]SDGOLQDFK
2V]URQLRQHJD ]LH ZLHUNyZFKODVWD\SRWZDU]\VPDJD\SRUDPLRQDFKV\SD\
]DNRQLHU]ORGRZ\S\
-H]LRUDQLHZLG]LDFDDNRWOLQDMDNZU] F\NRFLRF]DURZQLFZ\SHQLRQDE\D
PJ
$OH%RQKDUWZLHG]LD H G]LHZF]\QDWDPMHVW
&]XWR
3 G .HOSLH
6SRGNRS\WNDUHMNODF]\V\SQ DVL ]PDU]QL WDJUXGD
&LULSU]\ZDUDGRNR VNLHJRNDUNX:LGRN FLJDM FHJRM %RQKDUWDSU]HM M
]JUR] %DDVL WHJRF]RZLHND1DP\ O RVWDZLHQLXPXF]RDZZDOFH
QLHZLG]LDOQDSL ]DFLVNDDVL MHMQD R GNX
1LHQLHPRJD]QLPZDOF]\-HV]F]HQLH
:LH D8UDWRZDM PR H W\ONR:LH D,SRUWDO7DNMDNQD7KDQHGGJG\
F]DURZQLN9LOJHIRUW]MX E\WX WX MX Z\FL JDNXQLHMU N
-HG\Q\UDWXQHNWR:LH D -DVNyNL
0JDXQLRVDVL
&LUL FL JQ DZRG]HF]XM FMDNREOHZDM QDJOHSRWZRUQHJRU FR1LHPRJ F
XZLHU]\ZWRFRZLG]LDD&RPLDDSU]HGVRE
%RQKDUWWH ]REDF]\,ZU]DVQ WULXPIDOQLH1DNUD FXMH]LRUDQLHE\RZLH \
1LHE\RQDZHWUXLQZLH \QLHE\RSRSURVWXQLF7\ONROHGZRZLGRF]Q\OHGZR
]DU\VRZDQ\SDJyUHNW\ONR]DUR QL WHJR\P]PDU]\PEDG\OHPXV\SLVNRJD]yZ
2WRWZRMDZLH DU\NQ 2WRWZRMDPDJLF]QDZLH D2WRWZyMUDWXQHN
.XSDNDPLHQL
']LHZF]\QD]GDZDDVL QLHV\V]HLQLHZLG]LH3RGSURZDG]LDNODF]Z
SREOL H SDJyUDQDNDPLHQQHXV\SLVNR8QLRVDRELHU FHNXQLHEXMDNJG\E\
]RU]HF]\DQLHELRVRP]DWRFRM VSRW\NDR
0yZLHPFL]DU\F]D%RQKDUWG JDM F VZHJRJQLDGRV]DRVWURJ H MHVWH
PRMD H ]UREL ] WRE FR]HFKF H QLNWPLZW\PQLHSU]HV]NRG]L$QLOXG]LH
DQLERJRZLHDQLGLDE\DQLGHPRQ\$QL]DNO WHZLH H-HVWH PRMDZLHG PLQNR
3RGNRZ\JQLDGRV]DG]ZRQL\QDORGRZHMWDIOL
0JDQDJOHVN ELDVL ]DZU]DDSRGXGHU]HQLHPZLFKUXVSDGDM FHJRQLH
ZLHG]LHVN G*QLDGRV]]DU DL]DWD F]\V]F]HU] F ] E\QDPXQV]WXNX%RQKDUW
RGFK\OLVL Z VLRGOH FL JQ NU OH]HZV]\VWNLFKVLERNR V]DODU]XFDEHP
WXSD OL]JDVL QDORG]LH
3U]HGQLPPL G]\QLPDEU]HJLHPQDNWyU\PVWDD&LULWD F]\QDWDIOL
QLH QRELD\MHGQRUR HFVWDM F G EDSU]\ELHUDM F SR] ]QDQ ] KHUERZ\FKWDUF]
1LH]HPQ WDNLHV]WXF]NLU\NQ RZFDRSDQRZXM F NRQLD1LHPQLH
F]DUDPLVWUDV]\'RSDGQ FL &LUL7\PUD]HPFL ]DELM ZLHG PLQNR-HVWH
PRMD
0JDVN ELDVL ]QRZX]DNRWRZDDSU]\EUDDG]LZQHNV]WDW\.V]WDW\
VWDZD\VL FRUD]Z\UD QLHMV]H7RE\OLMH G F\.RV]PDUQHV\OZHWNLXSLRUQ\FK
MH G FyZ
%RQKDUWZ\EDXV]\RF]\
1DNR FLRWUXSDFKNRQLVLHG]LD\V]NLHOHW\MH G FyZXVWURMRQHZSU]H DUWHUG]
SDQFHU]HLNROF]XJLVWU] S\SDV]F]\SRJL WHLVNRURGRZDQHKHP\XGHNRURZDQH
EDZROLPLURJDPLUHV]WNDPLVWUXVLFKLSDZLFKSLyURSXV]\6SRGRNDSyZKHPyZ
RF]\XSLRUyZ ZLHFL\VLQDZ\PEODVNLHP6]XPLD\SRGDUWHSURSRUFH
1DF]HOHGHPRQLF]QHMNDZDONDG\FZDRZD]EURMQ\]NRURQ QDKHPLH]
QDV]\MQLNLHPQDSLHUVLRELMDM F\PVL R ]DUG]HZLD\NLU\V
3UHF]]DGXGQLRZJRZLH%RQKDUWD3UHF] PLHUWHOQLNX2QDQLHMHVWWZRMD
2QDMHVWQDV]D3UHF]
-HGQHJRQLHPR QDE\R%RQKDUWRZLRGPyZLRGZDJL1LHSU]HO NVL ZLGP
2SDQRZD]JUR] QLHSRGGDVL SDQLFH
$OHMHJRNR RND]DVL PQLHMRGSRUQ\
*QLDG\RJLHUVWDQ G EDEDOHWRZR]DWD F]\QDW\OQ\FKQRJDFK]DU DG]LNR
ZLHU]JQ LSRGVNRF]\3RGXGHU]HQLHPSRGNyZOyGS N]SU]HUD OLZ\P
FKUXSHPWDIOHVWDQ \SLRQRZRWU\VQ DZRGD.R ]DNZLF]DXGHU]\RNUDZ G
SU]HGQLPLNRS\WDPLVNUXV]\M %RQKDUWZ\V]DUSQ VWRS\]HVWU]HPLRQVNRF]\
=DSy QR
:RGD]DPNQ DVL QDGMHJRJRZ :XV]DFK]DGXGQLRL]DG]ZRQLRMDNZ
G]ZRQQLF\3XFDJUR]L\S NQL FLHP
0LDV]F] FLH-HJRNRSL FHZRG VWRS\QDWUDIL\QDFR ]DSHZQHQDLG FHJRQD
GQRNRQLD2GELVL ]LPSHWHPZ\QXUNRZDSOXM F LVDSL F8FKZ\FLVL
NUDZ G]LSU]HU EOD1LHXOHJDM F SDQLFHGRE\QR DZELJRZOyGZ\FL JQ VL
/H DG\V] F FL NRZRGD FLHNDD]QLHJR]SOXVNLHP
-H]LRUROyGR QLH RQH]ERF]DF]DUQ\ELDROXNURZDQ\ ZLHUNRZ\ODV
ZV]\VWNR]DODDUDSWHPQLHQDWXUDOQDWUXSLDMDVQR
%RQKDUW]RJURPQ\PZ\VLNLHPXQLyVVL QDNRODQD
1DGKRU\]RQWHPJUDQDWRZHQLHER]DSRQ RR OHSLDM F NRURQ MDVQR FL
ZLHWOLVW NRSX ]NWyUHMZ\URV\QDJOHRJQLVWHVXS\LVSLUDOHZ\VWU]HOL\
WD F] FHNROXPQ\LZLU\ ZLDWD1DQLHERVNRQLH]DZLV\PLJRWOLZHUXFKOLZH
V]\ENR]PLHQLDM FHNV]WDW\ZVW JLLGUDSHULH
%RQKDUW]DVNU]HF]D1DJDUGOHZ\GDZDRPXVL PLD HOD]Q REU F]JDURW\
:PLHMVFXJG]LHMHV]F]HSU]HGFKZLO E\W\ONRJR\SDJyULNXSDNDPLHQL
Z]QRVLDVL ZLH D
0DMHVWDW\F]QDVWU]HOLVWDLVPXNDF]DUQDJDGNDO QL FDMDNJG\E\Z\NXWD]
MHGQHJRNDZDODED]DOWX2JLH PLJRWDZQLHOLF]Q\FKRNQDFKZ] EDW\FK
NUHQHOD DFKV]F]\WXSRQ DDXURUDERUHDOLV
:LG]LDG]LHZF]\Q REUyFRQ NXQLHPXZVLRGOH:LG]LDMHM ZLHWOLVWHRF]\L
SU]HNUH ORQ\OLQL EU]\GNLHMEOL]Q\SROLF]HN:LG]LDMDNG]LHZF]\QDSRS G]DNDU
NODF]MDNQLHVSLHV] F VL ZMH G D ZF]DUQ\PURNSRGNDPLHQQ\XNZHM FLD
-DN]QLND
$XURUDERUHDOLVHNVSORGRZDDR OHSLDM F\PLZLUDPLRJQLD
*G\%RQKDUW]DF] ]QRZXZLG]LHZLH \ MX QLHE\R%\R QLH RQ\SDJyU
NXSDNDPLHQL]HVFKHF]DUQHEDG\OH
.O F] F QDORG]LHZNDX \ FLHNDM FHM]QLHJRZRG\RZFDQDJUyG]DNU]\F]D
G]LNRRNURSQLH1DNO F]NDFKZ]QLyVV]\U FHNXQLHEXNU]\F]DZ\]RU]HF]\
L EOX QLOXG]LRPERJRPLGHPRQRP
(FKRNU]\NXWRF]\RVL SRSRUR QL W\FK ZLHUNRZLHPVNDUSDFKQLRVRVL SR
]DPDU]QL WHMWDIOLMH]LRUD7DP0LUD
:Q WU]HZLH \ ]UD]XSU]\SRPQLDRMHM.DHU0RUKHQWDNLVDPGXJLF]DUQ\
NRU\WDU]]DDUNDG WDNDVDPDQLHNR F] FDVL RWFKD Z SHUVSHNW\ZLHNROXPQOXE
SRV JyZ%\RQLHGRSRM FLDMDNLPVSRVREHPRWFKD WDPR H PLH FLVL Z
VPXN\PREHOLVNXZLH \$OHSU]HFLH ZLHG]LDD H QLHPDVHQVXSUyERZDWHJR
DQDOL]RZDQLHZSU]\SDGNXZLH \NWyUDZ\URVD]QLFR FL]MDZLDVL WDPJG]LH
MHMQLHE\R:WDNLHMZLH \ PRJRE\ZV]\VWNRLQLF]HPXQLHQDOH DRVL G]LZL
2EHMU]DDVL 1LHZLHU]\DE\%RQKDUWR PLHOLVL L ]GRDZHM WX]DQL
$OHZRODDVL XSHZQL
$UNDGDSU]H]NWyU ZMHFKDDSRQ DQLHQDWXUDOQ\PEODVNLHP
.HOSLH]DG]ZRQLDNRS\WDPLSRSRVDG]FHSRGSRGNRZDPLFR ]DFKU] FLR
.R FL&]DV]NLSLV]F]HOHNODWNL HEURZHIHPXU\PLHGQLFH-HFKDDZ UyG
JLJDQW\F]QHJRRVVDULXP.DHU0RUKHQSRP\ ODDZVSRPLQDM F8PDU\FK
SRZLQQRVL ]DNRS\ZDZ]LHPL-DN H WRE\RGDZQR:WHG\ZLHU]\DPMHV]F]H
Z FR WDNLHJR:PDMHVWDW PLHUFLZV]DFXQHNGOD]PDU\FK$ PLHUWRSR
SURVWX PLHU$]PDU\WRW\ONR]LPQ\WUXS1LHMHVWZD QHJG]LHOH \JG]LH
SUyFKQLHM MHJRNR FL
:MHFKDDZPURNSRGDUNDG\PL G]\NROXPQ\LSRV JL&LHPQR ]DIDORZDD
MDNG\PXV]\Z\SHQL\MHMQDWU WQHV]HSW\ZHVWFKQLHQLDFLFKHLQNDQWDFMH3U]HG
QL QDJOH]DSRQ DMDVQR RWZDU\VL JLJDQW\F]QHGU]ZL2WZLHUD\VL MHGQHSR
GUXJLFK'U]ZL1LHVNR F]HQLHZLHOHGU]ZLRFL NLFKVNU]\GDFKRWZLHUDRVL
SU]HGQL EH]V]PHUX
.HOSLHV]DG]ZRQL F SRGNRZDPLSRSRVDG]FH*HRPHWULDRWDF]DM F\FKM FLDQ
DUNDGLNROXPQ]RVWDDQDJOH]DNyFRQDWDNJZDWRZQLH H &LULSRF]XD]DZUyW
JRZ\:\GDRMHMVL H ]QDMGXMHVL ZHZQ WU]MDNLHM QLHPR OLZHMZLHOR FLHQQHM
EU\\MDNLHJR JLJDQW\F]QHJRRNWDHGUX
'U]ZLRWZLHUD\VL QDGDO$OHQLHZ\W\F]D\MX MHGQHJRNLHUXQNX:\W\F]D\
QLHVNR F]HQLHZLHOHNLHUXQNyZLPR OLZR FL
$&LUL]DF] DZLG]LH
&]DUQRZRVDNRELHWDSURZDG] FD]DU N SRSLHODWRZRV G]LHZF]\Q
']LHZF]\QDERLVL ERLVL FLHPQR FLO NDVL URVQ F\FKZPURNXV]HSWyZ
SU]HUD D M G]ZRQLHQLHSRGNyZNWyUHV\V]\&]DUQRZRVDNRELHWD]HVNU] F VL
RGEU\ODQWyZJZLD]G QDV]\LWH VL ERL$OHQLHGDMHWHJRSRVRELHSR]QD
3URZDG]LG]LHZF]\Q GDOHM.XMHMSU]H]QDF]HQLX
.HOSLHNURF]\1DVW SQHGU]ZL
,ROD'UXJDL(XUQHLGZNR XV]NDFK]WRERNDPLPDV]HUXM ]PDU]QL W\P
R QLH RQ\PJR FL FHP1LHERMHVWJUDQDWRZH
1DVW SQHGU]ZL
,ROD3LHUZV]DNO F]\SU]HGRWDU]HP2ERNQLHMPDWND1HQQHNH2ELHSDWU]
WZDU]HZ\NU]\ZLDLPJU\PDVSU]HUD HQLD&RZLG] " 3U]HV]R F]\SU]\V]R "
3UDZG F]\QLHSUDZG "
1DGQLPLRELHPD1HQQHNHL,RODU FH:\FL JQL WHZJH FLHERJRVDZLH VWZD
U FHNRELHW\R]RW\FKRF]DFK:QDV]\MQLNXNRELHW\EU\ODQW ZLHF F\MDNJZLDGD
]DUDQQD1DUDPLHQLXNRELHW\NRW1DGMHMJRZ VRNy
1DVW SQHGU]ZL
7ULVV0HULJROGSRGWU]\PXMHVZRMHSL NQHNDV]WDQRZDWHZRV\V]DUSDQHL
SO WDQHSRU\ZDPLZLDWUX3U]HGZLDWUHPQLHPDXFLHF]NLQLFSU]HGZLDWUHPQLH
RVWDQLH
1LHWX1LHQDV]F]\FLHZ]JyU]D
1DZ]JyU]HZNUDF]DGXJLQLHNR F] F\VL V]HUHJFLHQL3RVWDFL,G ZROQR
1LHNWyU]\RGZUDFDM NXQLHMWZDU]H=QDMRPHWZDU]H9HVHPLU(VNHO/DPEHUW
&RHQ<DUSHQ=LJULQL3DXOLH'DKLEHUJ)DELR6DFKV-DUUH7LVVDLDGH9ULHV
0LVWOH
*HUDOW"
1DVW SQHGU]ZL
<HQQHIHU]DNXWDZD FXFK\SU]\PRFRZDQHGRRFLHNDM F\FKZLOJRFL FLDQ
ORFKX-HMGRQLHV MHGQ PDV VNU]HSHMNUZL&]DUQHZRV\VWDUJDQHL
]PLHU]ZLRQH8VWDUR]ELWHLRSXFKQL WH$OHZILROHWRZ\FKRF]DFKZFL QLH
]JDV]RQDZRODZDONLLRSRUX
0DPXVLX7U]\PDMVL :\WU]\PDM,G FLQDSRPRF
1DVW SQHGU]ZL&LULRGZUDFDJRZ =SU]\NUR FL ,]D HQRZDQLHP
*HUDOW,]LHORQRRNDNRELHWDRF]DUQ\FKNUyWNRRVWU]\ RQ\FKZRVDFK2ERMH
QDG]\=DM FLSRFKRQL FLVRE 'DZDQ VRELHZ]DMHPUR]NRV]
&LULRSDQRZXMH FLVNDM F JDUGRDGUHQDOLQ SRS G]D.HOSLH.RS\WDVWXNDM :
FLHPQR FLW WQL V]HSW\
1DVW SQHGU]ZL
:LWDM&LUL
9\VRJRWD"
:LHG]LDHP H FLVL XGDG]LHOQDSDQQR0RMDP QD-DVNyNR:\V]D EH]
V]ZDQNX"
3RNRQDDPLFK1DORG]LH0LDDPGODQLFKQLHVSRG]LDQN \ Z\WZRMHM
FyUNL
0LDHPQDP\ OLV]ZDQNSV\FKLF]Q\
3RZVWU]\PDDP]HPVW 1LH]DELDPZV]\VWNLFK1LH]DELDP3XV]F]\ND
&KRWRRQPQLH]UDQLLRV]SHFL2SDQRZDDPVL
:LHG]LDHP H ]Z\FL \V]=LUHDHO, H ZHMG]LHV]GRZLH \&]\WDHP
SU]HFLH R W\P%RWRMX ]RVWDRRSLVDQH7RZV]\VWNRMX ]RVWDRRSLVDQH
:LHV]FRGDM VWXGLD"8PLHM WQR NRU]\VWDQLD]H UyGH
-DNWRPR OLZH H UR]PDZLDP\9\VRJRWR&]\W\7DN&LUL8PDUHP$
QLHZD QH:D QLHMV]HMHVWF]HJRVL GRZLHG]LDHPQDFRZSDGHP-DMX ZLHP
JG]LHSRG]LD\VL VWUDFRQHGQLFRVWDRVL QDSXVW\QL.RUDWKMDNLPVSRVREHP
]QLND ] RF]XSRJRQL
,MDNLPVSRVREHPZHV]DPWXGRWHMZLH \WDN"6WDUV]D.UHZNWyUDS\QLHZ
1DMH]LRU]HOH DDPJLHNDOHFLXWNLMDNSXFKRSDUV]\ENR]ZLHZDQ\ZLDWUHP
3RZLHU]FKQLDZRG\E\DJDGNDMDNOXVWURQD]LHORQ\FKG\ZDQDFKSDVNLFKOL FL
JU]\ELHQLDELHOD\NZLDW\
%U]HJLWRQ \Z]LHOHQLLNZLHFLX
%\RFLHSR
%\DZLRVQD
&LULQLHG]LZLDVL -DNPRJDVL G]LZL"3U]HFLH WHUD]ZV]\VWNRE\R
PR OLZH/LVWRSDGOyG QLHJ]PDU]QL WDJUXGDXV\SLVNRNDPLHQLQDQDMH RQ\P
EDG\ODPLSDJyU]HWRE\RWDP$WXWDMMHVWWXWXWDMVWU]HOLVWDED]DOWRZDZLH D ]
] EDW\PLEODQNDLPQDV]F]\FLHRGELMDVL Z ]LHORQHMXVLDQHMELHO QHQXIDUyZ
ZRG]LHMH]LRUD7XWDMMHVWPDMERSU]HFLH Z PDMXNZLWQLHG]LNDUy D LF]HUHPFKD
.WR Z SREOL X JUDQDIXMDUFHOXEIOHWQLZ\JU\ZDZHVR VNRF]Q PHORG\MN
1DEU]HJXMH]LRUDSU]HGQLPLQRJDPLZZRG]LHVWD\SLM FGZD QLH QRELDH
NRQLH.HOSLHSDUVNQ DXGHU]\DNRS\WHPRVND :WHG\NRQLHXQLRV\JRZ\L
RFLHNDM FHZRG FKUDS\D&LULZHVWFKQ DJR QR
%RWRQLHE\\NRQLHOHF]MHGQRUR FH
&LULQLHG]LZLDVL :]G\FKDD]SRG]LZXQLH]H]G]LZLHQLD
0HORGL V\FKDE\RFRUD]Z\UD QLHMGRELHJDD]]DREZLHV]RQ\FKELD\P
NZLHFLHPNU]DNyZF]HUHPFK\.HOSLHUXV]\DZWDPW VWURQ VDPDEH] DGQHJR
SRQDJODQLD&LULSU]HNQ D OLQ 2EDMHGQRUR FHQLHUXFKRPHMDNSRV JLSDWU]\\
QDQL RGELMDM F VL Z JDGNLHMMDNOXVWURWDIOLZyG
=DNU]DNLHPF]HUHPFK\VLHG]LDQDRNU J\PNDPLHQLXMDVQRZRV\HOIR
WUyMN WQHMWZDU]\LRJURPQ\FKPLJGDRZ\FKRF]DFK*UD]U F]QLHSU]HELHUDM F
SDOFDPLSRSLV]F]DNDFKIOHWQL&KRZLG]LD&LULL.HOSLHFKRSDWU]\QDQLHQLH
SU]HVWDZDJUD
%LDHNZLDWXV]NLSDFKQLD\]F]HUHPFK R WDNLQWHQV\ZQ\P]DSDFKX&LULQLJG\
Z \FLXVL MHV]F]HQLH]HWNQ D,QLFG]LZQHJRSRP\ ODD]XSHQLHSU]\WRPQLHZ
ZLHFLHZNWyU\P \DPGRWHMSRU\F]HUHPFK\SRSURVWXSDFKQ LQDF]HM
%RZWDPW\P ZLHFLHZV]\VWNRMHVWLQQH
(OI]DNR F]\PHORGL SU]HFL J\PZ\VRNLPWUHOHPRGM IOHWQL RGXVWZVWD
'ODF]HJRWDNGXJR"VS\WD]X PLHFKHP&RFL ]DWU]\PDR"
.21,(&7208&=:$57(*2