You are on page 1of 111
meakingin 1995 taboo-brtking Gem DIRECTORS’ COTS fic on te srk giant eee | the cinema of LARS VON TRIER filmmakers, iho Uniensy Sh ithe cdi of 2007) and has publ cm Hochotnal rch and P raph rye ye her sien oe Dr Ca ere ste soma of EMIR KUSTURICA: ats fio hn thine of REN LOCH: av es of there thn WIM WENDERS: hid enone KATHERYN BIGELOW: or the cinema of Sits seer cman asssons LARS VON TRIER the cinoma of ROBERT LEPAGE: de pis ofmomry ee authenticity and artifice SSemgCngmgy sates rte ee ome een eae ae ee Bae deanery ieee Gaba tion wow he ies of JOHN CARPENTER: the ci of err ol gate aac ae tan Se rc aneatsc neve Analy Mfr | om nfm Tee Tank An An Elton oTchaigne and Sie WKF ON Te Fao Tog Wp Vion of timry 28 Fi dain and Mey {YAW TWO Tnirmaone TVR Cop Daa 98 ‘Seer Zam ean mca mig ng hei A Now Vion: Doge 95 ad the Digital Revoon 3 “a npn tb nn ete pb bk DNirnive Since, Narre Codes and Quedoas of Gea 2 cote ahr iim enh ny fl Specuontip een Dien ince GoldHearilogy 31 Is sr 05 pba Gatmsocaca fas YOUN bpetinninn ihe Bound eee Aion he Ming Dien mde ie nd di eye Suen and Manton 62 AckNowLEDGEMENTS “Ws ak hs he er ur fy and prs of pete, sad sen Ao vewoke des bdo Maing Wie Tun snd Eis in the Wok ‘an Tr. wich ws pubs a he oral fr Cabal Roar (20088 3 DAI Sone he marlin chagrin Jt Lookin Tae ho nd Speci which ws abled See CD, 4, 4,353 un pl he sap and esorgemen of many cleus the dpa Pym Sesar the Universo Est Laon and Maia and Cala 4 oxapon Unies, specly Dr Pal Bows De Bon Coding. De Tot De He Oraceing aod Dr Pal Rizo In pari {woul ie Hk Dr At Bes Dr Deira Je an Dr Heather Nan ll of wo al end, cocks ands spp ea on many cans sw yo va dcp Spl hank ede omy dea ke aed iy Ca Yt wh ee nd pied ape my wok he The pur funbenicty tough atoning nc: Hower Deion (2008) sug, Wheneerthe asthe in ett od Gt on oak Athi pond he For aon Ter ep fate ie ‘heat iemainn becca neon thea thar en o pe ‘meas fee a the anny of bure cka valcad Fm he anley OF te ee ners of inves aoa he pean of hi wok, Tr “pins tha "When gto denn youbaeo rae somes of ay xe tees, ie whe yu ca cond ing You contol ina i Tht ity fo tna for een ns, i (man 203 19) Fer veo Tr hen, Shc can enc toring pin which he experince of hint eal and dtd and inthe come o which a ween be deed The stag fr utes pal one the arog rs see a For Tet Sir anche iam oak wich pp ck pn an ie ‘oder ently i ira ebespecy o iana Ing moder teste fe sure rn para the “irs naeing nt en tcoe vonTic wok nl me fe char ‘ct a postmoden poration AG doe whe wor rode nthe ater ‘lomo moc ofS at ene as Miro Ande! Tl. 1975) an ‘chef Orn Wels 1958) aps sar vedere aon of Yok ‘oh myname as produce ees frogs and sie, on Tre ‘os a a earn fared shes. Home Dk ‘poe pe hi eion and on Tiers nics baling iin pla that od he pec fh wok These of on Tet wk iby now eer mere ache 27 yas ct roducin oir finch 16m srt, Nar (1980 wom Ties pda 2 po wed incrporting the pif feu laste evs ses ‘nd von pc een me vide andar elites Hel och Inert pie evden ine cone of ce nde dhe anno te Dogme 95 and Aa Party pj and write ad podcd Sas made by ver eos th Thoms Vie fil logy ind a teed 1 the ves ing eae fx of ce poe) Asa ai, von week tinted thet fl, ay a tier ema peje ‘fm wih ie and dip etl The cio of dena ue ‘hen han gry bce cael his oa a ee Ath ne ng at Ter ep how thane pera pest wou do ot wth eat an Beno i extuotaty nk uno sos procs of int nd Menai. The woe fie ited one of “Tike ind conc on Ter wok mn expla ithe corteson of is Tonk da i tion eee ute and are dha ie on Ts ety fing Wey and ving up Bis wok ceting new a port “Tetons thf of iin be meni ery To ied cisbook st at ‘ea peal ith Lae on Tt fn and nex wt ch ul expr oH woe Testes afc al ics en celine scape i 0 by ‘gt ky infact te ls lh ae noe serio (feet eas pd wlchar ao bay aan DVD. Homeport (Satna th ways in ick any of he darshan nso ope Uncen chanal ft sprain nasa 00 Teen shor Ss ‘hn aegis deans, wn i ad art nao ack ‘Steno (200) nly they fers ad y voi oside edo of imran debt era Teirwoh ning bower hc may ofthe xy hanes harem and pr son Tien fi ethene fr th wrk alow- In Bible mag Fine 198) example the ee of ibd ee he leet of Ce and Ea (991) a ely dered yon Ter eos be doing rch Des ying on ence pie Na fers igh ‘Theol teraion heen of Word Warn al (988) eles ls aged rsp by Ca Theor Dj apd eed elm Demi ae on VHS (ance ses of wn er comer with ee inne ai fr mare ae ‘Litne. Sc mes cme driv Ter er wrk a coups thee ccs in bya sengeance an nh hs cation wi sissy ad hes fondne nth nsf he Goll Hae egy (Braking We (1990 “nue ie i, 1998), Dan ese Dar (200) ain tei mo Bis he ‘USA Lando Opportunity Depil(2003); Maney (209) “Tito eon sw on thal can be made dough a aa of oo Tt eu ad se nd wh ees oh ees faiaton with ln ‘Sted anv, By inept ea Tan wo hoya ‘Atul wus and by ding pra theses © ep te slason [two ai dena og hat utes a ein ee fron Tice Ts peop oe Gly signed is his opin of he Ys he he of hsp mame ngs ane for hil a Sig Bhan (Gs) gg) won Tier cena acter bl by His poe peter writs ao bt gig he enc posing quent ‘dw nr emmy, Undine masgcre, owee, ng, “Sammie che pent abe and means ing mode expres Ini ee posses a layin sign sem and Bare proves wi x ‘ein hs anf alin fod andthe Gabon ate (meng other hing) (thse hide. Fr example, hia be sen I i ing ania he ‘rin which dau and vale sound ice pcan, lay sprency td Teel ety we compound ie aon the oe ce of art ack ‘magi shoving «young Mickel sting in deference owt ned co eth Pc (1972 119. What Barthes donanae sear in doable incon: pins ow and i mots, makes ws undead mein ad "impoverion of (1972117). Hemen of year bound the seme a ‘epesenctio nie which they anton bu they ral ate y thes ‘Nertclan mys har, sh wid Gem Undine ha come acy ery purr url pon wa ces el of toga satu Many Ele tersrand cc comment open how Halpern In grclat hs Beane a mode of mytaking am fy which poe sales ines sete te dre Meso dn, fn oe 1 facton aan cea signing opm, an appar dgh which ear ‘alsa ne repre but ale frm scoring sin cla sora egal ale ye Iw ici reference vo cinema hisory, then, ‘apt eo mythlogal era ber eal bt m po rf coca so Ingen bats tha leek of aera” a coe wo chrcertsvon Tit fs [A caper ne mae det, te weaning nde os ot dear on ited peri f ceric ips lnncad: wen the En ‘logy Yon Tier mec an ary f dict, pe snd ene ccanping ‘laa Haliywond (Oren Well, Aled Hick, lms Mane Dei Tatianna ean (Raber Rolin Feet Felis Geman Espresso [New Gama Cina Pte Lang, UFA Werner Heo Rune Wee aside, ‘Manprethe on Tr) and Eagan at ets nga Bean Co hn Drees Ande Toy Le Goda. The lar of incetealyevoning tough the ‘Eros logy ae eer comple, the. lntercenley works longi mythlog” to produc clad ‘utc ofthe ighy mead vioament of ery ely. As St Lah as Sgt, ‘Wea ling ina vce in which ea prpindcel aa len vo rprecins 9 seal” (98024. ofthe peo ie ‘erly cael oh ay nerplie he pecan anon the cea {Spal wih which he ir net Howe, lo cnt ptt hgh oonraton of ciel dtc, lo eprcting ements of ches es tet twoiethe tial einer ta objec plas at gai bch fyi ‘momento mythology caning with cence tot fee, ht ‘ating ec to casing to manure dunce th be ich "cna any te capcky den meaning’ Tene, oe shor dug wih queson of sen bch nm, cena dian of oso, and th import in detain pl efitvenee? Inde Europ egy he qusion funy cra te fic nae se Vo Tier cnc qunion a dic wayne of ln Io The let °f ine fr xp Fv purl what shal be ued et Is dogged vexgion of Osbourn (End Keg) hypothe around ii ‘lity is imines paring Har Gen he marke Fer eli oon of uh and sets out on ony tht ens is demise. His anton made xpi fo the Bi opening ene inch wee Faber big hypo in Calo Sd in wih is lnging or Europe eos frat ir nc fact Ln pide the qin of ue rane hog the le ihn th cing on Dr Meane (Lar von Tier) tence o he ety ofthe plague, Auten {hits mpoby ae als embded in he araie race fhe ing ly 2 von Tier and low xpi Nic Vor urge pode mp in fv das noe mee dhe denne inp on thm by tht proces aden up inked by the nol lage athe Bare fh ln they wrt The budai a th edly and Bion bce red ere, ighighing she compl lip fh sons of cna and poli ve oe nd fide fay In Bap of eoue, utente a ened conc of te ple whch arate ‘many hand mon concerns For eampl dre ane in whch the compl Bp rater orn a he ip of rm Ue Wee fhe Ames ty ace te dominant pace hing Jesh eo eo the fendi of known Nani oder to ape the erage of ayn the coatwcen pogumnein poet Geman The tic i of Lo Kerr ean Ma Har matron ao aquest ough be semen fom ruber afore pion ae elt tha of ur hough tee mares commcny onthe pool bjee plot skein she pura of utes Iie ng tha cach of be lw oy ees a oe ono Germany 5 the eat of Europe, Germany o's hey mytlogy runing hag hie tly ae er aon el oat the “Ea lgy won Tet dems on + umber of alo cba datos sen of Germann The lef Cr, th Bi ope cot Ca the prog ype ean Je Ivor or dhe Seimei ene ye in 2 amp ora hs hed ne hr rere by Germany gid dough the ole we ofthe lpg oi tee tht Germany ntl we he ofthe Inst a fa pen pon and Bupa Germany ite exit Te the mies, wite he ie ln ely sgaling whe ete tate Byker plc in Germany the Year Ze In cach ofthe Ri making up the i vn errr to trope twp i ir ln choo gracnon pcre, ager of ashe ss hac i te asf eee bey oman Ce one tn: He ba coment at hi bone eo be he nef th icy they non op get very hing ing ur cy bee lr cer he sae ot ‘of woul atthe to sham, whether or on you've actually heen ther Clie are ke opt an 2009 47-8), Slr en Tie fs engin ent or Dame, Crt) cyt ke Wn they ok mt Ero beet hihigh heparan fhe "Cen en, fn mae of conte ia vos Th werk ty he oer in gape a npc non toh llr northern Ear pram eure. Germany isin rms of 9 might and in ao wo so (So benvef hc Aurr-thngn Engl Vn Tit ee Pt pd ty Gemany iin theagh perl land fy, In ot cet ‘terete of couse Germany neato be undestodnrt of rin the won was ern hit al of the wen ena Fem dhe ut of isco vo Tr nein Gea hae ed the experince feet ‘the end of Word War I, Germany ecm the te of aed tenga pe ‘ogering snd sara ool bel fhe yma af ower nd capi iwc, Gamay sm nl to be nde in wlan ogra nd ioral ants Aa se fle ay re ne of te mos ieee ‘tide th Used Soe, Ar a fm cat vo Tr edn of Germany the Lev ef Enraged o he cen tier we a ected with Exper ‘Soi he bth of fl rs of propaganda ls andthe contra of ln 22a Ica pins othe nproenction of Geman in ay mambe of cemate ‘wets cocmpuning mat fil and ri’ ln ar well a oedema. The Foca on Germany cn shoot uly be prt rom he ontempory c and grpoil cmnto the f pan gen the ingot eeopcas trol he Earp Unio ra th changing cape of Eamonn set “he consracton of Germany’ In von Tins thn complex ad aes toecte comicetinn juts apes weer of ierected payers nthe incon ofthe can ache pmb and Keni lve Ke paraly Ineong sha ouch ofthe bbc omer of Germany a3 ema omc tral srg ence fm ry in vo Tiers wok di eon of (Germanys cacy ied nt of thi Fo ramp the ia of Gen qeecln Epacwc tray ge del claps farmer ee ntl Bit ‘ced by Holood ae pve allowing Word Wa Chaperone ced tome of thee rg, cing te uch Brn Bip, Garman Yar Z and A ‘Brig Afr As Rooind Galt ha uggoned in aon Earp, ‘he hor ad geographic sein for Zone [empl s oc ment fog octet loaton ea pce verti nner Sim hior ais Europa pls. Ths 140s (i ls poiesome ln hort mow one nage of Geman Tare to hee fie is invoke Germany pose by ake on 2 ded and unin dpe Zope pe rr of popes by de often eet teo-Gemman fm repetng Germ in 1945, Bu i ao ernie, ‘and elaboreves this work through extensive visual and narrative references. eto nee he wy in wich uh of he ein chs The sting of The Elon of resi vio ofthe dele sce of Earp dn waren and wi in roe dws o he here af ei by UFA ding the 1201 ad 1930 sting ik ewe he Valo rensnnng of Espreionin a ar and the wok of disc mach at "Wr Langan Mma among ots In pei he ery ae ofthe F(t sitio dpe) ewes Kelle seca wih che le may andthe United Sener nich coe theese eds of le so dws hy onthe Waghsan ope dion. The af mae he infec of Ries Wee uid and Wien Wee, Thee a pram contst beteen tes and pls ape of he leit ik ming i wich ee pany ahd af ein sy, marking Wt Inet the New Geman Cinema ‘udergoand Rie The copa an the nae in von Trt eaten of Germany’ yagi he sil fis la apather iporane myth a trey std o Brereeeteiey Sigs Mitac ‘the hart f the work, The complex layers of lntertxtuaicy allude 10 the roo of Slime nde es ge ny a arp ‘phe Castel cng el mpg ao Sy te ap ly p oc nr ipl es ‘rap ve anya Une Sas oe hie eases Site plndey. Ome spe eigenen nero ye ang pnp ae fl ar nel ol eset ea crane od ine on ly mi dead on nce wih of end ef by el gh image fps a ‘ Poll value Arse of oppsnalwerldiws andthe arpstion of last eommunsen te Gamay ofthe pid precling theillof he Ben| Whi rovers trope forvonTerof the dacunivecomtrcinn fu nspon, sous In The Ble of Come fr instance the opec of Earp pe Sa hough ef Germanic inecion murky nd ope cee snd “atl deening The eens of eon, rate nd far of rep runing Vong he lm eek ofthe altri aod prt ate pp es an hl late pon fay and per Dap theft tthe re nfl in th Engh guste pe fre red bythe Geran a aaa he degoyment of costae and ote spe ofthe mine ‘ ksgnd heighten the sifing marr acne wth he apps egimes power mos quel algal withthe commun poll postin cpio (omg eigiting te wn Expo pti cert ‘OF nest ht ithe way on Tir ao the fn si ste his werk ‘hem sy ofthe fn eat cegig em Halve cb ad ‘ympeomaccaly in aon oe en he ofc nd ext ee ned with nes Europ nang dit of dare cantons vor Te dfs lr place ary and an neve mene fh Commit ca bese king wp povociive poston inde pers he lat ‘scumpins of msn cine n The Bee of Gime ad Ea on Tit eso prsethe question ef mph forthe ages, wih wa fis eo ln padutin i, ae of elf Agung Edn ha ‘Sk sl ke ‘eo yoursha sr Tier se ou oan and odie rely “amas pec he Geman prin eine Oe se nematic ean he rn with sence on of Eampe at Forve Ties rp tndn ops Asi, amon which ba spp ad marlin tn pel lsd ich yo Te opt CS poche ss sha untlee a heeding ft of he ‘mms tlh he ae which pe dtm the Une See be “ote nd pwd with tds teed or compe tennant inf he Eup egy en Ter ser eo ts of Geman cynic cb gp hr ly econo 1 Thon cll uty och toi cles hen a ‘moro aed ihe ype etn he Amen cs te fim nat ee cere (San 249 The myc er ofthe nrc naw befound at bata ape fro Trad ryote sof Goma Te Gey ef hci pein which wT ad ee compen candela poli eps cabodjings gf en mado ld and og {et alu Germany cnr no sop ovens nt ogee asthe ope of ange pl nponsopeaing imide de oss tcomespno woo wich nombre cmd ue dor lel fom sland wastes sound sgl nm ad en {Chapt wl yo ep ten ee deh) By theme Ee ate ple of Spe hal hed. he fof the Bin Wal in 989 a ot se bsg th Pre ed cote Fanpe anda opened wan wh st of emi bee tpl at roa seg apes Un Te qo eat woo be end Eon bat abou of debe ms many ce (pollicl, Wdeologheal and econoente consents and this continues to dae (Mader 2001; Ne 200; Bros 8 North 2005 and 2000) Fury wa eel 19, ye ‘ed an pemenc The coe of hee of hl hen ring in ro the wy pes an emer naloy a what Erope mg be ent te Ga a aged neigh fl nro the nblene eenthip ec Germany no and Germany 1945, ba tab map cred Earpean sg fom which oa 2005 17). Dacing the calibre Europea oe: ning fr ce, be a og Earp sens haya due binds it os back om x ary hat so ‘oder Th wo see Buope a the mane of renin dhe sno tle Epe cre parton, Wha cents the isto rags thst tha nectar he pra dete ‘es neinle disppoinmens, [mp] seus the imply of ‘tg aly Euopean ap, but In aging the clei of he cont sent joni oral ct bio gine the sas he le ‘Europe olde the dominae Worn dune (200515) Ics inereing char he eon of this psn crag all the len hie tragyande ce thew Yo Tier drs pons dnt blogg doe trae quan aca what tes tbe Eaopen ach ln pple wih his ine of nao of hisoy a ald ote bu thy abo make eee wr af the menpor fhe pct oor eon the ops iwc pore a se sche nets of je ad power Mach the wok in thea trl fs dyed on he scan thier othe en ety ed is mpracoin though a tint pce apeoch of and mien tne ‘hich reinicenr fhe Moder nea demons he ata of myth though romeo deeing bor eat, Taree ergy nena igus cals eneson me feel cmv ion fhe la ent snd theo hi nara Trugho, on Tier mbes Kwa cam with mugs of yard he Ege en ope by Fr csperinenntion in thw of abil oor sae, fon and apes ‘nd mper impos, For uml acer ute cat in Te Ele of Cine the Faber dep joven the hotel wth Kn Me Me Lal ae ‘al sent or dean age Scone nich che sal encoarer erento “hare om th bonne of car arin with Fer lings emoxonl ‘Son ound theca of Har Grea biexperencf nea dace Bound tpt he contin of ge othe pn, uber gins el he pain of lary Gey mein, with he oe ht he nvigon Ico 2 me hor forthe me ivenigaton of Fars spon. The ming cone of he iar inporant ee a bps of Fahri ine hoe ee with stat of wc fr the viewer The in weed qusion af he elain af ally ‘ony corer pet inh Bi The use of hypraas o« mechaniam by which the fle tn de erlogy eight be desde import gpl ih lterelsip betwen and cry tht ura he la’ ten fhe omen? Th ree ‘an for unending the may thei come carmen he coterporay ‘apernce of whaet meso Earp ery Fay and Eup Vivian Soba hn ged hat ixory ms aos be ude smehisony sd et htop abo aang and eing mi ther hn ding {ny Kind of bjt eth 996 4). emcee, den, or elon (ohn crys mecirdee, hr tse th rahi jo fanny mic nore Bind expr, et ys be prin word techy ‘ended ho what Ft cal sopdon of eprentin in ore te ec Sle = ar Lie ory, aay lays conveyed and thee rode {any arp dep eV Tare of poo pnt plone ‘of nave fr utes ry efi cis ep AS Sobek as saad, Iris “appe’ happes en in he res the empor pace tee the pad the ure, Butte eitece of icy gg ‘onpond cme and pd conker or x agi ed ‘igance ta cnr om hip eon and mak oe oF ‘hope ahd ter something trp ate (1996: 14) “Theses of inary doughou ewig hey sen, rey connected othe hema of Germany in the lis. Thi binge anderandig che ay 00 “Ter eal oper oer ndeneding of ery fo ape itn of hat nde she conmpoty cla poston fn coin Erope The soy of Germany (Goan bon of Sop) ond ton br me of Bape! eh ee ‘nc hgh the in the logy Ti agp hat he ep oF hry incon at Kindo spam of eel eaumas tat Seine the "pen frmton of Esper Mee Ther exenie renin of Weld Wil and he es ofthe xine of dfn teers of har with wich we Ter engage an Be dae a ‘womens fal au in Earopen bis, 2 EA Kaplan as nod, I wha sre i pole to sek onl gum? Whe alge righ poe Bows ea of nda sd curler? Cold ‘rey hatin aca aren individu an cnr re ‘hangs best ple of Thar in tonsa te Tne share, yer naitng ot semen, isting 0 epg ent presen? (201: 202) Wisin discontent that won Ther use of the crope of hyponis became interesting, ‘swale uly see th wpe of hypo laye an mprtan par shaping he Ante tent of pce ood tne in he logy, The cece nla he [bernie npr hee, poo ia yf experi epee memo fi hey and lise ne way he sujet te prow aed he Tn illo the repel memoria ake ae comple wang they dow Ih che compen an eta aie aed te ute cs Teg Hypo, there a opprny wo maa the compe of dae eet wh ¢ owing through them aed dey idgaf ing wich her. Wh Is tray hypo ly empha by von Tera Bune spec, ina flor ny of poston the pectoral vitae area een ich tien het whine nd oly ace, nh cote os od Five ey which com 6 Be a ee he fv Ter eager at gh IB tment ‘he aston of Ea a pia pace ‘lay bes fliypooeaa mean wnching epee ntor eno om he pee pic of mace or eel seo. This wed xn Ve tne fhow ha inser revue psp he ihn ga Inthe content of procera en The croing th sing ean fw be undated sre in eel comet lig the ease a Yo Tet is can fly be inate by rene chee The mae of nema sac bt the elon of aya Mary Ine sabumed whi the fra pct of he at ors ep with ep othe my of emt daca be sn prelim (ne Ene 200; ‘ipl 2001 Rone 20; Ten 2001 Inde Kaplan age, dependent tte cig show para epeton, cecal pecs af he nw eps of aura and ye ofthe seh ote ts a 001 208. The Ine of hype a dain pe on Ts Europ logy Bight the ned tn etnies pain (and fen andeguty ackmlgd pat undring the fat ai ww Eaope ety th cof Ka nd pl ast daring hela 4nd ely 19s dng tein othe ey of Ver and of ware moral dent Yor Ter line eg pessoa theses da compleate de argo ase anew ene of eso cegng eet sich the dereopmen of he Europe Union ad tel ef he Bein Wil Hypo den, bene cll ruse hgh which alam he sv impli nde eeopmnent. Ar Marc Tri re see cant that mig be pt ideo buys pas eat ad no en ‘edad hough cn) be bed aoe oly by lt emer, bt alr “onsitanyby clo make th coe been he aan tk era he pene (2001: 207) his prey wha ia pla ne migh age hat on Te ‘in he phone depen of hypo nd ‘vod mas ood play 0 hein alin of the power of cinema to address these fundamental aspects of (supra-Jnational history and Meni The deplomene of formal exgerinenation aco ihe fs wok ogee wih this rte smatte© mytlog ey mmen of steal wumea a bucked in my tht peas hse ry tomes fam at natal the Farman of nor tele aound the Farman fay “Epes Mey Following Feds eso, Haya Whe (199) gc ttc an apron a be rad finden Mori i sein thst one ese omch nay ‘hath hn of etic nd placed with an oer aching aro of this mylogallnporance:Highlghing the way in mich uma ees en thr efoto leq membered, Whit sagen at Maden cigs reprenatin provide the pili of deh ‘gtr and he nny scout tech deny thee ey pe inthe oso pretending epee thon rely Tl de Feng can then care way otha proce of ough lone can tine the ue of history and make a mn, ely ale eeptinn feat problems pone (196: 32) In aig then orens of clu tam underlain de emergent Seeman af Erp ety though he op fips hen on Tes Ri, ‘ren me ofthe cme ofthe dee mony pose ht eed Bad ‘oom fr epreaion inthe lon of European fe Tat cee tea of ‘orgs of epee fail wm pontwar cea he Earp ely onsareavery al exploration of he wae nh nnn canals lage ‘Seer ofidenty snd very though om al mate The opps pom {iis of the malplcioslaerng ofl qutions and sic exes gly ‘nuk modem ely nthe ese ta een deol eva re procrsdem patie Tougher the tags hao ey dey in (be tone anise oGermay esa propels ensue The pon of oa Tiers work wii the ones of Europea cena alo ‘nceting thse The Hen of Cn we ase er compton the Canes Fl Fel in 1986 and ake the eof + sneha flow pid for Danish cna Tefen war warded the tcp nd 4 ra Ter quipped Etpean cc enton Indo th fin wa exten wel ced in Frcs Ses heme (202; 39-40) ecg te The low nue jl wy weal depts plying in the "Un Ceca Regn sen oft 987 Cannel Once gti, the le as et ech the Fach ros each pote oer Dena el ra th ‘arpa tht on Te ats a ant ba wo bcos andthe Sm eo orth cal pi nde Pc dry ot Cannen 199), angen waren in fg errs sound de wel “Thee of Bape he, cong terms of bth grpicl ndcn ace myogenic he Une Sates and with ic eee ‘9 Germany athe philorophical heart of Europe, The quenion of wha perceived as ‘harap hi work and ip cond pce powe ad tah The ats of ie cloud up wth ei dhe porn of then inn wo the sare dvs nacho he lea he Bop el The ha cher code tha theme a me ea CHAPTER THREE Exhics, Idealism and Identity ‘Are an chapter thes of mon and gop pepe on history ‘we lnpoant in emaltingan underanding of Lan vo Ti won nthe Europa ‘og However aa mae mires thera amp com Wh Rovio of ower and cad he lace inl win tuning og ‘he Hl The oli of Kenyan goons about how buna nate mo 0 slo whi sce ae ery ges in ls work adh sow texte ‘rich on Ter acne by dbs aout humana, The usm of wat eundestond by enya te hn af tae la VT secs am of deny in elon wo these etal an appopie een he ‘ene of god re than sho fe br hil so Jonata th pi nly mol dyamic eae spe on. Eis ne mea in very omg es ith dons enya cll yale and eh logy of nw sri he Probes the hs eens ton o bua oa “hens orn ies fee meray hgh texan of | wer eons nd the fc of power on the sontacn of ey Patt pha in othe exploration of mazes is with on Tr een ‘opgocing het og finde msec ane The aden) wove ‘dea an ide eed witha ani of how men a alt sage exc of enya rion oh complex ats of pone tha ate peal acs Mdealegheal wevelns wach es religion, the bourgeols senulbllry and social srucrures of ator Dict oie ena line, erence conn dion rating the ee tude prec on man ate ith ich we preted nr work fanny dpa ome. Thischaper wl corer thw heres In lato he pr a eh ed amin sine dee po hoof human mre lal comer how the Bs comping he Earp ipo» pian view fh egal acne he iy The pl Ws oy inthis of work a a pei enya hecho! he catenin bso emer plein che oo, ng Mango oer voy doce avo er war rough ap na very ber ule ons and thitexpsenc one hat at paced cena He and rk! Vo Terhinsel bas getline fear Jl wo tbe il otek which andro hs prion ame wo i ly wok nd Vheseder oh acom then). evabo athe bet ofr ates tr fl conn Deak pj which si ror in the nels et ofthe Doge 95 bheroed: Von Te ifeand work aa be cnet ‘ns mcd concen withthe ef the plied ac a by erin "eee coterie nc heron infec von Tees lame ey ado depen in i wake. Algaing ins with edn © quedo and ee pre Meso hae ie for nee and gpd intents, Fike oe al kind of Sms icadng Nas ln Lng ave oti 1 long he choo ugh har bers hat people are ae det ws nckions (Hj Bonde 2001-217), For von Ti, pte ate cal baund up with prec ean eo lal als and le apple wih te lc of ion se nda. Th ic ‘ected othe nrpon of power inact nd can be wero wih fence ‘tue f Meloy and hen diced yen mich Loi Aner tod Antonio Gee ‘Altus gps hale yum (vith owe gad rip) of ‘spss Gigs myth eo cons apd thar sol and interpersonal oss chap the aya which nid rere el condom of lve eens (196 231), thn fine the nian fsck and he ‘lehip win wc arnt Intel at an cat of the abe, hag clo import neon the eof he her, ih rene wham theeabjas de bei Aer rete econo the poses py the work of Msg, nd highligh he fice ht mp of tly rot ered of presents nt simpy sroagh what thy oe a, but loo och reference to thelr lence. Althuseet goes Further vo suggest that Weobagy loo ‘pera tough the yea mel pais hat a coated Oph Upland repre se ppteies Meso te apt ich ay dhe ection ye wok to al whi she oda certain se feta ‘deol This Meso erates he nding be ‘im atone of je, Thos ls a pli nd elo oh he se ‘free state ppt ah the pols focal he tay Fo Alte ‘Be how elgy perp lf and we ate consunly ale sj role seaed farof epi soul el epee al ch ‘Socnnal ar nfl ercslatons of og postions, ‘Alhascts denon of soy, howe Ines ie spac forthe tion of cof wih he vac Laer nthe sage wc fran. eames & “nscale tothe manila ely Gram (171) formato tbegmony ul in artigo sofia acts of cl expr. the wry ontaes, vom Tes work has demonstrated a particular concern with ahi of th wher he hn hee af hry a he pets! moc oun wih which hs sce sada ln, dag of «Re et 1 se Hil dae of Work War sly afer Denmark wa Wr, a ps senso pony and ven Jae conte ofthe ais oa eli Th fr restating conus ry oe Ne fie ing she provcuve wal cfg ewig tea with the nile ht nest Waite of pod apd el cng ott donna cha che hn in boon ugh with comple ad moral acento, Pr won Tie, Mey hacia which bla ocein the xpeincef dt and it that nse om aver of gl cane be pated ot oe po Bf Ware sl quetions of meray ie hee oe ees ced uy oy fl tn wrk, she ky are hed xeon SW intense inerlinhipbecwen marly, power and ey i lot nnn of wpe. Fr eng Erp puppet the ha if hor coun o the moans ofthe Arc in pon We War td wth be Geman expr fee. Te logy awl onten- ‘non going poss of pan, Aras cot fe onan hi ier ato of moray clon ad eth nd epost coma Freamee ef dent pas ide at for epein ba een pf ee al or resin in weet gal the sipping 2 low es xpreianin uc away 8 maintain thes gu Pcs he oematon of enya any cect mono vere Vo Tt er, ‘sane snd nomenon lp tar ha power reine nla, crt il th he ica of enti the omer Gabel cone Is oem inposed on the sje of gen. These er sou he ofa nus nes round peered enya uur ieee andi work, ef re okt ison the ation of eee a cl i nyc cone ed gues eeu wh iene be vm "hough th reprecntion ofthe seuge wih Mesum and a oni ui, Wha ashe ef flea ctl cont he Jor pled vo Te fle io of eno indie? Ti fda que Th the Eropelogycocen wth loka nd monic proce Wiig dough se Eaap ee te doit inthe conmuctinn ofthe Ge revs and ten hough ‘onepralaton of te ote with rence o which the precapoi of he te chanced. Running sugh toe fle an erating cancer wie ‘Spence fe ther athe els ef aon the oman of ey ec {he eling op th ogy he cme emg ins ee kng l fie ofthe ocean aut wl Fo example In Te Eman of Chime Tecan nginlin the lap fcime i cael au by Hay Gey Ie becom de murder inl. pls se fan’ daar onthe oa af gue ad hey hemos end up contig the de fils he Haro og dew usin of on ancl pal ery th char ep While Te Element of Ces pide oes comerpony pind, Eup reaching conned with ison onal enya cote of po Wl Wn Germany lf hl sede he myloprteate rund uetons of Ah ule, rnin thereat of ne grein eo athe aed es which your ai radaly cape by he mee seo coll pole that dominate ech arn eaters. Wher slo mina fare he Home of ima, eine al eth or al fis (Emp) ses unpre the og xporeche oii hr idea ay mispae, being ie cata vale fuer bland deo of buy. ca i aria highligh the onarlne af paral monies In The Bem of Crime, she's faith tn che ayntenn of justice bs underinined ot surmber fl a mary way he bens tr heya er an ‘eens wha come cp pit he pated of a nin pn fh eo wor Fh he orion of Commit Kramer (old Wel ‘rane he lr to pur the pry af Onborncs cme detection sem arin bes ou tm tren Kemer sic et bes i ound up nth i ivrigton tht he il corre by, ermine lic of he Lono mando His Ke i wernt thee of def when be cll wth Kramer in allowing Osc sce oes Osborne the ‘ether hn Fae i The prado ofa es a corpo ‘ely conned dough he fim 0 quan ffi sd pore Names ‘eet nang he dil yom and tows pes ofthe nein af rine ‘ha dus peerenten cotinrdan gal ches wich gerd ud ls ‘Shed ie slg ves ele bythe ste, Hegeonle oats ‘Fp opt though the deployment of mach pee and wok 0 este dha evn ft sd etininaton a find in cn oh leant elo Prono, whi omewha einen ot opr nde decom lending oe implementation os pu for of ti, ene oh ‘speence hind dor aorbld mach fren lation theses [recent of epic power Ii nro ode tha the bis af pod emu esc The gril pou ee by eloped pe Tre aparnan wich shape wth fn opcode of ory ‘heir tn ops ales wach low the la of pment. The marae ees of bth pom and op i shore p the spstent Inesapabity af uch proces by founding speemly oppo Meteo ‘fics ad cally bekng her down he ota whe the cee of gen ‘pores brome ned arpa fr xp eo Kees Wer onda it charred hha wi fern tcp sd inert nd hi in “ounterpitthetly anssened enor imperveof the Werle who ‘Say sof vrs oe quo aligned wih uc, Though 2 mae rt Ty pombe i romance Kes Ei oe though the mano oe rato werd ty Katrina Haimin (Bas Sukor) and be be ee ‘Ship eaughep inthe nies uncer round what te ob tj In the tame of loe aed som, Tor tach ofthe pages inde ln, Hetty is sch hc i foe Fer th ester an Oetipl on a i Hound up wid Hg Gen (bore i fre etn uring to Europe in an eft Sly ander stand The Benen of ri, Fier the m2 Kind of prodigal on whose {er hee sapped ciently te pata cralogia {nd epee meting In pldeni, De Mer aca one pole, ‘Shing ee te miata hemi es yep hi lig te wee ‘at thom Dstt mln mae him by he couel ef mi who became the cing geen inthe wii the fl, Dr Mane nara oa ni Inbred inion dcop spreading the pau ats ele Tha oid a ns the lo of eae gone aly wrong The le of Dr Meer ences "icine inetpton of he sb min the Famer of iealogy ad he Bie thin the ly sear Kind of parable ei. up, Kees Wey Touind ap with tendency oa the obey of cen option and il aero nna oppsing Woo positon in the name af ce eae dee nde lef th oa rangle towed wit these gue aud dhe cso a aed he stor da perp the oF gan Hele yn the ed dpa through cca a pune "on Tier a sgged hate cos inthe ulm igh othe individ vo shapeicown i Shwande 2003-23), yeh ofthe ai eo thes sharp ele he pretest acm the projet nia, The pce he inva in he end shaped wih tence to hpeony ated a Iyxalied ye of iy ad chi. AB Altus work si the ind ‘ia inept by eo and secby ire a a bjt of em The Bop gy rie the working f had bole the my ologiing tender a ele uc nd ti nine fy spe ha det ot allow mich rom for manor ‘Another ey make of hielo aetna orm and sto, andthe alent fhe lms tempore in ere fencing ana of he Pols fens omer: Bent of Cm lo rsa attr fo pa api von fee Eup td ‘ide The ln x wend wis abe elie aed deh and de, and ines era and ev Aswan ln a he nal, The lent Of Cme concen ne ith the any el ud the nce recs of nn thes of poner nd inom, andthe mic rv-tcexabie h ey etiencng he sof Ande! ato in ror and Salles nw apc 10 img fee cc me ter nt of ie ft rch Bde sh eile ros oan be dan dep Inclined scence ef be apeclpicudrmol cei By coma Edi ste and pre-op of Ring which andi Serato ates ny see tf tcl extn on and minal eneneion The ming nae snc the orale of woth ‘diet vo ae funding fara fe sie ad i erly onc and selec, The fiw eetly como cole wih deel mol un tinge pede the ple yoo th und of ion ending ins he ea ‘eit te fing nate The metphoreliepirons ecle hede (Spay cat doy rely wth yd api Tends csp poten ad he jlo the spar who ses pes ‘he wore Hore ea Ther appar snd phe noon ofthe sar, br he doe to by smlancoaly cating tpn shut theo of he ln indy an ‘lanahip ro netanment. Ones pin, omer ia the hn of het lad ts iterlatinn with acy ely darted. Tela apes ahs esis 2 ees expeaton omlsng fara com one pyrene prope Fein inthe conto geal glia th poco he uence i stand wacacmbee Rms wich do at hang thr tinh dey ad tomcat ning pra of cea By conta othe eer Bn ofthe oy pe pre cnn. With high-gain nepal echnigu le deploys experi inthe ere foanvets produc fim harshly and aed ey ace Aa aed 18 Tier makes wc of ata fent-projetion reigns, the apstion of lor sd Maceand wit images inthe sme Fane, ad enigues of epernpotion The fn guy and highly cnenat ring te work of Aled Hick and (nea Wells and devin atenisy on the German eposionin of fn cpr wo dain The infu ofboth Expense nd fi na eh wat dhe ehogy In the paramo und pesimitc vensibily evokes. Hepers eon abla bat w prefs apps le ee wo highten the oom of he pening the rae In ype hore wok ih rowel the expen concrete bn of he hare Wha tbe undereod soe ee? Wh the pcg cdg ofthe pote of Westy? How can pone rake wp nr nthe wf he opener of ge of pave! Where nigh the fd Ead pte fo isl nd en ra ail eis anton prompting sete es permeate Whe low of al she in ough they an etapa sen mat eal in Eup The we of fone an ee pojion snare vo of Earp hat iad ough carl Fees depining ecene ioya the peur caper pn nado, he ln sox dgh withthe compen of Went and tonsa ender The dake gait of Fp complemen he nighearch phere f The Blt of ime and ober of pone Te pyc Ipc urelingf thers of es nd inn alone ees ime a poet vo Te, nd he npos a ey eve Hh ot hi wine lao Exe sd fl er cn the em fh pe fra eke that ely ea oper the fren hema ac dco a che Iso hag of i ps nd ica ene a hp try ype inl ome wens Pow cvs sd pos pra nes which nig of clo peopel nt sn pens igh bended. sn onde ogy Ts besa wil or cm ene pore a ‘crip he jes eof hea en, ens ad mes The por fps ell inp init cot edhe xo th abl mon any bp tip. von Tsp gh be ss ened whe tiny of Gerard he ec ‘anyon rane, Mix Drees to pi art dha Te dep women ih che bas alt (200239) Cet gps far dawg on pcos to kash» ppl mode ol the hops pal onion at 4 meopor of a of natal ancosous ich ote nab memory fil ud lg ell pci lc ‘and inoporon wo the bighy ronald cur of contmpory Europea Slenty 00 391-4, Suggesting tha Kingdom apes opt ond Set {Seuinal "uncon exploring thereof ell memory in the construct ‘bat penal and mond ides (202: 398), Cree comarca coving ‘odin the ene ci cet tot thee fan ed pesorl e thy nthe comer of pride [simran nero hi ang rte hail amewod of fl son gen i oigaiiance or on Tee and to eet onthe ways in which De Kingdon nd Te Kengo 1 et sts Seer sound elu been ‘soln with isn a Earp nd with incr nthe aba ind emer ‘Gol lero fen lg with args of tae ad er oe ss stetheclly le gop angi» mene of arly gear ae eatin ang nh ad til ln sound The Kg nigh eal a again with he apn of uy eon ei ovr ay stake undsentnlt eens we popl cll fons uch she ‘Dap open. compl sata then al or leon impor ‘hice Von Ter ele ode on thecal pi anand wilh European Irene and his coud or parca exponen of ht mde of mang ‘end thor’ oh ow tein fata update pisophia ‘een athe al mening nh cone of lol nema, home by ap inex more popu oe, on Tier Sind ay xp ee demand ree tment hat enn wir atl ppl or isc Ameen nem Ted Fm of Te Ringo ceogy begat arsine ome ofthe cnet sound US ‘luigi da il care moe soso expe in von Tie errors chapter igh and nine wil exo Tne dacasng of German nema Thomas Ener hat ogee ht Any mann aout thsi pla meting ofthe tach {erepes bot he atmo fhe Boil meron a he nom be aa eel and ek sues ot whee hey nea ir ‘cht bc he ole of cnr, whee there evden that the havc, worked oe placed rejected eens fhe sxe or soci gh in oer ring hem o epeention whi teem Fama gener consi (198825). ee va fie er slo commensal whore asus be "he rlaiclulal of dhea unllevon wie hwing emp at hat cane adh of she mea frase dry and ding en othe econ pics at play At he ame tne the xa of he Kno Hn the complex cso uch pardons on she fmation of ajc he ohne This cher el rs te es bel ‘Glen Creer alla of Te Kingdon mae renew» Fowian Game: Wrork of antl sod de stention to te tporanc of rein hat wok Bist, Timothy Tanger ge hat Foreoupdad nhs eli rq ofthe mae Dan wt ae seth competing eli flea auto and itelcnal made loyan ronal poi epee By the hop lpi ‘tava maps pulse repent by the charac Drs At uch one ind ew cmpriag dacs nvr Ter lon King ‘On hone an hehe poland ahora dhcoune of moder dial peri endoned and noaliedby ceateOa theoe a hte the agile dour of a beh dered in he ii eal nd rel Ween etic dace, 201: 3-4). Yor both hehe apd Tange, The Kingdom expo he dome ooo ‘und he Dash ia were state pla un aesing om de stn Inonbeshp ofthe Emopan Union tat peli he any ding the {iy 199s anger 2001: 45; Creer 202: 597-8 The operat shes fos af on Tes ary ne th acing a a meng fre aed ge (i wth he hire antecedent concrpoay conten and igling the ‘tycin which he mrp of Danish anal deny decyl ad This angen in he mare oer sical mgccesofhe e whih he rly bureau mil absense af gveranc erp lly lpeoned. A vie he pal ys gonerene miter poms De Mi trl ole al Hansen o able tsps for xorg he ai on + 1a he san Swe ial Sg Heimer on he rounds ht Map ‘es pod of Operon Morning Ai hat he cot bu ke on te eps sity him Likeing the i oh xperiense a cd of having pling Be Ioagad haw ao i mehr bu only Big capabe of runing aay and ing leh «dor Moca hacer « pln sot 0 bein ofc when he miner ves, ageing thar Her sb hin that he a ben ele way to operate in Odie or Habu. oe mehr. In he aul eee when he mie des ae dices Moya! ding ne hi oie Sk nd wo he ee teow bi acund te boop wich eral rn nis ig dcr "har elton teeing Ste ar eythane ss the se of Me Dra (Kite le), Buller (ne Oli) and Dr Krpe) eqn nd ph en Pu a Toe Rago (Seen ill exon te ght of Mary (Anne ben he sent ‘owns he grup ecoune Boilie ne apa penton aking lana te Newry depart ahi ellow gens pt ‘onde the peony wehial eee fs epseoma ino ht bay by seplcng with now hey onan. Bonde protrudes no want he person, using te miner gat conermation. Tidy he group wali on he ‘cpt in sort adh Bg Riser onamour fetarin te peso exam ‘be on lay the eae it te dnb nyt Sd Cra Mocgzuts son, Moge (ter Mygind, sing ax ete. The mine deces hoc es oc enough an hao the end fh eT, 00 Ter ed Inner of gveanc, epublica of dine al pore Sov uy in oe loop dawing ae oe bars of he ronal ‘Zee sory atibued ote medial oko nd ewig os found malts and the inuprorine of ona Thema sa of Te Kopel of what Tange al Ye from stoy ofthe plo teapot marae wich ete he aly aly of Tin iT can be undecuad a ding the papa uli of he tex Inerpteal ans er with indir and he aly of ‘heey wo proce a fete sued sod in an src tf mgt sd Hectn, Howe a es Te Kip operte noe {roc md wach hve fe dees siya the pra pean {has iporatcovequens forthe mie comes 0 be inept Ie ot ‘rough oil the dace faa the tex wd algo and sa Rincon Ti ave ae hat simply npn oil racic aod clad memory a ttl Wty. sen, so mai rer moe fundamental ‘ueson ound dhe sca ofinl Keney and bjey and do his tw Ws arian of the ew af syoery at he heat af He rarvaive concern ihe wah thet ri lh rence he pie ath forrur way och the pgp pn ih hg modo te wasn Tor Cee il Asi wih nus woundaramerny ante npc fata es maton of el Wer hee at hed Hubive ough he deayen of nny a bygone eI, mero he Goh in he Kno ipl een ih hi the uncon igcan wn te elope he er pent wih he el i” unceasing he ok ya or goig cin tip ewe pt spo nd Wi he wes tn which dice clay fo tm fy, yt tf le sb pera int estan th complex nrg bor al comely ta uw oh th ly de seryogp ope The set coe eps dhe importance the inion ede Het in re ae quero abut he a pa de ny Inthe Kno of Aron end he Urey The wncinny compl ston. rasa the fs tne othe pp Fl wy of tha which dep tla adam t ut ses fw sil on ap ith unc pce nd wir of nnd ce ps, Ni The uncanny sot Ii once withthe cage wea and mt ‘ows wih ick Senet norco) fw peau The uncanny ils fling f uncer in par een the ‘cy of who ones and what rng epee Ba he cay npn eseene of mangoes oct, Mae spay a commingling of ilar a unfiar Theuneanny har odo th che roof ect cout spatiale fm a appeherson weer ting. of omehing tse esl ee sd doe fas come wih = Ath ume ime the cay ee fa ro strething omit. 2003: 1-3) uncanny, he, neatly pie anc rf ay ans 1 Te Kingdom which coca al wth ste ean beeen ot id preset, ie od deh, aoa an spsinalm ad wich md he nl -sarangely comtingeat series GF eelfvsed WAilen parimesies thse SrNSg SRS tht gun Though Ty Rigdon wa Te Kg he wy tr net hg enone we he i wld eye bp the ing qo i in th ‘Sinem cant ess hone ‘ony pty tne geen cates se gore Enh cunnerregeniniv ln, Ts hen mie teh ont heal sack oft omy cua ces foe ae he ‘ince npg acre ro en ene on ah Srna en oan li we oar he mony fu ay (ned wt Mas dnl op abe ae Kgs (0d fe so hepa ‘seins hytong yin inert er decom oe get nel noma = Cygne ey se im oo he Jae tons ampere dug br ppg se Kept cel MDs hour mig se “Trea fhe Gly some Ip pogo cine fi trp so pln ae dl alarmed by Mey oF ee pls worl preven ve winariliae i vers which ross a falar, Ns eee taf dv una Hwee th pie i hh the nea TWA cue the we (oth oe eceyton whith vcd ow Te Iie of sh venta ha a by the pct ana thn med theugh th Frain fhe nea ogh sets ony A een Torn 1979) a he Te depends on arear fhe and vceny aed vad Fre the dehoory oof perepton The feu ob et mat hallowed alas bce lad the ian eth and ees of tie ini ae anes and me uncer othe tor of Toe Kigl Sersiny dominwe The sora psematon of gh part ote mal fe aber on of onl athe he te a seri places ihn ve sbctum fee which expend hog al cat a he bl sepa For the spat hi pre puting lp. As Csr and Tange ve hissed heel epson ofthe pet por ov algry fr what scl al cle eps an ad nya eet ht he epee aay fis ¢ wy oe dr une 4 reading ofthe text cll caro ona de wees Freud (9918) sage, he mee preset fe wan ht en coke the eerie of the cna em neces to ton he wy The Kino woes prac eta fhe uy an i lg fo I cher wo, wh hou Te Kido that sy and ow Sc ht Brit meaning? Jones Donal gs he human bigs e's roan Otto eine he ans fest’ (1989 257). Thao He Rm the en she ile wsre te text Fr eampl Sg einer ep ake he Nan on Ha One Spon sand fortes" Bee? (Wo Kc) sands forte imma ote? Mary andthe nes and or che ional ote sudan Mir Dre sand are em necro 1 King hasten in qusion in ety and mae ob lay nr unlomble chee emt padi re ff talon cey ar Wht comes uncanny in ered the knows han vy \hecontemporry cone of pstnderim ling Dov poseo ad he Kino a2 ext that throm int eee anda pb of ponte or the cmerpory frente abject nd ha be undead gh ay which The igo ring tte coun of the pp te unas fn the tas pede de of eine oa age eae "hs ambipity bees ornately cam be sf he skolyment ftepopul’ oon pol eons in cee clara srgument he poplar deans he rad ested en whet as in maaan ad honor films dling wih ney eeatlonalty and deuth, Bur the poprilar always denotes « centrifugal fonee” rand in eso wth Kr cena pl war conser that iy ome poplar forms = expel he ote nessa {he nblne tangeston of aes Boundaes and dar, (1989) 26-7) Foe Dore uncanny day Bod wp wth anions the ne ba aie whe of abject, Deng on thew ofa Kise, Donal fxg “Reway hat ther ents in tines feet races 0PM Tina tetris cite with the tanpesion of bore and they xpi he Bglny a th lew’ and duping ce sseaiy of meaning (89:2) (One cate how sch despa fhe abject ca esc eo ba ply The ing he uf Jl adh wy he ces to cape west at 12 ining mehr in Berm the an ofthe ing and he en of he ded 1 Paar cmc of his In beonng anges, nol te photic of fer mamfomaton ta crs uneaay fr bot he pecto and Dr Kosh ocr he hat she seme ob bh and ded capping dhe Lino ne desea hewbee inthe txt atte Swedeborg Koon! whi inane ‘Scr cut er nye en pele anche epi a ‘hentai fbr etn Her edb sbi a his procs he ‘canny de per ad fr De Kibo evs the ely of The “anim thea of he ine Ta Ketsee gg he aj ge wih chemin (192: 1), Th de eee ut of canto for nuda of ens dunce of amity «for ht eames dion mode of boro: by masqcaing 1 coda pena by pening sels» maneaion fe pope “hit maining is othe fats a 0 er chris quire ‘Mote mean ce The eis of hs ghee by von Ties of the Fan elmer sealing fl prs at bt in the concen son a ich ely nny undone a bth he dcve and uncon ee The King thet boinc th play of score knowledge and entiy conse ocfuand nd the lo fe ncany andthe nai o tbat present the fas angle sur of tah smn exposes the gly a ‘hp concedtwugh dei sactas a masons Th cali in ‘tamer af ey exml sing hoigh te ext Fath wen jth Bess ‘ipuce se eme fo ene he eis of the aexony she cs 2 phe ugh niche plo ale ule king hat Jt Becomes pony hotbed er gan ar or ol —In fase eo {hing ic the mone progeny fhe ghost Er of Mary he pie sing, ELIE by Mer Dra Iisa nesting that Me Drs be median ht ‘bean De Kops nf guidance a adie 09 who do wth his lop ‘Si Lee ine King Kensie 2b inhabiting he pace a ‘eee iad death wie Ms Damon kil in aoa cen an sen onc te Smeenbog Reon! one ey undeand shat her neo ath | voncile thle world wih the offal history of che hospital Vr tt hind ewer ad eran bjecoisn gh hy eanenivesd ily podem tx wich the ono of ema omen ow en mil ug Te may lp Sarg neem te lo of aan, bua in terms of he ptioemporal contruction a the et cet section will consider. 7 a eK a Tresild ‘ia pes Bh Ment he indie of pe ‘nln i stain on se of eg af eg ne etl of oe ee Croom ee hte cng ie yn hh mee he Te gh oN baer at sen Lelprherapla~reenmsineirireperregrimmeraie r= ieee aon uns ur! he ghny anlane n he it insalnetthe SS er e See itr ta st sve re i ting C Sree ern ll rete Trt meer al Tenor aera eee gree ieee eee leremire tee etre Se ad Soe ee eal cere erie eal Semana Peete torch beaten tate aera ee nce ete al peo come nema onad ater al ieee yao Se aa a Ss eee all cect ey ea eo me ete cer ad Eonar Sateen Sinciern ncaa eee Sicerrem ered ontanans et Spruill tse ep il Soca sarees mete PF hte, pour ein npn ft eS of Pe mrepes rasta truth deeb Waloging i down v0 earth (1984: 21), In ation, gree sh Wc wh of hd a pve aul wou dow once Sale iy outa a= he the nk ere he tong tn so hich an bev a wo ef he sues as spc st a Yes se tee anol be epee n scl ae hee sop Wi ce ofan can tll ate unde pec Winvnobleandundngnghaclynwhuh heirs ose en {19:16 eso qe al evn eid Tse Monn by Le Be, bh no ing eames seh an Hh Mont banana cin Sin gas een soe tho sie nao ofthe gee a The pon, Reha aoe ib yesh mene ofa regs Inet thot gto ps dra hay I ote mal wold he one bie ve ethoeseie lnc Ving ih domain of et, The nny de pcg end pt Jo wi seh been and deh abo nes oe i slg caning wine ig nar eos pn Fis, bss ad eis lw sspy de nil pa fee a shh wich axl with dhe npn and wih is peal ar a the potas te hatin o each as hicks coc aden Ine Kno thet op ois he deena de, hl werden passin ih on Swen fica wail mats can bi ceo ayy ‘rin fhe way ch abjetn un esos ale apang nn wih clef Wegener hcl hoe snot egronyand eine guceringa weiner olen hein hour ad home htc ne glares * yranoeh enc te fares bay. he text py doce e yf is fl dors ds cul ol ted th wnkoowe de sapenatr. Than bc ans un soa es lle renin fl bee which int ca bere ars ot loa sco te ton ofan Te cto thon mse apa ‘heute dng al mats The myn whch net sora tr scopy thi pa Ke tn deh clon) fot ake as imperan quinn stu Be dest Se nan ‘hey of done, the sac con l oggs oth and Dee The Kingdon he question fee on that as ned prychoanaic wings om bj tnd dhe wean Fr Fe (19913, human dete oie te sl en 0 the dese look a he div knw Fd alas the dee fr Ln, ‘edge io elation wo the plesure of voyeur (which involves scive looking) = “ace mo pero prl yest ne ofthe formato of die nd jetty, In The Kno the dee whe dey bone pw he ‘yal amoung the eno he jet Ar Mere th pil ee (Ge oft et cso the rth ht has Ben Bt a he spas ito he ‘pus th opin hich itary seed by ely and hws the pol ‘objec rae “Are hve sc Mts Dac aden fd he Held spas ofthe espa a beset conrad he i sa Ia The Kiso she eps er ding Ferd sure Sredenorg Roos fr ng cough 0 ai her wth ce sa information abut he ht of Mary =e emes Mis Drs invest {ncn The King Hs Dee era sits the Senor Roo a oe Facto face ith hr fio and Mary enlarge rine, ‘het dee the vol of Mary in th elses of the ing eb ie laborory wks foune, unable bear hi? As wth any etna dws “te Mir Drs nigh and wedge hat pe te mart a aes tn Sheba he means oh ich our nove the nai histor {fh coment bing Fremont gh Mex Dre ivestpions hac we in ocr he yy af het me enue’ wo ey wit ‘eri nd wo cna he nar oer deste the over epee view hat ‘helen niger and chara (De Hele cers thea umes oi ‘brown the en Ou enon wih Ms Dame permit ew ace tocar forthe pecto the pee of Sh “ht eT Ringe ont an cbr ass of wat ight be unde sot at dent I th cots ofthe marae death seed othe expion of nly fants Sj seme anced he mito he Udy th wus ‘arc suring pi sob oho din he ern pce ewes Iiond doch Thee insite he race fide ht the et ‘Solr though on The sugges th eye premio he a Sten f bec iis a th enone wih death At ne ee hecho the Slr cigar ety and lw For the eploaion of nt once tnd up with ihe Nise Sel eu among ker Mey a dca in hope one Howere hei ak buck en xr above i lata abe ‘Son and ote prod context of he ple ‘Adocuse ae bjs gar mportnly Cough The King do tng conc the gil of amon sj and sepa 0 the mdb ‘aon a conf whe harman bone ura fm corporal pe {ip Ths ver sense ht the meses bd ints essa encounter trek dei hat pore far the ean of ss of ajay. Aue ‘abet enor ound ahr within the body ba rat some ‘hing that reste Imi fhe By and seats he inporane of the Wi Seal em, eo wich fin reed nd ried by elo process and {dcoame Tee ste investing pr ere wh the wok of pcan Nils ‘Aaa. in hs pper on phantoms Abram agen ha deh pervade gus ‘ule ad gals dhe importance of she purse sa sues oe of ath fr the theme fh daw, ng sled men by ne ly syncs kf cp cp ory ed dando Ge a va flling tat, national systems (1987s 171) * Abraham eagbacan ven of he ng i nveatonof hike acontrat rf the apse wits bythe secrets i) Th plana ha 0 the fk sens frail st ican the ge hyn henge he prs a ian heh ‘cea i velacion eo the ways in t oc a ih dominant dons of analy cee a ‘apa cls down opens fr ah tiem, Te Kido ape ove the metaphor the pao! a3 mpm ft orden codon The ‘theme more cops gana inte eam po lon bier sd aged sd wa af bran ete Tha itil he il ed ae hg The ul Scamenr gst dis poeple hh ‘he males then sn Waring ge wun emp ee hte in of ec epee ea Inger ening hep ued whet stant maton py of ean perce a Ins he King olaping ft andar lesion lg ic pi tw eo do Inn of op ctl ramet ‘srs efor eniy tin cer th ae cal towed ins of tempera on bended rely oe” 1, tictig show me wh he any ‘hing smo alenon nas domination sd tory hg omer ethene arse igo sca esther ois earn cio he, an pina fe devon ion: Frmal einen sen ode he aon ae ‘hocitalbml nung of dma ey tens af ts of Dope 95 sco: pons el iy what ipa ice oon nolan sa apne reg te perf any poe the npn ft mae ‘mena reson of te pe cy fname hal on sowgh vo Ts fe wok in cong nee. The gre wie smh gh wh ua jee ested oe wy ani pn pis pi oo Tey ot ‘hp thread autho me en snd epoca ie he wo ha Flow on ise and mg ef he comety ‘any et sin amie Began he ae of daemon a form that has something valuable ¥ express in dhe content of the contemporary Civ comer of lt capt ma gba ow, Ay the vasa pe ‘ea crcl lyn eer the portance fhe at wok nan a eprint lence and fog of dominant ele a The Ko th dons PART THREE Dogme 95 and the Gold Heart’ Trilogy fuarren vive A New Vision?: Dogme 95 and the Digital Revolution In 199, vo Tet retook an inporantchng of deon wih he larch of he De 5 noose ich wa Te olor with aur rcs Dan con. lucked x panoave sof eaten wc mel ve ps Sm indy and weno own cmplceney arund e dee w uke mony. The manifeve war accompil by+ Vow of Chay cone ‘uo gd he odin of lms ur se unl of the mae” Ws foc onthe che posse of nr a the nd of he ewe cory ee ajc 95 poet hp ve Ter pion il tthe foot of the Se In specs ine hereby devopmet in digital elo Ia some es weve thi war the tae of cance athe than dg at he nga Init and silo in the"Vow af Chay’ id node spec om the Ie f cna bing ed gl pre Ind, hile, on he one and i Ino sg hr ealopal oem gg he ml which lb te hin demecratson of the clematis wchlogal nom ih he el the elton of ame 0 Gon By sing ew tehsogy ‘yn anytime can wah hea gin of ay i the ely embceo eno (8 Tr 19954 "he mans reece ecole specaly couched in tesa ital as proacing opportunites fr anthing ote tan he tao of ie mse pres prc aon, ded fis ut ee nme ‘co death’ and fall of ‘superficial ation Ln face, wich its ipuation dha he film Forme” ipa he Academy Sewn Tier 19980), he "Vow f Chu appeal he ne nye ee the poe ofthe developmen in dig ‘anes closing sen Despite ths ome, many Dag ls ne “Stal been shron los pain reponse ted vocal wih ‘ng 35mm ln cata ond hah sos As von Tes nen thera splat ef nest on 35 lv amin Acaley ‘Wh es ley ied forma Bat when you ees into» cle you Tc toaubmit nde eletne Soren ag Jcben] made the sat toe imepeig te ale a ening edabsion fo. That he ‘ds ane pe could do be so om 1mm = che cl far was oly thethey wre cued om 38m. Tall vein fm ling wo ws vein ur the opponent thn si tera It only bon Fru thn of cose you coal soot your im on ideo ~ hat mk ty ope We aed saws, be Fak, has Ben aot hd ha en some cil ifn estes Mainly chs made he Fron much cape whch of ours plese me Aad it a ed 4 Trend whee ple around vc wd ae eed nang he cep, hep ‘Dope me, They might aor be compe acorn he ul, bu eat tha pple wh wed 0 Be mid by mac of how proper ‘Boutin peopl ow et ht thyme in he fd ie Fee cen quay oie unde 199) eis portant w ackolage fm the out then tha er he unde of he Doge 9$ movment dil realiion war at «spice. Neer ‘heer proc seul the mano eu inked oh digo (mens ind here depend penepon shat splayed sift oe the apr emocrtaton of em dha has compl the hala selopmens “The fw of te movement in i xg fo i oensy marae by she lieu change onto on als or et the ie The Ferma of Dogme 35 a malin en clo lls the by now very ania dene of won Tet toward spar. Wha sino eta on Tes nec o he fr Tova Dag 5 tly cs up mewor for he fare of dine tars ceed rom apps lean afr. By deploying» mano, he Now of ‘Chany nd seis of conf flr fo ace to he inne es of (Ge puja won Te etl plc ls demas epson a he Be ofthe Dope poet nding he shaperthe lunch of the movement aoe tele imcreoal signe ~ evn Ter ply machine ul srt ‘houghone tego he eset ad is nent te het of Sees Mood te Rr of cn sod hes ofS Thi chap canes the jean of von Tir sping Doge 9 and ss ou the mays which i ‘ene esse bp os be mp ofl inthe digit ge. ep ‘SIPS ESTES Gy ie posvelies Yar Gemceverleetion made wvallahle by diglal ‘eng a he nil amon fhe poe. Manon testo, Tico nade wane nc ofeaiionoeie edcoe pa es ee are ning ots wo tr make ete oe een ea ean eer ee ce ee tora etapa ewe ar Cotes Dap tear tar es cemeteries Ne re Cm poansaen ea ee sy Seedy So cna tn ah, peas oe ma cree pce peje ‘sgl hy wae ich Dog 95 erannporan me smn hat oe a ae shesyna of the mao mony om by erin ‘iy sonatas ny nl ha an, ad © manok wt tp Te ane dlrs tn te mais "fas dle or action he mre espn end re Concion coy rok openly and dalam lems ot ‘htc ee enc Meese 208 9) fr Mace he ite Dp 95 ma ion ny nd aon he iro pied Hee apc (a ona of lig pod psn mi ab be fring cn access sow keene seo For the Doge 95 ben, the echortatns spi and dese wo apie nf ces irae Whee one ‘re aunttrcn talento nechone ee eae ‘a sug eh tne et co ee pa ‘Saga 9 mle cers een ep es ‘rope ee ro ot pcs linen we ‘al ethno ln eo ‘lie insted et 39-3 Dope hn oboe dt mani sme fe log poset ccna ged fn senpecs cages hiya nn ang pom gin det ce dco he Boge ‘Sos ne on any oie gh hn inne eng el eb ine Seep I was intially Formulated in rexpomnse wo a Unvtacors Wo Wpaek Hb 8 Yan 2 ty nme ia 19 Fron Ts pel ope toyed cen pe puny. The a wlan ing heal ers eclaig heel a epoca in igh hon oe wh von righ itary ‘ested mening ean a egg Ne Gn dan ing eect he nro SORE outon nai vig sth Br sh po te Sonnac any nlg lhl ty yD npn Wargo hn be ee tah an ee Meine meen vo Ti ye tanpon of onl LINE Sitaopya npc hone ner ack proson wo 08 ‘Gye nal tna alas coment sin be por nde yor er wal bales wl Alea sgnl ve ways in which von THe andl she other bret wished wo ave he pt of oaconmertl ian. Th rus coe wh the mares 1h he "ow of Chany aout an nen sry orton she op 1 he exp reqling ame cme eal hl ea wreath ln sa meando race anor nd lve pone Jo se constant pon thn bythe ale he sey ve ely 1th oe and neha spline Poe monn come nd yf apg sod eps Wi scm ender lemon gente aa Pylon yl sina Ayr ene nbs ence pat gs —eplinhatsoal inn dep hae omen of ppt cn, age 9 ste espn te psy ecm an acces ital dae ne is ne eae mae tel too sealed wpa ee ‘nein ah ad psi spar aoe sce ‘sob plaleobsereon a highly aoe anal ted tot archy ponte, An Ava Seiiy St ct he cn So tinea teeny ail ic man ‘ Se ey ney dy Nee eee can af opt oc deni fms ih fyi en gly mops ie tr ec eects wre oe sb sa nn pete mo apm yong eh i item cna ce 9 tl Seen ec gen Sn eee acer See ee ee —. . ‘else cone end mei chy ren ecg neonate eee rent wants oc he ea min none chem SO ns tags mn SS STS SST Sire ac opener lh “Ppa desc amen nn el a caer Roe alten eqn x Dope 5 is eal ge ct ah os pl ene aap ea mnie Presi "he pel and igh ioc dann pe ofthe Dogme 95 maton andthe "in of Chay’ makes gra lyf trea on one and and atic the es nd both he things omtine pace dine pom le forthe movement. With ks selena ref avi and fogs ‘xo, the funding documentation of th mmemen cal ret de oo The eon ivsment gos bi rey wa een ake he sept ‘og tants dog he plage diss epee co mae ie vhs ut ats of wc ia tine bonete component oth liga sscnae and set lipo: de vows uber en wed fo ssa of ommandnents Member fhe manent aed be tnd thy a expected to provide 'aneion? ort in’ or mi hy tee 'ssimands om low bss upon pein ofl MacRae comms the boy mariage ofthe spf the Prom work eal Cal ag lao ae in th vw af cha (205: 53), and ss since of epee wal wih gon sates to eat he hear ch fon Ter iu work ooh pura cbc ety thas pe wih eign oe isnt limita the emf te Dgre mani soe’ Rate fa wn Tes ‘ss as is case sein ln fo he wea Ga a ‘ona publi sce with heme of Te Hen of Chime vo Tc ‘ates char "We wane ese reighon cn tv sere’ The chi namie, publishes Ws Sie rps eed cafe ad won Te del eles here w ee ‘Hewat wich ln bl become rac wa faa the he pal ‘eco mano by saying Nay Gos lone ade ne fo lhe report cre i fem elo Bone thing ct: Me noe the ce ‘neve Bd sequoia there dine This epee ‘Reoune oe dain fon woul age tha he ey ond eon {Dit ine Dogme 9 agenda are conouenc af wa Ter on awed om ng inc nal senitnent lgon ars mode of een. Taving ben brag up wih a wily shit home, von Ter une nied gon when be are forth iene nd bone x Cul The ea (ero nisi doe by ven Te ila? dsp thea ha a eaptha longing to bit eral story. Seng hat be ek» ned Torte felon sme of i, von Ter in quick sia ‘he at sha eet ch epi practice a whi eis incre aa the ie of Gol. Are i per oe, on Ti cna wh he wk of (Cad Tenor Deer ply grounded in Doe hme proach 1 ions SF Gad and for von Tc the punt of eon sens deo an are vad he cpio hat os king i i bod Home fr Yon Tes rp ao wm provide famewa trough whi hats dome if co eran In be epic sgl that i psn il cai vn of gon lo coin he lees tat [wold leva in insite se moral moi (Miche 203: 12, Th Tat beeen ligon ta and ttn fandment udestnding the le thn ron Ter ee el pole chat hs concen cos age fH but chen rept ne of he Die 95m oer the man Cleat example, with Baling Wo founding rpsty mn oe ‘Whe nergy nv Ter wok ign becomes a ears by wh the mportans ofthe atonal domain f ae ans lin the fron of ‘coerce the wold ihe ‘Drawing onthe wok of Suey Cave (1979) an dhe way the pho nein alas sto somthing hat ot poe whether in al (hee inure, Ge Ways gested ha fi us unig pome in ening the cls mar sense af dace ‘et om ey or iin of dane om Poplar ls ations ‘Mwy an ope ad psy in Mac nm f ha te). By at ‘sing dont shanely the parealy med forms of aeaton, Tes baling the tance ern the vewer Gl) andthe word viewed (in) an apparent quo macro tthe vw ised fhe Nanden of that diane Onset band = many of the grea ey Flag ar piel need io alo that eatoship oe an anne pce need den In tbe owt fd ther mays oF esi the mer bun canon (1998) Washi this ew vembring wf | ovabing en lia In Brig the eigen, by drawing bn he vi cvamalipal nee nh Theta nn Bo ais ste nme ores nds he pal ele hese nl Glo ppp (20), by he me open peas th Ter ing dr ate op high tinal ncn Spe mec Degen Hohn of athetc maxim ho lt fer rh in: a na mv en hi ru a te al). One mg wget he pl deaming po einen he Dg 8 hilo he Vow af Chaya alec ch pcr and ha hee he im hsm dy he Oe po ee ifs nti yng at cee by me ha ge snd igs ab the nae ain two bri ny and ig i Duron of be Bat Den tent ay de te mee Beam toma fon nace arc ton en ee enacts msn erat binging oer rs ma cui the src ffm ny sal Eiitantetarigeenecnretnstet ici Joho Vis bas suggested, the Slmmakers sought to be 3 hese ‘princi adr empha hat hy denn shir waka me nel comer esp with echnigue. ‘Tao stan expen ofoppestion the way Ba iowmaking ws nai a ame eds the nc -eotventions of style and technique ~ he inslarence on sella Fader West as ‘dng the presen vei hia in re podton ‘arth ance several mre mo =a ele he We poe ‘Biter isa an pion the mop operating in lo tisuibcon, and te final of prac an ow coir Rie ‘chic wee iff, consoeil Hate was evolved ot nl the aa {mand fran indent ier ing Hmm ater han 3m tl onded an anus gauge) Bt a concer sow tha goed ls srr ua mot mor ly fo mado sal besa (1977. ae et nsesacred wh voto a ats npn oan rn oS a ‘ai wd ane csi re fe ec 1th stn ot nea he rian esa ee Dap if impotent a tg a ois oT Dg 3, ‘hein he De Aenea te Prof Tt is aoa ou they lis omen of re Cinema igling he pote Spe the cnt of ic und, pore competion a gh es ‘Son afediing nd be wan wich hoe ngs wee oie pro Shr showe nc hat ingly lo ke br bw the aly a ts won Song artigos ea ne inca mated yea deo ‘Ronse porcie making ques andthe rfactor in sok “Te a cea ure ere with sp ofthe Doge move. dicencebereen Fe Cine sd Doge 9, howe ha he flo ve (10) al Ade ano C1967 examine wha mal ‘ines rein dcuments ad were roundly ound vp wither Bieftwbency ‘dca tx” Nowe fr Macken tras of bs in. ad et Kocsce e raen iv th sued. Fre Cina te gre oar of Dg 93, He emphasis he a dt Dogme Fe Cie fcsionl rh new way a ns nd a sunt nw pee gen wi pb meré (200: 31). Thee {Zo dented ramen stad see hea of ech movencat in es ‘emp nda Ande nd von Ter mobil no aon. Mace Magee hat cal fence bree he ve Cina aie a Fane thar he Dope mania Sethe empss une ofthe mane and et of vows uaepaning Dogme 95 spe ay the dog oh proj mere aay fom ec of don nl coms of suc and rh, Sale ave commenced bo sie abe as eed in ra sendin he hey Doge Bs yon 1995: Conch & Tne 200; Veal Kat 2000, Chena ol 2008), The lationship bres ln and ale an eb san bin lv hry al hoe etc dew nn by ees sch Sg in Dope ns oda the poe owyrphiccompostion wo ey somthing of tae wo. Sigg atte up sandler labore mien edt ft th alt enc ot rm Kec anes tha i pre odin fi fom rs The coneyoFa dss ao an ano cover ly cnema” nsf, hats which incor aspects fps ely witha view ming ‘pins dem. And yet he he li einen of wal 1 sdk, which ae vail nese f ln an at a ser ‘hol oe be cafe wie te eb as cen tee sag Imac owing oe ea ee poet (1960; 40) fen fom + pope elgal etq of cama prfucton a wl tone eraneegel oo os hoe wich nl aldrans mola prods doer wow fing sol cic oh lly ei sche nan hee he Dg : =e Kes th, hate scent fs pop nema’ ee eon ef eperneeince pcan hs topecno Dop ste foc or le Vier H0, Sag Iii oH crave us pa ents jee es sl abe eh ofan gag, Te se mena th whic ft enn sci oF cr es eng ‘isons mona of amoronl pn no men The aso 4 aly patie with Sse ee Ain nis fds ice Ia of mel aon andthe mir Kes eal Jpn iment gin opening tenant coe We Mos Kan when tpn veh pe oes ty hen ee Wh sone en wth Kaen an a wire penn ke ‘We ci em ga one in aon he ay of ning awe sa he yh Dope Seerwat aay rs nn reson meray ea Sew pad Sed the pall he wy SOLE Dope im rs in ree eh ona Dieter poe memo ce a een SoBe 35) nad, Mk a sem eu ‘epee he dcimenaty cob nn he ayo GL muh he Doge tren We Macnee a ce aa fink en de fm te cone 1 iT tant el gd he pe hee ‘Ss pingon This haan ingore ct of he Frain of our emotional repose ‘eel, whch canbe uno in ers fact ‘Act can be peealyundertod whe bere xpeson of main, bic may ive ll xpeions, ah et or Bling, among ther “hing. The pcbaogal imenson of nodon wht a sake ete ne aman sbjece may Bd themes enpreing minal ragoes which hey ae sot dicey eons of dng bu everest cools ran cere ne nother coma ispoublet over a emtinlexont being within ‘cl without it ing wl epronel~in her words pone ein repr pec modo pans and he afield “Accounts of hw aes he aes fen dew on the dices of acannon the ways which emotes can non the enon el well a the ofthe concn il Fr Fe eles i ‘lat othe inno deer and th changs in bial neers wth the des Explloting Fats potion, em Lplncsnd J Beraed Pat ager et ie af hs py espe vale, digi he emesoat ‘eprom expres pel one Mat fer ower ‘ete purposes untae ay ofcahede hear dei at thes ramponion of he yf mena energy Ke a {woe tem i cou einige wicoat oe ence sscomclonen, (1988: 1) ‘Actchsa bunds the ein inp fame nds feng ano with ental xeric ay ot bey dca ‘wat raber tepeemed. ‘This makes it posible for affect to become buried within the ' md ce wr of ther exesienes ln Whe cones ln espera mages ihe itch fle reponse, gt bg the freemen engi sad epost ey eer ‘ie malades Thi portant oan unde of hw bec ower bar unplemiable lagen even cxperence ean dvi Ising ta cof on Tiers work spent api uch ue a ‘Mec anderen and Th i gegen The qioton of ct an portant nen rao lhe ln aoc wih he Dog 95 been. The Sl ve wan aug the ne and, Fat shoananptorcroct our emaomland colic eperen ofthe mel In hirer Dogan be and with An Ba mani ve of cnc tr, Fr Bi the eo cf Seo buen wat le raf way ‘es abou the nto of rath or atin the wed Aslan Coch ad Ela Titel ve gee, Bsn + ln be rach une baa ein oF map Them pear een rte iageshuld e fl the epee fhe mage ered by the pcr in ey 200. ‘What sneering nthe dain fhe elm ofthe Doge 95 ri ‘he wei asm nla p with hese he movement which ea eat roxmblince documentary segs Ye, ax Ove Cree, ha bere, the ‘nes of Dog ls ar prema be Betta he nto ze ‘he mdiene tobe teri’ (200s) The eof documenta ye as more yes tha aes about te reltnsip of ety to etm she Dope ns hgliging hema dacamentay ye can be deployed ithe cones of Sto ‘eth the legge of fmaling ad leon ie dry Ths cera ‘bout he neal of ech, ri and cans ecapeled matdely oe ios ease of ery ile pay with the igi of acumen What cars hirer mesure play withthe sf of nena How dos von Tir manip ni coments a od to evs the spins nding ‘wht nes al emai! Wha dos hina ote pls of wg ch {lin And ow dosh pay dh doctentay erate ity othe pc log oa ace Whe th a Li Recent debe dacamenay thoy Frond the ere dae ition of dca rena t0 Boon, of dosumneay cli andi cave et vo cours Fauhonipand nection (Wion 195; Carer 1996 Bras 2000: Niche 200) In ne eal ager Stone eh i iering in ation {lac Th iin which en coe cabo with per cr. ‘cee daca of eal and ec The nave flow the anc of {seg oF young pope wt mmnerdc mesial, Spe engin ole {© eros call ab sound bly snl ety. The ln i aot aan ld camer, nein ae of camer work mre ly acid ‘with documentary, tay includes » number of o-cemern ‘aking heed inerview cone ch hye wr ef uc? do tt Utes wei of pc gel etn oa “he ne ng of decay lg tt might bgp with Corr ode (99 or th Bl Nel nr told G01 39 cea cnptvon py Mea poopie ‘reeds ener em cry reg nt {ound How Sen hawt wets of econ me oe re tepnsfsctln Yo fe co empl fecha eft Thr pn op abe, 188 compe dca aed decane. nwa sc nthe ie of wat Nec on dw fete model deena (1996 50) se acing ae nd ‘lrg ptt eng nd eee cl cnt ne a choosing to incaporate a hand-teld camera 8y-n-the-wall aesthetic and co- comers ni pts th natn The Has, pon or ‘ay ith he amen at in der ght he in hel a ths cnn ngen fhm sre al fantom ‘She ee fre he 009) te eve Gy lr momen tise deren, dhe ny emt Ahn they tod on pane econ Wh he fol a (Soonby espn nbn ceri en al ogni ‘weston ened igh nl ate aoe Toad el afc The ver dpi alr our maps wh ty bt thy 3 by qn en lecvting Th ro ges ak cs ah TOSaE tage iene ali of te ces cage tes he seca pied ese ere ‘cals ental see et aed ari tse at ‘Secs ndg Moree Teena tae ching Coven in edwin Wet cmon te mes he ac, dey lens ect, Imig pra hegre eth peepee tubing of tg Bis Some Lehigh che ny fet ‘aint nas papain: Reedy towers we eros ‘monet emempl nine aon heme en gh a (Sueno he nce acco he in ae pore {Sting cing emer of eer rape nh Tink nya epee i he concn oar he ag et Of fin when arora home pan of em “Tener ns pt a wt he leo Sr ps mae es oe tip sce of ten Hn ped (anchor quads of ncn tht aged ak an enon rope one hats pemial ina The ol of he canes mir the Spectra wns crcl he proces or rtomip tthe Been whe malin mde of cling ar ope ot fay with the langage af However in the doing anqunc fh ln, he dc ad he pc ie companies ch wil dpe node reduce iI the lis dling sequen the came, which ha wal om Rone eno he ‘ean ula «Joinery ett, deny seo hs sees a ot Of much more Fin ave md ia wich the eer antpt he xton “The apparent independence ofthe ears fom he one ne weed unl nw ep aBton th pn a the cae tk on the gui of Ades (Vans Henk Clemensen, Kae bands hese Her he cae ree fod ar scans! fr + peseped Bon, aniping sn roving wt Andes abe ns Karen For hepato de pclae of i amet to rote meray he ince ofthe aaa this pt. The to this ‘ben som docunatary mance fie mode wanes us fom he peste seat of he dar oat a Bence Theo the moments pound. We rely awoken wo the i of he cba Beas be sede of na ld dd Taff the more core cnet Ineo he lege vlc ut ao i pone epee vlence imped om wv he imi om Then are npr cai remind tat wee aching when ssccemingy shold ee Pycoanle nodding tpn ‘be places acetate inch id of ptt. There ge deal af emery fo the wel other of pcan fr en, dame by ‘hei sch as Lata Miley (1973) dl te Nel (983) and ameoue cher thesis who re sng wi dene woe ch cnet punto wcrc the px an qcstont af pede and pect Bulg othe woo of pct ‘hea nach Cheitin et (981) apd JLo Bary (198), wee ed the thin ade tee of he i hgh + psoas ee omg thaw the camer sips Are ong of Ke, were cued Ou oceariow pcs ora the into ie ped we Aa pee ‘ei heuer die o announce or presence 2 we wath thi ene and we ae fora in be uname pron of voyeur The sane bse sean srperable br seangcty ompeling nd we conn to ge nt dee te ‘ico ca produ walt Etc Te ier pean to cee hemi of king, ccounig ot encom ade te pon of enloner ont Fay in drt mann {bone te fol we of he Gn. At de mete, howe, the le teamed sl tegh tr peacion of ecemereny yen egy Teisonly tthe nd when ths ippge mae ptt otha we fd ele In eunbeanble potion af kid no ropes the arate dour rom se ft fur vjeation ad the eof th marae ea, "held dr no alow to tay with panies reper oking fe, sv are activ t ond ined age mening, We ae re «© gig with be inal mera aucaig rth in oder 92 kong, ‘passions The we of documentary ast sais the ssf decades ‘hespecrtaroout the by ofthe lin, What or, he arate aban hem eves onthe chil qusnabe ans oa op of wiles young peopl who sck the ‘inner illo’ by Spang in ai of pb and pera ‘ange The we ofthe doce sever ht, ocurge pas udp ‘mse oaraive a 1 wore wah und yo, wt ype {al deuterayand ne alg dre This ha a pt et ela oa eprence fpr nen Trdktonly plein cn dered con oth ens we ae ale tu mak wth pagans ad marae ts om decry of dexmagl mee and the ig of lone in he en feat In Th i ception ae dared Tt pce fo so nh l,m anchor panei which we nigh ely dacen meting oh ay of Inngige ac avecmeto ow i Thecompecy a te nermesrng of eons of trathand Bon cle mucin there mloed by on eta in is lings oe ure th bok nour ying or pho wge oon. The alls pda in the spc the py, and eur cpu lea te ema eof hi el in acto a ade pve wih mene ding peat ah ln. Esse ln Fre coro een tothe image ope a abc or ail penpacive on our nrc xprnce. Thispene p+ ew span which comer poi ening (oie with sca pean ene of joy hat etl ade rd dsonsroced rope and eased ugh the acs wing” or von Te he, fe Bei th traf lft ee of ¢bespeae His play wth nat nd msn endences hee impr _sthou he seking cone the wean fran inde th pon ack {no nem This ne the ols of Des ese he net af out rpbolgliveent in cinema plane. The fantom lm ara hs ome "oben nd gh testis ap tt any deny mad ‘Shon and wich are hee props ema in Krcaues see I abo imporane note tat Te do dees a relent pec inca sense atthe lel fae formal proper aa prune he Peloematv pls atthe arf he monroe salle Doge: Pied Acc ond Os ‘Asal Gast, Ore Chinn an ote ve ot Ti i shou fl raking aa pt For Cheeven, ‘hes i sou ang ad ole playing, On fhe hanes the raion bre plying lean Being tpn The fn ln bat making Te dog the ln destiuou anh ages a oon aed sel hay ete of he ak rope lighting and he hl ‘ame The eltingdew aeon othe ln al Bi ala pr of the docamentary le The nyo wcon duty ine Ile ronan eth) sd mad ry here kes ‘he ah invite int hear fl an the rama In ‘his, The do lst own ang, 2000) For Git, Dh lio aned Porton ate is abun autewr projects aswel athe pursuit fw (2008 10), a te lee of fo, ad paral a te fing that hee Dope ln nde ne a ten ices once with yea of Frtbing w apace. This in keping wh te tos ll of lay abd Anowingen that ae depye i the mani el of cure, ad it ie hporant wo ae bo that td cobintion of snenn vo elf, ‘he Marg of yuna beth nate and foal vel ad the sel ‘onl ad pyle of ear pcp (epi the one authaing ‘Snemaic ecigue impli nthe a) tt mark he ou plc Tob Raters aga that Doge 95 lacks pal punch sod chanced by dele rence (1999: 12) Thi seme isthe pif he py wih oo of elim, docamenary sey and Sera, bower, ei we econ the ats of he Bm aa The pls of Doge 9 spar oe in ‘heve-dephyment of deat aout ibe ao nr aad iin dis repre ‘0 thececpingcommeraliaton of he fn wdd on gb cl With ro ‘sn shes pene in wht Chien a charset tly em we in Sige ch at Clots Kevin Sri, 1994) and The Bai Wa Pat (Dai Mick {Tauro Slat, 1999) anda ames contemporary ality tevin sows). age an be cone aly and dace Never in onic fencing of dba aoa autheip andthe dn ofthe ee wae he ‘movment abo deploys an rnin er tee diane Stes of lm sry 1nd ln hon they een the enol ase udepaning he scholrin ‘ound ens nd pstioning elf a coment po The mull of ling ann fre carci the ey lms emeig from the movement Thi show bo the fae embed nthe mari a i ues gh the en acing leer who wih oe ta incenng onmerciaion ftir ae The plier f Doge 95 sep the mann ‘ater han rly att bu thesis write in th editing ecg ‘el the me an inthe delbersecnurucion af ma such teaching + oom on cameo hw a oy suet ein dpe of at The me Aly of the cof sing 2S sighed in nts sch th, and chi Ingoan in png ores the wy in wich ene rs de ‘ood. This fancimenaly abou omadcios a he pj sos 1 ek ot ‘men of lentng the views ft ls whibe sinleoalyecoaring he to pe graner auton Whee Rar oleh the vie ofthe lr here 'eangy fess ad bj csi spa on aff anyone ot sything i) wold suggest in che ppt thc The wef the imma iemade epic nthe diy of he mann and er ands ine sen: The pair f he mara arcultedthrogh he elo of ye ‘arene and fr andr designed up engi apne ou cheat im and the ues of nema apa the pr ofthe ape 95 funeral 3 ‘est projet making rom fora otk de ponies oft ecole of ae al eu dh {2 asef debe daar nent othe ote of inna in coli domains of fie eormumption. Jane a the in of de rma srg te: ‘abl wha coed he i lef nena the Rin pred gh he Dope 98 projet can be em poo the plo Gee an et famat heart of cod century. The ute oth Dope 95 re hen Inbound wp wih ine allowed ueone about the ie of et and aan a play wth the eget of the unc ingen ad wth ch abi af ‘heise cating thom, Dope ly rw aero chi raping opamp abu ‘wal ea, aed ier ae oc The ele vege othe de of od! lang pace tt ante by Dope le teal the work of Ralph Ace (1957 fr whom, nando become 4 work ‘far lm nels to go beyond he ache eri inet mel ng ‘ole ei The ranpuleson of aly gh cigs ach at ing ‘cnr the ic endear of cinema in hw While Dg expire the prea fr inlecing rly hough sete ofan fray with ‘ing came cig po ede ely in partly eat ‘hur ocean compa the stony of fle an ain a igh ney ‘ht rao ith Armco Aran iV “he quesion ofthe aii vase of Dogme 95 a4 project by ition nc to ‘ake in acount de extoninty spel of be movement boond he hou ‘Ine The bcos Wee nen in he Doge aif a the Vw (Chari have impr umber of rf? efron the projec inl ‘aging rom documento dace and compute gue diy In oon, tee oe ben amr af ands of the Doge mate wich make gps pay vith sce sd alr, Mace Hoe fran nein ner ofthe dae ae proi, paing hey example inching the Ly 98 mani winen bya np of Dan spear and arr re wong oth tn hy ral wen in wont st dv and ln viewing» pate 0036 140-1) For Hp, ‘ork the pris pd the interac exes ofthe of he meen her sper feral productions inv of is expt cee mines, ighlghig tbe it tt the mas can and inp the cot ofthe ls Hore gg ar Invited. win chee nate wor an avian osc so lope a me-cmaticsuac tat makers cing raga phe enn of flowing the bu for more mmm and aan ellen on the hitry af dems, nding some fe wr ad ‘rene plans, Aadncr af une meat fo engage othe Kd Ffiscnde pcs of meningmaking ta lw com eke see ‘ofthe unlng plo and to be move by the charac with wham thay te encore alg hemacher: Br by ise fhe Dog ae thy ‘ee abo epee vo enerain mond-onr comer ang od fo ‘example, with che pervasiveness arp al lyimacy of ertin nematic tc hell ierveaing ofthe mani wth the mate ln bjs sa fe Hr oun or the pid Jobat of Dogs 5, wk fins bing ae ‘Sedan eit al ound the wel Th es ein ioral pctciy ml hes ower at ltl to the rola he tre in sring the (aby of the Dogme rojo lal nll cand pao od ‘Sin aich come porta in any temp andeneand he pli eg hs tic netcinmc eeu “The Doge 95 website in any way 2 cea che vis of he ne snc tis othe manent he anf, he le atthe ls he Scher Wh it ifmon ago of ick ee loge te bck of ep, [Steeda dha atendon to de seeing) Bape use in which tbe fora co be sod, Conaning inks to res and nerve abt “Eee ning been an the Hi they produced under te ups of he Iotemet the west originally aged by Nib nd Zetrops podcton ‘Binpmts e-omed bythe inc themes 202th Doge 95 callie ‘SoU coe down the ‘Dogon wi the ret atthe Doge fl ‘Torco te wade by anyone a all uel nye inte woe old naw ee (era (mma. doer poset. or a number ‘Foca sed the ed of Dogo ovement (Gilbey 2002, Bl 2009) ‘Netcast Dg wee contin oe ena resoarce on which Bl ‘ke moe cr ofthe Dag la snow mage by an acai Athol the wei ap to dt wh infrmation abut tember ols ade ‘caer de fo the pedo tie. Dogme er fm ded vs “ugh lng fhe nr ad che mp te moerent oni be psiveaoad the we Toco of the mere ee hn ter ri Ihe pres Doge a s plied nate-cienat arin and allows the enon ted sect morement wo sure Beond the enone of ts wh conc ‘Te age 95 besten may penal ave with fe the proj, bu te Cy et sie and conta 0 desap hgh» kind of sos Low ‘genta hs ecourg nd 0 make ins ad 0 ake hi los nye he csi of dg echosag: Dsante wor of Jang rma Osa Neg and leader Kage, Hjorth an porta poi EE delopment of cone puis in fing sac forthe exploration of Ince ie fr he bagi pble per (0018) Fr Ho this {porcishapng he ayn wich Doge Rsk Te open pe: ‘nich covers aot nar are clint he pub acon romping usin. Kies she ce however ha ener publ ae making Teun fhe nero a eae of acting oun aemonc pin Reandpetics (Becher sal 200 Soh 2003)" The new och overets a een inch cy mentyfie cen rex he pte of haere ods Wty al ping reat new ‘pus wap of ga son he het el meron Inch dra f commana di the De 95 poe deen fhe ie tm walang cen. To pig Joni ofthe pe pero ho ake een sae oe ‘he movement in ent ites ang eh be wad Sal ang Dg doin cn te pl yo od en er thf en of ang a tm an dtc, Yu he es ae De il nd ch Src bee ol be gon! i sn tink Dogue sd uve an asin em ee ewe id three agen dc wel ae ee ‘(Bondebjerg 2003: 222) a or on‘ he crn pd de in he way in which Doge ‘cna in aang mf mcr of he em He pont 2 pereea dich pried fn senders caning hepsi ‘an caing aa wore ipa ten So cery coms be bene sorely inte of ce stra ner es aco ‘ocmations unfolding across the incusty. Increasingly von Tree characterises his =i won Ter dnc a wth foment nny soo whet tect padcton rather han den, Repos coeur sas de fischer lain wih the co-owner of Zentop, er alec jen a 2005 en Ties enow pose rately nce fp er ping di sng tbs mache pod ely eae cen ls Beh ne ts el dane wa wings gp Cen 2003189) Ate ae tn hoe ths bes ahd chest ‘or Ties om nnaing i any fin et pe ig pa ‘ly ince a mained Te USA tad of Opp gy end ‘be pawn sy weno be Dope pot pods» nana ‘ete th res hy on hen sgh ape al ds Ie ‘etic dare of Dope 95 wih flo aon has hfe ne gun The polis, homes ate aly become more xi teat ly come moe epic, he ee cap _ CHAPTER SIX Narrative Structure, Narrative Codes and Questions of Genre and Spectatorship Aa we ave beady, on Ts Doge 9 roe ad he impacto he (oitesCabt of wr aig me iy om 2 ch Sloped sing twas Ba ome mck er ad moe ber “he pin caer hs ci rm he er of es rosin poche pt doen ich sone ci ih Teer Sc movenen of ener cae Th hore ot ‘neny snare one ln epson heel ors cane ee vo “Tran ge aon ce en “nig oy ey pai espn pach ln ich fey en sn oh lr of pn thew hr low on oh Dg ps copie te» doe ea tbo of etn pes wn er Doped wen heal Heat ‘Tog lef of anal aarp nig, bate a [Tce fom af mie sree in ich dma cts comp ental {eum tuapeson sed ly ecm. The gy tempi of ‘Braking Wn Te sd en Dk The Haves bse td dy mor le af dandy mak ie el een {Thc natiecomeionsadon inca ie pea hi cape Sal com he Rs logy say elles! fo we ne Tarp lg beef he ce ith con hog em hl -lferive quality of deve Hs ie npervane in wivlerstanding thet narrative devices, nd hse cel he wy vo Ter don grr eres in ech ‘th ne ‘Question fg ln ate ot nprcbematcand i thoy grape een sly with tbe question of what we ae to dst yi rm Mich wf is ete centres on the distin beeen ln ap nd gs, sigalig te yin ‘which oa cat cane be asd onthe bi of camel appeal td ind appraches wo ctegiation ad alo redo in calurly-pecc ‘ys! Conetadons of gene to emerged nthe ote ofthe ph ‘hi dy. with parca anton eng pido he ployment onary pp. il stats inde by of works by an gen dete (Ween 1998), Other iach the def ge in ls the nnd coun of oma phic pects of ge (come 1986) ot akg the my gent ep ‘hot wok feat nls ound sci neon (Scat). sn impr ‘un cntbaton he debate os gare Se Neng has ene ens ‘ois xpecatons conventions thar cca been ny etd ‘ube? (980 19) For Nee, hen gee shaped mach bythe sun expec ion sis rag eal onventon, Ges ana Eed and nord they ase Fel foundries Isted, gener onvenin le! ce he ec boas i, poche fons in many we von Ter wrk beeen ‘scxemplay of hs tendency, he llowing ston wil capo. We mii ages tte ‘Gld Hea’ egy of na wr tothe Raber San aerate the mos fl wy fing pn tha, ot et of cue Isoute a tamgeline resi by which gen dnc can ply {Tow gee lps Role ger, ij Rew ny in exe {pe our new progres cnt ins omvie gent ply ee that dsr rile. Ths we move fom wa tno t ce ‘tnfomatve operato.(2000: 129-30) Nath Tee The quston af nen hugh hel He egw he a i= ‘ew he ene of nos Von srr old fd iis Inthe wlevion see The King a diced in caper fu). Madama of ‘ue ain aie wih ep pete and wich he woman and hiner ‘singin hing tiga how we igh dno on Tiers in hh Gold ot elegy itn Tis’ og? For vn Ty, in his wrk, lor “una evi the ringers wna egy bcos he ‘wade ofthe lg in ase Howe rhs wil ma lent, none af ‘he tis ia salhtrvand eon fama tonal on et tales op the fadamena of mca uth compl them an compo: rvs hen by yids they wih fence toch sng icon nine the _rruous forme asthe documentary, comedy and de Unt HA Wier 0 ‘nc ofthe nares oped der o the emt od [Gocmai mln har gs ince dhe ahd ac sto wi dase and an appt aun Te len jsp ih “Sinica cm whic ae en epoac arg eg yh A easton wth ey ral gue sch Beat ech ad Dogar Sie? td with ew of wt sed eal peel ed fic, ig Sl ner of emir ger of wha slope aban) taeloenme i uence el plil poten. Mara "iin sate, dram sider wth he power ted in Gti 198721. Inisxcone plnton,snenson to the wealm feat and (fen xi epic of dog Sy mide fe 5 sof cn ac ese Iie and he expen of ey pcholop and ocr ate epee ‘ese nsich way ao aptlueon lw indtial prices wh athe amen raping the. Nodtama is fquniy enifiel n eMac rn he ‘Sco Lnd fil ge th rather ot wiht pital agen of Hall ‘sod aah nde Ease 1987 Io ems af the fos neon on colt nd guetions of moray and ehicy i pis to Dome cer why his ge of ‘Gea gpa diet ouch aon Tr Aled oe, wil ea in pap ‘errr tein eo ecnigue sc nec roared deta he a8 ferarhing concer wth quesion ih and wrong and mh ions of ei By eaming ay Fo the maine aca ipl in he cal wk cn adn von Tie shoul eke wp more melodia spac ois woe “Tac ch af the fins in he ‘Gd Hea og i ted nico can be seen ai ghnce Gn the bi plo dee Brig Mba ben called Femara melodic om 8 young wom, Bes Ely ‘tason), whe ith and die acl ine quton by din fb angering lore fr ber ing bad, Jan (San Sknaped, In The Hi the dda nds uly piu hop ofa pd docamenary come, aching ‘senda inthe lr sing nunc when Kate str ly ome a ‘ing ing fr vera wes afer he deh er cd in ore pin nt [sf them. Lay, Dene the Dark mal mde» ely id os In which he mua cmponeo af te fin reread ope im iy by he indnece f the dada cancer ofthe are (ced oe de ‘el “he modems quale of the lim, however aot mel maha the lel of oy and plo. An pore eof loam the wy nope aspect oth sry ae arcuate rough fil fom and wi evs, Fen the mo emotonalychalgiag macs of melds af ep oh seen eae men fhe ete at nndgete rate ‘eves sch t mas (Eiaener 1987) In moras, a wll doce, ch rec cones a fen sce ie ces 2 fe! of marae tit sei {echo the pycoloia sop and emainal capt of the saan ia ‘nh ena chara Hl mas. Yor von Ter. of cour, exces hoe road ‘ro Tac ck Weapon ig, ne cn cern gt ete rope fr exile ht wr en wok The pe mel ‘hana he, wld era ee din hin ‘on ie oe web nth log poe andinsibed a sie way occ fm As ene above, Binge Meas bee eed ‘simon eo a ayes commeneon how the ln ences bra rr of mort nr coveton The pl ener rue he ms. hii dec of teen ct, Be, nd er wil sj a reponse er hb ering hea The en oe fon the cond Inc ofthe cen for bth he chats nthe arate and the wee olin Mach ofthe Rn cond wh the waco emote xpd md Ho dine andthe ae eed via sof ba dpcting bet ‘erweaening pip on ere mod of compenent a xurlyenconel nora ears Te commen nich Bo espn erinanty ows one on dis deied wth ec sso wlio ety ‘hich dolled the power rats pay on th nal end, aad, ‘le Charch les ap dy‘ fie ling ean uct of eis iy wth gud hs emi. A fn the nn lana the reac brea te eommuniy ayo hou he mrs tei sal ‘haere Bets ly boner theta basa is bole and i wis inp dang Ja oon ae poly and all he bpd ‘nme camped open dept th ic tt we the al ates ino ens thine bu of ele Ter es ea we fe ap to frre thi camped snp nd his aden hed coms to thing an expan sb fhe ld dap oe and its pene In th moda aon ch conta cn be en race oh queion Kista th impale dite The wee nba hat which nat be vocal and hi incre in common wth Bes Us see fx and di in chit ln ded bom, ‘Sich bolo eno ernie ade of dhe Chu on ihe nd bat cao highligh be feng opprenive stoner sounding Bex whe come early he commun rs alot eaten ew nee ‘yeni with sang in bal ol eo ty seme Wess het Wer and notion olin edn ens nich she ken eveling cowed sh lead brea lanza of hen ech fal avy repr ack this es of urgoning bao and andere arin ‘fil amas eepone lo Ja le yo the iw ni thecramped lone ho whee she celle nal pce of ‘hetckphoe be eae the oly pce ae oes or teal of et sir pve er with le ven or wise wo cl and ‘het ila Kron wl cme a er “The sal of mama i highly dependent wp dhe poi ey of hunts emotional Ibex Nera erate ten sete ante placement of emotions sper and on the making of metaphor and marae parle. In aig he We one sich ral sews bere he conven thar Bes at ne elon i Jn a th ons with God, wich ne wea fo us hey ‘Spring sme ofthe ine a her ater ole race of bic Tan wb under incon ero rtrd om cra dese? AS ‘Bos her ile obe Haw cin oa lee + word ou cba ore words You ano bein oe with ard You cn be aber aman being Thats prion. Fragile hea thoughout the mith Bets perce men sy prong the hy urate mares fr hi Hone i he ends comes lat ‘rk efits und he lig dcrn pn whieh the Chard cde’ Contd oie n he and sail Dee he power imap ofthe gs bing rua in te and of ne af he vee dig Bes and Jas weg se, the pone of he Char respon prlaminany idea onset tog ‘on Tr deloymn ef te lima gle Av he bd fhe ln, when Do ‘ean Cards) ges the Ch ence a Bes ms a be bud ‘onload und the pica srcrre nal expe Melodrama fqn wha and lg cq asws he seen ninth cof vn Tie wore, ital ely thee Bos actos Soin of bu pu forth din a her arc aed be ecesve behvion Seinen depict hugh she mien te han ough mow inal means hancerition Her nergy hep apd re des ese a ferinsnence on enlig arund on 2 cyl aking hero athe sand Uke) ‘tle Betncong eo flo and lon onde one hand, bu ao ere mane commlemen lrg ot exces sera inte (hich se nich prod oer imagination a Ja xaos forgo with another nthe mame of pun f goon The native stat fhe le, wich ‘oq lo dps hee by srs of dialects which rescore by pop mi ck fm th 170 anders thi ating she Wo is rca nto seen chp and a0 elope” Each ‘pera by an tre of moving age soe tt hel i ‘ne sh. aig meee fhe ase sence wth enn! codons pe heigl theater novice of fl wh as tack dhe orp of mlorums tthe Roratie peri: Ue any ways Arabi ‘Se rp open ay ther ef oman reg apc of ‘oven en ng snes ocr of at dee SWlics etme ef aman min nab henge od oe fle wn ual cnn tnd ny Roman wen he Tiwi fe wens bln neg Sind pent hgh ool tice fe nk “pombe taly ed re mle wi unde emp ‘remo oman sing ‘rete ee onenil per ein eon scar tettoc ora" ewecfmatteciiamss aden ple fee Thomas Hiner har asst Medina ia dame nanan which mas scompanimen mks the emadoml ef. slow melodramatic cements bes ot onsac fs tem of ptason, ingens lou and chee ‘Brecon hyn by oes err pnd downs niga (1987: 50) Cee ma anda fot oe en ee eer Cie eg eee Free eeetsre meres ore ar stone htanenryereage ae bettie ee eee tein ketene teen eta rete serene id no a esarnen fay nore eye el agent cree ten aoe om eee tee iret er gen a Segre Tee i eee pee weer a pee re Seen dh erence ro se a ec reece ec ‘malo of me eve wlan emo. nore thee an bors on nie etn ee are sa making nw eet chs tna ee osname esti eeseeoa [tn mates echo Scan te kg Sint pene an alvenes hearers nee ee heeft Seah an ene se ‘sl ic wing hgh hemi sen se eg ce Sha hepa stn ly hanes Gace a ‘tig tee nor eon empha site tn dips emf mds So ed ‘Kern he crab sane oa ‘seco "ring ht he a er or el cn i png ee morn age on ae sei tee Mn ean meng on ne We iw med nh respon cer Bape ‘snr ao motes orn tess oe 21 ry ie The eet Br dot eho as ee ubing nee menace cas hake (htt ee ah ena ee Ws Dane eats wnt manor sane ta ‘ute Aan tlnp Sn Bi wap, in so fanantic on nee tk ‘ha ke ton ea ne eel ‘di cmpron he er se yeas Sl hea fe i csp So ‘aw ah han a ay Rees bo ee Vr he moe chm pate des nes en iat ete nose i bce ea a espn oan st hehe ten nee th iy ng nd dr mens wT geen Se cre ‘olin til mca ens sh he chen mi heed eo of por mun Sat sel se ‘can mig ay worn tao ee Site wing pa in pee ah oeaicbe het nite heparan rm tiene ‘ein foals pen fn en a Ih ge fed tan en wee ee oe ‘ng 1837) ae oe cl Ce, Ws ‘von Tiers ments, however 1s his by naw falar use of «very parioar hand Tells ed docuenay le ery par apps ede gto rive chee ent othe bat ao Tar ey spa “plan ip tosh igh on the ways wh the dren ee the buato {rnc conven nich the ls win hi oy. An Ba of Spe ‘noel sore he iematic yl of he "Gal Ha ely sind wth he ‘Pesoge 9 ln cch of he in making yp hogy thew one hat Tew in em of et athe prt fancy. Tis gl arate ‘hough hc ofan heli video camer strug a peck mont ‘Ang tht fronds ice wh which es posileto ening dey Bn ing in he conarction marti esting The han held ste of shod fins mores oct wih he pene of documenta, epesg i doe teouthingofthe tempo capa the ni fe memento flv ado ey he Inmet of ens te sna pear Ince cone fit las he le its uneapesed nd mew oon” This ban dean fr th conensnel ngage of cinema canbe nde ins numberof nage By sgn coc wh eos ane te nora ‘veo in ning lie ht pple with te ee ality feos i ‘Sig, Senay fen eager and eel fe motingcamer-wek ss the Lind of exes nlc at ewes of on Tir er wok a ‘hey ns cealn me of ratooip rain ough his wrk Te ‘Rotem fan pic pe sch moda hgh recur eo ech te ‘ronal erate witha olen aed dorama se dps expe: ‘ns ih ead he soa the marae mani tough he wea ‘aro documentary spe bs 8 athens he ovation a pcg “nsefteing dete on besten, amor he hecho these kgs “hd ping ay of eves thie i gore ahi wy, von Te see ean pro ccumnene signal proceso Herc ach whe wich nigh be ogee in near Halon ln. Tihs the sk loang he sporadic pson of mod eget with {rma and nate cen, ping now poston of af: dos. The SeERNe qu a fen nerd yoo Te weds ma inthis epee Ahn pe nd wbstnc, the following dcasion shows ‘nT approach othe queon of nematgrny in hl ogy re wich ent of then, Fes, Ter ade we of ne hun st came och ofthe musa sens on Dar he Dakin haem cpus 4 ‘lnc of ve tml! for the mca uke, Ona rina fino ng $n ch inulece wold be impo eae of he usin of xt O nr in Dek omer, thee of dita camer ened vo Ter 1 pare ‘hice feo show ta the moder usa ares eng souk fe toes eying to psy mn vying rica (nan 2013 29). On ‘waking he Waves, vies alana Wis author dscance frm the camer work, enone Ni Me ph ae re fsa hr smug ta eng weer vo ea (27a thes lo vo Ti el aes up he omer ping th ding lows nach (veut eon " Janae ea gm pie mo oy TN elf wg es "sh von Te pron i ps wi lly wh sot poi he aby af hacen and dasa shalom rahe rem hm nha a ie ene psf he pag erin sa Ignasi fo vn ee shat ty ‘nd shai (140) emg te ent abound a hie cre athe fo gt ‘how Leni ae ode ih sig Iason dane th pa opting ae I Beds Tha thc the eof Karn sd Saree Late Ha) td hin of Kara parton mr fy sna eb na al sonal em cing throm oD te DS sag _evalts her execution is again aoconnpanie by «pally NARagatve place of clove rein aot he se al reality The hn held caer ee wrk them ara selty wich prs fect ent e monet pace pe ake of ofthe thes? wpe ie wi 3 damn ashes pet anemones manips of demain Ty nob ir eyo Tie enw ced boundaries by ping racine hi exten. In any wap np pret 8 iat ate ceemen i ep erable von Tr © demonsate Rabon win appscaion of psi of tema. As he inl paras hc mane away em cis igh-aed approach conse eran vice fr jana 200215). Homer a we ie a sy hit kof aoe costs 01 witout om aoe ands The idee pen nl bce onogrph of par dive ward esi the coment fu of pontodernin (je haere arth The), reper ning (aie the way which 80 Thar emanating gee oma ey of rureting pacar men of toe tps pct of thew ery who si ocr the mening olen and seach fora el” which nigh be Nock ha rn write on she demas ng te posed je of ate spiton te the ncesing see of ecnetion af da in ‘SE i andthe dnc nein cated cancion of wat the A” sald ‘eilach 1978; Fh 1991, Gilden 1991 and 1992: Ca 1994: Richards 19% Pier 196) Sad mek onic omoder ue in cms of efesvy rs desta wc neal eign je (he) othe. Ts en ‘Spice the oul af an emerge tap eure In which dhe mij pss ‘rial w aucendcat dhe experience of eee emai by eu © model iyo nal eae it ough nthe wots fr nel the ‘Tamra pnmeriy egies nyt be athens ough ‘heer a ng wesc phenomenon as ee ike othe ee {prc nd popular af ety evan i he erent and aly weit ‘ftios Bea! 8 Nan 2005: 9-107 andi ond inthe er more nae ‘Sic tomnaon fhe dil pce Lach 1979. Thor om the qr of india phe a thea of Tie fshonng of he eda pe hs ise ct eal in Dae Dlr his muscles. Th Sia se cy ee 1 ef mein uch aly aye le a mm inne nen iy ne pee anf omc ne i ping oh eee Sn cron! ayn he fh reeling ot ee Inepto dt ome sls ps apo he re Upon aang ‘haribo i Od oa) hee tennessee sts gcapenion Sintra inin odouuter nk rein onan henry all a meine sl ‘crs in ih de um wi and ch Ss ag ‘hramnoe late of ne enya flo St Stoo sus ers fnay mn ehh ese Ds hey ipod scngan ng send cme na poe sor el pp “me gn hs en i mg em sccm ch wy non toe tS ioe {Picnic play ewe mand ‘ction oer i. Sy tl pr dip in

You might also like