UScARC 16-1p23- OP Case Srupns mw EwsamcrEurcnonLmcanon Ty GLE% Mwrey NATUR Boog Changing Party Affiliation C7? °¥a O-#pert. for a Primary Election Van Wie v. Pataki (David N. Hurd, 1:00-cv-322), Van Allen v. Cuomo (Gary L. Sharpe, 1:07-cv-722), and Van Allen v. Walsh (Lawrence E. Kahn, 1:08-cv-876) (N.D.N.Y.) Despite the Supreme Court’s 1973 ruling in Rosario v. Rockefeller that New York's lockbox procedure for changing party affiliation is constitutional,’ New York voters filed unsuccessful emergency complaints in 2000, 2007, and 2008 seeking a different result. The Supreme Court held that New York could delay the effectiveness of a change in party affiliation until after the following general elec- inhibit party ‘raiding,’ whereby voters in sympathy with one party desig- ‘nate themselves as voters of another party so as to influence or determine the re- sults of the other party's primary.”* ‘Two weeks in advance of New York's March 7, 2000, presidential primary, two voters filed a federal complaint in the Northem District of New York chal- lenging New York’s law that allowed new voter registrants to enroll in a political Party up to 25 days before a primary election but did not allow a change in party enrollment for already-registered voters to go into effect until after the next gen- cral election.* Two days later, Judge David N. Hurd issued an order to show cause why New York should not give effect to recent party enrollment changes." Judge Hurd held oral argument in Utica on February 29, one week before the election.’ He denied a motion by the Independence Party to intervene as a defend- ant, but permitted the party to participate as an amicus curiae,.® That day, he also dismissed the complaint, finding compelling New York’s interest in providing an incentive for new voters to register.’ An appeal was heard on January 23, 2001; on October 4, the court of appeals determined that the case was moot.* The court vacated the distriet court’s ruling.” 1.410 US. 752 (1973), 2. Id, at 760. 3. Docket Sheet, Van Wie v. Pataki, No. 1:00-cv-322 (N.DIN.Y. Feb. 22, 2000) [hereinafter Van Wie Docket Sheet]; Van Wie v. Pataki, 267 F3d 109, 112 (2d Cir. 2001); VanWie v. Pataki, 87 F. Supp. 2d 148, 150 (N.D.NY. 2000); see Tom Precious, Suit Filed 10 Open State's Primary 10 Independents, Buffalo News, Feb. 25, 2000, at All (suggesting thet the suit’s suevess would benefit John McCain's candidacy against George Bush). 4. Van Wie Docket Sheet, supra note 3 (DE. 4); Vaniie, 87 F. Supp. 2d at 150; see Lara Jakes, Non-Affliated Voters Take Heart in Court Victory, Allbany Times Union, Feb. 25, 2000, at B2, 5. Van Wie Docket Sheet, supra note 3 (D.E. 8); VanIVic, 87 F, Supp. 2d at 150; Van Wie, 267 3d at 112. 6. VanWie, 81 F. Supp. 2d at 150, 7. Id. at 152-53; Van Wie, 267 F.3d at 112; see Lara Jakes, Independent Voters Lose Fight for Primary Rights, Albany Times Union, Mar. 1, 2000, at B2; Tom Precious, Judge Rejects Effort to Allow Independents to Vote in New York Primary, Butfalo News, Mar. 1, 2000, at AS. 8. Van Wie, 267 F.3d 108. Federal Judicial Center 7282015 1Changing Party Affiliation for a Primary Election A voter filed a similar complaint in the same district on July 12, 2007, secking an injunction allowing him to vote in the September primary election." At a hear- ing one week later, Judge Gary L. Sharpe denied the plaintiff a temporary re- straining order and dismissed the complsint.”” Hearing a pro se appeal, the court of appeals affirmed Judge Sharpe’s ruling on September 17, 2010. While the 2007 plaintiff"s case was on appeal, he and two other voters filed a similar complaint in the Northern District on August 15, 2008." Judge Lawrence E. Kahn denied the plaintiffs relief on September 8 both on the merits and pursu- ant to res judicata." A different panel of the court of appeals affirmed the judg- ment on March 25, 2010." 9.14. at 16. 10. Complaint, Van Allen v. Cuomo, No. 1:07-cv-722 (NDNY. Suly 1, 2007), DE. 1; Van Allen ¥, Cuomo, 621 F.3d 244, 246 2d Gir. 2010), M1. Opinion, Fan Alen, No. 1:07-c¥-722 (NDNY. July 19,2007), DE, 24, available at 2007 WL 2091192; Transcript, id. (July 19, 2007, filed Nov. 15, 2007), D.E. 31; Minutes, id. (uly 19, 2007), DE. 22; Yan Allen, 621 F.3d at 246-47 12. Van Allen, 62 F.3d 244. 13. Complaint, Van Allen v. Walsh, No, 1:08-ev-878 (NID.N.Y. Aug. 15, 2008), DE. 1. 14, Opinion, id Sept. 8,2008),D.E. 17 15, Van Allen v, Walsh, 370 F. App'x 235 (2d Cir. 2010) (noting thatthe appeal was pro se). 2 Federal Judicial Center 7/28/2015: “OTA” Use (Pe Berm BALET @atidavit oath ae Me GEO ie, Nat eurty 7 0 Pan prt a ng an Lastname Ee ‘Sut ‘Your name eR Fearne [f/ieo LO sonal “Yl =| Use Oni: isisseaP te) SEY : ‘The address Apt Mumber_ Poco | (DVAF o vie youlve ——“eyraeuiny Maney shapers ermassvcoay UU LS. Nae Date oti } ened af str (© Passe heck each os appletoyou an ine prot Hans FE ince Reason hie say stat gad som oun ‘oteadoror th uar cation in penne amano nes ee ao athe mre in (neers ty pn ey ress cham Prodan aioe eae: Prior Address: ‘ast oes eiestion when wy, 18a dae Lanawole non sldnouseon hoe babepainden, geare rae ee ee en ome EES Leer yeu ene Nyame eet 34 =——| © cuaticaons apse ——— vexed correct et ste Sarmermecscensen AB ves_ No aaa i Pde More information| Tephetstoat | eu ae | Maint Ena ‘eruaany ont Theadéresswiew —_Attmerasn BS) Awet7y GOD Yeu rectve mai as eae C7 wot regres Soinesene d cvtownss JU Oi concetes Veting history oe) es aN wee Voting information Younes 5 hates changed = Ise /Remarks Sirmvrtcute einen yatanntiioe __Worpriornowertwion camps f Gos SD hekasmowanes 177 ——_ omatnaeinicce —_PRlnteroguayeesdsecyanie exe et (SLT) tine tar a roe: oe Tmeenatna nara ae ee cn seca een py 2 ones Eat pry See: eee, Sees” Sepals seit seperate pee or foe | Oona (© voit ats asp tn oat tow Oreeeninmieemeneeesueeai nist See gene oe (EI oe “Ea eaeresenas Yipee, To oe COMPLETED YELECTON MSPECTOR ; ‘Town or City ward andor | k Site Not hay Eketion Diet Wiley Run Hall 7 sas bo No coun ‘This Section For Board of Elections O wrong et ste oma Po Ste re. Commissioner's Ruling Commisioners initials en, re. Dae \ev AK g_[ Parton tnsectr Soran 2.16-1023 Docket Gonoral Docket Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit btps:/eef.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom Court of Appoals Docket #: 16-1023, Ine: Harold Wiliam Van Allo Appeal From: NDNY (SYRACUSE) Foe Status: Paid [Case Type Information: 41) Original Proceeding 2) Mandamus. 3) none Docketod: 04/01/2016 [Originating Court information: District: 0206-5 08-cv-876 Trial Judge: Lawrence E. Kahn, U.S. District Judge Trial Judge: Randolph F Treece, U.S, Magistrate Judge James A. Walsh, individual and oficial capacity as Commissioner ofthe New York State Board of Elections Respondent Douglas A. Kelnor, Individual and official capacity as ‘Commissioner of New York State Board of Elections Respondent Evelyn J. Aquila, Individual and ofcial capacity as Commissioner ofthe New York State Board of Elections Respondent Helena Moses Donohue, Individual and official capacity as ‘Commissioner of the New York State Board of Elections Respondent [New York State Board of Elections Respondent Thomas F. Turco, Individual and official capacity as Commissioner of tha Ulster County Board of Elections Respondent lots Date Rec'd COA: | oaow2016 Prior Cases: a (08-4731 Date Filed: 08/16/2008 Date Disposed: 08/25/2010 Disposition: FRAP procedural without judici (Current Cases: None Panel Assignmer [Pane Asin | Herold Wiliam Van Allen Harold Watiam Van Allen, - Pationer Direct 845-388-4966 ‘ INTC Pro $9] 351 North Road Hurley, NY 12443 Barbora D. Underwood, [COR NTC Government) New York State Office ofthe Attorney General 4120 Broadway New York, NY 10274 ‘Barbara D. Underwood, - [COR NTC Government] (00 above) Barbara D. Underwood, - [COR NTC Government} (see above) Barbara D. Underwood, - [COR NTC Government] (ee above) Barbara D. Underwood, - [COR NTC Government} (see above) Joshua N. Koplovitz, Esq, Direct 845-331-0100 [COR LD NTC Government) ‘Wapner Koplovitz & Feterfas 239 Wal Street kingston, NY 12401 4/20/2016 4:22 PM16-1023 Docket hhupsi/fecfca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom ‘John R. Perete, Individual and offcial capacity as Commissioner of Joshua N. Koplovitz, Esq, - the Ulster County Board of Elections Direct 846-331-0100 Respondent ICOR LO NTC Government) (see above) The Ulster County Board of Elections Joshua N. Koplovitz, sq, - Respondent Direct: 845-331-0100 [COR LD NTC Government] (see above) 2ofS 4/20/2016 4:22 PM.16-1023 Docket hhups://ef.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom 61028 In Re: Harols Wiliam Van Allen, Petitioner. | Harolé Willa Van Allen, Petitioner, ‘James A, Walsh, Individual and official apacty as Commissioner of the New York Stato Board of Elections, Douglas A. Kelner, IndWvidual end offcial capac as Commissioner of New York Siate Board of Elections, Evalyn J. Aqui, Individual and oficial capacity 25 Commissioner of the New York State Board of Elections, Helena Moses Donohue, individual and official capacity 2s Commissioner of the New York Stato Board of Elections, New York State Board of Elections, Thomas F. Turco, individual and offal capacity 26 |Commissioner of the Uister County Board of Elections, John R. Parete, Individual and official capacty as Commissioner ofthe Ulster ‘County Board of Elections, The Ulster County Boars of Elections, Respondents 30f5 4/20/2016 4:22 PM16-1023 Docket 4ofs bps:/ecf.ca2.uscourts.gov/n/beam/servlet/TransportRoom 4101/2016 o4ro1r2016 oaiosr2016 oajos2016 osiosi2016 41872016 o4 ORIGINAL PROCEEDINGS, PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS, on behalf of Patitoner Harold 470903820 Wiliam Van Allon, FILED.[1743347] [16-1023] [Entered: 04/05/2016 02.27 PAM] O. PAYMENT OF DOCKETING FEE, on behalf of Petitioner Harold Wiliam Van Allon, USCA receipt # 2g is2o1n@ — CA020D0670, FILED 1743967] [16-1023] [Entered: 04/05/2016 02:37 PM] Os INSTRUCTIONAL FORMS, to Pro Se itigant, SENT! 1743967] [16-1023] [Entered: 04/05/2016 02:46 PM 2p aKa Os PETITION FOR WRIT, SERVED. Service date 04/05/2016 by CMIECF{1743379] [16-1023] [Entered Topp. cosines 04/05/2016 02:59 PM] oO? ‘ATTORNEY, Berbara D. Underwood, in place of attomey Douglas J. Gogla, SUBSTITUTED {1743568} [16-1023] (Entered: 04/05/2016 04:14 PM] (146 __ SUPPLEMENTARY PAPERS TO WRIT [1] on behalf of Petitioner Harold Wiliam Van Allen, FILED. nope, 07s0ms Service date 04/18/2016 by CMIECF [1752907][16] [16-1023] [Entered: 04/18/2016 04:53 PM] 4/20/2016 4:22 PM.IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT (Connecticut — closed April 26th, New York — closed April 19th, Vermont — open March 1st) 2016 CINC-POTUS Federal Election Ballots 40 Foley Square New York, New York 10007 212-857-8585 For the Second Circuit - Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Associate Justice 16-1023-OP “In re: Natural Born Citizen Party, National Committee et al.” Originating Case USDC-NYND “Van Allen et al v Walsh et al.” 08-cv-0876-LEK-RFT USCA2C-08-04731-CV + Trump is being invited as a necessary party with unique standing as a public officer sworn 2016 CINC POTUS candidate on the ballot of every state primary or caucus - - and in this specific case Natural Born Citizen registered voters not enrolled in any ballot access party petitioning BEFORE THE UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTI-DISTRICT LITIGATION In re: Natural Born Citizen Party National Committee Litigationto join on the party enrollment lock-box USCA2C original proceeding requesting certification of question under SCOTUS Rule 19 allowing Trump to invite his New York State followers not enrolled as GOP into the April NYS CINC POTUS GOP primary. + See Rosario v Rockefeller 1973 SCOTUS docket 71-1371 + Van Wie v Pataki USCA2C 00-7379 + Cruz NBC eli; ty crisis has developed since enrollment lock-box closed October 2015 + Only Trump the resident New Yorker and lead GOP candidate has the standing to force this issue certified question successfully upon SCOTUS. 15-3472-OP Originating Case: USDC-NYND 1:04-cv-01193-LEK-RFT “Loeber et al. v Spargo, et al.” (National Association of Secretaries of State, United States Election Assistance Corporation) 15-3370-OP Originating Case: USDC-NYND 1:07-cv-00943-LEK-DRH “Schulz, et al. v State of New York, et al.” Constitutional principle of the public nature of elections and right to petition multi-state hand counting of general election ballots “In re: Natural Born Citizen Party National Committee, et al.” “In re: a.k.a. Donald J. Trump, Natural Born Citizen, et al.” BEFORE THE UNITED STATES JUDICIAL PANEL ON MULTEDISTRICT LITIGATION MDL In re: Natural Born Citizen Party National Commitee LitigationEastern District of New York - LIVE Database V6.1.1 bitps://eefnyed.uscourts.govegi-bin/DktRpt.pI?231123509528757-L. U.S. District Court Eastern District of New York (Central Islip) CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 2:16-cv-01892-SJF-AKT ‘Campanello et al v, New York State Board of Elections et al Assigned to: Judge Sandra J. Feuerstein Referred to: Magistrate Judge A. Kathleen Tomlinson Date Filed: 04/18/2016 Jury Demand: None Nature of Suit: 441 Civil Rights: Voting Cause: 42:1983 Civil Rights Act Jurisdiction: Federal Question intiff Leonard Joseph Campanello represented by Blaire Fellows Blaire Fellows, Esq. 140 Gazza Boulevard Farmingdale, NY 11735 631-532-0221 Fax: 631-777-7310 Email: blairefellowsesq@gmail.com LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Plaintiff Fabrizio Milito represented by Blaire Fellows (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Plaintiff Chandler Wilson represented by Blaire Fellows (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Alexandra K. Clark represented by Blaire Fellows (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED Plaintiff David Morrision, Sr. represented by Blaire Fellows (See above for address) LEAD ATTORNEY ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED lof 4/19/2016 2:17 PM.