Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
Profile of Citibank
These employees are charged with the task of being as efficient and effective as possible.
Citibanks main business strategy is to understand client needs by developing relationships with
each customer (Hitt, et al, 2011). Corporate consumers are encouraged to outsource financial
processing to Citibank, further deepening the banks understanding of customers current needs.
This knowledge can then be used to forecast customer technology needs for future development
and/or delivery.
As a large financial institution, Citibank conducts business around the world in over 100
countries on a daily basis (Hitt, et al, 2011). The bank continues to develop new markets in areas
that are not being serviced in an attempt to sustain its position as a global banking leader. To do
so, Citibank must optimize its e-banking services and anytime, anyplace banking.
This has been the priority of Citibank for the past 15 years. In 2000, Citibank made a
serious push to deliver integrated solutions that enabled its corporate consumers to conduct
business online (Hitt, et al, 2011, p. 99). Between 2000 and 2007, several entities within
Citibank were created to focus on the advancement of the institutions online banking options.
For example, in 2000, Citibank formed the Internet Operation Group, e-Capital, and e-Asset
Management (Hitt, et al, 2011). In 2002, Global Transaction Services was created within
Citibank to integrate technology and global efficiencies. In 2006, Citibank developed
TreasuryVision (p. 107) as a means to assist customers with liquidity management (Hitt, et al,
2011). These resources are a few examples of how, by 2007, Citibank offered a variety of webenabled business solutions to its customers.
4
Symptoms of Citibanks Problems
While Citibanks mission is to meet its customers needs, there are signs that the
institution is struggling to fulfill this mission. First of all, Citibank services corporate customers
of varying sizes around the globe (Hitt, et al, 2011). Citibanks customers are also expanding
their businesses and becoming e-enabled. Customers want the ability to collect payments online
and have access to more efficient web-enabled financial processes (Hitt, et al, 2011, p. 103).
This dynamic clientele base requires Citibank to offer, support, and improve a changing portfolio
of services. Because of the diverse and constantly changing needs, Citibank is struggling to keep
pace.
Additionally, profit margins have been reduced as a result of the subprime mortgage
meltdown in 2007 (Hitt, et al, 2011). The resulting credit crunch has left Citibank facing a tough
business environment filled with intense competition. The changing global economy left
corporate and personal customers with less money, resulting in more requests for efficient and
low cost banking options. Then in 2008, Citibank and other financial institutions came under
regulator scrutiny. According to Hitt, Ireland & Hikisson (2011), Citibanks revenue grew 8
percent; however, its operational expenses grew by nearly 15 percent (p. 102). Citibank has
therefore struggled to balance providing the banking technology desired by both corporate and
personal customers with the costs associated with risk management, compliance, and day-to-day
business operations.
5
Citibanks Goals for the Future
Citibanks leadership has several goals for the organization. Citibanks focus has been on
the customer meeting their needs has consistently been touted as the organizations number one
priority. As a result, the companys goals focus on achieving this mission.
One of Citibanks goals is to provide its customers with the technology that would enable
them to conduct business at any time, any place. Citibanks customers both corporate and
personal need the ability to work with their money in the most efficient manner possible.
Therefore, Citibank wants to web-enable its core services. Jorge Burmudez, Citibanks executive
vice president and head of e-Business, stated that, a core part of our e-business strategy is Webenabling our current services (Hitt, et al, 2011, p. 107).
Another of Citibanks goals is to align with partner companies that can provide Citibank
customers with innovative, seamless and efficient services accessible worldwide. Recognizing
that internal resources are limited, and it is resource intensive to internally develop new
technologies that will meet customers rapidly changing needs, Citibank has adopted the strategy
of aligning with partners to deliver e-services as a means to achieve their goal. As a matter of
fact, Tom Edgerton, head of the alliance for Citibank e-business, stated that in the future, it
wont be what your company can do, but what the network of companies you work with can
provide (Hitt, et al, 2011, p. 107).
Still yet, another of Citibanks goals is to provide customers with technology-based
services that would streamline their accounts receivable, accounts payable, and liquidity
management processes. To accomplish this, Citibank emphasizes the development of a single
web-enabled platform where customers could access any of their systems. Caroline Wong, Head
of Citibank Hong Kongs Cash & Trade stated that Citibank would focus on providing customers
7
Analysis of Citibanks Current Situation
of international credit card transactions (Citibank, 2006). This is the largest percentage of any of
Citibanks revenue types.
Another industry trend indicates that while consumers are interested in electronic
payments, they still prefer brand recognition and banking with institutions that can demonstrate a
proven history of financial security (Hitt, et al, 2011). Customers want to have peace of mind
when it comes to utilizing e-banking services.
Opportunities:
Weaknesses:
Declining Capital
Debt Obligations Due to
Subprime Market
High Customer Demands
Complicated Products
Threats:
Competition
Heavy Investments in Technology
Regulatory Scrutiny
Weakening Financial Markets
Strengths
Citibank/Citigroup benefits from strong brand recognition in the financial service
industry (Hitt, et al, 2011). As a result, Citigroup enjoys a strong competitive edge over its
competitors. Not only does Citibank have strong brand recognition within the United State, but
their brand name is known globally as well. According to Hitt, Ireland & Hoskisson (2011),
Citigroup provides a larger amount of credit cards than any other bank. Based on feedback from
this customer pool, in 2003 Forbes.com presented Citibank with a financial sector award, making
Citibanks superior customer service another of its strengths (Hitt, et al, 2011).
10
Citibank is also one of the most global of the existing financial service providers (Hitt, et
al, 2011). As a result, Citibank has a history of continually investing in its banking technology.
This reputation of superior technological offerings sets Citibank apart from its competitors.
Citibanks global presence is vital in continuous profits, and is therefore recognized as
another corporate strength (Hitt, et al, 2011). Their expanded portfolio enables Citibank to
deliver good results, regardless of the ongoing changes within the economy and banking
industry. Citibanks global presence also provides their customers with a better integration of
products and services.
Citigroup is also known for its diversified products and services (Hitt, et al, 2011). This is
essential in capturing new markets, as well as new consumers. Risk within Citibank is reduced as
a result of diversification. Diversity, in general, helps in positioning Citigroup with consistently
delivering superior products and services.
Weaknesses
The declining economy took a toll on the banking industry. Higher credit card costs and
the global economic slowdown accounted for declining capital within Citibank (Hitt, et al, 2011).
With credit card costs increasing, and financial losses due to the economy, Citibank had to take a
hard look at ways to improve technologies that would embrace and enhance performance.
Citibank also experienced a sharp decline in income levels subject to debt obligations
related to the sub-prime markets (Hitt, et al, 2011). These sub-prime markets strongly impacted
the bottom line profits of Citibank. Investors lost confidence in the financial industry as these
high risk loans escalated out of control.
As customer demands increased, Citibank found it difficult to keep pace with these
requests with less revenue at their disposal (Hitt, et al, 2011). Their lower scale of operations
11
restricted Citibanks ability to compete within the banking industry, thus limiting opportunities
within the banking environment.
Citibank experienced a weak competitive position that was primarily attributed to
underperformance (Hitt, et al, 2011). Citibank offered inferior products and services, and lacked
the innovation of new products and services that their customers desired. As a result, market
shares continued to decline over a four year period.
Opportunities
Citibanks positive reputation is well known within the global banking industry (Hitt, et
al, 2011). Citibank is focused on enhancing and expanding its good reputation. As a result,
Citibank has the opportunity to leverage its reputation to gain new customers, which will
increase profits.
Expanding global banking is essential in any banking organization. Citibanks product
portfolio could be enhanced by adding new products and services, as well as improving and
enhancing current offerings. Innovative products and services could potentially bring new
customers to Citibank.
Customer service is of utmost importance to Citibank (Hitt, et al, 2011). They want their
customers, new and old, to know they can rely on Citibank to focus on each persons individual
account as they would their own. This is the reason Citibank has made increasing customer
service of utmost importance.
Citibank is offering a fresh approach to banking. New technologies can provide
Citibanks customers with innovative and efficient accounts receivable, accounts payable, and
liquidity management services to be accessible anywhere, anytime, at the lowest cost (Hitt, et al,
2011). This will be a crucial tool in the success of Citibank.
12
Threats
As with any industry, competition is always a threat. Citibanks main competitors include
Bank of America, Chase Bank, as well as new entrants into the banking industry (Hitt, et al,
2011). Citibank must be innovative in developing new techniques in which to serve their
customers to remain strong and eliminate competition. Retaining current customers, as well as
attracting new ones, will prove crucial to the financial stability of the organization.
Even though investing in technology is one of Citibanks strengths, it also has the
potential to threaten the profitability of the organization. Developing and providing new
technologies is resource intensive (Hitt, et al, 2011). Whether Citibank simply enhances its
current technology, or purchases new technologies, the budget will be impacted.
Regulatory scrutiny is another threat to Citibanks growth (Hitt, et al, 2011). Banking
regulations change continuously. Staying abreast of these updates and implementing means to
stay in compliance is a resource burden on the industry. Being non-compliant, however, is an
even larger burden.
Weakening global financial markets also pose a threat to Citibanks growth (Hitt, et al,
2011). The declining economy provides an unstable condition that creates stress and fear for all
involved. This includes the banking industry, the customer, and the investors. As long as the
financial markets remain weak, threats to survival will remain.
13
Financial Analysis
The financial analysis provides the organization and stakeholders with the financial
condition of the organization. This is obtained from taking the financial statement, calculating
and analyzing ratios using simple averages, and calculating percentages based upon the data.
Business decisions are then based upon what these ratios reveal. Accounting ratios are one of the
most important tools used in analyzing and interpreting financial statements, as well as
determining the financial stability of the organization.
Financial ratios are pertinent when engaging in decision making. Managers need financial
information to better equip them with the tools needed to make current and future decisions for
organizational success. Financial strengths and weaknesses are revealed within the financial
ratios. Therefore, these ratios provide an essential tool in providing the organization what they
need to make educated decisions as to prior performance, current conditions, and future
predictions of the organization in relation to their overall goals.
Citibanks 2005 financial ratios are follows:
Profitability Rations
1. Return on total assets = 17.5% * Acceptable
2. Return on stockholders equity = 22.1% * Acceptable
3. Return on common equity = 22.3% * Acceptable
4. Operating profit margin = 1.6:1 * Acceptable
5. Net profit margin = 16.5% * Acceptable
Liquidity Ratios
1. Current Ratio = 1.2% *Acceptable
2. Quick ratio = 2.4% *Acceptable
14
Leverage Ratios
1. Debt-to-assets = 7.5% * Acceptable
2. Debt-to-equity = 12.2% * Acceptable
3. Long-term debt-to-equity = 1.9% * Acceptable
4. Times-interest-earned = 36.1% * Acceptable
5. Fixed charge coverage = .8% * Acceptable
Activity Ratios
1. Total assets turnover = 8.1% * Acceptable
2. Average collection period = 1.3 times * Acceptable
financial stability of an organization. They are not to be deemed as the ultimate factor in making
financial decisions. They are simply a piece of the puzzle to use in conjunction with additional
analyses to better understand whether it is a good move to go forward with something, or not.
15
Diagnosis of Citibanks Problems
16
It is therefore proposed that Citibank and Square collaborate and partner to offer this
technology to Citibanks current customers. The benefits to both parties will be exponential
because Square will have access to the Citibank trusted, globally recognized brand, and Citibank
will be able expand on its largest percentage of revenue by making it easier to use and process
electronic credit card payments.
GOAL OPTIONS
IMPROVES COST TO
TIME
QUALITY IMPLEMENT REQUIRED
EASE OF
STAFFING
FINANCIAL
RETURN
TOTAL
POINTS
High = 3
Low = 1
High = 1
Low = 3
A lot = 1
Not much = 3
Easy = 3
Difficult = 1
High return = 3
Low return = 1
13
13
11
Cut costs
17
Action Planning for a Better Citibank
To enable Citibank to partner with the complementary company and provide the credit
card processing services to its current customer base, thereby enabling Citibank to also increase
customer service satisfaction and profits, Citibank needs to:
Establish the web presence for this joint venture and identify staff who will be
responsible for maintaining the site
Identify help services for customers within Citibank and within Square
Develop an operations plan for the sales department to handle customer inquiries
and order processing
To work through this list, Citibanks leadership and departments will need to work
collaboratively to design and implement a synergistic strategic action plan. The individual
18
department action plans that follow illustrate how Citibanks leadership and marketing, IT, and
sales departments will develop and implement a marketing plan to promote this new technology.
Department Corporate
Completed
by:
Key Result
Area:
Leadership
Align with partner company to provide new technology to current Citibank customers, thereby
Increase profits and customer satisfaction
Goal:
Step #
Action
Responsibility
Outside Experts
Needed
Budget
Needed
Budget
Explaination
Corporate Level
N/A
N/A
N/A
Supervisory
Level
N/A
N/A
N/A
Manager Level
N/A
N/A
N/A
Corporate Level
N/A
N/A
N/A
Corporate level
N/A
N/A
N/A
Information Technology
Implement new technology for customers
Goal:
Step #
Action
Responsibility
Outside
Experts
Needed
Internal/External*
Yes
N/A
N/A
External*
Yes
N/A
N/A
Budget Needed
Budget
Explaination
Internal/External*
No
Yes
N/A
Internal/External *
No
Yes
N/A
Internal
No
N/A
N/A
Internal
No
N/A
N/A
Department Marketing
Completed
by:
Key Result
Area:
Marketing
Inform current customers of new credit card reader
Goal:
Step #
1
2
Action
Schedule a brainstroming session with the
marketing department and PR from Square
to contract with a company to design a survey of
the current customers
Responsibility
Outside Experts
Needed
Budget
Needed
Budget
Explaination
Internal
Yes
N/A
N/A
Internal
Yes
Yes
Internal
Yes
Yes
Internal
No
N/A
N/A
Internal
No
N/A
N/A
Internal
No
N/A
N/A
Internal
Yes
Yes
N/A
Internal
Yes
Yes
N/A
Internal
No
No
N/A
Operational Processes
To establish workflow for sales personnel responding to marketing plan of new product
Goal:
Step #
Action
Responsibility
Outside Experts
Needed
Budget
Needed
Budget
Explaination
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
10
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
Yes
11
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
Yes
12
Head of Sales
Admin Asst
NA
NA
13
Head of Sales
NA
Yes
14
Head of Sales
NA
NA
NA
15
NA
Yes
Overtime
16
NA
NA
NA
Head of Sales
and Sales Dept
Head of Sales
Duplication fees
19
References
Citigroup. (2006). 2005 Financial Information. Retrieved March 13, 2012 from
http://www.citigroup.com/citi/fin/data/k05c.pdf?ieNocache=353.
Culp, K. J. (2011, November 18). Home-Based Statistics You Should Know. Unknown,
Unknown, Unknown.
Hitt, M.A., Ireland, R.D., & Hoskisson, R.E. (2011). Strategic Management: Competitiveness
and Globalization (9th ed.). Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.
Square Up. Accessed April 5, 2012 from http://square.com.