Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Indian
Journal of
MARKETING
VOLUME : 40 NUMBER : 11 NOVEMBER, 2010
In This Issue
Life Insurance And Working Women : A Critical Study Of Dr. Manish Srivastava
Factors Affecting The Purchase Decision Megha Rastogi
INDIAN JOURNAL OF MARKETING, INDIAN JOURNAL OF FINANCE
AND PRABANDHAN : INDIAN JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
ARE NOW
CABELL'S LISTED JOURNALS
Dear Readers,
Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian
Journal of Management have been listed in the Cabell's Directory of Publishing
Opportunities.
We hope that all our readers take pride in the accomplishments of their journals.
Once again, we extend to you, our most sincere thanks for your unending
support.
Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management
have been an excellent platform for generation and dissemination of knowledge in the field of Marketing,
Finance and Management by publishing insightful research of the highest quality in diverse areas of
marketing, finance and management. Quality has been the hallmark of our three publications - Indian
Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management. Indian
Journal of Marketing and Indian Journal of Finance are being published monthly since long and from
January 2010, Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management also became a monthly journal and the
numbers of pages were increased to 56 from 40. Each issue of Indian Journal of Marketing and Indian
Journal of Finance contains 64 and 56 pages respectively. This year, Prabandhan: Indian Journal of
Management came out with the Special Issue on Corporate Governance, Corporate Social Responsibility
and Business Ethics (July and August Issue). The Management, Editorial Office and Board constantly
endeavors to keep evolving, improving and expanding the various aspects of our three publications.
The growth of our journals has been incredibly swift - with a growing number of submissions and an
increasing subscriber base. In the year 2010, all our three publications were indexed in various
international databases and directories - The Cabell's Directory of Publishing Opportunities, Ulrich's
International Periodicals Directory, Journal of Economic Literature (JEL), EconLit and the journals are
also available for purchase from Amazon.com. These accomplishments have been possible due to the
unending support and patronage provided to us by our readers and patrons.
Even in the face of pressing inflationary concerns, we never took any half measures with the quality of the
journals. Apart from printing distinguished articles, we lay a special emphasis on the quality of the paper
used in our journals. This paper comes from the house of Ballarpur Industries limited (BILT), which is
India's largest paper company and the only Indian company to rank amongst the top 100 paper
companies in the world. This paper has precedence over the others of its kind as it has a longer shelf life, is
non-toxic, is environment friendly, has exceptional whiteness and least amount of opacity among its
peers.
In order to maintain the paramount quality of the journals, and to maintain the infrastructure and
logistics of running three monthly publications with increased page allotments, we have increased the
annual subscription amount of Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan:
Indian Journal of Management to Rs.1200 (from Rs 1000).
We hope that the readers, patrons, and authors will support us in this endeavor and continue to lend us
their unflinching support, patronage and cooperation. Your comments, feedback and suggestions are
always welcome.
Mrs. S. Gilani
Editor- In- Chief
Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management
INTRODUCTION
Google has launched its new Chrome OS (Operating System) in the 2nd half of 2010, this became one of the most
popular news; posted on Google's official blog.
“It's been an exciting nine months since we launched the Google Chrome browser. Already, over 30 million people use
it regularly. We designed Google Chrome for people who live on the web - searching for information, checking email,
catching up on the news, shopping or just staying in touch with friends. Google Chrome OS is an open source,
lightweight operating system that will initially be targeted at net books. Later this year, we will open-source its code,
and net books running Google Chrome OS will be available for consumers in the second half of 2010.”(Source: The
Official Google Blog).
Basically, an Operating System is a bridge between the computer and its user, its takes instructions from users to
perform the task in the computer and then again, meet the user with drawn results or in more generalized form, an OS is
a software which act likes a means of communication between a user and the user's computer hardware. Microsoft's
Windows XP, Windows Vista and Windows 7, Apple's Mac X and the Linux based Ubuntu are the most popular
operating systems presently. Chrome OS would be an open ware (free for consumption and distribution which is a very
common feature of Linux based operating systems- moreover, open wares provide the code on which they have been
made to the users by which they can develop it further or can make changes to make it more functional to them
according to their individual needs) again as Google says- It will initially be targeted at net books -a light version of
laptop uses Intel atom processor for processing RAM 256 to 512MB- that's why ranges in $250 segment focuses only
to the internet access and needs very light version of operating system and could be understood easily if we say that it is
very similar to the main frame computers of 2001. So it left a room for Microsoft and Apple to think again about their
OSs- whether they will be able to compete against the Internet giant because presently available Google softwares are
doing tremendously well such as the Chrome browser (gained 7% of the world internet users from 3.1% in 12 months
from the time it was started), Picasa (photo viewing software just as windows picture and fax viewer) ….. etc. Both are
freeware and can be downloaded from Google's website freely and we can expect more from Google's OS just seeing
the performance of Picasa and Chrome browser. The truth about Window's and Microsoft's other product's much
success is that, very few know about what is Ubnutu and other Linux based OSs, what it costs and from where they can
get it! (Linux makers do not advertise! We can't expect anyone who is distributing his product free and also advertising
for its popularity). In case of Google's Chrome OS, coming from the company that has the world’s most preferred
home page and search engine, it would be very hard to remain in dark about it. The x factor would be its speed as
Google commits because what Microsoft says about Windows is that they are more secure. The researchers personally
feel that Linux is doing better in terms of security- it has no virus malware and has less other reasons for which one can
fear about security. But there are no free lunches at all, think what if Chrome OS will be in all systems worldwide- then
the whole power would be in Google's hand and they will become market leaders. They will be able to do anything
with our data, be able to access our computer any time they want. Yes, it might be able to save you from viruses,
malwares and other security threats because they are targeting firstly internet users, but what if they themselves want to
harm us in a similar kind of situation- when we have given our home keys in the hands of a thief ?
Users
Growth
Population Internet Users Internet Users Penetration %
World Regions 2000-
( 2009 Est.) Dec. 31, 2000 Latest Data (% Population) of
2009
Table
Africa 991,002,342 4,514,400 86,217,900 8.7 % 1,809.8 % 4.8 %
Asia 3,808,070,503 114,304,000 764,435,900 20.1 % 568.8 % 42.4 %
Latin
586,662,468 18,068,919 186,922,050 31.9 % 934.5 % 10.4 %
America/Caribbean
Again internetworldstate.com supports the same figure of 81 million internet users in India.But the country's telecom
regulatory authority makes you meet a different picture of the same.TRAI's Report (trai report
IndicatorReport1oct09.pdf), cannot be wrong because these are not derived by surveys, but are official statistics of a
country. The report shows that India presently has approximately 147.64 million internet connections and the number
of users must be more than that because in this developing country, not everyone can afford a computer, so they do visit
cyber cafés frequently, we cannot have the exact calculation of that. But for these 147.64 million, we can expect that
they know what is Google (most of the internet sites use Google search engine and get result from it and then mix it up
with their own preferred results) and this is the advantage for Google that more population know them than Microsoft
or different versions of windows
So we first start understanding the different Operating Systems, and for convenience of writing, we use the word OS at
the place of Operating System, which is also very popular in between advanced computer users but to develop a
common understanding of OS, we start with a graphical presentation.
OS is a bridge between a user and a computer and in technical language, it gives you the ground to interact with your
computer. For Foundation for an operating system (On which an OS is waived), we are considering only popular ones.
1.Microsoft's windows base
2.Linux
3. UNIX
Main structure or we call it Operating System
1. Microsoft's windows based operating systems (paid biggest in the market) :
Windows XP, Window Vista, windows 7.
2. Linux based (available free or very low priced for use) :Ubunto, Redhat, Mandriva
Linux, Back Track.
Safety(what is
The meaning of Many a time, you will find You hardly face any software crash but A Mac user , even an advanced
safety? Here the many softwares being crashed. many times, you might get a slow one, rarely has had
term implies system response. acquaintance with it.
only the amount
of safety it
provided to the
software
installed on your
system.
Software All softwares supports Windows You will find many emulators which 95% paid and unpaid software
Compatibility XP, a few less Vista, again most can run most of your windows based do support Mac but some
of them support Windows 7 software on Linux ground, but the idea Power users can feel their
also because you can run any does not work on all. You can’t run collar tight because it might
software in compatibility mode those ones which require registry disappoint them . Many small
of previous windows version. settings and many other heavy Softwares can only run through
softwares, but most of the commercial Emulator, but they might not
users do not prepare their software for work as expected.
Linux versions.
.
Hardware All hardware support Windows, HP & Compaq do not support Linux, Many meant for Mac books and
Support but all Mac hardware might Dell now officially supports Linux.Many Others may or may not support
not be supportable for these machines support and do not support Mac X leopard.
(Apple makes computer under different versions of Linux OS.
the brand name of Mac ; you
might have seen a commercial
at the time of Vista’s launch.
Drivers All hardware makers give driver Might find many types of drivers but Apple themselves provide all
support for the most popular would not be able to find wireless lan required support for Mac. It
OS in the world. XP and many
Drivers for almost all types of machines. depends whether they are
Vista versions still don’t have
providing it or not.
supportable drivers.
Price Very Nominal. Almost free or costs quite less for Mac OS is very expensive.
some OS.
Appearance XP is ordinary presently;Vista Different OS provide different The current one Mac X (Leopard)
had a better look and Windows facilities. Has the aqua look and looks
7 has a great look. great.
Source : Self testing, Internet polls,reviews and information gained via the internet.
CATEGORY DISSECTION
]Security : It would be wrong when you say that your product is the safest one, but actually nobody cares to break
your security because 80% users uses Window XP- that's why most of the hackers target only XP and again, about other
versions of Windows, Linux and Mac, they are secure only till the time when they do not have any big market share, it
may also possible that the other OS we are using might have viruses but we cannot get informed. Now hackers do not
make silly viruses which will spread text like 'I love you' or it will create a folder again and again in the folder but they
make them like that these will use very little amount of your internet connection and will continuously send your
password and personal information to strangers, its unbelievable but it is the truth.
]Safety : Again, very few people use Linux and Mac and again, majority in these don't have power users, they might
be only in minority, that means very few users uses every single bit of their computer for which they have paid. We
cannot have any fair idea until rubber meets the road.
]Price : If you are using an OS just for surfing, chatting, sending and receiving emails, then why to pay more for
Windows and Mac- just go for Linux but the real problem is not with the price. But until now, 95% users even don't
know what Linux really is. Most of them even can't install Windows on their own, which they have been using from
past many years.
]Appearance & Graphics : Think you are well prepared with a tie, court or in a jacket with polished shoes and working
in a farm somewhere in deep Africa, similarly, the same is with an OS also, these GUIs (Graphic User Interface ) can
give you best of the advanced look, but do you really require that ?
]Drivers : What about that condition when you can only use your PC or laptop as a paper weight because it cannot play
sounds, doesn't have a wireless connection, but in your office you only have wireless internet connection and what
about the PC which cannot be compared even with a TV also for visuals? We must remember that Linux PC might not
have these drivers. Then instead of a PC, we will rather be having it only as the priciest paperweight, but again,
companies do not feel any major requirement to get Linux versions of drivers because there are very few users
available and it might be very costly for them to manufacture these.
CONCLUSION
According to data available on the Internet, in the year 2008, we were with 1 billion computers and till the year 2015,
the number would cross the 2 billion mark, but the effect of Netbooks might be negative or also, it may be possible
that there would be a separate market for them (likewise IPods- that were a new product in the market few years
back).There might be a different product in coming years or months which again can affect the whole equation very
dramatically.
Steve Ballmer- the CEO of Microsoft says Linux has only a Price advantage over windows you even don't know who is
the manufacturer of it (from where it came) but is this really true? A big question!
Ballmer might be laughing at Google's OS approach but a couple of months before it launched its Bing search engine,
what was the need of it? if they are really not afraid of Google, which is the fastest and most reliable search engine and
the most popular one at that! But what about the drivers? We must understand if the mass market will move to Linux,
then we will be having a good packet of drivers and many viruses, worms, spywares and malwares as well, but there is
no need of panicking, these all can be made only when one has a very good knowledge of an OS and it will take time to
get prepared for this. Just because of its popularity, Google has won half of the battle in India, and Microsoft has to
cover a very long way. If the changes were not acclimated, then it is a possibility that the next generation will read
Microsoft in their history books only.
But the question that still stands- That will Google not draw an illegal or unexpected benefit from the uncontrolled
access that it would have to the systems of its OS users.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Magazine:-
1)LINUX articles on CHROME OS
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 7
2)PCWORLD November 2009 edition page 90-93 (how to deploy windows 7) and 58-59 (functions)
Web Pages:-
1.http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2009/07/introducing-google-chrome-os.html
2.http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2009/07/five-things-googles-chrome-os-will-do-for-your-netbook/
3 . h t t p : / / w w w. g o o g l e . c o m / u r l ? q = h t t p : / / e n . w i k i p e d i a . o r g / w i k i / F e a t u r e s _ n e w _ t o _ Wi n d o w s _ Vi s t a & e i = 5 0 z 5 S v r T E -
jkAX_oPm8Cw&sa=X&oi=nshc&resnum=1&ct=result&cd=1&ved=0CAgQzgQoAA&usg=AFQjCNFShFsZGR8G4AInm7_BSSLaoJLDQA
4.http://www.google.com/url?q=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XP&ei=2U35SsaOOs6NkAXEtazCCw&sa=X&oi=nshc&resnum=1&ct=result&cd=1&ved=0C
AgQzgQoAA&usg=AFQjCNHvcxQ_B6kG5qPmvXLt9zkQqVAxkg
5.http://www.google.com/url?q=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_XP&ei=2U35SsaOOs6NkAXEtazCCw&sa=X&oi=nshc&resnum=1&ct=result&cd=2&v
ed=0CAkQzgQoAQ&usg=AFQjCNFCX1ZRIzsW2lV4ikO4f68MECqtxw
6.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_7
7.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Features_new_to_Windows_7
8.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_7_editions
9.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Chrome_OS
10.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Vista
11.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_XP
12.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrome_os
13.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_os
14.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mac_OS_X_Snow_Leopard
15.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubunto
16.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chrome_(browser)
17.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macintosh.htm
18.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picasa
19.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_web_browsers
20.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netbook.htm
21.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_NT.htm
22.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Me.htm
23.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_2000.htm
24.http://windows.microsoft.com/es-ES/windows-7?os=win7
25.http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windows-7/get/
26.http://masoodmemon.wordpress.com/2008/11/01/five-reasons-why-windows-vista-failed/
27.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/compare/home.html
28.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2005/
29.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/1997/
30.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/1998/
31.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/1999/
32.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2000/
33.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2001/
34.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2002/
35.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2003/
36.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2004/
37.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2005/
38.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2006/
39.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2007/
40.http://itc.virginia.edu/students/inventory/2008/
41.http://news.softpedia.com/news/It-Will-Be-Windows-7-SP1-to-Go-Against-Google-Chrome-OS-121863.shtml
42.http://www.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idUSTRE56D5MU20090714
43.http://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/4834.html
44.http://www.daniweb.com/news/story220432.html#
45.http://news.zdnet.co.uk/software/0,1000000121,39211451,00.htm
46.http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-81431806.html
47.http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/legal/european/04-24-06windowsxpnsalesfs.mspx
48.http://www.science-portal.org/in/71
49.https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2153rank.html
50.http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=Windows+XP+vs.+Vista+vs.+Linux&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8
51.http://www.internetnews.com/ent-news/article.php/7_918881
52.http://www.swivel.com/graphs/show/19608943
53.http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats3.htm
54.http://www.trai.gov.in/WriteReadData/trai/upload/Reports/48/IndicatorReport1oct09.pdf
55.http://www.coolinterview.com/interview/15538/
56.http://www.aneki.com/internet.html
57.http://www.labnol.org/internet/usage-statistics-for-search-engines-browsers/7729/
58.http://www.cw.com.hk/content/five-reasons-some-xp-users-should-hold-windows-7
59.http://windowsitpro.com/article/articleid/23049/wininfo-short-takes-windows-xp-launch-special-edition.html
60.http://www.theeldergeek.com/slipstreamed_xpsp3_cd.htm
61. Http://www.essaysprofessors.com/samples/Computer-Technologies/Windows-XP-vs-Macintosh-OS-X-Comparison-and.html
INTRODUCTION
A key issue which has attracted considerable marketing thinking over the last two decades has been the notion of
customer retention. Also, forging long term, cost effective relationships with customers is gaining primacy. The idea of
relationship marketing can be seen as a logical extension of the way in which the forces of marketing have changed
from the 1980s view that marketing was essentially a business function to the idea that marketing should be an
organizational attitude, ethos and culture. One of the most powerful drivers of relationship marketing has been the
recognition of the fact that costs of gaining a new customer is often very high. Understandably, the marketing planner
needs to ensure that the existing customer base is managed as effectively as possible. The traditional path needs to be
shunned. We need to bid goodbye to the philosophy that marketing and selling are a series of transactions and in lieu,
think of marketing as being concerned with the management of long term relationships.The box below encapsulates
the features of traditional marketing, also known as transaction marketing and relationship marketing, the thrust of the
present paper.
Table 1: Transaction Marketing and Relationship Marketing
Transaction Marketing Relationship Marketing
A Focus On Single Sales. A Focus On Customer And Building Customer Loyalty.
An Emphasis On Product Features. An Emphasis Upon Product Benefits That Are Meaningful To The Customer.
Short Timescales. Long Timescales, Recognizing That Short Term Costs May Be
Higher, But So Will Long Term Profits.
Little Emphasis On Customer An Emphasis On High Levels Of Service That Are
Retention. Possibly Tailored To The Individual Customer.
Limited Customer Commitment. High Customer Commitment.
Moderate Customer Contact. High Customer Contact, With Each Contact Being Used To Gain
Information And Build The Relationship.
Quality Is Essentially The Concern Quality Is The Concern Of All, And It Is The Failure To Recognize This That
Of Production And No One Else. Creates Minor Mistakes Which Lead To Major Problems.
Transaction versus relationship marketing (adapted from Christopher et.al., 1991)
From the above, it is apparent that relationship marketing (or relationship management) communicates the idea that a
major goal of a business enterprise is to engage in interactions with customers over the long term. Contemporary
marketers realize that once a sale is effected, the organization must stress managing relationships that will bring about
additional exchanges. Making a sale should not be seen as the end of the marketing process; it is rather the start of the
organization's relationship with the customer which calls for management. The diverse notions about CRM is captured
by Frederick Newell in “Why CRM doesn't work” in the following words. “Some think CRM is a matter of technology.
Some still believe it's just a process of segmenting customers. Some think it's a matter of selling efficiency. Many
marketers still think CRM is just an advanced stage of database marketing using your customer database to find
which customers would be the right ones for a specific product offering. They don't understand that relationship
building must start with an understanding of the customer's needs. They talk about 'share of wallet' but fail to realize
that you can't get access to the customer's wallet if you don't first have access to the customer's heart and mind.” (p 4 -
5).According to Goodhue, Wixom and Watson (2002), CRM is any application or initiative designed to help an
organization optimize interactions with customers, suppliers, or prospects via one or more touch points for the purpose
of acquiring, retaining, or cross-selling customers.
*Assistant Professor, West London College of Business and Management Sciences, London, U.K.Email :vinnysri@gmail.com
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 9
An important facet of CRM is 'customer selectivity'. Numerous research studies have conclusively shown that not all
customers are equally profitable for an individual company.(Storbacka 2000) Moreover, in keeping with Pareto's law,
most companies would see that eighty per cent of their sales would be derived from twenty per cent of their customers.
Thus, we aver that while all customers should be treated with respect, all of them need not be treated equally.
Customers want to do business with organizations that know them, that understand what they want and need, and that
continue to fill those wants and needs. CRM is about making sure you have the information you need to do just that. A
review of CRM literature readily makes us behold that among other things, CRM is about growing advocates and
finding new ways to add value to the customer. Amazon.com is a company that has leveraged high tech to engender the
feeling of high touch. Their initiative has served to deepen the relationships with her customers. CRM tools that
support Amazon's customer relationship strategy allow Amazon to: Firstly, add value to customer transactions by
identifying related items with their “customers who bought this book also bought” feature. Secondly, strengthening
relationships by recognizing repeat shoppers and targeting them with gifts and knick knacks.
PROACTIVE CRM
Practicing CRM calls for a degree of pro-activeness. Disney Corporation does this brilliantly. At their theme parks,
they have taken note of the things customers do that cause problems. One example is that a tiny percentage of
10 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
customers leave their car running in the parking lot, in their excitement to get in to see Mickey. Even though it is a tiny
number of people, Disney knows that they can expect to see this happen. So, their parking lots are patrolled and the
staff-switch of the engine, keep the keys safe and even carry spare fuel so that the customer gets home safely. They
want nothing to spoil their customers' memory of their trip to Disney. Data gathering, data warehousing and data
mining play an important part in CRM. An additional example of proactiveness on the part of business is now
provided. Let us assume that data reveals that a particular customer has the habit of calling his bank every other
Tuesday at 11 a.m. to check his account balance. The bank can use this pattern of communication to communicate back
to the customer. To create a non intrusive interaction with this customer, the bank might call the customer at or around
11 a.m. on Tuesdays to communicate new services or introduce special promotions.
PERILS TO DODGE
A variety of factors preclude the proper implementation of CRM. Patricia Seybold, author of 'Customers.com' and 'The
Customer Revolution' has identified some common pitfalls that prevent organizations from deriving the benefits of
CRM. Since literature on CRM point to the fact that CRM initiatives very often fail, an awareness of the 'mistakes' that
companies make when implementing CRM is instructive. Common pitfalls that endanger CRM initiatives include:
]Designing from the inside out.
]Neglecting the necessary corporate culture changes.
]Focusing on customer acquisition rather than customer retention.
]Starting with sales force automation.
]Neglecting to streamline decision making information that customers need.
]Doing an inadequate job of customer database design.
]Postponing the integration of information and business processes across interaction touch points and operational
applications.
]Avoiding integration of direct and indirect sales and service channels.
EMERGENCY SYSTEM
Emergency security features such as a panic button are installed in the car along with First-Aid kits in case of any
accidents or emergency situations.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Adrian Paynee (1996). The Essence of Services Marketing: Prentice Hall of India.
2. Atul Parvatiyar and Jagdish N Sheth (2001). Conceptual Framework of Customer Relationship Management. Customer Relationship Management Emerging
Concepts Tools and Applications, edited by Jagdish N Sheth, Atul Parvatiyar and G Sainesh, Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, New Delhi, 1-25
3.Mohanbir Sawhney (2002). Beyond Relationship Marketing: The Rise of Collaborative Marketing. Defying the limits- Effective Strategies for Unlocking CRM's
Full Potential, Montgomery research Incorporation. 44-46.
4.Philip Kotler (2003). Building Customer Satisfaction, Value and Retention. Marketing Management, Pearson Education Pte. Ltd., 59-87.
5.The Business World Journal.
6.The Business-line news paper, http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/n
7.Valarie A.Zeithaml and Mary Jo Bitner(2003). Customer Perception of Services. Services Marketing- Integrating Customer Focus Across The Firm, Tata
McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, New Delhi, 83-118.
INTRODUCTION
'Recession' and 'Economic downturn' has been the talk everywhere; companies have wakened up for a more reforming
strategy to beat the heat of the crash. Across the globe, the economic slump has traumatized many companies to the
core, even the traditional and established companies. The market is becoming robust with the economic conditions
making their way up the ladder. Traditional practices of marketing are shifting from 'product-centric marketing' to
'customer-centric marketing'. They have recognized that customers are the core of a business and that a company's
success depends on effectively managing relationships with them. With the changing social trends, such as the
increase in ready-to-cook foods to automatic washing machines, marketing methods have changed. In addition to this,
the lesser Government controls have brought many foreign companies as well as competition in the market. In this
light, CRM is ringing its bell in every organization.
Figure 1: Traditional Marketing Vs CRM Approach
Customers are nowadays empowered to demand more, because of the availability of abundant information through
various sources such the internet, television, newspapers, exhibition and trade fairs, etc. Therefore, he is aware of the
various products available as well as the comparative analysis of their features. Hence, to aptly identify his needs and
to provide the right solution is the greatest challenge of the salesman. In an article, “Do You Want to Keep Your
Customers Forever?” in the Harvard Business Review, Pine, Peppers and Rogers mentioned that “Customers, whether
consumers or businesses, do not want more choices. They want exactly what they want, when, where and how they
want it- and technology now makes it possible for companies to give it to them”.
Despite several approaches towards the concept of CRM, the unifying factor quoted by Peppers and Rogers (1997) is:
Customers have hidden or overt preferences that marketers can reveal by building a learning relationship.
The key to customer relationship is to 'treat different customers differently'. Thus, it is a core business strategy that
provides a platform to create a long-term and profitable relationship with the customers. Organizations which have
realized the positive impact of CRM strategies have taken steps to implement them and are having competitive
advantage in the market. Especially, the Financial Services Markets which has become increasingly global, with many
foreign financial service companies entering into the Indian market. Recent advancements in IT and communications
have made it possible for even the smallest investor to purchase financial instruments from almost anywhere abroad.
The general revival in the economy has resulted in the rising personal income and savings in many areas around the
*Lecturer, Karunya School of Management, Karunya University, Coimbatore ,Tamil Nadu. Email : ruma.agnes@gmail.com
14 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
world. The need to protect this wealth, health & oneself, and provide significant opportunities for protecting them
against risk of theft or damage or loss has become crucial. This environment facilitates Insurance companies to seek
premiums and place investments globally. Today, most of the organizations are 'customer-centric'. Insurance is one
such industry that involves many customer touch points/interaction points. It requires a supportive back office enabled
with CRM technology. Insurance is a complex product which needs to be personalized and the Insurance companies,
on an average, manage around hundreds of customers/insurers per day. In order to maintain competitive advantage and
viability, Insurance companies are focusing very carefully on delivering superior customer service. CRM in insurance
begins with a single, complete, real-time enterprise view, so that call center representatives, agents and brokers can
understand and serve every aspect of individual customers, thereby increasing profitability of the company and
increasing the satisfaction of the customers.
According to Chan (2005), to enable a holistic view of customers, all interaction with the customers should be tracked
across various functions like sales and marketing, call centers, customer service, distribution channels and alliance
partners. Interactions across the department should be in a customer-centric manner instead of company-centric
manner. Few suggestions are as follows:
]Product features based on requirement of the customer - collaboration with customers for product innovation.
]Use of technology to fulfill customer transaction on a 24/7 basis - customer convenience should be of utmost
importance in all interactions with customers.
]Ensure updated information on all customer transactions are available to all concerned personnel to ensure proactive
fulfillment of customer requirements.
]Fulfilling the latent desires of customers - aiming at delighting the customer.
DELIVERING CRM
Thus, it is essential to develop and suitably deliver a CRM tool to ensure various benefits for the organization. First, by
developing a closer relationship with customers, organizations may gain a competitive edge. Over time, individual
customers typically educate a company about their individual needs, wants, and preferences-a costly process that they
are reluctant to repeat with a rival. Thus, getting to know customers intimately creates a barrier to imitation of the
leader's strategy. Second, effective CRM can lead to increased customer satisfaction. Properly implemented, the
customer company dialogue facilitates the tailoring of products and services closely to individual needs, and the
development of new products and services to meet changing needs or even anticipate future needs. Third, using CRM
techniques contributes to decreasing overall marketing expenditure as already mentioned above. Therefore, it is
obvious from the suggestions of CRM proponents that CRM leads to higher profitability due to increased sales,
declining customer acquisition costs, and increasing profitability of CRM program customers willing to pay a
premium for “better” service.
16 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
Figure 3: CRM Model
Fig 3: is the representation of how CRM will be effective for companies. In the Figure 3, CRM program illustrates on
building relationships with customers and thus establishing customer loyalty. The Data Mining lists the well-accepted
outcomes of data-mining activities. Together, those two sets of outcomes have stimulated many companies to invest in
creating a database-driven CRM system. Many CRM applications, which historically looked only at the customer
interaction area, now include all transactional data and processing along with the very important role of supply chain
and collaborative working.Today's CRM technology with its analytical, collaboration and multi-channel help
complements the traditional operational processes involved in supporting all aspects of customer-facing interactions.
Three segments identified in this framework are: Operational, Analytical and Collaborative.
]Operational CRM: Also known as “front-office” CRM, involves the areas where direct customer contact occurs. It
supports front office processes, for example, the staff in a call center (Vervest and Dunn 2000, Myers 1998, Crego and
Schiffrin 1995; and Greenberg 2001).
]Analytical CRM: Also known as “back-office” CRM or “strategic” CRM, it involves understanding the customer
activities that occurred in the front office. It builds on operational CRM and establishes information on customer
segments, behavior and value using statistical methods (Nykamp 2001, Peppers and Rogers 2001).
]Collaborative CRM: It concentrates on customer interaction using a coordinated mix of interaction channels
(multichannel management) for example, online shops and call centers, (Keen et al. 2000). It makes interactions
between a business, its channel and its customers possible (Reynolds 2002).
In Insurance companies, there is a constant challenge for effectively managing and resolving claims. This includes not
only managing the interactions between the many parties involved in settling the claim, but also defining the process
behind prioritizing and assigning the claim for completion. All too often, customers are asked to repeat the same
information over and over again to several different members of the insurance company who are involved in resolving
the claim. This extends the life of the open claim and helps to foster the familiar perception of insurance companies -
that they are eager to collect premium payments from customers, but are not as eager to assist customers when it comes
to paying out a claim. This can be ruled out only if the different CRM components work collaboratively.
CRM IN INSURANCE
The insurance industry has been a booming sector and companies are going overboard to get and retain customers.
CRM has proved to be an effective tool in the quest for better customer relationships for the insurance companies. The
aspects where insurance companies have been able to apply CRM concepts include:
A)PERSONALIZATION OF OFFER
In general, Insurance companies have appointed many trained 'insurance advisors' or 'insurance agents' who regularly
establish contact with prospective customers and undertake the job of explaining to them the benefits of the insurance
policies. These 'advisors' or 'agents' draw the profile of the prospect via a friendly conversation and suitably propose a
insurance product to meet their requirements.
B) REGULAR COMMUNICATION WITH CUSTOMER
Insurance products are intangible and customers are often left high and dry to understand the various aspects
concerning the policy that they have bought. Therefore, to ensure that customers are kept in the know, regular
communication is required from both the company to the customer and also the sales agent to the customer. Regular
communication with customer will also help the companies to identify the unmet insurance needs and further cross-
sell or up-sell another insurance product.
C) AGENTS ADOPTING A CUSTOMER-CENTRIC APPROACH
A study that was conducted to study the reason for customer defections and the role of agents to curb them revealed that
65% of the customers who had not spoken to the agent had defected, whereas 80% of the customers who had spoken to
the agent had not defected. Thus, agents need to be provided with suitable platform to constantly keep in touch with
their customers and also process the customer's request at the earliest.
D) SALES FORCE AUTOMATION
This feature or facility will offer more customer-facing time for the salespeople. All routine and preliminary works can
be outsourced to data management centers. The online details or profile of the customer will be accessible by the agent
and the salesperson to obtain the necessary information. Special access to agents can be given to quickly and
efficiently handle customer requirements.
E) UNIFICATION OF DATA-SINGLE CUSTOMER VIEW
Insurance companies are known to operate as silos with hardly any data sharing across the various divisions and
departments. This results in the same customer being targeted by the various divisions and resulting in irritation for the
customer as well as waste of efforts on the part of the insurance company. This can be suitable addressed and avoided
by proper utilization of CRM.
CONCLUSION
The increased competition from the local as well as the foreign insurance companies, has just resulted in the increase in
the demand and expectation of the customers. Thus, the concern of customer service and CRM are vital in the
developing environment. This is especially true in the case in developing countries where changes in customer
expectations are linked to increasing educational standards and literacy. Although there has been a significant and
rapid advancement in the area of customer management, there are many issues to be explored. Insurance companies
across the world have also started recognizing the value of superior customer care. However, they are still in the initial
phase of CRM implementation, with some foreign and private sector banks taking the initiative on the technology
front. One of the major challenges in implementing CRM is resistance to change. The success in the implementation of
CRM is achieved only if the company can create the right environment, a culture and attitude of the employees to serve
the customer better. Besides, it also reflects that CRM still requires the adoption by insurance companies of significant
new skills and technology, together with some reorganization of the marketing function.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1.Abhishek Raval (2007), Kotak Group Initiates Siebel CRM Implementation, BizTech2.com India - A Network18 Venture.
2. Akhtar Pasha (2004), Insurance sector to drive Indian CRM market, Express Computer.
3.Asia-Pacific Insurance (2003, 2004), Datamonitor.
4.Aviva plc (2008), Annual Report and Accounts.
5.Denish Shah, University of Connecticut, Roland T. Rust, University of Maryland, A. Parasuraman, University of Miami, Richard Staelin, Duke University,
George S. Day, University of Pennsylvania (2006), The Path to Customer Centricity, Journal of Service Research, Volume 9, No. 2.
6.Industry Credit Outlook: Asia-Pacific Life Insurance Outlook Revised To Negative As Industry Risks Increase The Pressure (2009), Standard & Poor's Ratings
Direct.
7.Jill Dyche (2009), The CRM Handbook - A Business Guide to Customer Relationship Management, Pearson Education.
8.Judith K. Wincaid (2003), Customer Relationship Management - Getting it Right!. Pearson Education.
9.Kaushik Mukerjee (2007), Customer Relationship Management - A Strategic Approach to Marketing, Prentice Hall of India Private Limited.
10.Kumar V, University of Connecticut. Katherine N. Lemon, Boston College. A. Parasuraman, University of Miami (2006), Managing Customers for Value An
Overview and Research Agenda, Journal of Service Research, Volume 9, No. 2.
11.Ramaseshan. B, Curtin University of Technology, David Bejou, Virginia State University, Subhash C. Jain, University of Connecticut, Charlotte Mason,
University of North Carolina, Joseph Pancras, University of Connecticut (2006), Issues and Perspectives in Global Customer Relationship Management, Journal
of Service Research, Volume 9, No. 2.
12.Tapan K Panda, Creating Customer Life Time Value Through Effective CRM In Financial Services Industry , Journal of Services Research, Volume 2, Number
2 (October '02-March, 2003).
*Dr. V. Murugaiah
**Radhika Vishvas
“One estimate is that attracting a new customer can cost five times as much as pleasing an existing one. And it
might cost sixteen times as much as to bring new customer to the same level of profitability as the lost customer.
Customer retention is thus more important than customer attraction.”
-Philip Kotler
INTRODUCTION
Sale of any product or service comes from two ways. One is through existing customers (repeat sales) and another is
through new customers (fresh sales). Nothing may seem more obvious than the need to keep customers coming back
(DeSouza Glenn, 1992) as, cultivating loyal customers can lead to increased sales and customer share, lower costs, and
higher prices (Reichheld and Teal 1996; Zeithaml, Berry, and Parasuraman 1996). But here, the challenge is to retain
the existing customers. Practitioners bombard consumers with relationship marketing efforts, value-creating
strategies, and key account programmes (Palmatier W. Robert 2007). Retaining existing customers and acquiring new
customers are two important challenges to the marketers. Retaining existing customers needs a totally different set of
strategies than attracting new customers every time. Now- a- days, it is very difficult to retain customers owing to
reasons like competition in the market place, customer education and awareness about the products and brands,
deficiencies in customer care, ever changing customer preferences for products, accessibility of products in the
market, etc,.Hence, marketers are equally focusing on attracting new customers into their fold, which is relatively
easier one. As a result, sales are mostly through first time purchases also. Now, the question before the marketers is
how to drive customers towards their products. Advertising, Sales promotion, Personal selling are some of the
important strategies being used for this purpose. In some cases, they bring desired sales to the firm. Now, the crux of the
problem with business houses is how to acquire new customers on one hand and on the other, how to retain existing
customers. This problem can be explored with help of analyzing the following: 1) The factors considered by the
customers for buying the products/services. 2) After buying them, what are the attributes/features they look for in the
product/service to draw satisfaction. 3) In case of dissatisfaction, how they experience it and attribute it to the various
factors associated with the same and at times, switch over to another shop/service provider for same product/service.
Against this backdrop, a survey has been conducted in the service sector, with the following specific objectives.
(Oi - Ei )2
2 =
Ei
Where,
Oi = Observed frequency
Ei = Expected frequency
The value obtained from the above procedure was compared with the table value at (r-1) x (c-1) degrees of freedom.
Here r and c refer to the number of rows and columns respectively. If the calculated value is greater than the table value,
it would be inferred that the impact of the variable on the switching behavior depends on the nature of service industry.
Otherwise, the impact of the variable on the switching behavior and the nature of the service industry are said to be
independent of each other.
It is found that switching over is quite common in all the four service segments of the study. But switching rate is high
in case of beauty parlours (70%) and low in case of hospitals (46%). This rate is 62% and 58 % in respect of petrol
pumps and browsing centers respectively. It clearly indicates that customers of nursing homes (Hospitals) could not
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 23
simply hop from one to another very frequently like the customers of other service segments. Of the respondents, in
each of the service segment, who have shifted their service providers in the recent past expressed the variables, which
strongly influenced them to do so are given in Table 2 and discussed hereunder:
Table 2: Variables That Influenced To Switch Over
Variable Service Industry Influenced Not- Influenced Total Chi-Value
Price
BP 20(57.14) 15(42.86) 35(100.00)
BC 18(62.07) 11(37.93) 29(100.00)
HP 6(26.09) 17(73.91) 23(100.00)
PP 1(3.23) 30(96.77) 31(100.00)
Total 45(38.14) 73(61.86) 118(100.00) 29.829*
Core Quality Service Failure
BP 18(51.43) 17(48.57) 35(100.00)
BC 15(51.72) 14(48.28) 29(100.00)
HP 10(43.48) 13(56.52) 23(100.00)
PP 11(35.48) 20(64.52) 31(100.00)
Total 54(45.76) 64(54.24) 118(100.00) 2.235
Response to service failure
BP 8(22.86) 27(77.14) 35(100.00)
BC 7(24.14) 22(75.86) 29(100.00)
HP 0(0.00) 23(100.00) 23(100.00)
PP 4(12.90) 27(87.10) 31(100.00)
Total 19(16.10) 99(83.90) 118(100.00) 7.217**
Ethical Problem
BP 1(2.86) 34(97.14) 35(100.00)
BC 3(10.34) 26(89.66) 29(100.00)
HP 7(30.43) 16(69.57) 23(100.00)
PP 10(32.26) 21(67.74) 31(100.00)
Total 21(17.80) 97(82.20) 118(100.00) 13.381*
Inconvenience
BP 17(51.43) 17(48.57) 35(100.00)
BC 8(27.59) 21(72.41) 29(100.00)
HP 9(39.13) 14(60.17) 23(100.00)
PP 14(45.16) 17(54.84) 31(100.00)
Total 49(41.53) 69(58.47) 118(100.00) 3.957
Relation service encounter failure
BP 10(28.57) 25(71.43) 35(100.00)
BC 9(31.03) 20(68.97) 29(100.00)
HP 1(4.35) 22(95.65) 23(100.00)
PP 6(19.35) 25(80.65) 31(100.00)
Total 26(22.03) 92(77.97) 118(100.00) 6.555
Note: Figures In Parenthesis Are The Percentages To Total Consumers Switched Over In The Respective Service Sector.
70
VARIABLES
]Inconvenience Resulting In Service 'Inconvenience Defectors': Between acquiring tangible goods and services,
generally, customers look into factors of convenience more for services than for tangible goods. The study too comes
out with the same analysis. These are the customers who switched to other services as a result of inconvenience caused
to them by these service providers. Inconveniences caused the customers, to a great extent (51.43%) in the category of
beauty parlours, to move over to new service providers. Switching behavior, because of inconvenience, is found
relatively in lesser degree in petrol pumps ( 45.16 per cent), hospitals (39.13 per cent) and browsing centers (27.59 per
cent). The range of switching behavior from one to another service industry is low i.e. 27.59 to 51.43 percent. The Chi-
square results, therefore, also prove that the nature of the service industry and inconvenience variable are not heavily
depending on one another with regard to switching behavior.
]Services Relations Encounter Failure Resulting In 'Relation Defectors’: One of the prominent non-price
competitive factors that rules the roost in present day business is relationship. If the relationship is good, business will
have longevity. This has been emphasized by one of the authorities in marketing management, Philip Kotler, as there is
shift from transactional marketing to relationship marketing. Recent developments in the arena of business provide
more scope for Customer Relationship Management (CRM). Though the concept of CRM is not very popular in the
Indian context like in developed countries, it has made its presence felt. Hence, relations account for around 31.03% in
browsing centers, 29.57 % in beauty parlours, 19.35% in petrol pumps and very low i.e. 4.35% in hospitals, with regard
to hopping decisions of customers. The association between the influences of service relations encounters failure and
nature of service industry proved only at 10 per cent probability level as per Chi-square results.
]Response To Service Failure Resulting In 'Service Failure Defectors': This is the high-tech age; everybody is busy in
his/her own way. If the service provider fails to respond to customers in a desired way, they might feel insulted and
neglected and switch over to another service provider. This tendency is said to be high in busy cities and towns.
However, customers in the study area also feel it. The rate of influence on switching behaviour is as follows: 22.86% in
beauty parlours, 24.14% in browsing centers, 12.90% in petrol pumps and is zero in hospitals. It is inferred through
Chi-square test that there exists a close relation between the influence of response to service failure and the type of
service industry. This is obvious from the study that customers rarely bother to notice service failure, when they are
happy with quality of core service.
]Pricing Failure Resulting In 'Price Defectors': These are the days of non-price competition; accordingly, the
respondents' expressed mixed response as to price is an important variable for their hopping behaviour. In case of
petrol pumps, price per unit being uniform one at all service providers, the respondents opined that price is not at all a
factor to be considered for shifting behaviour. But, at the same time, price per unit of service varies in case of the other
service segments. To this, the respondents in hospital category attach not much importance. Whereas, in case of beauty
parlours and browsing centers, price factor played a dominant role with regard to switching behavior.The degree of
importance that is being shown for price factor in service segments is as 3.23% in petrol pumps, 26.09% in hospitals,
57.14% in beauty parlours and 62.07% in browsing centers. The Chi-Square results endorse the above view by proving
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 25
the close degree of association between influence of the price variable on the switching behavior and the nature of the
service industry.
]Ethical Practices Resulting In 'Principled Defectors': Business houses should give priority, besides the above
factors, to ethical practices too. Every business house should have its own ethical code of conduct with respect to the
dealings with customers. If they undermine its importance, there are chances of customers moving away from them. It
is evident in the study. Among the four service segments of the study, customers (32.26%) of petrol pumps are more
prone in this regard. Next to that, it is hospitals (30.43%), browsing centers (10.34%) and very low (2.86%) in beauty
parlours. The test results disclosed that the impact of ethical practices on the switching behaviour depends on the kind
of service industry. Generally, customers don't tolerate unethical practices in petrol pumps and hospitals for obvious
reasons. However, this kind of impact is not that apparent in other service industry.
]Involuntary Switching Resulting In 'Market Defectors': There are chances of either migration of customers or
shifting of service providers from one to another place. In both the cases, customers are forced to hop the service
providers. This also appears to be a reason for switching behaviour in the study area. It is in higher side (11.43%) with
regard to beauty parlours, followed by petrol pumps (9.68%), browsing centers (6.90%) and hospitals (4.35).
]Competition Resulting In 'Hi-tech Defectors': Undoubtedly,business houses are through cutthroat competition.
Satisfied customers of the service provider do not take this into cognizance. It is proved clearly in the study. It has least
impact on switching behaviour. Degree of impact comes to 2.86% in beauty parlours, 3.23% in petrol pumps and nil in
case of browsing centers and hospitals.
FINDINGS
1. Switching Behavior Is Low (46%) With Hospital And High (70%) With Beauty Parlour Respondents: Generally,
patients (respondents in the hospital category) don't wish to change their doctors (nursing homes) very easily and often
as it very delicate thing to do so. Whereas customers of beauty parlours don't have such sensitivity in going for new
service providers. Next to beauty parlours the rate hopping is high in case of petrol pumps (62%) and browsing centers
(58%) respondents respectively.
2. Core Quality Service Impacts Between 38.48 And 51.47 Per Cent In Switching Behaviour: Its impact in browsing
centers is 51.73%, 51.43 % in beauty parlours, 43.48% in hospitals and 35.48% in petrol pumps.
3. Browsing Centers Lose Customers To Their Counter Parts Very Heavily On Price Front: Though price factor has no
role to play in losing/getting customers at petrol pumps, it has much to do in case of browsing centers (62.07%).
4. Word Of Mouth (WOM) Is The Major Influential Source For Switchover : Even though many studies suggest that
informal referrals from others account for three times as many purchases as advertising (cf. Morin 1983), is twice as
effective as radio advertising, four times more effective than personal selling, and seven times as effective as
newspapers and magazines (Katz and Lazarsfeld 1955), retailers and service providers seems to pay less attention
towards this factor. The study revels that positive WOM plays a dominant role in attracting new customers, in case of
hospitals, it works out to be 83% followed by beauty parlours (74%) and browsing centers (59%) but petrol pumps
(35%) are least affected by it.
Active search helps the people to locate best service providers next only to word of mouth. Though companies
knowingly spend huge outlays on advertising, perhaps its not the driving engine in service industry in the study area.
Table No. 3: Sources Influenced To Switch Over To The New Service Providers
90
80
DEGREE OF INFLUENCE
70
60
50
BP
40
30 BC
20
10 HP
0
PP
WOM ADVT A.SEARCH ACCIDENTAL OTHERS
SOURCES
CONCLUSION
Studies show that although customers are dissatisfied with one out of every four purchases, less than five percent of
dissatisfied customers will complain. Most customers will buy less or switch suppliers. “Relationship with a customer
doesn't end with the first sale- It actually starts”. This study endorses the above statements.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1.DeSouza Glenn (1992), “Designing customer retention plan”, The Journal of Business Strategy, March/April 1992, PP: 24-28.
2.Katz, Elihu, and Paul Lazerfield (1955), Personal Influence, Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
3.Lees Gavin, Garland Ron, Wright Malcolm (2007), “Switching banks: Old bank gone but not forgotten” Journal of Financial Services Marketing Vol. 12, 2 146-
156.
(Contd. On Page 35 )
INTRODUCTION
In India, after independence, industrialization has paved the way for people to possess luxury items such as television,
refrigerators, home appliances, cars, etc. Motor car is one of the commonly used conveyances by the upper and
middle-class people. Before two decades, only a few industrialists and rich people owned cars. There was a time when
one had to wait for weeks, months or even years to buy a car in India. The option of Indian drivers was limited to a few
models. But, after industrialization, the earning capacity of the middle-class people has also increased. Now-a-days,
motor car is not only bought for social status, but as a necessary one. Moreover, today, every middle / upper middle
class people wants to have a car today. A consumer's decision to buy a product or service is the result of interplay of
many internal and external forces or stimuli. The starting point is the manufacturers’ and marketer's stimuli in the form
of product offering through some promotional methods, available of the product or services at a reasonable price and to
satisfy and retain the customers using different marketing strategies. But the environmental stimuli enter the buyer's
mind through cultural, social, personal and psychological factors that play a critical role in purchase decision. Thus,
the choice of the product/brand/service totally depends upon the consideration and influence of many factors. In this
study, the researcher has focused upon the factors to assess the factors contributing to brand preference of passenger
cars and its impact on customer satisfaction.
METHODOLOGY
This study, endeavouring to test the brand preference model, is exploratory in nature. The data for the study, primary in
nature, has been collected using questionnaires from 712 customers of car owners in the area of Coimbatore city,
during the period from April, 2005 to April, 2008 in the State of Tamil Nadu, India.
TOOL USED
1. Friedman's test. 2. Multiple Regression Analysis
The Friedman chi-square tests the null hypothesis that the ranks of the variables do not differ from their expected value.
For a constant sample size, the higher the value of this chi-square statistic, the larger the difference between each
variables rank sum and its expected value. For these rankings, the chi-square value is 251.77; Degrees of freedom are
equal to the number of variables minus 1. The asymptotic significance is the approximate probability of obtaining a
chi-square statistic as extreme as 251.77 with nine degrees of freedom in repeated samples if the rankings of each
factors are not truly different. Because a chi-square of 251.77 with 9 degrees of freedom is unlikely to have arisen by
chance, it has to be concluded that the 712 respondents do not have equal preference for all factors.
It could be noted from the above Table 1 that among the ten factors, Advertisement (6.57) was ranked first. It is
followed by Friends (6.43), Relatives (6.12), Decisions influenced by spouse (5.98), Past experience (5.85) and Dealer
schemes (5.83) which were ranked second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth respectively.
Hence, it is concluded that among the 10 factors, Advertisement, Friends, Relatives and Decisions influenced by
30 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
spouse influences are more in consumer's car preference.
It is clear from the above Table 2 that among the thirteen factors, Brand name (7.28) was ranked first. It is followed by
Brand superiority (7.09), Brand loyalty (6.99), Driving comfort (6.81) and Image of the manufacturer (6.55) which
were ranked second, third, fourth, and fifth respectively.
Thus, it can be concluded that among the 13 factors, Brand name, Brand superiority, and Brand loyalty play a major
role in influencing consumers' car preference.
It could be noted from the above Table 3 that among the eight factors, Mileage (4.84) was ranked first. It is followed by
Maintenance cost (4.61), Price (4.60), Free insurance (4.50), Discount offers (4.42) and Resale value (4.41) which
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 31
were ranked second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth respectively.
Therefore, it can be concluded that Mileage, Maintenance cost and Price play a major role in influencing a consumer's
car preference.
It is noticed from the above Table 4 that among the twenty factors, Quality (11.79) was ranked first. It is followed by
Comfort (11.41), Technology (11.14), Brakes, Power Steering (10.98), Durability (10.86) and Seating capacity
(10.85) which were ranked second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth respectively.
It can be concluded that among the 20 factors, Quality, Comfort, Technology, Brakes, Power Steering and Durability
play major roles in influencing consumer's car preference.
The ANOVA Table 6 reports a significant F statistic, indicating that using the model is better than guessing the mean.
As a whole, the regression does a good job of modeling satisfaction on performance. The ANOVA Table tests the
acceptability of the model from a statistical perspective. The regression row displays information about the variation
accounted for the model. The residual row displays information about the variation that is not accounted for the model.
The regression sum of square is lesser than residual sums of squares, which indicates that nearly seventy four percent
of the variation in satisfaction on performance is explained by the model.
Table 6: Anova- Significant F Statistic
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F P
Regression 675.9964 4 168.9991 7.8786. 000**
Residual 15165.43 707 21.45039
Total 15841.43 711
** Highly Significant (at 1% level)
]Predictors: (Constant), Information Factors, Psychological Factors, Economic Factors And Product Factors.
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 33
]Dependent Variable: Satisfaction On Performance.
The significance value of the F statistic is less than 0.01, which means that the variation explained by the model is not
due to chance. Even though the model fit looks positive, the first section of the coefficients (Table 7) shows that there is
predictor in the model which is non-significant coefficients, indicating that the Information factors and Psychological
factors which do not contribute much to the model.
Table 7: Regression Coefficients
Factors B Std. Error T P
(Constant) 38.73736 0.764161 50.69265 0.000**
Information Factor 0.023491 0.066026 0.355786 0.722107
Psychological Factor -0.09703 0.071823 -1.351 0.177127
Economic Factor -0.35305 0.077541 -4.55311 0.000**
Product Factor 0.186608 0.044061 4.235254 0.000**
Dependent Variable: Satisfaction On Performance
The above Table 7 shows the coefficients of the regression line. It states that the expected level of satisfaction on
performance is equal to,
Y = 38, 73736 + 0.023491X1- 0.09703X2 - 0.35305X3 +0.186608X4.
Looking at the significance values from the Table 7, it can be seen that B coefficient of Information factors and
Psychological factors are not influencing significantly the level of satisfaction, because the 'p' value for Information
factors and Psychological factors are greater than 0.05. On the other hand, Economic factors and Product factors are
influencing significantly the level of satisfaction because the 'p' value for Economic factors and Product factors are less
than 0.05.
CONCLUSION
The present study made a systematic effort on studying consumer brand preference towards passenger cars in India by
analyzing the factors that influence brand choice of the customers and revealed the impact of brand preference
dimensions on customer satisfaction. It is indeed obvious from the study that the performance factors of the passenger
car brands have dominated the preference of customers, based on their economic status. The marketing
communication unleashed by manufacturers and dealers also had a fair say on the total decision of the customer
preference. Overall, it is the all round ability of the car brands, viz, reliability, safety, technology, value for money, high
resale value, high mileage, maintenance cost, quality, comforts, durability, etc., that prove to be decisive factors of
choice right across the globe as well as in India. Moreover, among the four dimensions, Information factors and
Psychological factors are not influencing significantly the level of satisfaction of the respondents than the Economic
factors and Product factors.
INTRODUCTION
To survive in the midst of intense competition, most of the companies are looking for unconventional ways of
marketing. Internet is perhaps the best unconventional form of marketing that has been embraced by the companies. As
the internet has been expanding, it has become a popular marketing channel (Cho and Park, 2001). Internet is an
“anytime anywhere' medium (Ramaswamy & Namakumari, 2002) that has given birth to entirely new business
models and opened completely novel opportunities for global marketing. Recognition of the operational efficiency
and effectiveness of the internet is increasingly driving managers in traditional companies to conduct transactions on
the internet (Chakraborty et al., 2002). Many companies have adopted internet for conducting business transactions
and sharing business information with their customers and business partners (Torre and Moxon, 2001). Ghose (1998)
predicted rightly that the internet is fast becoming an important channel for commerce in a range of businesses. The
internet offers direct links with customers and suppliers, and facilitates transactions, processes and information
transfer (Walters and Lancaster, 1999). It offers organizations inexpensive and sophisticated tools for advertising,
taking and placing orders, promoting their philosophies, and communicating with their customers all over the world
(Palumbo and Herbig, 1998). The internet provides a marketplace where buyers and sellers conduct transactions
directly, interactively, and in real time beyond the physical limitations of traditional brick and mortar retailers
(Brynjolfsson and Smith, 2000; Butler and Peppard, 1998; Griffith and Krampf, 1998; Peterson et al, 1997). Today,
almost all business firms use the internet to provide information about the firm, their products or services on the
offering, and advertise and sell their products or services. The internet offers a high degree of interaction and affords
customers unprecedented benefits, from convenience to bargain prices. The ever increasing mainstream activity on the
internet has opened up a whole new value of gaining customers. Thousands of companies, particularly retailers, were
drawn onto the internet by a fear that they would be left behind by online only competitors (Welling and White, 2006).
Thus, what started as a separate form of innovative retailing in the exclusive domain of new entrepreneurs has become
part of a multichannel strategy for established retailers (Grewal et al., 2002). Studying attitudes is helpful in
understanding the potential relationship between attitudes and behaviour. Attitudes that individuals consider
important tend to show a strong relationship to behaviour (Robbins, Judge, and Sanghi, 2009). Marketers should be
interested in their customers' attitudes because attitudes provide warnings of potential dissatisfaction among
customers. Satisfied customers will become loyal to the company. Given the fact that marketers want to keep
dissatisfaction down, especially among loyal customers, they will want to do things that result in positive attitudes
among customers. This is more important for e-marketers as the customers are skeptical due to the element of high
perceived risk and uncertainty associated in an online environment. Technological developments have transformed
the internet into a mainstream business medium, while at the same time, online customers are maturing and virtual
marketers realize the importance for a professional and customer oriented approach (Constantinides, 2004). As access
to the internet is increasing worldwide, customers' purchasing behaviours are changing drastically. India had an
estimated 45.3 million active internet users as in 2008 according to results of a study conducted by Internet and Mobile
Association of India (IAMAI). In India, internet penetration is becoming more widespread because of a number of
reasons. The primary reasons are bandwidth becoming readily available, low internet tariffs, and cheaper computer
hardware. The growing usage of the most interactive medium, the internet, among Indians provides an opportunity for
*Assistant Professor, Department of Management Studies, National Institute of Technology, Durgapur, West Bengal.
Email : neelotpaul@gmail.com
**Assistant Professor, Amity Global Business School, Kolkata.
***Reader, Centre for Management Studies, The University of Burdwan, Burdwan, West Bengal.
36 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
undertaking a fundamental research to understand the attitude of Indian customers towards online shopping. E-
marketers in India can develop their online marketing strategies if they know what drives the customers toward online
shopping.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Customers' attitudes towards online shopping have attracted a lot of attention from researchers across the globe.
Previous literature has provided us with a very strong platform with a plethora of e-shopping patronage from varied
perspectives. Swaminathan et al (1999) studied internet users' attitudes towards online shopping. The study revealed
vendor characteristics, perceived security of shopping transactions on the internet, and customer privacy concerns are
the three characteristics of the shopping environment that influences customers' attitudes toward online shopping. A
study undertaken by Modahl (2000) revealed that customers may perceive different types of risks in online purchasing
of goods, as a result of which they may not indulge in online shopping. Hoffman et al (1999) revealed that if consumers
concern for the safety of personal information is taken care of by the e-marketers, then it has a positive effect on the
number of online purchases customers make. Vellido et al (2000), from their study, found risk perception of customers
was demonstrated to be the main discriminator between those who reported that they purchased products online and
those who reported that they did not. Shergill and Chen (2005) found from their study that different types of online
buyers have different evaluations of website design, and website reliability, but similar evaluations of website
security/privacy issues, which indicates that online security/privacy issues are extremely important to almost all
online buyers. Ranganatham and Ganapathy (2002) concluded that security and privacy dimensions of websites have a
greater impact on the purchase intent of online buyers than information content and design of web sites. Gaertner and
Smith (2001) concluded that security concerns have been the most important reason for internet users not shopping
online. A study by Ratnasingham (1998) has revealed that the fear of online credit card fraud has been one of the major
reasons for customers avoiding online shopping. Benedict et al (2004) found from their study that the need to touch,
feel, smell, or ability to try a product influences customers' decision whether or not to shop online. Miyazaki and
Fernandez (2001) opined that one of the main reasons for which customers hesitate to shop online is that online
shoppers are unable to touch, feel, or see real products in order to evaluate the quality. Studies undertaken by Jones and
Vijayasarathy (1998), and by Tan (1998), revealed that the absence of touch and feel in the online purchase process and
concerns about the chances of receiving defective or unspecified goods increases the perceived risk in the minds of the
customers. Research studies conducted by Churchill and Supernant (1982), Oliver (1980), Luarn and Lin (2003) have
revealed that the ability of online companies to convert potential consumers into real depends largely on the service
they offer and on the perceived satisfaction of consumers. Jayawardhena and Foley (2000) identified that convenience,
site design, and financial security are the dominant factors in customer assessment of e-satisfaction. According to
Collier and Bienstock (2006), the factor having the strongest influence on online customers' satisfaction and future
purchase intention is product delivery. Grewal et al (2002) concluded that for those shoppers, who would not like to
invest time in conventional shopping, online shopping provides a convenient alternative. The possibility of saving
time is an important factor facilitating online shopping. Keen et al (2002) found that demographic factors like age,
gender, education, and income has a significant effect on the attitude of the consumers towards online shopping. Their
research also revealed that internet users, who are educated are more likely to feel less uncomfortable to go for online
shopping. The results from a three country (USA, France, & Macao) study, conducted by Kuhlmeier and Knight
(2005), suggested that a positive relationship exists between customer usage and experience of internet and the
likelihood of making online purchases. Prior research has focused on a number of predicators of customers' online
shopping attitude, but few studies have been done in the Indian context. Hence, more research studies are needed to
study Indian consumers' attitude arising as a result of the shift from in-store to online shopping.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
There are two main data sources for the research study - secondary and primary. To collect the data for this research
study, both primary and secondary sources were used. One of the cardinal rules in data collection is to exhaust all
secondary data sources before conducting a primary study. The operational features of secondary data are that it
already exists and is easily available. Secondary data can be quite versatile and is used for many purposes
(Neelankavil, 2007). To collect secondary data, at first, the researcher reviewed articles related to research objectives
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 37
that appeared in the scholarly literature. Key journals and proceedings were systematically scanned for any articles
related to the research topic. In addition to that, search for the key words in peer reviewed journals were undertaken.
This search led to articles in other related journals. To conduct an empirical investigation, a survey was conducted,
using a questionnaire. At first,the items to be included in the questionnaire were decided. Next, the survey was
conducted to collect the data and then the data were analyzed and interpreted to find the answers to the research
objectives. The survey for data collection was carried out in the early months of 2009.The researcher developed a
questionnaire based on the literature, deriving issues pertinent to the research objectives. The questionnaire was pre-
tested in a pilot study to fine tune the questionnaire. The pilot study was conducted among a convenience sample of
twelve people consisting of neighbours, students, and colleagues, to evaluate how well the questionnaire was framed
and understood. Based on the pilot study and feedback from the participants, some items were reworded to improve
clarity. The respondents were randomly selected, from a city and two major towns in West Bengal, to remove the
biasness in samples. Unfortunately, complete random sampling was not possible for a topic related to the internet, as in
India, there is still much ignorance about internet among the people. There are many who don't have any idea about the
internet, and ,therefore, asking their views on the research topic would lead to totally inappropriate results. Due to the
nature of the study, respondents were randomly picked from only those who were in the age group of 18 - 65 years of
both sexes, either earning or with access to expendable income, and using the internet at least once a week. In this
study, random sampling method using Kish method of sampling is done. The Kish grid was developed by Kish in 1949,
and is commonly used by those conducting large scale surveys. In total, 316 respondents completed the questionnaire.
No replacement was made for households which refused to be a part of the survey or where the selected family member
did not match with the defined population. The Kish method involves some sequential steps in which, a) The
interviewer is to record the name, gender, age of all the eligible persons & their relation to the housewife (because she
is the one who is mostly available), b) Then the candidates are arranged according to their increasing age, and c) Using
a random number table, the respondent is chosen.
Among the 202 respondents who shopped online, 89.1% were satisfied and 96.1% satisfied customers also engaged in
online shopping in future. This indicates that satisfaction level was very high among online customers, which is indeed
very good news for e-marketers in India. In response to the question what products/services they have purchased
online in the last four months, 35.6% of the respondents stated they have availed some type of service. Among the
products purchased online, laptop was purchased the most by 6% of the respondents, followed by computer (5%). For
rest of the products purchased by the respondents, the percentage falls below 5% for each product category. The
finding may make us infer that in India, people are more into the purchase of services rather than products online. A
possible reason for laptops being the most purchased product online may be the fact that the internet users in India tend
to be young students or professionals with a good expendable income. For this group of people, having a laptop is
extremely essential.
Table 5: Factors Facilitating Online Shopping
N=202 Mean Std. Deviation
Extensive & Current Information Available 4.1584 .76272
24x7 Availability 4.1386 .79838
Can Shop From Anywhere 4.0743 .70494
Can Engage In Other Online Activities While Shopping 3.7673 .82276
Home Delivery 3.6683 .86610
Cheaper Price 3.5644 .82155
The factors facilitating online shopping were measured on a five point Likert scale and anchored by 1 (not at all
important) and 5 (extremely important). The respondents were asked to rate the factors. The study investigated among
the 202 online shoppers the importance of factors that facilitate online shopping. The Table 5 reveals that availability
of extensive & current information is the most important reason for shoppers going online. The availability of huge
amount of information on the internet, and that also free of cost most of the times, is unmatched in the offline market.
With so much of online information, it becomes easier for the customers to make a decision on the product they want to
purchase or the service they want to avail. Surprisingly,cheaper price appears to be the least important factor
facilitating online shopping. This may imply that customers can get the benefit of low prices in the traditional market
but the other unique benefits provided by the internet cannot be matched by the physical market. The factors which
prevent online shopping were measured on a five - point Likert scale and anchored by 1 (not at all important) and 5
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 39
(extremely important). The respondents were asked to rate the factors. The study investigated among the 114 non
online shoppers that what prevents them from online shopping. The most important reason for customers not engaging
in online shopping is payment insecurity. Non online shoppers have a perception of risk associated with online
payment. It can be stated that security is the main reason for Indian customers not engaging in online shopping. This
implies that companies in order to gain customers trust should try to remove this fear from the minds of customers by
providing adequate security features as far as online payment is concerned. This is particularly important in case of
transaction in high risk or uncertainty environment like the internet. The least important reason for which the
consumers are not inclined towards online shopping is that they have no credit cards. As most of the time online
payment needs a credit card, so not having a credit card does become an obstacle for people from making online
purchase. Since this factor has been rated as the least important factor preventing online shopping, it may indicate that
most of the customers in India who use the internet do have credit cards.
Table 6: Factors Preventing Online Shopping
N=114 Mean Std. Deviation
Payment Insecurity 4.6404 .70557
Misuse Of Customer Data 4.2982 .75175
Absence Of Touch & Feel 3.8947 .82407
No Social Interaction 3.7281 .83385
No Credit Card 3.5439 .99681
HYPOTHESES TESTING
H1: There Is Association Between Age And Online Shopping.
Chi-Square Test
Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
a
Pearson Chi-Square 4.253 4 .373
N of Valid Cases 316
H2: There Is Association Between Monthly Family Income And Online Shopping.
Chi-Square Test
Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
a
Pearson Chi-Square 44.641 5 .000
N of Valid Cases 316
H3: There Is Association Between Frequency Of Internet Use And Online Shopping.
Chi-Square Test
Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 1.225E 2 .000
N of Valid Cases 316
H4: Time Spent Per Internet Session And Online Shopping Are Related.
Chi-Square Test
Value df Asymp. Sig. (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 13.723a 2 .001
N of Valid Cases 316
Results from the hypothesis testing shows there is no significant association between age and online shopping. The
reason for this may be attributed to the fact that at the time of the survey, most of the respondents from the households
who fitted the defined population are young people. Majority of the aged people in most of the households have never
CONCLUSION
The major findings revealed from the study in Indian context and their implications are discussed in this section. It can
be concluded that availability of extensive and current information is the most important factor which is driving Indian
customers to online shopping. Information gathering is a time consuming and costly affair in the physical market. This
is where internet provides a huge benefit to the customers. Informing refers that websites must provide relevant
information about their offerings. Relevant information directed at the needs and interests of the target audience
entices and propagates people to spend longer time periods at the company's website and make purchases. It can be
stated that concerns about online security is preventing customers from online shopping. So, e-marketers should try
their best to remove the security concerns from the minds of the customers by embedding adequate security features in
their websites and gain confidence of the customers. The present study also revealed that there is a significant
association of online shopping with monthly family income, frequency of internet usage and time spent per session of
internet use. This may imply that internet users with an average to high disposable monthly family income are more
likely to engage in online shopping than internet users with a low disposable monthly family income. As internet users
engage in using the internet more often, their perceived security concerns may gradually decrease and this may lead
them to engage in online shopping.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. E. Brynjolfsson & M.D.Smith (2000), “Frictionless commerce? A comparison of internet and conventional retailers”, Management Science, Vol.46 (4), 563-
585.
2. P.Butler & J.Peppard (1998), “Consumer purchasing on the internet: process and prospects”, European Management Journal, Vol.16 (5), 600-610.
3. G.Chakraborty, V.Lala, & D.Warren (2002), “An empirical investigation of antecedents of B2B web sites' effectiveness”, Journal of Interactive Marketing, Vol.
16 (4), 51 72.
4. N.Cho & S.Park (2001), “Development of electronic commerce user consumer satisfaction index (ECUSI) for internet shopping”, Industrial Management and
Data Systems, Vol. 101 (8), 400 405.
5. G.A.Churchill & C.Supernant (1982), “An investigation into the determinant of customer satisfaction”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 42 (2), 33 45.
6. E.Constantinides (2004), “Influencing the online consumer's behaviour: The web experience”, Internet Research, Vol. 14 (2), 111 126.
7. J.E.Collier & C.C.Bienstock (2006), “How do customers judge quality in an E-tailer?” MIT Sloan Management Review, Vol.48 (1), 45-71.
8. B.G.C.Dellaert, T.P.Y.Monsuwe & K.de Ruyter (2004), “What drives consumers to shop online? A literature review”, International Journal of Service Industry
Management, Vol.15 (1), 102 -121.
9. N.Gaertner & M.Smith (2001), “Ecommerce in a web based environment: Auditing relative advantages in the Australian health sector”, Managerial Auditing
Journal, Vol.16 (.6), 347-365.
10. S.Ghose (1998), “Making business sense of the internet”, Harvard Business Review, March, 126-135.
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 41
11. D.Grewal, G.R.Iyer & M.Levy (2002), “Internet retailing: enablers, limiters and market consequences”, Journal of Business Research, Vol.57 (7), 42-53.
12. D.Griffith & R.Krampf (1998), “An examination of the web based strategies of the top 100 US retailers”, Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, Vol.22 (3),
12-23.
13. D.L.Hoffman, T.P.Novak & M.Peralt (1999), “Building consumer trust online environments: the case for information privacy”, Communications of the ACM,
Vol.42 (4), 80-85
14. C.Jayawardhena and P.Foley (2000), “Changes in banking sector the case of internet banking in the UK”, Internet Research: Electronic Networking
Applications and Policy, Vol. 10 (1) 19 30.
15. J.M. Jones & L.R.Vijayasarathy (1998), “Internet consumer catalog shopping: findings from an exploratory study and directions for future research”, Internet
Research, Vol.8 (4), 322-330.
16. C.Keen, M.Wetzels, K.de Ruyter, & R.Feinberg (2002), “E-tailers versus retailers: which factors determine consumer preferences?” Journal of Business
Research, Vol.57 (7), 685-695.
17. L.Kish (1949), “A procedure for objective respondent selection within a household”, Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 44, 380 387.
18. D.Kuhlmeier & G.Knight (2005), “Antecedents to internet-based purchasing: a multinational study”, International Marketing Review, Vol.22 (4), 460-473
19. P.Luarn & H.Lin (2003), “A customer loyalty model for e-service context”, Journal of Electronic Commerce Research, Vol. 4 (4), 156 167.
20. A.D.Miyazaki & A.Fernandez (2001), “Consumer perceptions of privacy and security risk for online shopping”, The Journal of Consumer Affairs, Vol.35 (1),
27-44
21. M.Modahl (2000), “Now or never: How companies must change today to win the battle for internet consumers”, International Marketing Review, New York:
Harper Collins.
22. J. P. Neelankavil (2007), “International Business Research”, New York: M.E. Sharpe, Inc.
23. R.L. Oliver (1980), “A cognitive model of the antecedents and consequences of satisfaction decisions”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 17 (4), 460 469.
24. F.Palumbo & P.Herbig (1998), “International marketing tool”, Industrial Management & Data Systems, Vol.98 (6), 253-261.
25. R.A.Peterson, S.Balasubramanium & B. J. Bronnenberg, (1997), “Exploring the implication of the internet for consumer marketing”, Journal of Academy of
Marketing Science, Vol. 25 (4), 329 346.
26. V.S.Ramaswamy & S.Namakumari (2002), “Marketing Management”, McMillan Business Book.
27. C.Ranganatham & S.Ganapathy (2002), “Key dimensions of business-to-consumer web sites”, Information and Management, Vol. 39 (6), 457 465.
28. P.Ratnasingham (1998), “Internet based EDI trust and security”, Information Management and Computer Security, Vol.6 (1), 33 40.
29. S. P.Robbins, T. A.Judge & S.Sanghi (2009), “Organizational Behaviour”, Pearson Prentice Hall.
30. G.S. Shergill & Z.Chen (2005), “Web-based shopping: Consumer's attitude towards online shopping in New Zealand”, Journal of Electronic Research, Vol.6
(2), 79-94.
31. V.Swaminathan, L.White and B. P. Rao (1999), “Browsers or buyers in cyberspace? An investigation of factors influencing electronic exchange”, Journal of
Computer Mediated Communication, Vol. 5 (2)
Retrieved from:http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol5/issue2/swaminathan.htm
32. S.J.Tan (1998), “Strategies for reducing consumer's risk aversion in internet shopping”, Journal of Consumer Marketing, Vol.16 (2), 163-180.
33. J.Torre & R.Moxon (2001), “E-commerce and global business: the impact of the information and communication technology revolution on the conduct of
international business”, Journal of International Business Studies, Vol. 32 (4), 617 639.
34. A.Vellido, P.J. G.Lisboa & K.Meehan (2000), “Quantitative characterization and prediction of online purchasing behaviour: A latent variable approach”,
International Journal of Electronic Commerce, Vol. 4 (4), 83 104.
35. D.Walters & G.Lancaster (1999), “Using the internet as a channel for commerce”, Management Decision, Vol. 37 (10), 800- 816.
36. R.Welling & L.White (2006), “Website performance measurement: promise and reality”, Managing Service Quality, Vol. 16 (6), 654 670.
37. http://www.iami.in/PRelease_detail.aspx?nid=1801&NMonth=1&NYear=2009
38. http://www.iami.in/PRelease_detail.aspx?nid=1776&NMonth=1&NYear=2009
*Prashant D. Amin
**Dr. Bijal Amin
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Learning gender differences is significant. Although, gender differences in attitudes towards use of Internet may
lessen over time with the increased participation of females, it is unlikely that these differences will disappear any time
soon. Several analyses of consumer behaviour have suggested that males and females differ particularly in their
processing of information. Males and females respond in different ways to alternative consuming tasks and stimuli
such as pictures versus words. Females easily and quickly respond to non-verbal stimuli by evoking more associative,
interpretations and more elaborate descriptions than males. In order to attract more female online shoppers, marketers
should focus on female online shoppers; perceive her value in the functional aspects and emotional aspects such as
relative advantage and social prestige value of shopping online and social experiential dimensions. The stronger
influence of perceived ease of purchasing on both attitudes and online shopping intentions for females compared to
50 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
males indicates that online shopping intentions and attitudes are sensitive to female perceptions, given a higher
demand for the physical environment or a stronger desire for the sensory pleasures associated with touching a product.
Marketers could better target consumers and consequently foster more positive attitudes on their online shopping
intentions. Offering male consumers the right products whenever they need them and responding to inquiries in a
timely fashion can strengthen the attitudes and purchase intentions of male consumers. Establishing an online
consumer community based on gender and hobby provides another method of improving female perceptions of ease of
shopping owing to the effective communications among female consumers themselves. Compared to females, males
tend to reveal more masculine traits such as being assertive, impatient, and goal-oriented indicating that they desire to
successfully accomplish efficient online purchases without distraction.( Yu-Bin Chiu, Chieh-Peng Lin, Ling-Lang
Tang,2005).Hedonic benefits may be obtained from social components of the online shopping experience. E-retailers
interested in moving their customers to some form of electronic shopping must improve perceived hedonic benefit and
not concentrate only on utilitarian benefits. Finally, the gendered nature of conventional buying emerged clearly;
women prefer emotional and psychological involvement in the online and offline shopping process, whereas, men
focus on efficiency and convenience in obtaining shopping outcomes from the actual products.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1) A M. Levin (2005); A Multi attributes analysis of Preferences for Online and Offline shopping: Differences across Products, Consumers, and Shopping stages;
Journal of Electronic Commerce Research; Vol.6 No.4, 2005 pp.281-290.
2) Alisa Kolsaker and Claire Payne(2002);Engendering trust in e-commerce: a study of gender-based concerns; Marketing Intelligence and Planning; Vol.20,
No.4; 2002; pp.206-214.
3)Alka Verma (2000); Adoption of Internet shopping: The role of consumer innovativeness; Industrial management data system; pp.294-300.
4) Ananda Mitra, Jennifer Willyard, Carrie Anne Platt, Michael Parsons (2005); Exploring Web Usage and Selection Criteria among Male and Female Students;
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication; Vol.10, Issue 3; April 2005.
5) Anthony D. Miyazaki and Ana Fernandez (2001); Consumer perceptions of privacy and security risks for online shopping. Journal of consumer affairs, Vol.35,
No.1; pp.27-42.
6) Bijou Yang and David Lester (2004); Attitudes toward buying online; Cyber Psychology &Behavior; Vol 7, No.1; 2004; pp.85-91.
7) Bijou Yanga and David Lester (2005); Gender differences in E-commerce; Applied Economics; Vol.37, 2005; pp. 2077-2089.
8) Charles Dennis, Lisa Harris and Balraj Sandhu (2002); From bricks to clicks: understanding e-consumer; International Journal Qualitative Marketing Research;
an International Journal Vol. 5, No.4; 2002; pp. 281-290.
9) Chaung Hoon Park and Young Gul Kim (2003); Identifying key factors affecting consumer purchase behaviour in an online shopping context; International
Journal of Retail and Distribution management; Vol.31, No. 1, pp.16-29.
10) Despina A.Karayanni (2003); Web shoppers and non-shoppers: Compatibility, relative advantage and demographics; European Journal Review; Vol. 15, No.3;
2003 pp. 141-152.
11) Forrester Research (1998), “Worldwide Internet Commerce Will Reach As high as $3.2 Trillion in 2003”; http://www.forrester.com/, 1998.
12) Fram Eugene H., Grady, Dale B. (1995) "Internet Byers. Will the Surfers Become Buyers?" Direct Marketing; October 1995; Vol. 58, Issue 6; P. 63.
13) Heejin Lim and Alan F. Dubinsky (2004); Consumers' perception of e-shopping characteristics: An expectancy value approach; The Journal of consumer
affairs; Vol.35, No. 1, pp.27-42.
14) Helga Dittmar and others (2004); Buying on the Internet: gender difference in online and conventional buying motivations; sex roles; Vol.5, No.5-6 pp. 424-
443.
15) Hoffman, Novak, & Chaterjee, 1995 Online Shopping: To Buy or Not to Buy; International Journal of Retail and Distribution management; vol.33, No.2,
pp.122-132.
16) Hoffman, Novak, & Chaterjee, 1995 Online Shopping: To Buy or Not to Buy?;
17) International Journal of Retail and Distribution management; vol.33, No.2, pp.122-132.
18) Ira M. Wasserman, Eastern Mich(2005); Gender and the Internet: Causes of Variation in Access, Level, and Scope of Use; Social science quarterly; Vol.86,
No.1, March 2005, pp.252-270.
19) Joey F. George (2004); The theory of planned behaviour and Internet purchasing; Internet Research; Vol.14, No.3, pp.198-212.
20) Kaun-pin Chiang and Ruby Roy Dholkia (2003); Factors driving Consumer Intention to Shop Online: An Empirical Investigation. Journal Of Consumer
Psychology; Vol.13, No.1&2; 2003; pp. 177-183.
21) Leo R. Vijayasarathy (2003); Shopping orientations, product types and Internet shopping differences; Journal of electronic markets; Vol.13. PP.67-79.
22) Leo R. Vijayasarathy and Joseph M.Jones (2001); Do Internet shopping aids make a diference? An empirical investigation, Journal of electronic markets;
Vol.11, pp.75-83.
23) Linda A. Jackson, Kelly S. Ervin, Philip D. Gardner and Neal Schmitt (2001); Gender and the Internet: Women Communicating and Men Searching; Sex Roles;
Vol44, Nos. 5/6, 2001, pp.363-379.
24) Lynda Andrews, Jay Weerawardena, Geoffrey Kiel, Judy Drennan and Maree V. Boyle(2007); Gendered perceptions of experiential value in using web-
based retail channels; European Journal of Marketing; Vol. 41, No. 5/6, 2007, pp.640-658.
25) Patricia Source and others (2005); Attitude and age differences in online buying;
26) International Journal of Retail and Distribution management; Vol.33, No.2; 2005; pp.122-132.
27) Randall S. Sexton, Richard A. Johnson and Micheal A. Hignite(2002);Predicting Internet/ e-commerce use; Internet research: Electronic Application Policy;
Vol.12, No.5, 2002,pp.402-410.
28) Ronald E. Goldsmith and Leisa R. Flynn(2004); Psychological and behavioral drivers of online clothing purchase; Journal of Fashion Marketing and
Management; Vol.8, No.1; 2004; pp.84-95.
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 51
29) Rosie heimrath and anne goulding(2001); Internet perception and use: a gender perspective; Program;Vol 35; No 2, 2001,pp.119-134.
30) Ruby Roy Dholkia and Outi Uusitalo (2002); Switching to electronic stores: consumer characteristics and the perception of shopping benefits; International
Journal of Retail & Distribution Management; Vol. 30, No.10; 2002 pp. 459-469.
31) Sendy Farag and others (2006); E-shopping and its relationship with in store shopping: empirical evidence from the Netherlands and USA; Transport reviews;
vol.26. No.1 pp. 43-61
32) Sheril & Stanford (2003); Comparing online and non-online shoppers; International Journal Of Consumer Studies; Vol.27, No.2; March 2003; pp. 126-133.
33) Shwu Ing wu (2003); The relationship between consumer characteristics and attitude toward online shopping; Marketing intelligence and planning; pp.37-44.
34) Sita Mishra(2007); Consumers' attitude towards online shopping for clothing; The ICFAI Journal of Marketing Management; Vol.6, No.1, 2007; pp.32-40.
35) Tak-kee Hui and David Wan (2006); Factors affecting Internet shopping behavior in Singapore: Gender and educational issues; International Journal of
Consumer studies; 2006; pp.1-6.
36) Thompson S.H. Teo (2001); Demographic and motivation variables associated with Internet usage activities; Internet Research: Electronic networking
applications and policy; Vol. 11, No 2; 2001; pp. 125-137.
37) Tulay Giard and others (2003); Relationship of type of product, shopping orientations and demographics with preferences for shopping on the Internet; Journal
of Business and Psychology; Vol.18, No.1; 2003; pp.101-118.
38) Yu-Bin Chiu, Chieh-Peng Lin, Ling-Lang Tang( 2005); Gender differs: assessing a model of online purchase intentions in e-tail service; International Journal
of Service; Industry Management; Vol. 16, No. 5; 2005; pp. 416-435.
WEBLIOGRAPHY
1) http://planningcommission.nic.in/plans/planrel/fiveyr/10th/volume2/v2_ch7.
2) http://research.stikipad.com/language/show/Hindi
3) http://ritim.cba.uri.edu/wp2003/pdf_format/Wiley-Encycl-Internet-Usage-Gender-Final.pdf (gender and Internet)
4) http://southasia.oneworld.net/article/view/139805/1/ 05-05-07
5) http://static.scribd.com/docs/e8fdfkdryzyou.pdf
6) http://www.crito.uci.edu/noah/HOIT/HOIT%20Papers/Gender%20Asymmetry.pdf
7) http://www.crm2day.com/news/crm/114943.php
8) http://www.iamai.in
9) http://www.iamai.in/ioainnews.php3?article_mon=Oct&article_year=2006 09-05-07
10) www.Emarketer.com
INTRODUCTION
As the economy is developing, the mind set of the people is also changing at a very fast pace. Some decades back, the
best place for women was considered to be their home. It was thought that women are born to look after the family and
children. They were not allowed to work outside because it ruined the reputation of the family and at the same time, it
was not accepted by society. But now the scene has changed and so has the position of women in society. Women are
working in every field. Their earning is at par with that of their male counterparts and they enjoy both personal and
professional life, but in terms of insurance, they are either under insured or uninsured. Despite all of the changes, many
married women still rely on their husbands' insurance policy to protect them. Studies have shown that while women
indicate they understand life insurance as a product, few have quantified its economic value. A recent research
conducted by Prudential Financial in USA says :
]Nearly 80% of women say they understand life insurance well or somewhat well (It is worth noting, that life
insurance ranks among highest in women's understanding of financial products, second only to “savings accounts.”).
]However, few women have put a price on their human life value. Just one out of three have preparations for
premature death and life insurance. More than four in ten (44%) have not even discussed the issue with their spouse.
Another survey by country Insurance & Financial Services reveals that:
]76% of women (vs. 69% of men) rate life insurance as very or somewhat important,
]Fifty six percent of working women (who have life insurance coverage) do not believe or are unsure that the amount
of coverage they have is adequate.
]46% full time working women have not taken any steps to determine their life insurance needs.
]Although 69% of Americans believe both parents in a household -where one parent works and the other stays at
home to care for children- should have life insurance, just 7% report that to be the case in their home.
]Today, 59 percent of women have at least some life insurance (compared to 64 percent of men).
In India, social taboos and illiteracy has made the situation worse. Working women also do not have the right to spend
their money as per their wishes. The latest National Family Health Survey (NFHS) found that one in six married
working women had absolutely no control over the money they earned; only one in ten married women were able to
make even relatively insignificant decisions, such as visiting friends and family and more than a quarter of them had
say on the crucial matter of their own healthcare. The situation in India is shaping towards the need of Insurance
products among working women. There are some companies, including the largest insurance player, that have come up
with policies exclusively for women, but the awareness and interest towards insurance products is quite less. This
paper is an attempt to know the behavior of working women towards the insurance products.
LITERATURE REVIEW
There is no such study available which studies the factors affecting the selection of life insurance product for working
women. There are some studies regarding some factors affecting selection decision. A study done by Xumei Zhang at
el. (2007) has found that worrying about future, economical condition, cognition about life insurance and adventure
*Associate Professor, KIET School of Management, Krishna Institute of Engineering & Technology, Ghaziabad, Uttar
Pradesh.Email : manishiftm@gmail.com
**Lecturer, Department of Management Studies, Institute of Foreign Trade & Management, Moradabad,Uttar Pradesh.
Email : megharastogimoradabad@gmail.com
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 53
activities preference have significant positive effects on the intention of purchasing life insurance. Economical
condition also has significant positive effect on the premium of purchasing life insurance; health status has significant
negative effect on the premium of purchasing life insurance. Headen and Lee (1974) studied the effects of shortrun
financial market behaviour and consumer expectations on purchase of ordinary life insurance and developed structural
determinants of life insurance demand. They concluded that life insurance demand is inelastic and positively affected
by change in consumer sentiments; interest rates playing a role in the shortrun as well as in the longrun. Cargill and
Troxel (1979) ) studied the effect of interest rates on life insurance demand. He concluded that that the competing
yield is negatively related to the demand for life insurance.Greene (1954), Fortune( 1973) and Brown and Kim(1993)
examined the impact of the expected inflation rate on life insurance demand .Since a rising inflation may lead to
devaluation of the future benefits from purchasing life insurance, inflationary expectation would seem to dampen
insurance demand. The findings from these studies show that inflation is indeed statistically significant and negatively
related to life insurance. Babbel (1981) studied the detrimental influence of inflation on demand. He identified
empirically that life insurance sales in Brazil were still affected by inflationary expectations even after policies were
linked to a price index. He concluded that anticipated inflation can lead to higher perceived real costs of life insurance,
even when policies are index-linked.Schlesinger (1981) reveals that an optimal insurance decision is directly related to
the level of risk aversion of the insured person and shows, following Pratt (1964) and Sziprio (1985) that the more risk
adverse an individual is, the higher the amount of insured. Lewis (1989) and Showers and Shotick (1994) studied the
effect of the dependency ratio on life insurance consumption. Lewis' theoretical explanation of dependency ratio
influence (through term-life polices) is that life insurance is purchased to satisfy the needs of dependents, and that
individual demand depends on the demographic structure of that household. He found out that the number of
dependents act as an influence on the demand for life insurance.
The study by Truett et al. (1990) discussed the growth pattern of life insurance consumption in Mexico and United
States in a comparative framework, during the period 1964 to 1984. They assumed that at an abstract level, demand
depends upon the price of insurance, income level of individual, availability of substitute and other individual and
environment specific characteristics. Further, they experimented with demographic variables like age of individual
insured(s) and population within the age group of 25 to 64 and also considered education level to have some bearing on
insurance consumption decision. They concluded the existence of higher income inelasticity of demand for life
insurance in Mexico with low income levels. Age, education and income were significant factors affecting demand for
life insurance in both countries.
Truett and Truett (1990) studied the impact of education on insurance. He found out that an increase in the number of
educated people in a country may be associated directly with a greater recognition of various types of products offered
by life insurance companies, leading to higher levels of demand. Browne et al’s (1993), assumption that inhabitants of
a country are homogeneous relative to those of other countries, expanded the discussion on life insurance demand by
adding newer variables namely, average life expectancy and enrollment ratio of third level education. The study based
on 45 countries for two separate time periods (1980 and 1987) concluded that income and social security expenditures
are significant determinants of insurance demand, however, inflation has a negative correlation. Dependency ratio,
education and life expectancy were not significant but incorporation of religion, a dummy variable, indicates that
Muslim countries have negative affinity towards life insurance.
Browne and Kim (1993) studied the positive influence of education on life insurance demand through its effect on the
period of dependency. He concluded that individuals educated over longer periods forgo the opportunity of full-time
employment, and extend their reliance on the income stream of other working members of the family, increasing the
demand for policies. It can also be proposed that these effects are exacerbated by the income effect of education.
Browne and Kim (1993) studied the impact of inflation on life insurance. He concluded that inflation has a 'dampening
effect' on demand for products offered by life insurance companies, as it erodes the real value of these products.
Brown and Kim (1993) studied the ratio of total expenditure on life insurance premiums to the amount of life insurance
in force, and found that price is negatively related to life insurance consumption with an estimated price elasticity of 0-
24 , suggesting that demand is price elastic. Rubayah and Zaidi (2000) studied the effect of interest rates on life
insurance demand. He identified significant negative relationships between the demand for life insurance and both
interest rate measures.Enz (2000) studied the affect of income on insurance and found out that at higher levels of
income insurance, consumption becomes less sensitive to income growth as insurance product saturation is reached.
The main reason for this phenomenon is that at high- income levels, consumers become so wealthy that they can afford
54 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
to retain risk and start saving. Esho et al. (2002) studied the affect of cultural factors on life insurance. He concluded
that the demand for insurance is unaffected by cultural factors. Ward and zurbruegg (2002) did examine the impact of
legal and political determinants on life insurance consumption within Asia and OECD countries. They concluded that
in Asia, an improvement in the legal system has a significant and positive impact on life insurance demand. However,
in the OECD countries, the functioning of the legal system was found to be insignificant. Beck and Webb (2003) also
studied the positive impact of education on life insurance. He concluded that a better understanding of the benefits of
risk management and long-term savings may encourage risk aversion. Hwang and Gao (2003) studied several reasons
to explain why life insurance consumption should rise with income. Firstly, there is no reason to believe that insurance
is anything other than a normal good, in the sense that consumption is rising in income. Also, if consumption levels fall
relative to income, there follows a need for financial instruments to absorb surplus funds, enabling greater
accumulation of wealth .Secondly, as a person's level of income rises, so too does the opportunity cost of dying. Thus,
the desire to maintain living standards of dependents generates larger policies. According to Beck and Webb (2003), a
higher real interest rate increases LIC investment returns and thus their profitability, in turn offering greater
profitability of financial relative to real investments for potential purchases of life insurance policies. However, results
of neither study offer any evidence to support the hypothesized relationship. Lim & Haberman (2004) studied the
effect of interest rates on life insurance demand. He concluded that higher interest rates might be expected to reduce
demand as higher yields on alternative savings products makes life insurance less attractive. Wasaw and Hill (1986) ,
Brown and Kim (1993), Enz (2000) and Ward and Zurbruegg (2002) studied that whether countries with a strong
Islamic background does dampen demand for life insurance consumption. They found that Consumers in Islamic
nations purchase less life insurance policies. Brown and Kim(1993) , Ward and Zurbruegg (2002) studied the impact of
social welfare provision on life insurance demand. They concluded that the needs for individuals to make private
provision against longevity or early death via life insurance are reduced when government spending on social security
is increased. La Porta et al. (1997, 2000) and Levine (1998, 1999) studied the impact of legal and political factors on
life insurance demand. They concluded that a legal environment, which provides good investor protection tend to
encourage a higher degree of financial intermediation as well as economic growth. Hammond et. al. (1967), Drucker
(1969) and Berekson (1972) reveal that one of the main purpose of life insurance is to protect dependants against
financial hardship in the case of a wage earner's premature death. Beenstock et. al (1986), Brown and Kim (1993),
Outreville (1996) and Ward and Zurbruegg (2002) assumed that the longer people expect to live, the greater it will be
for life insurance. They find a positive relationship between life expectancy and life insurance demand. Yaari (1965)
studied the problem of uncertain lifetime and life insurance. Including the risk of dying in the life cycle model, he
concluded that an individual increases expected lifetime utility by purchasing fair life insurance and fair annuities.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The study for exploring the factors affecting the decision to purchase Insurance Products was carried out on working
women. A sample of 170 working women was taken and the questionnaire was distributed online and offline (offline
survey was done in N. Delhi, Moradabad and Varanasi). The sampling Technique was convenience sampling. The
researchers received the responses of 127 respondents, out of which, 15 questionnaires were rejected due to
ambiguous data, missing data and in some cases, to maintain accuracy of the analysis. The respondents were young
working women in the age group of 23-39 years. Type of questionnaire was structured, non-disguised and questions
were closed ended with application of Likert scale.
Insurance is a product, which often people do not buy. There is need of motivators, who motivate the individual to
purchase a particular policy. In case of working women, these motivators can be different than others. From Chart no.
1, it is very much obvious that the motivators in case of working women are mainly parents and husband, although
Insurance agents and Tax advisors also play a significant role in helping working women to decide about the insurance
products. The next question was related with the information collection after awareness and motivation to purchase the
insurance product. The result of the survey says that most of the working women (58%) even do not care to collect
some more information before actual purchase. The next question of the survey was to know the person who is paying
insurance premium of working women. The result is depicted in Chart No 2.
Chart 1: People Influencing The Purchase Chart 2: Person Who Pays The Premium
Of Insurance Policy
Insurance Agents Husband
11% 11% Any other
0%
Tax Advisor Parents
11% 11%
Parents
40%
Colleagues
3%
Siblings
7%
Self
Husband 78%
28%
Chart 3: For Whom The Premium Is Paid Graph 1: Name of the Company
Parents 72
0%
Sibling 64
17%
56
48
40
Series1
Series2
32
Husband
18% 24
16
Children
65%
8
0
LIC Bajaj Allianz Tata AIG ICICI Prudential Kotak Mahindra Aviva Life Max Newyork Life
Insurance Insurance
From the above Graph No. 1, it can be concluded that maximum number of women have invested their money in LIC
and both private players- ICICI Prudential and Max New York life insurance occupy the second place. Here, the total
no. exceeds 112, as respondents have option to tick more than one. The next question was to know the different type of
plans which are chosen by working women.
Graph 2 : Types of Insurance Plan
48
40
32
24 Series1
16
0
Children Plan Endowment Plans Money Back Unit Link Special Money Joint life Policy Any Other (Please
Plans Insurance Plans Back Policy For Mention)
Women
64
56
48
40 Series1
32
24
16
Agent 0
75% Monthly Quarterly Half Yearly Yearly
The Chart 4 clearly mentions that 75% of women paid premium through their agent from whom they have taken their
policy. There are some women (14%) who pay the premium in the offices of insurance company either themselves in
person or send someone to pay the premium in the office of insurance company. The next question was to know the
frequency of premium payment. Here, 8 respondents have marked more than one frequency as they have chosen
different frequency for payment for different policies. The result is presented in Graph 3. From the Graph 3, it is clear
that maximum number of women prefer to pay premium only once in a year. Next question was to know the annual
amount which the working women spend for insurance policies. From the Chart 5, it is obvious that 71% women pay
the annual premium of ` 10,000-30,000. The average annual Income of working women is found to be `
2,70,535.714. For this average salary, the Income tax lies between ` 10,000-30,000.
Chart 5: Annual Amount of Premium Graph 4: Objective of Insurance
More Than 50,000 Below-10,000 100
4% 11%
30,000-50,000
14%
80
60
Series1
40
20
0
10,000-30,000 Tax Saving Family Protection Children Education, Post Retirement Appreciation of Any other ( Please
71% Marriage Benefit Wealth. Specify
70 67.142
63.571
60 57.142
50.714 52.142
P er cent age
50
40 35.714
29.285
30
20
10
0
g
nt
e
er
ge
n
ce
m
e
nt
n
in
tio
ur
am
ge
ur
iu
ay
ge
ra
vi
ss
ed
et
op
em
ad
A
pl
ve
N
A
re
oc
R
lic
ut
nd
co
pr
tD
er
nc
pr
nc
e
yo
ub
iv
th
ng
ra
ra
isk
en
ra
ct
n
fa
Pa
/P
B
tio
su
yi
Ag
u
R
tra
’s
ns
pa
d/
In
ta
te
ny
At
an
en
e
fI
iva
wn
in
nc
pa
ro
sb
m
Pr
e
no
ra
m
nc
Hu
cu
de
su
Co
K
ie
Do
en
In
en
G
nv
Co
100
90 87.857
84.285
80 77.857 77.857
75.714
70
60 60.714
60 57.142
P ercentage
50
40
30
20
10
0
Attractive Risk coverage Convenience in Company’s Husband/ father Private/ Public Documentation Payout option
Return paying premium Brand Name advice player procedure
90
80
70
60
P ercentage
Customer Expectation
50
Customer Satisfaction
40
30
20
10
n
ge
er
e
e
m
n
io
ur
ic
ur
am
iu
ay
ra
pt
dv
ed
et
em
pl
ve
to
N
ra
R
oc
lic
nd
co
pr
ou
he
e
pr
ub
iv
ra
ay
ng
sk
at
ct
n
B
tio
yi
/f
Ri
P
tra
e/
pa
’s
nd
ta
At
ny
at
en
ba
in
iv
pa
m
Pr
e
s
m
Hu
cu
nc
Co
ie
Do
en
nv
Co
From the Graph 7 itself, it can be drawn that the customers are satisfied and there is no gap between expectation and
satisfaction level. To confirm it,we use Chi- square test with the null hypothesis as There is no difference in expectation
and satisfaction of working women regarding insurance services.
Table 2 : Chi-Square Test
Attributes Expectation Index Satisfaction Index
Attractive Return 75.714 75.714
Risk coverage 82.857 84.285
Convenience in paying premium 67.142 87.857
Company's Brand Name 77.142 77.857
Husband/ father advice 77.857 77.857
Private/ Public player 63.571 60
Documentation procedure 50.714 57.142
Payout option 52.142 60.714
The value of Chi- square coefficient is 8.8469. The degree of freedom for this problem is (8-1)x(2-1)= 7. For 7 degrees
of freedom, the critical value is 14.1 at 5% level of significance. That approves our null hypothesis i.e. there is no
difference in expectation and satisfaction level of working women regarding insurance.
CONCLUSION
From the above analysis, it can be easily concluded that the decision to purchase an Insurance policy is mainly affected
by the advice of Father/ Husband and even women blindly follow advice of their family without searching for more
information regarding the policies. The main objective of purchasing policies for working women is to save income
tax. Majority of the working women have invested their money in government approved LIC because they are risk
60 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
aversive. Most of the women do not even remember the name of policy they have purchased. Risk coverage,
Company's brand name and Father/ husband’s advice are the most influential attributes for the purchase of insurance
policy by them. Working women are satisfied with the attributes for which they invested their money. In fact, there is
no significant difference in their expectation and satisfaction level. Although the Insurance in India is an industry
which is almost one and a half centuries old, having begun in the 1850s with the Tital Insurance Company, the
insurance industry still has a long way to go in addressing problems related with working women.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1) Babbel, D. F. (1981) Inflation, indexation and life insurance sales in Brazil, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 48, 115-135.
2) Berekson, L. L. (1972) Birth order, anxiety, affiliation and the purchase of life insurance, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 35, 93108.
3) Browne, M. J. and Kim, K. (1993) An international analysis of life insurance demand, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 60,4, 616-634.
4) Beck, T. and I. Webb (2003) “Economic, Demographic, and Institutional Determinants of Life Insurance Consumption Across Countries”, World Bank
Economic Review, Vol. 17; pp 51-88.
5) Cargill, T. F. and T. E. Troxel (1979) “Modelling Life Insurance Savings: Some Methodological Issues”, Journal of Risk and Insurance¸ Vol. 46; pp 391-410.
6) Drucker, J. M. (1969) Expenditures for life insurance among working-wife families, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 36,525-533.
7) Enz, R. (2000) “The S-curve Relationship Between Per-Capita Income and Insurance Penetration”, Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, Vol. 25; pp 396-406.
8) Fortune, P. (1973) A theory of optimal life insurance: Development and tests, Journal of Finance, 28, 587-600.
9) Greene, M. R. (1954) Life insurance buying in inflation, Journal of the American Association of University Teachers of Insurance, 21, 99-113.
10) Hammond, J. D., Houston, D. B. and Melander, E.R. (1967) Determinants of household life insurance premium expenditure: An empirical investigation,
Journal of Risk and Insurance, 34,397-408.
11) Headen, R. S. and J. F. Lee (1974) “Life Insurance Demand and Household Portfolio Behaviour”, Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol. 41; pp 685-698.
12 Hwang, T. & Gao, S. 2003, 'The determinants of the demand for life insurance in an emerging economy: The case of China', Managerial Finance, vol 29, no. 5/6,
pp. 82-97.
13) Lim, C.C. & Haberman, S. 2004, 'Modelling life insurance demand from a macroeconomic perspective: The Malaysian case', Research paper: The 8th
International Congress on Insurance, Mathematics and Economics, Rome
14) Lewis, F. D. (1989) Dependants and the demand for life insurance, American Economic Review, 79,452-467.
15) La Porta, R., Lopez-De-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A. and Vishny, R. W. (1997) Legal determinants of external finance, Journal of Finance, 52,3, 1131-1150.
16) Levine, R., 1998, The Legal Environment, Banks, and Long-Run Economic Growth, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 30(3 part 2): 596-613.
17) Levine, R., 1999, Law, Finance, and Economic Growth, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 8(1/2): 36-67.
18) Mossin, J. (1968) “Aspects of Rational Insurance Purchasing,” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 79; pp 553-568.
19) Outreville, J. F. (1996) Life insurance markets in developing countries, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 63,2, 263-278.
20) Pratt, J. W. (1964) Risk aversion in the small and in the large, Econometrica, 32, 122-136.
21)Rubayah, Y. & Zaidi, I. 2000 'Prospective insurance', Utara Management Review, vol. 1, pp. 69-79.
22) Showers, Vince E. and Joyce A. Shotick, 1994, The Effects of Household Characteristics on Demand for Insurance: A Tobit Analysis, The Journal of Risk and
Insurance, Vol. 61, No.3, 492-502
23) Schlesinger, H. (1981) The optimal level of deductibility in insurance contracts, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 48, 465-481.
24) Szipiro, G. G. (1985) Optimal insurance coverage, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 52, 705-710.
25) Truett, D. B. and Truett, L. J. (1990) The demandfor life insurance in Mexico and the United States: A comparative study, Journal of Risk and Insurance, 57,2,
321-328.
26) Wasaw, B. and Hill, R. D. (1986) The Insurance Industry in Economic Development, New York University Press, New York.
27) Ward, D. and Zurbruegg, R. (2002) Law, politics and life insurance consumption in Asia, The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, 27,3, 395-412.
28) Yaari, M. (1965) Uncertain lifetime, life insurance and the theory of the consumer, Review of Economic Studies, 32, 137-150.
29) Xumei Zhang, Yingxiu Zhang, Hanguang Qiu, Bin Dan (2007) An Empirical Study Of The Key Factors Affecting Consumers' Purchase Decision On Life
Insurance, International Conference on Service Systems and Service Management, 2007 , page 1-5.
30) Country Insurance and Financial Services, PR Newswire, “Women Lag Behind Men on Life Insurance Coverage”, May 2007.
31) Annual MetLIfe Study of Employee Benefits, Press Release August 2008.
32) http://www.prudential.com/media/managed/2006WomenBrochure_FINAL.pdf
Payment Details:
(Outstation cheques are not accepted.Only Payable at par cheques are accepted)
Delivery Details:
Name: _______________________________________________________________________
Address:: _______________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________ ________________
____________________________________________________Pin_________________
Send Your Subscription to : Meenakshi Gilani
Subscription Manager
Indian Journal of Marketing
Y-21, Hauz Khas
New Delhi-110016
Telephone: 011-42654857, 011-32547238
Url : http://www.indianjournalofmarketing.com
Email : meenakshi.gilani@indianjournalofmarketing.com
Email : editor@indianjournalofmarketing.com
Email : priyanka.gilani@indianjournalofmarketing.com
Payment Details:
(Outstation cheques are not accepted.Only Payable at par cheques are accepted)
Delivery Details:
Name: _______________________________________________________________________
Address:: _______________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________ ________________
____________________________________________________Pin_________________
Send Your Subscription to : Meenakshi Gilani
Subscription Manager
Indian Journal of Finance
Y-21, Hauz Khas
New Delhi-110016
Telephone: 011-42654857, 011-32547238
Url : http://www.indianjournaloffinance.co.in
Email : meenakshi.gilani@indianjournaloffinance.co.in
Email : editor@indianjournaloffinance.co.in
Email : priyanka.gilani@indianjournaloffinance.co.in
Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010 63
PRABANDHAN: INDIAN JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
Payment Details:
(Outstation cheques are not accepted.Only Payable at par cheques are accepted)
Delivery Details:
Name: _______________________________________________________________________
Address:: _______________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________ ________________
____________________________________________________Pin_________________
Send Your Subscription to : Meenakshi Gilani
Subscription Manager
Indian Journal of Management
Y-21, Hauz Khas
New Delhi-110016
Telephone: 011-42654857, 011-32547238
Url : http://www.indianjournalofmanagement.com
Email : meenakshi.gilani@indianjournalofmanagement.com
Email : editor@indianjournalofmanagement.com
Email : priyanka.gilani@indianjournalofmanagement.com
64 Indian Journal of Marketing • November, 2010
GUIDELINES FOR AUTHORS
Dear Authors,
Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management are double
blind refereed journals on diverse areas of marketing, finance and management. The journals welcome original
dissertations from academicians, researchers and practitioners of marketing, finance and management. Papers
based on theoretical/empirical research and experience should satisfy good quality research and must reflect the
practical applicability/policy implications of the research.
Please adhere to the following instructions when submitting an article to Indian Journal of Marketing, Indian
Journal of Finance and Prabandhan: Indian Journal of Management.
Two or more referees review all contributions by following the double blind system-that is, with the author's name
and credentials deleted, so that the reviewers don't know who is authoring the work. The review process takes two
months and the status would be known within two months of submission of the article. It is mandatory to mention a
valid email address with content submitted online.We will acknowledge the receipt of your paper by email and an
article id will be issued to the corresponding author. The author(s) should keep in mind that it would be mandatory
to cite this id while sending a query about a paper submitted online. In the first page of the paper, please provide full
names (first, middle and last names) and full addresses (institute's address along with the designation and
correspondence address) along with the email address of the author(s).The author's name or affiliations should not
appear anywhere else in the body of the manuscript, because our peer-review process is blinded. A brief biographical
sketch of the author and an abstract of 200 words should accompany the manuscript on separate pages. The article
should mention the time period in which the research was conducted. The corresponding author should send a
signed soft copy of the Author Disclosure Form for Reviewal (The form can be downloaded from our website. It is
available on the Guidelines For Authors page). If the article is submitted by post, the hard copy must be accompanied
by one self -addressed stamped envelope. The enclosing covering letter should have the author's designation,
institution name along with a signed hard copy of the Author Disclosure Form For Reviewal. If any charges of
plagiarism come to our notice and are proven, stringent action would be taken against the offending authors.
Text Preparation: The acceptable file formats for the word processing documents are “Word for Windows 1997-2003
document”. Manuscripts must be double spaced, with 1-inch margins with “Times New Roman, Font Size 12, black”.
All tables, charts, graphs, diagrams, and images should be black and not in colour. The scanned images taken from
various sources should be redrawn in black and white format (and not pasted as they are).Wherever necessary, the
source should be indicated at the bottom. Number and complexity of such exhibits should be as low as possible. All
charts and graphs should be drawn legibly and figures should be indicated in millions and billions. Tables and figures
should contain self-explanatory titles. Please provide table(s) as real table(s) with rows, columns and cells. Each
piece of information should reside in its own cell. Please cite a table title. Footnotes, italics, and quotation marks
should be kept to the minimum. References and citations should be complete in all respects and arranged in
alphabetical order. Authors needing assistance can contact the Managing Editor, Priyanka Gilani at
priyanka.gilani@indianjournalofmrketing.com or 011-42654857, 011-32547238.
(a) Text references should appear as follows: Recent works from (xxxx, 2005, yyyy, 2006) show...
(b) Journal references should be listed as follows: Prof. T.V. RamRaj (2006),"Blog Marketing”, Indian Journal
ofMarketing,Vol36(9),3-7.
(c) Books should be referred as follows: - V. Venkata Raman, G. Somayajulu (2005),"Customer Relationship”, New
Delhi: Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Company Limited.
The final draft is subject to editorial amendments to suit the journal's requirements. An electronic version of the
manuscript in MS- Word would be required once the paper is accepted for publication. Please visit our website(s) to
submit your article online.
www.indianjournalofmarketing.com
www.indianjournaloffinance.co.in
www.indianjournalofmanagement.com
Posted on the 5th and 6th of Every Month
Published on the 1st day of Every Month
Postal Registration No. : DL-SW-16/4141/10-12
Registered with the Registrar of Newspapers under Regd. no. 16294/68
Printed and Published by Mrs. Satya Gilani on behalf of Associated Management Consultants (P) Ltd.
Y-21, Hauz Khas, New Delhi-110016 and Printed at Jagriti Offset, A-21/25, Naraina Industrial Area, Phase-II, New Delhi - 28
and Published at New Delhi. Editor : Mrs. Satya Gilani