Case: 10-55084 05/09/2011 Page: 1 of 4 ID: 7746150 DktEntry:

R I7-46tt k:
'/ *'Eë D
MOLLYc.D'//YER,CLERK
Us.COURTOFAPPEALS
CathyA.Catterson,AlexKozinski,andMollyDwyer
MAh
j
'êS20
w11
U.S.CourtsandCourtofAppealsfortheNinthCircuit SI
LED
P.O.Box193939 DOCKETED DATE .
I
NITI
AL
SanFrancisco,CA 94l19-3939
Regardi
ngcase09-56827 #
T
Uo :CathyA.Catterson,Circuit& CourtofAppealsExecutive OfficeoftheCircuitExecutive
.S.Cour tsfortheNinthCircuit
MollyDwyer,ClerkofCourt
P.O.Box193939 OflkeoftheClerk
SanFrancisco,CA 94119-3939
U.S.CourtofAppealsfortheNinthCircuit
SanFrancisco,CA 94119-3939
AlexKozinski,ChiefJudge OfficeoftheCircuitExecutive
U.S.CourtsfortheNinthCircuit Clerk'sOmce,9
P.O.Box193939 125SouthGrandAvenue
SanFrancisco,CA 94119-3939
Pasadena,CA 91105
Cc:Dr.OrlyTaitzandMr.GaryKreep,AttorneysforthePlaintiffs;
Mr.DavidDeluteandMr.RogerWest,AttorneysfortheDefendants;
Otherinterestedcitizens,groups,andentities,bothpublicandprivate.
Re:ExpressmandatesoftheUnitedStatesCode*require*aforcedconclusioninthiscase
DearOfficials,Judges,andStaffoftheNinthCircuit:
We,asAmericancitizens,knowyouwilldulyprovidecompletenoticeofthecontentshereinto
thepanelofjudgeswhowereassignedtoheartheoralargumentsonMay2andinPasadenawithin
theconstitutional-crisiscaseofWileyDrake,etalv.BarackObama,etal,DocketNo.09-56827.
Becausemandatesofexpressfederallaw*absolutelyrequire*thePlaintiffstowintheirprimary
objective(regardlessofanyargumentsraised),yotlrpanel'ssoleremainingdutiesare:torulein
theirfavoraccordingly;andtograntallreliefthatisnecessarilyessentialandsubsequentthereto
ifthepanel'srulingdoesnotcomplywiththesemandatesoflaw,thenyoucouldbecalledinto .
constitutionalethicsquestions,forfailing,ignoring,orotherwiseneglectingtorelaythesesame
commandingauthoritiestoyourownfellowemployees i
thisone-whereinseveralfederaljudgeshavealreadyr,ew vetahle
inds
tu
hc
eh
ira
tn
rehis
asot
oo
nri
ucsjc
uo
dn
ic
ti
earyt
mp is
as
nudeas
utterdisdaintbrourConstimtion,andforthePeople'sclearrighttoassurealawfulPresidency
So,then,thefollowingareamongsttheabsolutelymandatoryrequirementsoflawinplayherei .
Title44,Chapter22,oftheUnitedStatesCode,entitledastçpresidentialRecords'',clarifesandn:
mandates,interalia,that:(l1eachofthesoughtrecordsfromMr.ObamaakaSoetorohaving
probativevalueasevidencetodeterminehisconstitutionaleligibility,ornot..,totheOftkeof
PresidentisdeclaredbyexpressfederallawasaGtpresidentialrecord'';(21allsuchttpresidential
records''arenowentirelyandwhollyownedbytheUnitedStates,andnotbyMnObamaaka
Soetoroanymore;E3)nosuchGtpresidentialrecords''mayeverbeconcealedunderanyformof
privacywhatsoever;and(4)thesamerecordsarerequiredtobegeelyavailable,publicdomain.2
Thisisbecausetherepeatedstatutorykeyphrase-çthecarryingoutofconstitutional,statutory,
orotherofficialorceremonialdutiesofthePresident''-obviouslyincludesthedutyo fMr
ObamaakaSoetorotoqualifyhimselfAStheostensibly-eligiblePresident.Indeed,itisac. tually
amandatedlegaldutyofM1'.ObamaakaSoetoro,ASlçpresidenf',topersonallymakesurethat
h
frisrealbirthcertitkate,andothersuchconstitutionaleligibilitydocumentation reputintothe
eelyavailablepublicdomainuponhisveryfirstdayinassumingtheOfficeof,we thePresidency.
 Case: 10-55084 05/09/2011 Page: 2 of 4 ID: 7746150 DktEntry: 46

'
RephrasingthequestionagainstMr.ObamaakaSoetoro,itismerechild'splaytopointoutthe
oblviousstatutorymandatesoftheUnitedStatesCodeincontroloftheentirematter,e.
al ofBarack'ssamesuchrecordsofconstimtional-eligibilityimportanceareexpresslyg. n:oI
t1)that
protectedtoanyprivacy,whatsoever,44U.
ownthoserecords,anymore,because,asçprS e.
Cid.ejn2
s t2',04(c);further,that(2)Barackdoesnoteven
theyarenowownedsolelybytheUnited
States,44U.S.C.j2202;andevenfurther,that(3JBarack'sdutyunderlaw,mandated,has
alwaysbeentoensurethosesamerecordsaremadepublicdomainandfreelyavailableforthe
dailyreviewingbyanycitizen,see44U.S.C.jû22034a)and2204(c),t
Ironicallyalso,bytheveryoperationanddirecteFectofthesestatutes,h en5U.S.C.b552.
thereforenecessarilyhasnoIegalbasesorclaimsorinterestsorrights,wha.tOb Mr amaakaSoetoro
soever,tocontinue
concealingitpresidentialrecords''whichnowbelongonlyto&WenePeople',untilhewould
tirstprovehisownauthenticU.S.citizenshipofanylevel,therebyestablishingacitizenportion
oflegalownershiptosuchrecords-byftrstrevealingthesamerecordsasproofofcitizenship
Thisisaclassict1Catch-22'',ofcourse,but,infact,theentireworldwidetopicof*where*Mr...
O
inb amaakaSoetorowasbornbecomesinstantlyandlegallyirrelevantandmootintheface f.the
disputablefactthathesimplycanneverbeconstitutionallyeligibleasavalidHpresident''o under
thetlnaturalbcrn''clause,becauseeneparent(hisdaddy)neverhadU.S.citizenshipofanylevel
Toactasafederaljudgewithenoughlegalknowledgetoobtainoneofthehigherpositionsupon.
anyCircuitCourtofAppeals,yetbehaveasifwithoutunderstandingregardingthe:naturalborn'
clauseasitrelatestorequiringtwo(2)citizenparents,istoalsoconclusivelyrevealfartoomuch
incompetenceanddisdainforthelaw,toremaininsuchanimportantpositionofthepublictrust
lTihethree(3)diferentlevelsofU.S.citizenshipareestablished.Theyincludeçtnaturalborrp', .
nativebonf'andRnamralized''citizens.Forexample,StanleyAnnte)Dunham/soetoro,the
motherofMr> .ObamaakaSoetoro,wasoriginallyafull4çnaturalborn''citizen rsel:bei
conceivedbytwoexistingU.S.citizens(herparents)whowerealsobothstillU,.She ng
birth.lnfullcontrast,thefatherofMr.ObamaakaSoetoro,BarackSr.,wasneveraU.S.citt .citiz e
n sa her
ofanylevel,whatsoever,astheworldknows.Asadirectconsequence,Mr.ObamaakaSoetoe iz n
himself,i.e.,thecurrently-sittingttpresident''canneverbetçnaturalborn''asisconstitutionally , r
o
requiredforPresidency,butonlyGnativeborn''orçtnaturalized''assecondorthirdbestIevelsof
U.S.citizenship.Thesecondarylevel,Knativeborlf',iswhatthebirthcertitkateissueisall
a
bb out,asifborninHawaii,Obamawouldbeatleasttlnativeborn''onU.S.soil(i
bue e nbackonU.S.soilforatleast6monthspriortobirth,whichsheapparentlyhf a
d
mommyhad
notbeen..),
tstillneverRnaturalbonf',again,becausedaddywasnot*also#aU.S.citizenbef
birth,andneverwas,asisadmittedbyeveryone.EvenEtnativeborlp',Mr.Obamaakoare Barry's
Soetoro
wouldhavestillautomaticallylosthisany(doubtful)citizenshipwiththeU.S.,whenhis3
mommytookhimtoforeignIandsthatwereonourStateDepartment'sno-noIists,andenrolled
littleBarl. yasanew*citizen*thereinordertoattendtheirschools,suchaswhentheylivedin
Indonesia.ReturningtotheU.S. later,hismommy*might*havet riedtogetthemboth
linaturalized''asimmigrantsorreturningex-citizensobtaining/re-obtainingtheirU.S.citizenship,
butdidshedothateachtimetheylehforforeignlandsandlatercameback?Thisisproblematic
atbest.Furthermore,laterinIifeasayoungadult,Mr.ObamaakaSoetofohim/elftpokuphis
ownresidenciesinthesamemanner,againstourStateDepartment'srulesineffectatthetime
IikewhenhelivedinPakistan,etc.Onceagain,havingautomaticallyhadhisanyexisting ,
(doubtful)citizenshipcancelledeachtime,anyreturnbacktolivingintheUnitedStatesagain
wouldnecessitatere-initializingtheunaturalization''orftre-namralization''levelofcitizenship
becausehisanytrueRnativeborn''levelofU.S.ci ,
longgoneIost,anyway,whenBarryandmommyt kiezpentship
mo vi(nth
ge
bR
al
c-
l
kaw
anadiifboirrtthhaorron
uo
nt
d'
'ti
hss
euwo
e)w as
rld
tobadplaces.ltisseriouslydoubtfulthatMr.ObamaakaSoetorohasany*valid*naturalization
status,whichistheONLYpossiblecitizenshipIevelheCOULDhaveleûnow(the3rdlevel),
sincehisanynativeborn(2ndlevel)isautomaticallylonggonelost nd-tothesimplestpoint-
heneverevenhadtherequired1stlevelofcitizenship,unaturalborr,pa ',tobelawfulPresident,in
thefirstplace,becausedaddywasnever*also*aU.S.citizen,andals oaU.S.citizenbeforelittle
Barrywasborn...whereverObamawasborm Mr.ObamaakaSoetorois*not*alawfulU.S.
President,andneverwas.Thereisabsolutelynopossiblewayheevercouldbelegallyvalid.
Thelawonthiscriticalsubjectisfartoowellestablished,forliterallyhundredsofyearsnow,
andinmultipleformatsalIapplyingdirectlytotheultimateandinevitableconclusion- without
 Case: 10-55084 05/09/2011 Page: 3 of 4 ID: 7746150 DktEntry: 46

'
J*
.
havingb0thefhisparentsasU.S.ci
Mr.ObamaakaSoetorosimplyisnoti tzens(ofanycitizenshiplevel),andthataspriortohisbirth,
,a ndneverwas,lawfullyeligiblefortheU.S.Presidency,
a
availableundertheConstitution,andrepp
n d m ust be rem ove dfr
om O mc e ,as ex edientlyaspossi blebyatleastoneofthel
lacedwlththemostproperly-eligiblepersonunderlaw
egalmethods
Heck,evenyourownonlineNinthCircuitwebsitettvacancyAnnouncements''foremployment.
ofcourtpersonnelincludethesestandardconditionsofallemploymentroles(emphasisadded):
' CONDI TIONSOFEMPLOYMENT
MustbeaU.S.citizenoracitizenofacountrywithadefensetreatywith
theU.S.whoiseligibletoworkintheU.S.PositionswiththeU.S.Courts
areexceptedserviceappointments.Exceptedserviceappointmentsareat
willandcanbeterminatedwithorwithoutcausebytheCourt.Employees
willbehiredprovisionallypendingtheresultsofabackvound
investigationandGngerprinting,andaresubjectt oaprobationaryperiod.
Directdepositofpayrequired.
ltdoesn'tmatterthatRpresident''ChesterA.Art hurgotawaywiththisexactsamefraudovera
hundredyearsago,whenhisownfatherwasstillnotaU.S.citizenatthetimeofChester'sbirth
(Chester'sfathergotGnaturalized''afterChester'sbirth,andChvsteralsoallowedand/orhelped.
histo
ma tewn ltbirther''issuetodistractfromthetrueissue- lackofKnaturalborn''status heonl
rofimportancerelevanttothatpriorexperience,now,isthat,obviously,thee.n)tiT reF e d
e
yal
r
GovernmenthasmiserablyfailedtheAmericanpeopleagain,andshouldprobablybeheldliable
Moreover,knowledgeableAmericancitizensaretiredofthetreasonousfraudbeingcommitted .
b
Py theU.S.DepartmentofJusticeattorneysdefendingMr.ObamaakaSoetoroinallthesecases
ursuanttofurtherexpressly-writtenmandatesoffederalstatutes,neitherMr.EricHolder,the .4
currentUnitedStatesAttorneyGeneral,noranyofhi sUS
a
Sn cl/orHU.S.AssistantAttorneys'')areeverallowedto eve/nDO coJnsst
ia
df
ef
radt
to
e fr
en
ne
dyinsgCU Mr .S.Attorneys''
oetorointhesesimations.ltisanabsolutelypreposterousandoutrageouslycrimin.aOb lcaoma
ntlia
ck
taof
i n t e r
Underalltest f
o r an yo fthesepeople t
o actu ally try tod efe nd h i
m in th ese ma tter
s
herelevantstatutesoftheUnitedStatesCodepertainingtoanyof,ta hteap noystsi
ime
ble,teev
rer.
ms
involved7i.e.,tç oath''Rnaturalization'''tçloyalty''*ççeligibility''>ttcitizenship''>ç4nationality'';and
etc.,theU.S.Attorne> yGeneralandhisU.S.DOJstaffofattorneysmustavoidrepresentationin
d
oe nfeenofse
thf
osrean
o sj
lmiglo
av
re
tr
en
rm
me
sn
,toemc
pr ia
cise lo
lybree
cmaupsl
eoy
the
ee
ywahro
ei s
ree
qmubirreo
dil
bedlb
y ay
wle ga
to *l
ii
nsvseusets
igf atl
a li
e *ng
anudnder
*prosecute*againstanysuchpeopleonU.S.soilwithraisedissuesofpotentialaliennationality
orillegalimmigation.See,manyindividualfederalsututeslike8U.S. C.jll03andetc.,but
generallythewholeofChapters12ClmmigrationandNationalit/')and13Clmmigrationand
NaturalizationService'')underTitle8oftheU.S.Code,rememberingthatthisentireINSagency
i
Isasub-componentoftheU.S.DepartmentofJustice,alawenforcementagency Ste,891551.
nparticular,Mr.EricHolderandhisUS/DOJstafhave*always*been- eversi.nc ethevarious
%çeligibility''caseshadfirstoriginated-absolutelydutyboundtostartacriminalinvestigation
a
bgea instEçpresident''Obamaregardingtheseissues ursuantt
causenotonlyistheUS/DOJinchargeofkand,rp esponsibloeo
efxrpressmandateof28USCj59l,
issueswithinAmericaanditsvariouspoliticaloftkes,but,inhav,inth eseimmigrgtioplfùreigner
gmultitudesofdirectIegal
documentation/evidenceserveduponthem-multipletimes,bymultipletçbirther''attorneys,in
thedirectduecourseofmultiplelegalproceedings-Mr.EricHolder,alongwithlttheusual
suspects''(asmallgroupofthesameUSAttorneyswhohavebeenroutinelydefendingObama
overandoverinthesedifferenteligibilitycases),arealsoeachalreadyandintimatelyfamiliar
withthesheermountainoffraudinvolvedbyObama i.e.,theyknowthatMr.Obamaaka
SoetoroiscurrentlyengagedinmultipleformsofOb,structionofJustice-wellmorethanenough
t
Nootriggertheexpressmandateof28USCj591tocrhninallyinvestigatehim..NOTdefendhim!
tonlyshouldthepanelofthisCourtsuaspontestrikeallpleadingsandoth.e rtilingsmadeby
theUS/DOJattorneysfromtherecordonappeal,andgiveSummaryJudgmenttothePlaintiffsat
b
ino
tt
eh
reletvaenls
s do
afporo
ls ac
fe
fie
rdinj
ma tls
v,
ei
t
yaa
l ls
so
siag
lp
stne
ga
rs,.thatfromcol
Mr nmi ttingsuchonerousconfli ctsof
ObamaakaSoetoroincontinuingtodefraudallof
America,thateitherAttorneyGeneralEricHolder,hi
attorneysherein,arenowalsosubjecttoimmediaterems moevlt
allafn
rodm
/orth
ae
ls
io
rothe
ses
ft
kesameGovernment
provisionsof28U.S.C.jj528,5308and547.neywere*required*toprose,cpuutr es uanttothe
,notde fend!!
 Case: 10-55084 05/09/2011 Page: 4 of 4 ID: 7746150 DktEntry: 46

Next,anyttmere''citizenhasexpressly-providedjurisdictionANDstandingtodirtctlysueover
thesematters,undervarietyofstatutoryauthority,e.g.,2U.S.C.j437h,5U.S.C.jj702&706,
26U.S.C.j90l1,42U.S.C.jl973gg-9andetc.Jurisdictionandtçmere''citizenstandingcanbe
#also*achievedthroughfoundationalConstitutionalauthority,e.g.,usingArt.IV,Sec.2,Clause
l(equalprivilegesandimmunitiesofcitizens),and/orArt.lV,Sec.4(guaranteedformof
governmentliand/orArt.VI,Clause3(PresidentrequiredtosupportConstitutionbyoathor
affirmation),Amend.I(petitionforredress),Amend.IX(nodenyingrightsofpeople),Amend.
X(powersreservedtopeople),and/orAmend.XIV,Sec.l(nodenyingequalprotectionoflaw).5
lnreversesummary,therefore,theseareamongthemandatedresultsofexpressly-writtenfederal
statutesinANYandALLoftheeligibilitycasesouttherefiledagainstMnObamaakaSoetoro:
.An
yilmere''citizenhasnotjustone,but,infact,multiplestatutoryauthoritiestoprovide
himorherwithclearjurisdictionandstandingovertheseissues,inonewayoranother;
.Fromtheveryfirst4teligibility''casefiledintothefederalcourtsystem,AttorneyGeneral
EricHolderandhiscrewofUS/DOJAtt orneyswere*required*toprosecuteMr.Obama
akaSoetoro,and*never*allowedtodefendhlm,ever-AlloftheirpleadingsinalIof
thesemanycasesare*required*tobestrickenfromtherecords,butwecanskipthat,if
'
theywill
.ThePl
justDOtheirmandatedjobs,now,andinitiatethecriminalprosecutionts);
aintiffsareabsolutelyentitled,asamatteroflaw,toobtainthevariousrecordsthat
theyseekfordisclosurefrom Mr.ObamaakaSoetorotoeitherproveordisprovehisany
eligibilityforthePresidency-Notonlyaretheyentitledtoanoutstanding,tçlandslide''
SummaryJudgmentintheirfavor,anyway,buttheseçtpresidentialRecords''arerequired
tobepublicdomain,regardless,already,anditwas/isObama'sjobtoensurethatisdone;
.EventhoughPlaintiffsareabsolutelyentitledtooneoftheirprimaryobjectives,whichis
obtainingallthoserecordstofinallyprovetheactualplaceofbirth,ALLofthatisSTILL
t otallyirrelevant,intheend,becauseofhigher,clear-cuttçnaturalborn''requirements;
.Be causeMr.ObamaakaSoetoroneverhadBOTHofhisparentsas(anylevelot)U.S.
citizens,hecannotIegallyhaveeverbeen,andcertainlyisnot,a*valid*President;and,
.Acc ordingly,Mr.ObamaakaSoetoroabsolutelymust,byIaw,beremovedfrom Office.
We,asAmericancitizens,arenauseatedbyseeingallthreeBranchesofourFederalGovernment
actuallytçrunningcover''intheIargestconspiracyofmoderntimes,todefraudtheentireworld
byt
Ho rea
wevseo
rn
,ous,
we asyond
ls ui
nc
da
te
ersp
tar
o
nt
det
c
ht
i
ao
tn
tsorf
he ea
no
maybv
bi
eousl
undy
u-
i
nie
e nl
i
t
lgui
b
enl
e
ceIm
sj
lno
vs
ot
o
lvr
ei
dn.
si
degoaurr
Re dWh
lessi
tehHouse.
,t ough,
itishightimefortheJudiciaryBranchtoshowalittlebackboneagainsttheotherBranches,and
standupfortheobvioustruthofthings,thatmuchofAmericaalsoseespainfullywell.Itistime
fortheJudiciaryBranchtoregainahealthyamountofenergizingrespectithaslostinpastyears,
anditistimeforMembersoftheJudiciaryBranchtogivetheConstitutionbacktotheirchildren.
Removingthefauxçpresident'shouldpresentnofearwhenthereplacementsolutionsareguided
bylaw,itself.Becausethelanguageofthe12
th
Amendmentnecessarilyprovidesactualseparate
electioncampaignsbyPresidentialandVice-presidentialcandidates,orelsethevariousldistinct'
phrasesbecomepointlessandmeritless(fortherewouldneverbeanyneedforflcountingrules''
todistinguishbetweenvotetotalsthatwerealwaysthesameforbothRrunningmates''),itismost
reasonablylikelythatSarahPalinwouldhave,infact,wontheVice-presidencyonherownover
Biden'sanycompetingcampaign,andthatshewouldnowbethecurrentlysittingVice-president
alongsideMr.ObamaakaSoetoro.WhetherPalinorBidenshouldt4best''betherenow,Speaker
BoehneradvancesbehindasnewVice-president.Intheonlyalternative,the12
th
Amendment
shouldbestruckdownforpervertingtheoriginal,protkablere-blendingoftwopartiesintoour
WhiteHouse,everyfouryears,intothependulumsystemswingingourNationevenfurtherand
furtherapart,everyfolzryears.lnthatsolution,teoriginalselectionprocessyieldsMccainand
Nader,asnexttopvote-getterzs'
f
o omePrsidentandVice-president.Chooseonesolution.
,'
. I
Signed: .wen llardJf Dated:05/05/2011