Professional Documents
Culture Documents
70 yo Normal
72 yo MCI
74 yo AD
Cognitive Continuum
Normal
Alzheimer's Disease
CP926864- 35
MEMORY COMPLAINT MEMORY IMPAIRED FOR AGE NORMAL GENERAL COGNITIVE FUNCTION NORMAL ACTIVITIES OF DAILY LIVING NOT DEMENTED
Control AD 1-2%/yr
100 90 80 70 60 50 Initial 12 exam 24 36 Months 48
CP926864- 12
STUDY DESIGN-ADNI1
MCI (n= 400): 0, 6, 12, 18, 24, 36 months AD (n= 200): 0, 6, 12, 24 months Controls (n= 200): 0, 6, 12, 24, 36 months Clinical/neuropsychological evaluations, MRI (1.5 T) at all time points FDG PET at all time points in 50% 3 T MRI at all time points in 25% PIB sub-study on 120 subjects Blood and urine at all time points from all subjects; CSF from 50% of subjects 0, 1 yr, 2 yr (subset); DNA and immortalized cell lines from all subjects GWAS study
Private/Philanthropic + Public
ADNI Executive Steering Committee
PET Core: Berkeley: Jagust MRI Core: Mayo: Jack Clinical Core: UCSD: Aisen Mayo: Petersen
FDA
NIBIB and other ICs
Our goal: Standardization of image qualities (CNR, spatial resolution, resistance to artifact, reliability) across sites/platforms, and consistency across time in the face of ongoing upgrades Site equipment survey determine technical specifications for each potential scanner in the study, select optimum scanner at each site Create a generic, non-platform specific MRI protocol Organize vendor support With vendor support, create a platform specific protocol for each scanner 91 scanners, 48 distinct compiled versions of the ADNI protocol Deliver protocol to each scanner electronically, not manual creation Create an ADNI MRI procedures manual and deliver to sites Phone/email training of MRI site personnel by ADNI MR tech Site certification phantom and human volunteer scans
Recertification of scanners after upgrades (79 scanners re- certified to date, some numerous times) Hands-on trouble shooting by ADNI technical personal (ie MR physicist, MR tech, radiologist) QA of images: visual + electronic inspection in 3 areas protocol compliance electronically check every relevant MRI parameter against the master protocol for that system for each image acquired in the study, also identify scanner upgrades that were not reported by sites Visual inspection and rating of image quality request patient re scan if necessary Identify medical abnormalities for inclusion/exclusion as well as medical care purposes
MRI PHANTOM
ADNI1 Demographics
Normal controls (n=229)
Age, mean (SD) Female (%) Years of education, mean (SD) Apolipoprotein E e4: Positive (%) 76.4 (5.0) 48.0 15.6 (3.1)
MCI (n=398)
75.3 (7.5) 35.4 16.0 (2.9)
AD (n=192)
75.8 (7.4) 47.4 14.7 (3.1)
26.6
53.5
65.6
<0.001
CP1307278-1
Subject Evaluation
Baseline/screening eval and q 6 mo.
Labs, Apo E Hamilton(S) Beck MMSE ANART ADAS-cog NPI CDR ADL
ADAS Cog 11
3003731-7
MMSE
3003731-9
+2%
Diagnosed as NC
-2%
Lateral View
Medial View
Holland et al.
P<0.001
P<0.001
Kewei Chen, Ph.D., Eric M. Reiman, M.D. Banner Alzheimer's Institute Translational Genomics Research Institute University of Arizona Arizona Alzheimers Consortium Phoenix, Arizona, USA
P<0.001
MCI
PIB Imaging:
Chet Mathis
FDG
PIB
2.5
1.5
Normals MCI AD 9/19 (47%) 47/63 (68%)17/19 (89%) PIB+ PIB+ PIB+
18 3 47
Converters to AD 21
Rowe et al
HC (n=106) MCI (n=65)
PiB-ve Subjects:
Converters to naMCI
74
2 (3%)
PiB-ve Subjects:
Converters to AD: Converters to DLB: Converters to FTD:
20
1 2 1 1 45 32 (5%) (10%) (5%) (5%)
PiB+ve Subjects:
Converters to MCI/AD
32
8 (25%)
(71%)
PiB(-)
10
Converters to MCI 0
PiB(+) 9
Converters to MCI 2
Total Tau, p-Tau181p and Ab1-42 in CSF of ADNI subjects at Baseline using a bioanalytically validated xMAP Luminex immunoassay system and Innogenetics immunoassay reagents
Clinical Core Leslie M Shaw, John Trojanowski University of Pennsylvania Medical Center
ADNI BASELINE CSF biomarker concentrations show the expected average differences between AD and MCI and NC
AD (n=102)
MeanSD
Tau
12258
Ab1-42
14341
MCI (n=200)
MeanSD
10361
16455
3518
0.80.6
0.30.2
NC (n=114)
MeanSD
7030
20655
2515
0.40.3
0.10.1
p<0.0001, for each of the 5 biomarker tests for AD vs NC and for MCI vs NC. For AD vs MCI:p<0.005, Tau; p<0.01, Ab1-42; p<0.01, P-Tau 181P; p<0.0005, Tau/Ab1-42; p<0.005, PTau 181P/Ab1-42. Mann-Whitney test for statistical differences used for these non-normally distributed data sets.
ADNI baseline visit CSF biomarkers-general statistics separated by APO E4+/concentration (pg/mL) ratio
group ( apo E genotype) AD4+ (n=70) AD4-(n=30) Normal distribution (4+, 4-) p value
**p value calculated using Mann-Whitney test for each biomarker in each study group, segregated by APO E4, except for the one instance for which both 4+ & 4- subgroups were both normally distributed. Each value in the table is the mean + SD for the respective biomarker concentration in CSF.
CSF biomarker cutpoints established using CSFs collected from ADNI-independent autopsy-based AD and age-matched cognitively normal
subjects
Tau
ROC AUC Threshold values Sensitivity (%) Specificity (%) Test accuracy (%)
Positive predictive value (%) Negative predictive value (%)
Ab1-42
0.913 192 ng/mL 6.4 76.9 87.0 81.8
pTau181p
0.753 23 ng/mL 67.9 73.1 73.1 67.9
73.8
95.2
70.4
84.6
88.1
100
Ab1-42 concentrations in CSF, collected at the baseline visit, of 37 ADNI MCI subjects who at their one year visit converted to a diagnosis of probable AD. The data points for the MCIAD converters are presented as a horizontal dot plot with the x axis scale identical to that of the Ab1-42 frequency plot for the entire ADNI MCI group. The vertical line indicates the Ab1-42 cutoff concentration obtained from ROC analysis of an ADNI-independent cohort of autopsy-based AD subjects CSF.
250
Control
CSF Ab 1-42
200
150
100
Hippocampal atrophy rates (L+R) free surfer data in ADNI subjects with CSF Ab1-42 >192 pg/mL or <192 pg/mL Hippocampal % atrophy rates (BL12 mos), for ADNI subjects with Ab1-42< 192 or >192 pg/mL
Ab1-42 <192pg/mL Ab1-42 >192pg/mL
ALL AD MCI NC
-5.64.7
-8.05.9 -4.83.6 -3.63.2
-2.64.1
-4.23.5 -2.93.7 -2.24.3
These data show that in ADNI AD, MCI and NC subjects the rate of hippocampal atrophy increases at a significantly higher rate in subjects with Ab1-42 <192 pg/mL cutoff concentration compared to those >192 pg/mL
Feb-09; N. Schuff
Lab Alexander
SS/arm 334
Dale
Schuff - FS Dale Dale
Whole Brain
Hippocampus Ventricles Hippocampus Ventricles CV - % change VBSI % change
207
201 132 126 119 106 105
Studholme
Schuff - FS Studhome Fox
Fox
Thompson
BSI % change
CV - % change
71
54
45
ADNI Genotyping
Initial goal: high density genome wide scan Identified major microarray platforms for GWAS Compared marker selection strategies, HapMap coverage of genome, performance & reliability, as well as cost/sample Illumina platform was selected by consensus of the Genetics Committee & ISAB for this project TGen (Phoenix, AZ) was selected to perform the assays Illumina Human 610-Quad
GWAS of candidate QT
Structural MRI + 600k SNPs = GRIN2b as Novel Risk Factor for MTL deficits in Alzheimers
Stein et al 2010; ADNI
Continue to follow all EMCI, LMCI and NC from ADNI 1 and ADNI GO for 5 more years Enroll:
100 additional EMCI (supplements 200 from GO) 150 new controls, LMCI, and AD
3T MRI at 3, 6, months and annually F18 amyloid (AV-45)/FDG every other year LP on 100% of subjects at enrollment Genetics
Normal
MCI
AD
0.5 CDR
1
3004153-1
EMCI have milder memor dysfunction than LMCI approximately 0.5-1.5 SD below the mean for CN. They are CDR 0.5 as are LMCI. LMCI were 1.5 SD below the mean for memo function.
3 5 9 No
2 4 8
2 4 8
No Yes
* Ron Petersen
FDG-PET
MRI hipp
Fxn
The eMCI group: selected to be intermediate between NC and later MCI, at baseline.
Baseline eMCI yellow is intermediate in ADAS-Cog between NC (green) and MCI (blue).
Also intermediate in complete cortical florbetapir index; considerable heterogeneity in all groups except perhaps AD (red).
Volumetric summaries and FDG-PET measures show eMCI more like NC at baseline.
ECog Memory
4
Self Partner
0 CN EMCI LMCI AD
New functional measure: everyday cognitive function (ECog). Can be self-reported or informant-reported (better!)
Frequency
89/212
42% positive
1.11 threshold
ADNI Data processed with freesurfer & whole cerebellum reference
51/64 80% positive
AD (n=53)
MCI (n=78)
eMCI (n=150)
P-value
e-14
AD (n=53)
MCI (n=78)
eMCI (n=150)
0.05
e-16
0.05
P-value
e-4
Ab1-42
t-tau
(pg/mL)
p-tau181
(pg/mL)
t-tau/Ab1-42
p-tau/Ab1-42
Normal
(107)
23371
7334
41.320
0.370.27
0.210.15
EMCI
(192)
23172*
8153**
44.428** *
0.450.49* ***
0.240.22**** *
LMCI
(66)
18168
10355
63.840
0.680.45
0.420.31
AD
(25)
* Ab1-42:
15152
13459
70.133
0.970.49
0.540.33
p<0.000001 vs AD; p<0.00001 vs LMCI, p=0.83 vs NL. ** t-tau: p<0.000005 vs AD, p<0.005 vs LMCI, p=0.86 vs NL. ***p-tau181:p<0.0005 vs AD, p<0.00005 vs LMCI; p=0.91 vs NL. **** t-tau/ Ab1-42: p<0.0000001 vs AD, p<0.00005 vs LMCI, p=0.99 vs NL *****p-tau / Ab : p< 0.00005 vs AD, p<0.000001 vs LMCI; p=0.96 vs NL.
Baseline ADAScog results in ADNI subjects with CSF Ab1-42 >192 pg/mL or <192 pg/mL
Baseline ADAScog results for ADNI subjects (meanSD) with Ab1-42 <192 pg/mL or >192 pg/mLAb1-42 Ab
1-42
<192pg/m L
>192pg/m L
ALL
n=385
NC
n=106
EMCI
n=190
LMCI
n=65
AD
n=24
Baseline AV45 SUVR results in ADNI subjects with CSF Ab1-42 >192 pg/mL or <192 pg/mL SUVR Baseline AV45
results for ADNI subjects (meanSD) with Ab1-42 <192 pg/mL or >192 Abpg/mLAb
1-42 1-42
<192pg/m >192pg/m L L
ALL
n=246
NC
n=53
EMCI
n=148
LMCI
n=32
AD
n=13
NC Spearmans r=-0.74
AV45 SUVR
Spearmans r=-0.73
AV45 SUVR
Ab1-42, pg/mL
Ab1-42, pg/mL
1.28 SUVR cutpoint as described by Landau and Jagust (ADNI web site)
EMCI to LMCI
1.0 strata ApoE=e4+ ApoE=e4
0.8
p = 0.001 Probability
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0
Years
ApoE=e4 ApoE=e4+
142 139 91 82 79 57
59 29
53 21
39 17
36 12
27 6
18 4
6 0
2 0
Numbers at risk
Standardization: imaging, biomarkers Neuroscience: relationships among biomarker trajectories elucidate neurobiology Trials: new understanding of biomarkers has facilitated interventional studies in very early AD Data sharing: ADNI has demonstrated the power of real-time public data sharing Collaboration: academia, industry, non-profits, regulatory agencies world-wide
9/2009 N. Schuff
http://www.adni-info.org http://www.loni.ucla.edu/ADNI
World-Wide Standardization
Alzheimers Association efforts to standardize CSF and hippocampal volume measures
CAMD
Utilization of ADNI data to develop documents to qualify CSF and MRI measures for regulatory purposes to FDA and EMA for enrolling subjects at high risk
http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/napa/
NAPA Goals 1. Prevent and effectively treat Alzheimers disease by 2025 2. Optimize care quality and efficiency 3. Expand patient and family support 4. Enhance public awareness and engagement 5. Track progress and drive improvement
28
176
2008
2009
140,000 images archived (raw and processed) 1.2 million image downloads 90,000 downloads of non-image data (clinical, genetic, proteomic, summary) from 36 countries
ADNI Manuscripts
504 manuscripts utilized ADNI data
Published Epub ahead of print In Press Under revision In submission 274 16 8 2 191
11 2
Reasons authors cited for not submitting manuscripts for review: Didnt submit this time, but will in the future (19) Forgot to submit, but have since (3) No response (8) Author reported paper to us after publication (5)