1

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
prove strict compliance =ith all re@uirements *or summary proceeding: as omission o* re@uired act o*
service is *atal to plenary"
7/C1#
" !arlier today% on 3cto>er )'th% )-) Coughlin su>mitted *or *iling% essentially% a duplicate o* this
*iling =hich% un*ortunately% upon *urther revie=% contained a signature that =as not close enough to the
signature line% argua>ly% to >e e**ective" 1here*ore% a correction has >een made in that regard% placing the
signatures in a more appropriate setting in relation to the signature line" 1he only other change involves the
*ollo=ing paragraph% =ith the additional materila in >old:
On February 27th, 2012, while awaiting trial before 1udge Nash Holmes in 11 TR
26800, and in a private meeting with Reno City Attorney Allison Ormaas in one of the private
conference/meeting rooms outside the interior doors to the court room, RMC Marshal Harley
entered the room and purported to personally serve Coughlin a document in the appeal of the
eviction from Coughlin's former home law office, in CV11-03628, apparently at the direction of
Richard G. Hill, Esq., on behalf of his client Merliss (the landlord, whom all three of the appointed
defenders provided by the RMC to Coughlin refused to subpoena, apparently because it would cut
into their $7K fee from the RMC and because of an apparent desire to torpedo Coughlin's defense,
despite Merliss being a material witness. Further, it is believed OFficer Carter and Sargent Lopez
were subpoened by the City, and perhaps by Coughlin, though a continuance was denied upon their
faling to appear). Washoe County Sheriff's Deputy 1ohn Machen filed a false Affidavit of Service on
November 7th, 2011, in R1C Rev2011-001708 alleging to have "personally served" Coughlin at the
time the WCSO's Deputy Machen effectuated the lockout on November 1st, 2011 at 4:30 pm (by
which time the ORders of October 25th and October 27th, 2011 made exhibits in this Trial by the
City had become stale, invalid, perhaps void, etc. given, as admitted to, apparently, by both the
- 2/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
R1C's Chief Civil Clerk/Supervisor Karen Stancil (to be clear, I mean this only to the extent that Ms.
Stancil has represented to the undersigned the "usual custom and practice" of the R1C is to fax over
Orders such as those mentioned above to the WCSO the day they are file stamped, or at the latest by
the next day...plus Baker testified, apprently to receipt of the ORder by the WCSO on October 28th,
2011...all making the WCSO's "receipt" of the Orders outside the statutorily dictate that the lockout
occur "within 24 hours" thereof under NRS 40.253. Regardless, back to RMC Marshal Harley
(whom RMC 1udge Nash Holmes, in her March 12, 2012 rendition of some Order finding Coughlin
guilty of every RPD in the book, incident to a traffic citation matter tha 1udge Nash Holmes had
transmogrified into a hearing before the NNDB, apparently (see In Re Kunstler), 1udge Nash Holmes
alleged that Marshal Harley, apparently, followed Coughlin into the bathroom during the restroom
break just prior to 1udge Nash Holmes incarcerating Coughlin, whereup Harley apparently played
peeping tom on Coughlin the bathroom stall and averred to 1udge Nash Homes that Coughlin
"dissassembled his smart phone" (Martin Crowley is laughing somewhere)...the thing is, "summary
contempt" (even "misdemeanor summary criminal contempt", ie, some law 1udge Nash Holmes
appears to have legislated on the spot, and which does not require her to comply with the dictates of
NRS 189.010-060, as she refuses to transmit the record and order the production o the transcript
(and its illegal for the RMC to force criminal indigents to pay Pam Longoni, and only Pam Longoni,
ANYTHING, up front, in some application of a civil statute related thereto. Regardless, 1udge Nash
Holmes "summary criminal contempt" Orders relies upon allegations of conduct allegedly
committed OUTSIDE the presence of the Court, so whichever Marshal went playing peepin' Tom on
Coughlin in a restroom stall needs to sign their name on an Affidavit and stand behind it like a
grown up rather than right some insipid letter to the State Bar of Nevada criticizing Coughlin's
fashion sense, then proceeding to lie and lie and lie about Coughlin whilst also demonstrating a
- 3/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
distrubing extent to which the City of Reno Marshals behave as a coordinated crew of intimidators
and coerces towards the citizens of Reno attempting to access justice, and to which these Marshals
themselves obstruct justice on a regular basis. Right in line with that behavior was that
demonstrated by RMC Marshal Harley in barging into a plea bargaining session between City
Attorney Ormaas and Coughlin and undertaking the legally questionable task (but certainly an
intimidating, coercive, and inappropriate action by Harley) of "personally serving" Coughlin and
ORder to Show Cause in CV11-03628 (despite Coughlin already having been served it via his
electronic filer status, something Richard HIll and Casey Baker, ESq. knew full well) . Harley
personally served Coughlin some document, then WCSO Machen filed an Affidavit of Service on 3 8
12 saying he himself personally served Coughlin. The RMC puts peopel in jail for less than that
every single day. Then Harley got real uncomfortable with Coughlin asking him questions related to
the propriety of what Harley just did. Then Harley starts whispering in City Attorne Ormaas's ear
during the trial in 11 TR 26800, held after that on the same day, despite the RMC, apparently, in
light of 1udge Nash Holmes March 14, 2012 letter/grievance against Coughlin to the SBN indications
therein, being aware that an Order For Competency Evaluation of Coughlin was entered at 1:31pm
on 2/27/12 in RCR2012-065630, as 1udge Nash Holmes admits to communications with the WCPD
regarding Coughlin. The RMC Marshals, especially Marshal Menzel like to bark menacingly at
defendnats that they have to sign some acceptance of service or waiver of service of various
documents in some apparent effort to cost cut postage expenses of the RMC in affording others due
process. But worse than that is Marshal Harley taking it upon himself to personally serve Coughlin
documents on behalf of Richard G. HIll, Esq. especially where RPD Sargent Tarter came to testify
that day about the 3 traffic citations he issued for Hill against Coughlin, and Tarter put his feet up on
Judge Nash Holmes bench (ie, where the Judge might set her gavel) while the RMC staff served
- 4/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Sargent Tarter bottled water. Avoding an appearance of impartiality or impropriety is a cannon or
something, some might say. This is true especially incident to a trial appearance related to 3
retaliatory traffic citations issued by the RPD after they told Coughlin to leave the sidewalk near
Hill's law Office, and where 1udge Nash Holmes told Coughlin she would "put you in jail if you say
Richard HIll's name one more time"... See some of the materials in Exhibit 1 that show Also,
there may be some clerk failure or misconduct where Michelle Purdy and or Lori Matheus appear to
have refused a filign by Coughlin on October 19th, 2011 which arguably could have functioned as a
Motion for STay in CV11-03051 - ZACH COUGHLIN VS. MATT MERLISS ET AL (D1) Filing
Date: Wednesday, October 19th, 2011 . And City Attorney allison Ormaas and Dan Wong both
told Coughlin the were not going to investigate, follow up on, notate, or in any way document the fact
that Coughlin repeated to them the exact words that RPD Officer Chris Carter said to Coughlin on
November 13th, 2011 when the following exchange occurred between Coughlin and RPD Officer
Carter after Carter subjected Coughlin to a custodial criminal trespass arrest where Hill and
Sargent Lopez both admit that nobody issued Coughlin a warning to leave the premises that day and
that the RPD did not identifiy themselves as law enforcement or issue a lawful order to leave to
Coughlin prior to landlord Merliss kicking in a "basement" door:
Coughlin: (speaking to RPD Officer Carter) Are you on Richard G. Hill's
payroll, too?
RPD Officer Chris Carter, 1r: "Yes, I am. Richard Hill pays me a lot of
money so I arrest who he says to arrest and I do what he says to do".
Officer Carter said it. I reported it. Period. Now the SBN's Patrick King has failed to subpoena
Marshal Harley or City Attorney Ormaas (maybe he is afraid they will start whispering in each
other's ears again during some hearing the SBN wants to violate Coughlin's due process rights in
holding on November 14th, 2012), and instead Pat King has listed his old friend and coworker from
the Attorney Generals Office to come testify at the hearing and also listed Marshal Coppa (instead of
- 5/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Harley?) to testify as the hearing? Hhmmmmmn......Its just wrong for a smirking and chortling
RMC Marshal Harley to be perpetuating the fraud of WCSO Machen and the Rambo charlatan
litigation tactics, attempts at intimidation, and creation of the appearance of impropriety that
Richard HIll and Casey Baker cultivate so well in everything they do. Besides, why does Hill need
to have the wCSO and RMC serving Coughlin notices of Orders to Show cause when the following is
documented: 02-08-2012 Court Proof of Electronic Service Filed by or in behalf of: Court Proof
of Electronic Service 02-08-2012 Court Ord to Show Cause Filed by or in behalf of: Court Ord to
Show Cause...02-10-2012 Court Proof of Electronic Service Filed by or in behalf of: Court Proof
of Electronic Service 02-10-2012 Defendant Notice of Entry of Ord Filed by or in behalf of:
RICHARD HILL, ESQ. Notice of Entry of Ord - Continuation (if not for some impermissible
purpose?).
/ll o* the allegations herein also relate to AirregularitiesA in the proceedings and prosecutorial
misconductA Bust*ying the relie* re@uested herein" CoughlinCs a>ility to get this e+culpatory video =herein
#argent 6opeD admits $.D 3**icer Carter and $ichard 2ill% !s@" and Casey BaEer% !s@" lied% under oath (in
2illCs case) at the <une 'th% )-) 1rial and in violation o* N$C. $ule (in BaEerCs case in his Novem>er
)st% )- 3pposition to CoughlinCs 4otion to Contest .ersonal .roperty 6ien) =as severaly comprimised%
to an e+cusa>le neglect e+tent% and to a good cause standard% >y the various *raudulent% retaliatory arrests
and incarcerations (=hich have seen attendant deprivations o* CoughlinCs medication or medications% some
o* =hich are considered ApyschotropicA >y the 9CDC)% and the *raudulent attempts >y $.D 3**icer
9arren and others to alienate Coughlin *rom his *amily and any other type o* a support system% all in the
name o* covering up =rong*ul arrests >y the 9C.D% and or 9C#3 and or =rong*ul Asummary contemptA
*indings% including those in 1$ ),'--% $C$ )-)F-,(,3- ( /$gent #i*reCs order to arrest Couglin on
<anuary 4th% )-) *or Amisue o* emergency communciationsA% in addition to 9C#3 Deputy 4achenCs
- 6/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
*raudulent arrest o* Coughlin on <une )'th% )-)% including the *raudulent A#i+th /mendment
representation >y 9C.D <im 6eslie and Biray Dogan (in $C$ )-)F-,(,3- and $C$)-)F-,79'-) in
those matters)) (i* 4arshal 2arley is going to *ollo= Coughlin into the restroom% then peer through a
restroom stall and% as alleged >y <udge Nash 2olmes in her 3G)G) 3rder *ollo=ing a hearing that
Coughlin =as not appropriately noticed on >y the $4C% despite it >eing a=are o* CoughlinCs then current
address at the time it mailed a )G)'G) 3rder in 1$ ),'-- to Coughlin"""and <udge Nash 2olmes is
going to enter and 3rder *inding Coughlin to >e guilty o* Asummary criminal contemptA (=hich isnCt even
an actual charge under N$#)% then 4arshal 2arley and or <udge Nash 2olmes need to sign a**idavits to the
e+tent those 3rdes e+plicitly re*erence alleged conduct in a >athroom stall% ie% not% allegedly Acommitted in
the courtCs presenceA under any section o* N$# ))))% then 4arshal 2arley needs to sign an a**idavit% =hich
he has not done" /nd $4C 4arshal Coppa should perhaps *ocus less on criti@uing CoughlinCs alleged
=earing o* ApaBama >ottomsA to the $4C *iling o**ice coutner =hile checEing a tra**ic citation% and more
on =hether he violated the 7ourth /mendment and other la=s incident to his conduct on 7e>ruary )7th%
)-) in pulling into a >acE room in the sally >ay at the 9CDC 9C#. Deputy Cheung and seeEing to% upon
in*ormation and >elie*% commit some misconduct (and the $4C 4arshals coming >acE to the 9CDC on
<une )'th% )-) and retrieving CoughlinCs smart phone% phone% and micro sd card is not a Asearch incident
to arrestA% and a =arrant needs to >e produced to sho= ho= the $4C and or the 4arshal did not violate the
7ourth /mendment" 7urther% the $4C needs to ans=er *or =hy it has *louted Nevada la= in *ailing to
transmit the appropriate materials in response to CoughlinCs *iling% on 4arch 7th% )-)% o* a N3tice o*
/ppeal (see N$# '9"--F"-(-) in 1$ ),'--)" 7urther% i* any Arecording deviceA =as Adissassem>ledA
during a >athroom >reaE% then ho= could CoughlinCs ans=ers to <udge Nash 2olmes sua sponte
interrogation% incident to improper suggestions made to her >y the $eno 4arshals and or City /ttorney
/llison 3rmass% possi>ly >e appropriateH 7urther% in C$)F-37, CoughlinCs rights =ere raped >y the court
- 7/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
system% and 9C.D Biray Dogan and <eremy Bosler% and <udge !lliotCs incarcerating Coughlin on /pril
9th% )-) until /pril ),th% )-) (incident to a *raudulent *iled letter >y 6aEeCs Crossing o* /pril 't% )-)%
signed >y Dr" Bill Davis% and Dr"7armer% though Davis disclaims and connection to that letter% amaDingly)
provides a *urther e+cusa>le neglect >asis% as does the *raudulent conduct o* the $<C and or the 9C#3
(including Deputy 4achen) o* <une )'th% )-) in the custodial arrest (=ith impermissi>le denial o* a phone
call% *or no= reason at all% thanEs to the misconduct o* Deputy &an der 9all and ANurse ?atherineA% and
Deputy Beatson% in denying Coughlin a phoen call *or )- hours% *or no reason =hatsoever (despite 9CDC
policy and or the la= re@uiring one =ithin 3 hours)% in addition to the *raud o* Nevada Court #ervices
(partners =ith $4C court appointed de*ender 6e= 1aitel% =hom represented Couglin in this very matter%
C$ ),4-(% despite an o>vious con*lict)" /lso% the *raud >y 6tn" ?evin Bro=n% #argent 3liver 4iller%
3**icer /lan 9eaver% and #argent Dye o* the $.D in connection =ith the incarceration o* Coughlin *rom
<uly 3rd% )-) to <uly )st% )-) contri>uted to preventing Coughlin *rom (as did the *raud >y the 9CDC
in re*using to timely *ile CoughlinCs court *ilings so su>mitted% including oneCs in this case and in the sister
case appeal in cvF-3,)' =herein during his incarceration Coughlin =as prevented *rom opposing or
other=ise addressing an outrageous I4-%-(- attorneyCs *ees a=ard to $ichard ;" 2ill% !s@" incident to the
appeal o* the =rong*ul summary eviction in $<C $ev)-F--7-' >y $ichard" ;" 20ll% !#@"% and *urther
curious is $4C <udge ;ardnerCs G3-G trans*erring o* the ridiculous =rong*ul arrest *or ABay=alEingA o*
Coughlin on <anuary )th% )-) incident to CoguhlinCs peace*ully *ilming 2illCs cre= loading up personalty
*rom CoughlinCs *ormer home la= o**ice to taEe to the to=n dump% =herein 20ll lied to $.D 3**icer /lan
2ollings=orth% i na criminal violation >y 2ill% eventually leading to a =rong*ul custodial arrest o* Coughlin
*or Bay=alEing in $4C ) C$ --,9, (the case A/dministrative <udgeA 9illiam ;ardner o* the $4C Bust
so happened to trans*er to <udge Nash 2olmes (to go along =ith all the =orE she =as puttinC in *or thr $4C
on 1$ ),'--% the triple tra**ic citation incdient to Coughlin seeEing the return o* his clientCs *iles and
- 8/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
state issued indenti*ication *rom $ichard ;" 2ill% !#@" on N3vem>er )(th% )-% *ollo=ing CoughlinCs
relesae *rom 3 days incarceration incident to the *raudulent and =rong*ul custodial arrest o* Coughlin on
N3vem>er 3th% )- in C$ ),4-( >y $.D 3**icer Carter and #argent 6opeD"" !verytime% Coughlin
has >een =rong*ully arrested (=hich is everytime Coughlin has >een arrested) the 9CDC has
impermissi>ly =ithheld CoughlinCs medications *rom him =hile the 9CD/Cs 3**ice and $!no City
attorney and or the $4C and $<C have sought to violate N$# 7'"4-( and N$# ("-- in plo=ing ahead
=ith 1rials and settings during the pendency o* an 3rder *or Competency !valuation (including the oneCs
detailed in CoughlinCs previous *iling in this regard)" /dd to that the *raud o* North=inds in $<C reve)-)F
---4'% the *raud o* ;/yle ?ern and 9N4Cs #ue ?ing in the Coughlin v" .arE 1errace 1o=n 2omes
23/ in the $<C and that o* <e** Nichols in Couglhin v N0chols (another landlrod tenant matter in the $<C)
and its e+cusa>le neglect any e+tent to =hich Coughlin did not previously produce this e+cuplatory video%
particularly =here it =as =rong*ully =ithheld *rom his under an unla=*ul rent distraint or other
impermissil>e action >y a landlord% and ho= that is e+cusa>le neglect is o>vious% no matter =hat $4C
<udge 2o=ardCs lacE o* appreciation o* =hat >eing a tenant su>Bected to *raud >y a landlord may have
revealed in C$ ))7, or the misconduct o* .am $o>erts% !s@"% City attorney in that matter (and all the
*allout o* the decisions and action >y those t=o therein)"
" <anuary 3th% )-) $.D #argent 4arcia 6opeD and 3**icer 1ravis 9arren and 3**icer /vila
respond to a call *or help regarding a domestic distur>ance *rom Zach Coughlin relating to the attacEs >y
his housemates% Christopher A!rinA /lla>acE and 6aura 7oreshee *or =hich Coughlin ultimately received
t=o 3rders o* .rotection in 7&)F--'7 and 7&)F--''" #argent 6opeD su>Bected Coughlin to a
custodial arrest *or criminal trespass in $eno 4unicipal Court case C$ ),4-(% on Novem>er 3th% )-
(=hich resulted in Coughlin >eing convicted *or criminal trespass *ollo=ing the <une 'th% )-) 1rial
=herein $ichard 2ill testi*ied as *ollo=s:
- 9/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1he admission >y #argent 6opeD =as captured on a high 'mm video camera that Coughlin >ought
*rom a thri*t store *or *ive dollars a*ter his then housemate ruined his digital smart phone video recorder >y
thro=ing hot co**ee on it an Coughlin" Coughlin then trans*erred the tape *rom that high 'mm to a digital
version >y *ilming a television =ith a digital video camera later o>tained% =hile it =as playing that high
'mm tape" 1he *ile =as name A-)- cropped Carter 6opeD ),4-("=mv% and the *ollo=ing represents and
accurate transcription thereo*% in relevant part:
Coughlin: #argent 6opeD are you going to arrest Nevada court services
*or trespassH
6opeD: 0Cm not going to arrest them *or trespass"
Coughlin: >ut you arrested me *or trespass"
6opeD: >ecause you =ere s@uatting in the property"
Coughlin: =hy do you say that you have any evidence o* thatH ((
seconds o* silence is #argent 6opeDCs response) did you announce that
you =ere $eno .D prior to EicEing the door inH
6opeD: 0 didnCt EicE the door in"
Coughlin: did you announce that you are $eno .D prior to any>ody
EicEing the door inH
6opeD: 0 didnCt have to%
Coughlin: so no>ody announced that they =ere $eno .DH
6opeD: >ecause the guy =ho EicEed it in had to EicE in his o=n door
>ecause you =ere s@uatting in his place"
Coughlin: so you are admitting that you guys didnCt announce that you
=ere $eno .D"
6opeD: you are =earing my patience thin% #ir% oEay" 0 am trying to
come here to help you% and 0 >ring a specialiDed o**icer (motioning to
$.D 3**icer 1ravis 9arren% =hom has >een descri>ed as some sort o*
$.D 3**icer =ith some specialty in Amental healthA related areas)"
Coughlin: thatCs interesting% you admit that you and 3**icer Carter
never announced that you are $eno .D% and that you never asEed me to
leave% did you% prior to the door >eing EicEed inH
3**icer 1ravis 9arren: #he didnCt have to do anything liEe that"
Coughlin: you didnCt have toJ 1hatCs great% >ut that means you didnCt
either"
9arren: hold on Zach" 8ou asEed us to come here >ecause you needed
help no= you are >eing con*rontational"
Coughlin: no 0Cm not% no not" /ny>ody =ho asEed you a @uestion is
con*rontational% 0 guess% huhH
9arren: Zach% letCs try to stay on topic"
Coughlin: 3n topicH 0Cm not on the topic you =ant me to >e on"
9arren: Zach the topic that 0Cm interested in"""
- 10/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: 0s the one that covers your assJ
9arren: No% itCs not"
Coughlin: 8es% it is"A
"""
Coughlin: #o% #argent 6opeD you have admitted that you did not asE
me to leave and you did not announce that you are $eno .D either you
or your partner either o* those things =hen you arrested me *or
trespass" /re you >een arrest Nevada Court #ervices *or the trespass
that there is video evidence o* on 8ou1u>e right no=H /re you can a
do that% #argentH #argent% are youH
9arren: Zach% thatCs not the topic =ere on"
Coughlin: /re you going to do that% #argentH #argent% are youH
6opeD: are you going to *ill out your statementH
Coughlin: sure" /re you going to do thatH
6opeD: 0 am not going to arrest Nevada Court #ervices"
Coughlin: 9hy% are they your >uddiesH
6opeD: >ecause they did their Bo>"
Coughlin: =ait a did their Bo> >y going >ehind my >acE *ence and
>anging on my =indo=s *or 4( minutes three times a time a dayH
0nteresting"""
6opeD: Zach% =e need you to *ill out the paper"
Coughlin: 0nteresting ho= it =orEs do=n there at the $eno .D" 8ou
Eno=% there is a lots o* documentary *ilmmaEers out there these days%
#argent 6opeDH Do you have anything you =ould liEe to sayH
6opeD: Zach% you need to *inish your statement"
9arren: Zach% you call us here to help you% and no= your are"""
Coughlin: =ell apparently not >ecause you arrest me *or trespass =hen
you either didnCt tell me to leave *or announced that you =ere the .D
(police Department) and then you have video evidence o* Nevada
Court #ervices doing trespassing harassing >anging on =indo=s *or 4-
min" at a clip three times a day% >ehind a >acE gate is o>viously
trespassing% and you are seeing you are not going to do anything"""
6opeD: have you had your day in court on that yetH
Coughlin:1hat is coming up"
"""
9arren: Zach% =e really need to stay on topic% oEayH
Coughlin: 9hat is the topicH Nevada Court #ervicesH 1he >uddies o*
#argent 6opeDH
9arren: No"""
"""
Coughlin: are you guys going to do anything on this call >ecause the
last time you didnCt run any>odyCs priors and i* you had it =ould have
>een interesting =hat you =ould have *ound% =hat did you sayH 0s that
proper procedure children some>odyCs priorsH
6opeD: 1he priors *or =hoH
- 11/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: >ecause you guys didnCt do that""" 9ell =ho =ould 0 >e
talEing a>outH
6opeD:(smirEing) 8oursel*% may>eH 1he priors *or yoursel*H
Coughlin: 3h% is that a"""do you thinE you are *unnyH
6opeD: 0 thinE it is *unny% yeah" 0 thinE everything is *unny% actually" 0
am amused >y a lot o* stu**"
Coughlin: $eallyH Do you thinE itCs *unny =hen your partner says that
$ichard 2ill pays him a lot o* money to arrest =hom he says toH
6opeD: 0 am pretty sure he didnCt""K
Coughlin: and you =ere thereH /nd you didnCt *ollo= up =ith the
@uestions o* =hether $ichard 2ill had given me a >ill *or rent that
month and yet you still arrested me *or trespassH
6opeD: ( min" Zach"
Coughlin: 0 thinE thatCs *unny% that you thinE itCs *unny"
6opeD: 4 min" Zach
"""
6opeD:% did the management give you an eviction noticeH
Coughlin: =hat are you getting involved in civil matters no=H 8ou are
going a>ove and >eyond% #argent 6opeD% getting involved in civil
matters"""
6opeD: Zach did they give you an eviction notice or notH
Coughlin: =o= you are =orEing o* the storm over there arenCt you
6opeD: 8es or no:
9arren: you could say no comment% Zach"
Coughlin: thanE you% counselor" 0 appreciate your advice" No=% =hat
criminal matter =ere you investigating hereH
6opeD: 0 am asEing you a @uestion"
Coughlin: />out a =hatH / civil matterH
6opeD: Zach% did you get an eviction notice *rom these guys (#argent
6opeD is re*erring to 9estern Nevada 4anagement posting a <ohn Doe
3- day eviction notice% allegedly% on the door o* the 4)) !" 9th #t" L)
to=n home that 9N4 (=hich% liEe NC#% commits the unauthoriDed
practice o* landlord tenant la=) had agreed to some deal =ith
CoughlinCs housemates (or may>e they =ere his su>lessorsH Coughlin
rented a room *rom them o** o* Craigslist% >ut to some e+tent they =ere
held out to >e employees or partners o* 9N4% and 9N4 did testi*y at
a 7e>ruary )3rd% )-) hearing a*ter Coughlin *iled an interruption o*
essential services complaint against 9N4% ;ayle ?ern% !s@"% 61D%
and .arE 1errace 1o=nhomes that *ormer 9N4 manager% $o>yn
Batalado received approval *rom the .arE 1errace 1o=n 2omes
2omeo=ners /ssociattion to allo= CoughlinCs su>lessors to live their
in e+change *or some handyman =orE (and perhaps in light o* the
lessened insurance costs associated =ith not having the unit vacant
incident to some scenario =here the .1123/ >ought the unit at a
*oreclosure sale)"
- 12/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
9arren: 9e =ill taEe that as a yes or no% or a may>e% =ho Eno=sH /ll
right% ZachH 8ou are not going to >e a>le to >ait us into saying thingsH
Coughlin: 9ell% 0Cve >een listening to you here =hether youCve >een
>aited or not% you have said a =hole lot today"
"""
Coughlin:""" 9hat i* $ichard 2ill sent me a Bill *or rent *or the month o* Novem>er% should you
*ollo= phone that >e*ore you maEe it trespass arrestH /nd =hat did you say to thatH 8ou say no =e
are not going to that $ichard 2ill pays us a lot o* money% and =e are going to arrest =hom he says
to arrest% did you hear that #argent 6opeDH
9arren: Zach% letCs stay on topic"
Coughlin: this could >e your star turn""" 1his could >e your star turn"
6opeD: you need some help% >rother"
Coughlin: reallyH
6opeD: 8eah% you do"
"""(#argent 6opeD and 3**icers 9arren and /vila then leave shortly
therea*ter% and Coughlin has the *ollo=ing e+change =ith his
housemateCsGa>users teenage daughter):
Coughlin: looE someday% you are trying to support yoursel* and
someone steals your license plate% and slashes your tires% and locEs you
out a*ter you have given them the last money you had"""
1eenage ;irlCs 7riend: =ell% someday =e =onCt >e an asshMle liEe you
Coughlin:9hat is an AasshMleA a>out thatH
1eenage ;irl: you are *McEing rMtarded% you are >eing rMtarded% youCre
maEing my dad not liEe you% you steal his Enives" 2is steaE Enives% liEe
seriouslyH
Coughlin: 8ou mean the one o* he held =hile chasing me up the stairs
=ith saying he =as gonna Eill meH
1eenage ;irl: 2e didnCt *McEinC chase you up the stairs and tell you he
=as gonna Eill you" 9hy =ould he say that% heCs not liEe that" /nd i*
he sayCs it% it doesnCt mean he means it" 8ou maEe him say that% you
*McEinC prMcE"A
<anuary )th% )-) custodial arrest *or Apedestrian *ailing to use side=alE =here availa>leA (aEa%
Bay=alEing) in *ront o* CoughlinCs *ormer home la= o**ice at ) $iver $ocE #t"% $eno% N& '9(-"
(in the video Coughlin >egins *iliming *rom the parEing lot in *ron o*
his *ormer home la= o**ice and =alEs to=ards the property% =here
2illCs contractor .hil #te=art is already there (*or some reason 2ill Eept
maEing a deal a>out ho= Coughlin =as Aalready at the propertyA =hen
#te=art returned their *rom the trans*er center% >ut that is not true%
Coughlin actually tooE almost 3- minutes to get to the $iver $ocE
.roperty a*ter the talEs at the trans*er center% as Coughlin had to go
retrieve his hi 'mm video camera *rom his !" 9th #t" address on that
date"
- 13/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: 9hat =ould the contractorCs >oard say a>out you su>mitting
*raudulent >illsH (said to 2illCs contractor% .hil #te=art% o=ner and
operator o* Nevada Building 0ndustries (NB0)% =hose >ill *or I%-,-
*or AsecuringA the property =as su>mitted as an attachment in 2illCs
4emorandum o* Costs and in 2illCs 3pposition to CoughlinCs 4otion
to Contest .ersonal .roperty 6ien under a personalty lien theory citing
to N$# '/"4,-% =hich allo=s *or reasona>le costs *or Amoving%
storage% and inventoryingA a tenantCs personal property)" 9ould they
>e oEay =ith thatH NecE carpet right there thatCs Dr" 4erlissCs property
i* you thro= it a=ay% you are thro=ing a=ay the carpet% so you are on
notice and you should tell $ichard 2ill% i* he tries to sue me *or the
carpet% and you thro= it a=ay% 0 =ill sue you *or *raud"
"""
(Coughlin is seen in the video =alEing a *e= *eet o** the side=alE in
light o* the *act that 2illCs contractorCs cre= have taEen up the =hole o*
the side=alE (#te=artCs =hite dumptrucE is parEed so as to e+tend *rom
the drive =ay out onto the street so as to completely >locE the
side=alE% and >eyond that% the side=alE is dotted =ith various items
#te=artCs cre= is in the process o* moving *rom the *ormer home la=
o**ice) on the southern *acing side o* the property in *urtherance o*
their e**orts to load up the rest o* CoughlinCs personalty and taEe it to
the dump (as there =as apparently an incredi>ly urgent need to do
something =ith the property% despite the *act that% to this day% over one
year later% it still remains unFrented)"
Coughlin: gentlemen% you are under notice this is my property and 0
=ant it" 0 >elieve 0 might have some legal recourse against you *or
destroying my property" 0 could >e =rong" 8ou are certainly =elcome
to listen to your >oss" 8ou Eno= =hat is interesting is that 0 have proo*
right here that you used my o=n ply=ood to >oard up the property and
then you try to charge a thousand dollars *or it and *or *i+ing a leaE
thatCs my ply=ood .hil or =hatever your name is% guy =ith a
contractorCs license" (Coughlin is saying this =hile in the parEing lot o*
the studio apartments that a>uts the >acEyard *ence to his *ormer home
la= o**ice (ie% not on the side=alE even" 3ne o* #te=artCs la>orers
=alE up to Coughlin =ithin a>out ' *eet o* him and snaps a *lash
photo):
<ohn Doe: 9hatCs upH" (snaps another photo o* Coughlin in the parEing
lots o* the 4ill .lace studio apartments)
Coughlin: 2i% ho= are you doingH 9hatCs your nameH
<ohn Doe: <ohn Doe"
Coughlin: <ohn Doe% reallyH
Doe: DonCt get mouthy% >uddy"
- 14/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: 9hatCs thatH
Doe: 0 said donCt get cro=ley% >uddy"
Coughlin: 9hatCs Acro=leyAH
Doe: ACro=leyA means liEe ACro=ley 6aEeA"
Coughlin: 0 donCt Eno= =hat you mean" /ny=ays .hil =hat do you
have to say a>out the *act that you *raudulently su>mitted a Bill *or
thousand dollars *or >oarding up the property to *i+ a leaE yet you used
my ply=ood to do it% .hilH
<ohn Doe: 2ey% can you stay a=ay *rom him (motioning to .hil
#te=art)H
Coughlin: 0 am on a pu>lic spot right here (actually% Coughlin is still
standing in the 4ill .lace studio apartmentCs parEing lot at this time)" 0
am not >othering him you guys Bust e+pect people to =atch you use
their o=n property to >oard up a placeH
.hil #te=art: do you have a receipt *or thatH
Coughlin: yeah 0 do" 0t =as su>mitted into evidence guy" 8ou guys
su>mitted it into evidence as a >ill" (Coughlin then =alEs out o* the
4ill .lace parEing lot and around #te=artCs =hite dump trucE (=hich
=as completely >locEing the side=alE) and out a *e= *eet into the road
on Court #t =est o* $iver $ocE% =here the cameraCs vie= reveals
#te=artCs cre= has set a couch and some other personalty on the
side=alE% =here #te=art and <ohn Do= =alE onto to=ards the *ront o*
the property on $iver $ocE #t" to talE =ith $ichard ;" 2ill% !s@") are
you going to asE $ichard a>out thatH 0 even asE $ichard a>out the *act
they used my o=n property to >oard up the property and charged =ith
thousand dollars *or it this gotta >e an easier =ay to maEe money =as
and ainCt that easy to >e an attorney as you can see% .hil"
#te=art: you o>viously need to start taEing your medication"
Coughlin:(Coughlin has retreated >acE to the 4ill .lace parEing lot at
this point) =hat did you sayH /re you maEing some sort o* accusation
or insult a>out taEing medicationH 0s that =hat you are doingH 8ou
Eno= it is *unny >ecause a lot o* this property couldCve >een used to
*eed *amilies in need" .hil are you going to thro= a=ay the carpet and
then try to >ill >e*ore it is that =hat you are going to do some pretty
sure that that =ould >e *raud .hil" #ir% 0 am putting you on notice that
carpet >elongs to Dr" 4erliss (a couple mem>ers o* #te=artCs cre= are
no= seen picEing up the rolled up >undles o* carpet that Coughlin%
=hom has no= =alEed around to the *ront o* the property to $iver
$ocE #t" =alEing Bust o** the side=alE (though a large tanG>ro=n
#ilverado style picEup trucE parEed on the North #ide o* Court #treet%
that Coughlin recalls seeing a large manilla *older in =ith the notation%
in hand =riting% A#argent Bradsha=A is an o>stacle Coughlin must =alE
around% especially =here #te=art himsel* is utiliDing the side=alE% and
given <ohn DoeCs very recent re@uest that Coughlin Astay a=ayA *rom
#te=art% it =ould seem cautious o* Coughlin not to attempt to =alE on
the same small patch o* side=alE o** Court #treet as #te=art and his
- 15/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
la>orers") 2ey% .hilH .hilH 1he carpet% there =as also some more o*
it right around there""" 2ope*ully you havenCt thro=n it a=ay already"""
2ope*ully% you do not try to >ill me *or it .hil""""
(Coughlin is no= standing on the side=alE on the =estern side o* $iver
$ocE% parallel =ith the northern >oundardy line o* the property% =hen
<ohn Doe appears *rom around the corner o** o* Court #treet and snaps
another *lash >ul> photograph at Coughlin)"
Coughlin: #ir% this is a pu>lic street" 1his is a pu>lic street you do not
on the side=alEs are have you ever heard o* a documentaryH 8ou
Eno= thereCs a lot o* guys maEing documentaries these days a>out the
>ad things people do"
(up rolls $.D 3**icer 2ollings=orth on his motorcycle% and $.D
dispatch chatter can >e heard descri>ing a Asuspect in a larcenyA"
3**icer 2ollings=orth has >een called to the scene >y $ichard ;" 2ill%
!s@" and .hil #te=art" 2ill sho=s up seconds a*ter 2ollings=orth"
No=% neither 2ill nor #te=art =ere charged =ith Amisuse o* emergency
services liEe Coughlin =as in $C$)-)F-,(,3-" #o in this video
#te=art talEs =ith o**icer 2ollings=orth *or a *e= moments until
$ichard 2ill arrives""")
Coughlin: hey $ich ho= are you doingH
2ill: ;reat% Zach% thanE you >uddy"
Coughlin: =ould you pre*er o* psychology 4r" 2illH
2ill: 0 =ould% Zach"
Coughlin: 4r" 2ill% ho= are you doingH 2ey that is a cool AsEullsA
shirt% 4r" 2ill (2ill is =earing a >lacE !d 2ardy style >o=ling shirt
=ith *laming red sEulls on it"" 2ill >egins doing his $eno .D thing
=ith 3**icer 2ollings=orth% Coughlin stands >acE a>out ) *eet *rom
their communi@ue)"
2ill: (to 3**icer 2ollings=orth) can =e get him out o* hereH (and
therein% >esides calling 9G$.D dispatch in the *irst place =here no
legitimate reason e+isted to% 2ill proceeds to leverage la= en*orcement
acting =ith color o* la= to prevent opposing counsel *rom collectin
evidence *or a =rong*ul eviction damages analysis)"
2ollings=orth: *irst o* all o* gotta *igure out i* 0 have legal authority to
do so"
2ill: $e: court order evicting him *rom the property% su>se@uently =e
had him arrested *or trespass is lost his appeal (=hich =as totally not
true =hen 2ill made that *alse statement to a police o**icer seeEing to
have Coughlin arrested% on <anuary )th% )-)% given that the appeal
=ould not >e decided *or months)% heCs lost"""" No= =e have >een
talEing to our =orEers
2ollings=orth: 2ave you tried to get a protection orderH
2ill: no >ut =e do have an order *rom the court disposition o* the
premises (unintelligi>le""")
- 16/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: =hat a>out the side=alE >ridge you on the side=alEH
2ill: is >een over to the trans*er station #argent Bradsha= 0 Bust le*t
*rom there is #argent Bradsha= =ho is >een on (unintelligi>le)""" 1hese
over here Bust generally >eing a pain in the ass
Coughlin: *reedom o* the press% $ich" (2ill starts maEing some >ig
gesticulating motions to 3**icer 2ollings=orth liEe a child =hom is not
>eing given the toy he =anted *or Christmas or &eruca #alt thro=ing a
*it in CharleyCs Chocolate 7actory)" 1hey have important things to do
rich they are >usy" (2elen #te=art continued talEing the 2ollings=orth
>y this time 3**icer Del &ecchio is sho=ed up% it looEs liEe 3**icer
4cNuattie is there (actually% that might >e then trainee 3**icer 6eedy%
3**icer 6ooE is there no= too)
3**icer 6ooE: hey ho= are you doing
Coughlin: 2i% #ir% good to see you again" 0 didnCt catch your name last
time 0 recogniDe you *rom the the day""
6ooE: =ith o**icer looE
Coughlin nice to see you again 0 thinE 0 sa= you the other day =hen
came out on a call =ith 3**icer ;annon% *or a domestic distur>ance a
run !astF#age
looE: 0 honestly donCt remem>er
Coughlin: 8eah% 0 thinE you guys are up in my >edroom"""
6ooE: $ight on #cottsdale
Coughlin: #atan !" 9th #t"% .arE 1errace 1o=n homes""" 7reedom o* the
press% $ich"
6ooE =hat you guys have going on todayH
2ill: contempt o* court 4r" CoughlinJ
Coughlin: =ell% that carpet >elongs to your client% 4r" 2ill i* you try to
thro= it a=ay and then >uild me *or itK
2ollings=orth: (comes over to talE to Coughlin) can you turn that o**%
#ir% *or a second stu** over here on over on the side=alE (Coughlin
=as already on the side=alE% >ut 2olling=orth leads them *urther
North along the $iver $ocE side =alECs =estern side)" 3Eay so =hatCs
the deal today =hy are =e hereH
Coughlin: 0 donCt Eno=% sir"
2ollings=orth did used to live hereH
Coughlin: 0 pre*er to Bust Eeep my privacy as a private citiDen" But 0
mean you no disrespect #ir"
2ollings=orth no pro>lem% 0 can respect that hereCs the deal you
understand here in the side=alE no pro>lem you on it student run tape
no pro>lem >ut you canCt inter*ere =ith them doing their Bo> and theyCre
pro>a>ly enough apply *or temporary station order against you in
=hich heGshe can >e =ithin -- yards o* there or them" (2ill gets into
his I--%--- .orsche Carrera =here he goes o** the $eno <ustice Court
and gets a 1.3 signed >y <udge #chroeder =ithin 4- minutes o* the
application >eing stamped in" Behind 2illCs .orsche is 3**icer 6ooECs
- 17/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
patrol car and the patrol car >eing utiliDed >y 3**icer 6eedy and his
training% tenured 3**icer% 3**icer Del &ecchio" 1hese vehicles are in
addition to the motorcycle ridden >y 3**icer 2ollings=orth" $ichard
2illCs =i*eGlegal assistant #heri 2ill is parEed in the lot on the east side
o* $iver $ocE in her maroon 6e+us #5&" Contractor #te=art is seen
Bay=alEing across $iver $ocE to the lot =here #heri 2ill is parEed% >ut
he is not arrested")" /ll they are trying to do is get their >usiness or
taEing care o*
Coughlin: 0Cm trying to taEe care o* my >usiness% too"
2ollings=orth: oEay is there something =e can help you =ithH
Coughlin: 0 donCt >elieve so% sir" 0 called the police recently 0 told them
some>ody threatened my li*e the the day that in si+ see *it to arrest
any>ody so apparently $ichard 2ill is a national treasure"
2ollings=orth: 3Eay% =ell% 0 donCt Eno= =ho that is% all 0 Eno= is 0Cm
here today and you are here =ith the camera and youCre not >reaEing
any la=s that 0 can see >ut theyCre gonna try to get it to =here you are
violating a temporary protection order
Coughlin 0 understand it threatening a>use o* process and malicious
prosecution
2ollings=orth: so it =ould >e help*ul i* may>e you could *ind
something else to do this a*ternoon >ecause 0 have >een listening on the
radio and =eCve had t=o or three calls *or service *or you already today
and =ould liEe to >e evidence o* do some other =orE today% no one 0
mean
Coughlin oEay =ell 0 hear =hat youCre saying
2ollings=orth is >asically a second help you =ith
Coughlin: i* you =ouldnCt mind telling me your last name
2ollings=orth: 2ollings=orth
Coughlin thanE you% #ir% ;ood>ye 3**icer 6ooE% good to see you
again% #ir"(Coughlin then proceeds to =alE >acE to=ards the mill place
parEing lot 9estern 6ane along court street he does not =alE in the
street >ut rather uses the side=alE =hich is no= cleared o* #te=artCs
la>orers and any o* the personalty they are seeEing to taEe to the dump
ho=ever the =hite dump trucE >elong to #te=art is still >locEing the
side=alE" Coughlin 7o+ all the =ay >acE to the area in the 4illCs .lace
parEing lot immediately to the =est o* the *enced% gated >acEyard to his
*ormer home la= o**ice% and can vie= 3**icer 2ollings=orth pull a=ay
on his motorcycle heading north on $iver $ocE" 7ootage o* contractor
#te=artCs =hite dump trucE reveals ho= e+tremely implausi>le #te=art
s=orn testimony =as at the 7e>ruary )3% )-) 3rder to #ho= Cause
hearing (=hich 2ill had Coughlin personally served Notice o* >y
9C#3 Deputy 4achen (>y =ay o* $4C 4arshal 2arley) incident to
Coughlin arriving and =aiting at the $4C *or the tra**ic citation 1rial
in 1$ ),'-- stemming *rom the three tra**ic citations $.D #argent
<ohn 1arter had issued to Coughlin incident to the Novem>er (
incident at 2illCs la= o**ice =here Coughlin ventured upon >eing
- 18/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
released *rom three days incarceration *ollo=ing the Novem>er 3%
)- criminal trespass rests at CoughlinCs *ormer la= o**ice Coughlin
=ent to 2illCs o**ice to retrieve his Eeys state issued drivers license and
or identi*ication his =allet and his clientCs *iles% =hich 2ill re*used to
release" 0t tooE until Novem>er ))nd% )- >e*ore 2ill turned over
CoughlinCs =allet and driverCs license to Coughlin" 0t tooE until
Decem>er ))nd% )- >e*ore 2ill turned over CoughlinCs clientCs *iles%
causing Coughlin to incur great e+pense in arranging *or alternatives"
Coughlin starts to maEe his =ay >acE to=ards the *ront o* the property
and decides to =alE along the edge o* the parEed 1an Bro=n picEup
trucE instead o* venture near it >e la>orers =orEing *or #te=art =ho are
no= utiliDing the side=alE on the north side o* court street once again"
Coughlin notices the large manila envelope and the dash>oard o* the
tracE =ith a large" 9ritten note indicating #argent Bradsha= on the
outside o* o* the *older" Coughlin then crosses the street in a straight
continuation *rom the northern side=alE on Court #t" to the parEing lot
on the east side o* $iver $ocE% Bust as any pedestrian =ould (e+cept
Contractor #te=art actually Bust =alEed out in the middle o* the road
=hen he crossed $iver $ocE earlier% rather than in a straight
continuation o* the side=alEs" Coughlin notices Contractor #te=art
milling a>out on the =est side=alE o* $iver $ocE Bust north o* his
*ormer la= o**ice" 1his group includes #te=art% Del &ecchio% 6eedy%
and 6ooE% =hom are no= Boined >y #argent #i*re" 3**icer
2ollings=orth has le*t to do some real police =orE >y this time" #heri
2ill is still =atching on *rom her maroon 6e+us #5& in the parEing
lot)"
Coughlin: (talEing vaguely in the direction o* Contractor #te=art =ho
is appro+imately 3- *eet a=ay) you might =hen 0 try to maEe sure you
donCt thro= a=ay that carpet over there >ecause 0 =ill dispute it i* you
guys try to >ill me *or it" (Coughlin then positions himsel* to get a shot
o* the interior o* the *ormer home la= o**ice =here a he sees a very
sentimental item to him that he *orgot to gra> at the last second during
the mad rush to move his property out to =hatever e+tent possi>le >y
the ( .4 deadline Decem>er )3 this item is a (A + ,A caricature o* his
*ormer domestic partner o* the preceding *our and a hal* years *rom a
relationship that ended in late 4ay )- and himsel* done during the
early stages o* their relationship" 1his =as amongst CoughlinCs most
treasured possessions and =as only le*t atop a cro=n molding during
the move =ith the idea that it =ould >e the last thing Coughlin =ould
gra>% and there*ore he =ould >e a>le to place it in a sa*e place on his 5F
2auls dash >oard or some=here else =here it =ould >e sa*e" 2o=ever%
the chaos incident to $ichard 2illCs sho=ing up in demanding everyone
>e o** the property >y e+actly ( .4 under the threat o* arrest caused
Coughlin to overlooEed gra>>ing this treasured sentimental item" 1his
caricature is visi>le in the video)
- 19/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: that is that sentimental picture that 0 told them a>out o*
4elissa and 0" the caricature""" /nd 0 >elieve the dolphin =indchime
mo>ile% one o* the last things my grandmother gave me >e*ore she died
is in there"""oh% and looE at that there is I(- appliance" (to Contractor
#te=art)" #ir 0 season sentimental heirloom EeepsaEes in their that 0
guess you are Bust going to thro= it a=ay you donCt care% the last thing
my grandmother gave me >e*ore she died very sentimental thing (at
this point Contractor #te=art turns to the camera an maEes a revolting
gesture)" #ir =hen you put a padlocE on the >acE *enceH (2illCs placing
a padlocE on the >acE *ence only Bust a>out the time that it =as
CoughlinCs right to remove his property resulted in CoughlinCs progress
in moving all his personalty >eing severely impeded")"
"""
(/t this point in the video Coughlin returns to the parEing lot o* 4illCs
.lace% private property% >ehind the *enced >acE yard o* his *ormer
home la= o**ice" 6iEe a couple o* goons approaching% 3**icerCs 6eedy
and 3**icer 6ooE venture into that private property% the 4illCs .lace
parEing lot:
3**icer 6eedy: 4r" Coughlin could talE to *or secondH
Coughlin: 0 mean neither con*irming that thatCs my name% #ir% >ut you
are the la= under asEing to speaE to some>ody so"
(at this point 3**icer 6ooE approaches Coughlin very rapidly and
immediately gra>s CoughlinCs =rist% Couglin holding his video camera%
=hich is% o>viously% still *ilming% as 3**icer 6eedy and 3**icer 6ooE
immediately Bump straight to applying e+cessive *orce to CoughlinCs
=rists" 3**icer 6ooE Bumps at Coughlin *rom CoughlinCs le*t side and
3**icer 6eedy sneeEs around >ehind Coughlin and gra>s CoughlinCs
camera out o* his right hand and turns it o**)
3**icer 6ooE: video camera do=n% put your camera do=n"
Coughlin:9hoaJ 9hoaJ 9hy are you touching meJ (3**icer 6ooE is
captured on video >reaEing >acE CoughlinCs le*t =rist and =renching
CoughlinCs le*t arm >ehind his >acE% prior to any sort o* attempt to
peacea>ly approach Coughlin% a license attorney% =hatsoever% >ut then
accidentally turns it >acE on a second later% a *act to =hich he is
una=are" 3**icer 6eedy places >oth o* his hands on CoughlinCs right
side and right arm and =rist in a display o* e+cessive use o* *orce")
3**icer 6eedy: 9e donCt =ant your camera""""
Coughlin =hy are you touching me this is not their properties% #irH
(the camera goes >lacE *or a moment)
Coughlin: 3===J" 8ou are >reaEing my =ristJJ 3==J 3===JJ
2elpJJJ 2elpJJJ 4y =rist hurts% some>ody call 9" 3===JJ
3===JJJ #ome>ody helpJJJ #ome>ody helpJJJ #ir% there is no need to
>reaE my =rist liEe that% #ir" 3==JJJ" 3==JJJ9hy are you
handcu**ing me% #irH
3**icer 6eedy: 8ou are >eing placed under arrest"
- 20/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: 7or =hatH 7or =hatH
#argent .aul #i*re: 1heyCll e+plain everything to you in a little >it (>ut%
actually% Coughlin =ould not >e told =hat he =as charged =ith *or
over an hour and a hal*% and in the intervening period =hile he =as
handcu**ed and placed in the 3**icer 6eedyCs patrol car% =ith tenured
training 3**icer Del &ecchio (=hom had handcu**ed Coughlin% and
placed him in the >acE o* his patrol car on night in <uly )- incident
to Del &ecchio dra=ing his =eapon% or appearing to% on >oth Coughlin
(=hom =as =alEing his >iEe at the time) and another >icyclist in *ront
o* CoughlinCs *ormer home la= o**ice at appro+imately - pm at night%
all >ecause 3**icer Del &ecchio *elt the light on CoughlinCs >iEe =as
Anot up to codeA)"
#argent #i*re: 0 am going to shut your camera o** so the >attery =ill not
run do=n"(3**icer Del &ecchio can >e seen in the video at this point
=alEing around in his acid =ash Beans)"
Coughlin: 0 donCt =anCt it shut o**% #ir" 8ou are o>structing Bustice i*
you shut it o**J (#argent .aul #i*re then shuts o** the video camera
=hereupon 3**icerCs 6ooE and trainee 3**icer 6eedy continuing
applying the =rong*ul use o* e+cessive *orce to CoughlinCs arms and
=rists as they pin him *ace do=n to the concrete =ith a smug%
nauseating Cali*ornian transplant name #argent .aul #i*re (=hom
incident to another =rong*ul detention o* Coughlin on 4arch )9th%
)-) told Coughlin he doesnCt liEe Nevada or $eno% >ut the Bo> he has
pays him so much% and he has so little chance o* *inding such an
arrangement in any local more to his liEing% that he essentially has a
pair o* Agolden handcu**sA tying him to Northern Nevada% =hich he
detests% >e*ore going on to tell Coughlin a>out ho= he lead his little
league team in >oth home runs and striEe outs% then proceeding to
ram>le on unconvincingly a>out ho= he =as Atrying to get you the help
you needA% in a tone that =as more suggestive o* a veiled threat to
Coughlin% the import o* =hich =as clear% ie% that Coughlin >etter not
complain anymore a>out the $.DCs police misconduct% such as
Coughlin did in his =ritten complaints to the $.D on #eptem>er 7th%
)- and <anuary 'th% )-) =herein Coughlin complained o* the police
misconduct >y $.D 3**icers NicE Duralde and $on $osa during the
=rong*ul arrest o* Coughlin on /ugust )-th% )-in $C$)-F-,334
(=ritten complaint su>mitted to the $.D on #eptem>er 7th% )- and
supplemental on <anuary 'th% )-)% at =hich time a =ritten complaint
against Nevada Court #ervices% $.D 3**icer Chris Carter% <r"% and
#argent 4arcia 6opeD incident to their police misconduct during the
Novem>er 3th% )- =rong*ul arrest o* Coughlin in $4C C$
),4-(" #argent #i*re =ould again order Coughlin arrested less than
4' hours later in $C$)-)F-,(,3- *or Amisue o* emergency
communications servicesA" 0n >et=een these t=o arrests $.D 3**icer
Duralde =ould get a chance to retaliate against Coughlin incident to
pulling Coughlin over in his car in the early morning hours o* <anuary
- 21/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
3th% )-)% a*ter Coughlin >ailed himsel* out o* Bail and use a
com>ination o* a ca> ride and =alEing to get to his car in )- degree
=hether on a very =indy night" Coughlin instantly recogniDed #i*reon
<anuary 4th% )-) *rom seeing him on <anuary )th% )-) as on >oth
days *act that #i*re =as =earing a short sleeves uni*orm shirt
emphasiDing his tri>al arm>and tatoos% and >ody >uilder >iceps"
"""
#ee attached in !+hi>it the videos *rom all o* these varius =rong*ul
arrests >y local la= en*orcemtn o* Coughlin
9hile it may >e e+pendient *or some in local la= en*orcement
to discredit Coughlin or have him AcommittedA% it does not maEe it
legal% and it does not vitiate the import o* la= en*orcement misconduct
in all o* the =rong*ul arrests o* Coughlin since /ugust 9th% )-"
Coughlin =as Bust in*ormed >y his mother that this same 3**icer 1ravis 9arren% along =ith another
$.D 3**icer and At=o social =orEer typesA met =ith CoughlinCs mother% &ery #pecial /rts o* Nevada
(&#/N) .rogram Director 4ary BarEer% and CoughlinCs *ather% Dr" 1imothy D" Coughlin% 4D% o* $eno
7amily .hysicians at Dr" CoughlinCs medical o**ice in an purported attempt to have Coughlin AcommittedA
sometime in appro+imately 7e>ruary )-)" #uch a meeting is conveniently and suspiciously close in time
to the video transcri>ed a>ove =herein #argent 6opeD essentially admits that she and 3**icer Carter lacEed
pro>a>le cause *or a criminal trespass arrest o* Coughlin (and% upon in*ormation and >elie*% the $.D =as
served a su>poena >y Coughlin re@uiring Carter and 6opeDCs presence at 1rial% though neither managed to
sho= up% despite the City /ttorneyCs having previously su>poenaed at least one o* them *or that purpose as
=ell"""0t seems to City /ttorneyCs 3**ice got =ind o* ho= terri>ly *raudulent 3**icer CarterCs pro>a>le cause
sheet =as (and Carter did tell Coughlin% in the AZachCs arrest --"mp4A video that Carter =ould put his
name on the Aarrest sheet i* you have any pro>lem =ith thatA in response to Coughlin mentioning to 3**icer
Carter that the police did need to have pro>a>le cause to maEe such an arrest" 7urther trou>ling is the *act
that $.D #argent #i*re had Coughlin arrested Bust over )4 hours a*ter #argent 6opeD put her *oot in her
mouth her% >ringing ( other $.D 3**icers =ith him on <anuary 4h% )-) to respond to a 9 call >y
- 22/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin reporting the disappearance o* his .eEingese dog% <acEson .a=lucE% and the menacing statements
connected thereto >y the house mates against =hom Coughlin =ould eventually >e a=arded t=o di**erent
1.3Cs"
<ust a>out ) hours prior to #argent 6opeD and 3**icer 9arren and 3**icer /vila arriving at
CoughlinCs !" 9th #t" rental in response to a call >y Coughlin reporting a domestic dispute (t=o o*
CoughlinCs tires had >een slashed and his license plate had turned up missing)% Bust a*ter Coughlin spent his
last I,- >ailing himsel* out o* Bail incident to the <anuary )th% )-) ABay=alEingA arrest ordered >y $.D
#argent .aul #i*re% Coughlin =as pulled over =hile driving home his vehicle a*ter maEing his =ay to it
*rom the 9ashoe County Detention Center (=hich had seen *it to release Coughlin e+actly a couple
minutes a*ter the last $1C >us had le*t *or the night (on a night =here the temperature =as a >almy )(
degrees% =ith a considera>le =ind chill on top o* that) >y the same $.D 3**icer NicE Duralde (=hose =i*e
is an emergency communications dispatcher% <essica Duralde% =hich complicates matters considering that
the petty larceny o* an i.hone case% $C$)-F-,334 stemming *rom DuraldeCs =rong*ul /ugust )-th%
)- arrest o* Coughlin has involved an in@uiry =herein DuraldeCs >asis *or alleging he =as Busti*ied in
conducting a 1erry #top A=eapons checE pat do=nA and or a search incident to arrest =as largely premised
upon some purported Ain*ormation he received *rom dispatchA o* a Adistur>ance or possi>le *ightA% despite
the *act that none o* the discovery% 9 logs% dispatch reports% etc" propounded to Coughlin mention a
Apossi>le *ightA% >ut they do mention a Adistur>anceA and Apossi>le larceny o* a cell phoneA and the A$.
(reporting party) screaming at the accusedA" DD/ 8oung may need to ans=er *or Bust =here this =hole
notion o* Duralde >eing dispatched mention o* a Apossi>le *ightA comes *rom e+actly% other than the
prosecutors =ish list o* things he =ishes there =as documentation o* to support his hopes o* proving
CoughlinCs 7ourth /mendment rights =ere not violated >y an 3**icer eager to sho= up the la=yer in *ront
o* some teenFagers and early t=entyFsomethings" 1o >e *air% those youths did a *air amount o* lying that
- 23/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
night in their *raudulent attempts to cover up the conduct o* Cory ;o>le% =hich may >e tantamount to
having a>andoned (and i* ;o>le did not a>andon it% then anyone =hom claimed it in response to the Aman
holding a si+FpacEA o**ering it up and threatening to Athro= it in the river i* someone doesnCt claim it right
a=ayA% argua>ly AsavedA the i.hone *rom >eing destroyed in connection =ith ;o>leCs alleged negligence or
a>andonment o* it% and there>y% the i.hone =as no longer ;o>leCs% i* it =as% indeed% his to >egin =ith
(=hich is unclear given ;o>leCs contradictory statements in that regard =here he alleges that he himsel*
>ought it three years previously% according to Duralde in his #upplemental Declaration incident to his arrest
report% in comparison to ;o>leCs testimony on the /ugust )9th% )-) 1rial date in $C$)-F-,334%
=herein ;o>le alleges his >rother >ought it *or him three years previously% not that 9C.D <im 6eslie
=ould undertaEe any investigation or issue a su>poena to clari*y such a thing% mind you) his three year old
i.hone 3; (;o>leCs *riend testi*ied that ;o>le set it do=n on the concrete ground at around :-- pm or so
on a #aturday evening in the do=nto=n $eno sEate plaDa in *ront o* City 2all (and ;o>leCs statements in
his 9itness #tatement% that he =as AsEate>oarding ( *eet a=ay *rom the phoneA con*licting sharply =ith
>oth ;o>leCs statements on the audio tape o* his 9 calls (=herein he admits to having >een at his <eep at
the relevant time% =hich =as% apparently% according to ;o>leCs *riend Nathaniel ZarateCs testimony% parEed
on the =est side o* the sEate plaDa% on &irginia #treet% =hereas some still unidenti*ied Aman holding a si+F
pacEA =hom Zarate alleges picEed up the phone o** the ground and held it alo*t (and ZarateCs *riend Nicole
9atson admitted on a video *ilmed >y Coughlin upon his >eing released *rom 7 days in 9CDC% =here this
li*elong resident o* $eno% an attorney% =hose entire immediate *amily lives here% =ho had no criminal
record previous convictions aside *rom a <anuary )--3 AdryA recEless driving conviction% =as denied an 3$
release >y a retaliatory 9CDC sta** *or 7 days% and =here CoughlinCs >ail =as impermissi>ly in*lated >y
DuraldeCs *raudulent overcharging as *elony grand larceny *or the purported the*t o* an item that =as three
years old and on =orth A>et=een I)(- and I3--A =hen it =as >ought ne= three years previously" 1he
- 24/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
$4C impermissi>ly violated N$# ("- =hen <udge ;ardner held CoughlinCs arraignment in C$ ))7,
on 3cto>er -th% )-) during the pendency o* the 3rder *or Competency !valuation o* Coughlin in
$C$)-F-,334" #o% 3**icer Duralde and *ive other $.D 3**icers Bust happened to >e hanging around
CoughlinCs car =hen he *inally made his =ay to it upon his release *rom Bail in the early morning hours o*
<anuary 3th% )-)" Coughlin had previously *iled a =ritten complaint against $.D 3**icer Duralde and
3**icer $on $osa on #eptem>er 7th% )- and <anuary 'th% )-)% maEing such a large sho= o* *orce
incident to that pull over (*or a license plate that Bust so happened to all the sudden turn up missingA% and
the main suspects =ould >e the $.D% or CoughlinCs then house mates% or% *inally% some stranger)" / video
o* the =rong*ul arrest =as taEen >y Coughlin% and here is the transcript (o* the video Coughlin tooE o* the
/ugust )-th% )- petty larceny arrest in $C$)-F-,334):
RETALIATORY ARREST: "Let him do his job or we will call the Nevada Bar and tell them how you cooperated with
our investigation. How's that runnin' for ya?" and "Now, your're under arrest ofr larceny. Now we can search you
incident to arrest. How's that?"
3n the videoGaudio recording o* the arrest ( &0DO)--')-O)3)'-) the *ile name o* =hich represent an accurate time
stamping o* the time at =hich the video *ile >egan recording on 'G)-G at :)':- pm incident to the petty larceny charge
Coughlin is currently *acing in $C$)-F-,334)
(3 second marE)
Coughlin: 0 am scared o* you young Eids"""you have nothing to lose% o* course 0Cm scared o* you"""please
donCt hurt me"""you have clearly scared meA
(at appro+imately the )) second marE $.D 3**icer Duralde arrives on the scene)
/ustin 6ichty: 9e sa= it light up in his pocEet" 2e =onCt give it >acE"
$o>ert Da=son: 2e =onCt give us the phone he stole"
()7 second marE)
Zarate: 0 sa= the =hole thing"
()' second marE)
Duralde: Do you have the phoneH"""0s it in your pocEetHA
Coughlin: 9hatH
Colton 1empleton: 1he i.honeJ
6ichty: DonCt play dum>% Bust give it to usJ
Duralde: 1he i.hone"
(4 second)
Coughlin: DonCt 0 have a right not to ans=er an 3**icer =hen he in@uires as to =hat is in my pocEetsH
5nless this is a 1erry #top% >ut 0 donCt thinE this is a reasona>le cause to do a pat do=n"""
Duralde: 0t is a reasona>le cause to do one"
Coughlin: .erhaps% you might >e right"
((4 second marE)
- 25/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1empleton: /nd i* he calls it and it lights up in his pocEet% =ill that prove itH
Duralde: #et your >iEe do=n on the ground% and move over there *or a pat do=n"
(:-- minute marE)
Coughlin: 1his dog liEes to run a=ay% 3**icer% can 0 tie it to somethingH
Duralde: 1ie it to your >iEe"
Coughlin: 3Eay"
/ustin 6ichty: Corey% 9e can call it" 6etCs call it"
(:-) marE)"
Duralde: Dude% 0 am going to >e real =ith you right no=% the Eid =ill pro>a>ly >e *ine i* you give him
the phone >acE% if not, we are going to get it out of your pocket and you are going to go to jail "
(7rom the :-' marE to the :)' marE Coughlin ties his dog to his >iEe and moves several *eet south
to=ards the #iena in response to DCs direction")
1empleton: 8ou =ant to go to Bail over a i.hone thatCs not yoursH
6ichty: 8ou have a touch screen phone
;o>le: #eriously% 0 donCt get it% you Bust said i.hones are played out"""
(:)' marE)
Duralde: 7ace that =ay% other hand on the >acE o* your head"""this hand on the >acE o* your head% there
you go"""
(:3) marE)
Coughlin: Can% 0 say one thing 3**icerH 0Cm a la=yer"
(:3, marE)
Duralde (startled): 3EayJ (strange slippingGclicE sound emitted on video o* arrest at this point)
Coughlin: 8ou Bust touched my BunEJ 3**icer% 0 donCt appreciate you touching my penis" 0 am a la=yer%
and you havenCt even asEed me a @uestion yet and you are handcu**ing me" 0 donCt see ho= this is a 1erry
#top" 0 =ish you =ould tell me =hy you are proceeding liEe this"
():-- minute marE)
/laEsa: 8ou are a suspect in a larceny o* a phone" 8ou have >een identi*ied >y a victim as a suspect in a
larceny o* a phone" 9e are conducting an investigational stop" 9e checEed you *or =eapons to maEe
sure that you do not have any =eapons%"
Zach: 1hose young men assaulted me% 0 do not see them >eing handcu**ed"
():3( marE)
Duralde: Dude% you are the one =ho is accused o* the *ricEinC crime"
Coughlin: 0 am accusing them o* assaulting me"
Duralde: 3Eay% and 0 am saying that is un*ounded ho= are you inBured"
Coughlin: 5h% assault isnCt inBury% its apprehension o* imminent >odily harm"
Duralde: 3Eay% so =hat did they doH
Coughlin: 1hey gra>>ed me% they pushed me% they reached into my pocEet% and they pulled my dog *rom
me%
Duralde: 0* they touched you its not assault"
Coughlin: """/s a gang o* sEaters% t=enty o* them >acEed me up into oncoming tra**ic"
(3:-( marE)
Duralde: CitiDenCs arrest" 1hey =ouldnCt have >een coming a*ter you i* you hadnCt stolen the Eids phone"
Coughlin: 3**icer% let me tone this do=n a little >it% oEay" 0 have respect *or you"
Duralde: 9hat is your nameH
Coughlin: Zachary Coughlin% Nevada Bar num>er 9473"
Duralde: 0 donCt care =hat your >ar num>er is% =hat is thatH 2o= does that >are on thisH
Coughlin: 9ell% may>e it >ares to=ards"""oEay% you seem to not respect or >e =illing to hear anything an
attorney says% yet a group o* sEaters you >elieve =holeheartedly"
Duralde: Do you have the phoneH
Coughlin: 0Cm not an"""=ell% let me thinE a>out that""""Do 0 have the phoneH Do I have a right not to
answer your question?
- 26/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(3:4 marE)
Duralde: 1ust don't talk anymore"
Coughlin: 3Eay"
(3:4()
Coughlin: Do you have a right to search my pockets right nowH
Duralde: 9hat is your last name% ho= do you spell itH
(3:(( marE)
Coughlin: /m 0 under arrestH
Duralde: Dude% you are detained *or a crime =e have every right to identi*y you"
Coughlin: #o% 0 thinE its under the 2ii>el case =here the guy re*used to give the police o**icer his nameH
$osa: 0ts called 7")3% 1erry #top" 8ou can provide your name or >e arrested *or o>struction"
Coughlin: 8ou Eno= =hat 0Cm talEing a>out"
$.D 3**icer $osa: 8eah% 0 Eno= =hat your are talEing a>out"
Coughlin: #earch incident to arrest"
$.D 3**icer $osa: 1hatCs not =hat your >eing"""you are >eing detained% dude"
Duralde: 8ou are not under arrest"
Coughlin: 3Eay"
(4:( marE)
$.D 3**icer $osa: Provide your name or go to jail for obstruction, and we will call the Nevada Bar
and let them know how you cooperated with our investigation, how is that runnin' for yaH 9e are
tired% and =e are >usy tonight% =e have got >etter things to do tonight than >e out here and de>ate the la=
=ith you" ;ive the man your name and let him do his Bo>" 0s there anything =rong =ith thatH
Coughlin: 9ell% can 0 asE you a @uestionH
$.D 3**icer $osa: NoJ 8ou canCt% Bust provide your name and in*ormation or go to Bail" 1hose are your
options% =e are done discussing the la="
(4:4- marE)
Coughlin: /m 0 under arrestH
$.D 3**icer $osa: 2o= many times do 0 have to tell you% your are >eing detained"
(4:4) marE% dispatch radio tra**ic can >e heard in the >acEground *rom the 3**icerCs radio saying A3994A%
the #tate *ailed to produce any dispatch recordings despite >eing served =ith a su>poena and despite the
*act that such radio tra**ic is recorded under $.D policies)"
$.D 3**icer /laEsa: / decision has not >een made
(4:4, marE% o** in the distance)
#Eater voice% liEely 1empletonCs: 0t =ill either light up or vi>rate"
Coughlin: 3Eay% Can 0 Bust asE a @uestionH
$.D 3**icer $osa: 9hat is your @uestion"
Coughlin: 0 have total respect *or you% >elieve me% 0 do"
(4:( marE o** in distance)
;o>le: He might have switched it over and or flipped it over.
(4:52 mark)
$.D 3**icer $osa: 9ell then give the man your name% sho= him a little respect"
(4:(4 marE)
;o>le: He might have flipped it over to the right if it isn't in there then.
6icthy: 8eah% that is =hat he did"
(4:(' marE)
Coughlin: Can you asE these Eids to >acE o** so =e can tone do=n this situation""
$.D 3**icer /laEsa: 8ou guys can you leave us alongJ BacE o**J 0 said 0 =ould help you out" 3Eay%
allo= me to do my Bo>% oEayH
- 27/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
((:-) marE% radio dispatch tra**ic remains audi>le)
((:-7 marE)
Duralde: No=% you are under arrest *or larceny" No=% =e can search you incident to arrest" How's that?
Coughlin: 9ell% 0 mean% 0 =ish you had asEed me some @uestions prior to arresting me% 0 mean% it might
looE >etter *or you"
Duralde: #tand upJ
((:39 marE)
$.D 3**icer /laEsa: 9ho do you live =ith% #ir"
Coughlin: /t this point 3**icer% though 0 respect you% i* you guys =ant to play so hardcore =ith me% you
Eno="""
$.D 3**icer /laEsa: 0 =ant to try to help you =ith your dog and your >iEe% =ho can taEe care o* your
dogH
Coughlin: 0 live alone"
((:() marE% $.D 3**icer Duralde removes CoughlinCs 21C ;) smartphone *rom CoughlinCs right side
shortCs pocEet% looEs at the screen light up a*ter touching it% and presses the red recording >utton to stop
the video recording)"
1he $.D and or $eno City /ttorneyCs 3**ice misconduct Busti*ies a tolling o* any deadline to *ile a
4otion *or Ne= 1rial% or /rrest <udgment% or any other deadline given the many instances o* such
=rong*ul conduct% including the *ollo=ing <anuary 4th% )-) arrest o* Coughlin in $<C $C$)-)F-,(,3-
*or Amisuse o* emergency servicesA (and add to that the repeated *raud >y the preFtrial services sta** at the
9CDC in lying and comitteing misconduct incident to their retaliatory dealings =ith Coughlin)" 2ere is a
transcript% in relevant part% o* at least some o* the video and or audio recordings o* the momenets prior to
the arrest in $C$)-)F-,(,3- (and !C344 and DD/ 8oung and the $.DG#tateCs misconduct in re*using
to turn over e+cuplatory recordings and materials in that matter *urther provides a good cause% tolling%
e+cusa>le neglect >asis *or granting the relie* re@uested herein)"
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORDING OF RPD INTERACTIONS, IN PART, OF COUGHLIN
INCIDENT TO CUSTODIAL ARREST FOR MISUSE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES INCIDETN
TO CUSTODIAL ARREST OF COUGHLIN ON 1ANUARY 14TH, 2012 IN RCR2012-065630:
$.D 3770C!$ #C2/5$: ho= are you doing over hereH
Coughlin: not so good"
#chaur: 9hatCs =rong"
Coughlin: 4y dog is gone"
#chaur: 9hat Eind o* dog do you haveH
Coughlin: .eEingese"
#chaur: .eningeseH 0 didnCt see a .eEingese =hen =e =ere cominC in here"""do you have a tracEer on it or
somethinC on it% one o* those little scannersH
- 28/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin: 6iEe a microchipH 8ou have si+ cops hereH 9hyH 0 recogniDe this guy over here (re*ercing
$.D #argent .aul #i*re% =hom admits to having ordered Coughlin >e su>Bected to a custodial arrest *or
ABay=alEignA =hich o>structed Bustice incident to Coughlin collecting evidence *or a =rong*ul eviction
la=suit stemming *rom $<C $ev)-F--7-'") 8ou arrested me *or Bay=alEing the other day"
$.D #argent .aul #i*re: No% 0 didnCt arrest you *or Bay=alEing >ut 0 =as on the scene"
Coughlin: =hat =as your nameH
#argent #i*re: 2ereCs the deal"""=hat do you need todayH
Coughlin: 4y dog is gone% threatening statements and smirEs =ere made >y the t=o =omen or girls in here
and the man"""
"""
#i*re: 8ou are not inBured or anythingH
Coughlin: No% sir"
#i*re: are these your roomatesH
Coughlin: she =asnCt she moved in a*ter=ards% itCs my understanding she is supposed to >e living =ith her
mother" Can 0 go in there an here =hat they are saying (motioning to the $.D intervie=ing 6aura 7oreshee
and #tephanie /lla>acE)"
#i*re: No% you have to stay here% =e have to *igure out i* you even have a domestic relationship"
Coughlin: #o% you didnCt arrest me the other dayH
#i*re: No% 0 =as on the scene% though"
Coughlin: #o% =ho did arrest meH
#i*re: its on the paper=orE"
Coughlin: 9ho did arrest meH 3**icer 6eedy% the trainee% or 3**icer Del &ecchio% the o>serverH
#i*re: 3**icer 6eedy% the trainee%"
Coughlin: #o 6eedy =as the trainee >ut he =as maEing the arrestH
#i*re% 8eah% >ut he =as still s=orn personnel" 2o= long have you >een livinC here, manH
Coughlin: =hy =ouldntC you tell me =hat the arrest =as *orH
#i*re: 8eah% they told you"
Coughlin: 9hat =as itH
#i*re: .edestrian in a road=ay"
Coughlin: is that normally necessitate a custodial arrestH
#i*re: 0t can >e"
Coughlin: 9hy did it need to >e a custodial arrest% #irH
#i*re: 1hat one% >ecause 0 said it =asH
Coughlin: 9hy did you maEe that choiceH
#i*re: Because =e had several incidents involving you yesterday% or% uh% 1hursday"
Coughlin: /nd Bust >ecause they involved me% it necessitated a custodial arrestH
#i*re: 8eah% you didnCt @uali*y *or a citationH
Coughlin: 9hy =as thatH
#argent #i*re: 0 Bust told you% =e had several incidents involving you"""
Coughlin: But% =hat i* 0 =as the victim in each incidentH
$.D #argent #i*re: then you shouldnCt Eeep putting yoursel* in that situation"
Coughlin: Oh, okay. (Coughlin previously =orEed as a domestic violence attorneyGadvocate at 9ashoe
6egal #ervices and is =ell *amilar =ith the A>laming the victimA methodology employed here >y $.D
#argent #i*re)G
#argent #i*re: 1hat is =hy you got served =ith the 1.3 (temporary protection 3rder *iled >y $ichard ;"
20ll% !s@"% incident to his a>use o* process and success*ul attempts to o>struct Bustice in
- 29/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1he cases =herein Coughlin =as a victim o* opposing party and or la= en*orcement misconduct
Busti*ying the relie* sought herein% include% >ut are not limited to
$!& )-)F---') North=ind /pts" &s Zach Coughlin
$!& )-)F---'3 North=ind /pts" &s Zach Coughlin
$!& )-)F-7(,(' Zach Coughlin vs <e** Nichols
$<C )-)F-7,74, Zach Coughlin vs North=ind /pts"
$!& )-)F--374 .arE 1errace 1o=nhomes vs Zach Coughlin
$!& )-)F-744-' Zach Coughlin vs .arE 1errace 1o=nhomes
$!& )-)F---4' North=ind /pts vs Zach Coughlin
$!& )-)F--,7 North=ind /pts vs Zach Coughlin
$<C $C.)-)F---)'7 4ilan ?re>s (North=inds maintenance man) v" Zach Coughlin (another 1.3 the
$.D *raudulently induced a landlord to procure against Coughlin% thanEs to $.D 3**icer /lan 9eaver%
#argent 3liver 4iller% and 6tn" ?evin Bro=n)"
$!& )-)F--,' North=ind /pts vs Zach Coughlin
$!& )-F--49) 4att 4erliss vs Zach Coughlin
$!& )-F--7-' 4atthe= 4erliss vs Zachary Coughlin
$<C )-)F-7'43) Zachary BarEer Coughlin vs #uperior 4ini (in this matter% on appro+imately #eptem>er
))nd% )-)% >esides $.D 3**icer 9eaver calling up CoughlinCs mother an attempt to coerce her into
assisting him and the $.D 0n violating #oldal v" CooE County% the $.D and 3**icer 9eaver and #argent
3liver 4iller also attempted to induce #uperiorCs 4att ;rant to *ile another *raudulent Adistru>ing the
peaceA charge against Coughlin shortly a*ter 9eaver s=aggeringly% and in a smug manner% threatened to
*raudulently arrest Coughlin again *or another A*ailure to secure a loadA citation and conduct another
impermissi>le Asearch incident to arrestA or AinventoryingA o* CoughlinCs vehicle" $.D #argent Dye and
3**icer 9eaver had also violated criminal la=s in attempting to dissuade Couglin *rom testi*ying at to their
misconduct in $4C ) C$ )4)- on #eptem>er (th% )-) (#/rgent Dye tracEed Coughlin do=n =hile he
=as deliverying materials incident to his part time Bo>% shortly a*ter midnight on #eptem>er (th% )-) to
attempt to intimidate Coughlin in a #colariCs desolate parEing lot% and 3**icer 9eaver made menacing
gesticulations to Coughlin in court =hile they =aited *or the ) C$ )4)- case to >e called% =herein $eno
City /ttorney committed pro*essional misconduct in violating $.C 3"' in amending the criminal complaint
in that matter to charge Coughlin =ith trespassing% and $4C Ade*endersA ?eith 6oomis% !s@" and 2enry
#otelo >oth violated N$# 7'"4-( and N$# ("-- at various times >y *ailing to a>ide >y the stay re@uired
therein and in o>taining orders allo=ing their =ithdra=al (o* course% the Eept their monthly% princely I7?
Aside gigA payment *rom the $4C% =hich *or all purposes seems to >e made in e+change *or their selling
their criminal indigent clientCs do=n the river and or su>Becting them to impromptu cross e+amination
demanding ans=ers to =hich they are not entitled% especially in 6oomisCs case% and other=ise =ithholding
*rom criminal indigent de*endantCs the *e= inviola>le rights they have% including% the right to counsel under
the #i+th /mendment% the right to su>poena or call =itnesses% and the decision on =hether or not to testi*y"
#torage" 6oomis also committed *raud in assisting in having Coughlin incarcerated =rong*ully *or nearly
)- days in <uly )-)% including his *ailure to *or=ard to the $4C the proo* o* insurance Coughlin provided
6oomis (=hich had already >een provided to charlatan police o**icerCs 9eaver and Dye any=ays)% and in
coercing =rong*ully *rom Coughlin some purported consent to vie= CoughlinCs 20.// protected medical
records (something 9CDC social =orEer <an ;uidetti also sought to do on >ehal* o* $4C <udge Nash
2olmes)
- 30/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin also tooE a video o* the <anuary )th% )-) ABay=alEingA arrest in $4C ) C$ --,9,%
and Coughlin also tooE a video o* at least part o* the <anuary 4th% )-) arrest *or Amisuse o* emergency
servicesA (a gross misdemeanor) in $C$)-)F-,(,3-" Both arrests =ere ordered >y #argent #i*re% as
admitted >y #i*re himsel* in the video Coughlin tooE o* at least part o* the <anuary 4t% )-) arrest" /nd%
curiously% the $.D% !C344% and DD/ 83ung% despite having >een loaded up =ith visi>le cameras and
audio recorders (amongst the various , o**icers dispatched in response to CoughlinCs 9 call o* that night)
have so *ar *ailed to propound (despite 9C.D Dogan purporting to have made such re@uests and or served
the appropriate su>poenas"""though everything =ith Dogan has >een rather AmurEyA% =ith his supervisor
<im 6eslie hovering around the case e+acting a similar toll upon CoughlinCs de*ense as that 6eslie has done
to t=o other cases =herein he purports to >e Ade*endingA Coughlin (in $C$)-F-,334% the i.hone petty
larceny case% =hich Coughlin *inally managed to get 6eslie >ooted *rom on 3cto>er ))nd% )-)% leaving
Coughlin little time to prepare *or the Novem>er 9th% )-) resumption o* that 1rial% particularly =here
6eslie has still *ailed to comply =ith an 3rder in that matter re@uiring him to digitally transmit various
materials *rom CoughlinCs *ile to Coughlin: and in $C$)-)F-,79'-% the A*alse statement to a pu>lic
o**icerA retaliatory prosecution that DD/ 8oung is >ringing against Coughlin incident to a =rong*ul arrest
>y olC 9C#3 Deputy 4achen on <une )'th% )-)% stemming *rom a #ummary !viction 3rder that <udge
#chroeder o* the $<C managed to sign despite numerous =ritten correspondences to the $<C and the
#parEs <ustice Court providing a Aheads upA that the ( day unla=*ul detainer served >y olC North=ind
/partments /ssociates% 66C (a corporation% and there*ore% not entitled to appear =ithout an attorney under
N$C. % nor entitled to utiliDe an entity committing the unauthoriDed practice o* la=% though they did% in
hiring Aeviction consulting and process servicesA *irm Nevada Court #ervices% in $<C $!&)-)F---4'%
=hose licensed process service $o>ert 9ray (or may>e it is $yan 9rayH) *iled a *raudulent declaration o*
service alleging he personally served Coughin on <une 4th% )-) a ( day unla=*ul detainer notice incident
- 31/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
to 9ray and North=indCs 4anager Duane <aEo> attempting to >reaE into CoughlinCs rental L)9 at
North=indCs /partments on that date% a rental =ith no =indo=s =hose door =as closed and locEed% though
9ray alleges to have Apersonally servedA the notice (and there>y cut short >y 3 days the amount o* time the
tenant had to *ile a 1enantCs /**idavit"""though Coughlin did su>mit Bust that to the court listed as having
Burisdiction on the Nevada Court #ervices prepared <une 4th% )-) ( day notice (=hich AmistaEenlyA listed
#parEs <ustice CourtA as the *orum to *ile such a 1enantCs /ns=er or /**idavit)% #parEs <ustice Court% on
<une ),th% )-) (and the #<C *a+ed as much over to the $<C on <une )'th% )-))" Deputy 4achen
arrested Coughlin on <une )'th% )-)% alleging it did
3**icer 9arren 1o >e *air% 3**icer 1ravis 9arren did a rather pro*essional and admira>le Bo>
recently in coordinating% =ith $.D 3**icer 9ilson% a Acivil stand>yA o* sorts at North=ind /partments% on
or a>out 3cto>er -th% )-) =hen Coughlin =ent there to retrieve =hat remained o* his personalty a*ter he
=as una>le to remove it all *rom his three di**erent rentals at North=inds on during the , hours allotted on
/ugust 3thF4th% )-)" / North=indCs apartment maintenance man =as a>le to assist his employer in
su>verting the civil eviction process along =ith some inspiration and coa+ing >y $eno .olice Department
o**icer /lan 9eaver and #argent Dye >y o>taining a temporary order protection against Coughlin on <uly
(% )-) in $<C $C.)-)F---)'7 (4ilan ?re>s v" Zach Coughlin)" 3**icer 9eaver and #argent Dye had
arrested Coughlin on <uly 3% )-) (in $4C )C$)4)-% =hich has no= seen granted two di**erent 4otion
to 9ithdra= >y CoughlinCs court appointed Counsel in that matter: ?eith 6oomis% !s@" (and 6oomis scored
a similar 3rder allo=ing him to depart *rom his purported #i+th /mendment *ul*illment a*ter continuing to
do little =hile un*ailingly collecting his Aside gigA I7? a month as a contracted court appointed counsel *or
the $4C% gotta pay *or that ne= =hite B49 someho=% right% ?eith) and 2enry #otelo% !s@" (also pulling
in a princely Aside gigA as one o* the $4CCs many% many 4c;eorge #chool o* 6a= alumni *ormer
prosecutors turned court appointed prosecutorCs helpers% er% indigent criminal de*endant herders% er% de*ense
- 32/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
counsel% to go along =ith the various 4c;eorge #chool o* 6a= alumni sitting Budges at the $4C (some% o*
=hom% liEe $4C <udge ?enneth 2o=ard% have >een close personal *riends =ith 6oomis since their days
playing on the la= school >asEet>all team >acE at 4c;eorge: <udge 2o=ard% 4c;eorge 9'% another
Budge at the $4C% 4c;eorge% 9'(% <udge Nash 2olmes% 4c;eorge 977% court appointed de*ender
*ormer prosecutor ?eith 6oomis% 4c;eorge 9'): court appointed de*ender *ormer prosecutor 2enry
#otelo% 4c;eorge 9'7: 6oomis has >een >usy puttinC in =orE *or the $4C o* late =ith respect to
Coughlin% managing to torpedo CoughlinCs de*ense in the criminal trespass matter >e*ore <udge 9illiam
;ardner in C$ ),4-( >y *lat out re*using to su>poena either #argent 6opeD or 3**icer Carter% or
landlord 4erliss% despite all three >eing the only other eye =itnesses to the events to the Novem>er 3th%
)- arrest scene (>esides the seemingly conveniently edited videos 2ill and 4erliss *ilmed% =hich 2ill
seemingly never >othered to vie= as they e+pressly contradict his s=orn testimony at the <une 'th% )-)
1rial in that matter) incident to pulling him over *or a minor tra**ic violation and alleged in plastic tu> had
*allen o** his vehicle =herein they charged him =ith *ailure to secure load and *ailure to maintain proo* o*
insurance% despite the *act that Coughlin provided proo* o* his vehicles and should current insurance in the
*orm o* a .D7 highFresolution image o* his insurance card on his ( inch smart phone screen to =hich
o**icer 9eaver declared that the proo* needed to >e on actual paper at =hich point o**icer 9eaver arrested
Coughlin *or distur>ing the peace incident to some alleged statement >y Coughlin that morning at
North=ind apartments =herein 4ilan ?re>s asserts Coughlin said something all along the lines o* AdonCt
mess =ith my locEs again or else youCll >e sorryA (=hich Coughlin did not even say% though Coughlin did
arrive at his rental at North=indCs on that <uly 3rd% )-) morning to *ind AsomeoneA had placed some sort
o* glue in the Eey slot o* the locE on his rentalCs door)% though ?re>sCs statements in his application *or an
order o* protection compared to those he maEes in his =itness statement incident to the <uly 3 arrest o*
Coughlin contains some glaring inconsistencies particularly =ith respect to the protection order going into
- 33/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
some alleged propensity o* Coughlin to carry around large >utcher Enives =here is the =itness statement in
connection =ith the <uly 3 distur>ing the peace arrest *ails to mention such a minor detail" ?re>s also
maEes an allegation that Coughlin >urglariDed his trucE despite the *act that Coughlin has a video o* the
incident ?re>s re*ers to =earing ?re>s admits under o* at the e+tension hearing on his application *or a
temporary protection order that he =as not present during incident =herein his co=orEer 6uEe idea and his
manager D=ayne <aEo> indicated him that they caught Coughlin attempting to >urglariDed his trucE"
Coughlin also has a video o* the incident =herein ?re>s alleges Coughlin =as *ollo=ing him *or ( minutes
and screaming out threats and inciting in the violence" /lso may >e critical o* CoughlinCs propensity to *ilm
things one might asE himsel* =here Coughlin =ould >e had he not all these e+culpatory videos proving the
perBury o* various individuals including 3**icer 9eaver% North=indCs /partmentCs /ssociates% 66C (part o*
the monolithic /C;F/4.0% 0nc"% doing >usiness in ten states operating enormous apartment comple+es that
are Eno=n *or cheating itCs tenants out o* their damage deposits >y asserting especially spurious rationale in
support *or *ailing to so return such deposits) 4anager D=ayne <aEo> (=ho lied under oath at the <uly 3st%
)-) 2earing related to various 4otions Coughlin *iled in connection =ith a =rong*ul arrest o* <une )'th%
)-)% =herein the 9ashoe County #heri**Cs 3**iceCs Deputy 4achen (the same deputy =hose *raudulent
a**idavit o* service *iled Novem>er 7% )- asserted that it personally served Coughlin the locEout order on
Novem>er % )- incident the eviction *rom CoughlinCs *ormer home la= o**ice despite the *act" 4ansions
supervisor 9ashoe County #heri**Cs o**ice civil division supervisor 6iD digital admits and had 7e>ruary
)-) eFmail to Coughlin that matching merely posted" #ummary eviction order on the door to CoughlinCs
*ormer la= o**ice =hen no one =as home and proceeded to then e**ectuate a locEout% and there>y *ailed to
comply =ith the dictates o* N$# 4-"4-- (=hich incorporate the Nevada $ules o* Civil .rocedure into
landlord tenant summary eviction proceedings and unla=*ul detainer actions under N$# 4-" /rrested
- 34/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin (and% yes% that arrest =as captured on video tape as =ell% and is providing another >asis *or DD/
Zach 8oung to *urther hone his retaliatory prosecution chops) an idea
"9hen Coughlin =as in the @uasiFA>asementA (it isnCt a room *it *or ha>itation or use under the 2ousing
Code (only one e+it% ceiling are a>out ( *eet high in most places% *loor =as dirt =hen Coughlin *irst rented
it% >ut he *i+ed it up very nicely over time and it certainly looEed liEe someone could have >een living in
there =ell prior to the eviction% >ut <udge ;ardner ruled all that stu** a>out Ausing it as a residenceA =as
irrelevant% e+cept *or the *act he mentioned it in his 3rder and 2aDlett let it creep into his closing
arguments"""") there =as not any voices calling to him (certainly the videos *ilmed >y 2ill and 4erliss%
propounded to the City and the court appointed de*enders =ho re*used to su>poena 4erliss despite 2illCs
and the $.DCs o>vious motive and >ias"""sho= that neither 2ill nor 4erliss% as con*irmed >y 2illCs 1rial
testimony% made any ver>al incantations to Coughlin% >ut rather% retreated upstairs to =ait *or the $.D""")
prior to =hat =as ultimately revealed to >e the $.D arriving" /s sho=n =ith a lot more indicia o*
relia>ility than 2illCs lie *illed <une 'th% )-) s=orn testimony at trial% in his Novem>er )st% )-
Declaration% 2ill *ails to assert that the $.D Aidenti*ied themselves as la= en*orcementA and issued a
la=*ul order to emerge *rom the >asement (=hich is not necessarily la=*ul% even i* they identi*y themselves
as la= en*orcement% i* they =ere not given the authority to issue it >y someone having such authority% and
its not clearl that either 4erliss or 2ill did""")" $egardless% the $.D de*initely D0D N31 Aidenti*y
themselves as la= en*orcementA prior to 4erliss EicEing the door do=n" $ather% it is telling that in 20llCs
Novem>er )st% )- Declaration he merely mentions the $.D attempting to (see this dissected in glorious
detail in the attached Bar grievance) Acoa+ Coughlin to emerge *rom the >asementA" /nd the $.D did Bust
that" 3nly% they didnCt identi*y themselves as la= en*orcement at any time prior to the door >eing EicEed
do=n" #o% i* you are Coughlin% and you have a real strong claim o* right de*ense to any allegation o*
trespass% then Bust hearing some random voices Acoa+ingA him to talE to them liEe they are therapists or
- 35/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
some other crap liEe that is not tantamount to a Ala=*ul order to emerge *rom the >asementA or =arning to
leave the premises else >e cited or arrested *or criminal trespass" (2ill told Coughlin he =as >illing him the
same I9-- a month as =hen Coughlin =as there under a lease allo=ing *or A*ull use an occupancyA: any
eviction order =as void *or lacE o* Burisdiction% Coughlin =as entitled to a stay Coughlin had yet to receive
>acE *rom the $<C the Arent escro=A I)%)7( that <udge #*erraDDa% on 3cto>er )7t% )-% announced =ould
>e held onto >y the $<C as CoughlinCs A>ond on appealA (meaning the supersedeas >ond% as appeal >ondCs
are set statutorily at I)(- in such matters and supersedeas >ondCs are the ones teh $<C typically maEes in an
amount =orth Athree monthCs rentA (ie% the $<C canCt Eeep the money *or the stay% and call it that% and deny
the stay"""its liEe calling it a summary eviction hearing% >ut ruling on more than possession% then ruling
Coughlin esta>lished a genuine issue o* material *act and noticing the 3cto>er )7th% )- date as a A1rialA
in =riting (BaEer says on the record in that case Athe use o* the term A1rialA =as un*ortunate% 8our
2onor""""A% then ordering an impermissi>le rent escro= deposit"""not giving the )- days to respond to a
Complaint called *or >y <C$C. -9"""">asically giving 20ll and 4erliss all the >ene*its o* the @uicE and
easy summary eviction proceeding (Coughlin =as precluded *rom maEing counterclaims or >ringing in
third party de*endants liEe DicEson $ealty or N& !nergy or ;reen /ction 6a=n #ervice% etc)% and
Coughlin none o* the procedural protections o* a plenary unla=*ul detainer% =hile also attempting to a**or
20ll and 4erliss the >ene*its o* a plenary unla=*ul detainer (a=arding >acE rent% attorneyCs *ees% landlord
=as a>le to >ring a summary eviction proceeding against a commercial tenant >ased only on a No Cause
Notice% ver>oten under N$# 4-")(3""")" 7urther% and this is sho=n on the videos 2ill and 4erliss *ilmed%
the $.D at no time gave Coughlin a =arning to leave =here Coughlin could have heeded it and le*t% or
other=ise >een issue a citation in lieu o* a custodial arrest" 1he $.D =anted to maEe the >ig rich landlord
and attorney happy here% and neither the $.D (=hich =as mad at Coughlin *or *iling a police misconduct
complaint incident to the =rong*ul /ugust )-th% )- arrest o* Coughlin that ainCt looEinC good *or the #tate
- 36/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
no= that Coughlin got 9C.D <im 6eslie >ooted *rom the case in $C$)-F-,334) nor 2ill or 4erliss
=ere going to >e satis*ied =ith Bust issuing Coughlin a A=arningA to leave the premises% as they *igure
Coughlin =ould Bust heed any such =arning""""1he $.D and 4erlissG20ll =ere all BacEed up on revenge
po=der and =anted Coughlin arrested" Dr" 4erliss is practically *rothing at the mouth (demanding Amore
eye contactJA *rom Coughlin in the video AZachCs arrest ---A Bust >e*ore Dr" 4erliss commits a crime in
lying to the $.D in response to CoughlinCs @uerying those there as to =ho =arned him against trespassing
and =hen% =hereupon Dr" 4erliss lies in order to get Coughlin arrested% and 2ill coFsigns it:
$ichard ;" 2ill% !s@" (opposing counsel in the civil eviction case *rom =hich this criminal trespass trial
stems) testi*ied% under oath% that the $eno .olice Department identi*ied themselves as la= en*orcement and
issued a la=*ul order to leave prior to the $.D entering the door that 2illCs client 4erliss EicEed do=n
after such identi*ication and issuance o* a la=*ul order or =arning to leave the premises =as issued >y the
$.D" /dditionally% >eyond the impermissi>le e+tent to =hich $4C D) <udicial /ssistant 6isa 9agner
*ailed to *ile CoughlinCs <une )'th% )-) Notice o* /ppeal (*a+ *iling allo=a>le under $4C $ules% any
3rder >y <udge ;ardner to the contrary spoEe to preFtrial 4otions only)% the 9ashoe County Detention
Center impermissi>ly re*used to timely *ile CoughinCs additional Notice o* /ppeal in a timely *ashion =hile
Coughlin =as =rong*ully incarcerated incident to a =rong*ul arrest >y the $.D% >uttressed upon an
impermissi>le >ail increase (supported in <udge ;ardnerCs rationale >y a Apu>lic health and sa*etyA
rationale not providing a >asis *or >ail under Nevada 6a=)% at an unnoticed impromptu >ail hearing on <uly
(th% )-) =herein the $4C and court appointed de*ender ?eith 6oomis% !s@" coerced *rom Coughlin an
impermissi>le invasion o* CoughlinCs medical records under e+tremely coercive circumstances made =orse
>y the *raud committed upon the court >y $.D #argent Dye and 3**icer 9eaver (the arrest in that matter
) C$ )4)- =as prete+tual and *raudulent% and compounded >y #argent 3liver 4iller and 3**icer 9eaver
su>se@uent misconduct incident to another #oldal v" CooE County violation on their part involving
- 37/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin and #uperior 4ini #torage in an $<C eviction matter stemming *rom police misconduct >y 4iller
and 9eaver on or a>out #eptem>er ))nd% )-)"
1here =as an 3rder 7or Competency !valuation >y <udge Cli*ton in $C$)-)F-,(,3- entered
7e>ruary )7th% )-)% and the 3rder in C$)FF-37, adBudging Coughlin competent and remanding
Burisdiction >acE to the lo=er court =as not entered until 4ay 9th% )-)% yet 6oomis and 2aDlettF#tevens
persisted in seeEing to ramrod the criminal trespass case in $4C C$ ),4-( through"""and >oth =ere
=ell a=are o* the 7e>ruary )7th% )-) 3rder *or Competency !valuation and the import o* N$# 7'"4-(%
re@uiring the suspension o* all proceedings during the pendency o* such an 3rder% made applica>el via
N$# ("-- and the various rationale set *orth in the attached materials" 7urther% the $4C *ailed to *ile the
timely Notice o* /ppeal 0 su>mitted *or *iling on <une )'th% )-)% and =hich =as served >y delivering to
the City /ttorneyCs 3**ice on <une )7th% )-) (timely =ithin - days under N$# '9"--) resulting in the
dismissal o* the appeal" 1he *raud o* the 9C#3% $.D% City /ttorney and others prevented Coughlin *rom
having an appropriate chance to *ile as complete and thorough a 4otion *or Ne= 1rial as he intended%
including a =rong*ul arrest on <une )'th% )-)% the 9CDC denying Coughlin even a phone call *or no
reason *or )- hours% until a*ter the $4C had closed on 7riday% <une )9th% )-)% and then another =rong*ul
arrest on <uly 3rd% )-) >y the $.D% =ith an impermissi>le >ail increase >y the same <udge 9illiam
;ardner =hom should have recused himsel* *rom the <une 'th% )-) 1rial in C$ ),4-( in the $4C%
violating o* most provision *ound in the N$# related to >ail"
C3NC65#03N
.lease grant this 4otion *or Ne= 1rial or &acate the <udgement o* Conviction or 4otion to /rrest
the <udgement (and return CoughlinCs money% including the I3- the $4C Eept% =hich made it t=ice the
usual *ine *or *irst o**esnse criminal trespass) and or reinstate CoughlinCs appeal and apprise D- in C$)F
- 38/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
),) o* CoughlinCs timely *iling a notice o* appeal on <une )'th% )-) and timely serving the City
/ttorney" De*endantG/ppelant Coughlin here>y respect*ully re@uests all 3rders% Convictions% <udgments%
Contempt 7indings% etc% >e amended% set aside% etc"
/770$4/103N .ursuant to N$# )39B"-3-
1he undersigned does here>y a**irm that the preceding document does not contain
the social security num>er o* any person" /nd 0 declare the >it a>out $.D 3**ier 1ravis 9arren and others
is true to the >est o* my Eno=ledge under N$# (3"-4( and that the videos and transcripts are% to the >est o*
my Eno=ledge% accurate and true" 1he restH 9ell% one% tape dont lie" 1=o% i* 2aDlett donCt have to sign a
declaration in putting in all his uns=orn hearsay paBamaFcentric tacEy testimony% 0 shouldnCt have ta" But
to the e+tent that 0 am *orced toH 8eah% that stu** is s=orn to as =ell"
D/1!D this 3cto>er )'th% )-)
OGsG Zach Coughlin
Zach Coughlin
De*endant
- 39/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
.$337 37 #!$&0C!
0% Zach Coughlin% declare:
3n this date% 0% 4r" Zach Coughlin served the *oregoing document >y emailing and or *a+ing and
or placing in the 5#.# mail% /ND .!$#3N/668 D!60&!$0N; 13 12! 3770C! 37 12! $!N3
C018 /113$N!8 a true copy thereo* to:
C2$0#13.2!$ 2/Z6!11F#1!&!N#% !#N"
<32N ?/D66C !#N"
haDlettFstevenscPreno"gov
EadlicBPreno"gov
Company: $eno City /ttorneyCs 3**ice F Criminal Divison
."3" Bo+ 9-- $eno % N& '9(-(
.hone Num>er: 77(F334F)-(- 7a+ num>er: 77(F334F)4)-
courtesy copies *iled =ith the $4C either >y *a+ *iling% emailing and or paper *iling
D/1!D 120# 3cto>er )'th% )-)
B8:
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
Zach Coughlin
.ro #e De*endant Denied #i+th /mendment $ight 1o Counsel and
#u>poenas
- 40/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
00ND!Q 13 !Q20B01#
" !+hi>it : $!6!&/N1 4/1!$0/6# /ND &0D!3# on a CD% including the ne=ly uncovered
e+culpatory videos o* =rong*ul arrests o* Coughlin detailed in the a>ove *iling% including% >ut not limited
to% the *ollo=ing videos% =hich can also >e *ound at the *ollo=ing linE:
rpd sargent lopeD i have a @uestion *or you cr ),4-( --,9, ),'--"=mv (3", 4B)
&0DO)--')-O)3)'- o**icer duralde and rosa ' )- arrest"*lv (9"( 4B)%
#/4O-'9Ompeg4 rpd hill si*re Bay=alEing cr ),4-( tr ),'-- rmc"mp4 ()") 4B)
#/4O-9-Ompeg4 rpd hill si*re Bay=alEing cr ),4-( tr ),'-- rmc"mp4 (-"- 4B)
)-)-,-(O)-43-7 cory go>le *licEs cigarette at coughlin hits coughlinCs le*t shoulder $C$)-F
-,334"mp4 ((", 4B)
and one hundred and ninety *ives (9( pages) o* e+hi>it Cs paperGpd* materials"
- 41/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
!Q20B01
!Q20B01
- 42/42 -
N310C! 37 !$$/1/ /ND $!&0#!D #5..6!4!N1/6 43103N 73$ N!9 1$0/6% 3$% /61!$N/10&!68% #5..6!4!N1/6
43103N 13 &/C/1! <5D;4!N1 3$ C3N&0C103N% 3$ 0N 12! /61!$N/10&!% 43103N 73$ /$$!#1 37 <5D;4!N1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY INCIDENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
PROPERTY LISTINGS
Camera/Photo Equipment - Auto Winder For Camera 21
8000.00
please see attachments for detailes
STN
1
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
$ $
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
BURGR Residential Burglary 12/12/2011 01:25 AM 01/08/2012 01:25 AM 01/08/2012 01:35 AM
121 river rock Street, Reno, NV
Retail Store Unknown
T12000219
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
BUS
775-338-8118 ***
1
TYPE LAST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
REP Coughlin Zach *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com ***
*** Zach Coughlin, Esq.
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
i also want to report a Trespass by Joel Durden, process server for Nevada Court Services on or about October 20th, 2011.
Mr. Durden and an associate from Nevada Court Services assaulted my law practice and trespassed behind the back gate
into the back yard to bang on back room windows. You guys felt it necessary to do a custodial arrest on me for trespass,
well, how about for them? See attached pleading. Casey Baker, Esq. reported the burglary of approx 12 12 11 to me in an
email on 12 14 11, see attached pleading.
Also, richard hill, esq. withheld my State of Nevada driver's license from November 15th, 2011 to November 22nd 2011 and
contributed to the false arrest against me for trespass from November 12, 2011, lying to Officer Carter and Lopez about
whether his office had sent me a bill for the full rental value of the property for November 2011. Officer Carter indicated that
Richard Hill, Esq. pays him a lot of money and therefore, Officer Carter arrests who Richard HIll says to and does what
Richard Hill tells him to do.
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 2
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
Also, I was arrested on August 20th, 2011, wrongfully and am hereby complaining of the lies Nate Zarate told, Officer Duralde
touching my penis and conducting an impermissible search prior to a search incident to arrest, Officer Rosa attempting to
extort a consent to an impermissible search by threatening to defame me to the State Bar of Nevada, etc. etc.
Page 2 of 2
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
PROPERTY LISTINGS
Computer and Electronics - Accelerator Board 21
8000.00
PLEASE SEE ATTACHED DOCUMENTATION
STN
1
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
$ $
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
BURGR Residential Burglary 12/12/2011 01:40 AM 01/08/2012 01:40 AM 01/08/2012 02:25 AM
121 river rock Street, Reno, NV
Retail Store Unknown
T12000222
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
BUS
775-338-8118 ***
1
TYPE LAST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
zach coughlin esq
REP coughlin zach *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com ***
*** zach coughlin esq
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
please see attached reports/pleadings/witness statement
Reno PD Officer's Duralde and Rosa, wrongful arrest, attempts to extort consent to impermissible search by threatening
defaming lawyer to State Bar of Nevada,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PR7q4OI5b0
see other exculpatory evidence here:
http://www.youtube.com/user/anonymousprivacy
The August 20th, 2011 ARREST RUINED MY FUCKING LIFE. I SPENT SIX DAYS IN JAIL, DURING WHICH AN EVICTION
NOTICE WAS ALLEGEDLY POSTED ON MY DOOR, THIS HAS RUINED MY PROFESSIONAL REPUTATION AND COST
ME THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS AND MY PEACE OF MIND, WHY DON'T YOU GUYS START TRYING
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 2
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
FIX THIS MESS INSTEAD OF EXACERBATING IT? BELIEVE ME, I WOULD RATHER PUT ALL THIS BEHIND ME.
Process Server Joel Durden, trespass behind back gate banging on windows in back yard of law office:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_eW3_KZkdZQ&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL
Page 2 of 2
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
PROPERTY LISTINGS
Collectibles and Keepsakes - Bar/Ingot (gold Or Silver) 21
8000.00
PROFESSIONAL REPUTATION RUINED BY OFFICERS DURALDE AND ROSA
STN
1
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
$ $
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
BURGR Residential Burglary 08/20/2011 10:40 PM 01/08/2012 02:40 AM 01/08/2012 02:47 AM
121 RIVER ROCK Street, Reno, NV
Retail Store Unknown
T12000223
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
BUS
775-338-8118 ***
1
TYPE LAST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
ZACH COUGHLIN ESQ
REP COUGHLIN ZACH *** *** *
ZACHCOUGHLIN@HOTMAIL.COM ***
*** ZACH COUGHLIN ESQ
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
SEE ATTACHED
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
PROPERTY LISTINGS
Collectibles and Keepsakes - Bar/Ingot (gold Or Silver) 21
8000.00
PROFESSIONAL REPUTATION RUINED BY OFFICERS DURALDE AND ROSA
STN
1
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
$ $
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
BURGR Residential Burglary 08/20/2011 10:40 PM 01/08/2012 02:40 AM 01/08/2012 02:47 AM
121 RIVER ROCK Street, Reno, NV
Retail Store Unknown
T12000223
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
BUS
775-338-8118 ***
1
TYPE LAST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
ZACH COUGHLIN ESQ
REP COUGHLIN ZACH *** *** *
ZACHCOUGHLIN@HOTMAIL.COM ***
*** ZACH COUGHLIN ESQ
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
SEE ATTACHED
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100300
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
HARASS Harassment 12/28/2011 12:35 AM 01/10/2012 12:35 AM 01/10/2012 01:04 AM
1422 East 9th Street, 2, Reno, NV
Residence
T12000286
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC coughlin zach *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
VIC coughlin zach
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
T12000283 please add this to that report
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY INCIDENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120100302
VEHICLE LISTINGS
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
DOP NRS Destruction of Property 01/02/2012 02:15 PM 01/09/2012 11:15 PM 01/10/2012 12:29 AM
1422 East 9th Street, 2, Reno, NV
Apartment/Condominium
T12000283
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC Coughlin Zachary *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
VIC Coughlin Zachary *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com ***
Zach Coughlin
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
SUS Allaback Christopher *** *
*** ***
***
3
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
*** 37 509 180
MIDDLE NAME
SUS Harrison Laura *** *
*** ***
***
4
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
*** 22 505 99
MIDDLE NAME
Page 1 of 2
REPORT NUMBER: 120100302
VEHICLE LISTINGS
HONDA accord 1996 Silver/Alumin
838NER NV Auto
3000.00
DAM
1
INVL LIC PLATE TYPE LIC PLATE NO LIC ST VEHICLE TYPE VIN
MKT VALUE DMG VALUE YEAR COLOR MODEL MAKE STYLE
DESCRIPTION
LIC YEAR
$ $
PROPERTY LISTINGS
Office Equipment/Cell Phone
Silver/Aluminum
1 HTC G2
500.00
HTC G2 smartphone $500 if not subsidized by a 2 year contract
DAM
1
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
50.00 $ $
Other (None of the Above)
Black
2 Tires 15 inch
150.00
2 slashed 15 inch all season automotive tires for 1996 accord
DAM
2
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
.00 $ $
Other (None of the Above) 1 Room for the night
50.00
they admitted changing deadbolts to my residence for an entire overnight
DAM
3
INVL ITEM QUANTITY BRAND
SERIAL NO COLOR MKT VALUE DMG VALUE
DESCRIPTION
MODEL
OWNER APPLIED NO
.00 $ $
Laura Harrison, 22 slashed two tires on my vehicle. I believe her former name is Laura Petrone; she had a RMC court date
on 12 5 11, Dr. Assad's patient Christopher Ervin "Erin" Allaback, 37 years old,
http://www.whosarrested.com/nevada/washoe-county/reno/wcdc/205001-christopher-allaback
ruined my HTC G2 smartphone when he threw hot coffee on it an me, which was recorded on video, along with he verbal
admission that he did so throw hot coffee on me and the phone and that he meant to do so and was glad to have done so.
Additionally both of these individuals have verbally and physically threatened me and thrown harmful objects at me, with
Allaback chasing me up the stairs to me room, once with a 8 inch butcher/kitchen knife often assaulting and or battering even
breaking the lock to my door and the door itself on several occasions. Additionally Allaback and Harrison have thrown
anashtray at me that shattered against the sheetrock wall on the stairs to me room and left a 1 inch square divot in the wall,
which is also adorned over a 20 foot section with an enormous coffee stain from when he threw hot coffee on me. They
locked me out of my residence, admitting verbally to doing so (on tape I believe as well) on approximately 1/1/11 at midnight,
when the temperature was freezing, bragging that they had changed the deadbolt. They have denied me access to the
laundry washer and dryer I paid for the use of and thrown my property over the fence in the back of the house, including
expensive carpet and padding, and have further made threats to defame and or frame me for false crimes, and causing death
and or substantial bodily harm. Officer Stacey Gardner apparently faked an arrest of Allaback on approx 1 7 2012 and
refused to arrest Harrison. They have denied me access to my mailbox. I believe they put chewing gum in my dog's coat. I
don't enjoy reporting this but they have damaged my life, finances, business, transportation, and mail/communications
resources
NARRATIVE
Page 2 of 2
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY INCIDENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120103420
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
HARASS Harassment 06/08/2012 02:40 PM 06/08/2012 04:40 PM 06/08/2012 04:45 PM
1680 sky mountain Drive, Reno, NV
Retail Store
T12004554
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC coughlin zach *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
Today, the light was shut off to yet another rental unit of mine, unit 29. The light to unit 45 is still shut off. I reported the light
being shut of to unit 29 to Dwayne Jakob minutes after it happened. Mr. Jakob refused to tell me how he felt I was in breach
of the rental agreement other than to indicate that he felt I failed to keep a door locked. He supported that assertion by
admitting that he attempted to unlawfully enter unit 45 by trying to open the door to it, which was closed. He admitted he was
unable to open the door (maybe it was locked?), but rejected any argument that the cause of his being unable to do so may
have been a lock.
I was assaulted on or about 6 5 12 by a member of your staff, Luke. I am attaching a video of the assault, but only a partial
video. Shortly after reporting this second ultra suspicious shut off of the light to one of my rentals, this same Luke attempted
to extort me into leaving the property by falsely accusing me of trying to break into his red and white truck. He claimed he
could tell from about 80 yards away that I was trying to break into this truck, despite our being on opposite sides of the truck.
That is a criminal threat to make a false police report and abuse process through encouraging a malicious prosecution. I may
have a video fo the entire incident, so he will be exposed as the liar that he is for alleging that I was trying to break into his
truck, part
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120103420
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
HARASS Harassment 06/08/2012 02:05 PM 06/08/2012 03:05 PM 06/08/2012 04:38 PM
1680 sky mountain Drive, Reno, NV
Retail Store
T12004553
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC Coughlin Zach *** *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
VIC coughlin zach
*** ***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
on June 5, 2012, I was assaulted on or about 6 5 12 by a member Northwind Apartments staff, Luke. I am including or
attaching a video of the assault, but only a partial video. Shortly after reporting this second ultra suspicious shut off of the
light to one of my rentals, this same Luke attempted to extort me into leaving the property by falsely accusing me of trying to
break into his red and white truck. He claimed he could tell from about 80 yards away that I was trying to break into this truck,
despite our being on opposite sides of the truck. That is a criminal threat to make a false police report and abuse process
through encouraging a malicious prosecution. I may have a video fo the entire incident, so he will be exposed as the liar that
he is for alleging that I was trying to break into his truck, particularly if the video shows no such action taking place. I will let
he and you wonder whether or not I am bluffing about the video for now.
I am writing to complain about a violation of criminal law by NOrthwind staff. On at least two occasions your staff has
attempted to enter the unit I rent without permission. They attempted to open the door without knocking or otherwise
indicating they were about to seek entry. They have never been given permission to enter, nor will they receive such
permission at any time.
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY INCIDENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120105605
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X
TRESPASS Trespassing 09/21/2012 10:55 AM 09/21/2012 07:55 PM 09/21/2012 08:09 PM
7750 West 4th Street, 431, Reno, NV
Storage Shed
T12007703
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC Coughlin Zach *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
SUB grant matt
superior.storage@yahoo.com ***
Marvin Dye Jr
***
***
2
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
Please place a copy of this complaint of police harrassment by Officer Alan Weaver in his personnel file. I already spent 18
days in jail incident to his wrongful July 3rd, 2012 arrest in 12 cr 12420, and his and Sargent Dye's fraudulent and succesful
to have my bail raised impermissbly on July 5th, 2012. Further, please do the same for Sargent Oliver Miller and Ltn. Kevin
Brown as they threatened me with criminal trespass where I still had a valid lease at 1680 Sky Mountain Drive, Northwinds
Apartments. Now today, they are up to it again at Superior Mini Storage. Pursuant to an agreement of August 28th, 2012, I
am a sublesse to Derek Swanson, some might say, and have 30 days thereunder to use the facility, whereupon contractual
interpretation need be done as to whether that is a reoccuring monthly agreement/obligation. See Soldal v Cook County for
the proposition that it is a 42 USC Sec 1983 violation for OFficer Weaver to seek to play landlord tenant Judge. Weaver was
harrassing me again today and threatened to make another baseless custodial arrest of me, then subsequently returned to
Superior Storage in an attempt to influence another private citizens, similar to the Milan Krebs "distrubing the peace" arrest of
July 3rd, 2012, to sign another baseless criminal complaint at Weaver's urging. His lack of professionalism is appalling.
Further, he an Sargent Dye attempted to intimidate me as a witness, Dye finding me thirty minutes after midnight in a parking
lot the night before trial, Weaver by making menacing jestures in court the mornign of Trial. Superior and Matt and Ken Grant
admit to illegally locking out tenants for 14 years by disablign the gate code if rent not paid by the 10th day of the month,
which violates NRS 108, further if the disagree to the arrangment I have with Swanson, they need pursue a civil rememdy,
not have Officer Weaver embarass the force some more.
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 2
REPORT NUMBER: 120105605
Page 2 of 2
RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT SUMMARY SUPPLEMENT REPORT
REPORT NUMBER: 120105605
INCIDENT INFORMATION
X TRESPASS Trespassing 09/21/2012 08:45 PM 09/21/2012 08:45 PM 09/21/2012 08:49 PM
7750 West 4th Street, 431, RENO, NV
Storage Shed
T12007705
LOCATION TYPE THEFT TYPE METHOD OF ENTRY PT OF ENTRY ENTRY LOC
REPORT FILED FROM TRACKING NUMBER LOCATION OF OCCURRENCE
INCIDENT CODE INCIDENT TYPE INITIAL
SUPP
DATE/TIME STARTED DATE/TIME ENDED DATE/TIME REPORTED
R2273/Carol Starks
APPROVED BY
METHOD OF EXIT PT OF EXIT
PERSON LISTINGS
VIC coughlin zach *** *
zachcoughlin@hotmail.com *** ***
***
1
TYPE LAST NAME FIRST NAME DOB RACE SEX DRIVER LIC NO LIC ST
HOME PHONE
WORK PHONE
RESIDENCE ADDRESS EMAIL
EMPLOYER NAME BUSINESS ADDRESS
SSN ETHNICITY RESIDENT EYE COLOR HAIR COLOR AGE HEIGHT WEIGHT CELL PHONE
MIDDLE NAME
Matt Grant opened up my box of personal property and filmed it with her video camera despite my expressing my refusal to
allow her permission to do so. Violation of privacy, reported to RPD, did nothing but allow Alan Weaver and O. Miller to
harrass me some more and Welch to threaten to arrest me if I didn't not move my stuff right then.
NARRATIVE
Page 1 of 1
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Close Print
Your Online Police Report T11005956 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report T11005956 Has Been Rejected
Your Online Police Report T12000219 Has Been Submitted
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 9/07/11 9:36 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t empor ar y r epor t number i s T11005956.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 9/07/11 10:51 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
We' r e sor r y t he f ol l owi ng pr obl emwas f ound dur i ng r evi ew
of your submi t t ed r epor t T11005956:
THI S I S NOT THE FORUM FOR THI S TYPE OF COMPLAI NT HOWEVER THI S REPORT WAS PRI NTED AND PASSED
ON TO THE OFFI CER' S SUPERVI SOR AND I T WI LL BE ADDRESSED.
Thank you,
Of f i cer WOZNI AK,
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Sun 1/08/12 1:35 AM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12000219.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report T12000222 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report T12000223 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report T12000283 Has Been Submitted
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Sun 1/08/12 2:25 AM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12000222.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Sun 1/08/12 2:47 AM
To: ZACHCOUGHLIN@HOTMAIL.COM
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12000223.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report T12000286 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report 120100300 Has Been Approved
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Tue 1/10/12 12:29 AM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12000283.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Tue 1/10/12 1:04 AM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12000286.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y f i ve busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 1/11/12 3:09 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120100300-0.pdf (76.4 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your r epor t has been appr oved r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120100300.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report 120100300 Has Been Approved
Your Online Police Report 120100300 Has Been Approved
Your Online Police Report 120100300 Has Been Approved
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 1/11/12 3:29 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120100300-1.pdf (76.4 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your r epor t has been appr oved suppl ement al r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120100300.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 1/11/12 3:29 PM
To: ZACHCOUGHLIN@HOTMAIL.COM
1 attachment
report-120100300-2.pdf (62.7 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your r epor t has been appr oved suppl ement al r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120100300.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 1/11/12 3:32 PM
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report 120100302 Has Been Approved
Your Online Police Report T12004553 Has Been Submitted
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120100300-3.pdf (64.5 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your r epor t has been appr oved suppl ement al r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120100300.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 1/11/12 3:35 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120100302-0.pdf (81.2 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
Your r epor t has been appr oved r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120100302.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Fri 6/08/12 4:39 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12004553.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y t en busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report T12004554 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report 120103420 Has Been Approved
Your Online Police Report 120103420 Has Been Approved
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Fri 6/08/12 4:45 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12004554.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y t en busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Mon 6/11/12 4:10 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120103420-0.pdf (71.4 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your r epor t has been appr oved r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120103420.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Mon 6/11/12 4:11 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report T12007703 Has Been Submitted
Your Online Police Report T12007705 Has Been Submitted
1 attachment
report-120103420-1.pdf (70.9 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your r epor t has been appr oved suppl ement al r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120103420.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Fri 9/21/12 8:09 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12007703.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y t en busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Fri 9/21/12 8:49 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your onl i ne r epor t has been successf ul l y r ecei ved and t he
t r acki ng number i s T12007705.
You wi l l be not i f i ed vi a emai l of any pr obl ems wi t h your
r epor t . Once your r epor t i s appr oved, i t wi l l be i ssued
a case number and you wi l l r ecei ve a PDF copy as an at t achment
i n your emai l wi t hi n appr oxi mat el y t en busi ness days.
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease
cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons you have f or i mpr ovi ng our
syst em.
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...orts%20by%20coughlin%20063341%20duralde%20carter%20lopez%20sifre%201708%2026405%2026800.htm[10/29/2012 4:08:55 AM]
Your Online Police Report 120105605 Has Been Approved
Your Online Police Report 120105605 Has Been Approved
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Thu 10/04/12 3:42 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120105605-0.pdf (10.8 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your r epor t has been appr oved r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120105605.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
From: NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Thu 10/04/12 3:54 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
1 attachment
report-120105605-1.pdf (8.6 KB)
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THI S E- MAI L****
****THI S I S AN UN- MONI TORED MAI L BOX****
Your r epor t has been appr oved suppl ement al r epor t and t he per manent number of t he case i s
120105605.
t he del i cat e i nf or mat i on i n hi s r epor t has been r epl aced f or *** t o suppor t i sol at i on i n
t hi s emai l .
Thank you f or usi ng our onl i ne r epor t i ng syst emand pl ease cont act us wi t h any suggest i ons
you have f or i mpr ovi ng our syst em.
Onl i ne Of f i cer
Reno Pol i ce Depar t ment
10/01/12 09:20AM HP LASERJET FAX
p.02
aTY OF RENO, Plaintiff
l@cQprv Coughlin. Defendant
IN THE MUNICIPAL COURT OF THE CITY OF RENO
COUNTY OF WASHOE, STATE OF NEVADA
vs.
Dept 1110. 1, '/
...
Name (First, Mlddl .... !.ilst)

PO Box 3961. Reno. Nv. 89505
City, State, Zip
MOTIQN
Comes now the undersigned and here make the following request:
MOTION TO BE RELIEVE!;! AS CQVNSEL
This Motion is based on the following:
HENRY SOTELO. ESQ., has ZACHARY COUOHUN since August 13, 2() 12, and has petformed
legal services in that regard. Circumstances have developed which have led to the breakdown of
communications between Attorney and the Client, a difference of opinion and deterioration of the
Attorney/Client relationship. Nevada Supreme Omrt, Rule 46 provides:
The attorney in an action or special proceeding may be changed at any time before .judgment
or final determination us follows:
1. Upon consent oCthe attorney, approved by the client.
2. thereof O!l .. or thc client.
After judgment or fina! determination, an attorney may withdraw lIS attorney ofrccord at any
time upon the attorney's filing a withdrawal, with or without the client's consent.
(emphasis added). HENRY SOTELO, ESQ., moves this Court to issue an Order allowing the withdrawal of
counsel. There has not yct been a final determination in this case, therefore, the Court's permission is
necessary. Nevada Rules of Professional Conduct 1.16(b)
(0) Except as stated in paragraph (c), a lawyer may withdraw fi'om representing a client if
(I) Withdrawal cnn be accomplished without material adverse effect on lb, interests of the
client;
(2) The client persists in a COIUlle of action involving the lawyer's serviccs that the lawyer
rea.wnably believes is criminal or fraudulent;
(3) The cliem bas used the lawyer's services to perpetrate a crime or fraud;
(4) A client insists upon taking action that the: Imvyer considers 1Y!pugmmt or with w!tich
tlte lawyer Itas fu "Jame1<tai difu.greement;
lO/Ol/l2 09: 20Al! HP LASERJET FAX p.03
(5) The client mils substantially to fulftll an obligation to the lawyer regarding the lawyer's
services and has been given rea!lonable warning that the lawyer will withdraw unless the
obligation is thlfilled;
(6) The representation will result in an unreasonable financial burden on the lawyer or has
been rendered unreasonably difficult by the client; or
(7) Other good cause for withdrawal exists.
(emphasis added)
HENRY SOTELO, ESQ., SI.at0s sufficient ["ea.'IOIl;; .""ist for permitting HENRY SOTELO, ESQ., to w;thdr"w
from representation at this time.
HENRY SOTELO, ESQ, asserts it would be impossible for him to provide and competent
representation for ZACHAR Y COUGHLIN as the client insists upon taking a course of action that the lawyer
considers repugnant and with which the lawyer has a fundamental disagreement, In addition. ZACHARY
COUGHLIN and HENRY SOTELO, ESQ. are unable to engage in the type of open communication thaI would
be helpful in providing a reasonable chance of proper representation by HENRY SOTELO, ESQ.
Furthermore. as the case in Reno Municipal Court now stands, ZACriAR Y COUGHLIN is being charged with
a minor vehicle traffic violation: Unsecured Load, RMC 6.14,.130, The more serious charges ofTrcspassing
and Disturbing the Peace have been dismissed by the City Al10mey at the last trial date on U23f2012. Thus,
since ZACHARY COUGHLIN is not facing any jail time for the minor traffic violation, a COURT
APPOINTED Legal Defender is not necessary.
Finally, ZACHARY COUGHLIN will not be adversely all'ecled by this withdraw, as his no new trial date has
been reset, pending a Competency Hearing in Reno Justice Court on October 15, 2012. This allows
ZACHARY COUGHLIN enough time to retain new legal counsel.
Accordingly, HENRY SOTELO, ESQ., requests an order from this Court permitting him to immediately
withdraw from legal representation of ZACHARY COUGHLIN, This Motion is not made for the purposes of
delay. Deputy City Attorney Brian Sooudi has been notified ofthis Motion and has NO OBJECTION to the
above request
, declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
.
J61
10/01/12 09:20AM HP LASERJET FAX
p.04
ORDtR
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the motion be:
YGramed __ ,Denied __ Other
DATED THIS of. .oCa 2012
We. , .. 8''---.. --.-'.,
HOnOrabUlf3Y Dilworth. Judge. Depc One
STATE BAR OF NEVADA
September 4, 2012
Zach Coughlin
P.O. Box 3961
Reno, Nevada 89521
RE: Grievance I Keith Loomi s, Esq.
Reference No. 12-1354
Dear Mr. Coughli n:
Please allow this letter to acknowledge receipt of your August 28, 2012,
grievance to the State Bar of Nevada regarding attorney Keith Loomis, Esq.
A review of court records and the information provided indicates that your
grievance invol ves issues best addressed in the appropriate court settings. The
Office of Bar Counsel and the disciplinary boards of the State Bar are not
substitutes for the court system. The State Bar has no authority to take any act ion
which could affect the outcome of any ci vil di sputes or litigation. Accordingl y.
your allegations are. at this time, more appropriately handled in the proper judicial
forum.
Therefore, the grievance has been di smi ssed. As such, please consider this
matter closed.
I f a court makes any findings that clearly establish professional
misconduct, you may submit that infonnation with any supporting documentation
for reconsideration.
Thank you for bringing thi s matter to the attention of our office.

Patrick O. King
Assistant Bar Counsel
POKlvh
600 Charleston Blvd.
Us Vegas, NV 89104-1563
phn"r - 02.3 2.2200
,0111," 800. 254.2- 97
f:u. - 02.385. 28- 8
9456 Double R Blyd .. St.:. B
Reno.!\'V 89521 ;9--
:t!-.O!I( --5.329.4100
r .... - 75.329.0521
UJUJIV.lIvbar.org
lASI SlMMR\
LA5 ^O. RCR2011-063341
SI:l!r Of "1\t8 V'S.Zachary Barker Coughlin
ornst
I PETIT LARCENY
neg
M
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
Locauon:
Ju0ICI8 OCer'
Filed on'
PgCBcy Number'
D1Slnc\ Attorey Number:
Probable Cause Number:
HnuCril11inll
Sf(rraz. Pefer
0812412011
RI)II-OI6J99 (RPI)
432068
RI'DII \2566C
lJal(
08/24/2011
Case Type: Mistl'lIIllIIiOr
Arrest. 08124/2011 RPD - Reno Pohee Department
Ca Status' 09/0712012 Aeli""
2. POSSESSION OF STOLEN
PROPERTY
M 08/2412011
AlTcst: Osn4l2011 RID - Reno "oher Dep:mcnl
StaliSlifal Closures
0510712012 Transferred (before/durmg tnal)
Ronds
Cash Ball wllh NOller ,63376 5465 00
11116120118:5);40 Iosted
AM
Counts: 1,2
Own RCcognt7.nCC "62023 oU
Counts: |.
l11
l'laln'irr
Dffend",t'
Current Cas( Assignmenl
Cae Number
Coun
Dale AssIgned
JuuLIUl Occr
Tilt 5UI[t of Nt\'atlll
Coughlin. Zachary Ulrkrr
RCR2011-063341
RenoCnmmal
082412011
SfCr11l, Peter
I'\NI' /'H)N\I\IIO'
Wilne5S
ZARATE, NATII/\NIEL KRAIG
1)\11
Case Flags. Upcoming Hurings
al('l Tr2I1SCri
l
ll
LcudAllory
Young, Zach
77S-328-3200 x3S IO(W)
Public Uer L DCcI
KPmIct
77S-337-l800(\V)
08/2-2011
08124/2011
::,':"
g
"

''' '
. :..-.-0'ml0It0c]hCCJJ16",d l:J .
( I<
08/24/2011 I'lea (JudIcial Officer- Sfer. Peter)

I. P1l1 LAKCtNY
Not GUilty
I'AG" l O5
c_ ' '
I!mOH I002J0I?m!7JXM
b/Z3lZ11
b/Z3|Z11
b/3|11
V/b/Z11
1l1Z/Z11
1l1J/Z11
1/1J|Z11
1/0lZ11
11 1+lZ11
11/ZZ1I
Z'V'1
lASi SlMMARY
CASE 1. RCR201'-063341
Vr|8!gUtIIrn!(1.P^| (Ju0\C\8Ll.00f: b0J . 0I0f|
8t btl
(n Recognt:ana: 8011 Condmons l by Ihe Ifonorubl" Jad Srhroder
l
'
46j MO0Jor Cah Hall Hall CondltlOllS m;b) IheIlQrorable ,e,. _
1
_
,1I1Lunrtttl1r(bP^) (u0l0IL6 LlI0
j\lollonlrtanq ^^) (Ju0ICI3L00l b0I|dJ 0f
f^LLLLL jIOllon llearing (1 ^^) {Jut|IrlI Omrrr: ,-,"rh, I:urld)
VQcaled
CANCELED 1 \lolion Htaring (.P^) {Jutlid1 Omrtr: Sftrrazu, I'rur)
Vael/lti
ilolion llraring (1 ^) (JD0\0mLl10f >0D. 0I0f|
Hmb0I
40J0Hond or Cash 8ml Bad Condl/lOnS lby tlu,lIonoftble "tIer J Sferra=a
I'r,Trial Conrertntt (. AI) (Ju0I0IdLl1Cc| bl0fG 0I0f| ___ _
\ittIitorrm1(b, ^^) (Jv0I6I\L0f` bl0D.c|cf|
"~ - ,_

==

C
J
H,p'"o
s""
,o

""o

'
_
/

00/Z1Z
3|Z1Z
3|l1
3'/ Z1Z
310Z1Z
3|J/Z1Z
I1
Neao

Request for S'lbmlSSlon

"urll($ Prest'1I1 PlulII/if[ The SIlJ ;N4Ul/u
-4>' I
I'llbfte De/ender L0m Joe

Deputy Lt$IrtCI"/lome YOt g

,

/) ,j",do'" Cm'ghl .

^WBdl0d|hL0uHIJu0CIdLl1\00f. bl0H'M7d 0|0f |
' /
?
De/nse requested 10 be trul15jerrtd 10 Menial 1I('0/{ 1I Court Sture til/not o as fong as

,he lk/em/am entered a pfea 10 Ihe cnarglS The Courtjnd Ihat the lk/em/mlf dos not tn/act
hmY M ent",. a plea Stale requesud Ihol i the COlirt decu/IS to trolll/er Ihls caJe M Mental

fleallh Cour/. prior to Ihat hapfNntng, "ltnell/eel paid tn tle an/oullt 0/575 () lk/ense

opposed s/olmg th/endllll ha no means 0/ pa) tng "'Iness feel It 1 ordered that Ihe

fk/rndanl lS to pay S75 () \llness /e b)' May 7. 1013 Upan/urthtr or/er o/ lht Calm, thIS
/
cwe I$trans/erred to Ihe jlmSd,CI/On o/Dwncl Court Menla/lfeallh Coun "'lhOUI a plea /
L5InScfIc0 l0Pn0th0rL0uG
Kcqu05! Of Pu0IoLL ltc0
rrqueSled by Joseph Goodnlghl, lput' ('ubbc De/ndKr
Kcnd|0tttbtCon0Ju0I0I0 I90IClLOuH IW0
Omer Rewrl/lIIg Case/rom Speclall) Court 10 Ongmal Dt'punm"m
1sdrmvnu:rUI (V ^^1) (Ju0tCt0!Cc| blc0 a, Ct0f|
I'arlles Preselll "{alnIi tcStOle 0/ N""uda
F^L1OI5
t `

-
`-

Ir '



FrnIrlU !0KJ/.0JJR ! Jd1l
08.'09/2012
08:09/2012
08/091 2,l
08JOW2012
\4
081 27.2012
OS/27,2012
0827/2012
127/2012
081292012
|

0819,2011
lASI S MMAR\
t^SL ^O. RCRlOII-063341
DepUIY DUtrlCI Al/ornC"' lung 7AIh
rf
De/<ndant
COI/ghiln, Zacha, 8arJer
Pub/I! fk/Indlr 80sler, Jlrlm>

Hc8fIhgKcSuI [Jut0m|'ICcf bR,cIcf_

Ik/ense IIOl'S lor conllnuance. l'ubhc I/ender Jerem) 805er Indlcoled thOl U nClo Depuy
l'ubtc De/ender shal b apponled to raJe Ol' Ihl case SIOIe Agrs Trlol $hMlset on
Augl 29. lOll. umOlIO shall Mdendcd al Ihal da_
`
'
KcqucSI oIPud10L1t1o
' |
No!I0h 1td
10 /'rOCIII/ H Forma Puuperlx

N0I1oH1cIcd

'l
f0I',,,,d 1 ,
NIICc
/ Z
T|eI /onorlble Ptter J S/erra;a" III heu
;
MOIIon 10 Supprss 1I 11Je lime sel or1'rwl
Nu0Lfahtcd
10 slrlk, s.cond Amlnded Crlmlllal ComplOln1
HcJIIhg KcSull
nJe SllIIt rem/ ol /erll "Ico negoUllO7U mto IIii' record III uCt IIInrIhe lJ/tndlul accepled
1/'1 olered plea The Statejilf/ A me"ded emmnul Lomplaux lIelrlllg pro<"edcd AI
roncl!uion a/ til hearing, I1Je n)Urt wu|not acel lJl,/ CII(/(III/'s pl4a 711 Stall mOW!l/ 10
SlrlJe mended Crmllnlll COII/plaml GRANTElJ TrJlI r('/IIlS set AliglSt 19, 1011. lt 9 00
AM
F
m

MlsdclItnor Trhll (9, 00 ^N) |Jud1CIa'lCcf

ZACIIARY COLLIILlN lC
bIcffaZ'a, cIcf)

08 911011

.
_

Conllnued 10 081911011 MSC RCeIlConmMaH'

O4 . Coughllll, Zuha,) 8arkt>r
l'aresPresenl Plalnlll TnfSal('o/Nt'adll
/Hpur DlSfC'I Allorne\ )Oung. 7ch

lendlnl Cough"Il, 7Achan Bark"r

IM, {,.d" /,1". Jam4 .

R"", |ePud10LL1c

Reqlleslit/ b\ JIm 5hc, Jeput) Publtc lJt1em/if

`
10OgKcSuI (JuI0:8'IC0t bI0U/ 78. 0|0|

Ik/emlom mldrtssel/ mO/lon 10 QpoI l oCounsei Ik/em/ams COl/llstl addressed mOllOIl 10 I

IlpfOmt (o-colms . f TteSlIt(' opPOI. mOllon tIOppomt c-t<tmvr MotIOn IENI/l I/
De/tlliam so cloos(s the CO/If WI" COIII/IiC/ a Fartl/a C(lIlI'S IhIldalll mo,'td lor self
r(preSl'I J/Mlon The Court C0t|VG5$t'd1111 lJt,/ entialt/ regarding Ihe Parella tnqWf The SII/e
l'AGl: JO| 5
1',,, ltd O!0JZ?0!2m!I JAM
08'30fl012
09/0512012
09'0512012
09i05/2012
09107/2012
09/122012
09117/2012
09/17/2012
10/022012
1012212012
11119/2012
lAl l
lASI SlMMAR\
!A>l 1. RCR201 1-063341
ObfCC|5 |OrfCud0uI
'
5 mOIIOuIOrCrC5CuItlU uCg Or| ltC grOtt0dlh0/lI IS :th'ltmCy0ud lh0I
|h15J fOr |hCItrO5C OfdC0y0ud uOIth gOOd f0dh jud0m`5cittA$r/uJrC5$8dmOItOlIfOr
5CjCC5ruI0IIOn OltOu^ !ACI0Ir
'
5 mOl|O/ IrtkC 0DCIlIIICIIlS /h0 WCrC
l/d 5OCybyIhC7jrudutrl I$ hCrCby A^1 JhC?jrud0uI rC\'tOu5)Cd OItOu |O
ttr?55 Olt0I| C0t1Ig0ccCdCd !AC I0I8OO5rrjCud0uI5OItouO ur
LrjCrId0ttI`5ttOltOt| |OtqrC55A^1/0 hC rIIruIOjlm 0IdO\vlI 5C0rCh Jrl0
OCCCdCd UlI0C55C5 hrd |O$ttbOtm5.
0Request for AudiO CD Filed
rrguC5ICd byZ0Ch0t}LOughlth
Misdcmtllnor Trilll (10:00 AM)
0r|tC5rr5CttI '0mIt_
!rI/Q'/$Irtt/ AlIOrtrj:
rjt'ud0ul
tlbIC?fC00Cr
lIur55
tC./mOj^cI0d0
f0tmg, Zch
LOughtn.Z0Ch0t)0r8Cr
L0tC,J0mC5rt0ud
Lttr0dr, ^lChO05
lIearmg Result (JudiCial Officcr' Srcr., Peter)
Jrt0 rOcCCdCd 'ttr5ttdBI IO IhC Lr|CrOj lhCLOurI. dttdtO rOcrrt/lttg5m0ybC gnCu I0
!tIJ0ItI 0IuOcO5I rjrruC htOI'c$jOr 0 COmrICuQ' C\`0tt0ItOu OIIOIt A^
rj.'trd0tiI5OrdCrCdRObmltt0 IOmrh0 c)Iwt/Itrt|IOtt Jrt0COttIttmCdI0 Lc|Obrr J, /,
U V A A rCl0tI jOrJIIIge jCrr0L0
_Requesl for AudiO CD Filed
CgttC5I jOr 0udtOI0I ttbhc0xrucjrOmC/rud0ttIgr0ltlCd byJudgrCrr0L0
Order Filed
Lrdrr jorLOm!rrt'L\'0u0ItOuttr5u0uIIO^ 4J gCd
qRequcst ror AudIO CD FIled
CguC5ICd byZ0ch0QLOttgmtr'
Request for AudiO CD Filed
rCguCId byJo|mC5lr.Cu|yublcCfCudCr
gRequest ror AudiO CD Filed
rCguc5Icd byJ0mC5c5lC,?1tQttbcCj0mrr
Evaluation Completed
lOmCICttC}'1'0tt0ltOIt
^u\uu 1rWf uj(10:00 AM) (Judicial Ofcer: Sfcm Peter)
LOmCIruIIOuC0rtug
`S01IIIItIu1Trial (8:30 AM) (JudiCial Officer' Sfen.a, Petcr)
LA L.-DJJ4 t50 LCd.!JJL dZZ LL^^L!
1A!1L LL17^
//., COttItlmCd I0//V, - 'rC-Jrmr5CI/LOuImu0ncC~ 1Ml0ICOj
^t'10d0, COtt h/ltt,Z0ch0 10rkcr
O,fClJd:znt Coughlin, Zachary Barkcr
Total Charges
Total Payments Bnd Credits
lJalantc I)ue as or 1012120lZ
1AN1 1Al lHVl Al lON
75.00
0 00
15.00
IAGE40rS PrifllNDn l(l11011m II J91I


\
IlIIIUI.:nt lIll!!::
/l'h Coughlin.h.q.
`I \ ada Bar `1. 947}
14:2 |. '>th SI..
RI1H1, NV 8951:
!\
\cB

\"1
`

Cll-tOUll.t1 f;')r Ikl,:ndant Coughlin

I' 1111'.11 >IICI l\l'R I 01 RI.:>O I 01\ Sllll'
t
I ,\SIlI OR 1111' L\l I Y OF \'ASIIOI:, S r,\ II: OF :I'VAIM
SI \11' l `\ V,\\)\,
L\I "l!. RCR 11-061,-11
PIuinli |I+
DFP | `\. ,
`S.
RI'IJ RI' IIOI6399
,'ACIII\RY L\l (;IILlN: !
!
Ik|cnuanl.

____
_ , f
W\|O-v J 1. '!>L
I'OIN I SAND AIIIIIORII'II'S
FACIS
1lotion Ix ]>1.1':'011111 lilt-s of 1`! a >un| Ol1il'lr Nicholas \)urulde admill('d, on the night ol'the
am::.!. \ Ddcndant /al'h Coughlin Illal hI.' had compJainh lillt1 again>I him ill the pa.1. .te1ll1l1ing
(rom hi: l'mpltl me:nl a: u puJile ollil'l'r. amI furthlr indil'ate:t! th:1I Itl' hat! bl'cl1 sueu ill Ih::l CUIXlcil)
pre' il\u . l A 1994 cn > C againt the RPI) and OSu !hO\\. t|pOH COUftCOIlIlccl for Ihe >cconu luuil'ial
I )i :!It.I Lu\|I|.
RI'D mi:conduct ju .. tiiies:t dimisal or applic,ltil\!l oj" 1" l'llI.iollar ruk in e:,cral \\<.1):.. RPO
I )uril Icjoked .iitu i11Uxk.U\oughIU.men:lc:i n gl i nd iClcd he: "ns IJ\Crchargi ng Ihl oncne: as
"grand 1<m:l'n" Iran olckr IIhlldcl Jg iPhone Ihal t:karl

\\l>!1
'
1 "urth IllUrl' tl1l:l1 !0. lJpon
intimll:llion ,lilt! lx:lid'und Duralth:'s ()\\n mlnlcing statl'me:nts. Ihi \| dUll\.' hcallse it "nulu
inc{lI1\ nicm:e and J1uni:h Coughlin more gi\ 111 Ihl' gr:1\ it D!th charg\. '. uln3ge: his rputalion.
rcquirl: great hail. U pft;'t111 Iht ,)llCllt: f[1I1I1 !In.ding UI III.tur in tile: RP() Offil'e:rs prl''>C1H |u
mi .. l!t:II1t::lmlr c:ulOui,11 arrt: ^ |:Ilnl pl:fn1i' :ihlc \\l'rl' Ihi" i:lhl case unt!I. 'r IRS). lutJll'r !hl D,'
\,
y
Ht.NO 1HlU^Al
LASI SLMMAR\
LA5 ^O. RCR2012-065630
Stall LNe"lda * ZBthB] iJarkrr Coughlin
9
9
Locallon.
JudlclalOfficcr:
Filed on:
HtnutlPlna
liflOn,David
0112312012
9
9
9
9
9
9
Case Numb Ilstory' RCX2012-000103
Agenc), Numba"
Dlstnct Anome) Number
Probabe Cause: Number
KI' 12-00074 (RPJ)
436377
RPOlloo02OC
1H0nS Q

Ca.5 Tye Cross Mlsdtllllanor

1 UNLA WFUL USE LEMERGENCY
L
TELEI'II ONE NU\1BER
0112312012
Arrest 011232012 HL Reno Pohce Department
lJonds
Balllond
31212012
Counts 1
Case Status: 0512312012 Aelh Y
Case Flags: UJolllln t1arlngS
&IIICTransaill
F^1 0-00584726 o,500.00
Surcly Bond Posted
Ball Bond
2121'2012
Counts- 1
IA 1 0-574.195
Posted
SI,5000
'talnlif
UvlcnuBnt
UA11
0112312012
01!/2012
O1l +2012
022J/20J2
Oll 212012
0Z1 2012
CUrrtlll Cast Asslnmtnt
Case l\umber
CouO
Date ASSigned
JudiCial Officcr
Tht Slllf u'e\ ada
Fonnal Charges
RCR2012-05630
Reno LOP|0
0112)12012
Chfton, Da\ld
I'\HI\ I\lUH\I\III)'
USE OF TIlE 911 EMERGENCY S.!)7E, WilEN 1'0 ACTUAL OR 1'RCEIV1 D
!ERGE{n t.. o 1OlallO o/NRS 10; 145
CANCELED }\rntljumelll (10.00 AM) (Judicial Offierr: Prrn, SCUll)
Varated
}\rraigllmtul (10 00 AM) (JudIcial Officer l'cln, SCOII)
Ball SCI
I5m00 RQd or l`qhHorl Ho('ondlllo". St mthe Iionor(bl . Jad Shroeder
3t1^0I
I^LL LJ
f.ead Allorney
Auun.7Bh
775-328-3200 xJ51 O(W)
Public t>efrrnlcr
RellwII'1f
715-337-.180W
In"lm a" /0'0]]0/] al // 4/ AM
02127.2012
02t2sn012
0)022012
0]/15/2012
0]n9/2012
OSnJ/ 2012
0713 112012
OSlO9 2012
08/ 09 2012
0&09 2012
08/ 21 2012
081 21 / 2012
0827.2012
0827,2012
0827(20[2
08/ 2712012
lASi S MMARY
LA5 ^O. RCRl012-065630
1500 00 ondor Cash Ball Ball CondlltonIby lhe lIonoruble Scali Peurson
^1aD:aIut} hlaIu5Conference (I ]0 PM) (1Bd1C18 '1!Ccf bf00Cf.18CX|
L3Scf8hSclfcd I0 Ph0Icf L0uU
10 D C lflmOl1 PS)CII
5ufClyHond oSIcd
Uohd LXuDCf8Icd
CANCELED M:lldlIOJ bIIuSConference (I ;30 I'M) (Jullkial OrCtr: L) nch, "atrlcl.)
V(ealt
qKCmDd lfom bcCoDd 1ud1018l 1lSIfICIL0BH Ilcd
gMallon 1!cd
MOl/Oil /or l.ca1A o/ Courl luHnund ComplUlf// fled
KcqucSI of.Vud1OLL:lcd
Iollon Filed
/0 '>rud 1 Forma Pal/puIS
Mallon Denied
to />rofed 1 Formu PUlI/rlS
*10lu IIlrln(I'30PM) (!ud1:ia!m:rr bl0,clcl|
06I 121012 Continued 0 7116011 - MSC NeSeflCOnilnuunC' n SlatV ol\e
l'
Cough/III, Zachar Barker
0 7//61011 Conllnued 10 08062 011-MSC ReSefCOrlllnuunc(' The Slate o/.\Ivada
Coughlin, Zochar)
' 8(1f/er
0861 1011 Can/li/led U081111011 MSC ResetlCanlllll/allCe Th, State o/ Nel'ada
COl/ghlin, Zodlry 80rkfr
"OrllfS PrtSf'n/ P/allltif
!
Th! SIO/' 0/ Nemda
Public lk/Vnier Dog(/I, Hlfuy
Deputy Dlstricl Allarnf' YOIlllg,7, ,,eh
/)f/tlliam lOllRMlII, Zachar /arker
Hc8fmg KcSu!I l1ud10t3'!!Ccf` bcH8. clcf_
/Jo/endU/1/ /alled U appear, lk/ensl requests thal lhlS case bl COrll/fIIled Ulld sel >\llh hiS
IlIIsdemtolior Reno Jusllce Courl Cast set/or August )9,201) al 8 JOA M Sale opposes as
Ihls uAIr Cuugh/Ill's second "me/adlllg O appear I/ense'
s mOilOn IS CRANTED MSC I
set/or AI/gusl19, ]011 at 9 ^
^uI\un Il(arln (830 AM) {1ud1C18!'l!1Ccf bC 8. clcf|
PUrle S Present PIQlllllf cStOlt 0/ "elmia
lut' D,st"ct Alloe Young. Mch
De/endanl COUgh/III, /.chuf OorAer
PubliC De/endfr udl!e, Jumes O"ulld
Pmthdcd Lflmm8!LumQ8Ihl 1lcd {1u0lCI8'ICcf b clct
tr4A4n
cM:hg KcSuI 1ud1018!'l10cf bCN ,l'clCI|
Thf Statf mo\0d10 smi Secold Amell ifd Cm7/lIIol Camploml
Mallon LI8Dlcd {1ud1018!'ICcf: bcH,cIcf_
Io1rkccc0udHmcItdcd Crullnul Complaml
I'A\ 2| J FrttOR l0J7lor |l 4!I
08127/2012
0812912012
0812912012
0812912012
09/1212012
103012012
lASi StM 1ARY
CASE O. RCR1012-065630
0Ml0gResult
7'e Slale rem/ offered plea n<gOIUJIIons lllto fil rlcord at .. hlc|lime flt Defendalll "('('epled
Ihe off eud plea The Slate ji/td Ament/e!f Cflmllli Complmllls lIearlng proceeded AI
conclUIon of lhe hearlllg, rhe l0tIO .. dillal accepllkflndanl's pleo The Stare mOld 10
Slrlke Amended Crlmlllal ComplulIl GNA/lD MalldatoryS/alu COlferelll'e remallS St
August 19, lOll, ot9 ooA
oIou IIc:ring (90 AM) (11dICi3L00|
oDIcstc5ct|I I'/||||t
7rIcDefelt/tr
f
tQLI$lrcAllorn(,
Ikfelldllll
blI8 0|0|)
n,e SlotI of Nel'atla
DogIII,8"1)'
Yo ig, lorh
Coughlll, loch"r" 8a,*er
H0M|0gK0uI(Judt:3L0tl bh, 0|0|_
The StOle's motlOIl "'or L0ofCollrl to Amend Comp/Oint wIhbe IJdressed (1/ a OItot|
hellrlllg sel Dc/ober), J0IJa/ I000I M
Ku05| for AudIO L FIled
Rftlcred b)' J",I I.VIII, Deput rIcDlfender
K0qu05| l0| Pu0l0 LFiled
IJcllu'd
., lotion l03t0g(1000 AM) (JudICIal Lt0c LU!!O0. 1vt0)
I02/20I2 COllllnued /0 I0/J020I2-^LRe$eIlCOlllllluaI/ce The Stult of P'rv00d
Cu nttt, la(ho 'Barker
tf0040\ L0ughIin,athaqcr
Total Charges
Total dym00IS300L|00||5
l2a0tf1ur3S 101212012
I'AL1JLJ
4000
oo
0.00
!rnIdUH l0!J7l2m l1 J lm
ht bI:|rultV80a
V'S.
7aCHaJ Uatkrt$uuhH
HlO1HlH^AI
lASI S MMAR\
!A5L ^O. RCRlOJ 2-067980
00||00
JuJ|.m| L160|'
||000H'
HtH0 LtlHHu
$1|0H, !a VU
/bJ1J
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
L52"um00| Hl5|0ly H'\,1,-106
Pg0h0y"um00I`
lI|.| PR0m0y "um00I'
|0030|0LuM"um00|
*L1J-1
411b
*bL1166L
$cH5c
I)t
Jar
/6/414
L50 Ty ^S0tHt2H0t
I |0Sm|O 0| 00tu0I u0||0 0100| N!
PL YLI 0
PH05I YLbLY85000L0u0|)b00ML0c
U||0S
L50 l3||YB0Ou|P0|t00 b3UU.UU
J|J U1 l'05l00
L0u0l5 I
||000
J'U1
L0u0|5' 1
lI|
'aH11
PL`J1J 0J0 o1,J .UJ
bu|0|y 000 0S20
Lutrrn1 L2St.SSHI1tD
L50um0t
L0u|
3I0 55lg020
JuJ|0m|L00|
htblu1c u^c\0a
10Vjh!07\tthRt} RtKct'
KLKU1-JV0U
K000LGm|0|
U1'UU1
L||H00. La\t0
L350bI8d5 |b/J1J ^c1)t
L2 |g5` |0UlH[ l1tIug>
Iad Auonw)S
0uHg. #.IH2J N.
JJJ-0-JJXJJ(Y)
'uDc ctI\0tt
Retained
JJJJJJ-+0J(Y]
l!l 1 t11xkDM!H 11 O+l I'm,
UJ'J/JU1Z
UJ'UU1
UJ'U3U1
UJ'UJ'U1
UJ/U1
UJ/U0ZU1
bu||y 00005I00
9|0030|0Lu0P0av:I(00
LMmm|L0m|mI ||20
5500 0
0000&000lJlc0
Certificate olSlIrrtmder 01 Dele"dam by 8m/ tgem f/
d
.tt2JIIH61| \|U JP} (Ju0|0l|L0c|' b 0|cf}
ParllC Prlell iJ/em/a1 (m.gh/tI, lAcha,)Har/wr
||b0|(Ju0t0|3|$CPl ocO, 0|0|)
'^LE I OIJ
1rmmO !0TJ/0.U ! 4I
07/()6,2012
07/09/2012
07/09'2012
07/23/2012
07/31/2012
08109'2012
08,09/2012
081 09'2012
081 23/2012
081 27 1 2012
27-2012
081 292012
10 152012
I) \ I.
Hl'0 RI !1N^
lASE SlMMAR\
A5 O. RCIU012-067980
/wl Sn at 5500 00 IJe/"dulII Rma"'/cd 10 Ih Custody o/ Ihe Wahoe COUllty Sherif
u0:C Lcl0h00|Apinted {Ju0|0|3 Lll100|.ol0H0J. 00t)
Judge S/trraza
nlIl1tMrilig (2.00 ) (JudlcUli LlI00|' 03|5O0,o00I|)
I'artles Prese,,1 I>/wlllif The Siule 0/ Nelada
Publ,c D/e"der 8rady. Chmlme Jo"es
OqUl)' DIS/FIt Allor"l 7oung, thuQ' N
ie/e"dalll COUghlt", 7.urhury 8urkcr
H8l 0OBg(Ju0|0|3Ll.00|' ?l500.Scott )
l'h/ellu reql4ests lft/C"dulll lw re/eused 0" h,s OWN RECOGNIZANCE SIOIe opposcs
IJc/clltufls OWN RE('OGNIZNCE rellU IS hu,by DENIED Bad reOUIli Q S500 00
oolldab!e
L3 Ball POSted
Ifl Ihe amO"fI/ o/HOO 00
CANCEI.ED ,\rraignmcnt (10,0 P} (Judirial omrtr; I'taroon. Seoll)
Vacutl'd
K0qu05| l0|Pu0|0L|K0
^0I|00|00
10 PrOC{ed 1 Forma !aupcFs
0l|00 0Mcu
/0 prxed III Forma l'Ul1f!rlS
Nou(c
SIIIIll'lIIeIlWI Nonce 0/ IVI/nesses l'urSlwn/lo NRS I //JJ4
*0\l0B liuring (8.30 P} (JudlcUlI LCr Sfcr 0|0|}
I'ar/lt Presl'' Plamlj Te male 0/ N(I'ada
lkpul DlStrlCI AI/orne} >oung, thmN
/)1/elldlllrt COI/ghlill, 7.urhury Horktr
I'ubltc De/ender l.Js/lc, James Hriflllli
H0J||0gK0Su||(Ju(hcud LlI00r lHM 0|0|)
The Stalt read ojtred p/u negollutloll 11110 Ihe record at YhIChllnle the rCOdant aIpl<d
Ihe ofered plea The SUllejilcd AniI'm/cd ('",,,,,,01 Complumts ! RCR 1011-063341 ad RCR
lOI l065630 lI!orlllg IrQCCl'dc/1 A/ COlldlSjO'1 of lire h('armg, IhC COMI . 1/1 not acap/
IJicm/(II/'s plea |c Stale m(I'((IO Slrlkl Amlm/l'd Crllllllral Complal,lls GRANTED Trwl
rtlil/IIU lel plmber 18, 1011, 01 V 00 A A
Ku25| l0|Pu0|0LLlc
R('qull'Ifd by JIm Lhc, Dcpllly I'ublrc In/emfer
I' rc-Trill Conreren(t (830 P)
0711111011 COl/lllllled /0 07//61 1011 Pre-Trial Rese/Conlmuance - The SWle 0/
Ne\uta, Coughlrn, Zacha1) Harklr
07//611011 ('ontlllllld to 086101 1 MSC Rt'S1 COfI,watlcl The State o/\I!'lka.
COltgM!, /clIuHurker
081611011 C 1nlllllCd 10 091/81011 Tria! /(/I'III AI/ortley R/quesl l8 SUI. 0/
Nt\'du, COUgh/III, 7.ochu1)' Borker
18:01 Z CunlrllUed /Q 101 F01 J - p", Trwl HCSCIJConlllllloIlU The ::laU oJ
Nel'da, COli Mm. 7cllr Hurker
11'\"( 1\1 l1Rt^!11
r^L1VUIJ
HtNO fRIJII
lASI StMMAR\
LA ^O. ULUZ1Z-V
Derendalll Coughlin. Zachary Barker
0l0Charges
Total Payments and CredilS
Iblance Due W0! 1111
AG1QJ

.
.
FrnIrdONJ0J?'?7l,GlJ4l m
1
2
3
IN THE
IN AND FOR
4 THE STATE OF NEVADA,
5 Plaintiff,
6 v.
7 Z C H k ~ Y BARKER COUGHLI N,
8 Defendant.
9 I

10 MOTION FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO AMEND COMPLAINT
11 COMES NOW, the State of Nevada, by and through RICHARD A.
12 GAMMICK, District Attorney of Washoe County, and ZACH YOUNG, Deputy
13 Di strict Attorney, and moves this Honorable Court for an Order
14 granting the State's Motion for Leave of Court to Amend Complaint.
15 This Mo tion is based upon the following Points and Authorities, all
16 papers and pleadings on file herein, and any oral arguments to be
17 presented to this Court.
18 POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
13 I. STATEMENT OF THE CASE
20 Zachary Barker Coughlin (hereinafter "the Defendant") is
21 charged with Use of the 911 Emergency System When No Actual or
22 Perceived Emergency Exists, a gross misdemeanor in violation of NRS
23 207.245 . To the charge, the Defendant has pled not guilty; after
24 several continuances, the matter is currently set for a status
25 hearing on August 6, 201 2, at which time no witnesses will be
26 III
(
1 present.
'
The State now seeks to amend the charge to a misdemeanor
2 offense of Resisting, Delaying, or Obstructing a Public Officer in
3 violation of NRS 199 . 280(3) . See Proposed Amended Complaint, Attached
4 Hereto as Exhibit 1.
5 I I. ARGUMENT
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
A court may, in its discretion, allow for an amendment to a
charging document upon proper motion. Viray v. State, 121 Nev. 159,
162 (2005). NRS 173.095 ( 1 ) provides:
"The court may permit an indictment or information to be
amended at any time before verdict or finding if no
additional or different offense is charged and if
substantial rights of the defendant are not prejudiced . "
In the instant matter, the State seeks to amend the charge
to a misdemeanor, thereby resolving the case at the Justice Court
level. The proposed charge essentially alleges the same misconduct as
was alleged in the original charge. The State does this in the
interests of justice, and such is permissible based on the State's
vested discretion in charging cases. See Stromberg v . State, 125 Nev.
18 1, 6 ( 2009) (acknowledging that "a prosecutor has broad discretion in
19 charging a defendant" and that "so long as the prosecutor has
20
probable cause to believe that the accused committed an offense
21
defined by statute, the decision whether or not to prosecute, and
22
what charge to file or bring before a grand jury, generally rests
23
entirely 1n his discretion" ) .
24
III
25
26
Of note, the State has not requested any of the continuances in this matter.
2
1 Further, such an ame ndment does not prejudice the
2 Defendant, as under the proposed amended charge, he would be subject
3 only to criminal punishment of a mi sdemeanor rather than the harsher
4 potential sentence of the original charge, which is a gross
5 mi sdemeanor. Finally, this proposed amendment is timely and being
6 made well in advance of trial - in fact, the only hearing currently
7 set in this matter is a hearing without witnesses.
8 III. CONCLUSI ON
9 The State hereby respectfully requests that this Court grant its
10 Motion for Leave of Court to Amend Complaint, so that this matter can
11 proceed to trial as a misdemeanor .
12 AFFIRMATION PURSUANT TO NRS 239B . 030
13 The undersigned does hereby affirm t hat the preceding
14 document does not contain the social security number of any person .
15 DATED chis day of
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 0727436377DPB
3
RICHARD A. GAMMICK
District Attorney
20l2.
Washoe

By __ ________________ _
!
1 telephone calls to the 911 emergency system when no actual or perceived
2 emergency existed and/ or continued to call the 911 emergency system
3 when no actual or perceived emergency existed after having been warned
4 or otherwise advised not to so call, to wit: during the calls, the s a id
5 defendant, among other things, falsely reported that officers on scene
6 were shining a flashlight in his face, asked for law enforcement
7 assistance when law enforcement officials were alre ady on scene, used
8 profane and otherwise inappropriate l a nguage when speaking with 911
9 emergency dispatchers, requested to lodge various complaints against
1 0 public officers, was argumentative with and failed to cooperate with
11 questions asked by 911 emergency dispatchers, and/ or hung up on 911
12 emergency dispatchers, in Reno, Washoe County, Nevada.
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
DATED this
PCN RPD120 0020C
Custody:
Bailed: X
Warrant:
0727436377Adpb
__ day of
__________________ , 2012
2
District Court Dept: 10
Di strict Attorney: YOUNG
Defense Attorney:
Bail
Restitution:
J
EXHIBIT 1
Proposed Amended Complaint
(DO NOT FILE)
EXHIBIT 1
,

/
DA # 436377
RPD RP12-000974
1 IN THE JUSTICE COURT OF RENO TOWNSHIP
2 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF l'iASHOE, STATE OF NEVADA
3 * * *
4 THE STATE OF NEVADA,
5 Plaintif f,
6 v .
7 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN,
8 Defendant.
9 /
RCR 2012-065630
DEPT: 1
[PROPOSED] AMENDED
CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
10 ZACH YOUNG of the County of Washoe, State of Nevada,
11 verifies and declares upon information and belief and under penalty
12 of perjury, that ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, the defendant above-named,
13 has committed the crime of:
14 RESISTING, DELAYING, OR OBSTRUCTING A PUBLIC OFFICER, a
15 violation of NRS 199.280 (3 ) , a misdemeanor in the manner following, to
16 wit:
17 That the said defendant on or between the 12th day of
18 January, 2012 and the 14th of January, 2012, at Reno Township, within
19 the County of Washoe, State of Nevada, did willfully and unlawfully
20 resist, delay, or obstruct public officers, namely, RENO POLICE
21 DEPARTMENT OFFICERS JASON SCHAUR, SCOTT HEGLAR, TIMOTHY BROADWAY,
22 AND/ OR OTHER RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT OFFICERS AND/ OR RENO POLICE
23 DEPARTMENT SERGEANTS PAUL SIFRE AND/ OR CARLOS ~ D R I D AND/ OR CITY OF
24 RENO EMERGENCY DISPATCH SUPERVISOR KARIANN BEECHLER AND/ OR OTHER RENO
25 EMERGENCY DISPATCHERS, in discharging or attempting to discharge a
26 legal duty of their office, in that the said defendant made one or more
1 telephone cal l s to the 911 emergency system when no actual or perceived
2 emergency existed and/or continued to call the 911 emergency s y stem
3 when no actual or perceived emergency existed after having been warned
4 or otherwise advised not to so call, to wit : during the calls, the said
5 defendant, among other things, falsely reported that officers on scene
6 were shining a flashlight in his face, asked for law enforcement
7 assistance when law enforceme nt officials were already on scene, used
8 profane and otherwise inappropriate language when speaking with 911
9 emergency dispatchers, requested to lodge various complaints against
10 public officers, was argumentative wi th and failed to cooperate with
11 questions asked by 911 emergenc y dispatchers, and/ or hung up on 911
12 emergency dispatchers, in Reno, Washoe County, Ne vada.
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
DATED this
peN RPD1200020C
Custody:
Bailed: X
Wa rrant:
07 27436377Adpb
d ay of
___________ , 2012
2
District Court Dept: 10
District Attorney: YOUNG
Defense Attorney:
Bail
Restitution:
J
1 Pursuant to NRS 1 74.234, the following are the names and
2 addresses of such witnesses the State intends to call in its case in
3 Chief.
4 RENO POLICE DEPARTMENT
5 OFFICER JASON
OFFICER TIMOTHY BROADWAY
6 SERGEANT PAUL SIFRE
SERGEANT CARLOS MADRID
7
RENO EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS
8
KARIANN BEECHLER
9
10 NRS 174.234 also requires the defendant, at least five
11 judicial days prior to the trial date, to file and serve upon the
12 prosecuting attorney a written notice containing the name and last
13 known address of any witness the defendant intends to call during
14 his / her case-in- chief. Failure to do so may result in the exclusion
15 of the witness.
16
17 The party executing this docume nt hereby affirms that this
18 document submitted for recording does not contain the social security
19 number of any person or persons pursuant to NRS 239B . 230.
20 RICHARD A. GAMMICK
District Attorney
21 Washoe County, Nevada
22
23
24
25
26
3
By

Deputy District Attorney
1 CERTIFICATE OF FORWARDING
2 I hereby certify that I am an employee of the Washoe County
3 District Attorney's Office and that, on this date, I forwarded a true
4 copy of the foregoing document, through the Washoe County interagency
5 mail, addressed to:
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
BIRAY DOGAN, D.P.D.
WASHOE COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER'S OFFICE
RENO, NEVADA
DATED this QOti' day of
RCR2012-06.5630
De artment 5
CHARGES:
MSC
July 16,2012
1:30 PM
COURT REPORTER:
UNLA WFUL USE OF EMERGENCY TELEPHONE NUMBER
WITNESS / EXCLUSIONARY RULE INVOKED
__ YES
DRD
CRe
DRD
CRC
DRD
CRC
DRD
CRe
FOR J.D.
ADMITTED
STATE'S
EXHIBITS
STATE'S
FOR J.D.
ADMITTED
EVIDENCE RETURNE TO STATE __ YES __ NO
Public Defender
PROS TOR
___ NO
DEFENSE
DEFENSE
DEFENDANT INFORMED OF RIGHT TO CALL WITNESS YES __ NO
DEFENDANT INFORMED OF RIGHT TO TESTIFY __ YES NO
ARGUMENT: STATE YES __ NO/ DEFENSE YES NO
DEFENDANT BOUND OVER COUNTS ___ DISMISSED COUNTS. __ _
DEFENDANT FOUND GUILTY COUNTS NOT GUILTY COUNTS __ _
SENTENCINGIREVIEW DATE: BAIL ____ ---:-__ _
DRD
eRe
DRD
CRC
DRD
CRe
DRD
CRC




















Zach Coughlin, Esq.
PO Box 3961
Reno, NV 8955
!el" ##5 338 8118
$ax" 9%9 66# #%&
ZachCoughlin'ho()ail.co)
*e+(e),e- 9(h, &1&
*(a(e Ba- o. Ne/a0a
co)+lain('n/,a-.o-g
co)+lain(s'n/,a-.o-g
1a/i0C'n/,a-.o-g
1ea- Ba- Counsel,
1ea- Ba- Counsel,
Please acce+( (his co--es+on0ence as a .o-)al g-ie/ance agains( ,o(h 2ashoe Coun(3 1e+u(3 1is(-ic(
4((o-ne3 Zach 5oung, Esq. an0 2ashoe Coun(3 Pu,lic 1e.en0e- Bi-a3 1ogan, Esq. .o- (he -easons se(
.o-(h he-ein, 6i(h (he un0e-s(an0ing (ha( 7 +lan (o su++le)en( (his .u-(he- in (he nea- .u(u-e.
8-. 1ogan, 0es+i(e RPC sec(ions 0e/o(e0 (o 0iligence, co)+e(ence, an0 co))uncia(ions 6i(h clien(s,
3ou .aile0 (o co+3 )e on 9o- e/en in.o-) )e o.: 114 5oung;s a((e)+( (o a)en0 (he co)+lain( in
RCR&1&<6563 (o a )is0e)eano- (ha( 6oul0 -equi-e, i. a con/ic(ion is ga-ne-e0, Ba- Counsel (o .ile
Pe(i(ion see=ing sus+ension o. one;s la6 license un0e- *CR 11196:, gi/en >o,s(-uc(ing a +u,lic o..ice->
is s+eci.icall3 0elinea(e0 as a >se-ious o..ense> (he-ein. 7 ha/e, in (he +as( in 6-i(ing an0 /e-,all3,
in0ica(e0 (o 1ogan an0 his su+e-/iso-s ?i) @eslie an0 ?e-e)3 Bosle-, (ha( 7 0e)an0 (o ,e co+ie0 o.
e/e-3 .iling in an3 case .o- 6hich (he3 a++ea- .o- )e. 1ogan )a0e con(-a0ic(o-3 an0 un(-u(h.ull
s(a(e)en(s (o )e 6i(h -ega-0 (o 6he(he- he e/e- ga/e )e a co+3 o. )3 .ile in (his )a((e-. 4( .i-s(,
1ogan in0ica(e0 he 0i0 hi)sel., an0 (ha( he 6as su-e o. (ha(, (hen )inu(es la(e- he s(a(e0 he 6as su-e
(ha( he 6as (he-e (o 6i(ness ?i) @eslie gi/e )e (he one co+3 (he 2CP1 e/e- +-o/i0e0 )e. 2CP1
s(a.. has a0)i((e0 (o )e (ha( (he-e 6as a +ac=age a/aila,le .o- )e (o +ic= u+, a.(e- (he 0a(e on 6hich
1ogan an0 @eslie allege (he3 ga/e )e )3 .ile, ,u( (ha( ,ecause 7 0i0 no( +ic= i( u+ soon enough, i( 6as
6i(h0-a6n .-o) (he .-on( 0es=. !he-ea.(e- 1ogan an0 @eslie ha/e )ain(aine0 (he +osi(ion (ha( 7 6as
+-o/i0e0 (ha( +ac=age, 6i(h /a-3ing, con(-a0ic(o-3, e/asi/e, an0 /ague s(a(e)en(s 9an0 in @eslie;s case,
(es(i)on3: as (o Aus( ho6 an0 6hen (ha( occu--e0.
400i(ionall3, 1ogan an0 @eslie +e-sis( in see=ing (o co),ine hea-ings in (his case an0 (he (6o cases
1B8
































?i) @eslie is a((o-ne3 o. -eco-0 on 9RCR&11<633%1 an0 RCR&1&<6#98:6i(h (he case 1ogan is
a((o-ne3 o. -eco-0 on 9RCR&1&<6563, an0 6hich @eslie al(e-na(el3, 6hen i(s con/enien( (o hi),
)ain(ains he is allo6e0 (o chi+ in on, o-, al(e-na(el3, )ain(ain (ha( he has no( a connec(ion (he-e(o an0
(hus an3 )iscon0uc( in connec(ion 6i(h (ha( case )a3 no( +-o/i0e a ,asis .o- a con.lic( ,eing .oun0 in
RCR&11<633%1:, 0es+i(e )3 ex+-ess in0ica(ion (ha( 1ogan an0 @eslie )us( -e.-ain .-o) 0oing so.
$u-(he-, 114 5oung is /iola(ing RPC 3.8 an0 o(he- e(hical -ules. 7n see=ing (o a((ain so)e le/e-age in
RCR&1&<6563 ,3 a)en0ing (he Co)+lain( (o a cha-ge (ha( .alls 6(ihin (he +u-/ie6 o. *CR 11196:
9>se-ious o..ense>, e(c:, 6he-e (he allega(ions 0o no( +-o/i0e +-o,a,le cause .o- such a cha-ge, 114
5oung is /iola(ing RPC 3.8. $u-(he-, 114 5oung has a 0u(3 (o 0i/ulge (o (he Cou-( (he con.lic(
inhe-en( in his o..ice;s +a-(ne-ing 6i(h an en(i(3 (ha( 7 a) suing on a 6-ong.ul
0ischa-geB0isc-i)ina(ionB-e(alia(ion ,asis, 2ashoe @egal *e-/ices, 6hich is +a-(ne-ing 6i(h (he 2C14
in an Ea-l3 Case Resolu(ion +-og-a) (ha( is /iola(i/e o. (he *ix(h 4)en0)en( Righ( (o Counsel.
h((+"BBsix(ha)en0)en(.o-gBC+D%63
Rule3.8.Special Responsibilities of a Prosecutor.!he +-osecu(o- in a c-i)inal case shall"
9a:ERe.-ain .-o) +-osecu(ing a cha-ge (ha( (he +-osecu(o- =no6s is no( su++o-(e0 ,3 +-o,a,le
causeF
9,:E8a=e -easona,le e..o-(s (o assu-e (ha( (he accuse0 has ,een a0/ise0 o. (he -igh( (o, an0 (he
+-oce0u-e .o- o,(aining, counsel an0 has ,een gi/en -easona,le o++o-(uni(3 (o o,(ain counselF
9c:ENo( see= (o o,(ain .-o) an un-e+-esen(e0 accuse0 a 6ai/e- o. i)+o-(an( +-e(-ial -igh(s, such as
(he -igh( (o a +-eli)ina-3 hea-ingF
90:E8a=e (i)el3 0isclosu-e (o (he 0e.ense o. all e/i0ence o- in.o-)a(ion =no6n (o (he +-osecu(o-
(ha( (en0s (o nega(e (he guil( o. (he accuse0 o- )i(iga(es (he o..ense, an0, in connec(ion 6i(h
sen(encing, 0isclose (o (he 0e.ense an0 (o (he (-i,unal all un+-i/ilege0 )i(iga(ing in.o-)a(ion =no6n (o
(he +-osecu(o-, exce+( 6hen (he +-osecu(o- is -elie/e0 o. (his -es+onsi,ili(3 ,3 a +-o(ec(i/e o-0e- o. (he
(-i,unalF
9e:ENo( su,+oena a la63e- in a g-an0 Au-3 o- o(he- c-i)inal +-ocee0ing (o +-esen( e/i0ence a,ou( a
+as( o- +-esen( clien( unless (he +-osecu(o- -easona,l3 ,elie/es"
91:E!he in.o-)a(ion sough( is no( +-o(ec(e0 .-o) 0isclosu-e ,3 an3 a++lica,le +-i/ilegeF
9&:E!he e/i0ence sough( is essen(ial (o (he success.ul co)+le(ion o. an ongoing in/es(iga(ion
o- +-osecu(ionF an0
93:E!he-e is no o(he- .easi,le al(e-na(i/e (o o,(ain (he in.o-)a(ionF
9.:EExce+( .o- s(a(e)en(s (ha( a-e necessa-3 (o in.o-) (he +u,lic o. (he na(u-e an0 ex(en( o. (he
+-osecu(o-Gs ac(ion an0 (ha( se-/e a legi(i)a(e la6 en.o-ce)en( +u-+ose, -e.-ain .-o) )a=ing
ex(-aAu0icial co))en(s (ha( ha/e a su,s(an(ial li=elihoo0 o. heigh(ening +u,lic con0e)na(ion o. (he
accuse0 an0 exe-cise -easona,le ca-e (o +-e/en( in/es(iga(o-s, la6 en.o-ce)en( +e-sonnel, e)+lo3ees
o- o(he- +e-sons assis(ing o- associa(e0 6i(h (he +-osecu(o- in a c-i)inal case .-o) )a=ing an
ex(-aAu0icial s(a(e)en( (ha( (he +-osecu(o- 6oul0 ,e +-ohi,i(e0 .-o) )a=ing un0e- Rule 3.6 o- (his
Rule.
&B8








































114 5oung has con(inuall3 sough( (o 0en3 Coughlin his -igh( (o a legi(i)a(e +-e<(-ial hea-ing
in RCR&1&<6563, in .ac(, 5oung nee0s (o ans6e- (o 6he(he- o- no( R8C ?u0ge Nash Hol)es an0
he 9as 6ell as 1ogan o- an3one 6i(h (he 2CP1: )e(, on o- a,ou( $e,-ua-3 &#(h, &1&, )inu(es ,e.o-e
?u0ge Nash Hol)es en(e-e0 he- cou-(-oo) in 11 !R &68 an0 sho-(l3 (he-ea.(e- .oun0 Coughlin in
>c-i)inal con(e)+(> in a (-a..ic ci(a(ion (-ial, secon0s a.(e- Coughlin (es(i.ie0 (ha( RP1 *a-gen( Ca-(e-
lie0 in his (es(i)on3 -ela(e0 (o (he (h-ee (-a..ic ci(a(ions he ha0 issue0 on Coughlin inci0en( (o Richa-0
Hill, Esq;s -e.usal (o -e(u-n Coughlin his clien(;s .iles o- Coughlin;s s(a(e issue0 i0en(i.ca(ion.
400i(ionall3, +lease a00 (o (his g-ie/ance, Reno Ci(3 a((o-ne3 4llison O-)aas, .o- he- lac= .o- Can0o-
(o (he !-i,unal 9RPC 3.3: in asse-(ing (ha( (he 6o-0 >-e(alia(ion> an0 (he su,Aec( o. -e(alia(ion 0i0 no(
a++ea- in (he +olice -e+o-( .o- (ha( No/e),e- 15(h, &11 (-a..ic ci(a(ion 6hen clea-l3, (he -e+o-( -e/eals
(ha( is 0oes. !he *CR 11# Pe(i(ion Coughlin no6 .aces is ,ase0 in la-ge +a-( on ?u0ge Nash Hol)e;s
O-0e- an0 su,sequen( g-ie/ance .ile0 6i(h (he *(a(e Ba- in connec(ion 6i(h a !-ial in 11 !R &68 on
$e,-ua-3 &#(h, &1&, se( .o- 1"3 +), an0 114 5oung an0 1ogan allege0l3 )e( on $e,-ua-3 &#(h,
&1&, a( o- a-oun0 1" +), 0es+i(e ha/ing no(ice0 Coughlin (ha( (he *(a(us Con.e-ence se( .o- (ha(
(i)e in RCR&1&<6563 ha0 ,een /aca(e0. ?u0ge Nash Hol)es ?u0icial 4ssi(an( coul0 no( loca(e
?u0ge Nash Hol)es .o- nea-l3 %5 )inu(es on (ha( 0a(e 6hen (he (i)e .o- !-ial ca)e a-oun0. 2CP1
Bosle- an0 1ogan ha/e -e.use0 (o con.-i) o- 0en3 6he(he- (he3 ha0 an3 co))unica(ions 6i(h ?u0ge
Nash Hol)es o- an3one connec(e0 6i(h (he R8C on o- a-oun0 (ha( 0a(e -ega-0ing Coughlin;s allege0
>co)+e(enc3> issues. @eslie has ,een ex(-e)el3 e/asi/e in ans6e-ing such ques(ions. Cou-(;s ha/e a
0u(3 (o sus+en0 +-ocee0ings i. co)+e(enc3 issues a-e -aise0, ac-oss 0e+a-()en(s, an0 a-gua,l3 ac-oss
(he R?C (o (he R8C, +a-(icula-l3 i. ?u0ge Nash Hol)es 6as +-i/3 (o (he >sec-e(> *(a(us Con.e-ence
(ha( 6as hel0 on $e,-ua-3 &#(h, &1&, 0e+si(e (he R?C ha/ing /aca(e0 i( an0 1ogan ha/ing
co))unica(e0 as )uch (o Coughlin a.(e- Coughlin +oin(e0 ou( (he sche0uling con.lic( 6i(h 11 !R
&68. 7 a) .o-)all3 -eques(ing Ba- Counsel (o ini(ia(e an inqui-3 in(o 6he(he- ?u0ge Nash Hol)es
6as +-i/3 (o (he O-0e- .o- Co)+e(enc3 E/alua(ion o-0e-0 on $e,-ua-3 &#(h, &1& in RCR&1&<
6563, an0 i. so, 6he(he- she /iola(e0 an3 RPC;s ,3 con(inuing (o hol0 (he !-ial in 11 !R &68,
es+eciall3 in ligh( o. he- su,sequen( g-ie/anceBCo)+lain( 6i(h (he *BN an0 O-0e-s in (ha( )a((e-.
114 5oung /iola(e0 RPC 3.8 in see=ing (o ha/e Coughlin -e(u-ne0 (o cus(o03 in *e+(e),e-
5(h, &1&. !he-e 6as a,solu(el3 no ,asis .o- 5oung see=ing (o 0o so a( (ha( (i)e o(he- (han (o
0isa0/an(age Coughlin, ego (-i+, an0 i)+e-)issil,3 coe-ce Coughlin ou( o. +u-suing an3 ci/il -e)e0ies
(ha( he )a3 ha/e a/aila,le gi/en (he +olice an0 +-osecu(o-ial )iscon0uc( (ha( Coughlin has
s3s(e)a(icall3 ,een su,Aec(e0 (o in (he las( 3ea-.
On (ha( no(e, (he ?ul3 3-0, &1& a--es( in R8C 1& CR 1&%& .o- >0is(-u,ing (he +eace>, no
>+-oo. o. insu-ance> an0 >.ailu-e (o secu-e a loa0 on a (-uc=> le0 (o Coughlin s+en0ing &1 0a3s in Aail
a.(e- (he RP1, in conAunc(ion 6i(h Reno Ci(3 4((o-ne3 ?ill 1-a=e a0/oca(e0 .o- R8C ?u0ge Ia-0ne- (o
-aise (he J1,%15 ,on0a,le ,ail (o J3, cash onl3, on a >+u,lic sa.e-(3 an0 6el.a-e ,asis> 0es+i(e (he
onl3 +e-)issil,e -a(ionale .o- ,ail un0e- Ne/a0a la6 ,eing (o insu-e (he 0e.en0an(;s a++ea-ance a( (-ial.
Please acce+( (his as a g-ie/ance agains( ?ohn Ka0lic an0 ?ill 1-a=e, Esq. .o- /iola(ing RPC;s, inclu0ing
RPC 3.8. 7( is (elling (ha( (he 0is(u-,ing (he +eace cha-ge an0 +-oo. o. insu-ance cha-ge 6e-e 0-o++e0
on *e+(e),e- %(h, &1&, ,u( no( ,e.o-e a Reno Ci(3 4((o-ne3 9(he signa(u-e is illegi,le: sough( (o
/iola(e *ol0al /. Coo= Coun(3 an0 2heele- /. Coss so)e )o-e ,3 a00ing a (-es+ass co)+lain( agains(
Coughlin, 6ho) ha0, a( (he (i)e o. (he a--es(, (6o /ali0 leases a( (he +-o+e-(3 in ques(ion. 7. a Reno
Ci(3 a((o-ne3 .ile0 a (-es+ass cha-ge, i( is a /iola(ion o. (he RPC, an0 7 6ish .o- (his (o ,e cons(-ue0as a
3B8






























g-ie/ance an0 .o- .u-(he- in/es(iga(ion (o ,e un0e-(a=en. Ce-(ainl3, Kei(h @oo)is g-ie/ance o. 4ugus(
&8(h, &1& loo=s )o-e su++o-(a,le
Rule3.3.Candor Toward the Tribunal.
9a:E4 la63e- shall no( =no6ingl3"
91:E8a=e a .alse s(a(e)en( o. .ac( o- la6 (o a (-i,unal o- .ail (o co--ec( a .alse s(a(e)en( o.
)a(e-ial .ac( o- la6 +-e/iousl3 )a0e (o (he (-i,unal ,3 (he la63e-F
9&:E$ail (o 0isclose (o (he (-i,unal legal au(ho-i(3 in (he con(-olling Au-is0ic(ion =no6n (o (he
la63e- (o ,e 0i-ec(l3 a0/e-se (o (he +osi(ion o. (he clien( an0 no( 0isclose0 ,3 o++osing counselF o-
93:EO..e- e/i0ence (ha( (he la63e- =no6s (o ,e .alse. 7. a la63e-, (he la63e-Gs clien(, o- a
6i(ness calle0 ,3 (he la63e-, has o..e-e0 )a(e-ial e/i0ence an0 (he la63e- co)es (o =no6 o. i(s .alsi(3,
(he la63e- shall (a=e -easona,le -e)e0ial )easu-es, inclu0ing, i. necessa-3, 0isclosu-e (o (he (-i,unal. 4
la63e- )a3 -e.use (o o..e- e/i0ence, o(he- (han (he (es(i)on3 o. a 0e.en0an( in a c-i)inal )a((e-, (ha(
(he la63e- -easona,l3 ,elie/es is .alse.
9,:E4 la63e- 6ho -e+-esen(s a clien( in an a0Au0ica(i/e +-ocee0ing an0 6ho =no6s (ha( a +e-son
in(en0s (o engage, is engaging o- has engage0 in c-i)inal o- .-au0ulen( con0uc( -ela(e0 (o (he
+-ocee0ing sIhall (a=e -easona,le -e)e0ial )easu-es, inclu0ing, i. necessa-3, 0isclosu-e (o (he
(-i,unal.
9c:E!he 0u(ies s(a(e0 in +a-ag-a+hs 9a: an0 9,: con(inue (o (he conclusion o. (he +-ocee0ing, an0
a++l3 e/en i. co)+liance -equi-es 0isclosu-e o. in.o-)a(ion o(he-6ise +-o(ec(e0 ,3 Rule 1.6.
90:E7n an ex +a-(e +-ocee0ing, a la63e- shall in.o-) (he (-i,unal o. all )a(e-ial .ac(s =no6n (o (he
la63e- (ha( 6ill ena,le (he (-i,unal (o )a=e an in.o-)e0 0ecision, 6he(he- o- no( (he .ac(s a-e a0/e-se.
114 5oung /iola(e0 RPC 3.3 6hen, a( (-ial in RCR&11<633%1 on 4ugus( &9(h, &1& he asse-(e0 (o
R?C ?u0ge *.e--aLLa (ha( @a3(on / *(a(e +-esen(e0 )an0a(o-3 ,in0ing au(ho-i(3 in Ne/a0a +-e/en(ing
?u0ge *.e--aLLa .-o) exce-cising an3 0isc-e(i(ion 6i(h -ega-0 (o 6he(he- Coughlin coul0 a++ea- as his
o6n co<counsel. Ce-(ainl3, 2he,3 an0 o(he- cases +-o/e o(he-6ise. 5e(, 114 5oung 6as insis(en(
an0 clea- in his s(a(e)en(s (ha( (he-e 6as >)an0a(o-3, ,in0ing au(ho-i(3> +-e/en(ing an3 exce-cise o.
such 0isc-e(ion ,3 (he cou-( (o +e-)i( a co<counsel a--ange)en(.
114 5oung has con(inuall3 sough( (o 0en3 Coughlin his -igh( (o a legi(i)a(e +-e<(-ial hea-ing in
RCR&1&<6563, in .ac(, 5oung nee0s (o ans6e- (o 6he(he- o- no( R8C ?u0ge Nash Hol)es an0 he
9as 6ell as 1ogan o- an3one 6i(h (he 2CP1: )e(, on o- a,ou( $e,-ua-3 &#(h, &1&, )inu(es ,e.o-e
?u0ge Nash Hol)es en(e-e0 he- cou-(-oo) in 11 !R &68 an0 sho-(l3 (he-ea.(e- .oun0 Coughlin in
>c-i)inal con(e)+(> in a (-a..ic ci(a(ion (-ial, secon0s a.(e- Coughlin (es(i.ie0 (ha( RP1 *a-gen( Ca-(e-
lie0 in his (es(i)on3 -ela(e0 (o (he (h-ee (-a..ic ci(a(ions he ha0 issue0 on Coughlin inci0en( (o Richa-0
Hill, Esq;s -e.usal (o -e(u-n Coughlin his clien(;s .iles o- Coughlin;s s(a(e issue0 i0en(i.ca(ion.
400i(ionall3, +lease a00 (o (his g-ie/ance, Reno Ci(3 a((o-ne3 4llison O-)ass, .o- he- lac= .o Can0o- (o
(he !-i,unal in asse-(ing (ha( (he 6o-0 >-e(alia(ion> an0 (he su,Aec( o. -e(alia(ion 0i0 no( a++ea- in (he
+olice -e+o-( .o- (ha( No/e),e- 15(h, &11 (-a..ic ci(a(ion 6hen clea-l3, (he -e+o-( -e/eals (ha( is 0oes.
%B8


































Rule 3.3 9.o-)e-l3 *u+-e)e Cou-( Rule 1#&: is (he sa)e as 4B4 8o0el Rule 3.3.
Rule3.4.Fairness to Opposing Part and Counsel.4 la63e- shall no("
9a:EMnla6.ull3 o,s(-uc( ano(he- +a-(3Gs access (o e/i0ence o- unla6.ull3 al(e-, 0es(-o3 o- conceal a
0ocu)en( o- o(he- )a(e-ial ha/ing +o(en(ial e/i0en(ia-3 /alue. 4 la63e- shall no( counsel o- assis(
ano(he- +e-son (o 0o an3 such ac(F
9,:E$alsi.3 e/i0ence, counsel o- assis( a 6i(ness (o (es(i.3 .alsel3, o- o..e- an in0uce)en( (o a
6i(ness (ha( is +-ohi,i(e0 ,3 la6F
9c:EKno6ingl3 0iso,e3 an o,liga(ion un0e- (he -ules o. a (-i,unal exce+( .o- an o+en -e.usal ,ase0
on an asse-(ion (ha( no /ali0 o,liga(ion exis(sF
90:E7n +-e(-ial +-oce0u-e, )a=e a .-i/olous 0isco/e-3 -eques( o- .ail (o )a=e -easona,l3 0iligen(
e..o-( (o co)+l3 6i(h a legall3 +-o+e- 0isco/e-3 -eques( ,3 an o++osing +a-(3F
9e:E7n (-ial, allu0e (o an3 )a((e- (ha( (he la63e- 0oes no( -easona,l3 ,elie/e is -ele/an( o- (ha( 6ill
no( ,e su++o-(e0 ,3 a0)issi,le e/i0ence, asse-( +e-sonal =no6le0ge o. .ac(s in issue exce+( 6hen
(es(i.3ing as a 6i(ness, o- s(a(e a +e-sonal o+inion as (o (he Aus(ness o. a cause, (he c-e0i,ili(3 o. a
6i(ness, (he cul+a,ili(3 o. a ci/il li(igan( o- (he guil( o- innocence o. an accuse0F o-
9.:EReques( a +e-son o(he- (han a clien( (o -e.-ain .-o) /olun(a-il3 gi/ing -ele/an( in.o-)a(ion (o
ano(he- +a-(3 unless"
91:E!he +e-son is a -ela(i/e o- an e)+lo3ee o- o(he- agen( o. a clien(F an0
9&:E!he la63e- -easona,l3 ,elie/es (ha( (he +e-sonGs in(e-es(s 6ill no( ,e a0/e-sel3 a..ec(e0 ,3
-e.-aining .-o) gi/ing such in.o-)a(ion.
114 5oung, on ?ul3 16(h, &1&, /iola(e0 RPC 3.% 6hen he )a0e (he s(a(e)en( (o (he Cou-( in
RCR&11<633%1, a( !-ial, (ha( Coughlin cause0 (he con(inuance (ha( 6as necessi(a(e0 (ha( 0a3 ,3 ?oe
Ioo0nigh(, Esq. 92CP1: su00en -e)o/al .-o) (he case. Coughlin +oin(e0 ou( (ha( e/en he ha0 no(
,een gi/en an3 -a(ionale .o- Ioo0nigh(;s su00en -e)o/al .-o) a 8on0a3 !-ial 6hen Ioo0nigh( ha0
)e( 6i(h Coughlin .o- (-ial +-e+ (he $-i0a3 ,e.o-e, (en0ing (o in0ica(e (ha( ei(he- 5oung 6as +-i/3 (o
in.o-)a(ion .-o) (he 2CP1 (ha( Coughlin 6as no( +-i/3 (o, o- 5oung 6as )a=ing a-gu)en(s no(
,ase0 in .ac( o- la6 o- in line 6i(h RP1 3.%9e:. 114 5oung (hen sough( (o ,ac=(-ac=, )a=ing )incing
s(a(e)en(s a,ou( ho6 he >assu)e0> (his o- (ha( an0 ho6 he ha0 no( ac(ual3 ha0 i)+e-)issil,e
co))unica(ions 6i(h 2CP1 Bosle- 96ho 6as .illing in .o- Ioo0nigh(:. R?C ?u0ge *.e--aLLa
-e,u=e0 114 5oung, +oin(ing ou( (ha( he shoul0 no( >assu)e> an3(hing.
114 5oung con(inues (o i)+e-)issi,l3 see= (o le/e-age ano(he- o,s(-uc(ingB-esis(ingB)a=ing a
>.alse> s(a(e)en( (o a +u,lic o..ice- cha-ge in RCR&1&<6#98, 0es+i(e his ha/ing ,een +-o/i0e0
excu+la(o-3 /i0eos an0 0es+i(e a lac= o. +-o,a,le cause (o su++o-( (he co)+lain(, (he in.o-)a(ion +le0
(he-ein ,eing 0e.icien( as 6ell. 400i(ionall3, Coughlin;s ?une &6(h an0 ?ul3 3-0, &1& e)ails 9see
,elo6: )a=e clea- (ha( (he RP1, Reno ?us(ice Cou-(, 2ashoe Coun(3 *he-i.., e( al 6e-e )a0e a6a-e
6ell in a0/ance o. (he 0e.iciencies in (he 5 0a3 unla6.ul 0e(aine- no(ice 0-a.(e0 an0 se-/e0 ,3 @e6
!ai(el, Esq;s a++a-en( ,usiness +a-(ne-s, Ne/a0a Cou-( *e-/ices, 6ho a-e co))i((ing (he unau(ho-iLe0
5B8





































+-ac(ice o. la6 in (hei- >e/ic(ion consul(ing se-/ices> 9+lease see )3 -ecen( g-ie/ance in (ha( -ega-0:.
4n a((o-ne3 6ho ini(ia(es, causes (o ,e ini(ia(e0, o- (h-ea(ens (o ini(ia(e a c-i)inal +-osecu(ion .o- (he
+u-+ose o. in.luencing a ci/il )a((e- is /iola(ing (he -ules o. e(hics. *ee 8o0el Co0e o. P-o.Gl
Res+onsi,ili(3 1R #<15 91983:. *ee also I-ego-3 I. *a-no, 4nno(a(ion, 7ni(ia(ing, o- !h-ea(ening (o
7ni(ia(e, C-i)inal P-osecu(ion as I-oun0 .o- 1isci+lining Counsel, %& 4.@.R.%(h 1 9&6:. 114
5oung an0 (he 2C14 )a3 ,e /iola(ing (he .ollo6ing" 4((o-ne3 /iola(e0 +-o.essional con0uc( -ules
+-ohi,i(ing con0uc( +-eAu0icial (o (he a0)inis(-a(ion
o. Aus(ice an0 +-ohi,i(ing a la63e- .-o) (h-ea(ening (o +-esen( c-i)inal cha-ges
solel3 (o o,(ain an a0/an(age in a ci/il )a((e-, 6he-e a((o-ne3 (h-ea(ene0 a co)+lainan( 6i(h
c-i)inal +-osecu(ion an0 a 0e.a)a(ion sui( (o +-e/en( hi) .-o) +-essing .o-6a-0 6i(h a 0isci+lina-3
co)+lain(. *(a(e Ba- 4-(icles o. 7nco-+o-a(ion, 4-(. 16, Rules o. P-o..Con0uc(, Rules
8.%90, g:, @*4NR.*. .oll. 3#"&&&. 7n -e Ro,inson, %6 *o. 30 66& 9@a. &1:. 400i(ionall3, a
+-ac(i(ione- )a3 ,e sanc(ione0, o- e/en 0is,a--e0, .o- coe-cing an3 +e-son connec(e0 (o (he case, .o-
)a=ing .alse s(a(e)en(s o. )a(e-ial .ac( o- la6, o- .o- .-i/olous ,eha/io- ,e.o-e (he i))ig-a(ion cou-(s.
4 Plain(i.. (ha( has ,een ha-asse0, in(i)i0a(e0 o- (-ea(e0 in a ,a0 .ai(h )anne- ,3 a 1e.en0an( has (6o
-ecou-ses" Rule 119,:91: an0 Rule 119,:9&:. Ho6e/e-, )alicious +-osecu(ion ac(ions a-e necessa-3 (o
0e(e- +e-sons .-o) +-ocu-ing (he a--es( o. ano(he- )aliciousl3 an0 6i(hou( +-o,a,le cause. Hun( /.
@a6son, &8 2@ %6915& 9K3. &8:, as co--ec(e0, 9Oc(. &%, &8:. 8e-le( /. RiLLo, 6% Cal. 4++. %(h
53, #5 Cal. R+(-. &0 83 91s( 1is(. 1998:.
2CP1 ?i) @eslie has /iola(e0 RPC 1.& in RCR&11<633%1 in a((e)+(ing (o 6i(h0-a6 .-o)
c-i)inal 0e.en0an( Coughlin one o. (he .e6 in/iola,le -igh(s a c-i)inal 0e.en0an( has. @eslie has
-e.use0 (o a((e)+( (o +-ocu-e au(hen(ica(ion o- .oun0a(ion .o- (he a0)ission o. excu+la(o-3 /i0eos o.
(he a--es( o. 4ugus( &(h, &11 in (ha( case .-o) an3 o. (he 6i(nesses in (he case. Ra(he-, @eslie has
)ain(aine0 (ha( he 6ill onl3 +u( on such /i0eos 96he(he- as e/i0ence o- (o -e.-esh a 6i(ness
-ecollec(ion, an0 o- .o- i)+each)en( +u-+oses: i. Coughlin hi)sel. (a=es (he s(an0 an0 +-o/i0es
au(hen(ica(ion an0 .oun0a(ion .o- (he /i0eos, (he-e,3 ex+osing Coughlin (o a 6ai/e- o. his -igh( (o
0eci0e 6he(he- o- no( (o (es(i.3, an0 o+ening (he sco+e o. c-oss exa)ina(ion i)+e-)issi,l3. $u-(he-,
@eslie has -e.use0 (o 0o o- +-o/i0e an3 legal -esea-ch (o 0e(e-)ine (he +e-)issi,ili(3 o. onl3 u(iliLing
+o-(ions o. an3 such /i0eo e/i0ence. !ha( is (o sa3, @eslie insis(s (ha( (he /i0eos )us( ,e su,)i((e0 in
(o(o, e/en +o-(ions (ha( 0a)age Coughlin;s case. @eslie has a 0u(3 o. 0iligence an0 co)+e(ence, an0
his ,lase -e.usal (o +-o/i0e an3 legal ci(a(ion .o- his con(en(ion (ha( Coughlin;s 0e.ense )a3 no( inclu0e
+ic=ing an choosing 6hich +o-(ions o. such /i0eos (o u(iliLe in !-ial is /iola(i/e o. (hose 0u(ies, in
a00i(ion (o /iola(ing RPC 1.&;s 0ic(a(e (ha( a >la63e- shall a,i0e ,3 a clien(Gs 0ecision conce-ning (he
o,Aec(i/es o. -e+-esen(a(ion an0, as -equi-e0 Rule 1.%, shall consul( 6i(h (he clien( as (o (he )eans ,3
6hich (he3 a-e (o ,e +u-sue0> an0 (ha( >(he la63e- shall a,i0e ,3 (he clien(Gs 0ecision, a.(e-
consul(a(ion 6i(h (he la63e-, as (o a +lea (o ,e en(e-e0, 6he(he- (o 6ai/e Au-3 (-ial and whether the
client will testif...>.
Rule!.".Scope of Representation and #llocation of #uthorit $etween Client and %awer.
9a:E*u,Aec( (o +a-ag-a+hs 9c: an0 90:, a la63e- shall a,i0e ,3 a clien(Gs 0ecision conce-ning (he
o,Aec(i/es o. -e+-esen(a(ion an0, as -equi-e0 Rule 1.%, shall consul( 6i(h (he clien( as (o (he )eans ,3
6hich (he3 a-e (o ,e +u-sue0. 4 la63e- )a3 (a=e such ac(ion on ,ehal. o. (he clien( as is i)+lie0l3
au(ho-iLe0 (o ca--3 ou( (he -e+-esen(a(ion. 4 la63e- shall a,i0e ,3 a clien(Gs 0ecision 6he(he- (o se((le a
6B8





































)a((e-. 7n a c-i)inal case, (he la63e- shall a,i0e ,3 (he clien(Gs 0ecision, a.(e- consul(a(ion 6i(h (he
la63e-, as (o a +lea (o ,e en(e-e0, 6he(he- (o 6ai/e Au-3 (-ial an0 6he(he- (he clien( 6ill (es(i.3.
9,:E4 la63e-Gs -e+-esen(a(ion o. a clien(, inclu0ing -e+-esen(a(ion ,3 a++oin()en(, 0oes no(
cons(i(u(e an en0o-se)en( o. (he clien(Gs +oli(ical, econo)ic, social o- )o-al /ie6s o- ac(i/i(ies.
9c:E4 la63e- )a3 li)i( (he sco+e o. (he -e+-esen(a(ion i. (he li)i(a(ion is -easona,le un0e- (he
ci-cu)s(ances an0 (he clien( gi/es in.o-)e0 consen(.
90:E4 la63e- shall no( counsel a clien( (o engage, o- assis( a clien(, in con0uc( (ha( (he la63e-
=no6s is c-i)inal o- .-au0ulen(, ,u( a la63e- )a3 0iscuss (he legal consequences o. an3 +-o+ose0
cou-se o. con0uc( 6i(h a clien( an0 )a3 counsel o- assis( a clien( (o )a=e a goo0 .ai(h e..o-( (o
0e(e-)ine (he /ali0i(3, sco+e, )eaning o- a++lica(ion o. (he la6.
$u-(he-, (his g-ie/ance see=s (o ha/e an in/es(iga(ion un0e-(a=en (o 0e(e-i)ine 6he(he- (he
ci-cu)s(ances 0e(aile0 in (he ?une #(h, &1& e)ail ,3 Coughlin (o 0a/i0c'n/,a-.o-g, an0 (he 2C14,
6he-ein a ,a((e-3 /ia a li( ciga-e((e +-oAec(e0 a( Coughlin a( close -ange ,3 Co-3 Io,le 6as (he su,Aec(
o. a g-an( o. i))uni(3 ,3 (he 2C14, 0es+i(e (he ex(en( (o 6hich such con0uc( is illegal an0
-easona,le calcula(e0 (o 0issua0e Coughlin .-o) (es(i3ing in RCR&11<633%1. $u-(he- inqui-3 is
-eques(e0 as (o (he +e-)issi,ili(3 o. 2CP1 ?i) @eslie -e.using (o e/en ,-ing u+ (he su,Aec( on c-oss
exa)ina(ion o. Io,le, Za-a(e o- 1u-al0e in (ha( )a((e-.
Co)+ensa(o-3 1a)ages !o+ic *u))a-3 Co--ela(ion !a,le Re.e-ences O 11#. 7nAu-3 (o -e+u(a(ion
2es(;s Ke3 Nu),e- 1iges( 2es(;s Ke3 Nu),e- 1iges(, 8alicious P-osecu(ion =6# Co)+ensa(o-3
0a)ages in a )alicious +-osecu(ion ac(ion )a3 inclu0e ha-) (o (he +lain(i..;s -e+u(a(ion cause0 ,3 (he
un0e-l3ing ac(ion,P$N1Q inclu0ing (he 0a)age (o one;s -e+u(a(ion .-o) (he )alicious ins(i(u(ion o.
a0)inis(-a(i/e +-ocee0ings.P$N&Q !hus, (he +lain(i.. in an ac(ion .o- )alicious +-osecu(ion )a3 -eco/e-
0a)ages .o- inAu-3 (o his o- he- -e+u(a(ion,P$N3Q inclu0ing inAu-3 -esul(ing .-o) (he +u,lica(ion o.
-e+o-(s o. (he +-ocee0ings.P $N%Q Cau(ion" 4l(hough a )alicious +-osecu(ion is, a( co))on la6,
assu)e0 (o ,e ha-).ul (o an in0i/i0ual;s -e+u(a(ion, i( is none(heless necessa-3 (o )a=e an o,Aec(i/e
sho6ing o. an in0i/i0ual;s -e+u(a(ion ,e.o-e (he )alicious +-osecu(ion /e-sus (he 0a)age0 con0i(ion o.
his o- he- -e+u(a(ion a.(e-6a-0s (o su++o-( an a6a-0 o. 0a)ages .o- inAu-3 (o -e+u(a(ion.P$N5Q !he
+lain(i..;s o6n (es(i)on3 (ha( he o- she los( -es+ec( 0ue (o (he )alicious +-osecu(ion is no( enough,
6i(hou( o(he- o,Aec(i/e e/i0ence, (o su++o-( such an a6a-0.P$N6Q E/i0ence o. a +lain(i..;s +-io- a--es(s
is +-o+e-l3 a0)i((e0 in a )alicious +-osecu(ion ac(ion i. (ha( e/i0ence ,ea-s 0i-ec(l3 on (he ques(ion o.
6he(he- o- no( (he +lain(i..;s a--es( in .ac( 0a)age0 his o- he- -e+u(a(ion, in /ie6 o. his o- he- +-e/ious
a--es(s.P$N#Q Ho6e/e-, i( has also ,een hel0 (ha( a (-ial cou-( 0oes no( e-- in exclu0ing such e/i0ence,
,ecause i( has no -ele/anc3 (o (he issue o. co)+ensa(o-3 0a)ages.P$N8Q P$N1Q Bha(ia /. 1e,e=, &8#
Conn. 39#, 9%8 4.&0 19 9&8:F *i=o-a /. Ii,,s, 13& Ohio 4++. 30 ##, #&6 N.E.&0 5%, 111
4.@.R.5(h 685 91(h 1is(. $-an=lin Coun(3 1999:F 2ech( /. PI Pu,. Co., #&5 4.&0 #88 9Pa. *u+e-. C(.
1999:. P$N&Q 8el/in /. Pence, 13 $.&0 %&3, 1%3 4.@.R. 1%9 94++. 1.C. 19%&:. P$N3Q B-o6ning /.
Ra3, 1968 OK 5&, %% P.&0 #&1 9O=la. 1968:. P$N%Q I-i)es /. I-een,la((, %# Colo. %95, 1# P. 1111
9191:. 4s (o +-oo. o. +u,lici(3 gi/en (o +-osecu(ion, see O 119. P$N5Q Ro0ic= /. Ci(3 o. *chenec(a03,
856 $. *u++. 15 9N.1. N.5. 199%: 9a++l3ing Ne6 5o-= la6:. P$N6Q Ro0ic= /. Ci(3 o. *chenec(a03,
856 $. *u++. 15 9N.1. N.5. 199%: 9a++l3ing Ne6 5o-= la6:. P$N#Q 1elcha)+s, 7nc. /. B-3an(, #38
*o. &0 8&% 94la. 1999:. P$N8Q *La-eA=o /. 4)e-ling Vol=s6agen, 7nc., 55 4.1.&0 81, 39 N.5.*.&0
&66 930 1e+;( 19#6:.
#B8


*ince-el3,
Zach Coughlin
PO BOR 3961
Reno, NV 8955
!el ##5 338 8118
$ax 9%9 66# #%&
ZachCoughlin'ho()ail.co)
8B8
Report Selection Criteria
Case ID: CV11-03051
Docket Start Date:
Docket Ending Date:
Case Description
Case ID: CV11-03051 - ZACH C!"H#I$ VS% &A'' &ER#ISS E' A# (D1)
*iling Date: +ednesda,- cto.er 1/t0- 1011
',pe: CA - 2!S'ICE C!R' CIVI# A33EA#
Stat4s: EV$'C#SED - E5ent Closed
Related Cases
$o related cases 6ere 7o4nd%
Case E5ent Sc0ed4le
$o case e5ents 6ere 7o4nd%
Case 3arties
Se8 9 Assoc E:pn Date ',pe ID $a;e
1 24dge D1 <ERR=- H$RA<#E 2A$E' 2%
Address: 4na5aila.le Aliases: none

3 / 3etitioner >110?1@1 C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Address: 4na5aila.le Aliases: C!"H#I$- ZACHAR= <ARAER
CA!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
C!"H#I$- ZACHAR= <ARAER
C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
C!"H#I$- ZACH
C!"H#I$- ZACAAR=

B 3ro 3er-3lt7C3etCAppellant 3R3ER 3ro3er 3erson
Address: 4na5aila.le Aliases: none

5 Respondent >1111/?5 &ER#ISS- &A''
Address: 4na5aila.le Aliases: none

/ 3 Attorne, /B@3 Co4g0lin- Es8%- Zac0ar,
Address: 111 Ri5er Rock St%
Reno $V D/501 Aliases: none

1
Docket Entries
*iling Date Description $a;e &onetar,
1/-C'-1011
03:0? 3& A77ida5it %%% C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: A**IDAVI' * 3VER'= (DE*E$DA$') - $'ICE * A33EA# *R& RE$ 2!S'ICE
C!R'

1/-C'-1011
03:0? 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: DC!&E$' 'I'#E: &'I$ ' 3RCEED I$ *R&A 3A!3ERIS (DE*E$DA$')
(3A3ER RDER 3RVIDED) 3AR'= S!<&I''I$": ZACH C!"H#I$ DA'E S!<&I''ED:
10C1/C1011 S!<&I''ED <=: V% A##E$ DA'E RECEIVED 2!D"E **ICE:

1/-C'-1011
05:0? 3& &tn 3roceed *or;a 3a4peris C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: $'ICE * A33EA# *R& RE$ 2!S'ICE C!R'

01-$V-1011
03:1/ 3& &otion %%% C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: A&E$DED &'I$ A$D A**IDAVI' I$ S!33R' * &'I$ ' 3RCEED $
A33EA# I$ *R&A 3A!3ERIS

01-$V-1011
03:1/ 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: DC!&E$' 'I'#E: A&E$DED &'I$ A$D A**IDAVI' I$ S!33R' * &'I$
' 3RCEED $ A33EA# I$ *R&A 3A!3ERIS ($ 3A3ER RDER) 3AR'= S!<&I''I$":
ZACH C!"H#I$ DA'E S!<&I''ED: 11C01C11 S!<&I''ED <=: D2 DA'E RECEIVED
2!D"E **ICE:

0D-$V-1011
10:1/ A& rd Den, in *or;a 3a4peris
Entr,: 'ransaction 15@?DD/ - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-0D-1011:10:11:3/

0D-$V-1011
10:15 A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 15@?/1B - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-0D-1011:10:1@:BB

0D-$V-1011
10:31 A& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co;plet
Entr,: none%

0D-$V-1011
10:31 A& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co;plet
Entr,: none%
1

0D-$V-1011
01:3D 3& E:-3arte &tn%%% C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: EE 3AR'E E&ER"E$C= &'I$ ' S'A= A$D SE' ASIDE S!&&AR= EVIC'I$
RDER

13-$V-1011
0B:51 3& &tn 3roceed *or;a 3a4peris C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: &'I$ *R REC$SIDERA'I$ * I*3F R A#'ER$A'IVE#=- &'I$ '
3RCEED I$*R&A 3A!3ERIS

13-$V-1011
0B:51 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission C!"H#I$- ZACHAR=
Entr,: DC!&E$' 'I'#E: &'I$ *R REC$SIDERA'I$ * I*3F R A#'ER$A'IVE#=-
&'I$ ' 3RCEED I$*R&A 3A!3ERIS (3A3ER RDER $' 3RVIDED) 3AR'=
S!<&I''I$": ZACH C!"H#I$ DA'E S!<&I''ED: $V% 1D- 1011 S!<&I''ED <=:
'+HI'E DA'E RECEIVED 2!D"E **ICE:

1/-$V-1011
11:BB A& $otice o7 Appearance
Entr,: ZACH C!"H#I$ ESG *R ZACH C!"H#I$ - 'ransaction 1?11/B? - Appro5ed <,:
AZI$ : 11-1/-1011:0/:10:11

1/-$V-1011
0/:1B A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?11310 - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-1/-1011:0/:15:35

0D-DEC-1011
11:03 3& rd Den,ing &otion
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?3B15D - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-0D-1011:11:0B:13

0D-DEC-1011
11:0B 3& HH Case Closed
Entr,: none%

0D-DEC-1011
11:05 3& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?3B1?1 - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-0D-1011:11:05:BB

10-DEC-1011
05:0/ 3& rd Den,ing &otion
Entr,: *R REC$SIDERA'I$ * I*3F R A#'ER$A'IVE#= &'I$ ' 3RCEED I$
*R&A 3A!3ERIS - 'ransaction 1?5D3@B - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-10-1011:1@:10:1B

10-DEC-1011
05:0/ 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co;plet
Entr,: none%
3

10-DEC-1011
05:10 3& HH Case Closed
Entr,: none%

10-DEC-1011
05:11 3& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?5D3@? - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 11-10-1011:1@:11:15

10-2A$-1011
05:35 A& $otice o7 Appearance Co4g0lin- Es8%- Zac0ar,
Entr,: ZACH C!"H#I$- ESG% $ <EHA#* * ZACH C!"H#I$ - 'ransaction 1?/0013 -
Appro5ed <,: #&A'HE!S : 01-10-1011:0/:0/:3D

10-2A$-1011
0/:10 A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?/035@ - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 01-10-1011:0/:11:1@

11-2A$-1011
0?:03 A& E:-3arte &tn%%% Co4g0lin- Es8%- Zac0ar,
Entr,: E&ER"E$C= EE 3AR'E &'I$ *R C#ARI*ICA'I$ * RDER DE$=I$" I*3 -
'ransaction 1?/1?DD - Appro5ed <,: #&A'HE!S : 01-11-1011:11:1?:15

11-2A$-1011
0?:1D A& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co4g0lin- Es8%- Zac0ar,
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?/1?D/ - Appro5ed <,: #&A'HE!S : 01-11-1011:11:1@:01 DC!&E$'
'I'#E: E&ER"E$C= EE 3AR'E &'I$ *R C#ARI*ICA'I$ * RDER DE$=I$" I*3
3AR'= S!<&I''I$": ZACH C!"H#I$- ESG% DA'E S!<&I''ED: 01C11C11 S!<&I''ED <=:
#&A'HE!S DA'E RECEIVED 2!D"E **ICE:

11-2A$-1011
11:1D A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?/3/0? - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 01-11-1011:11:30:1D

11-2A$-1011
11:30 A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1?/3/1B - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 01-11-1011:11:31:1B

11-2A$-1011
11:33 3& HH Case Reopened
Entr,: none%

1D-2A$-1011
01:1@ 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co;plet
Entr,: none%

1@-2A$-1011
B
10:1@ A& rder %%%
Entr,: 'ransaction 1@15BD1 - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 01-1@-1011:10:1D:1D

1@-2A$-1011
10:1D A& HH Case Closed
Entr,: none%

1@-2A$-1011
10:1/ A& 3roo7 o7 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: 'ransaction 1@15BD/ - Appro5ed <,: $REVIE+ : 01-1@-1011:10:30:3B

01-*E<-1011
03:55 3& Re84est 7or S4.;ission Co;plet
Entr,: C0ie7 24dge iss4e

5
2
3
5
6
7
8
9
10
I I
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
22
23
(.lse No. II TR 26S00 21
Dept. No. J
IN THE MUNICIPAL COURT OF THE CITY OF RENO
COUNTY OF \V ASHOE STATE OF NEVADA
CITY OF RENO.
Plaintiff.
ORDER
vs.
ZACHAR Y nARKER COUGHLll'I.
Defendant.
_____________________ 1
March 12. 2012 was lhe time set for the resumption of the traffic citation trial of
Defendant ZACIIAR Y [3ARKER COUGHLIN who. as member No. 947J of the Nevada [Jar.
is an attorney representing himself. the defendant. The trial was cont inued on Fcbmary 27.
2012. when. ana approximately an hour and a half. the defendant was held in criminal
contempt hy the court for hi s antics and misconduct during that trial. His behavior is noted in
lkt3il in the court's Order entered on Feb(\lary 27. 2010.
r<l day. :VIr. COl1!lhlin fa iled to appear to complet e this trial. He 11)3 not contacted Ihis
2
J
5
6
7
8
9
10
I I
12
I J
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
11
11
I
I i
,
I
i
, , I
)
he ,awe! his liv..:-day ofCvurt by this (Ollrt on
27, 2012, :-"Ir. Coughlin f:lx-tiled to this court I a 224-pagc document entitkd "Noti,
of ,\ppeal of Summary Contempt Order; :-"Iotion to Return Personal Property CUlltiscJted by
Reno \lunicipaJ Court:md Its :-"Imhals; Motion for New Trial and to Alter or
Summary Contempt Order." rhe: document purported to appe:llthis court's Order hole! ing
him in direct criminal contempt. It conwined a portion of one sentence on page seeking l
continuJnce oftod:lY's hearing, but no further discussion orthat topic. It also mentioned
being a "tolling" motion in:m apparent afterthought. It did not address most of the oth.:r
topics li sted in the caption. InstcJd, the: document contained rambling references to his
and this court's; his father', football career in college; dozens of of string
citati ons t:lken off Ihe internet; documents rrom a prisoner online site; un article about a
" police stJte;" an article about Discovery; a website: printout showing a police or'fkcr ' s salJry:
and copy of court docwnents tram a District of Columbia case.
It was a di sjointed regurgitation of case law citations from a legal research onl ine sit e
with liille reference to, or argument about, the Cacts o f his instant SlIl p" Irarti c
case. The uocum"nt was an incoherent .nd Jemonstration ofwhJt might once have
been legal and academic proweS3 that appears to now he greatly dJITIJIlCd. '.!r. COlJ"hli n (ax-
riled another oocll nlcnt in whi ch he apparently took a Moti on to Prncecd In(orma I' Jllpcris
[:i el ill Jl hHha case ,Ind typed over lor ,\ udio of fdmury ":'", el) I"
1 I .
. '
2
J
4
5
6
7
g
9
10
II
12
IJ
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
2 l
i
, I '
. ,
,
27, 12 disrupted Department J ,'f this court and distress to this COlirt and
its stalT and JS JS the prosecutor and the witness, and resulted in \fr. Coughlin
hdd in contempt of court, his and tiling uf these documents greatly Jisnlpted the
uperatiun uf the entire Reno Municipal Court system, including the ckrk 's and the
other Jcpanm"nts, "nd necessitated that nction be taKen by the Court Administrator Jnd
Administrative Judge.
,\pparently beginning on 9, 2012 at 12:38 p.m., Mr. Coughlin again lI nderto"k
another massive t:'L'(-filing to Reno Municipal Court, This time it was a document that was
tile-stamped by the clerk on 12, 2012 at 8: 12 a.m. This second 2lS-page document
purported to be yet another motion in this case entitled "Motion to Return Cell Phones;
Motion to Set Aside Summary Contempt Order; and Notice of Appeal of Summary Contempt
Order." With scant discussion of, or relevance to, the above-captioned malter, said document
mostly argues against Judge Howard in a Department 4 case and again contains more than
200 pages of string kgal citations; lyrics to rocks songs; Mr. Coughl in's personal family
history; Ji "cussion o f an "ViCl ioll and contempt case; disjoinkd legal citat ions,
and other non"ensical matters that have no apparent relevance to his traffic citati on el se.
!l oth documents massive and tnok up a great deal of time because the court haJ to
review them to look fur some connecti on to the case. This court has the inherent authority to
rn J. intain re spect, and <.h:corum in the court . . 1nJ t l) refuse tll tdl ow tht.: ( uurt [ll re.! tl -> t.: J
, .
, .
. ,
2
J
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
13

15
16
17
18
19
20
11
22
; 3
1 ,
ll r his to the co urt. lilJSnluch .lS the hJS at kJst fOll r J ii'fcn:nt
.IJJres5cs for him. it is unabk to Jscertain his cxact whereabouts. He shows signs or mental
instJbili ty. if not serious il lnes!.
[h scd upon the total circumstances of this C35e. the in-cOl rt perfonnance of th<!
Jd'cndant, .15 observed by this court, the written documents f:l.xed to the court tor tilin!,l by
this JefenJant. the st:lICmen ls and behavior of this defendant anJ his overall conduc t hcrein.
this court rinds, by c1c:I[ and convi ncing evidence, that Zachary f3 arker Coughlin, an atlOrnt:y
liccnsed to practice law in Ihe State has commillcd numerous acts ot'atlOmey
misconduct, including, but not limited to, violating the following Rules of Professional
Conduct:
R . .J(e}--cngJging in dishonesty. fraud, Jeceit or mi srepresent ation;
8.-1 (d}-engaging in conJuct that is prej udic ial to the admini stration of justice;
J.J (a}-lack of candor to the court by knowingly making false statcment s to j tribunal;
J . I-1CI" fcnding in a proceeding by asserting or cont rovert ing an issue without a basis in
fac t ;lnJ wi th Ih3t are known to be fri volous;
J .l-fail ll re to make reasonabl e efforts to li tigati on, :lnd, in I:,c t, taking
me3surcs to delay litigation;
J..J (e )-hcing lI nl'iir to opposing cuunsel by continually 311 udi ng to ll1att crs the !awya
n"t reasonJb ly he lieve Me relevant or .' lIppor1eJ by :l dmi ssible evidence;
[0 a(; t '-'lith diligence :1f1d ,IIlJ
- I
1
'1 j "t,.'!l ', ) d Ill ! ;'! ..... J' .'. J I hl ll ' r :, !I' d I ."p" . .. '!i '. ' , I ':
- .
2
3
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
13

15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
13
25
21i
Whether or not there are medical reasons to \Ir. Coughlin's actions is not for
this court to decide. He has become nothing les! than a vexatious litigant to Reno \Iunicipal
Court due to his disruptive, bizarre and irnlional methods and practices that go
beyond the pale of anything th:lt is civil, ethical, professional or competent. Gaud cause
appearing therefore, the court orders as follows:
IT IS ORDERED thai this matter is continued, and all proceedings relating thereto are
tolled, until further order of this court, "'hile the matter of attorney Zachary Barker Cou!!hlin
is referred to the Stale Bar of Nevada;
IT IS ORDERED that no further action shall be taken by the Reno City A!tomey's
Office, or the clerks or statT of Reno Municipal Court, in the above-entitled case, pending
further order of this court;
IT IS ORDERED that Zachary Barker Coughlin is barred and fo rbidden fro m
emailing, delivering, having Jdivered, serving, presenting for tiling, personally or other"i se,
any motion or Jocum!!nt to Reno Municipal Court, in the above-entitled case, penJing fu rt her
(J rJer 0 f this court.
DateJ Ihis 121h Jay of March. 2012.
;r/)tf=t?7'4
rhe 110n, DO,9'thy Nas h
Reno ,\( unicl pal Ili dge
p
--5
STATE BAR OF NEVADA
Februar) 14.2012
Zach Cou*hlin. Esq.
1422 E. 911 Street
Reno. NY 89512
RE: Grievanc\, File #NG12-0:0" / Rich.lrd G. 1Iill
Dear ;Ir. Coughlin:
60 UII Ch;lc.n HI,d.
U. \'... I\ H91DIS6J
-01 \81111U
t l 80.l5 r9-
", -02 '8528-g
9'15(, [),,,,bl. R m,J. ,. 1
Rmo. NV 89521 59-'
r--Ul'-Jl
,,, ^Vusn
u/'I,.mb.lr.or
g
The Olliee of Bar Counsel has received the enclosed corrl!spondcncc from Richard G.
lIill. Esq .. "hieh :lllcgcs professional misconduct 011 )our parI. /\5 such. a grievance file has
bl.'cn opened.
Pkil!l rlspond in \\riling to this grievance within len (10) (b)5 from lhc dale orlhis !.-lIer
and kindly dirert your response 10 the SI:!!(' l3:tr's Reno office. Your response should addn.:ss
each alllgation contained within Mr. Ililrs grievance and. \\hCIH:\Cr possible. all applicable
documentation in support of your response should be im:luded.
If you intend to supplement your response. please indicate an expected date of receipt for
the same in your n:sponsc. If you havc any questions. please clo not hesitate to contact me.
Sinct.rcly.
Patrick O. King
Assistant Bar Counsel
POK/lp
Enclosure
_.i Co Lor!
././r '7 (//
"C/7., o/V
H/(IINJ)I, /flU
,1,,/1 " r" h,I/ ,I/"I!"" 1!Il
( {\fl' J) IHAFR
"IIlt.",, 1/. l"mll,I/,," " ""
'lll) I {;111Hilf'R /,,,,,11,,,./,,,,,
'1,'//"1./0.., ,I'" ;,11,/1"/0'",, ",,
'"FRRI f IfI J L .. ,'/ {"/lI,1'1I
,lull ,I 7t hd"III1f,,, tI0
A IHf\ I \IF/Sf\ {.I"/I",,"ur'
k,".'I",, 1tILh,mll!!I1"" *0
.` f'"rnl \rr../
N,-"" \,-\,,,1,/ 1\;11
/,,,,, (JIf;, t
'
H". - `II
H,',,.,_ \,'\,,,/,/ \\_IUI
\' I. \ E:\ tAl L ON .1 |IItK1 !I\Du
lu\I1t.K IHg, Esq .
. \ssbtllIt u1COllIISl'!
`!u!t. u1 O! .'\\.it.i
Q_ !ouDle V. G.
VCIIO. .t'V.IGu H95:. I
`!I. f.\ing:
Rc: Zal'h;lI'Y B. LO\_!I1,
E(l.
Nevada Hal' No. ')47:1
uHHu !_, :!i)I:.
f1 I_II.,",
J-I ,"JI J.J\Ii.\H
W11% ru h"re/h.II"" OP
YOU uDU I H;1\ Qn." iOUSy UIStISStU ! r, LOugHlII. !I. LOHgH!H, Guttu
HiS HCH!u IH:luDII!\, lu<K O! IHICgII\\, \I\G cOIIIQlCtc inColllpctCIH.:e, con!'titutl's u GuHgtI
\O!H ]HILi! l\c IulO1\ LG 10 l'OHtIHut 10 QIuIlItC |.W. H1S C!\CI ISWII!\CH !O
GI:t`H.\Igt 1\ uHU Illy uS5t1|`Iu\cS IcQolIHyODIgu\IOnS UHGtI Vl\ H._. 'tu:t LI\SIGt'I
!hl' lOO\\iHg:
I, UlSSrm(' L', (,(.ill, ('\' I 0-0 !|qI, .Y!hOH_h HO\ .IIIIOHg !r LOugH! i n's
\IOI S:gHi!1tuHI t.-Ih i.d ^ IOlul ions. i I Q't

'-t'IIb a gOOG III hIOtS1\I O!H1S GCILid iOI1!l, !r

It'5::H \\i5 uIIt'HI O! OHI OUII't. 1t UtIuUUCU !HC QuI\I!. as 1S HI5 /IIUe/IIS opel'ulJ(/i IH
Ut'uIHg WI !H \vOHCH .QQIOXIHu!l'ly OH ' \ CuI.illt1`juGg\11'Hl \uS 'I1!cIcO aud !HC\i:v
cOHtutt

G, :11', CoughlIn IH!cl]'UGHII:\:tIH!HC<:;!se 011 Dt:HuO l\'55IH. !\IHg I

<ollcrt 011 d SuHt!IOH uWurU .IuI11\ O]0J1\g tOUISC !I luI OH! lHu! Dt't.I1:t HC HuU
l1CG hankrupll'Y, (;/, ',,>11l nn lOng']" O\HS !H1SuIII. !-{)\I OOK l! \HI fk', \OU\\I:t '.'
Ih,lt Coughlin .l][t i\1`t'G .IHG Iltl'nlilt'd;t D\Z.i1't: Qu1I.Il \` I!hGruWu dOl'IIIlltllt 011
't't'1I H. 2O'.
OISt!OS\II`t

.
t'!!tI to Patrit'k King, !.*Q.
3HUuI\ J, 2!11.:
Page :
hUDStQIItH! !Othat tImf, LOUgh!iH has heen ghost\\ II!IHg documents that
purport to be frolll It55IH, IHOIVIOUu!!\, uHOt!!!IHg thtllI for It5IH. 1t IS I5IHg the
J5J for Gessin's .igHu!Hl.!. Thcse arc dearly lIot OOCUIItH!5that uIt SigllO O!
]

C]uItOD\ Ir. (;essin, and the 1ut'!that OolllthoOy [\OHgH!IH} t'1I!t'5thl'm confirms he
I5gho')t\\ riting \\it \OU!!Ht IeQUIred 1n aOOi!iOH, I! appears t hat Coughlin
has futI!itatcd IHt liling O!\\hat II\u\ hl' u 1IIIIOII!tH! HuHKIU]!Cj Oil DeHu!f of \t55IH.
Lough!iH!utK of cOlllpelelU.:e is til. 'lIIollstrated ill till' \t5SII C\5t H\!Htfact that Ht
OOt5 HO!UHOtI5!uHO !Ht v1tt on !Ht0\\ ltISHip O1 lt:SIH
1
R1!tII!Iu!dai11I< from
lt55IH huviH_1!!tOa HuHKIU]!tj. eLl.+ the claims now Dt'!OHg to the HuHKIU]!t\ !!U5!tt.
HO!lt5siH.}
As with u!! uf !HtHu!lt1SIt1tIt'HCtOHt!Dv. 1 S!IO:Ig!\ SH@t5!!Hu!\OU
t'OH!ut'! the Second JUOItIu! Oislrit;t Court and get t1!!IJIg utttSS to the tuSL5menlIOH!d
so you tan !OOKat the OOtIIHtH!5\OUISt!I. (;1:1(\(' 1u!!. 5Q. + is OppOsing tOUHSt! IH lHu!
ca( uHOIIIu\Dt O1 Ht!] !O \OU.
:. !H\1IH1O1HtO uHO !It\t !Hu! !I.LOUgH!iH Vu5 ItceHt!\tOHVIt!tOof a
theft CIIHt IH !t'1IO `1UHieIp.t LOUI!. 1 am further infurmed !Hu!IHt malleI' arises O1I!of
5hO]!iftIHg u! Vu!HuII. ThaI Cu5t I5 ]Ie5eHt!y OII u]Qtu! !O !Ht OI5!IIt!tOUI!In case
HUHDtI LV11:()64. !I. LoUgh!iH is n..:precnting himself.
_. `!r. Coughlin is ]Ii': l. ntly IadHg criminal ehaqcs I`tga!OiHg!Ht !HtI! of
uH IOO. Thill I5pt.nding in Reno .US!Itt LOut as l'ase numher VLV.11-Oh__,1. 1
H.|\ t It\ItWtO !Ht file. Ir. CoUgh!iHgot into SOHt SOI!()f;lrlIment with HI5]UD!IC
Ot1t'1uI. Sa I`t5II!t, he was It1L1't'O O11t for ucom pdl. ll:)' tVuIIu I iOIt.
4 \\'t' I`1'pIt 'S tH! I. Iatlhc\\ I{'rliss, a ph .
.
. il.'ian from LHII'O. lI!IO1Iu

lI. `1t!!I5S O\vJIS !Ht propel'l) al I:.!I VI\`er VOtK`!ItC. VtHO. .

t\uOu. tgIHHIHg IH
Iun:h :OIO, Ihl' ]roptIt\ Wu5 !tu5tO !O I`. LOUgh!iH uHO his thcH"giI!f!itHd. The !Uu5t
expired in |tHIUuI\ : mII. The giI!1IieHd !tI! the eommUHi!y in appro\illl:tlI) Iay:w |1.
I. `1tI:cOH!

IttOUSIHappro:\illlatdy .V\:gUS! 2O11 10 u5SIS! IH e\ ntIHg \I.

LOUgH!IH. LOUgh!In HuOHO! uIO ItH! o U!I!I!IU5:IHtt `!I\'. !1t LO1I!tHOtOthat !Ht!t
WtIt huDitubI!It\ISSHc5wilh the property that justified hI5witHHo!OIHg ICH!. .!!of his
daims \\'l'I't t!etidt.d uO\l' 1'''I) to IiI` po-;itIOH at the tVIc!ion HtuII11). .II5!It: O1 the
tuCt Pl'll'r hfl'rM7I OI1tI`O LO|I)hI in l.'\ It`!tO1Iom Ihe pn'lH ISt:- effectI\t :O\cmbel' I.
:Oll. 011 thdt datl', the Wa!ihoc LOI11I!\ `HtII1S lt]uI!HtH! perfOImeO !HtII 1IO!'1H.\
t\It!IOI\ ]IOttOIIIt'. !OCK5WtItthu1Iy1d uHO the e\ ItIOH Hotict \\a. pO`teOOil thl! front
dooI. \\t' \ IO$otapl`d !Ht HOIIIt .IHO I!S t`t1II!t'Hl5.I!!H.I!!HIIt. \]OH I1\5]tt'!IOH OVtI !Ht
lIe:1 ft. '\\' Ou\S, It tiIIHt u]]uICH! !HI! 5O1I\tDOO\\\as HO'uKIHgIHlO!Hthome OII u
It'U!.II H.ISI5.
On >UnOa\. f)\l'ml1t'r IJ, :OII. Ik II55tuHt to lo`\H . uHO 1 met him
.I! !Ht hUIIll.' tH VI\tI VOCK Stred . . h \\l.' \\.I!KtOthrough thl' homt:. it \1;Is OH\HJUSthat
!I'\I\_
_OIH_
I\IH_
t'\!t !O u!IIt IHg, Q.
uHUuI\ q, : Ol:.
lugC
SO\I\'O\Jt' HuU Dti'HIH!Ht.'IC S\II\`t' | HuU uS!DccII IHSCVCIu Uu\S DCOIv. Dr 1CII:-S
UIStOVt'IT!Hu! !HC DuStIIICH!UOOI uS DuIIIt`uUt'U [HO\ OLKCU] !IOH !HCIHSIUt. Ht
C\\O OIt`t |t[uI!IIICH! WuS:H\\\I\IOI1tU HC\!IItU!O1`O\X WHOC\CI uS IH !HC
Du; tUJI'IJ! OU!. I!Hi11! SUttCSS. .!tI !l. 1CIISSHuU!t1 KItK!Ht UOOI UOWH, I! WuS
UISt`OVt'ICU !Hu! !I. LOUgHIH HuUHIOKCH III uHUWuS IH !HCHu5CHtH!. 1t \\.S
uIICS!tU uHU lS QItStH!\ utIHg tIIHIHu !ItSQuSS tHuIgtSIH |CHO \IHItIQu LOH\. See
tuStHO. l\ LV2OqI! !?\. 11C IS uSO!ut\\_ u t'OD\CI\\[\ I\IO!IO1J III !IOIJ! O!UUgC >ltI.\Zu
III !Ht CVu!IOH tu:t .UUgC hCIu.'7u HuSS!u\tU !Hu!Hu!!CI QtHUIHg !HCICSOU!IOH O !Ht
tJIHIHu!IIu. Hu!\IIu WuS S.HtUUtUOIUuHUuJ` 1. :Ol:l, HU! W:IS tOH!IHUtU u! !Ht
ItI

IIt! O! 1I. lOUgHIII

SHCW u!!O1t\.
s. Ht C\It!IOH OIUPI IS HOW OII .IQQCu!O !HC 'ttOHU.UUICIu \S!!\C!
LOUI!. .tt:uSt('\'11(J:6:!8. QCHUIHgIHI)c

x\r!IlICH!7. S uI!1i!!HCCVIt!IOH QIOttSS,

.IICII uS uSSCI\UuguIH:!!HC [tlSOUu QIOQCI!\!Hu!lOUgHIH t!DCHJHUu!!HCHOHt.
lII `OVvII\DtI 16, OI1. lOUgHIHItU u HO!IOH !OtOH!tS\ !HCuHUOIUS \t1I III !Ht VtHO
US!It'C LOUI!. HC'OUI! !IItU !O Q!OHQ!\St! u HCuIIHg, HU! LOUgHIH IuUStU !O
tOOQtIu!t IH:C!!IHg!HCHu!!tl \IJU !HCtOUI! !OOK I! O tuLHUul. \OU[H\H !HPHIt'~
IIII!Iu!t'U !Hu![lOt'C5S uHUuHCuIIHgWuS It

tIH J,'1\\Dtl. ,II \H1 \1Ht \1\ tOUI!HtuIU

t'\ IUCIu'C O! LOUgHI HS d+K OOO[t`!u!IOH iHSt'!!1Hg !Ht .VOCIIIHCI HCuIIHg. 1OU Hu\
uSO uH! \OttJH!.|v! tI\O US!It.t'LOU!! 5!u!!.uI\t! 1II QuI!ItUuI,t`HItCIK uICH >!,I\I\,
uHOU! !I. LOUgHIHSuHUSI\ t lItu\UtH!O! HCI uHUHCI S!u!. !!t'I !HCHt
`
uIIHg, !HCCOUI!
ISSIltUu\ \IGtI gIuH!IHglOUgHIH u !WOUu\ !IHCWIHUOW !O lt\\IO\t HIS QtISOHu
QIOQtI!\. Ht !1!<! Uu\WuSHUl511J\, !tL!HDtl .?.?, 2O \ \ !lCI LODgHIH WuS uOWtU
IH!O!HCHOHC!Hu! HIS!Uu\,HCtI\! O1\! uHtHuI !O!HC ttt!!Hu! DttuUSCHCHuU
uQQCuCUUUgC>CIuZuS OIUtI, HC vuSCH!I!tU!Ou S!u\O!QIOi!CCUIHgSuHU WuS
!OItSUIIIt IH !Ht Hi1II\t. .YSuItSU!. HC UJUVt!\ \\t !OItHUVt uH\O!HIS QC)SOJIu
QIOQCIl\ !Hu!Uu\. lII IIUu\.C(.'c)\\DCl 2j ' .u\\ u!tI Ht tuJCU, uguIH, !Hu!HIS S!u\
HuU ttI\ UCHICU. LOUgHIH u 5CHDtU u SHu t`ItW uHU\It '\ WtIt uDC !O |t':IIOVt u
5|JDS!.IH!Iu|11\t1IIH! O HI QCISOHuQ!OQtI\\. lAO\I \\t:tG !O

UHUCIS!uHU!Hu! 1I.
lOUgHIH IS u HOuIUt1. \Yt HuVC lHt QHO!O:-uHO \ IUI'OS I! \OU WOIIU IKC ! StC!Ht\\\.]
!1OWt\t'I. !I. lOugH\I\ UIU IIO!gt!u O!HISQIOQC1!)OU!. !Ol CXuHQC, .OIIII!tU lj1`il
Stu!S\Hi\ Ht HuU :OHCHOW HuHugtU (0 gt!OH IH!O!HCHuSCHtJ\!.
11.:\ IHg !uItU !OICHOV Cu O! HIS DCOII|{IHgS, !I. ltgHIH!HtII |IIOVt'U
HIOIt

.|!UgC uHuguH !OI iI !t\IJ QO!uI\ItS! IuI \\IH[ OIUtI !O [lt\`t'1J!IHC UIS[|15uI O! H IS
JDuIItIJI\tO PI'O
I
)I\\IH uCCOlU.\\It'v I!I,IUUgt >!tI.\/.\5 OIUCI. .\!!.\`ICU IS :1I.
LOUgHIII
`
SHO!IOH, \II\ O!!1it OQQOSI|IOH. uHU 1I. lOUgH I\\S It'Q\. HtSt' tJOCU|I\tII\
UtHOHS!Iu!C 1I. IOUgHIHS IOIII[t'\t' .\\u1\I!lt'` IIILOHQt!C!ItC uSIH u!!O!t\.
\\ .\!\\Iu1 \+, :Ol:, JUUgC 1HuguH Ut'HIt

U I. lOugHIHS!'t'QUt'l OI ,I
\t'!J1[OI I'S!:`uIII\IIg Oti'I`. lU.II\J!II\ I.! .!!I1, !HCtOH!Iut`!OI HIIL'U !Otlt'.l1J !Hc
HOI\`l 1`O\II1IIt'1\tt'O III`K. !I`

LOUgHIH !1uggtU !HC tOH!IutO1 UOWII IH !Iu!!1C HCH Ht'

[!IttOJI!Iut!OJ} .I:OII HI .\\ !O!Hv UUHQ IlH !HC uDuHUOHtU QIOQLI!\!IOH !Ht
HOI:It' ('O\igH!II\ l.\iCU!1' QOItP, WHO uI!IVt'U u! !Hc!IuH!tI S!u\IO!I. LOUgHIH \ uS
lI:t:Vu5St'I!IUg !H.I! !It' tOH!Iut!OIHuU!IItU!OIUHHIHInl. 1t JSO!OU!Ht[O!\tL '
I`L t. '
.t!!tI t u!IItK !IH_, SQ.
uHUuI\ 14. 201:
u_t 4
!Hu!!HC tOD!IutOI HuO S!OltD HISQOSStSSIOHS. .!tJ | QItStH!tO!Ht tOHJ! OIOtIS IO !Ht
QOlItP, !Ht tOH!IuI'!OI'WuS.:|O\-Ct1 t QIOtttO .! !HtIIIHS!I\IiIOH,
I
H.\CDOW HuOu|\
I:-SH|`O.IguIHS!LOH}{HlIH D\ ltJIOJH5!ILCLOUJ!.
|JOWt\c:I,DtOIt!Htt'OD!Iut!OCt1\IlOC!Dut`K t !Ht lIVtI lOt K HOUSt,
LOH_HlDWuS!HtIt. J t HuOHIS\IOtOtuHtIu uHO\\uSWulKIHgH[uHOOOWHIHP S!Irt!
St1tuJIIIHg uHO yt!lID_ u!!HC QOlIt`t, u!!HCI`OH!1uiOI, uHO u!Hc, WHtHJ uIII\tO. !I
LOH_HlIHtDOtOUQDtIH_ .\JJt::!tO uHO!uKtH !O]uI. Ht QOltC IHOIHCOHC !Hu!
Ht 't`uHSt O !HC HUHDPI and !\QtSO tOH!uiS!H6yH.\\t HuO V!HHIH, HCIS \1O lOH_tI
dI_IDlc OIt`IIu 1IOHS IH !HC t'Vt!l 1 OIH IuCOHS.
HtlOSt`O\+JII \\ Ill HHO u tOQ)O u 5UQ[ltHPH!ul OOtHHtH! 1ltODy )11'.
OU_HlIHO11 uD\\J' 1:. :012, uHO StH! !O H\S!uuHO D\CH\Il 1O1\I LOH_HlH 1Hu!
I\\O!IH_. ltu:t HO!t IHu! !Ht u!!G:t) OtSI_Hu!IOH O1I!Ht 1JS! Qu_t IHOItu!tS !Hu! I! IS
DtIH_ HltO D\ lOU_HlID uS QQtlluH!. `OU WIll HO!C !Hu! IHt tuQ!IOJI S IOH u OCICJI!
tuSc. !ISIIlldcilr IJ\ WHItHt`uS6 )11'. LOJgHlIH IH!tHOtO !O lt IHISOOtHHtH!. ul!HOH_H,
Dtt`iJ\ISCO!Ht t\St IJJHDt'I uHO!Ht tuQ!IOH. I! uQQtuIS!OHu\t Ul!:Hu!tl\ DtCH IOU!IO !U
!Ht LuIQtH!ICI CdSt (C\'uOI709) uHOHO! !HP CVIt!IOH uQ[tul tuSC (CVIIo:628). uH
!OlO!Hu!I't1HI\S t! D!H6tu[!IOHPO tuScI:\u\ ulSO Dt IH !Ht QIOc`C55 O 11lIH_u DuJ
tOuQluID! "WIIHS\ LOH_l:H.
n. \\'hl'll !Ht HO\SCWuS SPt'UItO uItI LOU_HlH
'
S uIICS!, \\'t OUHO u tIutK
QI[t uJ\tJ u Du_ O WHu! uQ]tuIPO t Ht HuIIJUuHu. Htc'O\I!Iut` !O1ulSO ItQOI!tO lIHOIJ\g u
DOX O QIllSuHOu \IulOSOHtSOI!. Vt HDOtIS!uHOLOU_HlIH HuS HDS\!tt6SS\Jll\ !IItO
!!\t' ..vt `IS LOHtt:tO YI .\!\\tIS QIO_ImH. uHO!H:!HC HuSu HI!O1OSHDS!uDCP
Q1OD'HI.
.
. )!1'. LOU_HlIH HuS lIltO !\\Olu\\`SUI!S u_uD:-! HIS OI'IlltI tI\!QlOy tJ,
!\u:HOt' ..'_ul>tI\IttS. 1t' HuS\JtOull O!HCHOu1O O UIItt'!OJ`S uHO!HCHuHu_tHtH! O
IIIt'l.'Olllpany. |OIH tuStS H.1\t HOW HttH OISIlIISSt'. !O!H tu5tS OtHODS!Iu!t HIS lutK O
t`OQt'1t.J\t`C. SU__tS!\O\\1I\\ut!tISLQHIuIID. -Q, II\ luS C_.\S. .I5 Ht WuS tO1!:IStl
OJ!Ht' Ot1tHOuHIS IH!Hu!\Sv. AOH Hu\WuHI !OtOD!uC uUl ltuHO, !.Q,. !HCOI1tt!OI
O \\uSHUt'J.t'_.i I >t:`\tt'S.
K. `!I LO\gHlIH Hu5 uHuHI!O IH!Iu!D_ tuStS uDOu<KID_ !OQJcCCtl ill
-'orllll/ })(I1II)('l'i:. Jlu Hu5 OtJIt':O IHtuStS u_uIH5! :11t`. Hy`O11tC, Hy` tItH\, uHO \uSlt'
.t'_ul `tII 'CS. `OUWll IDO !HcI1\ I \OH IHDu StuItH OI LOH_HlIHZ U11 !Ht `ttODO
UI!t.ul !I::1IIt! LOHI!\\!'DSI!c. HPCOHI!S!Hu!Hi|t ICvItWPO!HCOOtUHtH!5Hu\P
_t':It''ull\t!t'HItOHIS l`tQ\It``IS. VHu!ISO HO!CS!H.I!HISIt[ItStJI!u!IO:IS IH!Ht
tQQlItuIIOtiS !OQJOt't'O i /I );"'/I/a 1)(1II11C't'is u IJIt.OIISIS!cI\! \\!It uHO tOD!IuIV !O I!It'
I'QIt ''tJ\!uIIOH:i!H\I ll|' lIu: HuOt!OHO_t ' !Du_uH I!\!Ht tHI\t'S!O St'tKIH .t
!t'HQO`uJ\ It`.tr<linin OIhI IH l!It' Oh HuHO. Ht!tlS !!ItI'O\\\`I Ht IHJOKt uHOHuSJ\i!
QIO]tJ`!\. lIId OHIlt' O!HtIHuHO. HtIS!tlIJIg!Ht I`OJI!!Hu! Ht HuS u _\t'\! Otu O
\.:Dlt [IDQCJ!\ .\! lHt OHt !Hu! I\ttOS !O Dt ' QIO!tt!t'O. HISOt:IIOH!Iu!CS u _IDS:-
P`KOt.HOOI\\I!H !It' IIHUD.HS W!H\\HItI Ht Utu
all\lhing
l.ettl'r tt) Patl irk King. I :"-'q .
.
January 14. :.Ol:.
Page .
9. COllh1in has also tried to file a casc against me. my asol'iate. my dient.
.lIld others, including the Reno .]u!licc Court. It is I1lso to he found Oil tht \\'L'bsite .
.JudgL' Stclnheimcr has ruled that he did not comply with RCP 8.
1. Coughlin's hch:1\ ior was unusual to !)tart, and has become more and
more hi ?+l"J"e during thL' lime we havL' hL'en dealing with him. lie scl'\cs p:'pcrs hc dOl'!
not filt'. ;lnd lites papers he ducs nol SCI"\"C. Ill' I.:onsistenlly SigiiS l'.'rtifiealcs of service
that he has mailed tu u!. but we have received from him by mail. Ill. has
posted videos of Ihe evil:! ion service attempts and parts of the trial on YouTuhe.
including some rel.onlings he secrdly made ill court with his ccllphnne.
II. Another example of his incompetence is that he does nol understand
whal orders arc. :l.ld arc 11OI. apPf'alahle. ! Ie does not understand Ih:lt filing a notice of
appeal di\e!ts the 10\\' e!" court of jurbdil:!iotl.
I am confident Ihat once you look into this matter, )OU \\ill ':gn.c that ,11'
Coughlin !)hould nOI he pral'licing Ia\\. Ill is a danger t the comlllllllity.
RGII:kn
Enclosures:
Sillcel"ely.
lSI
Richard G. Iii!!
-Coughlin .\lIlcllllcd Emergency .Iolion for Restraining Order
-:lcrliss Oppositiull to .Iolion forTRO
-Coughlin Reply ttl Opposition to .lotioll fOl" TRO
Supplemental Reply tu Opposition dated l/q/12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Document Code:
Zach Coughlin,Esq.
NV Bar No: 9473
4!! E. 9th "t. #!
$eno, NV %9&!
'ele: 77&(33%(%%
)a*: 949(++7(74,!
-ttorne. /or 0ro "e -ttorne. 1itigant
23"'4CE C53$' $EN5 '56N"740
6-"75E C53N'8, NEV-D-
0-$9 'E$$-CE '56N75:E" -""N
; 6E"'E$N NEV-D- :-N-<:EN',
4NC., <a.le -gnes 9ern, Esq. and <a.le -.
9ern. 1td.; 1-ND15$D 5$ D318
-3'75$4ZED -<EN';
1andlord,
=s.
Z-C7-$8 B-$9E$ C53<714N;
'enant.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
C-"E N5:
DE0'. N5:
?23D<E ")E$$-ZZ- 4ND4C-'ED the.
6531D N5' -CCE0' '74" C-"E )5$
74" C-1END-$ 5$ 5'7E$64"E 7E-$
-N8'74N< 4N $E1-'45N '5 4'>
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
'EN-N'@" -N"6E$ -ND 'EN-N'@"
-))4D-V4'ADEC1-$-'45N '5 3, D-8
N5'4CE '5 B34'; :5'45N )5$
"-NC'45N" -ND -''5$NE8@" )EE"
'EN-N'@" -N"6E$ -ND 'EN-N'@" -))4D-V4'ADEC1-$-'45N '5 3, D-8 N5'4CE '5
B34'; :5'45N )5$ "-NC'45N" -ND -''5$NE8@" )EE"
054N'" -ND -3'75$4'4E"
'enantADe/endant, Zach Coughlin, Esq., hereC. /iles an -nsDer, or alternati=el., an
-mended 'enant@s -nsDer to the 3, da. N5'4CE '5 B34' -ND -N8 "3B"EB3EN' & D-8
N5'4CE '5 B34' 3N1-6)31 DE'-4NE$ N5'4CE,
'enant /urther mo=es /or sanctions against landlord, Eursuant to N$" 7.,%&, /or the attorne.s@ /ees
tenant has needlessl.
( (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
note: this was file stamped
2/27/12 by the RJC in
RJC REV2012-000374
disposed of by RJC Judge
Schroeder, on 3/15/12 on a default
basis where Coughlin was 8 minutes
late to the stacked docket hearing
coughlin, pursuant to wcso police was cuffed
and evicted at gunpoint
3 hours later.
also, Judge Schroeder listed on docket in
rcr2012-065630 as presiding over 2/27/12 "conference"
or hearin
~
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
incurred due to 0arF 'errace and E' -1@s recFless uses o/ this court@s Erocesses. 0arF 'errace has not
comElied Dith the requirements o/ the rules o/ ci=il Erocedure the. seeFs to in=oFe. 7is
motion is /atall. /laDed and in/irm as a matter o/ laD.
'his oEEosition and motion is Cased on the Eoints and authorities CeloD, the
aCo=e(re/erenced statute and rules o/ ci=il Erocedure, and all EaEers and Eleadings on /ile
herein.
NRS 40.310 Issue of fact to be tried b !ur if "ro"er de#a$d #ade. %&e$e'er a$ issue of fact
is "rese$ted b t&e "(eadi$)s* it s&a(( be tried b a !ur* if "ro"er de#a$d is #ade "ursua$t to
t&e Ne'ada Ru(es of +i'i( ,rocedure or t&e Justice +ourt Ru(es of +i'i( ,rocedure.
C5:E" N56, the undersigned 'enant and states:
. 4 am the tenant o/ a rental united located at 4!! E. 9th "t. #!, $eno %9&!.
!. m. rent is not suCsidiGed C. EuClic housing authorit. or other go=ernmental agenc..
<laGier =. 2ustice Court o/ "mith Valle. 'E., Ne=. %+4, %99 0.!d ,& ?Ne=. 2ul !7, 99&>:
H"ummar. e=iction statute alloDing landlord to aEEl. to Iustice@s court /or e=iction
order Cased on de/ault in Ea.ment o/ rent did not aEEl. to unlaD/ul detainer action
against tenant Dho ne=er Eaid an. rent nor Das required to Ea. an. and, thus,
summar. e=iction order Das outside Iurisdiction o/ Iustice@s court. N.$.". 4,.!&3..5n
:arch , 993, $ichard )ulstone, Eresident o/ )ulstone, ser=ed <laGier Dith a thirt.(
da. notice to quit the EroEert.. <laGier /ailed to =acate the Eremises,and on -Eril !,
993, )ulstone ser=ed <laGier Dith a /i=e(da. notice. 'his notice e*Eressl.
threatened an action in Iustice@s court /or e=iction, Eursuant to N$" 4,.!&3,)N the
summar. e=iction statute. )N. N$" 4,.!&3 alloDs a landlord to aEEl. to the Iustice@s
court /or an e=iction order Cased on de/ault in Ea.ment o/ rent. 4/ the tenant can
shoD, C. a//ida=it, a legal de/ense to the alleged unlaD/ul detainer, /urther
Eroceedings must Ce conducted Eursuant to the more /ormal e=iction Erocedures in
N$" 4,.!9, to 4,.4!,. 4/, on the other hand, the tenant /ails to shoD a legal de/ense
to the alleged unlaD/ul detainer, then the Iustice@s court ma. issue a summar. order
/or remo=al o/ the tenant. 'he Iustice@s court held a hearing Eursuant to the Ero=isions
o/ N$" 4,.!&3 and ordered that <laGier =acate the EroEert. Dithin thirt. da.s.
( ! (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
<laGier then /iled a Eetition /or a Drit o/ certiorari Ce/ore the district court, alleging
that the Iustice@s court e*ceeded its Iurisdiction under the Jsummar.K e=iction
Ero=isions o/ the statute C., inter alia, inquiring into matters Ce.ond the truth/ulness
and su//icienc. o/ the a//ida=its, and /ailing to dismiss the Jsummar.K e=iction
Eroceeding once a legal de/ense had Ceen raised. 'he district court held a hearing on
the Drit Eetition and denied the Eetition. 5n aEEeal to this court, <laGier argues that,
Eursuant to N$" 4,.!&3, once he raised the legal de/ense that he Das a li/e tenant
under the grant o/ a li/e estate, the Iustice@s court Das oCligated to dismiss the
Jsummar.K Eroceeding and to require that the landlord Erosecute his unlaD/ul
detainer action under the JElenar.K e=iction Eroceedings Ero=ided /or in N$" 4,.!9,
to 4,.4!,. LL,+ -lthough <laGier@s argument is logicall. sound, it is simEl.
irrele=ant. 4t is clear that, desEite all the Eroceedings CeloD and the arguments o/ the
Earties Ce/ore this court, N$" 4,.!&3 does not aEEl. to this case. 'he statute is
aEElicaCle JDhen the tenant o/ an. dDelling M N Dith Eeriodic rent reser=ed C. the
month or an. shorter Eeriod, is in de/ault in Ea.ment o/ the rent.K ?EmEhasis L%++
added.> -ll Earties to this action concede that <laGier ne=er Eaid an. rent, nor Das he
required to Ea. an.. 4t ma. Ce that )ulstone is entitled to ha=e <laGier remo=ed /rom
the EroEert., Cut not Eursuant to N$" 4,.!&3. 'here Das no case or contro=ers.
Ce/ore the Iustice@s court Cased on N$" 4,.!&3, and accordingl., the Iustice@s court
e*ceeded its Iurisdiction C. issuing the summar. e=iction order. -ccordingl., De
re=erse the Iudgment o/ the district court and remand to the district court Dith
directions to grant the Drit. )urther, De order that the e=iction order entered C. the
Iustice@s court Ce =acated. Ne=.,99&. <laGier =. 2ustice Court o/ "mith Valle. 'E.
Ne=. %+4, %99 0.!d ,&, "ee, also, Ne=.,99+. 1iEEis =. 0eters ! Ne=. ,,%,
9! 0.!d !4%H
N$" 4,.!&3 3nlaD/ul detainer: "uEElemental remed. o/ summar. e=iction and e*clusion o/ tenant
/or de/ault in Ea.ment o/ rent. . E*ceEt as otherDise Ero=ided in suCsection ,, in addition to the
remed. Ero=ided in N$" 4,.!&! and 4,.!9, to 4,.4!,, inclusi=e, Dhen the tenant o/ an. dDelling,
aEartment, moCile home, recreational =ehicle or commercial Eremises Dith Eeriodic rent reser=ed C.
the month or an. shorter Eeriod is in de/ault in Ea.ment o/ the rent, the landlord or the landlordOs
agent, unless otherDise agreed in Driting, ma. ser=e or ha=e ser=ed a notice in Driting, requiring in
the alternati=e the Ea.ment o/ the rent or the surrender o/ the Eremises: ?a> -t or Ce/ore noon o/ the
/i/th /ull da. /olloDing the da. o/ ser=ice; or ?C> 4/ the landlord chooses not to Eroceed in the manner
set /orth in EaragraEh ?a> and the rent is reser=ed C. a Eeriod o/ DeeF or less and the tenanc. has
not continued /or more than 4& da.s, at or Ce/ore noon o/ the /ourth /ull da. /olloDing the da. o/
( 3 (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4 ha=e not recei=ed a notice /rom the landlord telling me to lea=e the Eremises. the. can talF aCout
Dhat the. told H2ohn DoeH to do, Cut...-itFen requires the. change an. H2ohn DoeH notices to re/lect
m. actual name one the. Dere aEErised o/ it. 'he Dere as earl. as 2anuar. &th, !, according to
"ue 9ing, .et the. /ailed to ser=e aEEroEriate notice.. 4/ 4 ha=e e=er oDed the landlord an. rent, 4
ha=e Eaid it all or ha=e Eaid it Dithin the time required C. laD.
-ssociation@s negligence =is a =is 1aura and Chris@s negligent andintentional torts committed against
me, Dhich ha=e resulted in thousands o/ dollars o/ damages. 0lease coE. me on an. and all
corresEondence =ia /a* or email as the landlords and or their argents ha=e Ceen or areDithholding m.
mail or otherDise inter/erring Dith m. acces to it, and the. ha=e also done Dith resEect to the
essential ser=ice o/ electricit... -ssociation@s negligence =is a =is 1aura and Chris@s negligent
andintentional torts committed against me, Dhich ha=e resulted in thousands o/ dollars o/ damages.
0lease coE. me on an. and all corresEondence =ia /a* or email as the landlords and or their argents
ha=e Ceen or areDithholding m. mail or otherDise inter/erring Dith m. acces to it, and the. ha=e also
d 6ritten comElaint to 0'75-@a emElo.ees or agents, causing 0'75- to retaliate against Coughlin
Das Ero=ide on 2anuar. %, !,! in tDo seEarate Dritings, Dhich alleged: H0ursuant to N$" %- and
N$" 4,, 4 am hereC. comElaining in Driting o/ .ours and 1aura 7arrison@s =iolation o/ the /olloDing
criminal laDs: - /elon. con=iction /or malicious destruction o/ Eri=ate EroEert. under N$" !,+.3,
and 93.&& must Ce C4V41 14-B414'8 )5$ 15"" 5$ D-:-<E '5 0$50E$'8 N$" !,&.9%,
Determination o/ =alue o/ loss /rom crime; notice to =ictim; order o/ restitution deemed Iudgment to
collect damages. C7-0'E$ !,+ ( :-14C453" :4"C74E) N$" !,+.,,& J<ra//itiK de/ined. N$"
!,+.,, Destruction or damage o/ EroEert. C. unlaD/ul assemCl.. N$" !,+.,& Destruction or
damage o/ croEs, gardens, trees or shruCs. N$" !,+.,4, Entering EroEert. Dith intention to damage
or destro. EroEert.. N$" !,+.!& Damage o/ EroEert. used /or EurEose o/ religion, /or Curial or
( 9 (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4,.!&3 maFes inaEElicaCle a summar. e=iction Erocedure under those circumstances, rather, a
Elenar. Erocedure is required. $egardless, a EroEer Iur. trial demand is hereC. made.
'here is EerhaEs another Eerson against Dhom this action should Ce Crought, namel. Erin -llaCacF
and 1aure )orshee.
4 ha=e not Ceen EroEerl. named in the notices. $ather, the Notice EurEortedl. Eosed on 2anuar.
,th, !,! onl. names a H2ohn DoeH desEite m. numerous Dritings to 6estern Ne=ada Dherein m.
name Das madse clear. 'he -itFen case maFes clear that the Erocedural and notice requirements o/
summar. e=iction matters must Ce stricl. adhered to, as such this H2ohn DoeH notice is ine//ecti=e.
4 ha=e other de/enses as /olloDs: retaliation, discrimination, lacF o/ allegation o/ nonEa.ment o/ rent,
75- admitted tenants Dere not oCligated to Ea. rent, as such, under <laGier, summar. e=iction
Erocedures una=ailaCle. 4:05$'-N': 4n some cases, the Court has the EoDer to gi=e .ou time to
/ind a neD Elace to li=e e=en i/ .ou do not ha=e an. o/ the listed de/enses. 4/ .ou Dish the Court to
determine Dhether .ou are entitled to it, Elease checF CeloD:
4 ha=e Ero=ided Dritten request to landlord /or an e*tension o/ 3, da.s in light o/ m. disaCilit..
4 am Driting to request the 3, da.s e*tension Cased uEon disaCilit.. 4 am in=oFing m. 740-- and other Eri=ac. rights
Dith resEect to di=ulging an.thign /urther aCout m. disaCilit..
C53N'E$C1-4:
4/ .ou Celie=e that .ou are entitled to a return o/ Eart o/ .our rent Ea.ment or other damages /rom the
landlord, comElete the statement CeloD: 4 here C. counterclaim in e*cess o/ R,,,,, in damages. 4
/eel that 4 am entitled to this amount /or the /olloDing reasons: damages to m.sel/, m. clients, and
m. Eractice in light o/ landlord@s and landlord@s agents actions. 1aura and Chris Ceing the
-ssociations emElo.ees and there/ore .ou gu.s or them Danted to settle Dith
me on account o/ a resEondeat suEerior theor. o/ liaCilit. maFing .our
( !+ (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
e*Eosure signi/icant enough to Iusti/. doing so. -ssociation@s negligence =is a =is 1aura and Chris@s negligent
andintentional torts committed against me, Dhich ha=e resulted in thousands o/ dollars o/ damages. 0lease coE. me on
an. and all corresEondence =ia /a* or
email as the landlords and or their argents ha=e Ceen or areDithholding m. mail or otherDise inter/erring Dith m. acces
to it, and the. ha=e also done Dith resEect to the essential ser=ice o/ electricit..
,-INTS AND AUT.-RITIES
)-C'"
N$" %-.&, $etaliator. conduct C. landlord against tenant ErohiCited; remedies; e*ceEtions.
. E*ceEt as otherDise Ero=ided in suCsection 3, the landlord ma. not, in retaliation, terminate a
tenanc., re/use to reneD a tenanc., increase rent or decrease essential ser=ices required C. the rental
agreement or this chaEter, or Cring or threaten to Cring an action /or Eossession i/:
?a> 'he tenant has comElained in good /aith o/ a =iolation o/ a Cuilding, housing or health code
aEElicaCle to the Eremises and a//ecting health or sa/et. to a go=ernmental agenc. charged Dith the
resEonsiCilit. /or the en/orcement o/ that code;
?C> 'he tenant has comElained in good /aith to the landlord or a laD en/orcement agenc. o/ a
=iolation o/ this chaEter or o/ a sEeci/ic statute that imEoses a criminal Eenalt.;
?c> 'he tenant has organiGed or Cecome a memCer o/ a tenantOs union or similar organiGation;
?d> - citation has Ceen issued resulting /rom a comElaint descriCed in EaragraEh ?a>;
?e> 'he tenant has instituted or de/ended against a Iudicial or administrati=e Eroceeding or
arCitration in Dhich the tenant raised an issue o/ comEliance Dith the requirements o/ this chaEter
resEecting the haCitaCilit. o/ dDelling units;
?/> 'he tenant has /ailed or re/used to gi=e Dritten consent to a regulation adoEted C. the landlord,
a/ter the tenant enters into the rental agreement, Dhich requires the landlord to Dait until the
aEEroEriate time has elaEsed Ce/ore it is en/orceaCle against the tenant; or
?g> 'he tenant has comElained in good /aith to the landlord, a go=ernment agenc., an attorne., a
/air housing agenc. or an. other aEEroEriate Cod. o/ a =iolation o/ N$" %.,, to %.!,,
inclusi=e, or the )air 7ousing -ct o/ 9+%, 4! 3.".C. QQ 3+, et seq., or has otherDise e*ercised
rights Dhich are guaranteed or Erotected under those laDs.
!. 4/ the landlord =iolates an. Ero=ision o/ suCsection , the tenant is entitled to the remedies
Ero=ided in N$" %-.39, and has a de/ense in an. retaliator. action C. the landlord /or Eossession.
3. - landlord Dho acts under the circumstances descriCed in suCsection does not =iolate that
suCsection i/:
?a> 'he =iolation o/ the aEElicaCle Cuilding, housing or health code o/ Dhich the tenant
comElained Das caused Erimaril. C. the lacF o/ reasonaCle care C. the tenant, a memCer o/ his or her
household or other Eerson on the Eremises Dith his or her consent;
?C> 'he tenanc. is terminated Dith cause;
?c> - citation has Ceen issued and comEliance Dith the aEElicaCle Cuilding, housing or health
code requires alteration, remodeling or demolition and cannot Ce accomElished unless the tenantOs
dDelling unit is =acant; or
?d> 'he increase in rent aEElies in a uni/orm manner to all tenants.
'he maintenance o/ an action under this suCsection does not Ere=ent the tenant /rom seeFing damages
or inIuncti=e relie/ /or the landlordOs /ailure to comEl. Dith the rental agreement or maintain the
dDelling unit in a haCitaCle condition as required C. this chaEter.
( !7 (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1ost Ero/its, lost goods, such as /ood, and the Cene/its o/ lost ser=ices, such as ad=ertising, are
e*amEles o/ losses that ma. constitute Hactual damagesH /or illegal e=iction. 4 :.$.".-. Q +,4?!>
?->. Degenhardt =. EDe 1td. 0artnershiE, !, :E !3, 3 -.3d 79, ?:e. !,>. Being an attorne. is
hard enough Dithout dealing Dith all o/ 0arF 'errace@s mal/easance. 0erhaEs i/ E' -1 e=er gathers
uE the gumEtion to hang out his oDn shingle the. Dill more /ull. aEEreciate that.
ANALYSIS
'enant@s reco=er. o/ damages /or emotional distress under 3ni/orm $esidential 1andlord and 'enant
-ct, + -.1.$.4th &!%; $ight o/ landlord legall. entitled to Eossession to disEossess tenant Dithout
legal Erocess, + -.1.$.3d 77; $eco=er. C. tenant o/ damages /or Eh.sical inIur. or mental anguish
occasioned C. Drong/ul e=iction, 7 -.1.$.!d 93+; & -m. 2ur. 0roo/ o/ )acts 3d 37&, 'enant@s $ights
and $emedies -gainst $etaliator. E=iction C. 1andlord. 99 -m. 2ur. 'rials !%9, $etaliator. E=iction
Claims.
E=idence suEEorted /inding that landlord@s e=iction o/ tenant Das retaliator. /or her comElaints
concerning Eersistent ElumCing EroClems and condition o/ common areas. N.$.".
%-.&,. 0aullin =. "utton, 9%+, 7!4 0.!d 749, ,! Ne=. 4!.
B. Da. o/ analog. to Je=iction millsK /or landlords, consider J)or e*amEle, aCuse o/ CanFruEtc.
Eroceedings C. renters Cecame so DidesEread in the Central District o/ Cali/ornia that JMiNn 99, 2.
Cli//ord 6allace, Chie/ 2udge o/ the Ninth Circuit Court o/ -EEeals, estaClished an -d 7oc
Committee on 3nlaD/ul Detainer and BanFruEtc. :ills to looF into EossiCle solutions to the Eractice
o/ aCusi=e /ilings to Ere=ent e=iction.K 2udge <eraldine :und, 3Edated $eEort o/ 3nlaD/ul Detainer
'asF )orce ?99!>. 'he committee /ound that CanFruEtc. JmillsK are a suCstantial cause o/ the
aCuse: 'he. churn out large numCers o/ Eetitions ?Dhich result in an automatic sta., /orestalling
e=iction>, Cut Eursue no /urther action. Estimates suggest that in the Central District alone, some
( !% (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
!,,,,, to 4,,,,, such Eetitions are /iled e=er. .ear /or the sole EurEose o/ dela.ing the deCtor@s
e=iction. "ee id. at 7. -s those /amiliar Dith CanFruEtc. Eractice are onl. too Eain/ull. aDare, this
t.Ee o/ strategic maniEulation isn@t limited to renters@ Eetitions. "ee generall. :arc. 2.9. 'i//an.,
Crime and BanFruEtc., !4 BanFr.Ct.Dec. ?C$$>, at - ?"eEt. !, 993>.K
Awarding Attorney's Fees to Pro Se Litigants Under Rule 11, 2une, 997, 9& :ich. 1. $e=. !3,%,
2erem. D. "Eector. E' -1 cites no authorit. on this or an. other issue that li=es an.Dhere Ce.ond
/orm motion, temElate time, turn and Curn Eractice o/ laD. 6hile E' -1 did manage to cite the
"eller@s case, the. quotes no language /rom it and seemingl. maFes not attemEt to anal.Ge its ruling.
the. should ha=e. "ellers sEeaFs to aDards o/ attorne.@s /ees to Ere=ailing Earties in ci=il actions. 4t
does not EurEort to sEeaF to attorne.@s /ees aDards stemming /rom $ule =iolation, a situation
Dhere the granting o/ attorne.@s /ees to an attorne. Ero se litigant is /ar more acceEted throughout
-merican IurisErudence. "imEl. Eut, the "eller@s case is inaEElicaCle and E' -1 should stoE citing
cases Dhere the. clearl. has a =er. shalloD grasE o/ Dhat the. sEeaF to.
'o Dit:
Jstates that ha=e considered Dhether an attorne. EroEer Eerson litigant ma. Ce
aDarded attorne. /ees are di=ided, Dith a slight maIorit. Eermitting such /ees.
Decisions aEEro=ing /ee aDards to attorne. EroEer Eerson litigants generall. do so
on the Casis that an attorne. is Eaid /or rendering legal ser=ices, and i/ the. renders
such ser=ices on his oDn Cehal/, it results in as much Eecuniar. loss to him as i/
the. Eaid another attorne. to render the same ser=ices. "o, i/ a losing Eart. must
Ea. attorne. /ees an.Da., it should maFe no di//erence Dhether the /ees are to Ce
Eaid to an attorne. reEresenting himsel/ or another attorne. emElo.ed C. him. 4n
short, Ha laD.er@s time and ad=ice are his stocF in trade.H...6e interEret N$" +9.,3,
( !9 (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
to require that all EroEer Eerson litigants, Dhether attorne. or non(attorne., Ce
oCligated to Ea. attorne. /ees as a Ererequisite /or an aDard o/ Ere=ailing Eart.
attorne. /ees. 'his interEretation gi=es e//ect to the 1egislature@s clear intent that the
Ere=ailing Eart. in Iustice@s court Ce reimCursed C. the losing Eart. /or out(o/(
EocFet costs incurred to Erosecute the suit. 'o interEret the statute otherDise Dould
require us to rede/ine Dhat is meant C. an attorne. /ee, Dhich is commonl.
understood to Ce the sum Eaid or charged /or legal ser=ices. Because :attheDs
reEresented himsel/ and did not Ea. or incur an. oCligation to Ea. attorne. /ees, the
Iustice@s court e*ceeded its Iurisdiction C. aDarding such /ees. 6e there/ore grant,
in Eart, the Eetition /or a Drit o/ certiorari.K "ellers =. )ourth 2udicial Dist. Ct., 9
Ne=. !&+, 7 0 .3d 49& ?!,,3>.
N$" +9.,3, J0re=ailing Eart. alloDed attorne.@s /ee to Ce ta*ed as costs in Iustice court. 'he
Ere=ailing Eart. in an. ci=il action at laD in the Iustice courts o/ this "tate shall recei=e, in addition to
the costs o/ court as noD alloDed C. laD, a reasonaCle attorne. /ee. 'he attorne. /ee shall Ce /i*ed C.
the Iustice and ta*ed as costs against the losing Eart..K "o, E' -1@s Cig contriCution to the legal
research required to rule on this case is to cite "eller@s, Dhich does not sEeaF to Dhether a Ero se
attorne. can recei=e attorne.@s /ees Eursuant to a $ule sanction. 'he statute in=ol=ed does not
aEEl. here, either, Dhere a $ule "anction motion is in Ela.. )urther, e=en i/ it did aEEl., Dhich it
doesn@t, Coughlin did KEa. or incur an. oCligation to Ea. attorne. /eesK as the. has stated in the )act
section that the. Eaid to and incurred such an oCligation to himsel/. 6here :attheDs ma. ha=e not
Ceen e*act enough in his Eleadings, Coughlin has Ceen.
Coughlin has actuall., reasonaCl. and necessaril. incurred R&,,,, in the EreEaration o/ the Eleadings
the. has Eut /orth so /ar in this matter, and in dealing Dith E' -1@s regrettaCle, declasse conduct in
( 3, (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
this matter. E' -1 should Ce sanctioned in that amount, Elus an. /ees incurred in dra/ting a reEl. in
suEEort o/ this motion, and EreEaring /or and attending an. hearing. )urther, Coughlin hereC.
requests a hearing reElete Dith A JURY ?- $4<7' <3-$-N'EE B8 '7E 3N4'ED "'-'E"
"30$E:E C53$' EVEN 4N "3::-$8 EV4C'45N :-''E$", -N '7E$E 4" N5 15N<E$
2C$C0 ,+, "5 4 <E' -N -00E-1 '55T> on this matter to a=oid e=iction. 'here are e=identiar.
issues such as the amount o/ rent deductions agreed to, the amount o/ damages done C. 0arF
'errace@s landscaEing creD, thin sFulled tenant issues, etc.

67E$E)5$E, tenant, Zach Coughlin, Era.s that this Court rule that a summar. e=iction Eroceeding
is una=ailaCle to landlord here and aDard in e*cess o/ R,,,,, damages to 'enantACounterclaimant.
Dec(aratio$ #ade u$der "e$a(t of "er!ur/
I Dec(are* "ursua$t to NRS 03.040 t&at t&e fore)oi$) is true a$d correct a$d #ade u$der
"e$at( of "er!ur
A11IRMATI-N ,ursua$t to NRS 2334.030
'he undersigned does hereC. a//irm that the Ereceding document does not contain
the social securit. numCer o/ an. Eerson.
Dated this: )eCruar. !7th, !,!
UAsA Zach Coughlin
Zach Coughlin
'enantACounterclaimant
( 3 (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
,R--1 -1 SER5I+E
4, Zach Coughlin, declare:
5n )eCruar. !7th, !,!, 4, :r. Zach Coughlin ser=ed the /oregoing 'enant@s -nsDer and
-//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim C. Elacing a true and
correct coE. hereo/ in the usEs mail, emailing, maFing all reasonaCle attemEts at Eersonall. ser=ing,
and /a*ing true coE. thereo/ to:
0arF 'errace 'oDnhomes 75-
cAo <a.le -gnes 9ern, Esq. and <a.le -. 9ern. 1td.
&4! 9ietGFe 1ane "uite !,,
$eno , NV %9&
'el: 77&(3!4(&93,
)a*: 77&(3!4(+73
ga.leFernVFernltd.com
0arF 'errace 'oDnhomes -ssn
cAo 6estern Ne=ada :anagement, 4nc.
$esidential, Commercial W -ssociation :anagement
"ue 9ing
0residentABroFerA"uEer=ising C:
%,4 :ill "treet, $eno, NV %9&,!
0h: 77&(!%4(4434
)a*: 77&(!%4(44+&
sueVDesternn=.com
DDD.Desternn=.com
in/oVDesternn=.com
$eno 2ustice Court, Ci=il Di=ision
". "ierra "t.
$eno, NV %9&,
Ci=il Di=ision )a*
?77&> 3!&(+7&
Dated this: )eCruar. !7th, !,!
(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((
Zach Coughlin, 'enant
( 3! (
'enant@s -nsDer and -//ida=itADeclaration to 3, Da. No Cause E=iction, 'enant@s Counterclaim
From: Zach Coughlin
To: "keithloomis@earthlink.net"
Subject: FW: rmc 11 cr 26405 you are appointed counsel? for puentes ne taitel?
Date: Monday, February 27, 2012 8:00:00 AM
Hi Keith,

Did you attend law school with or work with or work at the same place (though maybe not at
the same time) with anyone working at the RMC or the Reno City Attorneys Office. We
had some conflicts checks problems with Taitel, and RMCR 5 was not followed, STILL.
Hoping to avoid anything further like that.

Thank,s
Keith Lloyd Loomis Company: No information provided Address: 9468 Double R Blvd.
Suite A Reno , NV 89521 Phone Number: 775-853-7222 Fax number: 775-853-0860 Email:
keithloomis@earthlink.net Website: No information provided Admit Date: 12/31/82 Law
School: McGeorge Specialization: None Professional Liability Insurance:

From:
ZACH COUGHLIN, ESQ.
NV BAR NO 8473
1422 E. 9TH ST. #2
RENO, NV 89512
TEL: 775 338 8118
FAX 949 667 7402
ZACHCOUGHLIN@HOTMAIL.COM


From: Zach Coughlin [mailto:zachcoughlin@hotmail.com]
Sent: Monday, February 27, 2012 7:56 AM
To:
Subject: rmc 11 cr 26405 you are appointed counsel? for puentes ne taitel?

hi, i guess Mr. Loomis was appointed as my 3rd defense attorney in RMC case 11 cr 26405. I have
not heard anything about this case, and the RMC indicated they had nothing scheduled. Please
communicate with me only via email or fax please, having issues with my mail incident to domestic
violence committed against me my fax is 949 667 7402. thanks,
Zach Coughlin
1 Case No. 11 CR 26405
2 Dept. No. 2'
3
4
5
6
IN THE MUNICIPAL COURT OF THE CITY OF RENO
COUNTY OF WASHOE, STATE OF NEVADA
* * * * *
7
8 THE CITY OF RNO,
Plaintif,
9
v. ORDER CONTING TRIAL
10 ZACHARY COUGHLIN,
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Defendant.
___________
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING, and there being no objection fom Defense, the Motion to Continue
Trial fled by the City Attorey is granted.
It is so ORDERED.
Dated this 28
T
day of November, 20 II t;
Willidner
Reno Municipal Court
Depatment Two
2
)
1
5
6
.,
B
9
10
11
::
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
l2
2)
2-l
25
26
,
.- t . -"
,. . I i I i )
. ! - ... " '
CODE 2<)60 2Ql2FEB 21 PH I: 31
I THEJUSTICECOLIRTOF RENO roWNSHIP
INAND FOR TilECOUNTY OF WASHOE, STATE01' NEVADA
THESTATEOFNEVADA,
Plaintiff,
vs.
Case No.'(/...C'((. 1L OC:::>':J(;30
15. ):Y)
0. _1-
Dclcndant.
____________________1
ORDERFOR [VALUATIONS
Uponmotionofwunsd lor Dcfendwl! herein nnd good causeappearing thcrcl,m;,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Ddcnd'Ult beexamined by two psychiatrists,
two psychologists, orone psychiatristand one psychologist from Lake's Crossing fo rthe purpose
ufdetermining whetherthe Defeodant has the presentabihtyto:
I . Understand the natureofthe criminal chargesagainsthun;
2. Untkrst,md the nature and purposeofthecoun pruceeull1gs; or
3. Aid and assist hiscuunscl In thedefense"ith areasonabledegreeofratillnal
understailliing.
I;
/,/
1
, "

, , -
1 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED Ih"t th" is lu bdurc
2 Hunorabk E//,?'It uf Ihe SI!cond JuJlcial Dislrict Court. Dcpartmcnt \ 11\
...1'\
J 121Il!12 30 at hour of < '.5ZJ for a competcncy
1
cvaluation
5
DATED \
.20 / ,;)"
6
1
8
JUST ICE OF 'I'll EACE
9
1 0
11
12
13
15
16
11
18
19
20
21
2 2
23
25
26
2
gr
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 Code No. 2145
RICHARD G. HILL, ESQ.
2 State Bar No. 596
CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ.
3 State Bar No. 9504
RICHARD G. HILL, LTD.
4 652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
5 (775) 348-0888
Attorney for Respondent Matt Merliss
6
7
8
9
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
10 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
11
12 v.
Appellant,
Case No.: CVll-03628
Dept. NO.7
13 MATT MERLISS,
14 Respondent.
15
16
17
SECOND MOTION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Plaintiff) MATTHEW MERLISS, through counsel, RICHARD G. HILL, LTD.,
18 and CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ., moves the court pursuant to NRS 22.010(3) for an order
19 requiring appellant, ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN ("COUGHLIN"), to appear and show
20 cause why he should not be held in contempt of this court for unlawfully resisting Merliss'
21 efforts to comply with this court's order of January 11, 2012. This is plaintiffs second
22 motion for order to show cause, and is in addition to the motion plaintiff filed in the Reno
23 Justice Court on November 21, 2011. This motion is based on the points and authorities
24 below and all papers and pleadings on file herein.
25
26
27
POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
ADJUDICATED FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
~ ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ ~ 28
1. Merliss is the owner of the real property located at 121 River Rock Street,
Reno, Nevada (the "PROPERTY").
(77 5) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0856
F I L E D
Electronically
01-20-2012:02:35:37 PM
Joey Orduna Hastings
Clerk of the Court
Transaction # 2711293
gr
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 Code No. 2145
RICHARD G. HILL, ESQ.
2 State Bar No. 596
CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ.
3 State Bar No. 9504
RICHARD G. HILL, LTD.
4 652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
5 (775) 348-0888
Attorney for Respondent Matt Merliss
6
7
8
9
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
10 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
11
12 v.
Appellant,
Case No.: CVll-03628
Dept. NO.7
13 MAT MERLISS,
14 Respondent.
15
16
17
SECOND MOTION FOR ORDER T SHOW CAUSE
Plaintiff) MATHEW MERLISS, through counsel, RICHARD G. HILL, LTD.,
18 and CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ., moves the court pursuant to NRS 22.010(3) for an order
19 requiring appellant, ZACHRY BARER COUGHLIN ("COUGHLIN"), to appear and show
20 cause why he should not be held in contempt of this court for unlawfully resisting Merliss'
21 eforts to comply with this court's order of January 11, 2012. This i plaintifs second
22 motion for order to show cause, and is in addition to the motion plaintif fled in the Reno
23 Justice Court on November 21, 2011. This motion is based on the points and authorities
24 below and all papers and pleadings on file herein.
25
26
27
POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
ADJUDICATED FACTS AND PROCEDUR HISTORY
:a; 28
1. Merliss is the owner of the real property located at 121 River Rock Street,
Reno, Nevada (the "PROPERTY").
(77 5) 348-0888
Fa(775) 348-0856
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
2. OnoraboutMarch1,2010,MerIissrentedthePropertytoCoughlinandhis
then-girlfriend.
3. OnAugust22, 2011, MerlissproperlyandlawfullyterminatedCoughlin's
month-to-monthtenancy pursuantto NRS 40.251, by servingthe statutoryNo-Cause
Termination Notice to Vacate NRS 40.251(1) uponhim.
4. OnSeptember27,2011,MerIissproperlyservedCoughlinwithaFive-Day
Notice of Unlawful Detainer For Failure to Vacate Rental Unit - NRS 40.251 (No-Cause
Termination) and Notice ofSummary Eviction - NRS 40.254.
5. OnOctober27,2011,afteralldueandpropernoticeandopportunitytobe
heardhadbeengiventoCoughlin,thiscourtentereditsFindingsofFact,Conclusionsof
LawandOrderGrantingSummaryEviction. Atrueandcorrectcopyofthereferenced
orderisattachedheretoasEXHIBIT1.

6. EXHIBIT 1wasservedonCoughlinonNovember1, 2011bytheWashoe
CountySheriffsDepartmentinitscustomarymanner,bypostingsameonthefrontdoor
ofthepropertyinthemannercustomaryforevictionsinWashoeCounty. Thelockstothe
premises were changed at that time, thereby ejecting and dispossessing Coughlin of
possessionoftheProperty.
7. Thereafter, Mr. Coughlin unlawfully, and without any right to do so,
reenteredupon,andtookpossessionof,theProperty.
8. Specifically,onNovember13,2011,Mr.Coughlinwasfoundtobelivingin
thebasementoftheProperty. Coughlinwasarrestedandchargedwithtrespassingatthat
time. Amotionfor ordertoshowcauserelatingtoCoughlin'sunlawful reentryonthe
PropertyiscurrentlypendingintheRenoJusticeCourt. Thatreentryisnotthesubjectof
thismotion,but isreferencedheretogivethecourtsomebackgroundoftheeventsleading
uptothismotion.
III
III
2
LW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 2. On or about March 1, 2010, MerIiss rented the Proper to Coughlin and his
2 then-girlfriend.
3 3. On August 22, 2011, Merliss properly and lawlly terminated Coughlin's
4 month-to-month tenancy pursuant to NRS
4
0.251, by serving the statutory No-Cause
5 Termination Notice to Vacate NRS 40.251(1) upon him.
6 4
. On September 27,2011, MerIiss properly served Coughlin with a Fve-Day
7 Notice of Unlawfl Detainer For Failure to Vacate Rental Unit - NRS 40.251 (No-Cause
8 Termination) and Notice of Summary Eviction - NRS 40.254.
9 5. On October 27,2011, afer all due and proper notice and opportunity to be
10 heard had been given to Coughlin, this court entered its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of
11 Law and Order Granting Summary Eviction. A true and correct copy of the referenced
12 order is attached hereto as EXHIBIT 1.
13 FACSSHONGCONTEMPTOFCOURT
14 6. EXHIBIT 1 was served on Coughlin on November 1, 2011 by the Washoe
15 County Sherifs Department in its customary manner, by posting same on the front door
16 of the property in the manner customary for evictions in Washoe County. The locks to the
17 premises were changed at that time, thereby ejecting and dispossessing Coughlin of
18 possession of the Property.
19 7. Thereafer, Mr. Coughlin unlawlly, and without any right to do so,
20 reentered upon, and took possession of, the Property.
21 8. Specifcally, on November 13, 2011, Mr. Coughlin was found to be living in
22 the basement of te Property. Coughlin was arrested and charged with trespassing at that
23 time. A motion for order to show cause relating to Coughlin's unlawl reentry on the
24 Property is currently pending in the Reno Justice Court. That reentry is not the subject of
25 this motion, but is referenced here to give the court some background of the events leading
26 up to this motion.
27
III
Post O ice Box 2551
28
III
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
2
5
10
15
20
25
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
9. On December21, 2011, aftera hearingonCoughlin's motiontocontest
Merliss'personalpropertylien,JudgeSferrazzaoftheRenoJusticeCourtenteredanother
order. Atrueandcorrectcopyof thatcourt'sorderresolvingmotiontocontestpersonal
propertylienisattachedheretoasEXHIBIT2.
.10. AlsoonDecember21,2011,thiscasewassentuptothiscourtonappeal
fromtheRenoJusticeCourt.
11. PursuanttoEXHIBIT2,CoughlinwasprovidedaccesstothePropertyon
Thursday,December22,2011. Thatday,Coughlinsentanemailtotheundersignedand
JudgeSferrazza,inwhichheessentiallyannouncedthathewasentitledtoastay,andto
returntoandcontinueinpossessionoftheProperty. JudgeSferrazzaquicklyresponded
byemail,andremindedMr.Coughlinthatthestayhadbeendenied. Coughlinremoved
verylittle ofhispropertythat day,andclearlyintendedtosimplyre-takepossessionof the
house,untilJudgeSferrazzadisabusedhimofthatnotion.
12. OnFriday,December23,2011,Coughlinhadacrewof helpers,andmade
progress. Nonetheless,Coughlinfailedtoremoveallof hisbelongingsfromtheProperty.
Coughlinfailedtoremovehisthingsdespitehavingbeengivenadditionaltimetodosoafter
17 thetimesetbytheRenoJusticeCourtinitsorderofDecember21,2011(EXHIBIT2)had
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD Q. HILL
~ ~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ : a ~ ~ x 8 ~ ~ 28
(775)348-0888
Fax(775)346-0858
expired.
13. On December 30, 2011, Coughlin moved this Court for a temporary
restraining order to prevent Merliss from disposing ofthe items he (Coughlin) had
abandonedontheProperty. Coughlin'smotionwasfullybriefed,andtheCourtenteredits
orderdenyingthemotiononJanuary11, 2012. AtrueandcorrectcopyofthisCourt's
January11,2012orderisattachedheretoasEXHIBIT3.
14. On Thursday, January 12, 2012, in accordance with EXHIBIT 2 and
EXHIBIT3, alicensedcontractorhiredbyMerlissbegancleaningupthePropertyand
disposingof theabandoneditemsstillremainingthere.
III
III
3
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD Q. HILL
1 9. On December 21, 2011, after a hearing on Coughlin's motion to contest
2 Merliss' personal property lien, Judge Sferrazza of the Reno Justice Court entered another
3 order. A true and correct copy of that court's order resolving motion to contest personal
4 property lien is attached hereto as EXHIBIT 2.
5 . 10. Also on December 21, 2011, this case was sent up to this court on appeal
6 from the Reno Justice Court.
7 11. Pursuant to EXHIBIT 2, Coughlin was provided access to the Property on
8 Thursday, December 22, 2011. That day, Coughlin sent an email to the undersigned and
9 Judge Sferrazza, in which he essentially announced that he was entitled to a stay, and to
10 return to and continue in possession of the Property. Judge Sferrazza quickly responded
11 by email, and reminded Mr. Coughlin that the stay had been denied. Coughlin removed
12 ver litle of his property that day, and clearly intended to simply re-take possession of the
13 house, until Judge Sferrazza disabused him of that notion.
14 12. On Friday, December 23, 2011, Coughlin had a crew of helpers, and made
15 progress. Nonetheless, Coughlin failed to remove all of his belongings fom the Property.
16 Coughlin failed to remove his things despite having been given additional time to do so afer
17 the time set by the Reno Justice Court in its order of December 21, 2011 (EXHIBIT 2) had
18 expired.
19 13. On December 30, 2011, Coughlin moved this Court for a temporary
20 restraining order to prevent Merliss from disposing of the items he (Coughlin) had
21 abandoned on the Property. Coughlin's motion was flly briefed, and the Court entered its
22 order denying the motion on January 11, 2012. A true and correct copy of this Court's
23 January 11,2012 order is attached hereto as EXHIBIT 3.
24
25
26
27
14. On Thursday, January 12, 2012, in accordance with EXHIBIT 2 and
EXHIBIT 3, a licensed contractor hired by Merliss began cleaning up the Property and
disposing of the abandoned items still remaining there.
o:a
x
866 28
III
III
(775) 348-0888
Fa
x
(775) 346-0858
3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
.
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G, HILL
PostOfficeBox2551
Reno, Nevada89505
(775)34S-0888
Fax(775)3480858
15. Earlythatafternoon,whilethecontractorwashaulingthefirstofseveral
loadsof abandonedpropertytothetransferstation(dump)fordisposal,Coughlinstopped
thecontractorintrafficandattemptedtopreventhimfromcarryingouthistask.
16. Specifically,Coughlinstoodinfrontofthecontractor'svehicleinaneffort
topreventhimfrom proceedingtothetransferstation. Coughlinthreatenedtosuethe
contractor. Coughlin climbeduponthecontractor'svehicle. Coughlinthencalledthe
policeandfalselytoldthemthatthecontractorhadstolenhispossessions, andthatthe
contractor hadtriedtorun himover. Coughlin'sactswerespecificallycalculatedto
preventthecontractorfrom disposingoftheabandonedproperty, andto
frustrateandinterfere withMerliss'compliancewiththisCourt'sJanuary11,
2012order.
17. WhenMr.Hilloftheundersigned'sofficewasnotifiedof theforegoing,he
wenttothetransferstationandpresentedEXHIBIT2 andEXHIBIT3 tothepolice. The
contractorwasthenallowedtoproceed.
18. However,beforethecontractorcouldreturntotheRiverRockProperty,
Coughlinwasthere. Hehadhisvideocameraandwaswalkingupanddownthestreet
screamingandyellingat thepolice,thecontractor,andMr.Hill,onceMr.Hillarrived. At
theinstructionof thepolice,Mr.Hillthenobtainedatemporaryprotectiveorder("TPO")
i n ~ t CoughlinfromtheRenoJusticeCourt. Coughlinendedupbeing arrestedandtaken
tojailthatdayasaresultof hisanticsatthetransferstationandtheProperty.
19. Onthemorningof Friday,January13,2012,Coughlinsentanemailtothe
office ofthe undersigned.Attachedtothat emailwasa"SupplementalReply"prepared and
signedby Coughlin.Atrue andcorrectcopyofthe emailandattached "supplementalreply"
areattachedheretoasEXHIBIT4.
20. Thecourtis askedtonotethaton page 1 ofhis "supplemental reply,"
Coughlinidentifieshimselfas"Properappellant,"which,togetherwithhisaccompanying
email,seemstoindicatethatheintendedtofilethe"supplementalreply"inthiscase.
III
4
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G, HILL
1 15. Early that afernoon, while the contractor was hauling the first of several
2 loads of abandoned property to te transfer station (dump) for disposal, Coughlin stopped
3 the contractor in traffic and attempted to prevent him from carrying out his task.
4 16. Specifcally, Coughlin stood in front of the contractor's vehicle in an efort
5 to prevent him from proceeding to the transfer station. Coughlin threatened to sue the
6 contractor. Coughlin climbed up on the contractor's vehicle. Coughlin then called the
7 police and falsely told them that the contractor had stolen his possessions, and that the
8 contractor had tried to run him over. Couglin's acts were specifcally calculated to
9 prevent the contractor fom dsposing of the abandoned propert, and to
10 fustrate and interfere with Merliss' compliance with this Court's January 11,
11 2012 order.
12 17. When Mr. Hill of the undersigned's ofce was notifed of the foregoing, he
13 went to the transfer station and presented EXHIBIT 2 and EXHIBIT 3 to the police. The
14 contractor was then allowed to proceed.
15 18. However, before the contractor could return to the River Rock Property,
16 Coughlin was there. He had his video camera and was walking up and down the street
17 screaming and yelling at the police, the contractor, and Mr. Hill, once Mr. Hill arrived. At
18 the instruction of the police, Mr. Hill then obtained a temporar protective order ("TPO")
19 againt Coughlin from the Reno Justice Court. Coughlin ended up being arrested and taken
20 to jail that day as a result of his antics at the transfer station and the Property.
21 . 19. On the morning of Friday, January 13,2012, Coughlin sent an email to the
22 ofce of the undersigned. Attached to that email was a "Supplemental Reply" prepared and
23 signed by Coughlin. A true and correct copy of the email and attached "supplemental reply"
24 are attached hereto as EXHIBIT
4
.
25 20. The court is asked to note that on page 1 of his "supplemental reply,"
26 Coughlin identifies himself as "Pro per appellant," which, together with his accompanying
27 email, seems to indicate that he intended to file the "supplemental reply" in this case.
Post Ofic Box 2551
28
III
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 34S0888
Fax(775) 3480858
4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551 28
Reno, Neveda 69505
(775)34808S8
Fax(775) 3480858
However, thecaptionofthedocument, aswell asmostofits content,indicatesthathe
perhapsintendedtofile itinthe Carpentier v. Aames Funding case (Case No. CV08-
01709). On information andbelief, thedocumentendedupbeingactuallyfiled inthe
Carpentier case.
21. OfparticularnotetothisCourt,however,isthefirstsixpagesofCoughlin's
"supplementalreply,"whereinCoughlindescribes,insomedetail,the eventsofJanuary12,
2012.
22. OnJanuary17, 2012, Coughlinfiledtwodocumentsinthiscase. Each
documentwasentitled"OppositiontoMotionforAttorney'sFees." Thereisnot,andhas
neverbeen, any motion for attorney's fees filed in this case inthis court. Coughlin's
oppositionis a fugitive document, itviolates Rule 11 andNevada RPC 3.1 (meritorious
contention),andshouldbestrickenbythecourt. It isonlyworthmentioningherebecause
itcontainsthesame6-pagerantabouttheeventsofJanuary12,2012asdoeshisearlier
"supplementalreply."
23. Referenceismadetothedeclarationof PhillipStewart,attachedheretoas
EXHIBIT5..
24. Referenceis madetotheDeclarationofRichardG. Hill, Esq., attached
heretoasEXHIBIT6.
lAW
.1. ReferenceismadetoNRS22.010:"Thefollowingactsoromissionsshallbe
deemedcontempts:...3. Disobedienceorresistancetoanylawful writ,order,rule
orprocessissuedbythecourtorjudgeatchambers." (Emphasisadded.)
2. ReferenceismadetoNRS22.030(2),whichprovides:"2. Ifacontemptis
notcommittedintheimmediateviewandpresenceof thecourtorjudgeatchambers,an
affidavitmustbepresentedtothecourtor judgeof thefactsconstitutingthecontempt,or
astatementof thefactsbythemastersorarbitrators."
III
III
5
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 However, the caption of the document, as well as most of its content, indicates that he
2 perhaps intended to fle it in the Carentier v. Aames Fnding case (Case No. CV08-
3 01709). On information and belief, the document ended up being actually fled in the
4 Carpentier case.
5 21. Of particular note to this Court, however, is the frst six pages of Coughlin's
6 "supplemental reply, " wherein Coughlin describes, in some detail, the events of January 12,
7 2012.
8 22. On Januar 17, 2012, Coughlin fled two documents in this case. Each
9 document was entitled "Opposition to Motion for Attorney's Fee." There is not, and has
1 0 never been, any motion for attorney's fees fled in this case in this court. Coughlin's
11 opposition is a fugitive document, it violates Rule 11 and Nevada RPC 3. 1 (meritorious
12 contention), and should be stricken by the cour. It is only worth mentioning here because
13 it contains the same 6-page rant about the events of January 12, 2012 as does his earlier
14 "supplemental reply. "
15 23. Reference is made to the declaration of Phillip Stewar, attached hereto as
16 EXHIBIT _.
17 24. Reference is made to the Declaration of Richard G. Hill, Esq., atached
18 hereto as EXHIBIT 6.
19 Y
20 . 1. Reference is made to NRS 22.010: "The following acts or omissions shall be
21 deemed contempts: . . . 3. Disobedience or resistace to any lawl writ, order, rule
22 or process issued by the court or judge at chambers. " (Emphasis added.)
23 2. Reference is made to NRS 22.030(2), which provides: "2. If a contempt is
24 not committed in the immediate vew and presence of the court or judge at chambers, an
25 afdavit must be presented to the court or judge of the facts constituting the contempt, or
26 a statement of the facts by the masters or arbitrators."
27
III
Post Ofice Box 2551
28
III
Reno, Neveda 69505
(775) 34808S8
Fax(775) 3480858
O
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 346-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
~ ~ { S I S
OnDecember21,2011,JudgeSferrazzaoftheRenoJusticeCourtenteredan
orderthat,amongotherthings,allowedMerlisstodisposeof anythingleftattheProperty
after5:00p.m.onFriday,December23,2011. See EXHIBIT2. OnJanuary11, 2012,this
Court denied Coughlin's motion for a temporary restraining order, and, in so doing,
affirmedJudgeSferrazza'spreviousorder. See EXHIBIT3. WhenMerlissattemptedto
complywith the courts' orders, Coughlin attempted to prevent him from doing so.
Coughlinevenattemptedtofraudulentlyenlistthepolicetoaidhiminhiseffortstothwart
thisCourt'sandtheRenoJusticeCourt'sdirectives. Coughlin'sactionsconstitutecontempt
ofcourtunderNRS22.010(3).TheaffidavitscontemplatedbyNRS22.030(2)areattached
heretoasEXHIBIT5andEXHIBIT6. TheformoftheorderMerlissasksthecourttoenter
isattachedheretoasEXHIBIT7.
WHEREFORE, Merlisspraysforanorderofthiscourtrequiringdefendant,
ZACHARYBARKERCOUGHLIN,toappearandshowcausewhyheshouldnotbeheldin
contemptofthis courtunder NRS 22.010(3) for his resistance tothis court's lawfully
enteredorder;andforsuchother,furtherandadditionalreliefasseemsjusttothecourt
inthepremises.
AFFIRMATION Pursuant to NRS 239B.030
Theundersigneddoesherebyaffirmthattheprecedingdocumentdoesnot
containthesocialsecuritynumberofanyperson.
,
DATEDthis d.\) dayof January,2012.
RICHARDG. HILL, LTD.
CASEY .BA
RICHARDG.
652ForestStreet
Reno,Nevada89509
AttorneysforPlaintiff
6
LW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 1SIS
2 On December 21, 2011, Judge Sferrazza of the Reno Justice Court entered an
3 order that, among other things, allowed Merliss to dispose of anything lef at the Property
4 afer 5:00 p.m. on Friday, December 23, 2011. See EXHIBIT 2. On January 11, 2012, this
5 Court denied Coughlin's motion for a temporary restraining order, and, in so doing,
6 afrmed Judge Sferrazza's previous order. See EXHIBIT 3. When Merliss attempted to
7 comply with the courts' orders, Coughlin attempted to p revent him from doing so.
8 Coughlin even attempted to fraudulently enlist the police to aid him in his eforts to thwart
9 this Court's and the Reno Justice Court's directives. Coughlin's actions constitute contempt
10 of court under NRS 22.010(3). The afdavits contemplated by NRS 22.030(2) are attached
11 hereto a EXHIBIT 5 and EXHIBIT 6. The form of the order Merliss ak the court to enter
12 is attached hereto as EXHIBIT .
13 WHEREFORE, Merliss prays for an order of this court requiring defendant,
14 ZCHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, to appear and show cause why he should not be held in
15 contempt of this court under NRS 22.010(3) for his resistance to this court's lawfully
16 entered order; and for such other, further and additional relief as seems just to the court
17 in the premises.
18 AFIRTION OtSORDIIONR RQM.OO
19 The undersigned does hereby afrm that the preceding document does not
20 contain the social security number of any person.
k
21 DATED this d\ day of January, 2012.
22
23
24
25
26
27
RICHARD G. HILL, LTD.
CASEY . BA
RICHARD G.
652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
Attorneys for Plaintif
Post Ofic Box 2551
28 Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 346-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Posl Office Box 2551
Reno. Nevada 69505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
CERTIFICATEOFSERVICE
Pursuant toNRCP5(b),IherebycertifythatIamanemployeeof RICHARDG.
HILL,LTD.,andthaton ofJanuary,2012,IdepositedintheUnitedStatesmail
.atReno, Nevada, ina sealedenvelope, postage prepaid,a trueandcorrectcopyofthe
foregoingSecondMotionforOrdertoShowCauseto:
ZachCouffihlin, Esq.
1422E. 9 Street,#2
Reno,Nevada89501
I' . 1,1-./

LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1
2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Pursuant to NRCP 5(), I hereby certif that I am an employee of RICHARD G.
3 HILL, LTD., and that on te'day of January, 2012, I deposited in the United States mail
4 . at Reno, Nevada, in a sealed envelope, postage prepaid, a true and correct copy of the
5 foregoing Second Motion for Order to Show Cause to:
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Zach Cou
f
hlin, Esq.
1422 E.
9
Street, h2
Reno, Nevada 8
9
501
I'




Posl Ofic Box 2551
28 Reno. Nevada 69505
(775) 38-0888
Fax(775) 38-0858
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
EXHIBIT INDEX
EXHIBIT NO.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
DESCRIPTION PAGES
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order 6
Granting Summary Eviction dated 10/27/11
Order resolving motion to contest personal property
lien dated 12/21/11
5
Order dated 1/11/12 denying motion for temporary
4
restraining order
Email and "supplemental reply" dated 1/13/12 27
Declaration of Phil Stewart
3
Declaration of Richard G. Hill
4
Proposed order 2
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
PostOfficeBox2551
Reno, Nevada89505
(775)348-0888
,
Fax(775)348-0858
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Post Ofice Box 2551
28
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fa(775) 348-0858
EXHIBIT NO.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
EXHIBIT INDEX
DESCRIPTION PAGES
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order 6
Granting Summary Eviction dated 10/27/11
Order resolving motion to contest personal proper
lien dated 12/21/11
5
Order dated 1/11/12 denying motion for temporary 4
restraining order
Email and "supplemental reply" dated 1/13/12 27
Declaration of Phil Stewart 3
Declaration of Richard G. Hill 4
Proposed order 2
,
EXHIBIT 5
EXHIBIT 5
F I L E D
Electronically
01-20-2012:02:35:37 PM
Joey Orduna Hastings
Clerk of the Court
Transaction # 2711293

b
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
gr
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
PostOfficeBox2551
Reno, Nevada89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775)348-0858
Code No. 1520
RICHARD G. HILL, ESQ.
State Bar No. 596
CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ.
State Bar No. 9504
RICHARD G. HILL, CHARTERED
652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
(775) 348-0888
Attorney for Respondent Matt Merliss
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, )
) Case No.: CVU-03628
Appellant, )
) Dept. NO.7
v. )
)
MATT MERLISS, )
)
Respondent. )
--------------------------)
DECLARATION OF PHILLIP STEWART
PHILLIP STEWART, being first duly sworn, deposes and under penalty of
peIjury avers:
1. I am a resident ofthe City of Reno, County ofWashoe, State of Nevada,
and over 18 years ofage. This declaration is based on my personal knowledge, except those
matters stated on information and belief, and as to those items I believe them to be true.
This declaration is made in support of respondent's Motion/or Order to Show Cause, and
represents my testimony if called on to present same in court.
2. I am the owner of Nevada Building Industries, and a licensed contractor
in the State of Nevada. My contractor's license number is 15023.
III
III
gr
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 Code No. 1520
RCHARD G. HILL, ESQ.
2 State Bar No. 596
CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ.
3 State Bar No. 9504
RICHARD G. HILL, CHARTERED
4 652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
5 (775) 348-0888
Attorney for Respondent Matt Merliss
6
7
8
9
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
IN AD FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
10 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN,
11 Appellant,
12 v.
13 MT MERLISS,
Respondent.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Case No.: CU-03628
Dept. NO.7
14
15
16

)
DECLATION OF PHILLIP STEWAT
17 PHILLIP STEWART, being frst duly sworn, deposes and under penalty of
18 peIury avers:
19 1. I am a resident of the City of Reno, Count of Washoe, State of Nevada,
20 and over 18 years of age. This declaration is based on my personal knowledge, except those
21 matters stated on information and belief, and as to those items I believe them to be true.
22 This declaration is made in support of respondent's Motion/or Order to Show Cause, and
23 represents my testimony if called on to present same in court.
24 2. I am the owner of Nevada Building Industries, and a licensed contractor
25 in the State of Nevada. My contractor's license number is 15023.
26
27
III
Post Ofie Box 2551
28
III
Ren, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fa(775) 348-0858
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551
Reno, Nevada 69505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 346-0858
3. NevadaBuildingIndustrieswashiredbythelawofficeofRichardG. Hill,
Ltd.tocleanoutthepropertyleftbehindat121RiverRock, Reno,Nevadaafterthemost-
recenttenantwasevicted.
4. OnThursday,January12,2012,webeganwork.
5. Earlythatafternoon,asIwastakingthefirstloadofdebristotheWaste
Managementtransferstation,IwasflaggeddownbyZachCoughlin. AtfirstIthoughtit
wasacitizentryingtoalertmethatdebriswasfallingoutofthetruck,soIstopped. The
driverapproachedme. IimmediatelyrecognizedMr.Coughlinfromapreviousencounter
withhimattheRiverRockproperty,andfromhavingseenhimincourt.
6. Mr. Coughlinwasvery confrontational. He accusedmeofstealinghis
things. Heclimbedonmyvehicle. HethreatenedtosuemeifIdisposedofmyloadatthe
transferstation. Hetriedtopreventmefromdoingsoby,amongotherthings,standingin
thestreetinfrontofmytruck.
7. Mr.Coughlinthreatenedtocallthepolice. Itoldhimthatifhedidn'tcall
them,Iwould. IthencalledMr. Hill. Mr. HilltoldmetohaveMr.Coughlincallhim(Mr.
Hill)todiscusstermstoreleasetheloadinmytrucktoMr. Coughlin. Mr. Coughlinsaid
hedidnothaveacellphone. Ithenproceededtothetransferstation,butnotwithoutbeing
harassedalongthewaybyMr.Coughlin.
8. WhenIarrivedatthetransferstation,Mr.Coughlinjumpedinfrontofmy
trucktostopmefromenteringthetransferstationbuilding. Heproducedacellphoneand
wastalkingtosomebody,whoIlaterlearnedwasafemaleSergeantwiththeRenoPolice
Department. CoughlinwasfalselyscreamingthatIwasrunningoverhim. Hephysically
preventedmefrom proceeding. ThepolicearrivedandIcalledMr. Hill tocometothe
transferstation. Mr. Hill arrivedatthetransferstationashorttimelater. AfterMr.Hill
showedsomepaperworktothepoliceofficer,Iwasallowedtoproceedwithdumpingmy
loadatthetransferstation.
III
III
2
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 3. Nevada Building Industries was hired by the law ofce of Richard G. Hill,
2 Ld. to clean out the property lef behind at 121 River Rock, Reno, Nevada afer the most-
3 recent tenant was evicted.
4 4. On Thursday, Januar 12, 2012, we began work.
5 5. Early that afernoon, as I was taking the frst load of debris to the Waste
6 Management transfer station, I was fagged down by Zach Coughlin. At frst I thought it
7 was a citizen trying to alert me that debris was falling out of the truck, so I stopped. The
8 driver approached me. I immediately recognized Mr. Coughlin from a previous encounter
9 with him at the River Rock property, and from having seen him in court.
10 6. Mr. Coughlin was very confrontational. He accused me of stealing his
11 things. He climbed on my vehicle. He threatened to sue me if I disposed of my load at the
12 transfer station. He tried to prevent me from doing so by, among other things, standing in
13 the street in front of my truck.
14 7. Mr. Coughlin threatened to call the police. I told him that if he didn't call
15 them, I would. I then called Mr. Hill. Mr. Hill told me to have Mr. Coughlin call him (Mr.
16 Hill) to discuss terms to release the load in my truck to Mr. Coughlin. Mr. Coughlin said
17 he did not have a cell phone. I then proceeded to the transfer station, but not without being
18 harassed along the way by Mr. Coughlin.
19 8. Wen I arrived at the transfer station, Mr. Coughlin jumped in front of my
20 truck to stop me from entering the transfer station building. He produced a cell phone and
21 was talking to somebody, who I later learned was a female Sergeant with the Reno Police
22 Department. Coughlin was falsely screaming that I was running over him. He physically
23 prevented me from proceeding. The police arrived and I called Mr. Hill to come to the
24 transfer station. Mr. Hill arrived at the transfer station a short time later. Afer Mr. Hill
25 showed some paperwork to the police oficer, I was allowed to proceed with dumping my
26 load at the transfer station.
27
III
Post Ofce Box 2551
28
III
Reno, Nevada 69505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 346-0858
2
5
10
15
20
25
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : a ~ ~ x ~ ~ ~ ; 28
(775)3480868
Fax(775)348-0858
9. When I finished atthetransferstation, I returnedtothe River Rock
property. Mr. Coughlinwasalreadythere. Mr. Coughlinwaswalkingupanddownthe
streetwithhisvideocamera,yellingandscreamingatme,mycrew,and,later,thepolice
andMr. Hill,whentheyarrived. ThepolicetoldMr. HilltogototheRenoJusticeCourt
andgetaTPO,whichhedid.
10. Mr.Coughlincontinuedvideotapingandharassingme,mycrew,andthe
police. Finally,afterherefusedtocomplywiththeirrequests,Mr.Coughlinwasarrested
andtakenintocustody.
11. Ideclareunderpenaltyofperjurythattheforegoingistrueandcorrect.
AFFIRMATION Pursuant to NRS 239B.030
Theundersigneddoesherebyaffirmthattheprecedingdocumentdoesnot
containthesocialsecuritynumberof anyperson.
. DATEDthis___dayof January,2012
3
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 9. When I fnished at the transfer station, I returned to the River Rock
2 property. Mr. Coughlin was already there. Mr. Coughlin was walking up and down the
3 street with his video camera, yelling and screaming at me, my crew, and, later, the police
4 and Mr. Hill, when they arrived. The police told Mr. Hill to go to the Reno Justice Court
5 and get a TPO, which he did.
6 10. Mr. Coughlin continued videotaping and harassing me, my crew, and the
7 police. Finally, after he refsed to comply with their requests, Mr. Coughlin was arrested
8 and taken into custody.
9 11. I declare under penalty of perury that the foregoing is true and correct.
10 AFFIRATION Pursuant to NR 239B.030
11 The undersigned does hereby affrm that the preceding document does not
12 contain the social security number of any person.
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
. DATED this day of January, 2012
.`ss 28
(775) 3480868
Fax(77 5) 348-0858
3
----------- ..
EXHIBIT 6
EXHIBIT 6
F I L E D
Electronically
01-20-2012:02:35:37 PM
Joey Orduna Hastings
Clerk of the Court
Transaction # 2711293
. - ---


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
gr CodeNo. 1520
RICHARDG. HILL,ESQ.
StateBarNo. 596
CASEYD. BAKER,ESQ.
StateBarNo.9504
RICHARDG. HILL,CHARTERED
652ForestStreet
Reno,Nevada89509
(775)348-0888
AttorneyforRespondentMattMerliss
INTHESECONDJUDICIALDISTRICTCOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEVADA
INANDFORTHECOUNTYOFWASHOE
ZACHARYBARKERCOUGHLIN, )
) CaseNo.:CVU-03628
Appellant, )
v.
)
)
Dept.NO.7
)
MATTMERLISS, )
)
Respondent. )
)
DECLARATIONOFRICHARDG.HILL,ESQ.
RICHARDG. HILL,ESQ.,beingfirstdulysworn,deposesandunderpenalty
of perjuryavers:
1. IamaresidentoftheCityofReno,CountyofWashoe,StateofNevada,
andover18yearsofage. Thisdeclarationisbasedonmypersonalknowledge,exceptthose
mattersstatedoninformationandbelief,andastothoseitemsIbelievethemtobetrue.
Thisdeclarationismadeinsupportofrespondent'sMotionfor Order toShow Cause, and
representsmytestimonyifcalledontopresentsameincourt.
2. IamanattorneydulylicensedassuchbytheStateofNevadatopractice
beforeallcourtsof thisStateandmaintainmyofficeat652ForestStreet,Reno,Nevada.
I amalsolicensedtopracticebeforetheUnitedStatesDistrictCourtfortheDistrictof
Nevada,theNinthCircuitCourtof AppealsandtheUnitedStatesSupremeCourt.
III

LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858

gr
LW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Code No. 1520
RICHARD G. HILL, ESQ.
State Bar No. 596
CASEY D. BAKER, ESQ.
State Bar No. 9504
RICHARD G. HILL, CHARTERED
652 Forest Street
Reno, Nevada 89509
(775) 348-0888
Attorney for Respondent Matt Merliss
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
10 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN, )
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
11
12 v.
13 MAT MERLISS,
14
15
Appellant,
Respondent.
Case No.: CVU-03628
Dept. NO.7
DECLATION OF RICHAD G. HILL, ESQ. 16
17 RICHARD G. HILL, ESQ., being frst duly sworn, deposes and under penalty
18 of perjury avers:
19 1. I am a resident of the City of Reno, Count of Washoe, State of Nevada,
20 and over 18 years of age. This declaration is based on my personal knowledge, except those
21 matters stated on information and belief, and as to those items I believe them to be true.
22 This declaration is made in support of respondent's Motionfor Order to Show Cause, and
23 represents my testimony if called on to present same in court.
24 2. I am an atorney duly licensed as such by the State of Nevada to practice
25 before all courts of this State and maintain my ofce at 652 Forest Street, Reno, Nevada.
26 I am also licensed to practice before the United States District Court for the District of
27 Nevada, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and the United States Supreme Court.
Post Oic Box 2551
28
III
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
Post Office Box 2551
Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348"()858
3. Myofficerepresentstherespondent,Dr.MatthewMerliss,inthismatter.
4. InaccordancewiththeRenoJusticeCourt'sorderofDecember21,2011,
on Thursday, December 22, 2011, Mr. Coughlin was given full run ofthe River Rock
property,startingat9:00a.m. Ataboutnoonthatday,hesentanemailtotheeffectthat
becausehehadappealedthejusticecourt'sorder,hefelthimselfentitledtoresumeliving
inthepropertyandwouldnotleave. Laterthatday,JudgeSferrazzasentoutanemailthat
Coughlin'sstayhadbeendenied. Whenwearrivedat5:00p.m.tolockthepropertyup,it
wasapparentthatMr.Coughlinhaddonevirtuallynothingtoremoveanypossessions.This
isrelevanttotheordertoshowcause,becauseitshowsthatCoughlinwasmoreinterested
inconfrontationthatinactuallygettinghispossessionsoutofthehouse.
5. On Friday, December23, 2011, we unlockedthehouseat9:00a.m. as
ordered. Weoverlookedthechainonthebackgate. Therewasnobodyatthehousewhen
wewerethere.
Atapproximatelynoon,mystaffinformedmethatanenragedMr.Coughlin
hadcalledtheofficescreamingthathecouldnotgetinthebackyard. WhenIfinishedthe
meetingIwasin,Iimmediatelywentoverandunlockedthebackgate.
Coughlinhadasmallcrew. Hechargedatmeandmadephysicalcontact. He
wasenraged. Weleft.
When we returnedat5:00p.m., Mr. Coughlinwas screamingandyelling
obscenities. HedroveoffinasmallU -Haul. Hiscrewremained. Wewalkedtheproperty
withthem. Theinside.groundfloorwasmostlyclearedofallbutabigTV. Thebasement
hadbeenclearedsomewhat,but therewasstillalotof"junk."Wecouldnotaccesstheattic.
We wentoutside. ItoldCoughlin'screwtheycould removeanythingand
everythingoutside,iftheywouldonlytrytorehangthegatethatMr.Coughlinhadtaken
offthehingesbeforewecouldgetovertounlockit. ItoldthemIwouldlockthegatesinthe
morning.
III
III
2
LW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1
2
3. My ofce represents the respondent, Dr. Matthew Merliss, in this matter.
4. In accordance with the Reno Justice Court's order of December 21, 2011,
3 on Thursday, December 22, 2011, Mr. Coughlin was given fll run of the River Rock
4 property, starting at 9:00 a.m. At about noon that day, he sent an email to the efect that
5 because he had appealed the justice court's order, he felt himself entitled to resume living
6 in the property and would not leave. Later that day, Judge Sferrazza sent out an email that
7 Coughlin's stay had been denied. When we arrived at 5:00 p.m. to lock the property up, it
8 was apparent that Mr. Coughlin had done virtually nothing to remove any possessions. This
9 is relevant to the order to show cause, because it shows that Coughlin was more interested
10 in confrontation that in actually getting his possessions out of the house.
11 5. On Friday, December 23, 2011, we unlocked the house at 9:00 a.m. as
12 ordered. We overlooked the chain on the back gate. There was nobody at the house when
13 we were there.
14 At approximately noon, my staf informed me that an enraged Mr. Coughlin
15 had called the ofce screaming that he could not get in the back yard. When I fnished the
16 meeting I was in, I immediately went over and unlocked the back gate.
17 Coughlin had a small crew. He charged at me and made physical contact. He
18 was enraged. We lef.
19 When we returned at 5:00 p.m., Mr. Coughlin was screaming and yelling
20 obscenities. He drove of in a small U -Haul. His crew remained. We walked the propert
21 with them. The inside.ground foor was mostly cleared of all but a big T. The basement
22 had been cleared somewhat, but there was still a lot of "junk. " We could not access the attic.
23 We went outside. I told Coughlin's crew they could remove anything and
24 everything outside, if they would only try to rehang the gate that Mr. Coughlin had taken
25 of the hinges before we could get over to unlock it. I told them I would lock the gates in the
26 morning.
27
III
III
Pot Ofice Bx 2551
28 Reno, Nevada 89505
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348"858
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
When I returned the next day, Coughlin's crew had not taken much of what
had been outside the night before. I secured the backyard, and nothing was moved until the
events detailed herein.
6. On Thursday, January 12,2012, I met with Phil Stewart of Nevada Building
Industries at the River Rock property to make arrangements with him to remove and
dispose of the abandoned property left there by Mr. Coughlin. I then returned to my office.
7. Approximately four to five hours after returning to my office, I received a
telephone call from Mr. Stewart. Mr. Stewart informed me that Mr. Coughlin had flagged
him down near the Waste Management transfer station, where Mr. Stewart was attempting
to dump his first load of debris removed from the house that morning.
8. Mr. Stewart told me that Coughlin was accusing him (Mr. Stewart) of
stealing his things, threatening to sue Mr. Stewart, and generally trying to prevent Mr.
Stewart from disposing of those items by, among other things, standing in the street in front
of Mr. Stewart's truck. I told Mr. Stewart to have Mr. Coughlin call me, because I wanted
to try to negotiate terms to release the contents of the truck to Mr. Coughlin. Mr. Stewart
told me Mr. Coughlin said he did not have a cell phone.
9. Shortly thereafter, I received another call from Mr. Stewart. He was at the
transfer station. Mr. Coughlin had stopped him from entering. Mr. Coughlin had called the
police, and told them that Mr. Stewart had stolen his (Coughlin's) possessions, and that
they were in the truck.
10. I immediately drove to the transfer station. When I got there, Mr.
Coughlin was present, and being cordoned away by two Reno Police Department officers.
After I presented the police officers with the Reno Justice Court's December 21,2011 order,
and this court's January 11, 2012 order, Mr. Stewart was allowed to proceed. I then
returned to my office.
11. Approximately 15 minutes later, I received another call from Mr. Stewart,
who informed me that Mr. Coughlin was at the River Rock property. I immediately drove
LAWOFACE
RICHARD G. HILL
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ : a ~ ~ ~ ~ ; g ~ over to the River Rock property.
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
3
LAWOFACE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 When I returned the next day, Coughlin's crew had not taken much of what
2 had been outside the night before. I secured the backard, and noting was moved until the
3 events detailed herein.
4 6. On Thursday, January 12,2012, I met with Phil Stewart of Nevada Building
5 Industries at the River Rock propert to make arrangements with him to remove and
6 dispose of the abandoned proper lef there by Mr. Coughlin. I then returned to my ofce.
7 7. Approximately four to fve hours afer returning to my ofce, I received a
8 telephone call from Mr. Stewart. Mr. Stewart informed me that Mr. Coughlin had fagged
9 him down near the Waste Management transfer station, where Mr. Stewart was attempting
10 to dump his first load of debris removed from the house tat morning.
11 8. Mr. Stewart told me that Coughlin was accusing him (Mr. Stewart) of
12 stealing his things, threatening to sue Mr. Stewart, and generally trying to prevent Mr.
13 Stewart from disposing of those items by, among other things, standing in the street in front
14 of Mr. Stewart's truck. I told Mr. Stewart to have Mr. Coughlin call me, because I wanted
15 to tr to negotiate terms to release the contents of the truck to Mr. Coughlin. Mr. Stewart
16 told me Mr. Coughlin said he did not have a cell phone.
17 9. Shortly thereafer, I received another call from Mr. Stewart. He was at the
18 transfer station. Mr. Coughlin had stopped him fom entering. Mr. Coughlin had called the
19 police, and told them that Mr. Stewart had stolen his (Coughlin's) possessions, and that
20 they were in the truck.
21 10. I immediately drove to the transfer station. When I got there, Mr.
22 Coughlin was present, and being cordoned away by two Reno Police Department ofcers.
23 Afer I presented the police ofcers with the Reno Justice Court's December 21,2011 order,
24 and this cour's Januar 11, 2012 order, Mr. Stewart was allowed to proceed. I then
25 returned to my ofice.
26 11. Approximately 15 minutes later, I received another call fom Mr. Stewart,
27 who informed me that Mr. Coughlin was at the River Rock propert. I immediately drove
:a;g 28 over to the River Rock proper.
(775) 348-0888
Fax(775) 348-0858
3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12. When I got there, Mr. Coughlin was walking up and down the street and
in the street with his video camera, yelling and screaming at me, the police, and Mr.
Stewart.
13. On the advice of the police officer on the scene, I then went to the Reno
Justice Court and obtained a temporary protective order against Mr. Coughlin to prevent
him from returning to the River Rock property or further harassing Mr. Stewart and his
crew. I filled out the TPO paperwork and returnedto River Rock. Mr. Coughlin was already
in custody. He was in the back of a squad car. When he saw me, he began swearing and
yelling. He was screaming at the police and would not cooperate with them. I received a
call to return to the Reno Justice Court to retrieve the TPO, which I subsequently gave to
an RPD officer, who said he would serve Mr. Coughlin at the jail.
14. I have personally reviewed exhibits 1-4 to the instant motion, and each
exhibit is a true and correct copy of what it purports to be.
15. Mr. Coughlin's behavior was calculated to disrupt the removal of debris
from thehome. I counted no less than 13 automobile seats in the basement, including what
I am told is the front bench-seat from a Chevrolet Blazer. Mr. Coughlin left significant
quantities of trash and garbage at the property.
16. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
AFFIRMATION Pursuant to NRS 239B.030
The undersigned does hereby affirm that the preceding document does not
contain the social security number of any person.
DATED this {t:j 2'day of January, 2012 __
~ = . . . . . .
LAWOFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
PostOfficeBox2551
Reno. Nevada89505
(775)348"()888
Fax(775)348"()858
4
LAW OFFICE
RICHARD G. HILL
1 12. When I got there, Mr. Coughlin was walking up and down the street and
2 in the street with his video camera, yelling and screaming at me, the police, and Mr.
3 Stewart.
4 13. On the advice of the police ofcer on the scene, I then went to the Reno
5 Justice Court and obtained a temporary protective order against Mr. Coughlin to prevent
6 him from returning to the River Rock property or further harassing Mr. Stewart and his
7 crew. I filled out the TPO paperwork and returned to River Rock. Mr. Coughlin was already
8 in custody. He was in the back of a squad car. When he saw me, he began swearing and
9 yelling. He was screaming at the police and would not cooperate with them. I received a
10 call to return to the Reno Justice Court to retrieve the TPO, which I subsequently gave to
11 an RPD ofcer, who said he would serve Mr. Coughlin at the jail.
12 14. I have personally reviewed exhibits 1-4 to the instant motion, and each
13 exhibit is a true and correct copy of what it purports to be.
14 15. Mr. Coughlin's behavior was calculated to disrupt the removal of debris
15 from the home. I counted no less than 13 automobile seats in the basement, including what
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
I am told is the front bench-seat from a Chevrolet Blazer. Mr. Coughlin lef signifcant
quantities of trash and garbage at the property.
16. I declare under penalt of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
AFFIRATION Pursuant to NR 239B.030
The undersigned does hereby affrm that the preceding document does not
contain the social securit number of any person.
DATED this {t 2day of January, 2012 _

Post Ofice Box 2551
28 Reno. Nevada 89505
(775) 348"888
Fax(775) 348"858
4
1
2
3
4
5
6 IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
7 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
8
9 ZACHARY COUGHLIN, Case No.: CVII-03628
10 Plaintiff, Dept. No.: 7
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
vs.
MATTHEW MERLISS,
Defendant.
~ /
ORDER
This case is an appeal from Reno Justice Court ("RJC") and involves the summar
eviction of a tenant, Plaintiff ZACHARY COUGHLIN ("Coughlin"), under NRS Chapter 40.
Currently before this Court are three matters, all of which have been fully briefed and submitte
for decision.
The first matter is Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52(b) to Amend or Make Additiona
Findings of Fact; or, Pled in the Alternative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter or Amend th
22 Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal of Personal Property. The second matter i
23 Defendant MATTHEW MERLISS's ("Merliss") Motion for Leave to File Answering Brief i
24 Excess of Five Pages. The third and final matter is the parties' Appellate Briefs, includin
25 Coughlin's Opening Briefand Merliss's Answering Brief This Court will address each ofthes
26 matters in turn.
1
27
28
I The parties are familiar with the facts and procedural history of this case. Thus, this Court will recite neither th
facts nor procedural history unless doing so is necessary to this Court's determination.
1
F I L E D
Electronically
03-30-2012:04:14:37 PM
Joey Orduna Hastings
Clerk of the Court
Transaction # 2859996 1
2
3
4
5
6
IN THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
7
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF WASHOE
8
9
ZACHARY COUGHLIN, Case No.: CVII-03628
10
Plaintiff, Dept. No.: 7
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
vs.
MATTHEW MERLISS,
Defendant.

ORER
This case is an appeal from Reno Justice Court ("RJC") ad involves the suar
eviction of a tenant, Plaintiff ZACHARY COUGHLIN ("Coughlin"), under NRS Chapter 40.
Currently before this Court are three matters, all of which have been flly briefed and submitte
for decision.
The frst matter is Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52() to Amend or Make Additiona
Findings of Fact; or, Pled in the Alterative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter or Amend th
22 Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal of Personal Propert. The second matter i
23 Defendant MATTHEW MERLISS's ("Merliss ") Motion for Leave to File Answering Brief i
24 Excess of Five Pages. The third and fnal matter is the parties' Appellate Brief, includin
25 Coughlin's Opening Briefand Merliss's Answering Brief This Court will address each of thes
26 matters in t. 1
27
28
I The parties are familiar with the facts and procedural history of this case. Thus, this Court will recite neither th
facts nor procedural history unless doing so is necessary to this Court's determination.
1
1 NRCP 52(b) and NRCP 59
2 The object of Coughlin's Motion filed on January 30, 2012 appears to be this Court'
3 Order dated January 11, 2012. In that Order, this Court denied Coughlin's emergency reques
4 for a temporary restraining order. Coughlin made the request after Judge Sferrazza of RJ
5 entered an Order on December 21, 2011, in which he ordered: (1) Coughlin to pay $480.00 t
6 Merliss for storage of his personal property between November 1,2011 and November 16,2011;
7 and (2) Coughlin shall have access to the premises from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
8 December 22,2011 and December 23,2011 to remove his personal property.
9 Coughlin claims this Court's January 11, 2012 Order "is clearly inaccurate to the exten
lOis purports to find that the undersigned made any agreement to waive his security deposit i
11 exchange for additional access to the property." (PI. Mot. at p. 12.) In addition, Coughlin aver
12 counsel for Merliss misled this Court by claiming Coughlin was permitted to remove persona
13 property after 5 :00 p.m. Coughlin further alleges counsel for Merliss "boarded up" the premises
14 "install [ ed] a chain and padlock on the back gate," and later attempted to file suit for the disposa
15 costs of removing the property, all of which prevented Coughlin from removing the items in th
16 first place. (PI. Mot. at p. 14.) Consequently, Coughlin contends this Court's Order should b
17 amended or altered under NRCP 52 or 59 to include these allegations as additional findings 0
18 fact.
19 Conversely, in his Opposition filed on February 3, 2012 Merliss avers Coughlin fails t
20 articulate which findings he wants amended under NRCP 52. Even if Coughlin did articulat
21 such findings, however, Merliss contends relief under NRCP 52(b) is nonetheless unavailable t
22 Coughlin because this Court's Order did not contain a final judgment, as that rule requires.
23 Similarly, Merliss contends Coughlin is not entitled to relief under NRCP 59(e) because "n
24 judgment has ever been entered by this court in this case, so there is no judgment for this court t
25 alter or amend." (Def. Opp'n at p. 2.) In short, Merliss contends Coughlin's Motion lacks an
26 evidentiary basis, is "nonsense ... filed only to delay this matter and drive up fees," and i
27 "completely devoid of any merit whatsoever," to the extent "it is even decipherable." (Def
28
2
1 NRCP 52b) and NRCP 59
2 The object of Coughlin's Motion fled on January 30, 2012 appears to be this Court'
3 Order dated January 11, 2012. In that Order, this Court denied Coughlin's emergency reques
4 for a temporary restraining order. Coughlin made the request afer Judge Sferrazza of RJ
5 entered an Order on December 21, 2011, in which he ordered: (1) Coughlin to pay $480.00 t
6 Merliss for storage of his personal property between November 1, 2011 and November 16, 2011;
7 and (2) Coughlin shall have access to the premises fom 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
8 December 22, 2011 and December 23, 2011 to remove his personal property.
9 Coughlin claims this Court's January 11, 2012 Order "is clearly inaccurate to the exten
lO is purports to fnd that the undersigned made any agreement to waive his security deposit i
11 exchange for additional access to the property. " (PI. Mot. at p. 12.) In addition, Coughlin aver
12 counsel for Merliss misled this Court by claiming Coughlin was permitted to remove persona
13 property afer 5 :00 p.m. Coughlin fher alleges counsel for Merliss "boarded up" the premises
14 "install [ ed] a chain and padlock on the back gate, " and later attempted to fle suit for the disposa
15 costs of removing the property, all of which prevented Coughlin from removing the items in th
16 frst place. (PI. Mot. at p. 14.) Consequently, Coughlin contends this Court's Order should b
17 amended or altered under NRCP 52 or 59 to include these allegations as additional fndings 0
18 fact.
19 Conversely, in his Opposition fled on February 3, 2012 Merliss avers Coughlin fails t
20 articulate which findings he wants amended under NRCP 52. Even if Coughlin did articulat
21 such fndings, however, Merliss contends relief under NRCP 52(b) is nonetheless unavailable t
22 Coughlin because this Court's Order did not contain a fnal judgment, as that rule requires.
23 Similarly, Merliss contends Coughlin is not entitled to relief under NRCP 59(e) because "n
24 judgment has ever been entered by this court in this case, so there is no judgment for this court t
25 alter or amend. " (Def. Opp'n at p. 2.) In short, Merliss contends Coughlin's Motion lacks an
26 evidentiary basis, is "nonsense . . . fled only to delay this matter and drive up fees, " and i
27 "completely devoid of any merit whatsoever, " to the extent "it is even decipherable. " (Def
28
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
attached thereto, and afte
finds the Order i
claims.
Rib Roof, Inc., 247 P.3d 1107, 1108 (Nev. 2011
a judgment that "disposes of all the issue
As a consequence, this Court find
have in this case.
Mak
Opp'n at p. 1, 2.) In fact, Merliss claims Coughlin should be subject to
"vexatiouslitigationtactics." (Def.Opp'natp. 3.)
After reviewing the parties' pleadings and the exhibits
reviewing this Court'sJanuary 11,2012Order, this Courthas gleaned from Coughlin'sMafia
certainadditionalfindings offactthatCoughlincontendsshouldbeincluded- byamendment0
alteration - in this Court's Order. Ultimately, however, this Court
unamendableorunalterableundertheRulesCoughlincitesbecausesaid Order doesnotcontai
a final appealable judgment, or a disposition that resolves all ofthe parties'
Simmons Self-Storage Partners, LLC v.
(explaining jurisdiction to consider an appeal from the district court depends on whether th
district courthas entered a final judgment); Lee v. GNLV Corp., 116Nev. 424, 426, 996 P.2
416, 417 (2000) (defining "final judgment" as
presented in the case, and leaves nothing for the future consideration ofthe court, except fo
post-judgment issues such as attorney's fees and costs.").
reliefunderNRCP52 or59isunavailabletoCoughlin.
Although Simmons and GNL V involve appeals to the Nevada Supreme Court from th
districtcourt,thisCourtfinds thejurisdictionalprinciplesannouncedinthosecasesalsoapplyt
the district court when the district court considers appeals from the justice courts, as well a
when the district court considers motions under NRCP 52 or 59, as we
Therefore, this Court concludes Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52(b) to Amend or
Additional Findings of Fact; or, Pled in the Alternative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter a
Amend the Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal ofPersonal Property isDENIED.
LeavetoFileAnsweringBriefinExcessofFivePages
In light ofthe voluminous record in this case (which exceeds 2,000 pages), includin
lengthybriefsfiledbyCoughlin,
2
thisCourtfinds goodcauseexiststo grantMerlissleavetofil
2 ThisCourtacknowledgesMerliss'scomplaintthatCoughlinhasviolatedthepagelimitscontainedinOrders fro
this Court, as wellasthe localrules. However, pursuanttothisCourt'slongstandingpolicyofconsideringcases0
the merits, as opposed to dismissing them for procedural reasons, this Court will overlook such violations in thi
particularcase.
3
1 Opp'n at p. 1, 2.) In fact, Merliss claims Coughlin should be subject to
2 "vexatious litigation tactics." (Def Opp'n at p. 3.)
3 Afer reviewing the parties' pleadings and the exhibits attached thereto, and afe
4 reviewing this Court's January 11, 2012 Order, this Court has gleaned from Coughlin's Mafia
5 certain additional fndings of fact that Coughlin contends should be included - by amendment 0
6 alteration - in this Court's Order. Ultimately, however, this Court fnds the Order i
7 unamendable or unalterable under the Rules Coughlin cites because said Order does not contai
8 a fnal appealable judgment, or a disposition that resolves all of the parties' claims.
9 Simmons Self-Storage Partners, LLC v. Rib Roof, Inc., 247 P.3d 1107, 1108 (Nev. 2011
10 (explaining jurisdiction to consider an appeal from the district court depends on whether th
11 district court has entered a fnal judgment); Lee v. GNLV Cor., 116 Nev. 424, 426, 996 P.2
12 416, 417 (2000) (defning "fnal judgment" as a judgment that "disposes of all the issue
13 presented in the case, and leaves nothing for the fture consideration of the court, except fo
14 post-judgment issues such a attorey's fees and costs."). As a consequence, this Court fnd
15 relief under NRCP 52 or 59 is unavailable to Coughlin.
16 Although Simmons and GNL V involve appeals to the Nevada Supreme Court from th
17 district court, this Court fnds the jurisdictional principles announced in those cases also apply t
18 the district court when the district court considers appeals from the justice courts, as well a
19 when the district court considers motions under NRCP 52 or 59, as we have in this case.
20 Therefore, this Court concludes Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52() to Amend or Mak
21 Additional Findings of Fact; or, Pled in the Alterative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter a
22 Amend the Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal of Personal Propert is DENIED.
23 Leave to File Answering Brief in Excess of Five Pages
24 In light of the voluminous record in this case (which exceeds 2,000 pages), includin
25 lengthy briefs fled by Coughlin,
2
this Court fnds good cause exists to gant Merliss leave to fl
26
27
28
2 This Court acknowledges Merliss's complaint that Couglin has violated the page limits contained in Orders fo
this Court, as well as the local rules. However, pursuant to this Court's longstanding policy of considering cases 0
the merits, as opposed to dismissing them for procedural reasons, this Court will overlook such violations in thi
paicular case.
3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an answering briefin excess offive pages. In addition, this Court denies Merliss's motion t
strikethe excessmaterial filed by Coughlinand also denies Merliss'srequest for leaveto file
supplementalbrieftomeettheargumentscontainedinthatexcessmaterial.
3
AppellateBriefs
Asmentionedpreviously,this caseinvolvesthe summaryevictionofCoughlinfrom 121
River Rock Street, Reno, NV 89501 ("the Property"). After two hearings in RJC in whic
Coughlin alleged defenses of habitability, retaliation, and discrimination, Judge Sferrazz
adjudged Coughlin summarily evicted from the Property pursuant to NRS 40.253(6) by Orde
dated October 27, 2011. Specifically, Judge Sferrazza found Merliss properly terminate
Coughlin'stenancy and thereafterproperly served Coughlinwith anotice ofunlawful detainer.
JudgeSferrazzafurtherfound "Coughlinfailed to presentanyevidencethatMerlissactedinan
prohibited, discriminatory, or retaliatory fashion as alleged by Coughlin, or otherwise.'
(Sferrazza,J., Order,CaseNo.REV2011-001708,Oct.27,2011.)
As a result, Coughlin was ordered to vacate the premises by October 31, 2011 at 5:0
p.m. Coughlinfailed todoso. Healsofailedtoremovehispersonalbelongings. Consequently
Merliss sought a personal property lien for storage ofCoughlin's personal belongings in th
Propertyfrom theperiodofNovember 1, 2011 toNovember 16,2011. Coughlinfiled amotio
to contestthe lien. OnDecember21, 2011,Judge SferrazzaorderedCoughlintopaytoMerlis
$480.00as "fairandreasonable compensation"for Merliss'sstorageofhispersonal belongings.
(Sferrazza,J., Order, CaseNo. REV2011-001708, Dec. 21, 2011.) Judge Sferrazzaalso grante
Coughlin access to the Property to remove his personal belongings by December 23, 2011 a
5:00 p.m. Coughlin failed to do so. As a result, Merliss hired a contractor to dispose 0
Coughlin'spersonalbelongings. Coughlinappealed.
Coughlin filed his Opening Brief ("Brief') on February 6, 2012.4 Merliss filed hi
Answering Brief ("Response") on February 24, 2012. This Court took the matter unde
3 Seenote2,supra. Merlissmadethisrequestinfootnote 14ofhisAnswering Brief, discussedinfra.
4 Thispleadingreplacedan Opening Brie/Coughlin previouslyfiledtwodaysearlier. Consequently,thisCourtwil
treat this brief as the operative pleading. In addition, on February 7, 2012 Coughlin filed a Supplement I
Appellanl's Opening Brief, towhichheattachedan exhibitcontainingaCDofaudiorecordings.
4
1 an answering brief in excess of five pages. In addition, this Court denies Merliss's motion t
2 strike the excess material filed by Coughlin and also denies Merliss's request for leave to fle
3 supplemental brief to meet the arguments contained in that excess material. 3
4 Apellate Briefs
5 As mentioned previously, this case involves the su ary eviction of Coughlin from 121
6 River Rock Street, Reno, NV 89501 ("the Property"). Afer two hearings in RJC in whic
7 Coughlin alleged defenses of habitability, retaliation, and discrimination, Judge Sferrazz
8 adjudged Coughlin suarily evicted from the Property pursuat to NRS 40.253(6) by Orde
9 dated October 27, 2011. Specifcally, Judge Sferrazza found Merliss properly terminate
10 Coughlin's tenancy and thereafer properly served Coughlin with a notice of unlawfl detainer.
11 Judge Sferrazza frther found "Coughlin failed to present any evidence that Merliss acted in an
12 prohibited, discriminatory, or retaliatory fashion as alleged by Coughlin, or otherwise.'
13 (Sferrazza, J., Order, Case No. REV2011-001708, Oct. 27, 2011.)
14 As a result, Coughlin was ordered to vacate the premises by October 31, 2011 at 5:0
15 p.m. Coughlin failed to do so. He also failed to remove his personal belongings. Consequently
16 Merliss sought a personal property lien for storage of Coughlin's personal belongings in th
17 Property from the period of November 1, 2011 to November 16, 2011. Coughlin fled a motio
18 to contest the lien. On December 21, 2011, Judge Sferrazza ordered Coughlin to pay to Merlis
19 $480.00 as "fair and reasonable compensation" for Merliss's storage of his personal belongings.
20 (Sferazza, J., Order, Case No. REV2011-001708, Dec. 21, 2011.) Judge Sferrazza also grante
21 Coughlin access to the Property to remove his personal belongings by December 23, 2011 a
22 5 :00 p.m. Coughlin failed to do so. As a result, Merliss hired a contractor to dispose 0
23 Coughlin's personal belongings. Coughlin appealed.
24 Coughlin fled his Opening Brief ("Brief') on February 6, 2012.
4
Merliss fled hi
25 Ansering Brief ("Response") on February 24, 2012. This Court took the matter unde
26
27
28
3 See note 2, supra. Merliss made this request in footote 14 of his Answering Brief discussed infa.
4 This pleading replaced a Opening Brie/Coughlin previously filed two days earlier. Consequently, this Court wil
teat this brief as the operative pleading. I addition, on February 7, 2012 Coughlin fled a Supplement I
Appellanl's Opening Brief to which he attached a exhibit containing a CD of audio recordings.
4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
submission on February 27, 2012. This Order now follows. As a preliminary matter, however
this Court notes it is the issue of summary eviction and the Judge Sferrazza's October 27, 2011
Order that presently concerns this Court.
5
Standard of Review
On civil appeals from justice courts to district courts, a case "must not be tried anew.'
NJCRCP 72(c). Whether on appeal at the Nevada Supreme Court from a district court, or 0
appeal at a district court from a justice court, a lower court's findings "will not be disturbed 0
appeal unless they are clearly erroneous and are not based on substantial evidence." Gibellini v
Klindt, 110 Nev. 1201, 1204,885 P.2d 540, 542 (1994).
"[A]n order granting summary eviction under NRS 40.253(6) should be reviewed 0
appeal based upon the standard for review of an order granting summary judgment under NRC
56 because these proceedings are analogous." Anvui, LLC v. G.L. Dragon, LLC, 123 Nev. 212
215, 163 P.3d 405, 407 (2007). Summary judgment is proper only if no genuine issue 0
material fact exists and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. NEV. R.CIv
P. 56(c); see Wood v. Safeway, Inc., 121 Nev. 724, 729, 121 P.3d 1026, 1029 (2005). Th
moving party bears the initial burden of proving there is no genuine issue of material fact. Main
v. Stewart, 109 Nev. 721, 726-27, 857 P.2d 755, 758 (1993).
Once the moving party satisfies this burden, however, the burden shifts to the nonmovin
party to show the existence of a genuine issue of material fact. Id. at 727. While the pleading
and the record must be construed in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, the part
must do more than simply show there is some metaphysical doubt as to the operative facts
Wood, 121 Nev. at 729. To avoid having summary judgment entered against it, the party must
5 On appeal, Coughlin's Brief spans forty-seven pages and contains several allegations and claims. Many of thes
claims touch upon collateral issues like, for example, alleged relationships between Merliss's counsel and la
enforcement, alleged unconstitutional acts of city employees under Monell v. Dep't of'soc. Servs., 436 U.S. 65
(1978), and Merliss' s alleged disinterest in complaints from people like Coughlin and others associated wit
Coughlin. As such, this Court will not address these issues. In addition, because Coughlin failed to timely file hi
notice of appeal regarding the personal property lien, see NRS 40.253(8), and because Coughlin's notice of appea
fails to identify an error regarding the court's procedure in setting a hearing on this issue, this Court will no
consider this issue.
5
1 submission on February 27, 2012. This Order now follows. As a preliminary matter, however
2 this Court notes it is the issue of summary eviction and the Judge Sferrazza's October 27, 2011
3 Order that presently concers this Court.
5
4 Standard of Review
5 On civil appeals from justice courts to district courts, a case "must not be tried anew.'
6 NJCRCP 72(c). Whether on appeal at the Nevada Supreme Court fom a district court, or 0
7 appeal at a district court from a justice court, a lower court's fndings "will not be disturbed 0
8 appeal unless they are clearly erroneous and are not based on substantial evidence." Gibellini v
9 Klindt, 110 Nev. 1201, 1204, 885 P.2d 540, 542 (1994).
10 "[A]n order granting summary eviction under NRS 40.253(6) should be reviewed 0
11 appeal based upon the standard for review of an order granting su ary judgment under NRC
12 56 because these proceedings are analogous. " Avi LLC v. G.L. Dragon, LLC, 123 Nev. 212
13 215, 163 P.3d 405, 407 (2007). Su ary judgment is proper only if no genuine issue 0
14 material fact exists and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. NEV. R. CIv
15 P. 56(c); see Wood v. Safeway, Inc., 121 Nev. 724, 729, 121 P.3d 1026, 1029 (2005). Th
16 moving party bears the initial burden of proving there is no genuine issue of material fact. Main
17 v. Stewart, 109 Nev. 721, 726-27, 857 P.2d 755, 758 (1993).
18 Once the moving party satisfes this burden, however, the burden shifs to the nonmovin
19 party to show the existence of a genuine issue of material fact. Id. at 727. While the pleading
20 and the record must be construed in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, the part
21 must do more than simply show there is some metaphysical doubt as to the operative facts
22 Wood, 121 Nev. at 729. To avoid having summary judgment entered against it, the party must
23
24
25
26
27
28
5 O appeal, Couglin's Brief spans forty-seven pages ad contains several allegations and claims. Many of thes
claims touch upon collateral issues like, for example, alleged relationships between Merliss's counsel and la
enforcement, alleged unconstitutional acts of city employees under Monell v. Dep't of 'soc. Servs., 436 U.S. 65
(1978), and Merliss' s alleged disinterest in complaints fom people like Coughlin and others associated wit
Coughlin. As such, this Court will not address these issues. In addition, because Coughlin failed to timely fle hi
notice of appeal regarding the personal propert lien, see NRS 40.253(8), and because Coughlin's notice of appea
fails to identif an error regarding the court's procedure in setting a hearing on this issue, this Court will no
consider this issue.
5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
by affidavit or otherwise, set forth specific facts demonstrating the existence of a genuine issu
for trial. Id.
Legal Analysis
This Court has reviewed all of the parties' pleadings and the exhibits attached thereto
This Court also has considered all of the parties' relevant arguments. After this review an
consideration, this Court will not disturb Judge Sferrazza's October 27, 2011 Order grantin
summary eviction. This Court finds that Order was based on substantial evidence and it was no
clearly erroneous. Thus, this Court concludes Merliss has met his initial burden of proving ther
is no genuine issue of material fact regarding whether Coughlin was summarily evicted properly
Consequently, the burden shifts to Coughlin to show the existence of a genuine issue of materia
fact.
Although Coughlin raises several claims and makes numerous allegations in his Brie
Coughlin fails to present additional facts related to his defenses raised in RJC that undermine 0
legitimately call into question the substantial evidence upon which Judge Sferrazza relied whe
he granted summary eviction. This Court gives substantial deference to the lower court's factua
findings in this regard, particularly in light of the numerous hearings held before Judge Sferrazz
and Coughlin's related opportunities to present evidence supporting his various defenses.
Therefore, this Court finds no genuine issue of material fact exists regarding whether Coughli
was summarily evicted properly in the lower court. As a result, Coughlin's appeal is DENIED.
CONCLUSION
Accordingly, in summary, this Court orders:
1) Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52(b) to Amend or Make Additional Findings of
Fact; or, Pled in the Alternative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter or Amend the
Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal ofPersonal Property is DENIED;
2) Merliss's request for leave to file Answering Brief in excess of five pages is
GRANTED; and
III
III
6
1 by afdavit or otherwise, set forth specifc facts demonstrating the existence of a genuine issu
2 for trial. Id.
3 Legal Analysis
4 This Court has reviewed all of the parties' pleadings and the exhibits attached thereto
5 This Court also has considered all of the parties' relevant arguments. Afer this review a
6 consideration, this Court will not disturb Judge Sferrazza's October 27, 2011 Order grantin
7 suary eviction. This Court fnds that Order was based on substantial evidence and it was no
8 clearly erroneous. Thus, this Court concludes Merliss has met his initial burden of proving ther
9 is no genuine issue of material fact regarding whether Coughlin was su arily evicted properly
10 Consequently, the burden shifs to Coughlin to show the existence of a genuine issue of materia
11 fact.
12 Although Coughlin raises several claims and makes numerous allegations in his Brie
13 Coughlin fails to present additional facts related to his defenses raised in RJC that undermine 0
14 legitimately call into question the substantial evidence upon which Judge Sferrazza relied whe
15 he granted suary eviction. This Court gives substantial deference to the lower court's factua
16 fndings in this regard, particularly in light of the numerous hearings held before Judge Sferrazz
17 and Coughlin's related opportunities to present evidence supporting his various defenses.
18 Therefore, this Court fnds no genuine issue of material fact exists regarding whether Coughli
19 was summarily evicted properly in the lower court. As a result, Coughlin's appeal is DENIED.
20 CONCLUSION
21 Accordingly, in summary, this Court orders:
22 1) Coughlin's Motion Under NRCP 52() to Amend or Make Additional Findings of
23 Fact; or, Pled in the Alterative, Motion Under NRCP 59 to Alter or Amend the
24 Order Denying Motion to Prevent Disposal of Personal Propert is DENIED;
25
26
27 III
28 III
2) Merliss's request for leave to fle Answering Brief in excess of fve pages is
GRNTED; and
6
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
3) Coughlin'sappealregardingsummaryevictionfromthePropertyisDENIED.
ITISSOORDERED.
DATEDthis-3.CLdayof March,2012.
PATRICKFLANAGAN
DistrictJudge
7
1 3) Coughlin's appeal regarding summary eviction fom the Property is DENIED.
2 IT IS SO ORDERED.
3 DATED this - day of March, 2012.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
7
PATRCK FLANAGAN
District Judge
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
PursuanttoNRCP5(b),IherebycertifythatIam anemployeeof theSecondJudicial
DistrictCourtof theStateof Nevada,CountyofWashoe;thatonthis dayof March,
2012,IelectronicallyfiledthefollowingwiththeClerkof theCourtbyusingtheECFsystem
whichwillsendanoticeofelectronicfilingtothefollowing:
ZacharyCoughlin,Esq.onhisownbehalf;and
RichardHill,Esq. forMattMerliss.
IdepositedintheWashoeCountymailingsystemforpostageandmailingwiththe
UnitedStatesPostalServiceinReno,Nevada,atruecopyof theattacheddocumentaddressed
to:
8
1 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
2 Pursuant to NRCP 5(b), I hereby certify that I a an employee of the Second Judicial
3 District Court of the State of Nevada, County of Washoe; that on this day of March,
4 2012, I electronically fled the following with the Clerk of the Court by using the ECF system
5 which will send a notice of electronic fling to the following:
6 Zachary Coughlin, Esq. on his own behalf; ad
7 Richard Hill, Esq. for Matt Merliss.
8 I deposited in the Washoe County mailing system for postage and mailing with the
9 United States Postal Service in Reno, Nevada, a true copy of the attached document addressed
10 to:
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
8
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
Close Print
RE: WCSO Deputy Machem's "personally served" Affidavit of
11/ 1/ 2011
From: Stuchell, Liz (LStuchell@washoecounty.us)
Sent: Tue 2/07/12 11:40 AM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
Cc: Kandaras, Mary (mkandaras@da.washoecounty.us)
Mr. Coughlin,

Our records indicate that the eviction conducted on that day was personally served by Deputy Machen by posting a
copy of the Order to the residence. The residence was unoccupied at the time.

Liz Stuchell, Supervisor
WCSO Civil Section

From: Zach Coughlin [mailto:zachcoughlin@hotmail.com]
Sent: Monday, February 06, 2012 2:58 AM
To: Stuchell, Liz; Kandaras, Mary; nvrenopd@coplogic.com; Silva, Roxanna; kadlicj@reno.gov; fourthestate@gmail.com;
jamesandreboles@msn.com
Subject: WCSO Deputy Machem's "personally served" Affidavit of 11/1/2011


lstuchell@washoecounty.us mkandara@da.washoecounty.us

Dear IA Supervisor Stuchell and DDA Kandaras,
I realize you will likely not read all of this. The main thing is I am respectfully
requesting that you confirm with Deputy Machem that he did, in fact, "personally
serve" the Summary Eviction Order on me at 121 River Rock St., Reno 89501 on
November 1, 2011 at 4:30 pm, in connection with performing the lockout. It is my
position that I was not "personally served" and I am trying to figure out whether
Deputy Machem is lying or whether the phrase "personally served" means something
other than what I believe it means, etc., etc. I appreciate your attention to this.
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]

I am writing to inquire about and complain with regard to an Affidavit of Service filed
by or for WCSO Deputy Machem with respect to the service of a Order Granting
Summary Eviction against me (in my law office where non-payment of rent was not
alleged, no less in violation of NRS 40.253 and where a $2,275 rent escrow deposit
was foisted upon me in violation of 40.253(6), especially where a stay of eviction was
not granted even while the RJC held on to most all my money...).

My issue with the WCSO is that Machem's Affidavit of Service indicates that he
"personally served" me, which kind of reminds me of all that robo-signing and MERS
fraud I come across in my day job (and do you wonder how many attorneys in the
foreclosure defense game I am in constant contact with who are watching and witness
the potential RICO violations this writing mentions?), which includes being a
foreclosure defense attorney. So which is it? Did Machem "personally serve" me the
Summary Eviction Order? Richard G. Hill, Esq. likes to argue that I was "served" in
compliance with all time related rules because it was done in the "usual custom and
practice of the WCSO. What, exactly, is the "usual custom and practice of the
WCSO? I hear a lot about this "within 24 hours" stuff. So, I go hunting for some
black letter law to support what those at the RJC and in the clueless community at
large (which often includes Nevada Legal Services and Washoe Legal Services, the
people you guys had such trouble actually serving in the lawsuits I filed, which may
have actually helped improved legal services in this community, if they were not
dismissed due to insufficiency of service of process, even where the IFP required the
WCSO to served the defendants....). Anyway, back to the "within 24 hours"
phraseology: "

This whole business about The court may thereupon issue an order directing the
sheriff or constable of the county to remove the tenant within 24 hours after receipt of
the order... is inapplicable to this situation, where an Order Granting Summary
Eviction was signed by October 27
th
, 2011. That language is only found in situations
inapplicable to the current one. NRS 40.253(3)(b)(2), and NRS 40.253(5)(a) are the
only sections of NRS 40 where this within 24 hours language occurs, and those
situations only apply where, in:
40.253(3)(b)(2): 3. A notice served pursuant to subsection 1 or 2 must: ...(b) Advise
the tenant: . (2) That if the court determines that the tenant is guilty of an unlawful
detainer, the court may issue a summary order for removal of the tenant or an order
providing for the nonadmittance of the tenant, directing the sheriff or constable of the
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
county to remove the tenant within 24 hours after receipt of the order
and,
40.253(5)(a): 5. Upon noncompliance with the notice: (a) The landlord or the
landlords agent may apply by affidavit of complaint for eviction to the justice court
of the township in which the dwelling, apartment, mobile home or commercial
premises are located or to the district court of the county in which the dwelling,
apartment, mobile home or commercial premises are located, whichever has
jurisdiction over the matter. The court may thereupon issue an order directing the
sheriff or constable of the county to remove the tenant within 24 hours after receipt of
the order. The way these summary eviction proceedings are being carried out in Reno
Justice Court presently shocks the conscience and violates Nevada law. There is not
basis for effectuating a lockout the way WCSO's Deputy Machem did in this case. The
above two sections containing the within 24 hours of receipt language are
inapplicable, as those situations do not invoke the present circumstances, where the
Tenant did file an Affidavit and did contest this matter to a degree not often seen. To
require Nevada's tenants to get up and get out within 24 hours of receipt of the
order (what does that even mean? The use of terms like rendition, rendered,
notice of entry, pronounced, is absent here, and this receipt of the order
language is something rarely found elsewhere in Nevada law-see attached DMV
statutory citations, and in employment law litigations where one must file a Complaint
within 90 days of receipt of a Right To Sue Letter, a situation which follows NRCP
5(b), and NRCP 6(e) in imputing receipt of such a letter, when actual receipt is not
shown, by applying a constructive notice standard that relies upon the days for
mailing extension of time for items served in the mailing, etc.). In Abraham v. Woods
Hole Oceanographic Institute, 553 F.3d 114 (1st Cir. 2009), the record did not reflect
when the plaintiff received his right-to-sue letter. The letter was issued on November
24, 2006. The court calculated that the 90-day period commenced on November 30,
2006, based on three days for mailing after excluding Saturdays and Sundays. In order
to bring a claim under either Title VII or the ADA, a plaintiff must exhaust
administrative remedies and sue within 90 days of receipt of a right to sue letter. See
42 U.S.C. 2000e-5(f)(1). See Baldwin County Welcome Center v. Brown, 466 U.S.
147, 148 n.1, 104 S.Ct. 1723, 80 L.Ed.2d 196 (1984)(granting plaintiff an additional
three days for mailing pursuant to Rule 6).
Further, despite what the inaccurate handouts of Nevada Legal Services may say about
this 24 hours and the applicability of the JCRCP to cases like these, NRS 40.400
Rules of practice, holds that :The provisions of NRS, Nevada Rules of Civil
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
Procedure and Nevada Rules of Appellate Procedure relative to civil actions, appeals
and new trials, so far as they are not inconsistent with the provisions of NRS 40.220 to
40.420, inclusive, apply to the proceedings mentioned in those sections. As such
NRCP 6(a),(e) applies to the Order of Summary Eviction that WCSO Deputy Machem
alleged, under penalty of perjury, that he "personally served" upon me on November 1,
2011. That is a lie by Mr. Machem, unless "personally served" is defined in a rather
impersonal way and or Machem and I have totally different understanding of the
definition of "personally served", which may be the case. Or, perhaps the Sheriff's
Office is busy and doesn't want to wait around to "personally serve" every tenant it
wishes to evict. Fine, then just use the "mail it and allow three days" rule in NRCP
6(e)...the landlord's might not like it, but they can use that frustration as an incentive
not to jump to litigating every disagreement about habitability that a tenant brings to
them. You may not realize how ridiculous some landlord's get. In my case, I offered
to fix basic things that clearly implicated the habitability rules in NRS 118A.290 and
the Californian neurosurgeon, Beverly Hill High School graduate landlord balked and
complained then hired and attorney four days into a dispute.....at which point the rules
against contacting represented parties prevented much in the way of real settlement
discussion, particularly where opposing counsel has continuously demonstrated a
complete indifference to pursuing settlement (why would he at the rates he bills hours
at?). I just don't think the Sheriff's Office needs to sully its image or damage the
citizen tenants of Washoe County in the name of pleasing people like Dr. Matt Merliss
or Richard G. Hill, Esq.

I AM REQUESTING, IN WRITING, THAT BOTH OF YOUR OFFICES
INVESTIGATE THIS AND PROVIDE A SWORN AFFIDAVIT FROM MR.
MACHEM THAT ADMITS THAT I WAS NOT PERSONALLY PRESENT WHEN
HE SERVED THE ORDER FOR SUMMARY EVICTION IN RJC REV2011-001708
ON 11/1/12 AT 4:30 PM (ACCORDING TO HIS AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE). YOU
NEVER KNOW, I MIGHT HAVE IRREFUTABLE PROOF THAT I WAS
SOMEWHERE ELSE AT THAT TIME, SO, BE CAREFUL. There simply is not
anything specific in Nevada law addressing how such Summary Eviction Orders are
to be served and carried out. The sections dealing with
NRS 40.253 Unlawful detainer: Supplemental remedy of summary eviction and
exclusion of tenant for default in payment of rent....
6. Upon the filing by the tenant of the affidavit permitted in subsection 3,
regardless of the information contained in the affidavit, and the filing by the landlord
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
of the affidavit permitted by subsection 5, the justice court or the district court shall
hold a hearing, after service of notice of the hearing upon the parties, to determine the
truthfulness and sufficiency of any affidavit or notice provided for in this section. If
the court determines that there is no legal defense as to the alleged unlawful detainer
and the tenant is guilty of an unlawful detainer, the court may issue a summary order
for removal of the tenant or an order providing for the nonadmittance of the
tenant....
7. The tenant may, upon payment of the appropriate fees relating to the filing and
service of a motion, file a motion with the court, on a form provided by the clerk of
the court, to dispute the amount of the costs, if any, claimed by the landlord pursuant
to NRS 118A.460 or 118C.230 for the inventory, moving and storage of personal
property left on the premises. The motion must be filed within 20 days after the
summary order for removal of the tenant or the abandonment of the premises by the
tenant, or within 20 days after:
(a) The tenant has vacated or been removed from the premises; and
(b) A copy of those charges has been requested by or provided to the tenant,
whichever is later.
8. Upon the filing of a motion pursuant to subsection 7, the court shall
schedule a hearing on the motion. The hearing must be held within 10 days after
the filing of the motion. The court shall affix the date of the hearing to the motion
and order a copy served upon the landlord by the sheriff, constable or other
process server. At the hearing, the court may:
(a) Determine the costs, if any, claimed by the landlord pursuant to NRS 118A.460
or 118C.230 and any accumulating daily costs; and
(b) Order the release of the tenants property upon the payment of the charges
determined to be due or if no charges are determined to be due...."

I also want to know why NRS 40. 253(8) was not followed with respect to my
November 17th, 2011 filing of a Motion to Contest Personal Property Lien. Why
didn't the WCSO serve notice, as required by NRS 40.253(8) upon the landlord's
attorney Richard Hill? Why didn't I get a hearing within the 10 days called called for
by that section (to get back my client's files no less), but rather, I had to wait a full 33
days to get a hearing, and service of notice of the hearing was not effectuated, as
required by NRS 40.235(8), by the WCSO. Why?

Please provide an indication, in writing, of the names and case numbers for the last 20
incidences when the WCSO has served notice of a hearing set pursuant to NRS
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
40.253(8). What's that? The WCSO has NEVER served such notice? Yet the WCSO
is there with bells on (or Machem is) to lie in Affidavits of Service to lock out the
citizen tenants of Washoe County impermissilby early vis a vis NRCP 5(b)(2) and
NRCP 6(e)? Why is that? Is it a conspiracy? Does money talk? When I was arrested
for trespassing on November 12th, 2011 by RPD Officer Chris Carter and Sargent
Lopez, Carter admitted to me that "Richard Hill pays him a lot of money and therefore
he arrests whom Richard Hill says to and does what Richard Hill says to do...." Both
Carter and Sargent Lopez refused to investigate, despite prompting, whether Richard
Hill has sent the tenant/arrestee a bill or demand letter in bill for the full rental value
of the property, $900 per month, under some interpretation of the "reasonable storage,
moving, and inventorying expenses" collectable by a landlord under a personal
property line set forth in NRS 118A.460 (one could also interpret such a bill as Hill's
withdrawing or eradicating the Order of Summary Eviction itself, which was not
"personally served" by the Washoe County Sheriff (despite what their Affidavit of
Service says...I wasn't even there at the time they changed the locks...and so the
Summary Eviction Order was not properly served under NRCP 6, and despite the
Reno Justice Court impermissibly converting $2300 of my money under a "rent
escrow" Order its required I comply with in order to litigate habitability issues in a
summary eviction proceeding under NRS 40.253, despite NRS 40.253(6)'s express
dicate against such an Order (unless, pursuant to JCRCP 83, a justice court gets such a
rule, like Justice Court Rule of Las Vegas (JCRLV) Rule 44, published and approved
by the Nevada Supreme Court, which the RJC has not, rather, the RJC applies all
these insidious secret "house rules" (like forcing tenants to deliver themselves to the
filing office to submit to personal service notice of a summary eviction hearing within,
like, 12 hours of the Tenant filing a Tenant's Answer or Affidavit in response to an
eviction Notice, rather than the service requirements of such notice following NRCP 6
(days for mailing, etc., etc., in other words, in the RJC everything is sped up
imperissilby to help landlord's out, and the NV. S. Ct ruling in Glazier and Lippis
clearly contemplate personal liability against the Court and or Judges themselves for
so doing)....A Qui Tam action or something a la Mausert's in Solano County, I believe,
in California, would be very interesting...Still haven't heard anything from the Reno
PD about the various complaints I have filed with them in writing related to the
wrongful arrests, excessive force and other misconduct committed against me, though
they did arrest me the other day for calling 911incident to some domestic violence for
which I was granted to Extended Protection Orders against my former
housemates....old Sargent Sigfree ordered that arrest, as he did two days prior when he
ordered a custodial arrest of me for "jaywalking".
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
Funny thing, I never heard anything back from the RPD about complaints like the
following one:
From:NvRenoPd@coplogic.com
Sent: Wed 9/07/11 10:51 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
****DO NOT RESPOND TO THIS E-MAIL****


We're sorry the following problem was found during review
of your submitted report T11005956:

THIS IS NOT THE FORUM FOR THIS TYPE OF COMPLAINT HOWEVER THIS
REPORT WAS PRINTED AND PASSED ON TO THE OFFICER'S SUPERVISOR
AND IT WILL BE ADDRESSED.

Thank you,

Officer WOZNIAK,
Reno Police Department

What is interesting there is that at least I was provided the name of an officer, a
"Wozniak" (though I have been unable to confirm the existence of
such an RPD Officer...
or whether " THIS IS NOT THE FORUM FOR THIS TYPE OF COMPLAINT
HOWEVER THIS REPORT WAS PRINTED AND PASSED ON TO THE
OFFICER'S SUPERVISOR AND IT WILL BE
ADDRESSED."
What is more strange is that I submitted several online police reports to the Reno PD
(a couple of which asserted complaints against various Reno PD officers, or asked
why RDP Officer Carter, whom admitted taking bribes from Richard G. Hill, Esq. at
the time of my custodial arrest for trespassing (the one where Richard Hill signed a
Criminal Complaint for trespass, then Officer Carter and Sargent Lopez refused to
follow up on my imploring them to ask Hill whether he has recently sent me a bill for
the "full rental value" of the property, the same amount that had been charged for the
"use and enjoyment" of the premises, $900, in comparision to what NRS 118A.460
may deem "reasonable storage" expenses for which a lien is available to a landlord,
though NRS 118A.520 has outlawed rent distraints upon tenant's personal
property....Regardless, between January 8 - 12th, 2012, and was arrested twice by the
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
Reno PD shortly after submitting these written complaints to the Reno PD.
Actually, upon being release from jail on November 15th, 2011, incident to the
custodial trespass arrest, I went to Richard HIll's office to get my wallet and driver's
license. He refused to provide it to me until late November 22nd, 2011. Hill called
the Reno PD on the 15th (or maybe I did because he was withholding my state issued
ID, the one I would need to rent a room, drive my car, and my wallet, which is kind of
useful in such situations....). Anyways, Sargent Tarter of the Reno PD showed up, he
went inside Hill's office with Hill for quite some time and the result was Tarter telling
me to leave. I did, but while driving down St. Laurence towards S. Virginia (Hill's
office is at 652 Forrest St. 89503 and would have required turning down the wrong
way of a one way street, Forrest, to go back to Hill's Office (so clearly I was not
headed to Hill's office) Sargent Tarter began tailing me, then he pulled me over, then
he gave me a ticket, in retaliation if you ask me for reporting RPD Officer Carter
admitting that he takes bribes from Hill to Sargent Tarter minutes earlier. Uh, well,
anyways, another Sargent calls me later that night, taking the "good cop" role. But
upon informing him of what RPD Officer Carter told me about Hill paying him money
to arrest people during the 11/12/11 trespassing arrest, that Sargent immediately
informed me that, despite this being the first he heard of that, he was sure that was not
happening....I guess RPD Officer Carter is trying to explain away his comments about
Richard Hill paying him money to arrest people by dismissing them as sarcasm, a
joke, said in jest, whatever....but I don't see how that situation (a license attorney
getting arrested for a crime, a conviction for which would result in that attorney being
required to report said conviction to the State Bar of Nevada under SCR 111, etc., and
possibly resulting in a suspension of that attorney's license to practice law, or worse...)
is all that jocular of a situation. Combine that with the too quick to dismiss my
reports of bribery by Richard Hill to officer Carter to the RPD Sargent who called me
on 11/15/11 regarding the retaliation by Sargent Tarter that I complained of, and I
don't think it is all that unreasonable for anyone to take RPD Officer Carter at his
word regarding Richard G. Hill, Esq. paying him money to arrest whom Hill says to
arrest. Add to that Sargent Sigfree ordering my arrest for jaywalking (by a trainee
RPD Officer) on January 12th, 2011 (custodial arrest, bail of $160 emptied my bank
account out, or pretty close to it) while I was peacefully filming from a public spot
Richard G. Hill, Esq's contractor Phil Howard, whom had submitted bills in courts
records and filings under the lien for "reasonable storage moving and inventorying"
found in NRS 118A.460, even where old Phil used my own plywood at the property to
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
board up the back porch (curiously leaving the screws holding up the plywood
exposed to exterior of the property where anyone could easily unscrew them, and also
leaving in a window unit ac secured only by ducttape in a window facing a sidewalk
by the LakeMill Lodge....which resulted in $8,000 at least of my personal property
being burglarized from my former home law office on Decmeber 12th, 2011 while
Hill was asserting a lien on all my personal property found therein (and my client's
files, which arguably are not even my property, but rather, the client's property). Hill
went on to place what he believes to be my social security number in court records, on
purpose, despite his signing an Affirmation pursuant to NRS 239B.030 that that was
not the case (attaching a two page report to the RPD as an Exhibit). Then Hill and his
contractor Phil Howard both committed perjury when the signed Declarations attesting
that I had climbed on the contractors truck or ever touched Hill. Hill lies constantly,
whether under penalty of perjury or now, so I don't have time to rebut every little lie
he makes (he makes me out to comes across as a Yosemite Sam caricature of a human
being in his filings when he describes me...).
Further, why am I arrested for trespassing and not those from Nevada Court Services
where they went behind closed gate the the backyard of my home law office and
banged on window extremely loudly for 40 minutes at a time 3 times a day, one guy
ringing the doorbell, one guy moving around all other sides of the property banging on
the windows, peering in closed blinds, and affecting a phony "color of law" tone,
resemblance, and verbal communications, misleadingly announcing that they were
"Court Services, come out now!", wearing their pretend Sheriff outfits, big equipment
saddled belts (including firearms, I believe, and radios), etc. ,etc.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQ132q2O7DY
Add to that that Nevada Court Services Jeff Chandler drives by in his Monster Truck
baring his personalized "NCS" license plate while I am in the RPD squad car,
handcuffed, outside my former law office at 121 River Rock, at the time of the
1/12/12 jaywalking arrest and the appearances are troubling. Now, add to that that
Lew Taitel, Esq. was my court appointed public defender in the Reno Municipal Court
in the trespass case, and that Judge Gardner had refused to provide me the names of
prospective appointed defense counsel (I wanted to run a conflicts check) at my
arraignment (where Marshal Mentzel barked at me in a threatening tone, using
menacing language), whereupon Taitel was appointed as my defense attorney and
filed a notice of appearance, and received my confidential file, pc sheet, arrest reports,
ssn, etc....only its turns out that Taitel shares and office and a receptionist with Nevada
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
Court Services and they list him and his picture on their website as "associated with"
their Process Server corporation, despite the prohibition lawyers face against fee
sharing with non-lawyers. Then, Taitel somehow manages to get out of defending my
case without filing a Motion to Withdraw as Counsel, despite that being required by
the Reno Municipal Court Rule 3(B):
RMCR Rule 3(B): Authorization to Represent (B): An attorney desiring to withdraw
from a case shall file a motion with the court and serve the City Attorney with the
same. The court may rule on the motion or set a hearing.
But, perhaps most troubling of all is the implication that the Reno City Attorney's
Office, which defends actions against the City of Reno Police Department and its
Officers, has a vested interest in discrediting me in advance of the wrongful arrest
lawsuit that the Reno City Attorney's office knew was imminent at the time of all of
the above incidents, relating to the following August 20th, 2011 wrongful arrest by
RPD Officer's Duralde and Rosa. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PR7q4OI5b0
So, that's what attempting to coerce a suspect's consent to an impermissible search
sounds like? Add to that that the trespassing case is before Judge Gardner, whom
most recently was employed with the Reno City Attorney's Office.
And, you know what is funny? Officer Del Vecchio cuffed me and placed me in his
squad car last summer after he terrified me and another gentleman who had bicycles.
He veered across the road and screeched his squad car to a halt, jumped out, and did
some other stuff, then demanded my name and ID...and the lawyer in me didn't like
that that much, and he didn't like me not wanting to give it to him. This occurred right
in front of my home law office in the summer of 2011. He cuffed me and told me I
was going to jail for something about a light on the front of my bicycle (the one NV
Energy likely stole when the shut off my power, unnoticed, on October 4, 2011)
despite my bike actually having such a light....but then Del Vecchio's partner did him
a solid and talked some sense into him, and I humbled it up for Del Vecchio and we
both let it go, and I didn't go to jail....Until Del Vecchio was present supervising some
Officer's training at the scene of my custodial (9 hour) jaywalking arrest) on 1/12/12.
But Del Vecchio, I guess either didn't want to or wasn't able to talk some sense into
Sargent Sigfree.....and then Sargent Sigfree (the spelling is likely off) had me arrested
and charged with a gross misdemeanor, "Misuse of 911" just two days later, on
January 14th, 2011 when I called 911 to report that my roommates were laughing
menacingly when I asked them why my dog was missing (I had also been chased up to
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
my room numerous times since moving in with these people, something I had to do
because so much of my money had been taken up with bail or lost earnings due to all
these wrongful arrests and abuse of processes mentioned above...also these
housemates had chased me with a ten inch butcher knife, two of my tires were
slashed, I was locked out all night on New Years Even when these changed the locks
at around midnight, had my furniture thrown in the street, property stolen, coffee
thrown on me, destroying my smart phone in the process, etc., etc...And despite the
housemate having an outstanding arrest warrant, and animal abuse being listed
amongst the elements of domestic violence, Sargent Sigfree told me he was arresting
me because I "keep putting yourself in these situations", like, where I am a victim, and
that he was "trying to help you", he said with a smirk and a laugh to his fellow RPD
Officers, whom then proceeded to use excessive force against me. I guess he was
helping me by saddling me with a gross misdemeanor with a $1,500 bail, especially
where its been arranged for Court Services, or pre-Trial Services to forever deny me
an OR, despite my meeting the factors for such set forth in statute (30 year resident,
entire immediate family lives here, licensed to practice law in Nevada, etc., etc)...I
guess it should not be too much of a surprise to me that Reno City Attorney Pam
Roberts failed to address the perjury of all three of her witnesses or that her fellow
Reno City Attorney Christopher Hazlett-Stevens lied to me about whether or not the
Reno City Attorney's Office even had any documentation related to my arrest or
whether it would in the month before my arraignment, despite that fact that subsequent
productions of discovery tend to indicate that the Reno City Attorney's Office did
have those materials at the time. I could be wrong about some of this...But that would
require and awful lot of coincidences.
Sincerely,
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
1422 E. 9th St. #2
RENO, NV 89512
tel: 775 338 8118
fax: 949 667 7402
ZachCoughlin@hotmail.com
Nevada Bar No: 9473

Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
RE: IFP Coughlin Service of Complaints WLS employment law;
landlord tenant case
** Notice** This message and accompanying documents are covered by the electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-2521, and may contain
confidential information intended for the specified individual (s) only. If you are not the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, copying, or the taking of any action based on
the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. This message is confidential, intended only for the named recipient(s) and may contain
information that is privileged, attorney work product or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you are not the intended
recipient(s), you are notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or any action taken or omitted to be taken in reliance on the
contents of this information is prohibited and may be unlawful. If you receive this message in error, or are not the named recipient(s),
please notify the sender, delete this e-mail from your computer, and destroy any copies in any form immediately. Receipt by anyone
other than the named recipient(s) is not a waiver of any attorney-client, work product, or other applicable privilege.
From: Stuchell, Liz (LStuchell@washoecounty.us)
Sent: Mon 12/05/11 12:32 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
Mr. Coughlin,

Per your demand stated in the e-mail received from you on November 7
th,
all document packets that were provided by
you were assembled and served by November 16
th
. Affidavits of Service were sent to your new address that you
provided on November 30
th
. Affidavits with case numbers were sent directly to the court. Last week copies of those
were sent to you free of charge. You also will receive original Affidavits of Service of documents that did not have case
numbers.

Any further inquiries should be made to our Civil Attorney, Mary Kandaras at the District Attorneys Office.

Liz Stuchell
WCSO Civil Section

From: Zach Coughlin [mailto:zachcoughlin@hotmail.com]
Sent: Sunday, December 04, 2011 2:53 AM
To: Silva, Roxanna; Stuchell, Liz
Subject: RE: IFP Coughlin Service of Complaints WLS employment law; landlord tenant case

Dear Ms. Stuchell and Ms. Silva,
I don't mean to be a jerk, I am under inordinate stress right now (not that that is anybody's problem but mine).
The citation below would tend to indicate that your office might, MIGHT, have a duty to photocopy the
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]
electronic versions I sent and serve them in a manner that the opposing attorneys will not respond to by filing
"Motions to Dismiss" based upon illegibility or bad copying/printing. They object to the 9 pages per page
stuff...In an ideal world your office would serve one page per page of these things, after you print them out,
etc...If you can do that, I would of course be extremely grateful, if you can't, I am of course let to scratch and
claw my way through this lawsuit like every other thing in my life as an IFP who can seemingly be curbstomped
by the older richer attorneys whenever they feel like it (and who have some dubious help in doing so). One
interesting thing is that one of the employment cases, etierh cv11-01955 or cv11-01986 (whichever was filed on
June 27th with an IFP) has to be served within 120 days of WHEN? The docket seems to suggest the Complaint
in that IFP case was only entered on or around August 11th, 2011, which would obvioulsy changed the 120 days
calculation, however, whether the filing date relates back to the IFP is something I have never been able to get a
clear answer on anywhere....

Thank You,

Zach Coughlin, Esq.
817 N. Virginia St. #2
Reno, NV 89501
tel: 775 338 8118
fax: 949 667 7402
Licensed in Nevada and USPTO
** Notice** This message and accompanying documents are covered by the electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 2510-
2521, and may contain confidential information intended for the specified individual (s) only. If you are not the intended recipient or an
agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this document in error and that
any review, dissemination, copying, or the taking of any action based on the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. This
message is confidential, intended only for the named recipient(s) and may contain information that is privileged, attorney
work product or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you are not the intended recipient(s), you are notified that
any disclosure, copying, distribution or any action taken or omitted to be taken in reliance on the contents of this
information is prohibited and may be unlawful. If you receive this message in error, or are not the named recipient(s),
please notify the sender, delete this e-mail from your computer, and destroy any copies in any form immediately. Receipt
by anyone other than the named recipient(s) is not a waiver of any attorney-client, work product, or other applicable
privilege.

Subject: RE: IFP Coughlin Service of Complaints WLS employment law; landlord tenant case
Date: Thu, 1 Dec 2011 08:52:29 -0800
From: RSilva@washoecounty.us
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
You and I are the only ones who got this. Is he asking us to serve more docs?

From: Zach Coughlin [mailto:zachcoughlin@hotmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, November 30, 2011 6:37 AM
To: Silva, Roxanna; Stuchell, Liz
Subject: IFP Coughlin Service of Complaints WLS employment law; landlord tenant case

"The defect in service (that the photocopy of the complaint provided was too
faint) was not attributable to the plaintiff, but to court personnel, who are
responsible for making copies of the initial pleadings for IFP litigants".
McKENZIE v. AMTRAK M OF E, 777 F.Supp. 1119.
Hotmail Print Message
file:///R|/...nd%20from%20Stuchell%20lstuchell@washoecounty.us%2026405%201708%2026800%2001896%2060302.htm[10/29/2012 2:26:41 AM]

Please serve a full, one page per page copy of each complaint to each defendant in all of
the matters for which I have provided you IFP proof, summons, and complaints.
PLEASE NOTE I HAVE A NEW ADDRESS.
Sincerely,
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
817 N. Virginia St. #2
Reno, NV 89501
tel: 775 338 8118
fax: 949 667 7402
Licensed in Nevada and USPTO
** Notice** This message and accompanying documents are covered by the electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18
U.S.C. 2510-2521, and may contain confidential information intended for the specified individual (s) only. If you are not
the intended recipient or an agent responsible for delivering it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you
have received this document in error and that any review, dissemination, copying, or the taking of any action based on the
contents of this information is strictly prohibited. This message is confidential, intended only for the named recipient(s) and
may contain information that is privileged, attorney work product or exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If you
are not the intended recipient(s), you are notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or any action taken or omitted
to be taken in reliance on the contents of this information is prohibited and may be unlawful. If you receive this message in
error, or are not the named recipient(s), please notify the sender, delete this e-mail from your computer, and destroy any
copies in any form immediately. Receipt by anyone other than the named recipient(s) is not a waiver of any attorney-client,
work product, or other applicable privilege.
****** IMPORTANT NOTICE - READ THIS INFORMATION *****
PROOF OF SERVICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING
A filing has been submitted to the court RE: CV11-03628
Judge: PATRICK FLANAGAN
Official File Stamp: 02-08-2012:16:34:48
Clerk Accepted: 02-08-2012:16:35:22
Court: Second Judicial District Court - State of Nevada
Case Title:
ZACHARY COUGHLIN VS. MATTHEW
MERLISS (D7)
Document(s) Submitted: Ord to Show Cause
Filed By: Kathryn Sims
You may review this filing by clicking on the
following link to take you to your cases.
This notice was automatically generated by the courts auto-notification system.
If service is not required for this document (e.g., Minutes), please disregard the below language.
The following people were served electronically:
ZACHARY COUGHLIN, ESQ. for ZACH
COUGHLIN
CASEY BAKER, ESQ. for MATTHEW MERLISS
RICHARD HILL, ESQ. for MATTHEW MERLISS
The following people have not been served electronically and must be served by traditional
means (see Nevada electronic filing rules):
****** IMPORTANT NOTICE - READ THIS INFORMATION *****
PROOF OF SERVICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING
A filing has been submitted to the court RE: CV11-03628
Judge: PATRICK FLANAGAN
Official File Stamp: 02-10-2012:13:49:40
Clerk Accepted: 02-10-2012:13:50:37
Court: Second Judicial District Court - State of Nevada
Case Title:
ZACHARY COUGHLIN VS. MATTHEW
MERLISS (D7)
Document(s) Submitted: Notice of Entry of Ord
-**Continuation
Filed By: RICHARD HILL, ESQ.
You may review this filing by clicking on the
following link to take you to your cases.
This notice was automatically generated by the courts auto-notification system.
If service is not required for this document (e.g., Minutes), please disregard the below language.
The following people were served electronically:
ZACHARY COUGHLIN, ESQ. for ZACH
COUGHLIN
CASEY BAKER, ESQ. for MATTHEW MERLISS
RICHARD HILL, ESQ. for MATTHEW MERLISS
The following people have not been served electronically and must be served by traditional
means (see Nevada electronic filing rules):
`++J J \1 `1`J
~I+s:Ib:tlcsto: Bld
NBICD J6, 20J2
IV.z.NVS91-!^'
phrc 0.82.`00
00.2+.2
I= I2.3.288
6entVIa U.6. MaIl, CertIhed MaIland vIa E-MaI!
5oloub|cRBlvd Src. H
Fcro.N'8V52J5;7
ZBCDBIy C. \CUQDID, LS.
phmc 52.-l0
J422L. PID!D C!ICC!, #2
f 2'0'2?
CDC, PV d9J2
uu uubar:v_
|L. PHCIDCy LISCI|IDC
LCBI NI. \CUQDID
JDC \HICC C CBI \CUDSC DBS ICCCIVCC SCVCIB QIICVBDCCS CCDCCIDIDQ yCUI
CCDCUC! BS B BWyCI. JDC QIICVBDCCS IDCUCC SU||CI!IDQ CVICCDCC ID !DC CIH C.
BUCIC C yCUI CCDCUC! ID CCUI! |ICCCCCIDQS BDC CC|ICS C |CBCIDQS BDC CCCUHCD!S
|IC|BICC BDC ICC Dy yCU ID JUS!ICC BDC LIS!IIC! \CUI!. JCQC!DCI !DCSC QIICVBDCCS
IBISC SCIICUS UCS!ICDS ICQBICIDQ yCUI CCH|C!CDCy BDC BDII!y !C |IBC!ICC BW.
JDCSC CCDCCIDS BIC SCIICUS BDC !DC \ICC C CBI \CUDSC IS CCDSICCIIDQ !DC
DCCCSSI!y C SCCKIDQ B |C!I!ICD !C LC!CIHIDC \CH|C!CDCy |UISUBD! !C CU|ICHC
\CUI! |UC JJ7.
| BH CDCCSIDQ WI!D !DIS C!!CI CC|ICS C B QIICVBDCC C!!CI, ICH !DC NUDICI|B
\CUI! BDC B CC|y C BD \ICCI ICH LIS!IIC! \CUI!. |CBSC ICS|CDC !C BCQB!ICDS
|CIlBIDIDQ !C yCUI CCDCUC WI HBKC BVBIBDC CI yCUI lCVICW BDC IDS|CC!ICD lDC
SU||CI!IDQ CCCUHCD!S BDC BUCIC ICCCICIDQS.
| DBVC lC| |DCDC HCSSBQCS BDC SCD! yOU BD OHB! BSK|DQ yOU !O CB HO lS
C !DO C!a|IDQ C !D!S lCICI yCU DBvO DC! CBOC HO | WCUC KC lO HCC! WIID you so
lhaI WO L! discuss !DIS IH|O!lBI! HBI!CI BUC ee l !DOC |S B WBy !DBI WC Cc lCl|
OU lQBID, QlCBSC CB HC d\ yOU! OBIIIOS! CQ|CI!UDlly.
CIDCCICly,

lB!IICK ^'DQ
-ssisIanl Uar COunsel
M!^+ t^ ` . 1Y!HM
Upmtmcnt l
M!^. Y11^ ll^H^H
lcpar|mcntZ
M!^. !H!M` ^^M M!1>
lcpurtmcnIJ
M!^. bt^^t1M H. M!Y^H
lcpurImcnI4
hI. uV!U LuIK, Sq.
|JHCC OJ uI LOULSC
IuIC 3I OJ `CVuUu
U1^! 1^!1^1!!1U
hu!C 14,?01?
t^h>^^H^ Jtb !^
\oun^dmnis!ra|or

H!|jH
lcparImcnt
oIAIlcmalvc5cnIcncng
A` .

/|:
1c lLY
b' '|l
4OUC VU., U!IC
CLO, `N 8?1 t!^1111^1^
C. 'uCuI uIKCI LOUy!L, `CVuUu uI `O. 47J
CuI hI. LuIK.
J!S CIICI COLSI!IUICS u \u COHu!L! OJ uIIOILC H!SCOLUUCI uLU/OI USu!!I uyu!LSI
'uCuI uIKCI LOUy!L. JC uCCOHu!Ly OX OJ HuICI!uS UCHOLSIIuICS SOHC OJ IC
IOCHS V!I IC IuCI!CC OJ I!S uIIODC C!Ly CXCI!CLCCU HSCJ uLU IC OICI IICC
[UUyCS !L CLO hHL!C!u LOUII. h IVO HOSI ICCCLI |IUCIS !L VuI SOUU C u S!HC IIuJC
C!IuI!OL CuSC uIC SCJ-CXuLuIOI uLU uIC !LCUUCU, IOyCICI V!I CO!CS OJ HuSS!VC UOCUHCLIS
hI. LOUyL uS JuX-HCU IO OUI COUII L I!S CuSC. /UU!O ICCOIU!LyS OJ IVO OJ H CuI!LyS !L
I!S HuIICI uIC uSO !LCUUCU. C !uCU IO uCuI !OI IC SCCOLU OLC I!S uSI hOLUu.
uVC uLOICI IIuJ1IC CuSC CLU!Ly IIu V!I H IuI VuS IC-uSS!yLCU IO HC uSCU OL OU!
CuIIHCLI 1)UUyC C!Ly OUI JOI SUIyCI. VC uVC HUI!C uUUICSSCS JOI hI. LOUyL uLU
CuL! SCCH IO O\uIC H CIVCCL CuSCS VCI CuS!. VC uIC SCIILy IuI CuSC JOI II!u uLU
uIICHI!Ly IO SCIVC !H uI IC HOSI ICCCLI uUUICSS VC uVC (14?? . '

I. #?,CLO `N 81?).
uIlOUy CuIU IOUu lC Hu C V!Ly !L IS VC!CC SOHCVCIC. VC UO uVC uL uUUICSS JOI
l!S HOIC!, OVCVC!, H SC !CCCLI! OSICU 3!I O u HLC OI l!H.
JIu_. !0B OVu!u. !CmIC:\ -, uU . CC L `. LOuy!!H 3'C uSI CuI !Lul iS L(V
OL u|0 O C C.OI J\U.!3! !!I.! \OU!!. JLuy. !!' 'd|uC:. CjJI!UCi ., uSO luS o
Hu!ICI CUIICI! CLU!Iy iL !S UII V! h!. LULI uS!. uC.10U!. V CI.CSCu SCUt
COICS OJ UOCUHCL!S !IOH IOSC HuIICIS, lL IOLOOytu UluCIq SIU |CuS I u.u! IO
UCHOLSIIuIC IuI C !S qU!CK\ UCCOHtLSuILy IL !S HCL!u SIu!US. |I 5luJ u!5O HuUC UU
SOHC uUUIO IuCS O LOUyL CuI!LyS !L CuIIHCLIS . uHU 4SO OU CuL CuI !OI OUISCJ OV
IH!S uIIOHC uCIS !L COUII. `OU C3L SCC !S CuV!O! !L H IIuJC C!IuI!OL CuSC UOCS LO! u|CuI '
lC L iSOuICu !HL!O.L!
l. lCX l. H<tu. ` Y-1 P l ^ou:n hi:rru frcct. Hcno, " hVD1
1tlcunt. b.+-`1V'+ uf51m: *-J.+-.^1+
AOU V! IC JU uLU IC OJ
hUH!C!u |OUII !L OUI UISU!I OJ hI. |OUy!!L uS OS!I!OHCU !LSCJ uS u
!I!yuLI !L OUI COUII. uLIuyOL!Z!Ly IC uHU CVCL OUI jru lemj OL IC HOSI
uLU H!SUCHCuLOI HuIICIS. UO I!HK I!S !S u CuSC OJ SOHC uHU
uOOy!ZC IuK!Hy IVO UuS IO I!S IO OU, OUI J CISOL VuS ! uLU COUU LOI
HuKC IC CO!CS OJ IC uUU!OS OJ hI. |OUy!LS CuI!HyS UHI!! IOUu, uLU JC!I !I VuS !HOIIuLI
IuI IlC uUU!OS !HCUUCU !L IC HuICI!uS IO C COLS!UCICU IC IuIC uI. |L !CIUuI !7,
!01 hI. |OUy!L IO!U HC VuS IuCI!C!Ly uV uLU uU uO!LIHCLIS V!I C!!CLIS.
UO LOI KHOV !J IuI VuS IIUC, UI !J SO, C COUU C CuUS!Hy SCI!OUS uIL IO IC IuCI!CC OJ uV !L
`OIICD `CVuUu uLU COUU C [COuIU!Z!Ly SOHCOHCS JICCUOH OI IOCII !LICICSIS.
!CuSC COLIuCI HC !J OU LCCU uL OIlCI !LJOIHuI!OL. h U!ICCI !LC !S 77-JJ4-J8!JuLU
L CC!! OLC !S 77-!0-0JJ0(LOI ID!U!!C U!SSCH!LuI!OH). h CHu! !S
h JUU!C!u .SS!SIuLI !S huI!L JOyLOH! uLU SlC CuL ICuC LC uI uL I!HC.
JJ4-J8!!uLU CI CHu! !S
JuHK I+I OUI uIICLI!OH IO Il!S HuIICI.
IIU,
b.
I1111
0-1J-2009.09.2J.4dPN
OOY.
1 LL|h. ib
LH DC LDUI
4
2

1 I| PNY |IVIbILO
8 L JML bhLLO| )L|ILIP |JKIL LLLKJ L JML bJPJL L OLVP|P
V U^LLK L LLIY L YPbHLL

PbMWO )LMI,
12 L8C OO. |V0J!J
Vb.
|CQ! OO !+
4
MPKJI |LbMI,
|CtCnOu!/ LOun!CtOmn!.

LHLLHPILH1HP
11
^ LOmQtn! tOt |VOtCC W8 ttCO Oy PbWIO ]!MI [hCtCnt!Ct N.)O8h], Oy
18
nO !htOug ht8 !tOtnCy, )LMO . bKOLLPJL, E. On )u!y d, 2JJ. Pn PmWCt nO
1V
LOun!CtC!m W8 tCO Oy MPK1 ]LMI [hCtCtnUt `W.)O8h], Oy nO !htOu_h hCt
2
t!OOCy Ot tCCOtO, ZPLMPKY b. LLLLMIIO, L.,On |uIy 1d, 2Jd. Pr_umCnt Ws
2
htO On NtCh J2, 2J nO NtCh 7,2JJJ. N.)O8ht W8 QtC8Cn! nO tCQtCn!CO Oy
<
|Ohn . nO W. Ws nO
Z
3 .
14
t^LLbLtAL
2 . JhC Qr!:C8WCrCU 0Ny 11, n bOmDy, lnd.
JCQt!C8hVC !WOchIdrC, OOUO!WhOmarCnOW duIu.
4
PI!hOughNr. YOsD nOOOIga!On!O8uQQr!8adchdrCn IOngCr
punun!!OPK.1U(V)(O),N. O8hirCquC8!8!hC!nncaIa888!ancC O!Nr. O8h 8O
a8!OQrOVdC!Or dC ch!IdrCn8 cOnunuing Cduc!On. (1n8WCr, Qg. Z,InC8Ub).
CLOur! nO!C8!ha!OnPu_8!1,Z,Nr.]O8h!UCd 'NOuOnOrKC!uCL!
!C8OnaI !rOQCr!y rCquC8ung!ha!N8.]O8hrC!uOD Qa88QOr!, _CCncrdnd8OaI
V 8Ccur!ycard. Ln Pugu8!,Ub,N8.|O8m, Oyand!hrOughhCra!!OtCyO!roOrd,
10 N. LOu_In,!ICd anLQQO8!On !O!hCrC!urnO!Nr.]O8D8 Qa88QOr! c!ngcasIaW
11 nVOIVngmnOrchIdrCnand dCr8uQQOr!. N8.YO8hI!ICd8adOQQO8uOnWhIC
12 cKnOWICdgng!hCQar!ech:IdrCnWCrCOO!hOVCrC_!CCn yCr8O!agCa!!hC!mC. L
13 Pugu8!b,Ub, ]udgC>humachCrOrdCrCdN8.|O8h!O u Cda!CIyrC!uCNr.]O8h'8
QQOr!WUD!VCdy8.
1 J. JhCrC8cOmmuni!yQrOQCr!y!O D dVOcd.
1 lnNr. ]O8h8 LOmQIan!!ICd|uIyb,Ud,hC mdca!Cd!hCrCWa8cOmmun!!y
1 QnQCr[anddCO!8Whch8hOuIdDdVdCdOymCLOur!.
1 N8.|O8h!ICdmPn8WCranOLOun!CnIamOn]uyb,Ub,ndcaung!hC
1V QruC8 cOmmum!y QrOQCrj8hOuIdD Cqu!aOIydVOCd,nIudngN8.]O8h8
20 WOmCn8WCaI!h, !hC VChcIeUCchQar!y8QO888On,!hC VChicIemdCrchIdrCn8
2J QO On, nd!hCmOnCydC[N8. YO8h:] CmnCdWhICWOrK:ng!Or!CgCndmy!uXury
WhchWa8au!OmaucaIIy OCQO8!Cd n [Nr.O8h8j
[Nr.
1
|Oh. N.|O5h 5l!CU Ul hC WOuU COH!Cl D5 DUVU, WhO uy hVC 5OmC O UC
Z QtOQCtQ, DU U mmPIlC tCU hN.|O5hI.
O. wt. |Oh DUOUuCCU Ul lhC HCC
4 OH hI5 0uLhCVtOCl ZCt 5 $b,0J.7b 5 O wtCh , UV. [t LXhIOl ^), HU
tCCy uC OOk VuC Ot lhC ZCt 5 $0,V0[LXhOl ). JhCtCOtC, UCCl OlhC
mOuDl O jjtOXuwy $,J00.UCX5!5 OD lhC VChCC. ^l UC COHCu5OD O U8,w".
7 |O5hI tCQuC5!CU lhl hC D WtUCU lhC \CVtOCl ZCt.
w5. |O5hI jtC5CDlCU HO CVUCDCC OD U5 I55uC. JO lhC LOutl5 kDOWCU_C, N.
V |O5h CODUuClCU DO U5COVCqOD lhI5 55uC
1 C. VChICC 1hCtC W5 HO CVUCDCC IDUOUuC tC_tUID_ UC
11 VuC O w5. |O5h`5 Ct.
1Z U OD'5 VChCC wt. |O5DJ lUlICU lhl h5 Uul 5OD 5 jtC5HUy
UtVD_ UC |CCQ LtDU LhCtOk0 DU 5 ukID_ lhC QyuCD!5 Ot lhC Ct UtOUy lO lhC
14 CHUCt, LCt blt HHCI. Olh jtlC5 lC5lCU lhl w5. |O5h DU lhC jtUC5 5OH tC
1O HM0 OH lhC llC. O CVUCDCC W5 jtC5CHlCU tC_tUD_ lhC ODCC OWCU OD lhC |Cj
1 LtDU LhCtOkCC.
17 w5. |O5h QtC5CDlCU DO CVUCDCC OD lhI5 SuC. JO lhC LOut!5 kOWCU_C,
1 w5. |O5h CODUuC!CU HO U5COVCty OD lhi5 55uC.
1V C. VChCC N.|O5h U5UCU !hl lhC QtlC5 Uul
Z Uu_hlCt OVC5 DU ukC5 QyuCDl5 OH lhC ODU ^CCOtU DU lhl lIlC uhCU D lhC
Z1 HmC O Ulh wt. |O5h DU lhC Qt!C5` Uu_hlCt.
w5. lC5UH0 lhl mUC $,000.00OD htt
1V
C " Nt. |OSDI lCS!IlICU l l DC UIU HOl KHOW
Z UhS. |OSDIS COH_S ltOU JHZ0I WCtC QCCU LOHUOH DHK CCOuHl. N.|OSDI
DC UIU HOl COHU hS. |OSm S DOHCy l Ul UUC.
4 hS. |CSDI QteCHlCU HO CVIUCHCC Ul DCt wCtC QCCU :H LOHUOH D
CCOuHl. JO lDC LOutlS KHOwCU_, NS. |OSD: COHUuClCU HO UISOVCty OH lDIS WSuC.
l. HK PCCOuHU - hS. ]OSD1 lCSUCU Ul SDC tCQuCSlC
COS lO lDC UDCCOuHlS ltOU ht. ]OSD:, Dul lDl DC WOuU HOl Cl DrSCC lDC DHK
8 SllCUCHU. !ut\DCt, hS. |OSD: lCSUCU lDl SDC U:U DVC DCt OWH CtCUIl HU SDC UIU DVC
V CCCSS lO ht. |OSDIS CtCU:l CtU SmlCUCHlS.
1 JDCtC WS HO lutCt CV:UCHCC QtCSCHlCU S lO lDC COUDuHI!y DnK CCOuHlS.
11 1. JCtC IS COUUuHIty UCD! lO DC U:V:UCU.
2 JDC LOutl HOlCS lDC lOOWIH_ :HOtUl!OH DS DCCH QtOV!UCU HU DS DCH lKCH
13 IHlO COHSIUCtl:OH OH UISSuC.
14 . \CHCt LtCUIl LtU CDl * Pt. ]oshlCSllCU lDl DC OWCS
1 apprOximateIybb,bU incrcditltdUCDl [tI3 tD:l `L), andargedthcCH3t_CS
1O w0C JHCuttCU lOt CODUuHIty CXQCHSCS, DOIUyS, lD:y CXQCHSCS HU DOuSCDOU
l1 CQCHSCS.
18 NS. |OSDI QtCSHlCU HO CVIUCHCC tC_tU:H_ COuuH:ly CtCU:l CtU UCDl.
D. CSl LtU LCDl Nt. |OSD: SllCU lDl C Qtl:CS
Z QutCDSCU CODQulCt HU T.V. l CSl uy lOt QQtOID!Cy $iJi1.0. N.]oh
Z1 uUlICU N. |OSDI DS lD Ol IlCUS
ZZ |OSDJ DC WtUCU lDC COUQulCt IH hS.
Z me TV
<4
N$. |O$h
DO OD !h$ UC !Out!$ KuOWCU_C, N$.
Z CODUuC!CU DO U!$COVCry OD !h$
3 U. - !hCtC tC O UCOU OWD_ I O DCDt$ Ot OD
4 h! O! !D!y mCmOCt$ !h! WCtC QtCCD!CU ! !rt.
Nt. |O$D D!tOUuCCU CVtUCDCC ! U tC_tUD_ $b,UU.UUCO! !O KOU DU
NCC OWCt [t LhtO! !] tD !hC !Otm O! !C!!Ct DOD KOU DU NCCD OWCt.
7 hC CUCt $!!C$ !h! !hC Qt!tC$ OWC DODCy U!hC DOuD! O! $,UU.U,WhtCh W$ OD_
8 OVCtUuC Oy QQtOtD!Cy $t [ yCt$, !Ot DODCy ODCU !O Nt. |O$h!`$ DOUCt WhCD
9 $hC W$ !. hC C!lCt D!CtCDCC$ COQy O! yOut C!!Ct _CD_ !O Qy u$ OCK, Ou! UtU
10 DO! lICh COQy O! $tU C!!Ct. P! !t, Nt. |O$h! !C$!!CU !h! hC UU DO! hVC COQy O!
1 1 UC tC!CtCDCCU CUCt. N$. |O$h !C$!!CU !h! !h$ UCO! W$ mUC uQ.
J2 Nt. |O$h !C$U!CU tC_tUtD_ UCO! O! QQtOm!Cy $b,UUOWtD_ !O !mty
13 mCDOCt Oy !hC DDC O! P$htK DOy {$Q`], !Ot OuyD_ QDC !CkCU !Ot !hC |O$h !mt!y
14 !O COmC !O !hC LDtV$ bl!C$ D J. N$. |O$h !C$!I!CU !h! $hC COuU DO! OOtD Dy
15 D!Otm!OD tC_tUtD_ !h$ UCO! $ !hC OUCt Qt!y WD!CU !O $!y Ou! O! UC UtVOtCC.
1 P! ltt, Nt. |O$ht OUCtCU !O Qy UC$C COmDuD!y UCOU.
17 C. ICDCt CO! - Nt. |O$D !C$!!!tCU !h! hC Qy$
J8 QptOnhy $ QCt mOD!h !Ot COmDuD!y UCOU, CCuUD_ h$ Ct DU tDSutuCC.
19 N.|O$ht QtC$CD!CU DO CVtUCDCC r_tUtD_ _CCt CODuD!y UCO!.
20 Nt. |O$h O!!CtCU !O Qy !hC COmmuD!y UCO! D h$ DmC !h! hC DU CD QyD_
Z1 nU !kC u uDCqu UtV$OD O! COmDuDt!y UCO!.
b. N$. |O$h $uQQOtt
Z O
Z
PQtCn!y
N.)O8hI 8 O h8
!O !hC Lnt!CO 8
)OhI
4 8hC h8 tt8CO UC ChtOtCn nd !hCtCOy
OQQOttun!tC8 nO h8 Qu! hCt dtCm8
O Nt. )O8h !O!tlCO hC u h_h 8hOO _Ou!C. Nt. )O8h u CmQOyCd 8 C!Ctn_
1 mn_Ct. !n 20 Nt. )Oh CDCd QQtOIm!Cly b1,OJ.JJ WhilC WOtKIn_ tOt tO
COmQnIC8 - PmCtICn t nd KO!utn! nd bICO bQOt! >tVCC. P! UIl, N. )O8hI
9 nUOOuCCd h8 Y- DOm PmCDC t nO KC8!Utn! tCHCCtn_ CD_8 Ot >,1O/.
T [t hO! L], nO DY- DOm bCtt bQt! bCtv|CC n UC Oun! Ot >/,J.1d
JJ [t hIOt! L]. N.)O8ht !C8!ItCd !h! Ou8InC88 t8 8OW nO hC t8 QtC8Cn!y wOtKtn_
J2 tOt Only OnC COmQny - PmCtCn t nd C8!utn!. Nt. )O8ht !OUlICO hC h8 Ony twO
1 WCCK8 Ot WOtK 8ChCOuCd IOt NtCh, J, nO hC ttCd tOt unCmQOymCn! OCnCIU In
14 NtCh,J
1 Nt. )O8ht tCQuO!CO !hC LOutt COn8IOCt ht8 nC! InCOmC t!Ct dCduC!In_ !C8, tC!Ot
JO m !hC QtC8Cn! 5 QCt mOn!h hC t8 QtC8CUy Qyn_ tOt COmmunt!y OCO!, nd 8C! Ott ny
J1 ImOny tC8QOn8tO:ty Oy h8 88UmQUOn OI unCQu Ot8UtOu!tOn OI COmmUn1!y dCO!.
J 1utUCt, !O QtO!CC! N.)O8h| tn UC CVCn! Nt. )O8ht tlCd tOt OnKtuQ!Cy, Nt. )O8ht
J9 8u@C8!CO !h! !hC COut! mIn!m utt8ICOn OVCt !hC t88uC Ot 8QOu8 8uQQO! tOt VC
N.)O8ht tCQuC8U tC8OnOC t!ODCy8 OC QId !O Y8hOC
tCQUO!8
J3
J
LOL!OOCt Z,|uU_C|OtUOQt0IUCU OVCt !DC QtHC$' wm_CDCOl
2 LODCt6C. /lUl D0tO_ UCQtUCSWCtCuOOC lOtCCD $C!!CDCO!. utUCt, OO
3 NtCD Z, |uU_C tUOCtCOOUuClCU !CDCO!LOHlCtCOCClOtQQtOXIUlCyOOC
4 U OOC-Dl DOut$, QtIOt lO$!DIO_lDC U lQQtOXIU!Cy.UQD. C UIU
OO! OO$CltCD<l OU !tIW$ COUUCOCCU.
lHDI$CO$IO_t_uUCOl !U1, wt.LOu_DIO, OOOCDl Olw$.|O$DI,$llCUU!DC
UIUOOluOUCt$lOUDUCOuU OOl_tCCWIUCQuIZ1O_ UCO!WDCO OOC Qt!yCOUCUuQ
WIlD DCCt Ct. C$llCU lDlDCDUCtuOCDCUlDC OuDOCt$ OU COuUOO!$CC!!lDC
9 OUCtWy. Nt. LOu_DIO CIlCUO/LhtlICCtC_tU1H_COUDuOI]UCOlOU$!!CU DI$
1 C6lUO$ OOl DVCDuCD lOtlDCCCUI!Ot$lO LC. CtCQuC$lCUUl DI$C!COl $$uDC
J J OOC-DUlDCCOUDuOIlyUCO!OUlDllDCLOut!lIOUDlIl$ !WO$,0UCOblOlDIy
lZ DCDDDOUltICOU$$wt.|O$DI`$$CQtlCUCOl$. wt.LOu_DtO$l!CUDI$CICO!I$DIO_
$kCUlOlOOllDCOIlOtIO!Il$UCOl$OUtClCtCOCCUUlN$.|O$DII$ CtIO_OU
J4 COUD1llCU DOlDCt.
wt.|O$DI !C$lIl!CUlDlDCDUQIUwt. QtIO__lC$,U0.00$IOCC|uy,2UUH,
J lOt !!OOCy$ lU$OUCO$l$.
1 Nt.|O$DI tCQuC$!CUlDl N. LOu_DIOQCt$OD!!yQyDI$ l!OOCy`$ lCC$lOt+.JO
1 DOut$Ol!tI lUCt!C Ol bZZb QCtDOutQut$uH! !O h.0bb. wt.OQtIO__!C!C$UICU
J9 N.LOu_DIHDU OO!COOUuClCUOyUI$COVCty,DUQtOUuCCUOOCVIUCHCCtC_UID_
Z w$.|O$D$COUUuOI|UCOU OlDCtlDODCt IDOCI CCtUOO OODC, DUQt0COlCU
2J OOCVIUCOCCtC_tUIO_1DOOy,HUDUClCUIOVCX!IOu$OUuOtC$OHOCDOOCt
Z IO N$.|O$DI iO!D$UIVOtCCQtOCCCUIO_.
?
4 1
J3
23
Uchld rcachcsH OfacuhcsnOlOncr nhh
2 whcnhc v Of
D bcnnOcvdcnccprccntcd ]Oshjust|fyngarcguct
4 coununsuppOrtOfthcparte' adultchldrcn. thcrc IcnnOlca|
5 prcntcdtOmkcsuchandngthcCOurtdcn|csMs.]Osh'srcgucstthatN.]Osh
LnancallyprOv|dcfOrthcadu|tchildrcn'scducatOn.
2.
8 IursuantUZb.bU[)(b)andu!kHn0nU. u!!O0n, JPcv., vJv I.Zd
9 U17(7),nrnt|nad|vOrcc,mcCOutshmlesurc cgua|d|spOshOnOfthc
1 cOmmun|tycstatc, absmtcOmpcl|nrcasOnsjusbfy|nanuncgua|d|sbbut|On.1hc
1 COurtmustmakcwr|ttendinsastOwhysuchadvisiOnisapprOpriatc.
J2 a. WOmcn'sW=|m- 1hcpartcshavcarccdthatthcpartcs'
cOmmuntyntcrcsminthcwOmcnswca|th blOnscntrc|ytOMs.]OshaccOrdn|O
4 |hcrcustOmarybl|cfs,andthcrcbyshOuldbcdcc|arcdhcrsOlcandscparahprOpcr|y
1 Assuch, Nr.]Oshi s Ordcrc tOcOntactanyanda|lrclativcswhOmayhavcth|sprOpcrty
J andmmcdatc|yrctumsadprOpcr|tOMs.]OshassOOnaspOss|blc.
1 b. N. Vch|c|c- 1hc20bChcvrO|ctb|azmsh|| cOn|dcrcd
J8 N.]Osh'ssO|cmdscparatcprOpcrty. N. ]Oshshall rcspOns|blcfOrthcdcbt
lU rcma|n|n mcrcOn. AsmccW wOrm$U,vU.0butthcrc|s$b,U0v.7bducandOw|n
20 Onsmd car, thcCOurtwllcOnsidcrMr.]OshsassumpbOnOf thsassctas undcrtakin
2J cOmmun|tydcbtOf apprOximatcly$1,UU.0.
Z c Ms. carshallbe hcr and
T4
C. OHy OH !hS SuC W3S
Z Q3tUCS 3Uul U3u_hlCt US C3t u3kCS Q3yuCHlS lhCtCOH. PS.
Ol 3 D33HCC OH lhC C3t Ot l3t u3tkCl V3uC.
4 lh5 C3t W HOl D U!VUCU 0 3 CODuuDly 3S5Cl.
l. - lhCtC W35 HO CVUCHCC QtCSCHlCU lO lhC
b LOutl S3d D3 3CCOuHl CSlS. FS SuCh, S HO l3Clu3 D3SS lO SuQQOtl
7 OtUCt dVUH_ l 3S 3 COuDuHQ 3SSCl.
3HK /CCOuHL - lhCtC W3S HO CVUCHCC QSCHlCU 3S lO
9 lhC CSlCHCC Ol CODuHly D3Hk 3CCOuHlS. FS SuCh, lhCtC S HO l3Clu3 D3SS SuQQOtl
10 3H OtUCt UVUH_ l 3S 3 CODuHly 3SSCl.
T T h. - Pt. |OSh S 3W3tUCU UC COuQulCt QutCh0Cd 3l CSl
17 uy. PS. |OSD Sh3 UCIVCt S3U COuQulCt lO Pt. bQDH__3lCS OllCC OH Ot DC|OtC tU3y,
J3 FQtJ, Z, 3l J.Qu.
\ " w.|OSh S 3W3tUCU lhC lCCVSOH QutCh3SCU 3l CSl
1D uy. l S lhC LOutlS uHUCtSUHUH_ lDS lCCV5OH 5 CuttCHUy !H P5. |OShS QOS5CSSOH.
lb
I
LCHCt3 LtCdl L3tU CDl - JhC CVUCHCC QtCSCHlCU HUC3lCS 3
J7 _6Ct3 UCDl Ol 3QQtOu3lCy OJ, . WhCh h3S be CQCHUCU lOt COuDuHly
1 " QUtQOSCS.
J9 Pt. |OSh 3_CU lO DC tC5QHSDC lOt lhS UCDl 3l O3. /S SuCh, Pt. |O5h Sh3 b
Z 5Cy 3HU 5CQ3t3lCy tC5QODDC lOt lhS dCDl.
1 K. JhC CVUCHCC HU|C3lCS
iS 3 UCDl Ol 3QQtOH3lCy Oull3HU|H_ lOt
l /S
egualized, In
As Mr. ]oshI has ouered to pay mese debt, he shall
2 solely and separauly responIble for th payment of $,7J.0to 5t.Mary's
3 and $0.0to Rema
4 m. Debt - There was no doumenm presented as to
me debt owIng to AshIk ^anaby (sp7) for buying plane tIckets for the ]oshI famly.
b urther, as me ony evIdence provIded regardIng me $,00.00debt to Rod and Meen
Fowler IndIcates saId debt was Incmred for the benefIt of Mr. |oshI's mother. As
Mr. ]oshi has agreed to mke on both of these debL, they shah henceforth be his sole and
9 separa responsibity.
10 n. General Debt - There was no evIdence other than
J J tesumonial evIdence to establIsh communIty debL. As w.]oshI has offered to pay any
12 remaIning commumty debt in his name dat Is hereafter ouLtandIng saId debt shall be
J3 the sole and separate responsIbIlIty of Mr. ]oshi.
14 The Court notes N.]oshI has lIkely Incurred an unegual distrIbutIon of me
1 communIty debt In thIs case. The Court hnds hIs teumonial acguIescence at nal to take
1b on this debt Is a compellIng reason to make an ungua| dIstrbutIon of the comunIty
17 debl
l J
19 The smtutory mandate for alimony is mt It b ]ust and eguItable.
20 !?.15(!)(a). AlImony Is an uItable award to serve the poslecree needs and
21 rIghL of the former spouse. !!2 Mev. 2 P.2d !6 (!). Although
22 pot-decree income need not
O
1
!ursuant IKb !25.!50(8), mere are (!!) me court shal| consider in
7 awarding
w. |ohi presented no in support oI her reguest Ior alimony omer than
4 her own testimona| that she raued me had
educahonal opportuniues, and put her dreams on hold while married. w.|oshi ttiIied
tht she is healthy and D always worked. 1here was no to any oI th
7 Iactors in IK5 !?.!50(8) in Ms. |oshi's presentation and in support oI an
8 awmd oI spousal support.
V 1he Court IinOs that the parti prendy ea approimately the same amount,
10 Ms. |oshi eam $2,458 per monm and N. |ohi eaned approximate|y $J,!25 Qmonth
1 1 in , but teshIied he i s working subsmntia|ly less i n 2O and has Iued Ior
1Z unemployment benmits the bgnning oI March 200. lK5 !25.!50(8)(a) 1e
pardes have been mared 2! yeam and Ns. |oshi has always been employo dunn that
14 hme. lK5 !25.!50(8)(d) . Ms. |oshi obtained a collee degree prior to mrriae and
15 Mr. ]os has a hh school degee. lK5 !25.!50(8)(h)). Both parues are healthy and
1 able to work. IK5 !?.!50(8)(k)).
17 Based upon the evidence presented and the applicable law, this Court dos not
1D blieve w.|osh is entitled to an award oI alimony.
1V 4. !ees
7 1hs Court en|oys disceuon to award attomey `5 Iees in a divorce acuon.
7 lKb !?.!50(J); !!4 lev. 5 !.Zd 52 (!8).) pursuant to
77 lK5 !8.0!0(2)(b), the court D aumori to order

D
DlOtC COutl lDI$ C COutl $D tCuItC C llOOCy QCt5ODy lO lDC
7 HU !lOOCy$ IHCuttCU
COHUuCl.
Pl UI, wt. bQtIH__lC lDl ^. LOu_DIH DU COHUuClCU HO
UCC. UUUIUOH, ^. LOu_DIH lICU QtC$CHl OHC UOuDCHlty QICCC
D l UI OH DCD Ol N$. |O$DI`$ CID$. ^.LOu_hIH t_uCU IHCC5Hly WIU UC LOutl
1 lDtOu_DOul UI HU UUC $tCSlIC, UCtO_lOty tCUtK$ lO !DC LOutl, Nt. bQtIj_lC,
HU ht. |O$DI lDtOu_DOul ltI.
V JC LOutl HOlC$ lDl UCtC WCtC WC OVCt +OD]6lIOHS UutIH_ lOut [4) DOutS O
D wt. bQtu__lC`$ ODjCClIOH$ WCtC WC-lOuHUCU HU COHluuOu$y $u$lIHCU CXCCQl
J J IH OHC IHSlHCC. wt. LOu_hIH W OVCttuCU OH CVCty ODjCClIOH CXCCQl OHC mU t_CU
7 WIlD lDC LOutl OVCt DO$l tuIH_$. wt. LOu_DIH W$ UDOHmDCU QQtOXIUlCy !5 lIDC$
1 Dy lDC LOutl lO QuIl tguIH_ lO $K $QCCIlIC quC$lIODS, lO UI$COHlIHuC $KIH_ quC$lIOHS
CIH_ lOt C_ COHCuSIOH, HU lO tCltIH HU DKIH_ UC_tUIH_ tCDtK$ lO DOU N.
|O$DI HU wt. bQtIH__lC.
D JC LOutl HOlC$ Ul l OHC QOIHl, ulCt H CXDIDIl DU DCCH UmIllCU,
Nt. LOu_DIH CODU HOl mOlDC COQy QtOVIUCU Dy wt. bQtIH__lC IH UI$COVCty. Nt.
LOu_D!IH UCDHUCU COQy DC QtOVIUCU l !tI, $l!IH_ U l$uQQOSCU lO tUJH_
1V lDtOu_D Dy QQCt$ wy uHUCtSlHUIH_ P!Dl yOu tC $uQQO$CU D QtOVIUC COQy.
7 YDCH $KCU DC DU lDC COQy O lDC UOCuDCHl, Nt. LOu_DIH $\lCU, UO HOl KHOW.
7 COuU $QCHU Dy !DC HU DCHl CHCt_ OOKH_ tOuHU Ot Nt. bQtH_glC$ UOuUCHl
/ IKC U Ot WC COuU Nt. lO QtOVIUC l lIUC $
5llC. wt.
wt. LOu_h!ID CU D ^u5WCt DU OD w5. Uh
7 IDCuUCU uD5ujjOtUU DU HCU d LjjO5IIIOD !O Ot
3 tC!uO O N.]O5D5 W!hOu! Dy Ot ut!hCt, ! wt.
LOu_hD uO5! DO CVIUCDCC !O 5ujjOt! N.|O5hI5 tCQuC5!5 U CmU.
5 hC uO5! UOuOID_ 5jC! O !hI5 C$ W5 w.LOugID`5 tuUC, 5D5UC DU
UIStUp jtC$DmDOD ! hI, wt. LOu_hID5 IDOI!!y !O uDUCt5!DU
! h5 IutC !O CODUuC! UI5COVCty, DU DCk O kDOWCU_C WI!h !O !hC tuC5 O
8 uUCCC DU hI jtOCCUutC. ^ O !H5 W5 COujOuDUCU W!h CODDDuOu5y
V Dm_ODISIC jtC5CDmUOD O UC C5C U! t6u!CU U 5hI! tOu Ity 5iujC UIVOtCC
10 C5 !O COD!CDUOu5 UIVOtCC !tI 0UD_ D CXCC55IVC uOuD! O UuC.
11 Ot UC5C tC5OD, !hC LOut! DU5 U! wt. LOu_hID5 jtC5CDmIiOD O UC C$
TZ DU tguCDU ID 5ujjOt! UCtCO !O DC uDOuDUCU ID C!, uDWFDUU Dy CI5UD_ W,
13 uDtCSODDC, DU VCXDOu5 UOu_hOu! !hI5 CD!tC jtOCCCUiD_.
T4 D5CU ujOD !DC OtC_CID_, wt. DjtID__IC5 tCQuC5! !h! ^t. LOu_DID jCt5ODy
1b Qy N.]OSh 4.15 hOut5 ! UC t!C O $25 jCt hOut Ot !hC CO5! O !hC !tI I5 LJI.
1 . LOu_hD 5h 5uDu! ChCk !O wt. |O5h u IhC uOuD! O $34 WI!hID 30 Uy5 O
1! !h5 LtUCt.
18 5. O UC ICC-
19 wt. DjtiD__!C 5D jtCjtC !hC UCtC O UIVOtCC COD5I5!CD! WI!h !hI5
Z u0OtDUuu UCC5IOD. wt. DjtD@w 5h !CDUCt hI5 jtOjO5CU UCCtCC !O wt.
Z1 LOu_hID, jut5uD! !O WR WI!hD 20 Uy5 tOu !hC U!C O !H5 OtUC.
lLLLALbLALAH1NL,111bbLLHILHL.
Z ^ jti
<
=
LtH11tLA1tL1NA1LML
Z to 5(b), I tht I an
3 Court, tht on me day ot ApH, 2O, I hled me foregoin
4 wth the Clerk t!e which wll snd a ling to the
tollowing:

7 Document CRDER ATER TRIAL

8
]OHN I. 5IR!!GGATE E
V
ZACHARY . CCUGHLIM F
1
1
17
13
14
1
1
T7
18
1V
7
21
22
23
24
Zach Coughlin
PO BOX 60952, RENO, NV, 89506
Nevada Bar No 9!"#
$el ""5 ##8 8%%8
&a' 9!9 66" "!02
ZachCoughlin(ho$)ail*co)
+,,N Reno -unici.al Cour$ /udge0, 1onna Ballard, Chie& -ar0hal /u0$in Ro.er, 2iling O&&ice
Per0onnel, and Cour$ +d)ini0$ra$or Ca00andra /ac30on
re %% CR 22%"6, %% cr 26!05, %% ,R 26800, and an4 o$her ca0e0 5herein Zach Coughlin i0 a na)ed
.ar$4 or o$her ad)in0$ra$ive &ile0 involving $he 0a)e*
&a'ed $o ""5 ##! #82!
-arch 26$h, 20%2
1ear Reno -unici.al Cour$ /udge0, 2iling O&&ice Per0onnel, and +d)ini0$ra$or0,

Plea0e no$e )4 ne5 addre00* 6 5a0 recen$l4 $5ice ad7udge a vic$i) o& do)e0$ic violence in 2V%28
00%88 and 2V%2800%8"* 2ur$her, /udge Na0h 9ol)e0 ha0 co).ounded $he di&&icul$ie0 in )ain$aining
)4 0a&e$4 :4 con&i0ca$ing :o$h o& )4 cellular .hone0, 5hich 5ere nece00ar4 $o )4 de&en0e in a recen$
hearing on a -o$ion &or Order $o ;ho5 Cau0e :e&ore /udge 2lanagan in 1e.ar$)en$ ", in $he a..eal o&
$he evic$ion )a$$er $ha$ Richard <* 9ill, E0=*, i0 o..o0ing coun0el on* /udge 2lanagan denied -r*
9ill>0 -o$ion $oda4* 6 have &iled a -o$ion &or Re$urn o& $ho0e i$e)0 o& .er0onal .ro.er$4 $hough 6 have
received no re0.on0e in $ha$ regard or o..o0i$ion ?$hough $he $a).ering 5i$h )4 )ail )a4 have .la4ed
0o)e role in an4 dela4 inciden$ $o $he deliver4 o& an4$hing in $ha$ regard@* 6nciden$ $o $he0e do)e0$ic
violence a$$ac30 $ha$ 6 have :een vic$i)iAed :4 ha0 :een $a).ering 5i$h and di&&icul$ie0 in ge$$ing )4
)ail* 6 a03 $ha$ 4ou co.4 )e via &a' and e)ail on all corre0.ondence0, &iling0, co))unica$ion0 5i$h
$he ;$a$e Bar or o$her govern)en$al agencie0, e$c*, un$il $he .ro:le)0 a00ocia$ed 5i$h $he deliver4 o&
)4 B;P; )ail are re0olved*
Ca0$ 5ee3 6 vi0i$ed $he &iling o&&ice coun$er o& $he R-C and had a civiliAed di0cu00ion 5i$h 2iling
O&&icer ;u.ervi0or 1onna Ballard and 2ron$ Coun$er Cler3, 1aniel* 9o5ever, a..aren$l4 co).le$el4
un.rovo3ed, $5o Ci$4 o& Reno -ar0hal, -ar0hal Co..a and -ar0hal ,ho)0.0on 0$or)ed over and
de)anded $ha$ 6 leave a$ once 5hile 1aniel 5a0 0ee3ing clari&ica$ion &ro) -0* Ballard on a .oin$*
2ur$her, $he audio o& $he ,rial 6 order in %% ,R 26800 i0 0$ill no$ read4, according $o -0* Ballard,
5ho) 5a0 una:le $o $ell )e i& an4 record e'i0$0 o& )4 ever )a3ing a re=ue0$ &or 0uch in $he &ir0$ .lace*
+ddi$ionall4, -0* Ballard indica$ed a co).le$e lac3 o& concern &or $he &ac$ $ha$ $he )a$erial0 6 &iled :4
e)ail :e$5een %%D29D%% and %2D%6D%2 ?a&$er receiving her e'.re00 .er)i00ion $o 0o &ile :4 e)ail in an
a$$e).$ $o avoid over$a'ing $he R-C &a' )achine@ 5ere no$ accura$el4 re.re0en$ed in $he record on
a..eal or $he cer$i&ied co.4 o& $he doc3e$ in R-C %% CR 22%"6* 6 a) a$$aching $o $hi0 corre0.ondence
0o)e )a$erial0 $ha$ 0.ea3 $o 5ha$ a :reach o& her du$4 $ha$ i0 and a03 $ha$ a co.4 o& $hi0
corre0.ondence and $he a$$ached )a$erial0 :e .laced in her .er0onnel &ile* 2ur$her, 6 re=ue0$ $ha$ $he
0a)e :e done &or -ar0hal Co..a and -ar0hal ,ho).0on, 5ho de&iled 5i$h $heir $o$ali$arian :ehavior
la0$ 5ee3 5ha$ 0hould :e an environ)en$ 5here 7u0$ice and $ran0.arenc4 &louri0h* Ra$her, $he4 0ough$
1/2
$o cur$ail $he acce00 $o 7u0$ice, re&u0ed $o .rovide an4 rea0oning &or doing 0o, and a$$e).$ed $o &a:rica$e
a di0hone0$ accoun$ o& even$0 $ha$ da4*
Ca0$l4, i$ ha0 co)e $o )4 a$$en$ion $ha$ /udge Na0h 9ol)e0 i0 0ending $he ;$a$e Bar o& Nevada
corre0.ondence0, da$ed, #D%!D%2, 5herein 0he ci$e0 $o unna)ed E0ource0F $ha$ have here :elieving 6
)gi$h :e E0lee.ing in )4 carF* Plea0e .rovide $he na)e0 o& $ho0e 0ource0 and $he :a0i0 &or 0uch
accu0a$ion0* 6$ i0 hard $o under0$and ho5 )4 variou0 Pe$i$ion0 $o Proceed 6n 2or)a Pau.eri0 have :een
0o roundl4 denied in $he R-C, 4e$, 6 a) 0u:7ec$ $o $he0e hear0a4 accu0a$ion a0 .u:li0hed :4 /udge
Na0h 9ol)e0* 2ur$her, /udge Na0h 9ol)e>0 le$$er $o $he ;$a$e Bar o& Nevada )en$ion0 $ha$ a ca0e 5a0
$ran0&erred $o her due $o 1e.ar$)en$ % having 0urger4* 9o5ever, )4 record0 indica$e a Econ&lic$F 5a0
ci$ed a0 $he rea0oning &or 0uch a $ran0&er* 6& $he0e are $5o di&&eren$ $hing0, .lea0e .rovide 0o)e
indica$ion o& $he correc$ rea0on &or 0uch a $ran0&er ?unle00 $here i0 a )ul$i8&ace$ed ra$ionale &or 0o
$ran0&erring $he ca0e@*
On ano$her no$e), Cour$ +d)ini0$ra$or Ca00andra /ac30on 0en$ )e an e)ail 0o)e $i)e ago .ur.or$ing
$o in$er.re$ /udge 9o5ard>0 Order in %% CR 22"%6, 5here, $he Order indica$e0 $ha$ 6 a) no$ $o 0end
e)ail $o an4 R-C .er0onnel in $he con$e'$ o& $ha$ one .ar$icular ca0e* -0* /ac30on 0ee)0 $o e'$end
$ha$ Order 5here in her e)ail 0he indica$e0 $ha$ 6 a), unli3e an4 o$her ci$iAen, una:le $o u$iliAe
Reno-uniRecord0(reno*gov &or 0i).le record re=ue0$0, and 5here 0he .ur.or$0 $o e'$end $he Order $o
ca0e0 :e4ond $he 7uri0dic$ional li)i$0 a$$endan$ $o /udge 9o5ard>0 Order in %% CR 22%"6* Ou$ o&
re0.ec$ &or /udge 9o5ard, 6 have :a0icall4 &ollo5ed -0* /ac30on>0 a).li&ied Order, :u$ doing 0o ha0
crea$ed an undue :urden on )e a0 a li$igan$ in $he R-C and 6 5ri$e 0ee3ing clari&ica$ion 5i$h re0.ec$ $o
$he $rue i).or$ o& /udge 9o5ard>0 Order in $ha$ regard*
;incerel4,
Zach Coughlin, E0=*
2/2
please note my new address, SOLACE PROGRAM REQUEST?
3/!/"
Reply ?
#a$% Co&'%l(n
To )do'an*was%oe$o&nty+&s, rw%omes*was%oe$o&nty+&s, ,)osler*was%oe$o&nty+&s,
sterm(t-*s)$'lo)al+net, .'*npr(+or', ed*npr(+or', ,md*randa--a+$om, m,r*randa--a+$om,
.adl($,*reno+'o/, .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net, ,'oodn('%t*was%oe$o&nty+&s,
.stan$(l*was%oe$o&nty+&s, -yo&n'*da+was%oe$o&nty+&s, $arly+$o&'%l(n$r$*'ma(l+$om,
am*npr(+or', 'eo0'(les*%otma(l+$om, lor(w*n/)ar+or', e%e,ny*la.es+n/+'o/, (n0o*la.es+n/+'o/,
$o&'%l(n*ypl,+$om, r$ornlaw*"12+reno+n/+&s, /sane/ada*,&no+$om
3rom4
#a$% Co&'%l(n 5-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om6
Sent4
7ed 3/!/" 1438 PM
To4
)do'an*was%oe$o&nty+&s9 rw%omes*was%oe$o&nty+&s9 ,)osler*was%oe$o&nty+&s9
sterm(t-*s)$'lo)al+net9 .'*npr(+or'9 ed*npr(+or'9 ,md*randa--a+$om9 m,r*randa--a+$om9
.adl($,*reno+'o/9 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net9 ,'oodn('%t*was%oe$o&nty+&s9
.stan$(l*was%oe$o&nty+&s9 -yo&n'*da+was%oe$o&nty+&s9 $arly+$o&'%l(n$r$*'ma(l+$om9
am*npr(+or'9 'eo0'(les*%otma(l+$om9 lor(w*n/)ar+or'9 e%e,ny*la.es+n/+'o/9 (n0o*la.es+n/+'o/9
$o&'%l(n*ypl,+$om9 r$ornlaw*"12+reno+n/+&s9 /sane/ada*,&no+$om
:otma(l A$t(/e ;(ew
" atta$%ments 5total <+3 M=6
>%tml?
>%ead?
>t(tle?Report 'enerated on 2"@"2@3 342!>/t(tle?
>/%ead?
>)ody?
>pre?
>)?A Ar$%(/e C4BPer0e$t 7orld Enterta(nmentBTemporary Cnternet
3(lesBContent+CE1BQTODAE<FBplease note my new address, SOLACE PROGRAM REQUEST+-(p>/)?
2"@"2@3 342< <2332 <2332 "" TR E!22 GOTCCE O3 APPEAL AGF MOTCOGS 3 <
" 7CT: EH:C=CT " ATTAC:EF+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "I3!EI2 "I3!EI2 3 "E " 0aJ to w$so re e/($t(on par. terra$e %(ll et$
re/mar'(ns remo/ed+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< 13"8< 13"8< 3 E " 0aJ to rm$ re'ard(n' address ema(ls and $ar
sleep(n' alle'at(ons+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< 3<<<"2 3<<<"2 all ema(ls 0rom Patr($. K(n' =ar Co&nsel Ge/ada
Patr($.K*n/)ar+or'+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< ""E283" ""E283" Co&'%l(n wLeJ%()(tsL23"E" 3 "E " Letter 0rom =ar
Co&nsel Patr($. K(n' w(t% D&d'e Gas% :olmes 3ormal Compla(nt Atta$%ed+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "<1<81 "<1<81 CR""@2E8@E<E2I8 5Oppos(t(on to Mtn +++6+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "1<8 "1<8 CR""@2E8@E!8<I 5S&pplemental +++6+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "33E1 "33E1 CR""@2E8@EI"3!E 5Open(n' =r(e06+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "318E "318E CR""@2E8@EI"83" 5Mtn 0or EJtens(on o0 T(me6+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< E!3<3 E!3<3 C;""@23E! Co&'%l(n / Merl(ss 3 E 2" R($%ard G+ :(lMs
"/"
Mot(on 0or Order to S%ow Ca&se A'a(nst Co&'%l(n (s FEGCEF+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< 3E<12< 3E<12< C;""@23E!@EI2!"1 5Open(n' =r(e06+pd0
2"@"2@3 342< "8E318 "8E318 T:E "" " ema(l to 7CSO RPF Reno C(ty Attorney :(ll
GPUC :(ll et al+pd0
>)?A
A Total S(-e Pa$.ed 3(les
A <8"E1!2 <8"E1!2 "
>/)?>/pre?
>/)ody?
>/%tml?
C;""@23E+++pd0
Fownload5E!+1 K=6
Co&'%l(n +++pd0
Fownload5""E3+" K=6
Fownload all as -(p
Fear Fep&ty 7as%oe Co&nty P&)l($ Fe0ender =(ray Fo'an, EsN+, et al,
M&st C &se La.eMs Cross(n' 0or t%(s se$ond $ompeten$y e/al&at(on? Fo yo& %a/e some sort o0 0(nan$(al
arran'ment w(t% La.eMs Cross(n'? Please pro/(de a wr(tten answer as to w%om else C may &t(l(-e 0or
s&$% an e/al&at(on and t%e reN&(rements, $ert(0($at(ons, or standards, w%($% t%ey m&st meet (n order to
)e el('()el to per0orm s&$% an e/al&at(on+ Gonet%eless, C %a/e yet to re$e(/e anyt%(n' 0rom La.eMs
Cross(n', )&t C w(ll $all t%em now and $opy t%em on t%(s ema(l (n an attempt to $omply w(t% t%e
e/al&at(on reN&(rement+ Ms+ :e,ny o0 La.es Cross(n', C was a)le to $%e$. my /o($e ma(ls desp(te
0ormer pr(son warden or adm(n(strator RMC D&d'e Gas% :olmes s&mmar(ly se(-(n' my, an attorneyMs,
$ell&lar and smartp%one (n $o&rt on /</", and st(ll re0&s(n' to release t%em, desp(te :er :onor 0(l(n'
a 'r(e/an$e a'a(nst Co&'%l(n w(t% t%e State =ar o0 Ge/ada t%at ne'le$ts to ment(on t%at se(-&re at
all++++nonet%eless, a d(00($&lt to d(s$ern messa'e so&nd l(.e (t was 0rom a Fr+ =rown w(t% La.es
Cross(n'+++Ms+ :e,ny, wo&ld yo& 0orward t%(s on to %(m w(t% a messa'e t%at C am try(n' to meet %(m
and $omply w(t% all s$%ed&l(n' reN&(rements (mposed &pon me?
Please $opy me /(a ema(l and 0aJ on my ent(re 0(le+ T%e domest($ /(olen$e atta$.s a'a(nst me (n 3;"@
22"!! and 3;"@22"!< res&lted (n (nter0eren$e w(t% re$e(pt o0 my USPS ma(l+ C %a/e ta.en all
reasona)le steps to $o&ntera$t t%at, %owe/er, (n an a)&ndan$e o0 $a&t(on, C as. t%at yo& $opy me on
e/eryt%(n' /(a ema(l and 0aJ and %a/e La.es Cross(n' do so as well+ Add(t(onally, D&d'e Gas% :olmes
$on0(s$ated my p%ones on /</" and st(ll %as not released t%em or pro/(ded 5as 0ar as C .now6 any
(nd($at(on 0or %er )as(s 0or do(n' so, et$+
Mr+ Fo'an, please eJpla(n yo&r pos(t(on /(s a /(s yo&r m(ss(n' t%e Arra('nment (n my $ases, (n$l&d(n'
spe$(0($ re0eren$e to t%e approJ(mately I2 m(n&te meet(n' yo& and C %ad (n ad/an$e o0 t%at
arra('nment+ 3&rt%er, please pro/(de an (nd($at(on (n wr(t(n' as to w%y yo& 0elt t%(s more (n/as(/e,
more (n/ol/ed $ompeten$y e/al&at(on yo& mo/ed 0or was a reN&est )ased (n law or 0a$t, (n$l&d(n'
spe$(0($ deta(ls and do$&mentat(on (n s&pport t%ereo0+ O%, t%atMs r('%t, =(ray Fo'an and Doe Goodn('%t
o0 t%e 7CPF only )el(e/e t%at GRCP "" appl(es to $r(m(nal matters w%ere t%ey need to le/era'e (t as
an eJ$&se not to 0(le a Mot(on to F(sm(ss or some ot%er pre@tr(al mot(on++++Fo'an and Goodn('%tMs
pos(t(on on Ge/ada R&le o0 C(/(l Pro$ed&re "" (n a $r(m(nal $onteJt, t%o&'%, (n t%e $onteJt o0 0(l(n'
any Mot(on 0or San$t(ons a'a(nst Goodn('%tMs or'an($ 0ree trade $o00ee s%op )&ddy FA #a$% Oo&n' (s
t%at PGRCP "" does not apply (n a $r(m(nal $onteJtP+ Cts rem(n(s$ent o0 t%e RPF approa$% to s(t&at(ons
w%ere R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ ma.es a report o0 some $r(m(nal /(olat(on, (n $ompar(s(on to w%en
someone reports a $r(m(nal /(olat(on )y R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ Some m('%t say w%en :(llMs 0(les a report
or s('ns a $r(m(nal $ompla(nt, t%e RPF treats (t as a P/(olat(on 0o $r(m(nal law, a pol($e matterP, )&t t%at
/"
w%en anyone po(nts o&t :(llMs attempts at eJtort(on, )r()ery, a)&se o0 pro$ess, lar$eny, w(t%%old(n'
oneMs state (ss&ed (dent(0($at(on, per,&ry, et$+, et$+, t%e RPF s(mply was%es t%e(r %ands $lean o0 t%e
$ompla(nants reN&est, (nd($at(n', Psorry, )&ddy, t%atMs a $(/(l matter, yo&r remedy (s w(t% t%e $o&rts+++P+
So, w%en :(ll wants a Temporary Prote$t(on Order a'a(nst #a$% Co&'%l(n, )e$a&se, 'os% darn (t,
Co&'%l(n (s 0(ml(m(n' and $olle$td(n' e/(den$e o0 t%e personal property t%at :(llMs $ontra$tor, P%(l
StewartMs $rew (s t%row(n' away 0rom Co&'%l(nMs 0ormer %ome law o00($e, (n ant($(pat(on o0 a wron'0&l
e/($t(on laws&(t a'a(nst :(ll and %(s =e/erly :(llMs :('% S$%ool 'rad&ate Cal(0orn(a Ge&ros&r'eon
landlord $l(ent, Matt Merl(ss 5now on appeal (n C;""@23E!, w%ere(n D&d'e 3lana'an o0 Fepartment <
re$ently den(ed one o0 :(llMs PN&adr&ple ,eopardyP $%eap s%ots at Co&'%l(n, )y deny(n' :(llMs Mot(on
0or Order to S%ow Ca&se 5now t%at ,&st lea/es t%e )aseless State =ar o0 Ge/ada 'r(e/an$e :(ll 0(led on
)e%al0 o0 (nd(/(d&als w%om are not e/en %(s $l(ents, w%ere(n %e $(tes &nattr()&ted %earsay and 0or
w%($% %e 0a(led to atta$% an a$t&al s('nat&re t%ereto, and w%($% $ons(sts $%(e0ly o0 (nn&endo and
$ompla(n(n' t%at Co&'%l(n dared to a$t&ally reN&est a 0ee wa(/er 0rom t%e F(str($t Co&rt to 0(le a
$ompla(nt, desp(te do(n' so )e(n' an a$$epta)le pra$t($e as set 0ort% (n stat&te (n GRS "+2"16+ So,
w%ere Co&'%l(ns pea$e0&lly 0(lm(n' on a s(dewal., t%e RPF doesnMt tell R($%ard :(ll, EsN+ t%at P(ts a
$(/(l matter, sorry yo&r remedy (s w(t% t%e $o&rtsP, )&t rat%er, Sar'ent Pa&l S(0re orders a yo&n'
tra(nee , O00($er Leedy, to wal. &p to Co&'%l(n &npro/o.ed, 'ra) t%e /(deo $amera o&t o0 %(s %and pr(or
to ma.(n' any sort o0 attempt to en'a'e Co&'%l(n or ot%erw(se eJpla(n w%y t%e RPF wo&ld )e, (n a
matter o0 two se$onds, apply(n' eJ$ess(/e 0or$e to Co&'%l(nMs )ent )a$. wr(sts and o)str&$t(n' ,&st($e
)y t&rn(n' o00 %(s /(deo $amera desp(te Co&'%l(nMs eJpress (ns(stan$e t%at Sar'ent Pa&l S(0re re0ra(n
0rom do(n' so+
3&rt%er, please eJpla(n w%at eJa$tly yo& meant w%en yo& told me, a0ter we d(s$&ssed my pre/(o&s
wor. eJper(en$e at :ale Lane, t%at yo& $o&ld ne/er do $(/(l law (n t%e pr(/ate se$tor w%at w(t% all t%at
%ard wor. and t%e )(lla)le %o&rs reN&(rements )e(n' demand(n' o0 yo&r t(me and e00ort, and t%at yo&
0o&nd t%e p&)l($ de0ender l(0estyle m&$% more to yo&r l(.(n'+ Please also eJpla(n w%y yo& 0o&nd (t
ne$essary to po(nt o&t %ow )(tterly d(sappo(nted yo& were w(t% t%e la$. o0 d(/ers(ty (n RenoMs ,&d($(ary
and Reno (n 'eneral, and %ow m&$% yo& sympat%(-ed w(t% t%e pl('%t o0 poor D&d'e :oward 5w%om %as
ne/er de0eated anyone (n an ele$t(on desp(te )e(n' on t%e )en$% s(n$e "II!6 (n %a/(n' to deal w(t% me
(n "" $r "<E, w%ere(n %e senten$ed Reno attorney Co&'%l(n to 3 days (n ,a(l 0or a 0(nd(n' o0 s&mmary
$ontempt &nder GRS +2"2 0or -ealo&sly ad/o$at(n' on )e%al0 o0 a de0endant (n a $r(m(nal matter
w%ere pol($e m(s$ond&$t was alle'ed+ Mr+ =osler, C am %ere)y reN&est(n' t%at a $opy o0 t%(s and all
ot%er $orresponden$es )etween =(ray Fo'an and mysel0 and my $omplete 0(le (n t%e matter 0or w%($%
Mr+ Fo'an (s represent(n' me )e pla$ed (n Mr+ Fo'anMs 0(le and t%at a 0ormal $ompla(nt (n/est('at(on
a'a(nst Mr+ Fo'an 0or %(s ne'l('en$e (n represent(n' me so 0ar and %(s retal(atory approa$% 5%a/(n' a
psy$%e e/al&at(on ordered t%at (s d(splayed on t%e www+$$was%oe+$om $o&rt$onne$t do$.et (n $lose
proJ(m(ty to my $ompla(n(n' o0 Mr+ Fo'anMs 0a(l&re to appear at my arra(n'ment and %(s N&est(ona)le
statements to me, as well as t%e pra$t($e %e and Fep&ty PF Doe Goodn('%t attempted to employe
pre/(o&sly were t%ey (ns(sted &pon tal.(n' to me on t%e p%one as a pa(r, (n a s&rpr(se approa$% manner+
Cn$(dentally, t%e RPF Sar'ent w%om $%ar'ed me w(t% t%e Pm(s&se o0 I""P 'ross m(sdemeanor t%at C am
$&rrently 0a$(n', pla'&ed wt(% t%e representat(on o0 one =(ray Fo'an (n, a$t&ally mana'ed to lose my
do' last n('%t, w%en Sar'ent S(0re was respond(n' to a tr&e (nstan$e o0 m(s&es o0 I"", w%ere #a$%
Co&'%l(nMs Ps(sterP Carly Goel Co&'%l(n, $alled I"" to report t%at Mr+ Co&'%l(n %ad arr(/ed at CarlyMs
%o&se, w%ere s%e %ad (n/(ted %(m to drop o0 %(s pe.(n'nese do', Da$.son Pawl&$., (0 %e e/er wanted
Ms+ Co&'%l(nMs P0r(endP to wat$% Da$.son a'a(n+ Ms+ Co&'%l(n (nd($ated t%at Pt%e peopel w%o wat$%ed
%(m last t(me $r(ed w%en C went to 'o 'et %(m, so C donMt really wanna do t%(s a'a(nP desp(te %er earl(er
(nd($at(on t%at s%e wo&ld+ Ms+ Co&'%l(n, 'rew annoyed w(t% Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs reN&est and rene''ed on
%er o00er to transport t%e do' to t%e d(sa)led woman to w%om (t )ro&'%t so m&$% ,oy, and %er da&'%ter+
3/"
Mr+ Co&'%l(n wal.ed )a$. to %(s $ar w(t% %(s do' to lea/e, )&t %(s $ar was apparently to low on 'as to
start+ Ms+ Co&'%l(n $ont(n&ed to re'ale Mr+ Co&'%l(n w(t% %er %ypo$r(t($al, sat&rn(ne approa$% to
%&man relat(ons 5t%(s desp(te %er wor.(n' (n t%e mental %ealt% $are 0(eld, apparently, and per%aps, most
tro&)l(n'6+ Ms+ Co&'%l(n t%reatened to $all I"" (0 Mr+ Co&'%l(n d(d not lea/e (mmed(ately, Mr+
Co&'%l(n sa(d %e wo&ld, as.ed w%at on eart% s%e wo&ld )e $all(n' I"" a)o&t, and promptly attempted
to start %(s $ar to lea/e+ Ct wo&ld not, and Ms+ Co&'%l(n dro/e o00+ Mr+ Co&'%l(n, .now(n' 0&ll well t%at
%(s s(ster wo&ld (n 0a$t )e $all(n' I"", and t%at s%e was well aware o0 Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs re$ent tr(als and
tr()&lat(ons w(t% lo$al law en0or$ement (n l('%t o0 Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs a)errant )el(e0 t%at people (n t%(s
$o&nty a$t&ally do %a/e r('%ts and t%at we do not l(/e (n a pol($e state6, and t%at s%e, (n 0a$t, so&'%t to
0&rt%er $a&se Mr+ Co&'%l(n d(s$ord w(t% law en0or$ement, somet%('n w%($% s%o&ld wo&ld, o0 $o&rse,
later Prem(JP as %er P$on$ernP 0or %(s Pwel0areP+ Sar'ent S(0re, w%om 0or some reason was ass('ned to
answer t%(s $all )y t%e RPF, e$%oed t%ese sent(ments to Mr+ Co&'%l(n and pro/(ded %(s pro0ess(onal
op(n(on t%at Ms+ Co&'%l(n d(d P$are so /ery deeplyP a)o&t Mr+ Co&'%l(n+ Apparently, t%(s pro0o&nd
$on$ern was also eJ%()(ted (n Ms+ Co&'%l(n $all(n' I"" a se$ond t(me t%e n('%t o0 3/</" w%en Mr+
Co&'%l(n ret&rned some two %o&rs laters to %(s /e%($le, par.ed on Keele St+, on a p&)l($ street, w(t% a
'as $an w(t% %al0 a 'allon o0 'as, (ntend(n' to pla$e (t (n %(s $are and dr(/e o0, %ope0&lly )e0ore, on$e
a'a(n, )e(n' a)&sed )y lo$al law en0or$ement, l(.e Sar'net S(0re, w%om was la&'%(n' on "/"8/" w%en
%e arrested Co&'%l(n and $%ar'ed %(m w(t% a 'ross m(sdemeanor, Pm(s&se o0 I""P+ Ms+ Co&'%l(n o0
$o&rse so&'%t to %a/e Mr+ Co&'%l(n arrested 0or not%(n' and to 0&rt%er (n/ol/e Mr+ Co&'%l(n w(t% lo$al
law en0or$ement, t%o&'% t%at pro)a)ly %as not%(n' to do w(t% %er /ar(o&s )(tter statements o/er t%e
years a)o&t %ow Ct %as not )een 0o&nd and may well )e dead '(/en t%e proJ(m(ty o0 tra00($ and t%e
do'Ms (neJper(en$e (n deal(n' w(t% (t+ :ow Sar'ent S(0re $o&ld poss()ly le$t&re Mr+ Co&'%l(n 0or o/er
an %o&r, per%aps $a&s(n' Co&'%l(n to m(ss an ele$tron($ 0(l(n' deadl(ne (n an (mportant le'al matter (s
&n$lear, part($&larly w%ere Sar'ent S(0re adm(tted to Co&'%l(n t%at Ms+ Co&'%l(n adm(tted Mr+
Co&'%l(n d(d not to&$% %er, %arm %er, or t%reaten %er (n any way+ :ow (t (s t%at Ms+ Co&'%l(n (s not
'&(lty o0 Pm(s&se o0 I""P w%ereas Mr+ Co&'%l(n was s&),e$t to a $&stod(al arrest 0or t%e /ery same
$%ar'e, )y t%e /ery same RPF Sar'ent, Pa&l S(0re, (s ,&st not /ery $lear+ =&t, one s%o&ldnMt %old oneMs
)reat% wa(t(n' 0or any sort o0 -ealo&s ad/o$a$y )y one =(ray Fo'an, Fep&ty 7as%oe Co&nty P&)l($
Fe0ender, or any 'reat eJ%()(t(on o0 restra(nt )y Fep&ty F(str($t Attorney #a$% Oo&n'+ Mr+ Co&'%l(n
was a)le to 0(nally lea/e and $ont(n&e w(t% %(s le'al wor. w%en lo$al PD&d'e 7%(spererP Fr+ T(mot%y
F+ Co&'%l(n, MF arr(/ed w(t% a 'as $an at t%e s$ene and pla$e a 'allon o0 'as (n Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs
/e%($le+ T%at represented t%e 0(rst eJpend(t&re )y Fr+ Co&'%l(n towards P%elp(n'P %(s son t%at was not
$ond(t(oned &pon some )(-arre, M&n$%a&sen )y ProJy, Power and Control 7%eel 5F&l&t% Model6
em)ody(n' p%ys($(an $ontrol 0rea./lawyer en/y (ns(sten$e t%at Mr+ Co&'%l(n )e s&),e$t to some
eJper(emental treatment t%at Fr+ Co&'%l(n 0o&nd reN&(red '(/en Fr+ Co&'%l(nMs )el(e0 %(s son, Reno
Attorney (s a00l($ted w(t% a $ond(t(on w%ere(n a PdemonP res(des (ns(de o0 %(s son+ Fr+ Co&'%l(n le0t %(s
son, Reno Attorney #a$% Co&'%l(n as /o($e ma(l (n t%e last year w%ere(n %e state to %(s son, PC tr&ly
)el(e/e yo& %a/e a demon (ns(de o0 yo& P w%ere&pon Fr+ Co&'%l(n demanded &pon some sort o0
)a$.woods eJor$(sm )e(n' per0ormed &pon attorney Co&'%l(n, w%om re'&larly re0ers to %(s 0at%er as
PT(mP or PFr+ Co&'%l(nP, )&t only /ery rarely, anymore, as PFadP+ Fr+ Co&'%l(n (s re0erred to )y some
as t%e PD&d'e 7%(spererP '(/en %(s stat&s as t%e p%ys($(an o0 $%o($e to &t(l(-e (n t%e s%ame )ased
sled'%ammer role d&r(n' (nter/ent(ons w(t% mem)ers o0 t%e Ge/ada D&d($(ary w%om alle'edly %a/e
s&)stan$e a)&se pro)lems+++ And (ts not &n%eard o0 0or mem)ers o0 t%e ,&d($(ary to approa$% attorney
#a$% Co&'%l(n and as. w%ere t%ey may 0(nd Fr+ Co&'%l(n, as t%ey wo&ld l(.e to p&n$% %(m sN&are (n
t%e mo&t%+ Anyways, Sar'ent Pa&l S(0re %ad to adm(t to #a$% Co&'%l(n, on 3/</", t%at %e and %(s
RPF asso$(ate %ad allowed Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs do' Da$.son, to es$ape 0rom Ms+ Co&'%l(ns &nlo$.ed
res(den$e, w%ere Mr+ Co&'%l(n %ad pla$ed t%e do' (mmed(ately )e0ore attempt(n' to 'o wal. to a 'as
8/"
stat(on and 'et 'as, '(/en Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs reasona)le )el(e/e t%at (0 %e le0t %(s do' (n %(s par.ed $ar,
o&ts(de Ms+ Co&'%l(nMs %o&se, %e wo&ld )e arrested )y t%e RPF 0or Pdo' endan'erment or ne'le$t or
an(mal $r&eltyP++++Ama-(n'ly, e/en a0ter lett(n' Mr+ Co&'%l(nMs do' es$ape 0rom Ms+ Co&'%l(nMs %o&se,
and per%aps )e %(t )y a $ar, Sar'ent S(0re st(ll saw 0(t to le$t&re Mr+ Co&'%l(n and po(nt o&t t%e
)ene/olen$e o0 t%e pol($e state Sar'ent S(0re and t%ose l(.e %(m $&rrently %a/e (n pla$e (n 7as%oe
Co&nty and t%e C(ty o0 Reno+ =&t, RPF Sar'ent S(0re was s&re to po(nt o&t to attorney Co&'%l(n %ow
/ery pro0o&ndly deep Fr+ Co&'%l(n and Carly G+ Co&'%l(nMs $on$ern was 0or attorney Co&'%l(n+
:owe/er, t%e(r $on$ern (s apparently not so s('n(0($ant as to allow, say, attorney to store a plast($
'ar)a'e )a' 0&ll o0 eJpens(/e s&(ts &nder Fr+ Co&'%l(nMs Ca&'%l(n Ran$% %ome, w%($% %as 1 empty
)edrooms and a Pm&droomP t%e s(-e o0 an a(r$ra0t %an'er &nder t%e %ome 0or stor(n' t%(n's+ A0ter t%e
)a' o0 s&(ts )e(n' )eneat% Fr+ Co&'%l(nMs %ome 0or approJ(mately a wee. t%ey o&twore t%e(r wel$ome,
prompt(n' Fr+ Co&'%l(n and %(s w(0e, Mon($a Morell( Co&'%l(n to (nN&(re as to w%en attorney
Co&'%l(n m('%t )e a)le to remo/e s&$% )a' 0rom t%e Pm&droomP &nderneat% t%e(r %ome, w%($%, a'a(n,
%as 1 empty )edrooms+ Fr+ Co&'%l(n pre/(o&sly telep%one t%e Fean o0 t%e UGL; =oyd S$%ool o0 law
to de0ame %(s son, w%ere&pon Fean R($%ard Mor'an, e/er t%e r(s. m(n(m(-er m(ddle mana'(n',
)&s(ness attorney, $&tt%roat, ed&$ator t%at (s %e, promptly $alled &p t%e State =ar to report as m&$%+
And wo&ld Carly Goel Co&'%l(n )e alr('%t w(t% allow(n' %er )rot%er, attorney Co&'%l(n to store, say, a
'&(tar or a )oJ o0 papers at %er %ome 0or a l(ttle w%(le? O0 $o&rse s%e wo&ldnMt+ T%o&'%, M(ss Carly
s&re w(ll p&t on a s%ow o0 P$on$ernP 0or Sar'ent S(0re w%en %e s%ows &p, tw($e+++++O%, )&t %ow /ery
m&$% t%ey want to P%elpP+ D&st only w(t% psy$%o)a))le and 0a&J $on$ern and sel0 ser/(n' power
%&n'ry, man(p&lat(/e e'o tr(ps, rat%er t%an any d(s$ern()le, tan'()le )ene0(t to t%e tas.s at %and+ Fr+
Co&'%l(n (s Reno C(ty Attorney Do%n Kadl($Ms personal p%ys($(an, and Kadl($ (s 'od0at%er to t%e
da&'t%er Fr+ Co&'%l(n %ad w(t% Mon($a Morell( Co&'%l(n, o0 Morell( /+ Morell( 0ame4
%ttp4//www+lea'le+$om/JmlRes&lt+aspJ?
Jmldo$Q"I!E"88<2Pd<28L""8"I+JmlRdo$)aseQCSL7AR@"I!E@22E
Cn Morell( /+ Morell(, Ge/adaMs 0(rst Ctal(an Ge&ros&r'eon was s&ed )y %(s now attorney "! year old
da&'t%er 0or t%e $ost o0 %er $olle'e and law s$%ool t&(t(on, w%($% was eJpressly set 0ort% as a
st(p&lat(on (n t%e mar(tal settlement a'reement (n t%at matter+ T%e da&'%ter was awarded t%e t&t(on and
0at%er and da&'%ter ne/er spo.e a'a(n d&r(n' Fr+ Morell(Ms l(0et(me, some 2 more years+
Cron($ally, t%e Pm(s&se o0 I""P $%ar'ed stemmed 0rom my $all(n' a)o&t t%e myster(o&s and mena$(n'
d(sappearan$e o0 my do' 5w%om C appeared w(t% (n t%e Fe$em)er 2" (ss&e o0 t%e Ge/ada Lawyer6,
w%($% o$$&red (n t%e $onteJt o0 a $ont(n&o&s )arra'e o0 domest($ /(olen$e to w%($% C was eJposed,
t%or&'% t%e 0(rst s(J wee.s o0 2", )y t%e a$t(ons o0 my t%en %o&semates, and 0or w%($% C attempted to
o)ta(n prote$t(on or ,&st($e 0rom )y $onta$t(n' t%e RPF, (n$l&d(n' Sar'ent #a$% T%ew 5alle'edly, C was
arrested w%(le alle'edly attempt(n' to $onta$t Sar'ent T%ew, (n a$$ordan$e w(t% Sar'ent T%ewMs
eJpress (nstr&$t(ons t%at C do so
%ttp4//www+yo&t&)e+$om/wat$%?/QoU3tL.RR2RA
++++w%($% =(ray Fo'an .nows, )&t 0or w%($% Mr+ Fo'an %as re0&sed to 0(le any Mot(on to F(sm(ss or
ot%er a$t(on on my )e%al0, rat%er, Mr+ Fo'an see.s to retal(ate a'a(nst me and to em)arass me w(t% yet
anot%er retal(atory P$ompeten$yP e/al&at(on, desp(te t%e 0a$t t%at C passed, w(t% 0ly(n' $olors, t%e one
adm(n(stered )y L())y :e(,ne a0ter Fep&ty 7as%oe Co&nty P&)l($ Fe0endenr Cary :yl(n ordered one
5s&)seN&ent 0(l(n's )y t%e 7CPF (nd($ated t%at a P%ear(n'P too. pla$e w%ere(n s&$% an e/al&at(on was
reN&ested )y :yl(n and orderd )y D&d'e Da$. S$%roeder, yet no s&$% P%ear(n'P too. pla$e69
RPF Sar'ent S(0re 5w%om a$t&ally ma.es more money t%ro&'% %(s p&)l($ employment t%an most
F(str($t Co&rt D&d'es6 arrested me anot%er t(me, ma.(n' (t tw($e (n two days, on Dan&ary "t%, 2" 0or
P,aywal.(n', t%en %e o)str&$ted ,&st($e )y t&rn(n' o00 my /(deo $amera w%(le RPF O00($er Loo. and
O00($er Leedy were &s(n' eJ$ess(/e 0or$e 5$ompletely o&t o0 t%e )l&e and w(t% -ero ,&st(0($at(on 0or
1/"
do(n' so, as e/(n$ed )y t%e /(deo (tsel06 on me+
%ttp4//www+yo&t&)e+$om/wat$%?/Q'=&I-0lGALER0eat&reQrelated
Fep&ty F(str($t Attorney #a$% G(0on', er, #a$% Oo&n', EsN+, %as )een eJtremely res(stant to any sort o0
plea )ar'a(n(n' (n e(t%er $ase, as %e %as )een (n t%e matter 0or w%($% Fep&ty P&)l($ Fe0ender Doe
Goodn('%t, EsN+ (s Prepresent(n'P me as my PattorneyP+ T%at matter RCR also (n$l&ded pol($e
m(s$ond&$t )y t%e Reno Pol($e Fepartment, )y O00($ers Ron Rosa and G($. F&ralde+ 7%ere wo&ld
Reno attorney #a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+ )e (0 t%ere was not /(deo tape o0 all o0 t%(s pol($e m(s$ond&$t?
%ttp4//www+yo&t&)e+$om/wat$%?/Q1PR<N8OC1)2R0eat&reQrelated
Fesp(te %a/(n' t%(s /(deo, FA #a$% Oo&n' retal(ated a'a(nst Co&'%l(n 0or Co&'%l(nMs 0(l(n' a GRCP ""
Mot(on a'a(nst )ot% Goodn('%t and Oo&n' )y amend(n' t%e $r(m(nal $ompla(nt to o/er$%ar'e some
more+ Go, rat%er FA #a$% Oo&n' and t%e RPF see t%e w(tness tamper(n' and attempts to d(ss&ade
G($ole 7atson 0rom o00er(n' any (ns('%t (nto t%e wron'0&l arrest o0 !/2/" )y G($%olas F&radle as Pa
$(/(l matterP, not a P$r(m(nal oneP+ :e$., t%e RPF doesnMt e/en see )attery, assa&lt, a''ra/ated assa&lt,
or domest($ /(olen$e as P$r(m(nal (n nat&reP w%en t%ese t%(n's %appen to pes.y 3(rst Amendment
attorney #a$%ary =ar.er Co&'%l(n, EsN+, +++no, rat%er, t%ose are matters o0 a P$(/(l nat&reP and
Co&'%l(nMs Premedy (s w(t% t%e $o&rtMsP, so sayet% RPF O00($er Sta$ey Gardner, Sar'ent Mon($a Lope-,
O00($er M$N&attry, O00($er Loo. and Leedy and Fel/e$$%(o, O00($er 7arren, et$+, et$+,
Cn$(dentally, (t wo&ld )e %elp0&l (0 an ent(ty l(.e 7as%oe Le'al Ser/($es too. an a''res(/e approa$% to
ad/o$at(n' on )e%al0 o0 tenantsM+++++7as%oe Le'al Ser/($es EJe$&t(/e F(re$tor Pa&l El$ano %as
reportedly $all Fr+ Co&'%l(n (n an attempt to (n0l&en$e attorney Co&'%l(n to $lose t%e $ase Co&'%l(n
%as a'a(nst 7LS 0or wron'0&l term(nat(on+
Cts a 'ood t%(n' Ge/ada %as so many )ra/e 3(rst Amendment attorneyMs l(.e DM Fe/oy and %(s
asso$(ate Mar$ Randa--a, ne(t%er o0 w%om %a/e any asso$(at(on w(t% Mr+ Co&'%l(n+ C, Mr+ Co&'%l(n
am aware t%at (t (s sl('%tly aw.ward to wr(te t%(s sw(t$%(n' )etween t%e 0(rst and t%(rd person, %owe/er,
t%e eJ('en$(es and e$onom($s o0 solo law pra$t($e were at play (n do(n' so+
At least t%ere (snMt m&$% o0 a so$(etal $ost to t%e le'ally N&est(ona)le manner (n w%($% e/($t(ons are
de$(ded and $arr(ed o&t (n 7as%oe Co&nty4
%ttp4//www+yo&t&)e+$om/wat$%?/QssE237:3GEO
%ttp4//www+yo&t&)e+$om/wat$%?/QK,GaE,slr8
7ell, Mr+ Loom(s, t%(n.s my ar'&ments a)o&t t%e (ns&00($(en$y o0 ser/($e o0 t%e S&mmary E/($t(on
OrderMs (s P0r(/olo&sP, )&t, %ey, %e (s ,&st 'ett(n' pa(d to -ealo&sly ad/o$ate on my )e%al0, so++++
And ,&st )e$a&se =ar Co&nsel Patr($. K(n', EsN+, 0eels t%e 're(/an$es C 0(led are not wort% p&rs&(n'
w%ereas t%ose 0(led )y R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ are de0(nately wort%y o0 lots and lots o0 0ollow &p 5e/en
w%ere %e la$.s stand(n' to so 0(le or (s o00er(n' only &nattr()&ted %earsay (n s&pport o0 %(s $ontent(ons,
et$+6 does not mean =ar Co&nsel Patr($. K(n' (s a$t(n' as an atta$. do' 0or t%e r($%, t%at wo&ld not )e
an a$$&rate statement, (n all l(.el(%ood+
S(n$erely,
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, PO =OH E2I1, REGO, G;, !I12E, tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
Fear Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
T%(s messa'e (s sent to address (ss&es ra(sed (n t%e e@ma(l yo& sent on 3@E@"+
"+ Please note t%at yo& are 0ree to send t%e $omm&n($at(ons yo& send to me, to anyone else yo& des(re+
Oo& s%o&ld )e aware t%at send(n' yo&r $omm&n($at(ons to ot%er part(es w(ll $a&se yo&r
$omm&n($at(ons to me to lose t%e(r attorney@$l(ent $on0(dent(al(ty+
+ 3or w%at spe$(0($ p&rposes do yo& need a $ont(n&an$e? A $ont(n&an$e p&rely 0or t%e p&rpose o0
delay (s not a proper reason 0or a $ont(n&an$e+
3+ 7%et%er yo& are ent(tled to e@ma(l t%e Reno M&n($(pal Co&rt (s not my $on$ern+ T%at (s a pro)lem to
E/"
)e addressed )etween yo& and t%e Co&rt+
8+ Ms+ Fra.e (s no lon'er t%e attorney %andl(n' yo&r $ase 0or t%e Reno C(ty AttorneySs O00($e+ Oo&r
$ase (s now )e(n' %andled )y C%r(stop%er :a-lett@Ste/ens, EsN+
1+ Cn response to yo&r N&est(on re'ard(n' t%e wea.nesses o0 t%e trespass(n' $ase C o00er t%e 0ollow(n'4
a+ T%e $ompla(nt (s de0($(ent (n t%at (0 0a(ls to set 0ort% t%e elements o0 t%e $r(me o0 trespass+ Ct 0a(ls to
(dent(0y w%et%er yo&r presen$e on t%e prem(ses was 0or t%e p&rpose to /eJ or annoy t%e owner or
o$$&pant o0 t%e prem(ses or w%et%er (t was an entry onto t%e prem(ses a0ter a warn(n' not to so
trespass+ T%(s (s pro)a)ly eas(ly remed(ed )y an amendment at t%e t(me o0 tr(al+ Ge/ert%eless t%ese are
alternat(/e t%eor(es on w%($% a trespass $ase $an )e p&rs&ed and t%e de0endant (s ent(tled to .now on
w%($% t%eory or t%eor(es a $ase (s )e(n' prose$&ted (n ad/an$e o0 s%ow(n' &p 0or tr(al+
)+ Oo& 0(led an appeal on O$to)er "I, 2"", apparently, o0 t%e order made )y D&st($e o0 t%e Pea$e
S0erra--a on O$to)er "3, 2""+ T%at order den(ed yo&r reN&est 0or a $ont(n&an$e and 'ranted s&mmary
e/($t(on &nless yo& 0(led a depos(t w(t% t%e $o&rt+ Typ($ally t%e $o&rts lose ,&r(sd($t(on to r&le on ot%er
matters (n t%e $ase on$e an appeal (s ta.en+ Ct (s $lear 0rom t%e $o&rt re$ords t%at t%(s appeal was
pend(n' )e0ore t%e Se$ond D&d($(al F(str($t Co&rt at t%e t(me t%e $o&rt %eld a %ear(n' on t%e &nlaw0&l
deta(ner on O$to)er 1, 2""+ Ct may well )e t%at t%e D&st($e Co&rt lost ,&r(sd($t(on to %old t%e e/($t(on
%ear(n' w%(le t%e appeal was pend(n'+
$+ C am wor.(n' on some ot%er t%o&'%ts+
E+ C0 yo& are d(ssat(s0(ed w(t% t%e way C am represent(n' yo&, yo& rema(n 0ree to see. a new attorney+
<+ Anot%er $%&$.le re'ard(n' my owners%(p o0 str(p $l&)s+ C donSt own or %a/e any owners%(p (nterest
(n any str(p $l&)s, )rot%els, ad&lt )oo. stores or mo/(e %o&ses+ C '&ess t%at lea/es me 0ree to moral(-e+
!+ C st(ll donSt see t%e (mportan$e o0 Fr+ Merl(ss+ T%e reN&est 0or payment o0 an amo&nt eN&al to rent,
was 0or stora'e o0 yo&r personal property+ Oo& are ent(tled to $ontest t%e amo&nt o0 t%e stora'e 0ee,
w%($% yo& d(d+ T%ere (s no $red()le e/(den$e anyw%ere w%($% s&''ests t%at anyone (ntended to reopen
or $reate a new tenan$y allow(n' yo& to reta(n possess(on o0 t%e prem(ses+
I+ Fr+ Merl(ss (s an o&t o0 state w(tness+ Cn order to $ompel %(s appearan$e, %(s test(mony m&st )e
mater(al+ GRS "<8+815"6+ Ct does not appear t%at %(s test(mony (s mater(al &nder t%e (n0ormat(on yo&
%a/e pro/(ded 3&rt%er, &nder GRS "<8+8156 %e (s ent(tled to )e pa(d %(s s&)s(sten$e and tra/el
eJpenses (n$&rred (n $om(n' to Ge/ada+ Are yo& prepared to pay t%ose eJpenses (n ad/an$e o0 %(s
$om(n' to Ge/ada?
"2+ C donSt (ntend to 0aJ or e@ma(l to yo&, yo&r 0&ll 0(le (n t%(s $ase+ Oo& already %a/e e/eryt%(n' w(t%
t%e eJ$ept(on o0 a $o&ple o0 (tems w%($% C ma(led to yo&r old address+ C w(ll send t%em a'a(n to yo&r
new address+ C0 yo& want to re/(ew t%e 0(le yo& are wel$ome to do so at my o00($e+ C0 yo& want $op(es
o0 anyt%(n' (n t%e 0(le yo& may mar. t%e (tems+ A0ter '(/(n' yo& a $ost est(mate, 0or w%($% C reN&(re
payment (n ad/an$e, we w(ll pro/(de yo& w(t% $op(es o0 t%e mar.ed (tems+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 Monday, Mar$% E, 2" "2433 PM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net9 sterm(t-*s)$'lo)al+net9 ,md*randa--a+$om9 ,)oles*$allat'+$om9
.r(st(emann(n'*ya%oo+$om9 .adl($,*reno+'o/
S&),e$t4 ( was e/($ted 3 "1 ", ( need a $ont(n&an$e
Fear Mr+ Loom(s,
C was wron'0&lly e/($ted on 3 "1 ", and C need a $ont(n&an$e (n t%e $r(m(nal trespass matter t%at yo&
set o/erly N&($.ly a'a(nst my eJpress w(s%es anyway+ My a)(l(ty to $olle$t e/(den$e ne$essary to my
de0ense and ot%erw(se prepare %as )een ad/ersely a00e$ted+ Add(t(onally, C donMt 0eel as t%o&'% yo& are
per0orm(n' (n an appropr(ate manner as de0ense $o&nsel, )&t rat%er yo& seem st&$. (n yo&r
prose$&tor(al ways, too N&($. to loo. 0or any eJ$&se w%atsoe/er to )&ry oneMs $ase, so C t%(n. yo& %a/e
</"
0or$ed a spl(t %ere, w%($% 0&rt%er pre,&d($es my $ase and a&'ers towards a $ont(n&an$e+ Please mo/e
0or one (mmed(ately and $opy me on my ent(re 0(le )y ema(l and 0aJ please+ Add(t(onally, please see.
$lar(0($at(on 0rom t%e RMC as to w%et%er C am allowed to e/er send an ema(l to
renom&n($re$ords*reno+'o/+ Please note, today, D&d'e 3lana'an den(ed R($%ard :(llMs latest 0r(/olo&s
mot(on+
F(d yo& .now t%at Ke/(n Kelly, o0 t%e State =ar o0 Ge/adaMs C%ara$ter and 3(tness Comm(ttee 0or at
least t%e last de$ade owns and r&ns t%e Spearm(nt R%(no str(p $l&) (n Las ;e'as4
%ttp4//www+re/(ew,o&rnal+$om/l/r,L%ome/22/Mar@2E@7ed@22/news/"!8"81+%tml
C .now C always l(.e my t%ree %o&r to&rs o0 %ea/y %anded moral(-(n' 0rom someone w%o r&ns a
monol(t%($ str(p $l&) (n Las ;e'as+
Oo& are on t%e State =ar o0 Ge/adaMs 0ee d(sp&te $omm(ttee, arenMt yo& Mr+ Loom(s? Fo yo& own any
str(p $l&)s?
Mr+ Loom(s, w%($% o0 t%e elements o0 t%e trespass $%ar'e RMC !+"2+282 do yo& 0eel are wea.est 0or
Fep&ty C(ty Attorney D(ll Fra.e, w%om C (n0ormed a)o&t t%e adm(ss(on )y Reno PF O00($er C%r(s
Carter t%at R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ )r()es %(m, )&t 0or w%($% Ms+ Fra.e (nd($ated a $omplete la$. o0
(nterest and eJpressed t%at s%e wo&ld not )e 0ollow(n' &p on t%at report o0 )r()ery o0 a RPF O00($er+
Mr+ Kadl($, please pla$e a $opy o0 t%(s $orresponden$e (n D(ll Fra.eMs personnel 0(le+ Add(t(onally
please pla$e one (n All(son OrmaasMs personnel and employment 0(le too, (n add(t(on to Fep&ty C(ty
Attorney Fan 7on'Ms employment 0(le, as all t%ree o0 t%ose Fep&ty C(ty AttorneyMs were pro/(ded t%at
report and all t%ree (nd($ated t%ey d(d not $are and %ad no (ntent(on o0 0ollow(n' &p or ot%erw(se
(n/est('at(n' t%e adm(ss(on )y RPF O00($er C%r(s Carter t%at R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ )r()ed %(m+ C t%(n.
t%e 0a(l&re to 0ollow &p )y any o0 t%ese 3 Fep&ty C(ty AttorneyMs relates to any 0&t&re ne'l('ent %(r(n',
tra(n(n', and s&per/(s(on $la(ms t%at t%e Reno C(ty Attorney may need to de0end a'a(nst w%en
represent(n' t%e Reno PF l(.e (t d(d (n t%e Eeo0 /+ P(tsno'le $ase4
%ttp4//www+l/r,+$om/news/reno@o00($(al@a$$&sed@o0@w(tness@tamper(n'@""E1!E1!+%tml
Oo& .now, Fep&ty C(ty Attorney OrmaasMs de$(s(on to p&s% on 0or t%at V<2 tra00($ t($.et (s loo.(n'
more and more (nterest(n'+ BB
O%, and, Mr+ Loom(s, Fr+ Merl(ss presen$e (s ne$essary )e$a&se %(s &nderstand(n' o0 t%e eJtent to
w%($% %(s attorney, R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ %ad e00e$t(/ely res$(nded any e/($t(on Order )y send(n' a )(ll
0or t%e same amo&nt as 0&ll &se and o$$&pany o0 t%e lo$at(on at "" R(/er Ro$. St+ 'oes to t%e
s&)stan$e o0 t%e elements 0o&nd (n RMC !+"2+282 as well as t%e $red()(l(ty o0 )ot% Merl(ss and :(ll+
S(n$erely,
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, PO =OH E2I1, REGO, G;, !I12E, tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, PO =OH E2I1, REGO, G;, !I12E, tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
Close Pr(nt
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 rm$ "" $r E821 yo& are appo(nted $o&nsel? 0or p&entes ne ta(tel??
/</"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To M#a$% Co&'%l(nM
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon /</" 34< PM
!/"
To4 M#a$% Co&'%l(nM 5-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om6
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
E@ma(l wor.s well 0or me+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 Monday, 3e)r&ary <, 2" <41E AM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 rm$ "" $r E821 yo& are appo(nted $o&nsel? 0or p&entes ne ta(tel?
%(, ( '&ess Mr+ Loom(s was appo(nted as my 3rd de0ense attorney (n RMC $ase "" $r E821+ C %a/e not
%eard anyt%(n' a)o&t t%(s $ase, and t%e RMC (nd($ated t%ey %ad not%(n' s$%ed&led+ Please
$omm&n($ate w(t% me only /(a ema(l or 0aJ please, %a/(n' (ss&es w(t% my ma(l (n$(dent to domest($
/(olen$e $omm(tted a'a(nst me my 0aJ (s I8I EE< <82+ t%an.s,
#a$% Co&'%l(n
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
$o&rt date?
3/21/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To M#a$% Co&'%l(nM
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon 3/21/" 842I PM
To4 M#a$% Co&'%l(nM 5-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om6
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
C %a/e reN&ested t%at $o&rt set yo&r trespass $ase 0or tr(al (n a)o&t 32 days+ C w(ll let yo& .now t%e date
and t(me as soon as C .now+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 $o&rt date?
3/2</"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 7ed 3/2</" 843E PM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
On w%at 'ro&nds, ot%er t%an t%ose already set 0ort% (n yo&r eJ(st(n' mot(on, do yo& )el(e/e a mot(on to
d(sm(ss s%o&ld )e 0(led?
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 7ednesday, Mar$% 2<, 2" "481 AM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 $o&rt date
I/"
Mr+ Loom(s,
Please $opy me on any and all $orresponden$es, 0(l(n', or ot%er do$&mentat(on or /er)al reN&ests,
$orresponden$es, et$+ t%at yo& s&)m(t to t%e Co&rt, (n$l&d(n' t%e one yo& re0eren$e )elow+ Please do
not 0ollow Ta(telMs ta$t o0 a'ree(n' to reN&ests or 0a(l(n' to oppose mot(ons w(t%o&t e/en attempt(n' to
o)ta(n my perm(ss(on to (n ad/an$e t%ereo0+
C wo&ld l(.e 0or yo& to dra0t a Mot(on to F(sm(ss (n t%(s $ase 0or me re/(ew+
T%an.s,
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3rom4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
S&),e$t4 $o&rt date
Fate4 Mon, 1 Mar 2" "E42I4"I @2!22
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
C %a/e reN&ested t%at $o&rt set yo&r trespass $ase 0or tr(al (n a)o&t 32 days+ C w(ll let yo& .now t%e date
and t(me as soon as C .now+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 $o&rt date?
3/2I/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 3r( 3/2I/" "24"8 AM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Go worr(es+ Made me la&'%+
Co&ple o0 N&est(ons4
F(d yo& 0(le an appeal 0rom D&st($e o0 t%e Pea$e S0erra--aSs e/($t(on order?
C0 yes, %as (t )een resol/ed?
F(d S0erra--a anno&n$e at t%e $lose o0 t%e %ear(n' on t%e 1t% t%at %e was 'rant(n' t%e e/($t(on and as.
:(ll/=a.er to pro/(de a wr(tten order?
F(d yo& e/er see t%e e/($t(on order posted )y 7CSO
C0 yes, w%en?
7%at (s rele/an$e o0 personnel 0(les o0 Carter or Lope-?
:ow (s Fr+ Merl(ssS test(mony mater(al to t%e de0ense o0 t%(s $ase?
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 T%&rsday, Mar$% 2!, 2" "48E AM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 $o&rt date
Fear Mr+ Loom(s,
C apolo'(-e S(r 0or w%at C am s&re $omes a$ross as r&deness on my part+ Oo& seem l(.e a 'ood '&y, and
yo& %a/e 'reat %a(r+ C s(mply donMt %a/e t(me, money or ener'y to do any o0 t%(s t%e pol(te way '(/en
"2/"
t%e P&n(N&enessP o0 t%(s s(t&at(on++++Please ,&st .now C mean yo& no d(srespe$t+
7o&ld yo& please 0(le a reN&est or Mot(on 0or t%e Personnel 3(le o0 RPF O00($er C%r(s Carter and
Sar'ent Mon($a Lope- as well as s&p)oena 0rom t%e RPF all t%e /ol&mns o0 $rap R($%ard :(ll %as
'(/en t%em on t%(s (n add(t(on to not($(n' t%e $o&rt and C(ty Atty as to R($%ard :Cll )e(n' a w(tness,
s&)poena %(m 5t%o&'% t%e earl(er $ont(n&an$e wo&ld appear to (mply %e already (s6 AGF SU=POEGA
T:E OLF CALC3ORGCA GEUROSURGEOG 7:O CAG GET :CS OUT FO7G :ERE 3OR T:E
TRCAL AGF A FEPOSCTCOG PRCOR T:ERETO, ETSPECCALLO COGSCFERCGG T:AT T:E
;ARCOUS POLCCE REPORTS AGF MOTCOGS 3OR ORFERS TO S:O7 CAUSE QUOTE
MERLCSS AS SAOCGG :E 7AS AT T:E PROPERTO CG T:E P7EEKS PRECEEFCGGP T:E
ARREST, ETC+, ETC+ 5T:E STU33 =O==O PUEGTES GOT OOU 7:EG :E COPCEF OOU MO
3CLE, CE MO 3AHES TO =O==O, SET T:CS OUT CLEARLO6+ (3 T:ESE 3OOLS 7AGT TO
:A;E ME ARREST AGF ATTEMPT TO RUG A TRACG OG ME, T:EG T:EO CAG PUT T:E
TCME AGF 7ORK CG AGF GOT P:OGE CT CG 3ROM CALC AGF :A;E T:ECR REGT@A@
LOCAG rCC:ARF :CLL FO CT+
ALSO PLEASE 3CLE A MOTCOG TO d(sm(ss )ased &pon den(al o0 r('%t to a speedy tr(al, spol(at(on
o0 e/(den$e, et$++++
PEACE
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
Tr(al Fate?
3/2I/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 3r( 3/2I/" "2488 AM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
" atta$%ment
Co&'%l(n Tr(al Sett(n'+pd0 5<<"+! K=6
See atta$%ed
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 Tr(al Fate?
3/"/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon 3/"/" I4E AM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
C $an do t%at (0 t%ere (s a 'ood reason to /a$ate t%e date+ 7%at (s t%e reason?
Ke(t%
""/"
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 3r(day, Mar$% 2I, 2" E4! PM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 Tr(al Fate
Please 0(le somet%(n' w(t% t%e $o&rt see.(n' to /a$ate t%at tr(al date and eJpla(n(n' t%at yo& 0a(led to
e/en on$e $ons&lt w(t% yo&r $l(ent pr(or to sett(n' (t+
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3rom4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
S&),e$t4 Tr(al Fate
Fate4 3r(, I Mar 2" "24884"< @2!22
See atta$%ed
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 $o&rt date?
3/"/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon 3/"/" "242 AM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
T%(s e@ma(l (s sent to address t%e 'ro&nds yo& (dent(0(ed as 0orm(n' t%e )as(s o0 a mot(on to d(sm(ss+ As
yo& .now t%ere (s )ot% a $onst(t&t(onal r('%t and a stat&tory r('%t to a speedy tr(al+ T%(s $ase (s now%ere
$lose to a /(olat(on o0 t%e $onst(t&t(onal r('%t to a speedy tr(al+ T%e stat&te does pro/(de 0or a r('%t to
tr(al w(t%(n E2 days o0 arra('nment (n m&n($(pal $o&rt+ GRS "<!+11E56+ Cn t%(s $(r$&mstan$e t%e $o&rt
XmayY d(sm(ss t%e $ompla(nt+ T%e stat&te reN&(res, %owe/er, t%at t%e tr(al not %a/e )een postponed at
t%e reN&est o0 t%e de0endant+ Ct (s my &nderstand(n' t%at t%e Dan&ary "2, 2", tr(al date, was postponed
at yo&r reN&est+ C0 t%at (s tr&e t%en t%ere are not 'ro&nds to d(sm(ss on t%e )as(s o0 a /(olat(on o0 a r('%t
to speedy tr(al+
F(sm(ssal )ased on spol(at(on (s a $(/(l $on$ept+ Ct %as not )een appl(ed to $r(m(nal $ases (n Ge/ada as
o0 yet+ See :(''s /+ State, "E Ge/+ Ad/+ Opn " 52"26+ Rat%er de0endants (n $r(m(nal $ases are
prote$ted 0rom t%e loss o0 e/(den$e (n t%e %ands o0 t%e prose$&t(on )y t%e do$tr(ne o0 d&e pro$ess+
ConseN&ently yo& m('%t %a/e a )as(s to reN&est d(sm(ssal (0 t%e C(ty AttorneySs O00($e lost e/(den$e, (n
(ts possess(on mater(al to t%e $ase+ Cn s&$% $ase (0 t%e C(ty a$ted (n )ad 0a(t% or w(t% $onn(/an$e or (0
yo& were pre,&d($ed )y t%e loss t%en t%ere may )e 'ro&nds on w%($% to )ase a d(sm(ssal+ Please ad/(se
as to w%at e/(den$e was lost and %ow (t was lost+
Oo& %a/e not (dent(0(ed any ot%er 'ro&nds as a )as(s 0or d(sm(ssal+ C0 yo& )el(e/e t%ere are ot%er
'ro&nds, let me .now+
T%an.s
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 T%&rsday, Mar$% 2!, 2" "48E AM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
"/"
S&),e$t4 RE4 $o&rt date
Fear Mr+ Loom(s,
C apolo'(-e S(r 0or w%at C am s&re $omes a$ross as r&deness on my part+ Oo& seem l(.e a 'ood '&y, and
yo& %a/e 'reat %a(r+ C s(mply donMt %a/e t(me, money or ener'y to do any o0 t%(s t%e pol(te way '(/en
t%e P&n(N&enessP o0 t%(s s(t&at(on++++Please ,&st .now C mean yo& no d(srespe$t+
7o&ld yo& please 0(le a reN&est or Mot(on 0or t%e Personnel 3(le o0 RPF O00($er C%r(s Carter and
Sar'ent Mon($a Lope- as well as s&p)oena 0rom t%e RPF all t%e /ol&mns o0 $rap R($%ard :(ll %as
'(/en t%em on t%(s (n add(t(on to not($(n' t%e $o&rt and C(ty Atty as to R($%ard :Cll )e(n' a w(tness,
s&)poena %(m 5t%o&'% t%e earl(er $ont(n&an$e wo&ld appear to (mply %e already (s6 AGF SU=POEGA
T:E OLF CALC3ORGCA GEUROSURGEOG 7:O CAG GET :CS OUT FO7G :ERE 3OR T:E
TRCAL AGF A FEPOSCTCOG PRCOR T:ERETO, ETSPECCALLO COGSCFERCGG T:AT T:E
;ARCOUS POLCCE REPORTS AGF MOTCOGS 3OR ORFERS TO S:O7 CAUSE QUOTE
MERLCSS AS SAOCGG :E 7AS AT T:E PROPERTO CG T:E P7EEKS PRECEEFCGGP T:E
ARREST, ETC+, ETC+ 5T:E STU33 =O==O PUEGTES GOT OOU 7:EG :E COPCEF OOU MO
3CLE, CE MO 3AHES TO =O==O, SET T:CS OUT CLEARLO6+ (3 T:ESE 3OOLS 7AGT TO
:A;E ME ARREST AGF ATTEMPT TO RUG A TRACG OG ME, T:EG T:EO CAG PUT T:E
TCME AGF 7ORK CG AGF GOT P:OGE CT CG 3ROM CALC AGF :A;E T:ECR REGT@A@
LOCAG rCC:ARF :CLL FO CT+
ALSO PLEASE 3CLE A MOTCOG TO d(sm(ss )ased &pon den(al o0 r('%t to a speedy tr(al, spol(at(on
o0 e/(den$e, et$++++
PEACE
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
RE4 Tr(al Fate?
3/"8/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 7ed 3/"8/" 431 PM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Fear Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
My o)l('at(on &nder Ge/ada R&le o0 Pro0ess(onal Cond&$t "+ (s to a)(de )y a $l(entSs de$(s(on
$on$ern(n' t%e o),e$t(/es o0 representat(on and, as reN&(red )y R&le "+8 to $ons&lt w(t% t%e $l(ent as to
t%e means )y w%($% t%e o),e$t(/es o0 representat(on are to )e p&rs&ed+ Z Cn a $r(m(nal $ase t%e lawyer
s%all a)(de )y t%e $l(ents de$(s(on, a0ter $ons&ltat(on w(t% t%e lawyer, as to plea to )e entered, w%et%er
to wa(/e ,&ry tr(al w%et%er t%e $l(ent w(ll test(0y+
Under R&le "+8 5a6516 a lawyer s%all $ons&lt w(t% t%e $l(ent a)o&t any rele/ant l(m(tat(ons on t%e
lawyers $ond&$t w%en t%e lawyer .nows t%at t%e $l(ent eJpe$ts ass(stan$e not perm(tted )y t%e R&les o0
Pro0ess(onal Cond&$t or ot%er law+
Under R&le +"+ Cn represent(n' a $l(ent, a lawyer s%all eJer$(se (ndependent pro0ess(onal ,&d'ment and
render $and(d ad/($e+ Cn render(n' ad/($e, a lawyer may re0er not only to law )&t to ot%er
$ons(derat(ons s&$% as moral e$onom($, so$(al and pol(t($al 0a$tors, t%at may )e rele/ant to t%e $l(entSs
s(t&at(on+
Under R&le 3+"+ A lawyer s%all not )r(n' or de0end a pro$eed(n', or assert or $ontro/ert an (ss&e
t%ere(n, &nless t%ere (s a )as(s (n law and 0a$t 0or do(n' so t%at (s not 0r(/olo&s, w%($% (n$l&des a 'ood
0a(t% ar'&ment 0or an eJtens(on, mod(0($at(on or re/ersal o0 eJ(st(n' law+ A lawyer 0or a de0endant (n a
"3/"
$r(m(nal pro$eed(n' t%at $o&ld res&lt (n (n$ar$erat(on, may ne/ert%eless so de0end t%e pro$eed(n' as to
reN&(re t%at e/ery element o0 t%e $ase )e esta)l(s%ed+
Under R&le 3+5a6 and 5)6+ A lawyer s%all ma.e reasona)le e00orts to eJped(te l(t('at(on $ons(stent w(t%
t%e (nterests o0 t%e $l(ent+
T%e d&ty stated (n para'rap% 5a6 does not pre$l&de a lawyer 0rom 'rant(n' a reasona)le reN&est 0rom
oppos(n' $o&nsel 0or an a$$ommodat(on, s&$% as an eJtens(on o0 t(me, or 0rom d(sa'ree(n' w(t% a
$l(entSs w(s%es on adm(n(strat(/e and ta$t($al matters, s&$% as s$%ed&l(n' depos(t(ons, t%e n&m)er o0
depos(t(ons to )e ta.en, and t%e 0reN&en$y and &se o0 wr(tten d(s$o/ery reN&ests+
Under R&le !+85d6 Ct (s m(s$ond&$t 0or a lawyer to en'a'e (n $ond&$t w%($% (s pre,&d($(al to t%e
adm(n(strat(on o0 ,&st($e+
T%ese, and ot%ers, are t%e pro0ess(onal r&les C operate &nder (n pro/(d(n' le'al representat(on to yo& (n
$ase n&m)er "" CR E821, a $ase (n w%($% yo& are $%ar'ed w(t% t%e $r(me o0 trespass+ Ct (s my
&nderstand(n' t%at yo&r o),e$t(/e (n t%(s $r(m(nal $ase (s t%at yo& )e a$N&(tted o0 t%e $r(me o0 trespass+
T%at (s my p&rpose (n represent(n' yo&+ C am %appy to wor. towards t%at o&t$ome to t%e )est o0 my
a)(l(ty+ Ct (s my op(n(on, %owe/er, t%at m&$% o0 w%at yo& as. to )e done (s not (n $ompl(an$e w(t% t%e
a)o/e r&les+ A$$ord(n'ly, C w(ll not )e 0(l(n' a mot(on to d(sm(ss )ased &pon GRCP E5a6 and 5)6, C see
t%at ar'&ment as 0r(/olo&s+ C w(ll not )e pro$eed(n' w(t% t%e s&mmon(n' o0 an o&t@o0@state w(tness
5Merl(ss6 &nless yo& $an esta)l(s% %(s mater(al(ty to t%e de0ense+ Gor w(ll C )e s&)poena(n' t%e
personnel re$ords o0 law en0or$ement personnel &nless yo& $an esta)l(s% to my sat(s0a$t(on w%y t%ey
are rele/ant to t%(s $ase+ C %a/e no (ntent(on at t%(s t(me o0 $ond&$t(n' any depos(t(ons (n t%e $ase or
send(n' reN&ests 0or prod&$t(on o0 do$&ments or (nterro'ator(es (n t%e $ase+ C see t%ese a$t(ons as
&nd&ly )&rdensome on t%e ,&d($(al system, and &nwarranted )y anyt%(n' yo& %a/e pro/(ded to t%(s
po(nt+ C also see t%em as 0r(/olo&s and an attempt to &t(l(-e t%e $r(m(nal ,&st($e system to a$$ompl(s%
o),e$t(/es not rele/ant to my p&rpose (n represent(n' yo&+
C0 yo& are d(ssat(s0(ed w(t% t%e l(m(tat(ons C per$e(/e to eJ(st re'ard(n' my representat(on o0 yo&, yo&
are wel$ome to term(nate my representat(on o0 yo&+ Oo& may t%en as. t%e Co&rt to appo(nt a new
lawyer to represent yo&+
Ct (s my &nderstand(n' t%at Fep&ty Ma$%em w(ll )e test(0y(n' (n t%e $ase alon' w(t% R($%ard :(ll and
Casey =a.er+
C do t%(n. t%at t%ere are some (nterest(n' an'les to t%e $ase &pon w%($% a de0ense $an )e )ased and C
w(ll )e p&rs&(n' t%ose an'les+ C %a/e as.ed yo& (n pre/(o&s e@ma(ls to pro/(de (n0ormat(on w%($% C
)el(e/e w(ll )e %elp0&l to t%e de0ense o0 yo&r $ase+
C ad/(se yo& t%at t%e C(ty %as o00ered to re$ommend t(me@ser/ed as a senten$e (0 yo& enter a no@$ontest
plea to trespass+ Ct (s also my &nderstand(n' t%at yo& %a/e ot%er $r(m(nal $ases pend(n' (n )ot% Reno
D&st($e Co&rt and (n t%e Se$ond D&d($(al F(str($t Co&rt o0 t%e State o0 Ge/ada+ Ct (s my &nderstand(n'
0&rt%er t%at all o0 t%e $r(m(nal $ases $an )e resol/ed (n a s(n'le plea to a m(sdemeanor o00ense (0 yo&
w(ll o)ta(n psy$%olo'($al $o&nsel(n'+ Ct (s my o)l('at(on to (n0orm yo& o0 t%e a/a(la)(l(ty o0 t%ese
resol&t(ons to t%e present $r(m(nal $ase (n w%($% C pro/(de representat(on+ C w(ll, o0 $o&rse, a)(de )y
yo&r de$(s(on as to w%et%er to a$$ept t%ese resol&t(ons or not+
C note t%at t%ere (s a psy$%(atr($ e/al&at(on s$%ed&led 0or yo& (n nd D&d($(al F(str($t Co&rt Case Go+
CR"@23<E on Apr(l 3, 2"+ T%e o&t$ome o0 t%at e/al&at(on $o&ld %a/e an (mportant (mpa$t on t%(s
$ase+ C am as.(n' t%at yo& a&t%or(-e a release o0 t%e (n0ormat(on $onta(ned (n t%e e/al&at(on to me so
t%at C may determ(ne w%at (mpa$t (t $o&ld %a/e on yo&r )e%al0 (n t%(s $ase+
C rema(n prepared to represent yo& (n t%e trespass $ase+ C t%(n. t%at a tr(al o0 t%e $ase w(ll )e (nterest(n'+
My representat(on, %owe/er, (s $(r$&ms$r()ed )y t%e Ge/ada R&les o0 Pro0ess(onal Cond&$t+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
"8/"
Sent4 T&esday, Mar$% "3, 2" 84I PM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 Tr(al Fate
Fear Mr+ Loom(s,
Cn yo&r mot(on to d(sm(ss, C wo&ld l(.e yo& to really 0o$&s on and set 0ort% to t%e $o&rt t%e 0a$t t%at t%e
e/($t(on order needed to )e ser/ed (n $ompl(an$e w(t% GRCP E5a6 and E5e6+ GRS 82+822 R&les o0
pra$t($e+ T%e pro/(s(ons o0 GRS, Ge/ada R&les o0 C(/(l Pro$ed&re and Ge/ada R&les o0 Appellate
Pro$ed&re relat(/e to $(/(l a$t(ons, appeals and new tr(als, so 0ar as t%ey are not (n$ons(stent w(t% t%e
pro/(s(ons o0 GRS 82+2 to 82+82, (n$l&s(/e, apply to t%e pro$eed(n's ment(oned (n t%ose se$t(ons+
T%e lan'&a'e a)o&t Premo/(n' t%e tenant w(t% (n 8 %o&rs o0 re$e(pt o0 t%e orderP (s only appl($a)le to
t%ose s(t&at(ons w%ere t%e tenant does not 0(le a TenantMs Answer or TenantMs A00(da/(t+ C d(d 0(le s&$% a
TenanMts A00(da/(t, and l(t('ated t%e matter t%oro&'%ly+ Cn t%ose s(t&at(ons, GRS 82+822 reN&(res GRCP
to apply, spe$(0($ally GRCP E5a6 and E5e6, and $learly 7CSO Ma$%em 5please s&)poena and (dent(0y
as w(tnesses Mary Kandaras, EsN+ o0 t%e 7CFA C(/(l F(s/(s(on, 7CSO Fep&ty Ma$%em, and 7CSO
C(/(l F(/(s(on s&per/(sor L(- St&$%ell 0or t%e tr(al (n t%(s matter, and 0&rt%er send o&t a reN&est 0or
prod&$t(on and s&)poena d&$es te$&m to t%e 7CFA and t%e 7CSO as.('n t%em to spe$(0y, (n wr(t(n'
and (n deta(l, t%e eJa$t pro$ed&res and pol($(es (n pla$e w(t% respe$t to t%e ser/($e and $ond&$t(n' o0
s&$% lo$.o&ts 5(e, not de0a&lt lo$.o&ts w%ere t%ere (s not a s&mmary e/($t(on %ear(n', )&t oneMs l(.e t%e
present one, w%ere t%ere was a TenantMs Answer and %ear(n' %eld, et$++++6+ =e s&re to as. w%et%er t%e are
aware o0 w%at Ppersonally ser/edP means, and w%et%er t%ey ma(l t%e Orders on top o0 merely post(n'
t%em to t%e door+ 3&rt%er, C %a/e )een told t%at t%e 7CSO %as a pol($y or penatly system (n pla$e
w%ere)y t%e dep&t(es m&st 'et t%ese lo$.o&ts per0ormed Pw(t%(n 8 %o&rs o0 re$e(pt o0 t%e orderP t%e
re$e(pt )e(n' t%e 7CSOMs re$e(pt, and not t%e tenantMs re$e(pt+ C donMt n$essar(ly read t%e stat&te t%at
way, )&t++++t%e 7CSO pol($y and p&n(s%ment system wo&ld )e at least some (nd($at(on o0 w%at t%e
le'(slat&re meant 5C '&ess, )&t C dontM really t%(n. so, t%o&'%, yo& w(ll note t%at :(ll was le0t w(t%
not%(n' )&t $(t(n' to t%e P&s&al and $&stomary pra$t($e o0 t%e 7CSOP (n ser/(n' t%e E/($t(on ORders
and per0orm('n lo$.o&ts, C )el(e/e, )e$a&se t%e law does not $onta(n m&$% to s&pport :(llMs $ontent(on
and t%ere0ore %e w(s%es to see t%e 7CSO P$&stomary pra$t($esP )e(n' '(/en t%e we('%t o0 law+
Please see some spe$(0($ sele$t(ons atta$%ed 0rom t%e e/($t(on matter+ C .now, C .now, yo& want to
$&rta(l t%e s$ope o0 yo&r representat(on to an (mma$&late de'ree++++)&t :(ll $an $learly )e seen (n %(s
/ar(o&s Mot(on to S%ow Ca&se, State =ar Gr(e/an$es, Temproary Prote$t(on Order Appl($at(ons, et$+,
et$+, to )e a p&n. w%o doesnMt m&$% l(.e $ompet(n' on an e/en play(n' 0(eld, l(.e any 'ood pr(/ate
s$%ooler, %e wo&ld rat%er s($. an atta$. do' on some)ody t%an 'et (n t%e o$to'on and 'o toe to toe
mentally+ Re'ardless, :(ll s%ows a $ont(n&al des(re to s&)/ert GRCP E5e6, w%($% appl(es to ser/($e o0
do$&ments 0(led ele$ron($ally (n t%e Se$ond D&d($(al F(str($t Co&rt+ :e wo&ld rat%er w(t%%old oppos(n'
$o&nsels $omp&ters, laptops, $l(ent 0(les, dr(/erMs l($ense, et$+ T%e last t%(n' %e wants (s to 'o ar'&ment
0or ar'&ment, resear$% 0or resear$%, wr(t(n' 0or wr(t(n'+ Pr(/ate s$%ool and daddyMs plead(n' )an.+ :(ll
0(les a Mot(on to S%ow $a&e alle'e(n' Co&'%l(n s&)/reted an Order t%at was 0(led on Dan&ary ""t%,
2" w(t% Co&'l(nMs a$t(on o0 Dan&ary "t%, 2"+ Under GRCP E5e6, t%e Order Feny(n' t%e TRO %ad
not e/en )een ser/ed yet, and t%ere %as )een no (nd(d$at(on t%at :(ll 'a/e t%e Order at t%e town d&mp
to anyone ot%er t%an an RPF O00($er+
3&rt%er, (t (s not all t%at $lear w%y :(lls Mot(on 0or ORder to S%ow Ca&se deser/es a 0&ll )lown
%ear(n' w%en F< does not (nd($ate a %ear(n' w(ll )e a$$orded to t%e appeal+ T%(s (s part($&larly s&spe$t
'(/en t%at An/&( sets 0ort% t%at appeals (n s&mmary e/($t(on matters are done on a tr(al de no/o )as(s+
T%ere are a n&m)er, )&t %ow a)o&t yo&r $omplete la$. o0 $omm&n($at(on w(t% me pr(or to so sett(n'
t%at date+ :ow a)o&t Mr+ Ta(tel and Mr+ P&entesMs 0a(l&re (n t%(s matter and t%e pre,&d($e to my $ase so
$reated? :ow a)o&t yo&r 0a(l(n' to (dent(0y yo&rsel0 as t%e p&)l($ de0ender to a room 0&ll o0 de0endants
"1/"
(n ,a(l at t%e arra('nment?
T%ere are ot%er reasons as well, (n$l&d(n', )&t not l(m(ted to, yo&r res(stan$e to s&)poena t%e mater(als
C %a/e and am reN&est(n'+
C w(s% 0or yo& to s&)poena t%e personnel 0(les o0 )ot% RPF Sar'ent Mon($a Lope- and O00($er C%r(s
Carter+ C w(s% 0or yo& to l(st Fr+ Merl(ss as a w(tness and s&)poena %(s appearan$e and appropr(ately
not($e t%e C(ty o0 Reno (n t%at re'ard, same 'oes 0or R($%ard :(ll and Casey =a.er 5=a.er, )y letter
dated Go/em)er "2t%, 2"" demands t%e 0&ll rental /al&e 0or t%e property as Pstora'eP &nder GRS
82+13, w%(le also assert(n' %e w(ll 'o a0ter mo/(n' and (n/entory $osts, (n add(t(on to :(llMs $ontra$tor
P%(l Stewarts later r(d($&lo&s $%ar'es and per,&ry+ Please s&)poena Stewart as well+
Most (mportantly s&)poena 7as%oe Co&nty S%er(00Ms O00($e Fep&ty Ma$%em to test(0y and ser/e a
s&)poena d&e$es te$&m, reN&ests 0or prod&$t(on, and (nterro'ator(es see.(n' re$ords and responses
0rom t%e 7CSO as set 0ort% (n t%e letter C sent L(- St&$%ell 5see atta$%ed6 on or a)o&t 3e)r&ary "2t%,
2"+ Oo& see, t%e 7CSO and Fep&ty Ma$%em may )e $omm(tt(n' a 0ra&d &pon t%e p&)l($ )y
repeatedly 0(l(n' a00(da/(ts o0 ser/($e t%at attest to personal ser/($e w%ere L(- St&$%ell, o0 t%e 7CSO
adm(ts t%at t%ey $learly do not .now, or $%oose to Prem(JP t%e le'al mean(n' o0 Ppersonally ser/eP+
3&rt%er, please (n0orm t%e C(ty o0 Reno and appropr(ately not($e t%e same as to t%e eJ(sten$e and (ntent
to o00er (nto e/(den$e a /(deo o0 R($%ard :(ll, EsN+, adm(tt(n' t%at %e and %(s 0(rm, on )e%al0 o0 Fr+
Merl(ss, were w(t%%old(n' t%e a$$&sed personal property, (n add(t(on to t%e $l(entMs 0(les 0rom t%e
0ormer $ommer$(al lease %ome law o00($e o0 t%e a$$&sed and assert(n' a l(en, &nder GRS 82+13 0or
Pstora'eP, %owe/er, as t%e /(deo tape s%ows, :(ll adm(ts to $%ar'(n' t%e &nders('ned t%e same VI22 per
mont% rent as was $%ar'ed 0or t%e P0&ll &se and o$$&pan$yP o0 t%e prem(ses at "" R(/er Ro$. St+,
Reno, G; !I1"+ :(ll 0&rt%er demands t%at property )e remo/ed (n a $erta(n order, re'ardless o0
w%et%er %(s art($(0($ally (n0lated l(en was pa(d or not+ Add(t(onally, :(ll $omm(tted 0ra&d &pon t%e $o&rt
(n a n&m)er o0 (nstan$es and 0(led 0alse pol($e reports w%ere(n %e alle'es t%at %e a'reed to or ot%erw(se
made a/a(la)le to t%e a$$&sed (tems s&$% as t%e a$$&sedMs $l(ents 0(les 5and 0or a t(me wallet and state
(ss&ed dr(/erMs l($ense6 w%ere, $learly, w(t%o&t reN&(r(n' any payment )y t%e a$$&sed, %owe/er, $learly,
t%e 0a$ts s%ow t%at :(ll ne/er a$t&ally l(/ed &p to t%ose assert(ons and repeatedly 0a(led to s%ow
pro/(de s&$% (tems a)sent payment o0 %(s art(0($ally (n0lated l(en+
3&rt%er, C w(s% 0or yo& to d(/&l'e and pro/(de not($e t%at (t (s a/a(la)le 0or p($.&p and t%at we (ntent to
(ntrod&$e (nto e/(den$e a /(deo o0 RPF Sar'ent Mon($a Lope- adm(tt(n' t%at s%e and RPF O00($er
Carter d(d not (dent(0y t%emsel/es as pol($e o00($ers or ot%erw(se as. t%e a$$&sed to lea/e "" R(/er
Ro$. St+ on t%e date o0 t%e arrest pr(or to Merl(ss open(n' t%e door to t%e )asement+ T%(s (s apparently
(n d(re$t $ontrad($t(on to t%e sworn 0(l(n's made )y R($%ard :(ll, EsN+ (n %(s a00(da/(ts atta$%ed to %(s
/ar(o&s Mot(ons to S%ow Ca&se, t%e Reply to Oppos(t(on t%ereto, Oppos(t(on to TRO, et$+, et$+ 5(n RDC
Re/2""@22"<2! and t%e appeal (n C;""@23E!6+ 3or t%at reason alone Merl(ssM presen$e (s reN&(red+
:e was a pre$(p(ent w(tness and yo& are as.(n' me w%y %e s%o&ld )e t%ere? Oo& %a/e a d&ty to
-ealo&sly ad/o$ate on my )e%al0, Mr+ Loom(s+ Oo& are pa(d, )y t%e p&)l($, to do so+ Please d(/&l'e any
pr(or asso$(at(ons yo& %a/e w(t% anyone employed )y or wor.('n as an (ndependent $ontra$tor w(t% t%e
RMC and or t%e Reno C(ty Attorney, (n$l&d(n' anyone yo& went to law s$%ool w(t% or attended t%e
same law s$%ool as, w(t%(n a 1 year per(od+
3&rt%er, C w(s% 0or yo& to 0(le a mot(on see.(n' a m(str(al or ot%erw(se reN&(r(n' t%e re$&sal o0 t%e RMC
and 0&rt%er d(s$los(n' w%y (t (s t%at D&d'e Gardner seem(n'ly %as re$&sed D&d'e F(lwort% 5w%y
wo&ldnMt D&d'e F(lwort% re$&se D&d'e F(lwort%?6 (n one $ase, w(t%o&t deta(l(n' w%y eJa$tly, w%(le
D&d'e Gardner apparently (s (ntent on rema(n(n' on (n "" CR E821, desp(te t%e 0a$t t%at an apparent
$on0l($t eJ(sts, one w%($% %e only d(s$losed &pon prompt(n' 0rom t%e a$$&sed, w(t% respe$t to D&d'e
GardnerMs /ery re$ent employment w(t% t%e Reno C(ty AttorneyMs o00($e and t%e eJ(st(n' and or )rew(n'
l(t('at(on 5or, at least, poss()le l(t('at(on6 )etween t%e a$$&sed and t%e C(ty o0 Reno, Reno C(ty
"E/"
Attorney, and poss()ly, t%e RMC+
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3rom4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
S&),e$t4 RE4 Tr(al Fate
Fate4 Mon, " Mar 2" 2I4E431 @2<22
C $an do t%at (0 t%ere (s a 'ood reason to /a$ate t%e date+ 7%at (s t%e reason?
Ke(t%
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 3r(day, Mar$% 2I, 2" E4! PM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 Tr(al Fate
Please 0(le somet%(n' w(t% t%e $o&rt see.(n' to /a$ate t%at tr(al date and eJpla(n(n' t%at yo& 0a(led to
e/en on$e $ons&lt w(t% yo&r $l(ent pr(or to sett(n' (t+
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3rom4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
S&),e$t4 Tr(al Fate
Fate4 3r(, I Mar 2" "24884"< @2!22
See atta$%ed
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 ( was e/($ted 3 "1 ", ( need a $ont(n&an$e?
423 PM
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 7ed 3/!/" 423 PM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Fear Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
T%(s messa'e (s sent to address (ss&es ra(sed (n t%e e@ma(l yo& sent on 3@E@"+
"+ Please note t%at yo& are 0ree to send t%e $omm&n($at(ons yo& send to me, to anyone else yo& des(re+
Oo& s%o&ld )e aware t%at send(n' yo&r $omm&n($at(ons to ot%er part(es w(ll $a&se yo&r
$omm&n($at(ons to me to lose t%e(r attorney@$l(ent $on0(dent(al(ty+
+ 3or w%at spe$(0($ p&rposes do yo& need a $ont(n&an$e? A $ont(n&an$e p&rely 0or t%e p&rpose o0
delay (s not a proper reason 0or a $ont(n&an$e+
3+ 7%et%er yo& are ent(tled to e@ma(l t%e Reno M&n($(pal Co&rt (s not my $on$ern+ T%at (s a pro)lem to
)e addressed )etween yo& and t%e Co&rt+
8+ Ms+ Fra.e (s no lon'er t%e attorney %andl(n' yo&r $ase 0or t%e Reno C(ty AttorneySs O00($e+ Oo&r
$ase (s now )e(n' %andled )y C%r(stop%er :a-lett@Ste/ens, EsN+
1+ Cn response to yo&r N&est(on re'ard(n' t%e wea.nesses o0 t%e trespass(n' $ase C o00er t%e 0ollow(n'4
"</"
a+ T%e $ompla(nt (s de0($(ent (n t%at (0 0a(ls to set 0ort% t%e elements o0 t%e $r(me o0 trespass+ Ct 0a(ls to
(dent(0y w%et%er yo&r presen$e on t%e prem(ses was 0or t%e p&rpose to /eJ or annoy t%e owner or
o$$&pant o0 t%e prem(ses or w%et%er (t was an entry onto t%e prem(ses a0ter a warn(n' not to so
trespass+ T%(s (s pro)a)ly eas(ly remed(ed )y an amendment at t%e t(me o0 tr(al+ Ge/ert%eless t%ese are
alternat(/e t%eor(es on w%($% a trespass $ase $an )e p&rs&ed and t%e de0endant (s ent(tled to .now on
w%($% t%eory or t%eor(es a $ase (s )e(n' prose$&ted (n ad/an$e o0 s%ow(n' &p 0or tr(al+
)+ Oo& 0(led an appeal on O$to)er "I, 2"", apparently, o0 t%e order made )y D&st($e o0 t%e Pea$e
S0erra--a on O$to)er "3, 2""+ T%at order den(ed yo&r reN&est 0or a $ont(n&an$e and 'ranted s&mmary
e/($t(on &nless yo& 0(led a depos(t w(t% t%e $o&rt+ Typ($ally t%e $o&rts lose ,&r(sd($t(on to r&le on ot%er
matters (n t%e $ase on$e an appeal (s ta.en+ Ct (s $lear 0rom t%e $o&rt re$ords t%at t%(s appeal was
pend(n' )e0ore t%e Se$ond D&d($(al F(str($t Co&rt at t%e t(me t%e $o&rt %eld a %ear(n' on t%e &nlaw0&l
deta(ner on O$to)er 1, 2""+ Ct may well )e t%at t%e D&st($e Co&rt lost ,&r(sd($t(on to %old t%e e/($t(on
%ear(n' w%(le t%e appeal was pend(n'+
$+ C am wor.(n' on some ot%er t%o&'%ts+
E+ C0 yo& are d(ssat(s0(ed w(t% t%e way C am represent(n' yo&, yo& rema(n 0ree to see. a new attorney+
<+ Anot%er $%&$.le re'ard(n' my owners%(p o0 str(p $l&)s+ C donSt own or %a/e any owners%(p (nterest
(n any str(p $l&)s, )rot%els, ad&lt )oo. stores or mo/(e %o&ses+ C '&ess t%at lea/es me 0ree to moral(-e+
!+ C st(ll donSt see t%e (mportan$e o0 Fr+ Merl(ss+ T%e reN&est 0or payment o0 an amo&nt eN&al to rent,
was 0or stora'e o0 yo&r personal property+ Oo& are ent(tled to $ontest t%e amo&nt o0 t%e stora'e 0ee,
w%($% yo& d(d+ T%ere (s no $red()le e/(den$e anyw%ere w%($% s&''ests t%at anyone (ntended to reopen
or $reate a new tenan$y allow(n' yo& to reta(n possess(on o0 t%e prem(ses+
I+ Fr+ Merl(ss (s an o&t o0 state w(tness+ Cn order to $ompel %(s appearan$e, %(s test(mony m&st )e
mater(al+ GRS "<8+815"6+ Ct does not appear t%at %(s test(mony (s mater(al &nder t%e (n0ormat(on yo&
%a/e pro/(ded 3&rt%er, &nder GRS "<8+8156 %e (s ent(tled to )e pa(d %(s s&)s(sten$e and tra/el
eJpenses (n$&rred (n $om(n' to Ge/ada+ Are yo& prepared to pay t%ose eJpenses (n ad/an$e o0 %(s
$om(n' to Ge/ada?
"2+ C donSt (ntend to 0aJ or e@ma(l to yo&, yo&r 0&ll 0(le (n t%(s $ase+ Oo& already %a/e e/eryt%(n' w(t%
t%e eJ$ept(on o0 a $o&ple o0 (tems w%($% C ma(led to yo&r old address+ C w(ll send t%em a'a(n to yo&r
new address+ C0 yo& want to re/(ew t%e 0(le yo& are wel$ome to do so at my o00($e+ C0 yo& want $op(es
o0 anyt%(n' (n t%e 0(le yo& may mar. t%e (tems+ A0ter '(/(n' yo& a $ost est(mate, 0or w%($% C reN&(re
payment (n ad/an$e, we w(ll pro/(de yo& w(t% $op(es o0 t%e mar.ed (tems+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 Monday, Mar$% E, 2" "2433 PM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net9 sterm(t-*s)$'lo)al+net9 ,md*randa--a+$om9 ,)oles*$allat'+$om9
.r(st(emann(n'*ya%oo+$om9 .adl($,*reno+'o/
S&),e$t4 ( was e/($ted 3 "1 ", ( need a $ont(n&an$e
Fear Mr+ Loom(s,
C was wron'0&lly e/($ted on 3 "1 ", and C need a $ont(n&an$e (n t%e $r(m(nal trespass matter t%at yo&
set o/erly N&($.ly a'a(nst my eJpress w(s%es anyway+ My a)(l(ty to $olle$t e/(den$e ne$essary to my
de0ense and ot%erw(se prepare %as )een ad/ersely a00e$ted+ Add(t(onally, C donMt 0eel as t%o&'% yo& are
per0orm(n' (n an appropr(ate manner as de0ense $o&nsel, )&t rat%er yo& seem st&$. (n yo&r
prose$&tor(al ways, too N&($. to loo. 0or any eJ$&se w%atsoe/er to )&ry oneMs $ase, so C t%(n. yo& %a/e
0or$ed a spl(t %ere, w%($% 0&rt%er pre,&d($es my $ase and a&'ers towards a $ont(n&an$e+ Please mo/e
0or one (mmed(ately and $opy me on my ent(re 0(le )y ema(l and 0aJ please+ Add(t(onally, please see.
$lar(0($at(on 0rom t%e RMC as to w%et%er C am allowed to e/er send an ema(l to
renom&n($re$ords*reno+'o/+ Please note, today, D&d'e 3lana'an den(ed R($%ard :(llMs latest 0r(/olo&s
"!/"
mot(on+
F(d yo& .now t%at Ke/(n Kelly, o0 t%e State =ar o0 Ge/adaMs C%ara$ter and 3(tness Comm(ttee 0or at
least t%e last de$ade owns and r&ns t%e Spearm(nt R%(no str(p $l&) (n Las ;e'as4
%ttp4//www+re/(ew,o&rnal+$om/l/r,L%ome/22/Mar@2E@7ed@22/news/"!8"81+%tml
C .now C always l(.e my t%ree %o&r to&rs o0 %ea/y %anded moral(-(n' 0rom someone w%o r&ns a
monol(t%($ str(p $l&) (n Las ;e'as+
Oo& are on t%e State =ar o0 Ge/adaMs 0ee d(sp&te $omm(ttee, arenMt yo& Mr+ Loom(s? Fo yo& own any
str(p $l&)s?
Mr+ Loom(s, w%($% o0 t%e elements o0 t%e trespass $%ar'e RMC !+"2+282 do yo& 0eel are wea.est 0or
Fep&ty C(ty Attorney D(ll Fra.e, w%om C (n0ormed a)o&t t%e adm(ss(on )y Reno PF O00($er C%r(s
Carter t%at R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ )r()es %(m, )&t 0or w%($% Ms+ Fra.e (nd($ated a $omplete la$. o0
(nterest and eJpressed t%at s%e wo&ld not )e 0ollow(n' &p on t%at report o0 )r()ery o0 a RPF O00($er+
Mr+ Kadl($, please pla$e a $opy o0 t%(s $orresponden$e (n D(ll Fra.eMs personnel 0(le+ Add(t(onally
please pla$e one (n All(son OrmaaMs personnel and employment 0(le too, (n add(t(on to Fep&ty C(ty
Attorney Fan 7on'Ms employment 0(le, as all t%ree o0 t%ose Fep&ty C(ty AttorneyMs were pro/(ded t%at
report and all t%ree (nd($ated t%ey d(d not $are and %ad no (ntent(on o0 0ollow(n' &p or ot%erw(se
(n/est('at(n' t%e adm(ss(on )y RPF O00($er C%r(s Carter t%at R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ )r()ed %(m+ C t%(n.
t%e 0a(l&re to 0ollow &p )y any o0 t%ese 3 Fep&ty C(ty AttorneyMs relates to any 0&t&re ne'l('ent %(r(n',
tra(n(n', and s&per/(s(on $la(ms t%at t%e Reno C(ty Attorney may need to de0end a'a(nst w%en
represent(n' t%e Reno PF l(.e (t d(d (n t%e Eeo0 /+ P(tsno'le $ase4
%ttp4//www+l/r,+$om/news/reno@o00($(al@a$$&sed@o0@w(tness@tamper(n'@""E1!E1!+%tml
Oo& .now, Fep&ty C(ty Attorney OrmaasMs de$(s(on to p&s% on 0or t%at V<2 tra00($ t($.et (s loo.(n'
more and more (nterest(n'+ BB
O%, and, Mr+ Loom(s, Fr+ Merl(ss presen$e (s ne$essary )e$a&se %(s &nderstand(n' o0 t%e eJtent to
w%($% %(s attorney, R($%ard G+ :(ll, EsN+ %ad e00e$t(/ely res$(nded any e/($t(on Order )y send(n' a )(ll
0or t%e same amo&nt as 0&ll &se and o$$&pany o0 t%e lo$at(on at "" R(/er Ro$. St+ 'oes to t%e
s&)stan$e o0 t%e elements 0o&nd (n RMC !+"2+282 as well as t%e $red()(l(ty o0 )ot% Merl(ss and :(ll+
S(n$erely,
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, PO =OH E2I1, REGO, G;, !I12E, tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
Close Pr(nt
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 rm$ "" $r E821 yo& are appo(nted $o&nsel? 0or p&entes ne ta(tel??
/</"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To M#a$% Co&'%l(nM
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon /</" 34< PM
To4 M#a$% Co&'%l(nM 5-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om6
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
E@ma(l wor.s well 0or me+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 Monday, 3e)r&ary <, 2" <41E AM
"I/"
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 rm$ "" $r E821 yo& are appo(nted $o&nsel? 0or p&entes ne ta(tel?
%(, ( '&ess Mr+ Loom(s was appo(nted as my 3rd de0ense attorney (n RMC $ase "" $r E821+ C %a/e not
%eard anyt%(n' a)o&t t%(s $ase, and t%e RMC (nd($ated t%ey %ad not%(n' s$%ed&led+ Please
$omm&n($ate w(t% me only /(a ema(l or 0aJ please, %a/(n' (ss&es w(t% my ma(l (n$(dent to domest($
/(olen$e $omm(tted a'a(nst me my 0aJ (s I8I EE< <82+ t%an.s,
#a$% Co&'%l(n
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
$o&rt date?
3/21/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To M#a$% Co&'%l(nM
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 Mon 3/21/" 842I PM
To4 M#a$% Co&'%l(nM 5-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om6
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
C %a/e reN&ested t%at $o&rt set yo&r trespass $ase 0or tr(al (n a)o&t 32 days+ C w(ll let yo& .now t%e date
and t(me as soon as C .now+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 $o&rt date?
3/2</"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 7ed 3/2</" 843E PM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
On w%at 'ro&nds, ot%er t%an t%ose already set 0ort% (n yo&r eJ(st(n' mot(on, do yo& )el(e/e a mot(on to
d(sm(ss s%o&ld )e 0(led?
Ke(t% Loom(s
3rom4 #a$% Co&'%l(n Tma(lto4-a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$omU
Sent4 7ednesday, Mar$% 2<, 2" "481 AM
To4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
S&),e$t4 RE4 $o&rt date
Mr+ Loom(s,
Please $opy me on any and all $orresponden$es, 0(l(n', or ot%er do$&mentat(on or /er)al reN&ests,
$orresponden$es, et$+ t%at yo& s&)m(t to t%e Co&rt, (n$l&d(n' t%e one yo& re0eren$e )elow+ Please do
not 0ollow Ta(telMs ta$t o0 a'ree(n' to reN&ests or 0a(l(n' to oppose mot(ons w(t%o&t e/en attempt(n' to
o)ta(n my perm(ss(on to (n ad/an$e t%ereo0+
C wo&ld l(.e 0or yo& to dra0t a Mot(on to F(sm(ss (n t%(s $ase 0or me re/(ew+
2/"
T%an.s,
#a$% Co&'%l(n, EsN+, "8 E+ It% St+ A, REGO, G; !I1", tel4 <<1 33! !""!, 0aJ4 I8I EE< <829
#a$%Co&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om Ge/ada =ar Go4 I8<3
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
3rom4 .e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
S&),e$t4 $o&rt date
Fate4 Mon, 1 Mar 2" "E42I4"I @2!22
Mr+ Co&'%l(n4
C %a/e reN&ested t%at $o&rt set yo&r trespass $ase 0or tr(al (n a)o&t 32 days+ C w(ll let yo& .now t%e date
and t(me as soon as C .now+
Ke(t% Loom(s
3&ll /(ew
W
W
=a$. to messa'es
RE4 $o&rt date?
3/2I/"
Ke(t% Loom(s
To -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
3rom4 Ke(t% Loom(s 5.e(t%loom(s*eart%l(n.+net6
Sent4 3r( 3/2I/" "24"8 AM
To4 -a$%$o&'%l(n*%otma(l+$om
Go worr(es+ Made me la&'%+
Co&ple o0 N&est(ons4
F(d yo& 0(le an appeal 0rom D&st($e o0 t%e Pea$e S0erra--aSs e/($t(on order?
C0 yes, %as (t )een resol/ed?
F(d S0erra--a anno&n$e at t%e $lose o0
"/"
REC EIVED
FIL 0
;':' ' I "i: CIPf..L COURT
Case o. 11 TR 2680021
APR 13 2012
Dept. 0.3 '-'I""[)
H 10: II i I .. II i I I I
Reno Cour1

'::L J. I,,:: LCU, T
DeputyClerk
BY
IN THEMUNICIPALCOURTOFTHECITYOFRE ODEPUTY
CO TYOF WASHOESTATEOF EVADA
CITYOFRE 0,
Plaintiff,
ORDER RELEASING PROPERTY
vs.
ZACHARYBARKERCOUGHLm,
Defendant.
----------------------,/
IT IS ORDERED that the\ ashoeCountySheriffsOfficeshallreleaseto the
Defendant,ZACHARYBARKERCOUGHLIN, threeitemstakenfrom him on February27,
20I2, althe'I ashoeCountyRegional DetentionFacility duringhisbooking for incarceration
pun;uaru to impo itionof a 5-dayjailsentencefor ContemptofCourtin theabove-entitled
case,towit: one amsungCell Phone;oneT-MobileCell Phone;and oneBraunElectric
Razor, as identified in Case umberWC 12-1805 and referred to underControl#C-47951.
Datedthis29
th
dayof March,2012.

Reno Municipal Judge
FW: CHANGE OF ADDRESS Goodnight speedy trial motion? and RE: Dogan's !or"in'
#onstr$#tion #ommentary?
%&'(&')
Reply ?
*a#h Co$ghlin
+o st$ttle,!ashoe#o$nty-$s. /yo$ng,da-!ashoe#o$nty-$s. phalstead,da-!ashoe#o$nty-$s.
m"andaras,da-!ashoe#o$nty-$s. !illiam-rempel,latimes-#om. ed,npri-org.
0goodnight,!ashoe#o$nty-$s. 1dogan,!ashoe#o$nty-$s. 01osler,!ashoe#o$nty-$s.
0leslie,!ashoe#o$nty-$s. 1illda2is,la"es-n2-go2. s3armer,la"es-n2-go2. oli2ero#s"ay,yahoo-#om
Hotmail A#ti2e 4ie!
4ideo 3rom 5o$+$1e
Dear 6r- +$ttle et al.
7lease a##ept this !riting as the #orresponden#e yo$ re8$ested 3rom me- 9 ha2e not re#ei2ed any o3 the
3ilings 3rom either the DA or the 7D sin#e last 9 2isited the R:C Criminal Di2ision 3iling o33i#e and
re8$ested #opies o3 e2erything in the 3ile- 6y re#ords indi#ate that that last 2isit ;and 9 am re3erring to
2isits !here 9 !as allo!ed to re#ei2e s$#h #opies only< !as appro=imately appro=imately Fe1r$ary
)>th. )>') ;tho$gh 9 am s$re Ne3i !ill ha2e notated !hen last 9 !as in there and pro2ided #opies. as he
is 2ery #ons#ientio$s and thoro$gh. a real #redit to the Criminal Di2ision Filing O33i#e<-
9 ha2e had some di33i#$lties lately !ith the ?S7S deli2ering my mail- Some. li"e the @&'@&') letter
3rom the R:C Ci2il Di2ision. did in 3a#t. $ltimately ma"e it to me. in a##ordan#e !ith the Change o3
Address 9 3iled !ith the ?S7S- Other pie#es o3 mail. s$#h as a @&'%&') mailing 3rom the Reno
6$ni#ipal Co$rt. !ere $ltimately ret$rned to the R6C- With respe#t to any #o$rt do#$ments.
#orresponden#e. or #o$rt 3ilings in matters 3or !hi#h Airay Dogan is atta#hed. 9 ha2e re#ei2ed nothing
in the mail. and 9 am pretty s$re 9 ha2e not re#ei2ed a #opy o3 any s$#h matters 2ia 3a= or email
;despite my n$mero$s !ritten please to 6r- Dogan et al at the WC7D. !herein 9 set 3orth the
inter3eren#e !ith my mail and #on#omitant str$ggles !ith the ?S7S that ens$ed in#ident to my 1eing
ad0$dge a 2i#dtim o3 domesti# 2iolen#e in F4')B>>'CC and F4')B>>'CD. in addition to the
mal3easan#e o3 the landlord and its agents in R:C Re2)>')B>>>@D%-
So. my please to the WC7D ;Dogan and Goodnight< that 9 1e #opied 2ia 3a= and email on all
do#$mentation. 3ilings. et#- ha2ing gone $nresponded to ;tho$gh 9 1elie2e 6r- Goodnight. to his #redit.
has a#t$ally done so one or t!i#e. in addition to phoning me !hile 9 !as in 0ail in#ident to a s$mmary
#ontempt 3inding 1y :$dge Nash Holmes. !hi#h res$lted in my smart phone 1eing sei/ed in#ident to
the s$mmary #ontempt arrest. and it and a @)g1 mi#ro sd #ard 1eing ret$rned to me only @C days later.
!ith the #ontents o3 the mi#ro sd #ard ha2ing 1een erased----and only a3ter the WCSO re3$sed to
#omply !ith the R6C Order o3 @&@>&'). 1$t rather pass me o33 to 6ary Eandaras. o3 the Distri#t
Attorney's O33i#e. !hi#h 1rings $p the point. 9 3eel yet another #on3li#t no! e=ists re8$iring the
Distri#td Attorney's o33i#e to !ithdra! 3rom this prose#$tion. gi2en the $ltra s$spi#io$s #ir#$mstan#es
o3 the sei/ing o3 this mi#ro sd #ard and smartphone. the prolonged detention thereo3. and the s$spi#io$s
eras$re o3 its #ontents. parti#$larly in the #onte=t o3 the WCSO stalling the ret$rning thereo3 !ith
dire#tions to #onta#t 6ary Eandaras. espe#ially !here 6atty o3 the WCSO 3ront des" re3$sed to tell
me !hom ga2e here those instr$#tions to pass along. 1$t rather. !here 6atty responded 1y ha2ing
Dep$ty Aeatson tra#" me do!n o$tside and threaten me !ith mali#io$s prose#$tion and retaliatory
arrest and !here he threatened to #ompletely 3a1ri#ate a distr$1ing the pea#e #harge merely in an
attempt to #on3is#ate the net1oo" 9 had in my hands. pres$m1aly so the WCSO #o$ld sei/e that item
too 3or some @C days only to ret$rn it !ith the hard dri2e !iped-
So. any!ays. yes. please 6r- +$ttle. please a##ept this !riting as the re8$est 3or #opies o3 #o$rt 3ilings
that yo$ as"ed me to pro2ide yo$ gi2en the 3ail$re o3 6r- Goodnight ;to some e=tent< and 6r- Dogan
;to e2ery e=tent< to either mail me #opies. and or to alert me to the 3a#t that they re#ei2ed any s$#h
mailing 1a#" 3rom the ?S7S as $ndeli2era1le or other!ise-
Fastly. 6r- +$ttle. 9 !ill point o$t ;gi2en the interest yo$ e=pressed in my disatis3a#dtion !ith ho!
these #ompeten#y e2al$ation Orders !ere 1eing pro#$red< that not only does the 3ile in many matters
indi#ate s$#h an Order !as rendered a3ter a hearing and $pon a motion 1y the de3endant's #o$nsel
;!here no hearing too" pla#e. and !here no motion !as e2er 3iled----#an't ha2e an oral motion i3
there !as not a#t$al hearing---#an't ma"e oral motions to the 3iling o33i#e #o$nter. #orner #$t. #orner #$t.
ts"---ts"---<G1$t no!. at least a##ording to 6r- Aosler. !hom !as hand pi#"ed. at least in part. 1y
Distri#t Attorney Gammi#" ;!hom did in2ite me 1a#" 3or a 3ollo! $p to my inter2ie!. to o33er some
ad2i#e. a #lassy and tho$ght3$l gest$re to 1e s$re< http:&&!!!-ne!sre2ie!-#om&reno&ne!B
de3ender&#ontent?oidH)%I@C . the Co$rt itsel3 is insisting 9 $tili/e only that entity that the Washoe
Co$nty 7$1li# De3ender has a re8$irements #ontra#t !ith. Fa"e's Crossing. to per3orm a #ompeten#y
e2al$ation 3or !hi#h the stat$tory re8$irements only #onsist o3 #ertain #erti3i#ations and li#ens$res
1eing re8$ired o3 those per3orming the e2al$ations. and !hi#h say nothing o3 the re8$irements #ontra#t
!ith Fa"e's Crossing that 6r- Aosler spea"s o3- 6r- Aosler has re3$sed to #ompensate my #hoi#es o3
e2al$ators or other!ise reim1$rse me 3or this se#ond ro$nd o3 #ompeten#y e2al$ations ;a ro$nd !hi#h
!as highly s$rprising #onsidering that :$dge S3erra//a re3$sed to a##ept the 1ill 3rom Fa"e's Crossing
a3ter the 3irst #ompeten#y e2al$ation. parti#$larly !here :$dge S3erra//a #hided D7D :oe Goodnight
3or see"ing to !ithdra!al so soon a3ter insisting $pon a #ompeten#y e2al$ation- :$dge S3erra//a
sagely pointed o$t to Goodnight. 3$rther. that #on2i#tion !o$ld ha2e dire #onse8$en#es $pon 6r-
Goodnight's #lient's la! li#ense ;the #rime #harge is li"ely a serio$s o33ense !ithin the p$r2ie! o3
SCR '''<. something !hi#h 6r- Goodnight !as s$re to point o$t he didn't m$#h #are a1o$t and didn't
#onsider part o3 his 0o1- 6r- Goodnight. did. ho!e2er. ta"e #are to point o$t to his #lient. Co$ghlin.
the 'holisti#' approa#h that the WC7D li"es to ta"e. early on in the representation- Apparently s$#h a
holisti# approa#h does not m$#h ta"e into a##o$nt the e33e#t on one's li2elihood s$#h a prose#$tion as
this !o$ld ha2e sho$ld a #on2i#tion 1e had- What. perhaps. is most dist$r1ing a1o$t this #ase.
ho!e2er. is the 3a#t that 2ideo and a$dio e2iden#e e=ists pro2ing that this !as a !rong3$l arrest and
that the material !itness is a liar. and that a retaliatory moti2e !as displayed thro$gho$t the arrest. and
that perhaps. an e=tortionate attempt to se#$re #onsent to an impermissi1le sear#h !as made 1y
O33i#er Dosa ;note to Goodnight. please see" to ha2e this #ase dismissed 1ased $pon the State
#ontin$ally re3erring to O33i#er Rosa as O33i#er Dosa in the Complaint. perhaps. an error that !o$ld
#a$se many to miss the 3a#t that O33i#er Rosa !as named in a s$it. in his o33i#ial #apa#ity in 'II%.
something 3or !hi#h Co$ghlin has re8$ested Goodnight and the WC7D loo" into. 1$t 3or !hi#h no
resear#h on the part o3 the WC7D has 1een $nderta"en----< http:&&!!!-yo$t$1e-#om&!at#h?
2HJ7RD8%O9J1>
Well. then there is the 3a#t that the in2estigator 3or DDA 5o$ng s$ggested p$rs$ing a intimidating a
!itness #harge against the in2estigator 3or the de3endant merely 1e#a$se the de3endant's in2estigator
#a$ght the State's star material !itness. Nate *arate. !ho is a liar. attempting to intimidate one Ni#ole
Watson. !ho admitted to the in2estigator. on tape. that *arate's 2ersion o3 the e2ents o3 the arrest o3
C&)>&'' !ere ina##$rate !hen she re2ealed that she hersel3 !itnessed the $nidenti3ied man hold the
iphone alo3t. and e=#laim to the deni/ens o3 the CalBNe2ada i#eBrin" s"ate pla/a. that he !o$ld thro!
this iphone in the ri2er i3 someone doesn't #laim it right a!ay----. !hi#h o3 #o$rse #ompletely
#ontradi#ts *arate's telling O33i#er D$ralde that he !itnessed Co$ghlin gra1 the phone o33 the #on#ret
ledge and !al" a!ay !ith it-----lies. lies. lies. *arate- F$rther lying is 6r- Go1le. allegedly the phone's
o!ner. !ho #laims he !as a mere 'J 3eet a!ay 3rom his phone. yet. someone. he didn't hear this
$nidenti3ied man hold the phone alo3t and anno$n#e to e2eryone in the s"ate pla/e. in a lo$d. 1ooming
2oi#e. that he !o$ld thro! this phone in the ri2er i3 someone doesn't #laim it right a!ay----
http:&&!!!-yo$t$1e-#om&!at#h?2HtoG?OF9##F!
What is interesting. is that. i3 the Reno City Attorney's o33i#e re#ently re3$sed to pro2ide R6C de3ender
Eeith Foomis a #opy o3 the #d propo$nded to Co$ghlin's pre2io$s de3ender Ro1erto 7$entes. 1e#a$se.
a##ording to the Reno City Attorney's O33i#e. it #ost them K)>> to ha2e a #opy o3 a #d made. they ha2e
to send it o$t. 1lah. 1lah. 1lah-----then 0$st ho! m$#h money is Fa"e's Crossing getting paid to do these
#ompeten#y e2al$ations?
Co$ld this 1e the same reason that the City o3 Reno does not list the #ost it pays 3or employees health
#are 1ene3its !hen reporting its 1$dget? Fets ta"e R7D Sargent +arter. 3or instan#e. !hom Co$ghlin
!as #ross e=aming a1o$t an admission o3 1ri1ery o3 the Reno 7D in2ol2ing lo#al attorney Ri#hard G-
Hill. Es8- ;in the #onte=t o3 e=amining !hether Sargent +arter's tra33i# #itations !ere 1ased in a
retaliatory moti2e<. shortly 1e3ore R6C :$dge Nash Holmes sei/ed Co$ghlin's smartphone and @)g1
mi#ro sd #ard. in a tra33i# #itation trial. '' +R )(C>>. and ordered lo#al attorney Co$ghlin to spend J
days in 0ail ;pre0$di#e to his #lient's #ases 1e damned< in#ident to a s$mmary #ontempt 3inding---
http:&&!!!-transpa-#om&sarentne2ada-#om&salaries&)>''&reno&0ohnBtarter&
+he City o3 Reno 3ailed to report the #ost o3 employee health #are 1ene3its- Only the #ost o3 retirement
1ene3its is in#l$ded !ithin the Aene3its #ategory 3or this 0$risdi#tion-
http:&&!!!-transparentne2ada-#om&salaries&)>>I&reno&0ohnBtarter&
DDA 5o$ng and Halstead !ere #opied on this to a2oid an appearan#e o3 e= parte #omm$n#iations.
tho$gh R:C Co$rt Administrator re8$ested this !riting. and tho$gh no R:C :$dge is #opied hereon---
Sin#erely.
Sin#erely.
*a#h Co$ghlin. Es8-. 7O AOL @I('. RENO. N4. CIJ>J. tel: DDJ @@C C''C. 3a=: I%I ((D D%>)M
*a#hCo$ghlin,hotmail-#om Ne2ada Aar No: I%D@
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
From: /a#h#o$ghlin,hotmail-#om
+o: 01osler,!ashoe#o$nty-$sM loode!,hotmail-#omM 1illda2is,la"es-n2-go2M s3armer,la"es-n2-go2M
stermit/,s1#glo1al-netM 0goodnight,!ashoe#o$nty-$sM oli2ero#s"ay,yahoo-#om
S$10e#t: CHANGE OF ADDRESS Goodnight speedy trial motion? and RE: Dogan's !or"in'
#onstr$#tion #ommentary
Date: 6on. '( Apr )>') )':%):') B>D>>
6r- Aosler.
+han" yo$ 3or yo$r response- A#t$ally. in at least one o3 the Orders 3or Competen#y E2al$ation. 9 sa!
that the only mention o3 Fa"e's Crossing !as something s#ra!led o$t in hand!riting atop the Order-
Are yo$ s$re it !as the Co$rt that ordered 9 $tili/e only Fa"e's Crossing? Wo$ldn't that 1e a 1it
$nto!ard 3or a #o$rt to insist 9 $tili/e only one entity !hen a stat$te spe#i3ies merely that 9 m$st $tili/e
an indi2id$al !ith a #ertain #erti3i#ation- 9 reali/e that is pretty m$#h the 1$siness model o3 the p$1li#
de3enders o33i#e. it. a #o$rt agreeing to pro2ide a #o$nsel. 1$t then insisting that the de3endant may
only re#ei2e paid representation i3 the de3endant $tili/es the attorney pro2ided 1y the p$1li# de3ender's
o33i#e ;tho$gh. see Widdis 2- Se#ond :$di#ial Distri#t Co$rt 3or a #o$nterpoint to that<. 1$t 9 am not
s$re that approa#h e=tends all the !ay to #ompeten#y e2al$ations- Can yo$ #lari3y that. indeed. it is
the Co$rt insisting 9 $tili/e Fa"e's Crossing 3or the e2al$ation. and not 0$st that that is yo$r !ish
gi2en yo$r re8$irements #ontra#t !ith Fa"es? F$rther. 9 really !o$ld appre#iate a !ritten response
3rom yo$ as to ho! Dogan's as"ing me i3 9 !as #$rrently !or"in' #onstr$#tion !hile sneeringly
loo"ing me $p and do!n !as at all appropriate-
9 ha2e ne2er re#ei2ed this s$pposed Order 3or Competen#y E2al$ation in the matter Dogan is attorney
o3 re#ord on- 9 ha2e re8$ested Dogan send me a #opy o3 my 3ile. yet 9 ha2e not re#ei2ed one- 7lease
email or 3a= me a #opy o3 my 3ile in the matter Dogan is appearing on as !ell as in the matter
Goodnight is appearing in- 6r- +$ttle has re3$sed to pro2ide me those materials. espe#ially the ne!er
3ilings- 6r- +$ttle. please let this !riting ser2e as my re8$est that yo$ pro2ide me a #opy o3 all
materials ne! to either 3ile sin#e last 9 2ent$red into the R:C Criminal Di2ision 3iling o33i#e. ;an dealt
!ith all the harrasment 1y R:C Aaili33 :ohn Reyes. he o3 the 9 am going to p$t my 3oot $p yo$r ass
se=$al assa$lt #ommitted $pon me in 3$ll 2ie! o3 Washoe Co$nty 7$1li# De3ender's :im Feslie and :oe
Goodnight. !hom ea#h did nothing !hatsoe2er<-
6r- Goodnight. the Go +rial date in the matter yo$ are attorney o3 re#ord on 3ast approa#hes- 9 ha2e
as"ed 3or yo$ to ma"e se2eral 3ilings on my 1ehal3. and yet. 9 ha2e not heard 3rom yo$- 7lease $pdate
me in !riting !ith respe#t to all those re8$ests. in#l$ding. 1$t not limited to. the Si=th Amendment
Right to A Speedy +rial 6otion to Dismiss that 9 ha2e re8$ested yo$ 3ile 1ased $pon the State's 3ail$re
to appropriately arraign me on the amended #harge. as !ell as s$1poening Ni#ole Watson. Ro1
Da!son. F$#y Ayington. et al. and e=plaining yo$r d$m13o$nding de#ision to s$1poena Colton
+empleton 1e3ore any o3 those indi2id$als- 7lease identi3y and or dis#lose the 2ideo and a$dio
materials to 1e p$t 3orth at trial. espe#ially the one !here Ni#ole Watson admits to hearing the man say
he !o$ld thro! the phone in the ri2er. yo$ "no!. the one !here the State's star !itness. Nate *arate.
8$i#"ly see"s to diss$ade Ni#ole Watson 3rom ma"ing any 3$rther statements that sho! *arate to 1e the
liar and $ntr$st!orthy !itness that he is? +hat one-
F$rther. 6s- 7elosi 3rom Fa"e's Crossing has made statements similar to those made 1y 6r- Aosler.
!ith respe#t to the p$1li# 1eing 3or#ed to send 1$siness Fa"e's Crossing's !ay anytime a #ompeten#y
e2al$ation is ordered- 9 !o$ld appre#iate a response 3rom a s$per2isor at Fa"e's Crossign !ith respe#t
to !hy the e2al$ation !as not #ond$#ted !hen 9 presented on time last +h$rsday. and as to the antiB
tr$st matters re3eren#ed herein-
9 reali/e 6r- Aosler !as #hosen to 1e the 7$1li# De3ender in large part 1e#a$se Distri#t Attorney
Gammi#" appro2ed o3 6r- Aosler. 1$t 9 !o$ld still li"e some /ealo$s representation here:
http:&&!!!-ne!sre2ie!-#om&reno&ne!Bde3ender&#ontent?oidH)%I@C
F$rther. 9 reali/e my 1eing a National 6erit Finalist. passing the 1ar e=amination a3ter my se#ond year
o3 la! s#hool. 1eing ran"ed in the top '> in my la! s#hool #lass. 1eing a li#ensed patent attorney. ha2e
e=tremely deep ties to the #omm$nity 9 spent the last @) years in and !here my entire 3amily resides.
ha2ing litigation e=perien#e. and repeatedly applying 3or a position !ith the Washoe Co$nty 7$1li#
De3ender's O33i#e !as not eno$gh to get me m$#h #onsidered 3or an inter2ie!. 1$t hope3$lly those
attri1$tes !ill not pre2ent me 3rom getting some /ealo$s ad2o#a#y too. here-
Sin#erely.
*a#h Co$ghlin. Es8-. 7O AOL @I('. RENO. N4. CIJ>J. tel: DDJ @@C C''C. 3a=: I%I ((D D%>)M
*a#hCo$ghlin,hotmail-#om Ne2ada Aar No: I%D@
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
S$10e#t: RE: Dogan's !or"in' #onstr$#tion #ommentary
Date: Wed. '' Apr )>') '@:%J:@D B>D>>
From: :Aosler,!ashoe#o$nty-$s
+o: /a#h#o$ghlin,hotmail-#om
CC: ADogan,!ashoe#o$nty-$s
*a#h.
+he pro#ed$res regarding #ompeten#y e2al$ations are 3o$nd in NRS 'DC-@IC'. et se8- ?nder NRS
'DC-%'J. the Co$rt appoints the persons !ho are to #ond$#t the e2al$ation- +hose persons m$st 1e
#erti3ied 1y the Department o3 Health and H$man Ser2i#es- NRS 'DC-%'D-
+he #o$rt has ordered yo$ to #omplete the e2al$ation thro$gh Fa"e's Crossing- +hey are re8$ired to
pro2ide #erti3ied e2al$ator and pro2ide a #opy o3 the report to the #o$rt- +he 7$1li# De3ender's O33i#e
!ill not 1e pro2iding monies 3or an e2al$ation 1y an o$tside psy#hologist or psy#hiatrist-
Again. 9 en#o$rage yo$ to #ooperate !ith Fa"e's- Fail$re to do so may res$lt in san#tions 1y the #o$rt-
+han" yo$ in ad2an#e 3or yo$r #ooperation-
:eremy Aosler
Washoe Co$nty 7$1li# De3ender
@J> So$th Center Street. Jth Floor
7O Ao= @>>C@
Reno. N4 CIJ)>B@>C@
DDJB@@DB%C)@
01osler,!ashoe#o$nty-$s
NN Noti#eNN +his message and a##ompanying do#$ments are #o2ered 1y the ele#troni#
Comm$ni#ations 7ri2a#y A#t. 'C ?-S-C- OO )J'>B)J)'. and may #ontain #on3idential in3ormation
intended 3or the spe#i3ied indi2id$al ;s< only- 93 yo$ are not the intended re#ipient or an agent
responsi1le 3or deli2ering it to the intended re#ipient. yo$ are here1y noti3ied that yo$ ha2e re#ei2ed
this do#$ment in error and that any re2ie!. dissemination. #opying. or the ta"ing o3 any a#tion 1ased on
the #ontents o3 this in3ormation is stri#tly prohi1ited-
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
From: *a#h Co$ghlin Pmailto:/a#h#o$ghlin,hotmail-#omQ
Sent: +$esday. April '>. )>') %:%I 76
+o: Aosler. :eremy
S$10e#t: RE: Dogan's !or"in' #onstr$#tion #ommentary
6r- Aosler.
6$st 9 $tili/e Fa"e's Crossing 3or the e2al$ation or #an 9 ha2e an o$tside psy#hologist and psy#hiatrist
per3orm the e2al$ations and !ill the WC7D reim1$rse them i3 that is allo!a1le- 7lease respond in
!riting !ith #itations to a$thority-
Sin#erely
*a#h Co$ghlin. Es8-. 7O AOL (>IJ). RENO. N4. CIJ>(. tel: DDJ @@C C''C. 3a=: I%I ((D D%>)M
*a#hCo$ghlin,hotmail-#om Ne2ada Aar No: I%D@
R S$10e#t: Dogan's !or"in' #onstr$#tion #ommentary
R Date: +$e. '> Apr )>') '>:>):%' B>D>>
R From: :Aosler,!ashoe#o$nty-$s
R +o: /a#h#o$ghlin,hotmail-#om
R
R
R *a#h.
R
R 9 spo"e !ith Airay and he told me that he !as s$rprised 1y yo$r appearan#e- He said yo$r #lothes
!ere dirty and yo$ appeared as i3 yo$ hadn't sho!ered- He !as #on#erned that other people. in#l$ding
the #o$rts and Fa"e's Crossing personnel. might 3ind that $n$s$al ;3or a li#ensed attorney to present in
s$#h a !ay<- Nothing more-
R
R 9 !o$ld also
en#o$rage yo$ to #onta#t Fa"e's and get the e2al$ation #ompleted- R
R
R
R :eremy Aosler
R Washoe Co$nty 7$1li# De3ender
R @J> So$th Center Street. Jth Floor
R 7O Ao= @>>C@
R Reno. N4 CIJ)>B@>C@
R DDJB@@DB%C)@
R 01osler,!ashoe#o$nty-$s
R
R NN Noti#eNN +his message and a##ompanying do#$ments are #o2ered 1y the ele#troni#
Comm$ni#ations 7ri2a#y A#t. 'C ?-S-C- OO )J'>B)J)'. and may #ontain #on3idential in3ormation
intended 3or the spe#i3ied indi2id$al ;s< only- 93 yo$ are not the intended re#ipient or an agent
responsi1le 3or deli2ering it to the intended re#ipient. yo$ are here1y noti3ied that yo$ ha2e re#ei2ed
this do#$ment in error and that any re2ie!. dissemination. #opying. or the ta"ing o3 any a#tion 1ased on
the #ontents o3 this in3ormation is stri#tly prohi1ited-
R
R
R
R
R
R
R BBBBBOriginal 6essageBBBBB
R From: *a#h Co$ghlin.Es8- Pmailto:/a#h#o$ghlin,hotmail-#omQ
R Sent: 6onday. April >I. )>') I:@@ 76
R +o: Dogan. AirayM Aosler. :eremy
R S$10e#t: Dogan's !or"in' #onstr$#tion #ommentary
R
R 7lease e=plain
R
R Dogan. Airay SADogan,!ashoe#o$nty-$sR !rote:
R
R R6r- Co$ghlin. here is the email that Fa"e's Crossing sent to me- 7lease s#hed$le yo$r e2al$ations
soon- 5o$r Co$rt date is set on April. 'Ith at C:@> a-m-
R R
R RGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
R R
R RFrom: Forraine 6- 7elosi Pmailto:lmpelosi,la"es-n2-go2Q
R RSent: Friday. April >(. )>') %:)D 76
R R+o: Dogan. Airay
R RS$10e#t: Client Conta#t
R R
R R
R R
R R
R R6r- Dogan.
R R
R R
R R
R RFa"e's Crossing Center has 1een ha2ing some iss$es !ith yo$r #lient. *a#hary Co$ghlin !ith regard
to him emailing the psy#hologists to ma"e an appointment- 93 yo$ !o$ld please instr$#t yo$r #lient to
#onta#t me. Forraine 7elosi to s#hed$le his appointment it !o$ld 1e appre#iated- 9 ha2e #alled 6r-
Co$ghlin and le3t a message !ith t!o a2aila1le dates 3or an appointment and rather than ret$rn my #all
he emailed Dr- Farmer stating phone pro1lems- +han" yo$ 3or yo$r assistan#e in this matter-
R R
R R
R R
R RForraine 7elosi. AA 94
R R
R RFa"e's Crossing Center
R R
R RJ>> Galletti Way
R R
R RSpar"s. N4 CI%@'
R R
R RDDJ (CCB'I>> e=t- ))C
R R
R RDDJ (CCB'I>I Fa=
R R
R Rlmpelosi,la"es-n2-go2
R R
R R
R R
R R
R R
R R+his message and a##ompanying do#$ments are #o2ered 1y the ele#troni# Comm$ni#ations 7ri2a#y
A#t. 'C ?-S-C- OO )J'>B)J)'. and may #ontain #on3idential in3ormation intended 3or the spe#i3ied
indi2id$al;s< only- 93 yo$ are not the intended re#ipient or an agent responsi1le 3or deli2ering it to the
intended re#ipient. yo$ are here1y noti3ied that yo$ ha2e re#ei2ed this do#$ment in error and that any
re2ie!. dissemination. #opying. or the ta"ing o3 any a#tion 1ased on the #ontents o3 this in3ormation is
stri#tly prohi1ited- 93 yo$ ha2e re#ei2ed this #omm$ni#ation in error. please noti3y $s immediately 1y
EBmail. and delete the original message-
R R
R R
RE: RJC trial date - RCR 2011-066341
From: Zach Coughlin (zachcoughlin@hotmail.com)
Sent: Thu 6/07/12 11:48 AM
To: jgoodnight@washoecounty.us; jrains@washoecounty.us;
enovak@washoecounty.us; phalstead@da.washoecounty.us;
chicks@da.washoecounty.us; dgammick@da.washoecounty.us; coe@gbis.com;
keith@leelawoffice.net; judgemcgee@msn.com; geofgiles@hotmail.com;
nvlawcom@gmail.com; davidc@nvbar.org; glennm@nvbar.org;
patrickk@nvbar.org; jboles@callatg.com; molezzo@hardylawgroup.com;
lkdesq@aol.com
12 attachments
Harvard Law Review The Law of Finders.pdf (106.1 KB) , Abandoned, lost, or
mislaid property alrs.pdf (922.1 KB) , alrs on lost larceny.pdf (303.1 KB) , alrs on
lost property larceny.pdf (96.8 KB) , larceny lost.pdf (948.6 KB) , 20120605_204307
cory goble flicks cigarette at coughlin hits coughlin's left shoulder.mp4 (5.5 MB) ,
VID_20110820_232413 you are all on tape now.3gp (2.9 MB) , 911 call by Coughlin
on August 20th, 2011 were Goble et al issue threats p00 Start_Time = Saturday,
August 20, 2011 23-26-45 Source_ID = 50.avi (201.0 KB) , 234 k16 k. Property lost
or mislaid. nrs nevada.pdf (2.8 MB) , 234 k16 k. Property lost or mislaid..pdf (6.7
KB) , 911 call by Goble lying about Coughlin being super aggressive but wait, not
that's it, he is trying to get away to, contradictory lies p00 Start_Time = Saturday,
August 20, 2011 23-22-52 Source_ID = 50.avi (390.5 KB) , Goble 911 call alleging
aduult just socked a minor p00 Start_Time = Saturday, August 20, 2011 23-26-20
Source_ID = 49.avi (226.5 KB)
Dear District Attorney Gammick, DDA Young, et al,
I amrespectfully submitting these materials to you for your consideration. I
would stipulate to a Disturbing the Peace charge or some other similar charge
which would not seemto require reporting to Bar Counsel under SCR 111,
with credit for the 7 days served in jail (I served a bunch of other days in jail
this year, for things like asserting my privacy rights vis a vis my medical
records in connection with the competency evaluation that was ordered, but I
don't know whether credit can be applied accross cases like that....) and if it
will auger toward the District Attorney's Office entering such a plea deal, I
could agree to pay some fine, however, I amindigent, seriously, there is a real
possibility my law license will be taken away or suspended, etc., etc., and I just
would hope that a fine could be avoided given my extreme indigency at this
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
1 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
point. Bar Counsel and the Supreme Court of Nevada are aware of the arrest
in this case (well, the Supreme Court has been provided documentation related
to it, whether they are "aware" of it I could not really say...).
I feel that the recordings of the 911 call by Goble further demonstrate the
extent to which he and his compatriates, including Zarate, were willing to lie to
the police to accomplish their goal...to achieve the return of that which Goble
arguably was no longer entitled to, or that which would be in the river were it
not for the intervention of a third party, or to enable Goble et al to avoid
pursuing a civil remedy or otherwise dealing with a difficult to sustain criminal
charge given the actual facts at hand by spicing up their story to include
allegations that:
on one of his 911 calls, Goble allegations that "someone just socked a
minor"...apparently indicating that I punched the 17 year old kid seen in the
videos. Clearly, no one is saying that now, however, it was definitely useful
for Goble to say that to the 911 operators (who likely relayed it to the
police...and I believe the textual record provided of the calls and dispatch
reports includes a citation to this allegation of physical violence too...). The
operator and the police hear that "someone just socked a minor" and it gets
their attention and skews the approach by the police immeasurably.
On his other 911 call, Goble makes like the J on Lovitz liar character fromthe
1980's Saturday Night Live sketches...the "wait, yeah, that's the ticket..."
catchphrase. Goble starts the call indicating that Coughlin "just stole his
phone" and "is being super aggressive and given us all sorts of trouble" but
then Goble decides, "wait, no, yeah, that's it, he is trying to get away too!". So
which is it? Super aggressive and giving you all sorts of trouble or trying to
get away? Any why are Goble and his associates listed in the 911 and dispatch
text reports as the one's yelling? Why is Goble heard on a 911 call screaming
"give me my phone or I amgoing to threaten you right now!". Why are Goble
and his associates the one's reaching into Coughlin's short's pocket, attempting
to take Coughlin's dog and bike?
But, best of all, on Goble's 911 call of August 20th, 2011 at 23:22:52 at the 31
second mark, the wise 911 operator asks
operator (O): "how did he end up with your cell phone?".
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
2 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
Goble: "my phone was just sitting on the ledge and I was just skateboarding
and stuff, and he just picked it up. Everyone saw himpick it up." Lies, lies,
lies. What about the unidentified man holding the phone aloft and indicating
he would shortly throw the phone in the river? In the background on that same
call Goble's associates can be heard menacingly commenting on taking and
touching Coughlin's dog and bike. Coughlin can be heard exclaiming "you just
assaulted me!".
Then, at the 1 minute 7 second mark Goble says:
Goble: "Dude, just give me my phone, its right in his pocket just get it out. I
amabout to grab it out of his pocket"
Then at 1 minute 57 second mark Goble reiterates:
Goble: "He is just getting super aggresive with us, grabbed my phone, I swear,
and he will not give it back ...He grabbed my phone, I swear, its in his pocket,
dude...I was right here, my J eep was right here, my fucking J eep was right
there!".
So, which is it Goble? Were you skateboarding and stuff, or in your J eep?
Why does your written Witness Statements fromthat night indicate you were
only fifteen feet away fromwhere you set your phone down when Coughlin
allegedly walked right up and grabbed it? Doesn't "he just grabbed it" sound a
bit more like someone "grabbing" an itemby force fromsomeone, in a big
hurry, and attempting to run away, rather than, what Nicole Watson says
happened, ie, that an unidentified man picked the phone up,held it aloft,
announced he would throw it in the river, etc....
So, why should the District Attorney's Office countenance Goble and his
associates obvious attempts to leverage the police force through trick and
deception?
Next, on the video of the battery upon me and attempts to dissuade my
testimony by Goble, on J une 5, 2012 (still no word on whether he has been
arrested...) Goble is heard massaging his story back and forth. I
z: who are you?
cg: I'mover it, its all good. Remember? We went to court together. Its all good
zc: Yeah. Oh, its all good for you? Oh, good, I'mgoing to lose my career.
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
3 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
cg: I'msorry that sucks.
zc: Yeah, what's your name, Cory?
cg: Yeah
zc: Hey, how are you guys?
some early twenties brunette female: Wonderful, how are you
early twenties Asian male: you can filmus all you want.
zc: Hey, did you lie to the police?
cg: Do?
zc: Yeah, Did you guys say I just ran up and grabbed the phone?
cg: That's basically what you did. (then he says something unintelligible)
zc: Okay, is that basically it or is that what I did? And what did you tell the
police?
cg: That's exactly what you did.
brunette female: He's...he's...he fucking has a camera.
zc: What did...are you a little high? You got...you've got "fuck" tattoed on your
hand (spelled out on his four knuckles)
brunette: we don't do drugs, your're a crazy person, excuse me, excuse me...just
cuz someone's talking to you.... (actually Goble, Zarate, and Colton
Templeton's social networking website postings are very clearly that they
smoke marijuana quite a bit...)
cg: I was just saying I was over it...
brunette: windows up
zc: Oh, wonderful, you're over it.
cg: (flicks lit cigarette at me fromabout 2 to 3 feet away at a high rate of
speed. The lit cigarette hit my suit jacket at my left shoulder and the tip
exploded into sparks, then fell to the ground. This is shown right before the 52
second mark of the attached video, my camera jerks right when I was hit with
the lit cigarette, which was projected at me by Goble flicking it in a propulsive
manner between his middle and index fingers and his thumb...it actually got
traveling at a fairly high rate of speed and the flicking and cigarette darting
through the air, and the cigarette hitting my should and exploding are all very
discernible in this video, especially the audio of those sounds, particularly
when considering that the camera jerking coincides exactly with the exploding
sound).
zc: Oh, you just did me such a big favor, guy.
I amreporting the conduct of Goble and his party as an attempt to dissuade a
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
4 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
witness, myself, and wish to press charges in addition to the assault and
battery. It really is not clear to me how it is just that Goble and his party
basically attacked me as a gang last August 20th, 2011 (that is shown in videos
on Youtube.comand provided to DDA Young and the 911 calls, one of which
was made by myself...Goble and his gang attempted to grab away my dog from
me, to pull my mountain bike away fromme, and to reach into my shorts
pocket...Officer Duralde dismissed my reports of their assaults and batteries by
indicating that he viewed themas a "citizen's arrest"...well, I guess I could have
physically detained Goble on J une 5, 2012 as a citizen's arrest too...but I
instead told himI was calling the police to report his battery and that he should
remain at the scene. He chose to leave (I suspect he and his party got out of the
Lexus RX300 they were in and departed in a Toyota Prius, with the brunette
female no longer being in the driver's seat for a couple reasons...one, they may
have had contraband in the Lexus and felt getting pulled over was about to
become a very real possibility...and or two, the brunette female knew she
would likely face a DUI or at least a sobriety test, so someone less impaired
needed to drive a different car).
A video just prior to the August 20th, 2011 petit larceny arrest, wherein I made
a 911 call and reported the assault and battery that Goble and his gang were
committing upon me, shows me explaining to Goble et al that reaching into my
pockets was a very poor choice and that everyone involved need to relax, settle
down, be peaceful, etc. and I referenced the tragic consequences of failing to
do so that had, at that time, just recently been seen in the death of 25 year old
Stephen Gale during an armed robbery of a female's purse on California
Avenue. The partial video of Goble et all assaulting and battering me is linked
to here, and the audio of the 911 calls wherein Goble lies about "someone just
socked a minor" and where I call and report their violent and threatening
behavior is attached:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74aEVkgA5MA&feature=plcp
But, to get back to the lying that Goble, Zarate, and all engaged in...They lied
to the 911 operator and the officers on the scene to get me arrested, placed in
cuffs, searched etc. It was only after all that was accomplished that Zarate
realized he better put something a bit more truthful down on paper, and that is
when the unidentified man who held the iphone aloft and announced to the
denizens of the skate plaza that he would "throw it in the river if someone
doesn't claimit immediately". Goble, in his written statement, continued to
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
5 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
lie, however. Goble wrote that he set his phone down and was only 15 feet
away fromwhere he set it...However, if that were true, then why didn't Goble
claimthe phone fromthe unidentified man? Why did it take over 90 seconds
for Goble and his two associates to approach me? Could it be that Goble was
trying to minimize the extent to which he had carelessly set down a smartphone
on concrete, unattended, not in a bag, just by itself, bare, then went off
skateboarding,, talking to girls and his friends and doing who knows what
else? So, this drunken, high 24 year old skateboarder who rides around in
newish Lexus's with cans of Pabst Blue Ribbon beer falling out, who flicks lit
cigarettes at attorneys who are only 2 to 3 feet away, even though he knows he
is being video recorded...he gets to massage the truth, get Officer Duralde into
a mess, have my arrest reported to Bar Counsel (courtesy of a letter to Bar
Counsel by opposing counsel, Richard Hill, Esq., in the wrongful eviction from
my former home law office, in which Hill billed $50K to his neurosurgeon
client to procure a summary eviction order against a commercial tenant where
the non payment of rent was not alleged and the Eviction Notice was a No
Cause Eviction Notice...something that is expressly forbidden under NRS
40.253, the summary eviction proceeding statute...basically Hill performed a
"wrong site surgery" for his surgeon client...just that it took place in a
courtroomrather than the OR.
Then, Goble gets to eat up over 9 months of District Attorney's resources
prosecuting this case, where his damages were apparently that he was without
his phone for about ten or fifteen minutes? He gets to have me arrested and
spend six and a half days in jail? Then he gets to assault and batter me by
flicking a lit cigarette at me from2 to 3 feet away, and apparently, escaping
any arrest or prosecution for doing so?
Goble and his two still unidentified accomplices who initially approached me
(Novak and Goodnight claimto have investigated this matter and interviewed
Goble and Zarate, Further, Goodnight and Novak were unable to locate
material witness Nicole Watson, whomadmitted on video tape that she was
there and heard and saw the unidentified man hold aloft the phone and
announce he would "throw it in the river". Goodnight admitted that he failed to
view the video provided to himof Nicole Watson stating this during a client
interview just minutes before the Trial that was to take place May 7th,
2012...at which DDA Young managed to subpoena and have appear Duralde,
Zarate, and Goble, yet DPD Goodnight et al refused to subpoena any of the
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
6 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
individuals I requested be made to testify. Goodnight also admitted that he had
failed to even once look at the ALR, AmJ ur and CJ S selections that I had
provided himthat detail cases wherein lost, mislaid, or abandoned property is
or is not the subject of larceny.
Nicole Watson admitted hearing say that he would throw the phone in question
"in the river" if it wasn't claimed immediately (http://www.youtube.com
/watch?v=to_UOFIccLw at the four minute ten second mark of the video just
linked to Nicole Watson admits to hearing and seeing this man exclaimthat he
would throw the iPhone in the river...so Goble's own friend, Nicole Watson
admits that Goble's phone would have been in the river anyways...
Sincerely,
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
PO Box 3961
Reno, NV 89505
Tel: 775 338 8118
Fax; 949 667 7402
To denneym@reno.gov, jgoodnight@washoecounty.us, zyoung@da.washoecounty.us
From:Zach Coughlin (zachcoughlin@hotmail.com)
Sent: Wed 6/06/12 1:36 AM
To: denneym@reno.gov; jgoodnight@washoecounty.us; zyoung@da.washoecounty.us
Dear Officer Denney and the Reno Police Department, DDA Young, and DPD
Goodnight,
This is the supplement to the report of the battery that Cory Goble committed
upon me last night, J une 5th, 2012.
lexus rx300 brownish color license plate 073xyf brunette female early twenties
behind the wheel, indicated the lexus belonged to her early twenties blonde
female friend. Cory Goble sat on the passenger side in the back seat. Asian
man early twenties in front passenger seat.
Reno Police Department case number 12-10761 for incident occurring at
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
7 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
approximately 8:44pmin parking lot of Imperial Lounge on Arlington and 2nd
Street.
911 call made announcing Toyota Prius (license plate number provided during
911 call) was the getaway vehicle for Goble and his three associates when
Coughlin announced he was calling 911 to report the battery by Cory Goble.
I was at the Washoe County Law Library until Nikki Britt, law librarian told
me it was time to go at 7:30pm. She let me stay after the usual 7:00pmclosing
time because she is nice and because the "Lawyer in the Library" programwas
running late, so she was going to be there anyway. I left my car parked in the
court house's lot and decided to go for a walk in the entertainment corridor
downtown between arlington and sierra streets and First and Second Streets. I
don't have much money right now and so I was more watching to big screen
television replays of the Heat Celtics game than anything else through the
window in the imperial parking lot. I didn't go in because I don't have much
money to spend, the place looked kind of dead anyways, and I was getting
tired anyways after doing legal research for several hours. While watching the
sports highlights I heard a young man's voice kind of clowning me about my
wearing a suit. Then the voice exclaimed that I was "the guy who stole my
phone". At that point I turned on my smart phone recorder and that is where
the tape starts, with Goble repeating that he was "over it" now and, apparently,
no longer upset about the situation, which was somewhat puzzling considering
he did not lose the use of his phone for anything more than a few minutes at the
most back on August 20th, 2011, and also considering that the still unidentified
man that Nicole Watson admitted hearing say that he would throw the phone in
question "in the river" if it wasn't claimed immediately
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=to_UOFIccLw at the four minute ten
second mark of the video just linked to Nicole Watson admits to hearing and
seeing this man exclaimthat he would throw the iPhone in the river...so Goble's
own friend, Nicole Watson admits that Goble's phone would have been in the
river anyways....)
J oe Goodnight never watched that video linked to, despite the fact that it was
provided to himand qualifies as exculpatory evidence. Goodnights admits that
he failed to utilize or watch that video. The other individual providing a
witness statement, Nate Zarate, is seen in the videos attempting to dissuade
Nicole Watson fromproviding any insight into what she actually eye witnessed
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
8 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
the night of the grand larceny arrest of Coughlin by the RPD, at the behest of
Goble and Zarate on August 20th, 2011.
In the video fromJ une 5, 2012, Cory Goble is seen with the word "FUCK"
tatooed on the knuckles of his left hand in large font and black ink. He appears
highly intoxicated. A Pabst Blue Ribbon beer can was seen under the section
of the Lexus RX300 that Goble was seated in.
The early twenty somethings appeared to feel it rather necessary to switch cars,
and possibly drivers. The excuse profered later, apparently by a shaggy brown
haired taller early twenty something male that the RPD interviewed, and whom
was very threatening to Coughlin in the parking lot, seems thin. The excuse,
that these four switched cars because Coughlin was blocking the egress of their
Lexus seems particularly suspect considering the merely switched to a Toyota
Prius parked some 3 parking spaces away. Why, if Coughlin was truly
preventing themfromleaving he couldnt' have just blocked the Prius, is
unclear.
What is clear is that no forcible "citizen's arrest" was made by Coughlin.
Coughlin made the decision to allow Goble and his associates to leave
peaceably (though they likely presented a danger to others on the road
considering they all seemed intoxicated). However, in the video of the August
20th, 2011 arrest of Coughlin, wherein Goble signed a criminal complaint,
RPD Officer Duralde cheerfully dismisses Coughlin's protestations that
Coughlin himself called 911 in light of the skater youth's violent and
threatening behavior (attempting to steal Coughlin's pekingnese puppy and
Coughlin's bike, attempting to reach into Coughlin's shorts pocket, gleefully
exclaimign the lack of culpability one of their cohorts would face given he was
"only 17 years old and still a minor". Officer Duralde is hear in the video
dismissing Coughlin's account of the assaults and batteries this gang of skater
youth committed by deeming their behavior a "citizen's arrest".
Coughlin, however, chose not to utilize any of the force or threat utilized by
the skater youth's in the video of the August 20th, 2011 arrest of Coughlin for
grand larceny (Duralde cheerfully explained to Coughlin that he was
purposefully charging it as a "felony" and went on to detail the advantages to
Duralde in doing so and the disadvantages to Coughlin that that decision by
Duralde would present.
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
9 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
I amreporting this battery by Goble within 48 hours of it taking place. As
such, he should be arrested. I swear, under penalty of perjury, that Goble
flicked his lit cigarette directly at me, fromabout 3 feet away and that it hit me
in the left should area of my suit jacket and the sparks and ash exloded fromthe
tip of the lit cigarette when it hit my left shoulder of my suit jacket.
The attached video reveal Goble flicking his lit cigarette at me and it hitting
my left should at the 51 second mark. For a couple seconds afterwards I was
literally to shocked to say anything, as it was such a phenomenally stupid thing
for himto have done, especially considering that his female friend had only just
a few moments before made sure to announce that I, Coughlin, was obviously
recording and or filming the interaction. The group admits that Goble started
the conversation with me and they also readily acknowledge that his conduct
invited the interaction.
I appreciate your attention to this matter.
If you choose to make an arrest, locating Goble should not be that difficult.
Goble's parents are apparently located at 2480 Montego Dr_ Pamela and
Timothy Goble. The Criminal Complaing by DDA Young list Cory Goble's
address as 5020 Las Brisas Blvd in Reno, NV.
Sincerely,
Zach Coughlin

Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=0da9f039-...
10 of 10 8/8/2012 12:48 AM
Notification of Electronic Filing in IN RE: DISCIPLINE OF
ZACHARY COUGHLIN, No. 60838
From:efiling@nvcourts.nv.gov
Sent: Thu 6/07/12 3:23 PM
To: zachcoughlin@hotmail.com
Supreme Court of Nevada
NOTICE OF ELECTRONIC FILING
Notice is given of the following activity:
Date and Time of Notice: Jun 07 2012 03:22 p.m.

Case Title: IN RE: DISCIPLINE OF ZACHARY COUGHLIN
Docket Number: 60838
Case Category: Bar Matter
Document Category:
Filed Order of Temporary Suspension and Referral to Disciplinary Board."We refer this
matter to the appropriate disciplinary board for the institution of a formal hearing . . . .
We hereby temporarily suspend attorney Zachary B. Coughlin from the practice of law in
Nevada, pending final disposition of the disciplinary proceedings."
Submitted by: Issued by Court
Official File Stamp: Jun 07 2012 02:05 p.m.
Filing Status: Accepted and Filed
Docket Text:
Filed Order of Temporary Suspension and Referral to Disciplinary Board."We refer this
matter to the appropriate disciplinary board for the institution of a formal hearing . . . .
We hereby temporarily suspend attorney Zachary B. Coughlin from the practice of law in
Nevada, pending final disposition of the disciplinary proceedings."
The Clerk's Office has filed this document. It is now available on the Nevada Supreme Court's E-Filing website. Click here
to log in to Eflex and view the document.
Electronic service of this document is complete at the time of transmission of this notice. The time to respond to the
document, if required, is computed from the date and time of this notice. Refer to NEFR 9(f) for further details.
Clerk's Office has electronically mailed notice to:
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=5a5315ae-b...
1 of 2 8/8/2012 12:45 AM
Zachary Coughlin
No notice was electronically mailed to those listed below; counsel filing the document must serve a copy of
the document on the following:
Patrick King
This notice was automatically generated by the electronic filing system. If you have any questions, contact the Nevada
Supreme Court Clerk's Office at 775-684-1600 or 702-486-9300.
Hotmail Print Message https://bay148.mail.live.com/mail/PrintMessages.aspx?cpids=5a5315ae-b...
2 of 2 8/8/2012 12:45 AM
Report Selection Criteria
Case ID: CV11-03126
Docket Start Date:
Docket Ending Date:
Case Description
Case ID: CV11-03126 - ZAC C!"#$I% VS& 'A(( 'ER$ISS) '&D& et al&
*iling Date: +ednesda,) !cto-er 26t.) 2011
(,pe: #C - #E%ERA$ CIVI$
Stat/s: !RD01"D*$D - !rder or 1/dge2ent *iled
Related Cases
%o related cases 3ere 4o/nd&
Case E5ent Sc.ed/le
%o case e5ents 3ere 4o/nd&
Case 6arties
Se7 8 Assoc E9pn Date (,pe ID %a2e
1 1/dge D: S(EI%EI'ER) !%!RA;$E C!%%IE 1&
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

2 1< 6lainti44 =12062<2 C!"#$I%) ZACAR>
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: C!"#$I%) ZACAR> ;AR?ER
CA"#$I%) ZACAR>
C!"#$I%) ZACAR> ;AR?ER
C!"#$I%) ZACAR>
C!"#$I%) ZAC
C!"#$I%) ZAC?AR>

3 6ro 6er-6lt406et0Appellant 6R!6ER 6ro6er 6erson
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

: De4endant =1212@6A 'ER$ISS) 'A((
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

A De4endant =1213:20 'A((E+ 1& 'ER$ISS $IVI%# (R"S(
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

6 De4endant =1213:21 $A+ !**ICE !* RICARD #& I$$
1
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

< De4endant =1126311 I$$) ESB&) RICARD #&
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

C De4endant =1213:22 ;A?ER) ESB&) CASE>
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

@ De4endant =1213:23 #REE% AC(I!% $A+% SERVICE
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

10 De4endant =1213:2: 'ACA$-CR"Z) %ER> R&
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

11 De4endant =1213:2A SAR6E) DAR$E%E
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

12 De4endant =CC16C0 DIC?S!% REA$(>
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

13 De4endant =11A6212 %V E%ER#>
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: *?A SIERRA 6ACI*IC 6!+ER
%V E%ER#>) I%C&

1: De4endant =1213:26 %EVADA C!"R( SERVICES
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

1A De4endant =1213:2< D"RDE%) 1!E$
Address: /na5aila-le Aliases: none

16 De4endant =160A23 RE%! 1"S(ICE C!"R(
Address: 6& !& ;!D 300C3
RE%! %V C@A20 Aliases: none

1< 2 Attorne, @:<3 Co/g.lin) Es7&) Zac.ar,
Address: 121 Ri5er Rock St&
Reno %V C@A01 Aliases: none

Docket Entries
*iling Date Description %a2e 'onetar,
26-!C(-2011
0A:12 6' EECi5il Co5er S.eet C!"#$I%) ZACAR>
Entr,: none&

2
26-!C(-2011
0A:12 6' A44ida5it in S/pport&&& C!"#$I%) ZACAR>
Entr,: '!(I!% A%D A**IDAVI( I%S "66!R( !* '!(I!% (! *I$E C!'6$AI%( A#I%S(
FsicG 'ER$ISS E( A$& F/n4iled co2plaint sent to D: 4or I*6 deter2ination) no re7/est 4or s/-2ission
or paper order pro5idedG

0C-%!V-2011
10:20 A' !rd Den, in *or2a 6a/peris
Entr,: (ransaction 2A<6C@A - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 11-0C-2011:10:22:3@

0C-%!V-2011
10:2A A' 6roo4 o4 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: (ransaction 2A<6@26 - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 11-0C-2011:10:2<::2

2@-%!V-2011
12:1< A' %otice o4 Appearance Co/g.lin) Es7&) Zac.ar,
Entr,: ZAC C!"#$I% ESB *!R ZAC C!"#$I% - (ransaction 2611@:2 - Appro5ed ;,:
AZI!% : 11-2@-2011:10::0:2A

2@-%!V-2011
10::1 A' 6roo4 o4 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: (ransaction 26126@@ - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 11-2@-2011:10::1:A6

10-1A%-2012
01:A2 A' 'tn 6roceed *or2a 6a/peris Co/g.lin) Es7&) Zac.ar,
Entr,: '!(I!% *!R REC!%SIDERA(I!% !* I*6H !R A$(ER%A(IVE$> '!(I!% (!
6R!CEED I%*!R'A 6A"6ERIS) !R A'E%DED I*6 - (ransaction 26@0020 - Appro5ed ;,:
$'A(E"S : 01-10-2012:0@:16::A S";'I((ED (! D1A - %! 6A6ER !RDER 6R!VIDED - $'

10-1A%-2012
0@:1C A' 6roo4 o4 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: (ransaction 26@03@6 - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 01-10-2012:0@:1C:A3

2<-1A%-2012
10:1: A' !rder &&&
Entr,: (ransaction 2<2A:11 - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 01-2<-2012:10:1::A1

2<-1A%-2012
10:1A A' 6roo4 o4 Electronic Ser5ice
Entr,: (ransaction 2<2A:1C - Appro5ed ;,: %!REVIE+ : 01-2<-2012:10:16:26

3