Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTERNATIONAL
A senior Indian journalist takes a critical look at mistakes made by both India and Pakistan during the Foreign Ministers meeting and their acts of courage - points that people on both sides may find hard to swallow. However, it is only when we try to see beyond our own perceptions that there can be any real understanding leading towards productive dialogue
he good news at the end of the much hyped-up meeting of the Foreign Ministers of Pakistan and India was that the two countries will continue the dialogue. The bad news was that none of the gains that had been expected were in sight easing of visa restrictions (which would benefit ordinary people from both countries as well as boost local economies), forward movement on Kashmir (Pakistans hope/expectation), a commitment from Pakistan on terror (Indias hope/expectation) to name some. Theyre just saying well keep talking but well also keep biting, commented a disgruntled senior colleague at the post-press conference reception in Islamabad. However, in the context of India-
transcripts had been handed over to the Pakistan government in a succession of dossiers. But by making it public just before the talks India brought both the Pakistan army and the large right wing of the Pakistan media into the picture. Last Thursday both were seething with rage. Qureshi was therefore left with only two choices: he had either to brazenly rebut the accusation, or get something
made abundantly clear was that talks between Pakistan and India should be held away from the media glare. Peace is not an event but a process, as a Naga woman said, addressing a gathering of South Asian women some time ago. This is something that the governments on both sides need to understand. Time to stop playing to the media gallery and the public, and move towards a sustained, consistent and open-minded communication. The bottom line is that there is no alternative to dialogue. And that while the governments sort out their political differences, they should at least not let the people suffer ease visa restrictions, let people meet, allow trade (yes, even transit trade), remove non-tariff barriers. In short, behave like civilised neighbours in the 21st century. Beena Sarwar
way with ease. All he had to say was that India would gladly pick up the threads of the Manmohan Singh-Musharraf dialogue whenever Pakistan was prepared to. But the moment he heard the K word, Krishna dug his heels in. This left Qureshi with nothing to show for the conference. Despite this, the talks did not break down. Qureshi accepted Krishnas observation that Kashmir had an elected government and chief minister. He also referred to Indian administered Kashmir in his press statement as Jammu and Kashmir and not Indian-occupied Kashmir. Krishna, on his part, also tacitly accepted that the Home Secretarys statement had been uncalled for. These were remarkable acts of courage. It is ironic that they are precisely the ones for which both foreign ministers are being pilloried in their own countries. But if Delhi did not understand Islamabads constraints, Islamabad did not understand Delhis either. India has been under attack from terrorists based in Pakistan for more than a decade. Pakistan has resolutely insisted that it is unable to control them and is itself their victim. Then come two pieces of detailed, firsthand, information from the confessions of Qasab and David Coleman according to which the Pakistan army was behind the Mumbai attack, and the ISI is not only sheltering the Lashkar and elements of the Taliban, but helping them to forge links with Al Qaeda. Delhi could not make any commitments, let alone timebound ones, till Pakistan was at least prepared to admit that its army, or sections of its army, had continued to use terrorism as an instrument of policy abroad. But that is something that no elected government in Pakistan has so far had the courage, or indeed the power, to do.
eace building takes many forms but the most sustainable is the medium of healing through education exchanges, and learning solutions to common challenges from basic to most complex forms of knowledge generation, management and its dissemination. Since 2006 many of us education walas have been engaged in an exciting initiative that began in Lahore at a conference on February 1-2, 2006 titled Local Governance, Texts and Contexts Perspectives from South Asia. The conference concluded with the formation of the South Asia Forum for Education Development (Safed). Safed in Urdu is white. It is also universally known as the colour of peace. Well known professors Ayesha Jalal and Krishna Kumar, in their keynote addresses, urged South Asians to rise to the challenge of education beyond borders, seeking answers to education relevance, how children learn, what for, so that we can together undertake fundamental education reforms. Mian Imran Masud, then Minister Education Punjab, endorsed Safed for its work in the core areas of quality and learning; promoting girls education; cross cultural research; education in emergencies; human rights and sustainable development; ensuring linkages of higher with basic education. Since 2008 Safed has teamed up with Indian institutions like The Pratham Education Foundation, Jamia Millia University, Women In Security, Conflict Management and Peace (Wiscomp), National Council of Education Research and Training (NCERT) and Ankur Society to find common ground for problems in education. In each endeavour the focus has been to engage in meaningful programs of learning and becoming, beyond an event mentality as a long term enterprise. Linked to all this are the efforts of Professors Radha Kumar, Janaki Rajan and Veena Sikri at Jamia who spearheaded the South Asian Women Network (SAWN) across eight sectors including education, peace, health and microcredit with women and men of South Asia. In August 2009, SAWN and Safed
our needs the support of the media, corporate sector and concerned citizens alike. In 2010 ASER Pakistan will reach 35 districts and 2011 in all districts across the country. There have also been cross cultural collaborations for a South Asian educators group in heritage, environment and peace. On March 21, 2010 a week long conference, funded by the US Dept of State, was held on education leadership in Delhi and Karachi simultaneously with over 60 educators from Pakistan, India and the USA.
rights activist and artist Rumana Hussain (Childrens Museum for Peace and Human Rights) have volunteered for action. Under the banner of Aman ki Asha we urge hosting of a unique two day conference of 16 eminent educators from Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and Afghanistan, our icons of education and thinking, who will hold conversations with 2,000 youth on the substance of Education for Tomorrow, Yesterday and Today. Bring together eminent educationists from India and Pakistan like Professor Anita Ghulam Ali, Raza Kazim, Yaspal ji, Ayesha Jalal, Krishna Kumar, Madhav Chavan, Amartya Sen, Manzoor Ahmed, Abid Hussain, Anita Rampal, and Dr. Ashraf Ghani from Afghanistan. Aman ki Asha could do this both face to face and virtually in four locations simultaneously. Some of us can volunteer to organise this. Yashpal ji, Vice Chancellor, Jawaharlal Nehru University is pining to visit Lahore one more time. Baela, a visit to Lahore, and I shall be at peace with my maker. Can we deny this honour to our eternally young and Grand Educator, who does not go to bed until he is intellectually provoked by 100 questions from children: Why is the colour of the sky blue?, What makes sea water salty? How do puris puff? Each day is a multiple disciplinary journey. Our youth across borders needs to be in the company of inspiring regenerating icons and thinkers. This would be a moment to seize, passing on an invaluable, diverse and rich mosaic of living intellectual heritage of South Asia. It needs to urgently find spaces amongst our youth, valid as narrations and constructions of history, shared today and working as the masala for a resilient future so that South Asian societies will live in peace, diversity and dignity through contemporary powerful knowledge and experience avatars both virtual and actual. The write is Director Programs, Idara-e-Taleem-oAaghi (ITA) and Coordinator SAFED. Email itacec@gmail.com
A peace initiative whose time has come... Destination Peace: A commitment by the Jang Group, Geo and The Times of India Group to create an enabling environment that brings the people of Pakistan and India closer together, contributing to genuine and durable peace with honour between our countries.