Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JDiJ^l
BJo
h~-
Book.
Gop\Tighi^N?.
COPYRIGHT DEPOSITS
par
le
ne se fait rien de grand dans le monde que genie et la fermete d'un seul homme qui
Voltaire.
THE
WORLD AT WAR
BY
GEORG BRANDES
TRANSLATED BY
CATHERINE
D.
GROTH
N*ro flork
J\5ZZ
Copyright, 1917,
up and
printed.
MAY 10 1917
CI.A460656
PKEFACE
at
Brandes has
col-
some of
his essays
it,
leading
conflict.
up
to
From
basis of
lasting peace,
In his
letter to
to his attitude:
If he
to be
is
not Truth's
only
fit
thrown on the
C. D. G.
CONTENTS
Foreboding
1881 A
...
Death
of
PAGE 1
1888 The
1905 The
Probability
French Youth
pirations
1913 Its
Characteristics
and As14
German
Glorification of
War
22
World War
Different Points of View on the War 1914 English, French and German Point of View
Conditions in Eussian cution of the Jews
32
55
93
Poland 1915-16 Poland's History and Hopes The Conquest of Basra 1914 The Bagdad Railway
and the
118
War
for
Trade
.
138
147
153
167
The
Praise of
War 1915
174
183
CONTENTS
An Appeal 1916 A
Ideals
PAGE
Plea for
Common
to
Sense
213
or Politics? Archer
!
1916 Reply
1916 Reply
to
Mr.
Mr.
William
220
to
William
232
Belgium
Mr.
William
242
Archer
1916 Conclusion The Abolishment of Militarism 260 and Universal Free Trade
1881
...
come
to
of years.
Yet
is, is
pursued
Who
This does not imply, however, that any real blow has
On
the contrary,
fundamental principles
upheld by
as a
men
of science like
follower of Eodbertus and Lassalle only to end as a believer in the confused principles of the Christian state
and
He who
has
the last few years the rare " red " intellects
with the
pletely.
grown damp.
Of
official
who use
socialism as a
liberals,
cover.
in-
all
reactionary.
men
of
sixty or over.
a free
to,
thinker
religion,
in,
he seems to have no
difficulty in associating
official
Chris-
and
political
conservatism.
Politically,
the
love
young are
old,
The
many
only
among men
And when
isolated,
Germany
a strong-
FOKEBODIJSTG
hold of conservatism in the centre of Europe.
it,
Around
and eager
to carry
them out in
But Germany
will
and half
stifled in
to the teeth,
and protected by
all
And
If
there will
come great
struggles
Germany
if
But
Germany
it is
loses,
then
But
The
short interregnum
is
over.
by others, has passed away without being able to fulfil any promise or carry out any expectation. It seems
a symbol of the tenacity of European conservatism that
his father lived to be ninety.
Emperor whose name was synonymous with noble generosity, manly warm-heartedness, liberal intelligence
the
political
first
broad-minded personality
for the
first
time,
made use
But even
politically,
if
Emperor Friedrich
4
had he had
The whole world gasped at the drama " dismissing Germany's " Major Domo
who, on his deathbed,
insolence and despotism
political freedom.
man
an emperor
Puttkammer's
was an execution
in
effigie
The wooden
liberty remains
pression of unusual
As Crown Prince, Emperor Friedrich gave an immanly beauty. In his white cuiand blue
impressive figure.
His
distin-
manner was
clear,
feeling.
Hamlet speaks
to Horatio.
free,
He
was
intellectually
sonality
was
full
armour
his
face and
manner showed
and his
6
son,
He had
There
was
something
magnanimous
about
his
military discipline.
spot French
field
Upon
German
At
such as
his.
And
reaction, the
to
bark again
with
ness.
its
three heads
As Napoleon's short break in Louis XVIIFs reign was called The Hundred Days, so this short gleam of a clear human spirit breaking in on our war-mad empire might be called the Hundred Days Intermission. And the late Emperor represented not only real humanity but the real German spirit the spirit which abdicated when the new German Empire was estab-
lished.
It is curious
how
is
Germany's
Iena
in
At
is
German
spirit first
grew
to be a
power and
that
Everything German
Soon, indeed,
German spirit will be only a saga German The possibility of its blosin the German Empire. soming forth again vanished with Emperor Eriedrich's With him the last representative of a human death.
Germany now left.
disappeared.
A
is
is
Undoubtedly Denmark
an enemy.
we cannot
at the
have
it
as
present
moment Russian
much more
liberal
German
ity. Not liberty, but order and might, is the motto of new Germany. And the days in store for Europe may
Saga
Hard
The
desire
for
peace professed
by most "
intel-
lectuals " in
man
is
to believe
he
is
In
them
as they
really are.
Our
men-
as " sen-
and praises
war
is
impossible.
is
Allow me,
first
of
all,
it
pos-
able.
f
to speak.
If
we
on
And
in this respect I
of the facts
we have solid ground under our feet. knew more than three months ago which we are only beginning to wake up to
if at that
Denmark's perilous
position, it
my
scribbling compatriots
who
cull
most
of their knowledge
Much
of
June
seri-
Europe was
So
June
It
6,
Germany was
Emperor William's
extraordi-
In the
German ambassador
in
Eome
in-
if
was reported
10
to the Sultan.
But
Germany supported
of
defiance
a policy which,
sooner or later,
to
might
Sultan
lead
France to send
to follow
it
an ultimatum
the
and
up by despatching
border.
offered to
these advances
replies.
Yet
be-
Rome, M.
Barrere, in-
formed
his
note, the
French
to
ambassador in London, M.
Paris
Cambon, telegraphed
in the end of
May
to enter into
an agreement whereby
Negotiations followed
and led
to
an understanding.
Some very
startling revelations
sheer
in-
most
part,
and open
to ridicule, like
wig
but
men
in Schles-
shadow of a doubt.
In
official circles
attempts are
made
to explain every-
thing by the
following
if
innocent
formula.
England
were
to
11
So much had
significant
is
knew
to
of the
Matins
sensational revela-
were published.
appear as a clubhouse politician,
Without wishing
I would like, briefly, to mention a few facts which, as far as I know, are not state secrets:
1.
If England
is
to
Germany
England
tries to increase
and
still
increase her
fleet
3.
will
no longer
be able to build
bility of finding
of the impossi-
man
Certain men in England consider a war with Germany unavoidable and would prefer to have it while Germany is comparatively weak. For every year that
goes, victory will
It
may
dis-
his stay
12
The demon-
strative way in which King Edward avoided meeting Emperor William during his stay in Marienbad pointed in the same direction. No one can deny that Germany has great naval ambitions.
With or without
to
reason,
Emperor William's
Baltic.
by many
If
Germany
was
des-
and Russia
wished
it,
become a German
Russian
fleet
to stir.
As
a coun-
herself
fleet to
in
larger
the
Baltic than
Germany had
done.
visit
When German
men-of-war
Danish waters
it
causes no surprise.
at
way
out a light.
acquiring
it.
Germans.
neglects
England scorns or
English
And
it
13
memory
fleet visited
Germany
fleet
When
the English
visited
Danish
ports,
fleet in
Ger-
FRENCH YOUTH
(August, 1913)
its
youth
France to-day.
a desire to
know what
its
think-
ing
its
of,
what
what
will be
arti-
force of action.
filled
with
cles
Of
many
divergencies of opinion.
First of
all,
is
claimed to be
young, at
last.
optimistic.
self-confidence.
its
Exercise
daring.
pride in
It is intensely energetic,
but
energy
is
It is
FRENCH YOUTH
Secondly,
it is
15
It looks
passionately idealistic.
down
course, in fiction).
Europe
what
a brilliant example.
Thirdly,
its
it is
intensely national.
It shakes off
it
to learn
from them.
;
It
worship
it
French
tradition.
Finally,
admires
passionately
it
everything
that
ignores whatever
would tend
to split them.
it
principles of fraternity,
every
In art
it
looks
upon symbolism
and
as
an expression of
it
personal sensitiveness,
dislikes
therefor.
its
Roover-
manticism, with
its
developed sentimental
equally spurned.
It be-
as proclaimed
is
by
its
poet, Jules
Romain.
It
Its
motto
unanimity,
La Vie Unanime.
tends
finest
toward
classicism,
traditions
French
XIY
period.
Furthermore
16
part of the
on intelligence
consolidat-
ing force.
As French youth
in French tradition,
looks
is
attracted
by everything venerable
it is
attracted
as
by Catholicism.
It
more or
less
synonyas the
mous.
attract it so
much
an Gothic French
art
Church, which
inspiration.
reveres
Catholicism,
because
the
achievement of the
Jeanne d'Arc
the
it.
national
The youth
attracted
know
young
great-
its
no
creed.
Yet
Barres,
is
who made
scarcely
now
Catholic
Paul Bourget
many ways
its
He
In
other days he
the Caliiers de la Quinzaine which were the refuge of the intellectual aristocracy of
young France.
is
From
a chasm be-
FKENCH YOUTH
wise they have
17
fervor
much
in
common.
The Lorraine
many
The youth
development along
The
first
Franco-Prussian War,
men
like Zola
it
and Maupassant,
it.
to inspire hatred of
their time.
As
have seen
how
it
with Germany.
officers
such
and
such
an
imaginary
secret
(Emperor
sort)
were
divulged, war would ensue and French soldiers would be " led to slaughter."
place.
throughout the French nation. Statesmen, obviously professing the desire to " maintain peace," knew they
18
In
1912,
however,
the
foreigner
visiting
France
finest of the
functionaries
appreciated
Germany,
and
a
its
They had
In 1913
all
this
was changed.
whose training
who had worked for peace; was half German young func;
known
and
it
to
one
all
had changed.
They spoke
of war, considered
it
as a purifying
force.
War
aries
felt
As war was
calm.
Yet
des
it
is
Armes The
this author,
Appel
Call of Arms.
War and
the mili-
by
tion
would seem
Psichari
Ernest
Renan's
grandson.
His grand-
FRENCH YOUTH
father, the greatest
19
sort
Germany during
the
war
of 1870
(letters
At the time
ately than
young author's
glorifica-
tion of the
army and
its
traditions,
If ever a
it
admire war
army and
traditions.
Its subject is
fact, is
hymn
to war, against
Germany.
the erotic element has but a small place in the book and
is
of time.
a forty-
Army, and
young
Mor-
man
dier.
of twenty
whom
the older
man
trains as a sol-
While
wounded
in
occo.
20
human
at the
same time.
of
According
is
France
in
them
both, as
in Charles Peguy's
Youth's Master.
sincerity
hearts
officers
and great
If France had
many
such
and
privates, she
humanity.
The book
closes
cleverly, of a character
cele-
The
officer,
XVIIFs army
lacked:
The
intention
is clear.
The provinces
of Alsace
members
for the
of the
first
war.
di-
The working
rect all
maintaining peace.
FKENCH YOUTH
Which
of the two opposing forces, that of the
21
army
or that of the people, will prove itself most powerful in the long run ? *
Ernest Psichari was one of the first young officers to fall in Charles Pguy fell the year after. General Piquart died before the outbreak of the war.
*
1914.
GERMAN PATRIOTISM
(1913)
Among
the
and
The
is to
bouring
guilty.
states,
Germany, in
this
respect,
is
equally
In Prance the
theoretically
was crushed
and
is
in
reality
it
intensely
present.
When
the
Chambre voted
the
pulsory military service, mortal enemies from the Dreyfus affair like General Mercier and Joseph Reinach,
ceau as well as
its
staunchest
admirers
all
alike
Prance
felt in
ing sacrifices
may
to.
GEBMAN PATKIOTISM
in
23
But if patriotism is vibrant in France, it is fanatic Germany. Great organisations like the All German Association (All Deutscher Verband), The German Defence Association (Der Deutsche Wehrverein), The
Naval Association (Deutscher Flottenverein), Young
Germany both
physically and
is
newspapers
Many
and
magazines
by
pamphlets
and books.
influential
men
of affairs or political
re-
from
Keim, Liebert,
innumerable
Bernhardi,
Eichhorn,
Wrochem,
to excite
and
up and draw
it
ger of
One
affiliated
It
is
General
Keim
defence association.
24
crystallisation of the
power
The
vanced
"
first
is
all
war "
of
in
Germany.
The
human
is
activity.
crepit,
timorous dotards
beautiful.
But war
War
is
German
people's
only salvation.
It alone prevents
War
states.
German
ele-
ment
in Slav
and Magyar
states
and
its
disappearance
value to
Germany than
feeble
military prowess.
grow
and
apathetic.
Woe
to
to the nation
if it
that is not
up
to the
mark!
its
Woe
humanity,
imagines
it
can do without
Although the
is
up-
man and
form of war.
as a rule
War
volition.
It
is
an independent elementary
force,
GERMAN PATRIOTISM
riot.
25
all
All treaties,
all
Which
Schiller,
great
men do
the
Germans
glorify?
No. Fred. .
.
Goethe,
cold
men
of blood
lives.
and iron
they who
Bismarck
hard,
sacrificed thou-
sands of
They
verging
on adoration.
logically
be looked
and moral
feel lifted,
carried
away by such giants of bloodshed. Germany in Arms, the Crown Prince's recent
courage the highest expression of manhood.
is
book,
calls
The
book
new The
era which
according to a statement
cellor,
made by
it
the
Wealth
it
gives
birth
to
all
peace
at,
fanatics.
Hence,
and the
of
war and
26
is
determined to crush
We
know,
all
of us, that
The
longer
we
We
speak of de-
But a defensive attitude is equivalent to suicide. Our salvation lies in offensive, only. An offensive war is the only wise or permissible one.
fending ourselves.
It
it
it.
In France,
spirit,
the
of
Germans
claim,
reigns
new
that
self-confidence.
possibility of a
war
France
shows
that
children
spirit.
are
systematically
brought up in a chauvinistic
ists
French national-
The
to
of peace impossible.
silence
Ten years ago the French tried a man like Deroulede when he preached
revanche.
Now
the
word
is
used by a semi-official
like Millerand.
altar.
man
The
revenge
is
GERMAN PATRIOTISM
Even Klnische Zeitung
of peace."
calls
27
And
of the
its
number only 40,000,000, after the voting new law of three years' military service, France will have a standing army as strong as Germany's, an army better trained, with better reserves, reinforced,
inhabitants
besides,
by African
troops.
has a quarbet-
more
is
soldiers
ter trained
officers.
Germany
called a nation
is
in
arms.
France
one.
And France
not carrying
many from actively increasing many is hampered by the cost continues to build new warships
and they are destined
her
fleet.
While GerEngland
and Dundee,
to challenge
Germany.
From
all
North Sea.
to
Norman
Aingell
came
The Germany
celebrated
to preach
illusory.
The Germans
28
Germany with
" interna-
Lastly Russia.
The changes in the Balkans, after the Balkan War, oblige the Hapsburg monarchy to fight for its very existence. While France regards Berlin as her enemy and hopes to win back her lost provinces, Russia challenges Vienna and wants to break up the Austro-Hungarian state. Germany, of course, must stand by Austria, because Austria represents the German element. Italy cannot be counted on. Owing to her immense
coast
line,
German and
an
effective
is
ally
against England.
Italy at
an
absurd impossibility.
Germany must go
war
to satisfy
her thirst for land. " Our borders are too small," says General Keim " we must create a thirst for land or we will lose our
;
why
made only
why we
In
all
GERMAN PATRIOTISM
the land she needed.
29
But years have passed and conNow we must have ditions have changed since then. land; colonies of our own are our only safeguard for
"
the future."
A
:
Eckhart, adds, in an outburst of anger at the Kaiser's " Eew German emperors have unpacifist attitude
derstood the people.
spite of its emperors/'
great in
In
fact,
German diplomacy,
the
war
faction.
call the
And
at the present
Among
France.
semi-official
At
made
a
at
France, and
rector
the
Berlin
University
France the
may
and
is
its actions,
provided
it
30
nothing
is
to be gained
Western neighbour.
Unfortunately
France
has
never
quite
an active campaign
is
tional fanaticism.
The
celebrated
author,
Ludwig Thoma,
a former
But
and
power of
when
is
up
to vote
war
credits.
The
real
menace
in
would seem
to lie elsewhere
it is
remain
silent
influence
An
officer is
man whose
smelled
An
officer
who
hasn't
powder
man
GERMAN PATRIOTISM
who
pass,
31
as the years
hasn't
shown
his mettle,
and who,
may
to sea
an
The
;
officer's
he
is,
show what
stuff
he
is
made
of;
manoeuvres.
The military
staffs of
per-
WOKLD WAR
(August, 1914)
me
if
I would give
my
opinion on the
" It
is
usually admitted,"
men
ways a
in our
disaster
even
War
is
al-
to
the victor.
Besides,
the
day are
war between
to refuse a
is
honorary
editor.
I therefore replied:
great
"
As
Mormon
has more
dis-
than Bentham.
man,
Norman Angell
that a great
32
war
33
ruin and
it
misery.
" In
all
is
peace
As
a rule only
officers
and am-
And
render
it less
war enthusiasm, and I do will be possible to do away with war or frequent through any appeal to reason.
it is
to excite
The matter
is
is still
in a state
of medievalism.
For
cided advantage.
how Germany
states,
Aus-
and Prussia.
alliance
Austria's exclusion
man
most Germans.
" Japan could not have become a world power without the war against Eussia.
As long
as
Japan
excelled
Europe began
to respect the
flinch at self-
vie-
34
but
mind
that if
in-
it
evils of
it
sometimes
conditions
because
entails
immeasurable advantages.
"
great European
all
tragedy for
concerned.
many
would
it
I have
met with
this theory
and Austria-Hungary.
little use.
They convince only those who know how to think. Humanity in the mass is trained to obey when commanded, and
is
led
It is
enthusiasm
is
often heroic in
its
and devotion,
but,
At
the present
are tearing
moment five great European powers Europe with " murderlust " and destructive
and
its
it.
desire to maintain
its
craving
35
ing the
German
ultimate object
is vaster.
The
and
all
pray
Heaven upon
their armies.
all
Science
humanity's
genius, are
passion.
now
in the
Even
new
what
throwing.
soldier
The
aviator
knows how
bombard; the
riddling his
how
to bring
machine with
bullets
down the
aviator,
and
light
massacre
human
Blood
earth
;
cries out to
Heaven.
it
sea.
Germany
declared
war instead
her
every
possible
36
decisive
moment.
this
In a sense
was an
Italian.
Machiavelli
sense,
It
Besides, after
I wrote
mense
Britain
inconceivable."
Trieste.
The
was
so great
that
circles the
Germany's.
37
army
Wil-
later, so
Yet in 1912
entirely paci-
was
still
First of
all,
War was
circles,
many
to
were tied by bonds of personal or artistic Germans, and many, familiar with the
little
sympathy
civil
confidence in
place.
War was
? ?
inevitable
it
why
Why
Even
have
ening cloud
as high
who a year before had beEven lieved in peace, now foresaw war without regret. the author who knew and understood Germany better than any one else, Romain Rolland, approved of war
dent of the Seine Council,
and awaited
it
with confidence.
cabinet
officer,
My
greatest desire is
to live to shoulder
my
rifle
and
man who
38
tiary, said
:
headway without
France to new
and awaken
that, in
When
bility.
such
men
desired war,
it
was evident
as a possi-
It
And
ness of France.
Most of the
man
in public life
The
conviction cost
and he
#
fell,
assassinated, a
During
in
this
same period
Germany.
her
many was
initiative,
disliked
amazing development,
her
industry.
This hatred
felt
and
spite.
felt entitled to
39
Ger-
many
Many German
tial spirit
among
was due
to them, per-
men
week
The French
in 1900
are a
temperament
like the
Germans.
When
it
was
amen-
allied
voluntarily,
demanded
that
their
fare.
colonial warbitterly
about
same
officers
The Russians hate the Germans for their virtues as much as for their less estimable qualities. For centuries men of German descent have played a prominent part in
St.
Although the
much from
40
not grateful.
made
itself sin-
and Estland.
In return, the
in diintelli-
is
unmethodical
gence.
But,
first
Germans
discussing
to crush
And, when
Alexandre II
fecit.
And
spirit
that
is
man
confederation
grew
into
Germanism and
this
of
Pan-Slavism.
Pan-Slavism was
finally
erected in opposition to
position between Russia
is
The changes
Balkan penin-
41
Hapsburg monarchy
to fight for
is
pure
And when
Serbia,
War, began
bian,
quite Ser-
Austria,
crush Serbia's
and
Ruthenians
within
her
boundaries,
she
poses,
de-
outside her
own
champion and
And
to
lost
is
directed toward
as
representative of Germanism.
*
is
England
is
Austria
a secondary con-
sideration to England.
rivalry between
England
possible.
the world
war
42
For
cen-
turies
They
at
Fashoda
incidents.
Yet now
their past
and seem
to have
come
to a real understanding.
They clashed
in
Crimean
War
interests in Asia.
In
race,
most
sincerely.
Goethe
worshipped
Shake-
speare; Haeckel,
executive
flected
ability
temperament as
re-
in
Shakespeare.
Many
Coleridge, have
shown
traces of
German
influence,
and
call
hymn
to
him, prais-
him
as the
43
Britons admired
Germany
at the
expense of
Germanic
origin, to
is
added in Eng-
land, Slav in
Germany.
and closely
related.
Protestants, a minority of
Koman
Catholics.
In the
At Waterloo
armies.
made war on
ten-
The
first
time
after
Tangiers
war
was avoided
after
Agadir
*
because
*
Germany
retreated at the
decisive
moment.
*
As long
as
England ruled
satisfied
supremacy
at sea, the
Island
Empire was
and
Germany, on the
Power
44
And
fundamental
dif-
who
believe in liberty
and inde-
cracy.
ernment responsible
official
Germany a
semi-
press,
This op-
or misunderstanding.
Germany needed an
numer-
ous population.
to
the
mother country.
So
Germany,
pressed by the need of expansion, looked about for colonies of her own.
And
Yet Germany
herself, twenty-five
46
Germany was
personified
by Bismarck,
upon
as
a snare or a danger.
to
He
encouraged the
forget Alsace,
make them
thanks.
It
would be absurd
Bismarck
of his
shortsighted.
life
work, and
Germany now
#
suffers
from a
*
thirst for
Germany with
disfavour,
is
German
people
made them
A man
like
Maxe, for
years designated
ject,
Germany
all
as the
enemy.
As a
sub-
German
is
universities.
In
Scotland there
literature.
is
In England there
one
in Cambridge.
It is held,
The ignorance
German is so great in England that out of one hundred members of the House of Commons ninety-five do not know one word of the language.
Yet ignorance
is
46
there English
extensively known.
we
This
was unnecessary
as
the undis-
Her
land.
their
navy feverishly
it
Now
supremacy
at sea is
Empire.
as
much
as a
Euro-
is
to safeguard
Eng-
and
to prevent the
mother country
In
this
way
Germany
For while
47
strain,
scription
who
find
enough men to
felt
man
these ships.
England, therefore,
as a challenge.
defensive, as
it
needed to guard
and
But
the immense,
is
admirably
principally an of-
now a German steamer, even at half speed, cannot reach the German possessions in the Pacific Ocean. This, of
course,
is
it is
foolish of
England
Germany
coaling stations.
German
created
by English
German army
England.
An
attack through
as the present
one
and
to
the annexation of
a citizen of
48
the world.
foreign
community where he
he becomes a
German,
German seems a
absorbs
cosmopoli-
He
translates
also
and
everything
worth
is
knowing,
everything
English.
Shakespeare
many than
England.
a radical.
in
And
as a cosmopolitan the
German seems
Eucken, James, or
German
is
professor
is
a conservative,
all
dearer to
him than
the red
Even
German
uni-
members
of the op-
own home,
the
German
is
not a
as well as
bounded
self-sufficiency
conscience Danes,
Poles,
49
For a long time German and Prussian were considered antithetical terms.
to
Since Prus-
Undoubtedly
Germany
to guarantee
it
in
at
some practical
to
war
military
work
foment
industries
officers
like
Krupp, for
is
instance,
and thousands of
warfare of the
whose business
an example.
war.
Not in
vain did the Kaiser in his speech in July, 1900, set the
Huns up
as
The plunder-
shame.
Prussia
is
a military nation
military
and
is
in
its
history
and
tradition.
around
Rossbach,
like
it
Waterloo,
Sparta's,
set
Sedan.
Prussia's
characteristic,
fighters,
to
be
nation
all
of
and
has
that
stamp
on
Ger-
many.
Never have
at
ideals been
Germany
world.
Germany's
finest in the
50
Germany she would have had to introduce conscription. At the present moment her army is of slight importance
compared with Germany's.
to
mean
fittest
made
in war,
Darwinism in GerLessing
the
divine
organisation
the
universe,
peaceful endeavour of
flabby.
The
"
good cause does not ennoble war but a good war en-
*
first
*
caused dissatisfaction in
German
England
;
trade rivalry
tariffs in
Germany.
therefore ob-
German technician Eranz Reulaux (1877) correctly dismissed German wares with the disparaging phrase which long clung to them, billig und schlecht. But time
51
The English, soon had to admit that the Germans were more painstaking, knew more languages, strove more anxiously to satisfy their customers. The German salesman is known to outdistance all others.
Germany's
ities,
success,
due
to her
ill
many
admirable qual-
feeling in
England had
the
so parvenus.
did not like that the people felt what the Kaiser openly
asserted:
We
Germans acted
And now
years
is
all
breaking out.
peace
thorough cleaning.
may
be accorded Euro-
efforts are
when they work. A perfect example of a useless diplomat is, perhaps, the Erench ambassador in Vienna, who
had
so little
al-
the
52
who
are
now beginning
So in
a
sort
war
call
each on his
God
to crush the
enemy.
an-
cient days
Moab
cried to
Jehovah.
national
is
when
the
Tzar
says,
" Russia's
God
a powerful God,"
and a
sort
of
Olympian God
when the President of the Duma speaks of Him as the " King of Kings and the God of Gods." The God of Austria-Hungary guards the rights of the Dual Monarchy; the Serbian God protects Serbia. The German " Our Old Ally from RossGod, also spoken of as
bach," guards the Kaiser as His representative on earth,
calls
on his people to
fall
on their knees
Him
the King.
best
without
is
particular
success
defend
Bel-
gium's independence.
The
anti-clerical
government of
to
and
cause
On this
seem
Most assuredly,
Germany and France, Russia and Germany, Austria and Serbia, Germany and England, etc., justice means
exactly the opposite.
In
single statesman
to
53
mass murder.
to
Justice!
It is
has
name the objects for which the nations were fighting, as when Italy fought to become an independent nation, or when Prussia wanted the port of Kiel. But at the present moment
In other wars
it
was easy
to
powers
like Austria,
fighting
posi-
by the war
Socialism.
by private capital
remain in force
war
is over.
Russia moves slowly and she has always shown herself rather
lukewarm
to France.
It took the
French
to the
The
re-
border.
Until that
only
three
Berlin.
To
concentrate
54
four or
five
now
requires the
passed.
would seem
as if
mutual destruction.
Germany's first entrance on the battlefield was not marked with the assurance of 1870. She stumbled Belgium undoubtedly surprised over the threshold.
her by her undaunted resistance,
credit
is
for
which much
fortress
builder of
modern
times.
particularly renowned.
are
or-
ganisation
is
all obstacles.
In a country
ugly and
causing
But
is tragically inspiring.
The
so
awed
into
silence.
tragedy
beginning.
No
and
if
terror.
jurists
to the
increasing
peoples,
col-
possibility.
The
is
to Goethe,
still
"
We may
look
upon
all civilised
same goal."
As
wrote
Ruyssen,
:
the
University
is
of
Bordeaux,
"
One
thing,
at least,
55
certain
war
be-
56
comes
ical
politstates,
more or
less satisfactory
manner.
first
is
The most
fettered
excitable
by countless
Some
is
of the best
men
so
in
Europe
be-
far.
Now
Vis-
count Haldane
for
my
But
first
From
Vienna.
he who now
war on
Servia, France,
Eng-
and Japan.
Emof
members
of this
The 18th
war
at the City
Hall in
When
Austria-Hungary
declared
on
my
regrets.
The
conference,
57
war broke out and blazed to proportions which no other war on this earth ever reached, all
of the warring states disclaimed responsibility for
it,
and began
The
as to
have,
known, taken
Of
war,
the
twenty-four.
naturally
first
men-
a peace advocate
all
Women "
He
an-
stoian, or of
one
who
is
who
is,
believes
official
explanations as to the
British,
German, and
58
a powerful
party in
moment when
tria
she
France more
foresees
But he
made us
peace.
aggressors.
We had done
we
When
we need
not have
United States."
Gilbert
Murray then
asks
" Suppose
you saw a
man
highway.
Would you not stop him, and, if necessary, " Why knock him down ? " The Tolstoian replies
:
Let
I do
man
At
least,
world."
No
way.
discussion
is
who
"
feel this
Gilbert
Murray
looks
upon matters
Serbia
:
as follows:
little
wicked
little state.
me.
Discharge at once
all
functionaries, politicians,
and
soldiers
who do
not love
59
list
shall,
every
now and
then, send
you a
whom
for
life.
my
you
to
do so."
Serbia agreed to two-thirds of Austria's demands, suggested arbitration in regard to the remaining third
to
which
it
its
na-
tional sovereignty.
of war.
as follows:
The
assassination
of the Austrian
place.
Archduchess had
taken
High Catholic
intolerance
it
mount the
But
Indescribable horror
was expressed
at the assassination.
many
of the
members
of
By
60
the
agreed,
among
of a
Yet Germany
rel
said to
Belgium
"
We
have no quarto
with you.
and perhaps
fight a battle or to
We know
and we
will
that
permit
we
Con-
pay you in
Refuse, and we'll punish you so you will wish you had
never lived."
Belgium
tion.
at that
moment was
either.
If
it
would
right to
command.
is
The
result is that
stricken
from the
roll of
II
According to the English, the German-speaking peoples have scant respect for small nations.
tral
As
the Cen-
to
an amalgamation of
not surprising.
As opposed
com muni-
61
versity of Sheffield,
H. A.
S.
"
all
drama and
Eliza-
Louis
map
of the world.
Germany
consider
But even
if
we were
to grant
humanity
shown
itself
beneficial?
Has Has
not
the
who
divided
it
between them
has
it
Has
and subjects
amazed
they realise
how
unin-
62
telligent
has been.
The Ger-
man method
may
be
but
as offensive
which
which
it
it
very rarely
is
is.
The advantage
tions have the
of small communities
to
modify the
Small na-
same
effect
has on society
they
if it
implies
intel-
good
will,
faithfulness
to
duty,
self-sacrifice,
is
lectual interest,
no reason
monopolised by the
Such patriotism
may
an expression of fanaticism,
burnt heretics on
annihilates what-
it
its
plans.
Ill
Therefore,
if
We promised
63
Bel-
when
it
now
we.
uphold
just as
Of what use
if
without penalty,
so
?
it
convenient to do
is
to
law and
all civilisation.
Germany
said,
'
neutrality if
Germany had
not done
so.
But France
Sir
intentions.
Edward Germany
German
Chancellor soon
a scrap of paper.'
we
want
Germany by
small
race or language.
struggles
Germany
nations'
for
independence
the
freedom in our
days.
we
opposed to autocracy.
an
constitu-
more than
progressing
is
fifty
been assassinated.
is
and
constitutional
government.
gov-
France
a republic.
64
The Emperor is war lord. The army and navy are under his command alone. " Furthermore, we are fighting for the peace of Euaristocracy.
rope; for arbitration to prevent war, and for the organisation of states on a basis of peace as opposed to
militarism.
of
1864,
1866,
War was
looked
upon
'
as all powerful in
Treitscke wrote:
;
We
disposed of Austria
we
left:
disposed of France
the
last
is
England.'
Germany's
to dis-
fleet
were supposed
We
are
first
and
and hard
as
existence.
The Germans
First they had
meant
hoped
England
last of all.
that they
because
we
65
?
What
if
the
Germans were
to
succeed
What
would happen ?
" Belgium would remain
said, the
German
and, as Napoleon
pistol at
England's heart.
Even
if
it
apparent independence,
submit to
German
colonies.
tariff regulations.
course, be taken,
and
this
" Even
if
Holland were
to
pendent
it
would be German in
Rotterdam
imposed on her in
this
1871 seem
from Morocco.
German Agadir on
The
entire
Africa.
North
to
By means
fleet.
Germany
without
it
over
66
the world.
Germany dominated
While
Germany
to invade
United States in
self-defence.
Important
territories in Australia
would be conquered
Hong
Gibraltar
and Malta
be wrenched
away.
And
even
if
to keep India
and
it
lost these
man
garrisons.
ber
'
In Hamburger Fremdenblatt for SeptemGerman Vice-Admiral Kirchoff wrote: Germany's army and navy are now ready to attack
4
the
by
We
eco-
at sea, in
financial, political,
and
nomic
forces.
short,
Germany will
"
Boer
War
67
life
on a war of
and
The French
in 1870-71.
feel
We
Although bled
to
The civilised world can bear more than forty years we element in Europe. With
liberty.
we have
German
swords.
But we never
our
"
We
lived in peace.
to think
of our defence
and
as
we were
divided politically
we
provided badly
attacking.
We
never thought of
And when
German
we
mask
a movement,
68
"
from
liberal
con-
flicting traditions
the
the socialistic
divided
and
that
lose
life,
now
now
that
we cannot
highest
potentiality.
Now
other.
you cannot
find
two
derisions
France
The French
man
people.
as to the superiority
joy by
German men of science. In opposition to this the French now contend that the narrow elongated skulls are also found among wild races like the Hottenthe Ashanti Negroes, the Papuans.
tots,
In opposition
German people fact that the Prussians, who rule GerGerman origin. The German knights
adventurers from
all races,
69
to ascribe variations in
to racial
differences.
Among German theorists, Woltman teaches that the German has reached the highest civilisation, " thanks to the perfect organisation of the German mind " all the great men in history were German in reality, he claims. Giotto's real name was Jotte, Tasso was Dasse, Leonardo was a German by the name of Leonhard, Diderot was Tieroth; Gounod, Gundiwald. The whole Italian Re(I know the book naissance was a German product.
;
it,
mankind must be
credited to the
men
that the
Germans
The French
felt
unpleasantly affected
when German
70
patriotism.
make
is
it
in reality most
humane
as
it
brutality are
law.
it
What was
theoretically
it is
way
which, because
Eminent
Marshall
We
and
Northern France
Somme and
the Loire."
And
des-
by the argument,
which
"
We
civilising mission
war as war. In Germany during the last years war has again and again been declared the highest and
holiest expression of
human
71
and
From
song
the
territory the
rises,
And
humanity ?
the French ask, " Also above right, justice, liberty, "
Nevertheless
France.
The unpleasant
French mili-
events in Saverne in
tarists to
stirred
Both the
William II wished
even
to
selves covered
officers
in the
wrong
"
Would
that
!
In
this
Germany,
modern democracy
To them,
is
The members
known, by a three
in Berlin, enabled
elect twice as
many
men who
is
class.
Europe
reac-
72
Poland
at the
time of
Prussia, as opposed to
state; but
of the
Now
the
Germans stamp
the Rus-
and enemies of
police watched
and
woe
to
him
if these
With
glee he
was
handed over
Russian
police.
was Berlin.
re-
to the inscription
on
an
to fact
inscription bearing,
it
is
true, little
semblance
and claim
German monuments
after the fall of
Es
ist
verboten.
In France, attention
is also
drawn
Count Biilow
(as a
punishment because
promised not
to interfere in
German
politics) the
new
" bloc " has levied taxes to the amount of six hundred
million francs a year on articles of necessity.
Great
this.
73
have
fallen
into
oblivion
while
junker
and
criti-
person
is
considered arch-holy,
suits
There
nothing
socialist
In Germany a
mother,
majeste,
Cases of
therefor,
Use
have
steadily increased.
From 1888
In La
Revue
it is
One thing
is sure,
makes use of
In
reigns in
for
contrast
France
an
admirable
discipline
Germany,
room
is
independent thought.
;
Even German
is
science
official
as Frederick the
Great
Then I always
men
of science
my
claim."
The
Frenchman who
visits
Germany.
74
in France the
titles
mode
of address
is
flourish to such
member
his
title.
which
appears in
look
many forms
it
upon
as servility.
So far
is
as
no
difficulty in
The
foreigner
is
smothered with
is
and documents.
But France
different.
And
cation of magazines,
At long
intervals
we
him
only.
who
They
contain, as
the corresponding
German
publications,
insults
" Barbarians,
bandits,
murderers "
correspond
in
French
to the
:
German
England
" cowards,
criminals,
hypocrites,
liars,
75
The world scarcely has echo for such salutations. But they create and stimulate a national hatred so great that one can scarcely see how co-operation among the nations will be possible within the next
dozen years.
In
all belligerent
much
to be
proud
of.
As
it
Vernouillet
"Ah, Giboyer,
GlBOYER
"
Ne men
men
At
Germany The is that of civilisation itself against barbarism. whole world feels this, but our Academy has special authority to express it. As it has devoted itself to the
The
struggle that
is
"
it is its
Among
the poets,
frequently
Now
him and
76
The Hague
Peace Palace
" In spite of the horror which
filled
the civilised
itself.
Such a monument
is
a sanctu-
The
must reply
to the insult
among
we
that
in
from
protest.
its
Until
authors
of
these
un-
names on
by
this violent
superlatives.
He
many, in
fighting
spite of the
On
Au
dessus
de
of
la melee),
all
countries:
!
With what
reckless
77
whom
other!
rushing to save
your
race,
the
German
colossus,
my
"
who have
all
!
me
a beautiful farewell
how
I love
you
The
is
from France
While the
ing the blame for the war on one another, and while the people resign themselves to war, as brought on by a
and worshipped
it.
As
And now
is
the herd
war
casting fuel on
full.
countries
is
the elite of
all
rank and
is
file,
country's cause
progress.
The
as the
clergy in
sionate nationalists.
No
one
so intent on
war
Y8
representatives
Socialists
irons.
the
King
of
Peace.
Even
the
They
Germany, hastened
This
true
to forge
new
to defend
The
and
carcasses.
to
lost provinces.
this ideal
seemed pushed
aside.
Among
liest feeling
France seems
these provinces
away from
the
Germans by military
may
to
be obtained by a collapse
Europe but
to the entire
States, as a Chris-
Germans
calling
on
300,000
Mohammedans
79
England as a
mother country.
The
twentieth
century
all expectations.
war something very extraordiHigh and mighty Germany, whose motto for the last fifty years had been, Oderini dum metuant! (Let them hate provided they fear) suddenly
the outbreak of the
love,
At
began to crave
for sympathy.
bureaus, she had the words " lies and calumnies " on her
lips;
to the skies,
from
their books in
Germany.
Authors like
who
in one
way
mean
and measure.
Few
80
As
ment were
tisan
with
flashed before the eyes of the potential parthreats implied in case of refusal.
:
let-
"
diesen
bezeigt,
Wer in dem
wird
rekte Gleichgiltigkeit."
It is unnecessary to
add that
on an author of standing.
therefore for-
is
But
to be acceptable, praise
must be unconditional.
asked,
first
know
war.
of an author
who was
by a German,
Then he
received a tele-
gram from a
this
lish.
was not
sufficiently
pro-Eng-
both sides
isolate
how
to isolate
him
so
81
nor
when
attacked by Germany.
superior
munitions and
irresistible
German
task within
Bismarck
is
German diplomats had neglected their terrain and at moment enemy after enemy rose against Germany. Germany's army was so perfect that it could challenge a much larger army. German diplomacy had
the decisive
done
its
against
More than
On
190
the two
alone
France-Russia
represents
millions
The German Government immediately began to issue White Books to prove the Kaiser's love of peace and his
efforts to
maintain
it
to the
Tzar
and
to
King George
European War.
war lay
human power
to
82
even a finger
culties before a
European
tribunal.
Of
In
would
if the nation's
sovereignty were
if
He
Rus-
the
integrity
of
wanted peace, or
pose without
it)
(if
a short
quick triumph, in
inform the
He
had
al-
Germany. In their hearts the great mass of Germans knew they had not wanted war but had been absorbed in peaceful endeavour. The nation was taking giant
strides in
commerce, shipping, in
It
all
branches of indus-
had
had the
largest universities.
It
had gradually
out-
83
as in business initiative.
made in the last generation, and its only ambition was new fields of expansion. And now it was suddenly
hemmed
in on every side
It
meet
its
am-
Why
Germany, the
it
had made
a point
And
the wise
men
liked,
to the people.
was universally
and Wie-
and
Schiller,
But
this
real rea-
Germany was
the
Rhine
great
"
German Empire was crumbling; Bund " was under foreign domination and
and
political
Germany was
and
;
strong
the
greatest
as
was hated
the
mighty always are; now she was calumniated because of the most despicable jealousy now she was being en-
84
circled,
II
And from
German
people rose an
thing!
the Vistula,
"
While
all
Dies
The
first
characteristic of the
German
feeling
was a
women
men and
away opponents
the Keichstag.
Russia
cent,
85
slackers
and
men
while in
to enter the
army
for
Germany
by the million
suffer,
and
all
ready to
to give their
to their
country.
183
;187Q ;
self-sacrifice.
phases
of
intellectual
and
senti-
mental
life in
Steigerung,
worked up
before
it.
Even
it
German
territory
were
smitten by
to take part in a
war
The
first
exaltation
lib-
day
finally
against what
murand
Russian despotism,
English treachery,
Japanese knavishness."
Russia's hatred
is
no
less violent
than Germany's.
Incidentally
it
is
86
^consider
it
the
is
Now
that he
to
have
name
of his city.
Burg by
Grad
is
found
etc.;
word brought
is to
into Slavonic
by the Varangians.
In-
stinctively one
nenhampf
a Russian name.
It will be
one by one.
The
first officer's
had one of the beautiful names ending in of or ski. " Thank Heaven " cried the Emperor when he heard
!
And
Romanofs
all
What
is
to be
Oranienbaum, etc?
87
a rather clever
German
suggested
Ill
Soon, however,
Germany
up
the hounds
now
being
made by men
of
is hypocritical,
England
of
is
mendacious, England
passion of greed."
moral armies." England has calumniated Germany's " herrliches und sittenstrenges
Heer/'
Harnack
believes in "
When
texts."
weaken
it
so that
alone.
"
Because
she cannot bear to see our strength, our thrift, our prosperity.
is
no other explanation."
And
with
considerable pride
Harnack concludes in
the following
"If we
fall,
88
."
many.
tearing
What does it mean? That Great Britain is down the barrier which has saved western Euits
rope and
culture
desert."
Harnack
liam III, who a hundred years ago was Russia's greatest ally
to
remember
that
stag
as "
mountain
is
high above
opprobrious
the
now
more
opprobrious
as
England
Eng-
own
race.
call
They
all
Germany
intellectual
antipodes.
The Englishman, on
narrow-minded islander
the contrary
arrogant,
looks
And by
fills
now
The world
is
deceived by Britain's
mask
89
German
chorus.
Professor
Otto
Hinze.
The
joins
celebrated
philologist
Wilamonitz-Moellendorf
"
in
the
same
We
all
know
that
England
stirred
.
.
has always
made
it
a rule to violate
international
vir-
and now
it tries
infa-
mous
lies to stir
word ever
crosses Sir
that
Not a The
true
cele-
with-
which caused
this
world
Germany.
sad phase of
of the
war
is
that
it is
same
race.
" Compared to
Belgians
who
"
von
Liszt,
ward VII.
" holy
War
"
is
to
him
war."
Our
opponent's
it
;
strength
does
not
frighten us.
We
must break
we must win."
IV
It
was necessary
to
win
at
any
price.
The English
motto,
My
90
gharply criticised.
was
tacitly accepted.
As
ethics, ex-
was
There
In
Germany asked
if
Engif
it
vis
the fate which her ally, Bussia, held in store for this
little
country.
Serbia's sovereignty,
tween them.
And how
it
about Egypt?
and
civilisation
was asked
if
by championing
liberty
and progress.
Never did Germany (any more than France or England) assert that nations are not
siderations but
moved by moral
conpro-
by
political ones.
When Germans
mind
When
they claimed to be
91
need of an offensive-defensive
When Germany
mark
in
monetary
1807-08)
loss of a fleet
is
(as inflicted
by England in
loss of three
as nothing
provinces (taken by
Germany
When Germany
against, she
seemed
to
had
to
Germany
is
now
fighting.
And most
Denmark.
as
English,
actuated
by
political
motives,
not
by
And
as statesmen
for-
people cry
"
We
We
We
are a nation
in arms,
militaristic nor
92
are
They
call
us barbarians
are a nation
we
exists.
we were weak.
Now
We
are the
new
forces in humanity,
civilisation.
as
opposed to
represent
We
As
theorists
we
pre-
we
Not
we
possess
ethics,
we shown
Introduction
oned.
The immense losses of the war may be easily reckThe advantages which are eventually to come
it,
out of
their
Yet those
But
armies
been no revolts either in Prussian Poland, the Russian " Kingdom," or in Austrian Galicia. Indeed, one may
say that the internal splitting of the Polish people
is
seems to be divided.
made by
the Russian
Com-
94
mander-in-Chief, Grand
dle
of August.
It
began
" Poles
dream.
people
!
Under
cluded
this sceptre
Poland
shall be reborn
and free in
it
religion,
:
language,
"
and government."
of
And
con-
The dawn
new
life is
before you.
Let
Although
liberty
this
manifesto with
its
astonishing love of
necessities of the
moment and
which one
the
made by
the
Russia),
appeal
made
a certain impression.
It seemed an expression
to impress
and of a nature
now
called
The purpose
of the manifesto
was
to prevent
an
in-
It seems to have
made
little
was a
95
young men
to sports
to
to help Austria
all.
The Ruthenian
formed
^
wooed the good-will of Poland
and tried
to
win
it
month
In
it
he
said,
among
other things:
me
you
They made
tiful
serfs of
and
reli-
gious liberty
Such
is
my
mighty
Emperor "
!
When
how
96
Emperor
better.
As
politically
most undevelIts
motto
is:
We
Austria.
We
We
hundred
years.
Politi-
under
and
politics, or else
remain in
Why
evident to any
am
inclined to say
it
matters
little
what forms
may
In 1812,
paign,
too,
all
Europe sympa-
But
97
and
terrible crisis,
how
anxiously
ideals.
Yet
at this
moment
more
in
war
or rebellion.
And
this is not
due
to the
war
manity
not
to
1914
I
ried
has,
on the whole,
Europe).
may
by the Poles.
it
I expressed
my
ions.
became the
my
opin-
my
As
until ten
into
years later,
when
it
German.
Writing in Danish
on the whole,
like writ-
ing in water.
It
am
98
have
And
for
In 1898 I refused
made
bitter
who
dumb
as a wall
For-
do
little
harm.
elections
and
re-
mained
me
to
it
whom
filled
who
It
me
pathy.
is
am
is
writing
these lines.
The very
the Jews
to
deny
is
all rights.
Every now
instance,
in
Kishinef,
for
but
normal
99
move, to study.
Even
schools
and universities
is
Moscow
registered as a prostitute
card.
and received a
she
up
Jew who
to
is
may move
Moscow, and
he
is
married he
may
child
But
if
old, it
them.
capital.
Neither
in cars
or railroads.
Only by
special authorisation
can the parents keep the child; and to obtain such authorisation a detailed application
must be
sent to the
Governor-General,
it.
who has
the
power
to grant or refuse
in-
may
in a
Maxime Kova-
me
that
when
Duma
were tak-
100
this,
and
tried
elected,
man who
Bo you
another
think we would let so much money go when we might get it ourselves ? "
told
to
me
village.
He
"
as they
seemed so good-
natured.
To his surprise they replied, " Yes," adding, You know why." And they explained they had killed
Jews because the Jews had killed their Saviour. Said Kovalevski, " But that was a long time ago, and
the
The
ment
last
"
A
"
!
We
it
week
It
few days
before.
But
is
Jews spread
to read
to
Russian
"
Kingdom
101
and
to live there
Their
Jewish
What
off
from the
world
Jews
in
Denmark
day.
the
In 1794 a corps
in
1809.
When
Jews
later
on dared to
them by banishing
All their
boys from the age of six were sent under Cossack guard
to
Archangel to be trained as
sailors.
Most of them
masses.
And
from
Poland's distinguished
rising.
men
tried to pre-
vent
it
Adam
Poland,
Pan Taadeuz
(1834),
made
102
He
the
poem culminates when Jankiel plays the Dombrowski march for Dombrowski himself. Indeed the history of Poland from 1791-1812 seems crystallised, symbolised in the poem which seems to throb and vibrate
with the spirit of the Napoleonic year in which the
scene
is laid.
At about 1860 Jews and Catholics were equals in Warsaw, and when in February, 1861, the crowds kneeling in the two great public squares singing the national
tried
show their
national spirit.
hymn.
This
last trait
the two
made such
as one of the
And now
nationalism
lost,
over Europe,
all fellow-feeling is
to
burning race
hatred.
103
to be elected to
is
Duma.
The population
of the city
somewhere
was in
their
power
to elect a
Jewish representative.
the Jews renounced
As Polish
this right.
nationalists, however,
They felt that Warsaw, the capital of the Polish Kingdom, should be represented by a man of They simply asked that Polish race as well as spirit.
the electoral committee should nominate a candidate
who would
not be an
enemy
of the Jews.
The comanti-
would
Duma
in order
Poland of Jews.
It
is,
by
word
rid,
of
lips
with incredible
As
who would
This
candidature maintained.
The
result of this
was
104
that the
bound
to
them.
efforts
At
had proved
Demo-
Jewish candidate.
As
all
the leading
Jews belong
to the
higher
middle
classes,
them
to
back him.
Lord
inclines
sighted politicians
Here
was proved.
in Russian Poland
who
since the
sensibilities
took
European
electoral victory to
The
movement
at
which
now began
to be systematically
and
105
rang
In private
out
Have
nothing to
At
intel-
lectuals,
among
meta-
them confirmed
chowski.
many
conversions,
who
tion.
ski,
lack of character
But
the author of
Chawa Rubin,
my
life
could
Not only do all Alexandre Swientochowski's writings rise up against him, but all the fiery words which fell from his lips in his days of glory now
never happen.
turn against him.
The
Semitic campaign.
Young
women
the as-
there.
By
of the
Groszi,
Nawas
tional-Democratic party, a
new
paper,
Dwa
founded
which
openly
advocated
pogroms.
little
Bloody
In the
town of Welun
106
house of a
make war on
the Jews.
the ritual
is to this
fully
proved
(!)
Beilis
Under
well
known
A relative
of the great
and pleaded,
at last
amid
Not a
sult
All this happened before the war, and the direct re-
But during
again,
for
and
107
Immense Pogroms against Jews in England. The English Government makes no effort to stop them." The lie was evident. But the object was to establish
a precedent.
When
metals.
silver.
Thej were
Nevertheless the Jews were accused of having smuggled a million and a half rubles of gold into
in a coffin.
priests
Germany
in
And while the Jewish representatives and Warsaw protested, and their protest was
it
printed in Russia,
paper.
single Polish
Many
other prepara-
were made.
The
They had
who
All
who were
on the
spot.
Jews were
ac-
108
were blamed.
The
when Austrian troops conquered a town or a village as well as when Russian troops drove away the Austrians. The result was the same in either case. A certain number of Jews were
espionage.
to serve
was made
Lists
of
those
really
guilty
of
Aristocratic Polish
names were on
a Potocki,
list
for instance,
to death
but the
did
Jew
called
Dark
leg-
it
is
a proof of hu-
manity's
indescribable
simple-mindedness.
Few
caused such a
the centuries.
of thousands.
sum
of suffering
It has
of the story
is
impossible.
its
environs.
He
101)
multitude.
every
hide,
woman and
known by each and every one; by every child. Not alone does he not but wanders about, followed by disciples who
is
He
And
it is
him
and for
But
men
effect
by a
:
to point
him
!
kiss
Which
of
you
Jesus
He
from the
who
eventually succeeded in
making people
forget that Jesus, all the apostles and all the evangelists,
as well,
name
reads
has become
as
spy, in the
Even
fell as a
Now
it is
110
By means
many
other frightful
of Russian Poland.
no
dearth.
Many hundred
innocent
people
the
have been
sacrificed.
few examples
among
many.
In the
trians,
city of
Bychawa, which was taken by the Auscitizens took sides with the
se-
Conse-
man
When
away
shortly
same Polish
that the
citizens
commanders
Jews in the
communicated
Russians of them.
As
a result
many
children) were
hung on
if
in Galicia.
city, the
When
the Russian
army
recon-
quered the
111
arrested.
As they denied
Madonna
in his hand,
that
it
He
proved
The
had
But
five
In the city of Jusefow the Jews were accused of having poisoned the wells so that a hundred Cossacks lost
their
lives.
Seventy-eight
Jews were
stores looted.
killed,
many
women
violated, houses
and
In
this
way
greater or smaller
loot
have raged
Kelts.
Warsaw,
Eye
me
of Jewish soldiers in
various hospitals
In their delirium
ones
own dear
whom
112
The Russian Poles' anti-Semitic campaign is all more odious since 40,000 Jewish soldiers, among them many volunteers, serve in the Russian army and as
the
army and
the
Red
Cross
In larger communities
special hospitals
soldiers
have received
the
highest
an active anti-Semite.
Russian
The
proc-
my
in
it
accusation in Politikken.
ciliate
who
are
The
Jew
does
is
not proved in
one way,
proved in another.
the
M. Warinski mention
CONDITIONS
Poland.
refuse to do
sian Poland
m RUSSIAN POLAND
113
is
as I, for one,
In the long run how could the Russian Poles be unfaithful to the only powers they can count on
call
on
And
is
so strong
cannot be crushed by
How
uge
to its children?
Probably, in reply to
my
it
will
be explained
this appeal.
it is
because of
my
race that I
now make
Personally
my
me
so little that I
and
faith.
last
Even
spring during
my
stay in
America I was
That was
shows that
it is
not because of
of
my
opinions, that I
114
thy
is
and
It
One
it
loves
or Eng-
mean
and
to
is
asm!
best in
lives
Poland
which humanity
Those were
now.
my words,
Must I be ashamed
Poland's future
is
now
that
Europe
into a
and a bankrupt
sort of
estate,
one
would
some
war.
an internal peace
would reign within the boundaries of the different countries participating in the
arti-
and
justice.
Yet
since the
press, dis-
war Russia has suppressed the workingmen's solved the labor societies, imprisoned five members of
the country's
Duma,
which were not even made by the Tzar himself but by a commander whose words bound no one and
ganised a persecution of the Russian Jews which
oris
The number
of
Jews
army
is
calculated to be between
ment
is
Jews a
single right.
116
Neither does
in
Poland
When
to
boundless misery
from
from Charkov, whose face was half torn away and who
was
to
and had
Jewish
origin.
And
Jew
is
officers.
In Poland a
series of
many
places
murdered.
evicted
live in
;
Furthermore,
territory they
the
inhabitants
have been
to
from
notice.
streets
into the
Warsaw
left in the
The Jews
cities, fleeing
117
were
filled
to protest is the
While in Eussia
and men: a
in short, take
up
the cause
Jews and
look
upon
the excitation to
pogroms as a
like
men
Nemo-
is
behind
Poland's leading
men
act as if
intellectual elite to
drag down
instead of to uplift.
POLAND
(November, 1915)
who
is
to speak at the
woman who
As
so
many
women, she
main
politically
weak.
She belongs
to
a celebrated
Polish family.
Ledochowski,
Her who as
May
laws.
He had
him
to
and he had
In 1875, Pius
cardinal.
The Countess
side she
is
is
On her mother's
of Salis in
several branches
re-
But
POLAND
which
is
119
it is
of
Ledochowska who
nothing esteemed
else.
to this
day a highly
name
Her
brother
is
As
it
She hopes
to
to
way
which
now
for
more than sixteen months has ravaged the popuidle life of a society
lation.
woman.
entirely given
girls.
up
is
her
the education of
young Polish
She
filled
human
one.
As
I have said,
is
who
is
strange
as
it
may seem
something
120
He who
are convinced
all
simultaneously massacre
man by
nature
is
a vastly more
whom
Goethe char-
by the celebrated
lines:
" Ein Theil von Jener Kraft Die Stets das Bse will und
stets das
Oute Schaft."
Man, or
ferent and
much more
terrible.
He
und
stets das
Bse
schafft."
For
all
naval commanders,
all,
day
do the right
but
of.
The
fight for
the good has had the certain result of causing the most
awful
evil
As conditions in Poland have a political as well as a human side, it may not be amiss to add a few polit-
POLAND
ical
121
point.
As
will be
gun by a manifesto made by the Russian Commander-inChief Grandduke Nicholas Nicholaijevitch to the Poles
in Russian Poland.
It
what
its
limi-
would
be,
was
Austrian army.
or
and
if it
its
at least pre-
much
as Slav.
An-
is
more
not so thorough.
systematic.
It
may
its
be more barbarous,
but
it is less
It contains loopholes
through
defined.
which one
outline
is less
And
one advantage
122
moved
cal
Prussian bureaucrat
honourable,
an incorruptible, fundament-
ally
governmental
automaton
virtues.
without
the
differences
between the
for
who counted on
who hoped
man
victories.
But enough
to fight against
differences
remain
powers
Kingdom
is called,
and the Poles who favour the Central Powers have the
floor.
And
it.
Germany
alone pub-
month
and there
is
swarm
pos-
of pamphlets.
that
from
all
these
it
would be
and
some
very
events.
But
this is
bears the
official
stamp.
ing to be unofficial are published under a wakeful censorship and are inspired by the authorities.
ent
At
the pres-
joyfully
accepted
Russian
POLAND
standards in regard to freedom of speech.
life is
123
Intellectual
The
There
teacher cannot
is
lying, gloss-
ing over, erasing, omitting, inventing, and double dealing to please one political faction or another.
As
look
Galicia
is
human
rights,
it
was natural
to
upon Galicia
as the kernel of
Poland reborn.
The
polit-
Kingdom
it
be united with
ical
and
all
The
possibility of
Kingdom
the
project
regent's
But
this
it
changed
were, of the
German Empire. Two points deThe first, that Germany " is attention.
it
124
The words were chosen with care and revealed the Yet the Chancellor's intention not to commit himself.
speech was surprising, and
if a
words, and
if
German and
especially
Prussian
If
politics.
Germany intended
freely,
it
from Russian
acteristics
could not
refuse the
Poles
in
his
would be in
and Galicia
evenly
Kingdom " is quite Polish divided among Poles and RuthePosen are Gerless
man, and
hard
in Prussia
no
would be very
would be
and
if,
let
They
is
constructing
it
materially.
There
nothing to hint
Poland, but
much seems
to prove Austria's
and Prussia's
POLAND
desire to concede Polish language every right
125
which
it
The
it
is
pass resolutions or
make promises
for the
future.
And
of, there is
terially.
The
traditions of
to such
seriousness looked
upon the
hundred
moves comparable
to those of a
years ago
sia's
those
out
the
way
to Siberia in the
For
live-
to seek food.
this treat-
ment.
The
allowed to go out.
126
sympathy
which misery
excites.
territory
had
as
sum
of suffering heaped
upon them
now when
fore their eyes as not too far distant nor too uncertain.
In 1866 I wrote:
ing to mortal eyes
is
hopeful by
at least accord-
of finding a
way
like
on his mind
to
be no solution of his
cept that which might arise in the problematical event of a great war between Russia on one Germany on the other."
side
and Austria-
What
So
I,
almost
fifty
hensively, has
now
taken place.
good cause,
POLAND
Lecture delivered March 13, 1916
The nations
the earth and
That
all
we know
war
in
articles
hatred in the
it last
?
There
is
blood-
press.
How much
earth?
longer can
general
We
in a black shroud.
We
rise
What
is
Europe?
battlefields,
enormous bankrupt
lum.
128
The
as well
as
the spectators
of the
huge
tragedy have heen taught from childhood that a supernatural and wise destiny directs the world.
believe that everything,
And
they
is
They ask
this?
in deep
anxiety:
What good
is to
come out of
will
From
the
now
the enemy,
they
come what
is
called justice.
Most people
as ministers
on them.
And
profess
who know that humanity is worth more than nationality. Few who know that where hatred is
are they
Few
Few
they are
who
feel, as it
says in a
little
Swedish
foot,
Truth despised,
Then my blood
boiled.
POLAND
Now
I
129
When
In
I
know know
spite of prayers
life's
and
tears,
law
is
And
yet
it
if in
may
be,
uncertain and
is
flicker-
this
future
is
considered.
present.
For
rarely, perhaps
nowhere on
In the
by
three
three great
bil-
men
:
crippled
and mutilated
real
great
powers
Added
cruelty.
drown
unfortunately
it
triumph here
as
everywhere
it
else.
!
War
is
cultural power,
is
claimed to be
sordid
everything
has
the earth.
130
And
seem
become
We
see the
shimmer
of an
its
greatness, but
still
a Poland
Kingdom
West
and given
much
inde-
pendence as small
to
remember
Danes
Kot only
throbbed
old, not
only
see the
age and his leadership did not prove worthy of the task.
To
see
and talk
to these
men was
And some
tion to
During a
Koloszinski.
Warsaw
He
showed
me
while examining
to see the
POLAND
sumptuous
civilisation
131
of the
of aristocratic Poland
my
eyes.
hetmans,
castellans,
bishops
all
these
bands
and I
felt
how
all this
splendour symbolised
and beauty.
He who had
such a
the
gold-brocaded
scarf
And
boundless hospitality,
eating and drinking,
its
its
ethics of princes.
its
women,
its
And
so
women were taught to love high ideals and grace, From childthe men were trained to heroic courage.
filled
One
dissenting vote
was enough
world
to prevent
any common
decision.
132
the days of
It culminated in
is
modern
But even
of mail.
in
war
is
old
Poland was a
feast of splendour.
ever present.
is
supposed to
ways
It
Slowacki, in his
of
poem Beniowshi
God
"
that crawl.
mad
gallop
He is not a God of worms or of creatures He loves the flight of gigantic birds and the He is the dashing of storming horses.
No one except a Pole would define the Deity so. When Polish decadence and the politics of Catherine
II led" to the
first
The
brilliant decadent
thirteen millions
magnates in
The
POLAND
to
133
In Poland,
as
in Iceland
After the
selves.
first
The
They had
as
five millions.
lost.
The
elective
able
way
monarchy,
majority, the independence of the judiciary, and a relative protection of the peasant class against the arbi-
The
constitution of
May
3,
must
rejoice.
Then Catherine II
interfered, in
first
agreed to recognise
allied
him-
Traitors
among
134
Xavier Branicki formed the confederation of Targowica, in order to preserve the liberum veto, and handed
their country over to the partitioning powers.
his
Their
rewarded by Bonaparte.
of the
Danube and
Here
it
famous Polish national anthem was created for Dombrowski's soldiers, the Jescze Polska:
is
not
yet crushed.
No
the
At
own
was
at
stake,
the
On
Only 36
in
them were
left the
next morning.
When Moreau
POLAND
1814 made the mistake of surrendering the
sons, the
135
fort of Sois-
resisted a besieg-
ing
army
judg-
to be trapped.
More
1863.
Europe has
European
be found
countries
mostly
Adam
The
Germany
to
too.
Europe, to
to
"Die Lfte wehn so schaurig, Wir ziehn dahin so traurig Nach ungewissem Ziel.
Kaum
Das
Europa
vom Ferne
grosse Trauerspiel/'
At
the Barriere of
La
Cite, Lies a
Humble
Little
Cafe."
The
silent
136
who drink
chest.
. .
"
You
fools,
Do you
realise
how
Why
the
how deep
is
as
is to
Astrup by a Polish
be shot she holds her
Mother.
When
the father
man may
see
him
upon him, and With the force and the strength Which death alone can give Consecrate him to vengeance "
!
The
revolt of 1863,
birth to
much
among which
the
is
On
Poland
as " the
empty spot
And honey
A monument No
it
which crackles
ends,
it
would seem
will be reconstructed.
is still
POLAND
During the war, the press of the
has succeeded in exciting to an
137
belligerent countries
unknown degree
hatred which
the most
race or birthplace
hatred.
and national
This hatred
vents peace.
And
It is
exerts itself.
human
it
wounds
has caused.
The importance
will
But
it
*
profitable colonies in
to-
Minor
England began
to feel acutely
menaced.
referring
to
Turkey and
its
fate
was
of no
interest to
Germany and
gle
Pomeranian grenadier."
But
for
years Germany's influence has been decisive at the Bosphorus, while France, during her necessary but badly
centuries.
During
this
time the
made
and
139
Minor
sealed a solemn
still
alli-
dripping
The
It
had
Germany
Bagdad
German
history.
The story of the Bagdad road is an example of the way in which the fate of nations depends on a few
men
in reality, are
making war
war
away from
become
financial
their neighbours.
Now
industrial states
and are in
by
140
no
Each
war
to-
its
vestment for
its capital.
The
real character of
day
is
in
1900 in order
Manchuria.
in
1904
The conquest
of territory
Now
coal
and
iron as well as by her spirit of enterprise and her unrivalled sea power.
tor
the race.
Germany, which
nation.
ical
She began
abound in foundries,
a budding navy.
mills,
chem-
new
railroads,
no un-
But as the years passed and the Germans progressed, England discovered that many an article supposed to be of home maunfacture was Ger-
141
And
as
German
to
consuls and
German
conflict
everywhere, in
The
first
move
in this international
game
of chess was
Germany by
He came
France in the
was
cleared.
About
this
time
of
German
it
Gulf and
old
as first
planned
was
Roman
Taurus Mountains
plain of
cities in the
cheapest
But Russia
protested,
since
it
would
142
case of
trans-Caucasian
French companies.
One
of Alexandrette.
Finally the
be used by
all
By means
come a
sort of
German
province.
network of tracks
One
of the terminals
The
it
made
pos-
There would
incalculably decreased.
143
As Germany
formed.
presi-
Bank and
pagnie du
Nord
et
du Midi.
On
Back
of
him were
finan-
Rouvier.
financial understanding
As soon
as this
had been
It
must be remembered
and
As a
La Revue, France
four
affiliated
is
practically governed
by three or
without giv-
and invest
it
144
also
the
Government.
the
won
And when
men had
The
first
to
were taken.
Jules Lemaitre,
who
at that
time had
At
with
this
England began
to
torious.
not on
If
Germany were
to secure the
The consequence of the Franco-German understandas ing was King Edward's visit to Paris in 1903
stated above.
As an
masses.
still
The
England was
During
the
man
145
diplomat he knew what he wanted and was bent on making use of every opportunity to insure England's supre-
macy
it
Germany.
He
realised
difficult to stir
During
casse,
his stay in
who
at the
In 1901
St.
Petersburg
he tried
to
and
King Edward's
day after he
stay in Paris
was well
spent.
The
left for
London
it
company and
solved.
that the
Basra
is
England's
step to thwart
The outcome of the war alone will decide whether Bagdad Railway is to be completed by Germany or
other Powers.
the
146
The Bagdad Railway incidentally is one of the many threads which, bound together, have forged the this war for busicable which brought on the war,
It rages
bank directors and kings of industry. madly while Europe's unhappy and peace-lovartificially
ing
peoples,
stirred
by national hatred,
and
justice.
The war
fatherland
for trade
is
of that fatherland
which statesmen in
and developed
tion
grenade.
How
often
!
we hear
that
we
making days
human
scale.
lives
All this
may
that benefit
humanity steamships,
etc.
which
But
valuable.
Of
course
may
great.
But
as a
general thing, wars are not waged for ideals but for
profit.
Economic competition
is
nations,
148
on
The
ing for right and never doubt that Heaven owes them
victory.
They
all
frown on neutrals,
whom
they de-
They who
arguments, and
futile to
Among
and America.
It
went against
all
sense of justice,
to all right.
That neutrality
ac-
Yet
it
August
2,
M. Cambon
that if the
come
troops.
melted
149
the
Dutch
Low German,
dis-
Walloons
felt
Belgium
after the
war
it is
The Belgians
And man
while Belgium
may
Germany with
is
example
From
gramme.
the very
They were
for
right.
war a The
pro-
pro-
out in such a
way
as to crush
and
to
Germany was
France was
to get Alsace-Lorraine;
Denmark, North
150
t be united
This
last
What
suffered
is
more
war than
share of
1863.
And
its
But
the
Poland has
Eastern
battle-field
many
Galicia,
are
fighting
Russian
Austria,
now under
the knout.
The Ruthenians,
(who while oppressed in Russia had been free in Austrian Galicia) are deprived of the right of speaking their
own language by
They num-
While
mothers
lost
race,
Rus-
German
enemies.
And
in this
unhappy country
151
Abused by
all sides,
forming
war
They have no human rights. And whatever and suffering is let loose upon them, is made to apSince the conquest of Jerusalem the Jewish race
by massacres
Christian
of this
soil.
The
great days
we
Everything
bestial
in
human
all
nature
all
spreads
and
stretches itself.
ing,
is
Murder
sacrificed
night and
day, unceas-
their youth is
and the
starva-
people at
tion.
home
perish
And
152
seen
that some-
As
for me, I
am
will look
we
look
NEUTRALITY
An Open Letter
to Georges Clemenceau
28, 1915)
(February
Dear Friend:
Your remark about the Danes, that they are a nation without pride, has made bad blood in this country and has wounded me personally. A writer of your rank
should refrain from derogatory expressions about a
strikes a butterfly
with a
You
doubtless
subject.
You
attack
and
You
ascribe
it
I,
Germany
who,
if I
sub-
mitted
say
so,
it
to
it,
may
myself by
tion
war as madness. Through your paper, which I read, I know you feel that Denmark ought to As long as there is a grain declare war on Germany.
in
the
happen.
153
154
No Dane who
that
Denmark then
from a national
if
may
but in
We have
not
by which the
to be
And
interest
German
regime's
and
spirit in
North Schleswig.
still
Nevertheless, some of us
political insight,
retain a fragment of
declar-
ation of
war on Germany
The war
of
was accepted
in case
Denmark
alone.
is desired,
a fertile study.
was pursuing a wise policy in supporting Prussia, hoping naively that Bismarck might sometime do her a
NEUTRALITY
protest, allowed Prussia to acquire the port of Kiel.
155
If
to-day
Denmark has
neither a
fleet
capable of offensive
this is
If
Denmark would
But she
the offensive.
The few Danes who have tried to enrich themselves during the war without regard to the country's weal or
its
officially
by the
de-
law and
by public opinion.
They do not
Dear Friend
it
Your
articles against
Denmark
sting.
have,
Once
you said
was
characteristic that I
letter to you.
You
spoke of this
me
mention
France.
to save
flections
my
name.
from
" Re-
In your
is
on Neutrals," there
also a passage
which
many
celebrated
that
Scandinavian
country
which has suffered most from German brutality. A Russian journalist repeated to you certain remarks which the thinker in question
is
156
marks.
Would
as I
that
and
Even
as influ-
ential a writer as
at
my
door in vain.
word
supposed to
have
and I
by you.
The warm friendship which has bound us for many years, and which, from my side, has never been broken, makes me wish to answer you briefly and clearly, as one
would answer a friend and a man who hates
and circumlocutions.
your highmindedness.
inconsiderately about
futilities
know your
it is
love of truth
and
If
Denmark
do not know our language and are not familiar with our
conditions.
In old friendship,
G. B.
NEUTRALITY
Reply to Georges Clemenceau
(March, 1915)
157
When
neutral,
the
herself
difficulties of the
street corners.
it
had
few who are generally known and who in the eyes of the
foreigner are looked upon as representing the people.
Not
I,
personally,
must
Added
to this
to in a
would give when writing for publication. You did not Allow me here to requite grasp the sense of it.
mark
my
lights
and
also
and
trust.
my
reserved posi-
You seem
have
to
imply that
it
was of importance
to
me
to
my
Per-
my
He
has been
158
in
my
eyes, however,
was not
(i.e.,
to
Danish Government
for
moment Denmark).
The most
do
And
this
might hap-
same name.
my brother,
Denmark
or that he shared
When you
is
of little consequence
if
by protesting I could
cities or
a re-
Of
course the
German
if
That I
am no
voice
afraid of raising
my
when
I believe
my words
can
and
if
you knew
my writof the
know
As
me
single ex-
ample
Kurds.
You
ally
NEUTRALITY
my
opinions so frequently (they
159
may
be found in
my
trying to get
said.
may have
to
said
you
at
remark that we
last
At
that time
the
European
open
situation,
is
to-day,
could
My
letter to
only.
You
in-
an
which
my
protest.
!
Your
few
It
:
me
Us
Denmark ought
to declare war.
You
made
it
seem
as if the
not declaring
war on Germany. And you repeatedly dwelt on the pitiable figure the Danes would cut at the peace negotiations when they would ask the Allies for
(Holstein,
Schleswig,
Lauenburg)
Danish conditions.
No
polit-
make such
160
demand.
tion
ma-
spirited.
is
What
the
the restitution
the resti-
we were
to obtain it
by
humiliating Germany.
For
many would
This
Denmark
The
many.
It
must
not the
So far Germany
Allies.
Imagina-
man
The
may
for
look
in
especially as events
my
part,
am
not sanguine.
is
I do not for a
to be the last
Your
putting
letter
ends
way
by
me through
a cross examination.
am not fond
NEUTRALITY
of inquisitions, even
161
when
European
The purpose
reveal
my
me
man
way
the problem
I have expressed
my
so
many
My
sympathy for
from the
My
entire
me want
that
Bel-
gium and France freed from the enemy. Since you insist, I must admit, however,
this occasion, as otherwise in life, I
upon
I
to
understand them.
When
so
you ask
French
me who
all
is
in the right,
162
would mean
fill
with
To you
Renan' s Caliban,
my name
war
is
of a
of truth.
ings in Finland,
ised to reunite,
prom-
and where
Galicia
it
is
tears
down Ruthenian
away
the
atrocities
treated
its
cause
is
the just
my
NEUTKALITY
hatred that
reaction.
victory.
is
163
splitting
Europe
as a sign of
an immense
You want me to look forward to the Allies' The problem is too complex. I could, as I
and
still less
at Ja-
pan's.
Not
against Japan.
But the
after having
wrenched away
culture
is
all
its
Asiatic colonies.
but
is
different
and foreign
to ours,
And you would expect good results from an Austro-German victory " 'Not for a moment.
!
"
The organisation
sential
of which
Germans
es-
who
are
now
The Prussian Government hoped from it. The session refused to amend the
to be
it
refused to
amend
if
Prussian Diet.
But what
win a
decisive vie-
164
tory?
He
he
is
Be
it
said to his
honour that
he dared speak
had not
opponent.
men
In
my
Even
if
name
of morality
fact,
am
constituted to-day,
by
political
and not
ethical
motives.
When
is
not
moral but
When England
is
the
as
I look upon
the
German
way
NEUTKALITY
an outrageous injustice
foreseen, however,
odicals of
165
political expedient.
As
this
many
by a layman
surprised that
slightest defence.
The English
a beautiful book,
many
foreign-
ers contributed.
fall of
Would
Antwerp!
You,
my
my personal feelings.
when
forty years
five years'
am
indebted to
Germany
because,
my
country for
welcomed
me
never
let
me
feel I
was a stranger.
only
it
German opinion
turned against
Schleswig.
to me.
me
when
I protested regarding
Since then
more indebted to England, where I have been received as in no other country, and where I have
I
still
am
am most
For
mv
whole education
French.
166
everywhere I
form in which
it
my
in-
is,
my
entire mentality, I
as willingly.
owe
I
to France.
do not lack
as
do,
nor
is it true,
to
France.
My
it.
entire
sympathy
is
with her.
I believe
my
But I wish
to state that I
If he
to be
The
people or a
his ideals,
let
class,
no matter how unpopular they may be, nor down on them, nor pretend that he sees them realised
It is not the
remain
when he knows
silent
He must
if
remain
where
silence is golden.
face,
And
same
that
truth which
The
tral.
Any
participation in the
angle.
and sympathies
Allies.
intellectuals,
on Germany's
As Sweden
fears Russia
with
Sweden
are
the
The
Swedish upper
classes
pro-German
It
is
to a certain extent.
self-evident that
absolute neutrality.
Danish territory
is
we
could
of Copenhagen within
Denmark
could
Half
168
European Power.
it is
lish
annex
two-fifths
of
Denmark's
territory.
Germans
Danish must
clothes
ex-
For
lit-
if
the
up in the respect of Denmark and The Reichstag has voted appropriations for buying up Danish land in Schleswig, and Polish land in Posen. Young Schleswigers are obliged to fight and bleed in the German ranks for a fatherland
ones were brought
traditions.
Danish
For weighty
pathise with
reasons, therefore,
Germany.
If,
inspires respect.
beyond
simply
upon the
In
169
being
is
human
who has
same
for
time.
The very
Russia
and
vice versa.
con-
those
who
who
naturally hope
value
real en-
On
West.
for which
in
are even
more exaggerated
which impel one
Russia
Germany
is
hated
the East
many
of the
West
Of
alliance to explain
as
ignorant as
it
is
not to be
170
They
army passing
They
believe
insist
Of
course there
The English
Sheffield),
off
The whole
but
it
affair
proved to be a
flight of imagination,
was given
general credence.
The
affair
may
that Kaiser
Wilhelm decorated
To
is
not entirely
to blame.
No
one
is
The
belligerents
none
of
them
allow
truth to
find expression.
171
Truth
is
smothered as one
object of the cen-
The
any material
enemy.
But
it
army or
they
how
justified
may
and
Even
peril neutrality
The
United
constituting
great
power,
I witnessed the
War
of 1870-71.
I was in France
and Italy
fully.
at the
truth
One
The was
and
to stimu-
during reverses.
least
we may
now
the worst of
them
all
And
still
172
thought
That
change
is its
to say,
will
very nature.
its
become reason:
deny the
if
atrocities in Serbia.
Even
there
is
many
inary or exaggerated
and
And
I,
may
be imag-
this has
been proved
enough
left.
for
my
part,
do not doubt
the brutality of
civilised,
all
sides.
know
the
Germans
the
are
the
Russians
good-natured,
Austrians
smart.
But war
If murder of
the so-called
enemy
made
From under
man
A pessimist once
of brutes."
" a gang
divided
He
was mistaken.
Humanity
As
is
this
motive
is
never admitted,
all
nations purport
parties
Even a
173
has systematically
and
relentlessly crushed
In
it
is
fighting for.
their
own defence
to protect right
their right.
Of
vail.
make
right pre-
My
suffices.
Each nais
In the
it is
at peace at last
arise.
Hu-
to look truth
humanity
reacts
and
war
justice
reign.
Every war
is to
be
The
mortal
thought.
When
Denmark would
if the
Gerfilled
humiliated so that
it
would be
me
fel-
Esteemed "
me
letters.
I seem to nourish
Germany be
humiliated.
As
175
Denmark had
!
ated, etc.
when
is
all
the
patients in an insane
the in-
man among them. The student of humanity cannot doubt but that the war madness which rages all over the earth is a relapse
sane
to the oldest hereditary instincts.
Stone Age.
The
all
war
pro-
god above
other gods.
He
In
all
was
men were
away and
Israel,
killed
carried
In old
it
If a king spared
he
ingenious cruelty.
warfare.
how
it
may have
won
was
no
matter
always considered
a proof
to be
176
1500
b. o.
to
a. d.
A
velli
Neither
the Powers.
all
Machia-
mind
"
prudent
word
if
by
so doing he goes
duced him
to
One
"
The Eusooner
all treaties
way
yet
National security
Nor
by war.
war
of 1871
would have
Security
in a
is
the
problem of Alsace-Lorraina
only to be had
when
way which
but
it
This soluis
does satisfy
human
beings,
and fortu-
177
number
is
greater.
And
common
of fanatics.
From
war and
earth.
I simply
By
nature
man
is
But
let
never rid
war.
One
war
as
to
But
as
surely
The attempts
to
do so are
fruitless, insane.
But
mean
eradicated.
Merely that
will
other way.
thinkers.
178
manity
For
and Mohammedans
centuries.
The
rea-
The Moors
For
Even in Shakespeare's day the tortures perpetrated in the name of religion constituted a public as well as a
royal spectacle; they were one of the court diversions.
Just as
Mary
reli-
King
at
nails
bleeding fingertips.
virtue,
August the
who died
love
the
passionate
of
the
deceased
Elector
John
George.
may
be,
we no
179
We
is
we burn heretics, Jews, or do not declare war for the sake of reli-
It
For, as
we
all
way
to national
madness.
But
if
we have succeeded
in
may
After
all,
religion
is
founded
Some day
we have
may
Among
Few
as the duel.
finest instincts in
humanon
on hatred
In
Saxons, as well as
It is still
it still flourished among Angloamong Latins, Germans, and Slavs. But in ineradicable in Germany and France.
it is
dead, as in the
Scandinavian countries.
If the duel could die a natural death one
of a day
may dream
when war
will die.
But
by Richelieu,
by con-
180
Think of
as
all
had
to
be destroyed
What
the duel
And
it
yet, quietly,
humanity.
According
to
ought
given
birth to cowardice
Yet no man in
the German.
American or
man
There
is
no more reason
to praise
war than
there
is
We
it
But those
convinced.
of us
who
are not
slightly civilised
when an
But in
larger communities, in
181
less rich.
Nor has
lux-
The disappearance
duel.
of
fatal
We
dull
are
all
absence of
war would not advance the world but would mankind and allow it to relapse into a life of ease.
logical in the
is
We
mouth
of a
general, that
permanent peace
a beautiful one.
We
have
all
No
besides horrors
and
atrocities
without number.
this is
It re-
But
no reason for
worshipping
it.
fire
many
hymns
to cholera or
typhus.
182
Europe
moment
is
in the hands of
He who
ad-
All
made by Europe
is
supremacy
Europe
is
being bled to
insanity.
In the face of
abandon
is
this view.
worth more
to the
world than
masterly organised
brutality.
The
inhabitants
of
all
belligerent
countries
is
are
in
enemy
in the wrong.
When
the
immense war
is
show up
his lack of
judgment
"Answer!
in the
Which
if it
which side
wrong ? "
!
Eight
less
As
had anything
to
of
dilettantes
humanity:
Austria-Hungary's
on
Serbia
all
power
183
184
mands
an
act
which
Germans added atrocities without number. But when this double attack is presented as uncalled
and
as if
it
for,
tory,
made
abdicate
all
power of thought
And the more so because Germany, in spite of her inhuman treatment of the Polish, Danish, and French
elements within the empire, also claims to be fighting
for the rights and the independence of small nations.
She
is
fighting Russia,
solemnly
made
pledges than
who with still less regard for Germany has let the Finher wrath, and who in the kingdom of
of oppression.
Poland has kept the Poles and even more the Jews in
an outrageous
state
Germany
claims
to
abolish
Persia's
independence
The
division of Persia,
by the way,
day and
Indeed,
it
may
185
its
The former friendship between Eussia splitting of Poland. The more recent alliance between Austria and Germany was sealed at the expense of Denmark. The hearty underindependence.
Morocco.
This war
is
rich in examples
which
it
is
On
own
interests.
states,
made with
jest.
all
But
It is not neces-
seven centuries.
beginning
little to
guard
its
neutrality, sank
fleet
to Bernadotte as a
In the
lost their
have
independence.
186
The
republics of Transvaal
and Orange
Persia lost her independence by what even in England has been called " a bargain of thieves " between
The Queen
as Austria-
Shortly
But
neither
Power
felt
any inclination to
broken.
interfere.
Neither
its
death-
bed, and is
now no more.
is
Now
Europe
on her deathbed.
One
is
187
At any
human
being.
An
in the
am
quoting
because
it
an educated French-
although I
am
with
it.
He
writes:
Very
far
from the
battle-field,
in Soudan,
it
where
me and where
has kept
me
May,
in the war.
"
At
the distance
it is
to
intrude.
me
and yesterday?
It is strange that
no foreigner has
am
name
to it
188
is
:
" In the
place
There
is
a profound difference
it
seems to have
two nations.
Amalis
im-
mutual nonunderstanding.
been declared because the two peoples did not understand each other and never could.
" Secondly
Economically
speaking
the
Germans
a military
(I
am
is
institution
am
problem. )
life there
But
in spite of the
German
influx in
French
was no
visible loss of
is
few
at-
no matter how
little
we understood them.
Germany.
"Further:
real
political
189
Nowhere
ac-
paw and dupes. The Germans were right, in one sense, except that we knew what we were doing and even helped create
cused us of being England's cat's
"
the illusion.
Germany
the hereditary
enemy f
Not
at
all.
The
first
generation of French-
men who
alive.
the
looked upon Germany as the enemy are still They belong to the generation that fought in War of 1871. The enemy which we, without in-
not
is
:
England.
'
You
cannot
At
Fashoda incidents who would ever have thought England and France would fight side by side on French
territory
!
'
And many
it
is
The Englishman
Yet from an
is
not our
enemy by
and
has at
cul-
ture or race.
historical
political
all
standpoint he
He
As
for Russia,
we do
not
know
her.
The
190
we read about
comes to help
sia in
He
is
the giant
who
us.
looks
upon Rus-
That
is
why
journalists the
steam
roller.'
We
also look
upon the
But
Social-
make an
All in
billions,
was a
by a Germany
"
To conclude
What
is
not a political question but an anatomical one. " Before the days of the Revolution political treaties
were
satisfied
judgment
as fate.
with their fate, looked upon every Then the nineteenth century real-
new
principle
nationalism.
The
191
Germany's unity
the result of
it.
Yet
at the
very
many cemented
country
her national
even
Alsace-Lorraine
swelled
with
na-
tional feeling,
this land
away from
may
;
who knocks
been cut
the loss of
his life.
its
silent
as to
wring
1
or to pull
nails out!
it
!
also cried:
back
" Alsace-Lorraine
is
to
as
is
For
thirty
repeated humiliations
everything
nated
to
this
one
consideration.
We
silence,
felt
it
our
to
lie
low
say to
Germany
c
:
lions,
am
!
now
we'll
see
some fun
192
the
" If
defined
of culture
'
which may be
had been a
stupid
intelligence
there
sia,
had said
raine break
it
to us
i
:
the alliance
'
we
Russian or German-English
Germany
all
could,
our colonies,
as allies
and
to
abandon
Russia and
tions
all
our
billions.
Germany
" But
"
'
stupid intelligence
'
decided otherwise.
When
am
seventy mil-
you
are
only
forty/
Europe
was
amused,
who never
Yet
193
be on our guard,
If the
has taken
Germany
thirty years
to
perfect,
is
partially in the
to
then
II
To
to
this
French and
German mentality is impossible. This fundamental M. Dauville takes as his starting point is a strange delusion. The intellectual life of Alsace
contradicts
it.
flatly
French
lan-
The same
is
even true of
men
of science.
One
In our
Cherbuliez and
Rod
194
In Berlin,
Many
and
among
scientists of distinctly
An
He
As
tury
This
is
due
to the
immense
lead of France.
As
early as the
from France
to
to its source.
Chres-
Aue.
German when Charles Nodier is affected by Goethe and Amadeus Hoffman, Alexandre Dumas by Schiller. Most distinctly may German inIt is not until the nineteenth century that
is felt
influence
in France, as
195
whose feeling
is
quite Ger-
Herder and
German
feeling
and character.
In the course of a whole people's
this tardy
intellectual history
not, of course,
amount
music,
to very
if in certain respects, as in
it
But
if
Just as the
feeling.
Much more
recently Victor
Hugo
influenced
in-
numerable German
disciples.
The
differences, then,
man
may
be overracial
come.
The attempt
opposition
Latin-German
to account for
is
them by the
196
In
reality,
there
in the
Germans
The next
doubtlessly true.
French trade
its
to rival
Germany's, and
inferiority
Such desperate
by
thrift
and investment
as
German
capital
through business
initiative.
new or
even
differ-
have
heard,
before
is
the
who
at that
left
the diplomatic
The
to give
ill-feeling
up Fashoda: it was manifest throughout the entire Boer War, when collections for the benefit of the Kruger was fighting Boers met with great response.
grossly
more
clearly
shown
at the
Scotch workingmen,
whom
197
France.
M. Dauville
France had
to
is right,
of course,
when he
explains
why
alliance at
any
price.
And
ment
he
is
when he
it
states the
ignorance of the French masses as to the real governin Russia, whose authority
is
now a duty
to
admire.
He
make an
This
attitude
which has
dominated
for
more than
and
sian tyranny.
made by
if
a Russian or a
But
his-
Emperor Alexander III listening with bared head, to the " Marseillaise," played by a Russian
military band.
Even more
bitterly ironical it
198
Ill
to blame.
of the present
war
is
the oppo-
with
Austria for
the
domination
of
the
Balkans.
Germany would have preferred to fight it out with Russia without war with France. The agreement which Great Britain made openly with
was an
ally of Russia.
still
She needs
She requires
But
investor
to borrow.
Ever
since
King Edward
visited the
Tzar in
toward conin-
stitutional freedom.
As
in France, the
classes conspired to
199
its
Government and
to
whitewash
republic.
Eussia
that,
financiers
And
downe.
But
the
man who
first
really carried
them
out,
It
be
The
Duma
Eussian people.
radical
Yet a great hope surged through the The new Duma showed an immense
and the
Constitutional
majority
Democrats
to fight a
They had
The
able to
despotism
if it
had been
words
the
Your safe is empty, your credit gone. We, leaders of new Eussia, have the people and Europe
us.
back of
to grant appropriations,
200
But
if
rights,
we
The Duma could not take this stand. In March, 1906, the immense loan had been floated in London and Paris, and when the Duma met in May the Government's cash box was
full.
How
states in
Europe not
less
to kill
After
Duma
was
out Parliament while court-martials imposed death sentences throughout the whole country.
met
the
in
to be even
first.
Stolypine
accused
the
Social-Democrats,
the
all
parties
unanimously pro-
Duma.
By
a coup oV
etat, thirty-five
court, seventeen
five years'
hard labour,
of
Two
them died
treated
from consumption.
They were
all
201
common
The
Duma
practically killed
Russian
number
from an
He
pris-
The number
of political exiles
ing to
official figures,
seventy-four a day.
Among
The Alliance
At
war
was
growing
disposal.
liberal,
To show he was
actions,
up
his state-
ments by his
he went to Russia.
No
sooner
much more
of the
members
Duma
202
One
was sentenced
to
hard labour
sailors.
among
IV
The next and most
explanation
is
decisive point in
M.
Dauville's
He
dwells
to
restitution
colonies
or
costly
To win
these
provinces
back was
As a term
would
fol-
apt, since it
or even immediately
make
a
cut,
to
from which
is,
it
had been
comparison
on the whole, of
slight importance.
is
But
what
is
more incomprehensible
that an
educated
how
a country suffers
when
its
He
tion in
North Schleswig.
parently,
how
when provinces
it
which
historically
and
linguistically belong to
are
203
XI V,
We
all
know
surprising.
M. Dauville
remark on the
where he
says,
in the
wrong regarding an
incidental
restitution of Alsace-Lorraine.
That
is
Bis-
of Alsace-
North Schleswig.
As
his
now
forgotten letter
settle the
to
Denmark should
if
ing population,
foreign affairs.
Even
Schleswig,
the hope of
As for Alsace-Lorraine, after the Franco-Prussian War, Bismarck opposed the imperialistic tendencies of Moltke and the war party as he did after Austria's At
the Prague Conference he succeeded in enforcing
defeat.
Prussian.
War
he asserted
to
would lead
fifty
years or
so.
204
enemy what
the sword
The
duced
loss of
re-
rank power.
M.
Danville, however,
made
else.
up
An
1898
interesting.
It
thinker,
Clemence Royer,
away from us, as we took them, by force. We may take them back again. They will then again be taken away from us. What do
the provinces gain by this, except to be ravaged again
And
can
we
Under
the
Merovingien kings
whose language
it
G. MotfTEEGUEix
is
The day
a beautiful
rouses to energy.
205
is
conceive of
making war
it;
to
The young authors of the day advanced startling opinions. The Brothers Paul and Victor Margueritte, whose father had been mortally wounded at Sedan,
(Paul Margueritte recently published a passionate war
volume
Contre
les
Barbares) said
"
One may others will forget them. when the names Sedan and Metz will not stir us any more or differently than Waterloo, or the Allies' march into Paris in 18 14." " A revolution in Alsace Ferdinand Hekold
remember them but
;
against
And
how
"
Not a
The bourgeois does not want to The fight. Artists would only be disturbed by war. only one who would welcome war is the exhausted, conreconquering Alsace.
206
in
dawn
to the factory
from
scaf-
Andre Lebet
selves
"
We
submit to
ways think of
One replies immediately The following day is too late. We alAlsace we often weep about it at dessert
;
we solemnly drink
But
that
is all."
to its
Remy de Gottrmont
"
inevitable. The German is no The stupidity of calling Germany the hereditary enemy is only seen in papers playing for public favour. But public favour does not meet them
half way."
" Revanche
out
is
elec-
" It
lost
when Boulangism
its
general's indecision.
we
by the stupid
birth."
207
:
member
of the Academie)
is
a matter
momentary
inferior-
That
is
why
it galls us.
wound would
heal
even
if
Even seventeen years ago these sentiments did not any one who had followed the evolution of French mentality. In Le Journal (22 July, 1898) the
surprise
He
why
a dismal failure.
At
many was
same remark
France."
made practically the M. Dauville now, namely, that "not Germany, but England, is the hereditary enemy of
almost forgotten, and I
as
Niger inflamed
that time, the
At
socialistic or anarch-
many but
brothers.
wrote
" Enthusiasm
as
is
208
often
among French
is
intellectuals.
Richard
in France
Wagner, who
discussed
more passionately
the tendency
to learn
and
In writing the
last sentence I
few
He
often spoke
German
to
me and
I replied in French,
^"ow he accuses
me
of
affair
in-
when
men
Paul
until
Not
And
is
not exclusively on
of the
article
all
German
side is
shown by the
In
it
Mercure de France.
Public opinion
209
German
France ?
He
who were called God's people by speGod has loved no nation on earth as much Explain it whoever can. To call this naall
most noble of
serves
nations
edly
is
which
it
undoubt-
France
ter
is
who they
A whole,
neces-
God because
otherwise
He
would not
exist
and
He
No
matter what
may
have com-
God
He
own
glory,
who
Few German
210
to pride
themconif
on and
it is
little to
is
vinced
Europe and
God
tory.
is
God,
If
cause
Father
He must He is.
and kind
German barbarism, seen by German eyes German culture and guards especially the house of Hohenzollern. Both France and Germany are certain
that they are
He hates He favours
His being on
If
He
were
to fail
them
He
would
He
cries
bitter complaints to
attacks.
An
when
by the
rather
mere human,
Yet
to
is
attacked or misunderstood
his right to explain his
their attacks, or
belligerents.
it is
attitude
and
how unfounded.
After M. Clemengeau in a
me
re-
211
I have
my
to write
me
'
" complaining that I have neither love of truth nor the courage to express it.' "
quotes the
Temps
as
To
My
love for
this stupid
clamour; yet
And
this
mean
the op-
what they
really do.
me
conditional and
it
and England, I
am
grateful for
Still
its
intention
and
its at-
tempt to understand.
more
grateful
am
I to
M.
re-
my ideals.
European press some
When
212
around M. Alberti, 1
at
members
He
a jolly good
reveals
when dealing
finances,
was accused
AN*
APPEAL
(May, 1916)
Each waging
all
of the Great
is
it
is
a war of defence.
all
They have
all
been
at-
Eor
of
are necessary
means
defence.
But
since
The
and
must
first
barism
and
!
civilisation
their
conception
of
Civilisation
The
first
The second
is
that
the days of
human
sacrifice.
or ve prisoners of
war were
much
now four
or five mil-
" Satan
mankind with a
fiendish thought.
He
said
213
214
to
them
men and
them arms
Then I
They
shall give
them two
idols called
honour and
loyalty,
worship these
idols
this law."
When we
tarism
war
to crush mili-
we
find that
to the only
from
it,
We
might; every
letter is opened,
even personal
letters be-
tween neutrals.
We
ing which
and Poland
which right
is
every-
interests of the
governments alone
independence of small
is
on both sides
in-
first
of all
want
The
But
civilian
the gov-
seats,
dig their
AN APPEAL
madly
on.
215
The
it
Public opinion
is
usually
on the
one side or the other and thereby forgets to add her bit
to the scale of justice.
Among
all
neutrals, one
the
others
combined.
to profit
Do
?
the
United States of
no
who
believes in peace, in
common
sense,
and in
sound judgment ?
The cry
silent,
from
belligerent
But
if
mankind remains
call
And where
and meadows
cry,
The whole world is in the throes of malicious joy. The only satisfaction is to hurt others, in self-defence.
Ships are torpedoed
" successfully. "
Bombardments
brings
One man
there
?
down
is
his
And
is rejoicing.
If any
the
How
The end
justifies the
means."
216
treachery.
The Germans
Allies
rejoice.
suffer
The
Belgium
and
Serbia
are
crushed.
rejoice.
Both
among
have broken
loose,
and both
nately right.
The Central Powers say they want peace. But they do not seem willing to make any real compromise to obtain
it.
Their object
is to
" peace
may
be lasting."
" de-
The
tained what they for nearly two years have been fight-
They
too
want
to crush their
discuss peace.
battles
air-
how many
one thing
tice
is
sure:
Why
is
now ?
What
is
to be gained
Peace
AN APPEAL
a
sibyl
217
whose books,
i.e.,
day that
goes.
all
We
first
are
"
We
is
must
all
that
gained
wholesale murder.
can be crushed.
And when people declare they do not wish to crush Germany but only its militarism, it is as if one were to
say, " I don't
want
to hurt the
pull out
its quills."
Every day
it
becomes more
What may
is lost
be
by pro-
Has humanity forgotten that there are other means of settling human disputes than by resorting to bombs
and grenades
?
How
say:
They
will
In those days, in
single statesman
Had
there been
it
would
Gen-
Had
on either
erals
side, it
The future
218
to realise that
That was
re-
war
is
It
would be best
the
war were
to
And
it
inflicted
on the
enemy does not replace a single human life. Each human life represents a value. Mankind
alike.
is
not
There
is slight
losses
Who
not a
knows
if
among
There
may
Kant
a Rubens, a Tolstoi
among
who have
fallen.
mean in comparison to the loss of such a personality? The gain is temporary; the loss is irretrievable. The gain
does a slight change in the boundary line
is
What
the loss
is
humanity's.
destroys the na-
calculate
how war
AN APPEAL
tions' wealth,
219 no one
the loss
cal-
how
will be able to
But
is
in
human
never
culated.
We
upon
races.
It has called
the whites.
Europe
and not
little satisfaction.
The
create
upon
itself to excite
war enthusiasm.
it calls
destroying hatred
after the war,
new
wars.
The longer
war
lasts,
IDEALS OR POLITICS
(June, 1916)
me
me.
we may
am
much
ing.
Allow
me
to explain
my
sigh at meeting so
first
I have
because
of a certain
my-
From
the
it
eighteenth
centuries
made
220
a point of honour to
IDEALS OR POLITICS?
environment.
221
For even
Each of the
belligerents, then as
now, looked
upon
The
day.
to-
Both
sides look
as
a holy war.
is
Definite sides
must be taken
prove
this
The
right
entirely
the enemy.
ac-
Both
sides
set
up
From
moment when
i.e.,
the
wrong undoubt-
invaded.
From
nate
little
prove that England and her Allies were fighting for the
sacredness of treaties and for the rights of small nations
ideals alone.
On
Germans, however,
also
began an
222
intellectual
They
first
tion of
Belgium
officer
had made a
to be-
to land
Belgium.
German But no
That
is
brutality and
;
German
atrocities in
if
men
first
are to
why
national hatred
at the
German
In
troops.
mans
and
as inconceivable
and reprehensible.
series of
self-de-
fence the
Germans made a
awful retaliations,
eyes out of
wounded Germans,
short, that
were so inhuman, in
too severe.
no punishment could be
it
an out-
German
conscience.
IDEALS OE POLITICS?
223
At first, Germany considered Eussia the real enemy. The German Government reminded the people how the Finnish constitution had been broken, how Eussia for
years had oppressed Poland, annihilated Persia, and as
the
Germans on
to the
and education
as well as in
agriculture, trade
civilisa-
for the
Jews
whom
whom
Georgians,
the Ukrainians,
the
White Eussians
whom
she brutalises.
As
mans went
As
Belgium
out
the invasion of
of the
maze
Germans
for
seized the
And
although
as a
now suddenly
ment of barbarism.
On
when
of
House
224
at-
Germany only
as Russia's ally
if
by Russia.
too simple
an innocent and unprepared passer-by, and who overthrown and found to have his pockets
is
finally
full of
reli-
Of
war lay
in Austria-Hun-
weaker neighbouring
state.
Furthermore, as Germany
to
has
that
Emperor Franz Joseph declared war on Serbia with Emperor William's full assent. No reasoning being can entertain any doubt as to the origin of the present war, nor as to
who threw
IDEALS OK POLITICS?
Nevertheless the
so simple a
225
relatively
pedition into a
The war
and
is
ceaseless competition
power
to frustrate
Aus-
between herself
states.
As
3,
nervous.
make Germany nervous." And Germany grew There came an unrest over the German press,
to speak of
which began
226
Germany thought
to lose if the Slavs
were not
to split
when Austria
would
a fact one
Why
Germany
now
of France.
the Ger-
mans had not grasped, that the much more solidly cemented than The Russian ministry had drawn
from the naval review
at
moment
it
England
to
Besides the
Austro-German
IDEALS OK POLITICS?
tween two rival groups of Powers.
structive
227
an
in-
It is also
times of peace.
As
a
in Heiberg's
was
really
many
man
Even
in times of peace,
speaker in Ibsen's
poem Our
"
people
But
like the
seeth-
the
in economical
One
is
made
in times of peace
an expression of
But, above
all,
antiquated prejudices.
The saying that might primes not something which Germany has monopolised
It is characteristic of all Europe, even
in times of peace.
And
The
brutality
war
is
When French
why
correspondents besieged
me and
asked
my
when I
if
my
my humane
228
was scornfully
bombardment
of open cities,
?
of civilian populations
is
My
answer
life to-day.
progressed beyond
that point.
When La
men
and
Salle in his
day explained
to the working-
Government
to grant a constitution
In
is
For
this
har-
monises with
my
ethical standard
and
my
moral
ideals.
praise
The
that of
difference between
La
Salle's point of
view and
Germany
of to-day is that
Germany
and even
The Germans
IDEALS OR POLITICS?
ever,
229
seem
to
sway in the
tion
with Russia,
and
on an equal
ideals
for
all
of hu-
manity, in short.
It
would be
tell
interesting,
if
you
would
fighting at the
present
moment?
makes
as
when
she
ideal
England
fights
of hunger,
land, does
when she establishes a state of siege in Ireaway with Persia's independence, and when
with the word " Nationality " on her lips she gives half
a dozen small nations over to enslavement
?
Or
for
We
all
know
is
political liberty,
which Germany
is
attained.
We
know
questions but
on
is
reli-
such as
it
much
Danes
We
to use a very
mild expres-
enemy
against
their friends.
it
may
have inspired
230
We
main
And we know
liberalism
culture,
liberal
is
a reality, just as
it
we know
that French
is
where
has reached
more
of Germany's lust of
from both
sides.
It
also
may happen
its interest
furthers civilisation.
that.
act nobly
as
War
of Independence
Unlike
Wilson
at the present
by
political ones.
IDEALS OR POLITICS ?
231
have been so from time immemorial. No nation, and least of all a great Power in our days, offers millions
of
men and
billions of
ject
nomic advantage.
letters,
signed or
my
ignorance or insulting
The very same day you published your open letme I received with the German mail a note, as far can judge, from a business man in Mainz. He
accuses
me
many
in the
dis-
pleasure.
The
in part
article
War and
the
Belgian General
Staff,
found in Brussels
These docu-
opportunity."
told
232
233
prison-
German
Germany.
cannot
in this worst of
neutrals
you
cannot
help
despising
The
me
You
see,
me from Germany
and
my unknown
Ger-
man
alone
correspondent
is
responsible for
That
is
my
*
to regard
it
as a sort of
at a
time
when
Allies'
decisive victory.
"
The worst
you
Therefore
let sacrifices
be heaped upon
still
sacrifices, let
good cause
234
At
war I
felt it
would end
as a draw,
and
And my
is
Yet peace
bound
to
come some
time.
As
war
are of a polit-
on a political-economic understanding.
agreement can be made now,
it is
And
as such
an
war
it
is
to
one side
least.
By
exhausted, and
the earth.
more misery
By that
who
in times of peace
fire
state
of exaltation and
become a
reality.
235
down
as long as
common
sense.
But
if
the
and rage
as
it
wake
of the
war
Commune
ground with
mercy
as the
Yet
I
and cripples
men
left.
know very
well that
war
is
popular in England.
The masses Has any war think as they are cleverly led to think. been more popular in England than the war against the colonies when they tried to break away from England And how is that war to become the United States?
But
that does not
move
my
stony heart.
In
who can find enough opposition between England and Germany to warrant a continuation of slaughter ? As far back as April 5, 1916, the German Chancellor,
Bethmann-Hollweg,
its
declared
" Europe,
for
the sake of
The peace
that
It
is to
come
war must be a durable peace. contain the seed of a new war, but the seed and final peaceful settlement of European
must not
for a definite
affairs."
236
Germany, not
to
wipe her
off
the
map
of
Euthe
'
The
Allies'
war
is to
One
ever,
is
the
countries,
in belligerent
unhesitatingly
own
They
his country's
falsifies history.
way.
word German
articles
was not
like
that before.
Erasmus wrote
" There
is
so baneful, so destructive, as
war; nothing
worthy
237
.
"War
is
no wild beast
fight
is
as frightful as
man
with
man.
while
Wild animals
only,
we prepare
for
general
.
WQiat trage-
most miseranti-
able pretexts!
Purely
What
is
theft perpetrated
by masses
attack-
war one of
Few
proved
realists
its
Few
have
first
absurdity as he.
He was
probably the
as
much
"
as the vanquished.
Voltaire
attacks
preventive
is,
You must
who who might intend to do so. In your own land on the chance of
its
ruining another's."
ness
and ban-
He
asks:
"What
238
"
You
he
cries,
a pinprick and
that
is
lift
to hurt his
The small
figure
"
Do
like myself
moment
are kill-
ing a hundred thousand other such animals because they wear turbans ? Or are killed by them ? " (Allusion to
Russia's
in 1737.)
patriot like
What would he
Rolland
is
when a
Romain
stamped as a traitor
still
he admitted he
ple?
on war in general.
You
say
gain by allowing
it ?
to be trodden
"
Alas, dear
Mr. Archer,
as
you know,
eyes.
As
which
239
able-
deals with
a young,
who
in
to the
therefor.
Four or
The judge
life."
objects
It
sirs,
The spokesman
plies
"
:
Here lives a poor, decrepit baker, Who, by death, will soon be carried off. We have two bakers, let us hang the elder!
Life would
still
life that
The judge
suggestion
reflects
and
Since life must pay for life, To have the elder baker hang for the blacksmith's crime, As suitable, well deserved punishment for himself
And
This
who
on both
sides, are as
240
as the baker
mitted murder.
Suppose
it
whom
like
Grey, Mr. Sazonoff, M. Delcasse, writers like General Bernhardi, Maximilian Harden, the Englishman Maxse,
in-
Would
meted out
all
if these
men
the atrocities of
former days?
No man
then,
is
How much
a few
less,
by obliging
women and
and misery!
children, are
doomed
I
tial
to death, mutilation
well, dear
knew very
essen-
why
is
this
Even amount
if
Germany
of territory, she
weak
economically and must pay for the cessation of the British blockade.
Incidentally
it
seems to
me that
programme the
demanded
that the
241
French
at once
of
liberty
arranged.
turned to France,
Denmark was
Rus-
in the hands of
the
if it is to
this
would have
I burn with
it fulfilled.
Only I do not
as they.
believe
it is
And
and be
from such
powers preserve
us
BELGIUM PEKSIA
Reply to Mr. Archer
(July, 1916)
Danish writer
is
For even
carefully
if
it
scarcely ever
of the other
statements he has
fute
made on
They
In
credit
him
their
excite-
When
who may
him
ject.
He
The Danish
BELGIUM PEESIA
nothing
is
243
is
concerned.
He
his
is
again
and again.
On
such
premises
how
be interpreted.
An
me
in
open
letter to
Dr.
and
to
me, explain
it,
to
group
my
opinions on certain
main
issues
Belgium
There can scarcely be any difference between Mr.
by Bel-
know Captain de
the
sympathise
poured.
with
people
on
whom
felt
misfortunes
not only in
as if
Europe but
the
in all
America
as well, it
would seem
244
more
had marched
of the world
at
Verdun
instead of
attracting the
tral state,
odium
by attacking a neu-
especially one
selves
had guaranteed.
Mr. Archer, have been content to reap " the satisfactions of neutrality,"
satisfactions embittered,
On
And
as far as the
at all clear
seem
to
me
As
other
Powers,
guaranteed
Belgian
neutrality.
She
went on record
defend
to
Britain could not give any such promise for the simple
reason that she would be unable to live
up
to
it.
at
England's disposal
Now
the possibility of a
The gen-
BELGIUM PERSIA
245
iar with it. The most probable strategetic moves of the war had been discussed beforehand in the various
According to authoritative
to deal
opinions,
Germany, in order
France a rapid
it
could be
In other words,
suc-
All
railroads
knew that Germany had built her network of up against the Belgian frontier. In SeptemLord Winston Churchill said in Parliament
ber, 1914,
that he
three years.
As
private citizen
the author
layman and
said in a
German
plan.
had no
realisa-
Still,
Under
frontier?
these conditions
to pre-
Did
at least
owed the
little,
dangerously
Belgium
246
transport a sufficient
number
of British
was,
to bring
up reinforcements
still
rapidly.
preferred to resist
not,
hinder
then
upon
let
her
hands
to
lie idle,
attitude brought
much
to
which course
to take.
As
August
that the
gian Government
"
We
For the
will de-
to appeal to the
finds necessary to
Even
one can
BELGIUM PEKSIA
see,
247
assuming
If she
Belgium
had given in
to force
damage
done by German troops, Belgium undoubtedly would have lacked the aureole of heroism which now shines
and
still
more
cruel humiliations.
And no
is
sane person
wisdom.
now highly
praised
paw
II
too
much
Nevertheless,
draws of
me
For
(like
my
Ger-
my
abilities
may
be considerable, I lack
mean between
to feel the in-
am unable
man
my
indigna-
248
tion
is
well founded,
belligerent
my pessimism too deep, my doubts too my idealism too unshakeable. Neither group answers to my conception of justice
benefit to
my
accusers attack
me
is
by
The mode
low that " no matter how much sorrow the war has
caused him or will bring
him
for nothing in
the world
would he be a
neutral.'
life
When
Denmark
In 1864 Den-
mark
all
and the
And
they are
still
new allies. In 1864 all these powers remained neutral. Not a single one moved a finger against the two Central Powers, in spite of the fact that Denmark accepted war because she relied on definite promises made by the English Government to the effect that " Denmark would not be allowed to stand alone. ." " And Denmark is abused and called neutral by the Germans, who assaulted us at that time and now
seeking
.
.
is
BELGIUM PEESIA
trality.
249
And
mark
is
own interests, stubbornly remained when Denmark with her two million
arms of the
set half the
powers
have
if possible.
BELGIUM PERSIA
III
Peesia
Persia
is
the
name
of Asiatic Belgium.
As her
among
The
rivalry be-
Near
East.
at the
strike in
midsum-
No
less
BELGIUM PEKSIA
this victory to
251
much
as to their
own
(Meilis),
was opened in
greater.
Then Sir Edward Grey, without consulting the Persians made an agreement with Russia. Persia was surprised and hurt to find that England (as well as Russia) looked upon the country as a mere stretch of land,
a
means of granting
concessions, a
to
market for
trade.
respect
Persia's
sovereignty
the
and
cities
of Teheran,
strip
Be-
districts
and mountains.
of political liberty, of free trade, as the only
home
when
her principles
252
When
her under the arms and held her up, this was only a play
for Russia's good-will and alliance in view of a coming
price.
Englishmen
much opposed
be
to
It
is
that
Persia's
maintained
to act as a buffer
Edward Grey counted on England's and Russia's way to Russia's friendship lasting eternally. England noted as first now shortened, and India was
Evidently Sir
result of the
rail-
1907.
To
They claimed
to be united
and
in-
affairs
The Angloto
con-
her
efforts
on internal
reforms.
The
BELGIUM PEKSIA
were unfounded.
253
The agreement,
He
tion he himself
had agreed
to defend.
In 1908 Parlia-
ment determined
stitution.
lish
to depose him for abolishing the ConBut both the Russian Minister and the Engd' Affaires
Charge
If
it
own
to
Russian-Persian brigade,
The Russian Colonel Liakof when he, at the head of his bombarded the House of Par-
liament while the Shah killed the deputies and the news-
army and
last
When
it at
to
254
death,
of this step
and promised
temporary.
The
army marched
against Teheran
from
from the
and his
and a new
off
work broken
by Liakof.
peaceful, and
its
pay their
taxes.
Russian protection.
made
To
rectly with a
The English
demanded
BELGIUM PEKSIA
ganise South Persia.
to send
255
Morgan
ment
finances.
Shuster, arrived.
the
He
of
United
States
reorganise
Persia's
He
executive ability, inspired such confidence in Parliait accorded him almost autocratic power. Morgan Shuster engaged an English major, who spoke Persian and was familiar with the country to form a gendarme corps to collect taxes. The Persian Government confiscated the property of the brother of the former Shah, who had allied himself with the exiled monarch who was now preparing to attack the country, and established Morgan Shuster in this brother's palace
ment that
at
Teheran.
ward Teheran.
Sir
Persians to
the
Edward Grey then intervened and advised the make some settlement. He guaranteed that Russian army would not penetrate further into the
if
country
Accord-
ing to this
to be
immediately de-
to
was
to be
paid to Russia.
As Parliament
it
was
dissolved.
256
an end.
Russia
court martial
established,
men were
hung.
The
hung on a great
Good Friday.
an
irre-
The
British
where she
and Turkey
as
Belgium
to
Dur-
Germany
The only
Sir
Persia's neutrality.
Edward Grey did not go to war to maintain The solemn promise to respect the
Belgium was broken
like Prussia's
integrity of Asiatic
BELGIUM PEKSIA
All
257
have
as a free nation
moment
it
was becoming an
independent
state, just
as
May 3,
In order to
man
I have
drawn only on
It
in
my
entirely
upon English
one
many an Englishman
C.
a great example.
H. Norman
is
E. D. Morel
who
who
may view
is
without
he
opponents.
As
If,
far as I
;
like
Mr.
258
much
that
is justified
and in
spite of
The word right does not bring much political advancement or as La Salle, in Assisenrede expressed it
" In the
ciple, for
life of
a nation right
is
a dangerous prin-
And he
says
When
Louis
XIV in 1647
When
in
was
to be compensated,
mutilated,
although
the
treaty
of
Frankfort
of the
German Empire.
more or
less,
that
when German
men and
beis
This
But may
is
it
navy, right
is
also flouted?
BELGIUM PEESIA
right.
259
Why then
to
know on which
side
is
right
An
"
"Goats!
To
the left!"
Thus
will the
!
Judge command.
"
To
Yet, it is to be hoped the Judge will also say: " Opposite me, ye men of reason."
CONCLUSION
Keply
TOi
Mr. Archer
(July, 1916)
It is agreeable to
meet an opponent
one of
like
Mr. Archer
Outside of England
vulgarity.
common
Mr.
Danish
mention anonymous
Danish
rabble, allow
me
once for
all
am
honourary member of
of L.L.D.
upon me.
It is evident
am
by strong
art-
bonds and
istic
am
myself
strongly attracted
by English
life
and
spirit.
CONCLUSION
from Austria-Hungary,
of
261
not
a fourth-class decoration.
member
society.
German
Because of
my
opinions on the
One
could hardly
say I
am
When
the reason
is
not neces-
am
is
Powers
(i.e.,
certain of their
men
one
war proves
if
To my mind,
summer
of
was due
leaders.
And
yet
And what
262
The 27th
Morocco agree-
Answer
was given
Edward Grey
said
" Let
me
We
We
On August
liament,
in Par-
among
French ambassa-
You have
it
if either
Government had
Power
to
know whether
it
Power
(a very
"
it
CONCLUSION
if so
263
to take in
common."
even
"
We We
are not
do not
know
(A most remarkable
Address debate
tion has been
Hugh
" It
is
by an
an expeditionary force
to operate
Mr. As-
bound
The 24th
again asked
He
replied
"
As has been
repeatedly stated,
known
to take part in
any war."
Was
As
clared
this
the
year, Sir
:
Edward Grey,
"
by the
the
same
as that explained
his reply of
March
24, 1913."
June
Edward Grey
no
replied to the
same
question.
" There
are
unpublished
agreements
264
which would
hamper
letter of
November
which unmistakably
into
associated
The end
was
still
more remarkable
concluded that
the
"
But
if
to be
made
it
it
Prime
ought,
would be
II
The above quotations from parliamentary speeches show that England was not unacquainted with the
thought of a war with Germany.
it
Germany
anx-
The military party undoubtedly did but Great Britwar was so unexpected it caused the greatest consternation in Germany. One may regard the German Government as extremely naive in
ain's declaration of
undoubtedly
it
sur-
prised.
H. Norman has
CONCLUSION
main
neutral.
265
make
He
had shown
England by
demand
to join
them
in
And
to
His Govreckoning,
certain.
But
in
German
people
Germany,
is
due precisely
to the surprise at
meeting
At the
last. moment
German diplomacy
It
did what
its
it
groped
way.
offered Sir
French
territorial
66
ward Grey
Germany was
not willing to
if
Ger-
many did not violate Belgian neutrality. This promise Sir Edward Grey did not wish to make; he wished to have his hands free. ("I did not think we could give a promise of neutrality on that condition alone.") Would he promise to remain neutral if Germany agreed to guarantee the integrity of both France and her colonies
?
Would he then
give
JSTo.
("
whether I could
He
As
this
I have said before, and as any one can see, Gerfor a German-Russian war, in case
Serbia.
She
CONCLUSION
would have
peace
a war.
Russia.
if
267
left
But France,
as
it is
generation, whose
wisdom
the future
must judge,
is
at
any rate one of the reasons why half a dozen million men
spend their days in miserably trying
to kill
one another.
of foreign affairs
promised
without
France
to help
European war.
this policy, if it
had known of
it.
But
it
upon England
to
Russia
relation of
the only
to lose
by
a war.
loss
Russia's
human
of
human
life in the
event of
war could be
re-
garded as an incident.
the
and led
to victory.
If informed of the political situation, public opinion in Great Britain would have realised that the very
origin of the
Even in the event it heralded an immense increase of Russia's power, and meant victory for a form of government opposed to England's. For the Russian
268
people, who, as
this victory
won Europe's
heart,
meant no betterment.
Ill
I do not believe
my
excellent opponent,
Mr. Archer,
I.
It has
one between
Germany and Russia and the other between Germany and France. Its excuse in regard to France
that the French have taken Berlin half a dozen times,
is
and
its
insolence
is re-
But
is
other
countries.
Under
the Dreyfus
affair
Europe,
take.
And
as for
who have
fascinated
my
environs.
them out
the
When
women threw
CONCLUSION
press, in 1907, precisely the
269
verified
the
November
nese
men and
"
women and
till
The
torture, until
the city
will be
till
remem-
is
of little importance.
I wish
pretty
much
the
same
all over.
Mr. Archer
30,
German
Africa.
He
fifty
see how the inhabitants of Cameroun, about women and men, surprised by the declaration of
would
war,
suffered when English officers locked them command of blacks who maltreated them.
in
under the
They were
prisoners
thirst.
The
they
had
to
remain standing.
On
a transport to
thirst.
If they asked
270
for water
it
:
officer said
Such
is
English militarism.
be
is
it
much
when
stirred to
IV
Would
that
who
is
responsible for
fall
the
and
way
To
may
The
At
the Conference
war
when
the clash of
arms comes
to
an end.
Insanity seems
The war must end with an agreement, and as the real nature of the war is economic, this agreement must be
economic.
England
as
nation
tariff
agreement will be
CONCLUSION"
271
reached at
last.
A
He
man from
M. Henri Lambert,
garding a
tariff
agreement
live.
is
to be just
and
to allow
reduce
its
protective tariff.
For
this,
complete and
That
instru-
ment
which the English so blame the Germans, can only be done away with by the " open door."
tariff
Economic
Conference in Paris,
against
should
decide
to
discriminate
tariffs.
the
defeated
by means of unequal
set
back to the
272
within
Po-
litical alliances
do not
last half
a century.
In
same way
following pages contain advertisements of books THE by the same author or on kindred
subjects.
Shakespeare:
"
A Critical Study
Cloth, 8vo, 600 pp.
and index,
$2.60.
these volumes as a whole we can bestow hearty praise and commendation. No other single work on Shakespeare includes so much, and so much that is valuable. Dr. Brandes is a good, a first-rate 'all-round man.' There is no side of his subject which he neglects. He is both an antiquary and a critic, interested in the smallest details of biography, and also taking broad and comprehensive views of Shakespeare's thought and style. His book is in its way encyclopaedic, and we venture to say that there are few who would not find themselves the better people few scholars informed and the wiser for its perusal. He has equipped himself for his task by wide study and research and on all the materials he has amassed he has brought to bear a judgment well balanced and vigorous, and a mind liberal and independent. It is many years since there has been any contribution to Shakespearean literature of such importance as this. These two volumes are of solid worth, and deserve a place in every Shakespearean student's
On
library."
Ferdinand Lassalle
8V0, $2.09
Those who know Lassalle only as the passionate lover in George Meredith's Tragic Comedians will wish to know him also as the democratic leader, the man of letters and of law, and to observe from a wider outlook the progress of a restless career. George Brandes has told the story interestingly, throwing new light upon
a
much
"
discussed personage.
Mr. Brandes's monograph bears the stamp of that talent which has won for him his prominent place in the literature of the nineteenth century. As a character study the book is far more than
brilliant.
having read
Tribune.
It is of sterling consistency, so lucidly developed that, it, one returns with fullest appreciation to the brief
its
characterization of
"
it
opens."
New
York
Brandes is the painter to make us see Lassalle alive and breathing. He mixes his colors with faith." Chicago Evening Post. " The story as told by the Danish critic is as extraordinary as
any romance." New York Sun. "The most interesting book about Lassalle ever written. Its accuracy, its sympathy, and its critical penetration make it well worth reading." The Dial. " He charms us by the graces of his style, and stimulates us by
The Nation.
Main
Currents in Nineteenth
Century Literature
Volume
i.
Emigrant Literature.
France.
Volume VI.
"
The Set
$9.00
The
won from
English readers
and foreign criticism must always entitle his work to serious consideration. Judgments from without should be instructive; and Dr. Brandes is marvelously well-read, illuminating in analysis, comprehensive and balanced in his historic outlook." London
Athenum.
" Dr. Brandes's
work
English readers.
doing
history
so.
life
His volumes form a valuable commentary upon the of the age with particular reference to its political and
social affiliations."
"
The Independent.
of literature can afford to neglect found of great interest by the general reader is Main Currents in Nineteenth Century Literature,' by George Brandes, which is translated from the Danish and is issued in six volumes by the Macmillan Company. Since Taine's History of English Literature' there has been no work given to the world that contains more that is original and suggestive in regard to the great English authors while from his position of detachment in Denmark the critic has been able to pass in review the whole development of European thought as it found expression in the best writers of France, Germany and the Scandinavian countries."
and which
'
'
San
Francisco Chronicle.
New York
The beginner
one of the most interesting interpretations of Nietzsche's life and character and work that has been issued since Philadelphia North American. his death, fourteen years ago."
is
"
The volume
that is something critique of Nietzsche by a spiritual peer we have not had hitherto, nor even come within distant sight of. correspondence between Nietzsche and a spiritual peer that is something that even the future will not give us again, in all probability.
"A
" But in this one small book, and for this once, George Brandes gives us both, and they are both of such quality as should evoke the enthusiasm of all who are dedicated to the triumph of the spirit in its eternal war with mediocrity.
" In this fascinating book Brandes gives us his first reaction to Nietzsche's thought, a brief running sketch of Nietzsche's world view and life view, shows his own agreements and disagreements with them, and follows with that correspondence which ended with one of the shortest and most tragic letters that the world has been
given "' To the Friend Georg: " When once you had discovered me, it was easy enough to find me the difficulty now is to get rid of me. The Crucified.' "
'
; .
. .
" In the mass of vituperative and eulogistic criticism to which he has been subjected it is refreshing to find such a fair and sympathetic review of his philosophy and personality as that of Dr. Brandes. Every student of Nietzsche can draw profit and instruction from Dr. Brandes's book, which combines fulness and accuracy of information with fairness and moderation of style." Philadelphia Press.
. .
New York
Land,
People and
Literature
Cloth, 8vo, $3.00
made
before.
life,
own
land
life
and
most
He is
fitted
him
to write.
Of
is
much
it.
to say
and as a
critic
he
The book
not
is
fail to attract
same time
and sociology.
New York
Bookkeeper process
2001
Magnesium Oxide
Treatment Date:
f^AY
PreservationTechnologie:
A
WORLD LEADER
111
IN
PAPER PRESERVATIOI
Drive
Thomson Park
PA 16066