Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CONTENTS
CHAPTER ONE: RESEARCH
Ferrymead Site Photos Service & Transport Sport Facilities & Fitness Ferrymead Information Profile Ferrymead Present Status Ferrymead CCC Master Plan Historical & recent photos of Ferrymead Transports & distance in Ferrymead area Sports in Ferrymead area Based on Census 2001 & 2012, predict 2022 Demolish buildings & percentage Introduction, Approach, Context & Vision Pg. 1 - 4 Pg. 5 - 8 Pg. 9 - 10 Pg. 11 - 13 Pg. 14 - 16 Pg. 17 - 20
CHAPTER FOUR: RECLAIMED ISLAND - THE DOCKS Project Description City scale research Grid testings City overlay Grid creating Road and Island formation Integrating existing building Zones Finalise design Renders Overall information about my project Reseached on Vancouver & Leiden Testing out different grid layouts Putting the city scale onto Ferrymead Grid s created within the Ferrymead area Road and Islands are formed according to grid Adding the existing and new buildings in the new plan Specify which each islands function Building, Land use ratio &proposed master plan Renders for Dock islands & enclosed renders Pg. 37 Pg. 38 Pg. 39 - 40 Pg. 41 Pg. 42 Pg. 43 Pg. 44 Pg.45 Pg.46 - 47 Pg.48 - 49
CHAPTER THREE: RECLAIMED ISLAND Project description City scale research City overlay Reshaping the island Ferrymead layout Public & private Finalise design Renders
WATER SPORT FACILITIES Overall information about my project Reseached on Cobenhagen & Irvine Putting the city scale onto Ferrymead New form developed for reclaimed islands Arranging roads & block on ferry road Giving programs & function to the blocks Building, Land use ratio &proposed master plan Renders for water sport facilities Pg. 50 Pg. 51 - 52 Pg. 53 - 54 Pg. 55 - 56 Pg. 57 - 59 Pg. 60 - 61 Pg. 62 - 67 Pg. 68 - 69
RESEARCH
Railway to Ferrymead
Moncks Bay / Beach Bay Redcliff - The boundary for swimmer on the beach.
Woolston Ferrymead Bridge under Construction - Bridge connect Ferrymead and Mount Pleasant, was damaged by the earchquake in 2011.
Ferrymead
Healthcote River - A river that goes through Woolston, Ferrymead and Mount Pleasant
Railway
Bay/River
Main Roads
Roads
Photos
Woolston
Ferrymead
Mount Pleasant - Photo of the inland sea taken from Mount Plesant distinct. Railway Bay/River Main Roads Roads Photos
Connal Avenue house - Unique housing beside Healthcote river, bulit in 1956 was not damaged in the Christchurch earchquake.
Ferrymead shops - Service centre before the earchquake, most of them were Temporary closed.
Mt Pleasant Yacht Club - Yacht club on the other side of the bridge, inland sea as the background.
The first Christchurch railway station on the broad-gauge line that ran to Ferrymead: trains are no. 1 (Pilgrim) & no. 2 locomotives. [ca. 1864]
On 6 May 1863 the first steam locomotive, "Pilgrim" was landed (unassembled) at the Railway Wharf and on 1 December 1863 the line was formally opened. It was the first steam passenger railway to operate in New Zealand. When the line closed in 1877 as a consequence of the opening of the rail tunnel, it once again made rail history, having the distinction of being the first line to close. The line may have been both short and short-lived, but it was an important milestone. It demonstrated the determination, progressivism, and vision shown by a small community which would soon lead to other significant rail developments, including the tunnel and the West Coast line, developments which would contribute greatly to the economic prosperity of Canterbury. The rail embankment is still clearly visible and is now used by the Canterbury Railway Society for its railway at Ferrymead Heritage Park.
This was built around 1862 by Captain Penfold, Captain of the schooner "Excelsior" which traded between New Zealand and Australia until it was wrecked on the Sumner Bar in 1862. Penfold then worked on the construction of the Ferrymead Railway, building the cottage at weekends from sod cut from the river bank and material salvaged from the "Excelsior". The cottage has been largely reconstructed (with cob rather than sod)
The old sod whare on the Sumner Road near the Heathcote Bridge The cantilever bridge over the Heathcote River [1907] An electric tram crosses the cantilever bridge over the Heathcote River on the road to Sumner, Christchurch.
In 1907 a new cantilever bridge was built 20 metres upstream from the swing bridge. Although designed to be opened to allow river traffic through, it was never opened after the initial opening ceremony as it wouldn't close properly. This bridge was replaced by the present road bridge in 1965, which is sited in the same position as the first bridge. In 1862 the Provincial Council authorised construction of a bridge at Ferrymead, to be built in such a way as to allow navigation upstream. The bridge was designed as a wooden bridge in two parts connected by a wrought iron swing bridge manufactured in England by Robert Stephenson & Co. of Newcastle (a firm founded by the son of George Stephenson, builder of the pioneer steam locomotive "the Rocket"). The bridge was opened on 14 April 1864, replacing the ferry service.
Clifton Heights: The original Sumner Road ran under the cliffs. Part of the road is still visible opposite the car park. When the tram was introduced it ran next to the road. Following a major rock fall in 1914, the Tramway Board decided to construct a causeway to avoid the delays and danger caused by rock falls. This opened in 1916. The present road follows the line of the tram causeway. After the causeway, the tram crossed what was then the sandy beach of Clifton Bay by means of a trestle bridge.
The old swing bridge, soon before removal from over the Heathcote River
A Kitson steam tram departs from Cave Rock, Sumner The trestle bridge can be seen clearly.
CHRISTCHURCH - SERVICES
Focusing on the Hagley Ferrymead wards, after the demolish of Ferry road service centre, hardly any food store can be found in the region, and noun big box retail can be found near by. These will be taken into account during my design and planning process, how to reduce the glossary shopping time for local residents in Ferrymead would be one of the concern in the following process. A Mega countdown has begun construction, replacing the one lost.
Countdown
Good Fresh
City Seafood Market Big T Asian Market The Warehouse Countdown - Eastgate Warehouse Stationary
Photo Warehouse The Warehouse PAKn SAVE Moorhouse Liberty Market Countdown - Moorhouse Ave Super Value
New World
The Warehouse
Sumner Supervalue
CBD
Resident 1
Pathway to Service
Resident 2
Pathway to Service
To Redcliff Convenience Store Car Bike Walk 3 km 3.2 km 2.9 km 5 minutes 13 minutes 34 minutes
To Linwood Warehouse Car Bike Walk 5.4 km 5.5 km 5.4 km 9 minutes 21 minutes 65 minutes
To Harikrupa Food Market Car Bike Walk 5.3 km 4.9 km 4.5 km 10 minutes 18 minutes 56 minutes
To Linwood Warehouse Car Bike Walk 5.5 km 5.5 km 6.0 km 9 minutes 18 minutes 79 minutes
To Woolston Food Centre Car Bike Walk 5.9 km 4.3 km 4.3 km 10 minutes 20 minutes 51 minutes
To CBD Car Bike Walk 7.6 km 7.8 km 7.6 km 13 minutes 29 minutes 91 minutes
To Woolston Food Centre Car Bike Walk 6.4 km 4.0 km 4.4 km 11 minutes 16 minutes 59 minutes
To CBD Car Bike Walk 7.1 km 7.7 km 7.0 km 14 minutes 28 minutes 89 minutes
Focusing on the Hagley Ferrymead wards, it is a highly sport active area, but some of the store are to far away from the sport centre or field, this should be changed during the reconstruction of Ferrymead region.
Kilwell Sports
High Ground Histribution Canterbury Sport Wholesale Enforme Fitness Studio Gym Alpine Ice Sports Centre
Woolston Technical FC
UpsideDown Scooters Topsport Kayaking Ferrymead Gym Ferrymead Physio Snowworld sport
Beckenham Tennis Club Cash Target Shooting Anytime Fitness St Marin Valley Tennis club
Divewerks PPADI Dive Centre Womens Basketball Club Biking recreation Macpac Head Office Soccer Field
Gurney Gears Sumner Lifeboat Institute Inc. SumnerPhysio Golf Club Sumner Croquet Club
Horse Riding
CBD Target / Service Region Sports centre / Field Sport Related Kayking & Swimming
Kilwell Sports
Surfing
Dive HQ & Ski world Scotty Brown Golf Factory Outlet Fishing Industry High Ground Histribution
Swimjoy Topsport Kayaking Exit Surf shop Sadhana Surfboards Groundswell Jada Products Ltd
The Outlet
Golf field Biking recreation Ocean Blue Gurney Gears Sumner Lifeboat Institute Inc.
Ferrymead Golf
Soccer Field
the closest Kayking retail store the closest Surfing retail store the closest Diving retail store
the closest Fishing retail store the closest Golf retail store the closest Biking retail store
Change since 1996 Census 681 7,194 118,974 1The area used for this profile is based on Statistics New Zealand's area unit. Age profile At the 2001 Census: 20.7 percent of people in Ferrymead were under the age of 15 years, compared with 19.3 percent in Christchurch City and 22.7 percent for all of New Zealand.13.9 percent of people in Ferrymead were aged 65 years and over compared with 13.7 percent of Christchurch City and 12.1 percent for all of New Zealand. Age distribution (years) Ferrymead 0-14 20.7% 15-64 65.4% 65+ 13.9% Education At the 2001 Census: 22.2 percent of people aged 15 years and over in Ferrymead had a post-school qualification, compared with 32.8 percent for Christchurch City and 32.2 percent for New Zealand as a whole. Highest qualification No qualification School Post-school Ferrymead 36.3% 41.7% 22.2% Christchurch City 26.1% 41.1% 32.8% New Zealand 27.7% 40.1% 32.2% Christchurch City New Zealand 19.3% 22.7% 67.0% 65.3% 13.7% 12.1%
Ethnic groups (total responses) At the 2001 Census: 85.8 percent of people in Ferrymead said they belong to the European ethnic group, compared with 89.5 percent for Christchurch City and 80.1 percent for all of New Zealand. Ethnic groups (total responses) Ferrymead Christchurch City European 85.8% 89.5% Maori 9.4% 7.1% Pacific Peoples 8.5% 2.5% Asian 4.0% 5.7% Other 0.5% 0.7% New Zealand 80.1% 14.7% 6.5% 6.6% 0.7%
Average annual household spending for select groups Ferrymead Food $6,218 Housing $9,228 Housing Operation $4,765 Transportation $5,993 Christchurch City $6,429 $8,975 $5,018 $6,580 New Zealand $7,004 $10,159 $5,472 $7,358
30
30
10
20
10
20
Occupation
Ferrymead
Ferrymead
No Qualification Managers Certificate Gained as School Level 1, 2 Secondary Certificate Professionals Technicians & Trades Workers Community & Personal Service Workers Administrative Workers
Qualification
Christchurch City Christchurch City
Level 3, 4 Secondary Certificate Overseas Secondary School Qualification Level 1,2 & 3 Certificate Gained Post School Level 4 Certificate Gained Post School Level 5 Diploma Level 6 Diploma Sales Workers Machinery Operators & Drivers Labourers Bachelor Degree and Level 7 Qualifications Postgraduate and Honours Degree Master Degree Doctor Degree Others
10
20
40
60
80
Transports
Ferrymead
Worked at ome Did not go to work Today Drove a Private Car, Truck or Van Drove a Company Car, Truck or Van Passenger in a Car, Truck, Vanor Company Bus Public Bus Train Motor Cycle or Power Cyle Bicycle Walked or Jogged Others Not Elsewhere Included
Ferrymead
Ferrymead
Ethnicity
Ferrymead
Residential
Christchurch City
Christchurch City
Canterbury Region
Canterbury Region
New Zealand
New Zealand
0 40 10 20 30 0
Age
0 - 4 Years 5 - 9 Years 10 - 14 Years 15 - 19 Years 20 - 24 Years 25 - 29 Years 30 - 34 Years 35 - 39 Years 40 - 44 Years 45 - 49 Years 50 - 54 Years 55 - 59 Years 60 - 64 Years 65 Years & Over
Christchurch City
25
50
75
European
Maori
Pacific Peoples
Asian
MELAA
Other
Source : 2001 Census Number of people: Median age: Median personal income: Number of households: 2,560 36.8 $18,900 983
Source : 2006 Census Number of people: Median age: Median personal income: Number of households: 2,967 38 $22,300 1,137
Source : 2013 Census Number of people: Median age: Median personal income: Number of households: 3,460 39.2 $28,500 1,384
Prediction for 2023 Number of people: Median age: Median personal income: Number of households:
?
4380
Number of people
45 40 35
44.2
Median age
30
35800
30000 20000 10000
1850
Number of households
2001
2006
Feb 2011
2013
2023
FERRYMEAD CCC FERRY ROAD MASTER PLAN 2012 - CONTEXT & VISION
CONCEPT
DEMOLITION
TRAFFIC
ISSUES IDENTIFIED
CONCEPT ONE
From dredging from the northeast sea to fill up the land at the south side of the zone increases the overall area, providing more spaces available to be built on. This concept is based on dividing the site into three zones, the outer circle is for residential, to have a good view to the sea and away from the heavy traffic roads. The inner circle is the Commerical and Industrial zones where companies are at and service centre for nearby citizens to shop. The roads are also slightly changed, because of the heavy traffics in Ferry road. There is safety issues for walkers and cyclists so adding more roads around the area encourages drivers to take different routes when travelling pass Ferry road.
Dividing The Zones Industrial Area Residential Area Commerical Area Green Zone River & Sea Road
CONCEPT TWO
An extra space area created by dredging the Healthcote River, and it was firstly made into a green zone, creating connection with the Charlesworth Reserve park at the north. But however, due to the high demand on residential homes in Christchurch, this concept was changed into filling that area with residential homes. But the lost in green land must be recovered in someway. Hence the next step was to fill the empty spaces created between buildings into a green area, result shows that the Ferrymead had became a village like place, homes are set away from the high traffic road. The buildings along the road becomes service centres attracting people that passes through Ferry road. -
Node Pattern
Block Separation
Road Developing
Density Scale
CONCEPT THREE
Conceptual Sketch
Land available to be built on becomes less and less, but the demand of residential homes becomes higher. Stats shows that there is a need of a total 36,000 homes in the future 10 years, so lack of land becomes a problem. This concept is about using the dredging technique to create new lands within the Ferrymead area. A few islands are created in the Healthcote river serving different needs, the main function would be residential homes. The existing site would be developed into Service Centre and commerical areas iwith slight change to the roads to reduce traffic within Ferry road and to create connection to the island, provides ease for people to get into the shopping areas.
Green Zone
Possible Street
CONCEPT THREE
CONCEPT THREE
Initial Sketch
Road Developing
Movement
Reserved Park
Service Centre
Building Blocks
Redeveloped Roads
Creating Islands
We merged the main strength of the three concept ideas to create a final deciding concept. The building block layout which keeps the commerical and industrial buildings near the main road so people will inhabbit it more, the residential buildings are set back which are more quite and gives great view to the sea. The traffic issue and the cyclist saftey issue are solved by adding more roads to the area, drivers have options to take different routes so the traffic will be reduced. Natural hazard and lack of land problems are solved by dredging into new islands. It increase the total area of this space and gives more space to build residential homes for people.
Reserved Park
Commerial Uses
Residential Uses
Entertainment purpose
PROJECT DESCRIPTION Through the research of the site - Ferrymead, I found out that this area was once a place where people go shopping and do water sports activities, an area where lots of actions are going on, but since the earthquake occurs, some buildings are damaged, some are demolished. People began to use this space less and less because of the loss of service centre, it becomes a dead space where its use is just for cars driving pass through. There has been a list of issues that must be solved such as: The loss of service Centre needs to be replaced, walking and cycling safety issues, Natural environment issues, lack of residential homes, and also the inefficient use of land. These are the issue I found from the research phase and will be solved so the site will be brought back to live again. The existing sites open spaces are limited to build residential homes, so I use the dredging technique to create new islands for residential houses, industrial zones and place for water sport activities. This way also solves the traffic issues along Ferry Rd by creating new paths for cars and cyclists. Dredging also solves the Natural environment issue because it stops the sea level rise rate. After deciding to Dredge, I started to overlay city plans such as Irvine, Vancouver and Copenhagen into the site Ferrymead and ended up using the Vancouver model of The Gridding it has an efficient use of land, and an logical pattern. The new roads and cyclist paths are formed from the grid I created in the site and changed slightly to suit the site more. Two grid (Building footprint) layouts were designed, a 50x50m grid, the other one is 200x100m, the larger one were chosen because it is more flexible and the tall buildings will not block each others view to the sea. However, one Vancouver style site did is not enough, for new dredged islands, I used the docks design (Holland), islands are like giant docks floating in the sea with residential, industrial or commercial buildings on each of them, the canals between them will allow water flow smoothly into the water activity area. There will be roads connecting each of the docks together.
Vancouver, a city known for its urban planning, the city is planned in a grid, where it is extremely ordered and logical. The term Vancouverism is an internationally known that describes a new kind of city living. Vancouverism combines deep respect for nature with enthusiasm for busy, engaging, active streets and dynamic urban life. Vancouverism means tall slim towers for density, widely separated by low-rise buildings, for light, air, and views. It means many parks, walkable streets, and public spaces, combined with an emphasis on sustainable forms of transit.
Test one of Vancouver gridding This layout I used small grids of 50x50m, and inside each grid there is a building in it, The order of the building size is shown on the grid table above, tall building in the centre, then medium to low. The advantage of this grid layout is that there will be a lot of open space for carpark and green spaces, but there are no flexibility in the building footprint layout.-
Test Two of Vancouver gridding This layout I used Big grids of 200x100m with sub grids available to be divided, inside each big grid there are tall, medium and low building including open spaces, in which the order is totally flexible which is the advantage of this grid layout. Building are able to be arranged so that each building will get an open view to the islands. The open space is also just enough in this layout compared to the other, which had a lot and some is wasted. So I decided to choose this 200x100m grid to go further.
VANCOUVER OVERLAY
Overlayed the downtown of Vancouver to my existing site, roads and island will be formed according to this overlayed maps.
CREATING GRID
Grids are created through the whole site, the size of the chosen grid layout is 200x100m per grid, roads/paths and building foot print will be created according to the grid.
Roads and Island (docks) formed according to the gridding. Each grid (200x100m) will contain a mixture of tall, medium and low building, also includes car park area or green space.
The existing building of the site is added to this new planned site. Also new buildings are added to fill the grid and to the docks (islands)
ZONES
SCALE 1 1000
SITE PLAN
SCALE 1 1000
RECLAIMED ISLAND
Water sport facilities Owen (Weiwei) Xing
My proposal is for Reclaimed islands in the Hagley - Ferrymead Ward, This proposal would create strong integration between facilities and water sport site, also resolves the lack of service centre in the district. The project is located to the South-East of Christchurchs CBD, with a high traffic density road passing through the centre. The project proposes for a group of islands to be reclaimed on both sides of Ferrymead by dredging the mud from the bays and rivers. The reclaimed islands are mainly for private purposes, these includes private properties, membership club related to water sports, apartments and offices etc. By dredging the Heathcoat River and the Estuary additional land can be created. This new area can be used for building a new housing typology, one that is integrated into a recreation area. Through the research, we found the area is lacking services, not only is shopping a drive away but all services that support the recreation areas are also a drive out of the area. The area is also characterized by avid sports and recreation, however there is a clear lack of relationship between the sport sites and the stores that support them. In this project we aim to offer a way to bring living, recreation and the supporting services together. This also works well given the area is predicted to increase in population & business in the area. As an inland bay, Ferrymead is the perfect space for water sports like kayaking, surfing and diving, the reclaimed island would improve the conditions for these water sports. Dredge not only remove the century of built up slit, but it can also improve the area for various habitats such as birdlife and sealife. Extra land with properties can help resolve with increased population & business. The design concept is an integration of the two urban typologies: Irvine (Garden city concept) and Cobenhagen (Semi private space). The garden city concept is adjusted to suit the landscape, for example the island to the east has private surrounded by public service which means the water sport related centre is at the perimeter and housing is in the centre. This concept allows the reclaimed islands to form four looped layers, where public transitions to semi public to private to semi private. As for the area around Ferry Road, public space are to the north, closest to the inland sea, the main road is surrounded by semi public spaces, such as supermarkets and service retails. Private and semi private are located to the south, these are the office zone & private properties zone, semi private spaces can only by used by people who works or own the private spaces. In comparison to the Garden City urban design model, Copenhagen is transferring the city scale into individual scale, almost every buildings and structure follows the same pattern, in my design I would include this concept, taking the bigger scale format and duplicate into the design of the buildings.
KEY
Existing Building Proposed Commercial Building Proposed Residential Building
Inland sea / Healthcote River Green Zone - Parks / Fields Unbulit Space Mix of Green & Unbulit Space Semi Private within Building Roads Sand Zone Parking Zone Waling Path & Parking on Bridge
Simplify
Flip
Town Centre
IRVINE
Looking at the Irvine arrangement, it follows the pattern of the original, a park or lake in the centre, then spread out to office and industrial, or class room and lecture room for university, the external layer includes the apartment and private properties. After simplifying the garden city concept, I thoughts were flipping the concept to suit my landscape. As the many islands my design reclaimed, private surrounded by public water sport centres would be more appropriate, as for the high performance properties, they would be located in the centre of the islands, as my design goes further, I would also consider, Public -> Private -> Public.
Irvine - Small town near Los Angela Harima science Garden city by PWP Landscapes Design based on Garden city concept
Denmark
Compare to Garden City format, Cobenhagen is transfering the city scale into individual scale, almost every buildings and structure follows the same pattern, in my design I would also like to include this concept, taking the bigger scale format and deplicate into the format of every building. Individual structure Pattern:
Public -
CBD
CBD of Cobenhagen
Bird View of the City - Each building structure forms its own semi private sapce in the centre
Semi - private (mix of green & soild) Private (Building structures) Semi - public (soild) Public (mix of green & soild) Public (Green) Road of CPH CPH Overlay
After the research on Cobenhagen and Irvine ( Garden city), I overlay the format of Cobenhagen onto Ferrymead landscape, it is intersting to see what difference can be made once given Ferrymead a new format. Even though each individual building is worth looking into, but the layout and flow of the street does not quiet fit the lanscape, road and public space must be modified again, in order the take this further, I would test the garden city format as the big scale and each structure would remain the same. Almost every buildings and structure follows the same pattern, pubic space -> semi public -> private -> semi private, in my design I would also like to include this concept, it creates extra layers to the landscape.
Scale Change
Semi - private (Storage or private lookouts) Private (office, apartment & properties) Semi - public (Receiption, service stores) Public (Service & retail industrial) Public (Green)
First stage of testing the possibility of combine the Garden city concept with the Cobenhagen layout, the programs can be arrange into each layer, the ones next to Ferry road are the service and retail industries, followed by the receiptions and stores, and the privates are closer to the river side. Islands create in conceptual stage can not stand by itself, the reason for why the shape of the islands is in such a way is not satisified, therefore before the complete match of these two concept, I needed to modify the shape of the island. The islands in Developed garden city concept format on Ferrymead is a base form of the new islands, will take it further in the next steps.
Starting point
Wind direction
Shape formation
Creating a surrounded space for water sport, which forms a circle to correspond to the garden city concept
The changes were made on the forms of the reclaimed islands, in the designing process, I included the concept of Garden city, and transfer it into an unequal grid, the structures in these grids will follow the flow, each individual structure will have their semi private spaces. Also I need to consider the wind flows this, this would effect the quality for wind surfing. Having a reach out from the existing can provide better users experiences for water sport players. Once I have finalise the forms and layouts for these dredged islands, I would apply or extend this same format onto the rest of Ferrymead.
Water sport related Gear / equipment related private properties Service / retails connections
Starting point
Road as Grid
Structure Layout
Based on the concept of Garden city, each individual refers to Conbenhagen format
Private
Public
Taking existing Ferry road as the start point, applied the format thats used on the island onto mainland. First, Grid to create layer. Second, apply extra parts or field to existing structures to fit the grid. Third, Cobenhagen format into the structure style.
Private Semi Public Semi Public Private
Public
NEGATIVE
Semi Public
POSITIVE
Semi Private
On the diagram below, I have identify the programs that spaces would have, mainly focused on the reclaimed islands, It would be related to on water sport, making it easier for the people from private zone to use the spaces in the centre.
Semi Public
Public
Private properties
Private
Public
Office / Apartments
Semi Private
- Land increased - high proportion of green zone - Visible parallel - Semi private space for each buildings - Forming its own loop Appears parellel - building has size difference Finalise layouts
FINALISE PROJECT
Building Blocks
KEY
Existing Building Proposed Commercial Building Proposed Residential Building
Inland sea / Healthcote River Green Zone - Parks / Fields Unbulit Space Mix of Green & Unbulit Space Semi Private within Building Roads Sand Zone Parking Zone Waling Path & Parking on Bridge
Private properties
2%
29%
Roads
9%
27%
Unbulit Spaces
33%