Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The sintering behavior of three different types of hydroxyapatite (HA) i.e. a commercial powder, HA(C), a
Received 20 June 2011 synthesized powder by wet chemical precipitation method, HA(W) and a synthesized powder by mech-
Accepted 5 August 2011 anochemical method, HA(M) were investigated over the temperature range of 1000–1350 °C. It has been
Available online 12 August 2011
revealed that the sinterability and mechanical properties of the synthesized HA(W) was significantly
higher than that of the HA(C) and HA(M). The optimum sintering temperature for the HA(W) samples
Keywords: was 1100 °C with the following properties being recorded: 99.8% relative density, Vickers hardness of
A. Engineering Ceramics
7.04 GPa and fracture toughness of 1.22 MPa m1/2. In contrast, the optimum sintering temperature for
C. Sintering
E. Mechanical
the HA(C) and HA(M) samples was 1300 °C with relative density of 98% and 95.5%, Vickers hardness of
5.47 GPa and 4.73 GPa, fracture toughness of 0.75 MPa m1/2 and 0.82 MPa m1/2 being measured. The pres-
ent research showed that the wet chemical precipitation reaction was beneficial in producing a highly
crystalline, high purity and single phase stoichiometric HA powder that is sinteractive particularly at
low temperatures below 1100 °C.
Ó 2011 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
addition of ammonium (NH3) solution (25% concentration). NH3 powder consists of a mixture of fine powder particles ranging from
solution. The precipitate was allowed to settle down overnight be- 1 to 3 lm diameter and larger particles of 5–10 lm diameter. The
fore filtration. The filtered precipitate was rinsed three times by larger particles appear to be large agglomerates of loosely packed
using distilled water and then dried overnight in an oven. The dried smaller particles, resulting in a rough surface as shown in Fig. 1.
filtered cake was crushed and sieved to obtain a well-defined, The drying of the filter cake of synthesized HA could have resulted
highly crystalline HA powder. in less compaction of the precipitate and resulted in the formation
The HA powder synthesized by mechanochemical method in of soft agglomerates which was found to break easily using a very
the present work was prepared according to the method reported low pressing pressure of 1.3–2.5 MPa during powder compaction
by Rhee [8]. The starting precursors used were commercially avail- to form the green body. Due to the soft nature of the powders, at-
able calcium pyrophosphate, Ca2P2O7 (99.9% purity, Aldrich) and tempts to use higher pressures during uniaxial pressing the sam-
calcium carbonate, CaCO3 (99% purity, Aldrich). The mixture, in ples proved to be futile as powders lamination on the die surface
the mole ratio of Ca2P2O7:CaCO3 = 3:4, was milled for 8 h with a was observed and in some extreme cases, a layer of compacted
rotating speed of 170 rpm in a high-density polyethylene bottle powders separated immediately from the green body upon ejec-
using zirconia balls and distilled water as milling medium. Once tion from the mold.
milling was completed, the slurry was dried in oven at 150 °C for In contrast, although the particle size for powder synthesized by
24 h and then heat-treated at 1100 °C for 1 h. Finally the dried mechanochemical method ranges from 0.5 to 4 lm diameters, it
powder was sieved to obtain the HA powder, hereafter will be should be highlighted that the powder consists of hard agglomer-
known as HA(M). In order to evaluate the sinterability and perfor- ates as typically shown in Fig. 2. Additionally, ‘‘neck’’ formation
mance of different HA powders, a commercially available stoichi- could be observed between smaller particles as a result of the heat
ometric HA manufacture by Merck, Germany was also studied for treatment process carried out on this powder during the synthesis
comparison purpose, hereafter is known as HA(C). Green samples stage.
were fabricated by uniaxial compaction at about 1.3 MPa to On the other hand, the HA(C) powder consisted of a mixture of
2.5 MPa. The green compacts were subsequently cold isostatically small and large particles as shown in Fig. 3. The presences of soft
pressed at 200 MPa (Riken Seiki, Japan). This was followed by con- agglomerates could not be observed in the commercial powder
solidation of the particles by pressureless sintering performed in but instead the particles appeared to be large, up to 10 lm, and
air using a rapid heating furnace over the temperature range of seemed to be more compacted when compared to those observed
1000–1350 °C, with ramp rate of 2 °C/min. (heating and cooling) for the HA powder synthesized by the wet chemical method.
and soaking time of 2 h for each firing. All sintered samples were X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of the synthesized HA(W) and
then polished to a 1 lm finish prior to testing. HA(M) powders produced only peaks which corresponded to the
The calcium and phosphorus content in the synthesized HA standard JCPDS card no: 74-566 for stoichiometric HA as shown
powder were determined by using the Inductively Coupled Plas- in Figs. 4 and 5, respectively. The only difference in the XRD pat-
ma-Atomic Emission Spectrometry (ICP-AES) technique. The parti- terns of HA(W) and HA(M) powders before sintering was in the de-
cle size distributions of the HA powders was determined using a gree of crystallinity. The XRD patterns of HA(W) indicated that the
standard MicromeriticsÒ SediGraph 5100 X-ray particle size ana- powder was poorly crystalline as depicted by the broad diffraction
lyzer. The specific surface area of the powder was measured by peaks, which is a characteristic of HA prepared by an aqueous pre-
the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method. The morphology of cipitation route. This observation is in agreement with that re-
the starting powder was examined using a Philips ESEM model ported by Gibson et al. [11] who found that calcination at higher
XL30 scanning electron microscope. The phases present in the temperature, as in the present case for HA(M) powders, would ex-
powders and sintered samples were determined using X-ray dif- hibit a narrower diffraction peaks and not a broad one as observed
fraction (XRD) (Geiger-Flex, Rigaku Japan). The bulk densities of for the HA(W) powder in the present work.
the compacts were determined by the water immersion technique In contrast, powders prepared by mechanochemical process
(Mettler Toledo, Switzerland). The relative density was calculated produced a diffraction pattern that indicated a highly crystalline
by taking the theoretical density of HA as 3.156 Mg m3 [2]. The material, with narrow diffraction peaks as a result of heat treat-
microhardness (Hv) of the samples was determined using the Vick- ment as typically shown in Fig. 5. It should be noted that HA could
ers indentation method (Matsuzawa, Japan). The indentation frac- only be obtained in this powder upon heat treatment at 1100 °C.
ture toughness (KIc) was determined from the equation derived by This is shown clearly in Fig. 5 where the XRD trace of the prepared
Niihara et al. [9]. powder before heat treatment produced peaks that corresponded
to the starting precursors (calcium carbonate and calcium pyro-
phosphate). Similarly, X-ray diffraction analysis of the commercial
3. Results and discussion powder, HA(C), produced only peaks which corresponded to the
standard JCPDS card no.: 74-566 for stoichiometric HA as shown
The Ca/P molar ratio determined by ICP-AES for the three pow- in Fig. 6.
ders varied slightly from 1.66 to 1.68, thus close to the stoichiom- After sintering in air atmosphere, the commercial HA compacts
etric value of 1.67 as shown in Table 1. Ozeki et al. [10] have were observed to have a distinct color change, i.e. from white (as-
emphasized the importance of the Ca/P ratio since any deviations received powder) to blue (as-sintered). The intensity of the blue
from the stoichiometric value would have an adverse effect on color was also observed to increase with increasing sintering tem-
the sintered properties of the hydroxyapatite body. The HA(W) perature, i.e. from light blue (1000 °C) to dark blue (1350 °C). It has
been reported by Yubao et al. [12] that most commercial HA pow-
ders contained small additions of impurities and the origin of the
Table 1
apatite blue color was due to the presence of Mn5+ or MnO3 4 ions
ICP-AES results of the starting HA powders.
at the PO34 sites in the apatite crystal structure. According to these
HA(W) HA(M) HA(C) authors, sintering at high temperature not only increases the
Color White White White intensity of oxidation in the oxidizing atmosphere, but also pro-
Calcium (% w/w) 38.9 38.3 37 vides enough energy for the oxidized manganese ion (Mn2+ to
Phosphorous (% w/w) 23.2 23 22
Mn5+) to migrate within the crystal lattice. This color change how-
Ca/P ratio 1.676 1.665 1.681
ever was not observed in both the synthesized HA(W) and HA(M)
Author's personal copy
5 µm
Fig. 1. SEM micrographs of HA(W) revealing the presences of loosely packed particles.
Neck formation
2.5 µm
Hard particles
Fig. 2. SEM micrographs of synthesized HA(M) revealing neck formation between particles and presences of hard particles.
Fig. 4. Comparison of XRD patterns of synthesized HA(W) with the standard JCPDS card for stoichiometric HA.
Fig. 5. Comparison of XRD patterns of synthesized HA(M) powder before and after heat treatment at 1100 °C.
The XRD traces of hydroxyapatite synthesized via the mechano- employed is another important factor that could influence the sin-
chemical technique also revealed the present of only HA phase as tering behavior of HA. Kim et al. [18] synthesized HA powder by
indicated in Fig. 8. The present results obtained for the sintered mechanochemical method using water as the milling medium
HA(M) samples contradicted the findings of Mostafa [16]. In gen- and the milling time was set at 60 min. Nevertheless, the authors
eral, the author reported that the powder which was synthesized observed secondary phases in their HA matrix upon sintering.
using the same technique as the present HA(M) transformed par- The effects of sintering temperature on the sintered densities of
tially into b-TCP upon sintering at 1100 °C. In another work, Yeong the three HA compacts are shown in Fig. 9. All samples were
et al. [17] have also confirmed that the HA powder synthesized heated to the chosen sintering temperature at 2 °C/min. and, after
using mechanochemical method transformed partially into TCP a dwell time of 2 h, cooled to room temperature at 2 °C/min.
when sintered beyond 1200 °C. The difference in the results re- In general, the bulk density increases with increasing sintering
ported in the literatures as compared to the present work could temperature regardless of the type of powder studied. A small in-
be attributed to the milling medium used, the milling time and crease in density is observed before the onset of densification and
probably due to the high purity of the starting powders. The mill- this corresponds to the first stage of sintering, where necks are
ing medium used in the current work was water with a milling formed between powder particles. The second stage of sintering
time of 8 h. Rhee [8] has emphasized the importance of having corresponds to densification (onset of densification) and the re-
100% water content in the milling medium during the mechano- moval of most of the porosity. The onset of densification, indicated
chemical synthesis process. Yeong et al. [17] have synthesized by a sharp increase in the sintered density, for HA(M) and HA(C)
their HA powder using ethanol as the milling medium and this was between 1100 °C and 1200 °C. In the case for HA(W) samples,
could be the reason for obtaining secondary phases upon sintering sintering was carried out from 700 °C so as to determine the onset
due to insufficient H2O present in the medium to suppress decom- densification temperature. As shown in Fig. 9, this temperature
position activity in the HA structure. Additionally, the milling time was found to be between 900 °C and 1000 °C. Generally, sintering
Author's personal copy
Synthesized HA(W)
1350ºC
1300ºC
1250ºC
1200ºC
1150ºC
1100ºC
1050ºC
1000ºC
Fig. 7. XRD patterns of synthesized HA(W) sintered at various temperatures. All the peaks corresponded to that of stoichiometric HA.
above this range resulted in very low increase in density which is when sintered at the same temperature. As for HA(M), the highest
associated with the final stages of sintering where small levels of relative density of 98% could only be attained when the material
porosity are removed and grain growth begins. was sintered at 1350 °C. In general, the densification behavior of
The synthesized HA by wet precipitation method achieved a HA(W) was more superior to that of HA(M). This could be attrib-
final sintered density of 97–99% of theoretical density at uted to the higher BET surface area of 60.7 m2/g for HA(W) which
1050–1100 °C, whereas the commercial HA required a sintering promoted a large driving force for densification as compared to a
temperature of 1250–1300 °C to attain a similar density. In gen- low 2.7 m2/g for HA(M). Furthermore, the spherical nano particles
eral, these results indicate that HA synthesized by wet precipita- of HA(W) as observed within the larger agglomerates (Fig. 1)
tion method is more sinteractive than the commercial HA. The would have a higher heat transfer area and thus accelerate densi-
fact that HA(W) shows improved relative density as compared to fication upon sintering. In contrast, HA(M), which consists of hard
HA(C) could be attributed to the physical basis of the Herring agglomerates (Fig. 2), could have led to a lower packing density in
law of sintering [19], which suggests that the sintering rate at a gi- the green state and hence poor sintering behavior.
ven temperature is inversely proportional to the square of the The effect of sintering temperature on the Vickers hardness of
powder particle size. In the present study, the particle size mea- the three HA is shown in Fig. 10. Throughout the sintering temper-
sured using particle size analyzer for HA(W) and HA(C) were ature range studied, it can be noted that HA synthesized by the wet
1.78 ± 0.22 lm and 3.26 ± 1.53 lm, respectively. Thus, the smaller chemical precipitation method displayed superior hardness as
the particle size, the larger would be the BET surface area i.e. compared to HA synthesized by mechanochemical method and
60.7 m2/g for HA(W) as compared 28.4 m2/g for HA(C) and hence commercial HA. The hardness for HA(W) increased as the sintering
the easier would be for HA(W) powder to achieve high density temperature was increased and reached a maximum value of about
Author's personal copy
Fig. 8. XRD patterns of synthesized HA(M) sintered at various temperatures. All the peaks corresponded to that of stoichiometric HA.
100 1.2
Fracture Toughness (MPam 1/2)
95
1
Relative Density (%)
90
0.8
85
80 HA(W) 0.6
75 HA(M)
HA(C) 0.4 HA (W)
70 HA (M)
65 0.2 HA (C)
60 0
1000 1050 1100 1150 1200 1250 1300 1350 1000 1050 1100 1150 1200 1250 1300 1350
Sintering Temperature (ºC) Sintering Temperature (ºC)
Fig. 9. Effect of sintering temperature on the relative densities of HA(W), HA(M) Fig. 11. Effect of sintering temperature on the fracture toughness of HA.
and HA(C) samples.
in Fig. 10. This trend is similar for HA(M) which achieved a maxi-
8 mum hardness of 4.73 GPa when sintered at 1300 °C. Nevertheless,
7 a decreased of hardness was observed for both HA(C) and HA(M)
Vickers Hardness (GPa)
4. Conclusions [5] Ramesh S, Tan CY, Bhaduri SB, Teng WD, Sopyan I. Densification behaviour of
nanocrystalline hydroxyapatite bioceramics. J Mater Proc Tech 2008;206:
221–30.
The sinterability of a high purity, single-phase HA powder pro- [6] Uskokovic V, Uskokovic DP. Nanosized hydroxyapatite and other calcium
duced in this study by a wet chemical precipitation reaction, was phosphates: chemistry of formation and application as drug and gene delivery
agents. J Biomed Mater Res B: Appl Biomater 2011;96B:152–91.
significantly higher than for powder synthesized via mechano-
[7] Ramesh S. A method for manufacturing hydroxyapatite bioceramic. Malaysia
chemical technique and a commercial HA powder. The X-ray Patent 2004; PI.20043325.
diffraction signatures of both the synthesized HA studied compared [8] Rhee SH. Synthesis of hydroxyapatite via mechanochemical treatment.
Biomaterials 2002;23:1147–52.
very favorably with that of a stoichiometric HA. Decomposition of
[9] Niihara K, Morena R, Hasselman DPH. Evaluation of KIc of brittle solids by the
HA phase to form tri-calcium phosphate, tetra tri-calcium phos- indentation method with low crack-to-indent ratios. J Mater Sci Letts
phate and calcium oxide was not observed in the present work 1982;1:13–6.
for all the powders. It has been revealed that the sinterability in [10] Ozeki K, Fukui Y, Aoki H. Influence of the calcium phosphate content of the
target on the phase composition and deposition rate of sputtered films. Appl
terms of density, Vickers hardness and fracture toughness of the Surf Sci 2007;253:5040–4.
synthesized HA via precipitation method was significantly greater [11] Gibson IR, Ke S, Best SM, Bonfield W. Effect of powder characteristics on the
than that of the synthesized HA using the mechanochemical meth- sinterability of hydroxyapatite powders. J Mater Sci: Mater Med 2001;12:
163–71.
od and the commercial HA. Generally, although the chemical and [12] Yubao L, Klein CPAT, Xindong Z, DeGroot K. Relationship between the color
phase compositions of the powders studied were similar, the pow- change of hydroxyapatite and the trace element manganese. Biomaterials
der morphology and particle size distribution were very different. It 1993;14:969–72.
[13] Liao CJ, Lin FH, Chen KS, Sun JS. Thermal decomposition and reconstitution of
is believed that the different powder characteristics were largely a hydroxyapatite in air atmosphere. Biomaterials 1999;20:1807–13.
result of the different powder processing methods used and these [14] Wang CK, Ju CP, Chern Lin JH. Effect of doped bioactive glass on structure
differences were evident in the sintering characteristics of the and properties of sintered hydroxyapatite. Mater Chem Phys 1998;53:
138–49.
powders.
[15] Kothapalli C, Wei M, Vasiliev A, Shaw MT. Influence of temperature and
concentration on the sintering behavior and mechanical properties of
Acknowledgements hydroxyapatite. Acta Mater 2004;52:5655–63.
[16] Mostafa NY. Characterization, thermal stability and sintering of
hydroxyapatite powders prepared by different routes. Mater Chem Phys
The authors would like to thank the Ministry of Science, Tech- 2005;94:333–41.
nology and Innovation of Malaysia for providing the financial [17] Yeong KCB, Wang J, Ng SC. Mechanochemical synthesis of nanocrystalline
support under the Grant No. 03-02-03-SF0073. hydroxyapatite from CaO and CaHPO4. Biomaterials 2001;22:2705–12.
[18] Kim W, Zhang Q, Saito M. Mechanochemical synthesis of hydroxyapatite
from Ca(OH)2–P2O5 and CaO-Ca(OH)2–P2O5 mixtures. J Mater Sci
References 2000;35:5401–5.
[19] Herring C. The physics of powder metallurgy. In: Kingston WE, editor. New
[1] Oguchi H, Ishikawa K, Mizoue K, Seto K, Eguchi G. Long-term histological York: McGraw-Hill; 1951. p. 143–79.
evaluation of hydroxyapatite ceramics in humans. Biomaterials 1995;16:33–8. [20] De With W, Van Dijk JA, Hattu HN, Prijs K. Preparation, microstructure and
[2] Hench LL. Biomaterials: a forecast for the future. Biomaterials 1998;19: mechanical properties of dense polycrystalline hydroxyapatite. J Mater Sci
1419–23. 1981;16:1592–8.
[3] Suchanek W, Yoshimura M. Processing and properties of hydroxyapatite-based [21] Van Landuyt P, Li F, Keustermans JP, Streydio JM, Delannay F, Munting E. The
biomaterials for use as hard tissue replacement implants. J Mater Res influence of high sintering temperatures on the mechanical properties of
1998;13:94–117. hydroxylapatite. J Mater Sci: Mater Med 1995;6:8–13.
[4] Afshar M, Ghorbani N, Ehsani MR, Sorrell CC. Some important factors in the [22] Muralithran G, Ramesh S. The effects of sintering temperature on the
wet precipitation process of hydroxyapatite. Mater Des 2003;24:197–202. properties of hydroxyapatite. Ceram Inter 2000;26:221–30.