Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Copyright 1994-2006
Taxation 2005
You now request confirmation of your opinions as follows: 1) Subic Power Corporation should withhold 5% as final withholding tax on the interest income remitted to U.S. bondholders in connection with its "Rule 144 A" offering in the U.S.; The assumed 5% final withholding tax is considered additional financing charges of Subic Power Corporation; and The withholding tax base for purposes of applying the 5% final withholding tax is the total amount of income to be remitted without grossing up the 5% final withholding tax due thereon.
2) 3)
In reply, please be informed as follows: 1. In Suggestion 5 of Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 46-77, this Bureau has recognized and stated that it is aware of the market convention that the local borrower assumes the tax on the creditor's income in a foreign loan agreement. Thus, the Bureau adopted measures for local institutions to be at par with non-resident creditors. In this connection, a withholding agent is held to be directly and independently liable for the tax that, by law, it should withhold. (Commissioner of Internal Revenue vs. Procter & Gamble Philippine Manufacturing Corporation and the Court of Tax Appeals, G.R. 66838, December 2, 1994). Pursuant to Republic Act No. 7227, Subic Bay Freeport (SBF) Enterprises, such as SPC, are subject to the maximum tax rate of 5% in lieu of all other national or local taxes. The 5% tax of SBF Enterprises is a commutation tax which effectively accords the grantee exemption from all other taxes. (Philippine Air Lines vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, CTA Case No. 5 dated February 8, 1956; PNRC vs. CIR, G.R. 10045, 34 Phil 401). Such being the case, your opinion that SPC should withhold 5% as final withholding tax on the interest income remitted to U.S. bondholders in connection with its "Rule 144A" offering in the U.S., is hereby confirmed. This Bureau similarly recognizes that when an enterprise assumes payment of taxes withheld and due from a foreign lender-remittee on interest payments of foreign loans, the taxes assumed by the registered enterprise represent necessary and ordinary expenses
CD Technologies Asia, Inc. Taxation 2005 2
2.
Copyright 1994-2006
incurred by the enterprise; hence, deductible from its gross income. [Section 2(b), Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 13-80 dated April 10, 1980]. Therefore, your opinion that the 5% final withholding tax assumed by Subic Power Corporation under the circumstances described above should be considered its additional financing charges is hereby confirmed. 3. The assumption of the tax constitutes an additional income of the non-resident creditor-bondholders, which in turn should be subject to tax. (Old Colony Trust Co. vs. Commissioner, 279 U.S. 716). Thus, the tax base should be grossed-up by adding to the interest income payments the amount of tax assumed.
prcd
Copyright 1994-2006
Taxation 2005