Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 1

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
US DISTRICT COURT
for the
DISTRICT OF MARYLAND US
(Northern Division)
!"##"A$ %&'( %&)*P' '&+* """
Plaintiff
,-
!"##"A$ $- )C'$A#.*#/0
Defendant
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Case (o-2 1214-c,-1683-*#'
FIRST AMENDED ANSWER OF DEFENDANT,
COUNTERCLAIMS OF WILLIAM M. SCMALFELDT
AND !URY DEMAND
!"##"A$ $- )C'$A#.*#/0
Counterclaim Plaintiff
,-
!"##"A$ %&'( %&)*P' '&+* """
Counterclaim Defendant
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
!"##"A$ $- )C'$A#.*#/0
Counterclaim Plaintiff
,-
C'3") )- '*A0'*3
283 Arlin4ton A,e-5 6pper
3acine5 !isconsin 5343
Counterclaim Defendant
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
!"##"A$ $- )C'$A#.*#/0
Counterclaim Plaintiff
,-
7PA6# 83*(/#*39 :Anon;mous <lo44er1
Counterclaim Defendant
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ANSWER
/efendant !illiam $- )c=malfeldt5 in answer to Plaintiff !illiam %o=n %osep=
'o4e """s Complaint5 denies and a,ers as follows2
NATURE OF TE ACTION
1- /efendant a,ers t=at t=is is an action for cop;ri4=t infrin4ement- 'e
denies t=e reproduction Plaintiffs cop;ri4=ted wor> was unaut=ori?ed5 or a
preparation of deri,ati,e wor>- /efendant a,ers t=at Plaintiff =as a cop;ri4=t
interest in t=e wor>s descri@ed5 @ut /efendant also a,ers t=at all wor>s used @u;
/efendant were used under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se /octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t #aw5
17 6)C A 17- /efendant denies t=at use of t=e wor>s was unaut=ori?ed and infrin4in4-
2- /efendant denies t=e alle4ations of Para4rap= 2 of t=e Complaint in toto-
3- /enied in toto-
!URISDICTION
4- /efendant su@mits to t=e Burisdiction of t=is Court-
5- /efendant su@mits to t=is Court as t=e proper ,enue for t=is action-
"ARTIES
6- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 7 of t=e
Complaint-
7- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 8 of t=e
Complaint eCcept as noted- /efendant denies =is conduct was =arassment as descri@ed @;
$ar;land #aw 3-83- /efendant is currentl; awaitin4 word from t=e $ar;land Court of
Appeals on =is petition for a writ of certiorari in appeal of t=e peace order-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ANSWERS TO MR. O#E$S COM"LAINTS
8- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 9 of t=e
Complaint-
9- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 1 of t=e
Complaint-
1- /efendant does not =a,e enou4= information to form an opinion as to
Plaintiffs a,erment in Para4rap= 11 of t=e Complaint- /efendant is aware t=at
Plaintiff claims =e purc=ased t=e ri4=ts =e =as claimed- <ut /efendant =as ne,er seen
a s=red of e,idence or proof t=at t=is transaction was e,er le4all; effected-
ANSWER TO "LAINTIFF$S COM"LAINT ON CO"YRI#T INFRIN#EMENTS
11- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 12 of t=e
Complaint-
12- /efendant denies t=e a,erment made in Para4rap= 13 of t=e Complaint-
13- /efendant admits in part and denies in part t=e a,erments made @;
Plaintiff in Para4rap= 14 of t=e Complaint- /efendant is not aware of Plaintiff e,er
filin4 a /$CA ta>edown notice or infrin4ement notice wit= an "nternet )er,ice Pro,ider
used @; /efendant- /efendant denies =is use can le4all; @e defined as infrin4in4 as
t=e use clearl; fits t=e four pillars of t=e .air 6se /octrine- /efendant denies t=at
a /$CA 0a>edown was sent to #ulu-com for t=e @oo> Brain Dead.
14- /efendant admits to =a,in4 made t=e statement of fact in Para4rap= 15 of
t=e Complaint on $a; 15- /espite Plaintiffs apparent @elief t=at t=is amounted to a
declaration of 7" dare ;ou to sue me59 /efendant was merel; statin4 t=e polic; set
fort= @; t=e /$CA-
ANSWER TO INFRIN#EMENT %IA &OO'S AND E&OO'S (COUNTS I, II (n) III)
15- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are =ere@; incorporated @; reference-
16- /efendant admits to Plaintiffs a,erment of pu@lis=in4 a @lo4 post titled
Are You Pondering What Im Pondering on April 145 214-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 4
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
17- /efendant admits to Plaintiffs a,erment in Para4rap= 18 of =is
Complaint5 and maintains t=e @lo4 post was pu@lis=ed to illustrate t=e point /efendant
was ma>in4 in t=e @oo>5 and was used under t=e .air 6se /octrine- &ne cop; of t=e e-
@oo> was purc=ased and t=at was apparentl; @; t=e Plaintiff-
18- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments of Plaintiff in Para4rap= 19 of =is
Complaint-
19- /efendant denies t=at =is use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done
under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se /octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er
denies t=at /efendant is entitled to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
ANSWER TO COUNT II * BRAIN DEAD
2- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
21- /efendant admits to t=e a,erments made @; Plaintiff in Para4rap= 22 of
t=e Complaint- 'e admits one cop; of t=e @oo> was sold- 0=e @oo> was purc=ased as a
proof cop; @; t=e /efendant-
22- /efendant denies t=e a,erments made @; Plaintiff in Para4rap= 23 of t=e
Complaint- .or one t=in45 t=e @oo> was pu@lis=ed in 2145 not 214- /efendant is not
aware of an; Complaints made a@out infrin4in4 material in 7<rain /ead-9 /efendant
admits t=e @oo> was remo,ed from t=e #ulu-com catalo4 on April 225 @ut it was at t=e
demand of t=e /efendant-
23- /efendant denies t=e a,erments in Para4rap= 24 of Plaintiffs Complaint
t=at =is use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se
/octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er denies t=at /efendant is entitled
to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
CANSWER TO COUNT III * INTENTIONAL INFLICTION
24- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
25- /efendant admits to t=e Plaintiffs a,erments in Para4rap= 26 of t=e
Complaint in part and denies in part- "t was actuall; more li>e 7 percent of a @lo4
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
post t=at Plaintiff did not own at t=e time t=e @oo> was pu@lis=ed- /efendant did not
7@ra49 a@out repu@lis=in4 t=e portion of t=e @lo4 entr;-
26- /efendant does not =a,e sufficient information as to t=e trut= of t=e
a,erments made @; Plaintiff in Para4rap= 27 of t=e Complaint-
27- /efendant denies t=e a,erments in Para4rap= 28 of Plaintiffs Complaint
t=at =is use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se
/octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er denies t=at /efendant is entitled
to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
ANSWER TO INFRIN&EMENT %IA INTERNET WE&SITES (Co+nts I% thro+,h L%II)
28- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are =ere@; incorporated @; reference-
29- /efendant admits in part and denies in part t=e a,erments made @;
Plaintiff in Para4rap= 3 of =is Complaint- 'e admits to usin4 t=e material- 'e denies
it was infrin4ement as t=e material was used under t=e .air 6se /octrine of t=e 6)
Cop;ri4=t #aw-
3- /efendant admits in part and denies in part t=e a,erments made @;
Plaintiff in 0a@le 1 of =is Complaint- /efendant admits to usin4 t=e material-
/efendant denies t=e use was infrin4ement as t=e material was used in accordance wit=
t=e .air 6se /octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law-
31- /efendant denies t=e a,erments in Para4rap= 32 of Plaintiffs Complaint
t=at /efendants use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done under t=e terms of t=e
.air 6se /octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er denies t=at /efendant is
entitled to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
32- /efendant denies t=e a,erments in Para4rap= 33 of Plaintiffs Complaint
t=at =is use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se
/octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er denies t=at /efendant is entitled
to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
ANSWER TO INFRIN#EMENT %IA TWITTER (COUNTS L%III TEOU# C--I%)
33- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are =ere@; incorporated @; reference-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 6
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
34- /efendant admits t=e a,erments made @; Plaintiff in Para4rap= 25 of t=e
Complaint-
35- /efendant does not =a,e enou4= information to admit or den; eac= of t=e
instances of w=at Plaintiff in 0a@le 2 of =is Complaint calls 7"nfrin4in4 0weets9 as
/efendant no lon4er =as access to t=e ,ast maBorit; of t=e tweets- /efendant denies
7reproducin4 all or almost all9 of eac= of Plaintiffs wor>s-
36- /efendant denies t=e a,erments in Para4rap= 37 of Plaintiffs Complaint
t=at =is use of t=e wor> was unlawful as it was done under t=e terms of t=e .air 6se
/octrine of t=e 6) Cop;ri4=t law- /efendant furt=er denies t=at /efendant is entitled
to an;t=in4 as a result of t=is case-
AFFIRMATI%E DEFENSES
37- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are =ere@; incorporated @; reference-
38- 0=e Complaint fails to state a claim upon w=ic= relief can @e 4ranted-
39- 0=e Complaint fails @ecause an; use @; /efendant as to w=ic= Plaintiff
=olds a cop;ri4=t interest constitutes a non-infrin4in4 fair use and de minimis use
under 6nited )tates law-
4- "n eac= instance descri@ed @; Plaintiff in =is Complaint5 /efendant used
enou4= of Plaintiffs @lo4 posts to illustrate t=e point /efendant was tr;in4 to ma>e
a@out Plaintiffs 18-mont= campai4n of =arassment a4ainst /efendant-
41- 0=e .air 6se /octrine does not set a percenta4e or 7word count9 of =ow
muc= of a persons cop;ri4=ted wor> can @e used @; anot=er to illustrate a point and
pro,e t=e trut=fulness of w=at =e is writin4 and to a,oid misrepresentin4 w=at t=e
Plaintiff said or wrote in =is @lo4-
42- "t is true t=at /efendant used a si4nificant portion of anon;mous @lo44er
7Paul 8rendlers9 @lo4 entr; of April 235 214 to illustrate t=e point t=at t=e =atred
@ein4 4enerated a4ainst /efendant @; Plaintiff and =is followers =ad reac=ed a point
of near insanit;- 0=e portion used @; t=e defendant reads :in part1 as follows2
Old and crazy, fat and demented, Bill Schmalfeldt sat at his curbside reject card table, wishing he
could rub two dimes together and find an old desk at a yard sale. But who would help him haul it
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 7
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
home? Gail? (Defendants wife) She was rarely home anymore. She spent her nights wandering the
streets of Elkridge, desperate to get out of the house, out from under his hateful eye. Away from the
unrelenting stink of old diapers and sweating feet. She spent the days sleeping off the nights. With the
dogs. He stared at a blank page, considering his next post.
....
Whats happened to me? God damn it, Im relevant. Relevant! He shook a fist at the ceiling,
splattering mayonnaise on his monitor.
He absently wiped the stain from his monitor and licked the creamy goo off his finger. He liked
creamy, gooey things. For no particular reason, he thought of his lost brother Bob. (Defendants
identical twin brother, who died of a stroke on March 19, 2004)
Oh, God, Bob, he thought, still sucking his finger clean. I miss you so.
He sat back and closed his eyes, remembering fondly the many years of sharing a bedroom with the
Bobber. The playful teasing and wrestling that almost always ended up with grunts and moans,
communicating brotherly love in the special language that only identical twins knew.

Will you ever get away from that GODDAMN COMPUTER? his wife screeched. She was blitzed.
Again. He looked at the clock above the television. It was only 10:30 in the morning. Christ.
He looked at her sideways, avoiding eye contact. She was wearing a long Army surplus winter coat,
so he couldnt tell if she lost another skirt last night. In her right hand she held a nearly empty fifth
of bourbon. Always with the bourbon. She had apparently lost her right shoe. The left one, a
utilitarian tan orthopedic number, had something wrapped around the ankle, hanging to the floor.
Pink granny panties. Sexy.
Blast you, woman! he grumbled. Ill do the writing. You do the drinking. Understood?
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 8
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
She responded with a derisive laugh and a healthy, wet fart. He hoped it was a fart, anyway.
Sometimes he couldnt be sure if he was hearing the right orifice. The awards on the trophy shelf
rattled and for a moment Bill feared some might fall from the cheap particle-board shelf his son
gave him on his fiftieth birthday. Some great milestone day that was. He wonders when the last time
Peter even thought about him was.
Gail slammed the door and shambled back to the bedroom like a flatulent zombie. She would
probably pass out without getting undressed. He hoped she didnt piss the bed again and force
another costly trip to Goodwill. He desperately wished this shitty little shack had a second bedroom
he could move into. But no, they couldnt afford more than this single-wide on his paltry disability
payments and government pension.

For no particular reason, he thought of Bobber again. And Brett. And Neal. Brett and Neal. And
Bob. Neal and Bob. Neal and Bob
When he looked up at the clock again, twenty minutes had passed. How had that happened? He
pulled his finger out of his mouth again. He couldnt remember putting it in. Dementia? It was all
pruned up. There was no mayonnaise.

Will you PLEASE shut the HELL up about your IMAGINARY FRIENDS!! Im trying to sleep
back here! Gail had stuck her freakishly large head out into the hall. Bill realized hed been talking
to the Horsemen out loud again. It must be the Parkinsons, because he KNEW he wasnt crazy. The
Horsemen would take care of anyone who said so.
Shut up, you besotted trollop. And if you leak on my bed again, I swear Ill
Youll what? Chase me down in your little rolly chair and beat me up? Id like to see you try!
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Cackling, Gail slammed the bedroom door. Bill looked with fresh worry at his trophy shelf. What
would he do if his legacy were destroyed?

Behind him, he heard the bedroom door open. He turned and saw Gail, still in her coat, shuffling
quickly into the bathroom. Bluuuuuh His wife hurled eighteen hours worth of bourbon, pork
rinds and something else into the big white confessional. The aroma, mixed with the stale urine and
feet, nearly drove Bill to retch onto his only remaining link to the outside world the broken down
laptop on the card table. Instead he spun quickly to his left and managed to hit the waste basket with
the sick. He looked up and saw his wife on the way back to the bedroom. She looked at him with
contempt. She used to be pretty, but the bitterness of being with Bill had turned her hard, like
petrified wood.
Grady. He will pay for Hoges crimes. I know Grady, the sociopath, knows more about the nefarious evil
of Hoge than he lets on. If I squeeze that zit, it will pop. Bill realized, too late, that he just squeezed a
zit on his own forehead. He looked at his fingers. Pus clung to his finger and thumb like mayonnaise.
Mmmmmayonnaise. Smooth and creamy and gooey.
For no particular reason, he thought of Bobber. His finger slipped into his mouth again. He barely
noticed the taste of pus. He was remembering a pleasantly vile yet familiar smell from his childhood.
But why was it mixed with pork rinds and bourbon? And feet?

WILL YOU SHUT YOUR GODDAMN CHOMP HOLE?!?!? roared the voice of his wife from
behind the bedroom door.
Im not crazy, Bill repeated. He opened the refrigerator, reached for the open jar of mayonnaise.
The smell nearly knocked him from his chair. He rolled to the curtained off cubby they called a
pantry and found no fresh jar.
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
WELL, FUUUUUCK ME, he shrieked. YOU FORGOT THE MAYONNAISE AGAIN, YOU
BLEEDING WITCH!
Not tonight, his wife slurred from the other end of the house.
He glared with baleful contempt in his eyes at the last of only three women he had ever
touched, none of whom would ever touch him again.
For no particular reason, he thought about his twin brother once more.
He rolled back to the computer, hungry now for the lost days when he and Bobber would sit on the
floor together, sucking down footlongs with mayonnaise. He typed a Paragraph about Hoge. The
writing was nothing to write home over, but it was relatively benign. He typed a few more words,
adding a little spice to the post. Fifteen minutes later, he came up for air having blown seventy-five
words into over five hundred words of spit, bile and projectile vomit onto the page. A wave of fresh
hate washed over him, and he clenched his whole body to absorb its full power.
He hit the POST button, and felt that old familiar sensation of a job well done.
DAMN IT STRAIGHT TO JESUS! he hollered as the fresh, deep, earthy stench hit him, and he
realized he would have to wake Gail to change his Depends again.
43- "f /efendant =ad @een allowed access to t=e comment section on
Plaintiffs @lo45 muc= of t=is could =a,e @een a,oided- <ut Plaintiff onl; allows
people w=o a4ree wit= =im to post on =is @lo45 ma>in4 it necessar; for t=e /efendant
use Plaintiffs @lo4 posts on 0witter or on a @lo4 entr; to pro,e t=e trut=fulness of
w=at =e was sa;in4-
44- Plaintiff =ad a Peace &rder in place a4ainst /efendant for one ;ear5 not
allowin4 /efendant to contact =im and as> =is permission to use t=e material-
45- "n e,er; instance cited @; Plaintiff5 t=e material used was used under
t=e .air 6se /octrine of 6) Cop;ri4=t #aw5 w=ic= sets out four factors to @e
considered in determinin4 w=et=er not a particular use is fair2
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 11
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
a- The .+r.ose (n) /h(r(/ter of the +se, in/0+)in, 1hether s+/h +se is of
/o22er/i(0 n(t+re or is for non.rofit e)+/(tion(0 .+r.oses. &ne sentence from t=e
Plaintiffs @lo4 was used in a @oo> t=at remains offline after Plaintiffs /$CA
ta>edown- A lar4er portion was used in a su@seDuent @oo>5 =owe,er Plaintiff claims =e
purc=ased t=e 7ri4=ts9 to t=e anon;mous @lo4 entr; se,en da;s after t=e @oo> was
pu@lis=ed- )ince t=e @oo> was remo,ed t=e same da; =e claimed 7owners=ip59 =e cannot
claim dama4es- 0=e @lo4 and 0witter entries =e ta4s as 7infrin4in49 are clearl; under
t=e .air 6se /octrine as not once did Plaintiff e,er file a /$CA ta>edown reDuest wit=
/efendants "nternet )er,ice Pro,ider or wit= 0witter-
@- The n(t+re of the /o.3ri,hte) 1or4. "n practicall; e,er; instance5 t=e
cop;ri4=ted wor> was used to illustrate a point /efendant was ma>in4 a@out t=e
=arassment =e =as suffered at t=e =ands of Plaintiff since .e@ruar; 2135 w=ic= will
@e detailed in t=e @elow permissi,e counterclaim-
c- The (2o+nt (n) s+5st(nti(0it3 of the .ortion +se) in re0(tion to the
/o.3ri,hte) 1or4 (s ( 1ho0e. "s Plaintiff claimin4 eac= @lo4 post as a separate
cop;ri4=ted entit;E &r is =e claimin4 =is entire 'o4ewas=-com @lo4 as a cop;ri4=ted
entit;E "n eit=er case5 onl; as muc= as was needed @; /efendant to pro,e t=e
trut=fulness of w=at =e was claimin4 in =is @oo>s5 @lo4s and 0weets was used-
d- The effe/t of the +se +.on the .otenti(0 2(r4et for, or v(0+e of, the
/o.3ri,hte) 1or4- (o one to /efendants >nowled4e =as stopped readin4 Plaintiffs @lo4
due to /efendants fair use of material from Plaintiffs @lo4- "f an;t=in45 @;
pro,idin4 t=e @lo4 wit= additional eCposure5 /efendant =as increased t=e ,alue to
Plaintiff of =is @lo4-
COUNTERCLAIM A#AINST WILLIAM !ON !OSE" O#E III
46- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
47- Counterclaim Plaintiff )c=malfeldt :)c=malfeldt1 @rin4s t=is permissi,e
counterclaim a4ainst Counterclaim /efendant 'o4e :'o4e1 in accordance wit= 3ule 13 of
t=e .ederal 3ules of Ci,il Procedure-
48- 0=is Court =as Burisdiction o,er t=is action pursuant to 28 6)C A 1331
:federal Duestion1-
49- $r- )c=malfeldt is a retired 4o,ernment emplo;ee w=o =as suffered from
Par>insons disease for 14 ;ears since @ein4 dia4nosed in 2- 'e rarel; lea,es =is
=ome due to t=e increased difficult; =e =as wit= mo,ement5 wal>in4 and @alance- 'e
resides wit= =is wife5 +ail5 and >eeps =imself @us; wit= @lo44in4 and operatin4 an
online "nternet radio station pla;in4 music from t=e 192s and 193s-
5- $r- 'o4e runs a @lo4 for t=e entertainment of =is readers- "t is called
7'o4ewas=-com-9 0=e @lo4 consists of dail; 7Pin>; and t=e <rain9 references5 attac>s
on <rett 8im@erlin of <et=esda5 $ar;land :w=o is currentl; suin4 'o4e amon4 se,eral
ot=er defendants in state and federal court on a ,ariet; of torts related to
=arassment and 3-"-C-&- ,iolations1 and attac>s on me5 in w=ic= =e encoura4es =is
readers=ip to Boin in-
51- 'o4e =as wor>ed wit= ot=ers o,er time to totall; destro; )c=malfeldts
online reputation @; pu@lis=in4 lies a@out )c=malfeldts pre,ious wor> as an
in,esti4ati,e reporter :freelance1 and paintin4 =im as an 7o@sessi,e stal>er9-
52- 'o4e rarel; refers to )c=malfeldt wit=out mentionin4 =im as 7adBudicated
c;@er stal>er-9 0=is is a result of 'o4es successful acDuisition of a peace order
a4ainst )c=malfeldt in %une 213-
53- 'o4e secured t=e peace order on =is t=ird attempt @; con,incin4 a Carroll
Count;5 $ar;land5 Circuit Court Bud4e t=at 7@loc>in49 )c=malfeldt on 0witter would @e
t=e same t=in4 as disa@lin4 a portion of =is "nternet functionalit; or =a,in4 to
c=an4e =is telep=one num@er to a,oid telemar>eters-
54- "n trut=5 @loc>in4 anot=er 0witter user is as simple as pus=in4 a @utton
onscreen t=at sa;s 7@loc>9 or 7@loc> and report9 t=is user-
55- (ot onl; did 'o4e refuse to @loc> )c=malfeldt5 less t=an one mont= after
o@tainin4 =is peace order5 =e attempted to follow )c=malfeldts 0witter account-
)c=malfeldt @loc>ed 'o4es attempt to follow =im-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 13
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
56- 'o4e =as displa;ed a sa,a4e5 sadistic strea> in =is =arassment of
)c=malfeldt5 includin4 t=ree =undred siCt; se,en :3671 misdemeanor criminal c=ar4es
filed a4ainst )c=malfeldt @; 'o4e in Carroll and 'oward Counties- All were ultimatel;
deemed nolle prosequi @; )tates Attorne;s-
57- 'o4e uses =is @lo4 to =arass5 defame and li@el )c=malfeldt on a dail;
@asis5 and =e encoura4es =is readers to do t=e same-
58- <; filin4 false /$CA ta>edown reDuests5 'o4e =as @loc>ed t=e pu@lication
of two self-pu@lis=ed @oo>s written @; )c=malfeldt5 t=e profits w=ic= were meant to @e
donated to t=e (ational Par>inson .oundation5 an or4ani?ation t=at wor>s toward
findin4 a cure for t=is disease-
59- <ecause of =arassment or 7trollin49 @; readers of 'o4es @lo45 encoura4ed
@; 'o4e5 t=e (ational Par>inson Association =as as>ed )c=malfeldt to disassociate
=imself from t=eir or4ani?ation-
COUNTERCLAIM A#AINST CRIS S. EATER
6- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
61- Counterclaim Plaintiff )c=malfeldt :)c=malfeldt1 @rin4s t=is permissi,e
counterclaim a4ainst Counterclaim /efendant 'eat=er :'eat=er1 in accordance wit= 3ule
13 of t=e .ederal 3ules of Ci,il Procedure-
62- 0=is Court =as Burisdiction o,er t=is action pursuant to 28 6)C A 1332
:di,ersit; of citi?ens=ip1-
63- &n fait= and information5 )c=malfeldt @elie,es 'eat=er to @e unemplo;ed
and li,in4 wit= =is mot=er in 3acine5 !isconsin-
64- )c=malfeldt =as positi,el; identified 'eat=er as t=e 0witter entit; >nown
as 7F*m@r;riddlealum9 :*3A1- 'e also comments on counterclaim defendant 'o4es @lo4 @;
t=at name5 as well as 7'oward *arl-9
65- )c=malfeldt identified 'eat=er as *3A w=en =e saw on t=e !isconsin Court
);stem Case )earc= :=ttp2GGwww-wicourts-4o,Gcasesearc=-=tm1 t=at C=ris 'eat=er =ad
filed a domestic a@use case a4ainst a woman in 1995- )c=malfeldt contacted *3A ,ia
0witter and as>ed if it was true t=at =e 4ot 7@eat up @; a 4irl-9 *3A denied it-
)c=malfeldt told *3A t=at =e =ad spo>en to t=e woman- *3A replied5 7)o5 ;ou can tal>
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 14
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
to 4=osts nowE9 )c=malfeldt ne,er mentioned t=e womans name to *3A- 0=e woman 'eat=er
filed a domestic a@use case a4ainst in 1995 died in Hir4inia in 211- 'eat=erG*3A =ad
no answer for t=is-
66- 'eat=er =as @een flamin4 and trollin4 )c=malfeldt in one anon;mous form
or anot=er since 211-
COUNTERCLAIM A#AINST ANONYMOUS &LO##ER 6"AUL 'RENDLER7
67- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
68- Counterclaim Plaintiff )c=malfeldt :)c=malfeldt1 @rin4s t=is permissi,e
counterclaim a4ainst Counterclaim /efendant Anon;mous <lo44er 7Paul 8rendler9
:78rendler91 in accordance wit= 3ule 13 of t=e .ederal 3ules of Ci,il Procedure-
69- 0=is Court =as Burisdiction o,er t=is action pursuant to 28 6)C A 1332
:di,ersit; of citi?ens=ip1-
7- 78rendler9 is t=e 7aut=or9 of a @lo4 called 70=e 0=in>in4 $ans Iom@ie9
w=ic= can @e seen at =ttp2GGt=in>in4mans?om@ie-wordpress-comG
71- 7Paul 8rendler9 was t=e c=aracter name of actor 3a; #iota in t=e mo,ie
7'anni@al-9 0=e =eader p=oto on t=e @lo4 s=ows a cop;ri4=ted ima4e of 3a; #iota in
t=at mo,ie @ein4 fed a piece of =is own @rain @; 'anni@al #ecter-
72- 78rendlers9 @lo4 seems to @e little more t=an an attempt to parod;
andGor 7satiri?e9 t=e writin4s of )c=malfeldt-
73- 78rendler9 is t=e anon;mous person from w=om 'o4e claims to =a,e
purc=ased t=e portion of t=e @lo4 t=at 'o4e claims )c=malfeldt infrin4ed on =is
cop;ri4=t @; pu@lis=in4 in =is @oo> Intentional Infliction.
74- &n se,eral attempts @; )c=malfeldt5 78rendler9 refused to re,eal =is
actual identit;-
FIRST CLAIM FOR RELIEF
M(0i/io+s "rose/+tion (n) A5+se of "ro/ess
75- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 15
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
76- 'o4e inserted =imself into an on4oin4 contro,ers; @etween )c=malfeldt and
se,eral ot=er ri4=t win4 eCtremist @lo44ers after two of t=ese @lo44ers filed
=arassment c=ar4es a4ainst )c=malfeldt in 'oward Count;- All t=ese c=ar4es were
dismissed-
77- 'o4e claimed5 under oat=5 t=at t=e words 7<eware t=e "des of $arc=9
uttered @; )c=malfeldt durin4 a <lo4 0al> 3adio )=ow on or a@out .e@ruar; 135 2135
constituted a deat= t=reat aimed at =im-
78- After @ein4 turned awa; from t=e 'oward Count; Court Commissioner5 'o4e
filed =is first t=ree criminal c=ar4es a4ainst )c=malfeldt in Carroll Count; /istrict
Court on .e@ruar; 155 213- 'e alle4ed =arassment5 electronic mail =arassment and a
c=ar4e of unaut=ori?ed access to a computer5 sa;in4 )c=malfeldt =ad some=ow
commandeered a computer "P address in 8ansas Cit;5 $&5 usin4 it to send t=reatenin4
messa4es to 'o4e from t=at address- 0=ese c=ar4es were dismissed on April 175 213-
79- &n .e@ruar; 215 2135 'o4e too> =is first s=ot at 4ettin4 a peace order
a4ainst )c=malfeldt- 'e was denied in Carroll Count; /istrict Court on .e@ruar; 28
@ased on a lac> of clear and con,incin4 e,idence of pro=i@ited conduct- 'e immediatel;
appealed-
8- !=ile waitin4 on word a@out =is appeal5 'o4e reDuested a second peace
order on $arc= 185 213- 0=is was also denied on $arc= 25 for lac> of clear and
con,incin4 e,idence of =arassment-
81- Also on $arc= 255 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner t=at
)c=malfeldt =ad =arassed =im- 0=is c=ar4e was dismissed @; t=e Carroll Count; )tates
Attorne; on April 175 213-
82- !=ile a temporar; peace order was in effect5 'o4e con,inced a Carroll
Count; Court Commissioner to c=ar4e )c=malfeldt wit= ,iolatin4 t=e temporar; peace
order- 0=at c=ar4e was also dismissed on April 175 213-
83- &n %ul; 85 2135 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner to
file fi,e :51 c=ar4es alle4in4 )c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated t=e peace order =e was
e,entuall; awarded in %une- 0=ese c=ar4es were dismissed on )ept- 115 213-
84- &n Au4ust 55 2135 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner to
file t=ree :31 c=ar4es alle4in4 )c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated t=e peace order- 0=ese
c=ar4es were also dismissed on )ept- 115 213-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 16
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
85- &n (o,em@er 85 2135 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner
to file a sin4le c=ar4e of electronic mail =arassment a4ainst )c=malfeldt alon4 wit=
t=irt;-siC :361 c=ar4es alle4in4 )c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated t=e peace order- 0=e c=ar4es
were dismissed on %anuar; 295 214-
86- &n (o,em@er 125 2135 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner
to file one =undred ninet;-ei4=t :1981 c=ar4es alle4in4 t=at )c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated
t=e peace order- An arrest warrant was issued for )c=malfeldt5 =owe,er w=en
)c=malfeldt was contacted @; a deput; wit= t=e Carroll Count; )=eriffs /epartment and
learned w=at was @e=ind 'o4es c=ar4es5 t=e warrant was rescinded and a summons was
issued- 0=ese c=ar4es were dismissed on %anuar; 295 214-
87- &n (o,em@er 155 2135 'o4e con,inced a Carroll Count; Court Commissioner
to first file ei4=t;-ei4=t :881 and t=en an additional twent;-nine :291 c=ar4es t=at
)c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated t=e peace order- 0=ese were also dismissed on %anuar; 295
214-
88- &n /ecem@er 95 2135 'o4e sou4=t and recei,ed a siC mont= eCtension of
t=e ori4inal peace order-
89- &n April 15 2145 apparentl; =a,in4 worn out =is welcome in =is =ome
count;5 'o4e con,inced a 'oward Count; Court Commissioner to file a c=ar4e alle4in4
)c=malfeldt =ad ,iolated t=e peace order- 0=e c=ar4e was dismissed on April 15-
9- 'o4e is well aware of )c=malfeldts deterioratin4 =ealt=5 and is also
aware t=at it is a pro,en medical fact t=at t=e pro4ression of Par>insons disease is
eCacer@ated @; unnecessar; stress-
91- &n $a; 25 2145 feelin4 t=at law enforcement =ad no mec=anism in place
to protect a disa@led adult from t=e same >ind of c;@er@ull;in4 t=at t=e; protect
teena4ers from5 )c=malfeldt filed suit in t=e 6) /istrict Court for t=e /istrict of
$ar;land alle4in4 se,eral torts5 suc= as =arassment5 stal>in4 and a@use of process-
92- &n $a; 215 after a ,isit wit= =is neurolo4ist5 /r- )tep=en +rill of
*l>rid4e5 $ar;land5 )c=malfeldt too> =is doctors ad,ice and mo,ed to wit=draw =is
lawsuit from t=e 6) /istrict Court for t=e /istrict of $ar;land- 0=e case was
ultimatel; closed on $a; 29-
93- &n $a; 215 )c=malfeldt @lo44ed t=at =e =ad pulled =is lawsuit after =is
doctor warned =im t=at t=e stress @rou4=t on @; suc= a lawsuit mi4=t result in =is
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 17
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
premature deat=- 7"s it reall; wort= ris>in4 ;our life to 4et re,en4e on t=is 4u;59
/r- +rill alle4edl; told )c=malfeldt-
94- After commentin4 on =is @lo4 t=at =e was aware )c=malfeldt =ad wit=drawn
=is lawsuit5 'o4e filed t=e instant suit >nowin4 full well t=at =e was drawin4
)c=malfeldt into a lawsuit t=at could well end =is life due to t=e eCacer@ation of =is
Par>insons disease caused @; stress-
95- 'o4es constant return to t=e 7well of Bustice9 onl; to @e denied 367
times and =is l;in4 a@out t=e 7difficult;9 of @loc>in4 )c=malfeldt on 0witter5 t=en
4ettin4 a peace order eCtended for an additional siC mont=s can onl; @e seen in t=e
li4=t of an o@sessed person5 a@usin4 t=e le4al process for no ot=er reason t=an to
maliciousl; prosecute )c=malfeldt-
SECOND CLAIM FOR RELIEF
Def(2(tion (n) Li5e0
96- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
97- <efore runnin4 afoul of 'o4e5 $r- )c=malfeldt enBo;ed a sterlin4
reputation as a writer and reporter- A +oo4le searc= of =is name would =a,e re,ealed
lin>s tellin4 of t=e @oo>s =es written a@out =is ,oluntar; participation in a
clinical trial at Hander@ilt 6ni,ersit; $edical Center- "n 275 )c=malfeldt @ecame
one of 15 people in t=e 6nited )tates to =a,e under4one eCperimental /eep <rain
)timulation sur4er; as part of an eCperiment to see if patients in t=e earlier sta4es
of P/ could sur,i,e t=e operation and tolerate t=e lon4-term placement of t=e
necessar; =ardware-
98- )c=malfeldt retired from =is position as a +)-13 !riterG*ditor wit= t=e
(ational "nstitutes of 'ealt= in <et=esda5 $ar;land due to t=e ad,ancement of =is
disease in 211- 'e supplemented =is income as a freelance in,esti4ati,e reporter-
99- "n $a; 2125 )c=malfeldt learned of a 4an4 of ri4=t win4 eCtremists w=o
were 4an4in4 up online to attac> an eC-con w=o was released from prison in 21 and
was doin4 =is @est to li,e an =onest life @; foundin4 a non-profit or4ani?ation to
educate ;oun4 people a@out t=eir ri4=ts as ,oters-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 18
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1- )e,eral of t=ese ri4=t win4 eCtremists too> 4reat eCception to
)c=malfeldts writin4 a@out t=is case and @e4an to attac> =im personall;- 'e drew t=e
attention of 'o4e in )eptem@er f 212-
11- )ince t=at time5 especiall; since @ein4 awarded =is peace order5 'o4e =as
seemed sadisticall; o@sessed wit= )c=malfeldt5 wit= o,er 15 @lo4 posts mentionin4
=im @; name in t=e title-
12- &n %une 25 2145 'o4e directl; li@eled )c=malfeldt @; referrin4 to =im as
7someone willin4 to steal intellectual propert;J9 on t=e we@site of a 'o4e supporter
w=o =ad Bust @anned )c=malfeldt from defendin4 =imself in t=e comment section of t=e
@lo4- As )c=malfeldt maintains t=at t=e use of t=e intellectual propert; in Duestion
was .air 6se9 under 6) Cop;ri4=t law5 it is false5 defamator; and li@elous to paint
)c=malfeldt as a t=ief- =ttp2GG@lu@@ersues@lo44ers-comG;es-it-alwa;s-comes-@ac>-to-
free-speec=G
13- 'eat=er would rise from "nternet dormanc; from time to time to =url an
insult at )c=malfeldt and t=en ,anis= a4ain- !=en 'eat=er saw t=at )c=malfeldt was
en4a4ed in a contro,ers; wit= t=e ri4=t win4 eCtremists5 =e returned full time5 first
as F+untotin4tea@a45 until )c=malfeldt eCposed t=at identit;- 'e resurfaced as
7*m@r;riddlealum9 s=ortl; t=ereafter-
14- A current +oo4le searc= of )c=malfeldt will find =im defined @; 'o4e and
=is ri4=t win4 eCtremist friends as 7adBudicated c;@erstal>er59 a 7deran4ed
c;@erstal>er5 friend of pedop=iles5 and =arasser of c=ildren wit= an anal rape
fetis=-9 (one of it is true5 @ut t=e t=eme is continued on a dail; @asis @; 'o4e
t=rou4= =is @lo4s and t=e comments of =is readers- <ot= 'o4e and 'eat=er =a,e
contri@uted to t=is mountain of li@el-
15- <; pu@lis=in4 information identif;in4 )c=malfeldt usin4 t=e a@o,e-
mentioned false and defamator; slurs on t=eir @lo4s5 @lo4 comments and 0witter
accounts5 t=e counterclaim defendants =a,e irrepara@l; dama4ed t=e counterclaim
plaintiffs reputation5 earnin4 capacit;5 destro;ed =is le4ac;5 alienated =is friends5
and caused companies t=at )c=malfeldt =ad done @usiness wit= in t=e past to cease
association wit= =im-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 19
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
16- 78rendler9 is t=e person w=o wrote t=e defamator;5 o@scene5 li@elous and
dis4ustin4 filt= outlined in para4rap= 34- Alt=ou4= truncated for t=e sa>e of space5
t=e entire @lo4 entr; can @e read at =ttp2GGt=in>in4mans?om@ie-wordpress-comG
17- 78rendler9 continues to defame and li@el )c=malfeldt @; writin4 items
pre,iousl; @lo44ed @; )c=malfeldt5 strate4icall; c=an4in4 words to ma>e )c=malfeldt
appear @uffoonis=5 depra,ed and criminal-
18- 0=e actions of all t=ree counterclaim defendants can @e seen in no ot=er
li4=t t=an to @e a conspirac; @etween ri4=t win4 eCtremists to li@el5 defame5 and
destro; t=e reputation of someone t=e; percei,ed as a political enem;-
TIRD CLAIM FOR RELIEF
(r(ss2ent (n) Intention(0 Inf0i/tion of E2otion(0 Distress
19- All Para4rap=s a@o,e are incorporated @; reference-
11- &ne mi4=t t=in> after =is first 5 or so criminal c=ar4es a4ainst
)c=malfeldt were dismissed5 'o4e mi4=t =a,e 4otten t=e idea t=at =e wasnt 4oin4 to
successfull; put )c=malfeldt in Bail- "t seems5 instead5 =e decided to eit=er render
=im totall; disa@led or dead due to t=e eCacer@ation of =is Par>insons disease caused
@; t=e stress of 367 criminal c=ar4es-
111- )c=malfeldt alle4es 'o4es main reason for filin4 t=ese criminal c=ar4es5
ori4inall; intended to protect people from non-famil; mem@ers w=o sou4=t to do t=em
=arm5 was to =arass and intimidate )c=malfeldt5 to inflict emotional distress and
=asten =is deat= due to Par>insons disease-
112- 'o4es attempt to follow )c=malfeldts 0witter account less t=an a mont=
after recei,in4 =is peace order was a clear attempt to =arass )c=malfeldt and 4oad =im
into ,iolatin4 t=e peace order-
113- 'is 15-plus posts a@out t=e e,il of <ill )c=malfeldt are clearl; meant
to inspire =is followers into =atin4 )c=malfeldt5 and one read of t=e 'o4ewas= @lo4 in
t=e comments section s=ows t=e ,irulent =atred 'o4es supporters =a,e for )c=malfeldt-
114- 'is filin4 of a cop;ri4=t suit two da;s after @ein4 informed t=at
)c=malfeldts neurolo4ist as>ed )c=malfeldt to wit=draw =is own lawsuit out of fear
t=at )c=malfeldt would not sur,i,e a protracted suit s=ows a le,el of rec>less
endan4erment and disre4ard for life one would find in a sadist-
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
115- (o@od; can =old a candle to 'eat=er w=en it comes to online sadism- As
far @ac> as 2115 =e would send .ace@oo> messa4es to )c=malfeldt wit= a picture of a
man wit= a 4un to =is =ead and t=e caption5 70=e Cure for Par>insons /isease-9 $an;
times in =is postin4 and 0weetin45 'eat=er =as adBured )c=malfeldt to 70a>e t=e Cure5
)=a>e;K9 'eat=er =as 0weeted a ,ariet; of ,iolent ima4es to )c=malfeldt of people
@lowin4 t=eir =eads off wit= t=e same 70a>e t=e Cure9 messa4e-
116- &n fait= and information5 )c=malfeldt @elie,es 'eat=er to @e t=e
anon;mous e-mailer 7P*$ason549 w=o at one time was a re4ular commenter on 'o4es @lo4-
7P*$ason549 sent direct e-mails to )c=malfeldt t=reatenin4 to murder =is do4s5 and to
rape =is wife in front of =im-
117- 'eat=er 4a,e awa; =is identit; as P*$ason54 w=en =e posted t=e followin4
in a @lo4 forum on %une 12
Please send me a copy of the peace order. My email is
PEMason54@gailspussytasteslikepenicillinyeastandtuna.edu Thanks, Shakey.
118- 'eat=er =as sent man; suc= messa4es to m; e-mail and t=rou4= comments to
m; @lo4 w=ere =is e-mail return address offers a Duer; re4ardin4 t=e 7taste9 of m;
wifes pri,ates-
119- 0=e depictions of )c=malfeldts wife as written @; 78rendler9 caused =er
4reat emotional distur@ance and made )c=malfeldt ,er; an4r;5 addin4 to =is stress5
furt=erin4 t=e eCacer@ation of =is Par>insons disease-
12- 78rendlers9 refusal to pro,e =e 7sold9 t=e 7world @oo> and e-@oo>
ri4=ts9 to t=at portion of =is @lo4 is a source of pro,ocation5 desi4ned to an4er
)c=malfeldt and cause =im emotional distress-
121- 0=e actions of all t=ree counterclaim defendants can @e seen in no ot=er
li4=t t=an a conspirac; of ri4=t win4 eCtremists to cause as muc= emotional dama4e to
)c=malfeldt as t=e; could-
IN!URY
122- As a direct and proCimate result of 'o4es5 'eat=ers and 78rendlers9
willful5 >nowin4 and intentional acts as set a@o,e5 )c=malfeldt suffered permanent
inBur; to =is reputation5 to =is =ealt=5 to =is a@ilit; to earn income5 and an
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 21
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
irre,ersi@le increase in t=e pro4ression of =is Par>insons disease- 'a,in4 to spend
countless =ours5 da;s5 wee>s and mont=s defendin4 a4ainst t=e false narrati,es5
worr;in4 a@out t=e 367 criminal c=ar4es5 w=ic= of 'o4es followers would send t=e neCt
profane e-mail to @e seen @; )c=malfeldts wife5 w=et=er or not 'eat=er would cross
t=e line from "nternet stal>er to personal t=reat5 t=e emotional =arassment caused @;
deat= t=reats ,ia e-mail5 0witter and @lo4 comments5 t=e amount of dama4e done @;
78rendler95 'eat=er and 'o4e5 w=o dares to sue )c=malfeldt for L695 for tellin4
t=e world w=at a sadistic =arasser 'o4e is5 =as resulted in permanent5 irre,ersi@le
dama4e t=at can not @e properl; measured-
"UNITI%E DAMA#ES
123- 0=e actions of Counterclaim /efendants 'o4e5 'eat=er and 78rendler9 as
set fort= in t=is counterclaim demonstrate a remar>a@le5 un@elie,a@le and nearl;
incompre=ensi@le amount of malice a4ainst someone onl; 'o4e =as e,er met5 someone
'eat=er and 78rendler9 >now @; name onl;5 a person t=e; =a,e no le4itimate Duarrel
wit=- 0=e e4re4ious conduct5 insult and per,erse 4ratification and 4lee seen in
'o4es5 78rendlers9 and 'eat=ers writin4 a@out )c=malfeldt5 cele@ratin4 eac=
percei,ed ,ictor; and eac= new decline in )c=malfeldts =ealt=5 t=e causin4 of
irre,ersi@le dama4e to =is =ealt= and reputation5 reDuires t=e most se,ere punis=ment
t=is court can deli,er- Accordin4l;5 )c=malfeldt reDuests an award of puniti,e dama4es
@e;ond and in eCcess of t=ose dama4es necessar; to compensate =im for t=e remo,al of
=is @oo>s from t=e mar>et place and t=e irre,ersi@le5 permanent dama4e done to =is
=ealt= and reputation-
"RAYER FOR RELIEF
!=erefore5 Plaintiff reDuests t=e followin4 relief from eac= counterclaim defendant2
M Compensator; /ama4es and conseDuential dama4es of L155N
M Puniti,e dama4es as t=e Court ma; determine applica@le to punis=N 'o4es
78rendlers9 and 'eat=ers repre=ensi@le and a@=orrent conduct to pre,ent
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 22
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
furt=er occurrence of t=is @e=a,ior and to dissuade ot=ers from doin4 t=e
sameN
M An order permanentl; enBoinin4 'o4e5 78rendler9 and 'eat=er from en4a4in4
in an; contact w=atsoe,er wit= )c=malfeldtN
M An order reDuirin4 'o4e 78rendler9 and 'eat=er to apolo4i?e to
)c=malfeldt on t=eir @lo4s5 0witter accounts5 .ace@oo> accounts @lo45 and
to remo,e e,er; instance of =is mentionin4 of )c=malfeldt @; name5
nic>name or inference from =is @lo4N
M An order reDuirin4 'eat=er and 78rendler9 to re,eal all of t=eir ,arious
.ace@oo> and 0witter 7soc> puppet9 accountsN
M An order for@iddin4 'o4es5 78rendlers9 and 'eat=ers access to social
media for one ;earN
M .or eDuita@le relief as appropriate pursuant to applica@le law5 includin4
@ut not limited to issuin4 a permanent inBunction t=at @ars 'o4e5
78rendler9 or 'eat=er from retaliatin4 a4ainst )c=malfeldt5 =is famil;5
=is friends or an;one else as punis=ment for )c=malfeldt filin4 t=is
counterclaimN
M Costs and fees incurred in t=e prosecution of t=is counterclaimN and
M An; furt=er relief as t=is Court deems Bust and appropriate-
!URY DEMAND
/efendant and Counterclaimin4 Plaintiff )c=malfeldt =ere@; demands a Bur; trial
of all issues in t=is action tria@le as of ri4=t @; a Bur;-
3espectfull; )u@mitted5
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and Counterclaims - 23
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
%une 35 214
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
!illiam $- )c=malfeldt5 Pro )e
6636 !as=in4ton <l,d-5 #ot 71
*l>rid4e5 $/ 2175
@sc=malfeldtFcomcast-net
41-26-9637
CERTIFICATE OF SER%ICE
" =ere@; certif; t=at a cop; of t=e fore4oin4 Answer and Counterclaim was
mailed t=is 3rd da; of %une5 2145 to !illiam %o=n %osep= 'o4e """5 Pro )e5 at 2
3id4e 3oad5 !estminster5 $ar;land 21157 and C=ris )- 'eat=er at 283 Arlin4ton A,e-5
6pper5 3acine5 !isconsin 5343-