2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
Solutions of Selected Problems in Chapter 4 - The Time Value of Money (Part 2) Prepping for Exams 1. b. 2. b. 3. d. 4. a. 5. b. 6. a. 7. d. 8. c. 9. a. 10. b. Problems 1. Different Cash Flow. Given the following cash inflow at the end of each year, what is the future value of this cash flow at 6%, 9%, and 15% interest rates at the end of the seventh year? Year 1 $15,000 Year 2 $20,000 Year 3 $30,000 Years 4 through 6 $0 Year 7 $150,000 ANSWER FV at 6% = $15,000 1.06 6 = $15,000 1.4185 = $21,277.79 + $20,000 1.06 5 = $20,000 1.3382 = $26,764.51 + $30,000 1.06 4 = $30,000 1.2625 = $37,874.31 + $150,000 1.06 0 = $15,000 1.0000 = $150,000.00 FV = $21,277.79 + $26,764.51 + $37,874.31 + $150,000.00 = $235,916.61 FV at 9% = $15,000 1.09 6 = $15,000 1.6771 = $25,156.50 + $20,000 1.09 5 = $20,000 1.5386 = $30,772.48 + $30,000 1.09 4 = $30,000 1.4116 = $42,347.45 + $150,000 1.09 0 = $15,000 1.0000 = $150,000.00 FV = $25,156.50 + $30,772.48 + $42,347.45 + $150,000.00 = $248,276.43 FV at 15% = $15,000 1.15 6 = $15,000 2.3131 = $34,695.91 + $20,000 1.15 5 = $20,000 2.0114 = $40,227.14 + $30,000 1.15 4 = $30,000 1.7490 = $52,470.19 Chapter 4 The Time Value of Money (Part 2) 77 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall + $150,000 1.15 0 = $15,000 1.0000 = $150,000.00 FV = $34,695.91 + $40,227.14 + $52,470.19 + $150,000.00 = $277,393.24
3. Future value. A speculator has purchased land along the southern Oregon coast. He has taken out a ten-year loan with annual payments of $7,200. The loan rate is 6%. At the end of ten years, he believes that he can sell the land for $100,000. If he is right on the future price, did he make a wise investment? ANSWER To solve this problem, we must calculate the rate of return earned on an annual investment of $7,200 over a 10-year period, with a future value of $100,000 and compare it with the interest rate paid on the loan. If the rate earned is higher, then the investment would be worth it. FV = $100,000; PMT = -$7,200; n = 10; PV = 0; CPT I% = 7.11% > 6%; Good Investment 5. Future value: You are a new employee with the Metropolis Daily Planet. The Planet offers three different retirement plans for you to choose from. Plan 1 starts the first day of work and puts $1,000 away in your retirement account at the end of every year for forty years. Plan 2 starts after ten years and puts away $2,000 every year for thirty years. Plan 3 starts after twenty years and puts away $4,000 every year for the last twenty years of employment. All three plans guarantee an annual growth rate of 8%. a. Which plan should you choose if you plan to work at the Planet for forty years? b. Which plan should you choose if you only plan to work at the Planet for the next thirty years? c. Which plan should you choose if you only plan to work at the Planet for the next twenty years? d. Which plan should you choose if you only plan to work at the Planet for the next ten years? e. What do the answers in parts (a) through (d) imply about savings? ANSWER Part a: Plan One FV = $1,000 (1.08 40 -1)/0.08 = $1,000 259.0565 = $259,056.51 Part a: Plan Two FV = $2,000 (1.08 30 -1)/0.08 = $2,000 113.2832 = $226,566.42 Part a: Plan Three FV = $4,000 (1.08 20 -1)/0.08 = $4,000 45.7620 = $183,047.86 Chose Plan One Part b: Plan One FV = $1,000 (1.08 30 -1)/0.08 = $1,000 113.2832 = $113,283.21 Part b: Plan Two FV = $2,000 (1.08 20 -1)/0.08 = $2,000 45.7620 = $91,523.93 Part b: Plan Three FV = $4,000 (1.08 10 -1)/0.08 = $4,000 14.4866 = $57,946.25 78 Brooks Financial Management: Core Concepts, 2e 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall Chose Plan One Part c: Plan One FV = $1,000 (1.08 20 -1)/0.08 = $1,000 45.7620 = $45,761.96 Part c: Plan Two FV = $2,000 (1.08 10 -1)/0.08 = $2,000 14.4866 = $28,973.12 Part c: Plan Three FV = $4,000 (1.08 0 -1)/0.08 = $4,000 0.0000 = $0.00 Chose Plan One Part d: Plan One FV = $1,000 (1.08 10 -1)/0.08 = $1,000 14.4866 = $14,486.56 Part d: Plan Two FV = $2,000 (1.08 0 -1)/0.08 = $2,000 0.0000 = $0.00 Part d: Plan Three FV = $4,000 (1.08 0 -1)/0.08 = $4,000 0.0000 = $0.00 Chose Plan One Part e: The sooner you begin to save the better and that increasing the amount of savings in later years may not be sufficient to catch up to an early savings program. 7. Present value of an ordinary annuity. Fill in the missing present values in the following table for an ordinary annuity. Number of Payments or Years Annual Interest Rate Future Value Annuity Present Value 10 6% 0 $250.00 20 12% 0 $3,387.88 25 4% 0 $600.00 360 1% 0 $2,571.53
ANSWER Formula Answer (Rounded final answer to two decimal places) PV = $250.00 [1 -1/(1 + 0.06) 10 ] / 0.06 = $250.00 7.3601 = $1,840.02 PV = $3,387.88 [1 -1/(1 + 0.12) 20 ] / 0.12 = $3,387.88 7.4694 = $25,305.58 PV = $600.00 [1 -1/(1 + 0.04) 25 ] / 0.04 = $600.00 15.6221 = $9,373.25 PV = $2,571.53 [1 -1/(1 + 0.01) 360 ] / 0.01 = $2,571.53 97.2183 = $249,999.85 9. Present value. County Ranch Insurance Company wants to offer a guaranteed annuity in units of $500, payable at the end of each year for twenty-five years. The company has a strong investment record and can consistently earn 7% on its investments after taxes. If the company wants to make 1% on this contract, what price should it set on it? Use 6% as the discount rate. Assume that it is an ordinary annuity and that the price is the same as present value. Chapter 4 The Time Value of Money (Part 2) 79 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall ANSWER Formula Answer (Rounded final answer to two decimal places) PV = $500.00 ([1 -1/(1 + 0.06) 25 ] / 0.06) = $500.00 12.7834 = $6,391.68 11. Payments. Cooley Landscaping Company needs to borrow $30,000 for a new front-end dirt loader. The bank is willing to loan the funds at 8.5% interest with annual payments at the end of the year for the next ten years. What is the annual payment on this loan for Cooley Landscaping? ANSWER Payments = $30,000 / [(1 1/(1.085) 10 ) / .085] = $30,000 / 6.5613 = $4,572.23 13. Annuity due. Reginald is about to lease an apartment for the year. The landlord wants the lease payments paid at the start of the month. The twelve monthly payments are $1,300 per month. The landlord says he will allow Reginald to prepay the rent for the entire year with a discount. The one-time annual payment due at the beginning of the lease is $14,778. What is the implied monthly discount rate for the rent? If Reginald is earning 1.5% on his savings monthly, should he pay by month or take the one annual payment? ANSWER Using TVM Keys from a Texas Instrument BAII Plus Calculator and rounded to two decimal places for interest percent. The P/Y and C/Y variables are set to 12. Set the MODE to BGN as this is an annuity due problem. INPUT 12 -14,778 1,300 0 TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 12.00 This is an annual rate so with simple interest you get 12% / 12 = 1% per month. If he can get 1.5% interest per month...then his annual rate is 18% and he can generate $1,334.82 per month with the $14,778 it would take to pay off the rent. He is ahead $34.82 per month by not taking the one time payment. INPUT 12 18.0 -14,778 0 TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 1,334.82
15. Perpetuities. The Canadian Government has once again decided to issue a consol (a bond with a never-ending interest payment and no maturity date). The bond will pay $50 in interest each year (at the end of the year) but never return the principal. The current discount rate for Canadian government bonds is 6.5%. What should this bond sell for in the market? What if the interest rate should fall to 4.5%? Rise to 8.5%? Why 80 Brooks Financial Management: Core Concepts, 2e 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall does the price go up when interest rates fall? Why does the price go down when interest rates rise? ANSWER at 6.5%, $50 / 0.065 = $769.23 at 4.5%, $50 / 0.045 = $1,111.11 at 8.5%, $50 / 0.085 = $588.24 The price rises when interest rates fall because the present value of each future interest payment is worth more in present value due to the lower discount rate. The price falls when interest rates rise because the present value of each future interest payment is worth less in present value due to the higher discount rate. 17. Annuity due perpetuity. In Problem 16, The Stack agrees to the one-time payment at a 5% discount rate but wants the royalty payments figured from the beginning of the year, not the end of the year. How much more will the band receive with annuity-due payments on the royalty checks? ANSWER This is the same as before but with an additional payment at time 0 or PV = $200,000 + $200,000 / 0.05 = $4,200,000 Use the following information for Problems 18 through 21. Chuck Ponzi has talked an elderly woman into loaning him $25,000 for a new business venture. She has, however, successfully passed a finance class and requires Chuck to sign a binding contract on repayment of the $25,000 with an annual interest rate of 10% over the next ten years. She has left the method of repayment up to him. 18. Discount loan (interest and principal at maturity). Determine the cash flow to the woman under a discount loan, in which Ponzi will have a lump-sum payment at the end of the contract. ANSWER FV = $25,000 1.10 10 = $25,000 2.593742 = $64,843.56 19. I nterest-only loan (regular interest payments each year and principal at end). Determine the cash flow to the woman under an interest-only loan, in which Ponzi will pay the annual interest expense each year and pay the principal back at the end of the contract. ANSWER Ten Annual Interest Payments are $25,000 0.10 = $2,500 Plus the principal of $25,000 for total repayment of $2,500 10 + $25,000 Chapter 4 The Time Value of Money (Part 2) 81 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall = $50,000.00 20. Fully amortized loan (annual payments for principal and interest with the same amount each year). Determine the cash flow to the woman under a fully amortized loan, in which Ponzi will make equal annual payments at the end of each year so that the final payment will completely retire the original $25,000 loan. ANSWER PMT = $25,000 / [(1 1/1.10 10 ) / 0.10] = $25,000 / 6.144567 Annual Payment = $4,068.6348 and total payment back is 10 $4,068.6348 = $40,686.35 21. Amortization schedule. Ponzi may choose to pay off the loan early if interest rates change during the next ten years. Determine the ending balance of the loan each year under the three different payment plans. ANSWER Plan One (discount loan) Year (a) Beginning Balance (a) 1.10 = (c) Annual Increase (c) Ending Balance 1 $25,000.00 $25,000.00 1.10 = $27,500.00 $27,500.00 2 $27,500.00 $27,500.00 1.10 = $30,250.00 $30,250.00 3 $30,250.00 $30,250.00 1.10 = $33,275.00 $33,275.00 4 $33,275.00 $33,275.00 1.10 = $36,602.50 $36,602.50 5 $36,602.50 $36,602.50 1.10 = $40,262.75 $40,262.75 6 $40,262.75 $40,262.75 1.10 = $44,289.025 $44,289.03 7 $44,289.03 $44,289.03 1.10 = $48,717.93 $48,717.93 8 $48,717.93 $48,717.93 1.10 = $53,589.72 $53,589.72 9 $53,589.72 $53,589.72 1.10 = $58,948.69 $58,948.69 10 $58,948.69 $58,948.69 1.10 = $64,843.56 $64,843.56 Plan Two (interest only loan) Each year the interest is paid so the ending balance is $25,000.00 which reflects the original principal. Plan Three (amortized loan) Amortization Schedule of Payments 82 Brooks Financial Management: Core Concepts, 2e 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall Annual Interest is Beginning Balance 0.10 And Principal Paid is Payment Interest Year (a) Beginning. Balance (b) Payment (a) 0.10 = (c) Interest for Year (b) (c) = (d) Principal Paid (a) (d) Ending Balance 1 $25,000.00 $4.068.63 $2,500.00 $1,568.63 $23,431.37 2 $23,431.37 $4.068.63 $2,343.14 $1,725.50 $21,705.87 3 $21,705.87 $4.068.63 $2,170.59 $1,898.05 $19,807.82 4 $19,807.82 $4.068.63 $1,980.82 $2,087.85 $17,719.97 5 $17,719.97 $4.068.63 $1,772.00 $2,296.64 $15,423.33 6 $15,423.33 $4.068.63 $1,542.33 $2,526.30 $12,897.03 7 $12,897.03 $4.068.63 $1,289.70 $2,778.93 $10,118.09 8 $10,118.09 $4.068.63 $1,011.81 $3,056.83 $7,061.27 9 $7,061.27 $4.068.63 $706.13 $3,362.51 $3,698.76 10 $3,698.76 $4.068.63 $369.88 $3,698.76 $0.00
Note that all payments, interest for year, principal paid, and ending balance are rounded to nearest cent. 23. Waiting period with an ordinary annuity. Fill in the missing waiting periods (years) or number of payments in the following table for an ordinary annuity stream. Number of Payments or Years Annual Interest Rate Future Value Annuity Present Value 6% 0 $250.00 $2,867.48 8% $5,794.62 $400.00 0 10% 0 $636.48 $6,000.00 4% $100,000.00 $80.80 0
ANSWER Formula Answer (Rounded final answer to whole periods) n = ln [$250 / ($250-$2,867.48 0.06)] / ln [1+0.06] = 1.1654 / 0.0583 = 20 n = ln [$5,794.62 0.08/$400 +1] / ln [1+0.08] = 0.7696 / 0.0770 = 10 Chapter 4 The Time Value of Money (Part 2) 83 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall n = ln [$636.48 / ($636.48-$6,000 0.10)] / ln [1+0.10] = 2.8592 / 0.0953 = 30 n = ln [$100,000 0.04/$80.80 +1] / ln [1+0.04] = 3.9221 / 0.0392 = 100 25. Number of payments. Your grandfather will sell you a beach front property for $72,500. He says the price is firm whenever you can pay him cash. You know that your finances will only allow you to save $5,000 a year and that you can make 8% on your investment. If you invest faithfully every year at the end of the year, how long will it take for you to accumulate the necessary $72,500 future cash for the beach front property? ANSWER Number of Payments = ln [($72,500 0.08 / $5,000) + 1] / ln (1.08) = ln [($5,800/$5,000) + 1] / ln (1.08) = 0.7701 / 0.0770 = 100065 10 payments or 10 years Or on the calculator INPUT ? 8.0 $0 -$5,000 $72,500 Variables N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 10.0065
27. Estimating the annual interest rate with an annuity due. Fill in the missing annual interest rates in the following table for an annuity-due stream. Number of Payments or Years Annual Interest Rate Future Value Annuity Present Value 10 0 $500.00 $3,680.04 20 $25,000.00 $346.97 0 30 0 $1,946.73 $20,000.00 100 $1,044,010.06 $400.00 0
ANSWER Using TVM Keys from a Texas Instrument BAII Plus Calculator and rounded to two decimal places for interest percent. The P/Y and C/Y variables are set to 1. The Mode is Srt to BGN for each of these solutions. INPUT 10 -3,680.04 500.00 0 TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 7.57 INPUT 20 0 -346.97 25,000 84 Brooks Financial Management: Core Concepts, 2e 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 11.09 INPUT 30 -20,000 1,946.73 0 TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 10.13 INPUT 100 0 400.00 -1,044,010.06 TVM KEYS N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 4.94
29. I nterest rate with annuity. A local government is about to run a lottery but does not want to be involved in the payoff if a winner picks an annuity payoff. The government contracts with a trust to pay the lump-sum payout to the trust and have the trust (probably a local bank) pay the annual payments. The first winner of the lottery chooses the annuity and will receive $150,000 a year for the next twenty-five years. The local government will give the trust $2,000,000 to pay for this annuity. What investment rate must the trust earn to break even on this arrangement? ANSWER Using a calculator TVM keys with P/y=1 and C/y = 1 in end mode: INPUT 25 ? $2,000,000-$150,000 $0 Variables N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 5.5619%
31. Lottery. Your dreams of becoming rich have just come true. You have won the State of Tranquilitys Lottery. The State offers you two payment plans for the $5,000,000 advertised jackpot. You can take annual payments of $250,000 for the next twenty years or $2,867,480 today. a. If your investment rate over the next twenty years is 8%, which payoff will you choose? b. If your investment rate over the next twenty years is 5%, which payoff will you choose? c. At what investment rate will the annuity stream of $250,000 be the same as the lump sum payment of $2,867,480? ANSWER Part a. Find the present value of the annuity stream at an 8% discount rate. PV = $250,000 (1 1/1.08 20 ) / 0.08 = $250,000 9.8181 = $2,454,536.85 Take the lump sum of $2,867,480. Part b. Find the present value of the annuity stream at a 5% discount rate. Chapter 4 The Time Value of Money (Part 2) 85 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall PV = $250,000 (1 1/1.05 20 ) / 0.05 = $250,000 12.4622 = $3,115,552.59 Take the annuity stream of $250,000. Part c. Find the interest rate that sets the PV of $2,867,480 equal to a twenty year annuity stream of $250,000. $2,867.480 = $250,000 (1 1/(1+R) 20 ) / R and this implies that the PVIFA is PVIFA = (1 - 1/(1+R) 20 ) / R = $2,867,480 / $250,000 = 11.4699 Looking up this value on Table A-3 for N = 20 we find the value in column 6%. Or on the calculator INPUT 20 ? $2,867,480 $250,000 $0 Variables N I/Y PV PMT FV OUTPUT 6.0 So at 6% investment rate over the next twenty years you would be indifferent between the two payoff choices.