Brokers of Justice

Brokers of Justice ?
Justice Lodha - WAKE UP

S.O.S e - Clarion Of Dalit - Weekly Newspaper On Web
Working For The Rights & Surial Of The Oppresse!
"!itor# N$%$R$&$.'.R( )O*.+ issue.,-(( .,./.0/1.-2

Frazer Town rape: Inspector arrested for
delaying FIR

Pulakeshi Nagar Inspector Mohammed Rafiq, who has been booked under section 166a of the
IPC for failing to register a rape case in angalore!s "ra#er $own, has been arrested b% &alasoor
Police on "rida%'
(ssistant Commissioner of Police )&alasoor *ub di+ision, -'' Man.unath, who is in+estigating
the case, questioned Mr' Rafiq for more than tow hours' $he Inspector was later let out on
conditional bail'
Mr' Rafiq was accused of not onl% dela%ing the filing of an "IR in the rape case but also
allegedl% tried to dilute the issue' $he +ictim brought it to the notice of the Cit% Police
Commissioner, who ordered the /urisdictional (CP to conduct an inquir% in this regard'
$he preliminar% inquir% re+ealed that Mr' Rafiq was guilt% following which he was kept under
suspension' 0n $hursda%, an "IR was filed against him in the same police station where he was
working'

DSP among six arrested on charge of deer hunting

Forest Department authorities on Friday arrested Deputy Superintendent of
Police (CID), Mysore, T.K. Dharmesh and fie others for alle!edly huntin!
do"n a spotted deer in the #m$ara forest ran!e of %andipur Ti!er &esere.
The carcass of the male deer "ith a 'ullet in(ury "as found in )a!anapura
third 'loc$ in the forest ran!e, accordin! to Forest Department sources.
They said the Forest staff sa" the accused in the forest ran!e durin! routine
patrollin! early on Friday and too$ them into their custody. They later
com'ed the area and found the deer carcass. Senior Forest officers rushed
to the spot on !ettin! the information and conducted inesti!ation.
*The deer carcass had entry and e+it 'ullet "ound. The post,mortem "as
performed and the iscera samples hae 'een presered,- the sources said.
. case under the /ildlife Protection .ct, 0123, has 'een 'oo$ed a!ainst the
accused.
The names of other accused "ere !ien as Man(aiah, &a!hu, 4anif, .ti5 and
Farid.
*. .676 serice rifle and a multi,utility ehicle used for committin! the
alle!ed offence hae 'een sei8ed from the accused,- the sources said.

accused.
Farid.

accused.
Farid.

accused.
Farid.

DACOITY by Mysore Police - An embarrassment for olice to brass

Mysore9 Southern &an!e I:P;s !unman Pra$ash has reportedly named some
senior policemen as his partners,in,crime in the &s3,crore sei8e,s"indle
scam.
Pra$ash "as thorou!hly !rilled follo"in! his arrest on Tuesday. Sources in the
police said PK :ar!, additional director !eneral of police of the CID<it 'ein!
the a!ency pro'in! the case<interro!ated Pra$ash, the !unman serin! I:P
K &amachandra &ao. Sources in the police department did not identify the
top cops Pra$ash has reportedly named.
Sources in police said that t"o mem'ers of the s5uad that raided the 'us
"ere not supposed to 'e there. /hen intercepted, the 'us "as in =ela"al
police;s (urisdiction, 'ut the police s5uad had t"o mem'ers "or$in! "ith
%annur police.
Mean"hile, su',inspector >a!adish and Sathish, "ho "ere part of the team
that raided the 'us, "ere arrested "hen they came to %an!alore to apply
for anticipatory 'ail.
D:?I:P @alro$huma Pachau has as$ed the CID to leae no stone unturned in
the inesti!ation and to !et incriminatin! eidence a!ainst eery policeman
inoled in the case, re!ardless of his ran$.
Police sources said the CID has o'tained the telephonic conersation
'et"een Pra$ash and the police informants "ho tipped him off a'out the
'us carryin! the moolah. Sources said Pra$ash, the informants and the
raidin! party e+chan!ed many a call the ni!ht the 'us "as raided and the
cash "as sei8ed.
The case
#n >anuary A, a police team led 'y su',inspector CD >a!adeesh intercepted
a Kerala,'ound priate 'us 'elon!in! to Kalpa$a traels at =el"al a'out 0.67
am, after receiin! information that a hu!e sum of money "as 'ein!
transported in it.
They reportedly found &s3.32 crore in the 'us, and too$ the drier .$thar
4ussein and cleaner Muneer into custody. The 'us "as first ta$en to =el"al
police station and later some policemen as$ed the drier to par$ the 'us on
Mysore,%ant"al 4i!h"ay.
The policemen alle!edly too$ si+ 'a!s of money $ept in the 'us and dumped
one of them containin! cash &s37 la$h in the tools 'o+ of the ehicle.
/hile the drier denied that he "as a"are of the money $ept in the tool
'o+, the FI& mentioned that he "as ille!ally carryin! cash &s37 la$h.
.fter the drier came out on 'ail, some !old merchants from Kerala accused
the police of s"indlin! their money. They claimed that the money "as
o'tained from the sale of !old in %an!alore 'y their local a!ents. They also
claimed that the money "as $ept in a secret 'o+ located in the middle of
the 'us floor and that it "as $no"n only to the drier.
The !old merchants also approached Kerala home minister &amesh
Chennithala, "ho as$ed his Karnata$a counterpart to loo$ into the matter.
:oin! 'y the eracity of the case, the D: ? I:P had transferred the
inesti!ation to the CID.
Follo"in! this, the accused policemen are on the run. Some of them hae
also applied for anticipatory 'ail. The CID has so far arrested four people,
includin! the !unman of the I:P and three police informants.
The CID sleuths hae re5uested the court to permit them to 'oo$ a dacoity
case a!ainst the accused.
In .u!ust 3773, a !roup led 'y the then assistant commissioner of police
(Traffic,Bi(ayana!ar), . %elliappa, alle!edly ro''ed the employees of a !old
merchant from Ko8hi$ode of &s01 la$h. The errant police staff posed as
customs officials and ro''ed the t"o employees, "ho "ere returnin! to
Kerala in a priate 'us. %elliyappa "as dismissed for his inolement in the
case.
In )oem'er 3707, Mico @ayout police station inspector C) >anardhan "as
suspended for irre!ularities. 4e "as char!ed "ith misusin! recoered
property. 4e had alle!edly sold 3.A $! !old , "orth &s6.AC la$h , that "as
recoered from the accused in Muthoot :old Finance theft case. 4e "as also
facin! seeral other char!es.
In >anuary this year, the police inspector of 4.@ station &a(esh and three
consta'les "ere suspended for alle!edly e+tortin! &s6 la$h from an old
offender 'y threatenin! to 'oo$ him in a false case. The errant policemen
had e+torted money from >aed, "ho had complained a'out it to DCP (South
Dast). . preliminary internal pro'e reealed that the policemen had
receied &s6 la$h and had distri'uted the money amon! themseles and
they "ere suspended later. Police are on the loo$out for &a(esh.
ETop cops em'olden (uniors in $ha$i to play it dirtyF
Despite 'ein! "arned 'y the chief minister and the home minister to not
inole in ille!al actiities, the %an!alore police personnel, time and a!ain,
are cau!ht for their misdeeds.
. retired police officer, re5uestin! anonymity, said policemen inolin! in
ille!al actiities is an old trend. *The nature of the "or$ demands ne+us
"ith people "ith criminal 'ac$!round to !ather information. Dthical
policemen use such information for professional re5uirements only, 'ut
some policemen use such information for their personal !ain. /hat is
disheartenin! is that some senior police officers, "ho hae to set an
e+ample for their (uniors, identify "ith such policemen and $eep them
close,- he said.
*The lo"er,run! policemen !et into direct contact "ith senior officers 'y
ne!lectin! hierarchy. The seniors encoura!e them to inole in ille!al
actiities and protect them "heneer they !et into trou'le. Ma$in! hu!e
money is the sole o'(ectie 'ehind this,- he stated.
*Police are e+posed to all $ind of criminal actiities o"in! to the nature of
their "or$. So, they thin$ that they can easily !et a"ay 'y committin! some
or the other offence,- another officer said.

Government asks Supreme Court collegium
to elevation of Justice ! "an#unat$

$he go+ernment is learnt to ha+e returned a file relating to the ele+ation of a 1arnataka &igh
Court .udge as the Chief /ustice of the Pun.ab and &ar%ana &igh Court to the *upreme Court
collegium with a request to reconsider its decision'
$he 2aw Ministr% is understood to ha+e returned the file relating to the ele+ation of /ustice 12
Man.unath as Chief /ustice of the Pun.ab and &ar%ana &igh Court to the *upreme Court
collegium headed b% Chief /ustice of India /ustice RM 2odha'
(s per practice, /ustice 2odha had consulted a senior *upreme Court .udge who had ser+ed in
the 1arnataka &igh Court, on the ele+ation of /ustice Man.unath'
$he senior .udge had flagged certain issues in his two3page note to the *upreme Court collegium'
$aking note of the issues raised b% the senior *upreme Court .udge, the 2aw Ministr% returned
the file to the collegium with a request to reconsider its recommendation'
(s per the Memorandum of Procedure for appointment of &igh Court .udges, the Chief /ustice
of India sends his recommendation for the appointment of a puisne .udge of the &igh Court as
Chief /ustice of &igh Court in consultation with the two senior most .udges of the *upreme
Court'
&e also ascertains the +iews of the seniormost colleague in the *upreme Court who is con+ersant
with the affairs of the &igh Court in which the recommendee has been functioning'
If the *upreme Court collegium sticks to its recommendation, the go+ernment will ha+e to
appro+e the name'
$his for the second time that the N4( go+ernment has returned to the *upreme Court collegium
file pertaining to appointment of a .udge'
Chief /ustice 2odha had e5pressed unhappiness at the go+ernment6s decision to unilaterall%
segregate the name of senior law%er -opal *ubramanium6s from three others who were
appointed to the top court'
7I fail to understand how the appointment to a high constitutional post has been dealt with in a
casual manner' $he segregation of -opal *ubramanium6s file was done unilaterall% without m%
knowledge and concurrence which was not proper,7 /ustice 2odha had said'
ut the go+ernment had defended its decision to return the recommendation of the *upreme
Court collegium sa%ing its mo+e was based on 7proper, cogent and sound7 grounds'

Supreme Court Collegium Takes on
Government on Justice ! "an#unat$%s
&ppointment

$he *upreme Court collegium has reiterated its recommendation to ele+ate 1arnataka &igh
Court .udge 12 Man.unath as Chief /ustice of Pun.ab and &ar%ana &igh Court, turning down the
Centre6s ad+ice to reconsider it, sa% sources'
$he $op Court6s decision sets the stage for another round of confrontation between the e5ecuti+e
and the .udiciar%' $he Chief /ustice of India, R M 2odha had earlier this month critici#ed the
go+ernment for dropping former *olicitor -eneral -opal *ubramanium6s name from the panel of
names suggested b% the collegium for appointment as *upreme Court .udges'
$he latest round of standoff between the two sides arose after the Centre returned the *upreme
Court collegium6s recommendation on ele+ating /ustice Man.unath, the senior3most .udge of the
1arnataka &igh Court, and sought clarification based on complaints against him from a senior
.udge of the *upreme Court'
$he *upreme Court Collegium, after e5amining the complaints, found no merit in them, and
reiterated its recommendation to shift /ustice Man.unath as Chief /ustice of the Pun.ab and
&ar%ana &igh Court, sources said'
8ith the $op Court collegium standing firm on its position, the Centre now has no option but to
appoint /ustice Man.unath as Chief /ustice of the Pun.ab and &ar%ana &igh Court'

arnataka 'C #udge faces conflict of interest
in $ousing case

( .udge of the &igh Court of 1arnataka is set to hear a case that is likel% to impact the fate of a
housing societ% plot owned b% his daughter'
(n in+estigation b% The Hindu shows that 1'M' Chaitra, daughter of /ustice 1'2' Man.unath,
was allotted the plot when she was li+ing with her father and showed his residence as her
address' $he allotment appears to put /ustice Man.unath in a position of conflict of interest as he
heads a 4i+ision ench that is hearing a public interest litigation )No' 91:6;<9;11, petition
related to allotment of housing societ% plots'
$he petitioners in this PI2 ha+e questioned a -o+ernment 0rder )-0, passed on No+ember 9;,
9;1; b% the *tate /P go+ernment' $he -0 legalises the allotment of housing societ% plots to
non3members b% admitting them into the cooperati+e societ% as associate members at the time of
sale'
4ocuments accessed b% this newspaper show that Ms' Chaitra was not a member of the
=%alika+al &ouse uilding Cooperati+e *ociet% and was made an (ssociate Member at the time
of the allotment of a >,?6; sq' ft plot at Nagawara, an upmarket area on the road to engaluru
International (irport'
$he sale deed dated "ebruar% :, 9;;? shows that the plot was sold to her for Rs' 6':9 lakh' (s on
date, the plot is estimated at Rs' 1'6@ crore A Rs' @,;;; per sq' ft' Meanwhile, hundreds of
members who .oined the housing societ% in 1B:? continue to wait for an allotment'
*ignificantl%, the allotment to Ms' Chaitra was made at a time when she sta%ed with her father'
$his is borne out b% the fact that the permanent address, mentioned in the sale deed, is that of
/ustice Man.unath' "urther, as per the list of assets declared b% the .udge, he is the owner of that
residence'
Consequentl%, the allotment appears to be in +iolation of *ection 1; )a, of the go+ernment3
framed model b%e3laws for house building cooperati+e societies, which mandates that an allottee
or her famil% should not ha+e an% other residential propert% in angaloreC the same section also
bars multiple allotments'
$he +er% rationale for cooperati+e housing societies rests on the premise that the% enable persons
who are unable to pa% market prices to afford a dwelling unit at subsidised cost' Indeed, *ection
1; )a, was in fact inserted in the b%e3laws to ensure that onl% genuine and need% persons are
allotted sites' It is for this reason that aspirants were mandatoril% required to file affida+its
declaring that the% do not own an% other residential propert% in the cit%' $his is done in order to
weed out applicants who do not demonstrate a dire need for a dwelling unit, a law%er familiar
with the rules said'
/ustice Man.unath declined to comment when The Hindu contacted him on 8ednesda% e+ening
for a response'
(sked for his legal opinion, $eam (nna member and *upreme Court law%er Prashant hushan
said, D$he Ehousing cooperati+e societ%F plot allotment scam is a huge one in 1arnataka' /ustice
Man.unath should not hear the case because of conflict of interest' (n application can be filed
asking him to recuse himself'G
$he =%alika+al &ouse uilding Cooperati+e *ociet% 2td' has been at the centre of contro+ers%
o+er the past one %ear'
$his is the same societ% that allotted a ?,;19 sq' ft plot to the wife of retired *upreme Court
.udge and former 2oka%ukta *hi+ara. Patil' 8hen the allegedl% irregular allotment was e5posed
b% two newspapers, including The Hindu in *eptember 9;11, Mr' Patil resigned as the 2oka%ukta
and returned the contro+ersial plot' Mr' Patil!s post has since been +acant' $wo other .udges,
nominated to succeed Mr' Patil, withdrew from the race after details emerged of their own
in+ol+ement with housing societ% allotments'
"ormer &igh Court .udge and Hpaloka%ukta R' -urura.an too was forced to step down after
details of societ% plots that had been allotted to him in apparent +iolation of the law were
published in the media'

!ditorial " Court #ixing not $udgement #ixing alone %

Throught this issue & term $'D(! includes all the ublic officials
functioning )udicial * +uasi )udicial functions right from munsif &
talu, magistrate to sureme court )udge- .o/adays olitical
disensations & o/ers that be are aointing unfit ersons & ersons
/ho are fa0orable to them to the osts of )udges- (o0ernment is one
of the biggest litigant in the country 1 o/ers that be misusing their
constitutional ositions are doing many acts against the letter 1 sirit
of constitution- 2hene0er aggrie0ed ersons aroach courts of
)ustice & the hand ic,ed ersons of o/ers that be in the chair of
)udge /ill gi0e fa0orable )udgements * rulings- The said )udge /ill
ma,e far fetched interretations consider outlandish arguments all
to fa0or o/ers that be - As a result common eole are being meted
out in)ustice e0en in the courts of la/ 1 ublic exche+uer is cheated
of-

'rgent need of the hour is establishment of rofessional & imartial &
transarent mechanism for aointment & romotion & transfer of
)udges-
This is the 0ery reason /e ha0e raised follo/ing +uestions in 3TI aeal
to sureme court of india 1 arliament to clearly define the /or,
ractices of it4s members- 5ut they are not ans/ering & because they
/ill be caught for /rongdoings- $ust consider the re0ious cases of
ele0ation of P D dina,aran 1 6 goala go/da-
7oe saner sense /ill re0ail on sureme court of india - $ai 7ind-
6ande mataram-

Your4s
.agara)a-M-3-

$ustice Mar,andey 8at)u9s Allegations Confirmed by !x-:a/ Minister

/hen as$ed a'out "hy he "aited for 07 years to disclose that an alle!edly
corrupt (ud!e "as allo"ed to continue in office in the Madras 4i!h Court,
>ustice Mar$andey Kat(u insisted on )DTB that the G5uestion is not "hy I did
not ma$e this disclosure earlier, the 5uestion is "hether "hat I;m sayin! is
correct or not.G
/hen the interie"er pressed for an e+planation a'out his timin!, he pulled
out his earpiece and ended the interie".
>ustice Kat(u, no" the chairman of the Press Council of India, "as in 377A,C
the Chief >ustice of the Madras 4i!h Court. 4e claims that an Intelli!ence
%ureau inesti!ation sou!ht 'y him, confirmed the char!es, 'ut that three
e+,Chief >ustices of India made Gimproper compromisesG 'y refusin! to end
the term of the (ud!e.
Their actions, he said, "ere the result of political pressure , "ithout namin!
the DMK, he said that an ally from Tamil )adu of Prime Minister Manmohan
Sin!h "arned it "ould 5uit the coalition if the (ud!e "as remoed.
The DMK has denied the alle!ations "ith senior leaders sayin! there "as no
truth in it. Party chief M Karunanidhi is e+pected to respond tomorro".
The ne" %>P !oernment said GManmohan Sin!h should clarify "hat "as
happenin! in his re!ime.G
Con!ress leader 4& %hard"a(, "ho "as the @a" Minister at the time,
confirmed that the (ud!e "as 'ac$ed 'y a lar!e !roup of MPs "ho
complained a'out >ustice Kat(u;s opposition.
G.round 0H SCIST MPs met PM Manmohan Sin!h in 377A and complained
a'out in(ustice to the accused additional (ud!e,G Mr %hard"a( told )DTB,
addin! that Gultimately, the Chief >ustice of India cleared the appointment.G
>ustice Kat(u alle!es that Chief >ustice &C @ahoti e+tended the t"o,year
tenure of the controersial (ud!e. >ustice =K Sa'har"al alle!edly !ae the
corrupt (ud!e another term despite an aderse Intelli!ence report and
>ustice K: %ala$rishnan confirmed him as permanent (ud!e 'ut transferred
him to another state.
>ustice @ahoti told )DTB, GDerythin! is a matter of record. I hae neer
done anythin! "ron! in my life.G /hile >ustice %ala$rishnan, the current
chairman of the )ational 4uman &i!hts Commission said that the (ud!e;s
confirmation "as cleared 'y the Chief >ustice of the Madras 4i!h Court, 'ut
he did "hat he could. GThere "ere alle!ations that this (ud!e "as close to
the rulin! party (the DMK) ...so I transferred him to .ndhra Pradesh,G he told
)DTB.
The accused (ud!e had reportedly !ranted 'ail to DMK chief M Karunanidhi
after his dramatic midni!ht arrest 'y the >ayalalithaa !oernment in 3770.

Some +uestions for $ustice :ahoti

>ustice @ahoti, the former Chief >ustice of India, "hen contacted 'y some
media people a'out my statement "hich "as pu'lished on my 'lo! and in
Times of India yesterday, !enerally remar$ed that he has neer done
anythin! "ron! in his life. 4e has not !one into any specifics, so let me put
him some specific 5uestions 9

0. Is it , or is it not, correct that I first "rote him a letter from Chennai,
statin! that there "ere serious alle!ations of corruption a'out an .dditional
>ud!e of Madras 4i!h Court, and therefore he ( >ustice @ahoti ) should !et a
secret intelli!ence en5uiry held a!ainst that .dditional >ud!e,and thereafter
I personally met >ustice @ahoti at Delhi and a!ain re5uested for a secret I%
en5uiry a!ainst the .dditional >ud!e a'out "hom I had receied seeral
complaints, and from seeral sources, that he "as indul!in! in corruption J

3. Is it, or is it not, correct that on my re5uest >ustice @ahoti ordered a
secret I% en5uiry a!ainst that >ud!e J

6. Is it, or is it not correct, that a fe" "ee$s after I personally met him in
Delhi and then returned to Chennai, he telephoned me from Delhi ( "hile I
"as at Chennai ) and told me that the I%, after thorou!h en5uiry, !ae a
report that indeed the >ud!e "as indul!in! in corruption J

A. Is it , or is it not, correct that after receiin! the aderse I% report
a!ainst the .dditional >ud!e, >ustice @ahoti, "ho "as then Chief >ustice of
India, called a meetin! of the 6 >ud!e Supreme Court Colle!ium, consistin!
of himself, >ustice Sa'ar"al, and >ustice &uma Pal, and the 6 >ud!e
Colle!ium, hain! perused the I% report recommended to the :oernment of
India not to e+tend the 3 year term of that .dditional >ud!e J

C. Is it , or is it not, correct that after that recommendation of the 6 >ud!e
Colle!ium of the Supreme Court "as sent to the :oernment of India, he
( >ustice @ahoti ), on his o"n, "ithout consultin! his 3 other Supreme Court
Colle!ium collea!ues, "rote a letter to the :oernment of India as$in! the
:oernment to !ie another 0 year term as .dditional >ud!e to the
concerned >ud!e J

K. If indeed the I% reported, after an en5uiry, that the >ud!e "as indul!in!
in corruption, "hy did he ( >ustice @ahoti ) recommend to the :oernment
of India to !ie that corrupt >ud!e another term of 0 year as .dditional
>ud!e in the 4i!h Court J

Some people hae commented a'out the timin! of my statement. /hat
happened "as that some Tamilians had commented on Face'oo$ that I am
postin! seeral matters on my Face'oo$ post, so I should also post some of
my e+periences in Madras 4i!h Court. Then I started postin! a'out my
e+periences there, and it "as at time I remem'ered this e+perience too,
and posted it.

7o/ a corrut $udge continued in the Madras 7igh Court
There "as an .dditional >ud!e of the Madras 4i!h Court a!ainst "hom there
"ere seeral alle!ations of corruption. 4e had 'een directly appointed as a
District >ud!e in Tamilnadu, and durin! his career as District >ud!e there
"ere as many as H aderse entries a!ainst him recorded 'y arious portfolio
>ud!es of the Madras 4i!h Court. %ut one .ctin! Chief >ustice of Madras
4i!h Court 'y a sin!le stro$e of his pen deleted all those H aderse entries,
and conse5uently he 'ecame an .dditional >ud!e of the 4i!h Court, and he
"as on that post "hen I came as Chief >ustice of Madras 4i!h Court in
)oem'er 377A.
That >ud!e had the solid support of a ery important political leader of
Tamilnadu. I "as told that this "as 'ecause "hile a District >ud!e he
!ranted 'ail to that political leader.
Since I "as !ettin! many reports a'out his corruption, I re5uested the Chief
>ustice of India, >ustice @ahoti, to !et a secret I% en5uiry made a'out him. .
fe" "ee$s thereafter, "hile I "as in Chennai, I receied a call from the
Secretary of the C>I sayin! that the C>I "anted to tal$ to me. >ustice @ahoti
then came on the line and said that "hat I had complained a'out had 'een
found true. Didently the I% had found enou!h material a'out the >ud!e;s
corruption.
Since the 3 year term as .dditional >ud!e of that person "as comin! to an
end I assumed he "ould 'e discontinued as a >ud!e of the 4i!h Court in ie"
of the I% report. 4o"eer "hat actually happened "as that he !ot another 0
year appointment as an .dditional >ud!e, thou!h K other .dditional >ud!es
"ho had 'een appointed "ith him "ere confirmed and made permanent
>ud!es of the 4i!h Court.
I later learnt ho" this happened. The Supreme Court Colle!ium consists of C
seniormost >ud!es for recommendin! names for appointment as a Supreme
Court >ud!e, and 6 seniormost >ud!es for dealin! "ith 4i!h Courts.
The 6 senior most >ud!es in the Supreme Court at that time "ere the Chief
>ustice of India, >ustice @ahoti, >ustice Sa'ar"al, and >ustice &uma Pal. This
Supreme Court Colle!ium recommended that in ie" of the aderse I%
report the >ud!e should 'e discontinued as a 4i!h Court >ud!e after his 3
year term "as oer, and this recommendation "as sent to the Central
:oernment.
The Central :oernment at that time "as the LP. :oernment. The
Con!ress "as no dou't the lar!est party in this alliance, 'ut it did not hae
a ma(ority in the @o$ Sa'ha, and "as dependent on support 'y it allies. #ne
of such ally "as the party in Tamilnadu "hich "as 'ac$in! this corrupt
>ud!e. #n comin! to $no" of the recommendation of the 6 >ud!e Supreme
Court Colle!ium they stron!ly o'(ected to it.
The information I !ot "as that Prime Minister Manmohan Sin!h "as at that
time leain! for )e" =or$ to attend the L.). :eneral .ssem'ly Session. .t
the Delhi airport he "as told 'y the Ministers of that party of Tamilnadu
( "ho "ere Con!ress allies ) that 'y the time he returns from )e" =or$ his
!oernment "ould hae fallen as that Tamilnadu party "ould "ithdra"
support to the LP. ( for not continuin! that .dditional (ud!e ).
#n hearin! this Manmohan Sin!h panic$ed, 'ut he "as told 'y a senior
Con!ress minister not to "orry, and he "ould mana!e eerythin!. That
Minister then "ent to >ustice @ahoti and told him there "ould 'e a crisis if
that .dditional >ud!e of Tamilnadu "as discontinued. #n hearin! this >ustice
@ahoti sent a letter to the :oernment of India to !ie another term of 0
year as additional >ud!e to that corrupt >ud!e, ( I "onder "hether he
consulted his t"o Supreme Court Colle!ium mem'ers ),and it "as in these
circumstances this corrupt >ud!e "as !ien another 0 year term as
.dditional >ud!e ( "hile his K 'atch mates as .dditional >ud!es "ere
confirmed as permanent >ud!es ).
The .dditional >ud!e "as later !ien another term as .dditional >ud!e 'y
the ne" C>I >ustice Sa'ar"al, and then confirmed as a permanent (ud!e 'y
the ne+t C>I >ustice K.:. %al$rishnan, 'ut transferred to another 4i!h Court.
I hae related all this to sho" ho" the system actually "or$s, "hateer it is
in theory. In fact in ie" of the aderse I% report the >ud!e should not een
hae 'een continued as an .dditional >ud!e

Attemt to influence 7C )udge" A 3a)a named

In further em'arrassment to former Telecom Minister . &a(a, the Madras
4i!h Court today suspended from the 'ar a top la"yer "ho "as alle!edly
inoled in an attempt to influence a (ud!e ta$in! the name of the minister.
. Diision %ench, comprisin! >ustice F.M.I'rahim Khalifulla and >ustice
M.M.Sundaresh, said the status of & K Chandramohan, a mem'er and
su'se5uently as Chairman of the %ar Council of Tamil )adu and Pondichery,
shall stand suspended forth"ith.
4e should not not 'e permitted to function as such pendin! disciplinary
action 'y the %ar Council of India, the 'ench said.
Disposin! of a petition 'y a la"yer, the %ench appended a portion of a letter
"ritten 'y a former (ud!e of the court >ustice S &e!hupati, "ho had
reported that Chandramohan had entered his cham'er last year and pleaded
that the case of a father and a son, accused in a mar$s scandal case in
Puducherry, for anticipatory 'ail 'e considered faoura'ly as they "ere
?5uotMfamily friends of a Lnion Minister 'y name &a(a?5uotM.
The la"yer handed oer his mo'ile phone to the (ud!e sayin! that the
?5uotMunion minister is on the line to hae a tal$ "ith me?5uotM.
?5uotMI discoura!ed such conduct of Mr. Chandramohan and told him that
the case "ould 'e disposed of in accordance "ith la", if listed 'efore
me,?5uotM >ustice &e!hupati had said in his letter of >uly 2, 3771 to the
then Chief >ustice of India.
>ustice &e!hupati, "ho has since retired, had in his letter, complained a'out
the Chandramohan;s ?5uotMout'urst and uncontrolla'le?5uotM 'ehaiour.
Darlier, the (ud!e had in the open court last year alle!ed that a Lnion
Minister, throu!h a la"yer, attempted to spea$ to him on telephone see$in!
faours in a case 'ein! inesti!ated 'y C%I posted the matter to another
(ud!e. %ut he had not not named the minister.
In his letter to the C>I, >ustice &e!hupati had o'sered that ?5uotM a
counsel, "ho made an attempt to e+ert influence on the court 'y usin! the
name of a Ca'inet minister, cannot 'e allo"ed to succeed in snatchin! an
order in his faour 'y adancin! threat?5uotM.
The issue 'ecame a ra!in! controersy that the then C>I had told the media
that the (ud!e had sent a report to him ma$in! it clear that no no union
minister spo$e to him directly.
>ustice &e!hupati made those remar$s addressin! Chandramohan, "ho "as
appearin! in connection "ith an anticipatory 'ail plea 'y S Kiru' Shridhar, a
third year student in a priate medical colle!e in Puducherry, and his
doctor,father Krishnamoorthy.
The 'ail pleas "ere moed 'y Chandramohan on 'ehalf of the t"o "ho had
'een 'oo$ed 'y the C%I for alle!edly usin! the serices of a Pondicherry
Lniersity official and a middleman to inflate mar$s to !et a medical seat at
the time of admission.
>ustice &e!hupati, in his letter to the C>I, had o'sered that Chandramohan
made a plea to him that the court should call for the case diary and hear the
case "ith reference to the material collected durin! the course of
inesti!ation.
?5uotMI hae impressed upon the representin! counsel 'y e+plicatin! that a
li$e direction could 'e !ien to the prosecution only in the eent of a (ud!e
satisfyin! that such course is ineita'le and a'solutely necessary in a !ien
situation and that on mere demands and as a matter of routine such
e+ercise cannot 'e underta$en.
?5uotM.t that time Mr. Chandramohan stood up and made a similar demand
and "hen I emphatically declined to accede to his adamant demand, he
ociferously remar$ed that the Court is al"ays ta$in! sides "ith the
prosecution and not not acceptin! the su'missions made 'y the counsel for
the accused "hile !iin! importance to the Prosecutor.
?5uotM#n such pointless remar$, I said that the counsel had en!a!ed to
ar!ue on his 'ehalf has made his su'mission and he is not not supposed to
pass such slanderous and dero!atory remar$s,?5uotM >ustice &e!hupati had
said in his letter.
The la"yer, "ho had filed the petition, moed the Court for de'arrin!
Chandramohan from continuin! as %ar Council Chairman for his alle!ed
misconduct and order the %ar Council of India to ta$e disciplinary action
a!ainst him.
The %ench also said >ustice &e!hupathi;s letter shall 'e under the custody of
the &e!istrar :eneral in a sealed coer "hich, ho"eer, shall 'e part of the
case.

!x-C$I /as a/are of 3a)a influencing )udge" SC $udge
In an em'arrassment to former C>I K : %ala$rishnan, Supreme Court >ud!e
4 @ :o$hale today contradicted his claim that he "as not a"are that it "as
former Lnion Telecom Minister . &a(a, "ho had tried to influence a Madras
4i!h Court (ud!e in a criminal case.
In a statement, >ustice :o$hale, "ho "as the chief (ustice of the Madras
4i!h Court at that time, said that in his letter to >ustice %ala$rishnan, the
then C>I, he had clearly referred to the name of &a(a.
>ustice :o$hale;s statement totally contradicts >ustice %ala$rishnan;s claim
that there "as no mention of any Lnion Minister in the report sent 'y
>ustice :o$hale, then 4i!h Court Chief >ustice, on >ustice S &e!hupathi
episode.
GI re!ret to say that the alle!ations are a'solutely incorrect,G %ala$rishan
had said last "ee$ referrin! to ne"s reports that he had suppressed a letter
purportedly "ritten 'y >ustice &e!hupathi to him "hen he "as Chief >ustice
of India.
In a statement today, >ustice :o$hale said, GThe former C>I has stated in his
press conference that in my letter I did not mention the name of any Lnion
Minister hain! tal$ed to >ustice &e!hupathi oer phone to influence him.G
G/ith respect to this statement I may point out that >ustice &e!hupathi;s
letter "as already "ith him and in the second para!raph thereof (ustice
&e!hupathi had specifically mentioned the name of &a(a.
GI had no personal $no"led!e a'out the incident and o'serations in my
reply "herein are in conformity "ith the contents of >ustice &e!hupathi;s,G
>ustice :o$hale said.

Daughter-in-la/ files do/ry harassment case against AP 7igh Court )udge
in Chennai
The dau!hter,in,la" of a sittin! .ndhra Pradesh 4i!h Court (ud!e has filed a
do"ry harassment complaint a!ainst her hus'and and his family mem'ers.
Kaya &ao (67) a resident of Chennai came to the Chennai Police
Commissioner;s officer on /ednesday afternoon and filed the formal
complaint. In her complaint Kaya said her father, a Chennai 'ased
'usinessman arran!ed her "eddin! "ith the 4i!h Court (ud!e;s son in 3772.
She said durin! their marria!e her parents had paid &s.A6.C la$h as do"ry,
'ut the (ud!e and his "ife and other relaties demanded &s.C7 la$h more.
Kaya also said that her hus'and lost his (o' in 377H and hence they moed
from %an!alore to 4ydera'ad. GDer since the harassment 'e!an and my in ,
la"s pressurised me to 'rin! in atleast C7 la$hs rupees immediatelyG

Kaya in her complaint also su'mitted that since her family could not
arran!e this much money immediately she "as made to stare 'y her inla"s.
%ut after some time her parents !ae her inla"s money at fre5uent
interals. /hen she could not tolerate the a!ony she returned to Chennai to
lie "ith her parents.

%ut een after that the trou'les did not end for her , her father,in,la"
lod!ed a false complaint a!ainst her father. #n the insti!ations of the
(ud!e, a'duction and theft cases "ere filed a!ainst my father she said and
added the (ud!e is influencin! the police in Chennai. 4er hus'and came to
her house in Chennai a "ee$ a!o and ransac$ed it . Kaya has a small 'a'y
!irl. In her complaint she said her hus'and, mother,in,la" and father,in,la"
are attemptin! to a'duct her child.

The complaint "as filed "ith the .dditional Commissioner of Police
(head5uarers) &.S. )allasiam. It "as later for"arded to the Deputy
Commissioner of Police, .dayar ran!e for further inesti!ations. G/e hae
informed the Chief >ustice of India. The .P 4i!h Court (ud!e is attemptin!
to influence the local police here. /e "ill "ait for four or fie days. If the
Police does not ta$e any action "e "ill moe the Madras 4i!h Court for
direction to the Chennai Police Commissioner to ta$e suita'le action in this
re!ardG said K.%alu, adocate of Kaya in an interei" "ith India Today
#nline.

Proosal for 3econsideration of Judges Case I& II& and III

http9II""".!oo!le.co.inIurlJ
saNt?rctN(?5N?esrcNs?sourceN"e'?cdN6?edN7CC!OF(.C?urlNhttpP6.P3F
P3Fla"commissionofindia.nic.inP3FreportsP3Freport30A.pdf?eiN&yDCL,
8H#Ha0u.S"u=:=%"?us!N.FO(C):o)Sm)6uQ(:a8K$1s$Km>Q.F4R&.?cadNr
(a ,

2hy /as $ustice Shah byassed for ele0ation to the Sureme Court%

In #cto'er 377H, The :oernment of India recommended to the colle!ium
of the Supreme Court that >ustice .(it Shah of the Delhi 4i!h Court should
'e eleated to the Supreme Court.
4e "as not eleated, thou!h the :oernment tried t"ice. >ud!es (unior to
him "ere recommended.
.ny idea "hyJ Is it 'ecause he allo"ed the Supreme Court to come "ithin
the am'it of the &TIJ

'day :alit to be ne/ Sureme Court )udge after (oal Subramaniam
contro0ersy

. day after the Lnion %ud!et 370A "as presented, the )arendra Modi,led
)ational Democratic .lliance !oernment has 8eroed in on Lday @alit as the
ne" (ud!e of the Supreme Court of India. Senior la"yer Lday @alit "as also
the special prosecutor in the controersial 3: spectrum case. The
deelopment came in after )D. didnFt support the candidature of former
Solicitor,:eneral :opal Su'ramaniamFs appointment as the Supreme Court
(ud!e.
.mit Shah, "ho "as appointed as the %haratiya >anata Party president on
Thursday, >uly 07, had earlier aailed serices of Lday @alit in t"o eminent
criminal cases. .mit Shah "as accused li$e murder and conspiracy alon!
"ith Lday @alit. Three other senior 4i!h Court (ud!es "ere su!!ested 'y the
Supreme Court 'ench comprisin! &a(endra Mal @odha, Chief >ustice of India.
The appointment of Lday @alit comes days after the )arendra Modi
!oernment refused to support :opal Su'ramaniam as the ne+t Supreme
Court (ud!e. Lday @alitFs appointment also douses the controersy oer
Su'ramaniamFs candidature as an .pe+ Court (ud!e.
*IFm fully conscious that my independence as a la"yer is causin!
apprehensions that I "ill not toe the !oernment line. This factor has 'een
decisie in refusin! to appoint me,- said :opal Su'ramaniam in his letter to
Chief (ustice of India.
The %>P !oernment re(ected the su!!estion of Su'ramaniamFs appointment
and re5uested the Supreme Court 'ench to reconsider it. Su'ramanian has
also alle!ed that there "as a smear campai!n a!ainst him and the char!es
leelled a!ainst him "ere false.
#thers "ho "ere recommended for the role "ere #rissa 4i!h Court Chief
>ustice .darsh Kumar :oel, senior adocate &ohinton )ariman, and Calcutta
4i!h Court Chief >ustice .run Mishra.

(oal Subramaniam contro0ersy" (o0t o0ersteed its boundaries& says
C$I :odha

In an assertion that may pitch the !oernment and the top (udiciary head,
on, Chief >ustice of India &M @odha on Tuesday said that the !oernment had
acted unilaterally in se!re!atin! the name of former solicitor !eneral :opal
Su'ramanium from the panel of four names, recommended 'y the colle!ium
for appointment as ape+ court (ud!es.
Chief >ustice @odha made this disclosure at a function or!anised to 'id
fare"ell to >ustice %S Chauhan, "ho retired yesterday.
GThe se!re!ation (of Su'ramanium;s name) "as unilaterally done 'y the
e+ecutie (!oernment) "ithout my $no"led!e and consent,G Chief >ustice
@odha said at the function.
GThe first thin! I hae ta$en o'(ection to that the se!re!ation of
Su'ramanium;s proposal from other three proposals unilaterally 'y the
e+ecutie "ithout my $no"led!e and concurrence "as not proper,G he said.

The ape+ court colle!ium had recommended four names includin! that of
another former solicitor !eneral &ohinton )ariman for appointment as
(ud!es of the Supreme Court 'ut the !oernment, "hile clearin! three
names, returned the name of Su'ramanium for reconsideration 'y the
colle!ium.
/hile Chief >ustice @odha e+pressed his dismay "ith the !oernment
se!re!atin! Su'ramanium;s name and returnin! his recommendation, he also
e+pressed re!ret oer Su'ramanium (umpin! the !un and releasin! to the
media a letter "ritten to him "hile he "as a'road.
4e said that he had as$ed Su'ramanium to "ait for him to return and deal
"ith the matter.
Chief >ustice @odha said that soon after reachin! Delhi, he had a 2C minute
meetin! "ith Su'ramanium and as$ed him to reconsider his letter
"ithdra"in! his consent to 'e a (ud!e of the top court.
GSu'ramanium told me that he "ould !et 'ac$ the ne+t day 'ut instead he
sent a 'rief letter e+pressin! his ina'ility to reisit his decision to "ithdra"
the consentG he said.
GIndependence of (udiciary "ill neer 'e compromised,G Chief >ustice @odha
assured the mem'ers of the 'ar present at the function as he referred to
the e+cerpts of Su'ramanium;s letter "herein the latter had said9 GI am,
ho"eer, una'le to dispel the sense of unease that the (udiciary has failed
to assert its independence 'y respectin! the li$es and disli$es of the
e+ecutie.G
Descri'in! as Gshoc$in!G the alle!ation of independence of the (udiciary
'ein! compromised, Chief >ustice @odha said that he "ill not stay in the
post een for a minute if the independence of the (udiciary "as
compromised.
Sayin! that he "as a fierce upholder of the independence of the (udiciary,
he said that he had "or$ed for the institution first as a (ud!e of a hi!h
court, then of the ape+ court and no" as the Chief >ustice of India.
Clearly soundin! hurt at fin!ers 'ein! pointed at the independence of
(udiciary, he said9 GFor last more than 37 years, I fou!ht for independence of
(udiciary and to me this is one su'(ect "hich is not ne!otia'le. .t no cost,
the independence of (udiciary can 'e allo"ed to 'e compromised.G
GI "ill 'e the first man to leae this chair...if I $no" that (udiciary;s
independence has 'een compromised. I "ill not hold my office for a
second,G he asserted.

(o0t not entitled to )udge my character" (oal Subramanium to C$I

Puttin! an end to the on!oin! controersy oer his nomination 'y a Supreme
Court colle!ium for the post of a (ud!e in the ape+ court, former solicitor
!eneral :opal Su'ramanium has "ithdra"n his candidature.
.ccordin! to reports, the senior la"yer "ithdre" his candidature from the
(ud!e;s post on /ednesday follo"in! media reports "hich said the )D.
!oernment o'(ectin! to his appointment as a Supreme Court (ud!e,
'ecause of his ;lin$s; "ith corporate lo''yist )ira &adia and a ;ne!atie; C%I
report.
The !oernment is understood to hae returned the recommendation for his
appointment to the ape+ court to its colle!ium "ith a re5uest to reconsider
the decision.
Sources in the !oernment said "hile returnin! the recommendation relatin!
to the former Solicitor :eneral to the colle!ium headed 'y Chief >ustice of
India & M @odha, the !oernment cleared the other names for appointment.
Those cleared "ere Calcutta 4i!h Court Chief >ustice .run Mishra, #rissa
4i!h Court Chief >ustice .darsh Kumar :oel and senior adocate &ohinton
)ariman. The "arrants of appointments in these cases are li$ely to 'e issued
'y the &ashtrapati %haan shortly, the sources said.

The !oernment is learnt to hae sent a note to the colle!ium !iin! out
reasons for its reserations oer appointin! Su'ramanium to the ape+ court.
.s amicus curiae in the Sohra'uddin fa$e encounter case, Su'ramanium "as
critical of the :u(arat !oernment headed 'y )arendra Modi and 'rou!ht
out ne" facts on the 'asis of "hich the Supreme Court had ordered a C%I
pro'e into the case.
.s per the Memorandum of Procedure relatin! to the appointment of
Supreme Court (ud!es, the !oernment can return the file for
reconsideration once. %ut if the colle!ium reiterates its recommendation,
the !oernment has to comply "ith it.
There is no fi+ed time frame for the !oernment to appoint a (ud!e once
the recommendation is reiterated 'y the colle!ium. It is ery rare that the
colle!ium recommends names of la"yers to 'e appointed as Supreme Court
(ud!es.
>ustice ) Santosh 4e!de "as the last la"yer to hae 'een eleated directly
to the SC. 4e!de "as appointed as a (ud!e of the ape+ court in 0111.

CID chargesheets ; officials in 8PSC scam

The criminal inesti!ation department (CID) has filed a char!esheet a!ainst
si+ officials of the Karnata$a Pu'lic Serice Commission (KPSC) in connection
"ith alle!ed irre!ularities in the recruitment of 0K3 :roup,. and 377 :roup,
% !a8etted pro'ationers in 3700.
The 07,C30,pa!e char!esheet names former KPSC chairman :onal Man(appa,
special officer .runachalam S, .sho$ Kumar %, personal assistant to KPSC
mem'er Man!ala Sridhar, and officials Sudhir alias Sridhar, Somanath M
Chi$$amath alias Somesh and K &a(she$har as accused.
CID sources said KPSC mem'er Man!ala Sridhar and former KPSC secretary
Sunder are yet to 'e char!esheeted as inesti!ations a!ainst them are still
on. The char!esheet "as su'mitted to the 36rd additional city city ciil and
sessions (ud!e.
The si+ officials hae 'een char!ed under sections 001 (concealin! desi!n to
commit offence 'y a pu'lic serant)M 0KK (diso'eyance 'y pu'lic serant)M
0K2 (framin! incorrect documents 'y a pu'lic serant)M AKH (for!ery for the
purpose of cheatin!)M 370(causin! disappearance of eidence) and AKC
(for!ery) read "ith 62 (cooperation in committin! offence) of the Indian
Penal Code.
Some sections under the Preention of Corruption .ct 01HH hae also 'een
ino$ed a!ainst them.
The CID said they had ta$en 30K "itness accounts "hile inesti!atin! the
case, "hich "as first re!istered at the Bidhana Soudha police station in
>anuary 3706 on complaints from candidates. They accused the KPSC of
oerloo$in! them and alle!edly faourin! those not 5ualified in "ritten or
oral e+aminations.
/hat is the case
The scandalous recruitment scam, nic$named as the cash,for,(o's rac$et,
"as re!istered in >une last year "ith Bidhana Soudha police and later
referred to the CID.
The case "as filed 'y the department of personnel and administratie
reforms (DP.&), "hich for"arded the complaints of Dr Mythri and .(ay :
"ith a note to re!ister a first information report (FI&).
@e!al e+perts in the directorate of prosecution recommended that a case 'e
re!istered. It "as then referred to the CID on the director !eneral of police
(D:P);s recommendation.
The scandal relates to the e+amination held for 6K3 !a8etted pro'ationers;
posts (K.S :roups . and %) in .pril,May 3706.

Supreme Court vs go0ernment o0er romotions for three ---
Sureme Court 0s go0ernment o0er romotions for three )udges

The Supreme Court colle!ium is stic$in! to its decision of eleatin! the chief
(ustices of the 4i!h Courts of #rissa, Karnata$a and Tamil )adu to the top
court, sources hae told )DTB.

The colle!ium had nominated #rissa 4i!h Court Chief >ustice B :opala
:o"da, Karnata$a 4i!h Court Chief >ustice Bi$ram(it Sen and Madras 4i!h
Court Chief >ustice M = D5'al, 'ut the !oernment had as$ed it to
reconsider the names and also "hether the panel had considered alle!ations
a!ainst them.

The colle!ium, comprisin! of fie senior (ud!es and headed 'y the Chief
>ustice of India .ltamas Ka'ir, in its reply to the !oernment reportedly said
it has already considered the alle!ations raised 'ut "as satisfied "ith the
names and cleared their names for eleation.
The !oernment "ill no" hae to approe the names of these three (ud!es
as under the present system, if the colle!ium sends 'ac$ the names, then
the !oernment is 'ound to consider them for eleation.

Indian $udiciary stands in Cross 3oad

Indian $udiciary stands in Cross 3oad,la"yers in #rissa 4i!h Court
comment. >ud!es in hi!her (udiciary includin! Sureme Court of India are
no" 'rou!ht to the touch stone of integrity and morale 0alues .>ud!es are
human 'ein! not the !od as "e address them in an an!lici8ed "ords as *My
lord&your lordshi and the li$e- and all human instincts are in them as a
result of "hich >ustice A-8-(anguly has 'een 'rou!ht under the scanner 'ut
that can also 'e aoided 'y formin! a panel to e+amine the truthfulness as
that of the panel constituted in the case of sex scandal a!ainst three (ud!es
of 8arnata, 7igh Court namely $ustice .-S-6eerbhadraiah, $ustice
Chandrase,hariah and $ustice 6-(oal (o/da 'y a committee comprisin!
of Chief >ustice of %om'ay 4i!h Court ,$ustice C-8 Tha,,ar ,Chief >ustice
of Kerala 4i!h Court 9$ustice (-:-(uta and the then senior (ud!e of #rissa
4i!h court 9$ustice A-8-Patnai, and the oice of the people in the country
appeared to hae 'een choc,ed under the threat of Contemt of Court,'ut
fact remains ,the intellectuals "ere not happy the manner ,the three (ud!es
"ere !ien the clean chit 'y the (ud!es themseles re!ardless of the
existing in0estigating mechanism upon "hich the )udiciary &at the main&
rely uon- #nce a domain for particular e+pertise is deised ,is it at all
roer to be a )udge of one4s o/n cause. The (ud!es 'rou!ht under
scannin! then and for "hom entire (udiciary in our country "as 'lamed hae
also 'een re"arded "ith their time to time eleationM and on the other
hand, any (udicial mem'er in su'ordinate (udiciary if 'rou!ht under the
threat of any such alle!ation are 'ein! dispensed "ith .Lmpteen num'er of
instances are no" surfaced. .s per opinion surey ,the Odisha 5ulletin
5ureau has collected the ie"s from intellectuals of different field of
e+pertise, the (ud!es are in piotal post of passin! the rulin!s 'ut the
efficiency of a (ud!e no" matters and that 'ein! so ,selection of the (ud!es
ou!ht to 'e $ept a"ay from the reach of monopolist mechanism of a
!roup ,may it 'e (udiciary or 'ureaucratic or the political masters those are
al"ays found to 'e in nec$ deep corruption M and a set of standard of
ri!orous principle of selection has to 'e adopted to preent un"orthy
personalities from (oinin! (udiciary em'odied "ith the threat of 3e-Call
mechanism and a dynastic aroach in the selection of (ud!es should not
hae direct or indirect influence on the issue .)o", a,days ,it is inaria'ly
seen that (ud!es 'reeds (ud!es re!ardless merit or suita'ility for the hi!hest
constitutional post of the country M it is also seen that the children of the
(ud!es or the relations, as the case may 'e , practicin! in courts are
appearin! to 'e loaded "ith cases from priate and also !oernment
a!encies meanin! there'y that fertility !erminates no sooner one of the
family mem'ers 'ecomes !ets eleation to (ud!eship. #pen corridor
discussion su!!ests ,relation of many (ud!es in the 4i!h Court >udicature of
#rissa hae mana!ed to create name ,fame and fortune "ithin shortest
tenure of their practicin! la" .The theory of uncle )udge has had its ital
role in #rissa 4i!h Court.
In order to !et rid of pu'lic 'lame and in order to sae the ima!e of
(udiciary ,no" hence the (ud!e selection ou!ht to 'e done "ith care and
caution ,not 'y faoritism.In #rissa ,it is seen, (ud!es eleated to Supreme
court are hain! lot of tours to the state as that of a politicians more li$ely
as Constituency $udge and are apprehend to hae 'een t"istin! the
selection process and this has 'ecome a common and open scene for Orissa
7igh Court. /ithin last couple of months (ud!es from supreme court hae
made their recurrin! and successie isits to the state for this plea or other
and therefore ,pu'lic comment on them 'ein! the Constituency $udges.
5e you e0er so high &the la/ is abo0e you& C>I P. Sadasiam told .In this
(uncture ta$in! the pro'in! mechanism to the (udiciary itself 'ye,passin!
the esta'lished mechanism of pro'in! and I or inesti!ation is nothin! 'ut
arrestin! the democracy of the country,pu'lic commentM and
therefore,>ustice :an!uly 'e allo"ed to face the inesti!atin! a!ency "ith
due re!ard to his la" ma$in! process ,not la" 'rea$in! "hen it comes to his
person.
%efore la" ,eery 'ody should 'e treated e5ually ,may he 'e Asharam,
Tarun Te)al , $ustice A-8-(anguly, $ustice Altmas 8abir and the li$e .
In Orissa 7igh Court , half a do8en of (ud!es are alle!ed to hae !ra''ed
land of the !ot in concessional rates in the !uise of discretionary +uota
,'ut nothin! happened in spite of 'est efforts 'ein! put from different
5uarters of the society and addin! fe" more instances ,it is surprisin!
,>ustice P.$.Tripathy durin! his actie tenure has unauthorisedly ac5uired
more than one acres of land in CD. and carried on cultiation 'y employin!
staffs of #rissa 4i!h court ,'ut nothin! happened 'ecause he "as after all a
(ud!e and the person to address on such ille!ality is also nothin! 'ut a (ud!e
in fact and in the close nei!h'ourhood.:radually , the temple of (ustice is
losin! the confidence of the people ,bad sign for the democracy-
Dreaming to ha0e a country shaing into rogressi0e modernity can be
destroyed if )udiciary &last hoe of the common mass& lost to the scanner-

'PA :o, Ayu,ta should ha0e clean image" M# Saldanha to go0ernor

>ustice Chandrashe$araiahFs appointment as the second Lpa @o$ .yu$ta has
'een 5uestioned 'y >ustice MF Saldanha, also a former (ud!e of the
Karnata$a hi!h court.
>ustice Chandrashe$araiahFs appointment as the second Lpa @o$ .yu$ta has
'een 5uestioned 'y >ustice MF Saldanha, also a former (ud!e of the
Karnata$a hi!h court.
In a letter "ritten to !oernor 4& %hard"a(, >ustice Saldanha said the
hi!hest standard must 'e maintained to uphold the institution of the @o$
.yu$ta.
D).has a copy of the letter "ritten 'y Saldanha to the !oernor.
>ustice Saldanha pointed out that Chandrashe$araiah did not hold a clean
record, and named the controersies that the latter "as inoled in <
includin! the infamous Mysore &oost &esort scandal. Saldanha re5uested the
!oernor to choose a person "ith a clean trac$ record for the post of @o$
.yu$ta.
Chandrashe$araiah "as appointed the second Lpa @o$ .yu$ta on >anuary 30,
"hile the state !oernment and !oernor %hard"a( "ere already en!a!ed in
a 'itter 'attle oer the appointment of @o$ .yu$ta. The !oernor has thrice
re(ected the state !oernmentFs recommendation to appoint former Kerala
hi!h court Chief >ustice S& %annurmath as @o$ .yu$ta of Karnata$a.
The second Lpa @o$ .yu$taFs post had 'een lyin! acant since #cto'er, "hen
>ustice & :urura(an resi!ned citin! family and health issues.
Summarisin! the controersies in "hich >ustice Chandrashe$araiah "as
inoled, Saldanha alle!ed that the former "as inoled in the &oost &esort
se+ scandal. Saldanha also cited a case "here Chandrashe$araiah "as
'eaten up "ith slippers 'y a schoolmaster, "ho accused the (ud!e of sidin!
"ith the accused.
>ustice Saldanha said9 *The post of Lpa @o$ .yu$ta is ery important and
sensitie. The appointee must inspire total confidence and if there is een a
sli!ht 'lemish in his trac$ record, it "ould dis5ualify the candidate.- 4e
further pointed out that citi8ens should 'e informed a'out the name that
has 'een recommended and 'e !ien enou!h time to post their o'(ections,
if any, to the !oernment.
*%ut in the case of Chandrashe$araiah, no one "as a"are that his name "as
recommended and he "as s"orn in 'efore any material could hae 'een
placed 'efore the appointin! authority. Such de!ree of speed can 'e
dama!in!,- >ustice Saldanha said.
Spea$in! to D)., >ustice Saldanha said9 *The crucial appointment of @o$
.yu$ta is yet to 'e done. @et the person appointed hae a clean and clear
trac$ record. @et not the mista$es made in the appointment for Lpa @o$
.yu$ta 'e repeated. The Lpa @o$ .yu$ta appointment "as made in a hushed
manner.-
D)., in a series of reports, had pointed out that (ud!es of the Karnata$a
hi!h court and Supreme Court "ere allotted sites 'y the Karnata$a State
>udicial Dmployees 4ouse %uildin! Co,operatie Society, in iolation of 'y,
la"s.
>ustice Chandrashe$araiah "as also allotted a site "hen he "as the (ud!e of
the hi!h court.
#n this issue, >ustice MF Saldanha said9 *. mem'er of the hi!her (udiciary is
a constitutional functionary and cannot claim to 'e a (udicial employee. 4e
cannot aail a site meant for an employee and it is 'ad. This position "as
held 'y the 011C diision 'ench of the Karnata$a hi!h court.- /hen D).
contacted Chandrashe$araiah, he hit out at Saldanha and refused to
comment on the letter.

3ead "
Justice & $udocracy and Democracy in India " 5oundaries and --- &
htt"**boo,s-google-co-in*boo,s%
id<n=>)A/AA?5A$1g<PA@A@1lg<PA@A@1d+<ele0ationBtoBindiaBsure
meBcourtB)udgeBscandals1source<bl1ots<)Ona#.bdlt1sig<dbA?.3a!a
mI5/7'Y#C((oYA-
5A1hl<en1sa<C1ei<23DC'=DM8Ey2uATSoI(?Ag10ed<ACCo?;A!/AgF0<
oneage1+<ele0ationG@AtoG@AindiaG@AsuremeG@AcourtG@A)udge
G@Ascandals1f<false

The strange case against $ustice P.D. Dinakaran H churumuri

APP:ICATIO. #O3 I.#O3MATIO. AS P!3 3TI ACT @AAI
J S!! 3':! @@ O# 3TI ACT @AAI K

#':: .AM! O# T7! APP:ICA.T " .A(A3A$A-M-3-

ADD3!SS O# T7! APP:ICA.T " .A(A3A$A-M-3-&
!DITO3 & SOS !-6OIC! $'STIC! 1 SOS !-C:A3IO. O# DA:IT &
F :I(-@ * L;M& OPP 2AT!3 2O38S O##IC!&
7'DCO #I3ST STA(!& :ACMI8A.TA.A(A3&
7!55A:& MYSO3! & 8A3.ATA8A PI. N ILAAML-

2e salute honest fe/ in ublic ser0ice & $udiciary & olice &
arliament 1 state legislati0e assemblies- our /hole hearted resects to
them- 7!3!5Y & I DO 7'M5:Y 3!?'!ST YO' TO (I6! M! 23ITT!.
STAT!M!.TS * A.S2!3S TO T7! #O::O2I.( ?'!STIO.S N 27IC7 I.
ITS!:# J ie ans/ers K A3! T7! I.#O3MATIO. SO'(7T 5Y M!- 7!3! 2IT7 I
AM S!!8I.( .OT T7! OPI.IO.S A5O'T SOM! 7YPOT7!TICA: ISS'!S & 5'T
YO'3 O##ICIA: STA.D & :!(A: STA.D O. ISS'!S 27IC7 A3! O#
#3!?'!.T OCC'33!.C! 27IC7 A3! 6IO:ATI.( P!OP:!4S #'.DAM!.TA:
3I(7TS 1 7'MA. 3I(7TS- 2! DO 7A6! 7I(7!ST 3!SP!CTS #O3
$'DICIA3Y 1 A:: P'5:IC I.STIT'TIO.S & T7IS IS A. APP!A: #O3 T3'T7 &
I.#O3MATIO. SO T7AT TO APP3!7!.D CO33'PT #!2 I. P'5:IC S!36IC!&
27O A3! AIDI.( 1 A5!TTI.( T!33O3ISM & '.D!32O3:D 1 C3IMI.A:S- I
7A6! S7O2. I. D!TAI: 2IT7 :I6! & ACT'A: CAS!S & !CAMP:!S & 7O2
I.DIA. :!(A: SYST!M IS MA.IP':AT!D 5Y C3IMI.A:S 2IT7I. $'DICIA3Y &
PO:IC! & P3OS!C'TIO. & !TC- 3!AD D!TAI:S AT "
htts"**sites-google-com*site*eclarionofdalit*/heeling-dealing-)udges-
olice &
Atrocities on Women by JUDGES
ttps!""sites.goog#e.com"site"ec#ariono$da#it"atrocities%by%&udges

A N O of Maniulation of Indian :egal System
http9II""".scri'd.comIdocI0H2C2C37KI.,R,of,Manipulation,of,India,@e!al,
System ,
http9II""".scri'd.comIdocI026HCACA0IChief,>ustice,of,India,.,Criminal ,

>ustice Sathasiam , .re you DD.F DLM% ? %@I)D
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIeclarionofdalitI(ustice,sathasiam,,,are,you,
deaf,dum','lind ,
&a(i :andhi .ssassination Coer,up
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeIra(i,!andhi,
assassination,coer,up ,
S4.MD S4.MD MPs ? M@.s
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeIshame,shame,mps,mlas
,
7ereby & /e do re+uest CPIO O*O 7onourable Chief $ustice of India &
Sureme Court of India & .e/ Delhi to ans/er the follo/ing +uestions in
ublic interest & for safeguarding national security & .ational unity 1
integrity 1 to legally arehend anti-nationals & criminals /ithin the
)udiciary 1 olice-

0 . 4o" many (ud!es are 'oo$ed for !raft , se+ual crimes , crimes a!ainst
"omen , irre!ularities , amassin! disproportionate "ealth , failure of duty ,
!ettin! ille!al allotment of sites ? other crimes since independence till date
, year"ise J
3. "hat action ta$en case"ise J
6. are the action ta$en similar to commoners , common people committin!
same type of crimes J
A. did all the cases handled 'y tainted (ud!es su'(ected to reie" , retrial
'y other honest (ud!es J
C. ho" many adocates "ere prosecuted 'y court for influencin! "itnesses I
eidences , for tutored I concocted eidences , etc since independence till
date , year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
K. ho" many police officials I la" enforcin! officials "ere prosecuted 'y
court for influencin! , intimidatin! "itnesses throu!h threats , 6
rd
de!ree
torture , for concocted eidences , etc since independence till date ,
year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
2. ho" many police I la" enforcement officials "ere prosecuted for loc$,up
deaths , fa$e encounters , ille!al detention , 6
rd
de!ree torture , etc since
independence till date , year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
H. in ho" many cases police I la" enforcement officials "ere made to pay
compensation to innocent ictims "ho "ere "ron!ly char!ed , detained ?
tortured , murdered 'y police , since independence till date , year"ise J
"hat action J if not "hy J
1. in some cases , on appeal (ud!ements of hi!her court turns do"n the
(ud!ement of lo"er court. In ho" many such cases , lo"er court (ud!e is
made to pay compensation to ictims of their "ron! (ud!ement , since
independence till date year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
07. ho" many (ud!es hae defaulted in filin! their annual financial returns
!iin! out their "ealth , income details , year"ise since independence till
date J "hat action J if not "hy J
00. ho" you are erifyin! the annual financial returns of (ud!es J
03. since independence , ho" many conicts hae 'een sentenced to *death
'y han!in!- , year"ise J
06. ho" many death sentances "ere carried out ? ho" many are pendin! J
0A. ho" many police officials "ere made to pay compensation ? prosecuted
for defamation , "hen innocents falsely char!ed 'y police "ere ac5uitted ,
dropped from char!es 'y courts J if not "hy J
0C. ho" many lo"er court (ud!es "ere made to pay compensation ?
prosecuted for defamation , "hen innocents "ron!ly conicted 'y lo"er
court , 'ut on appeal hi!her courts ac5uittin! , droppin! them of char!es J if
not "hy J
0K. are (ud!es !ettin! paid from pu'lic e+che5uer , for their e+penses on
li5uor I alcohol , 'ody massa!es , etc in their T. D. 'ill "hile on tour ,
official isits , official parties hosted 'y (ud!es J
02. ho" many appeals for (ustice concernin! pu'lic "elfare , iolation of
human ? fundamental ri!hts , threat to lies I lielihood , etc "ere made
to supreme court of india , 'y na!ara(a mysore ra!hupathi alias na!ara(a M
& alias myself since 0117 till date J appeals "ere made throu!h ordinary
post , re!istered post , e,mail ? 'y "e' throu!h D.&P: , DP:. /hat
.CTI#) ta$en 'y supreme court of india "ith respect to each appeal J
0H. due to ne!li!ence I conniance of supreme court (ud!es in(ustices "ere
meted out to pu'lic ? pu'lic are still sufferin! in(ustices. Crimes "hich
could hae 'een preented 'y SC happened eenthou!h 'rou!ht to early
notice of supreme court. /hat action a!ainst errin! SC >ud!es J if not "hy J
01. I hae repeatedly offered my serices to supreme court of india , to
apprehend criminals "ithin (udiciary , police ? pu'lic serice. /hat action
ta$en 'y supreme court of india J if not "hy J
37. in my le!al stru!!le for (ustice , due to ne!li!ence I conniance of SCI
(ud!es I hae suffered murder attempts on my life , (o' losses , my
ne"spaper closed , not !ettin! press accreditation to my "e' ne"s papers ,
threats 'y ro"dies , police , etc. "hat action a!ainst errin! chief (ustice of
india J if not "hy J
33. I repeatedly appealed to supreme court of india to permit me to appear
as amicus curie 'efore supreme court of india ? (ain commission of en5uiry
re!ardin! late PM &a(i :andhi assassination case. I "as not permitted
"hy J
36. "ho are the (ud!es coerin!,up &a(i :andhi assassination case J "hat
action ta$en J if not "hy J
3A. @a" is one ? same for all , 'ut la" enforcement ? la" interpretation is
not same for common people , >ud!es ? Police J "hy J

Y!A3 TO 27IC7 A5O6! P!3TAI.S " MA$O3ITY O# DOC'M!.TS P!3TAI.S
TO Y!A3 MPPA-@AM> - SOM! O# T7! DOC'M!.TS A3! DAT!D 5AC8 TO
MP>L-
P'5:IC I.#O3MATIO. O##IC!3 #3OM 27OM I.#O3MATIO. IS 3!?'I3!D "
CPIO & o*o Chief $ustice of India & S'P3!M! CO'3T O# I.DIA & .!2
D!:7I-

#!!S PAID " IPO @@# @E@EAI for ruees ten only

DAT! " AQ-A;-@AM> RRRRR--RRRRRRRRR.A(A3A$A-M-3-

P:AC! " MYSO3! & I.DIAR-- RRRRRRRRR-J APP:ICA.TK

2ritten Argument N 3TI APP!A:
At the outset & /e exress our /hole hearted resects to the honest
fe/ ublic ser0ants in ublic ser0ice including )udiciary- 7o/e0er& the
corrut in ublic ser0ice don4t deser0e resect as indi0iduals N as they
are arasites in our legal system- Still /e resect the chairs they occuy
but not the corrut indi0iduals-

All the follo/ing articles * issues & /hole articles ublished in the
/eblin,s mentioned belo/ forms art of this aeal- The term S$'D(!T
mentioned throught includes all ublic ser0ants discharging )udicial
functions right from talu, magistrates & +uasi-)udicial officers to Chief
$ustice of India-

Indian :egal * $udicial System is maniulated at 0arious stages 1 is for
sale- It is a S7AM!- The ersons /ho raise their 0oice see,ing )ustice
are silenced in many /ays- The criminal nexus has already attemted to
silence me in many /ays - If anything unto/ard haens to me or to my
family members & my deendents & 7onourable Chief $ustice of India
together /ith )urisdictional olice officer /ill be resonsible for it-

7ereby& /e do once again offer our conditional ser0ices to the
honourable sureme court of India 1 other go0ernment authorities& in
arehending criminals including corrut )udges 1 olice- 7ere/ith & /e
once again aeal to the honourable sureme court of India & to
consider this as a PI: Aeal in ublic interest-

To my reeated aeals for )ustice & reeated aeals to utiliDe my
ser0ices to arehend criminals & reeated PI: etitions & reeated
aeals for information under 3TI act & your resonse /as silence /ith
resect to 3TI alications literally no information /as gi0en to PPG of
+ueries nor you transferred the +ueries to resecti0e deartment /hich
can ro0ide ans/er - This silence or intentional negligence of duty
amounts to crime co0er Nu- Due to imroer action on your art
crimes /hich could ha0e been nied at the bud Jinformation of crime
gi0en by us to SCIK haened & /hich amounts to abetting crime- Once
again if you deny me information to follo/ing +ueries & you are
reinforcing the roof that concerned sureme court of india )udges are
also C3IMI.A:S themsel0es- Ans/er follo/ing +uestions "

0 . 4o" many (ud!es are 'oo$ed for !raft , se+ual crimes , crimes a!ainst
"omen , irre!ularities , amassin! disproportionate "ealth , failure of duty ,
!ettin! ille!al allotment of sites ? other crimes since independence till date
, year"ise J
3. "hat action ta$en case"ise J
6. are the action ta$en similar to commoners , common people committin!
same type of crimes J
A. did all the cases handled 'y tainted (ud!es su'(ected to reie" , retrial
'y other honest (ud!es J
C. ho" many adocates "ere prosecuted 'y court for influencin! "itnesses I
eidences , for tutored I concocted eidences , etc since independence till
date , year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
K. ho" many police officials I la" enforcin! officials "ere prosecuted 'y
court for influencin! , intimidatin! "itnesses throu!h threats , 6
rd
de!ree
torture , for concocted eidences , etc since independence till date ,
year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
2. ho" many police I la" enforcement officials "ere prosecuted for loc$,up
deaths , fa$e encounters , ille!al detention , 6
rd
de!ree torture , etc since
independence till date , year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
H. in ho" many cases police I la" enforcement officials "ere made to pay
compensation to innocent ictims "ho "ere "ron!ly char!ed , detained ?
tortured , murdered 'y police , since independence till date , year"ise J
"hat action J if not "hy J
1. in some cases , on appeal (ud!ements of hi!her court turns do"n the
(ud!ement of lo"er court. In ho" many such cases , lo"er court (ud!e is
made to pay compensation to ictims of their "ron! (ud!ement , since
independence till date year"ise J "hat action J if not "hy J
07. ho" many (ud!es hae defaulted in filin! their annual financial returns
!iin! out their "ealth , income details , year"ise since independence till
date J "hat action J if not "hy J
00. ho" you are erifyin! the annual financial returns of (ud!es J
03. since independence , ho" many conicts hae 'een sentenced to *death
'y han!in!- , year"ise J
06. ho" many death sentances "ere carried out ? ho" many are pendin! J
0A. ho" many police officials "ere made to pay compensation ? prosecuted
for defamation , "hen innocents falsely char!ed 'y police "ere ac5uitted ,
dropped from char!es 'y courts J if not "hy J
0C. ho" many lo"er court (ud!es "ere made to pay compensation ?
prosecuted for defamation , "hen innocents "ron!ly conicted 'y lo"er
court , 'ut on appeal hi!her courts ac5uittin! , droppin! them of char!es J if
not "hy J
0K. are (ud!es !ettin! paid from pu'lic e+che5uer , for their e+penses on
li5uor I alcohol , 'ody massa!es , etc in their T. D. 'ill "hile on tour ,
official isits , official parties hosted 'y (ud!es J
02. ho" many appeals for (ustice concernin! pu'lic "elfare , iolation of
human ? fundamental ri!hts , threat to lies I lielihood , etc "ere made
to supreme court of india , 'y na!ara(a mysore ra!hupathi alias na!ara(a M
& alias myself since 0117 till date J appeals "ere made throu!h ordinary
post , re!istered post , e,mail ? 'y "e' throu!h D.&P: , DP:. /hat
.CTI#) ta$en 'y supreme court of india "ith respect to each appeal J
0H. due to ne!li!ence I conniance of supreme court (ud!es in(ustices "ere
meted out to pu'lic ? pu'lic are still sufferin! in(ustices. Crimes "hich
could hae 'een preented 'y SC happened eenthou!h 'rou!ht to early
notice of supreme court. /hat action a!ainst errin! SC >ud!es J if not "hy J
01. I hae repeatedly offered my serices to supreme court of india , to
apprehend criminals "ithin (udiciary , police ? pu'lic serice. /hat action
ta$en 'y supreme court of india J if not "hy J
37. in my le!al stru!!le for (ustice , due to ne!li!ence I conniance of SCI
(ud!es I hae suffered murder attempts on my life , (o' losses , my
ne"spaper closed , not !ettin! press accreditation to my "e' ne"s papers ,
threats 'y ro"dies , police , etc. "hat action a!ainst errin! chief (ustice of
india J if not "hy J
33. I repeatedly appealed to supreme court of india to permit me to appear
as amicus curie 'efore supreme court of india ? (ain commission of en5uiry
re!ardin! late PM &a(i :andhi assassination case. I "as not permitted
"hy J
36. "ho are the (ud!es coerin!,up &a(i :andhi assassination case J "hat
action ta$en J if not "hy J
3A. @a" is one ? same for all , 'ut la" enforcement ? la" interpretation is
not same for common people , >ud!es ? Police J "hy J

The ublic ser0ants 1 the go0ernment must be role models in la/
abiding acts & for others to emulate 1 follo/- if a student ma,es a
mista,e it is excusable 1 can be corrected by the teacher- if the teacher
himself ma,es a mista,e & all his students /ill do the same mista,e- if a
thief steals & he can be caught & legally unished 1 reformed - if a olice
himself commits crime & many thie0es go scot- free under his atronage-
e0en if a olice & ublic ser0ant commits a crime & he can be legally
rosecuted 1 )ustice can be sought by the aggrie0ed- )ust thin, & if a
)udge himself that too of aex court of the land itself commits crime -
0iolations of 3TI Act & constitutional rights 1 human rights of ublic and
obstructs the ublic from erforming their constitutional fundamental
duties & /hat haens % it gi0es a booster dose to the rich 1 mighty &
those in o/er & criminals in ublic ser0ice to committ more crimes-
that is exactly /hat is haenning in india- the educated ublic must
raise to the occassion 1 eacefully & democratically must oose this
criminalisation of )udiciary & ublic ser0ice- then alone & /e can build a
3AM 3A$YA O# MA7ATMA (A.D7I9S D3!AM-

'ind#y go troug te $o##o(ing artic#es ) provide &ustice by giving
comp#ete trut$u# in$ormation to us * by pub#ic#y ans(ering te
$o##o(ing +uestionnaire in an unambiguous manner.

,e constitution o$ India as prescribed certain -U.DA/E.,A0 DU,IES
to eac citi1ens o$ India. It is te duty o$ every citi1en to protect )
upo#d te dignity * onour o$ our democratic institutions * to
protect our nationa# integrity * to respect ) protect te rigts o$ our
$e##o( citi1ens. .o constitutiona# autority as te rigt to obstruct
te discarge o$ tese duties by citi1ens o$ India. .o #ega# privi#eges o$
constitutiona# $unctionaries is superior over te -U.DA/E.,A0 DU,IES
2- CI,I3E.4S 2- I.DIA.
We need rigts to per$orm our duties. Constitution o$ India as
guaranteed tose rigts as -U.DA/E.,A0 5IG6,S to a## citi1ens o$ India
) by birt itse#$ everyone o$ us as secured 6U/A. 5IG6,S as
individua#s. ,o e7press ourse#ves * (e need in$ormation * data $eed
back * to ascertain (eter (e are getting e+ua# opportunity * (eter
(e are getting e+uitab#e &ustice * etc * (e need in$ormation . so *
basica##y 5igt ,o In$ormation is an ina#ienab#e part o$ our
$undamenta# rigts ) uman rigts. Wat 5,I Act as done is $i7ed time
#imit * responsibi#ities o$ pub#ic servants up to certain e7tent.
6o(ever te citi1en4s $undamenta# rigt ) uman rigt to seek
in$ormation e7tends $ar beyond te scope o$ 5,I Act.
6ereby * (e seek comp#ete trut$u# in$ormation $rom supreme court o$
India * (it respect to my 5,I app#ication appea#. 6E5E89 * WE A5E
2.09 SEE'I.G ACC2U.,A8I0I,9 2- PU80IC SE5:A.,S I. PU80IC
I.,E5ES, ) JUS,ICE. 6ereby * (e re+uest you to register tis appea#
as a PI0 petition ) to ascertain te stand o$ ape7 court on various
matters raised in my 5,I App#ication * in pub#ic interest ) e+uitab#e
&ustice. 5ead !

.otice to C$I $ustice 3 M :odha
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeInotice,to,c(i,(ustice,r,m,
lodha &

2hy .OT Punishment for 3aist $udges 1 Police %
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeI"hy,not,punishment,for,
rapist,(ud!es,police

2e salute honest fe/ in ublic ser0ice & $udiciary & olice & arliament
1 state legislati0e assemblies- our /hole hearted resects to them-
7!3!5Y & I DO 7'M5:Y 3!?'!ST YO' TO (I6! M! 23ITT!. STAT!M!.TS *
A.S2!3S TO T7! #O::O2I.( ?'!STIO.S N 27IC7 I. ITS!:# J ie
ans/ers K A3! T7! I.#O3MATIO. SO'(7T 5Y M!- 7!3! 2IT7 I AM
S!!8I.( .OT T7! OPI.IO.S A5O'T SOM! 7YPOT7!TICA: ISS'!S & 5'T
PO:IC! & P3OS!C'TIO. & !TC- I do hoe sense of constitutional
roriety & )ustice /ill re0ail- $AI 7I.D- 6A.D! MATA3AM-

Date " AI-AL-@AM> Your4s
sincerely&
Place " Mysore .agara)a-M-3-

PAY 'P $ustice 3 M :odha - DAMA(!S PAYM!.T I #I.A: S7O2-CA'S!
.OTIC! TO C7I!# $'STIC! O# I.DIA

I don4t ,no/ /hether secretariat staff of C$I office 1 DA3P( * DP(
officials are for/arding my aeals for )ustice & e-mails to you or not-
They /ill be held accountable for their lases if any- This notice is
against the reeated failure of constitutional duties 1 indirect collusion
/ith criminals by re0ious C7I!# $'STIC!s O# I.DIA- .otice is ser0ed
against them & to the office of C$I & .OT ersonally against you- At the
indi0idual le0el I do /hole heartedly resect 7onourable $ustice 3 M
:odha-
Please refer my aeal for )ustice through DA3P( U
D:(:A*!*@AMQ*AA@P@
D!PO$*!*@AMQ*AA;LP

In india democracy is a farce & freedom a mirage- the most basic freedom
3I(7T TO I.#O3MATIO. 1 !CP3!SSIO. & is not honoured by
the go0ernment&as the information oens u the crimes of 6-6-I-Ps 1
leads to their ill-gotten /ealth- The ublic ser0ants are least
bothered about the li0es of eole or )ustice to them- these tye of fat
cats & arasites are a drain on the ublic exche+uer - these
eole /ant &/ish me to see dead & /ish to see 7'MA. 3I(7TS 2ATC7
closed - so that& a 0oice against in)ustices is silenced fore0er & the crimes
of 6-6-I-Ps closed & buried fore0er-
To my numerous aeals & 7324s aeals to you &you ha0e not
yet relied- It clearly sho/s that you are least bothered about the
li0es of eole or )ustice to them -it ro0es that you are hell bent
to rotect the criminals at any cost- you are )ust ressurising the olice
to en+uire me &to ta,e my statement& to reeatedly call me to olice
station all /ith a 0ie/ to silence me-all of you en)oy Slegal immunity
ri0ilegesT &/hy don4t you ha0e gi0en o/ers to the
olice * in0estigating officer to summon all of you for en+uiry %or else
/hy don4t all of you are not aearing before the olice 0oluntarily
for en+uiry %at the least /hy don4t all of you are not sending
your statement about the case to the olice either through legal counsel
or through ost% you are aiding criminals &by denying me
)ob ourtunities in 3-5-I C'33!.CY .OT! P3!SS mysore & city ci0il court
&bangalore & distict court & mysore &etc 1 by illegally closing my
ne/saer-
there is a gross& total mismatch bet/een your actions and your oath
of office- this amounts to ublic cheating 1 moral turitude on
your art-
M-you are ma,ing contemt of the 0ery august office you hold-
@-you are ma,ing contemt of the constitution of india-
Q-you are ma,ing contemt of citiDens of india-
>-you are sonsoring 1 aiding terorrism 1 organiDed crime-
I-you are 0iolating the fundamental 1 human rights of the citiDens
of india and of neighbouring countries-
;-you are 0iolating 1 ma,ing contemt of the '-. 7'MA. 3I(7TS
C7A3T!3 to /hich india is a signatory-
L-you are obstructing me from erforming my fundamental duties as
a citiDen of india-
E- As a result of your gross negligence of constitutional duties you ha0e
caused me damages * losses to the tune of 3'P!!S T2O C3O3! O.:Y-
you are hereby called uon to Pay damages to me and S7O2-CA'S!
/ithin QA days & /hy you cann4t be legally rosecuted for the abo0e
mentioned crimes -

If i am reeatedly called to olice station or else /here for the sa,e of
in0estigations & the losses i do incurr as a result li,e loss of /ages &
transortation & )ob & etc must be borne by the go0ernment- re0oiusly
the olice * I5 ersonnel reeatedly called me the comlainant Jsufferer
of in)usticesK to olice station for +uestioning & but ne0er called the
guilty culrits e0en once to olice station for +uestioning & as the culrits
are high 1 mighty - this tye of one sided +uestioning must not be done
by olice or in0estigating agencies - if anything unto/ard haens to me
or to my family members li,e loss of )ob & meeting /ith hit 1 run
accidents & loss of li0es & etc & the )urisdictional olice together /ith
abo0e mentioned accussed ublic ser0ants & Chief $ustice of India 1
$urisdictional District Magistrate /ill be resonsible for it- !0en if
criminal nexus le0els fa,e charges & olice file fa,e cases against me or
my deendents to silence me & this comlaint is 1 /ill be effecti0e-
if anything unto/ard haens to me or my deendents & the go0ernment
of india is liable to ay 3s- T2O crore as comensation to sur0i0ors of
my family- if my /hole family is eliminated by the criminal nexus &then
that comensation money must be donated to Indian Army 2elfare #und-
after/ards & the money must be reco0ered by (OI as land arrears from
the salary & ension & roerty & etc of guilty )udges & olice officials &
ublic ser0ants 1 Constitutional fuctionaries- Than,ing you- $ai 7ind &
6ande Mataram-

Date " @;-A>-@AM>RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR--your4s sincerely&
Place " Mysore & IndiaRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR-.agara)a M 3

Chief $ustice of India J C$I K a Criminal %
- PI: Aeal to 7onorable Sureme court of India #or 2rit of Mandamu
s

To,
4onoura'le &e!istrar ,
Supreme Court of India ,
)e" Delhi.

Su'(ect 9 PI@ appeal for /&IT #F M.)D.MLS ? Disciplinary action ,
criminal proceedin!s a!ainst Chief >ustice of India

I don4t ,no/ /hether secretariat staff of C$I office 1 DA3P( * DP(
officials are for/arding my aeals for )ustice & e-mails to you or not-
They /ill be held accountable for their lases if any- This notice is
against the reeated failure of constitutional duties 1 indirect collusion
/ith criminals by re0ious C7I!# $'STIC!s O# I.DIA- .otice is ser0ed
against them & to the office of C$I & .OT ersonally against you- At the
indi0idual le0el I do /hole heartedly resect 7onourable $ustice 3 M
:odha-
Please refer my aeal for )ustice through DA3P( U
D:(:A*!*@AMQ*AA@P@
D!PO$*!*@AMQ*AA;LP

The chief (ustice of india is not replyin! to my repeated sho",cause notices ,dama!e
payment notices nor ta$in! appropriate le!al actions , in time . 4o"eer the
pu'lic serants ta$e their thousands of rupees salary ? per$s "ell in time "ithout fail
on 0
st
of eery month. .s a result of continued ne!li!ence of
constitutional duties since years "e pu'lic are sufferin! in(ustices , crimes
"hich could hae 'een preented are ta$in! place. There'y C>I is aidin! the criminals
in committin! crimes ? coer up of crimes , in the course 'ecomin! a criminal
himself. /e salute our freedom fi!hters , military personnel ? martyrs for all
the sacrifices made 'y them. @et us 'uild a stron! , Secular , Democratic India
'y !ettin! rid off fe" corrupt elements , anti nationals , traitors amon!
pu'lic serants , amon! (udiciary ?amon! police "ho are !reater threat to IndiaF
security ? inte!rity than Pa$istani terrorists or chinese military.

Information input forms part of process of oneFs e+pression. #neFs e+pression in any
forms S "ritten , oral , etc 'ecomes information input to the opposite person , in
turn he e+presses his reply. Information ? D+pression are insepara'le parts ?
form lifeline of a democracy. That is the reason , &i!ht to D+pression is the
'asic fundamental ri!ht as "ell as human ri!ht of eery Indian citi8en. /hen
a personFs ri!ht to e+pression is iolated , his other ri!hts to e5uality , (ustice ,
etc also are iolated. Suppression of Information amounts to cur'in! of D+pression. In
a democracy , people hae a ri!ht to $no" ho" the pu'lic serants are functionin! .
4o"eer till date pu'licserants are hidin! 'ehind the eil of #fficials Secrets .ct
("hich is of 'ritish inta!e created 'y 'ritish to suppress natie Indians ). %y this
coer,up pu'lic serants are hidin! their o"n corruption ,
crimes , mismana!ement , failures , etc. een &TI .ct is not 'ein!follo"ed intoto 'y
pu'lic serants. 4o"eer the recent delhi hi!h court rulin! affirmin! that C>I is
under &TI purie" ? 'ound to ans"er &TI re5uest , is note "orthy. #ur
preious &TI re5uest to C>I , union home secretary of :#I, President of India , D:
? I:P of :#K and others "ere not honored. The information is sou!ht "ere ans"ers
to the follo"in! 5uestions mentioned in the 'elo" mentioned "e'sites . the
5uestions concerned the past , present continuin! in(ustices meted out to
millions of Indian citi8ens , due to "ron! I ille!al "or$practices of
Indian (ud!es , police ? pu'lic serants . The information "e sou!ht "ould
e+pose the traitors , anti,nationals , criminals in pu'lic serice .The information "e
are see$in! are no defense secrets , no national secrets .The truthful information
e+poses the anti,nationals , traitors in the pu'lic serice ? stren!thens our national
security , national unity ? inte!rity.

4ere'y , i do re5uest the honoura'le supreme court of india , for a Supreme Court
monitored C%I Dn5uiry into this "hole issue as $arnata$a police are helpless , they
don;t hae le!al po"ers to prosecute hi!h ?
mi!hty ,constitutional functionaries. They hae not een en5uired the !uilty
BBIPs een once ho"eer Lnder pressure from hi!her,ups they
repeatedly called me the complainant to police station too$ statements from
me all for closin! the files. 4ere'y , I do re5uest the honora'le supreme court of
India to consider this as a PI@ for 9 *"rit of Mandamus- and to issue instructions to the
concerned pu'lic serants in the follo"in! cases to perform their duties ? to ans"er
the 5uestions. .s the trial court >ud!es cross erify the antecedents , history of the
parties in a case to ascertain partyFs honesty ,inte!rity , as the inesti!atin!
police officers cross chec$ the antecedents , history of a
complainant I accussed I"itnesses to ascertain their honesty , inte!rity of the
accussed I complainant ,in the same "ay the parties in a case , as complainant I
accussed I "itnesseshae a ri!ht to ascertain the inte!rity , honesty of the trial court
(ud!e ? inesti!atin! police officers to ensure they are not 'iased and
proide a fair ,leel !round. >.I 4I)D. B.)DD M.T.&.M.

Date9 3K.7A.370A
=ourFs sincerely ,
Place 9 Mysore )a!ara(a.M.&

DSP among six arrested on charge of deer hunting

accused.
Farid.

accused.
Farid.

accused.
Farid.

accused.
Farid.

DACOITY by Mysore Police - An embarrassment for olice to brass

Mysore9 Southern &an!e I:P;s !unman Pra$ash has reportedly named some
senior policemen as his partners,in,crime in the &s3,crore sei8e,s"indle
scam.
Pra$ash "as thorou!hly !rilled follo"in! his arrest on Tuesday. Sources in the
police said PK :ar!, additional director !eneral of police of the CID<it 'ein!
the a!ency pro'in! the case<interro!ated Pra$ash, the !unman serin! I:P
K &amachandra &ao. Sources in the police department did not identify the
top cops Pra$ash has reportedly named.
Sources in police said that t"o mem'ers of the s5uad that raided the 'us
"ere not supposed to 'e there. /hen intercepted, the 'us "as in =ela"al
police;s (urisdiction, 'ut the police s5uad had t"o mem'ers "or$in! "ith
%annur police.
Mean"hile, su',inspector >a!adish and Sathish, "ho "ere part of the team
that raided the 'us, "ere arrested "hen they came to %an!alore to apply
for anticipatory 'ail.
D:?I:P @alro$huma Pachau has as$ed the CID to leae no stone unturned in
the inesti!ation and to !et incriminatin! eidence a!ainst eery policeman
inoled in the case, re!ardless of his ran$.
Police sources said the CID has o'tained the telephonic conersation
'et"een Pra$ash and the police informants "ho tipped him off a'out the
'us carryin! the moolah. Sources said Pra$ash, the informants and the
raidin! party e+chan!ed many a call the ni!ht the 'us "as raided and the
cash "as sei8ed.
The case
#n >anuary A, a police team led 'y su',inspector CD >a!adeesh intercepted
a Kerala,'ound priate 'us 'elon!in! to Kalpa$a traels at =el"al a'out 0.67
am, after receiin! information that a hu!e sum of money "as 'ein!
transported in it.
They reportedly found &s3.32 crore in the 'us, and too$ the drier .$thar
4ussein and cleaner Muneer into custody. The 'us "as first ta$en to =el"al
police station and later some policemen as$ed the drier to par$ the 'us on
Mysore,%ant"al 4i!h"ay.
The policemen alle!edly too$ si+ 'a!s of money $ept in the 'us and dumped
one of them containin! cash &s37 la$h in the tools 'o+ of the ehicle.
/hile the drier denied that he "as a"are of the money $ept in the tool
'o+, the FI& mentioned that he "as ille!ally carryin! cash &s37 la$h.
.fter the drier came out on 'ail, some !old merchants from Kerala accused
the police of s"indlin! their money. They claimed that the money "as
o'tained from the sale of !old in %an!alore 'y their local a!ents. They also
claimed that the money "as $ept in a secret 'o+ located in the middle of
the 'us floor and that it "as $no"n only to the drier.
The !old merchants also approached Kerala home minister &amesh
Chennithala, "ho as$ed his Karnata$a counterpart to loo$ into the matter.
:oin! 'y the eracity of the case, the D: ? I:P had transferred the
inesti!ation to the CID.
Follo"in! this, the accused policemen are on the run. Some of them hae
also applied for anticipatory 'ail. The CID has so far arrested four people,
includin! the !unman of the I:P and three police informants.
The CID sleuths hae re5uested the court to permit them to 'oo$ a dacoity
case a!ainst the accused.
In .u!ust 3773, a !roup led 'y the then assistant commissioner of police
(Traffic,Bi(ayana!ar), . %elliappa, alle!edly ro''ed the employees of a !old
merchant from Ko8hi$ode of &s01 la$h. The errant police staff posed as
customs officials and ro''ed the t"o employees, "ho "ere returnin! to
Kerala in a priate 'us. %elliyappa "as dismissed for his inolement in the
case.
In )oem'er 3707, Mico @ayout police station inspector C) >anardhan "as
suspended for irre!ularities. 4e "as char!ed "ith misusin! recoered
property. 4e had alle!edly sold 3.A $! !old , "orth &s6.AC la$h , that "as
recoered from the accused in Muthoot :old Finance theft case. 4e "as also
facin! seeral other char!es.
In >anuary this year, the police inspector of 4.@ station &a(esh and three
consta'les "ere suspended for alle!edly e+tortin! &s6 la$h from an old
offender 'y threatenin! to 'oo$ him in a false case. The errant policemen
had e+torted money from >aed, "ho had complained a'out it to DCP (South
Dast). . preliminary internal pro'e reealed that the policemen had
receied &s6 la$h and had distri'uted the money amon! themseles and
they "ere suspended later. Police are on the loo$out for &a(esh.
ETop cops em'olden (uniors in $ha$i to play it dirtyF
Despite 'ein! "arned 'y the chief minister and the home minister to not
inole in ille!al actiities, the %an!alore police personnel, time and a!ain,
are cau!ht for their misdeeds.
. retired police officer, re5uestin! anonymity, said policemen inolin! in
ille!al actiities is an old trend. *The nature of the "or$ demands ne+us
"ith people "ith criminal 'ac$!round to !ather information. Dthical
policemen use such information for professional re5uirements only, 'ut
some policemen use such information for their personal !ain. /hat is
disheartenin! is that some senior police officers, "ho hae to set an
e+ample for their (uniors, identify "ith such policemen and $eep them
close,- he said.
*The lo"er,run! policemen !et into direct contact "ith senior officers 'y
ne!lectin! hierarchy. The seniors encoura!e them to inole in ille!al
actiities and protect them "heneer they !et into trou'le. Ma$in! hu!e
money is the sole o'(ectie 'ehind this,- he stated.
*Police are e+posed to all $ind of criminal actiities o"in! to the nature of
their "or$. So, they thin$ that they can easily !et a"ay 'y committin! some
or the other offence,- another officer said.

RRRRRRRR--D!C:A3ATIO.RRRRRRRRR

.ame " ---------------------------.A(A3A$A-M-3-
Address " -------------------:I(-@ * L;M & 7'DCO #I3ST STA(! & OPP
2AT!3 2O38S O##IC! & :A8S7MI8A.TA.A(A3 & 7!55A: & MYSO3! -
ILAAML I.DIA
Professional * Trade Title " S-O-S - e N 6oice #or $ustice
Periodicity " 2!!8:Y
Circulation " #O3 #3!! DIST3I5'TIO. O. 2!5
Donations " .OT ACC!PT!D- Self financing - .e0er acceted any
donations & subscritions either for oursel0es or on behalf of other
organiDations * indi0iduals -
Monetary gains " nil & ne0er made any monetary gain by /ay of
ad0ertisements on my /ebsites or /eb ne/s aer or other/ise-
O/ner*editor*rinter*ublisher " .A(A3A$A-M-3-
.ationality " I.DIA.
5ody Donation " Physical 5ody of .agara)a M 3 & !ditor & S-O-S- e N clarion
of Dalit 1 S-O-S-e-6oice for $ustice is donated to $SS Medical College &
Mysore J Donation .o- M;L dated @@ * MA * @AAQ K & In case of either
'nnatural death or .atural Death at the hands of criminal nexus & my
body must be handed o0er to $SS Medical College & Mysore for the study
uroses of medical students-
!ye Donation " 5oth !Y!S of .agara)a M 3 & !ditor & S-O-S- e N clarion of
Dalit 1 S-O-S-e-6oice for $ustice are donated to Mysore !ye 5an, &
Mysore & In case of either 'nnatural death or .atural Death at the hands
of criminal nexus & my eyes must be handed o0er to Mysore !ye 5an, &
Mysore 2IT7I. ; 7ours for immediate eye translantation to the needy-
7ome age "
ttp!""in.groups.yaoo.com"group"sosevoice$or&ustice" *
ttp!""groups.goog#e.co.in"group"r(epaper " * ttp!""sites.goog#e.com
"site"sosevoice$or&ustice " * ttp!""evoiceo$umanrigts(atc.(ordpres
s.com " * ttp!""nagr(.tripod.com"evoice" *
ttp!""e%voiceo$umanrigts(atc.b#ogspot.com * http9IIpaper.liIf,
06KH6K13A1
Contact " naghr/V yahoo-com & nagara)hr/Vhotmail-com &

'ID Aadhaar .o " ILAQ IQQP Q>LP
Cell " PM PQ>ME@AQMQ
I &.A(A3A$A-M-3- hereby do declare that information gi0en abo0e are
true to the best of my ,no/ledge 1 belief- If i am reeatedly called to
olice station or else /here for the sa,e of in0estigations & the losses i do
incurr as a result li,e loss of /ages & transortation & )ob & etc must be
borne by the go0ernment- re0oiusly the olice * I5 ersonnel reeatedly
called me the comlainant Jsufferer of in)usticesK to olice station for
+uestioning & but ne0er called the guilty culrits e0en once to olice
station for +uestioning & as the culrits are high 1 mighty - this tye of
one sided +uestioning must not be done by olice or in0estigating
agencies - if anything unto/ard haens to me or to my family members
li,e loss of )ob & meeting /ith hit 1 run accidents & loss of li0es & death
due to imroer medical care & etc & the )urisdictional olice & re0enue
officials & District Magistrate 1 Chief $ustice of India together /ith abo0e
mentioned accused ublic ser0ants /ill be resonsible for it- !0en if
criminal nexus le0els fa,e charges & olice file fa,e cases against me or
my deendents to silence me & this comlaint is 1 /ill be effecti0e-
If I or my family members or my deendents are denied our fundamental
rights & human rights & denied roer medical care for oursel0es & If
anything unto/ard li,e hit 1 run cases & murder attemts & unnatural
deaths & etc haens to me or to my deendents or to my family
members - In such case Chief $ustice of India together /ith the
)urisdictional re0enue 1 olice officials /ill be resonsible for it & in
such case the go0ernment of india is liable to ay 3s- T2O crore as
comensation to sur0i0ors of my family- if my /hole family is eliminated
by the criminal nexus &then that comensation money must be donated
to Indian Army 2elfare #und- After/ards & the money must be reco0ered
by (OI as land arrears from the salary & ension & roerty & etc of guilty
olice officials & guilty $udges & guilty ublic ser0ants 1 guilty
Constitutional fuctionaries-
date " M@-AL-@AM>--RRRRRRRRR--Your9s sincerely&
lace " IndiaRRRRRRRRRR------------.agara)a-M-3-

APP!A: '.D!3 S!C MP JQK O# 3TI ACT @AAI O# (O6!3.M!.T O# I.DIA
1 (O6!3.M!.T O# 8A3.ATA8A
3ef " D!PO$*!*@AM>*AAIQM 3TI #irst Aeal sent 0ia DA3P(
APP:ICATIO. #O3 I.#O3MATIO. AS P!3 3TI ACT @AAI
J S!! 3':! @@ O# 3TI ACT @AAI K

3TI #irst Aeal 5efore "
Shri - M-8- 7an)ura &
3egistrar 1 3TI #irst Aellate Authority &
Sureme Court of India &
.e/ Delhi -

#':: .AM! O# T7! APP:ICA.T " .A(A3A$A-M-3-

ADD3!SS O# T7! APP:ICA.T " .A(A3A$A-M-3-&
!DITO3 & SOS !-6OIC! $'STIC! 1 SOS !-C:A3IO. O# DA:IT &
F :I(-@ * L;M& OPP 2AT!3 2O38S O##IC!&
7'DCO #I3ST STA(!& :ACMI8A.TA.A(A3&
7!55A:& MYSO3! & 8A3.ATA8A PI. N ILAAML-

At the outset & /e exress our /hole hearted resects to the honest
fe/ ublic ser0ants in ublic ser0ice including )udiciary- 7o/e0er& the
corrut in ublic ser0ice don4t deser0e resect as indi0iduals N as they
are arasites in our legal system- Still /e resect the chairs they occuy
but not the corrut indi0iduals-

All the follo/ing articles * issues & /hole articles ublished in the
/eblin,s mentioned belo/ forms art of this aeal- The term S$'D(!T
mentioned throught includes all ublic ser0ants discharging )udicial
functions right from talu, magistrates & +uasi-)udicial officers to Chief
$ustice of India-

Indian :egal * $udicial System is maniulated at 0arious stages 1 is for
sale- It is a S7AM!- The ersons /ho raise their 0oice see,ing )ustice
are silenced in many /ays- The criminal nexus has already attemted to
silence me in many /ays - If anything unto/ard haens to me or to my
family members & my deendents & 7onourable Chief $ustice of India
together /ith )urisdictional olice officer /ill be resonsible for it-

7ereby& /e do once again offer our conditional ser0ices to the
honourable sureme court of India 1 other go0ernment authorities& in
arehending criminals including corrut )udges 1 olice- 7ere/ith & /e
once again aeal to the honourable sureme court of India & to
consider this as a PI: Aeal in ublic interest-

The ublic ser0ants 1 the go0ernment must be role models in la/
abiding acts & for others to emulate 1 follo/- if a student ma,es a
mista,e it is excusable 1 can be corrected by the teacher- if the teacher
himself ma,es a mista,e & all his students /ill do the same mista,e- if a
thief steals & he can be caught & legally unished 1 reformed - if a olice
himself commits crime & many thie0es go scot- free under his atronage-
e0en if a olice & ublic ser0ant commits a crime & he can be legally
rosecuted 1 )ustice can be sought by the aggrie0ed- )ust thin, & if a
)udge himself that too of aex court of the land itself commits crime -
0iolations of 3TI Act & constitutional rights 1 human rights of ublic and
obstructs the ublic from erforming their constitutional fundamental
duties & /hat haens % it gi0es a booster dose to the rich 1 mighty &
those in o/er & criminals in ublic ser0ice to committ more crimes-
that is exactly /hat is haenning in india- the educated ublic must
raise to the occassion 1 eacefully & democratically must oose this
criminalisation of )udiciary & ublic ser0ice- then alone & /e can build a
3AM 3A$YA O# MA7ATMA (A.D7I9S D3!AM-

'ind#y go troug te $o##o(ing artic#es ) provide &ustice by giving
comp#ete trut$u# in$ormation to us * by pub#ic#y ans(ering te
$o##o(ing +uestionnaire in an unambiguous manner.

,e constitution o$ India as prescribed certain -U.DA/E.,A0 DU,IES
to eac citi1ens o$ India. It is te duty o$ every citi1en to protect )
upo#d te dignity * onour o$ our democratic institutions * to
protect our nationa# integrity * to respect ) protect te rigts o$ our
$e##o( citi1ens. .o constitutiona# autority as te rigt to obstruct
te discarge o$ tese duties by citi1ens o$ India. .o #ega# privi#eges o$
constitutiona# $unctionaries is superior over te -U.DA/E.,A0 DU,IES
2- CI,I3E.4S 2- I.DIA.
We need rigts to per$orm our duties. Constitution o$ India as
guaranteed tose rigts as -U.DA/E.,A0 5IG6,S to a## citi1ens o$ India
) by birt itse#$ everyone o$ us as secured 6U/A. 5IG6,S as
individua#s. ,o e7press ourse#ves * (e need in$ormation * data $eed
back * to ascertain (eter (e are getting e+ua# opportunity * (eter
(e are getting e+uitab#e &ustice * etc * (e need in$ormation . so *
basica##y 5igt ,o In$ormation is an ina#ienab#e part o$ our
$undamenta# rigts ) uman rigts. Wat 5,I Act as done is $i7ed time
#imit * responsibi#ities o$ pub#ic servants up to certain e7tent.
6o(ever te citi1en4s $undamenta# rigt ) uman rigt to seek
in$ormation e7tends $ar beyond te scope o$ 5,I Act.
6ereby * (e seek comp#ete trut$u# in$ormation $rom supreme court o$
India * (it respect to my 5,I app#ication appea#. 6E5E89 * WE A5E
2.09 SEE'I.G ACC2U.,A8I0I,9 2- PU80IC SE5:A.,S I. PU80IC
I.,E5ES, ) JUS,ICE. 6ereby * (e re+uest you to register tis appea#
as a PI0 petition ) to ascertain te stand o$ ape7 court on various
matters raised in my 5,I App#ication * in pub#ic interest ) e+uitab#e
&ustice.

2e salute honest fe/ in ublic ser0ice & $udiciary & olice & arliament
1 state legislati0e assemblies- our /hole hearted resects to them-
7!3!5Y & I DO 7'M5:Y 3!?'!ST YO' TO (I6! M! 23ITT!. STAT!M!.TS *
A.S2!3S TO T7! #O::O2I.( ?'!STIO.S N 27IC7 I. ITS!:# J ie
ans/ers K A3! T7! I.#O3MATIO. SO'(7T 5Y M!- 7!3! 2IT7 I AM
S!!8I.( .OT T7! OPI.IO.S A5O'T SOM! 7YPOT7!TICA: ISS'!S & 5'T
PO:IC! & P3OS!C'TIO. & !TC- 3!AD D!TAI:S AT "
htts"**sites-google-com*site*eclarionofdalit*/heeling-dealing-)udges-
olice &
Atrocities on Women by JUDGES
ttps!""sites.goog#e.com"site"ec#ariono$da#it"atrocities%by%&udges

A N O of Maniulation of Indian :egal System
http9II""".scri'd.comIdocI0H2C2C37KI.,R,of,Manipulation,of,India,@e!al,
System ,
http9II""".scri'd.comIdocI026HCACA0IChief,>ustice,of,India,.,Criminal ,

>ustice Sathasiam , .re you DD.F DLM% ? %@I)D
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIeclarionofdalitI(ustice,sathasiam,,,are,you,
deaf,dum','lind ,
&a(i :andhi .ssassination Coer,up
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeIra(i,!andhi,
assassination,coer,up ,
S4.MD S4.MD MPs ? M@.s
https9IIsites.!oo!le.comIsiteIsoseoicefor(usticeIshame,shame,mps,mlas
,

7ereby & /e do re+uest PIO O*O 7onourable Chief $ustice of India &
PIO & O*O 7-!-7onorable President of India & PIO O*O 7onorable Sea,er
of :o, Sabha & PIO O*O Dy Chairman of 3a)ya Sabha & PIOs of 8arnata,a
3a) 5ha/an & 8arnata,a CMO & 'nion 7ome Ministry (OI and D( 1 I( of
Police of (o0ernment of 8arnata,a to ans/er the follo/ing +uestions in
ublic interest & for safeguarding national security & .ational unity 1
integrity 1 to legally arehend anti-nationals & criminals /ithin the
)udiciary 1 olice-
Main A "
M- 2hat action you ha0e ta,en against )udges in0ol0ed in
atrocities against /omen & case/ise % if not & /hy %
@- 2hat action you ha0e ta,en against )udges in0ol0ed in land
scams & case/ise % if not & /hy %
Q- I ha0e sho/n /ith actual cases ho/ maniulation * fixing
ta,es lace & from comlaint filing to )udicial ronouncement
stage- Are the )udges 1 olice & abo0e la/ %
>- I ha0e numerous PI:s & 3TI aeals before sureme court of
india- 5ut they /ere not registered & not honoured & /hy %
I- To my legal notice * sho/ cause notice * damage ayment
notice to sureme court of india 1 chief )ustice of india & till date I
ha0e not recei0ed the rely & /hy %
;- Is it not the duty of sureme court of india to rotect the life
1 liberty of all Indian citiDens %
L- Is it not the failure of sureme court of india& /hen it failed
to rotect the life of a comlainant %
E- 5y negligence of their duties & are not sureme court )udges
aiding 1 abetting criminals & anti nationals 1 terrorists %
P- 2hile crores of Indians are barely sur0i0ing on a single iece
meal a day & eole dying due to star0ation & sureme court )udges
are getting salary 1 er,s amounting to la,hs of ruees from the
same suffering ublic * ublic exche+uer- Are not those duty
shir,ing )udges ashamed %
MA- 2hat action you ha0e ta,en against )udges in0ol0ed in hushing
u late rime minister ra)i0 (andhi assassination case %
MM- 2hy the sureme court of india didn4t allo/ me to aear
before it in the said case of late PM 3a)i0 (andhi Assassination
Case %
M@- 2hy the sureme court of india didn4t rotect my life & my )ob
ourtunities & my ne/saer from the /rath of criminal nexus %
MQ- 2hen e0en cable T6 )ournalists & /eb )ournalists are getting
P3!SS * M!DIA accreditation & my /eb ne/s aers & myself are not
getting P3!SS accreditation since P years & /hy %
M>- Are the sureme court )udges hand in glo0es /ith the
criminal nexus %

Main 5 "
You ha0e not ta,en aroriate action to my re0ious 3TI re+uests &
.umerous aeals for )ustice 1 olice comlaints- You ha0e not relied
to sho/-cause notice also- Your inaction has heled the criminals in
maniulating 1 destroying e0idences-

Your inaction * delay in erforming your duties not only amounts to
denial of information & but amounts to 0iolation of our fundamental 1
human rights & co0er-u of crimes & aiding 1 abetting criminals - The
criminal nexus tried to silence me in many /ays- Is not these acts of
your4s a crime in itself %

If your acts of crime co0er-us & information * e0idence co0er-us &
aiding 1 abetting criminals & silencing a crusader is )ust 1 legal- The
same tye of acts of crimes erformed by other citiDens /ill also be legal
%

Main C "
At the outset & /e exress our /hole hearted resects to all
constitutional institutions 1 to the honest fe/ in ublic ser0ice-
Contemt of constitutional institutions & citiDens of India is being made
by the corrut ersons in constitutional ositions themsel0es- This is an
aeal to the honest fe/ in ublic ser0ice & constitutional ositions & to
bring their corrut colleagues to boo,-

M- does the action of MPs & M:As ta,ing money * recei0ing
fa0ors from 0ested interests & to formulate olicy decisions & to raise
+uestions in arliament * legislati0e bodies or to abstain from 0oting
legal %
@- /hy transarent & fair in0estigation is not done in such
cases %
Q- )ust remember & the 0ulgar acts of Mr-5ora 5abu Singh in
state legislature 1 ho/ some M:As 0ulgarly beha0ed /ith Ms-$ayalalita
in state legislature & years ago- Are these tye of 0ulgar actions by MPs 1
M:As legal % does not these constitute contemt of the house by MPs 1
M:As themsel0es %
>- all the eole4s reresentati0es from anchayath member
to resident of India must read A5CD Of Democracy ro0ide along
/ith-since indeendence of India till date & MPs 1 M:As are forcing
ro)ects on eole against the /ishes of eole & formulating olicies
against the /ishes of eole- Are not such ro)ects & go0ernment olicies
1 :a/s & undemocratic 1 illegal %
I- is the election commission of India 0erifying the
authenticity of affida0its submitted by electoral candidates %
;- ho/ many candidates ha0e been caught so far for gi0ing
false affida0its % are all the 0iolators rosecuted%
L- are the MPs & M:As submitting their /ealth details on
affida0its yearly to 0igilance authorities % defaulters & 0iolators ho/ many
%
E- /hat legal action ta,en against 0iolators & defaulters & for
gi0ing false affida0its %
P- /ho is chec,ing the authenticity of those affida0its
submitted by MPs & M:As %
MA- the agricultural incomes of some MPs & M:As & their ,ih 1 ,in
raises e0en during the time of se0ere drought & floods & fall in rices of
agricultural roducts & their comanies register increase in turno0er *
rofits e0en during recession & the trusts * .(Os set u by them recei0e
huge donations- Are all these income legal %

Main D "
M- /e do once again offer our conditional ser0ices to the
go0ernment of india & all state go0ernments 1 sureme court of india & in
arehending tax e0aders & land grabbers & corrut olice & corrut
)udges & corrut ublic ser0ants & labor la/ 0iolators & etc- /hom the the
go0ernment officials & 0igilance authorities ha0e failed to arehend-
2hy the authorities & courts & sureme court of India & are not ready to
utiliDe our ser0ice % are they afraid of being caught %
@- the ublic ser0ants & courts thesel0es are delaying gi0ing
information * records to us in many cases- So in the issues * cases raised
by us & the clause of time bar doe not aly- Are these delaying tactics of
ublic ser0ants & courts legal %
Q- /hy no roer & timely action /as not ta,en based on
numerous olice comlaints made by us %
>- /hy D( 1 I(P & (o0ernment of 8arnata,a & has not made
any efforts to see, legal sanction for rosecution of 66IPs J mentioned in
our comlaint K & from union 1 state home ministries %
I- the criminal nexus is trying to silence me in many /ays &
but the sureme court of India 1 national human rights commission has
failed to undo the in)ustices & /hy % is it because it is not a high rofile
case % is it because it is not hi-fi & does not get image ratings & T3Ps %
;- the ublic ser0ants are aiding under/orld & naxalites 1
terrorists & by their delaying tactics 1 denial of information & records-
2hat action has been ta,en against such anti-national elements in ublic
ser0ice %
L- ho/ many comlaints are made by .agara) -M-3- & 7uman
3ights Acti0ist & Mysore Jeditor of SOS e-clarion of dalit 1 SOS e-0oice for
)usticeK to 8arnata,a olice & to national human rights commission to
sureme court of India till date % /hat action ta,en /ith resect to each
comlaint %
E- the delay in ta,ing action by ublic ser0ants /ith resect
to follo/ing cases has resulted in more crimes & destruction *
maniulation of e0idences & records and more in)ustices to commonman-
2hy the authorities did not ta,e timely action against criminals in
follo/ing cases %

S2S Appea# to SUP5E/E C2U5, o$ I.DIA
ttp!""e%c#ariono$da#it.b#ogspot.com";<=<"<>"s%o%s%appea#%to%supreme%
?
DEA0S I. C2U5,S ) P20ICE S,A,I2.S 5EAD !
ttp!""sites.goog#e.com"site"ec#ariono$da#it"satyameva%&ayate *
ttp!""e%c#ariono$da#it.b#ogspot.com";<=="<="satyameva%&ayate.tm# *
ACCUSED Cie$ Justice o$ India
ttp!""sites.goog#e.com"site"ec#ariono$da#it"accused%cie$%&ustice%o$?
*
ttp!""e%c#ariono$da#it.b#ogspot.com";<=="<;"accused%cie$%&ustice%o$?
C52SS E@A/ 2- 62.2U5A80E C6IE- JUS,ICE 2- I.DIA * SUP5E/E C2U5,
2-
I.DIA %
ttp!""crossc&i.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""crosse7amo$cie$&ustice.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""crimeso$supremecourt.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""crossc&i.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""crosse7amo$cie$&ustice.(ordpress.com" *
C52SS E@A/ 2- U.I2. 62/E SEC5E,A59 * G2I * .EW DE06I A
C52SS E@A/ 2- DG)IG 2- P20ICE * G2' * 8A.GA025E A
C52SS E@A/ 2- G2:E5.25 * 5ESE5:E 8A.' 2- I.DIA
ttp!""te$tinrbi.b#ogspot.com" * ttp!""te$tinrbi.redi$$b#ogs.com"
* ttp!""te$tinrbi.(ordpress.com"
C52SS E@A/ 2- /UDA C2//ISSI2.E5 * /UDA * /9S25E A
ttp!""crimeso$muda.b#ogspot.com" * ttp!""manivannanmuda.b#ogspot.
com"
* ttp!""crimesatmudamysore.(ordpress.com" *
C52SS E@A/ 2- 8DA C2//ISSI2.E5 * 8DA * 8A.GA025E A
ttp!""crimeso$bda.b#ogspot.com" * ttp!""bdacrimes.(ordpress.com" *
C25P25A,E C5I/ES 5PG CA80ES 0I/I,ED
ttp!""crimesatrpg.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""crimesatrpg.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message";=>
/EGA -5AUD 89 G2:E5./E., 2- I.DIA
ttp!""mega$raudbygoi.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""mega$raudbygoi.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message"=BC
are you ready to catc ta7 tieves D
/28I0E P62.ES * CU55E.C9 SCA.DA0S
re#iance industry (ere is accountabi#ity D
crimes at in$osys campus
ttp!""crimeatin$y.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""crimeatin$y.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message";=E
crimes by 8.D.A against a poor (oman
ttp!""crimeso$bda.b#ogpot.com" *
ttp!""bdacrimes.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message";=;
crimes o$ #and ma$ia in India
ttp!""#andscamsinindia.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""#andscam.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message";=;
currency te$ts in 58I Press
ttp!""te$tinrbi.b#ogspot.com" *
ttp!""te$tinrbi.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message"><
ki##er co#as ) ki##er medicines o$ India
ttp!""deatco#a.b#ogpot.com" *
ttp!""deatco#a.(ordpress.com" *
ttp!""groups.yaoo.com"group"nagr("message";<=
62.25 2- I.DIA. PA0IA/E., -25 SA0E
htt"**sites-google-com*site*eclarionofdalit*honor-of-indian-arliament-
for-sale
Persecuted I3OM S7A3MI:A of Puttaarthi AP N usha ,olasani on
hunger stri,e in anantaur district )ail Andhra Pradesh
htt"**sites-google-com*site*eclarionofdalit*ersecuted-irom-sharmila-of-
uttaarthi-a

P- ho/ many )udges are caught by authorities for doing
imroer & immoral 1 illegal acts & since indeendence till date % /hat
action ta,en in each case %
MA- /hat action ta,en against coy cat )udges caught red handed
/hile coying in ublic examination in Andhra Pradesh %
MM- ha0e you re0ie/ed all the re0ious )udicial decisions ta,en
by such )udges of doubtful integrity 1 honesty %
M@- is it not the duty of go0ernment 1 sureme court of India & to
rotect the fundamental rights 1 human rights of all Indian citiDens %
MQ- /hy the go0ernment 1 sureme court of India has failed to
rotect the fundamental rights 1 human rights of me 1 those
mentioned in my comlaint %
M>- ho/ many former C$Is & sureme court 1 high court )udges
ha0e disroortionate /ealth %
MI- Your denial of information to my re0ious 3TI re+uests
amounts to suression of e0idence & hiding crimes & /hat action against
erring ublic ser0ants %
M;- /hy my re0ious 3TI re+uests or art there of /as not
transferred to aroriate authorities and information gi0en to me in a
consolidated form %

Main ! "
?M- 2hy not death sentence to corrut olice /ho murder eole in in
loc,-u * fa,e encounters %
?@- 2hy not death sentence to corrut olice /ho aly Q
rd
degree
torture on risoners %
?Q- 2hy not death sentence to corrut olice & /ho conni0e /ith
criminals 1 bac,stabs our motherland & it4s national security %
?>- Don4t the olice ha0e suo-motto o/ers to ta,e action in the interest
of ublic /elfare & la/ 1 order %
?I- Daily /e see numerous reorts of misdeeds by olice & ublic
ser0ants & industrialists & etc in the media - Then /hy not olice ta,ing
any action /ith resect to them %
?;- no/adays /e see numerous reorts of scams & scandals by
constitutional functionaries & ublic ser0ants in the media- Instead of
/asting money & ,illing time by rolonging formation of arliamentary
committees & )udicial commissions & /hy not sub)ect those accussed
ublic ser0ants to narco analysis & lie deector test & etc to ascertain truth
1 ro0ide timely )ustice %
?L- If a commonman files a comlaint & olice * courts /ants e0idences &
/itnesses to ta,e action against the rich 1 mighty croo,s- 2here as if a
rich erson )ust gi0es a comlaint against a oor cha & he is arrested &
tortured e0enthough there are no e0idences & /itnesses- 2hy this double
standard %
?E- If a oor cha tries to collect e0idences as er his fundamental rights
or as er 3TI ACT & the ublic ser0ants don4t gi0e full & truthfull
information- Still & olice * courts don4t ta,e action against those ublic
ser0ants hiding crimes- 2hy %
?P-/hy I /as not ermitted to aear as an Samicus curieT before )ain
commission of en+uiry or sureme court of india robing late rime
minister ra)i0 (andhi assassination case %
?MA- The criminal nexus tried to silence me & by closing my ne/s aer &
by snatching a/ay my )ob ourtunities in go0ernment ser0ice& by
hysically assaulting me & by threatening me of false fix-us in cases 1 by
attemts to murder me- 5ut no action against culrits & /hy %
?MM- 2hereas & I /as en+uired number of times by olice 1 intelligence
ersonnel about this case & but the culrits /ere not en+uired e0en
once & /hy %
?M@-/ho comensates the losses I ha0e suffered due to these in)ustices %
are not olice resonsible for it %
?MQ- Is it not the duty of olice to rotect the li0es & li0elihood of
/itnesses 1 all arties in0ol0ed & both during case 1 after/ards %
?M>- 7o/ do you monitor 1 chec, corrut olice ersonnel 1 increase in
their family4s /ealth year after year %
?MI- 2hile getting aointed into go0ernment ser0ice from the ran, of
eon to IAS officer & olice 0erification is mandatory- 2hile aointing to
sensiti0e defense establishments & research institutes in addition to
olice 0erification & central intelligence agencies cross-chec, candidate4s
bac,ground- 7o/e0er is there no bac,ground chec,s of constitutional
functionaries & MPs & M:As & & /ho are ri0y to national secrets % /hy %
?M;- 3ecently & the oosition arties ha0e made allegations during
residential allegations that close relati0e of one of the front running
candidates ha0e s/indled ublic money by their ban, & misused ublic
money through one of their .(O- Is it true %
?ML-has (OI funded any terrorist outfits in india or abroad %
?ME-india reaches non-0iolence & anchasheel rinciles to the /orld-
In india & more than half the oulation are oor & eole are star0ing to
death- Insite these bac,ground & (OI funded 1 aided terrorist outfits in
former east Pa,istan ensuring the creation of 5angladesh & (OI has
funded 1 aided terrorist outfits li,e :TT! & T':# & !TC in srilan,a & M?M
in Pa,istan- In turn these terrorist outfits ha0e murdered thousands of
innocents in those countries- Are these acts of (OI )ust 1 legal % Is not
(OI resonsible for all those murders of innocents % has (OI aid any
comensation to those 0ictims or their family mebers % /hy not %
?MP-/ithin india & to reduce the influence of certain terrorist grous &
(OI has funded 1 aided couter terrorist grous & is it right 1 legal %
?@A- In $har,hand & chattisgarh & etc & the go0ernment has armed &
trained 1 funded Ssal/a )udumT to counter naxalites- Sal/a )udum
cadres are terroriDing innocents )ust li,e naxalites- Is this action of
go0ernment )ust 1 legal %
?@M-in india& TADA & POTA is being ramantly misused by olice- !0en
/here there are no roblems of terrorism & TADA * POTA is being slaed
against innocents & e0en children- In M-M-7ills of 8arnata,a state & ST#
ersonnel charged tribal eole /ith TADA on fri0olous charges of ta,ing
lunch to 0eeraan & stiching dress for the forest brigand& etc- /here as
the rominent olitical& film & sorts ersonalities /ho ha0e lin,s /ith
under/orld & anti national elements 1 attended arties hosted by
da/ood Ibrahim & other dons in gulf countries & else /here- 5ut these hi-
fi eole are not charged /ith TADA * POTA % /hy %
?@@- #ilm actor san)ay dutt had contacts /ith under/orld 1 fully
,no/ing /ell the criminal ob)ecti0es of criminals & hid the dangerous
arms 1 ammunition in his home & /hich /ere intended for terroriDing
ublic- 7o/e0er mr-dutt is not charged /ith TADA * POTA instead he is
charged /ith illegal ossession of arms act J /hich is normally alied to
farmers /ho use illegal home made guns to scare a/ay animals & birds in
their farms K- 2hy this fa0ourable treatment of mr-dutt by olice %
rosecution % is this because dutt is olitically mighty 1 rich %
?@Q- :a/ is one 1 same for all & the ublic ser0ants& olice interretes &
enforces it differentially bet/een rich 1 oor % /hy this differentiation %
?@>-recently in 5angalore olice nabbed criminals belonging to
international criminal syndicate selling dulicate no,ia mobiles- !0ery
no,ia mobile comes /ith MI digit IM!I number & this number is also used
by olice for trac,ing criminals- In consumer disute at consumer
disutes redressal forum Mysore CD >P*AI & no,ia comany stated that all
it4s roducts come /ith IM!I number only 1 stated that the roduct in
disute sold by tata indicom dealer M*S I.TOTO COMM'.ICATIO.S &
Mysore are not their4s as it doesn4t ha0e IM!I numbers- #urther no,ia
stated they don4t ha0e any business relationshi /ith either tata indicom
or it4s dealer- 7o/e0er the tata indicom dealer stated that indeed his
roducts are genuine & first hand roducts & but doesn4t ha0e IM!I
numbers - this ro0es the dealer in collusion /ith tata comany is selling
illegal no,ia mobile hand sets 1 cheating the ublic- These mobiles are
e0ading taxes & as /ell as these are /ithout IM!I numbers best buy for
criminal elements /ho /ant to e0ade olice trac,ing- 2hat olice are
doing
?@I- 2ho & of /hich ran, among olice ersonnel ta,es the decision to
close a case ie to file S5T reort & /hen after certain time limit no leads
are found in in0estigation %
?@;- 7o/ do you monitor corrut olice ersonnel & /ho urosefully
fail to in0estigate case roerly & so that either the case can be closed
/ith S5T reort or the rosecution fails to ro0e the case in court %
?@L- 2ho among olice ta,es the decision to aeal against the 0erdict
of a lo/er court & /hen the rosecution fails %
?@E- 2ho too, the decision & not to aeal against the argentina court
order ac+uitting mr-+uatrochi accussed in bofors scandal %
?@P- Do you treat all the rison con0icts same in the rison or does the
notorious big time rich criminals get sacious barrac,s /ith t0& ne/s
aer & ade+uate food & medical care & etc /hile small time criminals &
oor are crammed into ig sty li,e rooms /ith ;A-LA inmates /ithout any
basic re+uirements %
?QA- 2hat is the status of my comlaint made to the D( 1 I( of olice &
go0ernment of 8arnata,a on MA*M@*@AA> % the coies of comlaint /as
released at ress meet at atra,artara bha0an Mysore on same day& e0en
coies /ere gi0en to olice 1 intelligence ersonnel %
?QM- 2hy no action & rely regarding the comlaint till date %
?Q@- Our constitutional frame /or,ers ga0e legal immunity ri0ileges to
certain constitutional functionaries & so that they are not burdened /ith
fri0olous court cases 1 can concentrate on their constitutional duties-
5ut these ri0ileges doesn4t co0er the indi0idual actions of those ublic
ser0ants li,e rae & murder & do/ry harassment & tax e0asion & misuse of
office & etc- but still la/ enforcement * olice deartment is bound to
send re+uest to home ministry see,ing ermission 1 home ministry sits
o0er files for months- This gi0es the accussed amle time to destroy
e0idences- Is it right 1 legal %
?QQ- Does legal immunity ri0ileges co0er their official actions alone % if
not /hat does it co0er %
?Q>- 2hat is the time limit for home ministry to gi0e sanction for the
rosecution of tainted constitutional functionaries %
?QI- 7o/ many resent MPs & M:As & M'.ICIAPA: CO3PO3ATO3S & other
eole4s reresentati0es are facing criminal charges %
?Q;- In the ast & ho/ many MPs & M:As & cororators /ere facing
criminal charges & year/ise since MPEL % ho/ many of them /ere
e0entually con0icted %
?QL- 7o/ many MPs & M:As & rominent film & sorts ersonalities ha0e
ha0e contacts /ith under/orld & foreign intelligence agencies %
?QE- 7o/ many of them ha0e attended fre+uent arties hosted by
under/orld dons in gulf countries & else /here %
?QP- 7o/ many MP & M:A & other eole4s reresentati0es are /anted by
olice in 0arious cases - but sho/n in the olice records as absconding
but in reality are attending the roceedings of the house as usual %
?>A- 2hen did smt- Sonia (andhi became a citiDen of india % did she
occuy any ublic office before naturaliDation %
?>M- In india & ho/ many MPs & M:As & M:Cs are of foreign origin or ha0e
a souse of foreign origin %
?>@- Does smt- Sonia (andhi ha0e citiDenshi of any other country %
?>Q- Did she occuy any ublic office /hile en)oying dual citiDenshi %
?>>- 7o/ do you monitor ublic ser0ants /ho ha0e souses of foreign
origin 1 /hile they are on foreign tour & from national security
ersecti0e %
?>I- Is mr- M-S S'55A member of arliament a citiDen of india %
?>;- 2hat is the status of comlaint made by former union minister
mr-subramanya s/amy alleging that late P-M ra)i0 gandhi4s family
recei0ed money from foreign intelligence agencies %
?>L- In many cases li,e mass riots in0ol0ing certain olitical arties &
/hen that culrit arty comes to o/er all the cases in0ol0ing it4s
artymen are /ithdra/n by the go0ernment orelse rosecution fails to
ro0e it4s case 1 refers not to aeal- $ust remember 5ombay riot case
in0ol0ing shi0 saini,s 1 others & /hen shi0 sena N 5$P came to o/er in
Maharashtra & all the cases against it4s artymen /ere /ithdra/n- Are
these tye of decisions by go0ernment )ust 1 legal %
?>E-/hat damages has been done to india4s national security due to mole
in the PMO& as alleged by former union minister mr-nat/ar singh %
?>P- 2hat action by the go0ernment %
?IA- 7o/ many Indians are in the custody of olice * military in 0arious
foreign countries %
?IM- 7o/ many foreigners are there in Indian risons %
?I@- 7o/ (OI is rotecting the human rights of these risoners %
?IQ- Is the go0ernment aying any comensation to 0ictims of olice
failures & fix-us & & /ho suffer in )ail for years 1 ac+uitted by courts
uon finding them as not guilty %
?I>- Do you register murder charges * attemt to murder charges against
guilty olice officers /ho are resonsible for loc,-u deaths & fa,e
encounters 1 Q
rd
degree torture %
?II- 7o/ many cases has been filed since MPEL till date %
?I;- 2hat action has been ta,en against guilty olice officers & ST#
ersonnel /ho /ere resonsible for gross human rights 0iolations &
Q
rd
degree torture & loc,-u deaths of innocents in forest brigand
0eeraan4s territory & based on )ustice A-$-Sadashi0a commission
findings % if not /hy %
?IL- I & as a citiDen of india as my Sfundamental dutyT hereby do offer
my conditional ser0ices to (OI 1 (O8 to arehend corrut ublic
ser0ants- Are you ready to utiliDe my ser0ices %
?IE- Police ersonnel are al/ays in the forefront of containing crimes &
mass fury & riots & etc- they suffer more 1 e0en their family members
suffer threats from the criminal elements- Do the go0ernment ro0ide
insurance co0erage to olice 1 their family members on the lines of
defense forces %
?IP- 2hat is the amount of co0erage to a olice constable 1 his family %
?;A- 2ho ma,es the remium contributions %
?;M- Do the go0ernment ro0ide o0ertime allo/ance & food allo/ance to
olice /ho daily /or, beyond E hours of duty %
?;@- Is the go0ernment gi0ing any training to olice ersonnel in ublic
interaction & human rights %
?;Q- Is it right to ost rofessionally trained olice to sentry & orderly
duties of ministers %
?;>- 2hat is the ratio of olice ersonnel to total oulation in india
since MPEL %
?;I- IS T7! (O6!3.M!.T (I6I.( AD!?'AT! #OOD& M!DICA: CA3! &
C:OT7I.( & :I6I.( SPAC! TO P3ISO. I.MAT!S & AS 3!?'I3!D 5Y A
.O3MA: 7'MA. !I.( ACCO3DI.( TO 2-7-O .O3MS %
?;;- Is the forensic science deartment /hich conducts narcfo-analysis &
lie-detector test & etc under the control of olice deartment %
?;L- Is it not right to ut it under imartial control of .73C or li,e
bodies %
?;E- Is the action of some olice officers arranging comromise meetings
1 subtly insisting the oor to to/ the line of rich or else face the
conse+uences & is it right 1 legal % this haens mostly in real estate
matters-
?;P- Did go0ernment ma,e any ransom ayments to forest brigand
0eeraan during his 0arious ,idnaings %
?LA- 2hat action has been ta,en based on re0ealations by ,arim telgi
during narco analysis about ublic ser0ants in0ol0ement %
?LM- 7o/ many cases of allegations against )udges /ere made in the
media about misuse of office & criminal acts by )udges from munsiff court
to sureme court of India % since MP>L till date
?L@- are the en+uiry reort findings& action ta,en reorts of such cases
accessible to ublic % if not /hy %
?LQ- /hat action has been ta,en against guilty )udges %
?L>- are the guilty )udges legally rosecuted in all such cases % or has it
)ust ended /ith their resignation from ser0ices or his suerior )udge not
allotting him any )udicial /or, %
?LI- /hy some high ran,ing )udges are not legally rosecuted for their
/rong doings %
?L;- are )udges abo0e la/ % are not e0erybody e+ual before la/ %
?LL- do the )udiciary sub)ect & all the cases handled by accussed *
tainted & guilty )udges to re0ie/ & to undo ast un)ust )udgements %
?LE- ho/ % if not /hy %
?LP- ho/ do the )udiciary monitor the net /ealth gro/th of some )udges
including the /ealth in the name of )udge4s family members %
?EA- do all the )udges file their annual income & /ealth statements on
s/orn affida0its to the higher )udiciary % defaulters ho/ many %
?EM- ho/ does the )udiciary 0erifies those statements %
?E@- is such statements made ublic & on /eb %
?EQ- /hen the )udgement of a lo/er court is turned do/n by the higher
court & /hat action is initiated against lo/er court )udge for ma,ing
un)ust )udgement 1 meating out in)ustice %
?E>- /hen allegations of corrution & misuse of office & etc against )udges
are made & /hy the accussed N )udges are not sub)ected to tests li,e
Soly grah & lie detector & brain maing & etcT & in the interest of
)ustice 1 truth %
?EI- )udges are not emloyees of go0ernment & so they are ineligible to
be the members of S8arnata,a state go0ernment )udicial deartment
house building co-oerati0e societyT- Then ho/ come & many )udges
including sureme court )udges are admitted as members of this society
1 allotted rime residential site /orth crores of ruees for a fe/
thousands by the said society at said society4s N )udicial layout &
yelahan,a & 5angalore % /hile the ordinary members li,e eons & cler,s in
)udicial deartment are /aiting for a site since years & is not the /hole
thing grossly illegal %
?E;- in more than LAG of cases before all courts in India & central
go0ernment or state go0ernment or go0ernment agency is one of the
arties- 7o/ many )udges or their family members & ha0e recei0ed out of
turn & fa0ourable allotments of sites & gas agency & etrol ums & etc by
the go0ernment % is not such allotments illegal % /hat action %
?EL- /hen a erson under olice custody or )udicial custody suffer
Q
rd
degree torture by olice & is not the )udge of the resecti0e court
/hich is handling that tortured erson4s case resonsible for it %
?EE- has the higher )udiciary legally rosecuted resecti0e )udges 1 the
olice officers for committing Q
rd
degree torture & on charges of attemt
to murder 1 murder % if not /hy %
?EP- registrar & Mysore district 1 sessions court & has called for the
candidatures to 0arious 0acancies in that court from the ublic 0ide
notification no " ADM.*A*MAE@I*@AAQ dated MP*MM*@AAQ- Please furnish
me the merit ran,ing list of selected candidates along /ith my merit
ran,ing for the ost of eon-
?PA- registrar & 5angalore city ci0il court & has called for the
candidatures to 0arious 0acancies in that court from the ublic 0ide
notification no " ADM-IJAK>@@*AQ dated MP*AI*@AAQ- Please furnish me
merit ran,ing list of selected candidates for the ost of eon-
?PM- /hen a erson doesn4t get ade+uate food & medical care /hile
under olice custody or )udicial custody & is not the resecti0e )udge
dealing that erson4s case resonsible for it % /hat action %
?P@- ho/ )udiciary is monitoring food 1 medical care to risoners %
?PQ- numerous accussed ersons are suffering in )ail under )udicial
custody & for eriods far exceeding the legally stiulated sentence
eriods- #or examle " a ic,-oc,eter is in )ail for one year & the )udge
finds him guilty of offence 1 gi0es him Q months sentence- 2hat about
the excess unishment of P months- Is not the )udge resonsible for the
illegal & excess unishment of the con0ict % /hat action against the )udge
in such cases %
?P>- numerous innocents suffer in )ail for years 1 finally the )udge finds
them as innocents 1 ac+uits them of the charges- 2hat about the rison
sentence & the innocent has already ser0ed % is not the )udge resonsible
for this illegal & un)ust unishment to an innocent % remedy % /hat action
against the )udge %
?PI- does the ri0ileges of )udges co0er both their official actions 1 the
actions arising out of misuse of office %
?P;- does the ri0ileges of )udges co0er both their official actions as
)udges 1 their ersonal actions as indi0iduals %
?PL- are the fundamental rights of citiDens sureme or the ri0ileges of
)udges & constitutional functionaries sureme %
?PE- /hat is the criteria adoted for romotion of )udges %
?PP- /hat is the criteria adoted for aointment of ad0ocates from
bar & as the )udges %
?MAA- /hat is the criteria adoted for aointment of retired )udges & as
go0ernors of states & members or as chairman of commissions & etc %
?MAM- ho/ many )udges belonging to oressed classes N scheduled
caste & scheduled tribe & other bac,/ard classes & minorities 1 /omen
are their in sureme court & state high courts 1 subordinate courts %
,indly ro0ide secific figures -
?MA@- /hat are the legal measures enforced by )udiciary & to enforce the
accountability of )udges 1 to chec, corrution in )udiciary %
?MAQ- are not these measures a failure & loo,ing at resent state of
affairs of )udiciary %
?MA>- does the )udges arrange for distribution of alchoholic drin,s at the
official meetings & arties & at the tax ayer4s exense %
?MAI- does any )udges ha0e included their consumtion of alchoholic
drin,s & in their hotel bill 1 claimed tra0eling allo/ance %
?MA;- /hat action has been ta,en against N selectors ie 8arnata,a high
court )udges 1 ne/ly selected /omen )udges in0ol0ed in roost resort
scandal in Mysore & 8arnata,a %
?MAL- /hen common eole * tax ayers 1 e0en go0ernment emloyees
are not getting roer health care from go0ernment at go0ernment
hositals- Is it right 1 )ust to ro0ide remium health care to )udges &
constitutional functionaries at I-star ri0ate hositals in India & abroad &
all at tax ayer4s exense %
?MAE- are the )udges sub)ected to eriodical health chec,-us to
ascertain their health & mental faculties 1 mental balance in the midst of
all /or, ressures & emotional tensions %
?MAP- /hat is the criteria adoted by )udiciary for acceting alications
see,ing ublic interest litigations %
?MMA- /hy numerous aeals for PI: by me & /ere not considered %
?MMM- /hat is the criteria adoted by )udiciary & for aointing Samicus
curieT in a case %
?MM@- /hy my aeal to honourable sureme court & to ma,e me as an
Samicus curieT in late P-M 3a)i0 (andhi4s assassination case & /as not
considered by the court %
?MMQ- /hat is the criteria adoted by )udiciary & for initiating suo-motto
action %
?MM>- numerous cases of in)ustices are reorted in the media daily & /ith
suorting e0idences - /hy not the )udiciary ta,e suo-motto action in all
such cases %
?MMI- legal aid boards re-)udge the cases in the name of ta,ing legal
oinion & before ro0iding legal aid to the needy % is it not needy
erson4s rights 0iolation %
?MM;- is not the safety of /itnesses & arties in cases resonsibility of the
court & both during hearing of the case 1 after/ards %
?MML- is the use of Q
rd
degree torture by olice on risoners & during the
olice custody * )udicial custody * rison sentence right % /hat action %
?MME- /hen the corrut olice officer 1 go0ernment rosecution
ad0ocate together co0er-u e0idences & conducts imroer in0estigation
intentionally to fail the case N to co0er-u rich croo,s & high 1 mighty
eole & /hat action )udge ta,es in such cases %
?MMP- ho/ does the )udiciary monitor the /ealth gro/th of olice &
go0ernment ad0octes & tax officials & officials of licensing authorities & to
ensure roer 1 fair rosecution of cases against rich 1 mighty %
?M@A- /hat are the status of aeals made by human rights acti0ist
.A(A3A$-M-3- to the honourable sureme court of India %
?M@M- corrution is ramant for selection of officers to +uasi-)udicial
ositions li,e district * talu, magistrates & tax officers & re0enue officers &
land ac+uisition officers & etc- ho/ the )udiciary monitors o0er their
+uasi-)udicial actions %
?M@@- sub)ect to conditions & I & .A(A3A$-M-3- & editor & e-0oice of
human rights /atch & do offer my free ser0ices to honourable sureme
court of India & to arehend corrut )udges & are you N the honourable
court ready to utiliDe it %
?M@Q- /hat are the status of my aeals & sent to the honourable
sureme court of India & through go0ernment of india4s on-line grie0ance
system J DP( 1 DA3P( K "
DP(*M*@AA;*EAAAE & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AAAIL& DA3P(*!*@AA;*AA@@I &
DP(*M*@AA;*EAA@M & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AA@IQ & DP(*M*@AA;*EAAQ@ &
DA3P(*!*@AA;*AMM>P & DP(*M*@AA;*EAA>L & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AMM;> &
DP(*M*@AA;*EAA>Q & DP(*M*@AA;*EAAEI & DA3P(*!*@AA;*A;LA> &
DA3P(*!*@AA;*ALAML & DA3P(*!*@AA;*ALAME & DP(*M*@AA;*EAMIP &
DP(*M*@AA;*EAM;@ & DA3P(*!*@AA;*ALE;> & DP(*M*@AA;*EAM;I &
DA3P(*!*@AA;*ALELL & DP(*M*@AA;*EAM;L & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AEA@E &
DA3P(*!*@AA;*AEA@P & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AEAQ@ & DA3P(*!*@AA;*AEA>Q &
DA3P(*!*@AA;*AEA>> & DP(*M*@AA;*EAML> & DP(*M*@AA;*EAMPQ &
DA3P(*!*@AAL*AAA>> & DP(*M*@AAL*EAAAQ & DP(*M*@AAL*EAAMA &
DA3P(*!*@AAL*AAM;> & DA3P(*!*@AAL*AAM;I & DP(*M*@AAL*EAAM> &
DP(*M*@AAL*EAA@I & DP(*M*@AAL*EAA>P & DP(*M*@AAL*EAAII &
DP(*M*@AAL*EAAI; & DP(*M*@AAL*EAALE & DP(*M*@AAL*EAAE@ &
DA3P(*!*@AAL*A@;ME
?M@>- the aeals made to the honourable sureme court of India &
coies of /hich are a0ailable at follo/ing /eb ages
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/*message*ME@ &
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/*message*@A; &
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/*message*@AE &
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/*message*@M@ &
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/*message*@AP &
htt"**grous-yahoo-com*grou*naghr/
/hat are the status of those aeals %
?M@I- in the media & /e ha0e seen reorts about )udges committing
crimes N rae & attemt to murder & s/indling go0ernment money &
untouchability ractice & the disresect to national flag & sale of )udicial
orders & bail & receit of monetary gains by /ay of royalty for boo,s &
rime real estate urchase at discounted rate & ta,ing round about long
foreign tours along /ith family in the name of official /or, & etc- by this
/ay & )udges themsel0es are ma,ing contemt of court & constitution of
India 1 citiDens of India- 7o/ you are rotecting the honour of the
)udiciary & constitution of India 1 citiDens of India % lease ans/er-
?M@;- Is the go0ernment gi0ing any facilities * affirmati0e actions to
olicemen4s family as being gi0en to defense ersonnel & ex-ser0icemen
1 their families & li,e referential site allotment & lg agency & ration
deot & reser0ation in college admission & soft ban, loans & etc %
?M@;- if not & /hy % after all & the contribution of olice to national
security is on ar /ith defense forces-
?M@L- is not some high olice officials addressing their subordinates in
singular term & abusing them /ith 0ulgar /ords /rong %
?M@E- is not some olice ersonnel calling ublic /ith singular term&
abusing ublic /ith 0ulgar /ords /rong %
?M@P- is it not the duty of rison authorities to rotect the health& li0es
of rison in-mates %
?MQA-/hat action is ta,en against olice ersonnel /ho /rongly charged
an innocent erson of criminal acts & resulting in his confinement in )ail &
finally ac+uitted by court as found to be innocent %
?MQM- is it not right to /ith hold salary & gratuity & ension to such guilty
olice ersonnel 1 ay it as comensation to 0ictims of olice failures 1
atrocities %
?MQ@- does our Indian constitution legally ermit a citiDen of foreign
origin naturaliDed by marriage to an Indian or naturaliDed by otion & to
occuy any constitutional office %
?MQQ- during british rule in india 1 0arious other british colonies &
criminal cases /ere foisted against our freedom fighters in India 1 other
british colonies- After india4s indeendence /hat haened to those
cases % did our Indian go0ernment close all such cases or did it continue
/ith the rosecution %
?MQ>- in ho/ many cases (OI 1 other state go0ernment continued /ith
the rosecution A(AI.ST O'3 #3!!DOM #I(7T!3S % /hy %
?MQI- /hat about the status of cases against shri-neta)i subash Chandra
bose %
?MQ;- has (OI deorted any freedom fighters to 5ritain or it4s colonies &
to face rosecution after India gained indeendence % 7AS (OI 3!C!I6!D
A.Y 3!?'!ST #3OM 53ITAI. TO T7AT !##!CT % if yes & /hy & /hom %
?-MQL- the honourable sureme court of India failed ro0ide information
to me as er my 3TI re+uest aeal no " PM * @AAL in resonse to your
letter no " #M * 3TI * A-PM * @AAL dt MQ-M@-AL & /hy %
?MQE - the honourable union home secretary failed to gi0e me
information as er my rti re+uest & he transferred my alication to
others & in turn they transferred the alication to some others- #inally &
comlete truthful information /as not gi0en & /hy % as the union home
secretary has got coies of all those relies in resonse to transferred 3TI
alication & /ill he send me a consolidated rely to my resent 3TI
re+uest %
?MQP- in a high rofile case before the honourable delhi high court & /e
ha0e seen ho/ defense ad0ocate mr- 3-S-A.A.D 1 rosecution ad0ocate
mr- I-'-87A. made a secret act to /in the case in fa0our of rich
criminal & totally maniulating rosecution /itnesses & e0idences 1
rosecution stand & totally ma,ing moc,ery of )ustice system - ho/ you
are ensuring the deli0ery of )ustice & there being numerous such
ad0ocates in ractice %
?M>A- Smt- Sonia (andhi is erson of foreign origin & she /ields
enormous clout more than the Prime Minister himself o0er the
go0ernment of India being the chair erson of 'PA- Is she legally
ermitted to summon confidential official records & minutes of the
cabinet & to hold the cabinet meeting of union ministers %
?M>M- As er la/ & is she ermitted to hold constitutional offices li,e
rime minister of India or resident of India & etc %
?-M>@- 2hat are the fundamental rights of a citiDen guaranteed under
the constitution JArticle @MK %
?M>Q- 2hat are the ri0ileges conferred on legislators 1
arliamentarians by the constitution of India%
aK Inside the 7ouse bK Outside the 7ouse
?M>>- 2hat are ri0ileges conferred on constitutional functionaries& li,e
aK President of India bK Prime Minister of India
cK Chief $ustice of India dK Chairman of .73C
eK Central 6igilance Commissioners-
?M>I- Are the ri0ileges legal immunity conferred on abo0e mentioned
constitutional functionaries %
aK Co0er all their official actions irresecti0e of merit-
bK Co0er both their official 1 ersonal actions-
?M>;- Are the ri0ileges defined 1 codified %
?M>L- Are these ri0ileges abo0e freedom of the ress %
?M>E- Are the liberty 1 fundamental rights of the citiDens guaranteed by
the constitution& abo0e the ri0ileges of the constitutional functionaries
or e+ual or belo/ %
?M>P- Can the Indian legislatures 1 arliament be e+uated to the 7ouse
of commons in !ngland /hich is considered to be a suerior court and
court of records %
?MIA- Can the di0ision of o/ers& namely the legislature& the executi0e
and the $udiciary& be e+uated to the functioning of the 7ouse of
commons and 7ouse of :ords in !ngland %
?MIM- Can a citiDen be said to ha0e committed breach of ri0ilege of the
7ouse or court and causing contemt of the house or court by raising the
issues of accountability of constitutional functionaries %
?MI@- Can a :egislature or Parliament enact a ne/ la/& to circum0ent or
to nullify the $udicial orders /ith resect to /rongdoings by eoles
reresentati0es 1 executi0e % does not it amount to infringement of
$udicial o/ers 1 contemt of the court by the 7ouse-
?MIQ- Are the #'.DAM!.TA: D'TI!S of a citiDen more imortant than
constitutional duties of a constitutional functionary or e+ual in
imortance to it %
?MI>- Can a constitutional functionary commit crimes& anti-national
acti0ities in the name of constitutional duties& behind the legal 0eil of
official4s secret act 1 go unaccountable for his actions and go ununished
by his legal immunity ri0ileges
?MII- Are the :egislators members of arliament& 7igh court 1 Sureme
court $udges and other constitutional functionaries not /illing to codify
their ri0ileges for the reason that if codified their ri0ileges /ould be
curtailed and their action /ould be sub)ected to legal scrutiny- %
?MI;- 5y 0otes of citiDens :egislators and arliamentarians get seats in
the legislature and Parliament out of tax ayer4s money& they get their
ay& er,s 1 lead I-Star luxurious lifestyles- 7ence /hether a 0ote of a
citiDen is abo0e JMore 0alidK or a seat of legislator or arliamentarian is
abo0e or more 0alid in a democracy %
?MIL- $udges 1 Constitutional functionaries are indirectly aointed by
0oters * tax ayers- Out of tax ayers money& they get their ay& er,s 1
lead I-star luxurious lifestyles- 7ence& /hether the 0ote of a citiDen&
fundamental duties of a tax ayer is abo0e Jmore 0alidK or a seat of )udge
* constitutional functionary is abo0e Jmore
0alidK in a democracy %
?MIE- If there is a 0acuum in the :egislature or arliament& /ho is to fill
u that 0acuum till such time that the legislature or arliament acts
ro0ide a solution by erforming its role by enacting roer legislation to
co0er the field J0acuumK %
?MIP- 2hile it is an unhealthy ractice for a $udge to claim to be a $udge
in his o/n cause& is it not /orse for the members of the legislature and
arliament to be )udges in their o/n cause %
?M;A- Are the Technicalities of the case more imortant to a )udge or
$ustice to a citiDen& rotection of fundamental rights of citiDen-%
?M;M- 2hy not the constitutional functionaries initiate suo moto action
/ith resect to numerous cases of in)ustices reorted in Media %
?M;@- 2hy not the $udges admit 0arious cases of In)ustices affecting
ublic& as the Public Interest :itigationT % In some cases& the Public or
the erson reresenting them is unable to afford the high cost of the
case- 2hy not free legal aid is gi0en %-
?M;Q- 2hat is the criteria for admitting a P-I-:- 1 gi0ing free legal aid %
?M;>- Communication N free flo/ of information is the lifeline of a
democracy- 2hy the constitutional functionaries are not honouring the
3ight to Information of CitiDens %
?M;I- 3ecently & /hile assuming office as honourable chief )ustice of
8arnata,a & )ustice- P-D-DI.A8A3 & ga0e a blan,et /ithdra/al of all
internal deartmental en+uiries against aroximately @AA )udges & is it
)ust 1 legal % gi0e me the names of accused )udges 1 descrition of
charges against them %
?M;;- does it not sho/ that )udges are more e+ual than others %
?M;L- /ho are in0ol0ed in P# scam % /hat action against guilty )udges %
?M;E- 2hy you did not gi0e information to me as er 3TI Act insite of
aeal % refer- #M*3TI*APM*@AAL-
?M;P- Almost a year ago & in the 8arnata,a state ne/ chief )ustice of
8arnata,a high court honble Mr-Dina,ar Jno/ ele0ated to sureme court
of IndiaK )ust on assuming offices /ithin hours scraed discilinary
in+uiry roceedings against @AAB erring )udges- In such a short time no
human being can study all the cases in detail & then ho/ come he arri0ed
at this 0ital decision in such short time% 2ho are those @AAB )udges
facing en+uiry %
?MLA -3ecently in the 8arnata,a state & high court found out that a
district )udge /ithout conducting hearings roerly & entering fictious
dates of hearings J/hich haens to be go0ernment holidays K facilitated
in exonerating a to olitician - has the court en+uired into the re0ious
)udgements of the accussed )udge % did it find any /rongdoings%
?MLM- As er la/ & /hile on duty a erson should not be drun, & under
the influence of alchohol & as it limits the functioning of his senses 1
brain- That is /hy the acts 1 sayings of drun,ards & committed * said
/hen they are drun, are not ta,en seriously- 7o/e0er most of the olice
officers after e0ening hours are drun, & in that state only they arehend
many susects 1 roduce those susects at the residences of magistrates
before magistrate during /ee hours * night- Some of of the )udges are
also drun, during that time- Does the senses of drun,en olice 1 )udges
/or, roerly to do their resecti0e duties in identifying criminals &
arehending them 1 to issue )udicial orders- Are these actions of olice
1 )udges in drun,en state legal %
? ML@ - 2hat action has been ta,en in bhoal gas lea, case against the
guilty olice officials /ho changed the charge sheet against union carbide
officials %
? MLQ - 2hat action has been ta,en against guilty olice officials &
district magistrate & state ministers 1 central ministers /ho fully aided
the criminals N 'nion Carbide official Mr- Anderson to escae la/ & to
)um bail 1 flee the country /ithout court4s ermission %
? ML> - 2hat action has been ta,en against the abo0e said guilty /ith
resect to their contemt of court 1 for aiding a criminal to escae %
? MLI- 2hat action has been ta,en against the chief )ustice of India &
/ho changed the legal clause under /hich the guilty should be tried %
/hat action has been ta,en against the C$I /ho became an official of
the trust belonging to the criminal %
? ML; - 2hat action has been ta,en against the Indian Public ser0ant /ho
decided to /ithdra/ cases from 'S Courts /ith resect to 5hoal gas
tragedy %
? MLL - 2hat action has been ta,en against the state labour deartment
1 ollution control board officials /ho ha0e failed in their duties & insite
of earlier /arnings by )ournalists %
? MLE - 2hat action has been ta,en against state cabinet ministers /ho
decided the +uantum of comensation money to fa0our the criminal
although they don4t ha0e right to do so %
? MLP - 2hat action has been ta,en against Presiding $udge of the trial
court & Chief $ustice of India & state olice officials & ublic rosecutors 1
Central 5ureau of In0estigation officials /ho ,et +uite all along and
didn4t ress for the extradition of the criminal Mr-Anderson & for
roducing the criminal accussed no-M before the trial court %
? MEA - Is it not S7AM!#': for the )udiciary & olice & go0ernment
officials 1 eole4s reresentati0es /ho became art of Oeration Crime
7ush ' 1 aided criminals resonsible for ghastly murders of thousands
1 maiming of la,hs of haless ublic in 5hoal (as :ea, Tragedy%
? MEM - Are these Corrut Police & corrut )udges & corrut ministers &
corrut labour * ollution control board officials 7'MA. 5!I.(S %
? ME@ 2hy olice are not registering my comlaint against C$I 1
other 66IPS &!0en after years %
? MEQ don4t the olice of 0i)ayanagar olice station mysore ha0e
legal )urisdiction to register the case against these 66IPs % or )ust
because the criminals haens to be 66IPs &they are not boo,ed by
olice% If the said olice don4t ha0e legal )urisdiction to boo, these
66IPs & they should ha0e transferred the comlaint to those authorities
/ho ha0e )urisdiction 1 authority to boo, 1 rosecute these 66IPs &
but not done so & /hy %
? ME> are not all these actions & of 66IPs 1 olice amounting to co0er
u of crimes 1 criminals % are not these co0er us itself is a crime %
? MEI- !0en an aeal for )ustice by ost card must be treated as PI: by
courts of )ustice - ho/e0er my aeals for )ustice concerning ublic
/elfare & national security sent through ost & e-mail to sureme court
of india are not admitted as Public interest litigation & /hy % does not
these acts of Sureme court amount to aiding criminals & anti nationals%
? ME; Are not the honourable chief )ustice of india together /ith the
)urisdictional olice 1 3e0enue district magistrate resonsible to
rotect the fundamental 1 human rights of eole % /hy the C$I &
Mysore DC 1 $urisdictional Police ha0e failed to rotect the fundamental
1 human rights of eole including mine % #or all the re0ious in)ustices
I ha0e suffered at the hands of the criminal nexus 7onourable C$I &
Mysore re0enue district magistrate 1 )urisdictional olice are together
resonsible & if anything unto/ard haens to me or to my family
members or to my deendents the +uartet N 7onourable Chief $ustice of
India & 7onourable District Magistrate & Mysore & 7onourable Police
Commissioner of Mysore city 1 Circle Insector of olice & 0i)ayanagar
olice station & mysore /ill be resonsible -
These corrut arasites /ill feel & understand the ain only /hen they
also suffer in the same manner- :et us ray to almighty N In /hose Court
of )ustice MATC7 #ICI.( is not there 1 e0ery body is e+ual & let us ray
to that god to gi0e these corrut arasites ghastly deaths nothing less
nothing more-

Y!A3 TO 27IC7 A5O6! P!3TAI.S " MA$O3ITY O# DOC'M!.TS P!3TAI.S
TO Y!A3 MPP>-@AM> - SOM! O# T7! DOC'M!.TS A3! DAT!D 5AC8 TO
MP>L-

P'5:IC I.#O3MATIO. O##IC!3 27O #AI:!D TO (I6! #':: I.#O3MATIO."
CPIO & S'P3!M! CO'3T O# I.DIA & .!2 D!:7I-

#!!S PAID " IPO @@# @E@EM> for ruees ten only

DAT! " @M-A;-@AM> RRRRR--RRRRRRRRR.A(A3A$A-M-3-

P:AC! " MYSO3! & I.DIAR-- RRRRRRRRR-J APP:ICA.TK

edited , printed , published & owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @ : LIG-
2 !"# , $%&'( )IR*+ *+AG, , (-- .A+,R .(R/* ())I', ,
LA/*$MI/AN+ANAGAR ,$,00AL ,M1*(R, -2!33#! IN&IA
4ell : 5# 567#8236#6 , 5# 85!36#8232
ho9e p:;e:
http:sites.;oo;le.4o9sitee4l:riono<d:lit$o9e ,
http:;roups.;oo;le.4o.in;roupe-4l:rion-o<-d:lit ,
http:e-4l:riono<d:lit.blo;spot.4o9 ,
http:in.;roups.y:hoo.4o9;roupe-4l:riono<d:lit ,
http:p:per.li<-#6"!568"!7 ,
'ont:4t : n:;hrw@y:hoo.4o9 , n:;:r:=hrw@hot9:il.4o9 ,
http:www.:9nesty.or;enusern:;hrw
A Me9ber o< A9nesty Intern:tion:l

Brokers of Justice

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Brokers of Justice

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Brokers of Justice ?

Justice Lodha - WAKE UP

You might also like