Professional Documents
Culture Documents
8 August 2000
Status Epilepticus:
FOCAL POINT
Managing Refractory
★ Because status epilepticus (SE)
frequently occurs outside the
hospital, prompt prehospital
treatment, including rectal and
Cases and Treating
intranasal administration of
drugs, can improve patient
management.
Out-of-Hospital
KEY FACTS
Patients*
■ SE that does not respond to a
benzodiazepine or phenobarbital University of Georgia
requires more aggressive Simon R. Platt, BVM&S, MRCVS
treatment; potential reasons for John J. McDonnell, DVM, MS
refractory seizure activity include
inadequate anticonvulsant doses,
an uncorrected metabolic ABSTRACT: Status epilepticus (SE) is an emergency medical situation that may not respond
abnormality, intoxication, to benzodiazepine or phenobarbital treatment. This situation is termed refractory SE and re-
quires more aggressive treatment such as anesthesia. SE may also occur in the home environ-
or tumor.
ment where facilities are limited. The time that passes before treatment is instituted is crucial
in the prevention of permanent cerebral damage and may be important in saving the patient’s
■ Adequate doses of thiopental and
life. For such patients, the efficacy of rectally delivered diazepam has been established. In-
pentobarbital will usually control tranasal delivery of anticonvulsants is being evaluated in dogs and may represent a future
the physical manifestations of method of at-home seizure control.
seizures, but severe hypotension
limits their safety.
S
tatus epilepticus (SE) is a medical emergency that requires prompt treatment
■ The resources needed to avoid appreciable neurologic morbidity.1–5 The proper management strat-
to manage the potential egy involves prompt control of seizures.3 Benzodiazepines (i.e., diazepam, lor-
complications of intravenous azepam, midazolam, and clonazepam) are potent, fast-acting anticonvulsants that
therapy in seizuring patients are form the cornerstone of early SE therapy.1-4 In animal screening tests, benzodi-
often inadequate, and may result azepines have shown a broad spectrum of anticonvulsant activity and may at low
in severe systemic and cerebral doses effectively inhibit seizure activity.6 However, there are situations in which
damage or death. these drugs do not arrest continuous seizure activity and other treatments should
be employed. The companion articles in this series discussed the manifestations,
■ Rectal administration of pathophysiology, and treatment of patients with SE. This paper explores the
anticonvulsants is relatively easy treatment of refractory SE by veterinarians and at-home seizures by owners.
to carry out in the home and, *A companion article entitled “Status Epilepticus: Clinical Features and Pathophysiology”
therefore, is useful in appeared in the July 2000 (Vol. 22 No. 7) issue of Compendium. The second installment,
emergencies. entitled “Status Epilepticus: Patient Management and Pharmacologic Therapy,” can be
found in this issue. This is the final article in the series.
Compendium August 2000 Small Animal/Exotics
REFRACTORY STATUS EPILEPTICUS its rapid clearance, chiefly eliminated by hepatic conju-
Status epilepticus that does not respond to a benzodi- gation to inactive metabolites, and less profound hy-
azepine or phenobarbital is considered refractory and potensive effects.2,3,13 However, propofol should be used
requires more aggressive treatment5,7,8 (Figure 1). Poten- with caution and preferably in settings in which defini-
tial reasons for resistant seizure activity include inade- tive airway control and hemodynamic support are possi-
quate anticonvulsant doses, an uncorrected metabolic ble because hypoxemia secondary to apnea as well as
abnormality, or the presence of intracranial disease myocardial depression are primary side effects.2
(e.g., a tumor).3,9 These patients are often difficult to When using propofol, seizures have been observed
treat. Short-acting anesthetic drugs are commonly used during the induction of and emergence from anesthe-
to treat resistant SE because these agents have a rapid sia, but the importance of these proconvulsant effects
onset of action and short half-lives and reduce cerebral in SE management is unknown.3,7 Whether the convul-
metabolic rates.3 These drugs should be used only in an sive phenomena occasionally seen with the use of this
intensive care setting because blood pressure and cen- drug represent seizures, excitatory events, and/or a dis-
tral venous pressure should be monitored continuously. order of muscle tone is controversial.2 Experimental an-
General anesthesia prevents tonic–clonic movements imal models have documented the anticonvulsant ef-
and allows control of respirations. fects of propofol.2 This drug has been shown to raise
the lidocaine seizure threshold in rats, arrest bupiva-
Continuous Benzodiazepine Infusion caine-induced seizures as effectively as thiopental at 10-
Continuous benzodiazepine infusion has been shown mg/kg doses, and be as potent as is diazepam at pre-
to be effective for treating refractory SE in humans and venting pentylenetetrazol-induced seizures in rabbits.2
animals.5,10 Continuous intravenous (IV) infu-
sions of diazepam were administered to 124 of Seizures persist despite treatment
186 (66.8%) dogs with severe seizures,10 but with diazepam and phenobarbital
the efficacy of this treatment could not be de-
termined. The authors reported that continu-
Medical team and
ous diazepam infusions may be underused in No
owner decide to use
Yes
10
the management of dogs with seizures. The aggressive treatment
Several reports have documented the anticonvulsant ac- these anesthetics for patients in which benzodiazepines
tivity of propofol in humans.12 Stecker and colleagues and phenobarbital fail.
recently reported that propofol can control refractory
SE more quickly in humans than can high-dose barbi- Etomidate
turates.12 Because of the pharmacokinetics of propofol, Etomidate, which has shown GABA-ergic activity in
it is believed that even if this drug failed to control the brain, is a short-acting drug. The anticonvulsant ef-
seizures and high-dose barbiturates were required, little fects of this agent in dogs and cats have not yet been
time would be lost and there would be no long-term documented.4
interference with other treatments.12 Heldmann and
colleagues recently studied the use of propofol in in
four cats and one dog with naturally occurring seizures Lidocaine
following the surgical attenuation of single extrahepatic In 1955, IV lidocaine was first reported as a treat-
portosystemic shunts. 15 All of the patients, two of ment for SE in humans.17 Since that time, a number of
which had seizures that were unresponsive to other an- studies, mostly in Europe, have reported the efficacy of
ticonvulsants, responded to propofol.15 All five animals lidocaine in refractory SE,9 although no large, double-
had regular indirect blood pressure measurements and blind, placebo-controlled studies have proven the drug’s
remained hemodynamically stable when the drug was efficacy in humans with SE.17 The exact mechanism by
appropriately administered.15 All of the animals sur- which lidocaine terminates seizures is unknown at pres-
vived to discharge. ent. Lidocaine decreases neuronal excitability by block-
ing voltage-dependent sodium channels in the cell
Barbiturates membrane.17 In addition, it reduces potassium efflux
Thiopental and pentobarbital have shown potential, into the extracellular space and decreases neuronal mi-
although unproven, cerebral protective effects in the tochondrial metabolism and cerebral oxygen consump-
management of SE. Adequate doses of these drugs usu- tion.17 Increased extracellular potassium increases the
ally control the physical manifestations of seizures, but concentration of the excitatory neurotransmitter gluta-
severe hypotension limits their safety.4,7,8 Pentobarbital mate and may increase the recruitment of other neu-
sodium (Nembutal®; Abbott), used at standard safe rons into the seizure activity.17 Most reports on the use
doses, is a general anesthetic with negligible anticonvul- of lidocaine in humans recommend a maintenance in-
sant properties.4 Thiopental has been associated with a fusion after initial termination of SE.17 Lidocaine has
higher degree of cardiac toxicity than has pentobarb- been reported to cause seizures as well as myocardial
ital.13 In one study, Roesch and colleagues reported more depression and cardiac conduction abnormalities. 17
ventricular arrhythmias in animals treated with thio- However, the signs attributable to lidocaine toxicity are
pental than in those treated with pentobarbital at doses rare clinically when the drug is used specifically for its
lower than those required to cause a flat electroen- anticonvulsant properties. The optimal anticonvulsant
cephalogram (EEG).13 At higher doses than those re- dose of lidocaine in humans and animals is unknown;
quired to produce a flat EEG, only two of seven dogs we do not recommend its use in SE until further inves-
treated with thiopental survived whereas all 17 dogs tigations have been pursued.
treated with pentobarbital survived.13 Pentobarbital
should be given to effect and not as a specific dose (3 to Inhalational Anesthesia
15 mg/kg IV) because response varies widely among pa- Inhalational anesthetics have been recommended as a
tients (Figure 1). treatment of last resort for patients with resistant SE.
Patients treated with “barbiturate coma” commonly The equipment and personnel necessary to administer
require an extended period of mechanical ventilation in inhalational anesthesia may not be readily available and
an intensive care setting.5,8,12 In general, the side effects the equipment can be cumbersome. Isoflurane, an in-
of barbiturate coma include depression of myocardial halational general anesthetic agent, may be efficacious
metabolism, vasodilation with a decrease in venous re- in the treatment of resistant SE.3 Not all of the volatile
turn, and decreased cardiac perfusion.16 These effects anesthetic agents have antiepileptic potential; however;
can be minimized by using saline infusion and small enflurane may actually increase seizure activity.3 Isoflu-
doses of dopamine. Patients can develop poikilothermia rane, which has been studied extensively, does not un-
and decreased urinary output during myocardial de- dergo hepatic metabolism and has a rapid onset of ac-
pression and hypotension. Neurologic evaluation is dif- tion.3 Obviously, isoflurane therapy requires ventilation
ficult because spontaneous respiratory responses and and intensive care monitoring; hypotension may occur
movements cease. We recommend reserving the use of during therapy.3
7. Lowenstein DH, Alldredge BK: Status epilepticus. N Engl J 27. Morton LD, Rizkallah E, Pellock JM: New drug therapy for
Med 338(14):970–976, 1998. acute seizure management. Semin Pediatr Neurol 4(4):51–
8. Koul RL, Aithala GR, Chacko A, et al: Continuous midazo- 63, 1997.
lam infusion as treatment of status epilepticus. Arch Dis 28. Podell M: Seizures in dogs. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim
Child 76(5):445–448, 1997. Pract 26(4):779–809, 1996.
9. Ropper AH: Neurological and Neurosurgical Intensive Care. 29. Cereghino JJ, Mitchell WG, Murphy J, et al: Treating repet-
New York, Raven Press, 1993, pp 383–410. itive seizures with a rectal diazepam formulation. Neurology
10. Bateman SW, Parent JM: Clinical findings, treatment, and 51(5):1274–1282, 1998.
outcome of dogs with status epilepticus or cluster seizures: 30. Bechgaard E, Gizurarson S, Hjortkjaer R: Pharmacokinetic
156 cases (1990–1995). JAVMA 215(10):1463–1468, 1999. and pharmacodynamic response after intranasal administra-
11. Podell M: Seizure management in dogs, in Bonagura JD tion of diazepam to rabbits. J Pharm Pharmacol 49 (8):747–
(ed): Kirk’s Current Veterinary Therapy XIII. Philadelphia, 750, 1997.
WB Saunders Co, 2000, pp 959–969. 31. Van Hoogdalem EJ, De Boer AG, Breimer DD: Pharma-
12. Stecker MM, Kramer TH, Raps EC, et al: Treatment of re- cokinetics of rectal drug administration. Part I. General con-
fractory status epilepticus with propofol: Clinical and phar- siderations and clinical applications of centrally acting drugs.
macological findings. Epilepsia 39(1):18–26, 1998. Clin Pharmacokinet 21(1):11–26, 1991.
13. Cruz J: Neurologic and Neurosurgical Emergencies. Philadel- 32. Podell M, Smeak D, Lord LK: Diazepam used to control
phia, WB Saunders Co, 1998, pp 51–88. cluster seizures in dogs (letter). J Vet Intern Med 12 (2):120–
14. Plumb DC: Veterinary Drug Handbook, ed 3. White Bear Lake, 121, 1998.
MN, Pharma Vet Publishing, 1999. 33. Nordt SP,Clark RF: Midazolam: A review of therapeutic
15. Heldmann E, Holt DE, Brockman DJ, et al: Use of propo- uses and toxicity. J Emerg Med 15(3):357–365, 1997.
fol to manage seizure activity after surgical treatment of por- 34. Lui CY, Amidon GL, Goldberg A: Intranasal absorption of
tosystemic shunts. J Small Anim Pract 40(12):590–594, flurazepam, midazolam, and triazolam in dogs. J Pharamceut
1999. Sci 80 (12):1125–1129, 1991.
16. Wilmore LJ: The first seizure and status epilepticus. Neurol- 35. Kendall JL, Reynolds M, Goldberg R: Intranasal midazolam
ogy 51(Suppl 4):34–38, 1998. in patients with status epilepticus. Ann Emerg Med 29 (3):
17. Walker LA, Slovis CM: Lidocaine in the treatment of status 415–417, 1997.
epilepticus. Acad Emerg Med 4(9):918–922, 1997. 36. Hartgraves PM, Primosch RE: An evaluation of oral and
18. Indrieri R: Status epilepticus, in Indrieri R (ed): Problems in nasal midazolam for pediatric dental sedation. J Dent Child
Veterinary Medicine. Baltimore, Lippincott, 1989, pp 606– 61 (3):175–181, 1994.
617. 37. Robertson SA, Eberhart S: Efficacy of the intranasal route
19. Scott RC, Besag FMC, Boyd SG, et al: Buccal absorption of for administration of anesthetic agents to adult rabbits. Lab
midazolam: Pharmacokinetics and EEG pharmacodynamics. Anim Sci 44 (2):159–165, 1994.
Epilepsia 39(3):290–294, 1998. 38. Platt SR, Randall S, Scott K, et al: Comparison of plasma
20. O’Regan ME, Brown JK, Clarke M: Nasal rather than rectal benzodiazepine concentrations following intranasal and in-
benzodiazepines in the management of acute childhood travenous administration of diazepine to dogs. Am J Vet Res
seizures? Dev Med Child Neurol 38(11):1037–1045, 1996. 61(6):651–654, 2000.
21. Powers DL, Seigler RS, Kilgore DG: The effect of diazepam 39. Bjorkman S, Rigemar G, Idvall J: Pharmacokinetics of mida-
enema on the rectal mucosa of rats. Pediatr Emerg Care 7(3): zolam given as an intranasal spray to adult surgical patients.
152–153, 1991. Br J Anaesth 79(5):575–580, 1997.
22. Wagner SO, Sams RA, Podell M: Chronic phenobarbital
therapy reduces plasma benzodiazepine concentrations after
intravenous and rectal administration of diazepam in the About the Authors
dog. J Vet Pharmacol Ther 21(5):335–341, 1998.
When this article was submitted for publication, Drs. Platt
23. Mealey KL, Boothe DM: Bioavailability of benzodiazepines
following rectal administration of diazepam in dogs. J Vet and McDonnell were affiliated with the Department of
Pharmacol Ther 18(1):72–74, 1995. Small Animal Medicine, College of Veterinary Medicine,
24. Podell M, Fenner WR, Powers JD: Seizure classification in University of Georgia, Athens. Dr. Platt is now affiliated
dogs from a non-referral-based population. JAVMA 206(11):
with The Animal Health Trust, Centre for Small Animal
1721–1728, 1995.
25. Papich MG, Alcorn J: Absorption of diazepam after its rectal Studies, Suffolk, England. Dr. McDonnell is affiliated with
administration in dogs. Am J Vet Res 56(12):1629–1636, the Veterinary Medical Center, Tufts University, North
1995. Grafton, Massachusetts. Both authors are Diplomates of
26. Lehmann B, Boulieu R: Determination of midazolam and
the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine
its unconjugated 1-hydroxy metabolite in human plasma by
high performance liquid chromatography. J Chromatogr B (Neurology).
Biomed Sci Appl 674(1):138–142, 1995.