You are on page 1of 24

K\b`2

K\b`. K_\C\X[\ij_`g=XZkfi
6NN] 9[N\RMNW] -[ +RUU 3XWN\ JWM >WMN[P[JM^J]N -NJW -[ 9J] +UN`N]]

K\b`/ 8kk_\:fi\f]:@L
* +RKURLJU >WR_N[\R]b ¬ @QJ]±\ >Y `R]Q =QJ](

K\b`0 :@LIfZbj
8^[ ,X[N ?JU^N\ J[N \N] RW <]XWN

K\b`1 :@LÂj8eXkfdp
1NJM 1NJ[] 1JWM\

K\b`2 8YflkFliD`[[c\EXd\ K\b`0


@N±[N 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU

K\b`3(4 JXdgc\N_XkPfl:XeC\XieXk:@L
<XVN XO X^[ 6X\] 9XY^UJ[ 9[XP[JV\
K\b`,1
K\b`,+ ;flYc\Gi\gXi\[kf:_Xe^\k_\Nfic[
BX^±UU .J[W J -X^KUN 6JSX[

K\b`,, =Xdflj=fcbj
,2> 0[JM\ BX^ VJb QJ_N 1NJ[M *KX^]

K\b`,-(,. ;fPfl=`e[k_\:fjkf]:fcc\^\J_fZb`e^6
*WM 8]QN[ /[NZ^NW]Ub *\TNM :^N\]RXW\

K\b`,/(,0 @Âm\^fkX;\^i\\%EfnN_Xk6
,2> ,J[NN[ <N[_RLN\

K\b`,1(,2 K_\i\ÂjDfi\kfC`]\k_Xe?\id\e\lk`Zj
1N[VJW `QX(

K\b`,3 N_Xk[f@E\\[kf[fE\ok6
.J\b @Jb\ ]X /RWM 8^] 6X[N *KX^] ,2>

K\b`,4 C`]\$:_Xe^`e^<m\ekj
<YNLRJU -Jb\ J] ,2> ]X 4NNY BX^ XW =[JLT

K\b`-+ :XdgljG_fkfKfli K\b`-,


@N `X^UMW±] `JW] bX^ ]X PN] UX\]
K\b`-,
K\b`-
-,
K\b`-, AXZbpKXd`ÂjK`gj]fiJlim`m`e^:fcc\^\ K
K\b`--
;XXVVJ]N\ <VNUUb <XLT\ N]L ,XU^VKRJ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R]b JMVR]\
\]^MNW]\ XO JWb [JLN LXUX[ WJ]RXWJU JWM N]QWRL
K\b`-- <Xk`e^n`k_8YY\p X[RPRW ]X JUU ]QN [RPQ]\ Y[R_RUNPN\ Y[XP[JV\
JWM JL]R_R]RN\ PNWN[JUUb JLLX[MNM X[ VJMN
BX^[ 0^RMN ]X 0[NJ] 0[^K RW ,XU^VKRJ J_JRUJKUN ]X \]^MNW]\ J] ]QN \LQXXU 2] MXN\
WX] MR\L[RVRWJ]N XW ]QN KJ\R\ XO [JLN LXUX[

K\b`-. Jkl]]kf[f8ifle[:fcldY`X WJ]RXWJU JWM N]QWRL X[RPRW RW JMVRWR\][J]RXW XO


R]\ NM^LJ]RXWJU YXURLRN\ JMVR\\RXW\ \LQXUJ[
\QRY JWM UXJW Y[XP[JV\ JWM J]QUN]RL JWM X]QN[
=QN CXX 5JTN 6^[[Jb 6^\N^V\ JWM VX[N

=
=QN
QN C
CXX
XX 55JTN
TN 6
6^[
^[[Jb
Jb
b 6
 6
6^\\N
N^
N ^V\ JWM
JW
J WM V
VX
VX[N
[N

\\LQXXUJMVRWR\]N[NM Y[XP[JV\
\L
LLQ
QX
XX
XXU
XUUJM
X J
JMV
JMVVRW
RWR\
WR\
R\]
\]N[N
\] N[[N
[NM
M Y
Y
Y[[XP
P[[JV
[J
JV
JV\
V\

- rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
FliGi\j`[\ek
;i%9`ccAfe\j`jX
m\ipYljpdXe%
7X] XWUb R\ QN Y[N\RMNW]
XO ,2> QN JU\X ]NJLQN\
,2> LUJ\\N\ JWM R\ ]QN
LXOX^WMN[ XO ]QN VR\
\RXW\ JPNWLb ,[X\\X_N[
,XVV^WRLJ]RXW\ 2W]N[WJ
]RXWJU UXLJ]NM S^\] JL[X\\
]QN \][NN] O[XV ,2>
=JUT JKX^] LXW_NWRNW]

1N JU\X ¹WM\ ]RVN ]X S^\]
QJWP X^] `R]Q ]QN
\]^MNW]\

1N QJ\ MNP[NN\ O[XV \XVN Y[N]]b RVY[N\\R_N YUJLN\# +^] QN R\ Y[XKJKUb KN\] TWX`W OX[ \QJ[RWP ]QN UX_N
0NX[PRJ 2W\]R]^]N XO =NLQWXUXPb 5^]QN[ ;RLN <NVR JWM OX[PR_NWN\\ XO ,Q[R\] `R]Q ]XW\ XO YNXYUN
WJ[b 0X[MXW ,XW`NUU <NVRWJ[b JWM XO LX^[\N X_N[ ]QN bNJ[\ VJWb XO ]QNV QR\ P^N\]\ RW ]QN
,XU^VKRJ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R]b ,2> LJON]N[RJ

IdaZVgcbdgZVWdji9g#?dcZhX]ZX`dji/
lll#X^j#ZYj$egZh^YZci#

;i%GXk9c\n\kk`jX[\Xen`k_
XgXjkfiÂj_\Xik%
0XM QJ\ PRO]NM QRV RW J ^WRZ^N `Jb 1N
QJ\ X_N[  bNJ[\ XO JLJMNVRL JMVRW
R\][J]RXW RW ,Q[R\]RJW LXUUNPN \N]]RWP\
J\ `NUU J\  bNJ[\ XO YJ\]X[JU NaYN[R
NWLN 1R\ YJ\\RXW OX[ VRWR\][b QR\ UX_N
XO ]QN LXUUNPNJPN \]^MNW] QR\ Y[JL]RLJU
`R\MXV [XX]NM RW ]QN @X[M JWM QR\
K[NJM]Q XO URON NaYN[RNWLN VJTN QRV
JW JYY[XJLQJKUN VNW]X[ JWM VXMNU ]X
VJWb \]^MNW]\ XW LJVY^\

BX^±UU URTN PN]]RWP ]X TWX` QRV


BX^ UU URTN PN]]RWP ]X TWX` QRV

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p .
®,2> NM^LJ]N\
YNXYUN O[XV J
KRKURLJU `X[UM
_RN` ]X RVYJL]
]QN WJ]RXW\
`R]Q ]QN
VN\\JPN XO
,Q[R\]¯

/ rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
Di\rjmg_apggjancdaodib]`gd`an'rc`i
ompocdn\hjqdibo\mb`o'rc`ioc`qjd^`n
jaoc`^pgopm`^jiÚd^oËrc\oÐn\ooc`^jm`ja
>DP_j`nijo^c\ib`)Rc\or`]`gd`q`dn
n`odinoji`Gdo`m\ggt

Oc`m`\m`Ùq`]dbmj^fnji^\hkpn
oc\om`km`n`iojpm>jm`Q\gp`n5

8lk_fi`kpf]JZi`gkli\ QN +RKUN JWM


*] ,2> bX^±UU UNJ[W ]X ^WMN[\]JWM ]
JYYUb R]\ ]NJLQRWP
M`Zkfi`flj:_i`jk`XeC`m`e^ JLJMNVRL Na
BX^±UU KN NWLX^[JPNM ]X \][R_N OX[
]QN MbWJVRL
LNUUNWLN K^] JU\X YN[\XWJU P[X`]Q$
[R\] RW MJRUb
XO ]QN 1XUb <YR[R] ]X VJTN ^\ URTN ,Q
UR_RWP
Nfic[<mXe^\c`qXk`fe WN[J]RXW
BX^±UU KN Y[NYJ[NM ]X [NJLQ bX^[ PN
JL] XW ]QN
`R]Q ]QN PX\YNU JWM VJTN JW RVY
V¯ `QN]QN[
`X[UM J\ YJ[] XO ]QN ®VR\\RXW\ ]NJ
W]
RW J ®\NWMRWP LQ^[LQ¯ X[ J\ XWN \N
GiXp\i=X`k_ ] \NNT\ ]X KN
BX^±UU KN YJ[] XO J LXVV^WR]b ]QJ
OX[ VJ]N[RJU
VJ[TNM Kb SXbO^U [NURJWLN XW 0XM
RW ,Q[R\]URTN
Y[X_R\RXW _RL]X[b X_N[ \RW P[X`]Q
WN\\ JWM O[^R]O^UWN\\ RW VRWR\][b
<mXe^\c`ZXcLe`kp [R\]RJW\ XO
BX^±UU UNJ[W ]X UR_N RW ^WR]b `R]Q ,Q
\ bX^ NWLX^[
_J[RX^\ N_JWPNURLJU LXW_RL]RXW\ J
J[N RW ]QN
JPN JWM NMROb XWN JWX]QN[ JWM \Q
`X[T XO VRWR\][b

>DP>c\i^`ggjm?m)B`jmb`Hpmm\t'rcjc\n]``i\nnj^d\o`_
rdoc>DPajm\gjibodh`'o\gfn\]jpo>DPÐn>jm`Q\gp`ndi\iji(
gdi`qd_`j)O\f`\gjjf\o5rrr)^dp)`_p*\]jpo*q\gp`n)cohg)
d_`j)O\

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p 0
68>JZYjXVi^dc^h\ddY[dgndj>i¼hX]dX`ZY[jaad[hdja"cdjg^h]^c\7^WaZXaVhhZhVcY
g^\dgdjhVXVYZb^XVcYegd[Zhh^dcVaigV^c^c\idl]^endj^cidh]VeZ[dgl]ViZkZgldg`
<dY^hXVaa^c\ndjidYd#Ndj¼aa \gdljeidWZVW^\VcYhigdc\
XdaaZ\Z\gVYjViZ^c_jhi [djgnZVghdgndjgbdcZn
WV""LV^i!lZ XVc¼ihVni]Vi#

?\i\Âjk_\nXpfli\[lZXk`feXcg_`cfjfg_pj_Xg\jlg1

R`Ðggc`gktjp
h\f`dokphkajm
E`npn)Am`lp`io
m`npn^do\odjin\m`
km`n^md]`_ocmjpbc^c\k`g'
^jia`m`i^`n'nh\ggbmjpk
hdidnomd`n'km\t`m_\tn @sk`^o
Epnojk`i \i_tjpmdiqjgq`h`io oc`hojb`o
di\gj^\g^cpm^cja _dmot)Hdidnomt\i_
dopk\i_r`Ðgg
tjpm^cjd^`) ^\m``mjkkjmopidod`n
Ùggdordoc\^\_`hd^
`s^`gg`i^`rdococ` \m`c\i_n(ji\ntjp
=d]g`\ooc` ]`bdiojm`\^cjpo
^jm`) oj\rjmg_di
i``_)

1 rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
2S`fe`fc>ZUU]V?R^V«
C\kÂjZ_Xe^\k_\nfic[kf^\k_\i%
=X LQJWPN ]QN `X[UM `N WNNM ]X PX ]X ]QN `X[UM =QJ]±\ `Qb ,2>±\ VRMMUN WJVN R\ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU BX^±UU UNJ[W
O[XV Y[XON\\X[\ `QX QJ_N UXPPNM VX[N ]QJW  bNJ[\ XO RW]N[WJ]RXWJU NaYN[RNWLN RW X_N[  LX^W][RN\
@N±_N
N_NW WJVNM ]QN VJRW \][NN] XW]X LJVY^\ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU +X^UN_J[M 2]±\ URWNM `R]Q ºJP\ O[XV LX^W][RN\ J[X^WM ]QN
`X[UM [NY[N\NW]RWP X_N[  WJ]RXW\ ]QJ] ,2> \]^MNW]\ LJUU QXVN JWM X_N[  WJ]RXW\ `QN[N ,2> P[JM^J]N\ J[N
\N[_RWP

IfX[Ki`g
3N\^\ \JRM ]X VJTN MR\LRYUN\ XO JUU WJ]RXW\ <X UN]±\ PX
BX^ VJb ¹WM bX^[\NUO RW .^[XYN 6NaRLX /RSR X[ N_NW
`JUTRWP RW ]QN \JWMJU \]NY\ XO 3N\^\ RW 3N[^\JUNV BX^ VJb N_NW PX ]X J LX^W][b bX^±_N WN_N[ QNJ[M XO *\ J ,2>
\]^MNW] bX^±UU QJ_N ]QN XYYX[]^WR]b ]X `X[T JUXWP\RMN X]QN[ KNURN_N[\ RW YUJLN\ \^LQ J\#
/XL^\ XW ]QN /JVRUb 2W\]R]^]N
.M^?NW]^[N RW *\RJ
3N[^\JUNV >WR_N[\R]b ,XUUNPN
1.*;= 1^WPN[ .M^LJ]RXW *WM ;N\X^[LN =[JRWRWP RW /UX[RMJ
<XURM ;XLT 8^]MXX[ 6RWR\][b <;86 @RUMN[WN\\ .aYN[RNWLN\ RW @bXVRWP
*6+.A ,X[KJW ,XUUNPN RW 0N[VJWb

PfldXpËe[pflij\c]feXd`jj`fejfijkl[pkfli`e1
.^[XYN
+NURcN =NJLQN[ .M^LJ]RXW X[ .W_R[XWVNW]JU <LRNWLN
-XVRWRLJW ;NY^KURL BX^]Q 6RWR\][b
@J\QRWP]XW -, *VN[RLJW 1R\]X[b 0X_N[WVNW]
Ú =XX VJWb X]QN[ YUJLN\ ]X WJVN

=E F C 2 =  D E F 5:6D
? @ H  E 9 2E  : ?E6C4F
5:5J@F< F = 2 C  > 2 ; @ CD0
6  @ 7  @ F C  > @DEA@A
:D@ ?

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p 2
D`jj`fe1KfdXb\Xe[dfY`c`q\[`jZ`gc\jXe[[`jZ`gc\dXb\ij
BX^]Q 6RWR\][b P[JM\ `QX J[N LQJWPRWP ]QN `X[UM# ]fiA\jlj:_i`jk%

=m`ioH`o^\ga G\Ojt\M``_ =mt\ioG\dm_


+[NW] UNJM\ VRMMUN JWM 5J=XbJ R\ JW J\\R\]JW] +[bJW] R\ [N\YXW\RKUN OX[
QRPQ \LQXXU VRWR\][RN\ LQJYUJRW JWM \YR[R]^JU [NL[^R]RWP QR[RWP JWM
J] +[N_J[M ,XVV^WR]b MN_NUXYVNW] _XU^W]NN[ ][JRWRWP \^VVN[ \]JOO OX[
,Q^[LQ RW +[N_J[M 7, LXX[MRWJ]X[ J] ]QN <X^]Q ]QN VRWR\][RN\ XO @X[UM
1N R\ JU\X RW_XU_NM ,J[XURWJ -NYJ[]VNW] ,QJWPN[\ JWM 9X`N[
`R]Q ]QN /NUUX`\QRY XO XO 3^_NWRUN 3^\]RLN 1N[ 9UJW] 7X[]Q *VN[RLJW
,Q[R\]RJW *]QUN]N\ J] ]QN UXLJU QRPQ \LQXXU M^]RN\ RWLU^MN X_N[\NNRWP `X[\QRY \N[_RLN\ 6R\\RXW +XJ[M 1N JU\X X_N[\NN\ ]QN MN]JRU\
JWM \N[_N\ J\ LQJYUJRW XO ]QN QRPQ \LQXXU±\ JWM +RKUN \]^MRN\ J\\R\]RWP \XLRJU `X[TN[\ OX[ @X[UM ,QJWPN[\ JWM 9X`N[9UJW] Y[XS
OXX]KJUU JWM KJ\NKJUU ]NJV\ JWM LX^W\NURWP <QN NWLX^[JPN\ bX^]Q ]X NL]\ RW ]QN \]J]N XO <X^]Q ,J[XURWJ
VJTN KN]]N[ LQXRLN\ JWM JMXY] YX\R]R_N
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_=m`io5 _JU^N\ JWM KNQJ_RX[ Cjr>DPKm`k\m`_=mt\io5
=QN P[NJ]N\] `Jb ]QJ] ,2> Y[NYJ[NM VN `J\ BX^]Q 6RWR\][RN\ -R[NL]X[ -[ -J_RM 8U\QRWN
Kb Y[XON\\X[\ `QX RW_N\]NM RW VN [NUJ]RXW
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_G\Ojt\5 \N] J QRPQ \]JWMJ[M OX[ VN JWM Vb LUJ\\
=QN TWX`UNMPN 2 PJRWNM O[XV \]^MbRWP JWM
JUUb =QNb VNW]X[NM JWM LQJUUNWPNM VN RW [N\NJ[LQRWP Y[NYJ[NM VN OX[ Y[NJLQRWP JWM VJ]N\ @QNW 2 P[JM^J]NM O[XV ,XU^VKRJ
Vb `JUT `R]Q ,Q[R\] RW\RMN JWM X^]\RMN ]QN ]NJLQRWP ]QN @X[M XO 0XM JWM PJ_N VN 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R]b 2 TWN` ]QJ] 2 `J\
LUJ\\[XXV 2 MRMW±] ONNU URTN J \]^MNW] 2 ONU] ]QN `R\MXV 2 WNNM ]X `X[T `R]Q bX^]Q ,2> YJ[] XO J VRWR\][b VX_NVNW] ]QJ] `J\ VJT
URTN 2 `J\ J O[RNWM @J]LQRWP ]QNR[ J^]QNW QNUYNM VN \NN ]QN RVYX[]JWLN XO 0XM RW N_
QNUYNM VN \NN ]QN RVYX[]JWLN XO 0XM RW N_ RWP J
RWP J MROON[NWLN
MROON[NWLN RW
RW ]QN
]QN `X[UM
`X[UM JWM
JWM -[
-[ 8U\QRWN
8U\QRWN
]RLR]b JWM YJ\\RXW OX[ KNRWP J ,Q[R\] OXU N[b]QRWP 2 MX JWM ]X [NJURcN `QX 2 JV RW 3N\^\ YUJbNM J L[^LRJU [XUN RW ]QJ] X^]LXVN
UX`N[ QJM J ][NVNWMX^\ RVYJL] XW Vb X`W ,Q[R\] =Q[X^PQ ,2> 2 OX^WM ]QN PRO]\ JWM ]JU
,Q[R\] =Q[X^PQ ,2> 2 OX^WM ]QN PRO]\ JWM ]JU
YN[\XWJU `JUT `R]Q ,Q[R\] 2 MXW±] KNURN_N NW]\ ]QJ] NaR\] `R]QRW VN JWM 2 KNLJVN KXUM
]QN[N R\ J KN]]N[ YUJLN ]QJW ,2> ]X Y[NYJ[N JWM LX^[JPNX^\ 6b ,2> NaYN[RNWLN\ `R]Q
bX^ OX[ \]^MNW] VRWR\][b 0XM Y[XON\\X[\ JWM O[RNWM\ LQJWPNM Vb URON

D`jj`fe1Kf_\cgjkl[\ekjle[\ijkXe[fk_\ijXe[k_\dj\cm\jj`^e`ËZXekcp
^k_\B`e^[f
Y\kk\i#jfk_Xkk_\jkl[\ekjZXeY\dfi\\]]\Zk`m\Xk\ok\e[`e^k_\B` d
e^[fd
9\bLQXUXPb P[JM\ `QX J[N LQJWPRWP ]QN `X[UM#
f]>f[fe<Xik_%
?\id`g >c\_Gpf` @hdgtNcjm`t
,QJM R\ MR[NL]X[ XO -R\ .VRUb UR_N\ RW 6J\\JLQ^
=gjh]`mb LN[WVNW] JWM MR[NL]X[ XO \N]]\ JWM \N[_N\ `R]Q
-JWRNU R\ J UJ`bN[ `R]Q
]QN ,NW]N[ OX[ ,JUURWP  /R[\] <]NY\ OX[ /JVRURN\
]QN *UURJWLN -NONW\N
,J[NN[ J] 6J[b_RUUN JWM ,QRUM[NW JW JPNWLb
/^WM RW 4JW\J\ ,R]b MXRWP
,XUUNPN RW =NWWN\\NN ]QJ] XOON[\ QXVNKJ\NM
UR]RPJ]RXW RW LXW\]R]^]RXW
\N[_RLN\ ]X OJVRURN\
JU UJ` `R]Q J OXL^\ XW O[NNMXV XO [NURPRXW
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_>c\_5 RWLU^MRWP YJ[NW] ][JRWRWP OJVRUb LX^W\NU
2 KNURN_N ]QJ] Vb ]RVN RW ]QN 9\bLQXU RWP JWM QX^\NQXUM K^MPN]RWP <QN QJ\ JU\X
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_?\id`g5
XPb Y[XP[JV J] ,2> MN_NUXYNM RW VN ]QN `X[TNM RW <X^]Q *\RJ `R]Q 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU
2 `J\ YUNJ\NM ]X ¹WM ]QJ] ]QN ][JRWRWP 2
TWX`UNMPN JWM \TRUU\ ]X QNUY VN NaYN[RNWLN 3^\]RLN 6R\\RXW LJ[RWP OX[ `XVNW JWM PR[U\
[NLNR_NM J] ,2> KX]Q RW Y\bLQXUXPb JWM
]QN \^LLN\\ 2 QJ_N TWX`W J\ J Y[XON\\RXWJU [N\L^NM O[XV \Na ][JO¹LTRWP
RW KRKURLJU \]^MRN\ `J\ Na][NVNUb QNUY
LX^W\NUX[ =QN NM^LJ]RXW JWM YN[\XWJU
O^U RW KNLXVRWP J PXXM UJ`bN[ 6b ,2>
`X[T Y[NYJ[NM VN OX[ ]Na]^JU JWJUb\R\ JWM
VNW]X[RWP 2 [NLNR_NM QJ_N \RPWR¹LJW]Ub Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_@hdgt5
LQJWPNM VN JWM ]QN `X[T ]QJ] 2 MX 2 \Jb `R]QX^] [N\N[_J]RXW ]QJ] ]QN 9\bLQXU
RW]N[Y[N]J]RXW YN[\XWJU RW]N[JL]RXW JWM
XPb Y[XP[JV J] ,2> VX[N ]QJW Y[NYJ[NM VN
^WMN[\]JWMRWP$ R] JU\X PJ_N VN ]QN VX[JU
OX[ Vb P[JM^J]N `X[T =QJWT\ ]X 9\bLQXU
O[JVN`X[T WNLN\\J[b OX[ \^LLN\\ RW UJ`
XPb 9[XP[JV -R[NL]X[ -[ <]NYQNW /J[[J JWM
QR\ ]NJV 2 QJM WX Y[XKUNV `R]Q JWb P[JM^
J]N \LQXXU 9\bLQXUXPb[NUJ]NM LUJ\\

3 rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
D`jj`fe1Kf\eXYc\jkl[\ekjlj`e^kf[XpÂjk\Z_efcf^pkf
,XVV^WRLJ]RXW P[JM\ `QX J[N LQJWPRWP ]QN `X[UM# :fddle`ZXk\:_i`jk:i\Xk`m\cp%

N\m\cJmi`m E\id`Rdgnji <gtnn\C\gg


<J[JQ \N[_N\ RW ]QN :^JU 3JWRN \N[_N\ RW ]QN ,XV *Ub\\J UR_N\ RW /UX[
R]b -NYJ[]VNW] J] <X^]Q V^WRLJ]RXW -NYJ[]VNW] NWLN <, JWM R\ ]QN
NJ\]N[W /[NRPQ] 5RWN\ RW J] 0[NJ]N[ .^[XYN 6R\ VJ[TN]RWP VNMRJ
5NaRWP]XW <, <QN QNUY\ \RXW 0.6 RW ,XUX[JMX \YNLRJUR\] J] ]QN 7X[]Q
`R]Q JW NVYUXbNN [NLXP 0.6 R\ J VR\\RXWJ[b *VN[RLJW QNJMZ^J[]N[\
WR]RXW Y[XP[JV J\ `NUU \NWMRWP JPNWLb ]X .^ XO .<*+ @NUMRWP JWM
J\ ]QN X[PJWRcRWP XO NVYUXbNN N_NW]\ JWM [XYN 7X[]Q *O[RLJ JWM =^[TNb <QN L[NJ]N\ ,^]]RWP 9[XM^L]\ JW
]QN LXVYJWb±\ >WR]NM @Jb LJVYJRPW P[JYQRL\ JWM `[R]N\ LXYb OX[ ]QN VRWR\][b RW]N[WJ]RXWJU VJW^OJL]^[RWP LXVYJWb <QN
`NK\R]N J\ `NUU J\ X]QN[ Y^KURLJ]RXW\ JWM J\\R\]\ RW JM_N[]R\RWP JWM ][JMN \QX`\ JWM
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_N\m\c5 OX[V^UJ]N\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW \][J]NPRN\ VJWJPN\ ]QN \JUN\ UNJM MJ]JKJ\N\
=QN ,XVV^WRLJ]RXW 9[XP[JV Y[NYJ[NM VN
OX[ ]QN K^\RWN\\ `X[UM Kb ]NJLQRWP VN ]QN Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_E\id`5 Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_<gtnn\5
KJ\RL\ XO LXVY^]N[ Y[XLN\\RWP JM_N[]R\RWP 2W ]QN ,XVV^WRLJ]RXW Y[XP[JV J] ,2> 2 @QRUN J] ,2> 2 [NLNR_NM RW_JU^JKUN Y[NYJ[J
VJ[TN]RWP `[R]RWP L^U]^[N JWM [N\NJ[LQ 2] `J\ ][JRWNM RW \YNLR¹L J[NJ\ \^LQ J\ `[R]RWP ]RXW OX[ NW]N[RWP J K^\b LX[YX[J]N NW_R[XW
JU\X ]J^PQ] VN ]X ]QRWT ®X^]\RMN ]QN KXa¯ OX[ ]QN VNMRJ JWM P[JYQRL MN\RPW =QR\ ][JRW VNW] =QN VX\] RVYX[]JW] ]QRWP ]QJ] 2 XOON[
OX[ `Jb\ 2 LJW RVY[X_N Vb YN[OX[VJWLN RWP PJ_N VN J \XURM OX^WMJ]RXW J\ 2 KNPJW .<*+ R\ Vb LQJ[JL]N[ L[NJ]R_R]b JWM QNJ[]±\
XW ]QN SXK *U\X ]QN _J[RX^\ ]QNXUXPb JWM ]X `X[T RW ]QN ®[NJU `X[UM¯ 2 LXW]RW^N ]X MN\R[N ]X \QX` X]QN[\ ]QJ] 2 `X[T WX] OX[
+RKUN LUJ\\N\ ]QJ] 2 ]XXT J] ,2> QJ_N KNNW K^RUM XW ]QJ] KJ\N `R]Q WN` \TRUU\ Vb NVYUXbN[±\ Y[JR\N JWM \J]R\OJL]RXW
RW_JU^JKUN RW Y[NYJ[RWP VN OX[ Vb VRWR\][b JUXWN K^] ^U]RVJ]NUb ]X QXWX[ Vb 0XM JWM
RW ]QN K^\RWN\\ `X[UM /J]QN[ `QX PR_N\ ]QN JKRUR]b JWM \]JVRWJ
]QJ] 2 WNNM ]X [NLNR_N JWN` N_N[b VX[WRWP
JW J]]R]^MN XO SXb JWM J \YR[R] XO XY]RVR\V

D`jj`fe1Kf`ejg`i\#Xe[\hl`gjkl[\ekj]fik_\^cfYXcd`jj`fef]
.M^LJ]RXW P[JM\ `QX J[N LQJWPRWP ]QN `X[UM#
\[lZXk`fek_ifl^_giXZk`ZXcgif]\jj`feXckiX`e`e^n_`Z_`j
kiXej$ZlckliXccpfi`\ek\[Xe[9`Yc`ZXccpZ\ek\i\[%
>cmdnotBm\h`n =`iUdka Ij`gH\mlp\m_
,Q[R\]b ]NJLQN\ J] JW +NW ]NJLQN\ !]Q P[JMN 7XNU ]NJLQN\ J] J VR\
RW]N[WJ]RXWJU \LQXXU RW +RKUN J] *WWJYXUR\ *[NJ \RXWJ[b \LQXXU RW <NW
,J[JLJ\ ?NWNc^NUJ ,Q[R\]RJW <LQXXU RW *W NPJU @N\] *O[RLJ
WJYXUR\ 6J[bUJWM$ R] R\
Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_ XWN XO ]QN UJ[PN\] Y[R_J]N Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_
>cmdnot5 ,Q[R\]RJW \LQXXU\ XW ]QN Ij`g5
,2> Y[NYJ[NM VN OX[ ]NJLQRWP JK[XJM Kb .J\] ,XJ\] ,2> PJ_N VN J QNJ[] OX[ VR\\RXW\ JWM NbN\
PR_RWP VN J ¹[V OX^WMJ]RXW XO KRKURLJU ][^]Q OX[ ]QN `X[UM 2 `J\ JKUN ]X ][JW\R]RXW RW]X
`QRLQ QNUY\ VN ]X \^[_R_N ]QN LQJX\ XO URON Cjr>DPkm`k\m`_=`i5 <NWNPJU±\ L^U]^[N ]Q[X^PQ ]QN TWX`UNMPN 2
X_N[\NJ\ =QN =NJLQN[ .M^LJ]RXW Y[XP[JV =QN Y[N_RX^\ !]Q P[JMN +RKUN ]NJLQN[ `J\ J XK]JRWNM RW L^U]^[JU LUJ\\N\ J] ,2>
NZ^RYYNM VN `R]Q ]QN UJ]N\] VN]QXM\ XO P[JM^J]N XO ,2>±\ +RKUN =NJLQRWP Y[XP[JV 2
]NJLQRWP JWM _JU^JKUN NaYN[RNWLN\ RW ]QN `J\ QR[NM UJ[PNUb KJ\NM XW ]QN [NY^]J]RXW
LUJ\\[XXV =QN VJWb QX^[\ XO \N[_RWP ,2> QJ\ OX[ Y[XM^LRWP QRPQ LJURKN[ ]NJLQN[\
YNXYUN O[XV _J[RX^\ KJLTP[X^WM\ M^[RWP `QX NZ^RY JWM Y[NYJ[N ]QNR[ \]^MNW]\ 8WN
,2> ¹NUM NM^LJ]RXW Y[NYJ[NM VN ]X ]NJLQ `Jb ,2> Y[NYJ[NM VN `J\ Kb Y[X_RMRWP ]QN
Vb _N[b MR_N[\N LUJ\\ ]XMJb ]XXU\ WNLN\\J[b ]X LXVV^WRLJ]N 0XM±\ ][^]Q
]X Vb \]^MNW]\$ RWLU^MRWP J O[JVN`X[T
OX[ UN\\XW YUJW MN_NUXYVNW] L[NJ]R_R]b RW
LUJ\\[XXV J\\N\\VNW] JWM J KJ\RL ^WMN[
\]JWMRWP XO ]QN MN_NUXYVNW]JU UNJ[WRWP
\]JPN\ XO LQRUM[NW
\]JPN\ XO LQRUM[NW
\]JPN\ XO LQRUM[NW

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p 4
5`fS]VAcVaRcVU Rc`itjpr\gf
\^mjnnoc`no\b`
e`4YR_XVeYVH`c]U dioc\oapiit(
gjjfdib^\k\i_
bjrijibm\_p(
\odji_\t\o>DP'
oc`_dkgjh\di
tjpmc\i_rdgg
m`km`n`io\_jp(
]g`h\ejm)Oc\oÐn
n`mdjpnnopaa)
TjpÐggc\q`\h\(
ejmdi=d]g`\i_
\i\^\_`hd^*kmj(
a`nndji\gh\ejm)
?jp]g`km`k\m`_
oj^c\ib`oc`
rjmg_

=d]g`&<^\_`hd^*Kmja`nndji\gH\ejm8?jp]g`H\ejm
Pi_`mbm\_p\o`Kmjbm\hn AjpmT`\m=\^c`gjmjaN^d`i^`*<mon#^jio)$
Ú 8WN BNJ[ +RKUN ,N[]R¹LJ]N 2W]N[L^U]^[JU <]^MRN\ 6R\\RXW\
Ú =`X BNJ[ *\\XLRJ]N XO *[]\ Ú 6RMMUN .J\]N[W <]^MRN\
Ú /X^[ BNJ[ +JLQNUX[ XO <LRNWLN*[]\ Ú 6^\RL
Ji`T`\m>`modÙ^\o` Ú 9J\]X[JU 6RWR\][b
Ú  <NVN\]N[ ,[NMR] 9[XP[JV OXL^\NM XW KRKURLJU Ú 9\bLQXUXPb
\]^MRN\ JWM KJ\RL VRWR\][b \TRUU\ Ú =NJLQN[ .M^LJ]RXW *,<2 ,N[]R¹LJ]RXW
Ú ,X^[\N\ O[XV ]QN KJLQNUX[±\ MNP[NN Y[XP[JV J[N Ú BX^]Q 6RWR\][b
^\NM ]X O^U¹UU ]QN [NZ^R[NVNW]\ OX[ ]QR\ Y[XP[JV Hdijmn
OrjT`\m<nnj^d\o`ja<mon Ú +^\RWN\\  8[PJWRcJ]RXWJU 5NJMN[\QRY
Ú  <NVN\]N[ ,[NMR] 9[XP[JV KJUJWLRWP KRKURLJU Ú .WPUR\Q
\]^MRN\ PNWN[JU NM^LJ]RXW JWM KJ\RL VRWR\][b Ú 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU ,XVV^WR]b -N_NUXYVNW]
\TRUU\ 8^]MXX[ 5NJMN[\QRY
Ú ,X^[\N\ O[XV ]QN KJLQNUX[±\ MNP[NN Y[XP[JV J[N Ú 9QRUX\XYQb
^\NM ]X O^U¹UU ]QN [NZ^R[NVNW]\ OX[ ]QR\ Y[XP[JV Ú =NJLQRWP .WPUR\Q J\ /X[NRPW 5JWP^JPN
AjpmT`\m=\^c`gjmjaN^d`i^`*<mon Ú -RPR]JU 6NMRJ
+RKUN  9[XON\\RXWJU 9[XP[JV\
Ú *YYURNM .WPUR\Q
Ú +RKURLJU 5JWP^JPN\
Ú +RKUN =NJLQRWP
Ú ,XVV^WRLJ]RXW
Ú /JVRUb JWM ,Q^[LQ .M^LJ]RXW /*,.
Ú 0NWN[JU <]^MRN\ OX[ ][JW\ON[ \]^MNW]\
Ú 1^VJWR]RN\
8>J^hVXXgZY^iZYWni]Z6hhdX^Vi^dc[dg7^Wa^XVa=^\]Zg:YjXVi^dc67=:VcYi]ZHdji]Zgc6hhdX^Vi^dcd[8daaZ\ZhVcYHX]ddahH68H
8e[Ypk_\nXp¶n_\epflÂi\[fe\Xk:@LÂjLe[\i^iX[lXk\JZ_ffc#pflÂccËe[Xe\XjpkiXej`k`fekf
:@LÂj>iX[lXk\JZ_ffcfik_\:@LJ\d`eXipJZ_ffcf]D`jj`fej
::@LÂj>>iX[lXk\JJZ_ffcffikk_\::@LJJ\d`eXipJJZ_ffcff]DD`jj`fej

,+ rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
<A`rjaoc`>DP<gphidTjpÐq`Kmj]\]gtC`\m_ja

" -X_N
CXliXJkfQip[R\]RJW \RWPN[\XWP`[R]N[ [(JW MB `N\ RWbWXN^[ QJ_N BX^±_N Y[XK
XO J 

5J^[J R\ J , NJ[M XO QN X[\QRY JW]Q


NV
J b b X ^ ±_N WN_N[ Q ]N ] Q N ` URW RW
*`J[M  <
O Q N [ \X W P \
<QN ` [X
\] RJ W \ RW P N [ ,Q[R\ =XV
WN X RP QR] OX[ ,Q
[R
]QN `X[\QRY

JKUb \^WP X QRLQ `J\ J K LN[] <QN R\
g^ W V W aZ ` RW P R W L X W
>cYZhX ,2> ]X \
XO]NW _R\R]\ ]UJW]J
 5J^[J ]N [ ,Q^ Q RW *
[L
J ] 9 N [R V N
UNJMN[

i8>J
^cXdcXZgiV
AVjgVHidgn ZY^XVi^dcd
[
8 >J h ij Y Z cihVii]ZY d g#
\gZZih c
HVbBddgZ ZY^c]^h]d
d gZ ; ^i c Z hh 8ZciZgcVb
8>J¼hBd
JXd \]^DMNfWf]i\ QN YJRM OX[ QR\ \LQMXNXWUR]\W `P KQbX QJM
XX[N `J\ J ,
2> N[ \]^
L[^R]NM X]Q NJ[M XO
@QNW <JV 6 X[ ]X MXX[ 1N UJ]N[ [N J b b X ^ ±_N WN_N[ Q
\NUURWP +RKUN
\ M X XUUNP N  < QJ\NM
N R[ ` J b ]Q[X^PQ L b 2W  "" QN Y^[L
J WNNM ]X `
X [T ] Q P LXV Y J W N\] +RKUN
Q N J [M X O Q R\ Y^KUR\QRW U\ X W R \ ]Q N `X[UM±\ UJ[P
N N
QRV( BX^±_  =QXVJ\ 7
V J \ 7 N U\ X W 9^KUR\QRWP RX ^ \ K X X T Y^KUR\QRWP

=QX [ RW [ N UR P
M J UNJMN
Y^KUR\QN[ JW

A\i\Vdb 4pRWBP\U`eN^b Rj\ c\]QpN


3N[N 
8WNURON 6RW
OX^WMN[ XO J W P N UR \]
W N _
R\][RN\ JWM J W
RURJ[ OJLN X
`QX R\ J OJV N LJV
UUNP
,Q[R\]RJW LX
] ,Q[R\]RJW
Y^\N\ JWM J
LQ J\ ]QN
LXWLN[]\ \^ U
^\RL /N\]R_J
<XW\QRWN 6 N [
^NW] \YNJT
8>JhijYZc
ihV[iZg 1N R\ J O[NZ N
\ i d NU\ JWM ]Q
E]^a^eNVcXZ
nh e Z V ` ^c
XVXX^YZci# J] ,2> LQJY
YZVi]igV[Ä N KXXT 7Z
hjgk^k ^c \ V c Z V g" J^]QX[ XO ]Q
cY^c\id
AVhi/9ZhXZ
<gZVicZhh#

`c `g P X e Z \ p  QJ_N [NJM X
G_ \ J KN\]\NUURWP J^]QX[ BV`ZVcn9^[[ZgZcXZ4
BX ^ V J b
WN XO

9QRURY R 9dZh^i ]Zc^i
X X T \ \^ L Q J\ EgVnZg/ 4  L ] Z gZ^h<dYL
QR\ K ji<gV XZ [T QJ\
i¼h hd 6 bVo^c\VWd Y n 7 ^W aZ  9QRURY±\ `X
L ] V C>KH ij VYZg¼h
J W M ] QNHijYZci P J cR W N \ O[XV I]ZGZ hijYZcih#
= j gi h4
NM R W J
RW J KK^WLQ XO V J
IdYVn h idXdaaZ\Z
ZnheZV`h
\X J
JUU\\X JYYNJ[[N Z ]X 8
]X
  ] g^hi
8]g^ ^Vc^i
hi^V inI
^in ?ZgZ
?Z b n @ ^c \ ha
8 V b e j h
h A
A^
A ^[Z
^[[
9^^\ \Zhhii ]]X 8

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p ,,
?\iBmdaÙi'_dm`^ojmja<_hdnndjin\i_Nop_`ioAdi\i^d\gN`mqd^`n\i_cdno`\hrdgg
rjmfgdf`^m\utojÙi_tjphji`t=porc\oÐnhjm`dhkjmo\iodnoc`kjr`mjaBj_
rjmfdibocmjpbcoc`h)C`m`Ðn\nojmt?\igjq`nojo`gg5

DcZV[iZgcddc>lVhh^ii^c\^cbnd[ÄXZl^i]V lVhViiZcY^c\8>J!i]^hbVch]Z]VYcZkZgbZi!
ndjc\aVYnl]dlVh]Vk^c\Y^[ÄXjainbV`^c\ ZmegZhhZYVc^ciZgZhi^cVhh^hi^c\]ZgÄcVcX^Vaan#
]ZgeVnbZci[dgi]ZjeXdb^c\hZbZhiZg#H]Z I]ZbVcldjaYWZWg^c\^c\VX]ZX`id8>Ji]Vi
]VYVh^\c^ÄXVciVbdjcid[hijYZciadVchVcY V[iZgcddcidXdkZgi]ZWVaVcXZd[]ZgVXXdjci#
XdjaYcdiWdggdlVYY^i^dcVa[jcYh#BZVcl]^aZ! 6YY^i^dcVaan!Vh]ZXdci^cjZYid]Zae]ZgeVn
]ZgeVgZcihlZgZjcl^aa^c\idVhh^hi]Zg [dgZYjXVi^dcVaZmeZchZh!]ZVahdVhh^hiZY]Zg^c
ÄcVcX^Vaan#H]ZhjeeaZbZciZY]Zg^cXdbZWn eVn^c\WVX`]ZghijYZciadVch#
ldg`^c\ViVadXVagZhiVjgVci!WjiVYY^i^dcVa
[jcY^c\dei^dch[dgi]ZjeXdb^c\hZbZhiZg L]^aZi]^hhidgnbVnhZZbjc^fjZ!>]VkZbVcn
lZgZadd`^c\WaZV`# bdgZ_jhia^`Z^i>XdjaYh]VgZl^i]ndj>cbn
nZVghd[hZgk^XZVi8>J>]VkZ
H]ZYZX^YZYidgZ\^hiZg[dgXdjghZhVcYegVn WZZcVbVoZYVi]dl<dY
i]Vi<dYldjaYegdk^YZi]Z[jcYhh]ZcZZYZY Xdci^cjZhidegdk^YZ
idXdci^cjZhijYn^c\Vi8>J#Dci]Zbdgc^c\d[ ÄcVcXZh[dgdjg
i]ZeVnbZciYZVYa^cZh]ZgZijgcZYidbnd[" hijYZcih#
ÄXZl^i]V\adldc]Zg[VXZ#6XjhidbZgVii]Z
adXVagZhiVjgVciVh`ZY]Zgi]ZZkZc^c\WZ[dgZ
VWdji]ZgXdaaZ\ZeaVch#L]Zch]ZidaY]^bh]Z

-JW 0[RO¹W

,- rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
L)Cjr_jD\kkgtajmÙi\i^d\g\d_: nop_`ionrcjnp]hdo\A<AN<ajm\kmj( nkmdib)<kkgd^\odji_`\_gdi`ajmdio`m(
<)Oc`b`i`m\g\kkgd^\odjiajmÙi\i^d\g ^`nn^\gg`_q`mdÙ^\odji)>jgg`b`n\i_ i\odji\gnop_`iondnEpgt,ajma\gg\i_
\d_dnoc`Am``<kkgd^\odjiajmA`_`m\g pidq`mndod`n\m`m`lpdm`_oj^jgg`^o\ ?`^),ajmnkmdib)
Nop_`io<d_#A<AN<$)Ocdndn\am`` o\sm`opmi\i_\q`mdÙ^\odjirjmfnc``o
\kkgd^\odjioc\odnnpkkgd`_]toc`P)N) amjhdi_dqd_p\gnrcjr`m`n`g`^o`_) L)Rc\o\m`tjpmojkh\ejmn:
?`k\moh`ioja@_p^\odji)Do^\i]` <)Dio`m^pgopm\gNop_d`n'TjpocHdidn(
^jhkg`o`_jik\k`mjmjioc`r`]\o L)RdgghtÙi\i^d\g\d_^c\ib`amjh omt'>jhhpid^\odji'Knt^cjgjbt\i_
rrr)a\an\)`_)bjq)>DP\gnjm`lpdm`n t`\mojt`\m: @_p^\odji)
oc`^jhkg`odjija\i\__dodji\g\kkgd^\( <)Oc`m`\m`h\itq\md\]g`ndi_`o`m(
odji)#Kg`\n`n``cook5**rrr)^dp)`_p* hdidibrc`oc`m\nop_`ioÐnÙi\i^d\g L)Rc\odnoc`h\g`*a`h\g`m\odj:
Ùi\i^d\g\d_*ajmhn$ \d_rdgg^c\ib`)Hjnojajpmn^cjg\m( <)/2*0.
ncdkn\i_bm\ionc\q`hdidhphBK<
L)Rct_jDi``_\KDI\i_rc`m`_jD m`lpdm`h`ion)Di\__dodjiojBK<'joc`m L)Rc\o\m`oc`N<Ojm<>O
b`odo: q\md\]g`nrcd^c\aa`^o\nop_`ioÐnÙi\i( m`lpdm`h`ion:
<)Tjp^\i\kkgtajm\KDI\okdi)`_)bjq) ^d\g\d_\m`@A>#_`o`mhdi`_]toc` <)N<O8,-4+jpoja-/++
<KDIrdgg]`h\dg`_ojtjpÌjmdatjp A<AN<$'^jhkg`odji_\o`jaoc`A<AN<' 31+jpoja,1++
kpodi\i`(h\dg\__m`nn'dordgg]`n`io m`nd_`i^tno\opn'`o^) <>O8,3jpoja.1
ojtjpm`(h\dg\__m`nn)Ocdniph]`m
^jiÙmhntjpmd_`iodotrdococ`P)N) L)Rc\ootk`nja\d_\m`\q\dg\]g`: L)>\iD`(h\dght`nn\tojtjp:
?`k\moh`ioja@_p^\odji\i_\ggjrn <)Oc`m`\m`h\itnjpm^`noj\nndno <)T`n)@(h\dgdoojt`n^dp;^dp)`_p)
tjpoj`g`^omjid^\ggtndbitjpmA<AN< tjpdik\tdibajm^jgg`b`)Oc`ajpmh\di
\kkgd^\odji)Do\gnj\ggjrntjpojbjdi otk`nja\d_\m`A`_`m\g'No\o`'Dinodop( L)?jtjp\^^`koom\ina`m^m`_do:
\i_h\f`^c\ib`n'm`lp`no\Nop_`io odji\g'\i_Jpond_`m`njpm^`n)Dodn]`no <)T`n)Tjph\tom\ina`mdi^m`_do
<d_M`kjmo#N<M$jmÙggjpo\m`i`r\g ojrjmfrdocjpmjaÙ^`jm\cdbcn^cjjg rc`m`tjp`\mi`_\>jm\]jq`amjh\i
\kkgd^\odjidinp]n`lp`iot`\mn)Ocdn bpd_\i^`^jpin`gjmojn`^pm`oc`]`no \^^m`_do`_^jgg`b`)
iph]`mc\nm`kg\^`_\kctnd^\gndb( kjnnd]g`\d_k\^f\b`)
i\opm`\i_h\f`nkmj^`nndibhp^c L)Cjrhp^cdnoc`\kkgd^\odjia``:
lpd^f`m) L)Rc`irdggDm`^`dq`\i\r\m_ <)/0
ijodÙ^\odji:
L)Rc\odnoc`_`\_gdi`oj\kkgtajm <)>DPrdgg]`bdikmj^`nndib\r\m_ L)?jtjp\^^`ko<K^m`_do:
Ùi\i^d\g\d_: g`oo`mn\ao`mA`]),)Ji^`tjpmÙg`dn <)T`n'r`\^^`kon^jm`nja.\i_\]jq`)
<)Oc`kmdjmdot_`\_gdi`ajm^jhkg`odib ^jhkg`o`_#\ggm`lpdm`__j^ph`ion\m`
oc`A<AN<\i_>DPn^cjg\mncdk\kkgd( m`^`dq`_]t>DP$tjprdggm`^`dq`\ L)Rc\odnoc`BK<m`lpdm`h`io:
^\odjidnE\i).,ja`\^ct`\m)<kmdjmdot ijodÙ^\odjirdocdiorjr``fn) <)-)+
_`\_gdi`dhkgd`noc\o\itnop_`iorcj
^jhkg`o`noc`A<AN<\ao`mocdn_\o` L)>\iDb`o\ej]ji^\hkpn: L)>\iD\kkgtjigdi`:
h\t]`np]e`^ooj\m`_p^odjidiapi_( <)<ggnop_`iorjmf`mej]q\^\i^d`n\m` <)T@NOc`gdifoj\kkgtjigdi`dn5
dib)Apmoc`mhjm`'oc`no\o`jaNjpoc kjno`_\orrr)^dpjigdi`)^jh\i_ji cookn5**rrr)\kkgtr`])^jh*\kkgt*^dp*
>\mjgdi\m`lpdm`noc\ooc`A<AN<]` ]pgg`odi]j\m_ngj^\o`_dioc`Nop_`io
np]hdoo`_ijg\o`moc\iEpi`.+) >`io`m\i_i`\moc`>\m``mN`mqd^`n L)>\i\am`nch\ic\q`\^\m:
Oc`A<AN<hpno]`^jhkg`o`_`q`mt jaÙ^`ndioc`<_hdidnom\odji]pdg_dib) <)T`n)
t`\mdircd^c\nop_`iordnc`noj\kkgt Nop_`iorjmf`mej]n\m`jk`ioj<GG
ajmÙi\i^d\g\d_) m`bdno`m`_nop_`ion'rc`oc`mtjp\m` L)?jtjpc\q`Dio`mi`odioc`_jmhn:
A`_`m\gRjmfNop_t\kkmjq`_jmijo) <)T`n)
L)Rc\odnq`mdÙ^\odji:
<)Oc`P)N)?`k\moh`ioja@_p^\odji L)Rc`idnoc`\kkgd^\odji_`\_gdi`: L)?jtjpc\q`RdAdji^\hkpn:
m\i_jhgtn`g`^on.+k`m^`iojaoc` <)<pb),ajma\ggn`h`no`m\i_E\i),ajm <)T`n'dihjno^\hkpn]pdg_dibn)

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p ,.
]d]gd^\grjmg_qd`r 'tjpc\q`oc`jkkjm(
Efnn_Xk6 Ijroc\otjpc\q`]``i`_p^\o`_amjh\oc` i\odjinrdococ`h`nn\b`ja>cmdno)
dhk\^o
opidotojajggjrocmjpbcji>DPÐnkpmkjn`5oj h`\
\mooj^c\ib`oc`rjmg_)Rc`oc`mtjp]`^j
Ijrtjpc\q`\ijkkjmopidotoj_jtjpmk o`mdib
k\m\^cpm^cjmhdnndjinn`oodib$'jm\hdidn
kmja`nndji\ghdidno`m#rjmfdibdi\^cpm^c'
m``rdggjk`i_jjmnajmtjp)
kmja`nndji\g#dioc`h\mf`okg\^`$'>DPÐn_`b
Pbm\_p\o`nc\q`ojn\t5
C`m`Ðnrc\ok`jkg`rcjc\q``hkgjt`_>D

®2 `JW] ]X ]JTN ]QR\ XYYX[]^WR]b ®* QRPQ YN[LNW]JPN XO X^[ ®=QN ,J\XW 0[X^Y QJ\ QJM ]QN
]X ]QJWT JUU XO ]QN UNJMN[\QRY `X[TN[\ RW JKX^] ! LX^W][RN\ YUNJ\^[N XO NVYUXbRWP Z^R]N J
Y[XON\\X[\ JWM \]JOO J] ,XU^V QJ_N Y[NYJ[NM ]QNV\NU_N\ J] ON` P[JM^J]N\ XO ,XU^VKRJ
KRJ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R]b OX[ ,XU^VKRJ 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R 2W]N[WJ]RXWJU >WR_N[\R]b
MXRWP \^LQ JW X^]\]JWMRWP SXK RW ]b 2±V LXW_RWLNM ]QJ] ,2> R\ XWN @N QJ_N LXW\R\]NW]Ub KNNW
]QN MN_NUXYVNW] JWM NM^LJ]RXW XO ]QN KN\] YUJLN\ RW ]QN `X[UM RVY[N\\NM `R]Q ]QN MNMRLJ]RXW
XO bX^[ \]^MNW]\ @N QJ_N ]QN ]X LJY]^[N 0XM±\ QNJ[] OX[ ]QN TWX`UNMPN JWM Y[XON\\RXWJUR\V
Y[R_RUNPN XO NVYUXbRWP \XVN XO WJ]RXW\ `QRUN KNRWP NZ^RYYNM ]QJ] ,2> JU^VWR K[RWP ]X X^[
bX^[ P[JM^J]N\ J] <X^]QNJ\]N[W `R]Q ]QN TWX`UNMPN LQJ[JL]N[ X[PJWRcJ]RXW¯
/[NRPQ] 5RWN\ 2WL @N QJ_N KNNW JWM \TRUU\ ]QJ] J[N [NZ^R[NM OX[
`NUU YUNJ\NM `R]Q ]QN NM^LJ]RXW VRWR\][b RW \XVN XO ]QN ]X^PQN\] E]naa^h8#?d]chdc
`X[T N]QRL JWM LQJ[JL]N[ ]QJ] UXLJ]RXW\¯ KEd[DeZgVi^dchVcY=G
]QNb QJ_N MNVXW\][J]NM RW ]QN I]Z8Vhdc<gdje!>cX
K^\RWN\\ NW_R[XWVNW]¯ HiZkZG^X]VgYhdc!
J#H#9^gZXidgd[B^hh^dch6\ZcXn
?d]cL#Egndg E^dcZZgh
K^XZEgZh^YZci=GHV[Zin
Hdji]ZVhiZgc;gZ^\]iA^cZh!>cX#

,/ rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
g_Xe`\
Pfle\\[kf^\kkfbefnJk\ pio'>DP Ðn > \ m` ` m N ` mq d^`ndnoc`m`ajm
`
c ` i do Ðn o dh ` o jno\mooc`ej]c d` = mt \ i o b ` on ^\ggn\ggoc`odh
R kc\ i
d^`n_dm`^ojmNo` m>DPbm\_n)Nc
`
tjp)>\m``mN`mq oc\ o \ m` gj j f di b a j
ja
\i_]pndi`nn`n ^gp_`n\gdnodib
amjhhdidnomd`n E j ] = j \ m_ o c \ o di
f`ndo
jaoc`jigdi`>DP _p\o`n'\i_h\
\gnjf``knom\^f p _ ` i on \ i _ b m\
kjmopidod`najmno
`hkgjth`iojk  n5
`mnojkjnoej]n) o>\m``mN`mqd^`
`\ntajm`hkgjt _nc\ q ` o j n \ t \ ] j p
`>DPbm\
C`m`Ðnrc\onjh

®=QN ,J[NN[ <N[_RLN\ -NYJ[]VNW] J] ,2> `J\ JW RW_JU^


JKUN [N\X^[LN ]X VN J\ 2±_N SXK Q^W]NM X_N[ ]QN YJ\] \N_N[JU
VXW]Q\ <]NYQJWRN +[bJW] ]XXT ]QN ]RVN ]X ]NJLQ VN JKX^]
[N\^VN `[R]RWP JWM Y[XXO[NJM \N_N[JU XO Vb [N\^VN\
=QN ,2> 3XK+XJ[M R\ J P[NJ] YUJLN ]X \]J[] `QNW UXXTRWP OX[
NVYUXbVNW]¯
·AncZiiZ7^iiZgbVc

®2 JYY[NLRJ]N `QJ] <]NYQJWRN +[bJW] JWM ,J[NN[ <N[_RLN\


R\ MXRWP 2 QJ_N [NLNR_NM P^RMJWLN XW `[R]RWP J SXK [N\^VN
JWM ]RY\ OX[ SXK JYYURLJ]RXW\ JWM RW]N[_RN`\ 2] R\ PXXM ]X
TWX` ]QJ] ]QN[N R\ \XVNXWN `QX R\ \X `RUURWP ]X QNUY P[JM
^J]N\ `R]Q ]QN Y[XLN\\ XO ¹WMRWP J SXK¯
·GZWZXXV8dccZaann

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p ,0
EYVcV·d>`cVe`=ZWV
“Herme cience of
is the
art or
e v
s
e r
feZTd
eYR_YVc^V_V?\idXen_f66
neutics

mind. Y
ou’ll
et-...N nough – when
interpr e
t soon !”
find ou ake MY class
you t

N\_Xm\Xjk\if`[$]i\\jgfikjgif^iXd%K_\i\_Xm\
Y\\eefE:88m`fcXk`fej]fik_\gXjk/,p\Xij
[^]LQ¹NUM
-[ 3XQW ,

LZ¼kZcZkZgWZZcijgcZY
YdlcWnVcVi]aZiZi]Vi
lZgZXgj^iZY#7jii]Zc!
lZ¼kZcZkZg]VYVhedgih
egd\gVbJCI>ACDL
HZg^djhan!lZVgZVXi^kZan
ejghj^c\bZbWZgh]^e^c
i]ZC88669^k^h^dc>>
VcYZmeZXiidÄZaYdjg
ÄghiiZVbh^ci]Z;Vaad[
'%&%!l^i]i]Zedhh^W^a"
^ind[hdbZheg^c\hedgih
^c'%&%#NdjXdjaYbV`Z
]^hidgnWnWZ^c\dcZd[
8>J¼hÄghiVi]aZiZh

,1 rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
>jgph]d\Dio`mi\odji\gPidq`mndotc\njq`m\_ju`inop_`iojmb\idu\odjinaj^pndibji\^\_`hd^n'
^jhhpidotn`mqd^`'^pgopm\g\r\m`i`nn'\i_^\hkpnpidot)
K_\J\eXk\<o\Zlk`m\:fdd`kk\\ X_N[\NN\ JUU \]^MNW] X[PJWRcJ]RXW\ O^WL]RXW\ J\ ]QN URJR\XW KN]`NNW OJL
X_N[\NN\ JUU \]^MNW] X[PJWRcJ]RXW\ O^WL]RXW\ J\ ]QN URJR\XW KN]`NNW OJL
^U]b\]JOO JWM \]^MNW]\ UNJM\ \]^MNW] PX_N[WVNW] VNN]RWP\ JWM YUJW\ \YNLRJU N_NW]\ OX[ \]^MNW]\
:cXjjF]ËZ\ij YUJW LUJ\\ N_NW]\ ]QJ] OX\]N[ LXVV^WR]b `R]QRW NJLQ ^WMN[P[JM^J]N LUJ\\
K_\8]i`ZXe8d\i`ZXe=\ccfnj_`gD`e`jkip YUJW\ N_NW]\ ]QJ] OX\]N[ MR_N[\R]b KX]Q XW LJVY^\ JWM `R]QRW ]QN
LXVV^WR]b
DlBXggX LXWWNL]\ \]^MNW]\ `QX P[N` ^Y XW ]QN VR\\RXW ¹NUM ]X *VN[RLJW L^U]^[N JWM ]QN ,2> LXVV^WR]b
LXWWNL]\ \]^MNW]\ `QX P[N` ^Y XW ]QN VR\\RXW ¹NUM ]X *VN[RLJW
K_\:i\[f R\ JW JLJMNVRL Y^KURLJ]RXW OX\]N[RWP ]QN RW]NUURPNW] LXW\RMN[J]RXW JWM MR\L^\\RXW XO RMNJ\
K_\DXii`\[Jkl[\ek8jjfZ`Xk`fe LXWWNL]\ VJ[[RNM LX^YUN\ `R]Q NJLQ X]QN[ JWM ]QN \]^MNW] KXMb
K_\>iX[C`]\:flej\c \N[_N\ KX]Q ]QN <NVRWJ[b JWM ]QN 0[JM^J]N <LQXXU Kb QX\]RWP N_NW]\ ]QJ] Y[XVX]N
LXVV^WR]b JWM RW]N[JL]RXW JVXWP ]QN P[JM^J]N \]^MNW]\ J\ `NUU J\ `R]Q ^WMN[P[JM^J]N\
K_\=i\j_d\eC\X[\ij_`gK\Xd#=CK  \N[_N\ ]QN O[N\QVJW LUJ\\ Kb QX\]RWP \XLRJU\ UNJMRWP LQJYNU\ JWM
RW_N\]RWP RW O[N\QVNW J\ ]QNb JMS^\] ]X LXUUNPN URON
K_\Jkl[\ekD`jj`fe:fee\Zk`feJD: QNUY\ \]^MNW]\ LXVN ]X J KN]]N[ ^WMN[\]JWMRWP XO VR\\RXW\ JWM
VX[N \YNLR¹LJUUb NJLQ \]^MNW]±\ YJ[] RW [NJLQRWP ]QN `X[UM OX[ ,Q[R\]
K_\Jkl[\ekLe`fe YUJW\ N_NW]\ ]QJ] K^RUM [NUJ]RXW\QRY\ JWM ^WR]b XW LJVY^\ ._NW]\ RWLU^MN J \]^MNW] V^
YUJW\ N_NW]\ ]QJ] K^RUM [NUJ]RXW\QRY\ JWM ^WR]b XW LJVY^\ ._NW]\ RWLU^MN J \]^MNW] V^
\RL ON\]R_JU LJVYRWP ][RY\ \TR ][RY\ JWM J MXMPN KJUU ]X^[WJVNW]
K_\G`c^i`dÂjGifk\jk R\ J \]^MNW] WN`\YJYN[ MN_X]NM ]X ]QN O[NN LXWON\\RXWJU JWM [N\YNL]O^U NaLQJWPN XO
JUU RMNJ\ *[]RLUN\ J[N LXW][RK^]NM Kb \]^MNW]\ OJL^U]b JWM \]JOO =XYRL\ [JWPN O[XV ]QX\N ^WRZ^N ]X ,2> ]X
RW]N[WJ]RXWJU JOOJR[\
K_\@ek\ieXk`feXcJkl[\ekD`e`jkip@JD  \N[_N\ \]^MNW]\ O[XV X]QN[ LX^W][RN\ JWM YJ[]WN[\ `R]Q UXLJU VRW
\N[_N\ \]^MNW]\ O[XV X]QN[ LX^W][RN\ JWM YJ[]WN[\ `R]Q UXLJU VRW
R\][RN\ ]X VNN] ]QN ][JW\R]RXWJU JWM XWPXRWP WNNM\ XO RW]N[WJ]RXWJU \]^MNW]\
K_\=`e`Xc R\ ]QN JWW^JU bNJ[KXXT Y[NYJ[NM OX[ \]^MNW]\ JWM Kb ]QN \]^MNW]\ ]X LNUNK[J]N `QJ] 0XM R\ MXRWP
`R]QRW X^[ LXVV^WR]b

DefUV_e2TeZgZeZVd
@ekiXdliXcJgfikj IfZbXgXccfqX    :_i`jk`XeC`]\:fe]\i\eZ\
Nfic[:_i`jk`XeN\\b Jkl[\ekLe`feJb`Ki`g GiXp\i;Xpj   
Lck`dXk\=i`jY\\   =fidXcFg\e;fidj   8e[Xn_fc\cfkdfi\
:@L9fnc Dl[Ile
;fidNXij    Fe$:Xdglj:Xdgflk  
?fd\Zfd`e^ Jg`i`kN\\b
Ale`fi&J\e`fi=fidXc   ?Xim\jk=\jk   
Jkl[\ekLe`fe:_i`jkdXj9Xehl\k

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p ,2
HYReU ` : ? V V U e ` U ` ? V i e 0
:@LGi\m`\n;Xpj ,2> 9[N_RN` -Jb\ J[N O^W JWM RWOX[VJ]R_N -^[RWP ,2>
9[N_RN` -Jb\ bX^ LJW ]X^[ ]QN LJVY^\ J]]NWM LUJ\\N\ JWM LQJYNU NJ]
U^WLQ `R]Q ,2> 9[N\RMNW] +RUU 3XWN\ RW]N[JL] `R]Q L^[[NW] \]^MNW]\ LQJ]
`R]Q Y[XON\\X[\ RW]N[_RN` OX[ \LQXUJ[\QRY\ JWM NJ] YRccJ 4NNY JW NbN
XW X^[ `NK\R]N ,2>NM^ OX[ ]QN MJ]N\ XO ,2> 9[N_RN` -Jb\

H``odib?m)?\qd_Jgncdi`dnrjmococ`omdkoj>DPKm`qd`r
?\tn)Jgncdi`dnoc`_dm`^ojmjaoc`TjpocHdidnomtkmjbm\h)

I%:%DZHl`cb`eJZ_fcXij_`gN\\b\e[1X` `X^UM bX^ URTN J O^UU¬


]^R]RXW \LQXUJ[\QRY ]X J]]NWM ,2>( *] ]QN ;, 6L:^RUTRW <LQXUJ[\QRY @NNTNWM \N_N[JU \LQXUJ[\QRY\
J[N J`J[MNM ]X Z^JUR¹NM QRPQ \LQXXU \NWRX[\ RWLU^MRWP ]QN O^UU]^R]RXW ;, 6L:^RUTRW 5NJMN[\QRY
<LQXUJ[\QRY 2]±\ WJVNM JO]N[ ,2>±\ ¹[\] Y[N\RMNW] =QN `NNTNWM RWLU^MN\ RW]N[_RN`\ `R]Q ]QN OJL^U]b
P[X^Y MR\L^\\RXW\ RW]N[JL]RXW `R]Q L^[[NW] \]^MNW]\ QJWPRWP X^] `R]Q O^]^[N LUJ\\VJ]N\ JWM NJ]RWP
YRccJ =QN ;, 6L:^RUTRW <LQXUJ[\QRY @NNTNWM R\ QNUM N_N[b OJUU

G\ijfeXcM`j`k<LQNM^UN J _R\R] XW J MJb ]QJ] `X[T\ KN\] OX[ bX^ 9UNJ\N


WX]ROb ^\ J `NNT KNOX[N bX^ _R\R] @N±UU VJTN J[[JWPNVNW]\ OX[ bX^ ]X
VNN] `R]Q ]QN JMVR\\RXW\ ]NJV J]]NWM LQJYNU =^N\MJb/[RMJb \R] RW XW
J LUJ\\ ]QJ] RW]N[N\]\ bX^ VNN] `R]Q <]^MNW] /RWJWLRJU <N[_RLN\ \]Jb RW J
MX[V X_N[WRPQ] JWM QJ_N U^WLQ `R]Q J Y[XON\\X[ RW ]QN LJON]N[RJ `QN[N
bX^ LJW NJ] YRccJ

N^c`_pg`tjpmqdndo]t^jio\^odibpn\o#3++$222(---2'`so)
0+03'
`(h\dgqdndo;^dp)`_p)

c`Kjdio`_pmdib
oc`M)>) _d_r`
kÙm`\oO
m\mjpi_\^\h
Nop_`ionb\oc` ) h`iodji
\mncdkR``f`i_
H^LpdgfdiN^cjg
kduu\::

,3 rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
0
`fe
9\`e^Xnfic[Z_Xe^\ii\hl`i\j[Xpjf]g\ijfeXci\Ì\Zk Km\t`m?\tn
[Xpj
Xe[Z_Xcc\e^\%K_XkÂjn_pXk:@Ln\j\kXj`[\jg\Z`Xc
@N ]JTN Y[JbN[ \X \N[RX^\Ub ]QJ] `N JL]^JUUb
LJWLNU LUJ\\N\ \X N_N[bXWN LJW YJ[]RLRYJ]N RW
k_Xk_\cgpfl]fZljXe[jkXpfekiXZb]fi>f[% 9[JbN[ -Jb\ 9[JbN[ -Jb\ J[N QNUM NJLQ \NVN\
]N[ `R]Q JW NVYQJ\R\ XW KX]Q LX[YX[J]N JWM
YN[\XWJU Y[JbN[ 6JWb ,2> P[JM^J]N\ KNWN¹]NM
\X V^LQ O[XV ]QNR[ ,2> 9[JbN[ -Jb\ ]QJ] ]QNb
\]RUU \LQNM^UN Y[JbN[ MJb\ RW ]QNR[ YN[\XWJU
UR_N\

Rjmg_>cmdnod\iR``f
-^[RWP @X[UM ,Q[R\]RJW @NNT ,2> \]^MNW]\ LNU
NK[J]N `QJ] 0XM R\ MXRWP J[X^WM ]QN `X[UM JWM
LXW\RMN[ ]QNR[ YJ[]RLRYJ]RXW RW ]QN 0[NJ] ,XV
VR\\RXW ;NY[N\NW]J]R_N\ O[XV VR\\RXW\ JPNWLRN\
J[X^WM ]QN `X[UM J[N J_JRUJKUN ]X MR\L^\\ ]QNR[
`X[T `R]Q bX^ 7X VJ]]N[ `QN]QN[ bX^ J[N J
PXN[ X[ J \NWMN[ ,Q[R\]±\ LXVVJWM ]X ®VJTN
MR\LRYUN\ XO JUU ]QN WJ]RXW\¯ LXVN\ RW]X OXL^\
M^[RWP @X[UM ,Q[R\]RJW @NNT

>c\k`g
,QJYNU R\ QNUM =^N\MJb
]Q[X^PQ /[RMJb 2] RWLU^MN\
V^\RL UNM Kb J \]^MNW]
`X[\QRY KJWM \TR]\ _RMNX\
Y[XM^LNM Kb \]^MNW]\ JWM
J KRKURLJU LQJUUNWPN O[XV
YNXYUN RW_XU_NM RW VRWR\][b
]QN VJ[TN]YUJLN JWM
PX_N[WVNW] `QX J[N
>cmdnod\iGda`>jia`m`i^`
®LQJWPRWP ]QN `X[UM¯
=QN ,Q[R\]RJW 5RON ,XWON[NWLN R\ J `NNT XO [NWN`JU
JWM YN[\XWJU LXVVR]VNW] =QN N_NW] LXRWLRMN\ `R]Q
1XVNLXVRWP \X bX^ QJ_N ]QN XYYX[]^WR]b ]X VNN]
,2> JU^VWR `QX QJ_N PXWN XW KNOX[N bX^ ]X LQJWPN
]QN `X[UM

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p ,4
TR ^ a f d  a Y ` e `
Jfd\GcXZ\j8ifle[:XdgljPflE\\[kfBefn8Yflk
=QN[N J[N \XVN Y[N]]b RVYX[]JW] YNXYUN ]QJ] QJWP X^] RW ]QN H^Lpdgfdi<_hdidnom\odji=pdg_dib
H^Lpdgfdi<_hdidnom\odji=pdg_dib 
7X] XWUb `RUU bX^ ¹WM ]QN Y[N\RMNW] JWM _RLN Y[N\RMNW]\ ]QN[N ]QN [NPR\][J[ `QX TNNY\ ]JK\ XW bX^[ LUJ\\ L[NMR]\
QJ\ JW XO¹LN ]QN[N +N WRLN ]X N_N[bXWN RW ]QN ;NPR\][J[±\ 8O¹LN

BX^±UU \YNWM J UX] XO ]RVN RW ]QN Adnc`m=pdg_dib  KNLJ^\N ]QJ]±\ `QN[N VX\] XO ]QN LUJ\\[XXV\ J[N UXLJ]NM
=QN[N J[N KNWLQN\ LXW_NWRNW]Ub UXLJ]NM X^]\RMN `QN[N bX^ LJW LXUUJY\N JO]N[ NaJV\

=QN[N±\ WX J_XRMRWP ]QN B)<gg`iAg``^`Gd]m\mt  ._NW ]QX^PQ ]QN[N R\ 2W]N[WN] JLLN\\ JUU X_N[ LJVY^\ J
Y[XON\\X[ `RUU N_NW]^JUUb \NWM bX^ ]X ]QN URK[J[b OX[ J QJ[M LX_N[ KXXT X[ bX^±UU `JW] ]X PX ]QN[N ]X \NNT [NO^PN
O[XV bX^[ [XXVVJ]N

<]Jb RW \QJYN J] Oc`


Oc`Hjjm`Adoi`nn>`io`m  =QN 6XX[N /R]WN\\ ,NW]N[ ONJ]^[N\ KJ\TN]KJUU JWM _XUUNbKJUU
Hjjm` Adoi`nn >`io`m
LX^[]\ J `NRPQ] [XXV JN[XKRL\ NZ^RYVNW] UXLTN[ [XXV\ JWM \XVN ^W^\^JU MXMPN KJUU ]X^[WJVNW]\ *U\X RW
]QN ¹]WN\\ LNW]N[ R\ J UX^WPN J[NJ `R]Q J ¹[NYUJLN O^[WR]^[N JWM \WJLT KJ[

=QN Qd^ojmtKm\t`mOjr`mn  J[N J P[NJ] YUJLN OX[ VNMR]J]RXW XW =QN @X[M JWM LXVV^WRLJ]RXW `R]Q ]QN
5X[M 8LLJ\RXWJUUb LX[YX[J]N Y[JbN[ ]JTN\ YUJLN J] ]QN Y[JbN[ ]X`N[\ \^LQ J\ J LJWMUNURPQ] _RPRU

    

=QN _jmhn
_jmhn  J[N UXLJ]NM XW ]QN NJ\] JWM `N\] \RMN\ XO ]QN LJVY^\ K^] YUNJ\N `N Y[NON[ ]X LJUU ]QNV
[N\RMNWLN QJUU\

Ncjmo`nn>c\k`g   R\ `QN[N `N VNN] OX[ LQJYNU \N[_RLN\ JWM X]QN[ RVYX[]JW] N_NW]\ \^LQ J\ LXVVNWLNVNW]

=QN MjnndNop_`io>`io`m! QX^\N\ ]QN KXXT\]X[N ]QN YX\] XO¹LN JWM ]QN MRWRWP [XXV `QN[N O[RNWM\ VNN] ]X
Mjnnd Nop_`io >`io`m
NJ] JWM LQJ] `R]Q ]QN ,2> Y[N\RMNW]

Oc`Kjdio` " R\ J [RMPN X_N[ ]QN +[XJM ;R_N[ `R]Q ]QN \TbURWN XO MX`W]X`W ,XU^VKRJ RW ]QN MR\]JWLN I]ZHiViZ
Oc` Kjdio`
WN`\YJYN[ XO ,XU^VKRJ LJUU\ R] XWN XO ]QN KN\] YUJLN\ ]X `J]LQ J \^W\N]

Oc`N`^m`oK\nn\b`r\t  R\ NaJL]Ub ]QJ] * <NL[N] @N LJWWX] ]NUU bX^ `QN[N R] R\ UXLJ]NM X[ `QN[N R]
PXN\ +^] \XVN XO ]QN XUMN[ JU^VWR LUJRV R] ^\NM ]X LXWWNL] ]QN VNW±\ JWM `XVNW±\ MX[V\

 ! " 

-+ rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
nt walls
ti c k to the ceme room-
ictures s noyed with your
1) Bring

m a te y
h
LO
th
T
is
best wit an always use
ou c
S
it
of
e m ,
tape (p
a ls o if you
a li tt
get an
le to stop

ie te s t p
the noise
!)

lace from etween


about 9
b
AXZbpKXd`ÂjK`gj]fi
’t the qu n on sleeping
g s - d or ms aren y ou p la
plu if
2) Ear ing til 2am! So veral pairs.
m orn g se e
in th e
es, plea
se b r in sses ar
these tim or f r e s hmen cla b u r n
f ou
uildings makes y t.
hi r ts - All the b that shivering w e a ts hir
ts r d s
3) Swea NG! I once hea orth it! Bring a
I w
FREEZ t it’s not really smell-
calorie s , b u
ha v in g a sweet itting in
s
secret to laundry
e z e - th is is the just say, dirty our room.
y
4) Febre xperience. Let’s eally smell up
ing dorm
e s can r ppropr
iate
c lo s e t for week this is a ng laundry
your u r e if
’m not s ear because doi
ok, so I underw
r w e a r - s worth.
5) Und e
b r in g LOTS of t least 3 week
se a
but plea N! I recommend o bring en
ough
P A I th e m , s
is a ys stea
ls
r r oo m m ate alwa ll.
-you le ha
6) Pens lf and your who lly this
iss
for y ou r s e
m r oo m - basica of your-
your d or ictures
e r a s e board for You can draw p our every move!
y r ! y
7) Dr your doo inform them of
book on
like face our friends and times
least 2 to let
a n d y a m a t
self

a da y ,
t p
8) Swea r gonna need th
y ou
a

mach out.
n ts -
ting ice
after ea to wear around
ese
cre

Jlim`m`e^:fcc\^\
the dorm

say somm
e
your sto ou r p r ofessors anded taking
aper- y to be str of room
of n otebook p you don’t want un out
9) Lot s
a z in g stuff, th e w a y, you r
m by
pretty a our arm (which,  BX^±[N WX] RW 4JW\J\ JWbVX[N ¬ ,XUUNPN R\ LXVYUN]NUb
¬ ,XUUNPN R\ LXVYUN]NUb
e s on y
n ot MROON[NW] ]QJW UR_RWP J] QXVN `R]Q VXVVb JWM MJMMb
st!)
really fa =QN[N R\ WX XWN ]X ]NUU bX^ ]X NJ] bX^[ P[NNW\ KNOX[N
bX^[ MN\\N[] JWM WX XWN ]X ]NUU bX^ ]X ]^[W bX^[ URPQ]
XOO J] VRMWRPQ] 2] R\ ^Y ]X bX^ WX` ]X MN]N[VRWN ]QX\N
KX^WMJ[RN\
 ;^KKN[ M^LTb bX^±[N ]QN XWN bX^ VJTN KJ]Q ]RVN \X
 bX^ VJTN KJ]Q ]RVN \X
V^LQ O^W ¬ ;NVNVKN[ ]X K[RWP \QX`N[ \QXN\ [NPJ[M
UN\\ XO bX^[ PNWMN[
BX^ MXW±] TWX` `QX\N \`NJ]b °PRO]
PR_RWP± ONN] QJ_N ]X^LQNM ]QN KJ]Q[XXV ºXX[
 2±V [^KKN[ bX^±[N PU^N `QJ]N_N[ bX^ \Jb KX^WLN\ XOO
 `QJ]N_N[ bX^ \Jb KX^WLN\ XOO
XO VN JWM \]RLT\ ]X bX^ ¬ 2O bX^ J[N Y^]]RWP YX\]N[\ ^Y
RW bX^[ [XXV ^\N ]QN KU^N \]RLTb ]JLT R] `RUU QXUM ]QN
KN\]
 ;R\N JWM \QRWN ¬ 6^LQ XO ]QN ]RVN J\ J O[N\QVNW X[
¬ 6^LQ XO ]QN ]RVN J\ J O[N\QVNW X[
][JW\ON[ bX^ `RUU QJ_N JW NRPQ] X±LUXLT \X bX^ VJb
`JW] ]X K[RWP J LXOONN YX] X[ QX] `J]N[ YX] ]X QNUY
TNNY bX^ O[XV OJUURWP J\UNNY 2 \JRM 1.59 ]QR\ `XW±] KN
J VR[JLUN LXOONN YX] X[ QX] `J]N[ YX] bX^±UU QJ_N ]X MX
bX^[ YJ[]

¬ +[RWP bX^[ -?-\ ?RMNX


 5RPQ]\ LJVN[J JL]RXW ¬ +[RWP bX^[ -?-\ ?RMNX
0JVN\ ,XVY^]N[ 0JVN\ JWM ,-\ ]X \QJ[N `R]Q X]QN[\
6X_RN WRPQ] R\ LXVVXW [NPJ[MUN\\ XO PNWMN[
 *]]JLT XO ]QN O[N\QVNW  ¬ =QR\ VJb WX] WNLN\\J[RUb
¬ =QR\ VJb WX] WNLN\\J[RUb
KN Kb ]QN LJON]N[RJ OXXM K^] VX[N \X PXRWP X^] ]X NJ]
JWM QJ_RWP OXXM RW bX^[ [XXV +N JM_R\NM ]QJ] M[RWTRWP
J LQXLXUJ]N VRUT\QJTN JWM NJ]RWP 6L-XWJUM±\ /[NWLQ LQ

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p -,

._N[b [N\]J^[JW] RW ]X`W `JW]\ ]QN
*KKNb <QXNVJTN[ ]Q^VK\^Y

 h Z e Y  2 S S V j
6ReZ_XPfli>l`[\kf>i\Xk>ilY`e:fcldY`X
JF'r`Ðm`km`oot^jiÙ_`iotjpÐm`ijobjdiboj`\o`q`mth`\gdioc`>DP^\a`o`md\#`q`idatjp_jkpm^c\n`oc`apgg
h`\gkg\i$)Oc\oÐnrctr`n`io>DPajj_^mdod^#\i_nop_`io$<]]`tNcj`h\f`mjpoji\ojpbc\nndbih`io5Adi_oc`
hjnoapi\i__`gd^djpnkg\^`noj`\odi>jgph]d\ji\^jgg`b`nop_`ioÐn]p_b`o)<]]`tÙg`_ocdnm`qd`r5
CX=f^XkX >i\XkNiXgj
7gdVYG^kZgGdVY =VgW^hdc
7X] ONNURW± URTN ]QN ]JLX KJ[ RW ]QN ,2> LJON]N[RJ ]XWRPQ]( ,QNLT X^] 1J_N bX^ QJM XWN ]XX VJWb VRMWRPQ] @JOºN 1X^\N [^W\ JWM WNNM
]QN J^]QNW]RL JOOX[MJKUN 6NaRLJW OXXM J] 5J /XPJ]J ;RPQ] MX`W \XVN]QRWP ]X VJTN bX^ ONNU QNJU]Qb JPJRW( 0[NJ] @[JY\ `RUU MX
]QN RW]N[\]J]N O[XV LJVY^\ 5J /XPJ]J XOON[\ J Q^PN \NUNL]RXW XO ]QN ][RLT 1X] `[JY\ P[RUUNM \JWM`RLQN\ JWM MNURLRX^\ YR]J\ `RUU
]JLX\ K^[[R]X\ Z^N\JMRUUJ\ OJSR]J\ NWLQRUJMJ\ JWM WJLQX\ ]QJ] `RUU QNUY bX^ KNJ] ®]QN O[N\QVJW ¯ JWM VJbKN N_NW LJWLNU X^] ]QX\N
¹UU bX^[ \]XVJLQ `R]QX^] K[NJTRWP ]QN KJWT =QN JYYNJURWP MvLX[ 6L-XWJUM±\ O[RN\ bX^ J]N UJ\] WRPQ] 0[NJ] \RMN\ JWM M[RWT\ VJTN R] J
JWM NO¹LRNW] \N[_RLN ]JTN bX^ \X^]Q XO ]QN KX[MN[ ¬ JWM bX^ `XW±] VNJU J] J Y[RLN JWbKXMb LJW QJWMUN
N_NW WNNM J YJ\\YX[]
:Xifc`eXN`e^j
=`m\>lpj <ZgkV^hHigZZi9dlcidlc
9dlcidlc!=VgW^hdc!HVcY]^aah 7X XWN \X^]Q XO +^OOJUX MXN\ `RWP\ URTN ,J[XURWJ @RWP\ \X K[RWP
/R_N 0^b\ \N[_N\ K^[PN[\ QX] MXP\ JWM O[RN\ ]QJ] `RUU QR] ]QN \YX] bX^[ JYYN]R]N JWM MXW±] `NJ[ bX^[ OJ_X[R]N \QR[] ¬ bX^±[N PXRWP ]X
`R]Q JUU ]QN ]XYYRWP\ bX^ LJW ]QRWT XO JWM ]QNb±[N O[NN
 .WSXb PN] VN\\b ,XVYUN]N `R]Q KRP \L[NNW =?\ ,J[XURWJ @RWP\ R\ ]QN
LXVYURVNW]J[b YNJW^]\ `QRUN bX^ `JR] K^] \J_N [XXV OX[ bX^[ OXXM YN[ONL] YUJLN OX[ OXXM JWM O^W +^[PN[\ JWM \JWM`RLQN\ J[N JVXWP
¬ ]QN[N `RUU KN UX]\ XO R] 7X YUJLN RW ]X`W `RUU PR_N bX^ \X VJWb VNW^ R]NV\ K^] ]QN `RWP\ J[N ]QN [NJU MNJU @R]Q \N_N[JU \J^LN
O[RN\ JWM \^LQ Q^PN K^[PN[\ OX[ bX^[ VXWNb ºJ_X[\ ]X LQXX\N O[XV N_N[bXWN R\ \^[N ]X UNJ_N QJYYb

D\ccfnDlj_iffd K_\>flid\kJ_fg
<ZgkV^hHigZZi9dlcidlc HVajYV6kZcjZ;^kZEd^cih
2O bX^±[N UXXTRWP OX[ J YUJLN X]QN[ ]QJW =QN 9XRW]N ]X ]JTN bX^[ MJ]N =QN 0X^[VN] <QXY UXLJ]NM RW ]QN QNJ[] XO /R_N 9XRW]\ XOON[\ QRPQ
6NUUX` 6^\Q[XXV R\ ]QN YN[ONL] \YX] =QN LXXU UJRMKJLT J]VX LUJ\\ OXXM J] J Y[RLN N_NW LXUUNPN \]^MNW]\ LJW JOOX[M 1^VV^\
\YQN[N JWM O[RNWMUb \N[_RLN VJTN R] J P[NJ] QJWPX^] JWb MJb XO ]QN LQNN\N YUJ]N\ \JUJM\ \JWM`RLQN\ `[JY\ JWM L[XR\\JW]\ J[N XWUb
`NNT 6NW^ R]NV\ [JWPN O[XV \JUJM\ ]X LJUcXWN\ ]X YRccJ\ `R]Q J ON` XO ]QN VJWb \NUNL]RXW\ J] ]QR\ .^[XYNJW LJOv 8W J WRLN MJb
YX[]RXW\ UJ[PN NWX^PQ ]X \QJ[N BX^ `RUU UNJ_N O^UU \X J `JUT J[X^WM VJaRVRcN ]QN NaYN[RNWLN Kb NWSXbRWP bX^[ OXXM XW ]QN ]JKUN\ X^]
]QN \]J]N LJYR]XU K^RUMRWP JO]N[`J[M VRPQ] KN J PXXM RMNJ XQ JWM \RMN JWM ]QNW PXRWP OX[ J `JUT J[X^WM /R_N 9XRW]\
bX^[ MJ]N `RUU KN Na][J RVY[N\\NM `R]Q bX^[ ]QX^PQ]O^UWN\\ ¬ N\YN
LRJUUb RO bX^ K[RWP J LJVN[J Efik_DX`e;\c`
Cdgi]BV^cHigZZi
Qf‡jB`kZ_\e 5R]N[JUUb [RPQ] MX`W ]QN \][NN] O[XV LJVY^\ 7X[]Q 6JRW -NUR R\ J
;dgZhi9g^kZ P[NJ] XY]RXW `QN]QN[ bX^ WNNM PXXM OXXM OJ\] X[ bX^ `JW] ]X \R]
CXy\ VJb KN L^]N JWM ][NWMb K^] R]±\ WX] S^\] OX[ ]QN UJMRN\ =QN JWM LQJ] OX[ J`QRUN =QN VNW^ XOON[\ ][JMR]RXWJU MNUR R]NV\ URTN
\RVYUN bN] NLUNL]RL VNW^ XOON[\ N_N[b]QRWP O[XV `[JY\ ]X TJKXK\ ]X \JUJM\ JWM \JWM`RLQN\ K^] JU\X ONJ]^[N\ QXVNLXXTNM XY]RXW\ URTN
Z^N\JMRUUJ\ ]X \JUJM\ ]QJ] `RUU UNJ_N N_NW ]QN KRPPN\] JYYN]R]N\ O^UUb UJ\JPWJ VJ\QNM YX]J]XN\ JWM YX^WM LJTN 7X]QRWP R\ URTN 6XV±\
\J]R\¹NM /[RNWMUb NVYUXbNN\ JWM MNURLRX^\ OXXM VRPQ] S^\] LJ^\N LXXTRW± K^] 7X[]Q 6JRW -NUR LJW PN] Y[N]]b LUX\N ¬ JWM VJbKN N_NW
bX^ ]X PN] QXXTNM ¬ KN LJ[NO^U
\J]R\Ob bX^[ Q^WPN[ LXVYUN]NUb \XVN]QRWP ]QJ] QJ\W±] Z^R]N QJY
YNWNM \RWLN VX_RWP ]X \LQXXU
Df\Âj
9dlcidlc!AV`ZBjggVn7akY#!HVcY]^aah JXckpElk:X]„
+N\] K^[[R]X\ RW ]X`W ¬ QJWM\ MX`W RO bX^ LJW UN] PX XO bX^[ OXXM <gZZcZHigZZi;^kZEd^cih
]QJ] R\ 6XN±\ MXN\ <X^]Q`N\] OXXM [RPQ] `R]Q Z^N\JMRUUJ\ ]JLX /UJ] \L[NNW =?\ RW NJLQ KXX]Q *W NWMUN\\ \^YYUb XO YNJW^]\ JWM
\JUJM K^[[R]X\ WJLQX\ JWM OJSR]J\ .JLQ R]NV R\ LXXTNM ]X X[MN[ bX^ LJW ]Q[X` ]QN \QNUU\ XW ]QN ºXX[ 2]±\ J LXUUNPN \]^MNW]±\ YJ[J
VNJWRWP bX^ LJW LQXX\N bX^[ X`W RWP[NMRNW]\ JWM ]XYYRWP\ 1NJY MR\N :^JUR]b K^[PN[\ `[JY\ JWM \JWM`RLQN\ J[N \N[_NM J] J Y[RLN
RWP YX[]RXW\ JWM LXVYURVNW]J[b LQRY\ JWM \JU\J NW\^[N bX^ `XW±] KN ]QJ] `RUU VJTN N_NW ]QN P[^VYRN\] [XXVVJ]N L[JLT J \VRUN
UNJ_RWP J\TRWP OX[ ®VXN¯
,2> \]^MNW] *Y[RU 1J]]NW MNVXW\][J]N\ Y[XYN[
,2> \]^MNW] *Y[RU 1J]]NW MNVXW\][J]N\ Y[XYN[
9Xb\i9ifk_\ij8d\i`ZXe;\c` ;\jj\ik&:f]]\\ /[NWLQ O[b N]RZ^N]]N
BV^cHigZZi9dlcidlc 6XWTNb 2LN
5XLJ]NM LXW_NWRNW]Ub XW 6JRW <][NN] +JTN[ +[X]QN[\ R\ JW JOOX[M 7XWWJQ±\
JKUN JU]N[WJ]R_N ]X OJ\] OXXM @R]Q \YNLRJU]b \JWM`RLQN\ \JUJM\ ,XXU +NJW\
JWM \X^Y ]QR\ MNUR R\ \^[N ]X KN J OJ_X[R]N =QN LUNJW LXVOX[]JKUN =QN @R[NM +NJW
J]VX\YQN[N VJTN\ R] J P[NJ] YUJLN ]X QJWP X^] `R]Q O[RNWM\ =QN O^W 2VVJL^UJ]N ,XW\^VY]RXW
UXLJ]RXW JWM NWN[PN]RL \]JOO J[N \^[N ]X VJTN bX^[ NaYN[RNWLN N_NW
UX
XLJ
J]RRX
XW J
XW JW
WMM N
NWN
WN[PPN N]]RL \
RLL \]JOO
]]J
JOOOO J[N
J[[N
N \\^[
^[N ]X
]X V
VJT
JTN b
bXX^[ N
^[[ NaY
^ aYN
YN[
N[RN
RNWL
WLN N
N_N
N_NWW <]J[K^LT\
<]
]J[K^LT\
VX[N NWSXbJKUN
VX
V X[N N
X[N
[N N
[N NW
WSSXb
XbJK
XbJJKUN
UN
N

-- rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p
:fcldY`X`jk_\ZXg`kXcZ`kpf]Jflk_:Xifc`eX%@kÂjcfZXk\[`ek_\d`[[c\f]k_\jkXk\n_\i\k_\
JXcl[XXe[9ifX[I`m\ijd\\kkf]fidk_\:fe^Xi\\I`m\i%:_\Zbflk1
Mdq`m]\ifnUjj!=jo\id^\gB\m_`i ONJ]^[N\ JWRVJU\ O[XV NUNYQJW]\ ]X TXJUJ\ O[XV YNWP^RW\ ]X
\QJ[T\ O[XV OX[VJU PJ[MNW\ ]X WJ]^[JU `XXMUJWM\

Oc`Njpoc>\mjgdi\No\o`Cjpn` \]RUU QJ\ ]QN \LJ[\ UNO] KNQRWM `QNW >WRXW OX[LN\ ^WMN[ 0NWN[JU
<QN[VJW XLL^YRNM ]QN LR]b RW ! JWM LJWWXWKJUU\ \][^LT ]QN \][^L]^[N

Oc`>jgph]d\Hpn`phja<moQJ\ JW Na][JX[MRWJ[b LXUUNL]RXW XO .^[XYNJW JWM *VN[RLJW ¹WN JWM


MNLX[J]R_N J[] ]QJ] \YJW\ LNW]^[RN\

Oc`@_Q`iopm`>cdg_m`iÐnHpn`ph ONJ]^[N\ .--2. ]QN `X[UM±\ UJ[PN\] LQRUM /X[]bONN] ]JUU \R]]RWP
MX`W bX^[ SX^[WNb ]Q[X^PQ .--2. UNJM\ bX^ RW\RMN QR\ K[JRW QNJ[] JWM \]XVJLQ

Oc`Njpoc>\mjgdi\No\o`Hpn`ph R\ QX^\NM RW J OX^[\]X[b OX[VN[ ]Na]RUN VRUU K^RU] RW !"

>jib\m``I\odji\gK\mf ONJ]^[N\ ]QN UJ[PN\] [NVJRWRWP ][JL] XO XUM P[X`]Q KX]]XV UJWM RW 7X[]Q
*VN[RLJ

G\f`Hpmm\tQJ\  VRUN\ XO \QX[NURWN ]X^LQRWP OX^[ LX^W]RN\ +XJ]RWP \`RVVRWP ¹\QRWP

Oc`Cdnojmd^>jgph]d\Ajpi_\odji XOON[\ ]X^[\ XO \XVN XO ]QN XUMN\] M`NUURWP\ RW <X^]Q ,J[XURWJ


RWLU^MRWP ]QN ;XKN[] 6RUU\ 1X^\N `QN[N ,2> `J\ XWLN UXLJ]NM

+^] `JR] ]QN[N±\ VX[N


,XU^VKRJ R\ XWUb JKX^] ]`X QX^[\ O[XV ]QN ]`\^cJWM JKX^] ]`X QX^[\ O[XV ]QN
hjpio\din)

* OX^W]JRW RW ,XU^VKRJ±\ /RWUJb 9J[T `R]Q


]QN LR]b \TbURWN RW ]QN KJLTP[X^WM

rrr)^dp)`_p #3++$222)---2 t`n^dp;^dp)`_p -.
$ * 6  4 & . * / " 3 :  t  ( 3 " % 6"5 &  4 $ ) 0 0 -

Co
but iit could cost
b
them their lives.

Li
“Mr. Williams” organizes
training events for
pastors in closed
countries.

CIU is known for training and equipping leaders to serve in cultures around the globe. The alumni
of our graduate school and seminary are passionate for the gospel of Christ and committed to
living it wherever God takes them. Whether they’re teachers, counselors, businessmen, chaplains,
pastors, or missionaries, they’re changing the world. If this sounds like you — we need to meet.
Visit www.ciu.edu/equip for more information about CIU’s graduate and seminary programs.

Let’s change the world together.


For more information,
visit www.ciu.edu/equip
e-mail: yesciu@ciu.edu
phone: (800) 777-2227, ext. 5335

You might also like