You are on page 1of 14

ACEA A1/B1-10

Overview
ACEA A1/B1 oils are Mainline lubricants. They are designed for use in gasoline and light duty diesel engines that have been
specifically designed to use a low viscosity oil. ACEA A1/B1 oils are typically used in older vehicles as they do not provide the
minimum performance demanded by the latest OEM specifications. These oils may be unsuitable for use in some engines.
ACEA A1/B1 oils are typically low HTHS (3.5cP) SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA A1/B1 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
2.9 and 3.5 xW-20 2.6
1.3
Report
Report
15
8.0

The low HTHS (3.5cP) required by ACEA A1/B1 limits the number of additional performance claims that can be coupled with ACEA
A1/B1.
Prior to ACEA 2008, ACEA A1/B1 was usually coupled with the Ford specification, WSS-M2C913-B. However, a new edition of this
specification has been introduced by Ford which requires a higher minimum ACEA performance level of ACEA A5/B5-10. This will
further reduce the range of applications for which ACEA A1/B1-10 oils are suitable.

Changes
ACEA A1/B1 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004, however, it is based upon the original ACEA A1 and ACEA
B1 sequences that were introduced in 1996.
For ACEA 2010 a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA A1/B1 have been made which fundamentally change the
performance required to meet ACEA A1/B1-10. These include the inclusion of the VW TDI engine test, as a replacement for the VW
ICTD and the inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with increases in sludge
handling.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
Total Base Number
VW ICTD
VW TDI
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


A new limit of 8.0 mgKOH/g has been added
Removed
New test added
Removed.
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations or 9.0%

The introduction of a minimum Total Base Number (TBN) of 8.0 mgKOH/g affects the number of ACEA sequences that can be
combined with ACEA A1/B1-08. Prior to ACEA 2010, depending upon the performance of the engine oil, it was possible to combine
ACEA A1/B1 with a number of other sequences including ACEA C1 and C2. However, as engine oils meeting the ACEA C
Sequences are formulated to a lower sulphated ash level they tend to deliver a TBN of less than 8.0 mgKOH/g. Therefore, with the
introduction of ACEA 2010 it is unlikely that engine oils meeting the ACEA C sequences will also be able to meet ACEA A1/B1.
The inclusion of the VW TDI engine test, which evaluates direct injection diesel piston cleanliness and ring sticking, changes ACEA
A1/B1 the most. Previously ACEA A1/B1 oils were only evaluated for diesel piston cleanliness and ring sticking in an indirect
injection engine test (VW ICTD). By introducing a requirement to provide a high level of protection for direct injection diesel engines
ACEA have significantly raised the diesel piston cleanliness performance demanded from ACEA A1/B1 oils. Some existing ACEA
A1/B1 engine oils will be unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.

The limits for an acceptable level of sludge handling in the M111SL engine test have been raised to the highest level seen within
ACEA, with every sequence now required to provide the same level of performance. Some existing ACEA A1/B1 engine oils will be
unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA A1/B1 oils.

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 A1/B1-04 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 A1/B1-10 represents an upgrade in
piston cleanliness, wear protection and sludge handling.

ACEA A3/B4-10
Overview
ACEA A3/B4 oils are Upper Mainline lubricants. They are designed for a use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines and are typically used in newer vehicles as they provide the minimum performance demanded by many OEM
specifications.
ACEA A3/B4 oils are probably seen in the widest range of viscosity grades. The most common being:

SAE 10W-40 based on a mix of API Group I and Group III, or API Group II base oils.
SAE 5W-40 and SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils.
SAE 0W-30 based on API Group IV base oils.

The main physical and chemical requirements for ACEA A3/B4 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Depending upon the viscosity grade blended, ACEA A3/B4 is usually coupled with a range of OEM specifications including:
SAE 10W-40

Daimler MB-Approval 229.1


Daimler MB-Approval 229.3
Volkswagen VW50200
Volkswagen VW50101
Volkswagen VW50500

SAE 5W-40

Daimler MB-Approval 229.3


Daimler MB-Approval 229.5
Volkswagen VW50200
Volkswagen VW50500
GM / Opel Longlife B
BMW Longlife 01

Limit
3.5
1.6
Report
Report
13
10.0

Porsche

SAE 5W-30

Daimler MB-Approval 229.3


Daimler MB-Approval 229.5
Volkswagen VW50200
Volkswagen VW50500
GM / Opel Longlife A
GM / Opel Longlife B
BMW Longlife 01

Changes
ACEA A3/B4 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004, however, it is based upon the original ACEA A3 and ACEA
B4 sequences that were introduced in 1996 and 1998 respectively.
For ACEA 2010 a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA A3/B4 have been made which raise the performance required
to meet ACEA A3/B4-08. These include raising the level of diesel piston cleanliness performance in the VW TDI engine test and the
inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with increases in sludge handling.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
Total Base Number
VW TDI
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


A new limit of 8.0 mgKOH/g has been added
Piston cleanliness increased from RL206 -3 points to RL206.
Removed.
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations or 9.0%

The introduction of a minimum Total Base Number (TBN) of 8.0 mgKOH/g affects the number of ACEA sequences that can be
combined with ACEA A3/B4-08. Prior to ACEA 2008, depending upon the performance of the engine oil, it was possible to combine
ACEA A3/B4 with a number of other sequences including ACEA C3. However, as engine oils meeting the ACEA C Sequences are
formulated to a lower sulphated ash level they tend to deliver a TBN of less than 8.0 mgKOH/g. Therefore, with the introduction of
ACEA 2010 it is unlikely that engine oils meeting the ACEA C sequences will also be able to meet ACEA A3/B4.
The limits for an acceptable level of direct injection diesel piston cleanliness in the VW TDI engine test have been raised to the
highest level seen within ACEA, aligning performance with ACEA A5/B5 and all of the ACEA C Sequences. Some existing ACEA
A3/B4 engine oils will be unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.
The limits for an acceptable level of sludge handling in the M111SL engine test have been raised to the highest level seen within
ACEA, with every sequences now required to provide the same level of performance. Some existing ACEA A3/B4 engine oils will be
unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA A3/B4 oils.

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 A3/B4-04 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 A3/B4-08 represents an upgrade in
piston cleanliness, wear protection and sludge handling.

ACEA A3/B3-10
Overview

ACEA A3/B3 oils are Mainline lubricants. They are designed for general usage use in a wide range of gasoline and light duty diesel
engines. ACEA A3/B3 oils are typically used in older vehicles as they do not provide the minimum performance demanded by the
latest OEM specifications.
ACEA A3/B3 oils are seen in a wide range of viscosity grades. The most common being:
* SAE 10W-40 based on a mix of API Group I and Group III.
* SAE 15W-40 based on API Group I base oils.
The main physical and chemical requirements for ACEA A3/B3 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
1.5
Report
Report
13
8.0

Prior to ACEA 2010, the minimum performance level required by many OEM specifications was above the performance of ACEA
A3/B3 as many OEMs require a measure of direct injection diesel engine protection and specified ACEA A3/B4 to achieve this.

Changes
ACEA A3/B3 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004, however, it is based upon the original ACEA A3 and ACEA
B3 sequences that were introduced in 1996.
For ACEA 2010 a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA A3/B3 have been made which fundamentally change the
performance required to meet ACEA A3/B3-10. These include the inclusion of the VW TDI engine test, as a replacement for the VW
ICTD and the inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with increases in sludge
handling.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
Total Base Number
VW ICTD
VW TDI
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


A new limit of 8.0 mgKOH/g has been added
Removed
New test added
Removed.
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations or 9.0%

The introduction of a minimum Total Base Number (TBN) of 8.0 mgKOH/g affects the number of ACEA sequences that can be
combined with ACEA A3/B3-10. Prior to ACEA 2010, depending upon the performance of the engine oil, it was possible to combine
ACEA A3/B3 with a number of other sequences including ACEA C3. However, as engine oils meeting the ACEA C Sequences are
formulated to a lower sulphated ash level they tend to deliver a TBN of less than 8.0 mgKOH/g. Therefore, with the introduction of
ACEA 2010 it is unlikely that engine oils meeting the ACEA C sequences will also be able to meet ACEA A3/B3.
The inclusion of the VW TDI engine test, which evaluates direct injection diesel piston cleanliness and ring sticking, changes ACEA
A3/B3 the most. Previously ACEA A3/B3 oils were only evaluated for diesel piston cleanliness and ring sticking in an indirect
injection engine test (VW ICTD). By introducing a requirement to provide a high level of protection for direct injection diesel engines
ACEA have significantly raised the diesel piston cleanliness performance demanded from ACEA A3/B3 oils. Some existing ACEA
A3/B3 engine oils will be unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.
The limits for an acceptable level of sludge handling in the M111SL engine test have been raised to the highest level seen within
ACEA, with every sequences now required to provide the same level of performance. Some existing ACEA A3/B3 engine oils will be
unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA A3/B3 oils.

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 A3/B3-04 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 A3/B3-10 represents an upgrade in
piston cleanliness, wear protection and sludge handling.

ACEA A5/B5-10
Overview
ACEA A5/B5 oils are Upper Mainline lubricants. They are designed for use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines that are specifically designed to use a low viscosity oil. These oils may be unsuitable for use in some engines.
ACEA A5/B5 oils are typically low HTHS (3.5cP) SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA A5/B5 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
2.9 and 3.5
1.6
Report
Report
13
8.0

The low HTHS (3.5cP) required by ACEA A5/B5 limits the number of additional performance claims that can be coupled with ACEA
A5/B5.
Prior to ACEA 2010, ACEA A5/B5 was not usually coupled any OEM specifications. However, Ford has issued a revision to WSSM2C913-B which raises the minimum ACEA performance level from ACEA A1/B1 to ACEA A5/B5-010. Therefore, in future some
ACEA A5/B5-08 engine oils may also meet the requirements of Ford WSS-M2C913-C.

Changes
ACEA A5/B5 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004, however, it is based upon the original ACEA A5 and ACEA
B5 sequences that were introduced in 2002.
For ACEA 2010 a small number of changes to the requirements for ACEA A5/B5 have been made. These include the inclusion of
the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with increases in sludge handling.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
Total Base Number
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


A new limit of 8.0 mgKOH/g has been added
Removed
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations or 9.0%

The introduction of a minimum Total Base Number (TBN) of 8.0 mgKOH/g affects the number of ACEA sequences that can be
combined with ACEA A5/B5-08. Prior to ACEA 2010, depending upon the performance of the engine oil, it was possible to combine
ACEA A5/B5 with a number of other sequences including ACEA C1 and C2. However, as engine oils meeting the ACEA C
Sequences are formulated to a lower sulphated ash level they tend to deliver a TBN of less than 8.0 mgKOH/g. Therefore, with the
introduction of ACEA 2010 it is unlikely that engine oils meeting the ACEA C sequences will also be able to meet ACEA A5/B5.
The limits for an acceptable level of sludge handling in the M111SL engine test have been raised to the highest level seen within
ACEA, with every sequences now required to provide the same level of performance. Some existing ACEA A5/B5 engine oils will be
unable to deliver this performance without being reformulated.

The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA A5/B5 oils.

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 A5/B5-04 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 A5/B5-10 represents an upgrade in
wear protection and sludge handling.

ACEA C1-10
Overview
ACEA C1 oils are Top Tier lower SAPS1 lubricants. They are designed for use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines where advanced aftertreatment systems such as Diesel Particulate Filters (DPFs) and Three Way Catalysts (TWC) are
used.
ACEA C1 oils are typically low HTHS (3.5cP) SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA C1 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
2.9
0.5
0.05
0.2
13
-

The low HTHS (3.5cP) and low sulphated ash (0.5%) required by ACEA C1 limits the number of additional performance claims
that can be coupled with ACEA C1. ACEA C1 is usually coupled with JASO DL-1.
At present there are no OEM performance claims that require an ACEA C1 level of performance.
Note 1: SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
ACEA C1 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004 and was not updated in the 2007 issue of the Sequences.
For ACEA 2010 a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA C1 have been made. These include the inclusion of the new
OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with increases in sludge handling and fuel economy improvement.
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA C1 oils.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
OM602A
OM646LA
M111FE
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


Removed.
New test added
Fuel economy improvement increased from 2.5% to 3.0%
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations
or 9.0%

Relative Performance

The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 C1-07 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 C1-10 represents an upgrade in wear
protection, sludge handling and fuel economy improvement.

ACEA C2-10
Overview
ACEA C2 oils are Top Tier lower SAPS1 lubricants. They are designed for use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines where advanced aftertreatment systems such as Diesel Particulate Filters (DPFs) and Three Way Catalysts (TWC) are
used.
ACEA C2 oils are typically low HTHS (3.5cP) SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA C2 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
2.9
0.8
0.070 and 0.090
0.3
13

Although the mid SAPS1 requirements for ACEA C2 align well with many OEM performance specifications ACEA C2 oils are
usually formulated to a low HTHS (3.5cP) to achieve the high level of fuel economy improvement required. This limits the number
of additional performance claims that can be coupled with ACEA C2.
Although ACEA C2 oils do not usually carry any additional performance claims a number of OEMs (for example PSA) specify ACEA
C2 oils as suitable for some of their vehicles.
Note 1 : SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
ACEA C2 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004 and was not updated in the 2007 issue of the Sequences.
For ACEA 2010 a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA C2 have been made. These include the inclusion of the new
OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with an increase in sludge handling.
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA C2 oils.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


Removed.
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 + 4 standard deviations or 9.0%

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizols interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 C2-07 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 C2-10 represents an upgrade in wear
protection and sludge handling.

ACEA C3-10
Overview
ACEA C3 oils are Top Tier lower SAPS1 lubricants. They are designed for use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines where advanced aftertreatment systems such as Diesel Particulate Filters (DPFs) and Three Way Catalysts (TWC) are
used.
ACEA C3 oils are typically SAE 5W-30 or SAE 5W-40 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA C3 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
0.8
0.070 and 0.090
0.3
13
6

The mid SAPS1 requirements for ACEA C3 align well with many OEM performance specifications and usage of ACEA C3 oils has
become widespread since their introduction in ACEA 2004.
ACEA C3 is usually coupled with a range of OEM specifications including:

Daimler MB-Approval 229.31


Daimler MB-Approval 229.51
Volkswagen VW50200
Volkswagen VW50500
Volkswagen VW50501
BMW Longlife 04
Porsche (SAE 5W-40 only)

Note 1 : SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
ACEA C3 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2004 and was updated in the 2007 issue of the Sequences by raising
the diesel piston cleanliness requirement in the Volkswagen TDI engine test from RL206 - 3 points to RL206.
For ACEA 2010 a number of additional changes to the requirements for ACEA C3 have been made. These include the inclusion of
the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, along with an increase in sludge handling.
The inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test raises the diesel wear protection performance demanded from ACEA C3 oils.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
OM602A
OM646LA
M111SL

Change for ACEA 2010


Removed.
New test added
Average engine sludge to requirement to increase from RL140 to RL140 +4 standard deviations
or 9.0%

Relative Performance

The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 C3-07 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 C3-10 represents an upgrade in wear
protection.

ACEA C4-10
Overview
ACEA C4 oils are Top Tier lower SAPS1 lubricants. They are designed for use in high performance gasoline and light duty diesel
engines where advanced aftertreatment systems such as Diesel Particulate Filters (DPFs) and Three Way Catalysts (TWC) are
used.
ACEA C4 oils are typically SAE 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical requirements for ACEA
C4 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
cP
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
0.5
0.090
0.2
11
6

The high HTHS (3.5cP) and low sulphated ash (0.5%) required by ACEA C4 limits the number of additional performance claims
that can be coupled with ACEA C4.
ACEA C4 is usually coupled with Renault RN0720.
Renault's RN0720 performance specification builds on top of an ACEA C4 baseline with additional performance requirements in
areas such as detergency, oxidation and durability.
Note 1 : SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
ACEA C4 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 2007, and many of the changes made for other sequences in ACEA
2010, such as increased sludge handling, were already incorporated in ACEA 2007 C4-07.
For ACEA 2010 the inclusion of the new OM646LA engine test, as a replacement for the OM602A, raises the diesel wear protection
performance demanded from ACEA C4 oils.
The changes for ACEA 2010 are summarised below:
Test
OM602A
OM646LA

Change for ACEA 2010


Removed.
New test added

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
existing ACEA 2007 C4-07 oil sequence with the ACEA 2010 version. As shown, ACEA 2010 C4-10 represents an upgrade in wear
protection.

ACEA E4-12
Overview
ACEA E4-12 oils are Ultra High Performance Diesel (UHPD) lubricants designed for use in severe duty, long-drain applications.
ACEA E4-12 oils are typically SAE 10W-40 and 5W-30 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical
requirements for ACEA E4-12 are shown below.
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
mPa.s
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
2.0
13
12

ACEA E4-12 is usually coupled with Daimler MB-Approval 228.5 and MAN 3277, MTU Oil Category 3 and Deutz DQC IV-10.
Daimler, MAN, MTU and Deutz performance specifications build on top of an ACEA E4-12 baseline with additional performance
requirements in areas such as wear protection. Daimler MB-Approval 228.5 also specifies an ash level of 1.0-2% which prevents
low ash formulations from carrying the same approval.

Changes
ACEA E4 was first introduced into the ACEA Oil Sequences in 1998. Although the testing requirements for ACEA E4 have been
updated with each issue of the sequences it was not until 2008 that the severity was increased. This was due to the replacement of
older engine tests with new engine tests.
A number of further changes to the requirements for ACEA E4-12 have been included in the ACEA 2012 issue of the oil sequences.
The changes for ACEA E4-12 are summarised below:
Test
CEC L-105

Change for ACEA 2012


Low temperature Pumpability test added

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E4-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E6-12 oil sequence.
This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide similar performance in terms of bore polish, wear
protection, soot handling and piston cleanliness. However, ACEA E6-12 is expected to a greater level of corrosion protection and
the highest level of compatibility with advanced exhaust aftertreatment systems.

ACEA E4-12 and ACEA E6-12

The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E4-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E7-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E4-12 and ACEA E7-12

This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide different performance with ACEA E4-12 providing similar
bore polishing but greater piston cleanliness than ACEA E7-12. ACEA E7-12 provides a higher level of performance in terms of
wear protection, soot handling and corrosion protection.

ACEA E6-12
Overview
ACEA E6-12 oils are low SAPS1 Ultra High Performance Diesel (UHPD) lubricants designed for use in severe duty, long drain
applications.
ACEA recommends their use in vehicles fitted with aftertreatment systems for the reduction of particulate matter (DPFs) and oxides
of nitrogen (EGR and/or SCR), in combination with low sulphur diesel fuel.
ACEA E6-12 oils are typically SAE 10W-40 based on API Group III base oils. The main physical and chemical requirements for
ACEA E6-12 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
mPa.s
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
1.0
0.08
0.3
13
7

ACEA E6-12 is usually coupled with Daimler MB-Approval 228.51 and MAN 3477, MTU oil category 3.1 and Deutz DQC IV-10 LA.
Typically Daimler, MAN, MTU and Deutz performance specifications build on top of an ACEA E6-12 with additional performance
requirements in areas such as wear protection.
Note 1 : SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
There are a number of changes to the requirements for ACEA E6-12 in the ACEA 2012 issue of the oil sequences.
The changes for ACEA E6-12 are summarised below:
Test
CEC L-105

Change for ACEA 2012


Low Temperature Pumpability test added

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizols interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E6-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E4-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E6-12 and ACEA E4-12

This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide similar performance in terms of bore polish, soot handling
and piston cleanliness. However, ACEA E6-12 is expected to have a greater level of corrosion protection, wear protection and the
highest level of compatibility with advanced aftertreatment systems.
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E6-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E9-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E6-12 and ACEA E9-12

This comparison illustrates how ACEA E6-12 is expected to provide a higher level of aftertreatment system compatibility and piston
cleanliness. ACEA E9-12 has a greater level of corrosion protection, wear protection, soot handling and bore polish performance.

ACEA E7-12
Overview
ACEA E7-12 oils are Super High Performance Diesel (SHPD) lubricants for use in mid-drain applications.
ACEA E7-12 contains many elements of the North American API CI-4 specification. ACEA E7 is the minimum performance
requirement for heavy duty applications.
ACEA E7-12 oils are typically SAE 15W-40 based on API Group I base oils. However, there is a growing demand for ACEA E7-12
10W-40 oils. The main physical and chemical requirements for ACEA E7-12 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
mPa.s
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
2.0
13
91

ACEA E7-12 is usually coupled with Daimler MB-Approval 228.3, MAN M3275, Volvo VDS-3, MTU Oil Category 2 and Deutz DQC
III-10.
The Daimler, MAN, Volvo and Deutz performance specifications all build on top of an ACEA E7-12 baseline with additional
performance requirements in areas such as wear protection and deposit control.

Changes
A number of changes to the requirements for ACEA E7- 10 have been introduced in the ACEA 2012 issue of the oil sequences.
The changes for ACEA E7-12 are summarised below:
Test
CEC L-105

Change for ACEA 2012


Low Temperature Pumpability test added

Relative Performance

The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E7-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E4-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E4-12 and ACEA E7-12

This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide different performance with ACEA E7-12 providing lower
bore polishing but a higher level of performance in terms of wear protection, soot handling and corrosion protection than ACEA E412.
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of requirements of the
ACEA 2012 E7-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E9-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E9-12 and ACEA E7-12

This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide similar performance in terms of bore polishing and piston
cleanliness. However, ACEA E9-12 is expected to provide a higher level of performance in terms of corrosion protection, soot
handling, aftertreatment compatibility and wear protection than ACEA E7-12.

ACEA E9-12
Overview
ACEA E9-12 is a new mid SAPS1 requirement Ultra High Performance Diesel (UHPD) lubricants for use in mid drain applications.
ACEA E9-12 contains many elements of the North American API CJ-4 specification.
ACEA recommend ACEA E9-12 for use in vehicles fitted with advanced exhaust aftertreatment systems for the reduction of
particulate matter (DPFs) and the oxides of nitrogen (EGR and/or SCR) in combination with low sulphur diesel fuel.
ACEA E9-12 oils are SAE 15W-40 based on API Group II base oils and 10W-XX based on either API Group II or Group III or a mix
of Group II/III base oils. The main physical and chemical requirements anticipated for ACEA E9-12 are shown below:
Requirement
HTHS viscosity
Sulphated Ash
Phosphorus
Sulphur
Evaporation loss (NOACK)
Total Base Number

Method
CEC L-36-A-90
ASTM D874
ASTM D5185
ASTM D5185
CEC L-40-A-93
ASTM D2896

Unit
mPa.s
%wt
%wt
%wt
%
mgKOH/g

Limit
3.5
1.0
0.12
0.4
13
7

The unique inclusion of the Mack T-11 and ISM engine tests in this category places an emphasis on enhanced soot handling
performance and soot related wear control. This means that ACEA E9-12 takes a global position, aligning with global OEM
specifications such as Daimler MB228.31, Volvo VDS-4 and Deutz III-10LA.
E9-12 anticipates baseline performance for Euro VI emission legislation, which demands mandatory DPFs on all vehicles in Europe
(aligning with EPA 2010).

Note 1 : SAPS refers to Sulphated Ash, Phosphorus and Sulphur, the levels of which are often restricted in the latest performance
specifications.

Changes
A number of changes to the requirements for ACEA E9-12 have been introduced in the ACEA 2012 issue of the oil sequences.
The changes for ACEA E9-12 are summarised below:
Test
CEC L-105

Change for ACEA 2012


Low Temperature Pumpability test added

Relative Performance
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance requirements of ACEA
2012 E9-12 oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E7-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E9-12 and ACEA E7-12

This comparison illustrates how both sequences are expected to provide similar performance in terms of bore polishing and piston
cleanliness. However, ACEA E9-12 is expected to provide a higher level of performance in terms of corrosion protection, soot
handling, aftertreatment compatibility and wear protection than ACEA E7-12.
The relative performance diagrams presented below compare Lubrizol's interpretation of the performance of the ACEA 2012 E9-12
oil sequence with the ACEA 2012 E6-12 oil sequence.

ACEA E6-12 and ACEA E9-12

This comparison illustrates how ACEA E9-12 is expected to provide a greater level of corrosion protection, wear protection and soot
handling than ACEA E6-12. ACEA E6-12 has a higher level of aftertreatment system compatibility, piston cleanliness and bore
polish resistance

You might also like