You are on page 1of 19

Reprod. Nutr. Dev.

45 (2005) 261–279 261


© INRA, EDP Sciences, 2005
DOI: 10.1051/rnd:2005019
Review

Particularities of reproduction and oogenesis


in teleost fish compared to mammals

Bernard JALABERT*

Groupe « Sexualité et Reproduction des Poissons », Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique,


SCRIBE, Campus de Beaulieu, 35042 Rennes Cedex, France

Abstract – Compared to mammals, teleost reproduction presents many original features.


Reproductive strategies of species are diversified into numerous adaptations to a large variety of
aquatic environments. This diversity may concern sexuality, spawning and parental behaviour,
sensitivity to environmental factors, and specific features of gametogenesis such as the duration of
vitellogenesis, and egg morphology. Sexuality presents a variety of natural modalities, from
gonochorism to hermaphrodism. The absence of definitive arrest of body growth in the adult of most
species gives a particular interest to the practical control of growth-reproduction interactions.
Vitellogenesis, which represents an important metabolic effort for the maternal organism, involves
the synthesis of vitellogenin, a specific glycolipo-phosphoprotein produced in the liver under
estradiol stimulation, and its incorporation into oocytes by a receptor mediated process. Both estradiol
synthesis in follicle cells and vtg uptake by vitellogenic follicles appear to be mainly controlled by
FSH. Oocyte maturation is directly triggered by a progestin, or MIS (maturation inducing steroid)
synthesised in follicle cells mainly under LH control, and acting through the non-genomic activation
of a membrane receptor. Practical applications of some of these particularities result mainly from
the external character of the fertilisation process and of embryonic development, which allows
manipulating respectively egg chromosome stocks and sex differentiation. Moreover, the sensitivity
of sex differentiation to exogenous factors favours the development of practical methods to control
the sex of farmed populations. Finally, the sensitivity of reproductive mechanisms to xenobiotics
has led to various kinds of bioassays for putative pollutants.

reproductive strategies / sexuality / spawning / vitellogenesis / oocyte maturation / fertilisation

1. INTRODUCTION such a natural diversity is very interesting


for comparative biology. But it also con-
Modes of reproduction in fishes offer an tains numerous biological models, some of
extreme diversity related to the great number which are particularly convenient to acquire
of species (about 28700, according to Fish- physiological or genetic knowledge of gen-
Base: www.fishbase.org), and to the large eral interest in vertebrates, and some other
variety of aquatic environments inhabited. more convenient to develop fish farming
This resulted in numerous adaptations also systems. Professor Charles Thibault was
called “reproductive strategies” [1]. Of course, probably highly conscious of these ideas,

* Corresponding author: Bernard.Jalabert@rennes.inra.fr

Article published by EDP Sciences and available at http://www.edpsciences.org/rnd or http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/rnd:2005019


262 B. Jalabert

Table I. World evolution of finfish aquaculture natural variants, from strict gonochorism to
production compared to total aquaculture, total simultaneous functional hermaphroditism.
fisheries, and total terrestrial animals, from 1970 [3–5].
to 2000 (million metric tons) (source: FAO). Gonochorism can even be underlied by
1970 2000 Coefficient
a more or less tight genetic determinism. In
fact, only some species exhibit morpholog-
Terrestrial animals 100 235 * 2.35 ically differentiated sex chromosomes [6].
Total fisheries 66 96 * 1.45 In the others, male or female heterogamety
Total aquaculture 3.5 46 * 13.1 was first deduced from results of back
Cultured finfishes 1.5 23 * 15.3 crossing individuals obtained by hormonal
sex reversion [7], like in tilapias Oreochromis
mossambicus [8] and O. niloticus [9], or
thirty-five years ago, when he decided to from artificial gynogenesis like in rainbow
draw up a state of knowledge in the field of trout Oncorynchus mykiss [10]. In tilapias
fish reproductive physiology as a part of a belonging to the genus Oreochromis, the
university course. Thus noticing an obvious heterogametic sex may be either the male or
lack of knowledge at that time, he strongly the female depending on the species. This
contributed to develop in INRA a research may explain why crossing homogametic
group in that field. Since that time, a con- males from one species with homogametic
siderable number of research works has females from the other can give monosex
also accumulated in the world. Fishes male F1 offspring, an interesting result for
became biological models for various sci- tilapia fish farming since monosex male
entific disciplines [2]. On the other hand, populations are expected to express a better
the world production of cultured fish exhib- growth rate without growing in number
ited a tremendous rise (Tab. I). All this [11]. However, sex-ratio results from the
shows that the initiative taken by professor back crosses between F1 and parent species
Thibault was in fact a precursor enterprise. suggest that the genetic determination sys-
The present paper does not intend to reach tem might not be so simple [9, 11]. Recent
exhaustivity in a field now so wide. It is data actually confirm that sex chromo-
only aimed at bringing out some particular- somes of O. niloticus, although identified
ities of reproduction in fishes compared to by in situ hybridation techniques, are still
mammals. Therefore, it will give a brief weakly differentiated [12, 13], and that sex
overview of various reproductive strate- determining genes can be localised on other
gies, then it will focus on some original chromosomes [14]. In salmonids, where the
points about teleost oogenesis, and finally male is generally considered as the hetero-
it will give some examples of applications gametic sex, the determining locus can be
to the control of reproduction in fish farm- situated on different chromosomes depend-
ing. Bibliographic references will be pref-
ing on the species [15], and other loci can
erentially chosen among original works
also play a role [16]. Such weak differenti-
from the research groups that were initially
ation of sex chromosomes may probably
established by Professor Charles Thibault.
explain that viable abnormal new geno-
types YY can be obtained relatively easily
2. MAIN PARTICULARITIES through various procedures, such as auto-
OF FISH REPRODUCTION fertilisation in hermaphroditic rainbow trout
obtained by estrogenic treatment [17].
2.1. Sexuality Moreover, the phenotypic sex in some
gonochoric species appears to result from
Reproductive strategy diversity first con- interactions between genetic and environ-
cerns sexuality, which shows numerous mental factors during gonad differentiation
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 263

[5]. Thus, among farmed species, sex-ratio hermaphroditic species, age and size of sex
deviations in favour of males can be inversion can be strongly influenced by
observed in tilapia O. niloticus and atipa environmental factors in a wide sense, i.e.
Hoplosternum littorale [18] exposed to a including social interactions, and particu-
high incubation temperature [19], and in sea larly by the sex ratio within a fish group.
bass Dicentrarchus labrax submitted to Finally, the occurrence of simultaneous
complex interactions between temperature hermaphroditism with self fertilization was
[20, 21] and probably other factors associ- discovered in a species of the tropical man-
ated with juvenile farming stages [22]. In grove, Rivulus marmoratus [30]. In this spe-
both cases, the sensitivity to environmental cies, however, some males can be excep-
factors appear to exhibit a strong genetic tionally found with a low frequency which
component. can be artificially increased by exposition
Finally, another particularity of sex dif- to lower temperatures than normal (19.5
ferentiation in fishes compared to mam- instead of 25) during development [31]. In
fact, this seems to be the case in various
mals is that exogenous steroid treatments,
populations of this species, some of which
administered during gonad differentiation
have been shown to be distinct homozygous
through either balneation or food, are rela-
strains, whereas some outcrossing might
tively efficient to obtain functional sex-
occur in the others, due to the occasional
reversed fishes. Such an ability, which was
presence of some males. Such outcrossing
first demonstrated in various aquarium spe- is suspected to have evolved as a phenotyp-
cies [4], was further developed for experi- ically plastic character, and its expression in
mental purposes [5] and even for fish farm- R. marmoratus has been suggested to be
ing when rearing monosex populations is dormant unless triggered by some ecologi-
economically advantageous [23]. cal factor that is not well understood [32].
Concerning hermaphroditism, numerous Finally, the occurrence in some species
variants of this strategy and underlying of sex strategies which have been described
mechanisms have been extensively reviewed as “degraded” must be mentioned [33]. This
[3, 5, 24]. The most current is successive is the case of natural gynogenesis and hybri-
hermaphroditism. This can be protandrous, dogenesis that have been exhaustively
when the fish breeds as a functional male reviewed [34]. The “Amazon molly”, Poe-
during the first part of the life cycle, before cillia formosa, is a famous well known
undergoing sex inversion to breed as a example of natural gynogenesis [35]. This
female during the second part. Among cul- species is structured into a limited number
tured species, this is the case of barramundi, of clones [36], diploid in general, or more
Lates calcarifer [25], and of numerous rarely triploid. Reproduction depends on
sparid fish such as the sea-bream [26] and the activation of oocytes by the spermato-
red porgy Pagrus pagrus [27]. Protogynous zoa from sympatric close-related species.
hermaphroditism is particularly frequent As a result of the suppression of normal
among serranid fish, especially groupers [28]. mechanisms of meiosis [37], oocytes are
Simultaneous hermaphroditism is charac- either diploid or triploid, depending on
terised by the development of testicular and clones, and they are holding the same gen-
ovarian parts that reach maturity at the same otype as the mother. This species has been
time within the gonads of the same fish. It suggested to result from an initial hybrida-
can be found in some serranid species from tion event [38]. Other examples of natural
coral reefs, but occurrence of self fertilisa- gynogenesis are known, such as two sub-
tion is exceptional because each partner species of Carassius auratus, the gibelio
alterns its sexual role and successively Carassius auratus gibelio (China and East-
releases eggs and sperm in turn along suc- ern Europe), and the gimbuna Carassius
cessive spawning sequences [29]. In most auratus langsdorfii (Japan) which exist as
264 B. Jalabert

triploid, usually monosex, female popula- parental cares to eggs and fry. Fertilisation
tions. In gimbuna, at least two meiosis is the more often external, after almost
anomalies can explain this mode of repro- simultaneous release of eggs and sperm
duction: the formation of an abortive tripo- during spawning. Only some examples will
lar spindle in place of the first meiotic divi- be given here, mainly taken among cultured
sion [39], and the unability of oocytes to species. Pelagic spawning concerns species
promote the nuclear envelope breakdown like cod Gadus morhua [43], or sea-bass
of the spermatozoa, which cannot be trans- Sparus aurata that annually spawn a very
formed into a male pronucleus after activat- large number of small floating eggs. The
ing the oocyte [40]. Another case of special eggs of various freshwater species are laid
sexual strategy is hybridogenesis with a surrounded by an external sticky layer, like
well known example in the genus Poecili- the common carp Cyprinus carpio [44], and
opsis [41]. This strategy allows an actually some silurid species such as the African cat-
hybrid all-female population, in which both fish Clarias gariepinus [45]. Such eggs are
parental genomes are co-expressed at the pasted upon aquatic plants, floating debris,
somatic level, to persist by way of a non or any kind of immersed substrate where
recombinant meiosis that selectively dis- they are left after spawning. Salmonids
card one parental genome. Thus, the back deposit large sized demersal eggs in a gravel
cross with males of one parental species tough excavated by tail movements of the
gives normal individuals of this species, while female and leave them without additional
the back cross with the other species again care. Some farmed silurids like Ictalurus
produces the hybrid species. punctatus in America and Chrysychtys
Such diversity is potentially rich of situ- nigrodigitatus in Africa spawn within shel-
ations especially convenient for the unscram- tered cavities where both parents take care
bling of mechanisms common to all verte- of the eggs and embryos during the incuba-
brates. For example, the availability of two tion period. The male of another silurid, the
different strains of gibelio, one gonochor- atipa Hoplosternum littorale in tropical
istic with a normal first meiotic division, South America, builds a floating nest made
and the other gynogenetic, with a first mei- of vegetal debris and mucus bubbles where
otic division inhibited, appeared conven- eggs are deposited and bitterly defended
ient to try to identify genes differentially against intruders [46]. Finally, in tilapias of
expressed in fully-grown oocytes of both the genus Oreochromis, the male digs a fun-
populations [42]. This allowed finding dif- nel-shaped nest on the bottom with its mouth.
ferential expression of four genes, out of In the course of several repeated spawning
which two were novel genes. The others sequences, successive egg clutches are laid
were histone H2A, and cyclin A2. The by the female, covered with a ribbon of
mRNA of the last were found to be stored sperm by the male, and then taken in the
in much higher amounts in oocytes of the mouth by the female. She will keep the
gynogenetic strain than in the gonochoristic embryos continuously within the buc-
strain. copharyngeal cavity during a first period of
15 days (at ~ 27 °C) of embryo develop-
2.2. Reproductive and parental ment, thus ceasing to feed, then liberating
behaviour – spawning the young fry temporarily for increasing
and fertilisation periods, up to definitive release at the end
of larval development [47]. In that species
Reproductive behaviours in the wild are exhibiting repeated successive reproductive
also widely diversified, from collective pelagic cycles of about one month, mouth brooding
spawning without any egg care, up to behaviour is closely related to the rhythm of
sophisticated sexual behaviours eventually ovarian development [48] and endocrine
involving nest building, and followed by profiles of growth hormone, prolactin
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 265

(PRL) and sex steroids [49]. In tilapias belong- migrations during the natural life cycle of
ing to the genus Sarotherodon, mouth brood- some species. In those with seasonal repro-
ing is normally performed by the male, but duction, a major adaptation concerns spawn-
the female can occasionally participate [50]. ing time which is adjusted in such a way that
Although an implication of PRL in the reg- the specific food requirements of young fry
ulation of maternal behaviour has been sug- coincide with the seasonal availability of
gested in various fish species, no definitively that food. Depending on the species, this
convincing evidence has been brought so far. adjustment depends on specific character-
In particular instances among teleost spe- istics of embryonic development duration,
cies, fertilisation can be internal, for instance itself related to the amount of yolk and egg
in some silurids [45] or well known vivip- size. It involves an anticipation of the game-
arous cyprinodontiforms like the mosquito togenesis physiological processes, which
fish, Gambusia affinis, or the guppy, Poe- can last more or less according to different
cilia reticulata. In the latter, males exhibit species, from several months up to one year
a gonopodium resulting from the modifica- in some of them, such as salmonids. Most
tion of several anal fin rays into a kind of generally, as underlined by Bromage [54],
erectile gutter which allows discharging the “photoperiod is the main factor entrain-
sperm clusters, or spermatozeugmata, into ing the endogenous processes or clocks
the female genital papilla [51]. Spermato- which time reproduction, the other environ-
zoa get through the oviduct into the ovarian mental factors probably acting in a permis-
cavity where they can retain their fertilising sive manner to ‘gate’ endogenous processes”.
ability for several months. Storage sites are Among these, temperature can obviously be
either a seminal receptacle formed by an expected to play an important role in poikil-
extension of the antero-dorsal region of the otherm species through modulation of all
physiological processes and endocrine reg-
ovarian cavity, where spermatozoa are
ulations. In some cases, temperature can
inserted into specialised cells presenting an
simply play as a higher or lower limiting
astonishing ultrastructural analogy with
factor during certain gametogenesis stages.
testis Sertoli cells [52], or knob-shaped
Thus meiotic maturation and ovulation in
micropockets expanding from the ovarian
salmonids are inhibited over a higher
cavity to the follicle surface which are prob-
threshold depending on species, of the order
ably the sites of sperm entry at fertilisation
of 8 °C in the Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus
time [53]. Oocyte maturation is not fol-
[55], and of 15 °C in rainbow trout [56].
lowed by ovulation, but by intrafollicular
Conversely, the same processes are revers-
fertilisation with spermatozoa released from ibly blocked in the rainbow trout at exces-
storage sites. Embryo development also sively low temperatures [57]. However, the
occurs inside the follicles, up to parturition physiological targets of these inhibitions
of fully developed fry. are not easy to dissociate, and endocrino-
logical approaches often give paradoxical
2.3. Importance of environmental results. Thus, maintaining goldfish Caras-
factors sius auratus at high water temperature after
spawning also durably maintains a high
The role of environmental factors in the plasma level of gonadotropin, but inhibits
control of fish reproductive cycles has been spermatogenesis [58]. Recent data obtained
reviewed in several papers, out of which in the grass carp, Ctenopharyngodon idella,
only one of the most recent will be men- introduced in a tropical area, suggest that
tioned here [54]. Fish reproduction must be several relays along the brain-pituitary-
closely adapted to the fluctuations of aquatic gonad axis may be simultaneously deregu-
medium, whether such fluctuations result lated [59]. Apart from temperature, other
from cyclic seasonal variations or from physico-chemical factors can also play a
266 B. Jalabert

role, especially in euryhaline migrating spe- reproductive cycle [68]. As a result of this
cies, such as hydrostatic pressure associated subcontinuous growth, absolute fecundity,
with depth in the European anguilla Anguilla i.e. the number of eggs produced by one
anguilla [60], water salinity changes in the female, is well known to increase in relation
Atlantic salmon Salmo salar, or water elec- to female age and size. Besides, numerous
tric conductivity changes in mormyrids fish species exhibit sex dimorphism, like
[61]. Finally, social factors, i.e. all conge- many other vertebrates. Concerning farmed
neric signals, coming through visual, sound, species, such a dimorphism leads to privi-
tactile or chemical stimuli, may act more or leged rearing of the best growing sex, for
less at some level in some species. They example females in the sea-bass Dicentra-
play a role in the control of sex differentia- rchus labrax [69] or males in the tilapia
tion in some hermaphroditic species, partic- O. niloticus [47, 70]. Moreover, growth dif-
ularly in serranids, even in farmed species ference in the latter species, is accentuated
such as groupers [28, 62]. In the tilapia Ore- by female starvation during mouth brood-
ochromis mossambicus, they advance the age ing [71]. Finally, in some species like sal-
at first spawning [63] or modulate the dura- monids, the first spawning may occur one
tion of the inter spawning interval [64]. But, year earlier in males than in females. Since
most of all, social interactions are very spawning is temporarily detrimental to body
important to synchronise maturation and growth and flesh quality, this feature often
release of gametes from both sexes during leads to privileged female rearing, even in
spawning. Thus, acoustic emissions in O. the absence of an important growth dimor-
mossambicus was suggested to play a role phism [72].
in advertising the presence and spawning All these interactions between growth
readiness of males and in synchronising and reproduction, also known to occur in
gamete release [65]. Chemical signals appear many vertebrates, thus appear particularly
generally as hormonal substances or their important in fish. They are underlain by
metabolites which are released into water endocrine interactions between the gonado-
and act as sex pheromones in addition to tropic axis and the somatotropic axis,
their hormonal role [66]. For example, among which the pituitary Growth Hor-
17,20β-dihydroxy-4pregnen-3one and pros- mone appears to play a specific role in the
taglandin F2α (PGF2α), two molecules that physiology of puberty, gametogenesis and
are respectively and successively involved
fertility [73].
in the control of oocyte maturation and ovu-
lation in female goldfish, as will be seen
below, are also released in water and trigger
respectively and successively spermiation 3. OOGENESIS
and spawning behaviour in the male [66]. In
the African catfish Clarias gariepinus, ster- 3.1. Ovary, ovarian follicle and oocyte
oid glucuronides released by the male act as
olfactory stimulants promoting the attrac- Table II shows a brief survey of the diver-
tion of ovulated females [67]. sity of egg characteristics in some species,
related to the great variety of reproductive
strategies. A much more exhaustive table
2.4. Growth and reproduction can be consulted in the book of J. Mellinger
A particularly original feature of most [33].
fish species compared to mammals is the Despite a great diversity in their aspect,
absence of a definitive arrest of body growth the ovaries of numerous teleost species
in the adult. At the most, the growth curve show a similar general structure that was
may show some slowing down, more or less already described some time ago [74]. In
important according to species, related to the most cases, they generally appear as paired
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 267

Table II. Egg number and size diversity in some teleost fish.

Species Mean fecundity Eggs mean diameter Particularities


(eggs number·kg–1) (mm)
Turbot (Scophtalmus maximus) 1 000 000 1.02 Floating, pelagic
Cod (Gadus morhua) 500 000 1.4 Floating, pelagic
Carp (Cyprinus carpio) 50 000–100 000 1–1.5 Adhesive on vegetal
substrate
Salmonids 2 000–3 000 4–5.5 Benthic
Tilapia (genus Oreochromis) 50–200 2–4 Maternal mouth-brooding
Tilapias (genus Tilapia) 500–1000 1–2 Substrate brooding

elongated organs oriented longitudinally body cavity where mature oocytes are
within the abdominal cavity. They are sur- directly released at ovulation, and where
rounded by a conjunctive tunica, the meso- they can remain some time before being laid
varium, adherent to the dorsal lining of the though the genital papilla.
abdominal cavity, under the swim bladder. In comparison with a preovulatory mam-
The posterior part of each ovary is pro- malian follicle, a fish postvitellogenic fol-
longed by an oviduct connected to the gen- licle has no antrum, and most of its volume
ital papilla. Ovaries are compartmentalised is occupied by the oocyte. At that stage the
by numerous septa formed by folds of the oocyte contains a great amount of yolk and
germinal epithelium, usually called oviger- a large germinal vesicle (several hundreds
ous lamellae, projecting into the ovarian of microns), often localised in a peripheral
lumen. These lamellae contain nests of oog- position. It is surrounded by a relatively
onia and oocytes at early stages of entry into thick acellular envelope exhibiting a porous
the meiotic prophase, and follicles at vari- fibrillar structure [80], the zona radiata, and
ous stages of oocyte and follicle growth and by several cell layers. A first monolayer of
differentiation. In contrast to mammals, oog- granulosa cells, directly attached to the zona
onia keep on proliferating in adult females radiata, is first surrounded by a thin basal
[75] thus renewing the stocks of young lamina, and then by several more or less dis-
oocytes and follicles. Oogonial mitosis may tinct theca cell layers. The zona radiata,
generally be observed more easily within which is the future egg shell or egg chorion,
the germinative epithelium after ovulation shows numerous tiny radial canals through
when the ovarian tissues are reorganising which finger-like microvilli from the oocyte
[76, 77] or in the remnant ovary just after and from granulosa cells cross each other,
unilateral ovariectomy [78]. At ovulation, linked by numerous “gap-junctions” [81,
mature oocytes are released from their fol- 82]. Granulosa cells form a regular monol-
licle into the ovarian cavity, before being ayer, but the morphology and functions of
laid outside through the oviduct and the these cells may be somewhat different
genital papilla. Apart from the schema between the animal and vegetal poles [83].
above, there are some exceptions. Vivipa- Moreover an enormous highly specialised
rous poecilids have only one ovary [79] which cell at the animal pole, the micropylar cell,
presents specialised structures devoted to closes up the micropyle [84]. The last,
long term preservation of spermatozoa [52, which has been described in many species,
53]. On the contrary, the ovaries of some appears as a kind of funnel with a small
species such as trout and salmon are not opening on the oocyte side of about 5 µ in
completely surrounded by the mesovarium wide in the rainbow trout, which will be just
and the ovigerous lamellae are open on the enough to allow one sperm to get through
268 B. Jalabert

[85]. Theca layers are vascularised by small of vitellogenesis, against about 1% some
capillary vessels, close to which special time after ovulation, in numerous species
cells showing ultrastructural features of that spawn yearly only once, such as the
steroidogenic cells may be observed [86]. rainbow trout. The term “vitellogenesis”
But granulosa cells are also known to par- has often been used to designate more or
ticipate in ovarian steroidogenesis by syn- less restricted phases of a whole of complex
thesising estradiol during vitellogenesis and processes, among which the synthesis of
progestins during oocyte maturation, from organic compounds within the oocyte, the
precursors provided by theca cells [87, 88]. incorporation of macromolecules synthe-
In rainbow trout, theca cells that were look- sised in the liver and brought by the blood,
ing like fibroblast cells during vitellogene- and the deep reorganisation of all these
sis, undergo rapid morphological differen- reserves at the time of meiotic maturation
tiation into smooth muscle-like cells during [33]. This term will be used here in a
oocyte maturation and behave functionally restricted meaning, to designate only the
as such [89]. Immediately after ovulation, accumulation of the lipoproteic yolk com-
these cells participate actively in the ovar- ing from its hepatic precursor, vitellogenin
ian reorganisation, rapidly phagocytozing (vtg), brought by the blood. Vitellogenin is
the collagen bundle, thus breaking down the a glycolipophosphoprotein containing 79%
pre-existent collagen fiber framework of proteins and 19% lipids, with 70% phos-
the theca [90]. pholipids, in the rainbow trout [100]. It is
Oogenesis developmental stages have synthesised in the liver in response to estro-
been extensively described in numerous genic stimulation [101–103], like most of
species, with some differences depending zona radiata proteins (ZrP) in many species
on the species and the classification criteria. [104]. After leaving the blood vessels, vtg
Only some of the earlier and the more goes through the follicle wall and is selec-
minutely detailed will be mentioned here: tively incorporated into the oocyte [105], by
in the flounder, Liopsetta obscura [91, 92], receptor-mediated endocytosis [106, 107].
goldfish, Carassius auratus [93], several Vtg is then transferred into multivesicular
tilapia species [94], Fundulus heteroclitus bodies from the lysosomial compartment
[95], zebrafish Brachydanio rerio [96], and [108] where it is colocalised with a proteo-
also reviews by Wallace and Selman [97] lytic enzyme, cathepsin D [109], which is
and Guraya [98]. Moreover, a recent review probably responsible for its cleavage into
skimmed through the present state of yolk proteins.
knowledge about the mechanisms of oog-
enesis [99]. Therefore, only some original The duration of vitellogenesis is extremely
modalities compared to mammals will be variable depending on the species. It can be
developped below, concerning mainly vitel- a lengthy process, from several months up
logenesis, oocyte meiotic maturation and to one year in species that spawn once a year
ovulation. with an important mass of large eggs, like
salmonids. It lasts about 1–2 weeks in tila-
pias, tropical species that spawn several
3.2. Vitellogenesis hundreds medium sized eggs every 3–4
The storage in the oocyte of an important weeks in favourable external conditions
amount of yolk or vitellus, made of organic [47, 48]. The duration of vitellogenesis can
substances destined for embryo and larvae drop to about one day in medaka Oryzias
nutrition is an important original feature in latipes, spawning a few tens of small eggs
all lower vertebrates. It generally requires every day [110].
an important metabolic effort for the mater- Vitellogenesis regulation is overall under
nal organism. Ovary weight can in fact gonadotropic control by the pituitary. FSH
reach 20 to 25% of body weight at the end (or GtH I) is expected to play the main role,
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 269

as suggested by the endocrine and ovarian tions, encouraged by professor Thibault,


responses after unilateral ovariectomy [111], was developed thirty years ago [120–122],
or the coincidence between FSH plasma and was followed by numerous develop-
levels and ovarian vitellogenic stages in the ments in France and in the world. Morpho-
rainbow trout [112], even when vitellogen- logical features of maturation, more or les
esis is accelerated through an accelerated obvious depending on the species, are
photoperiodic regime [113]. The gonado- mainly the disparition (or “breakdown”) of
tropic control is relayed in part by the ovar- the germinal vesicle (GVBD), yolk clarifi-
ian production of estradiol [114], which is cation, and an increase of oocyte volume.
the main inductor of vitellogenin and ZrP GVBD, a phenomenon common to all ver-
synthesis in the liver. The respective roles tebrates, corresponds to the first meiotic
of FSH and LH (or GtH II) in estradiol ovar- division immediately followed by the prep-
ian synthesis have been controversial for a aration of the second division that will
long time, because both hormones are active remain blocked at metaphase II until ferti-
to stimulate estradiol synthesis by ovarian lisation. Yolk clarification and oocyte vol-
follicles in vitro. However, recent data ume increase are more particular to fish, but
demonstrate a specific role of FSH when with some species differences. These phe-
short incubation times are performed in nomenon are due to a deep reorganisation
vitro [115]. Such results would tend to con- of lipoproteic yolk [123–125] involving the
firm older data suggesting an increased effi- action of proteolytic enzymes such as cathe-
ciency of pulsatile gonadotropic action on psins [126]. In oocytes of marine fish that
ovarian estradiol production [116]. How- lay pelagic eggs, like the halibut Hippoglos-
ever, gonadotropic control by FSH also sus hippoglossus, this results in an impor-
appears to act more or less directly upon vtg tant rise of free amino acids and ions, lead-
incorporation in the oocyte. First, estradiol ing to an osmotic disequilibrium, thus
which stimulates vtg synthesis by the liver,
causing water entry and multiplying oocyte
cannot stimulate vtg incorporation in the
volume by a factor of 4 [127]. Water entry
oocyte alone, as shown for example by the
is less important in marine fish laying
long term in vivo effect of estradiol silastic
demersal eggs, like Fundulus heteroclitus,
implants in the brook trout [117]. On the
contrary, FSH appears to stimulate vtg incor- just doubling oocyte volume [128], and
poration into rainbow trout follicles in vitro does not go over 15% of oocyte volume in
[118]. However, other data in several other the rainbow trout (Jalabert et al. unpub-
species suggest in fact that cooperation lished).
between various hormonal and paracrine Ovulation is the release of a mature
factors are required to control vtg incorpo- oocyte from its follicle into the ovarian cav-
ration during vitellogenesis. ity (or the abdominal cavity in salmonids).
This process requires the separation of the
oocyte from the granulosa layer, the rupture
3.3. Oocyte maturation and ovulation
of follicle layers and the expulsion of the
The term “oocyte maturation” desig- oocyte. Since the first data suggesting an
nates a succession of complex cellular proc- implication of prostaglandin F2 as a possi-
esses corresponding to meiosis resumption ble local ovulation regulator in trout [89]
up to the second metaphase arrest in most and goldfish [129], a number of works
vertebrates [119]. In fish, morphological man- [130] suggest that ovulation in fish proba-
ifestations of this phenomenon are more often bly involves the cooperation of various
easy to observe and have already been ovarian factors such as proteases and pro-
described some time ago throughout their tease inhibitors, progestins, eicosanoids,
progress in vivo [74]. A methodology based catecholamines and vasoactive peptides,
on in vitro experimentation and observa- like in mammals [131].
270 B. Jalabert

Like in mammals, oocyte maturation and ciency to trigger oocyte maturation was
ovulation in fish are triggered by the action first demonstrated in vitro in rainbow trout
of pituitary gonadotropins on the surround- [134]. Then, it was identified in the incuba-
ing follicle. This is why intrafollicular oocyte tion medium of follicles from another sal-
maturation of rainbow trout follicles has monid, stimulated by a salmon gonadotro-
been used as a bioassay to prepare one of the pin [135]. In various marine species, such
first salmonid gonadotropins [132]. A typ- as the spotted sea-trout Cynoscion nebulo-
ical “ovulatory discharge” of gonadotropin sus, another progestin, 17,20β,21-trihydroxy-
has been observed in some fish species such 4pregnen-3one, has been identified as a
as the common carp Cyprinus carpio [133], MIS [136]. Moreover, two different MIS
but not in rainbow trout. Instead, in that spe- receptors have been identified in this spe-
cies, plasma levels of both gonadotropins cies, a membrane receptor [137], and a
FSH and LH show a progressive moderate nuclear receptor [138], exhibiting very dif-
rise, starting respectively about 6 and 4 days ferent binding affinities for various C21
(at 12 °C) before the beginning of matura- steroids [139]. The membrane receptor
tion [112]. Moreover, a second rise of plasma would be more particularly responsible for
gonadotropins, in a much larger range than the non genomic action of the MIS on
the first increase, was observed after ovu- oocyte maturation, whereas the nuclear recep-
lation, but depending on the evacuation or tor would be responsible for a genomic
retention of ovulated eggs: taking these action promoting ovulation [140]. The gene
immediately after ovulation promoted a of the membrane receptor, which was
large increase of FSH levels and a decrease recently cloned [141], seems to belong to a
of LH during two weeks after ovulation, family, so far unknown, of putative mem-
whereas the retention of eggs in the body brane receptor genes that is present in var-
cavity promoted a large increase of LH and ious vertebrates, including humans, Xeno-
only a weak increase of FSH during the pus, Fugu, and zebrafish [142]. Details
same time. These differences in both gona- about the follicular mechanisms triggered
dotropin postovulatory profiles may be by nuclear receptor activation are almost
suggested to be related either to postovula- unknown. On the contrary, many works
tory ovarian reorganisation, including gonial have been devoted in the world to mecha-
multiplications, and/or to the preservation nisms triggered in the oocytes of amphibi-
of the quality of ovulated eggs when these ans, mammals and fish, by the non-genomic
are retained a long time in the body cavity. activation of a putative membrane receptor.
In any case, it seems obvious that both These results will not be developed here
gonadotropins are actually involved in the since they have been extensively reviewed
endocrine regulation of follicular events and because they tend to emerge into a gen-
just preceding, accompanying and follow- eral model [143].
ing maturation and ovulation. Follicular and oocyte competence are
In contrast to mammals, but like in amphib- defined as the ability to respond correctly to
ians, the gonadotropic action which triggers a hormonal stimulation by producing good
oocyte maturation in fish is clearly relayed quality oocytes, i.e. able to develop nor-
by a steroid hormone, designated by the mally after fertilisation. Like in mammals,
term “maturation inducing hormone” or MIS, the acquisition of follicular and oocyte com-
synthesised by the follicular envelopes petence is a crucial problem, because fish
[119]. In salmonids and some other fresh- farming constraints often require artificially
water fish, the MIS is a progestin, 17,20β- controlling the end of the reproductive
dihydroxy-4pregnen-3one or DHP, which cycle, and imposing quality norms concern-
was first identified in the plasma of Pacific ing the results. Several factors have been
salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) during the involved in the control of competence acqui-
periovulatory period. Its predominant effi- sition, particularly the state of homologous
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 271

and heterologous gap-junctions, connex- only stimulating examples of possible gen-


ins, IGF and activins [99]. In rainbow trout eralisations. New knowledge has opened on
ovaries, the analysis of expression profiles applications not only in the field of fish
of various genes during the preovulatory farming but also in the field of environmen-
period allows to associate the evolution of tal evaluation. Taking into account the
some of them with competence acquisition importance of permanent exchanges with
[144–146]. Most correspond to factors which their aquatic environment, fish appear as
have already be suggested, in other teleost sensitive indicators of the quality of this
or in mammals, to be involved in compe- environment which is a receptacle of many
tence acquisition, in modulation of follicu- substances coming from human activities
lar or oocyte sensitivity to hormones, in [148]. Thus, the sensitivity of the hepatic
yolk processing, or in ovulation mecha- responses to estrogen-like pollutants, and
nisms. This is the case of IGF 1 and 2, FSH the relative simplicity of vtg and ZrP detec-
receptors, members of the activin and inhibin tion in vivo in the blood or in vitro in hepatic
family, cathepsins, and enzymes of the cell cultures [149], has incited a considera-
prostaglandin biosynthesis pathway. The ble number of works in the world to use
multiplicity of factors putatively involved these responses as biomarkers of exposition
is not surprising, since competence acqui- [150], or to evaluate estrogen-like potency
sition necessarily corresponds in fact to the of various substances [151]. But many other
progressive coordinate differentiation of important reproductive mechanisms can be
several ovarian compartments. Moreover, negatively affected by xenobiotics, like sim-
if the necessity of some physiological coor- ple morphological features such as the
dination between the acquisition of follicu- gonopodium of the mosquito fish [151], or
lar competence as a whole, and the emission more complex phenomenon such as in vitro
of appropriate stimulating signals from the
oocyte maturation [152].
neuroendocrine system seems obvious, insuf-
ficient attention has probably been paid so In the field of fish culture, only some
far to signals from the ovaries, and not only applications, which result from fish repro-
steroids. Finally, the analysis of gonado- ductive particularities compared to mam-
tropic signals from the pituitary should not mals, will be mentioned here. Thus, the exter-
be limited to the mean absolute level of FSH nal character of fertilisation has favoured
and LH, but should also take into account various kinds of manipulations on both
short-term profiles, thus renewing ancient gametes, such as sperm irradiation to inac-
works performed when available assays tivate the genome without altering its motil-
probably only gave a mean value between ity and its ability to activate the oocyte, and
both gonadotropins [147]. the application of thermic or hyperbare
shocks to the eggs in order to inhibit either
the second meiotic division (retention of the
4. APPLICATIONS first polar body), or the first embryo mito-
sis, depending on the chronology of these
Research carried out in the world during shocks during and after fertilisation events.
the last thirty years on reproductive mech- These manipulations theoretically allow
anisms in the teleost has certainly increased obtaining several kinds of chromosome
our knowledge concerning not only fish, stock modifications (Fig. 1) [153]. One of
but also vertebrates as a whole. The contri- the most interesting modifications for fish
bution to a general model of cellular mech- farming is triploidy which can give sterile
anisms of meiotic maturation [143], or the fish that are expected not to waste energy
possible discovery of a gene family of puta- for gonadal growth instead of body growth.
tive steroid membrane receptors present in In salmonids, the first positive results were
various vertebrates and humans [142] are obtained by using thermic shocks [154],
272 B. Jalabert

Figure 1. Theoretical possibilities of intervention on fertilisation in fish: destruction of paternal


genome (A); inhibition of 2nd meiotic division through retention of the second polar body (B);
blockage of first embryo mitosis (C). A selected combination among these possibilities allows
obtaining original genetic products (gynogenetic, androgenetic, triploid, tetraploid) (after Breton
et al. [154]).
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 273

then hyperbare shocks [155], that are now genetic, physiological, and environmental
widely used in industrial practice. influences. Aquaculture 2002, 208: 191–364.
Similarly, the external character of embry- [4] Yamamoto T. Sex differentiation. In: Hoar
WS, Randall DJ (Eds), Fish Physiology, Aca-
onic and larval development is highly favour- demic Press, New York, 1969, Vol 3, p 117–175.
able to the application of various chemical [5] Baroiller JF, Guigen Y, Fostier A. Endocrine
treatments. This is especially the case of all and environmental aspects of sex differentia-
treatments administrated either through tion in fish. Cell Mol Life Sci 1999, 55: 910–
balneation or via the food of young fry, in 931.
order to obtain phenotypic sex inversion in [6] Nakayama I, Foresti F, Tewari R, Schartl M,
the trout [72], tilapias [47], and presently Chourrout D. Sex chromosome polymor-
phism and heterogametic males revealed by
many other species. In the rainbow trout, two cloned DNA probes in the ZW/ZZ fish
androgen treatments are able to produce Leporinus elongatus. Chromosoma 1994,
XX neomales that are used as brooders to 103: 31–39.
inseminate eggs of normal XX females, [7] Chourrout D. Revue sur le déterminisme
thus giving monosex female populations génétique du sexe chez les poissons
téléostéens. Bull Soc Zool Fr 1988, 113: 123–
that have never been directly treated by ster- 144.
oids. Moreover, insemination may be com- [8] Clemens HP, Inslee T. The Production of Uni-
bined with thermic or hyperbare treatments, sexual Broods by Tilapia mossambica Sex-
to obtain, through second polar body reten- reversed with Methyl Testosterone. Trans
tion, triploid sterile monosex female popu- Amer Fish Soc 1968, 97: 18–21.
lations, that can be used to rear large fish in [9] Jalabert B, Moreau J, Planquette P, Billard R.
which growth will not be slowed down by Déterminisme du sexe chez Tilapia macro-
chir et Tilapia nilotica: action de la methyl-
reproduction [153]. Finally, in tilapias, testostérone dans l’alimentation des alevins
where male monosex populations are pre- sur la différenciation sexuelle ; obtention de
ferred for farming, these can be obtained by mâles inversés fonctionnels et proportion des
crossing normal females with “neo-super sexes dans la descendance. Ann Biol Anim
Biochim Biophys 1974, 14: 729–739.
males” of genotype YY. These, which are
[10] Chourrout D, Quillet E. Induced gynogenesis
viable and functional, are obtained by cross- in the rainbow trout: sex and survival of prog-
ing normal XY males with neo XY females enies of all-triploid populations. Theor Appl
resulting from estrogenic treatment of nor- Genet 1982, 63: 201–205.
mal fry [156]. [11] Jalabert B, Kammacher P, Lessent P. Déter-
The practical use in fish of artificial pho- minisme du sexe chez les hybrides entre Tila-
pia macrochir et Tilapia nilotica. Étude de la
toperiods to control the spawning season sex-ratio dans les recroisements des hybrides
[157], and of hormonal treatments to induce par les espèces parentes. Ann Biol Anim Bio-
maturation and ovulation [153] are men- chim Biophys 1971, 11: 155–165.
tioned here only as a matter of interest and [12] Harvey S, Masabanda J, Carrasco L, Bromage
will not be developed. N, Penman D, Griffin D. Molecular-cytoge-
netic analysis reveals sequence differences
between the sex chromosomes of Oreo-
chromis niloticus: evidence for an early stage
REFERENCES of sex-chromosome differentiation. Cytogenet
Genome Res 2002, 97: 76–80.
[1] Wooton RJ. Introduction: tactics and strate- [13] Harvey S, Boonphakdee C, Campos-Ramos
gies in fish reproduction. In: Poots GW, R, Ezaz M, Griffin D, Bromage N, Penman D.
Wootton RJ (Eds), Fish Reproduction: Strat- Analysis of repetitive DNA sequences in the
egies and tactics, Academic Press, London, sex chromosomes of Oreochromis niloticus.
1984, p 1–12. Cytogenet Genome Res 2003, 101: 314–319.
[2] Powers DA. Fish as Model Systems. Science [14] Ezaz M, Myers J, Powell S, McAndrew B,
1989, 246: 352–358. Penman D. Sex ratios in the progeny of andro-
genetic and gynogenetic YY male Nile tilapia,
[3] Devlin RH, Nagahama Y. Sex determination Oreochromis niloticus L. Aquaculture 2004,
and sex differentiation in fish: an overview of 232: 205–214.
274 B. Jalabert

[15] Woram R, Gharbi K, Sakamoto T, Hoyheim years of life. Ann Biol Anim Biochim Biophys
B, Holm L, Naish K, McGowan C, Ferguson 1978, 18: 877–882.
M, Phillips R, Stein J, Guyomard R, Cairney
M, Taggart J, Powell R, Davidson W, Danzmann [27] Fostier A, Kokokiris L, Menn F, Mourot B,
R. Comparative genome analysis of the pri- Pavlidis M, Divanach P, Kentouri M. Recent
mary sex-determining locus in salmonid advances in reproductional aspects of Pagrus
fishes. Genome Res 2003, 13: 272–280. pagrus. Cahiers Options Mediterraneennes
2000, 47: 181–192.
[16] Quillet E, Aubard G, Queau I. Mutation in a
sex-determining gene in rainbow trout: detec- [28] Debas L, Fostier A, Fuchs J, Weppe M,
tion and genetic analysis. J Hered 2002, 93: Nedelec G, Bennett A, Aquacop, Cauty C,
91–99. Jalabert B. The sexuality of cultured herm-
aproditic fish species: analysis of morpholog-
[17] Chevassus B, Devaux A, Chourrout D, Jalabert ical and endocrine features in a protogynous
B. Production of YY rainbow trout males by hermaphrodite, Epinephelus microdon, as a
self-fertilization of induced hermaphrodites. J basis to control reproduction in the groupe. In:
Hered 1988, 79: 89–92. IFREMER (Ed), Advances in tropical Aqua-
[18] Hostache G, Pascal M, Tessier C. Influence culture, Tahiti, French Polynesia, 1989,
of the incubation-temperature on the male- p 543–557.
female ratio of atipa Eggs, Hoplosternum lit- [29] Fischer EA. The relationship between mating
torale Hancock (1828). Can J Zool 1995, 73: system and simultaneous hermaphroditism in
1239–1246. the coral reef fish, Hypoplectrus nigricans
[19] Baroiller J, Chourrout D, Fostier A, Jalabert (Serranidae). Anim Behav 1980, 28: 620–633.
B. Temperature and sex chromosomes govern [30] Harrington RW. Oviparous hermaphroditic
sex ratios of the mouthbrooding cichlid fish fish with internal self-fertilization. Science
Oreochromis niloticus. J Exp Zool 1995, 273: 1961, 134 (3492): 1749–1750.
216–223.
[31] Harrington RW. Environmentally controlled
[20] Pavlidis M, Koumoundouros G, Sterioti A, induction of primary male gonochorists from
Somarakis S, Divanach P, Kentouri M. Evi- eggs of the self-fertilizing hermaphroditic
dence of temperature-dependent sex determi- fish, Rivulus marmoratus Poey. Biol Bull
nation in the European sea bass (Dicentra- 1967, 132: 174–199.
rchus labrax L.). J Exp Zool 2000, 287: 225–
232. [32] Weibel AC, Dowling TE, Turner BJ. Evi-
dence that an outcrossing population is a
[21] Saillant E, Fostier A, Haffray P, Menu B, Thi- derived lineage in a hermaphroditic fish (Riv-
monier J, Chatain B. Temperature effects and ulus marmoratus). Evolution 1999, 53: 1217–
genotype-temperature interactions on sex 1225.
determination in the European sea bass
(Dicentrarchus labrax L.). J Exp Zool 2002, [33] Mellinger J. Sexualité et Reproduction des
292: 494–505. Poissons. CNRS editions, Paris, 2002.
[22] Saillant E, Fostier A, Haffray P, Menu B, [34] Chevassus B. Modification du phénotype sex-
Chatain B. Saline preferendum for the Euro- uel et du mode de reproduction chez les pois-
pean sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax, larvae sons salmonidés : inversion sexuelle hormo-
and juveniles: effect of salinity on early devel- nale, gynogenèse, hybridation interspécifique
opment and sex determination. J Exp Mar Biol et polyploïdisation. Thèse doctorat Univ Paris
Ecol 2003, 287: 103–117. Sud, 1998.
[23] Donaldson E. Manipulation of reproduction in [35] Hubbs CL, Hubbs LC. Apparent parthenogen-
farmed fish. Anim Reprod Sci 1996, 42: 381– esis in nature, in a form of fish of hybrid origin.
392. Science 1932, 76: 628–630.
[24] Reinboth R. Intersexuality in fishes. Mem Soc [36] Kallman KD. Population genetics of the gyno-
Endocrinol 1970, 18: 515–543. genetic teleost, Mollienesia formosa (Girard).
Evolution 1962, 16: 497–504.
[25] Guiguen Y, Cauty C, Fostier A, Fuchs J,
Jalabert B. Reproductive cycle and sex inver- [37] Rasch EM, Monaco PJ, Balsano JS. Cytopho-
sion of the seabass, Lates calcarifer, reared in tometric and autoradiographic evidence for
sea cages in French Polynesia: histological functional apomixis in a gynogenetic fish,
and morphometric description. Environ Biol Poecilia formosa and its related, triploid uni-
Fish 1994, 39: 231–247. sexuals. Histochemistry 1982, 73: 515–533.
[26] Zohar Y, Abraham M, Gordin H. The gonadal [38] Schartl M, Wilde B, Schlupp I, Parzefall J.
cycle of the captivity-reared hermaphroditic Evolutionary origin of a parthenoform, the
teleost Sparus aurata (L.) during the first two Amazon molly, P. formosa, on the basis of a
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 275

molecular genealogy. Evolution 1995, 49: cycle of the mouthbrooding cichlid fish Ore-
827–835. ochromis niloticus. Gen Comp Endocrinol
[39] Yamashita M, Jiang J, Onozato H, Nakanishi 2000, 117: 54–65.
T, Nagahama Y. A Tripolar Spindle Formed [50] Fishelson L, Hilzerman F. Flexibility in repro-
at Meiosis I Assures the Retention of the Orig- ductive styles of male St. Peter’s tilapia,
inal Ploidy in the Gynogenetic Triploid Cru- Sarotherodon galilaeus (Cichlidae). Environ
cian Carp, Ginbuna Carassius Auratus Biol Fish 2002, 63: 173–182.
Langsdorfii. Dev Growth Differ 1993, 35:
631–636. [51] Rosen DE, Gordon M. Functional anatomy
and evolution of male genitalia in Poecilid
[40] Yamashita M, Onozato H, Nakanishi T, Fishes. Zoologica 1953, 38: 1–47.
Nagahama Y. Breakdown of the sperm
nuclear envelope is a prerequisite for male [52] Jalabert B, Billard R. Étude ultrastructurale du
pronucleus formation: direct evidence from site de conservation des spermatozoides dans
the gynogenetic crucian carp, Carassius aura- l’ovaire de Poecilia reticulata (Poisson
tus langsdorfii. Develop Biol 1990, 137: 155– téléostéen). Ann Biol Anim Biochim Biophys
160. 1969, 9: 273–280.
[41] Schultz RJ. Hybridization, unisexuality, and [53] Kobayashi H, Iwamatsu T. Fine structure of
polyploidy in the teleost Peciliopsis (Pecilii- the storage micropocket of spermatozoa in the
dae) and other vertebrates. Am Nat 1969, 103: ovary of the guppy Poecilia reticulata. Zool
605–619. Sci 2002, 19: 545–555.
[42] Xie J, Wen JJ, Chen B, Gui JF. Differential [54] Bromage N, Porter M, Randall C. The envi-
gene expression in fully-grown oocytes ronmental regulation of maturation in farmed
between gynogenetic and gonochoristic cru- finfish with special reference to the role of
cian carps. Gene 2001, 271: 109–116. photoperiod and melatonin. Aquaculture
2001, 197: 63–98.
[43] Marteinsdottir G, Gudmundsdottir A,
Thorsteinsson V, Stefansson G. Spatial vari- [55] Gillet C. Egg production in an Arctic charr
ation in abundance, size composition and via- (Salvelinus alpinus L.) brood stock: effects of
ble egg production of spawning cod (Gadus temperature on the timing of spawning and the
morhua L.) in Icelandic waters. Ices J Mar Sci quality of eggs. Aquat Living Resour 1991, 4:
2000, 57: 824–830. 109–116.
[44] Linhart O, Kudo S, Billard R, Slechta V, [56] Pankhurst N, Purser G, Kraak G, Thomas P,
Mikodina EV. Morphology, composition and Forteath G. Effect of holding temperature on
fertilization of carp eggs: a review. Aquacul- ovulation, egg fertility, plasma levels of repro-
ture 1995, 129: 75–93. ductive hormones and in vitro ovarian ster-
oidogenesis in the rainbow trout Oncorhyn-
[45] Legendre M, Linhart O, Billard R. Spawning chus mykiss. Aquaculture 1996, 146: 277–
and management of gametes, fertilized eggs 290.
and embryos in Siluroidei. Aquat Living
Resour 1996, 9: 59–80. [57] Morrison JK, Smith CE. Altering the spawn-
ing cycle of rainbow trout by manipulating
[46] Hostache G, Mol JH. Reproductive biology of water temperature. Prog Fish-Cult 1986, 52–
the neotropical armoured catfish Hoploster- 54.
num littorale (Siluriformes, Callichthyidae): a
synthesis stressing the role of the floating bub- [58] Gillet C, Billard R, Breton B. Effets de la tem-
ble nest. Aquat Living Resour 1998, 11: 173– pérature sur le niveau de gonadotropine plas-
185. matique et la spermatogenèse chez le poisson
rouge, Carassius auratus. Can J Zool 1977,
[47] Baroiller J-F, Jalabert B. Contribution of 55: 242–245.
research in reproductive physiology to the cul-
ture of tilapias. Aquat Living Resour 1989, 2: [59] Glasser F, Mikolajczyk T, Jalabert B, Baroiller
105–116. JF, Breton B. Temperature effects along the
reproductive axis during spawning induction
[48] Tacon P, Ndiaye P, Cauty C, Menn F, Jalabert of grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella). Gen
B. Relationships between the expression of Comp Endocrinol 2004, 136: 171–179.
maternal behaviour and ovarian development
in the mouthbrooding cichlid fish Oreo- [60] Dufour S. The Neuroendocrinology of Eel
chromis niloticus. Aquaculture 1996, 146: Reproduction – from Fundamental Research
261–275. to Applied Problems. Bull Fr Peche Piscic
1994, 187–211.
[49] Tacon P, Baroiller JF, Le Bail PY, Prunet P,
Jalabert B. Effect of egg deprivation on sex [61] Schugardt C, Kirschbaum F. Control of
steroids, gonadotropin, prolactin, and growth gonadal maturation and regression by experi-
hormone profiles during the reproductive mental variation of environmental factors in
276 B. Jalabert

the mormyrid fish, Mormyrus rume probosci- [74] Fulton TW. On the growth and maturation of
rostris. Environ Biol Fish 2004, 70: 227–233. the ovarian eggs ofteleostean fishes. In: 16th
Annual Report of the Fishery Board for Scot-
[62] Quinitio GF, Caberoy NB, Reyes DM. Induc- land, Part III, 1898, p 88–124.
tion of sex change in female Epinephelus
coioides by social control. Isr J Aquacult- [75] Tokarz RR. Oogonial proliferation, oogenesis
Bamidgeh 1997, 49: 77–83. and folliculogenesis in nonmammalian verte-
brates. In: Jones RE (Ed), The vertebrate
[63] Silvermann H. The effects of visual social ovary. Comparative Biology and evolution,
stimulation upon age at first spawning in the Plenum Press, New York, 1978, p 145–179.
mouth-brooding cichlid fish Sarotherodon
(Tilapia) mossambicus (Peters). Anim Behav [76] Billard R. The reproductive cycle of male and
1978, 26: 1120–1125. female brown trout (Salmo trutta fario): a
quantitative study. Reprod Nutr Dev 1987, 27:
[64] Silvermann H. Effects of different levels of 29–44.
sensory contact upon reproductive activity of
adult male and female Sarotherodon (tilapia) [77] Sriramulu V, Rajalakshmi M. Origin of a new
mossambicus. Anim Behav 1978, 26: 1081– crop of oocytes in Gobius giuris (Hamilton-
1090. Buchanan). Z Mikrosk Anat Forsch 1966, 75:
63–73.
[65] Amorim MCP, Fonseca PJ, Almada VC.
Sound production during courtship and [78] Dadzie S, Hyder M. Compensatory hypertro-
spawning of Oreochromis mossambicus: phy of the remaining ovary and the effect of
male-female and male-male interactions. J methallibure in the unilaterally ovariect-
Fish Biol 2003, 62: 658–672. omized Tilapia aurea. Gen Comp Endocrinol
1976, 29: 433–440.
[66] Kobayashi M, Sorensen PW, Stacey NE. Hor-
monal and pheromonal control of spawning [79] Chambolle P. Recherches sur les facteurs
behavior in the goldfish. Fish Physiol Bio- physiologiques de la reproduction chez les
chem 2002, 26: 71–84. poissons “ovovivipares”. Analyse expérimen-
tale sur Gambusia sp. Bull Biol 1973, 107: 29–
[67] Hurk R, Resink J. Male reproductive system 101.
as sex pheromone producer in teleost fish. J
Exp Zool 1992, 261: 204–213. [80] Flugel H. Licht- und elektronenmikroskopis-
che Untersuchungen an Oozyten und Eiern
[68] Le Bail PY. Growth-reproduction interaction einiger Knochenfische. Z Zellforsch Mikrosk
in salmonids. In: Zohar Y, Breton B (Eds), Anat 1967, 83: 82–116.
Reproduction in fish, basic and applied
aspects in endocrinology and genetics, INRA [81] Kessel RG, Tung HN, Roberts R, Beams HW.
éditions, Paris, Les colloques de l’INRA, The presence and distribution of gap junctions
N° 44, 1988, p 91–108. in the oocyte-follicle cell complex of the
zebrafish, Brachydanio rerio. J Submicrosc
[69] Saillant E, Fostier A, Menu B, Haffray P, Cytol 1985, 17: 239–253.
Chatain B. Sexual growth dimorphism in sea
bass Dicentrarchus labrax. Aquaculture 2001, [82] Toshimori K, Yasuzumi F. Gap Junctions
202: 371–387. between Microvilli of an Oocyte and Follicle
Cells in the Teleost (Plecoglossis altivelis). Z
[70] Toguyeni A, Fauconneau B, Fostier A, Abucay Mikrosk Anat Forsch 1979, 93: 458–464.
J, Mair G, Baroiller JF. Influence of sexual
phenotype and genotype, and sex ratio on [83] Iwamatsu T, Nakashima S, Onitake K, Matsuhisa
growth performances in tilapia, Oreochromis A, Nagahama Y. Regional Differences in
niloticus. Aquaculture 2002, 207: 249–261. Granulosa-Cells of Preovulatory Medaka Fol-
licles. Zool Sci 1994, 11: 77–82.
[71] Massou AM, Panfili J, Le Bail PY, Lae R,
Mikolasek O, Fontenelle G, Baroiller JF. Evi- [84] Riehl R, Götting KJ. Zur Struktur und
dence of perturbations induced by reproduc- Vorkommen de Mikropyle an Eizellen und
tion on somatic growth and microincrement Eiern von Knochenfischen (Teleostei). Arch
deposition in Orochromis niloticus otoliths. J Hydrobiol 1974, 74: 393–402.
Fish Biol 2004, 64: 380–398.
[85] Szöllösi D, Billard R. The micropyle of trout
[72] Chevassus B, Chourrout D, Jalabert B. Le eggs and its reaction to different incubation
contrôle de la reproduction chez les poissons. media. J Microsc 1974, 21: 55–62.
1. Les populations “monosexes”. Bull Fr Pis-
cic 1979, No. 274: 18–31. [86] Nagahama Y. The functional morphology of
teleost gonads. In: Hoar WS, Randall DJ
[73] Legac F, Blaise O, Fostier A, Lebail PY, Loir (Eds), Fish physiology, Vol IX, Reproduction
M, Mourot B, Weil C. Growth-Hormone (Gh) Part A, Endocrine tissues and hormones, Aca-
and Reproduction – A Review. Fish Physiol demic Press, New York, USA, 1983, p 223–
Biochem 1993, 11: 219–232. 275.
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 277

[87] Nagahama Y. Gonadotropin action on game- [101] Bohemen CG, Lambert JGD, Peute J. Annual
togenesis and steroidogenesis in teleost changes in plasma and liver in relation to
gonads. Zool Sci 1987, 4: 209–222. vitellogenesis in the female rainbow trout,
Salmo gairdneri. Gen Comp Endocrinol
[88] Senthilkumaran B, Yoshikuni M, Nagahama 1981, 44: 94–107.
Y. A shift in steroidogenesis occurring in
ovarian follicles prior to oocyte maturation. [102] Vaillant C, Le Guellec C, Pakdel F, Valotaire
Mol Cell Endocrinol 2004, 215: 11–18. Y. Vitellogenin gene expression in primary
culture of male rainbow trout hepatocytes.
[89] Jalabert B, Szöllösi D. In vitro ovulation of Gen Comp Endocrinol 1988, 70: 284–290.
trout oocytes: effect of prostaglandins on
smooth muscle-like cells of the theca. Pros- [103] Emmersen BK, Petersen IM. Natural occur-
taglandins 1975, 9: 765–778. rence, and experimental induction by estra-
diol-17-beta, of a lipophosphoprotein (vitel-
[90] Szöllösi D, Jalabert B, Breton B. Postovula- logenin) in flounder (Platichtys flesus, L.).
tory changes in the theca folliculi of the trout. Comp Biochem Physiol B 1976, 54: 443–
Ann Biol Anim Biochim Biophys 1978, 18: 446.
883–891.
[104] Hyllner SJ, Oppen-Berntsen DO, Helvik JV,
[91] Yamamoto KI. Annual cycle in the develop- Walther BT, Haux C. Oestradiol-17 beta
ment of ovarian eggs in the flounder, induces the major vitelline envelope proteins
Liopsetta obscura. J Fac Sci Hokkaido Univ, in both sexes in teleosts. J Endocrinol 1991,
Ser VI (Zool) 1956, 12: 362–373. 131: 229–236.
[92] Yamamoto K. II. Changes in the nucleus of [105] Campbell CM, Jalabert B. Selective protein
the oocyte of Liopsetta obscura, with special incorporation by vitellogenic Salmo gaird-
reference to the activity of the nucleolus. J neri oocytes in vitro. Ann Biol Anim Bio-
Fac Sci Hokkaido Univ, Ser VI (Zool) 1956, chim Biophys 1979, 19: 429–437.
12: 375–390.
[106] Nunez-Rodriguez J, Bon E, Menn FL. Vitel-
[93] Yamamoto K, Yamazaki F. Rhythm of devel- logenin receptors during vitellogenesis in the
opment in the oocyte of the gold-fish, Caras- rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss. J Exp
sius auratus. Bull Fac Fish Hokkaido Univ Zool 1996, 274: 163–170.
1961, 12: 93–110.
[94] Kraft AV, Peters HM. Vergleichende Stud- [107] Avail B, Pakdel F, Bujo H, Perazzolo LM,
ien über die Oogenese in der Gattung Tilapia Waclawek M, Schneider WJ, Menn Fl. Evo-
(Cichlidae, Teleostei). Z Zellforsch 1963, 61: lution of oogenesis: the receptor for vitello-
434–485. genin from the rainbow trout. J Lipid Res
1998, 39: 1929–1937.
[95] Selman K, Wallace R. Gametogenesis in
Fundulus heteroclitus. Am Zool 2005, 26: [108] Busson-Mabillot S. Endosomes transfer yolk
173–192. proteins to lysosomes in the vitellogenic
oocyte of the trout. Biol Cell 1984, 51: 53–66.
[96] Selman K, Wallace R, Sarka A, Qi X. Stages
of oocyte development in the zebrafish, [109] Sire MF, Babin PJ, Vernier JM. Involvement
Brachydanio rerio. J Morphol 1993, 218: of the Lysosomal System in Yolk Protein
203–224. Deposit and Degradation During Vitellogen-
esis and Embryonic-Development in Trout. J
[97] Wallace R, Selman K. Cellular and dynamic Exp Zool 1994, 269: 69–83.
aspects of oocyte growth in teleosts. Am Zool
1981, 21: 325–343. [110] Iwamatsu T, Ohta T, Oshima E, Sakai N.
Oogenesis in the medaka Oryzias latipes –
[98] Guraya SS. The Cell and Molecular Biology stages of oocyte development. Zool Sci 1988,
of Fish Oogenesis. Monographs in Develop- 5: 353–373.
mental Biology, Sauer HW (Ed), Karger,
Basel, München, Paris, London, New York, [111] Tyler CR, Pottinger TC, Coward K, Prat F,
New Delhi, Singapore, Tokyo, Sydney 1986, Beresford N, Maddix S. Salmonid follicle-
18: 1–223. stimulating hormone (GtH I) mediates vitel-
logenic development of oocytes in the rain-
[99] Patino R, Sullivan CV. Ovarian follicle bow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss. Biol
growth, maturation, and ovulation in teleost Reprod 1997, 57: 1238–1244.
fish. Fish Physiol Biochem 2002, 26: 57–70.
[112] Breton B, Govoroun M, Mikolajczyk T. GTH
[100] Frémont L, Riazi A. Biochemical analysis of I and GTH II secretion profiles during the
vitellogenin from rainbow trout (Salmo reproductive cycle in female rainbow trout:
gairdneri): Fatty acid composition of phos- relationship with pituitary responsiveness to
pholipids. Reprod Nutr Dev 1988, 28: 939– GnRH-A stimulation. Gen Comp Endocrinol
952. 1998, 111: 38–50.
278 B. Jalabert

[113] Bon E, Breton B, Govoroun M, Menn F. [123] Carnevali O, Mosconi G, Roncarati A,


Effects of accelerated photoperiod regimes Bervedere P, Romano M, Limatola E.
on the reproductive cycle of the female rain- Changes in the electrophoretic pattern of the
bow trout: II seasonal variations of plasma yolk proteins during vitellogenesis in the gilt-
gonadotropins (GTH I and GTH II) levels head sea bream Sparus aurata L. Comp Bio-
correlated with ovarian follicle growth and chem Physiol B 1992, 103: 955–962.
egg size. Fish Physiol Biochem 1999, 20:
143–154. [124] Iwamatsu T, Takahashi SY, Ohishi M, Yokochi
T, Maeda H. Changes in Electrophoretic Pat-
[114] Idler DR, Campbell CM. Gonadotropin stim- terns of Oocyte Proteins During Oocyte Mat-
ulation of estrogen and yolk precursor syn- uration in Oryzias latipes. Develop Growth
thesis in juvenile rainbow trout. Gen Comp Differ 1992, 34: 173–179.
Endocrinol 1980, 41: 384–391.
[125] Matsubara T, Sawano K. Proteolytic cleav-
[115] Montserrat N, Gonzalez A, Mendez E, Piferrer age of vitellogenin and yolk proteins during
F, Planas JV. Effects of follicle stimulating vitellogenin uptake and oocyte maturation in
hormone on estradiol-17 beta production and barfin flounder (Verasper moseri). J Exp
P-450 aromatase (CYP19) activity and Zool 1995, 272: 34–45.
mRNA expression in brown trout vitello-
[126] Carnevali O, Carletta R, Cambi A, Vita A,
genic ovarian follicles in vitro. Gen Comp
Bromage N. Yolk formation and degradation
Endocrinol 2004, 137: 123–131.
during oocyte maturation in seabream Sparus
[116] Zohar Y, Breton B, Fostier A. Gonadotropic aurata: Involvement of two lysosomal pro-
function during the reproductive cycle of the teinases. Biol Reprod 1999, 60: 140–146.
female rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri, in
[127] Finn RN, Ostby GC, Norberg B, Fyhn HJ. In
relation to ovarian steroid secretion: in vivo
vivo oocyte hydration in Atlantic halibut
and in vitro studies. In: Richter CJJ, Goos
(Hippoglossus hippoglossus); proteolytic
HJT (Eds), Reproductive Physiology of Fish,
liberation of free amino acids, and ion trans-
PUDOC, Wageningen, 1982, p 14–18.
port, are driving forces for osmotic water
[117] Lessman C, Habibi H. Estradiol-17 beta influx. J Exp Biol 2002, 205: 211–224.
Silastic implants suppress oocyte develop-
[128] Wallace RA, Selman K. Oogenesis in Fun-
ment in the brook trout, Salvelinus fontinalis.
dulus heteroclitus. I. Preliminary observa-
Gen Comp Endocrinol 1987, 67: 311–323.
tions on oocyte maturation in vivo and in
[118] Tyler CR, Sumpter JP, Kawauchi H, Swanson vitro. Dev Biol 1978, 62: 354–369.
P. Involvement of gonadotropin in the uptake
[129] Stacey NE, Pandey S. Effects of indometh-
of vitellogenin into vitellogenic oocytes of
acin and prostaglandins on ovulation of gold-
the rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss.
fish. Prostaglandins 1975, 9: 597–608.
Gen Comp Endocrinol 1991, 84: 291–299.
[130] Goetz FW, Garczynski M. The ovarian reg-
[119] Jalabert B, Fostier A, Breton B, Weil C.
ulation of ovulation in teleost fish. Fish Phys-
Oocyte maturation in vertebrates. In: Pang
iol Biochem 1997, 17: 33–38.
PKT, Schreibman MP (Eds), Vertebrate
endocrinology: fundamentals and biomedi- [131] Thibault C. Ovulation. Contracept Fertil Sex
cal implications, Vol 4, Part A, Academic 1999, 27: 605–613.
Press, 1991, p 23–90.
[132] Jalabert B, Breton B, Billard R. Dosage
[120] Jalabert B, Breton B, Bry C. Maturation et biologique des hormones gonadotropes de
ovulation in vitro des ovocytes de la truite poissons par le test de maturation in vitro des
arc-en-ciel Salmo gairdnerii. C R Acad Sci oocytes de truite. Ann Biol Anim Biochim
Hebd Seances Acad Sci D 1972, 275: 1139– Biophys 1974, 14: 217–228.
1142.
[133] Santos AJG, Furukawa K, Kobayashi M,
[121] Jalabert B. In vitro oocyte maturation and Bando K, Aida K, Hanyu I. Plasma Gonado-
ovulation in rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri), tropin and Steroid Hormone Profiles During
northern pike (Esox lucius), and goldfish Ovulation in the Carp Cyprinus carpio. Bull
(Carassius auratus). J Fish Res Board Can Jap Soc Sci Fish 1986, 52: 1159–1166.
1976, 33: 974–988.
[134] Fostier A, Jalabert B, Terqui M. Action pré-
[122] Jalabert B. Production of fertilizable oocytes dominante d’un dérivé hydroxylé de la
from follicles of rainbow trout (Salmo gaird- progesterone sur la maturation in vitro des
neri) following in vitro maturation and ovu- ovocytes de la truite arc-en-ciel (Salmo
lation. Ann Biol Anim Biochim Biophys gairdnerii)]. C R Acad Sci Hebd Seances
1978, 18: 461–470. Acad Sci D 1973, 277: 421–424.
Reproduction and oogenesis in the teleost 279

[135] Nagahama Y, Adachi S. Identification of [146] Bobe J, Nguyen T, Jalabert B. Targeted gene
maturation-inducing steroid in a teleost, the expression profiling in the rainbow trout
amago salmon (Oncorhynchus rhodurus). (Oncorhynchus mykiss) ovary during matu-
Dev Biol 1985, 109: 428–435. rational competence acquisition and oocyte
maturation. Biol Reprod 2004, 71: 73–82.
[136] Thomas P, Trant J. Evidence that 17 alpha,20
beta,21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one is a [147] Zohar Y, Breton B, Fostier A. Short-term
maturation-inducing steroid in spotted trout. profiles of plasma gonadotropin and 17
Fish Physiol Biochem 1989, 7: 185–192. alpha-hydroxy,20 beta-dihydroprogesterone
levels in the female rainbow trout at the peri-
[137] Patino R, Thomas P. Characterization of ovulatory period. Gen Comp Endocrinol
membrane receptor activity for 17[alpha],20 1986, 64: 189–198.
[beta],21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one in ova-
ries of spotted seatrout (Cynoscion nebulo- [148] Jalabert B, Baroiller JF, Breton B, Fostier A,
sus). Gen Comp Endocrinol 1990, 78: 204– Le Gac F, Guiguen Y, Monod G. Main neuro-
217. endocrine, endocrine and paracrine regula-
tions of fish reproduction, and vulnerability
[138] Pinter J, Thomas P. Characterization of A to xenobiotics. Ecotoxicology 2000, 9: 25–
Progestogen Receptor in the Ovary of the 40.
Spotted Sea-Trout, Cynoscion Nebulosus.
Biol Reprod 1995, 52: 667–675. [149] Celius T, Haugen TB, Grotmol T, Walther
BT. A sensitive zonagenetic assay for rapid
[139] Thomas P, Zhu Y, Pace M. Progestin mem- in vitro assessment of estrogenic potency of
brane receptors involved in the meiotic mat- xenobiotics and mycotoxins. Environ Health
uration of teleost oocytes: a review with some Perspect 1999, 107: 63–68.
new findings. Steroids 2002, 67: 511–517. [150] Denslow ND, Chow MC, Kroll KJ, Green L.
[140] Pinter J, Thomas P. Induction of ovulation of Vitellogenin as a biomarker of exposure for
mature oocytes by the maturation-inducing estrogen or estrogen mimics. Ecotoxicology
steroid 17,20beta,21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen- 1999, 8: 385–398.
3-one in the spotted seatrout. Gen Comp [151] Latonnelle K, Menn Fl, Bennetau-Pelissero
Endocrinol 1999, 115: 200–209. C. In vitro estrogenic effects of phytoestro-
[141] Zhu Y, Rice CD, Pang YF, Pace M, Thomas gens in rainbow trout and Siberian sturgeon.
P. Cloning, expression, and characterization Ecotoxicology 2000, 9: 115–125.
of a membrane progestin receptor and evi- [152] Monod G, Rime H, Bobe J, Jalabert B. Ago-
dence it is an intermediary in meiotic matu- nistic effect of imidazole and triazole fungi-
ration of fish oocytes. Proc Natl Acad Sci cides on in vitro oocyte maturation in rain-
USA 2003, 100: 2231–2236. bow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Mar
Environ Res 2004, 58: 143–146.
[142] Zhu Y, Bond J, Thomas P. Identification,
classification, and partial characterization of [153] Breton B, Quillet E, Jalabert B. The control
genes in humans and other vertebrates of reproduction and sex in fish in aquaculture.
homologous to a fish membrane progestin Prod Anim 1996, Hors série, 50 ans de
receptor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2003, 100: recherches en productions animales, p 17–
2237–2242. 26.
[143] Yamashita M. Toward modeling of a general [154] Chourrout D. Thermal induction of diploid
mechanism of MPF formation during oocyte gynogenesis and triploidy in the eggs of the
maturation in vertebrates. Zool Sci 2000, 17: rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri Richardson).
841–851. Reprod Nutr Dev 1980, 20: 727–733.
[144] Bobe J, Maugars G, Nguyen T, Rime H, [155] Chourrout D. Pressure-induced retention of
Jalabert B. Rainbow trout follicular matura- second polar body and suppression of first
tional competence acquisition is associated cleavage in rainbow trout: Production of all-
with an increased expression of follicle stim- triploids, all-tetraploids, and heterozygous
ulating hormone receptor and insulin-like and homozygous diploid gynogenetics.
growth factor 2 messenger RNAs. Mol Aquaculture 1984, 36: 111–126.
Reprod Dev 2003, 66: 46–53. [156] Beardmore J, Mair G, Lewis R, I. Monosex
[145] Bobe J, Maugars G, Nguyen T, Jalabert B. male production in finfish as exemplified by
Specific gene expression profiles are associ- tilapia: applications, problems, and pros-
ated with follicular maturational competence pects. Aquaculture 2001, 197: 283–301.
acquisition in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus [157] Maisse G, Breton B. Contrôle photopéri-
mykiss). Fish Physiol Biochem 2003, 28: odique de la saison de reproduction chez les
309–311. salmonidés. Prod Anim 1996, 9: 71–77.

You might also like