Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Resources .............................................................................................................................................................................................................19
Credits.................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
This report marks the third year of a rewarding partnership between the
AIA New York Chapter and the New York City Department of Health and
Mental Hygiene. The Fit City 3 conference in May 2008 featured not only
public health officials and architects, but Commissioners from five City
departments, urban planners, parks experts, bicycle advocates, real estate
developers, and many others.
The goal of this years conference was to take the lessons from previous Fit City
dialogues and explore how scientific research on obesity and physical activity,
and the design and planning principles that have been found to be effective
interventions for better health, can become urban policyboth for City
agencies, and in the standard practice of real estate developers and architects
working in the private sector.
To be informed about Fit City programs at the Center for Architecture through
our calendar and event mailing lists, and to see publications from previous
years, please visit www.aiany.org.
Sincerely,
INTRODUCTION
Collectively, New Yorkers gained 10 million pounds between 2002 and 2004.
In those two years alone, an additional 170,000 New Yorkers were identified as
obese. There were increases in obesity for almost all racial and ethnic groups.
Globally, as well, were seeing a big increase in obesity. We are exporting our
successful model of unhealthy living. And obesity starts early. Only half of our
young children are at a healthy weight.
From 2002 to 2004, an additional 70,000 New Yorkers were diagnosed with
diabetes. In 2004, there were at least 700,000 New Yorkers with diabetes. In the
past fifteen years, the number of people with diabetes has more than doubled,
leaving this population with a very high risk of heart attack, stroke, kidney
failure, blindness, and amputation. Anything that reduces our weight or
improves our fitness is going to have a lot of positive impact. Even if theres no
reduction in obesity, an increase in fitness reduces risk of cancer, heart disease,
and high blood pressure.
INTRODUCTION
I want to end by introducing our new stair prompt, which has been designed to
encourage people to take the stairs, not the elevators. Its soon to be seen in a
building near you, and you can get it for free by calling 311.
3
INTRODUCTION
GOALS:
To encourage active living for city
residents by shaping the public realm.
To better welcome pedestrians to the
built environment by minimizing sidewalk
congestion, creating access to a closedoff waterfront, and making green more
prevalent than pavement.
ILLUSTRATION
Alexandros Washburn, AIA, the Departments Chief Urban Designer, described the
zoning mechanisms that will build a fit city. Transit-oriented development zones
will place more housing near public transit, so that cars become less and less a part
of city life. Stairways will be re-prioritized with better amenity and visibility to
encourage their use. Street tree and side yard regulations, passed last winter as part
of PlaNYC 2030, will prevent the paving-over of green spaces and mandate tree
planting, creating welcoming places for people to walk in every neighborhood in
the five boroughs. And neighborhood rezonings, like Greenpoint/Williamsburg, and
new projects like Hunters Point South, are also designed to help the Fit City cause:
the goal is active and walkable streets, light and air for everyone by controlling the
bulk of the buildings that go up, and access to parks.
Stephanie Gelb, AIA, Chief Architect of the Battery Park City Authority, noted
that these sorts of characteristics are already part of our favorite New York
neighborhoods. At Battery Park City, for example, ample parkland, safe streets,
public facilities, and mixed uses all contribute to a community where people
feel comfortable being outside and active. This is just what you do when youre
building a successful neighborhood.
GOAL:
To make bicycling in New York City safer
and more common, and to promote as
often as possible the use of alternative
forms of transportation.
ILLUSTRATION
are also part of the Departments effort. As Jim Sallis pointed out, a study in
Portland, Oregon found that half of bicycle trips were taking place on bicycle lanes
and paths. Cyclists are seeking out the protected places, where they can feel safe,
Sallis observed.
Government agencies are not the only ones who have taken up this challenge.
Through a future zoning modification, as well as building owner and employer
initiatives, bicycle storage and racks will become more common in both public and
private buildings. With all of these steps, bicycling will continue to gain stature as a
convenient, safe, and healthy way to move around New York City.
GOAL:
To encourage children to develop habits
of active play and physical activity,
helping to prevent childhood obesity and
reverse current obesity trends.
ILLUSTRATION
This attention to type of activity is crucial to creating spaces that are actively used.
Sallis observed that having recreation facilities nearby is a very important policy,
but we must also design them to maximize physical activity. Facilities like
volleyball, basketball and tennis courts encourage high levels of energy (and
calories) to be expended. In one study, Nilda Cosco found that young children
respond with more active play to compact playground areas with a mix of
natural and manufactured elements. She found that the most active landscape was
a wide, curvy wheeled toy pathway for kids to play on. Design is really crucial to
the success of a park in promoting fitness and health.
In the practice of Robyne Kassen, Assoc. AIA, playful and active uses are
incorporated into everyday structures such as benches and bicycle racks, giving
children and adults alike the experience of an urban playscape. We believe that
movement and workouts are not isolated experiences to be partitioned off from our
lives to the gym, she explained. Instead, we view our daily lives and paths as
opportunities to explode movement throughout our day, and we design for this
movement. The Whistler Olympic Village will feature the work of Kassen and her
Pedestrian Studio, in collaboration with their partner firm, Movement Engineering.
GOAL:
To provide people of lower income as
much access to parks, fitness facilities,
and healthy food as have those who
live in higher-income neighborhoods;
to address disparities in obesity and
health among different socioeconomic
groups.
10
ILLUSTRATION
11
community. Most of our retail is locally owned. We will not lease to fast food
restaurants, and we will not lease to liquor stores, he said. Active spaces are also a
priority. The Kalahari project has a green roof, to provide open space and an
opportunity for residents to really get to know each other, as well as a free fitness
center for building occupants.
Related Companies, a leading development firm with over $15 billion worth of real
estate assets nationwide, also pursues projects in densely populated urban areas
near public transportation hubs. By increasing both the density and the diversity of
housing types near transit and encouraging fitness activities, we can help to increase
daily mobility among city residents of all incomes, said Executive Vice President of
Design and Planning Vishaan Chakrabarti, AIA. We apply these principles as much
as we can to both our affordable housing developments, as well as to our market
rate developments.
GOAL:
To foster private market demand
for healthy living, and to encourage
developers to include health as a factor
in design excellence.
12
ILLUSTRATION
13
Copenhagen.
Photo by Gehl Architects
14
ILLUSTRATION
15
But in the past century, weve seen what I call the car invasion. In Europe it started
about ten years after the Second World War, when cars really started to pour into
the communities. And soon they filled up every nook and cranny in our cities. Whatever was given to them, they took. And the first thing that happened was that all the
people who got a car rushed down to the main streets of the cities to show the
other people that theyd gotten a car.
This was fifty years ago, and it is my opinion that at that point we started to panic.
We started to think that the major purpose of cities was to find more capacity for
more cars. And everything has been devoted to accommodating the cars ever since.
Many of the decisions which have been made for cities actually came from this
single purpose to have more capacity for more cars.
So we have the invaded cities from the mid 1950s, when the kids started to have
to run faster and faster to get across the streets, but that was only healthy for them
if they happened to get across. And there was gradually a deterioration of the
quality of cities. We got used to bad air, to too much noise, to less space, to crowded
sidewalks, and we started to define this as a good life. And gradually over the years,
more and more undignified things happened to people walking about in cities.
We had to maneuver, we had to do all kinds of slaloming between the mufflers and
the bumpers, and we forgot about why we had the cities. We were just lucky to get
through without getting killed.
Copenhagen.
Photo by Gehl Architects
16
ILLUSTRATION
This deterioration happened over the last fifty years of cheap petroleum. And we
had, after a period of time, the next phase of city planning, when people gave up.
Then we had the abandoned cities. Especially in the United States, and you can see
them also in various Australian and Canadian locations but in these places the
environment for moving about, for walking was so bad that people completely gave
up, they went home and stayed there, and did everything from their car.
Weve seen the result of all this combined with lifestyle changes and changes in
economy: obesity. Weve seen it, weve heard about it, and there have appeared
gimmicks about how to get people into exercise, whether they want to or not.
But weve also seen lately the re-conquered cities. Those are the cities where
somebody has put down his or her foot and said, Hey, why did we come together
in cities? So that we could find as much space for driving and parking as possible?
Or were there other reasons for coming together? And of course, these cities have
started to demand a better balance between meeting, market and motoring.
They have found a better balance between vehicular traffic and other needs of
the city.
We have also started to study very carefully the importance of public life and what
it means to a society and to a democratic nation. In public spaces, we can meet our
fellow citizens, and we can see what society were a part of. Regardless of what we
see on television about this group or that group, when we go into the streets we see
that most of the other guys are absolutely all right and great guys. We need this
feeling of community in an open city and in a democratic society.
17
These cities have been striving to be lively, attractive, safe, sustainable and
healthy cities. And most of them have done it by celebrating the pedestrians
and celebrating bicycling. In Copenhagen weve decided to look at bicycling as a
type of street life. Its just a little bit faster than walking. Its the same speed as
running. And a street full of bicycles is not empty of life. A street full of cars is
full of metal but a street full of bicycles is full of people who are just moving
slightly faster.
My suggestion for a simple healthy city policy is to say: in this city we will do
everything we can to invite people to walk and bicycle as much as possible in the
course of their daily doings. That is by far the simplest thing to do, and the most
efficient. You dont have to set a certain time to go to the fitness center or go to the
park you just walk and bike in the course of your day. The word invite is crucial,
because biking or walking shouldnt be something that you will survive or is
simply possible. You really must show that people are invited. People are welcome.
Were waiting for people to do it.
Ill talk a little bit about why we walk. I take a much wider view on walking. To me,
walking is certainly not only a means of transportation, or about getting from A to
B. There is much more to walking than walking. Theres much more attached to you
being on your feet among your fellow citizens. I would say that any city could have
many people on the sidewalks. New York is an example. But thats not the mark of
a good city. A good city you can always recognize from the fact that many people
have stopped walking and started to enjoy, because the places they come by are so
attractive that they cannot resist stopping, and sitting, and enjoying, and listening,
and talking. And then they can go on walking. So whenever you see a city where
many people are walking and then not walking, stopping to enjoy, thats a city of
very good quality. But of course, we should also be able to get from A to B.
You can walk and talk, you can walk and watch, and you can be watched. Watching
people is the number one attraction in any city, and it has always been. There
is nothing more interesting in our life than other people. By being sweet to
pedestrians in the city, and being sweet to people walking, you open up for them
doing all the sweet things which are associated with living. So be on your feet
in the city as much as possible thats good for the livability of cities, the
attractiveness of cities, and by the way, for your health.
What is good about bicycling? Some cities would say, we cant bicycle here
because its too cold, or its too hot, or its too hilly. Well, in Trondheim, Norway,
they have escalators for bicyclists to get up the mountains. Bicyclists can also put
more clothes on. Bicycling we consider part of city life. Bicyclists move slowly
enough so you can see they are people, they can talk and they can look at each
other, and they can easily become pedestrians by just jumping off. So they are close
to pedestrians.
18
And, by the way, one automobile parking spot will provide you with 10 bicycle
parking spots. Earlier on I heard someone say there was not enough bicycle parking
here in New York why dont you take 100 car parking spaces and turn them into
1,000 bicycle parking spaces? In New York you have a lot of space in your streets.
You have just used it impractically for a period of time. On a bicycle lane you can
have four times as many people as you can have in a car lane. Bicycling is very
energy-efficient. It supports a very good environment, since bicycles produce
no noise. Its also very cheap, by the way, to bicycle compared to other modes of
transportation. From the case study of Denmark we know that bicyclists live longer.
Actually, if you do 30 minutes on a bike everyday, you gain seven extra years on
your life.
So its a good idea to bike, its a good idea to walk, and its a good idea to take
the stairs. But its not enough that we simply take the stairs. We must also go out
and make healthy cities again. We must be friendly to bicycles and friendly to
pedestrians, in order to make a people oriented city.
Pedestrian Studio
http://www.pedestrianstudio.com/
Department of Transportation
http://www.nyc.gov/dot
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) StairWELL to Better Health
http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpa/hwi/toolkits/stairwell/index.htm
19
RESOURCES
Amanda Burden, Hon. AIA NY, Commissioner, NYC Department of City Planning
David Burney, FAIA, Commissioner, NYC Department of Design and Construction
Acknowledgements:
Vishaan Chakrabarti, AIA, Executive Vice President, Related Companies
New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene
Thomas R. Frieden, MD, MPH, Commissioner
20
CREDITS
PRE SORTED
STANDARD
US POSTAGE PAID
BALTO. MD
PERMIT 3361
IF FC3 IS TO BE MAILED