Professional Documents
Culture Documents
On December 5, 1995, SPO3 Manlangit arrested Jun and the latter led them
to his associate, Neneth. They took "Neneth and "Jun," together with the
box, its contents and the marked bills and turned them over to the
investigator at headquarters. It was only then that the police learned that
"Jun" is Florencio Doria while "Neneth" is Violeta Gaddao. The one brick of
dried marijuana leaves recovered from "Jun" plus the ten bricks recovered
from "Neneth's" house were examined at the PNP Crime Laboratory and were
found to be dried marijuana fruiting tops.
Issue: WoN the warrantless arrest was valid. (Valid, as regards Dorias arrest.)
Decision: Florencio Doria was convicted and Violeta Gaddao was aquitted.
RD:
The warrantless arrest of Doria is lawful since he was caught in the act of
committing an offense. A person may be arrested without a warrant if he "has
committed, is actually committing, or is attempting to commit an offense."
The warrantless search and arrest of Gaddao is unlawful. Search and seizure may be
made without a warrant and the evidence obtained therefrom may be admissible in
the following instances: (1) search incident to a lawful arrest; (2) search of a moving
motor vehicle; (3) search in violation of customs laws; (4) seizure of evidence in
plain view; (5) when the accused himself waives his right against unreasonable
searches and seizures.
Gaddao was not caught red-handed during the buy-bust operation to give ground
for her arrest under Section 5 (a) of Rule 113. She was not committing any crime; in
fact, she was going about her daily chores when the policemen pounced on her.
Neither could her arrest be justified under "Personal knowledge" of facts because it
must be based upon "probable cause" which means an "actual belief or reasonable
grounds of suspicion." The grounds of suspicion are reasonable when, in the
absence of actual belief of the arresting officers, the suspicion that the person to be
arrested is probably guilty of committing the offense, is based on actual facts, i.e.,