VOASites by Language

Log in Sign up
HOMEUSAAFRICAASIAMIDEASTEUROPESCIENCE & TECHHEALTHENTERTAINMENTECONOMYPROGRAMS
Listen
News / Economy

Bulgaria Key Battleground in US-Russia Energy War

Print
Comment (1)
Share:
FILE - Protesters shout slogans and carry a banner that reads "Ban shale gas tests through hydraulic
fracturing" during a rally in central Sofia, January 14, 2012.
FILE - Protesters shout slogans and carry a banner that reads "Ban shale gas tests through hydraulic
fracturing" during a rally in central Sofia, January 14, 2012.

Pin It
RELATED ARTICLES

US 'Deeply Committed' to Bulgarian Security, Democracy Kerry Says

Russia's Relations With Hungary Warm as Ties With West Chill
Croatia Revives Gas Terminal Project
Moscow Condemns Arrest of Alleged Russian Spy in NYC
Mark Snowiss
Last updated on: February 23, 2015 3:04 PM

WASHINGTON
As the U.S. wages a high-profile campaign against Russia over Ukraine, it is also battling Kremlindominance on another front - energy in Eastern Europe.

NATO member Bulgaria, which relies on Russia for 85 percent of its natural gas and all its nuclear fuel, is
on the frontline of this confrontation.

For Russia, energy has always been a means for the Kremlin to extend its geo-political priorities and the
financial interests of certain people involved, said former Bulgarian energy minister Traicho Traikov.

Economic benefits come last. Enough people in Bulgaria owe favors to Russia so [this policy] is
successful, he said.

The U.S. recently pledged to send an energy envoy to Sofia and is promoting an American company to
build a nuclear power plant there. Washington is also looking to help fund new gas pipelines and
terminals in the region.

In the area of energy security, we're not just talking the talk, now we're walking the walk," U.S.
Assistant Secretary of State of European Affairs Victoria Nuland said in January of U.S. intentions.

Her boss, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, visited Bulgaria for economic discussions earlier this year.

A lot of time" was spent discussing energy security, Kerry said, adding that Bulgaria needs to find new
sources.

The U.S. moves come amid renewed charges that Russia through its state-controlled energy company,
Gazprom has successfully blocked shale gas exploration in Bulgaria through a shadowy but well-funded
campaign waged to protect its regional energy dominance.

Graphic: Gas supplied by Russia CLICK TO ENLARGE

Graphic: Gas supplied by Russia CLICK TO ENLARGE
Along with the massive drop in energy prices, hydraulic fracturing constitutes the greatest threat to
Russian financial and political influence in Europe and to future Russian tax receipts, said Keith Smith, a
former U.S. ambassador to Lithuania with additional posts throughout Europe.

He and other former U.S. and European officials and energy experts who spoke with VOA outlined an
effort by which Russian officials, working with foreign consultancies in Brussels, have financially
supported anti-fracking activities in several European countries.

Bulgarias shale U-turn

Despite paying some of the highest prices in the world for energy, Bulgaria in 2012 issued an openended ban on hydraulic fracturing, cancelling a license for unconventional gas exploration granted less
than six months earlier to the U.S. energy giant Chevron.

When anti-fracking protests quickly spread to other East European countries with little prior interest in
ecological issues, a number of high-ranking officials and energy experts pointed to Russia.

Moscows position as the principal supplier of expensive European natural gas imports means huge
profits for the Kremlin, which raises about 60 percent of its federal revenue from energy exports.

Along with Bulgaria, Hungary, Finland and the Baltics also receive nearly all their gas from Russia;
Germany, the worlds fourth largest economy, depends on it for almost 40 percent of its supply.

Their influence is continuing. Russia will do anything to disrupt production, especially in Central and
Eastern Europe, Smith said.

Russia and Gazprom have denied the accusations, as have Bulgarian environmental groups.

This is very bad propaganda. Nothings been proven, no ones been named as a paid agent of the
Russians, said Borislav Sandov, co-founder of the Bulgarian Green Party and spokesman for Fracking
Free Bulgaria, a leading environmental group.

Much of Europes anti-fracking movement, as in the United States, stems from real environmental
concerns.

Activists point to evidence linking fracking to groundwater contamination as having galvanized popular
opinion and governments against the controversial drilling technique by which water, sand and
chemicals are pumped underground to retrieve oil or natural gas.

Graphic: 2013 Unproved Wet Shale Gas Technically Recoverable Resources CLICK TO ENLARGE
Graphic: 2013 Unproved Wet Shale Gas Technically Recoverable Resources CLICK TO ENLARGE
But when it comes to Eastern Europe, the allegations against Russia and its ties to environmentalists are
public and widespread.

[The Russian campaign] is no secret. The U.S. knows through diplomatic channels, but previously didnt
have the resources or urgency to act. Ukraine changed the game. The West doesnt want to be friends
with [Russian President Vladimir] Putin anymore, Traikov said.

Before stepping down last year, former NATO Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen openly
accused Moscow of aiding Europes anti-fracking movement.

Russia, as part of their sophisticated information and disinformation operations, engaged actively with
so-called non-governmental organizations environmental organizations working against shale gas to
maintain European dependence on imported Russian gas, Rasmussen said.

Evidence for the alleged Russian campaign is based mainly on financial links and anecdotal accounts.

The money trail is very difficult to trace, said Margarita Assenova, an analyst at the Washington D.C.based Jamestown Foundation.

[But] at least two Brussels-based consultancies allegedly transferred funds to several Bulgarian
environmental groups through local corporate structures connected with Russia, she said.

The assets initially went through Overgas, Gazproms Bulgarian subsidiary, and the lobby supporting
Russian nuclear energy projects. Both have been used in the past to promote Gazproms interests.

Overgas dominates the Bulgarian market for licensing and drilling, said Ilian Vassilev, managing partner
of the Sofia-based consultancy Innovative Energy Solutions and a former Bulgarian ambassador to
Moscow.

They can make life for [multinational oil] companies very difficult challenging them in court, sitting on
exploration blocks for years doing nothing, he said.

Chevron vs Gazprom

When Chevron moved into Bulgaria in 2010, it became the single largest investor of the shale era.

They introduced a completely new business culture, put down 30 million [$38 million] up-front. It was
an unheard of amount of money and triggered a chain reaction when the Russians realized Chevron
meant business, Vassilev said.

He described a process by which groups that normally have nothing to do with one another saturated
the public with misleading information about shale gas, creating a climate of mistrust and fear.

Graphic: U.S. Energy Information Administration map of basins with assessed shale oil and shale gas
formations CLICK TO ENLARGE
Graphic: U.S. Energy Information Administration map of basins with assessed shale oil and shale gas
formations CLICK TO ENLARGE
It was a sophisticated effort, indirectly funded, mainly involving nationalists and leftists, including the
Socialists Russophile wing, Vassilev said. The funds were directed to local NGOs, Orthodox Churchrelated organizations, media and sports clubs.

The tide peaked on January 14, 2012 with rallies in at least six major cities, three European capitals and
a 60,000-strong Facebook group backed by a sophisticated media campaign and pledges of support from
local officials.

Bulgarias shale gas hysteria was a manufactured public relations campaign, although it did reflect
genuine environmental concerns, Traikov said.

When Chevron paid the 30 million signing bonus, the pro-Russian media immediately started
trumpeting kickbacks. Thats how reality was perverted, he said.

A Sofia-based source contacted by VOA pointed to businesspeople serving as intermediaries for Russian
corporate interests as key components to the moratoriums success.

But detractors say incompetence, rather than a Kremlin-led conspiracy, is the key reason
unconventional gas failed in Bulgaria and why the country remains so dependent on Russian energy.

The entire energy sector is a mess. Its heavily politicized, with huge turnover in personnel and not
conducive to business, said Andreas Goldthau, an energy expert at Harvards Belfer Center whose
teams interviewed protest groups, activists and government officials in the Balkan country.

Yet those who see Russian fingerprints on Bulgarias energy maneuvers remain resolute.

Sofia is a small city that cant keep secrets for long when it impacts something as big as this, Vassilev
said.

Mark Snowiss
Mark Snowiss is a Washington D.C.-based multimedia reporter. He has written and edited for various
media outlets including Pacifica and NPR affiliates in Los Angeles. Follow him on Twitter @msnowiss and
on Google Plus.
Print
Comment (1)
Share:

Pin It
YOU MAY LIKE

VOA Exclusive: Video Interview With Freed Swedish Journalist in Syria

Less than 24 hours after his release late Saturday, Joakim Medin tells VOA how he was arrested and
detained in northern Syrian Kurdish town of Qamishli More
A general view of the damage caused by a bomb blast is seen at the gate of the Iranian ambassador's
residence in Tripoli, Libya, Feb. 22, 2015.
Islamic State Having Significant but Limited Impact in Libya
US officials caution that Islamic State's foothold in Libya remains tenuous More
A view shows a burnt compound after an attack by Boko Haram militants in the village of Ngouboua,
Feb. 13, 2015. Boko Haram fighters attacked the village in Chad on Friday.
Boko Haram Resorts to Guerilla Tactics as Pressure Mounts
Sect has been staging attacks outside its usual areas of strength as military gains force a strategic shift
More
Comment Sorting
Comment on this forum (1)
Comments
by: Yan McGregor from: Bulgaria
February 24, 2015 8:09 AM
ReportReply
We don't want your help!!!!! Get out of our country !!!

FEATURED VIDEOS

Pakistan Literary Festival Defies Violence

Pakistan Literary Festival Defies Violence New Fighting Sends Surge of Refugees to Sudan's Border
Region Birdman Tops Academy Awards With IS Forced Out, Village Life Returns for Some in Syria
Oscar Nominee 'Leviathan' Stirs Controversy in Russia With Yemen Near Civil War, UN Envoy Hails Talks
Breakthrough Picket Fence of Super Towers Rises in New York Stocks Soar As Greece Reaches
Emergency Loan Deal With Eurozone Germany Returns Antique Books Stolen in Italy Obama Calls
Chicago's Pullman District a 'Milestone' in US Journey In Philippines, a Debate Over Links Between Guns
and Violent Crime Fighters Not the Only Foreigners Seeking IS
VOA SPECIAL REPORT

ALL ABOUT AMERICA

All About America-Asian American Politicians

All About America Promo-Alaska
All About America-Religion

DAY IN PHOTOS

CIRCUMVENTING CENSORSHIP

Teaser image for circumvention site

An Internet Primer for Healthy Web Habits
As surveillance and censoring technologies advance, so, too, do new tools for your computer or mobile
device that help protect your privacy and break through Internet censorship.
More
MORE ECONOMIC NEWS

Greece's Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras chats with Greece's Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis
during a Presidential vote in Athens, on Wednesday, Feb. 18, 2015.
Greece Submits Reform Plan to Lenders
FILE - International Monetary Fund (IMF) Managing Director Christine LaGarde makes a statement about
sanctions leveled against Russia, during a news conference in Washington, April 30, 2014.
IMF's Lagarde Calls for End to 'Conspiracy' Against Women

Scrap-Metal Separation May Become Cheaper

FILE - Protesters shout slogans and carry a banner that reads "Ban shale gas tests through
hydraulic fracturing" during a rally in central Sofia, January 14, 2012.
Bulgaria Key Battleground in US-Russia Energy War
FILE - Zimbabwe's Finance Minister Patrick Chinamasa and Agriculture Minister Joseph Made
(right). (Photo/Irwin Chifera)
Zimbabwe Asks African Bank for Debt Relief

Israeli Utility Begins West Bank Power Cuts

FILE - A Greek flag flies behind a statue to European unity outside the European Parliament in Brussels.
Greece Slides Past Deadline for Reform Proposals
FILE - Two trucks move shipping containers at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach, California, Feb. 17,
2015.
US West Coast Ports Begin Working on Cargo Backlog
A busker plays music in front of a graffiti that refer to Greece's Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras in the
traditional Plaka district of Athens, Feb. 21, 2015.
Greece Faces Monday Deadline On Reform Proposals
FILE - President Barack Obama speaks in Washington at the White House Summit on Countering Violent
Extremism, Feb. 18, 2015.
Obama: New Free-Trade Deals Will Create More Jobs
More Articles
WORLD CURRENCIES

EUR

USD

0.8851

JPY

USD

119.04

GBP

USD

0.6507

CAD

USD

1.2618

INR

USD

62.315

Rates may not be current.

Most Viewed
'Birdman' Takes Most Oscars

Foreign Fighter: American Joins Battle Against Islamic State

US Homeland Security Chief Calls for Vigilance Following New Video
UK: More Costs for Russia Possible Over Ukraine
Boko Haram Resorts to Guerilla Tactics as Pressure Mounts
Most Emailed
Foreign Fighter: American Joins Battle Against Islamic State
US West Coast Ports Begin Working on Cargo Backlog
11 Ways to Keep Yourself Safe Online
Australia to Challenge Radical Islam Online
US Names First Envoy for Gay Rights
Most Discussed
Report to Allege Direct Kremlin Link to Ukraine Invasion (30)
Foreign Fighter: American Joins Battle Against Islamic State (15)
'Birdman' Takes Most Oscars (8)
Malcolm X Remembered, 50 Years After His Death (7)
Turkey's Evacuation of Tomb Guards In Syria Draws Rebuke (7)
SERVICES:PodcastRSSMail SubscriptionMobile

VOANews.com
USA
Africa
Asia
Mideast
Europe
Americas
Science & Technology
Health
Arts & Entertainment
Business & Economy

Blogs
Video
Editorials
About VOA
Media Relations
Contact Us
Job Opportunities
Terms of Use/Privacy Policy
Our Languages
Usage Requests
Our Partners
RFE/RL
Radio Free Asia
MBN
Radio Marti
Our Broadcasts
Frequencies and Schedules
Pronunciation Guide
Broadcast Programs