Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Empowermentandparticipation
Objectives;
Todevelopanunderstandingof:
Empowerment
Processofempowerment
RandolphsEmpowermentmodel
Strategicperformanceempowermentmodel
Participation
FeaturesofWorkersparticipationinmanagement:
BenefitsofParticipation
Prerequisitesofparticipation
Expectationsfromemployeesandmanagers
Programsforparticipation
Guidelinesforparticipation
WhatIsEmpowerment?
TakenfromORGANIZATIONALBEHAVIOURHumanBehavioratwork(TENTHEDITION)byJOHNW.NEWSTROM
andKEITHDAVIS,TataMcGrawHillPublishingCompanyLimited,NEWDELHI
Mostworkorganizationshaveanumberofemployeeswhobelievethattheyaredependentonothers
andthattheirowneffortswillhavelittleimpactonperformance.
Thispowerlessnesscontributestothefrustratingexperienceoflowselfefficacytheconvictionamong
peoplethattheycannotsuccessfullyperformtheirjobsormakemeaningfulcontributions.Problems
withselfefficacyareoftencausedbymajororganizationalchangesthatarebeyondtheemployees
control(suchasmergers).
Problemsmayalsostemfromhavingtoworkunderanauthoritarianleader,withinarewardsystem
thatfailstoreinforcecompetenceorinnovation,orinajobthatlacksvariety,discretion,roleclarity.
Fortunately,individualperceptionsoflowlevelsofselfefficacycanberaisedbyempowering
employees.Empowermentisanyprocessthatprovidesgreaterautonomytoemployeesthroughthe
sharingofrelevantinformationandtheprovisionofcontroloverfactorsaffectingjobperformance.
Empowermenthelpsremovetheconditionsthatcausepowerlessnesswhileenhancingemployee
feelingsofselfefficacy.Empowermentauthorizesemployeestocopewithsituationsandenablesthem
totakecontrolofproblemsastheyarise.Fivebroadapproachestoempowermenthavebeen
suggested:
1. Helpingemployeesachievejobmastery(givingpropertraining,coaching,andguided
experiencethatwillresultininitialsuccesses)
2. Allowingmorecontrol(givingthemdiscretionoverjobperformanceandthenholdingthem
accountableforoutcomes)
3. Providingsuccessfulrolemodels(allowingthemtoobservepeerswhoalreadyperform
successfullyonthejob.)
4. Usingsocialreinforcementandpersuasion(givingpraise,encouragement,andverbalfeedback
designedtoraiseselfconfidence)
5. Givingemotionalsupport(providingreductionofstressandanxietythroughbetterrole
definition,taskassistance,andhonestcaring)
Whenmanagersusetheseapproaches,employeesbeginbelievingthattheyarecompetentand
valued,thattheirjobshavemeaningandimpact,andthattheyhaveopportunitiestousetheirtalents.
Ineffect,whentheyhavebeenlegitimatelyempowered,itismorelikelythattheireffortswillpayoffin
thekindofperformancethattheorganizationvalues.ThischainofeventsisillustratedintheFigure
below.
Managershavemanybehavioraltoolsavailabletothemtoattackthepowerlessnessproblem.
Someofthesetools,suchasmutualgoalsetting,jobfeedback,modeling,andcontingentreward
systems.Amajorapproach,however,liesintheuseofvariousprogramsforparticipativemanagement.
Suchprogramsprovideemployeeswithvaryingdegreesofperceivedownership,inputintovarioussteps
inthedecisionmakingprocess,andthekeyfeelingofchoiceintheirworkenvironment.
Theprocessofempowerment
Removeconditions
Ofpowerlessness
.Changes
.Leadership
Perceptionof
Empowerment
.Rewardsystem
.Job
EnhancejobrelatedSelf
efficacy
Competence
Highvalue
Jobmeaning
Increaseduse
oftalent
.Jobmastery
.Controlandaccountability
.Rolemodels
.Reinforcement
.Support
RandolphsEmpowermentmodel
ShareInformation
Sharecompanyperformanceinformation
Helppeopleunderstandthebusiness
Buildtrustthroughsharingsensitiveinformation
Createselfmonitoringpossibilities
CreateAutonomythroughStructure
Createaclearvisionandclarifylittlepictures
Performance
Createanewdecisionmakingrulesthatsupportempowerment
Clarifygoalsandrolescollaboratively
Establishnewempoweringperformancemanagementprocesses
Useheavydosesoftraining
Letteamsbecomethehierarchy
Providedirectionandtrainingfornewskills.
Provideencouragementandsupportforchange.
Graduallyhavemanagersletgoofcontrol
Workthroughtheleadershipvacuumstage.
Acknowledgethefearfactor
Randolph,A.w(1995)Navigatingthejourneytoempowerment,OrganizationalDynamics
IMPORTANTREADING
StrategicperformanceempowermentmodelGeroy,WrightandAnderson
Empowerment in Organizations,Vol. 6 No. 2, 1998, pp. 57-65. MCB University Press, 0265671X states that coaching, modeling and career path development should be present in the
organization to provide necessary guidance to employees to become empowered employees.
WhatIsParticipation?
Participationreferstoinvolvementofindividualsorgroupofindividualforcommonpurpose.Workers
Participationinmanagementreferstotheemotionalandmentalinvolvementofanemployeeto
contributeforthegoalsandshareresponsibilitiesofanorganization.Itwillbeeffectiveonlyifthereis
interactionamongindividualsorgroups.Participativemanagersconsultwiththeiremployees,bringing
theminonproblemsanddecisionssothattheyworktogetherasteam.Themanagersarenotautocrats,
butneitheraretheyfreereinmanagerswhoabandontheirmanagementresponsibilities.Participative
managersstillretainultimateresponsibilityfortheoperationoftheirunits,buttheyhavelearnedto
shareoperatingresponsibilitywiththosewhoperformthework.Theresultisthatemployeesfeela
senseofinvolvementingroupgoals.Itfollowsthatparticipationisthementalandemotional
involvementofpeopleingroupsituationsthatencouragesthemtocontributetogroupgoalsand
shareresponsibilityforthem.Therearethreeimportantideasinthisdefinitioninvolvement.,
contribution,andresponsibility.
MENTALANDEMOTIONALINVOLVEMENTFirst,andprobablyforemost,participationmeansmental
andemotionalinvolvementratherthanmeremuscularactivity.Apersonsentireselfisinvolved,not
justhisorherskill.Thisinvolvementispsychologicalratherthanphysical.Apersonwhoparticipatesis
egoinvolvedinsteadofmerelytaskinvolved.
MOTIVATIONTOCONTRIBUTEAsecondconceptinparticipationisthatitmotivatespeopleto
contribute.Theyareempoweredtoreleasetheirownresourcesofinitiativeandcreativitytowardthe
objectivesoftheorganization.,justasTheoryYpredicts.Inthiswayparticipationdiffersfrom
consent.Participationismorethangettingconsentforsomethingthathasalreadybeendecided.Its
greatvalueisthatittapsthecreativityofallemployees.
Participationespeciallyimprovesmotivationbyhelpingemployeesunderstandandclarifytheir
pathstowardgoals.Accordingtothepathgoalmodelofleadership,theimprovedunderstandingof
pathgoalrelationshipproducesaheightenedsenseofresponsibilityforgoalattainment.Theresultis
improvedmotivation.
ACCEPTANCEOFRESPONSIBILITYFinally,participationencouragespeopletoacceptresponsibilityin
theirgroupsactivities.Itisasocialprocessbywhichpeoplebecomeselfinvolvedinanorganization
andwanttoseeitworksuccessfully.Whentheytalkabouttheirorganization,theybegintosaywe,
notthey.Whentheyseeajobproblem,itisours,nottheirs.Participationhelpsthembecome
goodorganizationalcitizensratherthannonresponsible,machinelikeperformers.
Asindividualsbegintoacceptresponsibilityforgroupactivities,theyseeinitawaytodowhat
theywanttodo,thatis,togetajobdoneforwhichtheyfeelresponsible.Thisideaofgettingthegroup
towantteamworkisakeystepindevelopingitintoasuccessfulworkunit.Whenpeoplewanttodo
something,theywillfindaway.Undertheseconditionsemployeesseemanagersassupportive
contributorstotheteam.Employeesarereadytoworkactivelywithmanagersratherthanreactively
againstthem.
FeaturesofWorkersparticipationinmanagement:
a)Emotionalandmentalinvolvement
b)Contributeforthegoals
c)Shareresponsibilitiesofanorganization
ObjectivesofWorkersparticipationinmanagement
Primaryobjective:
a)industrialharmony
b)senseofcommitment
c)senseofbelongingness
d)goodcommunicationskills
e)handlestheresistance
Secondaryobjectives
a)Economical
b)Social
c)Psychological
WhyIsParticipationPopular?
Managershaveforyearsrecognizedvariousbenefitsofparticipation,butthesebenefitswerefirst
demonstratedexperimentallyinclassicstudiesinindustrybyRoethlishberger,CochandFrench,and
others.Theircollectiveresultssuggestedthegeneralpropositionthat,especiallyintheintroductionof
changes,participationtendstoimproveperformanceandjobsatisfaction.Participativepractices
offerstoincreaseproductivityortospeedtheintroductionofproductstomarket.Thesepractices
expeditethesegoalsbyplacingmoreresponsibilityatlowerlevelsoftheorganizationandbyspeeding
uptheapprovalprocess.Participativepracticesmayalsoprovidepoweropportunitiesearlierto
minorityworkersinanincreasinglydiverseworkforce,sincesuchworkersneednotwaituntilreaching
higherorganizationallevelsbeforebeingallowedtocontributemeaningfully.
Participationalsoseemstohelpsatisfytheawakeningemployeeneedformeaningandfulfillment
atwork.
Otherreasonsforthepopularuseofparticipativepracticesarenoteworthy.Theeducationallevel
oftheworkforceoftenprovidesworkerswithuniquecapacitiesthatcanbeappliedcreativelytowork
problems.Theseemployeeshavealsoacquiredbothagreaterdesireforinfluencingworkrelated
decisionsandanexpectationthattheywillbeallowedtoparticipateinthesedecisions.Anequally
strongargumentcanbemadethatparticipationisanethicalimperativeformanagers.Thisviewrests
ontheconclusionthathighlynonparticipativejobscausebothpsychologicalandphysicalharmto
employeesinthelongrun.Asaresultofthesefactors,managersneedtocreateparticipative
conditionsthatwillallowinterestedemployeestoexperiencefeelingsofempowermentintheirwork.
BenefitsofParticipation
Participationtendstoimprovemotivationbecauseemployeesfeelmoreacceptedandinvolvedinthe
situation.Theirselfesteem,jobsatisfaction,andcooperationwithmanagementalsomayimprove.
Theresultsoftenarereducedconflictandstress,morecommitmenttogoalsandbetteracceptanceof
change.Turnoverandabsencesmaybereducedbecauseemployeesfeelthattheyhaveabetterplace
toworkandthattheyarebeingmoresuccessfulintheirjobs.Finally,theactofparticipationinitself
establishesbettercommunicationaspeoplemutuallydiscussworkproblems.Managementtendsto
provideworkerswithincreasedinformationabouttheorganizationsfinancesandoperations,andthis
sharingofinformationallowsemployeestomakebetterqualitysuggestions.
MeritsofWorkersparticipationinmanagement
a)Increaseproductivity
b)Increaseefficiencyofemployee.
c)Establishindustrialpeace
d)Establishindustrialdemocracy
e)Wellbeingofindividual
f)Personalitydevelopment
g)Mutualunderstanding
h)Socialwellbeing
i)Welcomechanges
j)Rapidindustrialization
DemeritsofWorkersparticipationinmanagement
a)Inactivetradeunion
b)Chancesofsuspicion
c)Employeemayleadacarelesslife
d)Industrialanarchy
PrerequisitesforParticipation
1. Adequatetimetoparticipate
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Potentialbenefitsgreaterthancosts
Relevancetoemployeeinterests
Adequateemployeeabilitiesdealwiththesubject
Mutualabilitytocommunicate
Nofeelingofthreattoeitherparty
Restrictiontotheareaofjobfreedom.
ContingencyFactors
DIFFERINGEMPLOYEENEEDSFORPARTICIPATIONDifferentemployeeneedforparticipationwill
determinewhetheremployeeswillacceptandbesatisfiedwiththedegreeofparticipationofferedby
organization
RESPONSIBILITIESOFEMPLOYEESANDMANAGERAcriticalcontingencyelementinthesuccessof
anyparticipativeprogramisthedegreetowhichallemployeesrecognizethattheopportunities
providedareaccompaniedbyasetofresponsibilities.Ideally,allemployeeswouldagreeto
Expectationsforemployees
..Befullyresponsiblefortheiractionsandtheirconsequences
..Operatewithintherelevantorganizationalpolicies
..Becontributingteammembers
..Respectandseektousetheperspectivesofothers
..Bedependableandethicalintheirempoweredactions
..Demonstrateresponsibleselfleadership
Theseresponsibilitiesofemployeesprovideabalancetothoseofthemanager:
Expectationsformanagers
..Identifyingtheissuestobeaddressed
..Specifyingthelevelofinvolvementdesired
..Providingrelevantinformationandtraining
..Allocatingfairrewards
PROGRAMSFORPARTICIPATION
MethodsforimplementingWorkersparticipationinmanagement
a)Copartnership/coownership
b)Workerscommittee
c)jointmanagementcouncil
d)suggestions
e)boardrepresentation
ConsultativeManagement
Consultativemanagementisthekindofparticipationthatmanagersoftenpracticeeventhoughthe
peopleabovethemdonotapplyit.Consultativemanagement,asthenameimplies,meansthat
managersasktheiremployeestothinkaboutissues,sharetheirexpertise,andcontributetheirown
ideasbeforeamanagerialdecisionismade.
SuggestionPrograms
Suggestionprogramsareformalplanstoinviteindividualemployeestorecommendwork
improvements.Inmostcompaniestheemployeewhosesuggestionresultsinacostsavingsmayreceive
amonetaryawardinproportiontothefirstyearssavings.
QualityEmphasis
Formanyyears,bothunionandnonunionfirmshaveorganizedgroupsofworkersandtheirmanagers
intocommitteestoconsiderandsolvejobproblems.Thesegroupsmaybecalledworkcommittees,
labormanagementcommittees,workimprovementtaskforces,orinvolvementteams.Theyhavebroad
usefulnessforimprovingproductivityandcommunicationsbecausemostoftheemployeescanbe
involved.Popularapproachesforthispurposearequalitycirclesandtotalqualitymanagement.
QUALITYCIRCLESVoluntarygroupsthatreceivetraininginstatisticaltechniquesandproblemsolving
skillsandthenmeettoproduceideasforimprovingproductivityandworkingconditionsareknownas
qualitycircles.
Tobesuccessful,qualitycirclesshouldbeusedaccordingtotheseguidelines:
..Usethemformeasurable,shorttermproblems.
..Obtaincontinuoussupportfromtopmanagement.
..Applythegroupsskillstoproblemswithinthecirclesworkarea.
..Trainsupervisorsinfacilitationskills.
..Viewqualitycirclesasonestartingpointforothermoreparticipativeapproachestobeusedinthe
future.
TOTALQUALITYMANAGEMENT
TheTQMapproachgetseveryemployeeinvolvedintheprocessofsearchingforcontinuous
improvementsintheiroperations.Thetotalqualitymanagementapproachconstituteaformalprogram
withdirectparticipationofallemployees.Almostanyissueissubjecttoexploration,andtheprocessisa
continuingoneoflongduration.Consequently,TQMholdspromiseasasubstantialprogramin
participativemanagement.
MiddleManagementCommittees
MiddleManagementCommitteesaregroupmechanismstoimproveparticipationofmanagersbelow
toporganizationlevels.Theircoreisajuniorboardofdirectorsthatisgiventheopportunitytostudy
anyproblemandtorecommendcoursesofaction.Suchprogramsencouragecarefulstudyofideas
beforetheyarepresentedtotopmanagement:thereforetopmanagementrarelyvetoesa
recommendation.
SelfManagingTeams
Somefirmshavemovedbeyondconsultativeanddemocraticformsofparticipation,allowinganumber
ofmajordecisionstobemadebyemployeegroups.
Amoreformalversionofthegroupdecisionapproachistheselfmanagingteam.Sometimescalled
semiautonomousworkgroupsorsociotechnicalteams,selfmanagingteamsarenaturalworkgroups
thataregivenalargedegreeofdecisionmakingautonomy;theyareexpectedtocontrolheirown
behaviorandresults.Akeyfeatureisthediminished(ordramaticallychanged)roleofthemanageras
theteammemberslearntoacquirenewskills.
EmployeeownershipPlans
Employeeownershipofafirmemergeswhenemployeesprovidethecapitaltopurchasecontrolofan
existingoperation.Thestimulusoftencomesfromthreatenedclosingsofmarginallyprofitableplants,
whereworkersseelittlehopeofotheremploymentinadevastatedlocaleconomy.
Guidelinesforparticipationprogramsuccess
1. Letworkersprogressfrominvolvementonsimpleissuestomorecomplexones.
2. Provideemployeeswithrelevanttrainingsothattheyunderstandbroaderorganizationalissues
andfinancialstatements.
3. Communicateinadvancetheirareasofdecisionalfreedomandtheassociatedboundaries.
4. Dontforceworkerstoparticipateiftheydonotwishtodoso.
5. Providecounselingforsupervisorssothattheywillknowhowtohandlepowersharing.
6. Setrealisticgoalsfortheearlystagesofanyparticipativeprocess.
7. Keeptheguidingphilosophybehindparticipationfirmlyinmindatalltimes.
8. Neverattempttomanipulateadecisionundertheguiseofparticipation.
9. Maintainadelicatebalancebetweenoverparticipationandunderparticipation.
10. Monitoremployeeperceptionsofthelevelofempowermentexperienced.
NewRolesForManagers
Managersneedtostartrelinquishingtheirrolesofjudgeandcriticandbeginviewingthemselves
aspartnerswithemployees.Theystillneedtocommunicateadirectionfortheirunit,helpset
challenginggoals,andmonitorresources.Buttheirnewroleinvitesthemtoviewthemselvesas
stewardsofabroadrangeofhumanandtechnicalresources.Thisstewardshipparadigmshiftstheir
emphasisfromdirectionandcontroltothatofservantleadership,wheretheirchallengeistohelp
othersattainrelevantgoalswhiledevelopingtheirskillsandabilities.
Questions
1. WhatisEmpowerment?Describetheprocessofempowerment.
2. Writeshortnoteson(a)RandolphsEmpowermentmodel(b)Strategicperformance
empowermentmodel
3. WhatisParticipation?DescribethefeaturesofWorkersparticipationinmanagement
4. WhatarethebenefitsofParticipation?Whataretheprerequisitesofparticipation
5. Statewithexamplestheexpectationsfromemployeesandmanagers.Inthisconnection
describetheguidelinesforparticipation
6. DescribethedifferentProgramsforparticipation.Whatarethecontingenciesofparticipation.