Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.corporatebridge.net
www.corporatebridge.net
www.corporatebridge.net
This method assumes that the first units purchased are the first units sold
The LIFO inventory costing method assumes that the last units purchased are the first to be sold
This method assumes that the units are sold without regard to the order in which they are purchased
Example
Summary Inventory Records
Inventory on January 1st, 2006
Inventory purchased in 2006
Cost of goods available for sale in 2006
Inventory sold in 2006
No. of units
600
200
800
$/unit
100
150
Total cost
60,000
30,000
90,000
550
250
137,500
www.corporatebridge.net
FIFO:
FIFO
Sales
COGS (550 @ $100)
Gross Profit
137,500
(55,000)
82,500
Liability
Shareholders Equity
$55,000 flows
through the Income
Statement as expense
$55,000
cost of goods sold
LIFO:
LIFO
Sales
COGS (200 units @ $150)
COGS (350 units @ $100)
Gross Profit
137,500
(30,000)
(35,000)
72,500
Liability
Shareholders Equity
$65,000 flows
through the Income
Statement as expense
www.corporatebridge.net
Total cost
Total units
Average cost
90,000
800
112.5
Liability
Shareholders Equity
$61,875 flows
through the Income
Statement as expense
$61,875
cost of goods sold
137,500
(61,875)
75,625
Summary
Summary
FIFO Costing
LIFO Costing
Average Costing
COGS
55,000
65,000
61,875
Ending Inventory
35,000
25,000
28,125
www.corporatebridge.net
All three inventory valuation methods (FIFO, LIFO and Weighted Average costs) will yield the same
results for Inventory, COGS and Earnings
LIFO
FIFO
COGS
Higher
Lower
Higher as inventory reflects the most
recently purchased items
Ending Inventory
and Working Capital
Net Worth
Lower Taxes
Higher Taxes
Same
Same
Taxes
Earnings
www.corporatebridge.net
Analytical adjustments
Profitability
LIFO produces higher COGS balances and are better measure of true economic costs
In an environment of rising prices, LIFO produces income that are lower than FIFO
Gross margins and profit margins are lower due to lower income under LIFO
For FIFO firms, profitability ratios should be recalculated using estimates of what COGS would
have been under FIFO
Liquidity
FIFO produces inventory figures that are higher and are a better measure of economic value
LIFO, however, uses prices that are outdated (in an environment of rising prices)
Liquidity ratios such as current ratios are higher under FIFO than in LIFO
For LIFO firms, Liquidity ratios should be recalculated using inventory balances that have been
restated using LIFO reserve
Assets
LIFO Reserve
Liability
LIFO Reserve
x Tax Rate
Shareholders Equity
LIFO Reserve
x (1-Tax Rate)
Solvency
Solvency ratio like debt ratio, debt-to-equity ratio will be lower under FIFO because of higher denominator
For firms that use LIFO, ratios should be calculated using asset and equity figures restated by
using LIFO reserve
www.corporatebridge.net
www.corporatebridge.net
Depreciation Policies
NO IMPACT?
Impact on Earnings
Firm that chooses an accelerated method of depreciation instead of using straight-line will tend to have
greater depreciation expense and lower net income
Will continue if the firm is investing in new assets that the lower depreciation on old asset is more than
offset by the higher depreciation on new assets
ROE?
Retained Earnings?
www.corporatebridge.net
Depreciaton Expense
Net Income
Assets
Equity
Return on Assets
Return on Equity
Turnover Ratios
Cash Flows
Straight Line
Lower
Higher
Higher
Higher
Higher
Higher
Lower
Same
Accelerated (WDV)
Higher
Lower
Lower
Lower
Lower
Lower
Higher
Same
Wrote back Rs9.2bn into its P&L, which helped the company to report profits during the quarter
It also helped Jet to report higher net worth, which will help in keeping reported gearing low
TCS, the software major, increased its depreciation policy on computers from 2 years to 4
years. As a result, 1QFY09 PBT was higher by an estimated Rs500m (c.4% of net profit in
1QFY09).
10
www.corporatebridge.net
11
www.corporatebridge.net
Introduction to Leases
Leases
Contractual agreement between the lessor (owner of asset) and the lessee (rents the asset)
Obligations for taxes, insurance, and maintenance may be assumed by the lessor or the lessee
Operational
Disadvantages of leases?
Private and Confidential Not for Circulation
12
www.corporatebridge.net
Operating Leases
Leases that do not transfer substantially all the benefits and risks of ownership are operating leases
Capital lease
Capitalize a lease that transfers substantially all of the benefits and risks of property ownership, provided
the lease is non-cancelable
Lessee records the leased asset in the balance sheet (i.e. capitalizes the asset) and reflects the
corresponding lease obligation
Leases that do not meet any of the four criteria are accounted for an Operating
Lease
Yes
Capital Lease
No
Operating Lease
13
www.corporatebridge.net
Test 1
Does the lease transfer ownership of the property to the lessee by the end of the
non-cancellable lease term?
Answer
No
Test 2
Does the lease contain an option to purchase the leased property at a bargain price?
Cost to purchase asset at end of lease
Estimated asset value at end of lease
na
na
14
www.corporatebridge.net
Test 3
Is the lease term greater than or equal to 75% of the estimated economic life of the
leased property?
Estimated useful life (years)
75% of estimated useful life
Non-cancellable Lease term (years)
Difference
5.0
3.8
4.0
-0.25
Difference is negative
implies capital Lease
Test 4
Does the present value of rental and other minimum lease payments, excluding that portion
of the payments representing executory cost, equal or exceed 90 percent of the fair value
of the leased property?
Value of leased asset
90% of value of leased asset (at lease inception)
"Present Value" of lease
Difference
$100,000
$90,000
$88,067
$1,933
If difference is negative,
then Capital Lease
15
www.corporatebridge.net
Assets
Shareholders Equity
Shareholders Equity
No Entry
No Entry
Liability
Liability
Cash reduced by
periodic lease
payments
Operating leases do not affect the lessees liabilities and hence, are referred to as off-balance
sheet financing
Footnote disclosure of lease payment for each of the next five years is required
16
www.corporatebridge.net
Assets
Present value of
minimum lease
payment
Liability
Shareholders Equity
Shareholders Equity
Present value of
minimum lease
payment
a)
Cash reduced by
periodic lease
payments
Liability
Lease obligation is
reduced by periodic
lease payment LESS
Interest payment
b) Leased property is
reduced by
depreciation
amount
Interest expense = Discount rate times the Lease liability at the beginning of the period
If lease transfers ownership, depreciate asset over the economic life of the asset.
If lease does not transfer ownership, depreciate over the term of the lease.
Only portion of the lease payment that is considered interest payment reduces CFO
17
www.corporatebridge.net
Operating Lease
If we assume that the lease is an Operating Lease
a) Balance Sheet: No Impact
b) Income Statement Effect: Lease payments of $26,000 treated as expense
c) Cash Flow: Lease payment of $26,000 treated as outflow for Cash flow from operations
Capital Lease
In the earlier illustration, the lease was a capital Lease
Balance Sheet at Inception
a) Present value at 7% is $88,067
b) Both Asset and Liability increases by the present value of lease payments at inception
Assets
US$88,097
Liability
Shareholders Equity
US$88,097
18
www.corporatebridge.net
Assets
a)
Cash reduced by
periodic lease
payments of
US$26,000
Liability
Lease obligation is
reduced by periodic
lease payment
US$26,000 LESS
US$6,165
Shareholders Equity
Flows through Income
statement as Interest
expense of US$6,165
and Depreciation
expense of US$22,017
b) Leased property is
reduced by
depreciation
amount of
US$22,017
Year
0
1
2
3
4
(a)
Beginning
Leasehold
Value
$88,067
$68,232
$47,008
$24,299
(b)
Interest
Expense (a) X
7%
$6,165
$4,776
$3,291
$1,701
(c)
Lease
payment
$26,000
$26,000
$26,000
$26,000
(d)
Ending
(e)
(f)
Leasehold value Depreciation Book Value
(a+b-c)
Expense
of Assets
$88,067
$88,067
$68,232
$22,017
$66,051
$47,008
$22,017
$44,034
$24,299
$22,017
$22,017
$0
$22,017
$0
Note: a) The book value of assets decline each year by the depreciation amount as shown in column (f)
b) Depreciation (term of 4 years) = $88,067/4 = $22,017
c) Principal repayments equals the lease payments LESS interest expense
d) The asset (column f) is being depreciated at a rate that is different from the rate of amortization for
the liability (column d), the two values are equal only at the inception and termination of the lease
19
www.corporatebridge.net
Year
1
2
3
4
Capital Lease
Operating Expense =
Total Expense
$26,000
$26,000
$26,000
$26,000
Operating Expense
$22,017
$22,017
$22,017
$22,017
Non-operating
expense
$6,165
$4,776
$3,291
$1,701
Total Expense
$28,181
$26,793
$25,307
$23,718
Operating
lease
$28
Expense ('000 $)
Operating Lease
$27
$26
$25
$24
Capital lease
$23
$22
$21
1
Years
Capital Lease
Cash flow from
operations
($6,165)
($4,776)
($3,291)
($1,701)
20
www.corporatebridge.net
Financial Statement
Capital Lease
Operating Lease
Assets
Higher
Lower
Liabilities
Higher
Lower
Lower
Higher
Higher
Lower
Lower
Higher
Same
Same
Effect on Ratios
Financial Statement
Capital Lease
Operating Lease
Current ratio
Lower
Higher
Working Capital
Lower
Higher
Asset Turnover
Lower
Higher
Return on assets
Lower
Higher
Return on equity
Lower
Higher
Debt/Equity
Higher
Lower
21
www.corporatebridge.net
Capitalization vs Expensing
22
www.corporatebridge.net
Capitalize
Expense
Cost incurred
Capitalization
Expensing
Income
Statement
Balance Sheet
Net Income
(Depreciation or
Amortization
Expense)
CFI Outflow
Net Income
(Expense)
CFO outflow
Management discretion in exercising these choices can significantly impact the financial
statements and the ratios
23
www.corporatebridge.net
WorldCom Case
Transaction
$3.8bn 2001-02
expenditure on
line costs
Regulators?
What was
required as per
GAAP
What WorldCom
did?
Accounting
Treatment
$3.8bn must be
treated as
operating
expense
WorldCom
capitalized the
costs
Financial
Statement
Effects
Pre-tax Income
should be
deducted by
$3.8bn
$3.8bn was
capitalized and
put on the
balance sheet
(for
amortization)
WorldCom declared
bankruptcy in July 2002.
Chief accounting and
finance executives charged
with securities fraud
24
www.corporatebridge.net
Expensing
Capitalizing
Income Variability
Greater variability
Expensing
Capitalizing
Lower
Higher
Higher
Book Value/Share
Lower
Higher
Expensing
Capitalizing
Lower
Higher
Higher
Lower
Same
Same
Matching of revenues
25
www.corporatebridge.net
Capitalization of interest
Capitalized interest is the interest incurred during the construction of long-lived assets.
Capitalized interest is included as the initial cost of the asset on the balance sheet instead of
being charged off as interest expense on the income statement
They must require a period of time to make them ready for use
26
www.corporatebridge.net
Intangibles Assets
27
www.corporatebridge.net
Patents
Goodwill
Advertisements
28
www.corporatebridge.net
Future benefits from R&D expenditures is highly uncertain at the start of a project
However, when one firm buys another firm, the total purchase price must be apportioned
among the individual assets acquired
Immediately written off
$5,000
$4,000
In-process
R&D (no future
alternative)
$600
$400
Tangible Assets
Purchase price
SFAS 2 requires that a portion of purchase price be allocated to in-process R&D and be
immediately written off
Managers have a strong incentive to allocate a large portion of the purchase price to
purchased in-process R&D
29
www.corporatebridge.net
Software development cost is a major costs for many small, growth service companies and
thats their main asset
Capitalized and
amortized
Technologically feasible
Research
expenditures
Development
expenditures
Before
After
30
www.corporatebridge.net
Intangibles Example
Example: Intangibles
An enterprise is developing a new production process. During the year 2001, expenditure incurred
was Rs. 10 lakhs, of which Rs. 9 lakhs was incurred before 1 December 2001 and 1 lakh was incurred
between 1 December 2001 and 31 December 2001. The enterprise is able to demonstrate that, at
1 December 2001, the production process met the criteria for recognition as an intangible asset.
The recoverable amount of the know-how embodied in the process (including future cash outflows
to complete the process before it is available for use) is estimated to be Rs. 5 lakhs.
During the year 2002, expenditure incurred is Rs. 20 lakhs. At the end of 2002, the recoverable
amount of the know-how embodied in the process (including future cash outflows to complete
the process before it is available for use) is estimated to be Rs. 19 lakhs.
31
www.corporatebridge.net
Intangible Asset
Research and development
Advertising costs
Expensed as incurred
Goodwill
32
www.corporatebridge.net
Deferred Tax
33
www.corporatebridge.net
Indian GAAP
Taxable Income
Income tax expense from GAAP and income tax payable from Income Tax Act do not equal
When income and expense are treated differently on financial statements than it is on the
companys tax returns results in Deferred tax asset or Deferred tax liabilities
Recognize deferred tax liability or deferred tax asset for the tax consequences of amounts that will
become taxable or deductible in future years as a result of transactions or events that already have
occurred
34
www.corporatebridge.net
Temporary differences
Difference between the tax basis of an asset or liability and its reported (carrying or book)
amount in the financial statements that will result in taxable amounts or deductible amounts
in future years
Future Taxable
Amounts
Deferred Tax
Liability
Unrealized gain from recording investments at fair value (taxable when asset is sold)
Future
Deductible
Amounts
Deferred Tax
Asset
Warranty expenses are accrued on income statement (tax deductible only when warranty claims are paid)
Deferred compensation cost is recognized as it is earned (tax deductible only when payments are made)
Asset impairment
35
www.corporatebridge.net
Year 1
5,000
5,000
Year 2
2,500
5,000
7,500
Year 3
1,250
2,500
5,000
8,750
Year 4
1,250
1,250
2,500
5,000
Year 1
2,500
2,500
Year 2
2,500
2,500
5,000
Year 3
2,500
2,500
2,500
7,500
Year 4
2,500
2,500
2,500
7,500
Year 1
750
750
Year 2
750
1,500
Year 3
375
1,875
Year 4
-750
1,125
Temporary difference
reverses from Year 4
If there is no reversal of deferred liability, the cumulative deferred liability will continue to
increase as long as the firm continues to grow
36
www.corporatebridge.net
Permanent differences
Permanent differences
Results mainly from revenues or expenses that affect pretax income or taxable income, but not both
Premium on life insurance policies where the company is beneficiary (not deductible for tax purposes)
As these differences are never deferred but are considered decreases or increases in the effective tax
rate
If the only difference between taxable and pretax incomes were a permanent difference, then tax expense
would be simply tax payable
Income Statement
80,000
20,000
-5,000
95,000
NA
NA
28,000
29.5%
Tax Return
80,000
80,000
32,000
-4,000
28,000
40.0%
No deferred liability or
assets are created
37
www.corporatebridge.net
Deferred Taxes
Companies
78 companies
HUL, ITC & M&M
Canara Bank, Allahbad Bank
SBI, MRPL, HDFC
ONGC
Others
% of total
94.75%
2.15%
0.67%
0.58%
0.44%
1.41%
38
www.corporatebridge.net
The analyst should consider the firms growth rate and capital spending levels when
determining whether the difference will actually reverse
Impairment generally result in creation of Deferred tax assets since the write-down of assets
is recognized immediately for financial reporting, but not for tax purpose until the asset is
sold
Restructuring also leads to creation of Deferred tax assets since for financial reporting
purpose the costs are recognized immediately when restructuring is complete, but not
expensed for tax purpose until actually paid
39
www.corporatebridge.net
Contingent Liabilities
40
www.corporatebridge.net
Contingent Liability
Contingent liabilities represent potential expenses for a company where the outcome is
dependent upon one of more future events
If it is probable the liability will crystallize then the full amount must be accrued in the
financial statements
However, if payment is less than probably (usually interpreted to be a probability of less than
50%) then no entry is made in the balance sheet; although a contingency is disclosed in the
notes to the accounts
Common contingencies include loan guarantees, product warranties and legal claims
Do Nothing
Private and Confidential Not for Circulation
41