Safeguarding against employer insolvency

Construction Management Guide

All you need for your career..

home

about

ask cmguide

register

downloads

contact

jobs
Search

Print This Post

Ads by Google Contract LawsContract Form Loan Contract

Insolvency

Safeguarding against employer insolvency

Filed in Contract Administration on Nov.11, 2008

What are the options available and mechanisms that a contractor should have in place to
safeguard its interests in the event of its employer becoming insolvent? MARTIN PRESTON* of
Norton Rose provides a guideline.

Founder & Chief Editor: Samer H Skaik

BSc. Civil Eng., MSc. CPM (Distinction), PMP

Subscribe to CMGUIDE Newsletter

Your email:
Enter email address...
Subscribe

Unsubscribe

Related Links
Open a Forex Demo Account

Trade virtual Forex money and join the

competition to win $3000!
www.windsorbrokers.com

Ask a UK Lawyer Online

Under the laws of the Emirate of Dubai, employers have to comply with Law No 8 of 2007 (the
Escrow Law).
This requires developers undertaking off-plan sales to ensure that money coming into the project
as and when sales are made or as a result of property finance (excluding the developers own
capital contribution) is ring-fenced by being paid into an escrow account. Only certain payments
are permitted to be made from this account.
A contractor entering into a construction contract with an employer governed by the Escrow Law
should ensure that payments due under the construction contract are permitted to be made from
the escrow account, thereby providing the contractor with the comfort that funds coming into the
project will be made available to pay the contractor.
If the Escrow Law does not apply because the project is outside Dubai or if the project is largely
self-funded by the developer, how can a contractor ensure that it will be paid?
Although most standard form construction contracts (including the FIDIC forms prevalent in this
region) contain provisions entitling a contractor to interest on late payment and to suspend
performance of the works should the employer fail to pay sums due to it, the contractor will at this
stage be out of pocket as it will have carried out the works covered by the unpaid payment
certificate.
The right to suspend does, however, give the contractor some leverage against the employer and
ensure that it does not have to keep incurring costs once payments have been missed by the
employer. It does not, however, provide much protection should the employer become insolvent
and unable to make payments under the contract.
FIDIC and other forms of contract entitle a contractor to terminate the contract (or its employment
thereunder) if the employer is insolvent and this enables a contractor to cease construction and
the incurring of costs after the employer is insolvent (or, more correctly, after the contractor is
aware that the employer is insolvent, which may be somewhat later). However, this will not
provide any comfort to the contractor in relation to costs incurred and/or payments due that the
employer cannot make because of its insolvency. Similarly, the right to terminate for non-payment
while providing the contractor with a remedy if a solvent employer fails to make payments when
due will not assist a contractor when the employer is unable to make payments because it is
insolvent.
Ideally, then, a contractor will have in place mechanisms that ensure that it is paid. The most
obvious of these is an escrow account into which the employer deposits the amounts that are to

http://www.cmguide.org/archives/219[2012/4/2 06:18:20]

A UK Lawyer Will Answer You Now!

Questions Answered Every 9 Seconds.
UK-Law.JustAnswer.com

The sound of 5

Visit F/5gumarabia for a journey of self

discovery and creativity.
www.facebook.com/5gumarabia

Become a Fan of CMGUIDE

Construction
Management Guide cmguide.org

Categories
Civil Engineering
Cmguide Articles
Construction Industry
Construction Law
Construction Technology
Contract Administration
General Management
PMP Hints
Procurement Management
Project Management
Upcoming Events

Safeguarding against employer insolvency

become due to the contractor under the building contract. An employer would probably be
reluctant to place the entire contract price in an escrow account but an alternative would be for
the employer to place an amount equal to the next anticipated payment certificate into the escrow
account and for the account to be replenished after each payment has been made from it.
The contractor will need a right to suspend performance of the works under the building contract if
such funds have not been replenished so that it does not incur the costs of carrying out the works
without the certainty of knowing that funds will be available to pay the next payment certificate. In
certain jurisdictions, the escrow agreement will need to be drafted with care to ensure that
payments into the escrow account are not set aside on an insolvency as preferential payments to
creditors or as a result of any moratorium preventing the exercise of rights on an insolvency,
thereby depriving the contractor of the protection that that account is intended to provide.
Another option is for the employer to provide to the contractor a performance bond or letter of
credit for a certain amount, which the contractor could draw against if payment was not made. As
with the escrow account, the contractor should have a right to suspend works under the building
contract if there is a call under the performance bond or letter of credit and either it is not
replenished to its full amount or the unexpired portion is less than the anticipated value of the next
payment certificate. It will be important to ensure that the performance bond is drafted so that the
contractor can draw upon it when required. This will depend on whether it is an on-demand or
conditional bond and, if conditional, on the conditions that need to be satisfied before a call can be
made. Further discussion of performance bonds can be found in my article in the February 2007
edition of Gulf Construction.
If the employer has a parent company, then another option may be to seek a parent company
guarantee, such that the contractor can obtain payment from the parent company if the employer
fails to meet its payment obligations under the construction contract. This option may prove more
attractive to an employer as the cost is less than that of funding an escrow account or providing a
bond or letter of credit, although equally the parent company may not want to be exposed to the
liabilities of one of its subsidiaries in this way.
From the contractors perspective, a parent company guarantee will only be of value if the parent
company has the financial ability to meet any claims made against it. The contractor will therefore
have to conduct due diligence on the parent company and to ensure that it is aware if there is any
deterioration in the latters financial standing, the parent company would be unable to meet its
obligations under the guarantee. In this case, the contractor will want to ensure that alternative
security for the employers payment obligations is put in place.
Gulf Construction

I Thought Youd Never Notice: The Civil Code and

the Red Book
Contemporary records
Goals, Strategies and Objectives Explained
Times running out on FIDIC Middle East
Can disputes be settled like gentlemen?
Time At Large
CMGuide is the Media Partner for the 3rd FIDIC
Middle East Contract Users conference
FIDICs Middle Eastern Contract Users conference
returns for a 3rd year!

Recent Comments
Enas on Downloads
Pat Alpajora on Ask CMGUIDE
FHHA on Extension of time claims
FHHA on Extension of time claims
Najam Waheed on Ask CMGUIDE

Downloads
FIDIC-Client Consultant agreement (50 bytes, 7,315
hits)
Lessons in project management (1.5 MiB, 936 hits)

Similar Topics
Protection against contractor insolvency
Dubai Escrow Law
UAE laws do not favour contractor
Agreements should sort payment issues
Getting into the Greenbacks: Hurdles in Competing for U.S. Government Construction Work

You do not have permission to download this file.

FIDIC-Guide to the use CONDITIONS OF
CONTRACT FOR Design and Build (1.7 MiB, 935
hits)
You do not have permission to download this file.
FIDIC RED BOOK 1999 (13.6 MiB, 916 hits)
You do not have permission to download this file.

ShareThis
Print This Post

Take Control Of Your Cash hsbc.ae/Payments_Services

Flow With HSBC Payment Services. Start
Thinking Long-Term With HSBC

Latest Articles

Four ways to become an effective manager (871.9

KiB, 861 hits)
You do not have permission to download this file.

Construction News
Contract Mgmt Training purchasing-procurement-center.com
Check The Benefits Of Attending The Seminar
On March '12, Kuala Lampur
International Tax Law www.moskowitzllp.com
Talk with a Tax Attorney Today No cost
consultation (888) 829 3325
Construction Jobs in UAE www.GulfTalent.com
Job Opportunities in Construction. Apply Now!

New projects must benefit Rabigh's people, says

governor
JIG to build 3 hotels in Saudi Arabia
??? ????? ????? ???? ????? 90% ?? ???? ???
???
Galfar Saudi office to begin bidding for tenders in
June
????????? ???? ???? ?? ?????? ?????? ??????
??

Category: Contract Administration

Tags: contractor, employer

Comments (1) | 2,568 views

One Response to Safeguarding against employer insolvency

http://www.cmguide.org/archives/219[2012/4/2 06:18:20]

Tags

arbitration budget building civil

claim communication
contractor cost crisis delay

Safeguarding against employer insolvency

Maggie Proest

dispute disruption employer

Says:

March 9th, 2010 at 6:47 am

I love this blog. Thanks for the great information. I have it bookmarked and
will be back.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Ads by Google Contract LawsContract Form Loan Contract

Insolvency

escalation extension

FIDIC

industry insurance JV LAD

finishes

green

law

manager negotiation nomination notice

partnering payment planning
procurement products quality risk
safety skills structure suspension
sustainability technology tendering

termination TQM variations WBS

User Panel
Register
Log in
Lost your password?

Join CMGUIDE Networks

General Management| Project Management | Civil Enigneering|Contract Administration|Construction Industry| Management Hints|Download| Cmguide Articles
Copyright 2008 cmguide.org . All rights reserved.

http://www.cmguide.org/archives/219[2012/4/2 06:18:20]