Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ON
A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON CONSUMER
PREFERENCE AMONG CLOUD HRMS VIS--VIS
ON-PREMISE HRMS
By
(i)
CERTIFICATE OF ORIGINALITY
(Student's Signature)
Date: ________________
(ii)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
In successfully completing my project report, I am indeed indebted to a large no. of people who have
encouraged and helped me in a variety of ways. Its indeed a privilege to express my gratitude to the
people involved.
(iii)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Changes on the surface of HR don't begin to reveal the complexity of what is going on behind
the scenes. HR professionals are rethinking everything from HR's structure to its delivery of
services to the very competencies that it needs to survive and succeed.
Outsourcing HR functions is still a relatively new frontier in business practices - it's been less
than 10 years since its debut - and it's still growing rapidly globally. Most analysts predict that
the growth will continue at least through 2008. Many companies currently outsourcing HR
functions say that they intend to continue and expand outsourcing in the coming three years to
include leave management, training and development, payroll, recruitment, health and wellness
program administration, and global mobility.
The main objective of this study is to know which module of HRMS is preferred in the organizations
among Cloud HRMS and On-premise HRMS and understanding why that particular module is preferred.
This study further helps in knowing if there is any significance difference between Cloud and On-premise
HRMS on the basis of cost and also on the basis of data security.
The project begins with in-depth research about Cloud and On-premise HRMS software. The HRM
(Human Resource Management ) System that organization need to implement and then the focus gets
shifted to deeply understanding the concept and listing out the main features of Cloud and On-premise
HRMS software tool. The conclusion drawn from the research in the form of data is represented in under
suggestions.
(iv)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
SUMMER TRAINING COMPLETION CERTIFICATE------------------------
CERTIFICATE OF ORIGINALITY-------------------------------------------------- II
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT----------------------------------------------------------------- III
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY---------------------------------------------------------------- IV
TABLE OF CONTENTS-------------------------------------------------------------------- V
CHAPTER 1 : INTRODUCTION---------------------------------------------------
1-29
35-38
35
35
3.2.1Research Objectives------------------------
35
35
36
36-37
37-38
38
39-48
49-50
REFERENCES---------------------------------------------------
51
BIBLIOGRAPHY-----------------------------------------------
52
ANNEXURES-----------------------------------------------------
53
(v)
CHAPTER 1 : INTRODUCTION
Company Profile :
XecuteHR Solutions, Gurgaon :
XecuteHR which is a technology driven Human Capital Enhancement organization was
founded in August 2009. In the last 2 years XecuteHR have successfully established themselves
in the other HR delivery and support verticals. The current portfolio of XecuteHR includes
services in the areas of Recruitment Process Management, Onboarding Management, HR
Operations Management, HR Shared Services, Strategic HR Consulting, Search and Selection
and Temporary Staffing.
XecuteHR has its own in-house developed HR software named Xite that supports delivery across
all possible HR verticles including Recruitment, Onboarding, Employee database Management,
Attendance and leave Management, Payroll and Compliance Management, Performance
Management, Employee Query Management and others.These models are highly customizable
and offers services at the click of a button with convenience to the process manager as well as
the end users (employees, managers and management) of any organization.
Vision and Mission :
Every company has got its own vision and mission. The vision and mission of XecuteHR
Solutions is given below.
Vision :
Empowering organizations through unique human capital services and solutions.
Mission :
The mission of XecuteHR Solutions is To Create Value and Make a Difference everywhere
we engage. by offering the highest level of end to end services and solutions in HR thus
empowering organizations towards leading the competition with imparting a greater focus on
strategic core business areas.
Management Desk :
(i) Koustuv Mitra
Founder, XecuteHR Solutions Pvt. Ltd.
Koustuv Mitra is an HR Professional with an experience of 24 years in various fields of Human
Resource. He has an experience in leading HR in various multinational companies Like
Convergys, Electrolux and Airtel. Moreover he also held a very senior HR Leadership position
in BP and Coca Cola. His core experience lies in Organization Transformation and Employee
Productivity and have led the HR part in leading to a significant increase in Profitability and
Employee satisfaction. In his last assignment as Head of HR for the Non- mobile business for
Airtel, he was responsible for successfully managing outsourcing of a critical function (4000+
employees) and this is said to be the largest transition done anywhere in the world in any
company that provides Telecom services.
Arunachal
Plywood
Industries
Ltd,
The
Park
Tollygunge
Club
Saraswati Press (Government of India Undertaking), World Bank - Accounting for WBHSDP.
He is an expert in Application Development , Database Administration in wide variety of
business applications, Client/server and relational database design using MS-SQL Server,
Migration projects, Crystal Reporting.
XiTE :
The team at XecuteHR has not only created its web-based Human Resources Management
Solutions but has also successfully implemented it in more than five client environments. It is
named as XiTE HRMS suite and the HR software solutions are hosted on the NaviSite server and
is provided as a SaaS solution to medium and large enterprises including multinationals.
It is built using Microsoft Technologies and this suite consists of over 25 HR sub modules to
cover all aspects of an employee lifecycle in an organization starting from recruitment to onboarding, employee interact, performance and compensation management, query tracking and
finally alumni management. It provides reliable and accurate strategic and operational inputs to
all concerned.
everyday. Thus HRMS Payroll is a payroll software specially designed for managing all the
payroll functions of an organization and it is a very simple, flexible and user friendly module of
the HRMS.
Time and Attendance :
It is a HRMS tool which enables an organization to collect, analyze and take immediate control
of its employees attendance in real time. All these functions are available on on-premise license
and also on cloud basis. This technology reduces the burden of manual processes which is used
calculating time and attendance of the employees of an organization. Time and attendance is an
important function as it is a proof of attendance of the employees. By automating the entire
functions one can easily collect and analyze an employees time and attendance data related to
employee hours worked, overtime etc.
Performance Appraisal :
A performance appraisal is a part of guiding and managing career development. It is a process of
obtaining, recording and analyzing information about the relative worth of an employee in an
organization. In HRMS performance appraisal, analysis of an employees recent success and
failures, personal strengths and weakness and suitability for promotion or for further training is
calculated effectively and efficiently.
The results of performance appraisal can be assessed to identify areas of strong performance of
all employees by department. Standardized performance assessments allows companies to
aggregate, calculate and analyze results to show where performance is strong and where
performance is weak. Thus these areas of strength can serve as opportunities for sharing of the
best practices for other areas of the organization.
Benefits administration :
HR professionals spend up to 30% of their time on routine benefits administration. If a company
offers multiple benefits such as life, health and disability insurance, they have to set up and
administer plans which consists of multiple insurance carriers. When an organization expand
their HRMS to include benefits management functionality, it simplifies benefits setup,
administration, and enrollment for improved efficiency. Inside the HRMS, they will be able to
define benefit plans and enter employee beneficiaries. An organization can even track and
monitor elections of employee and calculate employer and employee contributions for benefits.
When employees leave a company, they can even track COBRA enrollments, coverage details,
and payment history of the employee.
Recruiting :
Attracting, recruiting and retaining the right people are the top priorities of any organizations
success. In todays world, e-recruiting is playing a major role in recruitment policies. In HRMS,
RMS which stands for Recruitment Management System is also playing a major role in
recruitment processes. It is either in-house i.e on-premise or it is hosted in cloud basis. RMS
allows complete applicant tracking and automation of a companys recruitment needs.
Performance record:
This module helps an organization in recording and maintaining the performance records of the
employees on the basis of three parameters namely KPI, competency and behavior. Before the
final decision is made, users can develop their own scenarios in order to analyze the
consequences relating to various conditions in order to determine the budget required for salaries
or bonus payment.
Employee self-service :
It helps in providing the employees with access to their own benefits. ESS (Employee SelfService) solutions allow employees and their managers to view, create and maintain their
information using a web browser. Self-service is a very good way to let employees to find
answers to questions about their paychecks and benefits, as well as update information such as
contact information. ESS also reduces the paperwork burden, while considering and maintaining
the ability to control and approve processes. ESS technology can be used to create a
communication portal that distributes key information about companys policies and benefits to
the entire workforce of the company.
Absence Management :
Within a competitive business environment, the lack of a reliable absence management system
will result in high cost, productivity and risks effects associated with employee absenteeism.
Organizations need to address the complex and diverse requirements that results from managing
absence policies around the globe.
Absence Management enables configuration of transactions and absence plans to eliminate
manual processes, reduce extra costs and to implement requirements according to organizations
policies. Moreover, it also provides full absence visibility for the different roles of the
organization without compromising the individual privacy or company policy concerns.
Analytics :
Using analytics in HRMS, an organization can turn the HRMS data into an implementable and
actionable information and allowing to make better business decisions. One can determine what
data is analyzed and how that data should be presented, and can also build dashboards to help in
getting the required data very easily. With the help of this toolset, one can create, manage,
display and analyze statistics and other metrics, as well as Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
for HR benefits like payroll, recruiting information and more.
Pre-defined analytics and KPIs are delivered as part of the toolset, along with functionality
allowing users to create an unlimited number of analytics of own or modify existing ones.
In addition to these, automatic calculation, storage, alerts relating to KPIs etc are also included.
No doubt, a huge investment irrespective of size has to be made to implement an HRMS system.
Hence the top management and the decision makers have to be convinced of its benefits as the
importance of accuracy and timeliness in operating, planning and controlling activities in HR
cannot be underestimated. In addition to this several administrative and strategic advantages are
there when it comes to using HRMS. However, atleast five reasons are given for which
companies should use HRMS. These are as follows :
(iii) To shift the focus of HR from the processing of transactions to strategic HRM.
According to a HR Survey it was found that the top four reasons for supporting HRMS in
businesses were to improved productivity within HR organization, cost reductions, return on
investment, and to enhanced employee communications. Companies should quickly realize the
amount of cost reductions and efficiency gains that would be possible as early in the
implementation of an HRMS system, so they quickly set up the implementation process. But, the
payback period, or the time it takes to reimburse the investment, may be as short as one to three
years. HRMS contribute to quality/customer satisfaction, reduction of cost and innovation.
Computerized HRMS function enables faster decision making process, faster development, faster
planning and administration of HR because data is much easier to update, store classify, and
analyze. Moreover, while it may be possible to identify many of the relevant costs (e.g., software
and hardware), it is more difficult to quantify the huge amounts of benefits that are waiting to be
derived from an HRMS system. Beyond productivity improvements and cost reduction, HRMS
potentially affect the revenue channels. Establishing direct and objective benefits measures is
more difficult to achieve. No doubt there are also many costs associated with HRMS
implementation like workers need to have personal computers and global Internet connections.
In addition, there are also transition costs caused by movement of traditional HR to an HRMS as
there may be chances of slowdowns, mistakes, and other consequences associated with changing
traditional systems to integrated ones. Hardware costs for servers and software costs for
application programs also cause considerable expenditure to an organization and moreover there
are costs to continuously update the technology as better technology becomes available.
Therefore many companies hesitate before making such an investment. Hence many firms opt
for less complex and expensive systems before transforming their HR departments fully to an
automatic system. Even the ones who have implemented the HRMS system fully are yet to
realize its complete benefits. A survey by Towers Perrin found that whiles 80 per cent of
respondents affirmed employee self-service ability to lower FIR costs, only 5 per cent fully
achieved this objective; another 35 per cent had only partially achieved that objective, and only 3
per cent was accelerating HR's transformation to a strategic partner.
services to form hybrid clouds where non-sensitive functions are always allocated to the
public cloud to maximize the efficiencies on offer.
Cloud HRMS :
Cloud computing usually refers to a utility-based provisioning of all computational resources
over the Internet. Widely used analogies to explain cloud computing are electricity and water
supply systems. Like the Cloud, they provide centralized resources that are accessible for
everyone. Also, in the Cloud you only pay for what you have used. And finally, it is usually
consumed by those who have difficulties to produce necessary resources by themselves or just do
not want to do that. One of the main aspects to define cloud computing is the fact that it is still
evolving and taking its shape. The definitions proposed in the cloud computing community are
often focused on different perspectives and have different baselines.
Cloud technology has revolutionized the IT landscape. In Cloud HRMS no on-premise hardware
is required as all the informations of the HR processes are stored on cloud. Cloud HRMS has lot
of advantages when compared to on premise HRMS because it is very easy to access and also to
implement. HRMS on the cloud saves a business a lot of resources and money and it is the only
reason for gaining popularity. Moreover the installation is faster with less installation hassles and
updation of the system will be much easier. With a lot of SaaS providers focusing on Cloud
solutions, Cloud HRMS has become more user-friendly reducing the eort and time spent on
training the workforce to use these applications. With Cloud HRMS the business can choose to
pay based on factors like period of usage, number of users or the storage required. This makes
Cloud HRMS highly aordable and eective. And as far as business accounts are concerned,
Cloud subscriptions tend to be listed under operational expenditure which not only make a huge
budgetary dierence but also provides free up capital for other crucial business initiatives.
v) Resource Pooling:
Computing resources of the provider are shared across multiple users. Different resources are pooled
in a diverse way so that they can be dynamically assigned and reassigned to serve consumers needs.
vii) Usability:
Normally cloud HRMS platforms provide a simple externally managed environment to hide
deployment and operating details from the user. Cloud computing systems provide APIs to interact
with the environment, which simplifies the development process. Many of these characteristics are
well known from service oriented architecture (SOA), distributed computing, peer-to-peer, etc.
i) Public Clouds :
Public or external clouds are traditional clouds where resources are dynamically provisioned via the
Internet by the off-site third-party providers. These resources are publically available to everyone.
Cloud consumers are charged depending on the quantity used. Examples are Microsoft Azure,
Google App Engine and Amazon Web Services.
Another widely used cloud ontology describes three cloud models depending on provided
Capabilities. These are as follows
i) Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS),
ii) Platform as a Service (PaaS) and
iii) Software as a Service (SaaS).
It is also called a cloud stack because the cloud models are typically built on top of each other. They
can exist independently or in combination with each other. These three infrastructures are described
below.
processes because programmers can focus more on the core logic. Microsoft Azure and Google App
Engine are examples of PaaS.
i) No upfront investments :
Companies usually have to create their own data centres to reliably support large software
systems. Hardware and equipment should be purchased and installed in advance to fulfill the
expected system load. Cloud HRMS eliminates most of these upfront investments. Companies
can simply host their applications on cloud providers data centres, paying only for consumed
resources. This HRMS module is especially attractive for startups or small organizations.
can also result in a bad customer experience, while surplus hardware is inefficient for allocation.
Cloud HRMS provides much more flexible model of capacity. Here, users are able to consume
minimum required capacity at any time as a result the cloud HRMS model is also financially
attractive.
ii) Availability:
Another major concern of cloud HRMS adoption is availability. Even though cloud HRMS
providers offer a high level of availability, outrages such as permanent and temporary occurs in
the cloud platform. Permanent outrage means that the cloud HRMS provider goes out of
business. Secondly, temporary outrage means service unavailability during a relatively short
period of time. The biggest cloud HRMS providers have experienced several problems for the
past several years.
iii) Performance :
While adopting cloud HRMS, there are also some performance implications. Cloud HRMS
platforms should guarantee a fair resource distribution across the applications running on the
same machine. Unlike on-premise system, they can keep their code and data in the same runtime
environment., cloud components communicate via the network. Performance can become a
serious problem especially when the number of request and amount of data increase.
v) Multi-tenancy :
On-premise HRMS packages can be customized in various ways as they are installed for each
customer separately. In SaaS applications, a single copy of software is shared by all users.
Customization of cloud systems is very limited and moreover, it requires an extra development
effort.
viii) Licensing :
A regular software licensing model for commercial software does not match cloud computing,
because licenses commonly restrict the computers on which the software can run. It brings
ambiguities when using supporting commercial software for SaaS applications. Confusing licensing
terms and conditions is the biggest obstacle, especially for large organizations considering the Cloud.
Even if a cloud-enabling HRMS system does not use any supporting software, the system itself might
not have a proper licensing model. Software vendors need to reconsider the way they charge for their
products in order to sell in the Cloud.
On-premise HRMS :
In on-premise HRMS, the HRMS is run and installed on computers on the premises of the
organization rather than from a remote facility. An in-house or a non-hosted solution leaves the
hardware and software under the management and control of the company itself. While there is
technical assistance available from the company that sold the software, the purchasing company
is still responsible for implementing, upgrading and troubleshooting the HRIS software.
Consequently, any hardware problems or security issues fall under their purview. The
information can be conveyed via the Internet or on a company intranet. In-house solutions are
typically more difficult for hackers to penetrate as there is usually no outside point of entry.
Advantages of an On-premise HRMS :
Any human resource management system (HRMS) is only as good as the information it contains
and the ability of the proper people to access that info. Recognizing this fact, many small to midsized companies are now moving away from a simple paper and file system to a computerized
one that allows more flexibility, enhanced accessibility and greater security while still remaining
easy to implement and use. The main advantages for keeping an HRMS system on-premise are
as follows :
i) Versatility
ii) Accessibility
iii) Security
iv) Compliance
v) Ease of implementation and use
The details of these have been discussed below.
i) Versatility:
While the first HRMS that a company obtains is generally sold as complete module, all HRISs
can be customized to fit the HR needs of a company as it grows. For example, on-boarding
activities, training modules and performance review functions can be incorporated into almost
any system. In addition, the scale of the system can also grow with the company and there is
essentially no limit to the number of employee records that can be efficiently stored.
ii) Accessibility:
The ability to access information from any location in the company without having to interact
with the HR staff is one of the most powerful features of an in-house HRIS. Managers can input
hiring, training and counseling info and leave the HR staff with just a gate keeping task.
Similarly, managers can access pay, training and review info about current employees. This ease
of access is doubly beneficial as the manger has the info immediately and the HR staff can
concentrate on other matters as it is not inundated with requests for information.
iii) Security:
These two issues revolve around the actual process of maintaining and accessing the hardware
and the information. In the first case, the physical location of the electronic files is under your
direct control. There is no need to be concerned with third party access as in a cloud-based
solution.
In a similar way, an IT team controls all access to the information. Several levels of permissions
can be granted so that managers, HR staff and employees can obtain the information that they
need directly from the server through any connected site. These connected sites can be made
available on the Internet or, for more security, only on the company intranet.
iv) Compliance:
Remembering and fulfilling the necessary legal requirements when dealing with hiring, firing
and other HR issues is a complicated and, sometimes, fruitless exercise. An HRIS can be
designed to serve as a gatekeeper on any of these processes. A manager or HR person can be
required to fulfill one step in the process before moving to the next. A well designed system can
facilitate any HR operation and guarantee that all corporate and governmental mandates are
observed.
(Verma 2012). On the contrary, Kim et al. 2009 mention in their paper, the inability for the
service providers to scale up their computing infrastructure as customer demands increase
beyond the original expectation. It is therefore important for the enterprises to first understand
the service providers capacity assumption and scale-out plans regarding the computing
infrastructure. Moreover, advantages like access to specialized and advanced technology, easy
integration with other cloud services, rapid updates and upgrades are more or less mentioned in
different papers to be evident within the cloud-based ERP systems.
Enterprises are always insecure regarding data that is stored in the cloud since they do not have
control over security, but depend upon the cloud-based service providers. This will make the
enterprise more vulnerable since cloud has become a honey pot for hackers. Also, a dishonest
employee of the service provider could potentially disrupt the computer system or data (Kim et
al. 2009). A hosted solution is typically prone to the same risks. On the contrary, on-premise
solutions tend to be more secure since the enterprises have more direct control over the systems.
Another risk issue is the performance which includes amongst others the communication
between the clients computer and cloud-based service provider, speed and reliability of the
network. The performance tend to decrease as the number of users and the amount of data
transferred to and from increases (kim et al. 2009). On the contrary to this statement, Rong et al.
2012 mention in their paper that the cloud model simplifies installation, operation and
maintenance of information system while increasing system reliability and efficiency.
Armbrust et al. described they vision of cloud computing, emphasizing elasticity as an important
economic benefit. Motahari-Nezhad et al.added that significantly reduced upfront commitments
and potentially reduced operational and maintenance costs are also important benefits of cloud
computing from business prospective. Chappel elaborated on different opportunities that cloud
computing brings to ISV, including the potential for more sales and easier customer upgrades.
Kim et al.made and extensive research on cloud computing issues, emphasizing security and
availability as the most challenging ones. Security and privacy seems to be one of the mostly
discussed obstacles for cloud computing adoption
We have found several papers that evaluated existing cloud implementations. Rimal et al. made a
comparative technical study of cloud providers and suggested taxonomy for identifying
similarities and differences among them. Later, Louridas discussed the migration of applications
to the Cloud, examining key features of cloud offerings based on the taxonomy from Li et al.
suggested a set of metrics related to application performance and cost in a cloud environment,
comparing cloud providers based on these metrics. The authors concluded that none of the cloud
providers is clearly superior, even though they observed diverse performance and cost across
different platforms.
Babar et al. shared experiences and observations regarding the migration of anexisting system to
a cloud environment, which also included some guidelines and suggestions.
Moreover, Williams and Sears (2008) as well as Campbell (2008) show that there are many
technologies that are created on cloud computing concept, such as Infrastructure as a Service
(IaaS), platform as a Service (PaaS), and Software as a Service (SaaS), it shown the effect of
using internet to create new opportunity to offer new kind of services to organization (Williams
and Sears, 2008) (Campbell, 2008). Additionally, cloud computing is the main concept of using
benefit of internet to create strong network infrastructure, in order to improve the way of delivery
data and application (Scanlon & Wieners, 1999).
While talking about HRMS as a Service, we can relate to Software as a Service (SaaS) platform,
and above all of these concept, let start with cloud computing concept, it play important role as a
key framework for these days online service. Cloud computing is the main key theoretical in our
research; it is style of computing that offer dynamically activities including effective resources as
a service over the internet (Gruman & Knorr, 2008). By doing this, users need not have
knowledge expertise or control skill over the technology infrastructure "in the cloud" that
supports them. Next, the concept of cloud computing incorporated with Software as a Service
(SaaS) trends that create theme of trust on the internet for fulfilling the computing needs of the
users (Campbell, 2008). Nowadays, most of providers turn themselves into cloud by providing
on-demand application as a new channel of service delivery, where application and data of
clients stored on external server and client can accessed through internet.
Cloud computing is the next step in information technology. Researchers studied on cloud
computing concept, which is about secure, reliable, financial sense, etc. As Information Week
analytics cloud computing reports that, most of organizations still have doubt on moving into
cloud, and they not yet decide to move their IT infrastructure into cloud computing platform
(InformationWeek report).
According to John McCarthy, in cloud computing, instead of buying their own computer
systems, companies, individuals, and even governments can share time on a common computing
infrastructure, which consists of interchangeable parts providing computation, data storage, and
communications. If one piece malfunctions or needs updating, programs and data automatically
move to others. Multilevel security prevents users from interfering with one another. This vast
system is cheaper to operate than many individual computers scattered among different
businesses and agencies, because both the hardware and the administrative staff can be utilized
much more efficiently.
In a Mobile Security Survey conducted by Information Week in 2013, over 45% of the
respondent organizations said that they had a data loss within the past 12 months. In the same
survey, over 36% of organizations felt that users forwarding corporate information to nonsupported cloud based storage services such as Dropbox or iCloud to save for reuse or sharing
purposes was their top concern.
According to PwCs 17th Annual Global CEO survey, only 34% of HR organizations are
prepared for the necessary transformative changes they need to make for the future. This survey
further reveals the pressure put on business leaders to transform their HR organizations and drive
business value. Making matters worse are cost constraints, demands to do more with fewer
resources and, align HR with the business. Most HR leaders lack reliable and innovative HRMS
tools to pursue transformative HR strategies that deliver value to their organization.
While many HR leaders have transformed their talent strategy by adopting talent management
systems, only 16% of HR departments currently have their core HRMS application in the cloud.
However, 45% of organizations will move their HRMS to the cloud within the next year, as per
PWC's 2013 HR technology survey.
To make good on the premise to align with the business, HR must modernize and transform. To
be an agent of change, HR needs to choose the right human resource management system in the
cloud to manage the entire employee lifecycle. Disparate, on-premise solutions where core HR
functions like payroll and benefits are processed in separate systems are not integrated with those
used for talent management, workforce optimization and training.
According to a journal entitled An Approach to Cloud Computing in HR Domain for Small
Enterprise Solution, the author concludes that employee is one of the most important assets for
every organization. No doubt HR Management is the guaranteed aspect to achieve competitive
advantage for the enterprise. This paper provided an open-source HR Management technology
framework that can lead to a new era and provides a management technique for efficient
solutions, workings, analysis, associating to Human Resource Management of any enterprise.
Lastly it can be said that the idea of the internet as we know it is quickly surpassing the simple
need to obtain information with ease through web applications, and is now evolving into a
nubers of systems which perform tasks, calculations, accurate searches, and many other complex
operations. Web Services are the perfect example of a solution to the need for a simplistic
system which allows many different technologies to merge and communicate with each other.
Being available to the end user over the internet, Web Services will keep increasing in popularity
due to their functionality but according to the author this popularity will also expose the threat to
the servers hosting them.
Ho: There is no significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
cost.
Ha: There is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of cost.
And,
H1o: There is no significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
data security.
H1a: There is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
data security.
Sample Size :
This refers to the number of items to be selected from the population. This is a major problem
before a researcher because the size of the population should not be very large nor should not be
very small. It should be optimum. For my research a sample size of 35 is taken.
Sampling Method
The sampling technique used in this study was Judgemental and Snowball sampling. It is a nonprobability sampling technique. Judgemental sampling is a type of convenience sampling in
which a researcher selects sample members to conform to some criterions. In this study different
companies working in different verticles were selected. In snowball sampling technique sample
respondents are selected through referral networks and one sample member suggests the other
sample members.
(i) Now, to find out the 1st objective i.e the module of the HRMS which is most preferred by the
organizations the statistical data has been found.
Number of companies that prefer Cloud HRMS : 33
Number of companies that prefer On-premise HRMS : 2
35
30
25
20
Series1
15
10
5
0
Companies preferring Cloud HRMS
Fig : Bar diagram showing companies preference on Cloud HRMS and On-premise HRMS
(a)
Total number of companies using On-Premise HRMS : 6
Total number of companies using On-premise HRMS but prefer to go On Cloud : 5
Total number of companies using On-premise HRMS but doesnot prefer to go On Cloud : 1
Series1
0
Companies using On-Premise HRMS Companies using On-Premise HRMS
but prefer Cloud HRMS
but don't prefer Cloud HRMS
Fig : Bar diagram of companies using On-premise HRMS but showing the tendency to shift
to Cloud.
(b)
Total number of companies using Manual HRMS : 11
Number of companies using Manual HRMS but preferring to go On Cloud : 10
Number of companies using Manual HRMS but preferring to go On-Premise : 1
12
10
6
Series1
4
0
Companies using Manual HRMS but
prefer Cloud HRMS
Fig : Bar diagram of companies using Manual HRMS but have a tendency to shift to Cloud
(ii) To find out the 2nd objective i.e the most influenced factor for using Cloud HRMS the
following analysis have been made.
Sl.
No.
Company Name
1 Federal Mogul
Saviance
2 Technologies
3 Bayer Crop Science
4 Distant Frontiers
5 TNS
6 Pepsico
7 Assotech
Cost
Reductio
n
Low
implementati
on &
investment
risk
HR
transaction
sl functions
made easy
Reliabilit
y
Flexibilit
y
Data
Securit
y
5
4
4
4
5
4
4
3
2
3
4
3
4
4
4
4
4
4
3
4
4
4
3
2
4
4
5
3
4
4
3
2
3
3
3
3
8 Estel
9 360 Realtors
10 Dhoot
RSP Design
11 Consultants
12 OSC
13 Mitsubishi Electric
Olympus Medical
14 System
15 Louis Vuitton
16 We Chat
17 Jeena & Company
18 F6 Finserve
Total
Mea
n
4
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
3
4
4
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
4
3
4
3
4
4
3
4
4
3
4
3
4
4
4
3
4
5
5
4
5
78
3
3
4
4
3
61
3
3
4
3
5
69
3
3
4
4
4
63
4
4
4
3
3
66
3
4
4
4
3
60
4.3
3.4
3.8
3.5
3.6
3.3
To find out the most influenced factor for using Cloud HRMS, the sum of the ratings obtained by
individual factors are calculated and the mean is obtained. The factor with the highest mean is
considered.
From the above analysis it is found that the most influenced factor for which organizations prefer
Cloud HRMS is Cost Reduction.
The above data is analysed graphically :
Ratings
Cost Reduction
78
61
69
Reliability
63
Flexibility
66
Data Security
60
Ratings
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Ratings
(iii) To find out the 3rd objective i.e the most influenced factor for using On-Premise HRMS, the
following analysis has been made:
Sl.
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
Total
Mean
Companies
DTZ
Bacardi India
Asahi India
Glass
Du Pont
Edelman
CHEP
Low
implementation
Cost
& investment
Reduction risk
2
2
2
3
3
1
2
2
12
2
3
2
3
2
15
2.5
HR
transactional
functions
Data
made easy
Reliability Flexibility Security
3
4
3
4
4
3
3
4
4
3
4
4
22
3.7
2
4
3
3
19
3.2
3
4
4
3
20
3.3
5
4
5
5
27
4.5
To find out the most influenced factor for using On-Premise HRMS, the sum of the ratings
obtained by individual factors are calculated and the mean is obtained. The factor with the
highest mean is considered.
From the above analysis it is found that the most influenced factor for which organizations prefer
On-premise HRMS is Data Security.
The above data is analysed graphically :
Ratings
Cost Reduction
12
15
22
Reliability
19
Flexibility
20
Data Security
27
Ratings
30
25
20
15
10
5
Ratings
(iv) To find out the 4th objective i.e to find out if there is any significant difference between
Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of cost. For this analysis the following hypothesis
have been made.
Ho: There is no significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
cost.
Ha: There is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of cost.
The analysis have been carried out by using Z Test in Microsoft Excel and is shown below.
Mean
Known Variance
Observations
Hypothesized Mean Difference
Z
z Critical one-tail
P(Z<=z) two-tail
z Critical two-tail
Variable 1 (Cloud)
4.333333333
0.235294118
18
0
8.263091946
Variable 2(On-premise)
2
0.4
6
1.644853627
2.22
1.959963985
From the above table it is found that the calculated value of Z which is 8.26 is greater than the
critical value of Z which is 1.95. Therefore null hypothesis is rejected.
Hence it is found that there is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on
the basis of cost.
(v) To find out the 5th objective i.e to find out if there is any significant difference between Cloud
and On-premise HRMS on the basis of data security. For this analysis the following hypothesis
have been made.
H1o: There is no significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
data security.
H1a: There is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on the basis of
data security.
The analysis have been carried out by using Z Test in Microsoft Excel and is shown below.
Variable 2(On-premise)
3.333333333
4.5
0.352941
0.3
18
0
-4.421989752
1.644853627
9.7
1.959963985
From the above table it is found that the calculated value of Z which is -4.42 is less than the
critical value of Z which is 1.95 and doesnot lie in the acceptance zone. Therefore null
hypothesis is rejected.
Hence it is found that there is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS on
the basis of data security.
Thirdly, it was found that there is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise HRMS
on the basis of cost.
Fourthly, it has been found that there is a significant difference between Cloud and On-premise
HRMS on the basis of data security.
There have been various studies conducted which proposed that HRMS can contribute for long
term competitive advantage through the integration of HR functions. It has also been found that
many organizations have started shifting their data to cloud and many of them have been
planning to do so. HRMS on the Cloud have evolved considerably since it was first introduced.
Cloud HRMS is now full of features and is self-contained more than evernot just in terms of
data storage systems we once knew them as. But it is also essential for every business to stop and
analyze the way HR functions and processes are run before taking a call to go On Cloud. All this
HRMS tools on the Cloud are what HR professionals can use on a daily basis to revolutionize the
way the world looks at HR.
Recommendations :
In this era of cloud computing, Cloud HRMS is very much important for the achievement of
goals and objectives for the company and it was seen in the study that both Cloud and Onpremise HRMS can play an important role in achieving it. Seeing the benefits of these two
HRMS modules it is suggested to all the companies to implement it in their organizations and not
just use it for administrative or operational purposes but also use it for strategic tasks to achieve
the goals and objectives of the company. Nevertheless, before implementing Cloud or Onpremise HRMS, an organization should see their own cost and benefits. With this keeping in
mind an organization should analyze which module of the HRMS is important for them. Then
accordingly they should go for implementation. HRMS should be used by the HR departments in
the companies to justify their importance. It is also recommended that to gain full benefits of
HRMS, the companies should use all the modules differentially adjusted for their organization.
References :
Books :
(i) Research Methodology, C.R. Kothari
(ii) Armstrong, M. Strategic Human Resource Management: A Guide to Action
Journals :
(i) Deloitte Review, Issue 11, 2012 Cloud Hits the Enterprise
(ii) HeriotWatt University Private Cloud Computing in a government enterprise
(iii) An Oracle Whitepaper, January 2014 Simplifying Cloud Integration
(iv) IJCSI International Journal of Computer Science Issues, Vol. 9, Issue 4, No 2, July 2012
Challenges Involved in Implementation of ERP on Demand Solution: Cloud Computing
(v) Proceedings of the 2012-13course on Advanced Resource Planning, W.J.H. van Groenendaal
(ed.)
Benefits and drawbacks of Cloud-Based versus traditional ERP Systems
by Jiaqi Duan, Parwiz Faker, Alexander Fesak, Tim Stuart
(vi) Above the Clouds: A Berkeley View of Cloud Computing- Michael Armburst
(vii) 15th Ernst & Young Annual Global Information Security Survey 2012.
(viii) The Impact of Human Resource Information Systems: An Exploratory Study in the Public
Sector by Nicholas Beadles, Christopher M. Lowery and Kim Johns.
(viii) Assimilation of the Cloud: Report on the Benefits and Challenges of Adopting Cloud
Technology by Lorraine Morgan, Lero, NUI Galway.
(ix) Cloud computing and its applications in the world of networking by Puja Dhar.
(x) 17th Annual Global CEO survey by PwC.
(xi) Cloud Collaboration: Peer-Production and the Engineering of the internet by Mike Graham.
BIBLIOGRAPHY :
(i) www.oracle.com
(ii) http://www.ibm.com/in/en/
(iii) http://www.eweek.com/
(iv) www.thecloudcomputing.org/2014/
(v) http://www.ieeebigdata.org/2014/
(vi) http://www.insight.bt.com/en/hot-topics/the-cloud
APPENDICES :
Questionnaire
1. Name of the organization.
HR manager name.
Cloud
On-premise
Yes
No
Out of the three systems, which system do you like the most ?
Cloud
If you are using cloud HRMS, then what are the benefits? (Give rating 1 to 5, 5 being highest)
On-premise
Manual
Did cloud based HRMS has low implementation and investment risk?
Did cloud based HRMS made your HR transactional functions easier or difficult?
Manual
If you are using on-premise HRMS, then what are the benefits? (Give rating 1 to 5, 5 being highest)
Did on-premise based HRMS has low implementation and investment risk?
Did on-premise based HRMS made your HR transactional functions easier or difficult?