Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wind Energy
In MEXICO
Project financed by
The TECH4CDM project, developed over 2008 and 2009, and financed by
the European Union under the Sixth Framework Programme of R&D, has
as its primary goal, the promotion of renewable and efficient energy
technologies, paying special attention to overcoming technological
barriers, as well as the analysis of the Clean Development Mechanisms
(CDM) of the Kyoto Protocol that may assist in projects based on wind
energy, cogeneration, solar thermal and rural electrification through
renewable energies.
Both European and Latin American institutions participate in the
project, which is coordinated by the Spanish Institute for Energy
Diversification and Saving (IDAE). The technological partners
participating in the project include: the European Photovoltaic Industry
Association (EPIA), the Spanish Wind Energy Association (AEE) and the
Solar Thermal Industry Association (ASIT). In the case of cogeneration,
the participation of COGEN Spain is essential, as well as that of the
Spanish Office for Climate Change (OECC) for the part related to the
CDM.
The 5 countries where the project activities are being carried out are
Argentina, Chile, Ecuador, Mexico and Peru, and in each of these, local
partners contribute, assuring the maximum use of these collaborating
forces. Participating entities include: the Secretariat of Energy and the
Industrial Union of Argentina, the National Energy Commission (CNE) of
Chile, the Ministry of Electricity and Renewable Energy (MEER) of
Ecuador, the National Commission for the Efficient Use of Energy
(CONUEE) of Mexico and the Centre for Energy Conservation and
Environment (CENERGIA) of Peru.
Project activities include the completion of a series of studies of the
technologies situation in each country. This document summarizes the
main features.
More information at www.tech4cdm.com
Contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
MEXICO............................................................................................................ 4
MEXICAN ENERGY CONTEXT........................................................................ 5
ANALYSIS OF THE WIND ENERGY SECTOR .............................................. 14
RESULTS ....................................................................................................... 24
REFERENCES................................................................................................ 26
1.
MEXICO
MEXICO
2000
2005
2007
2008
General Data
Population, total (millions)
Population growth (annual %)
Surface area (sq. km) (thousands)
97,97
103,09
105,28
106,35
1,4
1,0
1,0
1,0
1.964,4
1.964,4
1.964,4
1.964,4
1.533
1.713
..
..
3,9
4,1
..
..
1.794
1.968
..
..
581,43
846,99
1.022,82
1.085,95
28
34
36
37
68
62
60
59
6,6
3,2
3,2
1,8
12,1
4,4
4,7
6,5
31
27
28
28
33
29
30
30
17.942
20.945
24.686
..
Economy
GDP (current US$) (billions)
Agriculture, value added (% of GDP)
Industry, value added (% of GDP)
Services, etc., value added (% of GDP)
GDP growth (annual %)
Inflation, GDP deflator (annual %)
Exports of goods and services (% of GDP)
Imports of goods and services (% of GDP)
Foreign direct investment, net inflows
(BoP, current US$) (millions)
2.
By the end of 2008, the installed capacity of renewable energy sources totalled
nearly 2,000 MW of power. This includes wind, small scale (less than 30 MW)
hydroelectric, geothermal, biomass and biogas energies. Renewable sources
represented 3.3% share of the total Mexican energy matrix. The greatest share
belonged to fossil fuels at 75.3% followed by large-scale hydroelectric power
generation, with 19%. The energy matrix is strongly dependent on fossil fuels:
The National Commission for Efficient Energy Use (Spanish acronym CONUEE):
The National Commission for Efficient Energy Use is a technically and operationally
independent decentralised administrative agency of the Ministry of Energy. Its
purpose is energy savings and efficient use, as well as promoting the use of
renewable energies; it serves as a technical agency in the area of the sustainable
energy use.
Energy Regulatory Commission (Spanish acronym CRE):
The transparent, impartial and efficient regulation of the gas, refined hydrocarbon
products and electrical industries, creating a feeling of confidence that encourages
investment in production, promoting healthy competition, fostering adequate
coverage and satisfying the need for reliability, quality and safety in the supply and
provision of services, at competitive prices, in the interest of the users.
Federal Electricity Commission (Spanish acronym CFE):
The Federal Electricity Commission is a company owned by the Mexican government
that generates, transmits, distributes and sells electrical energy to nearly 27.1
million customers nearly 80 million inhabitants adding more than one million
new clients a year.
Electrical Research Institute (Spanish acronym IIE):
The IIEs objective is to be a reference institute for innovation at the national level
with scientists and technologist of recognised prestige, whose results promote the
sustainable development of the country.
Following up on this basic idea, and with the aim of achieving the overall
development of the country, with respect to energy, the established goal is to ensure
a reliable, quality and competitively priced supply of the energy services demanded
by consumers. To do this, the proposal is to promote efficient energy use, as well as
the use of technologies that allow the environmental impact generated by traditional
fossil fuels to be reduced. Thus, the plan is to reconcile societys energy
consumption needs with caring for natural resources.
In response to the threats from climate change and to energy security, the Mexican
government has made a commitment to a transition of the energy in the energy
matrix.
This energy transition consists of a change in the energy sectors focus. This process
will lead to a better use of fossil fuels and the development and promotion of
renewable energies. Its aim is to diversify primary energy sources and mitigate the
impact on the environment as the result of the reduction in greenhouse gases caused
by the use of fossil fuels which, currently, are the main energy source at the
international level.
These ideas are the general guidelines governing the National Development Plan
(Spanish acronym PND) and they, along with the Energy Sector Programme, establish
the basic objectives in the matter of the energy efficiency and renewable energy
policies. The most relevant aspects are mentioned below.
The National Development Plan is based on the Planning Law and on Vision Mexico
2030 and establishes the national objectives, strategies and priorities that should
guide the government's actions during the current term. To do this, the Plan is
structured around five guiding principals, each one having its own objectives and
strategies, and assumes as its basic premise the search for humane sustainable
development. The five guiding principals upon which the PND is based cover
economic, social, political and environmental spheres.
The strategies be followed with respect to renewable energies included in the PND
propose promoting the efficient use of energy, as well as the use of technologies that
allow the environmental impact caused by traditional fossil fuels to be reduced by
taking advantage of the great potential Mexico has in the area of renewable
energies. These strategies are:
On the other hand, the Energy Sector Programme 2007-2012, which was created
based on the PND, is essentially based on three points: to ensure the supply of the
energy services required by the economy; to strengthen the sector's publicly-owned
companies in order to improve the opportunity for and quality of the supply; and to
intensively promote energy efficiency and renewable energies with the aim of
reducing the environmental impact caused by the use of fossil fuels.
In addition, Mexico has specific strategies and programmes for the renewable
energies sector and the energy transition.
Special Programme for Using Renewable Energies:
The objectives to be achieved by 2012 in the area of renewable energy are
established in the Special Programme for Using Renewable Energies", defined in the
Law on the Use of Renewable Energies and the Financing of the Energy Transition and
its Regulations (Spanish acronym LAERFTE), and prepared and coordinated by the
Ministry of Energy:
Cross-cutting
Sustainable
Housing
Programme
it
provides
for
the
10
The Law on the Use of Renewable Energies and the Financing of the Energy
Transition and its Regulations (LAERFTE)
11
exploitation to its consumption. The most relevant aspects of the law are listed
below:
The drafting of the National Programme for Sustainable Energy Use (Spanish
acronym PRONASE).
The creation of the Advisory Council for Sustainable Energy Use, whose purpose is
to assess compliance with the objectives, strategies, actions and goals
established in the PRONASE.
A Registry of Funds and Trust Funds that were created by the federal government
receive federal resources or are guaranteed by the federal government and
whose purpose is to support sustainable energy use.
The definition of criteria for identifying users with a high energy consumption
pattern.
The creation and publication of a list of the equipment and devices requiring
energy to operate that contains technical information about their energy
consumption.
12
of both the consumption and the processes avoided as a result of the sustainable
use of energy.
The inclusion of short messages promoting efficient energy use on bills and
invoices from energy sector companies and institutions.
13
14
Annual installed capacity by region 2003-2009 (Source: Global Wind Energy Council).
Europe leads the world market in wind energy, both in what is referred to as
installed potential as well as the industry of the sector, and we can currently confirm
that wind farms have been created in practically every geographical area of the
continent. The production of electrical energy in systems connected to the network
through wind energy is being consolidated in many European countries as a way of
diversifying the current energy structure.
According to the annual report of BTM Consulting, there is a predicted increase in
wind energy potential in Europe, from the period of 2007 to 2011, of some 59,150
MW, followed by North America, with an increase of some 33,050 MW over the same
period. In reviewing the data from the International Energy Agency for the year 2005,
it is found that Spain was predicted to be the second country in the world in terms of
largest percentage of energy demand covered by wind energy. This prediction was
verified as Spain in fact reached 9.5 % in the year 2007, only surpassed by Denmark
having a value of 20.10%.
15
Today the wind energy industry has surpassed the R&D stage, operating in an
industrial manner, with technical reliability, economic efficiency and virtually no
environmental impact.
The current series machines have considerable power (of some 850 to 3000 kW),
permitting the wind farms to reach important total production potentials, with
significant levels.
Chart of the evolution of wind turbines over the period from 1982-2006
There are different supplemental pricing systems for the energy retribution.
Regulatory frameworks should offer adequate remuneration so as to guarantee the
economic viability of the projects. The regulatory frameworks include:
Feed-in Tariffs (FIT): Renewable energies are integrated into the electrical
system with a guaranteed rate during a determined period. The market sales
price depends on the requirements of the electrical system, based on an
initial price. In addition, the FIT may offer incentives added to the average
price of the electric power market (in the case of Spain). Within the FIT
system, there are two options: remuneration depending on production of the
wind farm (the case of Germany and France) and independent of the farm
production level. This is the case in Spain where remuneration may be a
regulated price or is set at the rate of the Electric Power Market.
16
Premium
Tax
credits
20.000
Installed in 2007
Installed in 2006
Premium
Installed in 2005
15.000
MW
Total at 31/12/2004
5.000
Premium
Green
Certificates
Premium
Green
Certificates
Tax
credits
10.000
0
GERMANY
EEUU
SPAIN
INDIA
CHINA
DENMARK
ITALY
FRANCE
UK
17
In addition, those countries having certificate mechanisms had energy sale prices
that were higher than those countries with Feed-in Tariff systems, without having
significantly more renewable energy generation facilities.
The specific investment in wind farms (/MW) has progressively decreased by almost
half over the past 20 years, due to the increase in size, the standardization of
products caused by increasing demand and improved technologies. However, over
recent years this trend has changed, with an increase being observed in this
parameter due to, on the one hand, the fact that the increased size has not absorbed
the cost reduction, and on the other hand, due to the increased complexity required
of the machines for network integration. It is also important to note the increase in
steel costs which according to current predictions will increase at a rate equal or
above 3%, driven by a strong increase in international demand.
Current situation:
Different areas of Mexico have been identified as having potential for exploiting wind
energy in order to generate power. The most important among these include the
area of the Isthmus of Tehuantepec in the state of Oaxaca, La Rumorosa in the state
of Baja California, and areas in the states of Zacatecas, Hidalgo, Veracruz, Sinaloa
and the Yucatan Peninsula. By the end of 2009, the installed wind power generation
capacity surpassed 250 MW of power, while the authorised capacity is some 2,300
MW, so there is still a part of the capacity that has yet to be developed.
18
(800-1500) MW
Lpez Mateos
Zacatecas
Mazatln
(1000-2000) MW
Veracruz
(1000-1500) MW
(1000-1500) MW
Cozumel
Cancn
Hidalgo
Potential sites
Installed projects (85.42 MW)
Projects in the bidding stage (200 MW)
La Venta III
100 MW)
La Venta II
OAXACA I
(83 MW)
(100 MW)
OAXACA II,III,IV
(300 MW) Isthmus of
Tehuantepec
(2000-3000 MW)*
19
20
connection contract opens up the possibility for self-sufficient type permit holders
supplying electricity exclusively to municipal, state or federal facilities to use the
power line connection contract with any kind of renewable energy source (biogas,
biomass, geothermal, etc.), since formerly it was only used for intermittent type
renewable sources (sun, wind and water).
Open Season for Reserving Transmission Capacity:
This began when it was discovered that the transport grids lacked the capacity to
absorb all of the wind generated power in the Oaxaca area. Together, the CRE, the
CFE and the SENER agreed to hold an Open Season (Spanish acronym TA) to
determine the transmission capacity that private developers were willing to reserve
under firm and irrevocable conditions, in order to have all of the elements required
to justify authorising the resources needed for a financed public works project to be
carried out by the CFE beginning 2009.
Technological Barriers:
The technologies of wind energy are mature and well developed, particularly in more
developed countries where the market has reached a level of maturity. In the case of
Mexico, it is a new market in which there are technological barriers which may
impede its growth. The following is an analysis of the main barriers detected:
A lack of adapting the wind turbines to each areas specific wind regimes. In the area
of Oaxaca, in particular, winds are very strong and constant, at times exceeding the
cut out wind speed for the machines which occurs at 25 m/s. These winds, in
addition to hindering the machines operational and maintenance tasks, increase the
possibility of early deterioration.
Another design aspect to be considered is that of the significant rate of lightening in
this area. Currently, the protective systems are not adequate to always protect the
machines and they may be seriously damaged.
21
Network integration:
The main problem to be solved is that of integrating into the system, a considerable
generation contingent with incorporation priority, whose availability is random, free
of location and fragmented, and who in situations of instability, will disconnect from
the same, requiring the rest of the generation to increase its participation share in
the complementary system services, so as to ensure proper functioning.
Additionally, the fact that wind farms are generally located in areas with low
population densities must be considered, as these areas typically have weak
electrical supplies requiring reinforcement and improvement. Further, the Peruvian
electrical system is radial and not very redundant.
The emergence of voltage dips and the control of reactive energy are also particular
features of network integration.
The wind energy market in Mexico is a recent one, implying the existing need for
various services related to this technology, including the need for engineering,
installation and maintenance services.
In addition to the scarcity of services, there is also a lack of qualified project
developers, installers and maintainers. In other words, the wind market is not a
developed and mature market.
Other barriers
Regulations:
22
Land possession:
The property regimen existing in the area of the greatest wind power potential,
Oaxaca, and dispersed nature of the property owners has complicated the acquisition
of land by the wind power company promoters.
23
4.
RESULTS
Proposed measures
Network integration:
The use of predictive measures. There are in fact, different methods of prediction,
in order to estimate a value for the wind energy, and these methods vary between
the use of statistical models and physical models, or a combination of both.
Similarly, the prediction may be based on the estimation of production for a set of
wind farms, or it may use various methods of prediction for one individual farm, with
the goal of improving the understanding and therefore, increasing the results.
It is also necessary to coordinate with the electrical companies and wind farm
promoters in order to solve the problems resulting from wind farm network
integration. An example of effective coordination with the system operator is the
control centre of renewable energies (CECRE), created by the Spanish Electricity
Network. This centre is unique in the world and it controls and coordinates the
generation of all of the producers of wind energy installed in Spain.
With regards to the adequacy of the voltage dips, it is recommended the use of
technology that complies with the determined requirements offers a response to such
dips in the wind farms. Countries having advanced uses of these technologies, as is
the case in Europe, have defined these requirements.
24
Finally, the control of reactive energy may be carried out through the retributive
supplements for the maintenance of the reactive regulation.
Reinforcing the technical abilities of the agents in the sector through training
courses. For this, reliance on the experience of European countries with increased
knowledge is essential. For example, the promotion of alliances so as to permit
technological transfer between international engineering companies and the local
engineering companies would be a useful measure. As it has been said, work is being
undertaken to create a Regional Centre of Wind Power Technology (CERTE) located
in Oaxaca. This infrastructure will allow the development of local and national
capacities.
The regulatory frameworks should facilitate the connection of the installations to the
electric system, besides offer adequate remuneration so as to guarantee the
economic viability of the projects. Any type of regulatory framework should establish
the following minimums:
Predictable: Allowing for the prediction of the investment during the service
life of the facility.
25
5.
REFERENCES
Estrategia
Nacional
para
la
Transicin
Energtica
aprovechamiento
26