CA Case Law Finder (2008-2012)

How to read citation:
Case name, SP/CR/CV No., date of

promulgation, volume O.G. page
COURT OF APPEALS CASES
Arnold vs. Torio, SP No. 84590,

October 27, 2010, 108 O.G. 3798
Arsenio vs. Local Civil Registrar
Bauang, La Union, CV No. 72841,
June 22, 2010, 108 O.G. 4784
Atinaja
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines, CR No. 30510, February
25, 2010, 108 O.G. 5917
January-December 2012
7TH Security & Investigation Service
Inc. vs. National Labor Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
109097,
January 28, 2010, 108 O.G. 4466
A
Abad-Bersola vs. Fe, SP No.
105712, July 9, 2010, 108 O.G.
6231
B
Baclas vs. National Labor Relations
Commission, SP No. 111502, July
20, 2010, 108 O.G. 518
Baesa vs. Bulalacao, CV No. 87678,
March 31, 2008, 108 O.G. 1788
Abon vs. Abon, CV No. 68353, May

25, 2010, 108 O.G. 2745
Bank of the Philippine Islands vs.

Northeast Equipment Corporation,
CV No. 79450, July 27, 2010, 108
O.G. 1052
Ajinomoto Philippines Corp. vs.

National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No,
113311,
October 27, 2010, 108 O.G. 1274
Bernal-Legaspi vs. Legaspi, Jr., CV

No. 90865, April 23, 2010, 108 O.G.
2614
Alisasis vs. Dulalia, CV No. 88930,

February 27, 2008, 108 O.G. 1646
Bertumen vs. de Leoz, CV No.

66013, June 28, 2010, 108 O.G.
4691
Aquil vs. Asencio, SP No. 98221,

February 27, 2008, 108 O.G. 1651
No.
Binag vs. National Labor Relations

Commission, SP No. 112043, March
28, 2010, 108 O.G. 4593
Arbues vs. Arbues, CR No. 92271,

November 18, 2010, 108 O.G. 1159
Boehringer Ingelheim (Phils.) Inc.

vs. Julaton, CV No. 70589, January
28, 2010, 108 O.G. 5799
Araneta vs. Atalpao,

95215, March 8, 2007
SP
Arenas-Gonzales vs. Local Civil

Registrar of Calasiao, Pangasinan,
CV No. 84552, December 12, 2007,
108 O.G. 3943
Bomagat vs. Bacani, CV No. 92507,

September 8, 2010, 108 O.G. 728
Page 1 of 29
BPI Family Savings Bank , Inc. vs.

Vilfran Liner, Inc., CV No. 79847,
December 20, 2010, 108 O.G. 4797
C
California Manufacturing Co., Inc.
vs V. Capemco Trade Corporation,
CV No. 62414, May 19, 2010, 108
O.G. 1038
Castillo vs. Judge of RTC Paranaque
City, SP No. 90018, February 4,
2010, 108 O.G. 2013
Celones vs. Celones, CV No. 73571,
November 29, 2007, 108 O.G. 3261
Ebron
vs
Republic
of
the
Philippines, CV No. 91241, October
22, 2010, 108 O.G. 3793
Environmental
Compliance
Consultants
International
Corporation vs. National Labor
Relations Comission (2nd Division)
[SP No. 97801. June 26, 2007]
Espiloy vs. Repizo, CV No. 74550,
May 25, 2010, 108 O.G. 1374
Estrella vs. Mesa, CV No. 93673,
March 7, 2011, 108 O.G. 5062
Estrera vs. Magtangob, CV No.
85045, October 22, 2010, 108 O.G.
3678
D
De Abriol vs. Tan, CV No. 78898,
December 30, 2010, 108 O.G. 1501
Eustaquio-Dimaguila vs. Republic

of the Philippines, CV No. 79452,
November 29, 2007, 108 O.G. 3249
De Vera vs. RTC Sorsogon City, SP

No. 107099, April 26, 2010, 108
O.G. 2739
Exaltacion vs. Fajardo, SP No.

112814, February 9, 2011, 108
O.G. 4961
delos Reyes vs. Lacson, CV No.

92017, March 19, 2010, 108 O.G.
4585
Dimagiba vs. Escubio-Samar, SP

No. 94934, March 31, 2008, 108
O.G. 1878
Diray vs. Marcos, SP No. 91653,
June 8, 2010, 108 O.G. 3013
Dorao vs. Rudio, SP No. 111866,
July 28, 2010, 108 O.G. 3673
Filweb System Technology vs

National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
111641,
October 28, 2010, 108 O.G. 3804
Franco vs. Macalino, CV No. 91635,
September 15, 2010, 108 O.G.
1383
Fung vs. Devanadera, SP No.
111289, August 26, 2010, 108 O.G.
3401
E
G
Page 2 of 29
Genetic Farm, Inc. vs. National

Labor Relations Commission, SP
No. 109291, May 28, 2010, 108
O.G. 2999
Gonzales vs. Penta Capital Finance
Corporation,
CV
No.
70566,
October 22, 2010, 108 O.G. 3681
Guerra vs. Pasia, SP No. 95994,
September 12, 2008, 108 O.G.
1882
Guiao vs. Fe, CV No. 71643, March
30, 2010, 108 O.G. 6129
Lomotan vs. Miranda, CV No.

88177, February 12, 2010, 108
O.G. 4473
Lonzanida vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
87306,
November 15, 2010, 108 O.G.
3938, 108 O.G. 4291
M
Mabanglo-Villeta vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 93772, March
28, 2011, 108 O.G. 5068
MacMar Shelis Taxi vs. National
No. 106024, July 29, 2010, 108
O.G. 1062
I
Ileto vs. Rizal Commercial Banking
Corporation, CV No. 86634, January
31, 2008, 108 O.G. 1486
Magsipoc
vs.
National
Labor
Relations
Comission,
SP
No.110250, May 12, 2010, 108 O.G.
19
Malubay
vs.
National
Labor
Relations Commission, SP No.
109096, July 13, 2010, 108 O.G.
524
J
Jenia Land Ventures vs. Register of
Deeds of Baguio City, CV No.
64772, August 17, 2010, 108 O.G.
1270
L
Lajarca vs. Anchor Savings Bank,
CV No. 93478, May 24, 2011, 108
O.G. 5201
Laplana vs. Republic of the
29, 2010, 108 O.G. 6550
Manahan vs. Belmonte, SP No.

108456, August 17, 2010, 108 O.G.
3539
Maniquiz vs. Dumayas, SP No.
100647, January 27, 2010, 108
O.G. 5792
Mendoza vs Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 90934, July 30,
2010, 108 O.G. 3394
Mendoza
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines, CR No. 32463, May 28,
2010, 108 O.G. 3005
Page 3 of 29
Meneses vs. Cruz, CV No. 76151,

January 15, 2010, 108 O.G. 5670
Metropolitan
Bank
and
Trust
Company vs. Arnaldo, CV No.
93561, November 15, 2010, 108
O.G. 3932, 108 O.G. 4284
Metropolitan
Bank
and
Trust
Company vs. Caf Mei, Inc., CV No.
86123, October 22, 2010, 108 O.G.
6542
Montes
vs.
Civil
Service
Commission, SP No. 101960, May
27, 2010, 108 O.G. 2164
People of the Philippines vs. Dela

Cruz, CR No. 26974 September 17,
2010, 108 O.G. 739
People of the Philippines vs. dela
Cruz, CR-H.C. No. 03807, July 15,
2010, 108 O.G. 1045
People of the Philippines vs.
Esogon, CV No. 32208, June 29,
2010, 108 O.G. 4790
People of the Philippines vs. Figer,
CR No. 32143, April 26, 2010, 108
O.G. 4680
Gavino, CR No. 32686, June 23,
2010, 108 O.G. 381
P
Pait vs. Denso, SP No. 103488,
March 12, 2010, 108 O.G. 6018
Paneda vs. Javarata, CV No. 87597,
January 31, 2008, 108 O.G. 1482
Parallag vs. Civil Registrar of
Cauayan, Isabela, CV No. 84761,
September 20, 2010, 108 O.G.
6455
Tugano, CR No. 25964, November
30, 2006,
People of the Philippines vs. Celis,
CR No. 32671, June 21, 2011, 108
O.G. 5373
People of the Philippines vs. de
Jesus, CR No. 04365, June 14, 2011,
108 O.G. 5363
People of the Philippines vs. Del
Rosario, CR No. 32175, September
17, 2010, 108 O.G. 829

Labutap, CR No. 31363, January 18,
2010, 108 O.G. 5675
Liwanag, CR-HC No. 03250, March
22, 2010, 108 O.G. 2457
Manalang, CR-H.C. No. 03644,
December 8, 2010, 108 O.G. 4122
Maraorao,
CR
No.
32677,
September 17, 2010, 108 O.G.
1152
People of the Philippines vs. Paje,
CR No. 31750, August 27, 2010,
108 O.G. 3545
People of the Philippines vs. Plaza,
CR No. 31568, June 27, 2011, 108
O.G. 5492
Page 4 of 29

Poblete, Sr., CR No. 30722,
February 26, 2010, 108 O.G. 6010
People of the Philippines vs. Robles,
CR HC No. 03955, June 27, 2011,
108 O.G. 5504
Santiago, CR HC No. 03711, June
11, 2011, 108 O.G. 5206
R
Ramirez vs. Dayag, SP No. 112757,
September 15, 2010, 108 O.G. 732
Ramos vs. Manotoc Realty, Inc., CV
No. 88141, March 12, 2010, 108
O.G. 2316
Ramos vs. Office of the Clerk of
Court, RTC, CV No. 73306, May 13,
2010, 108 O.G. 145
People of the Philippines vs. Sosa,

CR No. 31268, June 29, 2010, 108
O.G. 3389
Ramos vs. Soriano, SP No. 111606,

December 29, 2010, 108 O.G. 1496
Pearedondo vs. National Labor

112930, August 11, 2010, 108 O.G.
1264
Rizal
Commercial
Banking
Corporation vs. Kwong, SP No.
107270, August 3, 2010, 108 O.G.
1072
Petralba
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines,
CR
No.
32117,
November 17, 2010, 108 O.G. 1283
Philippine National Bank vs. de

Castro, SP No. 107777, July 23,
2010, 108 O.G. 3534
Pilar Development Corporation vs.
Guray, SP No. 103086, June 16,
2010, 108 O.G. 3135
Pimentel vs. Tiu, SP No. 99751,
April 30, 2010, 108 O.G. 6136
Sabado
vs
People
of
the
Philippines, SP No. 109963, June
17, 2010, 108 O.G. 4600
San
Adres
vs.
Supreme
Transportation Liner, Inc., CV No.
93005, January 27, 2011, 108 O.G.
4954
Santos vs. Santos, SP No. 112686,
November 26, 2010, 108 O.G. 1490
Sapulno
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines,
SP
No.
99948,
September 9, 2010, 108 O.G. 6340
Q
Quick N Hearty vs. National Labor
105833, August 27, 2010, 108 O.G.
6236
Security and Safety Corporation of

the Philippines vs. Mupas, SP No.
107658, December 20, 2010, 108
O.G. 4127
Quing vs. Capatan, CV No. 85066,

November 29, 2007, 108 O.G. 3257
Page 5 of 29
Sicat vs. Province of Tarlac, CV No.

85951, October 11, 2010, 108 O.G.
6460
Sinad vs. Natividad, CV No. 85030,
February 24, 2010, 108 O.G. 2155
Solidbank Corporation vs. Daracan,
CV No. 78783, February 5, 2010,
108 O.G. 5912
T
Valdez vs. Maramba, CV No. 61949,

May 26, 2010, 108 O.G. 276
Virgilio vs. Villanueva, CV No.
76131, July 28, 2010, 108 O.G. 716
2100 Customs Brokers, Inc. vs.
Insurance Company North America,
SP No. 83014, January 28, 2008,
107 O.G. 3882
Tahanlangit vs. Arboleda, SP No.

106128, March 10, 2010, 108 O.G.
2159
A
Tallano vs. Rementilla-Gongon, CV
No. 83803, September 17, 2010,
108 O.G. 6348
Tokyo Marine Malayan Insurance
Co., Inc. vs. Geologistics, Ltd., SP
No. 104933, November 30, 2010,
108 O.G. 4116
Tumaneng II vs. Narciso, SP No.
107000, March 12, 2010, 108 O.G.
2310
Ty vs. Corporal, CV No. 78205, July
27, 2010, 108 O.G. 711
U
Uy vs. How, SP No. 104101, June 8,
2010, 108 O.G. 3130
Uy vs. National Labor Relations
Commission, SP No. 109166, July
29, 2010, 108 O.G. 1066
V
Abuan vs. Orlanes, CV No. 83092,

March 16, 2007, 107 O.G. 1104
Agro Commercial Security Service
Agency, Inc. vs. National Labor
86637, November 11, 2008, 107
O.G. 5873
Aleda vs. Torres, CV No. 70767,
May 9, 2007, 107 O.G. 2445
Alimorom vs. Secretary of the
Department
of
the
Agrarian
Reform, SP No. 91289, March 15,
2007, 107 O.G. 2096
Alvarez vs. Manalansan, CV No.
82891, January 15, 2007, 107 O.G.
1444
Aragon vs. Lacsina, CV No. 79921,
February 29, 2008, 107 O.G. 4027
Aralar vs. Fernandez, SP No. 92812,
September 18, 2008,
107 O.G.
4973
Page 6 of 29
Arcega vs. Garcia, CV No. 86017,

May 30, 2008, 107 O.G. 4665
Asperilla vs. Flores, CV No. 85313,
September 12, 2008, 107 O.G.
3616
Aure vs. Republic of the Philippines,
CV No. 79110, August 29, 2006,
107 O.G. 412
Bongat vs. RTC Antipolo City,

Branch 74, SP No. 89070, June 25,
2008, 107 O.G. 4846
C
Centeno vs. Bangko Rural ng
Kalumpit, Inc., CV No. 80326, May
30, 2008, 107 O.G. 4661
Chan vs. Sio, CV No. 60576, March
6, 2006, 107 O.G. 2750
B
Bacud vs. National Labor Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
92493,
February 29, 2008, 107 O.G. 4185
Ballesteros
vs.
University
of
Pangasinan, SP No. 90500, April 28,
2006, 107 O.G. 3133
Baltazar vs. Baltazar, SP No. 94845,
July 31, 2006, 107 O.G. 3243
Barroga
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines,
CR
No.
30543,
December 12, 2007, 107 O.G. 5720
Behavior Modifications, Inc., vs.
Fabros, SP No. 93728, May 11,
2006, 107 OG 2882
Berones vs. Cruz, SP No. 96588,
March 13, 2007, 107 O.G. 1622
Bersamin vs. Provincial Sheriff of
Abra, CV No. 70934, June 29, 2007,
107 O.G. 241
Binayug
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines, CR No. 29405, January
17, 2007, 107 O.G. 1784
Chua vs. Sayo, Jr., SP No. 77648,

January 31, 2008, 107 O.G. 3878
Combined Blue Dragon Security
and Services vs. National Labor
Relations Commission, SP. No.
98481, August 29, 2008, 107 O.G.
4969
Comoco
Incorporation
vs.
Gumangan, CV No. 78869, May 22,
2007, 107 O.G. 880
Coronel vs. Reyes, CV No. 68530,
May 7, 2007, 107 O.G. 330
Cortez vs. Dizon, CV No. 84462,
January 17, 2008, 107 O.G. 3371
Creus vs. United Methodist Church,
CV No. 75434, April 2, 2007, 107
O.G. 1289
Cucio vs. Arcilla, CV No. 79316,
February 29, 2008, 107 O.G. 4032
Cuevas
vs.
Republic
of
the
Philippines, CV No. 86777, May 31,
2007, 107 O.G. 326
D
Page 7 of 29
D.G. Jones and Partners Phils., Inc.

vs.
National
Labor
Relations
Commission, SP No. 94470, July 31,
2008, 107 O.G. 4965
De Castro vs. Ombudsman, SP No.
93960, May 30, 2006, 107 O.G.
3234
De Leon vs. Flores, SP No. 92897,
May 17, 2006, 107 O.G. 3142
Flores vs. People of the Philippines,

CR No. 30002, September 7, 2006,
107 O.G. 3366
Fontillas vs. Abrigo, CV No. 84901,
March 13, 2007, 107 O.G. 2764
Fumar vs. Commission on Audit, SP
No. 91814, March 23, 2007, 107
O.G. 2364
G
Dela Vega vs. Bismark, CV No.

69361, July 31, 2006, 107 OG 1629
Development
Bank
of
the
Philippines vs. Register of Deeds of
Isabela, CV No. 75832, July 24,
2007, 107 O.G. 1462
Garcia vs. National Labor Relations

Commission,
SP
No.
90953,
February 28, 2007, 107 O.G. 873
Garcia vs. Garcia, CV No. 75205,
March 9, 2007, 107 O.G. 4
Escoto vs. Bautista, CV No. 86690,

December 14, 2007, 107 O.G. 970
La Salle College International vs.

National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
111415,
January 29, 2010, 107 O.G. 6258
Everlast International Placement,

Inc., vs. National Labor Relations
Comission, SP No. 93548, February
28, 2007, 107 O.G. 2257
Labaro vs. National Labor Relations

Commission,
SP
No.
93892,
September 8, 2006, 107 O.G. 3468
F
Fernandez vs. Carungi, CV No.
85718, August 17, 2006, 107 O.G.
3460
Filipinas Agri-Milling Corporation vs.
RTC, Branch 62, Gumaca, Quezon,
SP No. 87943, January 31, 2008,
107 O.G. 3632
Land Bank of the Philippines vs. del

Rosario, SP No. 95559, March 29,
2007, 107 O.G. 1109
Libas vs. Candelaria, CV No. 82944,
April 26, 2007, 107 O.G. 1458
Lucero vs. Marcelo, SP No. 85390,
August 24, 2007, 107 O.G. 5239
Fianza vs. Abance, CV No. 80159,

October 11, 2007, 107 O.G. 5405
M
Macatangay vs. Republic of the
15, 2007, 107 O.G. 18
Page 8 of 29
Manubay
vs.
National
Labor
98369, September 13, 2007, 107
O.G. 6009
Perez-Martinez vs. Arborvitae Plains
Montessori, Inc., CV No. 90036,
January 29, 2010, 107 O.G. 6604
Mendoza vs. Republic of the
14, 2007, 107 O.G. 959
Mijares vs. Gana, SP No. 86858,
June 25, 2008, 107 O.G. 4842
N
Naigan vs. Bautista, SP No. 95933,
February 28, 2007, 107 O.G. 2252
Newborn Food Products, Inc. vs.
National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
102260,
October 28, 2008, 107 O.G. 5091
O
Ongking vs. Avelino, CV No. 84775,
August 24, 2007, 107 O.G. 5233
Oyod vs. Civil Registrar, Cordon,
Isabela, CV No. 87133, September
22, 2008, 107 O.G. 5084
Ozaeta vs. Cabanos, SP No. 93663,
April 28, 2008, 106 O.G. 934, 107
OG 2875
Pacific Plans Employees Association

vs. Pacific Plans, Inc., SP No. 91810,
April 29, 2008, 107 O.G. 4385
Pader vs. Mallilin, CR No. 29405,
January 17,2007, 107 O.G. 1784
People of the Philippines vs. Fabros,
CR H.C. No. 00955, July 11, 2006,
107 O.G. 3022
People of the Philippines vs. Hu, CR
No. 29493, August 8, 2006, 107
O.G. 3031
Altuveros, CR H.C. No. 01828,
March 21, 2007, 107 O.G. 2634
Gonzales, CR No. 29881, June 29,
2007, 107 O.G. 2767
Escano, CR No. 29354, February
12, 2007, 107 O.G. 2247
Alcaraz,
CR-H.C.
No.
01288,
February 21, 2007, 107 O.G. 2090
People of the Philippines vs. Pion,
CR-H.C. No. 01848, January 31,
2007, 107 O.G. 2083
People of the Philippines vs. Gener,
CR-HC No. 02780, January 29,
2010, 107 O.G. 6456
People of the Philippines vs. Ebrole,
CR No. 31856, March 30, 2010, 107
O.G. 6463
People of the Philippines vs. Muoz,

CR No. 29175, March 19, 2007, 107
O.G. 2439
Page 9 of 29
People of the Philippines vs. Icayan,

CR-H.C. No. 02323, February 9,
2007, 107 O.G. 1776
Agcaoili,
CR-H.C.
No.
02514,
January 31, 2008, 107 O.G. 3721
People of the Philippines vs. Divina,
CR- H.C. No. 00696, June 6, 2007,
107 O.G. 2452

Soliveres, Jr., CR No. 29932, May
31, 2007, 107 O.G. 113
Mirambil, CR- H.C. No. 01541,
November 19, 2007, 107 O.G. 246
Gimena-Cacho, CV No. 86803,
March 14, 2007, 107 O.G. 967
People of the Philippines vs. Valino,

CR No. 30529, April 29, 2008, 107
O.G. 4373
Philippine
Clearing
House
Corporation vs. City Treasurer of
Manila, C.V. No. 73439, September
20, 2006, 107 O.G. 326
People of the Philippines vs. Bianes,

CR No. 30611, April 30, 2008, 107
O.G. 4523
Pineda, Sr. vs. Gonzales, SP No.

94158, February 11, 2008, 107
O.G. 3734

Samson, CR No. 29964, June 19,
2007, 107 O.G. 2550
Plan Dot Com, Inc., vs. National

No. 92837, April 7, 2006, 107 O.G.
2866

Manangan, CR No. 28664, January
17, 2007, 107 O.G. 1616
Provident Insurance Corp. vs. Mc

Mai Cebu Trading, CV No. 69312,
March 29, 2007, 107 O.G. 1449

Anguluan, CR.-CH No. 02281,
November 26, 2007, 107 O.G. 5562
Bacillano,
CR-HC
No.
02174,
November 26, 2007, 107 O.G. 610
Latonio, CR No. 30286, December
20, 2007, 107 O.G. 5724
Bautista,
CR-HC
No.
01220,
December 19, 2007, 107 O.G. 6117
R
Raymundo vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 91529, April,
2010, 107 O.G. 6752
Residence Inn Corporation vs. Pe,
CV No. 84415, January 24, 2008,
107 O.G. 3376
Reyes vs. Montojo, CV No. 91131,
February 10, 2010, 107 O.G. 6609
Reyes, Jr. vs. Farrales, SP No.
98767, March 31, 2008, 107 O.G.
4194
Page 10 of 29
Rosales vs. Sabroso, CV No. 79825,

March 27, 2008, 107 O.G. 4037
Sta. Rosa vs. Atutubo, CV No.

85220, October 11, 2007, 107 O.G.
5411
Ruiz vs. Felicen, SP No. 92681, April

7, 2006, 107 O.G. 2758
Rural Bank of Pozorrubio, Inc. vs.
Acosta, SP No. 96656, April 30,
2008, 107 O.G. 4528
Rural Bank of Tagkawayan, Inc. vs.
Malibiran, CV No. 81372, March 31,
2008, 107 O.G. 4191
T
Tamondong vs. Union Bank of the
2007, 107 O.G. 6001
Telecom I vs. National Labor
91353, February 22, 2008, 107
O.G. 3886
S
Salonga vs. Bernal, SP No. 91962,
July 16, 2008, 107 O.G. 4851
Santos-Molina vs. Molina, Sr., CV
No. 66280, June 7, 2007, 107 O.G.
2545
U
Urbanes, Jr. vs. National Labor
97760, December 19, 2008, 107
O.G. 5879
Say vs. Buena, Jr., SP No. 95855,

November 7, 2007, 107 O.G. 123
Security and Safety Corp. of the
Philippines Inc., (SSCP) vs. National
Labor Relations Comission, SP No.
94474, March 21, 2007, 107 O.G.
2357
Security Bank Corporation vs. Tacan, SP No. 95109, May 26, 2008,
107 O.G. 4656
Sicat vs. Acua, SP No. 93015,
March 23, 2007, 107 O.G. 2360
Skippers United Pacific, Inco. vs.
Secretary
of
Labor
and
Employment, SP No. 92615, April
23, 2007, 107 O.G. 11
V
Velez-Lee vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 78842, January
30, 2007, 107 O.G. 1925
Toyota Cubao, Inc. vs. BPI Family
Bank, CV No. 86434, November 14,
2007, 107 O.G. 5557
Travero vs. Bitonio, SP No. 95451,
Jaunaury 18, 2007, 107 O.G. 1920
Treasureland Developers, Inc. vs.
Cinco, CV No. 91838, February 11,
2010, 107 O.G. 6744
Trilles vs. Trilles, CV No. 86642,
September 10, 2007, 107 O.G.
5245
Page 11 of 29
Trinidad vs. Gutierrez, SP No.

95983, January 25, 2007, 107 O.G.
1274
V
Career
Philippines
Shipmanagement, Inc. vs. National
No. 97413, May 13, 2007, 106 O.G.
5017
Velasco vs. Santiago, CV No.

78950, March 9, 2007, 107 O.G.
419
Celino vs. Department of Justice, SP

No. 72583, December 14, 2007,
106 O.G. 7042
Cham vs. Hon. Secretary of Justice

[SP No.86842. November 27, 2007]
106 O.G. 6673
Yang vs. Alejo, SP No. 89500, April

29, 2008, 107 O.G. 4379
Yap vs. Republic of the Philippines,
CV No. 73913, October 30, 2007,
107 O.G. 6015
Cuevas vs. Secretary of Justice, SP

No. 88942, December 13, 2006,
106 O.G. 4434
D
Daria vs. Local Civil Registrar of
Iba, Zambales, CV No. 83360, April
3, 2006, 106 O.G. 2343
A
ARG
Reality
Development
Corporation vs. Torres, SP No.
53251, February 14, 2006, 106
O.G. 1904
De Guzman vs. Platinum Holdings

and Consultancy, Inc., SP No.
91113, January 10, 2007, 106 O.G.
6389
Dela Cruz vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
85366,
December 13, 2006, 106 O.G. 4545
B
Bajet vs. Pobre, SP No. 97693,
September 18, 2007, 106 O.G.
5168
Delbros Waterfront Leasing, Co.,

Inc. vs. MOF Co., Inc., CV No.
85779, November 10, 2006, 106
O.G. 1569
Barangay Salian vs. Sangguniang

Bayan of Abucay, Bataan, CV. No.
77543, September 27, 2006, 106
O.G. 5320
Department of Public Works and

Highways vs. Home Construction,
Inc., SP No. 46930, August 31,
2007, 106 O.G. 5629
Diars Assistance, Inc. vs. National

Page 12 of 29
No. 94872, September 28, 2007,

106 O.G. 5326
Galicia vs. Bank of San Juan, Inc.,

CV No. 84913, April 07, 2006, 106
O.G. 2491
Dizon vs. Philippine Savings Bank,

CV No. 85522, January 31, 2007,
106 O.G. 2612
Galvez vs. Vibandor, SP No. 90674,

March 19, 2007, 106 O.G. 6901
Dollar Transport, Inc. vs. Standard

Insurance Co., Inc., SP No. 96248,
May 23, 2007, 106 O.G. 6767
Gamma Holdings Corporation vs.

Saulog, CV No. 65343, August 31,
2007, 106 O.G. 2772
Guerzo vs. Velicaria, CV No. 67066,

April 19, 2007, 106 O.G. 491
Ebojo vs. Verzon, SP No. 94428.

June 19, 2007] 106 OG. 5022
Eiseltin
vs.
Republic
of
the
Philippines,
CV
No.
77834,
November 23, 2006, 106 OG 4230
Ignacio vs. Datumanong, SP No.

79743, April 4, 2006, 106 O.G.
1563
Estiller vs. Oria, CV No. 81431,

October 22, 2007, 106 OG 2930
In re Ancheta vs. Palparan, SP No.

95656, June 19, 2007, 106 O.G.
2765
Espiritu vs. Sera Jose, SP No.

85016, May 30, 2006, 106 OG 622
F
In re Ang Ban Ting vs. Republic of

the Philippines, CV No. 87534,
September 10, 2007, 106 O.G. 38
Filinvest Land Inc. vs. Pastor, SP No.

83175, August 24, 2007, 106 O.G.
6912
In re Padua vs. Republic of the

Philippines,
CV
No.
67878,
November 29, 2007, 106 O.G. 1057
Flores vs. Llamzon, SP No. 92401,

June 19, 2006, 106 O.G. 483
In re Raeses vs. Republic of the

Philippines, CV No. 84607, June 6,
2006, 106 O.G. 1051, 107 O.G.
3016
Food Terminal, Incorporated vs.

National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
90801,
February 15, 2006, 106 O.G. 4219
G
Galderma vs. Pineda, SP No. 94286,
December 21, 2007, 106 O.G. 5458
Indo Phil. Textile Mills, Inc. Workers

Union-Ptgwo vs. Regional Tripartite
Wages and Productivity Board No.
03, SP No. 99434, December 13,
2007, 106 O.G. 202
Interconental
Broadcasting
Corporation (IBC-13) vs. National
Labors Relations Comission, SP No.
Page 13 of 29
91787, March 12, 2007, 106 O.G.

4716
Commission, SP No. 91000, January

31, 2006, 106 O.G. 4117
Irao, Jr. vs. Ceroilfood Shandong

Cereals and Oils Import and Export
Company, CV No. 84603, May 24,
2006, 106 O.G. 4305
Metropolitan
Bank
and
Trust
Company vs. Eugenio, Jr., SP No.
95051, February 26, 2007, 106
O.G. 6657
Minguita
vs.
National
Labor
95129, October 26, 2007, 106 O.G.
794
Ledesma-Gonzalez vs. RTC Makati,

Branch 148, SP No. 99816,
November 28, 2007, 106 O.G. 941
Landicho
vs. Corcuera, SP No.
94132, October 17, 2006, 106 O.G.
199
Lora Jr.vs. Metrobank Card Corp.,
SP No. 93560, December 13, 2006,
106 O.G. 2348
Mix Rich Trading, Inc. vs. National

No. 86543, September 22, 2006,
106 O.G. 1722
Muhlach vs. Cruz, CV No. 67792,
March 12, 2007, 106 O.G. 7029
N
M
Macalintal vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 73410, January
23, 2006, 106 O.G. 3094
Magsakay
vs.
Mass
Housing
Builders, Inc., CV No. 76700,
August 29, 2006, 106 O.G. 1427
Nayve vs. People of the Philippines,

CR No. 26585, February 17, 2006,
106 O.G. 3217
Nicer vs. Fernandez, CV No. 68533,
January 23, 2007, 106 O.G. 6662
O
Mangubat-Policarpio, vs. Policarpio

IV, CV No. 74629, September 11,
2006, 106 O.G. 3629
Oriental
Assurance
Corp.
vs.
Basilla, SP No. 87102, April 7, 2006,
106 O.G. 196
Marcelo vs. Yagana, SP No. 88157,

April 27, 2006, 106 O.G. 30
Mercado
vs.
National
Labor
90690, December 13, 2007, 106
O.G. 6774
Metro Eye Security Incorporated vs.
National
Labor
Relation
Pagsasama sa Iisang Adhikain, Inc.

(PIA) vs. Lopez, CV No. 87082, June
29, 2007, 106 O.G. 2924
Camana, CR No. 26945, June 15,
2007, 106 O.G. 6141
Page 14 of 29
People of the Philippines vs. David,

CR No. 25817, June 22, 2007, 106
O.G. 6130
People of the Philippines vs. Lazaro,

CR No. 27372, May 30, 2007, 106
O.G. 7036

Cantuba, CR-H.C. No. 01357, March
31, 2006, 106 O.G. 3345

Lachica, CR-H.C. No. 01491, June
13, 2007, 106 O.G. 7197

Salvador Batta, CR No. 26620, July
30, 2007, 106 O.G. 6146

Illustre,
Jr.,
CR
No.
29031,
December 19, 2007, 106 O.G. 7204
People of the Philippines vs. San

Miguel, CR No. 01523, December
14, 2007, 106 O.G. 6152
People of the Philippines vs. Evora.

CR No. 29181, April 30, 2007, 106
O.G. 7304

Duldulad, CR No.29759, October30,
2007, 106 O.G. 6136

Mabborang, CR No. 25804, August
30, 2007, 106 O.G. 6236
People of the Philippines vs. Lucas,

CR No. 29454, June 30, 2006, 106
O.G. 4125

Corpuz, CR No. 29894, September
14, 2007, 106 O.G. 6244

Bangkiling,
CR
No.
28383,
September 27, 2006, 106 O.G.
3790

Batimana, CR-H.C. No. 00210,
February 19, 2007, 106 O.G. 6393

Caindoy, CR No. 29331, December
29, 2006, 106 O.G. 5446
Dequito, CR-HC. No. 01287, May
28, 2007, 106 O.G. 5008
Ochotorena,
CR
No.
28524,
February 22, 2006, 106 O.G. 2061
Tolentino,
CR-HC
No.
01229,
November 29, 2006, 106 O.G. 2067

Saguin, CR No. 20954, September
26, 2007, 106 O.G. 6398
People of the Philippines vs. Boceo,
CR No. 29758, November 16, 2007,
106 O.G. 6523
Lumna, CR No. 29503, January 17,
2007, 106 O.G. 6652
People of the Philippines vs. Obia,
CR No. 26699, April 18, 2007, 106
O.G. 6667
Page 15 of 29
People of the Philippines vs,

Ramirez, CR No. 29499, March 19,
2007, 106 O.G. 5618

Altuveros, CR H.C. No. 01828,
March 21, 2006, 106 O.G. 777
People of the Philippines vs. Levoit,

CR No. 29297, April 23, 2007, 106
O.G. 5623
People of the Philippines vs. Escoto,

CR No. 28766, March 29, 2006, 106
O.G. 377

Quidatu, CR No. 29589, April 26,
2007, 106 O.G. 5797
People of the Philippines vs. Fabros,

CR H.C. No. 00955, July 11, 2006,
106 O.G. 1172

Ramos, CR No. 25913, May 17,
2007, 106 O.G. 5805
People of the Philippines vs. Hu, CR

No. 29493, August 8, 2006, 106
O.G. 1292
People of the Philippines vs. Barad,

CR No. 26482, May 18, 2007, 106
O.G. 5968

Villanueva,
CR
No.
29434,
November 9, 2006, 106 O.G. 1713
People of the Philippines vs. Rivera,

CR No. 25810, May 22, 2007, 106
O.G. 5973
People of the Philippines vs. de

Guzman, Jr., CR. HC No. 00724,
August 28, 2006, 106 O.G. 3468
People of the Philippines vs. Junas,

CR H.C. No. 01679, January 18,
2007, 106 O.G. 4708
Penafrancia
Broadcasting
Corporation vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
79393,
November 6, 2006, 106 O.G. 4226
People of the Philippines vs. Flores,

CR No. 29195, November 29, 2007,
106 O.G. 5810
Borromeo,
CR
No.
27614,
December 14, 2007, 106 O.G. 5978
People of the Philippines vs. Torres,
CR HC No. 02411, March 23, 2007,
106 O.G. 4848
People of the Philippines vs. Arasa,
CR No. 29737, April 10, 2007, 106
O.G. 4859
Perez vs. National Labor Relations

Commission,
SP
No.
92992,
September 26, 2007, 106 O.G.
7310
Perryman vs. Bicol Hair Export
Corporation, SP No. 91485, October
30, 2006, 106 O.G. 34
Prudential Guarantee & Assurance
Inc. vs. ADR Shipping Service and
Liberty Shipping Corporation, CV
No. 63514, October 25, 2006, 106
O.G. 3635
R
Page 16 of 29
Ramos vs. Baybay, SP No. 74855,

April 20, 2006, 106 O.G. 486
98025, June 29, 2007, 106 O.G.

5163
Raymundo vs. De Tejuco, SP No.

91800, April 23, 2007, 106 O.G.
630
A
Republic of the Philippines vs.

Reyes, CV No. 86864, December
19, 2007, 106 O.G. 5332
Rosales vs. Equidata Philippines, SP
No. 72225, March 24, 2006, 106
O.G. 1910
Acacio
vs.
Republic
of
the
2007, 105 O.G. 6376
Aces Productions, Inc. vs The
Castaway Corp., CV No. 69534,
June 20, 2005, 105 O.G. 1197
S
Singh
vs.
Republic
of
the
2006, 106 O.G. 374
Songcuya vs. Lim, SP No. 57357,
August 31, 2006, 106 O.G. 5158
Acong Hardware vs. National Labor

96079, June 25, 2007, 105 O.G.
7510
Active Realty & Development

Corporation vs. Republic of the
2006, 105 O.G. 4990
Tan vs. National Labor Relations

14, 2007, 106 O.G. 7190
Alejandrino vs. Reyes, SP No.

82994, April 10, 2006, 105 O.G.
2482
Tan vs. Republic of the Philippines,

CV No. 78112, January 19, 2007,
106 O.G. 381
Aliwalas vs. Gabriel, CV No. 66458,

May 25, 2005, 105 O.G. 170
Tangonan vs. Local Civil Registrar

of Solana, Cagayan, CV No. 78791,
July 31, 2006, 106 O.G. 3455
Tinero vs. Saclolo, SP No. 97495,
November 14, 2007, 106 O.G. 2999
Toreda vs. Querubin, SP No. 92535,
June 30, 2006, 106 O.G. 2608
Alog vs. Alday, CV No. 73560, July

31, 2006, 105 O.G. 2832
Armigos vs. De Bacena, CV No.
39446, August 18, 2006, 105 O.G.
539
Aviles vs. Aviles, CV No. 77234,
January 10, 2006, 105 O.G. 1509
B
Trojan Marketing vs. National Labor

Page 17 of 29
Balisi
vs.
Liberty
Insurance
Corporation,
CV
No.
73432,
September 1, 2006, 105 O.G. 3481
Bank of the Philippine Islands vs.
Asian Construction & Development,
CV No. 78920, September 15,
2005, 105 O.G. 2145
Batangas Laguna Tayabas Bus
Company Inc. vs. Barza, SP No.
77973, May 17, 2006, 105 O.G.
4497
Battad vs. Coronel-Paolelli, CV No.
63962, May 19, 2005, 105 O.G. 34
Bellis vs. Quilala, SP No. 91723,
January 13, 2006, 105 O.G. 6613
Benedicto
vs.
Kingsville
Construction
&
Development
Coporation, SP No. 66041, March
31, 2006, 105 O.G. 4353
Bermundo vs. Cabrera, CV No.
85623, July 31, 2006, 105 O.G.
7505
Bona Scentio Corporation vs.
Blossomer Plastic Corporation, CV
No. 78243, February 24, 2006, 105
O.G. 7642
Bondoc vs. Roque, CV No. 77715,
November 30, 2005, 105 O.G. 1357
Briones-Takenoshita vs. Cayanan,
CV No. 65310, May 31, 2006, 105
O.G. 2489
C
Caoile vs. Caoile, CV No. 56098,
July 28, 2005, 105 O.G. 1030
Canuto vs. Adina, CV No. 66334,

November 29, 2006, 105 O.G. 2978
Carpio, Jr. vs. Carpio, CV No. 83923,
January 5, 2006, 105 O.G. 3670
Cervantes vs. Sabio, A.C. No. 7828,
August 11, 2008, 105 O.G. 3954
Chan vs. Local Civil Registrar of
Candon, Ilocos Sur, CV No. 66597,
October 23, 2006, 105 O.G. 4357
Classic Everwood Profiles Pty.
Limited vs. Metropolitan Bank and
Trust Co., CV No. 81692, February
28, 2006, 105 O.G. 2327
Confiado
vs.
Civil
Service
18, 2006, 105 O.G. 4194
Consolidated Orient Leasing &
Financing
Corporation
vs.
Panganiban, CV No. 61595, April
27, 2005, 105 O.G. 1192
Cliffhanger Watchman Agency vs.
Layam, SP No. 90235, January 24,
2006, 105 O.G. 3333
D
De Estacio vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 79877, March 4,
2005, 105 O.G. 164
De Jesus vs. Navarro, CV No.
71295, March 23, 2007, 105 O.G.
6132
de Rama-Hill vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
65241,
November 30, 2006, 105 O.G. 2839
Page 18 of 29
Del Rosario vs. Cardona, CV No.

68309, February 13, 2007, 105
O.G. 5278
Dela Rosa vs. Conrado, Sr., CV No.
74501, September 28, 2006, 105
O.G. 545
Development
Bank
of
the
Philippines vs. Reach Multi-Purpose
Cooperative Inc., CV No. 69343,
October 13, 2005, 105 O.G. 1035
Dirige vs. Development Bank of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
77627,
December 15, 2005, 105 O.G. 1844
Dreu vs. Sangguniang Panlungsod
of Makati, SP No. 67466, October
31, 2006, 105 O.G. 4201
Dy vs. Marahaj, CV No. 86440,
March 29, 2007, 105 O.G. 6505
Gallo vs. Hachero, CV No. 80364,

March 30, 2007, 105 O.G. 6248
Garcia vs. Mesina, CV No. 79646,
January 6, 2005, 105 O.G. 533
GDSK Development Corporation vs.
Republic of the Philippines, CV No.
77308, May 27, 2005, 105 O.G.
1026
Great Pacific Savings Bank vs.
Buenaventura, CV No. 68434,
September 27, 2006, 105 O.G.
4198
Guevarra vs. Pia, CV No. 58123,
August 10, 2005, 105 O.G. 1692
I
In re Dealer Finance Corporation
vs. Manalo, CV No. 79004, May 2,
2006, 105 O.G. 1977
E
Empire East Land Holdings, Inc. vs.
Pizarro, SP No. 75541, June 26,
2006, 105 O.G. 4867
Investors
Financial
Services
Corporation vs.
Ygaa, SP No.
74414, October 30, 2006, 105 O.G.
3832
Florendo vs. Simon, CV No. 76955,

May 3, 2006, 105 O.G. 2148
Keppel Monte Bank vs. Mantilla, CV

No. 68514, July 31, 2006, 105 O.G.
1364
Fuentabella vs. Fama, CV No.

57066, June 21, 2005, 105 O.G.
852
Kolping Society of the Philippines,

Inc. vs. Caeso, SP No. 87035, July
28, 2006, 105 O.G. 6886
Furio
vs.
Republic
of
the
Philippines, CV No. 61941, August
28, 2006, 105 O.G. 3677
Lalosin, Jr. vs. Republic of the

2005, 105 O.G. 664
Page 19 of 29
Land Bank of the Philippines vs.

Tan, SP No. 88867, January 19,
2007, 105 O.G. 6000
Limos vs. Victory Liner, Inc., CV No.
65623, January 27, 2005, 105 O.G.
290
Lumanlan vs. Tirona, CV No. 83210,
September 22, 2006, 105 O.G.
4360
Morning Star Travel and Tours, Inc.

vs.
National
Labor
Relations
29, 2007, 105 O.G. 6244
Municipal Government of Marikina
vs. Luzong, CV No. 61812, February
27, 2006, 105 O.G. 3674
Municipality
of
Limay
vs.
Dimaculangan, SP No. 77794,
February 28, 2007, 105 O.G. 6128
M
Macasaquit vs. Viola, SP No. 81655,
March 30, 2006, 105 O.G. 7138
N
Magno vs. Liwanagan, CV No.
80977, January 31, 2005, 105 O.G.
414
Nakpil vs. Lopez, CV No. 78883,

February 14, 2006, 105 O.G. 2319
Macairog
vs.
National
Labor
91646, March 28, 2007, 105 O.G.
6005
Nagsama-Purefoods-Hormel-Pulo
vs.
National
Labor
Relations
Commission,
SP
No.
92416,
October 31, 2006, 105 O.G. 5662
Mayo vs. Aglipay, SP No. 87501,

January 21, 2005, 105 O.G. 4070
Navarro vs. Philippine Rabbit Bus

Lines, Inc., CP No. 80551, October
25, 2006, 105 O.G. 3147
Mendoza vs. Viola, SP No. 87782,

January 10, 2006, 105 O.G. 6372
Neri vs. Villanueva, SP No. 83290,

March 23, 2007, 105 O.G. 4997
Metro
Manila
Development
Authority
vs.
Trackworks
Rail
Transit Advertising Vending and
Promotions Inc., CV No. 29222,
February 24, 2005, 105 O.G. 3477
Ocampo vs. Billones, CV No. 76488,

November 22, 2005, 105 O.G. 667
Metropolitan
Bank
and
Trust
Company vs. Ochavillo, CV No.
78919, September 6, 2006, 105
O.G. 7647
Office of the Court Administrator

vs. Panganiban, A.M. No. P-041916, August 11, 2008, 105 O.G.
3949
Morales vs. Obispo, CV No. 83006,

October 30, 2006, 105 O.G. 5551
Orbeta vs. Lava, SP No. 97797,

August 9, 2007, 105 O.G. 7650
Page 20 of 29
Ortiz vs. Valdez, CV No. 76981,

October 31, 2006, 105 O.G. 1984

Fortaleza,
CR-HC
No.
00504,
February 21, 2006, 105 O.G. 2741
P
Gonzales, CR No. 27395, June 30,
2006, 105 O.G. 7333

Casimiro,
CR
No.
29335,
September 27, 2006, 105 O.G.
2973
People of the Philippines vs. Deang,

CR No. 30024, May 31, 2007, 105
O.G. 5419

Paayong-Ayong, CR No. 28356,
June 30, 2005, 105 O.G. 174

Villavicencio,
CV
No.
29852,
January 31, 2007,
People of the Philippines vs. Laron,

CV No. 28032, February 17, 2005,
105 O.G. 844

Espinosa,
CR
No.
26843,
Novemeber 30, 2006, 105 O.G.
5832

Tunday, CR No. 00237-HC, June 6,
2005, 105 O.G. 1502

Perucho, CR No. 28037, January 31,
2006, 105 O.G. 4863

Maycacayan, CR No. 28430, August
31, 2006, 105 O.G. 1696
People of the Philippines vs. Abion,

CR No. 27387, June 30, 2006, 105
O.G. 5145
Philippine
Commercial
and
International Bank vs. Soriao, SP
No. 96546, March 16, 2007, 105
O.G. 5828
People of the Philippines vs. Bori,

CR No. 22585, March 21, 2006, 105
O.G. 4489
Plaridel Surety and Insurance

Company vs. Rojas, S.P. No. 95449,
June 25, 2007, 105 O.G. 7338

Manarpies,
CR.
No.
29481,
December 29, 2006, 105 O.G. 3343
Pua vs. Bautista, CV No. 77318,

August 11, 2006, 105 O.G. 2747
Q

Avesilla, CR No. 00150, January 4,
2005, 105 O.G. 3822
People of the Philippines vs. Crisol,
CR No. 29237, April 19, 2006, 105
O.G. 3828
Quiroz vs. Feliciano, CV No. 79745,

June 26, 2006, 105 O.G. 5414
R
Ramirez vs. Guzman, SP No. 82979,
January 10, 2006, 105 O.G. 6998
Page 21 of 29
Razo vs. Panganiban, A.M. No. P05-2012, August 11, 2008, 105
O.G. 3949
RCL Trading CIE, N.V. vs Geelode
Philippines, Inc., CV No. 82644,
August 31, 2005, 105 O.G. 299
Tarroquin vs. Saberon, CV No.

60808, June 23, 2005, 105 O.G. 29
Tower Corporation vs. Rodriguez,
SP No. 093078, July 19, 2006, 105
O.G. 4726
Tria vs. Pitalbo, CV No. 85605,
January 31, 2007, 105 O.G. 5670
S
San
Miguel
Corporation
vs.
Presiding Judge, RTC of Gumaca,
Quezon, Branch 62, SP No. 64020,
March 28, 2006, 105 O.G. 4076
Trinidad vs. Cruz, CV No. 62192,

March 31, 2005, 105 O.G. 294
Tuazon vs. National Labor Relations
20, 2006, 105 O.G. 4721
Santiago vs. Republic of the

Philippines,
CV
No.
62714,
December 20, 2006, 105 O.G. 3152
Santos
vs.
General
Milling
Corporation,
CV
No.
64942,
December 27, 2006, 105 O.G. 3339
Sapitan
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines, CR No. 29602, June 19,
2007, 105 O.G. 7142
U
UE Automative Mfg. Inc. vs.
Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co., CV
No. 82637, September 27, 2006,
105 O.G. 7001
Universal Weavers Corporation vs.
CFW-Universal
Weavers
Association, SP No. 87090, April 10,
2006, 105 O.G. 5137
SMO Development Corporation vs.

Molina, CV No. 66158, February 23,
2005, 105 O.G. 424
T
Tampol vs. Yao, CV No. 55223, July

28, 2006, 105 O.G. 6734
Vargas vs. Garcia, CV No. 76829,

February 28, 2006, 105 O.G. 5272
Tan, II vs. Presiding Judge, RTC of

Manila, Branch 21, SP No. 97291,
May 29, 2007, 105 O.G. 6617
Ventura vs. Barayuga, SP No.

81158, January 10, 2006, 105 O.G.
6498
Tangonan vs. Local Civil Registrar

of Santiago City, CV No. 83703,
December 29, 2005, 105 O.G. 671
Z
Zamudio vs. Rural Bank of GOA,
Inc., CV No. 59943, April 18, 2006,
105 O.G. 1848
Page 22 of 29
Bautista
vs.
First-E
Bank
Corporation, CV No. 83178, August
31, 2005, 104 O.G. 6913
A
Acosta vs. Elfa, CV No. 74038,
January 10, 2005, 104 O.G. 4686
Acua vs. Cuello, CV No. 66742,
November 18, 2004, 104 O.G.
Bayani vs. Oraa, CV No. 53507,

April 29, 2004, 104 O.G. 1038
Buendia vs. Emeris, CV No. 78596,
May 26, 2004, 104 O.G. 89
C
Alcid
vs.
Republic
of
the
25, 2004, 104 O.G. 2542
Alli vs. Alli, CV No. 75141, February
21, 2005, 104 O.G. 8423
An-na Caridad Holdings Corp. vs.
65325, November 26, 2004, 104
O.G. 4977
Arante
vs.
People
of
the
Philippines, CR No. 27570, January
10, 2005, 104 O.G. 6304
Ayala Corporation vs. Power and
Development Equipment, CV No.
72271, January 31, 2005, 104 O.G.
6158
Azuma vs. Calimbas-Azuma, CV No.
64669, Septemper 25, 2005, 104
O.G. 5373
B
B.F. General Insurance Co., Inc. vs.
Torres, CV No. 68710. July 2, 2004,
104 O.G. 1445
Castillo vs. Sopranes, CV No.

54228, June 30, 2005, 104 O.G.
8430
Cayaban vs. Brodeth, CV No.53774,
June 1, 2005, 104 O.G. 5110
Chu vs. Marasigan, CV No. 51566,
January 26, 2004, 104 O.G. 888
Chua vs. dela Pea, CV No. 77345,
August 22, 2005, 104 O.G. 5367
Colas vs. Registry of Deeds of
Benguet Province, CV No. 78052,
August 9, 2004, 104 O.G. 2270
Crescini vs. Bagalawis, CV No.
64329, November 5, 2004, 104
O.G. 4682
Cuenca vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
84111,
September 29, 2005, 104 O.G.
8292
Cua vs. Cua, CV No. 61173, July
15, 2005, 104 O.G. 5614
D
Bautista vs. Republic of the

2005, 104 O.G. 7750
Page 23 of 29
Dampor, Sr. vs. Espella, CV No.

59659, April 29, 2004, 104 O.G.
1273
Degisica vs. Godinez, CV No.

52894, February 24, 2004, 104
O.G. 3094
Dargo vs. Pilipinas Bank, CV No.

49737, April 29, 2005, 104 O.G.
7537
Diente vs. Philippine Commercial

International Bank, CV No. 76161,
January 12, 2004, 104 O.G. 1439
Dario vs. Philippine Bank of

Communications, CV No. 51199,
July 28, 2005, 104 O.G. 8755
Domingo vs. Calaoagan-Costales,

CV No. 55781, July 30, 2004, 104
O.G. 3836
Dayanghirang vs. Briz, CV No.

78637, November 9, 2004, 104
O.G. 2073
Dumpit vs. Rivera, CV No. 80562,

March 18, 2005, 104 O.G. 6620
E
De Guzman vs. Republic of the

2005, 104 O.G. 2746
de Jesus-Edasawa vs. delos Reyes,
CV No. 61901, October 4, 2004,
104 O.G. 4197
Enriquez
vs. Cuevas, CV No.
67786, February 21, 2005, 104
O.G. 2274
Equitable Banking Corporation vs.
Ong, CV No. 61432, March 16,
2005, 104 O.G. 8281
De Leon vs. Republic of the

Philippines, CV No. 75992, August
30, 2004, 104 O.G. 3619
De Leon vs. Balinag, CV No. 69135,

May 31, 2005, 104 O.G. 4980
Far East Bank and Trust, Co. vs.

Montilla, SP No. 74556, November
11, 2004, 104 O.G. 4000
De Paz vs. R. Transport Corporation,

CV No. 79337, August 20, 2004,
104 O.G. 1802
Felizardo vs. De Jesus, CV No.

57681, February 19, 2004, 104
O.G. 3089
Del Rosario vs. Philippine Airlines,

CV No. 55621, August 21, 2004,
104 O.G. 4399
Filinvest
Homes
Homeowners
Association
vs.
Tivoli
Royale
Subdivision, CV No. 56742, March
30, 2005, 104 O.G. 6167
Dechavez vs. Republic of the

Philippines,
CV
No.
62208,
September 30, 2005, 104 O.G.
2943
Filomeno vs. Shoemart, Inc., CV No.

77597, September 2, 2004, 104
O.G. 2060
FS Management & Development
Corporation vs. MLI Enterprises, CV
Page 24 of 29
No. 54441, March 30, 2004, 104

O.G. 3420
G
Gacula vs. Lorenzana, CV No.
56519, August 16, 2004, 104 O.G.
1625
Gayoso vs. Groyon-Canillas, CV No.
80308, September 12, 2005, 104
O.G. 8768
Gonzales
vs.
Municipality
of
Calabanga, Camarines Sur, CV No.
77832, July 15, 2004, 104 O.G.
1617
I
J.C. Lee Construction vs. Tyco

Development Corporation, CV No.
69373, April 29, 2005, 104 O.G.
4841
Jupiter System, Inc. vs. Semorlan,
CV No. 75889, February 17, 2004,
104 O.G. 711
K
Kathlyn vs. Filipino Merchants
Insurance Co., Inc., CV No. 44965,
September 29, 2005, 104 O.G.
6017
Koh vs. Register of Deeds of
Pampanga, CV No. 81673, May 20,
2005, 104 O.G. 7354
In re Bulaag vs. Republic of the

15, 2005, 104 O.G. 2557
In re Capistrano vs. Republic of the
2005, 104 O.G. 6629
In re FBM Construction and AgroIndustrial Corporation vs. Republic
of the Philippines, CV No. 68246,
September 16, 2005, 104 O.G.
5860
In re Hembra vs. Republic of the
Philippines,
CV
No.
83656,
September 30, 2005, 104 O.G.
2749
L
Ladaw vs. Simbulan, CV No. 57789,
August 31, 2005, 104 O.G. 721
Land Bank of the Philippines vs,
North Negros Marketing, CV No.
61441, July 15, 2005, 104 O.G.
7755
Lantion vs. Reyes, CV No. 60959,
January 12, 2004, 104 O.G. 3996
Legasto vs. Perez, CV No. 59339,
April 29, 2005, 104 O.G. 4838
Lim vs. Republic of the Philippines,

CV No. 74116, June 10, 2004, 104
O.G. 3429
Javier vs. Navarrette, CV No.

52914, September 14, 2005, 104
O.G. 7358
Loreto
vs.
Republic
of
the
Philippines,
CV
No.
65650,
November 11, 2004, 104 O.G. 4527
Page 25 of 29
Lorico vs. Lorico, CV No. 59887,

August 4, 2005, 104 O.G. 8759
M
Magallon vs. Rodelas, CV No.
59405, July 29, 2004, 104 O.G.
3100
Maliwat-Atengco vs. Republic of the
Philippines, CV No. 76132, April 13,
2005, 104 O.G. 2940
Manaloto vs. Civil Registrar of San
Fernando City, Pampanga, CV No.
77794, April 21, 2004, 104 O.G.
1611
Mendoza vs. Castro, CV No. 81278,
June 30, 2005, 104 O.G. 8098
Muoz vs. Cornels, CV No. 588641,
June 2, 2005, 104 O.G. 5230
Odulio vs. Caguimbal, CV No.

52133, June 9, 2005, 104 O.G.
7003
P
Pangilinan vs. Santos, CV No.
57753, July 18, 2005, 104 O.G.
8287
Tolentino, CR No. 01315-H.C.,
October 13 2005, 104 O.G. 7760
Briguel, CR No. 01065, August 31,
2005, 104 O.G. 7905
Abarca, CR No. 27960, March 31,
2005, 104 O.G. 6778
Villanueva, CR No. 21102, March
31, 2005, 104 O.G. 6783
N
Namacon
Construction
and
Development
Corporation
vs.
Arenas, CV No. 79219, April 22,
2005, 104 O.G. 8094
New
San
Agustin
Oil
Manufacturing, Inc. vs. Allied
Banking
Corporation,
CV
No.
84350, November 17, 2005, 104
O.G. 7553
Northern Motor, Inc. vs. Filwriters
Guaranty
and
Assurance
Corporation,
CV
No.
51262,
September 14, 2005, 104 O.G.
5117
O

Villareal, CR No. 27256, May 30,
2005, 104 O.G. 6904
Elizalde, CR No. 28685, August 31,
2005, 104 O.G. 6908
Malolos, CR No. 00087, March 30,
2005, 104 O.G. 6625
Alcoreza, CR No. 27498, January
27, 2005, 104 O.G. 5856
People of the Philippines vs. Sacdal,
CR No. 28324, July 19, 2005, 104
O.G. 5234
Page 26 of 29

Bautista, CR No. 28076, June 22,
2005, 104 O.G. 5517
Ganiban, CR No. 22695, September
28, 2005, 104 O.G. 5675
Perez, Jr. vs. Nicolas, Jr., CV No.

58533, August 30, 2005, 104 O.G.
6789
Punzalan vs. Puzon, Jr., CV No.
72211, November 24, 2005, 104
O.G. 3628
R

Pantoja, CR No. 24635, May 31,
2005, 104 O.G. 4987
Ranska vs. de Jesus, CV No. 77676,

April 21, 2004, 104 O.G. 1795
People of the Philippines vs. Go, CR

No. 27455, November 23, 2004,
104 O.G. 4004
Rivamonte vs. Vasquez, CV No.

80525, June 29, 2005, 104 O.G.
6005
People of the Philippines vs. Regio,

CR No. 23253, October 13, 2004,
104 O.G. 4310
Ruaro vs. Private Development

Corporation of the Philippines, CV
No. 37907, August 31, 2004, 104
O.G. 1452

Libreja, CR No. 25019, September
30, 2004, 104 O.G. 4520
People of the Philippines vs. Torino,
CR No. 23293, September 30,
2004, 104 O.G. 3647
People of the Philippines vs. Obaa,
CR No. 27197, May 31, 2005, 104
O.G. 2742
Alangui, CR No. 26073, January 20,
2005, 104 O.G. 2935
Holandez, CV No. 26151, May 25,
2004, 104 O.G. 892
Peneyra vs. Philippine National
Bank, CV No. 78100, September
16, 2004, 104 O.G. 2068
S
Sales vs. International Corporate
Bank, CV No. 53450, April 21,
2004, 104 O.G. 3503
Sante-Julio vs. Gorospe, CV No.
68506, March 26, 2004, 104 O.G.
4304
Santiago-Guelas vs. Cruz, CV No.
78304, August 12, 2005, 104 O.G.
5671
Santos vs. City Trust Finance Corp.,
CV No. 75539, September 16,
2005, 104 O.G. 5121
Servicewide
Specialists,
Incorporated vs. Gregorio, CV No.
58564, July 11, 2005, 104 O.G.
7013
Page 27 of 29
Sharief vs. San Diego, CV No.

52812, October 15, 2004, 104 O.G.
4405
Tarnate vs. Rural Bank of Padre

Garcia, Inc., CV No. 79268, March
22, 2005, 104 O.G. 6309
Shellwood Industries Phils., Inc. vs.

68835, February 8, 2005, 104 O.G.
7190
Teodoro vs. Teodoro, CV No.55950,

June 23, 2005, 104 O.G. 4690
Silva vs. Silva, CV No. 77875,

September 16, 2005, 104 O.G.
5525
Six Stars Realty Development
Corporation vs. Aldana, CV No.
56860, April 1, 2004, 104 O.G.
3425
Tiu vs. Republic of the Philippines,

CV No. 67412, November 18, 2004,
104 O.G. 3624
Tizon vs. Cruz, CV No. 55728,
August 4, 2005, 104 O.G. 8620
Dispo-Torres vs. Torres, CV No.
76592, May 14, 2004, 104 O.G. 718
U
Soriano vs. Domingo, CV No.

83908, September 12, 2005, 104
O.G. 7205
Star Asia Realty, Inc. vs. Wholeasia
Development & Construction Corp.,
CV No. 70620, July 13, 2004, 104
O.G. 4393
Union Bank of the Philippines vs.

Gadil, CV No. 78933, February 28,
2005, 104 O.G. 6163
Urrutia vs. Rural Bank of Francisco
(Bulacan), Inc., CV No. 46760,
August 31, 2005, 104 O.G. 7914
Sy vs. Uy, CV No. 71597, April 27,

2005, 104 O.G. 6312
Sycip vs. Members of the Board of
Trustees of Christian Academy of
Manila, CV No. 57240. August 2,
2005, 104 O.G. 8102
V
Valdez vs. Alba, Jr., CV No. 79165,
June 27, 2005, 104 O.G. 7009
Villalobos vs. Resurreccion, CV No.
63782, September 3, 2004, 104
O.G. 3841
T
Tan vs. Ingco, CV No. 62358,
January 17, 2005, 104 O.G. 7345
Villamil vs. Sim, CV No. 59771,

September 30, 2004, 104 O.G.
3508
Tan vs. Musni, CV No. 83004, July

29, 2005, 104 O.G. 2281
Viray vs. Viray, CV No. 69431, July

28, 2005, 104 O.G. 2549
Tan vs. Capuyan, CV No. 46366,

August 10, 2004, 104 O.G. 4191
Page 28 of 29
Zacarias vs. Molina, Jr., CV No.

56913, March 11, 2004, 104 O.G.
4833
Prepared by:
Jonas Sahagun, UST Law Librarian
Page 29 of 29

CA Case Law Finder (2008-2012)

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

CA Case Law Finder (2008-2012)

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

How to read citation:

Case name, SP/CR/CV No., date of

Arnold vs. Torio, SP No. 84590,

Abon vs. Abon, CV No. 68353, May

Bank of the Philippine Islands vs.

Ajinomoto Philippines Corp. vs.

Bernal-Legaspi vs. Legaspi, Jr., CV

Alisasis vs. Dulalia, CV No. 88930,

Bertumen vs. de Leoz, CV No.

Aquil vs. Asencio, SP No. 98221,

Binag vs. National Labor Relations

Arbues vs. Arbues, CR No. 92271,

Boehringer Ingelheim (Phils.) Inc.

Araneta vs. Atalpao,

Arenas-Gonzales vs. Local Civil

Bomagat vs. Bacani, CV No. 92507,

BPI Family Savings Bank , Inc. vs.

Eustaquio-Dimaguila vs. Republic

De Vera vs. RTC Sorsogon City, SP

Exaltacion vs. Fajardo, SP No.

delos Reyes vs. Lacson, CV No.

Dimagiba vs. Escubio-Samar, SP

Filweb System Technology vs

Genetic Farm, Inc. vs. National

Lomotan vs. Miranda, CV No.

Manahan vs. Belmonte, SP No.

Meneses vs. Cruz, CV No. 76151,

People of the Philippines vs. Dela

People of the Philippines vs.

People of the Philippines vs.

People of the Philippines vs. Sosa,

Ramos vs. Soriano, SP No. 111606,

Pearedondo vs. National Labor

Philippine National Bank vs. de

Security and Safety Corporation of

Quing vs. Capatan, CV No. 85066,

Sicat vs. Province of Tarlac, CV No.

Valdez vs. Maramba, CV No. 61949,

Tahanlangit vs. Arboleda, SP No.

Abuan vs. Orlanes, CV No. 83092,

Arcega vs. Garcia, CV No. 86017,

Bongat vs. RTC Antipolo City,

Chua vs. Sayo, Jr., SP No. 77648,

D.G. Jones and Partners Phils., Inc.

Flores vs. People of the Philippines,

Dela Vega vs. Bismark, CV No.

Garcia vs. National Labor Relations

Escoto vs. Bautista, CV No. 86690,

La Salle College International vs.

Everlast International Placement,

Labaro vs. National Labor Relations

Land Bank of the Philippines vs. del

Fianza vs. Abance, CV No. 80159,

Pacific Plans Employees Association

People of the Philippines vs. Muoz,

People of the Philippines vs. Icayan,

People of the Philippines vs.

People of the Philippines vs. Valino,

People of the Philippines vs. Bianes,

Pineda, Sr. vs. Gonzales, SP No.

People of the Philippines vs.

Plan Dot Com, Inc., vs. National

People of the Philippines vs.

Provident Insurance Corp. vs. Mc