Common Pleas Court

Total Cases
Appealed
Reversed
Judge
Disposed
Cases
Cases
Ralph Winkler
3089
88
6
Timothy Hogan
1954
60
7
Patrick Dinkelacker
1258
44
8
Thomas Crush
3372
119
10
Arthur Ney, Jr
3219
125
14
William Morrissey
3032
121
22
William Mathews
2264
91
18
Thomas Nurre
3000
121
6
Ann Marie Tracey
3141
127
13
Robert Kraft
3138
127
7
Richard Niehaus
3353
137
16
John O'Connor
2969
129
12
Nobert Nadel
2959
131
20
Fred Cartolano
3037
137
12
Robert Ruehlman
3205
145
18
J. Howard Sundermann
955
60
10
Total
43945
1762
199
*The probablity of a case being appealed and reversed in Common Pleas is .6348
Domestic Relations Court
Total Cases
Appealed
Reversed
Judge
Disposed
Cases
Cases
Ronald Panioto
12970
32
3
Penelope Cunningham
2729
7
1
Patrick Dinkelacker
6001
19
4
Deborah Gaines
8799
48
9
Totals
30499
106
17
*The probablity of a case being appealed and reversed in Domestic Relations is .004
Municipal Court
Total Cases
Appealed
Reversed
Judge
Disposed
Cases
Cases
Karla Grady
5253
6
0
John A. West
2797
4
2
Deidra Hair
2532
5
0
James Patrick Kenney
2798
6
1
Mark Painter
2239
7
3
Dennis Helmick
7900
29
5
David Stockdale
5371
22
4
Melba Marsh
8219
34
7

Nadine Allen
Beth Mattingly
William Mallory
Timothy Black
Jack Rosen
Joseph Luebbers
David Davis
Albert Mestemaker
Timothy Hogan
Mark Schweikert
Leslie Isaiah Gaines
Mike Allen

7812
34
6
2971
13
1
8277
38
9
7954
41
6
7790
41
13
4698
25
8
7736
43
5
4975
28
9
2308
13
2
5403
33
6
5282
35
13
6149
43
4
Totals
108464
500
104
*The probablity of a case being appealed and reversed in Municpal Court is .0056
REPORT:

The three tables above are separated by the type of courts: Common Pleas Court, Domestic Relat
data of each table is consisting of the Judge, the total cases disposed, how many of those were a
probablity of appeal is shown, the probability of reversal, the probablity of a reversal given an a
rank by appeal because the amount of cases appealed were larger than reversed and I felt that w

Each Judge is ranked by the other judges of the court instead of against eachother. I feel the na
each judge. The cases dealt with in Common Pleas is a lot different than Domestic Relations an
different due to that. You could say one of the best judges would be Karla Grady as she has the
compared to one of the highest disposed.

Appealed
Probability
0.028488
0.030706
0.034976
0.035291
0.038832
0.039908
0.040194
0.040333
0.040433
0.040472
0.040859
0.043449
0.044272
0.045110
0.045242
0.062827
2.0534
on Pleas is .6348

Reversed
Probability
0.001942
0.003582
0.006359
0.002966
0.004349
0.007256
0.007951
0.002000
0.004139
0.002231
0.004772
0.004042
0.006759
0.003951
0.005616
0.010471

Prob of
reversal
given an
appeal
0.06818
0.11667
0.18182
0.08403
0.11200
0.18182
0.19780
0.04959
0.10236
0.05512
0.11679
0.09302
0.15267
0.08759
0.12414
0.16667

Appealed
Probability
0.0025
0.0026
0.0032
0.0055
0.0040
stic Relations is .004

Reversed
Probability
0.0002
0.0004
0.0007
0.0010

Prob of
reversal
given an
appeal
0.09375
0.14285714
0.21052632
0.1875

Appealed
Probability
0.0011
0.0014
0.0020
0.0021
0.0031
0.0037
0.0041
0.0041

Reversed
Probability
0.0000
0.0007
0.0000
0.0004
0.0013
0.0006
0.0007
0.0009

Prob of
reversal
given an
appeal
0
0.5
0
0.16666667
0.42857143
0.17241379
0.18181818
0.20588235

RANK
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

RANK
1
2
3
4

RANK
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

0.0044
0.0044
0.0046
0.0052
0.0053
0.0053
0.0056
0.0056
0.0056
0.0061
0.0066
0.0070
0.0056
pal Court is .0056

0.0008
0.0003
0.0011
0.0008
0.0017
0.0017
0.0006
0.0018
0.0009
0.0011
0.0025
0.0007

0.17647059
0.07692308
0.23684211
0.14634146
0.31707317
0.32
0.11627907
0.32142857
0.15384615
0.18181818
0.37142857
0.09302326

9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

PORT:

mon Pleas Court, Domestic Relations Court, and Municpal Court. The
osed, how many of those were appealed or reversed. After that, the
obablity of a reversal given an apeal, and their ranking. I chose to
r than reversed and I felt that would give a more accurate reading.

against eachother. I feel the nature of court has a lot to say about
ent than Domestic Relations and their probablities are going to be
d be Karla Grady as she has the lowest amount of cases appealed
the highest disposed.