Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Specialty Finance
Industry Insights
A review of M&A activity and
public market valuation in the
consumer and commercial
specialty finance sectors
William Blair
Table of Contents
Introduction .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................1
Consumer Specialty Finance .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................2
M&A Trends.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................2
Select M&A Transactions .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................3
Public Valuation Update .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................4
Commercial Specialty Finance..................................................................................................................................................................................................................7
M&A Trends.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................7
Select M&A Transactions .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................8
Public Valuation Update .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................9
Capital Markets Transactions ................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 12
Recent Equity Offerings ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 12
Recent Debt Offerings .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 14
Recent Preferred Equity Offerings .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 15
Financial Services & Technology Analysts and Coverage .......................................................................................................................................................... 16
Investment Banking Team Biographies ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 17
Select William Blair Transactions ........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 18
Notes ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
Disclosures..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 20
William Blair
Introduction
Specialty finance can be broadly defined as any financing activity that takes place outside the traditional banking system. Typically,
specialty finance firms are thought of as non-bank lenders that make loans to consumers and small to midsize businesses that cannot
otherwise obtain financing. This report covers trends in M&A activity, transaction multiples, and public company valuations in the
consumer and commercial specialty finance sectors. Specifically, consumer specialty finance includes auto finance, collection,
alternative financial services, credit card, and mortgage companies. Commercial specialty finance includes business development
companies (BDCs), commercial finance, commercial real estate lending, and leasing companies. We hope you enjoy this report, and
we welcome any feedback.
Both the M&A and equity markets performed strongly in the first quarter. Total global year-to-date M&A volume is over $400 billion,
up more than 5% from the corresponding period last year, and over the same period the total disclosed dollar volume of new equity
issuances (both initial public offerings and follow-on offerings) is up more than 17%. While some industry veterans believe
valuations are ahead of themselves, deal activity suggests otherwise.
This theme persists within the specialty finance sector and we believe 2015 M&A activity will remain strong for high quality
companies in this sector. Large strategic acquirers with healthy war chests will likely continue to pursue companies with
differentiated solutions, go-to-market strategies, and proven strong growth and profitability. In addition, private-equity firms remain
highly active in the specialty finance sector. Aging portfolio companies of private-equity firms in particular, specialty finance
businesses purchased before or during the downturn may create liquidity opportunities in the near to midterm and will continue to
fuel middle-market M&A activity.
Specialty finance companies generate high margins and recurring cash flows. In addition, these companies have meaningful
operating leverage. As a result, M&A transactions in the sector are generally completed at attractive multiples. Since 2002,
approximately 53% of the aggregate deals in the consumer specialty finance sector have been completed at above 10.0 times LTM
net income, and approximately 18% have been completed at more than 3.00 times LTM book value. In the commercial specialty
finance sector, approximately 46% of the aggregate deals since 2002 have been completed at above 10.0 times LTM net income, and
approximately 22% have been completed between 1.50 and 3.00 times LTM book value. Acquirers in the sector are most often
strategic parties that are able to pay more because of the significant revenue synergies generated by pushing new or stronger finance
products through an established distribution platform. In addition, many private-equity funds have developed a differentiated level
of industry knowledge and expertise, and as a result have established strong reputations in the sector.
In 2015 thus far, M&A activity in the sector has been strong, driven primarily by strategic acquirers looking for new products and
segments, differentiated platforms, and additional avenues for growth. Examples include New Residential Investment Corporations'
acquisition of Home Loan Servicing Solutions and Huntington Bancshares acquisition of Macquarie Equipment Finance. While global
economic uncertainty may cause the broad universe of buyers and sellers to proceed more cautiously in 2015, we remain optimistic
that both M&A and capital markets activity will remain strong for solidly performing businesses.
Robert Metzger
+1 312 364 8517
rmetzger@williamblair.com
J.P. Young
+1 312 364 8160
jyoung@williamblair.com
Kegan Greene
+1 312 364 8113
kgreene@williamblair.com
Consumer
Specialty
Finance
Sector
William Blair
Year-to-date aggregate M&A transaction volume is running slightly ahead of the comparable period in 2014, though disclosed
dollar volume is meaningfully lower over the same period.
Approximately 53% of the aggregate deals since 2002 have been completed at above 10.0 times LTM net income, and
approximately 18% have been completed at more than 3.00 times LTM book value.
Transactions less than $50 million were completed at an average of 5.9 times LTM net income, meaningfully lower than LTM net
income multiples on deals above $50 million.
Average: 49
79
47
41
2002
2003
75
53
2004
2005
2006
54
2007
32
33
46
50
2008
2009
2010
2011
25.0%
42
47
39
2012
2013
2014
10
2014
YTD
2015
YTD
$17,055
$26,075
2002
2003
$51,379
$8,866
2004
Average: $16,322
$16,926
2005
2006
$2,090
2007
$3,299
14.5%
32.3%
10.0x
5.0x
0.0x
5.9x
<$50mm
2009
7.5x
$50mm - $100mm
2010
2011
54.5%
5.0x to 10.0x
53.2%
$12,024
$10,519
2012
$1,817
2013
(27.4%)
$6,009
2014
$1,828
2014
YTD
$1,327
2015
YTD
2008
$2,754
$43,055
13.4x
>$100mm
18.2%
27.3%
1.36x
<$50mm
1.12x
$50mm - $100mm
1.34x
>$100mm
William Blair
Sub-Sector
03/10/15
Mortgage
02/23/15
Mortgage
03/03/15
02/22/15
02/18/15
02/10/15
02/09/15
02/09/15
01/28/15
01/28/15
01/27/15
01/12/15
01/08/15
12/18/14
12/15/14
12/10/14
12/10/14
12/01/14
11/24/14
11/13/14
11/10/14
11/07/14
10/21/14
10/08/14
09/24/14
09/23/14
09/16/14
09/11/14
09/09/14
08/25/14
08/06/14
08/01/14
07/07/14
07/02/14
06/05/14
05/05/14
04/17/14
04/16/14
04/15/14
04/02/14
03/27/14
03/26/14
03/03/14
03/01/14
AFS
Collection
Collection
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
AFS
Mortgage
Mortgage
AFS
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
AFS
Mortgage
AFS
Mortgage
Auto
Mortgage
Collection
Auto
Auto
Mortgage
AFS
AFS
Mortgage
Collection
Auto
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
AFS
AFS
AFS
AFS
Auto
Mortgage
Mortgage
Mortgage
Transaction
Value
$54.0
LTM Net
Income
-
LTM Book
Value
-
$4,250.0
7.5x
1.30x
$1,296.1
7.6x
1.02x
$7.0
Open Mortgage, LLC/ 360 Mortgage Group's reverse mortgage origination business
MidAmerica Mortgage, Inc./ Affinity Lending Soultions. LLC
$5.0
$19.3
$398.0
$34.7
$24.3
5.2x
0.70x
$15.9
$258.2
$297.8
13.8x
4.08x
$483.3
2.91x
$63.0
5.7x
$196.1
$25.7
$140.0
14.5x
$700.0
$127.1
$1,417.0
0.79x
William Blair
Current:
13.5x
14.0
12.0
10.0
8.0
6.0
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Feb 2014
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
ALLY
CPSS
CACC
NICK
Debt /
Equity
$20.78 $10,005.6
CRMT
Equity
Market
Cap.
LTM
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
(2.5%)
0.6%
$178.2
NMF
7.6x
6.6x
1.40x
11.4%
1.8%
$183.4
0.8x
$22.53
Median
ROAE
0.71x
$3,829.7
Mean
ROAA
10.6x
$183.30
FY2015
BVPS
15.3x
$456.0
$14.89
LTM
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
4.8x
$53.21
$6.96
EPS
0.5x
16.9x
16.2x
2.02x
17.6%
NA
20.9%
10.8%
(8.9%)
26.4%
18.8%
10.2%
36.7%
$7,862.6
$3,752.6
NMF
2.2x
10.5x
12.9x
9.3x
11.3x
2.29x
2.17x
NA
9.2%
2.6%
4.7%
$2,142.8
1.7x
13.5x
10.6x
1.71x
10.6%
4.1%
7.5%
5.5%
LTM
NMF
13.1%
13.6x
1.18x
6.2%
7.6%
15.4x
NA
5.45x
10.6%
2.5x
11.6x
Feb 2015
26.6%
24.5%
(3.4%)
12.3%
5.5%
40.7%
19.6%
6.6%
1.6%
22.9%
26.3%
18.8%
1.6%
23.6%
Collection
Indexed Price / LTM Earnings Ratios as of 2/28/2015
26.0x
Current:
12.4x
22.0x
18.0x
14.0x
10.0x
6.0x
2.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Feb 2014
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
ASFI
PFMT
$8.47
Equity
Market
Cap.
Debt /
Equity
EPS
LTM
FY2015
LTM
LTM
$259.1
1.2x
27.6x
22.4x
3.04x
$2,508.5
$977.2
1.6x
1.8x
14.3x
15.6x
10.6x
$645.2
1.4x
12.4x
LTM
0.62x
$50.09
ROAE
09-14
NMF
PRAA
Median
ROAA
LTM
10.0x
$1,031.4
$5.25
BVPS
0.2x
$39.97
4.2x
10.4x
7.9x
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
$110.0
ECPG
Feb 2015
NA
(2.1%)
NA
6.6%
1.78x
44.5%
13.6x
3.81x
10.6x
6.9%
47.5%
11.4%
(8.8%)
7.8%
15.9%
2.31x
28.5%
36.5%
10.3%
5.6%
19.9%
2.41x
36.5%
7.2%
19.4%
LTM
28.5%
9.7%
4.8%
13.5%
20.5%
20.0%
19.7%
15.7%
13.6%
20.0%
14.9%
William Blair
Current:
11.2x
15.0x
12.0x
9.0x
6.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Equity
Price
Market
Ticker 2/28/15 Cap.
CSH
$21.58
$652.5
0.2x
NMF
22.1x
1.16x
EZCORP, Inc.
EZPW
$10.44
$560.1
0.4x
15.8x
8.9x
1.16x
0.2x
NMF
ENVA
FCFS
QC Holdings, Inc.
$1,363.2
RM
$15.60
$198.8
WRLD
$82.11
LEAF
$762.0
$48.14
QCCO
$23.09
Debt /
Equity
$1.72
$38.45
$30.1
$4,415.3
3.2x
EPS
LTM
FY2015 LTM
6.8x
0.5x
BVPS
6.5x
16.4x
16.8x
1.9x
13.7x
8.6x
4.6x
7.99x
NA
8.8x
16.3x
$776.8
$1,094.9
1.9x
1.6x
8.3x
11.6x
8.0x
12.4x
$707.2
1.2x
11.2x
8.9x
Median
4.89x
Feb 2014
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
ROAA
ROAE
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
LTM
3.7%
1.4%
(0.9%)
(10.1%)
23.3%
4.4%
4.0%
NA
(5.4%)
NA
3.5%
15.1%
57.2%
19.8%
6.5%
NA
5.2%
8.7%
2.0
2.18x
(10.3%)
7.1%
7.5%
4.6%
32.6%
31.6%
9.0%
44.5%
11.8%
(5.4%)
2.46x
9.9%
22.8%
0.43x
1.13x
Feb 2015
14.5%
11.9%
7.6%
(22.9%)
1.3%
29.9%
2.67x
10.1%
8.5%
12.3%
16.4%
7.1%
20.1%
3.5%
10.9%
1.67x
10.1%
6.2%
14.3%
1.7%
10.5%
Credit Card
Indexed Price / LTM Earnings Ratios as of 2/28/2015
36.0x
Current:
21.9x
30.0x
24.0x
18.0x
12.0x
6.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
Equity
Market
Cap.
Debt /
Equity
EPS
LTM
FY2015
ADS
$278.51
$17,491.8
5.4x
35.4x
18.7x
DFS
$60.98
$27,272.7
2.0x
12.4x
11.4x
Synchrony Financial
SYF
MA
V
Median
Note: Dollar amount in millions.
Source: SNL Financial and Capital IQ.
$81.59
$83,154.5
$90.13 $103,510.0
$31.95
$26,638.8
3.0x
0.2x
2.6x
14.7x
29.1x
11.5x
Feb 2014
Feb 2015
Net Income
BVPS
Asset
CAGR
ROAA
ROAE
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
LTM
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
LTM
NMF
31.1%
2.75x
12.6%
12.4x
2.96x
NA
14.9x
4.95x
25.9x
NMF
4.9%
4.5%
29.6%
2.9%
21.2%
3.8%
15.5%
21.6%
29.3%
17.1%
9.5%
6.0%
18.2%
NMF
23.8%
38.2%
3.1%
30.4%
NA
3.7%
33.0%
33.4%
$271.31 $166,557.4
$70,770.9
NMF
2.7x
30.3x
22.2x
26.2x
18.3x
5.86x
4.13x
3.6%
13.5%
13.8%
8.3%
20.4%
26.2%
13.8%
12.9%
29.3%
43.3%
$55,213.6
2.6x
21.9x
16.8x
3.96x
12.6%
4.1%
29.3%
13.8%
33.2%
William Blair
Mortgage
Indexed Price / LTM Earnings Ratios as of 2/28/2015
25.0x
Current:
10.3x
20.0x
15.0x
10.0x
5.0x
0.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
EFC
$20.48
$685.1
2.2x
Nationstar Mortgage
Holdings Inc.
NSM
$26.65
$2,424.7
NMF
PMT
$21.44
$1,597.5
2.0x
SGM
$10.02
Stonegate Mortgage
Corporation
Walter Investment
Management Corp.
Mean
HBOS
OCN
PHH
WAC
Equity
Market
Cap.
$25.89
$8.14
$24.28
$16.67
Median
Note: Dollar amount in millions.
Source: SNL Financial and Capital IQ.
$228.0
$1,024.1
$1,243.1
$258.3
Debt /
Equity
EPS
LTM
9.8x
FY2015
ROAE
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
LTM
8.5%
78.9%
(9.3%)
7.3x
2.07x
54.1%
1.8%
20.0%
NMF
15.2%
4.2%
12.8%
44.5%
47.7%
NA
(12.9%)
5.1%
47.9%
9.5%
8.5%
44.5%
6.1x
4.4x
8.4x
NA
NMF
8.7x
8.4x
12.5x
ROAA
LTM
1.7%
3.8x
4.1x
BVPS
20.8%
23.4x
1.1x
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
0.88x
27.3x
8.7x
6.7x
1.61x
0.71x
1.01x
24.4%
28.8%
NA
0.5%
6.1%
5.3%
33.6%
57.1%
1.4%
(2.8%)
(11.3%)
2.12x
58.7%
(0.6%)
(9.8%)
0.95x
NA
NMF
2.4x
12.5x
9.8x
1.15x
25.9%
$1,024.1
2.1x
10.3x
7.8x
0.95x
24.4%
(2.4%)
1.3%
1.7%
25.5%
11.0%
0.80x
$628.8
$1,065.8
Feb 2015
8.3x
1.3x
10.9x
Feb 2014
(10.4%)
NA
8.6%
8.6%
8.4%
(9.3%)
8.6%
Commercial
Specialty
Finance
Sector
William Blair
Year-to-date aggregate M&A transaction volume and disclosed dollar volume are running significantly above those of the
comparable period in 2014.
Approximately 46% of the aggregate deals since 2002 have been completed at above 10.0 times LTM net income, and
approximately 22% have been completed between 1.50 and 3.00 times LTM book value.
Transactions less than $50 million were completed at an average of 5.6 times LTM net income, slightly lower than LTM net
income multiples on deals above $50 million.
39
45
26
2002
2003
43
40
2004
2005
Average: 32
42
2006
2007
29
2008
28
22
2009
16
2010
2011
29
26
2012
2013
125.0%
35
2014
2014
YTD
2015
YTD
$16,000
$12,000
$8,000
$4,000
$0
$1,551
$7,885
$9,126
2003
2004
2002
$6,484
$5,702
2005
2006
$11,162
2007
23.1%
30.8%
10.0x
5.0x
0.0x
5.6x
<$50mm
2008
$2,453
2009
46.2%
8.1x
$50mm - $100mm
$1,780
2010
$240
2011
$7,802
2012
NMF
$7,314
$4,159
2013
2014
$229
2014
YTD
$1,123
2015
YTD
Average: $6,237
$15,423
10.0x
>$100mm
71.7%
21.7%
6.5%
1.00x
<$50mm
1.40x
$50mm - $100mm
1.01x
>$100mm
William Blair
Sub-Sector
03/09/15
Commercial Finance
03/03/15
Commercial Finance
03/03/15
02/24/15
02/20/15
02/11/15
02/10/15
02/06/15
01/23/15
01/20/15
01/15/15
01/09/15
12/30/14
12/15/14
11/26/14
10/31/14
10/31/14
10/14/14
10/13/14
10/10/14
10/09/14
09/29/14
09/26/14
09/04/14
08/26/14
08/11/14
08/05/14
08/04/14
07/11/14
06/28/14
06/10/14
06/05/14
06/02/14
06/02/14
05/15/14
05/05/14
04/22/14
04/08/14
03/28/14
03/14/14
Leasing
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Leasing
Commercial Finance
Transaction
Value
$21.0
$45.4
$7.3
$1,775.0
$5.7
Omega Commercial Finance Corp./ AmericaVest CRE Mortgage Funding Trust, Inc.
National Bancshares, Inc./ Doral Healthcare Finance
$441.0
0.14x
1.7x
$22.5
Commercial Real Estate Northwest Federal Credit Union/ Park Place Equity, LLC
Commercial Real Estate Wood Creek Capital Management, LLC/ Genesis Funding Limited
Commercial Finance
$129.6
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Commercial Finance
1.58x
Commercial Finance
15.2x
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
$151.4
Commercial Real Estate Sutherland Asset Management Corp./ CIT Small Business Lending Corporation
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Commercial Finance
Leasing
Commercial Finance
$133.3
$624.0
Leasing
Leasing
Commercial Real Estate Walker & Dunlop, Inc./ Johnson Capital Group, Inc.
Commercial Finance
$425.0
LTM Book
Value
LTM Net
Income
$1,402.5
24.2x
3.80x
$2.0
$77.0
William Blair
Current:
11.4x
15.0x
10.0x
5.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2013
Feb 2012
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
AINV
BKCC
$1,844.2
0.8x
11.8x
$8.78
$654.5
0.5x
5.2x
$17.30
CPTA
$18.81
FDUS
$16.60
FSC
$13.73
$5,434.1
$244.0
$187.6
$266.0
$7.08
$1,085.6
GARS
$15.03
$251.9
HCAP
$12.55
$77.9
FULL
GBDC
HTGC
HRZN
KCAP
$3.88
$17.76
$46.4
$837.8
$15.55
$998.2
$7.50
$275.4
$14.13
$136.0
MAIN
$30.95
$1,397.7
MCC
$9.46
$555.6
TAXI
$10.45
MRCC
$14.91
PFLT
$13.97
OFS
PNNT
PSEC
$12.13
$9.51
TSLX
TCAP
Median
$208.1
$714.1
$854.4
$16.60
$808.6
$16.17
TICC
$116.9
$20.12
SUNS
TCRD
$141.9
$3,093.0
$15.76
TCPC
$258.6
$8.63
SAR
SLRC
EPS
LTM
$7.79
ARCC
CMFN
Equity
Market Debt /
Cap.
Equity
$12.09
$7.29
$18.54
$23.67
$84.8
$186.5
$409.9
0.7x
0.8x
0.7x
BVPS
FY2015 LTM
8.1x
0.89x
10.0x
0.88x
8.9x
10.8x
NA
9.8x
8.1x
NA
0.6x
12.2x
10.0x
1.0x
NMF
5.9x
1.0x
0.9x
21.4x
8.3x
8.0x
9.9x
1.0x
12.5x
13.6x
1.0x
14.1x
11.7x
0.7x
10.0x
7.8x
1.3x
9.2x
0.2x
0.6x
0.8x
8.3x
8.8x
8.1x
10.2x
13.4x
13.6x
0.9x
25.2x
7.0x
1.1x
11.8x
10.6x
13.8x
8.6x
0.8x
0.6x
0.8x
0.8x
1.1x
10.3x
14.0x
9.0x
7.0x
9.8x
9.4x
11.1x
8.1x
8.9x
0.2x
17.8x
12.5x
0.4x
NMF
10.3x
0.7x
16.0x
11.7x
0.6x
11.1x
$778.9
0.5x
11.1x
$779.6
0.8x
11.0x
0.8x
$425.0
0.8x
$440.0
$1,000.4
1.0x
NA
24.8x
8.8x
6.9x
Feb 2014
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
ROAA
ROAE
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
LTM
7.4%
5.3%
8.2%
4.1%
1.04x
32.6%
0.95x
NA
0.94x
1.09x
NA
NA
0.73x
45.0%
0.96x
NA
0.62x
NA
1.14x
28.7%
1.52x
20.6%
0.96x
(0.4%)
0.95x
2.6%
0.87x
0.98x
1.47x
0.75x
1.07x
0.87x
0.97x
NA
NA
53.9%
NA
NA
NA
NA
0.86x
22.5%
0.71x
10.9%
0.82x
0.90x
0.92x
57.6%
13.8%
NA
1.07x
16.9%
0.78x
35.8%
0.91x
1.18x
Feb 2015
NA
NA
8.0%
NA
36.7%
21.3%
NMF
4.8%
11.6%
22.8%
4.1%
5.6%
NA
(6.9%)
(1.7%)
38.2%
15.8%
4.8%
13.5%
4.6%
3.5%
4.9%
5.5%
7.2%
4.6%
NA
28.0%
NA
59.8%
79.7%
60.4%
7.2%
8.0%
NA
57.2%
5.3%
10.9%
5.9%
9.7%
5.0%
14.9%
5.5%
(19.1%)
4.9%
11.6%
17.0%
5.7%
3.3%
11.7%
2.4%
10.5%
4.9%
10.1%
3.9%
7.0%
3.0%
4.8%
5.5%
NMF
14.4%
NA
5.5%
29.6%
6.3%
NA
9.3%
NA
25.2%
4.1%
10.3%
(5.9%)
3.2%
5.7%
NA
3.0%
5.0%
(7.5%)
58.9%
49.6%
23.9%
47.9%
71.6%
69.9%
9.8%
13.3%
6.8%
9.2%
11.8%
47.2%
5.6%
41.8%
39.7%
52.9%
6.9%
(2.9%)
5.8%
5.8%
27.1%
NA
8.0%
31.2%
48.1%
(0.6%)
12.1%
7.2%
10.8%
11.2%
5.4%
6.4%
10.8%
37.5%
44.2%
33.3%
26.5%
9.2%
12.7%
10.8%
9.5%
10.1%
13.2%
5.3%
5.2%
9.6%
10.0%
9.3%
NMF
(8.1%)
45.0%
9.1%
12.4%
12.2%
9.4%
10.3%
16.1%
3.6%
3.7%
Dividend
Yield
74.9%
9.1%
7.7%
11.6%
8.0%
8.7%
9.3%
49.6%
11.2%
52.1%
8.4%
14.8%
12.5x
10.7x
9.8x
1.42x
0.97x
30.4%
24.2%
4.7%
8.3%
(20.7%)
12.3%
43.6%
9.8%
9.3%
11.4x
9.9x
0.94x
21.5%
4.9%
8.7%
14.9%
47.5%
9.5%
William Blair
Commercial Finance
Indexed Price / LTM Earnings Ratios as of 2/28/2015
35.0x
30.0x
Current:
23.1x
25.0x
20.0x
15.0x
10.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
CIT
$46.28
$8,139.8
4.0x
PacWest Bancorp
PACW
$45.84
$4,722.0
3.6x
NEWS
SIVB
Mean
$9.98
$122.90
Median
Equity
EPS
BVPS
Market Debt /
Cap.
Equity LTM FY2015 LTM
Feb 2014
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
ROAA
ROAE
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
LTM
8.1x
13.7x
0.99x
(4.4%)
2.3%
12.0%
$6,263.4
23.6x
7.9%
1.64x
25.1%
1.5%
17.0x
2.22x
25.0%
4.9x 18.3x
21.2x
2.64x
$4,897.6
23.1x
16.0x
12.7%
1.4%
$5,492.7
3.8x 23.1x
16.0x
1.60x
15.0%
$465.1
3.3x
8.6x
NMF
NMF
0.73x
Feb 2015
5.0%
0.4%
Dividend
Yield
NMF
44.5%
1.3%
49.3%
24.6%
4.4%
1.7%
(9.2%)
13.4%
8.8%
18.5%
15.4%
26.2%
19.3%
2.8%
1.4% 10.0%
15.4%
21.9%
2.8%
1.4%
16.6%
NA
NA
Current:
15.7x
15.0x
10.0x
5.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
LADR
$18.40
$946.3
2.1x
21.3x
WD
$16.03
$510.1
3.2x
NMF
$556.3 2.3x
10.1x
18.4x
15.7x
$510.1 2.1x
15.7x
Median
REXI
$9.30
Equity
EPS
Market Debt /
Cap.
Equity LTM
$212.6
1.5x
BVPS
FY2015 LTM
Feb 2014
Feb 2015
Net Income
Asset
CAGR
ROAA
ROAE
09-14
LTM
LTM
LTM
8.7x
1.38x
8.8x
1.33x
12.0x
1.47x
50.5%
1.39x
8.8x
1.38x
LTM
Dividend
Yield
NA
3.5%
8.9%
27.8%
21.2%
52.6%
2.7%
12.3%
13.8%
9.0% 20.8%
14.4%
2.6%
51.5%
3.3%
3.5%
13.1%
2.6%
51.5%
3.3%
8.9% 20.8%
14.4%
2.6%
1.4%
5.7%
NA
NA
NA
William Blair
Leasing
Indexed Price / LTM Earnings Ratios as of 2/28/2015
Current:
13.2x
21.0x
16.0x
11.0x
6.0x
Feb 2010
Feb 2011
Feb 2012
Feb 2013
Stock Price /
Company
Stock
Price
Ticker 2/28/15
AER
$44.50
$9,448.2
3.8x
9.8x
AL
$38.24
$3,915.5
2.4x
16.1x
$24.28
$504.7
2.9x
8.5x
AeroCentury Corp.
Aircastle LTD
ACY
AYR
CAP
EFN
GMT
MRLN
MINI
R
TAL
TGH
WLFC
$10.07
$23.07
$12.80
$62.25
$18.71
Equity
Market
Cap.
$16.2
$1,867.5
$3,380.9
$2,757.7
$239.9
Debt /
Equity LTM
3.2x
2.2x
2.8x
$41.73
$1,372.1
4.6x
$32.26
$21.34
Median
Note: Dollar amount in millions.
Source: SNL Financial and Capital IQ.
$4,980.3
$1,834.4
$179.6
2.5x
2.4x
3-Yr CAGR
Margin
LTM
LTM
LTM
Dividend
Yield
15.6%
67.6%
22.3%
NA
12.9x
1.41x
NA
3.8%
9.7%
68.8%
24.4%
0.4%
1.14x
36.9%
3.7%
14.1%
6.3%
26.5%
NA
2.24x
5.9%
2.9%
15.1%
22.8%
2.09x
3.7%
3.6%
5.2%
13.2%
8.3x
15.6x
12.6x
11.8x
9.7x
ROAE
4.4%
NMF
11.3x
ROAA
09-14 LTM
45.3%
11.5x
22.7x
Net Income
2.75x
18.5x
NMF
NA
1.1x
Asset
CAGR
Feb 2015
8.7x
10.3x
13.9x
$1,915.1
BVPS
FY2015 LTM
NA
3.3x
$41.49
$93.99
EPS
Feb 2014
11.8x
11.6x
14.8x
11.4x
10.8x
0.45x
1.09x
2.11x
1.34x
3.67x
4.5%
6.9%
NA
6.0%
9.1%
2.31x
18.9%
1.57x
26.2%
NMF
4.6%
0.7%
2.6%
5.9%
6.0%
2.5%
11.5%
3.9%
11.9%
4.1%
16.3%
4.6%
3.4%
18.3%
NA
26.9%
NA
46.3%
8.8%
8.4%
12.5%
16.0%
3.8%
NA
14.1%
2.4%
10.0%
1.8%
25.9%
3.3%
4.2%
19.1%
7.8%
NA
33.6%
2.7%
1.6%
6.9%
5.8%
3.5x
$2,493.2 2.9x
24.0x
14.7x
17.3x
12.1x
0.81x
1.77x
4.1%
15.2%
6.6%
3.5% 10.7%
(1.8%)
24.6%
8.0%
17.2%
3.2%
NA
$1,867.5 2.9x
13.2x
11.6x
1.57x
6.9%
3.8% 11.5%
13.2%
16.0%
2.6%
Capital Markets
Transactions
William Blair
Company
02/13/15
$14.25
12/10/14
LendingClub Corporation
$15.00
12/16/14
12/11/14
11/20/14
10/08/14
07/30/14
05/08/14
04/09/14
03/20/14
03/05/14
02/05/14
02/05/14
01/22/14
01/15/14
11/08/13
11/06/13
10/15/13
10/09/13
10/03/13
09/24/13
07/11/13
05/08/13
05/02/13
05/01/13
03/26/13
03/21/13
02/14/13
02/07/13
12/04/12
11/07/12
11/07/12
10/24/12
Price
5.0
Amount
$71.3
$20.00
10.0
$200.0
$15.00
10.5
$157.1
$20.00
$20.00
13.6
58.0
5.2
$16.00
7.0
$112.0
$25.00
$15.00
$15.00
95.0
8.3
6.7
$17.00
13.3
$14.00
13.9
$24.00
$15.00
$25.00
$17.00
$16.00
$20.00
$20.00
$15.00
$21.25
$15.00
$15.00
$15.00
$15.00
10.3x
$125.0
$2,375.0
$100.0
$225.3
12.4x
9.1x
6.3
$157.1
10.0
21.0
7.1
6.5
4.0
6.7
5.3
$15.00
$100.0
17.2x
$15.00
$15.00
$1,799.8
11.1
$20.00
9.8x
75.0
$18.00
$15.00
$103.1
$870.0
$2,875.0
6.6
12.1x
125.0
$15.00
LTM EPS
$272.7
$23.00
Note: Dollar amount and shares amount are in millions and exclude overallotment.
Source: SNL Financial and William Blairs market analysis.
Shares
3.4
6.5
4.0
2.4
$150.0
$195.0
$357.8
$51.0
$129.0
$80.0
$75.0
0.80x
1.03x
1.47x
6.44x
3.10x
2.48x
5.75x
$120.0
0.90x
$100.0
8.0
5.0
22.2x
$100.0
$60.5
$35.4
1.11x
$200.0
1.05x
1.12x
$100.0
$80.0
1.00x
14.1x
$130.0
$120.1
6.7
$113.6
5.7
6.7
LTM
Book Value
3.32x
2.35x
William Blair
Company
Apollo Commercial Real Estate Finance, Inc.
11/21/14
12/19/14
12/01/14
11/21/14
11/20/14
11/12/14
11/04/14
10/27/14
10/23/14
10/07/14
09/30/14
09/18/14
09/05/14
09/05/14
09/04/14
09/04/14
09/03/14
09/02/14
08/20/14
08/14/14
08/12/14
08/12/14
08/05/14
07/29/14
07/17/14
07/16/14
07/16/14
07/11/14
06/19/14
05/13/14
04/30/14
04/29/14
04/25/14
04/23/14
04/23/14
04/09/14
04/08/14
04/08/14
04/03/14
04/02/14
04/01/14
03/26/14
03/19/14
03/11/14
02/27/14
02/20/14
01/29/14
01/16/14
01/14/14
Price
$17.00
Shares
10.0
Amount
$170.0
$7.94
13.0
$103.2
$23.25
$41.23
$17.05
$15.30
$12.50
$23.00
$13.60
$14.53
$8.02
$17.00
$27.49
54.9
11.2
5.9
2.0
2.2
1.6
4.0
5.0
$1,277.0
$463.1
$100.6
$30.6
$27.5
$36.8
$54.4
$65.1
$18.63
$17.33
$14.50
8.5
8.0
10.0
22.8
39.5
4.3
5.0
5.4
2.0
$479.5
$98.9
$170.6
$115.5
$93.2
$93.6
$29.0
3.5
$38.5
$15.45
$16.35
$50.00
30.0
9.0
1.6
$6.10
25.0
$14.30
3.5
$13.00
$13.25
$31.50
5.0
6.0
$16.50
$12.55
$17.00
5.6
3.2
2.8
Note: Dollar amount and shares amount are in millions and exclude overallotment.
Source: SNL Financial and William Blairs market analysis.
7.9x
9.9x
12.8x
11.4x
5.2x
15.3x
$491.0
12.2x
$50.0
$190.7
$221.8
$91.7
$40.2
10.5x
14.0x
8.8x
5.3x
$47.6
18.1x
$34.2
17.5x
$22.5
1.7
10.2x
$79.5
1.8
$7.13
10.5x
$152.5
$12.50
2.3
11.2x
$65.0
$78.7
$284.7
$14.70
15.8x
10.4x
13.0
8.0
12.9x
$147.2
$21.90
$37.05
12.0x
$98.7
8.0
$7.59
13.0
$463.5
$131.8
13.0
$27.72
$14.67
7.9x
17.7x
$126.0
22.0
6.4x
$332.1
4.0
$22.32
29.4x
$11.00
13.3
16.8x
$294.3
$187.7
$224.5
15.0
11.3x
11.2x
13.5
$9.95
$191.4
$16.63
$22.14
$75.9
5.0
$26.85
16.5x
2.8
$13.02
$4.32
11.0x
21.7x
$34.0
$828.0
$12.91
11.4x
$219.9
2.0
$24.1
45.0
$18.68
6.1x
8.0
3.0
$18.40
$23.92
15.1x
10.0x
10.2
$27.61
10.4x
$72.7
$47.10
$11.63
LTM EPS
10.3x
$296.4
$11.8
23.1x
31.6x
LTM
Book Value
0.92x
0.74x
1.18x
1.01x
1.03x
1.25x
1.55x
1.00x
1.37x
1.08x
1.12x
1.29x
1.05x
1.38x
1.14x
0.87x
1.25x
1.24x
2.14x
1.14x
3.61x
1.95x
1.95x
1.13x
1.04x
0.94x
1.07x
0.85x
1.09x
0.76x
2.24x
0.88x
1.51x
1.00x
1.48x
1.17x
1.05x
1.75x
1.38x
1.02x
1.19x
1.11x
0.55x
2.43x
2.37x
1.26x
2.15x
0.85x
William Blair
Company
Offering Description
03/05/15
$500.0
03/10/20
03/02/15
$500.0
03/04/25
03/03/15
02/24/15
02/17/15
02/03/15
02/03/15
01/26/15
01/22/15
01/20/15
01/15/15
01/13/15
01/12/15
01/07/15
01/07/15
01/07/15
01/06/15
12/08/14
12/08/14
12/02/14
11/25/14
11/25/14
11/19/14
11/18/14
11/18/14
11/12/14
11/03/14
10/31/14
10/28/14
10/23/14
10/02/14
10/01/14
09/25/14
09/24/14
09/24/14
09/22/14
09/16/14
09/10/14
09/09/14
09/04/14
09/04/14
Floating rate series A senior unsecured global medium-term notes, due Dec
15, 2054
$25.0
$4,000.0
$500.0
$500.0
$600.0
$1,000.0
$100.0
$750.0
$1,000.0
$78.5
$600.0
$700.0
Floating rate series B medium term notes, due Oct 29, 2015
Floating rate series C senior unsecured medium-term notes, due May 12,
2017
5.000% Senior unsecured notes, due Oct 1, 2021
2.300% Series F senior medium term notes, due Sept 16, 2019
4.250% Senior unsecured notes, due Sept 15, 2024
$75.0
$300.0
$500.0
$400.0
$350.0
$750.0
$500.0
Caterpillar Financial Services Corporation 3.400% Series 84 senior notes, due Nov 25, 2017
RWT Holdings, Inc.
Amount
$325.0
$1,000.0
$400.0
$200.0
$300.0
$500.0
$175.0
$1,250.0
$1,250.0
$375.0
$500.0
$25.0
$800.0
$700.0
$1,250.0
$250.0
$500.0
$500.0
$1,000.0
$4,500.0
Maturity Date
03/09/18
03/03/25
03/02/20
03/30/25
03/15/22
02/03/20
01/16/20
01/27/25
01/27/17
01/16/18
02/15/22
02/01/22
01/15/20
01/15/20
01/09/18
12/11/17
12/15/54
12/05/24
01/15/20
12/15/19
11/25/17
01/15/20
11/15/19
11/17/17
10/25/24
12/01/19
11/04/19
10/29/15
10/15/17
07/28/17
05/12/17
10/01/21
09/30/24
09/25/21
10/01/19
09/16/19
09/15/24
08/15/19
09/06/24
William Blair
Company
American Express Company
Amount
$850.0
Call Date
03/15/20
11/05/14
$750.0
11/15/19
12/04/14
11/20/14
11/05/14
10/13/14
09/04/14
06/17/14
06/12/14
06/03/14
05/29/14
05/21/14
05/13/14
05/12/14
05/05/14
03/20/14
02/26/14
12/18/13
12/10/13
11/13/13
07/16/13
06/13/13
05/29/13
05/28/13
05/08/13
05/06/13
04/23/13
04/15/13
04/11/13
04/08/13
04/03/13
03/12/13
02/07/13
01/29/13
01/29/13
01/14/13
01/10/13
11/19/12
10/09/12
10/03/12
09/25/12
09/20/12
09/13/12
09/06/12
08/16/12
07/27/12
07/27/12
07/25/12
07/25/12
07/24/12
07/19/12
07/10/12
$240.0
$25.0
$36.0
$25.0
$150.0
$110.0
$75.0
$75.0
$28.0
$15.0
$55.0
$225.0
$125.0
$175.0
$75.0
$20.0
$100.0
$36.6
$300.0
$20.0
$1,000.0
$75.0
$150.0
$30.0
$200.0
$200.0
$50.0
$175.0
$175.0
$175.0
$135.0
$35.0
$74.0
$60.0
$325.0
$125.0
07/09/12
NorthStar Realty Finance Corp.
Note: Dollar amount in millions and excludes overallotment.
Source: SNL Financial and William Blairs market analysis.
$15.0
$500.0
$25.0
$100.0
$150.0
$400.0
$250.0
$75.0
$45.0
$50.0
$75.0
$1,750.0
$135.0
$102.7
$63.3
12/11/19
06/30/17
12/31/17
02/09/17
12/27/24
07/18/24
06/19/19
07/30/24
06/30/17
12/23/18
06/30/17
05/15/19
05/08/19
04/17/19
06/30/19
12/23/18
12/31/18
06/30/16
09/15/23
06/30/16
06/15/23
06/04/18
05/13/18
05/09/18
04/30/18
07/01/18
04/30/18
04/15/18
04/10/18
03/15/18
02/12/18
02/01/18
04/30/28
01/17/18
01/15/18
12/31/14
12/01/17
10/11/17
10/02/17
09/27/17
09/20/17
09/13/17
08/27/17
08/03/17
08/03/17
07/31/17
08/01/17
12/15/22
07/26/17
03/20/17
02/07/12
William Blair
William Blair
J.P. Young, Managing Director, is a member of the financial services industry group, where he focuses on the corporate finance needs
of banks, broker-dealers, and specialty finance companies. Mr. Young joined William Blairs investment banking group in 2009 from
Macquarie Capital and began his investment banking career in 2000 at Piper Jaffray. He has extensive experience providing M&A
advisory services and raising public and private-equity capital for clients. Mr. Young received a B.S. from Lehigh University and an M.S.
from the University of Chicago.
jyoung@williamblair.com
+1 312 364 8160
Kegan Greene, Vice President, joined William Blair in 2010. Before joining William Blair, Mr. Greene worked at Babcock & Brown,
Goldman Sachs, and Deloittes transaction services department. He holds an M.B.A. in finance and entrepreneurship from the
University of Chicago, a J.D. from DePaul University, and a B.A. in English from DePauw University.
kgreene@williamblair.com
+1 312 364 8113
William Blair
158,000,000
$70,000,000
$100,000,000
$29,000,000
$76,475,000
Arrow Global
Senior Notes
Follow-on Offering
Follow-on Offering
$1,285,000,000
Not Disclosed
$60,000,000
$151,800,000
$161,000,000
$66,815,000
Milestone Partners
Debt Placement
Follow-on Offering
Follow-on Offering
$100,000,000
Not Disclosed
$50,000,000
Not Disclosed
$34,000,000
Not Disclosed
has acquired
Persian Acceptance
Corporation
$287,500,000
$75,000,000
$18,750,000
has acquired
Follow-on Offering
$438,600,000
$51,000,000
525,000,000
has been acquired by
Convertible Senior,
Unsecured Notes
Follow-on Offering
Junior Unsecured
Notes
$42,000,000
$78,000,000
$92,000,010
$97,980,000
$35,000,000
$75,000,000
Follow-on Offering
Follow-on Offering
$125,000,000
$230,000,000
$74,000,000
Not Disclosed
$30,000,000
$102,212,920
Convertible Offering
Manheim
$75,469,000
188,893,000
$228,433,000
$15,000,000
28,000,000
$271,860,000
CFSI
INNOVATION
Follow-on Offering
Follow-on Offering
Follow-on Offering
COMPLIANCE
INTEGRITY
Second Lien
Term Loan
has sold a
minority stake to
Investcorp
Follow-on Offering
William Blair
Notes
William Blair
Disclosures
William Blair is a trade name for William Blair & Company, L.L.C. and William Blair International, Limited. William Blair & Company, L.L.C., is a Delaware company and is regulated by the Securities and
Exchange Commission, The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, and other principal exchanges. William Blair International Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority
("FCA") in the United Kingdom. William Blair & Company only offers products and services where it is permitted to do so. Some of these products and services are only offered to persons or
institutions situated within the United States and are not offered to persons or institutions outside of the United States.
This material has been approved for distribution in the United Kingdom by William Blair International Limited, Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), and is directed only at, and is only
made available to, persons falling within COB 3.5 and 3.6 of the FCA Handbook (being Eligible Counterparties and Professional Clients). This Document is not to be distributed or passed on to any
Retail Clients. No persons other than persons to whom this document is directed should rely on it or its contents or use it as the basis to make an investment decision.
William Blair & Company | 222 West Adams Street | Chicago, Illinois 60606 | +1 312 236 1600 | williamblair.com