Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This five classifications roughly correspond to the five classes of estimate defined in
the AACE Recommended Practice No. 17R-97[4]. This part will discuss on
Preliminary Design Estimate which is Class 3. For the cost estimation of a chemical
plant, a Class 3 estimate is typically +10% to -40% accurate. This means by doing
such an estimate, the true cost of building the plant would likely be in the range of
0.1 higher than and 0.4 lower than the estimated price. If greater accuracy is
required in the capital cost estimate, then more money and time must be expended
in conducting the estimate.
The purchased cost and an attribute of the equipment are the most common simple
relationship related to units of capacity and it is given by
Ca
A
= a
Cb
Ab
( )
Where:
Subscripts:
The cost of equipment is depend on past records or published correlations for price
information, it is essential to be able to update these costs to take into account
changing economic conditions (inflation). This can be achieved by using the
following expression:
C2 =C1
I2
I1
()
Where:
C= Purchased cost
I =Cost Index
Subscripts:
The value of K1, K2, and K3 can be obtained from Table A.1 and A is the capacity of
the equipment.
F BM =B 1+ B2 F M F P
+ 0.00315
2
( P+1 ) D
F P ,vessel =
Value of C1, C2, and C3 can be obtained from the Table A.2 and P is the unit pressure
of bar gauge or barg.
C BM =C oP F BM
D. Sample of Calculation
I.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
Step 1 (Characteristic)
E-301
E-302
E-303
E-304
E-305
E-306
E-307
E-308
E-309
A = 62.6 m2
A = 80.1 m2
A = 546 m2
A = 1567 m2
A = 348 m2
A = 57.8 m2
A = 54.6 m2
A = 22.6 m2
A = 17.5 m2
Floating Head
Floating Head
Floating Head
Fixed Head
Floating Head
Fixed Head
Floating Head
Fixed Head
Floating Head
SS-shell / SS-tube
SS-shell / SS-tube
SS-shell / SS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
CS-shell / CS-tube
K1 = 4.8306
K2 = -0.8509
K3 = 0.3187
K1 = 4.3247
K2 = -0.3030
K3 = 0.1634
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
E-301, Cp = $21,407
E-302, Cp = $23,212
E-303, Cp = $77,499
E-304, Cp = $105,842
E-305, Cp = $53,291
E-306, Cp = $19,865
E-307, Cp = $20,616
E-308, Cp = $16,369
E-309, Cp = $18,422
x.
xi.
xii.
xiii.
E-301, FP = 1.08
E-302, FP = 1.08
E-303, FP = 1.08
E-304, FP = 1.08
xiv.
xv.
xvi.
xvii.
xviii.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
II.
E-305, FP = 1.08
E-306, FP = 1
E-307, FP = 1
E-308, FP = 1
E-309, FP = 1
Step 1 (Characteristic)
H-301
T = 341.5 C
SS-tubes
K1 = 7.3488
K2 = -1.1666
K3 = 0.2028
H-301, Cp = $834,929
C1 = 0.1347
C2 = -0.2368
C3 = 0.1021
H-301, FP = 1
FT =1+0.00184 ( T )0.00000335
H-301, FT = 1.24
III.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
Step 1 (Characteristic)
P-301
P-302
P-303
P-304
P-305
Displacement
Centrifugal
Centrifugal
Centrifugal
Displacement
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel
Actual Power = 15 kW
Actual Power = 1 kW
Actual Power = 1 kW
Actual Power = 1.4 kW
Actual Power = 2.7 kW
K1 = 3.4771
K2 = 0.1350
K3 = 0.1438
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
P-301, Cp = $7,873
P-302, Cp = $2,501
P-303, Cp = $2,501
P-304, Cp = $2,578
P-305, Cp = $3,951
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
P-301, FP = 1.17
P-302, FP = 1
P-303, FP = 1
P-304, FP = 1.31
P-305, FP = 1.17
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
IV.
i.
ii.
Step 1 (Characteristic)
T-301
T-302
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel
45 SS Sieve Tray
76 SS Sieve Tray
K1 = 3.4974
K2 = 0.4485
K3 = 0.1074
K1 = 2.9919
K2 = 0.4465
K3 = 0.3961
i.
ii.
tray = 0.42
tray = 0.45
i.
ii.
i.
ii.
T-301, Cp = $44,477
T-302, Cp = $37,814
8500.6 ( P+ 1 )
+ 0.00315
2
( P+1 ) D
F P ,vessel =
i.
ii.
T-301, FP = 1.14
T-302, FP = 1.06
For Stainless Steel Sieve and Valve Tray: Identification number = 61, F BM = 1.8
For N 20, Fq = 1
i.
ii.
i.
ii.
i.
ii.
i.
ii.
V.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
Step 1 (Characteristic)
R-301
R-302
R-303
R-304
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
V = 20 m3
V = 25 m3
V = 30 m3
V = 1.67 m3
K1 = 4.7116
K2 = 0.4479
K3 = 0.0004
Pressure = 22 bar
Pressure = 22 bar
Pressure = 22 bar
Pressure = 22 bar
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
R-301, Cp = $197,246
R-302, Cp = $218,031
R-303, Cp = $236,633
R-304, Cp = $66,311
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
VI.
i.
Step 1 (Characteristic)
V-301
Horizontal
L/D=5
V = 7 m3
ii.
iii.
iv.
V-302
V-303
V-304
Vertical
Horizontal
Horizontal
L/D=3
L/D=3
L/D=3
K1 = 3.5565
K2 = 0.3776
K3 = 0.0905
For V-302:
K1 = 3.4974
K2 = 0.4485
K3 = 0.1074
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
V-301, Cp = $8,715
V-302, Cp = $11,306
V-303, Cp = $9,169
V-304, Cp = $8,176
V = 10 m3
V = 7.7 m3
V = 6.2 m3
B1 = 1.49
B2 = 1.52
For V-302:
B1 = 2.25
B2 = 1.82
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
+ 0.00315
2
( P+1 ) D
F P ,vessel =
V-301, FP = 1
V-302, FP = 1.03
V-303, FP = 1
V-304, FP = 1.02
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
VII.
I 2014
576.1
=C BM ( 2001 )
I 2001
394
No.
E-301
E-302
E-303
E-304
E-305
Heat Exchanger
E-306
E-307
E-308
E-309
Furnace
H-301
P-301
P-302
P-303
Pump
P-304
P-305
Tower
T-301
T-302
R-301
R-302
Reactor
R-303
R-304
V-301
V-302
Vessel
V-303
V-304
Total bare module cost,
CBM2011 ($)
11,503,595
E. Calculation for Total Module Cost (CTM) and Grassroots Cost (CGR)
CTM =1.18 C BM
i=1
= 1.18 x ($12,021,343)
= $14,185,185
= $14,185,185 + 0.50($11,503,595)
= $19,936,983
Factor
1. Direct cost
a. Raw materials
Description of Factor
Factors that vary with the rate of production
Costs of chemical feed stocks required by the process.
b. Waste treatment
c. Utilities
Fuel gas
ii.
Electric power
iii.
Steam(all pressures)
iv.
Cooling water
v.
Process water
vi.
vii.
Instrument air
viii.
d. Operating labor
e. Direct supervisor
ix. Refrigeration
Costs of personnel required for plant operations.
Cost of administrative/ engineering and support
personnel.
Costs of labor and materials associated with the
repairs
g. Operating supplies
maintenance.
Costs of miscellaneous supplies that support daily
operation not considered to be raw materials. Examples
include chart paper, lubricants, miscellaneous
chemicals, filters, respirators and protective clothing for
h. Laboratory charges
operators, etc.
Costs of routine and special laboratory tests required for
purposes.
Costs associated with property taxes and liability
insurance. Based on plant location and severity of the
process.
c. Plant overhead costs Catch-all costs associated with operations of auxiliary
(sometimes referred
to as factory
expenses)
a. Administration costs
manufacturing process
Costs for administration. Includes salaries, other
b. Distribution and
selling costs
c. Research and
development
The cost of manufacturing, COM, can be determined when the following costs are
known or can be estimated:
The table above gives data that are needed to calculate to estimate the individual
cost items that are identified above. With the exception of the cost of raw materials,
waste treatment, utilities, and operating labor all the data need to be calculate by
using certain equations. If no other information is available, the midpoint values for
each of these ranges is used to estimate the costs involved. Hence, all the
summation of the datas for the calculation of manufacturing cost can be simplified
into these equations:
We can obtain the total manufacturing cost by adding these three categories
together and solving for the COM and the result is:
= 1.18 CBM
= 1.18($12, 021343)
= $ 14,185,185
CGR
According to this method, the equation for the operating labor requirement for a
chemical processing plant is given by:
NOL= (6.29 + 3.17P2 + 0.23Nnp) 0.5
Where NOL is the number of operators per shift, P is the number of processing step
involving the handling of particulate solids, and N np is the number of non-particulate
processing steps handling steps includes compression, heating and cooling, mixing,
and reaction.
Nnp =
Equipment
Equipment
Compressor
Heat Exchanger
Furnace
Reactors
Towers
Vessels
Quantity
0
9
1
4
2
4
Nnp
0
9
1
4
2
-
Total
20
16
Hence, when Nnp is equal to165, the number of operating labor requirement is
NOL
NOL
= 3.158
The value of NOL is the number of operators required to run the process unit per shift.
A single operator works on the average 49 weeks (3 weeks time off for vacation and
sick leave) a year, five 8-hour shift a week.
= 49 week/yr 5 shift/week
= 245 shifts per operator/year
A chemical plant operates 24 hours per day. This requires (365 days / year
shift / day) 1095 operating shifts per year. The number of operators needed to
provide this number of shifts is
= 1095 shift/year
= 4.5 operators
Hence,
the operating labor = NOL 4.5 operators
= 3.158 4.5
= 14.21 15 operators
The cost of operating labor, C OL is equal to the salary given to each of operator
yearly which in this case the yearly salary given is $59, 580
Type
Type of
equipment
Heat exchanger
No. of
equipment
2
Price
$13.28 / GJ
$ 2,373,445.05
1.
Low-Pressure
Steam
2.
High-Pressure
Steam
Heat exchanger
$17.10/ GJ
$ 2,934,204.03
3.
Cooling Water
Heat exchanger
$0.354/GJ
$ 51,498.81
4.
Natural Gas
Furnace
$11.10/GJ
$ 2,755,953.47
5.
Electricity
Pump
$0.06/kWh
$ 13,989.28
Total
$ 8,129,090.59
1. E-301 Duty is 1.967 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of High-Pressure Steam =
$17.70/GJ
1.967
GJ
hr
$ 17.70
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 289,737.90 / year
2. E-302 Duty is 2.592 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of High-Pressure Steam =
$17.70/GJ
2.592
GJ
hr
$ 17.70
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 381,800.04 / year
3. E-303 Duty is 10.080 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of High-Pressure Steam =
$17.70/GJ
10.080
GJ
hr
$ 17.70
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 1,484,777/ year
4. E-304 Duty is 12.367 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of Low-Pressure Steam =
$13.28/GJ
$ 13.28
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 1,366,753.35 / year
5. E-305 Duty is 4.943 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of Cooling Water = $0.354/GJ
4.943
GJ
hr
$ 0.354
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 14,562.02/ year
6. E-306 Duty is 9.109 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of Low-Pressure Steam =
$13.28/GJ
9.109
GJ
hr
$ 13.28
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 1,006,691.70 / year
7. E-307 Duty is 7.276 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of Cooling Water = $0.354/GJ
$ 0.354
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 21,435.01/ year
8. E-308 Duty is 5.281 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of High-Pressure Steam =
$17.70/GJ
$ 17.70
GJ
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 777,888.13/ year
9. E-309 Duty is 5.262 GJ/h. From table above, Cost of Cooling Water = $0.354/GJ
$ 0.354
GJ
24 hr
1 day
= $ 15,501.70/ year
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
Equipment
P-301 A/B
P-302 A/B
P-303 A/B
P-304 A/B
P-305 A/B
15.0
1.0
1.0
1.4
2.7
Electric
(kW)
20.00
1.33
1.33
1.75
3.60
75%
75%
75%
80%
75%
= 28.01 kW x
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
= $ 13,989.28 / year
Benzene ($1.0934/kg)
kg
= 9276.721 hr
= $
$ 1.0934
kg
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
84,411,433.62
Ethylene ($1364/kg)
kg
3132.39 hr
$ 1.364
kg
24 hr
1 day
365 days
1 year
x 0.95
power
= $
35,556,421.76
84,411,433.62 +
35,556,421.76
$ 119,967,855.40
6) PROFITABILITY ANALYSIS
Working Capital, WC
= 20% FCI
= 20% ($19,936,983)
= $3,987,397
Land Cost, L
= $10,000,000
= $19,936,983