Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
A Region in Transition
You may neither copy nor disseminate this report. If quoted, proper attribution is required.
To order your copy of TrendLines, contact the Publications Administrator at 202.778.3100.
2
Foreword
To our friends, clients and colleagues:
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
PhilLIP M. McCarthy
Executive Managing
Director - Market Leader
Mid-Atlantic Region
Keith A. foery
Executive Managing
Director - Market Leader
Mid-Atlantic Region
In todays rapidly evolving real estate environment, access to timely and accurate market
information is vital to running your business successfully. The TrendLines Report has
delivered a valuable overview of the Washington, D.C., real estate market for many years.
This year marks the nineteenth annual TrendLines conference, and with it, a
longstanding tradition of informative and forward-thinking conversations among
the Washington, DC real estate community. Companies and institutions investing
in the regions real estate rely on TrendLines as the premier resource for
development and investment opportunities.
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
During the past year, innovative steps have been taken to boost the areas
economic growth with collaborative efforts throughout the DC metropolitan region.
Our nations capital continues its gentrification with exciting new projects located
in the SE and SW waterfront, as well as the expansion of the U Street, Shaw, and
14th Street neighborhoods. Virginia has immensely benefitted from Metros Silver
Line expansion and Maryland will open another casino this year at National Harbor.
Accompanying these developments, the recovering economy will complement
our growth as a region and as such, major corporations are choosing our region
for their headquarters. Together, these factors contribute to greater employment
opportunities, which increase our tax base for education and infrastructure.
Baker Tilly is dedicated to the real estate community and is recognized for
exceptional delivery of tax, assurance, and consulting services. Our professionals
look forward to continuing to advise the businesses and entrepreneurs who shape
DCs real estate industry. Our breadth and depth of resources focused on the real
estate industry help our clients maximize opportunities, implement actionable
ideas, and minimize risk in an ever-changing landscape.
PNC Real Estate is happy to continue sponsoring this premier resource for our regions
commercial real estate professionals. The Real Estate Banking segment of PNC Real
Estate has been a major participant in the Washington, D.C., marketplace since 1987.
Just in the last three years, our D.C. office has provided more than $3.0 billion in new
capital, including construction loans, bridge loans, lines of credit and permanent loans.
PNC Real Estate as a whole delivers one of the broadest platforms of products and
services in the industry. Our capabilities include acquisition, construction and permanent
financing for public and private developers and investors; agency financing for
multifamily and seniors housing properties; debt and equity capital for the affordable
housing industry; and access to the capital markets and treasury management services.
In addition, through Midland Loan Services, we provide third-party loan servicing, asset
management and technology solutions.
PNC is one of the nations top banks by deposits, with $362 billion in assets and 2,600
branches in 19 states and the District of Columbia as of September 30, 2015. Our
strength lies not only in our size, but in the innovative ways in which we deliver products
and solutions to help you achieve your business goals.
To learn how we can bring ideas, insight and solutions to you, call us or visit pnc.com/
realestate.
Sincerely,
Sincerely,
BAKER TILLY VIRCHOW KRAUSE, LLP
Michael N. Harreld
William R. Lynch III
President Senior Vice President
PNC Bank Greater Washington Area
PNC Real Estate
202.835.5513 202.835.4513
m.harreld@pnc.com william.lynch@pnc.com
PNC is a registered mark of The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (PNC).
2016The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
Table of Contents
Navigation Panel
Table of Contents
Previous Page
S1
S2
Section 1
A Region in Transition
Section 2
18
Section 3
28
Section 4
35
Section 5
44
Section 6
50
Section 7
60
Section 8
70
Section 9
78
Section 10
87
S3
S4
S5
Sections
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Next Page
A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S1 | A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
A Region in Transition
A Region in Transition
S2
While the overall economic news is positive, it comes with a major caveat: the forces that will drive
economic growth in the Washington region in the future will differ from those that have driven growth
in the past. Where past growth cycles in the region were led mostly by Federal employment and
procurement, all signs point to flat or declining Federal spending in the region over the next several
years. Consequently, the impetus for growth in the Washington economy and real estate market must
come from the private sector. There are several nascent efforts aimed at fostering better conditions
for starting and growing businesses in the Washington area. To succeed, these efforts must capitalize on the dramatic political, economic, and cultural changes that are reshaping how the region
will grow and prosper. With this in mind, we believe that Washington is a region in transition. Our
research for this years TrendLines highlights several ways in which the Washington area is changing.
S3
We think that change in the Washington area will be shaped in part by these four MegaTrends:
S4
S1
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
2. THERE IS A MISMATCH BETWEEN HOUSING SUPPLY AND DEMAND IN THE REGION. At recent
construction rates, the Washington metro area is producing 13,000 fewer housing units per year
than would be justified by job and household growth. Undersupply is helping fuel appreciation
growth that increasingly prices households out of the market. Two huge demographic cohorts
Baby Boomers and Millennials are driving the housing market, but with different and often
contradictory preferences. The mismatch between overall supply and demand and between
selection/price and household preference/budgets will be key issues for the region in the
coming years.
3. THE SHARING ECONOMY LOOKS A LOT LIKE LEASING OR BUYING. Today, it is possible to
take a vacation that includes driving a shared car, staying in a private room or home, using someone elses bicycle or golf clubs that you rented, eating a meal in a home with a local family while
wearing someones clothing that you rented, and then returning to work in your shared office
space. These are examples of the sharing economy one of todays hottest economic topics.
We take a look at two sharing economy examples that directly affect real estate: Airbnb and the
hotel industry; and coworking space and its relation to the conventional office market.
4. COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE MUST BECOME MORE RESILIENT. Catastrophic events, both
natural and man-made floods, storms, droughts, terrorism, cyber-attacks, and even economic
shocks require preparation and a new way of looking at the world. The term that has emerged
to describe these efforts is resilience. The commercial real estate community planners, developers, architects, engineers, construction companies, owners, and managers -- will need to be more
proactive in order to make their assets more resilient and protect their investments.
S1 | 8
A Region in Transition
This year is likely to be one of transition for the Washington metro areas economy and commercial
real estate market. We are likely to see a transition from weak job growth to stronger, from excess
apartment deliveries to more equilibrium conditions, and from experiential real estate as a new
niche to a full-fledged template of how to develop and operate real estate.
Yet, for all the change in our market, we see a lot of the constants enduring, qualities of the region
that have underpinned our successful market for decades: The highest-paid and best-educated
workforce in the country; the presence of the Federal government that lends stability and which
appeals to long-term investors; and the entrepreneurial spirit that is creating jobs and attracting
Millennials. Savvy investors can capitalize on this blend of transition and consistency to yield
successful real estate results.
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
+17
Reagan
Bush
+8
Clinton
Bush II
Obama
+21
-55
+23
-17
=+4
350
+74
300
-5
250
200
Source: BLS (Not Seasonally Adjusted), GMU Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates; February 2016.
For better or worse, the Washington metro area economy has long been dominated by the Federal
government. While the conventional wisdom remains that Washington is recession-proof, the truth
is much less optimistic. In fact, the influence of the Federal government over the Washington metro
areas economy has waned dramatically over the past several decades. In 1950, 38% of all jobs in the
region were provided by the Federal government; today, government workers account for just 12%
of the regions jobs. While the number of Federal jobs has fluctuated over the past 20 years, there
are presently about 365,000 people in the regions Federal workforce the same as in 1994.
Federal Procurement
Equally important to the regions economy is the influence of Federal procurement. Between 1980
and 2010, the amount of annual Federal procurement spending in the region increased from $4.2
billion to $82.4 billion. From 2010-2015, though, procurement spending decreased by 14%, and is
not expected to approach its 2010 peak anytime soon.
The combination of flat Federal employment and declining procurement is contributing to a dramatic
decline in the influence of the Federal government on the Washington areas economy. In 2010, the
Federal Government sector accounted for about 40% of the regions Gross Regional Product (GRP).
According to the George Mason University Center for Regional Analysis, by 2020 Federal spending
will represent only 27% of the Washington areas GRP.
2015
2010
2005
2000
1995
1990
1985
1980
1975
1970
1965
150
1960
S5
NixonFord Carter
+35
1955
S4
KennedyJohnson
400
1950
S3
Eisenhower
90
80
2015:
$71.1B
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S2
We hope the information in this report assists you in making informed decisions to meet your
business objectives in 2016 and beyond. Best wishes for success in the period ahead.
$ Billions
S1
Federal Employment
Source: GMU Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S1 | 9
A Region in Transition
The negative impacts of Federal cutbacks on the regions office market have been exacerbated by
the actions of the General Services Administration (GSA). During the current cycle, GSA has consolidated more Federal agencies in owned space, reduced the amount of square footage per employee,
and relocated several agencies to lower-cost spaces. As a result, from 2012-2015 the total amount of
office space leased by GSA in the region declined by three million square feet and the average rent
for GSA leases dipped by about $4.50/SF. The GSA is expected to continue these trends this will
further depress office demand and rental rate growth in the regions office market.
Fed Wages
& Salaries
10.0%
Looking ahead, several factors could have profound effects on the role of the Federal government in
the Washington areas economy:
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Non-Federal
60.2%
The 2016 presidential election is shaping up to be the most unpredictable race since at least
1968, and the results of the election could result in a fundamental reshaping of the governments footprint in the region. Or not cataclysmic changes anticipated ahead of previous
changes in administration and parties often did not pan out.
Pressure is building in Congress to pursue another round of Base Realignment and Closure
(BRAC) activity. The 2005 BRAC process resulted in a shift of millions of SF of office space from
leased buildings to GSA-owned properties, and between submarkets within the region.
Total Federal
39.8%
Fed Wages
& Salaries
6.7%
Total Federal
27.2%
Non-Federal
70.2%
Procurement
12.8%
Procurement
19.1%
2010
2020
Source: GMU Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates; February 2016.
The heightened threat of terrorist attacks is likely to lead to higher security standards for
government agencies, which would favor GSA-owned properties over leased space.
The potential for an international military conflict would ramp up defense spending, which
would drive procurement spending for defense and cybersecurity contractors.
Regardless of how these factors play out, it is clear that the Federal government will not dominate
the Washington regions economy in the future as it has in the past. The regions economic prospects going forward will necessarily depend far more on the performance of the private sector.
60
59
Millions of SF Leased
S1
Other Federal
7.7%
Other Federal
10.7%
58
57
56
55
54
53
2012
2013
2014
2015
S1 | 10
A Region in Transition
At recent construction rates, the Washington metro area is producing 13,000 fewer housing units per
year than would be justified by job and household growth.
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
While expected job growth will sustain demand for housing in the region, in practice, the regions
housing production has not kept pace with demand during this cycle. During the last expansion
cycle from 2000-2005, the region added an average of 37,000 housing units per year by comparison, the region only added an average of 21,000 units per year from 2010-2014. With demand projected to average 34,000 units per year, this recent construction pace amounts to an undersupply of
13,000 units per year. The repercussions of this undersupply include individuals sharing housing or
delaying household formation, and households finding homes outside the metro area and enduring
long commutes. Partly due to the slow pace of housing construction, the median home sale price in
the Washington metro area increased by 24% between June 2010 and June 2015.
The undersupply of housing in the region has also had a dramatic effect on the rental market,
particularly for low-income renters. From 2009-2015, Delta Associates research shows that the average effective apartment rent in the Washington area increased by 20%. The Washington area has
become of the most cost-burdened rental markets in the U.S. as of 2014, 81% of households in the
region that earn less than $45,000 per year spent more than 30% of their incomes on housing.
As with the rest of the U.S., the Washington areas housing market is primarily being influenced by
the wants and needs of two generations: Baby Boomers and Millennials. The divergent and often
contradictory preferences of these two generations will shape the regions housing market over
the next decade and beyond.
Thousands of Households
S3
2011
1,440
2023
1,400
1,200
1,000
830
67%
68%
800
675
600
400
32%
33%
200
0
Single-Family
Multifamily
Source: GMU Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates; February 2016.
2004:
38K
40,000
5+ Units
2-4 Units
SF
35,000
Permits Issued
S2
2014:
24K
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
S1
As of 2011 there were 2.12 million housing units in the Washington metro area. Of these, 675,000
(32%) were multi-family units. According to the George Mason University Center for Regional
Analysis, housing demand in the region between 2011 and 2023 will total 410,000 additional
housing units, an average of 34,000 per year. Of this demand, 155,000 units (38%) will be for
multi-family units.
1,695
1,600
5,000
0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
S1 | 11
A Region in Transition
S5
S6
65%
81%
60%
Photo
79%
78%
55%
73%
70%
63%
50%
57%
45%
56%
49%
48%
46%
to
S.
us
U.
Ho
s
lla
go
ica
Da
ta
lan
ph
At
Ch
ia
de
ila
Ph
rk
sto
Bo
Yo
w
es
el
Lo
Ne
sA
an
Fr
n
ng
cis
to
co
40%
S4
70%
ng
S3
75%
Sa
S2
80%
hi
S1
85%
as
Note: Cost-burdened households pay more than 30% of income for housing.
Source: JCHS tabulations of US Census Bureau ACS Data, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S7
S8
S9
S10
16%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
1990
2000
2010
2014
Year
Source: Census Bureau Decennial Census, ACS, and Current Pop. Survey, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S1 | 12
A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Millennials find themselves in a very different position. Only about one-quarter of young adults in
the U.S. are married and living in their own households, compared with 43% in the 1980s and 56%
in the 1960s. Many Millennials have yet to even form their own households: as of 2015, 35% of those
age 18-34 live with their parents this figure has historically hovered around 30%. Among those who
are living on their own, most are renting their homes, and a growing share is living in central cities or
close-in suburbs.
The critical question for the housing market as it relates to Millennials is this: Will they start buying
homes in large numbers and, if so, where will they buy? Like prior generations, Millennials do want to
be homeowners: Trulia reports that 93% of adults age 18-34 plan to buy a home in the future. More
critically, as documented in a recent ULI survey, a significant number of Millennials actually want to
live in the suburbs. With median single-family prices in excess of $500,000 in most of Washingtons
close-in suburbs, however, most young buyers will either need to settle for condos or townhouses, or
seek homes in outlying areas.
Boomers are bucking the patterns of previous aging generations in two key ways. First, they are
working longer the 2014 national labor force participation rate among the 65+ population was
17%, up from 15% in 2010 and from 12% in 1990. Second, Boomers more likely to stay in their
homes and age in place than prior generations, with the mobility rate for individuals age 65 and
older dropping from 5.0% in 1990 to 4.1% in 2014. Even with many Boomers aging in place, the
sheer size of this generation contributed to Boomers accounting for about half of all new renter
households in the U.S. over the past 10 years. So, contrary to popular notions, Millennials are not
the only force behind apartment demand.
93%
90%
80%
75%
72%
70%
60%
50%
39%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
18-34
35-44
45-54
55+
Age
Source: Goldman Sachs, Trulia, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S1 | 13
A Region in Transition
TRANSPORTATION
GOODS/FOOD
SERVICES
MONEY
Airbnb
Uber
Chegg
Freelancer
Lending Club
HomeAway
Lyft
Ebay
Instacart
Funding Circle
ZIpcar
Craigslist
Task Rabbit
Prosper
Onefinestay
RelayRides
Angies List
Kick Starter
Wework
Zimride
Etsy
Elance
Go Fund Me
Regus
Car2Go
Cookening
Bidwilly
Zopa
S1
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Today, it is possible to take a vacation that includes driving a shared car from Turo or Getaround,
staying in a private room or home that you found through Airbnb or HomeAway, using someone
elses bicycle or golf clubs that you rented through Spinlister or GearCommons, and eating a meal
in a home with a local family that you discovered through BonAppetour or Cookening while wearing
someones clothing that was listed on Rent the Runway or Vinted. And during your vacation, a pet sitter from DogVacay or Rover.com can take care of your dog. You can facilitate all of these transactions
through a website or an app on your smartphone, and when you return to work in your shared office
space at WeWork or Cove, you can write an electronic review of your experiences for others to read,
helping them to decide if this is for them. By the way, you will also be rated for your desirability as a
customer or a guest, so if you broke your Airbnb hosts best china without offering to replace it or pay
for it, you may want to look for a different service the next time around.
Perhaps you have noticed that none of these transactions involved any real sharing all of them
require a monetary payment. In other words, sharing is actually very similar to those conventional
concepts of buying and renting.
So how is the sharing economy affecting the real estate industry? We will try to answer that by looking
at two sectors where the sharing concept has had direct consequences for real estate: the lodging
and office sectors.
S2
Airbnb does not own any hotels, but it has more accommodations (listings) than the newly-merged Marriott/Starwood and Hilton combined,
according to The New York Times, and it is by far the largest sharing
economy service in the lodging sector. Since its founding in 2008,
Airbnb says it has grown to over two million listings serving 60 million
guests in more than 34,000 cities and 190 countries. It has a current
market capitalization of $25.5 billion; only Marriott/Starwood and
Hilton Worldwide are more valuable. Airbnbs revenue grew 106% in
2015 far outpacing Choice Hotels and Hilton, the next-closest hotel
chains, each of which saw about 9% growth.
In the District of Columbia, Airbnbs inventory is only about 12% as
large as the hotel room inventory, but this figure is growing. Given
that the Districts hotel occupancy rate has risen since 2010, even as
the room supply has grown, it appears that Airbnb may be helping to
expand the market instead of cannibalizing existing market share. Its
pricing may be affecting the composition of hotel demand, particularly
in the economy sector. The $118 average price of an Airbnb accommodation in the District in 2015 is about 43% less than the average
daily rate for a hotel room, indicating that Airbnb is primarily serving
the leisure travel sector, rather than business travelers, and perhaps
inducing new demand from guests who would not otherwise pay for
a hotel.
This could change, however, with the introduction of serviced apartments through Airbnb for Business, a new division offering rentals with
business class hotel amenities through a partnership with BridgeStreet, which has more than 50,000 mid-range and luxury rentals in
about 60 countries. Additionally, the Wall Street Journal reports that
Airbnb has discussed arrangements with national apartment operators
to allow tenants to rent out their units in exchange for a share of the
revenue. However, it remains to be seen if Airbnb will succeed in convincing local governments, tenant organizations, and property owners
and managers that increasing the number of apartments on Airbnb
will not cut the rental housing supply overall (affordable housing in
particular has been a sensitive political topic), flout existing zoning
regulations, affect tax revenues, or compromise security and safety
issues that have been raised in several cities already. Looking ahead,
Airbnb is expanding into new services that will improve the experiences of both its hosts and their guests and is expected to broaden
its strategic partnerships with apartment operators and perhaps even
hotel companies.
S1 | 14
A Region in Transition
In the case of WeWork, their business model involves renting large blocks of office space and building them out as fully furnished coworking spaces that range from unassigned desks in a large open
area to enclosed, lockable, private offices that can accommodate one or more people, and leasing
them on a month-to-month basis.
Today there are over 70 coworking or on-demand office space locations of various types in the Washington area. Variations include Cove, MakeOffice, Carr Workplaces, Metro Offices, Regus, and LiquidSpace (which is an online matchmaking service to list and find workspaces). The principal opportunity in the on-demand office space sector is that owners and managers can maximize their rents. For
example, it has been estimated that a typical coworking space in the Washington area averages 55
square feet per person and an average membership cost of $500 per month equating to more than
$90 per square foot in rent to the operator. Of course, this premium rent is offset by higher operating
expenses, and occupancy rates typically are lower than in the conventional office market. But the lure
of making productive use from otherwise vacant or under-utilized space is appealing.
While we expect coworking to continue to grow and to be a useful component of the office market, it
is not likely to replace the vast majority of conventional office space demand.
S1 | 15
A Region in Transition
The uptick in catastrophic weather events over the past 20 years is real and increasingly alarming.
From 1950 through the 1990s, there was an average of about two natural catastrophes per year
in the U.S. The average over the past decade has been eight per year; in 2011 alone there were
14 such events. In terms of economic damage, the two costliest types of natural catastrophes are
hurricanes/tropical storms and tornadoes. Between 1950 and 2013, these two types of events
caused more than $300 billion in damages (in 2014 dollars), representing 80% of the total damage
nationwide.
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
A wide variety of responses have been advanced to address the mounting threat from both natural
and man-made catastrophes. The Federal government now requires local governments to prepare
hazard mitigation plans in advance of disasters in order to qualify for FEMA funding. Congress has
passed several new laws aimed at improving the National Flood Insurance Program. Numerous state
and local governments have undertaken adaptation plans that ensure that infrastructure and buildings are protected from rising sea levels. The nonprofit community has taken on many initiatives,
most notably the Rockefeller Foundations 100 Resilient Cities program that is building a dialogue
among peer cities facing similar issues.
Professionals in the planning, engineering, and design fields have been devising new approaches
to resilience. This is exemplified by RELi, a resiliency standard created by the design firm Perkins +
Will that is modeled on LEED (the Leadership in Energy & Environmental Design rating system of
the U.S. Green Building Council) and measures how effectively buildings are designed to respond to
different types of hazards and events. RELi is envisioned as a standard that can be used by underwriters to measure the mitigation of risk for structures built in vulnerable locations.
6%
7%
41%
Tornadoes $154.9
Winter Storms $26.9
Terrorism $24.5
Wind/Hail/Flood $21.4
39%
Fires $6.0
Geologic Events $0.5
S9
S10
S1 | 16
A Region in Transition
Extreme Wind
Drought
Envelope strengthening
Graywater recycling
Rainwater catchment
Xeric landscapes
Material specification
Operable windows
Glass that deflects heat
Green roofs
S1
Sea-Level Rise/Flooding
S2
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
The commercial real estate community has been somewhat slower to respond to the rapidly
increasing need for resilience, though. The conventional wisdom in the real estate development
and finance world is that resiliency requires enormous upfront capital outlays with no increase on
return. The challenge is that future damages from floods and other natural disasters are typically not
measured in development pro formas, so there is no way to know the potential costs of ignoring
resilience measures.
There are several recent projects that are challenging this mindset mainly located in floodplains or
coastal areas. While these have mainly been large-scale mixed-use projects such as The Wharf here
in Washington, there have been some smaller scale developments in other cities that have begun
to incorporate resilience into their designs. As the threat of catastrophic events rises, the real estate
community will need to be more proactive in order to protect their investments.
The Washington area is, in spite of its low-lying location and prevalence of floodplain, well positioned to thrive in a resilience-focused world. A recent study by Grosvenor examined the vulnerability and adaptability of cities in the U.S. and globally. While this study found that Washington was
moderately at risk for future catastrophes, particularly flooding, it also found that Washington was
among the most prepared cities in the world in terms of its ability to respond to hazards. This adaptability should be a great asset for Washington real estate in the years to come.
Resiliency Rankings
United States | 2010-2015
Least Vulnerable
Most Adaptive
1. Chicago
1. New York
2. Pittsburgh
2. Los Angeles
3. Atlanta
3. Washington, D.C.
4. Boston
4. Chicago
5. Detroit
5. San Francisco
6. Washington, D.C.
6. Houston
7. Seatlle
7. Boston
8. New York
8. Pittsburgh
9. San Francisco
9. Seattle
10. Atlanta
S3
S1 | 17
S2
After a sluggish start, the national economy ended 2015 on a high note with strong job gains and
respectable GDP growth. Through November 2015, the U.S. economy marked 70 consecutive
months of job gains and added more jobs in the past two years than in any two-year period since
1998-2000. The unemployment rate is low, new claims for unemployment insurance are at cyclical
lows, and home prices rose. Still, some indicators have been only tepid and economic and political
troubles around the globe reverberate through the U.S. economy, leading to the feeling that things
are not quite stable yet.
S3
S4
Payroll job growth was strong, with 2.71 million jobs added during 2015; job growth was led
by the Professional/Business Services sector, which is among the highest paying employment
sectors. In addition, the Federal government finally posted a net job gain in 2015, ending
several consecutive years of reductions.
S1
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
The unemployment rate continued to decline through the year, and stood at 5.0% at December
2015.
After a sluggish start to 2015, GDP growth resumed in the 2nd quarter of 2015 and remained
healthy throughout the balance of the year.
GDP growth was primarily driven by increased consumer spending, though inventory cutbacks and
a slowdown in net exports prevented stronger growth. Strong employment growth over the year
pushed the national unemployment rate down throughout the year, even as the labor force
participation rate increased. Despite the healthy job increases, much of the growth has come in
lower paying industries, leading to weak wage growth. This should change over the next couple of
years, as higher-wage industries add more jobs and the low unemployment rate forces businesses
to compete for top talent.
Another encouraging sign for the national economy is continued growth in consumer buying power
from increases in both household net wealth and revolving credit. These trends reflect the upside of
historically low interest rates, which have encouraged consumers to invest their cash in riskier assets
and reach for their credit cards. With the national economy having weathered a scare in the international markets in August, the Federal Funds Rate was increased for the first time in nearly a decade
at the December 2015 meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC). The increase was
just one quarter of a percent and will likely slow consumer spending and revolving credit somewhat,
but will strengthen the dollar even further.
Revolving Credit
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
2013
2015*
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
-5.0%
-10.0%
-15.0%
-20.0%
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015*
Moving forward, the U.S. economy is poised to continue gaining strength through 2016 and beyond.
Major economic indicators are moving in a positive direction, although wage growth, international
trade, and economic turbulence in China and Europe remain areas of concern. The timing and size
of additional increases to interest rates also bear watching over the coming year.
S2 | 19
S8
Net monthly job growth for the last three months of 2015 averaged over 275,000 jobs; this resurgent
job growth has helped dispel concerns that the economic recovery was faltering after recording two
consecutive months of net job additions below 200,000 in August and September. Month-to-month
gains (seasonally adjusted) from January to December 2015 has averaged approximately 221,000
jobs per month:
S9
S10
S6
S7
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
15
15
c.
De
15
v.
No
15
t.
Oc
15
p.
Se
15
g.
Au
15
ly
Ju
15
ne
ay
Ju
15
.1
r.
Ap
15
ar
M
b.
15
Ja
Fe
14
n.
14
c.
14
0
De
S5
2,500
v.
S4
Public Sector
3,000
t.
S3
Job growth was robust throughout 2015 with the national economy adding 2.71 million new payroll
jobs over the year. Nearly all job growth was in the private sector, with 2.6 million private jobs added
over the 12-month period. After several years of job reductions, public sector employment began
to pick up in 2015, especially in the latter half of the year, with 110,000 new jobs added during the
year. The pace of public sector hiring is currently at its highest level since early 2010.
Private Sector
3,500
No
S2
Payroll Jobs
Oc
S1
Job Change
Note: Data are not seasonally adjusted.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S2 | 20
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
An ongoing area of concern for the national economy is the national average hourly wage, which
has increased at a slow rate since the end of the recession. Over the past five years, the growth rate
of average hourly wages has hovered around 2.0%. Prior to the recession, from 2007 to 2009, the
hourly wage growth rate averaged 3.1%. This is a pressing issue for many aspects of the economy,
including price levels and consumption patterns.
S1
The unemployment rate (seasonally adjusted) declined to 5.0% as of December 2015, down from
5.6% one year earlier, and marking its lowest level since before the Great Recession. This decline
occurred despite the labor force increasing 1.9% during the same time period. As the nations
economy has returned to a healthy state, unemployed persons are becoming more confident in
being able to find full-time jobs. The unemployment rate should continue to decline in 2016, but
at a slower rate, as the number of cyclically unemployed persons dwindles.
There are multiple competing theories that may explain the weak wage growth. One is that slow
growth in wages is an indicator that the jobs being created are in lower-paying industries. Even
if people are finding jobs, they are likely to be underemployed, meaning job seekers are taking
jobs that are below the education and experience levels they have achieved. Another theory has
to do with the changing composition of the workforce. The average age of workers has remained
relatively constant over the last few years, which indicates that younger workers are entering the
workforce at a faster pace than other age cohorts. These younger workers tend to start with lower
salaries, which may partly explain depressed average wage growth.
A third theory is that, due to slow moving wage adjustments, known as sticky wages, firms could
not adequately reduce wages to offset lower demand during the Great Recession, and we are
witnessing a slow correction in wages or pent-up wage cuts as workers become more accepting of
reduced nominal wages. Wage growth tends to be a lagging indicator of an economic recovery, and
the current recovery has progressed much slower than most. The combination of low unemployment and continued employment growth should lead to stronger wage growth in 2016 and beyond.
Unemployment Rate
United States | 1980 2015
12%
10%
Overall, initial unemployment claims have steadily decreased since peaking in March 2009. As of
the first week of January 2016 initial claims were 275,750, based on a four-week seasonally-adjusted
moving average. This is 5.8% below the same week in 2015, and 27.2% below the 15-year average
of 348,794. Unemployment claims should continue to erode into 2016 as the nation approaches full
employment and cyclical unemployment approaches zero.
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
80
85
90
95
00
05
10
15
3%
2%
1%
0%
2007*
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S2 | 21
Full-Time
3,000
Part-TIme
2,000
1,000
0
-3,000
-6,000
S6
S7
2015
S5
2010
-5,000
2014
-4,000
S4
2013
S3
-2,000
2012
S2
2011
S1
-1,000
S8
S9
S10
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
Thousands of Jobs
Note: Based on 12-month trailing average. Data are not seasonally adjusted.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S2 | 22
S2
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Real GDP growth for the 3rd quarter of 2015 was estimated at 2.1%, somewhat below the expected
growth rate of 2.7% for the quarter. GDP growth in 2015 was largely driven by consumer expenditures, state and local government spending, and exports, but was held back by restrained inventory
accumulations by businesses. After starting 2015 on a sour note, with 1st quarter GDP coming in at
a paltry 0.6%, GDP quickly recovered, recording a very healthy 3.9% growth rate in the 2nd quarter.
The economy shook off many of the weaknesses during 2015 including harsh weather, declining oil
prices, a sell-off in international markets (mainly China), and accelerated appreciation of the dollar,
which sent net exports plunging.
Looking forward into 2016, strong consumer spending will continue to be the main engine of economic growth, but steady improvements in the housing market, Federal and state/local government
spending, and business investments will move the economy forward as well.
The most recent report from the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphias Survey of Professional
Forecasters projects real GDP growth to be 2.8% in the 4th quarter of 2015 and 2.4% for all of 2015.
Looking further ahead, real GDP is predicted to average 2.6% in 2016, 2.5% in 2017, and 2.8% in 2018.
Corporate Profits
U.S. corporate profits totaled $2.06 trillion during the 3rd quarter of 2015 on an annualized basis,
down very slightly from $2.08 trillion in 2nd quarter of 2015 and from $2.20 trillion in the 3rd quarter of 2014. Corporate profits have largely plateaued in recent years as more companies are taking a
cautious approach of buying back shares and slowly increasing dividends. Companies are continuing to weigh options on how to best deploy earnings and profits and, in many cases, are showing
a preference for mergers and acquisitions over riskier, capital intensive projects that could rock the
boat for shareholders. However, the recent increases in hiring indicate that corporate leaders are
becoming more confident about consumer demand.
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2%
-4%
-6%
-8%
-10%
Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3 Q1 Q3
07 07 08 08 09 09 10 10 11 11 12 12 13 13 14 14 15 15
Note: Quarters are seasonally adjusted at annual rates.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
$120
Corporate Profits
S&P 500 12-Month EPS
$100
$2.0
$80
$1.5
$60
$1.0
$40
$0.5
$0.0
S4
S1
S3
Another positive indicator is the declining job availability ratio the relationship between potential
applicants and the number of jobs available. The national job availability ratio was 1.2 as of November
2015, down from 1.6 in November 2014. The Professional/Business Services sector had the greatest
number of job openings as of November 2015, with 1,074,000 jobs, and had the lowest job opening
ratio at 0.8, tied with the Education and Health Services sector.
The past year has been an auspicious time for underemployed workers seeking full-time employment.
As recently as 2011, the U.S. economy was adding more part-time than full-time jobs. Since 2014,
though, the gap (seasonally adjusted) between full-time and part-time employment growth has
grown along with the overall workforce. In August 2015, the gap between the 12-month net gain
in employment for full-time and part-time jobs reached a post-recession high of 4.03 million. The
gap narrowed somewhat in the fall, and was 2.69 million as of December 2015. Full-time positions
translate to more hours worked and higher paychecks. Recent trends in full-time employment seem
to also indicate that any negative effects of Obamacare on full-time hiring have been blunted by the
need for more full-time workers.
$20
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015*
$0
Note: *Through Sept. 2015, seasonally adjusted at annual rates. Yearly data are not seasonally adjusted.
EPS reflect operating earnings as of Sept. 2015.
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Standard and Poor's, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S2 | 23
Home prices in the 20 major metro areas covered by S&P/Case-Shiller increased 5.5% during the
12 months ending October 2015, the most recent data available. This is up from the September
2015 figure of 5.4%. The growth rate of home prices largely stabilized in 2015 as expanding
inventories of homes for sale in many metro areas eased pricing pressure. With an interest rate
hike just implemented, mortgage rates will almost certainly see a corresponding increase. However,
we expect the housing market to continue to flourish into 2016 with increased construction and
higher sales prices.
S2
According to the National Association of Realtors, the annualized pace of existing home sales
decreased to 4.8 million (preliminary) in November 2015, down from 5.0 million in November 2014.
The average existing home sales price was $263,900 (preliminary) in November 2015, up 4.0% from
$253,800 in November 2014.
S3
S4
The Federal budget deficit for the 2015 fiscal year was $439 billion (2.5% of GDP)--the lowest level
since FY 2007, and below the 40-year average. The budget shortfall in FY 2015 marked the sixth
consecutive year that the deficits share of the GDP has decreased since peaking at 9.8% in 2009.
The smaller deficit is attributed to greater than anticipated tax revenues from businesses and households as a result of the improving economy. In spite of this progress, the U.S. is still running a deficit
we are not paying down our debt, we are just increasing it at a slower rate.
S7
S8
S9
S10
After years of political wrangling Congress finally passed a budget bill in the 4th quarter of 2015,
which was signed by President Obama in November. The budget brought an end (at least for the
short term) to the ongoing drama of impending Treasury defaults, Federal government shutdowns,
and forced continuing resolutions. Federal discretionary spending caps were raised by $80 billion
over the next two years and provide $32 billion in overseas contingency funds to the Pentagon.
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
-20%
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
6,000
$280,000
$270,000
$260,000
5,500
$250,000
5,000
$240,000
4,500
$230,000
4,000
$220,000
3,500
3,000
S6
20%
S5
-25%
S1
Housing Market
$210,000
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014 2015*
$200,000
While the budget deal provides some fiscal stability over the next couple of years, there are still
many long-term concerns. Without action, the deficit would reach $1.0 trillion by 2025, with growth
driven by an aging population, rising health care costs, an expansion of Federal subsidies for health
insurance, and growing interest payments on the Federal debt. The national elections of 2016 could
have a major impact on the long-term picture as well, since the outcome could lead to profound
changes in Federal taxation and spending policies.
S2 | 24
Over the past couple of years the economic recovery has been fueled by healthy employment
growth. All major employment sectors have experienced strong job growth, with the high-wage
Professional/Business Services sector leading the way. The unemployment rate steadily declined
by 60 basis points over the 12 months ending December 2015, and the national economy is now
approaching the point of full economic employment. We expect that the sustained health of the
employment market will lead to improvements to the housing and retail markets in 2016.
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
0.0%
6%
30-Year Treasury
5%
4%
3%
2%
1%
14
13
12
11
10
09
08
07
15
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
06
0%
05
The national economic recovery continued in 2015, with most of the damage done by the Great
Recession now in the rear view mirror. GDP growth is projected to be 2.8% in the 4th quarter and
2.4% for all of 2015.
2016
20
Economic Outlook
2015
0.5%
% of GDP
04
Inflation remained flat during the 12 months ending November 2015, with a strong dollar and
lower domestic energy prices keeping prices in check. This is well below the Feds benchmark of a
2.0% increase, which had been a contributing factor to the delay in raising the Federal Funds Rate.
The personal consumption expenditure price index (PCEPI), which takes into account changes in
consumption habits as people substitute some goods and services for others, rose 0.4% during
the 12 months ending November 2015. We expect inflation to be contained in the near-term due
to modest wage growth and a strong dollar, coupled with the fact that price pressure tends to lag
economic growth by a year or more. Given these conditions, inflation will likely remain in the 0.5%
to 1.0% range on an annualized basis through 2016.
-1,200
Deficit
20
S10
1.0%
-1,000
03
S9
1.5%
-800
20
S8
2.0%
02
S7
2.5%
-600
20
S6
3.0%
01
S5
3.5%
-400
20
S4
Global financial markets are expected to experience continued volatility in the short-term, at least
until uncertainty surrounding the Chinese economy, and the Chinese governments corrective
measures, diminishes. Sudden swings in commodity prices and exchange rates also remain a concern. Sectors that have benefited from record-low borrowing rates will experience the most market
volatility. Commercial real estate and the REIT sphere are experiencing downward pressures as the
market accounts for higher costs of capital, though REITs with solid property fundamentals should
be able to weather the storm. As of the end of trading on January 12, 2015, the S&P 500 index stood
at 1938.68, down about 4% over the previous 12 months. The Index reached a 2015 high of 2130.82
on May 21, up 13% over 12 months.
4.0%
-200
00
S3
In addition to the December 2015 interest rate increase, the Fed has also indicated its intention to
enact further incremental increases to interest rates in 2016. Still, interest rates have been at historically low levels, so the expected modest increases will keep long-term interest rates relatively low.
4.5%
20
S2
20
S1
There had been a great deal of discussion throughout 2015 about when the Fed would increase
the Federal Funds Rate, and by how much. Stock market woes on Wall Street brought about by a
faltering Chinese economy and extremely low oil prices led the Federal Open Market Committee to
decline to raise rates at its September meeting. The somewhat disappointing August and September job growth numbers furthered the rumor that any interest rate hike would be pushed into 2016.
However, revitalized job growth in October and November, and consumer price increases, provided
the FOMC with the confidence to implement a slight, 0.25% increase in the Federal Funds Rate
target at the December 16 board meeting. The rate hike, which was nearly universally anticipated,
is the first since the recession.
Data are non seasonally adjusted monthly averages. 30-Year Treasury not issued between
March 2002-Dec. 2005.
Source: Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED), Delta Associates; February 2016.
S2 | 25
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Overall, 2016 will bring another year of sustained, but modest economic growth. The national
economy will expand and add jobs over the next year, but growth will continue to be slower than
in past economic recovery cycles.
S1
Another major concern moving forward in 2016 is international trade. China, one of the largest U.S.
trading partners, is in the midst of a considerable economic slowdown which will likely be a drag on
U.S. net exports bad economic news from China has already caused significant of economic turbulence in the first weeks of 2016. In addition, a strong U.S. dollar which saw virtually zero inflation in
2015, will also hurt the nations trade balance. We do expect inflation to return modestly, especially
since energy prices have likely hit bottom.
Percentage Change
Despite the generally good economic news in 2015, the current recovery has shown a few areas
of weakness. The primary area of concern is the lack of significant wage growth, stemming from
job growth in lower-paying sectors and limited competition for quality workers. We expect 2016 to
bring improvement in this area, as the pool of unemployed workers looking for jobs continues to
dry up and employers increase compensation to attract the best qualified personnel.
14%
CPI-U
12%
PCEPI
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2%
80
85
90
95
00
05
10
Note: *CPI-U and PCEPI through November 2015. Data reflects 12-month percentage change.
Source: Federal Reserve Economic Database (FRED), Delta Associates; February 2016.
job change
% change
2015
2,707,000
1.9%
2014
2,649,000
1.9%
2013
2,289,000
1.7%
2012
2,262,000
1.7%
2011
1,567,000
1.2%
2010
-958,000
-0.7%
2009
-5,937,000
-4.3%
2008
-766,000
-0.6%
2007
1,538,000
1.1%
2006
2,393,000
1.8%
2005
2,256,000
1.7%
Inflation: 1.5-2.5% for 2016 as consumer demand continues to strengthen, but fuel costs
remain low.
2004
1,431,000
1.1%
2003
-310,000
-0.2%
2002
-1,446,000
-1.1%
Federal Funds Rate: At least one incremental increase in 2016, following the 0.25% increase
in December 2015.
Long-term interest rates: Edging higher during 2016, particularly short-term rates, following
the Federal Funds Rate increase. Long-term interest rates will only increase very modestly.
The U.S. economy gained 2.65 million payroll jobs over the 12 months ending November 2015,
virtually unchanged compared to all of 2014. This compares to the 25-year annual average of 1.2
million jobs at a 1.0% average growth rate.
15*
Note that BLS has rebenchmarked figures since their initial publication; the figures presented above are
the most recent estimates.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates, February 2016.
S2 | 26
New York
167,000
job change
%
1.8%
LA Basin
S1
S2
S3
METRO AREA
Denver-Boulder
36,600
2.7%
Portland (OR)
36,500
3.3%
73,200
1.7%
Austin
36,100
3.9%
39,000
2.5%
Charlotte
35,500
3.3%
Riverside/San Bernardino/Ontario
46,100
3.5%
San Antonio
35,300
3.7%
158,300
2.2%
Philadelphia
34,500
1.2%
Detroit (Detroit/Warren/Livonia)
33,800
1.8%
52,300
5.1%
Baltimore
31,600
2.3%
42,200
4.1%
Minneapolis-St. Paul
30,700
1.6%
Total LA Basin
San Francisco Bay Area
S4
Oakland/Fremont/Hayward
S5
1.7%
Indianapolis
30,100
3.0%
3.6%
Nashville
26,900
3.0%
101,200
3.0%
Sacramento
24,400
2.7%
Atlanta
86,500
3.4%
Houston
23,700
0.8%
S7
Washington, DC
61,900
2.0%
23,400
3.5%
S8
Seattle
55,100
2.9%
Las Vegas
23,100
2.6%
Columbus (OH)
21,700
2.1%
Cleveland
18,700
1.8%
S6
S9
S10
Dallas/Ft. Worth
18,100
112,600
South Florida
West Palm Beach/Boca Raton
12,800
2.2%
Fort Lauderdale
27,000
3.4%
Raleigh-Durham
18,300
2.2%
Miami/Miami Beach/Kendall
18,100
1.6%
Cincinnati
16,800
1.6%
57,900
2.3%
Jacksonville
16,300
2.6%
Phoenix
49,600
2.6%
Kansas City
12,300
1.2%
47,900
1.8%
Pittsburgh
12,000
1.0%
Chicago
47,000
1.0%
Oklahoma City
10,700
1.7%
Tampa-St. Petersburg
40,500
3.3%
St. Louis
9,700
0.7%
Orlando
39,900
3.5%
Memphis
San Diego
37,800
2.7%
New Orleans
5,300
0.8%
(1,700)
-0.3%
S2 | 27
S3 | The Washington
Area Economy
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
2015 Highlights
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
The regions labor market is also doing well, with the unemployment rate continuing to decline
even as the labor force expands. The regional unemployment rate as of November 2015 was 4.1%,
well below the national average of 5.0%. One area of concern is the regions average wage, which
is down substantially from its 2010 peak. Wages are likely to begin increasing in 2016, though, as
growth has resumed in the metro areas Professional/Business Services sector, which has by far the
highest average wage among the regions top employment sectors. The recent passage of a Federal
budget has removed a major source of short-term uncertainty and should help bolster the regions
economic growth prospects. As economic output and labor demand increase, competition among
firms for top talent will also drive wage growth.
S1
The Washington areas economy performed very well in 2015, with most economic indicators
showing positive trends. Job growth has been particularly strong, with 61,900 net job additions
during the 12-month period ending November 2015, and year-end employment growth figures are
expected to show the regions strongest job growth in a decade. The private sector has been the primary source of job growth as it gains influence on the regional economy, but Federal employment
and procurement have stabilized after several years of declines. The Professional/Business Services
and Education/Health sectors led the region in job creation, adding 36,400 jobs combined between
November 2014 and November 2015.
The Washington metro is still an attractive place to do business, visit, and live. A recent Washington
Business Journal article documented how Washington sits at or near the top of many top 10 best
cities lists covering a range of factors, including: growth in STEM employment (science, technology,
engineering, math), women in technology, energy efficiency, walkability, gender pay equity, and job
opportunities for young professionals. With the regions fundamentals now back on track as well, all
indicators point to sustained economic growth over the next five years.
S3 | 29
Following two weak years, 2015 brought a return to strong job growth for the Washington metro
area economy, mirroring national trends. During the 12 months ending November 2015, the metro
area added an impressive 61,900 new payroll positions, well above the 20-year annual average of
41,800. Looking ahead to 2016, we expect job growth in the Washington metro area to continue at a
pace similar to what it did in 2015. With 3.2 million payroll jobs, the Washington metro area ranks as
the fifth largest job market, behind only New York, the LA Basin, Chicago, and Dallas/Ft. Worth.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
The top four sectors for job growth in the Washington metro area in the 12 months ending
November 2015 were Professional/Business Services, Education/Health, State/Local Government,
and Construction. These sectors alone accounted for a net gain of 50,900 jobs, representing more
than three-fourths of the total employment increase. The most positive development in 2015 was
in the Professional/Business Services sector, which rebounded from a net job loss in 2014 to reclaim
its place as the primary driver of job growth in the metro area. This is significant for the regional
economy since jobs created in the Professional/Business Services sector tend to pay well and
increase demand for office space.
Another notable trend in 2015 was the modest gain in Federal Government employment. This
sector shed jobs each year from 2011 and 2014 due to Federal budget reductions, so the increase,
however slight, is an indication that the recent period of Federal turmoil has been resolved at least
until the 2016 election. The only major sector to shed jobs over the year was Retail Trade, which is
one of the regions lowest-paying sectors.
The stronger performance in the Washington metro areas job market has been influenced by a
steadily growing private sector share of the regional economy. The private sector has been responsible for the vast majority of the job growth in the Washington region over the past two years,
although the waning effects of Federal budget cuts have helped. The bump in Federal employment growth, the recently approved Federal budget, and growing state and local budgets point to
a brighter future for public sector employment, but the majority of job growth will continue to be
sourced from the private sector.
100
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
-60
94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15*
*12 months ending in November 2015.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S1
The Washington areas rebound in 2015 was due in part to a surging national economy most of the
major metro areas also recorded healthy job growth over the year. The New York metro area led the
nation in total job growth in during the 12 months ending November 2015, followed by the LA Basin
and San Francisco Bay metro areas. During this time period, the Washington metro area ranked sixth
in the nation in terms of net job growth. The Professional/Business Services and Education/Health
sectors were the leading sources of job growth in most metro areas in 2015, including Washington.
Payroll Jobs
140,000
120,000
100,000
80,000
61.9
60,000
40,000
20,000
0
NY
LA SF Bay DFW
Basin
Atl
Was
South
FL
Phx
Bos
Chi
Denver Hou
S3 | 30
S1
12-month
change
20-Year Annual
Average
Professional/Business Services
Education/Health
Professional/Bus. Svcs.
735.3
24.9
15.6
Education/Health
427.8
11.5
9.1
Construction/Mining
344.2
8.3
4.1
Leisure/Hospitality
Construction/Mining
157.4
6.2
1.7
Leisure/Hospitality
304.5
4.2
5.6
Federal Government
Other Services
197.4
2.8
3.6
Financial Activities
66.8
2.5
-0.1
Other Services
Transportation/Utilities
Wholesale Trade
S2
Transportation/Utilities
S3
Federal Government
364.8
1.4
0.6
Manufacturing
Financial Activities
151.5
0.1
1.0
Retail Trade
63.3
0.1
0.0
Wholesale Trade
S5
Information
76.2
0.1
-0.3
S6
Manufacturing
50.0
0.0
-1.0
281.4
-0.2
1.9
3,220.6
61.9
41.8
S8
S9
S10
Total
Unemployment Rate
- 200
-5,000
1,000
7,000
13,000
19,000
25,000
Job Change
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
Unemployment Rate
S7
Retail Trade
Information
The Washington metro area, along with most other major metro areas, saw a marked decline in
unemployment in 2015. Although it maintained the lowest unemployment rate among the nations
large metro areas during the recent recession, the Washington metro area now has the fifth lowest unemployment rate among its peer group. Still, the regions unemployment rate has declined
steadily from its post-Recession peak of 7.1% and its November 2014 level of 4.6% to just 4.1%
in November 2015. This compares favorably with the national (seasonally adjusted) rate of 5.0%
as of November 2015, which is also down substantially from its November 2014 level of 5.8%.
We expect the Washington metro areas unemployment rate to hover around 4.0% during 2016.
8%
November 2014
November 2015
7%
Unemployment Rate
S4
62,100
National
Rate*
5.8%
6%
5.0%
5%
4%
3%
2%
1%
0%
-100
-40
Bos
Was
NY
Hou
Phx
S Fla
Atl
-50
-50
-110
60
-60
-60
-120
LA
Chi
-200
-60
Basin
*Seasonally adjusted.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S3 | 31
S1
Overall inflation was relatively flat in the Washington/Baltimore region in 2015, but it ticked upward
toward the end of the year as the economy grew. During the 12 months ending November 2015,
prices in the metro area increased 0.6%, which was higher than the national inflation rate of exactly
0.0% over the same period, but still minimal. Both the regional and national rates are far below the
2.0% rate that the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) targets. The marginal increase in the
regional inflation rate was driven by a 1.8% increase in the cost of housing and 5.6% increase in the
cost of medical care, but these were offset by a 7.0% decline in transportation costs. Low oil prices
and a strong dollar are holding back significant gains in the CPI, but this will likely change over the
long term. We expect inflation to pick up slightly in 2016 as the economy grows. Wage growth in the
coming years will also cause inflation to pick up.
S2
Housing Prices
S3
Home prices increased 2.1% (seasonally adjusted) in the Washington metro area during the 12
months ending September 2015, according to the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Index. This compares to a growth rate of 5.5% for the 20-City MSA Composite Index. The regions price growth has
been hampered by a growing inventory of homes for sale and a shift in market share toward condominium units, which priced lower than single-family units. Looking ahead, sustained job growth
should drive increased housing prices over the next few years.
S4
S5
S6
3%
2%
1%
0%
-1%
-2%
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S7
S8
S9
S10
25%
Washington MSA
20%
Percent Change
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
-20%
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
S3 | 32
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Federal Government
As with direct Federal employment, the stabilization of Federal procurement has been a major factor
in the regions economic rebound during 2015. Contractors are finally adjusting to the new economic environment in the region, which now depends more strongly on the private sector than the
public sector. Growth in Professional/Business Services by far the regions largest economic sector
bodes extremely well for continued forward momentum in the regional economy in 2016.
The Education/Health Services sector has stayed on its long-term growth trajectory: it was the only
non-government sector in the region to gain jobs during the Great Recession, and it has continued
to post strong employment gains throughout the recovery. The impact of this sectors growth is
blunted by the fact that most of its growth has occurred in lower-wage occupations, though. This
is also a concern for two other sectors: Retail Trade and Leisure/Hospitality.
35%
34%
Technology
Building Industry
$502
Billion
Int'l Business
Health/Education
Hospitality
3%
Other
5%
5%
5%
15%
Source: George Mason University Center for Regional Analysis, U.S. Conference of Mayors, Delta Associates;
February 2016.
20%
S2
A major share of Federal spending in the metro area economy is from procurement the governments purchase of goods and services from the private sector. After three years of declines,
total procurement spending in the Washington metro area (measured by place of performance)
increased 3.0% during 2014 (compared to revised 2013 data), to roughly $71.2 billion (in 2014
dollars). This represents 45% of all Federal funds flowing into the area economy. Since these dollars
drive private sector investment and job growth, they have a much greater secondary economic
impact than do dollars spent on Federal payroll.
S1
Share of GRP
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
-15%
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014*
*Projected
Source: George Mason University Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S3 | 33
After experiencing slow and inconsistent growth between 2011 and 2014, the Washington metro
area finally experienced a sustained economic expansion in 2015 we expect this positive trend to
continue through 2016 and beyond. Net job growth improved from 36,500 during the 12 months
ending November 2014 to a solid 61,900 for the 12 months ending November 2015. We expect future years to bring more gains, with 66,400 new jobs expected in 2016 and 57,800 in 2017. Although
employment growth is expected to slow somewhat in 2018 and beyond, the five-year forecast of
54,500 net new jobs per year represents a higher level of growth than the region has experienced
since the middle of the last decade.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Private sector job growth will in turn depend on expanding businesses already located in the region
rather than businesses lured from outside the region. The Washington areas high wages, property
costs, and taxes put the region at a competitive disadvantage for attracting companies that are
looking for low-cost places to do business. Efforts to build on the regions native assets a highly
skilled workforce, access to international markets, high quality education, and vast cultural resources
should drive strong employment growth in the Professional/Business Services sector. Growth in this
sector will both increase demand for commercial space and create additional jobs in the Education/
Health, Retail Trade, Leisure/Hospitality, and Construction sectors.
District
Sub. MD
No. Virginia
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
-60
00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, George Mason University Center for Regional Analysis, Delta Associates;
February 2016.
S1
This expansion cycle will necessarily be driven by the regions private sector. The regions business
community and elected leaders have correctly identified that Federal employment and contracting
can no longer be relied upon to drive economic growth, although the heavy Federal presence in the
region will continue to provide economic stability and shield the area from the worst effects of any
national or global economic downturns.
The passage of a Federal budget and related appropriation bills at the end of 2015 is critical to the
Washington metro areas economy. Moving forward into 2016, the regional economy is entering
a period of transition. While the Federal governments role in the economy is expected to remain
stable, its influence on the regional economy continues to wane. The region will need to respond to
profound changes in the global economy, security, the climate, demographics, the housing market,
and other factors. These factors are already reshaping business and real estate in the region and will
continue to do so over the next several years.
S3 | 34
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
During 2015 net absorption totaled 1.9 million SF and the overall vacancy rate declined 40 basis
points during the year the first decline in the vacancy rate since 2010. Despite these improving conditions, rents remain under pressure and declined 0.5% during 2015, as the vacancy rate
remains elevated. However, the pace of decline eased during the year, as generous concession
packages leveled off.
S1
We believe performance fundamentals will continue to improve during 2016, as the economy
strengthens and tenants become more certain about the economic outlook. Rental rate momentum
will appear in some submarkets in 2016, with metro-wide growth slightly positive and below average.
There are limited blocks of new Class A space on the market. Given the flight to quality, the pipeline
of new or renovated product could expand during 2016.
National Context
At 421 million SF of private office space, the Washington metro area is the 3rd largest office market
in the nation, behind New York and Los Angeles.
Net absorption of office space in the Washington metro area totaled positive 1.9 million SF during
2015. The San Francisco Bay, Dallas/Ft. Worth, and Houston markets were leaders in net absorption
during 2015.
S4 | 36
The Washington areas overall vacancy rate is 14.2% at year-end 2015, down from 14.6% one year
ago. Still, the Washington metro has the highest overall vacancy rate among large metro areas in the
United States. The San Francisco Bay and Boston metro areas have the lowest vacancy rates at 6.2%
and 8.4%, respectively.
2015 Highlights
S1
Net absorption: Positive 1.9 million SF during 2015, compared to negative 1.2 million SF
during 2014. The flight to quality continues: 2.1 million SF of Class A/Trophy space was
absorbed in 2015.
S2
Overall vacancy rate: 14.2%, down from 14.6% one year ago. Compares to 10.6%
national rate.
S3
Direct vacancy rate: 13.5%, down from 13.8% one year ago.
S4
Pipeline (U/C and U/R): 7.8 million SF, down from 5.4 million SF one year ago.
S5
S6
Effective rents: Effective rents: Down 0.5% during 2015, compared to a decline of 4.1%
during 2014.
S7
S8
Investment sales: $6.2 billion ($355/SF) during 2015, compared to $5.8 billion ($392/SF)
during 2014.
900
800
700
600
500
421
400
300
200
100
0
NY
LA Basin
Was
Chi
Bos
SF Bay
Phil
DFW
Hou
Atl
S9
12
Net Absorption
Net absorption in the Washington metro area totaled positive 1.9 million SF during 2015, compared
to negative 1.2 million SF during 2014. This compares to the 15-year average annual absorption of
3.6 million SF.
Each substate area within the Washington metro area had positive net absorption during 2015, with
the District of Columbia leading the way. The regions positive absorption was driven by a handful
of pre-leased deliveries and healthy leasing activity. For example, the Department of Justice signed
a 336,000 SF deal at 175 N Street, NE in NoMa. In addition, MRP Realty delivered 111,000 SF at 900
G Street, NW in the East End, which was 46% pre-leased at delivery to Simpson Thacher & Bartlett
and Herman Miller.
Net absorption was offset during 2015 by a handful of move-outs, including: Freddie Mac vacated
217,000 SF at 8000 Jones Branch Drive in Tysons, LMI vacated 235,000 SF at 2000 Corporate Ridge
Road in Tysons, and NIH vacated just over 150,000 SF at 6610 Rockledge Drive in North Bethesda.
S10
10
4
1.9
SF Bay
DFW
Hou
Bos
LA Basin
NY
Atl
Chi
Phil
Was
S4 | 37
14%
S1
S2
12%
8%
6%
4%
S3
2%
S4
0%
S5
S6
10%
SF Bay
Bos
NY
Phil
LA Basin
Chi
Atl
Hou
DFW
Was
S7
S8
S9
S10
18,000
16,000
14,000
12,000
15-Year Annual Average = 3.6 Million SF
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
-2,000
-4,000
00
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
S4 | 38
Throughout this cycle the markets newer buildings have significantly outperformed older properties.
Between 2009 and 2015, the net absorption of space in buildings less than 15 years in age was
positive 23 million SF, which buildings more than 15 years old suffered negative net absorption of
15 million SF.
S1
S2
S5
2014
Northern Virginia
(376)
464
Suburban Maryland
(1,132)
634
District of Columbia
271
841
(1,237)
1,939
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
2015
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
District of Columbia
Leasing Activity
25,000
Leasing activity in the Washington metro area increased during 2015, bolstered by some of the largest deals in this cycle. Notably, leasing by the Federal government increased to 15% of the total SF
leased during 2015, up from 5% during 2014. Major GSA leases during 2015 included: the Department of Defense renewing 912,000 SF at 2530 Crystal Drive and 2521 S. Clark Street in Crystal City/
Pentagon City and the Department of Justice signed for 336,000 SF at 175 N Street, NE in NoMa.
While 2015 was a better year than 2014, the Federal share of total leasing activity still remains well
below its 10-year average of 22%.
S4
Market
S3
Tenants continue to favor Class A space, but the gap between Class A and Class B/C space narrowed
in 2015. Net absorption of Class A space totaled 2.1 million SF during 2015, compared to negative
151,000 SF in the Class B/C market. During 2014, Class A absorption totaled 2.1 million SF and was
offset by negative absorption of 3.3 million SF of Class B/C space.
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
-5,000
-10,000
District of Columbia
Suburban Maryland
Northern Virginia
-15,000
-20,000
S4 | 39
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Vacancy Rate
S1
The Washington areas overall vacancy rate is 14.2% at year-end 2015, down from 14.6% one year
ago. The Washington metro areas direct vacancy rate was 13.5% at December 2015 down from
13.8% one year ago.
The Washington areas overall Class A vacancy rate is 12.6% at year-end 2015, down significantly
from 13.9% one year ago. The Washington areas direct Class A vacancy rate is 11.7%, down from
12.7% one year ago.
There are 1,160 buildings with contiguous blocks of available space that are 10,000 SF or greater at
December 2015, level compared to 1,161 one year ago. Just over half of the total blocks are located
in Northern Virginia. There are 142 buildings with blocks of space available over 100,000 SF, down
from 150 buildings one year ago. The number of large blocks decreased in Northern Virginia and
Suburban Maryland, but increased slightly in the District of Columbia.
Office Leasing
Balance
80%
Federal
60%
10-Year
Average =
22%
65%
40%
45%
20%
26%
15%
2009
Gross Leasing
Activity (SF) 26.2 M
9%
2010
2011
2012
2013
5%
2014
31.4 M
34.8 M
32.6 M
32.9 M
28.7 M
0%
DEC. 2014
DEC. 2015
Northern Virginia
17.0%
16.8%
Suburban Maryland
16.4%
15.9%
District of Columbia
Washington Metro Area
9.8%
9.2%
14.6%
14.2%
2015
30.9 M
1,160
1000
DC
800
Sub MD
NOVA
696
600
400
308
200
142
15%
Leasing activity from GSA could pick up during 2016, as several potential leases are waiting for
approval from Congress. However, we expect leasing will remain below average as Congress
continues to force densification measures on agencies requesting office space.
10,000 SF
20,000 SF
50,000 SF
100,000 SF
S4 | 40
Developers started construction on 4.0 million SF during 2015, up from 3.3 million SF during 2014.
Northern Virginia accounted for just over 50% of the total groundbreakings in the metro area, with
the District of Columbia closely following with 46% of the metro total. Although starts increased during 2015, the level is below the 10-year annual average of 6.1 million SF.
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
During 2015, Property Group Partners started on a total of 1.0 million SF at 200 and 250 Massachusetts Avenue, NW in the Capitol Hill submarket. The buildings are currently 0% pre-leased and are
expected to deliver by year-end 2018. The buildings are part of the Capitol Crossing mixed-use
project, which will deliver just over 2.0 million SF of office, retail, and residential combined upon full
build out. Also, Capital One started work on its 975,000 SF headquarters near the McLean Metro
station in Tysons; this building will deliver by 2018.
We expect construction starts to ramp up during 2016, as there is limited new space on the market.
However, groundbreakings should occur only in the very few submarkets where the supply and
demand is balanced. We expect renovations of Class B/C buildings to rise, as landlords position
themselves to compete for Class A tenants. In underperforming submarkets, conversation of older
vacated office space to multifamily, medical office, or self-storage could occur.
Developers delivered 1.7 million SF of office space, including renovations, in the Washington
metro area during 2015. These projects came online at 41% pre-leased. Notably, Boston Properties
delivered 479,000 SF at 601 Massachusetts Avenue, NW in the East End. This building was 84% preleased at delivery, with Arnold & Porter occupying 384,000 SF. In addition, COPT delivered 160,000
SF at 4870 Stonecroft Boulevard in the Rt. 28 South/Chantilly submarket, fully leased to GSA.
DEC. 2013
DEC. 2014
DEC. 2015
There is 7.8 million SF of office space under construction or renovation in the Washington metro
area at December 2015, up notably from 5.4 million SF one year ago. 50% of the space under
construction is pre-leased at December 2015, compared to 38% one year ago. This compares very
favorably to the 10-year average pre-lease rate of 40%.
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
2000
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Northern Virginia
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
2009
8,000
0.5
3.7
2008
Suburban Maryland
10,000
0.9
7.8
2007
12,000
1.3
2.4
2006
District of Columbia
Suburban Maryland
5.4*
2005
14,000
3.6
2.4
2004
16,000
2.0
64*
2003
2.8
Total
2002
Northern Virginia
District of Columbia
2001
In Thousands of SF
Construction
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S4 | 41
We project the metro-wide overall vacancy rate will continue to decline over the next two years
from 14.2% now to the low-to-mid 13% range by December 2017. Although we expect demand to
gradually increase over the next two years, we do not believe this demand will be robust enough
to significantly lower the vacancy rate metro-wide, as tenants consolidate or vacate space as new
product delivers. A portion of the demand will be generated by pre-leased deliveries arriving to the
market over the next two years.
We project the Northern Virginia overall vacancy rate will edge down to the high-15% range by
December 2017, from 16.8% today.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
We project the Suburban Maryland overall vacancy rate will edge down to the mid-14% range
by December 2017, from 15.9% today.
Although the Federal government approved a budget deal in late 2015 that will alleviate some of
the lingering effects of sequestration, the deal is a short-term solution to a longer-term problem,
as the looming deficit remains an issue. Regardless, we expect tenants to become more confident
about the economy over the next two years and therefore be more apt to lease office space, but at a
reduced rate compared to past recovery periods.
Effective Rents
The average effective office rent declined 0.5% during 2015, though the decrease was far smaller
than the 4.1% decline during 2014. Concession packages remained elevated during 2015, as landlords competed for tenants. For a typical 10-year term for a new lease deal signed during 2015, tenant improvement allowances averaged around $74.00 PSF with 11.6 months of free rent. Concessions remained relatively on par with the 2014 levels of $72.00 in tenant improvement allowances
and 11.1 months in free rent.
SF Available at Delivery
SF Leased at Delivery
12,000
We project the District of Columbia overall vacancy rate will edge down to the mid-8% range by
December 2017, from 9.2% today.
S1
In Thousands of SF
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
57%
36%
36%
23%
72%
61%
67%
52%
63%
41%
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
San Francisco
18.05%
New York
16.60%
Phoenix
15.53%
Atlanta
15.52%
Chicago
13.47%
National Average
13.05%
Denver
12.65%
Boston
11.64%
Dallas
10.82%
Los Angeles
9.80%
Houston
8.80%
Washington
6.79%
Wash. CBD
8.81%
Wash. Suburbs
1.96%
NCREIF compiles return based on its members $168.7 billion office portfolios.
The index includes both current income and capital appreciation returns.
Source: Delta Associates, based on data in NCREIFs 3rd Quarter 2015 Real Estate Performance Report.
S4 | 42
We expect that effective rents will edge up 0.5% to 1.5% during 2016 as the economy improves and
leasing activity picks up. Newly-constructed office buildings should experience greater rent gain as
the availability of such space is dwindling. Overall, the market remains in tenant favor, but the window of opportunity to secure lowered rents on larger blocks of quality Class A space in the centrally
located submarkets is closing or has closed in submarkets with better supply/demand balance.
Investment Sales
Investment sales totaled $6.2 billion or $355/SF in the Washington metro area during 2015, up from
$5.8 billion or $392/PSF during 2014.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Investment Returns
Total returns (cash flow plus appreciation) realized in the Washington office market were 6.79% for
the 12 months ending September 2015. The Washington area return is outpaced by the national
return of 13.05%, as other metro areas surpass the Washington market. Washingtons CBD returns
were notably higher compared to those of the suburbs.
S1
The average cap rate for core office assets in the Washington metro area, on a 12-month trailing basis, was 6.1% at the end of the 4th quarter of 2015, according to Real Capital Analytics. The average
cap rate is down 27 basis points from one year ago. We believe the 12-month trailing average cap
rate will remain in the low-6% range during 2016. However, trophy assets will likely continue to trade
at lower cap rates. Cap rates for recent Class A/Trophy trades have been in the mid-4% to mid-5%
range.
S4 | 43
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S5 | The Washington/Baltimore
Regional Flex/Industrial
Market
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
400
200
0
LA Basin
Chi
NY/NNJ
Phil
DFW
Atl
Det
SF Bay
Hou
Bos
Was/Bal
We expect greater traction during 2016, as rising demand, coupled with fewer large blocks of available
space, will create tighter market conditions that will lower the vacancy rate and push up asking rents.
National Context
8.6%
8%
S2
S1
Demand resulting from a much-improved economy in the Washington/Baltimore region and global
changes in retailing and distribution of consumer goods, together with a limited supply of large
contiguous blocks of space, combined to create very favorable conditions for the flex/industrial
market in 2015. Net absorption totaled positive 3.1 million SF due to pre-leased deliveries and
leasing activity, primarily in bulk warehouse space. The overall vacancy rate edged down 10 basis
points to 8.6% at year-end 2015. With tenants demanding efficient and modernized space, the
construction pipeline expanded. Given these conditions, asking rents grew 2.3% during 2015,
which was above average.
1,600
7%
6%
5%
4%
3%
2%
1%
0%
LA Basin
Hou
SF Bay
Det
NY/NNJ
DFW
Chi
Phi
Bos
Atl
Was/Bal
The Washington/Baltimore flex/industrial market, at 400 million SF, is the smallest market among the
nations largest metro areas. The markets primary function is regional distribution, accommodation
of R&D, and a low-cost office alternative in flex space.
S5 | 45
At 8.6%, the Washington/Baltimore regions overall vacancy rate is above the national average of
6.6%. The LA Basin and Houston metro areas have the lowest vacancy rates at 2.6% and 4.6% as of
December 2015, respectively.
2015 Highlights
Net absorption: 3.1 million SF during 2015, compared to 6.4
million during 2014.
Net Absorption
Overall vacancy rate: 8.6%, down from 8.7% one year ago.
Flex/industrial net absorption totaled 3.1 million SF in the Washington/Baltimore region during 2015,
compared to 6.4 million SF during 2014. This is slightly below the 15-year average of 3.6 million SF
per year. Although net absorption was lower compared to the year prior, it is important to note that
several large pre-leased deliveries drove net absorption during 2014. For example, 2010 Broening
Highway delivered 1.0 million SF fully leased to Amazon Fulfillment Center and 1467 Perryman Road
delivered 946,000 SF fully leased to Clorox in Harford County.
Direct vacancy rate: 8.4%, down from 8.5% one year ago.
Under construction: 3.8 million SF, up from 3.2 million SF one
year ago.
Pre-leased deliveries and other major lease deals boosted absorption during 2015. For instance:
22745 and 22755 Relocation Drive in the Dulles Corridor delivered 251,000 SF fully leased
to Amazon.
S5
7210 Preston Gateway Drive in the BWI submarket delivered 291,000 SF fully leased to
Coca-Cola.
S6
Pier 1 Imports leased 644,000 SF at 500 Old Post Road in Harford County.
S7
Canusa Corporation Fiber Group leased 216,000 SF at 8203 Fischer Road in Dundalk.
S2
S3
S4
S8
S9
S10
Office Movers leased 95,000 SF at 10100 Willowdale Road in Prince Georges County.
Bulk warehouse was the leader in net absorption during 2015, accounting for 2.5 million SF or 80%
of the total for all property types. The Washington metro area captured 82% of the regions net
absorption with Baltimore accounting for only 18%. This was due to several move-outs in Baltimore
City that hampered gains. For example, Henry Bath vacated 532,000 SF at 2200 Broening Highway
and Unilever vacated 152,000 SF at 3701 Southwestern Boulevard.
net absorption
2015
SF
SF
Bulk Warehouse
126.3
32%
2,457,000
Flex/Warehouse
245.6
61%
243,000
27.6
7%
358,000
399.58
100%
3,058,000
Flex/R&D
Total Flex/Industrial
S1
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
-2,000
-4,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
S5 | 46
sf
Washington
189.4
47%
2,497
82%
Baltimore
210.1
53%
561
18%
Total Flex/Industrial
399.5
100%
3,058
100%
S1
S2
S3
There were 935 buildings with contiguous blocks of available space over 10,000 SF in the Washington/Baltimore region at year-end 2015. This compares to 985 buildings one year ago. There are 89
buildings with blocks of available space over 100,000 SF in the region, down from 95 one year ago.
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
The largest block of available space is 1.3 million SF of Class C space at 2800 Eastern Boulevard in
the Baltimore metro area. The largest block of space in the Washington metro area is 509,000 SF
of flex/warehouse building located at 6805 Industrial Road in the I-95 Corridor. However, plans are
in place to convert this building to the 436,000 SF St. James Sports and Wellness Complex. Once
converted, this building will be removed from the flex/industrial inventory.
Vacancy Rate
1,000
935
Bulk Warehouse
Flex/Warehouse
800
Flex/R&D
564
600
400
232
200
S4
1,200
Number of Buildings
SF
The regions overall flex/industrial vacancy rate was 8.6% at year-end 2015, down from 8.7% one
year prior. The Washington areas overall vacancy rate is 50 basis points lower than the Baltimore
areas rate, a reverse trend compared to December 2014 when Baltimores rate was 60 basis points
lower than Washingtons rate. The regions direct vacancy rate was 8.4% at December 2015, down
from 8.5% one year ago.
89
0
10,000 SF
20,000 SF
50,000 SF
100,000 SF
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
2000
2002
2001
2004
2003
2006
2005
2008
2007
2010
2009
2012
2011
2014
2013
2015
The direct vacancy rate has been on a steady decline since peaking in 2009 at 10.6%. The rate is
currently below the 10-year average of 9.2%.
S5 | 47
Construction
The amount of flex/industrial space under construction in the region is 3.8 million SF at year-end
2015, up from 3.2 million SF one year ago. Space under construction is 55% pre-leased at December 2015, up significantly from 29% one year ago.
Redwood Capital Investments broke ground on 306,000 SF project at 2001 Wharf Road in Baltimore
County East during 2015. This project is fully leased by FedEx and is expected to deliver during the
1st quarter of 2016. In the Washington metro area, Prudential started on 236,000 SF at 13150 Mid
Atlantic Boulevard in Prince Georges County. This project should deliver by mid-2016.
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
Tenants are in the market for upgraded space with a focus on efficient building design and site layout, which includes better trailer loading, clear heights, column spacing, and parking. As a result, we
anticipate spec construction to ramp up to satisfy the undersupply of upgraded space during 2016.
Although the pipeline is set to expand, we believe several older and inefficient flex/industrial buildings will be demolished and converted to another property type. Notably, of the product that has
been demolished over the past 10 years, 49% has been converted to multifamily. We expect this to
occur in submarkets located inside the Beltway.
S7
Developers added 4.2 million SF of flex/industrial inventory to the market during 2015, compared to
5.6 million SF during 2014. Projects came on line at 36% pre-leased during 2015, compared to 87%
pre-leased on projects delivering during 2014.
S8
Supply v. Demand
S9
S10
The regional flex/industrial vacancy rate likely will tick down to the mid-to-high 7% range by yearend 2016, from 8.6% today. The vacancy rate will decline as leasing activity accelerates during the
next 12 months. Demand will be boosted by pre-leased deliveries, as over half of the 3.8 million SF
pipeline is pre-leased.
Washington/Baltimore Region
year-end
2005
year-end
2010
year-end
2015
Washington/Baltimore Region
8.1%
10.6%
8.4%
7.3%
11.4%
8.0%
8.9%
9.7%
8.7%
market
SF U/C
%
pre-leased
at 12/2015
sf u/c
%
pre-leased
Washington
1.5
35%
2.5
61%
Baltimore
1.7
23%
1.3
44%
Total Flex/Industrial
3.2
29%
3.8
55%
S6
Flex/Industrial Deliveries
Washington/Baltimore Region | 2015
metro area
millions of sf
delivered
Washington
%
pre-leased
1.7
42%
Baltimore
2.5
31%
Regional Total
4.2
36%
Bulk Warehouse
Flex/Warehouse
Flex/R&D
% change
december 2014 to december 2015
0.4%
4.0%
-1.4%
S5 | 48
Asking Rents
Flex/industrial asking rents in the Washington/Baltimore region increased 2.3% during 2015,
compared to a 1.2% increase during 2014. Flex/warehouse experienced the greatest gain in rent at
4.0%, which was slightly offset by the 1.4% decline in Flex/R&D rents.
Flex/industrial rents should rise during 2016 as market conditions continue to improve. We expect
flex/industrial rents to increase 2.5% to 3.0% during 2016.
Investment Sales
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Flex/industrial investment sales volume totaled $1.2 billion or $84/SF in the Washington/Baltimore
region during 2015, up from $706 million or $87/SF during 2014. Notably, MRP Realty and JP
Morgan Asset Management purchased the Northern Virginia Industrial Park in the I-95 Corridor for
$86.5 million, or $106/SF. In the Baltimore metro area, First Industrial Realty Trust purchased 400
and 500 Old Post Road in Harford County for $61.9 million or $62/SF.
We expect investment sales activity to remain healthy in 2016 as market conditions continue to
strengthen. We anticipate those with cash will continue to take advantage of purchasing flex/industrial assets in the Washington/Baltimore market, given its long-term growth prospects and stable
nature.
S5 | 49
2015 Highlights
Stabilized vacancy for all classes of investment grade apartments decreased by 60 basis points over the past year
currently at 3.9%, while Class A vacancy decreased by
100 basis points to 4.6%.
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Will these trends continue? Before we get to our outlook for 2016, lets understand the regions
national context and review the apartment markets recent performance.
National Context
Though seventh in population, the Washington metro area is the sixth-largest apartment market in the
U.S. with an inventory of approximately 580,000 units, which places it behind New York, the Los Angeles
Basin, Chicago, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Dallas/Fort Worth. The Washington metro-wide
vacancy rate is 3.9% for all classes of apartment product at 4th quarter 2015. The national rate is 4.3%.
Rents
S2
S1
Washington area Class A apartment absorption continues to break records six quarters in a row
and counting as the number of apartments filled remains well above historic norms. Demographic
and economic shifts in the market favoring apartments helped the region withstand the ongoing
influx of new supply in 2015. Absorption outpaced deliveries in Northern Virginia and The District.
Rent growth remains positive albeit very slight and vacancy is on the decline. Meanwhile, the
development pipeline was down overall for the year.
Metro area effective rents for all classes of investment-grade apartments rose by 0.5% in 2015. Class
A rents increased by 0.5% and Class B rents rose by 0.6%. Rent performance for Class A low-rise
product (up 1.4%) outperformed mid- and high-rise product (down 0.5%).
Vacancy
Washington metro area stabilized vacancy for all classes of apartments is 3.9% at 4th quarter 2015,
60 basis points lower than a year ago.
The December 2015 vacancy rate for stabilized Class A apartments in the Washington metro
area is down 100 basis points from a year ago to 4.6%.
Mid- and high-rise stabilized vacancy is down 150 basis points, while low-rise stabilized vacancy
is down 40 basis points.
National Rate:1
4.3%
5.0%
4.0%
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
NY
LA
Chi
Wash
Phi
Phx
DFW
Balt
Hou
Atl
The 79 largest apartment markets in the U.S.
1
The Quarter
79 largest
apartment
markets
in the U.S. Baltimore, and Philadelphia which are as of Fourth Quarter 2015.
*3rd
2015
data except
for Washington,
1
*3rd Quarter 2015 data except for Washington, Baltimore, and Philadelphia which are as of Fourth Quarter
2015.
Source: REIS, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S6 | 51
S1
S2
S3
18,000
16,000
15,648
13,983
14,000
12,000
14,115
12,014
10,000
8,000
5,943
6,000
5,540
6,400
7,032
4,752
4,000
2,000
S4
1,614
0
3/13
S5
S6
14,963 15,211
6/13
9/13 12/13
3/14
6/14
9/14 12/14
3/15
6/15
9/15 12/15
S8
S9
All Types and Classes of Apartments | Washington Metro Area* | 1999 2015
S10
6.0%
5.0%
4.0%
3.0%
2.0%
1.0%
0.0%
$1,900
$1,800
$1,700
$1,600
$1,500
$1,400
$1,300
$1,200
$1,100
$1,000
$900
$800
$700
S7
99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15
3.6% / Year
Long-Term Rent Growth
*Historic data includes Anne Arundel and Howard counties.
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
S6 | 52
Pipeline
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S1
The pipeline of likely deliveries over the next 36 months decreased by 12% during 2015, standing
at 32,164 units at the end of the year. We expect the 36-month pipeline to continue to shrink to a
more healthy level over the next 12 to 24 months as financial feasibility becomes more difficult in the
face of rising construction costs and relatively flat rents. Most of the pipeline decline will come from
projects that delay starting construction. Few pipeline projects are likely to deliver as condos, as only
11% of the 19,919 units currently under construction (but not yet leasing) metro-wide are of a scale
suitable for switching to condominiums before delivery. So far in this cycle, a handful of apartment
projects, ranging in size from 60 to 200 units, have switched to condominiums.
% Planned
% Under Construction
Q1 2015
16%
84%
Q2 2015
20%
80%
Q3 2015
21%
79%
Q4 2015
19%
81%
Per-project lease-up pace in 2015 was 15 units per month, unchanged from 2014, as a similar
number of new projects were open and competing for market share. There are 63 projects in active
lease-up at 4th quarter 2015 compared to 67 projects at 4th quarter 2014. The number of projects
in lease-up will remain elevated, with a large slate of projects set to deliver in the coming months,
likely putting pressure on the per-project lease-up pace during 2016.
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Number of Projects
in Initial Lease-Up:
12/08
12/09
12/10
12/11
12/12
12/13
12/14
12/15
49
34
30
18
29
56
67
63
Lease-Up Pace
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S6 | 53
During 2015, 10,785 units started construction in the Washington metro area, which is above the
long-term annual average. An estimated 14,004 units are slated for delivery in 2016, a 13% increase
over the 12,310 units delivered in 2015. Deliveries are expected to slow to 8,886 units in 2017, more
consistent with the absorption rate in recent years.
Growing Demand
S1
Class A apartment absorption in the Washington metro area was 13,429 units during 2015 a new
record for the region and more than double the 10-year annual average. Unlike past dynamics, Class
A absorption was not at the expense of the Class B market, which also experienced positive absorption. Contributing factors to this uptick include:
S2
S3
An increase in the types of jobs and income categories that tend to generate demand for rental
apartments rather than ownership housing.
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
No VA
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
Q1
Q2
An increase in Millennial households that tend to/prefer to rent rather than own.
An increase in the overall share of renter households vs. owners.
Sub MD
6,000
0
Q3
Q4
Q1
Q2
2013
Q3
Q4
Q1
2014
Q2
Q3
Q4
2015
Over the coming quarters, three factors will be necessary for sustained rental demand:
Job growth.
Projected Deliveries
Demographic shifts:
The un-grouping of 25- to 34-year-olds who are living together to save money.
Renter/owner preference shifts: The ratio of renters to owners stays the same or increases.
In recent months, at least two of these three factors have continued to favor the apartment market.
Job growth during 2015 was stronger than the 10-year average, and the share of renter households
in the metro area is on the rise. We expect all three of these factors to continue through the end of
this decade. These trends will produce solid Class A apartment absorption, supporting our projected
annual demand of 9,667 Class A units over the next three years, lower than the 13,429 units absorbed
during 2015, but substantially higher than the 10-year average.
4,500
S4
District
Sub MD
No VA
4,000
3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
2016
Q1
Q2
Q3
2017
Q4
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
2018
S6 | 54
S2
S3
S4
S5
Renter Households
Washington Metro vs. U.S. | 2007 2015
37%
36%
S1
35%
34%
33%
32%
Washington Metro
31%
U.S.
30%
29%
28%
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015*
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S6 | 55
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Years of Supply
Less than 1
1 1.9
2 2.9
3 3.9
S1
Although the 36-month pipeline is high across the metro area, absorption records have
been broken for several quarters in a row. When the prior years absorption is compared
to the development pipeline at the submarket level, 13 low-rise submarkets in Northern
Virginia and Suburban Maryland mostly outside the Beltway have less than four years of
supply (or less than one years worth of product overhang). Twelve of these submarkets have
less than two years of supply and could be considered supply-constrained. There are also
11 high-rise submarkets that have less than four years of supply; six of these have less than
two years worth. This suggests there are still development opportunities in the metro area,
despite an overall market perception of oversupply.
Note: Calculated by dividing 36-month development supply by net absorption during the past
12 months.
Unshaded submarkets have four or more years of supply.
Source: Delta Associates, February 2016.
Years of Supply
Less than 1
1 1.9
2 2.9
3 3.9
Note: Calculated by dividing 36-month development supply by net absorption during the past
12 months.
Unshaded submarkets have four or more years of supply.
Source: Delta Associates, February 2016.
S6 | 56
Given the projected delivery schedule of projects currently under construction, we expect that the
region-wide vacancy rate for stabilized Class A apartment properties will be 90 basis points lower in
three years than it is today 4.6%, but in the intervening years the rate likely will rise to nearly 5% as
the level of deliveries remains elevated in the short term. However, there will be significant variation
in conditions among submarkets.
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Washington Metro Area Class A Apartment Market | Dec. 2015 Dec. 2018
Demand
16
Net Absorption
9,667/Year = 29,000
14
12
Supply1
10
8
6
Under Construction
Supply: 27,286 units2
2
0
NoVA
Sub MD.
The District
3.5%
3.7%
4.0%
S2
S1
At the regional level, Class A rents likely will increase slightly in 2016 due to the large slate of
scheduled deliveries although projected demand remains above historic levels. Rents have thus far
held up surprisingly well despite the increased competition over the past couple of years, thanks to
record absorption. Also aiding the Class A market has been strong absorption of Class B product.
We expect rent growth to recover to the 2.5% to 3.5% range by 2017 as growth in 2018 approaches
long-term rates.
No VA
Sub MD *
The District
6%
5%
4%
3%
2%
Washington 2008
Metro
Vacacncy* 3.6%
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
4.4%
3.6%
5.0%
4.2%
4.7%
5.6%
4.6%
4.9%
4.2%
3.7%
S6 | 57
Total return (cash flow plus appreciation) on apartment investment in the Washington market continues to track below the national average. The 12-month total return through September 2015 was
4.29%, significantly off the cyclical peak of 28.64% in 2010 and lower than other cities in the MidAtlantic. Washington was early to recover from the 2009 recession and also early to peak in investment returns. Investors seeking the risk-adjusted safety of Washington apartments bid up prices
even as rent growth was slowing leading to lower overall returns. Nevertheless, recent apartment
investment activity remains healthy and valuations for new transactions (in terms of cap rates and
per-unit prices) are strong, as discussed below.
S1
S2
S3
S4
19.36%
Dallas
12.76%
S6
Austin
12.53%
S7
Chicago
12.37%
National Average
12.02%
Phoenix
11.87%
S8
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2%
Atlanta
S5
Return on Investment
S9
Houston
8.82%
S10
Baltimore
8.39%
Philadelphia
7.29%
Washington
4.29%
-4%
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
NCREIF compiles returns based on its members' $70 billion apartment portfolio.
The index includes both current income and estimated capital appreciation returns.
Source: Delta Associates, based on trailing 12-month data in NCREIF's "Real Estate Performance Report: Third Quarter 2015."
S6 | 58
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S6 | 59
2015 Highlights
Sales Volume: New unit sales volume (defined as net binding
contracts written with security deposits up) totaled 1,432
during 2015. This compares to 1,476 new unit sales in 2015.
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
National Context
The Washington metro area, the seventh-largest in population, is the fifth-largest condominium market in the nation, with approximately 127,000 units. Only the nations three largest cities (New York,
Los Angeles, and Chicago) and the popular second-home location of South Florida have larger
inventories of condominiums than the Washington metro area.
Sales Activity
For 2015, sales metro-wide are down 3% from 2014. However, sales are up 4% in the District and
up 18% in Suburban Maryland. See below for how the submarkets stack up compared to a year
ago. (It is important to keep in mind that product shortage has hampered sales volume in many
submarkets.)
500
Thousands of Units
S2
S1
400
300
200
127.2
100
NY
S Fla
Chi
LA Basin
Was
Bos
SF Bay
Tampa
Note: Estimated.
Source: U.S. Census, Delta Associates; February 2016.
S7 | 61
600
Montgomery: up 33%
Prince Georges: down 30%
The Loudoun/Prince William counties submarket continues to lead the metro area in new condo
sales activity (with mostly 2-over-2 townhouse-style development), followed by Mideast DC. In Suburban Maryland, Montgomery County led in sales activity in 2015.
Resale activity in the 12-month period ending November 2015 was up slightly from 2014. Since
2013, resale transactions have been averaging 14,425 units annually, up significantly from the
period 2009 2012 when the annual average was 11,615 units. Since 2008, the condo share of all
residential resales increased from 20% to 24%.
Net Sales
200
Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S8
S9
S10
S7 | 62
S1
S2
S3
S4
Q4 Sales/Remaining Inv.
Central DC
50 / 258
Mideast DC
49 / 448
Upper NW DC
8 / 51
Capitol East DC
27/ 544
Arlington/Alexandria
10 / 259
Fairfax/Falls Church
30 / 238
Loudoun/Prince William
469 / 673
Montgomery
79 / 720
Prince George's
35 / 54
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
-2%
-4%
-6%
2005
S5
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S6
S7
S8
Condo Submarket
S9
Loudoun/Prince William
469
Mideast DC
248
Montgomery
176
Fairfax/Falls Church
157
Capitol East DC
137
Arlington/Alexandria
102
S10
10%
Percent Change
Condo Submarket
# of Units Sold 1
Central DC
97
Prince George's
31
Upper NW DC
Washington Metro Total
15
1,432
Prices
The average effective price per square foot for same-store new condo sales in the metro area
rose by 3.3% in 2015. Leading the way in price growth over the year is Mideast DC with a 17.3% increase, followed by Central DC with an increase of 14.1%. The only submarkets in the metro area to
record a decline in prices are Montgomery County (down 4.7%) and Loudoun/Prince William (down
0.5%). Over the last 10 years, prices in the metro area have increased by 0.2% per year on average,
mainly due to sharp price drops in the outer suburbs of Northern Virginia during the market downturn and a lackluster recovery since then.
S7 | 63
$1,000
$800
$600
$400
S6
Upper NW DC
8 / 51
Capitol East DC
27/ 544
Arlington/Alexandria
10 / 259
S8
Fairfax/Falls Church
30 / 238
S9
Loudoun/Prince William
469 / 673
Montgomery
79 / 720
Prince George's
35 / 54
u/
Pr
es
rg
eo
Pr
Lo
p
Ca
$168
m
$291
/FC
$297
.G
Ea
st
nd
xa
le
l/A
DC
t
on
M
st
ea
$469
Ffx
$476
ria
$626
id
nt
ra
lD
DC
$713
Ar
49 / 448
Ce
50 / 258
Mideast DC
$884
DC
$1,500
$0
$200
Q4 Sales/Remaining Inv.
S5
S10
$1,200
rN
Condo Submarket
Central DC
S7
$1,400
pe
S4
2015
$1,600
Up
S3
*Reflects prices of condo projects currently selling, so averages should not be compared
fom quarter to quarter since locations of projects change each quarter.
*Reflects prices of condominium projects currently selling, so averages should not be compared from
quarter to quarter since locations of projects change each quarter.
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
20%
The regions highest effective prices per square foot are found in Upper NW DC, and the lowest
are in Loudoun/Prince William. The product currently selling in Upper NW DC is in luxury buildings,
while the majority of inventory on the market in Loudoun/Prince William is townhouse-style condo
developments. Prices for new condos in Central DC are higher than in most downtown areas in the
U.S. and similar to those in LA, but below other gateway cities such as New York and San Francisco.
Meanwhile, per-square-foot prices in Upper NW DC are currently on par with San Francisco.
As of November 2015, resale condo prices are down 0.3% metro-wide from a year earlier, while
single-family resale home prices rose by 1.3% during the same time period. Prices fell in several
submarkets, including Arlington, Alexandria, Prince William, and Montgomery.
15%
Percent Change
S2
S1
10%
5%
0%
-5%
-10%
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S7 | 64
Concession rates decreased by 100 basis points metro-wide during 2015, from 1.6% to just 0.6%
of the average asking price. The only submarkets where concessions increased over the year were
Mideast DC (0.5% to 0.6%) and Capitol East DC (0.7% to 1.2%). They are lowest in the District and
Northern Virginia, both averaging at or below 0.5% of the average asking price. They are highest in
Loudoun/Prince William, which is currently at 1.5% of the average asking price.
Pipeline
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
As the condo market has tightened, the pipeline has begun to grow. During 2015 the number of
units planned to begin sales within the next 36 months increased by more than 1,000 units to 4,288
units before attrition; 42% of those units will be located in the District. Of these units, we estimate
about 75% of the total will actually be built within the next three years. In addition, about 8,500 units
are in the longer-term condo pipeline and another 52,300 multifamily units that are in various stages
of planning may be built either as rental apartments or as condos.
The inventory-to-sales ratio (months of supply at current rates of sale) metro-wide is currently 15.3
months. Most of the District submarkets have the lowest months of inventory available for instance, Capitol East DC has only about five months worth; however, the months of inventory in this
submarket is expected to increase significantly in the next few months as some large-scale projects
begin sales. Montgomery currently has the highest inventory-to-sales ratio 40 months of inventory.
We have found over the years that a healthy ratio is between 24 and 30 months of supply in that
range, prices tend to move up gradually if the ratio of fresh product is above 65%. In contrast, the
rule of thumb in the resale market is that six months of supply is considered to be a healthy ratio.
The difference between the two corresponds to the 18 to 24 months it usually takes to build a new
condo project.
S1
The number of unsold units in projects currently marketing or under construction (and not yet marketing) is 3,245 units as of December 2015, similar to one year prior. For most of 2015 the actively
marketing pipeline steadily rose, but it fell by 15% in the last three months of the year. Currently, the
submarkets with the largest available inventory are Montgomery (720 units), followed by Loudoun/
Prince William (673 units) and Capitol East DC (544 units).
District of Columbia
Q4 2014
Q4 2015
0.7%
0.4%
0.5%
Northern Virginia
1.9%
Suburban Maryland
1.6%
0.8%
1.6%
0.6%
Sub MD
District
NoVA
3,729
4,000
Concessions
3,281
3,226
Dec. 2014
March 2015
3,834
3,245
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
June 2015
Sept. 2015
Dec. 2015
District of Columbia
Q4 2014
Q4 2015
9.5
7.2
Northern Virginia
22.1
15.8
Suburban Maryland
24.3
31.0
18.3
15.3
S7 | 65
Months of Inventory
S1
S2
Months of Inventory
Capitol East DC
5.1
Central DC
7.1
Mideast DC
7.8
Loudoun/Prince William
13.8
15.3
Fairfax/Falls Church
18.0
Upper NW DC
19.2
Prince George's
24.0
S3
Arlington/Alexandria
24.8
S4
Montgomery
40.0
S5
Note: Calculated by dividing actively marketing inventory by sales during the past 12 months.
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
60
50
Months of Supply
Condominium Submarket
S9
S10
20
'05
'06
'07
'08
'09
'10
'11
'12
'13
'14
'15
Q1
Q2
Q3
Q4
2016
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
The supply-demand balance in the metro area will continue to favor developers in most areas,
with limited new condo unit supply and rising prices most notably in Northern Virginia. However,
resale listings and sales are on the rise. Despite this increase, we foresee new unit prices rising and
improved development opportunities throughout the metro area through 2017.
Submarkets
40.0
13.8
Central DC
19.2
Mideast DC
7.8
7.1
S8
30
10
S6
S7
40
5.1
18.0
Upper Northwest DC
Capitol East DC
Arlington/Alexandria
Fairfax/Falls Church
24.0
24.8
Loudoun/Prince William
Montgomery
Prince Georges
Note: Calculated by dividing actively marketing inventory by sales during the past 12 months and
multiplying by 12.
Source: Delta Associates, December 2015.
S7 | 66
4,000
S1
S2
3,500
Supply1
3,000
2,500
2,000
Under Construction
and/or Marketing:
3,245 units2
1,500
1,000
500
S3
S4
The District
NoVA
Sub MD
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
District
6,000
Number of Listings
Sub MD
5,000
NoVA
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S7 | 67
Active resale listings at November 2015 were up to 3,388 units, an increase of 14% from November
2014. Despite the large percentage increase in active listings, there are only 2.7 months of resale
inventory on the market. Within the District, there is only 2.1 months of inventory.
S2
S3
S4
In addition, there are at least 21 apartment projects currently under construction of a suitable size
that could be potential candidates for switching to condo. Most of these projects are located in
the District and Bethesda. There are also limited opportunities to convert newer Class A apartment
buildings of medium size, but most conversion activity so far in this cycle has come in the form of
older boutique buildings.
S5
S6
1,693
Northern Virginia
248
Suburban Maryland
276
2,217
S8
1745N
Central DC
68
2501 M Street
Central DC
59
The McIntyre
Mideast DC
77
50 Florida Avenue
Cap East DC
166
Yards Condo
Cap East DC
135
Cap East DC
55
Arl/Alex
78
The Signet
Ffx/FC
103
The Enclave
Ffx/FC
80
District of Columbia
District
No VA
10,000
Name of Project
S10
Units
12,000
S7
S9
Sub-State Area
Submarket
# of Units
Lou/PW
219
Crown
Mont
128
Mont
104
Mont
99
S1
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
Since 2009, when the credit and housing crisis shut off the development pipeline, the number of
deliveries has consistently been below the normalized annual sales range of 2,300 to 3,300 units.
Deliveries in 2015 increased to 2,228 units, the highest annual total since 2009. However, in 2016,
only about 1,000 units are expected to deliver well below the forecasted level of demand.
S7 | 68
S1
S2
S3
S4
Sales Pace
S7
During 2015, 867 new units began selling in the metro area, about half of the level of 2014. Of all
new market entrants, 34% of units have been sold, compared to 28% during 2014. Projects that sold
out since 2014 have averaged 2.5 sales per month, while those that started selling during 2015 have
averaged 2.6 sales per month.
S8
S5
S6
S9
S10
A shortage of new condo units persists in the market, as the number of actively marketing units is
now about 15% of what it was at the peak of the last cycle. Conversions are not likely to play a significant role in this cycle as they did in the last, especially in suburban jurisdictions. Unlike the previous
cycle when many apartment projects converted to condos or switched midway through construction to become condos to meet demand, the inventory of apartment product this time around is
ill-suited for conversion because of location or project scale most sponsors and capital sources do
not have the appetite to work through such large and extended sell-out programs. There are some
newer 80- to 150-unit Class A apartment buildings that could be candidates for conversion these
total 2,217 units in 21 projects under construction. Larger projects are not likely candidates due to
the amount of time needed to pre-sell at least half of the units before settlements can begin. Consequently, the eventual ramp-up of new condo supply will be built largely from scratch, supplemented
by smaller conversions of older apartment buildings (mostly inside the Beltway). It will take longer to
replenish the condo supply in this cycle since it takes more time for new construction or older building renovation/conversion compared to newer building conversions or pipeline switches.
We anticipate price increases in the mid-single digits over the next 24 to 36 months, with price
spikes in certain submarkets.
We estimate new unit sales will be 1,600 to 2,100 units in 2016 as more product is brought
to market.
S7 | 69
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Neighborhood and community shopping center effective rents rose by 2.9% in Northern Virginia
since year-end 2014, to $25.75/SF. In Suburban Maryland, effective rents in the same types of
centers rose by 1.6%, to $23.32/SF.
Investment sales of grocery-anchored centers was robust $719.5 million during 2015, which
represents the highest total dollar volume for a full calendar year since 2005.
The region has 917,000 SF of grocery-anchored development underway at 4th quarter 2015
insufficient to keep pace with demand.
The Washington metro area retail market is showing consistent, if modest, improvement. Tenants
seeking space are interested in newer, Class A space, and the rise of the District of Columbia as a
destination for living, working, and shopping represents a unique opportunity for retailers in the
region. We predict that the trend toward mixed-use projects in core submarkets with a more urban
feel will continue for the foreseeable future, although recent plans for new centers and renovations
of old ones in the outer suburbs indicate that developers expect lifestyle centers with a sense of
place to thrive throughout the region.
S1
Vacancy rates for neighborhood and community shopping centers in Northern Virginia and
Suburban Maryland are 5.5% and 7.9%, respectively, down 10 basis points since year-end 2014
in Northern Virginia and down 40 basis points in Suburban Maryland.
S8 | 71
National Context
Northern Virginia has one of the lowest neighborhood/community center vacancy rates, after San
Francisco, among large metro areas. The vacancy rate for all types of neighborhood and community centers in Northern Virginia and Suburban Maryland were 5.5% and 7.9% at September 2015,
respectively. This compares favorably to the national average of 10.1%.
Shopping center retail maintains a relatively low vacancy rate in the region because of:
High incomes
S1
S2
The average household income in the Washington metro area increased by 49% from 2000 to 2015,
well above the national growth rate of 32%, and it currently exceeds the national average by 61%.
By 2020 the Washington metro areas average household income is projected to increase another
12%, compared to an increase of 14% nationally. The elevated household incomes in the Washington
area yield greater discretionary spending and support demand for retail goods and space.
S4
S5
S3
12%
10.7%
11.2% 11.2%
11.7%
12.1% 12.4%
10%
7.9%
8%
5.5%
6%
4%
6.0%
6.6%
3.3%
2%
0%
SF
N. VA
LA
Bos
Sub MD
Phx
Den
Hou
DFW
Chi
Atl
S6
S8
S9
S10
2000 (Actual)
2015 (Actual)
2020 (PROJ.)
$80,600
$120,456
$135,285
U.S.
$56,600
$74,699
$84,910
17
18
Neighborhood/Community
Center SF/Capita
S7
17.1
16
15.4
15
14
13
12
11
10
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
S8 | 72
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
In Northern Virginia, neighborhood/community shopping center vacancy rates at 4th quarter 2015
are lowest in the Suburban Fairfax County submarket, at 3.9%, and highest in Arlington/Alexandria,
at 7.0%. In Suburban Maryland, vacancy rates are lowest in the Bethesda/Silver Spring submarket,
at 4.4%, and highest in South Prince Georges County, at 12.0%. Neighborhood/community center
vacancy rates in Suburban Maryland were 34% higher than in Northern Virginia at their respective
cyclical lows in 2007, and the difference between the two substate areas remains pronounced.
As of 4th quarter 2015, vacancy rates in Suburban Maryland were 43% higher than those in
Northern Virginia.
Retail Pipeline
Washington Metro Area Suburbs | All Shopping Center Types | 4th Quarter 2015
6
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
Vacancy rates for Northern Virginia and Suburban Maryland at December 2015 are 5.5% and 7.9%,
respectively, down 10 basis points in Northern Virginia and down 40 basis points in Suburban Maryland from December 2014. While vacancy rates in neighborhood and community centers remain
elevated relative to their pre-recession averages across the metro area, they have been declining
slowly since 2012.
4
3
2
1
Effective rents in neighborhood and community shopping centers have been climbing slowly since
2010, and this pattern continued in 2015, with effective rents rising 2.9% in Northern Virginia and
1.6% in Suburban Maryland. Average effective rents at December 2015 are highest in Northern
Virginia, at $25.75 per SF. In Suburban Maryland, average effective rents are $23.32 per SF.
0
Under Construction
Planned
Proposed
S7
S10
Northern Virginia
9%
Suburban Maryland
8%
7%
6%
5%
4%
3%
2%
15
14
20
13
20
12
20
11
20
10
20
20
08
09
20
07
20
06
20
05
20
04
20
03
20
02
20
00
01
20
19
99
1%
20
S9
Vacancy Rates
20
S8
S8 | 73
PHOTO
Effective Rents
Washington Metro Area Suburbs | Neighborhood/Community Centers | 1999 2015
$30
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
$24
$22
S6
15
14
20
13
20
12
20
11
20
10
20
09
20
08
20
07
20
06
20
20
04
05
20
03
20
20
19
S5
02
$16
20
S4
20
$18
99
S3
01
$20
00
S2
$26
20
S1
$28
S7
S8
S9
S10
24.3
2.3
Total = 59.0 MSF
in 326 Centers
Northern VA
Suburban MD
The District
32.4
Note: Estimate; in millions of SF.
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
S8 | 74
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Rental rates at grocery-anchored centers increased 2.9% in 2015, after rising 2.3% in 2014. Metrowide average in-line tenant rents were $35.22/SF at December 2015, compared to $34.24/SF at
December 2014. Suburban Maryland rents were $35.18/SF, up 2.9% from 2014. Northern Virginia
rents were $34.96/SF, up 3.3% from 2014. Within Northern Virginia, grocery-anchored shopping
center rents are highest in Arlington County, at $52.25/SF, and lowest in Prince William County,
at $28.37/SF. In Suburban Maryland, rents are higher in Montgomery County, at $43.91/SF, than
in Prince Georges County, where grocery-anchored shopping center rents were $26.38/SF at
December 2015.
Core submarkets remain the most desirable in the metro area, as evidenced by their area-leading
rents of $47.34/SF, up 2.6% over the year. The inner and outer rings also experienced strong rent
growth, at 2.3% and 3.8%, respectively.
2015
2014
Core
5.4%
4.2%
Inner Ring
4.9%
6.4%
Outer Ring
3.8%
5.0%
Washington Metro
4.4%
5.5%
Asking Rents
2015
YR % CHANGE
Core
$47.34
2.6%
Inner Ring
$36.49
2.3%
Outer Ring
$33.41
3.8%
Washington Metro
$35.22
2.9%
S1
The metro-wide vacancy rate for grocery-anchored shopping centers edged down to 4.4% at
December 2015, from 5.5% at December 2014. The vacancy rate in Suburban Maryland dropped to
5.0% at December 2015, from 6.0% one year ago. Northern Virginia vacancy was 4.0% at year-end
2015, down from 5.2% one year ago. District of Columbia vacancy dropped to 2.6% at year-end
2015, down from 4.4% one year prior. Vacancy rates in the inner ring declined 150 basis points, and
outer ring vacancy fell 120 basis points, while the core area experienced a 120 basis point increase
during 2015.
Vacancy Rates
Grocery-anchored shopping center asking rents fluctuate dramatically across jurisdictions, but
certain anchor tenants allow centers to command consistently higher rents. Centers with a high-end
grocery anchor, defined in this survey as Fresh Market, Harris Teeter, MOMs Organic Market, Trader
Joes, Wegmans, or Whole Foods, receive an average non-anchor rent premium of 25.4% across the
S8 | 75
In Northern Virginia, centers with high-end grocery anchors had average non-anchor asking rents
of $39.78/SF, a 20.1% premium over centers with all other grocery anchors at December 2015.
Average rents at similar high-end centers in Suburban Maryland were $44.92/SF, a 32.2% premium
over other centers. In the District of Columbia, where most high-end grocers have no auxiliary retail
space, high-end anchor centers only command a premium of 3.4%.
S1
New Development
S2
There are seven notable grocery-anchored shopping centers, totaling 575,000 SF, under construction
in the metro area at December 2015, and many more are in the planning stages.
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
In October 2015, Walmart opened its new store at Fort Totten Square. At 120,000 SF, it is the
largest Walmart in the District of Columbia and includes 50,000 SF of grocery space. The
mixed-use project also has 345 rental units and four other retail storefronts.
In December 2015, Aldi opened its first location in Alexandria, completing renovations to a
24,000 SF space at Seminary Plaza.
MOMs Organic Market opened two new locations in the last quarter of 2015 as part of the
mixed-use projects at Verde Pointe in Arlington and the Hechts Warehouse in the District.
S9
High-End Grocers
$45.00
$40.00
$35.00
$30.00
$25.00
$20.00
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
District
High-End Grocers include Fresh Market, Harris Teeter, MOMs Organic Market, Trader Joes, Wegmans, and
Whole Foods.
Source: Delta Associates; February 2016.
S10
$600
JURISDICTION
RBA
Fairfax
180,000
Wegmans
Fairfax
125,000
Harris Teeter
Apollo H Street
District
75,000
Whole Foods
Falls Church
60,000
Harris Teeter
Bowie
50,000
Harris Teeter
Bethesda
50,000
Harris Teeter
District
35,000
Whole Foods
Bowie Marketplace
8300 Wisconsin
800 New Jersey Ave. SE
Total:
Source: Washington Business Journal, Washington Post, Delta Associates; February 2016.
575,000
Northern Virginia
Suburban Maryland
$500
ANCHOR
Sales in Millions
S3
Washington metro area over grocery-anchored shopping centers with a more traditional grocery
anchor. This premium, while impressive, likely overstates the degree to which high-end grocers influence shopping center rents. High-end grocers choose their locations carefully. They tend to select
centers where rents would be above the metro average regardless of anchor, and they tend to sign
leases in newer centers.
$400
$300
$200
$100
$0
2004 2005* 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Total: $342 M $796 M $401 M $429 M $85 M $79 M $178 M $454 M $476 M $644 M $309 M $719 M
S8 | 76
The dollar volume of investment sales of grocery-anchored shopping centers in 2015 totaled $719.5
million ($375/SF), more than double the 2014 total of $323 million ($353/SF). Grocery-anchored
center sales in 2015 represents the highest total dollar volume for a full calendar year since 2005.
All signs point to grocery-anchored centers continuing to be a popular investment in 2016. In our
year-end 2015 Market Maker Survey, grocery-anchored shopping centers scored the highest of all
property types on the investment-worthiness index.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
7.0
6.9
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
* A score below 5.0 is considered to have more interested sellers than interested buyers.
Source: Delta Associates Market Maker Survey; February 2016.
Retail real estate in the region avoided disaster during the recession and lackluster recovery
remarkable, considering the dual pressures of slow job and wage growth and booming online
merchandising. Now that the demand side of the retail sales equation has improved, we expect
improvements in retail real estate to ramp up through 2016.
S1
As 2016 begins, the Washington metro areas economy is performing better than it has since 2008,
and the retail real estate market is showing consistent, though modest, improvement. Among neighborhood/community shopping centers, vacancy rates continue to decline, and rents have been
rising steadily since 2010. Tenants seeking space are interested in newer, better quality space, and
the rise of the District of Columbia as a destination for living, working, and shopping represents a
unique opportunity for retailers in the region. We predict that the trend toward mixed-use projects
in core, urban submarkets will continue for the foreseeable future. Still, recent plans for new centers
and renovations of old ones in the outer suburbs indicate that owners and developers expect
better-located and better-tenanted lifestyle centers to thrive.
Investment Sales
S8 | 77
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
2015 was a year of unprecedented sales volume and pricing for CRE assets both locally and nationally. Institutional investors flocked to commercial property markets in light of volatility in other equity
investment classes, uncertainty in international securities markets, and depressed bond yields.
Healthy economic growth in the U.S. during 2015 was instrumental in encouraging foreign investors
to invest capital in U.S. real estate assets. Another factor that spurred CRE investment in 2015 was
the long-anticipated interest rate hike by the Fed that finally transpired in December.
Looking ahead, CRE assets will remain an attractive option for risk-averse institutional portfolios.
Property price growth is likely to ease as interest rates tick upwards. Cap rates, which continued to
fall through 2015, likely have hit bottom and will remain stable or slightly increase as the year goes
on, and income growth is expected to outpace appreciation for most asset classes.
Here are some major themes observed in the investment sales market during 2015:
The boom continues in Washington. It was a banner year for the investment sales market in the
Washington metro area. A strong job market, record-setting absorption, sustained rent growth
and low vacancy rates drove speculation on the multifamily side of the market. Confidence
remained high in future prospects for office assets market, despite current weak conditions. In
addition to rapidly growing trading volume, prices for office properties also escalated considerably, with multiple sales in central Washington breaking the $1,000/SF barrier. Institutional
investors accounted for a large share of transactions, attracted by the regions strong economic
fundamentals and demographics. Foreign investors also continued to invest heavily into Washington real estate.
Escalating volatility in financial markets enhances the appeal of CRE to institutional investors.
After years of steady growth during the national economic recovery, the U.S. stock market
experienced a period of correction in August 2015. While the market quickly recovered in the
subsequent weeks, 2016 began with another major sell-off. Consequently, institutional investors
have been allocating larger shares of their portfolios toward real estate. Results from the 2015
Institutional Real Estate Allocations Monitor survey, conducted by Cornell University and Hodes
Weill & Associates, LP, indicate that average target allocation by institutional investors to real
estate stood at 9.56%, up 26 basis points from 2015. Also, according to the survey, institutional
investors are increasingly focusing on value-add investments as opposed to core investments.
Spreads are growing between cap rates for newer office product in core submarkets and
older properties in suburban submarkets. Investor demand for Class A office properties in the
Districts CBD and East End led capitalization rates downward, with many properties trading at a
sub-4.5% cap rate. Class A sales in other District submarkets and inner-suburb submarkets such
as Rosslyn and Bethesda closed at record per-SF prices and cap rates under 6%. Meanwhile,
prices and cap rates remained stagnant for office product in traditional suburban office parks
where rents have been flat and vacancy rates have been on the rise.
S9 | 79
S6
S7
S8
Lets examine the investment market for commercial real estate in 2015 starting with the big picture
and then zeroing in on Washington. What does the markets performance tell us about 2016?
S9
S10
Investors continued to flock to CRE assets in 2015 as they took advantage of a favorable lending environment with historically low interest rates, despite concerns about declining yields and a possible
market bubble. The office and multifamily sectors were the main drivers of activity, but hotels and
industrial sectors saw marked growth as well. U.S. office sales volume totaled approximately $142.3
billion during 2015, up from the 2014 total of $125.7 billion. Overall, 2015 office sales volume was
more than six times higher than it was at the bottom of the market in 2009.
$250
$200
$150
$/SF
$150
$100
$100
$50
$50
15
20
13
14
20
12
20
11
20
20
09
10
20
20
07
08
20
06
20
05
20
20
20
04
$0
03
$0
02
$/SF
$200
20
S5
$300
Volume
01
S4
$250
20
S3
20
S2
S1
REIT growth slows. After several years of outperforming the broader equity market by a
significant margin, REITs delivered total returns of just 2.83% compared to 27.15% in 2014.
Compared to the 2015 S&P 500 return of 1.4%, U.S. REITs still outperformed the market, but by
a much narrower margin. The tepid growth was uneven across sectors, with self-storage and
apartment REITs posting the strongest performance and health care and hotel REITs exhibiting
the poorest performance. REIT growth was largely held back by uncertainty surrounding the
Feds interest rate hike. Looking ahead, REITs will likely outperform the equity market in 2016
as the U.S. economy expands and demand grows. The impact of the recent rate hike, as well as
those of future increases, are not as significant as supposed. The extension of the federal EB-5
program will also help returns, especially since foreign CRE investment is high.
Private
Institutional/Equity Fund
REIT/Public
Foreign
Unknown/Other
Note: Excludes portfolio sales and properties under contract; through September 2015.
Source: Real Capital Analytics, graphic by Delta Associates; February 2016.
S9 | 80
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Investors are also concerned with the level of risk they must assume when choosing between investments. Periods of market volatility can hamper returns across all asset classes and can spell trouble
for even the best-diversified portfolios. Increased market volatility in 2015 drove down yields in both
domestic and global securities markets, while returns on U.S. real estate investments rose. Over the
long term, CRE continues to provide better risk-adjusted returns than stocks and bonds.
At the national level, private equity was the largest source of capital for sales across all product
types, accounting for 38% of total CRE investment, up about 8% from 2014. Foreign sources led
investment growth with an impressive 150% increase over 2014 levels. Institutional investors appetite for CRE increased, as evidenced by a 36% increase in 2015. Publicly-traded REITs were the only
major capital source to exhibit a decline in investment, with acquisitions dropping off about 2%.
The share of investment activity from foreign sources doubled to 19.4% in 2015 from 9.8% in 2014.
Institutions and funds sourced 27.6% of capital, up from 25.5% one year ago, while publicly-listed
REITs sourced 18.0%, down from 17.8% one year ago. Finally, the percentage of total capital invested by private equity sources declined to 33.3% in 2015 from 39.0% in 2014.
Institutions already big players in commercial real estate investment are allocating even more to
CRE. From 2014 to 2015 the target for real estate increased globally, reaching 9.6% on average
across institutional portfolios. The target allocation for Asian institutions rose to 11.8% from 10.9%,
while the target allocation for Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) declined 120 bps to 8.8%.
Notably, institutions in all regions have negative current allocation margins (i.e. their portfolios are
under-invested in real estate compared to targets).
8%
.9
%
11
.
2015
.0
10
8.
9.
8%
9.
0%
4%
6%
9.
9.
10%
4%
12%
2014
10
14%
S1
Market diversity is another core strength of the nations real estate market with a variety of products in both gateway and secondary cities alike. Investors in U.S. markets can choose from a host
of assets that fit their risk/return objectives, from predictable returns in core markets to potentially
higher-yielding investments in secondary markets. Economic and geopolitical instability overseas
cements U.S. real estates position as a leading target for equity and debt participants. When comparing returns in stocks, bonds, and commercial real estate, it is CRE that stands out over the longterm, with an 8.02% annualized total return over the 10 years ending September 2015.
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
Global
The Americas
EMEA
Asia Pacific
Source: 2015 Institutional Real Estate Allocation Monitor, Delta Associates; February 2016.
$25
New York
U.S.
Los Angeles
Chicago
$20
$15
$/SF
For foreign investors, U.S. commercial real estate continues to be an attractive proposition for capital
despite concerns over impending interest rate increases, because of the relatively favorable longterm risk-adjusted returns the asset class offers. According to an annual survey conducted by the
Association of Foreign Investors in Real Estate (AFIRE), 64% of foreign investors expect to increase
their investment in U.S. real estate in 2016. Another 31% say they expect to maintain or reinvest their
investments, with no major decreases planned. The U.S. remains a leader for attracting global investment in commercial real estate, with sound fundamentals and robust economic growth.
$10
$5
$0
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
As national commercial real estate assets produced strong returns, the Washington metro area
remained among the nations top investment markets. Its 1-year performance declined, however,
compared to other cities due to factors including: price spikes, muted rent growth, and concern
over the Federal governments ongoing efforts to reduce its footprint. Institutional Net Operating
Income (NOI) rose a tepid 1.3% year-over-year for the 12 months ending in September 2014,
compared to a 3.5% rise at the national level.
S9 | 81
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
In spite of declining returns, sales volume in the Washington area in 2015 rose to $8.7 billion, up
from $7.5 billion in 2014, the third consecutive year of increases. Investors acquiring Washington
assets today are primarily focused on a longer-term horizon and the strong fundamentals of the region. The regions office investment sales market has held up remarkably well given the instability of
the Federal government and the regions subpar economic performance between 2012 and 2014.
With the regional economy back on a growth trajectory, returns and investment sales volume in the
region should both be back benefit on firm footing.
10-Year
3-Year
1-Year
15%
Total Return
S1
10%
5%
0%
-5%
NY
Hou
SF
LA
Den
Was
U.S.
Bos
Dal
Phx
Chi
Atl
Washington
16%
US
14%
Total Return %
Office investment returns in the Washington area remain below national averages. 1-year returns for
Washington for the 12 months ending September 2015 averaged just 6.79%, ranking last among
major metro areas and well below the national average of 13.05%. More positively, the annualized
10-year total return of 7.23% for the Washington metro area was only slightly behind the national
average of 7.79%, underscoring the regions longer-term strength. We expect enduring investor
confidence in the regions ability to produce solid results for long-term real estate returns.
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
Retail
Industrial
Apartment
Office
The Washington area also scored well in AFIREs survey of the top investment markets worldwide for
2016. The city climbed one spot since the previous survey, placing 4th in the United States, behind
New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco.
S9 | 82
S1
Office investors were optimistic in 2015, as regional job growth rebounded strongly and the office
market finally showed signs of recovery. Office investment volume rose 16% in 2015, to $8.7 billion,
compared to $7.5 billion in 2014. Notably, office investment sales volume in the Washington metro
area is at its highest level in nearly 10 years.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
Continuing the pattern of recent years, buyers preferred Washington investment targets in 2015
were leased-up office assets or well-located multifamily product most acquisitions were made with
plans to hold these well-performing assets for the long term. Total volume for all major product
types was $21.3 billion in 2015, up nearly 50% from $14.6 billion in 2014. All CRE sectors saw material gains, but multifamily sales posted the greatest increase, climbing to $8.5 billion in 2015 from
$4.1 billion in 2014. Class B buildings in less desirable locations attracted interest for value-add and
renovation plays.
$10
$5
$0
New York
Los Angeles
San Francisco
Washington, D.C.
Seattle/Boston (tie)
Washington
$15
market
Los Angeles
$20
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2015
Investment Sales
$35
S10
Flex/Industrial
Retail
$30
market
New York
Los Angeles
San Francisco
Chicago
Washington, D.C.
Dallas
Atlanta
Miami
Boston
10
Houston
Multifamily
2014
Office
$25
$20
$15
$10
$5
$0
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
S9 | 83
Industrial product has seen market fundamentals improve and speculative construction return due
to a lack of available space and increased demand for retail goods, particularly online purchases.
Flex/industrial investment sales totaled $1.3 billion during 2015, compared to $1 billion in 2014.
Retail investment sales totaled $2.8 billion during 2015, compared to $2 billion during 2014. Given
the sturdy performance of grocery-anchored retail and flex/industrial product, we expect to see
these two sectors continue to attract investment capital in 2016.
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S1
We expect that the Washington area will retain its position among the premier long-term investment
markets in the nation, even though returns from other major markets have surpassed Washingtons
in recent years. Washingtons still-high pricing and elevated vacancy rate are weakening investors
returns in the short term, though sales volume has remained strong. Investment sales activity is
likely to plateau along with the broader U.S. market, as the current level of sales/price growth is
not sustainable. However, the regions competitive economic advantages will give it a leg up on
its peers around the country.
Washington CRE Assets Gained Value, Cap Rates Declined Further in 2015
Class A and trophy office prices in the Washington metro area continued to rise in 2015, despite
concerns over near-term property performance challenges and potential overvaluation. Sales prices
averaged $430/SF in the Washington metro in 2015, representing the highest average per-SF price
since before the recession. This uptick in per-SF pricing has been influenced by the sales of multiple
trophy assets that have broken the $1,000/SF barrier. The most notable of these was Jamestown LPs
acquisition of two adjacent buildings at 51 Louisiana Avenue and 300 New Jersey Avenue NW for
$1,083/SF.
The District of Columbia accounted for the largest share of Washington metro area office sales during 2015, at 40%, but its share was down from 50% in 2014. Northern Virginia accounted for 24% of
total sales and Suburban Maryland 8%. The remaining sales resulted from partial-interest and whole
portfolio transactions. Notably, Brookfield Property Partners sold an eight-property portfolio in the
District and Maryland to an Australian institution for $662 million at a 4.8% cap rate. We expect the
District of Columbia to remain the leader in sales volume throughout this cycle as investors are still
targeting core downtown assets.
S9 | 84
S1
In the Washington area, average cap rates for all major asset classes declined during 2015. The
greatest drop was for Industrial/Distribution (down 80 basis points) and grocery anchored shopping
centers (down 48 basis points). Cap rates continued to hover near historical lows amidst a low interest rate environment and heavy competition among investors.
Class A Garden
Class A High-Rise
$400,000
Apartment pricing increased for garden product in 2015, while the average sales price for highrise product fell. In 2014, the region posted over $1.7 billion of multifamily Class A building sales
(five low-rise properties and 11 mid- or high-rise properties). In 2015, the metro area saw over $2.5
billion of multifamily Class A buildings trade hands (14 low-rise properties and 12 mid-rise or high
rise properties). The 2015 average per-unit price was 9.7% higher than in 2014 for low-rise units (at
$264,462), while high-rise prices fell 14.6% from 2014, at $392,288 per unit. The average price for
high-rise units has dropped off at a 0.3% annualized rate over the past five years.
$300,000
$200,000
$100,000
S2
Washington Area Product Type
S3
S4
$0
Apartments
-22
Office
-1
S5
Industrial/Distribution
+7
S6
+16
S7
Source: Annual survey by Delta Associates, conducted October 2015, of the regions leading commercial real estate players.
9%
For the first time since 2010, replacement cost for existing apartments exceeds sales price. Here are
the figures for a Class A high-rise apartment projects:
Average sales price per unit in 2015:
$392,288
Replacement cost in 2015 1/ $398,000
2010
2011
2014
2015
8.5%
8.4%
8%
7.9%
7.2%
7%
7.2%
7.2%
7.0%
6.8%
6.6% 6.6%
6.4%
6.7%
7.2%
7.1%
6.8%
6.4% 6.4%
6.3%
6.1%
6.0%
6%
5.8%5.8%
5.7%
5.5% 5.5%
Office
Flex/Industrial
5%
Apartments
5.8%
5.3%
GroceryAnchored SC
20
0
20 9
1
20 0
1
20 1
1
20 2
1
20 3
1
20 4
15
20
0
20 9
1
20 0
1
20 1
1
20 2
1
20 3
1
20 4
15
20
0
20 9
1
20 0
1
20 1
1
20 2
1
20 3
1
20 4
15
20
0
20 9
1
20 0
1
20 1
1
20 2
1
20 3
1
20 4
15
2013
8.9%
1/
For downtown office product, replacement cost also exceeds the sale price, although not by much:
2012
Cap rates by property type show that all types in the Washington region experienced a decline in
cap rates over the course of 2015, as shown in the accompanying table.
2009
S10
2008
S8
S9
2007
Historically low demand for new office space explains the narrow spread between office price and
cost. For apartments, the inversion of replacement cost and sales price is a partly a function of the
recent abundance of new product being delivered.
S9 | 85
Prices: Nationally, we expect modest price growth for the first half of 2016, before stabilization later
in the year as the Fed continues to increase interest rates. Demand from institutional and overseas
capital sources will continue to place upward pressure on prices, but asset performance will be an
increasingly important factor in valuations in the year ahead. We expect inflation to be greatest in
secondary cities as core markets begin to overheat and investors hunt for yield. In the Washington
region, price inflation will likely level off at some point during 2016 as the current level of growth
is unsustainable, particularly given the standing of the regions office market and the ever-present
threat of oversupply in the multifamily market. We do not anticipate a substantial reset in prices,
though, as the regions steadily improving economy and attractiveness to foreign investors keep
buyer interest high. As is the case nationally, income growth will weigh heavily in determining prices.
S1
Volume: Transaction volume for CRE assets will continue to be strong in the year ahead as increasing real estate allocations in institutional portfolios offset rising interest rates and a tighter lending
environment. The market has expected higher interest rates for quite a while, and small incremental
increases are unlikely to trigger shocks. Marginally higher interest rates will likely have a positive
effect in the short term as they signal renewed confidence in the national economy.
S9 | 86
2016 TrendSetters
Each year, Transwestern and its consulting affiliate, Delta Associates, honor an individual, or individuals, who have made a noteworthy
contribution to the commercial real estate industry as a whole, and to the Washington metropolitan area in particular.
This year our TrendSetter honorees are James J. Abdo, President & CEO of Abdo Development; and Deborah Ratner Salzberg, President
of Forest City Washington, LLC.
S1
S2
S3
James J. Abdo
President & CEO
Abdo Development
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Over the past twenty years, Abdo Development has built its reputation as a pioneering, innovative developer of high end residential, commercial and retail projects.
Concentrating its activities in emerging neighborhoods around the urban core of
Washington, DC and Northern Virginia, Abdo is particularly well regarded for its
emphasis on historical preservation, bringing distressed, noteworthy structures
back to life without sacrificing their authenticity.
Since joining Forest City in 1985, Deborah Ratner Salzberg has been instrumental in
securing and progressing major mixed-use development projects for the company
in the Washington metropolitan area. Among the most prominent of these are
Waterfront Station in southwest DC, The Yards in the Capitol Riverfront district and
Ballston Quarter in Arlington, VA.
As Founder, President and CEO, Jim Abdo has been at the forefront of this effort to
revitalize buildings and neighborhoods often bypassed by others. By focusing on
adaptive reuse in all projects, Abdo has proven adept at preserving the past while
building modern, new communities.
All of these massive, groundbreaking projects feature the many elements that have
come to define Forest Citys success: transformation of underutilized urban areas;
adaptive reuse of historic structures, creative use of public-private partnerships;
innovative architectural designs; and the creation of vibrant, thriving neighborhoods
where individuals live, work, shop and play.
In addition to serving on the Boards of a host of business and charitable foundations, Jim has received numerous awards for his responsible approach to urban
development. For his pioneering vision and resolute commitment to revitalizing
neighborhoods, we are very pleased to honor Jim Abdo as this years TrendSetter
of the Year.
Beyond her myriad professional accomplishments, Deborah has taken an active role
in countless community, charitable and business organizations both in the Washington, DC region and nationwide. For her distinguished leadership and exemplary
record of service, we are very pleased to honor Deborah Ratner Salzberg as this
years TrendSetter of the Year.
S10 | 88
A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
Mark D. Lerner
Mitchell N. Schear
George Carras
Doug Firstenberg
Michael Stevens
Robert J. Murphy
George F. McKenzie
Doug Donatelli
Elizabeth Price
Thomas S. Bozzuto
James E. Bennett
Donald Wood
Benjamin Jacobs
Michael Glosserman
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S10 | 89
A Region in Transition
S1
S2
S3
S4
Andrew Florance
Milton Peterson
F. Joseph Moravec
Bryant F. Foulger
Clayton F. Foulger
Douglas M. Duncan
R. William Hard
Anthony A. Williams
Robert Gladstone
Thomas M. Garbutt
2001 Institutional
TrendSetter of the Year
Managing Director
TIAA-CREF
Michael J. Darby
Jeffrey T. Neal
Ray DArdenne
Daniel T. McCaffery
Robert E. Burke
Raymond A. Ritchey
2001 Entrepreneurial
TrendSetter of the Year
Principal
Monument Realty, LLC
2001 Entrepreneurial
TrendSetter of the Year
Principal
Monument Realty, LLC
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S10 | 90
A Region in Transition
Delta Associates thanks all of our 2015 Market Maker Survey participants, among whom are the following:
S1
1788 Holdings
Crimson Partners
AHC Inc.
Davis Construction
Aimco
DFS Group
LCOR
Saul Centers
Avison Young
Ditto Residential
Lowe Enterprises
Standard Properties
Bank of Montreal
M&T Bank
StonebridgeCarras, LLC
Berkadia
McCaffery Interests
TF Cornerstone Inc
Eastdil Secured
McEnearney Associates
MetLife
Brookfield Properties
Buvermo Properties
Forge Company
Morgan Ventures
MRP Realty
CBRE
Gosnell Properties
NGKF
TSC Realty
CityInterests
Perkins Eastman
Clarion Partners
PMRG
Rappaport
ZOM
John Hancock
Reed Smith
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
S10 | 91
PNC REAL ESTATE | Successful commercial real estate owners, developers and investors can envision the properties of the future
even before the first sketch is made. PNC Real Estate shares that vision. As a top five originator,* we offer comprehensive banking
insights, solutions and the expertise to put them to work. Whether you need construction, bridge or permanent financing; public equity
or debt solutions; treasury management; risk mitigation; or loan syndications, know that we can help bring your vision to life.
To learn more, visit pnc.com/realestate.
REAL ESTATE BANKING
AGENCY FINANCE
Treasury management and lending products and services, and investment and wealth management and fiduciary services, are provided by PNC Bank, National Association (PNC Bank), a wholly owned subsidiary of PNC and Member
FDIC. Investment banking and capital markets activities are conducted by PNC through its subsidiaries PNC Bank, PNC Capital Markets LLC, Harris Williams LLC, Harris Williams & Co. Ltd. and Solebury Capital LLC. Services such as public
finance investment banking services, securities underwriting, and securities sales and trading are provided by PNC Capital Markets LLC. PNC Capital Markets LLC, Harris Williams LLC and Solebury Capital LLC are registered broker-dealers
and members of FINRA and SIPC, and Harris Williams & Co. Ltd. is authorized and regulated by Financial Services Authority (FRN No. 540892). PNC Bank and certain of its affiliates, including PNC TC, LLC, do business as PNC Real Estate.
Through its Tax Credit Capital segment, PNC Real Estate provides lending services, equity investments and equity investment services relating to low income housing tax credit (LIHTC) and preservation investments. PNC TC, LLC, an SEC
registered investment advisor wholly-owned by PNC Bank, provides investment advisory services to funds sponsored by PNC Real Estate for LIHTC and preservation investments. Registration with the SEC does not imply a certain level of skill
or training. This material does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any investment product.
Lending products and services, as well as certain other banking products and services, require credit approval.
2016 The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
Building a legacy
through real estate.
Congratulations to the TrendLines 2016 TrendSetters:
Deborah Ratner Salzberg of Forest City Enterprises and
Jim Abdo of Abdo Development!
A Region in Transition
Partners in Excellence
Transwestern is the Mid-Atlantic Regions preeminent full-service
commercial real estate firm.
Delta Associates, an affiliate, is a national provider of industry
information, market analysis, and feasibility consulting for
commercial real estate.
S1
S2
Locations
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
Atlanta
Northern Virginia
Austin
Oklahoma City
Baltimore
Orange County
Bethesda
Orlando
Suburban Maryland
6700 Rockledge Drive
Suite 500A
Bethesda, Maryland 20817
301.571.0900
Boston
Phoenix
Chicago
Dallas
San Antonio
Denver
San Diego
Northern Virginia
8614 Westwood Center Drive
Suite 800
Vienna, Virginia 22182
703.821.0040
Detroit
San Francisco
Fort Lauderdale
Fort Worth
Seattle
Greenwich
St. Louis
Houston
Walnut Creek
Los Angeles
Washington, D.C.
Mid-Atlantic Headquarters
1717 K Street, NW
Suite 1000
Washington, DC 20006
202.775.7000
1717 K Street, NW
Suite 1010
Washington, DC 20006
202.778.3100
www.DeltaAssociates.com
Baltimore/Washington Corridor
7160 Columbia Gateway Drive
Suite 210
Columbia, Maryland 21046
443.285.0700
National Headquarters
1900 West Loop South
Suite 1300
Houston, Texas 77027
713.270.7700
www.transwestern.com
Miami
Milwaukee
Minneapolis
New Jersey
New Orleans
New York
S10 | 94
S1
S2
S3
S4
S5
S6
S7
S8
S9
S10
TRANSWESTERN
1717 K Street, NW
Suite 1000
Washington, DC 20006
202.775.7000
www.transwestern.com
PNC
800 17th Street, NW
3rd Floor
Washington, DC 20006
202.835.4513
www.pnc.com/realestate
BAKER TILLY
8219 Leesburg Pike
Suite 800
Vienna, VA 22182
703.923.8300
www.bakertilly.com
DELTA ASSOCIATES
1717 K Street, NW
Suite 1010
Washington, DC 20006
202.778.3100
www.DeltaAssociates.com