Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NOVUS
IP USER
Client ID:
innlsbang-1
Content Type:
Title :
Delivery selection:
Current Document
14/03/2016
Page 2
Case Analysis
Bench
Where Reported
Case Digest
14/03/2016
Page 3
Relied On
Sodan Singh Etc. v New Delhi Municipal Committee And
Anr. Etc.1989 Indlaw SC 213, (1989) 4 SCC 155, AIR 1989
SC 1988, 1989 ALJ 1097, JT 1989 (3) SC 553, 1989(2)
SCALE 430, [1989] 3 S.C.R. 1038, 1990 (1) UJ 187
Kumari Chitra Ghosh and Another v Union of India and
Others1969 Indlaw SC 525, (1969) 2 SCC 228, AIR 1970
SC 35, [1970] 1 S.C.R. 413
Minor P. Rajendran v State of Madras and Others1968
Indlaw SC 341, AIR 1968 SC 1012, 1968 (2) MLJ(SC) 121,
1968 (2) SCJ 801, [1968] 2 S.C.R. 786, 1968 (2) SLJ 801
R. Chitralekha and Another v State of Mysore and
Others1964 Indlaw SC 103, AIR 1964 SC 1823, [1964] 6
S.C.R. 368
Affirmed
St. Stephen'S College v University Of Delhi 1991 Indlaw
SC 295, (1992) 1 SCC 558, AIR 1992 SC 1630, AIR 1992
SCW 1792, JT 1991 (4) SC 548, 1991(2) SCALE 1217,
1991 (6) SLR 1, [1991] Supp3 S.C.R. 121
Stephen's College vs. University of Delhi1992 (1) SC 558
Overruled
Unni Krishnan, J.P. And Ors. Etc. Etc v State Of Andhra
Pradesh And Ors. Etc. Etc.1993 Indlaw SC 1056, (1993) 1
SCC 645, AIR 1993 SC 2178, AIR 1993 SCW 863, JT 1993
(1) SC 474, 1993(1) SCALE 290, [1993] 1 S.C.R. 594,
1993 (1) SLR 743, 1993 (1) UJ 721
Distinguished
14/03/2016
Page 4
14/03/2016
Page 5
14/03/2016
Page 6
14/03/2016
Page 7
14/03/2016
Page 8
14/03/2016
Page 9
14/03/2016
Page 10
14/03/2016
Page 11
14/03/2016
Page 12
14/03/2016
Page 13
14/03/2016
Page 14
14/03/2016
Page 15
others
2013 Indlaw PNH 4868, 2014 (174) PLR 84
Saraswathi Educational Society and five others v
Government of Andhra Pradesh, Represented by its
Principal Secretary, Higher Education Department,
Hyderabad and others
2013 Indlaw AP 761, 2014 (1) ALD 580, 2014 (1) ALT 781
Sachin Mehta and others v State of Rajasthan and others
2013 Indlaw RAJ 1869, 2014 (3) SLR 776
H-Private Universities Management Association (H-PUMA) v
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
2013 Indlaw HP 915
Delhi High Court Bar Association and others v Govt. of (NCT
of Delhi) and another
2013 Indlaw DEL 2669, 2013 (203) DLT 129
Rita Mukherjee and others v State of West Bengal and
others
2013 Indlaw CAL 743, 2013 (4) CalLT 560
Thalappalam Ser. Co-op. Bank Limited and others v State of
Kerala and others
2013 Indlaw SC 663, (2013) 16 SCC 82, AIR 2013 SC
(Supp) 437, 2014(1) ALL MR 451, 2013 (6) AWC 6215,
2014 (1) CLT(SC) 187, 2014 (1) CompLJ 319, 2013 (6)
CTC 98, 2013 (4) KLT 232, 2014 (3) Law Herald (P&H)
1999, 2013 (7) MLJ 407, 2013 (4) RCR(Civil) 912,
2013(12) SCALE 527
Gujarat Minority Schools Association and others v State of
Gujarat and others
2013 Indlaw GUJ 1318, 2014 (2) G.L.R. 921
Tummuri Jalandhari v Government of Andhra Pradesh,
Represented by its Principal Secretary, Health Medical and
Family Welfare Department, Hyderabad and others
2013 Indlaw AP 193, 2013 (6) ALD 155, 2013 (5) ALT 749
Centurion University of Technology and Management,
Represented Through Pro-vice Chancellor, Ardhendu Mouli
Mohanty v State of Odisha and others
2013 Indlaw ORI 132
Bhojia Dental College and Hospital and another v State of
Himachal Pradesh through Principal Secretary and another
2013 Indlaw HP 865
14/03/2016
Page 16
14/03/2016
Page 17
14/03/2016
Page 18
14/03/2016
Page 19
14/03/2016
Page 20
14/03/2016
Page 21
14/03/2016
Page 22
others
2011 Indlaw DEL 3410, 2011 (185) DLT 168
Consortium of Engineering Colleges Managements
Association (CECMA) and others v Government of Andhra
Pradesh and others
2011 Indlaw AP 377, 2013 (3) ALD 572
V. Krishna Moorthy and others v State of Tamil Nadu
(Department of Education), Chennai and others
2011 Indlaw MAD 1041
Dr. T. Varghese George v Kora K. George & Ors.
2011 Indlaw SC 744, (2012) 1 SCC 369, AIR 2012 SC 144,
2011 (4) CLT(SC) 190, [2011] 12 S.C.R. 1070, 2012 (2)
UPLBEC 1325, 2012 (1) WLN(SC) 1
Colvin School Society and another v Anil Kumar Sharma
and another
2011 Indlaw SC 726, (2012) 1 SCC 200, 2012 (3) AWC
2755
Fee Regulatory Committee v Kalol Institute Of
Management, Etc
2011 Indlaw SC 732, (2011) 10 SCC 592, AIR 2012 SC
203, 2011 (5) ESC 756, [2011] 11 S.C.R. 829
Chhatrapalsinh Parakramsinh Jadeja Since Minor v Central
Board of Secondary Education
2011 Indlaw GUJ 1368
D. A. V. College Managing Committee v Laxminarayan
Mishra and others
2011 Indlaw ORI 167, 2011 (2) ILR(Cut) 730
Mount Abu Education Society v Anshu Sharma and another
2011 Indlaw DEL 3303, 2011 (183) DLT 184
Federation of Andhra Pradesh Minority Educational
Institution v Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee for
Matters relating To Fee Fixation in Private Unaided
Professional Colleges and others
2011 Indlaw SC 552, (2011) 12 SCC 358, 2012 (1)
ALD(SC) 50, JT 2011 (11) SC 159, 2011(9) SCALE 422
Dr. A. Christopher Asir, President, Governing Council of the
American College and another v State of Tamil Nadu and
others
2011 Indlaw MAD 766, 2012 (1) ESC 84
State Of Tamil Nadu & Ors. v K. Shyam Sunder & Ors.
14/03/2016
Page 23
2011 Indlaw SC 493, (2011) 8 SCC 737, 2011 (4) CTC 874,
JT 2011 (9) SC 166, 2011(8) SCALE 474, [2011] 11 S.C.R.
1094
Anmol Sandhu and another v Council for the Indian
Certificate of Secondary Education, through its Secretary,
New Delhi and others
2011 Indlaw UTT 1301
Management Board of Ansal Institute of Technology,
Gurgaon and others v State of Haryana and another
2011 Indlaw PNH 1144
Committee of Management, Aditya Birla Intermediate
College, Renukoot, Sonebhadra v State of Uttar Pradesh
and others
2011 Indlaw ALL 637, 2011 (7) ADJ 348, 2011 (88) ALR
586, 2012 (1) AWC 840
Dr. A. Safiullah v Director of Collegiate Education and
others
2011 Indlaw MAD 412
Management of DAV Public School and others v State of
Orissa and another
2011 Indlaw ORI 245, 2011 (2) ILR(Cut) 301
Harsh Vardhan Mathur v State of Jharkhand and another
2011 Indlaw JHKD 433
Ajinder Kaur Lamba and others v Guru Harkrishan Public
School and others
2011 Indlaw DEL 1061
NIMS University Rajasthan, Jaipur v State of Rajasthan and
others
2011 Indlaw RAJ 296
Humanity and others v State Of West Bengal And Others
2011 Indlaw SC 375, (2011) 6 SCC 125, AIR 2011 SC
2308, 2011 (88) ALR 261, 2011 (4) AWC 4286, 2011 (4)
CalLT 9, 2011 (3) CLT(SC) 403, JT 2011 (6) SC 334, 2011
(5) RCR(Civil) 439, 2011(6) SCALE 378, [2011] 8 S.C.R.
653
Haji Ismail Degree College v State of Uttar Pradesh and
others
2011 Indlaw ALL 542, 2011 (7) ADJ 23
Indian Medical Association and others v Union of India and
others
2011 Indlaw SC 379, (2011) 7 SCC 179, AIR 2011 SC
14/03/2016
Page 24
14/03/2016
Page 25
14/03/2016
Page 26
14/03/2016
Page 27
14/03/2016
Page 28
14/03/2016
Page 29
14/03/2016
Page 30
14/03/2016
Page 31
14/03/2016
Page 32
14/03/2016
Page 33
14/03/2016
Page 34
14/03/2016
Page 35
14/03/2016
Page 36
14/03/2016
Page 37
14/03/2016
Page 38
2007 Indlaw ALL 2073, 2007 (7) ADJ 429, AIR 2007 ALL
204, 2007 (4) AWC 3607, 2007 (4) ESC 2580, 2007 (3)
UPLBEC 2187
Vishnu Dayal Sharma v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
2007 Indlaw ALL 687
Madha Engineering College Kundrathur, Chennai and Others
v State of Tamil Nadu and Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 1337, 2007 (4) CTC 13
D. Aravinth and Others Etc v State of Tamil Nadu and
Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 2268, AIR 2007 MAD 300
Committee of Management, L.P. Inter College, Kanpur and
Another v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
2007 Indlaw ALL 834, 2007 (6) ADJ 621
Orissa Management Colleges Association and Etc v State of
Orissa and Etc
2007 Indlaw ORI 53, AIR 2007 ORI 120
R.V.P.R.T., Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Akola v Assistant
Provident Fund Commissioner, Nagpur and Others
2007 Indlaw MUM 400, 2007(4) ALL MR 584
R. V. P. R. T. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Akola v Assistant
Provident Fund Commissioner and others
2007 Indlaw MUM 1551, 2007 (3) LLJ 561, 2007 (4) MahLJ
273
B. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman, Nalgonda-Ranga Reddy
Milk Producers Co-Operative (District) Union Limited and
Others v State of Andhra Pradesh, Represented By Its
Secretary, Legislative Affairs and Justice, Law Department
and Others
2007 Indlaw AP 657, 2007 (6) ALT 681
S. Aswin Kumar and Others v State of Tamil Nadu and
Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 973, 2007 (2) CTC 677
Priyanka and Others Etc v State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others
2007 Indlaw MP 122, AIR 2007 MP 182, 2007(2) M.P.H.T.
536, 2007 (3) MPLJ 325
Priyanka D/o Chandra Prakash and others v State of
Madhya Pradesh and others
2007 Indlaw MPLJ 463
14/03/2016
Page 39
14/03/2016
Page 40
14/03/2016
Page 41
14/03/2016
Page 42
14/03/2016
Page 43
2006 Indlaw ALL 1310, 2006 (1) AWC 992, 2006 (1) ESC
147, 2006 (1) UPLBEC 268
Lisie Medical and Educational Institutions v State of Kerala
2006 Indlaw KER 115, 2007 (1) KLT 409
Abhishek v State of Uttaranchal and Others
2006 Indlaw UTT 12, AIR 2006 UTT 64, 2006 (2) UC 1011
Smt. G. Bharati Tarak Rao v Director of Education and
Others
2006 Indlaw DEL 25, 2006 (127) DLT 50
Committed of Management, National Inter College, Lal
Kurti, Meerut and another v Joint Director of Education,
Region-I, Meerut and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 594, 2005 (1) AWC 988, 2005 (1) ESC
740
Gopal Ji Trivedi v State of U. P. and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1455, 2006 (6) AWC 6126
M.I. Hussain v N. Singh and Others
2005 Indlaw DEL 1120, 2005 (8) AD(Del) 499, AIR 2006
DEL 86, 2005 (125) DLT 223, 2005 (85) DRJ 282
Dr. Naresh Agarwal v Union of India and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1457, 2005 (4) AWC 3745, 2005 (4) ESC
2489, 2005 (3) UPLBEC 2246
Lalita Rajpal v Director of Education and Others
2005 Indlaw DEL 1152, 2005 (125) DLT 581
Hon'Ble Justice R. J. Shah (Retd.) Fee Admission Committee
v G. S. E. Medical and Paramedical Association and Others
2005 Indlaw GUJ 250, AIR 2006 GUJ 40
Welfare Association of Self-Financed Institutions and others
v State of U. P. and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1477, 2005 (6) AWC 6199
P.A. Inamdar and Others v State of Maharashtra and
Others
2005 Indlaw SC 463, (2005) 6 SCC 537, AIR 2005 SC
3226, 2005 (4) AWC 3864B, 2005 (5) Bom.C.R. 859, 2005
(3) ESC 373, JT 2005 (7) SC 313, 2005 (2) LCD 1358,
2005(6) SCALE 471, 2005 (5) SLR 409, [2005] Supp2
S.C.R. 603, 2005 (5) Supreme 544, 2005 (3) UPLBEC 2295
Bal Patil and Another v Union of India and Others
2005 Indlaw SC 464, (2005) 6 SCC 690, AIR 2005 SC
3172, 2005 (5) ALD(SC) 123, 2005 (3) AWC 2796, 2005
14/03/2016
Page 44
14/03/2016
Page 45
14/03/2016
Page 46
14/03/2016
Page 47
14/03/2016
Page 48
14/03/2016
Page 49
Another
2003 Indlaw SC 1167, (2003) 12 SCC 414, AIR 2004 SC
1177, 2004 (54) ALR 172, 2003(10) SCALE 947, 2004 (1)
SLT 950, 2003 (8) Supreme 813
Keraleeya Samajam and others v State of Maharashtra and
others
2003 Indlaw MUM 808, 2004 (3) Bom.C.R. 723, 2004 (2)
MahLJ 171
Manager, Nirmala Senior Secondary School, Port v N.I.
Khan and Others
2003 Indlaw SC 1068, (2003) 12 SCC 84, (2004) SCC
(L&S) 1002, AIR 2004 SC 499, 2004 (1) CLR 644, 2004
(100) FLR 494, JT 2003 (9) SC 472, 2004 (1) LLN 43,
2003(10) SCALE 121, 2003 (1) SCW 6549, 2004 (1) SLR
397, 2003 (7) SLT 351, [2003] Supp6 S.C.R. 75, 2003 (8)
Supreme 437, 2004 (1) UPLBEC 997
State Of Punjab And Another v M/S. Devans Modern
Brewaries And Another
2003 Indlaw SC 1507, (2004) 11 SCC 26, JT 2003 (10) SC
485, 2003(10) SCALE 202, [2003] Supp5 S.C.R. 930
Government of Andhra Pradesh and another v Medwin
Educational Society and Others
2003 Indlaw SC 971, (2004) 1 SCC 86, AIR 2004 SC 613,
2004 (1) ESC 90, JT 2003 (8) SC 567, 2003(9) SCALE 500,
2003 (1) SCW 6162, 2003 (8) SLR 500, 2004 (1) SLT 12,
[2003] Supp5 S.C.R. 408, 2004 (1) Supreme 412, 2004 (1)
UPLBEC 372
Christian Medical College and Hospital, Vellore v Inspector
of Labour, Vellore and Another
2003 Indlaw MAD 99
Saurabh Chaudri and Others v Union of India and Others
2003 Indlaw SC 959, (2003) 11 SCC 146, AIR 2004 SC
361, JT 2003 (8) SC 296, 2003(9) SCALE 272, 2003 (1)
SCW 6392, 2004 (1) SLR 287, 2003 (6) SLT 724, [2003]
Supp5 S.C.R. 152, 2004 (1) Supreme 26, 2004 (1) UPLBEC
279
P.V.Suter Paul v Manager and Others
2003 Indlaw KER 261, 2003 (3) KLT 1019
Educate India Society v All India Council For Technical
Education
2003 Indlaw DEL 820, 2003 (8) AD(Del) 91, 2003 (108)
DLT 274
14/03/2016
Page 50
14/03/2016
Page 51
Legislation Cited
14/03/2016
Page 52
14/03/2016
Page 53