Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Subscribe (/subscribe)
Register (/user/register)
A (#)
A (#)
Podcasts (https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-gramophone-magazine/id944184210)
Facebook (http://www.facebook.com/pages/Gramophone/87870680838)
Twitter (http://twitter.com/gramophonemag)
Youtube (http://www.youtube.com/user/GramophoneMagazine)
The Archive
90 years of Gramophone now at
your fingertips
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009240/0/225/AdId=14217216;BnId=2;itime=265329679;key=Wolfgang%2520Amadeus%
(http://www.gramophone.co.uk/
2520Mozart;)
/classical-musicnews/gramophone-launchesnew-digital-archive-app)
Search
Go
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009240/0/225/AdId=14217216;BnId=2;itime=265329679;key=Wolfgang%2520Amadeus%
Est 1923
2520Mozart;)
(/)
HOME
REVIEWS
COMPOSERS
NEWS
FEATURES
(/)
(/REVIEWS)
(/COMPOSERS)
(/CLASSICAL-MUSIC-NEWS)
(/FEATURES)
AWARDS
HALL OF FAME
BLOGS
FORUM
SUBSCRIBE
(HTTP://WWW.GRAMOPHONE.CO.UK/AWARDS/2015)
(/HALLOFFAME)
(/BLOG/ALL)
(/FORUM)
(/SUBSCRIBE)
Home (/) Features (/features) The best recording of Mozarts Sinfonia concertante for violin and viola
Follow us
(http://www.facebook.com/GramophoneMagazin
(//twitter.com/gramophonemag)
(https://plus.google.com/115887304357022119
(http://www.youtube.com/user/GramophoneMag
sub_confirmation=1)
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009239/0/170/AdId=10881647;
BnId=3;itime=265349643;key=Wolfgang%2520
Amadeus%2520Mozart;)
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009239/0/170/AdId=14304503;
BnId=1;itime=265330217;key=Wolfgang%2520
Amadeus%2520Mozart;)
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009239/0/170/AdId=14304503;
BnId=1;itime=265330217;key=Wolfgang%2520
Amadeus%2520Mozart;)
The complete
subscription
Join the Club today
and receive all three great
Gramophone products
for just 103 per year.
An 83 saving than if
bought separately.
(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music1/gramophone/gramophone-premium)
from the 1951 Perpignan Festival with Isaac Stern, the second from
1956 with another famed violinist of the Russian school, Jascha
Heifetz. Yet its hard to believe Primrose had much say over tempo.
In the performance with Stern, conducted by Pablo Casals, the
The all-time
greats
Read about the artists
who changed the world
of classical music.
(http://www.gramophone.co.uk/features/focus/
gramophone-hall-of-fame)
(https://twitter.com/GramophoneMag)
(https://twitter.com/GramophoneMag)
Tweets by @GramophoneMag
Gramophone
@GramophoneMag
Embed
View on Twitter
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009238/0/529/AdId=14361562;
BnId=1;itime=265330559;key=Wolfgang%2520
Amadeus%2520Mozart;)
(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009238/0/529/AdId=14361562;
BnId=1;itime=265330559;key=Wolfgang%2520
Amadeus%2520Mozart;)
Period Influence
The lightness of touch, solo and orchestral, makes the 1989 BrownImai recording one of the earliest to absorb some of the lessons of
historically informed performance. Yet while period versions of
Mozarts symphonies are ten a penny, there are surprisingly few
performances of the Sinfonia concertante using gut strings and
natural horns. Rachel Podger and Pavlo Beznosiuk, with the
Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment in 2009, are at their best in a
frolicking, rollicking finale, spiced (uniquely in this survey) by cheeky
touches of ornamentation. They also take the fermatas at the
opening of the first-movement development as a cue for
spontaneous elaboration, as Mozart himself would probably have
done. Beyond this, their first movement is sturdy and straightforward,
their Andante properly flowing, though less inward than some.
Podger and Beznosiuk form a close, democratic
partnership. In two other period (or quasi-period)
versions, the violinist tends to outshine the viola player
in personality and sometimes sheer volume. In
2005, Thomas Zehetmair plays with a sense of fantasy
that can leave the husky-toned Ruth Killius in the
shade, though he tends to rush his fences in the outer
movements. In the Andante, borne on an urgent forward
motion, violin and viola often sound like a pair of viols.
In 2007 on Archiv, we hear a more massively conceived
period performance (and we know that Mozart liked large orchestras)
from Giuliano Carmignola and Danusha Wakiewicz with Claudio
Abbados Orchestra Mozart. This is arguably the bestconducted Sinfonia concertante on disc, unsurpassed in its longrange vision and placing and timing of orchestral detail. No other
conductor articulates so clearly the swirls of semiquavers in the violas
and basses, or makes the slow-burn crescendo in the opening tutti
Mozart beating the Mannheimers at their own game so elementally
thrilling. Abbado and his soloists ignore the composers
prescribed maestoso. Pathos is at a premium. Instead, the first
movement veers between high-voltage nervous intensity and a kind
of edgy playfulness. As recorded, Wakiewiczs viola has a slightly
dry, nasal timbre. But while she emerges as the more passive partner,
she reacts sensitively to the impulsively inventive Carmignola,
A Close Second
Julia Fischer vn Gordan Nikoli va Netherlands CO /
Yakov Kreizberg
(Pentatone)
Yakov Kreizbergs fiery opening tutti sets the tone for a
performance bristling with energy and imagination.
Fischer and Nikoli dare expressive extremes in
the Andante without ever letting the music sag. Read the
review (/review/mozart-concertone-rondo-k273sinfonia-concertante)
Top Choice
Iona Brown vn Lars Anders Tomter va Norwegian
Chamber Orchestra
(Chandos)
Superbly matched soloists and lithe ensemble playing in
a joyous performance mingling subtlety of detail with a
natural Mozartian flow. The Andante is profoundly
moving in its subtlety and restraint. Read the review
(/review/mozart-sinfonia-concertante-k364-2-pianoconcerto-k365)
Selected Discography
Date / Artists / Record company (review date)
1951 Stern, Primrose; Perpignan Fest Orch / Casals / Pearl
GEMS0168 (12/53R)
1953 Brainin, Schidlof; ECO / Britten / BBC Legends BBCB8010-2
1956 Heifetz, Primrose; RCA Victor SO / Solomon / RCA 88697
76138-2 (6/88R)
1963 I & D Oistrakh; Moscow PO / Kondrashin / Decca 470 2582DL2 (5/02R); 476 7288CC2
1963 I & D Oistrakh; Moscow PO / Menuhin / ICA ICAD5012
(11/99R, 9/11)
1964 Grumiaux, Pelliccia; LSO / C Davis / Philips 438 323-2PM2
(9/93)
1971 I & D Oistrakh; BPO / EMI 214712-2
1982 Perlman, Zukerman; Israel PO / Mehta / DG 415 486-2GH
(12/85); 476 1651PR
1983 Kremer, Kashkashian; VPO / Harnoncourt / DG 453 0432GTA2 (12/84R)
Gramophone
Subscriptions
Print
Edition (#)
(#)
Tweet (http://twitter.com/share)
8 (#)
Gramophone Print
The Gramophone
Club
(#)
(#)
Digital
Edition (#)
Digital
Archive (#)
8 (#)
(#)
The Gramophone
Digital Club
Gramophone
Reviews
Gramophone
Digital Edition
(#)
(#)
(#)
(#)
(#)
Reviews
Database
(#)
Events &
Oers (#)
(#)
(#)
(#)
(#)
From
50/year
From
(#)
50/year
From
50/year
(#)
Subscribe (http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music-1/gramophone/gramophone-magazine?utm_source=gramophone.co.uk
Subscribe (http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/m
Subscribe (http://mags
From
/year
From
82/year
66
Subscribe (http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music-1/gramophone/gram
Subscribe (http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music-1/gramophone/gramophone-premium?utm_so
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here
(https://institutions.exacteditions.com/gramophone)for further information.
Home (/)
Composers
(/composers)
Features (/Features)
Hall of Fame
(/halloffame)
Awards (/awards)
Blogs (/blog/all)
Contact Us (/contactus)
House Rules (/houserules)
Privacy Policy
(/privacy-policy)
Terms & Conditions
(/page/websiteterms-andconditions)
Twitter
(http://twitter.com/g
ramophonemag)
Facebook
(http://www.facebook
.com/pages/Gramop
hone/87870680838)
Sign In (/user/login)
Register
(/user/register)
Latest issue (/latestissue/april-2016)