Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Algal bio-fuels-Neg
INDEX:
Algal bio-fuels-Neg.............................................................................................................1
Inherency............................................................................................................................1
Pentagon is only months away from producing $3/Gallon algal fuel.....................................................1
The SQ if left alone will start producing Algal fuel at a competitive price to oil...................................1
Algal biofuels are already subsidized and will produce plenty in the SQ..............................................2
Solvency..............................................................................................................................2
There are currently no companies that can produce algal fuel on the necessary large scale for the
market......................................................................................................................................................2
Disadvantages.....................................................................................................................2
Immoral/unconstitutional/stupid subsidies.............................................................................2
Wasted Water and energy and greater GHG emissions .......................................................3
Algal fuels has higher GHG emissions, wastes more water, and is wastes more energy than corn
ethanol and other biofuels ......................................................................................................................3
Environmental degradation from fertilizers...........................................................................3
Algal fuels require much more fertilizer and petroleum energy input....................................................3
Wasted energy and greater dependence on fossil fuels..........................................................4
You have to burn extra fossil fuels to get the extra co2 required to turn the algal materials to fuel......4
Algal fuel production takes a ton of energy............................................................................................4
Inherency
Pentagon is only months away from producing $3/Gallon algal fuel
Wired news February 19, 2010 “Pentagon Researcher Promises Cheap Biofuel for Jets”
http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2010/02/pentagon-researcher-promises-cheap-biofuel-for-jets/
Pentagon officials have been talking for years about weaning their jets off of fossil fuels.
Now they say they’re only months away from producing a cheap fuel made from algae —
for less than $3 a gallon
The SQ if left alone will start producing Algal fuel at a competitive price to oil
Wired news February 19, 2010 “Pentagon Researcher Promises Cheap Biofuel for Jets”
http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2010/02/pentagon-researcher-promises-cheap-biofuel-for-jets/
Barbara McQuiston of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (Darpa) told
The Guardian, research projects have already produced fuel from algae at a cost of $2 a
gallon. She said a large scale production operation would come on line in 2011. The
facility would be able to produce 50 million gallons a year, and the costs would be
competitive with traditional, petroleum based fuels.
1
Josh Wilson Algal bio-fuels Neg Page 2 of 4
Algal biofuels are already subsidized and will produce plenty in the SQ
The Houston Chronicle December 5, 2009 “Federal money set to flow to renewable fuel projects”
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/business/6754306.html
Algenol Biofuels is slated to get $25 million for its 24-acre pilot-scale biorefinery in
Freeport, which will use algae to make ethanol from carbon dioxide and sea water.
In collaboration with Dow Chemical Co., the Georgia Institute of Technology and other
groups, the facility is expected to be able to produce 100,000 gallons of fuel-grade
ethanol annually
(Note: Don’t run this with the former inherency argument)
Solvency
There are currently no companies that can produce algal fuel on the necessary large
scale for the market
Wired news February 19, 2010 “Pentagon Researcher Promises Cheap Biofuel for Jets”
http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2010/02/pentagon-researcher-promises-cheap-biofuel-for-jets/
The Pentagon has big plans for biofuels — including a green strike group, with bio-powered F/A-
18s flying off of the aircraft carrier’s deck. But right now, there’s no company that can produce
the stuff cheaply enough or in great enough quantities.
Disadvantages
Immoral/unconstitutional/stupid subsidies
Use this DA if you are going to run the first or second inherency card, the argument
would go:
Link) Algal biofuels already sustainable
Internal link) AFF subsidizes them anyway
Impact) Subsidies are unconstitutional/harm human rights/distort markets/fail etc. (Use
all your subsidies=evilness/epic failure cards here, I’ve already got good ones from
source books that I’m not at liberty to trade so I’m not going to bother reproducing other
cards here.
If the aff challenges uniqueness you could argue it as a Kritik or just say less of a bad
thing is a good thing.
2
Josh Wilson Algal bio-fuels Neg Page 3 of 4
3
Josh Wilson Algal bio-fuels Neg Page 4 of 4