Professional Documents
Culture Documents
During the Cold War, except for hardcore Cold Warriors to whom all Communists
were identical, there was a relatively broad consensus about the specificities of
Chinese communism, generally identified with Maoism.
Actually these two terms are not synonymous. The term Maoism does not exist in
Chinese, but the CCP coined the term Mao-Zedong-thought to refer
to Maos reading of Marxism. Usually when historians talk of Maoism they refer
more broadly to one strand in Chinese communism, embodied and supported by
Mao, but not limited to the actions or thought of one person. Some people argue
that the early years of the PRC (from the Revolution in 1949 to the earliest
manifestations of the Great Leap Forward) were of course Communist Chinese,
but Maoist, meaning that the peculiarities of Maoism were not expressed very
clearly during that period.
Mao made much of the PRCs (and his) specificities compared with the USSR, at
least after Stalin died in 1953. His arguments were more or less taken up by
foreign observers. In this view, what made Maoism special was the adaptation of
Marxism or Marxism-Leninism to the Chinese reality actually, of Stalinism
would be more appropriate the model Mao and most of his comrades learned
from was Stalinism. The CCP was created in 1921 but it was tiny at that time, and
even his leaders had a very poor knowledge of what Communism was supposed
to be. Until 1927 there is a variety of influences exerted through the Comintern
(Boukharin, Trotski, Stalin), but after 1927 and the beginning of the civil war
with the Guomindang the main influence is Stalinism (Stalin himself eliminating
his rivals in the USSR around the same time).
The differences with Soviet communism according to this version are:
1
the heavy emphasis laid on the peasantry and the need, in Maos words, to
walk on two legs, i.e. not to neglect agricultural/rural development
(including small-scale industrialization in rural areas) like he thought the
Soviets had done
guerilla warfare as the main tool of victory. This is connected to the
previous point, since guerilla warfare implies being able to hide in the
countryside, hence to be close to the peasants. In Maos words again,
guerillas must hide in the population like a fish in water (actually this is
probably apocryphal, but whatever)
a very critical take on bureaucracy, a kind of ultra-leftist egalitarian
tendency very hostile to the privileges of the nomenklatura (as opposed,
for instance, to Stalin, who cared very little about this and even built his
power base on it).
About the peasantry. It is undeniable that Mao (himself a peasant) and his
comrades were conscious that China was even more overwhelmingly rural
than Russia in 1917, and had to deal with it. The land reform was impulse
by the state in China (in Russia it was mostly anarchical), which helped
strengthen the relationship between the Communists and the peasants.
After 1949, industrialization (and therefore urbanization) could only
proceed at a relatively slow pace, and the CCP leadership prevented a
mass influx of peasants into cities through a residence permit system (the
hukou). And during the Great Leap Forward, it is true that Mao encouraged
68). And he dies an old Stalinist despot in 1976. Stalinism prevails in the
end.