Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Treatment of Schizophrenia
Introduction
Early in January 1995, a 24-year old female patient was in my office with her
parents. Her parents were cheerful, the patient was exuberant. She was
normal by my criteria. She told me of her plans to attend university at Simon
Fraser University. I had first seen her 10 months earlier. She had been
schizophrenic for four years and was on heavy doses of drugs including one
of the recent ones so highly touted. Her psychiatrists had informed her and
her family that she would never recover, but that she might stabilize on her
tranquilizers by the time she reached age 30.
What is it worth to save a human from the fate of the chronically tranquilized
psychotic, barely able to get by to stabilize? I urge all physicians to reward
themselves and their patients by witnessing these recoveries. Do not wait for
their psychiatrists. They are still "avant guard" as of 30 years ago. Do it
yourself.
I have been practicing nutritional medicine since 1951, when I first began to
treat schizophrenic patients with large doses of vitamin B-3 and vitamin C. Dr.
Osmond and I were directed toward the use of these two vitamins by the
hypothesis we had developed about the cause of schizophrenia. We thought
that a main biochemical problem with the schizophrenic body was an
abnormal diversion of adrenaline into adrenochrome. Adrenochrome is an
hallucinogen( 1) which has an inhibitory effect on transmission at the synapse.
In 1952 the idea that adrenochrome was present in the body was resisted
strongly, but recently adrenolutin, the first major derivative from adrenochrome
has been proven to be present in the body.( 2, 3)
The chemistry of adrenalin and adrenochrome suggested that the formation of
the oxidation product could be inhibited by using nicotinic acid which is a
methyl acceptor and ascorbic acid which is an antioxidant. Removing methyl
acceptors from the body's pool of methyl groups would decrease the formation
of adrenalin from noradrenalin, and adding vitamin C would decrease the rate
Vitamins were used only to prevent classical deficiency diseases such as beri,
scurvy, pellagra and rickets. The vitamin paradigm was described by the
following statements: ( 1) vitamins were needed in very small quantities in
order to prevent deficiency diseases, enshrined by the recommended daily
allowances (RDA); ( 2) these quantities were available in a well balanced diet
which therefore did not need to be supplemented; ( 3) any dose above that
would not be therapeutic for anything but would be a waste of money since
the extra amount could not yield any additional good health and could be
toxic. The underpinnings of this paradigm were weak to begin with, and
became even less substantial when pellagrologists in the mid-30's showed
that the prevention of a resurgence of symptoms in chronic pellagrins required
600 mg of niacin (vitamin B-3) daily. To prevent pellagra in the first place less
than 20 mg daily is needed. This is the first example of using megadoses of
any vitamin for preventing disease.
We studied vitamin B-3 for treating acute schizophrenic patients in four double
blind controlled experiments beginning in 1951.( 3) In Saskatchewan we
studied the therapeutic effect of vitamin B-3 for acute schizophrenic patients.(
6) We concluded that adding this vitamin in doses of 3 grams daily to the
current best treatment program, doubled the two-year recovery rate. For many
years psychiatry has maintained that about one-third of schizophrenic patients
who become sick for the first time and have not been sick for a long time,
about one-third will recover even with no treatment. This is known as the
spontaneous recovery rate. I think this estimate is wrong because it is based
on the number of patients readmitted to hospital and not upon the real
recovery rate. I have seen many patients who had been admitted once to a
psychiatric hospital and who never reappeared there. Their psychosis did not
become as severe and they were able to stay out of hospital, but they were
not well. They remained chronically depressed, occasionally paranoid, almost
always in some difficulty. They were no longer having obvious hallucinations
but no one could have described them as well. In my opinion the natural or
spontaneous recovery rate is closer to 10 percent.
With the use of vitamin B-3 I have continued to see similar and even better
recovery rates as the program has become more sophisticated and
comprehensive. Our double blind experiments have become the standard way
to 200 pounds per person. The other additives are present in smaller
quantities, perhaps 5 pounds per person, but they are much more potent and
include any of the large list of chemicals allowed in our foods. They are there
for cosmetic reasons and to enhance stability over time. They do not maintain
or improve the nutritional quality of these foods.
2) The Supplements Vitamins
All the vitamins are safe when used in the dosages recommended by
orthomolecular physicians. They are very safe even in doses much larger than
these, but there is no point in taking more than is needed. Water soluble
vitamins are safer because they are not stored in the body to the same degree
as the fat soluble vitamins. The few fat soluble vitamins are vitamins A, D-3
and E. As a general rule it is wiser to take slightly more vitamin than is
required because they are so safe and this ensures that all the tissues are
provided with enough. The body is not stressed by taking slightly more, as it is
by taking slightly less. If there is a deficiency, some reactions in the body will
have to be slowed or halted and vitamin stores will be depleted making the
situation even worse. More does not slow down metabolism, less does.
Niacin and Niacinamide (also called nicotinic acid and nicotinamide
respectively; both are covered by the term vitamin B-3).(7)
Pellagra, the vitamin B-3 deficiency disease, is rare in industrialized countries,
but subclinical states of pellagra are a lot more common than nutritionists
have recognized. The four descriptive terms for pellagra are dermatitis,
diarrhea, dementia and finally death, for it is a terminal disease. This vitamin
is the one used most consistently by orthomolecular physicians. In
Saskatchewan we examined its role in treating schizophrenic patients over 40
years ago. It is a water soluble vitamin and safe in the following dose ranges.
(A) Niacin -- Up to 9 grams daily. Usually less than 6 grams is needed and the
most frequent dose is 1-1/2 to 3 grams daily. The maximum dose can be
determined by increasing the dose until the person becomes nauseated. As
soon as this happens the dose must be reduced. The nauseant dose varies
enormously from 3 to over 30 grams daily. The dose varies with the condition
being treated. To lower cholesterol levels the dose range is 1-1/2 to 9 grams
(B) Niacinamide -- This form of vitamin B-3 has a narrower dose range. Many
fewer people can tolerate more than 6 grams daily before getting nausea. The
most frequent dose is 3 grams daily. The decrease in tolerance for
niacinamide is a disadvantage since many patients need more than 6 grams.
If this is the case one can use smaller doses of both forms. Thus if 9 grams of
total B-3 is needed, one can use 4-1/2 grams of each form. Each form will be
below the dose which causes nausea but the total dose will be 9 grams.
I prefer to use niacinamide for young people who often cannot tolerate the
niacin flush or for people who do not want to flush for cosmetic reasons. It
might be embarrassing to flush in a social or business setting. Having both
forms greatly increases the versatility of this vitamin as one can switch from
one to the other depending upon the response. The indications are the same
except that niacinamide does not lower cholesterol and probably does not
have the same beneficial cardiovascular effects.
Pyridoxine, Vitamin B-6
This is the second most frequent member of the B vitamins used by
orthomolecular therapists. At first it was used empirically. Clinical studies by
Dr. A. Cott and Dr. B. Rimland had shown that patients treated with this
vitamin responded better to treatment. Later Dr. C C. Pfeiffer and his
colleagues at the Brain Bio Center, Princeton, demonstrated the need for high
doses of this vitamin was caused by the presence of large amounts of
kryptopyrole (kp) in the urine and/or by the presence of easily seen clinical
symptoms and signs. Kryptopyrole was originally discovered in my laboratory
about 30 years ago when we were looking for the schizophrenic biochemical
factor that would lead to better diagnosis and treatment. We called it the
mauve factor because it colored mauve when it was developed on the paper
chromatogram. Kryptopyrole binds with zinc and with pyridoxine producing a
double deficiency. Pyridoxine given in large enough doses will lower the
amount of kp in the urine and w ill at the same time hasten the therapeutic
effect of the regimen. This urine test is easily done in any hospital or private
laboratory. If the test is not available the clinical examination of the patient will
indicate when more vitamin B-6 is needed. One examines the patient for white
chalky areas in the nails, stretch marks on the body, changes in the skin,
increase in symptoms in the premenstrual phase and psychological changes.
For patients suffering from infantile autism the most important vitamin is
vitamin B-6 (Rimland(8)). For people who are well or nearly well and who wish
to ensure they will have enough I recommend 50 to 100 mg daily. For specific
indications I recommend between 100 and 500 mg daily. Larger doses have
been used but they are seldom needed. In children it may be necessary to
also use magnesium to prevent the pyridoxine from activating the child.
There are very few side effects. The ones that do occur are minor and
transient. Much has been made of the few patients collected from several
medical schools who took between 2000 and 6000 mg per day. The paper
describing these results was inadequate because it did not describe whether
they were taking any other nutrients and what type of diet they were on.
These patients developed a peripheral neuropathy which cleared after a year.
But based on this report the idea became current that vitamin B-6 was toxic.
Marks wrote, "It has been claimed that high doses of pyridoxine can lead to
liver damage, interference with the normal functions of riboflavin and a
dependency state. With the possible exception of the dependency states
these suggestions are not substantiated by scientific data. The dependency
states were very transient."
Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C)
Many physicians had been using megadoses of this vitamin for many years,
but little attention was given to it until Dr. Linus Pauling popularized it with his
book, Vitamin C and the Common Cold.(10) Dr. I. Stone had aroused Dr.
Pauling's interest.(11)
Every human suffers from subclinical scurvy, from a deficiency of ascorbic
acid. We can not make any in our bodies, and the amount present in even the
best possible diet will not provide more than 100 mg per day. This amount is
totally inadequate for optimum health. There is therefore no need to ask the
question, "Do I need any vitamin C?" The only question is how much is
needed. There are many clues in nature. Of these the best is the amount of
vitamin C which animals make in their body normally and also under severe
stress; animals are able to convert glucose into vitamin C. They make much
more than we take in from our food. Thus a goat, weighing about as much as
a man, will make 14 grams per day. Apparently all animals that make vitamin
C make about the same amount per kg of body weight.
Since we lost the capability of making vitamin C about 25 million years ago,
our bodies have had to adapt to chronic deficiency after we moved from a
food supply that did provide adequate amounts of vitamin C. But the cost of
this adaptation is very high. We are still paying the price, but we no longer
have to since synthetic ascorbic acid is very cheap and every person could
take ample quantities to replace what nature took away from us. We are not
as sick as if we had scurvy, but this is small consolation since scurvy is a
terminal disease and I do not think we should be content with being so close
to this terminal disease.
The oral dose ranges from 0 to 75 grams each day. Very few can tolerate
those extremely high doses because it exceeds the laxative dose. The
majority of people can take up to 12 grams per day. However it is best to think
in terms of the optimum tolerable dose which each person must determine for
themselves. When more vitamin C is taken than that individual can absorb
from the gastrointestinal tract, it causes increased formation of gas and the
bowel contents become very fluid. If the dose greatly exceeds this level
diarrhea will develop.
The ideal dose has optimum functions in the body without causing any effect
on bowel except to help regulate it. It is a very good laxative. Since at least
one-third of the population over 65 is constipated, it would seem to me to be
wise for all elderly people to control this problem not only by consuming
enough fiber but also by taking enough vitamin C. This is done by starting with
doses of 3 to 6 grams each day and gradually increasing it until the
sublaxative dose is reached. Then the dose is decreased to just below this
level. If the laxative level is 20 grams, the optimum oral level will be around 18
grams.
Dr. R. Cathcart discovered and first reported that the more the body needs the
vitamin, the more it can tolerate. I have observed the same as have almost all
body, the greater the amount which is retained and used by the body. In our
early research we found we could inject chronic schizophrenics with 90 grams
of vitamin C and could find none in the urine. If the dose is I gram, a fraction of
that will be retained. If the dose if 10 grams, many grams will be excreted but
conversely many grams will be retained. To increase the retention the dose
must be increased.
Mineral Supplements
Copper and Zinc
There is an inverse ratio between copper and zinc levels in the blood. It is
thus best to measure both when testing for adequacy. Because of the almost
ubiquitous use of copper plumbing, copper deficiency tends to be quite rare in
most areas, whereas copper excess is more common. I have found that the
blood copper levels increase with age beyond age 40, and that the rate of
increase is dependent upon the degree of memory disturbance. Elderly senile
patients have much more copper relative to an absolute level and relative to
zinc.
Low zinc levels will cause changes in sense of taste, which if extreme can be
life threatening. Patients simply stop eating because the food tastes so awful.
It is also associated with some cases of schizophrenia, and with children with
learning and behavioral disorders. A combination of zinc and vitamin B-6
deficiency may cause changes in the skin, hair and nails including white areas
in the body of the nail, stretch marks, as well as PMS and psychiatric
changes.
I have not found any cases of copper deficiency but advise my patients not to
take multimineral preparations if they contain more than one mg of copper. To
supplement with zinc I use any of the common preparations which usually
provide about 30 to 50 of zinc daily. Sometimes it may have to be given in
solution as the zinc sulfate solution, usually 10%. Pharmacists can easily
make up these solutions.
Linus Pauling's book, How To Live Longer and Feel Better(12) is one of the
best books which describes orthomolecular treatment. For physicians I have
prepared a different type of outline.(13)
Xenobiotic Treatment
By the time I see the schizophrenic patients they have already been placed on
a number of drugs including tranquilizers and antidepressants. Often
combined treatment is essential. I use the drugs to achieve rapid control, and
the orthomolecular component for recovery. When patients are well the drugs
are slowly removed. Some will require very small doses of medication, usually
not enough to make it impossible for them to be well. On tranquilizers alone
no one recovers even though their symptoms are relieved. I have yet to see
one patient on tranquilizers alone who is practicing medicine or law, or piloting
a plane.
Results of Treatment
Early Cases -- The sooner treatment is started the better are the results. With
my colleagues I have published a large number of studies including copious
case histories. We have described the results of four double blind controlled
experiments. These were the first ever done in psychiatry and probably the
first in North America in medicine.(14)
Based upon four double blind controlled therapeutic trials and upon clinical
experience since 1951 on over 5000 schizophrenic patients, I expect that 90%
will be well after one year of treatment. Most of the readers of this journal are
physicians. They will be interested in knowing that physicians can also
become schizophrenic, and when they do and are treated with drugs only,
about 15% become well enough to practice unassisted by their wives who are
nurses. I am personally familiar with and have treated some 17 young patients
who became schizophrenic. They were treated with orthomolecular methods,
recovered, went to college, became physicians and psychiatrists and are well
this day. One became president of a very large psychiatric association without
any of the members, most of them opposed to vitamins, knowing he had been
so treated. One is a research psychiatrist. One is chairman of a large
university clinical department, and the rest are practicing medicine and
Hoffer, A: The Effect of Nicotinic Acid on the Frequency and Duration of ReHospitalization of Schizophrenic Patients; A Controlled Comparison Study. Int
J Neuropsychiatry 2:234-240, 1966.
Hoffer, A: Treatment of Schizophrenia with a Therapeutic Program Based
Upon Nicotinic Acid as the Main Variable. Molecular Basis of Some Aspects of
Mental Activity, Vol II. Ed. O Walaas, Academic Press, New York, 1967.
Hoffer, A: Megavitamin B-3 Therapy for Schizophrenia. Can Psychiatric Assn
J 16:499-504, 1971. Hoffer, A,: Chronic Schizophrenic Patients Treated Ten
Years Or More. J. Orthomolecular Medicine Vol 9, 7-37, 1994.
Townsend Letter for Doctors & Patients.