Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Users repeatedly complain that an installed suite slows down their system. The laboratory found out in its speed test whether
this is really true or only imagined. To do so, 26.6 GB of data were copied onto a reference system, MD5 hash values were
calculated for files and a set of files was downloaded. In total, these tests took 146 seconds on the reference system.
Afterwards, the tests were repeated; naturally with each of the installed security suites. The best performers in this category
were the products from ClamXav, Panda, Bitdefender and Symantec. They slow down the system by about 10 percent. A value
that is not really noticeable in daily use. For Sophos, this value increases to 20 percent, Avira already jumps to 40 percent,
SentinelOne to 80 percent, and for F-Secure, it is already over 120 percent.
The application finishing last in this case is Avast, as it works differently for downloads: it already scans the downloaded file
during the download. This may be secure, but it also takes a lot of time. The other products only scan the file once it has arrived
and is executed.
Useful extras
Some paid programs offer extra features such as an anti-spam function, safe browsing, a firewall, parental control routines or a
backup function. The freeware system watchdogs generally do not offer any additional functions.
None of the commercial products delivers all the above functions in one package. Rather, all the solutions offer one, two or three
extra features. The security packages from Intego, Kaspersky and Symantec throw in the most additional features. Some also
even offer a system cleaning tool or functions for secure payment on the Internet.
Conclusion: There are many secure products, and many put the brakes on the system in daily use
A total of eight of the products examined detected all the malware threats in the test by 100 percent. These even include three
freeware products in the mix. But if you are seeking a solution with the best security performance at the lowest system load, the
field narrows considerably. The ones that remain are Bitdefender Antivirus for Mac and Symantec Norton Security with 100
percent detection with roughly 10 percent additional system load. Both are paid products.
Those looking for a freeware solution can turn to Sophos Anti-Virus. It also detected 100 percent of the threats in the test, but it
slowed down the system by 20 percent. The other freeware products from Avira and Avast do detect everything error-free, but a
system slowdown of 40 or 170 percent is not acceptable.
Our tip: Some versions of security software offered via the App Store differ from the version on the manufacturer's website. The
version offered directly from the manufacturer often includes more additional Features.
Andreas Marx,
CEO AV-TEST GmbH
Detection rates under Mac OS X: Of the 13 tested security suites, eight detected all of the threats 100 percent, and three products failed.
13 Security Suites for Mac OS X: Only four solutions slow down Mac OS X by 10 percent, from Sophos onward, it is already 20 percent, SentinelOne slows the
system down 80 percent more and Avast 170 percent due to immediate scanning of downloads.
Bitdefender Antivirus for Mac: This very compact solution detected all the threats, works quickly, but only offers surfing protection as an extra feature.
Symantec Norton Security: This security solution works quickly, safely and even throws in a Firewall.
Sophos Anti-Virus: The freeware security package for Mac OS X systems does indicate the highest security in the test, yet it slows down the system somewhat.