Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRESENT
Acoustical Measurement
StandardsforStereo
ListeningRooms
NyalMellor,AcousticFrontiersLLC&JeffHedback,HdAcoustics
2011
Thispaperpresentsinroomacousticalmeasurementstandardsaswellasquantifiersofthe
environmentitselfforthepurposeofhighperformance2channelaudioreproduction.Contextand
examplesareofferedinvariousmetricsrangingfromnoise,timerelatedelements,frequencyresponse,
roomsizeandroomconstruction.Thevariousindividualsectionsarecoveredeachwithintheirown
realmandinhowtheyinterrelatetowardtheresultinglisteningexperience.
Introduction
Muchhasbeenwrittenaboutacousticalstandardsforhometheaterandprofessionalstudiocontrol
rooms.Verylittle,however,hasbeencommittedtopaperaboutacousticalstandardsforhighend
stereoortwochannelmusiclisteningrooms.Theverypracticeoflocatingonlytwospeakersanda
singlelisteninglocationinaroomleadstoconsequencesthataretoooftenignoredandcertainlypoorly
understood.InthiscoauthoredwhitepaperNyalMellorofAcousticFrontiersandJeffHedbackof
HdAcousticsaimtoexplainabasicsetofacousticalstandardsthatcanbeusedintheevaluationof
existingroomsorthedesignandpostconstructionverificationofanewroom.
Whilstsomeofthestandardsforhometheaterandstudioscanbeseentohaveapplicabilityfor
residentialstereolisteningroomsmanydonot.Instudios,forexample,thehotseatisalmostalways
nearfieldduetothelocationofspeakersontopofamixingconsole,puttingtheminalocationwhere
theoverallsoundbalanceisdominatedbythedirectenergyfromthespeakers.Thisisaverydifferent
acousticalenvironmentthaninahomewherereflectedsoundsfromtheroomarestrongerthanthe
directsound.Theothertypicalstudioconfigurationisforthespeakerstobeflushorsoffitmounted,
whichsignificantlychangesthewayinwhichthespeakerinteractswiththeroom.Inahometheaterthe
prioritiesaredifferent:whilstmaintainingspectralbalanceisanequalpriorityinbothsituationsdigital
roomcorrectionisoftenusedinatheater.Acousticaldesignthenfocusesonminimizingseattoseat
variabilityinfrequencyresponsethroughcarefulstudyofthenumberandlocationofmultiple
subwoofers.Thispracticeallowssubsequentapplicationofequalization.Moreover,ahometheateralso
hassurroundspeakerswhichmakethegenerationofenvelopmentandthefeelingofbeingimmersedin
athreedimensionalsoundfieldsignificantlyeasiertoachievethaninatwochannelenvironment.Itis
thereforeimperativethatwedonotjustblindlyexpectwellknownstudioandhometheaterdesign
conceptstoportstraightintoatwochannelenvironment.Wemustdevelopourownsetofacoustical
standardsthattakeintoaccounttheuniqueaspectsoftwochannelreproductioninthehome
environment.
Withtherecentavailabilityoffreeorlowcostprosumeracousticalmeasurementsystemssuchas
RoomEQWizard,XTZRoomAnalyzerandPartsExpressOmnimicdedicatedenthusiastscannowtakea
setofmeasurementsthatdescribetheacousticalperformanceoftheirexistingroom.Thesesystems
makeiteasytotakemeasurementsbuttheydonotprovideguidanceonwhatagoodorbad
measurementlookslike.Thislackofguidancefromthesoftware,andthelackofanyformalstandards
fromtheacousticalpractitionercommunitythatarespecifictothechallengesoftwochannel
reproductionmakethiswhitepapersorelyneeded.
Thispaperputsforwardasetoftargetsforwhattheacousticalmeasurementsofahighperformance
twochannelmusiclisteningroomshouldlooklike.Wedescribewhatthekeymeasurementsare,what
anoptimalmeasurementwouldbeandarangeofacceptability.Oncearoomsmeasurementshave
beencomparedwithtargetstheendusercanthendecidewhethertogothepathofeducating
themselvesonacoustics,acoustictreatmentandacousticdesignbyreadingbooksandexperimenting
and/orhiretheservicesofanacousticaldesignertocorrecttheirroomsacousticaldeficiencies.
Page2of30
Summaryofacousticalstandards
Criteria
Measurement
Target
AcceptableRange*
A:NoiseControl
RC
RC20
RC30
B:ReflectedSound
EnergyTimeCurve,040ms
L&Rspeakersvisuallyidentical
~10dBreductioninenergylevel
by40ms
Cleardecreaseinenergyoverthe
40ms
Peakssmoothinpatternand
density
C:LowFrequencyDecay
Times
LowFrequencyResonance**
ReferencechartFigureC.1
ReferencechartFigure
C.1
D:MidrangeDecayTimes
T20,T30,T60
T60between0.2and0.5s
T20,T30deviation<25%across
onethirdoctavebands
E:MidrangeFrequency
Response
MidrangeFrequency
Response
Lspeakerwithin+/3dBat1/3rd
octave
Rspeakerwithin+/3dBat1/3rd
octave
Nodeviationgreaterthan3dB
betweenL/Rspeakers
F:LowFrequency
Response
LowFrequencyResponse**
G.RoomSizeand
Construction
Physicaldimensions
Within+/10dBat1/24thoctave
Within+/5dBat1/3rdoctave
Sizeofroom224sqftto475sqft
Volumeofroom1,750cuftto
4,750cuft
Dimensionslackcommondivisors
(2x)layersof5/8gypsumboard
Surfacesareconstructedusing
similarmethods
*Notallmeasurementshavealowerlevelperformancetargetdefined.
**Allmeasurementsshouldbecarriedoutforeachspeakerseparatelyexceptthelowfrequencymeasurementswhichshould
becarriedoutwithbothspeakersplayingtogether.Itisimportanttoensurethatthemeasurementlevelsareconsistentwhen
comparingleftandrightspeakersotherwiseerroneousconclusionsmaybedrawnfromexaminationofthedata.
Page3of30
A:NoiseControl(indicatedbyRoomCriterionRCrating)
Standard:NoisecriterionbelowRC30forexistingroomsorRC20forpurposebuiltrooms
Highnoiselevelscancauseauditorymaskingoflowleveldetailswithinrecordingsthatreduce
soundstagedepthandtimbralcolorby:
Obscuringthewayinwhichsounddecayswithinarecordingvenue.Eachrecordingvenuehasa
characteristicacousticsignaturethatcanbelostifnoiselevelsaretoohigh.Listeningtoclassical
music,itmightbedifficulttodifferentiateaperformanceintheDisneyHallrelativetothe
CarnegieHall.StandardsforconcerthallsandrecordingstudiosaretypicallyRC1520andone
couldarguethatareproductionenvironmentshouldhaveanequalorlowernoisefloorthanthe
recordingvenueiftheacousticsignatureofthatvenueistobereproducedfaithfully.
Obscuringthelowlevelharmonicsthatgiveeachmusicalinstrumentitscharacteristictimbre.
OnemightfinditdifficulttodifferentiateaBosendorferfromaSteinwaypiano.Thereisadirect
relationshipbetweenthenoisefloorofaspaceandtheabilitytoperceivethehighestlevelsof
audiomicrodetail.
ThenoiseinanexistingspaceshouldnotbeaboveRC30.Thiseliminatesmostdistractionsthat
otherwiseinterfereswiththelisteningexperience.Typicalresidentialspaceswillhavebackgroundnoise
levelsintheRC3545range.AratingaslowasRC25shouldbeachievablewithincommonductedHVAC
systemswithremediationinareasofinternalacousticalliningsandacousticallyratedgrilles/diffusors(as
justtwoexamplesofthetypesofchangesrequired).Itisimportanttofactorotheritemsliketheaudio
equipmentitselforcomfortelementssuchaswinechillersthatmaycontributetothebackgroundnoise
levelofthelisteningenvironment.FornewdedicatedroombuildswesuggestatargetofRC20.Meeting
RC20willrequirepayingattentiontonoiseisolationandusingspecializedconstructiontechniques.
TherearecertainlybenefitstoaratingofRC15andthispaperisinnowaydiscouragingthegreater
potentialofroomdynamicsandultrablacknoisefloor.Itisagreedforthepurposesofthispaperthat
theexponentialincreasestoroomconstructioncostsmakeestablishmentofRC15asastandard
unrealistic.
Page4of30
B:ReflectedSounds
Standards:
ETCoftheL&Rspeakersshould:
Bevisuallyidentical(withonlyminordeviations)from040ms
Bedownto10dBby40mstopreventbreakdownoftheprecedenceeffect
Clearlyshowadecreaseintheamplitudeofenergyover040ms.Thedecaypatternmay
ormaynotbecontinuous.
Showtheconsecutivepeaksofthehighestamplitudereflectionsviewedacrossthetime
axistoberelativelysmoothinpatternanddensity.
Thecriteriaaboveshouldbeconsideredinconjunctionwiththeotherstatedtargetsfor
reverberationtimeandL/Rfrequencyresponse.
BeforewegetstarteditisusefultounderstandwhatanETCisandhowitdiffersfromafrequency
responsechart.Frequencyresponse,asshownbyanFFTofanimpulseresponse,addsupallincident
soundwithintheimpulseresponse(IR)gatestoproducetheamplitudevs.frequencyplot.AnETCisa
timedomainviewintohowthespectrumbuildsup.EachpeakonanETCisapieceofreflectedsound
thatreachesthemicrophone.TheETCissimplylookingatamplitudeovertimebutitgivesnoinsight
intothespectrumofthatenergy.
Thekeyrequirementwithreflectedsoundsistoproperlymatethespeakersintendedresponseata
specificdistanceandaxistotheresponseasmeasuredatthelisteningposition.Typicallythismeans
keepingthespectrumofdirectandreflectedsoundsasconsistentaspossible.
ApopularapproachissimplytoanalyzethelevelofreflectionsonanETCandcomparethesetothe
directsound,settingatargetforthereflectionstobe10dBormorelessthanthedirectsound.This
analysisisnotsufficientsinceETCsarespectrallyblind(i.e.theycontainnoinformationastothe
spectralcontentofthereflectedsound)andtheauditorysystemisverydiscerninginitsrequirements
forspectralbalancebetweenthedirectandreflectedsoundsinaroom.
Thekeypointisthatspectraldistortioninthereflectedsoundsinterfereswithperceptionofboth
localizationandtimbre.Mostlistenersactuallyshowpreferenceforhighlevelsofreflectionsthatare
spectrallysimilartothedirectsound.Theyaddtotimbralrichnessandgivebodyandfullnesstoimages
withinthesoundstage.Twogoodquoteswillhelpclarifywhatishappening.Benade(FromInstrument
toEarinaRoom,JournaloftheAudioEngineeringSociety,1985)states:
"Theauditorysystemcombinestheinformationcontainedasetofreduplicatedsoundsequences(authors
notei.e.thedirectsoundanditsreflections)andhearsthemasiftheywereasingleentity,provided:
Page5of30
a) thatthesesequencesarereasonablysimilarintheirspectralandtemporalpatterns
and
b) thatmostofthemarrivewithinatimeintervalof40msfollowingthearrivalofthefirst
memberoftheset.
Thesinglyperceivedcompositeentityrepresentstheaccumulatedinformationabouttheacoustical
features(tonecolor,articulation,etc)sharedbythesetofsignals.Itisheardasthoughallthelater
arrivalswerepileduponthefirstonewithoutanydelaythatis,theperceivedtimeofarrivaloftheentire
setisthephysicalinstantatwhichtheearliestmemberarrived(authorsnotethisisknownasthe
precedenceeffect).
Theloudnessoftheperceivedsoundisaugmentedabovethatofthefirstarrivalbytheaccumulated
contributionsfromthelaterarrivals.
Theapparentpositionofthesourceofthecompositesoundcoincideswiththepositionofthesourceofthe
firstarrivingmemberoftheset,regardlessofthephysicaldirectionfromwhichthelaterarrivalsmaybe
coming"
AndWrightson(PsychoacousticConsiderationsintheDesignofStudioControlRooms,1986):
Normallyasoundperceivedbytheearsisspectrallyshapedbythepinna,torso,distance,etc.Thisaidsto
thelocalizationofthesoundsignal.Theintroductionofasimilarsignalwithdifferentcharacteristicswill
altertheperceivedlocalization
DeviationsfromthetargetsabovewarrantexaminingoneoctavebandpassfilteredETCsat500Hz,1kHz,
2kHzand4KHz.WhenanalyzingtheseETCsoneshouldbelookingforthefollowingdifferences:
BetweentheL&Rloudspeakersinthesameband(i.e.betweentheL&Rat500Hz)
Betweenadjacentbandsforthesameloudspeaker(i.e.betweenthe500Hzand1kHzfortheL
speaker)
Page6of30
FigureB.1:ThisistheLeft/RightspeakersofExampleRoom1(seepage26)whichmeetsallstandards:similarity,
smoothnessanddecay.
FigureB.2ThisroomexhibitsaraggedappearancetotheETCwhichwarrantsfurtheroneoctavebandstudies.Whilstthis
roomdoesmeetthecriteriafordecayof10dBover40msitdoesnotmeettheT60requirementsmidbandT60sareover
0.7s.Thisisactuallyseeninthegeneralreflectionpatternwhichhasnodecay(viewedbynotfocusingsolelyonpeaks).
Page7of30
FigureB.3:ThisETCmeasurement,whichisfromaleftloudspeaker,showsaraggedprofileworthyoffurtherinvestigation.
FigureB.4:FurtherinvestigationusingoneoctavefilteredETCsat500Hz,1000Hz,2000Hzand4000Hzshowsdistinct
differencesinthespectralcontent.ThesedifferencesaremoreclearlyseenwithsomeETCsmoothingseeFigureB.5
Page8of30
FigureB.5:SmoothedversionsoftheETCinFigureB.4usinga1msmovingaveragefilterandareducedverticalscale.Whilst
500Hzand1000Hztrackeachotherverywell,cleardifferencescanbeseenat2000Hzand4000Hz.Inthisroomthese
differencescanbetracedtothespeakerswhichhavepooroffaxisperformanceandthepresenceofthick,fibrouswallpaper
onallwalls.
Page9of30
C:LowFrequencyDecayTimes
Standards:
ReferenceFigureC.1.Inparticular:
o
Resonancesfrom35Hz300Hzshouldnotextendbeyond350msbeforedecaying
intothenoisefloororreachingalevelof40dB.
Below35Hzthisstandardisrelaxedto450ms.
RoomdimensionsshouldbereferencedtothestandardsinSectionGofthisdocument.
Ifthedimensionsfail,theexpectationofresonancecontrolshouldbelessened.
FigureC.1:showstheideal,minimumandacceptablerangesforLFresonance
Resonancesduetoroommodesareclearlyandmosteasilyseenonachartsuchasacumulative
spectraldecay,spectrogramorwaterfallthatshowtimeononeaxis,frequencyonanotherandplots
soundpressurelevelsasthedata.
Itisimportanttorealizethatwehearthefrequencyresponseandthatbelow250Hztherooms
behaviorismostlyminimumphasemeaningthatinpracticepeaksinthefrequencyresponse
correspondverycloselytoringinginthetimedomain.Howeverlookingataspectrogramclearlyand
Page10of30
quicklyallowsdiscriminationofthemodalresonancesandisthereforeausefulcomplimenttothe1/24th
octavefrequencyresponsemeasurements.
Resonancesshoulddecayintothenoisefloororreach40dBbefore350msotherwiseaudibleissues
mayoccursuchas'onenotebass'and'boominess'.Suchexcessresonanceisactuallyadistortionofthe
recordedwaveformaffectingtheattack,decayandtimbreofbassrangecontent.Intheworstcasesa
particularlyslowdecayingresonancecanmakeasystemalmostunlistenableasmusicalnotesatthe
resonantfrequencyseemtocomealmostomnidirectionallyfromtheroomratherthanfromthe
speakers.Inmildcasesonewillnoticethatsomenotesoninstrumentssuchanacousticdoublebasswill
soundlouderthanothersandwilldecayatadifferentratecomparedtothosearoundthem.This
unevendecaydamagesdynamicarticulation,particularlyonfastpacedmusic,andcanleadtoa
subjectivereductionindynamicimpact.
Below35Hzthetargetis450ms;itismuchmoredifficulttocontrolresonancesatverylowfrequencies
duetotheirverylongwavelengths.Furthermoreatfrequenciesbelow35Hzwearebelowthe
fundamentalfrequenciesofnearlyallmusicalinstruments.Forthesetworeasonsthedecaystandardis
relaxed.
FigureC.2:ExampleRoom1Spectrogram.ComparetoFigureC.1.IRwindowis300mswithafrequencyresolutionof3.3Hz.
Page11of30
FigureC.3:ExampleRoom2Spectrogram(seepage27).IRwindowis300mswithafrequencyresolutionof3.3Hz.
Page12of30
D:MidrangeDecayTimes
Standards:
Timetakenforsoundtodecay60dB(T60)shouldbebetween0.2sand0.5sfrom250Hz
to4kHz
T20andT30shouldbe+/25%acrossthesamefrequencybandusingonethirdoctave
smoothedbands.
SinglefigureT60measurementscannotdomuchmoreinasmallroomthantellyouwhetheraroomis
overlyliveoroverlydead.Moreusefulistolookathowsounddecaysacrossthecriticalmidrange
frequencybandsfrom250Hzto4kHzandtoexaminewhetherthespeedofthisdecayisconsistentover
time.Therearefourdifferentproblemsthatcanexistwithdecaytimestheycanbetoolong,too
short,unevenacrossthefrequencyspectrumorvaryexcessivelyovertime.
Overlylongdecaytimescanobscurelowleveldetailandthetimbreofavoiceorinstrumentinmuchthe
samewayasaroomwithahighnoisefloor.Aroomwithalongdecaytimesalsotendstosoundharsh
andbrittleandcanbeanunpleasantplacetolistenresultinginrapidfatigue.Overlylongdecaytimes
areconsideredthoseover0.5s.
Decaytimesthataretooshortmaynotallowaspacious,envelopingsoundstagetodevelopand
thereforecanbequiteboringplacestolisten.Overlyshortdecaytimesareconsideredthoseunder0.2s.
Musicdoesnotcometolifebutrathersoundsdryandsterile.Ofnoteisthefactthatacoustical
diffusorsactuallyyieldabsorptioneffectsintheprocessofdispersingenergy.Thisisimportantasa
spacewithampleuseofanappropriatetypeofdiffusormayhaveadecaytimeonthelowerrangebut
notfeeldry/sterile(likelyjusttheopposite!).Thisisaprimeexampleofthenuancednatureof
acousticalcontrolwheretheroadyoutaketoaspecificmeasurementresultiseverybitasimportant
astheendmeasurement.
Aroomthatexhibitsunevendecaycharacteristics,wherethesounddecaysmuchfasteratsome
frequenciesthanotherscanatworstsoundnoticeablyunbalancedwithadulltrebleorbloatedbass.
Unevendecayismostoftencausedbyfurnishingswithintheroomsuchasthindrapesandcarpetsthat
absorbsignificantlymoreenergyattreblefrequencies(abovearound1kHz)thantheydoatmidrange
frequencies.ProvidingtheenergyfollowsthecriteriainSectionBofthisdocument,itisactually
preferredtoretainuppermidrangeandhighfrequencyenergy.OurtargethereisforT20andT30tobe
within+/25%acrossthefrequencyspectrum.SignificantchangesindecaytimefromT20throughT60
arealsoagoodindicatorofspectrallyunbalancedreflectedsounds.
Page13of30
FigureD.1:ExampleRoom1isonthelowerendoftherangewhichisappropriateforthesecondaryfunctionofmulti
channelaudio(asopposedtohometheater).
FigureD.2:ExampleRoom2istowardtheupperendoftheacceptedrangeandwithindeviationtargets
Page14of30
FigureD.3:T20showingacceptablerangeofdeviation(+/25%)forExampleRoom3(seepage28).
FigureD.4:T30showingacceptablerangeofdeviation(+/25%)forExampleRoom3.
Afurthercomplexityisthatroomsizeandmusicalpreferencealsoplayintodeterminationofwhatthe
decaytimeshouldbe.
Onthesubjectofmusicalpreferenceswhilstmostofuslistentoawidevarietyofmusicsome
individualsnearlyexclusivelylistentoonetypeofmusic.Inthiscircumstanceitmaybeworth
consideringoptimizingthereproductionenvironmentsothatitbettersuitsthatparticular
Page15of30
musicalstyle.Ofparticularinterestisthetimeittakesforsoundtodecay.Classicalmusic
aficionadosmaybebestservedwithroomthatismorelive,withahigherT60of0.4to0.5s.
Thosewholistentonearlyexclusivelytoclosemikedmultitrackrecordingsshouldaimfora
lowertargetwithaT60approaching0.2to0.3s.
Onthetopicofroomvolumegenerallyspeakingthelargerthecubicvolumeofthespace,the
longerthedecaytimemaybe.
Page16of30
E:ConsistencyofMidrangeFrequencyResponsebetweenLeftandRight
speakers
Standard:
Inroomonethirdoctavesmoothedfrequencyresponsemeasurementatlistening
positionforeachspeakershouldbewithin+/3dBfrom250Hzto4kHz.
Eachspeakershouldexhibitadeviationofnogreaterthan3dBfromtheother
Nearlyallthefundamentalnotesproducedbymusicalinstruments,includingthehumanvoice,occur
withinarangeboundedatthetopendby4kHz.Atthelowend,fundamentalsoccurdownto35Hzor
evenslightlybelow.Onecouldarguethatahighendroomshouldthereforebeflatbetween35Hzand
4kHztomaintaintimbralaccuracyandspectrallybalancedsoundreproductionacrossthecritical
midrange.Inpractice,however,thisisverydifficulttoachieveduetothedominanceofmodal
resonancesandboundaryeffectsbelow250Hzwhichcausepeaksanddipsinthefrequencyresponse.A
sensibletargetmightthereforebestatedas+/3dBwithintherange250Hzto4kHzwhenthefrequency
responseisexaminedwithaonethirdoctavesmoothing.Inahighendroomonemighttryandgetthe
frequencyatwhichtheresponsebreaksthe+/3dBbarrieraslowaspossiblesuchas200Hzoreven
150Hz.
1/3rdoctavesmoothingisaverytraditionalwaytosmoothafrequencyresponsechartinorderto
createsomethingthatisclosertowhatwehear.Theearsresolutionisactuallyhigherthan1/3rdoctave
thoughrecentstudiesshowthattheearloudnesssummingresemblessomethingclosertoa1/4thor
1/6thfilterandeventheninbandfrequencyanomaliesaffectingtimbralresolutioncanbediscriminated.
1/3rdoctaveisneverthelessusefulforidentifyinggeneralspectraltrends.
FrequencyresponsemeasurementsshouldbeconductedforLeftandRightspeakersindividuallyandthe
responsescompared.
Sometimesdifferencesinplacementrelativetoroomboundaries,alackofleft/rightsymmetryinthe
room,poorpairmatchingoracousticallydissimilarsurroundingscanleadtoonespeakerhavinga
differentresponsetoitspartner.Thismustbeavoidedsincethisoftencausesthesoundstagetobe
pulledtowardsonespeakerconsistentlyoratcertainfrequencybands.Thefirsteffectcanbehandily
counteredbyusingabalancecontrol,assumingthatonesequipmentstillhasthisfunctionality.The
lattereffectmustbeavoidedatallcostssinceitcausesimagestowaverdependingon,forexample,
whichnoteisbeingplayedorsung.Thetargethereisforeachspeakertoexhibitadeviationofno
greaterthan3dBfromtheother.3dBisaperceivedloudnessdifferenceofaround20%.
Attentionpaidtospeakerquality,listeningroomsymmetryandappropriatetreatmentofreflection
pointsistypicallyenoughtomeettargetswithoutanyfurtheralterationstotheroomdesign.Notethat
verygoodresultscanbeachievedinslightlyasymmetricroomsaslongastheaboveconditionis
respecteditisnotnecessaryforthespeakerstobeplacedexactlythesamedistancefromtheleftand
rightsidewalls.Infactthisapproachcanoftenleadtoproblemssincethepathlengthdifferencesfrom
Page17of30
eachspeakertonearbyboundariesarethesame,causingspeakerboundaryinterferencerelatednullsto
coincide.
FigureE.1Exampleoffrequencyresponseforleftandrightspeakerthatisoutsidetolerance;inthiscasemoderateimaging
waveringwasobservedaswellasanoverallshiftinthecentralimagetowardstheleftspeaker
FigureE.2Exampleoffrequencyresponseforleftandrightspeakerthatiswithintolerance.
Page18of30
F:LowRangeFrequencyResponse
Standard:Inroomlowfrequency(LF)responsemeasurementatlisteningpositionshouldbe:
Within+/10dBat1/24thoctaveresolutionfrom20Hzto250Hzforbothspeakers
measuredtogether.
Within+/5dBat1/3rdoctaveresolutionfrom20Hzto250Hzforbothspeakers
measuredtogether.
Twomeasuresarerequiredtoproperlyvalidatethequalityofaroomslowfrequencyresponse.1/3rd
octavestudiesprovideaviewintooverallspectraltrendsequatingcloselytohowthehumanear
perceivesloudnesswhilst1/24thoctaveallowsdiscriminationofindividualresonancesthatcausetimbral
distortion.
Thelowfrequency(LF)responseofastereopairofspeakersinaroomisfirstdictatedbythespeaker
andlistenerpositionsandthenbytheacousticalcontrolthatexistswithin.Boundaryinterference
patternsarecreatedwithin~65mswhentheLFenergyofthespeakersmakescontactwiththeroom
surfacesandrecombineswiththedirectenergy.After65mstheroommodeswillimpartdistortionsif
notproperlydamped(referenceSectionD).
ToobtainthebestpossibleLFresponse:
Thespeakerandlistenerinitiallocationsshouldbecarefullyselectedbasedonproperstudyof
roomdimensionsandpracticality.Theleftandrightspeakersshouldcreateaspreadof45to60
degreesfromthecenterpointofthelisteningposition.
Afterasubjectivereviewoftheinitialresponse,acousticalmeasurementsshouldbetakento
beginthefinetuningofbothspeakerandlistenerlocations.Thesechangeswouldtypically
involvemovementsgreaterthan6.
Theremainingboundaryinterferenceissuescanbetoughertoaddress.Varyingthefixed
distancesfromspeakertoboundaryandlistenertoboundarywillreducestrong
cancellations.ItisabalancingactasonelocationthatmayofferasmootherLFresponsemay
notprovidetheoptimalmidrangeandtrebleresponse.Note:asspeakerdistancesfromthe
frontwallmayoftenbe46,aspeakerboundaryinterferencerelatednullislikelytoappear
between70Hzto45Hzrespectively.Therewouldalsobesimilartypenullbasedonthe
relationshipofthelisteningpositiontotherearwall.
Thefrequencyresponseshouldalwaysbecorrelatedtoaresonancestudyasbotharecrucialto
balanceandnaturalperceptionofLFtransients.
Moreevolvedlevelsofanalysiswouldfactorsinglespeakerdataaswellasthephaseaspectsof
theinroomresponse(excessgroupdelay).
Atthispoint,itisappropriatetolookcloselyatuseofparametricEQordigitalroomcorrection
optionstoflattentheLFresponse.OnthistopicfromDr.FloydToole,Itrytobecarefultosay
atlowfrequencies(subwooferregionbelow80Hz)smallroomsbehaveasminimumphase
systems(asitappliestoequalizingresonances).WhenpushedIgoontosaythatthisismostly
Page19of30
trueforresonantpeaksthatstandabovetheaveragespectrumlevel,butasthatlevelrecedes
belowtheaveragespectrumlevel,weclearlyhavea"signaltonoise"(minimumphasetonon
minimumphase)problem,becausethereareobviouslynonminimumphaseactivitiesinthe
regioninterferencedipsbeinganexample.Thisisrelevantbecausethebestevidenceofan
audibleresonanceisahighlyvisiblepeak,which,ifattenuatedtotheaveragespectrumlevel(i.e.
flat)resultsinasevereattenuationofringingwhichisthedesiredsituation.
Inthelargersense,everyonedesiresaflatLFresponseandnomodalringing.Simply,thisisatough
achievement.Theabsurdlylargecollectionofinterrelatedvariablesbetweentwofullrangespeakers
andtheroom(speakerdesign,speaker/listenerlocation,roomsize/constructionandacousticalcontrol
within)makesthisso.Itisuptotheindividualtodeterminewhattheirlimitsareasregardsplacement
andacoustictreatment.
FigureF.1:ExampleonetwentyfourthoctaveLFresponse.
FigureF.2:ExamplethirdoctavesmoothedLFresponse.
Page20of30
FigureF.3:ExampleRoom4(seepage29).ThenexttwoimagescompareanUNSMOOTHEDand3rdOctaveSMOOTHEDview
ofthesamedata.TheUNSMOOTHEDactuallyfallswithinstandardsat1/24thresolution.Theinterestofshowingthe
UNSMOOTHEDgraphexistsinstudyingthemanynarrowvalleyswhilethepeaksfollowaflattrend(withaslightuptilt
below50Hzthatcanbepleasing).Thesevalleysareduetoheavilyslopedceilinganglesandotherasymmetricalfactorsof
theroom.
FigureF.4showsthe3rdOctaveSMOOTHEDLFResponseofSampleRoom4.Itis+/3.5dB(wellwithinstandards).The
pointofinterestishowtogainvaluefromvariouslevelsofresolution.ThenarrownullsoftheUNSMOOTHEDresponseare
heardasflatinthissituation.
Page21of30
G:RoomSizeandConstruction
Squarefootageshouldbeintherangeof224to475sq.ft.
Roomvolume1,750to4,750sq.ft.
Theroomdimensionsshouldmathematicallyhavenocommondivisors
andnopairofdimensionsshouldsharemorethanonecommondivisor
Theuseof(2x)layersof5/8gypsumboardisadvisedforwallsand
ceiling
Irregularshaperooms,roomswithvariedconstructionmethodson
differentsurfacesandroomswithadjoiningsecondaryspacesshouldall
becarefullyconsideredforthetaskofhighperformancelistening.
BoththeSquarefootageandRoomVolumeareexcellentqualifiersofaperformancedrivendedicated
listeningenvironment.Thedesiredrangeofsquarefootageshouldbebetween225and475sqft.The
roomvolumeshouldfollowsuitwithadesiredcubicvolumeof2,250to4,750cuft.Sothen,what
shouldtheexactroomdimensionsbe?...well,itdepends(sorry,noeasyanswersexist).However,
havingatleastonedimensionbetween20and25allowstheroomslowestmodetobelowerthan
30Hz.Theceilingheightshouldbe9.5to11asthisplacesthelistenersearscomfortablybelowthe
floortoceilingmodalnull.Regardinginternalroomvolume,thetargetedrangeyieldsgreatermodal
densityextendingdowntoward50Hz.Followingtheseguideswilloffertangiblysmootherandmore
evenbassresponseandamorepureconnectiontothespeakerstrueoverallsound.
Theratioofroomdimensions(width,heightandlength)isafoundationalaspectofyourlistening
experience.Inthisregard,yourroomshouldbethoughtofasaninstrument.Properrelationships
betweentheroomdimensionswillyieldthesmoothest,mostconsistentbassresponse,period.Sorryto
reportthough,therearenofactorysetidealroomratios.Therearegoodstartingpointssuchasthe
LoudenRatioof1,1:4,1:9.Ifgivenablankpage,theroomdimensionsshouldmathematicallyhaveno
commondivisorsandnopairofdimensionsshouldsharemorethanonecommondivisor.Thegoalisto
yieldanevendensityanddistributionofroommodes.
Howthewalls,floorandceilingareconstructedisasignificantpartofthesonicsignatureofalistening
room.Massiveconcretesurfacesretainnearlyallbassenergywhilelightweightresidentialpartitions
allownearlysimilaramountstopassthroughtoadjoiningspaces.Optimalsoundqualityinthisrealmis
alotlikeGoldilocksnottoohotortoocoldbutjustright.Sonically(notfactoringisolationneeds),just
rightisadoublecourse(2x)of5/8gypsumboard.Thisyieldsenoughmassforthelowfrequency
energytobepunchyandfocusedwhendesiredbutnotsomuchthattheresonancesareoverwhelming.
Furtherbenefitscanbehadfromuseofcertainisolationhangersanddampenersastheydiminish
afterringelementsthatbuildingmaterialscanexhibitwhenfullyexcitedbysoundvibrations.
Page22of30
Conclusion
Thepurposeofthispaperistoofferclearstandardsinareasthataffecttheaudiophiletwochannel
listeningexperience.Itisimportanttorealizethatnosinglemeasurementcantellyouwhataroomwill
soundlike.Whenconsideredincombination,however,thesestandardsprovidepowerfulinsightsinto
yourroomsperformance.Itisourbeliefthatasaresultofthisarticleyouwillbemuchbetterplacedto
determineandprioritizetheacousticalareasthatneedimprovement.Further,itisclearlyshownthat
theprocessoflocatingtwospeakersandasinglelisteningpositioninaroomiscomplexandnospeaker
inandofitselfshouldbeexpectedtocompensateforallpossiblevariablesinagivenspace.
Itisnotrealistic,norisitcrucial,thatyourroommeetsallofthesetargets.Butidentifyingwhichareas
ofreproductionareimportanttoyouandoptimizingyourroomtomeetthesegoalsisanimportantstep
towardsimprovingyourlisteningpleasure.Whetheryouchoosetocompletethisjourneyyourself,or
seektheexpertcounseloftheauthorsNyalMellorofAcousticFrontiersorJeffHedbackofHdAcoustics,
youcanbesurethatthetimeandmoneyspentonoptimizingtheacousticsofyourlisteningspaceisone
ofthebestbangforthebuckinvestmentsyoucanmakeinthishobby.
Page23of30
Acousticaldesignconsiderationsfordifferentspeakertypes
Conventional(typicalforwardradiatingboxtypespeakers)
Thistypeofspeakerischaracterizedbyanonaxisandoffaxisresponsethatvariessignificantlyasthe
angleoffaxisincreases.Thisvarianceinoffaxisenergyrequiresmoreaggressiveandmuscular
acousticalcontrolatlateralandverticalfirstreflectionpoints.Absorptionofthelowermidand
midrangefrequencies(100Hz2KHz)istypicallyamusttoexperienceadynamicandcleanresponse.In
thiscase:tighterdecaytimes,lowerlevelsofreflectedenergyandmorecarefulspeakerlocationin
termsofmodalpeaks/nullsarekeystepstowardsonicexcellence.Frequenciesbelow~300Hz
propagateomnidirectionallyinthesespeakers.
ConstantDirectivity
CDtypespeakersorConstantDirectivity(alsocalledtermedcontrolleddispersion)arecharacterizedby
anoffaxisresponsethatvariesminimallyfromtheonaxisresponse.Itisnotuncommonfortheoffaxis
responseuptoaswideas40degreesinthehorizontalplanetohaveessentiallythesamefrequency
response.Itisalsotypicalthattheverticaldispersionismoretightlycontrolled.Inspeakerdesign
terms,thisisachievedbytheuseofahornorwaveguideelementinconjunctionwiththehigh
frequencyand/ormidrangedriver.Likeconventionalspeakers,frequenciesbelow~300Hzpropagate
omnidirectionally.
Dipoles
Dipolesareaquitepopulartypeofspeakerbothintraditionalelectrostatic/ribbon/planarmagnetic
configurationsandnewschoolconeopenbaffles.Dipoleshaveacoupleofcharacteristicsthatare
worthbearinginmindwithrespecttotheacousticaltargetsdefinedaboveandtheapplicationofproper
acousticdesigntorealizehighendreproduction.
1. Dipolesradiateequallyforwardsandbackwards.
2. Dipoleshavecancellationnodesperpendiculartothebaffleaxis.Duetothistheydonotexcite
roommodesalongthisaxisandhavereducedinteractionwiththesidewalls.
3. DipoleshavealowerreverberantfieldforagivenSPLatthelisteningposition(3.8dBless)
relativetoamonopoleduetotheirincreaseddirectivity.Thedistancetowhichthedirectsound
dominatesspectralbalanceisfurtherasaconsequenceofthis;thisalsomeansthatsinglefigure
T60scanbehigherfordipolesrelativetoconventionalspeakers.
4. Dipolesarevelocityratherthanpressuresources.Thismeanstheycoupletoroommodes
differently.Apressurepeakisavelocitylowandviceversa.
5. Dipolescannotpressurizearoombelowthefrequencyofthelowestmodalresonance.Thisisa
consequenceoftheirvelocitysourcenature.Insmallroomsthelowestmodalpeakcanbeinthe
30Hzrangewhichmakesasubwooferaconsideration.InadditionDipoleshavea6dBper
octavecancellationbelowthesocalleddipolepeak.Thismeansthatverylargebafflesizesand
displacementsarerequiredtoreproducelowfrequenciesathighSPLs.
Page24of30
Explainingthedivisionofthefrequencydomains
Thebehaviorofasmallroominthefrequencydomainistypicallybrokendownintoatleasttwoparts
abovethesocalledtransitionfrequencyandbelowit.Belowthetransitionfrequencytheresponseis
dominatedbytheeffectofroommodes.Above250Hztheresponseisdominatedbythespectrumof
theearlyreflections.Thisisoneofthekeyreasonswhyitisimportanttoensurethespectralbalanceof
reflectedsoundsaresimilartothedirectsound.Moresophisticatedanalysescanincludeatransition
zone,saybetween150Hzand350Hz,wheretheresponseisneithermodallydominatednorearly
reflectiondominatedbutisacombinationofthetwo.Sometimestheregionbelowaround80Hzisalso
splitoutintoanareacalledthesparselypopulatedmodalregionasthisiswhereroommodesare
spreadfurtherapart.Theactualfrequenciesdependonbothroomsizeandtheamountofabsorption
withintheroom.
Frequencies
below250HZ
Frequencies
above250HZ
Page25of30
ExampleRooms
Thissectioncontainsphotographsandshortdescriptionsofsomeoftheroomsfromwhichsomeofthe
acousticalmeasurementsinthispaperwerecaptured.
Room1
ThisisthededicatedaudiophilesurroundroomofTedBrady(moderatorofHiRezCircleatAudio
Circle).HdAcousticscompletedanacousticalrenovationofthisshowcaseroomin2010.TheSP
Tech/AetherAudioGrandRevelationsarematchedwithHdAcousticscustomdevices,RealTrapspanels
(20+)andGIKAcousticspanels.
Page26of30
Room2
KevinJoneslisteningspaceexemplifiestheresidentialsituationwithakitchenoffthetotheleftand
otheropenplanconnections.HdAcousticsperformedremoteacousticalanalysistocomplimenthis
existingGIKAcousticsmaterialswiththosefromReadyAcoustics.HisPurityAudioDesign/WilsonSasha
combinationisdescribedbyallintermsofgreatdynamicsandbeingveryrevealing.Thespeakerswere
setbyCraigHampel.
Page27of30
Room3
ThisroomatahighenddealerinSanFranciscowaspreviouslytreatedbyhangingthindrapesacross
50%ofthewallscreatinganunevenT20andT30asfrequenciesabove1kHzwereselectivelyabsorbed.
AcousticFrontiersrecommendedreplacingthedrapeswithstrategicallypositionedcombination
absorber/diffusorpanelsallowingT20andT30targetstobemetandthespectralbalanceofdirectand
reflectedsoundsmaintained.
Page28of30
Room4
JoeDaltonsroomoverthegaragefeaturestreatmentsdesignedbyHdAcoustics:customsidewall
sawtoothabsorbers,frontwallpolycylindricaldiffusorsandotherelementsworktoyieldbalanceinthis
architecturallytoughspace.ThesoundoftheWilsonSashasistrulyremarkableinthisspace.The
speakerswereexpertlysetbyCraigHampel.
Page29of30
AuthorBiographies
NyalMellor
NyalisthefounderofAcousticFrontiersLLC,acompanyspecializinginacoustic
design,acoustictreatment,roomcorrectionandsystemcalibrationforhighend
audioandhometheater.AcousticFrontiersisbasedinKentfield,MarinCounty
inNorthernCalifornia.NyalwasborninEnglandandholdsaBachelorsdegree
fromOxfordUniversity.Inhissparetimeheenjoyssnowboardingandmountain
biking.
JeffHedback
IsthefounderofHdAcoustics(formerlyHedbackDesignedAcoustics)afull
serviceacousticaldesignandconsultancyfirmspecializinginuniqueneedsof
smallroomacoustics.JeffholdsaBachelorofMusicDegreefromtheesteemed
BerkleeCollegeofMusicandbeganhisprofessionalcareerasaprobassplayer
withrecordingcreditsonmajorrecordinglabels,national/regionaltours,and
countlesssmellybargigs.HdAcousticsclientsincludeOzzyOsbourne,
LifehouseandTrevorHorn.
Acknowledgements
NyalMellorandJeffHedbackwouldliketosincerelythankDr.FloydToole,DukeLeJeune,DanFitzgerald
andBillWeirfortheirassistanceduringthecraftingofthispaper.
ContactDetails
ContactName
JeffHedback
NyalMellor
CompanyName
HedbackDesignedAcoustics
AcousticFrontiersLLC
Address
328S.AlfonteSt
1HillsideAve
Ingalls,IN46048
Kentfield,CA94904
Phone
(317)8630753
(415)2544204
Fax
(317)8630753
projects@hedbackdesignedacoustics.com
nyal@acousticfrontiers.com
Web
www.HdAcoustics.net
www.acousticfrontiers.com
Page30of30