Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Methodology
Qualitative method of research will suffice - this will relate to using
deductive approach - seeking to use existing theory to shape the
approach which i will adopt to the qualitative research process and to
aspects of data analysis. This method is very appropriate because i will
use observation and interviews as a means of collecting data and
explanation or description of events or data defines qualitative method of
research.
Theresearch undertaken is generic and for that reason the aim is to
information in production sector of the economy and service sector. It will
be appropriate to deal with production employees and service employees
as to enable myself to answer the research objectives of research with
validand accurate information pertaining to the problem faced.
Employees at an operational level, middle and top level management will
be my target group. The operational employees will assist in trying to
complete my problem towards the research topic with their real problems
that exists in their organisation. Also, information regarding my research
topic will be sourced from trade union members. This will play an
important role in my research. They are well-informed people in terms of
organisations that understand the labour laws, they know grievances of
most of the employees n the country. They will possibly give me
information for my research because my research doesnot cause any
threat to them but contributes to their planning, organising, leading and
control activities for their members.
Most of my research will be based on overall observation. This topic
generally produces a sense of suspicion and threat to managers therefore
employees/workers may feel unsafe to be giving out information against
their organisations. Revealing my research topic to most of managers will
hinder my research. However, employees will be asked to answer
questions through questionnaires that i will distribute during lunch time.
High profile personnel will be interviewed telephonically for my previous
colleagues to get information that may be difficult to access. The research
will focus on identifying the possible factors that contribute to the
problem. Clear, informative discussion will suffice. The biggest problem
that i noticed faced by researchers is ethics and issues of access. In this
regard, three interviews will take place with top managers, the access
issue will be relying on written letters of request and try to explain my
position as a student in management studies.
The best instrument to be used in interviews will be tapes, this will lessen
time spent asking question when not understood. Data collected from
operational employees will be mostly in the form of questionnaires. These
will be checked and try to get answers that are accurate and valid. Also, i
will expect questionnaires to be given to both men and women, young and
adults, professional and unprofessional, experienced and unexperienced.
This method will give me a clear picture of what problem is experienced
by different group and size of the population studied.
Findings/Results
As a point of departure, the factors that have been found to be the cause
of employees not willing to have a lifetime with certain employers have
been highlighted The following problems do occur - employers show that
they are dissatisfied with the work, low productivity, poor attitude towards
the enterprise, low morale, increased labour turnover, increased conflicts
and tension. Detailed findings explain how personal factors also refered to
growth factor contribute to problems as aforementioned.
Development - employees of lower level show great concerns towards
realising their goals. Some organisations do not have plans or facilities for
employee development, many employees at lower levels are very much
worried about their future, with modern life placing technology as an
important aspect. Employees who are aged 40 and above seen to be
affected my technology and they show worries, this technology
advancement show demand and pressure to such group of men and
women. These employees fail to meet changed job expectations/
requirements, they indicated to be superfluous and redundant.
Organisations that were observed seem to be employing youth for better
paying jobs - especially those that need specific skills at the expense of
old employees who are already in the industry. Human resources
management in certain organisation do not have assessment for the
opportunities for training and development. Those that does, they fail to
offer training applicable to the execution of the tasks. There is no
preparation of employees for higher position, there is totally no career
preparation. Development was identified as a self-actualisation, which
operates as an inner need or the upper needs. The age group of
employees aged between 40-60 indicated that they entered organisations
with great expectations and dreams. They gave everything to these
organisations but they have not reached anywhere, they didnt show hope
because they are old and being replaced. Employees of this category
showed boredom,they felt like they will never reach their destiny, they are
not proud of either themselves or the organisation.
4
Climate-Managers dont have time to create climate in which selfactualisation is possible; Instead they are busy developing themselves and
looking for power achievement. Also identified was certain organisation
that have plans structures for development but they do not implement it,
they do not have the strategies to implement development it is just
paperwork display and just shown to avoid labour issues or union
criticism during inspection.
Autonomy - workers at lower level are heavily supervised they are hardly
left alone to execute their tasks, but employees who are highly
educatedand experienced are often left to do the task, these enjoy the
execution, because they experience freedom and discretion to plan &
schedule. Employees who are non autonomous think that they are not
trusted by their supervisors in terms of task execution.
Organisations are failing willing employees, they do not design proper
methods of doing jobespecialy for poorly trained employees. This
mismatch does exist in a number of organisations, workers are not used
according to their potential, such as intelligent skills, qualification,
experience and training. Employees at middle level who are managers
were noticed to be over utilised. Many do not cope with what is done, they
are very busy, yet in other organisations were there is weak management
system, workers were found doing personal work during work hours.
These are identified by poor administration.
Achievement - employees did not show any understanding of the goals of
the enterprise. This behaviour is not in accordance with goals of the
organisations. There is no linkage in jobs goals and goals of the
organisation. The few organisations observed did not implement any form
of communicating their goals to their employees. Employees did not even
know what is expected from them. They did not know, or understand the
standards they are supposed to maintain. They did not know
accountability especially the poorly educated ones. Very few employees
manage or attempt to achieve their goals because guidelines within
certain tasks are not spelt out. This is the reason why employees did not
assess their activities within the functioning of organisations.
Questionnaires that were distributed to operational employees indicated
that the most inexperienced employees do not know what they do, how
they do job activities. The question why they do such activities was poorly
answered . It is true that job guidelines are not clearly spelt out to most
employees. The most common problem found was failure to implement
induction process to new employees. Top managers are the most
employees that showed to have a need for achievement which is not in
line with pre research studies that has shown high need for power for top
managers. This category shows that some still need achievement and
power too.
Those employees who indicated to have a high need for achievement are
often the top performers in one the organisations were interview was
undertaken. These frequently demonstrated the following characteristics:
they set challenging yet attainable goals
6
Supervisors' Leadership
Work Security
Salary
Status
Working Conditions :Safety - the most accident-prone employees
identified was the male and female under the age of 30. These showed a
lack psychomotoric and perceptual skills, they are impulsive and show
boredom. The few incidents that took place in a very big construction
company recording two deaths of men during work indicate that
machinery and equipment are badly serviced, the use of defective
equipment and inadequate mechanical protection. Organisations that
have safety programs do not have support and cooperation of manpower
management, the implementation of safety programs lack s proper
personnel and expertise.
Organisations are scared to appoint a safety representative, they fear that
his/her duties will hinder the organisational operation and fear that
workers will become very knowledgeable about their safety regulation.
Certain employees indicated that most of the incidents are kept under the
carpet.
Health - organisation observed indicated that they are heavily concerned
with production and profits & disregard the health position of their
workers. The management does nothing to promote occupational health.
It is very common that programmes are on paper documents but these
programmes are never implemented.
There are no medical facilities on the premises.
There are no nurses or medical personnel to monitor employees' health
regulary.
There are several employees of all age groups, male and female who are
victims of alcoholism, drug addiction and mental disturbances.
Employees at top level of management indicated work stress, they explain
that they have pressure to meet deadlines, the quality of work expected,
the number of clients per employee and clients nature. The most
government employees who face this dilemma are members of the police
force. Investors seem to bear most of this problem. They said they are
always having many clients to attend to and this results into change of
their behaviour and thus end up in drug & alcohol abuse.
10
The following emotional disorders were also noticed among managers anxiety, depression and anger. Burnout was found to be centered to
peolple/ workers who are goal-orientated. Problems appear when they
discover that the objectives they are pursuing are unattainable, such
people were found to be intense in everything they do, they set high
standards for themselves and usualy concentrate all their activities on
achieving certain objectives to the exclusion of all else, which often means
that they lead unbalanced lives.
Most employees at low level can cope with stress at work butthere are
some who suffer from these emotional disorders occasionally. A small
minority of these, however, approximately 3% need psychiatric treatment
because of the extent of their disturbances.
Organisational Policy & Administration
The following policies were fully studied and observed :
Compensation Policy - The objective of a compensation package is to
influence employee motivation in a positive manner so as to lead to
improved organisational performance and strategy. Organisations have
good compensation systems only on paper. There is no clear link between
compensation and performance. There is a great failure in achieving
employee pay satisfaction:
External equity - found is that employees employed in the same industry
but different organisation have different pay levels.
Internal equity - companies may make profit, reach high production level
but the pay does not relate to employer's high production level - there is
no fairness in the pay system.
Individual equity - employees were found to be doing / working the same
job and with the same performance but some are paid better than others.
Procedural equity - workers who are well skilled, highly educated have
their grievances attended quickly, have their pay queiriessorted faster as
compared to experienced but not well educated.
Some organisations show good salary packages that tempt people to
apply for the job.
Some organisations do not have systems that are able to retain good
workers.
Workers seem to be seeking employers who have good package systems
especially the well skilled and professional majority.
11
13
14
15
and lack the generic knowledge. They can not provide supportive
information to their subordinates in fear that they may be challenged by
young and academic employees who lack experience but have shown
potential in almost everything they do at work.
Most supervisor who were promoted because they have many years with
the organisation give threat to new employees and even use coercive
power over others, they target fast learners at work, who show greater
expectations, who are goal oriented, these fall to be victims of such
monstrous and evil supervisor to be.
Leadership - certain leaders do not have the agility to create a vision and
find it hard to excite people to achieve the impossible, most leaders were
described by employees as selfish and do not share knowledge with
employees. Several leaders tend to resign during hard times and were
identified as leaders who do not have inner strength.
Leaders observed seem to be lacking involvement in the exercise of
influence and not coercion. Managers in one of the organisation observed
are not effective because their leadership skills are not developed and
utilised. Most leaders lack integrity, corruption was noticed to be common,
because of such, they lack competitive advantage.
Most managers used outdated beliefs - they give detailed instructions,
supervise employees closely, use threats of punishment to control
behaviour. Employees treated this way tend to do just what is requiredof
them to stay out oftrouble. These employees start to abuse sick leave and
stay uncommited to the organisation or ts goal. Managers just focus on
task completion and results and fail to aim at quality production of goods
and services.
African Leadership Academy has a leader, during interviews with
educators and administration personnel they showed to be happy with
hm. He provides employees with opportunities, positive guidance and
recognition. They say that working with him makes them feel respected,
acknowledged and proud. The subsequent performance of these
employees reconfirms the original belief of the leader.
Leaders who are aged 50-65 seem to be laissez-faire leaders, they have
absolute minimum in both the job and interpersonal relationships. These
leaders were identified as lacking and avoids commitment to decision.
They also have shown little concern for production and little concern for
people.
According to observation regarding leaders - poor leadership skills, traits
contribute to leaders failure to organise and spell out the task of group
17
members by indicating who should do what, when, where and how. They
even fail to understand task behaviour. Such leaders could not institute
well-defined organisational patterns, channels of communication and
procedures for the execution of tasks.
Organisation do not have programmes that provide support for open
channels of communication, socio-emotional support, psychological
stroking and facilitating of subordinates'behaviour. Organisations are not
willing to train leaders and these leaders find it hard to switch from being
an ordinary employee to being a team leader. Certain Organisation fail to
be competitive because they do not allow leaders who are
transformational or visionary to institutea meaningful change even though
they show to be credible and capable.
Work security - employees prefer working for organisations that have the
following benefits : health and life insurance, medical aid schemes and
pension funds.
Health and life insurance - most organisations do not offer such benefit
only a few large companies with a competitive edge seem to be offering
health and life insurance. Employees do not like to subsidised the
premium rates that employees may pay. Many employees are not covered
from episodes such as trauma experienced as a result of a life threatening
disease, disability of the employee and death of a spouse.
Medical Schemes - employees who were interviewed in two organisations
were all not having medical aid scheme cover. They have joined private
insurance companies to enable them to provide coverage for both
themselves and their dependants.
Pension Fund - many organisations have been operating for many years
yet no impression upon their employee the importance of managing their
investment in retirement. Employees interviewed have been moving from
one company to another looking for better offers and they have fears that
their provision for retirement will be totally inadequate. Most organisations
do not provide a pension or a provident fund to which employees
contribute a percentage of their wages, a portion which is subsidised by
the employer.
Status - employees who work in a group with same qualification and
experience are not given the same status by organisation, that makes
other employees to have a negative attitude towards other employees.
Whenever these groups meet to brainstorm ideas, those with lower status
hesitate to share ideas, and ultimately, criticise the ideas of others. Most
18
professionals are the employees who are involved in the need to have jobs
that give them status.
Some organisations do employ people with highest qualifications in the
market but do not pay according, this makes those that have no proper
qualifications but being paid almost equivalent with the qualified, to
regard themselves as better, this in turn is affecting the behaviour of most
professionals and end up leaving organisation to join other organisations
that have properly designed pay system that recognises people who are
academic excellent and having skills and experience.
Discussion & Conclusion
Modern work life is characterised by technological and other changes,
placing increasing demands and pressure on employees. When employees
are unable to meet changed job expectations or requirements, they
become superflous and redundant. In this respect, development refers to
development possibilities within job or position for a specific employee
with reference to the employees' personal growth and personal goals.
Development in careers is a formal approach to ensure that employees
with proper qualifications and experience are available when needed. To
realise this organisations need to support career development and be
committed to it. It must make policy decisions to make resources available
for promotion of development plans of employees. The human resources
department should take charge and coordinate all career development
programmes. This human resources department should provide
information tools and guidance so that employees can implement their
development activities. The immediate superior of the employee is of
cardinal importance in providing support, advice and feedback, but the
employee himself is ultimately responsible for his own.
Career Development - employees proceed from one job to another in a
certain sequence. Each day the employee is given, offered different
challenges and different issues from which something can be learned.
Development can take place when a person is assigned a job for which he
has not yet developed the necessary skills and he would learn the skills
while doing the job. Also, an employee might be transfered to enable him
to learn the skills and knowledge needed for a further promotion.
Career development programmes can use both formal and informal
means.
Informal means would, for example, be on-the-job training or off-the-job
training, but with the organisation. Alternatively, it may be necessary for a
trainee to participate in off-the-job programmes away from the enterprise
19
21
are proud of their jobs, as this is the best indication of the status and
recognition they themselves give to the job.
Employees need love ,acceptance, friendship and the need to belong to a
group. Employees can hold social functions , encourage team work,
distribute an internal staff magazine or news letter, hold regular
department/office meetings and encourage canteen lunches and other
social gatherings
The extent to which the job allows the person to experience freedom and
discretion to plan, schedule execute the task puts recognition of
individuals ahead. An employee gains experience, responsibility by feeling
that she or he is personally responsible for the successful completion of
the job
Health, it is a condition characterised by the absence of diseases on the
other hand it could be more comprehensively described as a state of
physical, mental, and social well-being of the individual. In other words ,
health refers to the relationship between mans body and soul , his social
pattern . diseases , accidents or stress will be detrimental to an
employees health, This means that management must take care not only
of an employees physical well-being but also of his psychological well
being
Poor health among employees causes absenteeism and low productivity.
An organisation can greatly reduce loss by having both its employees and
its machinery checked regularly. The employees in turn can also benefit
from such a health programme in that he will loss fewer working days and
less pay as a result of absenteeism.
There are numerous elements to which an employee could be expected in
the work situation , which could have a detrimental effect on his health ,
these include toxic substances such as carbon monoxide , vinyl chloride,
caustics,hazardous substances and gases, radiation as well as excessive
nose and vibration , which may effect hearing and balance and cause
neurological balance problems, and extreme temperatures which may
cause respiratory problems . In addition , the employees well being could
be threatened by skin diseases, disorders of the kidneys and liver, blood
pressure problems and mental disturbances.
The responsibility to ensure that the work place , in such that occupational
health is promoted rests with management . They may achieve this by
introducing health programmes at the enterprise , which include the
following :
24
Programmes used to control drug abuse have the same approach as those
used for alcoholics. The emphasis falls on sensitivity on the part of the
supervisor so that he will be attuned to identifying the problem at an early
stage . Mental health can be defined as the state of mind an employee
displays , who is well adjusted, has an accurate perception of reality and is
able to adapt to lifes pressures and frustrations with reasonable ease.
Emotional disorders may be caused by physical illness , relationship with
with others outside the work situation ,and interaction and interaction
within the work situation. Emotional disorders may be the result of poor
relationship between supervisor, and subordinate, a poor motivational
climate , stress in the work situation.Work related factors such as too
much work and problems with clients may put too much pressure on an
employee, resulting in alcohol or drug abuse as a pathological reaction.
Safety, accidents at work may be described to two main factors, namely
unsafe working conditions or unsafe acts on the part of employees. Unsafe
working conditions include defective equipment , inadequate mechanical
protection , danger of explosions or fires , unsafe designs , unsafe
machines and unsafe locations of machinery and equipment . Unsafe acts
refer to the incorrect use of the tools and equipment , failure to adhere to
safety regulations . There is evidence that certain employees are more
accident prone than the average employee.Accident prone employees
are those who are under the age of 30, show a lack of psychomotoric and
perceptual skills , are also impulsive, generally bored .
The success of a safety programmes depends on the support and
cooperation of manpower management .Apart from the financial support
that is required for programme to work , it also needs moral support . The
success of a safety programme depends on how well employees and
supervisors work together and conform to safety rules and regulations
The following are the means that can be used to to avoid accidents :
-General adminstration of the work place , enough passages of the right
breadth; parts and equipment safely stored after use, flat and non slipery
surfaces ; materials safely stacked; fire extiguishers easily accessible ;
and workbenches tidy
-Handling of materials: safety of all means of conveyance ; safe loading of
all means of conveyance ; materials safely stored
-Electrical equipment: correctly stayed and earthed ; sufficient working
space around machines ; protective glasses worn; and gloves , protective
clothing worn
26
-Hand tools : in good working conditions ; properly stored; suitable for the
job
-Fire extiguishers : regularly serviced and identifiable ; readily accessible ;
in working condition
combine such documents for its own needs and purposes . Organisations
need to formulate short-term goals and strategies to achieve objectives .
The employment relations manager does not only do the formulation of an
employment relations policy or a human resources policy . It is the end
product of corporate planning and strategy formulation. Policy formulation
is the top managements responsibility , because the area of responsibility
of the top executive team is the optimum application and integration of
the resources . policy is depedent upon this intergration and application of
resources. Once a policy is formulated accepted , it is important to put in
writing and make it public , perhaps by publishing it in the in-house
magazine . This step is in itself proof of commitment to the policy . it is
easy to deny or reverse a policy that is merely part of the organisation s
culture . such informal policies are also open to manipulation or
misinterpretation , either accidentally or intentionally.
The failure of many organisation to develop formal company resources
and employment relations policies could be one of the reasons why there
is increasing labour unrest in South Africa. It is of cardinal importance for
the human resources manager to ensure that his or her organisation has
such policies and follows them. A policy provides proof of commitment,
and of preparedness to declare views and attitudes , and it sets limits of
behaviour .it shows the intention of the parties involved to honour these
declarations. It implies that there has been conscious and rational
consideration of the relationship between management and workers . It
recognises the security needs of workers and the interdependence of
workers and management in the organisation .it acknowledges that
workers are indispensable and that they are more than mere production
factors . At the same time, it recognises the rights of workers and the
obligations of managers .
The company policy therefore forms the basis for the development of all
other processes and procedures that determine the conduct of workers
and management in an organisation . An effective disciplinary procedure ,
for example can be drawn up only once an employment relations policy
has been formulated . An organisation therefore needs a policy statement
that indicates its approach and business philosophy , other terms in the
company policy statement could , for example , provide incentives to
ensure maximum productivity and encourage worker participation in
decision making that affects workers ; make provision for housing and for
educational projects for employees , and a statement of the organisations
right to manage these.
28
32
Personality:
Organisation must, therefore,not only recruit , employ , and induct new
individuals , but also ensure that they are attached to the organisation
and in particular , that they become involved in the pursuit of the goals of
the organisation . Employees will feel attached or involved with the
organisation if factors such as their immediate work enviroment , job
content are satisfactory . This will result in fewer resignation and reduced
absenteesim . A person joins and enters into a psychological contract with
an organisation on the basis of his or her personal needs and goals . The
intergration of personal goals with the goals of the organisation seems to
be the best way to uphold the contract .
Attachment to the organisations and involvement with the goals of the
organisation , greatly contribute to the success of the organisation
35
37