Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Towards Commercial
Interruption in TV
Programmes
NA
TABLE OF CONTENT
Certification .......................................................................................................... I
Dedication............................................................................................................. II
Acknowledgement ................................................................................................ III
Abstract ................................................................................................................. IV
Table of Content ................................................................................................... V
List of tables and charts ........................................................................................ VI
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
Background........................................................................................................... 1
Statement of Problem ........................................................................................... 4
Research Questions .............................................................................................. 6
Hypothesis ............................................................................................................ 6
Objectives of the Study ........................................................................................ 6
Significance of the Study...................................................................................... 7
Delimitations/Scope of Study ............................................................................... 8
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW
FOUR:
DATA
ANALYSES,
INTERPRETATION
AND
FINDINGS
Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 40
Recommendations ................................................................................................ 41
Limitations of the study ........................................................................................ 42
Bibliography ......................................................................................................... 43
Appendix ................................................................................................................... 48
FIGURES
Figure 1: Respondents decision to watch and understand a programme is affected by
the frequency of commercials.
Figure 2: Viewers recall rate of commercial and programme contents.
Figure 3: Viewers reactions when commercials interrupt TV programmes.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1. Background
The significance of television as a medium of mass communication is fast
assuming a highly imperative position throughout the world. Television by virtue of
sound, vision and movement offers a high degree of creative flexibility. Television has
added another feather to its wing, which is that of persuasion. This singular act by
television has made it possible for television to dazzle other media of communication. It
now serves as an organ through which governments and advertisers sell their goods and
services. It has brought the art of product awareness to millions of households. It has the
selling power for most types of goods and services detergents, soft drinks,
communication tariffs, beer, clothes etc. People have colour television sets and this
allows for greater pragmatism of presentation in commercials. In fact television is a
significant medium for advertisers.
In 2000, television accounted for 39 percent of total money spent on advertising
(US$51 billion) in the US, 32 percent or 3.9 billion in the UK (WARC, 2002) while in
Australia, it exceeded AUD$2.8 billion in 2003 (Brook, 2003). However, whilst the
amount of money spent on television advertising is significant, literature in the area
reveals that less time is devoted to television viewing. Additionally, the advent of remote
controls, fragmentation of TV channels and increase in the size and number of ad slots,
has resulted in viewers increasingly paying even less attention to the commercials (Beal
2002). Consequently, effective media placement decisions are becoming more imperative
than ever before. The goal for any advertiser is to get the best value for their advertising
money by placing their commercial in such a way as to effectively reach the maximum
possible proportion of the potential viewing audience. Television advertisement
4
placement decisions are based on programme audience viewing data (that is, the ratings
as measured by the people meters), which provides the currency by which airtime is
traded, and the method by which the value of different advertisement slots are compared.
From this, reach and frequency goals are set. In general, the higher the rating (the larger
the number of viewers with an opportunity to see a particular programme), the higher
the cost of the advertisement space during that time. (Lloyd and Clancy 1991). However
the ratings only deliver vehicle exposure, that is, likelihood that an individual watch a
television programme containing a particular advertisement (McDonald 1996). An
individual therefore has an opportunity to see the commercial but it is still not possible
to say with any certainty that the ad was actually seen. Yet, from an advertisers point of
view, it is the actual ad viewing which is important. Whereas media planners and
advertisers readily accept that commercial audiences are smaller than programme
audiences, no generalizable guideline exists by which they can determine the size of the
television audience actually viewing their commercials.This study will examine the
behaviour of viewers both during programmes and commercial breaks.
The Television Industry in Cameroon is still in infant stage comparatively to its
counterparts in other parts of Africa and the developed world. However, it has
transmuted remarkably since the liberalisation of the broadcast media in Cameroon in
the 90s, though it was effective only ten years after.
At its inception, television in the country was basically used for informational,
entertainment, educational and developmental purposes. It is different of its ability to
combine sound and picture. As a result of these qualities, it is possible for it to attract a
large number of viewing audiences.
One cannot, but remember the informational, educational and entertainment
programmes TV stations offer to the audience like: High cognitive (news and
documentaries), High affective (soap operas and series), Low impact (situation comedies,
action series), Sports, Talk shows, and Cartoons. Some of such programmes have been
5
known to force people to go home from wherever they are, so as not to miss the next
episode or edition.
While viewers are watching programmes, it is a common practice that television
houses often slot in commercials which break the continuity of these programmes to the
irritation of viewers. The advertisers often want their commercials to be aired at prime
time, while these viewers want their favourite programmes to be uninterrupted by
commercials. This creates conflicts between the interest of advertisers and interest of
viewers. Television houses do not seem to see anything unusual or abnormal per se
about this situation.
Consequently, television houses often just slot in these commercials even at prime
time without considering the interests and feelings of viewers. The viewers are now
forced to perceive and consume these commercials when watching their favourite
programmes, thereby subjecting them to the status of captive audience.
Some researchers have come up with evidence to show that commercial
interruption could induce aggressive tendencies in people. According to Green (1965), a
former Director General of the British Broadcasting Corporation, television is being
misused and broadcasters are betraying their responsibilities (p. 124)
There is no gain refusing the fact that television stations need the money realized
from these commercials to remain in business. The corporation has to undertake
commercial broadcasting in order to make money to supplement the subtrahend; sponsors
need the television station as a medium of communicating information about their goods
and services to the ultimate consumers with the solitary aim of arousing their interests for
the goods. But as new television stations are established and more stations introduce the
modern broadcasting, the need to interrupt programmes at the detriment of the viewers
will be further aggravated. Unless something is done now, this will be another ugly
incident and further alienation of television audience.
The points mentioned above have acted as stimuli for this research which is to find
out the attitude of television audience towards commercial interruption in television
programmes. Attitude is here defined as ways of thinking or feeling towards something,
in this case towards commercial interruption in television programmes. This attitude
survey is very crucial because it embraces a lot of things. For instance, it transcends
effects of commercial interruptions on television audience because it is only after a
subject has observed the effect of a phenomenon that the subject can form a reasonable
attitude towards that phenomenon.
According to Parker (2003), The sooner each new technology is studied, the
greater the chance of bringing to use research results to influence policy in a meaningful
way (p 123). We can deduce from this that it is necessary to examine audience attitude
towards commercial interruption by Cameroonian televisions at this embryonic state of
television industry, when the institutional and economic structures of broadcasting are
still being formulated.
On the one hand, it is suggested that commercial breaks at points where the
audience is devoting a great deal of attention to the programme are desirable because this
high attention level will be likely to carry over to the ad or ads shown during the
commercial break (Krugman, 1983). On the other hand, it is argued that commercial
breaks at points in a programme where the audience is particularly involved in the
programmes content will be detrimental because the ongoing processing of programme
content during the commercial break will interfere with, and distract them from
processing the commercial message (Soldow and Principe, 1981).
programmes are intermittently interrupted to make way for the insertion of commercial
messages.
The situation has come to a stage where it will be logically assumed that the
gullibility of the television audience is now taken for granted by television houses and
also that money has now become their primary consideration. Thus, this study intends to
examine the attitude of television audience (the case of UB Community) towards
commercial interruption of television programmes. The experience of the commercial
interruptionthat moment when the continuity of a programme is broken by the onset of
a series of commercialsis both widespread and frequent. Carefully situated in relation
to programme content for the purpose of maximizing attention, commercials frequently
occur at moments of dramatic intensity, involving suspense, tragedy or emotional
involvement (Barnouw, 1978, pp. 58; Goldsen, 1977, 7-8). In fact, the purpose of the
Finally, this study will also find out whether television audience will prefer
uninterrupted programmes to interrupted programmes, whether these commercial breaks
increase or decrease the viewers interests. It will come up with suggestions on how TV
stations can best serve their audience.
10
11
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
In this chapter, the major issue under view will be the review of literature related to
the subject matter under study, which is: Attitude of TV Audience Commercial
Interruption of TV Programmes in Cameroon-Buea, the UB Community. This chapter
also contains the theoretical framework on which the study is centered.
12
13
2.1.3. Agenda-Setting
Agenda-setting theory explains how media messages influence consumer
behaviour. This theory is one of the limited effects theories and referred to as the ability
of the media to affect the public perspectives on the significance of different social issues
(ibid).
According to Cohen (1963), media does not tell people what to think, but it
provides them with what to think about. His writing became the foundation of what is
now called agenda-setting theory. Two researchers, Maxwell E. McCombs and Donald
Shaw (1972), articulated their understanding of agenda setting through empirical studies.
They found that mass media play an important role in shaping viewers realities and
attitudes. Baran & Darris (2009), suggested that viewers are greatly influenced by the
vividness of the presentation of messages. Besides, people pay more attention to lead
stories of the news and accept that those stories are the most important stories at the time.
McCombs & Shaw (1972) found that there is a casual relationship between media
messages and viewers perception.
Agenda-setting theory assumes that the more viewers are exposed to the cued
media messages, the more they have the chance to learn new information and knowledge
(ibid). Previous studies have found that advertisers have the power to influence
consumers brand attitudes by increasing the salience of consumers beliefs of material
possesses (ibid). Consumer behaviour perspective in agenda-setting theory explains how
media messages cognitively affect viewers knowledge on products which are advertised
or shown in TV shows. Furthermore, TV programme producers and advertisers play
significant roles in the agenda-setting process by selecting products or services for
commercial breaks in TV shows.
14
15
16
week period, analyzing viewing behaviour in the second week only. Six types of
commercial break behaviour were identified; social interaction, tasking, reading,
flicking, ad watching and advertising interaction. These findings suggest a range of
attention to commercial television breaks, from complete avoidance to full attention.
Ritson et al draw similar conclusions to Byfield (2000), identifying the friends effect
a s an important factor influencing commercial break behaviour; the more people there
are in the room during a commercial break, the less chance there is that they will pay
attention to the ads. More recently, Pilota and Shultz (2005) have highlighted the issue
of simultaneous media consumption e.g. flicking through a newspaper whilst watching
the television, which may have implications for attention to advertising.
Some authors also demonstrate that, in some circumstances, advertising causes
irritation among viewers. That negative effect depends on several factors: profile of
audiences groups, the product announced, the spots quality and creativity, the amount of
advertising time per hour, and the commercial messages adaptation to the audience. For
instance, Rojas-Mndez and Davies (2005) showed that future -oriented people
consider advertising as a useful tool to plan purchases and, as a result, they are less likely
to avoid TV commercials than past-oriented people. On the other hand, Shavitt,
Lowrey and Haefner (1998) found that in the USA males, younger consumers, persons
with less education and income, and nonwhites generally report more favorable
advertising attitudes than others do (p.7). They conducted a survey that pointed out that
more Americans say that they like rather than dislike advertising overall. However, most
of Mittals (1994) respondents said that less than a quarter of television commercials
were honest and believable.
Producers of TV commercials may be able to avoid viewers irritation using
several techniques (Aaker and Buzzone, 1985): good casting and story lines; a positive
mood created by music and the scripts; the use of warm words like love, care or
wonderful; hiring the convenient characters and spokespersons; and creating the
18
perception that the commercial is informative, honest and amusing. On top of that,
programmers should decide what the convenient amount of advertising time per hour is
and which contents fit better with each targeted audience (Rotfeld, 2006).
The most expensive ads are likely to be the ones placed with programmes with
high ratings. This assumes that the programme environment is likely to influence ad
viewing. However, the literature in this area is contradictory and inconsistent. Some
researchers have argued that ads placed alongside higher level involvement programmes
tend to be perceived negatively (Bryant Comisky1978; and Kennedy,1971 ;Soldowand
Principe 1981), while others have claimed that the more the viewer is involved with the
programme, the more likely he/she will attend to the ad (Clancy and Kweskin 1971
;Krugman1983; Lloyd and Clancy 1991). Other researchers have suggested that
involvement with ads depends on the viewers attitudes to different types of programmes
(Hoffman Batra and 1991), which they have classified as high cognitive (news &
documentaries), high affective (mini-series and soaps) and low impact (situation
comedies and action series). They concluded that ad viewing takes place more often
during high cognitive impact programmes, and that such programmes influence the way
viewers evaluate the effectiveness of the commercials.
A common phenomenon during TV viewing is Ad avoidance.
Advertising
avoidance is defined as all actions by media users that differentially reduce their
exposure to ad content (Speck and Elliot, 1997 p61). Avoidance may be physical
(e.g. leaving the room), mechanical (e.g. switching channels) and cognitive (e.g.
ignoring the ad).
The majority of empirical work on advertising avoidance has focused on the
television medium. An area of interest explored in several studies is the level of
advertising avoidance by viewers. Abernethy (1991) concluded that around a third of
television breaks are avoided by viewers, either physically by leaving the room (22%),
or by changing channels (10%). Similar f i g u r e s were reported by Robinson and
19
Ayling (2004), with viewers spending an average 20% of television commercial breaks
out of the room and zapping 12% of breaks. Heeter and Greenberg (1985) examined the
profile of people who zap commercials, describing them as more creatures of chance
than of habit. Danaher (1995) analysed people meter data on a second by second basis,
finding lower levels of avoidance (5%) but li t t le systematic reason why viewers were
avoiding breaks. Van Meurs (1998) analysis of people meter data found much higher
levels of avoidance (29%) and discovered that strong programming was associated with
reduced zapping.
Many empirical studies in the area of advertising avoidance have concentrated on
the predictors of advertising avoidance behaviour, focusing primarily on the television
medium.
Several alternative techniques have been used to estimate the extent to which
television audiences actually watch advertisements. Nuttall (1962) tested day-after recall.
Allen (1965) used time-lapse cameras to photograph the behaviour of television
audiences in selected households. Steiner (1966) enlisted students as "observers" within
the selected households to observe the behaviour of other members. Wolfe, Brown,
Thompson, and Greenberg (1966) used a combination of post-exposure interviews and
in-home observers, and Twyman (1969) used both diaries and telephone interviews
which coincided with commercial breaks. Bunn (1982) used the increase in electricity
consumption during breaks to estimate the extent to which audiences did other things
than view television at these times. Collett (1986) developed a combination of video
camera and recorder, which he called a "C-box". All these studies agree in finding that a
substantial proportion of programme audiences do not watch advertisements, and even
when they dare to spend watch or spend some time trying to understand commercials,
little attention is paid to it, or they do so alongside some other chores.
20
suggest that heavy television viewers tend to believe that other people enjoy more
luxurious lives and possess more materials then light viewers. This is because
television viewing affects normative perceptions of consumer behavior, and television
as a socialization agent causes changes in consumers attitudes.
Bush et al. (1999) explored the influence of television watching on both AfricanAmerican and Caucasian consumers attitudes toward advertising. In their survey with
college students, respondents were asked to answer how many hours they watch
television, what their general attitudes toward advertising are, and how many hours
they spend on family communication about consumption. The results showed that heavy
television viewers have more positive attitudes toward advertising. Moreover, the
results confirmed that African-American consumers watch more television and use it
more for guidance of social utility than their Caucasian counterparts. However, this
study was limited to consumers attitudes toward general advertising in television and
was also restricted to two ethnicities at the college age level.
As other studies have found, the current study also posits that consumers
television consumption is significantly related to advertising exposure. Particularly,
watching television shows inevitably leads to exposure of product placement in today s
television environment. For clarification, watching television is defined in this study as,
consumers exposure to television shows which contain product placements in each
episode.
22
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
In this chapter, we shall examine the research design used, the research method, the
population under study and its characteristics, the sampling plan/technique, sample size
of the population, the instrument of data collection, specification of conditions and
procedures of observation or administration of fieldwork and the specification of
methods and techniques of data analysis.
23
sampled. The method used in this study has been used for a similar study in Ondo and
Enugu states in Nigeria and it yielded results.
24
3.5. Pre-Test
Pre-testing or pilot test is defined as the first test carried out to detect errors that
may appear on the data collection instrument, in this case the questionnaire. 20
questionnaires were used to run the pilot test of this study. After the exercise more
emphasis was laid on the way respondents should answer certain questions, like
emphasizing that only one response should ticked in questions that warranted such. Some
of the questions were also removed, and question was changed from If yes, why? to
Justify your answer. This was to allow for the respondents to justify their answers
whether they answered Yes or No.
25
Attitude
Conceptually, attitude means a way of feeling, thinking, or behaving. It is also a
psychological predisposition that allows a person to behave in a certain way towards
26
Audience
Conceptually, audience means a gathering of persons for the purpose of hearing a
speaker or a singer. It also means persons within hearing, whether they are together or
not, as in the case of broadcast. Operationally, audience in TV programmes includes men
and women, young or old, adults or children.
Commercial
Conceptually, it means pertaining to commerce. Operationally, it refers to
advertising, paid announcements over TV programmes to sell a product, idea or service.
They are advertisements inserted in TV programmes.
Interruption
Literally, it means a break in the continuity of speech, traffic or a programme.
Operationally, it refers to a break in any TV programme already started to slot in any
advertisement. Therefore commercial interruption as it applies to this study refers to ant
break in TV programmes already started, to slot in an advert.
Programme
Programme literally, means a lot of items or events for context or to be broadcast
for radio or television. Operationally programmes refer to a schedule of events to be
broadcast by television houses. These television houses do have many viewers each day.
They could be news, advertisement or entertainment programmes like the Telenovelas,
Sports, News, etc.
27
Regular
Literally, regular means doing something at the same time every day.
Operationally, a regular viewer refers to anybody who watches television programmes
daily or every day.
Non-regular viewers
This refers to people who do not watch television programmes daily.
Appeal
Literally, appeal means to attract, move the feeling of doing something.
Operationally, appeal means the attraction television programmes have for some people;
this makes them to watch it daily.
Favourite
Conceptually, favourite means most preferred above others. Operationally, it
refers to those programmes which people or viewers do prefer above others. It does not
matter whether they watch them or not.
More
Conceptually, more means greater in number or degree. But operationally, more
refers to greater number of people i.e. commercials that attract greater number of people.
Timing
A particular time when something happens.
Commercial interruption
The moment when television programme is interrupted by the onset of
commercials. Commercial interruptions are introduced within programmes to promote
28
product, services and ideas to member of the public which ordinarily would have been
interesting for people to watch. These commercial are usually present when programmes
that are interesting to people are being broadcast. This continual interruption would likely
cause heavy viewers of commercial to develop insensitivity as a protective mechanism.
29
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA ANALYSES, INTERPRETATION AND FINDINGS
In this chapter, the researcher will focus on analysing the output gotten from the
SPSS. According to the Product Marketing Manager for Shiver Corporation, Dayton J.
D., quoted in Kitty O. Locker (1997), quality analyses is based on taking a problem and
breaking it into questions that must be answered to solve it. It is for this reason that in
this chapter, dealing with analyses, emphasis will be laid on answering the research
questions as well as testing the hypotheses mentioned earlier in chapter one of this
work. The hypotheses will in turn be answered by aid of specific questions found in the
questionnaire. Tables, bar and pie charts will be explored to enhance proper
understanding.
70
62
Yes
Frequency
60
45
50
No
40
30
No response
20
10
0
1
Response category
Source: Pechulano 2014
31
programme, and, another (question 10) which asked the respondents if commercials
affect their understanding of a programme.
In the former, 45 respondents (41.7%) agreed that commercials affect their
decision to watch a programme, while however, in the later, 38 respondents (35.2%)
said commercials in programmes affect their understanding of a programme. The table
below shows the above explanations.
Table 1: Agreement level and understanding an interrupted programme
Rate your level of agreement to how
understanding of a programme?
watch a programme.
Response
Frequency
Percentage
Category
Response
Frequency Percentage
Category
Strongly
Agree
Agree
12
11.1
45
41.7
Neutral
38
35.2
Disagree
10
9.2
Yes
38
35.2
No
68
63.0
No
1.8
108
100
response
Strongly
2.8
Disagree
Total
Total
108
100
Source: Pechulano 2014
32
It was therefore necessary find out if the frequency of commercials will have a
combined effect on viewers decision to watch and understanding a programme which
has been confirmed in the bar diagram above.
For those who said commercials affect their understanding of a programme,
13.9% (15) of them said they lose track and concentration on the programme as result
of commercial interruption. 8 of them (7.4%) were of the opinion that a commercial
interruption a programme confuses them and they do not know which to follow. 3
others said they forget the content of the programme and that there is a conflict of
understanding, as most of the commercials often interrupt that high affective and/or
high cognitive moments, when the viewer is highly involved in, and attentive to the
content of the programme and trying to comprehend it. 2.8% of the respondents each
said they forget the content of the programme and they there is a conflict of
understanding respectively. An insignificant 0.9% (1) of the respondents said
commercial interruptions give him time to understand the content of the programme.
H2: Products in commercials have a high recall and purchase rate among TV
viewers.
Question 17 on the questionnaire played the test role to this hypothesis. Question
17: Between the content of a programme and that of a commercial which do you
recall more?
This question was posed to all 108 respondents. However, 3 respondents did not
give any option. 105 of them responded to the question. More than 70% of number (77
respondents) said they recall they recall the programme content. Exactly 25.9% (28
respondents) confirmed that they recall the content of the commercial, in essence, they
recall the commercial. This shows that the difference between those who recall the
content of commercials and those who recall content of programme is glaring. In effect,
33
hypothesis 2 (H2) was debunked. Therefore products in commercials have a low recall
rate among TV viewers. The bar diagram below represents the variable recalled more
by TV viewers.
Viewers' recall rate of commercial and programme contents
Frequency
77
80
Commercial
content
60
Programme
content
40
28
No response
20
0
1
Response Category
Source: Pechulano 2014
34
shows the number of respondents whose purchase rate of the product or service being
advertised, is affected by commercial interruption of
Table 2: Response for whether commercial interruption affects purchase rate
Response
Frequency
Percent (%)
Yes
52
48.1
No
54
50.0
No response
1.9
Total
108
100.0
Category
Hypothesis Three
H3: Viewers think programmes that are interrupted by commercials lack content.
Question 16 played the test role to this hypothesis. Question 16 was as follows:
What do you think about programmes that are interrupted by commercials? Out
of the 108 respondents, only 13 respondents (12%) affirmed to the fact that such
programmes that are interrupted by commercials lack content. A greater majority of the
respondents 65 of them (60.2%) said such programmes are money-minded. This was
closely followed by a 13% of respondents who gave other views. 10 of the respondents
(9.3%) thought that such programmes that are interrupted by commercials are not
credible (that is, they lack credibility).
From the results gotten and the explanations above H3 was therefore debunked.
The table below represents the literature above.
35
Response Category
Frequency
Percent
Lack Content
13
12.0
Lack credibility
10
9.3
Money minded
65
60.2
Others
15
13.9
No response
4.6
Total
108
100.0
Source: Pechulano 2014
Hypothesis Four (H4): Commercials are mostly slotted in the middle (high
affective moments) of TV programmes.
To test this hypothesis, question 7 on the instrument for data collection (the
questionnaire), was used. This question asked the respondents to rate, on a scale of 5,
how they see commercials at different points in a TV programme. These points were:
before the programme starts, at the beginning of the programme, in the middle of the
programme, just before the programme ends, at the end of the programme, and after the
programme. Respondents rated all the points differently and on 5, but for the purpose
of testing the H4 above, the number of respondents who rated 5/5 (that is they see
commercials 5/5) for the different points in TV programmes, was considered and
compared, as shown in the table below.
36
Point
Frequency of 5/5
Percent (%)
38
35.2
21
19.4
53
49.1
4.6
17
15.7
16
14.8
Source: Pechulano 2014
After the analysis and representation, as on the table above, it was discovered that 53
(49.1%) of the 108 respondents who rated seeing commercials in the middle of a
programme (high affective), rated 5/5. This was followed by 38 (35.2 %), out of the
108 respondents, who rated 5/5 for seeing commercials before programmes start. The
percentage of those who rated 5/5 for seeing commercials at the beginning of a
programme stood at 19.4 (21 respondents). It was found out that commercials come up
or appear on TV, just before a programme ends, but not as often as in the case of in the
middle, before a programme starts and at the beginning of the programme respectively.
This because only 5 out of the 108 respondents rated 5/5 for seeing commercials, just
before a programme ends.
From the analysis above, it can therefore be concluded that H4 which speculated that
commercials often interrupt programmes in the middle, has been confirmed, as has
been shown on the table above and explained thereof.
This hypothesis and its confirmation will now serve as a take-off point in answering
research question two RQ2 of the study.
37
38
Frequency
30
Switch channel
25
Watch
commercial
Stay but do not
concentrate
Others
20
15
10
5
0
1
Response Category
Source: Pechulano 2014
RQ2: At what time (point: beginning, middle, end) should a commercial interrupt
a TV programme?
With the hypotheses tested and the first research question answered, that is how
viewers react when commercials are inserted to interrupt TV programmes, finding out
when (at what point) in a programme will they prefer to see a commercial is what
research question two set to find out, with help of question 8 in the questionnaire. Such
point were: before the programme starts, at the beginning of the programme, in the
middle of the programme, just before the programme ends, at the end of the programme
and after the programme. Of the 108 respondents interviewed, 45 of them who make up
39
41.7% to be precise, stated that they will prefer to see adverts before a programme.
Second on the frequency table was 20 respondents (18.5% of them), who said they
prefer to see commercials in the middle of the programme. The difference of 25 This
was closely followed 16 other respondents (14.8%) who will prefer to see adverts at the
beginning of a programme. 15 (13.9%) respondents said they will prefer to see
commercials at the end of the programme. Based on the table shown below, research
question two has therefore been answered.
Table 5: Points Viewers will prefer to see commercials during TV programmes.
Response Category
Frequency
Percent
45
41.7
At the beginning
16
14.8
In the middle
20
18.5
programme ends
4.6
At the end
15
13.9
5.6
No response
.9
Total
108
100.0
40
41
said they sometimes (spend at least 8hours a week watching TV) watch TV. This was
followed by 18 of them who confirmed that watch TV very often. This very often was
rated as spending from 16 hours (16 hours ++ weekly) watching TV.
42
CHAPTER FIVE
CONCLUSION, RECOMMENDATIONS AND LIMITATIONS
5.1. CONCLUSION
The study aimed at examining the attitudes of the UB Community in Buea,
towards commercial interruption of television programmes and the extent to which
such variables like sex, educational level, marital status, and occupation will contribute
in shaping these attitudes. From the findings, 36 respondents which make up 33.3%
said they leave the room when a commercial interrupt a programme they are watching.
This number was closely followed by a 29.6% (32) of respondents who said they watch
the commercial, indicating that their actions at points when commercials interrupt the
programmes they are watching is cognitive. Still, a much closed number of 27 of the
respondents said they stay but do not concentrate. Thus if compared to the total number
of respondents that said they are not disturbed when adverts interrupt their programmes
the researcher can conclude that TV viewers are offended, better still, disgruntled when
commercials interrupt their TV programmes.
The researcher also sought to establish whether it is beneficial or detrimental to
insert commercials at highly involving points in television programming, and to
identify cognitive processes which account for the observed effects. Of the 108
respondents, 45 of them who make up 41.7%, stated that they will prefer to see adverts
before a programme, 20 respondents (18.5%), said they prefer to see commercials in
the middle of the programme. The difference of 25 This was closely followed 16 other
respondents (14.8%) who will prefer to see adverts at the beginning of a programme. 15
(13.9%) respondents said they will prefer to see commercials at the end of the
43
programme. With these results, the researcher can thus conclude that most Television
viewers prefer to see adverts before a programme begins so that there is no interruption
within the programme.
The study also investigated if television audience will prefer uninterrupted
programmes to interrupted programmes, whether these commercial breaks increase or
decrease the viewers interests. It will come up with suggestions on how TV stations
can best serve their audience. Question (9), in the questionnaire required the
respondents to rate their level agreement to the fact that commercials in TV
programmes affect their decision to watch a programme, and, another (question 10)
which asked the respondents if commercials affect their understanding of a programme.
In the former, 45 respondents (41.7%) agreed that commercials affect their decision to
watch a programme, while in the later, 38 respondents (35.2%) said commercials in
programmes affect their understanding of a programme. To this effect the researcher
can then inferred that TV viewers prefer uninterrupted programmes.
5.2. RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the findings of this study, and supported by the significance of the
study, the following recommendations are worth considering.
That advertisers and TV stations should place adverts before programmes start.
This will increase the viewership of TV channels and advertisers products and
also increase the advertising reach of advertisers products.
Considering the fact that the Cameroonian has since the 1990s liberalised the
ownership of the broadcasting media in Cameroon, this duopoly has given
impetus to the TV houses in the country to conduct their affairs in a manner
44
45
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
Beal, Virginia (2002) How has UK television viewing behaviour changed since
the 1980s? Insights for the Australian market Anzmac Proceedings
Brennan, Mike and Syn, Maureen (2002) Television Viewing Behaviour during
Commercial Breaks, Anzmac Proceedings
Light, Richard J., Judith D. Singer, and John B. Willett. (1990) By Design:
Planning Research on Higher Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press.
McDonald, Colin (1996) Advertising Reach and Frequency: maximising
advertising results through effective frequency, NTC Business
Books
R.V. Krejcie and D.W. Morgan (1970), Determining sample size for research
activities, Educational and psychological measurement. 30. 608,
Sage Publication.
Clemson
Journals
Abernethy, Avery M (1991) Television Exposure: Programme versus
Advertising, Current Issues and Research in Advertising, Volume
13, 61-78
46
Anderson, D.R., Field, D.E, Collins, P.A., Lorch, E.P. and Nathan, J.G (1985)
Estimates of Young Childrens Time with Television: A
Methodological Comparison of Parents Reports with Time Lapse
Video Home Observation Child Development, 56, October, 134557
Brook, Stephen (2003) People do anything but watch ads, The Australian,
February 13.
Bechtel, R.B., Acelpohl, C. and Akins, Roger (1972) Correlates Between
Observed Behaviour and Questionnaire Responses on Television
Viewing in Television and Social Behaviour, Volume 4, television
in Day to Day Life: Patterns of Use, E.A.
Bunn, Derek W (1982) Audience Presence during Breaks in Television
Programmes,
Journal
of
Advertising
Research,
22
(5),
October/November, 35-39
Ehrenberg, A.S.C and Twyman, W.A. (1967) On Measuring Television
Audiences, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 130,
1 -59
Esselmont, D and McLeavy, N (1993) The Behaviour of Television Audiences
During Commercial Breaks, Marketing Bulletin, 2, 12-18
Study
Assessing
Quality
of
Media
47
Exposures,
and
Commercials:
The
Use
of
In-Home
Media
Planning,
Journal
of
Advertising
Research,
August/September
Lynch, Kate (1999) The Influence of Viewing Quality on Ad Effectiveness,
Admap, March
48
Commercials,
Journal
of
Advertising
Research,
18
(December), 37-44
Ritson, M (2003) New Study Challenges Assumed Level of TV Advertisement
Viewing, London Business School, February 13
Ritson, M., Brodin, K. and Barwise, P. (2003) An Ethnographic Study of the TV
Advertising Audience. EMAC Conference Proceedings, Glasgow.
during
the
commercial
break.
EMAC
Conference
proceedings, Murcia.
Steiner, Gary (1966) The People Look at Commercials: A Study of Audience
Behaviour, Journal of Business, 39 (Spring), 272-304
Swallen, Jonathon (2000) Time is on Our Side: The Link between Viewing
Duration and Ad Effectiveness, European Society for Opinion and
Marketing
Breaks
Journal
of
Advertising
Research, 1,
January/February
Yorke, David A and Philip J Kitchen (1985) Channel Flickers and Video
Speeders, Journal of Advertising Research, 25, 2: 21-2
Zwaga, W.E.R. (1992) Delivering television audiences to the advertisers?
Impressions from the living room Marketing Bulletin, 3, 9-17
Websites
Social Science Research Institute Survey Research Center
http://www.ssri.psu.edu/survey/index.html
50
APPENDIX
Questionnaire of the Study
University of Buea
Faculty of Social and Management Sciences
Topic: Attitude of TV Audience towards Commercial Interruption of TV
Programmes; The Case of the UB Community
Sponsored By:
The Department Of Journalism and Mass Communication
University of Buea
This survey is part of a research project designed to assess the Attitude of TV
audience Towards Commercial Interruption of TV Programmes; the case of the
UB Community. Your participation in this study will greatly enhance the formation
of new guidelines, and recommendations for broadcast TV programming. Your name
will not be identified in the final presentation of the document. Only summarized
information will be reported. Any concerns can be addressed to Ali Pechu at 77 96 68
2. No
2. Where do you watch TV? Tick only one from the table below.
At home
Friend/neighbours
Public
Your
house
places
office
51
Others(specify)
3. On a weekly basis, how often do you watch TV? Tick from the table below.
Never (0
Rarely (4
Sometimes (8
Often (12
hours)
hours)
hours)
hours)
hours ++)
2 1
your
opinion
what
is
TV
commercial
(TV
advert)?
________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
6. How often do you see commercials in TV programmes? Tick one from the table
below.
Never (0%)
Rarely (25%)
Sometimes
Often (75%)
Very
(50%)
often
(100%)
7. Rate how you see commercials at the points below.(5=highest and 1=lowest)
Categories
52
Agree
Neutral
agree
Disagr
ee
Strongly
disagree
2. No
2 times
3 times
4 times
More than
4 times
53
13. Does the number of times affect your decision to watch, and your understanding
of the programme? 1. Yes
2. No
14. How do you react when commercials or adverts interrupt a programme you are
watching?
Leave the room
Switch channel
Watch the commercial
Stay but do not concentrate
Others (specify if any)
15. Apart from the timing and frequency of commercials, what other factor (s)
affect (s) your decision to watch, and your understanding of a
programme._____________________________________________________
16. What do you think about programmes that are interrupted by commercials?
Lack
Lack credibility
content
Money
Others (specify)
minded
2. Programme content
1. Yes
2. No
2.Female
54
21. Age:
15-25 years
26-35 years
36-45 years
45
above
23. Occupation___________________________________________________
55
and